HD LISA 1
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
EESTI ÜLEMINEK SÜSINIKNEUTRAALSELE SOOJUS- NING
JAHUTUSMAJANDUSELE AASTAKS 2050
TEHNILINE KIRJELDUS
Sisukord
1.1. Uuringu taust ................................................................................................................... 2
1.2. Üldine taust .................................................................................................................. 2
1.3. Hetke olukord .............................................................................................................. 2
2. Eesmärk............................................................................................................................... 4
3. Tulemused ........................................................................................................................... 5
4. Olemasolev sisendinformatsioon ........................................................................................ 6
5. Aruande formaat ................................................................................................................. 6
7. Tulemused ja ülesanded ...................................................................................................... 6
7.1. Vahearuanne 1: Uuringu planeerimine ........................................................................... 6
7.2. Vahearuanne 2: Olemasoleva olukorra ülevaade ............................................................ 7
7.3. Vahearuanne 3: Stsenaariumid süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse
saavutamiseks aastaks 2050 ....................................................................................................... 8
7.4. Vahearuanne 4: Sotsiaalmajandusliku mõju analüüs .................................................... 10
7.5. Vahearuanne 5: Riskianalüüs ........................................................................................ 12
7.6. Vahearuanne 6: Sensitiivsusanalüüs ............................................................................. 12
7.7. Vahearuanne 7: Süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse ülemineku
tegevusplaanid Eestis ............................................................................................................... 12
7.8. Tulemus 8: Lõpparuanne ............................................................................................... 13
8. Ajakava................................................................................................................................. 14
9. Metoodika............................................................................................................................. 14
10. Aruannete esitamine ja vastuvõtmine ................................................................................ 15
11. Kohtumised ........................................................................................................................ 15
12. Autoriõigused ..................................................................................................................... 15
1
1.1. Uuringu taust
1.2. Üldine taust
Aastaks 2050 on Eesti konkurentsivõimeline, teadmistepõhise ühiskonna ja majandusega
kliimaneutraalne riik, kus on tagatud kvaliteetne ja liigirikas elukeskkond ning valmisolek ja
võime kliimamuutuste põhjustatud ebasoodsaid mõjusid vähendada ja positiivseid mõjusid
parimal viisil ära kasutada1.
Euroopa Liidu tasandil on viimaste aastate jooksul välja tuldud järgmiste initsiatiividega:
- Euroopa roheline kokkulepe2
- Energiasüsteemi integreerimise strateegia3
- Renoveerimislaine strateegia4
Eesti kaugkütte valdkond on õigusaktidega reguleeritud ning vastavalt Euroopa Liidu direktiivi
2012/27/EU5 (EED) definitsioonile, loetakse kaugküte 93% ulatuses efektiivseks. See tuleneb
peamiselt puitkütustel põhinevate koostootmisjaamade laialdasest kasutamisest. Arvestades
eelmainitud initsiatiive, Euroopa energia ja kliimapoliitikat ja toodud direktiivi on vajalik
põhjalikult analüüsida hetke olukorda Eesti soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses ja luua sobilikud
teekaardid, mis toetavad antud valdkonna üleminekut süsinikneutraalsele majandamisele
aastaks 2050.
Euroopa liidu (sh. Eesti) sihiks on saavutada kliimaneutraalsus aastaks 2050. Soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduse investeeringute eluiga on kümneid aastaid ning seetõttu on vajalik
kindlustada, et järgnevate kümnendite investeeringud antud valdkonnas on jätkusuutlikud ning
toetavad kliimaneutraalsuse saavutamist. Kaugküte, lokaalküte, jahutus, salvestus ja tarbimise
juhtimine tuleb omavahel integreerida kliimaneutraalsele majandamisele üleminekul.
1.3. Hetke olukord
2019. aastal moodustas kogu soojusvarustusest ca 65% kaugküte (ca 4450 GWh).
Eestis on kokku 230 kaugkütte võrgupiirkonda. Soojusenergia kaalutud keskmine
käibemaksuta hind oli 2019. aasta novembris 50,58 €/MWh, aritmeetiline keskmine 60,27
€/MWh. Soojusenergia käibemaksuta hinnad olid 2019. aasta novembris vahemikus 35,33
€/MWh Narvas kuni 86,96 €/MWh Harkus. Reeglina on keskmisest kõrgema soojusenergia
hinna põhjus kallite kütuste nagu põlevkiviõli ja maagaasi kasutamine ning kaugküttesüsteemi
halb tehniline olukord.
1
https://vv.riigikantselei.ee/sites/default/files/riigikantselei/strateegiaburoo/Eesti2035/riigi_pikaajaline_arengustra
teegia_eesti_2035_eelnou_uldosa.pdf
2
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-
content/EN/TXT/?qid=1596443911913&uri=CELEX:52019DC0640#document2
3
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52020DC0299&from=EN
4
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=1603122220757&uri=CELEX:52020DC0662
5
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A32012L0027
2
Enimlevinud kütus kaugkütte tootmiseks on hakkepuit - 51,5% tarbitavast kaugküttesoojusest
toodetakse hakkepuidust. Sellele järgneb maagaas (21,2%) (graafik 1).
Lokaalküttes enimlevinud kütus on puit, millest 66% on küttepuu ning 34% pellet või muu
puittoode. Kolmandik lokaalküttest on lahendatud soojuspumpade ning viiendik maagaasiga
(graafik 2).
Viimastel aastatel on ka ellu viidud kaugjahutuse projekte Tallinnas6, Tartus7 ja Pärnus8.
Kaugküte kütuste lõikes
4,4TWh - 100% (2018)
Põlevkivi 9,8
Muu 3,5
Põlevkivi õli 2,2 Biomass
Turvas 4,9 Gaas
Uttegaas
Uttegaas 6,9
Turvas
Biomass 51,5
Põlevkivi õli
Muu
Gaas 21,2 Põlevkivi
Graafik 1 – Kaugkütte kütused, 2018 (Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium)9
Lokaalkütte kütused
2018
Muu
7%
Maagaas
15%
Puit
Puit
44% Soojuspumbad
Maagaas
Muu
Soojuspumbad
34%
Graafik 2 – Lokaalkütte kütused,, 2017 (Allikas: Statistikaamet, ETEK)10
6
Kaugjahutus Tallinnas - https://www.utilitas.ee/kaugjahutus/
7
Kaugjahutus Tartus - https://www.fortumtartu.ee/tooted-ja-teenused/kaugjahutus/
8
Kaugjahutus Pärnus - https://www.fortum.ee/media/2018/06/fortum-alustab-parnu-esimese-jahutusjaama-
ehitamist
9
https://mkm.ee/et/tegevused-eesmargid/energeetika/soojusmajandus
10
http://www.taastuvenergeetika.ee/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/ETEK_aastaraamat_A4_2019_veeb.pdf
3
Eestis reguleerib kaugküttesektorit kaugkütteseadus11 ning sellele lisaks on veel mitmeid
strateegilisi dokumente, mis soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse arengut käsitlevad. Käesolevas
uuringus peab soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse süsinikneutraalsuse saavutamise teekaartide
koostamisel lähtuma muuhulgas alljärgnevatest strateegilistest dokumentidest:
Energiamajanduse arengukava aastani 203012;
Strateegia “Eesti 203513”;
Üleriigiline planeering „Eesti 2030+“14;
Eesti säästva arengu riiklik strateegia „Säästev Eesti 21“15
Kliimapoliitika põhialused aastani 205016
Riiklik energia- ja kliimakava aastani 203017;
Hoonete rekonstrueerimise pikaajaline strateegia18
Eesti Ettevõtluse kasvustrateegia 2014-202019;
Kliimaneutraalsus eesmärgina on suhteliselt uus, seetõttu eelnevad dokumendid ei käsitle
teatud uusi märksõnu nagu süsinikneutraalsus20, energiasüsteemide integreerimine,
kaugjahutus, sesoonne soojussalvestus, kaugkütte tarbimise juhtimine, taastuvad gaasid jne.
Tugev omavaheline seotus toodud elementide vahel on süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduse nurgakiviks.
2. Eesmärk
Käesoleva uuringu eesmärgiks on koostada stsenaariumid, mis kirjeldaks
süsinikuneutraalse soojus- ja jahutusmajanduse saavutamise erinevaid võimalusi aastaks
2050. Uuringu tulemusena tuleb modelleerida vähemalt kolm stsenaariumit, mis on sisu poolest
erineva lähenemisega süsinikuneutraalse soojus- ja jahutusmajanduse saavutamisele ning neid
tuleb võrrelda praeguste suundumuste jätkumise stsenaariumiga (PSJS21) ehk kokku 4
stsenaariumit. Modelleeritud stsenaariumitele tuleb läbi viia sotsiaalmajandusliku mõju
hindamine ning koostada vajalikud tegevuskavad stsenaariumite elluviimiseks.
Stsenaariumite modelleerimise tulemusena koostatakse teekaardid22, mis on sisendiks
poliitikakujundajale, et saavutada keskkonnasõbralik, energiasäästlik,
sotsiaalmajanduslikult kasulik ja jätkusuutlik süsinikneutraalne soojus- ning
jahutusmajandus aastaks 2050.
11
Kaugkütteseadus https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/103032017012
12
https://www.mkm.ee/sites/default/files/enmak_2030.pdf
13
https://www.riigikantselei.ee/sites/default/files/riigikantselei/strateegiaburoo/Eesti2035/riigi_pikaajaline_arengus
trateegia_eesti_2035_eelnou_tegevuskava_ja_moodikud.pdf
14
https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/sites/default/files/Ruumiline_planeerimine/eesti2030.pdf
15
https://www.riigikantselei.ee/sites/default/files/content-editors/Failid/saastev_eesti_21.pdf
16
https://www.envir.ee/et/eesmargid-tegevused/kliima/kliimapoliitika-pohialused-aastani-2050-0
17
https://www.mkm.ee/sites/default/files/teatis_eesti_riiklik_energia-_ja_kliimakava_aastani_2030.pdf
18
https://www.ekyl.ee/wp-content/uploads/Hoonete-rekonstrueerimise-pikaajaline-strateegia-
l%c3%b5ppraport_2020-06-02.pdf
19
https://kasvustrateegia.mkm.ee/index.html
20
olukord, kus mõne toote või protsessiga seotud netoheitkogus on null; see saavutatakse vältimatu heite
kompenseerimise abil https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-
content/ET/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52014SA0014&from=ET
21
Praeguste suundumuste jätkamise stsenaarium
22
Teekaart=Stsenaarium+ Tegevusplaan
4
Edukaks osutunud pakkuja loob ning analüüsib erinevaid stsenaariume süsinikneutraalse
soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse saavutamiseks aastaks 2050. Stsenaariumitega kaasneb põhjalik
analüüs, mis peab arvestama erinevate lähenemistega seonduvaid kasvuhoonegaaside
heitkoguste ning võimalike sotsiaalmajanduslike mõjudega nende stsenaariumite korral.
Oluline väärtus on stsenaariumite tegevuskavadel, mis aitavad poliitikakujundajal valida
rakendatavat teekaarti.
Käesoleva uuringu tulemused peavad andma selge indikatsiooni milliseid vajalikke
muutusi on vaja rakendada ja kuidas, et saavutada süsinikneutraalne soojus- ning
jahutusmajandus Eestis aastaks 2050. Uuringu väljundid annavad olulise sisendi
strateegiliste dokumentide uuendamiseks (nt energiamajanduse arengukava, riiklik
energia ja kliimakava, kliimapoliitika põhialused 2050) ja üldiseks
poliitikakujundamiseks.
Uuringus väljapakutud lahendused peavad olema rakendatavad Eesti klimaatilistel tingimustel,
arvestades väljakujunenud kohalikku taristut ja seadusandlust.
Üleminek süsinikneutraalsele soojus- ning jahutusmajandusele peab olema vastavuses Euroopa
energia ja kliimapoliitika põhimõtete ja eesmärkidega (nt Rohelepe), arvestama kindlasti
energiasäästu meetmetega, mida on võimalik soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses efektiivselt
rakendada (nt tarbimise juhtimine, jääksoojuse kasutamine). Analüüsitavad stsenaariumid
peavad arvestama maksimaalse energiasüsteemide integratsiooniga23, et uusi tekkivaid
võimalusi energiaturgude integreerimisel ära kasutada.
Lõplik aruanne on terviklik dokument, koosnedes vahearuannetest, mis on välja toodud 7.
peatükis. Aruanne (iga vahearuanne ja lõpparuanne) peab olema lihtsasti loetav ja sisaldama
kontsentreeritud kokkuvõtet tulemustest iga peatüki juures. Sisu selgema edasi andmise
eesmärgil peab kasutama erinevaid lihtsustavaid visuaalseid tööriistu (nt graafikud, skeemid).
Oluline on, et vajalikud seosed, arengud ja mõjud selgelt välja tulevad.
3. Tulemused
Uuringu tulemused on järgmised:
Tulemus 1: Vähemalt kolme stsenaariumi (+PSJS24) võrdlev analüüs süsinikneutraalse
soojus- ning jahutumajanduse saavutamiseks Eestis aastaks 2050;
Tulemus 2: Süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse stsenaariumite
sotsiaalmajandusliku mõju võrdlev hinnang;
Tulemus 3: Süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse stsenaariumite
tegevusplaanid koos maksumustega aastaks 2050.
Kõigi stsenaariumite puhul peab olema tagatud varustuskindlus, jätkusuutlik soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduse areng ning Euroopa ja Eesti energia- ja kliimapoliitika eesmärkide täitmine.
23
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=COM:2020:299:FIN
24
Praeguste Suundumuste Jätkamise Stsenaarium (PSJS)
5
4. Olemasolev sisendinformatsioon
- Töö tellija aitab põhjendatud vajaduse ja võimaluse korral vajalike sisendandmete
kogumisel;
- Ministeeriumi kontaktisik osaleb uuringu läbiviija poolt korraldatavatel
kohtumistel;
- Ministeeriumi kontaktisik aitab kohtumiste läbiviimist turuosalistega, kui see on
põhjendatud ja vajalik.
5. Aruande formaat
Kõik aruanded (7 vahearuannet + lõpparuanne) tuleb koostada inglise keeles või eesti keeles.
Kohtumised, esitlused ja töötoad viiakse läbi inglise keeles või eesti keeles.
Lõpparuande juurde kuulub ka eestikeelne, 10…15 leheküljeline, kokkuvõte. Kokkuvõte peab
olema selge struktuuriga, peamised tulemused selgelt välja toodud ning visualiseeritud vajalike
graafikute, skeemide ja piltidega. Lisaks peab koostama 1-2 leheküljelise infolehe peamistest
uuringu tulemustest.
Kõik vahearuanded (7 vahearuannet vt. peatükk 7) peavad olema ühtse stiiliga (pealkirjad,
küljendus, viitamine, bibliograafia jne) ja sisaldama samuti kokkuvõtvat, peamisi leide ja
järeldusi sisaldavat peatükki. Viitamine algallikatele on oluline, et välistada kasutatud materjali
ebasobilik kasutamine.
6. Uuringuga tellitavad tegevused
Uuringu teostaja vastutab vajalike sisendandmete ja -informatsiooni kogumise eest,
kindlustamaks uuringu kvaliteetse läbiviimise. Uuringu teostaja korraldab kõik vajalikud
kohtumised turuosalistega ja teiste vajalike osapooltega. Tellija esindajad osalevad turuosaliste
määramise protsessil.
7. Tulemused ja ülesanded
Uuring on jaotutud etappideks, mida kirjeldatakse allpool toodud vahearuannete ja ülesannete
kaudu. Esitatud ülesannete ja küsimuste korrektne lahendamine on eelduseks eelpool toodud
tulemuste 1, 2 ja 3 saavutamisel. Tulemused esitatakse seitsme vahearuandena, mis
moodustavad ühtse tervikliku uuringu (lõpparuanne).
7.1. Vahearuanne 1: Uuringu planeerimine
Algetapi aruande eesmärgiks on osapoolte vahelise (Tellija ja Töö teostaja) ühise arusaama
loomine, et edasine uuringu läbiviimine kulgeks sujuvalt ja ootuspäraselt mõlemale osapoolele.
Aruanne peab sisaldama uuringu teostamise eeldusi (tarbimine, hinnad, maksud jne),
definitsioone (näiteks süsinikneutraalne soojus- ning jahutusmajandus, Power-to-X tehnoloogia
jne) ja metoodika täpsemat avamist. Sealhulgas on ära toodud tarbimisprognooside,
stsenaariumite aluste (sh PSJS), seotud tegevusplaanide, sotsiaalmajandusliku mõju, riski ja
sensitiivsuse analüüsi koostamise põhimõtted. Aruandes tuuakse välja olulised huvirühmad,
uuringu ajaplaan, kommunikatsiooni protokoll osapoolte vahel, avakohtumise protokoll koos
6
kokkulepitud järeltegevustega. Koostatav aruanne sisaldab ettepanekuid kuidas hinnata
uuringu järgseid tegevusi süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse arendamisel.
Ülesanded:
- Ministeeriumiga kooskõlastatult avakoosoleku korraldamine;
- Avakoosolekule eelnevalt päevakava ja koosolekul esitletavate materjalide edastamine;
- Avakoosoleku eesmärgid on:
(a) uuringu vahearuannete, ülesannete teostamise, ajagraafiku, metodoloogia ja
planeeritud tegevuste arutelu;
- (b) turuosaliste ja Ministeeriumi poolt vajalike sisendandmete ja -informatsiooni
vajaduste kaardistamine. Eesmärgi tulemuslikkust hinnata võimaldavate indikaatorite
arutelu. Kohtumine toimub füüsiliselt Tallinnas või elektrooniliste kanalite kaudu ning
arutelud toimuvad inglise või eesti keeles;
- Uuringu tulemuste analüüsiks sobiliku modelleerimise tarkvara välja pakkumine25;
- Aruande koostamine.
7.2. Vahearuanne 2: Olemasoleva olukorra ülevaade
Aruanne (ülevaade) peab sisaldama uuringu planeerimise vahearuandes kogutud
informatsiooni ning selle analüüsi. Kaardistatakse sobilikud tehnoloogiad, mille rakendamine,
Eesti süsinikneutraalses soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses, on realistlik. Aruande lisana
esitatakse koondatud arvandmed ja muu informatsioon muudetavate Exceli tabelitena, kus on
vajalikud viited algallikatele.
Ülesanded:
- Vajaliku informatsiooni koondamine. Eesti soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse
olemasolevat olukorda kirjeldatakse viimase viie aasta andmete põhjal (tarbimine,
tootmine, hinnad, kütused jne).
- PSJS stsenaariumi koostamiseks vajaliku informatsiooni koondamine, arvestades
lähitulevikus aset leidvaid muutusi soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses (REKK,
seadusandlus, tehnoloogiate integratsioon jne);
- Rakendatavate tehnoloogiate kaardistamine, millel on potentsiaalne roll
süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse saavutamisel järgneva viie või enam
aasta jooksul. Tehnoloogiad reastatakse tehnoloogia valmiduse taseme (TVT26) järgi
ning eristatakse tootmise, salvestamise, tarbimise juhtimise tehnoloogiaid;
- Stsenaariumite võrdlemiseks vajaliku sisendandmete koondamine (sotsiaalmajanduslik,
riski- ja sensitiivsusanalüüs ning keskkonna alased indikaatorid);
- Vahearuande koostamine, koondandmete edastamine muudetavas Exceli failis, vajalike
viidetega algallikatele.
25
https://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/strategies/analysis/models_en
26
https://www.etag.ee/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Tehnoloogilise-valmiduse-tasemed.pdf
7
7.3. Vahearuanne 3: Stsenaariumid süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduse saavutamiseks aastaks 2050
Aruandes peab analüüsima ja võrdlema modelleeritud stsenaariumeid: vähemalt kolm
süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse ülemineku stsenaariumit ja PSJS stsenaarium
aastaks 2050.
Süsinikneutraalset soojus- ning jahutusmajandust kirjeldavad parameetrid on
jätkusuutlikkus, majanduslikult tasuvad ärimudelid, energiaturgude integratsioon,
energiaefektiivsus (koos tarbimise juhtimisega), varustuskindlus, energiavaesuse
vältimine ja digitaliseerimine (targad võrgud, kaugloendurid jne).
Stsenaariumid peavad kirjeldama detailselt süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduse toimimist aastal 2050 Eestis. Stsenaariumite kvantifitseerimiseks on
vaja kasutada sobivat modelleerimise tarkvara27, mis on välja valitud uuringu
planeerimise vahearuandes.
Energiaturgude integreerimine on üks teguritest süsinikneutraalses soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduses. Aruandes antakse ülevaade erinevatest võimalikest tehnoloogiatest, mida
on võimalik integreerida ühtses süsteemis, nt Power-to-X, vesinik, geotermaal, jääksoojus,
jahutus, sesoonne salvestamine, elekter, päike, tuul jne. Ülevaade tehnoloogiatest on süsteemne
koos definitsioonidega, vältimaks tehnoloogiate erinevaid tõlgendusi.
Erinevate profiilidega turuosalised omavad erinevaid rolle terviklikus soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduses. Käesolevas uuringus on soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse turuosalised
jaotatud alljärgnevalt: eramajad, kortermajad hajaasustuses, linnaosa, linn tervikuna ja tööstus.
Analüüsis on vajalik välja tuua turuosaliste erinev roll ning selgelt defineerida.
Süsinikneutraalsuse saavutamiseks on rakendatavad strateegiad ja tehnoloogilised valikud
turuosalistel erinevad. Toodud eristus aitab poliitikakujundajatel kujundada vastavaid
meetmeid ning teha vajalikke otsuseid.
Aruandes kirjeldatakse stsenaariumites kasutatavate tehnoloogiate arendamise vajadusi.
Sisendina kasutada TVT ülevaadet, mis on koostatud olemasoleva olukorra kirjelduses
(Vahearuanne 2). Oluline on välja tuua baasinfo, pilootprojektid, planeeritud arendused, mis
vastavad jätkusuutlikkuse kriteeriumitele (fossiilkütuste tehnoloogiaid ei kirjeldata). Lisaks
kaardistatakse tehnoloogiate rakendamiseks vajalike seaduste muutmise vajadused.
Ülevaade tehnoloogiatest esitatakse alljärgnevalt:
- Tootmistehnoloogiad (nt soojuspumbad, geotermaalenergia, jääksoojus jne)
- Ülekandetehnoloogiad (nt madalatemperatuurne soojuskandija)
- Tarbimise tehnoloogiad (nt energiatõhusam soojussõlm)
- Salvestustehnoloogiad (nt sesoonne salvestus)
- Pilootprojektid ning arendused eelnevate tehnoloogiate kohta.
Primaarenergia kasutamine ja energiatõhusus on seotud ehitamiseks kasutatavate materjalide ja
tehnoloogiatega. Energiat tootvad seinad ja aknad, PV paneelide katustele paigaldamine ning
energiasäästlike hoonete ehitamine mõjutab hoonete energiabilanssi. Uuringus on vajalik
27
https://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/strategies/analysis/models_en
8
hinnata toodud arengute mõju hoonete energiabilansis (elektri osakaal). Tuuakse välja
eeldused ja üldised seosed kaugkütte ning -jahutuse, energiabilansi ja materjalide vahel.
Hoonete energiabilansi arvestuses võib tulevikus rolli mängida ka liikuvus (transport).
Elektriautode laadimistaristu, vesinikautode kasutamine jne, need on mõned näited, mis võiksid
olulist rolli energiabilansis omada. Aruandes esitatakse teoreetiline ülevaade, milline on
transpordi potentsiaalne osakaal süsinikneutraalses soojusmajanduse bilansis.
Uute võimaluste esile kerkimisega (energiapositiivsed majad, võrgus soojuse salvestamine,
energiaturgude integreerimine, aktiivsed tarbijad, jääksoojus, sesoonne salvestus jahutuse osas
jne) on vajalik analüüsida ülekande tehnoloogiate (soojusvõrk, jahutusvõrk) võimalikke uusi
funktsioone, mida seni ei ole rakendatud. Tarbimise juhtimise võimaluste rakendamine
sarnaselt elektri sektoriga ja seeläbi tipukoormuste vähendamine, võivad vähendada
investeeringute vajadusi nii võrkudesse kui ka tootmisvõimsustesse. Vähemalt üks
stsenaarium peab kesksele kohale seadma võrgu ja selle maksimaalse kasutuse
süsinikneutraalses soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses.
Iga stsenaarium peab kirjeldama tehnoloogiate arenguvajadusi (sh salvestustehnoloogiad),
energiaturgude integreerimise osa, mõju energiatõhususele, muutuseid seadusandluses,
majandusmudeleid, arvestama digitaliseerimise ning regionaalsete arengutrendidega, mis on
toodud strateegilistes alusdokumentides (p.1.3 toodud loetelu).
Loodud stsenaariumid esitletakse ülal mainitud (p.7.3) turuosaliste kaudu (eramaja, kortermaja
jne).
Loodavad stsenaariumid peavad olema erinevalt üles ehitatud, selgelt põhjendatud ning
vastama ka järgmistele küsimustele:
- Mis on süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses energia allikateks?
- Kas ning millega on võimalik biomassi tuleviku soojussüsteemis asendada?
- Millised tehnoloogiad tunduvad kõige jätkusuutlikumad, arvestades tervet tarneahelat?
- Milliseid muutusi on regulatsioonides vajalik teha, et saavutada süsinikneutraalsus?
- Milliseid tehnoloogiaid on vajalik täiendavalt arendada?
- Milliste meetmetega on võimalik suunata turuosalisi tarbimise juhtimist laiemalt
kasutama?
- Milline mõju on süsinikneutraalsel soojus- ning jahutusmajandusel energiatõhususele
võrreldes aastaga 2020?
- Milliste baasmõõdikutega on võimalik kirjeldada jätkusuutlikku soojus- ning
jahutusmajandust?
- Millised on peamised elemendid süsinikneutraalses soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses?
- Millised on kaugkütte võrgu funktsioonid jääksoojuse kasutamisel?
- Millistel alustel planeerida uusi kaugkütte piirkondasid?
- Kas ja mis tingimustel on mõistlik eraldada soojusvõrk tootmisest? Kummal juhul on
paremini lahendatud varustuskindlus?
- Kuidas suurendada soojus- ning jahutussektori positiivset koosmõju?
- Millistel tingimustel on jaotusvõrk oluline ja millised on tema funktsioonid?
- Milliseid tarbimisharjumuste muutused on vajalikud süsinikneutraalses soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduses?
- Milline stsenaarium aitab kõige paremini leevendada või ära hoida energiavaesust?
9
- Kuidas suurendada energiaturgude integreerimist ning kasulikkust süsinikneutraalses
soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses?
- Kuidas piiritleda lokaal- ja kaugkütet süsinikneutraalses soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduses?
- Milline on optimaalne kaugküttevõrgu suurus?
- Milline mõju võib olla ehitusmaterjalide (tehnoloogiatel) hoonete energiabilansis ning
kuidas see mõjutab võrguettevõtteid?
- Milline võib olla seos transpordivahendite taristu ja energiabilansi vahel ning kuidas see
mõjutab võrguettevõtteid?
Ülesanded:
- Prognooside koostamine soojuse ja jahutuse tootmisele, tarnimisele ja tarbimisele;
- Stsenaariumite detailne kirjeldamine;
- Eesti soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse projektsioonide loomine, kasutades sobilikku
modelleerimistarkvara;
- Exceli faili loomine vajalike tabelite, graafikute ja viidetega;
- Süsinikneutraalses soojus- ning jahutusmajanduses kasutatavate tehnoloogiate
arendamise vajaduste kaardistamine;
- Tehnoloogiate süsteemse definitsioonide loomine, vältimaks tehnoloogiate
ebakorrektset tõlgendust antud kontekstis;
- Tehnoloogia valmidustasemete (TVT) ülevaate loomine;
- Erinevate turuosaliste vaates süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse
kirjelduste loomine (eramaja, kortermaja, linnaosa, linn, tööstus);
- Konsultatsioonid erinevate huvigruppide/turuosalistega;
- Lokaalkütte ja kaugkütte võrdlus, mille tulemusena valmib sobilik otsustamise
maatriks;
- Süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse võimalike rollide ülevaade üldises
energiasüsteemis;
- Süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse peamiste parameetrite analüüs;
- Ülevaate koostamine ehitusmaterjalide ja transpordi taristu seostest hoone
energiabilansis;
- Looma ja esitlema vähemalt kolme (+PSJS) süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduse ülemineku stsenaariumit;
- Analüüsi esmane esitlus huvigruppidele/turuosalistele Eestis;
- Saadud tagasiside põhjal aruande täiendamine;
- Aruande koostamine
7.4. Vahearuanne 4: Sotsiaalmajandusliku mõju analüüs
Iga stsenaariumi kohta (lisaks PSJS stsenaarium), mis on loodud kolmandas vahearuandes
(Stsenaariumid süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse saavutamiseks aastaks 2050),
on vajalik koostada mõjude analüüs. Mõjude analüüside koostamisel kasutatakse uuringu
planeerimise etapis kokkulepitud metoodikat.
10
Loodud stsenaariumite mõjusid võrreldakse PSJS stsenaariumiga. Mõjude kirjeldamisel
võrreldakse sotsiaalmajanduslikke mõjusid, muutusi energiatõhususes, CO2 vähenemises,
lisaks on oluline eraldi välja tuua energia turvalisus, süsteemi stabiilsus ja varustuskindlus.
Mõjusid hinnatakse nii absoluutses kui suhtelises arvestuses. Mõjusid hinnatakse praeguste
suundumuste jätkamise stsenaariumiga (PSJS) ning esitletakse erinevatel tasanditel (otsene,
kaudne ja indutseeritud mõju) ning koosmõjuna.
Stsenaariumite (+PSJS) mõjude hindamise indikaatorid peavad sisalduma minimaalselt
järgmist:
- Sisemajanduse koguprodukt (SKP) jaotatuna põhikomponentideks;
- Muutused tööhõives;
- Muutused tööviljakuses (väljendatuna SKP muutus töötaja kohta);
- Majapidamiste brutosissetuleku muutused (energiahinna muutuste tõttu);
- Keskmine soojusenergia ning jahutuse hind (MWh) stsenaariumites;
- Muutused soojuseenergia ning jahutuse hindades kommertstarbijatele (eristatuna välja
tuua vähemalt: soojuse ning jahutuse hind (MWh)(müügihind), tasud ja maksud);
- Muutused soojuseenergia ning jahutuse hindades eratarbijatele (eristatuna välja tuua
vähemalt: soojuse ning jahutuse hind (MWh) (müügihind), tasud ja maksud);
- Muudatused kasvuhoonegaaside heitkogustes (KHG) tootmises, ülekandes ning
tarbimises;
- Muudatused riiklikes maksudes ja tuludes;
- Muutused energiatõhususes (sisaldades võrgukadusid);
- Muutused taastuvenergia tootmises ja kasutamises;
- Soojuse ning jahutuse tarbimist, jaotust ja tootmist;
- Mõjud elektrisüsteemile (suurenenud tarbimisvõimsus, jne).
Kõik kalkulatsioonid ja arvestused (kus on asjakohane) tuleb teha 2020 aasta hindadega
(reaalhindades). Kõiki koostatud stsenaariumeid on vajalik võrrelda praeguste suundumuste
jätkumise stsenaariumiga läbi toodud indikaatorite.
Sotsiaalmajandusliku kasu analüüs sisaldab vähemalt:
1. Otsesed mõjud - väljundiindikaatorid, mis iseloomustavad konkreetse tegevuse
eeldatavat vahetut tulemit (inglise keeles output), nt lisandväärtus, muutused tööhõives,
maksude laekumine, muutused kasvuhoonegaaside emissioonides, kulude ja tulude
muutused sihtrühmade lõikes (era- ja kommertstarbijad) jne;
2. Kaudsed mõjud - tulemusindikaatorid, mis näitavad taotletava tulemuse saavutamist
või saavutamise suunas liikumist (inglise keeles outcome). Need on näiteks otsesed
mõjud sihtrühmale, nt tarneahelate kaudu prognoositav lisandväärtus, tööjõuhõive
muutus, maksude laekumine, kaudsed mõjud sihtrühmade lõikes (era- ja
kommertstarbija) jne;
3. Indutseeritud mõjud - mõjuindikaatorid, mille abil on võimalik mõõta või hinnata
soovitud sotsiaalmajandusliku vm mõju (inglise keeles impact) saavutamist. Need
iseloomustavad tagajärgi väljaspool selle otsest ja kohest kokkupuudet adressaatide või
sihtrühmaga (nt mõju tarneahela firmade varustajatele või allhankijatele jne).
11
Ülesanded:
- Huvirühmadega konsultatsioonid;
- Mõjuanalüüside läbiviimine;
- Kõikide loodud stsenaariumide võrdlemine praeguste suundumuste jätkumise
stsenaariumiga (PSJS);
- Esialgsete tulemuste esitlemine huvirühmadele Eestis;
- Saadud tagasiside põhjal aruande täiendamine ning andmete edastamine muudetavas
Exceli failis, vajalike viidetega algallikatele.
7.5. Vahearuanne 5: Riskianalüüs
Uuringu teostaja viib läbi põhjaliku riskianalüüsi kõikidele kolmandas vahearuandes loodud
stsenaariumitele (Vahearuanne 3). Riskianalüüsid sisaldavad erinevate riskide (nt tehnoloogia,
mitte-minu-naabrusse (MMN), biomassi hinna tõus jne) kirjeldamist, nende esinemise
tõenäosust, riskide mõju ning välja toodud riskide maandamise võimalusi. Stsenaariumites aset
leidvate muutuste vastuvõtlikkust turuosaliste poolt on samuti vajalik käsitleda läbiviidavates
riskianalüüsides.
Ülesanded:
- Riskianalüüsi läbiviimine kolmandas vahearuandes loodud kõikidele stsenaariumitele;
- Stsenaariumite riskianalüüside võrdlus PSJS stsenaariumiga;
- Aruande koostamine, seotud Exceli tabelite esitamine koos viidetega.
7.6. Vahearuanne 6: Sensitiivsusanalüüs
Uuringu teostaja viib läbi sensitiivsusanalüüsid kõikidele kolmandas vahearuandes loodud
stsenaariumitele koostatud sotsiaalmajanduse mõju analüüsidele (Vahearuanne 4).
Sensitiivsusanalüüs viiakse läbi vähemalt järgmiste muutujate puhul: kütusehinnad,
soojusenergia ja tehnoloogia hind. Sensitiivsusanalüüs on meetod, mida kasutatakse selleks, et
määrata, kuidas sõltumatu muutuja erinevad väärtused mõjutavad sõltuvat muutujat antud
eelduste kogumi alusel. Sensitiivsusanalüüs põhineb asjakohasel metoodikal ning täiendab
neljanda vahearuande (sotsiaalmajandusliku mõju analüüs) tulemusi.
Ülesanded:
- Sensitiivsusanalüüside teostamine (3 stsenaariumit + PSJS);
- Sensitiivsusanalüüside võrdlus PSJS stsenaariumiga;
- Aruande koostamine, seotud Exceli tabelite esitamine koos viidetega;
- Aruande esitlemine huvipooltele;
- Aruande esitlemiselt saadud tagasiside põhjal aruande täiendamine;
- Aruande esitamine.
7.7. Vahearuanne 7: Süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse
ülemineku tegevusplaanid Eestis
Tegevusplaanid luuakse kõikidele kolmandas vahearuandes loodud stsenaariumitele
(vahearuanne 3). Koostatud tegevusplaanid peavad sisaldama terviklikku tegevuste
(muudatused seadusandluses, toetuste vajadus, tehnilised nõuded võrkude rajamiseks, uued
12
ärimudelid tootjatele ja tarbijatele (minimaalselt 3 mõlemale), digitaliseerimise arendamiseks
vajalikud sammud jne) ülevaadet, saavutamaks süsinikneutraalne soojus- ning jahutusmajandus
aastaks 2050. Praeguste suundumuste jätkamise stsenaariumi lähtekohaks on riiklik energia
kliimakava aastani 2030. Loodavad tegevusplaanid annavad sisu eelnevalt koostatud
stsenaariumitele, moodustades teekaardi edasiste tegevuste planeerimiseks. Tegevusplaanid
toovad selgelt välja vajalikud muudatused (nt seadusandluses) ning põhjendused
väljapakutavate muutuste elluviimiseks. Tegevusplaanid annavad ülevaate vajalikest
investeeringutest, et saavutada süsinikneutraalne soojus- ning jahutusmajandus Eestis aastaks
2050.
Ülesanded:
- Kolmandas vahearuandes loodud stsenaariumitele tegevusplaani loomine;
- Tegevusplaanides sisalduvate meetmete realiseerimise eeldatava maksumus ja
tasuvuse tuvastamine;
- Praeguste suundumuste jätkumise tegevusplaani võrdlus koostatud stsenaariumite
tegevusplaanidega;
- Omapoolsete soovitused esitamine sobilikuima teekaardi valimiseks;
- Loodud teekaartide põhjal arengut (keskkonna, sotsiaal-, majandus- ja regionaalset
arengut) toetavate soovituste esitamine loodud teekaartide põhjal;
- Eesti õigussüsteemi ja ühiskonda sobilike poliitikasoovituste esitamine;
- Täiendavate relevantsete soovituste pakkumine;
- Vahearuande koostamine, koondandmete edastamine muudetavas Exceli failis,
vajalike viidetega algallikatele;
- Esialgsete tulemuste esitlemine huvirühmadele Eestis;
- Saadud tagasiside põhjal aruande täiendamine;
- Aruande esitamine tellijale
7.8. Tulemus 8: Lõpparuanne
Lõpparuanne on terviklik dokument, mis koosneb eelnevalt loodud vahearuannetest
(vahearuanded 1-7). Aruanne (iga vahearuanne) peab olema lihtsasti loetav ja sisaldama
kontsentreeritud kokkuvõtet tulemustest iga peatüki juures. Sisu selgema edasi andmise
eesmärgil peab kasutama erinevaid lihtsustavaid visuaalseid tööriistu (nt graafikud, skeemid).
Oluline on, et vajalikud seosed, arengud ja mõjud selgelt välja tulevad.
Aruanne peab sisaldama vähemalt:
- Peamiste tulemuste kokkuvõtet;
- Ülevaadet uuringu vältel läbiviidud tegevustest;
- Kogetud väljakutsete ja nende lahenduste ülevaadet;
- Vajadusel täiendavaid ettepanekuid kuidas hinnata uuringu järgseid tegevusi
süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse arendamisel;
- Lihtsustavaid, illustreerivaid graafikuid, skeeme ja muid visuaalseid lihtsusi;
- Saadud kogemused ja soovitused edasiseks;
- 10-15 leheküljelist eestikeelset uuringu kokkuvõtet
Ülesanded:
13
- Aruande koostamine, koondandmete edastamine muudetavas Exceli failis, vajalike
viidetega algallikatele ja teistele seotud materjalidele;
- Aruande esitlemine huvirühmadele füüsilisel kohtumisel Tallinnas või
virtuaalsel platvormil.
- Aruande esitlemisel saadud tagasiside põhjal aruande täiendamine;
- Aruande esitamine tellijale.
8. Ajakava
Lõpparuande tähtajaks on 12 kuud alates lepingu sõlmimist. Eduka pakkuja ja hankija vahel
toimuvad kohtumised iga kahe nädala tagant, mille käigus annab edukas pakkuja ülevaate
teostatud töödest ning saavutatud vahetulemustest. Hankijal on õigus vajadusel edastada eduka
pakkuja töödele täiendavaid suuniseid. Aruannete üldine esitamiste tähtaeg on toodud allpool
näidisena.. Pakkuja peab koostama enda töökorraldust ja projektijuhtimist arvestava ajakava,
mis arvestab vahepealseid aruannete esitamise tähtaegasid kui ka lõpp-tähtaega.
Vahearuanded Periood
Vahearuanne 1: Uuringu planeerimine Lepingu sõlmimise
kuupäev +1päev +
0,5 kuud
Vahearuanne 2: Olemasoleva olukorra ülevaade Lepingu sõlmimise
kuupäev +1päev +
2 kuud
Vahearuanne 3: Stsenaariumid süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning Lepingu sõlmimise
jahutusmajanduse saavutamiseks aastaks 2050 kuupäev+1päev +
5 kuud
Vahearuanne 4: Sotsiaalmajandusliku mõju analüüs Lepingu sõlmimise
Vahearuanne 5: Riskianalüüs kuupäev +1päev +
Vahearuanne 6: Sensitiivsusanalüüs 7 kuud
Vahearuanne 7: Süsinikneutraalse soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse Lepingu sõlmimise
ülemineku tegevusplaanid Eestis kuupäev+1päev +
10 kuud
Lõpparuande esitlemine seotud osapooltele. Eeldatav kestvus Lepingu sõlmimise
maksimaalselt kaks tundi, millele lisandub küsimuste ja vastuste aeg. kuupäev+1päev +
Saadud tagasiside põhjal aruande täiendamine; 12 kuud
Lõpparuanne koos eestikeelse lühikokkuvõttega (p. 5)
9. Metoodika
Süsinikneutraalset soojus- ning jahutusmajandust kirjeldavad parameetrid on
jätkusuutlikkus, majanduslikult tasuvad ärimudelid, energiaturgude integratsioon,
energiatõhusus (koos tarbimise juhtimisega), varustuskindlus, energiavaesuse vältimine
ja digitaliseerimine (targad võrgud, kaugloendurid jne).
Nimetatud loetelu ei ole prioriteetsuse järjekorras vaid pigem tervikpilt, mis võimaldab otsuste
tegemisel erinevaid prioriteete seada. Töö teostaja pakub välja omapoolse nägemuse analüüsi
eesmärgi täitmise ning kõigile uurimisküsimustele põhjendatult vastamise metoodikast, millele
14
lisab omapoolsed võimalikud täiendused. Esitatud metoodika on üks
hindamiskriteeriumitest eduka pakkuja valimisel.
Käesolevas uuringus on soojus- ning jahutusmajanduse turuosalised jaotatud alljärgnevalt:
eramajad, kortermajad hajaasustuses, linnaosa, linn tervikuna ja tööstus. Analüüsis on vajalik
välja tuua turuosaliste erinev roll ning need selgelt defineerida. Süsinikneutraalsuse
saavutamiseks on rakendatavad strateegiad ja tehnoloogilised valikud turuosalistel erinevad.
Toodud eristus aitab poliitikakujundajatel kujundada vastavaid meetmeid ning teha vajalikke
otsuseid.
Uuringu läbiviimiseks pakutav metoodika peab arvestama kõiki vahearuannete
ülesannete ja toodud küsimuste lahendamisega.
10. Aruannete esitamine ja vastuvõtmine
Kõik koostatud aruanded esitatakse hankijale õigeaegselt vastavalt HD Lisa 1 p 8. toodud
ajagraafikule. Hankija tagasisidestab aruended 15 päeva jooksul aruande esitamisest. Kui
hankija ei ole selle aja jooksul tagasisidet andnud, loetakse aruanne vastuvõetuks.
Tagasiside põhjal täienduste osas peab uuringu läbiviija vastama 10 päeva jooksul,
adresseerides tehtud täiendusi ning teada andma täienduste lisamiseks kuluva aja osas.
11. Kohtumised
Regulaarsete kohtumiste ajakava lepitakse kokku lepingus. Kohtumiste planeerimisel tuleb
arvestada võimalike COVID-19 piirangutega, mis eeldab valmisolekut virtuaalseteks
kohtumiseks. Vastav ülevaade planeeritud kohtumiste ajakavast koos projektijuhtimisega
esitatakse koos pakkumisega.
Uuringu läbiviimise ajal planeeritakse vähemalt kaks füüsilist kohtumist hankijaga Eestis.
Võimalikke piiranguid arvesse võttes võivad kohtumised toimuda ka virtuaalselt.
Täiendava tagasiside saamiseks on pakkuja poolt oodatud rahvusvahelise ekspertide paneeli
kaasamist. Eksperdid peaksid tutvuma algaruande ja lõpparuandega. Ekspertide ülesandeks on
anda omapoolne sisend analüüsi läbiviimisele ja tulemustele. Kaasatud eksperdid ei tohi olla
otseses seoses pakkujaga ning peavad esindama erinevaid rahvusvahelisi soojus- ning
jahutusmajanduse valdkondasid. Ekspertidega kohtumiseks korraldab uuringu läbiviija kaks
kolmetunnist virtuaalkohtumist, millele lisandub küsimuste ja vastuste esitamine. Kõik kulud
seoses ekspertide ja nende kaasamisega peab sisalduma esitatud hinnapakkumises.
12. Autoriõigused
Analüüsi lõpparuanne koos kasutatud metoodikaga on teos autoriõiguse seaduse mõistes. Kõik
teosega seotud varalised autoriõigused kuuluvad hankijale pärast temapoolsete
lepingutingimuste täitmist. Hankijal, kes esindab riiki, on õigus teost kasutada viisil, mis toob
kaasa või võib kaasa tuua teose või selle osa avaldamise või selle osade olulises mahus
töötlemise (sh tõlkimine, kohandused, kokkuvõtted).
Kõik analüüsi käigus saadud, koostatud või kogutud andmed ning muud materjalid (nt
küsimustikud, joonised, juhendid, arvutustabelid, lisaandmed) kuuluvad hankijale. Kõik
15
autoriõigustega või muu intellektuaalomandiga seotud tasud sisalduvad esitatud pakkumuse
maksumuses.
16
Pilvero OÜ
Joint bid
Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and
cooling in Estonia by 2050
Public tender reference number: 234808
Authorized representative of joint tenderers: Stockholm Environment Institute Tallinn Centre
Contact person: Merlin Rehema
Email:
[email protected]
Reg No: 90000966
Address: Arsenal Centre, Erika 14, 10416 Tallinn, Estonia
Phone: +372 56654677
Partner: Trinomics B.V.
Contact person: Frank Gerard
E-post:
[email protected]
Reg code: 56028016
Address: Westersingel 34 3014 GS, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Phone: (+31) 010-341 45 92
Partner: Pilvero OÜ
Contact person: Ülo Kask
E-post:
[email protected]
Reg Code: 10076866
Address: Kulli 20, 13418 Tallinn, Estonia
Phone: +372-5532910
May 2021
Stockholm Environment Institute
Table of contents
Table of contents 2
1. Introduction to the proposed team 4
SEI ..................................................................................................................................................................4
Trinomics .......................................................................................................................................................5
OÜ Pilvero, Ülo Kask ......................................................................................................................................5
2. Understanding of the scope and challenges 7
Context of the assignment ............................................................................................................................7
Carbon-intensive Estonian heat production is susceptible to climate policy and must now transition
to a low carbon economy. 7
Objectives and impact ...................................................................................................................................8
3. Approach 9
Overview of approach ...................................................................................................................................9
Expert interviews...........................................................................................................................................9
Formulation of international expert panel..................................................................................................10
Workshops with national stakeholders .......................................................................................................12
Deliverables .................................................................................................................................................13
Deliverable 1: Inception report 13
Deliverable 2: Baseline data collection report 14
Deliverable 3: Report - Scenarios for reaching carbon neutral heating and cooling by 2050 16
Overview 16
2
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Stakeholder engagement 17
Modelling 18
Input 19
Calculation 19
Business as usual scenario 20
Development and analysis of additional climate-neutral pathways 20
Output 22
Stakeholder consultation 22
Report 22
Deliverable 4: Impact assessments 23
Deliverable 6: Sensitivity analysis 29
Deliverable 7: Action Plans for carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia 31
Deliverable 8: Final report 34
4. Project timeline and work plan 35
5. Cooperation with the Client 38
6. Organisational structure and team members 39
7. Possible risks and their mitigation 42
Annex I: Backgrounds of team members 45
Annex II: List of relevant reference projects 49
Bibliography 50
3
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
1. Introduction to the proposed team
This document is a joint bid prepared by Stockholm Environment Institute Tallinn Centre, Trinomics
and Pilvero OÜ for the tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”.
We participate in the procurement with a joint bid in order to offer the Client the best expertise and
form a strong team to perform the analysis. The field coincides with the previous experience and
priority themes of the co-tenderers. A more detailed overview of team members is given in Annex I,
relevant reference projects is given in Annex II and CVs of team members are included in the offer.
SEI
SEI Tallinn's field of activity is conducting environmental research, involving stakeholders and capacity
building in the Baltic Sea and European Union region. The SEI Tallinn Center shares and promotes SEI's
global know-how to promote sustainable development and resilience. The SEI Tallinn Climate and
Energy Program has a long history in the field of climate change mitigation and adaptation, energy
sector development plans, energy efficiency measures, energy modelling and scenario development.
The Centre's experts have extensive experience of participating in Interreg BSR, Horizon 2020, EEA and
Norway Grants, as well as other international and national projects. In 2019, an analysis of Estonia's
climate ambition until 2050 was carried out, after which the Estonian Government decided to support
the European vision to achieve climate neutrality by 2050. In addition, SEI Tallinn, Civitta and the
Institute of Chemical and Biological Physics recently performed a national tender regarding the
hydrogen potential for Estonia by 2050 and in addition, SEI Tallinn, as a joint tenderer, is conducting a
study of the Estonian energy sector with TRINOMICS B.V. on behalf of the European Commission. The
list of most recent and relevant projects for this particular bid include:
● Transitioning to a climate-neutral electricity generation, (Trinomics, SEI Tallinn, E3
modelling, 2020-2021)
● X-Road Emissions Calculator Project (Nordic Institute for Interoperability Solutions)
(Gofore, SEI Tallinn, 2021)
● Analysis of the deployment of Estonian hydrogen resources (Estonian Ministry of Economic
Affairs and Communications, 2020-2021)(SEI Tallinn, Civitta, KBFI, 2021)
● Analysis on reaching climate neutrality in Estonia by 2050 (Estonian Ministry of Economic
Affairs and Communications, 2019);( Meeliste, Siim; Tammiste, Lauri; Grünvald, Olavi;
Kirsimaa, Kerli; Suik, Karina; Org, Madis, 2019, SEI Tallinn)
● ENLARGE, Energies for Local Administrations: Renovate Governance in Europe
(Horizon2020, 2016-2017)(Peterson et al., 2018)
● Does Estonia fulfil the Paris Agreement? (Estonian Council of Environmental NGOs,
2018);(Kirsimaa & Peterson, 2018, SEI Tallinn)
● Nordic Green to Scale for countries. Unlocking the potential of climate solutions in the
Baltics, Poland and Ukraine (Nordic Council of Ministers, 2018);( Tammiste, L.; Poltimäe, H.;
Kuldna, P.; Kallaste, T.; Kirsimaa, K.; Grünvald, O.; Kuusk, K., 2018, SEI Tallinn)
● CAMS, Climate Adaptation and Mitigation Synergies in Energy Efficiency Projects (Interreg
BSR, 2019-2022)(SEI Tallinn, s.a.-a)
● BONUS Coherent policies and governance of the Baltic Sea Go4Baltic (SEI Tallinn)(Peterson
et al., s.a.)
● Realising ecological tax reform in Estonia (SEI Tallinn)(Poltimäe & Peterson, 2018)
4
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Trinomics
Trinomics offers extensive project management in large assignments for a wide variety of public
clients, including many projects for DG ENER as well as other DGs and Commission Services. Our expert
consultants have a strong knowledge of energy markets, energy infrastructure and carriers, the
decarbonisation of the energy system, and heating and cooling decarbonisation pathways and
solutions. They also have a thorough understanding of energy and climate policies affecting the
decarbonisation of the heating and cooling sector and the importance of a fair and cost-effective
pathway for decarbonisation.
Trinomics has extensive expertise in conducting energy and climate policy studies at EU and national
levels, and analysing long-term decarbonisation strategies, especially in the field renewable
technologies and gases, including hydrogen and biomethane, and a strong track-record analysing
barriers and constraints related to decarbonisation pathways. The team also offers an international
stakeholder network, including industry experts, energy actors, regulators and authorities.
Trinomics is currently conducting the aforementioned study on decarbonising the Estonian electricity
sector jointly with SEI. Other relevant projects recently completed by Trinomics include:
● Policy Support for Heating and Cooling Decarbonisation (European Commission, DG ENER,
2019-2021)
● Technical support for RES policy development and implementation: delivering on an increased
ambition through energy system integration (European Commission, DG ENER, 2020-2021)
● Study on Opportunities arising from the inclusion of Hydrogen Energy Technologies in the
National Energy & Climate Plans (ENER, 2019-2020)
● Technical support for RES policy development and implementation: delivering on an increased
ambition through energy system integration (ENER, 2020-2021)
● Study on energy prices, costs and their impact on industry and households (European
Commission, DG ENER, 2020)
● Impact of the use of the biomethane and of the hydrogen potential on trans-European
infrastructure (European Commission, DG ENER, 2018-2019)
● Technical assistance for policy development and implementation on buildings policy and
renovation - support for the ex-ante impact assessment and revision of Directive 2010/31/EU
on energy performance of buildings (European Commission, DG ENER, 2021)
OÜ Pilvero, Ülo Kask
Ülo obtained a technical higher education (diploma in thermal energy engineering) at the Tallinn
Polytechnic Institute, a master's degree from Tallinn University of Technology and at the same time
completed his doctoral studies. For 40 years he has worked at Tallinn University of Technology and its
predecessor TPI. In addition, he has 29 years of work experience in the private consulting business. Thanks
to the mentioned education and work experience, Ülo is also extremely well acquainted with what is
happening in the field of energy economy and energy education in the country. Having been the initiator
of several foreign projects (INTERREG, IEE) and national projects (EIC, Enterprise Estonia, companies) and
participated in many HORIZON2020 and INTERREG BSR program projects.
5
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Ülo has enough organizational skills and can successfully lead a team and play the role of an expert in a
team. His work so far has given him an extensive experience in the field of district heating and cooling. He
has prepared more than 30 development plans for district heating areas and other research and
development work in this field. He has all the necessary computer and language skills, being able to not
work only in Estonian, but being also fluent in English, Finnish and Russian. In addition, he has
continuously developed his knowledge and skills at annual seminars, conferences and trainings.
His most relevant projects related to this specific tender include:
● Heat Economy Development Plans (SMAK)
● Development of the conditions of the tender for the purchase of peak heat production
capacity in the Tallinn district heating network
● Taltech Contract 14137 Development and testing of a comprehensive district heating area
energy audit methodology in the framework of the "Smart Heat" project,
● Taltech Contract 15081 - Definition and nature of parallel heat consumption (advantages,
disadvantages, accompanying problems)
● Economic feasibility analysis of district heating network investments made by AS Esro in the
Viljandi and Jämejala network area
● Tartu Energy and Climate Plan 2030
● Possibilities of using exhaust heat and exhaust cooling energy in the heating or cooling energy
sector and assessing the potential of efficient district heating and cooling in Estonia”
● Training plan “Energy management planning. Urban district heating system development
plans "
● Training of local government specialists "Design and construction of energy efficient buildings"
within the framework of the Interreg Project SaveSmart
We hereby confirm that this offer is valid for 90 calendar days from the submission of the offer date.
We hereby confirm the takeover of all the conditions set out in the procurement document by
submitting the offer.
We hereby confirm that the tenderer can ensure the participation of experts meeting the
requirements provided in the procurement documentation throughout the whole contract period.
6
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
2. Understanding of the scope and challenges
Context of the assignment
Carbon-intensive Estonian heat production is susceptible to climate policy and must now transition
to a low carbon economy.
Renewable energy covers 51.6% of Estonia’s heat consumption, with over 95% coming from bioenergy
and 4.6% covered by heat pumps using renewable energy. In 2017, the share of renewables in heat
exceeded Estonia’s 2020 target of 38.4%, but significant progress is still needed to reach the 2030
target of 80% renewables in heat consumption1. In 2019, approximately 65% (4,450 GWh) of the total
heat demand was covered by district heating. Most common fuels in district heating are biomass 51.5%
and natural gas 21.2%2. Rest of the district heating is fuelled by Oil shale, peat and Retort gas. Local
heating is mostly fuelled by wood (around 44%), while heat pump, natural gas and other sources
account for 34%, 15% and 7% respectively3. The Estonian heating sector thus is still reliant on fossil
fuels (Oil shale and natural gas).
The increasing influence of EU climate and energy policy and Green Deal agenda ((Green Deal;
Powering a climate-neutral economy: An EU Strategy for Energy System Integration; A Renovation
Wave for Europe – greening our buildings, creating jobs, improving lives) within the last five years),
coupled with the release of several reports such as by SEI (releasing Estonia’s first costed climate
neutrality scenario) and the IEA’s sector assessment, encourage Estonia’s Prime Minister to commit to
support the European Climate neutrality target by 2050. The retrospective studies have concluded that
though Estonia has made good progress to increase the share of renewables, it is not on track to
achieve its ambitious 2050 targets. In addition, the new Governance Regulation (EU) 2018/19994
supports the attainment of the energy and climate policy objectives of the EU by setting out the
process for the Member States to prepare their Long-term Strategies, thus establishing a planning,
reporting and monitoring system for the achievement of these objectives.
Considering the political influence and losing market share of the oil shale sector, a just transition
approach will need to be considered in forthcoming decarbonisation strategies. The need to increase
the share of domestic fuels is important in heating, as the price of natural gas fluctuates and is supplied
mainly from Russia, which is a risk in terms of geopolitical security. It is therefore necessary to analyse
our current heating and cooling pathway to mobilize a smooth transition towards climate neutrality
by 2050.
1
https://www.connaissancedesenergies.org/sites/default/files/pdf-actualites/Estonia_2019_Review.pdf
2
https://mkm.ee/en/objectives-activities/energy-sector/heating-sector
3
http://www.taastuvenergeetika.ee/taastuvenergia-aastaraamat-2019/
4
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-
content/EN/TXT/?toc=OJ:L:2018:328:TOC&uri=uriserv:OJ.L_.2018.328.01.0001.01.ENG
7
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Objectives and impact
The objective of this study is to identify possible scenarios that would help to achieve carbon neutral
heating and cooling sector in Estonia by 2050. The analysis will consider at least three different
scenarios, compared with BAU scenario towards carbon neutral heating and cooling sector and will be
accompanied with socio-economic impact assessments and action plans for each scenario to support
in deciding the pathway. Relevant solutions and technologies considered in the scenarios will take into
account the Estonian climate conditions, the existing infrastructure and energy efficiency measures
that the heating and cooling sector can effectively implement.
Specific activities of the study will include:
1. Baseline collection of data describing the current situation of the Estonian heating sector
and potential technologies that can be used for climate-neutral heat generation.
2. Development and modelling of several potential pathways toward climate-neutral heat
production. National authorities will be provided with a user-friendly tool that will allow
them to use and run those different scenarios by varying criteria to develop possible
pathways and support decision makers to develop their own vision for carbon neutral
heating and cooling sector in Estonia by 2050.
3. Socio-economic impact assessment on direct, indirect and induced effects of each pathway.
4. Thorough risk analysis on potential acceptance of the actions required to achieve each
pathway.
5. Sensitivity analyses to determine how fluctuation in prices impact pathway modelling
results.
6. Detailing of action plans with proposed measures to achieve each decarbonisation
pathway.
The results of these activities will be synthesized in a final report and training materials that will
provide Estonian officials a clear understanding of the benefits associated with different pathways to
heating and cooling decarbonisation, and an evidence base for future policy recommendations to scale
Estonia’s low carbon transition. Moreover, the project will develop a transparent, updatable dataset
and modelling framework, as well as cohort of networked local expertise that are able to create new
scenarios and test arising needs from future industry and policy ideation process.
8
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
3. Approach
Overview of approach
The overall project consists of 7 deliverables that will form three main outcomes (figure 1). The
common methodologies used to fulfil the aims of most of the deliverables is literature review and
expert interviews. All mid-term results will be verified by 2 international expert panel meetings and 3
workshops with relevant national stakeholders.
The more detailed methodologies to be used under each deliverable are explained in the text below.
Figure 1. Overview of the project deliverables
Expert interviews
When analysing the heating and cooling sector in Estonia and its potential to become carbon neutral
by 2050, it is enriched by interviews with relevant national experts. The interviews focus on improving
the understanding and contextualization of the results of the literature review so that they correspond
to Estonian conditions and deepen the understanding of the best practices and strategies used in
different countries. Interviews are conducted in the format of expert interviews. Representatives of
relevant ministries and agencies in Estonia, representatives of research institutions and entrepreneurs
who have been exposed to heating and cooling research and business ideas, representatives of clusters
and associations are elected as interviewers. The final list of experts to be interviewed will be agreed
with the contracting authority (maximum 10), however the following interviewees are suggested to be
approached:
● Estonian Power and Heating Association (EPHA).
9
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
District heating companies:
● Utilitas Tallinn AS and Utilitas Eesti AS
● Fortum Eesti AS and Fortum Tartu AS
● Adven Eesti AS
● Eesti Energia AS (Enefit and Enefit Green)
● Elering AS
Public authorities
● Ministry of Economy and Communications Affairs, Energy department
● Competition Authority (Ministry of Justice)
● Environmental Investment Center (Ministry of the Environment)
Universities
● Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech), Institute of Energy Technology
● Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech), Institute of Energy Technology (Institute of
Electrical Power Engineering and Mechatronics).
Formulation of international expert panel
In order to obtain guiding and helpful input from experts throughout the study, the Tenderer convenes
a panel of international experts who would advise the Tenderer throughout the project including
setting the focus of the analysis, interpreting the results and developing conclusions. The advantage
of such an expert panel is that the experts are permanently involved in the project, aware of the
intermediate results and motivated to contribute to the achievement of the substantive results of the
project. Two online meetings will be organized by the lead partner of this study (SEI Tallinn) where
these experts can provide their feedback and verifications. In addition, these experts are willing to
consult the project team throughout the study also via e-mail in an ad hoc manner if required.
The panel of experts consists of three paid international experts. In order to use the widest possible
range of experiences and practices, the tenderer has selected a panel of experts from different
backgrounds, whose knowledge and competencies are complementary. In the tender submission
phase, we have received confirmation of participation in the expert panel from the following experts,
from whom the final composition of the panel will be determined in cooperation with the Client at the
beginning of the project.
10
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Expert Background (the CVs of all experts have been attached to this proposal)
Henrik Lund is a Danish engineer and professor at Aalborg University. His
research competencies, among many others, include Energy System
Analysis: Methods and models for the design and the evaluation of
technical and environmental consequences of energy systems with
emphasis on integrated distributed generation technologies such as energy
conservation, CHP and renewable energy. In 1990 he finished his PhD and
Henrik Lund is a Full Professor since 2006. As of October 2017 his h-index is 43 (Web of
Science) respectively 47 (Scopus) and is a member of The Danish Academy
of Technical Sciences. He is listed among ISI Highly Cited researchers and is
the editor-in-chief of scientific journal Energy, ranking 12th out of 89
journals in "Energy & Fuels" according to the Journal Citation Reports.
Link to CV: https://www.en.plan.aau.dk/henriklund/cv/
Brian Vad Mathiesen, Professor in Energy Planning and Renewable
Energy Systems at Aalborg University, holds a PhD in fuel cells and
electrolysers in future energy systems (2008). His research focuses on
technological and socioeconomic transitions to renewables, energy
storage, large-scale renewable energy integration and the design of
100% renewable energy systems. He is one of the leading researchers
behind the concepts of Smart Energy Systems and electrofuels. He is
on the Clarivate, Web of Science Highly Cited list (2015-2020), thus
among the top 1% most cited researchers globally. Among other
positions, he is member of the EU Commission expert group on
electricity interconnection targets in the EU and The newly founded
Science Advice for Policy by European Academies (SAPEA) Expert
Group on A Systemic Approach For the Energy Transition In Europe. He
Brian Vad is the Research Coordinator of the Sustainable Energy Planning
Mathiesen Research group, Principal Investigator (PI) of the RE-INVEST and
sEEnergies projects, and Program Director for the MSc in Sustainable
Cities. He has been PI, work package leader and participant in more
than 60 research projects as well as editorial board member of The
Journal of Energy Storage (Elsevier) and The Journal of Sustainable
Development of Energy, Water & Environment Systems; Associate
Editor of Energy, Ecology and Environment (Springer) and Editor of the
International Journal of Sustainable Energy Planning and
Management. Recently he started the new Elsevier Journal Smart
Energy. Furthermore, he is a member of The Danish Academy of
Technical Sciences (ATV) and a board member at The Danish Energy
Technology Development and Demonstration Program (EUDP).
Link to CV: https://www.en.plan.aau.dk/brianvad/cv/
Thomas Nowak is an expert on heating and electricity.
Thomas Nowak
11
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
In 2006, Thomas Nowak was appointed as the Secretary General of the
European Heat Pump Association (EHPA). His role in Brussels involves
promoting heat pump technology as a viable and efficient tool for the
future, by producing reports with key data as well as representing the
industry to the European institutions and stakeholders.
As an expert in the industry, Thomas has presented his research in
articles and conferences in international and European conferences.
They have largely been about the integration of heat pumps in the
energy market. Moreover, he has contributed to the IEA energy
technology perspectives and the REN21 Renewables Global Status
Report.
Thomas holds a degree in business administration and economics from
Paderborn University.
Link to his profile: https://www.linkedin.com/in/thomas-nowak-
ab735511/?originalSubdomain=be
Table 1. Overview of the expert panel and their background
Workshops with national stakeholders
To verify the results of the study, three national workshops with national experts are foreseen by the
Tenderer throughout the study, in addition to international expert panel meetings. The aim of those
workshops is to verify and test the mid-term results together with the national stakeholders. The
stakeholders to be invited to those verification workshops mostly overlap with the same experts that
will be interviewed under the expert interviews. The difference between the expert interviews and the
national workshops is that during the expert interviews the Tenderer expects to receive input from the
interviewed experts in terms of data and strategic questions to be asked, while the workshops aim to
verify the results of the project tasks of the Tenderer themselves.
12
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Deliverables
Our methodology for each deliverable is described in detail in the following sections. The duration
for each deliverable is summarised in the work plan attached separately to this proposal document.
Deliverable 1: Inception report
Deliverable 1: Inception report
To provide a common understanding among the parties (the
Aim Client and relevant key stakeholders ) on the implementation
approach of the project
Kick-off meeting (KOM) with all relevant parties
An agreed scope, methodology and finalisation of the detailed
Results
workplan
Establishing good working relations with the Client
KoM minutes with a list of agreed-on follow-up activities
Inception report with:
1. Presentation of assumptions and proposed methodologies
2. List of data and information required from the Ministry
3. List of relevant stakeholders to the project
Outputs 4. Timeline
5. Communication protocol
6. A short proposal of indicators that can be monitored during
implementation
7. Proposal of necessary modelling tool to be use throughout the
analysis
Table 2. Deliverable 1 description
To start the project, we will prepare and organise a kick-off meeting (KoM) with the full project team,
the Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, and other nominated key
stakeholders. The KoM will achieve the following:
● Introducing core team members to the Estonian Ministry of Economics and Communication
and key stakeholders;
● Clarifying open questions based on the submitted proposal.
● Aligning our view on all deliverables.
● Discussing the project planning, reporting, monitoring and communication of results, including
timeline, QA, progress expectations and their measurements based on key performance
indicators (KPIs) and preferred communication methods with the Client, proposing the
suitable modelling tool to be used.
13
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
● Determining local stakeholder engagement activities and preferences, including nominating a
steering committee that will be consulted throughout the project and during the pathway
development process.
Deliverable 2: Baseline data collection report
Deliverable 2: Baseline data collection report
Analyse and interpret collected data on the Estonian heating
Aim and cooling sector and on potential decarbonisation
technologies of last 5 years
Prepared comprehensive database that can be used for
Results
pathway modelling in Task 3
Relevant data describing the heating and cooling situation in
Estonia
Relevant data describing known and probable future changes in
the heat consumption in Estonia
Outputs Relevant data on potential technologies that can be used for
climate-neutral heat generation within 2-4 years and within 5
years or longer
Report and supporting Excel files with references to sources
used
Table 3. Deliverable 2 task description
The methodologies used to compile Deliverable 2 includes data collection, literature review, expert
interviews with relevant stakeholders in the field. The specific tasks to be achieved include:
Collecting the relevant data, of the last 5 years, describing the current situation of heating and cooling
market (generation, consumption, prices, fuels, etc.) in Estonia.
Collecting the relevant data to be used to describe BAU scenario on the known and probable future
changes in the heating and cooling market in Estonia (including National Energy and Climate Plan (NECP),
legislation, technology integrations solutions, etc.).
Collecting the relevant data on potential technologies that can be used to achieve carbon neutral heating
and cooling in Estonia within 5 years or longer up to 2050, at the Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs)
enabling actual use of such technologies for production, storage, demand/response, rather than just pilot
projects - TRL overview of technologies.
Collecting the relevant data for comparison of scenarios based on socioeconomic and environmental
indicators as well as risk and sensitivity analysis:
14
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
- Experience, results and summaries of previous projects will be used (e.g., All development
works in the field of district heating in the last 5 years, in the preparation of which Ülo Kask
has participated, articles and research on district heating completed at TUT, now TalTech).
- The feasibility and cost of the technologies are assessed by field experts or, in their absence,
by international organizations (IEA, IRENA, etc.) or peer reviewed articles.
The report will analyse and interpret the collected data and technology mapping possible to implement
to achieve carbon neutral heating and cooling by 2050. The report will include data excel tables with
references to sources used. The Excel table will be used for pathways modelling under Deliverable 3.
Assumptions and overall connections between district heating, energy balance and buildings are
delivered through this analysis. The following topics will be covered in more detail:
- Description of technology developments need to be implemented in carbon neutral heating and cooling
in Estonia.
- One systematic definition approach for technologies in TRL overview (to avoid inaccurate interpretations
in given context).
- Description of a carbon neutral heating and cooling for different market participants: single house,
apartment buildings, city district, city, industry.
Overview of the technologies will be presented in categories:
- Production technologies (Heat pumps, geothermal energy, industry and waste heat etc).
- Heat carrier technologies (e.g., low temperature carrier).
- Consumer technologies (e.g., energy efficient heat exchangers).
- Storage technologies (e.g., seasonal storage).
- Pilot and development projects overview in each category (a - d).
A technology overview through technology readiness levels and their possible developments are
described (including investment cost scenarios), to provide scenarios with relevant input. This additional
overview will provide the development needs of these technologies through existing base research, pilots
and planned developments, considering sustainability criteria. Additional view on the possible legislative
barriers and improvements for these technologies is a part of this overview.
15
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Deliverable 3: Report - Scenarios for reaching carbon neutral heating and cooling by 2050
Deliverable 3: Report – Scenarios for reaching carbon neutral heating and cooling by 2050
Define and analyze potential pathways to climate-neutral
heating and cooling in Estonia
Analyze at minimum pathways 3 possible scenarios (+ business
Aims
as usual (BAU))
Provide inputs to subsequent project tasks, notably Deliverables
4-7
Heat consumption forecast
Definition and key modelling outputs for pathways
Excel files with graphs and references to sources used
Results Presentation on preliminary results of analysis
Consultations with relevant stakeholders
Report on development of pathways for reaching climate-
neutral heat generation
Stakeholder consultations to frame Deliverable 3 analysis
Construction and calibration of business-as-usual pathway for
heating and cooling in Estonia
Development and analysis of additional climate-neutral
Outputs
pathways
Stakeholder consultations to gather feedback on preliminary
results of analysis
Deliverable 3 report and collected inputs for subsequent tasks
Table 4. Deliverable 3 description
Overview
The principal objective of Deliverable 3 is to define and analyse potential pathways to climate-neutral
heating and cooling in Estonia. The analysis must include at least 4 pathways including BAU. Through
our analytical process, we will identify pathways to climate-neutral heat production: planning
decisions that fulfil Estonia’s policy objectives in a wide variety of possible futures.
16
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Figure 2. Overview of developing Scenarios for reaching carbon neutral heating and cooling by 2050
Stakeholder engagement
We will begin Deliverable 3 with stakeholder consultations to define essential terms of the pathway
analysis. The consultations will involve industry experts in Estonia. Figure 3 exhibits the 4 key points
that are planned to be identified and confirmed from the stakeholders.
Figure 3. Main points of discussion with stakeholders
• Planning options to represent in the heating and cooling model: These represent potential choices
that are within planners’ control and should be simulated in the model. They will include heat demand
of buildings & industry at local/district level, heat supply from existing heat generation mix
(renewables & fossil fuels), existing infrastructure, potential renewable capacity deployment for heat
production and different measures for improving heat consumption (e.g., energy efficiency).
17
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
• Critical uncertainties: These are future factors that are outside planners’ control but that could
significantly affect the evolution of the Estonian heating system. Examples include changes in
population and fuel prices, gross domestic product, the cost of power technologies, import prices,
renewable resource potential, equipment contingencies, and the completion date for proposed large
power-sector projects. For each critical uncertainty, we will define a range and distribution of possible
future values.
• Pathway definitions: We will confirm the technologies allowed in each carbon-neutral pathway as
well as any enabling policies or other factors that should be assumed to be in place. We anticipate
analysing four pathways, but we will explore the need for additional pathways with stakeholders. We
propose that pathway 1 (business-as-usual [BAU]) allow all technologies that are currently
commercialized or are expected to become commercialized within 2-4 years, while the rest of the
pathways will include all technologies that may be commercialized during the study period (through
2050). This approach will illuminate the most cost-effective path to carbon neutrality but distinguish
between readily available and more speculative technologies.
• Planning metrics: These are outputs from the heating and cooling model that indicate how well
planning objectives are met. Examples include heating system costs, level of energy imports or
independence, and cumulative GHG emissions.
Technology, policy, and other data collected under Deliverable 2 will inform the selection of these
factors, and the inputs gathered from stakeholders will help structure subsequent modelling and
analysis. We will configure the heating and cooling model to represent the planning options, critical
uncertainties, pathways, and metrics.
Modelling
Taking retrospective experience and knowledge, and following stakeholder consultations, we will
construct a BAU pathway in our heating and cooling model. The model will be built using MS Excel, to
provide versatility, high level of transparency and the ability for different stakeholders to use the excel
model as a crucial tool for policy measures. The modelling approach is exhibited by Figure 4.
18
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Figure 4. Modelling methodology (using MS Excel)
Input
The model will use values of the existing situation in Estonia. It will consider the total heat demand
from industry, commercial and residential buildings. The source of heat consumed in each sector will
be distinguished accordingly (local/district, renewable/non-renewable etc.). The current heat
production from different sources will also be mapped to quantify the exact share of heat
consumption. Desk research, advent of different technologies in Estonia, renewable energy potential
and potential introduction of other energy carriers (e.g., Hydrogen) in Estonia will form the building
blocks of the simulated scenarios. Primarily, data collection from deliverable 2 will form the stark basis
as input for the model.
Calculation
The model will be built using MS Excel and will provide high flexibility to include any kind of suitable
scenarios. The tool can later be used by the Client to independently run scenarios and obtain outputs
for a range of different possibilities. The calculation model will simulate heat demand, generation and
distribution up to 2050 from different heating and cooling pathways. Simulations will be carried out
through multiple methods (engineering equations, econometric relationships simple linear regression
and more). The calculation model will include a pool of different renewable energy technologies (such
as wind, PV, biomass, geothermal, green-hydrogen), can use different demand-side measures (such as
energy-efficiency in buildings, energy efficient consumer technologies, fuel-cell based micro-combine
heat and power (CHPs) etc) and different pathways (district/local).
19
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Business as usual scenario
For this project, we will model heat demand up till 2050 by Key attributes of BAU
using simple linear regression based on historic data and pathway:
stakeholder input. The intent of the BAU pathway is to Existing climate and
provide a reference case projection for the Estonian heating energy policies
system. We will work with stakeholders to define the precise Validated with past
assumptions the BAU should make. The model will studies
represent a full suite of technologies that may be used to Reference case
decarbonize the Estonian heating system: centralized solar projections
PV, onshore and offshore wind, biomass, shale oil with CCS
and/or CCU, hydrogen use, and fuel cells. As noted above,
allowable future technologies will be confirmed with
stakeholders, and we propose that the BAU pathway will focus on technologies that are
already commercialized or nearly so. In addition to a restriction on technologies at a lower
readiness level, we propose that the BAU pathway should be based on central estimates for
the project’s critical uncertainties, and it should account for existing climate and energy
policies that affect Estonia’s heating sector. Such policies include GHG emissions, renewable
energy, and energy independence targets in Estonia’s National Development Plan of the
Energy Sector until 2030, General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050, and National Energy
and Climate Plan. All data required for the demand modelling will be gathered in Deliverable
2. The BAU pathway will also be validated by the projection of future demand and supply by
comparison to past studies such as the Baltic Energy Technology Scenarios,(Lindroos et al.,
2018) Nordic Energy Technology Perspectives,(OECD/IEA & Nordic Energy Research, 2016) and
other referenced resources.
Development and analysis of additional climate-neutral
Key attributes of pathways
additional scenarios: According to the EU 2030 climate and energy framework, the
Consists of different key targets include at least 32% share of renewable energy in
heat production methods the final energy demand (FED) and at least 32.5%
Will consider the most improvement in energy efficiency.5 Based on the current
suitable mix policies, the final energy demand (FED) for heating and
cooling (H/C) in the EU 28 in all decreases by around 7% from
6,350 TWh in 2012 to 5,930 TWh in 2030. The decrease is
mainly driven by thermal efficiency measures in buildings and
by higher average outdoor temperatures. The use of
renewable energy sources in final energy mix increases by
38% by 2030 compared to 2012, reaching a total of 1,093 TWh, whereas the direct use of fossil
fuels reduces by 15%6.
So, the current policies results in the final H/C energy mix that will be based on 8% coal, 9%
district heating, 11% electricity, 8% fuel oil, 0% geothermal, 41% natural gas, 2% solar energy,
5
https://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/strategies/2030_en
6
https://irees.de/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Scenarios-for-heating-cooling-demand-and-supply.pdf
20
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
and 3% on other fossil fuels. Although the use of natural gas decreases by 7% until 2030, it still
remains by far the important final energy carrier (41% of the final energy supply for H/C).7
In addition to BAU, three other scenarios will be developed to present different options for
climate neutral heating and cooling by 2050. The scenarios will mainly be distinguished by the
technologies that will be used in the heat production. Renewable heating and cooling are vital
to decarbonisation. A shift towards innovative and efficient technologies (including heat
pumps and micro-CHPs) and renewable energy (e.g., geothermal/solar heating and storage),
including through district heating systems, is needed. The three “possible scenarios” in
comparison to BAU are following:
Possible Scenarios Scenario description
Local heating: Direct electrification (heat pumps) + limited
bioenergy
District heating & cooling: renewable-based (mainly
Scenario 1 geothermal, heat pumps and solar heat)
Push towards local heating technology through
electrification, and complement with DHC (mainly
electrified) in urban areas
District heating & cooling: renewable-based (geothermal,
solar heat, hydrogen & other RFNBOs CHP & boilers)
Local heating: heat pumps + limited renewable gases
Scenario 2
(biomethane) and solid fuels (bio-energies)
Push towards district heating & cooling (all resources
except bio-energies), and complement with local heating
District heating & cooling: renewable-based (mainly based
on bio-energies, with limited use of RFNBOs)
Local heating: solid & gaseous bio energies boilers + heat
Scenario 3
pumps
Push towards bio-energies, both for local and district
heating systems
Table 5. Possible scenarios and their description
7
https://irees.de/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Scenarios-for-heating-cooling-demand-and-supply.pdf
21
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
The suggested scenarios in table 5 are indicative in nature. The exact penetration of each technology
and share of local and district heating will be decided in consultation with expert interviews and the
client to reach the most realistic numbers.
Output
The output of the modelling exercise will present with the following range of outputs for each
pathway:
Capacity for generators and storage
Consumption of input fuels for heat generation
Heat generation from different sources
Fuel costs (Levelized costing of heating (LCOH))
Capex investment & Opex towards each technology
Emissions of GHGs and other air pollutants from heat supply
Stakeholder consultation
For stakeholder consultation, we will prepare a presentation that summarizes key results and
highlights areas where confirmation and other inputs are needed. The presentation will be delivered
in one or more stakeholder meetings. At the meetings, we will share the presentation, supporting Excel
files and visualizations. Major sources will be noted in the presentation and Excel files; full
documentation of all sources will be provided in the model itself.
Report
After consulting stakeholders, we will use their feedback to finalize the pathways modelling and
analysis. The results will be documented in a Deliverable 3 report covering:
Robust decision-making approach
Stakeholder consultations and inputs
Model design and modelling methods
Definition and results of all pathways
Along with the report, we will deliver updated supporting Excel files and visualizations. We will also
use the Deliverable 3 model to prepare inputs required for later tasks. These are discussed further
below.
22
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Deliverable 4: Impact assessments
Deliverable 4: Report on socioeconomic impact assessments for decarbonization pathways
Aim To conduct a socio-economic impact assessment considering the impacts of all
defined pathways within Estonia
Results Analysis on the direct, indirect and induced impacts for several market
participants in both absolute and comparative terms
Outputs Socio-economic impact assessments comparing each pathway with the “business
as usual” pathway;
Presentations to relevant stakeholders in Estonia on draft impact assessment
results
Final draft of the analysis, with comments from stakeholders incorporated and
including supporting excel files with references to sources used
Table 6. Deliverable 4 description
To comprehensively understand the expected effects of modelled pathways towards climate neutral
heating and cooling by 2050, a detailed socio-economic impact assessment will be conducted based on
the results of Deliverable 3. Figure 5 gives an overview of the concrete steps that will be undertaken for
impact assessment.
Consideration of policy options
03
Analysis of impacts Objective setting
04
02
Problem 01 Comparison of 05
definition options
Figure 5. Overview of impact assessment approach
Step 1 – Problem definition. Processing data collected in Deliverable 2; we will map the current
socioeconomic landscapes in Estonia. We will conduct a literature review to incorporate analysis on
long-term socioeconomic trends and forecasts and we will assess the likely socioeconomic impacts of
each decarbonization pathway scenario.
23
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Step 2 – Objective setting. We will structure our analysis to generate results on impacts at the national
Estonian level. Direct, indirect, and induced impacts will be modelled and defined. Impacts on a range of
market participants – including industrial consumers, commercial consumers, and household consumers,
as well as heat producers and network operators – will be considered. The impact assessment will output
indicators on GDP, employment, labour productivity, household income and spending, heat costs, GHGs
and government taxes and revenues.
Step 3 – Consideration of the policy options. For each pathway analyzed in Deliverable 3, we will chart
potential effects in line with the following dimensions, which will influence the social and economic
impacts further analyzed in step 4:
Technical – Technological and infrastructural development opportunities
Generation of jobs
Subsidies and incentives
The considerations of the policy options will be consulted with the relevant stakeholders and the
client so a mutual agreement can be reached.
Step 4 – Quantitative and qualitative analysis of impacts. The transformation of the heat generation
system in Estonia towards carbon neutrality will be a capital-intensive process that will develop in a
dynamic framework where prices, technology costs, production structures, consumer preferences and
habits evolve requiring different types of labor skills, infrastructure and materials. Costs and benefits are
not expected to be equally distributed across firms and households. Those that supply the goods and
services required for the decarbonization of the system (RES equipment manufacturers, O&M suppliers,
engineers etc.) are expected to benefit while fossil energy producers, producers of associated equipment
and workers are expected to incur costs.
Below we outline key transformational channels that will be addressed in our analysis:
1. Construction of new renewable energy infrastructure, retrofitting of old infrastructure and installation
of new heating and cooling technologies and associated infrastructure (direct - short term effects):
Construction of new renewable energy infrastructure requires services, materials and equipment that are
partly domestically produced and partly imported. Using domestic capital and labor resources brings
benefits to the economy by increasing domestic activity and employment. This benefit is short term as it
lasts only during the period of installation of the new infrastructure. The jobs generated are short term
and last until the construction phase ends. Same is the case for the new heating and cooling technologies,
as they are majorly import dependent (presenting only installation jobs).
2. Operation and maintenance of RES and the heating and cooling infrastructure (long term effects):
Operation and maintenance has a long-term effect on economic activity and employment. Depending on
nature of the selected technology of RES and heating and cooling systems different employment skills and
labor intensities are required.
3. Phasing out of current energy sources: Mining and use of shale oil is a key economic activity that will
be mostly affected by the transformation of the electricity system for heating purposes.
4. Financing scheme of Investments: Investments in new heat generation plants and alternative
technologies play a key role in determining the overall adjustment of the economic system.
24
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
5. Prices: Alternative heat generation mixes impact differently on production costs which have direct
repercussions on market competitiveness and household disposable income.
To properly assess economy-wide impacts we propose to use a modelling framework that encompasses
all interactions among economic agents, considering input-output calculations, while describing in
sufficient detail the heating and cooling value chain of the Estonian industrial, commercial/private sector.
The impact assessment begins with the adaptation of data from the measures analyzed in the analytical
model:
Figure 6. Impact assessment modelling methodology
We will analyse the content of information, if necessary, supplement the original data to achieve the
completeness of the information. In the course, we appreciate the relationship between quantitative
input information on economic status, business efficiency and cost-effectiveness. We select the inputs
that are important to make the following calculations and that will be inputs to the model.
As a result of the first phase, the input information will be linked to the impact coefficients of relevant
products / sectors. Effects on labour market indicators, business efficiency (competitiveness) and cost-
effectiveness will be rated.
The aim of the next stage is to program a single analytical model with a suitable software solution (MS
Excel) and the results of the analysis:
25
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Figure 7. Model and calculation output concept
The results of each scenario will be evaluated against their performance compared to the baseline
scenario.
Impacts on sectoral value added / production for each activity represented in the model
(industries, services, households, transport, power generation, transmission and distribution).
Impacts on components of GDP (investment, balance of trade, consumption).
Household disposable income.
Labour productivity.
GHG Emissions.
Public Revenues and taxes.
The selection of the model software solution was based on the relative uniqueness of the analysis, which
is why the model is difficult to match potential pre-programmed products. Therefore, our preference is
to select a software solution using MS Excel program. MS Excel provides high versatility in developing any
suitable model that can later be used by the Client to run independent scenarios.
MS Excel is a suitable tool for performing an input-output analysis, provides a good overview of the data
used, describes the model links to the user understandably and is a very common modelling environment
that can handle the widespread number of users.
The approach outlined above will provide a complete and thorough analysis that will capture the direct,
indirect and induced short- and long-term impacts of the carbon neutral heating and cooling system.
Though there are distinct work streams, Deliverables 3 and 4 will crossover at certain points of study
implementation. Deliverable 3 will provide the outcomes of the heat generation mix (fuel, capacity,
energy system costs) for each scenario/pathway examined that will be used as input for Deliverable 4.
The links between the two deliverables are detailed in the following figure.
26
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Figure 8. Crossover of inputs/outputs between Deliverable 3 and 4
When we have constructed comprehensive mappings of the socioeconomic effects of each pathway, we
will present key projections and insights to stakeholders, and iteratively collect feedback from these
stakeholders. The analytical results of the impact assessment will then be refined and contextualised
based on input from relevant stakeholders.
Step 5 – Comparison of options. The impact assessment will conclude by summarising key analytical
insights integrated with stakeholder feedback. Figures and analyses comparing the impacts of each
pathway on parameters including GDP, employment, labour productivity, household disposable income,
heating costs, GHG emissions, and government taxes and revenues will be developed. The principal socio-
economic impacts of each pathway at national level will be summarised. And the pathways will be
compared and evaluated according to their projected socioeconomic impacts.
The results of the socioeconomic impact assessment will be compiled in an Excel that clearly and
accessibly presents key insights and allows users to explore projections across different pathways. The
figures and data included in the excel will be analysed in detail in the socio-economic impact
assessment report.
Deliverable 5: Risk analysis
Deliverable 5: Risk analysis report
Aim To perform a thorough risk analysis of choosing alternative
pathways, with descriptions of their likelihood and potential
impacts as well as proposed measures for mitigation and
avoidance
Results To perform a thorough risk analysis of choosing alternative pathways,
with descriptions of their likelihood and potential impacts as well as
proposed measures for mitigation and avoidance
Outputs Detailed risk analyses for each pathway
Report, including supporting Excel tables.
Duration
Table 7. Deliverable 5 description
27
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Risk analysis will be undertaken to highlight key risks that might threaten the effective implementation
of each modelled pathway. For all decarbonisation pathways modelled, matrices will be developed
that highlight the risks relevant to each pathway. Selected risks will be assessed in terms of their
likelihood and their severity, to provide an overview on which risks might derail pathway
implementation and the probability of their occurrence. For each risk, mitigation strategies will be
recommended.
Risks that will be considered for each pathway are outlined in the table below. Additional potential
risks will be flagged during Deliverable 3, as potential issues specific to the different pathways are
identified during modelling. A long-list of risks will be discussed and refined with the Ministry at the
start of the analysis. A basic list of potential risks is presented in the following table.
Type Risk
Technological Delayed technological development of key decarbonisation technologies
Key decarbonisation technologies do not reach economies of scale, such that
their costs remain higher than projected
Delayed infrastructural development, preventing integration of key
decarbonisation technologies
Regulatory Local policies present barriers to implementation
National policies present barriers to implementation
EU policies present barriers to implementation
International policies present barriers to implementation
Weak/Lack of planning at local level
Societal Local opposition to new infrastructure
Lack of widespread public acceptance of new infrastructure
Low uptake of renewable solution (incl. connection to efficient and
renewable DHC)
Low uptake of energy efficiency measures (mainly on building side)
jeopardising the expected evolution of heat demand
28
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Lack of RES installation performance and quality
Energy markets Inability to finance heating production and storage infrastructure
Lack of renewable technology and energy (fuels) competitiveness
Lack of resources
Economic EU or global economic crisis results in market volatility and limited spending
potential
Table 8. Overview of the possible risks
For each pathway, risks with the highest potential likelihood or severity will be selected from this
framework for in-depth analysis in a risk matrix. The matrices will include insights from additional
research and interviews conducted focused on selected risks. Risk assessment matrices for all
modelled pathways will be developed and displayed in accessible excel tables. They will be used to
contrast the scenarios with the “business as usual pathway,” pathway 1. Analytical results will be
synthesised and presented in the risk analysis report, which will provide overviews on the potential
severity and likelihood of all assessed risks. The results of the risk assessment – particularly the
proposed mitigation strategies – will be used as input in Deliverable 7, when Action Plans for
implementing pathways are developed.
Deliverable 6: Sensitivity analysis
Deliverable 6: Report on sensitivity analyses
Aim To determine how fluctuations in different variables – including heat prices – impact the
socio-economic analyses conducted in Deliverable 4
Results Increased robustness of the results of socio-economic analyses
Outputs Definition of variables considered in sensitivity analyses
Sensitivity analyses on results of Deliverable 4
Report, including supporting excel files.
Table 9. Deliverable 6 description
Sensitivity analyses will be performed to test the robustness of the results of socio-economic impact
assessments performed in Deliverable 4. The influence of fluctuating heat & electricity prices will be
prioritised for examination. Additional variables which could be tested include:
LCOEs of technologies (split into capital costs, O&M costs, input fuel costs, efficiencies, and
lifetime components).
Additional carbon taxes (beyond the ETS) on fossil fuels for heat production.
29
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
To analyse baseline output sensitivities to each selected variable, scenarios will be defined and the models
from Deliverable 3 and Deliverable 4 will be re-run, to generate sensitivity results comparable with the
baseline analytical results – i.e., the primary results of Deliverable 4’s impact assessments. For example,
to test sensitivity to ETS prices, the model will be re-run first assuming ETS prices 50% higher than baseline
values and then assuming ETS prices 50% lower than baseline values. Results from each scenario will be
inputted into the Deliverable 4 impact assessment model, through which socio-economic impacts will be
recalculated.
Ultimately, KPIs calculated in the initial socioeconomic impact assessment will be compared with the
results of sensitivity analyses.
A simple, indicative comparison table is depicted below (serves as a rough example to show relation), in
line with the example on fluctuating ETS price scenarios.
Socioeconomic Baseline pathway X Sensitivity analysis results
indicators results
Change compared to Given 50% increase Given 50% decrease
BAU values in ETS prices, change in ETS prices, change
compared to BAU compared to BAU
values values
Gross domestic +10% +6% +11%
product
… … … …
Changes in the +12% +20% +3%
heating and
electricity costs of
households
Changes in GHG -80% -90% -77%
emissions related to
heat and electricity
production
Table 10. Socioeconomic indicators comparison (example)
Areas significantly impacted by higher or lower ETS prices will be identified and further analysed, e.g.,
higher ETS prices might further reduce GHG emissions and result in higher heat costs for households
compared to baseline results. Significant fluctuations in these dependent variables due to changing ETS
or fuel prices will be highlighted and contextualised in the deliverable report.
The results of the sensitivity analysis will also show the conditions under which certain scenarios might
generate more favourable economic outcomes than others.
30
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Deliverable 7: Action Plans for carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia
Deliverable 7: Report on Action Plans
Aim To propose Action Plans for each defined pathway that include all steps that
the Government of Estonia could take in order to reach climate-neutral heat
production
Results Analysis for all pathways on how necessary heat generation capacities can be
brought to the market, how these activities could be financed and whether
and to which degree the support by public sector is required
Outputs Draft concrete Action Plans for each pathway
Definition of the expected costs and revenues for each Action Plan
Comparison of each Action Plan against the “business as usual” Action Plan
Recommendations for implementing the best pathway(s) for climate-neutral
heat production in Estonia
Recommendations on reducing the negative and increasing the positive
environmental, social and economic - including regional - impacts of each
pathway
Clear and concrete policy recommendations, and assessments of their
compatibility with the Estonian legal system and public perception
Report, including supporting excel tables.
Table 11. Deliverable 7 description
The aim of Deliverable 7 will be to propose Action Plans for each defined pathway that include all steps
(e.g., changes in legislative documents, establishment of new entities, subsidies) the Government of
Estonia could take in order to reach climate-neutral heating and cooling.
Analysis will be developed for all pathways on how necessary heating and cooling capacities can be
brought to the market, how these activities could be financed and whether support from the public
sector will be required.
Pathway action plan briefings
Analyses will be summarised in “action plan briefings” for each modelled pathway. The briefings will
be developed and presented in line with the following structure:
Part I. Pathway summary – The briefing introduction will concisely synthesise the results of previous
tasks related to the pathway. It will present the core components of the decarbonisation pathway
including reliance on selected technologies. It will consolidate the pathway’s modelled outcomes from
Deliverable 3, its key socioeconomic impacts from Deliverable 4, relevant risks from Deliverable 5, and
any significant sensitivities from Deliverable 6.
31
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Part II. Concrete recommendations on policy measures required to implement the pathway – The
bulk of the briefing will delineate the legislative actions needed to enable pathway implementation.
Legislative actions will be analysed across three categories:
A. Adjustments to the existing regulatory framework – Actions will be recommended to address
areas where existing legislation might block or stall pathway implementation. These areas will
be identified during the risk assessment.
B. Financial policies – Potential funding mechanisms will be surveyed and several key financial
strategies which can collectively fund pathway implementation will be recommended. The
survey will cover public and private financing mechanisms, though recommendations will
focus primarily on public funding through policy measures. Public funding mechanisms
considered for each pathway will include national tax schemes, tax cuts, subsidy programmes,
grant programmes, public tenders, increased research funding, and the establishment of
public-private partnerships. Recommended policies will be selected based on their records of
success at promoting the use of technologies integral to the pathway.
C. Organisational and social policies – Organisational and social policy actions often play vital
roles enabling clean energy transitions. Private and public outreach programmes will be
considered and potentially recommended. Private outreach programmes can be useful when
substantial changes to industry are required, or in securing public support for decarbonisation
and mitigating social risks like NIMBYism that can stall the installation of new technologies.
Public outreach policies will be detailed and recommended where they can address all relevant
social risks identified during the risk assessment.
Proposed policies will be expounded in detail and thoroughly justified. They will additionally be
analysed to determine their compliance with the Estonian legal system and their compatibility with
public opinion. Instances where policies might be legally unfeasible or publicly unpopular will be
flagged, and strategies to overcome incompatibilities will be proposed.
Part III. Recommendations on reducing negative and increasing positive pathway impacts – Key
negative and positive impacts of the pathway – as primarily determined in Deliverable 4 – will be listed
and categorised as environmental, economic or social. Actions will be proposed to address each impact
and where appropriate, these actions will be incorporated into the list of recommended policy
measures for the pathway. Proposed actions to mitigate negative impacts or amplify positive impacts
will be supported by case studies that illustrate instances where actions were successful.
Part IV. Synthesised timeline for recommended actions – All recommended policy measures will be
collated and mapped to an advised enactment timeline. The timeline will depict the dates by which
policies should be legislated to enable full pathway implementation by 2050. The timelines will also
include relevant policy actions from Estonia’s National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until
2030, for reference. The modelling results of Deliverable 3 – which will include time series projections
of required technological installations – will inform timeline mapping.
Part V. Costs and revenues of the recommended action plan – The expected costs and revenues
resulting from all recommended policy measures will be estimated. Data from Deliverables 3 and 4 will
be used as a basis for calculations. As most costs and revenues will be related to new financial policies,
32
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
they will be the focus of estimations. The net costs/net revenues of collective action plans will be
developed via an accessible Excel analysis and summarised in the action plan briefing.
Part VI. Action plan comparison to BAU – Recommended policy measures will be assessed against
strategies included in the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2030. The synthesised
timeline for recommended actions, with development plan actions included, will contribute to the
comparison. Areas of strong convergence will be highlighted and opportunities to synergise action
plans will be discussed. Conjointly, areas of significant divergence from BAU actions will be identified.
Additional measures will be proposed to resolve discrepancies where appropriate. The costs and
revenues of the BAU action plan, having been separately calculated, will be compared to the costs and
revenues of the pathway action plan. Areas where additional investments are required will be flagged,
as will areas where potential revenues might be gained. Key positive and negative features of the
pathway action plan – when compared with the BAU action plan – will be summarised.
The recommended policy measures will be discussed and agreed on with the key stakeholders, the
client and experts to conclude on the most effective recommendations that can rapidly be adopted.
Cross-pathway action plans report
The report on action plans will include all briefings on individual pathways, as well as synthesised
analysis on actions recommended across briefings. “No-regret” policies that would enable the
implementation of any decarbonisation pathway will be highlighted. The costs and revenues estimated
for pathway action plans will be compared, and the cheapest action plan will be determined. Pathways
will be assessed according to their overall compatibility with existing Estonian legislation, and their
compatibility with the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector currently in place. Significant
areas of incompatibility will be highlighted. Finally, the potential for reducing negative and promoting
positive impacts of every pathway will be compared. The net negative/positive impacts of each
pathway will be presented.
This synthesised comparison between pathway action plans – in conjunction with an assessment of
key conclusions from Deliverables 3, 4, and 5 – will directly inform the selection of optimal
decarbonisation pathway(s). Best pathway(s) will be presented and key recommendations on that
would lead to their successful implementation will be summarised at the close of the report.
33
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Deliverable 8: Final report
Deliverable 8: Final report
Aim To summarize the performed activities and provide
corresponding recommendations for further actions, including
evaluation and monitoring of project outcomes
Results Synthesised presentation of results of all project activities, a description
of project challenges encountered and how they were overcome
Outputs Report, including Excel tables with references to sources used
and other relevant materials
Presentation of the report during a workshop in Tallinn
Table 12. Description of deliverable 8
The final report will present key insights from the study, summarise the activities carried out, reflect
on challenges confronted and provide informed considerations that might benefit similar studies in
the future. The report will present an opportunity to take stock of the project and to assess the
indicators put in place to monitor its implementation.
The report will be developed by the leaders of all project tasks, who will provide input on the execution
of the study, address issues that surfaced in task analyses, flag challenges that were difficult to
overcome and might resurface in future similar studies and provide more general recommendations
to those undertaking such studies.
The report will also include recommendations on how to effectively monitor project outcomes and on
how to re-assess the results of the analysis if necessary, as situations evolve. Core insights of this report
– on project analyses, processes and results – will be presented to a workshop of relevant stakeholders
in Estonia at the conclusion of the project.
34
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
4. Project timeline and work plan
A separate Excel table that includes specified work plan has also been added to this offer.
The project timeline and work plan for the implementation of the project is compiled considering the
intermediate and final deadlines provided by the Contracting Authority, following the proposed
methodological approach. An indicative project timeline is shown in the following figure, where the
activities are presented with weekly accuracy. Where possible, project activities are planned to run
parallelly, including small time buffers, to mitigate the risk of not staying on schedule. The timeline
includes interim meetings and expert panel workshops, that are indicated with an “✓”. Regular
meetings of project work group formed of Tenderer´s and Client’s representatives, will take place bi-
weekly and is not added to the timeline separately.
In the timeline we have assumed that project activities will begin in July and accounted for bigger
holiday seasons like Christmas and New Year holidays. The actual schedule will be updated after the
award of the contract and will be discussed with the Client and agreed upon at the opening meeting
of the project.
Work results shall be presented at two public events after the completion of the work within one
month of the completion.
35
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
36
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
37
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
5. Cooperation with the Client
Close cooperation and continuous involvement of the Client is essential to ensure that the terms
specified in the procurement documents are met, and the methodological plan and the results
correspond to the expectations of the Client.
The contact person for the Client is the project manager, who is responsible for coordinating the
cooperation with the Contracting Authority as well as experts and the work within the proposed
Tenderer's team.
To ensure good quality of work and compliance of the results with the Customer's expectations
following is proposed:
● All important decision-making points in the project are coordinated with the Client.
● The Tenderer proposes to form a project steering group consisting of Tenderers and Clients
representatives that acts as an immediate decision-making board with required mandate for
any corrective action needed. Details of the steering group shall be agreed upon during the
opening meeting.
● During the planned opening and mid-term meetings proposed in the timeline an overview of
the work progress and interim results on deliverables are discussed to make decisions on
methodological or organizational issues.
● The Client shall help with gathering or gaining access to data, information and contact details
needed for the performance of the work.
● Overview of the progress of the analysis and results shall be given in regular biweekly meetings
of the steering group, where other related parties may participate, depending on the subject
being discussed. Possible faults or hinderances are reported immediately as they occur. When
necessary additional meetings will be organized.
● The materials on which meetings are based will be sent by the Tenderer to the participants at
least 4 working days in advance.
● Client shall give feedback on the submitted interim results, the draft final report and when
necessary, on an ongoing basis about the work process and results, which allows for even better
consideration of the Client’s wishes.
● The tenderer is responsible of preparing the minutes of the meetings on the topics and
agreements made and forwarding these to the Client and other related parties within 3 working
days of the meeting.
● Regular meetings are planned to take place virtually. If possible, two project meetings with the
client shall be held in person, including showcasing of final results, depending on the
restrictions.
● All important project documentation is uploaded to the agreed project environment upon
completion where access is given to the Client and other relevant parties.
● Documents are drafted in clear and comprehensible language, easily readable with good quality
visualizations.
● The project manager ensures that the quality of the interim results, reports and final report
submitted to the client meets the requirements, agreed format agreed deadlines.
38
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
6. Organisational structure and team members
The lead partner of the study is Stockholm Environment Institute Tallinn Centre. Other partners include
Trinomics B.V. and Pilvero OÜ. The exact tasks of the team members have been highlighted in the table
below. The more specific backgrounds and bios of the team members connected to their expertise can
be found from Annex I, Annex II and in the CV-s attached to the offer.
Team member Responsibilities and tasks in the project
● Leading deliverable 1 and 8
● Coordinating the work of the project team; monitoring the
timetable and action plan
● Communication with the client (exchange of information,
Merlin Rehema, Project manager (SEI coordination of intermediate stages and results,
Tallinn) organization of meetings, etc.)
● Arranging opening and interim meetings with the client
Expertise: project management, ● Participation in the process of designing the results of the
energy efficiency, long term study and compiling reports, organizing a validation
strategic planning seminar
● Organization of stakeholder events (national workshops,
international expert panel meetings)
● Carrying out quality control throughout the project
● Transfer of results and presentation of results
● Deliverable 3 and 7 leader
● Monitoring the content work of the project;
Frank Gerard, Project manager , ● Scenario modelling under deliverable 3 (scenario defining,
senior expert in the energy transition implementation of defined scenarios, forecasting
and low carbon economy (Trinomics production, distribution, and consumption of H&C,
B.V.) preparing projections)
● Action Plans for decarbonising heat generation
Expertise: district heating, cooling, ● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
long term strategic planning, energy reports, proposals and recommendations
efficiency ● Participation in meetings with the Client, national
stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
meetings
● Strategic coordination throughout the deliverables
● Participation in key data collection and analysis phases
Lauri Tammiste, Director of SEI ● Participating in drafting of Action Plans
Tallinn (SEI Tallinn) ● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
reports, proposals and recommendations
Expertise: energy – and climate ● Participation in meetings with the client, national
policies, energy efficiency, long term stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
strategic planning meetings
39
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
● Scenario modelling under deliverable 3 (scenario defining,
implementation of defined scenarios, forecasting
production, distribution, and consumption of H&C,
Adil Aslam, energy and climate preparing projections)
expert (SEI Tallinn) ● Data collection and scenario setting
● Participating in the risks assessment and drafting of Action
Expertise: climate- and energy Plans
policies and data, energy sector ● Participating in the meetings with the client
modelling, energy efficiency, long ● Presenting and participating during the national
term planning stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
meetings
● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
reports, proposals and recommendations
● Carrying out the data collection necessary for the
assessment of heating and cooling potential, compiling a
literature review
Kerli Kirsimaa, energy and climate ● Participation in key data collection and analysis phases
expert (SEI Tallinn) (incl. Conducting expert interviews, etc.)
● Participating in drafting of Action Plans
● Organization of stakeholder events (national workshops,
Expertise: climate- and energy
international expert panel meetings)
policies and data, long term
● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
planning, energy efficiency
reports, proposals and recommendations
● Participation in meetings with the Client, national
stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
meetings
● Deliverable 4 and 6 leader
● Socio-economic impact analysis
● Sensitivity analysis
● Participation in key data collection and analysis phases
Helen Poltimäe, senior expert of
(incl.
sustainable development (SEI Tallinn)
● Participating in drafting of Action Plans
● Conducting expert interviews, etc.)
Expertise: economic analysis, ● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
consumption management reports, proposals and recommendations
● Participation in meetings with the Client, national
stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
meetings
● Strategic coordination throughout the deliverables
Koen Rademaekers, Managing ● Participation in key data collection and analysis phases
Director of Trinomics (Trinomics B.V.) ● Participating in drafting of Action Plans
● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
Expertise: district heating, cooling, reports, proposals and recommendations
long term strategic planning, energy ● Participation in meetings with the client, national
efficiency stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
meetings
40
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
● Scenario modelling under deliverable 3 (scenario defining,
implementation of defined scenarios, forecasting
Natalie Jansow, energy expert and production, distribution, and consumption of H&C,
consultant (Trinomics B.V.) preparing projections)
● Action Plans for decarbonising heat generation
● Participation in key data collection and analysis phases
Expertise: energy- and climate
(incl. Conducting expert interviews, etc.)
policies, energy transition, energy
● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
technologies, long term strategic
reports, proposals and recommendations
planning
● Participation in meetings with the Client, national
stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
meetings
● Leading deliverable 2 and 5
● Baseline data collection and literature review
● TRL overview of technologies
Ülo Kask, senior heating and cooling ● Participation in key data collection and analysis phases
expert (OÜ Pilvero) (incl. Conducting expert interviews, etc.)
● Conducting risks analysis for each scenario
Expertise: district heating, cooling, ● Conducting expert interviews
long term strategic planning, energy ● Participation in the preparation of interim and final
efficiency reports, proposals and recommendations
● Participation in meetings with the Client, national
stakeholder workshops and international expert panel
meetings
Table 13. Team members and their responsibilities and tasks in the project
41
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
7. Possible risks and their mitigation
During the project there may be internal and / or external risks arising regarding the process, methods, the Tenderer and the Client. The following is the
Tenderer's vision of the main possible risks, their mitigation measures, and responsible persons. In addition, the likelihood of each risk occurring and the
impact on the results on a low-medium-high scale have been assessed.
Nr Potential risk Probability Impact Mitigation measure
At the opening meeting, the expectations of the Contracting Authority will be specified in
detail, including expectations for work procedures, main focus points, expectation for the final
The final result of the analysis does not
version of the analysis and similar circumstances.
meet the expectations of the Client
All research questions are also discussed in detail, as well as specific data and working methods.
The Client and the Tenderer have
1 Low High These will be agreed in the Inception report (deliverable 1).
different understandings of the
objectives of the project and the end The client contributes to the review of project working documents and interim results, as a
result does not fully meet the result of which it is possible to identify possible deviations at an early stage and take necessary
expectations of the Client. measures.
Responsible persons: Tenderer project manager, Clients contact person
The quality of the work is ensured by ongoing control, close exchange of information and
coordination of decisions with the involved parties.
Ongoing monitoring of the quality of work activities is planned to take place from the
specification of the methodology to the completion of the final results through regular working
The quality of the work is not up to meetings during which the work done (results) is reviewed, problem areas are resolved, further
2 Medium Medium
standards steps are planned, decisions are coordinated etc. In this way, the problems encountered
appear quickly and can be resolved immediately without affecting the results of the analysis.
Periodic exchange of information with the Client ensures that the Client is aware of the
progress of the project, the possibility to direct activities in important stages of analysis and
the Tenderer's assurance that the work performed meets the Client's wishes.
42
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Responsible persons: Tenderer's project manager
At the opening meeting, the existence and scope of the necessary data and the possibilities of
obtaining the data are discussed, with the possibilities of assistance from the Contracting
Authority in obtaining the data.
Necessary data is not available or
3 Medium Medium The project team has sufficient experience to combine and use complex databases and
difficult to process
methodologies when input data is incomplete. If necessary, additional expertise will be
involved in creating the source data.
Responsible persons: Tenderer's project manager, involving the Client
Risks may arise in case team members illness or being prevented from participating in the
project for other justified reasons. Enough resources have been planned with partially
overlapping expertise so that project team members can replace each other. The Tenderer's
team also includes experts with similar backgrounds and experience, who can be promptly
4 Lack of human resources Low High involved in the implementation of the project, if necessary as well as assistants that are
available to assist in data collection and compilation of materials according to the given
instructions.
Responsible persons: Tenderer's project manager
In order to ensure the timely implementation of the work activities, a detailed time and action
plan is prepared, the team members responsible for the activities and the involved parties and
Project activities (deliverables) take their roles are determined.
more time than planned
Regular team meetings review compliance with the action plan and respond promptly to
5 Shifts in the schedule caused by Low Medium
emerging circumstances (including, for example, attracting additional resources, making
internal or external factors endanger changes, including additional assistants in the team who can assist with data collection and
compliance with the set deadlines. compilation.
Responsible persons: Tenderer's project manager, deliverable leaders
Through the personal and professional networks of the project core team and the panel of
Interviewees or experts are not
experts involved, it is possible to reach most of the relevant experts and involved parties who
6 available or do not want to Medium High
need to be interviewed during the work. Experts will be informed well in advance so that they
participate in the study.
can find a suitable time for the interview that can be also held virtually.
43
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Interviews can be partially replaced by analysis of foreign practices and literature. In addition,
map the so-called backup contacts to whom to turn.
We consider it important that the Client supports reaching the experts sharing contacts or
establishing initial contact.
Responsible persons: Tenderer's project manager, deliverable leaders, Client's contact person
The Tenderer's team is ready to carry out the project activities remotely (incl. Video interviews
and webinar of the validation seminar) and using electronic channels. The team has remote
The next wave of the coronavirus
access to all necessary documents through a unified project environment.
pandemic will have a significant
7 Medium Medium
impact on results and process of the The Tenderer's team has the technical means and skills to conduct all meetings with the Client,
study. discussions within the team and data collection through electronic channels.
Responsible persons: Tenderer's project manager
Table 14. Possible risks and their probability, impact and mitigation measures
44
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Annex I: Backgrounds of team members
SEI Tallinn:
Merlin Rehema, SEI Tallinn
Merlin Rehema joined SEI Tallinn’s Climate and Energy Programme in March 2020 focusing mainly on
transport, mobility and energy related topics, currently also the acting program manager. She holds a
Master’s degree in Urban Management (MA) from Tallinn University and in Environmental Protection
(MSc) from Estonian University of Life Sciences.
