dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Sotsiaalministeerium
Väljaminev kiriAvalik

Vastus pöördumisele

Sotsiaalministeerium · 23. september 2020
Viit
1.4-2/2300-2
Registreeritud
23. september 2020
Dokumendi liik
Väljaminev kiri
Adressaat
European Commission, Commissioner for Jobs & Social Rights
Saabumis/saatmisviis
Outlook
Funktsioon
1.4 EL otsustusprotsess ja rahvusvaheline koostöö
Sari
1.4-2 Rahvusvahelise koostöö korraldamisega seotud kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
1.4-2/2020
Vastutaja
Agni Aav (Sotsiaalministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Euroopa Liidu ja väliskoostöö osakond)

Failid

  • 📎Kaaskiri.pdf96 KB
  • 📎X-eHealth_CONSORTIUM AGREEMENT_Sotsiaalmin...docx5143 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Aili Petti Teema: FW: Implementation of the Council Reccommentation on a EFQEA in Estonia Manused: Annex 1a_EFQEA reporting_EE.docx From: Robert Lippin <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 6:43 PM To: [email protected] Cc: Karin Ruul <[email protected]>; Teet Tiko <[email protected]>; Ülle Kurvits Brüsselis <[email protected]>; Anu Peljo <[email protected]>; Thea Treier Brüsselis <[email protected]>; Agni Aav <[email protected]>; Annely Salumaa <[email protected]> Subject: Implementation of the Council Reccommentation on a EFQEA in Estonia Dear Commissioner Schmit, Added to this email is the overview of implementation of Council Recommendation on a European Framework for Quality and Effective Apprenticeships in Estonia. The document has been created in close cooperation with the Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs and Estonian Ministry of Education and Research. Kind regards, Robert R. Lippin Deputy Secretary General Estonian Ministry of Education and Research Munga St. 18, 50088 Tartu, Estonia phone (+372) 735 4090 [email protected] www.hm.ee | fb.com/haridusministeerium | twitter.com/haridusmin 1 I mplementation of the Council Recommendation on a E uropean Framework for Quality and Effective Apprenticeships (EFQEA) Reporting template for Member States left 4649041 0 0 Introductio n 1.1 Context and purpose of the reporting The Council Recommendation of 15 March 2018 on a European Framework for Quality and Effective Apprenticeships (EFQEA) states that , as part of its actions to support EU Member States to implement the 14 EFQEA criteria, the Commission will ensure: ‘ 22. Monitoring the implementation of this Recommendation with the support of the tripartite A dvisory Committee on Vocational Training, b uilding on the existing monitoring instruments used in the framework of the European Semester ; 23. Reporting to the Council on the implementation of the Framework within three years from the date of its adoption ’. In this context , through the reporting template included in Section 2, to be completed by Member States, the Apprenticeship Support Services (AppSS) aims to : Collect up-to-date information from each EU Member State on recent and ongoing reforms on the implementation of the EFQEA at national level ; C onduct an an alysis of progress on the implementation of the EFQEA across the EU ; and P repare a preliminary analysis of the responses provided , which will feed into the Commission’s report, to be submitted to the Council. 1.2 Structure of the reporting template The reporting template (Section 2) consists of three parts : Part I: Country-specific information on apprenticeships Part II: Main developments and reforms on apprenticeships Part III: Progress per EFQEA criterion Two a nnexes (Section 3) provide additional information to complete the template : Annex I – EAfA National Commitments Annex II – Questions included in the b enchlearning self-assessment tool The AppSS also provides support to Member States (Section 4) to complete the reporting template , in case needed . 20955 4892202 0 2 .0 Reporting template – c ountry Estonia 2.1 Part I : Country-specific information on apprenticeships In this part, a few questions are asked about which apprenticeship schemes exist in your country, and what the main developments have been since the adoption of the EFQEA Recommendation in March 2018. To minimise the reporting burden and build on already existing information, the AppSS team have pre-filled some of the boxes based on information included in Cedefop’s European database on apprentice ship schemes . For each question, we ask you to check whether or not the information provided is correct and up to date and if not, to adapt in line with latest developments . Please complete all of the boxes that are not shaded in grey. Question 1 – Is the information on the understanding of apprenticeships in your country, as provided by Cedefop, correct? Information on Cedefop’s European database on apprenticeship schemes Workplace-based form of study is an equivalent to ‘apprenticeship training’ in Estonia. As defined under Article 28 of the Vocational Education Institutions Act (2013), workplace-based form of study is a form of full-time study where work practice constitutes at least two-thirds of the volume of a curriculum . The apprenticeship includes: a curriculum in the course of which a pupil performs work and study assignments with specific study objectives in the working environment under the supervision of an instructor; a tripartite contract between the VET institution, the pupil or his/her legal representative and the company that conducts the work practice regulating their relation and setting out the specific organisation of workplace-based study and the rights and obligations of the parties to the contract; the enterprise conducting the practical training pays remuneration for students for fulfilling the job assignments at enterprise, or a salary (in case there is a valid employment contract between enterprise and student). Validation of the Member State Is the information provided correct and up to date ? Yes ☒ No ☐ If no, please specify: Question 2 – Is the information on the embedding of apprenticeships in any national legislation , as provided by Cedefop, correct? Information on Cedefop’s European database on apprenticeship schemes The apprenticeship training was legalised as a new study form by Vocational Education Institutions Act in 2006. In 2007, the regulation on ‘Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning’ was introduced regulating the provision of apprenticeship training . The new regulation established that apprenticeship is integrated into the VET system and is formalised as one of two study forms (apprentices can study at all levels