Andmekaitse Inspektsioon · 26. jaanuar 2023
- Viit
- 2.1.-1/23/140-2
- Registreeritud
- 26. jaanuar 2023
- Dokumendi liik
- Väljaminev kiri
- Adressaat
- SA Croatia
- Saabumis/saatmisviis
- IMI Süsteem
- Funktsioon
- 2.1 Menetluse korraldamine
- Sari
- 2.1-1 Sekkumistaotlused (uus nimi alates 01.03.2024)
- Toimik
- 2.1.-1/23/45
- Vastutaja
- Alissa Hmelnitskaja (Andmekaitse Inspektsioon)
Sisu (failidest)
GDPR - Article 61 - Voluntary Mutual Assistance
IMI Number: 474665
Dear colleagues,
Thank You for the request. Please find our answers to Your questions below.
1. Is the consent of the person participating in the documentary required for filming? We
believe that consent would not be applicable in this particular case, because consent can
be withdrawn by data subject at any time.
We suppose that relying on the article 6(1)(a) of the GDPR may be problematical from a
practical point of view, because there is a data subject’s right to withdraw the consent at any
time and this problem cannot be eliminated. In Estonia we have a special regulation about
processing of personal data for academic, artistic and literary expression.
In accordance with the article 85 of the GDPR Member States shall by law reconcile the right
to the protection of personal data pursuant to this Regulation with the right to freedom of
expression and information, including processing for journalistic purposes and the purposes of
academic, artistic or literary expression. Thus, the Personal Data Protection Act § 5 prescribes
that personal data may be processed without the consent of the data subject for the purpose of
academic, artistic and literary expression, in particular disclosed if this does not cause excessive
damage to the rights of the data subject. This regulation was necessary due to disputes that arose
over a consent and the legal consequences if the data subject withdraws a consent. Moreover,
the justification for new regulation was the following:
“A consent can be withdrawn at any time, which can clearly lead to economic pressure on
producers and makers of biographical books and films. The right to withdraw a consent at any
time may result in a disproportionate burden on the makers of films and biographies, which
may clearly undermine the very nature of freedom of expression and information as a whole.
This regulation establishes the right to process personal data without the data subject's consent,
if this does not harm the data subject's rights. The essence of this section is to strike a balance
between two fundamental rights - freedom of speech and information and the right to privacy -
through the protection of personal data. Thus, the processing of personal data without the data
subject's consent for the purpose established in the regulation still requires consideration of
possible threats to the data subject's rights every time.”
Indeed, we would like to emphasise that each situation is different and it should be evaluated
on a case by case basis. For instance, if the person’s role is a major role in a film, so it may be
reasonable to proceed his or her personal data on the contract basis – the article 6(1)(b) of the
GDPR.
2. Is it allowed to record people with a hidden camera without their consent for the
purposes of filming documentary?
Regarding this question we would like to reference to the answers above. On the one hand,
Personal Data Protection Act § 5 prescribes that personal data may be processed without the
consent of the data subject for the purpose of academic, artistic and literary expression, in
particular disclosed if this does not cause excessive damage to the rights of the data subject.
Therefore, the particular case should be analysed as whether recording people with a hidden
camera cause excessive damage to the rights of the data subject or not.
On the other hand, it may depend on the situation the person and the purpose for which
concealed data collection is necessary. This may be possible based on article 6(1)(f) of the
GDPR.