ANNUAL PROGRAMME REPORT
FM14-21
Estonia
EE-INNOVATION Competitiveness
2020
1
A. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
“Green ICT” programme objective is increased value creation and sustainable growth in
Estonia’s private sector. Programme aims to stipulate and develop innovation-led long-term
business cooperation between Estonia and Norway by initiating bilateral cooperation projects
and events. Programme has three focus areas: Green Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare
Technology.
The Programme is implemented through a small grant scheme (hereinafter SGS), two open
calls and two pre-defined projects. This report shall mainly consist of the overview of the
results of SGS and first main call, also about progress made of the results framework.
SGS projects were all completed in the previous reporting period. SGS resulted with 42
implemented projects and payments done in total amount of 691,895.79 euros. In the current
reporting period, monitoring related activities have been completed.
First main call was opened for submission of applications on February 1st, 2020 and closed on
March 31st, 2020. 25 projects were awarded for a grant in total grant sum of 11,770,901.58
euros. First call results demonstrated the high relevance of SGS as 14 out 25 awarded projects
originated from SGS. Due to Covid-19 and global lockdowns in spring, the call received fewer
applications than initially expected, which is the reason behind the modest budget execution.
First call budget remainder was 7 237,202.25 euros in total. In order to achieve the objectives
of the programme's results framework, a second call was announced in November 16th, 2020,
which shall remain opened until February 1st, 2021. Second call was opened for applications
under two focus areas: Green Industry Innovation (budget 4,779,956.05 euros) and Welfare
Technology (budget 2,457,246.20 euros).
Significant progress has been on bilateral outcome, as first main call provided 16
comprehensive partnerships between Estonian and Norwegian companies. EE-INNOVATION-
0059 “Roofit.solar process innovation for developing software and automated production line”
implemented by Roofit Solar Energy OÜ in partnership with Norwegian company Søran AS and
EE-INNOVATION-0069 “AutoMVA” implemented by IPDx Diagnostics OÜ in cooperation with
Oslo University Hospital and Oslo Diabetes Research Centre are set as good project examples
on bilateral cooperation under the first call.
Two bilateral events were organised during the reporting period, which also contribute to the
outcomes as are focused to the strengthening bilateral relations between Norway and Estonia.
Green ICT programme website www.eas.ee/norwaygrants includes programme scope, calls,
events, application information and relevant deadlines.
Programme had 38 media coverages in total, including press releases and articles on launching
the two main calls and supported projects in national newspapers and online media. As a good
practice, press releases were prepared as a trilateral cooperation between the Programme
Operator (hereinafter PO), Implementing Agency (hereinafter IA) and the Royal Norwegian
Embassy in Tallinn, to ensure that the information reaches relevant target groups; and have
the maximum media coverage in Estonia.
1
B. PERFORMANCE
1. Programme context
The spread of the coronavirus from the start of 2020 had a major impact on the performance
of the Estonian economy and of the economy of the whole world. The economy of the euro
area contracted by almost 12%, which is the largest drop in the history of the single currency
area. Assistance measures taken by governments softened the drop. There has been a partial
recovery in different sectors after easing the restrictions in summer. The continuing
uncertainty in the outlook overshadows the recovery in services particularly, while there is
expectation to increases in orders in manufacturing sector.
There is major uncertainty about future growth in the economy though. As the virus started to
spread more actively again at the end of summer, it needs additional measures to keep it under
control.
The economy will grow slowly in 2021, and growth will accelerate in 2022. The latest economic
forecast from the Bank of Estonia expects the Estonian economy to recover from the crisis in
2021 and to return to where it was before the crisis in the second half of next year. The outlook
for the Estonian economy is uncertain though, as the pandemic remains impossible to predict
despite the hopeful news about vaccines, and the developments in the economy may differ
substantially from expectations.
The economy will contract by 2.5% this year. This is a much softer decline than was feared
when the coronavirus crisis erupted, and is also one of the smallest in Europe. The relatively
gentle blow means that exiting the crisis will be easier. If vaccination succeeds and the spread
of the virus can be brought under control in first half of next year, the economy will start
growing again in the second quarter of 2021 and GDP will grow by 2.9% in 2021.
The rapid bounce back of the economy in the third quarter of 2020 demonstrated that it is able
to grow rapidly after removal of restrictions. If the vaccination puts a stop to the pandemic
soon enough, the coronavirus crisis will not have caused lasting harm to the economy, which
will return to its growth track that was forecast before the crisis by 2022. Businesses have a lot
of resources standing unused and the lending conditions of the banks remain favourable. A
broad state budget stimulus will temporarily reinvigorate demand and consequently economic
activity.
The flexible labour market means that employment has dropped sharply and assistance will
need to be directed to the unemployed. Although the recession in Estonia has so far been one
of the smallest, employment has fallen further than in most other European countries. The
labour market is flexible by international standards and this allowed employment to adjust
rapidly to the new circumstances in spring and summer already, evidence for which is that the
ending of the wage subsidy was not followed by a wave of redundancies, and the number of
redundancies did not rise in October and November 2020. The unemployment rate will still
rise because of the second wave of the virus, and it will peak in early 2021 at a little above
10%, falling back to close to 7% by 2023.
2
Nevertheless, the outlook for the Estonian economy is uncertain. Although news of the vaccine
has increased hope of a rapid exit from the crisis, the forecast continues to be surrounded by
a great deal of uncertainty because the path of the virus and the restrictions imposed because
of it and their impact on the economy can vary widely from expectations. Although the base
scenario of the forecast is that the economy will grow by 2.9% next year, the negative scenario
is that it could shrink by a further 1.8% next year. The wide spread of these forecasts is closely
connected to the outlook for the euro area, where growth in 2021 is forecast to be between
0.4% and 6%. The major lack of clarity about foreign demand makes the outlook for the
Estonian economy uncertain as well.
Due to the described factors, participation of Estonian and Norwegian entrepreneurs in open
calls of Green ICT programme has been slightly less active than expected. Still, those who have
decided to participate have a clear vision how turning the products, services and solutions
greener will give them advantage in long run.
2. Results
Outcome 1: Increased competitiveness of Estonian companies within focus areas Green
Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology
Description and analysis of results
SGS was finalised in the reporting period. There were 42 implemented projects and three
terminated projects in SGS. Reasons behind termination varied from unsuccessful partner
search to insufficient interest of the target groups that ended pursuing the initial
developments. Payments were done in sum of 691,895.79 euros, in total. SGS budget surplus
(508,104.21 in total) has been added to the main call budget. To summarize, SGS has
demonstrated its importance and necessity in the course of preparations towards the main
call. In total 24 SGS’s project-promoters (54%) applied for a grant in the first main call.