in the VET system), and there is no age limit for participating in VET in Estonia. The regulation was then absorbed into the reformed Vocational Education Institutions Act in September 2013 (originally adopted in 2006), as a renewed regulation establishing Article 28, paragraph 7 of the Vocational Education Institutions Act. Historically, traditional apprenticeships have strong roots in Estonia (since medieval Hansaetic times). The apprenticeship training was not practiced in Soviet times (since 1950s). It was formally regulated in 2006 but remained unpopular. In recent years it became a clear priority to expand apprenticeship training in Estonia (through a special ESF programme). As apprenticeships have a relatively recent history in Estonia, there are indications of plans to develop the WBL pathway further, for example: plans to widen the dialogue to sector organisations; organisations offering their support in finding companies for on-the-job training in addition to VET schools; expanding cooperation to single enterprises; organising work practice at tertiary level. Validation of the Member State Is the information provided correct and up to date ? Yes ☒ No ☐ If no, please specify: Question 3 – Is the information on the history of apprenticeships in your country, as provide d by Cedefop, correct? Information on Cedefop’s European database on apprenticeship schemes In 2002, the workplace-based learning as a new and innovative study form was firstly piloted in Estonia during the project named ‘Development of Work-Based Learning Programmes and Network in North-East and South Estonia and in Islands Region’. In 2006, the workplace-based learning was legalised as a new study form in addition to school-based study form by Vocational Education Institutions Act. Validation of the Member State Is the information provided correct and up to date ? Yes ☐ No ☒ If no, please specify: We would like to add that in 2015, the European Social fund program PRÕM was launched with the aim of popularizing and expanding work place -based learning. In 2019, the regulation on “Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning” was renewed and the mandatory clauses of a tripartite agreement and the amount of supervisors’ guidance fees for companies were specified. Question 4 – Is the information on the different apprenticeship schemes in your country, as provided by Cedefop, correct? Information on Cedefop’s European database on apprenticeship schemes In Estonia , there is one main apprenticeship scheme. Workplace-based learning ( Töökohapõhine õppevorm ) Description : Apprenticeship training is targeted at: people who have completed or have not completed basic and upper secondary education, but who do not have any professional skills; younger people who prefer practical training to school-based studies, often identified as students with low academic levels; unemployed people; already working employees that do not have a required qualification. Status of the learner : The apprentices retain their status as students, unless the apprentice signs a work contract with the company (which is then covered by the Labour Code). The apprenticeship contract is only partly covered by the Labour Code (in terms of regulating the working time). Apprenticeship training participants are entitled to all the customary rights of vocational school students but also wages are paid to the apprentice. Level : Apprentices can study at all levels and in all programmes in the Estonian VET system. The only exception is level 351/353 (3C) programmes, where the apprentices can enter directly, while the other students have to enter the level 354 (3B) programme first and show that they have difficulties with the general education part of the curriculum. Number of enrolled learners in this scheme in 2018 (and 2019, if available) : In 2017, 921 pupils participated in school and work-based vocational programmes . T here are also active labour market policies and number of measures provided by Estonian Unemployment Insurance Fund which have apprenticeship elements, but can’t be entirely defined as apprenticeships. Validation by the Member State Is the information provided correct and up to date ? Yes ☐ No ☒ If no, please specify: Level : Apprentices can study at all levels and in all programmes in the Estonian VET system (without exceptions) . Comment: there is no differences anymore compared to school-based programmes entry requirements . Number of enrolled learners in workplace-based learning ( Töökohapõhine õppevorm ) 1729 (study year 2017/2018), 1729 (18/19), 1919 (19/20) 2.2 Part II : The m ain developments and reforms o f apprenticeships In this part, questions are asked about past and planned country-level developments . You are also invited to refer to the EAfA National Commitments to complete this section (see Annex I). Please fill in the white boxes in the tables below, following the instructions highlighted in yellow , and delete the yellow instructions when your answer is complete. Please delet e or add in extra rows where relevant for the amount of each of the apprenticeship schemes existing in your country . If no reforms or implementation measures have been planned or have taken since March 2018, please state this and briefly explain the reasons for this. Question 5 – Please discuss the country-level developments concerning apprenticeships in your country since March 2018 . For your information , you can find in Annex I the EAfA National Commitments for your country . PRÕM Description : Since March 2018, no new reform s ha ve been implemented . In 2015, the European Social Fund project PRÕM was launched and its activities will last until 2022. The aim of the project is to expand work-based learning and improve the quality of work-based learning. Within the framework of PRÕM, new learners are involved in work place -based learning, companies are informed about work place -based learning, the number of companies offering apprenticeship training is expanded, the best work practice and work place -based learning companies are recognized, and supervisors are trained. In 2019, a pilot project on quality assessment of the workplace-based learning process in schools was started within the project PRÕM. Apprenticeship scheme(s) affected : Estonia has only one Apprenticeship scheme , descri ption is given above . Results : Since the beginning of the program, the share of graduates in the workplace-based study form has increased from 4% to 12.4%. More than 6,000 work-based learning instructors have been trained Links : https://www.innove.ee/prom/tookohapohine-ope/ (only in Estonian) Name of the second development / reform in English ( n ame of the development / reform in the national language in brackets and italics ) Description : please provide a short description of the reform taken (context, aims / objectives, main actions included in the reform, etc.) : N/A Apprenticeship scheme(s) affected : please describe which apprenticeship scheme(s) and how they were affected by the reform : N/A Results : please describe any results of the reform : N/A Links : please include links to the (planned) reform / development, if available : N/A Question 6 – Please indicate any upcoming reforms or measures . PRÕM+ Description : Estonia plans to continue with the activities of PRÕM in the new period of structural funds. By the reform (PRÕM+) , workplace-based learning is expanded in priority fields and target groups (foremost youths , people with special educational needs and also SM Es ). The quality and accessibility of the process of internship and work-based learning (incl. training of company and school instructors, cooperation of schools and companies in developing and implementing internship and work-based learning, evidence based and cooperational learning (benchlearning), development activities) are ensured. The cooperation of employers and educational institutions in developing an internship system and work-based learning is supported. Apprenticeship scheme(s) affected : Estonia has only one Apprenticeship scheme, description above. Results : N/A Links : N/A Question 7 – Please briefly describe what impacts the COVID-19 crisis had on apprenticeships in your country and indicate any developments and / or measures related to apprenticeships to respond to the crisis (if any). Impact P lease briefly describe the impact : The crisis had rather small to moderate impact o n work place -based learning and no specific measures were planned. The most common problems were bankruptcy of the company (in which case the school found a new company for the student or the student continued school-based learning), suspension of the company and at that time the student could not acquire learning outcomes (in this case the study period was extended or the student had a school break). Development s / measure s Please briefly describe the development s / policy measures : The M inistry of Education and R esearch monitors the situation and, if necessary, finds a solution in cooperation with schools and companies. Question 8 – How could the EU support you to tackle specific challenges related to apprenticeships as a result of the impact of the COVID-19 crisis ? Please describe your response below: Support the exchange of experiences and mutual learning, especially between similar countries (apprenticeship scheme with similar or similar problems and challenges). Question 9 – Please describe whether and how, equal access and gender equality are being ensured and/or promoted in the apprenticeship schemes in your country ? Please describe your response below: As the share of work-based learning is small in Estonia, the aim is to expand work-based learning and involve all target groups. Workplace-based training is open to all applicants. No limi ts have been imposed on persons. Enrolment requirements pertaining to prior education are dependent on the type of vocational training applied for and whether the applicant wishes to study according to initial or follow up curricula. Question 10 – Please describe how your country i nclude d the relevant implementing measures in the National Reform Programmes under the European Semester ? Please describe your response below: Since 2016 d evelopment of work-based learning in vocational education; additional apprenticeship opportunities are being created and traineeship systems for vocational and higher educational institutions are being developed . The enlargement of apprenticeships studies is long-term process – it depends on the education system, but also on the situation in labour market, employers’ needs and attitudes, and the ability to offer mentors and study places in companies. Question 11 – Please describe whether and to what extent EU funds are being used to support apprenticeship schemes, and explain to what extent the EFQEA criteria are applied? Please describe your response below: Since 2015 Estonia uses EU funds to expand and popularize work place -based learning (project PRÕM) . All activities (incl pilots) are more or less in line with the EFQEA criteria . 2.3 Part III : Progress per EFQEA criterion In this part, questions are asked per criterion to review progress. In order to complete the assessment per criterion, the questions from the benchlearning self-assessment tool can be used for inspiration ( see Annex II) . I n the case that your country is taking part in the benchlearning activity and , a s part of this, has already completed the benchlearning self-assessment tool, you can also refer to the information from the self-assessment tool. Please fill in the white boxes in the tables for each criterion below, and briefly explain your response each time (even if no development took place) . Question 12 – To what extent are the following seven EFQEA c riteria for learning and working conditions in place in your country, and have any developments take n place relating to these criteria since March 2018? Criterion 1: Written contract / agreement EFQEA definition : ‘ Before the start of the apprenticeship a written agreement should be concluded to define the rights and obligations of the apprentice, the employer, and where appropriate the vocational education and training institution, related to learning and working conditions. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☐ (Some) d iscussion s have started, but this did not lead to any new measures ( yet ) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme chang e (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☒ Please explain your response : The written agreement is set out in r egulation on ‘Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning " from 2006. In 2019, the Regulation specified the principles of the agreement and the mandatory parts of the agreement. Criterion 2: Learning outcomes EFQEA definition : ‘ The delivery of a set of comprehensive learning outcomes defined in accordance with national legislation should be agreed by the employers and vocational education and training institutions and, where appropriate, trade unions. This should ensure a balance between job-specific skills, knowledge and key competences for lifelong learning supporting both the personal development and lifelong career opportunities of the apprentices with a view to adapt to changing career patterns. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: Work-based learning takes place on the basis of the school curriculum. The school prepares the curriculum on the basis of a professional standard (prepared by the representatives of the employers) or in cooperation with the employers. The general requirements and principles (volume of study, completion of studies, learning outcomes etc) of the curriculum are established in the vocational education standard (https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/515012020003/consolide) Criterion 3: Pedagogical support EFQEA definition : ‘ In-company trainers should be designated and tasked to cooperate closely with vocational education and training institutions and teachers to provide guidance to apprentices and to ensure mutual and regular feed-back. Teachers, trainers and mentors, specially in micro-, small and medium-sized companies, should be supported to update their skills, knowledge and competences in order to train apprentices according to the latest teaching and training methods and labour market needs. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☒ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☐ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any changes (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☒ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: According to the regulation on “ Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning ” t he company and school has an obligation to appoint a tutor s for the student and tutor’s contacts are fixed in a tripartite agreement. A school shall ensure the preparation of instructors for supervising students in work-based learning, proceeding from the specifics of work-based learning. From 202 1 , the partial occupational qualification of company tutors ( praktikajuhendaja ettevõttes ) ( part of professional occupational standard of vocational teacher) will come into force. Criterion 4: Workplace component EFQEA definition : ‘ A substantial part of the apprenticeship, meaning at least half of it, should be carried out in the workplace with, where possible, the opportunity to undertake a part of the workplace experience abroad. Taking into account the diversity of national schemes, the aim is to progress gradually towards that share of the apprenticeship being workplace learning. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measure (yet ) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: According to the regulation on “ Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning ” at least of 2/3 of study take place in company. The student has the opportunity to complete part of the study abroad (Erasmus) . Criterion 5: Pay and/or comp ensation EFQEA definition : ‘ Apprentices should be paid or otherwise compensated, in line with national or sectoral requirements or collective agreements where they exist, and taking into account arrangements on cost-sharing between employers and public authorities. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: According to the regulation on “ Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning ” the school reimburses for the company the tutor salary, which is related to the teacher's minimum wage. The company conducting the practical training pays remuneration for students for fulfilling the job assignments at enterprise, or a salary (in case there is a valid employment contract between enterprise and student). School pays the monthly basic allowance EUR 60. Around 40% of apprentices receive the allowance based on performance merit. Criterion 6 : Social protection EFQEA definition : ‘ Apprentices should be entitled to social protection, including necessary insurance in line with national legislation. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: A pprentices have the same social guarantees as learners in school-based VET . VET learners can apply for basic and special study allowances: (a) the monthly basic allowance is EUR 60 and is available from semester two in formal full-time programmes. Around 40% of VET learners receive the allowance based on performance merit; (b) a special allowance can be granted to learners in a difficult economic situation; Lunchtime meals are also paid by the State. This applies to VET learners up to age 20 who have not completed secondary education according to the initial training curricula (Parliament, 2013). VET learners are reimbursed public transport tickets between the learning venue and home. Dormitory residents and those who rent apartments close to the learning venue are reimbursed one return ticket to their hometown per week and an additional ticket during national and school holidays. Criterion 7 : Work, health and safety conditions EFQEA definition : ‘ The host workplace should comply with relevant rules and regulations on working conditions, in particular health and safety legislation. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: According to the regulation on “ Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning ” the apprenticeship contract between the school, learner and employee stipulates the rights and obligations of parties as well as the details of the learning process and it should be in accordance with the labour code but learners retain student status even if the employment contract is signed in addition to the apprenticeship contract. Question 1 3 – To what extent are the following seven EFQEA criteria for framework conditions in place in your country, and have any developments take n place in relation to these criteria since March 2018? Criterion 8 : Regulatory framework EFQEA definition : ‘ A clear and consistent regulatory framework should be in place based on a fair and equitable partnership approach, including a structured and transparent dialogue among all relevant stakeholders. This may include accreditation procedures for companies and workplaces that offer apprenticeships and/or other quality assurance measures. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☐ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☒ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: Before concluding an agreement, the school and the company work together to assess the learning conditions in order to make sure that the company is ready to meet the objectives of the curriculum and to ensure the safety and health of the student. Also w hich learning outcomes described in the curriculum can be acquired in a company and which are ensured in a school or other company . VET institutions cooperate with CHAPTER 2. Provision of VET 29 employers to design implementation plans for apprentices based on the existing curricula. The result of the evaluation is a written expert assessment, which is attached to the apprenticeship contract. Additional evaluation of the placement may also be carried out during the placement. VET quality is assured through external and internal processes that make no difference in their approach between school-based learning, work-based learning and self-learning . In 2019 and 2020, the quality assessment of the workplace-based learning process will be piloted within the framework of the PRÕM program. The aim of quality assessment is to support schools in ensuring the quality of work-based learning. Criterion 9 : Involvement of social partners EFQEA definition : ‘ Social partners, including, where relevant, at sectoral level and/or intermediary bodies, should be involved in the design, governance and implementation of apprenticeship schemes, in line with national industrial relations systems and education and training practices. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: Social partners, including trade unions and employer organisations participated in the working group on developing legislation. At local level, social partners participate in VET school counsellor boards. Advisory bodies link VET schools and society, advising the school and its management on planning and organising educational and economic activities. VET curricula s are based on the VET standard and the respective professional standard(s). Where such standards do not exist, the school must apply for recognition of the curriculum by social partners. Criterion 10 : Support for companies (cost-sharing arrangements) EFQEA definition : ‘ Financial and/or non-financial support should be envisaged, particularly for micro-, small and medium-sized companies, enabling cost-effective apprenticeships for companies, taking into account, when appropriate, cost-sharing arrangements between employers and public authorities. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☒ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☐ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☐ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☒ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: Schools are responsible for conducting work-based learning, and the state finances work-based learning for schools (structural funds, state budget). Funding covers training in school, training of company tutors and supervisor’s fees for the company. According to the regulation on “Policies and Conditions for Implementing Workplace-Based Learning” is set minimum supervisor fee and its related to the minimum salary of a vocational teacher. The company can decide how it will use the fee. Criterion 11 : Flexible pathways and mobility EFQEA definition : ‘ To facilitate access, entry requirements for apprenticeships should take into account relevant informal and non-formal learning and/or, if relevant, the accomplishment of preparatory programs. Qualifications acquired through apprenticeships should be included in nationally recognised qualification frameworks referenced to the European Qualifications Framework. Apprenticeships should allow access to other learning opportunities, including at higher education and training levels, career pathways and/or, where relevant, the accumulation of units of learning outcomes. Transnational mobility of apprentices, either at the workplace or education and training institutions, should be progressively promoted as a component of apprenticeship qualifications. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: Workplace based learning can be offered at all VET levels and in all its forms (initial and continuing), and lead to qualifications at EQF levels 2 to 5. Apprenticeships follow the same curri cula as school-based programmes and have to pass the same final exam inations as in school-based VET. Vocational training (incl workplace-based learning) is open to all applicants. No limits have been imposed on persons who have already acquired either vocational or higher education but who wish to supplement their knowledge base or learn a new trade or craft. Enrolment requirements pertaining to prior education are dependent on the type of vocational training applied for and whether the applicant wishes to study according to initial or follow up curricula. Criterion 1 2: Career guidance and awareness raising EFQEA definition : ‘ Career guidance, mentoring and learner support should be provided before and during the apprenticeship to ensure successful outcomes, to prevent and reduce drop-outs as well as support those learners to reengage into relevant education and training pathways. Apprenticeships should be promoted as an attractive learning pathway through widely targeted awareness-raising activities. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☐ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☒ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: All curricula must include entrepreneurship competence s, it is the ability to take initiative, act creatively, plan one’s own career in the modern economic, business and work environment, applying knowledge and skill s in different spheres of life. Career guidance is provided within formal education as part of the curricula. Each apprentice is supported by two supervisors: one at school and one at the workplace. In 2015, the ESF program PRÕM was launched with the aim of popularizing and expanding workplace-based learning. Criterion 13 : Transparency EFQEA definition : ‘ The transparency of, and access to apprenticeship offers within and between Member States should be ensured, including with the support of public and private employment services as well as other relevant bodies, and, when appropriate, by using Union tools such as EURES as provided for in the EURES regulation. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☒ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☐ Please explain your response: Vocational training is open to all applicants. No limits have been imposed on persons who have already acquired either vocational or higher education but who wish to supplement their knowledge base or learn a new trade or craft. Enrolment requirements pertaining to prior education are dependent on the type of vocational training applied for and whether the applicant wishes to study according to initial or follow up curricula. The European job mobility portal (EURES) network counsellors are engaged in 16 career information points that help search for jobs in the EU and the European Free Trade Association countries. There are career information specialists and counsellors working in every public employment service department. Criterion 14 : Quality assurance and graduate tracking EFQEA definition : ‘ Quality assurance approaches should be in place taking into account the European Quality Assurance Reference Framework for Vocational Education and Training (EQAVET) , including a process allowing a valid and reliable assessment of the learning outcomes. The tracking of employment and career progression of the apprentices should be pursued, in accordance with national and European legislation on data protection. ’ State of play in March 2018 Developments In our country, this criterion is: Not in place at all ☐ Somewhat in place ☐ To a large extent in place ☐ Fully in place ☒ Since March 2018, the following developments took place in relation to this criterion: No action taken ☐ (Some) discussions have started, but this did not lead to any new measures (yet) ☐ Initial stage of system/scheme change (some changes are visible) ☐ Advanced stage of system/scheme change ( changes are visible throughout the system/scheme) ☒ Please explain your response: VET quality is assured through external and internal processes that make no difference in their approach between school-base d learning, work-based learning and self-learning (including ‘non-stationary’) . The right to provide initial and continuing VET in the curriculum group is granted to a school for a specified term or without a term . The education minister decides the granting of this right on the basis of documents submitted by the school, the results of external assessment by an expert committee, and additional evidence, if necessary . To extend this right, the curriculum group must be accredited. Accreditation comprises external evaluation of curriculum groups at schools, based on their internal evaluation reports and assessment conducted by an external committee. Performance, sustainability, leadership, cooperation with stakeholders and management of resources, including human resources, are evaluated. Accreditation is organised by th e Education and Youth Authority . The evaluation report, including the internal evaluation, is publicly available and the outcomes are used to improve curricula and learning methods, strategic planning and management of VET providers. The education ministry, as the owner of VET schools, evaluates the reports in the light of strategic development planning at provider and system level. Education system data are collected in the Estonian education information system. This has information on education providers, learners, teaching staff, curricula and diplomas. The visual educational statistics database HaridusSilm allows comparing schools according to selected indicators. Question 1 4 – Please select at least three criteria on which the most progress has been mad e and provide a short description of the developments and progress made. Criterion 2 Learning outcomes Please explain your response: Employers and professional associations are all involved in the creation of workplace-based curricula. The general requirements and principles (volume of study, completion of studies, learning outcomes etc) of the curriculum are established in the vocational education standard . If the curriculum is based on a occupational standard, the study ends with a occupat ional qualification certificate. Before starting the study, the school and the company agree on which learning outcomes the learner can acquire at school and which in the company. The implementation plan of the curriculum (moodulite rakenduskava) is prepared in cooperation. Criterion 5: Pay and/or compensation Please explain your response: In cooperation with the employers' representatives and the trade union, the minimum amount of salary (or compensation) to be paid to the apprentice has been agreed and it is fixed in the legislation. Criterion 9 Involvement of social partners Please explain your response: Employers' representatives are involved in the development of workplace-based learning and the development of legislation. For example, the Estonian Employers' Confederation is a partner of the ESF program PRÕM program. Its task is to popularize work place -based learning (especially among employers), they are involved in the development and implementation of pilot projects. They also organize a competition for the best practice and work-based learning company (including a small company, a regional company) and a competition for the selection of the best trainee and apprentice "Praktik Cum Laude" ( https://www.employers.ee/en/news/czentralnyj-soyuz-rabotodatelej-estonii-prizyvaet-predpriyatiya-nominirovat-svoih-luchshih-praktikantov-na-konkurs-praktik-cum-laude/ ). If, in your country’s opinion, significant progress has been made on any other criteria, please describe this below: Question 1 5 – Please select at least three criteria where your country is experiencing implementation challenges and provide a short description of the specific implementation challenges related to each criterion. Criterion 1 0 Support for companies (cost-sharing arrangements) Please explain your response: Companies (especially small ones) expect more support, especially when they take on a young person. Today, schools train company supervisors and compensate the company for the remuneration of instructors. Criterion 14 Quality assurance and graduate tracking Please explain your response: The challenge is to ensure the quality of learning in the company. Before starting studies, the school assesses whether the necessary conditions for conducting studies exist in the company. It also trains co mpany supervisors if necessary. Criterion 3 (please replace with the relevant criterion) Please explain your response: If, in your country’s opinion, there have been chellenges implementing other criteria too, please describe those below: Question 1 6 – What further EU support would be beneficial to help you overcome the implementation challenges described in relation to the EFQEA criteria in question 15 ? Please describe your response below: Support the exchange of experiences and mutual learning, especially between similar countries (apprenticeship scheme with similar or similar problems and challenges). The Benchlearning process should definitely be continued. 