3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Ship-to-Ship Transfer Operations
PROCEDURE MANUAL
STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURES
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 1 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
1 SCOPE
The scope of this procedure is to provide guidance to personnel, to ensure that all Ship-to-ship cargo transfers
will be carried out in a safe and controlled manner.
2 APPLICATION
MariFlex Transfer Services
3 DEFINITIONS
Refer to Procedure 3.0.6 Abbreviations.
4 REFERENCES
CDI, ICS, OCIMF, SIGTTO - Ship to Ship Transfer Guide (Petroleum, Chemical and Liquefied Gas)
OCIMF - The International Safety Guide for Oil Tankers and Terminals (ISGOTT)
OCIMF - International Safety Guide for Inland Navigation Tank-barges and Terminals (ISGINTT)
IMO – MARPOL (Consolidated Edition 2011)
IMO Manual on Oil Pollution (MoOP).
OCIMF - Mooring Equipment Guidelines (MEG)
OCIMF – Effective Mooring
IMO – STCW Regulations
Nautical Institute – Bridge Team Management
ICS – Bridge procedure Guide
IMO – IMDG Code
5 REVISION RECORD
Version Date Description
0 January 2010 Created
1 April 2017 Revised to include amendments to STS Transfer Guide
1.1 August 2017 Incorporation of Danish and South African Waters
1.2 September 2017 Inclusion of High H₂S Cargoes
1.3 2 October 2018 Revision of Hose Life Policy
1.4 10 February 2019 Revised Chapter 11 - Personnel Transfer by Crane Procedures
6 DOCUMENT ISSUE RECORD
No. Date Issued To
1 August 2017 Mariflex Transfer Services BV. Original Controlled Document
2 Sept. 2017 DMA - Un-controlled Document
3 October 2018 BP Marine
7 PROCEDURE
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 2 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Table of Contents
1 Scope ...................................................................................................................................................................... 2
2 Application .......................................................................................................................................................... 2
3 Definitions ........................................................................................................................................................... 2
4 References ........................................................................................................................................................... 2
5 Revision Record ................................................................................................................................................. 2
6 Document Issue Record .................................................................................................................................. 2
7 Procedure ............................................................................................................................................................ 2
1 Emergency Contact Details .......................................................................................................................... 11
1.1 Key Points of Contact ......................................................................................................................... 11
1.2 External Points of Contact ARA Region .............................................................................................. 12
1.3 External Points of Contact South Africa ............................................................................................. 12
1.4 External Points of Contact - Denmark ................................................................................................ 13
1.4.1 Pollution Response in Denmark...................................................................................................... 13
1.5 External Points of Contact – Other Locations .................................................................................... 13
1.6 Global Oil Spill Response Organisations ............................................................................................. 14
1.7 IMO Coastal Contact List .................................................................................................................... 14
2 General Principles .......................................................................................................................................... 15
2.1 Preface ................................................................................................................................................ 15
2.2 Background ......................................................................................................................................... 15
2.3 Control of Operations ......................................................................................................................... 15
2.4 Person in Overall Advisory Control..................................................................................................... 16
2.5 Role of a Ship-to-Ship Superintendent/Mooring Master ................................................................... 16
2.6 The Duties of the STS Superintendent ............................................................................................... 16
2.7 Contingency Planning ......................................................................................................................... 17
2.8 Operations Risk................................................................................................................................... 17
2.9 Standard Oil Tanker Definitions ......................................................................................................... 18
2.10 Lightering Operations ......................................................................................................................... 18
2.10.1 Lightering ................................................................................................................................... 19
2.10.2 Reverse Lightering ..................................................................................................................... 19
3 Conditions and Requirements .................................................................................................................... 20
3.1 Transfer Areas .................................................................................................................................... 20
3.1.1 General ........................................................................................................................................... 20
3.1.2 STS Transfer Area Risk Assessment ................................................................................................ 20
3.1.3 Location Approvals ......................................................................................................................... 20
3.2 Vessel Compatibility ........................................................................................................................... 21
3.3 Notification to and, Approval from Authorities ................................................................................. 22
3.3.1 MARPOL Annex-1 Cargoes ............................................................................................................. 22
3.3.2 Chemical cargoes ........................................................................................................................... 22
3.3.3 Liquefied Gas Cargoes .................................................................................................................... 23
3.3.4 Other cargoes ................................................................................................................................. 23
3.3.5 Danish Waters ................................................................................................................................ 23
3.4 Material safety data sheet ................................................................................................................. 23
4 Environmental Conditions ........................................................................................................................... 24
4.1.1 Guidelines for Open Water Limiting Weather Criteria: .................................................................. 25
4.1.2 Guidelines for ARA Region in-port Limiting Weather Criteria: ....................................................... 25
4.2 Climatic Conditions and Measures ..................................................................................................... 25
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 3 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
4.2.1 Precautions and measures in cold weather conditions .................................................................. 25
4.2.2 Ship to ship operations in ice conditions ........................................................................................ 25
4.2.3 Electrical Storms ............................................................................................................................. 26
4.2.4 Special Conditions .......................................................................................................................... 26
4.3 Quality and Safety .............................................................................................................................. 26
4.4 Regulatory Requirements ................................................................................................................... 27
5 Safety and Security of Operations ............................................................................................................. 29
5.1 General Safety .................................................................................................................................... 29
5.2 Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) ................................................................................................ 29
5.3 Hydrogen Sulphide (H₂S) .................................................................................................................... 29
5.4 Security ............................................................................................................................................... 30
5.4.1 Responsibilities under the ISPS Code .............................................................................................. 31
5.4.2 MTS Security ................................................................................................................................... 31
5.4.3 Risk Assessment ............................................................................................................................. 31
5.5 Operations Risk................................................................................................................................... 31
5.5.1 Hazard Identification & Risk Reduction Measures ......................................................................... 31
5.6 Operational Spillage ........................................................................................................................... 32
5.6.1 Hose Rupture .................................................................................................................................. 32
5.6.2 Analysis of Likely Spill Causes from STS Operations ....................................................................... 33
5.7 Use of Safety Checklists ...................................................................................................................... 34
5.8 Drug & Alcohol Policy ......................................................................................................................... 35
5.9 General Safety Precautions ................................................................................................................ 35
5.9.1 Fire Fighting Equipment ................................................................................................................. 35
5.9.2 Oil Pollution Equipment.................................................................................................................. 35
5.9.3 First Aid .......................................................................................................................................... 35
5.10 Prevention of Fatigue ......................................................................................................................... 36
5.11 Mooring Master Handover Procedures.............................................................................................. 37
5.12 Safety Drills ......................................................................................................................................... 37
5.13 Safety During Cargo Transfer ............................................................................................................. 37
5.13.1 Smoking and Naked Lights......................................................................................................... 37
5.13.2 Boiler and Diesel Engines ........................................................................................................... 37
5.13.3 Ship-to-Ship Electrical Current ................................................................................................... 37
5.13.4 The elimination of hydrostatic electricity .................................................................................. 37
5.13.5 Places of Electrical Arching ........................................................................................................ 37
5.13.6 Use of Communication Equipment ............................................................................................ 38
5.13.7 Use of RADAR ............................................................................................................................. 38
5.13.8 Gas Accumulation ...................................................................................................................... 38
5.13.9 Electrical Storms ........................................................................................................................ 39
5.13.10 Galley Stoves .............................................................................................................................. 39
5.13.11 Fire Fighting Equipment ............................................................................................................. 39
5.13.12 Accommodation Access ............................................................................................................. 39
5.13.13 Unauthorised Craft .................................................................................................................... 39
5.14 Action in Case of Safety Breaches ...................................................................................................... 39
5.15 Safe Watch Keeping............................................................................................................................ 39
5.16 Helicopter Operations ........................................................................................................................ 39
6 Communications.............................................................................................................................................. 40
6.1 STS Instructions .................................................................................................................................. 40
6.2 Information Obtained from Vessel ..................................................................................................... 41
6.3 Navigational warnings ........................................................................................................................ 41
6.4 Communications During Mooring Operations ................................................................................... 42
6.5 Communications During Cargo Operations ........................................................................................ 42
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 4 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.6 Communication Failure ...................................................................................................................... 42
7 Preparations Prior to Operations ............................................................................................................. 43
7.1 Preparation of Ships ........................................................................................................................... 43
7.2 Joint plan of operation (JPO) .............................................................................................................. 43
7.3 Fender Selection ................................................................................................................................. 43
7.4 Preparation of ship ............................................................................................................................. 44
7.5 Lightering support vessels .................................................................................................................. 45
7.6 Navigational Signals ............................................................................................................................ 45
8 STS Equipment ................................................................................................................................................. 46
8.1 Pre-Operations Inspection.................................................................................................................. 46
8.2 Support Craft ...................................................................................................................................... 46
8.3 Fenders ............................................................................................................................................... 46
8.3.1 Primary fenders .............................................................................................................................. 46
8.3.2 Secondary Fenders ......................................................................................................................... 46
8.3.3 General ........................................................................................................................................... 47
8.3.4 Fender Testing and Fender Life Policy ............................................................................................ 47
8.3.5 Disposal of Fenders ........................................................................................................................ 47
8.3.6 Fender Positioning.......................................................................................................................... 48
8.3.7 Rigging Fenders for Offshore Operations ....................................................................................... 48
8.3.8 Rigging Fenders for In-port (double banking) Operations ............................................................. 49
8.4 Hoses .................................................................................................................................................. 49
8.4.1 General ........................................................................................................................................... 49
8.4.2 Periodic Hose Testing ..................................................................................................................... 49
8.4.3 Hose Life Policy ............................................................................................................................... 50
8.4.4 Disposal of Hoses ........................................................................................................................... 50
8.4.5 Electrical Continuity ....................................................................................................................... 50
8.4.6 Visual Examination ......................................................................................................................... 51
8.4.7 Hose Connection............................................................................................................................. 51
8.4.8 Length of Hoses .............................................................................................................................. 51
8.4.9 Cargo Hose Specifications .............................................................................................................. 51
8.5 Vapour Balancing................................................................................................................................ 52
8.5.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 52
8.5.2 Operational Procedure ................................................................................................................... 52
8.5.3 Before Venting................................................................................................................................ 54
8.6 Precautions for high Hydrogen Sulphide (H₂S) Cargoes ..................................................................... 54
8.6.1 Gauging and sampling ................................................................................................................... 54
8.6.2 Venting of cargo tanks ................................................................................................................... 54
9 Mooring Equipment ....................................................................................................................................... 56
9.1 Mooring Preparations ........................................................................................................................ 57
9.1.1 Berthing Principles ......................................................................................................................... 57
9.1.2 Manoeuvring Alongside with Two Ships under Power ................................................................... 58
9.1.3 Reverse Lightering Operations ....................................................................................................... 58
9.1.4 Approach at Anchor ....................................................................................................................... 58
9.1.5 Assessment of Approach Velocity .................................................................................................. 59
9.1.6 Mooring Operations ....................................................................................................................... 59
9.2 Mooring Considerations ..................................................................................................................... 60
9.2.1 Safe Use of Equipment ................................................................................................................... 60
9.2.2 ‘Snap-Back’ Zones .......................................................................................................................... 61
9.2.3 Mooring Bitts.................................................................................................................................. 62
9.2.4 Tension in Mooring Lines................................................................................................................ 62
9.2.5 Mooring Line Lead Angles .............................................................................................................. 62
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 5 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
9.3 Unmooring.......................................................................................................................................... 63
9.4 Unmooring Checks ............................................................................................................................. 63
9.5 Ships Departure .................................................................................................................................. 63
9.5.1 Using Toggle Pins During Unmooring ............................................................................................ 63
10 Procedures Alongside.................................................................................................................................... 65
10.1 Planning for Cargo Operations ........................................................................................................... 65
10.1.1 Cargo / Ship Documentation...................................................................................................... 65
10.1.2 Discharge / Loading Plans.......................................................................................................... 65
10.2 Additional Considerations for MARPOL Annex II cargoes (Chemicals) .............................................. 66
10.2.1 Planning ..................................................................................................................................... 66
10.3 Additional Considerations for STS Transfers Involving Liquified Petroleum Gas (LPG) Cargoes........ 66
10.3.1 Planning ..................................................................................................................................... 66
10.4 Additional Considerations for STS Transfers Involving Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) Cargoes ............ 67
10.4.1 Planning for Cargo Transfer ....................................................................................................... 67
10.4.2 Cargo Transfer ........................................................................................................................... 67
10.5 Dealing with Small Oil Spills................................................................................................................ 68
