Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , as amended International Labour Organization Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , as amended International Labour Office Geneva Copyright © International Labour Organization 2009 First published 2009 Publications of the International Labour Office enjoy copyright under Protocol 2 of the Uni - versal Copyright Convention. Nevertheless, short excerpts from them may be reproduced without authorization, on condition that the source is indicated. For rights of reproduction or translation, application should be made to ILO Publications (Rights and Permissions), International Labour Office, CH-1211 Geneva 22, Switzerland, or by email:
[email protected]. The International Labour Office welcomes such applications. Libraries, institutions and other users registered with reproduction rights organizations may make copies in accordance with the licences issued to them for this purpose. Visit www.ifrro. org to find the reproduction rights organization in your country. I L O Guidel i n e s f o r fla g S t at e i n spection s unde r t h e Marit i m e Labou r Convent i on , 2 006. Geneva , Int e r n ationa l Labou r Off ice , 2009 ISB N 9 78-92-2-121741- 1 (print ) ISB N 9 78-92-2-121742- 8 (web) me r cha n t mar i n e / s eafa r e r / w o r k i n g c o nd i t i o n s / la b ou r i n s p e c t i o n / s u p e r v is o r y mach i n er y / IL O Convent i o n / app l ication . 1 0.05.3 A l s o availabl e i n French : Dir e ct i v e s p o u r l e s i n s p e c ti o n s d e s Etat s d u p avi l l o n e n v e rtu d e l a c o n v e n ti o n d u t r avai l mar i time , 2 0 0 6 (IS B N 978-92- 2 -2217 4 1- 0) , Geneva , 2009, an d i n Spa n i s h : P a ut a s par a l a s i n sp e c c i o n e s p o r e l E s t a d o d e l p a b e ll ó n e n v i rt u d d e l C o nve ni o s o b r e e l t r a b a j o ma r í t i m o , 200 6 (ISB N 978-92-2- 3 21741-9) , Gene v a , 2009. IL O Cat a l o g u i n g in P u b li c a t i o n D a ta I L O Guidel i n e s f o r fla g S t at e i n spection s unde r t h e Marit i m e Labou r Convent i on , 2 006. Geneva , Int e r n ationa l Labou r Off ice , 2009 ISB N 9 78-92-2-121741- 1 (print ) ISB N 9 78-92-2-121742- 8 (web) me r cha n t mar i n e / s eafa r e r / w o r k i n g c o nd i t i o n s / la b ou r i n s p e c t i o n / s u p e r v is o r y mach i n er y / IL O Convent i o n / app l ication . 1 0.05.3 A l s o availabl e i n French : Dir e ct i v e s p o u r l e s i n s p e c ti o n s d e s Etat s d u p avi l l o n e n v e rtu d e l a c o n v e n ti o n d u t r avai l mar i time , 2 0 0 6 (IS B N 978-92- 2 -2217 4 1- 0) , Geneva , 2009, an d i n Spa n i s h : P a ut a s par a l a s i n sp e c c i o n e s p o r e l E s t a d o d e l p a b e ll ó n e n v i rt u d d e l C o nve ni o s o b r e e l t r a b a j o ma r í t i m o , 200 6 (ISB N 978-92-2- 3 21741-9) , Gene v a , 2009. IL O Cat a l o g u i n g in P u b li c a t i o n D a ta The designations employed in ILO publications, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the International Labour Office concerning the legal status of any country, area or territory or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers. The responsibility for opinions expressed in signed articles, studies and other contributions rests solely with their authors, and publication does not constitute an endorsement by the International Labour Office of the opinions expressed in them. Reference to names of firms and commercial products and processes does not imply their en - dorsement by the International Labour Office, and any failure to mention a particular firm, commercial product or process is not a sign of disapproval. ILO publications can be obtained through major booksellers or ILO local offices in many countries, or direct from ILO Publications, International Labour Office, CH-1211 Geneva 22, Switzerland . Catalogues or lists of new publications are available free of charge from the above address, or by email:
[email protected]. Visit our web site: www.ilo.org/publns. Photocomposed by the ILO, Geneva, Switzerland DTP Printed in France NOU Preface When the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 (MLC, 2006), was adopted by the 94th (Maritime) Session of the International Labour Conference of the International Labour Organization (ILO) in February 2006, it was described as a “historic event”. The MLC, 2006, is seen by seafarers as a “charter of rights” that will help ensure “Decent Work” for seafarers, no matter where ships sail and no matter which flag they fly. Shipowners also support the MLC, 2006, as it is seen as an important new tool to help ensure a level playing field for quality shipowners that may have to compete with ships that have substandard conditions. The MLC, 2006, is also im - portant for governments because it brings together nearly 70 inter- national legal instruments in one comprehensive modern document that covers almost every aspect of decent work in this sector. A key feature of the MLC, 2006, is that it builds on the strengths of the ILO approach to making sure that, in each country, international labour standards are effectively implemented at the “ground level” and enforced. At the same time the MLC, 2006, meets the challenges of this globalized industry by taking over many elements that are found in other major maritime Conventions and have contributed to the success of those Conventions in ensuring safer and secure shipping and preventing marine pollution. The most important of these elements is found in the emphasis in the MLC, 2006, on effective flag State inspection and certification of ships. Flag State inspectors, including those from Recognized Organizations, are at the front line of the combat to ensure decent conditions of work for seafarers. An effective and coordinated sys- tem of regular inspections, monitoring and other control measures of ships adopted by the competent authorities in flag States is the primary tool for ensuring that ships meet the requirements of the Guidelines for flag State inspections under the MLC, 2006 MLC, 2006, as implemented in national laws, regulations, collective bargaining agreements and practice. The International Labour Conference saw the importance of ensuring that the MLC, 2006, was backed up by an effective system for inspections by flag States complemented by a widespread har - monized port State control. It adopted two key resolutions intended to support the promotion, ratification and effective im - plementation of the Convention and the achievement of decent working and living conditions for seafarers. 1 These two resolutions are the “Resolution concerning the de- velopment of guidelines for port State control” (resolution IV), and the “Resolution concerning the development of guidelines for flag State inspection” (resolution XIII). Both resolutions called for tri- partite meetings of experts to develop guidelines for flag State in- spections and to assist port State control officers carrying out MLC, 2006, inspections. Resolution XIII on developing guidelines for flag State inspec - tion requested the ILO Director-General to convene a tripartite ex- pert meeting to develop “… suitable guidance for flag State inspec - tion .” The resolution explained that the success of the Convention will depend, among others, upon the uniform and harmonized im - plementation of flag State responsibilities in accordance with its relevant provisions, and that given the global nature of the shipping industry, it is important for flag State inspectors to receive proper guidelines for the performance of their duties . Developing international guidelines and the related national flag State inspections and guidelines for their inspectors is an important aspect of implementation of the MLC, 2006, and an es - 1 Adopted 22 February 2006, International Labour Conference, 94th (Maritime) Session, 2006, Provisional Record No. 16, p. 16/9. VI Preface sential aspect of ensuring widespread harmonized implementation of the MLC, 2006. The Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 were adopted in September 2008 by tri- partite experts’ meetings attended by nearly 300 participants. The experts were drawn from all regions of the world. The flag State inspection guidelines contained in this book are published along- side the Guidelines for port State control officers carrying out inspec - tions under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , which were also adopted by a tripartite experts’ meeting in September 2008 and are intended to assist port State control officers to carry out inspections of foreign ships coming into their ports. Each country may have its own practices relating to flag State inspection. The flag State’s competent authorities of the various countries may wish to adapt these guidelines to fit their current practices. These international guidelines are designed to be of prac - tical assistance to governments in drafting their own national guide- lines. It is hoped that they will, at the same time, achieve their pri - mary aim – namely, effective flag State inspection and, where appropriate, certification of ships for compliance with the require- ments of the MLC, 2006, as implemented nationally. If this is achieved, seafarers will benefit from decent conditions of work, not only in law but also in practice. Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry Director of the International Labour Standards Department Acknowledgements The ILO would like to express its appreciation to the Euro- pean Commission for its financial contribution to the preparation and publication costs of both Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 and Guidelines for port State control officers carrying out inspections under the Mari- time Labour Convention, 2006 , and for its commitment to promot - ing international cooperation in these important areas. Contents Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V Acknowledgements IX 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1.1. Explanation of the objectives and content of the guidelines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1.2. Brief overview of the MLC, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 1.3. Key concepts in the MLC, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 1.4. Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 The flag State inspection system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Overview of flag State responsibilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Maritime labour inspection and certification process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Inspecting the MLC, 2006, maritime labour requirements . . . 35 3.1. General note . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 3.2. The MLC, 2006, requirements to be inspected and, where applicable, certified . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 Action to be taken if deficiencies are identified . . . . . . . . . . . 73 4.1. General note . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 4.2. Guidance on making determinations as to action . . . . 75 4318000 40640 1 0 0 1 Introduction Explanation of the objectives and content of the guidelines In accordance with resolution XIII adopted by the Inter- national Labour Conference (ILC) at its 94th (Maritime) Session, these international guidelines have been developed to assist flag State administrations to effectively implement their responsibil - ities with respect to the ship inspection and certification duties under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , as amended (MLC, 2006). Pursuant to the 2018 Resolution of the Special Tripartite Committee established under Article XIII of the MLC, 2006 , t he guidelines have been updated to reflect the 2014, 2016 and 2018 amendments. The guidelines are intended to provide supplementary prac - tical information and guidance to flag States that can be adapted to specifically reflect their national laws and other measures imple - menting the MLC, 2006. It must be emphasized that these guidelines are intended as a practical resource that can be used by any government that finds them helpful. In all cases, the relevant national laws or regulations or col- lective bargaining agreements or other measures implementing the MLC, 2006, in the flag State should be viewed as the authoritative statement of the requirements in the flag State. The remaining sections of Chapter 1 provide general infor - mation on the structure, key concepts and terminology used in the MLC, 2006. Chapter 2 is divided into two sections. The first section pro- vides an overview of the flag State inspection system obligations in the MLC, 2006, and contains information with respect to actions or determinations that flag States or the competent authority in the flag State may take for ship inspection and certification. The second section provides more specific guidance on the process of maritime labour inspection and certification under the MLC, 2006. Chapter 3 addresses the requirements of the MLC, 2006, that are to be inspected and, if required, certified, on all ships covered by the MLC, 2006. It contains guidance as to what a flag State inspector (or a recognized organization (RO) that has been delegated this task by a flag State) would check in verifying compli - ance . It also provides some examples of deficiencies. Chapter 4 outlines a range of actions that can be taken if deficiencies or non-conformities are identified by flag State in- spectors (or reported to the flag State by ROs acting on its behalf). Brief overview of the MLC, 2006 The Preamble to the MLC, 2006, sets out the intentions and the objectives of the Members of the International Labour Organ- ization in adopting the Convention. The Preamble refers to the global nature of the shipping industry and the need for seafarers to have special protection. It also links the MLC, 2006, to the other key international Conventions that establish minimum standards for the shipping industry in connection with safety, security and marine environmental protection. The MLC, 2006, complement- ing other major international conventions, reflects international agreement on the minimum requirements for working and living conditions for seafarers. Like other international labour standards, the MLC, 2006, only sets out minimum international standards. However, recalling paragraph 8 of article 19 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization, the Preamble goes on to clarify that in no case shall the adoption of any Convention and Recommendation by the Conference or the ratification of any Convention by any 4318000 79375 1 0 0 1 Member be deemed to affect any law, award, custom or agreement which ensures more favourable conditions to the workers concerned than those provided for in the Convention or Recommendation. The MLC, 2006, contains an explanatory note, which was adopted by the 94th (Maritime) Session of the ILC to assist govern- ments with respect to their legislative obligations and to under- standing the legal relationship between the different parts of the MLC, 2006. It also provides an outline of the overall structure of the MLC, 2006. Explanatory note to the Regulations and Code of the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 This explanatory note, which does not form part of the Maritime Labour Convention, is intended as a general guide to the Convention. The Convention comprises three different but related parts: the Articles, the Regulations and the Code. The Articles and Regulations set out the core rights and principles and the basic obligations of Members ratifying the Convention. The Articles and Regulations can only be changed by the Conference in the framework of article 19 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization (see Article XIV of the Convention). The Code contains the details for the implementation of the Regu - lations . It comprises Part A (Mandatory standards) and Part B (Non- mandatory guidelines). The Code can be amended through the sim- plified procedure set out in Article XV of the Convention. Since the Code relates to detailed implementation, amendments to it must re- main within the general scope of the Articles and Regulations. The Regulations and the Code are organized into general areas under five Titles: Title 1: Minimum requirements for seafarers to work on a ship; Title 2: Conditions of employment; Title 3: Accommodation, recreational facilities, food and catering; Title 4: Health protection, medical care, welfare and social secur - ity protection; Title 5: Compliance and enforcement. Each Title contains groups of provisions relating to a particular right or principle (or enforcement measure in Title 5), with con- nected numbering. The first group in Title 1, for example, consists of Regulation 1.1, Standard A1.1 and Guideline B1.1 relating to min- imum age. The Convention has three underlying purposes: to lay down, in its Articles and Regulations, a firm set of rights and principles; to allow, through the Code, a considerable degree of flexibility in the way Members implement those rights and principles; and to ensure, through Title 5, that the rights and principles are prop- erly complied with and enforced. There are two main areas for flexibility in implementation: one is the possibility for a Member, where necessary (see Article VI, para- graph 3), to give effect to the detailed requirements of Part A of the Code through substantial equivalence (as defined in Article VI, para- graph 4). The second area of flexibility in implementation is provided by formulating the mandatory requirements of many provisions in Part A in a more general way, thus leaving a wider scope for dis- cretion as to the precise action to be provided for at the national level. In such cases, guidance on implementation is given in the non- mandatory Part B of the Code. In this way, Members which have ratified this Convention can ascertain the kind of action that might be expected of them under the corresponding general obligation in Part A, as well as action that would not necessarily be required. For example, Standard A4.1 requires all ships to provide prompt access to the necessary medicines for medical care on board ship (para- graph 1(b)) and to “carry a medicine chest” (paragraph 4(a)). The fulfilment in good faith of this latter obligation clearly means some- thing more than simply having a medicine chest on board each ship. A more precise indication of what is involved is provided in the cor 4318000 77470 1 0 0 1 responding Guideline B4.1.1 (paragraph 4) so as to ensure that the contents of the chest are properly stored, used and maintained. Members which have ratified this Convention are not bound by the guidance concerned and, as indicated in the provisions in Title 5 on port State control, inspections would deal only with the relevant requirements of this Convention (Articles, Regulations and the Standards in Part A). However, Members are required under para- graph 2 of Article VI to give due consideration to implementing their responsibilities under Part A of the Code in the manner provided for in Part B. If, having duly considered the relevant Guidelines, a Mem- ber decides to provide for different arrangements which ensure the proper storage, use and maintenance of the contents of the medicine chest, to take the example given above, as required by the Standard in Part A, then that is acceptable. On the other hand, by following the guidance provided in Part B, the Member concerned, as well as the ILO bodies responsible for reviewing implementation of inter- national labour Conventions, can be sure without further consider- ation that the arrangements the Member has provided for are adequate to implement the responsibilities under Part A to which the Guideline relates. 12. With particular reference to flag State inspection respon - sibilities and the ship certification system, as dealt with in these guidelines, it is important to take account of three six of the four seven appendices located at the end of Title 5 of the MLC, 2006: Appendix A2-I: Evidence of financial security under Regulation 2.5, paragraph 2; Appendix A4-I: Evidence of financial security under Regulation 4.2; Appendix B4-I: Model Receipt and Release F orm referred to in Guideline B4.2 .2 ; Appendix A5-I: List of matters for flag State inspection for cer - tification purposes; Appendix A5-II: Model documents relating to the flag State inspection and certification system established in Title 5: Maritime Labour Certificate; Interim Maritime Labour Certificate; Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance (DMLC (two parts – Part I and Part II)); Appendix B5-I: An example, to provide guidance as to the way both parts of the DMLC might be filled out by the flag State (Part I) and a shipowner (Part II). Key concepts in the MLC, 2006 This section of Chapter 1 sets out some of the key con- cepts relating to the application of the MLC, 2006. Section 1.4, which follows, contains the definitions of terms that are found in the MLC, 2006. Application The MLC, 2006, applies to all seafarers on all ships cov - ered by the MLC, 2006. A seafarer is any person who is employed or engaged or works in any capacity on board a ship to which the MLC, 2006, applies. All ships registered with a flag State, if cov - ered by the MLC, 2006, are subject to an inspection for compliance with the requirements of the MLC, 2006. The terms “seafarer” and “ship” are defined in the MLC, 2006 (see section 1.4 below). Seafarers’ rights The MLC, 2006, is intended to help achieve decent work for all seafarers. It sets out the fundamental rights and principles that seafarers have with respect to their working and living condi - tions . Article III of the MLC, 2006, relates to fundamental rights and principles requiring ILO member States to satisfy themselves that the provisions of their laws and regulations respect, in the con- text of this Convention, the fundamental rights to: freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; 4318000 79375 1 0 0 1 the elimination of all forms of forced or compulsory labour ; the effective abolition of child labour ; and the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation. Article IV relates to seafarers’ employment and social rights and states: Every seafarer has the right to a safe and secure workplace that complies with safety standards. Every seafarer has a right to fair terms of employment. Every seafarer has a right to decent working and living conditions on board ship. Every seafarer has a right to health protection, medical care, wel - fare measures and other forms of social protection. Each Member shall ensure, within the limits of its jurisdiction, that the seafarers’ employment and social rights set out in the preceding paragraphs of this Article are fully implemented in accordance with the requirements of the Convention. Unless specified otherwise in the Convention, such implementation may be achieved through national laws or regulations, through applicable collective bargaining agreements or through other measures or in practice. Ships The MLC, 2006, applies to all ships, whether publicly or privately owned, ordinarily engaged in commercial activities. Sub- ject to any national provisions to the contrary, the MLC, 2006, does not apply to: ships which navigate exclusively in inland waters or waters within, or closely adjacent to, sheltered waters or areas where port regulations apply; ships engaged in fishing or in similar pursuits and ships of trad - itional build such as dhows and junks; warships or naval auxiliaries. Compliance and enforcement (ship inspection and certification) The flag State must verify, through an effective and coord - inated system of regular inspection, monitoring and other control measures, that ships comply with the requirements of the Conven - tion as implemented in national laws or regulations, or collective bargaining agreements or other measures or practices implement- ing the requirements of the MLC, 2006. Generally, under Regu - lation 5.1.3, in addition to being inspected, ships must also be certified for compliance with the requirements for the 14 16 areas of seafarers’ working and living conditions set out in Title 5, Appen - dix A5-I. A flag State must also verify that its ships meet all MLC, 2006, requirements, even if the requirement is not one that must be certified. For ships that do not have to be certified (ships under 500 gross tonnage ( gt ), or ships that are not engaged in inter- national voyages and that do not operate from a port or between ports in another country) the flag State must still verify compliance for all the same requirements as a certified ship. The MLC, 2006, recognizes that ILO Members need some flexibility to address particular national situations, especially with respect to smaller ships and ships that do not go on international voyages or specific kinds of ships. It also recognizes that flag States may not always be in a position to implement the requirements of the MLC, 2006, in the manner set out in Part A of the Code and al- lows them to adopt measures which are “substantially equivalent” (see paragraph 37 below). The MLC, 2006, provides guidance pri - marily directed to national law-making bodies as to the ways in which this national flexibility can be exercised. For ships that are engaged in international voyages or operate from a port or between ports in another country these matters will be stated on the MLC, 2006, documents carried on ships for the information of 4318000 79375 1 0 0 1 flag State inspectors and authorized officers carrying out port State control inspections (PSCO). Certified ships For ships of 500 gt or over that are engaged in international voyages or ships of 500 gt or over that fly the flag of one country and operate from a port or between ports in another country, the MLC, 2006, contains a list of 14 16 areas that are subject to a mandatory certi - fication system (see MLC, 2006, Title 5, Appendix A5-I). Certifica - tion is mandatory only for some ships that are covered by the MLC, 2006; however, a shipowner can also request that a ship be certified even in cases where certification is not required. The documents that are issued by the flag State, or by an RO on its behalf, if so authorized, are the Maritime Labour Certifi - cate and a DMLC. The DMLC has two parts. Part I is filled out by the flag State and refers to the relevant national requirements that are to be certified as having been complied with. Part II is prepared by the shipowner and outlines the measures that the shipowner has put in place to ensure ongoing compliance on the ship with these flag State requirements. Models for the documents that must be carried on ships can be found in Appendix A5-II which is located at the end of Title 5 of the MLC, 2006. Ships that are not certified Ships that are not certified are subject to inspection, at intervals not exceeding three years, against the same MLC, 2006, requirements (as implemented nationally) for certified ships. The only difference is that the Maritime Labour Certificate and the DMLC are not issued to these ships. The national requirements for the 14 16 areas that are normally identified in Part I of a DMLC would also be relevant to flag State inspections of ships that are not certi - fied , as would all the other requirements of the MLC, 2006. 1.4. Definitions The following definitions are found in Article II, para- graph 1, of the MLC, 2006: competent authority means the minister, government depart- ment or other authority having power to issue and enforce regu - lations , orders or other instructions having the force of law in respect of the subject matter of the provision concerned; declaration of maritime labour compliance means the declaration referred to in Regulation 5.1.3; gross tonnage means the gross tonnage calculated in accordance with the tonnage measurement regulations contained in Annex I to the International Convention on Tonnage Measurement of Ships, 1969, or any successor Convention; for ships covered by the tonnage measurement interim scheme adopted by the Inter- national Maritime Organization, the gross tonnage is that which is included in the REMARKS column of the International Ton- nage Certificate (1969); maritime labour certificate means the certificate referred to in Regulation 5.1.3; requirements of this Convention refers to the requirements in these Articles and in the Regulations and Part A of the Code of this Convention; seafarer means any person who is employed or engaged or works in any capacity on board a ship to which this Convention applies; seafarers’ employment agreement includes both a contract of em - ployment and articles of agreement; seafarer recruitment and placement service means any person, company, institution, agency or other organization, in the public or the private sector, which is engaged in recruiting seafarers on behalf of shipowners or placing seafarers with shipowners ; ship means a ship other than one which navigates exclusively in inland waters or waters within, or closely adjacent to, sheltered waters or areas where port regulations apply; shipowner means the owner of the ship or another organization or person, such as the manager, agent or bareboat charterer, who 4318000 77470 1 0 0 1 has assumed the responsibility for the operation of the ship from the owner and who, on assuming such responsibility, has agreed to take over the duties and responsibilities imposed on ship- owners in accordance with this Convention, regardless of whether any other organizations or persons fulfil certain of the duties or responsibilities on behalf of the shipowner . The flag State inspection system Overview of flag State responsibilities General note 4318000 534035 2 0 0 2 This section of these guidelines is intended to assist flag States by providing a summary of their responsibilities primarily in relation to the flag State inspection system. In all cases, the national legal framework implementing the MLC, 2006, as well as the Con- vention itself, remain the primary sources of information and guid - ance as to specific responsibilities of the flag State (or competent authorities). The majority of the provisions in the MLC, 2006, are directed to national lawmakers with respect to the elements of the national legal framework that are needed to implement the Con- vention . This includes information on situations where a State, or a “competent authority” in a State, can (or in some cases must) make determinations and take actions that are related to ensuring decent working and living conditions for seafarers and, in particular, for seafarers on ships that fly its flag. 1 Many of these national determinations relate to specific areas where flexibility can be exercised in the flag State, to respond to specific situations in the country. In most cases these refer to determinations that are to be made by the “competent author- ity ” and require consultation with the seafarer and shipowner 1 National practice may vary with respect to which department (or departments) of government is considered as the “competent authority” (as defined in Article II – see para. 24 above) for purposes of giving effect to national laws or regulations or other measures implementing the require- ments of the MLC, 2006. organizations concerned. 2 Although some general information is provided on this matter, the process of legal implementation by either the flag State (or a competent authority of the flag State) at the national level is outside the scope of these guidelines. The question of whether a country has properly implemented its obligations under the MLC, 2006, is a matter that is dealt with by the international supervisory system that is established under the Constitution of the International Labour Organization. However, there are some specific actions that need to be taken at the more practical level to support implementation of the national requirements on ships. Of particular importance for these guidelines, which are concerned with flag State inspection respon - sibilities , are the: appointment of flag State inspectors, or ROs if authorized by the flag State to carry out some flag State tasks; inspection, monitoring and other control measures; issuance, renewal and withdrawal of the Maritime Labour Cer - tificate and completion of Part I of the DMLC; responding to seafarer complaints; responding to requests for information about its ships from port State control authorities; taking enforcement action where ships are found not to be in compliance with the requirements of the Convention. 2 In cases where representative organizations of shipowners or of sea- farers do not exist within a Member, any derogation, exemption or other flex- ible application of the MLC, 2006, for which the Convention requires consultation with shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations may only be decided by that Member through consultation with the special tripartite com- mittee established by the Convention (Article VII). Overview of the MLC, 2006, national flexibility (determinations/exemptions on application of the requirements) 4318000 864235 2 0 0 2 As noted above the exercise of national flexibility and determinations regarding the application of the MLC, 2006, is a matter for national legal implementation and is outside the scope of these guidelines. The discussion in this section of the guide- lines is intended only as a background summary for information purposes. General application to ships and seafarers In some cases, questions might arise with respect to whether a particular ship (or category of ships) is covered by the MLC, 2006, or whether a category of persons are seafarers within the meaning of the Convention or with respect to the extent to which the requirements of the Convention are to be applied to smaller ships that do not go on international voyages. Determinations can be made by the competent authority on these matters (if authorized to do so under national law) either in or, in many cases, after, consultation with the shipowners’ and sea- farers’ organizations concerned. In addition, any determinations that are made must be communicated to the Director-General of the International Labour Office (Article II, paragraph 7). If there is doubt as to whether a category of persons are seafarers, then paragraph 3 of Article II should be considered. Additional guidance on this determination is provided in resolu - tion VII adopted by the 94th Session of the ILC. 3 Likewise, if there is doubt as to whether the MLC, 2006, applies to a ship or a particular category of ships, then paragraph 5 of Article II should be considered. 3 Resolution concerning information on occupational groups. For ships of less than 200 gt that do not go on international voyages, paragraph 6 of Article II may need to be considered. Specific application matters There may also be decisions taken by flag States on other matters related to national implementation and application that are addressed in national laws or regulations or other measures, in- cluding substantial equivalences, determinations as to the applica - tion of, or exemptions from, some of the requirements under Standard A3.1 dealing with seafarer accommodation and recre - ational facilities for ships. National substantial equivalences, and exemptions in ac- cordance with Standard A3.1, as they pertain to the certified re- quirements of the MLC, 2006, will be stated in Part I of the DMLC. For other verified areas, specific national requirements would need to be consulted. Substantial equivalence Where a flag State is not in a position to implement a par- ticular requirement in Titles 1–4 of the Convention in the manner set out in Part A of the Code (the Standards), it is permitted, under Article VI, paragraph 3, of the MLC, 2006, to adopt a “ substan - tially equivalent” provision in its national laws, regulations or other measures. Any substantially equivalent provisions that re- late to matters that are subject to certification must be noted in Part I of the DMLC (see paragraph 36 above). In considering the adoption of substantially equivalent provisions, the flag State must take account of Article VI, paragraph 4, of the MLC, 2006, which lays down that, for a national law or other measure to be consid - ered as substantially equivalent, in the context of the Convention, the flag State must have satisfied itself that: it is conducive to the full achievement of the general object and purpose of the provision or provisions of Part A of the Code concerned; and it gives effect to the provision or provisions of Part A of the Code concerned. 4318000 276225 2 0 0 2 Exemptions and application of Regulation 3.1 and Standard A3.1 The purpose of the minimum requirements in Regulation 3.1 and Standard A3.1 is to ensure that seafarers have decent ac- commodation and recreational facilities on board ship. In many cases, the requirements are directed specifically at matters affect- ing ship design and construction (e.g. cabin size, location, etc.) and equipment. The provisions in this part of the MLC, 2006, are very detailed and it was recognized that, in some cases, a strict applica - tion of these requirements may not be possible on ships that are already in existence or are below a certain size or on certain cat- egories of ships. In addition, it was recognized that there is a need to take account, without discrimination, of the interests of sea- farers with differing and distinctive religious and social practices. Exemptions or variations (see paragraph 44 below) can only be granted after consultation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned. Exemptions must be noted in Part I of the DMLC. It is also advisable to note variations. Application to ships that exist at the time the MLC, 2006, enters into force for the flag State Regulation 3.1, paragraph 2, provides that the require - ments in the Code that relate to ship construction and equipment apply only to ships constructed on or after the date when the MLC, 2006, comes into force for the flag State. For ships constructed before the entry into force date, the requirements relating to ship construction and equipment that are set out in earlier ILO Conventions apply to the extent that they were already applicable under the law or practice of the Member concerned (see paragraphs 90 to 92 below). All other requirements in the MLC, 2006 (as implemented nationally), including those in Standard A3.1, that are not related to ship construction and equipment will still apply to these ships. Application to smaller ships and specific categories of ships Standard A3.1, paragraphs 20 and 21, permits flag States, in specified circumstances, to exempt ships of less than 200 gt from some requirements in the Standard relating to accommodation and recreational facilities. Standard A3.1 also has specific provisions whereby the re- quirements can be modified for passenger and special purposes ships. In addition, ships less than 3,000 gt may be exempted from some requirements. National law or regulations or other measures implementing the MLC, 2006, should be carefully reviewed by flag State inspectors to ascertain the requirements that have been adopted in the flag State. Variations for differing religious and social practices Variations are permitted on condition that they do not result in overall facilities less favourable than those which would result from the application of this Standard A3.1 (Standard A3.1, paragraph 19). In addition, evaluation of the quality and appro - priateness of food provisions on the ship needs to take account of differing cultural and religious backgrounds (Regulation 3.2, paragraph 1). Flag State inspectors would need to be aware of any national provisions as to application or exemptions or variations that have been made by the flag State under the MLC, 2006. It is essential that this information is communicated to flag State inspectors and any ROs that have been authorized to carry out flag State inspection responsibilities. Flag State inspection system responsibilities 4318000 96520 2 0 0 2 The flag State is required to establish an effective system for inspection and certification of maritime labour conditions on ships that fly its flag (Regulation 5.1, paragraph 2). This involves a wide range of matters including: drawing up the national documents required by the Conven - tion ; providing a sufficient number of qualified inspectors (training and competence); developing rules or regulations providing for inspectors’ powers, status and independence; guidelines regarding inspectors’ tasks and confidentiality; identification (credentials) for inspectors; reporting responsibilities; delegation of some aspect of the inspection system to ROs (if an RO is used); establishing a process for receiving and responding to com- plaints or requests for information. The purpose of the discussion below is to highlight some aspects of these areas of responsibility. National documents required by the Convention The flag State (or its competent authority) will need to draw up a number of documents if they do not already exist. With respect to the ship certification system, a national form of the Mari- time Labour Certificate and the two-part DMLC has to be drawn up (see paragraphs 49 to 55 below). In addition, other documents are required by the MLC, 2006, including: a standardized table for shipboard working ar - rangements (Standard A2.3, paragraphs 10 and 11); a standard medical certificate (Standard A1.2, paragraph 2); and a form for on-board medical reports (Standard A4.1, paragraph 2). A record- keeping system must also be maintained for inspection reports (Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 13). Many of these other documents will already exist. Certification system documents A Maritime Labour Certificate accompanied by a DMLC must be carried on board ships of 500 gt or over that are engaged in international voyages or operate from a port or between ports in another country. The Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC ( accom - panied by an English translation if it is not in English) is to be posted in a conspicuous place on the ship where it is available to seafarers with a copy made available, on request, to seafarers, flag State inspectors, authorized officials in port States and shipowners’ and seafarers’ representatives (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 12). The requirements for the Certificate and the DMLC are set out in Regulation 5.1.3 and Standard A5.1.3. Model documents are set out in Title 5, Appendix A5-II, with examples of how they might be filled out shown in Title 5, Appendix B5-I. The docu - ments must be in a form that corresponds to the model documents set out in Title 5, Appendix A5-II. Maritime Labour Certificate (Regulation 5.1.3) A Maritime Labour Certificate must be issued by the com- petent authority or by an authorized RO on its behalf, on comple - tion of a satisfactory inspection of the national requirements for the 14 16 areas listed in Title 5, Appendix A5-I. A DMLC must be at- tached for it to be valid. The Certificate must be issued for a period not exceeding five years (but see paragraph s 87 et seq. ). 4318000 -20320 2 0 0 2 Interim Maritime Labour Certificate (Regulation 5.1.3) Standard A5.1.3, paragraphs 5, 6, 7 and 8, detail the cir - cumstances when an interim Maritime Labour Certificate may be issued. Such a certificate may have a maximum validity of six months. No consecutive interim certificates may be issued, follow- ing the initial six months, by the same flag State, to the same ship- owner. A DMLC need not be issued for the period of validity of the interim certificate. An inspection must be carried out prior to ex- piry of the interim certificate to enable issuance of a Maritime Labour Certificate. Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance (DMLC) (Regulation 5.1.3) DMLC, Part I – Part I is to be completed by the competent authority. It contains references to the relevant details of the national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006. Any national substantial equivalences and any exemptions granted by the flag State must be specified in the DMLC, Part I. See Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 10, for the contents of Part I with additional guidance in Guideline B5.1.3, paragraph 1. An example of how it might be filled out is provided in Title 5, Appendix B5-I. DMLC, Part II – Part II is to be completed by the ship- owner and must identify the measures adopted to ensure ongoing compliance with the national requirements between inspections and the measures proposed to ensure that there is continuous im - provement . Part II is subject to inspection before certification by the competent authority or an RO on its behalf. See Standard A5 .1.3, paragraph 10, for the contents of Part II with additional guidance in Guideline B5.1.3, paragraphs 2, 3 and 4. See Title 5, Appendix B5-I for an example of how it might be filled out. Flag State inspectors Information on the appointment, powers, training, and the required credentials for flag State inspectors is contained in Stand- ard A5.1.4. This can include appointment of ROs to carry out aspects of these responsibilities. In addition, competent authorities need to develop guidelines for inspectors (see Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 7) as well as appropriate training, regarding the tasks to be performed. Authorization of recognized organizations Under Regulation 5.1.1, paragraph 3, public institutions or other organizations, recognized as competent and independent, may be authorized, in accordance with the MLC, 2006, by a flag State to carry out inspections or to issue certificates or do both on its behalf. They are called “recognized organizations” in the MLC, 2006. The role of the RO is described in paragraph 3 of Regula- tion 5.1.1 and paragraph 1 of Regulation 5.1.2. Standard A5.1.2 sets out requirements for flag States that may wish to appoint public institutions or other organizations to carry out inspections re- quired by the MLC, 2006, in accordance with normal practice. An up to date list of any authorizations (and the scope of the auth - orization ) for ROs must be provided to the International Labour Office for publication (Standard A5.1.2, paragraph 4). 4318000 1298575 2 0 0 2 When an RO is appointed, the flag State (or its competent authority) needs to specify the scope of the RO’s role with respect to verification of national requirements. Although the attention of an RO carrying out a flag State inspection might be drawn to a pos - sible deficiency on a ship by seafarers and reported to the flag State, the investigation of complaints that are made to the flag State regarding its ships (Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 5) or the enforcement of the national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006 (see Chapter 4 of these guidelines) should be dealt with by the competent authority in each flag State. Information as to the role of ROs and the scope of their authority should also be made avail- able to seafarers in the event that they have a complaint. The flag State should also have in place an oversight sys- tem for ROs that it has authorized. This system should include procedures for communicating with the RO and provision of information on any national measures that differ from the MLC, 2006, provisions (Standard A5.1.2, paragraph 3). Guideline B5.1.2, paragraph 6, provides additional information about oversight procedures. Annual reports The competent authority is required to publish an annual report on inspection activities within six months of the end of each year. When compiling an annual report, the flag State should give due consideration to the contents of Guideline B5.1.4, paragraph 10. Responding to requests for information It is the responsibility of the flag State to respond in a timely manner to requests for advice, information and assistance from a port State control authority in order to ensure that the ship in question is not unduly delayed by the port State authority. Responding to complaints about maritime labour conditions on a ship It is the responsibility of the flag State to receive com- plaints, investigate and take appropriate enforcement action. Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 5, of the MLC, 2006, provides that: If a Member receives a complaint which it does not consider mani - festly unfounded or obtains evidence that a ship that flies its flag does not conform to the requirements of this Convention or that there are serious deficiencies in the implementation of the measures set out in the declaration of maritime labour compliance, the Member shall take the steps necessary to investigate the matter and ensure that action is taken to remedy any deficiencies found. Information about non-conformity or serious deficien - cies in the conditions on a ship or the on-board implementation of Part II of the DMLC could come from a number of sources includ - ing from a concern raised with an RO by a seafarer during an inspection. A flag State is expected to have in place procedures for re- ceiving and responding to such complaints, and ensuring the neces - sary confidentiality. An RO may in some circumstances be specifically author- ized to investigate a particular complaint by a flag State, but the responsibility for resolution of a complaint remains with the flag State. Maritime labour inspection and certification process General note All ships covered by the MLC, 2006, are subject to inspec - tion for all the requirements of the Convention (Regulation 5.1.4, paragraph 1). For ships that will be certified the provisions of Regulation 5.1.3 and Standard A5.1.3 will also apply. The inspec - tion standards are the national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006. 4318000 643890 2 0 0 2 The relevant national provisions implementing the re- quirements of the MLC, 2006, in the 14 16 areas that must be certified for some ships will be referenced in Part I of the DMLC that is to be prepared by the competent authority. Although ships that are not certified will not have a DMLC, inspectors may, nevertheless, find it useful to refer to the national provisions which are normally identified in the DMLC, Part I, as a basic checklist for the matters it covers. Inspectors familiar with maritime inspections in connec - tion with the ship safety, human security and marine pollution pre- vention conventions of the International Maritime Organization (IMO) will note a difference of terminology in the MLC, 2006, in connection with the certification process. The IMO conventions refer to ships being “surveyed” for the purpose of issuing or en - dorsing a statutory certificate. The MLC, 2006, does not distinguish between a survey and an inspection. A maritime labour inspection can be divided into two parts: the first concerns the physical items such as the seafarer ac- commodation and galley conditions, whilst the second relates to other elements of decent work or human and operational issues such as payment of wages, seafarer employment agreements, min- imum age, medical certification and hours of work or rest. Some areas of concern, such as occupational safety and health, are mixed, involving physical aspects (protective equipment/construction) and operational practices on a ship. For a satisfactory inspection to be completed, it is likely that the inspector will need to employ dif - ferent methods, including document review, visual observation, general discussions with seafarers and interviews with seafarers in private. When inspectors are interviewing seafarers, they will need to be sensitive on what may be considered to be personal or poten - tially controversial matters. In addition, as stated in Standard A5.1.4, paragraphs 10 and 11: Inspectors shall treat as confidential the source of any grievance or complaint alleging a danger or deficiency in relation to seafarers’ working and living conditions or a violation of laws and regulations and give no intimation to the shipowner , the shipowner’s represent- ative or the operator of the ship that an inspection was made as a con- sequence of such a grievance or complaint. In particular, inspectors shall: … (b) subject to appropriate sanctions or disciplinary measures, not reveal, even after leaving service, any commercial secrets or con- fidential working processes or information of a personal nature which may come to their knowledge in the course of their duties. In all circumstances, attending inspectors must exercise their professional judgement when carrying out maritime labour inspections. Preparing for an inspection In addition to reviewing, especially in the case of the ini - tial inspection, a ship’s DMLC, Part II, the flag State inspector should review various sources of information in order to gain an understanding of a ship’s history (where applicable). Information could be obtained from the individual ship files containing previ - ous inspection reports, relevant flag State and port State control and other databases and ILO records. For existing certified and uncertified ships before an inspection of a ship is carried out, the flag State inspector should ascertain from the information sources available whether there are any outstanding deficiencies which have not been addressed by the shipowner . If there are any outstanding deficiencies not addressed by the shipowner then the competent authority or flag State inspector should take action (see Chapter 4 below) regarding recti- fication in a timely manner. 4318000 476885 2 0 0 2 A flag State inspector must also be aware of any national determinations, substantial equivalences, exemptions and vari - ations that have been made by the flag State under the MLC, 2006. Where a ship already carries a Maritime Labour Certifi - cate, this certificate and the attached DMLC should be the starting point for flag State inspections: the DMLC, Part I will remind inspectors of the national requirements in the 14 16 areas specified in Appendix A5-I that must be inspected for a certificate to be issued, and the DMLC, Part II sets out the shipowner’s measures for en - suring ongoing compliance with those national requirements. Where a ship does not already carry a Maritime Labour Certificate and the purpose of the inspection is to enable certifica - tion of the ship, the starting point should be the DMLC, Part I and either: the draft for a DMLC, Part II submitted for the competent authority’s approval, where a certificate is to be issued, or the information provided in accordance with Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 7, where an interim certificate is to be issued. For ships that are not subject to certification (unless cer - tification is requested), the requirements of the national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements or other measures implementing the MLC, 2006, are the starting point, although the national provisions which are normally identified in the DMLC, Part I may be helpful to inspections of these ships. Although the 14 16 areas for certification must be inspected for a certificate to be issued, both certified and uncertified ships must be inspected for compliance with all the requirements of the MLC, 2006, which are, therefore, included in the detailed inspec - tion information that is set out in Chapter 3, section 3.2, below. Overview of the process for ship inspections and certification Ships may need to be inspected and certified or may only be inspected in a variety of circumstances. Some ships may be under construction or newly constructed, others may transfer from another registry and some may not need to be certified. Infor - mation on the various stages and situations is in the remainder of this section of Chapter 2. Inspections prior to the issue of the first certificate In the case of ships under construction that have been, or are to be, registered in the flag State, the relevant drawings in rela - tion to applicable MLC, 2006, requirements (Regulations 3.1 (Sea- farer accommodation and recreational facilities), 3.2 (Food and catering) and 4.3 (Health and safety protection and accident pre- vention )) should be reviewed for compliance with the national re- quirements implementing the MLC, 2006. In the case of new ships entering service, the “as built” ar - rangement for items covered under Title 3 should be checked against the drawings when the flag State inspector attends the ship. Compliance with the other national requirements (including those covered by Part I of the DMLC in the case of ships that are to be certified) should be inspected, to the extent possible, immediately prior to the ship entering service on the basis of such documen - tation and information as is available. In this case where insufficient information is available because, for example, seafarers may not yet have joined the ship, only an interim certificate may be issued (see Standard A5.1.3, paragraphs 5–8). 4318000 807085 2 0 0 2 The shipowner must draw up the measures for ensuring initial and ongoing compliance in the DMLC, Part II. These measures must address the national requirements summarized in the DMLC, Part I. The inspector must review these Part II measures for the competent authority to certify Part II in accord- ance with Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 10. Where an interim certifi - cate is to be issued, the review will relate to the information submit- ted in accordance with Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 7. A full inspection, including the document review, must be completed before the Maritime Labour Certificate and the at - tached DMLC can be issued. In subsequent inspections (referred to below), the review with respect to the DMLC, Part II will concentrate on whether or not the measures set out in Part II are being properly implemented. Intermediate inspection An intermediate inspection must be carried out in order to ensure ongoing compliance with the requirements of the MLC, 2006. It must be between the second and third anniversary dates. 4 The scope and depth of the intermediate inspection is to be equal to an inspection for renewal of the certificate. The certificate is to be endorsed following satisfactory intermediate inspection. Failing to undergo this inspection and record the event on the Maritime Labour Certificate will invalidate a certificate (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 14(b)). 4 “Anniversary date” means the day and month of each year which will correspond to the date of expiry of the Maritime Labour Certificate (Stand- ard A5.1.3, para. 2). Renewal inspection For a Maritime Labour Certificate renewal inspection, all requirements need to be inspected. When the renewal inspection has been completed within three months before the expiry date of the existing certificate, the new certificate will be valid from the date of completion of the renewal inspection for a period of five years from the date of expiry of the existing certificate (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 3). It is possible for a renewal inspection to be completed more than three months before the expiry date of the existing Maritime Labour Certificate. In that case, the new Certificate would be valid for a period not exceeding five years starting from the date of completion of the renewal inspection (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 3 ). 88 bis . When a renewal inspection has been completed prior to the expiry of the existing Maritime Labour Certificate and the ship continues to meet national laws, regulations or other measures implementing the requirements of the MLC , 2006, but a new certificate cannot immediately be issued to and made available on board that ship, the competent authority, or the recognized organization , may extend the validity of the existing certificate for a further period not exceeding five months from the expiry date of the existing certificate. The certificate may be endorsed accordingly (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 4). 8 8 ter. The new certificate shall be valid for a period not exceeding five years starting from the date provided for in paragraph 3 of Standard A5.1.3 as applicable (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 4) . Changes of flag/re-registration, change of shipowner , substantial alteration A Maritime Labour Certificate ceases to be valid and a new certificate will be required when a ship changes flag or changes shipowner or substantial changes have been made to the structure or equipment dealt with under Title 3 (Seafarers’ accommodation) (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 14). The issue of a new certificate will require an inspection, which should be treated in the same way as the inspection of a new ship entering service, as covered in section 2.2.4 abov e . Ships in existence prior to entry into force of the MLC, 2006, for the flag State Regulation 3.1, paragraph 2, provides that the require- ments in Standard A3.1 that relate to ship construction and equip- ment apply only to ships constructed on or after the date when the MLC, 2006, comes into force for the flag State. The date of con- struction is defined as the date when a ship’s keel is laid or when it is at a similar stage of construction . 4318000 784860 2 0 0 2 For ships constructed before the entry into force for the flag State, the requirements relating to ship construction and equipment that are set out in the Accommodation of Crews Con- vention (Revised), 1949 (No. 92), and the Accommodation of Crews (Supplementary Provisions) Convention, 1970 (No. 133), apply to the extent that they were already applicable, under the law or practice of the Member concerned. One or both of those Con- ventions may have become applicable through ratification by the country concerned. Or their substance may have become applic - able through the country’s ratification of the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, 1976 (No. 147), and/or the 1996 Protocol to Convention No. 147; there may also be cases where Conventions Nos 92 and 133 have not been ratified but have been made applicable under the country’s national law. As noted in paragraph 41 above, all other requirements in the MLC, 2006, as implemented nationally , including those in Standard A3.1 that are not related to construction and equip- ment , will still apply even to ships constructed before the MLC, 2006, entered into force for the flag State. Ships where shipowners have requested certification In the case of ships that are not required to carry a Mari- time Labour Certificate, the shipowners may request that their ships be included in the certification system and be issued a Mari- time Labour Certificate upon submission of a DMLC, Part II and completion of the inspection process . Ships that are not certified The MLC, 2006, applies to all seafarers on ships covered by the Convention regardless of the type and size of ships or whether or not the ship has been issued with a Maritime Labour Certificate. This means that ships below 500 gt or ships that are not engaged in international voyages and that do not operate from a port or between ports of another country are to be inspected to the same extent as a ship that has been certified or is seeking certifica - tion . The national provisions implementing the requirements of the Convention on certified matters, as normally identified in the DMLC, Part I, would, therefore, be applicable to conditions on these ships. Flag State inspectors’ reports Regardless of whether the ship is certified under the MLC, 2006, or not, after conducting an MLC, 2006, inspection, the attending inspector would need to provide an inspection report (Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 12) in accordance with national law and regula tions. The report should stipulate that any deficiencies found during the inspection are rectified in accordance with standard inspection reporting procedures. A copy of the report is to be given to the ship’s master and a copy is to be posted on the ship’s notice board for the information of the seafarers. A third copy is to be retained by the flag State or RO which will keep the necessary records. Upon a request, on behalf of the seafarers, a copy of the report is to be sent to the seafarers’ representatives. For ships carrying a Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC, the results of subsequent inspections (following the first) or verifications and any significant deficiencies found during the verifi cations are to be recorded together with the date when the deficien cies were found to be remedied (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 11). 4318000 1298575 2 0 0 2 This record, in English (or an English translation when it is not writ- ten in English) is to be either written on the on-board copy of the DMLC or appended to it or otherwise made available in some way for the information of seafarers, flag State inspectors, authorized of ficers in a port State and shipowners’ and seafarers’ representatives. Inspecting the MLC, 2006, maritime labour requirements General note 4318000 1804035 3 0 0 3 As stated earlier, in all cases the relevant national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements or other measures implementing the MLC, 2006, are the authoritative statement of requirements on any issue. The MLC, 2006, sets out the requirements that are to be implemented nationally. These guidelines re- fer only to the MLC, 2006, requirements and are to be considered general guidance only. Thus, although more detailed guidance is provided in section 3.2 below, this guidance will not necessarily be wholly relevant in all countries. The guidance in section 3.2 takes account of the requirements of the MLC, 2006, as set out in the Articles and the Regulations and in Part A of the Code, including the requirement on ILO member States to give due consideration to implementing their responsibilities in the manner provided for in the non-mandatory Part B of the Code. This means that there may be differences of detail between provisions of the MLC, 2006, and national provisions (or other measures) that have been adopted to implement the MLC, 2006. These differences may be due to the fact that, after the required due consideration has been given, the national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements or other measures are implementing the obligations under Part A of the Code in ways that are different from those recommended in Part B. As discussed in section 2.1 of Chapter 2, a member State may also have decided to adopt legislative provi sions under Article VI of the MLC, 2006, that are “substantially equivalent” to the requirements of Part A. In addition, exemptions from certain requirements may have been determined in accord- ance with the MLC, 2006. Any such differences should be stated in Part I of the flag State’s DMLC and should be taken into account in the inspection. Flag State inspectors may, however, be unable to find any national provisions or other measures that cover certain of the Convention’s requirements. In the case of apparent gaps in cover- age of requirements, inspectors (including ROs) should request clarification from the flag State’s competent authority. Inspectors should alert the competent authority to any relevant deficiency or abuse not specifically covered by existing laws or regulations and submit proposals for improvement (see Guideline B5.1.4, para- graph 8(g)). All of the requirements set out below in section 3.2 are subject to inspection on all ships covered by the MLC, 2006. For ships that are to be certified, this inspection will result in the certifi - cation of the ships as complying with the national requirements in 14 16 of the areas set out in section 3.2 below, following inspection to verify: compliance with the national law summarized in the DMLC, Part I; and implementation of the measures that have been adopted by the shipowner to ensure initial and ongoing compliance (i.e. the measures set out in the DMLC, Part II). In order to verify that the national requirements are complied with and that the shipowner’s measures have been cor - rectly implemented and are being followed (to the extent possible in the case of newly built ships), the flag State inspector should ob - tain supporting objective evidence by: inspecting the relevant areas of the ship; examining further documentation such as passports or other official documents, medical certificates, training records, crew lists and payroll records, seafarer employment agreements, safe manning documents and work schedules; interviewing , in private, a representative number of seafarers, taking account of the need to preserve confidentiality and of the seafarers’ work and rest schedules. A s discussed earlier, in section 2.2, ships will be subject to inspection in very different situations. For example, the inspection of a new ship may of necessity be less extensive than that of a ship which has already been issued a Maritime Labour Certificate be- cause for new ships, there will not yet be historical operational information for the ship and in some cases seafarers may not yet have joined the ship and would not be available for interviews. In such a case, the inspection may be carried out, as far as reasonable and practicable, for the issuance of an Interim Certificate (see Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 7). On the other hand, if sufficient documentation is available for the issuance of a Maritime Labour Certificate, the inspection might involve a review of the shipowner’s measures for the purpose of certifying Part II of the DMLC, a physical inspection of the ship, a review of documentation and sea- farer interviews, in private. In this connection inspectors may wish to refer to the information contained under the headings “How to check the basic requirements” in section 3.2 below. For ships that are to be certified or already carry a Mari- time Labour Certificate, Part II of the DMLC must be reviewed. The first step in the inspection should be to ensure that the ship- owner’s measures for ongoing compliance in each of the 14 16 areas that are subject to certification are being followed on the ship. It should be noted that, whilst all the requirements of the MLC, 2006, must be inspected, any inspection is a sampling process and inspectors should use their professional judgement and expertise when determining the depth of inspection for each requirement. In addition, account should be taken of Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 15, which provides that, when inspections are conducted or when measures are taken, all reasonable efforts shall be made to avoid a ship being unreasonably detained or delayed. The MLC, 2006, requirements to be inspected and, where applicable, certified Regulation 1.1 – Minimum age Standard A1.1; Guideline B1.1 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Persons below the age of 16 shall not be employed or engaged or work on a ship (Standard A1.1, paragraph 1). Seafarers under the age of 18 shall not be employed or engaged or work where the work is likely to jeopardize their health or safety (Standard A1.1, paragraph 4). Special attention must be paid to the safety and health of sea- farers under the age of 18, in accordance with national laws and regulations (Standard A4.3, paragraph 2(b)). Night work* for seafarers under the age of 18 is prohibited, except to the extent that an exemption has been made by the competent authority under Standard A1.1, paragraph 3, in the case of training programmes (Standard A1.1, paragraph 2). * “Night” is defined in accordance with national law and practice. It covers a period of at least nine hours starting no later than midnight and ending no earlier than 5 a.m. (Standard A1.1, paragraph 2). How to check the basic requirements Check a crew list, or passports or other official documents con- firming seafarers’ birth dates. Check work schedule with respect to seafarers under the age of 18 to determine hours and nature of work. Check to see that types of work on board that are likely to jeop - ardize the safety of seafarers under the age of 18 have been identified. Check recent accident reports and safety committee reports to determine whether seafarers under the age of 18 were involved. Confirm information through interviews, in private, with a rep- resentative number of seafarers. Examples of deficiencies Person under the age of 16 working as a seafarer. Seafarer under the age of 18 working at night (and not as part of a training programme ). 4318000 129540 3 0 0 3 Seafarer under the age of 18 carrying out tasks that are likely to jeopardize their safety or health. Regulation 1.2 – Medical certificate Standard A1.2; Guideline B1.2 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Seafarers are not allowed to work on a ship unless they are cer - tified * as medically fit to perform their duties. For seafarers working on ships ordinarily engaged on inter- national voyages the certificate must be provided in English (Standard A1.2, paragraph 10). The medical certificate must have been issued by a duly quali - fied medical practitioner and must be still valid. The period of validity for a certificate is determined under national law in accordance with the following: two-year maximum for medical certificates except for sea- farers under 18; then it is one year; six-year maximum for a colour vision certificate. * Certificates issued in accordance with, or meeting the substance of the applicable requirements, under the International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers, 1978 (STCW), as amended, are to be accepted as meeting these requirements (Standard A1.2, paragraph 3). How to check the basic requirements Check the crew list. Check for valid medical certificates stating that seafarers are medically fit to perform their duties. Check for valid colour vision certificates, where appropriate. Check (by reviewing work schedules and interviews, in pri - vate ) that medical restrictions on work for individual seafarers are being respected and that seafarers are not assigned to or carrying out work contrary to these restrictions. In urgent cases where the competent authority of the flag State has permitted a seafarer to work without a valid or with an ex- pired certificate, the authorization or permit should be checked to ensure it is still valid (subject to a three-month maximum). In cases where a medical certificate has expired while at sea, the certificate must be obtained within a maximum of three months. Check that the medical certificates of seafarers on ships ordin - arily engaged in international voyages are in English. Check that the medical certificate has been issued by a duly qualified medical practitioner. Examples of deficiencies Seafarer on board without a valid medical or colour vision cer - tificate (where appropriate) or authorization from the compe - tent authority in urgent cases. Seafarer working on the ship or performing tasks contrary to a restriction on a medical certificate. Seafarer’s medical certificate not in the English language on a ship ordinarily engaged in international voyages. A medical certificate that has not been issued by a qualified medical practitioner. Regulation 1.3 – Training and qualifications * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements 4318000 26670 3 0 0 3 Seafarers must be trained or certified* as competent or other- wise qualified to perform their duties in accordance with flag State requirements. Seafarers must have successfully completed training for per- sonal safety on board ship. * Training and certification in accordance with the International Con- vention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers, 1978 (STCW), as amended, is to be accepted as meeting these requirements. How to check the basic requirements Check the minimum safe manning document (SMD) to verify the required qualifications of the seafarers. Check certificates and endorsements for STCW personnel confirming seafarers’ competency with respect to their duties (check crew list to determine duties). Check documentary evidence (from a shipowner or, if relevant to the position concerned, a national authority or otherwise) confirming that seafarers have any qualifications that may be required under national law for those performing other duties on board ship (for example, ships’ cooks – see below, Regulation 3.2). Check for evidence confirming that all seafarers have success- fully completed training for personal safety on board ship. Check a copy of the appropriate training material that is avail- able to the crew. Confirm training through interviews, in private, with a repre - sentative number of seafarers. Examples of deficiencies Seafarer’s qualifications not in accordance with the SMD. Seafarer working on the ship who is not trained or certified or otherwise qualified to perform required duties. Certificates or endorsements are not up to date or have ex- pired . Seafarer working on the ship who has not successfully com- pleted personal safety training. Regulation 1.4 – Recruitment and placement Standard A1.4; Guideline B1.4 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Where a shipowner has used a private seafarer recruitment and placement service,* it must be licensed or certified or regu - lated in accordance with the MLC, 2006 . Seafarers shall not be charged for use of these services. Shipowners using services based in States not party to the MLC, 2006, must ensure, as far as practicable, that these ser - vices meet the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (Standard A1.4, paragraph 9).** * If private seafarer recruitment and placement services are operating in their territory, flag States are responsible for establishing an effective inspection and monitoring system with respect to those services (Regula- tion 5.3; Standard A5.3, paragraph 1). 4318000 1091565 3 0 0 3 ** Flag States are responsible for ensuring that shipowners have a proper system for verifying that the recruitment and placement services conform to the national requirements implementing Standard A1.4 if they use recruitment and placement services based in States not party to the MLC, 2006. This responsibility may be fulfilled by continuously monitoring shipowners’ compliance with those requirements, by monitoring recruit- ment and placement services in relevant non-MLC countries through a quality management system, and by providing information on the extent to which services in such countries have been found to meet the requirements of Standard A1.4. How to check the basic requirements Check the national web sites of the competent authority re- garding the licensing or regulation of seafarer recruitment and placement services (manning agencies). Check documentation or other information to allow the inspec - tor to ascertain the following: Direct engagement Seafarers were recruited and engaged by the shipowner . If this is the case, this fact should be noted and no further action is necessary. Recruited through a public service Seafarers were engaged through a public seafarer recruit- ment and placement service in either the flag State or in another State to which the MLC, 2006, applies. If this is the case, this should be noted and no further action is necessary. Recruited through a private service (or a service operated by a seafarers’ organization) in a country that has ratified the MLC, 2006 If the seafarers were engaged through a private sea- farer recruitment and placement service in the flag State, check for documentary evidence confirming that the service concerned is operating in accord- ance with the national laws or regulations or other measures implementing the MLC, 2006, require- ments . Where the supervision of such services is en - trusted to another national authority in the flag State, a statement by that authority that the service has been found to be operating in accordance with the relevant law is sufficient for this purpose. If the seafarers were engaged through a private sea- farer recruitment and placement service in another State that has ratified the MLC, 2006, no action need be taken unless the inspector has received a clear indication that basic rights have been violated (such as charging seafarers for use of services). Recruited through a service that is based in a country that has not ratified the MLC, 2006 If the seafarers were engaged through a seafarer recruit- ment and placement service based in a country that has not ratified the MLC, 2006, check documentation show- ing that the shipowner has, as far as practicable, veri - fied through a proper system that the service is operated consistently with the MLC, 2006. This system may, for example, take account of information collected by the flag State, as well as any audits or certifications concern- ing the quality of services operating in countries that have not ratified the MLC, 2006. Other evidence which shipowners could provide might be checklists against the MLC requirements or an RO audit of a recruitment and placement service based in a country that has not ratified the MLC, 2006. Check, through interviews, in private, with a representative number of seafarers, that they have not paid a fee or other charge to a recruitment or placement service and have been in- formed of their rights and duties. Check, through interviews, in private, with a representative number of seafarers, that the recruitment and placement ser - vice used does not operate a blacklist. 4318000 -30480 3 0 0 3 Examples of deficiencies No documentary evidence available to indicate that the service or agency is operated in accordance with the MLC, 2006. A seafarer who was recruited through a private seafarer re- cruitment and placement service that was not licensed or certi - fied or regulated in accordance with the MLC, 2006, or whose licence or certificate or any other similar document is no longer valid. Use of a recruitment and placement service requiring the seafarer to pay a fee or otherwise making a charge for em - ployment services (if this is a possibility then it should also be reported to the competent authority in the State where the service is based). A seafarer working on board who was recruited by a recruit- ment and placement service operating in a country that has not ratified the MLC, 2006, in cases where the shipowner cannot support its conclusion of consistency with the MLC, 2006. Regulation 2.1 – Seafarers’ employment agreements Standard A2.1; Guideline B2.1 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements All seafarers must have a copy of their seafarers’ employment agreement (SEA) signed by both the seafarer and the ship- owner or shipowner’s representative (or, where they are not employees, other evidence of contractual or similar arrange- ments ). A SEA must, at a minimum, contain the matters set out in Standard A2.1, paragraph 4(a)–(k) of the MLC, 2006 (Stand- ard A2.1, paragraph 4). Seafarers must also be given a document containing a record of their employment on the ship (such as a discharge book) (Standard A2.1, paragraph 1(e)). Where a collective bargaining agreement forms all or part of the SEA, the agreement must be on board the ship with rele - vant provisions in English (except for ships engaged only in domestic voyages) (Standard A2.1, paragraph 2). A SEA continues to have effect while a seafarer is held captive on or off the ship as a result of acts of piracy or armed robbery against ships, regardless of whether the date fixed for its expiry has passed or either party has given notice to suspend or terminate it (Standard A2.1, paragraph 7). How to check the basic requirements Check a copy of the SEA and any applicable collective bar- gaining agreements for seafarers and, at a minimum, a stand- ard form of the SEA (in English) for the ship. Check, where possible, given the timing of the inspection rela - tive to employment period, possession by seafarers of a record of their employment (or request that such records are submit- ted to the inspector at a later date). Check that seafarers’ records of employment do not contain statements as to the quality of their work or as to their wages. Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm that, on signing a SEA, seafarers were given an oppor - tunity to examine and seek advice and freely accepted the agreement before signing. Examples of deficiencies A seafarer without a SEA working on the ship. A seafarer with a SEA that does not contain all the items in Standard A2.1, paragraph 4(a)–(k). 4318000 334645 3 0 0 3 A seafarer with a SEA that is inconsistent with the national re- quirements . No system or provisions for seafarers to have their employ- ment recorded. Seafarers are not given a record of their employment on the ship on completion of engagement. A collective bargaining agreement that forms all or part of the SEA is either not on board or, if on board, not in English on a ship that engages in international voyages. Standard form SEA is not in English. The SEA contains clauses that violate seafarers’ rights. Regulation 2.2 – Wages Standard A2.2; Guideline B2.2 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Seafarers must be paid at no greater than monthly intervals and in full for their work in accordance with their employment agreements.* Seafarers are entitled to an account each month indicating their monthly wage and any authorized deductions such as allotments. No unauthorized deductions, such as payments for travel to or from the ship. Charges for remittances/allotment** transmission services must be reasonable and exchange rates in accordance with national requirements. Where a seafarer is held captive on or off the ship as a result of acts of piracy or armed robbery against ships, wages and other entitlements under the SEA , relevant collective bargaining agreement or applicable national laws , including the remittance of any allotments, must continue to be paid during the entire period of captivity until the seafarer is released and duly repatriated, or, where the seafarer dies while in captivity, until the date of death as determined in accordance with applicable national laws or regulations (Standard A2.2, paragraph 7). * Flag States may wish to consider requiring shipowners to carry on board their ships’ documents such as a copy of payroll or electronic record sheets. ** An allotment is an arrangement whereby a proportion of seafarers’ earnings are regularly remitted, on their request, to their families or dependants or legal beneficiaries whilst the seafarers are at sea (Standard A2.2, paragraphs 3 and 4). How to check the basic requirements Check the SEA and documentation, such as the payroll records to confirm wages are being paid at intervals no greater than one month as specified in their SEA or relevant collective agreements. Check relevant documents showing service charges and ex- change rates applied to any remittances made to the seafarers’ families or dependants or legal beneficiaries at their request. Check relevant documents to confirm the payment of wages including the requirement that a monthly account (such as a wage slip) is provided to the seafarers. Copies of individual ac- counts should be available to inspectors at their request . Check that the wages set out in the SEA are consistent with national wages for seafarers, if national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements governing seafarers’ wages have been adopted. Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm compliance with requirements on the payment of wages. Examples of deficiencies A seafarer is not paid regularly (at least monthly) and in full in accordance with the SEA or collective bargaining agreement. A seafarer is not given a monthly account (such as a wage slip) of wage. Allotments are not being paid or are not being paid in accord- ance with the seafarer’s instructions. 4318000 40005 3 0 0 3 Charge for converting and transmitting currencies is not in line with national requirements. More than one set of wage accounts is in use. A seafarer who is held captive on or off the ship as a result of acts of piracy or armed robbery against ships is not or has not been paid during the entire period of captivity and until the release and due repatriation of the seafarer or, where the seafarer dies while in captivity, until the date of death as determined in accordance with applicable national laws and regulations. Regulation 2.3 – Hours of work and hours of rest Standard A2.3; Guideline B2.3 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements The minimum hours of rest* must not be less than ten hours in any 24-hour period and 77 hours in any seven-day period, if the relevant national law relates to hours of rest, or, if the relevant national law relates to hours of work, the maximum hours of work** must not exceed 14 hours in any 24-hour period and 72 hours in any seven-day period (Standard A2.3, paragraph 5, as implemented in national standards) .* ** Hours of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which must be at least six hours; the interval between consecutive periods of rest must not exceed 14 hours (Standard A2.3, paragraph 6, as implemented in the national stand- ards ).*** Account must be taken of the danger posed by the fatigue of seafarers (Standard A2.3, paragraph 4). * “Hours of rest” means time outside hours of work; this term does not include short breaks (Standard A2.3, paragraph 1(b)). ** “Hours of work” means time during which seafarers are required to do work on account of the ship (Standard A2.3, paragraph 1(a)). *** With respect to the national standards implementing Stand- ard A2.3: Standard A2.3, paragraph 3 provides that “Each Member acknow - ledges that the normal working hours’ standard for seafarers, like that for other workers, shall be based on an eight-hour day with one day of rest per week and rest on public holidays. However, this shall not prevent the Member from having procedures to authorize or register a collective agreement which determines seafarers’ normal working hours on a basis no less favourable than this standard.” Standard A2.3, paragraph 13 provides that “Nothing in paragraphs 5 and 6 of this Standard shall prevent a Member from having national laws or regulations or a procedure for the competent authority to authorize or register collective agreements permitting exceptions to the limits set out. Such exceptions shall, as far as possible, follow the provisions of this Stand- ard but may take account of more frequent or longer leave periods or the granting of compensatory leave for watchkeeping seafarers or seafarers working on board ships on short voyages.” How to check the basic requirements Check that there is an approved standardized table of ship- board working arrangements setting out the national require- ments for maximum hours of work or the minimum hours of rest and the schedule for service at sea and in port, posted in an easily accessible place on the ship. Check the working arrangement listed in the table. Check documents (the SEA or the relevant collective agree- ment and other documents, such as the bridge and engine room logbooks, that can also be checked) to confirm compli - ance with the basic requirements concerning minimum hours of rest or maximum hours of work. Check for a table of working arrangements or schedule in the working language or language of the ship and in English. Check that there are up to date records of work or rest, as re- quired under national standards, for each seafarer serving on the ship. 4318000 203200 3 0 0 3 Check for seafarer fatigue, possibly indicated by hours of work that are consistently at the upper limits and by other contri - butory factors, such as disrupted rest periods. If there are seafarers that show symptoms such as lack of concentration, irrelevant and inconsistent replies to questions, yawning and slow reaction times, further investigation may be considered. Examples of deficiencies A seafarer’s work schedule does not conform to the applicable standards. Table of working arrangements is not posted or does not con- tain required information. Table of working arrangements is not in English and the work- ing language(s) of the ship. Records of work or rest are not available or are not main- tained . Evidence of exceeding the limits of work and no record of sus - pension of the schedule, in accordance with Standard A2.3, paragraph 14, has been noted in a logbook or other document. Regulation 2.4 – Entitlement to leave Standard A2.4; Guidelines B2.4 * Inspected Basic requirements Seafarers must be allowed paid annual leave* in accordance with national laws and regulations implementing the MLC, 2006. Unauthorized agreements to forgo the minimum annual leave with pay are prohibited (Standard A2.4, paragraph 3). Seafarers are to be granted shore leave to benefit their health and well-being and consistent with the operational require- ments of their positions. * The MLC, 2006, allows for differing calculations but establishes a minimum annual paid leave calculated on the basis of 2.5 calendar days per month of employment. In addition to the minimum period of annual leave, seafarers may also be entitled to a number of public and customary holidays recognized by the flag State. This is regardless of whether they fall within the individual seafarer’s period of annual leave. For additional guidance see Guideline B2.4.1, paragraph 4. How to check the basic requirements Check documents, such as the SEA or the relevant collective agreement, to confirm that seafarers are provided with the an - nual leave with pay entitlement required by the flag State (at a minimum, to be calculated on the basis of 2.5 calendar days per month of employment). Check that seafarers’ employment and wage records confirm that this requirement is met. Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm that they receive paid annual leave and are allowed an appropriate level of shore leave by the shipowner . Examples of deficiencies Seafarer is not given paid annual leave. Seafarer who has an annual leave entitlement that is less than the national requirement (if more than 2.5 calendar days per month) or less than 2.5 calendar days per month of employ- ment . Seafarer does not have an entitlement to paid annual leave in the SEA. 4318000 280670 3 0 0 3 Seafarer has agreed to forgo minimum annual leave with pay (and the competent authority has not authorized the agree - ment ) (Standard A2.4, paragraph 3). Seafarer not allowed shore leave (although leave would be consistent with operational requirements of the seafarer’s position). Regulation 2.5 – Repatriation Standard A2.5 .1 ; Guideline B2.5 – Repatriation * Inspected Basic requirements Seafarers are to be repatriated, at no cost to themselves, in ac- cordance with the national provisions implementing the MLC, 2006. Shipowners are required to provide financial security to ensure that repatriation will occur. A copy of the applicable national provisions regarding repatri - ation must be carried on ships and available to seafarers in an appropriate language (Standard A2.5 .1 , paragraph 9). At a minimum seafarers are entitled to repatriation in the fol - lowing circumstances: if the seafarers’ employment agreement expires while they are abroad; when their seafarers’ employment agreement is terminated: by the shipowner ; or by the seafarer for justified reasons; and when the seafarers are no longer able to carry out their duties under their employment agreement or cannot be ex- pected to carry them out in the specific circumstances (Standard A2.5 .1 , paragraphs 1 and 2). How to check the basic requirements Check relevant documents confirming that shipowner has pro- vided financial security. Check that a copy of the national provisions or SEA or rele - vant collective bargaining agreement regarding repatriation is available (in an appropriate language) to seafarers. Check for compliance with any national provision that sea- farers under the age of 18 are to be repatriated after a pre- scribed period if it is apparent that they are unsuited to a career at sea (Guideline B2.5.2, paragraph 3). Examples of deficiencies Seafarer is not repatriated in accordance with national require- ments , or SEA or collective bargaining agreement. Ship does not have a copy of the national provisions on repatri - ation on board and accessible to seafarers. No evidence that financial security for repatriation has been provided. No provision for seafarer repatriation is in place. S tandard A2.5.2; Guideline B2.5. 3 – Financial security *Inspected and certified **Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements For all ships: A financial security system to assist seafarers in the event of their abandonment , is in place (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph s 1 and 3 ) . The financial security system may be in the form of a social security scheme or insurance or a national fund or other similar arrangements (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 3 ) . The financial security system must provide direct access, sufficient coverage and expedited financial assistance to any abandoned seafarer on board (Standard A2.5.2, paragraph 4 ). Assistance provided by the financial security system must be granted promptly upon a request made by the seafarer or seafarer’s nominated representative and supported by the necessary justification of entitlement (Standard A2.5.2, paragraphs 8 and 2). Assistance provided by the financial security system must be sufficient to cover (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 9 ) : a) outstanding wages and other entitlements due from the shipowner limited to four months; (b) all expenses reasonably incurred by the seafarer, including the cost of repatriation ( i.e. travel by appropriate and expeditious means, normally by air, and provision for food and accommodation from the time of leaving the ship until arrival at home, necessary medical care, passage and transport of personal effects and any other reasonable costs or charges arising from the abandonment (Standard A2.5.2, paragraph 10) ) ; (c) essential needs of the seafarer including such items as: adequate food, clothing where necessary, accommodation, drinking water supplies, essential fuel for survival on board the ship, necessary medical care and any other reasonable costs or charges from the act or omission constituting the abandonment until the seafarer’s arrival at home. The financial security must not cease before the end of the period of validity of the financial security unless the financial security provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority of the flag State (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 11 ) . Additional basic requirements for ships required to be certified : Ships must carry on board a certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security issued by the financial security provider (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 6 ) . A copy of the financial security certificate or other documentary evidence must be posted in a conspicuous place on board where it is available to the seafarer s (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 6 ) . Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, the document provided by each provider must be carried on board (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 6 ) . The certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must contain the information required in Appendix A2-I (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 7 ) . The certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must be in English or accompanied by an English translation (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 7 ) . How to check the basic requirements For all ships: Check relevant documents confirming that financial security has been provided . In addition, f or ships required to be certified : Check the certificate of financial security or other documentary evidence issued by the financial security provider, including when the financial security is provided through a social security scheme . Check that it is valid and posted in a conspicuous place. Interview seafarers in private. Check DMLC , Part I for any national substantial equivalences , and , if so, DMLC , Part II to check for compliance. Examples of deficiencies For all ships: No evidence that financial security for repatriation has been provided . Seafarers are not provided with direct access to the financial security system. The assistance provided by the financial security system does not cover outstanding wages limited to four months, reasonable expenses including the cost of repatriation and the seafarer’s essential needs. The financial security has ceased before the end of the period of validity as stated on the financial security certificate; or, where the financial security provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority of the flag State, the financial security has ceased before the end of that notification period; or is otherwise invalid. ALTERNATIVE WORDING: The financial security has ceased before: ( i ) the expiration date stated on the financial security certificate or (ii) the end of the notice period of at least 30 days given to the competent authority (where applicable); or is otherwise invalid. In addition, f or ships required to be certified : The certificate of financial security or other documentary evidence issued by the financial security provider, including when the financial security is provided through a social security scheme , is not carried on board. Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, not all documents provided by each provider are carried on board. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not posted in a conspicuous place on board where it is available to seafarers. The certificate or other documentary evidence does not include the required information as set out in Appendix A 2-I. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not available in English or is not accompanied by an English translation. The financial security certificate or other documentary evidence is invalid, for example, is expired or falsified . Regulation 2.7 – Manning levels Standard A2.7; Guideline B2.7 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Ship must have a sufficient number of seafarers employed on board to ensure that ships are operated safely, efficiently and with due regard to security under all conditions, taking into ac- count concerns about fatigue and the particular nature and conditions of voyage. 4318000 29845 3 0 0 3 Ship must comply with the manning levels listed on the Safe Manning Document (SMD) or equivalent issued by the com- petent authority (Standard A2.7, paragraph 1). How to check the basic requirements Check safe manning document (SMD) or applicable equiv - alent . Check crew list for number, category (such as cooks and those responsible for food preparation and those who are respon - sible for medical care) and qualifications of seafarers working on board. Check on-board table of working arrangements to confirm that safe manning requirements are being implemented. Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm that requirements are met. Examples of deficiencies Number and/or categories of seafarers working on board does not correspond with those stated in the SMD. No SMD or equivalent on board. Regulation 3.1 – Accommodation and recreational facilities Standard A3.1; Guideline B3.1 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Ships must be in compliance with the minimum standards es - tablished by the MLC, 2006, providing and maintaining decent accommodation and recreational facilities for seafarers work- ing or living on ships, or both, consistent with promoting sea- farers’ health and well-being. Seafarer accommodation must be safe and decent and must meet national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006 (Standard A3.1, paragraph 1). Frequent inspections of seafarer accommodation areas are carried out by the master or a designate (Standard A3.1, para- graph 18) and are recorded and the records are available for review. For ships coming into service: The attending flag State inspector should be aware of the plan approval process undertaken during the construction of the ship with respect to the seafarer accommodation arrange- ments . As part of the first inspection of a ship the inspector will need to verify that the accommodation and recreational facil - ities have been constructed in accordance with the approve d drawings. The same applies to ships that have been substan - tially altered. This process need not be repeated for subse - quent inspections. For ships that were in existence before entry into force of the MLC, 2006, for the flag State: Account must be taken of any national provisions that may have been adopted (see Chapter 2 of these guidelines) with respect to this issue. These ships will still need to be inspected in connection with seafarers’ accommodation and recreational facilities to verify that the ship: meets the standards set out in either ILO Conventions Nos 92, 133, 147 or the Protocol of 1996 to Convention No. 147 (if applicable in the flag State); and/or 4318000 469265 3 0 0 3 provides and maintains decent accommodation and recre - ational facilities for seafarers working or living on board, or both, consistent with promoting the seafarers’ health and well-being in accordance with national legislation. How to check the basic requirements Check the construction plan of the ship that shows dimensions and identifying the use to be made of each room or other area. Check the crew list compared to the number of sleeping rooms and berths. Carry out a visual observation of seafarers’ on-board accom - modation and recreational facilities with particular attention paid to the following requirements in the MLC, 2006: general requirements (Standard A3.1, paragraph 6); the size of rooms and other accommodation spaces (Stand- ard A3.1, paragraphs 9 and 10); heating and ventilation (Standard A3.1, paragraph 7); noise and vibration and other ambient factors (Stand- ard A3.1, paragraph 6(h)); sanitary and related facilities (Standard A3.1, paragraphs 11 and 13); lighting (Standard A3.1, paragraph 8); hospital accommodation (Standard A3.1, paragraph 12); recreational facilities (Standard A3.1, paragraphs 14 and 17); occupational safety and health and accident prevention requirements on ships, in light of the specific needs of sea- farers who both live and work on ships (Standard A3.1, paragraphs 2(a) and 6(h)). Check the on-board records to confirm that frequent inspec - tions are carried out by, or under the authority of, the ship’s master, as well as (for ships that carry a Maritime Labour Cer - tificate ) that other inspections or actions provided for in the shipowners’ approved measures found in the DMLC, Part II, have been carried out. Check that measures are being taken on the ship to monitor noise and vibration levels in seafarers’ working and living areas. Examples of deficiencies Location of sleeping rooms on the ship does not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. Number and/or size (including height) of sleeping rooms does not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. More than one seafarer per berth. Recreational facilities do not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. Heating, lighting or ventilation is inadequate or not function- ing correctly. Fittings and fixtures within seafarer accommodation areas, in- cluding the hospital, mess rooms and recreational rooms, do not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. Separate sleeping rooms are not provided for males and females. Separate sanitation facilities are not provided for males and females. Sanitary facilities are inadequate or not functioning. Hospital is being used to accommodate persons who are not sick. Seafarer accommodation or recreational facilities are not be- ing maintained in a clean and tidy condition. 