Rahandusministeerium · 17. august 2022
Sisu (failidest)
Ref. Ares(2022)5763046 - 16/08/2022
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE GENERAL
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL AFFAIRS
Resources and performance management
Control, planning and evaluation
DRAFT AUDIT REPORT1
Audit No. EE-Q2 2022
EPM Protection of the financial interests of the Union
MEMBER STATE: Republic of Estonia
AUTHORITIES AUDITED: KredEx (Estonian Business and Innovation
Agency);
AS Eesti Raudtee;
Welfare and Health Care Department of the
Tallinn City Government and the Foundation for
Development of Northern Estonia Medical
Campus;
Environmental Investment Centre.
ADDRESSEES OF THE REPORT: Ministry of Finance and State Shared Services Centre
DATE OF AUDIT: 30 May 2022 – 3 June 2022
PRINCIPAL AUDITOR: Emese Pásztélyi
ASSOCIATED AUDITORS: Dragana Djuričić, Peter Niklas, Daniel von Dungen
1
This report sets out the provisional findings, conclusions and recommendations of the Commission
auditors. These may be modified in the light of the observations and further information received from
the national authorities. Accordingly, this report should be treated as confidential until the follow-up
procedure has been brought to a final conclusion. If the whole or part of the report is transmitted to
persons concerned by the audit to enable them to provide comments, please ensure that the information
set out in this paragraph accompanies the transmission.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
LIST OF ACRONYMS AND REFERENCES ............................................................... 3
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ......................................................................................... 4
1.1. Introduction ....................................................................................................... 4
1.2. Audit conclusions and opinion .......................................................................... 4
1.3. Summary of audit findings ................................................................................ 4
2. THE ENGAGEMENT CONTEXT ............................................................................. 6
2.1. Legal Basis ........................................................................................................ 6
2.2. Objectives of the audit ....................................................................................... 6
2.3. Audit scope ........................................................................................................ 6
2.4. Methodology...................................................................................................... 8
3. FINDINGS, ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ......................................... 9
Auditee I: Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City
Government ....................................................................................................... 9
Auditee II: Estonian Railways Ltd ............................................................................ 19
Auditee III: Estonian Business and Innovation Agency (ex KredEx) ....................... 22
Auditee IV: Environmental Investment Centre ......................................................... 25
ANNEX I: IMPORTANCE OF FINDINGS ..................................................................... 27
2|P a g e
LIST OF ACRONYMS AND REFERENCES
AOD Authorising Officer by Delegation
CID Council Implementing Decision
DG ECFIN Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs
Decision Estonian Government’s decision on 30.6.2022
Department Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City
Government
EBIA Estonian Business and Innovation Agency
EPM Enquiry Planning Memorandum
EU European Union
Financial Agreement Recovery and Resilience Facility Financing Agreement
(FA) between the Commission and the Republic of Estonia
Financial Regulation Regulation (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046 of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 18 July 2018 on the
financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union
Foundation Foundation for Development of Northern Estonia Medical
Campus
Hospital Northern Estonia Medical Campus
IB Implementing Body
ISA International Standard on Auditing
KIK Environmental Investment Centre
MPM Mission Planning Memorandum
MS Member State
PFIU Protection of the financial interests of the Union
RRF Recovery and Resilience Facility
RRF Regulation Regulation (EU) 2021/241 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 12 February 2021 establishing the Recovery
and Resilience Facility
RRP Recovery and Resilience Plan
SSSC State Shared Services Centre
SFOS Structural Funds Management Information System
3|P a g e
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.1. Introduction
In accordance with DG ECFIN’s audit plan for 2022/23, and in the context of
assessing compliance with Regulation (EU) 2021/241 of the European Parliament
and of the Council of 12 February 2021, DG ECFIN auditors have conducted a
system audit on measures implemented to protect the financial interests of the Union
in relation to the Estonian Recovery and Resilience Plan.
1.2. Audit conclusions and opinion
Based on the audit work carried out, nothing has come to the EC auditors’ attention
that causes them to believe that the subject matter of the audit is not in compliance,
in all material respects with Articles 22(1) and 22(2) of the RRF Regulation and
Article 11 of the Financing Agreement, except for the few findings listed here
below:
Incomplete anti-fraud and anti-corruption framework strategies for PFIU;
Lacking emphasis on training programs and communication;
Issue for consideration: Better harmonisation of data collection and storage
systems;
This audit represents the assessment and evaluation of the design of the internal
control system at a specific point in time. Hence, this systems audit does not provide
assurance for future periods in view of risks such as the weakening of the internal
controls resulting from changes in conditions, or possible deterioration of the degree
of compliance with legal requirements or procedures.
The audit presents the findings of the auditors and any decision on impact pertains
to the authorising officer by delegation (AOD).