Merlin has extensive experience in project management, mapping work processes and user
requirements, and compiling documentation, leading the analysis of the creation of a national planning
database in the Ministry of Finance, the network module in Buildings registry the Ministry of Economic
Affairs and Communications and during previous public sector software development projects. Diverse
experience in data collection, analysis and visualization has also been gained at various levels in
compiling mobility studies and mobility plans at Hendrikson & KO and SEI Tallinn. Currently, Merlin is
the overall project manager of the Interreg Baltic Sea States transport project RESPONSE as well as
leading several smaller projects.
Lauri Tammiste, SEI Tallinn
Lauri is the director of SEI Tallinn since 2016. He has extensive and interdisciplinary experience in
energy, energy efficiency and innovation policy design, analysis and program management. During his
7 years at the Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications he was in various positions
responsible for shaping the national renewable energy plan, national R&D and innovation strategy,
designing and launching new support programs for energy efficiency and renewable energy and R&D,
coordinating and carrying out ex-ante and ex-post policy evaluations, international cooperation and
representing Estonia in various European Commission, OECD, IEA and Nordic-Baltic working groups.
Lauri has also served as a member of the management board of the Estonian Environmental
Investment Centre (EIC), which as a government-owned foundation is responsible for financing
sustainable environmental projects both from national and EU funds. His main tasks have involved
helping to shape new financing instruments, carrying out impact assessment of financed projects in 10
policy areas, implementing improvements in financing framework based on the impact assessments
and also improving the communication and marketing activities of EIC in order to raise the public
profile of the financed projects and to boost environmental awareness.
45
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Adil Aslam, SEI Tallinn
Adil joined the Climate and Energy programme in November 2020 and has worked as an external
consultant for Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit.
Adil is an energy expert working in the Climate and Energy team at SEI Tallinn since November 2020.
He has a versatile set of skills and work experience where he has worked on different energy
consultancy projects. He has also worked as an external consultant for Deutsche Gesellschaft für
Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) and performed an in-depth market analysis for Adaptive
Balancing Power GmbH to identify business opportunities for flywheels in Asia. He also worked as the
lead modeller in developing a hydrogen potential production and consumption model for Estonia. He
is an expert in conventional and renewable energy systems while being proficient in a whole range of
energy simulation software. He is adept in programming and has used Python and Matlab to develop
various energy models. His interests lie in energy systems, sector coupling, green finance, sustainable
business models, electricity markets and simulations.
He graduated from Technische Universität Berlin, Germany in 2020 with a Master’s in Business
Engineering Energy. He did his Master’s thesis at Forschungszentrum Julich (one of the largest
interdisciplinary research centres in Europe) and the Institut für Stromrichtertechnik und Elektrische
Antriebe (ISEA) RWTH, where he worked on modelling an energy management system for residential
PV home systems to sustain blackouts.
Kerli Kirsimaa, SEI Tallinn
Kerli joined SEI Tallinn’s Climate and Energy team in February 2015, having previously worked for the
Municipality of Rotterdam where she conducted phosphorus flow analysis for the city within the
International Architecture Biennale Rotterdam. Prior to that, Kerli graduated her Master degree at
Wageningen University and Research Centre in the Netherlands in the Urban Environmental
Management Program.
Throughout the extensive work experience at SEI Tallinn, Kerli has been participating both as an expert
and project manager for multiple national and international projects. Her expertise covers a wide
range of topics but include mostly climate mitigation and adaptation, energy efficiency, energy
modelling and climate- as well as energy policy analysis. The most significant projects for Estonia,
where Kerli has been an expert, include the national climate change adaptation strategy in 2015-2016,
short-lived climate pollutants study in 2017, an overview of whether Estonia fulfils the Paris Agreement
in 2018, climate ambition 2050 study for the Estonian government in 2019 and most recently the
hydrogen potential study for Estonia between 2020-2021. There has also been various international
projects funded by Horizon2020, EU & Norway Grants, Interreg BSR and many others where Kerli has
participated either as an expert or local project manager.
46
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Helen Poltimäe, SEI Tallinn
Helen Poltimäe works in SEI Tallinn since 2000. She is a senior expert, specializing in environmental
and ecological economics. She has been participating in projects related to assessing costs and impacts
of various environmentally related policies, strategies and action plans. Her main areas of interest and
research topics have been focused on climate, transport and agriculture. She has been involved in
projects on a country, but also international level. Helen has been specifically interested in the role of
environmental taxes and charges and their potential impacts on different stakeholders. Helen
defended PhD in economics in 2014. Her PhD thesis was about the distributional and behavioural
effects of Estonian environmental taxes. Since 2014, she also works part-time in University of Tartu, as
lecturer of economic modelling, teaching various statistical and research methods courses.
Trinomics B.V.
Frank Gerard, Trinomics
Frank Gérard is senior expert in the energy transition and low carbon economy. He has experience in
environmental impact assessment, socio-technical-economic assessments, policy evaluation and
negotiation, strategy and plan preparation, project management and stakeholder consultations. He is,
among others, covering the following topics: energy efficiency, building performance, market design
and flexibility, renewable, storage and DSR, security of supply, bio economy, climate finance, third
party financing.
Frank has worked previously as senior policy advisor to the Minister of Energy and Climate of the
Walloon government, Senior Policy advisor for the renewable energy association in Belgium, and as a
Business Manager, Energy consultant and specialist in environment for a multilateral organization. He
developed his communication skills through his contact with the press, as speaker for many
conferences and workshops and by conducting consultations with various stakeholders.
He holds a master’s degree in Electrical Engineering from the Catholic University of Louvain-la-Neuve
and in Environmental Management from the University Libre of Brussels.
Koen Rademaekers, Trinomics
Prior to starting-up Trinomics, he was head of Ecorys’ Energy & Environment unit for more than 5
years. He solved many assignments for the European Commission (especially DG ENER, DG CLIMA and
DG ENV) and other international institutions, covering a variety of disciplines ranging from socio-
economic assessments, impact assessments, evaluations and model-based analyses of policy options.
Koen has a broad professional background: his extensive experience ranges from the academic
(assistant professor in econometrics and finance), to the private (utilities, banks and industry) as well
as the public sector (advisor of a Minister). He demonstrated his leadership and communication skills
47
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
while managing international teams in different companies and during the multiple contacts with
different types of clients and press.
Natalie Janzow, Trinomics
Natalie Janzow joined Trinomics in July 2019, having previously worked as a consultant for Oliver
Wyman and an analyst at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs. As part of the Energy
cluster, Natalie focuses on analysis of energy and climate policy, identification of regulatory barriers
within energy markets, and assessment of new business models and innovation across energy
technologies. She has a deep-seated interest in the energy transition and in international initiatives to
combat climate change.
Natalie holds a Bachelor’s degree in Physics from Harvard University, where she also received citations
in French and Spanish literature. She holds a Master’s degree in Nuclear Energy from the University of
Cambridge, where she studied energy policy and economics at the Judge Business School in
conjunction with nuclear engineering. Her Master’s thesis, “Projecting energy markets and greenhouse
gas emissions in the Middle East,” combined policy and economic research of incumbent versus new
energy technologies in Saudi Arabia and Iran, with a particular focus on the role of nuclear
technologies. Her technical expertise combined with her experience in energy policy informs her
research and enables her to contextualise detailed technical initiatives within broader political energy
landscapes.
Natalie is a native English speaker, proficient in French and Spanish, and a basic user of Dutch.
Pilvero OÜ
Ülo Kask
Ülo obtained a technical higher education (diploma in thermal energy engineering) at the Tallinn
Polytechnic Institute, a master's degree from Tallinn University of Technology and at the same time
completed his doctoral studies. For 40 years he has worked at Tallinn University of Technology and its
predecessor TPI. In addition, he has 29 years of work experience in the private consulting business.
Thanks to the mentioned education and work experience, Ülo is also extremely well acquainted with
what is happening in the field of energy economy and energy education in the country. Having been
the initiator of several foreign projects (INTERREG, IEE) and national projects (EIC, Enterprise Estonia,
companies) and participated in many HORIZON2020 and INTERREG BSR program projects.
Ülo has enough organizational skills and can successfully lead a team and play the role of an expert in
a team. His work so far has given him an extensive experience in the field of district heating and cooling.
He has prepared more than 30 development plans for district heating areas and other research and
development work in this field. He has all the necessary computer and language skills, being able to
not work only in Estonian, but being also fluent in English, Finnish and Russian. In addition, he has
continuously developed his knowledge and skills at annual seminars, conferences and trainings.
48
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Annex II: List of relevant reference projects
Relevant reference projects are listed in the separate file added to this offer.
49
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Bibliography
Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs. (2017). National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until
2030 (lk 124). https://www.mkm.ee/sites/default/files/ndpes_2030_eng.pdf
Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Environment, & Ministry
of Rural Affairs. (2019). Estonia’s 2030 National Energy and Climate Plan (lk 195).
https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/documents/ee_final_necp_main_en.pdf
Estonian Ministry of Environment. (2016). General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050.
https://www.envir.ee/et/eesmargid-tegevused/kliima/kliimapoliitika-pohialused-aastani-
2050-0
Estonian Ministry of the Interior. (2012). Spatial Planning „Estonia 2030+. Estonian Ministry of the
Interior. https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/et/ruumiline-planeerimine/uleriigiline-
planeering
Estonian Renewable Energy Chamber, 2019, Renewable Energy Yearbook 2019:
http://www.taastuvenergeetika.ee/wp-
content/uploads/2020/10/ETEK_aastaraamat_A4_2019_veeb.pdf
Estonian State Chancellery & Estonian Ministry of Finance. (2021). „Estonia 2035“ (lk 18).
https://www.valitsus.ee/strateegia-eesti-2035-arengukavad-ja-
planeering/strateegia/materjalid
Institute of Thermal Engineering at TUT, Institute of Design at TUT, 2016, District heating weighing
factors, http://www.epha.ee/images/docs/Osa_1_Kaugktte_kaalamistegurid_26_04_16.pdf
Kirsimaa, K., & Peterson, K. (2018). Kas Eesti täidab Pariisi kliimakokkulepet?
https://www.sei.org/publications/kas-eesti-taidab-pariisi-kliimakokkulepet/
Lindroos, T. J., Lehtilä, A., Koljonen, T., & Kofoed-Wiuff, A. (2018). Baltic Energy Technology Scenarios
2018. https://www.nordicenergy.org/project/bente/
50
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Meeliste, S., Tammiste, L., Kirsimaa, K., Suik, K., & Org, M. (2019). Reaching climate neutrality in
Estonia. https://www.sei.org/publications/eesti-kliimaambitsiooni-tostmise-voimaluste-
analuus/
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications. (2013). Estonian Entrepreneurship Growth
Strategy 2014–2020. https://kasvustrateegia.mkm.ee/index_eng.html
OECD/IEA & Nordic Energy Research. (2016). Nordic Energy Technology Perspectives 2016.
https://www.nordicenergy.org/project/nordic-energy-technology-perspectives/
SEI Tallinn. (s.a.). Transitioning to a climate-neutral electricity generation in Estonia. SEI. Salvestatud
17. mai 2021, https://www.sei.org/projects-and-tools/projects/transitioning-to-a-climate-
neutral-electricity-generation-in-estonia/
SEI Tallinn. (2021). Analysis of opportunities for hydrogen deployment in Estonia.
https://www.sei.org/projects-and-tools/projects/analysis-of-hydrogen-deployment/
SEI US. (s.a.). Integrated resource and resilience planning capacity building plan for Lao PDR. SEI.
Salvestatud 17. mai 2021, https://www.sei.org/projects-and-tools/projects/irrp-lao-pdr/
Tallinn University. (2005). Estonian National Strategy on Sustainable Development Sustainable
Estonia 21 (lk 81). Estonian Ministry of the Environment.
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/elfinder/article_files/se21_eng_web.pdf
Tallinn University of Technology & Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications. (2020). Long-
term strategy for building renovation (lk 75).
https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/documents/ee_ltrs_2020.pdf
Tammiste, L., Poltimäe, H., Kuldna, P., Kallaste, T., Kirsimaa, K., Grünvald, O., & Kuusk, K. (2018).
Nordic Green to Scale for countries Unlocking the potential of climate solutions in the Baltics,
Poland and Ukraine. http://norden.diva-
portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1202698/FULLTEXT01.pdf
51
Proposal for the public tender “Transitioning to carbon neutral heating and cooling in Estonia by 2050”
Stockholm Environment Institute
Tallinn Centre
Arsenal Centre, Erika 14, 10416
Tel: +372 6 276 100
Contact:
[email protected]
Contact:
visit us: sei.org
@SEIresearch
@SEIclimate
LEPING nr 17-10/19-0387/4319
Tallinnas, 13.07.2021
Leping Eesti üleminek süsinikuneutraalsele soojus- ning jahutusmajandusele aastaks 2050
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, registrikood 70003158, asukoht Suur-Ameerika 1,
Tallinn 10122, mida esindab põhimääruse alusel energeetika ja maavarade asekantsler kantsleri
ülesannetes Timo Tatar (edaspidi Tellija),
ja
Sihtasutus Stockholmi Keskkonnainstituudi Tallinna Keskus, registrikood 90000966, asukoht Erika
tn 14, Tallinn 10416, mida esindab põhikirja alusel juhatuse liige Lauri Tammiste (edaspidi Töövõtja),
keda edaspidi nimetatakse eraldi Pooleks ja ühiselt Poolteks,
sõlmivad käesoleva hankelepingu (edaspidi Leping) alljärgnevas:
1. Üldsätted
1.1. Lepingu eesmärgiks on reguleerida Poolte suhteid, õigusi, kohustusi ning vastutust Lepingu
esemeks oleva töö „Eesti üleminek süsinikneutraalsele soojus- ning jahutusmajandusele aastaks
2050“ (edaspidi Töö) teostamisel järgides Lepingus, riigihanke alusdokumentides ja selle lisades
sätestatud tingimusi.
1.2. Pooled juhinduvad Lepingu täitmisel ja omavaheliste suhete reguleerimisel Lepingust ning
Lepinguga reguleerimata küsimustes riigihanke alusdokumentides ja selle lisades sätestatud
tingimustest ning Eesti Vabariigis kehtivatest õigusaktidest.
1.3. Leping sõlmitakse Tellija korraldatud avatud hankemenetlusega riigihanke „Eesti üleminek
süsinikneutraalsele soojus- ning jahutusmajandusele aastaks 2050“ (viitenumber 234808)
tulemusena ning vastavuses riigihanke alusdokumentidele ning Töövõtja edukaks tunnistatud
pakkumusele.
1.4. Poolte esindajad kinnitavad, et neil on kõik õigused ja piisavad volitused sõlmida Leping
esindatava nimel kooskõlas õigusaktidega ning nad ei tea ühtegi takistust Lepinguga võetud ja
selles sätestatud kohustuste täitmiseks.
1.5. Mõisted „Tellija“ ja „Töövõtja“ hõlmavad kõiki vastavalt Tellijaga või Töövõtjaga töö- või
teenistussuhetes olevaid isikuid, aga samuti kõiki teisi isikuid, keda Tellija või Töövõtja on
kaasanud teise Poole nõusolekul Lepingu täitmisse.
1.6. Töövõtja esindaja kinnitab, et tal on tehniline kompetentsus ja võimalused Lepingu
professionaalseks ja nõuetekohaseks täitmiseks.
1.7. Lepingu dokumendid koosnevad Lepingust, Lepingu lisadest ning Lepingu võimalikest
muudatustest, milles lepitakse kokku pärast Lepingu allkirjastamist.
1.8. Käesoleva Lepingu allakirjutamise hetkel on Lepingule lisatud ja Pooled loevad Lepingu
lisadeks järgmised dokumendid:
1.8.1. Lisa 1 – Töö üleandmise ja vastuvõtmise akti vorm;
1.8.2. Lisa 2 – Tehniline kirjeldus;
1.8.3. Lisa 3 – Riigihanke alusdokumendid koos nende lisadega (leitavad e-riigihangete
keskkonnas);
1.8.4. Lisa 4 – Töövõtja pakkumus.
2. Lepingu ese, Töö teostamise tähtaeg ning Töö üleandmine ja vastuvõtmine
2.1. Lepingu esemeks on Töö teostamine, järgides Lepingus, riigihanke alusdokumentides ja nende
lisades sätestatud tingimusi. Töö täpsem kirjeldus on sätestatud Lepingu Lisas 2 „Tehniline
kirjeldus“.
2.2. Töövõtja teostab Töö ja annab selle Tellijale üle koos digitaalselt allkirjastatud üleandmise ja
vastuvõtmise aktiga (Lisa 1, edaspidi A kt). Töövõtja annab Töö üle vastavalt
hankedokumendi Lisa 1 „Tehniline kirjeldus“ punktides 7 ja 8 toodud vahearuannete plaanile
ja lõpptähtajale (12 kuud arvates Lepingu sõlmimisest).
2.3. Tellija vaatab Töö üle ja tagastab digitaalselt allkirjastatud Akti Töövõtjale hiljemalt 15 tööpäeva
jooksul arvates Töö üleandmisest juhul, kui Töö on teostatud vastavalt lepingutingimustele ja
üle antud vastavalt punktile 2.2.
2.4. Töö lepingutingimustele mittevastavuse korral kohustub Tellija punktis 2.3 nimetatud perioodi
jooksul sellest Töövõtjat teavitama ja osutama konkreetsele puudusele Töös ning andma
Töövõtjale vähemalt 10 tööpäeva aega puuduse kõrvaldamiseks või uue, lepingutingimustele
vastava Töö esitamiseks.
2.5. Töövõtja arvestab Töö teostamisel Tellija antud juhistega ning kõrvaldab Tellija nõudmisel Töös
(punkt 2.1) esinevad puudused Tellija määratud tähtajaks.
3. Tasu suurus, väljamaksmise tähtaeg ja kord
3.1. Tellija tasub Töövõtjale teostatud Töö eest tasu 110 000 eurot, millele lisandub käibemaks (20%).
Tasu makstakse Töövõtjale alljärgnevate etappide kaupa:
3.1.1. „20% tasust makstakse välja pärast Lisa 2 „Tehniline kirjeldus“ punktides 7.1 ja 7.2
nimetatud vahearuannete Tellija poolt heakskiitmist (digitaalselt allkirjastatud Akti
tagastamist vastavalt Lepingu punktile 2.3).
3.1.2. 20% tasust makstakse välja pärast Lisa 2 „Tehniline kirjeldus“ punktides 7.3 ja 7.4
nimetatud vahearuannete Tellija poolt heakskiitmist (digitaalselt allkirjastatud Akti
tagastamist vastavalt Lepingu punktile 2.3).
3.1.3. 20% tasust makstakse välja pärast Lisa 2 „Tehniline kirjeldus“ punktides 7.5 ja 7.6 nimetatud
vahearuannete Tellija poolt heakskiitmist (digitaalselt allkirjastatud Akti tagastamist
vastavalt Lepingu punktile 2.3).
