Secretariat Paris MOU on PSC
2500 BD The Hague
PO Box16191 Our Ref: 03.06.2021 No 24.1-6/20-
0062/3550-1
The Netherlands
To Whom it May Concern
I am writing from Estonia concerning the flag performance table and the fact that due to the
reduced number of inspections (COVID-19 impact) carried out for Estonian flagged vessels then
with one detention from 2019 the flag has fallen to grey list taking effect on 01.07.2021.
We are on understanding that considering COVID-19 impacts and general approach that missed
PSC inspections are justified with the pandemic (which is without a doubt right approach) then
consequences of pandemic should be also analysed when looking at performance of flag state and
old agreements should be overlooked. We are not suggesting that detentions could or even should
be only justified with COVID-19 (although many of them are in straight correlation with the
pandemic) but flag performance should not be measured without an analyse through the numbers
which we have agreed that could be less than in normal conditions.
It is known that due to the restrictions that were implemented during pandemic period and specially
when epidemiologic situation was at its peaks the countries were locked down which also resulted
with passenger vessels operations were stopped. Estonia had the highest rate of infection for
several months in Europe and since the tourism was stopped and labour migration restricted to
minimum the amount of passengers travelling between Estonia (most of passenger vessel fleet
departs from flag State) and foreign country dropped to minimum and vessel operators did not find
it sustainable to continue the operations and majority of the passenger vessels remained in port
and some are until to this day still remaining in idle condition. This overall resulted in less vessels
visiting foreign ports and less port State controls were carried out. For example during the current
period (affected by COVID 19 crisis) total 71 inspections were carried out and before that total 86
were carried out. That means that only 15 inspections were carried out less than during normal
period compared that how many vessels were standing idle in different ports.
Due to the fact that the register is small also COVID impact was felt in cargo vessels operations
resulting in laid up vessels.
We are aware that the PMoU has agreed in principle to a new formula how to calculate the flag
performance list but as we know it can only be introduced when Directive 2009/16/EC will be
amended.
Taking into account of the COVID impact to the flag performance (specially for the small flags)
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
and proposed amendment to the calculation method we kindly ask Paris MoU to take previously
mentioned explanations into account when flag performance is measured and changing the flag
status from white to grey.
With best regards,
Kaupo Läänerand
Deputy Secretary General for Maritime
Jaak Viilipus
+372 625 6491
[email protected]
2 (2)