10.6 Cargo Operations Watchkeeping ....................................................................................................... 68
10.7 Sloshing of cargo tanks ....................................................................................................................... 69
10.8 Gas Accumulation on open decks ...................................................................................................... 70
10.9 Completion of Cargo Operations........................................................................................................ 70
10.9.1 Prior to Completion .................................................................................................................... 70
10.9.2 Cargo Hose Draining .................................................................................................................. 70
11 Personnel Transfer......................................................................................................................................... 72
11.1 Cranes ................................................................................................................................................. 72
11.1.1 Booms or Derricks ...................................................................................................................... 73
11.2 Transfer by Personnel Transfer Basket............................................................................................... 73
11.3 Limitations .......................................................................................................................................... 74
11.4 Training ............................................................................................................................................... 74
11.5 The Transfer by Crane Team. ............................................................................................................. 75
11.6 Instructions for Use ............................................................................................................................ 75
11.7 Lighting ............................................................................................................................................... 76
11.8 Auxiliary Equipment ........................................................................................................................... 76
11.9 Personnel Transfer by Crane Plan ...................................................................................................... 76
12 STS Documentation ........................................................................................................................................ 77
12.1 Records ............................................................................................................................................... 78
13 Emergencies ...................................................................................................................................................... 78
13.1 Contingency Planning ......................................................................................................................... 78
13.2 Emergency Signal................................................................................................................................ 78
13.3 Cessation of transfer operations as a precautionary measure .......................................................... 78
13.4 Emergency Situations ......................................................................................................................... 78
13.4.1 During Manoeuvring .................................................................................................................. 79
13.4.2 Gas Accumulation ...................................................................................................................... 79
13.4.3 Accidental Cargo Spill ................................................................................................................ 79
13.4.4 SOPEP/SMPEP ............................................................................................................................ 79
13.4.5 Emergency Breakaway............................................................................................................... 79
13.5 ERT Organogram................................................................................................................................. 80
14 Note of Protest.................................................................................................................................................. 81
Appendix-1 Additional Requirements for Danish Maritime Waters ................................................. 82
1 Scope .................................................................................................................................................................... 82
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 6 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
15 Application ........................................................................................................................................................ 82
16 Definitions ......................................................................................................................................................... 82
17 References ......................................................................................................................................................... 82
17.1 Internal ............................................................................................................................................... 82
17.2 External............................................................................................................................................... 82
18 Revision Record ............................................................................................................................................... 82
19 Procedures For STS Operations in Danish Maritime Waters .......................................................... 83
19.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 83
19.2 Control of Operations ......................................................................................................................... 83
19.3 Approval from Authorities.................................................................................................................. 84
19.4 Transfer Areas .................................................................................................................................... 84
19.5 Weather and Sea Conditions. STS Operational Parameters............................................................... 85
19.6 Quality Assurance ............................................................................................................................... 85
19.7 Checklists ............................................................................................................................................ 85
19.8 Navigational Warnings ....................................................................................................................... 86
19.9 OPERATIONAL PREPARATIONS BEFORE MANOEUVRING .................................................................. 86
19.9.1 Preparation of Ships................................................................................................................... 86
19.9.2 Joint plan of operation (JPO)...................................................................................................... 86
19.9.3 Preparation of ship .................................................................................................................... 86
19.10 Planning for Cargo Transfer ........................................................................................................... 87
19.11 Ballast Handling.............................................................................................................................. 87
20 Order no. 570 of 4 June 2014 Issued by the Danish Maritime Authority.................................... 88
20.1 Reporting form as well as any updates on STS operations in the territorial waters.......................... 93
21 DMA Approval to Perform STS Operations ............................................................................................ 94
Appendix-2 Additional Requirements for South African Waters ....................................................... 95
1 Scope .................................................................................................................................................................... 95
2 Application ........................................................................................................................................................ 95
3 Definitions ......................................................................................................................................................... 95
4 References ......................................................................................................................................................... 95
4.1 Internal ............................................................................................................................................... 95
4.2 External............................................................................................................................................... 95
5 Revision Record ............................................................................................................................................... 95
6 Procedures For STS Operations in South African Waters ................................................................ 96
6.1 Prior to STS Operations ...................................................................................................................... 96
6.2 Notification to and, Approval from Authorities ................................................................................. 96
6.2.1 Mariflex Notification to South African Maritime Safety Authority (SAMSA) ................................. 96
6.2.2 SAMSA Requirements ..................................................................................................................... 96
6.2.3 Conditions of approval for transfer ................................................................................................ 96
6.2.4 MARPOL Annex-1 Cargoes ............................................................................................................. 97
6.2.5 Chemical cargoes ........................................................................................................................... 97
6.2.6 Other cargoes ................................................................................................................................. 97
7 STS Transfer Location ................................................................................................................................... 98
7.1 Anchoring Procedure .......................................................................................................................... 98
7.2 Environmental Conditions .................................................................................................................. 98
7.2.1 Special Conditions .......................................................................................................................... 99
8 STS Equipment .............................................................................................................................................. 100
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 7 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
8.1 Cargo Hoses ...................................................................................................................................... 100
8.2 Vapour Hoses.................................................................................................................................... 101
8.2.1 Hose String ................................................................................................................................... 101
8.3 Fenders ............................................................................................................................................. 101
9 Berthing Operations.................................................................................................................................... 102
9.1 STS Operations ................................................................................................................................. 102
9.1.1 Use of Tug for Mother Vessel Directional Stability During Tanker Berthing Operations ............. 102
9.1.2 Task Risk Assessment for Berthing Assist Tug .............................................................................. 103
9.2 500m Exclusion Zone - Purpose & Application................................................................................. 103
9.2.1 Unauthorised Craft (ISPS Code) .................................................................................................... 103
9.2.2 Radio Protocol .............................................................................................................................. 103
9.2.3 Procedure for entering 500m Exclusion Zone............................................................................... 104
10 Emissions During Cargo Operations ..................................................................................................... 105
10.1 Vapour Balancing.............................................................................................................................. 105
10.1.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 105
10.1.2 Operational Procedure ............................................................................................................. 105
10.1.3 Before Venting ......................................................................................................................... 107
10.2 Oil Pollution Equipment ................................................................................................................... 107
10.2.1 OSR Equipment ........................................................................................................................ 107
11 Checklists ........................................................................................................................................................ 107
11.1 ANNEX-1 - Transfer Particulars ......................................................................................................... 108
11.2 ANNEX 2 - Berthing Checklist ........................................................................................................... 108
11.3 ANNEX 3 - General Checklist ............................................................................................................ 109
11.4 ANNEX 4 - Before Unmooring........................................................................................................... 110
12 Records ............................................................................................................................................................ 110
13 Flowchart ........................................................................................................................................................ 110
Appendix-3 Personnel Transfer by Crane Plan ...................................................................................... 111
Appendix-4 DNV Standard 2.22 – Lifting Appliances ........................................................................... 115
Appendix-5 Operations Personnel Handover Checklist (Form 3.0.34) ......................................... 116
Appendix-6 “Manual on Oil Pollution, Section I-Prevention” 2011 ................................................ 117
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 8 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Table of Figures
Figure 1 - Standard Oil Tanker Definitions by size ........................................................................................... 18
Figure 2 Ship to ship transfer ....................................................................................................................... 19
Figure 3 - Example of Location Approval ......................................................................................................... 21
Figure 4 - Screening Risk Assessment .............................................................................................................. 22
Figure 5 - Example of Port Authority Approval (Dutch & English Translation) ............................................... 23
Figure 6 - Oil Spill Risk Assessment.................................................................................................................. 34
Figure 7 - Example of Mooring Plan with VLCC to Aframax Tanker ................................................................ 40
Figure 8 - An example of a Safety Call and Message ....................................................................................... 41
Figure 9 - Rigging Fenders from Support Craft ................................................................................................ 48
Figure 10 - Rigging Secondary Fenders............................................................................................................ 48
Figure 11 - Example of STS Mooring Plan ........................................................................................................ 59
Figure 12 - Simple & Complex Mooring System illustrating the Potential for "Snap-Back" Zone................... 62
Figure 13 - Forecastle Deck Mooring Arrangement Illustrating Potential "Snap-Back" Zones ....................... 62
Figure 14 - Personnel Transfer Basket ............................................................................................................. 75
Figure 15 - Example of STS Time Sheet ........................................................................................................... 77
Figure 16 - ERT Organogram............................................................................................................................ 80
Figure 17 - Example of Note of Protest ........................................................................................................... 81
Figure 18 - Location approved for STS Transfer operations at Saldanha Bay ................................................. 98
Figure 19 - Personnel Transfer by Basket RA....................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Figure 20 - Handover Checklist ...................................................................................................................... 116
Figure 21 - Two ship preparing for a ship-to-ship transfer (OCIMF). ...................................................... 118
Figure 22 - Ship-to-ship transfer operation (Copyright: OCIMF). ............................................................ 122
Table 1 - PPE Matrix (extract from Procedure 3.0.21) .................................................................................... 29
Table 2- Typical Effects of Exposure to Hydrogen Sulphide (H2S) .................................................................. 30
Table 3 - Hose Throughput vs Diameter .......................................................................................................... 52
Table 4 – MoOP References .......................................................................................................................... 131
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 9 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
A BBREVIATIONS : SHE-Q Safety Health Environment and Quality
SMPEP Shipboard Marine Pollution Emergency
AIS Automatic Identification System Plan
CAR Corrective Action Request SMS Safety Management System
COLREGS Collision Regulations SOLAS International Convention for the Safety of
COSHH Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Life at Sea
COSWP Code of Safe Working Practices for SOP Standard Operating Procedure
Merchant Seamen SOPEP Shipboard oil pollution emergency plan
COW Crude oil washing SS Service Ship – loading vessel.
DOC Document of Compliance STBL Ship to be lightened
DMA Danish Maritime Authority STCW International Convention on Standards of
DWP Detailed Work Procedure Training, Certification and Watch-keeping
DWT Deadweight tons for Seafarers
EEZ Economic Exclusion Zone STS Ship-to-Ship Transfer
ERP Emergency Response Plan SWL Safe working load
ETA Estimated time of arrival UHF Ultra High Frequency (on scene radio
GMDSS Global Maritime Distress and Safety communication)
System UMS Unattended Machinery Space
H2S Hydrogen sulphide VHF Very High Frequency (maritime radio
ICS Institute of chartered shipbrokers communication)
IGS Inert gas system (flue gas)
IMDG International Maritime Dangerous Goods
Code
IMO International Maritime Organization
IOPP International Oil Pollution Prevention
Certificate
ISGOTT International Safety Guide to Oil Tanker &
Terminals
ISGINTT International Safety Guide to Inland
Navigation Tank-barges & Terminals
ISM International Safety Management
ISPS International ship to port facility code
KPI Key Performance Indicator
LMRA Last Minute Risk Assessment
LSA Life Saving Appliance
MARPOL IMO - International Convention for
Prevention of Oil Pollution from Ships
MCA Maritime and Coastguard Agency
MM Mooring Master
MOC Management of Change
MoOP IMO Manual on Oil Pollution
MSDS Material safety data sheet
MTS Mariflex Transfer Services BV
OCIMF Oil Companies International Maritime
Forum
OOW Officer of the Watch
OWS Oily Water Separator
PMS Planned Maintenance System
POAC Person in Overall Advisory Control
PPE Personal Protective Equipment
PTW Permit to Work
RA Risk Assessment
SCUBA Self Contained Underwater Breathing
Apparatus
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 10 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
1 EMERGENCY CONTACT DETAILS
In the event of an Emergency of any description, the Mariflex Transfer Services BV, Duty Operator shall be
alerted at the earliest opportunity. The following individuals may be contacted at the numbers below:
Company Name CoHold BV & Underlying Companies
Office Address Maassluissedijk 101, 3133 KA Vlaardingen, Port No.738. NL
Telephone EMERGENCY TELEPHONE NUMBER +31 (0)10 434 4445 (24 HOURS)
Fax N/A
Email
[email protected]
EMERGENCY RESPONSE PERSONNEL Primary Alternate/Secondary
Person in Charge (PIC) Ruud Cogels Walter van der Pluijm
Spokesperson Company Lawyer Ruud Cogels
Office Manager Suzanne Vons Admin. Assistant
Departmental Heads Cor van Hoeven Walter van der Pluijm
HSEQ Manager Cor van Hoeven Bart Vleggaar (ARBO Rotterdam)
HSEQ Representative Bart Vleggaar (ARBO Rotterdam) Ferry Kaminski (ARBO Rotterdam)
HR Officer Accounts Assistant Suzanne Vons / Marianne Jochems
Executive Administrator Suzanne Vons Admin. Assistant
Senior Mooring Master Captain David R. Brant Captain Kostiantin Aliabliev
1.1 Key Points of Contact
Telephones
Department Description
Fixed Network Mobile
Operations Duty Operator (Emergency Hotline Number) +31 10 434 4445
Management Ruud Cogels +31 10 434 4445 +31 6 5327 6532
Walter van der Pluym +31 10 434 4445 +31 6 2331 3881
Cor van Hoeven + 31 10 434 4445 +31 6 1156 1845
QHSE Bart Vleggaar (ARBO Rotterdam) +31 10 434 4445 +31 6 2939 9443
Consultants Ferry Kaminski (ARBO Rotterdam) +31 10 434 4445 +31 6 2939 9452
Other Capt. David R. Brant +31 10 434 4445 +31 6 5766 0918
(Senior Mooring Master/POAC) +44 7902 949846
Capt. Kostiantin Aliabliev +31 10 434 4445 +31 6 2317 3997
(Mooring Master/POAC) +380 67 4862871
Capt. Michael Sands +31 10 434 4445 +44 7713 877080
(Mooring Master/POAC)
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 11 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
1.2 External Points of Contact ARA Region
TELEPHONE E-MAIL VHF CHANNEL
General Emergency 112 Netherlands
Police 112 Netherlands
Ambulance Service 112 Netherlands
Fire Fighting Service 112 Netherlands
National Poisons Information +31 30 274 8888
Company Insurers Driekleur Through: Ruud Cogels
Company Lawyers Dornstedt/Dock Law Through: Ruud Cogels
Coastal state (e.g. Coastguard) Rotterdam Port Control +31 10 252 2400
Rotterdam Harbor Master +31 10 252 1000
Coastal state (e.g. Coastguard) Amsterdam Port Control +31 20 622 1515
+31 20 523 4778
Coastal state (e.g. Coastguard) Netherlands Coastguard +31 900 0111
+31 223 542 300
Oil Spill Response Organization “MariFlex Group” +31 10-434 44 45
Labour South West Region +31 10 479 8300
Milieudienst DCMR +31 10 246 8000
Water Delftland +31 15 260 8108
QHSE Coordinator (external) - +31 10 449 1257
ARBO Rotterdam
Yara Benelux B.V. (HAZMAT) +31 10 445 3000
Beelen Rotterdam B.V. - +31 88 260 0100
(Waste displosal)
1.3 External Points of Contact South Africa
General Emergency Location Contact Details
SAMSA Western Region: Cape Town
(Includes Port Nolloth, Saldanha 072-364-4958
Bay and Cape Town)
Police Flying Squad 10111
Police 022 714 8333/4
Ambulance Service 022 713 4590
Fire Fighting Service 022 703 4338
Port of Entry 022 714 4244
Sea Rescue 022 714 1726
SA Ministry of Environment 022 703 5449
Oil Spill Response Organization OSR – Saldanha Bay +44 023 8033 1551
Saldanha Port Control 022 703 5310
Saldanha Harbour Master 022 703 5314
Saldanha Port Engineer 022 703 5464
Saldanha Port Manager 022 703 5472
Saldanha Customer Service 022 703 5401
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 12 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
1.4 External Points of Contact - Denmark
In the event of an emergency, the following procedure must be followed: -
Immediate direct contact to the Maritime Assistance Service (MAS) and inform them of the situation, VHF
Ch.16.
