Meie 04.08.2022 nr 12.1-1/6310-1
Maaeluministeerium
TAMi järelevalve
Austatud kolleegid
Euroopa Komisjon (edaspidi komisjon) kontrollib perioodiliselt, kuidas täidetakse
liikmesriikide kohustust avaldada komisjoni läbipaistvuse moodulis TAM (Transparency
Award Module) informatsioon teatud piirmäära ületavate riigiabi otsuste kohta. Seoses
järelevalve läbi viimisega saatis komisjon kirja, kus juhib tähelepanu võimalikele puudustele
ja palub tagasisidet ning selgitusi kirjas nimetatud abimeetmete osas.
Palume Teil kontrollida Maaeluministeeriumi valitsemisalas olevate meetme raames tehtud
otsused ja saata komisjoni palutud selgitused Rahandusministeeriumile komisjonile
edastamiseks.
Komisjoni kirjas välja toodud riigiabi meetmed, mille raames tehtud otsuste TAMis
avaldamine on Maaeluministeeriumi kohustus, on SA.47248 (2017/XA) Aid of Natura 2000
to private forest land ja SA.46980 (2016/XA) Support for the breeding of agricultural animals.
Samuti palume ettepanekuid vastamiseks komisjoni kirja 3. osas esitatud küsimustele.
Ootame Maaeluministeeriumi tagasisidet 12. septembriks.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kaur Kajak
halduspoliitika asekantsler
/*Lisa(d): Euroopa Komisjoni kiri koos lisaga
Ljudmilla Sokolnikova 611 3360
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DG COMPETITION
Dirrectorate A - Policy and Strategy
Unit A3 - State aid Strategy
Brussels, 29 July 2022
TRANSPARENCY COMPLIANCE CHECKS 2022
Bilateral Communication on Compliance Issues – Estonia
Enhancing Transparency in public spending is a priority goal for the Commission.
The Transparency provisions introduced by the State Aid Modernisation (SAM) address
this concern by requiring Member States to publish detailed information on all individual
aid awards above certain thresholds, depending on the legal basis and the sector of activity
of the undertaking, as of 1 July 2016. In this context, periodically the Commission verifies
completeness and accuracy of the information published under the transparency
requirements through the compliance checks.
The Commission carried out a first exercise in 2017 concerning State aid measures
approved after the 1 July 2016 and for which expenditure was reported for the year 2016
in the context of the 2017 Reporting exercise. Main results were presented during the
Transparency Steering Group (TSG) held in Brussels on 23th November 2017.
The second exercise in 2019 enlarged substantially the coverage of the first exercise as it
investigated compliance for measures approved between 1 July 2016 and 31 December
2017 for which expenditure was reported for the years 2016 and 2017 under the 2017 and
2018 Reporting exercises.
This exercise investigates mainly compliance for all State aid measures approved between
1 July 2016 and 2020.
The analysis follows an integrated data approach that combines information from three
State aid data sources: (i) Case aid spending (SARI2), (ii) Case management applications
(Cases@EC/ISIS) and (iii) Transparency Award Module (TAM) or national transparency
registers.1
Information from Cases@EC/ISIS is used to identify the State aid measures subject to
transparency, as well as the expected number of beneficiaries for each State aid measure.
Once the measures have been identified, information from SARI2 is used to verify which
active measures have spent more than the threshold for the publication in the period
considered in the analysis. Using the expected number of beneficiaries from
Cases@EC/ISIS and the yearly amount spent under a given measure from SARI2, the
estimated amount spent per beneficiary is computed. Finally, the same measures and
related aid awards are searched in the TAM or in the national transparency registers, where
the analysis allows for the classification of compliance issues.
1
Three Member States use their national transparency registers.
Structure and main findings of the 2022 compliance checks exercise
This note presents the main findings of the 2022 compliance checks exercise and it is meant
to directly ask countries information on specific aid awards.
Member States are invited to provide further clarifications on the different issues identified
and to make general comments and suggestions. In addition, they are kindly invited to
communicate if any corrections to figures reported in TAM and/or in the national registry
will be applied following this round of compliance checks.
Compliance issues identified in the context of the 2022 compliance check exercise relate
to the publication obligation of the Member States.
This exercise aims at assessing both direct and possible compliance issues in terms of
publication obligation. The category of possible compliance issues includes, in turn, four
subcategories.
Further details and a description of the classes of issues mentioned above are provided in
the dedicated sections below.
1. Compliance Performance Indicators
This section provides an overview of the overall situation of the Member State in terms of
compliance with the transparency obligations.2
Table A: Total aid granted in the transparency register as a percentage of total aid
expenditure in SARI2
2018 2019 2020 non-COVID 2020 COVID
Estonia 98.29% 16.16% 32.18% 5.26%
Source: JRC Unit I.1. CC-ME computations based on Cases@EC, SARI2 and transparency data.
The Compliance Performance Indicators (CPI) provide a useful benchmark for Member
States to identify strengths and areas of improvement for the future.
Table 1: Key performance indicators
Estonia EU
Indicator % count % count
2018
Direct compliance issues 3.57% 1 13.31% 265
Possible compliance issues 46.43% 13 66.50% 1324
No issues 50.00% 14 20.19% 402
2019
Direct compliance issues 7.89% 3 15.23% 365
Possible compliance issues 68.42% 26 71.80% 1721
No issues 23.68% 9 12.97% 311
2020
Direct compliance issues 5.45% 3 16.57% 545
Possible compliance issues 76.36% 42 73.01% 2402
No issues 18.18% 10 10.43% 343
Source: JRC Unit I.1. CC-ME computations based on Cases@EC, SARI2 and transparency data.
2
Figures are temporary and will be adjusted after clarifications from Member States will be provided, if
necessary.
2
2. Compliance issues with respect to the publication obligation
The Commission considers that compliance issues with respect to the publication
obligation arise when a Member State fails to publish an aid award under a measure for
which the reported amount spent in the period of analysis exceeds the following thresholds:
- € 500,000 for cases under the General Block Exemption Regulation
- € 60,000 for cases under the Agriculture Block Exemption Regulation
- € 30,000 for cases under the Fisheries Block Exemption Regulation
- € 10,000 for Covid-19 TF cases in the agricultural and fisheries sectors
- € 100,000 for Covid-19 TF cases in other competition sectors
- € 60,000 for notified aid cases in the agricultural sector
- € 30,000 for notified aid cases in the fisheries sector
- € 500,000 for notified aid cases in other competition sectors
In this respect, the compliance issues identified are of two main types:
(i) Direct compliance issues;
(ii) Possible compliance issues.
2.1 Direct compliance issues
Direct compliance issues arise when a Member State fails to publish an aid award (i.e.
there are no entries or entries with the registered amount equal to zero in the TAM or in
the national registry) under a measure for which the estimated amount spent per beneficiary
is equal or higher than the thresholds listed in section 2.
When computing the estimated amount spent per beneficiary, the Commission makes a
distinction between State aid measures classified ‘Individual aid within a scheme’ or ‘ad
hoc cases’ and ‘schemes’. In the former cases, the amount spent per beneficiary
automatically corresponds to the amount spent under the measure. In the latter case, the
presence of compliance issues can only be established for cases in which the number of
estimated beneficiaries is known ex-ante (usually this is expressed in ranges, therefore it
is not precise) and an average amount spent per beneficiary can be computed.
Direct compliance issues were identified for the years 2018, 2019 and 2020 for 7 schemes.
In order to focus on the most relevant cases, the Commission selected a list of 5 cases to
be carefully assessed by the Member State list of main cases in available in the Annex (see
Excel “Compliance_Estonia.xlsx”, sheet “Direct compliance”).
Please indicate for which, if any, of the selected measures, your authorities consider that
there is no compliance issue, and explain why:
Click here to insert text.
For each of the remaining measures, please describe the specific difficulties that
contributed to the compliance issue and how they will be addressed in the future:
Click here to insert text.
2.2 Possible Compliance issues
The Commission considers that compliance issues may also arise when one of the
following conditions holds:
3
a. The calculated average amount granted per beneficiary is equal or higher than the
thresholds listed in Section 2, while less than 25% of the amount spent for the
measure in a specific year is registered in TAM.
b. The calculated average amount granted per beneficiary is below the thresholds
listed in Section 2, while there are no corresponding entries or entries with the
registered amount equal to zero in TAM or in the national registries.
c. The calculated average amount granted per beneficiary is below the thresholds
listed in Section 2, while less than 25% of the amount spent for the measure in a
specific year is registered in TAM.
d. The number of beneficiaries is unknown and:
d1: the total aid expenditure in SARI2 is above the 75th percentile of the
distribution of aid expenditure in the subsample of cases for which the
number of beneficiaries is unknown
d2: the total aid expenditure in SARI2 is below the 75th percentile of the
distribution of aid expenditure in the subsample of cases for which the
number of beneficiaries is unknown AND there are no corresponding
entries in TAM or in the national registries.
Possible compliance issues were identified for the years 2018, 2019 and 2020 for 81
schemes. In order to focus on the most relevant cases, the Commission selected a list of 45
cases to be carefully assessed by the Member State. The list of main cases in available in
the Annex (see Excel “Compliance_Estonia.xlsx”, sheet “Possible compliance”).
Please provide the list of schemes for which corresponding corrections would need to be
made.
