dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Rahandusministeerium
Väljaminev kiriAvalik

Estonian positions regarding the revision of the legal framework for European statistics

Rahandusministeerium · 21. november 2022
Viit
11-3.1/9158-1
Registreeritud
21. november 2022
Dokumendi liik
Väljaminev kiri
Adressaat
European Commission, European Commission, European Commission
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post, post
Funktsioon
11 RAHVUSVAHELINE SUHTLEMINE JA KOOSTÖÖ
Sari
11-3.1 EL institutsioonide otsustusprotsessidega seotud dokumendid (eelnõud, töögruppide materjalid, õigustiku ülevõtmise tähtajad) (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
11-3.1/2022
Vastutaja
Kristiina Abel (Rahandusministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Euroopa Liidu ja rahvusvahelise koostöö osakond)

Failid

  • 📎11-3-9158-1 21.11.2022 Kiri.pdf311 KB

Sisu (failidest)

REPUBLIC OF ESTONIA MINISTRY OF FINANCE Paolo Gentiloni / European Commission 3 Our ref ,?I. i’f 2022 No Rue de la Loi / Wetstraat 200 / 1049 Brussels, Belgium cab-gentiloni-contactec .europa. eu Estonian positions regarding the revision of the legal framework for European statistics Dear Mr Gentiloni, We welcome the effort to revise the legal framework for European statistics and aligning it with the developments in the national, the European and global data ecosystems. To contribute to the discussion and to facilitate the preparation of the forthcoming proposal of the amended Regulation 1 would like to present the Estonian initial positions on the future of European statistics and on the role and tasks of the European Statistical System (ESS) in the European data ecosystem. The positions have been approved by the Government of Estonia. According to the objective of the digitally ambitious European statistical programme the ESS should be able to produce and disseminate high quality statistics on Europe in a timely, impartial and cost-efficient manner, through enhanced partnerships within the system and with all relevant external parties, using multiple data sources, advanced data analytics methods, smart systems and digital technologies. The demand for timely and relevant statistics has become even more clear during the crises we have faced and are facing. There is an acknowledgement that the European statistics need to become more agile and innovative, going beyond established methods and data sources and make use of new types of data, data sources and tools. As we have witnessed during the COVID19, war against Ukraine and the global economic crises, acquiring data for timely statistics that would support necessary decision-making and give a glimpse of the changes in the society and economy has been difficult and is not a sustainable way to deliver the necessary insights and evidence. The legal framework of the EU should support catering for the data needs of the policy makers and the civil society, not hinder or delay the dealing with the challenges. Eurostat’s Trusted Smart Statistics initiative and the general effort to use privately held data should be enforced by corresponding legislation. The issues raised need to be solved now, not postponed into the future. For instance, the proposal of the Data Act together with the ongoing negotiations have produced a draft of the act that would create a legal distinction between non-exceptional (official) and exceptional statistics. In principle, we stress the idea that the production of the statistics for exceptional circumstances should be easier, more flexible and faster compared to the production of official statistics. Today, the legal framework is moving in the opposite direction. The production of exceptional statistics will become more complex than official statistics (e.g. justification to the data holders, time and scope limitations, establishment of fees for data, ambiguity of the legal framework for statistics etc). Suur-Ameerika 1/10122 Tallinn! Estonia / +372 611 3558 / [email protected] www.rahandusministeerium .ee / Reg. code: 70000272 Based on the current Data Act, collecting statistics in case of an exceptional need will become nationally more difficult than producing official statistics. We also believe that the implementation of the current Data Act draft might create a possibility for a dangerous precedent, where, for example, the duty of compensation can extend to the regular official statistics. To reduce the legal ambiguity, we propose not to regulate the domain of statistics (official or any other kind produced by the European Statistical System) in the Data Act and leave it solely to the Regulation for European Statistics and to the national legislation. This kind of legal clarity and facilitating best statistics need to be the driving forces in shaping the EU legal framework for statistics. If we do not address the need for better legislation now, we risk putting counterproductive constraints on delivering the necessary statistics that is demanded from us. The Estonian positions approved by the Government of Estonia are as follows. 1. We support making European statistics fit for future through the introduction of new data sources, and we are ready to consider increasing the flexibility of the European statistical system in describing societal changes. It is necessary to consider the limitations, opportunities and readiness of the entire data ecosystem when the planning and producing statistics. Certainly, added flexibility in the official statistics enables the use of timely and higher quality data in policy making. From the perspective of both public and private sectors, there is a particularly great need for up-to-date statistics during crises and emergencies. Currently, European statistics are not always able to respond to the needs of the stakeholder with sufficient speed. Moreover, the access of European statistical institutions to privately held data is not yet sufficiently and clearly legally regulated. Also, the technological capacity to receive and process big data has not yet been universally achieved and the relevant funding has not been taken into account. These aspects are prerequisites for flexibility and use of new data sources. We also consider it important to broaden the national statistical institutes’ opportunities for sharing and reusing the collected data in accordance with the basic principles of statistical confidentiality. In today’s data economy, in addition to the statistical system, other stakeholders in the public and private sector and academia must be more involved in the production of statistics that meets the future needs. Also, the public and private stakeholders should be ready to make high-quality data available in new ways. This adds more complexity to the statistics production than the current regulation on European statistics requires. 