4318000 346075 3 0 0 3 Regular inspections of seafarer accommodation are not being carried out by the master or another designated person. Laundry facilities are inadequate or not functioning correctly. Exposure to hazardous levels of noise and vibration and other ambient factors and chemicals in the seafarer accommodation or recreational or catering facilities. Regulation 3.2 – Food and catering Standard A3.2; Guideline B3.2 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Food and drinking water must be of appropriate quality, nutri - tional value and quantity, taking into account the requirements of the ship and the differing cultural and religious backgrounds of seafarers on the ship. Food is to be provided free of charge to seafarers during the period of engagement. Seafarers employed as ship’s cooks* with responsibility for preparing food must be trained and qualified for their posi - tions . Seafarers working as ship’s cooks must not be less than 18 years old (Standard A3.2, paragraph 8). Frequent and documented inspections of food, water and catering facilities are carried out by the master or a designate (Standard A3.2, paragraph 7). * “Ship’s cook” means a seafarer with responsibility for food prepar - ation (Regulation 3.2, paragraph 3; Standard A3.2, paragraphs 3 and 4). How to check the basic requirements Check documents (see Regulation 1.1 on minimum age) to confirm that the ship’s cooks are 18 years old or older and that the ship’s cooks are trained, qualified and competent for their positions in accordance with national requirements. In cases where a fully qualified cook is not required, check that sea- farers processing food in the galley are trained or instructed in food and personal hygiene and handling and storage of food on board ships. Check on-board records to confirm that frequent and docu - mented inspections are made of: supplies of food and drinking water; spaces used for handling and storage of food; galleys and other equipment used in the preparation and service of meals. Visual observation of catering facilities, including galleys and store rooms, to check that they are hygienic and fit for purpose. Check that food and drinking water are of an appropriate qual - ity (for example, not out of date) and quantity and nutritional value by: checking drinking water quality and ascertaining how the quality is monitored; reviewing menu plans together with visual observation of food supplies and storage areas to ensure that the food sup- plied is varied in nature. Check, by interviewing, in private, a representative number of seafarers, that they are not charged for food and are provided with drinking water and that food and drinking water are of ap - propriate quality and quantity. 4318000 -34290 3 0 0 3 Examples of deficiencies Food and drinking water are not of appropriate quality, nutri - tional value and quantity, for the seafarers on the ship. Seafarer is charged for food and/or is not provided with drink- i n g w a t e r. i n g w a t e r. Seafarer who has responsibility for preparing food is untrained or not instructed as required. Ship’s cook is not trained and qualified. Ship’s cook is under 18 years of age. Frequent and documented inspections of the food or water or the preparation/storage/handling areas are not being carried out. Catering facilities are not hygienic or are otherwise unfit for purpose. Regulation 4.1 – Medical care on board ship and ashore Standard A4.1; Guideline B4.1 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Seafarers must be covered by adequate measures for the pro- tection of their health and have access to prompt and adequate medical care, including essential dental care, whilst working on board. Health protection and care are to be provided at no cost to the seafarer, in accordance with national law and practice. Shipowners are to allow seafarers the right to visit a qualified medical doctor or dentist without delay in ports of call, where practicable (Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(c)). How to check the basic requirements Check documents (such as the SEA) to confirm that, to the extent consistent with national law and practice, medical care and health protection services while seafarers are on board ship or landed in a foreign port, are provided free of charge (see Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(d)). Check documents (such as the SEA) to confirm that seafarers are given the right to visit a qualified medical doctor or dentist, without delay, when calling at a port, where practicable (see Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(c)). Check records and equipment to confirm that general provi - sions on occupational health protection and medical care are being observed (Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(a)). Undertake visual observation to confirm that the ship is equipped with sufficient medical supplies including a medicine chest and equipment, including either the most recent edition of the International Medical Guide for Ships or a medical guide as required by national laws and regulations. Check documents (such as the SMD and crew list) to confirm that a qualified medical doctor is working on board ships that carry 100 or more people and that are ordinarily engaged in voyages of more than three days’ duration. Check that, where ships are not required to carry a medical doctor, they have at least one seafarer on board (who is trained and qualified to the requirements of STCW) to be in charge of medical care or is competent to provide medical first aid as part of their regular duties. Check that medical report forms are carried on board the ship. 4318000 398145 3 0 0 3 Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm that seafarers have access to medical care on board without charge and are given leave to obtain medical and den- tal care services when calling in a port, where practicable. Check that procedures are in place for radio or satellite com- munications for medical assistance. Example s o f de f i c i en c i es Example s o f de f i c i en c i es A seafarer working on the ship is denied, without justification, shore leave by the master and/or shipowner to go ashore for medical or dental care. A seafarer is not provided with appropriate health protection and medical care on board ship. Medical personnel, with appropriate qualifications, as required by national laws or regulations, are not on board. Medical chest or equipment does not meet national standards and/or no medical guide is on board. No medical report forms are on board. Evidence that a seafarer is being charged for medical or dental care, contrary to national law or practice. Regulation 4.2 – Shipowners’ liability Standard A4.2 .1 ; Guideline B4.2 .1 – Shipowners’ liability Standard A4.2.2; Guideline B4.2.2 – Treatment of contractual claims * Inspected and certified **Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements Seafarers have a right to material assistance and support from the shipowner with respect to the financial consequences of sickness, injury or death occurring while they are serving under a SEA or arising from their employment under such agreement ( Regulation 4.2, paragraph 1 ) . Shipowners are liable to defray the expense of medical care, in- cluding medical treatment and the supply of the necessary medicines and therapeutic appliances, and board and lodging away from home until the sick or injured seafarer has re- covered, or until the sickness or incapacity has been declared of a permanent character (Standard A4.2 .1 , paragraph 1(c)). Measures are to be taken for safeguarding property of seafarers left on board by sick, injured or deceased seafarers and for returning it to them or to their next of kin (Standard A4.2 .1 , paragraph 7). Shipowners are to provide financial security to assure compen - sation in the event of the death or long-term disability of sea- farers due to an occupational injury, illness or hazard, as set out in national law, the SEA or collective agreement (Standard A4.2 .1 , paragraph 1(b)). The system of financial security, as provided for in Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 1(b), may be in the f orm of a social security scheme or insurance or fund or other similar arrangements (Standard A4.2.2, paragraph 2) . The contractual compensation where set out in the SEA and without prejudice to Standard A4.2.1., paragraph 8 (c), must be paid in full and without delay (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (a) ) . There must not be pressure to accept a payment less than the contractual amount (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (b) ) . Where the nature of the long-term disability of a seafarer makes it difficult to assess the full compensation to which the seafarer may be entitled, an interim payment or payments must be made to the seafarer so as to avoid undue hardship (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (c) ) . I n accordance with Regulation 4.2, paragraph 2, t he seafarer must receive payment without prejudice to other legal rights, but such payment may be offset by the shipowner against any damages resulting from any other claim made by the seafarer against the shipowner and arising from the same incident (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (d) ) . The claim for contractual compensation may be brought directly by the seafarer concerned, or their next of kin, or a representative of the seafarer or designated beneficiary (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (e) ) . For the purposes of Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 8, the term “contractual claim” means any claim which relates to death or long-term disability of seafarers due to an occupational injury, illness or hazard as set out in national law, the SEA or collective agreement (Standard A4.2.2 , paragraph 1 ) . Effective arrangements must be in place to receive, deal with and impartially settle contractual claims relating to compensation referred to in Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 8, through expeditious and fair procedures (Standard A4.2.2 , paragraph 3) . Seafarers must receive prior notification if a shipowner’s financial security is to be cancelled or terminated (Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 9) . The financial security must not cease before the end of the period of validity of the financial security unless the provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 12) . The financial security must provide for the payment of all contractual claims covered by it, which arise during the period for which the document is valid (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 13) . A certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security issued by the financial security provider must be carried on board (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 11) . A copy of the certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must be posted in a conspicuous place on board where it is available to the seafarers (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 11) . Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, the document provided by each provider must be carried on board (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 11) . The certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must contain the information required in Appendix A4-I (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 14) . The certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must be in English or accompanied by an English translation (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 14) . How to check the basic requirements Check the SEA and/or relevant collective bargaining agree- ment to verify that seafarers have the coverage required by national law implementing the MLC, 2006. Check for on-board procedures with respect to property that is left on board by sick, injured or deceased seafarers. Check documents confirming that the shipowner has provided financial security to assure compensation as required. Check the certificate of financial security or other documentary evidence issued by the financial security provider. Check that the certificate of financial security or other documentary evidence is valid and posted in a conspicuous place. Check DMLC, Part I for any national substantial equivalences, and, if so, DMLC, Part II to check for compliance. Check the on-board complaint handling records. Interview seafarers in private . Examples of deficiencies No evidence that financial security has been provided. No information on coverage in the SEA or relevant collective bargaining agreement , if applicable . 4318000 35560 3 0 0 3 Where applicable, provisions in the SEA or collective bargaining agreement are not consistent with national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006. Seafarers do not receive contractual compensation payments as set out in the SEA . Contractual compensation delayed or not paid in full. Seafarers are pressured to accept a payment less than the contractual amount. Interim payment(s) are not made to the seafarer, where the nature of the long-term disability of a seafarer makes it difficult to assess the full compensation to which the seafarer may be entitled. Seafarers are not provided with direct access to the financial security system. No effective arrangements are in place to receive, deal with and impartially settle contractual claims in accordance with flag State requirements as set out in the DMLC, Part I, point 16. If the shipowner’s financial security is to be or has been cancelled or terminated , and s eafarers have not been notified. The financial security has ceased before the end of the period of validity as stated on the financial security certificate; or, where the financial security provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority of the flag State, the financial security has ceased before the end of that notification period. ALTERNATIVE WORDING: The financial security has ceased before: ( i ) the expiration date stated on the financial security certificate or (ii) the end of the notice period of at least 30 days given to the competent authority (where applicable). The certificate of financial security or other documentary evidence issued by the financial security provider , including when the financial security is provided through a social security scheme , is not carried on board. Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, not all documents provided by each provider are carried on board. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not posted in a conspicuous place on board where it is available to the seafarers. The financial security certificate or other documentary evidence does not include the required information as set out in Appendix A 4-I. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not available in English or is not accompanied by an English translation. The financial security certificate or other documentary evidence is invalid, for example, is expired or falsified . No procedures are in place to safeguard seafarers’ property left on board , as required by Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 7 . Regulation 4.3 – Health and safety protection and accident prevention Standard A4.3; Guideline B4.3 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements The working, living and training environment on ships must be safe and hygienic and conform to national laws and regulations and other measures for occupational safety and health protec - tion and accident prevention on board ship. Reasonable pre- cautions are to be taken on the ships to prevent occupational accidents, injuries and diseases including risk of exposure to harmful levels of ambient factors and chemicals as well as the risk of injury or disease that may result from the use of equipment and machinery on the ship (Standard A4.3, para- graph 1(b)). Ship must have an occupational safety and health policy and programme to prevent occupational accident injuries and dis- eases, with a particular concern for the safety and health of sea- farers under the age of 18 (Standard A4.3, paragraphs 1(c) and 2(b)). A ship safety committee, that includes participation by the sea- farer safety representative, is required (for ships with five or more seafarers) (Standard A4.3, paragraph 2(d)). Risk evaluation is required for on-board occupational safety and health management (taking into account relevant statisti - cal data) (Standard A4.3, paragraph 8). How to check the basic requirements Check relevant documents, such as the on-board occupational accident reports, and the reports of risk evaluations under- taken for the management of occupational safety and health on the ship. Check for documents evidencing membership and meetings of the safety committee (e.g. records and minutes of the meeti ngs, etc.) if the ship has five or more seafarers. Check documents related to the ship’s on-board ongoing occu - pational safety and health policy and programme , to confirm that: it is available to seafarers; it is consistent with national provisions; it includes risk evaluation, training and instruction for sea- farers; it pays special attention to the health and safety of young seafarers; adequate preventive measures are being taken; appropriate personal protective equipment is being used and maintained correctly. Check that relevant occupational safety and health and acci - dent prevention notices and official instructions with respect to particular hazards on the ships are posted on the ship in a location that will bring it to the attention of seafarers (Standard A4.3, paragraph 7). 4318000 116205 3 0 0 3 Check that appropriate protective equipment is available for seafarers to use. Check that a reporting procedure for occupational accidents is in place. Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm on-board occupational safety and health programmes and practices. Check that, with respect to health and safety protection and accident prevention, special consideration is given to any national requirements covering: the structural features of the ship, including means of ac- cess and asbestos-related risks; machinery; the effects of the extremely low or high temperature of any surfaces with which seafarers may be in contact; the effects of noise in the workplace and in shipboard ac- commodation ; the effects of vibration in the workplace and in shipboard accommodation; the effects of ambient factors (other than noise and vibra - tion ) in the workplace and in shipboard accommodation, including tobacco smoke; special safety measures on and below deck; loading and unloading equipment; fire prevention and fire-fighting; anchors, chains and lines; dangerous cargo and ballast; personal protective equipment for seafarers; work in enclosed spaces; physical and mental effects of fatigue; the effects of drug and alcohol dependency; HIV/AIDS protection and prevention; emergency and accident response ; harassment and bullying on board ship . Examples of deficiencies Conditions exist on board which may impair efforts to prevent accidents. No evidence of an on-board policy and/or programmes for the prevention of occupational accidents, injuries and diseases. No established or functioning ship’s safety committee when there are five or more seafarers working on board. Personal protective equipment is in poor condition or being in- correctly used or not being used. Risk assessments are missing. Seafarers are unaware of the measures adopted by the man- agement to provide OSH and to prevent accidents. Risks posed to young seafarers have not been addressed. Occupational accidents are not being investigated or reported in accordance with the ship’s procedures. Regulation 4.5 – Social security Standard A4.5; Guideline B4.5 * Inspected Basic requirements 4318000 711200 3 0 0 3 Seafarers who are subject to the flag State’s social security legislation, and, to the extent provided for in its national law, their dependants , are entitled to benefit from social secur - ity protection no less favourable than that enjoyed by shore workers. Note: The MLC, 2006, requires that all seafarers be provided with social protection. This covers a number of complementary requirements in- cluding prevention-based approaches in connection with occupational safety and health, medical examinations, hours of work and rest and cater- ing . Social protection is mainly addressed in the Title 4 with respect to Med- ical care (Regulation 4.1); Shipowner liability (Regulation 4.2); and Social security (Regulation 4.5). Regulation 4.5 and the related Standard A4.5 re- flect an approach that recognizes the wide range of national systems and schemes and differing areas of coverage with respect to the provision of social security. Under Standard A4.5, paragraph 3, a ratifying country is re- quired to “take steps according to its national circumstances to provide the complementary social security protection referred to in paragraph 1 of this Standard to all seafarers ordinarily resident in its territory”. The resulting protection must be no less favourable than that enjoyed by shoreworkers resident in its territory. The main responsibility of flag States is to ensure that the shipowners’ social security obligations are respected for seafarers on their ships, particularly those set out in Regulations 4.1 and 4.2 (see Standard A4.5, paragraph 5). A more general duty, referred to in Standard A4.5, paragraph 6, and Guideline B4.5, paragraph 5, is also applicable to flag States. ILO member States are to give consideration to ways in which comparable benefits could be provided to seafarers who do not have ade - quate social security coverage and to possibly themselves arrange for the needed protection to be provided. This responsibility reflects the fact that all States have an important role in promoting the protection of all seafarers and in cooperating to help ensure such protection. In this way flag States can make an important contribution to the achievement of adequate social security protection for seafarers worldwide. In the context of flag State inspection of ships the main concern lies with confirming the complementary protection to be provided by ship- owners and stated in the SEA (Standard A2.1, paragraph 4(h)). How to check the basic requirements Check for evidence that, for seafarers covered by the national social security system, the appropriate contributions are being made if it is a contributory system. Check the SEA to confirm the protection to be provided by the shipowner . Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm that mandatory contributions, if any, are made. Examples of deficiencies No information on protection in the SEA. Mandatory contributions are not being made. Standard A5.1.1 – General principles Standard A5.1.1; Guideline B5.1.1 * Inspected Basic requirements Ships are required to have a copy of the MLC, 2006, available on board. How to check the basic requirements Check to confirm that there is a copy of the MLC, 2006, on board. Examples of deficiencies No copy of the MLC, 2006, on board. Regulation 5.1.5 – On-board complaint procedures Standard A5.1.5; Guideline B5.1.5 * Inspected and certified ** Review DMLC, Part II Basic requirements 4318000 349250 3 0 0 3 Ships must have on-board procedures for the fair, effective and expeditious handling of seafarer complaints alleging breaches of the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (including seafarers’ rights). All seafarers must be provided with a copy of the on-board complaint procedures applicable on the ship. This should be in the working language of the ship. Victimization of seafarers for filing complaints under the MLC, 2006, is prohibited. How to check the basic requirements Check the document outlining the on-board complaint proced - ures to confirm that the procedures are functioning on the ship, paying particular attention to the right of representation and to the required safeguards against victimization. Check that seafarers are provided with a copy of the on-board complaint procedures in the working language of the ship. Check a document outlining the on-board complaint proced - ures to confirm that seafarers are able to complain directly to the ship’s master or an external authority. Interview, in private, a representative number of seafarers to confirm that seafarers are given a copy of the procedures and that they are able to complain directly to the ship’s master or an external authority and that there is no victimization. Examples of deficiencies No document setting out the on-board complaint procedures. Ship’s on-board complaint procedures are not operating. Victimization of a seafarer for making a complaint. Seafarer is not provided with a copy of the complaint proced - ures in the working language of the ship. Action to be taken if deficiencies are identified General note 105 . It is recalled that the national laws and regulations or other measures implementing the MLC, 2006, provisions remain the overriding authority on the applicable requirements for inspec - tions . The MLC, 2006, sets out a number of possible responses available to flag State inspectors (or the competent authority in the flag State) to help ensure that ships comply with those national re- quirements . Some actions are required while others allow for some exercise of discretion. All actions involve an exercise of pro- fessional judgement by the flag State inspector on identifying deficiencies (including those identified during the course of investi - gating a complaint (see Chapter 2) as set out in Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 5). 4318000 911225 4 0 0 4 In determining the action to be taken, an important con- sideration is the question of who is to take the action. Where authority for verifying compliance with the MLC, 2006, has been delegated to an RO, it is important to remember that the flag State remains fully responsible for the inspection and certification of working and living conditions of seafarers on ships that fly its flag (Regulation 5.1.1, paragraph 3). The RO must, however, as a min- imum be empowered to require the rectification of deficiencies that it identifies in seafarers’ working and living conditions and to carry out inspections in this regard at the request of a port State (Standard A5.1.2, paragraph 2). Some possible remedies, such as withdrawing certifi - cates, apply specifically to certified ships, others such as detaining a ship apply to all ships and relate to the flag State inspector’s author- ity to require rectification of the deficiencies before allowing a ship to sail. In addition, national laws or regulations may enable the flag State inspector or competent authority to impose penalties and other corrective measures on shipowners for breaches of the re- quirements of the MLC, 2006 (including seafarers’ rights). Action taken is subject to any right of appeal by the shipowner to a judicial or administrative authority (Standard A5.1.4, paragraph 8). In addition to specific events that may result in invalidity of a certificate (Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 14), Standard A5.1.3, paragraphs 7, 9, 16 and 17 should also be considered. Before a certificate can be issued or endorsed or a ship allowed to sail, the flag State inspector would need to have con- firmation either that all deficiencies noted during the inspection have been rectified or that a rectification action plan has been pro- vided by the owner and agreed by the inspector. As noted in Chapter 2, under Standard A5.1.3, para- graph 11, in the case of a ship that is certified, the results of subse - quent inspections (after the first inspection) or verifications and any significant deficiencies found during the verification are to be recorded together with the date when the deficiencies were found to be remedied. This record, in English (or an English translation when it is not written in English), is to be either written on the on-board copy of the DMLC or appended to it or otherwise made available in some way for the information of seafarers, flag State inspectors, authorized officers in a port State and shipowners’ and seafarers’ representatives. Chapter 3 contains examples of deficiencies for inspected items. In all cases any deficiencies should be rectified. Rectification of a deficiency related to shipowner use of recruitment and placement services should not, in principle, be to the detriment of the seafarers affected. In some cases a single instance of the deficiency, including a breach of seafarers’ rights, may be sufficient to prevent a ship from going to sea until it is rectified, e.g. a ship with an under- age person working as a seafarer. In other cases, a deficiency, for example, a breach of the lighting requirements in one sleeping room, may be rectified within a period of time. However, if there is a history of this problem or, if faulty or inadequate lighting in areas including sleeping rooms indicates an overall occupational safety and health problem (meeting criteria in Standard A5.1.4, para- graph 7(c)), a decision may be taken that the ship should not sail until the deficiencies are rectified. Flag State inspectors will need to use their professional judgement as to whether a ship should be allowed to sail before the deficiency is rectified and, if it is not rectified, to decide on what action to take including withdrawal of the certificate. Guidance on making determinations as to action Depending upon the number and severity of any defi - ciencies the flag State inspector may consider the following actions: give appropriate advice; 4318000 167005 4 0 0 4 list, with appropriate timescales, the deficiencies to be recti- fied , for example, before departure; within 14 days; or before the issue of a Maritime Labour Certificate ; prevent the ship from leaving port until necessary actions are taken ; taken ; impose any penalties or other corrective measures available under national law ; in the case of ships that are certified: withdraw the Maritime Labour Certificate; refuse to endorse the Maritime Labour Certificate follow- ing an intermediate inspection or refuse to renew the cer - tificate . When considering which action or actions to take, flag State inspectors should use their professional judgement. In add- ition , flag State inspectors should take into account the following when reaching a decision on whether or not to accept a rectifica - tion plan or prevent a ship from leaving port and/or recommend withdrawal of Maritime Labour Certificate: whether or not the non-conformities can be rapidly remedied in the port of inspection; whether the deficiencies constitute a significant danger to sea- farers’ safety, health or security; the seriousness of the breach of the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (including seafarers’ rights); length and nature of the intended voyage or service; size and type of ship and equipment provided; whether or not the appropriate rest period for seafarers is be- ing observed; nature of the cargo; prior history of similar deficiencies; number of deficiencies identified on the inspection; safe manning requirements; prior history with respect to rectifications. All reasonable efforts are to be made to avoid a ship being unreasonably detained or delayed (Standard A5.1.4, para- graph 15).
Aili Petti
Teema: FW: ILO – Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 – Request for comments on guidelines
Manused: FSG - update in English for circulation to member States MASTER 2.docx; PSG -
update in English for circulation to member States MASTER 2.docx
From: ILO-BIT-OIT <
[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, September 7, 2020 5:42 PM
To: ILO-BIT-OIT <
[email protected]>
Subject: ILO – Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 – Request for comments on guidelines
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR OFFICE
NOTE VERBALE
Ref.: ILO/RELOFF/07-09-2020/36
The International Labour Office presents its compliments to the Permanent Missions of States Members of the
International Labour Organization (ILO) and has the honour to transmit to them herewith the output of the
subsidiary body of the Special Tripartite Committee (STC) of the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 (MLC, 2006).
It is worth recalling that the STC was established under Article XIII of the MLC, 2006 to, inter alia, keep the
Convention under review. At its third meeting, in April 2018, the STC adopted the Resolution concerning
amendments to the ILO flag State inspection and port State control guidelines to reflect amendments to the Code of
the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006. This resolution sets out the process for updating the two sets of guidelines in
order to reflect the amendments adopted to the Convention. To this end, the STC decided, in accordance with
article 15 of its Standing Orders, to establish a subsidiary body to undertake the work. At its 334th session, the
Governing Body endorsed the establishment of the subsidiary body of the STC with the mandate described in
paragraph 20 of document GB.334/LILS/2(Rev.).
The subsidiary body of the STC, which is composed of four Government representatives, four Shipowner
representatives and four Seafarer representatives, and has been working in English via correspondence, has recently
completed its work. The output of the subsidiary body of the STC is herewith being circulated to all Member States
of the Organization (in English, French and Spanish, as appropriate) for comment by their competent authorities,
within three months of receipt, as provided in the STC resolution.
The Office would be grateful if Permanent Missions could channel this request through the authorities charged with
the implementation of the MLC, 2006, to ensure that the Government representatives submitting comments have
maritime experience or expertise. Any comments from Member States should be submitted by 7 December 2020 at
the latest, to Christine Bader (
[email protected]). All queries in this regard can also be addressed to Ms Bader by the
following means:
Christine Bader
Maritime Specialist
Maritime and Transport Unit
Sectoral Policies Department (SECTOR)
International Labour Office
4 route des Morillons
CH-1211 Geneva 22
Switzerland
Tel.: +41 22 799 7887
1
Email:
[email protected]
Permanent Missions will find attached the draft updates to the Guidelines for flag State inspections and Guidelines
for port State control officers carrying out inspections, under the MLC,2006. It is worth noting the following:
- All changes made to the text of the aforementioned guidelines are highlighted in yellow – be it newly
added text or deleted original text.
- Please indicate your disagreement, if any, with the changes made by the subsidiary body of the STC
using the tracked-changes mode.
- In the rare instances where there was no consensus within the subsidiary body of the STC, the changes
highlighted in yellow will, in addition, be underlined. Unless otherwise specified, the question is whether
to keep the relevant text or to delete it. Experts are invited to indicate their preference.
- The comments, if there were any, should not refer to page numbers or footnote numbers, as the
documents have not been formatted and these numbers may not be accurate; instead, they should
refer to paragraph numbers or the relevant MLC requirements.
- The preface will be modified and the formatting will be completed before the updated versions are
published online.
Under the coordination of the Officers of the STC, the final, updated version of the two updated flag and port State
guidelines will then be submitted to the Governing Body in March 2021 with the purpose of seeking its authorization
to publish the guidelines on the ILO website.
The International Labour Office avails itself of this opportunity to renew to the Permanent Missions of States
Members of the ILO the assurances of its highest consideration.
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS EMAIL.
-----------------------------------------
This electronic message may contain confidential, proprietary or privileged information intended solely for
the use of the named recipient. The ILO is not liable for any error or virus connected with this transmission.
-----------------------------------------
Ce message électronique peut contenir des informations confidentielles, ou spécialement protégées, à la
seule intention du destinataire. L'OIT ne peut être tenue responsable des erreurs ou des virus qui s'y
trouveraient.
-----------------------------------------
Este mensaje electrónico puede contener información confidencial o especialmente protegida para el uso
exclusivo del destinatario indicado. La OIT no se responsabiliza en caso de error o virus.