Advise the STS Agent. Specify any assistance required.
Call the local Pilot Station and brief them on the incident.
Maritime accidents and serious personal accidents should also be reported to the Danish Maritime Authority
by telephone shown below.
TELEPHONE E-MAIL VHF CHANNEL
Maritime Assistance Service +45 89 43 30 99
[email protected] Ch. 16 via the coast station
(MAS) Lyngby Radio
Danish Maritime Authority +45 72 19 60 00
[email protected]
(DMA)
DanPilot +45 63 25 66 66
[email protected]
Local Agent: +45 98 17 41 00
[email protected]
Jørgen Schultz Shipping A/S
Mariflex Transfer Services +31 10 43 44 445
[email protected]
B.V.
1.4.1 Pollution Response in Denmark
Each pollution response vessel carries pollution response equipment and has approximately 80 Cu. Metres
oil recovery capacity. The oil recovery vessels are based in Korsor and Copenhagen but are often on patrol
and in the vicinity of STS transfer operations.
Other oil spill equipment is available at Frederikshavn and Kalundborg as per the Danish National Oil Spill
Contingency Plan.
The STS Agents in Denmark are Jørgen Schultz Shipping A/S. The Agency will offer full support and co-ordinate
communication in the case of an incident or emergency.
The STS Superintendent and local Pilot shall be called as soon as practical. Service (MAS) to be called in the
event of any incident
1.5 External Points of Contact – Other Locations
TELEPHONE E-MAIL VHF CHANNEL
UK Maritime & Direct: +44
[email protected] Ch. 16 - via the nearest
Coastguard Agency (0)20381 72483 UK coast station
(MCA) Mobile: +44
(0)7772 352087
Transport for Malta +356 21222203
[email protected] VHF#16,14
Mariflex Transfer +31 10 43 44 445
[email protected]
Services B.V.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 13 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
1.6 Global Oil Spill Response Organisations
Contact Details
Country Port Organisation
24 hr Email
Nederland’s Amsterdam Amsterdam Port Control +31 206221515
Rotterdam Rotterdam Port Control +31 102522400
[email protected]
Vlissingen Vlissingen Port Control +31 118478741
[email protected]
(Flushing)
Belgium Antwerp Antwerp Port Control +32 32052152
[email protected]
Denmark Baltic Sea Maritime Assistance +45 89433099
[email protected]
Ports Service (MAS) VHF #16
Egypt OPL Port Said Scandinavian Shipping +202 22919038
[email protected]
Agency
South Africa Saldanha SAMSA / DEAT (W. Cape) 072 3644958
Cape Town Oil Spill Response Ltd. +44 023 8033 1551
UK Maritime Maritime Coastguard +44 0345 051 8486
Rescue Co- Agency +44 0191 376 2511
[email protected]
ordination MMO Marine Pollution +44 0300 2002024 g.uk
Centre Incidents Line (office
hours) +44 07770 977 825
MMO Marine Pollution
Incidents Line (out of
office hours)
Southampton Oil Spill Response Ltd. +44 023 8033 1551
[email protected]
1.7 IMO Coastal Contact List
The "Coastal Contact List” of national operational contact points responsible for the receipt, transmission
and processing of urgent reports on incidents involving harmful substances, including oil from ships to coastal
States" contained in the circular is updated at the end of each calendar year.
Appendix – C contains the latest IMO Coastal Contact List (IMO Circular – MSC-MEPC.6/Circ.15) which can be
found at http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Circulars/Pages/CP.aspx
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 14 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
2 GENERAL PRINCIPLES
2.1 Preface
This Ship-to-Ship (STS) Transfer Manual defines the procedures for the transfer of bulk liquid cargoes
between seagoing vessels and, between seagoing vessels and inland barges. Changes to operational
procedures are subject to review by Mariflex Transfer Services BV (MTS) and approval by the MTS
Director of Operations.
MTS is committed to the highest standard of safety, by maintaining a highly professional on-shore and
offshore staff, dedicated to high quality operations and customer service. The Senior Management of
Mariflex Transfer Services BV considers safety, environmental protection and incident free operations
as our highest priority. We will conduct our business in the most responsible manner to ensure that
our operations involve minimum risk to people, the environment, and equipment. Our targets are
zero personnel injuries, zero spills, and zero equipment damage.
This manual is primarily intended to familiarise Mooring Masters, STS Superintendents and MTS
personnel with the general principles involved in STS operations. MTS primary goal is to provide safe
and incident free STS transfer operations.
This manual comprises the following parts:
1. 3.4.14 - STS Operations SOP Manual (Including Danish & South African Waters)
2. 3.4.15 - STS Equipment Maintenance Manual
3. 3.4.16 - STS Checklist Booklet:
A. For in-port Ship to Inland Waterway Vessel, ARA region.
B. For in-port Ship to Ship, ARA region.
C. For STS, Non-ARA Region
2.2 Background
STS transfer operations have become a common industry practice an experience gained from these
regular operations has proved that STS transfers are safe given the use of suitable equipment and
compliance with proper procedures, including suitable weather and sea condition operating limits.
STS oil cargo transfers involving oil tankers of 150 gross tonnage and above have been regulated on a
statutory basis since the implementation of MARPOL, Annex 1, Chapter 8. Annex 1, which entered into
force on 1 January, 2011. These ships are required to carry an STS Operations Plan, which has been
approved by their respective flag administration.
2.3 Control of Operations
According to Regulation 41, Paragraph No. 3 of MARPOL Annex I Chapter 8 "Any oil tanker subject to
this chapter and engaged in STS operations shall comply with its STS operations Plan." In terms of these
regulations, Ship-to-Ship transfer operations should be under the advisory control of one individual,
the Person in Overall Advisory Control (POAC).
The appointment of the Person in Overall Advisory Control (POAC) is therefore a requirement of the
STS Operations Plan. The POAC should be qualified to perform all relevant duties relating to ship-
handling and cargo operations, taking into consideration the qualifications detailed in Chapter 1.7 of
the STS Transfer Guide and/or Paragraph No. 6.2.1.2 of the IMO Manual on Oil Pollution.
It is not the intention of these recommendations that the person in overall advisory control in any way
relieves the ship’s Master of any of his authority, duties, requirements or responsibilities. The Master
of each vessel SHALL always remain in command of his vessel, crew and cargo, he SHALL under no
circumstances permit safety to be jeopardised by the actions of others (STS Transfer Guide, section
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 15 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
1.5). The principles of 'Bridge Management' should be observed. Thus, the emphasis is upon
teamwork.
The operational STS Management Team consists of the Masters of the two vessels and the POAC/STS
Mooring Master or STS Superintendent. (See Bridge Procedures Guide (ICS))
The Mooring Master is not directly responsible for cargo transfer but should monitor cargo operations
to ensure that these operations are conducted in a safe and controlled manner.
The Mooring Master represents the interests of MTS as the STS facilitator on site and is responsible
for the safe transfer and utilisation of equipment belonging to MTS.
2.4 Person in Overall Advisory Control
The role of the POAC is not to relieve the Master(s) of their duties or responsibilities, but to provide
professional advice and guidance to the Master(s) in the co-ordination and safe completion of the STS
operation. (STS Transfer Guide, section 1.7)
The appointment of the POAC is a requirement of the STS Operations Plan. The POAC shall be qualified
to perform all relevant duties relating to ship-handling and cargo operations, taking into consideration
the qualifications detailed in Chapter 1.7 of the STS Transfer Guide and/or Paragraph No. 6.2.1.2 of the
IMO Manual on Oil Pollution.
2.5 Role of a Ship-to-Ship Superintendent/Mooring Master
An STS Superintendent is designated to assist the Ships’ Master in the mooring and unmooring of the
vessels and to co-ordinate the ship-to-ship transfer operation. In open water STS operations, the
Mooring Master is responsible for the safe transit and utilisation of equipment belonging to, or hired
by, MTS.
The STS Superintendent may be appointed to attend vessels engaged in “double-banking”, i.e. the in-
port transfer of cargo between vessels (ships and/or barges) where the Mother vessel is moored
alongside, to buoys/pilings or at anchor. Berthing of the vessels is normally carried out by a Licenced
Harbour Pilot under Port Authority control.
The role of the STS Superintendent is not to relieve the Master(s) of their duties or responsibilities. The
STS Superintendent should ensure, through the provision of professional advice and guidance to the
Master(s), the co-ordination and safe completion of the STS operation. (STS Transfer Guide, section
1.6)
2.6 The Duties of the STS Superintendent
The duties of the STS Superintendent may include:
• Review the Location Specific Risk Assessment.
• Review the JPO and associated Risk Assessments.
• Verify that agreed STS operating procedures are followed and that the operation is conducted
in compliance with all applicable regulatory requirements.
• Confirms that all required reports are made to the appropriate authorities.
• Confirms that all relevant checklists are completed.
• Overseas the correct placement of primary and secondary fenders.
• Sights and reviews mooring equipment.
• Conducts a pre-operations discussion with the responsible persons of involved vessels, including
lightering support vessels and tugs, as appropriate.
• Confirms that personnel involved in each part of the operation are properly briefed and
understand their responsibilities.
• Discuss current and forecasted environmental conditions and the need for their continuous
monitoring throughout the operation.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 16 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• For at sea transfers, discuss passage planning and agree courses and speed for manoeuvring and
mooring operations.
• Verifies joint agreement of the mooring plan.
• Reviews and verifies that any site-specific risk mitigations are in place.
• Supervises vessel approach and manoeuvring alongside.
• Confirms the safe connection of transfer hoses/arms and any associated emergency release
systems (ERS).
• Verifies that any Emergency Shut Down (ESD) system is properly connected and tested.
• Confirms that cargo transfer rates are being monitored together with associated vapour
management procedures.
• Monitor prevailing weather and environmental conditions and advise the Masters when to
suspend or terminate the STS operation.
• Verifies that the integrity of the mooring arrangement is being continuously monitored.
• Ensures that contingency plans are activated in the event of an emergency.
• Verifies that cargo transfer lines are properly drained and, where required, purged.
• Confirms safe disconnection of hoses/arms.
• Supervises the unmooring and separation of vessels.
• Where applicable, supervises the return of hoses, primary and secondary fenders and associated
transfer equipment to service craft.
2.7 Contingency Planning
In light of the risk of accident and the potential scale of the commensurate consequences, the
organisers of an STS operation are required to develop contingency plans for dealing with emergencies.
Before committing to an STS operation, the parties involved should undertake a risk assessment
covering operational hazards and the means by which they are managed. The output from the risk
assessment should be used to develop risk mitigation measures and contingency plans covering all
possible emergencies and providing for a comprehensive response, including notification of relevant
authorities.
MTS has developed three types of STS Risk Assessment plus standard and non-standard task risk
assessments:
i. Generic Risk Assessment covering all aspects of a Ship-to-Ship Transfer Operation.
ii. Location Specific Risk Assessment for each area MTS is involved in STS operations and,
iii. A further vessel specific screening Risk Assessment covering both the physical and operational
hazards/limitations. See Section 3.1).
2.8 Operations Risk
The most common incident to occur during STS operations is a collision between the two ships while
manoeuvring alongside each other or sailing. Collisions between the two ships typically occur for
reasons that include the following:
• Incorrect approach angle between the manoeuvring vessel and constant heading (mother) ship.
• The manoeuvring ship approaching at excessive speed
• Failure of one or both ships to appreciate meteorological and/or tidal conditions
• The mother vessel failing to control excessive swinging while at anchor and/or manoeuvring ship
failing to appreciate the swing
• Miscommunication between the vessels during manoeuvring
• Engine failure of one of the tankers, particularly during mooring and un-mooring, can also result
in a collision between the two ships. The failure of a ship's main engine to start at a crucial point
has also been a common cause of accidents.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 17 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Failure of mooring lines can occur because the mooring equipment is in poor condition.
• Excessive speed during mooring manoeuvres, extreme ship motion during the STS transfer
operation and a poor mooring arrangement leading to chaffing of the lines can also lead to
mooring line failure. Mooring line failure can cause fatal injuries to crewmembers, as well as
damage or failure of the cargo hose(s).
• The manoeuvring vessel landing too heavily on the mother tanker can compromise the integrity
of the fenders.
The event of pollution can arise from situations, which might include:
• Failure of cargo hoses and/or mooring lines
• Deterioration of the weather conditions and/or sea state
• Damage to the cargo hose(s)
• Cargo overflow
• Machinery failure on one of the oil tankers
• Failure of pressure relief (PV) valves, leading to tank explosion
• Securing and/or disconnecting of cargo hoses in a seaway and,
• Cargo pump, valve or line failure on one of the oil tankers
The event of spillage of hydrocarbons can in turn lead to fire and/or explosion. The possibility of
explosion exists during the transfer of lower flash point oils.
A risk to the safety of the crew also exists in the form of gas accumulations because airflows around
the decks of ships involved in STS operations are prone to eddies that prevent normal dissipation. In
this regard, normal tanker safety precautions should be maintained during cargo transfer operations.
2.9 Standard Oil Tanker Definitions
There are different tanker sizes used for the international transportation of oil, from a modest coastal
tanker to a VLCC or ULCC Supertanker. The common rule is that the volume that can be carried in a
tanker increases as a function of the cube of its length. For instance, a ULCC is about twice the length
of a coastal tanker (415 meters versus 205 meters), but can carry about 8 times the volume (50,000
deadweight tons versus 400,000 dwt).
