Saatja: "Janno Hermanson (EE)" <
[email protected]>
Saaja: "Johann Peetre" <
[email protected]>
Teema: Re: Horisont projekti sõltumatu auditi pakkumus, töö tähtaeg 7-10.05.2021
Kuupäev: 2021-04-12 08:25
Tere,
Tänud info eest. Meie minimaalne pakkumine on 1,990 EUR + käibemaks.
Parimat,
Janno
*Janno Hermanson*
PwC | Director | Accounting Advisory | Authorized Public Accountant
Office: +372 6 141 800 | Mobile: +372 56 653 509
Email:
[email protected] <
[email protected]>
AS PricewaterhouseCoopers
Pärnu mnt 15, 10141 Tallinn, Estonia
http://www.pwc.ee
https://www.linkedin.com/in/janno-hermanson-93052111/
<https://www.pwc.com/ee/et/konverentsid-ja-koolitused/konverents2020.html>
On Thu, 8 Apr 2021 at 14:37, Johann Peetre <
[email protected]> wrote:
> Tere
>
> MKM kulukirjeid FABULOS projektis:
> palgakulud: 36
> overhead: 4
> teenused: 24
>
> Johann
> 56453969
>
>
>
> On 8. Apr 2021, at 14:09, Janno Hermanson (EE) <
[email protected]>
> wrote:
>
> Tere hr Peetre,
>
> On Teil saata palun infot projekti aruande kohta, st kui palju on kulusid
> tabelis esitatud liikide lõikes (sisseostetud teenused, palgakulud jne).
> Seejärel saame hinnata töömahtu ning seda, kas pakkumise teostamine Teie
> poolt esitatud alampiiri arvestades on meie poolt võimalik.
>
> Parimat,
>
> *Janno Hermanson*
>
> PwC | Director | Accounting Advisory | Authorized Public Accountant
>
> Office: +372 6 141 800 | Mobile: +372 56 653 509
>
> Email:
[email protected] <
[email protected]>
>
> AS PricewaterhouseCoopers
>
> Pärnu mnt 15, 10141 Tallinn, Estonia
>
> http://www.pwc.ee
>
> https://www.linkedin.com/in/janno-hermanson-93052111/
>
>
> <https://www.pwc.com/ee/et/konverentsid-ja-koolitused/konverents2020.html>
>
>
>
> ---------- Forwarded message ---------
> From: Johann Peetre <
[email protected]>
> Date: Thu, 8 Apr 2021 at 13:19
> Subject: Horisont projekti sõltumatu auditi pakkumus, töö tähtaeg
> 7-10.05.2021
> To:
[email protected] <
[email protected]>
>
>
> Tere
>
> Sooviksin hinnapakkumist manuses olevale põhjale "Certificate On Financial
> Statements" (CFS) koostamiseks FABULOS projekti Majandus- ja
> Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumi kuludele.
> Töö oleks vaja juba teostada ja lõplikult üle anda 7-10.05.2021
> Parima pakkumuse valimise aluseks on hind. Sh hind ei tohi ületada 2000
> eurot.
>
> Projekti kodulehekülg on näha siit: https://fabulos.eu
> Rohkem infot saab leida ka siit:
> https://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/docs/h2020-funding-guide/grants/applying-for-funding/register-an-organisation/certifications_en.htm#CFS
>
>
> Lugupidamisega
> Johann Peetre
> transpordi arengu ja investeeringute osakond
> MKM
> 56453969
>
>
>
> Privacy Statement <https://www.pwc.com/ee/en/home/privacy-statements.html>
>
> The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to
> which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged
> material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or
> taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or
> entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received
> this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any
> computer. Please familiarize yourself with our privacy policy.
> <h2020-tpl-annex5-cfs_en.docx>
>
>
>
--
Privacy Statement <https://www.pwc.com/ee/en/home/privacy-statements.html>
The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to
which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged
material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or
taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or
entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received
this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any
computer. Please familiarize yourself with our privacy policy.
Terms of Business of PwC
2.2 Deliverables – You may not disclose a
Effective from 15 May 2018
deliverable or make the benefit of the services
available to anyone else or refer to the contents of
Contents a deliverable or the findings of our work, except
(i) as stated in the engagement letter, (ii) with
1 Introduction
our prior written consent on terms to be agreed,
2 Services (iii) where required by law or regulation, or (iv)
3 Your responsibilities to your lawyers or group members as long as you
4 Fees tell them, in advance, that we accept no liability
5 Confidentiality to them and that no onward disclosure may be
6 Intellectual property rights made.
7 Data protection 2.3 Liability to you alone – We accept no liability
8 Liability to anyone, other than you, in connection with our
9 PwC firms and subcontractors services and deliverables, unless otherwise
10 Materials agreed by us in writing. You agree to reimburse
11 Termination us for any liability (including legal costs) that we
12 Dispute resolution incur in connection with any claim by anyone
13 General else in relation to the services.
14 Interpretation 2.4 Changes – Either we or you may request a
change to the services or the agreement. A
change will be effective only when agreed in
1 Introduction writing.
1.1 Terms – These terms apply to the services you 2.5 Extent of services – In performing the
have engaged us to provide under the attached services, we will not be (i) carrying out an audit
engagement letter. These terms together with the or a review in accordance with applicable
engagement letter form the entire agreement professional standards, or (ii) attempting to
between you and us. If anything in these terms is detect fraud or other wrongdoing.
inconsistent with the engagement letter, these
2.6 Oral advice and draft deliverables – You
terms take precedence, unless the engagement
may rely only on our final written deliverables
letter specifically amends any of them.
and not on oral advice or draft deliverables. If
1.2 Commencement – The agreement will start on you wish to rely on something we have said to
the earlier of (i) the date of the engagement you, please let us know so that we may prepare a
letter; and (ii) the commencement of the services. written deliverable on which you can rely.
2.7 Monitoring – We shall not update our advice
for any changes in law or regulations, or their
2 Services interpretation, that occur after the date of the
2.1 Services – We will perform the services with services provided.
reasonable skill and care. You confirm that the 2.8 Deemed knowledge – In performing the
scope is sufficient for your purpose. The services services we will not be deemed to have
(including deliverables) are provided solely for information from other services we or other PwC
you for the purpose set out in the engagement firms may have provided to you.
letter or the relevant deliverable.
1 of 5
3 Your responsibilities 5 Confidentiality
3.1 Information – In order for us to advise you 5.1 Confidential information – We and you
properly you will make sure that (i) any agree to use each other’s confidential information
information given to us by you, or anyone else only in relation to the services, and not to
working with or for you, is (a) given promptly, (b) disclose it without prior written consent, except i)
accurate and (c) complete; and (ii) any where required by law or regulation or by a
assumptions are appropriate. We will not verify professional body of which we or our staff are
any information given to us relating to the members, or ii) to our legal advisors or insurers.
services. However, we may give confidential information
to other PwC firms or relevant subcontractors or
3.2 Your obligations – Our performance depends
service providers as long as they are bound by
on you performing your obligations under the
confidentiality obligations, and to your advisers
agreement. We are not liable for any loss arising
who are involved in the relevant matter. The
from you not fulfilling your obligations.
obligations to keep the information received in
connection with the agreement confidential shall
remain in legal effect for three years after receipt
4 Fees of such information. The above will not apply to
4.1 Payment for services – You agree to pay us information which (i) is publicly available, or (ii)
for our services. Any estimate we may give you is has been received from someone else who owes
not binding. no duty of confidence in relation to it, or (iii) was
already known by the receiving party.
4.2 Basis of fees – Our fees may reflect not only
time spent, but also such factors as complexity, 5.2 Referring to you and the services – We and
urgency, inherent risks, use of techniques, know- other PwC firms may wish to refer to you and the
how and research together with the level of skills services we have performed for you when
and expertise required of the personnel needed to marketing our services, we and they may also
perform and review the services. Our fees may wish to use your company logo when citing our
include any time spent travelling for the purpose experience in proposal documents. You agree
of the services that cannot be used productively that we and they may do so, as long as we do not
for other purposes. disclose your confidential information.
4.3 Expenses – You will pay any relevant expenses 5.3 Performing services for others – You agree
that we incur in connection with the services. that we may perform services for your
competitors or other parties whose interests may
4.4 Taxes – You will also pay any taxes, including conflict with yours, as long as we do not disclose
VAT, that are due in relation to our deliverables your confidential information and we comply
and services. You will pay us the full amount of with our ethical obligations.
any invoice, regardless of any deduction that you
are required by law to make.
4.5 Invoices and payment – Unless otherwise 6 Intellectual property rights
provided in the engagement letter we may
Where there are any intellectual property objects
invoice you on a monthly basis and all invoices
in the deliverables we will own the intellectual
are payable within 14 calendar days of the date of
property rights in the deliverables and any
the invoice. If you do not pay an invoice on time
materials created under the agreement, and you
we may charge you interest at the rate set by law.
will have a non-exclusive, non-transferable
licence to use the deliverables for your own
internal purposes.
7 Data protection
7.1 Compliance – You and we will comply with
applicable data protection legislation in relation
to any personal data shared with us under the
agreement.
2 of 5
7.2 Personal data – You will not provide us 7.5 Data transfers – We may transfer personal
personal data unless the agreement requires the data shared with us to other PwC firms,
subcontractors and IT service providers in
use of such personal data, including when we
relation to any of the purposes set out in clause 7.
request such personal data. You confirm that you Some of these recipients may be located outside
have competence and legal basis for the transfer the European Union. We will carry out such
of personal data, as required under applicable transfers only where we have a lawful basis to do
data protection legislation, in order for us to use so, including to a recipient who is: (i) in a country
and disclose such personal data in accordance which provides an adequate level of protection
for personal data; or (ii) under an instrument
with the agreement and that such data subjects which covers the EU requirements for the
have been given necessary information regarding transfer of personal data to data processors
its use. outside the EU.
7.3 Data processing – We will process personal
data received from you for any of the following
purposes: (i) providing the services, (ii) 8 Liability
maintaining and using relevant IT systems, (iii)
quality, risk and client management activities, 8.1 Specific types of loss – You agree that we will
(iv) providing you with information, including by not be liable for (i) loss or corruption of data
means of electronic communication, about us, from systems, (ii) loss of profit, goodwill,
other PwC firms and our and/or their range of
business opportunity, anticipated savings or
services, (v) disputes and litigation, (vi)
confirmation of provision of services for you, and benefits or (iii) indirect or consequential loss.
(vii) complying with any legal requirements or 8.2 Our liability – You agree that we will be liable
requirements of a professional body of which we
or our staff are members. We will process only when we are at fault for our actions or
personal data on paper as well as in electronic omissions. Our total liability (including interest)
form, for as long as necessary to provide the for all claims connected with the services or the
services under the agreement, safeguard our agreement (including but not limited to
rights and/or fulfil our obligations resulting from negligence) is limited to twice the fees payable for
applicable laws, regulations or professional
the services or the actual damages whichever is
standards.
the lesser. It is agreed that our fees have been
7.4 Data processor - Where we act as a data determined in consideration of, and reflect, the
processor in relation to your personal data (such limitations set forth in this clause.
as: name, surname, e-mail, phone number of
your employees, members of management, 8.3 Sharing of limit – Where we agree in writing
clients or suppliers), we will: (i) process it only on to accept liability to more than one party, the
your lawful documented instructions; (ii)
limit on our liability in clause 8.2 will be shared
implement appropriate measures designed to
ensure its security, including by imposing between them, and it is up to those parties how
confidentiality obligations on relevant personnel; they share it.
(iii) transfer it to sub-processors only under a
written contract which imposes obligations 8.4 No claims against individuals – You agree to
equivalent to those in this clause 7.4 and you bring any claim in connection with the services
authorise us to transfer your personal data to only against us, and not against any individual,
them; (iv) provide you with reasonable assistance however described.
in carrying out any legally required data
protection impact assessments, complying with
the rights of data subjects and complying with
your own data security obligations under 9 PwC firms and subcontractors
applicable data protection legislation; (v) notify
9.1 Subcontractors – We may use other PwC firms
you without undue delay after becoming aware of
a breach in respect of it; (vii) subject to clause (each of which is a separate and independent
10.1, on your request either return or destroy it at legal entity) or subcontractors to provide the
the end of the engagement (except as required by services. We remain solely responsible for the
applicable law or regulation); and (viii) on your services.
written request, provide you with reasonable
information necessary to demonstrate our 9.2 Restriction on claims – You agree not to
compliance with this clause 7.4, which may bring any claim (including a claim for negligence)
include any available third party security audit against another PwC firm (or its partners,
reports.
members, directors or employees) or
subcontractors.
3 of 5
9.3 Group members – You will ensure that no
group member including your subsidiaries,
associated companies and holding company
12 Dispute resolution
(unless a party to the agreement), both while they 12.1 Negotiation – If a dispute arises, the parties
are a group member and thereafter, brings any will attempt to resolve it by discussion and
claim against any PwC firm (or its partners, negotiation before commencing legal
members, directors or employees) or proceedings.
subcontractors in respect of any liability relating
to the services or the agreement. 12.2 Law and jurisdiction – Estonian law will
govern the agreement. All contractual and non-
contractual disputes shall be resolved by Harju
County Court.
10 Materials
12.3 Limitation period – Any claims must be
10.1 Policy – We may retain copies of all materials
brought no later than two years after the date the
relevant to the services, including any materials
claimant should have been aware of the potential
given to us by you or on your behalf.
claim and, in any event, no later than four years
10.2 Release – We will not release materials which after any alleged breach.
belong to us (including our working papers)
unless we have specifically agreed to do so. We
may require a release letter from the recipient as 13 General
a condition of disclosure.
13.1 Matters beyond reasonable control – No
party will be liable to another if it fails to meet its
obligations due to matters beyond its reasonable
11 Termination
control.
11.1 Immediate notice – Either we or you may end
13.2 Entire agreement – The agreement forms the
the agreement immediately by giving written
entire agreement between the parties in relation
notice to the other if (i) the other materially
to the services. It replaces any earlier
breaches it and does not remedy the breach
agreements, representations or discussions. No
within five business days upon receipt of a notice,
party is liable to any other party (whether for
(ii) the other is or appears likely to be unable to
negligence or otherwise) for a representation that
pay its debts or becomes insolvent or (iii) the
is not in the agreement.
performance of it (including the application of
any fee arrangements) may breach a legal or 13.3 Your actions – Where you consist of more than
regulatory requirement. one party, an act or omission of one party will be
regarded as an act or omission of all.
11.2 30 days’ notice – Either we or you may end the
agreement on 30 calendar days’ written notice. 13.4 Assignment – Unless the agreement expressly
provides otherwise, no party may assign, transfer
11.3 Fees payable on termination – You agree to
or deal with their rights or obligations under the
pay us for all services we perform up to the date
agreement without the prior written consent of
of termination. Where there is a fixed fee for
the other party, except (i) we may assign any
services, you agree to pay us for the services that
debts to another party for collection, and (ii) we
we have performed on the basis of the time spent
may novate the agreement to a transferee of all or
at our then current hourly rates, up to the
part of our business. Any assignment without the
amount of the fixed fee. Any contingent element
prior written consent (except as provided above)
of the fees will remain payable in accordance
shall be null and void.
with the engagement letter. If a contingent fee
cannot be paid for regulatory reasons, you agree 13.5 Survival - The provisions of the agreement
to pay all outstanding fees on the basis of time which expressly or by implication are intended to
spent, unless alternative arrangements have been survive its termination or expiry will survive and
agreed. continue to bind each of the parties including,
but not limited to, 2.2., 2.3, 2.4, 2.6, 2.7, 4, 5, 6,
7, 8, 9, 11.3, 12, 13 and 14.
4 of 5
14 Interpretation deliverables – any documents (in whatever
form) we provide to you from time to time;
In this agreement the following words and
expressions have the meanings given to them the agreement – these terms, any agreed
below: service specific terms and the engagement letter
to which they relate;
PwC firm – any entity or partnership within the
worldwide network of PricewaterhouseCoopers we, us or our – refers to AS
firms and entities; PricewaterhouseCoopers (registration code
10142876) whose registered office is at
services – the services set out in the Pärnu mnt 15, 10141 Tallinn, Estonia;
engagement letter;
you, your – the party or parties to this
agreement (excluding us).
Signatures:
The Client The Auditing Company
________________ ________________
5 of 5
CONTRACT FOR SERVICES
Tallinn, 29 April 2021
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, register code 70003158, registered address
at Suur-Ameerika tn 1, 10122 Tallinn, represented on the basis of the statues by Secretary
General Ando Leppiman (hereinafter referred to as Customer),
and
AS PricewaterhouseCoopers (hereinafter “the Auditing Company”), register code
10142876, located at Pärnu mnt 15, 10141 Tallinn, represented by Lauri Past, member of the
Management Board, acting pursuant to the Articles of Association of the Auditing Company,
hereinafter referred to as “the Party” or “Parties”, have concluded this Contract for services,
which, together with the annexed (Annex 3) Terms of Business of
AS PricewaterhouseCoopers and the document “H2020 Grant Agreement – Annex V - Terms
of Reference for an Independent Report of Factual Findings on costs declared under a Grant
Agreement financed under the Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Framework
Programme” (Annex 1), shall be deemed the Agreement between the Parties with regards to
rendering the services as follows:
1 The Contents of the Services
1.1 The Auditing Company shall perform agreed-upon-procedures (hereinafter “the
Services”) regarding the costs declared in the Financial Statements of the Customer
concerning the grant agreement “780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-
2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1“ in accordance with “H2020 Grant Agreement – Annex V -
Terms of Reference for an Independent Report of Factual Findings on costs declared
under a Grant Agreement financed under the Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation
Framework Programme”.
1.2 Procedures described in clause 1.1 of the contract for services (hereinafter: Contract)
shall be performed in accordance with the International Standard on Related Services
(ISRS 4400) applicable to agreed-upon procedure engagements. Draft report of factual
findings (hereinafter referred to as the Report) that shall be prepared by the Auditing
Company and presented to the Customer is enclosed to the Contract (Appendix 1).
1.3 The Contract is hereby concluded as a result of a public procurement tendering 1 and in
accordance with the procurement documentation and the tender of the Auditing
Company.