Thorough preparations in SGS and successful partner search ensured companies with strong
applications in the main call as 14 SGS projects out of 25 successfully received a grant in the
first main call.
For SGS, reporting period mainly consisted of monitoring activities, described in section C1
(Monitoring).
First open call launched on February 1st and closed on March 31st, 2020. Call was open for
submission of applications in three focus areas: Green Industry Innovation, Welfare
Technologies and ICT. Altogether 44 applications were submitted with 18,196,380.26 euros
total grant applied. Applicants showed the highest interest towards Green Industry Innovation
with 25 application in total with 10,964,902.73 euros applied, followed by ICT (12 applications,
3,427,352.73 euros applied) and Welfare Technology (seven applications, 3,804,124.80 euros
applied).
Evaluation of the first main call projects took place from April until June 2020. Selection
Committee meeting was held on June 18-19, 2020. As a result, Selection Committee proposed
3
to award grants to 26 applications with the total grant of 11,770,901.58 euros. Enterprise
Estonia management board agreed with the proposition made by Selection Committee and
decisions to award grants together with project contracts were signed by beginning of July
2020. 16 main call projects out of 26 are Estonian-Norwegian partnership projects, which
present good preconditions for bilateral relations and long-term partnerships. Grant was
distributed across focus areas as follows: Green Industry Innovation projects 17 (8,072,188.08
euros), ICT 4 (1,730,959.70 euros) and Welfare Technology projects 5 (1,967,753.80 euros).
In September 2020, one project promoter decided to discard the received grant (EE-
INNOVATION-0072 Centre of Food and Fermentation Technologies “Microbiome”, grant total
392,000 euros). Project promoter submitted the application to IA, explaining the reasons
behind termination of the project. Reasons included impacts of Covid-19 pandemic, which
ultimately require the Project Promoter to review its goals and substantially modify the
planned R&D activities. Also, a large order for analyses of Project Promoter’s existing
microcalorimeter had been cancelled, therefore the purchase of a microcalorimeter also had
to be postponed and with this, the large part of the Microbiome project budget remaining
unused (approximately 1/3). Another reason for termination was a recently signed preliminary
agreement with the Estonian Defence Forces (https://mil.ee/en/defence-forces), which
requires the Project Promoter to expand the project's planned activities and build on a wider
range of nutrition research competencies and slightly different than planned in the project
plan.
Based on the above-mentioned considerations, IA annulled its decision to award the grant to
Centre of Food and Fermentation Technologies project named “Microbiome”, grant total
392,000 euros retroactively from the entry into force of the initial decision. Project promoter
has not received any payments; the released amount has been added to the Welfare
Technology second call budget.
In the context of the programme results framework, first main call presented rather good
results. For Green Industry Innovation projects, the indicators are generally well achieved :
Number of SMEs supported to develop new green products/services/processes (target 5,
result 14)
Number of large enterprises supported to develop new products/services/processes (target 2,
result 0)
Estimated annual CO2 emissions reductions (target 25 000 tons of CO2 equivalent per year,
result 32 000 tons)
Estimated annual decrease of energy consumption of supported enterprises (target 5% MWh
per year, prognosis based on applications 48 918 MWh per year)
Targets of the indicators related to application of new green products/services/processes were
not met. Only 3 projects contribute to the achievement of the target value with 4 new green
products/services/processes applied in the course of implementation of the projects: 2 SMEs
(target value 15) and 1 large company (target 5). In addition, none of the large enterprises
applied for a grant for the development of new products/services/processes.
4
In Welfare Technology focus area, the set indicator was “Number of SMEs supported to
develop new welfare technology products/services/processes”. The set target was initially
achieved as 5 SMEs were awarded for a grant. Due to the termination of one of the projects
indicated above, the target has not been met with remaining 4 SMEs contributing to the
achievement of the results.
For ICT focus area, neither of the two objectives were met:
Number of SMEs supported to develop ICT products, services and processes (target 8, result
4)
Number of large enterprises supported to develop ICT products, services and processes (target
5, result 0)
The call was successful in terms of social impact, resulting in 290 total new jobs to be created
(target 100). Due to the large number of product development projects, the target for number
of new products/services/processes was also well achieved (target 25, result 36).
Bilateral indicator was not achieved. Only 16 projects out of 25 involved a Norwegian partner,
which is below the set overall target (45). Establishing partnerships was more successful for
companies that had previously started negotiations with Norwegian companies under SGS or
using help of Enterprise Estonia or Innovation Norway, who mediated partner searches for
Estonian companies. Finalizing the submission of the joint applications was scheduled to spring
2020, when Covid-19 lockdowns restricted travelling and thereby had negative impact on the
partnership negotiations. Hence, partnerships established before the virus caused emergency
situation definitely had a competitive advantage over other applicants. Although the bilateral
target was not achieved, the supported partnerships are considered solid and well elaborated.
Partners include reputable research and development institutions as Oslo University, Oslo
University Hospital, Cancer Registry of Norway; also, well-known Norwegian companies as
Vardar AS, ICB Digital AS, Incadea Norge AS and NXTech AS.
To summarize the first main call, companies participating in the first main call were not too
much into uptake of new technologies rather than product/service development (36 new
products/services/processes developed vs 4 new products/services/processes applied). That
can be explained with the agile business environment in Estonia, whereas the companies are
small and eager to pursue new ICT-led products and services. In addition, industrial companies
in Estonia are mostly small and medium sized companies, which was reflected in the
programme results, too. SME-s presented rather active representation in the call while large
companies participation remained modest (3).
While Green Industry Innovation and Welfare Technology calls presented rather good results
in the set indicators, ICT call did not achieve neither of the two targets. Considering that the
indicators were set before the final budget breakdown between GII and ICT, the result can be
reasoned with the small budgetary means (1,930,667 euros). Altogether 7 of the submitted
applications were evaluated above the threshold, which all could have been supported if there
hadn’t been aforementioned budgetary constraints.
5
Due to Covid-19 and global lockdowns in spring, the call received fewer applications than
initially expected, which is the reason behind the modest budget execution. First main call
budget remainder was 7,237,202.25 euros in total. In order to achieve the objectives of the
programme's results framework, a second call was announced in November 16th, 2020. Call
will remain opened until February 1st, 2021. Call budget has been divided between two focus
areas: Green Industry Innovation and Welfare Technology:
1. Green Industry Innovation second call budget is 4,779,956.05 EUR
2. Welfare Technology second call budget is 2,457,246.20 EUR
It is likely that the second call will have a positive impact on the indicators that remained
unachieved in the first call. However, considering the continuing situation with Covid-19 and
even more limited budget compared to the first call, bilateral indicators might not receive an
excessive impact in the second call either.