10,000–24,999 DWT: Small tanker
25,000–34,999 DWT: Intermediate tanker
35,000–44,999 DWT: Medium Range 1 (MR1)
45,000–54,999 DWT: Medium Range 2 (MR2)
55,000–79,999 DWT: Long Range 1 (LR1)
80,000–159,999 DWT: Long Range 2 (LR2)
160,000–319,999 DWT: Very Large Crude Carrier
(VLCC)
320,000–549,999 DWT: Ultra Large Crude Carrier
(ULCC)
Figure 1 - Standard Oil Tanker Definitions by size
2.10 Lightering Operations
Where cargo oil is transferred between ships moored side-by-side. Such operations may take place
when one ship is at anchor or alongside or when both are underway. In general, the expression includes
the approach manoeuvre, mooring, hose connection, procedures for cargo transfer, hose
disconnection, unmooring and departure manoeuvre. The operation may also be referred to as
“transhipment”.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 18 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
2.10.1 Lightering
Lightering Operations involve the Mother vessel discharging her cargo into one or more smaller ships
this term is used to describe an STS operation that is being performed for the purpose of discharging
a ship in deeper water at a location where available loading berths do not have sufficient water
alongside to safely handle the ship at her laden draught.
Figure 2 Ship to ship transfer
2.10.2 Reverse Lightering
Is an operation that involves discharge from one or more smaller ships into a larger ship. In this
scenario the Receiving ship is actually the Mother ship. Primarily, this term is used to describe an STS
operation that is being performed for the purpose of loading an exporting ship in deeper water at a
location where available loading berths do not have sufficient water alongside to safely handle the
ship at her laden departure draught.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 19 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
3 CONDITIONS AND REQUIREMENTS
3.1 Transfer Areas
3.1.1 General
Transfer areas may be defined in legislation by authorities. The size of transfer areas used varies
considerably and the space available will impact upon the type of manoeuvre that can be used for the
STS operation.
Where it is intended that both ships are to be underway, a relatively large transfer area will be needed
to accommodate the necessary manoeuvres. Conversely, a ship approaching another ship at anchor or
alongside will require a much smaller overall area.
For all STS transfers, a safe area around the vessels should be agreed and monitored. Contingencies
should be developed to address any potential breaches of the safe area. Some harbour authorities may
require a safety patrol vessel to be on station throughout the transfer operations.
Within port limits or in specified approved offshore locations, support in the form of pilots and tugs
may be available or be required by local legislation.
When assessing the suitability of an STS transfer location, reference may be made to the guidance and
example checklists contained within Ship to Ship Service Provider Management (reference' 6).
When the transfer is to take place alongside a terminal, restrictions on the transfer area should take
into consideration the proximity of passing ships and traffic density in the vicinity. Local regulations
may not permit more than one vessel alongside at any time and may require terminal facilities to be
specifically licensed for STS operations involving double banking.
Up to date Maritime Safety Information and Sailing Directions can be found at:
https://msi.nga.mil/NGAPortal/MSI.portal;jsessionid=TZpBb4qGY8ksLCGjjnv9y1qM7yrClnCy7BsCnxd
2nL17DbmFdc92!-1727825110!1951496448?_nfpb=true&_st=&_pageLabel=msi_pub_detail
3.1.2 STS Transfer Area Risk Assessment
All MTS transfer areas are assessed for risk using a Risk Assessment based upon the requirements
detailed in IMO Manual on Oil Pollution, Section 1 and comply with the 'best practice' advised in
"ICS/OCIMF/CDI/SIGTTO - STS Transfer Guide": 2.1, 3.2.1, 3.2.2 & Appendix 'K'. The Area specific RA
shall be review annually to verify its accuracy or when any key condition relating to identified hazards
changes, or a new hazard is identified, the risk assessment should be formally revised.
3.1.3 Location Approvals
Every location used for MTS Ship-to-Ship/Barge transfers by double banking or open water STS requires
a Location Approval signed by a Director.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 20 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Figure 3 - Example of Location Approval
3.2 Vessel Compatibility
When planning an STS transfer operation, MTS ensure that the ships to be used are compatible in
design and equipment; that they comply with the various recommendations included in this Procedure
Manual; and that mooring operations, hose handling and communications can be conducted safely
and efficiently.
The MTS ‘Client’ will submit the proposed vessels names, Q-88, STS Checklist No.1 and an electronic
copy of the vessel General Arrangement Plan to the MTS duty Operator, as per the “Process Control
Procedure 3.4.1”. The ‘Ship Specific Risk Assessment’ shall be completed by the Duty Operator for each
proposed STS to assess any adverse risk and mitigation measures to minimise that risk.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 21 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Figure 4 - Screening Risk Assessment
An initial Risk value of “3” may result in the nominated vessel being rejected and will result in the
proposed vessel and RA being forwarded to MTS Senior Management for action. Standard Risk
Mitigation measure may be applied to an initial Risk Value of “2” in order to reduce the Residual (New)
Risk Value to “1”. The Approval will remain valid for these vessels for a period not exceeding 12
months. A record of each Screening RA will be placed in the Job File in accordance with Document
Control Procedures.
The ‘Ship Specific Risk Assessment’ mitigation factors have been determined to allow for operations
with vessels of a similar length, i.e. having a length over all (LOA) differential of less than 10% and
overhanging bridge wings.
3.3 Notification to and, Approval from Authorities
3.3.1 MARPOL Annex-1 Cargoes
For STS Transfers involving MARPOL Annex 1 cargoes within the territorial sea or the Exclusive
Economic Zone (EEZ) of a party to the MARPOL Convention, the Master or Agent of each tanker
involved is required to notify the relevant Coastal State authorities not less than 48-hours in advance
of the scheduled operation.
The Local Agent, is responsible for notifying all concerned parties of the upcoming STS operation in
compliance with the MARPOL Convention.
3.3.2 Chemical cargoes
Government authorities may require notifications for STS transfers involving Annex II cargoes. Where
these transfers are conducted within port limits the harbour authority may require notification. In
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 22 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
either case a lightering plan may be required. If alongside a terminal, the operator, or owner may also
require a copy of the lightering plan.
3.3.3 Liquefied Gas Cargoes
Government authorities require notifications for STS transfers involving Liquefied Gas cargoes on a
case by case basis. Where these transfers are conducted within port limits the harbour authority may
require notification. In either case a lightering plan may be required. If alongside a terminal, the
operator, or owner may also require a copy of the lightering plan.
The approval must be displayed in the Cargo Control Room of the Mother vessel. Normally no other
operations, e.g. bunkering. Stores etc. may be carried out concurrent with the STS Transfer operation.
3.3.4 Other cargoes
For STS transfer involving other cargoes, the STS organiser (MTS) should check local and national
regulations to determine the level of approval required to conduct the transfer operation. Refer to
Location Approval
Figure 5 - Example of Port Authority Approval (Dutch & English Translation)
3.3.5 Danish Waters
Refer to Section: Appendix-A para. 19.3 Approval from Authorities
3.4 Material safety data sheet
Prior to operations commencing, both vessels should have copies of the material safety data sheet
(MSDS) for the products being transferred. Particular attention should be given to the potential of H2S,
Benzene and other toxic substances in the cargo vapours and all necessary personal safety precautions
should be taken.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 23 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
4 ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS
Various environmental conditions prevalent in the transfer location may impose restrictions on the
STS operation. Some coastal state authorities may have regulations that would limit STS operations
under adverse weather conditions.
a) It is impractical to generalize limiting weather conditions under which an STS operation can be
performed since much will depend on the effect of the sea and swell on the fenders and the
movements induced in the participating vessels, taking in to account their relative displacement
and freeboard
b) STS operations in locations subjected to long period waves should be treated with caution
c) When a STS transfer is to take place at anchor, the combined effect of current and weather
conditions on the movements of the moored tankers and the ultimate stress on the anchor cable
should be carefully considered
d) Available weather forecasts for the transfer area, supplemented by information from facsimile
weather records, are to be obtained before operations begin
e) Throughout the berthing operation, visibility conditions are required to be safe for maneuvering,
taking into account navigation and collision avoidance requirements
The Master of any ship involved in the operation retains the right to suspend operations and unmoor,
should he have concerns regarding the safety of the ships remaining alongside in the prevailing
weather and sea state conditions. For a given location, sea and swell height is generally a factor of
fetch, wind speed and direction.
Factors for at sea operations include the physical sizes of the ships and their manoeuvring capabilities,
prevailing visibility (>1nm), wind speed and direction; wave and swell height, period and direction, the
speed of the approaching weather, free surface effect, sloshing limitations, manning and workboat
capabilities.
Operations in port, would be affected by weather factors that could influence the available depth of
water, tidal heights, currents and sea states in exposed waters. Under keel clearances should be
constantly monitored and due account is to be taken of any temporary restrictions to the vessel’s
draught, that may often be a requirement of the local authorities.
The Mooring Master should obtain the latest weather reports for the transfer area 24-hours, 12-hours
and immediately prior to the planned operation. The Mooring Master may postpone the STS operation
if the weather reports indicate weather conditions exceeding the guidelines.
Under no circumstances should any operation commence if there is any doubt about the safety of the
crew, vessel or cargo. Where Terminal and/or Port Authority guidance is not applicable, the following
operational weather criteria limits have been established by MTS based on industry standards during
which STS mooring and cargo operation may take place. In-port berthing operation criteria are
regulated by Port Regulations and Pilot advise.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 24 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
4.1.1 Guidelines for Open Water Limiting Weather Criteria:
Mooring - maximum Wind speed - 20 knots (10 m/sec), Hs – 2.0m
Stop Cargo Transfer - maximum Wind speed - 30 knots (15m/sec), Hs – 2.5m
Remaining moored - maximum Wind speed - <35 knots (17m/sec), Hs – 3.0m
Wind velocity limit based on 10-minute mean average.
4.1.2 Guidelines for ARA Region in-port Limiting Weather Criteria:
Mooring - maximum Wind speed - 20 knots (10 m/sec),
Stop Cargo Transfer - maximum Wind speed - 26 knots (13m/sec),
Disconnect Hoses - maximum Wind speed - 30 knots (15m/sec),
Remaining moored - maximum Wind speed - <35 knots (17m/sec)
Wind velocity limit based on 10-minute mean average.
4.2 Climatic Conditions and Measures
4.2.1 Precautions and measures in cold weather conditions
Extreme cold weather conditions at the transfer areas mandate additional precautions to be taken to
ensure the safety of personnel and the immediate availability of essential ship systems. Guidance
measures may be found in national or international publications such as “The Use of Large Tankers in
Seasonal First Year Ice and Severe Sub-Zero Conditions”
The following is a non-exhaustive list of pertinent considerations:
a) Provision of appropriate cold weather clothing
b) The potential for slips and falls on icy surfaces
c) The suitability of fenders and cargo transfer equipment
d) The readiness of safety and fire-fighting systems
e) The proper functioning of pneumatic, steam and hydraulic systems
f) The correct operation of quick release couplings (QRCs)
g) The proper operability of high velocity vents, purge pipes, pressure vacuum breakers, ballast tank
vents and cargo/ballast system valves
h) As appropriate, ensuring that safety showers and eye wash facilities remain in an operational
condition
i) Oil spill plans and oil spill response plans may need to be revised if applicable, to consider cold
weather and ice conditions
j) The lower temperatures associated with cold weather may create low lying, heavier than air
flammable vapor that could spread over the side of the hull on to the lower vessel
4.2.2 Ship to ship operations in ice conditions
STS transfer areas may have ice conditions that could vary from solid pack to open sea.
Prior to undertaking any STS transfers in such areas, the following non-exhaustive conditions are to be
duly considered:
a) The experience that ship’s personnel and service providers have of operating in ice
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 25 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
b) The shelter that operating in ice areas offers. Swell, and particularly sea conditions, may be reduced
or eliminated within the ice edge
c) Accessibility to the designated STS position for the vessels involved
d) The suitability and ice classification of the ships’ hulls to allow operations in ice conditions
e) The need for ice breaking support
f) Fendering considerations will depend on the conditions, but the possibility of the ice itself acting as
a fendering agent between the ships should be considered
g) The possibility of structural damage caused by ships compressing the ice between the hulls or from
a higher ice classed vessel causing damage to a lower ice classed vessel’s hull
h) Contingency plans should address the requirement for safely breaking away in the event of an
emergency
i) The oil spill contingency plans should allow for the possibility of products being contained either on
the ice or within the open water surrounded by broken ice. Spill response equipment should be
capable of operating in the temperatures to be encountered
j) If engines are to be run to keep the propellers and rudders clear of ice, it will need an agreement
between the vessels
k) If the safety and the security of the fender moorings or vessel mooring arrangements have a
reasonable chance of failing due to the actual or potential buildup of ice causing a probable adverse
impact, the STS operation should be discontinued.
4.2.3 Electrical Storms
The transfer operation must be suspended when electrical storms are in the immediate vicinity in order
to prevent possibility of cargo gas ignition.
4.2.4 Special Conditions
If weather forecast received prior to operations commencing indicates wind velocity of 10 -12 m/s
based on 10min. mean average then operations should not commence until a clear weather window,
within acceptable limits, is promulgated for the duration of the intended operation.
Do Not Start Cargo Operations if any of the following weather parameters are experienced:
• Wind velocity >25 knots (12 m/sec) or more.
• Wave height of >7 feet (2 metres) or more.
• Crosswind or seas causing undue working of mooring lines.
Notwithstanding the weather conditions, should the Master of either vessel consider it unsafe to
remain alongside, the Mooring Master will follow the Ship Master's request.