1.4 The Report is prepared solely for the confidential use of the Customer and the
European Commission and solely for the purpose of submission to the European
Commission. The Report may not be relied upon by the Customer or by the European
Commission for any other purpose, nor may it be distributed to any other parties. The
European Commission may only disclose this Report to others who have regulatory
rights of access to it, in particular the European Anti-Fraud Office and the European
Court of Auditors.
1.5 This Contract is hereby signed with the following annexes:
1.5.1 Annex 1 Procurement documents including “Model for the certificate on the financial
statements” and Terms of Reference for an Independent Report of Factual Findings
1 The Ministry`s Procurement procedure § 9 “Procurement below the small procurement threshold”
(1)
on costs declared under a Grant Agreement financed under the Horizon 2020
Research and Innovation Framework Programme;
1.5.2 Annex 2 Offer of the Auditing Company;
1.5.3 Annex 3 Terms of Business of PwC.
2 Responsible Personnel
2.1 The responsible representative of the Auditing Company with regards to rendering the
Services shall be Lauri Past.
2.2 The responsible representative of the Customer with regards to rendering the Services
shall be Indrek Gailan (
[email protected]).
2.3 The responsible representative of the Customer shall have the right to represent the
Customer in all issues related to the Contract, except issues related to the amendment
of the Contract, unilateral termination of a Contract with a definite term and
presentation of a claim for forfeit, fine for delay and/or damages.
3 The Terms of Rendering the Services, and Submission of Reports
3.1 The Auditing Company shall commence rendering the Services upon signing of the
Contract. The Customer shall submit the Financial Statements to the Auditing
Company by 30 April 2021.
3.2 The deadline for presenting the Independent Report on Actual Findings by the Auditing
Company is 10 May 2021.
4 The Fee and the Procedure of Payment
4.1 For rendering the Services, the Customer shall pay the Auditing Company a fee of
EUR 1,990 (in words one thousand nine hundred ninety) plus VAT 20%.
4.2 The invoice will be presented to the Customer after acceptance by the Customer of the
Independent Report on Actual Findings.
4.2.1 The Customer shall review the Report and return the digitally signed act of
acceptance to the Auditing Company within five days of the delivery of the Report.
4.2.2 In the event of non-compliance with the terms of the contract, the Customer shall
indicate the specific defect in the Services or Report and set a reasonable time limit
for its elimination.
4.3 The due date of invoice shall be 10 days from the date of their acceptance by the
Customer. The late payment interest shall be 0.05% per day.
4.4 If the Auditing Company fails to provide the Customer with the Services in due date set
in clause 3.2 of the Customer Contract for reasons beyond the Customer, the
Customer has the right to demand contractual penalty of 0,05% of the Fee set in
clause 4.1 per day of delay.
5 Other Provisions
5.1 This Customer Contract, along with the Terms of Business, being the integral part
hereof, constitutes the Agreement between the Parties.
5.2 By signing hereof the Customer acknowledges being familiarised with the document
“H2020 Grant Agreement – Annex V - Terms of Reference for an Independent Report
(2)
of Factual Findings on costs declared under a Grant Agreement financed under the
Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Framework Programme” and Terms of
Business, effective since 15 May 2018, accepts these terms, and considers them
binding for itself.
5.3 The Customer Contract has been concluded in one copy and signed digitally.
Signatures:
The Customer The Auditing Company
/signed digitally/ /signed digitally/
__________________ __________________
Ando Leppiman Lauri Past
(3)
Grant Agreement number: 780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
ANNEX 1
MODEL FOR THE CERTIFICATE ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR AN INDEPENDENT REPORT OF FACTUAL FINDINGS ON COSTS
DECLARED UNDER A GRANT AGREEMENT FINANCED UNDER THE HORIZON 2020 RESEARCH
FRAMEWORK PROGRAMME
INDEPENDENT REPORT OF FACTUAL FINDINGS ON COSTS DECLARED UNDER A GRANT
AGREEMENT FINANCED UNDER THE HORIZON 2020 RESEARCH FRAMEWORK PROGRAMME
1
Grant Agreement number: 780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Terms of Reference for an Independent Report of Factual Findings on costs declared
under a Grant Agreement financed under the Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation
Framework Programme
This document sets out the ‘Terms of Reference (ToR)’ under which
Majandus ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium (‘the Beneficiary’)
agrees to engage
AS PricewaterhouseCoopers (‘the Auditor’)
to produce an independent report of factual findings (‘the Report’) concerning the Financial
Statement(s)1 drawn up by the Beneficiary for the Horizon 2020 grant agreement 780371, ‘Pre-
Commercial Procurement of Future autonomous bus urban level Operation Systems — FABULOS’,
duration from 1 January 2018 to 31 March 2021 (31.12.2020 intially) (‘the Agreement’), and
to issue a Certificate on the Financial Statements’ (‘CFS’) referred to in Article 20.4 of the Agreement
based on the compulsory reporting template stipulated by the Commission.
The Agreement has been concluded under the Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Framework
Programme (H2020) between the Beneficiary and the European Union, represented by the European
Commission (‘the Commission’).
The Commission is mentioned as a signatory of the Agreement with the Beneficiary only. The
Commission is not a party to this engagement.
1.1 Subject of the engagement
The coordinator must submit to the Commission the final report within 60 days following the end of
the last reporting period which should include, amongst other documents, a CFS for each beneficiary
and for each linked third party that requests a total contribution of EUR 325 000 or more, as
reimbursement of actual costs and unit costs calculated on the basis of its usual cost accounting
practices (see Article 20.4 of the Agreement). The CFS must cover all reporting periods of the
beneficiary or linked third party indicated above.
The Beneficiary must submit to the coordinator the CFS for itself and for its linked third party(ies), if
the CFS must be included in the final report according to Article 20.4 of the Agreement.
The CFS is composed of two separate documents:
- The Terms of Reference (‘the ToR’) to be signed by the Beneficiary and the Auditor;
- The Auditor’s Independent Report of Factual Findings (‘the Report’) to be issued on the
Auditor’s letterhead, dated, stamped and signed by the Auditor (or the competent public
officer) which includes the agreed-upon procedures (‘the Procedures’) to be performed by the
Auditor, and the standard factual findings (‘the Findings’) to be confirmed by the Auditor.
If the CFS must be included in the final report according to Article 20.4 of the Agreement, the request
for payment of the balance relating to the Agreement cannot be made without the CFS. However, the
payment for reimbursement of costs covered by the CFS does not preclude the Commission the
1
By which costs under the Agreement are declared (see template ‘Model Financial Statements’ in Annex 4 to
the Grant Agreement).
2
Grant Agreement number: 780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
European Anti-Fraud Office and the European Court of Auditors from carrying out checks, reviews,
audits and investigations in accordance with Article 22 of the Agreement.
1.2 Responsibilities
The Beneficiary:
must draw up the Financial Statement(s) for the action financed by the Agreement in
compliance with the obligations under the Agreement. The Financial Statement(s) must be
drawn up according to the Beneficiary’s accounting and book-keeping system and the
underlying accounts and records;
must send the Financial Statement(s) to the Auditor;
is responsible and liable for the accuracy of the Financial Statement(s);
is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of the information provided to enable the
Auditor to carry out the Procedures. It must provide the Auditor with a written representation
letter supporting these statements. The written representation letter must state the period
covered by the statements and must be dated;
accepts that the Auditor cannot carry out the Procedures unless it is given full access to the
Beneficiary’s staff and accounting as well as any other relevant records and documentation.
The Auditor:
is qualified to carry out statutory audits of accounting documents in accordance with Directive
2006/43/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 May 2006 on statutory
audits of annual accounts and consolidated accounts, amending Council Directives
78/660/EEC and 83/349/EEC and repealing Council Directive 84/253/EEC or similar national
regulations].
The Auditor:
must be independent from the Beneficiary, in particular, it must not have been involved in
preparing the Beneficiary’s Financial Statement(s);
must plan work so that the Procedures may be carried out and the Findings may be assessed;
must adhere to the Procedures laid down and the compulsory report format;
must carry out the engagement in accordance with this ToR;
must document matters which are important to support the Report;
must base its Report on the evidence gathered;
must submit the Report to the Beneficiary.
The Commission sets out the Procedures to be carried out by the Auditor. The Auditor is not
responsible for their suitability or pertinence. As this engagement is not an assurance engagement, the
Auditor does not provide an audit opinion or a statement of assurance.
1.3 Applicable Standards
The Auditor must comply with these Terms of Reference and with2:
- the International Standard on Related Services (‘ISRS’) 4400 Engagements to perform
Agreed-upon Procedures regarding Financial Information as issued by the International
Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB);
2
Supreme Audit Institutions applying INTOSAI-standards may carry out the Procedures according to the
corresponding International Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions and code of ethics issued by INTOSAI
instead of the International Standard on Related Services (‘ISRS’) 4400 and the Code of Ethics for
Professional Accountants issued by the IAASB and the IESBA.
3
Grant Agreement number: 780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
- the Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants issued by the International Ethics
Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA). Although ISRS 4400 states that independence
is not a requirement for engagements to carry out agreed-upon procedures, the
Commission requires that the Auditor also complies with the Code’s independence
requirements.
The Auditor’s Report must state that there is no conflict of interests in establishing this Report
between the Auditor and the Beneficiary, and must specify - if the service is invoiced - the total fee
paid to the Auditor for providing the Report.
1.4 Reporting
The Report must be written in the language of the Agreement (see Article 20.7).
Under Article 22 of the Agreement, the Commission, the European Anti-Fraud Office and the Court of
Auditors have the right to audit any work that is carried out under the action and for which costs are
declared from the Commission budget. This includes work related to this engagement. The Auditor
must provide access to all working papers (e.g. recalculation of hourly rates, verification of the time
declared for the action) related to this assignment if the Commission, the European Anti-Fraud Office
or the European Court of Auditors requests them.
1.5 Timing
The Report must be provided by 27 May 2021.
AS PricewaterhouseCoopers Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Lauri Past
Member of the Management Board Ando Leppiman
Secretary General
Signature of the Auditor Signature of the Beneficiary
4
Grant Agreement number: 780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Independent Report of Factual Findings on costs declared
under Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Framework Programme
(To be printed on the Auditor’s letterhead)
To
[ name of contact person(s)], [Position]
[ [Beneficiary’s] [Linked Third Party’s] name ]
[ Address]
[ dd Month yyyy]
Dear [Name of contact person(s)],
As agreed under the terms of reference dated [dd Month yyyy]
with [OPTION 1: [insert name of the beneficiary] (‘the Beneficiary’)] [OPTION 2: [insert name of
the linked third party] (‘the Linked Third Party’), third party linked to the Beneficiary [insert name of
the beneficiary] (‘the Beneficiary’)],
we
[name of the auditor ] (‘the Auditor’),
established at
[full address/city/state/province/country],
represented by
[name and function of an authorised representative],
have carried out the procedures agreed with you regarding the costs declared in the Financial
Statement(s)3 of the [Beneficiary] [Linked Third Party] concerning the grant agreement
[insert grant agreement reference: number, title of the action and acronym] (‘the Agreement’),
with a total cost declared of
[total amount] EUR,
and a total of actual costs and unit costs calculated in accordance with the [Beneficiary’s] [Linked
Third Party’s] usual cost accounting practices’ declared of
[sum of total actual costs and total direct personnel costs declared as unit costs calculated in
accordance with the [Beneficiary’s] [Linked Third Party’s] usual cost accounting practices] EUR
and hereby provide our Independent Report of Factual Findings (‘the Report’) using the
compulsory report format agreed with you.
The Report
Our engagement was carried out in accordance with the terms of reference (‘the ToR’) appended to
this Report. The Report includes the agreed-upon procedures (‘the Procedures’) carried out and the
standard factual findings (‘the Findings’) examined.
3
By which the Beneficiary declares costs under the Agreement (see template ‘Model Financial Statement’ in
Annex 4 to the Agreement).
5
Grant Agreement number: 780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
The Procedures were carried out solely to assist the [Commission] [Agency] in evaluating whether the
[Beneficiary’s] [Linked Third Party’s] costs in the accompanying Financial Statement(s) were
declared in accordance with the Agreement. The [Commission] [Agency] draws its own conclusions
from the Report and any additional information it may require.
The scope of the Procedures was defined by the Commission. Therefore, the Auditor is not responsible
for their suitability or pertinence. Since the Procedures carried out constitute neither an audit nor a
review made in accordance with International Standards on Auditing or International Standards on
Review Engagements, the Auditor does not give a statement of assurance on the Financial Statements.
Had the Auditor carried out additional procedures or an audit of the [Beneficiary’s] [Linked Third
Party’s] Financial Statements in accordance with International Standards on Auditing or International
Standards on Review Engagements, other matters might have come to its attention and would have
been included in the Report.
Not applicable Findings
We examined the Financial Statement(s) stated above and considered the following Findings not
applicable:
Explanation (to be removed from the Report):
If a Finding was not applicable, it must be marked as ‘N.A.’ (‘Not applicable’) in the corresponding row on the
right-hand column of the table and means that the Finding did not have to be corroborated by the Auditor and
the related Procedure(s) did not have to be carried out.
The reasons of the non-application of a certain Finding must be obvious i.e.
i) if no cost was declared under a certain category then the related Finding(s) and Procedure(s) are
not applicable;
ii) if the condition set to apply certain Procedure(s) are not met the related Finding(s) and those
Procedure(s) are not applicable. For instance, for ‘beneficiaries with accounts established in a
currency other than euro’ the Procedure and Finding related to ‘beneficiaries with accounts
established in euro’ are not applicable. Similarly, if no additional remuneration is paid, the related
Finding(s) and Procedure(s) for additional remuneration are not applicable.
List here all Findings considered not applicable for the present engagement and explain the
reasons of the non-applicability.
….
Exceptions
Apart from the exceptions listed below, the [Beneficiary] [Linked Third Party] provided the Auditor
all the documentation and accounting information needed by the Auditor to carry out the requested
Procedures and evaluate the Findings.
Explanation (to be removed from the Report):
- If the Auditor was not able to successfully complete a procedure requested, it must be marked as ‘E’
(‘Exception’) in the corresponding row on the right-hand column of the table. The reason such as the
inability to reconcile key information or the unavailability of data that prevents the Auditor from
carrying out the Procedure must be indicated below.
- If the Auditor cannot corroborate a standard finding after having carried out the corresponding
procedure, it must also be marked as ‘E’ (‘Exception’) and, where possible, the reasons why the
Finding was not fulfilled and its possible impact must be explained here below.
List here any exceptions and add any information on the cause and possible consequences of
each exception, if known. If the exception is quantifiable, include the corresponding amount.
….
6
Grant Agreement number: 780371 — FABULOS — H2020-ICT-2016-2017/H2020-ICT-2017-1
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Example (to be removed from the Report):
1. The Beneficiary was unable to substantiate the Finding number 1 on … because ….
2. Finding number 30 was not fulfilled because the methodology used by the Beneficiary to
calculate unit costs was different from the one approved by the Commission. The differences
were as follows: …
3. After carrying out the agreed procedures to confirm the Finding number 31, the Auditor found a
difference of _____________ EUR. The difference can be explained by …
Further Remarks
In addition to reporting on the results of the specific procedures carried out, the Auditor would like to
make the following general remarks:
Example (to be removed from the Report):
1. Regarding Finding number 8 the conditions for additional remuneration were considered as
fulfilled because …
2. In order to be able to confirm the Finding number 15 we carried out the following additional
procedures: ….
Use of this Report
This Report may be used only for the purpose described in the above objective. It was prepared solely
for the confidential use of the [Beneficiary] [Linked Third Party] and the [Commission] [Agency], and
only to be submitted to the [Commission] [Agency] in connection with the requirements set out in
Article 20.4 of the Agreement. The Report may not be used by the [Beneficiary] [Linked Third Party]
or by the [Commission] [Agency] for any other purpose, nor may it be distributed to any other parties.
The [Commission] [Agency] may only disclose the Report to authorised parties, in particular to the
European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) and the European Court of Auditors.
This Report relates only to the Financial Statement(s) submitted to the [Commission] [Agency] by the
[Beneficiary] [Linked Third Party] for the Agreement. Therefore, it does not extend to any other of
the [Beneficiary’s] [Linked Third Party’s] Financial Statement(s).
There was no conflict of interest4 between the Auditor and the Beneficiary [and Linked Third Party]
in establishing this Report. The total fee paid to the Auditor for providing the Report was EUR ______
(including EUR______ of deductible VAT).
We look forward to discussing our Report with you and would be pleased to provide any further
information or assistance.
[legal name of the Auditor]
[name and function of an authorised representative]
[dd Month yyyy]
Signature of the Auditor
4
A conflict of interest arises when the Auditor's objectivity to establish the certificate is compromised in fact
or in appearance when the Auditor for instance:
- was involved in the preparation of the Financial Statements;
- stands to benefit directly should the certificate be accepted;
- has a close relationship with any person representing the beneficiary;
- is a director, trustee or partner of the beneficiary; or
- is in any other situation that compromises his or her independence or ability to establish the certificate
impartially.
7
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Agreed-upon procedures to be performed and standard factual findings to be confirmed by the Auditor
The European Commission reserves the right to i) provide the auditor with additional guidance regarding the procedures to be followed or the facts to be
ascertained and the way in which to present them (this may include sample coverage and findings) or to ii) change the procedures, by notifying the
Beneficiary in writing. The procedures carried out by the auditor to confirm the standard factual finding are listed in the table below.
If this certificate relates to a Linked Third Party, any reference here below to ‘the Beneficiary’ is to be considered as a reference to ‘the Linked Third Party’.
The ‘result’ column has three different options: ‘C’, ‘E’ and ‘N.A.’:
‘C’ stands for ‘confirmed’ and means that the auditor can confirm the ‘standard factual finding’ and, therefore, there is no exception to be
reported.
‘E’ stands for ‘exception’ and means that the Auditor carried out the procedures but cannot confirm the ‘standard factual finding’, or that the
Auditor was not able to carry out a specific procedure (e.g. because it was impossible to reconcile key information or data were unavailable),
‘N.A.’ stands for ‘not applicable’ and means that the Finding did not have to be examined by the Auditor and the related Procedure(s) did not
have to be carried out. The reasons of the non-application of a certain Finding must be obvious i.e. i) if no cost was declared under a certain
category then the related Finding(s) and Procedure(s) are not applicable; ii) if the condition set to apply certain Procedure(s) are not met then the
related Finding(s) and Procedure(s) are not applicable. For instance, for ‘beneficiaries with accounts established in a currency other than the euro’
the Procedure related to ‘beneficiaries with accounts established in euro’ is not applicable. Similarly, if no additional remuneration is paid, the
related Finding(s) and Procedure(s) for additional remuneration are not applicable.
