Saatja: Tanel Kiik <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 10.02.2020 18:49
Adressaat: Triin Uusberg <
[email protected]>
Koopia: SOM nõunikud <
[email protected]>; SM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: A Proposal on a Digital Design fora Better Labour Market
Manused: REPORT PERFECT2JOB.pdf
Palun registreerime ja suuname õigele inimesele vastamiseks.
From: Nils Buhelt <
[email protected]>
Sent: Tuesday, February 4, 2020 4:40 PM
To: Tanel Kiik <
[email protected]>; Marika Priske <
[email protected]>
Cc: Ulla Lund <
[email protected]>
Subject: A Proposal on a Digital Design fora Better Labour Market
A Proposal on a Digital Design for a Better Labour Market
Dear Tanel Kiik, Minister of Social Affairs
Attached herewith, please find the report Perfect2Job for inspiration and consideration. It is an example
of how digitalization, artificial intelligence (AI) together with legislation can be used for developing public
service solutions.
Perfect2Job is a new design for job seeking and recruitment as further described in the attached report.
The design uses “legislation” to provide “perfect” data and concepts as well as transparency, efficiency
and equality. It is based on ESCO - the ontology provided by EU - and the discipline “AI and law”.
The new design ensures, among other things, that the quality and quantity of your information about
citizens' skills and competencies in order to improve their welfare is at least as good as those gathered by
Facebook, Google and LinkedIn for their growing business on job ads.
Overall, Perfect2Job is expected to deliver a macroeconomic gain nationally. However, the impact of the
new design differs between EU member states as labour markets are different. In particular, Perfect2Job
may have a potential to increase job mobility in member states that today have lower job mobility. This is
due to the elimination of the job application and opportunity to be anonymous in the job search as
suggested by the design. In the report, the Danish labour market is used as reference.
We will be pleased to elaborate on the new design and discuss our approach in general to digitalization
and how this could be adopted in your political interest field. Please, do not hesitate to contact us to
discuss how AI and digitalization may be applied in your field of interest.
Our company – Law Computer Interaction – is a social-economic enterprise working with “digitalization by
law” as a driver for prosperity and wealth. From our point of view, digitalization is of outmost importance
for politicians and public administrators drafting the bill.
You may use the new design for inspiration free of charge but please contact us - if you do - about why,
what and how the design can be of inspiration to you as well as nationally.
Best regards
Ulla Lund
CEO and founder
Law Computer Interaction
+45 53 64 10 24
[email protected]
[email protected]
www.lawcomputerinteraction.com
Torkel Badens Vej 10
2900 Hellerup
DENMARK
--
Med venlig hilsen / Best Regards
Nils Buhelt
LawComputerInteraction
The report is prepared by the social-economic enterprise ”Law Computer Interaction”,
November 2019, ISBN 978-87-970933-1-5.
Copyright © 2019 by Law Computer Interaction.
All rights reserved. This new design, named Perfect2Job, may not be reproduced in any
form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including digitalized implemented system,
prototyping, photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system
now known or to be invented, without written permission from Law Computer Interaction.
Therefore, write to us
[email protected] or call +45 53 64 10 24. Tell us
about your mission and we will come back a.s.a.p. with a permission free of charge.
For further information about our company see chapter 10.
This
www.lawcomputerinteraction.com
[email protected]
Torkel Badens vej 10
2900 Hellerup
Denmark
+45 53 64 10 24
+45 21 49 25 18
document outlines a new design for job search and recruitment - named Perfect2Job. It
is inspired by global trends towards easy, data-driven job search and recruitment. The
design is based on the international discipline "artificial intelligence (AI) and law". The easy
and data-driven design is provided by legislation in combination with the "AI and law"
l
➢
Cover photo by Reginaldo Sales/”Kongens Nytorv”/Metroselskabet Denmark
i
Preface
This report outlines a new design for job search and recruitment - named Perfect2Job.
It is inspired by global trends towards easy, data-driven job search and recruitment. The
design has been developed by using the law as tool to an easy and efficient framework
and platform for the job seekers and the recruiting companies. Legislation may be at
national or EU level. The design is based on the international discipline "artificial
intelligence (AI) and law". The easy and data-driven design is provided by legislation in
combination with the "AI and law" discipline.
The design will
➢ make job seeking and recruitment easy and efficient for employed, unemployed as
well as companies
➢ strengthen the companies’ “right to select” among all relevant job seekers without
limitation to a pile of received applications as today
➢ lower administrative burdens on job seeking and recruitment
➢ assign to every citizen a digital “CV box” with
➢ uploaded educational certificates including data on course content
➢ uploaded job certificates “signed-off” by former and present employers
documenting skills, competencies and knowledge acquired and used during
employment
➢ ensure quality in the outcome of automatic pairing of the job advertisement and
the jobseekers CV
➢ make use of a common job language (ontology) created for EU named ESCO.
The new design implies that
➢ traditional job applications from the jobseekers can be abolished
➢ receiving, processing, filing and storage of the job applications in the companies
and GDPR-compliance on this part can be abolished except for those applicants
selected for further interviewing and testing
➢ requirements for unemployed receiving public unemployment benefit to
document job search behaviour can be abolished
➢ companies will be notified on the outcome of automatic pairing of the job
advertisement and the jobseekers' CV (the degree of fulfilment of job
requirements based on a full intelligent data search) and can appoint the
applicants that is invited into the further recruitment process.
Macroeconomic consequences of the design: Better and easier pairing of job seekers
and vacant job positions releases resources, removes information barriers, and
strengthens productivity. The initiative is estimated to deliver a not insignificant
macroeconomic gain.
The impact assessments of the design: The new design's impact on business economics,
citizens and public spending is expected to be positive. Differences of labour market
between EU Member States can affect the impact assessments. However, in the long
term it is to be expected that the new design will help to make the labour markets more
equal by increasing job mobility in Member States where it is low; promoting equal
access to vacancies etc.
ii
Preface
1 Summary
2 Introduction
3 Automated pairing
3.1 The new pairing
3.2 “The selection right” changes
3.2.1 Abolishment of the job application
3.2.2 "Not unemployed" jobseekers
3.2.3 The job seeker on unemployment benefits etc.
3.2.4 Easy to be a job seeker - for both employed and unemployed
3.3 Other recruitment and search channels
4 The common labour market ontology - a common "job" language
4.1 Why a common labour market ontology?
4.2 Structure of ESCO
4.2.1 Occupation pillar
4.2.2 Skills pillar
4.2.3 Qualification pillar
4.3 Update of ESCO
5 Job advertisement
5.1 Job advertisement and other recruitment channels
5.2 Job advertisement today in Denmark
5.3 Design for a better job advertisement
5.3.1 Structure
5.3.2 Publicity
5.3.3 Ontology
6 The CV Box
6.1 The CV today
6.1.1 The companies' use of CV in recruitment
6.2 The CV as the data source in the new design
6.2.1 CV-box
6.2.2 Job search availability
6.2.3 Anonymity as a job seeker
6.2.4 Other availability
6.3 Education and Diploma
6.3.1 More data on educational content
6.3.2 Educational certificates - part of the common labour market ontology
6.4 Certificates for job experience
6.4.1 Ontology
7 The institutional set-up
7.1 Private versus public
7.2 EURES
8 Transition
9 Impact assessment
10 About LCI and us
1
1 Summary
This report reviews a proposal for a new design for a common job search and recruitment
service for everyone - for companies as well as employed and unemployed job seekers in
the EU. The design is based on the international discipline "artificial intelligence (AI) and
law". The design requires legislation on national or EU-level. Institutionally, the design - if
sustainable in relation to the labour market of the EU Member State - is recommended to
be lifted by private job portals etc., otherwise it should be lifted by national public
employment service (PES).
The new design is developed by the social-economic enterprise "Law Computer
Interaction", cf. Box 1.1.
Box 1.1 Our mission
"Perfect2Job" (“Perfect to Job”) is a design for job search and recruitment service that
combine legislation and IT-technology. "With the design, we seek to raise awareness of
using IT and legislation together - including the "AI and Law" discipline - to promote
prosperity and welfare in general in the world but particularly in the European Union.
The Member States can choose to implement the design individually or it can be
implemented as more common rules in the European Union" states the CEO Ulla Lund,
Law Computer Interaction.
In the new design, all citizens above the age of 18 shall have a CV box containing their
personal data on education and job experience. The data in the CV box must follow the
common European job language "ESCO" (European Skills / Competences, Qualifications
and Occupations). “ESCO” is already a part of regulation in the EU, cf. regulation 2016/589
on EURES1. ESCO is what is called an ontology within the discipline "AI and law".
In the new design, when a citizen actively wants to seek jobs, he2 must simply by “press
of a button” open and activate the CV box for search and hereby enable the companies'
job advertisements to "look into" the CV. This is the only thing the citizen has to do in the
new design when having decided to go from a state as “not jobseeker” to a state as “job
seeker” and it will no longer be necessary to keep one’s attention on job advertisements,
to select relevant ads3, to prepare and submit applications.
As today, companies must continue preparing and uploading job ads4 on the job portals.
In addition to the text information, the ads will, as something new, have a data layer
containing the company's requirements for knowledge, skills and competencies based on
the common European job language “ESCO”.
The job-seeking citizen no longer has to spend time finding job advertisements and
preparing applications. Companies also no longer have to spend time receiving, managing
and reading applications for the first screening.
In the new design, algorithms will pair the job seekers and job ads. First, all job seekers
who meet the ad's requirements in whole or in part are registered. Then, a ranking is done
based on the strength of the fulfilment of requirements in the job ad, e.g. 100 per cent
1 EURES stand for "European Employment Services" and is the European Job Mobility Portal.
2In this report, we have defined the terminology "he" and "his" as gender neutral terms for ”he/she” and “his/hers”
respectively. A decision made by flip a coin.
3
Advertisement and ad is used synonymously in the report.
4 Job advertisements are defined and discussed in chapter 5.
2
fulfilment, 95 per cent, 90 per cent etc. If the company pairs with many job seekers, a
"cut-off" level for the degree of required fulfilment can be allowed.
Jobseekers are informed about which jobs they are pairing with and their ranking in the
pairing. The jobseeker5 can choose to interact by, for example, making an interest
statement (a "like"). Especially, this can be useful, if the jobseeker does not have a good
ranking in the pairing, but is interested in the job, the company or the industry.
The further actions in the recruitment process are a matter for the company. The design
strengthens the companies “right to choose” among jobseekers. The individual company
with vacant positions is not to the same extent as today limited to the pile of applications
received. The company selects which job seekers they will contact and the recruitment
process hereafter is not a part of this design. The employed job seekers will have the
opportunity to not reacting or to cancel the invitation to enter the further process of
recruitment. In the design, job seekers receiving public unemployment benefit will be
more restricted regarding cancellation of invitations from the companies and will usually
be obliged to take part in the further recruitment process if invited.
With the new design the “right to choose” passes from the job seeker to the companies.
Today the job seeker currently has “the right to choose” as it is the job seeker who selects
which job to apply for and which companies shall receive an application. In the new
design all relevant job seekers will, in principle, come into play for a job. The companies
will get full information about all relevant job seekers. On this very broad basis, companies
can choose who to continue with, without being limited to the pile of incoming
applications.
Figure 1.1 The new design with a jobseeker as CV box and algorithm pairing where all
CV boxes are scanned against all job advertisements and vice versa and “the right to
choose” lies with the companies
5 Here, jobseeker is a synonym for the CV box owner.
3
The description above omits several options embedded into the design. For example, the
interest of non-unemployed job seekers in specific jobs, industries, geographical areas or
businesses may be considered in the design, and pairing may only occur if - and only if -
the stated interests are met.
The non-unemployed job seeker thus can set up filters in contrast to job seekers receiving
public unemployment benefits. In the new design, the right to apply filters for job search
will be more restricted for job seekers receiving public unemployment benefits.
Other options concern anonymity and secrecy in the job seeking process.
One very important part of the design is that data on labour demand and supply is based
on a common job "language" - a common ontology. As mentioned, the EU has established
"ESCO" by regulation. ESCO is a part of the EURES regulation and the EU Member States
are obliged to comply with ESCO in relation to EURES.
There has been tendency for a too high degree of individualism regarding demand and
supply on labour where each company and educational institution are responsible to
themselves only for the job language used and it has happened at the expense of common
wording and understanding.
The consequence of this has been lack of transparency in job advertisements with regards
to required knowledge, skills and competencies. Likewise, it has meant a wide range of
smartly named education programs, but unclear how these new programs differ from
existing educations with a longer historical tradition in the field.
With ESCO, steps have been taken to develop the common job language on occupations,
competencies, skills and knowledge.
The new design requires legislation if to be realized. This also applies even if it is
institutionally lifted by private job portals. Among other things, there need to be
legislation regarding
creation of a CV box for all citizens aged 18 or above or at the time of their first job
certificate or certificate of education
uploading a certificate of education incl. course content to the CV box and
hereby releasing the educational institution for its obligations to keep
documentation
uploading job certificates on acquired and used knowledge, skills and
competencies signed off by the employer and uploaded regularly (e.g. annually)
to CV box
ownership to the box which here is proposed to be the citizens'
rules for the design of the CV box including the settings of the box e.g. state,
activation, anonymity and filters (in relation to jobs, industries, businesses, etc.)
cessation of requirements to the number of job applications submitted and
documentation on search behaviour for jobseekers receiving public unemployment
benefit. Their CV box must however be open for pairing with job ads according to
availability rules
use of the common job "language" ESCO in relation to the job certificate and the
course content of certificate of education
rules for public inspection of private job portals being part of "Perfect2Job".
