Rotterdam Convention
Operation of the prior informed consent procedure
for banned or severely restricted chemicals
Decision Guidance Document
Hexabromocyclododecane
Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention
on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure
for Certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides
in International Trade
280619
Introduction
The objective of the Rotterdam Convention is to promote shared responsibility and cooperative efforts among
Parties in the international trade of certain hazardous chemicals in order to protect human health and the
environment from potential harm and to contribute to their environmentally sound use, by facilitating information
exchange about their characteristics, by providing for a national decision-making process on their import and export
and by disseminating these decisions to Parties. The Secretariat of the Convention is provided jointly by the United
Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
(FAO).
Candidate chemicals1 for inclusion in the prior informed consent (PIC) procedure under the Rotterdam Convention
include those that have been banned or severely restricted by national regulatory actions in two or more Parties 2 in
two different regions. Inclusion of a chemical in the PIC procedure is based on regulatory actions taken by Parties
that have addressed the risks associated with the chemical by banning or severely restricting it. Other ways might
be available to control or reduce such risks. Inclusion does not, however, imply that all Parties to the Convention
have banned or severely restricted the chemical. For each chemical included in Annex III of the Rotterdam
Convention and subject to the PIC procedure, Parties are requested to make an informed decision whether they
consent or not to the future import of the chemical.
At its ninth meeting, held in Geneva from 29 April to 10 May 2019, the Conference of the Parties agreed to list
hexabromocyclododecane in Annex III of the Convention and adopted the decision-guidance document with the
effect that this chemical became subject to the PIC procedure.
The present decision-guidance document was communicated to designated national authorities on 16 September
2019, in accordance with Articles 7 and 10 of the Rotterdam Convention.
Purpose of the decision guidance document
For each chemical included in Annex III of the Rotterdam Convention, a decision-guidance document has been
approved by the Conference of the Parties. Decision-guidance documents are sent to all Parties with a request that
they make a decision regarding future import of the chemical.
Decision-guidance documents are prepared by the Chemical Review Committee. The Committee is a group of
government-designated experts established in line with Article 18 of the Convention, which evaluates candidate
chemicals for possible inclusion in Annex III of the Convention. Decision-guidance documents reflect the
information provided by two or more Parties in support of their national regulatory actions to ban or severely
restrict the chemical. They are not intended as the only source of information on a chemical nor are they updated or
revised following their adoption by the Conference of the Parties.
There may be additional Parties that have taken regulatory actions to ban or severely restrict the chemical and
others that have not banned or severely restricted it. Risk evaluations or information on alternative risk mitigation
measures submitted by such Parties may be found on the Rotterdam Convention website (www.pic.int).
Under Article 14 of the Convention, Parties can exchange scientific, technical, economic and legal information
concerning the chemicals under the scope of the Convention including toxicological, ecotoxicological and safety
information. This information may be provided directly to other Parties or through the Secretariat. Information
provided to the Secretariat will be posted on the Rotterdam Convention website.
Information on the chemical may also be available from other sources.
Disclaimer
The use of trade names in the present document is primarily intended to facilitate the correct identification of the
chemical. It is not intended to imply any approval or disapproval of any particular company. As it is not possible to
include all trade names presently in use, only a number of commonly used and published trade names have been
included in the document.
While the information provided is believed to be accurate according to data available at the time of preparation of
the present decision-guidance document, FAO and UNEP disclaim any responsibility for omissions or any
1 According to the Convention, the term “chemical” means a substance, whether by itself or in a mixture or
preparation and whether manufactured or obtained from nature, but does not include any living organism. It
consists of the following categories: pesticide (including severely hazardous pesticide formulations) and
industrial.
2 According to the Convention, the term “Party” means a State or regional economic integration organization
that has consented to be bound by the Convention and for which the Convention is in force.
2
consequences that may arise there from. Neither FAO nor UNEP shall be liable for any injury, loss, damage or
prejudice of any kind that may be suffered as a result of importing or prohibiting the import of this chemical.
The designations employed and the presentation of material in this publication do not imply the expression of any
opinion whatsoever on the part of FAO or UNEP concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area
or of its authorities or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
3
Standard core set of abbreviations3
STANDARD CORE SET OF ABBREVIATIONS
< less than
< less than or equal to
> greater than
> greater than or equal to
µg Microgram
m micrometre
BAF Bioaccumulation factor
BCF Bioconcentration factor
bw body weight
BMDL Benchmark Dose lower confidence bound
BMR Benchmark Response
o
C degree Celsius (centigrade)
CAS Chemical Abstracts Service
cm centimetre
DNA deoxyribose nucleic acid
DT50 dissipation time 50%
DfE Design for the Environment (US EPA program)
dw dry weight
EC European Community
EC50 median effective concentration
ECHA European Chemicals Agency
EEC European Economic Community
EPS Expanded polystyrene
EU European Union
FAO Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
g gram
h hour
IARC International Agency for Research on Cancer
3 This core list should serve as the basis for DGDs for industrial chemicals, pesticides and severely hazardous
pesticide formulations. It should be augmented by abbreviations used in the individual DGDs relevant to the
chemical(s) in question.
Definitions and spelling should, as far as practicable, follow the IUPAC glossary of terms in toxicology and
the IUPAC glossary of terms relating to pesticides in their current editions.
As a general rule, it is preferable that acronyms used only once in the text be spelled out rather than included
in the list of abbreviations.
4
STANDARD CORE SET OF ABBREVIATIONS
IPCS International Programme on Chemical Safety
IUPAC International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry
k kilo- (x 1000)
kg kilogram
L litre
LC50 median lethal concentration
LD50 median lethal dose
LOAEL lowest-observed-adverse-effect level
lw liquid weight
m metre
mg milligram
ml millilitre
MW Molecular Weight
NES no effects at saturation
ng nanogram
NOAEL no-observed-adverse-effect level
NOEC no-observed-effect concentration
NOHSC National Occupational Health and Safety Commission
OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
POPRC Persistent Organic Pollutants Review Committee of the Stockholm Convention
PPE personal protective equipment
ppm parts per million (used only with reference to the concentration of a pesticide in an experimental
diet. In all other contexts, the terms mg/kg or mg/L are used).
TH Thyroid hormone
TSH Thyroid-stimulating hormone
UNEP United Nations Environment Programme
US EPA United States Environmental Protection Agency
w/w weight for weight
WHO World Health Organization
wt weight
wwt Wet weight
XPS Extruded polystyrene
5
Decision guidance document for a banned or severely restricted chemical
HEXABROMOCYCLODODECANE Published: September 2019
1. Identification and uses (see Annex 1 for further details)
Common name Hexabromocyclododecane
Chemical name and Hexabromocyclododecane
other names or 1,2,5,6,9,10-hexabromocyclododecane
synonyms
Molecular formula C12H18Br6
Chemical structure
CAS-No.(s) 25637-99-4: Hexabromocyclododecane Commercial substance (does not specify the
bromine positions)
3194-55-6: 1,2,5,6,9,10- Hexabromocyclododecane
134237-50-6: α- Hexabromocyclododecane stereoisomer
134237-51-7: - Hexabromocyclododecane stereoisomer
134237-52-8: γ- Hexabromocyclododecane stereoisomer
Harmonized System 2903.89
Customs Code
Other numbers EC Number 247-148-4, EC Number 221-695-9
Category Industrial
Regulated category Industrial chemical
Use(s) in regulated Japan:
category Flame retardant
Norway:
Hexabromocyclododecane has been used to produce flame retarded expanded
polystyrene (EPS) and extruded polystyrene (XPS) for onward use in building
applications abroad.
Trade names Cyclododecane, hexabromo; HBCD; Bromkal 73-6CD; Nikkafainon CG 1; Pyroguard F
800; Pyroguard SR 103; Pyroguard SR 103A; Pyrovatex 3887; Great Lakes CD-75P™;
Great Lakes CD-75; Great Lakes CD75XF; Great Lakes CD75PC (compacted); Dead
Sea Bromine Group Ground FR 1206 I-LM; Dead Sea Bromine Group Standard FR
1206 I-LM; Dead Sea Bromine Group Compacted FR 1206 I-CM.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 1.3 of the Norwegian notification – also POPRC
Risk Profile section 1.1)
This is an indicative list. It is not intended to be exhaustive.
Formulation types Not relevant.
6
Uses in other Japan and Norway:
categories No reported use as a pesticide.
Basic manufacturers BASF Corp.
Albemarle Corp.
Dow Chemical Co.
Source: TOXNET (https://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/sis/search2/f?./temp/~jrwyMs:1)
This is an indicative list of current and former manufacturers. It is not intended to be
exhaustive.
2. Reasons for inclusion in the PIC procedure
Hexabromocyclododecane is included in the PIC procedure as an industrial chemical. It is listed on the basis of
final regulatory actions notified by Japan and Norway that ban and severely restrict, respectively, its use as an
industrial chemical.
No final regulatory actions relating to pesticidal uses of hexabromocyclododecane have been notified.
2.1 Final regulatory action (see Annex 2 for further details)
Japan:
This chemical is designated as Class I Specified Chemical Substances. It is prohibited to manufacture, import or
use this chemical substance. (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 Sections 2 and 2.2.1 of the Japanese notification).
Reason: Human health
Norway:
Regulations to restrict production, import, export and sale of consumer products that contain
hexabromocyclododecane exceeding certain limit values.
Hexabromocyclododecane is regulated by Chapter 4 of the Regulation related to restrictions on the manufacture,
import and placing on the market of chemicals and other products hazardous to human health and the environment
(Product Regulation) act no. 922 of June 2004. This is the Norwegian implementation of Regulation (EC) No
850/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council on persistent organic pollutants and the implementation
of the amendment to its Annex I, Commission Regulation (EU) 2016/293 of 1 March 2016.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 sections 2, 2.2.1 and 2.2.2 of the Norwegian notification).
Reason: Human health and the environment
2.2 Risk evaluation (see Annex 1 for further details)
Japan:
The notification from Japan indicates that the regulatory action was based on a risk or hazard evaluation, which is
provided with a focussed summary in English, and also includes the Risk Profile document for
hexabromocyclododecane as prepared by the Persistent Organic Pollutants Review Committee (POPRC) of the
Stockholm Convention.
When a substance is listed in the Stockholm Convention, and when it is on the market in Japan, the Japanese
Government conducts a risk evaluation on the substance and its potential risks to inform the regulatory measures.
This internal risk evaluation, in combination with the Risk Profile document for hexabromocyclododecane were
supplied as supporting information by Japan in document UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2. A brief English
summary of that risk evaluation was provided along with the table of contents of the risk evaluation.
The internal risk evaluation was based on the monitoring data from fiscal year 2009 to fiscal year 2012 and
revealed a number of sites with a high ecological risk, while there were no sites with any human health risk. The
risk evaluation included a hazard assessment, an exposure assessment and risk estimation based on monitoring data,
and an exposure assessment and risk estimation based on environmental releases estimated from manufacture data.
The POPRC Risk Profile document cites a Japanese study which found hexabromocyclododecane levels in human
milk appearing to mirror the market consumption of hexabromocyclododecane. In mothers’ milk from Japanese
women (age 25–29) hexabromocyclododecane levels were below the detection limit in all samples collected during
the 10-year period from 1973-1983, but then increased from 1988 onwards.
The POPRC Risk Profile document states the developmental and neurotoxic potential of hexabromocyclododecane
observed in animal studies give cause for concern when considering risks to human health, particularly for unborn
babies and young children. This concern, along with the human milk monitoring study and results of other studies
in the Risk Profile document on cord serum, suggests some risk to unborn babies and young children in Japan.
7
Despite the absence of a quantitative link between the risks and the exposure levels provided, the risk is relevant
given the observed bioaccumulation and biomagnification of hexabromocyclododecane.
Norway:
The notification from Norway indicates that the regulatory action was based on a risk or hazard evaluation and that
it was relevant to both human health and the environment. The notification specifically cites the European Union
risk assessment for hexabromocyclododecane. The notification from Norway provides a summary of evidence of
exposure to consumers in Norway, its detection in the environment (including remote areas of the arctic), biota,
fish, moss, yolk sac of newly hatched chicks. Some temporal trends are noted.
Hazard endpoints are provided in the supporting information from Norway, originating from the United States
Environmental Protection Agency 2014 report, Flame Retardant Alternatives for Hexabromocyclododecane
(HBCD). High or very high hazards are noted for developmental effects, acute aquatic toxicity, and chronic aquatic
toxicity. Hexabromocyclododecane is highly persistent and bioaccumulates.
3. Protective measures that have been applied concerning the chemical
3.1 Regulatory measures to reduce exposure
Japan: The regulatory action notified by Japan bans the manufacture, import and use of
hexabromocyclododecane. There are no uses exempted from the ban. The regulatory action entered
into force 1 May 2014. (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 sections 2.2 and 2.3 of the Japanese
notification)
Norway: The regulatory action notified by Norway severely restricts production, import, export and sale of
consumer products that contain hexabromocyclododecane exceeding certain limit values.
It is prohibited to manufacture, import, export, place on the market and use substances that contain
0.01 per cent by weight or more of hexabromocyclododecane (CAS number 25637-99-4,
3194-55-6, 134237-50-6, 134237-51-7, 134237-52-8).
It is prohibited to manufacture, import, export and make available on the market products or flame
retarded parts of products that contain 0.01 per cent by weight or more of hexabromocyclododecane
(CAS number 25637-99-4, 3194-55-6, 134237-50-6, 134237-51 -7, 134237-52-8).
The use of hexabromocyclododecane, whether on its own or in preparations, in the production of
expanded polystyrene articles, and the production and placing on the market of
hexabromocyclododecane for such use, shall be allowed provided that such use has been authorised
in accordance with Title VII of Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 of the European Parliament and of
the Council, or is the subject of an application for authorisation submitted by 21 February 2014
where a decision on that application has yet to be taken.
The placing on the market and use of hexabromocyclododecane, whether on its own or in
preparations, in accordance with this paragraph shall only be allowed until 26 November 2019 or, if
earlier, the date of expiry of the review period specified in an authorisation decision or the date of
withdrawal of that authorisation pursuant to Title VII of Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 sections 2.2 and 2.3 of the Norwegian notification)
3.2 Other measures to reduce exposure
OSPAR Convention
Hexabromocyclododecane is included as part of the brominated flame retardants group in the List of Substances for
Priority Action of The Convention for the Protection of the Marine Environment of the North-East Atlantic (the
OSPAR Convention). The OSPAR Convention is made up of representatives of the Governments of 15 Contracting
Parties and the European Union.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 1.4 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants
Hexabromocyclododecane is included in Annex A (elimination) of the Stockholm Convention on Persistent
Organic Pollutants (decision SC-6/13). Specific exemptions exist for production and use of
hexabromocyclododecane in expanded polystyrene and extruded polystyrene in buildings. Parties to the Stockholm
Convention who register for the production and/or use exemption also agree, pursuant to Article 4, to take
necessary measures to ensure that expanded polystyrene and extruded polystyrene containing
8
hexabromocyclododecane can be easily identified by labelling or other means throughout its life cycle when
allowing the production and use of hexabromocyclododecane for expanded polystyrene and extruded polystyrene in
buildings.
(Decision SC-6/13: Listing of hexabromocyclododecane. http://chm.pops.int/Portals/0/download.aspx?d=UNEP-
POPS-COP.6-SC-6-13.English.pdf)
3.3 Alternatives
It is essential that before a country considers substituting alternatives, it ensures that the use is relevant to its
national needs, and the anticipated local conditions of use. The hazards of the substitute materials and the controls
needed for safe use should also be evaluated.
Japan:
No information on alternatives to hexabromocyclododecane was provided by Japan (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8
section 2.5.3.2 of the Japanese notification).
Norway:
A reference was provided to the document by the US EPA: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane. Final report June 2014. (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 2.5.3.2 of the Norwegian
notification). The report provides information on hexabromocyclododecane used as a flame retardant in polystyrene
building insulation, possible substitutes, and alternative materials. The report was developed by the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency with input from a partnership of stakeholders from business, government,
academia, and environmental organizations. According to technical experts on the Partnership, between 2011 and
2014 there were only three viable flame retardant alternatives to HBCD for use in expanded and extruded
polystyrene foam (EPS and XPS) insulation under current manufacturing processes. Alternative materials are also
available as substitutes to HBCD-containing insulation. These alternatives may require additive flame retardants or
other treatment to meet fire safety requirements. The Results section of that supporting document is reproduced
below:
Results
Members of the Partnership identified many chemicals as potential alternatives; however, only three chemicals were
identified as viable alternatives to hexabromocyclododecane in EPS and XPS foam: a butadiene styrene brominated
copolymer (CASRN 1195978-93-8), a tetrabromobisphenol-A (TBBPA)-bis brominated ether derivative (CASRN
97416-84-7), and TBBPA-bis(2,3-dibromopropyl) ether (CASRN 21850-44-2). Only three alternatives were
identified for evaluation in this report because flame retardants for EPS and XPS foam must allow the material to
comply with fire safety codes while not compromising the performance of the foam. All three alternatives are
brominated. No non-brominated flame retardants are known to be compatible in polystyrene manufacturing and
associated flame tests. Figure ES-1 summarizes the hazard information for hexabromocyclododecane and the three
alternatives assessed. (Figure ES-1 indicates whether endpoints were assigned based on empirical data or using
values from predictive models and/or professional judgment. The caveats listed in Figure ES-1 must also be taken
into account when interpreting the information in the table.) Few measured experimental data were available for the
9
TBBPA-bis brominated ether derivative; therefore, estimated hazard designations were determined using TBBPA-
bis(2,3-dibromopropyl ether) (CASRN 21850-44-2) as an analog.
The human health endpoints evaluated in Design for Environment (DfE) alternatives assessments include acute
toxicity, carcinogenicity, genotoxicity, reproductive toxicity, developmental toxicity, neurotoxicity, repeated dose
toxicity, skin sensitization, respiratory sensitization, eye irritation, and dermal irritation. Hexabromocyclododecane
has been assigned a “High” hazard designation for developmental neurotoxicity, a “Moderate” hazard designation
for reproductive toxicity and repeated dose toxicity, and an estimated “Moderate” hazard designation for
carcinogenicity and neurotoxicity; other health endpoints have “Low” or “Very Low” hazard designations. The
butadiene styrene brominated copolymer has “Low” hazard designations (either measured or estimated) for most
human health endpoints due to its high MW and limited potential for absorption; there is one “Moderate” hazard
designation for the eye irritation endpoint based on experimental data. The TBBPA-bis brominated ether derivative
and TBBPA-bis(2,3-dibromopropyl) ether have a “Moderate” hazard designation for carcinogenicity, mutagenicity,
reproductive toxicity, developmental toxicity, and repeated dose toxicity based on potential alkylating properties.
“Low” hazard designations have been assigned to these similar substances for acute toxicity, neurotoxicity, skin
sensitization and irritation.
The ecotoxicity endpoints evaluated in DfE alternatives assessments include acute and chronic aquatic toxicities.
Hexabromocyclododecane is toxic for the aquatic environment and has “Very High” hazard designations for both
acute and chronic aquatic toxicity. Aquatic toxicity for the three alternatives is “Low”, driven by their lack of
appreciable water solubility leading to “no effects at saturation”. Ecotoxicity data for terrestrial species was limited,
and thus the potential for impacts on high trophic level and terrestrial wildlife from hexabromocyclododecane and its
alternatives or associated degradation products is unclear.
The environmental fate of hexabromocyclododecane and the three alternatives is described primarily in terms of
persistence and bioaccumulation potential. All three chemicals have “High” or “Very High” persistence
designations, a quality typical for the majority of flame retardants. Long-term fate of the three alternatives in the
environment is not well understood. The butadiene styrene brominated copolymer is estimated to have “Low”
bioaccumulation potential due to its size (average MW >1,000 daltons) and lack of low MW components, while
hexabromocyclododecane, the TBBPA-bis brominated derivative, and TBBPA-bis(2,3-dibromopropyl) ether have
“Very High”, “High”, and “High” potential for bioaccumulation.
Under conditions where fire or incineration occurs, a halogenated substance may contribute to halogenated
dibenzodioxin and dibenzofuran formation, increase the generation of polyaromatic hydrocarbons, and impact fire
parameters such as smoke and carbon monoxide (Sidhu, Morgan et al. 2013). However, combustion reactions are
complex and variable and make inclusion of combustion by-products in hazard assessment challenging. Both
10
halogenated and non-halogenated flame retardants may yield other toxic by-products that would need to be
compared, not only halogenated dioxins and furans. For these reasons, the pyrolysis transformation products are not
assessed in this report.
In addition to the chemical hazard assessment of hexabromocyclododecane and its alternatives, Chapter 5 of the
report includes general information about alternative insulation materials. These technologies include rigid board
alternatives (e.g., similar to EPS and XPS), alternatives for certain functional uses (e.g., blanket insulation,
foamed-in-place insulation), and specialty and emerging alternative materials (e.g., aerogel, carbon foam). The
report does not assess these materials, does not compare them to EPS or XPS, and does not assess flame retardancy
needs for each of these materials.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18)
General:
The POPs Review Committee of the Stockholm Convention has undertaken an evaluation of alternatives to
hexabromocyclododecane during the Annex F (Risk Management Evaluation) phase of its review of
hexabromocyclododecane as a candidate POP. The information can be found in the document titled "Additional
information on alternatives to hexabromocyclododecane and use in expanded polystyrene (EPS) and extruded
polystyrene (XPS)" (UNEP/POPS/POPRC.8/16/Add.3) available online at:
http://chm.pops.int/Portals/0/download.aspx?d=UNEP-POPS-POPRC.8-16-Add.3.English.pdf
3.4 Socio-economic effects
Japan:
No information on socio-economic effects of the regulatory action was provided by Japan
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 2.5.3.1 of the Japanese notification).
Norway:
Hexabromocyclododecane has traditionally not been used in expanded polystyrene or extruded polystyrene for
constructions/buildings in Norway. Since these are the main uses of hexabromocyclododecane, low socio-economic
effects are expected from of the final regulatory action.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 2.5.3.1 of the Norwegian notification)
4. Hazards and Risks to human health and the environment
4.1 Hazard Classification
WHO / IPCS Not available.
IARC Not available.
European EU classification pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1272/2008 on classification, labelling and
Union packaging of substances and mixtures:
Repr. 2, H361 (Suspected of damaging fertility or the unborn child)
Lact., H362 (May cause harm to breast-fed children)
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.1 of the Norwegian notification)
US EPA Not available.
4.2 Exposure limits
Studies establishing a tolerable daily intake for humans are not available.
There are several studies on reproductive effects of hexabromocyclododecane. Saegusa et al. (2009) performed a one-
generation developmental toxicity study in rats, with maternal dietary exposure to 0, 100, 1,000 or 10,000 ppm
hexabromocyclododecane from gestation day 10 until weaning of the offspring. The LOAEL of this study is 1,000
ppm (81-213 mg/kg/day), and the NOAEL 100 ppm (8-21 mg/kg/day). The long continuous exposure study of van der
Ven et al. (2009) suggest that male reproductive organs are particularly sensitive to hexabromocyclododecane
exposure, i.e. a decreased testicular weight was observed at a BMDL of 52 μg/g bw in F1 males. A weight reduction in
other male organs; prostate, the adrenals, heart and brain as well as in F1 males' total weight was also observed. The
observed body weight loss makes it impossible to say whether any of these effects on organs’ weights are specific or
secondary to the general body weight loss. In females the cytochrome P450 19 enzyme activity, based on group
11
averages, showed a correlation to the internal concentration of γ- hexabromocyclododecane (linear correlation
coefficient of 0.90). The cytochrome P450 19 enzyme converts androgens to estrogens (Norris 2006), and is essential
for differentiation and development of gonads and brains of higher vertebrates, maintenance of reproductive tissues,
and sexual behavior (Conley and Hinshelwood, 2001, Simpson et al. 2002). In females the time to vaginal opening was
also delayed, but only at the top dose (BMDL 82.2 μg/g bw at a benchmark response (BMR) of 10%).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.4 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
4.3 Packaging and labelling
The United Nations Committee of Experts on the Transportation of Dangerous Goods classifies the chemical in:
Hazard Class UN number: 3077
and Packing Proper shipping name and description: Hexabromocyclododecane, ENVIRONMENTALLY
Group: HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCE, SOLID, N.O.S.
Chemical name: Hexabromocyclododecane
Class: 9
Classification code: M7
Packaging group: III
Labels: 9
Remarks: Hazard identification No: 90
(ECHA Guidance on Safe Use – Hexabromocyclododecane)
International UN number: 3077
Maritime Proper shipping name and description: Hexabromocyclododecane, ENVIRONMENTALLY
Dangerous HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCE, SOLID, N.O.S.
Goods (IMDG) Chemical name: Hexabromocyclododecane
Code
Class: 9
Packaging group: III
EmS number 1: F-A
EmS number 2: S-F
Labels: 9
Marine pollutant: yes (PP)
(ECHA Guidance on Safe Use – Hexabromocyclododecane)
Transport Not available.
Emergency
Card
4.4 First aid
NOTE: The following advice is based on information available from the World Health Organisation and the
notifying countries and was correct at the time of publication. This advice is provided for information only and
is not intended to supersede any national first aid protocols.
General: If you feel unwell seek medical advice (show this information or the container label where possible). Do
not give anything by mouth to unconscious person.
Inhalation: Remove to fresh air, Seek medical attention immediately.
Skin: Remove any contaminated clothing, completely launder clothing to ensure that no contamination remains
before reusing clothing. Wash skin thoroughly with soap and water for at least 15 minutes. If skin irritation occurs
seek medical attention immediately.
Eye: Hold eyelids apart and flush eyes with plenty of water for at least 15 minutes. Seek medical attention.
Ingestion: If the subject is conscious rinse the mouth with water and make the subject drink 1 to 2 glasses of water,
seek medical attention immediately.
(ECHA Guidance on Safe Use – Hexabromocyclododecane)
12
Prevention First Aid
Inhalation Use ventilation. Use local exhaust. Fresh air, rest.
Skin Protective gloves. Protective Rinse skin with plenty of water or shower.
clothing.
Eyes Wear safety spectacles. First rinse with plenty of water for several minutes (remove
contact lenses if easily possible), then refer for medical
attention.
Ingestion Do not eat, drink, or smoke during Rinse mouth.
work. Wash hands before eating.
IPCS (2001): International Chemical Safety Card (ICSC) 1413
4.5 Waste management
Technical guidelines on the environmentally sound management of wastes consisting of, containing or
contaminated with hexabromocyclododecane:
• Best practice for the End-of-Life management of Polystyrene Foams in Building & Construction
(European Chemical Industry Council (CEFIC) and PlasticsEurope, 2014;
• End-of-life treatment of HBCD-containing polystyrene insulation foams: Large-scale demonstration of the
treatment of Expanded Polystyrene Foam (EPS) and Extruded Polystyrene Foam (XPS) containing
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) as a flame- retardant by co-incineration in the Würzburg Municipal
Solid Waste Incinerator. Technical Summary report (PlasticsEurope, 2015)
• HBCD Hexabromocyclododecane in Polystyrene Foams Product Safety Assessment - 2016 Edition
Source: Basel Convention POPs Waste, Additional Resources
DISPOSAL: Dispose of as hazardous waste in compliance with local, regional and national regulations. Dispose of
wastes in an approved waste disposal facility.
Source: Source: ECHA Guidance on Safe Use – Hexabromocyclododecane
Annexes
Annex 1 Further information on the substance
Annex 2 Details on final regulatory action reported
Annex 3 Address of designated national authorities
Annex 4 References
13
Annex 1 Further information on the substance
Introductory text to Annex I
The information presented in the present annex reflects the conclusions of the two notifying Parties, namely Japan
and Norway. Where possible, information provided by these two Parties on hazards has been presented together,
while the risk assessments, which are specific to the conditions prevailing in the Parties, are presented separately.
This information is taken from the documents referenced in the notifications in support of the final regulatory
actions relating to hexabromocyclododecane.
The notifications from Japan and Norway were first reported in PIC Circular XLIV of 12/12/2016.
