dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Sotsiaalministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Küsimustik

Sotsiaalministeerium · 14. juuli 2020
Viit
1.4-2/2212-1
Registreeritud
14. juuli 2020
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
WHO
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
1.4 EL otsustusprotsess ja rahvusvaheline koostöö
Sari
1.4-2 Rahvusvahelise koostöö korraldamisega seotud kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
1.4-2/2020
Vastutaja
Elen Ohov (Sotsiaalministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Euroopa Liidu ja väliskoostöö osakond)
Lahendamise tähtaeg
7. august 2020

Failid

  • 📎Annex 1. Country profiles_ questionnaire_.docx862 KB
  • 📎Annex 2. Survey.docx111 KB
  • 📎E-kiri.pdf86 KB
  • 📎SDG Survey Report 090720 - for consultation .docx2172 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Annex 1. Country Profiles – tables Country Health-related SDG index National Development Plan National Health Plan Voluntary National Review Health priorities Armenia 68 Yes https://eeas.europa.eu/sites/eeas/files/armenia_development_strategy_for_2014-2025.pdf No Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20315Armenia_SDG_VNR_report.pdf Strengthening prevention of diseases through early diagnosis and treatment, with special emphasis on non-communicable diseases. A strong primary health care system needs to be in place, including increased accessibility to deprived populations, guaranteed availability of medicines. Develop and implement better standards in healthcare services. Ensure specialized inpatient medical care for vulnerable groups; improved maternal and child care; reproductive and adolescent health. Medical providers’ capacity building and professional development. Introduction of health insurance to enhance the financial sustainability of the overall health care system in the country. Belarus 55 Yes http://www.oneplanetnetwork.org/sites/default/files/belarus_ national_strategy_for_sd_to_2020.pdf Yes http://www.government.by/upload/docs/filecdf0f8 a76b95e004.PDF Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/conte nt/documents/16357Belarus.pdf Increasing life expectancy and health promotion Mather and Child Health NCD prevention and control (including CVD, cancer, alcoholism) CD (TB HIV) Health System modernization (quality of care and e-health) Belgium 77 Yes https://www.sdgs.be/sites/default/files/publication/attachments/brochure_sndd_fr_def.pdf No Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15721Belgium_Rev.pdf Access to health for all Adequate care supply in line with the needs of the population. A compass and modern organizational health system structure Correct pricing Efficiency of the health system Environmental Health Bulgaria 61 Yes https://www.eufunds.bg/archive2018/archive/documents/1357662496.pdf Yes https://www.mh.government.bg/media/filer_public/2016/09/12/nzs_2020.pdf No Creation of conditions for lifelong health for all Development of a fair, sustainable and effective healthcare system Quality and result-oriented Strengthening public health capacity. Croatia 67 Yes http://www.propisi.hr/print.php?id=15160 Yes https://zdravlje.gov.hr/UserDocsImages/dokumenti/Programi,%20projekti%20i%20strategije/Nacionalna%20strategija%20zdravstva%20-%20za%20web.pdf Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23943CROATIA_UN_final.pdf Noncommunicable diseases: i.e. cardiovascular diseases, cancer, chronic respiratory diseases and/or diabetes Child and adolescent health Healthy aging Cyprus 76 No No Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15886Cyprus.pdf Fully implement the National Health System by 1 June 2020. Czech Republic 69 Yes https://www.vlada.cz/assets/ppov/udrzitelny-rozvoj/projekt-OPZ/Strategic_Framework_CZ2030.pdf Yes Current health strategy: http://www.mzcr.cz/Verejne/dokumenty/informace-o-stavu-realizace-zdravi-2020-narodni-strategie-ochrany-a-podpory-zd_16291_3016_5.html New strategy: http://www.mzcr.cz/Verejne/obsah/zdravi-2030_4134_5.html Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15717Czech_Republic.pdf Healthy life expectancy is increasing for all groups of the population of the Czech Republic. The effects of health inequalities are decreasing. The public health care system is stable and the corresponding professional structure is developing - lower age average, higher remuneration. Healthy lifestyle is being supported with an emphasis on primary disease prevention and health promotion throughout life. Consumption of addictive substances as well as the burden of health-endangering substances and noise is reduced through better environmental quality. Estonia 6 8 Yes https://www.riigikantselei.ee/sites/default/files/content-editors/Failid/estonia_sds_2005.pdf Yes https://www.sm.ee/sites/default/files/content-editors/eesmargid_ja_tegevused/Tervis/Aruanded/rta_2009- 2020_2012_eng.pdf Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/10647estonia.pdf Healthy throughout the lifecourse and health and wellbeing is maintained and supported by the living environment and health system development . Increase life expectancy and healthy life years Inequality in health diminishes (based on gender, region, education etc ). Supporting healthy choices Person-centered healthcare Creating environments conducive to health Finland 79 Yes https://um.fi/documents/35732/48132/government_report_on_development_policy_2016 Yes https://stm.fi/en/strategy Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/10611Finland_VNR.pdf The overarching strategy of the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health reflects priority areas of work in the health and welfare sector in Finland. Including: active inclusion of people integrated services and benefits safe and healthy living and working environments financial sustainability wellbeing amidst the ongoing transformation of work. Hungary 67 Yes https://www.nfft.hu/documents/127649/4101265/NFFT-ENG-web.pdf/f692c792-424d-4f5a-9f9d-9e6200303148?t=1580130885736 Yes Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20137Voluntary_National_Review_of_Hungary_v2.pdf Promote the health-conscious behaviour and transmission to the future generation Stress reduction in the workplace and create working conditions. Launch prevention and screening programs Transmission of health-conscious behaviour patterns. Aid to the prevention and screening programs . Support the health-conscious behaviour transmission programs by the education Providing information about products that harmful for health and prohibiting and taxing them. Modernization the healthcare system Ireland 76 Yes https://www.dccae.gov.ie/en-ie/environment/topics/sustainable-development/sustainable-development-goals/Pages/National-Implementation-Plan-2018---2020.aspx Yes https://assets.gov.ie/9379/05384619bb2240c18c294b60578117e1.pdf https://assets.gov.ie/7555/62842eef4b13413494b13340fff9077d.pdf Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19382Ireland_Voluntary_National_Review_2018.pdf Increase proportion of people who are healthy at all stages of life Reduce health inequalities Protect the public from threats to health and wellbeing Create an environment where every sector of society can play their part Israel 82 Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.php?page=view&amp;nr=468&amp;type=504&amp;menu=139 Yes https://www.health.gov.il/PublicationsFiles/MOH-Work-plan-2018.pdf Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23576ISRAEL_13191_SDGISRAEL.pdf Digital Health as a tool to advance accessibility, quality and efficiency in healthcare services Positive Nutrition across all ages to combat NCDs and encourage healthy living Long-term Care in advanced community programmes The Ageing population and supporting community-based programming to handle the issues that arise within the context Advancing access to dental care across all sectors Vaccination programming Transitioning from hospital to community health programming Reducing the effects and prevalence AMR and other hospital acquired infections Latvia 64 Yes https://rio.jrc.ec.europa.eu/en/library/national-development-plan-latvia-2014-2020 Yes https://likumi.lv/ta/en/id/269591-on-the-public-health-policy-guidelines-2014-2020%20. Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19388Latvia_Implementation_of_the_SDGs.pdf To prevent inequality in the field of health by taking measures to ensure equal health promotion and health care opportunities for inhabitants. To reduce premature mortality from non-communicable diseases by reducing the negative impact of risk factors on health. To improve the health of a mother, father and child, to reduce infant mortality. To promote healthy and safe life and working environment, to reduce injuries and mortality from external causes of death. To reduce morbidity of inhabitants from communicable diseases. To ensure efficient management of the health care system and rational utilisation of resources. To improve access to health services and medicinal products. To provide sufficient human resources. Lithuania 58 Yes http://sdgtoolkit.org/wp- content/uploads/2017/02/NATIONAL-STRATEGY-FOR-SUSTAINABLE-DEVELOPMENT-Lithuania.pdf Yes https://e-seimas.lrs.lt/ portal/legalActEditions/lt/TAD/35834810004f11e4b0ef967b19d90c08?faces-redirect=true Yes https://sustainabledev elopment.un.org/content/documents/19673VNR_Lithuania_EN_updated.pdf Improve health of the Lithuanian population as well as longer life and reduced health inequities. Create safer social environment, reduce health inequities and social exclusion Create health promoting working and living environment Foster healthy lifestyle and its culture. Luxembourg 69 Yes https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/2018-european-semester-national-reform-programme-luxembourg-en.pdf No Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15709Luxembourg.pdf Eat healthily, move more Promotion of healthy nutrition at school with products of the agriculture sector Improve access to high quality health care National Cancer Plan National HIV Plan 2018-2022 National Hepatities Plan 2018 -2022 National Plan against drugs and associated addictions National T obacco Pla n National Plan promotion of emotional and sexual health Reduction of the number of road deaths Monaco N/A No No Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15697Monaco2.pdf Prévention et élimination des maladies Ensuring regulatory preparedness for public health emergency Strenthening rapid detection and risk assessment for potential health emergency Enhancing policies for risk reductions Assessing IHR core capacities Strethening health system governance Assessing drivers for epidemics Rational use of medicine and technologies Putting in place systems for acute emergencies Conducting impact analyses of health Norway 84 Yes https://www.regjeringen.no/globalassets/upload/fin/berekraftig/nat_action.pdf Yes https://www.regjeringen.no/no/dokumenter/meld.-st.-19-20182019/id2639770/sec1 Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/10692NORWAY%20HLPF%20REPORT%20-%20full%20version.pdf Communicable diseases Non-communicable diseases Substance abuse Pollution Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Implementation Portugal 71 No Yes http://1nj5ms2lli5hdggbe3mm7ms5-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/files/2015/06/Plano-Nacional-de-Saude-Revisao-e-Extensao-a-2020.pdf.pdf Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15766Portugal2017_EN_REV_FINAL_29_06_2017.pdf Reduce premature mortality Increase healthy life expectancy at 65 years Reduce the prevalence of smoking in the population aged ≥ 15 years and eliminate exposure to environmental tobacco smoke. Control the incidence and prevalence of overweight and obesity in children and the school population, in order to limit its growth by 2020 Portugal has also 12 Priority Health Programs on the subjects of: Healthy eating Physical activity Infections Control Antimicrobial Resistance Tobacco control Diabetes Brain-cardiovascular diseases Oncological diseases Respiratory diseases Viral hepatitis Infection HIV/AIDS Tuberculosis Mental health Poland 69 Yes https://www.gov.pl/documents/33377/436740/SOR_2017_streszczenie_en.pdf No (individual health policies available if you want to link here) Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19409Poland_VNR_20180615.pdf Improving diet, nutritional status and physical activity of the society. Prevention and resolution of problems related to the use of psychoactive substances, behavioral addictions and other hazardous behaviors. Prevention of mental health problems and improvement of mental well-being of society. Limit health risks resulting from physical, chemical and biological hazards in the external environment, workplace, residence, recreation &amp; education Promotion of healthy and active ageing Improvement of reproductive health Reduction of incidence and premature mortality due to cardiovascular diseases, malignant tumors, chronic respiratory diseases, diabetes Republic of Moldova 59 Yes https://moldova.un.org/en/15729-national-development-strategy-moldova-2030-approved-government No No Health education programmes Efficient healthcare system with individual safety element Universal health coverage, including develop an efficient health system with elements of individual insurance and incentives Protection against financial hardship Health policies in all areas to reduce NCD Increase medical knowledge of beneficiaries of services and patients, so they can apply this knowledge and skills obtained in their own interest Strengthen primary healthcare Reduce premature mortality caused by communicable and non-communicable diseases through prevention including screening and vaccination and individual universal access to sexual and reproductive health services Prevention and treatment of abusive drug use, alcohol consumption and smoking Health interventions to meet the needs of disadvantaged and marginalized persons (including access to services), especially of persons with physical Slovakia 73 Yes http://sdgtoolkit.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/NATIONAL-STRATEGY-FOR-SUSTAINABLE-DEVELOPMENT-FOR-THE-SLOVAK-REPUBLIC-.pdf Yes Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20131Agenda2030_VNR_Slovakia.pdf Implementation of integrated healthcare model with priority on first contact physicians (general practicioner for adults, children, gynecologist) Ensuring that the health care system is complemented by general practitioners and specialists through a resident program Implement medical prevention programs in the prevention of communicable and non-communicable diseases in cooperation with other health care services Redefine the hospital types and scope of the healthcare they provide, determine the catchment area, review types and structures of health care facilitie Reassessing the number and structure of acute beds and strengthening beds in aftercare, rehabilitation, nursing and nursing beds Functional reception and transmission of information between hospitals and other health care facilities in institutional and outpatient health care Implement public health programs (non-medical prevention, promotion of health awareness) and increase pandemic and bio-risk preparedness level. Raise the level of public health among socially disadvantaged communities Promote citizens´ health awareness and prevention using modern communication tools and technologies Improve the level of non-medical determinants of health through multi-sectoral cooperation (particularly in living, work and social environment) Slovenia 78 Yes https://www.gov.si/assets/vladne-sluzbe/SVRK/Strategija-razvoja-Slovenije-2030/Strategija_razvoja_Slovenije_2030.pdf Yes Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/16313Slovenia.pdf Raising NCDs burden Health inequalities Health threats Financial sustainability of healthcare system Patient mobility Satisfied patients and healthcare providers Greater contribution of health sector to economic and social development of Slovenia Health protection and disease prevention Primary healthcare strengthening Mental health Spain 74 No No Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/203295182018_VNR_Report_Spain_EN_ddghpbrgsp.pdf Primary and community care Equity in health Environment and health Climate change, ecological transition and health. Cohesion and strengthening of the National Health System. Health and development of the knowledge-driven economy. Oral health. Strategies against chronicity. Innovation in healthcare and health Financing, human resources policies and health training. Sweden 83 Yes https://www.regeringen.se/49e20a/contentassets/60a67ba0ec8a4f27b04cc4098fa6f9fa/handlingsplan-agenda-2030.pdf Yes Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/16033Sweden.pdf Create conditions for a good and equitable health in the population and close the avoidable health gaps within a generation Conditions in early life Knowledge, skills and education/training Work, working conditions and work environment Income and opportunities to earn a living Accommodation and neighbourhood Living habits Control, influence and participation Equitable and health-promoting health and medical services Switzerland 79 Yes https://www.are.admin.ch/are/en/home/sustainable-development/strategy-and-planning/sustainable-development-strategy-2016-2019.html Yes https://www.bag.admin.ch/bag/en/home/strategie-und-politik/gesundheit-2020/eine-umfassende-strategie-fuer-das-gesundheitswesen.html https://sustainabledev elopment.un.org/content/documents/10617Full%20Report%20HLPF%202016_Switzerland_EN%20fin.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20152Country_Report_Switzerland_2018_web.pdf Quality of life Equality of opportunity Transparency Quality of healthcare provision Tajikistan 57 Yes http://nafaka.tj/images/zakoni/new/strategiya_2030_en.pdf Y es Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/16021Tajikistan.pdf Maternal, Newborn &amp; Child Health Funding of healthcare Noncommunicable diseases Local Departments of Health Maternal, Newborn &amp; Child Health Turkey 66 Yes http://www.sbb.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/On-Birinci-Kalkinma-Plani.pdf Yes Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/107102030%20Agenda%20Turkey%20Report.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documen ts/23862TC_BUTCE_BAKANLIGI_RAPOR_09_EN.pdf Promoting and extending healthy life Strengthening primary health care services and making it more effective in health system Provision of accessible, effective, efficient and qualified health services Putting integrated health service delivery model into effect Increasing satisfaction of citizens and service providers and ensuring sustainability of health system Contributing to socioeconomic development of country and global health; developing national technologies in health industry and increasing nation Ukraine 48 Yes https://zakon1.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/5/2015 No No Reduce maternal mortality Minimize avoidable mortality among children under 5 years of age Stop the HIV / AIDS epidemic of tuberculosis, including through the use of innovative practices and treatments Reduce premature mortality from noncommunicable diseases Reduce premature mortality by a quarter, including through the introduction of innovative approaches to disease diagnosis Reduce the level of serious injury injuries due to road accidents, including through the use of innovative resuscitation, treatment and rehabilitation Ensure overall quality immunization of the population with the use of innovative drugs Reduce the prevalence of smoking among the population by using innovative means of informing them about the negative effects of smoking Reform the financing of the health care system United Kingdom 80 Yes http://sdgtoolkit.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/The-UK-Government-Sustainable-Development-Strategy.pdf No Yes https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23678UK_VNR.pdf To lead the health and care system to help people live more independent, healthier lives for longer Country snapshot b oxes Country snapshot – Armenia -65272 150258 0 0 Strengthening prevention of diseases through early diagnosis and treatment, with special emphasis on non-communicable diseases. A strong primary health care system needs to be in place, including increased accessibility to deprived populations, guaranteed availability of medicines. Develop and implement better standards in healthcare services. Ensure specialized inpatient medical care for vulnerable groups; improved maternal and child care; reproductive and adolescent health. Medical providers’ capacity building and professional development. Introduction of health insurance to enhance the financial sustainability of the overall health care system in the country National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://eeas.europa.eu/sites/eeas/files/armenia_development_strategy_for_2014-2025.pdf N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20315Armenia_SDG_VNR_report.pdf 41275 15240 0 0 Country snapshot – Belarus Increasing life expectancy and health promotion Mather and Child Health NCD prevention and control (including CVD, cancer, alcoholism) CD (TB HIV) Health System modernization (quality of care and e-health) National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR http://www.oneplanetnetwork.org/sites/default/files/belarus_national_strategy_for_sd_to_2020.pdf http://www.government.by/upload/docs/filecdf0f8a76b95e004.PDF https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/16357Belarus.pdf -5080 22860 0 0 Country snapshot – Belgium Access to health for all Adequate care supply in line with the needs of the population. A compass and modern organizational health system structure Correct pricing Efficiency of the health system Environmental Health National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.sdgs.be/sites/default/files/publication/attachments/brochure_sndd_fr_def.pdf N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15721Belgium_Rev.pdf 71120 147955 0 0 Country snapshot – Bulgaria Creation of conditions for lifelong health for all Development of a fair, sustainable and effective healthcare system Quality and result-oriented Strengthening public health capacity National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.eufunds.bg/archive2018/archive/documents/1357662496.pdf https://www.mh.government.bg/media/filer_public/2016/09/12/nzs_2020.pdf N/A -64770 156210 0 0 Country snapshot – Croatia Noncommunicable diseases: i.e. cardiovascular diseases, cancer, chronic respiratory diseases and/or diabetes Child and adolescent health Healthy aging National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR http://www.propisi.hr/print.php?id=15160 https://zdravlje.gov.hr/UserDocsImages/dokumenti/Programi,%20projekti%20i%20strategije/Nacionalna%20strategija%20zdravstva%20-%20za%20web.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23943CROATIA_UN_final.pdf -3516 5942 0 0 Country snapshot – Cyprus Fully implement the National Health System by 1 June 2020. National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR N/A N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15886Cyprus.pdf Country snapshot – Czech Republic -65036 222678 0 0 Healthy life expectancy is increasing for all groups of the population of the Czech Republic. The effects of health inequalities are decreasing. The public health care system is stable and the corresponding professional structure is developing - lower age average, higher remuneration. Healthy lifestyle is being supported with an emphasis on primary disease prevention and health promotion throughout life. Consumption of addictive substances as well as the burden of health-endangering substances and noise is reduced through better environmental quality. National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.vlada.cz/assets/ppov/udrzitelny-rozvoj/projekt-OPZ/Strategic_Framework_CZ2030.pdf Current strategy: http://www.mzcr.cz/Verejne/obsah/zdravi-2020_3016_5.html New strategy: http://www.mzcr.cz/Verejne/obsah/zdravi-203 0 _4134_5.html https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15717Czech_Republic.pdf -39517 144012 0 0 Country snapshot – Estonia Healthy throughout the lifecourse and health and wellbeing is maintained and supported by the living environment and health system development Increase life expectancy and healthy life years Inequality in health diminishes (based on gender, region, education etc ). Supporting healthy choices Person-centered healthcare Creating environments conducive to health National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.riigikantselei.ee/sites/default/files/content-editors/Failid/estonia_sds_2005.pdf https://www.sm.ee/sites/default/files/content-editors/eesmargid_ja_tegevused/Tervis/Aruanded/rta_2009-2020_2012_eng.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/10647estonia.pdf 6482 97848 0 0 Country snapshot – Finland The overarching strategy of the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health reflects priority areas of work in the health and welfare sector in Finland. Including: active inclusion of people integrated services and benefits safe and healthy living and working environments financial sustainability wellbeing amidst the ongoing transformation of work. National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://um.fi/documents/35732/48132/government_report_on_development_policy_2016 https://stm.fi/en/strategy https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/10611Finland_VNR.pdf Country snapshot – Hungary -62451 199804 0 0 Promote the health-conscious behaviour and transmission to the future generation Stress reduction in the workplace and create working conditions. Launch prevention and screening programs Transmission of health-conscious behaviour patterns. Aid to the prevention and screening programs Support the health-conscious behaviour transmission programs by the education Providing information about products that harmful for health and prohibiting and taxing them. Modernization the healthcare system. National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.nfft.hu/documents/127649/4101265/NFFT-ENG-web.pdf/f692c792-424d-4f5a-9f9d-9e6200303148?t=1580130885736 https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20137Voluntary_National_Review_of_Hungary_v2.pdf Country snapshot – Ireland 4623 83539 0 0 Increase proportion of people who are healthy at all stages of life Reduce health inequalities Protect the public from threats to health and wellbeing Create an environment where every sector of society can play their part National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.dccae.gov.ie/en-ie/environment/topics/sustainable-development/sustainable-development-goals/Pages/National-Implementation-Plan-2018---2020.aspx https://assets.gov.ie/9379/05384619bb2240c18c294b60578117e1.pdf https://assets.gov.ie/7555/62842eef4b13413494b13340fff9077d.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19382Ireland_Voluntary_National_Review_2018.pdf Country snapshot – Israel -65066 187354 0 0 Digital Health as a tool to advance accessibility, quality and efficiency in healthcare services Positive Nutrition across all ages to combat NCDs and encourage healthy living Long-term Care in advanced community programmes The Ageing population and supporting community-based programming to handle the issues that arise within the context Advancing access to dental care across all sectors Vaccination programming Transitioning from hospital to community health programming Reducing the effects and prevalence AMR and other hospital acquired infections National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.php?page=view&amp;nr=468&amp;type=504&amp;menu=139 https://www.health.gov.il/PublicationsFiles/MOH-Work-plan-2018.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23576ISRAEL_13191_SDGISRAEL.pdf Country snapshot – Latvia -16983 90775 0 0 To prevent inequality in the field of health by taking measures to ensure equal health promotion and health care opportunities for inhabitants. To reduce premature mortality from non-communicable diseases by reducing the negative impact of risk factors on health. To improve the health of a mother, father and child, to reduce infant mortality. To promote healthy and safe life and working environment, to reduce injuries and mortality from external causes of death. To reduce morbidity of inhabitants from communicable diseases. To ensure efficient management of the health care system National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://rio.jrc.ec.europa.eu/en/library/national-development-plan-latvia-2014-2020 https://likumi.lv/ta/en/id/269591-on-the-public-health-policy-guidelines-2014-2020%20. https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19388Latvia_Implementation_of_the_SDGs.pdf Country snapshot – Lithuania 67931 30007 0 0 Improve health of the Lithuanian population as well as longer life and reduced health inequities. Create safer social environment, reduce health inequities and social exclusion Create health promoting working and living environment Foster healthy lifestyle and its culture National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR http://sdgtoolkit.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/NATIONAL-STRATEGY-FOR-SUSTAINABLE-DEVELOPMENT-Lithuania.pdf https://e-seimas.lrs.lt/portal/legalActEditions/lt/TAD/35834810004f11e4b0ef967b19d90c08?faces-redirect=true https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19673VNR_Lithuania_EN_updated.pdf Country snapshot – Luxembourg Eat healthily, move more -65065 60487 0 0 Promotion of healthy nutrition at school with products of the agriculture sector Improve access to high quality health care National Cancer Plan National HIV Plan 2018-2022 National Hepatities Plan 2018 -2022 National Plan against drugs and associated addictions National Tobacco Plan National Plan promotion of emotional and sexual health Reduction of the number of road deaths National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/2018-european-semester-national-reform-programme-luxembourg-en.pdf N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15709Luxembourg.pdf Country snapshot – Monaco Prévention et élimination des maladies Ensuring regulatory preparedness for public health emergency Strenthening rapid detection and risk assessment for potential health emergency Enhancing policies for risk reductions Assessing IHR core capacities Strethening health system governance Assessing drivers for epidemics Rational use of medicine and technologies Putting in place systems for acute emergencies Conducting impact analyses of health National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR N/A N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15697Monaco2.pdf Country snapshot – Norway 4283 19110 0 0 Communicable diseases Non-communicable diseases Substance abuse Pollution Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Implementation National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.regjeringen.no/globalassets/upload/fin/berekraftig/nat_action.pdf https://www.regjeringen.no/no/dokumenter/meld.-st.-19-20182019/id2639770/sec1 https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/10692NORWAY%20HLPF%20REPORT%20-%20full%20version.pdf Country snapshot – Portugal Reduce premature mortality Increase healthy life expectancy at 65 years -65215 246289 0 0 Reduce the prevalence of smoking in the population aged ≥ 15 years and eliminate exposure to environmental tobacco smoke. Control the incidence and prevalence of overweight and obesity in children and the school population, in order to limit its growth by 2020 Portugal has also 12 Priority Health Programs on the subjects of: Healthy eating Physical activity Infections Control Antimicrobial Resistance Tobacco control Diabetes Brain-cardiovascular diseases Oncological diseases Respiratory diseases Viral hepatitis Infection HIV/AIDS Tuberculosis Mental health National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR N/A http://1nj5ms2lli5hdggbe3mm7ms5-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/files/2015/06/Plano-Nacional-de-Saude-Revisao-e-Extensao-a-2020.pdf.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/15766Portugal2017_EN_REV_FINAL_29_06_2017.pdf Country snapshot – Poland -65065 172188 0 0 Improving diet, nutritional status and physical activity of the society. Prevention and resolution of problems related to the use of psychoactive substances, behavioral addictions and other hazardous behaviors. Prevention of mental health problems and improvement of mental well-being of society. Limit health risks resulting from physical, chemical and biological hazards in the external environment, workplace, residence, recreation &amp; education Promotion of healthy and active ageing Improvement of reproductive health National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.gov.pl/documents/33377/436740/SOR_2017_streszczenie_en.pdf N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19409Poland_VNR_20180615.pdf Country snapshot – Republic of Moldova Health education programmes Efficient healthcare system with individual safety element -64888 365420 0 0 Universal health coverage, including develop an efficient health system with elements of individual insurance and incentives Protection against financial hardship Health policies in all areas to reduce NCD Increase medical knowledge of beneficiaries of services and patients, so they can apply this knowledge and skills obtained in their own interest Strengthen primary healthcare Reduce premature mortality caused by communicable and non-communicable diseases through prevention including screening and vaccination and individual universal access to sexual and reproductive health services Prevention and treatment of abusive drug use, alcohol consumption and smoking Health interventions to meet the needs of disadvantaged and marginalized persons (including access to services), especially of persons with physical National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://moldova.un.org/en/15729-national-development-strategy-moldova-2030-approved-government N/A N/A Country snapshot – Slovakia Implementation of integrated healthcare model with priority on first contact physicians (general practicioner for adults, children, gynecologist) -65080 367665 0 0 Ensuring that the health care system is complemented by general practitioners and specialists through a resident program Implement medical prevention programs in the prevention of communicable and non-communicable diseases in cooperation with other health care services Redefine the hospital types and scope of the healthcare they provide, determine the catchment area, review types and structures of health care facilitie s Reassessing the number and structure of acute beds and strengthening beds in aftercare, rehabilitation, nursing and nursing beds Functional reception and transmission of information between hospitals and other health care facilities in institutional and outpatient health care Implement public health programs (non-medical prevention, promotion of health awareness) and increase pandemic and bio-risk preparedness level. Raise the level of public health among socially disadvantaged communities Promote citizens´ health awareness and prevention using modern communication tools and technologies Improve the level of non-medical determinants of health through multi-sectoral cooperation (particularly in living, work and social environment) . National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR http://sdgtoolkit.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/NATIONAL-STRATEGY-FOR-SUSTAINABLE-DEVELOPMENT-FOR-THE-SLOVAK-REPUBLIC-.pdf N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20131Agenda2030_VNR_Slovakia.pdf Country snapshot – Slovenia -6350 210820 0 0 Raising NCDs burden Health inequalities Health threats Financial sustainability of healthcare system Patient mobility Satisfied patients and healthcare providers National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.gov.si/assets/vladne-sluzbe/SVRK/Strategija-razvoja-Slovenije-2030/Strategija_razvoja_Slovenije_2030.pdf N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/16313Slovenia.pdf -65287 195196 0 0 Country snapshot – Spain Primary and community care Equity in health Environment and health Climate change, ecological transition and health. Cohesion and strengthening of the National Health System. Health and development of the knowledge-driven economy. Oral health. Strategies against chronicity. Innovation in healthcare and health Financing, human resources policies and health training. National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR N/A N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/203295182018_VNR_Report_Spain_EN_ddghpbrgsp.pdf Country snapshot – Sweden -65066 176471 0 0 Create conditions for a good and equitable health in the population and close the avoidable health gaps within a generation Conditions in early life Knowledge, skills and education/training Work, working conditions and work environment Income and opportunities to earn a living Accommodation and neighbourhood Living habits Control, influence and participation Equitable and health-promoting health and medical services National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www .regeringen.se/49e20a/contentassets/60a67ba0ec8a4f27b04cc4098fa6f9fa/handlingsplan-agenda-2030.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment .un.org/content/documents/16033Sweden.pdf Country snapshot – Switzerland -65065 74 0 0 Quality of life Equality of opportunity Transparency Quality of healthcare provision National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://www.are.admin.ch/are/en/home/sustainable-development/strategy-and-planning/sustainable-development-strategy-2016-2019.html https://www.bag.admin.ch/bag/en/home/strategie-und-politik/gesundheit-2020/eine-umfassende-strategie-fuer-das-gesundheitswesen.html https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/10617Full%20Report%20HLPF%202016_Switzerland_EN%20fin.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/20152Country_Report_Switzerland_2018_web.pdf 4283 184136 0 0 Country snapshot – Tajikistan Maternal, Newborn &amp; Child Health Funding of healthcare Noncommunicable diseases Local Departments of Health Maternal, Newborn &amp; Child Health National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR http://nafaka.tj/images/zakoni/new/strategiya_2030_en.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23678UK_VNR.pdf Country snapshot – Turkey -64844 200099 0 0 Promoting and extending healthy life Strengthening primary health care services and making it more effective in health system Provision of accessible, effective, efficient and qualified health services Putting integrated health service delivery model into effect Increasing satisfaction of citizens and service providers and ensuring sustainability of health system Contributing to socioeconomic development of country and global health; developing national technologies in health industry and increasing nation National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR http://www.sbb.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/On-Birinci-Kalkinma-Plani.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/107102030%20Agenda%20Turkey%20Report.pdf https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23862TC_BUTCE_BAKANLIGI_RAPOR_09_EN.pdf Country snapshot – Ukraine -65139 279149 0 0 Reduce maternal mortality Minimize avoidable mortality among children under 5 years of age Stop the HIV / AIDS epidemic of tuberculosis, including through the use of innovative practices and treatments Reduce premature mortality from noncommunicable diseases Reduce premature mortality by a quarter, including through the introduction of innovative approaches to disease diagnosis Reduce the level of serious injury injuries due to road accidents, including through the use of innovative resuscitation, treatment and rehabilitation Ensure overall quality immunization of the population with the use of innovative drugs Reduce the prevalence of smoking among the population by using innovative means of informing them about the negative effects of smoking Reform the financing of the health care system National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR https://zakon1.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/5/2015 N/A N/A Country snapshot – United Kingdom -974 49560 0 0 To lead the health and care system to help people live more independent, healthier lives for longer National Development Plan National Health Plan VNR http://sdgtoolkit.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/The-UK-Government-Sustainable-Development-Strategy.pdf N/A https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/23678UK_VNR.pdf Survey to assess Member States’ progress in implementing the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development based on the WHO European Region Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development for better Health and Well-being At the 67th session of the Regional Co mmittee for Europe in 2017, Member States of the WHO European Region adopted the r oadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, building on Health 2020, the European policy for health a nd well-being (EUR/RC67/9) ( hereafter referred to as ‘t he r oadmap ’ ) . The roadmap aims to assist Member States of the WHO European Region strengthen their capacities to achieve better, more equitable, sustainable health and well-being for all at all ages. T o advance the implementation of both the 2030 Agenda and Health 2020 . t he roadmap proposes 5 interdependent strategic directions and 4 enabling measures : Strategic directions Advancing governance and leadership Leaving no one behind Preventing disease and addressing health determinants Establishing healthy places, settings and resilient communities Strengthening health systems for universal health coverage. Enablers Investment for health Multi-partner cooperation Health literacy, research and innovation Monitoring and evaluation This questionnaire aims to assess progress in alignment and implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) based on the application of the roadmap strategic directions and enabler measures. Accordingly, t he questionnaire is structured in 9 blocks to facilitate the collection of information . Completing the survey Click Next to begin the survey. You can either go through each section /block in chronological order by clicking Next or switch between them using the Question Index dropdown menu , in the top right corner. The survey can be saved and returned to at any time by clicking Resume later also in the top right corner. Closing the window tab without clicking Resume later , will result in some responses be ing lost. P revious ly saved answers and comments can be adjusted at any time until the survey is finali z ed by clicking Submit . In an effort to reduce the response time, t he survey has automatic skips, which means that certain questions are hidden depending on your previous answers. You are encouraged to select the answer that is most representative for your country and it may require contact with other relevant stak eholders/bodies. You may also be require d to upload and/or indicate web-links if available . Before you begin, it is advisable to have the following documentation (or similar) at hand for referencing : National d evelopment planning frameworks ( policy, s trategy or equivalent ) N ational h ealth planning frameworks ( plan , policy , strategy or equivalent ) Public health plan/policy/strategy or equivalent Voluntary n ational r eport Institutional mechanism for SDG implementation You will not be able to use Internet Explorer (IE) to complete this survey. Please use one of the following browsers: Chrome, Firefox or Opera. If you do not have access to any of these browsers, please fill in the Word version of the survey and return with any relevant supporting documents/evidence to the email provided below. Submission of the survey After you have submitted the survey, we will notify you that it has been received and we will review your responses to ensure the survey is valid and complete. We may then follow-up with you for further information or clarification. We thank you for your valuable time and input. Helpdesk If you require any support while completing the survey or have any questions on how to complete it , please contact E milia Aragon, Technical Officer, Health and Sustainable Development at [email protected] . Contact information Name and Surname _________________________________________________ Job title ______________________________________________________ Inst itution /Organization __________________________________________ Country ______________________________________________________ Email Address _________________________________________________ Phone Number __ ( _ + ______ ) ________________________________________ Block 1. Advancing governance and leadership Objective: to strengthen leadership, governance and investment for health to maximize co-benefits for health and sustainable development and to achieve the highest attainable standard of health and well-being for all at all ages and for future generations . 1.A Does your country have an overarching national sustainable development framework, strategy or action plan ? Overarching national planning frameworks refer to national sustainable development strategies, visioning documents, or roadmaps that integrate economic, social and environmental objectives into one strategically focused blueprint for action at the national level. Yes . N o . Please , explain the strategic approach used in your country to achieve the S ustainable D evelopment G oals. F ocus on providing information regarding the domestic priorities for health and sustainable development of your country as well as the coordination mechanisms set to addressing the priorities, financing and monitoring progress : (limit 200 0 characters) __________________________________________________________________ If you answered yes for question 1.A, please move to question 1.A.1 If you answered no for question 1.A, please move to question 1.B 1.A . 1 S pecify the year in which the national sustainable development planning framework was a pproved b y relevant government authority and the expiration date __ ( mm/yy ) __ - ___ (mm/yy) __. 1. A . 2 Has the n ational sustainable d evelopment planning framework been modified since its adoption? Yes No If you answered yes for question 1.A.2, please move to question 1.A.2.A. If you answered no for question 1.A.2, ple ase move to question 1.A.3 1. A . 2.A Please explain your response and indicate the key reason ( s ) for the modification and date ( s ) if available : Limit 1750 characters (e.g. change of national priorities/agenda, adoption of international commitments like the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, among others). Date (mm/yy) 1. A . 3 Does the national sustainable d evelopment planning framework include health and wellbeing as a development priority ? H ealth and wellbeing as a development priority , including measures to improve population health and well-being by considering health in all policies and reducing health inequalities . Yes No 1. A . 4 From the following priority areas, please select those that are included in the n ational sustainable d evelopment planning frameworks : ( please select as many options as applicable ) . Life-course approach Child and adolescent health (SDG targets 3.2, 4.2). (Examples of measures include: ending preventable deaths of mothers, newborns and children; ensuring health and wellbeing of mothers and children by reducing malnutrition, improving access to sexual and reproductive health; ensuring access to good-quality early childhood development; expanding enabling environments for children and adolescent’s health and wellbeing . ) Healthy aging ( SDG 3 , 5, 10 ) . ( Examples of measures include: prevention of falls; promotion of physical activity; vaccination of older people and prevention of infectious disease in health-care settings; public support for informal care giving with a focus on home care, including self-care; building capacity in geriatrics and gerontology among the health and social care workforce; prevention of social isolation and social exclusion; strategies to ensure the quality of care for older people, with a focus on dementia care and palliative care for long-term patients; prevention of elder maltreatment . ) Improve w omen’s and men’s health ( SDG 5 and 3). ( Examples of measures include: strengthening governance for the health and wellbeing of women and men ; eliminating discriminatory values, norms and practices that affect the health and well-being of girls and women; making gender equality a priority; tackling the impact of gender and social, economic, cultural and environmental determinants on women’s and men’s health and well-being; making health systems gender responsive; improving health promotion with gender-transformative approaches . ) Sexual and reproductive health (SDG targets 3.1, 3.7 and SDG 5). (Examples of measures include: guaranteeing universal access to sexual and reproductive health and eliminating inequities; enabling all people to make informed choices about their sexual and reproductive health; ensuring sexual and reproductive human rights are respected, protected and fulfilled . ) Noncommunicable diseases and risk factors Healthy lifestyles: healthy eating, reformulation of food products, increasing physical activity, reducing tobacco use, reducing the harmful use of alcohol and/or improving air quality (SDG targets 2.2, 3.4, 3.5, 3a, 3.9) . (Examples of measures include: promoting healthy consumption via fiscal and marketing policies; reformulating and improving product: salt, fats and sugars; reducing salt consumption; promoting active living and mobility; promoting clean air . ) Noncommunicable diseases: i.e. cardiovascular diseases, cancer, chronic respiratory diseases and/or diabetes (SDG target 3.4) . (Examples of measures include: providing access to early detection and effective treatment; providing access to cardio-metabolic risk assessment and management; providing access to vaccinations and relevant communicable disease control . ) Communicable diseases Antimicrobial resistance ( SDG 3 ) . (Examples of measures include: improving awareness and understanding of antimicrobial resistance; strengthening knowledge and evidence base through surveillance and research; reducing the incidence of infection through effective sanitation, hygiene and infection-prevention; optimizing the use of antimicrobial medicines in human and animal health; increasing investment in new medicines and technologies . ) Communicable Diseases: HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis, Viral Hepatitis and/or vector borne diseases (SDG target 3.3). (Examples of measures include: strengthening programmes for the control of infectious diseases; providing adequate access to services, including access to safe and affordable medications and vaccines; integrating patient-centred care and prevention services; focusing prevention strategies for vulnerable populations . ) Immunizations (SDG targets 3.8, 3b) . (Examples of measures include: strengthening and achieving financial sustainability of national immunizations programmes; eliminating measles and rubella; addressing vaccine hesitancy; tailoring immunization programmes to reach underserved groups; investing in research and development . ) Health system strengthening for universal health coverage Financial protection (SDG target 3.8) . (Examples of measures include: promoting policies to reduce out-of-pocket payments; ensuring adequate public financing for health systems; reducing fragmentation in health system funding channels; adopting strategic purchasing mechanisms; ensuring effective and equitable coverage decisions based on systematics, evidence-based and transparent processes . ) Fostering environmental sustainability of health systems (SDG 3, 6, 12, 13, 14 and 15) . (Examples of measures include: minimizing and adequately managing waste and hazardous chemicals; promoting an efficient management of resources; promoting sustainable procurement; reducing health systems’ emissions of greenhouse gases and air pollution; prioritizing disease prevention, health promotion and public health services; engaging the health workforce as an agent of sustainability; increasing community resilience and promoting local assets; creating innovative models of care . ) Health information and health information systems (SDG target s 17.7 and 17.8) . ( Examples of measures include: generating, measuring, analyzing, coordinating and promoting the use of data and information for policies to improve health and well-being and reduce inequalities . ) Q uality-assured, affordable medicines , vaccines and health products (SDG target 3b) . ( Examples of measures include: improving access to essential medicines and medical devices; supporting the appropriate use of medical products; improving efficiency of procurement systems; promoting effective regulations and quality control; promoting responsible use of medicines and medical devices; promoting research and development . ) Sustainable and resilient health workforce (SDG target 3c) . ( Examples of measures include: rethinking the roles of health workers and optimizing the skill mix; investing in and transforming health workforce education and training; improving the performance of health workers; establishing policies to ensure a sufficient and sustainable health workforce; ensuring the availability of the health workforce to quickly respond to emergencies or pandemics . ) Transforming health services to meet the current and emergent health challenges ( SDG target 3.8) . (Examples of measures include: strengthening the integration of primary health care and public health services, hospitals and social care; strengthening key processes of designing care, organizing providers and settings, managing services and improving quality . ) Emergencies All-hazard, multisectoral preparedness and response to health emergencies (SDG targets 1.5, 3d, 11.5) . B uilding strong public health-oriented and people-centred health systems, institutions and networks based on the essential public health functions and core capacities under the International Health Regulations (2005) (SDG target 3d). Strengthening adaptive capacity and resilience to health risks related to climate change ( SDG 13) and/or supporting measures to mitigate climate change and achieve health co-benefits in line with the Paris Agreement. Health determinants Addressing and preventing interpersonal violence, including the negative consequences of interpersonal violence (SDG targets 5.2, 16.1 and 16.2). ( Examples of measures include: prevention of child maltreatment , elder ly maltreatment, violence against women, among others ) . Addressing e ducation and life - long learning (SDG 4) . (Examples of measures include: improving access to high quality education services and protection from financial hardship in using those services; ensuring quality conditions for early childhood development .) Addressing employment, income and living conditions (SDG 1, 2, 8, 10 and 16). (Examples of measures include: fostering a healthy workforce and tackling the health risks of being unemployed or insecurely employed; developing universal social protection and policy priorities and strategies in order to reduce inequities and remove barriers to protecting households from deprivation and poverty; implementing a basket of coordinated social, economic and environmental policy measures , target ing groups that are being left behind or excluded . ) Enabling cities and regions to become healthier , more inclusive, safe r , more resilient and more sustainable (SDG 3 and 11) . (Examples of measures include: engaging with local and city levels; adopting healthy urban planning; providing access to active transport and green spaces; tackling air pollution and improving road safety; tackling inequalities in health; ensuring coherence in municipal policies for better health outcomes; working with other levels of governance to create and enabling system for better health outcomes . ) Improving r o ad safety (SDG target 3.6 and 11.2) . (Examples of measures include: enhancing leadership on road safety; implementing measures for speed management, infrastructure design and improvement; vehicle safety standards; enforcement of traffic laws; improving survival after a road accident. ) Migration and health ( SDG 10) . (Examples of measures include: establishing a framework for collaborative action; advocating for the right to health of refugees; addressing the social determinants of health; achieving public health preparedness and ensuring an effective response; strengthening health systems and their resilience; preventing communicable diseases; preventing and reducing risks posed by noncommunicable diseases; ensuring ethical and effective health screening . ) Promotion of social inclusion, gender equality and human rights ( SDG 1, 5, 10 and 16) . ( Examples of measures include: strengthening governance for health and wellbeing; eliminating discriminatory values, norms and practices that affect health and wellbeing; tackling the impact of gender and social, economic, cultural and environmental determinants of health and wellbeing ; improving health system responses to women’s and men’s health and wellbeing . ) Reduction of e nvironmental pollution and degradation and health-related risks (SDG target 3.9 and SDG 7, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15) . ( Examples of measures include: improving indoor and outdoor air quality for all; access to safe drinking water, sanitation and hygiene for all; minimizing the adverse effects of chemicals on human health and the environment; preventing and eliminating the adverse environmental and health effects, costs and inequalities related to waste management and contaminated sites; strengthening adaptive capacity and resilience to health risks related to climate change ; building the environmental sustainability of health systems . ) If any of the priority areas in question 1.A.4 are selected, please move to question 1.A.4.A If no priority areas in question 1.A .4 are selected, please move to question 1.A.5. 1. A . 4.A Please indicate the level of implementation of the health and wellbeing priority areas included in your country’s n ational sustainable d evelopment planning framework : High ( action is being taken on more than 75% of health and wellbeing priorities ) Moderate ( action is being taken on 50-75% of health and wellbeing priorities ) Low ( action is being taken on less than 50% of health and wellbeing priorities ) None ( no action is being taken ) 1. A . 4.B What is the level of alignment of the health priorities identified in the national sustainable development planning framework compared to the priorities stated in the national health planning framework? High ( m ore than 75% of health priorities are aligned ) Moderate (50-75% of health priorities are aligned) Low ( l ess than 50% of priorities are aligned) None ( n o alignment ) 1. A . 4.C Does the n ational sustainable d evelopment planning framework include targets on the health priorities identified? Yes No 1.A.4.D Does the national sustainable development framework include indicators on the health priorities identified? Yes No If you answered yes to question 1.A.4.D, please move to question 1.A.4.D.1 If you answered no to q uestion 1.A.4.D, please move to question 1.A.5 1.A.4.D.1 What is the level of monitoring of the health-related indicators? High ( m ore than 75% health-related indicators are monitored and reviewed at least once every two years to make decisions or change the course of action ) Moderate ( 50-75% of the key health-related indicators are monitored , review s take place every two to five years and are used often to make decisions or change the course of action ) Low ( l ess than 50% indicators are monitored and are not regularly used to make decisions or change the course of action ) None ( n o monitoring activity) Other . Please specify ( Limit 100 characters) ______________________________________ 1.A.5 P lease upload the n ational sustainable d evelopment planning framework and other relevant documents and provide URL if available : Upload up to 3 documents /drafts __________ Provide web link____________________________ 1.B . Within the administrative structure of government of your country, where is the leadership for im plementation of the 2030 Agenda? Please explain briefly and s pecify the name of the ministry, body , unit or institution al arrangement in charge of implementation of the 2030 Agenda within the administrative structure of government : ( Limit 700 characters) 1.C . What are the functions assigned to the institutional and coordination arrangement of your country? Promote horizontal coherence across ministries Promote vertical coherence across national and subnational government levels. Develop national sustainable development planning frameworks Oversee the monitoring and evaluation of the sustainable development planning frameworks Monitor sustainable development issues and provide policy advise Other . Please specify : ( limit 200 characters) __________________________. Please attach evidence , if available: (attach up to 3 files ) 1. D Please select the level of participation of the sectors involved in the coordination and institutional arrangement for implementation of the 2030 Agenda of your country . (please select as many sectors as applicable) Sector High ( has strong control over key decisions – acts as a partner in the development of alternatives and identification of preferred solutions ) Moderate ( is involved/consulted in the process of development of alternatives and identification of preferred solutions ) Low (is informed of key decisions). None (no participation) Agriculture Education Environment and natural resources Finance and economy Gender equality Health and wellbeing Labour, employment and social affairs Public administration Transport and infrastructure Rural development Others. Please specify only those you consider relevant sharing : (Limit 5 sectors) ______________ Other sector 1 ( limit 100 characters) Other sector 2 ( limit 100 characters) Other sector 3 ( limit 100 characters) Other sector 4 ( limit 100 characters) Other sector 5 ( limit 100 characters) Optional: Please explain your response, providing more detail on the participation and role of the different sectors : (Limit 500 characters) 1. E Is there a body or person assigned as SDG focal point in the Ministry of health? Yes No If you answered yes, please provide contact details below. If you answered no, please move to question 1.F Please provide contact details: ( L imit 200 characters) 1. F Has your country submitted a voluntary national review (VNR) to the H igh- L evel P olitical F orum (HLPF) meeting under the auspices of United Nations Economic and Social Council ( ECOSOC ) ? Yes No If you answered yes to question 1.F, plea se move to question 1.F.1 If you answered no to question 1.F , please move to question 1.G 1. F .1 Please indicate the extent of involvement from the Ministry of Health, public health institutions or other health stakeholders in the development of the VNR . Stakeholder involvement High ( had strong control over key decisions - Lead or co-lead the process of development of the VNR or was considered a strong partner ) Moderate ( was involved/consulted in the process of development of the VNR, e.g. providing data and information ) Low ( was informed of key decisions in the process of development of the VNR ) None (no involvement) Ministry of H ealth Public health institute Civil society organizations (related to health) Parliamentarians International development organizations and/or international financing institutions Others . Please specify ( up to 5 health stakeholders, limit 100 characters per stakeholder ) Other stakeholder 1 ( limit 100 characters) Other stakeholder 2 ( limit 100 characters) Other stakeholder 3 ( limit 100 characters) Other stakeholder 4 ( limit 100 characters) Other stakeholder 5 ( limit 100 characters) Optional: Please explain your response, providing more detail on the extent of involvement of the different stakeholders : (Limit 1 500 characters) 1 . G Please list the national health and wellbeing priorities of your country (as in the main health and wellbeing planning frameworks) (Up to 10 priorities , limit 150 characters per priority ) : 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 1 . H What is the level of alignment of your country’s health and wellbeing priorities with the SDGs? A lignment refers to the correspondence of the issues covered by the SDG targets to the health-related targets set in the national long-term, medium-term, and thematic or disease-specific plans. Alignment in s cope refers to the level of correspondence of the subthemes identified in the SDG target, or specific groups identified in the SDG target (sex disaggregation, rural and urban population, population groups, etc.) to the subthemes or specific group identified in the national long-term, medium-term, and thematic or disease-specific plans . Alignment in ambition refers to correspondence between the ambition set by the SDG targets to the ambition set in the national long-term, medium-term, and thematic or disease-specific plans. High ( more than 75% of the targets in the national planning documents are aligned to one or more health-related SDG targets, also in scope and ambition ) Moderate ( 50-75% of the targets in the national planning documents correspond to one or more SDG targets, but not completely in scope or ambition ) Low ( less than 50% of the targets in the national planning documents correspond to one or more SDG targets, but not in scope or ambition ) None ( targets in the national planning documents do not correspond to one or more SDG targets ) Unknown ( an analysis of the alignment of the targets in national planning documents against the SDG targets has not been done ). Please, explain your response briefly: Limit 7 00 character s. 1. I Please select the approach used in your country to address the national health and wellbeing priorities : (please select all applicable options) Implementing an overarching health poli cy or strategy covering the vision, policy directions, strategy and /or plans . Implementing thematic or disease-specific strategies or plans. Implementing sub-national and decentralized planning frameworks. Other . Please specify: (limit 700 characters) ________________________________________ 1. I .1 Specify the year in which the integrated health policy or strategy was approved by the relevant government authority and the expiration date (please provide the year that the integrated health policy or strategy was initially approved even if subsequent modifications have been made): __ (mm/yy ) _ _ -__ (mm/yy) __ . 1. I .2 Has the approved integrated health policy or strategy been updated or modified since its original adoption : Yes No. If you answered yes to question 1.I.2 plea se move to question 1.I.2.A If you answered no to question 1.I.2 , please move to question 1.I.3 1. I .2.A . Please explain your response, providing key reason (s) for modification and provide the most recent year in which modifications have taken place : (e.g. national priorities/agenda changed, international commitments, resulting from monitoring and evaluation activities. etc). Limit 7 00 characters (mm/yy) 1. I .3 P lease specify if your current integrated health policy or strategy includes measures about : ( please select as many options as applicable ) Life-course approach Child and adolescent health (SDG targets 3.2, 4.2). (Examples of measures include: ending preventable deaths of mothers, newborns and children; ensuring health and wellbeing of mothers and children by reducing malnutrition, improving access to sexual and reproductive health; ensuring access to good-quality early childhood development; expanding enabling environments for children and adolescent’s health and wellbeing . ) Healthy aging ( SDG 3, 5 and 10) . ( Examples of measures include: prevention of falls; promotion of physical activity; vaccination of older people and prevention of infectious disease in health-care settings; public support for informal care giving with a focus on home care, including self-care; building capacity in geriatrics and gerontology among the health and social care workforce; prevention of social isolation and social exclusion; strategies to ensure the quality of care for older people, with a focus on dementia care and palliative care for long-term patients; prevention of elder maltreatment . ) Improve w omen’s and men’s health ( SDG 5 and 3). ( Examples of measures include: strengthening governance for the health and wellbeing of women and men ; eliminating discriminatory values, norms and practices that affect the health and well-being of girls and women; making gender equality a priority; tackling the impact of gender and social, economic, cultural and environmental determinants on women’s and men’s health and well-being; making health systems gender responsive; improving health promotion with gender-transformative approaches . ) Sexual and reproductive health (SDG targets 3.1, 3.7 and SDG 5). (Examples of measures include: guaranteeing universal access to sexual and reproductive health and eliminating inequities; enabling all people to make informed choices about their sexual and reproductive health; ensuring sexual and reproductive human rights are respected, protected and fulfilled . ) Noncommunicable diseases and risk factors Healthy lifestyles: healthy eating, reformulation of food products, increasing physical activity, reducing tobacco use, reducing the harmful use of alcohol and/or improving air quality (SDG targets 2.2, 3.4, 3.5, 3a, 3.9) . (Examples of measures include: promoting healthy consumption via fiscal and marketing policies; reformulating and improving product: salt, fats and sugars; reducing salt consumption; promoting active living and mobility; promoting clean air . ) Noncommunicable diseases: i.e. cardiovascular diseases, cancer, chronic respiratory diseases and/or diabetes (SDG target 3.4) . (Examples of measures include: providing access to early detection and effective treatment; providing access to cardio-metabolic risk assessment and management; providing access to vaccinations and relevant communicable disease control . ) Communicable diseases Antimicrobial resistance ( SDG 3 ). (Examples of measures include: improving awareness and understanding of antimicrobial resistance; strengthening knowledge and evidence base through surveillance and research; reducing the incidence of infection through effective sanitation, hygiene and infection-prevention; optimizing the use of antimicrobial medicines in human and animal health; increasing investment in new medicines and technologies . ) Communicable Diseases: HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis, Viral Hepatitis and/or vector borne diseases (SDG target 3.3). (Examples of measures include: strengthening programmes for the control of infectious diseases; providing adequate access to services, including access to safe and affordable medications and vaccines; integrating patient-centred care and prevention services; focusing prevention strategies for vulnerable populations . ) Immunizations (SDG targets 3.8, 3b) . (Examples of measures include: strengthening and achieving financial sustainability of national immunizations programmes; eliminating measles and rubella; addressing vaccine hesitancy; tailoring immunization programmes to reach underserved groups; investing in research and development . ) Health system strengthening for universal health coverage Financial protection (SDG target 3.8) . (Examples of measures include: promoting policies to reduce out-of-pocket payments; ensuring adequate public financing for health systems; reducing fragmentation in health system funding channels; adopting strategic purchasing mechanisms; ensuring effective and equitable coverage decisions based on systematics, evidence-based and transparent processes . ) Fostering environmental sustainability of health systems (SDG 3, 6, 12, 13, 14 and 15) . (Examples of measures include: minimizing and adequately managing waste and hazardous chemicals; promoting an efficient management of resources; promoting sustainable procurement; reducing health systems’ emissions of greenhouse gases and air pollution; prioritizing disease prevention, health promotion and public health services; engaging the health workforce as an agent of sustainability; increasing community resilience and promoting local assets; creating innovative models of care . ) Health information and health information systems (SDG target 17.7 and 17.8) . ( Examples of measures include: generating, measuring, analyzing, coordinating and promoting the use of data and information for policies to improve health and well-being and reduce inequalities . ) Q uality-assured, affordable medicines , vaccines and health products (SDG target 3b) . ( Examples of measures include: improving access to essential medicines and medical devices; supporting the appropriate use of medical products; improving efficiency of procurement systems; promoting effective regulations and quality control; promoting responsible use of medicines and medical devices; promoting research and development . ) Sustainable and resilient health workforce (SDG target 3c) . ( Examples of measures include: rethinking the roles of health workers and optimizing the skill mix; investing in and transforming health workforce education and training; improving the performance of health workers; establishing policies to ensure a sufficient and sustainable health workforce; ensuring the availability of the health workforce to quickly respond to emergencies or pandemics . ) Transforming health services to meet the current and emergent health challenges ( SDG target 3.8) . (Examples of measures include: strengthening the integration of primary health care and public health services, hospitals and social care; strengthening key processes of designing care, organizing providers and settings, managing services and improving quality . ) Emergencies All-hazard, multisectoral preparedness and response to health emergencies (SDG targets 1.5, 3d, 11.5) . B uilding strong public health-oriented and people-centred health systems, institutions and networks based on the essential public health functions and core capacities under the International Health Regulations (2005) (SDG target 3d). Strengthening adaptive capacity and resilience to health risks related to climate change ( SDG 13) and/or supporting measures to mitigate climate change and achieve health co-benefits in line with the Paris Agreement. Health determinants Addressing and preventing interpersonal violence, including the negative consequences of interpersonal violence (SDG targets 5.2, 16.1 and 16.2). ( Examples of measures include: prevention of child maltreatment , elder ly maltreatment, violence against women, among others .) Addressing e ducation and lifelong learning (SDG 4) . (Examples of measures include: improving access to high quality education services and protection from financial hardship in using those services; ensuring quality conditions for early childhood development .) Addressing employment, income and living conditions (SDG 1, 2, 8, 10 and 16). (Examples of measures include: fostering a healthy workforce and tackling the health risks of being unemployed or insecurely employed; developing universal social protection and policy priorities and strategies in order to reduce inequities and remove barriers to protecting households from deprivation and poverty; implementing a basket of coordinated social, economic and environmental policy measures that target groups that are being left behind or excluded . ) Improving r o ad safety (SDG target s 3.6 , 11.2) . (Examples of measures include: enhancing leadership on road safety; implementing measures for speed management, infrastructure design and improvement; vehicle safety standards; enforcement of traffic laws; improving survival after a road accident. ) Migration and health ( SDG 10) . (Examples of measures include: establishing a framework for collaborative action; advocating for the right to health of refugees; addressing the social determinants of health; achieving public health preparedness and ensuring an effective response; strengthening health systems and their resilience; preventing communicable diseases; preventing and reducing risks posed by noncommunicable diseases; ensuring ethical and effective health screening . ) Promotion of social inclusion, gender equality and human rights ( SDG 1, 5, 10 and 16) ( Examples of measures include: strengthening governance for health and well - being; eliminating discriminatory values, norms and practices that affect health and wellbeing; tackling the impact of gender and social, economic, cultural and environmental determinants of health and wellbeing ; improving health system responses to women’s and men’s health and wellbeing . ) Reduction of e nvironmental pollution and degradation and health-related risks (SDG target 3.9 and SDG 7, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15) . ( Examples of measures include: improving indoor and outdoor air quality for all; access to safe drinking water, sanitation and hygiene for all; minimizing the adverse effects of chemicals on human health and the environment; preventing and eliminating the adverse environmental and health effects, costs and inequalities related to waste management and contaminated sites; strengthening adaptive capacity and resilience to health risks related to climate change ; building the environmental sustainability of health systems . ) Supporting and collaborating with cities and regions to become healthier, more inclusive, safe r , more resilient and more sustainable (SDG 3 and 11) . Providing access to connected services – including mental health services – such as social services, disability services and community integrated care; investing in health literacy and community empowerment; adopting policies, including in urban planning, that create a health promoting and salutogenic environm e nt to tackle risk factors and support health . ) Please, explain your response: Limit 7 00 characters . 