Rahandusministeerium Teie 12.05.2021 nr 12.1-3/3711-1
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 Meie 17.06.2021 nr 1.1-16/21-0021/3074-2
10122, Tallinn
Vastus pöördumisele asjas SA.57321
Austatud Merike Saks
Edastame ministeeriumi vastused Konkurentsi Peadirektoraadi küsimustele asjas SA.57321.
Palume Rahandusministeeriumil vastused peadirektoraadile edasi saata.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Timo Tatar
energeetika ja maavarade asekantsler
Lisad: Vastused küsimustele asjas SA.57321 (7 lk)
Lisaadressaadid: Elering AS
Rein Vaks
625 6347
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
Christof Lessernich Your Ref: 07.05.2021 No
Directorate B Energy, B3 COMP.B.3/MS/ajn*2021/049004
Directorate General for Competition
Place Madou, Madouplein 1 Our Ref: 17.06.2021 No 1.1-16/21-
1210 Saint-Josse-ten-Noode /Sint- 0021/3074-2
Joost-ten-Noode
Belgium
Reply to inqury in case SA.57321
Dear Mr. Lessernich,
The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications received the second complaint of Circle
K Eesti AS and the additional questions of Directorate General for Competition on the statistics
trading system for biofuels in Estonia (SA.57321). Herewith the Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications replies as follows.
As mentioned in our previous letter, the criteria of State aid1 are not met with the measure at hand.
Circle K Eesti AS (herein after the Complainant), however, is arguing that one of the criteria,
involvement of State resources, is present.
The Complaintis under the impression that the statistics trading system should be qualified as State
aid. To our understanding, the Complainant is arguing that since the statistics under discussion are
a tangible asset that are given to some market participants for free, the measure at hand must be
considered as State aid. This argument, however, is not true.
As we explained in our last letter on this matter, the statistics are not state owned. The word
“statistics” might be giving a wrong impression in this case. The state only provides a certificate
to prove that the owner of the certificate has released renewable fuel for consumption in the
transport sector. This certificate can be traded with all the fuel suppliers that are obliged to fulfill
the renewable energy obligation as defined in the Liquid Fuel Act § 21 section 12.
To obtain the certificate, the supplier must produce and release renewable fuel for consumption.
There is always a cost for such activities. Contrary to the arguments of the Complainant, the
certificates are not given free to the supplier. Each supplier must buy the fuel from the producer
and release the fuel for consumption. For example, the price of producing biomethane is ca 90
€/MWh, the price of renewable electricity with grid fee is ca 130 €/MWh, the price of hydrotreated
vegetable oil is ca 150 €/MWh, etc. In addition to this, the supplier must bear the costs related to
the infrastructure – e.g. the filling station or the charging station. This means that in practice there
is no possibility for the supplier to receive the certificate for free.
1
According to TFEU Art 107 para 1
2
Diesel fuel and pertol must include at least 10% of biofuel. This obligation may be fulfilled with certificates, as well.
Liquid Fuel Act § 21 paragraph 1 - https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/521122020007/consolide#para2b1
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
The quantities of the certificates and the suppliers able to trade with the certificates are not limited
by the State. The quantity of certificates and suppliers able to trade with the certificates is
determined by the suppliers not by the State. Furthermore, using the certificates is not mandatory,
it is one of the possibilities a supplier can use to fulfil the renewable energy obligation. Therefore,
the argument made by the Complainant that the State limits the number of suppliers and
certificates, is not valid.
Please find below our detailed answers to the submission.
1. Supply / blending obligation and penalty
1.1. In your reply of 02/09/2020, you confirm that there is no supply or blending obligation for
biomethane, but that there is a biofuel supply obligation. It is clear from the legislation at stake
that fuel retailers can comply with their biofuel obligation through the sale of biomethane. Even if
biomethane is not necessarily mixed in the final gas supply (i.e. it can be delivered pure), it
amounts to the same result and follows the same rules as blending obligation (i.e. receiving the
statistics proportionate to the amount introduced). In this regard:
a. Could you please explain why you consider that the biomethane statistics are not part of the
overall blending obligation requirements?
The legislation provides the obligation of fuel blending to the suppliers of diesel and gasoline3. In
case such suppliers also supply renewable electricity or biomethane to the transport sector, or are
able to fulfill the obligation with a partnership with someone that supplies renewable electricity or
biomethane to the transport sector, the quantities of this renewable energy may also be accounted
toward the fulfilment of the diesel and gasoline biofuel blending obligation. This is an option for
the suppliers.
b. Please also clarify why you consider that the existing schemes for biomethane remain GBER
exempted in view of this link to a supply obligation.
The point of GBER is that when there is an obligation to add biomethane to compressed natural
gas (CNG), such biomethane may not receive subsidy under GBER. As explained in the answer in
point 1.1 a., biomethane is not the subject of the blending obligation. If it were, the Liquid Fuel
Act would require the supplier of CNG released for consumption in the transport sector to add
some biomethane to such CNG. This, however, is not the obligation in the regulation. As explained
in the previous answer, the current Liquid Fuel Act does not set an obligation to the supplier to add
biomethane to CNG released for consumption in the transport sector.
1.2. Could please explain in further detail if there are any objective elements on why biomethane
3
Liquid Fuel Act § 21 paragraph 1 - https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/521122020007/consolide#para2b1
2 (8)
would be separated from the requirement for delivering a certain amount of renewables in
transport? Our understanding is that as of 2020, renewable electricity and biomethane can be
used to reach the renewables in transport objectives of the Revised Renewable Energy Directive
(RED II).
The renewables objective for the transport sector in Estonia is established primarily on adding
biofuel to diesel and gasoline. These fuels represent most of the transport sector energy usage (87%
in 20184) which is also the reason why these fuels have an obligation to add biofuel. The new
Renewable Energy Directive (RED II) sets out principles for the Member States to transpose into
their national legislation to allow for using all the renewable energy sources towards fulfilling the
renewable transport obligation. Estonia has selected an approach where the biofuel obligation is
set on diesel and gasoline whereas the obligation may optionally be fulfilled by using non-blended
fuels as renewable electricity of biomethane, as well.
1.3. In your reply, you note that the penalty for the fuel supplier that fails to comply with the yearly
10% biofuel requirement can reach up to 10 million euros. Could you please explain how the
penalty is calculated?
The penalty for failing to comply with this requirement is calculated and enforced by the
Environmental Board. The amount of the penalty is calculated based on the shortfall of meeting
the obligation. The main principle is that non-compliance to the obligation cannot be more
beneficial for the supplier than meeting the obligation.
1.4. Could you also inform whether the penalty has already been enforced and up to which
amounts?
To our knowledge, all the suppliers have managed to fulfil their obligations and therefore no
penalties have been enforced so far.
2. State resources
2.1. Could you please explain why you consider that the statistics trading system does not involve
State resources. In this regard, please address also the complainant’s claims that i) the States
creates demand/supply and determines market participants; ii) the State determines the price; iii)
the State organizes the statistics market.
The trading system is, in principle, a platform where the owners of transport certificates can trade
with the certificates. Although the demand side has been created by the State, the supply is still up
to the market participants. The State does not produce these certificates nor gives the certificates
for free to the market players.
4
Web page of Oil Stockpiling Agency - https://www.ospa.ee/et/kutuseturu-kirjeldus
3 (8)
The scheme used in Estonia is built on the principle that the biofuel target must be met by blending
biofuels to diesel and gasoline. Alternatively, if the fuel retailer chooses so, this obligation can be
met (or partially met) by using other renewable sources used in transport (biomethane, electricity).
The amount of renewables needed to fulfill the obligation is calculated in MWh. Fuel retailers can
either buy and sell fuels blended with sufficient biofuels or they can buy transport certificates. The
transactions with renewables can be done via bilateral contracts or via the trading platform that is
planned to be established later this year.
To allow the suppliers to trade with each other, a platform in which all the suppliers may place
their bids on obtaining or selling renewable energy certificates will be set up by the end of this
year. The certificates may be of biofuel origin (i.e. ethanol, biodiesel), renewable electricity origin
or biomethane origin. Each of these fuels is released to the market driven by market forces, without
the intervention of the State. Also, the certificates are owned, bought and sold by the market
participants and not the State. None of the mentioned fuels is released to the market by the State.
The price of the certificates is formed based on demand and supply forthe certificates and the fuel
from which the certificates originate. For example, the certificates from biofuel have a higher price
than certificates originating from electricity or biomethane. Such prices are set by the seller, the
State cannot intervene here. Therefore, the complainant’s claim that the State creates the supply
and sets the price is not correct.
The demand for such certificates is fully up to the market participants. As mentioned before,
exchanging certificates is an option for the suppliers. Furthermore, bilateral agreements between
suppliers and owners of certificates may also be conducted. Though the transfer of certificates
must be registered in the trading system, bilateral agreements do not have to be made via the
trading system5. The trading parties have not been limited, each individual person, including the
suppliers, may buy and sell the mentioned certificates. Therefore, the complainant’s claim that the
Stare creates demand and determines the strict list of participants is not correct.
Organizing the market of the certificates is the responsibility of the State. This is the only
possibility to determine that the trading of the certificates according to the principles of free and
fair competition. According to the Renewables Directive (EU) 2019/2001, the renewables
obligation (including in the transport sector) must be met by the Member State. The State provides
the platform and the rules to ensure a transparent and a competitive functioning of the certificates
market. This is in principle the same approach as the stock market has – the rules and the platform
for trading are set by organizer of the stock market and the market participants provide the demand
and supply of the stocks. Such an approach is not a matter of State aid. The development of similar
platforms, i.e. for reporting renewable energy consumption or registering guarantees of origin, are
also the responsibility of the State. This, however, does not mean that such platforms include some
elements of State aid.
5
Liquid Fuel Act § 22 section 2 - https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/521122020007/consolide#para2b2
4 (8)
3. Existing support schemes
3.1. In your reply, you note that the support measures will come to an end in 2023. However, all
three GBER schemes mentioned in your reply (SA.49198, SA.43899, SA.40745) seem to have
expired at the end of 2020. Please confirm/clarify. Please also explain whether any aid has been
granted or paid since 1/1/2021.
The scheme SA.49198 (Biometaanituru arendamise toetamine) was extended by SA.59787
(Biometaanituru arendamise toetamine (pikendamine)) until 31.12.2023 and the aid is being paid
on a monthly basis based on the amount of eligible biomethane produced. The scheme SA.43899
(Biometaani transpordisektoris tarbimise toetamise tingimused) was not extended as the budget
of the measure was exhausted by the end of 2020. For this scheme, aid has not been granted after
the end of 2020. All the relevant decisions on granting aid under this scheme have been made in
2020. Since some beneficiaries have not concluded the work on the projects, the funds from this
scheme have not been allocated to such beneficiaries, yet. As for the scheme SA.40745
(Kütteainena kasutatud biogaasi aktsiisvabastus), the scheme was extended by SA.60959
(Kütteainena kasutatud biogaasi aktsiisvabastus (muutmine ja pikendamine kuni 31.12.2023))
until 31.12.2023. All the aid given under the mentioned schemes has been reported in the State
Aid registry.
3.2. Please clarify which is the beneficiary of the scheme SA.43899. We understand that the
beneficiary of the scheme SA.49198 is the biomethane producer and of the scheme SA.40745 the
fuel retailer.
According to the Regulation of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure no 135 § 66,
this measure has several beneficiaries:
a) entities constructing a biomethane capable filling station;
b) entities operating public transport.
The following beneficiaries that have constructed a filling station, have been granted aid under
scheme SA.43899: AS Eesti Gaas (NACE 47.3); AS Alexela Oil (NACE 47.3); Alexela Energia
AS (NACE 46.7); Aktsiaselts KROONING (NACE 47.3); OÜ Alexela Tanklad (NACE 68.2);
JetGas OÜ (NACE 46.1).
The beneficiaries that have been awarded aid for using biomethane in public transport sector have
not participated in producing biomethane. However, such beneficiaries are not subject of the
possible income from the certificates scheme.
3.3. Please provide more details regarding the support granted to biomethane producers under
scheme SA.49198 (which is the aid amount, how it is calculated etc.) and for how many years the
6
Regulation of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure no 135 -
https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/114072020026#para6
5 (8)
support is paid.
Under the scheme SA.49198, a total of 19 384 247,61 € (as of 09.06.2021) has been paid to the
producers of biomethane7. The details of providing support to the beneficiaries is set with the
Regulation of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure No. 508. According to the
regulation, if the biomethane is used in transport, the biomethane producer will receive a subsidy
of 100 €/MWh minus the cost of natural gas for each MWh biomethane produced. For example,
when the price of natural gas is 20 €/MWh, the producer of biomethane will receive 80 €/MWh
for the biomethane produced and consumed in transport for that month. The support is paid until
funds allocated for the subsidy are depleted but not longer than by 10th of December of 2023.
According to the current production rate, the funds will run out by mid-2022. Currently, there are
four beneficiaries from this scheme: Rohegaas OÜ, Biometaan OÜ, Vinni Biogaas OÜ and Tartu
Biogaas OÜ. The party responsible for granting aid (Elering AS) is annually conducting an
overcompensation analysis on the beneficiaries.
To our knowledge, additional production facilities are being planned and will most likely start
production of biomethane from the end of this year or the beginning of next year. This is an
indication to the fact that the Estonian RES-T certificate based system has created a good market
based demand for biomethane in Estonia. The scheme for renewables certificates will substitute
the current aid schemes to producers and filling stations and motivate new investments to the
biomethane and renewable electricity sector without having to rely on further subsidies.
4. Cumulation and over-compensation
4.1. Could you please clarify whether the different forms of aid used to support infrastructure
construction and biomethane production mentioned in your reply are included in the cost of the
statistics and how?
The cost of the certificate is not set by the Government, it is determined based on supply and
demand. The nearest reference product to the certificates is the hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO).
This is the first option that the suppliers use to fulfil their biofuel obligation. HVO is convenient
to use as it is directly blended to diesel fuel and there is no physical limit to adding HVO to diesel
fuel. The price of HVO in 2020 was ca 130 €/MWh.
The cost to the developer of the filling station when producing such certificates depends on the
consumption rate of biomethane and the initial investment cost of the filling station. The majority
of the biomethane certificates are produced in biomethane filling stations where the owner of the
station has not received aid and where the consumption of biomethane is high. However, there are
some filling stations where the consumption is rather low and, therefore, the cost of one unit of
7
More information on scheme SA.49198 on Elering AS webpage - https://elering.ee/biometaani-toetus
8
Regulation of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure No. 50 -
https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/519122019005/consolide
6 (8)
certificate (MWh) is utmost high. The developers of such stations have received the investment
aid under discussion to boost the construction of such filling stations.
4.2. In your reply you note that the cost of the statistics is always dependent on the investment cost
of the relevant infrastructure and the cost of the fuel used. On the other hand, the complainant
suggests that such infrastructure (filling and charging stations) was built separately and was also
subsidized. Please clarify and provide details on the relevant GBER scheme (what exactly was
covered by the aid etc.).
The cost of the certificate is dependent on the investment cost (and operating cost) related to the
type of renewable fuel used and the investment made to the filling station. Also, the cost per unit
of energy sold is lower in filling charging stations where the turnover and the consumption rate of
energy is high (the investment can be spread on a larger amount of energy). The investment aid in
question was given to such filling stations where the risk for investing into such stations was too
high for the market participant. Hence, the need for the aid. The risk in such cases is high since the
consumption of gaseous fuels is still rather low compared to the consumption of petrol or diesel
fuel. Therefore, an investment to the infrastructure was not going to be made without the subsidy.
To incentivize the usage of alternative fuels, the infrastructure to support that process must be built
throughout the country. Hence the need for the subsidy. The subsidy covered a part of the
investment costs of the filling stations, but not more than 35% of the total investment9.
4.3. In your reply, you explain that you do not see any risk of overcompensation when undertakings
are producers and retailers at the same time. Could you please be more specific in that regard and
clarify whether said revenues generated through the sales of statistics count as a revenue for
undertakings that are both producers and retailers? Are these revenues taken into account for the
definition of the aid amount received under the relevant schemes (SA.49198, SA.43899,
SA.40745)?
Revenues generated through the sales of transport certificates may count as revenues for
undertakings that are both producers and retailers. There are (consolidated) companies that are
both producers and retailers at the same time. However, such revenues have been considered when
determining the cumulation of the aid along all the GBER measures. The income from the
guarantees of origin will be deducted from the aid granted to produce biomethane. Without the
guarantee of origin, the certificate for biomethane cannot be created. The guarantees of origin carry
relevant information about the fuel used in transport and need to accompany the tradable
certificates. This means that the producer of biomethane may not benefit from the sale of
guarantees of origin, during the period of receiving subsidy, the guarantee of origin must be sold
without any compensation.
9
Regulation of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure no 135, § 7 and 9 -
https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/114072020026
7 (8)
4.4. In your reply, you also state that the cumulation of aid has been analyzed for scheme SA.40745
that establishes an excise duty exemption for biogas used as heating fuel. Could you please explain
why an aid measure meant to support the use of biogas as heating fuel has been used to assess
cumulation for the use of biofuel in the transport sector?
The potential cumulation of aid must be taken into account when designing support schemes and
therefore potential cumulations must be analyzed. In this case , the producer of biogas might have
beforehand benefited from the excise duty reduction. The same biogas producer has now started
to produce biomethane and receives the production aid. Hence the need for an analysis on the
cumulation of aid. Only one producer has benefited both from excise duty reduction and
biomethane production aid (Vinni Biogaas OÜ). This producer has ended using biogas for
producing heat and started to produce biomethane. After starting the production of biomethane,
considerable investments were made compared to the time when only biogas was produced.
Comparing the investment and cumulation of excise duty rate exception aid, no overcompensation
has occurred.
We hope that the information provided is of help and is sufficient. We shall remain at your disposal
in case you have further questions. If this is the case, feel free to propose a call at your earliest
convenience.
Respectfully,
Timo Tatar
Deputy Secretary General for Energy
8 (8)