4.3 Quality and Safety
MTS has a Health, Safety, Environment and Quality Management System (HSEQ) in place recording all
Incidents, Accidents, Near Miss and Non-conformances in accordance with reporting procedures.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 26 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
4.4 Regulatory Requirements
The requirements of MARPOL Annex I, Chapter 8: “Prevention of Pollution during Transfer of Oil Cargo
between Oil Tankers at Sea”, Regulations 40, 41 and 42 have been reproduced verbatim in italics
below:
“CHAPTER 8 – PREVENTION OF POLLUTION DURING TRANSFER OF OIL CARGO BETWEEN
OIL TANKERS AT SEA
Regulation 40
Scope of application
1 The regulations contained in this chapter apply to oil tankers of 150 gross tonnage and above engaged
in the transfer of oil cargo between oil tankers at sea (STS operations) and their STS operations
conducted on or after 1 April 2012. However, STS operations conducted before that date but after the
approval of the Administration of STS operations Plan required under regulation 41.1 shall be in
accordance with the STS operations Plan as far as possible.
2 The regulations contained in this chapter shall not apply to oil transfer operations associated with
fixed or floating platforms including drilling rigs; floating production, storage and offloading facilities
(FPSOs) used for the offshore production and storage of oil; and floating storage units (FSUs) used
for the offshore storage of produced oil.
3 The regulations contained in this chapter shall not apply to bunkering operations.
4 The regulations contained in this chapter shall not apply to STS operations necessary for the purpose
of securing the safety of a ship or saving life at sea, or for combating specific pollution incidents in
order to minimize the damage from pollution.
5 The regulations contained in this chapter shall not apply to STS operations where either of the ships
involved is a warship, naval auxiliary or other ship owned or operated by a State and used, for the
time being, only on government non-commercial service. However, each State shall ensure, by the
adoption of appropriate measures not impairing operations or operational capabilities of such ships
that the STS operations are conducted in a manner consistent, so far as is reasonable and practicable,
with this chapter.
Regulation 41
General Rules on safety and environmental protection
1 Any oil tanker involved in STS operations shall carry on board a Plan prescribing how to conduct
STS operations (STS operations Plan) not later than the date of the first annual, intermediate or
renewal survey of the ship to be carried out on or after 1 January 2011. Each oil tanker’s STS
operations Plan shall be approved by the Administration. The STS operations Plan shall be written in
the working language of the ship.
2 The STS operations Plan shall be developed taking into account the information contained in the best
practice guidelines for STS operations identified by the Organization. The STS operations Plan may
be incorporated into an existing Safety Management System required by chapter IX of the
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 27 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974, as amended, if that requirement is
applicable to the oil tanker in question.
3 Any oil tanker subject to this chapter and engaged in STS operations shall comply with its STS
operations Plan.
4 The person in overall advisory control of STS operations shall be qualified to perform all relevant
duties, taking into account the qualifications contained in the best practice guidelines for STS
operations identified by the Organization.
5 Records of STS operations shall be retained on board for three years and be readily available for
inspection by a Party to the present Convention.
Regulation 42
Notification
1 Each oil tanker subject to this chapter that plans STS operations within the territorial sea, or the
exclusive economic zone of a Party to the present Convention shall notify that Party not less than 48
hours in advance of the scheduled STS operations. Where, in an exceptional case, all of the
information specified in paragraph 2 is not available not less than 48 hours in advance, the oil tanker
discharging the oil cargo shall notify the Party to the present Convention, not less than 48 hours in
advance that an STS operation will occur and the information specified in paragraph 2 shall be
provided to the Party at the earliest opportunity.
2 The notification specified in paragraph 1 of this regulation shall include at least the following:
.1 name, flag, call sign, IMO Number and estimated time of arrival of the oil tankers involved in
the STS operations;
.2 date, time and geographical location at the commencement of the planned STS operations;
.3 whether STS operations are to be conducted at anchor or underway;
.4 oil type and quantity;
.5 planned duration of the STS operations;
.6 identification of STS operations service provider or person in overall advisory control and
contact information; and
.7 confirmation that the oil tanker has on board an STS operations Plan meeting the requirements
of regulation 41.
3 If the estimated time of arrival of an oil tanker at the location or area for the STS operations changes
by more than six hours, the master, owner or agent of that oil tanker shall provide a revised estimated
time of arrival to the Party to the present Convention specified in paragraph 1 of this regulation.”
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 28 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
5 SAFETY AND SECURITY OF OPERATIONS
5.1 General Safety
For all STS operations, the Master remains responsible for the safety of his own ship (its crew, cargo
and equipment) and should not permit safety to be compromised by the action of others. Each Master
should ensure that the procedures recommended by the Ship-to-Ship Transfer Guide are followed and,
in addition, that internationally accepted safety standards are maintained. In this regard, procedures
and practises contained in relevant accepted industry guidance should be adhered to including, as
appropriate:
• International Safety Guide for Oil Tankers and Terminals (ISGOTT).
• Mooring Equipment Guidelines
• Effective Mooring
• Code of Safe Working Practice for Merchant Seamen
The senior management of MTS considers safety, environmental protection and incident free
operations as our highest priority. We will conduct our business in the most responsible manner to
ensure that our operations involve minimum risk to people, the environment and equipment. Our
targets are zero personnel injuries, zero spills and zero equipment damage.
5.2 Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
When working with equipment ashore or on deck of any vessel, MTS personnel must wear appropriate
PPE, as a minimum, safety helmet, coveralls and safety shoes. Life jackets must be worn any time MTS
personnel are “outside the rail” of any vessel or on the working deck of the support craft. Any person
being transferred between vessels via personnel basket must wear a safety helmet, life jacket and
safety shoes. For further information, refer to Procedure 3.0.21 Personal Protective Equipment
Following are the minimum basic personal protective equipment (PPE) that should be worn when on
board a ship:
On Deck (alongside During Transfer of Transfer over open
On Deck, small boats
Engine Room during STS Hose Toxic/Hazardous water (PTB, Pilot Ladder,
(at sea)
(dis)connection) Cargoes Gangway)
Hard Hat X X X X X
Life Jacket X X
Safety Shoes / Boots X X X X X
Work Gloves X X X
Eye Protection X X
High Vis Clothing X X X
Chemical resistant
X
Protective clothing
Suitable Communication
X X X X
Equipment
Personal Gas Detector X X
Table 1 - PPE Matrix (extract from Procedure 3.0.21)
5.3 Hydrogen Sulphide (H₂S)
Many crude oils come out of the well with high levels of hydrogen sulphide (H₂S) but it is usually
reduced by a stabilisation process before the crude oil is delivered to the vessel. However, the amount
of stabilisation may be temporarily reduced at times. Thus, a tanker may receive a cargo with a
hydrogen sulphide content higher than usual. In addition, some crude oils are never stabilised and
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 29 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
always contain a high hydrogen sulphide level. Hydrogen sulphide can also be encountered in other
cargoes such as naphtha, fuel oil, bitumens and gas oils.
It is important to distinguish between concentrations of hydrogen sulphide in the atmosphere
expressed in ppm by volume and concentrations in liquid expressed in ppm by weight. For example, a
crude oil containing 70 ppm (by weight) hydrogen sulphide has been shown to produce a concentration
of 7,000 ppm (by volume) in the gas stream leaving an ullage port above the cargo tank. Thus, it is not
possible to predict the likely vapour concentration from known liquid concentrations.
The Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) of hydrogen sulphide expressed as a Time Weighted Average
(TWA) is 10 ppm. The effects of the gas at concentrations in air in excess of the TWA are:
Table 2- Typical Effects of Exposure to Hydrogen Sulphide (H2S)
5.4 Security
Internationally trading ships, and terminals handling such ships, are required to take Measures to
enhance marine security and to be in compliance with the provisions of The International Ship and
Port Facility Security (ISPS) Code, Parts A & B. The Code is detailed in Chapter XI-2 of the International
Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS).
The ISPS Code is implemented through Chapter XI-2 Special measures to enhance maritime security in
the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS). The Code has two parts, one
mandatory & one recommendatory.
In essence, the Code takes the approach that ensuring the security of ships and Port facilities is a risk
management activity and that, to determine what security measures are appropriate, an assessment
of the risks must be made in each particular case.
It is recommended that all ships and terminals should have a security plan with procedures to address
all security aspects identified from a security assessment ships and terminals which are not required
to comply with the SOLAS and ISPS Code are encouraged to consider the provisions of SOLAS and the
ISPS Code when developing their security plans.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 30 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
5.4.1 Responsibilities under the ISPS Code
For a ship, the Company's responsibility for the plan rests with the Company Security officer. However,
the Master has overriding authority to make decisions regarding the required to be in place on board
the ship. This function may be conducted by the Master, although often one of the senior officers will
be appointed.
For a terminal, responsibility for the security plan rests with the terminal management & may
depending upon the circumstances at the terminal, require a designated security officer who has the
necessary skills and training to ensure full implementation of the security measures at the terminal.
Prior to commencing the STS transfer operation, the following security issues should be discussed and
any associated decisions recorded:
• Exchange of sufficient information to determine if a Declaration of Security is required.
• Agreement on how, and between whom, communications regarding security are to be made.
• Actions to be taken in the event of a breach of security, such as suspending operations and
separating vessels.
Local regulations may impose exclusion zones around the STS transfer operation. Due consideration
should be given to establishing safe distances to be maintained from other vessels and actions to be
taken if such distances are compromised.
5.4.2 MTS Security
It will be assumed that all vessels and ports are at Level 1. If there is a change to the above security
status the designated STS vessels are to inform MTS via email of the change to the vessels security
status. Base Agents are to inform MTS of the security change to the port status.
5.4.3 Risk Assessment
MTS Head Office Vlaadingen, is to be informed of any changes to the security status of the vessels or
the base above Level 1. On receipt of the above information the STS Risk Assessment will be updated
to include the security risk of the STS operation
5.5 Operations Risk
In the event of a non-standard STS operation, a specific Risk Assessment will be completed.
As a minimum, the risk assessment should:
• Identify the hazards associated with the operation (collision, proximity of passing vessels in the
vicinity, cargo vapour pressure, H₂S content etc.).
• Assess the risks according to the probability and consequence.
• Identify the means by which to prevent and/or mitigate the hazard.
• Contain guidelines for dealing with unanticipated events.
This risk assessment is designed to identify potential oil sources, the size of potential spills and to
estimate the probability of events that may result in a release of oil into the marine environment.
Furthermore, it assesses the consequence an oil spill may have on biological and economic resources
within the area defined by oil spill modelling.
5.5.1 Hazard Identification & Risk Reduction Measures
In order to determine which of the oil containing systems could result in an accidental spillage, the
initiating events and maximum quantity of oil that could be released has been identified and examined
considering the risk reduction measures in place during STS operations.
• Mother / Daughter Vessel Collision
• Third Party Collision
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 31 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Groundings
5.6 Operational Spillage
Worldwide spill statistics show that operational spills tend to be small, the majority being less than a
tonne. Spills occurring through transfer operations may be as a result of hose ruptures, failure of
connections or tank overflow.
5.6.1 Hose Rupture
The amount of oil spilled in the event of a hose rupture or flange leak during ship-to-ship transfer
operations would be governed by the size of rupture or leak and the pumping speed. Three scenarios
have therefore been identified:
• Lowest probability and worst case scenario, is the loss of all oil within one transfer hose, which
continues to pump for approximately 3 minutes until operations are shutdown. This has been
estimated at 100m3.
• A more likely scenario is a small tear or leak in a transfer hose. Only a fraction of the oil pumped
will be lost. This has been estimated at 10m3.
• Spillage from loading hose connection/disconnection is unlikely as the lines are cleared after
each operation; however, this risk has not been discarded. Drip trays located under each
manifold prevent the escape of any residual oil.
The manifolds of both vessels are manned at all times during the transfer, should a leak develop, it
would be immediately apparent to one of the manifold watchmen who would raise the alarm locally /
engage the emergency stop button as appropriate.
Incorrect loading of the vessel can lead to longitudinal and sheer stresses in excess of design
parameters and possible stress fracture of the hull. A cargo loading/discharging plan shall be
established by the vessel prior to arrival, detailing the condition of the vessel at intervals throughout
cargo operations. Vessels shall remain within their “Seagoing” stress limits at all times during STS
operations in open waters. The cargo plan shall be compared with the actual condition of the vessel to
verify stress and stability conditions using the “Class” Approved stability computer. The Mooring
Master can request evidence of compliance as per the Mariflex Transfer Services BV STS Checklist -
“SHIP TO SHIP TRANSFER OPERATIONS (STS) LETTER”, failure to comply with this requirement will
result in the cessation of cargo operations, notifying the Charterer and if necessary, unmooring of
vessels.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 32 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
5.6.2 Analysis of Likely Spill Causes from STS Operations
Based on the observations from the Risk Assessment, a range of potential oil spill causes exist from
STS operations that may result in a release of hydrocarbons into the marine environment. These are
mainly due to oil handling and tanker loading operations and are highlighted in the following Table
with Mitigation Measures.
POTENTIAL OIL SPILL
MAJOR HAZARD CAUSE OF SPILL MITIGATION MEASURES
IMPACT
Adverse weather Mooring failure & Oil spill into sea No STS if wind forecast >10m/s during the
conditions consequential hose planned STS operation. Monitor weather &
failure; increased risk of suspend operations early based on forecast.
collision & grounding Suspend cargo at 12m/s, call pilot,
Response Team & tugs to standby for
unmooring.
Poor Visibility Collision & grounding Oil spill into sea including Port regulations for berthing in restricted
high risk of major oil spill visibility apply, Visibility >1km.
