REPUBLIC OF ESTONIA
MINISTRY OF SOGIAL AFFAIRS
Helena Dalli
European Commission
Helena.DalIi©ec.europa.eu Our ref. 25.06.2020 No 1.4-2/2046-1
DG Justice and Consumers
Brussels 1049 Belgium
Nicolas Schmit
European Commission
[email protected]
DO Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion
Brussels 1049 Belgium
Estonia’s position on the Commission’s targeted pay transparency consultation
Dear Commissioner Dalli,
Dear Commissioner Schmit.
It is my great pleasure to inform you that the Estonian Government has approved our position
on the targeted consultation regarding the forthcoming Con,missioris pay transparency
initiative aimed at enforcing the principle of equal pay for same work or work of equal value
between men and women in the EU. Please accept my sincerest apologies that we were
unable to send you our feedback on time. due to thorough discussions held by the
Government. Let me assure you that ensuring the principle ot equal pay for same work or work
of equal value is and wiII remain important for Estonia.
Concerning the recent consultation. 1 hope you can still take the position of the Estonian
Government into consideration when designing the upcoming pay transparency measures in
the EU:
1. Estonia oonsiders it important to implement the principle of equal pay for same work or
work of equal value between women and nien in the EU member states and to coordinate
EUs activities and initiatives regarding the impiementation ofthis principle.
2. In the process of designing the pay transparency measures the possibilities and capability
of different sized organisations need to be taken into account We also need to assess the
balance between burden and costs and expected benefits for the organizations. We
consider it important that the future requirements would not entail disproportionate burden
for micro and small organisations. In addition, it is also necessary to continue to promote
and support carrying out voluntary measures by employers. AlI the measures for increasing
pay transparency in the EU need to be evidence-based and follow the principle of
proportionality, over-regulation should be avoided.
3. Regarding the implementation and enforcement of future pay transparency measures, we
consider it important to leave the discretion to decide the specific organisation of the
implementation of measures and super-vision to the member states. In Estonia, the possible
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA / 372 626 9301 /
[email protected] / www.sm.ee / Reg. no
70001952
supervisory organisations are the Gender Equaiity and Equai Treatment Cornmissioner
and the Labour Inspectorate. For ensuring enhanced pay transparency, the tasks of these
instituUons shouid be specified, when appropriate.
4. To guarantee the equal quaHty of impiementation ot EU rneasures and to alleviate the
accompanying administrative burden, we consider it relevant to make available digital tools
10 support empioyers. The Comrnission could support meniber states in developing such
recommended digital tools, promote the exchange of good practices between member
states. and enable the use of reievant EU financial resouroes.
At the moment, the Government did not make a decision on preferred specific EU level
measures for ensuring pay transparency. However, in my personal opinion there are many
measures that can be effective. For example, in order for the empioyers to be aware of whether
the principie of equai pay is properly foilowed in their organisation, they couid regularly analyse
information about pay leveis and gender pay gaps per empioyees’ category. Making use of
gender-neutral job evaluation and classification systems is a precondition for such analysis. in
addition, 10 raise awareness of employees and create relevant discussions on different leveis
in organisations but also in the framework of collective bargaining, employers should then
make the results of these analysis, together with proposais for decreasing gaps, public
internally in the organisation.
When considering the suitable pay transparency measures, also differences in sizes of
companies should be taken into account in order to prevent excessive administrative burden
on smafler organisations. At the same time, 1 find that measure(s) that do not add to an
administrative burden, e.g. inciuding either the salary or at ieast information about the range
of expected salary for the position into the vacancy note ota pubhcly advertised job vacancy.
could be toreseen for ali sizes of organisations.
1 remain at your disposal in case you have any additionai questions.
Yours sincerely,
Tanel KHk
Minister of Sociai Affairs of Estonia
Copy 10:
NeW.Kerr©eceuropa.eu
Antoine.Kaseiec.europa.eu
Agni Aav +372 6269 281
Agni.Aavsm.ee
2 (2)