Väljaminev kiriAvalik
Considerations for qualifying a home office as a permanent establishment in Estonia
Rahandusministeerium · 31. oktoober 2022
- Viit
- 5-1/7871-2
- Registreeritud
- 31. oktoober 2022
- Dokumendi liik
- Väljaminev kiri
- Adressaat
- LLM MBA
- Saabumis/saatmisviis
- e-post
- Funktsioon
- 5 RIIGI MAKSU- JA TOLLIPOLIITIKA KAVANDAMINE JA ELLUVIIMINE
- Sari
- 5-1 Kirjavahetus maksu- ja tollipoliitika ning riigilõivu osas (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
- Toimik
- 5-1/2022
- Vastutaja
- Tiina Hansson (Rahandusministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Finants- ja maksupoliitika valdkond, Maksu- ja tollipoliitika osakond)
Sisu (failidest)
Your ref. 06.09.2022
Pieter Manden
Our ref. 31.10.2022 No 5-1/7871-2
LLM MBA
Netherlands
[email protected]
Considerations for qualifying a home office as a permanent establishment in Estonia
Dear Mr Manden,
Estonian tax authority has not issued any specific guidelines on how to determine whether home
office constitutes a permanent establishment (PE) or not. We follow the Commentaries to the
OECD Model Tax Convention (MTC) as the means of interpretation of tax treaty provisions.
Based on the description provided in your letter dated 6 September 2022, we agree that the junior
and medior IT developers would not qualify as dependent agents. It is also unlikely that our tax
authority would regard the activities of the developers as of preparatory and auxiliary character.
For a home office to create a fixed base PE requires a certain degree of permanency and being at
the disposal of an enterprise. The facts and circumstances of each case need to be considered. It is
generally accepted that the home office must be used on a continuous basis (e.g. for at least six
months) for the performance of the activities of an enterprise, and the enterprise generally has to
require the individual to use that location to perform the enterprise’s business. The Commentaries
to Article 5 of MTC provide an example where a cross-border employee works mostly from a
home office in a jurisdiction different than the one in which their employer’s office is located. In
this scenario, the individual’s home office in not considered to be at the disposal of their employer,
as the latter did not require its use for business activities.
It seems from the description of the WorkMotion Software GmbH’s case that the nature of the
employment of IT developers does not necessarily require an office, which suggests that the fact
that the employer will not set up an office in Estonia might be less decisive.
Please note that there have been suggestions among OECD Member States to update the OECD
model tax convention in order to align the treaty rules better with the new ways of working and
these general guidelines given might not be relevant in the foreseeable future.
Furthermore, it is advisable to send questions regarding a particular case of a taxpayer directly to
the Estonian Tax and Customs Board ([email protected]).
Yours sincerely,
(signed digitally)
Erle Kõomets
Head of Tax Policy Department
Tiina Hansson +372 6113039,[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / Estonia / +372 611 3558 / [email protected]
www.rahandusministeerium.ee / Reg. code: 70000272