-----------------------------------------
2
Guidelines for port State control officers carrying out inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 as amended International Labour Organization Guidelines for port State control officers carrying out inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , a s amended International Labour Office Geneva Copyright © International Labour Organization 2009 First published 2009 Publications of the International Labour Office enjoy copyright under Protocol 2 of the Uni - versal Copyright Convention. Nevertheless, short excerpts from them may be reproduced without authorization, on condition that the source is indicated. For rights of reproduction or translation, application should be made to ILO Publications (Rights and Permissions), International Labour Office, CH-1211 Geneva 22, Switzerland, or by email:
[email protected]. The International Labour Office welcomes such applications. Libraries, institutions and other users registered with reproduction rights organizations may make copies in accordance with the licences issued to them for this purpose. Visit www.ifrro. org to find the reproduction rights organization in your country. I L O Gu i d e l i n e s f o r p o r t S t a t e c o n t r o l o f f i c e r s c a rr y in g ou t i n s p e c t i o n s u n d e r t h e Ma r i t i m e Labou r Convention , 2006 . Geneva , Int e r n ationa l Labou r Of fice , 2009 ISB N 9 78-92-2-121743- 5 (print ) ISB N 9 78-92-2-121744- 2 (web) guid e / m e rchan t marin e / se a t r anspor t / sea f a r e r / s a fe t y / wo r k i n g c o n d i t i on s / l a b our i n spec t i o n / IL O Convent i o n / app l ic a t ion . 1 0.05.3 A l s o availabl e i n French : Dir e ct i v e s p o u r l e s ag e n t s c h arg é s d u c o n t r ô l e p a r l ’ Etat d u p o r t effe c t u a n t d e s in s p e c t i o n s e n a p pl i c a t io n d e l a c o n v e n t i o n d u trava i l maritim e , 20 0 6 ( ISB N 978-92-2-2 2 1743- 4 ) , Gen ev a , 2009 , an d i n Spanish : P a ut a s pa r a l o s fu n c i o n a r i o s e n c a rga d o s de l c o n t r o l po r e l E s ta d o d e l p u e r t o q u e r e a l i za n i n s pe c c i o nes e n vi r t u d de l Conveni o so br e e l trabaj o mar í timo , 200 6 ( I SB N 978-92-2- 3 21743-3), Geneva , 2009. IL O Cat a l o g u i n g in P u b li c a t i o n D a ta I L O Gu i d e l i n e s f o r p o r t S t a t e c o n t r o l o f f i c e r s c a rr y in g ou t i n s p e c t i o n s u n d e r t h e Ma r i t i m e Labou r Convention , 2006 . Geneva , Int e r n ationa l Labou r Of fice , 2009 ISB N 9 78-92-2-121743- 5 (print ) ISB N 9 78-92-2-121744- 2 (web) guid e / m e rchan t marin e / se a t r anspor t / sea f a r e r / s a fe t y / wo r k i n g c o n d i t i on s / l a b our i n spec t i o n / IL O Convent i o n / app l ic a t ion . 1 0.05.3 A l s o availabl e i n French : Dir e ct i v e s p o u r l e s ag e n t s c h arg é s d u c o n t r ô l e p a r l ’ Etat d u p o r t effe c t u a n t d e s in s p e c t i o n s e n a p pl i c a t io n d e l a c o n v e n t i o n d u trava i l maritim e , 20 0 6 (ISB N 978-92-2-2 2 1743- 4 ) , Gen ev a , 2009 , an d i n Spanish : P a ut a s pa r a l o s fu n c i o n a r i o s e n c a rga d o s de l c o n t r o l po r e l E s ta d o d e l p u e r t o q u e r e a l i za n i n s pe c c i o nes e n vi r t u d de l Conveni o so br e e l trabaj o mar í timo , 200 6 ( I SB N 978-92-2- 3 21743-3), Geneva , 2009. IL O Cat a l o g u i n g in P u b li c a t i o n D a ta The designations employed in ILO publications, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the International Labour Office concerning the legal status of any country, area or territory or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers. The responsibility for opinions expressed in signed articles, studies and other contributions rests solely with their authors, and publication does not constitute an endorsement by the International Labour Office of the opinions expressed in them. Reference to names of firms and commercial products and processes does not imply their en - dorsement by the International Labour Office, and any failure to mention a particular firm, commercial product or process is not a sign of disapproval. ILO publications can be obtained through major booksellers or ILO local offices in many countries, or direct from ILO Publications, International Labour Office, CH-1211 Geneva 22, Switzerland . Catalogues or lists of new publications are available free of charge from the above address, or by email:
[email protected]. Visit our website: www.ilo.org/publns Photocomposed by the ILO, Geneva, Switzerland DTP Printed in France NOU Preface When the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 (MLC, 2006), was adopted by the 94th (Maritime) Session of the International Labour Conference of the International Labour Organization (ILO) in February 2006, it was described as a “historic event”. The MLC, 2006, is seen by seafarers as a “charter of rights” that will help ensure “Decent Work” for seafarers, no matter where ships sail and no matter which flag they fly. Shipowners also support the MLC, 2006, as it is seen as an important new tool to help ensure a level playing field for quality shipowners that may have to compete with ships that have substandard conditions. The MLC, 2006, is also important for governments because it brings together nearly 70 international legal instruments in one comprehensive modern document that covers almost every aspect of decent work in this sector. A key feature of the MLC, 2006, is that it builds on the strengths of the ILO approach to making sure that, in each country, inter- national labour standards are effectively implemented at the “ground level” and enforced . At the same time the MLC, 2006, meets the challenges of this globalized industry by taking over many elements that are found in other major maritime Conventions and have contributed to the success of those Conventions in ensuring safer and secure shipping and preventing marine pollution. The most important of these elements is found in the emphasis in the MLC, 2006, on effective flag State inspection and certification of ships, reinforced by international cooperation, particularly with respect to the inspection of foreign ships that is carried out in port States (port State control). Port State control is a practice that is already well developed under many regional cooperation agree- ments and memoranda of understanding (MOUs). These regional arrangements have proved to be very effective, in other areas of shipping , as a means of ensuring that ships continue to meet the international standards between flag State inspections and certifi - cation. The International Labour Conference saw the importance of ensuring that the MLC, 2006, was backed up by an effective system for inspections by flag States complemented by a widespread har - monized port State control. It adopted two key resolutions in- tended to support the promotion, ratification and effective imple - mentation of the Convention and the achievement of decent working and living conditions for seafarers. 1 These two resolutions are the “Resolution concerning the development of guidelines for port State control” (resolution IV), and the “Resolution concerning the development of guidelines for flag State inspection” (resolution XIII). Both resolutions called for tripartite meetings of experts to develop guidelines for flag State inspections and to assist port State control officers carrying out MLC, 2006, inspections. Resolution IV on developing guidelines for port State control requested the ILO Director-General to con- vene a tripartite expert meeting “to develop suitable guidance for port State control officers”, utilizing the technical expertise of the International Maritime Organization (IMO) in this area. The need to develop international guidelines and related national guidance for port State control had, in fact, been foreseen in the MLC, 2006, itself. The MLC, 2006, begins, in Article I, by requiring that: “Members shall cooperate with each other for the purpose of ensuring the effective implementation and enforcement of the Convention.” More specifically Regulation 5.2.1, paragraph 3 provides that “Inspections in a port shall be carried out by author- 1 Adopted 22 February 2006, International Labour Conference, 94th (Maritime) Session, 2006, Provisional Record No. 16, p. 16/9. VI Preface ized officers in accordance with the provisions of the Code and other applicable international arrangements governing port State control inspections in the Member.” Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 7 provides that “Each Member shall ensure that its authorized officers are given guidance, of the kind indicated in Part B of the Code, as to the kinds of circumstances justifying detention of a ship under para- graph 6 of this Standard.” Finally, Guideline B5.2.1, paragraph 3 provides that “Members should cooperate with each other to the maximum extent possible in the adoption of internationally agreed guidelines on inspection policies, especially those relating to the cir - cumstances warranting the detention of a ship.” Developing guidelines for port State control officers is thus an important response to the call for “internationally agreed guide- lines”, in so far as the implementation of the MLC, 2006, is con- cerned . However, a harmonized approach to port State control is an ongoing process that includes cooperation among countries and co- ordination of maritime inspection under several maritime Conven - tions , not just the MLC, 2006, but also particularly the relevant IMO Conventions. The Guidelines for port State control officers carrying out inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 (PSCO guidelines), were adopted in September 2008 by tripartite experts’ meetings attended by nearly 300 participants. The experts were drawn from all regions of the world. The PSCO guidelines con- tained in this book are published alongside the Guidelines for flag State inspection under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , which were also adopted by a tripartite experts’ meeting in Septem - ber 2008 and are intended to assist flag States to implement their inspection and certification responsibilities. Each country or region may have its own practices relating to port State control. These PSCO guidelines seek to fit in with those practices to the extent possible having regard to the special features and approaches of the MLC, 2006, in particular its tripartite charac - ter. The port State control authorities of the various countries may wish to adapt these guidelines to fit their current practices. These international guidelines are designed to be of practical assistance to governments in drafting their own national guidelines, espe - cially on the matter referred to in Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 7 mentioned above. It is hoped that they will, at the same time, achieve their primary aim – namely, uniformity worldwide in effective port State control to ensure compliance with the require - ments of the MLC, 2006. If this is achieved , seafarers will benefit from decent conditions of work, not only in law but also in prac - tice, and shipowners providing those conditions will know that they are doing so in a level playing field worldwide. Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry Director of the International Labour Standards Department Acknowledgements The ILO would like to express its appreciation to the Euro- pean Commission for its financial contribution to the preparation and publication costs of both Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 and Guidelines for port State control officers carrying out inspections under the Mari- time Labour Convention, 2006 , and for its commitment to promot - ing international cooperation in these important areas. Contents Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1.1. Explanation of the objectives and content of the guidelines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1.2. Brief overview of the MLC, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 1.3. Key concepts in the MLC, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 1.4. Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Port State control inspection responsibilities under the MLC, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Overview of the MLC, 2006, port State responsibilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 2.2. Port State control officers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Carrying out port State control inspections under the MLC, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 General considerations for MLC, 2006, port State control inspections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Procedure where inspection is initiated by the PSC authority . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Procedure for inspections initiated upon receipt of a complaint . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 More detailed inspection of maritime labour conditions on ships . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 4.1. General note . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 4.2. The basic requirements; sources of information; examples of deficiencies or non-conformities . . . . . . . 39 Action to be taken by port State control officers when finding deficiencies or non-conformities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Actions to be considered when deficiencies are found . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Examples of circumstances that may require detention of the ship . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 Factors to be considered by a PSCO in deciding whether to accept a rectification proposal . . . . . . . . . 70 Consultation prior to a decision concerning a rectification proposal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 Form and content of a proposal for rectification . . . . 71 Action to be taken if a rectification proposal is agreed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72 Action to be taken if the ship is not allowed to sail . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72 Onshore complaints by seafarers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75 4343400 197485 1 0 0 1 Introduction Explanation of the objectives and content of the guidelines In accordance with resolution IV of the 94th (Maritime) Session of the International Labour Conference (ILC), these inter- national guidelines for port State control officers 1 (PSCOs) have been developed to: assist port State administrations to effectively implement their responsibilities under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , as amended (MLC, 2006); and promote harmonization in the implementation of the provi - sions of the Convention concerning port State responsibilities. Pursuant to the 2018 Resolution of the Special Tripartite Committee established under Article XIII of the MLC, 2006 , the guidelines have been updated to reflect the 2014, 2016 and 2018 amendments. The guidelines are intended to provide supplementary practical information and guidance to port State administrations that can be adapted to reflect national practices and policies and other applicable international arrangements governing port State control inspections. The guidelines should be regarded as complementary to the national measures taken by administrations of flag States in their countries and abroad. They are intended to provide assist- ance to port State administrations in securing compliance with the 1 The MLC, 2006, uses the term “authorized officer” in Regulation 5.2.1 to reflect the fact that national situations differ and in some cases the person carrying out a port State inspection under the Convention may not necessar - ily be the same person or persons as those currently carrying out inspection under the existing international (regional) port State control arrangements. The 94th (Maritime) Session of the ILC resolution used the term “port State control officers”. In these guidelines the same term and the related acronym PSCO is used to refer to “authorized officer”. MLC, 2006. They should be read in conjunction with the guidelines for flag State inspections under the MLC, 2006, as much of the information contained in the flag State guidelines will also be helpful to personnel carrying out MLC, 2006, port State control inspections. The rest of Chapter 1 of these guidelines provides general information on the MLC, 2006, regarding its structure, key con- cepts and terminology. Chapter 2 provides background information on port State control inspection responsibilities in connection with the MLC, 2006. Chapters 3 and 4 address the procedures for carrying out port State control inspections under the MLC, 2006. The proced - ures describe, from a practical perspective, the various stages or steps that an inspection might go through, depending on the cir - cumstances that the PSCO finds when going on board a ship. Chap- ter 3 covers matters such as preparing for an inspection and the beginning part of a PSCO inspection, which is the on-board review of the ship’s MLC-related documents that provide prima facie evi - dence that the ship is in compliance. Chapter 3 also provides guid - ance on the matters that a PSCO would need to consider in making a determination as to whether an inspection is finished at that first point – the document review – or whether there are grounds for carrying out a more detailed inspection. Chapter 4 addresses the next stage, the more detailed on-board inspection of conditions on a ship in cases where the PSCO has concluded that there are grounds under the MLC, 2006, to carry out this level of inspection. Chapter 5 provides guidance on action to be taken by PSCOs on finding, after a more detailed inspection, that there are deficiencies or non-conformities on a ship. 4343400 235585 1 0 0 1 Chapter 6 outlines the steps to be taken in connection with the handling of onshore complaints that are made by seafarers (Regulation 5.2.2). Brief overview of the MLC, 2006 The Preamble to the MLC, 2006, sets out the intentions and the objectives of the Members of the International Labour Organ- ization in adopting the Convention. The Preamble refers to the global nature of the shipping industry and the need for seafarers to have special protection. It also links the MLC, 2006, to the other key international conventions that establish minimum standards for the shipping industry in connection with safety, security and marine environmental protection. The MLC, 2006, complement- ing other major international conventions, reflects international agreement on the minimum requirements for working and living conditions for seafarers. Like other international labour standards, the MLC, 2006, only sets out minimum international standards. However, recalling paragraph 8 of article 19 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization, the Preamble goes on to clarify that in no case shall the adoption of any Convention and Recommendation by the Conference or the ratification of any Convention by any Member be deemed to affect any law, award, custom or agreement which ensures more favourable conditions to the workers concerned than those provided for in the Convention or Recom - mendation . The MLC, 2006, contains an explanatory note, which was adopted by the 94th (Maritime) Session of the International Labour Conference to assist governments with respect to their legislative obligations and to understanding the legal relationship between the different parts of the MLC, 2006. It also provides an outline of the overall structure of the MLC, 2006. Explanatory note to the Regulations and Code of the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 This explanatory note, which does not form part of the Maritime Labour Convention, is intended as a general guide to the Conven - tion . The Convention comprises three different but related parts: the Articles, the Regulations and the Code. The Articles and Regulations set out the core rights and principles and the basic obligations of Members ratifying the Convention. The Articles and Regulations can only be changed by the Conference in the framework of article 19 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization (see Article XIV of the Convention). The Code contains the details for the implementation of the Regulations. It comprises Part A (Mandatory standards) and Part B (Non-mandatory guidelines). The Code can be amended through the simplified procedure set out in Article XV of the Convention. Since the Code relates to detailed implementation, amendments to it must remain within the general scope of the Articles and Regulations. The Regulations and the Code are organized into general areas under five Titles: Title 1: Minimum requirements for seafarers to work on a ship; Title 2: Conditions of employment; Title 3: Accommodation, recreational facilities, food and catering; Title 4: Health protection, medical care, welfare and social secur - ity protection; Title 5: Compliance and enforcement. Each Title contains groups of provisions relating to a particular right or principle (or enforcement measure in Title 5), with con- nected numbering. The first group in Title 1, for example, consists of Regulation 1.1, Standard A1.1 and Guideline B1.1 relating to mini- mum age. The Convention has three underlying purposes: to lay down, in its Articles and Regulations, a firm set of rights and principles; 4343400 233680 1 0 0 1 to allow, through the Code, a considerable degree of flexibility in the way Members implement those rights and principles; and to ensure, through Title 5, that the rights and principles are prop- erly complied with and enforced. There are two main areas for flexibility in implementation: one is the possibility for a Member, where necessary (see Article VI, paragraph 3), to give effect to the detailed requirements of Part A of the Code through substantial equivalence (as defined in Article VI, paragraph 4). The second area of flexibility in implementation is provided by formulating the mandatory requirements of many provisions in Part A in a more general way, thus leaving a wider scope for dis- cretion as to the precise action to be provided for at the national level. In such cases, guidance on implementation is given in the non- mandatory Part B of the Code. In this way, Members which have ratified this Convention can ascertain the kind of action that might be expected of them under the corresponding general obligation in Part A, as well as action that would not necessarily be required. For example, Standard A4.1 requires all ships to provide prompt access to the necessary medicines for medical care on board ship (para- graph 1(b)) and to “carry a medicine chest” (paragraph 4(a)). The fulfilment in good faith of this latter obligation clearly means some- thing more than simply having a medicine chest on board each ship. A more precise indication of what is involved is provided in the corre - sponding Guideline B4.1.1 (paragraph 4) so as to ensure that the con- tents of the chest are properly stored, used and maintained. Members which have ratified this Convention are not bound by the guidance concerned and, as indicated in the provisions in Title 5 on port State control, inspections would deal only with the relevant requirements of this Convention (Articles, Regulations and the Standards in Part A). However, Members are required under para- graph 2 of Article VI to give due consideration to implementing their responsibilities under Part A of the Code in the manner provided for in Part B. If, having duly considered the relevant Guidelines, a Mem- ber decides to provide for different arrangements which ensure the proper storage, use and maintenance of the contents of the medicine chest, to take the example given above, as required by the Standard in Part A, then that is acceptable. On the other hand, by following the guidance provided in Part B, the Member concerned, as well as the ILO bodies responsible for reviewing implementation of inter- national labour Conventions, can be sure without further consider- ation that the arrangements the Member has provided for are ade - quate to implement the responsibilities under Part A to which the Guideline relates. 12. Title 5 relates to compliance and enforcement and in- cludes the requirements of the MLC, 2006, in connection with carrying out inspections of foreign ships in a port (port State con- trol ) in Regulation 5.2.1 and Standard A5.2.1 with guidance pro- vided in Guideline B5.2.1. It is important to take account of the four seven appendices located at the end of Title 5 of the MLC, 2006. Appendix A2-I: Evidence of financial security under Regulation 2.5, paragraph 2; Appendix A4-I: Evidence of financial security under Regulation 4.2; Appendix B4-I: Model Receipt and Release Form referred to in Guideline B4.2.2; Appendix A5-III: List of areas that may be the subject of a more detailed inspection in a port State; Appendix A5-I: List of matters for flag State inspection for cer - tification purposes; Appendix A5-II: Model documents relating to the flag State inspection and certification system established in Title 5: Maritime Labour Certificate; Interim Maritime Labour Certificate; Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance (DMLC (two parts – Part I and Part II)); Appendix B5-I: An example, to provide guidance as to the way both parts of the DMLC might be filled out by the flag State (Part I) and a shipowner (Part II). Key concepts in the MLC, 2006 This section of Chapter 1 sets out some of the key concepts relating to the application of the MLC, 2006. Section 1.4, which fol - lows, contains the definitions of terms that are found in the MLC, 2006. Application 4343400 55880 1 0 0 1 The MLC, 2006, applies to all seafarers on all ships cov - ered by the Convention. A seafarer is any person 2 who is employed or engaged or works in any capacity on board a ship to which this Convention applies. 3 The terms “seafarer” and “ship” are defined in the MLC, 2006 (see section 1.4 below). 2 The MLC, 2006, provides that, in the event of doubt as to whether any categories of persons are to be regarded as “seafarers” for the purpose of the Convention, the question is to be determined by the competent authority in the flag State, after consultation with the shipowners and seafarers con- cerned . Guidance on this matter is provided in the resolution concerning information on occupational groups (No. VII), adopted at the 94th (Mari- time) Session of the International Labour Conference. 3 The MLC, 2006, applies to all ships, whether publicly or privately owned, ordinarily engaged in commercial activities. Subject to any national provisions to the contrary, the MLC, 2006, does not apply to: ships which navigate exclusively in inland waters or waters within, or closely adjacent to, sheltered waters or areas where port regulations apply; ships engaged in fish- ing or in similar pursuits and ships of traditional build such as dhows and junks; warships or naval auxiliaries. Seafarers’ rights The MLC, 2006, is intended to help achieve decent work for all seafarers. It sets out the fundamental rights and prin - ciples that seafarers have with respect to their working and living conditions. Article III of the MLC, 2006, relates to fundamental rights and principles requiring ILO member States to satisfy themselves that the provisions of their law and regulations respect, in the con- text of this Convention, the fundamental rights to: freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; the elimination of all forms of forced or compulsory labour ; the effective abolition of child labour ; and the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation. Article IV relates to seafarers’ employment and social rights and states: Every seafarer has the right to a safe and secure workplace that complies with safety standards. Every seafarer has a right to fair terms of employment. Every seafarer has a right to decent working and living conditions on board ship. Every seafarer has a right to health protection, medical care, wel - fare measures and other forms of social protection. Each Member shall ensure, within the limits of its jurisdiction, that the seafarers’ employment and social rights set out in the preceding paragraphs of this Article are fully implemented in accordance with the requirements of the Convention. Unless specified otherwise in the Convention, such implementation may be achieved through national laws or regulations, through applicable collective bargaining agreements or through other measures or in practice. Compliance and enforcement The flag State must verify, through an effective and coor - dinated system of regular inspection, monitoring and other control measures that ships comply with the requirements of the Conven - tion as implemented in national laws or regulations, or collective bargaining agreements or other measures or practices implement- ing the requirements of the MLC, 2006. Generally, under Regula- tion 5.1.3, in addition to being inspected, ships must also be certified for compliance with the requirements for the 14 16 areas of seafarers’ working and living conditions set out in Title 5, Appen - dix A5-I. For ships that do not have to be certified (under 500 gross tonnage ( gt ), or ships that are not engaged in international voyages 4343400 235585 1 0 0 1 and that do not operate from a port or between ports in another country) the flag State must still verify compliance for all the same requirements as a certified ship. The MLC, 2006, recognizes that ILO Members need some flexibility to address particular national situations, especially with respect to smaller ships and ships that do not go on international voyages or specific kinds of ships. It also recognizes that flag States may not always be in a position to implement the requirements of the MLC, 2006, in the manner set out in Part A of the Code and allows them to adopt measures which are “substantially equiv - alent ”. The MLC, 2006, provides guidance primarily directed to national law-making bodies in flag States as to the ways in which this national flexibility can be exercised. For ships that are engaged in international voyages or operate from a port or between ports in another country, these matters will be stated on the MLC, 2006, documents carried on ships for the information of flag State inspectors and authorized officers carrying out port State control inspections (PSCOs). Certified ships For ships of 500 gt or over that are engaged in international voyages or ships of 500 gt or over that fly the flag of one country and operate from a port or between ports in another country, the MLC, 2006, contains a list of 14 16 areas that are subject to a mandatory certi - fication system (see MLC, 2006, Title 5, Appendix A5-I). Certifica - tion is mandatory only for some ships that are covered by the MLC, 2006; however a shipowner can also request that a ship be certified even in cases where certification is not required. The documents that are issued by the flag State, or by an RO on its behalf, if so authorized, are the Maritime Labour Certifi - cate and a DMLC. The DMLC has two parts. Part I is filled out by the flag State and refers to the relevant national requirements that are to be certified as having been complied with. Part II is prepared by the shipowner and outlines the measures that the shipowner has put in place to ensure ongoing compliance on the ship with these flag State requirements . These two documents and also the conditions that they certify may be the subject of an inspection in foreign ports (port State control inspection). Models for the documents that must be carried on ships can be found in Appendix A5- II which is located at the end of Title 5 of the MLC, 2006. The Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC, if properly maintained by the ship concerned, constitute prima facie evidence that the ship meets the requirements of the MLC, 2006 , and will facilitate the process of inspection when the ship visits foreign ports. The MLC, 2006, was expressly designed to harmonize with the existing arrangements in the maritime sector for ship inspec - tions (by flag and port States) in connection with an earlier mari - time labour Convention – the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, 1976 (No. 147)) and the major ship safety and security and pollution protection conventions developed by the International Maritime Organization (IMO). 4 It also seeks to take account of the arrangements currently in place under the various regional Memoranda of Understanding (MOU) or Agreements on port State control. 4 See Regulation 5.2.1, paragraph 3; International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974, as amended (SOLAS); and the International Con- vention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, 1973, and the Protocol 1978 (MARPOL 73/78). 4343400 235585 1 0 0 1 To help ensure decent conditions of work for seafarers and a level playing field for shipowners , all ships covered by the MLC, 2006, irrespective of size, visiting foreign ports in ratifying States are potentially subject to an inspection (Article V, paragraph 4). States that ratify the MLC, 2006, are given the responsibil - ity to carry out port State control inspections of foreign ships that come into their ports. This responsibility, essentially reflecting a right, can also be understood as part of the ratifying member States’ shared interests and obligation (under Article I, paragraph 2) to cooperate with each other to help ensure the effective imple - mentation and enforcement of the MLC, 2006. Ships that are not certified Inspection in a foreign port applies even if the ship is flying the flag of a country that has not ratified the MLC, 2006, because the MLC, 2006, obliges the States that ratify it to give no more favourable treatment to ships of States that have not ratified it (Art- icle V, paragraph 7). This means that these ships may be the subject of a more detailed inspection as provided under the MLC, 2006. 5 5 The MLC, 2006, does not expressly address the requirements for these ships; however, the Convention was intended to operate as consistently as pos - sible with existing practices in the maritime sector and key international con- ventions of the International Maritime Organization. Based on the example found in IMO resolution A.787(19), section 1.5, on port State control, the fol - lowing would apply as the appropriate approach: “All Member Parties should as a matter of principle apply the procedures set out in these guidelines to ships of non-ratifying States and ships of ratifying States that, for reasons related to size, are not carrying documents required by the MLC, 2006, in order to ensure that equivalent inspections are conducted and that equivalent levels of sea- farers’ working and living conditions (including seafarers’ rights) apply on board these ships. The seafarers’ working and living conditions on such ships should be compatible with the aims of the provisions of the MLC, 2006; other- wise, the ship should be subject to such requirements as are necessary to obtain a comparable level with the MLC, 2006.” A similar approach is also reflected in the Paris Memorandum of Understanding on Port State Control. 1.4. Definitions The following definitions are found in Article II, para- graph 1, of the MLC, 2006: competent authority means the minister, government depart- ment or other authority having power to issue and enforce regu - lations , orders or other instructions having the force of law in respect of the subject matter of the provision concerned; declaration of maritime labour compliance means the declaration referred to in Regulation 5.1.3; gross tonnage means the gross tonnage calculated in accordance with the tonnage measurement regulations contained in Annex I to the International Convention on Tonnage Measurement of Ships, 1969, or any successor Convention; for ships covered by the tonnage measurement interim scheme adopted by the Inter- national Maritime Organization, the gross tonnage is that which is included in the REMARKS column of the International Ton- nage Certificate (1969); maritime labour certificate means the certificate referred to in Regulation 5.1.3; requirements of this Convention refers to the requirements in these Articles and in the Regulations and Part A of the Code of this Convention; seafarer means any person who is employed or engaged or works in any capacity on board a ship to which this Convention applies; seafarers’ employment agreement includes both a contract of em - ployment and articles of agreement; seafarer recruitment and placement service means any person, company, institution, agency or other organization, in the public or the private sector, which is engaged in recruiting seafarers on behalf of shipowners or placing seafarers with shipowners ; ship means a ship other than one which navigates exclusively in inland waters or waters within, or closely adjacent to, sheltered waters or areas where port regulations apply; shipowner means the owner of the ship or another organization or person, such as the manager, agent or bareboat charterer, who 4343400 233680 1 0 0 1 has assumed the responsibility for the operation of the ship from the owner and who, on assuming such responsibility, has agreed to take over the duties and responsibilities imposed on ship- owners in accordance with this Convention, regardless of whether any other organizations or persons fulfil certain of the duties or responsibilities on behalf of the shipowner . Port State control inspection responsibilities under the MLC, 2006 Overview of the MLC, 2006, port State responsibilities 4343400 173990 2 0 0 2 29. Although port State control inspection is voluntary or dis- cretionary in character as noted above, if a country chooses to carry out such inspections they must be based on an effective port State inspection and monitoring system (Regulation 5.2.1, paragraph 4). The main aspect of this obligation is the need to ensure that the port State has an adequate number of qualified officers trained to carry out port State control under the MLC, 2006. In most cases this will involve personnel that are already qualified under the existing international port State control arrangements, developed in connection with the IMO conventions and under regional MOU on port State control. 6 However, in some countries it is possible that these inspections would be carried out by an authorized officer who is not necessarily qualified as a PSCO for other purposes, for example, a maritime labour inspector. Irrespective of the approach adopted in each country, in general, most of the expectations and guidance for PSCOs, especially with respect to conduct and the level of training expected for a person to exercise professional judgement will be equally applicable. Port State control officers Port State control inspection under the MLC, 2006, is to be carried out by “authorized” officers (Regulation 5.2.1, para- graph 3). As mentioned earlier, the term “port State control officer 6 See for example IMO resolution A.787( 19), section 2.5, and Annex 7 of the Paris MOU. (PSCO)” is adopted in these guidelines. This means that persons must be authorized , by the competent authority in the port State to carry out these inspections and should carry official identification that can be shown to ships’ masters and to seafarers. PSCOs should also be given sufficient power under rele - vant national laws or regulations to carry out their responsibilities under the MLC, 2006, in the event that a port State authority decides to inspect a foreign ship. The MLC, 2006, does not set out specific requirements with respect to PSCOs, but port State control is to be carried out in accordance with the MLC, 2006, and “… other applicable inter- national arrangements governing port State control inspections” (Regulation 5.2.1, paragraph 3). This means that existing require- ments and international guidance with respect to qualifications and training required for persons functioning as a PSCO would be generally relevant. 7 Professional profile of authorized officers/PSCOs under the MLC, 2006 8 Port State control should be carried out only by author- ized PSCOs who have the qualifications and training necessary for them to carry out their duties under the MLC, 2006. The PSCO may be assisted by any person with the required expertise acceptable to the port State . 7 See: IMO resolution A.787( 19), section 2.5; Annex 7 of the Paris MOU, and the Code of good practice for port State control officers , adopted in the framework of the IMO (MSC-MEPC.4/Circ.2). The provisions of the MLC, 2006, relating to flag State inspectors may also be useful for port State author- ities to consider (Regulation A5.1.4, paras 2, 3, 6, 7, 10, 11 and 12). 8 See also IMO resolution A.787(19), section 2.4. Port State control inspection responsibilities under the MLC, 2006 4343400 1048385 2 0 0 2 The PSCOs and any persons assisting them should be im - partial and should have no commercial interest, either in the port of inspection, or in the ships inspected. PSCOs should not be em - ployed by or undertake work on behalf of ROs. They should, as ap - propriate , be required to apply the Code of good practice for port State control officers , adopted in the framework of the IMO (MSC-MEPC.4/Circ.2). The PSCOs should hold credentials issued by the port State in the form of a document or identity card bearing the holder’s photograph and indicating that they are authorized to carry out the port State control (see paragraph 57 below). Any per- son assisting the PSCO should also hold an appropriate authoriza - tion issued by the port State. Requirements of PSCOs The PSCO should be able to review documents written in English and communicate in English with seafarers. Specific training with respect to labour inspections under the MLC, 2006, is essential and, for personnel who have not been involved in port State control inspections previously, also with respect to the role and professional practice of PSCOs. Carrying out port State control inspections under the MLC, 2006 PSCOs should use their professional judgement in carry- ing out all duties, and consult others where they consider it appro - priate to do so. To ensure consistent enforcement of port State control requirements, PSCOs should carry a copy of the MLC, 2006, and of these guidelines, either in a digital format or paper copy, for ready reference when carrying out any port State control inspections. The PSCO may also have a copy of the Guidelines for flag State inspections under the MLC, 2006 . General considerations for MLC, 2006, port State control inspections The purpose and subject matter of MLC, 2006, port State control inspections The purpose of the inspection by PSCOs is to determine whether a ship is in compliance with the requirements of the Con- vention (including seafarers’ rights) (Article IV, paragraph 5). These requirements are laid down in the Articles and Regulations and in Part A (Standards) of the Code of the MLC, 2006, relating to the working and living conditions of seafarers on the ship (Regula- tion 5.2.1, paragraphs 1 and 3). Part B (guidelines) of the MLC, 2006, Code is not subject to inspection by port State control. Port State control inspections are, in principle, concerned with the 14 16 areas of working and living conditions on the ship (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 2) that are listed in Title 5, Appendix A5-III of the MLC, 2006, and are to be certified by flag States as being in compliance with the related requirements of the Convention. How- ever, the PSCO may also take action in the case of non-compliance with any other requirement of the Convention relating to working and living conditions (Regulation 5.2.1, paragraph 1). The details for the implementation of the MLC, 2006, requirements are to be prescribed , in accordance with the Conven - tion , in the national laws or regulations, collective agreements or other measures in the flag State concerned. On ships carrying a Maritime Labour Certificate, a summary of the relevant national standards adopted to implement the MLC, 2006, in the 14 16 areas referred to will be set out in Part I of the DMLC attached to the Certificate. As indicated below, the Certificate and DMLC should be the starting point in the inspection process as they constitute prima facie evidence that the ship is in compliance with the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (including seafarers’ rights). PSCOs may also be entrusted with handling and investi - gating complaints made by seafarers on ships visiting their ports. If complaint handling is not part of their functions, they should be able to direct seafarers to the competent official for handling com- plaints or to receive complaints for transmittal to the competent official. Conducting an MLC, 2006, port State control inspection The guidance in this section and in Chapters 4 and 5 of these guidelines describes port State control under the MLC, 2006, as a process involving three potential phases or stages, depending on the situation that the PSCO encounters when going on board a ship to initiate the inspection: review of the Maritime Labour Certificate and the DMLC constituting prima facie evidence of compliance (Chapter 3); more detailed inspection, where applicable (Chapter 4); action to be taken in case of deficiencies or non-conformities (Chapter 5). An inspection may end after a satisfactory document review or it may move to a more detailed inspection and end at that point or an inspection may also require that action be taken if defi - ciencies are identified. At all stages of the inspection, PSCOs should bear in mind the obligation to make all possible efforts to avoid a ship being unduly detained or delayed (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 8). 4343400 304165 3 0 0 3 The procedures recommended in the following sections deal with the initiation of the inspection, the first (or often only) stage of the inspection, which is mainly concerned with reviewing a ship’s MLC, 2006, documentation, the Maritime Labour Certificate and the DMLC. They are based on MLC, 2006, Standard A5.2.1 “Inspections in port”, taking account of other relevant inspection procedures. The PSCO should be familiar with Standard A5.2.1, especially paragraphs 1 and 4. Paragraph 1 reads as follows: 1. Where an authorized officer, having come on board to carry out an inspection and requested, where applicable, the Maritime Labour Certificate and the Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, finds that: the required documents are not produced or maintained or are falsely maintained or that the documents produced do not con- tain the information required by this Convention or are other- wise invalid; or there are clear grounds for believing that the working and living conditions on the ship do not conform to the requirements of this Convention; or there are reasonable grounds to believe that the ship has changed flag for the purpose of avoiding compliance with this Convention; or there is a complaint alleging that specific working and living con- ditions on the ship do not conform to the requirements of this Convention; a more detailed inspection may be carried out to ascertain the work- ing and living conditions on board the ship. Such inspection shall in any case be carried out where the working and living conditions believed or alleged to be defective could constitute a clear hazard to the safety, health or security of seafarers or where the authorized officer has grounds to believe that any deficiencies constitute a seri - ous breach of the requirements of this Convention (including sea- farers’ rights). Paragraph 4 reads as follows (see also section 5.1 of these guide- lines): 4. Where, following a more detailed inspection, the working and liv- ing conditions on the ship are found not to conform to the require- ments of this Convention, the authorized officer shall forthwith bring the deficiencies to the attention of the master of the ship, with required deadlines for their rectification. In the event that such defi - ciencies are considered by the authorized officer to be significant, or if they relate to a complaint made in accordance with paragraph 3 of this Standard, the authorized officer shall bring the deficiencies to the attention of the appropriate seafarers’ and shipowners’ organizations in the Member in which the inspection is carried out, and may: notify a representative of the flag State; provide the competent authorities of the next port of call with the relevant information. Inspections may be carried out by the port State authority either on its own initiative or upon receipt of a complaint. Where an inspection is to take place, the PSCO should first determine whether or not the ship is carrying a Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC, which constitute prima facie evidence of compliance (see paragraph 52 below). If the ship is not flying the flag of a ratify - ing Member then the ship may be the subject of a more detailed inspection (Chapter 4) and a document review is not applicable. The initial inspection may be followed by a more detailed inspec - tion (see Chapter 4) in any of the four cases described in subpara - graphs (a)–(d) of Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 1. In some cases a more detailed inspection must be carried out (see the last sentence of the Standard). Procedure where inspection is initiated by the PSC authority Preparing for inspections 4343400 342265 3 0 0 3 The effectiveness and conduct of a port State control in- spection may be improved if basic information is obtained prior to carrying out an inspection. In this regard basic information con- cerning the type of ship, cargo, flag and history as well as its previ - ous and next ports of call and time available in port for the inspec - tion should be obtained in advance, if possible. Special attention should be paid to any previously reported deficiencies or non-conformities and any related plan of action to rectify the non-conformities. Depending upon their nature, number and frequency on the ship concerned, or on ships of the same ship- owner, prior non-conformities may affect the decision whether or not to carry out an inspection on a particular ship. The non- conformities may be clear grounds for a more detailed inspection (see paragraph 67 below), especially if the subsequent review of the ship’s documentation shows no evidence that a prescribed rectifica - tion has been completed (see paragraphs 95 and 104 below). Sources of information Information on previous non-conformities is available, for example, from deficiency notices or inspection reports issued by the port State control authority itself and from the port State control authorities of previous ports of call, as well as from port State control databases or other material. In addition, it is important to share information and gen- erally coordinate activities with the PSCOs responsible for the inspection of ships for compliance with the requirements of the SOLAS, STCW and the MARPOL and other IMO conven - tions . Certain non-conformities with the MLC, 2006, may have already been noted as also constituting non-compliance with a requirement of the SOLAS or STCW conventions, or noted by the PSCO on the occasion of an inspection in connection with the IMO conventions. Scope of the port State control inspection Where the ship carries a Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC issued by a flag State that has ratified the MLC, 2006, these documents constitute “prima facie evidence that … the require- ments of this Convention relating to working and living conditions of the seafarers have been met to the extent so certified” (Regula- tion 5.1.1, paragraph 4). Except in the four situations set out under paragraph 1(a)–(d) of Standard A5.2.1 (see section 3.2.5 below), a port State control inspection, if undertaken, would be limited to carrying out a review of the ship’s Certificate and the DMLC (Regulation 5.2.1, paragraph 2). The document review is concerned with: ascertaining the existence of a MLC, 2006, Certificate and a DMLC (or an Interim Certificate) and verifying that these documents have been validly established for the ship; and verifying that the documents are complete , in the sense that they contain all the information required by the MLC, 2006 (see paragraph 63 below), especially with respect to the 14 16 subject areas listed in Appendix A5-I. Where the PSCO having come on board finds that the documentation is valid and complete , the inspection would come to an end at that point unless there are clear grounds for believing that the working and living conditions on the ship do not conform to the requirements of the Convention (Standard A5.2.1, para- graph 1(b)) or reasonable grounds to believe that the ship has changed flag for the purpose of avoiding compliance (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(c)) or there has been a complaint (Stand- ard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(d)). 4343400 274955 3 0 0 3 The MLC, 2006, requirements that may be the subject of a more detailed inspection by a PSCO As stated earlier, the requirements for working and living conditions to be met by all ships are those set out in the MLC, 2006, with the detailed implementation of those requirements being pre- scribed in the national law of the flag State concerned. Since many of the basic requirements of the MLC, 2006, are worded in general terms, reference should be made – in the case of ships carrying a Certificate and a DMLC – to the national law requirements out- lined in Part I of the DMLC, with note being taken of those that vary from the MLC, 2006, because of substantial equivalence, for example. Shipowners’ approved measures for ongoing compliance will be set out in Part II . Guidance relating to ships which do not carry a Certificate and a DMLC is provided in paragraph 85 below. Review of a ship’s MLC, 2006, documents in a port State control inspection The following guidance applies only in the case of ships flying the flag of a State for which the MLC, 2006, is in force. In any other case, the PSCO may decide to proceed immediately to carry out a more detailed inspection (see Chapter 4 below). Step 1: Boarding the ship and requesting documentation When boarding a ship, the PSCO should present to the master or to the duty officer, if requested to do so, the document or identity card (bearing the holder’s photograph), issued by the port State, confirming his or her authority to carry out the inspection (see paragraph 36 above). A PSCO having come on board should gain an impression of whether the ship is well maintained and operated. It should be borne in mind that the purpose of the inspection is (where applic - able) to review the Certificate and DMLC. When on board the PSCO may observe situations or practices that suggest that the working and living conditions on the ship may be inconsistent with the requirements of the MLC, 2006. Except in the case of a defi - ciency that requires immediate attention, any deficiencies observed should be dealt with after the review of these documents has taken place. If a Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC are not pro- duced , the PSCO may proceed to consider whether a more detailed inspection is needed (see step 5 below and Chapter 4 (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(a)). Step 2: Reviewing the documents As explained above (paragraph 53), a review of the ship’s Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC should include checking for: validity; and completeness . To the extent necessary to verify the Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC, further documentation referred to in the Certificate and the DMLC with regard to the working and living conditions may be checked at this stage of the inspection. Validity. In addition to checking the date of validity stated on the Maritime Labour Certificate, the PSCO should check that: the period of validity does not exceed five years 9 or, in the case of an Interim Certificate, six months; in the case that the validity of the Maritime Labour Certificate has been extended by the competent authority or a recognized organization (see Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 4), the extended period of validity does not exceed five months from the expiry date of the existing certificate. 4343400 1165860 3 0 0 3 except in the case of an Interim Certificate, the ship is covered by a signed and sealed or stamped certification and, where ap - plicable , endorsements, that purport to be based on an initial or intermediate inspection carried out in compliance with Standard A5.1.3, paragraphs 2 to 4 and Standard A5.1.4, para- graph 4 (see, in particular, Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006, sections 2.2.4– 2.2.7); 9 For Certificates that have been renewed the period may, in some cases, be up to three months longer than five years (see Standard A5.1.3, paragraph 3). the Certificate, and the accompanying DMLC (where applic - able), have apparently been signed and sealed or stamped by an authorized flag State official; where the person authorized to sign is an employee of an RO, reference should be made to the list of ROs authorized by the flag State concerned, made available by the ILO in accordance with Standard A5.1.2, paragraph 4 (see Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 , section 2.2). Completeness. A Maritime Labour Certificate must have a DMLC attached or it is incomplete. An Interim Maritime Labour Certificate, however, need not be accompanied by a DMLC. The PSCO should ensure that all spaces requiring input from the flag State have been completed in the Maritime Labour Certificate and the DMLC, or in the Interim Maritime Labour Certificate. The check for completeness should then ensure (except in the case of an Interim Certificate) that: Part I of the DMLC identifies, for each of the 14 16 certified areas, the national requirements embodying the relevant provisions of the MLC, 2006, by providing a reference to the relevant na - tional legal provisions as well as setting out, to the extent neces - sary , concise information on the main content of the national requirements, including ship-type specific requirements. In that connection PSCOs may find it helpful to consider the guidance provided in the MLC, 2006, to flag States to help them complete the DMLC Part I. The MLC, 2006, provides that “The statement of national requirements in Part I of the Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance should include or be accompanied by references to the legislative provisions relating to seafarers’ working and living conditions in each of the matters listed in Appendix A5-I. Where national legisla - tion precisely follows the requirements stated in this Conven - tion , a reference may be all that is necessary. Where a provision of the Convention is implemented through substantial equiv - alence as provided under Article VI, paragraph 3, this provi - sion should be identified and a concise explanation should be provided. Where an exemption is granted by the competent authority as provided in Title 3, the particular provision or pro- visions concerned should be clearly indicated.” Part II of the DMLC indicates the main measures adopted by the shipowner to ensure ongoing compliance with the national requirements between flag State inspections; The results of any subsequent flag State verifications, includ - ing those related to measures referred to in Part II of the DMLC are recorded in or attached to the DMLC or made available to the PSCO in some other way, and include inform- ation not only on any deficiencies found during the verifica - tions but also the dates when the deficiencies were found to have been remedied. The DMLC is not expected to cover every single national law or regulation or other measure adopted by the flag State to implement the requirements of the MLC, 2006. A DMLC should be considered as complete if it identifies, in each of the 14 16 areas, the national law requirements on the matters that are referred to as Basic requirements in Chapter 4 below. 4343400 380365 3 0 0 3 The documents will not be complete if any necessary element in them is not in English or accompanied by a translation into English, as required (for ships on international voyages) (Standard A5.1.3, paragraphs 11 and 12). If the documents are not complete, the PSCO may, instead of proceeding to a determination as to whether there are grounds for a more detailed inspection in step 3 below, decide to consider undertaking a more detailed inspection (see step 5 below) (Stand- ard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(a)). Step 3: Determining whether there are clear grounds for believing that the conditions do not conform to requirements Clear grounds for believing that the working and living conditions on the ship do not conform to the requirements of the Convention (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(b)) may result from: the ship’s Maritime Labour Certificate or DMLC or docu - ments referred to in the Certificate or DMLC; or other elements (see paragraphs 71 and 72 below). Clear grounds from the ship’s documentation. The ship’s Maritime Labour Certificate and DMLC must be viewed as prima facie evidence of compliance with the requirements of the Conven - tion (including seafarers’ rights), to the extent that they certify compliance with the national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006, relating to the working and living conditions of sea- farers (Regulation 5.1.1, paragraph 4). When reviewing these documents for completeness under step 2 above, the PSCO should form an opinion as to whether the information provided in the DMLC shows that: the requirements of the MLC, 2006, in each of the 14 16 areas ap - pear to be complied with, especially the requirements on the matters that are referred to as Basic requirements in Chapter 4 below; Part II of the DMLC identifies measures in each of the 14 16 areas to ensure ongoing compliance between inspections (see Stand- ard A5.1.3, paragraph 10(b)). If the information contained in the Certificate or the DMLC or documents referred to in the Certificate or DMLC or other elements clearly indicate that the ship may not be in compli - ance with the requirements of the Convention (including seafarers’ rights), relating to the working and living conditions of seafarers on the ship, the PSCO should consider taking the action indicated in the following paragraph. The following action would be appropriate: The PSCO should first take account of the relevant require- ments of the national law of the flag State as reflected in the DMLC Part I, paying particular attention to any substantial equivalences and permitted exemptions and variations that may be stated in the DMLC Part I. If it is not a case of non- compliance, no further action with respect to that question should be taken . If the DMLC Part I indicates a possible non-compliance, the PSCO should check whether or not the specific Convention requirements concerned are being complied with on the ship. If no case of non-compliance is found on the ship, no further action with respect to that question should be taken. If, however, it is clear to the PSCO that the requirement(s) concerned may not have been complied with on the ship, the PSCO should discuss the matter with the Master and, if neces - sary , with a representative of the flag State. 4343400 412115 3 0 0 3 If, after having carefully considered the information provided by the Master and, if applicable, by the flag State, the PSCO concludes that, in his or her professional judgement, one or more requirements of the Convention may not have been com- plied with on the ship, he or she should take a decision as to whether a more detailed inspection of the ship should be car- ried out in accordance with paragraph 1(b) of Standard A5.2.1. If further clarifications are necessary concerning the national requirements, as reflected in the DMLC Part I, the matter should first be promptly referred to the port State control authority, with a view to consultation with the flag State. Clear grounds from other elements. Clear grounds for believing that the working and living conditions on the ship do not conform to the requirements of the Convention may arise in several other contexts, including during the preparations for inspections (see sections 3.2.1 and 3.2.2 above), general impres - sions , visual observations when on board (paragraph 58 above) and during the investigation of a complaint (see paragraphs 83 and 117 below). Where clear grounds exist for believing that the working and living conditions on the ship do not conform to the require- ments of the Convention, the PSCO should proceed to step 5 below. Where clear grounds do not exist and there has been no change of flag justifying consideration of step 4 below, a more detailed inspec - tion should not be carried out . Step 4: Determining whether there are reasonable grounds to believe that the ship has changed flag to avoid compliance with the Convention A PSCO may also decide to undertake a more detailed inspection if there are reasonable grounds to believe that the ship has changed flag for the purpose of avoiding compliance with the MLC, 2006 (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(c)). Any change or changes of flag should be noted in the documentation of the ship concerned, in particular its Continuous Synopsis Record, main- tained under Regulation 5 of the SOLAS Convention, Chap- ter XI-1. There must be “reasonable grounds”, rather than “clear grounds” , to believe that the purpose of the change or changes was to avoid compliance. The PSCO could form an opinion on the purpose of changing flag by looking at any relevant inspection report. Significant outstanding deficiencies which have not been transferred to the new flag’s records may be reasonable grounds . The previous flag State may provide information, which could include difficulties it had in enforcing compliance. However, the shipowner’s representative may be able to inform the PSCO of legitimate reasons for changing flag which were not for the pur - poses of avoiding compliance. In the absence of reasonable grounds to believe that the ship has changed flag for the purpose of avoiding compliance with the MLC, 2006, a more detailed inspection should not be carried out . If there are reasonable grounds, the PSCO must determine whether or not to carry out a more detailed inspection. Step 5: Determining whether or not to carry out a more detailed inspection 4343400 1549400 3 0 0 3 Where the inspection has not been determined to be com- plete in any of the steps set out above, the question of whether or not to carry out a more detailed inspection (see Chapter 4 below) will normally be at the discretion of the PSCO or the PSC author- ity . A more detailed inspection must be carried out where the working and living conditions believed (by the PSCO) or alleged (by a complainant: see section 3.3 below) to be defective could con- stitute a clear hazard to the safety, health or security of seafarers or where the PSCO has grounds to believe that any deficiencies con- stitute a serious breach of the requirements of the Convention (including seafarers’ rights). Guidance on the concept of a serious breach is provided below (Chapter 5, section 5.2, paragraphs 96 and 98). If the PSCO decides, or is required, to carry out a more detailed inspection, the ship’s master should be informed as soon as possible of the grounds for this action. If the PSCO determines that a more detailed inspection is not needed , no further action is required. 3.3. Procedure for inspections initiated upon receipt of a complaint The MLC, 2006, envisages complaints in a port State in two different situations. Both situations can result in a more detailed inspection. However the steps and considerations differ. One relates to onshore complaints made by a seafarer under Regulation 5.2.2 and is addressed below in Chapter 6. The present section deals with complaints that are made as part of the port State control inspection procedure (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(d)). A com- plaint in this context means information submitted by a seafarer, a professional body, an association, a trade union or generally any person with an interest in the safety of the ship, including an interest in safety or health hazards to seafarers on board (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 3). The PSCO and/or port State authority should keep a record of the time when the complaint was received, the means by which it was transmitted, the source of the complaint, the name of the person receiving the complaint, the name and flag of the ship concerned, and the nature and details of the alleged non- conformity with the requirements of the MLC, 2006. A record of action taken upon receipt of the complaint should also be kept . Before taking any action upon a complaint, the PSCO needs to check that it relates to a requirement of the Convention (including seafarers’ rights) that is laid down in its Articles and Regulations or in Part A of the Code and that it relates to the work- ing and living conditions of seafarers on the ship concerned (Stand- ard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(d)). It need not be in one of the 14 16 areas listed in Appendix A5-III of the Convention. Appropriate steps shall be taken to safeguard the confi - dentiality of complaints made by seafarers (Standard A5.2.2, para- graph 7). On the basis of the complaint, the PSCO may , or must (where the working and living conditions alleged to be defective could constitute a clear hazard to safety or health or a serious breach referred to in the last sentence of Standard A5.2.1, para- graph 1 – see paragraph 75 above), decide to carry out a more detailed inspection on board ship. If the PSCO decides not to carry out a more detailed inspection and the complaint has been made by the seafarer with respect to his or her individual case , it should be handled in accord- ance with Regulation 5.2.2 (see Chapter 6 below). 4343400 1860550 3 0 0 3 The inspection carried out in response to a complaint must generally be limited to matters within the scope of the com- plaint. However, as noted in Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 3, inform- ation in the complaint itself or gained during its investigation may give the PSCO clear grounds for believing that the working and liv- ing conditions on the ship do not conform to the requirements of the Convention. In such a case, the PSCO may (or must , in the cir - cumstances referred to above) decide to carry out a more detailed inspection (see paragraph 71 above). In addition, where the results of the investigation seriously contradict information provided in the ship’s documentation, including with respect to ongoing com- pliance in Part II of the DMLC, this may constitute evidence that the required documents are falsely maintained, warranting a more detailed inspection on the basis of Standard A5.2.1, para- graph 1(a). More detailed inspection of maritime labour conditions on ships General note This chapter is intended to provide a practical tool for guidance concerning the subject matter of a more detailed inspec - tion under the MLC, 2006. For an authoritative statement of requirements on any issue, reference should be made to the text of the MLC, 2006, and – in so far as they are outlined in a valid Maritime Labour Certificate and attached DMLC – to the national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements or other measures implementing the MLC, 2006, that are applicable to the ship concerned. 