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
ACTUAL PERSONNEL COSTS AND UNIT COSTS CALCULATED BY THE BENEFICIARY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ITS USUAL
A
COST ACCOUNTING PRACTICE
1
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
The Auditor draws a sample of persons whose costs were declared in the Financial Statement(s)
to carry out the procedures indicated in the consecutive points of this section A.
(The sample should be selected randomly so that it is representative. Full coverage is required if
there are fewer than 10 people (including employees, natural persons working under a direct
contract and personnel seconded by a third party), otherwise the sample should have a minimum
of 10 people, or 10% of the total, whichever number is the highest)
The Auditor sampled ______ people out of the total of ______ people.
A.1 PERSONNEL COSTS
1) The employees were i) directly
For the persons included in the sample and working under an employment contract or equivalent hired by the Beneficiary in
act (general procedures for individual actual personnel costs and personnel costs declared as unit accordance with its national
costs) legislation, ii) under the
Beneficiary’s sole technical
To confirm standard factual findings 1-5 listed in the next column, the Auditor reviewed
supervision and responsibility
following information/documents provided by the Beneficiary:
and iii) remunerated in
o a list of the persons included in the sample indicating the period(s) during which they accordance with the
worked for the action, their position (classification or category) and type of contract; Beneficiary’s usual practices.
o the payslips of the employees included in the sample;
o reconciliation of the personnel costs declared in the Financial Statement(s) with the 2) Personnel costs were recorded in
accounting system (project accounting and general ledger) and payroll system; the Beneficiary's
accounts/payroll system.
o information concerning the employment status and employment conditions of personnel
included in the sample, in particular their employment contracts or equivalent;
3) Costs were adequately supported
o the Beneficiary’s usual policy regarding payroll matters (e.g. salary policy, overtime
and reconciled with the accounts
policy, variable pay);
and payroll records.
o applicable national law on taxes, labour and social security and
o any other document that supports the personnel costs declared. 4) Personnel costs did not contain
The Auditor also verified the eligibility of all components of the retribution (see Article 6 GA) any ineligible elements.
2
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
and recalculated the personnel costs for employees included in the sample.
5) There were no discrepancies
between the personnel costs
charged to the action and the
costs recalculated by the
Auditor.
6) For ERA-NET Cofund actions:
The personnel costs do not
contain any of the following:
a) costs of organising the calls
(i.e. preparation of the call,
selection of the projects etc);
b) costs for additional
coordination and networking
activities.
Further procedures if ‘additional remuneration’ is paid 7) The Beneficiary paying
To confirm standard factual findings 6-9 listed in the next column, the Auditor: “additional remuneration” was a
non-profit legal entity.
o reviewed relevant documents provided by the Beneficiary (legal form, legal/statutory
obligations, the Beneficiary’s usual policy on additional remuneration, criteria used for
its calculation, the Beneficiary's usual remuneration practice for projects funded under 8) The amount of additional
national funding schemes…); remuneration paid corresponded
to the Beneficiary’s usual
o recalculated the amount of additional remuneration eligible for the action based on the remuneration practices and was
supporting documents received (full-time or part-time work, exclusive or non-exclusive consistently paid whenever the
dedication to the action, usual remuneration paid for projects funded by national same kind of work or expertise
schemes) to arrive at the applicable FTE/year and pro-rata rate (see data collected in the was required.
3
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
course of carrying out the procedures under A.2 ‘Productive hours’ and A.4 ‘Time
9) The criteria used to calculate the
recording system’).
additional remuneration were
‘ADDITIONAL REMUNERATION’ MEANS ANY PART OF THE REMUNERATION WHICH EXCEEDS WHAT THE objective and generally applied
PERSON WOULD BE PAID FOR TIME WORKED IN PROJECTS FUNDED BY NATIONAL SCHEMES. by the Beneficiary regardless of
the source of funding used.
IF ANY PART OF THE REMUNERATION PAID TO THE EMPLOYEE QUALIFIES AS "ADDITIONAL
REMUNERATION" AND IS ELIGIBLE UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF ARTICLE 6.2.A.1, THIS CAN BE
10) The amount of additional
CHARGED AS ELIGIBLE COST TO THE ACTION UP TO THE FOLLOWING AMOUNT:
remuneration included in the
(A) IF THE PERSON WORKS FULL TIME AND EXCLUSIVELY ON THE ACTION DURING THE FULL personnel costs charged to the
YEAR: UP TO EUR 8 000/YEAR; action was capped at EUR 8,000
(B) IF THE PERSON WORKS EXCLUSIVELY ON THE ACTION BUT NOT FULL-TIME OR NOT FOR THE
per FTE/year (up to the
FULL YEAR: UP TO THE CORRESPONDING PRO-RATA AMOUNT OF EUR 8 000, OR
equivalent pro-rata amount if the
person did not work on the
(C) IF THE PERSON DOES NOT WORK EXCLUSIVELY ON THE ACTION: UP TO A PRO-RATA AMOUNT action full-time during the year
CALCULATED IN ACCORDANCE TO ARTICLE 6.2.A.1. or did not work exclusively on
the action).
11) The personnel costs included in
Additional procedures in case “unit costs calculated by the Beneficiary in accordance with its
the Financial Statement were
usual cost accounting practices” is applied:
calculated in accordance with
Apart from carrying out the procedures indicated above to confirm standard factual findings 1-5 the Beneficiary's usual cost
and, if applicable, also 6-9, the Auditor carried out following procedures to confirm standard accounting practice. This
factual findings 10-13 listed in the next column: methodology was consistently
o obtained a description of the Beneficiary's usual cost accounting practice to calculate unit used in all H2020 actions.
costs;. 12) The employees were charged
o reviewed whether the Beneficiary's usual cost accounting practice was applied for the under the correct category.
4
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
Financial Statements subject of the present CFS; 13) Total personnel costs used in
calculating the unit costs were
o verified the employees included in the sample were charged under the correct category
consistent with the expenses
(in accordance with the criteria used by the Beneficiary to establish personnel categories)
recorded in the statutory
by reviewing the contract/HR-record or analytical accounting records;
accounts.
o verified that there is no difference between the total amount of personnel costs used in
calculating the cost per unit and the total amount of personnel costs recorded in the 14) Any estimated or budgeted
element used by the
statutory accounts;
Beneficiary in its unit-cost
o verified whether actual personnel costs were adjusted on the basis of budgeted or calculation were relevant for
estimated elements and, if so, verified whether those elements used are actually relevant calculating personnel costs and
for the calculation, objective and supported by documents. corresponded to objective and
verifiable information.
15) The natural persons worked
For natural persons included in the sample and working with the Beneficiary under a direct
under conditions similar to
contract other than an employment contract, such as consultants (no subcontractors).
those of an employee, in
To confirm standard factual findings 14-17 listed in the next column the Auditor reviewed particular regarding the way
following information/documents provided by the Beneficiary: the work is organised, the tasks
o the contracts, especially the cost, contract duration, work description, place of work, that are performed and the
ownership of the results and reporting obligations to the Beneficiary; premises where they are
performed.
o the employment conditions of staff in the same category to compare costs and;
16) The results of work carried out
o any other document that supports the costs declared and its registration (e.g. invoices, belong to the Beneficiary, or, if
accounting records, etc.). not, the Beneficiary has
obtained all necessary rights to
fulfil its obligations as if those
results were generated by itself.
5
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
17) Their costs were not
significantly different from
those for staff who performed
similar tasks under an
employment contract with the
Beneficiary.
18) The costs were supported by
audit evidence and registered
in the accounts.
For personnel seconded by a third party and included in the sample (not subcontractors) 19) Seconded personnel reported to
the Beneficiary and worked on
To confirm standard factual findings 18-21 listed in the next column, the Auditor reviewed
the Beneficiary’s premises
following information/documents provided by the Beneficiary:
(unless otherwise agreed with
o their secondment contract(s) notably regarding costs, duration, work description, place of the Beneficiary).
work and ownership of the results;
20) The results of work carried out
o if there is reimbursement by the Beneficiary to the third party for the resource made belong to the Beneficiary, or, if
available (in-kind contribution against payment): any documentation that supports the not, the Beneficiary has
costs declared (e.g. contract, invoice, bank payment, and proof of registration in its obtained all necessary rights to
accounting/payroll, etc.) and reconciliation of the Financial Statement(s) with the fulfil its obligations as if those
accounting system (project accounting and general ledger) as well as any proof that the results were generated by
amount invoiced by the third party did not include any profit; itself..
o if there is no reimbursement by the Beneficiary to the third party for the resource made If personnel is seconded against
available (in-kind contribution free of charge): a proof of the actual cost borne by the payment:
Third Party for the resource made available free of charge to the Beneficiary such as a
statement of costs incurred by the Third Party and proof of the registration in the Third 21) The costs declared were
Party's accounting/payroll; supported with documentation
and recorded in the
6
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
o any other document that supports the costs declared (e.g. invoices, etc.). Beneficiary’s accounts. The
third party did not include any
profit.
