European Commission Our Ref: 16.02.2021 No 17-7/2021/969-1
Directorate-General for
Competition
State Aid Registry
1049 Bruxelles/Brussel
Belgique/België
[email protected]
a.eu, COMP-
[email protected]
Revision of the Guidelines on State aid for
environmental protection and energy 2014-
2020 (HT.5371, H.5475)
Dear Ms. Anna Colucci,
On the 12th November 2020, the Directorate-General for Competition launched the consultation
for the revision of the Guidelines on State aid for environmental protection and energy (EEAG)1.
Thank you for the opportunity to exchange views on the core principles of EEAG.
For Estonia it is utmost important that the revised EEAG shall provide an opportunity for the
Member State to react in a timely manner to guard and guarantee the security of supply of energy.
The increasing development of renewable energy production does on one hand provide necessary
further renewables in the consumption against the market conditions. On the other hand, such
developments lack of sufficient security of supply in terms of the whole energy system. The
intermittent nature of the current renewable energy production units reflects on the need to have
more and more dispatchable units in the electricity system. However, such units may have a
certain market barrier due to the relatively high cost of production compared to the
intermittent units and cannot compete on the technologically neutral tenders. A solution for that is
the possibility for a Member State to advance the usage of energy system and environment friendly
technologies that help to balance the consumption and production of electricity.
The current EEAG allows for the Member State to call for a technology specific tender if certain
criteria are fulfilled (see p 110 of the EEAG). This option should remain a possibility in the new
revised EEAG, as well. Renewable source based technologies (i.e. biomass fired CHP-s) that
contribute to grid stability and security of supply must be allowed to compete with similar
1
EEAG - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:JOC_2014_200_R_0001&from=EN
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
technologies under one auction.
Furthermore, the ENTSO-E 2020 mid-term adequacy forecast2 indicates that the loss of load
expected (LOLE) will increase in the following years throughout the Member States. This will
lead to a situation where more and more capacity mechanisms3 will be called for by several
Member States. Such mechanisms are utmost important for the security of supply of the energy
system. To facilitate a smooth state aid request process, the framework of such mechanisms’
approval in the guidelines must be clear, unambiguous and prompt.
Another topic that we see of important relevance is considering the financing of the renewable
energy schemes. According to the current version of the EEAG, only a certain number of sectors
are eligible under section 3.7.2 of the EEAG to be granted of reduction of funding the scheme.
This, however, is a constraint to the possible investment climate of a Member State when all the
rest of energy intensive consumers are concerned. For example, at the present data centers cannot
benefit from the reduction of the funding of the scheme since such a sector is not included in the
EEAG. Such centers are extremely energy intensive even though they are using the best available
technologies, they still depend to a large extent on the price of energy. In our view, all the sectors
that are highly energy intensive, are constantly applying measures to maximize energize
saving on their behalf and are relying to a large extent on the price of energy should have a
possibility to benefit from the reduction of funding the renewables schemes.
With best regards,
Timo Tatar
Deputy Secretary General for Energy
Rein Vaks
+372 625 6347
[email protected]
2
ENTSO-E mid-term adequacy forecast 2020 - https://eepublicdownloads.entsoe.eu/clean-documents/sdc-
documents/MAF/2020/MAF_2020_Executive_Summary.pdf
3
Further information on capacity mechanisms - https://ec.europa.eu/energy/topics/markets-and-consumers/capacity-
mechanisms_en
2 (3)
Copy to
Ministry of Finance
3 (3)
European Commission Our Ref: 16.02.2021 No 17-7/2021/969-1
Directorate-General for
Competition
State Aid Registry
1049 Bruxelles/Brussel
Belgique/België
[email protected]
a.eu, COMP-
[email protected]
Revision of the Guidelines on State aid for
environmental protection and energy 2014-
2020 (HT.5371, H.5475)
Dear Ms. Anna Colucci,
On the 12th November 2020, the Directorate-General for Competition launched the consultation
for the revision of the Guidelines on State aid for environmental protection and energy (EEAG)1.
Thank you for the opportunity to exchange views on the core principles of EEAG.
For Estonia it is utmost important that the revised EEAG shall provide an opportunity for the
Member State to react in a timely manner to guard and guarantee the security of supply of energy.
The increasing development of renewable energy production does on one hand provide necessary
further renewables in the consumption against the market conditions. On the other hand, such
developments lack of sufficient security of supply in terms of the whole energy system. The
intermittent nature of the current renewable energy production units reflects on the need to have
more and more dispatchable units in the electricity system. However, such units may have a
certain market barrier due to the relatively high cost of production compared to the
intermittent units and cannot compete on the technologically neutral tenders. A solution for that is
the possibility for a Member State to advance the usage of energy system and environment friendly
technologies that help to balance the consumption and production of electricity.
The current EEAG allows for the Member State to call for a technology specific tender if certain
criteria are fulfilled (see p 110 of the EEAG). This option should remain a possibility in the new
revised EEAG, as well. Renewable source based technologies (i.e. biomass fired CHP-s) that
contribute to grid stability and security of supply must be allowed to compete with similar
1
EEAG - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:JOC_2014_200_R_0001&from=EN
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
technologies under one auction.
Furthermore, the ENTSO-E 2020 mid-term adequacy forecast2 indicates that the loss of load
expected (LOLE) will increase in the following years throughout the Member States. This will
lead to a situation where more and more capacity mechanisms3 will be called for by several
Member States. Such mechanisms are utmost important for the security of supply of the energy
system. To facilitate a smooth state aid request process, the framework of such mechanisms’
approval in the guidelines must be clear, unambiguous and prompt.
Another topic that we see of important relevance is considering the financing of the renewable
energy schemes. According to the current version of the EEAG, only a certain number of sectors
are eligible under section 3.7.2 of the EEAG to be granted of reduction of funding the scheme.
This, however, is a constraint to the possible investment climate of a Member State when all the
rest of energy intensive consumers are concerned. For example, at the present data centers cannot
benefit from the reduction of the funding of the scheme since such a sector is not included in the
EEAG. Such centers are extremely energy intensive even though they are using the best available
technologies, they still depend to a large extent on the price of energy. In our view, all the sectors
that are highly energy intensive, are constantly applying measures to maximize energize
saving on their behalf and are relying to a large extent on the price of energy should have a
possibility to benefit from the reduction of funding the renewables schemes.
With best regards,
Timo Tatar
Deputy Secretary General for Energy
Rein Vaks
+372 625 6347
[email protected]
2
ENTSO-E mid-term adequacy forecast 2020 - https://eepublicdownloads.entsoe.eu/clean-documents/sdc-
documents/MAF/2020/MAF_2020_Executive_Summary.pdf
3
Further information on capacity mechanisms - https://ec.europa.eu/energy/topics/markets-and-consumers/capacity-
mechanisms_en
2 (3)
Copy to
Ministry of Finance
3 (3)