Communication failure Human error &/or Oil spill into sea including Approval of STS by Coastal Administration
(including failure to negligence leading to high risk of major oil spill and Harbour Pilot attendance; Establish
communicate the start of increased risk of on deck. reliable communication channels; ensure
STS operations, collision, possible loss of that emergency plan is communicated;
emergency plan, etc.) vessels. ensure that STS transfer procedure is
communicated & strictly followed by all
parties involved in the STS
Collision between the Fenders and/or Oil spill into water Licensed experienced Harbour Pilot,
mother and daughter mooring failure causing including high risk of a Experienced Mooring Master in attendance
vessels increased risk of major oil spill. at all times, agreed mooring plan, proper
collision, possible loss of mooring arrangements, use of dedicated
vessels tugs, fender maintenance programme
Collision between a Fenders and/or Oil spill into water Dedicated tugs/Tug crews, Fender
tanker and support / 3rd mooring failure causing including high risk of a maintenance, proper mooring
party vessel collision, possible loss of major oil spill. high risk of arrangements
vessels large oil volumes
beaching.
Mechanical failure on the Collision Oil spill into water Emergency generators, backup engines,
tanker during mooring including high risk of a vessel maintenance and adequate towage
(e.g., steering or power major oil spill. High risk of (two tugs in attendance throughout
failure) large oil volumes approach, mooring & unmooring
beaching. operations.
Error by Harbour Pilot Collision and grounding Oil spill into water Government Licensed Harbour Pilot has
including high risk of a proper qualifications and competence
major oil spill. High risk of
large oil volumes
beaching.
Oil spill onto tanker deck Oil spill on the deck - Fire / explosion on the Compliance with the STS operations
(e.g., during hose fire and explosion deck; Oil spill in the water procedure; equipment inspection and
connection / hazard; Oil spill into with possible beaching maintenance. Drip trays, scupper plugs and
disconnection) water; SOPEP equipment are all in place.
Hose / hose gaskets Oil spill on the deck - Fire / explosion on the Hose inspection and maintenance;
failure Fire / explosion hazard; deck; Oil spill in the water compliance with the STS operations
Oil spill into water; with possible beaching procedure; ensure supervision of
experienced STS Mooring Master
Valve failure (mechanical Oil spill on the deck - Fire / explosion on the Valves inspection and maintenance;
or human error) Fire / explosion hazard; deck; Oil spill in the water compliance with the STS operations
Oil spill into water; with possible beaching procedure. Emergency Actuator at hand for
hydraulic valves.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 33 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
POTENTIAL OIL SPILL
MAJOR HAZARD CAUSE OF SPILL MITIGATION MEASURES
IMPACT
Tank overflow Oil spill on the deck - Fire / explosion on the High / High-high alarms fitted on the
Fire / explosion hazard; deck; Oil spill in the tankers. Alarms will be tested prior to start
Oil spill into water; water. Typical spills are of the STS operations.
small (up to a few gallons),
but there is a risk of a
large spill with possible oil
beaching
VOC in confined places Fire / explosion hazard Potential of a large oil spill Use of Vapour Balancing to minimize toxic
with consequent oil leak with possible oil beaching vapour release. Controlled vapour release
from the tanker; procedures in place. Established 500m
possible vessel loss; Safety Zone. Max. H2S <10ppm.
human injury / loss
COW line failure Oil spill on deck Large spills are unlikely, Maintenance; Compliance with emergency
and small spills could be procedure
contained on board.
Electrostatic discharge Ignition of flammable Fire and explosion could Immobilise cathodic protection on both
between the tankers vapours / fire and lead to a major oil spill vessels. Electrically discontinuous hoses to
explosion on board with large oil volumes be used.
beaching
Over pressurisation of Oil seepage to the deck Risk of fire and explosion; Compliance with the operational procedures
tanks Fire and explosion could and crew training; pressure valves and
lead to a major oil spill vacuum breakers fitted (and alarmed),
with large oil volumes inspected and maintained. There is also an
beaching independent monometer on all ships.
Vapour balancing and hourly comparison of
vapour pressures
Failure of cargo pipes on Oil discharged on deck Large spills are unlikely Inspection and maintenance; compliance
the tanker with the operational procedures
Failure of unmooring Collision of the tankers Oil spill into water Compliance with the operational procedures
operations (e.g., ropes including high risk of a including adequate stern manning during
wrap around propeller) major oil spill. High risk of unmooring.
large oil volumes
beaching.
Figure 6 - Oil Spill Risk Assessment
Refer to Ship-to-Ship Transfer Guide, Section 3.2
5.7 Use of Safety Checklists
Checklists are an important risk management tool aimed at ensuring that operations are conducted in
a safe manner. They are essential reminders of the principal safety factors to be considered, but they
should be supplemented by continuous vigilance throughout the whole operation.
The STS Transfer Guide section 3.4 states that:
“Checklist 1 should be used when organisers are planning an operation. Checklists 2 to 5 apply to STS
transfer operations undertaken at sea and checklists 6 and 6a are provided as examples that may be
used for STS operations in port.
Before mooring operations commence, each ship should confirm with the other that all items on
checklists 2 and 3 have been checked and found to be correct. Checklist 4 should be completed before
commencing the cargo transfer. Checklist 5 should be completed before commencing unmooring and
separation.
It should be noted that the checklists have been developed to specifically address factors that are
relevant to the STS operation and the questions are supplementary to those contained in standard pre-
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 34 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
transfer checklists, such as the International Safety Guide for Oil Tankers and Terminals (ISGOTT)
Ship/Shore Safety Checklist. It is, therefore, important that the ISGOTT checklist, or equivalent, is
completed prior to the commencement of cargo transfer”.
Check Lists are contained within the appropriate MTS 'STS Transfer Safety Checklist' booklet for each
respective area of operation. These comply with the latest edition of the STS TRANSFER GUIDE
checklists. They ensure adherence to the most important aspects of a STS transfer.
It is the duty of the senior Officers of both vessels to complete the requisite OCIMF STS Transfer
checklists together with STS Mooring Master, as follows:
1) Check List (2) 'Before Operations Commence
2) Check List (3) 'Before Approach and Mooring
3) Checklist For Personnel Transfer By Crane
4) Checklist For Transfers Involving Vapour Balancing
5) Check List (4) 'Before Cargo Transfer
6) Check List (5) Before Unmooring
7) Check List (6) 'Pre Transfer Checklist For In-Port STS Cargo Transfer
8) Check List (6A) 'Checks During Transfer (For In-Port STS Cargo Transfer)'
9) Ship-to-Ship Safety Checklist
In addition, the “SHIP TO SHIP TRANSFER OPERATIONS (STS) LETTER” contained in the MTS 'STS
Transfer Safety Checklist' booklet must be completed and signed by the Master of the respective vessel
prior to commencing STS operations. Check Lists must be completed in a timely and chronological
order.
5.8 Drug & Alcohol Policy
Refer to MTS HSEQ policy. All MTS personnel shall be free from the effects of alcohol and any other
substance, including prescription drugs or other medication that may have a detrimental effect on the
Mooring Master judgement. To this end, the Mariflex ‘Drug & Alcohol Policy’ and the guidance
contained in the OCIMF publication, The Control Of Drugs And Alcohol On-board Ship will be followed
within MTS and by personnel contracted to Mariflex Group.
5.9 General Safety Precautions
5.9.1 Fire Fighting Equipment
All firefighting equipment and systems shall be kept ready and available for immediate use on vessels
during STS operations. Fire mains shall be kept pressurised. Portable foam branches and supplies of
foam compound shall be available at each vessel's manifold throughout the time that hoses are
connected. Fire Fighting equipment will also be kept in date and ready in the Base during all Base
operations. Personnel are to be trained in the use of the relevant Firefighting Equipment.
5.9.2 Oil Pollution Equipment
The respective tankers on-board oil spill clean-up (SOPEP or SMPEP) equipment shall be ready for
immediate use and each vessel is to maintain both a continuous manifold watch and a deck watch
throughout any transfer operation.
5.9.3 First Aid
As a minimum, the Base/vessels shall be equipped with the following:
• Eye Wash Station
• First Aid Kit
• Portable Operations First Aid Kit
Personnel are required to be trained and current in First Aid Procedures and the use of First Aid
Equipment.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 35 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
5.10 Prevention of Fatigue
Human error from fatigue is perceived as having contributed to a number of marine casualties. MTS,
together with the Mooring Master, have a duty to comply with the STCW Code Section A-VIII.I,
pertaining to Hours of Work/Rest. In complying with this code, all persons, during an STS transfer
operation, must take suitable rest periods. Work and rest records are kept by the Mooring Master and
shall be completed daily and submitted monthly.
Hours of Work and Rest shall be recorded on form F-3.4.1
Excess noise levels in the vicinity of rest areas can compound fatigue problems and should be
monitored.
Nr. Rest & work hours’ rules & monitoring procedure
1. Personnel appointed to commence STS operations outside normal working hours (08:00 ~
17:00 Monday to Friday) shall be adequately rested prior to commencing STS operations.
2. All STS personnel should have a minimum of 10 hours rest in any 24-hour period. The hours
of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which shall be at least 6 hours
in length, and the interval between consecutive periods shall not exceed 14 hours.
3. The requirement for rest periods may not be maintained in case of any emergency or in
other overriding operational conditions such as:
a) Essential work which cannot be delayed for safety or environmental reasons or which
could not reasonably have been anticipated at the commencement or completion of
the relevant operation;
b) Undue or unpredicted long standby for planned relevant operations.
4. Notwithstanding the above requirements, the minimum period of 10 hours may be reduced
to not less than 6 consecutive hours provided that any such reduction shall not extend
beyond two days and not less than 77 hours of rest are provided for each seven-day period.
5. All staff is to record their rest/work hours on a monthly basis and filed in the relevant rest
hour file. Records of actual work hours must be updated and maintained daily by all
personnel.
6. Senior management shall ensure that proper work arrangements are organized to comply
with the above requirements.
7. In the event of a multiple consecutive STS transfer operations, it is the duty of the Mooring
Master, together with the Captains' of the vessels and MTS, to manage the periods of duty
in a safe and structured manner, including calling for assistance if so required.
8. If work hours are being exceeded due to operational needs, or the management foresees
that there will be further violations, then the whole team should be informed accordingly.
9. Senior management are to verify on monthly basis individual’s work/rest hours.
10. In the event of an infringement, the company management shall investigate it and
implement necessary action to prevent reoccurrence. The management and SHEQ
department shall report the same to all staff, through company safety committee meeting
report.
11. The rest hour log records should be retained for a period of one year. Records for the past
one year shall be available in the respective file.
12. It is primary responsibility of the Staff to bring to the notice of Senior Management any
violation immediately
13. Travel time to/from STS location to be considered as working time.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 36 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
5.11 Mooring Master Handover Procedures
In the event of a change of Mooring Master during the course of an STS operations, the handover
checklist F-3.0.34 Operations Personnel Handover Checklist in Appendix-5 shall be used as guidance to
ensure that all aspects of the operation are considered.
5.12 Safety Drills
When sending Check List 1, it should be ensured that vessels engaged in STS transfers understand the
importance of conducting STS safety drills. Refer Ship to Ship Transfer Guide, section 3.2.
5.13 Safety During Cargo Transfer
The basic safety requirements for a STS transfer are similar to those for a normal port cargo operation
as contained in the latest edition of ISGOTT. The following points are emphasised for an STS transfer
operation:
5.13.1 Smoking and Naked Lights
Regulations regarding smoking and the use of naked lights should be strictly enforced. Warning notice
should be displayed and smoking rooms should be designated and clearly marked. See section on
‘Smoking Areas' contained in the MTS 'STS Transfer - Safety Checklist' booklet.
5.13.2 Boiler and Diesel Engines
It is not permitted to blow tubes during STS transfer operations. The Mooring Master should ensure
that the responsible ships' officers have disabled automatic soot blowers prior to operations.
5.13.3 Ship-to-Ship Electrical Current
It is the responsibility of the Master to ensure that no earths exist on the switchboards.
5.13.4 The elimination of hydrostatic electricity
Care must be taken when connecting STS hoses. Due to the 'potential difference' between the two
ships, it is important to switch off the cathode protection of each ship, thus avoiding the risk of a spark
when connecting hoses. To eliminate the potential for incendive arcing between the two ships, when
presenting the hose string for connection one of the following arrangements should be used:
a. A single insulating flange fitted at the manifold of one ship or within each hose string and all
hoses in the string electrically continuous; or
b. A single length of electrically discontinuous hose fitted in each hose string; or
c. Hoses that are specially constructed to prevent static build-up and limit electrical conductance
to an inherently safe level.
Where an insulating flange is used, it is important that no part of the conducting hose outboard of the
insulated flange comes into contact with the ship to which the insulating flange is fitted, for example
from the use of non-insulated hose saddles, as this could cause a spark.
5.13.5 Places of Electrical Arching
All ship-to-ship mooring lines should be insulated ether by using the natural properties of soft mooring
lines or by attaching a soft rope tail to the eye of each steel wire mooring line. Soft tails should be of
a suitable length so that they extend to the outboard side of the ship receiving the mooring.
Care should be taken to avoid low resistance ship-to-ship electrical contact in the following areas:
• Non-insulated metallic ladders or gangways between the ships – by the fitting of rubber ends.
• Crane wire runners and hooks – by careful operation.
• Unprotected bare wires and chains within fender support nets or cages – by good quality
maintenance.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 37 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
5.13.6 Use of Communication Equipment
All official communications (inter-ship) will be conducted in the English language.
5.13.6.1 Main Radio
The ships main radio transmitting aerials on both ships should be earthed and neither ship should
use this equipment whilst alongside one another.
5.13.6.2 Satellite Communication
Satellite communications normally operates at 1.6 GHz and the power levels generated are
considered to present few ignition hazard. However, this equipment should not be used when
flammable gas is in the vicinity of antennae.
5.13.6.3 VHF and UHF Communications
VHF and UHF communications are of low energy and therefore do not produce the same potential
dangers as might be expected from a ship’s main radio transmitter. Radio handsets should contain
a manufacturer's plate or other marking, or a certificate for each radio should be available on
board, indicating the set was manufactured as an intrinsically safe device. Radio sets should also
be in an operational condition, which ensures that their intrinsically safe classification has not been
compromised.