14
Annex 1 – Further information on notified chemical
1. Identity and Physico-Chemical properties
1.1 Identity Hexabromocyclododecane and 1,2,5,6,9,10 –hexabromocyclododecane
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2, POPRC Risk Profile)
1.2 Formula C12H18Br6
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2, POPRC Risk Profile)
1.3 Colour and Texture White odourless solid
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2, POPRC Risk Profile)
1.4 Decomposition temperature Decomposes at >190 °C
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2, POPRC Risk Profile)
1.6 Density (g/cm3) 2.38 Albemarle Corporation (1994)
2.24 Great Lakes Chemical Corporation (1994)
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2, POPRC Risk Profile)
1.7 Resistance to acids Not available.
1.8 Resistance to alkalis Not available.
3 2
1.9 Tensile strength (10 kg/cm ) Not available.
2 Toxicological properties
2.1 General
2.1.1 Mode of Action Recent studies with fish models suggest that hexabromocyclododecane may induce
oxidative stress and apoptosis.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.1 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
2.1.2 Symptoms of Not available.
poisoning
2.1.3 Absorption, Absorption:
distribution, The extent of oral absorption of hexabromocyclododecane in humans is largely
excretion and unknown (ECHA 2008a). Estimations suggest that the uptake of
metabolism in hexabromocyclododecane via this exposure route ranges from 50-100% (ECHA
mammals 2008a, European Union 2008). According to calculations made in the EU risk
assessment (European Union 2008) intake of hexabromocyclododecane via breast
milk is 1.5 ng/kg bw/day for 0-3 month olds and 5.6 ng/kg bw/day in 3-12 month
old babies. However, with the levels found in mothers’ milk from some locations in
northern Spain (A Coruña), Eljarrat et al. 2008 calculated the intake to be 175 ng/kg
bw/day for 1 month olds. This is 12 times higher than the estimated daily intake
(EDI) for 0-3 month old infants as determined in the EU risk assessment (European
Union 2008) and 25-1,458 times higher than the EDI for adults in Sweden,
Netherlands, United Kingdom and Norway (KEMI, 2009; Eljarrat et al. 2009,
Roosens et al. 2010). A Flemish dietary study suggests that the age group between 3
and 6 years seems to be the highest exposed with an EDI for the sum of
hexabromocyclododecane isomers of 7 ng/kg bw/day. Newborns and adults are less
exposed with EDI’s of 3 and 1 ng/kg bw/day, respectively (Roosens et al. 2010). In
all instances, however, children appear to be more exposed than adults.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.3.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
Distribution:
Hexabromocyclododecane can be absorbed from the gastro-intestinal tract, and the
highest concentrations are subsequently reached in adipose tissue and muscles
followed by liver, and with much lower activities present in lung, kidney, blood,
brain, and gonads.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.2.2 of the Norwegian notification)
15
In rodents, hexabromocyclododecane is readily absorbed through the
gastrointestinal tract with highest concentrations in adipose tissue and muscle,
followed by the liver; it has been found in much lower concentrations in the lungs,
kidneys, blood and brain. (ECHA, 2008; reported in a secondary source with limited
study details.)
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18 US EPA: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD)).
Bioaccumulation and metabolism:
Several studies in laboratory, in local food webs and local ecosystems confirm the
potential for hexabromocyclododecane to bioaccumulate and biomagnify. The field
studies show a general increase of concentrations in biota with increasing trophic
level in aquatic and Arctic food webs. No field studies in the terrestrial environment
have been identified, but two laboratory studies show that hexabromocyclododecane
has a potential to bioaccumulate in terrestrial mammals.
Two studies in the laboratory have examined the bioaccumulation of
hexabromocyclododecane in mammals (WIL 2001; Velsicol Chemicals 1980). In a
90-day repeated dose (technical hexabromocyclododecane, 1,000 mg/kg bw/day)
toxicity study with rats, WIL (2001) found that concentrations of the α-isomer were
much greater than that of the β- and γ-isomers at all sampling time points. The
relative percentage of the isomers measured in the rats (α-: 65-70%; β-: 9-15% and
γ-: 14-20%) was markedly different to the proportions in the
hexabromocyclododecane formulation used (α-: 8.9%; β-: 6.6% and γ-: 84.5%).
Velsicol Chemicals (1980) studied the pharmacokinetics of radiolabelled
hexabromocyclododecane (14C-hexabromocyclododecane, purity > 98%)
administered to rats as a single oral dose. The authors found that the test substance
was distributed throughout the body with the greatest amounts measured in fat
tissue, followed by liver, kidney, lung and gonads. Rapid metabolism to polar
compounds occurred in the blood, muscle, liver and kidneys, but
hexabromocyclododecane remained mostly unchanged in the fatty tissue. The study
concluded that hexabromocyclododecane accumulated in fatty tissues following
repeated exposure.
Findings have been made in the Norwegian Arctic. Sørmo et al. (2006) analyzed
representative species from different trophic levels of the polar bear food chain,
using samples collected from 2002 to 2003 at Svalbard in the Norwegian Arctic.
hexabromocyclododecane was below detection limits (minimum 0.012 ng/g lw) in
the amphipod, Gammarus wilkitzkii. Hexabromocyclododecane biomagnified
strongly from polar cod (Boreogadus saida) to ringed seal (BMF of 36.4, based on
whole body wet weight concentrations), but did not biomagnify from ringed seal to
polar bear (BMF of 0.6). Lower levels in the polar bear samples were considered to
indicate possible enhanced metabolic capability in the bears. In East Greenland the
comparative bioaccumulation, biotransformation and/or biomagnification from East
Greenland ringed seal (Pusa hispida) blubber to polar bear (Ursus maritimus)
tissues (adipose, liver and brain) of hexabromocyclododecane and legacy POPs was
investigated by Letcher et al. (2009). α-hexabromocyclododecane was found to only
bioaccumulate in the polar bear adipose tissue. The ringed seal blubber to polar bear
adipose BMF for total-(α)- hexabromocyclododecane >1. The authors concluded
that even if the metabolism of hexabromocyclododecane in polar bears was
enhanced compared to other species, the high exposure of hexabromocyclododecane
ensures biomagnification.
Morris et al. (2004) reported on biomagnification of hexabromocyclododecane in
the North Sea food web. Although individual BMFs were not reported, the authors
suggested that because concentrations of hexabromocyclododecane were higher in
species in the top of the food chain it implied that hexabromocyclododecane was
biomagnifying. For example, hexabromocyclododecane concentrations in top
predators such as harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) and harbour porpoise (Phocoena
phocoena) were several orders of magnitude greater than those measured in the
16
aquatic macroinvertebrates such as sea-star and common whelk. Similarly,
hexabromocyclododecane concentrations were high in liver samples from
cormorant, a predator bird-species and in eggs of the common tern, while lower
levels of hexabromocyclododecane were detected in their prey, cod and yellow eel
(Anguilla Anguilla).
Tomy et al. (2008) investigated isomer-specific accumulation of
hexabromocyclododecane at several trophic levels of an eastern Canadian Arctic
marine food web. There was a significant positive relationship of α-
hexabromocyclododecane with trophic level, with a TMF of 7.4 (p<0.01), indicative
of biomagnification throughout the food web, while a significant negative
relationship was observed between concentrations of γ-hexabromocyclododecane
and trophic level (i.e. trophic dilution). α-hexabromocyclododecane contributed
greater than 70% of the total hexabromocyclododecane burden in shrimp (Pandalus
borealis, Hymenodora glacialis), redfish (Sebastes mentella), arctic cod
(Boreogadus saida), narwhal (Monodon monoceros) and beluga (Delphinapterus
leucas), while γ-hexabromocyclododecane was greater than 60% of total
hexabromocyclododecane in zooplankton (mix), clams (Mya truncata, Serripes
groenlandica), and walrus (Odobenus rosmarus). The observed differences in
diastereoisomer predominance were attributed in part to differing environmental
fate and behaviour of the isomers, with the least water soluble γ-isomer more likely
to diffuse passively from the water column into zooplankton, which have
proportionately high lipid content. Similarly, as benthic filter feeders, clams may be
more likely to absorb a higher proportion of the γ-isomer from sediment. The
presence of higher proportions of α-hexabromocyclododecane, such as with the
beluga and narwhal, may indicate enhanced metabolic capability based on evidence
of stereoisomer-specific biotransformation of the γ-isomer to the α-form (Zegers et
al. 2005, Law et al. 2006d). This also corresponds with the findings of Tomy et al.
(2009) where the α-isomer accounted for >95% of the overall burden of
hexabromocyclododecanes in the beluga, while the Arctic cod, the primary prey
species of beluga in the western Canadian arctic marine food web, had a
hexabromocyclododecane-profile dominated by the γ-isomer (>77%). The authors
concluded that this was further evidence that beluga can bioprocess the γ- to the α-
isomer.
In vivo studies with rats suggest that hexabromocyclododecane is also debrominated
to PBCDe and TBCDe. In total, five different species of hydroxylated
hexabromocyclododecane metabolites have been found by LCQ and GC-MS;
monohydroxy- and dihydroxy-hexabromocyclododecane, monohydroxy- and
dihydroxy-PBCDe and monohydroxy-TBCDe (Brandsma et al. 2009).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.2.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
Excretion:
Hexabromocyclododecane is excreted mainly through faeces with minor elimination
in urine, and three polar metabolites as well as unextractable radioactivity have been
detected. Elimination from body fat appears to be markedly slower than from other
tissues, with an elimination half-life of the three diastereomers possibly being in the
order of weeks to months.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.2.2 of the Norwegian notification)
Rats (2 males, 8 females) administered a single oral dose of 1.93 mg radiolabeled
hexabromocyclododecane eliminated 86% of the dose within 72 hours (70% in
feces and 16% in urine). (EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; reported in a secondary
source. Authors state that caution is urged in interpreting the data due to the small
sample size and the brief nature of the final report.)
Four male Wistar rats orally administered 500 mg/kg-day hexabromocyclododecane
in olive oil for 5 days Average daily rate of excretion in the feces was 29-37% of
the dose; the cumulative excretion was constant at 32-35%; urinary excretion was
17
not observed; metabolites were not detected in the urine or feces;
hexabromocyclododecane was detected only in adipose tissue (0.3-0.7 mg/g fat).
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012, reported in a secondary source.)
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18 US EPA: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD)).
2.2 Toxicology
studies
2.2.1 Acute toxicity Oral:
Rat LD50 > 10,000 mg/kg (EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; reported in a secondary
source with limited study details.)
Rat LD50 > 6,400 mg/kg (EINECS, 2008; reported in a secondary source. Non-
guideline study. Dose and particle size not reported; 7-day observation period.)
Dermal:
Rabbit LD50 > 8,000 mg/kg (EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; reported in a secondary
source with limited study details)
Rabbit LD50 > 20,000 mg/kg (EINECS, 2008; NICNAS, 2012; non-guideline study.
Too few animals were used; clinical signs not reported.)
Inhalation:
Rat LC50 > 200 mg/L (EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; reported in a secondary source
with limited study details.)
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18 US EPA: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD)).
2.2.2 Short term Not available for mammals/vertebrates.
toxicity
2.2.3 Genotoxicity Gene mutation in vitro:
(including Negative in Salmonella typhimurium (strains not specified) in the presence and
mutagenicity) absence of metabolic activation. (EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; reported in a
secondary source with limited study details.)
Chromosomal aberrations in vitro:
Negative, mammalian chromosomal aberration test with human peripheral blood
lymphocytes in the presence and absence of metabolic activation
• Doses: 10, 19, 38, 75, 150, 300 and 600 μg/mL.
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; Guideline study. Performed according to current EPA,
OECD guidelines, and GLP.)
Other in vitro:
Positive, intragenic recombination test in Sp5/V79 and SPD8 hamster cells; cell
lines developed by study authors.
• Doses: 2-20 μg/mL.
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; reported in a secondary source. Non-guideline study.
Not a standard test used by regulatory agencies to assess genotoxicity. Reliability
and predictive ability is unknown.)
Negative, mouse micronucleus test.
• Doses: 0, 500, 1,000 or 2,000 mg/kg in dimethyl sulfoxide.
(EPA, 2005; reported in a secondary source. Guideline study. Performed according
to current EPA, OECD guidelines and GLP.)
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18 US EPA: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD)).
2.2.4 Long term The EU risk assessment of hexabromocyclododecane completed in 2008 provides
toxicity and the most comprehensive assessment of toxic effects and risks of
carcinogenicity hexabromocyclododecane exposure to human health and welfare (European Union
18
2008). This assessment concludes that hexabromocyclododecane may cause
reproductive toxicity and long term toxicity, whereas there is no concern for acute
toxicity, irritation, sensitization, mutagenicity and carcinogenicity.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.5 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
Repeated dose studies with oral exposure in rats and mice resulted in increased liver
weight and effects on the pituitary weight and thyroid hormone parameters. A
LOAEL of 22.5 mg/kg was proposed for repeated dose.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.2.2 of the Norwegian notification).
2.2.5 Effects on There are several studies on reproductive effects of hexabromocyclododecane.
reproduction Saegusa et al. (2009) performed a one-generation developmental toxicity study in
rats, with maternal dietary exposure to 0, 100, 1,000 or 10,000 ppm
hexabromocyclododecane from gestation day 10 until weaning of the offspring. In
this study thyroid effects were observed both in dams (thyroid weight increase and
follicular cell hypertrophy at 10,000 ppm) and offspring (thyroid weight increase,
decreased serum T3 and increased serum TSH at 1,000 and 10,000 ppm). The
thyroid effects together with the impaired oligodendroglial development in the brain
cortex (statistically significant at the high dose (-24%) supported by a dose-
dependent trend in the mid (-12%) and low (-8%) dose groups) and the decreased
female body weight (9% in the high dose group) could indicate developmental
hypothyroidism. The LOAEL of this study is 1,000 ppm (81-213 mg/kg/day), and
the NOAEL 100 ppm (8-21 mg/kg/day). The long continuous exposure study of van
der Ven et al. (2009) suggest that male reproductive organs are particularly sensitive
to hexabromocyclododecane exposure i.e. a decreased testicular weight was
observed at a BMDL of 52 μg/g bw in F1 males. A weight reduction in other male
organs; prostate, the adrenals, heart and brain as well as in F1 males' total weight
was also observed. The observed body weight loss makes it impossible to say
whether any of these effects on organs’ weights are specific or secondary to the
general body weight loss. In females the cytochrome P450 19 enzyme activity,
based on group averages, showed a correlation to the internal concentration of
γ-hexabromocyclododecane (linear correlation coefficient of 0.90). The cytochrome
P450 19 enzyme converts androgens to estrogens (Norris 2006), and is essential for
differentiation and development of gonads and brains of higher vertebrates,
maintenance of reproductive tissues, and sexual behavior (Conley and
Hinshelwood, 2001, Simpson et al. 2002). In females the time to vaginal opening
was also delayed, but only at the top dose (BMDL 82.2 μg/g bw at a benchmark
response (BMR) of 10%).
Like the studies of van der Ven et al. (2009) and Saegusa et al. 2009, Ema et al.
(2008) document reproductive and developmental effects (decreased pup viability,
fewer primordial follicles), and also changes in organ weights (e.g. liver and
thyroid), and thyroid hormone levels. Several effects were trans-generational and
affected both F0 parents and F1 and F2 parents and offspring. From the point of
view of reproductive toxicology, the general decrease in viability in F2 pups on
post-natal days 4 and 21 at 1,500 and 15,000 ppm and the decrease in primordial
follicles at 1,500 and 15,000 ppm hexabromocyclododecane exposure in F1 females
were the most severe effects. A reduced number of primordial follicles suggests that
reproductive potential of the female may be reduced, and is generally regarded as
sensitive biomarkers for adverse reproductive effects (Parker et al. 2006). It should
be noted however that the highest dose used by Ema et al. (2008) may be considered
to be very high. However, dosing was in this study done by mixing
hexabromocyclododecane particles into an appropriate amount of powdered basal
diet for each dietary concentration. The absorption kinetics of
hexabromocyclododecane likely depends on both the particle size and amount of
particles administered, and is expected to be lower than for dissolved
hexabromocyclododecane. The actual tissue doses from this study are therefore
presumably lower than the original dose would suggest, as may also be assumed
from the findings of similar studies such as that of WIL 2001 who only observed
reversible effects at doses up to 1,000 mg/kg bw/day in their 90-day oral exposure
study.
19
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.4 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
A NOAEL of 10 mg/kg/day has been deduced in a two-generation reproductive
toxicity study in rats. The NOAEL is based on dose-dependent decrease in fertility
index and a reduced number of primordial follicles. Other effects observed were
effect on liver and thyroid weight and TSH hormone level, and increased mortality
during lactation.
Neonatal hexabromocyclododecane exposure may cause developmental neurotoxic
effects as illustrated by statistically significant changes in spontaneous behaviour,
learning and memory defects. Male mice exposed orally with a single dose at day
10 postnatal (brain growth spurt in mice), were tested for behaviour effects at 3
months age. Clear effects were seen on all parameters tested at 13.5 mg/kg, and on
some at 0.9 mg/kg, giving an indicative LOAEL of 0.9 mg/kg/day from this study
(Eriksson et al., 2006, as described in the EU Risk assessment for HBCD 2008).
Hexabromocyclododecane inhibited the high affinity uptake of neurotransmitters
(dopamine and glutamate) into synaptosomes at similar concentration levels as
previously shown for polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) (Mariussen and Fonnum,
2003, as described in the EU Risk assessment for HBCD 2008).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.2.2 of the Norwegian notification).
2.2.6 Neurotoxicity/ Thyroid hormones are required for normal development of the nervous system, as
delayed are retinoids (Forrest et al. 2002, Maden 2007), and disturbances in these systems
neurotoxicity, may therefore result in long term neurotoxic effects in off-spring. For
Special studies hexabromocyclododecane, a neurotoxic potential has previously been indicated both
where available in vivo and in vitro with rodent models (Reistad et al. 2006, Mariussen and Fonnum,
2003, Dingemans et al. 2009, Eriksson et al. 2006, Lilienthal et al. 2009). In the in
vivo study of Eriksson et al. (2006) neonatal direct exposure of pups to a single oral
dose of hexabromocyclododecane (0.9 mg/kg or 13.5 mg/kg bw on postnatal day
10), induced alterations in spontaneous behavior with initial hypo-reactivity,
followed by impaired habituation in adult mice. This study also reported effects on
spatial learning and memory as assessed in a Morris water maze test with exposed
mice. In contrast, in their two-generation study with rats where exposure of pups
occurred indirectly via human breast milk, Ema et al. (2008), only observed
transient changes in the performance of F1 males in a water-filled T-maze test at an
exposure level of 1,500 ppm and higher and no effects on other parameters
(locomotor activity). According to Ema et al. (2008), the discrepancy in their results
from the results obtained in previous studies could be explained by differences in
exposure regime and/or by differences in species sensitivity. Results from in vitro
studies suggest that hexabromocyclododecane may be cytotoxic to nerve cells and
possibly also interfere with neuronal signalling events such as Ca2+ and
neurotransmitter uptake (Reistad et al. 2006, Mariussen and Fonnum 2003,
Dingemans et al. 2009).
The in vivo neurotoxic potential of hexabromocyclododecane has also been studied
by Lilienthal et al. 2009. In a one generation reproduction feeding study, they
showed that hexabromocyclododecane-induced loss in hearing function was
paralleled by changes in dopamine dependent behaviour (Lilienthal et al. 2009).
Loss of hearing function was attributed to a cochlear effect of
hexabromocyclododecane that resulted in increased thresholds and moderate
prolongations of latencies in the lower frequency range from 0.5 to 2 kHz and after
clicks. Both observed effects were dose-dependent with lower bounds of bench
mark doses (BMDL) between ≤ 1 and 10 mg/kg bw. Saegusa et al. (2009) on the
other hand detected weak hypothyroidism with increases in thyroid weight, thyroid
follicular cell hypertrophy and serum TSH concentrations as well as a decrease in
serum T3 levels in rat off-spring exposed to 10,000 ppm hexabromocyclododecane
in a soy-free diet from gestation day 10 to day 20 after delivery. The TH changes
were accompanied by a reduced density of CNPase-positive oligodentrocytes,
which is indicative of impaired oligodendroglial development. Increased thyroid
weights and decreased serum T3 concentrations were also observed in the adult
stage from 1,000 ppm. Though the above data suggest that
20
hexabromocyclododecane induced disturbances in TH-signalling is linked to effects
on the nervous system in rodents, changes in behaviour and cognition may also be
impacted by a decrease in apolar retinoids as observed in female rat livers following
hexabromocyclododecane exposure (van der Ven et al. 2006, van der Ven et al.
2009). Moreover, the interferences of hexabromocyclododecane with sex-steroid
hormones and their receptors should not be neglected as these hormones also exert
non-genomic effects on brain functions such as learning and memory, fine motor
control, pain perception and mood (Boulware and Mermelstein 2005, Chakraborti et
al. 2007, Meaney et al. 1983, Schantz and Widholm 2001).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.4 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
2.2.7 Summary of Hexabromocyclododecane exerts reproductive, developmental and neurotoxic
mammalian effects in mammals with a NOEC/NOAEL in the order of 1 mg/kg/day. In vivo data
toxicity and include:
overall • Decreased pup survival and fewer primordial follicles in rats at 100
evaluation mg/kg/day, NOAEL 10 mg/kg/day (Ema et al. 2008).
• Decreased pup weight, decreased testis and prostrate weights, impaired
hearing, and reduction in female bone mineral density in rat offspring at
30-100 mg/kg/day (van der Ven et al. 2009, Lillienthal et al. 2009).
• TH imbalance and impaired oligodendroglial development in the brain
cortex of rat offspring at 1,000 ppm (81-213 mg/kg/day), NOAEL 8-21
mg/kg/day (Saegusa et al. 2009).
• Behavioural effects in mice exposed to 13.5 mg/kg/day at day 10, NOAEL
0.9 mg/kg/day (Eriksson et al. 2006).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 3 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
3 Human exposure/Risk evaluation
3.1 Food In humans hexabromocyclododecane is found in blood, plasma and adipose tissue.
The main sources of exposure presently known are contaminated food and dust. For
breast feeding children, mothers’ milk is the main exposure route but
hexabromocyclododecane exposure also occurs at early developmental stages as it
is transferred across the placenta to the foetus. Human breast milk data from the
1970s to 2000 show that hexabromocyclododecane levels have increased since
hexabromocyclododecane was commercially introduced as a brominated flame
retardant in the 1980s. Though information on the human toxicity of
hexabromocyclododecane is to a great extent lacking, and tissue concentrations
found in humans are seemingly low, embryos and infants are vulnerable groups that
could be at risk, particularly to the observed neuroendocrine and developmental
toxicity of hexabromocyclododecane.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 Executive Summary of the POPRC Risk
Profile)
Reported dietary exposure levels in humans vary globally and regionally (Shi et al.
2009, Roosens et al. 2009). Surveys in Europe and the US reveal dietary exposure
levels for hexabromocyclododecane in the range of <0.01-5 ng/g w/w (see Roosens
et al. 2009 for overview). Fatty foods of animal origin such as meat and fish are
likely a major source of dietary human exposure, and the exposure situation closely
depends on the consumption of those products in the population (e.g. Shi et al.
2009; Remberger et al. 2004, Lind et al 2002, Driffield et al. 2008). Among all
dietary samples, the highest hexabromocyclododecane concentrations (up to 9.4
ng/g w/w) are reported for fish (Knutsen et al. 2008, Remberger et al. 2004, Allchin
and Morris 2003). Accordingly in Norway, where fish is an important part of the
diet, intake of fish has been found to closely correlate with serum
hexabromocyclododecane levels (Thomsen et al. 2008; Knutsen et al. 2008). Eggs
are another potential source of human exposure (Hiebl et al. 2007, Covaci et al.
2009). A survey of home-grown chicken eggs sampled near contaminated sites in
developing countries showed eggs to contain <3.0-160 ng/g lipid weight (IPEN,
2005). hexabromocyclododecane levels in eggs were high in Mexico (91 ng/g lipid),
Uruguay (89 ng/g lipid), Slovakia (89 ng/g lipid), relatively high in Turkey (43 ng/g
lipid), and extremely high in Kenya (160 ng/g lipid). That vegetables may contain
21
hexabromocyclododecane at similar concentrations as have been reported for meat
and fish, was shown by Driffield et al. (2008), who assessed 19 different food
groups representing the UK diet for 2004 for brominated flame retardants. The
presence of hexabromocyclododecane in vegetables and vegetable oils and fats may
arise from the presence of this substance in sewage sludge and the subsequent use of
sewage sludge as a food crop fertilizer (Kupper et al. 2008, Brändli et al. 2007).
Stereoisomeric patterns in food samples suggest both global and regional variation,
as well as stereoisomeric differences depending on food type (Roosens et al. 2009;
Shi et al. 2009).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.3.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
3.2 Air A study by Abdallah et al (2009) found hexabromocyclododecane in household air
(median concentration 180 pg m-3), household dust (median concentration 1,300
ng/g), offices (median concentration 760 ng/g), and cars (median concentration
13,000 ng/g).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.3.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
3.3 Water Not available.
3.4 Occupational In the work environment, direct dermal exposure and inhalation of fine
exposure hexabromocyclododecane dust or particles are particular concerns. In a study by
Thomsen et al. (2007) industrial workers at plants producing EPS with
hexabromocyclododecane were found to have elevated hexabromocyclododecane
levels in their blood (i.e. 6-856 ng/g lw serum). Serum/blood levels in non-
occupationally exposed individuals are typically much lower (i.e. 0.005-6.9 ng/g lw)
though the data indicates potentially significant sources of exposure (see KEMI
2008 for overview).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.3.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
3.5 Medical data Not available.
contributing to
regulatory
decision
3.6 Public exposure In non-occupationally exposed individuals indirect exposure via the environment or
products, be it oral, dermal or by inhalation, is the main concern. In a study by
Stapleton et al. (2008) hexabromocyclododecane levels in dust samples from indoor
environments ranged from <4.5 ng/g to a maximum of 130,200 ng/g with a median
value of 230 ng/g.
As a result of continuous exposure in homes, offices and cars,
hexabromocyclododecane is found in human adipose tissue (Pulkrabová et al. 2009;
Johnson-Restrepo et al. 2008; Antignac et al. 2008; Abdallah and Harrad 2009) and
blood (Weiss et al. 2004; Weiss et al. 2006; Lopez et al. 2004; Brandsma et al.
2009; Thomsen et al. 2007; Meijer et al. 2008; Roosens et al. 2009). Exposure
occurs at an early stage of development as hexabromocyclododecane is transferred
across the human placenta to the fetus (Mejier et al. 2008), and is also transferred
from mother to child via breast milk. Hexabromocyclododecane has been detected
in breast milk in Europe (Covaci et al. 2006; Lignell et al. 2009; Eljarrat et al. 2009,
Colles et al. 2008; Polder et al. 2008a; Polder et al. 2008b; Fängström et al. 2008;
Antignac et al. 2008), in Asia (Kakimoto et al. 2008; Shi et al. 2009; Malarvannan
et al. 2009; Tue et al. 2010), in Russia (Polder et al. 2008b), Mexico (Lopez et al.
2004) and in USA (Schecter et al. 2008). Hence exposure to
hexabromocyclododecane occurs at critical stages of human development, both
during pregnancy and postnatally via breast milk. Reported concentrations of
hexabromocyclododecane in breast milk range from below detection limit to 188 ng
hexabromocyclododecane/g lw (for overview see European Union 2008).
According to EBFRIP 2009b the typical range of total hexabromocyclododecane
concentrations in human breast milk in populations inhabiting industrialized areas
appears to be <1 to 5 ng/g lw. Geographically, the highest
hexabromocyclododecane levels have been found in mothers’ milk from two areas
in Northern Spain (Catalonia and Galicia). The reported hexabromocyclododecane
22
levels from these studies ranged from 3-188 and 8 -188 ng/g lw, with median values
of 27 and 26 ng/g lw, respectively (Eljarrat et al. 2009; Guerra et al. 2008a).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.3.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
3.7 Summary- The EU risk assessment of hexabromocyclododecane completed in 2008 provides
overall risk the most comprehensive assessment of toxic effects and risks of
evaluation hexabromocyclododecane exposure to human health and welfare (European Union
2008). This assessment concludes that hexabromocyclododecane may cause
reproductive toxicity and long term toxicity, whereas there is no concern for acute
toxicity, irritation, sensitization, mutagenicity and carcinogenicity. It moreover
states that hexabromocyclododecane poses no risk to adult consumers or to workers
when standard industrial hygiene measures are applied (current EU practice). These
conclusions are founded on an extensive list of toxicity studies and on a
comprehensive selection of exposure and risk assessments that consider not only
workers and adult consumers, but also indirect exposure of humans via the
environment (European Union 2008). The EU risk assessment documents that
currently in the general (human) population, hexabromocyclododecane tissue
concentrations are much below those reported to induce adverse effects in other
mammals (European Union 2008).
The substance is suspected of damaging fertility or the unborn child (Repr. 2;
H361), and the substance may cause harm to breast-fed children (Lact.; H362)
(KEMI 2009).
Significant levels of hexabromocyclododecane in human milk and exposure through
food has been reported near local sources. In humans, the main risks of
hexabromocyclododecane exposure are possible neuroendocrine and developmental
disturbances from exposure during the early developmental phases of the child.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.5 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
In humans, the main risks of hexabromocyclododecane exposure are possible
neuroendocrine and developmental disturbances from exposure during the early
developmental phases of the child.
