SURVEY
PART A. USE OF IN-HOUSE BIDDING IN PUBLIC COMPETITIVE TENDERS
Question 1: Is there any legislation or regulation in your country that forbids the use of in-
house bidding1 in public competitive tenders?
a. Yes ☐
b. No ☐
c. Don’t know ☐
d. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
If you answered Yes in Question 1, please answer Questions 2 and 3, otherwise please answer
Questions 4 to 8.
Question 2: Please identify the legislation or regulation in place that forbids the use of in-
house bidding in public competitive tenders.
Click here to insert text.
Question 3: What is the motivation for not allowing the use of in-house bidding in public
competitive tenders? Tick all that apply.
a. To ensure transparency ☐
b. To ensure no favoritism ☐
c. The legislation/regulation does not provide any ☐
reasons or motivation
d. Don’t know ☐
e. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
Question 4: Within the last 5 years, in what sectors or services have your country used in-
house bidding? Tick all that apply.
a. Cleaning ☐
b. Communication ☐
c. Computing ☐
d. Construction ☐
e. Defense ☐
f. Financial services ☐
g. Food ☐
h. Healthcare ☐
i. Legal ☐
j. Management consultancy ☐
k. Transport ☐
l. Don’t know ☐
m. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
1 In-house bidding in a public tender occurs when the public procurer allows for in-house providers to actively
submit bids and compete with external or outside firms for the procurement of a public contract.
1
Question 5: What are the main reasons for allowing the use of in-house bidding in public
competitive tenders, in your country? Tick all that apply.
a. To lower cost ☐
b. To ensure costs are capped ☐
c. To improve transparency ☐
d. To ensure equal treatment among providers ☐
e. Don’t know ☐
f. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
Question 6: Within the last 5 years, how often did an in-house bidder participate in public
competitive tenders, in your country?
a. Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐
b. Very often ☐
c. Sometimes ☐
d. Rarely ☐
e. Never ☐
f. Don’t know ☐
g. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
Question 7: Within the last 5 years and from those tenders in which an in-house bidder
participated in a public competitive tender, how often did an in-house bid win the tender?
a. Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐
b. Very often ☐
c. Sometimes ☐
d. Rarely ☐
e. Never ☐
f. Don’t know ☐
g. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
Question 8: Within the last 5 years, how often have public procurers in your country used
the first-price auction when running a tender, where lowest cost bidder wins the tender and
receives (or pays) the amount of his/her bid?
a. Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐
b. Very often ☐
c. Sometimes ☐
d. Rarely ☐
e. Never ☐
f. Don’t know ☐
g. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
2
PART B. USE OF REQUESTS FOR INFORMATION IN PUBLIC COMPETITIVE TENDERS
To all
Question 9: How common is it for public procurers in your country to request detailed or
additional information from the bidders before (or at) the submission of proposals in a public
competitive tender (e.g., information on the capacity to finance a project)?
a. Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐
b. Very often ☐
c. Sometimes ☐
d. Rarely ☐
e. Never ☐
f. Don’t know ☐
g. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
Question 10: In case you have answered positively to Question 9, could you please provide
some examples of the type of information that public procurers request the bidders to be
delivered before (or at) the submission of proposals?
Click here to insert text.
Question 11: Have you ever received complaints made by participants about the amount of
information requested by public procurers in a public competitive tender?
a. Yes ☐
b. No ☐
c. Don’t know ☐
d. Other, specify: Click here to insert text.
Question 12: In case you have answered Yes to Question 11, could you please provide some
examples of the type of complaints you have received?
Click here to insert text.
3
Saatja: Thomas Greve <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 26.11.2022 18:43
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: Request for information on public procurement (for research
purposes only)
Dear Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Estonia,
I am an Assistant Professor at the Department of Economics, at Instituto
Universitário de Lisboa (), Lisbon, Portugal. Currently, I am conducting
research in public procurement, and I would very much appreciate hearing
the views of public entities which work in public procurement.
In that context, I would like to invite you to answer a questionnaire in
the annex that will be used for research purposes only. I have also
enclosed a letter that provides a more in-depth explanation of my
research. For any clarification, please contact me directly by email.
Thank you in advance for your contribution.
Kind regards,
Thomas Greve
Assistant Professor of Economics, Instituto Universitário de Lisboa
(ISCTE)
ISCTE webpage:
Personal webpage:
ORCID webpage:
26 November 2022
Dear Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Estonia,
I am an Assistant Professor at the Department of Economics, at Instituto Universitário de
Lisboa (ISCTE), Lisbon, Portugal.