3.1.4. 20% tasust makstakse välja pärast Lisa 2 „Tehniline kirjeldus“ punktis 7.7 nimetatud
vahearuande7 Tellija poolt heakskiitmist (digitaalselt allkirjastatud Akti tagastamist vastavalt
Lepingu punktile 2.3).
3.1.5. 20% tasust makstakse välja pärast Lisa 2 „Tehniline kirjeldus“ p-s 7.8 nimetatud
lõpparuande, sh lühikokkuvõtete ja esitluse materjalide, esitamist ja Tellija poolt
heakskiitmist (digitaalselt allkirjastatud Akti tagastamist vastavalt Lepingu punktile 2.3).
3.2. Pärast Akti allkirjastamist Poolte poolt ja heakskiitmist punktis
2.3 nimetatud tingimuste kohaselt esitab Töövõtja arve Lepingu punktides 3.1.1 - 3.1.5
nimetatud Töö teostamise eest.
3.3. Tellija tasub lepingutingimustele vastava Töö eest pärast selle vastuvõtmist hiljemalt 30 päeva
jooksul Töövõtja esitatud arve kättesaamisest arvates.
3.4. Töövõtja esitab Tellijale arve masintöödeldaval kujul, vastavalt kehtivale e-arve juhendile
(https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/123042019008). Arvele märgitakse Tellija dokumendiregistris
registreeritud Lepingu number ja Lepingus nimetatud Tellija volitatud isik.
4. Tellija õigused ja kohustused
4.1. Tellijal on õigus:
4.1.1. nõuda Töövõtjalt vastavalt Lepingu tingimustele nõuetekohast ja tähtaegset Töö teostamist
ja selle üleandmist;
4.1.2. nõuda Töövõtjalt töölõikude asendamist samaväärsetega ilma lisatasuta, kui Töö teostamise
käigus selgub, et asendamine aitab paremini saavutada Töö tulemusi eeldusel, et asendatavat
töölõiku ei ole veel sooritama asutud ja Töövõtja vastaval kinnitusel on meeskonna
ressursivajadus vahetatavate töölõikude puhul sarnane või on uus töölõik kaetav Töövõtja
meeskonna vaba ressursiga;
4.1.3. kontrollida Töö teostamise käiku, hanke alusdokumentides nimetatud tingimuste täitmist ja
nõuda Töövõtjalt Töö teostamise kohta informatsiooni;
4.1.4. nõuda Töövõtjalt Lepingu täitmisel läbiviidavate koosolekute ja kohtumiste protokollimist
ning protokollide esitamist Tellijale ja seotud osapooltele kättesaadavaks tegemist kolme
tööpäeva jooksul arvates koosoleku või kohtumise toimumisest;
4.1.5. kasutada õiguskaitsevahendeid (sh öelda Leping üles), samuti nõuda Lepingus sätestatud
juhtudel leppetrahvi, kui Töövõtja ei pea kinni Lepingus, selle lisades või muudes Lepingu
juurde kuuluvates dokumentides sätestatud tähtaegadest, tingimustest ja maksumusest,
samuti kui Töövõtja ei täida või täidab mittevastavalt muid endale Lepinguga võetud
kohustusi.
4.2. Tellija on kohustatud:
4.2.1. esitama Töö teostamiseks vajalikud andmed ja informatsiooni või korraldama neile
juurdepääsu;
4.2.2. Töövõtja esitatud Töö üle vaatama ja vastu võtma, kui Töö on teostatud nõuetekohaselt ja
vastab Lepingu Lisas 2 toodud nõuetele;
4.2.3. Töö mittevastavuse korral Lepingu tingimustele teatama sellest Töövõtjale punktis 2.4
nimetatud tähtaja jooksul koos puuduste kõrvaldamiseks sätestatud tähtajaga;
4.2.4. maksma Töövõtjale Töö eest tasu punktis 3 sätestatud tingimustel.
5. Töövõtja õigused ja kohustused
5.1. Töövõtjal on õigus:
5.1.1. nõuda Tellijalt Töö teostamiseks vajalike andmete ja informatsiooni esitamist või neile
juurdepääsu võimaldamist;
5.1.2. kasutada Töö teostamisel oma töömeetodeid ja -vahendeid;
5.1.3. saada nõuetekohaselt teostatud ja Tellija vastuvõetud Töö eest punktis 3 ettenähtud tasu.
5.2. Töövõtja on kohustatud:
5.2.1. teostama Töö professionaalselt ja nõuetekohaselt vastavalt Lepingu tingimustele, hanke
alusdokumentidele, pakkumusele ja Poolte kirjalikult taasesitatavas vormis kokku lepitud
täpsustustele ning andma Töö Tellijale või tema näidatud isikule üle Lepingus sätestatud
tähtaegadeks ja korras;
5.2.2. järgima Töö teostamisel Lepingus ja õigusaktides sätestatud nõudeid ning tagama Lepingust
tulenevate kohustuste täitmise kooskõlas heade kommetega;
5.2.3. kaasama Töö teostamiseks kolmanda isiku Tellija nõusolekul;
5.2.4. lubama Tellijal kontrollida Töö teostamise käiku ja esitama Tellija nõudmisel Töö teostamise
kohta informatsiooni;
5.2.5. Tellija nõudmisel asendama töölõike samaväärsetega ilma lisatasuta, kui Töö teostamise
käigus selgub, et vahetus aitab paremini saavutada Töö tulemusi eeldusel, et asendatavat
töölõiku ei ole veel sooritama asutud ja Töövõtja meeskonna ressursivajadus on vahetatavate
töölõikude puhul sarnane või on uus töölõik kaetav Töövõtja meeskonna vaba ressursiga;
5.2.6. esitlema Töö tulemusi koos loodud slaididega kahel avalikul üritusel;
5.2.7. asendama Töövõtja esindajat teise isikuga vaid Tellija eelneval kirjalikul loal ja vähemalt
samaväärse kvalifikatsiooniga isiku vastu;
5.2.8. vahetama Lepingu Lisas 4 nimetatud meeskonnaliiget vaid Tellija eelneval kirjalikul loal
ja vähemalt samaväärse kvalifikatsiooniga isiku vastu;
5.2.9. Töö Lepingu tingimustele mittevastavuse korral kõrvaldama Tellija nõudmisel puuduse Töös
või esitama uue, Lepingu tingimustele vastava Töö Tellija sätestatud tähtaja jooksul.
6. Vastutus
6.1. Lepingut rikkunud Pool on kohustatud tekkinud kahjud teisele Poolele hüvitama.
6.2. Juhul, kui Töövõtja ei esita Tellijast mitteolenevatel põhjustel tähtajaks tellitud Tööd, on Tellijal
õigus nõuda Töövõtjalt leppetrahvi 0,25% üle andmata või teostamata Töö vastava etapi
maksumusest päevas iga viivitatud päeva eest, kuni Töö üleandmiseni. Tellijal on õigus
leppetrahvi summa võrra vähendada Töövõtjale Töö eest tasumisele kuuluvat vastava etapi
maksumust.
6.3. Juhul, kui Töövõtja rikub muid Lepingust tulenevaid kohustusi, on Tellijal õigus esitada nõue
rikkumise kõrvaldamiseks, andes Töövõtjale rikkumise kõrvaldamiseks 10 tööpäeva. Kui
Töövõtja ei täida nõuet selleks antud tähtaja jooksul, on Tellijal õigus nõuda Töövõtjalt
leppetrahvi 30% Lepingu maksumusest.
6.4. Leppetrahvi nõudmine ei välista Tellija õigust kasutada Töövõtja suhtes teisi seadusega
ettenähtud õiguskaitsevahendeid. Lisaks leppetrahvi tasumisele on Tellijal õigus nõuda
Töövõtjalt Lepingu täitmist ja/või kahju hüvitamist osas, mida leppetrahv ei katnud.
6.5. Juhul, kui Töö mittevastavuse korral ei kõrvalda Töövõtja puudusi või ei esita uut,
nõuetekohaselt teostatud Tööd punktis 2.4 nimetatud tähtajaks, on Tellijal õigus nõuda punktis
6.2 nimetatud leppetrahvi ning lisaks leppetrahvi nõudele Lepingust taganeda või Leping üles
öelda ja nõuda tekitatud kahju hüvitamist osas, mida leppetrahv ei katnud.
6.6. Tellija kohustub nõuetekohaselt teostatud ja tema poolt heakskiidetud Töö eest arve
mitteõigeaegse tasumise korral maksma Töövõtjale viivist 0,05% õigeaegselt tasumata summalt
iga tasumisega viivitatud päeva eest. Viivise arvestamist alustatakse viieteistkümnendast
päevast ning arvestatakse iga viivitatud päeva eest.
6.7. Lepingus sätestatud viiviste ja leppetrahvide tasumine ei vabasta Pooli Lepingust tulenevate
muude kohustuste täitmisest.
6.8. Poole koguvastutus seoses Lepingu täitmisega on piiratud punktis 3.1 nimetatud lepingutasu
summaga.
7. Vääramatu jõud
7.1. Pooled vastutavad kohustuste rikkumise eest, välja arvatud juhul, kui rikkumine on vabandatav.
Kohustuse rikkumine on vabandatav, kui selle on põhjustanud prognoosimatud või Poole
tegevusest olenematud asjaolud (vääramatu jõud). Vääramatu jõud on asjaolu, mida Pool ei
saanud mõjutada ja mõistlikkuse põhimõttest lähtudes ei saanud temalt oodata, et ta Lepingu
sõlmimise ajal selle asjaoluga arvestaks, seda väldiks, takistava asjaolu või selle tagajärje
ületaks.
7.2. Vääramatu jõu esinemise korral muutuvad Lepingus nimetatud tähtajad perioodi võrra, mille
jooksul vääramatu jõu tegurid takistavad Lepingu täitmist.
7.3. Pool, kes rikub kohustust vääramatu jõu asjaolude tõttu, peab vääramatu jõu asjaoludest ja nende
mõjust viivitamata teatama teisele Poolele pärast seda, kui Pool sai teada või pidi teada saama
vääramatu jõu asjaoludest. Poolel on kohustus võtta tarvitusele kõik võimalikud abinõud
vääramatu jõu asjaolude ning nende tagajärjel tekitatava kahju vältimiseks või mõju
vähendamiseks. Pool on kohustatud jätkama oma lepinguliste kohustuste täitmist niipea, kui
vääramatu jõu asjaolud on kõrvaldatud.
8. Teabe vahetamine
8.1. Pooled kohustuvad teist Poolt teavitama kõikidest asjaoludest, mis võivad mõjutada või
takistada Lepingus sätestatud kohustuste täitmist või õiguste realiseerimist.
8.2. Teade loetakse teisele Poolele kätte toimetatuks, kui:
8.2.1. teade on edastatud teisele Poolele elektronposti teel digitaalselt allkirjastatuna (teate
edastamise päeval);
8.2.2. teade on edastatud e-kirjaga ja selle kättesaamise kohta on esitatud kinnituskiri;
8.2.3. teade on üle antud allkirja vastu (teate allkirjastamise kuupäeval) või;
8.2.4. teade on saadetud postiasutuse tähitud kirjaga teise Poole näidatud aadressil (kui
postitamisest on möödunud kolm päeva).
8.3. Punktis 8.2 nimetatud viisil peavad olema edastatud eelkõige Poolte Lepingu lõpetamise
avaldused, samuti Poole nõue teisele Poolele, mis esitatakse tulenevalt Lepingu rikkumisest.
8.4. Informatiivset teadet võib anda ka telefoni ja e-kirja teel.
8.5. Kõigist muudatustest Lepingus nimetatud andmetes teatatakse teisele Poolele kahe tööpäeva
jooksul muudatuste tegemisest arvates.
9. Lepingu jõustumine, muutmine ja lõpetamine
9.1. Leping jõustub pärast Lepingu mõlemapoolset allakirjutamist ja kehtib kuni Poolte võetud
kohustuste nõuetekohase täitmiseni või ennetähtaegse lõpetamiseni.
9.2. Lepingut võib muuta kooskõlas riigihangete seaduses toodud reeglitega.
9.3. Pooltel on õigus ennetähtaegselt Lepingust taganeda või Leping üles öelda juhul, kui teine Pool
rikub oluliselt Lepingust tulenevaid kohustusi. Lepingu võib etteteatamistähtajata üles öelda
olulise lepingurikkumise puhul, mh juhul, kui Lepingu tingimustele mittevastava Töö esitamise
korral ei ole Töö puudust kõrvaldatud 15 tööpäeva jooksul temale Lepingu rikkumise lõpetamise
nõude esitamisest arvates.
10. Vaidluste lahendamine
10.1. Kõik Lepingu täitmisest, muutmisest, lõpetamisest või vastutuse kohaldamisest tulenevad
vaidlusküsimused lahendatakse läbirääkimiste teel.
10.2. Kui läbirääkimistega kokkulepet ei saavutata, lahendatakse vaidlus Eesti Vabariigi
õigusaktidega sätestatud korras Tellija asukohajärgses kohtus. Lepingu sisu puhul kohaldatakse
Eesti Vabariigis kehtivaid õigusakte.
10.3. Lepingu tõlgendamisel lähtutakse Poolte ühisest tegelikust tahtest, isegi kui see erineb sõnade
tavapärasest tähendusest. Kui Poolte ühist tegelikku tahet ei õnnestu kindlaks teha, tuleb
Lepingut tõlgendada nii, nagu teise Poolega samasugune mõistlik isik pidi Lepingut samade
asjaolude esinemise korral mõistma.
10.4. Lepingu tingimust tuleb tõlgendada koos Lepingu teiste tingimustega, andes igaühele neist
tähenduse, mis lähtub Lepingu kui terviku tähendusest.
11. Muud sätted
11.1. Kumbki Pool ei tohi Lepingust tulenevaid õigusi ja kohustusi anda üle kolmandale isikule ilma
teise Poole nõusolekuta.
11.2. Lepinguga seonduva konfidentsiaalse informatsiooni avaldamine kolmandatele isikutele on
lubatud vaid teise Poole eelneval kirjalikul nõusolekul. Lepingus sätestatud konfidentsiaalsuse
nõue ei laiene informatsiooni avaldamisele Poole audiitoritele, advokaatidele ja pankadele ning
juhtudel, kui Pool on õigusaktidest tulenevalt kohustatud informatsiooni avaldama. Töövõtja on
teadlik, et Leping on avalik, välja arvatud osades, mis on märgitud avaliku teabe seadusest
tulenevatel alustel asutusesiseseks kasutamiseks.
11.3. Töövõtja on teadlik, et Töö tulemused on vastavalt riigihanke alusdokumentidele avalikud ning
Tellijal on õigus neid ilma Töövõtja nõusolekuta avalikustada.
11.4. Leping allkirjastatakse digitaalselt.
11.5. Töö on teos autoriõiguse seaduse mõistes.
11.6. Varaliste õiguste loovutamine:
11.6.1. Töövõtja loovutab Tellijale kõik Tööga seonduvad autoriõiguse varalised õigused alates Töö
vastuvõtmisest Tellija poolt. Töövõtjal ei ole õigust anda Tellijale loovutatud õigustega
samasuguseid õigusi kolmandatele isikutele;
11.6.2. Töövõtja kinnitab, et tal on õigus Tellijale neid üle anda ning juhul, kui kolmandad isikud
esitavad Tellijale seoses nende õigustega mingeid nõudmisi, hüvitab Töövõtja Tellijale kõik
sellistest nõudmistest tulenevad kahjud ja kulud;
11.6.3. Tasu autoriõiguse varaliste õiguste loovutamise ja isiklike õiguste kasutusõiguse eest
sisaldub Lepingu punktis 3.1 nimetatud tasus.
11.7. Tellijal on õigus kasutada Tööd (teost) ja muid Töö tulemusi igal viisil, sh avaldada, levitada,
reprodutseerida, esitada, muuta või täiendada ilma territoriaalsete piiranguteta, sh üldkasutatavas
arvutivõrgus. Samuti võib Tellija kasutada teost viisil, mis toob kaasa või võib kaasa tuua teose
või selle osade olulises mahus töötlemise. Teose või selle osade avalikustamisel, refereerimisel
ja/või viitamisel kohustub Tellija viitama Töövõtjale.
11.8. Töö käigus välja töötatud originaalsed metoodikad ja uuringu käigus saadud, koostatud või
kogutud anonüümseks muudetud andmed ja muu materjali (näiteks küsimustikud, joonised,
juhendid, lisaandmed) annab Töövõtja Tellijale üle pärast Töö valmimist ning need kuuluvad
Tellijale. Töövõtja võib endale jätta materjalide ja andmete koopiad, kuid ilma Tellija eelneva
kirjaliku nõusolekuta ei tohi ta neid kasutada Lepinguga mitteseotud eesmärkidel, v.a teadus- ja
õppetöös.
12. Poolte volitatud esindajad
12.1. Tellija volitatud esindaja Lepingu tingimuste täitmisel, täitmise kontrollimisel ja Töö
vastuvõtmisel on Kristjan Lepp e-post:
[email protected], telefon +372 639 7602.
12.2. Töövõtja volitatud esindaja Lepingu tingimuste täitmisel ja kontrollimisel ja Töö üleandmisel on
Merlin Rehema, e-post
[email protected], telefon +372 5860 5876.
12.3. Tellija volitatud esindajal on õigus esindada Tellijat kõikides Lepinguga seotud küsimustes, välja
arvatud Lepingu muutmine, tähtajalise Lepingu ühepoolne lõpetamine ning leppetrahvi, viivise
ja/või kahjude hüvitamise nõude esitamine.
12.4. Juhul, kui Pool asendab oma esindaja teisega, teatab ta sellest teisele Poolele vastavalt punktis
8 sätestatule.
Poolte allkirjad
Tellija: Töövõtja:
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt) (allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Timo Tatar Lauri Tammiste
energeetika ja maavarade asekantsler juhatuse liige
kantsleri ülesannetes
LISA 1
Teostatud töö üleandmise ja vastuvõtmise akt hanke nr 234808 raames
Teostatava töö nimetus: „Eesti üleminek süsinikneutraalsele soojus- ning jahutusmajandusele aastaks
2050“
Töö teostaja andmed (täpsustada töö teostaja, üleantav töö):
Töö maksumus: Maksumus eurodes KM-ta:
Maksumus eurodes KM-ga:
Teostatud töö kirjeldus:
Töö on teostatud kokkulepitud mahus riigihanke viitenumber 234808 raames ning vastavalt riigihanke
alusdokumentide tingimustele.
Töö vastuvõtjale anti üle järgmised andmefailid:
Kõik kirjalikud materjalid on koostatud….. keeles
Töö vastuvõtja: Töö üleandja:
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium Sihtasutus Stockholmi Keskkonnainstituudi
Tallinna Keskus
Kristjan Lepp Merlin Lindemaa
Arendusnõunik Projektijuht
Allkirjastatud digitaalselt Allkirjastatud digitaalselt