2. The right to use privately held data in the production of official statistics and to share it in the public interest is essential, doing so transparently and with little burden for data providers. So, it is necessary to regulate the rights and obligations of statistical authorities in the regulation for the European Statistics. The right to use privately held data in the compilation of statistics is essential from the point of view of both the public and the private sector. At the same time, it is also necessary to continue to ensure the protection and confidentiality of all data at the disposal of statistical authorities and to respect and protect the reputation and business interests of data holders. We should continue the reduction of the data submission burden, which is why we must collect the very minimum data necessary. In the negotiation process of the proposal for the Data Act, Estonia has supported the preservation of special regulations for scientific and statistical institutions for the use of data for statistical purposes. Estonia strongly supports the idea that the rights and obligations arising from the special role of statistical offices, including the use of private sector data, should be stipulated by the Regulation of the European Statistics. 7 3. The role and tasks of statistical institutions in the development of the data ecosystem should be in line with and derive from the national data governance structure. The review of this role should not hinder the institutions’ self-determination and opportunities to participate in the national data governance within the limits of their competence. Although we agree to the importance of timely availability of administrative data for official statistics, it possibly calls for legal basis to pose additional obligations on the administrative data holders. Also, sufficient funding is necessary if the current position of the NSIs will be revised. The data governance is organised in various models in the Member States and in some cases the Member State’s main statistical institution is not at the centre of national data governance or in a leading role. We see that the current EU regulation already allows statistical authorities to participate in data govemance to the extent that is necessary for the data govemance system. In our opinion, it might not be justified to place the statistical institutions of the EU in the centre of the data ecosystem and to impose binding cross-cutting obligations on them on the basis of the future regulation on European statistics, as they may be within the competence of other entities in the Member States. Therefore, the entities in the data ecosystem should contribute to the development of the system based on their competencies and national legislation. If different or additional tasks for the ESS will be agreed upon at the EU level, funding for them must also be guaranteed at the EU and national level. 4. When introducing new data needs and new data sources, it is necessary to take into account the increase in the cost and burden of statistics in the Member States. We consider it necessary to monitor the growth of costs and burden and to take measures to limit excessive growth. The introduction of new data sources and the timelier production of statistics would require knowledge in the use of big data and the methodological capacity of related data processing, as well as the introduction of new technological solutions that require and support capable and better-paid employees. The increase in administrative burden and costs should be monitored using all available means (setting limits on the necessary and/or added number of indicators, the voluntary submission of nationally irrelevant indicators etc.). Therefore, costs may also incur in other government sector entities, for instance, at registrars to organise data and develop of information systems. The enforcement of new requirements or principles, sustainable funding for production of statistics, training of experts should be ensured in all Member States to ensure the quality of data and the comparability of indicators at the level of the European Union. It is also necessary for Eurostat financially and methodically to support the development needs resuLting from updating the ESS. 5. To increase the timeliness of statistics and increase the frequency of dissemination, Estonia considers it important to further automate, standardise and adhere to the once only-principle in the B2G data submission. In the national strategy for research and development, innovation and entrepreneurship, one of Estonia’s goals is to achieve a real-time economy by exchanging data between the government and businesses automatically and securely, digitally, in a standardised and machine-readable format. Both the business associations and the govemment sector entities in the data ecosystem consider it important to submit data only once and to make maximum use of the data already made available. For this purpose, the reuse of data and cooperation between different state institutions must be increased and the prerequisites for the automatic B2G data exchange must be created. The private sector also expects that the collected data to be used extensively and efficiently. Estonia intends to be the advocate for these principles at the EU level. More extensive use of data is important, but to achieve it effectively, we should find mechanisms that motivate market participants, and not overregulate. In addition to treating data as a public good, it is important to create measures at the EU leve! that provide support and incentives for companies to share data. 6. Estonia strives to be able to exchange data between statistical authorities in the European Statistical System, provided that pan-European methodologies and secure technologicai solutions have been created for this purpose. There are severa! official statistics areas in which data exchange between statistical authorities wou!d provide more accurate resu!ts, for instance, in foreign trade statistics, business, environmenta!, tourism and population statistics. The phenomena and societa! changes at the nationa! leve! and in neighbouring Member States will also benefit from more accurate and similarly compiled regional statistics. A way to harmonise methodologies and technology is to improve the production of statistics by joint projects. For example, Statistics Estonia is currently updating nationa! accounting systems in cooperation with Statistics Finland funded by the EU structural funds. In addition to cost efficiency, this kind of cooperation enables to onboard additional methodological and technical know-how and to create means for future data exchange suitable for several Member States. There are still many challenges in data exchange between Member States today. For example, there are country differences in statistical and data collection methods (administrative data, personal and enterprise surveys, big data), in the ability and legal regulation to exchange micro-data across borders, as well as in the resources for the production of statistics. Thus, the European Commission (primarily Eurostat) has a key role in the ESS in the coordination, methodological harmonisation and financing of the data exchange of statistical institutions, as the statistics presented by Eurostat must be coherent, comparable and should reflect the situation in the EU as precisely and objectively as possible. Estonia supports moving forward in data exchange between countries, provided that sufficient resources are allocated for this. 1 hope you find Estonian input beneficial when preparing the proposal to amend the Regulation of European Statistics. We remain at your disposal for further discussions and clarification. Yours sincerely, Annely Akkerm ann Minister of Finance Copy to: Ms Mariana Kotzeva, Director General of Eurostat; Dr Emanuele Baldacci, Director of Methodology, IT and Corporate Statistical Services of Eurostat. Kristiina Abel +372 611 3406 [email protected] 4
Allikas: Rahandusministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel