ERAELU KAITSE JA RIIGI LÄBIPAISTVUSE EEST
Dear Colleagues Yours: 24.01.2023
Ours: 08.02.2023 nr 2.1.-1/23/304-2
Answer to request
In response to your IMI request No. 479416 the Estonian DPI provides you the following
information.
The Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate was consulted on the proposal for implementation
of the "open data directive" 2019/1024/EU in April 2021. We provided some comments
regarding the need to clarify the relation to the GDPR, but did not have any comments on the
issue of anonymization or data that is considered as anonymous. Yet we were then expecting
that open data will not include personal data.
So, therefore, our main problem is that we have now some actual personal data that is public
information, but have no grounds to be as internal. For example according to our Commercial
Code article 145 in commercial register names and personal identification codes of the members
of the company`s management board must be published. Previously this kind of data was
published only till certain time and the register was not open to public search engines like
Google. Now we have many different state registers that have to classify their open data,
including personal data (mostly names and id-codes), so we are facing a problem where persons
will be easily profiled by open data users and we have no control of what they will use it for.
Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate does not know any instances in Estonia in which
information published due to this regulation was found not be anonymous or no longer being
anonymous. As we told we are facing more serious issues where identified personal data is
published as open data.
In our opinion an instance of published information no longer being anonymous might be a
breach of GDPR art 33 depending weather it is a big threat or not, and should be analyzed case
by case.
Best regards,
The Estonian DPI
Tatari tn 39 / 10134 Tallinn / 627 4135 /
[email protected] / www.aki.ee Registrikood 70004235