1.3. Summary of audit findings
The findings from the system audit on measures implemented to protect the
financial interests of the Union in relation to the Estonian Recovery and Resilience
Plan are summarised below:
Implementing
Finding Classification
Issue Body’s
n° (see Annex I)
response
(i.e. Accepted /
Incomplete PFIU framework: Lack of a
I.1 Critical partly accepted /
well-established anti-fraud strategy
rejected)
4|P a g e
Incomplete PFIU framework: Missing (i.e. Accepted /
I.2 targeted risk assessment and on-the-spot Critical partly accepted /
checks rejected)
(i.e. Accepted /
Not enough emphasis on training Very
I.3 partly accepted /
programmes important
rejected)
(i.e. Accepted /
No harmonised collection and storage of the
I.4 Desirable partly accepted /
standardised categories of data
rejected)
(i.e. Accepted /
II.1 Lack of clear and regular communication Desirable partly accepted /
rejected)
(i.e. Accepted /
Incomplete PFIU framework III: Lacking Very
III.1 partly accepted /
elements in the anti-fraud strategy important
rejected)
(i.e. Accepted /
IV.1 Missing elements in staff’s knowledge Desirable partly accepted /
rejected)
5|P a g e
2. THE ENGAGEMENT CONTEXT
2.1. Legal Basis
The legal basis for the Commission system audit on measures implemented to
protect the financial interests of the Union is provided by Articles 74(6) and 129(1)
of the Financial Regulation and Articles 11(4) and 12(1) of the Financing
Agreement. These provisions set out the Commission powers and responsibilities
pertaining to the implementation of Estonian Recovery and Resilience Plan.
2.2. Objectives of the audit
The system audit was performed in the context of the Enquiry Planning
Memorandum "System audit on measures implemented to protect the financial
interests of the Union".
The overall objective of the audit is to obtain reasonable assurance that the Member
States' internal control systems are able to prevent, detect and correct cases of
conflict of interest, fraud, corruption and double funding.
The specific objectives of the audit are:
to verify effective implementation of proportionate and effective anti-fraud,
anti-corruption measures and measures to avoid conflict of interests
to verify that the authorities entrusted with the implementation of the RRP
measures check the absence of serious irregularities (fraud, corruption, and
conflict of interests) and double funding for example through desk reviews or
on-the-spot checks; and
to verify an effective system to collect and store data on the final recipients of
RRF funds, contractors, and sub-contractors, beneficial owners, and list of
any measures for the implementation of reforms and investment projects
under the RRP is in place.
2.3. Audit scope
In particular, the following key requirements were covered by the audit on the spot:
KR 2: Effective implementation of proportionate anti-fraud, anti-corruption
measures and measures to effectively avoid conflict of interests.
KR 4: Appropriate measure, including procedures for checking the
fulfilment of milestones and targets and compliance with horizontal
principles of sound financial management.
KR 6: Effective system to ensure that all information and documents
necessary for audit trail purposes are held.
The audit work carried out included:
6|P a g e
(1) Inspection and review of the relevant documentation (manuals, procedures,
checklists, supporting documentation, working papers etc.);
(2) Interviews with the staff responsible
(3) Walk-through tests;
(4) Control testing carried out on the selected sample of measures; and
(5) Flowcharting (visual representation of how a process works, visualization of
flow of events and data through a system).
The audit work was carried out at the level of the following auditees and milestones
and targets:
Auditee Milestones and Targets
Ministry of Finance and the
State Shared Services Centre
(hereinafter: “SSSC”) –
Coordinating Body, Audit Body
KredEx (Estonian Business and EE-C[D]-I[4-3-.4-3-]-M[68]: Published calls
Innovation Agency) for renovation grant
AS Eesti Raudtee EE-C[E]-I[5-2-.5-2-]-M[84]: Award of a
railway construction contract for the
construction of a railway on the sections of
Turba-Ellamaa and Ellamaa-Risti
Welfare and Health Care EE-C[F]-I[6-2-.6-2-]-M[99]: Signature of the
Department of the Tallinn City design contract of the Northern Estonia Medical
Government and the Foundation Campus
for Development of Northern
Estonia Medical Campus
Environmental Investment EE-C[B]-I[2-3-.2-3-]-M[28]: Establishment of
Centre under the Ministry of the a working group to plan and set up the
Environment development programme
It has to be noted that due to the Estonian Government’s decision on 30.6.20222
(hereinafter: “Decision”) two audited measures here below are intended by the
Estonian authorities to be excluded from the Estonian RRP:
6-2. Establishment of the Northern Estonia Medical Campus
5-2. Construction of a section of the westbound Tallinn-Rohuküla railway
According to the exchanges between the Estonian authorities and the DG ECFIN
and Secretariat-General RECOVER colleagues3, Estonia would seek to revise its
plan only after the submission of the first payment request (which is expected in
2
Ares(2022)5268424
3
Ares(2022)5602046
7|P a g e
September/October 2022). Therefore, although the Estonian authorities intend to
exclude the aforementioned measures from the implementation of the RRP, the
below indicated first milestones pertaining to these measures will remain part of the
upcoming first payment request in accordance with the current CID.
EE-C[F]-I[6-2-.6-2-]-M[99]: Signature of the design contract of the
Northern Estonia Medical Campus – implemented by Government of Tallinn
city and the Foundation for Development of Northern Estonia Medical
Campus
EE-C[E]-I[5-2-.5-2-]-M[84]: Award of a railway construction contract for
the construction of a railway on the sections of Turba-Ellamaa and Ellamaa-
Risti – implemented by the AS Eesti Raudtee
Therefore, the below recommendations will be followed-up by the EC auditors.