1. I .4 Please describe the level of implementation of the integrated health policy or strategy : High ( action is being taken on more than 75% of health and wellbeing priorities ) Moderate ( action is being taken on 50-75% of health and wellbeing priorities ) Low ( action is being taken on less than 50% of health and wellbeing priorities ) None (no action is being taken) 1. I .5 Please select the challenges/barriers encountered when implementing the integrated health policy or strategy: ( please select as many options as applicable ) Insufficient budget to meet the priorities Limited partnership opportunities Frequent changes of key staff Ineffective mechanisms (e.g. legal, regulatory, financial) for ensuring coordination and cooperation. Poor quality of statistical information Low level of intersectoral cooperation and interaction. Other . Please specify : ( limit 200 characters) _________________________________ Please, briefly explain your response: Limit 700 characters . 1. I . 6 Does the integrated health policy or strategy outline budgetary requirements for its implementation? Yes No If you answered yes to question 1.I.6, plea se move to question 1.I.6.A If you answered no to question 1.I.6 , please move to question 1.I.7 1. I .6 .A Please indicate the degree the estimated costs of implementing the integrated health policy or strategy are covered by the current domestic resources . High ( more than 75% of all costs to implement priority actions are covered by the current domestic resources) Moder ate ( 50 -75% of all costs to implement priority actions are covered by the current domestic resources ) Low ( l ess than 50% of all costs to implement priority actions are covered by the current domestic resources and/or funds are insufficient to implement any of the main priorities ) Non e ( c overed costs by current domestic resources are insufficient to implement priority actions) 1. I . 7 What priorities , objectives or activities, if any, of the integrated health policy or strategy are currently underfunded or insufficiently funded? ( Limit 1400 characters ) 1. I .8 Is your government currently receiving international funds /official development assistance to support implementation of the national health priorities ? Yes No If you answered yes to question 1.I.8, please move to question 1.I.8.A If you answered no to question 1.I.8, please move to question 1.I.9 1. I . 8 .A Please describe the health and development priorities for which you are currently receiving international funds/official development assistance for and the share of international funds used to finance the se activities if available (percentage) (up to 5 priorities limit 200 characters per priority ) : Health priority 1 % Priority 2 % Priority 3 % Priority 4 % Priority 5 % 1. I .9 What are the greatest challenges (if any) in accessing international funds/official development assistance for development and health and wellbeing? ( please select as many options as applicable ) Lack of information on the opportunities Lack of country eligibility Lack of connection by health actors to the development processes Lack of capacity to prepare country proposals Lack of success in submitted previous applications Non e (no challenges/challenges were minimal) Not applicable Other . Please specify: ( limit 700 characters ) ________________________________________ 1. I . 10 Has your country assessed how the n ational b udget contributes to financing the health-related SDGs? Yes No If you answered yes to question 1.I.10, please move to question 1.I.10.A If you answered no to question 1.I.10, please move to question 1.I.11 1. I . 10 .A What is the share of the n ational b udget that can be attributed to achievement of the health-related SDGs in you r country? Percentage 1. I .11 P lease upload relevant documents related to the i ntegrated health policy or strategy and provide URL if available : Upload up to 5 relevant documents /drafts __________ Provide link____________________________ Block 2. Leaving no one behind Objective: to reduce health inequities by addressing all health determinants, taking life-course, gender-responsive and rights-based approaches to health, and action on universally progressive policies, legislation and empowerment. 2.A Is there a national/subnational health policy/ plan/ strateg y addressing the reduction of health inequalities (HI) and/or improvement of the social determinants of health (SDH) ? Yes No Other ( reducing health inequalities and/or improvement of the SDH is part of another national/subnational policy/strategy ) Please explain your response and specify the title of the policies/strategies addressing the reduction of inequalities : ( Limit 7 00 characters ) If you answered ‘yes’ or ‘other’ to question 2.A, please move to question 2.A.1 If you answered no to question 2.A, please move to question 2.B 2 .A . 1 P lease upload the national/subnational health policy/plan/strategy addressing the reduction of HI and/or improvement of the SD H and provide URL if available : Upload relevant documents /drafts __________ Provide link____________________________ Attach up to 3 files, policies/strategies 2 . B P lease specify which of the following measures to address the reduction of health inequalities and/or improvement of the SDH have been included in your country’s national/subnational polic ies /plan s / strategies or equivalent : ( please select as many options as applicable ) Improving access to high-quality health and education services and protection from financial hardships in using those services . Ensuring quality conditions for early childhood development, starting in places where children and their families live, learn, play and work . Fostering a healthy workforce and tackl ing the health risks of being unemployed or insecurely employed through active labour market policies . Developing universal social protection and policy priorities and strategies to reduce inequities and remove barriers to protecting households from deprivation and poverty . Implementing a basket of coordinated social, economic and environmental policy measures , target ing groups that are being left behind or excluded . A ddressing the structural causes of discrimination; ensuring policies and measures to reduce gender-based violence and to eliminate child and forced labour, trafficking and sexual exploitation . Other s. P lease specify (limit 1400 characters ) : ____________________________________ Block 3. Preventing disease and addressing health determinants by promoting multi- and inters ectoral policies and action throughout the life-course Objective: to foster the health sector’s cooperation with other sectors to integrate action to achieve multiple SDGs, and to optimize the co-benefits for health of policies and measures taken in other sectors to address the determinants of health 3 . A For the following health determining sectors, please indicate the level of collaboration between the M inistry of H ealth and the health-determining sector and describe the key health and wellbeing priorities to be addressed with in /by the sector . Sector High ( joint working and co-production of intersectoral plans with clear leadership, tasks, capacity and reporting obligations ) Moderate ( regular dialogue with cross consultations and/or mentioned as partners in respective sector’s plans ) Low ( i rregular ad hoc information sharing/gathering) None (no collaboration) Agriculture, food and nutrition Commerce Culture &amp; media Education Energy Environment, water and sanitation Finance and trade Gender &amp; women’s rights Habitat, housing, land use and urbanization Industry Labour and employment Welfare and social protection Transportation Local government Subnational government Other . Please specify: (up to 5 s ectors ) Other sector 1 (limit 100 character) Other sector 2 (limit 100 character) Other sector 3 (limit 100 character) Other sector 4 (limit 100 character) Other sector 5 (limit 100 character) Optional: Please explain your response, providing more detail on the level of collaboration and describe the key health and well-being priorities to be addressed within/by the different sectors . (Limit 1 500 characters) Optional: Please attach relevant documentation (action plans, joint memorandums of understanding, other agreements and/or other relevant evidence) that describes the main priorities for cooperation between the Ministry of Health and the health determining sectors. Attach up to 5 files 3 . B Please indicate the extent of actions taken for the following measures to prevent disease and address health determinants by promoting multi- and intersectoral policies and action throughout the life-course by the health sector : Action and measures High (measure has been identified as a priority and actions are being taken) Moderate (measure has been identified as a priority , but limited action is being taken) Low (measure has been identified as a priority, but no action is being taken) None (measure is not a priority) Communicate co-benefits for multiple sectors from addressing health and wellbeing Systematically adopting a Health in all policies approach in policy-making processes through normative frameworks Strengthen and implement legal and regulatory measures in sectors outside the health sector that tackle shared risk factors (e.g. such as air pollution) or unhealthy commodities (such as alcohol, drug, tobacco) to help control and manage noncommunicable diseases Ensure consumer environments promote healthy choices through pricing policies, information or economic and fiscal measures Promote information systems that provide integrated information to policy makers Develop national portfolio of action on environment and health (Ostrava declaration) If you selected the extent of actions for any of the measures as ‘high’ or ‘moderate’ for question 3.B, please answer question 3.B.1 If you selected the extent of actions for any of the measures as ‘low’ or ‘none’ for question 3.B, please answer question 3.B.2 3.B.1 . Could you list one or two examples of the actions and measures selected in the previous question? Up to 2 examples, limit 300 characters per example. 3.B.2 What are the main challenges to promote multi- and intersectoral policies and action ? Limit 300 characters . Block 4. Establishing healthy places, sett ings and resilient communities Objective: to engage local communities and stakeholders in designing and managing places, settings and communities consistent with the needs of their people throughout the life-course . 4 . A Please indicate which of the following measures , to establish healthy places, settings and resilient communities , are included in the national development planning framework and/or in the integrated health policy or strategy of your country: ( please select as many options as applicable ) Engagement with local communities and stakeholders in designing and managing places, settings and communities consistent with the needs of the people throughout the life-course with defined vertical accountability mechanisms . Create spaces that are supportive to groups of all ages and levels of ability, including access to natural resources and green and blue spaces. Engage communities in identifying the physical, social and cultural characteristics of places that are most supportive of the health and wellbeing of the inhabitants. Engage public agencies, spatial planners, voluntary bodies, business, industry and all other actors in taking action to implement the common priorities. Develop partnerships among communities, individuals, patients and their family members and carers in order to empower populations to develop health-promoting behavior. Increase resilience of households and communities so as to improve capacities to prevent, prepare, withstand, respond to and recover from climate risks and natural and man-made disasters. Other . P lease specify : ( limit 700 characters) __________________________________ Block 5. Strengthening health systems for universal health coverage (UHC) Objective: to ensure all people obtain the high-quality health promotion, disease prevention, curative, rehabilitative and palliative services they need without experiencing financial hardship 5 . A Is the pursuit of UHC expressed in a national / subnational policy strategy or statement ? Yes No If you answered yes to question 5.A, please move to question 5.A.1 If you answered no to question 5.A, please move to question 5.B 5.A.1 How is the pursuit of UHC expressed in your country: The pursuit of UHC is expressed in a thematic national/subnational policy/strategy or statement focused in the pursuit on UHC. The pursuit of UHC is expressed in another policy/strategy focused on health or health systems strengthening Other . Please specify: ( limit 100 characters) __________________________________ Please, explain your response briefly , indicating the name of the policy, strategy or statement and the approach proposed. U pload relevant document and i f available, provide URL : Limit 7 00 characters . Upload 1 document Provide URL 5 . A.2 Which body or agency is responsible for the pursuit / achievement of UHC in your country? Limit 700 characters 5 . B Within the context of your health system, are you able to identify specific actions or measures being taken to improve: ( please select as many options as applicable ) E quitable access to comprehensive, people-centred health services (in terms of access, this includes physical, social, financial etc) ? I ncreased public financing for health ? E fficient and equitable health financing policies to reduce out-of-pocket payments for core services ? T he scope of health services covered under a national basket of reimbursed services ? T he quality of covered services, including ensuring the availability of an appropriately skilled workforce ? T he re-orientation of primary health care (e.g., to serve the goals of bring ing care closer to the individual, reducing costs and waste in the system, promoting continuity of care etc . ) ? If any options in question 5.B are selected, please move to question 5.B.1 If no options in question 5.B are selected, please move to question 5.C 5 . B.1 For the above are there dedicated targets set with a monitoring and evaluation strategy? Yes No Partially . Please explain your response ( limit 700 characters ) 5 . C Indicate what are the obstacles or barriers , if any, to strengthening your health system in pursuit of UHC)? ( please select as many options as applicable ) S hortages, imbalances, mismatches between education models and health needs, and /or productivity concerns in health workforce. Challenges in access to and a ffordability of essential medicines and health technologies. Large gaps in health coverage . Weaknesses in the design of population entitlement, benefit package and user charges. Inefficient public spending on health Fragmentation in health services delivery Weaknesses in health system governance to define, lead and implement policies in health sector. Increased public demands for access to and use of new technologies, new medications and new models of care Higher expectations of quality and safe care. Ageing populations Emerging and re-emerging diseases Others . Please specify: ( u p to 5 challenges, 100 characters per challenge) _________________ 5.D Please upload the most relevant document (s) where the approach proposed to the pursuit of UHC is expressed and if available, provide URL Attach up to 3 document s Provide URL 5 . E Health system strengthening and the pursuit of UHC requires collaboration between and across levels of government and society. Can you describe national examples of collaboration between governmental, non-governmental and private sectors in delivering stronger health systems for UHC? Please, focus on describing the issue and the plan for action , methods of collaboration, context and stakeholders involved, challenges and results of collaboration (optional) . Limit 2500 characters If you responded to question 5. E , please move to question 5. E .1 If you did not respond to question 5. E , please move to question 6.A 5 . E .1 Would you agree to be contacted so you can elaborate on your example : Yes No Block 6. Investment for health and well-being Objective: To promote investment for health and well-being, to maximize co-benefits for health and sustainable development and to achieve the highest attainable standard of health for all at all ages 6 . A Indicate which of the following measures are used in your country to ensure adequate investments in health and wellbeing and its determinants : ( please select as many options as applicable ) Using evidence-informed and innovative mechanisms to incentivize non-health sectors to invest in actions for health and wellbeing Prioritizing and i ncreasing public funding for health at national and subnational levels by s etting appropriate investment targets for providing essential public services for all (health, education, food, housing, employment, energy, water and sanitation) that are consistent with national development strategies. Harmonizing development assistance and international funds for health with the county’s national priorities. Improving efficiency and equity on health spending by, for example, p rioritizing investment in evidence-informed health and other policies and interventions that have demonstrated co-benefits for health and sustainable development (accelerators). Ensuring adequate funding for pandemic and emergency response. Assessing systematically public- and private-sector investments for their health and health equity impact and applying incentives and disincentives to redirect them accordingly. Applying social and environmental criteria for all purchases and ensuring financial integrity in the health sector. Other . Please specify: ( l imit 350 characters) ___________________________________ Block 7. Multi-partner cooperation Objective: to increase institutional capacity, build and engage effective, accountable and transparent institutions, and strengthen collaboration with partners and stakeholders 7 . A Is there a strategy/plan/framework (or similar) with the purpose to enable better coordinat ion /enhance engagement with non-state actors in your country? Yes No 7.A.1 If the answer to 7.A is yes, p lease specify the name of the policy and objectives and upload relevant documentation. If available, provide URL: Name of pol i cy and objectives (Limit 1750 characters) Upload 1 document URL 7 . B For the followin g groups of non-state actors, please indicate the type of collaboration between the m and your M inistry of H ealth : Non-state Actor Non-state actor participates in meetings, consultation and hearings for dec ision-making and public policy. Non-state actor plays an explicit role in governance Generating evidence Participating in formal structures such as consultative groups, public consultations, and lobbying. Advocating, addressing the public to foment social change or create pressure on the political system to shape policy Mobilizing people to act through petitions, demonstrations, membership drives and social media actions Consensus-building Watchdog (monitoring public and private compliance with policy and ethics) Technical standard-setting Professional and other self-regulation Social partnership (with a social role in issues such as wage-setting, working conditions and workforce training). Providing services to public (e.g. disaster relief, needle exchange, free medical care) Groups united by shared interests and values Groups representing specific or general interests ( ranging from the most specific interest to the broadest issues of global welfare such as climate change ) O rganizations of professionals (e.g. medical associations and professional chambers) Community organizations Faith-based community organizations Identity-based community organizations (i.e. ethnic -based or another group) Local community organizations (e.g. neighbourhood or rural district organizations) Health-condition related community organizations Private sector entities International NGOs Academic institutions Other . Please specify . ( Up to 5 non-state actors) Other non-state actor 1 ( limit 100 characters) Other non-state actor 2 ( limit 100 characters) Other non-state actor 3 ( limit 100 characters) Other non-state actor 4 ( limit 100 characters) Other non-state actor 5 ( limit 100 characters) 7 . C Indicate which of the following measures are being used in your country to strengthen collaboration of the health sector with partners and stakeholders ( please select as many options as applicable ): Raising awareness activities to mobilize political will and investment in health and wellbeing, and implementation of the 2030 Agenda for sustainable development. Developing mechanisms / platforms to promote cooperation between various groups and cooperative initiatives in civil society, academia, settings and sectors. Creating accessible forums for civil society organizations to participate in decision-making. Strengthening informat ion sharing and health literacy. Other . P lease specify : ( Limit 200 characters) _________________________________________ Block 8. Health Literacy, research and innovation Objective: to promote international and regional research to support and promote the i mplementation of the health and well-being aspects of the 2030 Agenda and the SDGs 8 . A Are there national plans or strategies address ing strengthen ing health literacy of the population? WHO defines Health Literacy “as the cognitive and social skills which determine the motivation and ability of individuals to gain access to, understand and use information in ways which promote and maintain good health (…) Health Literacy goes beyond a narrow concept of health education and individual behavior-oriented communication, and addresses the environmental, political and social factors that determine health”. Yes No 8.A.1 If the answer to 8 .A is yes, p lease specify the name of the policy and objectives and upload relevant documentation. If available, provide URL: Name of pol i cy and objectives (Limit 1750 characters) Upload 1 document URL If you answered yes to question 8.A, please move to question 8.A.1 If you answered no to question 8.A, please move to question 8.B 8 . B Which of the following actions or measures to strengthen health literacy are you able to identify being implemented in your country ( please select as many options as applicable ) : Allocating f iscal and human resources for strengthening health literacy of the population . B uilding supportive environments for consumers ( e.g. clear labelling, a traffic light system to indicate healthier and less healthier choices, consumer design strategies, among others ) . Providing easy access to health information and services and navigation assistance ( e.g. using e-health and other digital technologies as appropriate ) . Acknowledging a wide variety of learning styles and using multiples approac hes to promote health literacy. Actions to improve the living environment. A ctions implemented at the workplace. A ctions implemented through media and digital/e-health. Actions at the individual, community, organization and system levels. Actions to support intersectoral work, political leadership and strategies to overcome cultural barriers into health literacy policy. Promoting health literacy in high risk situations, including outbreaks and emergencies. Other . Please specify : ( Limit 200 characters) ______________________________ 8 . C Is there a national strategy/plan to promote innovation, research and development to create new knowledge and evidence or technologies, as well as to find novel means of implementation, including legal and financial instruments for alignment and acceleration of SDG attainment: Yes No 8.C.1 If answer to 8. C is yes, p lease specify the name of the policy and objectives and upload relevant documentation. If available, provide URL: Name of pol i cy and objectives (Limit 1 75 0 characters ) Upload 1 document URL Block 9. Monitoring and Evaluation Objective: to strengthen national health information systems to inform and evaluate p olicies for health and well-being and support reporting on the SDGs to improve g overnance and comparability of information and the application of e-health standards across the European Region 9 . A Has your country per formed a SDG baseline analysis? SDG baseline analysis refers to an assessment of the current status of the SDG indicators. It could be specifically for the health-related SDG indicators, or a general SDG baseline analysis (list of health-related indicators attached). Yes No 9.A.1 If answer to 9.A is yes, p lease attach SDG baseline analysis: Upload 1 document 9 . B Indicate which of the following processes have been done in your country to support data and statistical development to monitor health-related SDGs : ( select as many options as applicable ) A ssessment of existing data production instruments across the entire national statistical system, including data sources, their comparability and frequencies to support monitoring health-related SDGs . Prioritization of SDG indicators for data production based on country’s needs and gaps (e.g. national development plans priorities), critical data for SDG acceleration and leaving no one behind. Strengthening the role of national statistical offices and data ecosystems, including official as well as non-official stakeholders ’ data. C oordination, partnership and innovation across the broader ecosystem of data stakeholders, to leverage technological innovations and new data sources, ensure interoperability of data systems, minimize duplication of efforts, and improve coherence of development implementation and reporting initiatives. Creation of platforms, portals and/or scorecards to inform on SDG progress. Other: Please specify ( limit 200 characters) ____________________________ Thank you for taking the time to complete this survey. This message indicates that you have now completed the questionnaire. Please click the Submit button if you are satisfied with your replies. We are very appreciative of the time you have taken to assist in our analysis, and we commit to utilizing the information gained to contemplate and implement improvements in our work . We will share these results in a report at the next Regional Committee for the WHO European Region. Saatja: LITTLEWOOD, Jodie Anne <[email protected]> Saadetud: 14.07.2020 09:04 Adressaat: Elen Ohov <[email protected]> Koopia: Triin Uusberg <[email protected]>; SM Info <[email protected]>; <[email protected]>; <[email protected]>; REINAP, Marge <[email protected]>; REINAP, Marge <[email protected]>; ARAGON DE LEON, Emilia <[email protected]>; MENNE, Bettina Maria (Maria) <[email protected]> Teema: RE: Consultation - Survey - SDG alignment and implementation in the Region This email has been sent on behalf of Dr Bettina Menne: Dear Ms Ohov It has been almost a year since we requested your assistance with completing the extensive SDG Survey (below). We thank you again for your valuable contributions and now share with you a draft document (attached, together with Annexes 1 and 2) for consultation. Please note that the report has been reviewed by external peer-reviewers. For this consultation, we kindly advise that you only need focus on the sections where your country is mentioned, to revise the statements/examples for accuracy and, where necessary, provide more details, updates and/or raise any concerns. Please do so by inserting comment bubbles in the document. For the sake of time-efficiency, we kindly recommend that you use the Search function in Word to locate where in the document your country is mentioned. After this consultation, the report will be English edited and also translated into Russian. Your collaboration is greatly appreciated and we look forward to hearing back from you by 7 August 2020. Please direct your replies to Dr Emilia Aragon de Leon, . Should you foresee any delay in the reply, due to the summer holiday period, please advise Dr Aragon de Leon. With kind regards Dr Bettina Menne Dr Bettina Menne Coordinator, Health and Sustainable Development mobile + 45 51979253 skype Bettina6WHO Regional Office for Europe Marmorvej, 51 Copenhagen, Denmark From: LITTLEWOOD, Jodie Anne Sent: Tuesday, July 16, 2019 6:25 PMTo: Cc: ; ; ; ; REINAP, Marge <>; REINAP, Marge <>; ARAGON DE LEON, Emilia Maria <>Subject: Survey - SDG alignment and implementation in the Region This email has been sent on behalf of Dr Piroska Östlin: Dear Ms Ohov At the 67th session of the Regional Committee for Europe in 2017, Member States of the WHO European Region adopted the (EUR/RC67/9) (hereafter referred to as the roadmap). The roadmap aims to assist Member States of the WHO European Region strengthen their capacities to achieve better, more equitable, sustainable health and well-being for all at all ages. To advance the implementation of both the 2030 Agenda and Health 2020, the roadmap proposes 5 interdependent strategic directions and 4 enabling measures: Strategic directions * Advancing governance and leadership * Leaving no one behind * Preventing disease and addressing health determinants * Establishing healthy places, settings and resilient communities * Strengthening health systems for universal health coverage Enablers * Investment for health * Multi-partner cooperation * Health literacy, research and innovation * Monitoring and evaluation A comprehensive survey has been developed to assess such progress in SDG alignment and implementation in the Region, based on the application of the roadmap strategic directions and enabler measures. Each Member State is required to complete and return the survey by Wednesday 14 August 2019. The results of such a survey will be vital in presenting progress in development and health policy alignment, the approaches for SDG implementation used by Member States, challenges and lessons learned. Please use the link below to access the survey: TOKEN: EST3ufeEu Please note you will not be able to use Internet Explorer (IE) to complete this survey. Please use one of the following browsers: Chrome, Firefox or Opera. If you do not have access to any of these browsers, please fill in the Word version of the survey (attached) and return with any relevant supporting documents/evidence to . Submission of the survey After you have submitted the survey, we will notify you that it has been received and we will review your responses to ensure the survey is valid and complete. We may then follow-up with you for further information or clarification. We thank you for your valuable time and input. Helpdesk If you require any support while completing the survey or have any questions on how to complete it, please contact Dr Emilia Aragon, Technical Officer, Health and Sustainable Development at . We look forward to receiving your completed survey. With kind regards Dr Piroska Östlin Director Division of Policy and Governance for Health and Well-being World Health Organization │Regional Office for Europe UN City - Marmorvej 51 - 2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark Tel +4545336804 │Email: -1905 52705 0 0 Health and well-being and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development in the WHO European Region: an analysis of policy development and implementation Report of the first survey to assess Member States ’ activities in relation to the WHO European Region Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development ABSTRACT This report presents an analysis of policy , governance and implementation arrangements to achieve health and well-being for all at all ages and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in Member States of the WHO European Region . The information presented and analyzed in this report was captured in a survey with participation of 29 Member States of the Region in 2019 . Results show that countries have prioritized implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and integration of the SDGs into relevant planning frameworks . This integration has been facilitated through the creation or adaptation of institutional arrangements with leadership from high- levels of government and participation of all sectors of society . The re view identifie d that more action is required to advance governance and leadership for health and wellbeing through a more holistic lens that e n c ompa s ses a life-course appr oa ch , considers the determinants of health and invests in preparedness , prevention and resilience . The review also identified mechanisms that were referred to facilitate intersectoral collaboration and improve accountability . F indings can be used by health stakeholders to identify solutions that can be adapted to Member States’ own context s to support achievement of the health and well - being goals and ultimately the SDGs . Keywords eXAMPLE eXAMPLE eXAMPLE eXAMPLE eXAMPLE eXAMPLE eXAMPLE Address requests about publications of the WHO Regional Office for Europe to: Publications WHO Regional Office for Europe UN City, Marmorvej 51 DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark Alternatively, complete an online request form for documentation, health information, or for permission to quote or translate, on the Regional Office website (http://www.euro.who.int/pubrequest). © World Health Organization 2020 All rights reserved. The Regional Office for Europe of the World Health Organization welcomes requests for permission to reproduce or translate its publications, in part or in full. The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the World Health Organization concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. Dotted lines on maps represent approximate border lines for which there may not yet be full agreement. The mention of specific companies or of certain manufacturers’ products does not imply that they are endorsed or recommended by the World Health Organization in preference to others of a similar nature that are not mentioned. Errors and omissions excepted, the names of proprietary products are distinguished by initial capital letters. All reasonable precautions have been taken by the World Health Organization to verify the information contained in this publication. However, the published material is being distributed without warranty of any kind, either expressed or implied. The responsibility for the interpretation and use of the material lies with the reader. In no event shall the World Health Organization be liable for damages arising from its use. The views expressed by authors, editors, or expert groups do not necessarily represent the decisions or the stated policy of the World Health Organization. Table of contents TOC \o "1-3" \h \z \u Table of contents PAGEREF _Toc45141964 \h 1 List of Abbreviations PAGEREF _Toc45141965 \h 3 List of Tables PAGEREF _Toc45141966 \h 4 List of Figures PAGEREF _Toc45141967 \h 5 List of Boxes PAGEREF _Toc45141968 \h 8 Acknowledgments PAGEREF _Toc45141969 \h 11 Foreword PAGEREF _Toc45141970 \h 12 Executive Summary PAGEREF _Toc45141971 \h 13 Introduction PAGEREF _Toc45141972 \h 21 Methodology PAGEREF _Toc45141973 \h 24 Survey design PAGEREF _Toc45141974 \h 24 Data collection PAGEREF _Toc45141975 \h 24 Data analysis PAGEREF _Toc45141976 \h 26 Limitations PAGEREF _Toc45141977 \h 30 Results PAGEREF _Toc45141978 \h 31 Block 1: Advancing governance and leadership for health and well-being PAGEREF _Toc45141979 \h 31 Health and well-being priorities in NDPs PAGEREF _Toc45141980 \h 35 Health and well-being priorities in NHPs PAGEREF _Toc45141981 \h 40 Governance arrangements and coordination mechanisms for implementing the 2030 Agenda PAGEREF _Toc45141982 \h 53 Block 2 Leaving no one Behind PAGEREF _Toc45141983 \h 68 Policies, plans or strategies addressing the reduction of health inequities PAGEREF _Toc45141984 \h 68 Measures to address the reduction of health inequities PAGEREF _Toc45141985 \h 69 Block 3: Preventing disease and addressing health determinants by promoting multi- and intersectoral policies and action throughout the life-course PAGEREF _Toc45141986 \h 76 Collaboration between Ministry of Health and health-determining sectors PAGEREF _Toc45141987 \h 77 Measures to promote multi- and intersectoral policies and action PAGEREF _Toc45141988 \h 81 Block 4: Establishing healthy places, settings and resilient communities PAGEREF _Toc45141989 \h 85 Block 5: Strengthening health systems for universal health coverage (UHC) PAGEREF _Toc45141990 \h 89 Policies and action to the pursuit of UHC PAGEREF _Toc45141991 \h 90 Barriers and obstacles to strengthening health systems in pursuit of UHC PAGEREF _Toc45141992 \h 97 Block 6. Investment for health and well-being PAGEREF _Toc45141993 \h 100 Block 7: Multi-partner cooperation PAGEREF _Toc45141994 \h 104 Non-state actor organizations and collaboration with the health sector PAGEREF _Toc45141995 \h 104 Measures to strengthen collaboration with non-state actors PAGEREF _Toc45141996 \h 109 Block 8: Health Literacy, research and innovation PAGEREF _Toc45141997 \h 111 8.1 Strengthening health literacy PAGEREF _Toc45141998 \h 112 8.2 Promoting health innovation and research PAGEREF _Toc45141999 \h 117 Block 9. Monitoring and Evaluation PAGEREF _Toc45142000 \h 120 Discussion PAGEREF _Toc45142001 \h 127 Engage PAGEREF _Toc45142002 \h 127 Assess PAGEREF _Toc45142003 \h 129 Align PAGEREF _Toc45142004 \h 130 Accelerate PAGEREF _Toc45142005 \h 134 Account PAGEREF _Toc45142006 \h 136 Conclusion PAGEREF _Toc45142007 \h 140 Annex 1: Country Snapshots PAGEREF _Toc45142008 \h 146 Annex 2: Survey PAGEREF _Toc45142009 \h 147 Annex 3: Description of qualitative analysis methodology PAGEREF _Toc45142010 \h 148 Annex 4: Interpretive frame PAGEREF _Toc45142011 \h 150 List of Abbreviations AMR Antimicrobial resistance CIS Commonwealth of Independent States EU European Union HI Health inequities MFA Ministry of foreign affairs NDP National development plan ning framework s NHP National health p lanning frameworks SDGs Sustainable Development Goals SDH Social determinants of health UHC Universal health coverage VNR Voluntary national review List of Tables TOC \h \z \c "Table" Table 1. Groupings of countries participating in the survey used in the analysis PAGEREF _Toc45142012 \h 27 Table 2. Approach used in countries to address the national health and well-being priorities: PAGEREF _Toc45142013 \h 42 Table 3. Example of code and theme generation PAGEREF _Toc45142014 \h 148 List of