In addition to the findings in the in vivo animal studies, there are a large number of
recent in vitro studies that document how hexabromocyclododecane upon
adsorption may act on, and possibly interfere with biological processes such as cell
homeostasis, protein repair, metabolism, intracellular signalling and neuroendocrine
processes. Such studies add to the understanding that exposure to
hexabromocyclododecane has various effects on human health and the environment,
and should also be regarded when considering the toxicity of
hexabromocyclododecane.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 3 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4 Environmental fate and effects
4.1 Fate
4.1.1 Soil The rate of degradation of hexabromocyclododecane is slower in the presence of
oxygen. Davis et al. (2005) reported on the biodegradation of technical
hexabromocyclododecane in freshwater sediments and soils. Using OECD test
guidelines 307 and 308, the authors demonstrated that the rate of loss of
hexabromocyclododecane at 20oC was appreciably faster under anoxic conditions
in both media. Relative to biologically sterile controls, biotransformation of
hexabromocyclododecane was faster in the presence of microorganisms and DT 50
values ranged from 11 to 32 days (aerobic) and 1.1 to 1.5 days (anaerobic) in
sediment. In soil, half-lives under aerobic and anaerobic conditions were 63 and 6.9
days, respectively. However, in this study only the degradation of
γ-hexabromocyclododecane was studied since the test concentration was too low to
23
allow detection of α- and β-hexabromocyclododecane. It was also not possible to
detect transformation products.
In the EU Risk Assessment, the degradation half-lives in aerobic sediment were
calculated at 20°C to be 113, 68 and 104 days for α-, β- and
γ-hexabromocyclododecane, respectively (European Union 2008). In sediment,
technical-hexabromocyclododecane was observed to be subject to primary
degradation with half-lives of 66 and 101 days in anaerobic and aerobic sediment at
20°C, respectively. The EU Risk Assessment notes that the study was conducted at
hexabromocyclododecane concentrations much greater (mg/kg) than Davis et al.
(2005) (µg/kg), so the degradation kinetics may be limited by the mass transfer of
chemical into the microbes. The main transformation product was
1,5,9-cyclododecatriene (CDT) which was formed via a step-wise reductive
dehalogenation of hexabromocyclododecane. No CO2 was detected during the
study. However, in a study performed according to OECD guideline 301F (Davis et
al. 2006b), it was shown that t,t,t-CDT can be degraded to CO2.
Degradation rate constants of hexabromocyclododecane, under anaerobic
conditions in sewage sludge have also been reported (Gerecke et al. 2006).
Experiments were conducted by adding individual target compounds or mixtures to
freshly collected digested sewage sludge. The sewage sludge was amended with
yeast and starch. Experiments, performed at 37°C, with racemic mixtures of
individual diastereoisomers showed that (+/-)-β-hexabromocyclododecane and (+/-
)-γ-hexabromocyclododecane degraded faster than
(+/-)-α-hexabromocyclododecane by an estimated factor of 1.6 and 1.8,
respectively. Based on the investigations of Davis et al. (2006a) and Gerecke et al.
(2006), α-hexabromocyclododecane seems to be subject to a slower degradation
than β- and γ-hexabromocyclododecane.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.2.1 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4.1.2 Water There are no reliable empirical data on the degradation kinetics of
hexabromocyclododecane in water. The hydrolysis of hexabromocyclododecane
has not been studied. Hydrolysis should however, not be considered as a significant
route of environmental degradation for this substance due to the low water
solubility, the high partitioning to organic carbon, and the lack of hydrolysable
functional groups (OECD 2007). According to calculations in the EMEP report on
hexabromocyclododecane, the physical-chemical properties of the technical
mixture and γ-hexabromocyclododecane stereoisomer give a half-life in water of
about 5 years (EMEP 2009).
According to EBFRIP (2009b) the half-life for water and soil derived from
comparing different model estimations lies in the range 8.5 – 850 days, with a
median of 85 days and confidence factor (CF) of 10. The half-life in freshwater and
marine sediments lies in the range 6 – 210 days, with a median of 35 days and CF
of 6. EBFRIP (2009b) does not differentiate between fresh water and marine
sediment.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.2.1 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4.1.3 Air The atmospheric degradation half-life of hexabromocyclododecane by gas-phase
reaction with hydroxyl radicals (OH) has not been experimentally measured but can
be modeled, providing an estimate (by AopWin v1.91) of 76.8 hours (3.2 days).
The estimate was obtained by assuming a concentration of 5×10 5 OH
molecules·cm-3 and that the reaction takes place 24 hours a day (these are values
used in the European Union risk assessments). It is noted that the model is sensitive
to the chosen OH concentration (NCM 2008).
Bahm and Khalil (2004) derived a 24-hour global annual average OH concentration
of 9.2×105 molecules·cm-3, with a value of 9.8×105 molecules·cm-3 for the northern
24
hemisphere and 8.5×105 molecules·cm-3 for the southern hemisphere. These values
are consistent with Prinn et al. (1995) and Montzka et al. (2000) who deduced OH
concentrations from atmospheric measurements of methyl chloroform, reporting 24
hour global annual average values of 9.7(±0.6)×10 5 and 1.1(±0.2)×106
molecules·cm-3 respectively. Considering the uncertainty in the model estimates of
kOH, the half-life for photochemical degradation of hexabromocyclododecane
ranges from 0.4 to 4 days and 0.6 to 5.4 days for the northern and southern
hemisphere respectively (EBFRIP 2009b).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.2.3 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4.1.4 Bioconcentration From two flow-through bio-concentration tests with fish. A BCF of 18,100 in
fathead minnow was chosen as a representative value in the EU risk assessment.
hexabromocyclododecane levels have been shown to increase with trophic levels in
a freshwater system: Fjeld (2006a) reported concentrations of
hexabromocyclododecane in European smelt (Osmerus eperlanus), Vendace
(coregonus albula), and Brown Trout (Salmo trutta trutta) from lake Mjosa in
Norway. European smelt and Vendace are important preyfish for the trout. The
concentrations of hexabromocyclododecane detected in 2005 were 466 µg/kg lwt
(8.8 µg/kg wwt), 374 µg/kg lwt (10.7 µg/kg wwt), 729 µg/kg lwt (18 µg/kg wwt)
for the European smelt, the Vendace, and the Brown trout, respectively.
HBCD has also been detected in other organisms high in rank in their food -chain
such as birds, seals, marine fish, dolphins, harbour porpoise and polar bear.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.2.3 of the Norwegian notification).
4.1.5 Persistence No or little degradation has been observed in water, soil and sediments.
Furthermore, hexabromocyclododecane adsorbs to particles which slow down the
degradation
Air: T1/2 - 51.2 hours (Wania 2003, as referred in EC 2008)
Water: T1/2 - 1140 hours (Wania 2003, as referred in EC 2008)
Soil: T1/2 - 112-119 days (12°C) for γ-hexabromocyclododecane diastereomer
Aerobic sediment: T1/2 ~ 197 days (recalculated to 12°C) for
γ-hexabromocyclododecane in a simulation study.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.2.3 of the Norwegian notification)
To evaluate the persistency of hexabromocyclododecane a compilation of data on
experimentally measured half-lives in different environmental compartments, data
on half-lives derived from modeling, and field data have been undertaken. Results
of the estimation model, BIOWIN (v4.10, EPI Suite v4.0), which estimates the
probability for aerobic biodegradation in the presence of mixed populations of
environmental microorganisms suggest that hexabromocyclododecane is not readily
biodegradable; the expected time of primary degradation is in the order of weeks.
Moreover, an early biodegradation study using Closed Bottle Test systems that
were conducted in accordance with OECD Guideline 301D, found no
biodegradation of hexabromocyclododecane over a 28-day study period (Wildlife
International 1996). It should be noted that while the studies were performed using
accepted test guidelines, the concentrations tested were about three orders of
magnitude greater than the water solubility of hexabromocyclododecane (7.7 mg/L
vs 66 µg/L).
Japanese authorities conducted a 28-day biodegradation study of 1,2,5,6,9,10-
hexabromocyclododecane based on the OECD Test Guideline 301C. The
degradation of the test substance, a mixture containing different stereoisomers, was
assessed by high performance liquid chromatography. The percentage
biodegradation of two hexabromocyclododecane isomeric forms (A and B), were
calculated to be 5 and 6%, respectively. (Chemicals Inspection and Testing
Institute, 1990).
Several studies using sediment cores show that hexabromocyclododecane
congeners deposited in marine sediments in Asia and in Europe at the beginning of
the 1970s/1980s are still present in significant amounts (Minh et al. 2007, Tanabe
25
2008, Kohler et al. 2008, Bogdal et al. 2008), indicating a higher persistency in
sediments than derived from experimental studies.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.2.1 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4.2 Effects on non-
target organisms
4.2.1 Terrestrial A recent study with American kestrels indicates that a technical
vertebrates hexabromocyclododecane mixture administered to birds via the diet is readily taken
up and distributed to internal organs (BFR 2009a; SETAC 2009). The main
stereoisomer detected in liver, fat and egg was α-hexabromocyclododecane,
followed by γ-hexabromocyclododecane and β-hexabromocyclododecane.
According to these observations, hexabromocyclododecane is preferentially stored
in fat and is transferred to eggs during development. Tissue concentrations were
such that fat>>eggs>liver>plasma (SETAC 2009). In this study, administration of
800 ng/g wwt of technical hexabromocyclododecane formulation in safflower oil
for 21 days followed by a 25-day depuration period, resulted in environmentally
relevant internal doses, i.e., sum of hexabromocyclododecane isomers of 934.8 ng/g
lw (20 ng/g ww) in liver and 4216.2 ng/g lw (181. 5 ng/g ww) in eggs) with the
level of α-hexabromocyclododecane being 164 ng/g wwt in egg) (BFR 2009b). A
parallel study assessed reproductive effects of hexabromocyclododecane in
American kestrels (Falco sparverius) (BFR 2009b; Dioxin 2010b). Also here
kestrels were exposed daily to 800 ng/g wwt of a technical
hexabromocyclododecane mixture in safflower oil from three weeks prior to
pairing until two days before hatching. α-hexabromocyclododecane dominated in
eggs, where it was found at a concentration of 164 ng/g wwt following exposure.
While clutch size (number of eggs per female) was greater in the treated kestrels,
hatchling numbers were comparable to that of controls (Dioxin 2010b). Treated
kestrel nestlings were smaller in weight and had a slower growth rate than controls
as determined by overall body weight. Behavioural parameters related to parental
care were also affected by hexabromocyclododecane exposure (BFR 2009b; Dioxin
2010c).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.3 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4.2.2 Aquatic species Ecotoxicity testing of hexabromocyclododecane in aqueous media is complicated
by its very low water solubility and high adsorption potential (EBFRIP 2009b,
NCM 2008). hexabromocyclododecane has a low acute toxicity to aquatic
organisms owing in part to its limited solubility in aqueous media (Wildlife
International 1997, Walsh et al. 1987, CEPA 2007 and ACCBFRIP 2001 for
overview). Regarding the long-term toxicity of hexabromocyclododecane it was
concluded to be very toxic to aquatic organisms in the EU Risk Assessment
(European Union 2008). This conclusion was based on the long-term ecotoxicity
test with Daphnia magna (28d-NOEC 3.1 µg/l; Wildlife International 1998) and on
the growth inhibition test with Skeletonema costatum (72h-EC50 52 µg/L; Wildlife
International 2005). In both tests calculated NOEC and EC50 values were below the
water solubility of the technical mixture of hexabromocyclododecane (66 µg/L).
Based on the effects in long-term tests with Lumbriculus variegates,
hexabromocyclododecane is known to cause adverse effects to aquatic sediment
organisms at exposure level relevant for the environment (Institute of Hydrobiology
2001).
Fish-feeding studies indicate effects on key biological processes. For example, an
interference of hexabromocyclododecane with the HPT-axis and liver
biotransformation enzymes were reported in rainbow trout exposed to individual
hexabromocyclododecane diastereoisomers via food for 56 days followed by a
depuration period of 112 days when fish were fed a reference diet (Palace et al.
2008). Lipid corrected concentrations of α-, β-, γ-isomers in the food were 29.14 ±
1.95, 11.84 ± 4.62, and 22.84 ± 2.26 ng/g, respectively (means ±SEM). Liver
detoxification processes (P450 CYP1A activity) were inhibited by all
hexabromocyclododecane stereoisomers after 7 days of dosing, and also after 56
days of dosing but then only in α- and β- exposed fish. Thyroid follicle epithelial
cell heights were significantly greater in γ-hexabromocyclododecane exposed fish
at day 56 of the uptake phase and in fish from the α- and
26
γ-hexabromocyclododecane exposed groups at day 14 of the depuration phase.
More recent studies also support that hexabromocyclododecane may interfere with
the fish thyroid system (Palace et al. 2010). The link between
hexabromocyclododecane induced disturbances in the HPT-axis and the importance
of such effects to smoltification in Atlantic salmon has also been examined (Lower
and Moore 2007). To assess this, Lower and Moore (2007) exposed juvenile
salmon to 11 ng/L of a hexabromocyclododecane mixture for 30 days during the
peak smoltification period in freshwater. The fish were then transferred to clean
seawater for 20 days. Throughout the hexabromocyclododecane-dosing and
saltwater exposures, 5-8 fish were sampled every 7 days and gill and blood tissues
were collected. In addition, electro-olfactrograms were recorded in an additional 5
fish every 10 days using urine from salmon from the same stream (considered to be
the cue for returning smolts) as an effector. The exposure to
hexabromocyclododecane was not observed to affect seawater adaptability,
although the peak of thyroxine was shifted and occurred one week earlier in
hexabromocyclododecane exposed fish than in controls. A reduction in olfactory
function, as evidenced by attenuated olfactory responses during early freshwater
transition, was also observed. This latter effect is important as it can affect
successful homing, and thereby ultimately also reproductive capacity in adult
salmon. In contrast to the above findings, in a third reported study assessing TH
effects in European flounders (Platichtys flesus), no effects neither on the liver’s
biotransformation capacity or TH-levels were reported, even though
hexabromocyclododecane accumulated dose-dependently (Kuiper et al. 2007). The
fish were in this instance exposed to hexabromocyclododecane in food (μg/g lipid)
and sediment (μg/g total organic carbon) in the following combinations; 0+0
(control); 0.3+0.08; 3+0.8; 30+8; 300+80; 3,000+800; and 0+8,000 for 78 days.
Lastly, hexabromocyclododecane may also interfere with amphibian
metamorphosis, a process that is tightly regulated by TH-hormones. As shown in
vitro, hexabromocyclododecane at 10, 100 and 1000 nM potentiates T3 induced
tadpole tail regression in a concentration dependent manner (Schriks et al. 2006). In
vivo such effects may result in precocious metamorphosis.
Recent studies with fish models suggest that hexabromocyclododecane may also
induce oxidative stress and apoptosis. Deng et al. (2009) examined oxidative stress
and the apoptosis pathway in four-hour post-fertilization zebrafish (Danio rerio)
embryos by exposing them to waterborne hexabromocyclododecane at
concentrations of 0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.5, and 1.0 mg/L for 92 hours. Survival was reduced
at the three middle doses equivalently, but was elevated at the highest dose
(1mg/L). Hatching rate was only affected at the highest dose (1 mg/L) with a 10%
reduction from controls. Malformation rates (including epiboly deformities, yolk
sac and pericardial edema, tail and heart malformations, spinal curvatures and
improper inflation of the swimbladder) increased dose dependently, and heart rate
and body length both also decreased with exposure to hexabromocyclododecane.
The levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) also increased dose dependently in
fish exposed to hexabromocyclododecane concentrations above 0.05 mg/L. With
regard to apoptosis, hexabromocyclododecane elevated expression of the pro-
apoptotic genes p53, Bax, Puma, Apaf-1, and caspase-9 and caspase-3, of which the
response of the latter two was verified at the enzyme level. The anti-apoptotic
genes Mdm2 and Bcl-2 were both significantly down regulated at the highest
hexabromocyclododecane exposure concentration. The overall results demonstrate
that waterborne hexabromocyclododecane may produce oxidative stress in
zebrafish embryos and lower survival at doses below the water solubility of
technical hexabromocyclododecane. The latter effect is important since
hexabromocyclododecane has been documented to be maternally transferred to
offspring in oviparous animals, hereunder also fish (Nyholm et al. 2008, Jaspers et
al. 2005, Lundsted-Enkel et al. 2006). The potential of hexabromocyclododecane to
induce oxidative stress in zebra fish embryos has also been demonstrated by Hu et
al. (2009). Here, the oxidative stress, assessed by lipid membrane damage (effects
at 0.5, 2.5 and 10 mg/L) was also accompanied by delays in hatching
(hexabromocyclododecane at ≤ 0.5 mg/ml), dose-independent changes in
superoxide dismutase enzyme activity (higher at 0.1, lower at 2.5 and 10 mg/L) and
an elevation of heat shock proteins (Hsp70) activity (≥0.1 mg/L), the latter effect
27
likely indicating increased protein repair activity. Moreover, in a study with
Chinese rare minnows (Gobiocyprinus rarus) Zhang et al. (2008) observed a
consistent increase in oxidative stress and cellular macromolecules in brain (ROS,
carbonylation, TBARS) and erythrocytes (DNA) by waterborne
hexabromocyclododecane in the 100-500 μg/l range (42 days). Protective
enzymatic- (superoxide dismutase) and non-enzymatic antioxidant glutathione were
compromised even at concentrations of 10 and 1 µg/L respectively. A shorter 28-
day exposure resulted in somewhat higher effect concentrations. However, since
most test concentrations in these studies are above the water solubility of
hexabromocyclododecane, the studies may not be suited to derive dose-response
relationships and to set thresholds of toxicity.
In fish proposed novel mechanisms of hexabromocyclododecane toxicity are
decreased protein metabolism and changes in cytoskeleton dynamics and cellular
defense mechanisms (Kling and Förlin 2009). Recently, hexabromocyclododecane
was also demonstrated to have a genotoxic potential and to increase cell death in
benthic clams (Macoma balthica) (Smolarz and Berger 2009).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.1 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
Hexabromocyclododecane is toxic to aquatic organisms such as Daphnia magna, a
21d-NOEC of 3.1 µg/l has been derived for a flow-through test.
Hexabromocyclododecane is not acute toxic to fish: In rainbow trout, no mortalities
or other effects were observed in a 4-week toxicity test at a concentration of
approximately 6.8 µg/l (mean measured concentration 2.5 µg/l).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 3.2.3 of the Norwegian notification)
Acute Aquatic Toxicity
Fish LC50
Oncorhynchus mykiss 96-hour LC50 >0.0068 mg/L (nominal) or >0.0025 mg/L
(mean measured)
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; Reported in a secondary source. Guideline study.
Performed according to current EPA, OECD guidelines and GLP. No toxicity at
HBCD’s limit of water solubility.)
Lepomis macrochirus 96-hour LC50 >100 mg/L (nominal)
(EPA, 2005; Reported in a secondary source with limited study details. Value
exceeds water solubility.)
Leuciscus idus 96-hour LC50 >10,000 mg/L (nominal)
(EPA, 2005; Reported in a secondary source with limited study details. Value
exceeds water solubility.)
Fish 96-hour LC50 = 0.30 mg/L (Estimated)
(ECOSAR v1.10; No effects at saturation (NES): The log Kow of 5.6 for this
chemical exceeds the SAR limitation for the log Kow of 5.0; NES are predicted for
these endpoints. Narcosis classes (neutral organics) are provided for comparative
purposes; DfE assessment methodology will use the lowest estimated toxicity value
provided by ECOSAR classes that have a more specific mode of action relative to
narcosis.)
Brachydanio rerio exposed to 0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.5 and 1.0 mg L for up to 96 hours.
• Cell apoptosis, induction of reactive oxygen species (ROS) at 0.1, 0.5 and
1.0 mg/L.
28
• Exposure to hexabromocyclododecane results in oxidative stress and may
induce apoptosis through involvement of caspases
• NOEC = 0.05 mg/L
• LOEC = 0.1 mg/L
(Deng et al., 2009; Guideline study. Study details taken from abstract. This study is
for a nontraditional endpoint for determining hazard designation. In addition,
NOEC and LOEC values are above the limit of water solubility and will not be
used to determine a hazard designation. No effects at saturation (NES) are
predicted.)
Daphnid LC50 / EC50
Daphnia magna 48-hour EC50 >0.0068 mg/L (nominal) or >0.0032 mg/L (mean
measured).
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; Reported in a secondary source. Guideline study
performed according to current EPA, OECD guidelines and GLP. No toxicity at
HBCD’s limit of water solubility; NES.)
D. magna 48-hour EC50 = 146 mg/L (nominal)
• Nominal test concentrations were 0.01-1,000 mg/L (both below and above
the water solubility)
(EINECS, 2008; Reported in a secondary source. Guideline study performed
according to current EPA, OECD guidelines and GLP. Value exceeds water
solubility.)
Daphnia 48-hour LC50 = 0.23 mg/L (Estimated).
(ECOSAR v 1.10; NES: The log Kow of 5.6 for this chemical exceeds the SAR
limitation for the log K Kow of 5.0; NES are predicted for these endpoints. Narcosis
classes (neutral organics) are provided for comparative purposes; DfE assessment
methodology will use the lowest estimated toxicity value provided by ECOSAR
classes that have a more specific mode of action relative to narcosis.)
Green Algae EC50
Skeletonema costatum 72-hour NOEC >0.01 mg/L (>10 μg
hexabromocyclododecane)
• EC50 = 0.027 mg/L (biomass)
• EC50 = 0.052 mg/L (growth rate)
(Desjardins et al., 2005; ECHA, 2008; Reported in a secondary source with limited
study details.)
Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata 96-hour EC50 >0.0068 mg/L (nominal) or
>0.0037 mg/L (mean measured)
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; Reported in a secondary source. Guideline study
performed according to current EPA, OECD guidelines and GLP. No toxicity at
HBCD’s limit of water solubility; NES.)
Chlorella sp. 96-hour EC50 >1.5 mg/L
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; Reported in a secondary source with limited study
details. No toxicity at HBCD’s limit of water solubility; NES.)
S. costatum 72-hour EC50 >0.0093-0.012 mg/L.
(EPA, 2005; NICNAS, 2012; Reported in a secondary source with limited study
details. No toxicity at HBCD’s limit of water solubility; NES.)
29
S. costatum 96-hour EC50 >0.0025 mg/L
(ECHA, 2008; Reported in a secondary source with limited study details. The test
substance was made up of a composite of HBCD samples from three manufacturers
containing 6.0% α-, 8.5% β- and 79.1% γ-diastereomers; total HBCD was 93.6% of
test substance. There were no effects at the highest concentration tested.)
S. costatum 72-hour EC50 >0.0406 mg/L (40.6 μg/L)
• NOEC >0.0406 mg/L (only concentration tested)
• LOEC = Not identified
(Desjardins et al., 2004 (as cited in ECHA, 2008; NICNAS, 2012);
Reported in a secondary source with limited study details; LOECs were not
identified. One test concentration at the limit of water solubility; NES.)
Thalassiosira pseudonana 72-hour EC50 >0.05–0.37 mg/L
(Walsh et al., 1987 (as cited in EPA, 2005; NICNAS); Reported in a secondary
source with limited study details. No toxicity at HBCD’s limit of water solubility.)
Scenedesmus subspicatus 96-hour EC50 >500 mg/L
• No effect on growth inhibition
(Siebel-Sauer and Bias, 1987 (as cited in EINECS, 2008); Reported in a secondary
source. Guideline study performed according to current EPA, OECD guidelines and
GLP. Value exceeds water solubility.)
Green algae 96-hour EC50 = 0.29 mg/L (Estimated)
(ECOSAR v. 1.10; The estimated effect exceeds the water solubility of 0.66 mg/L,
but not by 10x as required to be considered NES by ECOSAR.
Narcosis classes (neutral organics) are provided for comparative purposes; DfE
assessment methodology will use the lowest estimated toxicity value provided by
ECOSAR classes that have a more specific mode of action relative to narcosis.)
Chronic Aquatic Toxicity
Fish ChV
Oncorhynchus mykiss 88-day NOEC > 0.0037 mg/L (γ-hexabromocyclododecane).
27-Day hatching period;
• 61 days posthatch showed no effects on hatching success, time to swim-
up, larval survival, fry survival or growth
(Drotter et al., 2001; EPA, 2005; Reported in a secondary source. Guideline study
performed according to current EPA, OECD guidelines and GLP; LOEC and
MATC could not be determined due to absence of toxicity, but were considered
>0.0037 or 0.0068 mg/L (more than twice γ-HBCD’s water solubility). HBCD was
not chronically toxic to rainbow trout at concentrations at or above its limit of
solubility.)
Fish ChV = 0.043 mg/L (Estimated)
(ECOSAR v. 1.10; Narcosis classes (neutral organics) are provided for comparative
purposes; DfE assessment methodology will use the lowest estimated toxicity value
provided by ECOSAR classes that have a more specific mode of action relative to
narcosis.)
Chinese rare minnow 14-, 28- and 42-day waterborne hexabromocyclododecane
exposure to 0.1-0.5 mg/L
• Induced hepatic enzymes (as measured by EROD and PROD).
• Induced oxidative stress in fish brain (as measured by ROS and TBARS).
• 28-day LOEC = 0.5 mg/L
• 42-day LOEC = 0.1 mg/L
30
(Zhang et al., 2008; Study details reported in abstract. Values exceed water
solubility. This study is for a non-traditional endpoint for determining hazard
designation. In addition, LOEC values are above the limit of water solubility and
will not be used to determine a hazard designation. A NOEC was not identified.)
Daphnid ChV
D. magna 21-day life cycle toxicity test. Nominal test concentrations were 0.85,
1.7, 3.4 and 13.6 μg/L; measured test concentrations were 0.87, 1.6, 3.1, 5.6 and 11
μg/L.
• LOEC = 0.0056 mg/L (0.0042 mg/L geometric mean; reduced mean
lengths)
• NOEC = 0.0031 mg/L (γ-hexabromocyclododecane, measured)
(Drotter and Kruger, 1998 (as cited in EINECS, 2008; EPA, 2005; NICNAS,
2012); Reported in a secondary source. Guideline study performed according to
current EPA, OECD guidelines and GLP. Within the range of water solubility. The
test substance was made up of a composite of HBCD samples from three
manufacturers containing 6.0% α-, 8.5% β- and 79.1% γ-diastereomers; total
HBCD was 93.6% of test substance. Reduced lengths, dry weight and fewer young
observed in daphnia exposed to 0.011 mg/L.)
Daphnia ChV = 0.0.059 mg/L (Estimated)
(ECOSAR v. 1.10; Narcosis classes (neutral organics) are provided for comparative
purposes; DfE assessment methodology will use the lowest estimated toxicity value
provided by ECOSAR classes that have a more specific mode of action relative to
narcosis.)
Green Algae ChV
Green algae ChV = 0.38 mg/L (Estimated)
(ECOSAR v. 1.10; The effect level exceeds the water solubility of 0.66 mg/L, but
not by 10x as required to be considered NES by ECOSAR.
Narcosis classes (neutral organics) are provided for comparative purposes; DfE
assessment methodology will use the lowest estimated toxicity value provided by
ECOSAR classes that have a more specific mode of action relative to narcosis.)
Earthworm Subchronic Toxicity
Lumbriculus variegates 28-day sediment bioassay (spiked and aged sediment) with
hexabromocyclododecane at 0.05, 0.5, 5, 50 and 500 mg/kg dwt (nominal)
• LOEC = 28.7 mg/kg (rate of emergence)
• NOEC = 3.2 mg/kg dwt
• Mean number of eggs in F1 generation was significantly reduced at
highest concentration (159 mg/kg dwt).
(EINECS, 2008; Oetken et al., 2001; Performed in contrast with OECD Draft
Guideline 218, artificial sediment with a coarse grain size (100-2,000 μm) and other
carbon sources (stinging-nettle and leaves of alder). EINECS states that the results
for total emergence and emergence rate were not considered valid for the purpose
of risk assessment due to the large variations in solvent control.)
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18 US EPA: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD)).
4.2.3 Honeybees and Not available.
other arthropods
4.2.4 Earthworms Long-term toxicity of hexabromocyclododecane to earthworms has been assessed
by ABC (2003), who measured survival and reproduction in Eisenia fetida
(clittelate adults) following 56-day exposure to a technical
hexabromocyclododecane mixture. Hexabromocyclododecane was mixed dry into
31
artificial soil media at concentrations of 78.5 to 5,000 mg/kg dry soil weight. In this
study, the NOEC for survival and reproduction for hexabromocyclododecane were
determined to be 4,190 and 128 mg/kg dry soil respectively. The NOEC for
reproduction was later recalculated to 59 mg/kg dry soil weight because the soil
that was used contained a higher amount of organic matter than standard soil (NCM
2008).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4.2.5 Soil For effects of hexabromocyclododecane on soil micro-organisms, the only
microorganisms conducted study reports a NOEC of ≥ 750 mg/kg dw using nitrate production as an
endpoint for assessment (ECT 2007).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.2 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
4.2.6 Terrestrial Not available.
plants
5 Environmental Exposure/Risk Evaluation
5.1 Terrestrial Collectively, the findings from studies suggest that there is reason for concern of
vertebrates reproductive and developmental effects in wild birds, because the 800 ng/g wwt
dose that elicited effects in the studies by Marteinson and Fernie (see BFR 2009 for
overview) are similar to what have previously been observed in wild birds in
Central Europe and the Norwegian Arctic, i.e., (cormorant (liver): 138-1,320 ng/g
lw and tern (egg): 330-7100 ng/g lw (Morris et al. 2004); glaucous gulls
(liver):195-15,027 ng/g lw and great black- backed gulls (liver): 1,881 - 3,699 ng/g
lw (KLIF 2007); glaucous gulls (liver): 75.6 ng/g wwt (Verreault et al. 2007).
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.3 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
Further indications for concern come from recent preliminary data obtained with
captive American kestrels which suggest a risk for reproductive and developmental
effects in source regions. The findings from Marteinson et al. (Dioxin 200910c) and
Fernie et al. (Dioxin 2010cb) suggest that there is reason for concern of
reproductive and developmental effects in wild birds, not only because of the
seasonal changes in fat stores experienced by wild birds and the observed transfer
to eggs, but also because the 800 ng/g wwt dose and the subsequent in ovo
hexabromocyclododecane concentrations that elicited effects in these studies are
similar to what has previously been observed in wild birds in Central Europe, i.e.,
cormorant liver, 138-1,320 ng/g lw; and, tern eggs, 330-7100 ng/g lw (Morris et al.
2004). In the study, administration of 800 ng/g wwt of technical
hexabromocyclododecane formulation in safflower oil for 21 days followed by a
25-day depuration period, resulted in environmentally relevant internal doses, i.e.,
the sum of hexabromocyclododecane isomers, 934.8 ng/g lw (20 ng/g ww) in liver;
and, 4216.2 ng/g lw (181. 5 ng/g ww) in eggs (with the level of
α-hexabromocyclododecane being 164 ng/g wwt in eggs) (BFR 2009b; SETAC
2009).
Endocrine disruptor effects may arise from low dose exposure and are highly
dependent on the timing of exposure (WHO and IPCS, 2002). The study on
American kestrels (BFR 2009b; Dioxin 2010c) also suggests a risk for reproductive
and developmental effects in wild birds in remote regions, where the internal doses
(164 ng/g wwt of α-hexabromocyclododecane) that elicited effects in the studies by
Marteinson and Fernie (BFR 2009b) is exceeded by internal doses observed in wild
birds in the Norwegian Arctic, i.e. glaucous gulls (liver), 195-15,027 ng/g lw; and,
great black- backed gulls (liver), 1,881 - 3,699 ng/g lw (KLIF 2007); glaucous gulls
(liver): 75.6 ng/g wwt (Verreault et al. 2007). Muir et al. (2004) detected
hexabromocyclododecane isomers in concentrations in the blubber of beluga
whales (Delphinapterus leucas) in the Canadian Arctic in 2001, a species protected
by the Convention on migratory species. The concentrations were in the range of
9.8-18 ng/g lw. Muir et al. (2006) detected levels of hexabromocyclododecane in
adipose tissue of polar bears (Ursus maritimus) in several populations in the Arctic
region in 2002. The highest levels were detected in the female bears from the
32
Svalbard area (109 ng/g lw). Effects on polar bears and other marine mammals
were not investigated in these studies.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.6 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
5.2 Aquatic species A comparison of measured concentrations in the tissues and organs of species of
prey (fish) with the predicted no-effect concentration (PNEC) for secondary
poisoning for hexabromocyclododecane reveals that the concentrations in fish
exceed the PNEC of 5 mg/kg food for predators (mammals and birds) both near
local point-sources and source regions. In the vicinity of point sources such as the
river Skerne in the UK and the river Scheldt basin in Belgium,
hexabromocyclododecane concentrations above 5 mg/kg wwt have been measured
in fish (eel and brown trout). Also in marine mammals, concentrations higher than
the PNEC have been measured, the highest being 6.4 mg/kg wwt whole body
weight in harbour porpoise from the UK (European Union 2008). The potential risk
of hexabromocyclododecane to wild life near local point-sources and source
regions is further supported by the body/tissue residue based risk assessment made
by EBFRIP (2009b). Notably the upper third of the monitoring data used in the
assessment exceeds the specific-toxicity residue-based PNEC for freshwater fish
and for mammals. The upper limit of the monitoring data for birds also enters this
range.
Hexabromocyclododecane has been detected in many Arctic species (invertebrates,
birds, fish, terrestrial and marine mammals). Levels in Polar cod from Svalbard
(Arctic Norway) have been reported at 1.38-2.87 ng/g lipid weight (see levels and
effects tables in UNEP/POPS/POPRC.6/INF/25). The findings of
hexabromocyclododecane in fish in remote regions suggest a potential for
endocrine effects considering the laboratory studies done by Lower and More
(2007), Palace et al. (2008 and 2010) showing effect on the thyroid axis for salmoid
fish.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.6 of the POPRC Risk Profile).
5.3 Honey bees Not available.
5.4 Earthworms Not available.
5.5 Soil Not available.
microorganisms
5.6 Summary – Hexabromocyclododecane is persistent in the environment and has a strong
overall risk potential to bioaccumulate and biomagnify in food chains.
evaluation α-hexabromocyclododecane appears to be the more persistent of the isomers of
hexabromocyclododecane and to biomagnify more than
-hexabromocyclododecane and γ-hexabromocyclododecane.
Hexabromocyclododecane is widespread in the global environment and biota;
elevated levels are found in top predators and other threatened species in the Arctic.
Releases of hexabromocyclododecane to the environment are increasing in all
regions investigated. The increasing standing masses of construction materials are
potentially long-term sources of hexabromocyclododecane to the environment, as
well as representing larger releases when demolished or renovated in the future.
Releases during recycling of construction materials and electronic appliances can
be of importance and are likely to increase in the future. A general trend seems to
be that α-hexabromocyclododecane dominates in the upper trophic levels while the
main isomer in the lower levels appears to be γ-hexabromocyclododecane. In
human tissue α-hexabromocyclododecane seems to predominate in the general
population. Most toxicological studies with hexabromocyclododecane focus on
hexabromocyclododecane mixtures and the available data on stereoisomer specific
toxicity is very limited.
Hexabromocyclododecane is considered very toxic to aquatic organisms. There is a
risk of adverse effects in marine mammals and fish in the vicinity of point sources
and in regions with elevated background levels. The measured concentration levels
in biota exceed the PNEC for secondary effects of 5 mg/kg wwt in the EU risk
assessment of hexabromocyclododecane (European Union 2008). Levels in birds
from European regions with elevated back ground levels or near local point sources
33
are concluded to lie near the threshold levels for adverse effects. In avian species,
preliminary data from recent studies report effects such as reduced eggshell
thickness, growth and survival. Further indications for concern come from recent
preliminary data obtained with captive American kestrels which suggest a risk for
reproductive and developmental effects also in wild birds in remote regions.
Both older and recent available literature suggest that hexabromocyclododecane
can induce effects in mammals and that both chronic and subchronic, high and low
dose exposure to hexabromocyclododecane may have wide ranging and potentially
severe effects, particularly to the neuroendocrine system and to offspring during
early phases of development. Hexabromocyclododecane has a potential to interfere
with the hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid (HPT) axis and cause reproductive and
developmental effects. Many effects were trans-generational and affected both
parents and offspring. Hexabromocyclododecane is maternally transferred to
offspring, both in humans and in wildlife.
In addition to the findings in the in vivo animal studies, there are a large number of
recent in vitro studies that document how hexabromocyclododecane upon
adsorption may act on, and possibly interfere with biological processes such as cell
homeostasis, protein repair, metabolism, intracellular signalling and
neuroendocrine processes. Such studies add to the understanding that exposure to
hexabromocyclododecane has various effects on human health and the
environment, and should also be regarded when considering the toxicity of
hexabromocyclododecane.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 3 of the POPRC Risk Profile)
34
Annex 2 – Details on final regulatory actions reported
Country Name: Japan
1 Effective date(s) of 1 May 2014
entry into force of
actions
Reference to the The Chemical Substances Control Law (CSCL) and its Enforcement Order.
regulatory
document
2 Succinct details of This chemical is designated as a Class I Specified Chemical Substance. It is
the final prohibited to manufacture, import or use this chemical substance.
regulatory
action(s)
3 Reasons for action The regulatory action was based on concerns related to human health.
4 Basis for inclusion The regulatory action was taken to protect human health. The regulatory action was
into Annex III based on a risk evaluation taking into account the prevailing conditions in Japan.
4.1 Risk evaluation This chemical is persistent, highly bioaccumulative and has long-term toxicity to
humans. (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 Section 2.4.2.1 of the Japanese notification)
When a substance is listed to the Stockholm Convention, and when it is on the market
in Japan, the Japanese Government conducts a risk evaluation on the substance and its
potential risks to inform the regulatory measures. This internal risk evaluation, in
combination with the Risk Profile document for hexabromocyclododecane, were
supplied as supporting information by Japan in document
UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2. A brief English summary of that domestic
risk evaluation was provided along with the table of contents of the risk evaluation.
The internal risk evaluation was based on the monitoring data from fiscal year 2009 to
fiscal year 2012 and revealed a number of sites with a high ecological risk, while
there were no sites with any human health risk. The risk evaluation included a hazard
assessment, an exposure assessment and risk estimation based on monitoring data,
and an exposure assessment and risk estimation based on environmental releases
estimated from manufacture data.
The notification from Japan indicates that the regulatory action was based on a risk or
hazard evaluation and specifically cites the Risk Profile document for
hexabromocyclododecane as prepared by the POPRC (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8
section 2.4.1 of the Japanese notification). The POPRC document cites a Japanese
study (Kakimoto et al. 2008) which found hexabromocyclododecane levels in human
milk appear to mirror the market consumption of hexabromocyclododecane. In
mothers’ milk from Japanese women (age 25–29) hexabromocyclododecane levels
were below the detection limit in all samples collected during the 10-year period from
1973-1983, but then increased from 1988 onwards. In the period 1988-2006, α-
hexabromocyclododecane was detected in all 11 pooled milk samples with levels
ranging from 0.4-1.9 ng/g lw. Mean total hexabromocyclododecane concentrations
over the period 2000 – 2006 ranged from 1-4 ng/g lw.
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.3.2 of the Risk Profile document)
The Risk Profile document states the developmental- and neurotoxic potential of
hexabromocyclododecane observed in animal studies give cause for concern when
considering risks to human health, particularly for unborn babies and young children
(UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/17/Rev.2 section 2.4.6 of the Risk Profile document).
4.2 Criteria used Risk to human health.
Relevance to other The notifying Party did not provide information on the relevance to other States and
States and Region Regions.
35
5 Alternatives The notifying Party did not provide information on alternatives to
hexabromocyclododecane.
6 Waste The notifying Party did not provide information on waste management of
management hexabromocyclododecane or articles containing it.
7 Other None.
36
Country Name: Norway
1 Effective date(s) of 9 July 2016
entry into force of
actions
Reference to the Hexabromocyclododecane is regulated by Chapter 4 of the Regulation related to
regulatory restrictions on the manufacture, import and placing on the market of chemicals and
document other products hazardous to human health and the environment (Product Regulation)
act no. 922 of June 2004. This is the Norwegian implementation of Regulation (EC)
No 850/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council on persistent organic
pollutants and the implementation of the amendment to its Annex I, Commission
Regulation (EU) 2016/293 of 1 March 2016.
2 Succinct details of Regulations to restrict production, import, export and sale of consumer products that
the final contain hexabromocyclododecane exceeding certain limit values.
regulatory
action(s)
3 Reasons for action The regulatory action was based on concerns related to human health and the
environment.
4 Basis for inclusion The final regulatory action was taken to protect human health and the environment.
into Annex III The regulatory action was based on a risk evaluation taking into account the
prevailing conditions in Norway.
4.1 Risk evaluation The notification from Norway indicates that the regulatory action was based on a risk
or hazard evaluation and that it was relevant to both human health and the
Environment. The notification specifically cites the European Union Risk assessment
for hexabromocyclododecane (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/8 section 2.4 of the
Norwegian notification). Summarized in the body of the notification from Norway is
evidence of exposure to consumers in Norway, its detection in the environment
(including remote areas of the arctic), biota, fish, moss, yolk sac of newly hatched
chicks. Some temporal trends are noted such as the increase in
hexabromocyclododecane levels in eggs from Atlantic puffins and Atlantic cod liver.
The abstracts of the scientific articles presented in the supporting information from
Norway (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18) confirm the occurrence of
hexabromocyclododecane in the environment and biota in Norway and its
surroundings, and some cases of increasing concentrations over time.
Hazard endpoints identified in the United States Environmental Protection Agency
2014 report, Flame Retardant Alternatives for Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) are
also provided in the supporting information from Norway. High or very high hazards
are noted for developmental effects, acute aquatic toxicity, and chronic aquatic
toxicity. Hexabromocyclododecane is highly persistent and has very high
bioaccumulation. (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/18)
4.2 Criteria used Risk to human health and the environment.
Relevance to other The Stockholm Convention has agreed on listing hexabromocyclododecane in Annex
States and Region A (ban), with exemptions for production and use in expanded polystyrene and
extruded polystyrene in buildings. The global ban was introduced 26 of November
2014.
5 Alternatives The notifying Party provided the US EPA document: United States Environmental
Protection Agency: Flame Retardant Alternatives for Hexabromocyclododecane
(HBCD). Final report June 2014.
6 Waste The notifying Party did not provide information on waste management of
management hexabromocyclododecane or articles containing it.
7 Other None.
37
Annex 3 – Addresses of designated national authorities
Japan
CP
From PIC Website (20 November 2017):
Name: Mr. Kentaro Mizuuchi Phone: +81 3 5501 8245
Job title: Deputy Director Fax: +81 3 5501 8244
Department: Global Environment Division / International Email:
[email protected]
Cooperation Bureau
Institution: Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Postal address: 2-2-1 Kasumigaseki, Chiyoda-ku
100-8919 Tokyo
Japan
Norway
C
From PIC Website (20 November 2017):
Name: Ms. Christel Moræus Olsen Phone: +47 735 80 500
Job title: Senior Advisor, Rotterdam Convention Designated Fax: +47 735 80 501
National Authority for Industrial Chemicals and Biocides Email:
[email protected];
Institution: Norwegian Environment Agency
[email protected]
Postal address: Grensesvingen 7
0661 Oslo
Norway
C Industrial chemicals
CP Pesticides and industrial chemicals
38
Annex 4 – References
Regulatory actions
Japan
The Chemical Substances Control Law (CSCL) and its Enforcement Order.
Norway
Hexabromocyclododecane is regulated by Chapter 4 of the Regulation related to restrictions on the manufacture,
import and placing on the market of chemicals and other products hazardous to human health and the environment
(Product Regulation) act no. 922 of June 2004. This is the Norwegian implementation of Regulation (EC) No
850/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council on persistent organic pollutants and the implementation of
the amendment to its Annex I, Commission Regulation (EU) 2016/293 of 1 March 2016.
Supporting documentation provided by Japan
• POPRC (2010). Risk profile on hexabromocyclododecane. UNEP/POPS/POPRC.6/13/Add.2
• Environmental risk evaluation of hexabromocyclododecane, Ministry of Environment, Japan, October
2013. (The report is in Japanese. An informal English summary and a translation of the table of contents of
the report are provided)
Supporting documentation provided by Norway
• European Union: Risk assessment hexabromocyclododecane, CAS-No.: 25637-99-4, EINECS No.: 247-
148-4, Final Report May 2008. 492 pp.
• US EPA, United States Environmental Protection Agency: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD). Final report June 2014.
• Heeb NV, Schweizer WB, Kohler M and Gerecke AC. Structure elucidation of hexabromocyclododecanes
- a class of compounds with a complex stereochemistry. Chemosphere 2005; 61: 65-73.
• Bytingsvik J, Gaustad H, Pettersvik-Salmer M, Soermo EG, Baek K, Föreid S, Ruus A, Skaare JU and
Jenssen BM. Spatial and temporal trends of BFRs in Atlantic cod and Polar cod in the North-East Atlantic.
Organohalogen Compounds 2004; 66: 3869-3873.
• Christensen GN, Evenset A, Zaborska A, Berger U and Carroll J. Datering av sediment og historisk
utvikling av miljøgifter i Ellasjøen, Bjørnøya. Akvaplan-niva rapport. 2004; APN-514.2934, pp 35 pp.
Akvaplan-niva, Tromsø, Norge.
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/overvaking/2041/ta2041.pdf Note: The above
article is in Norwegian language with a Summary in English in page 5 of the article.
• Fjeld E, Rognerud S, Enge E, Borgen A and Dye C. Miljogifter i sedimenter fra Mjosa, 2005-2006. Norsk
institutt for vannforskning Statlig program for forureningsovervåkning TA-2210/2006 2006b;
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/2210/ta2210.pdf Note: The above article is in
Norwegian language with an Extended Abstract in English in page 4 of the article.
• Fjeld E, Schlabach M, Berge JA, Green N, Eggen T, Snilsberg P, Källberg G, Rognerud S, Enge EK,
Borgen A and Gundersen H. Screening of selected new organic contaminants - brominated flame
retardants, chlorinated paraffins, bisphenol A and triclosan. 2004; 4809-2004, pp 117 pp. NIVA, Norge.
(Only Section 2: “Extended abstract” is included in this compilation).
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/kjemikalier/2006/ta2006.pdf
• Fjeld E, Schlabach M, Berge JA, Green N, Eggen T, Snilsberg P, Vogelsang C, Rognerud S, Kjellberg G,
Enge EK, Dye C and Gundersen H. Bromerte flammehemmere, perfluoralkylstoffer, irgarol, diuron, BHT
og dicofol. Kartlegging av utvalgte nye organiske miljøgifter 2004. 2005; 927, pp 105 pp. NIVA, Norge.
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/overvaking/2096/ta2096.pdf Note: The above
article is in Norwegian language with an Extended Abstract in English in page 17 of the article.
• Fjeld E, Schlabach M, Rognerud S, Källberg G, NIVA, NILU. Miljøgifter i sedimenter og fisk i Mjøsa,
Drammensvassdraget og Drammensfjorden, Oppfølgende undersøkelser i 2004. 2006; pp 7. Norsk institutt
for vannforskning, Norge.
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/overvaking/2051/ta2051.pdf Note: The above
article is in Norwegian language with a Summary in English in page 6 of the article.
39
• Gabrielsen GW, Knudsen LB, Verreault J, Push K, Muir DDC and Letcher RJ. Halogenated organic
contaminants and metabolites in blood and adipose tissues of polar bears (Ursus maritimus) from
Svalbard. SPFO-Report. 2004; 915/2004, pp 32pp. Norwegian Polar Institute, Tromsø, Norway.
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/overvaking/2058/ta2058.pdf
• Jenssen BM, Sørmo EG, Salmer MP, Bæk K and Skaare JU. Brominated flame retardants (BFRs) in the
Arctic marine food chain. In The Third International Workshop on Brominated Flame Retardants - BFR
2004. Book of abstracts. Edited by Alaee M and et al. 2004; pp 207-208.
• Knudsen LB, Gabrielsen GW, Verreault J, Barrett R, Skåre JU, Polder A and Lie E. Temporal trends of
brominated flame retardants, cyclodeca-1,5,9-triene and mercury in eggs of four seabird species from
Northern Norway and Svalbard. SPFO-Report. 2005; 942/2005, pp 43 pp. Norwegian Polar Institute,
Tromsø, Norway. http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/overvaking/2134/ta2134.pdf
• Murvoll KM, Skaare JU, Anderssen E and Jenssen BM. Exposure and effects of persistent organic
pollutants in European shag (Phalaceocorax aristotelis) hatchlings from the coast of Norway. Environ
Toxicol Chem 2006; 25 (1): 190-198. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1897/04-333R.1/epdf
• Odland JØ, Heimstad ES and Sandanger TM. Kartlegging av miljøgifter i humane blodprøver fra Taimyr,
Russland og Bodø, Norge - en pilotstudie av "nye" miljøgifter. Assessment of “new” contaminants in
human blood samples from Taimyr, Russia and Bodø, Norway – a pilot study. 2005; SPFO-rapport:
930/2005, Statens forurensningstilsyn, Oslo, Norway.
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/overvaking/2103/2103.pdf Note: The above article
is in Norwegian language with a Summary in English in page 29 of the article.
• Schlabach M, Fjeld E and Borgen AR. Brominated flame retardants in Drammens river and the
Drammensfjord, Norway. In The Third International Workshop on Brominated Flame Retardants - BFR
2004. Book of abstracts. Edited by Alaee M and et al. 2004; pp 147-150.
• Schlabach M, Mariussen E, Borgen A, Dye C, Enge E-K, Steinnes E, Green N and Mohn H. Kartlegging
av bromerte flammehemmere og klorerte parafiner. 2002; 866/02, pp pp 69. SFT - Statlig program for
forurensningsovervåking, NILU - Norsk institutt for luftforskning, Oslo, Kjeller, Norway.
http://www.miljodirektoratet.no/old/klif/publikasjoner/overvaking/1924/ta1924.pdf Note: The above
article is in Norwegian language with an Abstract in English in page 70 of the article.
• Sørmo EG, Salmer MP, Jenssen BM, Hop H, Baek K, Kovacs KM, Lydersen C, Falk-Petersen S,
Gabrielsen GW, Lie E, Skaare JU. Biomagnification of polybrominated diphenyl ether and
hexabromocyclododecane flame retardants in the polar bear food chain in Svalbard, Norway. Environ
Toxicol Chem 2006; 25(9): 2502-2511. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/wol1/doi/10.1897/05-
591R.1/abstract
• Thomsen C, Frøshaug M, Leknes H and Becher G. Brominated flame retardants in breast milk from
Norway. Organohalogen compounds 2003; 64: http://www.dioxin20xx.org/pdfs/2003/03-527.pdf
• US EPA, United States Environmental Protection Agency: Flame Retardant Alternatives for
Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD). Final report June 2014.
https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2014-06/documents/hbcd_report.pdf
Other Documents
POPRC (2011). Risk management evaluation on hexabromocyclododecane. UNEP/POPS/POPRC.7/19/Add.1.
POPRC (2012). Addendum to the risk management evaluation on hexabromocyclododecane.
UNEP/POPS/POPRC.8/16/Add.3.
Relevant guidelines and reference documents
IPCS (2001): Hexabromocyclododecane (mixture of isomers). International Chemical Safety Card (ICSC) 1413.
Available at: http://www.inchem.org/documents/icsc/icsc/eics1413.htm
United Nations (2013): UN Recommendations on the Transport of Dangerous Goods - Model Regulations,
Eighteenth revised edition. Available at: http://www.unece.org/trans/danger/publi/unrec/rev18/18files_e.html
IMO (2016): International Maritime Dangerous Goods Code (IMDG Code). Available at:
http://www.imo.org/en/Publications/IMDGCode/Pages/Default.aspx
OSPAR Commission (2009). OSPAR Background Document on certain brominated flame retardants. Available at:
https://www.ospar.org/documents?d=7202
40
FORM FOR IMPORT RESPONSE
Country:
SECTION 1 IDENTITY OF CHEMICAL
1.1 Common name
1.2 CAS number
1.3 Category Pesticide
Industrial
Severely hazardous pesticide formulation
SECTION 2 INDICATION REGARDING PREVIOUS RESPONSE, IF ANY
2.1 This is a first tim e im port response for this chemical in the country.
2.2 This is a modification of a previous response.
Date of issue of the previous response: ..........................................................
SECTION 3 RESPONSE REGARDING FUTURE IMPORT
Final decision (Fill in section 4 below) OR Interim response (Fill in section 5 below)
SECTION 4 FINAL DECISION, PURSUANT TO NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE OR
ADMINISTRATIVE MEASURES
4.1 No consent to import
Is the import of the chemical from all sources
Yes No
sim ultaneously prohibited?
Is domestic pr oduction of the chemical for domestic use Yes No
sim ultaneously prohibited?
4.2 Consent to import
4.3 Consent to import only subject to specified conditions
The specified conditions are:
Are the conditions for import of the chemical the same for Yes No
all sources of import?
Are the conditions for dom estic production of the chem ical Yes No
for domestic use the same as for all im ports ?
4.4 National legislative or administrative measure upon which the final decision
is based
Description of the national legislative or adm inistrative measure:
SECTION 5 INTERIM RESPONSE
5.1 No consent to import
Is the import of the chemical from all sources
Yes No
sim ultaneously prohibited?
Is domestic production of the chemical for domestic use
Yes No
sim ultaneously prohibited?
5.2 Consent to import
Form for import response Page 2
5.3 Consent to import only subject to specified conditions
The specified conditions are:
Are the conditions for import of the chemical the same for Yes No
all sources of import?
Are the conditions for dom estic production of the chem ical Yes No
for domestic use the same as for all im ports?
5.4 Indication of active consideration in order to reach a final decision
Is a final decision under active consideration? Yes No
5.5 Information or assistance requested in order to reach a final decision
The following additional inform ation is reque sted from the Secretariat:
The following additional inform ation is requested from the country that notified
the final regulatory action:
The following assistance is requested from the Secretariat in evaluating the
chem ical:
SECTION 6 RELEVANT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, WHICH MAY INCLUDE:
Is this chemical currently registered in the country? Yes No
Is this chemical manufactured in the country? Yes No
Form for import response Page 3
If yes to either one of these questions:
Is this intended for domestic use? Yes No
Is this intended for export? Yes No
Other remarks
SECTION 7 DESIGNATED NATIONAL AUTHORITY
Institution
Address
Nam e of person in charge
Position of person in charge
Telephone
Telefax
E-m ail address
Date, signature of DNA and official seal: ___________________________________
PLEASE RETURN THE COMPLETED FORM TO:
Secretariat for the Rotterdam Convention Secretariat for the Rotterdam Convention
Food and Agriculture Organization United Nations Environment
of the United Nations (FAO) Programme (UNEP)
Viale delle Terme di Caracalla 11-13, Chemin des Anémones
OR
00153 Rome, Italy CH – 1219 Châtelaine, Geneva, Switzerland
Tel: (+39 06) 5705 2188 Tel: (+41 22) 917 8296
Fax: (+39 06) 5705 3224 Fax: (+41 22) 917 8082
E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected]
Form for import response Page 4
Saatja: BRS Secretariat (No-Reply) <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 16.09.2019 16:51
Teema: o Rotterdam Convention communication - Decision Guidance Documents and the
request for submission of import responses for hexabromocyclododecane and phorate
Manused: Encl 3_IR_simple word form_E.DOC; RC_DGD_Import response letter_16 Sept
2019_EN.pdf; CN.397.2019-Eng_Rotterdam Convention Annex III amendments 2019.pdf;
DGD_HBCD_En.pdf; DGD_Phorate_En.pdf; Encl 3_IR instructions E.PDF
Dear Designated National Authority,
Please find attached a letter from the Executive Secretaries of the Rotterdam Convention related to the
dispatch of Decision Guidance Documents and the request for submission of import responses on
hexabromocyclododecane and phorate.
Best regards,
Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention
Rotterdam Convention
Operation of the prior informed consent procedure
for banned or severely restricted chemicals
Decision Guidance Document
Phorate
Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention
on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure
for Certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides
in International Trade
280619
Introduction
The objective of the Rotterdam Convention is to promote shared responsibility and cooperative efforts
among Parties in the international trade of certain hazardous chemicals in order to protect human
health and the environment from potential harm and to contribute to their environmentally sound use,
by facilitating information exchange about their characteristics, by providing for a national decision-
making process on their import and export and by disseminating these decisions to Parties. The
Secretariat of the Convention is provided jointly by the United Nations Environment Programme
(UNEP) and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO).
Candidate chemicals1 for inclusion in the prior informed consent (PIC) procedure under the Rotterdam
Convention include those that have been banned or severely restricted by national regulatory actions in
two or more Parties2 in two different regions. Inclusion of a chemical in the PIC procedure is based on
regulatory actions taken by Parties that have addressed the risks associated with the chemical by
banning or severely restricting it. Other ways might be available to control or reduce such risks.
Inclusion does not, however, imply that all Parties to the Convention have banned or severely
restricted the chemical. For each chemical included in Annex III of the Rotterdam Convention and
subject to the PIC procedure, Parties are requested to make an informed decision whether they consent
or not to the future import of the chemical.
At its ninth meeting, held in Geneva from 29 April to 10 May 2019, the Conference of the Parties
agreed to list phorate in Annex III of the Convention and adopted the decision-guidance document
with the effect that this chemical became subject to the PIC procedure.
The present decision-guidance document was communicated to designated national authorities on
16 September 2019, in accordance with Articles 7 and 10 of the Rotterdam Convention.
Purpose of the decision guidance document
For each chemical included in Annex III of the Rotterdam Convention, a decision-guidance document
has been approved by the Conference of the Parties. Decision-guidance documents are sent to all
Parties with a request that they make a decision regarding future import of the chemical.