20955 4892202 0 3.0 Annexes 3.1 Annex I – EAfA National Commitments for name of the country The EAfA National Commitments for your country were provided as a separate a nnex in the email sen t to you. The EAfA National Commitments for your country can be used as inspiration to complete Part II of the reporting template, in which questions are asked about past and planned developments of apprenticeships your country. 3.2 Annex II – Questions included in the benchlearning self-assessment tool The table below can be used as inspiration to complete Part III of the reporting template, in which questions are asked about the details o f progress per EAfA criterion . In the case that your country is taking part in the benchlearning activity and, a s part of this, has already completed the benchlearning self-assessment tool, you can also refer to the information from the self-assessment itself . Criterion 1: Written contract / agreement 1.1 There is a written contract/agreement between either the employer and the learner, or the learner, the employer and the training institution / PES 1.2 Is there a procedure in place in case of breach of contract/agreement? 1.3 This contract/written a gre ement covers: 1.3.1 The duration of the learning in the company 1.3.2 The employers’ obligations 1.3.3 The apprentices’ rights and obligations 1.3.4 Details of remuneration 1.3.5 The hours in company 1.3.6 The holiday entitlement 1.3.7 How to terminate the contract/agreement Criterion 2: Learning outcomes 2.1 There is a system in place that requires the relevant actors (the employer, the education and training institution, and where relevant trade union) to agree the learning outcomes to be achieved by the individual apprentice in advance 2.1.1 This system takes into account needs and demands from different stakeholders (including companies, trade unions and society (government) 2.1.2 This system also takes into account future employment needs reflecting national and/or sectoral priorities 2.1.3 There is guidance in place for how learning outcomes should be described within programmes 2.2 The learning outcomes include non-occupation specific competences (e.g. transversal competences; key competences; competences to promote lifelong-learning and career changing/flexibility competences) Criterion 3: Pedagogical support 3.1 Employers have to assign a qualified staff member (in-company trainer) to train apprentices and/or provide mentoring 3.2 Quality and qualification criteria are defined for in-company staff (trainers/tutors/mentors) to train apprentices 3.3 In-company trainers engage in continuous professional development (CPD) activities 3.3.1 CPD includes both job-specific / technical competences and pedagogical competences 3.3.2 Undertaking CPD is a specified or legal requirement 3.4 Staff in VET institutions involved in apprenticeship delivery (teachers, trainers, mentors etc.) undertake CPD 3.4.1 CPD includes both job-specific / technical competences and pedagogical competences 3 .4.2 Undertaking CPD is a specified or legal requirement 3.5 Mechanisms for cooperation and exchange between in-company trainers and teachers (e.g. in schools) are in place 3.6 There are specific measures to support teachers, trainers and mentors in SMEs Criterion 4: Workplace component 4.1 There are general guidelines for the coordination of the work-based and school-based training 4.2 At least half of the time devoted to the apprenticeship is carried out in the workplace 4.2.1 If no, what is the approximate share? 4.2.2 Are there governmental plans to gradually increase this share (e.g. through providing administrative and/or financial support)? 4.3 Training plans or similar are in place that ensure that in-company learning covers a comprehensive set of practical skills and competencies required for a qualification 4.4 There are opportunities for mobility during apprenticeships that are available on a consistent and systematic basis Criterion 5: Pay and/or compensation 5.1 Which of the following do apprentices receive: 5.1.1 A salary (taxable income) 5.1.2 An allowance or compensation (non-taxable) 5.1.3 Only a reimbursement of expenses 5.1.4 Other form of compensation 5.2 What is the source of the wage/allowance/compensation? 5.3 What is the wage/allowance-setting mechanism? 5.4 Apprentices receive other financial support (e.g. study loans, reimbursement of travel costs etc.) 5.5 Apprentices are exempt from paying tuition fees Criterion 6: Social protection 6.1 Apprentices are covered by specific social protection regulations that specifically target apprentices 6.2 Apprentices are protected in case of company failure (e.g. bankruptcy) to continue the training Criterion 7: Work, health and safety conditions 7.1 There is regular inspection of work, health, and safety conditions in the apprenticeship workplace? 7.2 Apprentices are covered by health and safety regulations in the workplace 7.3 Apprentices are informed and trained to apply correctly the health and safety regulations in the workplace Criterion 8: Regulatory framework 8.1 A clear legal/regulatory framework is in place that covers all apprenticeship partners 8.1.1 This framework clearly outlines the mutual rights and responsibilities for each partner – e.g. VET providers, employers 8.1.2 This framework sets out a clear and balanced distribution of responsibilities between VET providers and employers 8.2 The regulatory framework includes quality assurance requirements or accreditation for companies to be engaged in the apprenticeship scheme? 8.3 Different levels of legislation (e.g. national and regional levels) cover apprenticeship schemes 8.4 (if applicable) There is adequate coordination between these levels of legislation with strategic and operational functions clearly defined Criterion 9: Involvement of social partners 9.1 A mechanism is in place to promote structured and transparent dialogue between all social partners and, where relevant, intermediary bodies? 