Chapter 2 gives a brief review of the content of each chapter.
4
2 Introduction
Even though, we are in the age of artificial intelligence (AI) with many advanced digital
solutions making our everyday life easier and better, job search and recruitment today
remains a resource-intensive area.
Global trends are towards data-driven recruitment and job search solutions. It should be
easy to look for a new job. It should be easy to get considered for a new job. The design
presented below is inspired by these global trends. It is also based on the international
discipline "AI and law".
Today, it takes resources to seek jobs and to recruit employees. The new design therefore
aims to make both parts easier and better and thus saving and optimizing resources.
The new design is named "Perfect2Job" inspired by economic theory of perfect market
with full information and transparency. The new design is estimated to be able to improve
the labour market on information and transparency to an extent, so it is sustainable to
name it "Perfect2Job".
However, the task is not to discuss the socio-economic, government-financial or business-
economic impact of the design and to put figures on it. The focus, on the other hand, is
on the "unfold" of the new design and by doing so to conceptualize the basis for the
economic calculation of resources that may be released if established. Based on this
“unfolded” new design, the economic effects for societies, public finances and businesses
can subsequently be estimated.
Chapter 3
Chapter 3 reviews pairing job seekers and companies job advertisements. With the new
design, the companies will in future have access to run data of job advertisements against
CV-data for all jobseekers with an active CV box, cf. chapter 6 with proposals for CV-boxes
for all citizens.
Today, it can be accidentally who of the jobseekers views a job advertisement. The new
design solves this problem as the companies will get information on all job seekers who
fully or partially meet the job advert's requirements and provides solid basis for selecting
candidates to participate in the further recruitment process.
As can be seen, the new design changes who is driving the process of job search and
recruitment. Today, it is the job seeker who is the one who finds relevant jobs typically on
the basis of job advertisements, selecting the jobs to be applied for and submitting
separate applications for each job. The job seeker today has what one can call the
"selection right" by being the initiator through the application.
Going forward, these tasks will be done digitally, and here the company's job
advertisement will be paired with all job seekers, where the ad's requirements are fully
or partially met. The companies will thus be able to search among all jobseekers for
relevant candidates. "The selection right" will hereby be transferred to the companies,
who then choose who they will call for participating in the further recruitment process,
cf. Figure 1.1.
The following presentation of the design emphasizes only the fundamental modelling. It
would be natural to incorporate as an opportunity into "Perfect2Job" an interactivity
between job seekers and companies. For example, it could be in the form of a "like
button" known from Facebook among others. This kind of extra features are not
addressed here, as the focus is on the design's basic elements.
The design is a radical change of the current processes in the labour market in connection
with job search and recruitment. What happens is that the application, in its present form,
5
is abolished as primary engine and substituted by an engine to pair the demanded and
supplied skills and qualifications based on ESCO - an ontology of the European labour
market.
The pairing will be driven by regulated algorithms, which the individual owner of the CV
box to some extent may deviate from through individual settings.
Chapter 4
Chapter 4 reviews ESCO ("European Skills/Competences, Qualifications and
Occupations"). When it is possible to remove the application, make recruitment easier for
the companies and to digitize the pairing between jobseeker's CV and the job
advertisement's requirements, it is due to legal initiatives to improve data quality. An
important element in this is the use of a common understood concept professionally
named an ontology6. ESCO is a common labour market ontology on which the job
advertisements' data layer, data from education and the companies' description of the
employees' job experience is proposed to be build.
Chapter 5
Chapter 5 deals with job ads. The new design will add an extra, wide and deep data layer
specifying skills and qualifications that the company demands. The data layer will be a
supplement to the job advertisement's text part. The text part itself is maintained as
today, as it also serves other purposes for the company such as PR and branding.
The job advertisement data layer must, as described above, build on same conceptual
basis as for education and the job certificate, namely ESCO. The fact that the job ad has a
data layer added and that the data layer must follow ESCO means that only job ads on job
portals that implement the legislation for the new design are included.
During the process of pairing with the CV boxes, the company can choose to be
anonymous, whereby the company name is not disclosed to the CV owner. The companies
can also choose to keep the content of the job advertisement secret. If both anonymous
and secrecy is the case, the CV owner is only informed about the degree of fulfilment of
the pairing but not the content of the advertisement or name of the company.
Chapter 6
Chapter 6 describes the CV box with data on 1) education and content as well as 2) job
experience. The CV box will be created by law.
The CV box is owned by the citizen concerned, who decides the state of the box. There
are two states to the box. The box can either have the state as "not job seeker" or the
state as "job seeker".
If the CV owner has the status "not job seeker" but wants to be seeking jobs, then the
state of the CV box must be changed to the state of "job seeker", whereby job
advertisements are allowed to pair with the owner's CV.
The owner will also be able to determine the terms of the job search by activating "filters".
For example, if the CV owner is only interested in being a job seeker within specific jobs,
industries and/or companies. It is these filter settings that determine "who" and "what"
have access to pairing with the CV box. One extreme is that no "filters" are activated and
therefore all companies' job advertisements (excluding current employers) can search
and pair with the CV box. Another extreme is to apply filter settings - whereby only
6 Our use of the concept “ontology” is further described in chapter 4.
6
companies and/or industries and/or specific jobs can pair with the CV and the degree of
compliance with the ad's requirements can be calculated.
The design's starting point is that the current employer for the owner of the CV box will
not be able to see if the employee is seeking jobs.
An owner of the CV box receiving public unemployment benefits with "a general
obligation of availability" will not have the option for applying "filters" to the same extent
as owners that are not receiving unemployment benefits.
There is also the possibility that the owner of a CV box appears anonymous to the
companies with which he is paired. The anonymity is cancelled if the owner of the CV box
accepts a company's invitation to enter in a recruitment process.
The CV box will contain educational certificates belonging to the owner of the CV box. It
shall be the educational institutions that uploads these certificates to the CV box. The
course content shall also be uploaded. The purpose of this is, among other things, to
facilitate the algorithm pairing and to provide the companies with an overview of the
content of the education. Course content associated with educational certificates must
be designed in accordance with the common labour market ontology “ESCO”.
As a new initiative the design introduces the job certificate. The job certificate specifies
knowledge, skills and competencies that the employee has used or acquired as part of his
work - also popularly known as "the Job Experience". Preferably, the job certificate may
be created in connection with the dialogues between employee and employer on job
performance and talent review; it shall be signed off by the employer and must be
uploaded to the CV box annually. The job certificate must be designed using the common
labour market ontology ESCO. It is noted that the job certificate is a legal right after one
year's employment. In relation to the job certificate, special business and industry
conditions must be taken into account in the employment contract or agreement.
Chapter 7
The chapter examines the institutionally set up. As the system must include all job seekers
- also job seekers in a current occupation - it is proposed that the private job portals to be
the responsible institutions for the design "Perfect2Job". There must be supervision that
the private job portals taking on the task comply with the legislation.
Chapter 8
Chapter 8 describes possible transitional arrangements for establishing the CV box, so that
educational certificates and employment experience from before the establishment of
the CV box are also made available in the CV box. A transitional arrangement is outlined
for how previous educational certificates and job experience can be made available in the
CV box and the quality of data is ensured.
Chapter 9
The chapter discusses briefly the impact assessments of the new design, i.e. impacts on
macroeconomics, public expenses and business economics as well as impact on citizens.
It is pointed out that the design will improve prosperity and welfare overall. However, the
task in this paper is to conceptualize the design and not to carry out an economical
analyse. Furthermore, the impact on business economics and business administration is
difficult to estimate. On the one hand, the design will strengthen the companies' selection
right among the labour force and at the same time release the companies from handling
of job applications. On the other hand, the job certificate is introduced, whose economic
impact must be investigated further.
7
Chapter 10
The chapter gives a short introduction to the company "Law Computer Interaction"
responsible for creating and conceptualization of the new design "Perfect2Job".
8
3 Automated pairing
3.1 The new pairing
The design is based on algorithm pairing of companies and job seekers. Each company
runs their job advertisement up against all job seekers in order to get a list of candidates
who meet the job advertisement requirements – a “pairing-list” will be created, cf. figure
3.1.
Figure 3.1. Pairing job advertisement and CV box
When algorithm pairing can occur, this is because the data base for the companies and
the job seekers is in place with the necessary depth and quality.
High data quality is a prerequisite for digitizing the process of pairing companies and job
seekers.
Designing the job advertisement data layer will govern how the automatic pairing occurs.
An important characteristic of algorithm pairing is that the company can get close to "full
information" about the job seekers' fulfilment of the job advertisement's requirements at
the given time.
There will be variation on the number of job seekers meeting the requirements on the
different job types.
9
On some job types, there will be a very large number of job seekers on the pairing-list and
the company may choose to concentrate the application process on - for example - the
first 30 job seekers on the list. For other job types, the number of job seekers may be very
limited. The company can carry out further investigations on which of the job
requirements that particularly limit the number of job seekers.
The company will be able to set a minimum level for fulfilling the job advertisement
requirements in relation to the pairing list, cf. the term "cut-off" in the figure.
The objective of the design is to provide a first thorough screening of the job seekers' that
satisfy requirements in a given job advertisement. It will be based on professional
qualifications (e.g. education) and skills (e.g. job experience) among job seekers and
hence the more objective parts of the job requirements.
Job seeker's personal skills will be subject to assessment through personal contact,
interviews, tests, etc. during the further recruitment process. It is the authors of this
report's position that AI is "problematic" for the part of the recruitment process which
concerns personal contacts and interviews and therefore not part of the new design.
The pairing lists will give the companies a good basis for selecting who they will continue
with in the subsequent recruitment process.
Box 3.1. Why use the concept "pairing" instead of "match"
The concept "match" is used today when an employer and job seeker find each other.
In the new design, this concept is rejected as it could lead one’s mind to think of "the
only one", "the right one", etc.
This would be a wrong perception of the job market and the companies' recruitment,
when the companies have high turnover on employees and many relatively short
employments. For example, in Denmark in 2017, almost 700 thousand people shifted
jobs7 corresponding to 24 per cent of the workforce. Therefore, we have chosen to use
the concept "pairing" rather than "match" and hereby emphasize that many job seekers
fulfil a job ad and that they do it with different degrees and profiles of competencies,
skills and qualifications. In other words, recruiting is a "relative" and not "absolute"
task.
3.2 “The selection right” changes
3.2.1 Abolishment of the job application
"Who" chooses "who" change with the new design.
Today, the selection right lies with the job seeker who selects which companies that
receives an application. The source of the pairing between the company and the job
seeker is today the "application". This approach comes from "old-time" with job
advertisements and applications on paper, which has contributed to information barriers
on labour market.
In the new design, the companies are paired with all job seekers8 who meet the company's
job requirements in whole or in part. The design means that society gets closer to a job
market with "full" information.
7
Not to be confused with the number of job changes of over 800,000 in 2017
8 As mentioned, there are proposed rules for anonymity.
10
In the new design, it is not possible to receive an "application"9 from the job seeker. The
individual company may well continue to receive an application, but it is not part of this
design. It may also be necessary to maintain the application for companies recruiting
outside the EU. When switching to an algorithm pairing between a company and a job
seeker, the selection right, where it has been the job seeker who decided which
companies that shall receive an application, will lapse.
Generally, there are significant problems associated with the current system, as it
contributes to what can be called "application-randomness", where it can be accidental
whether the job seeker see the relevant ads, prepares and sends the application to the
companies. This randomness is minimized by the new design.
For a company to have “the selection right" in relation to a job seeker, it is required that
the jobseeker has opened his CV box. As already described, all citizens above the age of
18 are suggested to have a CV box, but it is the citizens - provided they do not receive
public unemployment benefit - who choose whether to want to be job seeker and thereby
open their CV box for job search, cf. figure 6.1.
The fact that the companies take over the selection right is offset by the fact that the job
seekers get a legal right to see with which companies their CV is paired. However, this
does not apply if the company has chosen to maintain secrecy and anonymity, cf. section
5.3.2.
3.2.2 "Not unemployed" jobseekers
The "not unemployed" jobseekers include, in principle, all job seekers who do not receive
unemployment benefits. It can be employed, self-employed, assisting spouses, trainees,
and persons on public support with no obligation to take on employment (e.g. public
pension etc.). In principle, in this system one will be able to be on public elderly pension
combined with being a job seeker.
All CVs of the citizens will be electronically stored in the CV boxes, but not necessarily
available for job search, cf. figure 6.1. The individual CV owner must "turn on" or "turn
off" his CV box. The individual CV owner can also decide on a "job search policy" via the
CV box settings. The non-unemployed jobseekers will, among other things, have the
following opportunities to set filters on the job search:
Filtering on industries level, company level, employment level or geographical level.