Pre-defined projects
There are two proposals for pre-defined projects submitted:
“Open Cyber Range”;
“Health Sense”.
The goal of the predefined project "Health Sense" is to develop a secure data storage, integration,
access and analysis toolkit in order to provide large, complex and detailed sets of health and
lifecycle data for the public sector, private sector and R&D institutions. Raising the availability of
health and lifecycle data enhances the creation of new products, services and solutions by the
private sector, novel interventions by the public sector and relevant scientific knowledge by the
R&D communities in order to raise life expectancy and prolong healthy life years of people.
Application of “Health Sense” project has already gone through the appraisal process with
positive result. Ministry of Social Affairs will start the implementation of the project in
partnership with Health and Welfare Information Systems Center, Tallinn University of
Technology, University of Tartu, Helse West IKT and Western Norway University of Applied
Sciences in February 2021.
Main objectives of the predefined project "Open Cyber Range" are to create a platform for
(new) cybersecurity companies to develop, test and validate their innovative products, create
a launch pad for new products to emerge to the market, promote security thinking in private
sector and educate better workforce for the private companies.
PO has received the final application of “Open Cyber Range” project and appraisal of the
project application will start in the first quarter of 2021.
Bilateral Outcome: Enhanced collaboration between beneficiary and donor state entities
involved in the programme
6
Analysis of bilateral relations and achievements
Significant progress has been on bilateral outcome, as first main call provided 16
comprehensive partnerships between Estonian and Norwegian companies. In most cases,
partnerships are for product development or process innovation. In such projects after
development activities at a later stage of the project the product / service is validated in the
parties' supply chain. For example:
development of a marine certified ultracapacitor modules (Grace project ID: EE-INNOVATION-
0049) implemented by Skeleton Technologies OÜ in partnership with NXTech AS;
development of renewable energy map application "ReFinder" (Grace project ID:
EEINNOVATION-0041), implemented by Sunly OÜ and partner Vardar AS;
“Roofit.solar process innovation for developing software and automated production line”
project (Grace project ID: EEINNOVATION-0059), implemented by project promoter Roofit
Solar Energy OÜ and partner Søran AS.
The latter project originated from SGS and is considered as a good example from the first main
call. Project was also presented in the annual meeting of the EEA and Norway Grants in August
2020. See the short video about Roofit Solar project at IA Youtube channel:
https://youtu.be/DcC-yZ6-epw.
Norwegian universities mainly provide sectoral expertise to the Estonian companies, especially
in Welfare Technology projects where university knowledge for research and development is
essential for successful implementation of the projects. This is well presented in the project
“AutoMVA” (Grace project ID: EE-INNOVATION-0069) implemented by Estonian company IPDx
Diagnostics OÜ in cooperation with Oslo University Hospital and Oslo Diabetes Research
Centre. This project also originated from SGS and is considered as another good example from
the first main call. Project was also presented in the annual meeting of the EEA and Norway
Grants in August 2020. Video about the project at IA Youtube channel:
https://youtu.be/JojMoRl0zXM.
In addition to the abovementioned, two bilateral events were organised at programme level,
to attract companies to take part in programme and strengthen the already established
contacts between the parties. These activities also contribute to the outcomes as are focused
to the strengthening bilateral relations between Norway and Estonia.
On March 2-3, 2020 “Green Industry and ICT Matchmaking” conference took place in Oslo,
Norway. The study tour was organised by Innovation Norway and was targeted to all
companies eligible for and aiming at participation in a call. The main aim of the event was to
inform participants about opportunities the EEA and Norway Grants for the ICT and industrial
sector, international cooperation and introducing good examples of digitalisation and ICT
related projects. Conference provided participants a good platform for matchmaking and
meetings with potential partners. 10 Estonian companies participated in the event, five of
whom were awarded with the grant from the first main call in May 2020 (Energex Energy
Experts OÜ, Roofit Solar Energy OÜ, Waybiller OÜ, Netcorp OÜ, Modern Mobility OÜ).
7
Conference website: https://green-industry-and-ict-matchmaking.b2match.io/
Conference agenda: https://green-industry-and-ict-matchmaking.b2match.io/agenda
Second bilateral event “International Green Industry Innovation and ICT webinar” was held
virtually due to Covid-19 restrictions on December 15. The main aim of the event was to inform
about different funding opportunities under the EEA and Norway Grants and provided a
platform to match potential companies that would like to cooperate on a project. The focus
on the Green ICT programme was to attract Estonian and Norwegian companies to participate
in the second main call. 15 Estonian companies attended the webinar, for example Columbus
Eesti AS, Unsinkable Robotics OÜ, Green Tiger, Ekotekt OÜ. Webinar was organized in close
cooperation between IA and IN.
Webinar website: https://green-industry-innovation-ict.b2match.io/
Webinar agenda: https://green-industry-innovation-ict.b2match.io/agenda
Cooperation with DPP demonstrated strong lead in organising bilateral events. As bilateral
funds enable to organise joint bilateral events between different business programmes, DPP
has taken strong initiative to arrange such “umbrella” events that involve several beneficiary
countries. This provides various matchmaking opportunities and sets a ground basis for
partner search in all participating countries. In terms of DPP involvement in programme, the
comprehensive knowledge and experiences has sufficiently supported the evaluation process
of the first open call. IN was responsible of evaluating the bilateral partnerships in the
applications, which resulted with timely and thorough assessments. Due to DPP active
involvement in Cooperation Committee meetings, all the essential topics are mutually
deliberated prior any enforcements.
In 2020, one Cooperation Committee meeting was organised. Cooperation Committee
meeting in June was mainly focused on first main call results, but also on upcoming bilateral
events and preparations towards the second main call opening in November 2020. The next
Cooperation Committee meeting will be held in 2021 due to ongoing call as well as last
minute preparations on starting the pre-defined projects.
3. Implementation
Conformity with specific requirements
There are following conditions set in PA.
1. The National Focal Point shall ensure that the Programme Operator, prior to signing a
project contract for pre-defined project no. 1 “Open Cyber Range (OCR)” and no. 2 “Health
Sense”, carries out an external and independent appraisal of the project, in order to verify its
quality and contribution to the objectives of the Programme as well as compliance with EU
and national legislation.
