Rahandusministeerium · 30. september 2022
Sisu (failidest)
Ministry of Finance.
Corporate Tax Department.
Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn 10122
Pieter Manden LLM MBA
Legmeerstraat 60-2
Netherlands
Amsterdam, 6th September 2022
Subject: request for information/confirmation for WorkMotion Software GmbH
Dear Madam, Sir,
Via this letter, we would like to ask you to provide our company with clarity regarding a
Estonian corporate income tax matter. Our company is WorkMotion Software GmbH
(hereinafter: WorkMotion), a commercial company with limited liability based in Germany.
WorkMotion has no presence in Estonia yet, but is considering changing this going forward.
The main reason for this is the fact that WorkMotion would like to employ some people in
Estonia. These individuals will be working remotely for WorkMotion, that is from their home
offices in Estonia. For now, WorkMotion neither has intention to establish an entity in
Estonia nor to open up an office there.
Given this intention, the first question that has arisen is whether or not these individuals
would constitute a Permanent Establishment (PE) in Estonia. In case this first question should
be answered positively, the second question that has arisen is to what amount that is on the
-
basis of which methodology profits should be allocated to the Estonian PE. We hope that
-
you can help us answer these two questions. Below, we will elaborate on them in more detail
and share with you our suggested answers to them.
A. Permanent Establishment
As a first step in the PE-analysis, it needs to be assessed whether these employees would
qualify as a so-called Dependent Agents. If they do not, in a second step it needs to be
assessed if these home offices would qualify as so-called fixed places of business of
WorkMotion in Estonia. Before we perform both of these assessments, let us share some
more information on WorkMotion as a company and the typical profile that WorkMotion is
looking to employ in Estonia.
1. WorkMotion
WorkMotion is an European global HR platform that enables companies to hire & onboard
their employees internationally.
2. Profile 1. Junior software developer
A person who studied computer science or similar and is starting their career as a sofiware
engineer or already features 1-3 years of experience developing web
30 -O - 2022
TypeScript / ReactJS alone or as part of a team. Junior developers are expected to be quick
learners and team players, they are not expected to make bigger technical decisions on their
own.
3. Profile 2. Medior software developer
A person who studied computer science or similar and has 3-7 years of experience
developing web applications with Java / TypeScript / ReactJS alone or as part of a team.
Medior developers are expected to actively spread their knowiedge in the team and be able to
make technical decisions on feature scope independently.
4. Step 1, Dependent Agent PE
On the basis of the generally accepted OECI) guidance, a Dependent Agent PE is constituted
by an agent who acts on behaif of a foreign enterprise and habitually exercises authority to
conciude contracts in the name of the enterprise. In our view, neither the junior nor the
medior IT developer described above qualil’y as a Dependent Agent. Moreover, these
individuals have no authority to and will not conciude contracts on behaif of WorkMotion.
Reqiiest 1: We would like you to confirm that the eniployees nuentio,ied above do not
qualfy as dependent agents.
5. Step 2. Fixed Place ofBusiness PE
According to the generally accepted OECD guidance, a Fixed Place of Business PE exists
when there is a fixed place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly
or partly carried on. There are two crucial topics to address in this regard. The first one is
whether or not the employees of WorkMotion carry on the business or only perform activities
that are preparatory or auxiliary of naLure. Th second one is whcthcr or not th cmpioyees’
home offices qualify as a fixed place which is at the employers disposal or not.
6. Preparatory and auxiliary
ln case that the employees’ activities are merely preparatory and auxiliary of nature, they in
principle do not constitute a Fixed Place of Business PE. An activity cannot be regarded as
being preparatory or auxiliary of nature when the general purpose of the activity performed
by the place of business is the same as the general purpose of the whole enterprise. The core
business of WorkMotion is its online platform, on which both junior and medior IT
developers will work. This argues for the conciusion that these profiles do not perform
activities that can be qualified as preparatory and auxiliary.
At the same time, according to the OECD Commentary the decisive criterion is whether the
activity of the fixed place of business in itseif forms an essential and significant part of the
activity of the enterprise as a whole. In our view, the business in Estonia cannot be
considered as an essential and significant part in itself for three reasons. First, because it only
concerns a limited number of developers in Estonia. This is not a sign ficant part of
WorkMotion, who in total employs over 200 employees, over 30 of which are developers.
Second, these developers in Estonia would of course be important to the company, but given
thcir lack of seniority they cannot be considered an essential part of WorkMotion. Thirdly
and lastly, both because of the aforernentioned quantitative and qualitative aspects, the
developers would not form an in itselfpart of WorkMotion’s business. These developers
would not structurally work together in a way that wouldjustify a qualification of them as a
team or any other “in itseif’ part of the company.
This would argue against the conclusion that these profiles do not perform activities that can
be qualified as preparatory and auxiliary.
Request 2: Please sh are your insights on whether the emp!oyees mentioned above would
perform activities that are preparatory and auxiliary of nature.
7. Home office at employer’s disposal
Depending on your answer to Request 2 above, the discussion whether or not the employees’
home offices can qualify as a fixed place may be redundant. Nevertheless, we would still like
to address it.
According to OECD communications dated before the COVID- 19 pandemic, the question
whether home offices qualify as a fixed place will rarely be an issue. Also, the activities
carried on at a home office will often be merely auxiliary and will therefore fall within the
exception of subparagraph e) of paragraph 4 which is the exception of preparatory and
-
auxiliary activities. Clearly, the reality today is very different. The question whether home
offices qualify as a fixed place has developed into a rather common issue.
This issue was addressed in an update of the OECD policy, that says that a home office may
be a PE for an enterprise if it is used on a continuous basis for carrying on business of that
enterprise and the enterprise generally has required the individual to use that location to carry
on the enterprise’s business. Two distinct criteria can be discerned from this commentary: a
home office can be said to be a PE if the employee is instructed to work from the home
offices and if the employee is not given an office.
Applying these criteria on the employees of WorkMotion leads to the following. The
employees of WorkMotion are not specifically instructed to work from their home offices. In
principle, they are allowed to work from wherever they would like to. Theoretically, the
employees are welcome in the office in Germany but this is obviously a rather hypothetical
option. WorkMotion does not provide an office in Estonia, nor does it provide the employees
with an allowance for flexible workplaces or something alike. As such, strictly the conditions
as set by the OECD may not entirely be met here. flowever, in practice the employees of
WorkMotion in Estonia are likely to work from their home offices for the majority of time.
It seems that, ultimately, this remains a topic on which the authorities of the relevant
countries need to determine their own policy. Some countries have done so. Germany has
always considered the home office to be not at the employer’s disposal. More recently,
Denmark issued a ruling that a home office only constitutes a PE if the employee working
from it on a constant basis generates local revenue (22 Oct 2021 SKM2O21.546.SR). Also, in
Sweden the tax authority took a similar standpoint in its declaration No. 8-1677220 dated 17
May 2022. Pointing to consultation with number V0066-22 dated 18 January 2022, Spain
seems to be heading in a sirnilar direction.
Request 3: Can you share your policy regarding your quaijflcation of a home office as a
Jixed place in general, and more specjfica!ly sh are whether you quaijfy the home offices of
the employees of WorkMotion as afixed place?
B. Profit Allocation
Based on the previous analysis, the employees of WorkMotion do not necessarily constitute a
PE of WorkMotion in Estonia. Nevertheless, it is not unthinkable that WorkMotion will
establish a Estonian entity anytime soon to cmploy the individuals mentioned above. For this
reason, we would like to proactively address a profit allocation methodology with you. This
profit allocation methodology is standardiscd, so that it applies on the current employees but
especially also going forward as WorkMotion might attract additional talents in Estonian.
-
This provides both WorkMotion and you with certainty and should ensure a smooth
coliaboration.
1. Cost-plus methodology
The basis for the suggested profit allocation is the cost-plus methodology. This means that
the profit is determined as a percentage of the total employment costs of the empioyees in
Estonia. The total employment costs are the sum of the empioyees’ gross remuneration, the
money spent on their (grossed up) benefits in kind, and the additional employer costs such as
those related to social security, pensions, insurances and business trips. If at any point
WorkMotion will provide (an) office (spacc) to the employees, the costs related to this will be
considered as part of the total employment costs as weil. Please note that the total
employment costs consists of the employmcnt costs of all of the ernployees working for
WorkMotion in Estonia. As such, also the employment of an employee performing purely
activities that are preparatory and auxiliary of nature, would still be inciuded.
The profit percentage is employee specific and depends on both the department and the
seniority of the employee. We suggest work ing with the following three levels as represented
in the table below.
Profit mark-up Job Ievel/department dcscription
5% • For all employees in departments other than IT development,
Sales and Senior Managernent (board). Thus, this applies to
employees in departments such as HR, Finance, Marketing,
Custorner Support, etc.
• For junior level employees in the departments IT development
and Sales
10% • For medior level employees in the departments IT
development and Sales
15% • For senior level employees in the departments IT development
and Sales
• For all employees of the Senior Management (board)
Reqiiest 4: aii you please approve the profit a!locatioii methodology described above?
2. Exainpie profit caiculation
The table below provides an example profit caiculation. It applies the suggested profit
allocation methodology on the employees mentioned above, for whorn we have inciuded
estimated amounts for salaries and employer costs. On the basis of these estimates and the
suggested profit mark ups, you can see that the profit allocated to the PE/entity would amount
to € 5.520.
Junor IT developer
€36.000 Gross Salary
€5.400 15% Employer Costs
€41.400 Total Costs
€4.140 10% Profit
€45.540 Net Invoice. VAT reversed
Medior IT developer
€24.000 Gross Salary
€3.600 15% Employer Costs
€27.600 Total Costs
€1.380 5% Profit
€28.980 Net Invoice. VAT reversed
C. Agreement and revision
In advance, we would like to thank you for providing clarity by providing your feedback to
Hthe requests above. We understand that your feedback might change over time. In that case,
please feel free to reach out to us at any time. Until then, however, WorkMotion will work in
accordance with your feedback. Clearly this leaves some room for subjectivity, e.g. the
determination of the seniority level and to a lesser extent the assignment of a particular
- -
role into a department. WorkMotion commits to doing this in a fair and consistent manner,
bu.t appreciates the fact that you can still question and/or disagree with this in the future.
In case you have any questions and/or remarks, please feel free to reach out to me via
pieter.rnanden(workrnotion.com or +31(0)6 1962 3808.
Kind regards,
Pieter Manden LLM MBA
Certified Tax Lawyer