Only companies that pass-through filters will have access to the owner's CV, and
thus the CV Box will not be open to other companies
Block for current employer
Current employer cannot see that the CV owner is job seeker
Anonymity.
If the CV owner has chosen to be anonymous as job seeker, the owner is notified about
pairing with a company and can then decide whether the company is going to be informed
about the owner's name etc. The CV owner decides, if and when identification will
happen, however not later than confirmation of participation in an interview or the like,
to which the owner has been invited.
9 When a job applicant comes into contact with a company in the new design, it happens without the "application", as we
know it today. A job seeker may still choose to use the application and apply unsolicited to the company. However, it will not
be part of the new design, which will only work through pairing, where companies and jobseekers virtually are doing nothing
to establish contact.
11
3.2.3 The job seeker on unemployment benefits etc.
In general, it will be the individual CV owner who decides whether the CV box should be
available of pairing. However, this does not apply to unemployed receiving public benefits
such as unemployment benefits, and hence have an obligation to be available to the
labour market. The unemployed will be obliged to have his CV box turned on for job
search.
There will thus be full availability for pairing if the owner of the CV box receives
unemployment benefit with an obligation to be available to the labour market. In this case
the vacant CV owner will not be able to limit the job search to selected jobs, industries or
specific named companies in a way that does not comply with rules of availability.
The unemployed job seeker receiving unemployment benefits cannot opt out of a pairing
with companies that demands labour with qualifications and skills that the unemployed
possess. Apart from this, the unemployed will otherwise be treated in the same way as all
other job seekers. The unemployed also has legal requirements of anonymity and
notification as the not unemployed job seeker. If an unemployed CV owner, who wants
to be anonymous, gets exquisite and paired, he is then informed about the job
advertisement to which he is exquisite. The CV owner will also receive notification of the
company's name10 and how many other job seekers that have been included in the pool
of applicants11 for the position in question as well as his degree of fulfilment of the
company's requirements. Unlike the not unemployed CV owner, the unemployed owner
receiving public benefit cannot specify "no interest" but will always have to accept an
invitation for job interview etc, if the company wishes to move on to this.
In general, it is an objective for the new design to minimize discrimination between
unemployed job seekers and the non-unemployed job seekers. Therefore, the new design
proposes that the companies searching for employees are not informed about
employment status on the job seekers and therefore will not be able to opt-out of
screening and pairing with the category of public unemployment benefit recipients etc.
In Denmark, rules exist with regards to what job offerings recipients of unemployment
benefits are obliged to take on based on e.g. total daily transport time by public transport.
Whether such availability rules shall be incorporated into the algorithm is a political
choice.
However, it is important to emphasize that an unemployed recipient of public
unemployment benefit - selected by a company for participating in interviews etc. - can
refuse a job offer without consequences on the benefit if the job offer falls outside the
legal duty to be available to the labour market.
Finally, it should be mentioned that the political ideological discussion of the rules of
availability in the algorithm is important both for the unemployed job seekers as well as
the recruiting companies. In this report, however, it has first and foremost been chosen
to create a design that ensures that the unemployed jobseeker gets back into job and
therefore it has been chosen not to include the entire political discussion on availability
rules.
10
Does not apply if the company is anonymous.
11 Which can be both unemployed and non-unemployed.
12
3.2.4 Easy to be a job seeker - for both employed and
unemployed
A global trend in recruitment is to avoid making it unnecessarily cumbersome and time
consuming to seek jobs.
Or, to put it another way: It must be easier to be job seeker. Therefore, one goes more
towards data driven recruitment. The new design can be seen as part of this global trend,
but where it has been chosen to combine "the data-driven" with legislation.
The proposal here for a new design challenges tradition and history and in the future, the
job seekers (both the employed and the unemployed jobseekers) no longer has to spend
time on:
reading job ads
to "select" job ads and thereby which companies to receive the application / CV
to write application / CV
filling / uploading / submitting application / CV
3.3 Other recruitment and search channels
The new design only concerns the job advertisement channel and does not affect the
other recruitment channels, for example, unsolicited application, network or social media
(Facebook, LinkedIn etc.), cf. chapter 5. Companies and non-unemployed job seekers who
wish to continue using these channels will be able to do it. If so, it will be up to the
individual non-unemployed job seekers to combine it with his CV box, which is fully or
partly open to job search. If a CV box owner receiving unemployment benefit will also be
able to use these channels but will have to combine it with a CV box, which is fully open
to companies' job advertisements.
13
4 The common labour market
ontology - a common "job"
language
4.1 Why a common labour market ontology?
The new design revolves around the establishment of a common labour market ontology
on skills, occupations and qualifications in relation to demand and supply of labour.
Popularly one can talk about a “common job language”.
Establishing a common labour market ontology is crucial for limiting the information
barrier on the labour market so the employer can easily recruit the right employees and
the job seekers can easily get a new job that fulfils preferences, qualifications and
competencies.
The need for common ontologies, among other things, occurs when there are many and
different actors without the existence of "one force" to promote common and shared
concepts, terms and relations. This is a hallmark of the job market par excellence. When
we talk about the new design uses the discipline “AI and law” this is mainly due to the
common ontology.
There are several tools to create "one force" to promote common and shared terms, of
which legislation (especially if it is sanctioned) is one of the strongest. The EU Member
State’s parliaments have not taken legislative decisions to create common national
ontologies - common and shared conceptualization within the national labour market.
The EU, on the other hand, has done it on the EU level. Therefore, the EU Member States
are now subject to legal regulation in this area in accordance with Regulation 2016/589
on EURES.
The initiative in EU for creating a “common job language” is named “the European Skills,
Competences, Qualifications and Occupations” (ESCO) and developed by the EU, in
accordance with Article 19 of the EURES Regulation.
ESCO has been developed as part of strengthening the free movement of workers and
thus EURES and is part of the “Europe 2020” strategy. A common labour market ontology
is thus something that is decided and not a “new burden”. In the new design it is proposed
to use ESCO to strengthen information and transparency in national labour markets and
hereby getting closer to a more perfect labour market.
ESCO unites labour market and education in a consistently, transparently and applicably
manner with the "common job language" nationally as well as at EU level. ESCO has been
developed by the EU for the EU. However, ESCO is also a very important tool at national
level to ensure productivity, growth and prosperity in the future. Therefore, countries
outside the EU may also benefit from using ESCO.
The labour market as domain is one of the best examples from the discipline “AI and law”
of how significant ontologies are in some areas, their importance and impacts. Ontologies
have been discussed for many years in international academic circles and, not least, in
relation to the discipline of "AI and law". However, in order to use ESCO, it is not necessary
to have insight into ontologies or "AI and law". ESCO is well developed as a tool for
practical use in management of labour market.
14
ESCO - a judicial reality in the EU
As mentioned ESCO is now a “judicial reality” as the European Commission has adopted
the Implementing Decisions provided for in Article 19 of Regulation 2016/589/EU
regarding EURES. There are two implementing decisions.
The implementing Decision No 2018/1020 establishes the list of skills, competences
and occupations of the European classification (ESCO) to be used for the operation
of the EURES common IT platform as provided for in Article 19 of Regulation (EU)
2016/589 and lays down the procedures to update and review this list.
The Implementing Decision (No 2018/1021) lays down the technical standards and
formats necessary for the operation of the automated matching through the
common IT platform using the European classification (ESCO) and the
interoperability between national systems and the European classification.
Each EU Member State must decide within 3 years from mid-2018 how to implement
ESCO and therefore whether
to adopt the European classification (ESCO) (option 1), or
to map their current national classifications to ESCO for the purpose of the common
IT platform (option 2).
Box 4.1. About ESCO
Art. 19 of the Regulation 2016/589/EU stipulates that the Commission develops a
European classification –named ESCO - for the modernization of EURES with a common
IT platform to increase interoperability and allow a better matching of people to vacant
jobs across borders. Implementing acts has been adopted July 2018 and from this date
Member States have up to three years to adopt ESCO or to map to it for the purpose of
the common IT platform.
The development of ESCO was launched in 2010 by the Commission with an open
stakeholder consultation. ESCO is an important deliverable to support the Europe 2020
strategy. Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion manages the
development and continuous updating of the ESCO classification.
ESCO is an ontology encompassing a representation, formal naming, and definition of
concepts, terms, relations and properties of the labour market domain. An ontology as
ESCO can be seen as part of the 21st century "political toolbox" and are an important
part of "AI and law".
What should the EU Member States implement?
The resources required for handling the implementation depends on the decision of the
Member States. If a Member State decides to adopt ESCO nationally (option 1), the
resources required on classifications will be less in the longer run than the resources
required if the decision is to map current national classifications to ESCO (option 2).
Moreover, the mapping will be a regularly recurring activity as ESCO will be continuously
updated.
Member States that adopt option 1 share with the new design the use of ESCO as
classification. It is important to understand that a common labour market ontology is the
foundation and cornerstone of the new design. The common labour market ontology can
thus be used in the design of job advertisements, job certificates on job experience and
15
lifelong learning and educational certificates incl. content of courses. The consequence of
using the common labour market ontology is that job advertisements, as far as the data
layer12 is concerned, no longer solely can have their own invented vocabulary of terms
and meaning. The same is true of education and their content, as well as a description of
job experience. A common labour market ontology such as ESCO will, when applied to
labour market policy as is the case in the new design, establish strong connections
between labour market supply and demand as well as education and employment and
hereby tiering them together in a new way.
4.2 Structure of ESCO
ESCO is a 3 pillar-structure. One of the pillars is occupation. Another pillar is knowledge,
skills and competences. Finally, the pillar regarding qualification. The arrows in Figure 4.1
shows that there are relationships between the pillars.
ESCO is a common ontology that describes metadata, structure and relationships.
The term "skill" will be used in three different meanings. First, it will be used to define a
“skill” as methods or instruments in a particular setting and in relation to defined tasks.
Secondly, it will be used in the meaning of where it covers both the terms “skill and
competence”. The term “competence” means the proven ability to use knowledge, skills
and personal, social and/or methodological abilities, in work or study situations, and in
professional and personal development.
Thirdly, it can be used as a collective term of the skill pillar covering skills, competences
and knowledge as a whole.
Figure 4.1. The pillars of ESCO
ESCO can be considered as based on concepts. A concept is a thing, idea or shared
understanding of “something” and not language dependent and it can be represented by
“a term” in a language. Each concept in ESCO is associated with at least one term in each
EU-language but the term is language dependent and differs between the EU-language.
ESCO operates with a term hierarchy divided into three types of terms: preferred terms,
non-preferred terms and hidden terms. A term has always a relationship with a concept
in ESCO.
A preferred term is unique i.e. the preferred term for an occupation cannot describe other
occupations and be reused for skills. For each concept there is always one – and only one
- unique preferred term in each language in ESCO.
12 The text part of the job advertisement will not be covered by the common labour market ontology, cf. Chapter 5.
16
There are also other terms referring to the same/similar concept as a preferred term and
ESCO can therefore contain several terms per concept in each language. These terms –
that are not preferred terms - are named non-preferred term or alternative terms and can
be synonyms (words with similar or the same meanings) or abbreviations, spelling
variants, declensions.
A hidden term is also referring to the same/similar concept as a preferred term or as non-
preferred terms but is decided to be hidden because it is outdated, misspelled or
politically incorrect. When using a hidden term, the user is redirected to the preferred
term.
The categorization of a term into preferred and non-preferred is determined by "a
decision" within ESCO.
4.2.1 Occupation pillar
There are currently almost 3000 different occupations (ESCO v1).
An occupation is not “a job” but instead “a set of jobs” with high degree of similarities
regarding main task and duties13.
Figure 4.2. shows metadata for occupation and relations with other ESCO pillars and is
divided into "terms", "content" and "relations". The occupation concept can be seen as
the sum of the data on the metadata.
Figure 4.2. Metadata of the occupation pillar
Source: https://ec.europa.eu/esco/portal/occupation (9/10-2019).
13 The ESCO occupations include:
relevant occupations at EU level, regardless of the size of the business;
self-employed occupations;
volunteer-based occupations;
subsistence-based occupations;
arts and crafts occupations;
political mandates in case they constitute a job (e.g. mayor).
17
Ad terms
Terms comprises the preferred term and the alternative (non-preferred) and hidden
terms for the occupation as defined above.
Ad content
For each occupation there is a description of the meaning of the occupation and how it
should be understood - the main idea of what the occupation is about and how it differs
from other occupations. If the description is either widely accepted (for example agreed
by social partners at a European level) or legally binding throughout the EU it is captured
in "formal definition". The scope note is used for clarification.
Scope note is used in ESCO to reduce ambiguity. It clarifies specialties within the
framework or refers users to other similar employment.
Regulatory aspects concern when laws regulate access to an occupation in Member States
providing a direct reference to the Regulated Professions Database.
Ad relations
Relations relate partly to the relations to other classifications for occupation, such as ISCO,
and partly to the other pillars of ESCO, i.e. the pillar of skills and the pillar of qualification.
ISCO-08 - International Standard Classification of Occupations - is developed by the
International Labor Organization (ILO). Since ISCO-08 is a well-known classification
system, ESCO has chosen to maintain the ISCO-08's overall structure. Since ISCO-08 has
too little granularity, ESCO has been expanded downwards. Each occupation in ESCO is
hereby incorporated into the ISCO-08 structure.
For each occupation ESCO distinguishes between essential and optional competencies
and skills as well as essential and optional knowledge. "Essential" refers to the knowledge,
skills and competencies normally required within an occupation profession, independent
of work context or employer. "Optional" refers to the knowledge, skills and competences
that may be necessary or occur depending on the employer, the work context or
nationally.
Figure 4.3 illustrates "the ontological elements" expressed for a single selected
occupation, namely the occupation as a carpenter in Denmark translated into English.
There are two alternative terms in Danish for carpenters. The number of alternative terms
differs nationally. E.g. in the English version, there are considerably more alternative or
non-preferred terms for carpenters. In the figure, the lists of essential and optional skills,
competencies and knowledge for employment as a carpenter is shortened for the sake of
the overview.
18
Figure 4.3. Occupation pillar illustrated with the occupation "carpenter"
Source: http://data.europa.eu/esco/occupation/2a22ff9e-de3b-408d-b312-5034896cc4f4 (9/10-2019)
4.2.2 Skills pillar
Currently, the ESCO skills pillar (version 1) contains 13 485 competencies14. The pillar is
important for pairing or matching.
The skills pillar covers the following 3 elements: Knowledge, skills and competences.
Figure 4.4 indicates metadata for the skills pillar i.e. the terms, content and relations.
14 September 2019. The number must be expected to grow in line with ESCO's expansion
19
Figure 4.4. Metadata of the skills pillar
Source: https://ec.europa.eu/esco/portal/skill (9/10-2019)
With regard to explanation of "terms" (preferred, non-preferred (alternative) and hidden)
and "content" (description, definition and scope note), reference is made to the
explanation above for the occupation pillar.
Ad Skill Type
ESCO distinguishes between two skill types, namely skill/competence and knowledge.
“Skills type” is added under the heading "content" in figure 4.4.
ESCO do not distinguish between the terms “skill” and “competence”. ESCO's definition
of skills types is based on the European Qualifications Framework (EQF), which is
described under the qualification pillar. However, ESCO deviates from the EQF by having
skills and competences merged under the headline “skill”.
So far as a distinction is going to be made the term “skill” refers to the ability to apply
knowledge and use know-how to complete tasks and solve problems. Skills can be
described as cognitive (involving the use of logical, intuitive and creative thinking) or
practical (involving manual dexterity and the use of methods, materials, tools and
instruments).
ESCO express “competence” as the proven ability to use knowledge, skills and personal,
social and/or methodological abilities, in work or study situations, and in professional and
personal development. In EQF and therefore also in ESCO competence is described in
terms of responsibility and autonomy.
The skill type “knowledge” is on the other hand separated for itself. Knowledge is the
outcome of the assimilation of information through learning. It is the body of facts,
principles, theories and practices that is related to a field of work or study area.
ESCO distinguishes between the uses of skills (i.e. skill, competence and knowledge) and
divide the use into 4 levels. The classification is used to express the degree of usability of
a skill, which determine the degree of occupational and educational mobility, see figure
4.5.
20
Figure 4.5. ESCO's classification of the skill reusability level
At one end, there are job-specific skills that can only be used within one
occupation/employment category, cf. figure 4.5. Then comes sector-specific skills that are
relevant to an entire sector15 and not just a specific occupation. Skills can also be relevant
for more jobs in several sectors - referred to as cross-sectoral. Finally, there are
completely transversal competences, which are also often described with the term "core",
"basic" or "soft". It also consists of thinking, language, use of knowledge, social interaction
and attitudes and values.
Skill contextualisation
A skill can move from being transversal to the cross-sector level and/or on to the sector-
specific level and/or maybe even right down to the occupation-specific level. In each
jump, it becomes more and more specific and adapted to a sector or occupation. It still
contains elements from the previous level, but each time it moves down, additional
specializations are added. In ESCO, this mechanism or method it is called skill
contextualisation.
ESCO defines skill contextualisation as follows:
“A method to create knowledge or skill and competence concepts by analysing how
transversal skills, competences or knowledge are applied in the specific context of a sector
or an occupation. This allows bringing transversal knowledge, skills and competences
which are rather abstract to a more detailed level so that they can be directly used in
occupational profiles. Example: The skill “measure” is too abstract to be linked directly to
the occupation “metal furnace operator”. This relationship would produce too many
results if used in competence-based job matching since measuring is relevant for a large
number of occupations and sectors.
Through skill contextualisation, the skill can be made more specific. A skill named
“measure furnace temperature” could, for example, be used in the occupational profile of
the “metal furnace operator”16.
15 ESCO uses the NACE classification - the statistical classification of economic activity in the EU - consisting of 21 main
activities (or sectors).
16 https://ec.europa.eu/esco/portal/escopedia/Skill_contextualisation
21
Skill contextualization is the method of moving from abstract to the specific level.
Contrary hereto, decontextualization is the method for generalizing on occupation-
specific knowledge or skill/competence.
The transversal skill “carry out work-related measurements” is used for exemplification
of contextualization in figure 4.6. “Carry out work-related measurements” as skill has
many narrower skills. At cross-sector level it is for example “measure materials” and
“calculate materials”. At sector-specific level it is for example “measure pollution” and
“measure ship tonnage”. At occupation-specific level it is for example “inspect
semiconductor components” and “calculate aircraft weight”.
The figure also exemplifies the invers process going from the narrower to a broader skill,
i.e. decontextualization. Contextualisation/decontextualization is important for pairing on
the labour market.
Figure 4.6. Skill contextualization
There has been special interest in digital skills. ESCO classifies these as cross-sectorial
competencies. The Commission has thus developed what is called DigComp172.0. It is a
common vocabulary for digital competences at European level. DigComp's competence
framework has been integrated into ESCO as digital transversal competencies.
Ad Relations
The skills pillar has two kind of relationship.
A relationship between skills
Many skills have a hierarchical relationship described by the terms “narrower” or
“broader” and which express skill contextualization/decontextualization and which
can be useful information for the labour market.
The skill's relationship with the occupation pillar.
Relationship of the skills pillar to the occupation pillar is also described in the
column "relations" where all occupations using the skill concerned is mentioned.
The relationship is divided into “essential” or “optional”, where “essential” means
that the skill generally is relevant in the occupation independent of work context,
employer or country. “Optional” refers to occupations where the skill may be
17
https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/publication/eur-scientific-and-technical-research-reports/digcomp-20-digital-competence-
framework-citizens-update-phase-1-conceptual-reference-model
22
required or occur depending on the employer, on the working context or on the
country.
The relations between the occupation and skill pillar is described in figure 4.3 showing
the part of the ontology of the carpenter, which relates to occupation, where it
appears that the carpenter has many competences/skills and much knowledge.
Among these, the skill "interpret 2D plans" has been selected, cf. figure 4.7. This is a
sector-specific skill. It is also stated, in which occupations the competence/skill
"interpreting 2D plans" is "essential" and “optional” respectively.
Further, “interpret 2D plans” is an example of a skill that does not have a “broader” or
“narrower” relation to other skills and can thus not be (de)contextualized.
Figure 4.7. The skills pillar illustrated with the carpenter's skill "interpret 2D plans"
Source: https://ec.europa.eu/esco/portal/skill?uri=http%3A%2F%2Fdata.europa.eu%2Fesco%2Fskill%2Fdfce2aba-783e-
4e17-9c17-e74aca505ec2&conceptLanguage=da&full=true#&uri=http://data.europa.eu/esco/skill/dfce2aba-783e-4e17-
9c17-e74aca505ec2
4.2.3 Qualification pillar
A qualification in ESCO means the formal outcome of an assessment and validation
process which is obtained when a competent body (a nationally approved educational
institution18 19 or the like) determines that an individual has achieved learning outcomes
to given standards. As can be seen, ESCO uses learning outcomes, which are statements
of what an individual knows, understands and is able to do on completion of a learning
process defined by the term "knowledge", "skills" and "competences". Qualifications are
acquired through teaching, training and studies.
18 See “European Qualifications Framework” (EQF). ESCO's qualification pillar has also been developed in accordance with
EQF.
19 The official definition of qualification: “As defined by EQF Recommendation, a qualification is the formal outcome of an
assessment and validation process which is obtained when a competent body determines that an individual has achieved
learning outcomes to given standards (2016)” p.13, https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/ST-96202017-
INIT/en/pdf
23
All the metadata of the qualification pillar in ESCO will also be part of the new design, cf.
figure 4.8.
Figure 4.8. Metadata of the qualification pillar
Source: https://ec.europa.eu/esco/portal/qualification?conceptLanguage=en (9/10-2019) 20
Education is a national competence area. When education is a national matter, then the
qualification pillar also becomes a national matter. This design proposes that the
qualification pillar should use ESCO as far as possible and therefore the design will deviate
from the Member States' description of their education if they do not use ESCO as their
starting point for the description of their qualification pillar. The use of ESCO in the
qualification pillar in the new design will minimize the challenge to link the learning
outcomes of qualifications with the ESCOs skills pillar21. ESCO collects data on
qualifications from the Member States but they will not be validated. By October 2019,
there are so far only nine countries that have uploaded national qualifications to ESCO's
qualification pillar. For most EU Member States, the qualification pillar in ESCO is not in
place yet.
In the following, "the qualification pillar" is described as it must be developed in the new
design. To visualize we use the Danish carpenter education as an example, cf. figure 4.8.
There are alternative programs in Denmark to follow to qualify to carpenter. Our example
is based on the vocational education and training (VET) program, in Danish named “EUD”.
The learning outcome of the Danish vocational education and training (VET) to carpenter
is exemplified below, cf. figure 4.9. It is divided into basic level (cf. figure 4.10) and main
level (cf. figure 4.11).
In the new design, inclusion of data on content of completed courses of the education is
proposed but as it is not part of the qualification pillar of ESCO is it not described here.
Inclusion of course content in the qualification pillar is described in chapter 6.
EQF (the European Qualifications Framework for Lifelong Learning) level is included as
metadata, cf. Figures 4.8 and 4.9. The EQF is an EU initiative that enables the
comparability of qualifications at all levels across the EU. The Member States educational
certificates are currently subject to EQF level. Some Member States (e.g. Denmark) has
20The qualification pillar is shown as originally designed in ESCO.
21 For discussion of the challenge to provide insights into how the learning outcomes of qualifications included in the ESCO
pillar could be linked with the ESCO skills pillar, and how technical tools can provide effective and cost-efficient solution see
”RfS 43 - support for the development of the ESCO qualifications pillar. Final Report v7 February 2019, European
Commission".
24
chosen to build own qualification framework - abbreviated NQF - which, however,
translates into the EQF.
ECTS (European Credit Transfer System) is also included as metadata, cf. figures 4.8 and
4.9. It has also been introduced to create consistency and has been compulsory to use in
all the Member States for higher education since 200122. ECTS points do not say anything
about the level of the individual course, but only workload. In the ECTS system a full-time
study year comprises 60 ECTS points with an expected workload of a total of 1,500 and
1,800 hours to realize the learning objectives.
The qualification pillar also links the national education to the UNESCO-developed
international classification system ISCED - International Standard Classification of
Education23, cf. Figures 4.8 and 4.9. The purpose of ISCED is to have uniform,
internationally agreed definitions and are used to facilitate comparison of statistics and
indicators on education across countries. As a result of the EQF, ISCED is not interesting
today in a European context.
Figure 4.9. Qualification pillar illustrated with the qualification "carpenter (EUD)"
Note: It is the vocational education and training (VET) to carpenter, which is named EUD in Danish, that is described. There
are several other programs in Denmark qualifying to carpenter.
As far as EQF level is concerned, the carpentry education is on level 4, cf. figure 4.9. This
classification is based on the fact that the carpentry training meets the learning outcomes
required for level 4, namely:
Knowledge: Factual and theoretical knowledge in broad contexts within a field of
work or study.
Competences and skills: A set of cognitive and practical skills required to generate
solutions to specific problems within a field of work or study; exercise self-
management within the guidelines of work or study contexts that are usually
predictable but are subject to change; supervise the routine work of others, taking
some responsibility for the evaluation and improvement of work or study activities.
22 Therefore, there is no ECTS for carpentry education (cf. figure 4.9). It is difficult to get an assessment of what diploma
certificates from before 2001 today correspond to in ECTS points.
23 The ESCO qualification pillar will be linked so far with ISCED Fields of Education and Training (ISCED-F) from 2013.
25
As can be seen, the EQF is at a high level of abstraction and less applicable for search and
recruitment purposes. As seen in figure 4.8 and 4.9 a description of the qualification is a
requirement in ESCO, but the degree of specification is a decision of the EU Member
States and not “in the hands” of EU/ESCO.
In the following, it is chosen to use the official legislative description of the Danish
qualification to carpenter (EUD) as the description. This is a more detailed description of
the qualification than the EQF.
The education structure of the qualification “carpenter” (EUD) consists of the basic level
and the main level. The learning outcomes as described in the legislation for the basic
level is shown in figure 4.10.
The main level of the qualification “carpenter” (EUD) is shown 4.11.