Click here to insert text.
Please describe the specific difficulties that contributed to the compliance issues and how
they will be addressed in the future:
Click here to insert text.
3. Prospective part: Improving Compliance with the transparency requirements
3.1 Improvements to the TAM
Please indicate, if any, possible improvements of the Transparency Award Module that
would help improving compliance with the transparency requirements both in terms of
publication and quality of reporting:
Click here to insert text.
3.2 Interpretation of the rules and applicability
Please indicate which elements of the current design of the transparency obligations could
be further refined, in your experience, in order to improve compliance:
Click here to insert text.
4
Contact:
CANNAS Giuseppina – State aid case support and policy (A3), +32 2 29 83137
FERRARO Sara – State aid case support and policy (A3), +32 2 29 60480
ISELLA Lorenzo – State aid case support and policy (A3), +32 2 29 65872
VIDONI Daniele – State aid case support and policy (A3), +32 2 29 68739
5
Case Reference
Decision date
Country Type of aid Legislative sector
Covid case # beneficiaries
Estimated amount
Overall spent
amountperspent
beneficiary
(million(mil
EU
SA.39315 ######## Estonia AH Other competition sectors
0 1 2,87 2,87
SA.39315 ######## Estonia AH Other competition sectors
0 1 2,7 2,7
SA.51569 ######## Estonia Ad Hoc CaseOther competition sectors
0 1 17,3 17,3
SA.57586 ######## Estonia Individual Application
Other competition
within scheme
sectors
1 1 22 22
SA.57643 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 5 4 20
Total amount
Compliance
granted in
Year
issue
TAM (million EUR)
n/a Direct 2018
n/a Direct 2019
n/a Direct 2019
n/a Direct 2020
n/a Direct 2020
Case Reference
Decision date
Country Type of aid Legislative sector
Covid case # beneficiaries
Estimated amount
Overall spent
amountperspent
beneficiary
(million(mil
EU
SA.33449 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 28,45
SA.37526 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 300,5 0,019241 5,782
SA.39872 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 5,311
SA.41385 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 1,907
SA.41922 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 3,401
SA.44282 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 11,615
SA.46893 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 48,884
SA.47248 ######## Estonia Scheme Agriculture sector 0 n/a n/a 4,309
SA.48504 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 28,323
SA.39872 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 5,637
SA.43915 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 8,907
SA.44471 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 7,752
SA.45041 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 2,376
SA.45890 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 5,179
SA.46220 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 6,454
SA.46893 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 87,184
SA.47248 ######## Estonia Scheme Agriculture sector 0 n/a n/a 4,311
SA.47354 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 750,5 0,115459 86,652
SA.48504 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 29,451
SA.51535 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 2,088
SA.52911 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 3,478
SA.39872 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 3,4242
SA.43183 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 5,748
SA.43915 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 9,8518
SA.44471 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 7,4879
SA.44757 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 4,6974
SA.46220 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 6,9202
SA.46893 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 57,394
SA.46980 ######## Estonia Scheme Agriculture sector 0 n/a n/a 3,6376
SA.47248 ######## Estonia Scheme Agriculture sector 0 n/a n/a 4,3821
SA.48504 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 26,4227
SA.50702 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 2,9047
SA.52158 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 9,0426
SA.52911 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 4,391
SA.53257 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 0 n/a n/a 2,6803
SA.56804 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 5000 0,079824 399,122
SA.57014 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 5000 0,002932 14,6606
SA.57028 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 5000 0,009111 45,5537
SA.57234 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 5000 0,005842 29,2082
SA.57403 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 5000 0,000198 0,9911
SA.58678 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 300,5 0,00166 0,4989
SA.58748 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 5000 0 0
SA.58783 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 750,5 0,000917 0,6881
SA.59278 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 75,5 0 0
SA.59338 ######## Estonia Scheme Other competition sectors 1 75,5 0,047048 3,5521
Total amountCompliance
granted inYear
issue
TAM (million EUR)
55,28258 Possible d1 2018
0,637 Possible c 2018
n/a Possible d2 2018
n/a Possible d2 2018
n/a Possible d2 2018
2,60435 Possible d1 2018
55,2341 Possible d1 2018
n/a Possible d2 2018
0,75 Possible d1 2018
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
14,23065 Possible d1 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible b 2019
3,75 Possible d1 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible d2 2019
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d1 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
3,25 Possible d1 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
n/a Possible d2 2020
23,89 Possible c 2020
n/a Possible b 2020
4,30962 Possible c 2020
n/a Possible b 2020
n/a Possible b 2020
n/a Possible b 2020
n/a Possible b 2020
n/a Possible b 2020
n/a Possible b 2020
n/a Possible b 2020