If a VHF or UHF is being used while the vessel is conducting cargo operations, or is operating nearby
other vessels conducting cargo operations, the power output should be reduced to 1 watt or less.
If power cannot be reduced to less than 1 watt, it should be switched off if allowed by local
authorities.
5.13.6.4 AIS
The AIS equipment should remain in use at all times, including during STS operations on low power
output.
5.13.6.5 Portable Handsets
Non-intrinsically safe Mobile telephones and electrical items MUST NOT be used or carried when
switched on, on the open cargo deck.
5.13.7 Use of RADAR
The use of radar involves the operation of electrical equipment, which is not intrinsically safe.
Consultation between Masters is advisable before radar is used during cargo transfer operations. The
following section gives further advice.
Radiation from radar operating at frequencies above 9000 MHz (3cm) may be considered safe at
distances of over 10 metres. At the lower frequencies, as used by 10cm radar, the possibility of induced
arcing in parts of a ship’s structure is present at ranges of up to 10 meters.
Marine radars normally operate with a pulsed signal and a rotating scanner, so people are not
continuously exposed to radiation. Therefore, the power-scanner interlocks should never be
overridden without an appropriate risk assessment. However, MTS policy is for both vessels to switch
their respective Radars to “Standby” mode prior to berthing. This is normally initiated when completing
“Checklist No.3”.
5.13.8 Gas Accumulation
An STS transfer operation should be suspended if cargo vapour accumulation around the decks or
manifolds of either ship constitutes a risk to the ship or personnel, and should not be resumed until it
is considered safe to do so.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 38 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
5.13.9 Electrical Storms
Transfer operations must be suspended in the event of an electrical storm passing near to or over
vessels engaged in STS operations.
5.13.10 Galley Stoves
Before permitting the use of galley stoves and other cooking appliances while a vessel is engaged in
STS operations, responsible ship's Officers must ensure that such appliances are safe and that no
danger exists.
5.13.11 Fire Fighting Equipment
Fire-fighting equipment must be ready for immediate use on both ships. Ships Officers should prepare
for the remote activation of foam monitors. Additional fire-fighting equipment should be readily
available on deck.
5.13.12 Accommodation Access
All access doors to the accommodation, especially those opening directly on to the cargo deck, should
be kept closed during cargo transfer operations. Such doors, if used for normal access, must be closed
immediately after use. The air conditioning system for the accommodation should be switched to the
partial re-circulation mode.
5.13.13 Unauthorised Craft
No unauthorised craft should be allowed within the 500m-exclusion zone around the STS operation
whilst the oil-booms are connected.
5.14 Action in Case of Safety Breaches
If either ship fails to observe any of the safety requirements during a STS transfer, this should be
brought to the attention of the Master of the ship concerned and operations should be suspended
until the situation is rectified. Immediate notification to the Mooring Master and MTS shall take place.
Reference is made to the 'Master’s Responsibilities Letter' contained in the MTS 'STS Transfer Safety
Checklist' booklet.
5.15 Safe Watch Keeping
Guidelines as per STCW 95 Convention should be followed when planning hours of work. It should be
born in mind that STS transfer operations can put additional demands on ships’ crew. Personnel are
not only required for cargo transfer operation but also to keep a safe navigational or anchor watch
throughout the operation. In this respect, it is the duty of the STS Management Team to plan rest
periods accordingly. (See Section 5.10). The Mooring Master, will ensure that sufficient personnel
attend STS transfers.
5.16 Helicopter Operations
It is not permitted to land helicopters whilst transferring cargo and/or bunkers and/or ballasting into
cargo tanks. In exceptional circumstances, such operations can take place subject to:
• The respective Masters' permission is obtained
• All transfer operations are suspended and all cargo vents shut
• Suitable safety precautions are in place
• Suitable security (anti-terrorism) measures have been taken
Both ships are to carry out all helicopter operations in compliance with the ICS Guide to Helicopter /
Ship Operations. All helicopters used should be equipped with marine band VHF communications
capability.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 39 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6 COMMUNICATIONS
Good communications between the vessels is an essential requirement for successful STS transfer
operations. The language for all communication during the STS manoeuvring and cargo transfer
operation shall be English.
6.1 STS Instructions
The ship Charterer or Owner will issue voyage instructions to the ship’s Masters.
Additionally, prior to the scheduled STS operation, the MTS Duty Operator will send the Master of each
vessel the following Joint Plan of Operations:
• The organiser's full title, identification of person in advisory control (POAC or STS Superintendent
as appropriate) and contact numbers
• A description of the planned STS operation including the location of the transfer area
(Operations Plan) and timings.
• Details of equipment (including confirmation of fenders, cargo and vapour hoses etc), logistical
support and personnel to be provided.
• Requirements for the preparation of moorings, manifolds and lifting gear.
• Local and national STS regulations were applicable.
• Vessel specific ‘Mooring Plan’ for offshore operations (for in-port double banking, this may be
requested by the Master or Shipowner/Operator).
Figure 7 - Example of Mooring Plan with VLCC to Aframax Tanker
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 40 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.2 Information Obtained from Vessel
The following information should be received from involved ships:
• Confirmation of ETA at agreed intervals.
• Confirmation of arrival draft, freeboard, height of manifold above waterline, including maximum
manifold height anticipated during discharge.
• Confirmation that the ship complies with applicable local and national requirements.
The above suggestions can be expanded to include whatever information is required to ensure a safe
STS transfer.
6.3 Navigational warnings
Before commencing an STS transfer operation at sea, and then at intervals according to local
requirements (or more frequently if the situation warrants it) the STS Superintendent, or a designate,
should broadcast navigational warnings to all ships on VHF#16 advising:
• Names of the ships involved.
• Geographical position of operations.
• Nature of operations.
• Time of starting operations and expected duration.
• Request for wide berth.
On completion of the transfer operation, the navigational warning should be cancelled. For operations
conducted in port, local requirements may address the need for navigational warnings, their content
and responsibilities for their broadcast. The requirements may also include associated provisions for
traffic control.
VHF #16
SECURITE, SECURITE, SECURITE
ALL STATIONS, ALL STATIONS, ALL STATIONS
THIS IS (Name of the vessel spoken 3 times), (Call
sign of the vessel)
For STS Navigation Warning OPL Southwold, please
listen VHF channel (channel)
OUT
VHF #(working channel)
SECURITE, SECURITE, SECURITE
ALL STATIONS, ALL STATIONS, ALL STATIONS
THIS IS (name of vessel), call sign (call sign)
Navigation warning 0845 UTC
Position 45° 36’ North 013° 32’ East
Vessel is engaged in STS running-in maneuvers with
(name of 2nd vessel) on course, speed. All vessels
requested to maintain a wide berth.
OUT
Figure 8 - An example of a Safety Call and Message
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 41 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.4 Communications During Mooring Operations
The approach, mooring and unmooring between the two ships will be carried out on an agreed marine
VHF channel. At this time, in accordance with the information exchanged, OCIMF Check Lists 2 and 3
should be satisfactorily completed.
Clear unmooring instructions are to be given to each Master prior to casting off.
6.5 Communications During Cargo Operations
During cargo transfer, key personnel on both ships MUST maintain a common means of
communication; this is normally via the CCR VHF unit.
The primary communication channel used during STS operations must be identified on the SSSCL and
all personnel involved in the STS shall monitor this channel continuously. Due to the congested nature
of marine VHF frequencies it is essential that correct radio protocol be followed to prevent confusion
and to promote efficient operations. The nominated back-up channel in the event of primary channel
failure is VHF channel 16.
6.6 Communication Failure
In the event of a communication breakdown during an approach manoeuvre the manoeuvre should
be aborted until communications have been restored.
During cargo operations, in the event of a complete breakdown in communications on either ship, the
emergency signal (7 short blasts) should be sounded and transfer suspended in a safe and controlled
manner. Transfer should not resume until satisfactory communications have been re-established.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 42 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
7 PREPARATIONS PRIOR TO OPERATIONS
7.1 Preparation of Ships
Ships Masters engaged in STS transfers must ensure that preparation and planning are conducted as
per the “STS Transfer Guide” for Petroleum, Chemicals and Liquefied Gases and DMA Order no. 570 of
4th June 2014, for STS Operations in Danish Waters. To assist towards this, Mariflex Transfer Services
BV will supply checklists, smoking notices and environmental inspection check sheets. The checklists
should be completed in good time, such that vital equipment (e.g. long messengers and oil spill
emergency response equipment) are identified and prepared early.
After boarding, each Master, together with key ships’ officers, will be briefed during the LMRA by the
Pilot and/or the STS Superintendent regarding the mooring plan, tug utilisation and contingency plans.
7.2 Joint plan of operation (JPO)
During planning of an STS operation, MTS will send a “Pre-Arrival Letter” and “STS CL 1” to the masters
of the ships involved in the planned STS operation to ensure that ships are in alignment with regard to
how the operation is to be conducted.
Information include the following (as applicable):
• Details regarding rendezvous location and designated lightering area.
• Brief description regarding how the STS operation will be conducted.
• Details regarding any local or government regulatory requirements and mandatory notifications.
• Communication protocols.
• Security requirements.
• Procedures associated with any personnel transfers.
• Details regarding any service craft and launches.
• Details of transfer and associated equipment, including the number, type and dimensions of
cargo/vapour hoses and number, type and dimensions of primary and secondary fenders.
• Maximum and minimum draught and freeboard anticipated during operations, including details
of the stage of operations they relate to.
Before operations commence, the STS Superintendent shall establish agreement and consensus
between all parties. Information include the following:
• Environmental operating parameters/limits for each stage of the STS operation. These should
include environmental and operational limits that would trigger suspension of the transfer
operation and disconnection and unmooring of the vessels.
• Fender configuration and rigging arrangements.
• Mooring plans and arrangements and sequence of running lines, including use of any specialist
mooring equipment.
7.3 Fender Selection
To calculate a suitable fender arrangement, it is necessary to calculate the berthing energy of a ship
that must be absorbed by the fender at the point of contact.
Berthing speed is one of the most important criteria for determining fender requirements. Generally
the berthing speed of small ships (< 10,000 dwt) is 0.1-0.3 m/sec. (0.2-0.6 knots) and of larger ships is
less than 0.2 m/sec. (0.4 knots). It should be noted however, that it is not always possible to judge
approach speed accurately when berthing and that it may be prudent to err on the side of caution
when selecting fenders. Manufacturers' recommendations for a calm weather situation and a
maximum approach speed of e.g. 0.15 m/sec. (0.3 knots) may be inadequate should weather be a
factor and approach speed be significantly higher than planned, in which case selection of larger size
fenders may be appropriate.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 43 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
The selection of fenders for any STS operation depends upon the following:
• Size (displacement) of both vessels
• Location of the STS transfer, i.e. in-port or open water (at sea)
• Anticipated weather conditions during the transfer
• Required stand-off distance between vessels
• Approach velocity
In order to determine the size of fender to be used, the Berthing Energy, which is a factor of the
combined displacement (berthing coefficient (“C”)) of the ships and the approach velocity, must be
calculated using the formula contained in the STS Transfer Guide, section 9.1.2 and for “at sea”
transfers, Table 9.1 used to determine the size and number of fenders to be used. Further guidance is
also available in the STS Transfer Guide, Appendix H.
Reference to the table H-1 in Appendix H of the STS Transfer Guide provides information on energy
absorption values for fenders based on typical data from manufacturers. These values assume a
maximum guaranteed energy absorption at 60% compression. While this value should be used for
assessing fender requirements, it should be borne in mind that most manufacturers of pneumatic
fenders ensure that a safety margin is built in to the design to protect against accidental over-
deflection beyond the guaranteed value.
Fender Selection Tables contained in “Yokohama Pneumatic Fender” manual 2008, page 38 – 43 Tables
7.4 through 7.9 show the fender selection tables for three “At Sea” weather conditions; Calm,
Moderate and Rough for various vessel types including Petroleum and Gas Tankers. The berthing
energy, equivalent displacement coefficient and suitable fender system for each case are indicated.
For “in-port” STS operations (double banking), where the use of licenced harbour Pilots and tugs are
used for berthing operations, the following modified approach velocities are used to determine the
berthing energy, based on guidance contained in the Yokohama Pneumatic Fender manual 2008, Table
7-10 Berthing Velocity for Ship-to-Jetty Operations:
1) “In-port Sheltered”, location sheltered from prevailing wind and swell based on criteria for “Calm”
conditions
2) “In-port Exposed”, location partially sheltered from prevailing wind and swell based on criteria for
“Moderate” conditions
The “Ship Specific Risk Assessment” calculates the minimum size and number of fenders to be used for
each operation based on the above criteria.
7.4 Preparation of ship
The Masters of involved ships should make the following preparations as early as is practical:
• Review the operation-specific risk assessments and, where applicable, the related JPO and
ensure all identified preventive and mitigation measures have been implemented.
• Confirm that ships will be able to comply with the requirements of the relevant checklists.
• Train and brief crews on procedures and hazards, with particular reference to, mooring and
unmooring.
• Confirm that steering gear and all navigation and communications equipment is in working
order.
• Test engine and thruster controls (if applicable) and main propulsion plant ahead and astern.
• Test essential cargo and safety equipment.
• Confirm that each ship is upright, at a suitable trim with the propeller fully immersed. If one
vessel has a list, the possibility of safe stand-off distances being compromised should be
considered.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 44 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Prepare mooring equipment, including messengers, in accordance with the agreed mooring
plan.
• Ensure that fenders and transfer hoses are correctly positioned, connected and secured.
• For specialised lightering vessels, confirm that fender davits are in the stowed position.
• Prepare cargo manifolds and hose handling gear.
• Obtain area weather forecasts for the transfer period.
• Confirm actions to be taken if the agreed emergency signal is sounded.
• Confirm the security level at which the ship is operating in accordance with the provisions of the
International Ship and Port Facility Security (ISPS) Code (reference 13), and the requirements
being undertaken on board to ensure compliance.