2.4. Methodology
The audit work was carried out in accordance with the methodology (including
standard checklists) set out in the above-mentioned Enquiry Planning
Memorandum.
The audit was performed in line with the International Standards on Auditing (e.g.
those issued by INTOSAI, IFAC and IIA).
8|P a g e
3. FINDINGS, ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Auditee I: Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City Government
Description of the auditee:
The construction of the Northern Estonia Medical Campus (hereinafter: “Hospital”) is the
largest measure in the RRP4 involving also additional state and local funds, therefore the
audit had a particular focus on the specific aspects of the measure’s implementation. The
selected milestone5 included the tender procedure for the design of the Hospital which was
managed by the local Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City
Government (hereinafter: “Department”). The future construction works are planned to
be steered by the Foundation for Development of Northern Estonia Medical Campus
(hereinafter: “Foundation”). Although the Department has a mostly functioning internal
control and management system and the presented details of the first tendering procedure
for the design mainly fulfilled the key requirements 2 and 4, the new Foundation6, which
will be the sole responsible for the further implementation of the measure, is, however, in
a rather rudimentary stage of being created7.
As the selected measure was initially managed by the Department, while the Foundation
was only created at a later stage for the further management of the construction procedure
of the hospital, the EC auditors investigated the procedures and policies of the Department
(having managed the first call for tender for the design) in the first place. That is why, the
below findings on activities up to the moment of the EC audit concern the Department’s
relevant activities.
Finding n° I.1 Issue: Incomplete PFIU framework: Lack of a well-established anti-
fraud strategy
Key Requirements:
KR2: Effective implementation of proportionate anti-fraud, anti-corruption
measures and measures to effectively avoid conflict of interests
KR4: Appropriate measure, including procedures for checking the fulfilment of
milestones and targets and compliance with horizontal principles of sound financial
management
Description of the finding:
It is the primary responsibility of the Member State and its implementing bodies to take
4
According to the RRP the measure constitutes of 5 milestones and 2 targets, which shall be implemented
during the foreseen framework period of the RRF.
5
EE-C[F]-I[6-2-.6-2-]-M[99]: Signature of the design contract of the Northern Estonia Medical Campus.
6
The Foundation itself was officially starting on 1 June 2022, by the time of the audit (taking place the
same day), consisted of members delegated by ministries, financial, legal, medical and engineering
experts, though the number of staff will not be raised considerably in the future (around max. 15 to 20
members).
7
It was brought to the EC auditors’ attention that here will be no future involvement from the Department,
everything will be managed by the Foundation.
9|P a g e
appropriate measures to protect the financial interests of the Union. Article 22(2) of the
RRF Regulation, as well as the key requirements of the Member States' internal control
system contained in the Financing Agreement, identify as a priority “the prevention,
detection and correction of fraud, corruption and conflicts of interests”.
The EC auditors noted that the Department should improve its policies and strategies for
prevention, detection and correction of cases of fraud. The existing internal guidelines,
orders and regulations8 provide detailed information on the specific rules for conflict of
interests, corruption and double funding (e.g. definition, declaration, how to handle etc.),
the implementation of the relevant sanctions, transmission and control of findings and the
related trainings. However, besides the Estonian Penal Code (RT I 2001, 61, 364) and
Anti-Corruption Act (RT I, 29.06.2012), which are both applicable on a national level,
there is no formal anti-fraud strategy and/or policy in place, tailored for the specificities of
the Department.
Also, in contrast to other Member States, Estonia does not have a general code of conduct
/ ethics for government officials either, which would provide such framework.
In order to successfully tackle the issue of fraud, the Commission recommends9 that the
implementing bodies develop a structured approach to tackling fraud. Within any such
policy, which should be simple and focused, the following topics should be covered:
• Strategies for the development of an anti-fraud culture;
• Allocation of responsibilities for tackling fraud;
• Reporting mechanisms for suspicions of fraud;
• Cooperation between the different actors.
Furthermore, the Department has no internal whistle-blower function in place, meaning
that the employees have no real opportunity to anonymously report suspicions of fraud,
corruption, conflict of interests and control weaknesses within the organisation. This could
increase the auditee's susceptibility to serious irregularities significantly.
It is worthwhile to mention though, that based on the interviews conducted with staff
members it became clear to the EC auditors, that they are aware of the possibility of
anonymously informing the police about suspected irregularities via the financial crime
police’s website10. The interviews, however, also manifested that because of the small size
of the Department, internal reporting of any suspicious activity anonymously is almost
impossible and that employees would rather refuse or would not opt for internal
signalisation of suspected irregularities.
Ideally the implementing bodies under the RRF should have a well-established anti-fraud
framework, which should contain a specific section on whistleblowing, that outlines in
detail:
The purpose of the whistleblowing procedure and the types of ethical
violations, crimes, wrongdoings, or serious irregularities covered by it;
8
E.g. Article 13 of the Internal accounting rules of the City of Tallinn (Adopted 18.05.2011 No. 79)
9
Please see: https://ec.europa.eu/sfc/sites/sfc2014/files/sfc-files/guidance_fraud_risk_assessment.pdf
10
https://www.politsei.ee/en/corruption-offences
10 | P a g e
The ways that have been established to allow whistleblowing, e.g. through the
online page, by contacting a responsible person, by sending an email or letter,
or by calling a responsible person;
The name and contact details of the responsible person for the whistleblowing
procedure;
The timeline for processing reported cases and guidance on when a whistle-
blower should check again to verify if action was taken;
The obligations of staff and management to process whistle-blower records and
to report cases to law enforcement agencies when deemed necessary;
The independence of the person responsible for the whistleblowing procedure;
The protection of the whistle-blower from retaliation.