Project “Health Sense” has gone through the appraisal process with positive result.
8
PO has received the final application of “Open Cyber Range” project and appraisal of the
project application will start in the first quarter of 2021.
2. No costs shall be eligible under pre-defined project no. 1 “Open Cyber Range (OCR)” and no.
2 “Health Sense” before the detailed descriptions and budgets for these pre-defined projects
have been submitted to and approved by the NMFA.
PO has submitted the detailed description and budget of the “Health Sense” project to
Financial Mechanism Office and it has approved the application.
PO will submit the detailed description and budget of the “Open Cyber Range” project to
Financial Mechanism Office shortly after appraisal.
3. The Programme Operator shall submit the summary description of the procedure for the
selection of projects to the NMFA for approval, prior to the publication of the small grant
scheme and call for proposals foreseen under this programme. The programme agreement
shall be amended accordingly.
Programme agreement Annex II set the operational rules for the programme. Programme
agreement was amended with the procedure for the selection of projects in small grant
scheme and main call. The programme agreement has been amended accordingly.
4. The Programme Operator shall submit a communication plan for the programme to the
NMFA for approval, prior to the publication of the small grant scheme and call for proposals
foreseen under this programme.
Communication plan has been sent to the FMO prior to the publication of the small grant
scheme.
Cooperation with International Partner Organisations (IPOs)
There's no cooperaration with IPOs foreseen in this programme.
C. LEARNING
1. Monitoring
IA monitors project promoters granted under the Programme through verification of reports,
procurements and payment claims, also conducting on-the-spot inspections and follow-up
inspections (in the course of implementation of main call projects). Upon verification of
payment claims, reports and procurements and conducting on-the-spot inspections, IA
internal procedures “Inspection activities” shall be followed, as stated in the Management and
Control Systems. Inspection activities include on-the-spot activities according to the
programme’s risk assessment, control on procurement activities and results control (including
examination of results and involvement of experts, if necessary, i.e. for more complex
projects). The main purpose of the on-the-spot inspection is to obtain additional assurance on
the eligibility of costs, the progress of the project results and the objects, services or
9
developments supported, where it is not possible to verify without a site visit. On-site
inspections are carried out by IA monitoring specialists and project managers.
5 SGS projects were monitored in the previous reporting period, current period consisted of
the monitoring activities for the remaining 37 projects. All SGS related control activities by IA
have been completed in the reporting period, payments in sum of 691 895.79 euros for 42
project promoters have been made in total. SGS final budget surplus in sum of 86 997.36 euros
has been added to the second main call budget.
For all SGS projects, IA carried out the following control activities:
Examination on the activity reports to ensure the implementation of the activities set out in
the application (incl. prepared documents, for example project plan, environmental impact
analysis; partner search progress and participation in the main call);
Verification of the payment claims, including cost eligibility check and compliance with the
objectives of the programme;
Grant payments. All payments have been granted by IA under the terms and conditions
established in the project contract as a final payment.
IA monitoring unit did not conduct any on-the-spot inspections in the reporting period for the
SGS projects, because of the preparational nature of the projects (compilation of project plans,
partner search etc.) and projects mainly resulted with documentation. Document control and
cost verification for such projects do not require on-site control. Instead, project activities and
prepared documents were controlled as desk work electronically. However, on-site-visits will
be planned to conduct for main call projects, in order to ensure the purposefulness of the use
of programme funds, compliance with legislation and eligibility of project costs and fulfilment
of information and communication requirements. On-site-visits for main call projects start in
2021 according to the risk assessment conducted by IA monitoring unit.
Regarding main call, first projects started their activities in mid-July. First interim reports have
already been submitted to IA and cost verification as well as compliance related activities are
being processed.
Based on main call risk assessment, IA monitoring unit shall conduct on-the-spot inspections
for 50% of the projects in the focus areas of Green Industry Innovation and ICT. That means
that half of the financed projects shall pass the on-site control procedures in addition to the
customary control procedures in IA. Considering the higher maximum grant amount for
Welfare Technology projects, the percentage for the on-the-spot inspections is 100%, which
means that all projects financed under WT shall pass the on-site control procedures in addition
to the customary control in IA (cost verification, compliance, results control etc). The list of all
projects involved in sample for on-spot inspection shall be drawn up in early 2021 and
presented in next annual report.
Notifying of irregularities shall be based on Regulation No. 143 of the Government of the
Republic of Estonia of 1 September 2014 “Conditions and Procedure for Deeming Costs to Be
Compensated for out of Structural Assistance of the Period 2014–2020 as Eligible, Payment of
Support and Making Financial Corrections” and recovery of the grant shall be based on the
10
Performance Agreement (signed between PO and IA), Programme Agreement and Regulation
on the Implementation of the Norwegian Financial Mechanism 2014–2021. No irregularities
have been notified in the reporting period.
2. Evaluation
Final evaluation (ex post) of the programme’s implementation/impact will be carried out in
2024.
3. Lessons learned
Considered as force majeure, the Covid-19 global pandemic proved to be a challenge when
building new partnerships. Organising face to face meetings internationally was difficult or
even impossible. Without the direct communication, the trust between the newly
established partnerships remained rather weak to submit a joint application, especially for
partners with very short communication history. In some cases, electronic communication
channels could be used, but not always. As a lesson learned we see that limited
communication has negatively affected the bilateral cooperation in the programme. That is
also reflected in the bilateral indicators not achieved in the results framework.
D. ANNEXES
1. Updated results (indicator achievements)
2. Communication
3. Overview of contracted projects
4. Risk management
5. Monitoring plan
6. Evaluation report
7. List of individual mobilities
11
Annex 1: Updated results (indicator achievements)
Objective: Increased value creation and sustainable growth
Outcome 1: Increased competitiveness of Estonian companies within focus areas Green Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
First reductions occur in the
course of implementation of
Estimated annual CO2 emissions reductions Annual
0.00 0 (APR 2019) - - 0 25,000.00 the first main call projects (will
(tons of CO2 equivalent per year) number
be reported in the annual
report on 2021).
Estimated annual growth in turnover of
Percentage N/A - 0 0 - 5.00 % -
supported enterprises
Estimated annual growth in net operational
Percentage N/A - 0 0 - 5.00 % -
profit of supported enterprises
Estimated annual decrease of energy Will be calculated during the
consumption of supported enterprises (in Percentage - - 0 0 - 5.00 % implementation of specific
MWh) main call projects.
Number of products/services/processes
Implementation of the specific
tested in the Open Cyber Range security Number 0.00 0 (APR 2019) - - 0 10.00
PDP has not started yet.
platform
Number of new Implementation of projects
products/services/processes applied (new- Number 0 0 (APR 2019) - - 0 20 has recently started, there are
to-the-enterprise) (disaggregated by sector) no results yet.
Implementation of projects
Number of registered applications for
Number 0.00 0 (APR 2019) - - 0 5.00 has recently started, there are
Intellectual Property Protection
no results yet.
Projects have not reported the
Number of jobs created Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 100
results yet.
Gender
12
Female - - - - - 0 - -
Male - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Age
Children and youth (0-17) - - - - - 0 - -
Young adults (18-29) - - - - - 0 - -
Adults (30-64) - - - - - 0 - -
Elderly (65+) - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Number of new Implementation of projects
products/services/processes developed Number 0 0 (APR 2019) - - 0 25 has recently started, there are
(disaggregated by sector) no results yet.
Output 1.1: Enterprises supported to develop or apply innovative green products, services and processes
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Number of large enterprises supported in
Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 15 -
SGS to prepare projects for main call
Revised, as there was an error
Number of large enterprises supported to
in statistics reported in IFR.
apply new green Number 0 2 (IFR 2020) - - 1 5
Miscalculation in division of
products/services/processes
SMEs and large enterprises.
Number of SMEs supported in SGS to
Number 0 13 (IFR 2020) - - 13 30 -
prepare projects for main call
Number of SMEs supported to apply new
green products/services/processes (new-to- Number 0 2 (IFR 2020) - - 2 15 -
the-enterprise)
Revised, as there was an error
Number of SMEs supported to develop new in statistics. IA counted some
Number 0 17 (IFR 2020) - - 14 5
green products/services/processes of the project promoters twice
under different outputs.
13
Number of large enterprises supported to
Two large enterprises were
develop new green Number 0 2 (IFR 2020) - - 0 2
reported by mistake in IFR.
products/services/processes
Output 1.2: Enterprises supported to develop innovative ICT products, services and processes
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Number of SMEs supported in SGS to
Number 0 20 (IFR 2020) - - 20 25 -
prepare projects for main call
Number of SMEs supported to develop ICT
Number 0 4 (IFR 2020) - - 4 8 -
products, services and processes
Number of large enterprises supported in
Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 6 -
SGS to prepare projects for main call
Number of large enterprises supported to
develop ICT products, services and Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 5 -
processes
Output 1.3: Enterprises supported to develop innovative welfare products, services and processes
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Number of large enterprises supported in
Number 0.00 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 2.00 -
SGS to prepare projects for main call
Number of enterprises supported in SGS to
Number 0 11 (IFR 2020) - - 11 8 -
prepare projects for main call
Promoter of project EE-
Number of SMEs supported to develop new INNOVATION-0072
welfare technology Number 0.00 5 (IFR 2020) - - 4 5.00 “Microbiome” initiated the
products/services/processes termination of project.
Explanation regarding the
14
termination inserted to
GRACE.
Output 1.4: Open Cyber Range (OCR) is operational
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Number of SMEs supported to test new
products/services/processes in the Open Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 15 Project has not started yet.
Cyber Range
Number of professional staff trained Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 100 Project has not started yet.
Gender
Female - - - - - 0 - -
Male - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Roma
Roma - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Output 1.5: Health Sense data management platform developed and operating
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
Data collection, and publishing environment
architecture and data analysis environment Binary No No (IFR 2020) - - No Yes -
architecture developed and published
Data collection and publishing
Binary No No (IFR 2020) - - No Yes -
procedures/tools in place and documented
Data analysis procedures/tools in place and
Binary No No (IFR 2020) - - No Yes -
documented
15
Number of data mining/Artificial
Intelligence pilot projects successfully Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 3 -
finished
Number of professional staff trained Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 10 -
Gender
Female - - - - - 0 - -
Male - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Roma
Roma - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Bilateral Outcome: Enhanced collaboration between beneficiary and donor state entities involved in the programme
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
4.5,
6.52, Target is
Survey ≥4.5, and
carried an
Level of satisfaction with the partnership Scale 1-7 - - - 5.08 -
out on increase
behalf of on the
the FMO baseline
value
State type
Beneficiary State - - - - - 3.50 - -
Donor State - - - - - 6.67 - -
Not specified - - - - - - - -
6.52, 4.5,
Level of trust between cooperating entities Survey Target is
Scale 1-7 - - - 5.25 -
in Beneficiary States and Donor States carried ≥4.5, and
out on an
16
behalf of increase
the FMO on the
baseline
value
State type
Beneficiary State - - - - - 3.50 - -
Donor State - - - - - 7 - -
Not specified - - - - - - - -
50.00 %,
Share of donor business partnerships which
Target is
continue after project implementation Percentage N/A - 0 0 - -
minimum
period
50%
Number of jointly registered applications for
Number 0.00 0 (APR 2019) - - 0 3.00 -
Intellectual Property Protection
Donor State
Norway - - - - - 0 - -
Iceland - - - - - 0 - -
Liechtenstein - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
50, Target
Share of cooperating organisations that
is
apply the knowledge acquired from bilateral Percentage N/A - 4 4 100.00 % -
minimum
partnership
50 %
State type
Beneficiary State - - - 2 2 100.00 % - -
Donor State - - - 2 2 100.00 % - -
Not specified - - - 0 0 - - -
Bilateral Output 1: Bilateral partnerships supported
Achievements Achievements until end of December
until end of 2020
Unit of
Indicator Baseline previous Target Comment
measurement
reporting Numerator Denominator Value
period
17
Number of projects involving cooperation
Number 0.00 1 (IFR 2020) - - 16 45.00 -
with a donor project partner
Donor State
Norway - - - - - 16 - -
Iceland - - - - - 0 - -
Liechtenstein - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Number of staff from donor states in
Number 0 0 (IFR 2020) - - 0 5 -
exchanges
Donor State
Norway - - - - - 0 - -
Iceland - - - - - 0 - -
Liechtenstein - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Gender
Female - - - - - 0 - -
Male - - - - - 0 - -
Not specified - - - - - 0 - -
Type of exchange
Online - - - - - 0 - -
Physical - - - - - 0 - -
18
Annex 2: Communication summary
a. Visibility of the Grants and the donors
Communication plan 2017-2024 describes the Green ICT Programme communication goals,
target groups and main messages. Focus of the communication is on promoting Green ICT
programme: the focus, content and business opportunities for companies via bilateral
cooperation. The main channel for the programme specific information is
www.eas.ee/norwaygrants, which contains updated information about the calls, application
documents, seminars etc.