Figures TOC \h \z \c "Figure" Figure 1. Strategic directions and enablers of the WHO European Region Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. PAGEREF _Toc45142015 \h 20 Figure 2. Proportion of countries including the health and well-being priority area in NDP (N=22) PAGEREF _Toc45142016 \h 39 Figure 3. Countries’ national health and well-being priorities (as in the main health and well-being planning frameworks), WHO European Region (N=29). PAGEREF _Toc45142017 \h 45 Figure 4. Measures included in NHPs (N=18 countries) PAGEREF _Toc45142018 \h 47 Figure 5. Challenges and barriers to implement the National Health Plan (out of 22 Member States) PAGEREF _Toc45142019 \h 48 Figure 6. Leadership for coordination the implementation of the 2030 Agenda PAGEREF _Toc45142020 \h 54 Figure 7. Functions most commonly assigned to Member States’ institutional and coordination arrangements for implementation of the 2030 Agenda PAGEREF _Toc45142021 \h 56 Figure 8 Level of involvement by sector in the SDG coordination mechanism (27 Member States) PAGEREF _Toc45142022 \h 57 Figure 9. Measures to address the reduction of health inequities and/or improvement of the SDH included in Member States policies (N=29)* PAGEREF _Toc45142023 \h 70 Figure 10. Level of collaboration between the Ministry of Health and the health-determining sector (N=27) PAGEREF _Toc45142024 \h 77 Figure 11. Action and measures taken to prevent disease and address health determinants by multi- and intersectoral policies and action PAGEREF _Toc45142025 \h 82 Figure 12. Examples of measures to establish healthy places, settings and resilient communities included in NDPs and/or NHPs in Member States (N=29) PAGEREF _Toc45142026 \h 86 Figure 13. Specific actions or measures being taken by Member States to improve the dimensions of UHC (N=29) PAGEREF _Toc45142027 \h 93 Figure 14. Barriers or obstacles to strengthening health systems in pursuit of UHC (N=29) PAGEREF _Toc45142028 \h 97 Figure 15. Measures to promote investment for health and well-being and its determinants PAGEREF _Toc45142029 \h 101 Figure 16. Non-state actor organizations most frequently engaged in collaboration with the Ministry of Health in 29 Member States of the WHO European Region PAGEREF _Toc45142030 \h 104 Figure 17. Measures taken to strengthen collaboration with non-state actors by 29 Member States of the WHO European Region PAGEREF _Toc45142031 \h 109 Figure 18. Actions to strengthen health literacy in 29 Member States of the WHO European Region PAGEREF _Toc45142032 \h 113 Figure 19. Intervention context and strategic objectives of Portugal’s Health Literacy Action Plan PAGEREF _Toc45142033 \h 115 Figure 20. Processes carried out to support data and statistical development to monitor health-related SDGs in 29 Member States of the WHO European Region PAGEREF _Toc45142034 \h 120 List of Boxes TOC \h \z \c "Box" Box 1. National priorities are aligned to the SDGs, however fit to country’s own context. PAGEREF _Toc45142035 \h 33 Box 2. Cyprus: Sectoral frameworks and SDG coordination PAGEREF _Toc45142036 \h 36 Box 3. B elgium: health policy in a federated system PAGEREF _Toc45142037 \h 43 Box 4. Examples of challenges and barriers to implement health and well-being priorities PAGEREF _Toc45142038 \h 49 Box 5 Examples of health priorities referred to as underfunded or insufficiently funded PAGEREF _Toc45142039 \h 50 Box 6. Estonia: A network for collaborative leadership PAGEREF _Toc45142040 \h 55 Box 7. Examples of roles of multilateral organizations in the implementation of the 2030 Agenda PAGEREF _Toc45142041 \h 59 Box 8. Belgium: A process of putting together a VNR collaboratively PAGEREF _Toc45142042 \h 62 Box 9. Tajikistan: Collaboration in the design of monitoring and evaluation instruments PAGEREF _Toc45142043 \h 63 Box 10. Examples of mechanisms for intersectoral collaboration PAGEREF _Toc45142044 \h 64 Box 11. Examples of committees with the responsibility for coordination of the 2030 Agenda PAGEREF _Toc45142045 \h 65 Box 12. Poland: SDG implementation review with cross society stakeholders PAGEREF _Toc45142046 \h 66 Box 13. Belgium: Coordinating poverty reduction and inequity in a federated system PAGEREF _Toc45142047 \h 70 Box 14. Ireland: A Framework for Improved Health and Well-being 2013-2025 PAGEREF _Toc45142048 \h 72 Box 15. The importance of maximizing co-benefits for health and sustainable development PAGEREF _Toc45142049 \h 74 Box 16. Poland: Reducing social inequities to increase life expectancy PAGEREF _Toc45142050 \h 75 Box 17. Lithuania: Governance arrangement and coordination mechanism to ensure implementation of the state health programme PAGEREF _Toc45142051 \h 79 Box 18. Examples of mechanisms that facilitate intersectoral collaboration PAGEREF _Toc45142052 \h 81 Box 19. Examples of collaborations and measures taken to prevent disease and address health determinants PAGEREF _Toc45142053 \h 83 Box 20. Luxembourg: key health and well-being priorities to be addressed within/by the different sectors. PAGEREF _Toc45142054 \h 84 Box 21. Examples of how countries express the commitment to the pursuit of UHC PAGEREF _Toc45142055 \h 90 Box 22. Body or agency responsible for the pursuit of UHC PAGEREF _Toc45142056 \h 91 Box 23. Estonia: Improving health insurance coverage for UHC PAGEREF _Toc45142057 \h 92 Box 24. Tajikistan: UHC Partnership PAGEREF _Toc45142058 \h 95 Box 25. Ireland: Improving timely access to affordable care PAGEREF _Toc45142059 \h 96 Box 26. Lithuania: Financial challenges for better health care services PAGEREF _Toc45142060 \h 98 Box 27. Spain: programmes to promote healthy actions by other sectors PAGEREF _Toc45142061 \h 103 Box 28. Latvia: Procedures for public participation PAGEREF _Toc45142062 \h 107 Box 29. Belgium: Engaging with non-state actors in a Federal Council for Sustainable Development PAGEREF _Toc45142063 \h 109 Box 30. Spain: Health literacy schools PAGEREF _Toc45142064 \h 115 Box 31. Portugal’s Health literacy action plan and training manual PAGEREF _Toc45142065 \h 115 Box 32. Tajikistan: Reviewing data production PAGEREF _Toc45142066 \h 122 Box 33. Latvia: NDP assessment and use in budgeting PAGEREF _Toc45142067 \h 123 Box 34 . Open data platforms: Switzerland: MONET system and UK’s ONS’ National Reporting Platform PAGEREF _Toc45142068 \h 125 Acknowledgments The production of this report on the first survey to assess Member States ’ policy development and implementation activities in relation to the WHO European Region Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development was coordinated by the Sustainable Development and Health programme of the WHO Regional Office for Europe. Emilia Aragon and Priya Umachandra n are responsible for the analysis and drafting of the Report. Survey design was possible thanks to e xtensive technical support by Hilaire Armstrong, Christian Gapp , Florentina Furtunescu, Valeria Santoro Lamelas and Tarang Sharma . Administration of the electronic survey platform was performed by Mr. Sergei Bychkov . A nalysis of the results was possible thanks to the support of the analysis team , comprised of : Emilia Aragon, Hilaire Armstrong, Diogo Alves Lemos, Assia Brandrup- Lukanowa , Bettina Menne and Priya Umachandran. This report benefited from technical review by Tatjana Buzeti , Teresa Costa, Govin Permanand and Pia Vracko. Several colleagues from the Regional Office from all divisions contributed during different stages of the process , including: Chris Brown, Snezhana Chichevalieva , Emmanuelle Jouy , Marija Kishmann , Monika Kosinska , Joana Madureira Lima, David Novillo Ortiz, Piroska Östlin , Ivo Rakovac , Christian Schweizer, Christoph Wipple , Yongjie Yon and Francesco Zambon . Special thanks to colleagues in WHO Country Offices who supported us and national counterparts in the process of designing and filling out the survey as well as follow-up. Special acknowledgements to Ms. Jodie Littlewood for her essential administrative support . Bettina Menne and Emilia Aragon are responsible for the strategic development and coordination of the Report. Foreword [to be developed] Executive Summary I n September 2017 at the 67th session of the WHO Regional Committee for Europe , Member States adopted ‘The Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development , building on Health 2020, the European policy for health and well-being ’ ( hereafter referred to as the Roadmap). The Roadmap was developed to assist Member States in the implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and its Sustainable Developme nt Goals ( SDGs ) . The Roadmap proposes five strategic directions and four enabling measures to achieve better , more equitable and sustainable health and well-being for all at all ag es in the WHO European Region . In 2019 , an elect r onic survey was administered to assess the governance and policy development and implementation activities in Member States of the WHO European Region to support achievement of the SDGs. The survey, was design ed based on th e Roadmap ’s proposed five strategic directions : 1. advancing governance and leadership for health , 2. leaving no one behind, 3. addressing the determinants of health, 4. establishing health settings and resilient communities, 5. strengthening health systems for universal health coverage ; and four enabler measures: 1. financing and investment for health, 2. multi-partner cooperation, 3. health literacy research and innovation and 4. monitoring and evaluation . The s urvey was made available in English and Russian to WHO European Region Member States ’ official national counterparts on July 2019 and was opened until February 2020. This report presents the findings from this first survey . A lthough not representative of all Member States of the WHO European Region, nor of all the challenges and activities relevant to them in the implementation of the 2030 Agenda, this report provides a robust account of the data collected and is a rich baseline for understanding health-related and development activities in the Region. It is intended that this report enhances knowledge sharing by showcasing and exploring the variety of ways in which Member States are moving forward with the challenge of achieving the SDGs. In total, 29 Member States participated in the survey, representing 55% of all WHO European Region Member States . Of those who responded, 19 were from the European Union , five from the Commonwealth of Independent States and Ukraine and five other Member States not assigned to any grouping. Results of this survey show Member States have prioritized implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and integration of the SDGs into relevant planning frameworks. Th is integration has been facilitated through the creation or adaptation of institutional arrangements led mostly by high-levels of government in charge of promoting horizontal coherence across ministries . T he health and well-being sector was referred to have either a high or moderate level of involvement in these institutional arrangements . Engaging with key stakeholders was recognized as important for effective leadership. Member S tates referred in their responses to a number of mechanisms for intersectoral collaboration. Besides the interministerial coordination arrangements for SDG achievement, other mechanisms included the development of groups / platforms to promote cooperation between various stakeholder groups , such as commissions or councils that include d non-state actors. Some of these groups or platforms were created with a specific role, such as the development of a voluntary national review ( VNR ) . Some of the first steps towards integration of SDGs into relevant planning frameworks is for the Member State in question to understand their overall development process and identif y development priorities and needs, institutions, actors, resources and other factors that influence effective implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. For Member States responding to th is survey 86% had produced and presented a VNR at the High Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development , with a high or moderate level of involvement of the health and well-being sector (for those countries that had presented a VNR at the time of the survey). Through these processes, they also identified the importance of setting targets and indicators that are specific and adapted to their own context . The nature of policy development in a Member State may impact on when the SDGs are integrat ed. 76% of responding countries had an overarching national development planning framework (NDP) , with 90% including health and well-being as a development priority. Whilst NDPs aligned with the SDGs, all were adapted to the country’s own situation and priorities, particular ly over the long term. Other countries had NDPs in the process of being approved or stated that rather than having one overarching NDP framework, the SDGs were embedded across all or some government programmes. Despite seeing mostly positive results in the adoption and/or adaptation of mechanisms to implement the 2030 Agenda , and Member States referring to the strong role of the health sector in those effort s , more action is required to advance governance and leadership for health and well-being . H ealth and well-being as a development priority may benefit from being seen from a more holistic lens , that encompasses a life-course approach, considers the determinants of health and invests in health promotion, protection, preparedness, prevention and resilience. W hile more than 90% of countries reported health and well-being as a development priority, particularly in aspects covering noncommunicable diseases and the promotion of healthy lifestyles, c onsidering NDPs set the overall direction for all sectors of government , more focus could be placed on promoting and enabling healthy aging, education and life-long learning, promoting healthier settings and reducing environmental pollution and degradation . The new forms of leadership, governance arrangements, policy measures and actions Member States mentioned to have taken to advance implementation of the 2030 Agenda have the potential to become avenues to be leveraged by health stakeholders in support of achieving the health and well-being goals and ultimately the SDGs. Looking at policies within the health sector, Member States identified a h igh or moderate level of alignment between their country’s health and well-being priorities and the SDGs . Most of the health priorities referred by Member States were related to aspects of promoting healthier populations and advancing Universal Health Coverage ( UHC ) . There were some notable differences in the priorities listed according to geographical grouping : i n EU Member States , the most frequently listed priorities were related to healthier populations , wh ereas i n CIS Member States , the most frequently listed priorities were related to advancing UHC . Strengthening resilience and capacities to protect people from health emergencies w as reported by only four countries as a health priority. It is worth noting that this survey was taken before the COVID-19 pandemic . Regarding those sectors that the health sector most commonly collaborates with, a high level of collaboration was mostly indicated with the sectors of welfare and social protection, environment, water and sanitation, education , labour and employmen t. Member States referred to a number of challenges to collaboration, such as financial, cultural, logistical and political . Setting up coordination structures between different stakeholders for intersectoral cooperation is a challeng e. H owever, some countries referred to mechanisms that facilitated intersectoral collaboration , including by : m erging different functions , such as h ealth, l abour and s ocial p rotectio n , so they are regulated under one ministry ; u sing legal or other formal mechanisms, such as planning law s , conventions and protocols to facilitate and regulate participation, empowerment and collaboration ; identifying common principles to allow different sectors and groups to work together such as , “The principles of the European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development ” ; i nitiating a ction from the bottom-up, or what is referred to in this report as Localization , which was identified to facilitate integrating health with other sectors and non-state actors . Certain topics featured as c atalysts/accelerators for progress , including : Locali z ation , highlighted by some Member States , particularly those with decentralized governance arrangements. Locali z ation was expressed as c entral government, regions and municipalities adopt ing context specific approaches for effective alignmen t and implementation. Localiz ation was identified to facilitate participation, empowerment, enforcement of laws and regulations and collaboration. Benefits of collaboration with local level stakeholders were also referred to , particularly : facilitate integrating health with other sectors and non-state actors, implementing measures for UHC, as well as allowing successful monitoring of the SDGs. Increasing capacities, setting the appropriate coordination arrangements (such as community or municipal health boards) were some solutions Member States mentioned to enhance localiz ation . Digital innovation an d e - health , highlighted for advanci ng UHC , strengthening health literacy and reducing inequalities . Some Member States referred receipt of international development assistance to enhance digital and e - health infrastructure . Other Member States indicated to be increasing investment for research and building infrastructure for digital health service delivery and e - health. Some Member States also reported using i ncentives to strengthen innovation power in the community . To effectively implement the 2030 Agenda, there is a need of well-designed accountability mechanisms and “a robust, voluntary, effective, participatory, transparent and integrated follow-up and review framework” . R eview and follow-up mechanisms build on and go beyond quantitative data collection , and include qualitative and analytical assessment . To achieve this, Member States need to strengthen their analytical capacities and work collaboratively across governments and actors to c omplement official sources of data, fill gaps in data and/or supplement official reportin g. Member States reported that they were strengthening their analytical capacities by : expanding the role of national statistical bodies to monitor the SDGs and health targets ; working collaboratively across government and other groups ; initiating the process of collecting and ordering data to support SDG monitoring ; using t echnology to improve transparency, data collection and use ; and promoting participatory process to involve stakeholders in determining together the country’s baseline . H owever, fewer countries reported carrying out activities related to increas ing coordination, partnership and innovation to improve data collection and availability . Challenges and opportunities for effective implementation were identified in Member States responses. Most challenges can be categorized as financial, organizational , logistical , cultural or political challenges : Financial and political challenges were reported in the form of budget constraints and funding conflicts and accessing information on the availability of international funds – though th e latter was not an issue in all Member States . Organizational challenges were observed in a l ow proportion of Member States referring to have budgetary requirements for implementation outlined in their health plann in g frameworks . Cultural challenges were reported in the culture and identity of different sectors , which prevent effective intersectoral collaboration; Other gaps for effective implementation identified were the low proportion of Member States indicating they had implement ed evidence-informed proposed priorities . Few Member States report ed to implementing measures requiring collaboration and adaptability to promote investments for health and well-being , the pursuit of UHC, health literacy and overall better collaboration to address the determinants of health . Th ough it was not clear from responses the underlying reasons behind this trend. To support overcoming some of these challenges , Member States highlighted the importance of s trengthening efforts and increas ing capacities to advocate for the co-benefits of health and well-being to the achievement of other sustainable development priorities. Results also show that there is space to improve processes for increased accountability that could support, for example, the overcoming of political challenges . These include : • I mprov ing planning processes, including budget estimation; increased coordination, partnership and innovation, across all sectors; improved coordination within the broader data ecosystem ; increased transparency, availability and acce ssib ility for the public . These were measures reported as not being carried out by most Member States . Introduction In September 2017 at the 67th session of the WHO Regional Committee for Europe , Member States adopted ‘The Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development , building on Health 2020, the European policy for health and well-being ’ ( hereafter known as the Roadmap). The Roadmap was developed to assist Member States in the implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and its S ustainable D evelopment G oal s (SDGs) . The Roadmap proposes five strategic directions and four enabling measures to achieve better and more equitable and sustainable health and well-being for all at all ages in the WHO European Region (Fig. 1). Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 1 . Strategic directions and enablers of the WHO European Region Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Source WHO/Europe In this context , a range of governance and policy development and implementation arrangements have been adopted and adapted in countries to support achievement of the SDGs. To capture some of this progress and to support transfer of knowledge between Member States of the WHO European Region, the Regional Office invited Member States to participate in an electronic survey. The survey was designed based on the proposed five strategic directions and four enablers of the Roadmap . It was made available in English and Russian to WHO European Region Member States ’ official national counterparts i n July 2019 and was opened until February 2020. This report, prepared by the Health and Sustainable Development programme of the WHO Regional Office for Europe, responds to the request to the Regional Director to report on progress on implementation of the Roadmap . The report complements the analysis of Voluntary National Reviews ( VNRs ) undertaken in parallel also by the Health and Sustainable development programme . This report provides a robust account of the data collected and is a rich baseline for understanding health-related and development activities in Member States of the WHO European Region , in their efforts to achieve the health-related SDGs . Additionally , the report highlights some of the challenges and promot es new areas of research and innovation . Methodology Survey design T he survey was designed during the first two quarters of 2019, following closely t he structure the Roadmap strategic directions and enabling measures. Accordingly, the survey and the following report is structured around these nine blocks. Some blocks (1 and 8) have been split into sub sections for clarity. The survey was designed using both quantitative and qualitative approaches . This aimed to capture progress , challenges and lessons learnt from Member States in setting priorities , aligning their national development planning frameworks (NDP) and national health planning frameworks (NHP) to the SDGs , and setting effective multi- and intersectoral mechanisms to advance SDG policy implementation . Additionally , it aimed to capture the measures / activities included by Member States in their national and/or subnational policies that address leav ing no one behind , the determinants of health , establish ing healthy places and settting , achiev ing UHC , promo ting investment for health and well-being , promot ing multipartner cooperation , strengthen ing health literacy , promot ing health innovation and research and strengthen ing monitoring and evaluation . Data collection The survey had a total of 75 variables (Annex 2 ). A set of conditions was defined to facilitate answering the survey, resulting in 33 independent variables. Variables were mostly multiple-choice questions with qualitative categories. Where considered relevant, the survey provided the possibility to refer different choices than those offered in the preset options , as well as f ree space to explain certain response s. This gave Member States the opportunity to provide more context and nuance in conjunction with pre set options, as well as to explain the reasons behind a negative respons e. In relevant cases, respondents were asked to attach documents and web-links as proof of evidence . The survey was uploaded to the LimeSurvey platform. Each Member State was assigned a specific identifiable token for accessing the platform. Tokens were distributed to all 53 Member States of the WHO European Region through an email sent to the officially designated WHO national counterpart . They were invited to participate in the survey in July 2019. The survey was made available in English and Russian. Member States filled out the survey between July 2019 and February 2020. 29 Member States responded, a total of 55% of all WHO European Region Member States . 21 Member States completed the survey vi a the LimeSurvey platform, and eight sent their responses via email in a Word document. R esponses received in Word were later uploaded onto the platform by the analysis team . In some cases, Member States who completed the questionnaire using the Microsoft word version provided additional information that w as not allowed in the LimeSurvey platform due to pre-set limits and conditions . These cases were considered by the analysis team and decisions on how to treat the data was made by consensus. Responses from Belarus (Russian), Tajikistan (Russian) and Monaco (French) were not provided in English – their free text answers were translated into English. As the survey was distributed to WHO national counterparts , the person or team filling out the survey were all based in the Ministr y of Health or equivalent. The responses are considered official submissions on behalf of the Member State . Data analysis The data an alys ed in this report is mostly based on the 29 submitted responses by Member States . In some cases, the analysis extended to the uploaded documents and other relevant information (such as websites). One exception relates to the questions concerning the NDP and Voluntary National Reviews (VNR) ( questions 1a -f ) where answers were crossed-checked from data gathered for the VNR analysis and/or follow ed -up with Member States ’ focal points . Responses were analys ed by an analysis team made up of content experts and a qualitative methods expert. The analysis of the survey data took a mixed methods approach. For both types of data, initially data was checked for any duplicate entries, errors and missing data. Where considered necessary by the analysis team, Member States ’ focal points were contacted to clarify some responses. To summarize responses, Member States were grouped into commonly used regions , with similar geographical, historical , political and economic characteristics. The following groupings were chosen: European Union (EU), corresponding to 19 Member States , and Commonwealth of Independent States and Ukraine (CIS), corresponding to 5 Member States . 5 Member States were not assigned to any grouping. Table SEQ Table \* ARABIC 1 . Groupings of countries participating in the survey used in the analysis EU group CIS group Others group Bulgaria Belgium Croatia Cyprus Czechia Estonia Finland Hungary Ireland Latvia Lithuania Luxembourg Poland Portugal Slovakia Slovenia Spain Sweden United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland Armenia Belarus Republic of Moldova Tajikistan Ukraine Israel Monaco Norway Switzerland Turkey For the quantitative analysis, results were aggregated, and percentages calculated. For conditional questions, conditional percentages were calculated . Some questions allowed Member States to select more than one option, therefore calculating total percentages was not always possible. For the qualitative analysis, a novel qualitative interpretive thematic approach was used. The full free text answers were uploaded into NV ivo software programme with one analysis file per block of questions. K ey step s of the interpretive thematic approach were : Initial immersion in the data to identify initial codes Application of the interpretive frame Refinement of themes based on expert judgement Coding and theme generation was carried out mainly by one analyst but cross-checked and discussed with the wider analysis team to reduce errors and min i mize bias. A further detailed description of the methodology for the qualitative analysis can be found in Annex 2 , which includ es a sample of the coding. To maintain a coherent narrative flow to this document and to keep this analysis at a manageable length, we did not include a full list of codes. A full list and examples of codes can be made available on request. An interpretive frame (attached in Annex 4 ) was also used to assess the examples provided by Member States . The analysis team highlight ed those examples that particularly represented the themes of that block, were a strong outlier or a point of difference. To facilitate presentation of the data and readability of the report, case studies and phrases referred to by countries were in most case paraphrased. Focal points were invited to revise the report to check for accuracy. Limitations The data and analysis are limited by various factors: Although there was a reasonable geographic spread across the WHO European Region of participating Member States , this analysis is not representative of the WHO European Region. Nor does this analysis repr esent all the challenges and activities relevant to Member States ’ efforts to implement the 2030 Agenda and to achieve the health-related SDGs . The analysis is limited by the information provided by Member States . R elevant information or examples may not have been included in the responses or be contained in documents attached . There may be extra i nformation, programmes, activities or initiatives that may not have been captured by the way questions were designed or the space allowed by the online platform, nor was it possible to ensure all questions were applicable to all countries given the diversity within Member States of the Region. The analysis team also recognizes a risk of bias given that most case studies were parap h rased to facilitate presentation of the data and readability of the report. This potential risk of bias was mitigated by consultation with national counterparts once the report was finalized. Results Block 1: Advancing governance and leadership for health and well-being Member States have been encouraged and supported to strengthen leadership, governance and investment for health under the WHO European Region Roadmap to implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development . To achieve this, some of the measures propose d include: to integrate health and well-being, and their determinants, into national development planning frameworks; to integrate the SDGs in to national health policies; to align health and sustainable development policies, as well as ensuring successful implementation; to assess progress, identify targets and ensure compliance for the health-related SDG targets adapted to national contexts; and to set up institutional processes and mechanisms for effective implementation of the 2030 Agenda, including within health m inistries. The first block asked questions related to these measures. To guide their responses, Member States were advised to use their NDP s and NHP s . In their responses, Member States reflected their commitment to the SDGs and taking action to adapt and integrate them within their own planning frameworks and mechanisms . They used phrases such as concerted action , the need for sustained engagement with stakeholders and sustain momentum for long term impact. Member States also referred to the adoption or adaptation of action plans. Some Member States had for example, a general National Action Plan for Agenda 2030 relating to all SDGs , rather than a specific national action plan for health and the SDGs (Sweden). Most d ocuments and statements referred to action planned, rather than broad commitments to the SDGs without specific policy paths. Commitment was also seen in the high number of Member States with targets and indicators on the health priorities identified, underlining the importance of setting targets and indicators that are specific and adapted to Member State’s own context . Phrases such as “ alignment ” are often used in narratives about the SDGs. These phrases become more meaningful and concrete when it is understood how Member States have aligned their activities . Within this survey , alignment with the SDGs was defined based on national health and well-being targets ‘ scope and ambition ’ . A h igh or moderate level of alignment between their health and well-being priorities and the SDGs was indicated by 93% of Member States , which means most targets in their planning frameworks are aligned with the SDGs either or both in scope and ambition . In some instances, Member States situated their health strategies and leadership as being aligned to the SDGs , this included their N ational development plans and strategies, as well as targets and indicators . However, all were referred to fit to the country’s own situation and priorities, particular over the long term ( REF _Ref44479905 \h Box 1 ) Other Member States talked about the process and challenges of adopting and adapting the SDGs into their contexts , for example Slovakia referred to ‘ intense communication with partners to identify risks and barriers ’. Moldova referred to the challenge of identifying equivalent indicators to monitoring progress on the SDGs and a possible solution . Adapting the SDGs to the local context , within regions and municipalities, was another theme analysed in this block. Some Member States noted that this local adaptation was carried out through their s trategic plans, others expressed that adaptation was a way of strengthening the presence of regions and municipalities in national level decision making. Some Member States mentioned to have developed specific policy instruments for particular health issues , that align with the SDGs. For example , in Hungary a targeted instrument on infectious diseases illustrated alignment between this health and well-being priority area with the SDGs. Estonia indicated their separate plans and targets fo r specific health topics such as ‘… alcohol policy, tobacco policy, nutrition and physical activity.’ Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 1 . National priorities are aligned to the SDGs, however fit to country’s own context. Estonia stated: ‘The main [purpose] of the strategy is to answer the question[s] of what should be done to ensure successful functioning of the… society and state also in the longer term’ rather than focused on the SDGs alone. Israel stated that ‘ w hile Israel wholly supports the SDG-3 t arget goals as well as the global priority of ensuring all Member States reach the set indicators, many of the targets in SDG-3 are not as pressing in Israel, as many goals have been reached. While Israel is constantly working to improve indicators aligned with the SDG targets, there are many other unique issues facing the Israeli health system that the Israeli M inistry of Health must prioritiz e in the national planning framework.’ Moldova stated “ in the case of indicators for which it was not possible to identify a national indicator equivalent to a global or adjusted indicator, 26 proxy indicators were identified in the consultation process. ” Sweden stated their ‘health and well-being priorities reflects several of the targets in the 2030 Agenda, especially regarding equality, accessibility and quality. However, few directly refer to the SDGs.’ Alignment was also related to varying ways in which Member States approached the SDGs , aside from referring to explicit links in their NDP or VNR. One example was Slovakia, where the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister ‘… benefited in 2017-2018 from the OECD project ‘Developing the intervention logic of strategic planning by central government authorities’… Part of the project was a Situational Analysis, including [assessing the] distance to [achieving] SDG targets.’ Belgium mentioned ‘…administration is aligned with the SDGs for each strategic target but links have also been [identified] at each project level…’ Responsibilities to align and achieve the SDGs also rest with certain specific bodies. For example, in the UK, “ every government department ha d embedded the Goals in its single departmental plan. Each departme nt works with a range of organiz ations from sectors relevant to their areas of work. For example, the Department of Health and Social Care works with Public Health England to meet the SDG 3. ” With the objective to explore if the adoption of the 2030 Agenda had inspired modification of NDPs or NHPs, countries were asked about the key reason(s) for modification and when modifications have taken place. Reasons provided by countries show that modifications on NDPs are done on the basis of internal changes. For example, Estonia and Finland had review processes predefined into their plans , therefore showcasing the relevance of public financial cycles to allow for flexible planning and evaluation . In Israel, review processes are carried out routinely every year. In terms of what elements of the plans were modified, Bulgaria referred the changes as reflecting legislative changes and initiatives adopted with regard to the development of the country ’s healthcare system. Latvia gave the following context regarding how their plan was modified in response to a more recent National Development Plan : “ The Strategy was initially developed for the period from 2011 to 2017, but it was extended to update the situation description, problem formulation, objectives, policy results, tasks included in the Public Health Strategy for 2011-2017 and to align them with the National Development Plan for 2014-2020 and with the new financial programming period, including the European Union (EU) funding period. ” The following sections in this block explore more in detail the policy instruments and mechanisms. Health and well-being priorities in NDPs NDPs are defined as “a coordinated, participatory and iterative process of thoughts and actions to achieve economic, environmental and social objectives in a balanced and integrative manner” . Experience shows that NDP s are most effective when they are multisectoral, participatory, location-specific and embedded in multilateralism, and when the necessary resources and political will are available to ensure implementation . 