Figure 4.10. Description of the "basic level" of the VET qualification to "carpenter (EUD)"
Note: (A Danish) Executive Order the Woodworking Construction Training no 373 26. April 2018
26
Figure 4.11. Description of the "main course" of the VET qualification to "carpenter
(EUD)"
Educations are changed and hence qualifications. Therefore, it is crucial that the
qualification pillar contains both the existing layer as it is represented in the educational
system at the moment, and a historical layer. The latter represents educations still present
in the workforce but no longer offered in the current educational system. In the new
design every time an education changes, in principle, a new current layer is added, and
the previous layer must simultaneously be added to the historical archive on the national
level. It should be mentioned that the enlarged ESCO will be of great importance in
avoiding repetitions of previous learning and thereby contribute to more effective lifelong
learning efforts. The qualification pillar do not recommend a historic archive.
Any employer can go directly into the ontology - in the expanded ESCO - as set out in the
new design and search for a specific competences, skills and knowledge and see which
degree programs meet these. How the qualification pillar is converted into a personal
qualification profile - education profile - is described in chapter 6 about the CV box.
4.3 Update of ESCO
An important challenge is to keep ESCO up to date. New types of jobs are created and
existing are renamed while others disappear. New knowledge and new skills and
competences are offered and demanded, while others get obsolete. Updating ESCO is an
important challenge and must be done continuously. The challenge must be seen in the
context of ESCO covering the entire EU and thus all Member States.
The EU has drawn up a plan for the continuous updating process of ESCO. Possible
improvements to the ontology are decided by the ESCO Team24 on behalf of the
24
The ESCO team works on behalf of the Commission under the Commissioner for Employment, Social Affairs, Skills and
Labor Mobility.
27
Commission and are based on feedback from various sources (national and international
classifications, studies, stakeholders, etc.). At each stage of the updating process,
different actors will participate (ESCO domain experts, maintenance committees, etc.)
and various tools and techniques such as online forums, interviews and large data analysis
will be put into use. In the development of new versions of ESCO, the Commission will
involve architects and domain experts as well as labour market and educational system
stakeholders.
Establishing a common Member States labour market ontology, which actively builds on
ESCO, will promote a joint intelligent development of the labour market nationally as well
as on the EU level. This can, if necessary, be through an extended involvement of the
discipline "AI and law" in relevant areas.
28
5 Job advertisement
5.1 Job advertisement and other recruitment
channels
Results from existing studies on recruitment have been included in the analysis work prior
to the development of the design25. In the following, it has been chosen to refer Ballisager
Recruitment Analysis26 – yearly recruitment analysis performed by the Danish recruitment
company Ballisager.
According to Ballisager, Danish employers use several recruitment channels per.
employment. Job advertisement have been used in total for approx. 76 per cent of
recruitments, but with great differences. In small private companies, 59 per cent of
vacancies have been advertised through job ads in Denmark. In large private companies
it is 82 per cent. Public employers advertise 86 per cent of the posts. Danish private
companies generally use networks as a recruitment channel. The use of public
employment service centres (PES) as a recruitment channel has traditionally been low in
Denmark. This is also the case for the use of temporary agency/recruitment agencies and
external CV databases. The Ballisager Recruitment Analysis is carried out annually in
Denmark and points to increasing use of LinkedIn and Facebook as a recruitment channels
since 2011 and 2013 respectively, however with a small decline from 2018 to 2019.
Table 5.1 Use of recruitment channels in Denmark 2019
Several responses per respondent Use of recruitment channels among Danish
Total companies/authorities
Small private Large private Public
Traditional channels -------------------------------per cent----------------------------
Job advertisements 76 59 82 86
Network 58 70 63 40
Unsolicited job applications 25 27 28 19
Public employment service centres 17 24 13 16
Internal candidates 21 12 29 19
External CV-databases 5 7 4 2
Temp and recruitment agency 18 19 26 7
Social media
LinkedIn 51 47 65 37
Facebook 28 33 28 21
Source: Ballisager recruitment analysis 2019, Figure 4
There are differences between recruitment channels, not the least in respect to required
documentation of qualifications and skills required in relation to the individual job.
Whereas job advertisements have the quality that requirements for qualifications and
competences are well documented, recruitment only based on network or unsolicited
applications is not necessarily well documented with available data. However, it should
25 The following review is based on surveys of the job ad market in Denmark. For job ads, there may be national and cultural
differences, which is why it cannot be generalized based on the Danish case.
26 Jf. https://ballisager.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Rekrutteringsanalysen-2019.pdf?utm_campaign=unspecified&-
utm_content =unspecified&utm_medium=email&utm_source=apsis-anp-3&pe_data=D43405F477347455E4A7347435D4-
471%7C24823080 The analysis work in relation to the development of the design also looked at Ballisager's recruitment
analyses for 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018 and 2019, cf. https://ballisager.com/rekrutteringsanalyse/
29
be noted that the companies typically use several - typically 3 - recruitment channels for
each vacant job position to be filled.
Even though the new design is implemented, the other recruitment and search channels
will continue to be used by companies and job seekers like today. The job advertisement
must work in parallel with other recruitment channels as the new design is aiming at
expanding and improving the opportunities of companies and job seekers and create
greater transparency.
Chapter 7 discusses the institutional set-up for the new design and suggests that
"Perfekt2Job" is operated by the private job portals when they have a strong presence in
the Member State concerned as it is the case in Denmark.
5.2 Job advertisement today in Denmark
Although the job advertisement today is digital, it is still mainly "text". Apart from search
functions and links etc. the job advertisement corresponds virtually to previous job ads
there were published in the newspaper. Digitization has not been deep at job advertising
level in the form of a large data layer on the company's demand for skills and
qualifications. This is because the advertisement is intended to encourage the job seeker
to submit an application. The task of the job advertisement is mainly to "sell" the job. The
Danish job-portal JobIndex emphasizes the conditions for companies that "the candidates
wants in seconds to be able to relate to the company and the job. Candidates often seek
to get a “gut feeling” for whether the job or company is something for them”27. The fact
that a very short time is used to select a job advertisement also applies to the companies'
shortlisting of candidates based on received CVs, cf. section 6.1.
JobIndex has drawn up a guide on designing the job advertisement on the basis of, among
other things, own investigations - hereinafter referred to as JobIndex standard for the job
advertisement.
Below is shown the result of a study from 2016 "about a good job advertisement". It
shows that a precise and easily understandable job title as headline "catches the
attention". In addition, the company's requirements, expectations and description of job
content must be adequate.
Table 5.2 JobIndex analysis of "a good job advertisement" (2016)
More answer options Respondents answering that
this characteristic is important
for a good job ad
Catches attention from the start --------------per cent--------------
Job title / headline 87
Company LOGO/name 36
“Quote” about the job 30
Picture 17
Describes the job and expectations
Company requirements and expectations of the candidate 96
Job content is described in full 95
Company culture and social environment 62
Company turnover and number of employees 22
Source: https://www.jobindex.dk/virksomheder/den-gode-jobannonce?audiencetagid=3&backsupertagid=5 (18/11-2019)
JobIndex standard for the written part of the job advertisement is partly shown in box 5.1.
27 https://www.jobindex.dk/virksomheder/rampletmedjobannoncen?lang=da , (11/10-2018)
30
The recruitment companies may have different recommendations for the content of job
advertisements, including weighting of professional versus personal requirements, the
company's culture and job "day". At JobIndex, the professional qualifications and skills
required by the company (i.e. what the applicant must be able to) is still part of the
recommendation for a good job advertisement, but emphasis is also placed on other
things, including that the company sells the job and itself. JobIndex's advice indicates that
the job advertisement also serves other purposes for the company, such as PR and
branding.
Box 5.1 Extract from JobIndexs' guide to the company with the heading "How to hit the
spot with your job advertisement" (written part)
Five tips for the good job advertisement. The more specific you can be in the job
description, the easier it will be for the candidate to assess whether the job is relevant.
Remember also to translate the worn clichés into words and expressions that say
something about the job, the candidate or you as a business. Put yourself in the
candidates' place and think about what should get exactly the candidates you seek to
get to apply for the job. The candidate may already be in a similar job, so why should
he or she quit the present employment and apply at your company?
1. USE THE IMPORTANT SPACE CORRECT!
The start of the job advertisement is crucial for getting the candidates attention to
continue reading. Therefore, give the job advertisement a precise and easy-to-
understand job title in the headline, and use the first few lines / subheadings to tell the
best about the job or workplace.
Avoid internal/creative job titles as well as general introductions like "Are you looking
for new challenges?"
2. DESCRIBE THE JOB CONTENT
Give the candidate a holistic view of the job and focus on specific tasks and
responsibilities - especially if you are a lesser known company. Describe the everyday
life the candidate will become a part of, and whether there are perspectives in the job.
This section must fill at least 1/4, but preferably 1/3 of the job advertisement.
3. CREATE REALISTIC EXPECTATIONS FOR COMPETENCIES
Be realistic in your wishes for professional and personal skills. Set up 2-4 professional
competencies and select some that are unique to exactly this job in your particular
company - e.g. avoid searching for an accounting assistant with "flair for numbers", as
you probably have if you choose to work with accounting. If you want the personal
competencies included, then as mentioned carefully select those that are needed to be
successful in the job.
4. TELL ABOUT YOUR CULTURE
Over time, your company's image can be affected through the job advertisement. So,
tell about the department, your culture, vision and strategies - and also touch on the
softer values. What are, for example, attractive employee benefits besides wage? You
may link to your company website if you have provided the information there.
5. MAKE IT READER FRIENDLY AND USE THE MEDIUM
Write short sentences and short paragraphs of max 3-4 lines. Give each section a
meaningful heading. If using bullet point format, do not use more than five bullet points
in the same section. Avoid passive wording and use "you" instead of "one" or "the right
candidate". Use relevant links in the job advertisement to provide additional
information if insufficient space or as a service to the candidates -e.g. the annual report,
press review, a map or the travel instructions.
Note: Own translation. There is also a visual guide. However, not to be mentioned further.
Source: https://www.jobindex.dk/img/pdf/saadan-rammer-du-plet.pdf
31
As the JobIndex's analysis and guidelines point out, "word selection" is an important part
of the ad. The fact that it changes over time is stated in an academic study28 of "word
selection" in Danish job advertisements posted on Jobindex in 2007 and 2017
respectively. In total 205,970 job ads were analysed in 2007 and 133,337 in 2017.
The study shows that from 2007 to 2017 there is a clear increase in Danish job
advertisements with words such as “manager”, “chief” and “leader” used for the position
title (48 per cent in the period). Furthermore, it appears that there are examples of job
advertisements that use wordings (metaphors) such as “shark” and “squid” but the level
for this in 2017 is the same as in 2007.
As far as the use of adjectives - describing personality attributes29 - the greatest increase
in use from 2007 to 2017, are observed for the adjectives "creative/innovative",
"structured", "proactive", "curious", "robust/stable", "analytical" , "drive", "work ethic",
"ambitious" and "passionate/dedicated". In 2017, the five most commonly used
adjectives are the same as in 2007, however with increased use of concepts such as "team
player", "independent" and "structured". The use of “mood/happy" and "flexible" are
largely unchanged compared to 2007.
The purpose of the review above is to give an impression of the companies' challenges on
the preparation of the job advertisement. The new design creates a different division of
roles between jobseekers and companies, where the selection right passes to the
companies and the pile of applications disappears and thus the pressure to have to "sell
themselves". The review can justify the new design's proposal to improve the job
advertisement by expanding the ad with a deep and broad data layer based on a common
labour market ontology on the required qualifications and competencies. The proposal
does not affect the job advertisement text, which can continue rich in buzzwords, PR and
branding in unchanged form. In the new design, however, the text section will no longer
play a central role in relation to the pairing of job advertisement and job seeker.
5.3 Design for a better job advertisement
Figure 5.1 shows the proposal for a new design of the job advertisement, which can
strengthen the job advertisement as a data source and contribute to reducing information
barriers in the labour market. The design only affects the job advertisement and no other
recruitment channels.
28 ”Adjektiver og Titler i Danske Jobannoncer. Tekstanalytiske, korpuslingvistiske og semantiske perspektiver” (”Adjectives
and Titles in Danish Job Ads. Text analytic, corpus linguistic and semantic perspectives”) Louise Overgaard Akselsen, Thesis
in Danish, Department of Communication and Humanities, Roskilde University (2017).
29 The word "personality" is understood to mean personality related to the job.
32
Figure 5.1 New design of the job advertisement
In the new design, competences and qualifications are of crucial importance for
recruitment. One reason for this is that Ballisager's recruitment analysis30 indicates that
more than half of the redundancies are related to skills and qualifications: In 40 per cent.
"the employee's professional competence does not meet the requirements" and in 14 per
cent that “there is no need for the employee's competence”. Co-operation skills as cause
for redundancies constitute 31 per cent and the category "do not know" is 15 per cent.
5.3.1 Structure
The new design for a job advertisement consists of three elements:
The text layer as it is known today, including the job title used by the company.
A new data layer that describes the competence and qualification requirements with
the use of the common labour market ontology ESCO.
A data layer with terms for the job. This layer is currently included in the text
section, but it is suggested here to be created as an independent data layer. This
layer is less crucial to the new design and is not discussed further.
The current job design with only one text portion is less suitable for pairing. Since the job
advertisement also serves other purposes for the company such as PR and branding, the
proposed design implies that the company can maintain the textual job advertisement as
it is today. The job ad's text part will also remain important in recruitment because it puts
a "face" on the company and the job. It can especially be important in relation to the
employed job seekers, who must decide whether they are interested if invited to
participate in the further recruitment process of a company.
30Ballisager’s recruitment analysis 2018, table 27.
33
In order to ensure intelligent pairing, the job advertisement is associated with a non-
verbal data layer of information on employment, competence and qualification
requirements designed in accordance with the common labour market ontology. It is
crucial that this data layer is adequate, accurate and factual, because it must be used to
pair with job seekers with the right competencies and qualifications.
Figure 5.2 Example of differences between companies within the same industry in depth
and width of the data layer
Note: The text layer is a representation of 2 historically "real" job ads. The purpose of the illustration is to show that data
created for a job advertisement can be plain and simple like the job advertisement A. Since the data layer does not exist
today, it has been necessary to estimate - from the text etc. - how the data layer for job advertisement A and job
advertisement B could look like when using ESCO.
Source: http://www.jobindexarkiv.dk/cgi/showarchive.cgi?tid=r7650757 (text job advertisement A)
https://www.ofir.dk/resultat/toemrersvend-til-tagarbejde-329865979.aspx?jobId=329865979 (text job advertisement B)
It is the individual company's requirements that determine the extent of the data layer.
Some companies' requirements can be met easily, and the data layer becomes simple.
The requirements of others are special, and the data layer becomes complicated in order
to meet the needs. Below is an example of companies that are looking for carpenters. In
one case, the ad's data layer will be short, cf. figure 5.2. job advertisement A. In the second
case, it will be more comprehensive with additional competencies, skills and knowledge,
cf. figure 5.2. job advertisement B.
5.3.2 Publicity
It will be possible in the new design to open for anonymity and secrecy in relation to the
job advertisement.
By anonymity is here understood that the name of the company is not disclosed in the job
advertisement.
Secrecy is understood as the company is given access to search and pairing between a job
advertisement and the CVs without publishing the text and data layers of the
advertisement to the job seekers. Today, the job advertisement is publicly publicized so
that job seekers can find it, which may be less advantageous in terms of competition. An
advantage of the new design is, among other things, that the company will get better
34
opportunities to keep secret new recruitments as part of, for example, strategic
initiatives.
Secrecy and anonymity are two different settings that can be applied simultaneously.
When that is the case, job seekers do not have a legal right to get information about a
pairing. If the company wants to contact a job seeker with an invitation to participate in
further process of recruitment, anonymity and secrecy are lifted.
The possibility for secret and anonymous searches for labour is one of the options in the
new design that can be ideologically controversial and can be left out of the design.
Overall, the suggested design allows the job advertisement to be conveyed in text, as is
the case today, but supplemented with a data layer with requirement specification for the
job. It is important that the requirement specification meets the company’s needs.
5.3.3 Ontology
The labour market ontology will be common to job advertisements, educational and job
certificates. The data layer must be managed through the joint labour market ontology
ESCO. The text of the job advertisement will continue to be a private matter for the
individual company, which can therefore maintain, for instance, the use of a "marine
animal metaphor"31 in the actual text of the job.
31 For example, to be a "shark .." or "octopus .."
35
6 The CV Box
In order to reduce the information barrier on the labour market and making job seeking
and recruitment easy in the new design, a data layer must be created on the job
applicant's competencies and qualifications which "is of the same quality as" and "can talk
together with" the job advertisement's data layer.
The main source for the applicant competences and qualifications is today the job
applicant self. The applicant describes own competencies and qualifications and attach
himself documentation on educations. When the applicant himself is responsible for the
description of competencies and qualifications, it opens for less accurate or even false
information and cheating, e.g. with educational certificates.
It can be difficult and sometimes close to impossible for the employer to discover this.
The job-seeker's application material does not currently have the form of a validated and
objective data layer on job seekers' competencies and qualifications, that can be
reconciled with the data created in the job advertisement.
In the new design, the data source for the job seeker's CV will no longer be the job seeker
himself. For the job-seeker's educational component (qualifications), input to this part of
the data layer will come directly from responsible educational institutions. In relation to
job experience (competencies and skills), input will come from current and former
employers in the form of job certificates. Data on education and job experience for the
individual job seeker is placed in a CV box, which the companies' job advertisements can
access in connection with pairing.
6.1 The CV today
6.1.1 The companies' use of CV in recruitment
The design is based on a study on the behaviour of companies in relation to received
applications in Denmark32.
Approximately 80 per cent on average of all surveyed companies first reads the CV in the
application. Nine out of ten of the large private companies first reads the CV, and if this
does not catch interest, 56 per cent do not continue reading the application. Of all
companies, 51 per cent nevertheless reads the application, although the CV is not
interesting.
Ballisager's study underlines that CV is important in the initial screening and selection of
candidates.
In general, the companies only use very short time to read the CV and application in the
first screening. On average, less than 2 minutes are used on CV and application
respectively, cf. table 6.1.
It is questionable how deep insight on the individual application it is possible to obtain in
such a short time and the treatment of the individual applicant cannot be deep.
32
The recruitment analysis 2017 from Ballisager, cf. https://ballisager.com/wp-
content/uploads/2017/09/Rekrutteringsanalysen-2017.pdf
36
Table 6.1 How long time does Danish companies spend on reading CV and application
How long time do you use for reading the CV and the job
application respectively in the first screening?
CV Application
-------------------------------per cent----------------------------
I do not read in the first screening 2 11
0-1 minute 16 14
1-2 minutes 41 30
2-3 minutes 26 26
3-5 minutes 12 16
5 minutes or more 2 4
Source: Ballisager Recruitment Analysis 2017, Tables 12 and 13
In the Recruitment Analysis 201833, it is analysed what the employers find negatively
about a CV, cf. table 6.2.
Table 6.2 Danish companies' view of what is negative in a CV
Max 3 responses pr. Respondent Companies /authorities that says
this characteristic is negative in a CV
Over-all
Small Private Large Private Public
-------------------------------per cent----------------------------
The structure of the CV
CV-layout unmanageable 38 32 43 3
Picture on CV missing or unprofessional 30 29 30 31
CV text
CV too long 32 31 31 34
CV initial text unclear (profile text/resumé) 15 16 17 13
Too much insider language in the CV 7 8 7 8
Missing contact information in the CV 7 6 7 8
CV-content (including history)
CV lacks examples on concrete results 44 42 51 36
CV timeline shows gaps not explained
(unemployment, stress, maternity, etc.) 38 36 36 44
Source: Ballisager Recruitment Analysis 2018, Table 7
The employers (44 per cent) find it most negatively when specific results are missing in
the CV. Layout and text are important, and more than 30 per cent of employers find it
negatively with confusing layouts, long text and missing applicant's picture. In the new
design the companies are exempted from these annoyances, where the pairing between
CV and job advertisement is a relationship managed by algorithms. The jobseekers are
thus treated more "equal". If they in the new design are considered for the job, it has
been on the skills and qualifications required by the company and not the jobseeker’s
ability to design CVs according to the recipient company's norms for applications. In the
new design it has been an objective to release the job search process from being a "writing
and layout competition".
The companies also have a negative view on gaps in the timeline that is not explained.
The gaps may be related to history of unemployment, stress, maternity leave, etc.
Particularly, public employers in Denmark consider these gaps not explained to be
negative. The new design can help ensure proper conditions in the labour market for
unemployed, sick, pregnant etc.
33 https://ballisager.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/Rekrutteringsanalysen-2018.pdf
37
In the recruitment analysis 201934 it is further analysed which factors the employers first
look at when reviewing CVs, cf. table 6.3. There are differences in priorities dependent on
the age of the employer (person recruiting), but for all employers, work experience is the
far most important factor, followed by duration of employments, education and special
competencies.
Table 6.3 Which three factors does the Danish employer first look for in a CV?
Max 3 responses pr. respondent Which three factors does the Danish
employer first look for in a CV by age of
employer/person recruiting
18-40 years 41-54 years 55 years of
of age of age age or more
--------------------------per cent-----------------------
Work experience 89 88 89
Education 44 48 54
Place of residence 17 16 14
Durations of employments 59 50 40
Age 8 9 11
Sex 2 1 1
Unemployment periods 18 17 11
Image 17 13 8
Special competencies 34 50 54
Source: Ballisager Recruitment Analysis 2019, Table 19
6.2 The CV as the data source in the new design
6.2.1 CV-box
In the new design, it is proposed that each citizen above the age of 18 is given a CV box.
Educational institutions and employers are obliged to upload CV data so that the CV box
contain all information about the individual citizen's education and experience. The
uploading of certificates to the CV box will release the education institution - and other
public authorities – from the duty to keep the certificates on file. They will also be released
from any other administrative obligations in this regard. Therefore, it will not be possible
for the individual citizen to deny getting a CV box, to which educational institutions and
employers upload documentation. The individual citizen can however opt out of using the
CV box for job search.
In the new design, the CV box will contain educational certificates and data on previous
job experience. These are two different data sources. The educational certificate is
designed by the responsible educational institution, which is thus the source.
The source of previous job experience should be the employers of previous employment
relationship. However, today the source is the job seeker himself, possibly supplemented
by recommendations. A job certificate (proof of experience acquired through job) is today
unlike the educational certificate not an existing, well-known and regulated document.
The recommendation does not constitute such proof, and therefore the job seeker today
is himself a large part of the source of his own CV.
It will be the individual citizen who owns the CV box that is obliged to ensure that the box
is correct regarding the data of CV and thereby a description of his qualifications and
competences obtained from education and job experience. Figure 6.1 shows the structure
of the CV box.
34 https://ballisager.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Rekrutteringsanalysen-2019.pdf
38
Figure 6.1 The structure of the CV box
6.2.2 Job search availability
Besides being able to access his own CV box, the CV owner must also be able to make the
data available to others. The new design operates with two forms of accessibility.
Most importantly is whether the CV box is open to be paired with job ads. It is the owner
of the CV box that makes the CV box available for pairing with companies’ job ads. If the
CV box is available for pairing, the CV owner will have the status of job seeker.
The owner of the CV box can choose to set up criteria for the pairing and filtrering the
companies’ job ads. The criteria limits the pairing. Examples of relevant criteria can be
types of jobs/positions, industries, named companies, geography and distance from
residence.
If the owner does not set out criterias, the pairing will be with all job advertisements with
requirements on skills and qualifications met by the owner of the CV box. The job ads
will, as a starting point, be listed in accordance with the CV box’s degree of fulfillment of
requirements.
Figure 6.2 Correlation between the state of the CV box and its owner
39
Rules for recipients of unemployment benefit differs in the EU. The rules vary between
EU countries as well as within the countries, e.g. between industries, employment
relationships and geographies.
In the new design it is proposed for each Member State to incorporate their respective
national rules as they exist today and therefore not to harmonize these rules so that they
become uniform across the EU.
Some of the essential rules for recipients of unemployment benefit concern the
availability rules of the unemployed to the labour market locally, regionally and at EU
level. These rules relate to how the pairing takes place.
In order to ensure that the unemployed are made aware of the job opportunities locally,
regionally and at EU level, it can be an option for the jobseeker that the pairing takes place
with all job advertisements in the EU35. The reason for this is that it will create the best
possible basis for companies’ selection of candidates for an interview etc. Seen from the
angle of an unemployed, the advantage of opening for pairing at EU level is that it can
stimulate one to think on new paths of one's life and career plan.
The unemployed who is summoned by a company where it is beyond the scope of his
availability obligation may refuse to participate in interviews without further
consequences for the unemployment benefit.
It will be necessary for the authorities to have access to check the CV box’s log of
unemployed job seekers receiving public unemployment benefit with an availability
obligation. This will mainly be automatic. Already today recipients of unemployment
benefit in Denmark must report their job search activities to responsible authorities and
such job search reporting may lapse with the new design. In addition to making it easier
for unemployed job seekers, the new design therefore entails considerable savings on
public authorities' control of unemployed search activities.
6.2.3 Anonymity as a job seeker
It will be possible as a job seeker to be anonymous. It is the owner of the CV box who
decides whether one wants to be an anonymous job seeker.
If a company's job advertisement has paired with the anonymous job seeker and the
company requests contact information for invitation to interview or other recruitment
activities, the owner shall confirm the handing out of the contact information to the
requesting company. If the request is denied, the contact information is not handed out
and the recruiting activity is stopped.
The unemployed jobseeker can also choose to be anonymous. Due to the availability
obligation, anonymity is automatically terminated if a company wishes to contact the
person concerned and therefore requests contact information.
35 This part of the design has similarities as well as differences compared with EURES.
40
Figure 6.3 Coherence between the status of the CV box owner and anonymity when
pairing
6.2.4 Other availability
One form of accessibility concerns whether the public in general has access to view the
contents of the CV box. In the design, the CV box by default has closed access for the
public.
Recruiting through the job advertisement will work in parallel with other recruitment
channels such as unsolicited application, network and social media. Although the CV box
is closed to the public and not in the state of "job seeking", there may be a need for the
owner to grant temporary access to an employer requesting access in connection with
recruitment/job search using other parallel recruitment channels.
It may also be considered to build the CV box so that the owner himself can make it
publicly available, but this is not further elaborated here.
6.3 Education and Diploma
The concept of diploma is commonly used for the evidence received when completing the
entire educational program and have passed the required exams. In the following, other
similar documentation - for example, documentation for a partially completed education
- are included in the concept of the diploma. In the following the concept educational
certificate will be used synonymous with diploma of examination.
Educational certificates do not currently contain full information about the qualifications
acquired from the education regarding knowledge, skills and competences obtained. This
creates the risk of information barriers in relation to companies and the labour market in
general.
When the current educational certificates are not fully informative, it becomes the
companies, which must familiarize itself with the content of the applicants' education.
This increases the information barriers on the labour market and imposes a cost burden
on businesses. Moreover, it does not reduce the burden that the number of different
education programs nationally as well as in the EU are large and constantly under
development, where some cease to exist, the content of some existing educations
changes and new educations are added. This also applies to the content of the programs,
incl. courses.
41
The lack of fully informative educational certificates may cause that the company does
not have full information about the jobseeker's qualifications and skills acquired through
education. It may also have as consequence that the companies may prefer job seekers
with educations already well-known in the company, which not necessarily is the best
solution.
In terms of lifelong learning, the lack of fully informative educational certificates increases
the risk of unjustified repetition rather than expanding the individual's knowledge, skills
and competencies in cases when an educational certificate is not fully informative.
It should be mentioned that in some EU-countries exam databases exist already today,
but often with different purpose and is currently operating according to other principles36.
6.3.1 More data on educational content
The new design has as goal to limit the information barriers regarding knowledge, skills
and competencies acquired through jobseeker's education.
Today's education and educational certificates are regulated differently in the EU-
countries. In some countries by law.
There are currently no common rules for data required on the actual content of the
individual courses to be included on the certificate of an education. Only requirements
are the EU requirement to indicate EQF and ECTS for higher education. EQF is "too
general" to provide answer to whether the requirement to knowledge, skill and
competence of a job advertisement is partly/wholly met through the education. When
the EQF, as is the case today, stands alone, there is the risk that it contributes to deepen
the information barrier of the labour market by not helping the company with information
on what the jobseeker can "do" based on education.
Therefore, an element of the new design is that additional information about the content
of completed courses must be linked to the educational certificates. Specifically, it is
proposed that the educational institutions are obliged to upload information on learning
outcomes of completed courses to the candidate's CV box.
It will not be associated with an additional burden on the educational institutions to
upload - or at least to link - this information about the individual courses, as they are today
largely included in the central educational data bases that provides information to
students. Figure 6.4 shows an example of the course "Project Management" 2018/2019,
Faculty of Engineering, University of Southern Denmark.
As can be seen, a division into competence, skill and knowledge in this course description
is used, and hereby is already close to the common ontology ESCO. Requirements must
be made that the information on the content of the courses in relation to the CV box is
"lasting". The course information can also be used for other purposes such as providing
documentation for getting educational credit etc.
36 In Denmark, as an example, there is a national examination database of high school diplomas from 2004 onwards. This is
used for admission to higher education. In connection with the student's application, the proof is drawn, and algorithm
verification of grades takes place if you have a Danish social security (CPR) number. Currently, only the student can log in and
see his own grades but can neither print nor download a copy of the proof directly from the database. Primary school
diplomas from 2009 onwards can also be retrieved from the citizen portal database (borger.dk) if digitally filed by the school.
42
Figure 6.4 Example of a description of the course37 "Project Management" year
2018/2019, Faculty of Engineering, University of Southern Denmark
Source: https://odin.sdu.dk/sitecore/index.php?a=fagbesk&id=53530&listid=5094&lang=en
6.3.2 Educational certificates - part of the common labour
market ontology
In the EU, information on qualifications is a national matter38. Information on the national
qualifications comes from national qualifications databases which are owned and
managed by the EU Member States. Between the Member States, there are major
differences in organization, culture and legal regulation of education systems.
As mentioned, job advertisements, educational certificates39 and job certificates must be
based on the same ontology. It is a crucial objective of the design that the demand of
labour has a common "language" with the educational supplier of qualifications.
ESCO has chosen to structure the entire qualification column based on the QMS
(Qualifications Metadata Schema) form. The CV certificates of the CV box must, as far as
possible, follow the QMS form.
An important element of the new design is the duty to inform about the content of the
educational programs on course level. It also involves a duty for the educational
institutions to follow the common labour market ontology right down to the course level.
This may probably require legislation.
Digital support will be provided to educational institutions to ensure that fact sheets on
education, examinations and course content, are consistent with the common labour
market ontology as part of “Perfect2Job”. The new design, on the one hand, is set up, to
37 Course Title Project Management and part of the education “Bachelor in Product Development and Innovation”, Faculty
of Engineering, University of Southern Denmark (2019). It is possible to describe each single course using EQF and ECTS.
38 Considerations on the inclusion of private, sectoral and international certificates in the ESCO pillar are discussed "RfS 43 -
support for the development of the ESCO qualifications pillar. Final Report v7 February 2019, European Commission". It is
chosen not to include this issue here.
39 In ESCO, the term qualification is used - not education.
43
follow, as far as possible, ESCO as a kind of common ontology on educational certificates
and, on the other hand, to "expand" ESCO to also be used in relation to course content.
As far as the need of educated labour, the joint labour market ontology will be a powerful
tool to ensure reconciliation of educational institutions' production with business demand
(expressed by job ads). The common ontology will ensure that educational institutions
and companies work on the same "platform" and understand each other - speaking the
same job "language" - and mismatch between supply and demand will become more
readily visible.
6.4 Certificates for job experience
Work experience is the most important factor that the employer first looks for in the CV
(cf. Table 6.3). The design is based on the introduction of a legal requirement of
documentation of the experience acquired by an employee as part of an employment.
Conversely, it implies an obligation of the employer to prepare this documentation.
Today, it is considered good practice to write a recommendation upon end of
employment if requested by the leaving employee. The recommendation distinguishes
between the employer's expectation and the degree of fulfilment of this expectation. A
recommendation is subjective. Job experience is something else and does not relates to
the employer’s expectation but to what the employee actual did do and thereby did gain
experience with or knowledge of. Job experience can be described objectively.
Although the job certificate seems to have similarities with the recommendation, the
certificate is something else. The job certificate will be a fact sheet showing knowledge,
skills and competencies acquired or in use as part of the job through tasks and activities
that the employee has performed or been involved with, and the role in that context.
Figure 6.5 shows which metadata the job certificate can contain.
Figure 6.5 Suggestions for metadata included in a job certificate
The description on the job certificate must be in accordance with the common labour
market ontology ESCO. The ontology must be applied in a way that fully describes the job.
44
Most job experiences are expected to be fully covered by ESCOs occupation pillar and the
job certificate will indicate which competencies, skills and knowledge essential and
optional of the occupation that have been part of the job execution.
The job certificate will also include description of jobs that are not within an ESCO
occupation. There are jobs that cannot be represented by the occupations pillar and
therefore are without a ESCO term for the occupation. This kind of job can only be
described using the skills pillar.
Figure 6.6 exemplifies the design of a job certificate, where a fictitious case has been built
up on a carpenter who has worked with roofing during the period 1/1-31/12, 2017.
Figure 6.6. Fictitious case on a job certificate for a carpenter
In the design, it is suggested that the employees are entitled to a job certificate after an
employment period long enough to accumulate skills in the job. Specifically, it is proposed
that employers are obliged to provide a certificate after one year's employment whether
on full time or part-time. Issues around industries with a tradition of shorter employment
than one year and for seasonal occupations that may be repeated year by year is not
discussed further, but decisions need to be taken on this - most probably it would be an
issue for collective agreements or employment law.
The preparation of the job certificate can be done on an ongoing basis, but at least once
a year, the employer and employee must agree on the actual job content of previous
period. The job certificate process could for instance be done together with the
company's annual "talent review"40 processes to avoid - or minimize - extra burdens for
the companies by introducing the job certificate. Employers must, with their signoff,
ensure that the content of the certificate is correct and enough. It will be the employer's
responsibility to decide who will prepare the draft certificate, which may well be the
employee himself, given that the employer complies with the requirement for annual
signoff.
40 Likewise, there may also be industries where the job certificate will be naturally linked to quality assurance.
45
As a starting point, job certificates must be uploaded regularly to the CV box, but there
may be deviations from this, if the employee and employer agree on another frequency
for upload. As already mentioned, it is suggested that the ongoing uploading takes place
annually. In this way, the uploaded job certificates create "timelines" into the CV-box of
the acquisition and use of a given competence, skill or knowledge.
Each yearly uploaded job certificate is seen in the new design as an independent legally
valid document. And it cannot be revoked later. It will be up to the IT system - and not the
individual employers - to create an overall "overview" of the knowledge, skills and
competencies and hereby the overall profile on job experience of the owner of the CV
box.
An agreement on the frequency for uploading job certificates to the CV box can be
regulated by law and/or it can be a collective agreement question and/or otherwise
included in the employment contract. It will also be able to ensure that special professions
are taken into account, where postponement of uploading to expiry of the employment
clause can be considered as an exception due to national security or business secrecy.
The certificates are placed together with educational certificates and hereby form the
overall CV for the individual jobseeker.
Figure 6.7. Possible process of job certificate
Availability of the individual employee's job certificate follows the rules for the CV and is
hereby the same as for educational certificates.
An important role for the job certificate is to create greater security for future employers
when hiring new employees on non-formal qualifications and competences acquired
and/or used in the job. From the point of view of the employee, the job certificate will
provide better documentation and validation of non-formal qualifications and skills
acquired and/or used in the job. The job certificate can be designed such that it can be
used as an assessment tool to recognize "learning and experience" at the job in
connection with admission on education.
The job certificate will create other benefits for companies and employees that also have
importance in the work situation beyond the job search and recruitment itself. As
mentioned, the job certificate is proposed to be prepared and included as part of yearly
talent reviews. Here, the job certificate can be used as a tool for employees as well as
companies regarding the utilization and further development of skills, competencies and
knowledge in the current employment relationship and hereby increase the incentive for
lifelong learning as well as reduce the risk being stuck in a job function.
46
Other benefits of the job certificate will not be further addressed here but may include
greater transparency and better allocation of the labour resources at macroeconomic
level. In this connection, it could be relevant to investigate whether job certificates can
thus contribute to increased productivity through better use of the skills and resources
already available to companies. The introduction of documentation of job experience can
also help companies to retain employees.
Whether the job certificate imposes new burdens on the companies is an issue discussed
in chapter 9.
6.4.1 Ontology
Job certificates must be based on the same common labour market ontology - ESCO - as
job advertisements and educational certificates. Generally, the job certificate will be
based on ESCO's competence pillar. The employment pillar can also be relevant and
especially for some job types.
47
7 The institutional set-up
7.1 Private versus public
The organisational set up must be considered for the new design.
As already mentioned, the design will be a solution by law where the individual citizen will
own his CV box and control whether it is open or closed depending on whether he is a job
seeker or not.
There are several organizational sets up options.
One option is that the task is lifted by private providers of job portals and job
advertisements, who gain access to data in the CV boxes and thereby perform the pairing.
"The private solution" is the name of this option. The private solution could be much
deeper, precise and intelligent than LinkedIn and Facebook and would increase
competition in the area of recruitment and hereby productivity. The solution can be
combined with other recruitment services for employers. In the EU, data will be protected
by GDPR.
The private solution needs to be combined with a new public inspection of the behaviour
of receivers of unemployment benefit as well as the monitoring of the services etc. The
solution must be implemented together with public authorities at national, regional and
local level (the relevant ministries, regional and local authorities) as well as social
partners.
Another option on institutional set-up is that the task is lifted by PES (public employment
service) in accordance with the Employment Convention from 1948 of The International
Labour Organisation (ILO). "The public solution" is the name of this option. ILO has made
international rules in the form of a convention on the organization of employment
services requiring that the employment service is public as well as free and that the
employment service shall consist of a national system of employment offices under the
direction of a national authority. The convention defines employment services in article
6, cf. box 7.1. In the convention digitalization and AI is not playing a strong explicitly role
for employment service.
Which option - private or public?
Which of the two options that deliver most prosperity and welfare may depend on the
internal affairs of a Member State regarding job search and recruitment services and
therefore the labour market.
In the case of Denmark, the arguments are in favour of a private solution. In Denmark job
search and recruitment services are mostly driven by private companies (portals) and not
public institutions. In 2018 the Danish employers used in average approximated 3
channels per recruitment: Jobs advertisement in 76 per cent, LinkedIn in 51 per cent and
Facebook in 28 per cent of the recruitments. The PES (public employment service) in
Denmark were used only in 17 per cent of the recruitments, cf. chapter 5.
48
Box 7.1. Extract from The International Convention “Employment Service Convention”
1948 (No. 88)
Article 1
1. Each Member of the International Labour Organization for which this Convention is
in force shall maintain or ensure the maintenance of a free public employment service.
…
Article 2
The employment service shall consist of a national system of employment offices under
the direction of a national authority.
…
Article 6
The employment service shall be so organised as to ensure effective recruitment and
placement, and for this purpose shall:
(a) assist workers to find suitable employment and assist employers to find suitable
workers, and more particularly shall, in accordance with rules framed on a national
basis--
(i) register applicants for employment, take note of their occupational qualifications,
experience and desires, interview them for employment, evaluate if necessary their
physical and vocational capacity, and assist them where appropriate to obtain
vocational guidance or vocational training or retraining,
(ii) obtain from employers’ precise information on vacancies notified by them to the
service and the requirements to be met by the workers whom they are seeking,
(iii) refer to available employment applicants with suitable skills and physical capacity,
(iv) refer applicants and vacancies from one employment office to another, in cases in
which the applicants cannot be suitably placed or the vacancies suitably filled by the
original office or in which other circumstances warrant such action;
…
The private solution option will contribute to strengthening the private sector on job
search and recruitment services in Denmark and hereby increasing productivity. In
addition, many tasks regarding vacancies in private companies will be taken over by job
portals in the new design. This applies to tasks of the employers today such as receiving,
processing, filing and storage of relevant CVs in compliance with GDPR.
A stronger involvement of private actors is a goal that the new design shares with the
EURES regulation. However, the new design seems to go beyond EURES in the ambition
to involve the private sector.
The new design implemented in Denmark could, like today, be financed from revenues
from companies’ job ads. From the point of view of the job portals, the new design makes
it possible to work with data that they without the legislative initiative would not be able
to get access to. The job portals are not suggested to pay for the new possibilities which
the new design is expected to give them.
Some labour markets are very different from the Danish one and where placing the new
design publicly under the auspices of a countries' PES can be more appropriate. For
example, a low labour market mobility with low rate of job change can reduce the savings
and benefits of the new design in short run where the private market will not be in a
condition to lift the task with the new design for job search and recruitment immediately.
Under such conditions a strong involvement of public authorities (PES of the country) can
be needed in the institutional set-up of the new design.
49
7.2 EURES
The mission of the European employment service EURES is to fulfil the purpose of Article
45 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) and to promote the
mobility of cross-border labour in the EU. Before the change of the regulation of EURES in
2016 the EURES network has been limited to public employment services.
The new design has similarities with EURES. Most importantly the new design's use of the
ESCO ontology introduced by the EU with the EURES regulation in April 2016 and the two
implementing decisions from 2018. Furthermore, the openness of the new design
towards involving private employment services is also in line with the new EURES
regulation.
On several essentials, the new design differs from the EURES Regulation:
introduction of a CV box with
validated information on examination results and knowledge, competencies and
skills acquired through education
job certificate with validated information on occupation, skills, competencies
and knowledge acquired through the job
the addition of a data layer to the text of the job advertisement
access for companies to exhaustive pairing with all job seekers in the market
("reviewing each job seeker") - no dependence on a random applicant pile and thus
transferring the “selection right” to the companies
pairing of job seekers with all relevant job advertisements ("reviewing each job
advertisement") - the cancellation of the job application in the traditional sense.
50
8 Transition
It is important that the CV box accurately and exhaustively reproduces the owner's
education and job experience. To achieve this objective, it is necessary to establish a
transitional solution for educational certificates and job experience acquired before the
CV boxes' common "starting time". Educations certificates or job experience acquired
before “starting time” will be handled by the transitional solution.
Transitional solution for educational certificates
Education authorities or other public authorities in EU Member States may have filed and
stored data regarding students historically and are therefore able to upload to the CV box,
the educational certificates acquired back in time before starting time of the CV box.
Regarding the course content and the objectives of the program, the responsible
authority can upload this information along with the certificates. The authority is only
obliged to provide the information if it is available for them.
If certificates and/or course content and objectives of the educational programs are not
available to the public authorities, it may be considered to open the CV box so that the CV
owner uploads the information himself, which is similar to what is done today. It must be
stated in the CV box if the data is provided by the CV owner himself and therefore not
validated.
Transfer of certificates and course content should only include educational certificates
corresponding to EQF level 4 and above. For EQF level 3 and less, the CV owner can himself
upload if required or deemed necessary.
Transitional solution for job certificate
Many companies have not documented their current and former employees' job history
by registration, filing and storing the skills, competencies and knowledge acquired during
employment. These companies will not be able to upload information on job experience
from before starting time of the CV box.
Therefore, it is proposed that previous job experience to be reconstructed by the owner
of the CV box himself but in a way that follows the common labour market ontology.
Of course, companies are free to offer their current and former employees help with
designing and signoff of job certificates on job history from before “starting time”. If the
company validates content, job certificates on job history will come into the "signoff"
state in the CV-box.
The incomplete information on employee job history and a limited collective memory is
another reason why is so important to establish the job certificate for the future.
Other aspects regarding the transitional solutio n
Furthermore, it is proposed to have an age limit for participation in the transition scheme.
It must be reasonable to assume that most people with only a few years left to retirement
will not need the CV box.
A limit for the automatic creation of the CV box could be the age at which one is eligible
for public pension minus 5 years. This is named the age limit. The age for receiving
retirement pension of the individual citizen varies between Member States and therefore
also the age limit. There are differences among EU Member States on retirement age and
rules for retirement. It shall therefore be left to the Member States themselves to deviate
from the proposed age limit and create a transitional arrangement that is relevant to their
retirement and labour market.
51
However, the age limit does not apply for unemployed recipients of public unemployment
benefits. Even with an age above the age limit (i.e. with less than 5 years to retirement)
the unemployed recipients of unemployment benefits will automatically get a CV box
created for them through PES (the public employment services). All others with an age
above the age limit (i.e. with less than 5 years to retirement) have a right to apply for a
CV-box if they so wish.
The age limit will only apply during the transitional. In the long term everyone will have a
CV box - also as retired.
52
9 Impact assessment
The focus of the report has been on conceptualizing the new design. The design’s socially
and economically impact is expected to be positive. Detailed studies assessing impacts of
the new design has not yet been carried out. Below, it is briefly explained why it is
expected that the impacts of the design will be positive and why deeper assessments of
the impacts are needed. The impact assessments will be categorized into impacts on
macroeconomics, public expenses and business economics as well as impact on citizens.
Macroeconomics
The new design is estimated to be able to improve the labour market on information and
transparency, increase supply on labour and increase productivity. The design will
improve prosperity and welfare overall. The functioning of the labour market differs
throughout Member States of EU. The macro economic impact is estimated to be positive
in the EU Member States even though the nature, types and sizes of macroeconomic
impact of the new design will differ between the EU Members.
It is necessary through studies to dig deeper into the nature, types and sizes of the
macroeconomic impact of the new design in each country.
Public expenses
Chapter 7 outlines the institutional set up distinguishing between a private and public
solution. The new design is expected to be neutral or reduce the public expenditure in the
Member States with the private solution where the task with CV boxes and pairing are
going to be a task for private job portals. The public authorities are responsible of (public)
approval and supervision of the private job portals in the private solution. The
expenditure for this is expected to be less than savings from a more efficient control of
the availability for work and job search activities achieved by public authorities in the new
design.
For educational institutions, there will be a long-term relief by simplifying the task of
handling educational certificates. However, the transitional arrangement may well use
resources and involve additional costs, but these are estimated to be limited as a result
of digital solutions.
The public solution will not necessarily be neutral or reduce the public expenses which
also depends on the functioning of the labour market of the Member State. Therefore, it
is not clear and uniquely how a public solution affects the public expenses.
Business economics
The companies are expected to experience several resource savings in the form of not
having to handle, review and store job applications of the initial screening process, which
will also lessen burden from GDPR. The companies will also gain strengthened information
about the content of education programs, which can also save resources.
It will require closer examination to assess whether the job certificate and the new labour
market ontology will inflict administrative burdens on companies.
The new design will provide better information on the factors in the CVs most important
to the employers (cf. Table 6.3) and thereby contribute to lower risk and expense for "bad
hire".
The job certificate contributes to the companies getting better control of the
competencies, skills and knowledge in the company and that can be an advantage, e.g. it
could provide a tool for optimising the use of the pool of competencies, skills and
53
knowledge in the company. The job certificate is included in a circular process with reuse
of data from the job advertisement when designing the job certificate, etc. A job
advertisement's data layer can thus contribute to the design of the first job certificate for
the person who got the advertised job. If the job changes in relation to requirements in
the advertisement, qualifications and competences can be added or deleted. If an
employee leaves the job, his last job certificate can form the basis for the data layer in a
new job advertisement, if the job is to be filled again with unchanged requirements for
qualifications and competences.
Companies with many new employees will benefit more from the job certificate than
companies with few. Some companies are already documenting employees' tasks and
have systematized procedure for yearly "Talent Review" and here the transition to the job
certificate and the new labour market ontology will hardly constitute an additional
burden. However, it is far from all companies that do have such or similar procedures in
place.
As already mentioned, it may be necessary to further investigate the issue of possible
burdens from the job certificate, including existing systems within human resource
management. Furthermore, it should also be noted that the competitive situation in the
future may make it more important to have control over one's employees' competencies,
skills and knowledge.
Impact on the private job portals that lift the regulated task
It will be private job portals that on a voluntary basis carry out the regulated task with CV
boxes and pairing. The business model will continue to be based on payment for job ads
on the job portals. The new design will give the private job portals advantages of the
improved data basis created through regulation of the CV box by law. The private job
portals will have the opportunity to develop new services against payment as for example
tools for the companies' preparing of job certificates.
Impact assessment for citizens
The new design increases the opportunities on the job market and has virtually no
negative impact on citizens. For example, the design does not affect the number of
recruitment channels. Recruiting through networks, social media, unsolicited application
and head hunting will continue to be present.
The design is based on the premise that virtually all employers will make their job listings
available on the platform. This is an important prerequisite.
Impact assessment for employed
The new design will make it easier and more efficient for those in employment to be job
seeking due to the fact that the job seeker will automatically come into contact with all
companies of their interest - gets the entire relevant job market scanned. In general, it is
to be expected that the design increases the number of job seekers in employment and
reduces resources used on job search. In particular, it is expected to have a positive effect
on gender differences by increasing the number of female job seekers because it has
become easier and more efficient.
The labour markets and the recruiting vary between EU countries and therefore also the
impact assessment of the new design for the employees. In some countries, labour
mobility is very high, with many job changes annually, which is why the new design here
will mainly reduce resources spent on job mobility. In other countries, it is low, which is
why the new design can contribute to increase labour market mobility.
54
Impact assessment for unemployed receiving public unemployment benefit
The design will mean that unemployed receiving unemployment benefit no longer have
to spend time preparing and submitting job applications, which the employer anyway
does not spend much time reading. The increased "leisure" time can be used for
upgrading skills, competencies and knowledge of the unemployed, which can contribute
to increased possibility to get a job, but also to increased productivity (and often salary)
when employed again. A plan for improvement of skills, competencies and knowledge
may be introduced as a requirement by the responsible authorities for the payment of
unemployment benefits. Alternatively, it may be offered to the unemployed as an option.
The new design will improve the possibilities for the unemployed to get a job by providing
the employers better and deeper information about the labour market. It will further
improve the possibilities for the unemployed to get a job by ensuring that all their job
opportunities are examined and that the period of unemployment is used to
strengthening their position in the labour market, e.g. through up qualification.
The design is estimated to have a positive impact on the ability for the unemployed to get
back in employment.
55
10 About LCI and us
We are a company domiciled in Denmark working with the complement of HCI which is
LCI (law computer interaction), cf. box 10.1. Our aim is to improve a strong and good
interaction between laws/norms on the one hand and digitalization/AI on the other – and
thereby increasing welfare of citizens in society.
Box 10.1 HCI and LCI
IT-engineers and -programmers know the discipline of Human Computer Interaction
(HCI) taught on technical universities worldwide. No one questions the significant
impact of this discipline on developing the IT technology. From the view of the society,
it is also very important to be aware of and influence the interaction between the law
and the computer/technology. Therefore, we are aiming at making LCI a discipline in
itself or a main topic in discourse and science of IT technology.
We have developed “Perfect2Job” to inspire nationally as well as internationally how to
work with LCI systematically as a part of your political interest field.
There are several opportunities to create a strong and good interaction between
legislation and digitalisation among others:
Removing barriers for digitalisation by adjusting often old legislation
Inventing new legislation for the creation of new digital opportunities
Regulating digitization by legislation.
The initiative ESCO of the European union can be seen as an exemplification of the second
and the GDPR regulation the latter option.
Our company especially offers services on
the fit of new political proposals (e.g. bills) to digitalization/AI by digging deep into
the technological solution during conceptualization. We call it "making it smart from
start"
creating digital/AI prototypes of new political proposals and hereby illustrating how
it boosts prosperity and welfare in real life
use and deployment of the international discipline “AI and law” that have existed for
more than forty years working with legal ontology and logic as well as ML
We are interested in working for and/or together with institutions/administrations on
local, national or international level, private companies, research institutes sharing same
aspiration as us. For further information contact us.
www.lawcomputerinteraction.com Law Computer Interaction
www.lawcomputerinteraction.us Torkel Badens vej 10
2900 Hellerup
[email protected] DENMARK
+45 53 64 10 24
+45 21 49 25 18
56
57