4343400 533400 4 0 0 4 Where a ship is not carrying a Maritime Labour Certifi - cate and DMLC (because it is a ship for which certification is not mandatory (Regulation 5.1.3, paragraph 1) and has not requested a certificate or it is a ship of a non-ratifying State), PSCOs will need to use their professional judgement when evaluating compliance with the specific requirements of the MLC, 2006. This will also apply if the information contained in the Certificate or the DMLC or documents referred to in the Certificate or DMLC or other ele - ments clearly indicate that the ship may not be in compliance with the requirements of the Convention (including seafarers’ rights) relating to working and living conditions of seafarers on the ship. The exercise of professional judgement by PSCOs will be particu - larly necessary where a requirement of the MLC, 2006, may be stated in general terms in the Standards (Part A of the Code). Guidance as to the general expectations regarding this require- ment may be found in Part B of the Code, but this guidance should be considered with care since Part B is not mandatory and is not itself the subject of port State control; however, it provides information on the intention of the mandatory provisions. In cases of perceived non-conformity, the master should be given an oppor - tunity to produce evidence of the national requirements concerned and provide any necessary explanations. With respect to inspections that are initiated by the PSC authority, information is provided below on the basic require- ments to be complied with, accompanied by suggestions concern- ing sources of information for ascertaining compliance, as well as by examples of deficiencies or non-conformities, in the 14 16 areas for port State inspection that are specified in Appendix A5-III of the MLC, 2006. Since these are the same as those that are to be the sub- ject of flag State certification under Appendix A5-I (see paragraph 20 above), this guidance is based on the relevant parts of Chapter 3 of the Guidelines for flag State inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 . The guidance below may also be rele - vant to inspections initiated upon a complaint, within the limits of the scope of the complaint. It should, however, be borne in mind that except where a ship is evidently substandard, or the PSCO already has clear grounds to believe that aspects of the living and working conditions on a ship are not in compliance with the MLC, 2006, the more detailed inspection by the PSCO may be much less extensive than that carried out by the flag State. If, after visiting the main spaces on the ship and talking to seafarers, the PSCO finds that the ship appears to be well maintained and operated and the seafarers appear to be satisfied with their general conditions of work, the PSCO may decide to choose several of the 14 16 areas of the require- ments for a closer scrutiny, with a view to ascertaining whether the flag State inspections of the ship have been carried out and whether the shipowner’s measures for ensuring ongoing compliance are adequate and are being adequately implemented. Depending upon the results, the PSCO may decide to end the more detailed inspec - tion , or to extend it to more or even all of the other areas referred to in Appendix A5-III. Finally, in the following section, frequent reference is made to requirements under the national laws or to national require- ments or to similar terms. These relate to the relevant national requirements that have been adopted by the flag State to imple - ment the requirements of the Convention. It should be understood that it is not the function of PSCOs to enforce any national require- ments that go beyond the requirements of the MLC, 2006. The basic requirements; sources of information; examples of deficiencies or non-conformities Regulation 1.1 – Minimum age (Appendix A5-III – Minimum age) Basic requirements 4343400 144145 4 0 0 4 Persons below the age of 16 shall not be employed or engaged or work on a ship (Standard A1.1, paragraph 1). Seafarers under the age of 18 shall not be employed or engaged or work where the work is likely to jeopardize their health or safety (Standard A1.1, paragraph 4). Special attention must be paid to the safety and health of sea- farers under the age of 18, in accordance with national laws and regulations (Standard A4.3, paragraph 2(b)). Night work* for seafarers under the age of 18 is prohibited, except to the extent that an exemption has been made by the competent authority under Standard A1.1, paragraph 3, in the case of training programmes (Standard A1.1, paragraph 2). * “Night” is defined in accordance with national law and practice. It covers a period of at least nine hours starting no later than midnight and ending no earlier than 5 a.m. (Standard A1.1, paragraph 2). Sources of information A crew list, a passport or other official document confirming seafarers’ birth dates. Work schedule with respect to seafarers under the age of 18 to determine hours and nature of work. Information on types of work on board that have been identi - fied as likely to jeopardize the safety of seafarers under the age of 18. Recent accident reports and safety committee reports to deter- mine whether seafarers under the age of 18 were involved. Interviews, in private, with seafarers. Examples of deficiencies Person under the age of 16 working as a seafarer. Seafarer under the age of 18 working at night (and not as part of a training programme ). Seafarer under the age of 18 carrying out tasks that are likely to jeopardize their safety or health. Regulation 1.2 – Medical certificate (Appendix A5-III – Medical certification) Basic requirements Seafarers are not allowed to work on a ship unless they are cer - tified * as medically fit to perform their duties (Regulation 1.2, paragraph 1). For seafarers working on ships ordinarily engaged on inter- national voyages the certificate must be provided as a mini- mum in English (Standard A1.2, paragraph 10). The medical certificate must have been issued by a duly quali - fied medical practitioner and must still be valid (Standard A1.2, paragraphs 1 and 4). The period of validity** for a certificate is determined under the national law of the flag State in accordance with the follow- ing : two-year maximum for medical certificates except for sea- farers under 18; then it is one year (Standard A1.2, para- graph 7(a)); six-year maximum for a colour vision certificate (Stand- ard A1.2, paragraph 7(b)). * Certificates issued in accordance with, or meeting the substance of the applicable requirements, under the International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers, 1978 (STCW), as amended, are to be accepted as meeting these requirements (Standard A1.2, paragraph 3). ** The above requirements should be read in light of the following provisions of the MLC, 2006: 4343400 283210 4 0 0 4 In urgent cases the competent authority may permit a seafarer to work without a valid medical certificate until the next port of call where the seafarer can obtain a medical certificate from a qualified medical practi - tioner , provided that: the period of such permission does not exceed three months; and the seafarer concerned is in possession of an expired medical cer - tificate of recent date (Standard A1.2, paragraph 8). If the period of validity of a certificate expires in the course of a voyage, the certificate shall continue in force until the next port of call where the seafarer can obtain a medical certificate from a qualified medical practitioner, provided that the period shall not exceed three months (Standard A1.2, paragraph 9). Sources of information The crew list. The medical certificates. Colour vision certificates, where appropriate. Work schedules and interviews, in private, with seafarers to determine that medical restrictions on work for individual sea- farers are being respected and that seafarers are not assigned to, or carrying out, work contrary to these restrictions. The authorization or permit (subject to a maximum validity of three months) where the competent authority of the flag State has permitted a seafarer to work without a valid, or with an ex- pired , certificate in urgent cases. Examples of deficiencies Seafarer on board without a valid medical or colour vision cer - tificate (where appropriate) or authorization from the compe - tent authority in urgent cases. Seafarer working on the ship or performing tasks contrary to a restriction on a medical certificate. Seafarer’s medical certificate not in the English language on a ship ordinarily engaged in international voyages. A medical certificate that has not been issued by a duly quali - fied medical practitioner. Regulation 1.3 – Training and qualifications (Appendix A5-III – Qualifications of seafarers) Basic requirements Seafarers must be trained or certified* as competent or other- wise qualified to perform their duties in accordance with flag State requirements (Regulation 1.3, paragraph 1). Seafarers must have successfully completed training for per- sonal safety on board ship (Regulation 1.3, paragraph 2). * Training and certification in accordance with the International Con- vention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers, 1978 (STCW), as amended, is to be accepted as meeting these requirements . Sources of information Minimum Safe Manning Document (SMD) to verify the re- quired qualifications of the seafarers. Certificates and endorsements for STCW personnel confirm- ing seafarers’ competency with respect to their duties (as well as the crew list to determine duties). Documentary evidence (from a shipowner or, if relevant to the position concerned, a national authority or otherwise) con- firming that seafarers have any qualifications that may be re- quired under the MLC, 2006, for those performing other duties on board ship (for example, ships’ cooks – see below, Regula- tion 3.2). Evidence confirming that seafarers have successfully com- pleted training for personal safety on board ship. Appropriate training material that is available to the crew. Interviews, in private, with seafarers to confirm training. 4 Examples of deficiencies Seafarer’s qualifications not in accordance with the SMD. Seafarer working on the ship who is not trained or certified or otherwise qualified to perform required duties. Certificates or endorsements are not up to date or have expired. Seafarer working on the ship who has not successfully com- pleted personal safety training. Absence of a valid dispensation issued under STCW, where needed. Regulation 1.4 – Recruitment and placement (Appendix A5-III – Use of any licensed or certified or regulated private recruitment and placement service) Basic requirements Where a shipowner has used a private seafarer recruitment and placement service it must be licensed or certified or regu - lated in accordance with the MLC, 2006 (Standard A1.4, para- graph 2). Seafarers shall not be charged for use of these services (Stand- ard A1.4, paragraph 5(b)). Shipowners using services based in States not party to the MLC, 2006, must ensure, as far as practicable, that these ser - vices meet the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (Standard A1.4, paragraph 9). Sources of information National web sites of the competent authority regarding the licensing or regulation of seafarer recruitment and placement services ( manning agencies). If seafarers were engaged through a seafarer recruitment and placement service based in a country that has not ratified the MLC, 2006, documentation should be available to show that the shipowner has, as far as practicable, verified through a proper system that the service is operated consistently with the MLC, 2006. The shipowner’s system may, for example, take ac- count of information collected by the flag State, as well as any audits or certifications concerning the quality of services oper - ating in countries that have not ratified the MLC, 2006. Other evidence which shipowners could provide might be checklists against the MLC requirements or an RO audit of a recruitment and placement service based in a country that has not ratified the MLC, 2006. Interviews, in private, with seafarers to determine that they have not paid a fee or other charge to a recruitment or place- ment service and have been informed of their rights and duties. Interviews, in private, with seafarers to determine that the re- cruitment and placement service used does not operate a black- list. Examples of deficiencies No documentary evidence available to indicate that the service or agency is operated in accordance with the MLC, 2006. A seafarer who was recruited through a private seafarer re- cruitment and placement service that was not licensed or certi - fied or regulated in accordance with the MLC, 2006, or whose license or certificate or any other similar document is no longer valid. 4343400 267335 4 0 0 4 Use of a private recruitment and placement service requiring the seafarer to pay a fee or other charge for employment ser - vices. A seafarer working on board who was recruited by a recruit- ment and placement service operating in a State which is not party to the MLC, 2006, in cases where the shipowner cannot support its conclusion of consistency with the MLC, 2006. Regulation 2.1 – Seafarers’ employment agreements (Appendix A5-III – Seafarers’ employment agreements) Basic requirements All seafarers must have a copy of their seafarers’ employment agreement (SEA) signed by both the seafarer and the ship- owner or shipowner’s representative (or other evidence of contractual or similar arrangements) (Standard A2.1, para- graph 1(a)). A SEA must, at a minimum, contain the matters set out in Standard A2.1, paragraph 4(a)–(k) of the MLC, 2006 (Stand- ard A2.1, paragraph 4). Seafarers must also be given a document containing a record of their employment on the ship (such as a discharge book) (Standard A2.1, paragraph 1(e)). Where a collective bargaining agreement forms all or part of the SEA, the agreement must be on board the ship with rele - vant provisions in English (except for ships engaged only in domestic voyages) (Standard A2.1, paragraph 2). A SEA continues to have effect while a seafarer is held captive on or off the ship as a result of acts of piracy or armed robbery against ships, regardless of whether the date fixed for its expiry has passed or either party has given notice to suspend or terminate it (Standard A2.1, paragraph 7) . Sources of information A copy of the SEA (or other evidence of contractual or similar arrangements) and any applicable collective bargaining agree- ments for seafarers and, at a minimum, a standard form of the SEA (in English) for the ship. Evidence, where possible, given the timing of the inspection relative to employment period, of possession by seafarers of a record of their employment. Seafarers’ records of employment to determine that they do not contain statements as to the quality of their work or as to their wages. Interviews, in private, with seafarers to confirm that, on signing a SEA, they were given an opportunity to examine and seek advice and freely accepted the agreement before signing. Examples of deficiencies A seafarer without a SEA (or other evidence of contractual or similar arrangements) working on the ship. A seafarer, with a SEA that does not contain all the items in Standard A2.1, paragraph 4(a)–(k). A seafarer with a SEA that is inconsistent with the national re- quirements of the flag State. No system or provisions for seafarers to have their employ- ment recorded. Seafarers are not given a record of their employment on the ship on completion of engagement. A collective bargaining agreement that forms all or part of the SEA is either not on board or, if on board, not in English on a ship that engages in international voyages. Standard form SEA is not in English. The SEA contains clauses that violate seafarers’ rights. Regulation 2.2 – Wages (Appendix A5-III – Payment of wages) Basic requirements 4343400 31115 4 0 0 4 Seafarers must be paid at no greater than monthly intervals and in full for their work in accordance with their employment agreements (Regulation 2.2, paragraph 1; Standard A2.2, paragraph 1). Seafarers are entitled to an account each month indicating their monthly wage and any authorized deductions such as al- lotments (Standard A2.2, paragraphs 2, 3 and 4). No unauthorized deductions, such as payments for travel to or from the ship (Regulation 2.2, paragraph 1). Charges for remittances/allotment* transmission services must be reasonable and exchange rates in accordance with national requirements (Standard A2.2, paragraph 5). Where a seafarer is held captive on or off the ship as a result of acts of piracy or armed robbery against ships, wages and other entitlements under the SEA , relevant collective bargaining agreement or applicable national laws , including the remittance of any allotments, must continue to be paid during the entire period of captivity and until the seafarer is released and duly repatriated ; o r, where the seafarer dies while in captivity, until the date of death as determined in accordance with applicable national laws or regulations (Standard A2.2, paragraph 7) . * An allotment is an arrangement whereby a proportion of sea- farers’ earnings are regularly remitted , on their request, to their families or dependants or legal beneficiaries whilst the seafarers are at sea (Standard A2.2, paragraphs 3 and 4). Sources of information The SEA and documentation, such as the payroll records to confirm that wages are being paid at intervals no greater than one month as specified in their SEA or relevant collective agreements. Relevant documents showing service charges and exchange rates applied to any remittances made to the seafarers’ families or dependants or legal beneficiaries at their request. Relevant documents to confirm the payment of wages includ - ing the requirement that a monthly account (such as a wage slip) is provided to the seafarers. Copies of individual accounts should be available to PSCOs at their request. Interviews, in private, with seafarers to confirm compliance with requirements on the payment of wages. Examples of deficiencies A seafarer is not paid regularly (at least monthly) and in full in accordance with the SEA or collective bargaining agreement. A seafarer is not given a monthly account (such as a wage slip) of wages. Allotments are not being paid or are not being paid in accord- ance with the seafarer’s instructions. Charge for converting and transmitting currencies is not in line with national requirements. More than one set of wage accounts is in use. A seafarer who is held captive on or off the ship as a result of acts of piracy or armed robbery against ships is not or has not been paid during the entire period of captivity and until the release and due repatriation of the seafarer or, where the seafarer dies while in captivity, until the date of death , as determined in accordance with national laws and regulations . Regulation 2.3 – Hours of work and hours of rest (Appendix A5-III – Hours of work or rest) Basic requirements The minimum hours of rest* must not be less than ten hours in any 24-hour period, and 77 hours in any seven-day period, if the relevant national law relates to hours of rest, or, if the rele - vant national law relates to hours of work, the maximum hours of work** must not exceed 14 hours in any 24-hour period and 72 hours in any seven-day period (Standard A2.3, paragraph 5, as implemented in national standards).*** Hours of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which must be at least six hours; the interval between consecutive periods of rest must not exceed 14 hours (Standard A2.3, paragraph 6, as implemented in the national stand- ards ).*** 4343400 234950 4 0 0 4 Account must be taken of the danger posed by the fatigue of seafarers (Standard A2.3, paragraph 4). * Hours of rest means time outside hours of work; this term does not include short breaks (Standard A2.3, paragraph 1(b)). ** Hours of work means time during which seafarers are required to do work on account of the ship (Standard A2.3, paragraph 1 ( a )). *** With respect to the national standards implementing Stand- ard A2.3: S tandard A2.3, paragraph 3, provides that “Each Member acknow - ledges that the normal working hours’ standard for seafarers, like that for other workers, shall be based on an eight-hour day with one day of rest per week and rest on public holidays. However, this shall not prevent the Mem- ber from having procedures to authorize or register a collective agreement which determines seafarers’ normal working hours on a basis no less favourable than this standard.” Standard A2.3, paragraph 7, provides that “Musters, firefighting and lifeboat drills, and drills prescribed by national laws and regulations and by international instruments, shall be conducted in a manner that minimizes the disturbance of rest periods and does not induce fatigue.” Standard A2.3, paragraph 8, provides that “When a seafarer is on call, such as when a machinery space is unattended, the seafarer shall have an adequate compensatory rest period if the normal period of rest is disturbed by call-outs to work.” Standard A2.3, paragraph 13, provides that “Nothing in paragraphs 5 and 6 of this Standard shall prevent a Member from having national laws or regulations or a procedure for the competent authority to authorize or reg - ister collective agreements permitting exceptions to the limits set out. Such exceptions shall, as far as possible, follow the provisions of this Standard but may take account of more frequent or longer leave periods or the grant- ing of compensatory leave for watchkeeping seafarers or seafarers working on board ships on short voyages.” Sources of information An approved standardized table of shipboard working arrange- ments setting out the national requirements for maximum hours of work or the minimum hours of rest and the schedule for service at sea and in port, which should be posted in an easily accessible place on the ship (the table of working arrangements or schedule in the working language or lan - guages of the ship and in English). Documents (the SEA or the relevant collective agreement and other documents, such as the bridge and engine room log- books, that can also be checked) to confirm compliance with the basic requirements concerning minimum hours of rest or maximum hours of work. A table of working arrangements or schedule in the working language or languages of the ship and in English. Up to date records of work or rest, as required under national standards, for each seafarer serving on the ship. Cases of seafarer fatigue, possibly indicated by hours of work that are consistently at the upper limits and by other contribu - tory factors, such as disrupted rest periods; or cases of seafarers showing symptoms such as lack of concentration, irrelevant and inconsistent replies to questions, yawning and slow reac - tion times. Examples of deficiencies A seafarer’s work schedule does not conform to the applicable standards. Table of working arrangements is not posted or does not con- tain required information. Table of working arrangements is not in English and the work- ing language(s) of the ship. Records of work or rest are not available or are not main- tained . Evidence of exceeding the limits of work and no record of sus - pension of the schedule, in accordance with Standard A2.3, paragraph 14, have been noted in a logbook or other document. Regulation 2.5 – Repatriation (Appendix A5-III – Financial security for repatriation) Basic requirements For a ll ships: A financial security system to assist seafarers in the event of their abandonment , is in place (Standard A2.5.2, paragraphs 1 and 3) . The financial security system may be in the form of a social security scheme or insurance or a national fund or other similar arrangements (Standard A2.5.2, paragraph 3) . The financial security system must provide direct access, sufficient coverage and expedited financial assistance (Standard A2.5.2, paragraph 4 ) . Assistance provided by the financial security system must be granted promptly upon a request made by the seafarer or seafarer’s nominated representative and supported by the necessary justification of entitlement (Standard A2.5.2, paragraphs 8 and 2). Assistance provided by the financial security system must be sufficient to cover (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 9 ) : outstanding wages and other entitlements due from the shipowner limited to four months; all expenses reasonably incurred by the seafarer, including the cost of repatriation (i.e. travel by appropriate and expeditious means, normally by air, and provision for food and accommodation from the time of leaving the ship until arrival at home, necessary medical care, passage and transport of personal effects and any other reasonable costs or charges arising from the abandonment (Standard A2.5.2, paragraph 10) ) ; essential needs of the seafarer including such items as: adequate food, clothing where necessary, accommodation, drinking water supplies, essential fuel for survival on board the ship, necessary medical care and any other reasonable costs or charges from the act or omission constituting the abandonment until the seafarer’s arrival at home. The financial security must not cease before the end of the period of validity of the financial security unless the financial security provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority of the flag State (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 11 ) . Additional basic requirements for s hips required to be certified : Ships must carry on board a certificate of financial security or other documentary evidence issued by the financial security provider (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 6 ) . A copy of the certificate or other documentary evidence must be posted in a conspicuous place on board where it is available to the seafarer (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 6 ) . Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, the document provided by each provider must be carried on board (Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 6 ) . The certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must contain the information required in Appendix A2-I ( Standard A2.5.2 , paragraph 7) . The certificate or other documentary evidence must be in English or accompanied by an English translation (Standard A2.5.2, paragraph 7). Sources of information For all ships: Relevant documents confirming that financial security has been provided . In addition, for ships required to be certified : T he valid financial security certificate or other documentar y evidenc e issued by the financial security provider, including as regards the social security scheme in place. Interview s, in private , with seafarers. The DMLC, Part I to check whether there are any national substantial equivalences , and, if so, DMLC, Part II to check for compliance . Examples of deficiencies For a ll ships: No evidence that financial security for repatriation has been provided. Seafarers are not provided with direct access to the financial security system. The assistance provided by the financial security system does not cover outstanding wages limited to four months, reasonable expenses including the cost of repatriation and the seafarer’s essential needs. The financial security has ceased before the end of the period of validity as stated on the financial security certificate; or, where the financial security provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority of the flag State, the financial security has ceased before the end of that notification period; or is otherwise invalid. ALTERNATIVE WORDING: The financial security has ceased before: ( i ) the expiration date stated on the financial security certificate or (ii) the end of the notice period of at least 30 days given to the competent authority (where applicable); or is otherwise invalid. In addition, for ships required to be c ertified: The certificate of financial security or other documentary eviden ce issued by the financial security provider, including as regards the social security scheme in place, is not carried on board. Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, not all documents provided by each provider are carried on board. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not posted in a conspicuous place on board where it is available to seafarers. The certificate or other documentary evidence does not include the required information as set out in Appendix 2-I. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not available in English or is not accompanied by an English translation. The financial security certificate or other documentary evidence is invalid , for example, is expired or falsified . 4343400 -33020 4 0 0 4 Regulation 2.7 – Manning levels (Appendix A5-III – Manning levels for the ship) Basic requirements Ships must have a sufficient number of seafarers employed on board to ensure that ships are operated safely, efficiently and with due regard to security under all conditions, taking into ac- count concerns about fatigue and the particular nature and conditions of voyage (Regulation 2.7). Ships as a minimum must comply with the manning levels as stated in the SMD or equivalent issued by the competent authority (Standard A2.7, paragraph 1). Sources of information SMD or applicable equivalent. Crew list to ascertain number, category (such as cooks and those responsible for food preparation and those who are responsible for medical care) and qualifications of seafarers working on board . On-board table of working arrangements to confirm that safe manning requirements are being implemented . Interviews, in private, with seafarers to confirm that require- ments are met . Examples of deficiencies Numbers and/or categories of seafarers working on board do not comply with at least the minimum specified in the SMD. No SMD or equivalent on board. Regulation 3.1 – Accommodation and recreational facilities (Appendix A5-III – Accommodation) (Appendix A5-III – On-board recreational facilities) Basic requirements Ships must be in compliance with the minimum standards es - tablished by the MLC, 2006, providing and maintaining decent accommodation and recreational facilities for seafarers work- ing or living on ships, or both, consistent with promoting sea- farers’ health and well-being (Regulation 3.1, paragraph 1). Seafarer accommodation must be safe and decent and must meet national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006 (Standard A3.1, paragraph 1). Frequent inspections of seafarer accommodation areas are carried out by the master or a designate (Standard A3.1, para- graph 18) and are recorded and the records are available for review. Note: For ships that were in existence before entry into force of the MLC, 2006, for the flag State: These ships may still be inspected in connec - tion with seafarers’ accommodation and recreational facilities to verify that the ship: meets the standards set out in ILO Conventions Nos 92, 133 or 147 (if applicable in the flag State) (Regulation 3.1, paragraph 2); and/ or provides and maintains decent accommodation and recreational facilities for seafarers working or living on board, or both, consist- ent with promoting the seafarers’ health and well-being (Regula- tion 3.1, paragraph 1). Sources of information The construction plan of the ship showing dimensions and identifying the use to be made of each room or other area. The crew list for a comparison with the number of sleeping rooms and berths. 4343400 215265 4 0 0 4 Visual observation of seafarers’ on-board accommodation and recreational facilities with particular attention paid to the fol - lowing requirements in the MLC, 2006: general requirements (Standard A3.1, paragraph 6); the size of rooms and other accommodation spaces (Stand- ard A3.1, paragraphs 9 and 10); heating and ventilation (Standard A3.1 paragraph 7); noise and vibration and other ambient factors (Stand- ard A3.1, paragraph 6(h)); sanitary and related facilities (Standard A3.1, para- graphs 11 and 13); lighting (Standard A3.1, paragraph 8); hospital accommodation (Standard A3.1, paragraph 12); recreational facilities (Standard A3.1, paragraphs 14 and 17); occupational safety and health and accident prevention re- quirements on ships, in light of the specific needs of sea- farers who both live and work on ships (Standard A3.1, paragraphs 2(a) and 6(h)). The on-board records to confirm that frequent inspections are carried out by or under the authority of the ship’s master as well as for ships that carry a Maritime Labour Certificate, the DMLC Part II to check that other inspections or actions pro- vided for in the shipowners’ approved measures have been car- ried out. Evidence that measures are being taken on the ship to monitor noise and vibration levels in seafarers’ working and living areas. Examples of deficiencies Location of sleeping rooms on the ship does not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. Number and/or size (including height) of sleeping rooms do not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. There is more than one seafarer per berth. Recreational facilities do not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. Heating, lighting or ventilation is inadequate or not function- ing correctly. Fittings and fixtures within seafarer accommodation areas, in- cluding the hospital, mess rooms and recreational rooms, do not conform to national standards implementing the MLC, 2006. Separate sleeping rooms are not provided for males and females. Separate sanitation facilities are not provided for males and females. Sanitary facilities are inadequate or not functioning correctly. Hospital is being used to accommodate persons who are not sick. Seafarer accommodation or recreational facilities are not be- ing maintained in a clean and tidy condition. Regular inspections of seafarer accommodation are not being carried out by the master or another designated person . Laundry facilities are inadequate or not functioning correctly. Exposure to hazardous levels of noise and vibration and other ambient factors and chemicals in the seafarer accommodation or recreational or catering facilities. Regulation 3.2 – Food and catering (Appendix A5-III – Food and catering) 4343400 163830 4 0 0 4 Basic requirements Food and drinking water must be of appropriate quality, nutri - tional value and quantity, taking into account the requirements of the ship and the differing cultural and religious backgrounds of seafarers on the ship (Regulation 3.2, paragraph 1). Food is to be provided free of charge to seafarers during the period of engagement (Regulation 3.2, paragraph 2). Seafarers employed as ship’s cooks* with responsibility for preparing food must be trained and qualified for their posi - tions (Standard A3.2, paragraph 3). Seafarers working as ships’ cooks must not be under the age of 18 (Standard A3.2, paragraph 8). Frequent and documented inspections of food, water and catering facilities must be carried out by the master or a desig - nate (Standard A3.2, paragraph 7). * “Ship’s cook” means a seafarer with responsibility for food prepar - ation (Regulation 3.2, paragraph 3; Standard A3.2, paragraphs 3 and 4). Sources of information Documents (see Regulation 1.1 on minimum age) to confirm that the ship’s cooks are 18 years old or older and that the ship’s cooks are trained, qualified and competent for their positions in accordance with national requirements. In cases where a fully qualified cook is not required, evidence that seafarers processing food in the galley are trained or instructed in food and personal hygiene and handling and storage of food on board ships . On-board records to confirm that frequent and documented inspections are made of: supplies of food and drinking water; spaces used for handling and storage of food; galleys and other equipment used in the preparation and service of meals. Visual observation of catering facilities, including galleys and storerooms, to check that they are hygienic and fit for purpose. Evidence concerning how drinking water quality is monitored and the results of such monitoring. Menu plans together with visual observation of food supplies and storage areas to ensure that the food supplied is of an ap - propriate quality (for example, not out of date) and quantity and nutritional value and is varied in nature. Interviews, in private, with a representative number of sea- farers to ensure that seafarers are not charged for food and are provided with drinking water and that food and drinking water are of appropriate quality and quantity. Examples of deficiencies Food and drinking water are not of appropriate quality, nutri - tional value and quantity, for the seafarers on the ship. Seafarer is charged for food and/or is not provided with drink- ing water. Seafarer who has responsibility for preparing food is untrained or not instructed as required. Ship’s cook is not trained and qualified. Ship’s cook is under the age of 18. Frequent and documented inspections of the food or water, or of the preparation, storage or handling areas, are not being car- ried out. Catering facilities are not hygienic or are otherwise unfit for their purpose. 