Clear guidance on anti-fraud measures, including whistle-blowing functions helps the staff
members to better understand their personal responsibility in preventing fraud, corruption
and conflict of interests and the importance of controls.
Recommendation(s):
The Department is recommended:
1) To put in place an anti-fraud policy clearly and fully covering all the elements
required by Annex 3 - Fraud Policy Template to the Commission Guidance
Note on Fraud Risk Assessment11 and Effective and Proportionate Anti-Fraud
Measures for ESIF 2014-202012.
2) To establish an internal whistle-blower function and create guidance for the
staff members on where and how they should report suspicions of fraudulent
behaviour, corruption, conflict of interests or control weaknesses.
Deadline for implementation: Importance (See Annex I):
4 months Critical
Body responsible: Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City Government
Coordinating body’s response to recommendation (agree / partially agree / reject):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
11
Please see:
https://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/sources/docgener/informat/2014/guidance_fraud_risk_assessment_
annex3.pdf
12
Please see: https://ec.europa.eu/sfc/sites/default/files/sfc-files/guidance_fraud_risk_assessment.pdf
11 | P a g e
Coordinating body’s comments:
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Auditors’ further comments (if applicable):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
12 | P a g e
Finding n° I.2 Issue: Incomplete PFIU framework: Missing targeted risk assessment
and on-the-spot checks
Key Requirements:
KR4: Appropriate measures, including procedures for checking the fulfilment of
milestones and targets and compliance with horizontal principles of sound financial
management
Description of the finding:
The EC auditors noted that the Department does not have a comprehensive risk
assessment. There is a rather simple risk assessment word document of 8 pages, which
lists the potential risk categories (such as health protection and work environmental risk,
human resources risks, financial risks, regulatory risks, etc.) with shortly described
mitigation actions. The particular risk indicators, their actual assessment and the possible
risk monitoring activities are entirely missing. Furthermore, the risk assessment deals with
rather general topics, and misses the focus on irregularities and fraud.
The main objective of a risk assessment is the facilitation of a self-assessment by the
implementing body of the impact and likelihood of specific fraud, corruption and conflict
of interest scenarios occurring. The risks, which should be assessed, should be normally
identified through knowledge of previous fraudulent cases, on-the-spot checks throughout
the project implementations, as well as commonly recognised and recurring schemes. Any
other known risks for the RRF under assessment should be added. It is worthwhile to
mention here, that based on the documentation provided and the interviews concluded
with the staff members, the Department does normally not verify implementation of
actions through on-the-spot verifications. The on-the-spot verifications are left to SSSC
when they perform payment checks and only in rare cases SSSC may decide to go for on-
the-spot checks before validating the payments.
The EC auditors welcomed the fact the SSSC provides a standardised risk assessment
template (Excel sheet) for the RRF implementing bodies, which includes the following
main elements:
Identification, characterisation of risk;
Risk assessment;
Risk mitigation and monitoring;
Funds;
Dedicated list of fraud risks with reference to the corresponding wording of the
Commission; and the
Main risk categories.
A unified risk assessment of the RRF measures can help to embed an effective anti-fraud
strategy. Moreover, in the case of absence of a comprehensive risk assessment, the
Department might miss an opportunity to support its internal control system and
procedures. A well-targeted fraud risk assessment, combined with a clearly communicated
commitment to combat fraud can send a clear message to potential fraudsters.
13 | P a g e
Recommendation(s):
The Department is recommended:
1) To create a comprehensive and in-depth risk assessment with more complex
elements, alternatively, apply the unified risk assessment Excel sheet provided
by the SSSC.
2) Introduce on-the-spot checks based on the outcome of the risk assessment13 and
implement the possible lessons learnt.
Deadline for implementation: Importance (See Annex I):
4 months Critical
Body responsible: Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City Government
Coordinating body’s response to recommendation (agree / partially agree / reject):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Coordinating body’s comments:
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Auditors’ further comments (if applicable):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
13
The risk assessment would provide the basis to decide on the methodology (e.g. MUS sampling) and
frequency of on-the-spot checks
14 | P a g e
Finding n° I.3 Issue: Insufficient emphasis on training programmes
Key Requirements:
KR2: Effective implementation of proportionate anti-fraud, anti-corruption
measures and measures to effectively avoid conflict of interests
KR4: Appropriate measures, including procedures for checking the fulfilment of
milestones and targets and compliance with horizontal principles of sound financial
management
Description of the finding:
Based on documentation review and interviews conducted with the members of non-audit
staff, the Department could improve its overall training strategy.
The Department and the Tallinn City Government does not offer to their employees a
customized educational programme for the specific needs of the entity. Although a wide
range of trainings are accessible for staff members via the RTiP portal (which is a general
e-learning portal for all public servants on a national level) and general Youtube videos on
various subjects (including trainings about detection, prevention and avoidance of serious
irregularities), their completion is not always compulsory and there are no consequences
of non-completion.
The EC auditors welcomed the fact that the HR department has access to the training
records completed by employees; that the employees receive notifications and
recommendations on available trainings; that the employees also have to provide feedback
on completed trainings and that possible issues related to serious irregularities will be
frequently discussed in a less official manner between the employees.
However, during the interview conducted with a new employee, she was not able to recall
the list of trainings she had to complete and she was not sure on which educational
programmes she should participate.
As the Department has no experience with the management of EU funds, a more
thoughtful and structured training system would be helpful and necessary with a specific
focus:
a) on the unique characteristics of EU funds and in particular of the RRF; and
b) awareness-raising on the importance of prevention, detection and avoidance of the
serious irregularities.
Recommendation(s):
The Department is recommended to: Develop an internal training programme and
potentially create a specific training on the management of EU funds and related risks.
Deadline for implementation: Importance (See Annex I):
5 months Very important
15 | P a g e
Body responsible: Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City Government
Coordinating body’s response to recommendation (agree / partially agree / reject):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Coordinating body’s comments:
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Auditors’ further comments (if applicable):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
16 | P a g e
Finding n° I.4 Issue: No harmonised collection and storage of the standardised
categories of data
Key Requirements:
KR6: Effective system to ensure that all information and documents necessary for
audit trail purposes are held
Description of the finding:
As per Article 11(1)(c) of the Financing Agreement, Member States shall - for the purpose
of audit and control - provide comparable information on the use of RRF funds, and
collect and ensure access to the standardised categories of data. As per the Estonian RRP,
SSSC shall collect and store such data provided by the implementing bodies and make
them available to the Commission, OLAF and the European Court of Auditors. Apart from
that, Estonia should also have an effective system to ensure that all information and
documents necessary for audit trail purposes are held.
As a central and single data collection system, the Structural Funds Management
Information System (hereinafter: “SFOS”) is used by the SSSC along with most of the
implementing bodies under the RRP as a data collection system and data mining tool.
As SFOS – complementary to RRF purposes – is also applied for the implementation of
other European funds14, the Norwegian and European Economic Area programmes and a
number of national budget measures, it ensures a rich and comprehensive source of
information15. SFOS is linked to various national registers16, which allows effective
preliminary and ex-post cross- and horizontal compliance checks on companies, beneficial
owners, contractors and sub-contractors involved in public procurements, grants or other
support schemes. Furthermore, the audit trail (i.e. performance, connected procedures and
the outcome of the control activities concluded) related to the specific projects is also
traceable in the data collection system.
In the framework of their implementing activities the SFOS is used by almost all of the
auditees, namely by EBIA, the Environmental Investment Centre and the Estonian
Railways, be it for grant allocations, public procurements or ex-post controls. The
implementing bodies have access restricted to their own projects, but the data on final
recipients under other funds or support actions are available for all users. However, the
Department does not use the common SFOS, it uses another system called Postipoiss. The
EC auditors were presented with the features of the Postipoiss system17, which are indeed
very similar to SFOS’s functions (in terms of available sources, checklists).
However, if data is collected and stored in a different system than the SFOS, the detection
of double funding and the reporting on comparable data can be suboptimal, as screening
14
For example: ESF, ERDF, CF, JTF, REACT-EU.
15
The SFOS is a SAP based system with more than 570 active users within administration and more than
11.2 thousand public users. It has over 49 000 project entry records and over 93 000 payment claims.
16
State Business Register, the Population Register, the Criminal Register, the Public Procurement Register,
State Aid Register, Estonian Land Board Data Register, the Tax and Customs Board, the Ametlikud
Teadaanded (official online publication of the Republic of Estonia) as well as the MATS information
system (agricultural aid information system).
17
Please see the website here: http://www.ppoiss.ee/
17 | P a g e
and comparing more parallel data systems could result in inefficiencies. Therefore, it is
suggested for the Department to consider transferring all relevant data from Postipoiss to
SFOS.
Recommendation(s):
The Department is suggested to consider: Harmonising the data collection and storage
systems.
Deadline for implementation: Importance (See Annex I):
4 months Desirable
Body responsible: Welfare and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City Government
Coordinating body’s response to recommendation (agree / partially agree / reject):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Coordinating body’s comments:
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Auditors’ further comments (if applicable):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
18 | P a g e
Auditee II: Estonian Railways Ltd
Finding n° II.1 Issue: Lack of clear and regular communication
Key Requirements:
KR2: Effective implementation of proportionate anti-fraud, anti-corruption
measures and measures to effectively avoid conflict of interests
Description of the auditee:
The Estonian Railways Ltd18 is a state-owned company operating since 1870 and is
responsible for railway administration related tasks as well as the maintenance of the
railway infrastructure and efficient traffic management.
Given that the Estonian Railways Ltd has a long-standing experience with the
management of the European Cohesion Funds, its internal audit and control system is able
to detect, prevent and correct potential irregularities. Firstly, this was proven by the
documents sent in advance and during the audit (such as the code of ethics, internal
procedures, policies and arrangements regarding serious irregularities, internal risk and
control systems as well as public procurement procedures). Secondly, the concluded
interviews with the anti-fraud staff and with management provided sufficient assurance
that the staff has been familiar with the above mentioned matters and is obliged to comply
with the Estonian Railways’ Code of Ethics and with other guidelines (e.g. 4-eyes
principle, regularly updated declarations on conflict of interest and frequent background
checks).
However, minor issues have been detected and are listed as findings here below.
Description of the finding:
In compliance with Article 11(a) and (b) of the FA, the Member State shall regularly
check that the financing provided has been properly used in accordance with all applicable
rules and that any measure under the RRP has been properly implemented in accordance
with all applicable rules (in particular regarding the prevention, detection and correction of
the serious irregularities). Furthermore, the Member State shall take appropriate measures
to prevent, detect and correct the serious irregularities affecting the financial interests of
the Union and to take legal actions to recover funds that have been misappropriated,
including in relation to any measure for the implementation of reforms and investment
projects under the RRP.
Examples of good practices related to the prevention and detection of fraud, corruption
and conflict of interests include measures where the auditee has established and promoted
a clear communication to the staff, so it can understand the standards of conduct required
and their personal responsibility in preventing and detecting fraud, corruption and conflict
of interests.
During the audit, the EC auditors could verify that the auditee has anti-fraud policies,
18
Related measure implemented by the auditee: EE-C[E]-I[5-2-.5-2-]-M[84]: Award of a railway
construction contract for the construction of a railway on the sections of Turba-Ellamaa and Ellamaa-
Risti
19 | P a g e
measures to prevent and detect conflict of interests, implementation plans and manuals in
place. However, easy access to these documents is not provided. The documentation
cannot be found compiled at one place of the intranet. It was necessary to use the “search
function” on intranet to find, for example, the arrangements to avoid the conflict of interest
or anti-fraud policies and whistle blowing procedures.
This could prevent the staff from becoming aware of regular updates of strategies and
policies and understanding where and how they should report suspicions of fraudulent
behaviour or control weaknesses.
Furthermore, in the course of a random interview with 2 non anti-fraud staff members (one
newcomer and one technical project manager), it was not evident enough that the
employees are familiar with the anti-fraud, anti-corruption policies and the arrangements
to avoid the conflict of interest. The strong “tone from the top” as expected from the
auditee’s communication was not clearly detectable either (although the technical expert
spoke about “honesty” being one of the key values of the organisation).
Furthermore, the content of minutes and records of auditee senior management meetings
obtained during the audit barely cover the topics of fraud, corruption or conflict of interest.
It was explained that those topics are discussed in meetings on an ad-hoc basis.
The lack of a clear and regular external and internal communication strategy can lead to
the lack of awareness on the importance to avoid fraud, corruption and conflict of interest.
The regular communication at every level and clear messages on the penalties envisaged
for fraud cases can serve as a deterrent.
Recommendation(s):
1) The documentation on conflict of interest and anti-fraud policies should be
made easily accessible on the intranet.
2) Communication from the top management could be improved. Regular
reminders at staff meetings, on the intranet or through e-mails also to non-anti-
fraud staff are suggested.
Deadline for implementation: Importance (See Annex I):
4 months Desirable
Body responsible: Estonian Railways Ltd
Coordinating body’s response to recommendation (agree / partially agree / reject):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Coordinating body’s comments:
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Auditors’ further comments (if applicable):
20 | P a g e
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
21 | P a g e
Auditee III: Estonian Business and Innovation Agency (ex KredEx)
Finding n° III.1 Issue: Incomplete PFIU framework II: lacking elements in the anti-
fraud strategy
Key Requirements:
KR2: Effective implementation of proportionate anti-fraud, anti-corruption
measures and measures to effectively avoid conflict of interests
KR4: Appropriate measures, including procedures for checking the fulfilment of
milestones and targets and compliance with horizontal principles of sound financial
management
Description of the auditee:
KredEx and the Estonian Business and Innovation Agency (hereinafter: “EBIA”)
merged into one entity at the beginning of 2022. Due to the merger procedure and the still
ongoing transition period, by the time of the audit, some of the formal internal control
procedures and the framework of risk mitigating policies were not yet finalized. However,
it is worthwhile to mention that the former KredEx had more than 10 years of experience
in managing EU funds, therefore its internal structure, data system 19 and the experience of
the existing staff can potentially ensure the fulfilment of the above-mentioned 2 key
requirements. Despite this, the following recommendations shall help to further improve
and strengthen the auditee’s control systems.
Description of the finding:
The EC auditors noted that while EIBA20 has elements of an anti-fraud policy present in a
number of its internal guidelines and process descriptions, there is no well-documented,
formal anti-fraud policy or anti-fraud (action) plan. Based on the interviews conducted
with EIBA’s staff, the employees were mostly aware of the applicable procedures and the
responsible actors within the agency, however there were still some uncertainties
identifiable (e.g. on questions from the EC auditors on applicable procedures, the
interviewees often referred to the former practice of KredEx but were not sure how it will
be exactly managed further in the framework of the newly established implementing
body’s procedures). Also, it is worthwhile to mention, that though EBIA has a whistle-
blowing function for both external and internal users, the timeline and steps of the related
procedure; the types of ethical violations or serious irregularities covered by it; the name
and contact details of the responsible person; the independence of the person responsible
for the whistleblowing procedure; and the protection of the whistle-blower from retaliation
are not documented in detail. The Foundation’s Code of Ethics solely contains a section on
the reporting of breaches of ethical standards, which is rather short and devoid of details.
The uncertainties can also be attributed to the fact that by the time of the audit, besides
some informal trainings for newcomers, there was no comprehensive training system
available on the agency’s level, but only on a higher central level, organised by the SSSC,
19
KredEx also uses SFOS for data collection, storage and control purposes.
20
Related measure implemented by the auditee: EE-C[D]-I[4-3-.4-3-]-M[68]: Published calls for
renovation grant.
22 | P a g e
the Estonian Audit Authority or offered via RTiP website. Employees, especially process
owners/managers of the implementing authorities are responsible for the day-to-day
management of fraud risks and action plans and particularly for
ensuring that an adequate system of internal control exists within their area of
responsibility;
preventing and detecting fraud;
ensuring due diligence and implementing precautionary actions in case of
suspicion of fraud; and
taking corrective measures, including any administrative penalties, as relevant.
A well-established and robust anti-fraud strategy, with an effective structured training
system for employees can considerably reduce the fraud risk and mitigate potential
uncertainties. Hence, it is recommended to develop a dedicated anti-fraud policy and anti-
fraud action plan that should include
a commitment to combat fraud,
responsibilities for tackling fraud;
arrangements for reporting fraud;
anti-fraud measures;
a commitment to review the anti-fraud policy, to conduct risk and fraud risk
assessment at least annually and to revise it in the light of changes in circumstance
of reported fraud;
a commitment to disseminate the policy widely within organisation through the
intranet and/or communication to individual staff on a regular basis.
Furthermore, the auditee should consider implementing a formal process of regularly
reviewing cases of suspected or confirmed serious irregularities in order to improve
existing processes of prevention, detection, and correction. This should also serve the
purpose of addressing any possible control weaknesses identified. There should be at least
one such review and analysis per case and the analysis as well as the conclusions drawn
and improvements implemented should be documented and disseminated to the
appropriate colleagues.
Recommendation(s):
EIBA is recommended:
1) to develop a dedicated, formalized anti-fraud policy and anti-fraud action plan
that should include the above listed elements;
2) to establish a well-documented whistle-blowing procedure;
3) to conduct risk and fraud risk assessment at least annually;
4) to disseminate the policy and action plan widely within the organisation
through the intranet, effective and structured training system and / or
communication to individual staff on a regular basis.
Deadline for implementation: Importance (See Annex I):
4 months Very important
Body responsible: Estonian Business and Innovation Agency
23 | P a g e
Coordinating body’s response to recommendation (agree / partially agree / reject):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Coordinating body’s comments:
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Auditors’ further comments (if applicable):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
24 | P a g e
Auditee IV: Environmental Investment Centre
Description of the auditee:
The Environmental Investment Centre (in Estonian: Keskkonnainvesteeringute Keskus,
hereinafter: “KIK”) has an impressive 21 years of experience in managing funds, the
entity has a solid and effective internal control and management system. In addition to the
documents and procedures presented preliminary to and during the audit, the numerous
interviews concluded with the audit/risk assessment and management staff as well as non-
audit employees clearly supported the fact that the staff is overall competent and the risk
mitigating measures in place are well established and had proved being effective.
Finding n° IV.1 Issue: Missing elements in staff’s knowledge
Key Requirements:
KR2: Effective implementation of proportionate anti-fraud, anti-corruption
measures and measures to effectively avoid conflict of interests
KR4: Appropriate measures, including procedures for checking the fulfilment of
milestones and targets and compliance with horizontal principles of sound financial
management
Description of the finding:
The EC auditors noted the following minor issue during their audit at the KIK 21 with
regard to the existing training system. Although there is a well-established and
comprehensive training program available for the KIK employees, an interview concluded
with a member of the non-audit staff showed that the interviewee was not aware of all her
training options on the KIK’s in-house training portal. That is why, awareness raising
actions like e-mail reminders or other communication about possible trainings could
improve the visibility of the available catalogue of courses.
In addition to that, taking into account the specific features of the RRF, integration of
characteristics of the RRF programme in the training plan could further enhance the
efficiency of the internal training system of KIK.
Recommendation(s):
The Department is recommended:
1) To integrate the characteristics of the RRF programme compared to
management of cohesion programmes in the training plan.
2) To consider further awareness raising actions about and enhance knowledge
sharing within the organisation.
Deadline for implementation: Importance (See Annex I):
21
Related measure implemented by the auditee: EE-C[B]-I[2-3-.2-3-]-M[28]: Establishment of a
working group to plan and set up the development programme
25 | P a g e
4 months Desirable
Body responsible: Environmental Investment Centre
Coordinating body’s response to recommendation (agree / partially agree / reject):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Coordinating body’s comments:
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
Auditors’ further comments (if applicable):
[to be filled in during contradictory procedure]
26 | P a g e
ANNEX I: IMPORTANCE OF FINDINGS
System findings:
Critical: Corrective action is needed to address a fundamental weakness in key controls,
which puts in question the reliability of the whole or part of the internal control system to
protect the financial interests of the Union, and has led or may lead to widespread
irregularities. There is a substantial risk that the financial interests of the Union are not
protected
Very Important: Corrective action is needed to address a significant weakness in key
controls, affecting the reliability of a significant part of the internal control system to
protect the financial interests of the Union, which has led or may lead to irregularities.
There is a high risk to the reliability of measure to protect the financial interests of the
Union.
Important: Corrective action is needed to address a weakness or deficiency in the
internal control systems, which has a moderate impact at the RRP level but which,
combined with other weaknesses, may lead to irregularities. Improved controls would
benefit the implementation of the RRP and/or allow for greater effectiveness and/or
efficiency of the measures to protect the financial interests of the Union.
Desirable: Minor issue, the correction of which would support the effectiveness,
efficiency and reliability of the measures to protect the financial interests of the Union.
Individual findings:
Critical: Corrective action is needed to address a serious irregularity (including
irregularity of systemic nature) with high impact.
Very Important: Corrective action is needed to address an irregularity with medium
impact.
Important: Corrective action is needed to address a weakness or an irregularity with no
or limited (potential) impact.
27 | P a g e
Electronically signed on 16/08/2022 14:21 (UTC+02) in accordance with Article 11 of Commission Decision (EU) 2021/2121
Ref. Ares(2022)5763046 - 16/08/2022
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL AFFAIRS
Resources and performance management
The Director
Brussels,
ECFIN/R4 /EP/SGJ(2022)6326861
Subject: EPM 'System audit on measures implemented to protect the financial
interests of the Union'
Republic of Estonia’s Resilience and recovery plan
Draft audit report
Ref.: Audit No EE-Q2 2022 (to be used in all correspondence)
Announcement letter Ares(2022)2956082
Your Excellency,
Please find enclosed the draft audit report of the audit mentioned in reference.
The draft audit report sets out the provisional findings, conclusions and recommendations
of the Commission auditors. These may be modified in the light of the observations and
further information received from the national authorities. Accordingly, I request that you
treat the draft audit report as confidential until the contradictory procedure has been
brought to a final conclusion. When the whole or part of the report is transmitted to the
persons concerned by the audit to enable them to provide comments, please ensure that
the information set out in this paragraph accompanies the transmission.
In the context of the contradictory procedure, the national authorities are invited at this
stage to clarify or validate the facts presented in the draft audit report and to express their
agreement or disagreement with the findings, actions and recommendations set out in the
draft audit report within 30 calendar days of submission of the national language
version of this report. In this regard, the coordinating authority is invited to consult
during this contradictory process the implementing authorities concerned where needed
(in particular in relation to findings and preliminary conclusions under the responsibility
of the implementing authorities).
Please note that, in the absence of a reply within the requested period, we will consider
that the national authorities accept the findings and the conclusions stated in the draft
audit report and the enclosed version will be considered as final and sent to the Member
State for the required follow up.
Mr Aivo ORAV Keit Pentus-Rosimannus
Ambassador, Permanent Representative Minister of Finance
Permanent Representation of Estonia to the Ministry of Finance
EU Suur-Ameerika 1, 10122 Tallinn
Rue Guimard 11/13, 1040, Brussels
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË — Tel. +32 22991111
Following examination of the reply from the national authorities (where a reply is sent
within the above mentioned deadline), the Commission auditors will communicate the
final version of this report. The Member State will then be invited to inform the
Commission auditors on the implementation of the recommendations and actions within
the deadlines indicated for each recommendation in the final audit report.
Yours faithfully,
e-signed
Michaela Di Bucci
Enclosure: Draft audit report
c.c.: Kaur Siruli, Head of Financial Control Department, Ministry of Finance
of the Republic of Estonia, the RRF audit body
Mart Pechter, Advisor of the Financial Control Department, Ministry of
Finance of the Republic of Estonia, the RRF audit body
Triin Tomingas, Strategic Adviser of the State Budget Department,
Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Estonia, the RRF coordinating
body
Katri Targama, Expert for Result-based Management at State Shared
Services Centre
Annelii Ausmees, Project manager at KredEx/Estonian Business and
Innovation Agency
Lilly Ammon, Treasury manager at AS Eesti Raudtee
Janne Kivistik, Head of the legal and procurement unit at the Welfare
and Health Care Department of the Tallinn City Government
Gunnar Vaikmaa, Head of Risk Department at Environmental
Investment Centre
Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs
Coordination of economic policies of Member States; Declan Costello,
Deputy Director General
Mark Schelfhout, Head of Unit, ECFIN R.4
Massimo Suardi, Director ECFIN E
Joern Griesse, Head of Unit, ECFIN E.2
Delphine Leroy Deputy head of Unit ECFIN R.4
Recovery and Resilience Task Force
Johannes Luebking, Principal Adviser, SG.RECOVER.PA
Maria Teresa Fabregas Fernandez, Director, SG.RECOVER.B
Felicia Stanescu, Head of Unit, SG.RECOVER.B2
Ave Schank-Lukas, SG.RECOVER.B2 – Tallinn
Electronically signed on 16/08/2022 14:21 (UTC+02) in accordance with Article 11 of Commission Decision (EU) 2021/2121