76% of Member States had a n NDP, while two Member States had plans or strategies in the process of being approved (Spain and Portugal) . Three Member States commented that rather than having one overarching NDP framework, the SDGs were embedded across government programmes, for example in individual ministr ies or sectoral plans ( Cyprus, Croatia, The United Kingdom and Monaco) ( REF _Ref40136108 \h Box 2 ) . Some countries underlined that implement at ion of the strategies is an evolving process. Belgium added a clarifying answer regarding their federate system of respo nsibility for the SDGs, where there is as an umbrella framework in cluding some common commitments. H owever , each federal and federate entity has the responsibility to develop policies for sustainable development, including for health and well-being. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 2 . Cyprus: Sectoral frameworks and SDG coordination In their response, Cyprus referred to be working towards a co ordinated approach to the SDGs despite not having an overarching national sustainable development framework, strategy or action plan . Currently there are ‘…various sectoral frameworks, strategies or action plans devised by ministries or other national authorities’ with relevance to the SDGs. These differen t approaches to the SDGs are co ordinated and monitored by the Directorate General for European Programmes, Coordination and Development who has also ‘undertaken the task to map the various national policies and measures/actions addressing the 2030 Agenda Sustainable Development Goals.’ The overall aim of this work is to work towards formulating a comprehensive strategy and the ‘establishment of a mechanism that will supervise and assess the implementation of policies related to sustainable development.’ Whether health and its determinants are included in NDPs could give an indication on leadership for health and well-being . 90% of Member States with an NDP reported aspects of improving health and well-being , includ ing within their NDP priorities . ( REF _Ref39862876 \h \* MERGEFORMAT Figure 2 ) represents health and well-being priority areas and the p roportion of countries referring to have included them in their NDPs. The health and well-being priority area most frequently included was noncommunicable diseases with an average of 93 % Member States reporting it within the ir NDP (SDG target 3.4) , followed by the promotion of healthy lifestyles by 91% Member States (healthy eating, physical activity, tobacco, alcohol and/or improving air quality) (SDG targets 2.2, 3.4, 3.5, 3a, 3.9). A life-course approach to health and its determinants was the next most frequently referred priority area included in NDPs, with 91% of Member States including the health and well-being of men and women, 86% including child and adolescent health, 77% including healthy aging and 68% including sexual and reproductive health. Health systems strengthening for UHC was the next most frequently reported priority area included in NDPs (91% of Member States) , led by the inclusion of transforming health services to meet the current and emergent health challenges (SDG target 3.8) , followed by financial protection ( 82% Member States) , and a sustainable and resilient health workforce ( 77% Member States) . The determinants of health were next most frequently reported , led by education and life-long learning included by 86% of Member States with an NDP , healthier cities and regions by 82%, reducing environmental pollution and degradation by 82%, social inclusion gender equality and human rights by 77% and employment income and living conditions by 77%. The least referred priorities in this group were improving road safety by 68% of Member States , addressing and preventing interpersonal violence by 64% and aspects related to migration and health by 55% of Member States with an NDP. Aspects of emergency management and communicable diseases were the least frequently referred priority areas. Of note, only 59% of Member States reported including an a ll-hazard, multisectoral preparedness and response to health emergencies as a health priority with in their NDP . Only 50% of Member States reported to include antimicrobial resistance. Most Member States (90%) indicated a moderate to high level of implementation of the health and well-being priority areas included in their NDP, with action being taken on more than 50% of the health and well-being priorities. This was coherent with the high proportion of countries indicating to have included targets on the health priorities identified (90%) , and indicators ( 86%) . However, this was inconsistent with monitoring of the health related indicators, with only half of Member States reporting a high level of monitoring . Despite these results , more efforts to advance governance and leadership for health are needed . H ealth and well-being as a development priority may benefit from being seen from a more holistic lens , that encompasses a life-course approach, considers the determinants of health and invests in health promotion, protection, preparedness, prevention and resilience. W hile more than 90% of countries reported health and well-being as a development priority, particularly in aspects covering noncommunicable diseases and the promotion of healthy lifestyles, c onsidering NDPs set the overall direction for all sectors of government, more focus could be placed on promoting and enabling healthy aging, education and life-long learning, promoting healthier settings and reducing environmental pollution and degradation. The new forms of leadership, governance arrangements, policy measures and actions Member States mentioned to have taken to advance implementation of the 2030 Agenda have the potential to become avenues to be leveraged by health stakeholders in support of achieving the health and well-being goals and ultimately the SDGs. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 2 . Proportion of countries including the health and well-being priority area in NDP (N=22) Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 2 . Proportion of countries including the health and well-being priority area in NDP (N=22) Health and well-being priorities in NHPs Since its endorsement at the 62nd session of the WHO Regional Committee for Europe in 2012, Health 2020: the European policy for health and well-being has formed the basis of regional and national policies to achieve better, more equitable, sustainable health in the WHO European Region. I mproved health and well-being depend largely on political commitment. Both the SDGs and Health 2020 advocate for high-level leadership for health and well-being, and strong intersectoral mechanisms to address the many risk factors and determinants of health. Additionally, both promote whole-of-government, whole-of-society and health-in-all-policies approaches. Both strategies have also promoted the development of comprehensive plans for developing health and well-being, including developing and strengthening health services. A national health planning framework (NHP) – which can take many different forms – can provide an overarching or “umbrella” policy, involving a comprehensive range of stakeholders and sectors focusing on improving population health and its determinants, as well as the interaction between the health sector and other sectors . Such a strategy can support shared values, foster synergy and promote transparency and accountability. Survey responses showed that t he approach es being used by Member States to develop health and well-being were very diverse ( REF _Ref40281154 \h Table 2 ) . 8 2 % of 29 Member States referred to implement ing an overarching health policy either or both at the national level and subnational level ; compared to 93% of 42 Member States in 2016 . 14 % of 29 Member States referred to implement ing thematic or disease specific policies or strategies alone (Cyprus, Luxembourg, Monaco and Ukraine) ; O ne country, Moldova, referred to be transitioning from a thematic/disease specific approach to an overarching strategic approach , and is currently in the process of developing a Health Development Strategy 2030, in line with the National Development Strategy Moldova 2030. 48% of Member State s were implementing strategies at the subnational level ( REF _Ref39964358 \h Box 3 ) . Table SEQ Table \* ARABIC 2 . A pproach used in countr ies to address the national health and well-being priorities: O verarching health policy or strategy T hematic or diseas e-specific strategies or plans N ational and dece ntralized planning frameworks Bulgaria Belgium Estonia Croatia Cyprus Czechia Finland Hungary Ireland Latvia Lithuania Luxembourg Portugal Slovakia Slovenia United Kingdom Poland Spain Sweden Ukraine Tajikistan Moldova Belarus Armenia Switzerland Norway Monaco Israel Turkey Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 3 . B elgium: health policy in a federated system Belgium identified that their health policy was devolved in their regional system , which is guided by Federal and federated priorities: ‘As a Federal state … policies are shared between the Federal authority and the Regions and c ommunities. For instance, the funding of hospitals is a Federal competence, but disease preventio n relies on the Regions and c ommunities. Therefore, there is no explicit official integrated national policy framework for health, but several Federal and federated health priorities coexisting. The authorities c an therefore shape their health priorities as strategic plans or ad hoc policies. A coordination mechanism is set up between the Governments through a Health Inter- Ministerial Conference.’ Member States were then asked to list up to 10 health priorities as expressed in their health planning frameworks . The responses were analys ed and categorised into three overarching categories: Promoting healthier populations, Universal health coverage , Addressing health emergencies, and su bcategories under each. These categories were based on the WHO 13 th General Programme of Work triple billion goals and o utcomes. The most referred health priorities in their main health and well-being planning frameworks have been grouped in REF _Ref40880050 \h Figure 3 : 89 % of 29 Member States listed at least one priority related to promo ting healthier populations . The most frequently referred priorities expressed general aspects of healthier population, reducing risk factors for NCDs (alcohol, tobacco and food and nutrition) and health equity. 82 % of 29 of Member States listed at least one priority related to universal health coverage . The most frequently referred priorities expressed general aspects of health systems strengthening, including aspects to improve coverage and service packages for NCDs, maternal child and adolescent health, and communicable diseases. 14% of 29 Member States listed at least one priority re lated to address ing health emergencies. A h igh level of alignment between their country’s health and well-being priorities and the SDGs was indicated by 69% of Member States , defined as more than 75% of the targets in the national planning documents aligned to one or more health-related SDG targets both in scope and ambition. A m oderate level of alignment was indicated by 24% of Member States , defined as 50-75% of the targets in the national planning documents corresponding to one or more SDG targets, but not completely in scope or ambition. Of those Member States with a NDP, 85% also identified moderate to high levels of alignment between health and well-being priority areas in NHPs and NDPs. This is generally consistent with the findings of this survey. There were some notable differences in the prio rities listed according to geographical grouping. In EU Member States , the most frequently listed priorities were related to healthier populations , with four countries listing priorities related to healthier populations exclusively (Ireland, Lithuania, United Kingdom and Sweden) . In CIS Member States , the most frequently listed priorities were related to universal health coverage , with two countries listing priorities related to universal health coverage exclus ively (Armenia and Tajikistan). Examining the categorization through the health priorities of the WHO European Region, relatively few countrie s referred to AMR (two countries) , road safety (two countries), mental health (five countries), t obacco control (five countries) , and measures to reduce the harmful use of a lcohol (five countries). The results for alignment were stratified by the Human Development Index ranking, Sustainable Development Index ranking and G ross D omestic P roduct per capita ( shown in the individual country profiles in Annex 1 ) . Given the nature of the data and number of Member States included, it was not possible to identify a strong inference or trend. However , it should be noted lower GDP did not mean a lower level of alignment. Some Member States with low GDP relative to the other countries in the survey, for example Tajikistan, indicated a high level of alignment to health-related SDGs . W hereas Israel, with a relatively high GDP, indicated a low level of alignment. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 3 . Countries’ national health and well-being priorities (as in the main health and well-being planning frameworks), WHO European Region (N=29). For the countries with an overarching NHP, REF _Ref39962356 \h Figure 4 summarizes the measures included in the overarching health policy or strategy. R eported intervention areas are consistent with the main health and well-being priorities referred ( REF _Ref40880050 \h Figure 3 ), with the most frequent interventions areas being relate d to aspects to improve coverage and service packages for maternal child and adolescent health, communicable diseases, NCDs and sexual and reproductive health, as well as aspects of health systems strengthening, including transforming health services to meet the current and future health challenges, a sustainable and resilient health workforce and health information systems. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 4 . Measures included in NHPs (N=18 countries) I mplementation, challenges and barriers Most countries indicated either m oderate (33%) or high (61%) levels of implementation of the NHP priorities . O nly o ne country selected low levels of implementation, defined as action being taken on less than 50% of health and well-being priorities . REF _Ref39963615 \h Figure 5 summarizes the challenges/barriers to implement the NHP. The most selected challenge/barrier was ‘ i nsufficient budget to meet the priorities’ , which was selected by 72 % of Member States with a n NHP. Further explanations to this challenge and f urther context to the other challenges was provided in some cases ( REF _Ref39964365 \h Box 4 ) . Fo r example, in the shortage of health workers at local levels due to ‘brain drain’ abroad. Other challenges referred, were beyond the provided options . They related to polit ical priorities that are orient ed towards the short-term and the election cycle , including frequent reform cycles and updates to regulatory frameworks . W orsening health issues , ageing demographics, increasing inequalities and problems with accessing care were other challenges referred . Norway also highlighted that though there is progress in areas of collaboration and statistical data, there is always room for improvement. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 5 . Challenges and barriers to implement the National Health Plan (out of 22 Member States ) Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 4 . Examples of challenges and barriers to implement health and well-being priorities Countries referred to challenges related to polit ical priorities that are orient ed towards the short-term and the election cycle , including frequent reform cycles and updates in regulation frameworks . W orsening health issues , ageing demographics, increasing inequalities and problems with accessing care were other challenges referred . Hungary identified that ‘Development needs usually exceed available funding’ , especially regarding infrastructure investment. Such limited funding means ‘compromises’ in the extent and content of planned priorities/act ivities. Latvia referred to ‘…the current level of public spending on health is insufficient to provide good financial protection and timely access to a wide range of services with sufficient quality to be effective’ . Tajikistan provided more context to its financial challenges, explaining that over 90% of its budget is currently used to cover the salary of its public sector employees. T ajikistan also explained the challenges of limited availability of health professionals at the local level due to health workers' migration abroad. The local level implementation is also challenged due to rapid changes in its management. As a result of frequent reforms, regulatory framework s require constant revisions . Health planning, costing and budgeting are critical activities to inform policy development and implementation , which allow decision-makers to consider the extent to which policy objectives and strategic orientations are feasible and affordable . Having resource needs estimates readily available can help to advocate and mobilize additional resources from government and partners in support of the health plan. However , only half of Member States referred to hav e budgetary requirements for implementation outlined in their NHP. This may lead to a misalignment between the health sector priorities outlined in overall strategic plans and policies and the funds that are ultimately allocated to the health sector through the national budgeting process. This misalignment can have negative consequences ; for example, resources are not used as intended, and accountability is weakened. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 5 E xamples of health priorities referred to as underfunded or insufficiently funded Estonia: health prevention and promotion, access to health care and medicines; Croatia : noncommunicable diseases: that is cardiovascular diseases, cancer, chronic respiratory diseases and/or diabetes; Czechia: multidisciplinarity outpatient care with integrated health and social services, home care, palliative care; Finland and Slovakia : pr imary prevention; Latvia: the implementation of measures to improve access to health services (decrease waiting-times and patient payments), improve access to diagnostics and treatment of oncological diseases, reduce infection rates, reduce cardiovascular morbidity and improve treatment efficiency, as well as to improve m ental health access; Lithuania: infrastructure to support health service transformation including access to care, more focus on primary care and independent l iving community-based services. Norway: new and expensive treatments. Tajikistan: material and technical base, training and retraining of health professionals and u navailable laboratory service; Seven Member States (24%) indicated that their government was currently receiving international funds/official development assistance to support implementation of the national health priorities , six of these were Member States of the EU and 1 was a CIS Member S t ate . E xamples of projects being funded , included : Improving m ental health care (Czechia and Lithuania) , S trengthening or developing primary care (Estonia and Hungary) , E -health projects (Czechia and Hungary) , Maternal and child health, n oncommunicable diseases and c ommunicable diseases (Tajikistan) and pediatric emergency care (Hungary) . Framework to create conditions for good and equitable health in the population and close the avoidable health gaps within a generation (Sweden) Other priorities referred were o ptimi z ing hospital infrastructure , methodological development of the healthcare system , and a complex public health screening programme (particular disease area not provided). There was a low level of response about barriers and challenges to access ing international funds/official development assist ance for development and health, with ‘lack of information on the opportunities’ as the most selected response by 5 Member States (17%). Estonia elaborated on their response, mentioning the challenge of ‘Finding international partners, limited timeframe, for NGOs lack of co - funding and capacity.’ Governance arrangements and coordination mechanisms for implementing the 2030 Agenda The large scope of the SDGs requires efforts to mobilize institutions around the SDGs in order to improve their function and to promote horizontal coherence across ministries and vertical coherence between government levels . This is intended to break down organizational silos, remove contradictions and dysfunctions in existing structures, and promote holistic and innovative thinking. However a country decides to arrange its coordination, e xperience shows that factors associated with successfully delivering on a country’s sustainable development agenda includes ensuring: ro bust political leadership and support from the highest level of government; an institutional arrangement leading SDG implementation with sufficient influence and the ability to mobilize , as well as ; n ecessary capacities and mechanisms to plan SDG implementation in a comprehensive, coherent and integrated way; an institution al arrangement that reflects the cross - sectoral and inter - institutional needs of the country and is not perceived as restricted or biased to wards a specific sector; the creation or adaptation of specific mechanisms for monitoring and reviewing, auditing and budgeting structures and processes; This section covers responses from questions where Member States were asked to assess where leadership for implementing the 2030 Agenda is located with in their governance structures, the institutional and coordination mechanisms involved and the role of health stakeholders within those mechanisms. Leadership for coordinating the implementation of the 2030 Agenda was managed differently from country to country ( REF _Ref40126968 \h Figure 6 ) . 34% of Member States referred to having centraliz ed leadership, with Heads of Government or State Chancellery coordinating the implementation of the 2030 Agenda (Finland, Latvia, Slovakia, Spain, Republic of Moldova, Armenia, Switzerland, Monaco, Norway and Turkey) . Alternatively, 55% Member States referred to leadership at ministerial levels, either specifically referring to a specific ministry having the responsibility to coordinate leadership for the implementation of the 2030 Agenda or an interministerial structure . There were also some other variations, such as leadership resting with a government office for planning (Slovenia) or with an independent institution (Cyprus). The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Environment were the institutions most frequent ly identified responsib le for leading the implementation of the 2030 Agenda in those Member States with leadership at ministerial levels. Two Member States referred the M inistry of Economy and Trade and one Member State referred to the Ministry of Enterprise and Technology. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 6 . Leadership for coordination the implementation of the 2030 Agenda Most countries (38%) referred having an interministerial coordination structure . O ne country referred to a commis s ion with broader stakeholder participation, including civil society , in the process of development of plans and strategies ( REF _Ref40131547 \h \* MERGEFORMAT Box 6 ) . In Spain, the President of the Government created in 2018 a High Commissioner for the 2030 Agenda. Belgium created an Inter-Ministerial Conference for Sustainable Development (IMCSD) ‘… composed of all the ministers responsible for sustainable development and development cooperation’ – the IMCSD is the central coordination mechanism for dialogue between the various authorities implementing the 2030 Agenda.’ Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 6 . Estonia: A network for collaborative leadership In their development strategy, Estonia proposed a National Development Network (NDN) as a possible model of collaborative leadership to ensure consideration of a ll key development challenges. The NDN ‘… would be a politically independent body of strategic development planning outside of political parties, which would be both developing lo ng-term programmes and harmoniz ing the strategies of different sectors and monitoring their implementation… An NDN would be built up as a network consisting of the representatives of state authorities, the private sector, citizen associations, political parties and public agencies (universities, the Academy of Sciences). The role of the NDN would be to: draw up terms of reference for the preparation of development strategies, while the preparation of strategies would be ordered from both public and private analysis centres through public competition. organize discussions … with third sector actors function as a strategic self-management instrument of the society.’ T he functions most frequently assigned to the institutional and coordination arrangement are summarized in REF _Ref40127765 \h Figure 7 . ‘ Promote horizontal coherence across ministries ’ was the most commonly referred function, by 93% of Member States . Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 7 . Functions most commonly assigned to Member States ’ institutional and coordination arrangements for implementation of the 2030 Agenda Four Member States provided additional roles and funct ions of their institutional arrangements , including : t o ensure vertical and horizontal policy coherence (Belgium), to ‘circulate information and coordinate activities related to the High - Level Political Forum (HLPF) and implementation at the European Union’ (Portugal), assisting in the preparation of the VNRs (Czechia), and ‘dissemination and promotion of SDGs, creating space for substantive debate, exchange of experience and good practices in the implementation of specific projects for SDGs’ (Poland) . In general , all countries indicate d either a high or moderate level of involvement of the health and well-being sector in the country’s coordination arrangement . 69% of Member States reported the health sector as having strong control over key decisions, acts as a partner in the development of alternatives and identification of preferred solutions; while 24% reported the health sector having moderate participation being mostly involved or consulted. 83% of Member States reported to have a focal point for the SDGs in the Ministry of Health. Two Member States did not reply to these questions. For the engagement of other sectors, i n general, all sectors were highly or moderately involved ( REF _Ref40128259 \h Figure 8 ) . Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 8 Level of involvement by sector in the SDG coordination mechanism (27 Member States ) Some countries expanded on the options referring to the different role s m ultilat eral organiz ations have in SDG policy implementation ( REF _Ref40130217 \h Box 7 ) . In some countries, multilateral organizations had a central role in leadership or reviews, while in others, the work of multilateral organizations was seen as helping set international agendas , with countries themselves contributing or participating . In different instances, countries referred to the process of preparation of a voluntary national review (VNR) , which are a part of the formal follow-up and review mechanism of the 2030 Agenda voluntarily presented by Member States annually at the High-Level Political Forum (HLPF) on Sustainable Development. VNRs will be discussed more in detail in the next section. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 7 . Examples of roles of multilateral organizations in the implementation of the 2030 Agenda Armenia mentioned the UN office in the country as part of the leadership for the SDG agenda Czechia stated that all stakeholders with the exception of international organizations were invited to an open public consultation on the SDGs. Latvia mentioned the participation of their national statistical body in the UN Statistical Commission, which develops and approves the global indicator framework for measuring progress towards the SDGs, as an example of collaboration with international partners. Poland : WHO participated in reviews of SDG policy implementation Switzerland dis c ussed their role in international cooperation and efforts from the Swiss Federal Department of Foreign Affairs to promote Geneva as a centre of competence, including work on strengthening recognition of Switzerland at the international level and promoting establishment in Geneva of international institutions which are active in sustainable development. Voluntary National Reviews The SDGs will most effectively be achieved with the aid of well-designed accountability mechanisms and “a robust, voluntary, effective, participatory, transparent and integrated follow-up and review framework … operating at the national, regional and global levels.” At the global level, the High-Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development (HLPF) was launched in July 2013 to provide political leadership and guidance, to work to wards a global transformation for sustainable development and to play a central role in overseeing a network of different follow-up and review processes . Voluntary National Reviews (VNR) are a part of the formal follow-up and review mechanism of the 2030 Agenda voluntarily presented by Member States annually at the HLPF. VNRs are a key tool for accountability for the SDGs at both the national and global level. As the main mechanism for tracking progress on the SDGs at the national level and reporting at the global level, VNRs provide an opportunity for countries to answer to people with respect to t heir implementation of the SDGs, including an assessment of the results on the ground including successes, challenges, gaps in implementation, possible solutions and emerging issues. As a tool for accountability, the VNR process can strengthen national ownership of the SDGs, promote transparency, inclusiveness and participation in reporting on the SDGs, and support more effective implementation of the 2030 Agenda. For health stakeholders, VNRs are an opportunity to promote leadership for health and well-being and to put health issues high on the development agenda. Questions in the survey dealing with VNR development aimed at gaining a better understanding of how the responsibilities for implementation of the 2030 Agenda are shared in the country as well as the participation of health stakeholders. Questions specifically explored the involvement of the Ministry of health, public health institute, civil society organizations related to health and parliamentarians in the d e velopment of the VNR ( REF _Ref44584672 \h Box 8 ) . 25 participating Member States (86%) had submitted a VNR at the time of taking the survey . Regarding the involvement of health stakeholders: 68% of countries reporting to have a VNR indicated a high level of involvement of the Ministry of h ealth in the development of the VNR , where the Ministry had strong control over key decisions, led or co- led the process of development of the VNR or was considered a strong partner. 52% indicated a moderate level of involvement from Public health institutes . Moderate level of involvement was defined as instances where the groups were involved/consulted in the process of development of the VNR, such as providing data and information. 44% indicated a moderate level of involvement from Civil society organizations (related to health) . Moderate level of involvement was defined as instances where the groups were involved/consulted in the process of devel opment of the VNR, such as providing data and information. There was generally a low level of involvement from international development organizations and/or international financing institutions 64% of Member States indicating no involvement from this group. It should be noted that four Member States reported to not have submitted a VNR when they actually had . Therefore, they could not reply to these questions and be included in the results . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 8 . Belgium: A process of putting together a VNR collaboratively Belgium provided an in - depth account of their VNR process and how horizontal collaboration was achieved: ‘In order to prepare this first Voluntary National Review (VNR), a political steering committee, chaired by the Prime Minister was set up... Through this committee, a clear division of tasks regarding data collection was established. The Inter-Ministerial Conference for Sustainable Development was responsible for collecting data regarding implementation within the country, the federal Foreign Ministry regarding external action, and the Inter-Federal Statistical Institute regarding statistical data. Two pen holders within the federal Foreign Ministry were assisted by a close-knit network of focal points, ensuring gathering of additional inputs for the report text and easy contacts with the administrations and policy units within all respective federal and federated government bodies. At various points in time, the contributing administrations as well as the political steering committee were invited to share their insights about the successive drafts of the report. The Belgian VNR report was also discussed in the federal parliament during a joint session of its Committees on Foreign Relations, Environment and Health. Civil society involvement was ensured at different stages through the Federal Council for Sus tainable Development.’ Mechanisms for intersectoral collaboration Collaboration was a key theme in the national development plans and in the design of monitoring and evaluation instruments ( REF _Ref40132155 \h Box 9 ) . Member States mentioned mechanisms such as National Development Networks as ways in which collaboration could happen or is happening across sectors and different groups of stakeholders. Engaging with key stakeholders was important to effective leadership, in the words of one country. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 9 . Tajikistan: Collaboration in the design of monitoring and evaluation instruments The example of use of interviews with key actors to determine issues related to data collection in Tajikistan s hows the importance of engageme n t and collaboration when reviewing indicators to asse s s implementation of policy priorities. After two years of implementing the Republic of Tajikistan National Health Strategy (RTNHS) 2010-2020, the Ministry of Health identified a number of gaps that required a review of this package of indicators. In this regard, the Ministry of Health conducted an analysis of the package of indicators that revealed 22 out of the total 218 indicators were never collected due to lack of clarity in definitions of indicators and their sources. Besides, results from interviews with key participants from working groups showed that there were several indicators that were not indicative and did not carry significant information on t he implementation of the RTNHS. Member States also identified common principles to allow different sectors and groups to work together such as “ The principles of the European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development ” referred by Estonia, and in the design of monitoring and evaluation instruments, such as the revisions of the indicator set in Tajikistan. A number of formal mechanisms for intersectoral collaboration were discussed ( REF _Ref40289827 \h Box 10 ) . These mechanisms can refer to planning, monitoring and evaluation or to facilitate interministerial work as well as dissemination of information on - and promotion of the SDG s within government and beyond. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 10 . Examples of mechanisms for intersectoral collaboration S everal interministerial committees and coordination structures were mentioned for a variety of purposes, including general leadership related to the SDGs across government, on specific issues such as cross departmental working groups about housing in Tajikistan, but also specific tasks such as examining planning legislation. Portugal had two intergovernmental coordination structures, one internal to the lead ministry and one external to other ministries plus a network of formally designated focal points . In Estonia , the Gov ernment Office Strategy Unit co ordinat es the implementation and monitoring of sustainable development issues. References to the creation of specific entities to implement the 2030 Agenda and/or for developing the VNRs were also mentioned. examples include Sustainable Development commissions (Estonia and Finland), consisting of nongovernmental organizations who discuss drafts o f strategic action plans related to sustainable development before they are adopted by the government, and publish reports with policy recommendations. Spain created a High Commissioner for the 2030 Agenda, a “ …national institution whose function is to coordinate and follow up actions carried out by the State Administration. ” Czechia recognized the role of the representative for health in the coordination mechanisms as to ensure the representation of health in the country’s 2030 Framework. Ireland referred to a mechanism for engaging stakeholders in the development of the VNR, including stakeholder workshops. This was an informal mechanism of collaboration in the shape of an informal working group to develop the VNR. Though the presentation of a VNR itself is a formal mechanism at the international level, for the preparation of the VNR, the country here described the group as informal and going beyond government, with participation of “ social partners, ministry policy planners and other ” . The other side of collaboration were discussions regarding a centraliz ed or distributed responsibility for coordination of the 2030 Agenda. For example, in some cases the function of SDG coordination was delegated to an individual or to an ins titution, such as the High Commissioner for the SDGs in Spain ; or the Cross Sectoral Coordination Centre (CSCC) under the authority of the Prime Minister in Latvia, which is said to “ oversee the entire central government planning process, making changes when needed and providing guidance to ministries through consultation. ” In o ther cases, the respons i bility wa s delegated to a committee ( REF _Ref40289986 \h Box 11 ) . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 11 . Examples of committees with the responsibility for coordination of the 2030 Agenda In Slovenia, the Government office for Development takes overall responsibility for implementation and coordination of Agenda 2030 but is supported by the permanent Interministerial Working Group on Development Policies. Belgium had a political steering committee chaired by the Prime Minister receiving support from regional federated entities directly involved in the implementation of the 2030 Agenda and the SDGs. In Poland, a special Team was established to ensure coherence in the development of their strategy for sustainable development. The team operated as part of the Coordination Committee for Development Policy, which is a central platform for monitoring the country's development management process. It was ensured that members of the Team included representatives of administration at each level. In the Czech Republic, both centralisation and distribution of responsibility was done through a network of focal points in each ministry for the SDGs. Czechia also provided an example of collaborating on the collection of data related to the SDGs with a National Coordinator for the sustainable development agenda at the Ministry of the Environment in charge of coordinating the SDGs fulfilment, operation and evaluation activities with a network of focal points in each Ministry. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 12 . Poland: SDG implementation review with cross society stakeholders Poland gave the example of a review of SDG implementation and the coherence of the development plan in relation to the SDGs involving a range of stakeholders, including from local levels and multi-lateral organiz ations and public consultation s : “ A special Team was established to review coherence of the Strategy for Responsible Development with the Development Agenda. The team operated as part of the Coordination Committee for Development Policy, which is a central platform for monitoring the country's development management process. It was ensured that members of the Team included representatives of administration at each level. In addition to experts representing individual Ministries and Statistics Poland, the Team had representatives of regional and local levels… Socio-economic partners, including organizations of employees and employers, have been invited to cooperate within the Team. Among the participants were also representatives of academic circles, organizations belonging to the UN family (including WHO), and youth organizations. Public consultations were conducted in a multidimensional manner - at the national and regional level - by electronic means and by direct referring of the project to the opinions of specific commun ities and stakeholder groups. “ Block 2 Leaving n o one Behind Health inequities are differences in health status or in the distribution of health resources between different population groups, arising from the social conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work and age. Health inequities are unfair and could be reduced by the right mix of policies. The roadmap proposes to leave no one behind and reduce health inequities by addressing all health determinants, taking life-course, gender-responsive and rights-based approaches to health, and action on universally progressive policies, legislation and empowerment . Block 2 covers responses from Member States about their actions towards reducing health inequities . It should be noted that countries used in their responses the words inequalities and inequities interchangeably. For the purposes of this report, we understood inequities as the unequal distribution of resources between different population groups that are systematic and unfair. Policies, plans or strategies addressing the reduction of health inequities 86% of participating countries indicated they have a policy, plan or strategy addressing the reduc t ion of health inequities (HI) and or improvement of t he social determinants of health either at the national or subnational level. Of these, 60% of Member States ha d a specific policy dealing with the subject, while 40% indicated HI and SDH being addressed within other polic ies or strateg ies . The majority of countries (73%) reporting to have a strategy addressing th e reduction of HI , were Member States of the EU grouping . Member States illustrated their commitment to reducing inequities in various ways, such as making the case that reducing health inequities “is not only fair, but also a good investment” . Member States explicitly acknowledged the importance of reducing health inequ i ties for population wide improve ments in health and well-being, and ultimately for Sustainable Development. Not all Member States had specific policies or strategies dealing with the reduction of inequities, but most countries referred to the reduction of health inequities and/or improvement of the social determinants of health incorporated into various strategic frameworks. Czechia was an example of having both national health strategies dealing with the reduction of inequities by ensuring access to health care for socially excluded groups or people at risk of social exclusion , but also “ specifically targeted strategies … addressing the issue, such as social inclusion strategies, preventing and tackling homelessness, social housing concept, action plan to promote positive aging, strategies to protect children's rights, plan to promote equal opportunities for people with disabilities, Roma integration strategy, gender equality strategy, prevention of violence against children etc.”. Ukraine cited the L aw of Ukraine "On State Financial Guarantees of Medical Services for the Population" as an indication of governments commitment to reduce inequities. Measures to address the reduction of health inequities The survey then asked which measures to address the reduction of health inequities and/or improvement of the SDH had been included in the country’s national/subnational policies/plans/strategies or equivalent ( REF _Ref40132916 \h Figure 9 ). Improving access to high-quality health and education services and protection from financial hardship in using those services was the most frequently selected option , by 76% of Member States , followed by “ ensuring quality conditions for early childhood development, starting in places where children and their families live, learn, play and work ” , selected by 66% of Member States . Two Member States provided more information. Belgium had action plans “ …focused on several aspects of poverty, including health but also education, employment, social security… in a cross-sectoral perspective ( REF _Ref40290103 \h Box 13 ) . Monaco indicated not having a policy or strategy dealing with the reduction of inequities and explained that the issue was not relevant “ given the very high level of social security already existing ” . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 13 . Belgium: Coordinating poverty reduction and inequity in a federated system To red ucing health inequities, i n Belgium’s federated system both “ federal and regional authorities have adopted action plans dedicated to the reduction of poverty and the fight against social exclusion, in which the reduction of health inequ ities are included ” . There are number of action plans and reporting procedures related to the reduction of poverty and increasing social cohesion. For example, t he federal plan to fight against poverty includes guaranteeing the right to health as one of its six strategic objectives : 1) ensuring the social protection of the population, 2) reducing child poverty, 3) optimizing access to the labo u r market through social and professional activation, 4) intensifying the fight against homelessness and unsanitary housing, 5) guarantee the right to health , and 6) make public services accessible to all . For each strategic objective, the Plan formulates operational objectives, accompanied by concrete actions allowing its implementation. Implementation is monitored by the Federal Council of Ministers. At the regional level, for the Wallonia Region, health was one of twelve selected themes in the Walloon Poverty Alleviation Plan alongside other social and economic themes related to health such as housing and food. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 9 . Measures to address the reduction of health inequities and/or improvement of the SDH included in Member States policies (N=29) * *one Member State did not reply Access to healthcare was a strong theme in this block which also relates to Block 5 on universal health coverage. Universal access to healthcare was described as a way of addressing health inequities in Ireland and Czechia . Increasing health literacy for socially excluded groups or people at risk of exclusion was one of the strategies mentioned by Czechia . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 14 . Ireland: A Framework for Improved Health and Well-being 2013-2025 Healthy Ireland – is the national strategy including measures addressing the reduction of health inequities . The Healthy Ireland strategy targets the broader social determinants of health, recogniz ing that investment in population level interventions that improve health outcomes is not only fair, but also is a good investment. Sláintecare , the 10-year healthcare reform programme launched in 2017, supports the key aims of the Healthy Ireland strategy and aims to address health inequalties through providing higher-quality, accessible, universal healthcare. In reference to Block 5 on UHC and Block 3 on multisectoral collaboration, Oireachtas Committee on the Future of Healthcare was established to devise cross-party agreement on a single, long-term vision for health and social care and the direction of health policy in Ireland. Member States referred to strategizing at the local level as a specific mechanisms to ensure participation and reduce inequities . Belgium discussed federal and regional action plans to reduce poverty and social exclusion whilst in Portugal, Local Health Plans are a method to communicate health at the local level and promote community participation. These plans were described as “ strategic document[s] whose actions contribute to health gains, promoting more health for the entire population and tackling inequities . ” These subnation a l plans “ fall into strategic options of the National Health Plan…and are intended to contribute to increasing health gains through the pursuit of common goals, the integration of sustained efforts by all sectors of society, and the use of strategies based on citizenship, equity and access, quality and healthy policies. ” Empowerment and community participation were also themes identified to tackl e HI. Estonia described the need for “ …adequate and timely intervention [to] prevent the emergence of a new generation of excluded people ” with empowerment as a priority to achieve this aim. Portugal positioned their local health plans as a way of communicating health “ at the local [level] to increase community participation ” , though there were no details on how they stimulate the bidirectionality of communication to enable participation . The interlinkages between social and health issues in producing exclusion and poverty were highlighted by some Member States , as was the need to promote actions that will accelerate progress across multiple goals and targets ( REF _Ref44584754 \h Box 15 ) . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 15 . The importance of maximizing co- benefits for health and sustainable development P oland discussed the need for counteracting more than one threat at the same time, in particular in areas where there is scientific evidence of relationships between threats or correlating and protective factors. Luxembourg gave the example of employment as a way of tackling multiple causes of inequity : “ Government is giving the financial support to employers to facilitate access to employment and professional reclassification. ” Hungary focus ed their answers on food and nutrition, giving examples of a public health tax on unhealthy commodities , including a ban on sales at events targeted at children and students. The 2014 Public Catering Act is another initiative of the government to provid e healthier public catering . SDH were particularly highlighted in the examples of migration and NCDs provided by Switzerland , who framed their work on reducing on social and health inequities through these particular health areas. Related to this, migration and migrant communities were mentioned by Switzerland and Luxembourg in thei r responses to this block with Luxembourg citing a “ … s olidarity approach for migrants” as an example of reducing inequities : “ The Ministry/Directorate of Health takes care of the physical and psychological health problems of migrants. People with physical and mental health problems have easily access to the health system ” . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 16 . Poland: Reducing social inequities to increase life expectancy Poland’s National Health Program includes measures to address health inequities . Its strategic goals are to increase life expectancy for people in Poland, improve health-related quality of life and reduce social inequities in health. The implementation of each strategic goal is supported by operational objectives and tasks. Both operational objectives and tasks set out in the NHP will contribute to reducing social inequities in health, and are implemented concurrently to ensure coherence. Efforts are made to prioritize evidence-informed interventions with effects in more than one area. Block 3: Preventing disease and addressing health determinants by promoting multi- and intersectoral policies and action throughout the life-course The SDGs present a major opportunity to embed activity on the social, economic, commercial, cultural and environmental determinants of health across all sectors of policymaking and through engagement with a wide range of stakeholders. Many SDGs and targets are health determinants. For example, no poverty (SDG 1), zero hunger (SDG 2), education (SDG 4), gender (SDG 5), decent work and economic growth (SDG 8), reduced inequalities (SDG 10), sustainable cities and communities (SDG 11), climate action (SDG 13), peace (SDG 16), clean water and sanitation (SDG 6), life on land (SDG 15), and affordable and clean energy (SDG 7) all impact health and well-being. The extent to which a n SDG target is a health determinant is dependent primarily on the country context. There are several over-arching approaches to inter- and multisectoral action to address health determinants, including: Health in All Policies approach ; d eveloping portfolios of action on environment and health l egal and r egulatory f rameworks ; f inancial and f iscal incentives ; and i nformation, communication and engagement strategies . Often several of these approaches will need to be deployed to support interventions on health determina nts. The questions in this block aimed to explore the level of intersectoral collaboration between Ministries of Health and a range of health-determining sectors and describe the key health and well-being priorities to be addressed within/by health-determining sectors. Collaboration between Ministry of Health and health-determining sectors Collaboration was defined as high when there were joint working and co-production of intersectoral plans with clear leadership, tasks, capacity an d reporting obligations, moderate when there was regular dialogue through cross consultations and/or mentioned as partners in respective sector’s plans, and/or low , when collaboration is based on irregular , ad hoc information sharing/gathering. Based on th e s e definitions, Member States were asked to rate the level of collaboration between the Ministry of Health and the health-determining sector and describe the key health and well-being priorities to be addressed within/by the sector. 27 Member States replied to this question. Most sectors where highly or moderately engaged ( REF _Ref40134736 \h Figure 10 ). The following findings stand out: Ministry of H ealth had a high level of collaboration with the sectors of welfare and social protection (70% of Member States ) followed by environment, water and sanitation (62%), education ( 6 2%) and labour and employment (59%). Ministry of H ealth had moderate to high levels of collaboration with the sectors of gender &amp; women’s rights with at least 48% of Member States reporting joint working and co-production of intersectoral plans and/or regular dialogue with cross consultations. Similarly , for agriculture, food and nutrition, 48% of Member States reported high levels of collaboration , and 34% moderate levels of collaboration . Ministry of H ealth had moderate to low or no collaboration with the sectors of industry, transport, finance &amp; trade, habitat &amp; housing, commerce and culture &amp; media. Regarding collaboration with local and subnational government, results were mixed. High levels of collaboration were mostly reported by countries in the EU grouping . Other sectors mentioned with which the M inistry of H ealth engages in collaboration were private sector by Ireland, rating the collaboration as low; road safety by Spain, rating the collaboration as medium; taxes by Spain, rating the collaboration as medium; and, defense and interior by Spain, rating the collaboration as low. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 10 . Level of collaboration between the Ministry of Health and the health-determining sector (N=27) A variety of modes of collaboration were described in the answers suppli ed by Member States . Formal mode s of collaboration included trans-sectoral working group for developing guideline or established process for consultation. Spain described the creation of “ intersectoral tables ” at the local level with participation of other sectors, including the health sector, an activity that is promoted in the prevention and health promotion strategy of Spain. Belgium described “an Inter-Ministerial Conference set up to assure collaboration between the Governments of the Federal authority, the Regions and the Communities concerning health policies ” . Informal modes of collaboration were also described, f or example, Finland described “ informal meetings… and exchange of information … [ contributing] to successful intersectoral collaboration to achieve the health-related SDGs ” . Collaboration at different levels (local and regional) was a theme that also emerged . Croatia cited a national health promotion programme based on a multisectoral approach that “ required collaboration with the local government ” . Spain mentioned the provision of an on-line course about “Local Health” that can be completed by any person at the local level . It is designed with the purpose to increase the capacity of health professionals at the local level to foster health and well-being by promoting healthy environments and lifestyles. To facilitate access, the training programme was delivered online and was made available to any professional at t he local level. Lithuania mentioned a governance arrangement and coordination mechanism with representation from different levels of government to ensure implementation of the state health programmes ( REF _Ref40136108 \h REF _Ref44578061 \h Box 17 ). Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 17 . Lithuania: Governance arrangement and coordination mechanism to ensure implementation of the state health programme Lithuania mentioned a governance arrangement and coordination mechanism with representation from different levels of government to ensure implementation of the state health programmes. Each level of government has a differentiated responsibility: The Government of Lithuania is responsible for intersectoral collaboration and drafting legislation. The Ministry of Health is responsible for overseeing the entire health system. The National Health Board, with representation of national level institutions is in charge of health policy implementation. The National Health Board, which is subordinated to parliament, plays the most active role: the board consists of representatives from municipal health boards, universities, nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and public health professionals. The National Health Board coordinates public health policy areas while the municipal health boards implement health policy at the local level. Member States referred to a number of challenges to collaboration, including financial, cultural, logistical and political . For example, Cyprus mentioned that if actions resulting from collaboration with other ministries had spending implications , then these could be challenging to follow through with . Armenia mentioned financial conflicts of interest between the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Economy, where a framework for limitation of tobacco production is not supported by the Ministry of Economy due to the expected financial losses. Czechia mentioned the culture and identity of different sectors which can lead to a “ …kind of blindness to the other sectors” as well as the “ different political affiliation of members of the government ” as a political challenge to collaboration. La ck of leadership and political commitment, lack of evidence - based research and calculations of economic and health benefits, as well as massive industry interference in legislation and also lobbying ” in alcohol, tobacco and drug related policy was mentioned by Latvia . Additionally, Slovenia mentioned that political stability is a prerequisite for intersectoral collaboration. S etting up coordination structures between different stakeholders for intersectoral cooperation is indeed a challenge , this was highlighted by Croatia, however i t was unclear from the information given whether this was a logistics challenge or about a lack of will and clashing sectoral identities, or both. To the contrary, some countries referred to mechanisms that facilitated intersectoral collaboration ( REF _Ref44577995 \h Box 18 ) : merging of different functions regulated under one ministry, such as health, labour and social protection; using legal or other formal mechanisms, such as planning laws, conventions and protocols to facilitate and regulate participation, empowerment and collaboration; identifying common principles to allow different sectors and groups to work together such as “The principles of the European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development”; facilitating action from the bottom-up, identified to facilitate integrating health with other sectors and non-state actors. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 18 . Examples of mechanisms that facilitate intersectoral collaboration The Republic of Moldova provided an example of good collaboration “ between the health sector, labour and employment and welfare and social protection ” . These three areas are regulated under one ministry, the Ministry of Health, Labour and Social Protection. Ukraine provided an example of a planning law which required environmental assessment to be performed to consider the consequences of implementation of new state development projects for the environment, including for the health of the population. Belgium mentioned how the participation of the chair of Federal Public Service for Public Health as vice president of the Interdepartmental Commission for Sustainable Development facilitated the “ building of bridges ” between the vario u s sectors and this enables making progres s towards more integrated strategies and methodologies for the implementation of the SDGs. Measures to promote multi- and intersectoral policies and action Member States were then asked to rate the extent of measures taken to prevent disease and address health determinants by promoting multi- and intersectoral policies and action throughout the li fe-course by the health sector ( REF _Ref40292301 \h Figure 11 ). Most of the actions and measures were selected as a high or moderate priority. The strongest area of actions and measures referred to was “ strengthening and implementing legal and regulatory measures in sectors outside the health sector to tackle shared risk factors ”, with 66% of Member States indicating this area ha d been identified as a priority and actions were being taken , and 24% of Member States responding that the measure was identified as a priority, but with limited action being under taken. In their responses, Member States highlighted the need to- and actions taken by- Member States to consider both the contribution of health and impacts on health to and from other sectors . Estonia mentioned “ establishing common understanding on how the health objectives can contribute to the goals in other sectors, balancing different interests ” as an example of actions taken to promote multi- and intersectoral policies. Ukraine mentioned requiring environmental assessment for considering implementation of new state development projects to assess the impact of those projects for the environment, as well as for the health of the population. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 11 . Action and measures taken to prevent disease and address health determinants by multi- and intersectoral policies and action Member States gave brief examples of environmental and educational initiatives as exa mples of intersectoral c ollaboration ( REF _Ref40292401 \h Box 19 &amp; REF _Ref40292433 \h Box 20 ) . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 19 . E xamples of collaborations and measures taken to prevent disease and address health determinants Belgium mentioned an example of developing an action plan on Antimicrobial Resistance using a “One world One health” approach, as well as an awareness project focusing on health and environmental inequities. Croatia, Hungary, Latvia, Luxembourg, Ireland, Israel, Monaco, Finland, Slovakia, Norway, Moldova and Czechia mentioned actions related to the promotion of healthy nutrition and physical activity, some, for example, by applying taxes on sugar and sweetened beverages. Israel, Belgium, Tajikistan, Ukraine and Czechia mentioned actions related to environmental health. For example, Israel focused on air pollution and health . Belgium gave the example of an “ awareness project focusing on health and environmental inequities ” and Czechia mentioning a National Portfolio for Action on the Environment and Health in the Czech Republic 2019. Czechia, Estonia, Lithuania, Croatia, Latvia and Monaco mentioned efforts to reduce substance use and abuse, mentioning for example alcohol reduction programmes, tobacco control, harm reduction and drug demand and supply reduction programmes. Tobacco control in itself was a strong theme in need of intersectoral collaboration. For example, Armenia, mentioned the elaboration of the legal framework including introduction of comprehensive ban on tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship, total ban on smoking in indoor public places and other measures aim ed at decreasing tobacco use and consumption. The Republic of Moldova detailed that in coordination with local authorities, police are insuring the enforcement of respecting marketing of tobacco products near to schools and medical institutions. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 20 . Luxembourg: key health and well-being priorities to be addressed within/by the different sectors. Luxembourg referred to specific topics for collaboration between the health sector and a number of sectors. These are listed here to exemplify issues around which collaboration occurs: Agriculture: food safety; Media: collaboration between the communication service of the Ministry of Health and the government communication; Education: medical schools collaborate with the Ministry of Education regarding children’s health; Labor and employment: close collaboration with the Directorate of Health regarding disabilities, professional reclassification and surveillance of classified industries. Block 4: Establishing healthy places, settings and resilient communities Member States can address the challenge of achieving the SDGs through a renewed focus on the many dimensions of everyday places or settings. Both the physical and social characteristics of place can vary markedly between locations and over time, thus underpinning inequalities in health and well-being. Moreover, how people choose or are obliged to live – and to move and consume in the places they live – can directly affect the environmental processes and systems on which everyone relies for health and well-being. A key theatre and opportunity for action are those places perceived as local. Work to achieve the SDGs has attracted new alliances and actors involved in the longstanding healthy settings approach (for example, promoting health in schools, hospitals, workplaces and cities), such as cities and mayors. The Shanghai Consensus for Healthy Cities 2016 identifies 10 priority action areas for cities to achieve SDG 3 (Ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages) and SDG 11 (Make cities and human settlements inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable), and the Quito implementation plan for the New Urban Agenda , stemming from Habitat III – the United Nations Conference on Housing and Sustainable Urban Development, held in Quito, Ecuador, in October 2016 – creates the potential for new city-level collaboration for urban health; as well as the Sixth Ministerial Conference on Environment and Health , identified specific action points. The roadmap exemplifies a number of measures Member States can take to establish healthy places, settings and resilient communities, as included in the national development planning framework and/or in the integrated health policy or strategy. This block reviews those responses. In responses, Locali z ation of the SDGs was a theme highlighted by some Member States , particularly those with decentralized governance arrangements. Localization was expressed as c entral government, regions and municipalities adopt ing context specific approaches for effective alignmen t and implementation. Localiz ation also figured as an enabler to facilitate participation, empowerment, enforcement of laws and regulations and collaboration. Benefits of collaboration with l ocal level were also referred to, particularly : facilitate integrating health with other sectors and non-state actors, implementing measures for UHC , such as allowing for local specificities to be considered when planning health services , as well as on allowing successful monitoring of the SDGs. High levels of collaboration with local levels were mostly reported by EU countries. Increasing capacities, setting the appropriate coordination arrangements (such as community or municipal health boards) were some of the solutions Member States mentioned to enhance localizati on of SDGs policies and plans. A crucial task to provide better implementation support at the local level is not only to raise awareness about legal obligations or the requirements of statutory g uidance, but also assessing existing capacity to deliver, knowing what is being done well, what needs improving and how best to build new capacity. 72% of Member States referred to engag e public agencies, spatial planners, voluntary bodies, business, industry and all other actors in taking action to implement the common SDG priorities. Other measures are summarized in REF _Ref40137110 \h Figure 12 . Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 12 . Examples of measures to establish healthy places, settings and resilient communities included in NDPs and/ or NHPs in Member States (N=29) Of note, only 45% of Member States reported to be “ increasing resilience of households and communities so as to improve capacities to prevent, prepare, withstand, respond to and recover from climate risks and natural and man-made disasters. ” This is in contrast to the selection of meas ures and priorities for health-r elated emergency preparedness seen in Block 1 and financing for health emergencies seen in Block 6 . The United Kingdom referr ed to establish ing healthy settings as a responsibility at the regional level rather than national level: “ Health services …are devolved. Each of the four nations takes its own approach under its respective government; while most of these measures are in place, they are set out in diverse frameworks and policies ” . Block 5: Strengthening health systems for universal health coverage (UHC) Achieving universal coverage has been stated as the top priority at the WHO. When a country decides to move towards universal health coverage, it makes a political choice to ensure that all people receive quality health services, where and when they need them, without suffering financial hardship. Acting on that choice requires robust policies and political will, backed up by strong government capacity. There were a variety of ways in which Member States illustrated their commitment to the pursuit of UHC . These commitments ranged from a vision of universally accessible care, to commitments focused on reducing barriers to access and/or improving quality of service provision, as well as ensuring good use of services from the demand side. Member States also referred to the different mechanisms used to express their commitment to UHC ; for example : Moldova mentioned the commitment to UHC is expressed in their NDP, while Czechia, Estonia, Hungary reported the commitment of UHC being expressed in their NHP. Luxembourg reported their governmental programme containing the expre s sion of the commitment. Sweden highlighted the role of laws and regulations in implementing and achieving UHC . Portugal mentioned that UHC is enshrined in the Constitution of the Portuguese Republic. Belgium referred to different levels of government expressing the commitment to UHC, for example at the Federal level through agreements and political statements and at the regional level, through policy documents. In summary, 90% of Member States , including all 19 EU Member States , reported the pursuit of UHC was expressed in a national/subnational policy strategy or statement, with the majority of Member States being able to identify actions or measures being taken to improve in all dimensions of UHC (population access, services covered, and proportion of costs covered). Policies and action to the pursuit of UHC 42% of Member States referred to the pursuit of UH C being expressed in a thematic national/subnational policy/strategy or a statement focused on the pursuit on UHC . W hereas 35 % of Member States referred to the pursuit of UHC being expressed in another policy/strategy focused on health or health systems strengthening. 23% of Member States referred to expressing the pursuit of UHC in other ways ( REF _Ref40293557 \h Box 21 ) . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 21 . Examples of how countries express the commitment to the pursuit of UHC T he United Kingdom linked their response to the constitution of their National Health Service enshrining free access at the point of care. Poland and Moldova said UHC commitments were expressed in their national development planning frameworks. Israel stated that they had “ achieved UHC ” , therefore efforts were focused on improving services in the National Health Basket . Finland highlighted that the government directs the policy on social and health care client fees through legislatio n and responsibility for organiz ing services lies with local government, the municipalities. Regarding the body or agency responsible for the pursuit of UHC , most countries (72%) referred that the ministry in charge of health was the body or agency responsible for the pursuit/achievement of UHC in their country, while one country referred higher levels of government such as the office of the Prime Minister , and three countries referred the pursuit of UHC being a shared responsibility between the national and local levels of government ( REF _Ref40172128 \h Box 22 ) . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 22 . B ody or agency responsible for the pursuit of UHC I n Slovakia the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister of the Slovak Republic for Investments and Informatization was the body or agency responsible for the pursuit/ achievement of UHC. In Sweden, the “ National Board of Health and Welfare, the Swedish Social Security Agency, all the 21 regions were responsible for health and medical care, [and] all 290 municipalities responsible for elderly and disability care. ” In Estonia, the responsibility lay with the Ministry of Social Affairs, while Luxembourg cited the involvement of the social security ministry. Regarding the reference to regional or local level bodies, Finland said “ part of the responsibility lies with local g overnment, the municipalities… ” , while Norway said, “ t he responsibility to provide services rests with municipalities (Primary Health Care) and Regional Health Authorities (specialized care) ” . Member States reported to prioritize improve ments in all dimensions of UHC by implementing a number of specific actions or measures ( REF _Ref40172725 \h Figure 13 ), w ith at least 65% of Member States hav ing defined monitoring and evaluation activities to ensure progress ( REF _Ref40178866 \h Box 23 ). For example, in Ireland “ the Health Service Executive's national service plan and the deliverables in the Slai ntecare 2019 action plan detail targets and milestones to be achieved in 2019. Ireland is currently in the process of developing a framework to assess the overall performance of its health service, with the support of the EC Structural Reform Support Service. ” In Sweden, progress towards UHC is regulated by law or a decree and is followed-up by statistics available to the general public. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 23 . Estonia: Improving health insurance coverage for UHC Estonia referred to an analysis on the health insurance coverage conducted in 2018 . The analysis mapped current gaps in health insurance coverage and the reasons behind lacking or disrupted coverage among certain population groups. The following list key findings: The health insurance coverage of the Estonian population is low when compared to OECD and EU Member States : 86% of working age (19 - 65) population are covered. The lack of health insurance is unequally distributed between different groups: men, people of ideal working age, the non-Estonian speaking population and people with lower levels of education. Health insurance is missing for two main reasons: a) insufficient employment and income, and b) i nsufficient coverage of social protection and its take-up due to the population’s limited awareness of the preconditions for extension of coverage and/or lack of desire or motivation to request access to other benefits of the social system , which would qualify them for insurance (e.g. registering as unemployed or applying for an incapacity for work). There are many grounds based on which one could receive health insurance cover, some of them are ambiguous, it is difficult for the state to manage them and for the people to understand and be aware of them. Health insurance could be given to a further 1% of the population by adjusting the present system. To achieve u niversal health service coverage, attention must also be paid to waiting lists and cost-sharing, which are more challenging in Estonia than other EU Member States . The following recommendations were presented as possible options to increase insurance coverage: C hange the employment and contribution parameters in the present system so that health insurance would expand to people whose employment and earned income is unstable. Improve the take-up of health insurance by raising people’s awareness and influencing their behaviour. Replace the present system with a universal health cover that applies to all residents of Estonia. In spring 2019 , a national UHC working group was established to prepare proposals to the Government for achieving UHC. It includes representatives from the Ministry of Social Affairs, Ministry of Finance and the Estonian Health Insurance Fund. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 13 . Specific actions or measures being taken by Member States to improve the dimensions of UHC (N=29) To improve financing for health , Tajikistan shared the example of introducing performance-based funding financing reforms at the primary care level ( REF _Ref44578504 \h Box 24 ) . The reforms aimed at improving funding of primary health care, in particular , the level of per capita funding in all cities and regions of the country, as well as performance-based funding (in 10 pilot regions of the country, in collaboration with the World Bank). Reforming insurance to reduce financial barriers and increase coverage of people and services was also referred to , with Czechia discussing “ optimization of the reimbursement system in health care ” and Latvia prioritizing measures to increase the number of groups covered by the state health budget and setting a voluntary insurance for certain [services] that are not covered by the state budget. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 24 . Tajikistan: UHC Partnership In 2016, Tajikistan joined the UHC partnership of the World Health Organ ization and the European Union with a health system structured around input-based financing and significant out-of-pocket payments. To date, important targeted measures have been taken to determine the position of key stakeholders in order to advance key reforms in integrating and acquiring services, assessing the status of preconditions for introducing compulsory health insurance and improving financial protection, as well as the effectiveness of the healthcare system. The benefit package for the poor has been defined as well as a list of priority services, which will be included in the program for 2020-2023; the major criterion to design the benefit package was universal access to services. To improve service quality, Estonia referred to be taking into account socio-demographic and local specificities when planning and organizing health services, as well as developing remote services and a supportive e-health infrastructure. Israel mentioned a focus on improving services in the national health basket as a priority . Service integration was mentioned with reference to areas such as social services, community care, child and family services and mental health/psychiatric care. Finland said: “ the objective is to transform the services into an integrated system that responds to the needs of children and families ” . Slovenia mentioned the creation of health promotion centers within primary health centers , which would act as centers of health in local communities and would deliver preventive services in partnership with social services, the education sector, local administration and civil society. Estonia and Czechia mentioned integrating digital health into service delivery to improve access to services. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 25 . Ireland: Improving timely access to affordable care Ireland’s Sláintecare programme , implemented an Action Plan in 2019, which directly addresses an identified need within the country for “ … significant improvement in many areas, particularly in relation to timely access to affordable care. ” One of the four workstreams examines service redesign with a focus on reducing waiting lists and improving timely access. This workstream includes “ modelling various entitlement and eligibility scenarios and examin ing costs and benefits ” for universal access which will then be proposed to the government for consideration. It should be noted that Sláintecare was devised after the establishment of a cross-parliamentary party committee to agree on a single, long-term vision for health and social care. Core values to pursue UHC included collaboration, transparency and efficiency : Slovenia mentioned “u niversality, solidarity, equality, equity financing, accessibility, quality and safety of health care ” as core values of their health care system related to the achievement of UHC. Tajikistan mentioned that collaboration was required to complete the planned UHC-related reforms, particularly with the Ministry of Finance. Outside of government, Ireland, Luxembourg and Portugal gave examples of collabor ation between governmental, non governmental and private sectors in delivering stronger health systems – regulation of that collaboration is carried out through protocols and conventions. Czechia mentioned the Ministry of Health communicates and cooperates in formulating strategies and in their implementation with all key st akeholders both horizontally, that is with representatives of other m inistries, and vertically, that is with representatives of regions, cities and municipalities, with professional societies and representatives of patient organizations. Improving transparency was also mentioned by Switzerland in the context of their comprehensive healthcare strategy as a goal. The role s of local and regional levels were emphasized by some Member States , mentioning that local specificities need to be taken “ into account ” when planning health services. T he local and regional dimension was also mentioned in the way responsibilities are shared between central and local levels of government. For example, in Finland, Norway and Sweden, the local level is responsible for organiz ing and delivering services. Barriers and obstacles to strengthening health systems in pursuit of UHC Regarding barriers or obstacles to strengthening health systems in pursuit of UHC ( REF _Ref40293921 \h Figure 14 ) , the most frequen t ly selected option was an ‘ ageing population ’ by 72% of Member States . This finding was further elaborated by Finland, that did not select an ageing population as a barrier or obstacle to strengthening health systems in pursuit of UHC , but identif ied the need for continuous development due to demographic change as a challenge . This finding is also consistent with health priorities in NHPs and intervention areas, with transforming health services to meet the current and future health challenges as one of the priority areas most frequently referred to. Other barriers or ob s tacles most frequently selected were ‘ increased public demands for access to and use of new technologies, new medications and new models of care ’ (59% Member States ). Some Member States added limited funding of the healthcare system and coordination of care ( REF _Ref40173875 \h Box 26 ) . Of note, 80% of CIS Member States selected ‘Inefficient p ublic spending on health’ and ‘f ragmentation in health services delivery’. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 14 . B arriers or obstacles to strengthening health systems in pursuit of UHC (N=29) Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 26 . Lithuania: Financial challenges for better health care services Lithuania gave a selection of pri orities currently underfunded: “ Priority investment needs, to improve the affordability, quality, effectiveness and resilience of health care and long-term care services, have been identified , including f or example, improvements in infrastructure . Priorities are in particular to : improve equal access to affordable and good quality healthcare and long term care; move health services to the stronger primary care and more person-centred model; complete the transition from institutional care to independent living community-based services; support re-skilling, upskilling and retention of the healthcare, long-term and social care wor kforce ” . Block 6. Investment for health and well-being Better health and well-being can improve economic productivity, strengthen social capital and improve social protection while contributing to macroeconomic progress and inclusive sustainable growth. Investing in upstream health promoting policies and interventions brings economic, social and environmental benefits that contribute to sustainable development and equity. Current investment policies and practices (business as usual) are unsustainable and result in high human, social, economic and environmental costs . Only 10% of global gross domestic product (GDP) was spent on health in 2015, and arguably only around 3% of health care expenditure is allocated to public health and preventive action . If no measures are taken, total healthcare costs across the OECD countries will double by 2050 . In the Roadmap, Member States are advised of a number of measures to promote investment for health with the aim to achieve the most effective mix of investments across health promotion and disease prevention, treatment and care. The questions in this block aimed at exploring Member States activities to promote investment for health and well-being, to maximize co - benefits for health and sustainable development and to achieve the highest attainable standard of health for all at all ages. Member States were asked about which measures they were taking to ensure adequate investments in health and well-being and its determinants. Generally , results show an even spread on all the examples of measures provided ( REF _Ref40213305 \h Figure 15 ) . The most frequent ly selected measure was “ p rioritizing and increasing public funding for health at national and subnational levels by setting appropriate investment targets for providing essential public services for all (health, education, food, housing, employment, energy, water and sanitation) that are consistent with national development strategies ” selected by 62% of Member States , including 80% of the CIS Member States . The next most frequently selected measure was “ ensuring ad equate funding for pandemic and emergency response ” selected by 55% of Member States , coherent with the 59% of Member States report ing to includ e an “ a ll-hazard, multisectoral preparedness and response to health emergencies ” as a health priority in their NDP . The two least selected options were “ Assessing systematically public- and private-sector investments for their health and health and equity impact and applying incentives and disincentives to redirect them accordingly ” selected only by six Member States , and “ applying social and environmental criteria for all purchases and ensuring financial integrity in the health sector ” selected by eight Member States . Of note, only eight EU Member States referred to the measure “ applying social and environmental criteria for all purchases , and ensuring financial integrity in the health sector (Croatia, Czechia, Finland, Latvia, Luxembourg, Slovakia, Norway, Turkey). Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 15 . Measures to promote investment for health and well-being and its determinants Spain exemplified a measure of a public investment initiative related to the international Blue Flag programme related to the Spanish Healthy Cities Network ( REF _Ref40220632 \h Box 27 ). Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 27 . Spain: programmes to promote healthy actions by other sectors With the aim “ …to promote healthy actions by other sectors. ” In th is example given by Spain, “ Blue Flag guidance ” is a “ public investment in i tiative… to support the implementation of the Blue Flag programme that supports sustainable development of coastal areas by adopting the highest standards of sanitary conditions, health and safety, lifeguard provision and accessibility. ” Spain also mentioned the agreement with the Spanish Federation of Municipalities and Provinces (FEMP) to support the Spanish Healthy Cities Network (RECS), through which the FEMP establishes yearly Collaboration Agreements with the Ministry of Health and Consumption to reinforce the Network . Block 7: Multi-partner cooperation Public health and development challenges are often large in scale, with numerous and complex causes. Addressing these challenges lies beyond the capability and authority of any single actor and requires everyone to engage and actively commit to the SDGs. Making progress toward the SDGs requires collaboration among multiple stakeholders, including the public and private sectors, civil society organizations, other regional and international organizations within and outside the United Nations system, and individuals with the knowledge, resources and opportunity to become agents for change. Q uestions in this block aimed at exploring Member States ’ collab oration with non- state actors, partners and stakeholders and to asses s their efforts to wards strengthen ing that collaboration. Member States were asked if they had a strategy/plan/framework (or similar) that enable s better coordination or enhance s engagement wi th non- state actors. 69% of Member States reported to have a framework for better coordination, while 24% explicitly replied they did not have a strategy/plan/framework. N on-state actor organizations and collabor ation with the health sector The non- state actors most frequently engaged by the health sector were organizations of professionals (e.g. medical associations and professional chambers), followed by g roups representing specific or general interests (ranging from the most specific interest to the broadest issues of global welfare such as climate change) and ‘academic institutions’ ( REF _Ref40303160 \h Figure 16 ) . These three most frequently referred non-state actors were engaged in a range of activities, but most frequently in ‘participating in formal structures such as consultative groups, public consultations, and lobbying’. Other types of collaboration most frequently reported were ‘generating evidence’, particularly with aca demic institutions reported by 66% of Member States . Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 16 . N on-state actor organizations most frequently engaged in collabor ation with the Ministry of Heal t h in 29 Member States of the WHO European Region Faith-based community organizations were the non-state actor least frequently engaged by the Ministry of H ealth. Its ‘strongest’ engagement was in ‘advocating, addres s ing the public to instigate social change or creat ing pressure on the political system to shape policy’, re ported by 34% Member States . The most frequent types of engag e ment with non - state actors reported were through ‘ p articipati on in formal structures such as consultative groups, public consultations, and lobbying’, followed by ‘ a dvocating, addressing the public to instigate social change or create pressure on the political system to shape policy’, reported for almost all groups of non-state actors. ‘Generating evidence’ was most frequ ently a collaboration activity with academic institutions ( 69% of Member States ) and organizations of p rofessionals (55% of Member States ). ‘Consensus-building’ was reported as a collaboration activity most frequently engaging organizations of professionals ( 62% of Member States ), groups representing specific or general interest ( 51% of Member States ) and health-condition related community organizations ( 48% of Member States ). ‘Mobilizing people to act through petitions, demonstrations, membership drives and social media actions’ was reported as a collaboration activity most frequently undertaken for groups representing specific or general interest and health-condition related community organizations (both reported by 45% of Member States ), as well as identity-based community organizations and local community organizations (both reported by 38% of countries ). ‘Providing services to public (e.g. disaster relief, needle exchange, free medical care)’ was reported as a collaboration activity most frequently for groups representing specific or general interest and organizations of professionals (both by 41% of Member States ) as well as for private sector entities and health-condition related community organizations (both by 34% of Member States ). A ‘Watchdog function (monitoring public and private compliance with policy and ethics)’ was most frequently attached to organizations of professionals ( 45% of Member States ), groups representing specific or general interest and h ealth-condition related community organizations (both by 41% of Member States ). ‘Technical standard-setting’ was a collaboration activity almost exclusively engaging organization s of professionals as well as a cademics institutions (both by 55% of Member States ). ‘Social partnership’ (with a social role in issues such as wage-setting, working conditions and workforce training) was reported as a collaboration activity almost exclusively for groups representing specific or general interest and organizat ions of professionals (both by 38% and 45% of Member States respectively). Formal mechanisms were mentioned in terms of engaging with non-state actors, such as a procedure for consultation in planning , discussed by Latvia ( REF _Ref40224671 \h Box 28 ), the creation of advisory councils to ensure participation of civil society by law in Belgium, and the creation of intersectoral commi t tees to regulate and oversee strategy implementation in Tajikistan. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 28 . Latvia: Procedures for public participation The regulation of the Cabinet of Ministers “Procedures for the Public Participation in the Development Planning Process” prescribes the procedures for the public participation in the development planning process. The rules are binding to the Saeima , the Cabinet of Ministers, State institutions, planning regions and local governments. The purpose of the Regulation is to promote efficient, open, inclusive, timely and responsible public participation in the development planning process, thus, increasing the quality of the planning process and the conformity of the planning results with the public needs and interests. Public participation shall be implemented by formal (for example, associations, foundations, trade unions, employers' organi zations, religious organi z ations) and informal (unregistered initiative groups, interest associations) groups of the public, as well as individual persons (public representatives). Some Member States included mention of collaboration with informal groups. Latvia mentioned public participation in development planning processes implemented by both formal and informal groups (unregistered initiative groups, interest associations), groups of the public, as well as individual persons (public representatives) – though these are considered informal groups, participation is regulated by the Cabinet of Minister under defined procedures. Lithuania discussed the role of individuals as well as groups in the implementation of the health strategy, in terms of taking ownership of individual’s own health and family members. A range of outputs and outco mes of collaboration were mentioned, from raising awareness of the SDGs to specific inputs into strategies for health or more widely for sustainable development. Training was also mentioned by Hungary, who cited their “ … Strategic Partnership Agreement … to ensure more effective cooperation between the Chamber of Healthcare Workers Hungary and the Ministry of Human Capacities especially in the field of healthcare workers trainings and working co nditions”. Ireland cited an SDG Champions Programme with the aim to both raise awareness of the SDGs and to demonstrate, through the example of the Champions' engagement with sustainable development, that everyone in society can make a contribution to achieving the 17 SDG s. The regional and local dimensions of collaboration were also highlighted. Czechia used the example of their Strategic Framework that also serves as a guide for development of the strategies at regions and municipalities. Lithuania cited communities as key to implementation of the country’s health strategy. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 29 . Belgium: Engaging with non-state actors in a Federal Council for Sustainable Development Belgium explained having “ … a long tradition of involvement and consultation with civil society ” in the country. In all federal and federated entities, there is intense interaction with advisory councils (such as the "Federal Council for Sustainable Development" ). These structures bring together different societal groups, including social partners (trade unions and employers’ organizations) as well as environmental, development cooperation related, consumers, women, youth and academic organizations. The advisory councils are often created by law and are responsible for: Advising public authorities on various sustainable development policy measures and taking part in political dialogues with members of the government; Establishing a forum for the exchange of views on sustainable development, including the organization of stakeholder dialogues in preparation for sessions of statutory bodies, working groups and fora; Informing and raising awareness with citizens, private sector and public bodies on the subject of sustainable development; and Proposing research activities in all fields related to sustainable development. Close collaboration with civil society also exists in terms of raising public awareness of the SDGs. Measures to strengthen collaboration with non-state actors Regarding measures being tak en to strengthen collaboration , the most frequently reported measures were ‘c reating accessible forums for civil society organizations to participate in decision-making ’ and ‘s trengthening information sharing and health literacy ’ both reported by 72% of Member States . All other measures were reported by at least 62% of Member States and above , with no strong differences across CIS and EU ( REF _Ref40303375 \h Figure 17 ) . Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 17 . Measures taken to strengthen collaboration with non-state actors by 29 Member States of the WHO European Region 62% Raising awareness activities to mobilize political will and investment in health and well-being , and implementation of the 2030 Agenda for sustainable development. 66% Developing mechanisms/ platforms to promote cooperation between various groups and cooperative initiatives in civil society, academia, settings and sectors. 72 % Creating accessible forums for civil society organizations to participate in decision-making 77% Strengthening information sharing and health literacy 62% Raising awareness activities to mobilize political will and investment in health and well-being , and implementation of the 2030 Agenda for sustainable development. 66% Developing mechanisms/ platforms to promote cooperation between various groups and cooperative initiatives in civil society, academia, settings and sectors. 72 % Creating accessible forums for civil society organizations to participate in decision-making 77% Strengthening information sharing and health literacy Within their responses, Member States also identified common principles to allow different sectors and groups to work together , for example, “ The principles of the European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development ” referred by Estonia, and in the design of monitoring and evaluation instruments, such as the revisions of the indicator set in Tajikistan. Block 8: Health Literacy, research and innovation I ncreased health literacy gained through health education and various forms of communication, as well as actions taken through health systems and other policies, have the potential to support achievement of targets related to SDG 3 on health while advancing a wide range of other SDGs . Research and innovation are essential for achieving the SDGs. In this context, research and i nnovation refer not only to creating new knowledge and evidence or new technologies but also to finding novel means of implementation, including legal and financial instruments to ensure more effective and equitable health systems. The questions in this block aimed at exploring Member States efforts to strengthen health literacy in their population and to promote international and regional research and health innovation. The results for this block, including themes from the analysis of qualitative data, are split into two to better reflect both topics of health literacy and research/innovation. 8.1 Strengthening health literacy Health literacy is an important pillar of health promotion and a critical determinant of health . health literacy refers, broadly, to the ability of individuals to “gain access to, understand and use information in ways which promote and maintain good health” for themselves, their families and their communities . In the Roadmap, Member States are advised to integrate health literacy into policies and strategic planning at national, regional and local levels, invest in health literate organizations, services and systems and embrace new technology and innovations that enhance the health literacy at individual as well as societal levels, as well as other measures to strengthen health literacy. In the survey, Member States were asked about the availability of national plans or strategies to strengthen the health literacy of the ir population. 59% of Member States , had national plans or strategies to strengthen health literacy of the population s – o f these, 35% of Member States referred to a specific plan or strateg y for strengthening health literacy (Czechia, Portugal, Spain, UK, Norway, Israel). 41% of Member States referred to generalized health plans, agreeme nts or strategies that address health literacy (Belgium, Estonia, Latvia, Lit h uania, Poland, Tajikistan and Turkey). 12% of Member States referred to general health promotion plans (Croatia and Armenia). In Israel, the “ Healthy possibility ” programme, focuses on strengthening health literacy, specifically in the subject of nutrition. Tajikistan ex e mplified the importance of community participation in the priority - setting with the pilot project , “ Public Health Handbook ” . REF _Ref40303686 \h Figure 18 summarizes the actions Member States reported to be implementing to strengthen health literacy. The highest ranked actions were ‘providing easy access to health information and services and navigation assistance’ and ‘actions implement ed through media and digital health’, both reported by 69% of Member States . These actions were followed by actions in specific settings, with 55% of Member States reporting actions implemented at the workplace , 5 1% Member States reporting actions at the individual, community, organization and systems level , and 48% of Member States reporting actions to improve the living envi r o nment . The least frequently reported action was ‘to support intersectoral work, political leadership and strategies to overcome cultural barrier into health literacy policy”, ( 24% of Member States). This finding disputes the wider general commitment to support intersectoral working and multipartner cooperation ( REF _Ref44329891 \h Block 7 ) . Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 18 . Actions to strengthen health literacy in 29 Member States of the WHO European Region Individual health literacy levels among users , as well as providers, influencers, and decision-makers , is a precondition for successful implementation of any health initiative involving the exchange of information. Countries referred different examples to increasing capacity -building on health literacy. T he United Kingdom gave an example related to making library and knowledge services accessible , to increasing the awareness of health professionals on health literacy , as well as support ing members of the public in improving their health literacy, including their digital health literacy . This was done through partnerships between health librarians in the NHS and public librarians in local authorities. Portugal also deemed it important to “ promote the training of health professionals in the development of interaction and communication strategies with people ” ( REF _Ref40303797 \h Box 31 ) . Health literate settings was a theme observed in examples from the UK and Spain, where schools and prisons were also targeted sites for health literacy programmes ( REF _Ref40303756 \h Box 30 ). Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 30 . Spain: Health literacy schools Spain referenced the programme “ Network of Citizen’s Schools for health ” which is an online resource created with the purpose of empowering patients, famil ies and carers by making knowledge, tools and the best available information accessible through the website. The information available takes into account the best evidence , and presents it in a way that is understandable for the citizens as well as applicable within each person’s reality, values and beliefs. Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 31 . Portugal’s Health l iteracy a ction p lan and training manual Portugal has a Health literacy action plan that includes the following objectives : Adopting healthy lifestyles in the daily context Training for a proper use of the health system Promoting well-being Promoting knowledge and research The action plan intends to continuously and consciously improve health literacy levels of the Portuguese population in a sustainable way. It includes measures to facilitate the navigation of the National Health Service (SNS) and the health system in general. The Action Plan uses a life-cycle approach and frames its implementation by setting, context and strategic objectives, in line with the framework of the National Health Plan ( REF _Ref40880474 \h Figure 19 ) . Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 19 . Intervention context and strategic objectives of Portugal’s Health Literacy Action Plan Source: Portugal’s Health Literacy Action Plan Portugal also referenced their ‘Health Literacy Good Practices Manual’ for the training of health professionals. “ This manual is presented as a working tool available to health professionals in order to stimulate their reflection and action for promoting health literacy of the population. Its main objective is to promote the training of health professionals in the development of interaction and communication strategies with people and transform the existing paradigm, focused mainly on the cure of the disease towards a focus on disease prevention and health promotion. ” 8.2 Promoting health innovation and research The SDGs provide opportunities for innovation in, for example, information and communication technologies and use, improved service provision and system performance, and the monitoring of population health and of the impact of health policies. These opportunities also include new approaches to health information analysis, which have the potential to improve and contextualize the meaning of information and ensure its use as the basis for making effective health policy. In the roadmap, Member States are advised to : develop, implement and monitor intersectoral national and local strategies to strengthen information technology for use by individuals and in education , widely shar e evidence and promot e regional cooperation in science, technology and innovation to enhance knowledge sharing and translation In the survey, Member States were asked about the availability of a national strategy/plan to promote innovation, research and development to create new knowledge and evidence or technologies, as well as to find novel means of implementation, including legal and financial instruments for alignment and acceleration of SDG attainment. Only 44 % of Member States referred to have a national strategy/plan to promote innovation, rese arch and development, most of these Member States (77%) were EU Member States . Some countrie s gave examples of roadmaps, strategies and policies specifically related to research and inn ov ation for health and sustainable development. A variety of initiatives to promote research and innovation were referred to in Member State’s answers. Belgium mentioned a Federal research program with the purpose of meet ing the needs for scientific knowledge of the Belgian federal departments and to support the scientific potential of the Federal Scientific Institutions. The programme has three pillars, the third one focused on “ …Federal societal challenges, including sustainability and health ” . Sweden mentioned the creation in 2015 of the National Innovation Council to strengthen Sweden's innovation power. The council aims to strengthen cooperation in the community between important actors, such as academia, business and public sector, promote good cooperation within the government and the ministries for a developed innovation policy. Portugal mentioned GovTech , a Government initiative that aims to reward and support innovative start - up products and services that meet one of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Effective co ordination of cross societal institutions and organi z ations to lead to improvements in research and innovation was emphasized, with Latvia characterizing the groups involved under the concept of an “ innovation system ” , emphasizing the need to optimize “ science, technology and innovation governance by ensuring effective coordination and increasing investment [on] research and development. ” Coordination at a ministerial level was also cited as important. Finland referred to have a “ Health Sector Growth Strategy for Research and Innovation Activities Roadmap for 2016–2018 ” which was jointly developed by the Ministry of Employment and the Economy, the Ministry of Education and Culture, the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health, research and innovation funding providers (Finnish Funding Agency for Innovation, Academy of Finland) and health sector players. Cyprus cited centers working towards Innovation, Research and Development for new knowledge and evidence or technologies, like U niversities, Research Centers . Israel has a government Innovation Authority working in partnership with the Ministry of Health on health-related research, development and new technologies. Motivations to invest in health innovation and research included improving a count ry’s position as an internationally renowned forerunner in health sector research and innovation (Finland) , as well as the objecti ve to promote the international competitiveness of the country’s scientific sector (Latvia). Latvia also emphasized its principle of subnational development and concentrating research on fewer and stronger institutions that are spread through out the country. Latvia also had specific targets related to improvements in innovation and research, such as increasing publication of scientific articles published in recognized international databases to 1500 articles and inventions of up to 50 intellectual property units per year. Block 9. Monitoring and Evaluation T he 2030 Agenda place the generation and use of equity-sensitive evidence -based information at the core of the Member States ’ ability to make policies and measure their impacts. N ew ways of generating, measuring, analysing, coordinating and promoting the use of data and information for policies to improve health and well-being and reduce inequalities are needed for improved policy-making and to effectively engage other sectors and promote investment for health . Questions in this block aimed to explore Member State actions taken to strengthen national health information systems, inform and evaluate policies for health and well-being and su pport reporting on the SDGs. The first question of this block explored if the Member State had already completed a SDG baseline analysis. Only 69% of Member States referred to ha v ing performed a n SDG baseline analysis , while we know that 25 participating Member States (86%) had submitted a VNR at the time of taking th is survey (Block 1) . Two Member States supported their answer by attaching their Voluntary National Review (Ireland and Israel). 11 Member States uploaded other baseline documents. Regarding processes carried out to support data and statistical development to monitor the health-related SDGs, 72% of Member States had begun the initial work of collecting and ordering data to support SDG monitoring ( REF _Ref44578878 \h Box 32 ) , but fewer Member States (45%) had carried out activities related to increase coordination, partnership and innovation across the broader data ecosystem and making this information availabl e and accessible to the public. REF _Ref40227766 \h Figure 20 summarizes the processes started by Member States in this regard. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 20 . Processes carried out to support data and statistical development to monitor health-related SDGs in 29 Member States of the WHO European Region Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 32 . Tajikistan: Reviewing data production Tajikistan presented a process of reviewing indicators , which illustrates the importance of revising data production instruments, including data sources, their comparability and frequencies, and how these support monitoring progress on the country’s health goals and the SDGs. “ …After the second year of implementation of the strategy [Republic of Tajikistan National Health Strategy (RTNHS) 2010-2020], the Ministry of Health identified a number of gaps that required a review of this package of indicators. In this regard, the Ministry of Health conducted an analysis of the package of indicators with a view to its use as the main M&amp;E [Monitoring and Evaluation] tool to assess annual progress in the implementation of the RTNHS. In 2013, the review of the indicator package revealed that al though the data had been collected for 2 years, 22 out of the total 218 indicators were never collected due to a lack of clarity in definitions of indicators and their sources. Additionally , results from interviews with key participants from working groups showed that there were several indicators that were not indicative and did not carry significant information on the implementation of the RTNHS. ” The use of interviews with key actors to determine issues related to data collection is notable, and possibly something other Member States could consider when reviewing the indicators they use to asses implementation of policy priorities. Member States highlighted the international dimension considered when collecting data on SDGs targets nationally. For example, Latvia mentioned “ our sustainability agenda has both a domestic and an international dimension… ” recognizing that the Sustainable Development Agenda has both domestic and an international dimension. To adapt the SDG indicator framework, development planners compared the SDG targets and global indicators with existing policy goals and target indicators. Such comparison was enabled by using international indicator sets such as official UN, Eurostat, Sustainable Development Solution Network (SDSN) and OECD pilot project indicators ( REF _Ref44578915 \h Box 33 ) . Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 33 . Latvia: NDP assessment and use in budgeting Latvia gave an example of assessing the impact of development policy and how this has been used for planning and budgeting. In order to achieve more efficiency, in 2016 “ …the Ministry of Finance introduced a new budget expenditure review procedure. The government financing decisions made in previous years are periodically re - evaluated. This process refocuses budget expenditures on relevant performance indicators. The [SDG] Cross Sectoral Coordination Centre’s performs bi-annual impact assessments of the NDP assessing the contribution of investments in achieving progress on the desired policy outcomes, and provide recommendations to the government and Parliament. ” In 2017, a mid-term impact assessment was carried out for the NDP 2014-2020. Progress was qualified based on the SDGs: 1 - significant progress/ the trend fully complies with the sustainable development goal; 0 – insignificant positive or negative changes/ the trend does not move towards the achievement of the sustainable development goal; -1– significant negative changes/ the trend moves against the achievement of the sustainable development goal. A key finding of mid-term impact assessment was that “ …although income inequality has fallen in recent years, the NDP2020 target will not be achieved. The Gini Index, the inequality measure used in Latvia 2030, has also not changed significantly – it still remains one of the highest in the EU. ” The assessment highlighted two areas of focus: 1. Ensuring an Innovative and Eco-Efficient Economy 2. Reducing Income and Opportunity Inequality. Building on this assessment, in 2019 “ a series of midterm impact assessments will be carried out on several important Latvian sectoral policies, including public health, inclusive education, inclusive employment and other areas. These will provide additional detai l needed to plan future policy.” In the other direction, Czechia outlined how they have used data collected on international megatrends to shape their sustainable development strategies, including the possible impact on the effectiveness of meeting the objectives of the ir country’s sustainable development strategy . Monaco outlined a particular issue in obtaining data for their population: “ given the specificities of the Member State and the overlapping of populations and health systems with neighbouring France, it is sometimes difficult to obtain exploitable statistics. ” A number of methods for developing a baseline analysis on SDGs were presented. Switzerland used qualitative objectives to group their key development indicators ( REF _Ref44578800 \h Box 34 ) . Latvia had a participatory process to involve stakeholders in putting together the country’s baseline for all SDGs which is then approved by the Cabinet of Ministers. Hungary gave the example of their national e-health platform, the Electronic Health Service Space , as an answer to a process carried out to support data and statistical development to monitor the health-related SDGs. Digitalization for improving data collection and communication , and sharing these results, was a final theme. Member States were in the process of improving both the digital processes in collecting monitoring data (e.g. Latvia) , and in piloting a platform to verify the system of data collection and interpretation and publishing indicators and results available online (e.g. Switzerland). Box SEQ Box \* ARABIC 34 . Open data platforms: Switzerland: MONET system and UK’s ONS’ National Reporting Platform Switzerland’s MONET system, contains indicators designed to measure progress towards sustainable development. Intended for both the general public and policymakers, MONET provides data on ap p roximately 100 indicator s that are regularly updated. The system is based on three principles: social solidarity, economic efficiency and ecological responsibility. These principles ultimately constitute the framework with which observed developments can be rated with regard to their sustainability. Therefore, each indicator must be related to at least one principle. The assessment of each indicator is presented in a simplified manner in the form of a tile with colors and symbols t o facilitate its understanding. In the UK, d ata for the Global Indicators is reported to the United Nations (UN) by the Office for National Statistics (ONS), the UK’s national statistics agency. This data is open, transparent and accessible via the ONS’ National Reporting Platform . The Platform sets out the Global Indicators for which data is available, the source, disaggregation where available, and any other relevant information. Discussion For the discussion, r esults are summarized using the E4As approach developed and proposed by the WHO Regional Office for Europe as a framework for action to accelerate progress towards the SDGs . The E4A approach consists of five building blocks : engage; assess; align; accelerate; and account ( REF _Ref45143719 \h Figure 21 ) . Engage is the pace-maker that drives action; the 4As are building blocks and their elements can be used in a continuous and synchronized way. While all of these parts should be considered during implementation, some may be stressed or relied on more than others, depending on the needs and priorities of each country. P olicies, processes, activities, and interventions around these five building blocks, operating in continuous and synchronized action were identified in Member States responses. Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 21 . The E4A approach to implement the SDGs Engage E ngag e ment with key stakeholders was recognized as important to effective leadership by Member States participating in the survey . Phrases such as concerted action , the need for sustained engagement with stakeholders and sustain ed momentum for long term impact where referred to by Member States . C ommitment to the SDGs was reflected by taking action to adapt and integrate them within Member States’ own planning frameworks and mechanisms, rather than broad commitments to the SDGs without specific policy paths. Member States also referred in their responses to a number of mechanisms for engagement and intersectoral collaboration. I ntegration of the 2030 Agenda into relevant planning frameworks has been facilitated through the creation or adaptation of institutional arrangements , led mostly by high-levels of government , in charge of promoting horizontal coherence across ministries . All Member States referred to having an interministerial arrangement in charge of implementation of the 2030 Agenda , where, in general, either a high or moderate level of involvement of the health and well-being sector was indicated. O ther mechanisms /platforms established that aim to promote cooperation between various groups with their o verall objective to achieve the SDGs included commissions or councils that include non-state actors. Some of these mechanisms or platforms were created with a specific role, such as the development of a VNR. Assess Most Member States responding to the survey had undertaken assessment s to understand the distance to achieving the health-related SDG targets, as well as the context, opportunities and challenges to achieving them. 86% of Member States refer to this assessment having been produced and presented as a voluntary national review (VNR) at the High Level Political Forum on Sustainable Development . VNRs provide an opportunity for Member States to present an assessment of the results , including successes, challenges, gaps in implementation, possible solutions and emerging issues. For health stakeholders, VNRs are an opportunity to promote leadership for health and well-being and to put health issues high on the development agenda. Member States that had presented a VNR at the time of the survey reported a high or moderate level of involvement of the health and well-being sector . A ssessment should include measuring current trends and gaps; understanding alignment of existing policies and measures with the SDGs; as well as identifying gaps and bottlenecks. A strong assessment provides a detailed and nuanced understanding of the context in which commitment takes place in a way that facilitates planning and that identifies windows of opportunity for action at all levels of governance. Member States referred to such thorough assessments, and discussed the challenges of adopting and adapting the SDGs into their contexts , requiring communication with partners to identify risks and barriers . Align Align refers to the harmonization of policies and processes within and between sectors and levels of governance. Alignment starts with the existence or creation of a joint vision for health and well-being that maximizes co-benefits across the SDGs, minimizes the sustainability trade - offs generated by activities within the health sector and harmonizes financial, legal and regulatory mechanisms. All Member States identified their commitment to the SDGs , most having embarked in the processes of se tting targets and indicators that are specific and adapted to their own context. Some Member States elaborated on their vision as going beyond the SDGs. The development of comprehensive plans , involving a comprehensive range of stakeholders and sectors and focusing on improving population health and its determinants, as well as the interaction between the health sector and the other sectors , can support shared values, foster synergy and promote transparency and accountability for developing health and well-being and moving towards sustainable development. 76% of Member States had such a n overarching or “ umbrella” NDP, with 90% of these referring to include health and well-being as a development priority. W hilst NDPs aligned with the SDGs, all were fit to the Member State’s own situation and priorities, particular over the long term . Other coun tries had NDPs in the process of being approved , or stated that rather than having one overarching NDP framework, the SDGs were embedded across government programmes . Within the health sector , 81% of Member States referred to implement an overarching health policy , either or both at the national level and subnational level ; while 18% of Member States referred to implement thematic or disease specific policies or strategies alone. Within the health sector, Member States generally referred to a h igh or moderate level of alignment between their Member State ’s health and well-being priorities and the SDGs . Most of the health priorities referred by Member States were related to aspects of promoting healthier populations and advancing UHC . There were some notable differences in the prio rities listed according to geographical grouping : in EU Member States , the most frequently listed priorities were related to healthier populations , while in CIS Member States , the most frequently listed priorities were related to advancing UHC . Strengthening resilience and capacities to protect people from health emergencies was reported only by four countries as a health priority. Despite these positive results , more efforts to advance governance and leadership for health are needed . H ealth and well-being as a development priority may benefit from being seen from a more holistic lens , that encompasses a life-course approach, considers the determinants of health and invests in health promotion, protection, preparedness, prevention and resilience. W hile more than 90% of countries reported health and well-being as a development priority, particularly in aspects covering noncommunicable diseases and the promotion of healthy lifestyles, c onsidering NDPs set the overall direction for all sectors of government, more focus could be placed on promoting and enabling healthy aging, education and life-long learning, promoting healthier settings and reducing environmental pollution and degradation. The new forms of leadership, governance arrangements, policy measures and actions Member States mentioned to have taken to advance implementation of the 2030 Agenda have the potential to become avenues to be leveraged by health stakeholders in support of achieving the health and well-being goals and ultimately the SDGs. Result s also confirm the challenge that progress is dependent upon the process of implementation and that more needs to be done to try to ensure intentions are turned into results . Although it is difficult to make judgements on implementation based on the survey data, we observed that while the fameworks for governmental intervention have an adequate coverage of issues pertaining to health and the SDGs , when it comes to prioritizing measures to address the listed priorities , the number of Member States indicating to implement evidence-informed priorities is more limited . Fewer Member States report ed to be implementing measures requiring collaboration and adaptability to promote investments for health and well-being , the pursuit of UHC, health literacy and overall better collaboration to address the determinants of health . Disparities were also observed between the referred health priorities in NHP and the measures /interventions reported to be included in NHP, particularly in areas of emergencies and migration. Other c hallenges for effective implementation of the 2030 Agenda include financial , cultural, logistical and political challenges for effective alignment and intersectoral collaboration . Some of these were directly referred by Member States , others are implied based on the overall assessment of the survey: Financial and political challenges reported in the form of budget constraints and funding conflicts and accessing information on the availability of international funds – though th e latter was not an issue in all Member States . L ow proportion of countries referring to hav e budgetary requirements for implementation of their health priorities outlined in their health planning frameworks . Low proportion of countries making use of p ublic financial management instruments that may support more effective implementation and increased accountability . F or example, improved planning, including budget estimation; i ncrease d coordination, partnership and innovation , across all sectors making better use of incentives ; improved coordination of the broader data ecosystem and making this information available and accessible to the public . T hese were measures not being carried out in most countries . To support overcoming some of these challenges, Member States highlighted the importance of advocating for the co-benefits of health and well-being to the achievement of other sustainable development priorities. Setting up coordination structures between different stakeholders for intersectoral cooperation is indeed a challenge, however, some countries referred to mechanisms that facilitated intersectoral collaboration: Merging of different functions regulated under one ministry, such as h ealth, l abour and s ocial p rotectio n; Using legal or other formal mechanisms, such as planning law s, conventions and protocols to facilitate and regulate participation, empowerment and collaboration ; The identification of common principles to allow different sectors and groups to work together such as “The principles of the European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development ” Action from the bottom-up, or what is referred to as Locali z ation , which was identified to f acilitate integrating health with other sectors and non-state actors . P romoting the use of incentives to promote investments by non-health sectors and private sector in actions for health and well-being . For these me chanisms to succeed in promoting investments for health and intersectoral collaboration , policy-makers need to be equipped with the skills and capacities to generate s ufficient common ground and to produc e mutually agreed, realistic, context specific and achievable targets . Accelerate Certain topics featured as c atalysts/accelerators for progress: Localization , was highlighted by some Member States , particularly those with decentralized governance arrangements. Localization was expressed as c entral government, regions and municipalities adopt ing context specific approaches for effective alignmen t and implementation. Localiz ation was identified to facilitate participation, empowerment, enforcement of laws and regulations and collaboration. Benefits of collaboration with l ocal level were also referred to, particularly : facilitate integrating health with other sectors and non-state actors, implementing measures for UHC , such as allowing for local specificities to be considered when planning health services , as well as on allowing successful monitoring of the SDGs. In terms of collaboration between the health sector and local level, h igh levels of collaboration were mostly reported by EU countries. Increasing capacities, setting the appropriate coordination arrangements (such as community or municipal health boards) were some of the solutions Member States mentioned to enhance localiz ation of the SDGs . Digital innovation an d e - health were particularly highlighted for achieving UHC , strengthening health literacy and reducing inequalities. Some Member States referred receipt of international development assistance to enhance digital and e - health infrastructure . Other Member States indicated they are increasing investment for research and building infrastructure for digital health service delivery and e - health. Digital innovation was also seen as a way of engaging other sectors and partners in the achievement of the SDGs. Incentives with th e purpose to strengthen innovation power in the community between important actors and support innovative start - up products and services that meet one of the 17 SDGs were also mentioned by some Member States . Digitalization also featured in the process of collecting and monitoring data . Account To effectively implement the 2030 Agenda, there is a need of well-designed accountability mechanisms and “a robust, voluntary, effective, participatory, transparent and integrated follow-up and review framework” . Effective review and follow-up are crucial activities in the policy cycle. It helps monitor and evaluate the extent to which – by predefined targets – policy objectives have been met. This includes understanding if gaps were correctly identified , if policy expectations have been fulfilled , what lessons have been learned ; but also to cover the extent to which such an intervention has helped to secure policy legitimacy; develop stakeholder support; exhibit clarity of purpose; demonstrate a comprehension of co mplexity; sustain political support; and contribute to the wider attainment of policy objectives . R eview and follow-up mechanisms build on and go beyond quantitative data collection to include qualitative and analytical assessment. To achieve this, Member States need to strengthen their analytical capacities and work collaboratively across governments and actors to c omplement official sources of data, fill gaps in data and/or supplement official reportin g. In this regard , Member States reported : having strengthened the role of national statistical bodies to monitor the SDGs and health targets ; working collaboratively for monitoring and evaluation across government and other groups ; having started collecting and ordering data to support SDG monitoring ; using t echnology to improve transparency, data collection and use ; and promoting participatory process to involve stakeholders in determining together the country’s baseline . H owever, fewer Member States have carried out activities related to increas ing coordination, partnership and innovation across the broader data ecosystem and making this information availabl e and accessible to the public, for example, through the creation of platforms, portals and/or scorecards to inform the public on SDG progress. Even where governance is concentrated rather than dispersed, implementation will still be highly dependent on local context. All Member States have a shared responsibility to achieve the SDGs, and not only governments, but a range of stakeholders have a meaningful role to implement the goals locally, nationally, and globally . Localization was identified within survey results to facilitate participation, empowerment , enforcement of laws and regulations and collaboration. For local authorities to be able to deliver on these commitments, a crucial task is to provide better implementation support at the local level, not only through raising awareness about legal obligations or the requirements of statutory g uidance, but also assessing existing capacity to deliver, knowing what is being done well, what needs improving and how best to build new capacity. Indeed, investment in i ncreasing capacities, setting the appropriate coordination arrangements (such as community or municipal health boards) are needed, and these have been solutions highlighted by some Member States participating in this survey. The data produced by this survey has provided a rich account of the ways that Member States apply their policy-making activities in relation to the Roadmap and the SDGs. This is done in a diverse manner, and it is an e n couraging sign that Member States are utili z ing the SDGs fo r local efficiency and effect. Limitations As outlined previously, there are a number of limitations within the analysis. However , the purpose of the survey was not to provide a representative picture but instead to enhance knowledge sharing by showcasing and exploring the variety of ways in which Member States are moving forward with the challenge s of achieving the SDGs. Conclusion This survey was initiated in response to a Member States request to the Regional Director in Resolution EUR/RC67/R3 to report on progress on the impl e mentation of health - related SDGs. 29 Member States participated to the survey, 55% of all WHO European Region Member States. 19 of responding countries were from the European Union, five from the Commonwealth of Independent States and Ukraine and five other Member States not assigned to any grouping. Results show : Member States have prioritized implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and their integration of the SDGs into relevant planning frameworks. I ntegration has been facilitated through the creation or adaptation of institutional arrangements led mostly by high-levels of government . A ll countries indicated either a high or moderate level of involvement of the health and wellbeing sector. Engaging with key stakeholders was recognized as important to effective leadership. Member states referred in their responses to a number of mechanisms for intersectoral collaboration. Besides the interministerial coordination arrangements for SDG achievement, other mechanisms included the development of mechanisms/ platforms to promote cooperation between various groups, such as commissions or councils that include non-state actors. Some of these mechanisms or platforms were created with a specific role, such as the development of a VNR. Most countries responding to these survey had embarked in assessment efforts to understand the country’s overall development process and identifying the development priorities and needs, processes, institutions, actors, resources and other factors that influence effective implementation of the SDGs. Through these processes, countries also identified the importance of setting targets and indicators that are specific and adapted to their own context. 76% of responding countries had an overarching national development planning framework (NDP) , with 90% including health and wellbeing as a development priority. While more than 90% of countries reported health and well-being as a development priority, particularly in aspects covering noncommunicable diseases and the promotion of healthy lifestyles, considering NDPs set the overall direction for all sectors of government, more focus could be placed on promoting and enabling healthy aging, education and life-long learning, promoting healthier settings and reducing environmental pollution and degradation. Member States generally referred to a high or moderate level of alignment between their country’s health and wellbeing priorities and the SDGs. Most of the health priorities referred by Member States were related to aspects of promoting healthier populations and advancing UHC. There were some notable differences in the priorities listed according to geographical grouping: in EU Member States, the most frequently listed priorities were related to healthier populations, while in CIS Member States, the most frequently listed priorities were related to advancing universal health coverage. Strengthening resilience and capacities to protect people from health emergencies was reported only by four countries as a health priority. Action from the bottom-up, or what is referred to in this report as ‘localization’ and digital innovation were featured as c atalysts/accelerators for progress: Localization was a theme highlighted by some Member States to facilitate participation, empowerment, enforcement of laws and regulations and collaboration. Increasing capacities, setting the appropriate coordination arrangements (such as community or municipal health boards) were some of the solutions Member Sta tes mentioned to enhance localiz ation of the SDGs . Digital innovation an d e - health were also hi ghlighted to accelerate UHC , a nd as a way of engaging other sectors and partners in the achievement of the SDGs. Member States indicated they are increasing investment for research and building infrastructure for digital health service delivery and e - health. The use of i ncentives to strengthen innovation power were also mentioned by some countries . Challenges and opportunities for effective implementation were identified in Member States responses. Most challenges can be categorized as financial, managerial, logistical, cultural and political challenges: Financial and political challenges were reported in the form of budget constraints and funding conflicts and accessing information on the availability of international funds – though the latter was not an issue in all Member States. Managerial challenges were observed in the l ow proportion of countries referring to have budgetary require ments for implementation of their health priorities outlined in their health planning frameworks . Cultural challenges were reported in the culture and identity of different sectors which prevent effective intersectoral collaboration; Other gaps for effective implementation identified were a low proportion of countries indicating to implement evidence-informed proposed interventions . Few countries report ed to be implementing measures requiring collaboration and adaptability to promote investments for health and wellbeing , the pursuit of UHC, health literacy and overall better collaboration to address the determinants of health . Though it was not clear from responses the underlying reasons behind this trend. To support overcoming some of these challenges , based on responses it is recommended : To s trengthen efforts and increase capacities to advocat e for the co - benefits of health and well-being to the achievement of other sustainable development priorities. To i ncrease capacities to improve processes for better effectiveness and accountability, such as improved planning processes, including budget estimation; i ncrease d coordination, partnership and innovation ; improved coordination within the broader data ecosystem and making this information available and accessible to the public . These were measures reported as not being carried out in most countries . To improve intersectoral cooperation, the following mechanisms were reported by Member States to have facilitated intersectoral collaboration in their contexts: Merging of different functions regulated under one ministry, such as health, labour and social protection; Using legal or other formal mechanisms, such as planning laws, conventions and protocols to facilitate and regulate participation, empowerment and collaboration ; The identification of common principles to allow different sectors and groups to work together such as “The principles of the European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development” ; Action from the bottom-up, or what is referred to as Localization, which was identified to facilitate integrating health with other sectors and non-state actors. To improve accountability, Member States reported: to have strengthened the role of national statistical bodies to monitor the SDGs and health targets; to increase efforts to work collaboratively across government and other groups; to have started collecting and ordering data to support SDG monitoring; to use technology to improve transparency, data collection and use; and to promote participatory process to involve stakeholders in determining together the country’s baseline. For follow-up on this survey findings, we recommend to dig more deeply regarding how some of the processes Member States have referred to work in practice, such as the delegation of authority, the enablers of intersectoral collaboration, and others. F urther information could be gathered through qualitative interviews with key actors, focus groups or ethnographic studies. This survey did not focus on international cooperation or collaboration, although of course this is vital to underpinning the SDGs and their implementation. Further research could examine how Member States work together to achieve health related and other SDGs. Having fulfilled this request, it is hoped that the findings from this survey will enable mutual learning for all Member States and other actors involved in working towards integration of the SDGs and their achievement more widely. This survey should also inform future monitoring processes and serve as a baseline for upcoming surveys as well as inform ing the work of the WHO, United Nations Agencies, and Global Action Plan partners. Annex 1: Country Snapshots [see attached Annex 1] Annex 2: Survey [see attached Annex 2] Annex 3 : Description of qualitative analysis methodology The free text data from the questions were uploaded to the qualitative software programme NVIVO ensuring the country and text were kept connected. The use of NVIVO enabled the management of large amounts of data of different sorts, free text answers, website text and policy documents for example and allowed for ease of coding the data to produce themes. Following initial coding the text was recoded using an interpretive frame based on the objectives for each block (included in the next Annex 2). Documents uploaded by Member States for that block were also added to NVIVO, read for relevance to the interpretive frame and coded where relevant. These codes were further analysed and collapsed into themes. An example is provided in the table A1 below to show this process leading to theme generation. Due to space limitations, all the codes cannot be included here but can be provided on request. Table SEQ Table \* ARABIC 3 . Example of code and theme generation Theme Examples of codes within this theme Explanation What is not Examples Action Concerted action Joint or collaborative action Solely commitment to action, some joint working should be present in the example Estonia: ‘Willingness for concerted action. Driven by the sense of danger on the one hand and a relatively high level of pretensions on the other hand, an expectation for concerted action to strengthen the society and state and thereby increase our sustainability has developed in the Estonian society.’ Stakeholder engagement Broad term for any actions or activities regarding outreach to or engagement with stakeholders from government, including civil society, NGOs Not collaboration, a separate theme which relates more to joint activities undertaken with stakeholders Ireland: ‘Core components of implementation of the SDGs- Deep and sustained engagement with stakeholders’ Sustaining momentum References to the continuation of existing activities now oriented to SDG related goals In d i c ation of actions Ireland: ‘the wider health and social care system to work together over the long-term , sustaining momentum, and with a clear focus on the desired outcomes of reform.’ The analysis followed an interpretive thematic analysis approach with key elements being: Initial immersion in the data to identify initial codes emerging in relation to the survey Application of the interpretive frame Themes were also shared with SDG programme team to help refine the codes in theme production and to reduce bias . The examples were selected using an interpretive frame (attached in Appendix 2), for examples that particularly encapsulated the themes of that block or were a strong outlier. The selection was carried out in discussion with the SDG programme . Some examples were augmented with online research of publicly available information to clarify or provide extra information. Annex 4 : Interpretive frame The following interpretive frame was applied in the coding and theme generation stages of the qualitative analysis for the 7 Blocks with qualitative data. Block Objective 1 To assess the national development strategy and the level of leadership and commitment expressed on the health and well-being ; secondarily assessing the level alignment and quality of those policies. To assess where the leadership for SDGs comes from, the institutional mechanisms and the role of health stakeholders To assess the national health strategy and its alignment to the SDGs and quality of those policies, as well as the level of commitment to the SDGs using budget as a proxy indicator for the commitment. 2 To assess to reduce health inequities by addressing all health determinants, taking life-course, gender-responsive and rights-based approaches to health, and action on universally progressive policies, legislation and empowerment 3 To assess health sector’s cooperation with other sectors to integrate action to achieve multip le SDGs, and to optimize the co- benefits for health of policies and measures taken in other sectors to address the determinants of health Use co benefits as a filter for example Table as an indirect indicator 4 No qualitative data 5 To assess actions and measures countries are taking to improves access health promotion, disease prevention, curative, rehabilitative and palliative services they need without experiencing financial hardship, and obstacles and barriers 6 No qualitative data 7 To increase institutional capacity, build and engage effective, accountable and transparent institutions, and strengthen collaboration with partners and stakeholders 8 To assess the development and implementation of intersectoral national and local strategies to strengthen health literacy and information technology for use by individuals and in education To assess international and regional research to support and promote the implementation of the health and well-being aspects of the SDGs. 9 To assess what countries are doing to strengthen national health information systems to inform and evaluate policies for health and well-being and support reporting on the SDGs to improve governance and comparability of information and the application of e-health standards across the European Region. 2699566 6813096 World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe UN City, Marmorvej 51, DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø , Denmark Tel.: +45 45 33 70 00 Fax: +45 45 33 70 01 Email: [email protected] Website: www.euro.who.int 0 0 World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe UN City, Marmorvej 51, DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø , Denmark Tel.: +45 45 33 70 00 Fax: +45 45 33 70 01 Email: [email protected] Website: www.euro.who.int -480967 -675640 The WHO Regional Office for Europe The World Health Organization (WHO) is a specialized agency of the United Nations created in 1948 with the primary responsibility for international health matters and public health. The WHO Regional Office for Europe is one of six regional offices throughout the world, each with its own programme geared to the particular health conditions of the countries it serves. Member States Albania Andorra Armenia Austria Azerbaijan Belarus Belgium Bosnia and Herzegovina Bulgaria Croatia Cyprus Czechia Denmark Estonia Finland France Georgia Germany Greece Hungary Iceland Ireland Israel Italy Kazakhstan Kyrgyzstan Latvia Lithuania Luxembourg Malta Monaco Montenegro Netherlands North Macedonia Norway Poland Portugal Republic of Moldova Romania Russian Federation San Marino Serbia Slovakia Slovenia Spain Sweden Switzerland Tajikistan Turkey Turkmenistan Ukraine United Kingdom Uzbekistan 0 0 The WHO Regional Office for Europe The World Health Organization (WHO) is a specialized agency of the United Nations created in 1948 with the primary responsibility for international health matters and public health. The WHO Regional Office for Europe is one of six regional offices throughout the world, each with its own programme geared to the particular health conditions of the countries it serves. Member States Albania Andorra Armenia Austria Azerbaijan Belarus Belgium Bosnia and Herzegovina Bulgaria Croatia Cyprus Czechia Denmark Estonia Finland France Georgia Germany Greece Hungary Iceland Ireland Israel Italy Kazakhstan Kyrgyzstan Latvia Lithuania Luxembourg Malta Monaco Montenegro Netherlands North Macedonia Norway Poland Portugal Republic of Moldova Romania Russian Federation San Marino Serbia Slovakia Slovenia Spain Sweden Switzerland Tajikistan Turkey Turkmenistan Ukraine United Kingdom Uzbekistan
Allikas: Sotsiaalministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel