Draft ID: 14b6bbfe-c344-44a8-a8f9-bf23f84bb9e7
Date: 06/05/2021 11:24:46
Open Public Consultation on the Hydrogen and
Gas Market Decarbonisation Package
Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Introduction
The European Green Deal establishes a roadmap for cutting greenhouse gas emissions, fighting
biodiversity loss and tackling pollution, while boosting a modern, resource-efficient economy and creating
jobs. Energy policy is a central pillar in the European Green Deal and in the decarbonisation of the
European economy. Energy instruments are needed to achieve climate targets in a cost-effective manner,
to the benefit of EU customers. These include measures already outlined in the relevant initiatives adopted
under the European Green Deal. Specifically, the Energy System Integration Strategy and the Hydrogen
Strategy adopted on 8 July 2020 set out how the energy markets could contribute to achieving the goals of
the European Green Deal, including the decarbonisation of the production and consumption of hydrogen
a n d m e t h a n e .
This consultation aims to collect views and suggestions from stakeholders and citizens related to a possible
proposal for a revision of the Gas Directive (2009/73/EC) and Gas Regulation ((EC) No 715/2009). This
review is planned for Q4 2021.
The possible need for legislative changes relates primarily to cost-efficient decarbonisation of the existing
gas sector by (i) enabling a market for renewable and low carbon hydrogen allowing it to become a key
component of the energy sector, and (ii) facilitating the injection, transmission, distribution and trading of
renewable and low carbon gases in the existing gas grid in the context of the wider energy system
integration.
Moreover certain renewable gases might not be connected to any network at all, but could be consumed at
the place of production (e.g. by small modular electrolysers) or transported by other means (e.g. rail or
road) to where they will be used. The scope of the off-grid production compared to production connected to
a network depends inter alia on technological developments and market uptake.
While preparing for and incentivising the transition to renewable and low carbon gases, legislative changes
may also contribute to a better and more consumer friendly functioning of the gas market, taking into
account rapid technological developments and the principles introduced in the recent electricity market
d e s i g n p r o p o s a l s .
To organise the transition from fossil to carbon free fuels and to achieve a climate-neutral Europe by 2050,
the Commission will table a Fit for 55 package to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 55% by
2030. This will cover wide-ranging policy areas – from energy efficiency to renewables, energy performance
of buildings, as well as land use, energy taxation, effort sharing and emissions trading. The on-going
reviews of the Renewable Energy Directive ((EU) 2018/2001) and the Energy Efficiency Directive ((EU)
1
2018/2002) are addressing, among other things, issues of regulatory incentives for production or
consumption of renewable energy. The gas market legislation is part of the Fit for 55 package will need to
be consistent with measures under both Directives as well as other measures under the package.
In the Commission’s view, in order to deliver the 2030 and 2050 targets, an integrated planning and
operation of the energy system as a whole, across multiple energy markets, carriers, infrastructure types,
and consumption sectors is necessary.
Households and industrial consumers are at the centre of an integrated energy system. Consumers should
be able to choose among the available and accessible renewable and low-carbon technologies that best
serve their needs in terms of reliability, resource efficiency and cost. Competitive energy markets are a key
tool to achieve the targets of the Green Deal in a cost-efficient manner and to stimulate the significant
investments. Putting all technologies into competition, in particular smart electrification, demand response,
energy efficiency, and renewable and low-carbon gases like hydrogen and bio methane, or Carbon Capture
and Usage/Storage (CCU/S) technologies, will serve customers and empower them to make choices
which, in turn, help to achieve decarbonisation targets in a cost efficient way. As such efficiencies and
active consumer participation are facilitated, an integrated energy system must be effective and reliable in
providing vulnerable and energy poor consumers with a high level of protection.
Direct electrification is in most cases the most cost-effective and energy-efficient way to decarbonise final
energy demand. Electrification coupled with increased contribution from renewables, energy efficiency and
applying circular economy will thus deliver a substantial part of the emission reductions across the energy
system. In certain areas, where a decarbonisation of the current use of gaseous fuels through full
electrification is unlikely to be technically or economically viable, gaseous fuels are likely to remain present
in the EU’s energy system.
The answers to this questionnaire will feed into the review process of the Gas Directive and Gas
Regulation, in particular into the impact assessment that the Commission will carry out to assess whether a
revision is needed and, if yes, what revision would be the most appropriate.
In the context of developing this initiative, the Commission will conduct an evaluation of the relevant gas
market rules. The evaluation will assess the current effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, coherence and the
added-value of action at EU level of the Gas Directive and Gas Regulation, in particular in reaching the EU
decarbonisation targets.
The combined evaluation roadmap has been consulted previously and is available here:
https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12766-Revision-of-EU-rules-on-Gas
The questions are divided into eight sections: questions about the identity of respondents, general
questions on revising the Gas Directive and Gas Regulation and more specific technical questions on e.g.
consumer rights, infrastructure planning, hydrogen markets, access of renewable and low-carbon gases to
the gas market and infrastructures, gas quality, and security of supply.
If you do not have an opinion on a question, do not reply.
NB: There is a session timeout for the submission of your contribution after 60 minutes; this is an
automatic security feature. In order to avoid any loss of data, do not forget to use the “Save as Draft” option
on the top right side of your screen before the 60 minutes expire. You can subsequently resume work on
your contribution, and submit once completed.
2
Please note that this questionnaire will be available in all EU-languages in the coming weeks.
About you
* I am giving my contribution as
Academic/research institution
Business association
Company/business organisation
Consumer organisation
EU citizen
Environmental organisation
Non-EU citizen
Non-governmental organisation (NGO)
Public authority
Trade union
Other
* First name
Rein
* Surname
VAKS
* Email (this won't be published)
[email protected]
* Scope
International
Local
National
Regional
* Organisation name
255 character(s) maximum
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
3
* Organisation size
Micro (1 to 9 employees)
Small (10 to 49 employees)
Medium (50 to 249 employees)
Large (250 or more)
Transparency register number
255 character(s) maximum
Check if your organisation is on the transparency register. It's a voluntary database for organisations seeking to
influence EU decision-making.
* Country of origin
Please add your country of origin, or that of your organisation.
Afghanistan Djibouti Libya Saint Martin
Åland Islands Dominica Liechtenstein Saint Pierre
and Miquelon
Albania Dominican Lithuania Saint Vincent
Republic and the
Grenadines
Algeria Ecuador Luxembourg Samoa
American Egypt Macau San Marino
Samoa
Andorra El Salvador Madagascar São Tomé and
Príncipe
Angola Equatorial Malawi Saudi Arabia
Guinea
Anguilla Eritrea Malaysia Senegal
Antarctica Estonia Maldives Serbia
Antigua and Eswatini Mali Seychelles
Barbuda
Argentina Ethiopia Malta Sierra Leone
Armenia Falkland Islands Marshall Singapore
Islands
Aruba Faroe Islands Martinique Sint Maarten
Australia Fiji Mauritania Slovakia
4
Austria Finland Mauritius Slovenia
Azerbaijan France Mayotte Solomon
Islands
Bahamas French Guiana Mexico Somalia
Bahrain French Micronesia South Africa
Polynesia
Bangladesh French Moldova South Georgia
Southern and and the South
Antarctic Lands Sandwich
Islands
Barbados Gabon Monaco South Korea
Belarus Georgia Mongolia South Sudan
Belgium Germany Montenegro Spain
Belize Ghana Montserrat Sri Lanka
Benin Gibraltar Morocco Sudan
Bermuda Greece Mozambique Suriname
Bhutan Greenland Myanmar Svalbard and
/Burma Jan Mayen
Bolivia Grenada Namibia Sweden
Bonaire Saint Guadeloupe Nauru Switzerland
Eustatius and
Saba
Bosnia and Guam Nepal Syria
Herzegovina
Botswana Guatemala Netherlands Taiwan
Bouvet Island Guernsey New Caledonia Tajikistan
Brazil Guinea New Zealand Tanzania
British Indian Guinea-Bissau Nicaragua Thailand
Ocean Territory
British Virgin Guyana Niger The Gambia
Islands
Brunei Haiti Nigeria Timor-Leste
Bulgaria Heard Island Niue Togo
and McDonald
Islands
5
Burkina Faso Honduras Norfolk Island Tokelau
Burundi Hong Kong Northern Tonga
Mariana Islands
Cambodia Hungary North Korea Trinidad and
Tobago
Cameroon Iceland North Tunisia
Macedonia
Canada India Norway Turkey
Cape Verde Indonesia Oman Turkmenistan
Cayman Islands Iran Pakistan Turks and
Caicos Islands
Central African Iraq Palau Tuvalu
Republic
Chad Ireland Palestine Uganda
Chile Isle of Man Panama Ukraine
China Israel Papua New United Arab
Guinea Emirates
Christmas Italy Paraguay United
Island Kingdom
Clipperton Jamaica Peru United States
Cocos (Keeling) Japan Philippines United States
Islands Minor Outlying
Islands
Colombia Jersey Pitcairn Islands Uruguay
Comoros Jordan Poland US Virgin
Islands
Congo Kazakhstan Portugal Uzbekistan
Cook Islands Kenya Puerto Rico Vanuatu
Costa Rica Kiribati Qatar Vatican City
Côte d’Ivoire Kosovo Réunion Venezuela
Croatia Kuwait Romania Vietnam
Cuba Kyrgyzstan Russia Wallis and
Futuna
Curaçao Laos Rwanda Western
Sahara
6
Cyprus Latvia Saint Yemen
Barthélemy
Czechia Lebanon Saint Helena Zambia
Ascension and
Tristan da
Cunha
Democratic Lesotho Saint Kitts and Zimbabwe
Republic of the Nevis
Congo
Denmark Liberia Saint Lucia
The Commission will publish all contributions to this public consultation. You can choose whether you
would prefer to have your details published or to remain anonymous when your contribution is published. Fo
r the purpose of transparency, the type of respondent (for example, ‘business association,
‘consumer association’, ‘EU citizen’) country of origin, organisation name and size, and its
transparency register number, are always published. Your e-mail address will never be published.
Opt in to select the privacy option that best suits you. Privacy options default based on the type of
respondent selected
* Contribution publication privacy settings
The Commission will publish the responses to this public consultation. You can choose whether you would like
your details to be made public or to remain anonymous.
Anonymous
Only organisation details are published: The type of respondent that you
responded to this consultation as, the name of the organisation on whose
behalf you reply as well as its transparency number, its size, its country of
origin and your contribution will be published as received. Your name will not
be published. Please do not include any personal data in the contribution
itself if you want to remain anonymous.
Public
Organisation details and respondent details are published: The type of
respondent that you responded to this consultation as, the name of the
organisation on whose behalf you reply as well as its transparency number,
its size, its country of origin and your contribution will be published. Your
name will also be published.
I agree with the personal data protection provisions
* Language of my contribution
7
Bulgarian
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Estonian
Finnish
French
German
Greek
Hungarian
Irish
Italian
Latvian
Lithuanian
Maltese
Polish
Portuguese
Romanian
Slovak
Slovenian
Spanish
Swedish
I. General questions on the review and possible revision of the Gas Directive
and Gas Regulation
Costs for renewable energies have decreased significantly in the last ten years. In the relevant scenarios
used by the Climate Target Plan Impact Assessment, biogas, renewable and low-carbon hydrogen and
synthetic fuels would represent two-thirds of the gaseous fuels in the 2050 energy mix, with fossil gas used
in combination with CCU/S representing the remainder. The areas where renewable and low-carbon
gaseous fuels are expected to come into play include today’s industrial sectors (e.g. refineries, fertilisers,
steel making, glass, ceramics) and certain heavy duty transport sectors (ships, aviation, long distance
heavy vehicles). They are also expected to continue serving the needs of the electricity system as flexible
power production. The role of gas in heating depends on the competition with other technologies, including
heat pumps. The process to decarbonise the gas supply and to shift demand for gases to most needed
8
uses must start allready now. Achieving the 2030 renewable, energy efficiency and greenhouse-gas
reduction targets in time is an important step in this process.
1. What is your view on the role of gaseous fuels in 2030, in particular as regards
hydrogen, biogas and biomethane?
500 character(s) maximum
In 2030, decarbonized gaseous fuels will be used in sectors where renewable electricity cannot be used. In
addition some quantities of natural gas is also on the market as a bridge fuel.
2. Do you see a need to revise the Gas Directive and Gas Regulation to help to
achieve decarbonisation objectives?
Yes
No
3. If, yes what should the main elements of the reform be? Which benefits do you
expect?
500 character(s) maximum
The revized package should target the quality of gas in the decarbonized gas market, hydrogen transmission
system operator requirements, the digitalization of the gas market. Also, the regulation of gas market should
be aligned as much as possible with the electricity regulation, incl. the responsibilities of the DSO.
4. How could the revised legislation support the aims of the Energy Efficiency
Directive (2018/2002) and the Renewables Energy Directive (2018/2001/EU)?
500 character(s) maximum
The revized package has strong links with EED (digitalization, energy efficiency) and RED (decarbonized
gas market). Providing a strong market regulation to foster green gases is a must to reach the goals in RED
and EED.
5. Should the revised legislation, in addition to the instruments under the Fit for 55
package, in particular the Renewables Energy Directive and the Energy Efficiency
Directive, include also measures that dis-incentivise the use of unabated fossil
gases?
Yes
No
6. Should the revised legislation, in addition to the instruments under the Fit for 55
package, in particular the Renewables Energy Directive and the Energy Efficiency
Directive, include also measures that incentivise the use of renewable and low
carbon gases, for example via specific targets?
9
Yes
No
7. Do you expect that the technological and regulatory changes necessary to
decarbonise the gas market have a potential to create new jobs by 2030?
Yes
On balance neutral
No
8. What type of jobs will be created? What are the characteristics of jobs that are at
risk of being discontinued? If applicable please identify the potential changes in the
skills requirements, job quality and occupational safety of the gas market jobs.
500 character(s) maximum
9. Do you consider that investments in installations and infrastructure operating on
fossil methane gas subject to the risk of stranded assets. If so can the revised
legislation address this issue, and how?
500 character(s) maximum
II. Consumer’s choice and renewable and low-carbon gases
Recognising that citizens must be at the core of the Energy Union and the European Green Deal, clear and
easily accessible information is essential to enable citizens to change energy consumption patterns, switch
to solutions offered by an integrated energy system, and whenever applicable, switch supplier. Today’s
consumers are not always made aware of the origin of gases they consume and their climate impacts. To
that effect, the certification of renewable and low-carbon gases is envisaged in the context of the upcoming
revision of the Renewable Energy Directive (EU) 2018/2001. Recent changes to market rules for electricity
have established a comprehensive framework for consumer protection and empowerment (see articles 4, 5,
9-19, 22-29, and Annexes I and II of recast Electricity Directive (EU) 2019/944) in the sector.
While technical and economic conditions in gas markets may differ from electricity markets, updating the
legislative framework for gases could ensure an equal level of protection and empowerment for electricity
and consumers of gaseous fuels, and increase certainty for market actors. This revision could establish the
tools to empower consumers to actively take part in the energy transition while enjoying high level of
consumer protection , and ensure that they fully benefit from their contributions to the decarbonisation
process. This gives also an opportunity to complement existing legislation addressing the challenges
related to vulnerable households and energy poverty.
10
Consumers should become well-informed and empowered as buyers. This could be achieved through
clearer billing and advertising rules, trustworthy price comparison tools, the possibility to conclude contracts
to buy specifically renewable or low carbon gas and by leveraging their significant bargaining power
through collective schemes (such as collective switching and energy communities). Finally, consumers
need to be free to generate and consume their own energy under fair and transparent conditions in order to
save money, help the environment, and ensure security of supply.
10. Do you consider that the Gas Directive needs to be modified to ensure
consumer protection and empowerment?
(multiple answers possible)
Yes, it needs to be more ambitious to reflect the citizen/consumer focus of
the Clean Energy Package for all Europeans and the Green Deal.
Yes, and mirroring consumer protection and empowerment rights of
electricity consumers conferred by the recast Electricity Directive and by
2018 Energy Efficiency Directive would be the most straightforward
approach to do so.
No, it strikes the right balance as it is.
11. If you answered ‘yes’ to the previous question, which provisions pertaining to
consumer protection and empowerment should be prioritised in the revised Gas
D i r e c t i v e ?
(multiple answers possible)
Provisions on protection of energy poor and vulnerable customers.
Provisions on single points of contact for consumers for information on
rights, gas consumption and costs, legislation and dispute settlement.
Provisions on protection mechanisms to ensure efficient treatment of
complaints through transparent, simple and inexpensive procedures and out-
of-court dispute settlements.
Provisions on supply contract information and modification.
Provisions on accessibility to transparent information on share of renewable
gas consumed, gas quality, applicable prices and tariffs and on standard
terms and conditions.
Provisions on frequency of billing and available payment methods.
Provisions on cost of access to metering and billing information.
Provisions related to switching suppliers (switching related fees, final closure
account).
Provisions on accessibility of consumption data.
11
Provisions on smart installation of individual meters in multi-apartment or
multi-purpose buildings.
Provisions on intelligent and remotely metering systems and their costs.
Provisions on protection against disconnection during winter.
Other
12 Which of the following do you think would be appropriate in strengthening the
rights and information of consumers in the gas market? (multiple answers possible)
Consumer participation in demand response through aggregation contracts
to sell or buy gases.
Enabling the participation/the establishment of energy communities.
Access to reliable online price comparison tools for improved switching rates.
Introduction/deployment of smart metering systems for gases.
Obligations to provide pro-active consumer information on switching
possibilities, consumer rights etc.
More consumption and billing information.
Additional requirements (please explain further in next question).
Enabling self-consumption for large customers using gas absorption heat
pumps.
Setting minimum requirements for billing information.
Providing further billing information on breakdown of gas supply prices.
Providing further information about historical consumption and energy
sources.
Providing information on the nature of gas supply i.e. fossil, renewable, low
carbon.
Other
13. Please specify and/or explain your choice for the three previous questions.
500 character(s) maximum
14. Whether for residential or commercial purposes, consumers may bundle their
utilities with a single energy provider. The idea of bundling is based on combining
several services in one package. As regards households, some utility companies
12
can provide electricity, gases and heating offers in a single deal. How do you think
transparency and the flexibility of such bundled electricity, gases and heating offers
could be further improved to benefit consumers?
500 character(s) maximum
The regulation on gas and electricity must be aligned as much as possible. This would allow for the traders
and consumers to be on the same information field regarding the consumed energy. The less there are
differences in the regulation, the more flexible and transparent the market integration can be.
15. To what extent has current EU legal framework on gas been effective:
13
for vulnerable consumers in:
Highly Moderately Somewhat Not No
Effective
effective effective ineffective effective opinion
ensuring a fair protection against
disconnections?
14
for customer empowerment in:
Highly Moderately Somewhat Not No
Effective
effective effective ineffective effective opinion
contributing to decarbonisation i.e. choose the most affordable
sustainable energy source?
contributing to the achievement of the EU internal energy market (i.e.
choose the preferred supplier irrespective of their place of residence)?
stimulating the availability of comparison tools?
protecting consumers from aggressive marketing practice?
stimulating green offers?
stimulating diversity in the choice of payment methods?
setting clear deadlines for dealing with requests to switch supplier?
establishing unique contact points for consumers?
15
for information about dispute settlement mechanisms in:
Highly Moderately Somewhat Not No
Effective
effective effective ineffective effective opinion
establishing conditions to exercise the right of
withdrawal?
accessing to speedy and effective complaint handling
procedures?
providing available out-of-court procedures?
16
for right to information in:
Highly Moderately Somewhat Not No
Effective
effective effective ineffective effective opinion
spreading the practice of clear description of the service/product?
spreading the practice of offers presented in a clear, consistent and
simple manner?
spreading the practice of clearly presenting key information about
prices, discounts, termination fees?
17
for access to consumption data in:
Highly Moderately Somewhat Not No
Effective
effective effective ineffective effective opinion
ensuring access to consumption data shortly after
consumption?
boosting consumer confidence in the market?
ensuring transparency and fairness of contractual
conditions?
preventing unilateral change of contractual conditions by
the supplier?
18
for right to accurate information on billing and switching in:
Highly Moderately Somewhat Not No
Effective
effective effective ineffective effective opinion
providing price increase notifications?
stimulating transparent bundled offers to
consumers?
discouraging surcharges in the payment
methods?
ensuring a smooth and fast switching process?
preventing termination fee or penalty for
switching?
19
16. Do you see the price of residential gaseous fuel products as an important
element in affordability? Do you see an energy poverty challenge in households’
access to gaseous fuel products in the future?
500 character(s) maximum
20
17. In your view, how important are price signals to consumers in the gas market?
Very Not very Not No
Important Neutral
important important important opinion
Would consumers benefit from price signals?
Would price signals drive system integration and energy efficiency and
decarbonisation?
21
18. The recast Electricity Directive clarifies the scope of Public Service Obligations
which concern notably the price setting for the supply of electricity (see Art. 5) in
the electricity market. In your view, should such provisions be introduced in the field
of gas?
Yes
No
III. Integrated infrastructure planning
Coordinated infrastructure planning across multiple energy carriers, types of infrastructure, and
consumption sectors – is the cornerstone of an integrated energy system. In this spirit, the TEN-E
Regulation requires that projects of common interest are to be included in national network development
plans with highest priority. The Commission proposal
https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12382-Revision-of-the-guidelines-
for-trans-European-Energy-infrastructure
envisages provisions for cross-sectoral infrastructure planning. Hydrogen infrastructure is included as a
new infrastructure category and used for the network development plan on European level. The
requirements for national development plans of the Gas Directive and Gas Regulation are focused on
preventing underinvestment that could result in less competition. These requirements correspond neither to
the decarbonisation objectives nor to the planning requirements on European level. They also lack
consistency between gases and electricity sectors.
19. How to ensure non-biased scenario building and planning?
500 character(s) maximum
20. Do you support an alignment of the national network planning with the
European Network Development, for instance regarding frequency of the plans (i.e.
timing of submission), time-frames and scenarios to consider?
Yes
No
21. Should the national network development plan be based on a joint scenario
used for gases and electricity planning?
Yes
No
22
22. What actions are needed to ensure that national network development plans
properly take into account the Energy Efficiency First Principle, meaning that
energy efficiency alternative solutions must be first considered when national
network development decision are made?
500 character(s) maximum
23. What is your position on establishing a single national network development
plan for all energy carriers?
Completely Dompletely No
Statement Agree Neutral Disagree
agree disagree opinion
A single national
network development
plan can optimise
infrastructure needs.
All regulated
infrastructure should
be part of a single
national network
development plan.
Should the single
national network
development plan be
binding?
There is no objective
model to optimise
network planning
across different energy
carriers.
It is better to keep
separate network
plans for each sector,
but based on a joint
scenario.
24. Do you support requiring the setting up of national network development plans
by all electricity and gas transmission system operators, irrespective of the
unbundling model (i.e. also including ownership unbundled transmission system
operators)?
Yes
No
23
25. What role should distribution system operators have in relation to network
p l a n n i n g ?
(multiple answers possible)
Provide information on expected supply and demand for the creation of a
joint scenario for the national plan.
Prepare their own distribution system network plan.
Share information with transmission system operators for network planning
purposes.
Be allowed to conduct their own cross-sectoral optimisation.
None of the above.
26. Should hydrogen transmission/distribution infrastructure be included in national
network development plans?
Yes
No
27. What should the network development plan be used for?
(multiple answers possible)
Provide transparency.
Ensure a robust network to match supply and demand for different scenarios.
Enable execution of investments.
Regulatory prerequisite for cost acceptance in regulated network tariffs.
Guarantee that infrastructure contained in the plan is built (binding plan).
28. Should the national network development plans provide information where new
electricity production, consumers, storages or electrolysers reduce additional
investment needs into the network?
(multiple answers possible)
No, the selection of production, consumption and storage sites is not an
activity system operators should be involved in.
Yes, but only as information, without legal consequence.
Yes, for hydrogen production.
Yes, for electricity production (renewable and/or conventional).
Yes, for electricity and/or hydrogen storage.
Yes, for major consumption sites.
24
Yes, to take into account externalities not necessarily perceived by market
participants.
29. [question available only if “yes” to one of the bullets under 30]: If you answered
yes, how should this be achieved?
By selecting indicative areas which are particularly suitable from an energy
network perspective for the given type of production/storage/major
consumption site, as an information only.
By defining areas where sufficient connection capacity to the energy
networks for such sites can be guaranteed.
By establishing that this type of site may only be connected in the indicated
areas.
By establishing areas in which lower network tariffs for the use of the
respective sites, and/or connection charges can be expected, based on the
tariffs approved/decided by the national regulatory authority.
By indicating in which areas system operators expect to make offers for the
purchase of system services which could typically be provided by the given
type of site.
By using connection in designated areas as a prerequisite for eligibility in
support schemes.
Other
30. If you consider that, in question 29, other approaches are required, please
explain what approach is needed and why?
500 character(s) maximum
IV. Hydrogen infrastructure and a hydrogen market
Pure hydrogen, used today mainly as a feedstock, can be expected to be used as a fuel or as an energy
carrier. Pure hydrogen may be transported via a network of dedicated pipelines that could consist of
repurposed methane gas pipelines and/or newly built pipelines. Currently, infrastructure for the transport of
pure hydrogen is not covered by the Gas Directive, as the gas system currently does not include network
infrastructure dedicated to the transport of pure hydrogen.
The Commission’s vision as set out in the EU’s hydrogen strategy[1] is that (low carbon and, preferably
renewable) hydrogen will be used first in certain industrial applications (like refineries, steel production,
fertiliser production, chemical complexes) and certain transportation modes (heavy duty road
transportation, maritime) and that, progressively, an integrated market will emerge from initially
disconnected hydrogen valleys. The hydrogen landscape is expected to evolve rapidly in the coming years,
but its development is likely to differ in speed and scope per Member State. The present consultation seeks
25
to collect views on regulatory measures that may be required to accompany the emergence of an EU
hydrogen market over the next 10-15 years.
[1] https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/hydrogen_strategy.pdf
31. Which are in your view the main regulatory barriers to the development of a
well-functioning cross-border hydrogen market and a cross-border hydrogen
infrastructure within the EU?
500 character(s) maximum
The major risk is represented in the absence of the TSO criterias fot the Hydrogen infrastructure. It must be
clear that the system operator of the hydrogen infrastructure must meet the same criteria as the natural gas
TSO.
32. Which are in your view the main regulatory barriers to the development of a
cross-border hydrogen market and a cross-border hydrogen infrastructure with third
countries?
500 character(s) maximum
Pancaking of the IP prices must be excluded. An unified entry-exit system must be introduced in the
hydrogen infrastructure.
Section IV.1. Regulatory framework for pure hydrogen markets and pure hydrogen infrastructure
33. What regulatory model at EU level do you consider suitable to foster the
emergence of a well-functioning and competitive hydrogen market and hydrogen
infrastructure?
No regulatory intervention is needed. Progress so far has been made
without rules at EU level and competitive markets outcomes are likely to
emerge without intervention.
The creation of ‘competition for the market’ by tendering concessions at
national level to own and operate hydrogen networks is a market model that
can work for hydrogen. It will foster infrastructure development. Rules on the
operation of the network are not needed.
We need regulation to ensure “competition in the market”. A common
approach is needed in which an EU legislative framework outlining key
regulatory principles (such as neutrality of network operation, third party
access, cost reflective and market compatible network tariffs, treatment of
private networks) are set as networks can represent natural monopolies. The
26
rules could be developed stepwise, e.g. the creation of more detailed EU-
wide technical rules could be left to later, or Member States could be allowed
to develop such rules earlier where needed.
We need regulation to ensure “competition in the market”, already with a
greater level of detail at EU level. The final market organisation should be
specified now to prevent regulatory divergence between Member States and
create investment certainty. Detailed rules (with implementing regulatory
principles and technical rules) are needed at EU level from the start.
Other approaches are needed/required to regulate the hydrogen network as
the regulatory approach currently used in gas and electricity offers little
guidance.
34. If you consider that other approaches are needed/required, please explain what
approach is needed and why.
500 character(s) maximum
35. Although further development of hydrogen markets along the value chain
seems highly likely, significant uncertainties remain. How should this uncertainty be
taken account of in designing a ‘fit for purpose’ regulatory framework?
Setting clear key regulatory principles for infrastructures will remove
important uncertainties, while flexible rules do not. Precise rules are thus
better than flexible ones.
Setting main regulatory principles leaves enough flexibility for details to be
set later or at Member State level. No specific provisions are required to
allow for flexible application of main regulatory principles.
Main regulatory principles are needed. However, flexibility needs to be built
in, e.g. by allowing temporary exemptions/derogations from main regulatory
principles.
A dynamic regulatory approach should apply. Based on a periodic
assessment of the market's maturity, it will be decided if regulatory
intervention along pre-defined principles is needed. The benefits of such a
flexible approach outweigh the costs of interventions with retroactive effect
and regulatory uncertainty.
27
37. How important would you consider to define the following regulatory roles and principles early in order to facilitate the
development of a dedicated hydrogen network and market framework towards 2030?
No Very Not very Not
Role/regulatory principle Important Neutral
opinion important important important
Role of existing network operators (TSOs/DSOs) in developing hydrogen
infrastructure
Role of private parties (non-TSO/DSO operators) in developing hydrogen
infrastructure
Rules to ensure the neutrality of hydrogen network operations (i.e.
unbundling)
Third Party Access to hydrogen infrastructure
Cost-reflective, non-discriminatory network tariffs for hydrogen networks that
are market compatible.
Market rules on capacity allocation and congestion management at cross-
border interconnection points in hydrogen networks
Market rules on balancing the injection of hydrogen in a network with the
volumes taken off the network by a given network user
Rules on cross-border operability of hydrogen networks.
Rules on tariff setting for hydrogen networks
Rules on the valuation of assets when they are repurposed and taken out of
the regulated asset base of a gas-TSO
28
Section IV.2. Regulated versus non-regulated hydrogen networks
38. With the imminent phase out of low-calorific methane gas (L-gas) and the
demand for methane gas expected to decline after 2030, parts of the existing pan-
European gas infrastructure could be repurposed to provide for the necessary
infrastructure for large-scale cross-border transport of hydrogen. Should existing
methane gas network operators be allowed to own, operate and invest in hydrogen
networks?
Yes, the current gas network operators (TSOs/DSOs) should have a
prominent role. The current gas market model could serve as a model for
future hydrogen markets.
Yes, but a parallel pathway for non-regulated infrastructure investments by
private parties should exist.
No, a hydrogen network will need to be regulated, but the current gas
network operators (TSOs/DSOs) should not have a prominent role.
No, hydrogen networks should be left unregulated. “Competition for the
market” can work.
39. How should existing private hydrogen pipelines (pipelines directly connecting
hydrogen supply and demand whilst not being part of a meshed, interconnected
network) be regulated?
Existing private networks should be left unregulated. This is a pathway for
infrastructure development in parallel to a regulated system.
Existing private network operators should be left unregulated but able to
unilaterally choose to ‘opt-in’ into an existing regulated system.
Existing private networks can be exempted (under NRA supervision) from
regulatory requirements (such as unbundling and third party access) but a
sunset date needs to be set (e.g. once supply contracts expire, once it is
integrated in a other, already regulated hydrogen network or by conducting
regular market tests to verify market interest in accessing the pipeline).
No special treatment for existing private infrastructure. Main regulatory
principles should apply to all networks as of the moment of their introduction.
40. Should future private investments in hydrogen pipelines be regulated?
Future private networks should be left unregulated. This is a pathway for
infrastructure development in parallel to a regulated system.
29
The default rule for future networks should be that they are regulated.
Exemptions for private investment from certain provisions (e.g. unbundling,
third party access, tariff regulation) can be considered provided conditions
are met (akin to Article 36 of the current Gas Directive).
Private investments should be allowed and exemptions for private investors
to stimulate them should be considered. However, day-to-day operations of
private networks could be left to other bodies, e.g. an Independent System
Operator (ISO).
No special treatment for future private infrastructure. Main regulatory
principles should apply to all networks.
Section IV.3. Main principles for regulated hydrogen networks
41. Vertical unbundling[2] should prevent that hydrogen network operators (i)
discriminate against third parties with regard to the connection or access to the
network in favour of affiliated production and supply activities, and/or (ii) that
hydrogen network operators over- or under-invest in their energy network which
could increase energy system costs or purposely limit capacity to hinder competitor’
s access. Please indicate the extent to which the vertical unbundling principle
should apply to hydrogen networks:
[2] For the purpose of this questionnaire and to reflect the specific situation of interrelation between hydrogen and methane gas networks, the
Commission will refer to “vertical unbundling” when describing the separation of hydrogen production, trade and supply activities from
hydrogen network-related activities and to horizontal unbundling, when describing the separation between ownership of hydrogen and
methane gas networks.
Accounts unbundling should be applied: the use of separate accounts for the
regulated hydrogen network activities and hydrogen production and supply
activities.
Functional unbundling should be applied: the effective separation of the
decision making rights between the network and production/supply activities,
as well as the separation of the human, technical, physical and financial
resources.
Legal unbundling should be applied: the separation of network operation
activities in a distinct legal entity.
Based on the experience in gas and electricity markets, ownership
unbundling should be applied from the start: the same company is not
allowed to control both the hydrogen network and hydrogen production or
30
supply interests, although e.g. the ownership of minority shares without
rights to vote or appoint board members may be allowed.
42. Should (regulated) network operators (e.g. gas, electricity or hydrogen TSOs
/DSOs) have a role in Power-to-gas installations (i.e. electrolysers)?
Network operators should never own or operate Power-to-gas installations.
To avoid conflicts of interest and network foreclosure, system operators
should be precluded from investing in and running power-to-gas installations
(as is currently the case). Investment and management of power-to-gas
installations should be market-based and open to competition among market
players. Investment by regulated entities will discourage investments by
market participants and create competition distortions.
Network operators should never own or operate Power-to-gas installations.
However, network operators should be encouraged to be involved in R&D
and development projects that are related to energy grid operations (e.g.
grid connection and grid services, like balancing provision). Network
operators are well placed to assist in such projects and encouraging their
active involvement will facilitate the integration of Power-to-gas installations
where no rules exist and speed-up rule setting.
Vertical unbundling remains the default option. Exemptions for network
operators to own or operate Power-to-gas installations should only be
allowed in clearly defined circumstances. For example, only if this is
necessary to guarantee network operations and if no other market party is
willing to carry out the investment. Clear and limited conditions should be
defined (e.g. limitations in scope, scale and time), after it has been proven
that the market is not willing to invest in such installations and foreseeing a
procedure to transfer such installations back to a market-based regime once
the derogation expires.
There are no reasons to impose restrictions on network operators to operate
or invest in power to gas installations or such choices can be left to Member
States or National Regulatory Authorities.
43. How should non-discriminatory access to future regulated hydrogen networks
be ensured?
31
The principle of negotiated third party access should apply. It will be left to
the hydrogen network operator and the network users to negotiate the terms
of access to the network, such as tariffs. National regulators play a role at
distance only.
The principle of regulated third party access should apply. Infrastructure
operators should be obliged in EU legislation to provide non-discriminatory
access to network users on the basis of published terms and conditions,
including tariffs that are set or approved by the national regulator.
Third party access does not have to be ensured.
32
44. Today’s rules for gas network tariffs (see Art. 13 of the Gas Directive) seek to avoid cross-subsidies between network
users but also to provide incentives for investments. In an emerging hydrogen market, the transported hydrogen volumes
as well as the customer base might be low initially. This could lead in certain cases to high initial hydrogen network tariffs
for early users of a hydrogen network. Please indicate the appropriateness of the statements below in case incumbent
methane gas network operators should be allowed to retrofit their assets for hydrogen transport:
No Completely Completely
Statement Agree Neutral Disagree
opinion agree disagree
Horizontal unbundling rules should ensure that hydrogen pipelines are being
financed by hydrogen network users only and not by methane gas network
users. Methane gas network users should not carry the costs and risks for a
hydrogen network and non-TSO hydrogen operators should not suffer a
competitive disadvantage.
Cross-subsidisation between users of the methane gas infrastructure and the
hydrogen infrastructure should be allowed. This could lower the initial tariffs
for the use of hydrogen networks and could facilitate the conversion of parts
of the methane gas infrastructure into hydrogen infrastructure.
Cross-subsidies between methane and hydrogen network users should not
be allowed. Other measures should be made available to lower initial
hydrogen network tariffs (such as public grants or subsidies to network users
or network operators).
33
45. Do you think the current structure of cross-border gas transmission tariff system
is suitable for the development of the hydrogen market (or other renewable and low
carbon gases) in the EU?
Yes
No, other ideas should be developed, for instance to avoid tariffs on cross-
border points between EU Member States.
Please explain why
500 character(s) maximum
the regulation should incentivize a wide spread of joint entry-exit tariffs in the hydrogen networks
46. The creation of hydrogen networks, specifically by repurposing, may give rise to
coordination problems when operated by separate and fragmented system
operators. This may hamper the development of a well-functioning cross-border
hydrogen market. The creation of hydrogen markets opens up a possibility to
manage and operate the hydrogen pipelines by a European Independent System
Operator (ISO). Do you support to introduce an EU ISO model for hydrogen?
Yes
No
Please explain your answer
500 character(s) maximum
47. The configuration of many energy networks and the rules that apply to them set
out a clear distinction between a transmission and distribution level. Is this
distinction relevant for a hydrogen regulatory framework before 2030? Do you
expect the development of a “transmission” and a “distribution” level for hydrogen?
No: hydrogen networks may have different features than methane networks
(e.g. high/low pressure distinction less relevant in hydrogen network). At this
stage, main regulatory principles should apply at any point in a hydrogen
network.
Yes: Many potential customers are connected to distribution grids; it should
already be anticipated now that different rules should apply for the
distribution and transmission level.
34
Yes: At this stage, rules should be set for the transmission level only. EU
rules for the distribution level can wait until later or be defined at Member
State level.
Yes: At this stage, rules should be set for the distribution level. EU rules for
the transmission level can wait until later or be defined at Member State
level.
Please explain your answer
500 character(s) maximum
Section IV.4. Inventory of national rules on the construction of methane and hydrogen pipelines
48. In order to repurpose the existing methane gas infrastructure for hydrogen
transport, it is necessary to clarify whether rights of land use, private easements as
well as (other) public permits that have been granted for the construction and
operation of methane gas pipelines will remain valid once the transported gaseous
energy carrier changes from methane gas to hydrogen. In addition, a legal
framework covering these aspects might also be required for the construction and
operation of new hydrogen pipelines. Will the construction of dedicated hydrogen
pipelines (either repurposed or new built pipelines) be considered a public interest
in your Member State?
Yes
No
Do not know
49. Will rights and permits in your Member State initially obtained for the
construction and operation of methane gas pipelines remain valid in case the
development and (re-) use of these pipelines for hydrogen transport is foreseen?
Yes
No
Do not know
50. Is a (new) legal framework covering public permits and rights of land use
required in your Member State for the construction and operation of new hydrogen
pipelines?
Yes
35
No
Do not know
51. Should rights and permitting requirements for hydrogen infrastructure be similar
to that of those that are applicable today to methane gas pipelines in your Member
State?
Yes
No
Do not know
52. If you replied ‘no’, please explain
500 character(s) maximum
Section IV.5. Consumer rights for users of pure hydrogen
53. The Commission expects as set out in the EU hydrogen strategy [1] that
renewable and low carbon hydrogen will be used first in certain industrial
applications (like refineries, steel production, fertiliser productions, chemical
complexes) and certain transportation modes (heavy duty road transportation,
maritime). In view of these typical end-users that may adopt hydrogen by 2030,
what rights and protection rules for users connected to a pure hydrogen network
may be needed?
[3] https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/hydrogen_strategy.pdf
Other than network access rights, little needs to be done in terms of
customers rights. These typical end-users do not need specific consumer
rights and protection.
It is important that these typical users of a hydrogen network have the same
rights as if they would be connected to the methane gas grid. Having the
same consumer rights and protection ensures a level playing field between
energy carriers.
It is important that consumer rights and protection rules for all consumers
connected to a hydrogen grid are fully aligned with those for consumers of
connected to the methane grid, regardless as to whether they are likely to
use hydrogen or not or their size (i.e. households).
36
54. What consumers rights and protection rules will need to be clarified already
now for users receiving pure hydrogen from dedicated hydrogen networks?
Consumers rights No Very Not Very
Important Neutral
and protection rules opinion important important important
Access to
consumption data
Information on billing
Information on quality
of H2 supplied
Information on CO²
content of hydrogen
along its life-cycle[4]
[Including emissions
determined from hydrogen
transport, distribution,
liquefaction and storage].
Information on rights to
switch supplier
Information about
dispute settlement
mechanisms
Section IV.6. Quality standards for pure hydrogen and its governance
55. Different hydrogen production methods produce hydrogen of different purity
and different end-uses require specific purity levels[4]. To ensure the cross-border
flow of pure hydrogen from production to consumption centres and to ensure the
interoperability of the connected, neighbouring markets, common quality standards
or cross-border operational rules may be necessary. In your view, at what level
should such binding hydrogen quality (purity) standard be established?
[4] In a simplified way, we can distinguish between industrial grade purity for the hydrogen used e.g. in refineries, for ammonia and steel
production and fuel cell grade purity for use in low temperature fuel cells, e.g. current road and rail transport applications.
At Member State level (i.e. maintaining potential differences between
Member States).
At Member State level with EU-level cross-border coordination rules (i.e.
allowing for coordination between Member States).
At EU-level, setting common standards for hydrogen quality across the EU.
No common rules on hydrogen quality standard are necessary before 2030.
37
56. In a cross-border dedicated hydrogen network, adapting the quality of hydrogen
for specific end uses (purification) might become an important task (including the
measurement and monitoring of hydrogen quality). In your view, what would be the
most efficient and appropriate way to establish the necessary rules on roles,
responsibilities and cost-allocation for the management of hydrogen quality?
Member State level regulatory framework (i.e. with potentially very different
regimes per Member State).
EU-level principles providing for a common overall approach in the Member
States.
EU-level principles providing for a common approach combined with regional
implementation.
EU-level rules ensuring a harmonised approach across the EU.
No common rules are necessary before 2030.
Section IV.7. Hydrogen storage and hydrogen import from outside the European Union
57. Do you see the need to develop larger-scale, dedicated hydrogen storage
facilities in the EU in light of the increased use of hydrogen in the EU?
Yes
No
58. Do you think that regulation of hydrogen storage would be necessary?
Yes, to the same degree as for methane storage (leaving Member States the
choice of negotiated or regulated third party access).
Yes, but it should not be directly available to the market itself and should
only be used by the operators for network operation purposes.
No, hydrogen storage facilities can be left unregulated.
59. Hydrogen is likely to be produced inside the EU at the same time imports from
outside the EU may be possible and competitive for the supply of hydrogen.
I disagree, imports will not take place before 2030 and therefore there is no
need to look into relevant infrastructure.
Whilst imports may still be modest by 2030, they will require the necessary
infrastructure and reflection on appropriate measures should start now.
It is important that import infrastructure is in place by 2030.
38
60. Hydrogen may be transported via pipelines into the EU, but also via non-
network based transport options. In case you expect non-network based imports
from outside the EU, in which way do you expect hydrogen to be carried into the
EU?
Shipped into the EU as liquefied hydrogen.
Shipped into the EU as ammonia.
Shipped into the EU on the basis of Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers
(‘LOHCs’).
Transported into the EU via trucks.
61. Do you see a need to prepare EU LNG terminals to receive liquefied hydrogen?
Yes, todays import terminals can play an important role in supplying the EU.
No, imports will become important but large-scale LNG terminals will not be
relevant.
62. In case hydrogen is carried into the EU as liquefied hydrogen, ammonia or
LOHC, would you expect subsequent injection into pipelines?
No Yes
If imported as liquefied hydrogen
If imported as ammonia
If imported as LOHC
63. How important would you consider to define the following regulatory principles
early in order to facilitate the development of a dedicated hydrogen infrastructure
and market framework towards 2030?
No Very Not very Not
Regulatory principle Important Neutral
opinion important important important
Market rules for
access to storage for
(pure) hydrogen
Market rules for
access to import
terminals for pure
hydrogen
V. Access of renewable and low carbon gases to the existing methane gas
networks and markets, including LNG terminals and gas storages
39
Today, biogas[5] and biomethane provide the most significant sources of renewable and low carbon gases
in the EU with some 18 bcm annually (5% of total gas demand). Whereas biogas is used off the grid (for
power production or by the industry to reduce process related CO2 emissions), biomethane can be injected
into the existing methane network. However, the deployment of biomethane is currently below its potential.
There are about 725 biomethane plants connected to the gas grid, the majority at the distribution grid level.
Synthetic methane has the potential to support the decarbonisation of gas as well. It is produced by adding
CO2 captured during the upgrading of biogas to biomethane, from industrial processes, or eventually
directly from the air to renewable or low carbon hydrogen.
Biomethane and synthetic methane injected at distribution level may face barriers preventing it from being
traded on the EU’s wholesale markets to the same degree as methane gas. Similar difficulties may be
encountered by hydrogen when blended into the existing gas grid.
[5] Biogas is about 60% methane, 40% CO2 + some impurities. Upgrading biogas to biomethane level requires removal of CO2 and
impurities. If used and, more importantly, stored the CO2 obtained in production of biomethane from biogas is sometimes argued to create
‘negative’ emissions
64. Which are in your view the main regulatory barriers to the deployment of
biomethane and synthetic methane?
500 character(s) maximum
Lack of joint quality requirements on the EU level. The quality requirements must take into account an
ambitious share of biomethane in the gas system.
65. Do you consider it important to adapt the Gas Directive and Gas Regulation to
facilitate injection biomethane and synthetic methane into the existing methane gas
grid?
Yes No
66. Do you consider it important to adapt the Gas Directive and Gas Regulation to
the needs of hydrogen to be injected into the existing gas grid?
Yes No
40
67. How do you rate the measures below? (one answer per question)
No Very Not very Not
Measure Important Neutral
opinion important important important
Adapt tasks and responsibilities of national regulatory authorities to oblige
them to facilitate the process of decarbonisation of gas when taking
decisions (e.g. as regards development of infrastructure).
Improve the coordination between transmission and distribution system
operators to facilitate the process of decarbonisation of gas.
Ensure access to the transmission level and to the EU’s wholesale market of
renewable and low-carbon gases produced at distribution level.
Integrate the distribution system operator level into the entry-exit system with
the same balancing regime that is applicable to the transmission system
operator.
Extending the model of energy communities of the Electricity Directive to the
gas market to consume volumes of biogas, biomethane or hydrogen not
injected to the interconnected grid.
Obliging operators to ensure connection for new renewable gases facilities i.
e. priority connection and dispatch.
Reducing network tariffs for injection of renewable gases to the grid.
Limit tariffs to efficient network operations, not supporting other policy
objectives.
Make the short term capacity products for methane pipeline and storage
infrastructure more attractive to better reflect the interdependency with
electricity and compatibility with the support schemes for renewable and low-
carbon gases.
Abolish special treatment of fossil methane long-term contracts e.g. abolish
derogations for take-or-pay clauses.
41
System operators should be obliged to explore the opportunities for
improving the energy efficiency of the system (i.e. eliminate leaks, recovering
energy from pressure drops between high, medium and low pressure grids,
optimise heat management including cold recovery from pressure decrease).
42
68. The current gas market model implies diverging access tariffs at the borders of Member States. As pointed out by
ACER “Cross-border tariffs tend to have a referential role over hub price spreads, although the role may vary per case. In
hub pairs, mainly in the Nord-West Europe area, day-ahead price spreads are regularly below daily transportation tariffs
and frequently also below yearly transportation tariffs (the latter being usually more economic)[6]”. For the sake of an
enhanced efficiency of gas markets into an integrated EU-wide internal market so as to facilitate the uptake of renewable
and low-carbon gases within the market, a re-design of the access tariff to be more compatible with market dynamics
could be introduced. This would lead to a full integration of gas markets and avoid price spreads across EU. It would
however bear the risk of redistribution of transportation tariff between Member States in accordance with inter-TSO
agreements and changes to end-user tariffs. Moreover, the re-designing of the short-term capacity products may avoid
capacity foreclosure/lock-in in favour of long-term (natural) gas trade to the detriment to the renewable and low carbon
gases. This may also help in aligning the capacity products of the future methane-based system with the electricity market
operating on the basis of short-term trading. This could be done even in absence of EU-wide common rules on e.g. the
overall rate of return, depreciation times or asset value for the gas grids, as these are set out at national level.
How do you rate the measures below to reach this enhanced level of design?
[6] see ACER’s Market Monitoring Report 2019, p.58)
No Very Not very Not
Measure Important Neutral
opinion important important important
Abolishing grid charges on intra-EU cross-border points, payable
price for capacity booking determined by auctions only (minimum
price fixed at variable costs only).
Charging the entry points from non-EU countries based on capacity
weighted distance to a virtual point in the middle of EU’s grid in
addition to some fees set according to market and security of supply
criteria
43
Collecting the remuneration of the EU’s network operators from
capacity auction revenues at extra-EU entry points, intra-EU entry
points for gas’ production and from exit points
Introducing an inter-TSO compensation mechanism to reconcile
revenues by keeping TSOs revenues neutral with the current
circumstances.
Setting up short-term capacity products
Harmonising allowed revenues parameters for TSOs (e.g. WACC,
depreciation time, valuation of assets)
EU level guidance for the regional integration of the gas market, including
gas market mergers
44
69. The measures under question 67 and 68 could be combined. How do you see
such a possibility?
500 character(s) maximum
70. The LNG market in Europe has significantly changed since the adoption of the
Third Energy Package setting the rules applicable to LNG terminals in the EU.
Additional LNG volumes imported to the EU, more short-term trade and an
increased number of LNG terminals in the EU change the way the terminals
operate. Market participants are calling for more transparency, flexibility of products
and access rules[7]. Provided that adaptations are made and that sustainable
renewable gases can be verified in third countries, LNG terminals can play a role in
importing renewable and low-carbon gases (i.e. liquid hydrogen, biomethane,
ammonia, synthetic-fuels). Gas storage facilities may also play an important role for
renewable and low-carbon gases either directly or after adaptations. Do you think
the existing regulatory framework for LNG needs to be modified? (multiple answers
possible)
[7] https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/efa4d335-a155-11ea-9d2d-01aa75ed71a1/language-en.
Yes, it needs to incentivise and promote the access of renewable and low-
carbon gases into the LNG terminals (i.e. synthetic methane, bioLNG, etc.)
Yes, it needs to be more harmonised in terms of transparency and access to
available capacities to improve the functioning of LNG market in the
Yes, it needs to be less prescriptive compared to the current framework,
allowing for negotiated access rules to LNG terminals
No, it strikes the right balance as it is
Other (pls allow for comments)
71. Do you think that LNG terminals will play an important role in the
decarbonisation of the gas sector?
Yes, the import of renewable and low-carbon gases via LNG terminals into
the EU will play an important role
No, LNG terminals cannot be used to import renewable and low-carbon
gases
45
72. Which renewable and low-carbon gases, in your view, can be imported via LNG
terminals?
100 character(s) maximum
73. How important do you consider the following measures to be to improve the
current regulatory framework for LNG terminals?
Not
No Very
Important Neutral very
opinion important
imortant
Require LNG terminals and other gas
depressurising sites to provide waste
heat/cold to nearby heat/cold
consumers
Introduction of measures coordinating
the adaptation of LNG terminals to
renewable and low-carbon gases e.g.
coordination of development plans,
market tests etc.
Removing of the tariff discount for
gaseous fuels entering the TSO grid
from LNG terminals, regardless of the
type of gas.
Introduction of stronger enforcement
rules preventing cross-subsidisation of
LNG terminals.
Introduction of an EU-wide information
platform that ensures transparency on
and comparability between terminal
service offerings, tariff levels, and
available capacities.
Facilitate more transparency in the
secondary trading of capacity.
Harmonise the congestion
management rules to improve
terminals’ usage.
Provide an option for Member States to
opt for “negotiated” access similar to
storage facilities.
74. Do you have any other view or ideas related to improve current regulatory
framework for LNG? Please specify.
46
500 character(s) maximum
75. Do you think the Gas Directive and Gas Regulation should be revised to
encourage and promote the role of storage for use of renewable and low-carbon
gases by introducing transparency measures such as coordination of development
plans, market tests?
Yes
No
76. The blending of hydrogen and other renewable or low carbon gases into the
existing methane gas grid requires a consideration of its contribution to the
decarbonisation of the energy system as well as its economic and technical
implications (see specific questions on technical implications in section on gas
quality). Please indicate the appropriateness of the statements below with regard to
blending
Completely Completely
Statement Agree Neutral Disagree
disagree agree
Blending provides a cost efficient
and fast first step to energy system
decarbonisation. It will facilitate the
offtake of hydrogen and other
renewable and low carbon gases
by using existing methane gas
infrastructure
Blending prevents the direct use of
pure hydrogen in applications
where its value in terms of GHG-
emission reductions is higher, such
as industry and transport.
Blending creates technical
constraints and additional costs at
injection and end-use appliances
which makes it a less cost-efficient
option for decarbonisation.
VI. Gas Quality
The variety of sources of gases transported through the EU’s methane gas networks [8] leads to a
corresponding variety of gas quality with different physical and chemical characteristics. These gas quality
characteristics are an essential consideration for the design of gas infrastructure and end-use appliances,
as well as for industrial processes using gas as feedstock, in order to ensure the safety and efficiency of
47
operation. To this end, gas quality standards have been developed. Member States have established their
own practices to control gas qualities at national level, adapted to their national context (e.g. quality of
gases historically consumed and appliances in use). In addition, the CEN standard on H-gas quality [9] is
currently the fundamental standard for the EU gas sector used in EU Member States. However, the CEN
standard is not applied in a coordinated[10] or binding manner and therefore, is not sufficient on its own to
provide for a harmonisation of gas quality standards across EU Member States. Differences in gas quality
can lead to problems for end users and have negative effects on cross-border trade.
The issue of gas quality is becoming more pressing with the effort to decarbonise the EU’s energy sector,
as this will require the injection of growing volumes of renewable and low-carbon gases into the existing
gas transmission and distribution networks. The quality parameters of gas consumed and transported in
Europe will change, leading to more frequent quality fluctuations to a much larger extent than is the case
today. This will affect the design of methane gas infrastructure and end-user applications, as well as
industrial processes using gases as feedstock. However, the existing regulatory framework was not
designed to cater for such developments[11].
[8] Currently mainly natural gas from different sources in and outside of the EU combined with a growing volume of renewable and low-
carbon gases produced in the EU.
[9] European Committee for Standardisation, EN 16726 “Gas infrastructure – quality of gas – group H”, OJEU, December 2015.
[10] Study: Potentials of sector coupling for decarbonisation: Assessing regulatory barriers in linking the gas and electricity sectors in the EU,
December 2019, https://ec.europa.eu/energy/studies/potentials-sector-coupling-decarbonisation-assessing-
regulatory-barriers_en; 6th CEER benchmarking report on the quality of electricity and gas supply, 2016.
[11] The Interoperability and Data Exchange Network Code is establishing a dispute resolution process in case of cross-border trade
restrictions due to gas quality differences; Commission Regulation (EU) 2015/703 of 30 April 2015 establishing a network code on
interoperability and data exchange rules, Article 15.
78. In your view, what is necessary to ensure efficient coordination on gas quality
between Member States?
The current cross-border coordination framework, is sufficient to deal with
problems due to gas quality differences in the energy transition.
Reinforced cross-border coordination tools (e.g. streamlined procedure, involving all impacted market.
participants, increased transparency).
Harmonised application of gas quality standards across the EU.
79. In your view, the harmonised application of the CEN standard across EU
Member States would be best achieved by:
Completely Completely
Agree Neutral Disagree
disagree agree
Increased transparency on the
application of the current standards
(e.g. on measured parameters, on
frequency of measurement, on
rules of information provision).
48
EU-wide harmonised rules on
information provision and
publication of CEN quality
parameters.
Harmonising the gas quality
standard across the EU based on
the CEN H-gas standard.
Harmonising the gas quality
standard across the EU based on a
standard taking fully into account
renewable and low-carbon gases,
developed by an independent
technical expert group.
80. The injection of hydrogen into the existing methane gas network (blending) is
currently explicitly accepted only in a few Member States and only possible at very
low concentration levels. Similarly, hydrogen blending limits at cross-border
interconnection points are applied only in a few Member States. In your view, what
would be necessary to avoid or limit potential negative effects of hydrogen blending
into the existing methane gas network from the perspective of end-users and
infrastructure operators (e.g. for safety, production efficiency, product quality,
emissions, etc.)?
Not to blend hydrogen into the current methane gas network.
Develop robust gas quality standards (e.g. CEN, national) allowing for the
injection of renewable and low-carbon gases (including hydrogen) into the
existing methane gas network.
Establish EU wide harmonised quality specification at the transmission level,
including at cross-border interconnection points, allowing for the injection of
renewable and low-carbon gases (including hydrogen) into the existing
methane gas network.
81. Clearly defined allowed blending levels at the EU or national level (e.g.
minimum and/or maximum level of hydrogen in % by volume to be accepted in the
network) could provide certainty for producers, infrastructure and appliance
manufacturers and end-users. Applied at cross-border interconnection points, such
blending levels would enable the unhindered flow of blended gases across Member
States. In your view, should allowed hydrogen blending levels be introduced, and if
yes in what form?
Not at all.
National hydrogen blending levels set by Member States.
49
National hydrogen blending levels set by Member States in a standardised
and transparent way, based on EU rules.
Harmonised EU-wide hydrogen acceptance level for hydrogen blends, which
TSOs have to accept at cross-border interconnection points (minimum and
/or maximum level of hydrogen in % by volume).
82. Do you consider that rules on roles and responsibilities on gas quality
management, including e.g. on cost allocation, dispute resolution and regulatory
oversight, should be defined, and if yes in what form?
Not necessary to define such rules.
At Member State level (i.e. maintaining potential differences of the regulatory
framework across Member States).
By establishing EU-level principles providing for a common approach in the
Member States.
By setting EU-level rules ensuring a harmonised regulatory framework
across the EU.
83. Do you see changes to the roles, tasks and liabilities of market participants with
regard to gas quality monitoring, measurement and management?
Type of market participant No Yes
Gas producers, including producers of renewable and low-carbon gases
Transmission System Operators
Distribution System Operators
Consumers
Gas appliance manufacturers
Service providers
Others (please specify)
Please specify what these changes would entail (gas producers)
100 character(s) maximum
Please specify what these changes would entail (TSOs)
100 character(s) maximum
50
Please specify what these changes would entail (DSOs)
100 character(s) maximum
Please specify what these changes would entail (consumers)
100 character(s) maximum
Please specify what these changes would entail (gas appliance manufacturers)
100 character(s) maximum
Please specify what these changes would entail (service providers)
100 character(s) maximum
Please specify what these changes would entail (others)
100 character(s) maximum
84. In your view, at what point in the gas value chain should the quality of gases
be adapted to the standard specifications, considering also technical feasibility and
cost-effectivity?
At gas production/injection points by the producer (i.e. before injection into
the gas system, e.g. with adequate quality contracts).
In the transmission and/or distribution system by the system operator.
At the exit point by end-users.
At the exit point to end-users by a third party service provider.
85. While handling varying qualities and more frequent quality fluctuations of the
different renewable and low-carbon gases, gas quality management should remain
cost-effective in the coming years and decades. Cost effective quality management
requires sufficient transparency and information sharing. Do you consider that
providing improved visibility on gas quality and transparency on the cost of gas
quality measurement, monitoring and handling is needed?
Yes
No
51
86. The current regulatory framework[12] includes some requirements on TSOs to
share information on gas quality. In order to enable market participants to deal with
different gas qualities and potentially with quality fluctuations, it might be however
necessary to further develop the visibility on gas quality for market participants.
Please indicate the importance of the measures below.
[12] Commission Regulation (EU) 2015/703 of 30 April 2015 establishing a network code on interoperability and data exchange rules (Articles
7, 16, 17 and 18).
Not Very Not very
Measure Important Neutral
important important important
The current regulatory framework is
sufficient to ensure adequate
transparency on gas quality
(Interoperability and Data
Exchange Network Code).
Provide improved visibility on gas
quality (actual and forecast) to
market participants.
Extend the group of market
participants receiving gas quality
information (e.g. to include
producers, all end-users, appliance
manufacturers).
Ensure transparency on the roles,
responsibilities and liabilities for
gas quality management.
Provide for transparency on the
costs of gas quality management
(incl. measurement, monitoring and
handling).
Include gas quality aspects into the
coordinated network planning
(national and EU-wide).
87. The potential changes to the regulatory framework and the changing role of
market participants in gas quality management requires revisiting the question of
proper regulatory oversight. However, harmonised rules on the role of National
Regulatory Authorities (NRAs) for gas quality issues is currently missing. While
NRAs have a role in dispute resolution in case of cross-border trade restrictions
due to gas quality differences[13], most of them are not involved in setting gas
52
quality standards or in monitoring gas quality parameters. Do you consider it
necessary to reinforce the roles and responsibilities of NRAs in a harmonised way
to ensure proper regulatory oversight of the revised gas quality regulatory
framework?
[13] Commission Regulation (EU) 2015/703 of 30 April 2015 establishing a network code on interoperability and data exchange rules, Article
15.
Yes
No
88. Do you see any other issues related to improving the regulatory framework on
gas quality management you would like to raise? Please explain.
500 character(s) maximum
VII. Alignment of institutional rules for gaseous fuels to the Clean Energy
Package
EU electricity and gas market rules have been developed in parallel over the last 20 years and no
distinction was made so far as concerns regulatory oversight over gas and electricity markets. Sector
integration, i.e. more integrated EU electricity and gas markets may even require more aligned rules.
The revision of the Electricity Directive and Electricity Regulation adopted in 2019 (Directive (EU) 2019/944
on common rules for the internal market for electricity and Regulation (EU) 2019/943 on the internal market
for electricity) reinforced the institutional framework to make it fit-for-purpose for the changes in the
electricity sector (integration of renewables, decentralised electricity production, regionalisation, etc.).
However, this creates differences in the institutional set-up between the electricity and gas sectors, which
might lead to detrimental regulatory divergence and unnecessary complexity that could affect consumers,
industry and regulators alike.
The revision of the gas legislation would envisage to align the provisions on the institutional framework for
the gas sector to those already adopted for electricity, as this would also help implementing the sector
integration principle. Updating the institutional framework for gas appears also necessary to make the EU
gas sector fit for decarbonisation.
89. In your view, to ensure the consistency of the regulatory framework, in which
areas is it important to align the institutional provisions of the electricity and gas
sectors?
Align gas legislation
Gas market
to the rules in the
specificities
require a
Area of alignment to the electricity institutional framework
53
different set Clean Energy
of rules for Package (electricity
gas legislation)
Adapting ENTSOG’s mission, tasks and the rules governing
its transparency and oversight by the Agency for the
Cooperation for Energy Regulators (Electricity Regulation,
Articles 28-31).
Adapt the role of ACER to oversee the effective functioning of
the integrated markets and cross-border infrastructure (ACER
Regulation, Article 4).
Aligning the process for developing detailed regulatory rules
on the operation of the market and networks (i.e. network
codes and guidelines, Electricity Regulation, Articles 58-60
and ACER Regulation, Article 5).
Aligning the provisions reflecting the increasing link between
the distribution and transmission network levels in the
regulatory framework (e.g. requirements for cooperation on
network planning; Electricity Regulation, Article 57).
90. The revision of the Electricity Market Design formalised the role of Distribution
System Operators (DSOs) at European level by creating a single European DSO
entity, rendering their participation effective and independent (Electricity
Regulation, Articles 52-55). The aim was to facilitate distributed resources to
participate in the market by – among others – enabling DSOs to become more
active at European level and have increased responsibilities and tasks (similar to
those of the TSOs). In your view, what would be required to ensure the EU-level
representation of gas DSOs?
There is no need to establish a DSO entity for gases.
It is necessary to establish a separate DSO entity for gases.
It is necessary to establish a “department” for gases under the existing
electricity DSO entity with all rules from electricity applying.
It is necessary to establish a “department” for gases under the existing
electricity DSO entity with some specific rules applicable to gas DSOs.
91. Do you see any other issues related to the alignment of the gas institutional
provisions to the Clean Energy Package provisions? Please explain.
300 character(s) maximum
VIII. Security of supply dimensions
54
With the adoption of the Security of Gas Supply Regulation[14], the framework for the security of gas supply
in the EU has developed significantly over the past years. Other EU initiatives such as the protection of
critical energy infrastructure and cybersecurity were added to the energy security and safety framework.
The revision of the Gas Directive and the Gas Regulation needs to take into account this evolution. At the
same time, the upcoming revision and the clean energy transition might imply amendments to these other
pieces of EU acquis applicable in the sector of gases.
[14] Regulation (EU) 2017/1938 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2017 concerning measures to safeguard the
security of gas supply and repealing Regulation (EU) No 994/2010, OJ L 280, 28.10.2017.
92. How do you see the security of supply challenge in the context of the
decarbonisation of the supply of gases in the EU in line with the climate-neutrality
objectives?
Security of supply will not be an issue when renewable and low-carbon
gases will be used in the EU.
Security of gas supply will still be an important challenge that needs to be
taken into account in the context of increased use of renewable and low-
carbon gases in the EU.
New security issues should be taken into account.
93. In case you consider that new security issues should be taken into account
please explain which
500 character(s) maximum
94. Do you think that changes are needed to guarantee consistency between the
Gas Directive and the Security of Gas Supply Regulation:
Not Very Not very
Area of alignment Important Neutral
important important important
Definitions, in general
Definition of “protected customers”,
in particular
Clarify the conditions under which
PSOs on security of gas supply
grounds may be justified
Solidarity mechanism
Safeguard measures
55
95. Do you see room for harmonising other elements, in addition to those listed
under 94?
Yes
No
* Please specify what these changes would entail
500 character(s) maximum
no other elements have to be adressed
96. The scope of the Security of Gas Supply Regulation is currently limited to
guaranteeing the provision of “methane gas”. Do you think that the rules on security
of gas supply need to be amended ?
Yes, the SoS Regulation should be amended as soon as possible.
Yes, the SoS Regulation should be amended, based on the experience of
the application of the new gas market rules.
No, the SoS Regulation is fit for purpose (guaranteeing the methane gas
supply, based on existing gas corridors).
No, the provisions of the SoS Regulation are flexible enough and already
allow to take into consideration the expected adaptation of the market to the
needs of renewable and low carbon gases.
* Please explain (mandatory field)
500 character(s) maximum
new green gases on the market might call for the need to review the SoS regulation from the lockal
production side of view.
97. The increasing digitalisation of energy technologies and networks makes the
energy system smarter and enables consumers to benefit from innovative energy
services. At the same time, digitalisation creates significant risks as an increased
exposure to cyberattacks and cybersecurity incidents potentially jeopardise the
security of energy supply and the privacy of consumer data. Cybersecurity and
challenges related to it are evolving at a rapid pace, which is why the European
Commission has taken a series of measures to tackle it[15]. Taking into account the
specific challenges in the energy sector[16], the Commission adopted a dedicated
recommendation on cybersecurity in the energy sector in April 2019. Further, the
recent Clean Energy for all Europeans Package[17] introduced the possibility to
develop cybersecurity rules for electricity.
56
Do you consider that developments in the gas sector also require establishing
cybersecurity rules for gas?
(only one answer possible)
[15] At horizontal cross-sectoral level, the Commission adopted a package on cybersecurity and critical infrastructure on December 2020,
including a revised NIS Directive (Cybersecurity, COM(2020) 823 final), a revised Cybersecurity Strategy (JOIN(2020) 18 final) as well as a
new proposal for a Directive on the resilience of Critical Entities (COM(2020) 829 final).
[16] E.g. real-time requirements, cascading effects and the mix of legacy technologies with smart/state of the art technology.
[17] Further information on cybersecurity measures: https://ec.europa.eu/energy/topics/energy-security/critical-infrastructure-and-
cybersecurity_en?redir=1
There is no need to develop cybersecurity measures for the gas sector.
It is necessary to establish EU-level legislation for cybersecurity specifically
for the gas sector.
It is necessary to establish a comprehensive EU-level legislative framework
for cybersecurity for the energy sector (covering the electricity, gas,
hydrogen and heating sectors).
98. Do you think that energy-specific measures should be introduced to improve
the resilience of critical gas infrastructure, including renewable and low-carbon
gases?
Yes
No
* Please explain (mandatory field)
500 character(s) maximum
There is no need for further measures to be introduced in this aspect.
UPLOADING DOCUMENT IF NEEDED (possible in case the questions do not
cover all issues the respondent would like to rise)
Only files of the type pdf,txt,doc,docx,odt,rtf are allowed
Contact
57
Contact Form
58
Riigikantselei Teie 09.04.2021 nr 16.1.1/21-0551/-1T
[email protected]
Stenbocki maja Rahukohtu 3 Meie 14.05.2021 nr 2-13/21-2313
15161, Tallinn
Eesti seisukohad Euroopa Komisjoni avalikule
konsultatsioonile gaasiturgu ja -võrke
käsitlevate Euroopa Liidu eeskirjade
läbivaatamise kohta
Esitame 20. mai 2021. a Vabariigi Valitsuse istungile Eesti seisukohad Euroopa Komisjoni
avalikule konsultatsioonile gaasiturgu ja -võrke käsitlevate Euroopa Liidu eeskirjade
läbivaatamise kohta.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Taavi Aas
majandus- ja taristuminister
Lisad:
Vabariigi Valituse protokollilise otsuse eelnõu
Seletuskiri
Lisa 1. Gaasivõrkude eeskirjade läbivaatamise küsimustik
Lisa 2. Kaasatud huvigruppide nimekiri
Lisa 3. Kaasamise tabel
Kadi Avingo
625 6491
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
EELNÕU
.......
VABARIIGI VALITSUS
ISTUNGI PROTOKOLL
Tallinn, Stenbocki maja …………… 2021 nr
Eesti seisukohad Euroopa Komisjoni avalikule konsultatsioonile gaasiturgu ja -võrke
käsitlevate Euroopa Liidu eeskirjade läbivaatamise kohta
1. Kiita heaks järgmised majandus- ja taristuministri esitatud Eesti seisukohad Euroopa
Komisjoni avalikule konsultatsioonile gaasiturgu ja -võrke käsitlevate Euroopa Liidu
eeskirjade läbivaatamise kohta:
1.1. Eesti toetab gaasidirektiivi ja gaasimääruse muutmist viisil, mis soodustab ühiste
reeglitega regionaalsete gaasiturgude teket ja toimimist Euroopa Liidus, mis aitaks
kaasa ELi ühtse gaasituru tekkele. Pooldame täiendavate regulatsioonide kehtestamist
taastuvgaaside konkurentsivõimeliseks integreerimiseks gaasiturul. Muudatuste
tegemisel on oluline keskenduda Euroopa Liidu sisesele taastuvgaaside tootmisele nii
ülekandesüsteemi, kohalike jaotusvõrkude kui ka kohapealse tarbimise tasandil
vähendamaks importsõltuvust ning parandamaks energiasüsteemide varustuskindlust.
Taastuvgaaside kasutuselevõttu peavad liikmesriigid saama panustada vastavalt oma
võimetele, mistõttu Eesti ei pea vajalikuks seada liikmesriikidele kohustust saavutada
gaasisüsteemis taastuvgaaside tarbimises kindlat osakaalu.
1.2. Gaasiseadusandlus peab käsitlema gaasisüsteemi digitaliseerimist, gaasisüsteemi
arengu planeerimisel peab lähtuma energiasüsteemide integreerimise potentsiaalist ja
selle rakendamisest. Gaasi ja elektrituru regulatsioon peab olema võimalikult sarnane,
s.h tagama, et gaasisüsteemi võrguettevõtja ei tohi samaaegselt tegeleda taastuvgaasi
tootmise või salvestamisega.
1.3. Eesti pooldab süsinikuvaba vesiniku kasutuselevõtu soodustamiseks gaasisüsteemi
kõrvale üle-euroopalise vesinikutaristu loomist nii vesinikutrasside, mahutite kui
terminalide näol, kasutades seejuures taristu rajamisel võimalikult suures ulatuses
olemasolevat gaasitaristut. Vesinikutaristu halduril peavad olema sarnased kohustused
ja õigused nagu maagaasi süsteemihalduril ning taristu kasutamisel peaks piiriüleste
tariifide asemel kasutama kogu taristut hõlmavat ühist sisend- ja väljundhinnasüsteemi.
1.4. Võrgugaasil peab olema ühtne kvaliteedinorm üle Euroopa Liidu, mis võtab arvesse ka
taastuvgaaside mõju gaasisüsteemile. Gaasituru dekarboniseerimise tagamiseks on
oluline sätestada ühised nõuded gaasisüsteemi tehnilistele parameetritele, mille
täitmine võimaldab gaasisüsteemis taastuvgaasi tehniliste raskusteta transportida.
2. Eesti esindajatel Euroopa Liidu Nõukogu erinevatel tasanditel väljendada ülaltoodud
seisukohti.
3. Riigikantseleil esitada punktis 1 nimetatud eelnõu ja seisukohad Riigikogu juhatusele ning
teha seisukohad teatavaks Eestist valitud Euroopa Parlamendi liikmetele ning Eestist
nimetatud Majandus- ja Sotsiaalkomitee ja Regioonide Komitee liikmetele.
Kaja Kallas Taimar Peterkop
Peaminister Riigisekretär
SELETUSKIRI
Eesti seisukohad Euroopa Komisjoni avalikule konsultatsioonile gaasiturgu ja -võrke
käsitlevate Euroopa Liidu eeskirjade läbivaatamise kohta
Ülevaade ja eesmärk
2019. aasta lõpus esitas Euroopa Komisjon (edaspidi komisjon) teatise Euroopa roheline
kokkulepe1, milles on määratletud Euroopa Liidu (edaspidi EL) eesmärk saavutada
ressursitõhusa ja konkurentsivõimelise majandusega Euroopa ühiskond, kus aastaks 2050 on
saavutatud kliimaneutraalsus ja ressursside jätkusuutlik kasutus ning tagatud piisav
majanduskasv. 2020. a septembris avaldas komisjon 2030. aasta kliimaeesmärgi kava teatise2,
milles tegi ettepaneku sätestada uus 2030. aasta eesmärk vähendada kasvuhoonegaaside
(edaspidi KHG) netoheidet võrreldes 1990. aasta tasemega vähemalt 55% võrra, et saavutada
2050. aastaks ELis kliimaneutraalsus tasakaalustatud, õiglasel, realistlikul ja mõistlikul viisil.
See uus eesmärk kiideti ELi liikmesriikide riigipeade ja valitsusjuhtide poolt heaks 10.-11.
detsembril 2020. a toimunud Euroopa Ülemkogu kohtumisel.
Energia tootmine ja kasutamine kõigis majandussektorites põhjustab üle 75% ELi KHG heitest.
Energiasüsteemi süsinikuheite edasine vähendamine on seega võtmetähtsusega 2030. ja 2050.
aasta eesmärkide saavutamisel. 2020. a juulis avaldatud energiasüsteemi integreerimise
strateegias3 ja vesinikustrateegias4 tõi komisjon esile vajaduse vaadata läbi EL gaasiturgu
reguleeriv õigusraamistik, et hõlbustada taastuvallikatest toodetud gaaside kasutuselevõttu ja
suurendada tarbijate mõjuvõimu, tagades ELis samal ajal lõimitud, likviidne ja
koostalitlusvõimeline gaasisiseturg. Komisjon peab õigusraamistiku muutmist vajalikuks
gaasisektori kulutõhusa dekarboniseerimise võimaldamiseks, et soodustada taastuvatest
energiaallikatest toodetud ja vähese CO2-heitega gaaside (sh vesiniku) turuletoomist ning
hõlbustada nende juhtimist, edastamist, jaotamist ja nendega kauplemist olemasolevas
gaasivõrgus laiemas energiasüsteemi integreerimise kontekstis. Samuti leiab komisjon, et
tuleks ka kaaluda taastuvallikatest toodetud gaaside hajutatud tootmise ühendamist taristuga ja
turulepääsu, muu hulgas jaotustasandil, mis täiendaks taastuvallikatest toodetud gaaside
kasutamist suurema kohaliku mõõtmega ringmajanduse kontekstis (nt põllumajandusettevõttes
kasutatav biogaas). Kui taastuvallikatest toodetud gaasid suunataks gaasivõrku ja tarneallikad
oleksid mitmekesisemad, muutuksid ELis tarbitava ja siia transporditava gaasi kvaliteedi
näitajad. Selleks, et see ei viiks turu killustumise ja kaubanduspiiranguteni, tuleb uurida, kuidas
tagada gaasisüsteemide koostalitlus ja takistamatu gaasivoog üle liikmesriikide piiride.
Sellest tulenevalt on komisjon algatanud gaasidirektiivi 2009/73/EÜ5 ja gaasimääruse (EÜ) nr
715/20096 läbivaatamise ja muutmise. Gaasidirektiiv ja -määrus võeti vastu osana ELi
kolmandast energiapaketist, mis jõustus 2009. aasta septembris. Gaasidirektiivis kehtestati
1
Euroopa roheline kokkulepe COM(2019) 640
2
Euroopa 2030. aasta kliimaeesmärgi suurendamine: investeerimine kliimaneutraalsesse tulevikku meie inimeste
hüvanguks COM(2020) 562 final
3
Kliimaneutraalse majanduse saavutamine – integreeritud energiasüsteem kliimaneutraalsuse nimel
(COM(2020) 299)
4
Kliimaneutraalse Euroopa vesinikustrateegia COM/2020/301 final
5
Euroopa Parlamendi ja nõukogu direktiiv 2009/73/EÜ, 13. juuli 2009 , mis käsitleb maagaasi siseturu
ühiseeskirju ning millega tunnistatakse kehtetuks direktiiv 2003/55/EÜ
6
Euroopa Parlamendi ja nõukogu määrus (EÜ) nr 715/2009, 13. juuli 2009, maagaasi ülekandevõrkudele
juurdepääsu tingimuste kohta ning millega tunnistatakse kehtetuks määrus (EÜ) nr 1775/2005
ühised reeglid gaasi ülekandmiseks, jaotamiseks, tarnimiseks, hoiustamiseks ja turule
ligipääsemiseks. Gaasimäärusega kehtestati gaasivõrkudele juurdepääsu käsitlevad õiglased ja
mittediskrimineerivad eeskirjad piiriüleses kaubanduses, mis nägi ette ka erinevates
valdkondades detailsete võrgueeskirjade loomise.
Gaasitarbimine Eestis on langustrendis ja viimase kümnendi jooksul on maagaasi tarbimine
vähenenud ligikaudu kolmandiku võrra, gaas moodustab energiabilansis ca 6%. Tarbimine on
langenud nii soojuse tootmises, elektrienergia tootmises, tööstussektoris nii soojuseks kui ka
tooraineks kasutamises. Ülekaalukalt kõige rohkem kasutatakse maagaasi Eestis soojuse
tootmiseks nii kaugküttes kui lokaalses tootmises. Aastast 2008 on näha gaasitarbimise languse
trendi soojuse tootmiseks. Languse peamiseks põhjuseks on energiasäästumeetmete
rakendamine kaugküttepiirkondades ning üleminek kohalikele kütustele (puiduhake ja turvas),
aga ka vähese konkurentsi tõttu toimunud maagaasi hinna kasv. Kasvutrendi on olnud näha ja
oodatakse maagaasi tarbimises transpordisektoris.7 See on seotud ELi eesmärgiga katta 10%
transpordisektori energiatarbest taastuvenergiaga, kus Eestis nähakse suurt rolli biometaani
kasutamisel. 2020. aastal toodeti ja tarbiti transpordisektoris Eestis biometaani 97,4 GWh8.
Aastaks 2030 on riik võtnud eesmärgiks suurendada biometaani tootmismahte 380 GWh-ni
aastas.9 Lisaks oodatakse väiksemat tarbimise kasvutrendi kodumajapidamistes ning äri ja
avaliku teeninduse sektoris.
Joonis 1. Aastase gaasitarbimise statistika ja prognoos kuni aastani 2029 (Allikas: Elering AS)
Käesoleva konsultatsiooniga soovib komisjon koguda sidusrühmade arvamusi selle kohta,
kuidas tuleks gaasidirektiivi ja -määrust muuta. Avaliku konsultatsiooni küsimustik on
kättesaadav leheküljelt https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-
say/initiatives/12911-Revision-of-EU-rules-on-Gas/public-consultation (vastamise tähtaeg
18.06.2021). Vastused küsimustikule on lisatud seletuskirjale eraldi failina (Lisa 1). Täpsemad
7
Eesti gaasiülekandevõrgu arengukava 2020-2029, kättesaadav https://elering.ee/sites/default/files/2020-
02/Eesti%20gaasi%C3%BClekandev%C3%B5rgu%20arengukava%202020-2029.pdf
8
Elering AS https://elering.ee/biometaani-paritolutunnistused-ja-statistika
9
Eesti riiklik energia- ja kliimakava aastani 2030, kättesaadav
https://www.mkm.ee/sites/default/files/teatis_eesti_riiklik_energia-_ja_kliimakava_aastani_2030.pdf
Eesti seisukohad konkreetse algatuse kohta koostatakse pärast vastava eelnõu avaldamist 2021.
aasta neljandas kvartalis.
Koostajad
Seletuskirja koostasid Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumi energeetikaosakonna
energiaturgude valdkonnajuht Rein Vaks (
[email protected]), taastuvenergia valdkonnajuht
Liisa Mällo (
[email protected]) ning EL ja rahvusvahelise koostöö osakonna nõunik Kadi
Avingo (
[email protected]). Valdkonna eest vastutab Majandus- ja
Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumi energeetika ja maavarade asekantsler Timo Tatar
(
[email protected]).
Eesti seisukohad ja nende põhjendused
1. Eesti toetab gaasidirektiivi ja gaasimääruse muutmist viisil, mis soodustab ühiste
reeglitega regionaalsete gaasiturgude teket ja toimimist Euroopa Liidus, mis aitaks
kaasa ELi ühtse gaasituru tekkele. Pooldame täiendavate regulatsioonide
kehtestamist taastuvgaaside konkurentsivõimeliseks integreerimiseks gaasiturul.
Muudatuste tegemisel on oluline keskenduda Euroopa Liidu sisesele taastuvgaaside
tootmisele nii ülekandesüsteemi, kohalike jaotusvõrkude kui ka kohapealse tarbimise
tasandil vähendamaks importsõltuvust ning parandamaks energiasüsteemide
varustuskindlust. Taastuvgaaside kasutuselevõttu peavad liikmesriigid saama
panustada vastavalt oma võimetele, mistõttu Eesti ei pea vajalikuks seada
liikmesriikidele kohustust saavutada gaasisüsteemis taastuvgaaside tarbimises kindlat
osakaalu.
Selgitus: Euroopa Liidu siseselt on hulgaliselt killustatud gaasiturge, mis takistab tõhusal
konkurentsil tekkimast. Lisaks on siseturul hulgaliselt liikmesriike, kus ei ole gaasiturg
liberaliseeritud ning kus kehtivad teatud tarbijagruppidele endiselt reguleeritud hinnad (nt
Leedu gaasiturul on kodutarbijatel jätkuvalt reguleeritud lõpphinnad). Selline turumudel ei aita
kaasa gaasituru arenemisele ega taastuvgaaside kasutuselevõtule. Eesti, Läti ja Soome on
aastast 2020 kujundanud välja ühiste reeglitega gaasituru, mille raames on lahendatud nii
bilansi tagamise, kolmanda osapoole võrku ühendamise jms reeglid kui ka loodud ühine
tariifitsoon. Gaasipakett peab motiveerima selliste ühisreeglitega turgude teket, ideaalis võiks
taoliselt toimida kogu liidu gaasiturg. See võimaldab suurendada ka kohaliku gaasitootmise
konkurentsi naaberriikides ning aitab kaasa taastuvgaaside turu arendamisele. Siiski ei tohiks
gaasipaketi muutmisega seada liikmesriikidele kohustust saavutada gaasisüsteemis
taastuvgaaside tarbimises teatud osakaalu. Iga liikmesriik peab oma võimete järgi leidma
parimad viisid süsinikneutraalse energiamajanduse suunas liikumiseks.
Euroopa Liit sõltub energiasüsteemide dekarboniseerimise teel järjest enam gaaskütustest.
Tuumajaamade ja fossiilkütustel töötavate tootmisseadmete sulgemine toob kaasa maagaasi kui
üleminekukütuse kasutuse suurenemise. Enamus kasutatavast gaasist imporditakse,
suurendades seeläbi liidu impordisõltuvust gaasilistest kütustest. Euroopa Liidu siseselt
toodetud taastuvgaaside turule toomine vähendab impordisõltuvust ning kasvatab Euroopa
Liidu sisemajandust ning toetab kasvuhoonegaaside (KHG) heidete vähendamist jäätme- ja
põllumajandussektoris. Siiski on taastuvgaaside tootmine kapitalimahukas ning ei konkureeri
seetõttu veel edukalt maagaasiga. Seetõttu tuleb kaaluda taastuvgaaside konkurentsipositsiooni
parandamiseks näiteks taastuvgaasi võrgule ligipääsu parendamist võrgu sisendtariifile
täiemahulise soodustuse tegemise kaudu. Taastuvgaaside tootmine on olemuselt hajutatud, mis
suurendab riikide ja Euroopa Liidu gaasisüsteemide varustuskindlust. Seejuures ei peaks
piirama toodetud taastuvgaasi sisestuskohta gaasisüsteemi – taastuvgaasi peab saama sisestada
nii ülekandesüsteemi, kohalikku jaotusvõrku või tarbida seda kohapeal. Mõlemal juhul on
taastuvgaaside tootmisel ja kasutamisel positiivne mõju gaasi varustuskindlusele.
2. Gaasiseadusandlus peab käsitlema gaasisüsteemi digitaliseerimist, gaasisüsteemi
arengu planeerimisel peab lähtuma energiasüsteemide integreerimise potentsiaalist ja
selle rakendamisest. Gaasi ja elektrituru regulatsioon peab olema võimalikult
sarnane, s.h tagama, et gaasisüsteemi võrguettevõtja ei tohi samaaegselt tegeleda
taastuvgaasi tootmise või salvestamisega.
Selgitus: Digitaliseeritud energiasüsteem on paindliku turukorralduse ja energiaturgude
integreerituse alus. Kaugloetavad arvestid tootmises ja tarbimises tagavad võimaluse kaasata
tootjaid ja tarbijaid kõigist energiaturgudest ning on oluline eeldus energiasüsteemide
integreerituse loomiseks. Lisaks võimaldab gaasisüsteemi digitaliseerimine tarbijatel osaleda
tõhusalt tarbimise juhtimises.
Energiasüsteemid on omavahel järjest rohkem põimumas. Gaasisüsteemi saab kasutada edukalt
näiteks elektrisüsteemi salvestuselemendina (elektrienergia salvestus taastuvgaasidesse),
gaasisüsteemi salvestatud energiat saab omakorda kasutada soojuse ja jahutuse tootmisel jne.
Taastuvenergia tootmine elektriturul on sõltuv ilmastikuoludest, mistõttu ei pruugi alati
tootmine olla tasakaalus tarbimisega. Siinkohal on igasugune salvestusmeetod teretulnud
abivahend turgude paremaks toimimiseks, gaasi tootmine elektrienergiast ajal, mil
elektrienergia tootmist on turul rohkem kui tarbimist, tagab hea sümbioosi elektri- ja gaasiturul.
Tarbijad kasutavad sõltuvalt oma tarbijapaigaldistest lõpptarbijatena ennekõike energiat.
Seejuures ei ole tarbijate lõikes oluline, kas majapidamises või tööstuses kasutatav energia
saadakse gaasist, elektrienergiast või soojusest. Seetõttu on enamus jae- ja hulgituru tarnijaid
keskendunud korraga nii elektri- kui gaasitarnetele. Ühelaadne regulatsioon gaasi- ja
elektriturul tagab tarnijatele ja ka tarbijatele lihtsuse ja suurendab seeläbi ka konkurentsi nii jae-
kui hulgiturul. Ühtlasi peab tulevane gaasipaketi regulatsioon tagama, et jaotusvõrguettevõtjad
oleksid sarnaselt elektripaketile sõltumatud energia tootmisest (nt elektriturul ei tohi
jaotusvõrguettevõtja tegeleda elektrienergia tootmise või salvestusseadmete haldamisega).
Energiaturgude integreerumise vaatest on oluline, et gaasisüsteemi arengu planeerimine käib
käsikäes elektrisüsteemi (s.h jaotusvõrkude) ning kaugkütte ja -jahutuse planeerimisega. See
tagab, et erinevad energiakandjad ja kütused konkureerivad.
Taastuvgaaside, s.h biometaani ja vesiniku arendamine peab toimuma võimalikult turupõhiselt
ning eeldab gaasi tootmisest sõltumatut võrguettevõtjat. Vertikaalselt integreeritud ettevõtjate
mudelid peaks pigem jääma erandiks ning olema põhjendatud vaid äärmuslikel juhtudel.
Jaotusvõrkude ja süsteemihaldurite neutraalsus gaasisüsteemi integreeritud taastuvgaaside
tootjate omandisuhtes peab tagama, et taastuvgaaside tootjatel on tõhus koostöö neutraalsete
võrguettevõtjatega. Sarnane põhimõte kehtib ka elektriturul, kus näiteks jaotusvõrguettevõtja
ei tohi omada, käitada ja hallata elektrienergia salvestuse seadmeid või elektriautode
laadimistaristut. Selleks, et vabaturul toimuks võimalikult tõhus konkurents taastuvgaaside
tootmisel (s.h. elektrolüüserite abil vesiniku tootmine) või salvestamisel (gaasi salvestus
mahutites), ei tohi võrgu arengu eest vastutav võrguettevõtja tegeleda samaaegselt ka gaasi
tootmise või salvestusega. Vastasel korral oleks keeruline tagada läbipaistvat ja kõigile
turuosalistele võrdset turukeskkonda, mis võib omakorda pärssida konkurentsi ja tarbijatele
pakutava gaasiteenuse kulutõhusust.
3. Eesti pooldab süsinikuvaba vesiniku kasutuselevõtu soodustamiseks gaasisüsteemi
kõrvale üle-euroopalise vesinikutaristu loomist nii vesinikutrasside, mahutite kui
terminalide näol, kasutades seejuures taristu rajamisel võimalikult suures ulatuses
olemasolevat gaasitaristut. Vesinikutaristu halduril peavad olema sarnased
kohustused ja õigused nagu maagaasi süsteemihalduril ning taristu kasutamisel peaks
piiriüleste tariifide asemel kasutama kogu taristut hõlmavat ühist sisend- ja
väljundhinnasüsteemi.
Selgitus: Gaasisüsteemis ei ole mõistlik maagaasi ja rohelist vesinikku omavahel segada.
Esiteks ei saa gaasi lõpptarbijad suure vesinikusisaldusega gaasi tarbida, see ei sobi
tarbijapaigaldiste tänase spetsifikatsiooniga. Teiseks on vesiniku tootmine suhteliselt kallis,
selle segamine maagaasiga ei ole majanduslikult mõistlik. Vesiniku tootmine on olemuselt
energia salvestamine. Kõige tõhusam on kasutada vesinikku puhtal kujul konkreetselt selles
sektoris, mis on vesiniku kasutusele sellel alal spetsialiseerunud, kus see on kulutõhus ning kus
muid taastuvenergia allikaid kasutada ei saa või ei ole mõistilk. Selle tagamiseks on vajalik
arendada välja eraldi vesinikutaristu, mille ülesandeks on transportida vesiniku selle tootmise
kohast tarbimise juurde. Näiteks edukalt on võimalik toota vesinikku taastuvelektri
tootmisseadmete juures (avameretuuleparkides), sisestada toodetud vesinik vesinikutaristusse
ning transportida vesinik tarbijani läbi gaasitorustiku või veeldada vesinik ning tarnida see läbi
vastava terminali lõpptarbijani. Siiski tuleb pidada silmas, et pikemas perspektiivis on vajalik
lähtuda ainult rohelise või teatud tingimustel süsinikuvaba (nt tuumaenergia baasil toodetud)
vesiniku tootmisest ja tarbimisest – kivisöest või maagaasist toodetud vesiniku kasutuses ei ole
kliimaambitsioone silmas pidades kasu. Tagamaks, et vesinikutaristu funktsioneeriks
sõltumatult, aitaks kaasa vesinikuturu funktsioneerimisele ja uute tootmisseadmete turule
tulemisele, peab vesinikutaristu haldurile kehtima samasugune regulatsioon nagu täna kehtib
direktiivi 2009/73/EÜ10 kohaselt süsteemihaldurile (nt kolmanda osapoole ligipääsukohustus,
tariifi kooskõlastamise kohustus, keeld tegeleda tootmise ja salvestusega või terminalide
opereerimisega jne). Kuigi hetkel Eestis vesinikutaristu puudub, mistõttu on täpseid mõjusid
raske hinnata, võib maagaasituru kogemuse põhjal eeldada, et selline lahendus tagaks võrdsed
võimalused kõigile turuosalistele, oleks läbipaistev ja kulutõhus ning võimaldaks nii ka
tarbijatel saada parimat teenust. Vesinikutaristu loomisel tuleb vältida riigipiiridel kogutavaid
tariife, selle asemel peaks lähtuma põhimõttest, et võrgukasutuse tariifi peab maksma ainult
vesiniku sisestamisel vesinikuvõrku ning väljumisel vesinikuvõrgust. Vastasel juhul tekib
olukord, kus piiriülesed tariifid kuhjuvad ning muudavad vesiniku kasutuse trassi lõpp-punktis
majanduslikult ebamõistlikuks. On loogiline, et vesinikutaristu kasutamisel maksavad kõik
taristu kasutajad solidaarselt ühesugust sisend- ja väljundtariifi. Ühtlasi on oluline lähtuda
vesinikutaristu rajamisel maksimaalselt olemasolevast gaasitaristust – olemasoleva taristu
ümberkujundamine vesiniku transportimiseks on majanduslikult mõistlik ning vähendab
ressursikasutust.
4. Võrgugaasil peab olema ühtne kvaliteedinorm üle Euroopa Liidu, mis võtab arvesse
ka taastuvgaaside mõju gaasisüsteemile. Gaasituru dekarboniseerimise tagamiseks on
10
Euroopa Parlamendi ja nõukogu direktiiv nr 2009/73/EÜ, mis käsitleb maagaasi siseturu ühiseeskirju ning
millega tunnistatakse kehtetuks direktiiv 2003/55/EÜ - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-
content/ET/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02009L0073-20190523
oluline sätestada ühised nõuded gaasisüsteemi tehnilistele parameetritele, mille
täitmine võimaldab gaasisüsteemis taastuvgaasi tehniliste raskusteta transportida.
Selgitus: Taastuvgaaside järjest suuremale osakaalule gaasisüsteemis seab tugevad piirid
gaasisüsteemi tehniline valmisolek selliseid gaase vastu võtta, edastada ja jaotada. Tagamaks
gaasisüsteemi tehniline valmisolek näiteks biometaani vastu võtta, edastada ja jaotada, ei tohi
täna biometaani hapnikusisaldus olla gaasisüsteemi sisestades kõrgem kui 0,5 moolprotsenti11.
Vastasel juhul valitseb oht gaasisüsteemi tehnilisele terviklikkusele. Taastuvgaasid on viisil või
teisel maagaasist teistsuguse tehniliste parameetritega, mistõttu ei saa sellised gaasid
gaasisüsteemis suurtes kontsentratsioonides ringelda. Sellised piirangud ei võimalda
taastuvgaasidel Euroopa Liidu gaasisüsteemis konkureerida. Gaasisüsteemi tuleb arendada
selliselt, et need oleksid pikemas perspektiivis taastuvgaaside kasutuselevõtuks sobilikud. Siia
hulka ei kuulu ainult kompressorjaamad, gaasijaotlad ja gaasitrassid, vaid ka näiteks maa-
alused gaasihoidlad. Pikemas perspektiivis on oluline, et Euroopa Liidu ühes punktis sisestatud
taastuvgaas ei põhjustaks teises punktis gaasisüsteemi toimimisele ohtu.
Arvamuse saamine
Käesolevale konsultatsioonile vastamiseks küsiti sisendit Keskkonnaministeeriumilt,
Maaeluministeeriumilt, Rahandusministeeriumilt ja Siseministeeriumilt. Konsultatsioonide
küsimustikud saadeti ka arvamuse saamiseks lisas 2 loetletud organisatsioonidele. Saabunud
sisendid ja nendega arvestamine on välja toodud seletuskirja lisas 3 esitatud kaasamise tabelis.
11
Gaasituru toimimise võrgueeskirja § 19 lg 5 - https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/129122020033
Lisa 2: Kaasatud huvigrupid
Alexela
AS Tallinna Linnatransport
AS Varmata
Baltic Energy Partners
Eesti Autode Müügi- ja Teenindusettevõtete Liit
Eesti Biogaasi Assotsiatsioon
Eesti Biokütuste Ühing
Eesti Elektritööstuse Liit
Eesti Energia
Eesti Gaas
Eesti Gaasiliit
Eesti Jõujaamade ja Kaugkütte Ühing
Eesti Kaubandus-Tööstuskoda
Eesti Keskkonnaühenduste Koda
Eesti Korteriühistute Liit
Eesti Ringmajandusettevõtete Liit
Eesti Roheline Liikumine
Eesti Taastuvenergia Koda
Eesti Teadusagentuur
Eesti Vesinikuühing
Eesti Õliühing
Elcogen
Elering
Fortum Eesti AS
Konkurentsiamet
World Energy Council Estonia
Lisa 3. Kaasamise käigus esitatud märkuste arvestamise tabel
Ettepaneku esitaja Ettepanek/avaldus Arvestamine
AS Varmata MÕTTED JA ETTEPANEKUD Arvestatud.
Tagamaks taastuvgaaside kiirem turuletulek on vaja eemaldada olemasolevaid piirangud ja toetada efektiivsemalt
gaasitaristute arengut:
- Eesti peaks olema aktiivsem osaline/partner üle Euroopalises taastuvgaaside programmis;
- hoonete energiatõhususe arvutamisel peab olema lubatud biometaani kasutamine õiglase taastuvenergia
koefitsiendiga;
- hoonete soojatootmiseks peab lubama kasutada biometaani. Elektri ja gaasi kasutamisel soojuse tootmiseks on
soojuskaod märgatavalt väiksemad, kui seda kaugküte võimaldab. Kombineerides elamutes küttesüsteemis
soojuspumba ja gaasikasutamise, siis saavutame sünergia energia kasutamisel;
- uute gaasitaristute väljaehitamisel või olemasolevate renoveerimisel oleks soovitav toetada materjale, mis
suudavad transportida suurema vesiniku sisaldusega gaase;
- tarbijate kasvu kiirendamiseks leida toetusmeetmed esimestel aastatel hinnavahede kompenseerimiseks;
- toetada lokaalseid puidumassi gasifitseerimise tehnoloogiaid, mis vähendaks puiduhakke veokilomeetreid ning
sellest tulenevat keskkonnasaastet;
- rakendada gaasivõrkudele võrdse kohtlemise printsiipi võrreldes kaugküttevõrkudega;
- eemaldada võimalikud turutõkked (nt väljavõte Tartu energia- ja kliimakavast Tartu Energia 2030 - Maagaasi (sh
biometaani) tarbimine ei ületa 2017. aasta taset).
Eesti Biogaasi 2020 a toodetakse Eestis 10 mln Nm3 biometaani ja meil on 23 töötavat CNG tanklat ja Eestis kokku sõidab täna üle 200 Arvestatud.
Assotsiatsioon gaasibussi ja aasta paariga peaks see arv kahekordistuma. Küsimustiku skoobist
Tuleb teha selge vahe, et maagaas on fossiilne kütus ja biometaan ning sinine ja roheline vesinik on taastuvad kütused. Seega väljas olevad ja
maagaasi tarbimise suurendamine ei aita kaasa Rohepöördele ja EL Kliima Strateegia eesmärkide saavutamisele. Tuleb luua siseriiklikud
biometaani rahvusvaheline kvaliteedi standard, mis võtab arvesse biometaani tootmise eripärasid. Samuti luua eeldused ettepanekud
biometaani ja vesiniku piiriüleseks kaubanduseks muuhulgas nende päritolu tunnistustega. teadmiseks võetud.
Biometaan tuleb väga selgelt defineerida taastuva kütusena, ideaalis tagada biometaani kütuseaktsiisivabastus üle-
Euroopaliselt kuni aastani 2050, ainult selline maksupoliitika kindlus aitab kaasa EL süsinikuneutraalsuse saavutamisele
2050. Samuti kui biogaasi hakatakse kasutama kütuseelementides, tuleb see selgelt määratleda taastuvkütusena, biogaasi
ei tohi kütuseaktsiisiga maksustada, kui biogaasi kasutatakse SEK-ides, vältida tuleb SEKis kasutatava biogaasi maksustamist
maagaasi aktsiisiga ka tulevikus.
Biometaani tootmine loob töökohti, nagu näiteks biogaasijaamade operaatorid. Eestis on vastu võetud biogaasijaama
operaatori kutse riiklik standard, koostatud riiklik õppekava ja Järvamaa Kutsehariduskeskuse õppekava, mille alusel
esimesed 12 õppurit saavad sel aastal omandada biogaasijaama operaatori kutse. Lisanduvad töökohad hooldusele ja
remondile.
Varasemalt tehtud investeeringud fossiilkütustesse ongi ohus, sest fossiilsete kütuste põletamisest tulenev oht
kliimamuutusele on inimelule kahjulik. igasugune investeerimine fossiilsete kütuste tootmiseks, töötlemiseks transpordiks
ja kasutamiseks ei aita kaasa süsinikuneutraalsuse saavutamisele. Seadusandlus ei peaks looma pretsedente fossiilkütuste
taristusse tehtud investeeringute korvamiseks.
Biometaani tootmine on EL rohepöörde ja ringmajanduse elluviimine juba praktikas, mitte enam visioonipaberites,
strateegiadokumentides ja eelarve seletuskirjades. Tõeline innovatsioon on biogaasi kasutamine kütuseelemendis elektri ja
soojuse koostootmiseks, kohtades ja kogustes, kus elektri ja sooja tarve on olemas, aga biogaasi kogus transpordikütuseks
puhastamiseks liiga väike. EBA on kaasatud rahvusvahelisse koostööprojekti just sellise biogaasi kasutava tahke hapniku
kütuselemendiga (SOFC) elektri ja soojuse koostootmise pilootprojekti, vastava pilootseadme välja töötamiseks praktikas.
Koostööd kolmandate riikidega takistab nende vähene huvi, autokraatsete riikidega koostöö tegemine (näiteks Venemaa)
tugevdab autokraatide (võimu)positsioone nendes riikides. Vähene huvi võib olla ka riikidel, kes soovivad oma
energiakandjad kasutada poliitilise relvana (näiteks Venemaa ja maagaas). Võib olla otseses ja kaudses tähenduses aitab
vesinik autokraatsetel riikidel veel rohkem oma rahvast rõhuda ja veel rohkem oma relvasüsteeme arendada, mis on
suunatud vabade ja demokraatlike riikide vastu.
Rahvusvaheline ehk EL ülene biometaani kvaliteedi standard ja maagaasi torru sisestamise tingimused puuduvad.
Biometaani tootmist tuleb toetada, et biometaani tegemine biolagunevatest jäätmetest on rohepööre ja ringmajandus
praktikas ja aitab riikidel täita ka jäätmete ringlussevõtu eesmärke. Samuti aitab biometaani tootmine vähendada
iseeneslikku (kontrollimatut) metaani teket biomassist ja CH4 heidet atmosfääri. Biometaani peaks käsitlema valdkondade
üleselt, mitte looma bürokraatlikke takistusi.
Biometaani ja vesiniku roll aastal 2030 peaks olema oluliselt suurenenud. 2030.a. võiks olla biometaani tootmine jõudnud
100 miljoni Nm3 ehk 1TWh aastas. Metaankütust kasutavate sõiduautode arv võiks olla tõusnud 15 000-ni ja raskeveokite
(bussid ja veoautod) arv 1500. Vesiniku tootmine võiks olla saavutanud esimese tööstusliku tootmise ja laialdasema
kasutamise taseme, sh nii transpordi vahendites kui elektri ja soojuse koostootmises, kohtades, kus vesinikku toodetakse ja
tarbitakse kohapeal.
Ja elektri ja soojuse koostootmiseks võiks endiselt ja laialdasemalt kasutada puiduhaket, millest biometaani teha ei saa. Täna
biogaasi tootmist ja biometaaniks puhastamist kaaluvatel ettevõtetel puudub kindlus tuleviku osas, kuna on risk, et
biometaani totomise toetus lõpeb juba 2022 a kolmandas kvartalis, kui summat ei suurendata. Biometaani sertifikaadiga
kauplemine biokütuste segamiskohustuse täitmiseks ei ole täna piisav kindlustunde loomiseks, investeerimisriskide
maandamiseks ja minimaalse tasuvuse tagamiseks.
Teame, et täna paigaldatakse kuni 750 hj raskeveokitele surumaagaasi või surubiometaani balloone, mis vähendab
rasketranspordi õhuheitmeid oluliselt. Kuid kahjuks need kümned ja kümned metaangaasi kasutavad raskeveokid ei jää
sõitma Eestisse, vaid siirduvad Saksamaale. Seda põhjusel, et Saksamaal on metaankütust kasutav rasketransport vabastatud
teekasutustasust ja see loob majandusliku stiimuli ka kasutuses olevate diiselveokite ümber ehitamiseks surumaagaasile või
surubiometaanile.
Kui EL Rohepöörde elluviimiseks Eestis otsida abikõlbulikke valdkondi, siis biometaani tootmise viimine 100 miljoni Nm3
tasemele tänase 10 miljoni Nm3 aastasest tootmismahu tasemest on EBA arvates väärt ettepanek kaalumiseks
otsustajatele!
Eesti Biogaasi Assotsiatsioon teeb poliitikakujundajatele järgmised ettepanekud:
1. seada 2030.a biometaani tootmise sihtarvuks 100 miljoni Nm3 aastas
2. Metaankütust kasutavate sõiduautode 2030. a sihtarvuks on 15 000 ja raskeveokite (bussid ja veoautod) sihtarvuks on
1500
3. biogaasi kasutamise toetamine pilootprojektidega tahke hapniku kütuseelementides (SOFC)[1] kasutamiseks, eriti
väikesemahuliste seadmete puhul toorme tekke kohtades. SOFC-s tekkivat soojust ja elektrit saab kasutada kohapeal, sh
autonoomsetes kohtades, kus võrguelekter puudub, kaugküttest rääkimata.
4. EL Roheleppe elluviimise meetmeks pikendada biometaani tootjate toetust pikendades määrust “Biometaanituru
arendamise toetamise toetuse kasutamise tingimused ja kord” abikõlbulikkuse perioodi kuni 2030 või võtta vastu uus
samalaadne määrus.
5. Teeme ettepaneku Eestis vabastada ja diferentseerida EURO klasside alusel 40%-80% ulatuses metaankütust tarbivad
raskeveokid teekasutustasust.
6. Viia sisse ostutoetus kohalike gaasiveokite kasutamiseks Eestis (kohaliku veokipargi värskendamine EUROIII-lt EUROVI-le
Saksamaa näitel
7. Raskeveoki maksu vabastus gaasiveokitele ja diferentseerimine EURO klasside alusel
8. Biometaani tarbimisel maksutagastus ettevõtetele (Rootsi näitel)
9. Keskkonnasõbralikuma veeremi kasutamine riigi teenuste ostmisel (Clean Vehicles Directive elluviimisel eeskuju
näitamine) – nn rohelised hanked teedeehituses, Riigi Kinnisvara ehitustel, kus hanketingimustes metaankütuse tarbimine
annab lisapunkte pakkumiste hindamisel.
Eesti Energia Peamised pointid järgnevalt: Arvestatud ja
1. TSO peab võimaldama maksimaalset vesiniku osakaalu maagaasivõrgus (kui vesinikku saab segada maagaasivõrku, teadmiseks võetud.
siis tekib ka võimalus muundada tuuleparkides ületootmise hetkedel, kui elektrihinnad on väga madalad, roheline
elekter vesinikuks ja mitte piirata tuulikute tootlikkust (nagu tehakse praegu Saksamaal), täna on küll tuuleparkide
võimsus piirkonnas suhteliselt madal, kuid arvestades, et näiteks Enefit Greenil on plaanis kümnendi lõpuks
roheelektri tootmist kolmekordistada, siis suureneb ka tunduvalt paindlikkuse vajadus kohalikus elektrisüsteemis
ning vesiniku tootmine täidab paindlikkuse ülesannet efektiivselt).
a. Tõsta lubatud vesiniku osakaal kohtades kus gaasivõrgus allavoolu on CNG tankla 2%vol peale (kuniks CNG
transpordis on üle 2%vol vesiniku osakaal lubatud).
b. Kohtades kus allavoolu ei ole CNG tanklat tõsta lubatav vesiniku osakaal 5%vol peale.
c. Pikem vaade: Eleringi sõnul ei vasta maagaas enam kvaliteedinõuetele, kui vesinik osakaal on üle 5%vol,
maagaasile seatud kvaliteedinõudeid muuta tulevikus nii, et maagaasi ülekandevõrku saab segada kuni
10% vesinikku.
2. Elektrolüüserite omamine ja käit:
a. Maagaasi TSO-l ei tohi olla õigust omada ja käitada elektrolüüsereid, mis sisestavad vesinikku
maagaasivõrku (nn power-to-gas).
3. Gaasi siseturul tuleks kaotada reguleeritud hinnad lõpptarbijatele ning lasta gaasiturud vabaks.
4. Elektri ja gaasi müüki puudutavad regulatsioonid peaksid olema võimalikult sarnased, et müüjad saaksid tooteid
kombineerida ja arendada.
5. Gaasivõrgu pikaajalise planeerimise huvides on, et võrkudega (elekter, gaas) tegeleksid erinevad osapooled ja huvid
oleksid tasakaalustatud.
Eesti Gaasiliit Eesti Gaasiliit tänab võimaluse eest esitada arvamus Euroopa Komisjoni algatusele, millega planeeritakse muuta nii Arvestatud.
gaasidirektiivi kui ka gaasimääruse nõudeid, et tagada Euroopa Liidu roheleppes sisalduvate ambitsioonikate Küsimustiku skoobist
kliimaeesmärkide täitmist gaasisektoris. Kuna esitatud küsimustik on väga laiapõhjaline, esitame teatud põhimõtted ja väljas olevad ja
diskussioonipunktid, mida peame oluliseks. Eesti Gaasiliidule ei ole teada, et riigil oleks seatud konkreetseid eesmärke siseriiklikud
vesinikuenergeetikas, mida võiksid väljendada numbriliselt tarbimis- või tootmismahud. ettepanekud
teadmiseks võetud.
Eesti Gaasiliidu tähelepanekud on järgmised:
1. Gaasidirektiivi skoobi laiendamine, vesiniku lisamine gaasitrassidese, vesiniku lisamise kohustus ning selle kvaliteet
Meie hinnangul sobiks vesinik energiakandjana gaasidirektiivi alla siis kui vesinikku transporditakse läbi gaasitrassi. See
võimaldaks arvesse võtte vesinikuenergeetikaga kaasnevaid tehnilisi nüansse ning võimaldaks vastavalt vajadusele
olemasolevaid nõudeid ajakohastada. Gaasidirektiivi skoobist võiksid välja jääda autonoomsed vesinikutrassid.
Vesiniku lisamine gaasitrassidesse on meie hinnangul mõistlik ja sellele võiks kliimaeesmärkide saavutamise kontekstis
suuremat tähelepanu pöörata. Esiteks võimaldaks see praegust kõrget vesinikuhinda laiema segmendi peale jagada, andes
praeguses võtmes juba võimaluse välja arendada tootmisvõimekust.
Eesti Gaasiliit leiab, et vesiniku lisamise kohustust ei tohiks EL tasemel eksisteerida, sest liikmesriikide energiaportfellid ja
tarbimised on väga erinevad. Lisaks leidub juba praegu mitmeid liikmesriike, kes toetavad vesinikuenergeetika
väljatöötamist nii tootmisvõimsuste rajamiseks, aga ka olemasolevate gaasitrasside rekonstrueerimiseks, et transportida
suuremas mahus vesinikku. Kohustusliku vesinikukoguse lisamise kohustusest tuleneva investeeringu tegemist ei saa lükata
võrguettevõtjate õlule, sest võttes arvesse Eesti gaasitarbimise madalat mahtu ja tugevat ohtu selle edasiseks alanemiseks,
võib see põhjustada pöördumatut kahju ning ebamõistlikult kõrget võrgutasu klientidele. Seetõttu peaks ka VV
seisukohtades kajastuma põhimõte, et kõigepealt tuleb hakata leidma lahendusi tööstuse jaoks, sealt edasi
elamumajandusse ning siis nö pliidtarbijateni tuua. Alles siis kui vesinikuhind ja tehnoloogia on konkurentsivõimelised
olemasolevate energiakandjatega, või vähemalt nende läheduses, võiks rääkida kohustuslikult vesiniku lisamise nõudest kas
üle-euroopaliselt või liikmesriigi tasandil. Ühtlasi leiame, et vesiniku kvaliteet võiks olla sätestatud CEN või ISO standardiga.
Antud küsimuse valguses soovime informeerida, et praegusel hetkel on KOVid tegemas oma energia- ja kliimakavasid.
Näiteks Tartu linna energia- ja kliimakava näeb ette, et gaaskütuste tarbimine peab jääma 2017. aasta tasemele ega tohi
tõusta. Lisaks on Tallinna linn arendamas oma kliimakava ja ka seal on ette nähtud gaaskütuste kasutamise pidurdamine.
Seetõttu tekib küsimus, et kuidas saab riik tulevikus seada nõudeid võrguettevõtjatele vesiniku lisamise kohustuseks kui
olemasolevates võrgupiirkondades on sääraseid kitsendusi seatud. Lisaks soovime ohukohana välja tuua, et selliste otsuste
valguses ei pruugi suured omavalitsused vesinikuenergeetikast osa saada ja riigil võib kliimaeesmärkide täitmine
raskendatud olla.
2. Vesiniku infrastruktuur ja turg
Meie hinnangul peaks vesiniku infrastruktuuride arendus toimuma paralleelselt nii TSO kui ka DSOde juures. TSO lahendused
võimaldavad vesiniku ülekannet bilansitsoonis, aga ei aita kaasa välja töötamaks konkreetseid lahendusi tarbijatele.
Praegusel hetkel on väga paljudes riikides tehtud suuri projekte ja plaane aastani 2035/2040 ja ette nähtud ülekandevõrkude
juurdeehitamist, aga ka nende rekonstrueerimiseks/väljavahetamiseks vesiniku transpordiks. On üsna ilmne, et need plaanid
ka realiseeruvad. Eesti, Läti, Leedu, Soome kohta käiv info näitab Läti ja Leedu üsna leiget huvi vesinikuenergeetika vastu.
Eestis on kaardistatud meretuuleparkide potentsiaal vesiniku tootmiseks ja see, et võiksime olla eksportööri staatuses.
Seega on oluline, et riik panustaks ja haaraks kaasa DSOd ja pakuks võimalusi ja vahendeid.
3. Tarbija õigused rohelisele vesinikule
Lähtudes olemasolevast praktikast ja võimalustest Eesti energiaturul, kus tarbijal on võimalus valida elektrimüüjat ja
gaasimüüjat, siis peaks olema tarbijal võimalus valida ka vesinikumüüjat. Vesinikku saaks vahendada võrguettevõtja, kellega
tarbijal on leping. Meie arvates peaks olema tarbijatel (kaasa arvatud KÜ) kaugküttepiirkonnas õigus minna üle vesiniku
peale, sest biomasskütustega kaasnevad heitmeid ei pruugi olla vastuvõetavad paljude tarbijate jaoks ning soovitakse puhast
vesinikku, mida saab pakkuda kõige keskkonnasõbralikumalt maagaasi võrguettevõtja. See eeldab ka energiatõhususe
direktiivi ülevaatamist, mis eeldaks energiakandjate süsinikujalajälje arvestust ning hoonete energiatõhususe
miinimumnõuete juures rohkemate võimaluste pakkumist. Siseriiklikult oleks selle eelduseks ka maagaasi kaalumisteguri
ümberhindamine, mis võimaldaks elamuehituses hakata planeerima lahendusi, mis on tulevikus orienteeritud vesiniku
kasutamisele.
Eesti Kaubandus- Eesti Kaubandus-Tööstuskoda tänab Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumit võimaluse eest avaldada arvamust Teadmiseks võetud.
Tööstuskoda Euroopa Komisjoni gaasi siseturu ühiseeskirjade muutmise avaliku konsultatsiooni eelnõu (edaspidi: eelnõu) kohta, mille
abil soovitakse teada, kuidas gaasidirektiivi ja gaasimäärust muuta, et need oleksid kooskõlas Euroopa kliimaeesmärkidega.
Oleme eelnõuga tutvunud ning anname teada, et meil ei ole eelnõu kohta kommentaare, märkuseid ega ettepanekuid.
Keskkonnaministeerium Vastavalt Riigikantselei resolutsioonile nr 2-5/21-00839 esitab Keskkonnaministeerium ettepanekud Eesti seisukohtadeks Arvestatud ja
Euroopa Komisjoni avaliku konsultatsiooni kohta, mis käsitleb gaasivõrkude turulepääsu käsitlevate ELi eeskirjade teadmiseks võetud.
läbivaatamist. Palume Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumil arvestada Vabariigi Valitsusele esitatavas seletuskirjas
ja otsuse eelnõus järgmiste seisukohtadega.
1. Peame vajalikuks jaotusvõrkudes fossiilsetele gaasidele eeliste kaotamist, et tagada taastuvate gaaside turule
pääsemine ja konkurentsivõime turul.
Selgitus: Praegune regulatiivne raamistik toetab gaasivõrgu tsentraliseeritud varustamist, mis tähendab, et taastuvate
gaaside kaubeldavus ning juurdepääs turgudele ja gaasivõrku ei ole fossiilse maagaasiga võrdsel tasemel. Sellel on oluline
negatiivne mõju taastuvate gaaside tootjate äriplaanidele. Samuti ei pruugi olemasolevad veeldatud maagaasi terminalid
sobida taastuvate gaaside vastuvõtmiseks. Nimetatud barjääride eemaldamiseks ning fossiilsete gaaside eelisseisundi
kaotamiseks on oluline gaasitaristu terviklik kavandamine, mis arvestaks taastuvate gaaside vajadustega.
2. Peame oluliseks toetada biometaani kasutamist lisaks transpordile ka teistes sektorites, sh ELi heitkogustega
kauplemise süsteemi (edaspidi EL HKS) käitistes.
Selgitus: Biometaani kasutuselevõtu edendamiseks on vajalik tekitada piisavalt tarbijaid, et kodumaistel tootjatel tekiks
võimalus müüa oma toodangut. Kuna transpordisektoris on suund elektrifitseerimisele ja vesinikule, on oluline tõsta
biometaani kasutust ka teistes sektorites, näiteks ELi HKSi käitistes. 2019. aasta seisuga tarbiti ELi HKSi käitistes ligikaudu
5200 TJ maagaasi. Vastavalt ELi HKSi seire ja aruandluse määrusele (EL) 2018/2066 on võimalik säästlikkuse kriteeriumitele
vastavat biometaani arvesse võtta 0 heitega kütusena, kui sellele on väljastatud päritolutunnistus ning gaas on eraldatud
võrku ja seejärel sealt ära tarbitud. See võimaldab käitistel vähendada tööstustegevuses tekkinud CO2 heidet ja seeläbi
lubatud heitkoguse ühikute turuhinna tõusust tekkivaid täiendavaid kulusid. Biometaanile kasutuse leidmine mitte üksnes
ei aita dekarboniseerida nt tööstust ja soojamajandust, vaid toetab KHG heidete vähendamist jäätme- ja
põllumajandusektoris.
3. Peame vajalikuks taastuvatele gaasidele sihttaseme seadmist võrkudes.
Selgitus: Tõukamaks tagant tehnoloogia arengut ning taastuvate gaaside kasutamise osakaalu kasvu ELi HKS käitistes on
vajalik seada sihttase taastuvate gaaside osakaalule võrkudes. See aitab mh tagada biometaani nõudluse taseme ka
olukorras, kus transpordisektoris asendub biometaani kasutus suures osas elektri ja vesinikuga.