My research interests lie in the area of game theory, with particular emphasis on mechanism
design and auction theory.
Currently, I am conducting two different work strands, both related to public competitive
tenders. First, I am studying the use of in-house bidding, which according to OECD (1998),
“occurs when the staff presently performing an activity bids against an outside contractor for
an activity being considered for contracting out”.1 Second, I am studying the impact of large
requests for information – to be provided before the bidder is qualified to participate in a
tender, or when submitting its bidding proposal – on the bidding strategies of the bidders.
As part of this research, I would particularly like to hear the views from public entities which
work in public procurement, as to better understand how common in-house bidding is and
how common requests to information are, within public competitive tenders. In that context,
I would like to invite you to answer the questionnaire in the annex.
Your participation will help me better understand the use of in-house bidding and requests
for information across many countries.
In response to this questionnaire, I would like to request you to identify any information that
you may deem confidential. In such case, I will not use the confidential part of your
contribution in my research.
If possible, I would kindly ask you to respond within 15 (fifteen) working days after the receipt
of this communication, to the e-mail address:
[email protected]. Please let me know
if you may need additional time to reply.
For any clarification regarding this questionnaire, you can contact me directly by the above
email.
I would like to thank you in advance for your important contribution.
Kind regards,
Thomas Greve
(Assistant Professor of Economics, Instituto Universitário de Lisboa)
ISCTE webpage: https://ciencia.iscte-iul.pt/authors/thomas-greve/cv
Personal webpage: https://sites.google.com/site/thomasmgreve/home
ORCID webpage: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8594-2782
1 OECD, 1998. Contracting Out Government Services: Best Practice Guidelines and Case Studies No. 20. OECD
Publishing.
1
SURVEY PART A. USE OF IN-HOUSE BIDDING IN PUBLIC COMPETITIVE TENDERS Question 1 : Is there any legislation or regulation in your country that forbids the use of in-house bidding in public competitive tenders? Yes ☐ No ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. If you answered Yes in Question 1, please answer Questions 2 and 3, otherwise please answer Questions 4 to 8. Question 2 : P lease identify the legislation or regulation in place that forbids the use of in-house bidding in public competitive tenders. Click here to insert text. Question 3 : What is the motivation for not allowing the use of in-house bidding in public competitive tenders? Tick all that apply. To ensure transparency ☐ To ensure no favoritism ☐ The legislation/regulation does not provide any reasons or motivation ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. Question 4 : Within the last 5 years, in what sectors or services have your country used in-house bidding? Tick all that apply. Cleaning ☐ Communication ☐ Computing ☐ Construction ☐ Defense ☐ Financial services ☐ Food ☐ Healthcare ☐ Legal ☐ Management consultancy ☐ Transport ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. Question 5 : What are the main reasons for allowing the use of in-house bidding in public competitive tenders, in your country? Tick all that apply. To lower cost ☐ To ensure costs are capped ☐ To improve transparency ☐ To ensure equal treatment among providers ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. Question 6 : Within the last 5 years, how often did an in-house bidder participate in public competitive tenders, in your country? Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐ Very often ☐ Sometimes ☐ Rarely ☐ Never ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. Question 7 : Within the last 5 years and from those tenders in which an in-house bidder participated in a public competitive tender, how often did an in-house bid win the tender? Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐ Very often ☐ Sometimes ☐ Rarely ☐ Never ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. Question 8 : Within the last 5 years, how often have public procurers in your country used the first-price auction when running a tender, where lowest cost bidder wins the tender and receives (or pays) the amount of his/her bid? Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐ Very often ☐ Sometimes ☐ Rarely ☐ Never ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. PART B. USE OF REQUESTS FOR INFORMATION IN PUBLIC COMPETITIVE TENDERS To all Question 9 : How common is it for public procurers in your country to request detailed or additional information from the bidders before (or at ) the submission of proposals in a public competitive tender (e.g., information on the capacity to finance a project)? Always (of all public competitive tenders) ☐ Very often ☐ Sometimes ☐ Rarely ☐ Never ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. Question 10 : In case you have answered positively to Q uestion 9, c ould you please provide some examples of the type of information that public procurers request the bidders to be delivered before (or at ) the submission of proposals? Click here to insert text. Question 11 : Have you ever received complaints made by participants about the amount of information requested by public procurers in a public competitive tender? Yes ☐ No ☐ Don’t know ☐ Other, specify: Click here to insert text. Question 12 : In case you have answered Yes to Question 11, c ould you please provide some examples of the type of complaints you have received? Click here to insert text.