Saatja: SG COM ANTICI <
[email protected]>
Saaja: Esindus EL juures üldaadress
Teema: Fit for 55 letter and country fiche to Permanent Representation of Estonia - Ares(2021)4995148
Ref. Ares(2021)4995148 - 06/08/2021
ESTONIA
The Fit for 55 package is the European Union’s blueprint for a deep transformation of our economies and societies, with a
profound impact on each Member State. The Commission’s impact assessments, which accompany the legislative
proposals, show that this transformation comes with challenges. But it also brings unique opportunities to move towards a
sustainable, prosperous and fair future.
In previous decades, Estonia has made significant progress in laying the foundation of a low-carbon economy. Even
though its emissions reductions were amongst the highest in the EU, there are still large opportunities to make the
Estonian economy more resilient and sustainable, and to reduce systemic inequality across the whole of society.
1. IMPACT OF FIT FOR 55: MAIN OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES
Opportunities
Further modernisation of the economy. Between 1990 and 2019, economy wide greenhouse gas emissions in
Estonia decreased by 64%. But Estonia remains a greenhouse gas intensive economy with a particular large share
of oil shale in its energy sector. The Fit for 55 package will help Estonia achieve its oil shale phase-out.
The Fit for 55 package will also assist Estonia in achieving its revised national 2030 greenhouse gas reduction
target of -23% below 2005 levels under the Effort Sharing Regulation1. Significant mitigation opportunities exist, for
instance in the waste sector. Estonia can continue to use existing flexibilities to reach its target cost-effectively. The
package will also steer the country towards its own 2050 climate neutrality objective.
Significant budgetary means provided by the EU. The new Social Climate Fund under Fit for 55 includes EUR 207
million for Estonia. The EU budget, including the cohesion funds and the Just Transition Fund, as well as
1
This is for sectors currently not covered by the existing EU emissions trading sector (typically emissions from the buildings, road transport, small industry,
waste, agriculture and non-CO2 emissions from other sectors). The proposed national target will continue to cover this scope.
NextGenerationEU, provides EUR 6.4 billion to allow for significant investments in the greening and the
decarbonisation of the economy. Estonia also benefits from significant revenues generated through EU emissions
trading.
Reduction of energy poverty. Low income households in Estonia can be particularly affected by the energy
transition, as they spend a larger share of their income on energy and often cannot afford low-carbon alternatives.
Additional resources generated by Fit for 55 create opportunities to correct this negative impact.
Just transition in affected regions. The transition to a climate-neutral economy may also have a negative impact on
employment, particularly in regions where oil shale is mined. Such regions can benefit from the Just Transition
Fund, with which Fit for 55 is closely aligned.
Increased uptake of renewable energy. Estonia has a great potential in offshore wind farms in the Nordic-Baltic
region, and is exploring the development of hydrogen production. The Fit for 55 package will support such efforts,
notably through the more ambitious ETS and Renewable Energy Directives.
Further reduction of energy consumption, particularly in buildings and transport. Several Fit for 55 proposals will
allow Estonia to tap into its high energy savings potential in both areas. This will also have a positive impact on
energy poverty in the country.
Challenges
The Fit for 55 package will also help Estonia to meet some pressing challenges it faces at national or local level. These
include:
Estonia’s current electricity system is largely based on oil shale, which emits substantial amounts of greenhouse
gases. The government has announced that the use of oil shale in power generation will be phased out by 2035,
the production of shale oil by 2040.
Labour and skills shortages are limiting the pace of renovating the building stock.
Estonia’s projections in the National Energy and Climate Plan indicate a further decrease of net removals from land
use and forestry by 2030. This trend can be changed and additional removals can be achieved at moderate costs.
Estonia’s high share of biomass for renewable energy (80%) is reason for concern. While Member States can
continue to use felling residues or low-quality and non-industrial wood for bioenergy production, Estonia should
rather look into solutions to convert biomass into long living wood products. This would be in line with the revised
Renewable Energy Directive and would improve the functioning of its LULUCF sink.
2. KEY DATA IN FIT FOR 55
The above-mentioned challenges and opportunities are underpinned by the following key data:
2.1. Economy wide greenhouse gas emissions reductions
Economy wide GHG emissions reductions (incl. Excluding LULUCF Including LULUCF
international aviation), 2019 Estonia EU Estonia EU
Versus 1990 -64% -24% -63% -26%
GHG per capita (tCO2-eq/capita) 11.2 7.8
GHG per unit of GDP (tCO2/Mio € GDP) 602 263
The country’s total greenhouse gas emissions have considerably decreased compared to 1990. However, both the
greenhouse gas intensity of its economy and the emissions per capita still remain markedly above the EU average.
2.2. National greenhouse gas emissions reductions, sectors under the Effort Sharing Regulation (ESR)2
GHG emission reduction (ESR, versus 2005) Estonia EU
2019 emissions (preliminary) 20% -10%
2020 target 11% -9%
2030 NECP -20% -32%
Existing 2030 target -13% -29%
Proposed update 2030 target -24% -40%
Projected cost efficient contribution to EU target / EU target -18% -40%
The country’s ESR emissions in 2019 were higher than its 2020 target of limiting increase by +11% compared to 2005.
Emissions have increased in particular in road transport and in agriculture, the two sectors dominating the country’s ESR
emissions. In its National Energy and Climate Plan, Estonia intends to achieve higher reductions than its current ESR
target for 2030 of -13%. The proposed new ESR target for Estonia is -24%.
2
These emissions cover typically emissions from the buildings, road transport, small industry, waste, agriculture and non-CO2 emissions from other sectors.
2.3. Land use, Land use change and Forestry (LULUCF)
Net removals (-) or emissions (+) LULUCF sector.
Estonia EU
MtCO2eq
Average 2016-2018 -2.1 -268
Current 2030 target -0.5 -225
Proposed 2030 target -2.55 -310
Under current land management practices, Estonia is projected to see decreasing net removals by 2030. To reach its
target, Estonia needs to reverse this trend by implementing additional measures and changes in land management
practices. Additional land use, land use change and forestry credits under this new target may potentially be used to
comply with the ESR target.
2.4. Renewable energy sources
Renewable energy3 Estonia EU
2019 31.9% 19.7%
2030 NECP 42.0% 33.1 – 33.7%
Projected cost efficient 2030 contribution to EU
46% 40%
target4 / EU target
Based on the preliminary assessment5, Estonia has already reached its 2020 renewables target (i.e. 25%). Its National
Energy and Climate Plan includes an explicit contribution to the 2030 EU renewables target around 42%. The projected
cost efficient potential for contributing to the increased EU 2030 renewables target is estimated to be 46% by 2030.
3
Share expressed in % of Gross Final Energy Consumption
4
With RFNBOs accounted on the demand side.
5
See: COM(2020) 952 final
2.5. Energy Mix
Energy Mix (% of Gross Inland Consumption)6 Estonia EU
2019 2030 2019 2030
Solids 65.0% 57.2% 12.1% 5.8%
Oil 1.1% 0.0% 34.9% 32.1%
Gas 8.3% 5.5% 23.3% 21.5%
Nuclear 0.0% 0.0% 13.7% 12.0%
Renewables 25.7% 37.7% 16.0% 28.7%
The current share of renewables in Estonia’s energy mix is 25.7%. Projections indicate that this share would increase to
37.7% by 2030. Solid fuels, oil and natural gas would see a decreasing share in Estonia.
2.6. Energy Efficiency
Projected cost efficient
Energy Efficiency 2030 contribution to EU
target / EU target
Estonia EU
Primary energy consumption 2020-2030 -33% -39%
Final energy consumption 2020-2030 -34% -36%
Increased efforts will be needed to contribute to the new EU energy efficiency target. The projected cost efficient potential
for contributing to the increased EU 2030 energy efficiency target is estimated to be -33% for primary energy consumption
and -34% for final energy consumption in 2030 (compared to 2007 Baseline).