Decision-guidance documents are prepared by the Chemical Review Committee. The Committee is a
group of government-designated experts established in line with Article 18 of the Convention, which
evaluates candidate chemicals for possible inclusion in Annex III of the Convention. Decision-
guidance documents reflect the information provided by two or more Parties in support of their
national regulatory actions to ban or severely restrict the chemical. They are not intended as the only
source of information on a chemical nor are they updated or revised following their adoption by the
Conference of the Parties.
There may be additional Parties that have taken regulatory actions to ban or severely restrict the
chemical and others that have not banned or severely restricted it. Risk evaluations or information on
alternative risk mitigation measures submitted by such Parties may be found on the Rotterdam
Convention website (www.pic.int).
Under Article 14 of the Convention, Parties can exchange scientific, technical, economic and legal
information concerning the chemicals under the scope of the Convention including toxicological,
ecotoxicological and safety information. This information may be provided directly to other Parties or
through the Secretariat. Information provided to the Secretariat will be posted on the Rotterdam
Convention website.
Information on the chemical may also be available from other sources.
Disclaimer
The use of trade names in the present document is primarily intended to facilitate the correct
identification of the chemical. It is not intended to imply any approval or disapproval of any particular
company. As it is not possible to include all trade names presently in use, only a number of commonly
used and published trade names have been included in the document.
1
According to the Convention, the term “chemical” means a substance, whether by itself or in a mixture or
preparation and whether manufactured or obtained from nature, but does not include any living organism. It
consists of the following categories: pesticide (including severely hazardous pesticide formulations) and
industrial.
2
According to the Convention, the term “Party” means a State or regional economic integration organization that
has consented to be bound by the Convention and for which the Convention is in force.
2
While the information provided is believed to be accurate according to data available at the time of
preparation of the present decision-guidance document, FAO and UNEP disclaim any responsibility
for omissions or any consequences that may arise there from. Neither FAO nor UNEP shall be liable
for any injury, loss, damage or prejudice of any kind that may be suffered as a result of importing or
prohibiting the import of this chemical.
The designations employed and the presentation of material in this publication do not imply the
expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of FAO or UNEP concerning the legal status of any
country, territory, city or area or of its authorities or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or
boundaries.
3
Standard core set of abbreviations3
STANDARD CORE SET OF ABBREVIATIONS
< less than
< less than or equal to
> greater than
> greater than or equal to
µg Microgram
m Micrometre
ARfD acute reference dose
a.i. active ingredient
ADI acceptable daily intake
ANVISA National Health Surveillance Agency of Brazil
AOEL acceptable operator exposure level
b.p. boiling point
bw body weight
o
C degree Celsius (centigrade)
CAS Chemical Abstracts Service
cc cubic centimetre
cm Centimetre
DNA deoxyribose nucleic acid
DT50 dissipation time 50%
EC European Community
EC50 median effective concentration
ED50 median effective dose
EEC European Economic Community
EHC Environmental Health Criteria
EU European Union
FAO Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
g Gram
h Hour
ha Hectare
i.m. Intramuscular
i.p. Intraperitoneal
IARC International Agency for Research on Cancer
IC50 median inhibitory concentration
IBAMA Brazilian Institute for the Environment and the Renewable Resources
ILO International Labour Organization
IPCS International Programme on Chemical Safety
IPM Integrated Pest Management
IUPAC International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry
JMPR Joint FAO/WHO Meeting on Pesticide Residues (Joint Meeting of the FAO Panel of
Experts on Pesticide Residues in Food and the Environment and a WHO Expert Group on
Pesticide Residues)
3
This core list should serve as the basis for DGDs for industrial chemicals, pesticides and severely hazardous
pesticide formulations. It should be augmented by abbreviations used in the individual DGDs relevant to the
chemical(s) in question.
Definitions and spelling should, as far as practicable, follow the IUPAC glossary of terms in toxicology and the
IUPAC glossary of terms relating to pesticides in their current editions.
As a general rule it is preferable that acronyms used only once in the text be spelled out rather than included in
the list of abbreviations.
4
STANDARD CORE SET OF ABBREVIATIONS
k kilo- (x 1000)
kg Kilogram
Koc soil organic partition coefficient.
Kow octanol–water partition coefficient
kPa Kilopascal
L Litre
LC50 median lethal concentration
LD50 median lethal dose
LOAEL lowest-observed-adverse-effect level
LOEL Lowest-observed-effect level
MAPA Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Food Supply
m Metre
m.p. melting point
mg Milligram
ml Millilitre
MOE Margin of Exposure
mPa Millipascal
MRL maximum residue limit
MTD Maximum Tolerated Dose
ng Nanogram
NOAEC no-observed-adverse-effect concentration
NOAEL no-observed-adverse-effect level
NOEC no-observed-effect concentration
NOEL no-observed-effect level
OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
PEC Predicted environmental concentration
PMRA Pest Management Regulatory Agency, Canada
Pow octanol-water partition coefficient, also referred to as Kow
PPE personal protective equipment
ppm parts per million (used only with reference to the concentration of a pesticide in an
experimental diet. In all other contexts the terms mg/kg or mg/L are used).
RfD reference dose (for chronic oral exposure; comparable to ADI)
SMR standard(ized) mortality ratio
STEL short-term exposure limit
TER toxicity exposure ratio
TLV threshold limit value
TWA time-weighted average
UNEP United Nations Environment Programme
USEPA United States Environmental Protection Agency
UV Ultraviolet
VOC volatile organic compound
w/w weight for weight
WHO World Health Organization
wt Weight
5
Decision guidance document for a banned or severely restricted chemical
Phorate Published: September 2019
1. Identification and uses (see Annex 1 for further details)
Common name: Phorate
Chemical name and IUPAC: O,O-diethyl S-ethylthiomethyl phosphorodithioate;
other names or diethyl {[(ethylsulfanyl)methyl]sulfanyl}(sulfanylidene)phosphonate;
synonyms CAS: O,O-diethyl S-[(ethylthio)methyl]phosphorodithioate.
Also: O,O-diethyl S-[(ethylthio)methyl]ester of phosphorodithioic acid;
phosphorodithioic acid, O,O-diethyl S-(ethylthio)methylester;
O,O-diethyl S-ethylmercaptomethyl phosphorodithioate.
Manufacturers Code names: AC 8911, CL 35,024; EI 3911; AC 3911; ENT 24042
Molecular formula C7H17O2PS3
Chemical structure
CAS-No.(s) 298-02-2
Harmonized System
Customs Code
Other numbers EC No.: 206-052-2, OSHA IMIS Code Number: 2064, Caswell Number 660, CCOHS
Record Number 502, RCRA Waste Number TD9450000
Category Pesticide
Regulated category Pesticide
Use(s) in regulated Phorate was authorized in Brazil as an insecticide exclusively for agricultural use in
category cotton, potatoes, coffee, beans and corn.
Phorate is a systemic insecticide, which at the time of regulatory action was registered in
Canada for use on potatoes, beans, corn, lettuce and rutabagas.
Trade names Trade names listed by Brazil: Granutox and Granutox 150 G.
Trade names listed by Canada at the time of regulatory action: Thimet 15G Soil &
Systemic Insecticide Granular.
Other trade names: (manufacturer indicated in brackets): Thimet 15G Soil & Systemic
Insecticide, Cecurafox (Cequisa), Dhan (Dhanuka), Granural, Granutox, Granutox 150
G; Kurunal (Ramcides), Umet (United Phosphorus), Volphor (Voltas), Warrant (Searle
India), Agromet, Geomet, Phorate 10G, Rampart, Thimenox, Thimet (Cyanamid),
Vegfru Foratox, Timet and Vegfru.
This is an indicative list of trade names. It is not intended to be exhaustive.
Formulation types Granutox and Granutox 150 G are granules. The Canadian notification indicates type
“G”: granular.
Uses in other There is no reported use as an industrial chemical.
categories
Basic manufacturers AMVAC Chemical Corporation, BASF, Paramount Pesticides Ltd., Insecticides (India)
Ltd., P. I. Industries Ltd., Gujarat Pesticides Pvt. Ltd., Vimal Crop Care Pvt. Ltd.,
Modern Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., Sanova Pharma Chem Pvt. Ltd., Prime Agro Industries Pvt.
Ltd., , Insecticides India Ltd., Sudarshan Fertilisers, Sunray Chemical Industries, Trans
Yamuna Fertilizers Pvt. Ltd., P. I. Industries Limited, Balaa Pesticides, Jai Chemicals
6
(source: e-World Trade Fair), American Cyanamid Co. One Cyanamid Plaza (source:
Toxnet, 2017), United Phosphorus, Cequisa, Dhanuka, Ramcides, Voltas, Searle India
(Pesticide Manual 11th edition in (UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1)).
This is an indicative list of current and former manufacturers. It is not intended to be
exhaustive.
2. Reasons for inclusion in the PIC procedure
Phorate is included in the PIC procedure as a pesticide. It has been listed on the basis of the final regulatory
actions to ban its use, notified by Brazil, and to severely restrict its use, notified by Canada.
2.1 Final regulatory action (see Annex 2 for further details)
Brazil
According to the Law No. 7.802/89 (pesticide Law), the legal reference for pesticide management, regulated by
Decree No 4.074/02, no pesticide shall be manufactured, imported, exported, traded or used unless it has been
registered in Brazil.
Resolution RDC No. 12 of 13 March 2015, issued by the National Health Surveillance Agency (ANVISA),
prohibits the use of all technical and formulated products based on the phorate active ingredient in Brazil.
Therefore, the production, use, trade, import and export of products based on phorate was banned. The Resolution
cancelled the toxicological evaluation reports of all the technical and formulated products based on phorate and
excluded the monograph of the active ingredient phorate from the date of publication of the Resolution. It
obligated companies that held stocks of products based on phorate to provide adequate final disposal.
The Resolution was based on the Technical Note of Toxicological Re-evaluation of the Active Ingredient Phorate
prepared by ANVISA with the collaboration of the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation.
The final regulatory action has been taken for the pesticide category to protect human health.
Reason: Human Health
Canada
The Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) performed a re-evaluation of the active ingredient phorate,
carrying out an assessment of available information, and concluded that the use of phorate and associated end-use
products (EP) entail an unacceptable risk of harm to the environment pursuant to Section 20 of the Canadian Pest
Control Product (PCP) Regulation. As a result, PMRA determined that all uses of phorate were to be phased out.
Uses of phorate and associated end-use products on corn, lettuce, beans and rutabagas were phased out at the end
of December 2004.
Due to the lack of alternatives to phorate for control of wireworm on potatoes, the use of phorate, for this use only,
could be continued until 1 August 2008, with interim mitigation measures to protect workers (engineering
controls, requirements regarding additional Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)) and the environment
(environmental statements on the label). The use on potatoes was subsequently extended to August 2015. A new
phorate product, paired with application equipment to reduce environmental exposure, was registered in 2015.
Relevant regulatory documents are:
− Health Canada (2003): Proposed Acceptability for Continuing Registration (PACR 2003-01), Pest
Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) Re-evaluation of Phorate, January 24 , 2003 (see
UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1)
− Health Canada (2004): Re-evaluation Decision Document (RRD 2004-11) Phorate, 13 May 2004 (see
UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1)
− Health Canada (2007): Re-evaluation note, REV2007-07, Update on the Use of Phorate on Potatoes, 5 June
2007 (see UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1)
− Health Canada (2008): REV2008-05: Update on the Use of Phorate on Potatoes.
− Health Canada (2012): Re-evaluation Note REV2012-01: Update of the Use of Phorate on Potatoes. Pest
Management Regulatory Agency, 28 May 2012.
The final regulatory action has been taken for the pesticide category to protect the environment.
Reason: Environment
2.2 Risk evaluation (see Annex 1 for further details)
7
Brazil
The final regulatory action was based on a risk or hazard evaluation.
In accordance with the Brazilian Pesticide Law, governmental agencies responsible for pesticides registration
(ANVISA, IBAMA (Brazilian Institute for the Environment and the Renewable Resources) or MAPA(Ministry of
Agriculture, Livestock and Food Supply) can re-evaluate the registration of a pesticide, when there is evidence of
reduction of agronomic efficiency and/or change of risks to human health or environment. Technical Notes on the
toxicology and/or potential environmental hazards of the active ingredient are developed based on data collected from
studies and surveys conducted by national and international accredited institutions as well as information provided by
the National System of Toxic-Pharmacological Intoxications and Poisonings (SINITOX), Pesticide Residues in Food
Analysis Programme or pesticide registrants. After the re-evaluation, measures to restrict, suspend or prohibit the
production and import of pesticides could be taken as well as to cancel the registration, if a criterion of prohibition of
registration is fulfilled.
Human health
Brazil’s risk evaluation of phorate took into account toxicology and public health, occupational health and safety,
conditions of use, environmental impact and availability of lower-risk alternatives. An extensive review of relevant
data on hazard and risk of phorate using reviewed documents, published reports and literature was undertaken.
On the basis of available data, phorate and its metabolites were shown to be easily absorbed through skin and mucous
membranes and to irreversibly block the catalytic activity of acetylcholinesterase (AChE), the enzyme responsible for
mediating the hydrolysis of acetylcholine into acetic acid and choline acid. Thus, phorate and its metabolites interrupt
the transmission of nerve impulses in the cholinergic synapses of the central nervous system (CNS), autonomic
nervous system (ANS) and neuromuscular junction. Inactivation of AChE causes cholinergic hyperstimulation by
acetylcholine accumulation in the synaptic cleft.
Experimental and epidemiological studies involving the respiratory tract demonstrate that phorate has a high toxicity
for this system.
Data confirm that phorate can cause complex neurological clinical manifestations in humans, such as encephalopathy,
intermediate syndrome and delayed polyneuropathy. However, in laboratory animals that were exposed to phorate
there were no cases of intermediate syndrome or late polyneuropathy, that was concluded in ANVISA to show this
pesticide is more toxic to humans than it is demonstrated in tests with laboratory animals.
As stated in the Brazilian notification, besides its neurotoxic effects, phorate demonstrated potential to cause adverse
effects to the endocrine regulation processes of steroid hormones in humans (Usmani, 2003), which may contribute to
increased cancer cases (Alavanja et al., 2002; Mahajan et al, 2006; Koutros et al, 2010).
Several studies analysed by Brazil showed that agricultural workers exposed to phorate were victims of poisonings
and deaths related to the toxicity of the active ingredient. The exposure becomes even more dangerous due to the
difficulties related to the availability and/or ineffectiveness of personal protective equipment (PPE). A comprehensive
study on the conditions of pesticide use carried out in municipalities of the state of Amazonas in Brazil concluded that
farmers were not prepared for the proper use of pesticides, ignoring the risks of these products to human health and
the environment. PPE is not used because it is expensive, uncomfortable and unsuitable for the hot climate of the
region. Lack of training and poor knowledge of the hazards of pesticides contribute to incorrect handling during the
preparation and application of the pesticide, and the disposal of empty containers. In these conditions, the exposure of
farmers, their families, consumers and the environment is high.
The decision to ban phorate was taken on the basis of the evaluation of its hazardous properties as well as on the basis
of the expected exposure of agricultural workers to pesticides in general and also to phorate under the known
conditions of pesticide use in Brazil. ANVISA concluded that this active ingredient has the potential to cause
hormonal disturbances in humans and is more toxic to humans than demonstrated in tests with laboratory animals,
which are prohibitive criteria for registration of pesticides in Brazil.
Canada
As per Section 16 of the Pest Control Products Act, the PMRA re-evaluates all pesticides registered prior to 1995, and
also conducts re-evaluations of all pesticides on a 15-year cycle. In addition, a re-evaluation may be initiated if there
have been changes to the information requirements or the procedures used to evaluate risk. Re-evaluation uses current
scientific approaches to assess the potential risks consider the risks to human health and the environment, and to
determine if registered uses of pesticides continue to be acceptable.
8
Environment
On the basis of a deterministic assessment of the environmental risk of pest control products containing phorate,
conducted by the PMRA, phorate was found to be highly toxic to all terrestrial and aquatic species tested. Incident
reports of bird and mammal fatalities in Canada, the United States of America and the United Kingdom of Great
Britain and Northern Ireland support the conclusion that phorate presents a significant risk to birds and wildlife.
Surface broadcast application presents the greatest risk owing to the large number of exposed granules on the surface.
Although soil incorporation is expected to lower the risk of terrestrial and aquatic exposure, it nevertheless presents a
very high risk owing to unincorporated granules remaining exposed on the surface. The risk to small and moderate-
sized birds and small or moderate-sized mammals remains high to very high with either method of application. Owing
to its extreme toxicity to all organisms tested, the very high risk to moderate and smaller-sized birds and mammals,
the incident reports of bird and mammal mortalities (including large raptors in Canada), in addition to the persistence
and mobility of the toxic sulfoxide and sulfone transformation products, Canada has concluded that the use of phorate
in the country presents a high risk to the environment.
3. Protective measures that have been applied concerning the chemical
3.1 Regulatory measures to reduce exposure
Brazil Resolution RDC No.12 of 13 March 2015 from ANVISA prohibited production, use, trade, import
and export of products based on phorate. Complete entry into force of the final regulatory action
was 16 March 2015.
Canada Use of phorate and associated end-use products on corn, lettuce, beans and rutabagas where phased
out at the end of December 2004. No further use was allowed after December 2004, except on
potatoes, where use for controlling wireworms was allowed to be continued until 1 August 2008.
The use on potatoes was subsequently extended to August 2015. A new phorate product, paired
with application equipment to reduce environmental exposure, was registered in 2015.
Relevant regulatory documents are provided in section 2.1.
3.2 Other measures to reduce exposure
Brazil
None reported.
Canada
For the exempted use for controlling wireworm on potatoes, the use of interim mitigation measures to protect workers
(engineering controls, requirements regarding additional Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and the environment
(environmental statements on the label) was required.
General
None.
3.3 Alternatives
Brazil
Prior to the final regulatory action, phorate was used in insecticides authorized exclusively for agricultural use for
the following crops: cotton, potatoes, coffee, beans and corn.
The alternatives to phorate applied to cotton in Brazil are: acephate, acetamiprid, benfuracarb, methidathion,
esfenvalerate, imidacloprid, thiacloprid, permethrin, cypermethrin, azadirachtin, cyfluthrin, pymetrozine,
methomyl, beta-cyfluthrin, flonicamid, chlorpyrifos, bifenthrin, deltamethrin, dimethoate, carbosulfan,
clothianidin, zetacypermethrin, triazophos, fenthion, malathion, diafenthiuron, furathiocarb, thiodicarb, fenvalerate
and fenitrothion.
The alternatives to phorate applied to potatoes in Brazil are: acephate, acetamiprid, benfuracarb, esfenvalerate,
imidacloprid, thiacloprid, alpha-cypermethrin, pymetrozine, methomyl, beta-cyfluthrin, chlorpyrifos, bifenthrin,
deltamethrin, carbosulfan, betacypermethrin, piridafenthion, diafenthiuron, fipronil, chlorantraniliprole, cadusafos,
tebupirimfos, lambda cyhalothrin, gamma-cyhalotrin and chlorfenapyr.
The alternatives to phorate applied to coffee in Brazil are: esfenvalerate, imidacloprid, permethrin, cypermethrin,
azadirachtin, cyfluthrin, beta-cyfluthrin, chlorpyrifos, zeta-cypermethrin, alpha-cypermethrin, beta-cypermethrin,
novaluron, abamectin, chlorantraniliprole, teflubenzuron, lufenuron, cyantraniliprole, pyriproxyfen, fenpropathrin,
gamma-cyhalothrin, lambda-cyhalothrin and fluvalinate.
9
The alternatives to phorate applied to beans in Brazil are: thiodicarb, imidacloprid, malathion, chlorpyrifos,
esfenvalerate, acetate, acetamiprid, bifenthrin, beta-cyfluthrin, thiacloprid, phenopopation, clothanidine,
carbosulfan, permethrin and etofenprox.
The alternatives to phorate applied to corn in Brazil are: chlorpyrifos, fipronil, bifenthrin and imidacloprid.
Canada
Phorate was registered on rutabagas for the control of cabbage maggot (CM). Other organophosphate insecticides,
azinphos-methyl, chlorpyrifos, diazinon and terbufos, were also registered as a prophylactic treatment at planting to
control CM.
Phorate was registered for corn rootworm control. Alternative soil insecticides that were registered for control of
this insect include carbaryl, chlorpyrifos, diazinon, terbufos and tefluthrin.
General
It is essential that before a country considers substituting a substance with alternatives, it ensures that the use is
relevant to its national needs, and the anticipated local conditions of use. The hazards of the substitute materials
and the controls needed for safe use should also be evaluated.
There are a number of alternative methods involving chemical and non-chemical strategies, including alternative
technologies available, depending on the individual crop-pest complex under consideration. Countries should
consider promoting, as appropriate, integrated pest management (IPM) and organic strategies as a means of
reducing or eliminating the use of hazardous pesticides.
SAICM’s Fourth International Conference on Chemicals Management recommended that in replacing highly
hazardous pesticides the focus should be on agroecologically-based practices. Information on such practices can be
found at the following websites:
FAO Agroecology hub: http://www.fao.org/agroecology/en/
IPAM (International Peoples Agroecology Multiversity): http://ipamglobal.org/
OISAT (Online Information Service for Non-Chemical Pest Management in the Tropics):
http://www.oisat.org/
Replacing Chemicals with Biology: Phasing out Highly Hazardous Pesticides with Agroecology:
http://panap.net/2015/11/replacing-chemicals-biology-phasing-highly-hazardous-pesticides-agroecology/
3.4 Socio-economic effects
Brazil
No assessment of socio-economic effects was reported.
Canada
A significant challenge for PMRA was a regulatory decision that moved towards the goal of eliminating phorate in a
manner that was the least disruptive to the need to protect agricultural crops from pests. To meet its challenge, the
PMRA considered the availability of alternatives and the need for a transition period for those uses for which no or
limited alternatives were available. A significant challenge for industry was to develop alternatives in the relatively
short time frame of the proposed phase-outs. A significant challenge for the agricultural sector was to reduce the use
during the transition period and be open to using alternatives.
10
4. Hazards and Risks to human health and the environment
4.1 Hazard Classification
WHO / IPCS I a – Extremely Hazardous
European Classification according to Regulation (EC) No 1272/2008 of the European Parliament and of
Union the Council (CLP-Regulation)
Acute Toxicity (oral) 2* - H300 (Fatal if swallowed)
Acute Toxicity 1 - H310 (Fatal in contact with skin)
Aquatic Acute 1 - H400 (Very toxic to aquatic life)
Aquatic Chronic 1 - H410 (Very toxic to aquatic life with long lasting effects)
US EPA I – Highly toxic (acute oral, dermal and inhalation)
4.2 Exposure limits
Canadian risk evaluation:
Acute reference dose (ARfD): 0.00025 mg/kg bw
In animal studies, the adverse effects noticeable at the lowest dose (i.e. the toxicity end point) were clinical
signs observed in an acute rat neurotoxicity study (NOAEL = 0.25 mg/kg body weight (bw)). The uncertainty
factor was 100 (10x for interspecies extrapolation x 10x intraspecies variability). An additional safety factor of
10x was applied to account for the steepness of the dose-response and the high degree of potency (based on
lethality at very low doses). The acute reference dose was calculated to be 0.00025 mg/kg bw (0.25 mg/kg bw
/ 1000). This value was considered to be protective for infants and children.
Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI): 0.00025 mg/kg bw/d
As the ARfD value was lower than any acceptable daily intake derived from any of the repeat-dose toxicity
studies (reflecting the high acute toxicity and use of the additional safety factor), the ADI was established at
the same value as the ARfD. Thus, the ADI is 0.00025 mg/kg bw/d.
JMPR Report 2004, JMPR Report 2012
Acute reference dose (ARfD): 0.003 mg/kg bw
An ARfD of 0.003 mg/kg bw was established based on the NOAEL of 0.25 mg/kg bw for miosis in the study
with single doses in rats. Although inhibition of acetylcholinesterase activity is a C max-dependent
phenomenon, a safety factor of 100 was used in view of the steep dose–response curve and the slow recovery
of brain acetylcholinesterase activity because of irreversibility of its inhibition. This ARfD includes the
metabolites of phorate, phorate sulfone and phorate sulfoxide.
Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI): 0–0.0007 mg/kg bw
An ADI of 0–0.0007 mg/kg bw was established on the basis of an overall NOAEL of 0.07 mg/kg bw per day
for inhibition of brain acetylcholinesterase activity in rats and dogs and a safety factor of 100. This ADI
includes the phorate metabolites, phorate sulfone and phorate sulfoxide.
Occupational exposure limits (NIOSH, 2000):
OSHA PELhttps://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npg/pgintrod.html - exposure: none
NIOSH REL: TWA 0.05 mg/m3 ST 0.2 mg/m3 skin
NIOSH IDLH: N.D. See: IDLH INDEX (https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/idlh/intridl4.html)
TLV: (inhalable fraction & vapour) 0.05 mg/m3 as TWA; (skin); A4 (not classifiable as a human carcinogen); BEI
issued; (ACGIH 2008).
MAK not established.
MRL values
Canadian values (additional information, not provided in the notification):
https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/hc-sc/migration/hc-sc/cps-
spc/alt_formats/pdf/pest/part/consultations/_pmrl2015-47/pmrl2015-47-eng.pdf
This link indicates that the use of phorate on potatoes in Canada was approved for a new formulation Thimet
20-G in 2015 (see Section 2.1 above) with proposed MRLs of 0.6 ppm for potato flakes and granules, 0.2 ppm
for potatoes and 0.024 ppm for all food crops (other than those listed in this item).
11
EU values
http://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/pesticides/eu-pesticides-
database/public/?event=pesticide.residue.CurrentMRL&language=EN&pestResidueId=179
This link provides 378 individual entries with values ranging from 0.01 to 0.5 mg/kg phorate (sum of phorate,
its oxygen analogue and their sulfones expressed as phorate). Many of the values are at the lower limit of
analytical determination.
WHO drinking water guideline
Phorate is excluded from guideline value derivation.
4.3 Packaging and labelling
The United Nations Committee of Experts on the Transportation of Dangerous Goods classifies the chemical in:
Hazard Class
UN Hazard Class: 6.1
and Packing
UN Packing Group: I
Group:
For phorate (pure substance)
UN number 3018
International Organophosphorus pesticide, liquid, toxic (phorate)
Maritime Class 6.1
Dangerous Marine pollutant
Goods (IMDG) Source: IMO
Code (1996) http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Legal/HNS/Documents/IMDG%20Code%201996_search
able.pdf
Transport
Emergency TEC (R)-61GT6-I
Card
Further specific guidance on appropriate symbols and label statements applicable for phorate products may be
available in the FAO Guidelines on Good Labelling Practice for Pesticides (FAO, 2015).
4.4 First aid
Safety and first aid recommendations extracted from the IPCS/WHO safety data sheet (see whole safety data
sheet at http://www.inchem.org/documents/icsc/icsc/eics1060.htm )
Fire and explosion
Acute hazard: Combustible. Prevention: no open flames. First aid: Use water spray, foam, powder, carbon dioxide
STRICT HYGIENE! IN ALL CASES CONSULT A DOCTOR!
Inhalation symptoms
Laboured breathing. Pupillary constriction, muscle cramp, excessive salivation. Sweating. Prevention: Use ventilation,
local exhaust or breathing protection. First aid: Fresh air, rest. Refer for medical attention.
Skin:
Symptoms: MAY BE ABSORBED! See Inhalation. Prevention: Protective gloves. Protective clothing. First aid:
Rinse and then wash skin with water and soap. Refer for medical attention.
Eyes:
Symptoms: See Inhalation. Prevention: Wear safety goggles, face shield or eye protection in combination with
breathing protection. First aid: First rinse with plenty of water for several minutes (remove contact lenses if easily
possible), then refer for medical attention.
Ingestion:
Symptoms: See Inhalation. Abdominal cramps. Diarrhoea. Vomiting. Prevention: Do not eat, drink, or smoke during
work. Wash hands before eating. Rinse mouth. First aid: Give one or two glasses of water to drink. Refer for medical
attention.
12
SPILLAGE DISPOSAL
Collect leaking and spilled liquid in sealable containers as far as possible. Absorb remaining liquid in sand or inert
absorbent. Then store and dispose of according to local regulations. Do NOT let this chemical enter the environment.
Personal protection: gas-tight chemical protection suit including self-contained breathing apparatus.
PubChem (2017a)
Note: Phorate is a cholinesterase inhibitor.
Signs and Symptoms of Acute Phorate Exposure: Acute exposure to phorate may produce the following signs and
symptoms: pinpoint pupils, blurred vision, headache, dizziness, muscle spasms, and profound weakness. Vomiting,
diarrhoea, abdominal pain, seizures, and coma may also occur. The heart rate may decrease following oral exposure or
increase following dermal exposure. Chest pain may be noted. Hypotension (low blood pressure) may occur, although
hypertension (high blood pressure) is not uncommon. Dyspnea (shortness of breath) may be followed by respiratory
collapse. Giddiness is common.