If personnel is seconded free of
charge:
22) The costs declared did not
exceed the third party's cost as
recorded in the accounts of the
third party and were supported
with documentation.
A.2 PRODUCTIVE HOURS 23) The Beneficiary applied
method [choose one option and
To confirm standard factual findings 22-27 listed in the next column, the Auditor reviewed delete the others]
relevant documents, especially national legislation, labour agreements and contracts and time
[A: 1720 hours]
records of the persons included in the sample, to verify that:
[B: the ‘total number of hours
o the annual productive hours applied were calculated in accordance with one of the
worked’]
methods described below,
[C: ‘standard annual
o the full-time equivalent (FTEs) ratios for employees not working full-time were correctly
productive hours’ used
calculated.
correspond to usual accounting
If the Beneficiary applied method B, the auditor verified that the correctness in which the total practices]
number of hours worked was calculated and that the contracts specified the annual workable 24) Productive hours were
calculated annually.
7
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
hours. 25) For employees not working
full-time the full-time
If the Beneficiary applied method C, the auditor verified that the ‘annual productive hours’ equivalent (FTE) ratio was
applied when calculating the hourly rate were equivalent to at least 90 % of the ‘standard annual correctly applied.
workable hours’. The Auditor can only do this if the calculation of the standard annual workable
hours can be supported by records, such as national legislation, labour agreements, and contracts. If the Beneficiary applied method
B.
BENEFICIARY'S PRODUCTIVE HOURS' FOR PERSONS WORKING FULL TIME SHALL BE ONE OF THE 26) The calculation of the number
FOLLOWING METHODS: of ‘annual workable hours’,
A. 1720 ANNUAL PRODUCTIVE HOURS (PRO-RATA FOR PERSONS NOT WORKING FULL-TIME)
overtime and absences was
verifiable based on the
B. THE TOTAL NUMBER OF HOURS WORKED BY THE PERSON FOR THE BENEFICIARY IN THE YEAR documents provided by the
(THIS METHOD IS ALSO REFERRED TO AS ‘TOTAL NUMBER OF HOURS WORKED’ IN THE NEXT Beneficiary.
COLUMN). THE CALCULATION OF THE TOTAL NUMBER OF HOURS WORKED WAS DONE AS
FOLLOWS: ANNUAL WORKABLE HOURS OF THE PERSON ACCORDING TO THE EMPLOYMENT
25.1) The Beneficiary calculates
CONTRACT, APPLICABLE LABOUR AGREEMENT OR NATIONAL LAW PLUS OVERTIME WORKED
the hourly rates per full
MINUS ABSENCES (SUCH AS SICK LEAVE OR SPECIAL LEAVE).
financial year following
procedure A.3 (method B
C. THE STANDARD NUMBER OF ANNUAL HOURS GENERALLY APPLIED BY THE BENEFICIARY FOR ITS is not allowed for
PERSONNEL IN ACCORDANCE WITH ITS USUAL COST ACCOUNTING PRACTICES (THIS METHOD IS beneficiaries calculating
ALSO REFERRED TO AS ‘STANDARD ANNUAL PRODUCTIVE HOURS’ IN THE NEXT COLUMN). THIS hourly rates per month).
NUMBER MUST BE AT LEAST 90% OF THE STANDARD ANNUAL WORKABLE HOURS.
If the Beneficiary applied method
C.
‘ANNUAL WORKABLE HOURS’ MEANS THE PERIOD DURING WHICH THE PERSONNEL MUST BE 27) The calculation of the number
WORKING, AT THE EMPLOYER’S DISPOSAL AND CARRYING OUT HIS/HER ACTIVITY OR DUTIES UNDER of ‘standard annual workable
THE EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT, APPLICABLE COLLECTIVE LABOUR AGREEMENT OR NATIONAL hours’ was verifiable based on
WORKING TIME LEGISLATION. the documents provided by the
Beneficiary.
8
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
28) The ‘annual productive hours’
used for calculating the hourly
rate were consistent with the
usual cost accounting practices
of the Beneficiary and were
equivalent to at least 90 % of
the ‘annual workable hours’.
A.3 HOURLY PERSONNEL RATES 29) The Beneficiary applied
[choose one option and delete
I) For unit costs calculated in accordance to the Beneficiary's usual cost accounting practice (unit the other]:
costs):
[Option I: “Unit costs (hourly
If the Beneficiary has a "Certificate on Methodology to calculate unit costs " (CoMUC) approved rates) were calculated in
by the Commission, the Beneficiary provides the Auditor with a description of the approved accordance with the
methodology and the Commission’s letter of acceptance. The Auditor verified that the Beneficiary’s usual cost
Beneficiary has indeed used the methodology approved. If so, no further verification is necessary. accounting practices”]
If the Beneficiary does not have a "Certificate on Methodology" (CoMUC) approved by the [Option II: Individual hourly
Commission, or if the methodology approved was not applied, then the Auditor: rates were applied]
o reviewed the documentation provided by the Beneficiary, including manuals and internal For option I concerning unit costs
guidelines that explain how to calculate hourly rates; and if the Beneficiary applies the
o recalculated the unit costs (hourly rates) of staff included in the sample following the methodology approved by the
results of the procedures carried out in A.1 and A.2. Commission (CoMUC):
30) The Beneficiary used the
II) For individual hourly rates: Commission-approved metho-
The Auditor: dology to calculate hourly
o reviewed the documentation provided by the Beneficiary, including manuals and internal rates. It corresponded to the
organisation's usual cost
9
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
guidelines that explain how to calculate hourly rates; accounting practices and was
applied consistently for all
o recalculated the hourly rates of staff included in the sample (recalculation of all hourly
activities irrespective of the
rates if the Beneficiary uses annual rates, recalculation of three months selected randomly
source of funding.
for every year and person if the Beneficiary uses monthly rates) following the results of
the procedures carried out in A.1 and A.2;
o (only in case of monthly rates) confirmed that the time spent on parental leave is not For option I concerning unit costs
deducted, and that, if parts of the basic remuneration are generated over a period longer and if the Beneficiary applies a
than a month, the Beneficiary has included only the share which is generated in the methodology not approved by the
month. Commission:
31) The unit costs re-calculated by
“UNIT COSTS CALCULATED BY THE BENEFICIARY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ITS USUAL COST the Auditor were the same as
ACCOUNTING PRACTICES”:
the rates applied by the
IT IS CALCULATED BY DIVIDING THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF PERSONNEL COSTS OF THE CATEGORY TO Beneficiary.
WHICH THE EMPLOYEE BELONGS VERIFIED IN LINE WITH PROCEDURE A.1 BY THE NUMBER OF FTE
AND THE ANNUAL TOTAL PRODUCTIVE HOURS OF THE SAME CATEGORY CALCULATED BY THE For option II concerning individual
BENEFICIARY IN ACCORDANCE WITH PROCEDURE A.2. hourly rates:
HOURLY RATE FOR INDIVIDUAL ACTUAL PERSONAL COSTS: 32) The individual rates re-
IT IS CALCULATED FOLLOWING ONE OF THE TWO OPTIONS BELOW: calculated by the Auditor were
the same as the rates applied by
A) [OPTION BY DEFAULT] BY DIVIDING THE ACTUAL ANNUAL AMOUNT OF PERSONNEL COSTS OF AN
the Beneficiary.
EMPLOYEE VERIFIED IN LINE WITH PROCEDURE A.1 BY THE NUMBER OF ANNUAL PRODUCTIVE HOURS
VERIFIED IN LINE WITH PROCEDURE A.2 (FULL FINANCIAL YEAR HOURLY RATE); 32.1) The Beneficiary used only
one option (per full financial
B) BY DIVIDING THE ACTUAL MONTHLY AMOUNT OF PERSONNEL COSTS OF AN EMPLOYEE VERIFIED IN year or per month)
LINE WITH PROCEDURE A.1 BY 1/12 OF THE NUMBER OF ANNUAL PRODUCTIVE HOURS VERIFIED IN throughout each financial
LINE WITH PROCEDURE A.2.(MONTHLY HOURLY RATE). year examined.
32.2) The hourly rates do not
10
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
include additional
remuneration.
A.4 TIME RECORDING SYSTEM
33) All persons recorded their time
To verify that the time recording system ensures the fulfilment of all minimum requirements and dedicated to the action on a
that the hours declared for the action were correct, accurate and properly authorised and daily/ weekly/ monthly basis
supported by documentation, the Auditor made the following checks for the persons included in using a paper/computer-
the sample that declare time as worked for the action on the basis of time records: based system. (delete the
answers that are not
o description of the time recording system provided by the Beneficiary (registration,
applicable)
authorisation, processing in the HR-system);
o its actual implementation; 34) Their time-records were
o time records were signed at least monthly by the employees (on paper or electronically) authorised at least monthly by
and authorised by the project manager or another manager; the project manager or other
superior.
o the hours declared were worked within the project period;
o there were no hours declared as worked for the action if HR-records showed absence due 35) Hours declared were worked
to holidays or sickness (further cross-checks with travels are carried out in B.1 below) ; within the project period and
were consistent with the
o the hours charged to the action matched those in the time recording system. presences/absences recorded in
HR-records.