Website of PO https://www.mkm.ee/et/tegevused-eesmargid/valisvahendid/norra-ja-
euroopa-majanduspiirkonna-finantsmehhanismid provides the main information on Norway
Grants and programme “Green ICT”. It refers to the NFP website https://eeagrants.fin.ee and
IA Programme website www.eas.ee/norwaygrants, which includes more specific information
on programme, such as scope, calls, events, application information and relevant deadlines.
IA social media channels https://www.facebook.com/EnterpriseEstonia/ and LinkedIn profile
https://www.linkedin.com/company/enterprise-estonia are used to promote programme
events and activities (articles, good examples, events). IA Youtube channel
https://www.youtube.com/user/EnterpriseEstonia is used to present video material and best
practices (i.e. project examples).
NFP website http://eeagrants.fin.ee/en/ reflects a short description of the Green ICT
programme with links to the IA website for more detailed information.
b. Communication with the National Focal Point
Communication and cooperation with NFP has been effective and smooth. All programme
implementation related questions have been answered quickly, the exchange of information
is considered sufficient.
c. Website and social media
The main channel for media communication is IA website. All press releases are shared in IA
social media channels (Facebook, LinkedIN). Programme-specific information is published in
programme website www.eas.ee/norratoetus (in Estonian) and www.eas.ee/norwaygrants (in
English), including application information and documents, seminar ppt-s, videos etc.
Press releases were issued both before the opening of the calls and after the closing of the call
to introduce the results. As a good practice, joint communication of PO, IA and Royal
Norwegian Embassy in Tallinn has been used to reach the target groups and achieve the
maximum media coverage. IA, NFP and Embassy are active on sharing the news on their
websites http://eeagrants.fin.ee/en/ and social media channels in Facebook.
In addition to the programme level communication, projects have become active in sharing
their project achievements in their social media channels. Roofit Solar Energy OÜ
(https://www.facebook.com/Roofit.solar) and Eziil Production Intelligence OÜ
(https://www.facebook.com/EziilProductionIntelligence/) are the companies who especially
stand out in social media.
19
All supported projects from the first main call have started or already established their project
websites as set in the Regulation on the implementation of the Norway Grants 2014-2021 -
Annex 3: Information and communication requirements.
d. Best practice examples
A seminar was organised by IA to project promoters on July 14th, 2020. Seminar was targeted
to project promoters that had been awarded to grant from the first call. The organization of
such seminars is a standard IA practice for the smooth implementation of projects and to
ensure the understanding of project reporting specifics. IA introduced the general rules on
implementation, reporting and cost eligibility, procurement, payments, communication
requirements etc. Altogether 50 participants from all 26 projects attended the seminar.
Another seminar was held on November 16th prior second main call opening in order to
introduce the conditions and requirements for submission of applications. This event was held
electronically as a preventive measure of the coronavirus.
e. Multimedia
In the reporting period, “Green ICT” programme received 38 total references in the national
and local newspapers and online media. Press releases issued by PO, IA and Norwegian
Embassy were widely reflected in Estonian national newspapers (Äripäev, Postimees, Eesti
Päevaleht) and online media: Delfi (www.arileht.delfi.ee), Postimees (www.
majandus24.postimees.ee). Opening of the main calls were under special attention in ICT and
industry publications, e.g. IT News (www.ituudised.ee), Industry News
(www.toostusuudised.ee), Rohegeenius (www.rohe.geenius.ee). In addition, several articles
were initiated on the topics covered by the programme.
Media covered the opening of the calls as well as the results of the first call (most of them
listed below in English, Russian and Estonian):
Enterprise Estonia launches €19 million Estonia-Norway cooperation program
https://news.err.ee/1030648/enterprise-estonia-launches-19-million-estonia-norway-
cooperation-program (Estonian Public Broadcasting, 01.02.2020)
Enterprise Estonia opens €7.2 million round Estonian-Norwegian program
https://news.err.ee/1159598/enterprise-estonia-opens-7-2-million-round-estonian-
norwegian-program (Estonian Public Broadcasting, 16.11.2020)
Эстонско-норвежская программа поддержит развитие устойчивого
предпринимательства в Эстонии (Estonian-Norwegian program supports the
development of sustainable entrepreneurship in Estonia)
https://rus.err.ee/1030299/jestonsko-norvezhskaja-programma-podderzhit-razvitie-
ustojchivogo-predprinimatelstva-v-jestonii (rus.err.ee)
Seitse miljonit eurot Norra raha ootab Eestist IT-projekte (Seven million euros is waiting for IT
projects from Estonia) https://www.ituudised.ee/uudised/2020/11/16/seitse-miljonit-eurot-
norra-raha-ootab-eestist-it-projekte (ituudised.ee)
EAS kutsub ettevõtteid osalema Eesti – Norra koostööprogrammi lisavoorus (Enterprise
Estonia invites companies to participate in the additional call of the Estonian-Norwegian
20
cooperation program) https://majandus.goodnews.ee/eas-kutsub-ettevotteid-osalema-eesti-
norra-koostooprogrammi-lisavoorus/? (goodnews.ee)
12 miljonit eurot Norra riigi raha jõudis Eesti IKT-firmadeni, lisavoor tuleb sügisel (12 million
euros of Norwegian grants reached Estonian ICT companies, an additional call opened in
autumn) https://www.ituudised.ee/uudised/2020/07/20/12-miljonit-eurot-norra-riigi-raha-
joudis-eesti-ikt-firmadeni-lisavoor-tuleb-sugisel (ituudised.ee)
Rohe- ja tervisetehnoloogiate arendajad saavad rahasüsti (Developers of green and health
technologies will receive a cash injection)
https://www.foundme.io/uudised/2020/07/20/rohe-ja-tervisetehnoloogiate-arendajad-
saavad-rahasusti (foundme.io)
EAS toetab 12 miljoni euroga Eesti-Norra koostööprojekte (Enterprise Estonia supports
Estonian-Norwegian cooperation projects with 12 million
euros) https://arileht.delfi.ee/news/uudised/eas-toetab-12-miljoni-euroga-eesti-norra-
koostooprojekte?id=90498449 (arileht.delfi.ee)
EAS andis Eesti-Norra koostööprojektidele 12 miljonit (Enterprise Estonia provided 12 million
for Estonian – Norwegian cooperation projects)
https://majandus24.postimees.ee/7021358/eas-andis-eesti-norra-koostooprojektidele-12-
miljonit (majandus24.postimees.ee)
EAS toetab 12 miljoni euroga Eesti – Norra koostööprojekte (Enterprise Estonia supports
Estonian-Norwegian cooperation projects with 12 million euros)
http://majandus.goodnews.ee/toetus-i-eas-toetab-12-miljoni-euroga-eesti-norra-
koostooprojekte/? (goodnews.ee)
Kolm suunda. Milliseid teenuseid EAS tööstustele pakub? (Three directions. What services does
Enterprise Estonia offer to industries?) (Eesti Tööstus)
Ülevaade EASi tootearenduse ja digitaliseerimise toetustest tööstusettevõtetele (Overview of
Enterprise Estonia's product development and digitization grants for industrial enterprises)
https://www.toostusuudised.ee/sisuturundus/2020/02/27/ulevaade-easi-tootearenduse-ja-
digitaliseerimise-toetustest-toostusettevotetele (toostusuudised.ee)
EAS avas tööstuse ja rohetehnoloogiate taotlusvooru (Enterprise Estonia opened an
application round for industry and green technologies)
https://rohe.geenius.ee/rubriik/uudis/eas-avas-toostuse-ja-rohetehnoloogiate-taotlusvooru/
(geenius.ee)
Kuidas digitaliseerimine aitab meie tööstustel maailma tippu jõuda? (How will digitalization
help our industries reach the top of the world?)