6
GIC does not include ambient heat and electricity trade. Renewables include non-renewable waste.
2.7. Impact on energy expenditure and on energy poverty
2015 estimate As projected under current As projected under cost
Energy-related cost for households as % of
policies efficient achievement
private consumption
increased EU ambition
Estonia EU Estonia EU Estonia EU
Residential (fuel expenditure and capital cost) 8.9 6.1 8.2 6.9 8.3 7.5
Transport (fuel expenditure) 5.6 3.6 4.6 3.0 4.9 3.1
Source: PRIMES model.
The estimated energy-related costs in 2015 for households (as a percentage of total consumption) in residential and
transport are much higher than the EU average. Under existing policies, these costs would be lower in 2030 than the 2015
estimate (it would be higher for the EU on average).
Under the Fit for 55 package, the costs for households are projected to be slightly reduced compared to the 2015 estimate
in the residential sector and in transport. Revenues from emissions trading can be used for social corrections7.
Furthermore, revenues could be used for targeted support for investments, leveraging where possible private sector
investment means.
2019
Social impacts Estonia EU
Share of rural population at risk of poverty 24.9% 18.5%
Energy Poverty EE EU
Share of population at risk of poverty unable to keep
6.2% 18.2%
home adequately warm
Share of population at risk of poverty with arrears on
13.6% 14.9%
utility bills
Note: ‘at risk of poverty’ = below 60% of median equivalised income
7
A lump sum redistribution of additional revenues from carbon pricing to all households is estimated to fully compensate the negative welfare impact for the
lower- to middle-income households. A targeted redistribution to lower-income households would further improve outcomes in terms of equity and thus mitigate
the social impact.
Source: Eurostat
Estonia’s share of rural population at risk of poverty or social exclusion is higher than the EU average. Overall, its share of
population with arrears on utility bills is close to the EU average.
3. Distributional elements of the ‘fit for 55’ package
The Fit for 55 package wants to make sure that the costs and the benefits of the low-carbon transition are fairly
distributed. Several distributional elements are therefore built into the design of the proposals.
Revenues from emissions trading, especially from emissions trading in new sectors, can be used for social corrections,
which can cushion impacts for the low income groups. Furthermore revenues should be used for targeted support for
investments, leveraging where possible private sector investment means.
Estonia’s new 2030 Effort Sharing target of -24% compared to 2005 is based on GDP per capita, but with a correction
of 3 percentage points, to take into account that Estonia’s formula based target is more ambitious than its cost efficient
emission reduction projections. This results in a target increase of 10 percentage points, which is less than the EU
average increase.
The introduction of an emissions trading system in the building and road transport sector will allow Estonia to reverse
the increasing trend in combined emissions of these sectors, representing around 40% of emissions covered under the
national target.
Estonia can use credits generated in the land use and forestry sectors to reach its national greenhouse gas reductions
target under the Effort Sharing Regulation, equivalent to around 1.5% of its 2005 emissions, but will first need to
improve its sink in the land use and forestry sectors.
The revised ETS Directive foresees a considerable redistribution of revenues for Estonia, inter alia:
o Redistribution of 10% of auctioning allowances to low income Member States, which is fully maintained;
o Increase of the Modernisation Fund8 from 7.7 million to 11 million allowances over ten years, to invest in the
modernisation of the energy system. Estimated revenue for Estonia is equal to EUR 0.55 billion (assuming a
carbon price of € 50 per tonne);
8
This is the part that is redistributed between Member States. Concerned Member States can choose to further increase this from own means.
o Estonia continues to benefit from free allowances for its power sector (the so-called article 10c provision) and
reduced contributions to the Market Stability Reserve.
