Saatja: Kairi-Ly Einborn <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 28.06.2021 10:07
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Silver Tammik <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Letter to Minister Sutt regarding WTO Negotiations to End
Harmful Fisheries Subsidies
From: Isabel Jarrett <
[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, June 23,
2021 3:01 PMTo: Risto Kaljurand <
[email protected]>; Kristel Tänover
<
[email protected]>; Kairi-Ly Einborn <Kairi-
[email protected]>Subject: Letter to Minister Sutt regarding WTO
Negotiations to End Harmful Fisheries Subsidies
Dear Minister Sutt:
Please find attached a letter regarding delivery of the European
Commission Presidents mandate to lead on a global agreement to ban
fisheries subsidies ahead of the WTO Ministerial Meeting that will take
place on July 15.
Please note that a copy of this letter is being sent to ministers
responsible for international trade from all 27 EU member states as well
as EU President von der Leyen, Executive Vice-President Timmermans,
Commissioners Sinkevièius, Dombrovskis, and Ambassador Machado, Permanent
Representative of the EU to the WTO.
Kind Regards,
Isabel Jarrett
Isabel Jarrett
Manager, Ending Harmful Fisheries Subsidies
The Pew Charitable Trusts
e: | Skype: @isabeljarrett
18 June 2021
Mr. Andres Sutt
Minister of Entrepreneurship and IT
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn, 10122
Re: Delivering on the European Commission President’s mandate to lead on a global agreement to ban
fisheries subsidies
Dear Minister Sutt:
On behalf of The Pew Charitable Trusts’ (Pew) Reducing Harmful Fishing Subsidies campaign, I write to
bring to your attention recent developments at the WTO, where a new treaty to curb harmful fisheries
subsidies is currently under negotiation.
At the start of her mandate in September 2019, Commission President von der Leyen shortlisted this
process as one of the key priorities under her tenure, and tasked Commissioner Sinkevičius and former
Commissioner Hogan “to ensure that Europe leads discussions in the World Trade Organization on finding
a global agreement to ban fisheries subsidies that contribute to overfishing, illegal fishing and
overcapacity.” President von der Leyen also emphasized that the EU should “lead reform of the World
Trade Organization.” As the only file under active WTO negotiation, successful conclusion of the fisheries
subsidies negotiations would demonstrate that the WTO can deliver an outcome of global importance and
reinforce multilateralism. Within the context of international trade, this is one of the most important
opportunities to contribute to the EU’s commitment to delivering the Green Deal, and its biodiversity and
climate change agenda. It is vital that the EU’s trade policy agenda is consistent with its broader policy
objectives.
Harmful fisheries subsidies are a key driver of overfishing, the greatest threat to marine biodiversity. The
top seven subsidizing countries/territories contribute more than two-thirds of total estimated harmful
subsidies (67% or €12.1 billion). They are China, Japan, the European Union, the Republic of Korea, the
Russian Federation, the United States, and Thailand. As one of the world’s biggest harmful subsidizers, it
is imperative that the EU takes a leading role in WTO negotiations.
During the last three years, however, members of the academic community, fisheries scientists,
economists, small-scale fishers, and environmental organizations have raised concerns about the
disconnect between the laudable political objectives outlined in the Commission’s mandate, and the
current EU position in WTO negotiations. This disconnect raises questions regarding the internal
consistency of the Commission’s agenda and undermines the EU’s credibility as a world leader on
environmental issues and climate change, at a time when multilateral cooperation requires more, not
less, from the EU.
Specifically, we are concerned that two elements of the EU negotiating position at the WTO undermine
its position as a leader on environmental protection and multilateral cooperation: the EU position on fuel-
detaxation and the EU position on what is referred to as the management exemption.
Experts widely recognize fuel subsidies – direct or indirect – as the most damaging of harmful subsidies—
and the least effective form of support for fishers. Fuel subsidies represent one-third or €6.4 billion of the
€18.3 billion provided in harmful subsidies each year. After China, the EU is the second largest provider of
fuel subsidies globally. Currently, the European fishing fleet receives more than €605 million in fuel tax
exemptions annually--one-third of its total capacity-enhancing subsidies. These subsidies primarily flow
to large-scale fishing vessels, rather than benefiting small-scale fishers or coastal communities.
In the WTO context, the EU is perceived as leading the effort to ensure that fuel detaxation be excluded
from the scope of a WTO fisheries subsidies agreement. Decisively addressing this type of subsidy, in
particular for large scale fleets, is essential to the success of the WTO effort. It could also play a key role
in helping to fulfill the EU’s promises of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by at least 55% by 2030, and
in delivering the commitments under the European Green Deal to eliminate net emissions by 2050 and
decouple economic growth from resource use.
In addition to the EU’s unwillingness to shift on its fuel detaxation programs, it has positioned itself as a
key proponent of the management exemption. This exemption touches on what is arguably the central
pillar of the current draft text of an agreement. Currently, the EU is a stalwart proponent of allowing
members to maintain or grant new harmful fisheries subsidies if they demonstrate that measures exist to
manage the fish stock concerned, irrespective of whether these measures are effective and properly
implemented to avoid overfishing. If the EU draft language remains in the final agreement, it would lock
in the status quo whereby public funds continue to contribute to overfishing and overcapacity in Europe
and globally. Moreover, it would undercut President von der Leyen’s ability to deliver – and bring along
others with her – on the EU’s biodiversity commitments and would drastically impede efforts to level the
global playing field for all, including the EU industry.
World Trade Organization Director-General Okonjo-Iweala has called a Ministerial meeting on fisheries
subsidies negotiations on July 15. We believe that a good deal on fisheries subsidies is within reach and
that the EU with its Member States have a leading and historic role to play. We would therefore like to
request your intervention to ensure (1) that the EU and Estonia supports a WTO agreement which
addresses all harmful subsidies, including fuel detaxation schemes; and (2) that prerogatives which
would maintain the status quo and allow the EU and Estonia to continue to provide harmful subsidies
to its fishing fleet are not introduced within the agreement.
Yours Sincerely,
Isabel Jarrett
Manager, Ending Harmful Fisheries Subsidies
The Pew Charitable Trusts