Emergency Life-Support Procedures: Acute exposure to phorate may require decontamination and life support for the
victims. Emergency personnel should wear protective clothing appropriate to the type and degree of contamination.
Air-purifying or supplied-air respiratory equipment should also be worn, as necessary. Rescue vehicles should carry
supplies such as plastic sheeting and disposable plastic bags to assist in preventing spread of contamination.
Inhalation Exposure: 1. Move victims to fresh air. Emergency personnel should avoid self-exposure to phorate. 2.
Evaluate vital signs including pulse and respiratory rate, and note any trauma. If no pulse is detected, provide CPR. If
not breathing, provide artificial respiration. If breathing is laboured, administer oxygen or other respiratory support. 3.
Obtain authorization and/or further instructions from the Localized hospital for administration of an antidote or
performance of other invasive procedures. 4. Transport to a health care facility.
Dermal/Eye Exposure: 1. Remove victims from exposure. Emergency personnel should avoid self-exposure to
phorate. 2. Evaluate vital signs including pulse and respiratory rate, and note any trauma. If no pulse is detected,
provide CPR. If not breathing, provide artificial respiration. If breathing is laboured, administer oxygen or other
respiratory support. 3. Remove contaminated clothing as soon as possible. 4. If eye exposure has occurred, eyes must
be flushed with lukewarm water for at least 15 minutes. 5. Wash exposed skin areas three times with soap and water.
6. Obtain authorization and/or further instructions from the localized hospital for administration of an antidote or
performance of other invasive procedures. 7. Transport to a health care facility.
Ingestion Exposure: 1. Evaluate vital signs including pulse and respiratory rate, and note any trauma. If no pulse is
detected, provide CPR. If not breathing, provide artificial respiration. If breathing is laboured, administer oxygen or
other respiratory support. 2. Obtain authorization and/or further instructions from the localized hospital for
administration of an antidote or performance of other invasive procedures. 3. Vomiting may be induced with syrup of
Ipecac. If elapsed time since ingestion of phorate is unknown or suspected to be greater than 30 minutes, do not
induce vomiting and proceed to Step 4. Ipecac should not be administered to children under 6 months of age.
Warning: Ingestion of phorate may result in sudden onset of seizures or loss of consciousness. Syrup of Ipecac should
be administered only if victims are alert, have an active gag-reflex, and show no signs of impending seizure or coma.
If ANY uncertainty exists, proceed to Step 4. The following dosages of Ipecac are recommended: children up to 1
year old, 10 mL (1/3 oz); children 1 to 12 years old, 15 mL (1/2 oz); adults, 30 mL (1 oz). Ambulate (walk) the
victims and give large quantities of water. If vomiting has not occurred after 15 minutes, Ipecac may be re-
administered. Continue to ambulate and give water to the victims. If vomiting has not occurred within 15 minutes
after second administration of Ipecac, administer activated charcoal. 4. Activated charcoal may be administered if
victims are conscious and alert. Use 15 to 30 g (1/2 to 1 oz) for children, 50 to 100 g (1-3/4 to 3-1/2 oz) for adults,
with 125 to 250 mL (1/2 to 1 cup) of water. 5. Promote excretion by administering a saline cathartic or sorbitol to
conscious and alert victims. Children require 15 to 30 g (1/2 to 1 oz) of cathartic; 50 to 100 g (1-3/4 to 3-1/2 oz) is
recommended for adults. 6. Transport to a health care facility. (PubChem, 2017a)
Safety Data Sheet of Central Pollution Control Board of India (2017)
Fire
Fire Extinguishing Media:
Special Procedure: Keep containers cool by spraying water, if exposed to heat or flame.
Unusual hazard: Shock can shatter containers, releasing the contents. When heated to decomposition, toxic
fumes of sulfur oxides, phosphorus oxides, and nitrogen oxides are emitted.
EXPOSURE: First Aid Measures:
Inhalation: Remove the person to fresh air area and atropine powder or tablet may be given.
Skin: Remove the contaminated clothes and wash the affected area with plenty of water and soap. The
affected area may be decontaminated with 5-10% soln. of ammonia or 2-5% soln. of
chloramine.
13
Eyes: Flush eyes with water for at least 15 mins
Ingestion: Induce vomiting. Give half a glass of a 2% Na2CO43, soln. with 2-3 table spoonfuls triturated activated
charcoal to drink.
Antidote/dosages: See "Additional Information"
Spills
Steps to be taken: Spills should be washed with water and soda ash. May also be absorbed with dry sand or
vermiculite.
Safety Data Sheet of Sigma-Aldrich (2015) (link)
General advice: Consult a physician. Show this safety data sheet to the doctor in attendance.
If inhaled: If breathed in, move person into fresh air. If not breathing, give artificial respiration. Consult a
physician.
In case of skin contact: Wash off with soap and plenty of water. Take victim immediately to hospital. Consult a
physician.
In case of eye contact: Flush eyes with water as a precaution.
If swallowed: Never give anything by mouth to an unconscious person. Rinse mouth with water. Consult a
physician.
Firefighting measures
Suitable extinguishing media: Use water spray, alcohol-resistant foam, dry chemical or
carbon dioxide.
Special hazards arising from the substance or mixture: Carbon oxides, Sulphur oxides,
Oxides of phosphorus
Advice for firefighters: Wear self-contained breathing apparatus for firefighting if
necessary.
Further information: No data available
Accidental release measures
Personal precautions, protective equipment and emergency procedures:
Wear respiratory protection. Avoid breathing vapours, mist or gas. Ensure
adequate ventilation.
Evacuate personnel to safe areas.
Environmental precautions:
Prevent further leakage or spillage if safe to do so. Do not let product enter drains.
Discharge into the environment must be avoided.
Methods and materials for containment and cleaning up
Soak up with inert absorbent material and dispose of as hazardous waste. Keep in suitable,
closed containers for disposal.
4.5 Waste management
Regulatory actions to ban a chemical should not result in creation of a stockpile requiring waste disposal. For
guidance on how to avoid creating stockpiles of obsolete pesticides the following guidelines are available: FAO
Guidelines on Prevention of Accumulation of Obsolete Pesticide Stocks (FAO, 1995b), The Pesticide Storage and
Stock Control Manual (FAO, 1996a) and Guidelines for the management of small quantities of unwanted and obsolete
pesticides (FAO, 1999).
In all cases waste should be disposed in accordance with the provisions of the Basel Convention on the Control of
Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal (1996), any guidelines thereunder, and any other
relevant regional agreements.
It should be noted that the disposal/destruction methods recommended in the literature are often not available in, or
suitable for, all countries; e.g., high temperature incinerators may not be available. Consideration should be given to
the use of alternative destruction technologies. Further information on possible approaches may be found in Technical
Guidelines for the Disposal of Bulk Quantities of Obsolete Pesticides in Developing Countries (FAO, 1996b).
Disposal Methods for this chemical as cited in PubChem (2017b)
4
Note: original reference provides “NaIICO”, but this was not considered plausible by the CRC and the correct
chemistry in this context has been provided in the text.
14
Recycle any unused portion of the material for its approved use or return it to the manufacturer or supplier. Ultimate
disposal of the chemical must consider: the material's impact on air quality; potential migration in soil or water;
effects on animal, aquatic, and plant life; and conformance with environmental and public health regulations.
Potential candidate for liquid injection incineration with a temperature range of 650-1600oC and residence time of 0.1
to 2 seconds. Also, a candidate for rotary kiln incineration with a temperature range of 820 to 1600 oC with residence
times for liquids and gases: seconds; solids: hours. Also, a candidate for fluidized bed incineration with a temperature
range of 450 to 980oC with residence times for liquids and gases: seconds; solids: longer.
USEPA; Engineering Handbook for Hazardous Waste Incineration p.3-10 (1981) EPA 68-03-3025
Mix phorate with excess calcium oxide or sodium hydroxide and sand or other adsorbent. Sodium hydroxide (or
sodium carbonate) can also be added to the mixture to help speed the reactions when calcium oxide is used as the
main alkali. The amount of calcium oxide or sodium hydroxide to use depends on the amount of pesticide to be
disposed of and, to some extent, the concentration of active ingredient in the pesticide and the actual chemical nature
of the active ingredient. For safety, a preliminary test should be made in which a very small amount of the pesticide
and alkali are mixed and observed briefly to make sure it does not react too vigorously. Sizable quantities of
pesticides can be disposed of in several smaller batches, rather than all at once, for added safety. Recommendable
methods: Incineration and hydrolysis. Peer-review: For large amount: Incineration in a unit with effluent gas
scrubbing is recommendable. (Peer-review conclusions of an IRPTC expert consultation (May 1985)).
United Nations. Treatment and Disposal Methods for Waste Chemicals (IRPTC File). Data Profile Series No. 5.
Geneva, Switzerland: United Nations Environmental Programme, Dec. 1985., p. 241
Hydrolysis: Alkaline hydrolysis leads to complete degradation. Alkaline salts of O,S-diethylphosphorodithioate,
formaldehyde, and ethyl mercaptan are non-toxic. Acid hydrolysis leads to complete degradation. Essentially the same
products as alkaline hydrolysis. United Nations. Treatment and Disposal Methods for Waste Chemicals (IRPTC File).
Data Profile Series No. 5. Geneva, Switzerland: United Nations Environmental Programme, Dec. 1985., p. 242
Annexes
Annex 1 Further information on the chemical
Annex 2 Details on final regulatory actions reported
Annex 3 Address of designated national authorities
Annex 4 References
15
Annex 1 Further information on phorate
The information presented in this Annex reflects the conclusions of the notifying parties: Brazil and Canada. The
notification of Canada was published in PIC Circular XXVIII of December 2008. The notification from Brazil was
published in PIC Circular XLV of June 2017.
Where possible, information on hazards provided by the notifying parties has been presented together, while the
evaluation of the risks, specific to the conditions prevailing in the notifying Parties are presented separately. This
information has been taken from the documents referenced in the notifications in support of the final regulatory
actions to ban or severely restrict phorate.
Furthermore, information from the FAO/WHO Joint Meeting on Pesticide Residues (JMPR) monographs of
toxicological evaluation of phorate in reports of the year 20045 and of the year 20126, as well as other sources such as
PubChem, has been taken into account.
1. Identity and Physico-Chemical properties
1.1 Identity: ISO: phorate
IUPAC: O,O-diethyl S-ethylthiometyl phosphorodithioate; diethyl
{[(ethylsulfanyl)methyl]sulfanyl}(sulfanylidene)phosphonite
CAS: O, O-diethyl S-[(ethylthio)methyl]phosphorodithioate
1.2 Formula C7H17O2PS3
1.3 Molecular 260.4
weight
1.4 Colour and Technical phorate is a clear liquid at room temperature (Extoxnet, 1996)
Texture Phorate is a relatively stable clear to yellow liquid at room temperature (Toxipedia)
Pale straw to light brown; colorless to very light yellow liquid with skunk-like odor
(PubChem, 2017c)
1.5 Melting point <-15ºC (technical grade) (7)
1.6 Boiling Point 118-120ºC/0.8 mmHg (technical grade) (6)
1.7 Relative Density 1.167 (technical grade at 25ºC) (6)
(g/cm3)
1.156 at 25C (Toxnet, 2017)
1.8 Vapour Pressure 85 mPa at 25ºC (6)
1.9 Henry’s Law 5.9 X 10-1 Pa m3/mol (6)
Constant
4.368 X 10-6 atm.m3/mol (6)
1.10 Solubility in 50 (mg/L) at 25ºC (6)
Water
1.11 Solubility in Miscible with alcohols, ketones, ethers, esters, aromatic, aliphatic and chlorinated
Organic Solvents hydrocarbons, dioxane, vegetable oils, and other organic solvents. (6)
1.12 Partition LogKow: 3.92 (6)
co-efficient
1.13 Dissociation Not available, no pKa expected in the environmentally relevant pH range.
Constant
1.14 Surface tension Not available
1.15 Hydrolytic 2.6 d (pH 5), 3.2 d (pH 7), 3.9 d (pH 9) (6)
stability (DT50)
5 http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/agphome/documents/Pests_Pesticides/JMPR/Reports_1991-
2006/report2004jmpr.pdf.
6 http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/agphome/documents/Pests_Pesticides/JMPR/Report12/
JMPR_2012_Report.pdf.
7
Canadian notification and supporting documentation
16
1.16 Decomposition No information available
temperature
1.17 Resistance to Phorate is subject to hydrolysis under alkaline conditions, but is stable under neutral
acids and acidic conditions. (PubChem, 2017c)
1.18 Resistance to Phorate is subject to hydrolysis under alkaline conditions, but is stable under neutral
alkalis and acidic conditions. (PubChem, 2017c)
1.19 Tensile strength Not applicable
(103 kg/cm2)
1.20 Storage stability Stable under normal storage conditions for at least 2 years (6)
2 Toxicological properties
2.1 General
2.1.1 Mode of Action Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibition.
The main feature of the toxic mechanism of organophosphorus pesticides is
inhibition of the esterase enzyme activity, in particular of cholinesterase, which
plays an important physiological role. Organophosphorus pesticides can also
indirectly interact with the biochemical receptors of acetylcholine. (PubChem,
2017c)
Systemic with contact and stomach action (PPDB, 2018).
2.1.2 Symptoms of Phorate demonstrated to be extremely toxic, causing lethality at low doses, for
poisoning different exposure conditions. The studies show that agricultural workers exposed to
phorate are victims of poisonings and deaths related to toxicity characteristics of the
active ingredient.
Signs and symptoms of phorate poisoning are characteristic of AChE inhibition and
may include vomiting, dizziness, abdominal pain, tachycardia, excessive salivation
miosis and hypotension were observed in cases of intentional intoxication,
occupational and accidental exposure to phorate.
More severe symptoms such as convulsions, spasms, tremors, loss of muscle
coordination, increased muscle tone of the limbs, respiratory distress, cerebral
edema, loss of consciousness and deep coma have also been described. Findings in
some patients were consistent with brain death, including absence of corneal,
oculocephalic, pupillary and muscular reflexes, absence of reactions to pain or heat
stimuli, and absence of spontaneous respiration, with global suppression of cortical
activity. Some intoxication cases have evolved to death.
Phorate can cause complex neurological manifestations such as encephalopathy,
intermediate syndrome and delayed polyneuropathy in humans.
Furthermore, the experimental and epidemiological studies involving the respiratory
tract demonstrate that phorate has high toxicity for this system.
At doses similar to occupational human exposure, signs and symptoms may include
emphysema, bronchopneumonia, inflammatory changes and respiratory distress as
main effects that were shown to be irreversible for the observation period even after
the exposure ceased. It is known that these effects may cause increased pulmonary
vascular resistance, overwhelm the heart and even cause heart failure. (Brazilian
notification and supporting documentation).
Targeted organs
Eyes, skin, respiratory system, central nervous system, cardiovascular system, blood
cholinesterase. (PubChem, 2017c).
Further information on symptoms can be found in Toxnet (2017): under the section
”Clinical effects”.
2.1.3 Absorption, Brazilian notification
distribution,
Rate and extent of oral absorption: Rapid, approximately 90% within 24 h.
excretion and
Dermal absorption: Extensive based on acute toxicity.
metabolism in
Distribution: Rapid and extensive.
mammals
Potential for accumulation: None.
17
Rate and extent of excretion: 89% within 24 h; urinary excretion predominated
(77%); faecal excretion (12%).
PubChem (2017c)
Phorate is absorbed by all routes, oral, respiratory, and dermal. About 77% of an
oral dose was excreted in the urine of rats within 24 hr, and 12% was excreted in the
feces. Rats given oral phorate at 2 mg/kg or 6 daily doses at 1 mg/kg/day eliminated
up to 35% of the dose in urine and up to 6% in feces in 6 days. Rats treated at the
rate of 1 mg/kg/day for 6 days excreted only 12% in the urine and 6% in the feces
within 7 days.
Brain, liver and kidney tissues from the latter animals contained unidentified and
largely unextractable residues (IPCS INCHEM, undated).
Metabolism
Metabolism in animals - Major pathway: cleavage of phosphorus–sulfur bond,
methylation of the liberated thiol group and oxidation of the resulting divalent
moiety to the sulfoxide and sulfone.
Toxicologically significant compounds (plants, animals and the environment):
parent, phorate sulfoxide and phorate sulfone (Brazilian notification).
The urine of male rats given daily oral doses of 1 mg/kg bw contained 17% diethyl
phosphoric acid, 80% O,O-diethyl phosphorothioic acid and 3% O,O-diethyl
phosphorodithioic acid. Phorate sulfoxide, phorate sulfone, phoratoxon sulfoxide
and phoratoxon sulfone were formed (IPCS INCHEM, undated).
Metabolites of phorate were quantified in daily urine specimens obtained from
employees of a pesticide formulating plant. The predominant alkyl phosphates
found in urine were diethyl phosphate, diethyl phosphorothiolate, and diethyl
thiophosphate (PubChem, 2017c).
2.2 Toxicology
studies
2.2.1 Acute toxicity Rat, LD50, oral for male and female 3.7 mg/kg bw, 1.4 mg/kg bw, respectively
(Brazilian notification).
Rat LD50 oral for male and female 3.7 and 1.6 mg/kg bw, respectively (Canadian
notification).
Rat LD50 oral for male and female 2 and 1.1 mg/kg bw, respectively (PubChem,
2017c).
Mice LD50 oral 6 mg/kg bw (Canadian notification).
Mouse male LD50 oral 2.25 mg/kg bw (PubChem, 2017c).
Mouse male LD50 ip 2.1 mg/kg (PubChem, 2017c).
Mice LD50 range from 1.4 to 10 mg/kg bw (Brazilian notification, section 2.4.2.1).
Rat, LD50, dermal for male and female 9.3 mg/kg bw and 3.9 mg/kg bw,
respectively.
Rat, LC50, inhalation for male and female 0.06 mg/L of air (1 h) and 0.011 mg/L of
air (1 h), respectively (Brazilian notification).
Skin and eye acute percutaneous LD50 for male rats 6.2, female rats 2.5, male
rabbits 5.6, female rabbits 2.9, Guinea pigs 30.0 mg/kg (Canadian notification).
2.2.2 Short term Target/critical effect: brain and erythrocyte acetylcholinesterase activity, and miosis
toxicity (rats).
Lowest relevant oral NOAEL: 0.07 mg/kg bw per day (Brazilian notification).
Lowest relevant dermal NOAEL: 0.41 mg/kg bw from 28-day dermal toxicity study
for short- and intermediate-term dermal risk assessment in which there was
inhibition of cholinesterase activity at the next level (Canadian notification).
Lowest relevant inhalation NOAEC: No data (Brazilian notification).
NOAEL = 0.25 mg/kg body weight derived from acute rat neurotoxicity study
findings consistent with acetylcholinesterase inhibition (Brazilian notification).
2.2.3 Genotoxicity Negative results in vivo and in vitro (Brazilian notification).
(including
mutagenicity)
18
2.2.4 Long term Target/critical effect: Inhibition of erythrocyte and brain cholinesterase activity
toxicity and Lowest relevant NOAEL: 0.07 mg/kg per day (rat, Brazilian notification)
carcinogenicity Carcinogenicity: Not carcinogenic in mice and rats (Brazilian notification).
A rat study is available. The LEL in this study was 2.0 ppm (0.1 mg/kg/day); the
NOEL was 0.66 ppm (0.033 mg/kg/day).
- Chronic toxicity: Dog study is available (NOEL and LEL for systemic toxicity
were 50 and 250 µg/kg/day, respectively). Mouse study is available (NOEL and
LEL were .45 and .9 µg/kg/day, respectively). Rat study is available (LEL was
0.05 mg/kg/day, NOEL was not determined).
Source: Extoxnet (2017)
2.2.5 Effects on Reproduction target/critical effect: Reduced pup growth at maternally toxic dose.
reproduction Lowest relevant reproductive NOAEL: 2 ppm, equivalent to 0.17 mg/kg bw per day
Developmental target/critical effect: Decreased pup weights and delayed
ossification at maternally toxic doses (rats).
Lowest relevant developmental NOAEL: 0.3 mg/kg bw per day (rats).
(Brazilian notification)
2.2.6 Neurotoxicity/ Single dose study of neurotoxicity:
delayed Target/critical effect: Signs consistent with acetylcholinesterase inhibition; no
neurotoxicity, neuropathological effects.
Special studies Relevant NOAEL: 0.25 mg/kg bw.
where available Delayed neuropathy: No delayed neurotoxicity in hens.
Medical data: Findings consistent with inhibition of acetylcholinesterase activity; no
record of permanent sequelae.
(Brazilian notification)
2.2.7 Summary of Canadian notification
mammalian In laboratory animals, phorate was found to be extremely acutely toxic
toxicity and following acute oral, dermal and inhalation exposures. Following both single
overall and repeated dosing, the most sensitive indicator of toxicity was the inhibition
evaluation of acetylcholinesterase, an enzyme necessary for the proper functioning of the
nervous system or clinical signs of cholinergic toxicity. Female animals were
more sensitive to the toxic effects of phorate. Phosphorylated phorate
metabolites (phorate sulfoxide and phorate sulfoxone) are of comparable
toxicity to phorate. Phorate did not cause any apparent delayed neurotoxicity
and there was no evidence of histopathologic effects on the central nervous
system in any of the available studies. Phorate was not found to be genotoxic
nor was it carcinogenic to either rats or mice. Phorate did not cause fetal
malformations in either rats or rabbits, nor did it cause reproductive toxicity
in rats other than reduced viability of the young at doses that were maternally
toxic. The developmental and reproductive toxicity studies did not demonstrate
any sensitivity of young animals relative to adult animals although lack of
cholinesterase measurements in these studies precluded a definitive assessment
of this issue. On the basis of the available toxicity studies, phorate is
anticipated to have a high dermal absorption potential. One of the most
remarkable features of phorate was the steepness and potency of the dose-
response with acute and short-term dosing. No observed adverse effect levels
(NOAELs) were very close to dose levels that elicited mortality in the test
animals.
Brazilian notification
Phorate and its metabolites were found to be easily absorbed through skin and
mucous membranes and irreversibly block the catalytic activity of
acetylcholinesterase (AChE). Thus, it interrupts the transmission of nerve impulses
in the cholinergic synapses of the central nervous system (CNS), autonomic nervous
system (ANS) and neuromuscular junction. Inactivation of AChE causes cholinergic
hyperstimulation by acetylcholine accumulation in the synaptic cleft. Phorate is
considered one of the most toxic organophosphate AChE inhibitors (with mean oral
LD50 for mice ranging from 1.4 to 10 mg/kg body weight). Phorate can cause
complex neurological clinical manifestations in humans, such as encephalopathy,
intermediate syndrome and delayed polyneuropathy. In laboratory animals that
received phorate there were no cases of intermediate syndrome or late
19
polyneuropathy, which suggests this pesticide is more toxic to humans than
demonstrated in tests with laboratory animals.
The experimental and epidemiological studies involving the respiratory tract
demonstrate that phorate has high toxicity for this system.
Phorate demonstrated the potential to cause adverse effects to the endocrine
regulation processes of steroid hormones in humans, which may contribute to
increased cancer cases.
Several studies showed that agricultural workers exposed to phorate are victims of
poisonings and deaths related to toxicity characteristics of the active ingredient. The
exposure becomes even more dangerous due to the difficulties related to the
availability and/or ineffectiveness of personal protective equipment.
3 Human exposure/Risk evaluation
3.1 Food Monitoring data indicate that the general population may be exposed to phorate via
ingestion of food.
3.2 Air Monitoring data indicate that the general population may be exposed to phorate via
inhalation in ambient air.
3.3 Water Monitoring data indicate that the general population may be exposed to phorate via
drinking water.
3.4 Occupational Occupational exposure to phorate may occur through inhalation and dermal contact
exposure with this compound at workplace where phorate is produced or used.
Brazil
The notification refers to several studies that have shown that pesticide poisonings,
especially with organophosphorous pesticides, occurred in different regions of
Brazil. In addition, the technical note (ANVISA, 2009) indicates that many
pesticide poisoning incidents were not reported in Brazil.
According to a study from the Amazonas area of Brazil, agricultural workers were
not prepared to use pesticides correctly. They were not sufficiently aware of the
risks of pesticides to human health and the environment. This study further
concludes that farmers did not use protective clothing or equipment because it was
expensive and not suitable for a tropical climate. Due to lack of training and poor
knowledge of pesticide hazards, pesticides were handled carelessly during
preparation, application and disposal of empty packages. Exposure of farmers, their
families, consumers and the environment was thus high.
Although no poisoning incidents with phorate itself have been reported from Brazil,
the decision to ban phorate was taken on the basis of the evaluation of its hazardous
properties as well as the expected exposure of agricultural workers to phorate under
conditions of use in Brazil. . ANVISA concluded this active ingredient has the
potential to cause hormonal disturbances in humans and is more toxic to humans
than demonstrated in tests with laboratory animals, which are prohibitive criteria for
registration of pesticides in Brazil.
Canada
Occupational risk assessment
Workers can be exposed to a pesticide through loading or applying the pesticide,
and re-entering a treated site. Worker risk is estimated by an MOE that determines
how close the occupational exposure comes to the NOAEL taken from animal
studies. For workers entering a treated site, re-entry intervals are calculated where
required, to determine the minimum length of time required before workers or
others are allowed to enter.
The risks from loading and applying the clay-based granular Thimet 15-G (15%
active ingredient) using a Lock'n Load closed handling system and other mitigation
measures, are below the PMRA's level of concern. Approximately 60% of Thimet
15-G is sold in Lock'n Load packaging, according to the registrant. The risk of
loading Thimet 15-G in paper bags (open loading) exceeds the PRMA's level of
concern.
20
Chemical-specific exposure information was used to assess the closed handling
system scenario (Lock'n Load). The Pesticide Handlers Exposure Database (PHED)
was used to assess the open mixing and loading scenario. For Thimet 15-G,
adequate worker protection would be afforded under the following conditions: for
loading activities: Lock'n Load packaging, and personal protective equipment
including chemical resistant apron and gloves; and for application activities: closed
cab. As an interim measure pending implementation of closed cabs, chemical
resistant coveralls over long pants and long sleeves, chemical resistant gloves and a
respirator are recommended for application activities.
Adequate MOEs were not obtained for open loading activities with Thimet 15-G
packaged in paper.
The PMRA concluded that exposure to persons entering treated sites after
application is considered minimal due to the application method (soil incorporation
at planting). A Re-entry interval of 48 h based on acute toxicity is sufficient to
protect workers who may re-enter treated areas.
Toxnet (2017):
Phorate was detected in farmer’s cotton coveralls, worn during pesticide application
(1985-1987).
3.5 Medical data Poisoning incidents
contributing to Usha and Harikrishnan (2004) reported several cases of acute poisoning in
regulatory communities of Kerala, India. Among these, 5 cases (occurred between 1999 and
decision 2002), were associated to exposure to phorate.
According to the authors, in July 1999, about 12 people living in banana crop areas
were severely poisoned by phorate. After the product use, it rained on the region,
causing the product evaporate quickly and spread to nearby area, reaching the
homes. Shortly after application of the product, the symptoms appeared and the
affected required hospitalization. In June 2001, a 16-year-old boy died as a result of
occupational exposure to phorate for a period of one week. That same year, 40 rural
women workers in a tea plantation were intoxicated during harvesting. Symptoms
appeared within 30 minutes after exposure, featured by light-headedness, dizziness,
blurred vision, vomiting. Thirty-seven women had more severe symptoms and
remained hospitalized for two days. The authors point out that in July 2002,
31 children from an upper primary school were poisoned by phorate applied in
plantation nearby school.
The children showed persistent headache, chest pain, breathing difficulty, nausea,
giddiness, blurring of vision and stomach pain, and one of them showed
uncontrolled muscle twitching and convulsions even after 24 hours of treatment.
On 21 July 2006, 20 residents of Salkiana village, district Jalandhar, India, had to be
rushed to a hospital when neurotoxic symptoms of acute exposure to phorate were
observed. The product was used in a nearby sugarcane field. The worst affected
were the schoolchildren of an Elementary School. Teachers and students started
complaining of a strange smell and breathlessness. Suddenly one student fell
unconscious and then students started to faint. Within ten minutes, 16 students
fainted after inhaling something that was toxic. In addition to difficulty breathing,
the most frequent symptoms were feeling poorly, headache, eye irritation, dizziness,
nausea, vomiting, lacrimation, salivation excessive, muscle cramps and pain. Six
days after exposure to phorate, several patients still had symptoms such as eye
irritation, dermal reactions and general uneasiness. (Mission, 2006).
3.6 Public exposure Toxnet (2017):
“Phorate was detected on the hands of farmer’ children at the level of 15 ng,
following application of the pesticide in the fields” and “Secondary exposure of
children through contact with their parent’s contaminated clothing can also occur”.
21
3.7 Summary- Brazil has conducted a risk evaluation of the human health effects of phorate. Based
overall risk on the hazardous properties of phorate as well as on conditions of use in Brazil, the
evaluation expected risks resulting from the exposure of agricultural workers, bystanders and
the general population to phorate were considered too high.
4 Environmental fate and effects
4.1 Fate
4.1.1 Soil Brazil
Breakdown in soil and groundwater: Phorate is of moderate persistence in the
soil environment, with reported field half-lives of 2 to 173 days. A representative
value may be approximately 60 days. Actual residence times may be influenced by
soil clay and organic matter content, rainfall, and soil pH. Soil treatments often
leave more residues in plants than foliar treatments, because the compound persists
in the soil and is readily taken up by plant roots. Phorate binds moderately well to
most soils and is slightly soluble in water. It should therefore not be highly mobile
in most soils, and should mainly be transported with runoff via sediment and water.
Phorate has minimal potential to leach through the soil and contaminate
groundwater. This is most likely where soils are sandy and aquifers are shallow.
Field studies indicate that leaching is very low in soils high in clay and organic
matter content, and low in sandy soils.
Canada
Phorate is transformed by chemical and microbial action. It is moderately persistent
in soil (time required for 50% dissipation (DT50) = 49-75 d) under field conditions,
as seen in field studies in British Columbia. The major transformation products
phorate sulfoxide and phorate sulfone, that are formed as a result of microbial
action, are moderately persistent (DT 50 = 65-137 d) in soil under laboratory
conditions. These transformation products retain the phosphorylated structure and
are expected to exhibit cholinesterase inhibition, and therefore be as toxic as the
parent compound phorate.
Phorate is strongly sorbed to soil and is classified as having slight (Koc = 2000-
3000) to moderate mobility (Koc = 224-450). Phorate sulfoxide and phorate sulfone
partition preferentially into water and are both classified as having moderate (Koc =
172-210) to high mobility (Koc = 71-91) in a range of soil types. Phorate and its
major transformation products can enter aquatic systems through run-off, however,
the latter are more mobile than the parent compound.
4.1.2 Water Brazil
Breakdown in water: The half-life of phorate in acidic water solutions is between
a few days and a few weeks, depending on temperature; the half-life in alkaline
(basic) water may be much shorter. Phorate is degraded by waterborne
microorganisms and hydrolysis. As it breaks down in water, nontoxic, water-
soluble products are formed.
Canada
Phorate is soluble in water at 50 mg/L and highly volatile with a vapour pressure of
85 mPa at 25°C. The Henry's law constant is 4.368 x 10-6 atm.m3/mol, which
indicates there is potential to volatilize from water or moist soil.
Although there may be contamination of surface water through run-off, phorate is
not persistent in water owing to rapid hydrolysis. In sterile water at pH 5, 7 and 9,
the half-lives are 2.6, 3.2 and 3.9 d, respectively. Photolysis is also an important
route of transformation (dark control adjusted half-life of 1.9 d in pH buffer
solutions after 7 d of continuous irradiation). Formaldehyde, phorate sulfoxide and
phorate sulfone are the major transformation products formed during hydrolysis
and aqueous photolysis. Aerobic aquatic biotransformation studies with non-sterile
pond water showed the parent compound and transformation products did not
persist in the water (phorate DT50 of 0.5 d, phorate sulfoxide DT 50 of 9 d, phorate
sulfone DT50 of 21 d) and formaldehyde reached 17% of applied by 14 d after
treatment).
22
4.1.3 Air Canada
Phorate is highly volatile with a vapour pressure of 85 mPa at 25 oC. The Henry’s
law constant of 4.368 X 10-6 indicates there is potential to volatilise from soil and
water. However, as outlined below the literature indicates that phorate is not
persistent in air.
Literature
According to a model of gas/particle partitioning of semivolatile organic
compounds in the atmosphere, phorate, which has a vapour pressure of
0.000638 mm Hg at 25oC, is expected to exist solely as a vapour in the ambient
atmosphere. Vapour-phase phorate is degraded in the atmosphere by reaction with
photochemically-produced hydroxyl radicals; the half-life for this reaction in air is
estimated to be 1.5 hours, calculated from its rate constant of 2.5 X 10 -10
cc/molecule-sec at 25oC that was derived using a structure estimation method.
Laboratory experiments indicated rapid gas-phase photolysis of phorate under
midsummer sunlight conditions with observed half-lives <30 minutes (PubChem,
2017c).
4.1.4 Bioconcentration Canada
The n-octanol-water partition co-efficient (log Kow) is 3.92, which indicates there
is potential for bioaccumulation. However, the rapid degradation in water to more
water soluble products shown above in both the Brazilian and Canadian
notifications would suggest the bioconcentration potential is low. Further Canada
concluded that phorate is not bioaccumulative by the federal Toxic Substances
Management Policy (TSMP) Track-1 cut-off criterion (log Kow ~ 3.92)
Juvenile sheepshead minnows, Cyprinodon variegatus, after 28 days exposure to
phorate had a BCF of 90. According to a classification scheme, this BCF suggests
the potential for bioconcentration in aquatic organisms is moderate.
Bioconcentration of phorate from culture media by the blue green algae Anabaena
sp. (ARM 310) and Aulosira fertilissima (ARM 68) was studied. Bioconcentration
factors for phorate in Anabaena sp. were 3, 6 and 12 at 2.5, 5 and 10 µg/mL,
respectively. Elodea nuttallii plants grown for 2 weeks in water with a deposit of
C14-phorate in the bottom soil accumulated 30% of the originally soil-applied
radiocarbon in their tissues; 56% of phorate accumulated in plant tissues when the
insecticide was applied directly to the water (PubChem, 2017c).
4.1.5 Persistence Canada
Phorate in soil is moderately persistent (time required for 50% dissipation (DT 50) =
49-75 d) under field conditions, as seen in field studies in British Columbia. The
major transformation products phorate sulfoxide and phorate sulfone, that are
formed as a result of microbial action, are moderately persistent (DT 50 - 65-137 d)
in soil under laboratory conditions.
Although there may be contamination of surface water through run-off, phorate is
not persistent in water owing to rapid hydrolysis. In sterile water at pH 5, 7 and 9,
the half-lives are 2.6, 3.2 and 3.9 d, respectively. Aerobic aquatic biotransformation
studies with nonsterile pond water showed that the parent compound and
transformation products did not persist in the water (phorate DT 50 of 0.5 d, phorate
sulfoxide DT50 of 9 d, phorate sulfone DT 50 of 21 d and formaldehyde reached 17%
of applied by 14 d after treatment).
After phorate (Thimet 15-G) was assessed in regard to the federal Toxic Substances
Management Policy (TSMP) it was concluded that phorate does not meet the
TSMP criteria for persistence.
4.2 Effects on non-
target organisms
4.2.1 Terrestrial Brazil
vertebrates Effects on birds: Phorate is very highly toxic to birds. The reported acute oral LD 50
values are:
23
12.8 mg/kg in chukar, 7.5 mg/kg in starlings, 0.6 to 2.5 mg/kg in mallards, 7 to
21 mg/kg in northern bobwhite quail, 1 mg/kg in red-winged blackbirds, and
7 mg/kg in ring-neck pheasants.
The 5- to 8-day dietary LC50 values are reported as 370 to 580 ppm in Japanese
quail, mallard, northern bobwhite quail, and ring-neck pheasant.
Canada
Studies have shown that phorate is very highly toxic to birds on an acute oral basis
(mallard duck mean lethal dose (LD50) = 0.62 mg a.i./kg), and is highly toxic to
birds on a dietary basis (mallard duck LD50 = 248 mg a.i./kg). Phorate is very
highly toxic to small mammals on an acute oral basis (rat LD 50 = 1.1-3.7 mg a.i./kg)
and on a dietary basis (rat LD50 = 28 mg a.i./kg).
4.2.2 Aquatic species Brazil
Effects on aquatic organisms:
Phorate is very highly toxic to fish. Reported 96-hour LC50 values range from 2 to
13 µg/L in cutthroat trout, bluegill sunfish and largemouth bass. Other 96-hour
LC50 values are 110 µg/L in northern pike and 280 µg/L in channel catfish.
Reported 96-hour LC50 values for the compound in freshwater invertebrates such as
stoneflies and scuds are 4 µg/L, also indicating very high toxicity. Other LC 50
values are 0.006 µg/L for amphipods and 0.11 to 1.9 µg/L in other freshwater
invertebrates. The acute oral LD50 of phorate is 85 mg/kg in bullfrogs.
Canada
Phorate is very highly toxic on an acute basis to fish (rainbow trout mean lethal
concentration (LC50) = 13 µg a.i./L) and to aquatic invertebrates (Gammarus
fasciatus LC50 = 4 µg a.i./L).
Pesticide Properties DataBase (PPDB, 2018)
Fish - Acute 96 hour LC50 = 0.013 mg/L Oncorhynchus mykiss.
Fish - Chronic 21 day NOEC = 0.0002 mg/L Oncorhynchus mykiss.
Aquatic invertebrates - Acute 48 hour EC50 = 0.004 mg/L Daphnia magna.
Aquatic crustaceans - Acute 96 hour LC50 = 0.00033 mg/L Americamysis bahia.
Sediment dwelling organisms - Acute 96 hour LC50 = 0.081 mg/L Chironomus
riparius.
Algae - Acute 72 hour EC50, growth 0.13 mg/L. Unknown species.
4.2.3 Honeybees and Brazil
other arthropods Phorate is toxic to bees, with a reported topical application LD 50 of 10 µg per bee.
Canada
Phorate is moderately to highly toxic to bees on an acute contact basis
(0.32-10.1 µg a.i./bee).
4.2.4 Earthworms Pesticide Properties DataBase (PPDB, 2018)
Earthworms - Acute 14 day LC50 (mg kg-1) 20.8 Eisenia foetida.
4.2.5 Soil No data available
microorganisms
4.2.6 Terrestrial No data available
plants
5 Environmental Exposure/Risk Evaluation
5.1 Terrestrial The Brazilian notification does not contain any information or summary of the
vertebrates environmental risk assessment conclusions for terrestrial vertebrates.
Canada
Extremely high risks to terrestrial organisms have been identified from registered
uses of phorate. This assessment is supported by reports of incidents in Canada and
the U.S. Estimated exposure concentrations for terrestrial organisms exceed acute
24
effects levels for both birds and mammals. For in-furrow applications, the estimated
surface exposure is 1%. For banded subsurface emplacement to corn and rutabagas,
the estimated surface exposure is 15%. The acute risk from direct consumption of
granules is greatest for smaller species. The number of lethal doses (LD50s) that are
available within one square metre immediately after application (LD 50s/m2) is used
as the risk quotient (RQ) for granular products.
Risk quotients for acute effects in mammals were greater than 1 LD50/m2, the
threshold of concern for tested species, for use on potatoes and beans. Risk
quotients ranged from 198 to 13 112 LD50s/m2 for surface broadcast applications to
beans and 98 to 6 481 LD50s/m2 for in-furrow applications to potatoes, depending
upon the size of the mammal. For applications to lettuce, risk quotients ranged from
99 to 6556 LD50s/m2, for corn from 101 to 6782 LD50s/m2 and for rutabagas from
417 to 55 340 LD50s/m2. These are classified as high to extremely high risk.
Risk quotients for acute effects in birds were greater than 1 LD 50/m2, the threshold
of concern for tested species, for use on beans and potatoes. Risk quotients ranged
from 170 to 21 623 LD50s/m2 for surface broadcast applications to beans and 84 to
10 687 LD50s/m2 for in-furrow applications to potatoes depending upon the size of
the bird. For applications to lettuce risk quotients ranged from 85 to 10 811
LD50s/m2, for corn from 88 to 11 184 LD50s/m2 and for rutabagas from 358 to
91 263 LD50s/m2. These risk quotients are classified as high risk to extremely high
risk. Birds may also be exposed by other routes, such as by walking on exposed
granules and bathing, drinking water contaminated by granules and by eating
tainted prey.
5.2 Aquatic species Extremely high risks to aquatic organisms have been identified from all registered
uses of phorate. This assessment is supported by reports of incidents of adverse
effects in the U.S. Similar effects may have occurred in Canada, but there is no
equivalent reporting system in this country.
Estimated environmental concentrations exceed acute and chronic effects levels in
both fish and aquatic invertebrates:
Risk quotients for acute and chronic effects on the majority of freshwater aquatic
invertebrates tested were greater than 1, the threshold of concern. Risk quotients
exceeded 1000 for use on potatoes (RQ = 1476), beans (RQ = 1495), lettuce (RQ =
1917), corn (RQ = 2650) and rutabagas (RQ = 4500) and are classified as extremely
high risk.
Risk quotients for acute and chronic effects on freshwater fish were greater than 1,
the threshold of concern. Values exceeded 100 for applications to beans (RQ =
165), corn (RQ = 122) and rutabagas (RQ = 415) and are classified as very high
risk. For applications to lettuce (RQ = 89), the acute and chronic risks were
classified as high risk, as the RQ was greater than 10.
For estuarine and marine fish and invertebrates, the acute and chronic risk quotients
exceeded 1000, which is classified as extremely high risk.
5.3 Honey bees The Brazilian or Canadian notifications do not contain any information or summary
of the environmental risk assessment conclusions for honey bees.
5.4 Earthworms The Brazilian or Canadian notifications do not contain any information or summary
of the environmental risk assessment conclusions for earthworms.
5.5 Soil The Brazilian or Canadian notifications do not contain any information or summary
microorganisms of the environmental risk assessment conclusions for soil microorganisms.
5.6 Summary – Risk quotients and margins of safety calculated for applications of Thimet 15-G
overall risk indicate risks for all groups of organisms (birds, mammals, fish and aquatic
evaluation invertebrates) for all application scenarios. Based on the available toxicity data, risk
is classified as high to extremely high risk for freshwater aquatic organisms and
high to extremely high risk for birds. Similarly, risk to mammals is classified as
high risk for large mammals to extremely high risk to small mammals.
The identified risks to birds and fish are supported by reported incidents arising
from labelled use of the products.
The use of phorate and associated end-use products (EP) entails an unacceptable
risk to the environment pursuant to Section 20 of the Canadian Pest Control
25
Product (PCP) Regulations. As a result, the Pest Management Regulatory Agency
(PMRA) determined that all uses of phorate were to be phased out 8.
8 The use on potato was subsequently extended to August 2015. Furthermore, it should be noted that a new
phorate product, paired with application equipment to reduce environmental exposure, was registered in 2015.
26
Annex 2 – Details on final regulatory actions reported
Country Name: Brazil
1 Effective date(s) of March 16th, 2015
entry into force of
actions
Reference to the Resolution RDC No. 12 of 13 March 2015, issued by the National Health
regulatory Surveillance Agency (ANVISA)
document
2 Succinct details of Pursuant to resolution RDC No. 12 of 13 March 2015, issued by ANVISA, all
the final technical and formulated products based on phorate active ingredient are prohibited.
regulatory Consequently, production, use, trade, import and export of phorate are banned.
action(s) Before the final regulatory action entered into force, phorate was used in Brazil as
an insecticide authorized exclusively for agricultural use.
3 Reasons for action Human health: unacceptable risk for workers, consumers and general population.
4 Basis for inclusion The final regulatory action to ban phorate was based on a risk evaluation taking into
into Annex III consideration local conditions in Brazil.
4.1 Risk evaluation The final regulatory action was based on a risk and hazard evaluation. In accordance
with the Brazilian Pesticide Law, one or more of the governmental agencies
responsible for the pesticides registration (IBAMA, ANVISA or MAPA) can
re-evaluate the registration of a pesticide, when there is evidence of reduction of
agronomic efficiency and/or change of risks to human health or environment. In
order to carry out the re-evaluation a Technical Committee is established. The
Committee develops Technical Notes on the toxicology and/or potential
environmental hazards of the active ingredient in addition to an economic analysis
of pesticide substitutes, based on data collected from studies and surveys conducted
by national and international accredited institutions as well as information provided
by the National System of Toxic-Pharmacological Intoxications and Poisonings
(SINITOX), the Pesticide Residues in Food Analysis Programme or the pesticide
registrants.
The Technical Notes in the re-evaluation process assess the potential exposure and
exposure and the hazard in accordance with the parameters and methodologies
adopted internationally, especially by the World Health Organization (WHO),), the
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), the Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development (OECD), the USA Environmental Protection Agency
and the European Union. After the re-evaluation, measures to restrict, suspend or
prohibit the production and import of pesticides could be taken as well as to cancel
the registration, if a criterion of prohibition of registration is fulfilled.
The Brazil risk evaluation of phorate took into account toxicology and public
health, occupational health and safety, the environmental impact and availability of
lower-risk alternatives. An extensive review of relevant data on hazard and risk of
phorate using reviewed documents, published reports and literature was undertaken.
The re-evaluation took into account inter alia the study carried out by Waichman
(2008) in municipalities of the state of Amazonas (Manaus, Iranduba, Careiro da
Várzea and Manacapuru). This study concluded that farmers were not prepared for
the proper use of pesticides, ignoring the risks of these products to human health
and the environment. Personal protective equipment is not used because it is
expensive, uncomfortable and unsuitable for the hot climate of the region. Lack of
training and poor knowledge of the hazards of pesticides contribute to the incorrect
handling during their preparation and application, as well as the disposal of empty
containers. In these conditions, the exposure of farmers, their families, consumers
and the environment is high.
Considering all the toxicological effects associated with the active ingredient
phorate, especially its characteristics to be more toxic to humans than animal tests
are able to demonstrate, and although no poisoning incidents with phorate have
been reported from Brazil, the decision to ban phorate was taken on the basis of the
evaluation of its hazardous properties as well as the expected exposure of
27
agricultural workers to phorate under conditions of use in Brazil. The final
regulatory action was taken in order to protect the health of exposed workers,
consumers and the general population.
4.2 Criteria used Risks to human health and the environment
Relevance to other Similar concerns to those identified are likely to be encountered in other countries
States and Region where the substance is used, particularly in developing countries.
5 Alternatives See section 3.3
6 Waste None reported
management
7 Other None reported
28
Country Name: Canada
1 Effective date(s) In December 2004.
of entry into
force of actions
Reference to the Relevant regulatory documents are:
regulatory
− Proposed Acceptability for Continuing Registration (PACR 2003-01), Pest
document
Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) Re-evaluation of Phorate, January
24 , 2003
− Re-evaluation Decision Document (RRD 2004-11) Phorate, 13 May 2004,
− Re-evaluation note, Rev2007-07, Update on the Use of Phorate on Potatoes,
5 June 2007.
2 Succinct details The use of phorate and associated end-use products (EP) entails an unacceptable
of the final risk of harm to the environment pursuant to Section 20 of the Canadian Pest Control
regulatory Product (PCP) Regulation. As a result, PMRA determined that all uses of phorate
action(s) were to be phased out. Due to the lack of alternatives to phorate for control of
wireworm on potatoes, the registration of phorate, for this use only, was allowed to
be continued, with interim mitigation measures to protect workers (engineering,
controls, requirements regarding additional Personal Protective Equipment (PPE))
and the environment (environmental statements on the label).
3 Reasons for Environment: an unacceptable risk of harm to the environment
action
4 Basis for The final regulatory action to ban phorate was based on a risk evaluation taking into
inclusion into consideration local conditions in Canada.
Annex III
4.1 Risk evaluation Phorate is highly toxic to all terrestrial and aquatic species tested. Incident reports
of bird and mammal fatalities in Canada, the United States of America, the
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland support the conclusion that
phorate presents a significant risk to birds and wildlife. Surface broadcast
application presents the greatest risk owing to the large number of exposed granules
on the surface. Although soil incorporation is expected to lower the risk of
terrestrial and aquatic exposure, it nevertheless presents a very high risk owing to
unincorporated granules remaining exposed on the surface. The risk to small and
moderate-sized birds and small or moderate-sized mammals remains high to very
high with either method of application. Owing to its extreme toxicity to all
organisms tested, the very high risk to moderate and smaller sized birds and
mammals, the incident reports of bird and mammal mortalities (including large
raptors in Canada), in addition to the persistence and mobility of the toxic sulfoxide
and sulfone transformation products, Canada has concluded that the use of phorate
in the country presents a high risk to the environment. Additional information on
toxicity for aquatic organisms was also given in the supporting documentation
provided by Canada.
4.2 Criteria used Risks to the environment
Relevance to Similar concerns to those identified are likely to be encountered in other countries
other States and where the substance is used, particularly in developing countries.
Region
5 Alternatives See section 3.3
6 Waste None reported
management
7 Other None reported
29
Annex 3 – Addresses of designated national authorities
BRAZIL
Role: DNA CP* Phone: +55 61 2030 9644
Name: Mr. Reinaldo Salgado
Job title: Director Fax: +55 61 2030 5102
Department: Department for Environmental Sustainability
Institution: Ministry of Foreign Affairs Email:
[email protected],
Postal address: Esplanada dos Ministerios
[email protected],
Bloco H, Anexo II, Sala 204
[email protected]
70170-900 Brasilia D.F.
Brazil
Role(s): DNA CP* Phone: +55 61 3316 1592
Job title: Director
Department: Department of Environmental Quality (DIQUA) Fax: +55 61 3316 1347
Institution: Brazilian Institute for the Environment and the
Renewable Resources (IBAMA) Email:
[email protected]
Postal address: SCEN - Trecho 2 - Edificio Sede do IBAMA
70818-900 Brasilia D.F.
Brazil
Role(s): DNA CP* Phone: +55 61 2028 2355
Job title: Director - Secretariat of Climate Change and
Environmental Quality Fax: +55 61 2028 2073
Department: Department of Environmental Quality in Industry
Institution: Ministry of Environment Email:
[email protected]
Postal address: SEPN 505, Bloco B
70730-542 Brasilia D.F.
Brazil
CANADA
Role(s): DNA P* Phone: +1 613 736 3660
Name: Mr. Jason Flint
Job title: Director General Fax: +1 613 736 3695
Department: Policy, Communications and Regulatory Affairs
Institution: Pest Management Regulatory Agency Email:
[email protected]
Postal address: 2720 Riverside Drive
K1A 0K9 Ottawa
Quebec
Canada
Role: DNA C* Phone: +1 819 420 8047
Name: Ms. Nathalie Morin
Job title: Director Fax: +1 819 938 4218
Department: Chemical Production Division
Institution: Environment and Climate Change Canada Email:
[email protected]
Postal address: 351 St. Joseph Boulevard
K1A OH3 Gatineau
Québec
Canada
*C Industrial chemicals
CP Pesticides and industrial chemicals
P Pesticides
30
Annex 4 – References
Regulatory actions
Brazil:
The National Health Surveillance Agency (ANVISA) (2015): Resolution RDC No 12 of March 13, 2015, Document
UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/27.pdf
Canada:
Health Canada (2007): Re-evaluation Note REV2007-07: Update of the Use of Phorate on Potatoes. Pest Management
Regulatory Agency, 5 June 2007, Document UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1
Health Canada (2004): Re-evaluation Decision Document RRD2004-11: Phorate. Pest Management Regulatory
Agency, 13 May 2004, Document UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1
Health Canada (2003): Proposed acceptability for continued registration PACR 2003-01: Re-evaluation of Phorate.
Pest Management Regulatory Agency, 25 January 2003, Document UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1
Supporting documentation provided by Brazil:
Brazil (2017): Focused summary of the Notification of Final Regulatory Action for Phorate - Brazil. Document
UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/29.pdf.
Technical notes on the toxicological revaluation on the active ingredient phorate –prepared by National Health
Surveillance Agency (ANVISA) with collaboration of Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (FIOCRUZ). Document
UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/29.pdf (in Portuguese)
Usha and Harikrishnan (2004): Documentation of Pesticide Poisoning in Kerala and its Implications on Health and
Agriculture Planning and Policy. Kerala Research Programme on Local Level Development Centre for Development
Studies Thiruvananthapuram. 2004.96p. As cited in UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/29.pdf.
Mission (2006): Pesticide Spray Proves Disastrous In Salkiana Village, Jalandhar. 2006.
http://www.worldproutassembly.org/archives/2006/08/pesticide_spray.html. As cited in
UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/29.pdf
Waichman (2008): Uma proposta de avaliação integrada de risco do uso de agrotóxicos no estado do Amazonas,
Brasil. Acta Amazônica, v. 38, n. 1, p. 45-51, 2008. As cited in UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.13/INF/29.pdf.
Supporting documentation provided by Canada:
Health Canada (2008): Re-evaluation Note REV2008-05: Update of the Use of Phorate on Potatoes.
Pest Management Regulatory Agency, 26 March 2008
Health Canada (2012): Re-evaluation Note REV2012-01: Update of the Use of Phorate on Potatoes. Pest Management
Regulatory Agency, 28 May 2012.
To access these documents, they must be requested at the following link: https://www.canada.ca/en/
health-canada/services/consumer-product-safety/reports-publications/pesticides-pest-
management/decisions-updates.html#revnote.
It is noted that an excerpt for Phorate from re-evaluation summary table is not available online but is provided in
Document UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1
Pesticide Manual 11th Edition: Extract on Phorate. As cited in: UNEP/FAO/RC/CRC.5/9/Add.1
Other Documents
E-World Trade Fair (2017): http://www.eworldtradefair.com/phorate-manufacturers-india.html , access date
13 December 2017.
Extoxnet (1996): Extension Toxicology Network, Pesticide Information Profiles:
http://extoxnet.orst.edu/pips/phorate.htm
Extoxnet (2017): http://pmep.cce.cornell.edu/profiles/extoxnet/metiram-propoxur/phorate-ext.html, access date
13 December 2017
FAO (2015): Guidelines on Good Labelling Practice for Pesticides (revised). International Code of Conduct on
Pesticides. Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations and World Health Organisation.
31
http://www.schc.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=309:revised-guidelines-on-good-labelling-
practice-for-pesticides--2015-&catid=25:newsworthy&Itemid=199
IPCS INCHEM (undated), PHORATE
http://www.inchem.org/documents/jmpr/jmpmono/v94pr08.htm
JMPR Report 2012: Food and Agriculture Organisation of United Nations (FAO) and World Health Organisation
(WHO), Pesticide Residues in Food 2012. Joint FAO/WHO Meeting on Pesticide Residues. FAO Plant Production
and Protection Paper 215:
http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/agphome/documents/Pests_Pesticides/JMPR/Report12/JMPR_2012_Report.p
df
JMPR Report 2004: Food and Agriculture Organisation of United Nations (FAO) and World Health Organisation
(WHO), Pesticide Residues in Food 2004. Joint FAO/WHO Meeting on Pesticide Residues. FAO Plant Production
and Protection Paper 178:
http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/agphome/documents/Pests_Pesticides/JMPR/Reports_1991-
2006/report2004jmpr.pdf
NIOSH (2000): International Chemical Safety Cards: Phorate. https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/ipcsneng/neng1060.html,
accessed 13 December, 2017.
PMRA: Evaluation Report to Register a new granular insecticide end-use product. http://pr-rp.hc-
sc.gc.ca/1_1/view_label?p_ukid=96999729
PPDB (2018) Pesticide Properties DataBase phorate (Ref: ENT 24042),
http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/aeru/ppdb/en/Reports/519.htm
PubChem (2017a): PubChem database, Compound Summary for CID 4790, phorate. National Institute of Health,
Open Chemistry Database, https://PubChem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/phorate#section=First-Aid-Measures.
PubChem (2017b): PubChem database, Compound Summary for CID 4790, phorate. Disposal methods. National
Institute of Health, Open Chemistry Database
https://PubChem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/phorate#section=Disposal-Methods
PubChem (2017c): PubChem database, Compound Summary for CID 4790, phorate. National Institute of Health,
Open Chemistry Database, https://PubChem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/phorate#section=Top
TOXNET (2017): https://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/sis/search2/r?dbs+hsdb:@term+@rn+@rel+298-02-2, access
date 13 December 2017.
National or industrial Safety Data Sheets (non-exhaustive):
Central Pollution Control Board of India (2017): Material Safety Data Sheets, 490, accessed 13 December, 2017.
http://cpcb.nic.in/divisionsofheadoffice/pci-ssi/MATERIAL_SAFETY-DATABASE/MSDS2008/490.pdf
Sigma Aldrich (2015): Safety Datasheet, Phorate. Date: 8 April 2015.
https://www.sigmaaldrich.com/MSDS/MSDS/DisplayMSDSPage.do?country=PL&language=EN-
generic&productNumber=33388&brand=SIAL&PageToGoToURL=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.sigmaaldrich.com%2Fc
atalog%2Fproduct%2Fsial%2F33388%3Flang%3Dpl. Access date 13 December 2017.
Relevant guidelines and reference documents
Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal 1996.