Under the new Social Climate Fund made possible by revenues of the new ETS, Estonia receives 0.29% of the
revenues, a higher share than the basic auction revenue allocation of 0.2%, amounting to EUR 207 million in current
prices.
4. EU SUPPORTING MEASURES
To support the ambition laid out in the Fit for 55 package, Member States can also rely on several existing EU
instruments. Thirty percent of the programmes under the 2021-2027 Multi-annual Financial Framework are dedicated to
support climate action, next to 37% of the Recovery and Resilience Facility, which finances Member States’ national
programmes under the NextGenerationEU programme. The most significant funding sources Estonia are the Cohesion
policy funds with EUR 3.1 billion, the Agriculture policy funds with 2.1 billion and the Recovery and Resilience Facility with
EUR 1 billion through grants.
Programme Amount Share in Comments
EU funds
(%)
Cohesion policy funds (ERDF, In current prices. Includes funding for European territorial cooperation (ETC).
3.1 0.9%
ESF+, Cohesion Fund) Does not include amounts transferred to the Connecting Europe Facility.
European Agricultural Fund In current prices. Commitments under the multi-annual financial framework.
for Rural Development, and
direct payments from the 2.1 0.5%
European Agricultural
Guarantee Fund.
Recovery and Resilience In current prices as in Annex IV of the RRF Regulation (without prejudice to the
1 0.3%
Facility updated calculation by 30 June 2022).
Just Transition Fund In 2018 prices. Commitments under both the MMF and NGEU. Established
within the framework of cohesion policy and implemented through shared
0.3 1.8% management. Transfers of resources from ERDF and ESF+ will add to the JTF
allocation.
EU MFF + Next Generation EU funds available, 2021-2027: commitments, EUR billion. Cohesion policy funds, not including
ReactEU.
5. ADDITIONAL DATA
5.1. Current employment green economy/automotive manufacturing/fossil fuel extraction/transport sector
EU EE
Employment (thousand) † †
2010 2019* 2010 2019*
Total employment 183704 194849 548 634
Green employment (ESTAT definition) 4027.0 4363.0 27.2 30.0
% of total 2.2% 2.2% 4.5% 4.8%
Automotive manufacturing employment 2634.1 3325.3 3.2 3
% of total 1.4% 1.7% 0.6% 0.5%
Fossil fuel extraction employment 410.5 304 4.6 3.0
% of total 0.2% 0.2% 0.8% 0.5%
Note: † 2014 for green employment. * 2018 for green employment. Source: EUROSTAT
Estonia has in relative terms a very high share of green employment, notably related to its forestry sector. This offers
opportunities to further diversify the greening of the economy. Estonia has a relatively high – yet, declining – share of
employment in fossil fuel extraction. This could pose a Just Transition challenge. In 2018, Estonia employed 41654
persons in the transport sector.
5.2. Energy efficiency of the building stock
Building stock (energy efficiency/age) 2030
2019 As projected under cost efficient
achievement increased EU ambition
Estonia EU Estonia EU
Final energy consumption per capita in residential
7.0% -7.8% -22% -34%
sector - relative change compared to 2005
Source: EUROSTAT, Primes model.
Specific energy consumption per capita is a consensual indicator for the efficiency of energy use in residential buildings.
In 2019, compared to 2005, the energy consumption per capita in residential buildings in Estonia increased by 7%, while
the EU average decreased by 7.8%. By 2030, it is projected that the energy consumption per capita in residential
buildings both in Estonia and at the EU average will be below 2005 levels by 22% and by 34% respectively.
5.3. Renovation rate of buildings
Renovation rate/plans 2030
2020 As projected under cost efficient
achievement increased EU ambition
Estonia EU Estonia EU
Annual renovation rates (for buildings envelope) 0.9% 0.9% 1.7% 2.1%
Source: Primes model.
The annual renovation financing needs are expected to increase almost fivefold: from the current cost of under € 200
million up to € 900 million. Estonia should further promote the ESCO market. Labour and skills shortages are limiting
renovations.
5.4. Alternative Fuels Infrastructure roll-out
Estonia % of EU Estonia % of EU
2020 2030 (MIX scenario)
Number of public recharging points 424 0.2% 5758 0.2%
Number of hydrogen refuelling stations 0 0% 7 0.3%
5.5. Emissions from road transport
Share of total GHG
Projected under cost efficient
emissions (inc.
Road MtCO2, 2019 2019 versus 2005 achievement of EU target,
international aviation),
transport 2030 vs 2005
2019
emissions
Estonia EU Estonia EU Estonia EU Estonia EU
2 784 15% 21% 18% 0% -1% -30%
Source: PRIMES model.
Road transport in 2019 in Estonia represented 15% of the total greenhouse gas emissions, against 21% at the EU level.
Emissions have increased by 18% compared to 2005, against 0% in the EU. Under the Fit for 55 package, they are
projected to decrease by 1% (compared to a reduction of 30% for the EU on average).
5.6. Energy taxation
Estonian national rates are well above the current Energy Taxation Directive (ETD) minima. Therefore no upwards
adjustments would be needed to comply with the proposed ETD minima (with the exemption of marginal, non-aviation
uses of kerosene). Estonia is one of the few 2004 accession round Member States that does not apply a full exemption
neither to the household use of electricity nor to natural gas. The household use of both products is taxed well above the
ETD minimum.
Estonia’s national tax rates on petrol (563 EUR/1000 litres) and gas oil (493 EUR/1000 litres) are well above the
respective ETD minima (421 and 330 EUR/1000 litres). Consequently, diesel “differentiation exists”. The new ETD
proposal would end the possibility of this differentiation. The new proposal would introduce the equal taxation of gasoline
and gas oil (expressed in EUR/GJ).
Most important fossil fuel exemptions and reductions:
Industry: Estonia applies a reduced electricity rate of 0.5 EUR/MWh (the ETD minimum) down from the national business
rate of 4.46 EUR to hyper- electro intensive manufacturing companies (above 20% share of electricity cost in total
production cost). Benefiting from the tax relief is coupled to energy efficiency improvements: beneficiaries have to
undergo EVS-EN ISO 50001 certification. A similar tax relief exists for the industrial use of natural gas, with a threshold of
13% share in total production cost. Both criteria are relatively strict compared to other Member States.
Ref. Ares(2021)4995148 - 06/08/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Cabinet of Executive Vice-President Frans Timmermans
Head of Cabinet
Brussels
CA.2.CAB STAFF/DMS
Your Excellency,
As you know, on 14 July, the Commission adopted a broad package of inter connected
policy proposals1 that allow the EU to deliver the climate and energy ambition of the
European Green Deal, notably achieving at least 55% net greenhouse gas emissions
reductions in the EU by 2030 on our pathway to climate neutrality in 2050. These legal
proposals are supported by specific impact assessments, which assess the challenges and
opportunities related to each of the proposals.
To ensure coherence across the proposals and to allow evaluation of the impacts of
combined policy proposals, the impact assessments are based on a coherent set of
modelling. This modelling builds on the 2021 Reference Scenario, which captures
existing policies, including the National Energy and Climate Plans. This 2021 Reference
scenario was updated over the course of last year in collaboration with all Member
States, which were consulted on it and verified the data relevant to them.
The final report, as well as detailed Member States’ results, can be found on the
following website:
EU Reference Scenario 2020 | Energy (europa.eu)
A core set of three policy scenarios2 to achieve at least 55% greenhouse gas emissions
reductions has been developed. These scenarios represent key interactions of the policies
proposed. Each core scenario achieves the overall greenhouse gas target through policies
implemented with similar intensity across the EU.
1
COM(2021) 550 final
2
The set of core scenarios are the REG, MIX and MIX CP scenarios. All scenarios achieve at least 55%
net greenhouse gas reduction in a cost efficient manner across the EU. The REG scenario relies
strongly on regulatory strengthening while the MIX CP scenario building on the additional use of
carbon pricing.
His Excellency Aivo ORAV
Permanent Representation of Estonia
Rue Guimard, 11-13
B-1040 Brussels
[email protected]
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
Office: BERL 12/211 - Tel. direct line +32 229-60521
[email protected]
The MIX scenario represents a policy set-up similar to the policy package proposed by
the Commission on 14 July, i.e. both a significant strengthening of the regulatory
environment as well as the increased application of carbon pricing across the economy.
Detailed Member States’ results have been made available for each of these core
scenarios to enable each Member State to assess the impacts of cost effective
implementation of policies and actions across the EU at Member State level. These
detailed results cover the energy system (including end-use sectors such as transport,
buildings and industry), non-CO2 emissions as well as emissions and removals from the
Land Use sector. It also includes air pollution impacts.
They are available on the following website:
Policy scenarios for delivering the European Green Deal | Energy (europa.eu)
Next to a purely quantitative assessment based on modelling, the Commission services
have also summarised the key features of the package per Member State in a
corresponding country fiche attached to this letter.
This overview identifies a number of opportunities and challenges related to the
transformation in your country. It looks at key data, both historical and projected,
addressing the transformation in terms of greenhouse gas emissions and energy system
changes. The fiche also gives an outlook on key distributional features in different policy
proposals as well as on other support measures available in the EU for the transformation
to a climate neutral economy. Finally, it includes a number of additional data and
projections looking at sectoral change and policies.
The Commission is sharing this overview with you to inform ahead of the upcoming
policy debate. The fiche aims to give a coherent overview of what the package may
represent for your Member State but is not a formal document and will not be discussed
alongside the legal proposals. In case you see specific data that you think require
clarifications or you seek further explanation from a technical or methodological
perspective, the Commission’s services remain available. For these matters, please refer
by e-mail to
[email protected] .
We trust that the attached country-specific information as well as the information
published online will provide useful background information for a constructive debate in
the upcoming policy discussions and we look forward to engaging with the Council and
the European Parliament in order to allow for a swift adoption of the legislative
proposals. Time is of the essence in the climate and biodiversity crises.
Yours faithfully,
Diederik Maarten SAMSON
Enclosure: Country fiche
2
Electronically signed on 04/08/2021 08:58 (UTC+02) in accordance with article 11 of Commission Decision C(2020) 4482
Saatja: Webdesktop <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 06.08.2021 18:35
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; MKM info <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>
Koopia: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; kristiina tammeraid
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>
Teema: Webdesktop: Kiri nr 10.2-12.K/886 / Volinik Frans Timmermansi kiri
"Fit for 55" teemal
Tere!Edastan. Palun saatke veel edasi, kellele vaja.Reg. number: 10.2-
12.K/886Reg. kuupäev: 06.08.2021Sisu: Volinik Frans Timmermansi kiri "Fit
for 55" kliimapaketi teemal. Edastatakse ülevaade Eestist.Heade
soovidegaTiiu
[email protected]är EV AEEL juures***
TÄHELEPANU *** See e-kiri (kaasa arvatud manused) on mõeldud ainult e-
kirja adressaatidele ning võib sisaldada ametialaseks kasutamiseks
ettenähtud teavet. Teavet ei tohi ilma saatja selgelt väljendatud loata
edasi saata ega mistahes viisil kõrvalistele isikutele avaldada. Juhul,
kui Te olete saanud käesoleva e-kirja eksituse tõttu, paluet navitage
sellest koheassttjat ning kustutage e-kiir oma arvutist.*** ATTENTION ***
This e-mail and its attachments may contaiet nficial information. yntIou
are not the intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately,
delete this e-mail and destroy any copies. Any dissemination or use of
this information by a person other than the intended recipient is
unauthorized and may be unlawful.