ONLY THE HOURS WORKED ON THE ACTION CAN BE CHARGED. ALL WORKING TIME TO BE CHARGED 36) There were no discrepancies
SHOULD BE RECORDED THROUGHOUT THE DURATION OF THE PROJECT, ADEQUATELY SUPPORTED BY between the number of hours
EVIDENCE OF THEIR REALITY AND RELIABILITY (SEE SPECIFIC PROVISIONS BELOW FOR PERSONS charged to the action and the
WORKING EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE ACTION WITHOUT TIME RECORDS). number of hours recorded.
37) The exclusive dedication is
If the persons are working exclusively for the action and without time records
supported by a declaration
11
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
For the persons selected that worked exclusively for the action without time records, the Auditor signed by the Beneficiary and
verified evidence available demonstrating that they were in reality exclusively dedicated to the by any other evidence
action and that the Beneficiary signed a declaration confirming that they have worked exclusively gathered.
for the action.
B COSTS OF SUBCONTRACTING
B.1 The Auditor obtained the detail/breakdown of subcontracting costs and sampled ______ 38) The use of claimed
cost items selected randomly (full coverage is required if there are fewer than 10 items, subcontracting costs was
otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of the total, whichever number foreseen in Annex 1 and costs
is highest). were declared in the Financial
Statements under the
To confirm standard factual findings 37-41 listed in the next column, the Auditor reviewed the
subcontracting category.
following for the items included in the sample:
o the use of subcontractors was foreseen in Annex 1; 39) There were documents of
requests to different providers,
o subcontracting costs were declared in the subcontracting category of the Financial different offers and assessment
Statement; of the offers before selection of
o supporting documents on the selection and award procedure were followed; the provider in line with
internal procedures and
o the Beneficiary ensured best value for money (key elements to appreciate the respect of procurement rules.
this principle are the award of the subcontract to the bid offering best price-quality ratio, Subcontracts were awarded in
under conditions of transparency and equal treatment. In case an existing framework accordance with the principle
contract was used the Beneficiary ensured it was established on the basis of the principle of best value for money.
of best value for money under conditions of transparency and equal treatment).
(When different offers were not
In particular, collected the Auditor explains
i. if the Beneficiary acted as a contracting authority within the meaning of Directive the reasons provided by the
2004/18/EC (or 2014/24/EU) or of Directive 2004/17/EC (or 2014/25/EU), the Auditor Beneficiary under the caption
“Exceptions” of the Report.
12
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
verified that the applicable national law on public procurement was followed and that the The Commission will analyse
subcontracting complied with the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement. this information to evaluate
whether these costs might be
ii. if the Beneficiary did not fall under the above-mentioned category the Auditor verified
accepted as eligible)
that the Beneficiary followed their usual procurement rules and respected the Terms and
Conditions of the Agreement..
40) The subcontracts were not
For the items included in the sample the Auditor also verified that: awarded to other Beneficiaries
of the consortium.
o the subcontracts were not awarded to other Beneficiaries in the consortium;
o there were signed agreements between the Beneficiary and the subcontractor; 41) All subcontracts were
supported by signed
o there was evidence that the services were provided by subcontractor; agreements between the
Beneficiary and the
subcontractor.
42) There was evidence that the
services were provided by the
subcontractors.
43) For ERA-NET Cofund actions:
In case of costs for the
implementation of the trans-
national projects by the
Beneficiary, the personnel
costs do not contain costs of
organising the calls (i.e.
preparation of the call,
selection of the projects etc).
13
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
Result
Ref Procedures Standard factual finding (C / E /
N.A.)
C COSTS OF PROVIDING FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO THIRD PARTIES
C.1 The Auditor obtained the detail/breakdown of the costs of providing financial support to
third parties and sampled ______ cost items selected randomly (full coverage is required if
there are fewer than 10 items, otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of
the total, whichever number is highest).
The Auditor verified that the following minimum conditions were met: 44) All minimum conditions were
met
a) the maximum amount of financial support for each third party did not exceed EUR 60
000, unless explicitly mentioned in Annex 1;
b) the financial support to third parties was agreed in Annex 1 of the Agreement and the
other provisions on financial support to third parties included in Annex 1 were respected.
14
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
D OTHER ACTUAL DIRECT COSTS
D.1 COSTS OF TRAVEL AND RELATED SUBSISTENCE ALLOWANCES 45) Costs were incurred, approved and
reimbursed in line with the
The Auditor sampled ______ cost items selected randomly (full coverage is required if there
Beneficiary's usual policy for
are fewer than 10 items, otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of the
travels.
total, whichever number is the highest).
The Auditor inspected the sample and verified that: 46) There was a link between the trip
and the action.
o travel and subsistence costs were consistent with the Beneficiary's usual policy for travel.
In this context, the Beneficiary provided evidence of its normal policy for travel costs
47) The supporting documents were
(e.g. use of first class tickets, reimbursement by the Beneficiary on the basis of actual
consistent with each other regarding
costs, a lump sum or per diem) to enable the Auditor to compare the travel costs charged
subject of the trip, dates, duration
with this policy;
and reconciled with time records
o travel costs are correctly identified and allocated to the action (e.g. trips are directly and accounting.
linked to the action) by reviewing relevant supporting documents such as minutes of
meetings, workshops or conferences, their registration in the correct project account, their
consistency with time records or with the dates/duration of the workshop/conference; 48) No ineligible costs or excessive or
reckless expenditure was declared.
o no ineligible costs or excessive or reckless expenditure was declared (see Article 6.5
MGA).
D.2 DEPRECIATION COSTS FOR EQUIPMENT, INFRASTRUCTURE OR OTHER
ASSETS 49) Procurement rules, principles and
guides were followed.
The Auditor sampled ______ cost items selected randomly (full coverage is required if there
are fewer than 10 items, otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of the
total, whichever number is the highest). 50) There was a link between the grant
agreement and the asset charged to
For “equipment, infrastructure or other assets” [from now on called “asset(s)”] selected in the the action.
sample the Auditor verified that:
51) The asset charged to the action was
o the assets were acquired in conformity with the Beneficiary's internal guidelines and traceable to the accounting records
procedures; and the underlying documents.
15
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
52) The depreciation method used to
o they were correctly allocated to the action (with supporting documents such as delivery
charge the asset to the action was in
note invoice or any other proof demonstrating the link to the action)
line with the applicable rules of the
o they were entered in the accounting system; Beneficiary's country and the
o the extent to which the assets were used for the action (as a percentage) was supported by Beneficiary's usual accounting
reliable documentation (e.g. usage overview table); policy.
53) The amount charged corresponded
The Auditor recalculated the depreciation costs and verified that they were in line with the
to the actual usage for the action.
applicable rules in the Beneficiary’s country and with the Beneficiary’s usual accounting policy
(e.g. depreciation calculated on the acquisition value).
54) No ineligible costs or excessive or
The Auditor verified that no ineligible costs such as deductible VAT, exchange rate losses, reckless expenditure were declared.
excessive or reckless expenditure were declared (see Article 6.5 GA).
D.3 COSTS OF OTHER GOODS AND SERVICES 55) Contracts for works or services did
not cover tasks described in Annex
The Auditor sampled ______ cost items selected randomly (full coverage is required if there
1.
are fewer than 10 items, otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of the
total, whichever number is highest). 56) Costs were allocated to the correct
For the purchase of goods, works or services included in the sample the Auditor verified that: action and the goods were not
placed in the inventory of durable
o the contracts did not cover tasks described in Annex 1; equipment.
o they were correctly identified, allocated to the proper action, entered in the accounting
system (traceable to underlying documents such as purchase orders, invoices and 57) The costs were charged in line with
accounting); the Beneficiary’s accounting policy
and were adequately supported.
o the goods were not placed in the inventory of durable equipment;
o the costs charged to the action were accounted in line with the Beneficiary’s usual 58) No ineligible costs or excessive or
accounting practices; reckless expenditure were declared.
o no ineligible costs or excessive or reckless expenditure were declared (see Article 6 GA). For internal invoices/charges only
the cost element was charged,
In addition, the Auditor verified that these goods and services were acquired in conformity with without any mark-ups.
16
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
the Beneficiary's internal guidelines and procedures, in particular:
o if Beneficiary acted as a contracting authority within the meaning of Directive 59) Procurement rules, principles and
2004/18/EC (or 2014/24/EU) or of Directive 2004/17/EC (or 2014/25/EU), the Auditor guides were followed. There were
verified that the applicable national law on public procurement was followed and that the documents of requests to different
procurement contract complied with the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement. providers, different offers and
assessment of the offers before
o if the Beneficiary did not fall into the category above, the Auditor verified that the selection of the provider in line with
Beneficiary followed their usual procurement rules and respected the Terms and internal procedures and
Conditions of the Agreement. procurement rules. The purchases
For the items included in the sample the Auditor also verified that: were made in accordance with the
principle of best value for money.
o the Beneficiary ensured best value for money (key elements to appreciate the respect of
this principle are the award of the contract to the bid offering best price-quality ratio, (When different offers were not
under conditions of transparency and equal treatment. In case an existing framework collected the Auditor explains the
contract was used the Auditor also verified that the Beneficiary ensured it was established reasons provided by the Beneficiary
on the basis of the principle of best value for money under conditions of transparency and under the caption “Exceptions” of
equal treatment); the Report. The Commission will
analyse this information to evaluate
SUCH GOODS AND SERVICES INCLUDE, FOR INSTANCE, CONSUMABLES AND SUPPLIES, DISSEMINATION whether these costs might be
(INCLUDING OPEN ACCESS), PROTECTION OF RESULTS, SPECIFIC EVALUATION OF THE ACTION IF IT IS accepted as eligible)
REQUIRED BY THE AGREEMENT, CERTIFICATES ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS IF THEY ARE
REQUIRED BY THE AGREEMENT AND CERTIFICATES ON THE METHODOLOGY, TRANSLATIONS,
REPRODUCTION.
D.4 AGGREGATED CAPITALISED AND OPERATING COSTS OF RESEARCH
60) The costs declared as direct costs
INFRASTRUCTURE
for Large Research Infrastructures
The Auditor ensured the existence of a positive ex-ante assessment (issued by the EC Services) of (in the appropriate line of the
the cost accounting methodology of the Beneficiary allowing it to apply the guidelines on direct Financial Statement) comply with
costing for large research infrastructures in Horizon 2020. the methodology described in the
positive ex-ante assessment report.
17
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
In the cases that a positive ex-ante assessment has been issued (see the standard factual findings
61) Any difference between the
58-59 on the next column),
methodology applied and the one
The Auditor ensured that the beneficiary has applied consistently the methodology that is
positively assessed was extensively
explained and approved in the positive ex ante assessment;
described and adjusted accordingly.
In the cases that a positive ex-ante assessment has NOT been issued (see the standard factual
findings 60 on the next column),
The Auditor verified that no costs of Large Research Infrastructure have been charged as
direct costs in any costs category;
62) The direct costs declared were free
from any indirect costs items related
In the cases that a draft ex-ante assessment report has been issued with recommendation for
further changes (see the standard factual findings 60 on the next column), to the Large Research
Infrastructure.
The Auditor followed the same procedure as above (when a positive ex-ante assessment has
NOT yet been issued) and paid particular attention (testing reinforced) to the cost items for
which the draft ex-ante assessment either rejected the inclusion as direct costs for Large
Research Infrastructures or issued recommendations.
D.5 Costs of internally invoiced goods and services 63) The costs of internally invoiced
goods and services included in the
The Auditor sampled cost items selected randomly (full coverage is required if there are fewer Financial Statement were calculated
than 10 items, otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of the total, in accordance with the Beneficiary's
whichever number is highest). usual cost accounting practice.
64) The cost accounting practices used
To confirm standard factual findings 61-65 listed in the next column, the Auditor: to calculate the costs of internally
o obtained a description of the Beneficiary's usual cost accounting practice to calculate invoiced goods and services were
costs of internally invoiced goods and services (unit costs); applied by the Beneficiary in a
consistent manner based on
o reviewed whether the Beneficiary's usual cost accounting practice was applied for the objective criteria regardless of the
Financial Statements subject of the present CFS; source of funding.
18
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
65) The unit cost is calculated using the
o ensured that the methodology to calculate unit costs is being used in a consistent manner,
actual costs for the good or service
based on objective criteria, regardless of the source of funding;
recorded in the Beneficiary’s
o verified that any ineligible items or any costs claimed under other budget categories, in accounts, excluding any ineligible
particular indirect costs, have not been taken into account when calculating the costs of cost or costs included in other
internally invoiced goods and services (see Article 6 GA); budget categories.
o verified whether actual costs of internally invoiced goods and services were adjusted on 66) The unit cost excludes any costs of
the basis of budgeted or estimated elements and, if so, verified whether those elements items which are not directly linked
used are actually relevant for the calculation, and correspond to objective and verifiable to the production of the invoiced
information. goods or service.
o verified that any costs of items which are not directly linked to the production of the 67) The costs items used for calculating
invoiced goods or service (e.g. supporting services like cleaning, general accountancy, the actual costs of internally
administrative support, etc. not directly used for production of the good or service) have invoiced goods and services were
not been taken into account when calculating the costs of internally invoiced goods and relevant, reasonable and correspond
services. to objective and verifiable
o verified that any costs of items used for calculating the costs internally invoiced goods information.
and services are supported by audit evidence and registered in the accounts.
E USE OF EXCHANGE RATES
E.1 a) For Beneficiaries with accounts established in a currency other than euros
The Auditor sampled ______ cost items selected randomly and verified that the exchange
rates used for converting other currencies into euros were in accordance with the following
rules established in the Agreement ( full coverage is required if there are fewer than 10 items, 68) The exchange rates used to convert
otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of the total, whichever number is other currencies into Euros were in
highest): accordance with the rules
established of the Grant Agreement
COSTS RECORDED IN THE ACCOUNTS IN A CURRENCY OTHER THAN EURO SHALL BE CONVERTED INTO and there was no difference in the
EURO AT THE AVERAGE OF THE DAILY EXCHANGE RATES PUBLISHED IN THE C SERIES OF OFFICIAL final figures.
JOURNAL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
(https://www.ecb.int/stats/exchange/eurofxref/html/index.en.html ), DETERMINED OVER THE
CORRESPONDING REPORTING PERIOD.
19
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
IF NO DAILY EURO EXCHANGE RATE IS PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL JOURNAL OF THE EUROPEAN
UNION FOR THE CURRENCY IN QUESTION, CONVERSION SHALL BE MADE AT THE AVERAGE OF THE
MONTHLY ACCOUNTING RATES ESTABLISHED BY THE COMMISSION AND PUBLISHED ON ITS WEBSITE
(http://ec.europa.eu/budget/contracts_grants/info_contracts/inforeuro/inforeuro_en.cfm ),
DETERMINED OVER THE CORRESPONDING REPORTING PERIOD.
b) For Beneficiaries with accounts established in euros
The Auditor sampled ______ cost items selected randomly and verified that the exchange
rates used for converting other currencies into euros were in accordance with the following
rules established in the Agreement ( full coverage is required if there are fewer than 10 items, 69) The Beneficiary applied its usual
otherwise the sample should have a minimum of 10 item, or 10% of the total, whichever number is accounting practices.
highest):
COSTS INCURRED IN ANOTHER CURRENCY SHALL BE CONVERTED INTO EURO BY APPLYING THE
BENEFICIARY’S USUAL ACCOUNTING PRACTICES.
F For ERA-NET COFUND actions: COSTS FOR PROVIDING FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO
ERA-NET COFUND THIRD PARTIES
To confirm standard factual finding 70 in the next column, the Auditor obtained the list of final
beneficiaries for which costs have been claimed and traced it to the initial projects’ proposals.
70) The final beneficiaries for which
F.1 costs have been claimed are those
foreseen in the projects’ proposals.
20
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
To confirm standard factual findings 71-73 listed in the next column, the Auditor reviewed the
following documents provided by the Beneficiary:
- the acceptance of grants’ forms; 71) The final beneficiaries have signed
- the agreements between the Beneficiary and the final beneficiaries; the acceptance of grants’ forms.
- an overview of any ex-post audits carried out on the costs declared by the final beneficiaries; 72) Reimbursements to the final
beneficiaries were based on valid
- and the expense claim forms submitted by the final beneficiaries; expense claim forms submitted
F.2
before the payments.
73) No discrepancies exist between the
sum of the claim forms and the costs
claimed by project.
To confirm standard factual findings 74-76 listed in the next column, the Auditor obtained from
the Beneficiary proofs of payment to final beneficiaries and respective underlying documentation 74) The totality of financial support was
(grant agreements and the corresponding deliverables, particularly financial reports). distributed to the final beneficiaries.
75) The amounts of financial support to
final beneficiaries reconcile with the
ones set forth in the Annex 1 to the
F.3 grant agreement.
76) Payments to final beneficiaries are
based on the corresponding grant
agreements and subject to the
analysis of the appropriate
deliverables.
21
Grant Agreement number: [insert number] [insert acronym] [insert call identifier]
H2020 Model Grant Agreements: H2020 General MGA — Multi: v5.0 – 18.10.2017
For ERA-NET COFUND actions: COSTS FOR DIRECT COORDINATION COSTS OF
G ADDITIONAL ACTIVITIES
To confirm standard factual findings 77-80 listed in the next column, the Auditor: 77) The Beneficiary does not implement
itself the transnational project under
- verified that the beneficiary do no implement, partially or fully, the transnational project under
audit and it has not reported any
audit;
direct costs for the implementation
- obtained an understanding of the additional activities carried out; of that project.
- gathered supporting documents, such as meeting minutes, participants lists, presentations given
78) The additional activities
and reports produced during/after the meetings;
programmed for each year under
- obtained the annual programs for additional activities for each year under review; audit were carried out in full during
G.1
- reviewed Annex 1 of the ERA-NET grant and the progress reports. the year.
79) The number of unit equals the
period during which additional
activities were carried out, with the
period formatted as years.
80) The claimed amount equals the
number of units x EUR 29.000.
[legal name of the audit firm]
[name and function of an authorised representative]
[dd Month yyyy]
<Signature of the Auditor>
22