Andmekaitse Inspektsioon · 9. veebruar 2023
- Viit
- 2.1.-1/23/136-2
- Registreeritud
- 9. veebruar 2023
- Dokumendi liik
- Väljaminev kiri
- Adressaat
- SA The Netherlands
- Saabumis/saatmisviis
- Outlook
- Funktsioon
- 2.1 Menetluse korraldamine
- Sari
- 2.1-1 Sekkumistaotlused (uus nimi alates 01.03.2024)
- Toimik
- 2.1.-1/23/41
- Vastutaja
- Alissa Hmelnitskaja (Andmekaitse Inspektsioon)
Sisu (failidest)
GDPR - Article 61 - Voluntary Mutual Assistance
IMI Number: 469062
Dear colleagues,
Thank You for the request. Please find our answers to Your questions below.
- Do you have a specific view on the sharing of personal data within a holding of
companies based on the legitimate interest of the controller? For now we are specifically
excluding any eventual interests of third parties.
The Estonian SA is of the opinion that every intra-group data transfer must be analysed
separately for compliance and the data transmission should be allowed mainly, when it is
necessary for curtain purpose, on a case by case basis (e.g. there is a suspicion about fraudulent
activities etc.). So, for instance, if it is necessary to process personal data of
employee/customers of the group of controllers the analyse of the legitimate interests should be
done accordingly to a specific situation.
Pursuant to recital 48 of the GDPR controllers that are part of a group of undertakings or
institutions affiliated to a central body may have a legitimate interest in transmitting personal
data within the group of undertakings for internal administrative purposes, including the
processing of clients' or employees' personal data. Thus, we find that an investigation of
fraudulent activities may fall also into the internal administrative purposes.
- With regard to the proportionality of processing, would the processing of personal data
be less proportionate if the goal is to investigate fraudulent activities on the platforms of
controllers in the Holding when compared to investigating fraudulent activities on the platform
of the controller?
In this regard, we would like to emphasize that pursuant to the article 5(1)(b) and (c) while
processing of personal data there must be fulfilled principles of purpose limitation and data
minimisation.
So, in our view, the processing of personal data would be less proportionate if the goal is to
investigate fraudulent activities on the platforms of controllers in the Holding compared when
investigating fraudulent activities on the platform of the controller. Explanation of this
conclusion is that the measure for an investigation of fraudulent activities should be adequate
to achieve the envisaged purpose. If a prevention of fraudulent activities is possible within the
platform of the controller it will be disproportionate to do it within the platforms of controllers
in the Holding.
- With regard to the balancing of rights, would the balance be more likely to be in favour
of the data subject, when the personal data is shared within a group when compared to
investigating fraud by the controller itself? Personal data can be processed in numerous
different ways data to detect, prevent and investigate fraudulent activities. In this specific case
there are over 40 measures in place.
Pursuant to the previous answer we are rather of the opinion that the separate analyse should be
done to conclude whether the data subjects’ rights are balanced or not and the measure should
also be adequate to achieve the curtain objective.
- When confronted with a large variety of measures combatting fraud, what is your
opinion on investigating only those specific measures which might be disproportionate to the
data subjects’ rights?
It seems reasonable to investigate those specific measures which might be disproportionate to
the data subjects’ rights taking into account that, in general, the processing of personal data
should be designed to serve mankind. So, if the concrete data processing obviously harmfully
affect the rights or freedoms of data subjects the supervisory authority is obliged to intervene.