4343400 88900 4 0 0 4 Regulation 4.1 – Medical care on board ship and ashore (Appendix A5-III – On-board medical care) Basic requirements Seafarers must be covered by adequate measures for the pro- tection of their health and have access to prompt and adequate medical care, including essential dental care, whilst working on board (Regulation 4.1, paragraph 1; Standard A4.1, para- graph 1). Health protection and care are to be provided at no cost to the seafarer, in accordance with national law and practice (Regula- tion 4.1, paragraph 2). Shipowners are to allow seafarers the right to visit a qualified medical doctor or dentist without delay in ports of call, where practicable (Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(c)). Note: Port States are required to ensure that seafarers on board ships in their territory who are in need of immediate medical care are given ac- cess to the port State’s medical facilities on shore (Regulation 4.1, para- graph 3). Sources of information Documents (such as the SEA) to confirm that, to the extent consistent with the flag State’s law and practice, medical care and health protection services while seafarers are on board ship or landed in a foreign port are provided free of charge to seafarers (Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(d)). Documents (such as the SEA) to confirm that seafarers are given the right to visit a qualified medical doctor or dentist without delay in ports of call, where practicable (Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(c)). The DMLC Part II to check what provision the shipowner has made for access to medical facilities ashore. Records and equipment to confirm that general provisions on occupational health protection and medical care are being ob - served (Standard A4.1, paragraph 1(a)). Visual observation to confirm that the ship is equipped with sufficient medical supplies including a medicine chest and equipment, including either the most recent edition of the International Medical Guide for Ships or a medical guide as re- quired by national laws and regulations. Documents (such as the SMD and crew list) to confirm that: a qualified medical doctor is working on board (in the case of ships that carry 100 or more people and that are ordinar - ily engaged in voyages of more than three days’ duration); or where ships are not required to carry a medical doctor, they have at least one seafarer on board (who is trained and qualified to the requirements of STCW) to be in charge of medical care or is competent to provide medical first aid as part of their regular duties. Evidence that medical report forms are carried on board the ship. Interviews, in private, with a representative number of sea- farers to confirm that seafarers have access to medical care on board without charge and are given leave to obtain medical and dental care services when calling in a port, where practic - able. Evidence that procedures are in place for radio or satellite communications for medical assistance. 4343400 140335 4 0 0 4 Examples of deficiencies A seafarer working on the ship is denied , without justification, shore leave by the master and/or shipowner to go ashore for medical or dental care. A seafarer is not provided with appropriate health protection and medical care on board ship. Medical personnel, with appropriate qualifications, as re- quired by national laws or regulations, are not on board . Medical chest or equipment does not meet national standards and/or no medical guide is on board . No medical report forms are on board . There is evidence that a seafarer is being charged for medical or dental care contrary to national law or practice. Regulation 4.2 – Shipowners’ liability (Appendix A5-III – Financial security relating to shipowners’ liability ) Basic requirements Seafarers have a right to material assistance and support from the shipowner with respect to the financial consequences of sickness, injury or death occurring while they are serving under a SEA or arising from their employment under such agreement ( Regulation 4.2, paragraph 1). Shipowners are liable to defray the expense of medical care, including medical treatment and the supply of the necessary medicines and therapeutic appliances, and board and lodging away from home until the sick or injured seafarer has recovered, or until the sickness or incapacity has been declared of a permanent character (Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 1(c)). Shipowners are to provide financial security to assure compensation in the event of the death or long-term disability of seafarers due to an occupational injury, illness or hazard, as set out in national law, the SEA or collective agreement (Standard A4.2 .1 , paragraph 1(b)). The system of financial security, as provided for in Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 1(b), may be in the form of a social security scheme, insurance fund or other similar arrangements (Standard A4.2.2 , paragraph 2 ) . The contractual compensation where set out in the SEA and without prejudice to Standard A4.2.1. paragraph 8 (c), must be paid in full and without delay (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (a) ) . There must not be pressure to accept a payment less than the contractual amount (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (b) ) . Where the nature of the long-term disability of a seafarer makes it difficult to assess the full compensation to which the seafarer may be entitled, an interim payment or payments must be made to the seafarer so as to avoid undue hardship (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (c) ) . The seafarer must receive payment without prejudice to other legal rights, but such payment may be offset by the shipowner against any damages resulting from any other claim made by the seafarer against the shipowner and arising from the same incident (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (d) ) ; The claim for contractual compensation may be brought directly by the seafarer concerned, or their next of kin, or a representative of the seafarer or designated beneficiary (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 8 (e) ) . Effective arrangements must be in place to receive, deal with and impartially settle contractual claims relating to compensation referred to in Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 8, through expeditious and fair procedures (Standard A4.2.2 , paragraph 3) . Seafarers must receive prior notification if a shipowner’s financial security is to be cancelled / terminated (Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 9). The financial security shall not cease before the end of the period of validity of the financial security unless the provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority of the flag State (Standard A4.2.1, paragraph 12) . The financial security must provide for the payment of all contractual claims covered by it, which arise during the period for which the document is valid (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 13) . A certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security issued by the financial security provider must be carried on board (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 11) . A copy of the certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must be posted in a conspicuous place on board where it is available to the seafarers (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 11) . Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, the document provided by each provider must be carried on board (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 11) . The certificate or other documentary evidence of financial security must contain the information required in Appendix A4-I (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 14) . It must be in English or accompanied by an English translation (Standard A4.2.1 , paragraph 14) . Sources of information T he valid financial security certificate or other documentary evidence issued by the financial security provider . The DMLC, Part I to check whether there are any national substantial equivalences and, if so, the DMLC, Part II to check for compliance. The SEA and/or relevant collective bargaining agreement to verify that seafarers have the coverage required by national law implementing the MLC, 2006. T he on-board complaint handling records. Interview s, in private , with seafarers . Examples of deficiencies No information on coverage in the SEA or relevant collective bargaining agreement , if applicable . 4318000 35560 3 0 0 3 Where applicable, p rovisions in the SEA or collective bargaining agreement are not consistent with national requirements implementing the MLC, 2006. Seafarers do not receive contractual compensation payments as set out in the SEA. Contractual compensation delayed or not paid in full. Seafarers are pressured to accept a payment less than the contractual amount. Interim payment(s) are not made to the seafarer, where the nature of the long-term disability of a seafarer makes it difficult to assess the full compensation to which the seafarer may be entitled. Seafarers are not provided with direct access to the financial security system. No effective arrangements are in place to receive, deal with and impartially settle contractual claims in accordance with flag State requirements as set out in the DMLC, Part I, point 16. If the shipowner’s financial security is to be or has been cancelled or terminated, and seafarers have not been notified. The financial security has ceased before the end of the period of validity as stated on the financial security certificate; or, where the financial security provider has given prior notification of at least 30 days to the competent authority of the flag State, the financial security has ceased before the end of that notification period. ALTERNATIVE WORDING: The financial security has ceased before: ( i ) the expiration date stated on the financial security certificate or (ii) the end of the notice period of at least 30 days given to the competent authority (where applicable). The certificate of financial security or other documentary evidence, issued by the financial security provider, including as regards the social security system in place, is not carried on board. Where more than one financial security provider provides cover, not all documents provided by each provider are carried on board. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not posted in a conspicuous place on board or is not available to seafarers. The financial security certificate or other documentary evidence does not include the required information as set out in Appendix A4-I. The certificate or other documentary evidence is not available in English or is not accomp anied by an English translation. The financial security certificate or other documentary evidence is invalid, for example is expired or falsified . Regulation 4.3 – Health and safety protection and accident prevention (Appendix A5-III – Health and safety and accident prevention) Basic requirements The working, living and training environment on ships must be safe and hygienic and conform to national laws and regulations and other measures for occupational safety and health protec - tion and accident prevention on board ship. Reasonable pre- cautions are to be taken on the ships to prevent occupational accidents, injuries and diseases including risk of exposure to harmful levels of ambient factors and chemicals as well as the risk of injury or disease that may result from the use of equipment and machinery on the ship (Standard A4.3, para- graph 1(b)). Ships must have an occupational safety and health policy and programme to prevent occupational accident injuries and dis- eases, with a particular concern for the safety and health of sea- farers under the age of 18 (Standard A4.3, paragraphs 1(c) and 2(b)). A ship safety committee, that includes participation by the sea- farer safety representative, is required (for ships with five or more seafarers) (Standard A4.3, paragraph 2(d)). Risk evaluation is required for on-board occupational safety and health management (taking into account relevant statisti - cal data) (Standard A4.3, paragraph 8). Sources of information Relevant documents, such as the on-board occupational acci - dent reports, and the reports of risk evaluations undertaken for the management of occupational safety and health on the ship. Documents evidencing membership and meetings of the safety committee (e.g. records and minutes of the meetings, etc.) if the ship has five or more seafarers. Documents related to the ship’s on-board ongoing occupa - tional safety and health policy and programme , to confirm that: it is available to seafarers; it is consistent with national provisions; it includes risk evaluation, training and instruction for sea- farers; it pays special attention to the health and safety of young seafarers; adequate preventive measures are being taken; appropriate personal protective equipment is being used and maintained correctly. 4343400 149860 4 0 0 4 Relevant occupational safety and health and accident preven - tion notices and official instructions with respect to particular hazards on the ship, which should be posted on the ship in a location that will bring it to the attention of seafarers (Standard A4.3, paragraph 7). Evidence that appropriate protective equipment is available for seafarers to use. Evidence that a reporting procedure for occupational acci - dents is in place. Interviews, in private, with a representative number of sea- farers to confirm on-board occupational safety and health pro- grammes and practices. Evidence that, with respect to health and safety protection and accident prevention, special consideration is given to any national requirements, if applicable, covering: the structural features of the ship, including means of ac- cess and asbestos-related risks; machinery; the effects of the extremely low or high temperature of any surfaces with which seafarers may be in contact; the effects of noise in the workplace and in shipboard ac- commodation ; the effects of vibration in the workplace and in shipboard accommodation; the effects of ambient factors (other than noise and vibra - tion ) in the workplace and in shipboard accommodation, including tobacco smoke; special safety measures on and below deck; loading and unloading equipment; fire prevention and firefighting; anchors, chains and lines; dangerous cargo and ballast; personal protective equipment for seafarers; work in enclosed spaces; physical and mental effects of fatigue; the effects of drug and alcohol dependency; HIV/AIDS protection and prevention; emergency and accident response . Examples of deficiencies Conditions exist on board which may impair efforts to prevent accidents. No evidence of an on-board policy and/or programmes for the prevention of occupational accidents, injuries and diseases. No established or functioning ship’s safety committee when there are five or more seafarers working on board . Personal protective equipment is in poor condition or being in- correctly used or not being used. Risk assessments are missing. Seafarers are unaware of the measures adopted by the man- agement to provide OSH and to prevent accidents. Risks posed to young seafarers have not been addressed . Occupational accidents are not being investigated or reported in accordance with the ship’s procedures. Regulation 5.1.5 – On-board complaint procedures (Appendix A5-III – On-board complaint procedures) Basic requirements 4343400 454660 4 0 0 4 Ships must have on-board procedures for the fair, effective and expeditious handling of seafarer complaints alleging breaches of the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (including seafarers’ rights) (Regulation 5.1.5, paragraph 1). All seafarers must be provided with a copy of the on-board complaint procedures applicable on the ship (Standard A5.1.5, paragraph 4). This should be in the working language of the ship. Victimization of seafarers for filing complaints under the MLC, 2006, is prohibited (Regulation 5.1.5, paragraph 2). Sources of information The document outlining the on-board complaint procedures to confirm that the procedures are functioning on the ship, particularly with respect to the right of representation, the required safeguards against victimization and the ability of seafarers to complain directly to the ship’s master or to an ex- ternal authority. Interviews, in private, with a representative number of sea- farers to confirm that they are given a copy of the on-board complaint procedures in the working language of the ship, that they are able to complain directly to the ship’s master or an ex- ternal authority and that there is no victimization. Examples of deficiencies No document setting out the on-board complaint procedures. Ship’s on-board complaint procedures are not operating. Victimization of a seafarer for making a complaint. Seafarer is not provided with a copy of the ship’s on-board complaint procedures in the working language of the ship. Action to be taken by port State control officers when finding deficiencies or non-conformities Actions to be considered when deficiencies are found Where, following a more detailed inspection, the PSCO finds that the working and living conditions on the ship do not con- form to the requirements of the Convention, certain action must or may be taken, depending upon the situation (Standard A5.2.1, par- agraph 4). This chapter describes the three main steps to be taken in connection with this final stage in a port State control inspection. Step 1: Notification of any deficiencies The following action must be taken: the deficiencies found must be brought to the attention of the master of the ship, with required deadlines for their rectifica - tion ; 4343400 551815 5 0 0 5 if the deficiencies are considered by the PSCO to be significant, or if they relate to a complaint referred to in section 3.3 above, they must, in accordance with the MLC, 2006 (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 4), be brought to the attention of the appro - priate seafarers’ and shipowners’ organizations in the port State in which the inspection was carried out. Whether or not deficiencies are determined to be signifi - cant will depend upon the professional judgement of the PSCO concerned. Deficiencies which, having regard to their nature or quantity or repetition, the PSCO would not expect to find on a well- run ship would be significant. Rectification of a deficiency related to shipowner use of recruitment and placement services should not, in principle, be to the detriment of the seafarers affected. Where the deficiencies are significant or relate to a com- plaint, the PSCO may also: notify a representative of the flag State; provide the competent authority of the next port of call with the relevant information (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 4). The notifications referred to in paragraphs 90 and 91 above should draw attention to any non-conformities that need to be rectified before the ship can proceed to sea, stating (unless obvi- ous ) the reason why the non-conformities concerned fall within Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 6(a) and/or (b) (see paragraph 96 below). The notification of significant deficiencies should always be in writing. A PSC authority may decide to send the PSCO’s report to the ILO Director-General accompanied by any comments received by the flag State authorities (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 5). If information is provided to the competent authority of the next port of call, the PSCO in that port may decide to inspect the ship to verify that measures have been or are being taken by it to rectify the deficiency within the deadline given (see paragraph 104 below). If the rectification has not been made, the information may be considered as providing clear grounds warranting a more detailed inspection in accordance with Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 1(b) (see paragraph 71 above) and may eventually lead to the defi - ciency being considered a non-conformity constituting a repeated breach referred to in Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 6 (see below). Step 2: Determining whether the ship can sail prior to rectification Since all possible efforts must be made to avoid a ship being unduly detained or delayed (see paragraph 108 below), the ship should be allowed to sail (on the understanding that all defi - ciencies identified will be rectified within the deadline given) unless: the conditions on board are clearly hazardous to the safety, health or security of seafarers; or the non-conformity or non-conformities found constitute a serious or repeated breach of the requirements of the Conven - tion (including seafarers’ rights, whose violation is relevant for the consideration of the seriousness of a non-conformity) (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 6; see also Guideline B5.2.1, para- graph 2). In either case, the PSCO must take steps to ensure that the ship does not proceed to sea until all non-conformities correspond- ing to (a) or (b) above have been rectified, or until the PSCO has accepted a proposal for a plan of action to rectify those non- conformities. Examples of circumstances that may require detention of the ship 4343400 444500 5 0 0 5 Not every deficiency would be sufficiently serious to war- rant preventing a ship from sailing. However repeated breaches may be a reason for detaining a ship. The following are examples – and examples only – of the kinds of circumstances which could war- rant a decision to keep the ship in port (in the absence of agree- ment on a proposal for a plan of action to rectify the deficiency) either because they are repeated (in the sense of occurring several times on a voyage or recurring after a previous voyage in which the same deficiency was noted) or because of the seriousness of a single instance: the presence of any seafarer on board under the age of 16 (Standard A1.1, paragraph 1); the employment of any seafarer under the age of 18 in work likely to jeopardize their health or safety (Standard A1.1, para- graph 4) or in night work (see Standard A1.1, paragraphs 2 and 3); insufficient manning (Regulation 2.7 and Standard A2.7), in- cluding that caused by the removal from the SMD of under-age seafarers; any other deficiencies constituting a violation of fundamental rights and principles or seafarers’ employment and social rights in Articles III and IV; any non-conformity applied in a way that violates those funda - mental rights (for example, the attribution of substandard ac- commodation based on the race or gender or trade union activ - ity of the seafarers concerned); repeated cases of seafarers without valid certificates confirm- ing medical fitness for duties (Standard A1.2); seafarers on board the same ship repeatedly not in possession of valid seafarers’ employment agreements (SEAs) or sea- farers with SEAs containing clauses constituting a denial of seafarers’ rights (Regulation 2.1, paragraph 1); seafarers repeatedly working beyond maximum hours of work (Standard A2.3, paragraph 5(a)) or having less than the mini- mum hours of rest (Standard A2.3, paragraph 5(b)); ventilation and/or air conditioning or heating that is not work- ing adequately (Standard A3.1, paragraph 7); accommodation, including catering and sanitary facilities, that is unhygienic or where equipment is missing or not functioning (Standards A3.1, paragraph 11, and A3.2, paragraph 2; Regu - lation 4.3, paragraph 1); quality and quantity of food and drinking water not suitable for the intended voyage (Standard A3.2, paragraph 2); medical guide or medicine chest or medical equipment, as re- quired , not on board (Standard A4.1, paragraph 4(a)); no medical doctor for passenger ships engaged in international voyages of more than three days, carrying 100 persons or more, or no seafarer in charge of medical care on board (Standard A4.1, paragraph 4(b) and (c)); repeated cases of non-payment of wages or the non-payment of wages over a significant period or the falsification of wage accounts or the existence of more than one set of wage ac- counts (Standard A2.2, paragraphs 1 and 2). In considering the above examples, particular reference should be made to the guidance to be provided to PSCOs by their authority in accordance with Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 7, which requires PSCOs to be “given guidance, of the kind indicated in Part B of the Code, as to the kinds of circumstances justifying detention of a ship under paragraph 6 of this Standard”. Guideline B5.2.1, paragraph 1, recommends that there should be an inspec - tion policy for PSCOs with the objective of ensuring consistency and otherwise guiding inspection and enforcement activities related to the requirements of this Convention (including sea- farers’ rights). 4343400 120650 5 0 0 5 Guideline B5.2.1, paragraph 2, indicates circumstances warranting the detention of a ship considering that with respect to the breaches referred to in paragraph 6(b) of Standard A5.2.1, the seriousness could be due to the nature of the deficiency concerned. This would be particularly relevant in the case of the violation of fundamental rights and principles o r seafarers’ employment and social rights under Articles III and IV. For example, the employ- ment of a person who is under age should be considered as a seri - ous breach even if there is only one such person on board. In other cases, the number of different defects found during a particular inspection should be taken into account: for example, several in- stances of defects relating to accommodation or food and catering which do not threaten safety or health might be needed before they should be considered as constituting a serious breach. Factors to be considered by a PSCO in deciding whether to accept a rectification proposal PSCOs should exercise professional judgement to deter- mine whether to detain a ship until the non-conformities of the kind referred to in the above examples are corrected or to allow it to sail with some non-conformities, on the basis of an acceptable proposal for rectification. Before accepting the shipowner’s or master’s proposal for rectifying a deficiency, the PSCO must be satisfied that it will be implemented in an expeditious manner (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 6). PSCOs should therefore not accept a proposal if they have reason to believe that it may not be implemented expeditiously, unless they have a means of ensuring, through the assistance of the flag State or other port States, that the ship will be prevented from any further sailing if rectification is not expeditiously implemented. In deciding whether or not to accept a proposal for recti- fication , the following considerations may also be relevant: whether or not the non-conformities can be rapidly remedied in the port of inspection; the length and nature of the intended voyage or service; the nature of the hazard to seafarers’ safety, health or security; the seriousness of the breach of the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (including seafarers’ rights); any previous history of the non-conformities or similar ones on the ship; the size and type of ship and equipment provided; whether or not the appropriate work or rest periods for sea- farers are being observed; safe manning requirements; the nature of the cargo; any non-conformities which have been discovered in previous ports of call; the number of deficiencies found during the particular inspec - tion . Consultation prior to a decision concerning a rectification proposal 4343400 1418590 5 0 0 5 103. Detention of a ship is a serious matter involving many issues. It will be important for the PSCO to work with other inter- ested parties. For example, the PSCO may request the shipowner’s representatives or seafarers’ representatives to propose a plan of action for correcting the situation. Since the flag State would have been notified of the concern, the PSCO should cooperate with the flag State administration’s representatives or the RO responsible for issuing the Maritime Labour Certificate and the DMLC, con- sulting them regarding the PSCO’s or the shipowner’s proposal for actions that will be taken to rectify the deficiency. Form and content of a proposal for rectification 104. The proposal for rectification should be signed on behalf of the port State authority and the shipowner and specify the actions to be taken and the related time frame . It should contain an undertaking by the shipowner to facilitate the inspection of the ship by PSCOs in other ports in order to verify that the plan of action to rectify the non-conformities has been properly implemented, as well as a warning that the ship may be prevented from further sail- ing if rectification does not occur as proposed. Step 3: Notifying a decision to allow/not to allow the ship to sail Action to be taken if a rectification proposal is agreed 105. If the PSCO allows the ship to proceed to another port, subject to its implementation of the proposal for rectification, the PSCO should ensure that the competent authority of the next port of call and the flag State are notified . Action to be taken if the ship is not allowed to sail Where an agreement is not concluded on rectification, including the time frame for it to be carried out, the ship must not be allowed to proceed to sea. The PSCO must forthwith (by email or fax or similar means of communication): notify the flag State; invite a representative of the flag State to be present, if pos - sible ; and request the flag State to reply within a reasonable deadline (Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 6). The PSCO must also inform forthwith the appropriate shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations in the port State. In performing their functions referred to in this section, PSCOs should bear in mind the obligation of port States under Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 8, to make all possible efforts to avoid a ship being unduly detained or delayed, and to pay compensation for any loss or damage suffered if a ship is found to be unduly detained or delayed. The burden of proof in each case is on the complainant. 5 Onshore complaints by seafarers A complaint by a seafarer alleging a breach of the re- quirements of the MLC, 2006 (including seafarers’ rights), may be made to an authorized officer in the port at which the seafarer’s ship has called in accordance with Standard A5.2.2. Appropriate steps must be taken to safeguard the confidentiality of these com- plaints (Standard A5.2.2, paragraph 7) and the receipt of the complaint should be recorded by the authorized officer (see para- graph 78 above) . This chapter outlines the steps in the onshore complaints process. Step 1: Determining whether the complaint should be handled under the PSC inspection procedures 4312285 1862455 6 0 0 6 The PSCO must undertake an initial investigation to determine whether the complaint relates to the working and living conditions on the ship visiting the port and whether to undertake a more detailed inspection, following the procedure for complaints set out in section 3.3 above (Standard A5.2.2, paragraph 2; Guide- line B5.2.2, paragraphs 1 and 2). A more detailed inspection must be carried out (see Chapter 5, paragraph 75, above) if the working and living conditions alleged to be defective could constitute a clear hazard to the safety, health or security of seafarers or where there are grounds to believe that any deficiencies constitute a seri - ous breach of the requirements of the MLC, 2006 (including sea- farers’ rights), even if they relate to a single seafarer. In cases not covered by the procedure set out in section 3.3 above , the PSCO or other officer authorized to handle com- plaints under Regulation 5.2.2 should follow the procedures set out below. Step 2: Ascertaining whether on-board complaint procedures have been explored As noted in paragraph 110 above the authorized officer should carry out an initial investigation to find out the basic issues of the complaint and determine the appropriate process to follow. In making this determination the PSCO should bear in mind the objective of the onshore complaint handling procedures which is to facilitate a prompt and practical means of redress (Regulation 5.2.2, paragraph 1). In making this determination the PSCO may find it helpful to consider the guidance provided in Guideline B5.2.2. The authorized officer must, where appropriate, seek to promote a resolution of the complaint at the shipboard level and the initial investigation should include consideration of whether the on-board complaint procedures provided under Regulation 5.1.5 have been explored (Standard A5.2.2, paragraphs 2 and 3). A seafarer is not required to use the on-board complaints procedures and there may be good reasons for not doing so. If those proced - ures have not yet been explored and the authorized officer con- cludes , having given due consideration to the guidance provided in Guideline B5.2.2, paragraph 3, that those procedures should first be explored, the officer may refrain from any further action on the complaint except to suggest that the complainant take advantage of those procedures. Step 3: Carrying out an investigation In the investigation of the complaint, the master, the shipowner and any other person involved in the complaint should be given a proper opportunity to make known their views (see Guideline B5.2.2, paragraph 4). If the investigation reveals a non-conformity that falls within the scope of Standard A5.2.1, paragraph 6(a) and/or (b) (see Onshore complaints by seafarers paragraph 96 above), the procedure outlined in Chapter 5 above should be followed (Standard A5.2.2, paragraph 4). Step 4: Seeking advice and a corrective plan of action from the flag State In other cases, where a complaint has not been resolved at the ship-board level, the authorized officer must notify the flag State and seek, within a prescribed deadline, advice and a correct- ive plan of action (Standard A5.2.2, paragraph 5). Where the flag State demonstrates that it will handle the matter and that it has effective procedures and has submitted an acceptable plan of action, the authorized officer may refrain from any further involve- ment in the complaint (see Guideline B5.2.2, paragraph 5). Step 5: Reporting the unresolved complaint If the complaint has not been resolved at the flag State level and it is not demonstrated that the flag State is in a position to deal with the matter (see step 4), the authorized officer’s report must be transmitted to the ILO Director-General, accompanied by any reply received from the flag State within the prescribed dead- line. The appropriate shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations in the port State must be similarly informed. After this step, no fur- ther action on the complaint should be taken in the port State. However if, during investigation of the complaint, clear grounds for believing that the working and living conditions on the ship do not conform to the requirements of the MLC, 2006, have arisen, a PSCO may decide to carry out a more detailed inspection (see Chapter 3, paragraph 71 above). 6