https://majandus24.postimees.ee/6884770/kuidas-digitaliseerimine-aitab-meie-toostustel-
maailma-tippu-jouda (majandus24.postimees.ee)
Taotle toetust! Norra eraldas Eesti firmade IKT-projektidele 19 mln eurot (Apply for a grant!
Norway allocated 19 million euros to ICT projects of Estonian
companies) https://www.ituudised.ee/uudised/2020/01/31/taotle-toetust-norra-
eraldas-eesti-firmade-ikt-projektidele-19-mln-eurot (ituudised.ee)
21
Eesti-Norra koostööprogramm toetab tööstuse digitaliseerimist (The Estonian-Norwegian
cooperation program supports the digitalization of Industry)
https://www.toostusuudised.ee/uudised/2020/01/31/eesti-norra-koostooprogramm-toetab-
toostuse-digitaliseerimist (toostusuudised.ee)
Kuidas digitaliseerimine aitab meie tööstustel maailma tippu jõuda? (How will digitalization
help our industries reach the top of the world?) Postimees
Some of the supported projects were also active in media communication, receiving
considerable coverage in online media and newspapers:
Eziil Production Intelligence OÜ (project EE-INNOVATION-0053 “Development of Eziil
production software for product-based production companies”, partners Nordic Shelter AS,
Thorgate Digital OÜ, Energex Energy Experts OÜ, Nordic Shelter Production OÜ, Aktsiaselts
VMT Tehased, Mobi Lab OÜ):
o Viljandi idufirma lahendab Eesti tööstuste suurt probleemi (Start-up company from
Viljandi solves a big problem of Estonian industries) – Eesti Päevaleht
o Eesti tööstuste suurt probleemi lahendav Viljandi idufirma sai 1,2-miljonilise rahasüsti
(Start-up from Viljandi solves a big problem of Estonian industries and received a 1.2
million investment) https://arileht.delfi.ee/news/uudised/eesti-toostuste-suurt-
probleemi-lahendav-viljandi-idufirma-sai-1-2-miljonilise-rahasusti?id=91260213
(Delfi)
o Eesti tööstuste suurt probleemi lahendav Viljandi idufirma sai 1,2-miljonilise rahasüsti
(Start-up from Viljandi solves a big problem of Estonian industries and received a 1.2
million investment) https://sakala.postimees.ee/7078498/viljandi-
tarkvaraarendajad-said-1-2-miljoni-euro-suuruse-rahasusti (Postimees)
o Viljandist sirgunud tootmisidu Eziil korjas tuntud investoritelt 1,2 miljonit eurot ja
suundub Ühendkuningriiki vallutama (Eziil received 1.2 million euros from well-known
investors and goes to conquer the United Kingdom)
https://digipro.geenius.ee/rubriik/uudis/viljandist-sirgunud-tootmisidu-eziil-korjas-
tuntud-investoritelt-12-miljonit-eurot/ (Geenius)
o Tootmisi digitaliseeriv idufirma Eziil sai 1,2 miljoni eurose rahasüsti (Digitalization of
production start-up Eziil received 1.2 million euro cash injection)
https://www.foundmio/uudised/2020/10/05/tootmisi-digitaliseeriv-idufirma-eziil-
sai-12-miljoni-eurose-rahasusti (www.foundmio)
Roofit Solar Energy OÜ (projects EE-INNOVATION-0059 and EE-INNOVATION-0062
"Roofit.solar process innovation for developing software and automated production line”,
implemented with Søran AS and "Roofit.solar product development"):
o Eesti päikesekatuste tootja Roofit.solar siseneb tarkvaraärisse (Estonian solar roof
manufacturer Roofit.solar enters the software business) - Article in electricity and
energy magazine Elektriala
22
o Kiirelt arenev Eesti päikesekatuse tootja Roofit.solar arendab uusi tooteid
(Roofit.solar, a rapidly developing Estonian solar roof manufacturer, is developing new
products) – article in home and construction magazine TM Energia
o Eesti päikesekatuste tootja Roofit.solar siseneb tarkvaraärisse (Estonian solar roof
manufacturer Roofit.solar enters the software business)
https://majandus.goodnews.ee/eesti-paikesekatuste-tootja-roofit-solar-siseneb-
tarkvaraarisse/? (GoodNews)
o Päikesekatuste tootja Roofit.solar laiendab tootmist (Roofit.solar, a manufacturer of
solar roofs, is expanding production)
https://www.foundme.io/uudised/2020/08/31/paikesekatuste-tootja-roofitsolar-
laiendab-tootmist (www.foundme.io)
o Eesti päikesekatuste tootja Roofit.solar sai hoogu juurde (Estonian solar roof
manufacturer Roofit.solar received a large investment)
http://majandus.goodnews.ee/eesti-paikesekatuste-tootja-roofit-solar-sai-hoogu-
juurde/? (GoodNews)
o Eesti päikesekatuste tootja Roofit.solar paneb peagi üles 100 korda rohkem katuseid
(Estonian solar roof manufacturer Roofit.solar will soon install 100 times more
solar roofs) https://digipro.geenius.ee/rubriik/uudis/eesti-paikesekatuste-tootja-
roofit-solar-sai-miljoneid-tuge/ (digipro.geenius.ee)
UpSteam Eesti OÜ (project EE-INNOVATION-0061 “Developing UpSteam P2P business model
for car washing” implemented in cooperation with CityQ AS):
Mobiilset autopesuteenust pakkuv UpSteam lõi käed Norra ejalgratta tootjaga (UpSteam, a
mobile car wash service, has joined hands with a Norwegian ebike
manufacturer) https://keskkonnatehnika.ee/mobiilsetautopesuteenust-pakkuv-
upsteam-loi-kaed-norra-e-jalgratta-tootjaga/ (keskkonnatehnika.ee)
Roofit.Solar and Upsteam OÜ also participated in radio broadcast, where they introduced their
projects and their experiences about participating in the Green ICT programme:
https://www.aripaev.ee/raadio/episood/kogemus-koostoost-ehk-kuidas-saada-kasvul-
pidurid-maha?fbclid=IwAR2tsGN7nsrMG72KxkVCHuozavY1bq-nKlttjuYn9w6f2qomlHcWw-
zSmY8
(in Estonian).
AS Chemi-Pharm (project EE-INNOVATION-0063 “Improving the production of disinfectants by
full automating”):
Ruth Oltjer: tegime kevadel tootmise maailmarekordi (Ruth Oltjer: we set a world production
record in spring) Eesti Päevaleht
Chemi-Pharmi tehnikadirektor kriisiajast: tehas taheti ära osta (Chemi-Farm's technical
director from the Covid-19 crisis: the production had interested buyers)
https://www.aripaev.ee/lisa/2020/10/22/toostusuudised-22102020 (Äripäev),
23
https://www.toostusuudised.ee/uudised/2020/10/20/chemi-pharmi-tehnikadirektor-
kriisiajast-tehas-taheti-ara-osta (toostusuudised.ee)
24
Annex 3: Overview of contracted projects
# of % of
donor Amount outcome
Outcome Projects #
project contracted budget
partners contracted
Outcome 1: Pre-defined 0 0 €0 0.00 %
Increased Contracted through
26 15 € 12,162,902 48.59 %
competitiveness of open calls
Estonian companies Contracted through
within focus areas 45 1 € 828,451 3.31 %
small grants scheme
Green Industry
Innovation, ICT and Total Outcome 1 71 16 € 12,991,352 51.90 %
Welfare Technology
Programme Total 71 16 € 12,991,352 51.90 %
25
Annex 4: Risk management
Programmatic risks
Risk Risk
Risk description Risk related to Likelihood Consequence Response type
score N/A?
Reducing social
and economic 2 3 2.45 No
disparities
Description of
Risk did not occur in the small grant scheme, but is carefully
planned
Programme is vaguely targeted and assessment criteria does not observed in the preparations of opening the main call.
response
support the outcomes.
Description of
Carefully set application criteria resulted in project proposals
actual
supporting the outcomes of programme.
response
Planned future
Observation of projects continues.
response
Strengthening
Both objectives 2 3 2.45 bilateral No
relations
Description of Preparation of the second open call targeted to be opened in the
Programme implementation is obstructed due to many players planned autumn of 2020 was largely based on the experience gained in
and mixed interest. Risk could result in unachieved programme response the first open call.
(outcome) targets. Description of Programme outcomes have been well targeted, project
actual promoters are chosen according to programme specific criteria
response and therefore all the outcomes are reachable.
Planned future
PO and IA keep track on reaching the targets.
response
26
Strengthening
bilateral 2 3 2.45 No
relations
Description of
SGS projects were targeted to finding partners, result will be
Insufficient bilateral interest to implement joint cooperation planned
observed in the main call participations.
projects. Could result in low level of project cooperation and response
failure in achieving the bilateral outcome. Description of
Partner search database has been introduced and matchmaking
actual
events for entrepreneurs have been organised.
response
Planned future Organising additional partner search activities for contracted
response projects could be considered.
Strengthening
Both objectives 2 3 2.45 bilateral No
relations
Description of We have planned to announce another open call already in
Opening of calls delayed. planned autumn 2020, which should leave sufficient time buffer for
Because of the long description please consult original document response implementation of projects.
as uploaded. Description of
actual Additional call for proposals has been launched as planned.
response
Planned future Necessity of additional targeted call will be discussed in mid 2021
response to have sufficient time for implementation of projects.
Operational risks
Risk Risk
Risk description Risk related to Likelihood Consequence Response type
score N/A?
Public procurement conditions not clear for Project promoters. Both objectives 2 2 2.00 No
27
Ref. Regulation Art 8.15. State aid restrictions in main call apply to projects, which
Description of
mitigates procurement risks in projects. Risk is scored to "3"
planned
Because of the long description please consult original document instead of "4" and will remain under monitoring in projects in
response
as uploaded. main call.
Description of All the rules concerning public procurement have been
actual introduced and project promoters are welcome to ask guidance
response whenever it is necessary.
Planned future
Rules of procurement are being introduced on regular basis.
response
Reducing social
and economic 3 3 3.00 No
disparities
Description of
All the planned mitigation measures will be addressed in
State aid rules not clear for project promoters. Risk could result in planned
councelling of applicants during the application process.
project irregularities (i.e. miscalculated eligible activites, costs and response
aid intensity). Description of
Different state aid categories have been described in detail in
actual
conditions of call for proposal.
response
Planned future
Councelling of applicants continues in implementation phase.
response
Reducing social
Transfer of application and monitoring process into centralised and economic 3 3 3.00 No
information system administered by National Focal Point may disparities
cause need for additional manual data insertion by Implementing Description of
Implementing Agency seeks for automated solution in
Agency, which may cause errors in data. planned
cooperation with National Focal Point.
response
Overall risk of the programme
28
Risk
Likelihood Consequence
score
OVERALL RISK OF THE PROGRAMME 2 3 2.45
29
Annex 5: Monitoring plan
Please note this Annex is uploaded separately and is not visible in this document. Please
download and print separately if needed.
Annex 6: Evaluation report
Not Available
30
Laura Pikkoja
Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus
[email protected] Meie 15.03.2021 nr 24.4-7/17-0504/1631-1
Programmi "Green ICT" 2020. aasta aruande
edastamine
Austatud Laura Pikkoja
Edastame Eesti-Norra koostööprogrammi „Green ICT“ 2020. aasta aruande.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Keit Kaadu
juhataja
Lisa: APR EE-INNOVATION 2020.pdf
Lisaadressaat: Ettevõtluse Arendamise Sihtasutus
Katrin Tael
7153405
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158