dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Pöördumise edastamine

Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 18. juuni 2021
Viit
1.1-16/21-0015/3865-1
Registreeritud
18. juuni 2021
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
Riigikantselei
Saabumis/saatmisviis
DVK
Funktsioon
1.1/S Ministeeriumi juhtimine
Sari
1.1-16 Valitsusasutuste kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
1.1-16/21-0015
Vastutaja
Ando Leppiman (Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, Kantsleri valdkond)

Failid

  • 📎RK_21-01432-2.asice215 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Rahandusministeerium Meie: 17.06.2021 nr 7-5.8/21-01432-2 Pöördumise edastamine Edastan peaministrile saabunud MTÜ Jaagupi Sadam ja MTÜ Puhas Silmapiir esindajate pöördumise. Lugupidamisega (allkirjastatud digitaalselt) Aivar Rahno Istungiosakonna juhataja Teadmiseks: Keskkonnaministeerium Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium Stenbocki maja / Rahukohtu 3 / 15161 Tallinn / Estonia / registrikood 700004809 +372 693 5555 / [email protected] / www.riigikantselei.ee Lp. Kaja Kallas 14.06.2021 Peaminister Stenbocki maja [email protected] Regarding: EU summons KMH law. Your talk with Häädemeeste June 15 th 2021. Honorable Prime Minister, The EU summoned Estonia to repair the KMH law on forests (Aripaev). I write you in English be- cause our complaints at an EU level got heard. Our Estonian KMH or parish or governmental ques- tions were never answered (seriously). This chaos resulted in the letter of several parishes to you on 27.04.2021. (the letter: https://www.jaagupi.eu/Peaminister.pdf ) In this letter we give you the facts that proof that it is the parish leadership that abuses the holes in the current laws itself in the first place. Because of the frustrated local democracy based on KMH procedural shortages we wrote numer- ous letters to EU institutes. The recent EU forest top in Bratislava for example. The EU ministers also agreed to stop illegal forest felling. We were actively fighting to get this done by using do- mains like estonianamazon.eu to put our story on top of Google. We got heard. Now laws must be made first and, in the meantime, EU funding will not take place when EU values are not respected. Both RB and windmill projects we can stop this way. The ecosystems are connected by water lev- els (EU site wetlands.org) and fish egg rivers. The current KMH laws avoid research of cumulative effects. The economic viability and the legal foundation of the projects are missing. Estonia does not even offer open science according to EU guidelines, the basis of all research for any KMH. (EU) courts are wide open for us. We are sad to have to do so. We were simply not heard in democratic planning and there was no other way to be heard. The BR initiative we do offer to repair at the end of this letter bringing an original positive idea. We write you above all to find common ground and bring democracy and a dialog back to Estonia. -The 5 EU priorities not met by Estonia- The Green Deal is 1 of the 6 EU priorities. The green deal is 1 of the 6 EU priorities. https://ec.eu- ropa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024_et The EU concerns are most of all about EU (local) de- mocracy. Uus hoog Euroopa demokraatiale. We will prove that the current Häädemeste leadership abuses planning procedures on the Rail Bal- tic, sand mining, and the windmill KMH's. Linking to the EU concerns about EU (local) democ- racy. EU has its share in the guilt. The valuations take place because of EU subsidized projects like Windmills and RB. EU asks that Estonian must respect nature, you certainly should respect your people. -The EU core principle of free-market demand and supply violated- Above all, we like to point out that the EU stands for demand market-driven economic principles, just like art 2 of the Estonian constitution. It's the exact opposite of the old-style Russian plan econ- omy, where something is made according to state planning, without any demand. Now Estonia produces more energy than it needs. That means that Estonian Energy sells all the wind parks it creates and exports all energy it makes. That’s inefficient and not green. Long and ex- pensive (sea)cables are needed to transport wind electricity to Riga. Of course, Estonian does not want to use Latvian cables, because the cable owner is always the profit maker. The use of electric- ity is “created”, like oxygen plants and electrical railroad state plan. There is no demand for 2 track cargo train to Tallinn, having a capacity of a cargo train every 6 minutes to the capital. Let alone a passenger train, the Orient Express went bankrupt. People fly these days. In the EU a combination of cargo and passengers is not allowed on the same track for safety. The push for usage also creates a false economic picture for wind energy. The wind in Germany is many times stronger than Estonian. Expensive repairs in the winter when no ships can come (heli- copters) is not viable. It’s EU colonialism to copy the Economic wind model from windy western Europe and produce and maintain windmills with long service and supply lines. Long expensive cables (25mio/km) do not pay off and the cabling company does not receive compensation. They help us to frustrate the windmill parks. Summarizing this point. In Europe, it’s not the task of pushing a governmentally supported supply. The free west is built on a free-market demand above all. There is no need for national infrastruc- ture cabling in this parish. - Both the EU and Estonia are long aware of the shortages in planning - I like also to quote the Baltic States Sea Agreement. I Quote Art. 1. "RECALLING with serious concern the situation of the Baltic Sea marine environment" and Art. 2 "EXPRESS concern .." and Art. 3. "RESTATING our commitment to full implementation of the relevant European legislation" The EU is repeating these articles as apparently being violated. Also On the Eighth forest min- isterial Conference in Bratislava April 2021 there was agreed to stop illegal felling. RMK was con- victed by the court for illegal felling in our parish. - The problem with Häädemeeste, the people you meet June 15 th - According Karel Tölp Laws of Nature protection are a threat. You can find this in the SWOT anal- yses of the “strategic planning of the parish 2021”. Please review Page 34. I quote ”OHUD riigi- poolsete uute piirangute kehtestamine, eriti looduskaitses.