9.2 Employer organisations, trade unions and/or other intermediary bodies are involved in the definition of learning outcomes of apprenticeship schemes, including where relevant at the sectoral level 9.3 Employer and employee representatives (e.g. trade unions) and/or intermediary bodies play a role in the final assessment of apprentices 9.4 Employer and employee representatives and/or intermediary bodies play a role in quality assurance 9.5 Employer and employee representatives and/or intermediary bodies are involved in developing (future) policies related to the apprenticeship system or schemes 9.6 Employer and employee representatives and/or intermediary bodies are involved in identifying and expressing the demand for apprenticeships at sectoral/occupational level 9.7 Social partners and/or intermediary bodies play a role in the development of apprenticeship curricula and/or in defining learning outcomes Criterion 10: Support for companies (cost-sharing arrangements) 10.1 Apprenticeship schemes are supported financially by public authorities, enabling cost-effective apprenticeships for companies 10.2 Cost-sharing arrangements are in place that, as appropriate, enable the sharing of apprenticeship costs between employers and public authorities 10.3 In what form is financial support provided? 10.3.1 Tax incentives 10.3.2 Grants 10.3.3 Other 10.4 Specific financial support is available that is targeted at SMEs 10.5 Non-financial support is available to companies, including SMEs, to help with their engagement (e.g. support with accreditation procedures) 10.6 Recognition and/or award schemes are in place for companies that provide quality apprenticeships Criterion 11: Flexible pathways and mobility 11.1 Mechanisms are in place to validate apprentices’ prior learning – formal, non-formal and informal – and these are taken into account for accessing apprenticeship programmes. 11.2 Apprenticeship schemes provide qualifications which are formally recognised within National Qualification Frameworks and/or the European Qualification Framework 11.3 Apprenticeship schemes offer learners access to further specialisation, also at higher qualification levels 11.4 There are pathways in place that offer a route between preparatory / pre-apprenticeship programmes and full apprenticeships 11.5 Apprenticeship schemes offer opportunities for the transnational mobility of apprentices on a consistent and systematic basis, either at the workplace or through education and training institutions Criterion 12: Career guidance and awareness raising 12.1 Quality information on apprenticeship characteristics and opportunities is systematically provided to all potential apprentices (and their parents)? 12.2 Careers guidance from qualified professionals is part of apprenticeship schemes 12.3 Mentoring support is provided to apprentices? 12.4 Marketing and awareness-raising initiatives are implemented to promote apprenticeships as an attractive learning pathway (competitions; advertisements; awards; etc.)? 12.5 Mechanisms are in place to support the matching of potential learners to apprenticeship opportunities? 12.6 Potential apprentices and their parents receive targeted, unbiased and comprehensive information about apprenticeship and what is on offer. 12.7 Apprentices receive support in finding places (through the VET provider, chambers, employer organisations, etc.). 12.8 Mechanisms are in place to monitor and address dropout rates from apprenticeships Criterion 13: Transparency 13.1 Information about apprenticeship opportunities and places is easily accessible for potential apprentices (and their parents) 13.1.1 Such information is accessible via a job portal 13.2 Apprenticeship offers are published in a publicly available format 13.2.1 Such offers are accessible via a job-portal 13.3 Apprenticeship offers are published outside of the country or on an European platform (e.g. EURES) Criterion 14: Quality assurance and graduate tracking 14.1 Training institutions and companies periodically carry out self-assessments under regional frameworks or at their own initiative 14.2 Training institutions and companies are subject to periodic quality assurance inspections carried out by independent bodies 14.3 Companies are subject to periodic external quality assurance inspections around apprenticeship provision 14.4 Is there a quality assurance framework for apprenticeships 14.4.1 Does this lead to outputs that anticipate skills needs, and provide forecasts of supply and demand for apprenticeship places? 14.4.2 Do quality assurance mechanisms build on EQAVET framework? 14.5 Are responsibilities for quality assurance shared, and are roles and responsibilities clear in terms of the process? 14.6 Public authorities produce statistics to show the transition rate from apprenticeship to employment 14.7 Ex-ante impact appraisals are in place to inform the development of apprenticeship schemes 14.8 Ex-post impact evaluations are undertaken in respect of apprenticeship schemes 20955 4892202 0 4 .0 Support available to Member States 4 .1 Summary of support available Should you have any queries about completing the reporting template, there will be designated AppSS team members to contact for support. Key elements of the support the AppSS team members will be able to provide you with are: Responding to any queries on the reporting template . Advising on practical aspects of completing the reporting process – e.g. which (parts of) questions have to be completed, which (parts of) questions can be left more open (for example, because little or no developments have taken place since March 2018) , the level of detail required in each question, etc. Support with comment ing on and finalis ing the reporting template from a linguistic and formatting point of view. Table 5.1 Support contacts AppSS contact Countries Simon Broek [email protected] Austria, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Malta , Netherlands, Sweden Fran çois Staring [email protected] Belgium, Cyprus , France, Italy, Ireland, Luxembourg , Slovenia Lucija Kilic [email protected] Croatia, Hungary, Poland, Portugal, Spain Ionela Bulceag [email protected] Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Greece , Romania Milda Butkute [email protected] Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovakia 20955 4892202 0 -251460 1884680 You can download our publications or subscribe for free at: https://ec.europa.eu/social/publications If you would like to receive regular updates about the Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion sign up to receive the free Social Europe e-newsletter at: https://ec.europa.eu/social/e-newsletter You can download our publications or subscribe for free at: https://ec.europa.eu/social/publications If you would like to receive regular updates about the Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion sign up to receive the free Social Europe e-newsletter at: https://ec.europa.eu/social/e-newsletter 320040 4523105 EU_Social 0 EU_Social -127635 4485005 0 0 320040 3961130 Social Europe Social Europe -127635 3923030 0 0
Allikas: Sotsiaalministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel