Saatja: Aive Telling </o=JM/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=0dc4087cbe4b4cd186fc19cf2c937f95-Aive Telling>
Saaja: '
[email protected]'
Teema: FW: Questions about e-cigarette
Dear Lorenzo Guaragna.
Here are our common answers to your questions what You sent to many different recipients in our ministry and also to Health Board. Most of requirements are directly from TPD. Electronic cigarettes are regulated by Tobacco Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/523052019008/consolide and Alcohol, Tobacco, Fuel and Electricity Excise Duty Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/508012020001/consolide.
1. According to Estonian Tobacco Act there should be in the notification, made via EUCEG portal „a list of all ingredients contained in, and emissions resulting from the use of, the product, by brand name and type, including quantities thereof“. So for enforcement and competent authorities there are no secret ingredients. Regarding general public there is said in the Tobacco Act: „...the following information shall appear on each sales packaging and the grouped packaging directly covering the sales packaging:
1) a list of the ingredients contained in the product in descending order of the weight.“ So general public should know all the ingredients, but cannot see the amounts of the ingredients.
2. Yes, but please be informed, that according to Estonian Tobacco Act all flavourings are prohibited for e-cigarettes, except tobacco flavouring.
3. No, only complete electronic cigarettes and parts that are capable to contain e-liquid.
4. No, if manufacturer has already notified, there is no need to make double notification.
5. Question content incomprehensible.
6. Question content incomprehensible.
7. https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/tobacco/docs/approved_laboratories_en.pdf
8. According to the European Commissions meeting with e-cigarette industry stakeholders participants reached to the conclusion, that pharmaceutical grade ingredients should be used, where possible (EP or USP) for the excipients and for nicotine. If some pharmaceutical grade ingredients (e.g. flavours) are not available then food grade would be the next best alternative. (https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/tobacco/docs/ev_20150120_sumrec_en.pdf)
9. Classification is made on the basis of CLP-regulation.
10. According to the Estonian Tobacco Act on the labelling of the e-liquid there should be „a list of the ingredients contained in the product in descending order of the weight“ and there are no exceptions. So all ingredients have to be mentioned.
11. Yes, You can.
12. Leaflet is mandatory but there are no requirements how the leaflet should look like.
13. In the case of electronic cigarettes, yes, in the case of tobacco products, no.
14. The units are mg/ml
15. There are no special requirements
16. Electronic cigarettes and refill containers shall comply with the requirements provided for in European Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2016/586 on technical standards for the refill mechanism of electronic cigarettes (OJ L 101, 14.04.2016, pp. 15–16).
17. No
18. Yes.
19. Heated tobacco products are considered as smokeless or smoked tobacco products (it’s up to manufacturer to choose). So smokeless tobacco products are prohibited, for smoking products all the requirements can be found on the Tobacco Act (https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/523052019008/consolide)
Article 22(4) in Tobacco Act: It is prohibited to offer for sale and sell tobacco products or products related to tobacco products which are in the same packaging with other products. Meaning of the 22(4) is other products than tobacco products.
Best regards,
Aive Telling
keskkonnatervise ja kemikaaliohutuse juht | Rahvatervise osakond
7153474 |
[email protected]
Sotsiaalministeerium
Suur-Ameerika 1 | 10122 Tallinn
626 9301 | http://www.sm.ee <http://www.sm.ee/et>
From: Legal Team <
[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, March 5, 2020 1:35 PM To: Liisa Tolli <
[email protected]> Subject: Art. 22(4) Tobacco Act
Good Morning Lisa,
I hope my email finds you well.
I am Lorenzo Guaragna and working as a legal analyst for EcigIntelligence, based in Barcelona. My company doesn’t sell E-cigarettes, we just collect data about the regulatory landscape worldwide.
I wanted to get in touch hoping that you can clarify a provision from the Tobacco Act. In Article 22(4), the law says (according to google translate, let me know me please if it's incorrect): "It is prohibited to offer for sale and sell tobacco products or products related to tobacco products which are in the same packaging with other products."
I understand that this provision prohibits the selling of more than one item in a box. But if the items are all the same? For example, if a box contains 5 identical cartridges or more than one identical item, is that forbidden?
Thanks in advance, Warm regards.
Lorenzo Guaragna
From: Legal Team <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >
Sent: Monday, February 10, 2020 11:03 AM
To: Keskus TA <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >; Merili Sikk <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >; Eva Lehtla <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >; Maris Jesse <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >; Heli Laarmann <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >
Subject: Questions about e-cigarette
Good Morning,
I am Lorenzo Guaragna and working as a legal analyst for EcigIntelligence <https://ecigintelligence.com/> , based in Barcelona. My company doesn’t sell E-cigarettes, we just collect data about the regulatory landscape worldwide.
The Tobacco Act is very clear regarding e-cigs, but I still have some question about the e-cigarette legal landscape in Estonia. I would be very grateful if you can answer the following questions.
If you don’t know how to answer can you please indicate me who I have to write to?
1-Ingredients, what can be regarded as confidential?
2-Is a separate notification required for each individual product, including each flavour and strength variant?
3-Do all e-cigarette components and accessories need a product notification (e.g. batteries or a mouthpiece)?
4-If a non-EU manufacturer has already notified a product, is this sufficient or does the importer need to also notify it?
5-What is it expected from submitters when testing ingredients, nicotine uptake and emissions?
6-How are products supposed to be tested?
7-Where to test products?
8-What is considered “High purity” of an ingredient?
9-With the exception of nicotine, the ingredients used in the nicotine-containing liquid may not pose a risk to human health in heated or unheated form. Where and how is a substance classified as a risk to human health?
10-Is it possible to describe on the label, individual ingredients used in quantities below 0.1% of the final formulation by category?, for example “other flavourings”.
11-Can we use multilingual packages?
12-Leaflet: can the required elements for the leaflet be included in the bottle or box? Can the leaflet be in the form of a pull-out label?
13-If there is no outer box, is it possible to include the health warnings and/or other information in an external removable wrapping?
14-How to express in the label/package the nicotine dose?
15-Devices must be protected against breakage and leakage. How would it be considered that is satisfactorily achieved? Does this mean that glass bottles/devices are out of the question?
16-What are the requirements for a child-resistant e-cigarette device?
17-Is there any requirement for hardware (devices) outside of the TPD?
18-Are you coordinating with other member states to further regulate e-cigarettes or to ensure a more homogeneous interpretation?
19-How do you regulate and tax heated tobacco products?
Many thanks in advance.
Warm regards,
Lorenzo Guaragna.