Available at: www.basel.int
FAO (1995a): Guidelines on Good Labelling Practice for Pesticides. Rome. Available at:
http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/agphome/documents/Pests_Pesticides/Code/Old_guidelines/label.pdf
FAO (1995b): Guidelines on Prevention of Accumulation of Obsolete Pesticide Stocks. FAO, Rome. Available at:
http://www.fao.org/3/a-v7460e.pdf
FAO (1996a): The Pesticide Storage and Stock Control Manual, Rome. Available at:
http://www.fao.org/agriculture/crops/obsolete-pesticides/resources0/en/
FAO (1996b): Technical guidelines on disposal of bulk quantities of obsolete pesticides in developing countries.
Available at: http://www.fao.org/agriculture/crops/thematic-sitemap/theme/pests/code/list-guide-new/en/
FAO (1999): Guidelines for the management of small quantities of unwanted and obsolete pesticides, Rome.
Available at: http://www.fao.org/agriculture/crops/thematic-sitemap/theme/pests/code/list-guide-new/en/
32
INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMISSION OF AN IMPORT RESPONSE
FORM FOR IMPORT RESPONSE
Country:
r
INSTRUCTION: The
category or categories
SECTION 1 IDENTITY OF CHEMICAL checked here must be
1.1 Common name consistent with the
categories listed for
the chemical in Annex
III of the Convention.
1.2 CA S numbe r
The response given
later in Section 4 or
5 must relate to the
1.3 Cat egory Pe s tic id e category or categories
In dus trial
checked in this section.
Se ver ely h azar do us p es ticide for mu lation
INSTRUCTION: Both a
final decision as well
SECTION 2 INDICATION REGARDING PREVIOUS RESPONSE, IF ANY as an interim decision
2.1 Th is is a firs t time impo rt res po nse for th is c he mica l in th e co un tr y . can be revised with a
resubmitted completed
2.2 Th is is a mod ific a tion o f a p rev io us r esp on se .
Da te o f iss ue o f th e pr ev io us res po ns e : ..........................................................
Import Response Form.
The previous decision
will always be replaced
SECTION 3 RESPONSE REGARDING FUTURE IMPORT
by the new response.
Final decision (Fill in section 4 below) OR Interim response (Fill in section 5 below)
INSTRUCTION: Please check ONLY ONE of the two options to indicate
whether the response given in the form is a final decision OR an
interim response.
Page 1
SECTION 4 FINAL DECISION, PURSUANT TO NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE OR INSTRUCTION:
ADMINISTRATIVE MEASURES Section 4 must be
4.1 No conse nt t o import filled in ONLY WHEN
Is th e impo r t o f th e ch e mical fro m all so urc es a final decision has
Yes No
simu lta ne ous ly pro hib ited ? been taken.
Is domes tic pro du c tion of the c he mic al for domes tic use Yes No
simu lta ne ous ly pro hib ited ?
4.2 Cons e nt t o import
4.3 Cons e nt t o import only subject t o spec ified condit ions
Th e sp ec ified c on ditio ns a re :
Ar e th e co nd itions for impor t o f th e ch e mica l th e sa me for Yes No
all so urc es o f imp or t?
Ar e th e co nd itions for d o me s tic pro du ction o f the c he mica l Yes No
fo r d o mes tic us e th e sa me a s for all impor ts ?
4.4 Nat iona l le gislat ive or a dminist rat ive me as ure upon whic h t he f ina l dec is ion
is bas ed
Descr iption o f the na tio na l leg is la tive or a d ministr a tiv e me as ure :
INSTRUCTION:
SECTION 5 INTERIM RESPONSE
Section 5 must be
5.1 No conse nt t o import filled in ONLY WHEN
Is th e impo r t o f th e ch e mical fro m all so urc es
no final decision
Yes No
simu lta ne ous ly pro hib ited ? has been taken. An
Is domes tic pro du c tion of the c he mic al for domes tic use
Yes No interim response
simu lta ne ous ly pro hib ited ?
is valid during the
5.2 Cons e nt t o import
period until a final
decision is reached.
INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMISSION OF AN IMPORT RESPONSE Page 2
5.3 Cons e nt t o import only subject t o spec ified condit ions
Th e sp ec ified c on ditio ns a re :
Ar e th e co nd itions for impor t o f th e ch e mica l th e sa me for Yes No
all so urc es o f imp or t?
Ar e th e co nd itions for d o me s tic pro du ction o f the c he mica l Yes No
fo r d o mes tic us e th e sa me a s for all impor ts ? INSTRUCTION: If
5.4 Indica tion of a ct ive c ons iderat ion in order t o r ea c h a f ina l de c is ion additional information
Is a fin al de cis io n u nd er a c tiv e co ns id era tio n?
is required, this
Yes No
must be clearly
5.5 Inf ormat ion or a ss ist ance re que st ed in orde r to re ac h a f inal dec is ion stated. If assistance
Th e fo llow in g a dd ition al in for mation is re qu es ted fr o m the Secr e tar iat: is requested from
the Secretariat
in evaluating the
chemical, the specific
areas of difficulty
and the nature of the
Th e fo llow in g a dd ition al in for mation is re qu es ted fr o m the c ou n try tha t n o tifie d
assistance requested
th e fina l r eg ula tory ac tion :
should be indicated.
Th e fo llow in g as sis tanc e is re qu es te d fro m the Secre tar ia t in e va lu a ting the
che mica l:
SECTION 6 RELEVANT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, WHICH MAY INCLUDE:
Is this ch e mic al curr en tly r eg is te re d in the c ou n try ? Yes No
Is this ch e mic al man u fac tur ed in the c ou ntry? Ye s No
INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMISSION OF AN IMPORT RESPONSE Page 3
If ye s to e it he r o ne of t he se que st ions:
Is this inten de d fo r do mes tic us e? Ye s No
Is this inten de d fo r ex por t? Ye s No
Ot he r remarks
SECTION 7 DESIGNATED NATIONAL AUTHORITY
In stitu tio n
Addr ess
Na me o f p ers on in c har ge
Positio n o f pers on in ch arg e
Te le ph on e
Te le fax
E- mail a dd res s
Da te , s ig na tur e o f D N A a nd offic ia l se al: __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ _
PLEASE RETURN THE COMPLETED FORM TO:
Secretariat for the Rotterdam Convention Secretariat for the Rotterdam Convention
Food and Agriculture Organization United Nations Environment
of the United Nations (FAO) Programme (UNEP)
Viale delle Terme di Caracalla OR 11-13, Chemin des Anémones
00100 Rome, Italy CH – 1219 Châtelaine, Geneva, Switzerland
Tel: (+39 06) 5705 3441 Tel: (+41 22) 917 8177
Fax: (+39 06) 5705 6347 Fax: (+41 22) 917 8082
E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected]
INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMISSION OF AN IMPORT RESPONSE Page 4
ROTTERDAM CONVENTION
Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention
United Nations Environment Programme Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Office Address: International Environment House 1 Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, 00153 Rome, Italy
11–13, chemin des Anémones, 1219 Châtelaine, Geneva, Switzerland Tel: +39 06 5705 2061 ¦ Fax: +39 06 5705 3224 ¦ E-mail:
[email protected]
Postal Address: c/o Palais des Nations, 8-14, avenue de la Paix, 1211 Geneva 10,
Switzerland
Tel.: +41 (0) 22 917 8271 ¦ Fax: +41 (0) 22 917 8098 ¦ E-mail:
[email protected]
16 September 2019
Re: Dispatch of Decision Guidance Documents and request for submission of import responses
on hexabromocyclododecane and phorate
Dear Designated National Authority,
At its ninth meeting, by decisions RC-9/3 and RC-9/4, the Conference of the Parties to the
Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain Hazardous Chemicals and
Pesticides in International Trade agreed to amend Annex III to the Convention to list therein the
following chemicals:
- Hexabromocyclododecane; and
- Phorate.
The amendments to the Convention enter into force for all Parties on 16 September 2019. A copy
of the depositary notification (Reference: C.N.397.2019.TREATIES-XXVII.14) containing the full text of
these amendments in the six official United Nations languages is enclosed with this letter (enclosure 1).
Article 10, paragraph 2, of the Rotterdam Convention provides that each Party shall transmit to
the Secretariat, as soon as possible, and in any event no later than nine months after the date of dispatch
of the Decision Guidance Document (DGD) for a chemical, a response concerning the future import of
the chemical concerned. The Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention is herewith distributing the DGDs
for the above listed chemicals (enclosure 2) to all Parties with the request that they submit to the
Secretariat their response concerning the future import of these chemicals by 16 June 2020.
The import responses of your country may be transmitted using the on-line import response form
(available at http://www.pic.int/tabid/1165) or the enclosed word form (enclosure 3). In the latter case, the
original hard copy of the completed form, signed, dated and affixed with the official seal of the replying
authority, should be sent to the Secretariat by post, with a copy retained for your records. Further copies
of the import response form and instructions, as well as the DGDs may be found in English, French and
Spanish on the Rotterdam Convention web site http://www.pic.int.
To: Rotterdam Convention Designated National Authorities
cc: Rotterdam Convention Official Contact Points
Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention Page | 2
Article 10, paragraph 3, requires that the Secretariat, at the expiration of the time period indicated
in paragraph 2, address to a Party that has not provided such a response, a written request to do so. The
Secretariat will fulfil this obligation by listing in Appendix IV of PIC Circular LII (52), scheduled to be
dispatched in December 2020, those Parties that have failed to transmit import responses for these
chemicals.
If your country has nominated more than one Designated National Authority, you are kindly
requested to submit consolidated responses regarding the future import of these chemicals.
Thank you for your continued support of the Rotterdam Convention. We look forward to hearing
from you in due course. Please contact the Secretariat at the addresses provided in the letterhead if you
have any questions.
Yours sincerely,
Rolph Payet Hans Dreyer
Executive Secretary of the Basel, Rotterdam Executive Secretary of the Rotterdam
and Stockholm Conventions Convention
Enclosures:
- Enclosure 1: Depositary notification on the amendments
- Enclosure 2: Decision Guidance Document for the above listed chemicals
- Enclosure 3: Import response form and instructions
Reference: C.N.397.2019.TREATIES-XXVII.14 (Depositary Notification)
ROTTERDAM CONVENTION ON THE PRIOR INFORMED CONSENT
PROCEDURE FOR CERTAIN HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS AND PESTICIDES
IN INTERNATIONAL TRADE
ROTTERDAM, 10 SEPTEMBER 1998
AMENDMENTS TO ANNEX III
The Secretary-General of the United Nations, acting in his capacity as depositary,
communicates the following:
By letter dated 16 August 2019, the Executive Secretary of the Rotterdam Convention
informed the depositary that at its ninth meeting, held in Geneva from 29 April to 10 May 2019, by
decisions RC-9/3 and RC-9/4, the Conference of the Parties to the above Convention, in accordance
with the procedure laid down in paragraph 5 of article 22 of the Convention, adopted amendments to
Annex III to list therein the following chemicals: hexabromocyclododecane and phorate.
By the said decisions, in accordance with paragraph 5 (c) of article 22 of the Convention, these
amendments shall enter into force for all Parties on 16 September 2019.
…. The text of the amendments to Annex III, as contained in the above-mentioned decisions, in
the six authentic languages is transmitted herewith.
28 August 2019
C.N.397.2019.TREATIES-XXVII.14
Annex / Annexe
اﳌﻘﺮر ا ر :٣/٩-إدراج اﻟﺪودﻳﻜﺎن اﳊﻠﻘﻲ اﻟﺴﺪاﺳﻲ اﻟﱪوم ﰲ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام
إن ﻣﺆﲤﺮ اﻷﻃﺮاف،
إذ ﻳﻼﺣﻆ ﻣﻊ اﻟﺘﻘﺪﻳﺮ ﻋﻤﻞ ﳉﻨﺔ اﺳﺘﻌﺮاض اﳌﻮاد اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ،
وﻗﺪ ﻧﻈﺮ ﰲ ﺗﻮﺻﻴﺔ ﳉﻨﺔ اﺳﺘﻌﺮاض اﳌﻮاد اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ ﺧﻀﺎع اﻟﺪودﻳﻜﺎن اﳊﻠﻘﻲ اﻟﺴﺪاﺳﻲ اﻟﱪوم
ﻹﺟﺮاء اﳌﻮاﻓﻘﺔ اﳌﺴﺒﻘﺔ ﻋﻦ ﻋﻠﻢ وإدراﺟﻪ ،وﻓﻘﺎً ﻟﺬﻟﻚ ،ﺑﻮﺻﻔﻪ ﻣﺎدة ﻛﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ ﺻﻨﺎﻋﻴﺔ ﰲ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ
ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام اﳌﺘﻌﻠﻘﺔ ﺑﺘﻄﺒﻴﻖ إﺟﺮاء اﳌﻮاﻓﻘﺔ اﳌﺴﺒﻘﺔ ﻋﻦ ﻋﻠﻢ ﻋﻠﻰ ﻣﻮاد ﻛﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ وﻣﺒﻴﺪات آﻓﺎت ﻣﻌﻴﻨﺔ
ﺧﻄﺮة ﻣﺘﺪاوﻟﺔ ﰲ اﻟﺘﺠﺎرة اﻟﺪوﻟﻴﺔ،
وﻗﺪ اﻗﺘﻨﻊ ن ﲨﻴﻊ ﺷﺮوط اﻹدراج ﰲ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام ﻗﺪ اﺳﺘُﻮﻓﻴﺖ،
- ١ﻳﻘﺮر ﺗﻌﺪﻳﻞ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام ﻣﻦ أﺟﻞ إدراج اﳌﺎدة اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ اﻟﺘﺎﻟﻴﺔ:
اﻟﻔﺌﺔ اﻟﺮﻗﻢ/اﻷرﻗﺎم ذات اﻟﺼﻠﺔ ﰲ ﺳﺠﻞ اﳌﺎدة اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ
داﺋﺮة اﳌﺴﺘﺨﻠﺼﺎت اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ
ﻣﺎدة ﻛﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ ٤-٩٩-٢٥٦٣٧ اﻟﺪودﻳﻜﺎن اﳊﻠﻘﻲ اﻟﺴﺪاﺳﻲ اﻟﱪوم
ﺻﻨﺎﻋﻴﺔ ٦-٥٥-٣١٩٤
٦-٥٠-١٣٤٢٣٧
٧-٥١-١٣٤٢٣٧
٨-٥٢-١٣٤٢٣٧
- ٢ﻳﻘﺮر أﻳﻀﺎً أن ﻳﺒﺪأ ﻧﻔﺎذ ﻫﺬا اﻟﺘﻌﺪﻳﻞ ﻟﻨﺴﺒﺔ ﳉﻤﻴﻊ اﻷﻃﺮاف ﰲ ١٦أﻳﻠﻮل/ﺳﺒﺘﻤﱪ ٢٠١٩؛
- ٣ﻳﻌﺘﻤﺪ وﺛﻴﻘﺔ ﺗﻮﺟﻴﻪ اﻟﻘﺮارات ﺑﺸﺄن اﻟﺪودﻳﻜﺎن اﳊﻠﻘﻲ اﻟﺴﺪاﺳﻲ اﻟﱪوم).(١
) ،UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/7/Add.1 (١اﳌﺮﻓﻖ.
1
اﳌﻘﺮر ا ر :٤/٩-إدراج اﻟﻔﻮرات ﰲ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام
إن ﻣﺆﲤﺮ اﻷﻃﺮاف،
إذ ﻳﻼﺣﻆ ﻣﻊ اﻟﺘﻘﺪﻳﺮ ﻋﻤﻞ ﳉﻨﺔ اﺳﺘﻌﺮاض اﳌﻮاد اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ،
وﻗﺪ ﻧﻈﺮ ﰲ ﺗﻮﺻﻴﺔ ﳉﻨﺔ اﺳﺘﻌﺮاض اﳌﻮاد اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ ﺧﻀﺎع اﻟﻔﻮرات ﻹﺟﺮاء اﳌﻮاﻓﻘﺔ اﳌﺴﺒﻘﺔ ﻋﻦ
ﻋﻠﻢ وإدراﺟﻪ ،وﻓﻘﺎً ﻟﺬﻟﻚ ،ﺑﻮﺻﻔﻪ ﻣﺒﻴﺪ آﻓﺎت ﰲ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام اﳌﺘﻌﻠﻘﺔ ﺑﺘﻄﺒﻴﻖ إﺟﺮاء
اﳌﻮاﻓﻘﺔ اﳌﺴﺒﻘﺔ ﻋﻦ ﻋﻠﻢ ﻋﻠﻰ ﻣﻮاد ﻛﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ وﻣﺒﻴﺪات آﻓﺎت ﻣﻌﻴﻨﺔ ﺧﻄﺮة ﻣﺘﺪاوﻟﺔ ﰲ اﻟﺘﺠﺎرة اﻟﺪوﻟﻴﺔ،
وﻗﺪ اﻗﺘﻨﻊ ن ﲨﻴﻊ ﺷﺮوط اﻹدراج ﰲ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام ﻗﺪ اﺳﺘُﻮﻓﻴﺖ،
- ١ﻳﻘﺮر ﺗﻌﺪﻳﻞ اﳌﺮﻓﻖ اﻟﺜﺎﻟﺚ ﻻﺗﻔﺎﻗﻴﺔ روﺗﺮدام ﻣﻦ أﺟﻞ إدراج اﳌﺎدة اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ اﻟﺘﺎﻟﻴﺔ:
اﻟﻔﺌﺔ اﻟﺮﻗﻢ/اﻷرﻗﺎم ذات اﻟﺼﻠﺔ ﰲ ﺳﺠﻞ اﳌﺎدة اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ
داﺋﺮة اﳌﺴﺘﺨﻠﺼﺎت اﻟﻜﻴﻤﻴﺎﺋﻴﺔ
ﻣﺒﻴﺪ آﻓﺎت ٢-٠٢-٢٩٨ اﻟﻔﻮرات
- ٢ﻳﻘﺮر أﻳﻀﺎً أن ﻳﺒﺪأ ﻧﻔﺎذ ﻫﺬا اﻟﺘﻌﺪﻳﻞ ﻟﻨﺴﺒﺔ ﳉﻤﻴﻊ اﻷﻃﺮاف ﰲ ١٦أﻳﻠﻮل/ﺳﺒﺘﻤﱪ
٢٠١٩؛
- ٣ﻳﻌﺘﻤﺪ وﺛﻴﻘﺔ ﺗﻮﺟﻴﻪ اﻟﻘﺮارات ﺑﺸﺄن اﻟﻔﻮرات).(٢
_____________
) ،UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/8/Add.1 (٢اﳌﺮﻓﻖ.
2
RC-9/3:将六溴环十二烷列入《鹿特丹公约》附件三
缔约方大会,
赞赏地注意到化学品审查委员会的工作,
审议了化学品审查委员会关于对六溴环十二烷适用事先知情同意程序并
据此将其作为工业化学品列入《关于在国际贸易中对某些危险化学品和农药
采用事先知情同意程序的鹿特丹公约》附件三的建议,
确信列入《鹿特丹公约》附件三的所有要求均已满足,
1. 决定修正《鹿特丹公约》附件三,以列入以下化学品:
化学品 相关化学文摘社编号 类别
六溴环十二烷 25637-99-4 工业
3194-55-6
134237-50-6
134237-51-7
134237-52-8
2. 又决定本修正应于 2019 年 9 月 16 日对所有缔约方生效;
3. 核准关于六溴环十二烷的决定指导文件1。
1
UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/7/Add.1,附件。
3
RC-9/4:将甲拌磷列入《鹿特丹公约》附件三
缔约方大会,
赞赏地注意到化学品审查委员会的工作,
审议了化学品审查委员会关于对甲拌磷适用事先知情同意程序并据此将
其作为农药列入《关于在国际贸易中对某些危险化学品和农药采用事先知情
同意程序的鹿特丹公约》附件三的建议,
确信列入《鹿特丹公约》附件三的所有要求均已满足,
1. 决定修正《鹿特丹公约》附件三,以列入以下化学品:
化学品 相关化学文摘社编号 类别
甲拌磷 298-02-2 农药
2. 又决定本修正应于 2019 年 9 月 16 日对所有缔约方生效;
3. 核准关于甲拌磷的决定指导文件2。
2
UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/8/Add.1,附件。
4
RC-9/3: Listing of hexabromocyclododecane in Annex III to the
Rotterdam Convention
The Conference of the Parties,
Noting with appreciation the work of the Chemical Review Committee,
Having considered the recommendation of the Chemical Review Committee to make
hexabromocyclododecane subject to the prior informed consent procedure and, accordingly, to list it in
Annex III to the Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain
Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade as an industrial chemical,
Satisfied that all the requirements for listing in Annex III to the Rotterdam Convention have
been met,
1. Decides to amend Annex III to the Rotterdam Convention to list the following
chemical:
Chemical Relevant CAS number(s) Category
Hexabromocyclododecane 25637-99-4 Industrial
3194-55-6
134237-50-6
134237-51-7
134237-52-8
2. Also decides that this amendment shall enter into force for all Parties on
16 September 2019;
3. Approves the decision guidance document on hexabromocyclododecane.1
1 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/7/Add.1, annex.
5
RC-9/4: Listing of phorate in Annex III to the Rotterdam
Convention
The Conference of the Parties,
Noting with appreciation the work of the Chemical Review Committee,
Having considered the recommendation of the Chemical Review Committee to make phorate
subject to the prior informed consent procedure and, accordingly, to list it in Annex III to the
Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain Hazardous Chemicals and
Pesticides in International Trade as a pesticide,
Satisfied that all the requirements for listing in Annex III to the Rotterdam Convention have
been met,
1. Decides to amend Annex III to the Rotterdam Convention to list the following
chemical:
Chemical Relevant CAS number(s) Category
Phorate 298-02-2 Pesticide
2. Also decides that this amendment shall enter into force for all Parties on 16 September
2019;
3. Approves the decision guidance document on phorate.2
2 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/8/Add.1, annex.
6
RC-9/3 : Inscription de l’hexabromocyclododécane
à l’Annexe III de la Convention de Rotterdam
La Conférence des Parties,
Notant avec satisfaction les travaux du Comité d’étude des produits chimiques,
Ayant examiné la recommandation du Comité d’étude des produits chimiques tendant
à soumettre l’hexabromocyclododécane à la procédure de consentement préalable en connaissance de
cause et, en conséquence, à l’inscrire dans la catégorie des produits chimiques à usage industriel à
l’Annexe III de la Convention de Rotterdam sur la procédure de consentement préalable en
connaissance de cause applicable à certains produits chimiques et pesticides dangereux qui font l’objet
d’un commerce international,
Considérant que toutes les conditions régissant l’inscription d’une substance à l’Annexe III de
la Convention de Rotterdam ont été remplies,
1. Décide d’amender l’Annexe III de la Convention de Rotterdam pour y inscrire le produit
chimique suivant :
Numéro du Service des résumés
Nom du produit chimique analytiques de chimie Catégorie
Hexabromocyclododécane 25637-99-4 Produit à usage industriel
3194-55-6
134237-50-6
134237-51-7
134237-52-8
2. Décide également que cet amendement entrera en vigueur à l’égard de toutes les Parties
le 16 septembre 2019 ;
3. Approuve le document d’orientation des décisions concernant
l’hexabromocyclododécane1.
1 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/7/Add.1, annexe.
7
RC-9/4 : Inscription du phorate à l’Annexe III de la Convention
de Rotterdam
La Conférence des Parties,
Notant avec satisfaction les travaux du Comité d’étude des produits chimiques,
Ayant examiné la recommandation du Comité d’étude des produits chimiques tendant à
soumettre le phorate à la procédure de consentement préalable en connaissance de cause et,
en conséquence, à l’inscrire dans la catégorie des pesticides à l’Annexe III de la Convention
de Rotterdam sur la procédure de consentement préalable en connaissance de cause applicable à
certains produits chimiques et pesticides dangereux qui font l’objet d’un commerce international,
Considérant que toutes les conditions régissant l’inscription d’une substance à l’Annexe III de
la Convention de Rotterdam ont été remplies,
1. Décide d’amender l’Annexe III de la Convention de Rotterdam pour y inscrire le
produit chimique suivant :
Nom du produit chimique Numéro du Service des résumés Catégorie
analytiques de chimie
Phorate 298-02-2 Pesticide
2. Décide également que cet amendement entrera en vigueur à l’égard de toutes les
Parties le 16 septembre 2019 ;
3. Approuve le document d’orientation des décisions concernant le phorate2.
2 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/8/Add.1, annexe.
8
РК-9/3: Включение гексабромциклододекана в
приложение III к Роттердамской конвенции
Конференция Сторон,
отмечая с признательностью работу Комитета по рассмотрению химических
веществ,
рассмотрев рекомендацию Комитета по рассмотрению химических веществ о
включении гексабромциклододекана в процедуру предварительного обоснованного
согласия и, соответственно, его включении в качестве промышленного химиката в
приложение III к Роттердамской конвенции о процедуре предварительного
обоснованного согласия в отношении отдельных опасных химических веществ и
пестицидов в международной торговле,
удостоверившись в том, что все требования, касающиеся включения химических
веществ в приложение III к Роттердамской конвенции, были удовлетворены,
1. постановляет внести поправку в приложение III к Роттердамской
конвенции с целью включения в него следующего химического вещества:
Химическое вещество Соответствующие номера КАС Категория
Гексабромциклододекан 25637-99-4 Промышленный химикат
3194-55-6
134237-50-6
134237-51-7
134237-52-8
2. постановляет также, что эта поправка вступит в силу для всех Сторон
16 сентября 2019 года;
3. утверждает документ для содействия принятию решения в отношении
гексабромциклододекана1.
1 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/7/Add.1, приложение.
9
РК-9/4: Включение фората в приложение III к
Роттердамской конвенции
Конференция Сторон,
отмечая с признательностью работу Комитета по рассмотрению химических
веществ,
рассмотрев рекомендацию Комитета по рассмотрению химических веществ о
включении фората в процедуру предварительного обоснованного согласия и,
соответственно, его включения в качестве пестицида в приложение III к Роттердамской
конвенции о процедуре предварительного обоснованного согласия в отношении
отдельных опасных химических веществ и пестицидов в международной торговле,
удостоверившись в том, что все требования, касающиеся включения химических
веществ в приложение III к Роттердамской конвенции, были удовлетворены,
1. постановляет внести поправку в приложение III к Роттердамской
конвенции с целью включения в него следующего химического вещества:
Химическое вещество Соответствующий номер КАС Категория
Форат 298-02-2 Пестицид
2. постановляет также, что эта поправка вступит в силу для всех Сторон
16 сентября 2019 года;
3. утверждает документ для содействия принятию решения в отношении
фората2.
_________________
2 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/8/Add.1, приложение.
10
RC-9/3: Inclusión del hexabromociclododecano en el anexo III
del Convenio de Rotterdam
La Conferencia de las Partes,
Observando con aprecio la labor realizada por el Comité de Examen de Productos Químicos,
Habiendo examinado la recomendación del Comité de Examen de Productos Químicos de
someter el hexabromociclododecano al procedimiento de consentimiento fundamentado previo y, en
consecuencia, incluirlo en el anexo III del Convenio de Rotterdam sobre el Procedimiento de
Consentimiento Fundamentado Previo Aplicable a Ciertos Plaguicidas y Productos Químicos
Peligrosos Objeto de Comercio Internacional como producto químico industrial,
Convencida de que se han satisfecho todos los requisitos para la inclusión en el anexo III del
Convenio de Rotterdam,
1. Decide enmendar el anexo III del Convenio de Rotterdam con el fin de incluir el
producto químico siguiente:
Producto químico Número o números CAS Categoría
Hexabromociclododecano 25637-99-4 Industrial
3194-55-6
134237-50-6
134237-51-7
134237-52-8
2. Decide también que esta enmienda entrará en vigor para todas las Partes el 16 de
septiembre de 2019;
3. Aprueba el documento de orientación para la adopción de decisiones sobre el
hexabromociclododecano1.
1 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/7/Add.1, anexo.
11
RC-9/4: Inclusión del forato en el anexo III del Convenio de
Rotterdam
La Conferencia de las Partes,
Observando con aprecio la labor realizada por el Comité de Examen de Productos Químicos,
Habiendo examinado la recomendación del Comité de Examen de Productos Químicos de
someter el forato al procedimiento de consentimiento fundamentado previo y, en consecuencia,
incluirlo en el anexo III del Convenio de Rotterdam sobre el Procedimiento de Consentimiento
Fundamentado Previo Aplicable a Ciertos Plaguicidas y Productos Químicos Peligrosos Objeto de
Comercio Internacional como plaguicida,
Convencida de que se han satisfecho todos los requisitos para la inclusión en el anexo III del
Convenio de Rotterdam,
1. Decide enmendar el anexo III del Convenio de Rotterdam con el fin de incluir el
producto químico siguiente:
Producto químico Número o números CAS Categoría
Forato 298-02-2 Plaguicida
2. Decide también que esta enmienda entrará en vigor para todas las Partes el 16 de
septiembre de 2019;
3. Aprueba el documento de orientación para la adopción de decisiones sobre el forato2.
2 UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.9/8/Add.1, anexo.
12