“ The government law can never be a threat! Please call him to the order. You promised the EU the KMH repair Karel does not want. The parish signed the strategic planning before discussing it with the people. That’s against the law. The SWOT analyses calling the people a threat to the leadership. I quote “OHUD ühe osa elanike võõrandumine valla juhtimisest” must be “OHUD vallajuhtide võõrandumine elanikest”. Elame demokaatlikus riigis, kus kodanikel on alati õigus. Does Karel want the people to leave next elec- tions? In a democracy, the people are never a problem. Karel showed disrespect for the people. First, the document was signed before asking the people in an open dialog. That's against the law. The planning must be redone. Secondly, Karel obstructed democracy. Karel did obstruct the most important document of the parish, the document writes. Can anyone explain why old financial figures must be read aloud? And what do most boring old building pictures have to do with a strategic vision of any parish? On the question of what the rele- vance was, he told me to shut up and listen. Karel is obvious joking democracy. . Karel knows what he does and mentions his problem. SWOT at 5.1 tells: sisekommunikatsioon- isüsteemi puudumine. After Karel his delay during the presentation we quickly discussed the basic economic logic of the strategic planning of the parish. We simply explained that all the economic numbers are black and should be red because the data is red(minus). Quoting the IMF warnings to Estonia, The EU re- ported negative Q1 data for the GDP of Estonia. The German central bank warning. All warnings were of the last days. Simply explained for local people: we did not see a tourist; we did not have income. We cannot live from windmills and rails. Changing data from black to red changes the whole SWOT analysis resulting in a new mission statement that sounds like "no industry zone". Karel invited Estonian Energy to the Parish. EE violated KMH procedures. Karel was proactive in frustrating (KMH) procedures send back to you. They invited Kaur Lass. EE always flies in him for difficult KMH procedures. Kaur explains what’s all wrong with planning here. https://www.headandlead.com/Planeerimis-ja-juhtimisblogi It’s quite logic both the people and the government stop taking planning seriously. This exploit stops serious investments like the Jaagupi Sadam plan. It lets people vote with their feet by leaving the parish or voting against the central government that makes the parish to a planning playground of for industrials. Karel told in the newspaper and on several occasions, he loves the money from the industrials. Even today there was a closed meeting for “negotiating” compensation at the parish. If the price of the public good is not determined by a proper KMH valuation, it’s never the real price. Cumulative effects are not calculated either. EE took a scientist in service and made his work secret. Open science is the basis for any KMH and not available in Estonia TU tells. EE refuses even to speak/read English for sci- ence and her cross border planning KMH’s too. This English letter serves international purpose in- compliant letters at an EU level. EE is acting on invitation of the parish again. If you listen to the audio protocol of last EE KMH meeting individuals continuously offered “compensation”. We let you hear the threats the parish leadership delivers too, on the next page. Now we now know we can stop the nonsense at an EU level. By cutting EU financing. Awake the EU environmental watchdog. The doors of the (EU) courts are wide open now. RB and EE must be nuts to continue their unfair play. Our parish lives from tourism (see our current plaan, Karel ignored too) and agriculture. Above all we like to exploit the approx 10.000 km2 Livonian sea, a quarter of the Estonian surface. Look at our Sadam plaan. https://www.jaagupi.eu/JAAGUPISADAMAPLAAN.pdf The plan describes what we all can do of the sea is not sold exclusive to foreign (partly Russian) owned wind parks. We stress we are constructive people who do understand fisherman economics. On request of the parish, we first wrote a great plan how we can stand on our own legs and let the parish flourish. For many years Jaagupi Sadam has been blocked and fishermen have been frustrated. Look at the newspaper: https://dea.digar.ee/cgi-bin/dea?a=d&d=parnupostimees20141113.2.6.5 Most of the lo- cals left abroad logically. The planning chaos blocks all economic activities. Tourism and fishing investment are blocked as long as planning insecurity is there. The Häädemeeste vallavolikogu (VK) voted to act fast on the harbor in April 2021. Karel did not carry out the wish of the VK wish. Messing around week after week. Fishing season is lost and even funding is left unused by delays. Now ask the VK to take back control over this Jaagupi Sa- dam tender procedure to keep it fair. Karel is not acting alone. Häädemeeste vallavolikogu esimees Andrus Soopalu told Naar senior (a fifth-generation fisherman, 6 th is expected this week) to leave the parish if he did not like it. Naar is the initiative taker of the Jaagupi sadam plaan that is delayed, costing him this season (again). On the same place, Siim Suursild pushed people to hate other population groups. “ Kuulake palun Ka- bli seltsimajas (19.11.) asetleidnud koosoleku salvestust, kuidas abivallavanem Siim Suursild kir- jeldab Häädemeeste valla praegust olukorda ja planeerimist: kuulake palun alates min. 12:00 https://jaagupi.eu/SIIMSUURSILDHM.mp3 “ People are scared and do not speak out. We ask you and the VK to remove these men and enable the fishermen population to grow. - We like to reach out to you and embrace these solutions - We cannot help escalation. This is not about windmills in the first place. It’s about how we manage plan and discuss together. We do know you did embrace windmills more than once. It’s not about people that always agree of be part of the same political party. Far more interesting is how people overcome differences. Having eyes for each other wants & needs. As proof of our stance, we asked your party candidate Toomas Toodu. We asked him to sign your document. Toomas is against windmills in our Parish. He endorses our view and we endorse him. We do trust you to guard democratic checks and balances too. Local parties that rule our parish just miss basic democratic principles. We should manage our parish together and not sell it to the indus- trials. Selling is without having a proper KMH to check the real price or the negative side effects for the local people. We must keep Estonia together. We want to be constructive dialog, see our plan. Have a nice read and respect your difficult posi- tion. We embrace a dialog with Fermi for example. It's very difficult to explain that modern nuclear plants are different than Chernobyl. Fermi did try to explain their point of view at our Häädemeeste school. Discussing that the 2 richest men of the world (Bill Gates and Warren Buf- fett) build a new kind of nuclear reactor to save our climate with a new salt engine is nice. We do like Fermi their open front door approach that kids must understand first. Guess they will come to Tallinn schools too be Chernobyl because there is more demand for energy there than in Ikla. We do regret hurting the RB project. Its a collateral damage to stop the ridiculous planning. We of- fer you to embrace an alternative now, saving the EU funds RB for Estonia. Feel free to claim this vision as yours before the opposition does. The vision is called EST or BEST. The Electrical Super Train. The B stands for our Baltic friends who want the BEST. The Tartu RB track is the real and only alternative. This existing trick does not require complex KMH planning. The train to China could become the longest electrical train in the world. This vision comes with a geopolitical argument that EU needs a track around Belarus. Even Russia will like the alternative for its income. It’s the same economic logic as the EU used for having Nord Stream gas to deliver gas around unstable Ukraine. Maritime transport emits around 940 million tons of CO 2 annually and is responsible for about 2.5% of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (3 rd IMO GHG study). This makes a CO2-neutral train fitting the EU agenda and goals. It's a full fit great for the US Building Back Better (BBB) strategy as an alternative for the Chinese Belt and Road Initiative. Even relevant for the NATO top today. On top shipping knows a huge bureaucracy too, costing 50% of the shipping cost. 200 documents and a lot of time. Estonia can do digital clever digital clearance and truly shine here. We love to ex- plain our value network blockchain solution blueprint together with the support of Tartu (and also Tallinn) university members. The Suez Canal is the major income for Egypt. Panama the same. BEST will bring cargo clearance income to Estonia. Geopolitics and our unique location can make the Suez of the EU! Who does not want to claim the BEST? We reserved besttrain.eu Still redirected to nokillertrain.eu We take that away when our planning war is over. Please take care that our parish does not reach a tipping point by putting it under planning pressure. People vote using their feet, leaving the parish. Release us from the burden of the planning play- ground. All economic alternative investments are on a hold for a decade like the Jaagupi harbor. The sea was never fully utilized since Estonia her independence. We would love to have EU like democratic planning rules that support demand-driven free market forces. Yours sincerely, MTÜ Jaagupi Sadam Avo Naar Tave Naar Arnoud Willem Berghuis Madis Mardu Aivar Merila MTÜ Puhas Silmapiir Indrek Viiderfeld Eiko Roomet Piret Parve Reformierakond candidate 2021 Toomas Toodu From: info <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 14, 2021 10:52 PM To: Riigikantselei <[email protected]>; [email protected]; [email protected]; Jagupi Sadam <[email protected]>; Eiko Roomet <[email protected]>; Naari Kalatalu <[email protected]>; [email protected]; [email protected]; Piret Parve <[email protected]>; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected] Subject: EU & KMH law. Your talk with Häädemeeste Parish June 15th 2021 Lp. Kaja Kallas Peaminister Stenbocki maja [email protected] P��umine on manusega kaasas.
Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel