ERAELU KAITSE JA RIIGI LÄBIPAISTVUSE EEST
Dear Colleagues, Yours: 23.01.2023 nr
Ours: 16.02.2023 nr 2.1.-1/23/303-2
Answer to request
In response to your IMI request No. 478843 the Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate provides
you the following information.
Answer to question 1
The current practice of the Data Protection Inspectorate is based on the assumption that if a
natural person has added so-called black boxes to the part of the camera image that films the
public area, then the GDPR does not apply. However, we do not refer to this possibility during
an investigation/proceeding and we always emphasize that it is necessary to dismantle the
cameras or change the angles of the cameras in such a way that they do not film the public area.
However, we cannot rule out the right of an individual to add black boxes.
If, during an investigation/proceeding, there is a reasonable suspicion that the black boxes have
been added only for the duration of the procedure, we will ask for previous recordings, and in
the event of a violation, we will oblige a person to delete the previous recordings. In addition,
we always inform the camera owners about the possibility of the Data Protection Inspectorate
to carry out on-site follow-up inspections.
Answer to question 2
If it is private property and if only the area in one's possession (a private house and its yard) is
filmed, the GDPR does not apply. In this case, it does not matter for what purpose the camera
is used.
But when the public space (e.g a street) is within the camera's field of view, a natural person
must also consider whether he meets the conditions of legitimate interest. Besides, it is
mandatory to install a notice label about the camera where at least the following information
must be written: the legal basis, the purpose of storage and data processor's contacts. It helps to
ensure the requirements arising from the GDPR, including the requirement to notify the data
subject.
If it is an apartment association, the GDPR applies in situations 2 and 3.
The territory of the apartment association is jointly owned by the apartment owners, and what
happens within it on their area, is largely a matter of joint ownership between the owners
Tatari tn 39 / 10134 Tallinn / 627 4135 /
[email protected] / www.aki.ee Registrikood 70004235
(members of the association), which must be agreed upon within the association. According to
the usual practice, the installation of a camera is permitted by the decision of the general
meeting of the apartment owners. Those apartment owners who want to install a camera for
their own use (e.g. to film their apartment door or parking space) must also have permission
from the general meeting. When the camera films a public area, it is also mandatory to install a
notice label about the camera and there must be legitimate interest condition fulfilled.
Answer to question 3
The analysis of the legitimate interest must be documented and attached to the data protection
conditions. It must also be ensured that the data subject can familiarize with it if (s)he wishes
(e.g. by contacting the owner of the camera). The Data Protection Inspectorate has also prepared
a legitimate interest guide that is freely available to everyone via its website, in which we have
outlined everything that needs to be considered when preparing the analysis.
Answer to question 4
In the case of private property, the Data Protection Inspectorate treats the owner of the property
as the owner of the camera. In Estonia, a land register system is in use, according to which the
owner of the property is the one who is entered in the land register. The land register is public,
and anyone can consult the register part, i.e. get information about who is the owner of the
property (contact details are not public). When carrying out the investigation/proceeding, the
inspectorate has the right to receive the contact details of the owner from the population register.
If the property is jointly owned, the inspectorate considers both of them to be the owners of the
camera.
Best regards,
Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate
2 (2)