7.5 Lightering support vessels
Lightering support vessels are often employed to transport equipment and personnel to the STS
location and to assist in preparing vessels for the operation. (See section 8.2)
In addition to providing operational support for activities such as the rigging of fenders, hoses and
specialized mooring equipment, personnel on the support vessel will have roles that may include the
following:
• Maintenance of a radio watch on the agreed marine very high frequency (VHF) channels and/or
internal communication frequencies.
• Communicate and agree with tanker Masters on the approach manoeuvres alongside.
• Maintenance of a good lookout, both visually and by radar, for approaching vessels.
7.6 Navigational Signals
Lights and shapes must be shown on vessels engaged in STS operations as per the International
Regulations for the Prevention of Collisions at Sea.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 45 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
8 STS EQUIPMENT
8.1 Pre-Operations Inspection
To ensure STS equipment is always kept in good order, the mooring master shall check the condition
of all STS equipment prior to use in accordance with the Planned Maintenance System (PMS). It is the
duty of mooring master to closely inspect and report any malfunctioning of the gear after a transfer.
Each piece of equipment has its own unique identification number so that purchase, maintenance and
service history, can be recorded and if necessary a back-track can be performed on the use of any
equipment.
If any equipment intended to be used does not meet with industry standards or if the Mooring Master
has any doubt on the condition of any of the equipment it must not be used for operation and shall be
replaced accordingly.
The time of equipment inspection shall be recorded on the Operations Time Sheet using the guidance
on page 3 of the file. Any non-conformance identified shall be recorded on a NCR Report and shall be
submitted to the Duty Operations Manager upon completion of the operation. The Mooring Master
must also inform the Duty Operations Manager if any equipment requires any ad-hoc maintenance
prior to being used for coming operations.
8.2 Support Craft
Marine Support Craft used by MTS for STS operations are usually contract vessels known to the
Company. On occasion, a vessel may be hired that is not previously known to the Company, in this
case, the Mooring Master is required to carry out a pre-inspection in accordance with the “Marine
Support Craft Checklist” prior to loading the STS-equipment on board the vessel. If the Mooring Master
has any doubt regarding the suitability, safety or management of the vessel he/she must immediately
contact Duty Operations Manager.
8.3 Fenders
Fenders used in STS transfer operations are Primary and secondary Fenders.
Sea swell is generally not considered as detrimental to in-port STS (double banking) operations, due to
their sheltered location. As such, it has been determined that the use of “baby” fenders is not a
requirement for these locations, except perhaps between very large vessels close to the mouth of a
river or similar sized vessels, vessels with overhanging bridge wings and vessels with short parallel body
lengths. The rigging of which would create more of a hazard to personnel safety than their use would
be effective to the operation.
8.3.1 Primary fenders
Primary fenders are positioned along the parallel body of the ship and are designed to absorb energy
as the vessels berth alongside. It is normally preferable that fenders be secured to the manoeuvring
ship. During multiple transfers the STS equipment must be checked after each transfer in the best
manner available.
8.3.2 Secondary Fenders
Depending on the relative size of vessels and environmental conditions, secondary fenders may be
used to protect the vessel from sudden contact if the ships bow or stern swings in during mooring or
unmooring. Secondary fenders are rigged on the manoeuvring vessel. Ideally they should be rigged in
an optimum position just forward and aft of the vessel's parallel mid body, preferably utilizing a ships
fairlead.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 46 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
8.3.3 General
Fender Moorings must be tended during transfer operations to ensure that they remain on, or near
to, the ships' parallel body. The ship's crew must grease the fairleads to avoid abrasion damage to the
ropes.
If it is suspected that any significant damage to fender / fender cages / release of safety valve has
occurred, then the operation suspended until remedial action is taken.
The STS Equipment Maintenance manual and the manufacturers maintenance manual provides details
of planned maintenance requirements and general information. All maintenance and repairs carried
out on the fender must be to manufacturer’s guidelines.
Care must be taken to ensure that the fenders are maintained at their design pressure during STS
usage. In accordance with the STS Equipment Planned Maintenance, the fenders are inspected and
pressure checked monthly.
MTS fenders have an internal pressure of 0.5 Bar (0.5 kgf/cm2). Details of the energy absorption
capabilities for fenders of varying dimensions can be found in the manufacturer’s handbook.
8.3.4 Fender Testing and Fender Life Policy
The fenders used should be suitable in terms of energy absorption and result in sufficient standoff
distance such that the compressed diameter of the fenders must always be sufficient to ensure that
there can be no contact between ships' structures through rolling, during the period alongside.
It is recommended that the fender diameter is less than half the freeboard of the loaded ship, to
prevent inadvertent boarding of the ship by a fender during inclement weather, or reduced weather
parameters apply.
The longevity of fenders will be determined by several factors including frequency of use, method of
storage and standards of maintenance. As a general rule, MTS fenders should not be routinely used if
they are more than fifteen years old. However, if the fenders are more than fifteen years old,
assurances should be sought that reasonable measures have been taken to ensure that they continue
to be fit for the intended service. MTS have detailed and accurate records regarding the history of the
fenders. These records include the purpose they were used for, inspection, testing, maintenance and
casualty information.
8.3.5 Disposal of Fenders
8.3.5.1 Selling Onward
Fenders sold on to 3rd parties for continued use, shall be inspected and tested prior to sale and sold
with original certificates and pressure relief valve certification.
8.3.5.2 Fender Scrappage
All fenders, having reached the end of their service life shall be disposed of in accordance with the
Waste Management Procedure by an Approved Supplier.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 47 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
8.3.6 Fender Positioning
The exact positioning of the forward and aft fender moorings will be detailed in the Mooring Plan,
depending on the relative available flat side and mooring layout. If the vessel is not provided with a
suitable fairlead and bitts at the aft end of the main-deck, an extension 20m mooring rope should be
fitted to the end of the aft fender mooring and a messenger from the poop deck to main deck arranged
to heave up the aft fender tail pennant.
Figure 9 - Rigging Fenders from Support Craft
Figure 10 - Rigging Secondary Fenders
8.3.7 Rigging Fenders for Offshore Operations
Typically, four or five 3.3m x 6.5m STS fenders will be placed on the starboard side of the ‘mother’
vessel and, depending on the available flat side, in one continuous string or two strings of two fenders
plus a single fender (if applicable).
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 48 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
8.3.7.1 Single String 4x 3.3m x 6.5m fenders
No.1 fender is fitted with a 30m x 80mm multi-plat. PP/PES
Length of Fenders (m) mooring rope with hard eye and Master Link each end.
No.4 fender is fitted with a 60m x 64mm multi-plat. PP/PES
Fender #1 6.5 mooring rope with hard eye and Master Link at one end and a
Wire 3 soft eye at the other.
Pennant 15
Between fenders No.1 & No.2 and No.3 & No.4 is a 15m x 64mm
Wire 3 PP/PES rope Intermediate Pennant with hard eye and Master Link
Fender #2 6.5 each end.
Wire 3
Between fenders No.2 & No.3 4 is a 30~40m x 64mm PP/PES rope
Int. Pennant 40
Intermediate Pennant with hard eye and Master Link each end,
Wire 3
however, the actual length depends on the available flat side.
Fender #3 6.5
Wire 3 Depending on the available flat side, the 30~40m pennant can be
replaced by a shorter or longer pennant of similar construction.
Pennant 15
Wire The exact positioning of the forward and aft fender moorings
3
Fender #4 will be detailed in the Mooring Plan, depending on the relative
6.5
available flat side and mooring layout. If the vessel is not
Total Length 114
provided with a suitable fairlead and bitts at the aft end of the
main-deck, an extension 20m mooring rope should be fitted to
the end of the aft fender mooring and a messenger from the poop deck to main deck arranged to heave up
the aft fender tail pennant.
8.3.8 Rigging Fenders for In-port (double banking) Operations
Fenders for in-port operations are typically rigged singly or in pairs.
8.4 Hoses
8.4.1 General
The following criteria are guidelines, which form the basis of the hose manufacturer guidelines:
• Avoid kinking the hoses and lift on board using a suitable strop around the body of the hose, at
one end, clear of the flange.
• Composite hoses must only be lifted using the Hose Bun provided.
• NEVER lift a hose utilising the blank flange handle as a lifting point
• Ensure the hoses are suitably stowed between lightering
• Ambient operating temperatures are -20 to +80oC
The hoses utilised for STS transfers by MTS have been selected to comply with all existing guidelines
and are fit for purpose.
The maximum height of the cargo manifold above the waterline must never exceed the pre-agreed
limit as stated in Checklist 1 and further verified by ship response to Pre-arrival Information. It is the
responsibility of the Mooring Master to confirm suitability of the hose length prior to commencing
transfer.
A rule of thumb calculation for the minimum bend radius of rubber hoses (MBR) is given by the
formula: MBR = Nominal bore of the hose x 6
8.4.2 Periodic Hose Testing
All MTS hoses are tested in accordance with ISO-1402:2009 international standard for Hydrostatic
Testing. It is the policy of MariFlex Group to test all hoses at least every 12 months.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 49 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
MTS Hoses identified for use in Danish Waters are further subject to Danish Maritime Authority (DMA)
regulations and require more frequent test schedule to comply with these regulations.
Additionally, routine testing of in-service hoses may be more frequent if:
a) A visual examination shows signs of wear in excess of fair wear and tear.
b) Hoses having been utilised for special projects are cleaned, tested and issued with new
certificates (dependent upon existing certificate).
8.4.3 Hose Life Policy
Mariflex Hose Life policy is based on the requirements of the “Manual on Oil Pollution, Section I-
Prevention” 2011, section 6.2.6.8 and guidance from the hose manufacturers.
Hoses life is variable depending on make, type, manufacturer’s recommendations, hose throughput
and general condition of the carcass, as a guide:
a) For STS rubber hoses the hose life is typically 10 years or 50 million Cu M throughput.
b) For STS composite hoses the life is typically 5 years.
c) For Vapour composite hoses life is typically 8 years.
MTS Hoses having reached the above milestone are subject to a detailed thorough examination and
testing process and shall be tested every 6 months thereafter until a maximum age of:
a) For STS rubber hoses, the maximum hose life is 12 years.
b) For STS composite hoses, the maximum hose life 7 years.
c) For Vapour composite hoses, the maximum hose life 10 years.
If a composite hose is retired due to the above age criteria, the hose may be burst tested to verify
continued relevance of this policy within Industry Guidelines.
8.4.4 Disposal of Hoses
8.4.4.1 Selling Onward
Cargo/Vapour hoses sold on to 3rd parties for continued use, shall be tested prior to sale and sold with
original certificates, hose history data and certification.
8.4.4.2 Hose Scrappage
All hoses, having failed the above test procedure shall be disposed of in accordance with the Waste
Management Procedure by an Approved Supplier.
Prior to disposal, the hose end flanges will be removed and disposed of separately.
8.4.5 Electrical Continuity
Electrical resistance of hoses is defined by the various EN Standards that will need to be met by the
manufacturers. As the electrical continuity may be affected by any of the physical hose tests, it is
recommended that the check on electrical resistance be measured prior to and again following all
other hose tests.
Industry practices have also identified electrical resistance levels which should be specifically required
in the manufacturing of hoses if they are more stringent than the requirements of the relevant
Standard.
• Electrically continuous hoses shall not have a resistance > 1.0 ohms/metre measured between
nipples (end flange to end flange), but in no case greater than 10 ohms per dock hose length.
• Electrically discontinuous hoses shall have a resistance not less than 25k ohms measured
between nipples (end flange to end flange).
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 50 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Electrically Semi-continuous hoses have an electrical resistance less than 0.75 ohms/metre;
however, they do not currently conform to an International standard but are widely used for
STS operations, having given incident free service over many years.
8.4.6 Visual Examination
Prior to every STS operation, the Mooring Master shall make a visual inspection of the hoses and
associated gear. A visual examination should consist of:
• Examine the hose assembly for irregularities in the outside diameter, e.g. kinking.
• Examine the hose cover for damaged or exposed reinforcement or permanent deformation.
• Examine the end fittings for signs of damage, slippage or misalignment.
A hose assembly exhibiting any of the above defects shall be removed from service for more detailed
inspection.
When a hose assembly is withdrawn from service following a visual inspection, the reason for
withdrawal and the date should be recorded in the Hose Records. If for any reasons cargo hoses are
not suitable for their intended purpose, on being withdrawn from service they should be clearly
marked (or labelled) to avoid any improper use.
The status of the hoses prior to each operation must be entered in the Time Sheet with the Date/Time
checked by the STS Superintendent.
8.4.7 Hose Connection
Crewmembers of each vessel are responsible for connecting the cargo hoses, the Mooring Master shall
supervise both connection and disconnection of the transfer hoses.
When Camlock connections are not available, a new gasket must be used each time the hose end is
connected to a ship's manifold. Bolts should be tightened in a "rotating" manner (i.e. 12-6-3-9, etc) in
accordance with industry practice.
Tools utilised for connection shall not be capable of producing an incendiary spark. It is essential that
suitable webbing strop to be utilised for lifting the hoses.
After hose connection, the hose body must be supported between the hose and the ship's rail by a
nylon strap and suspended from the ship's crane. Continuous attention must be given to the manifold
area.
A crewmember from each vessel must be stationed at the manifold during the entire transfer.
The Mooring Master must carefully check the strops before use and advise the ships' crews to secure
the “hose bun” for composite hoses, lifting strap for rubber hoses, around the body of the hose about
30 cm from the hose flange. This will ensure that the hose flange does not abrade or cut the strop
during lifting.
8.4.8 Length of Hoses
The length of hoses used, depends on the relative freeboards expected between the vessels prior to
and, on completion of the transfer, allowing for a 3m offset between respective manifolds and the
bend radius of the hose. A 10% safety margin is also applied.
The minimum required length of hose required for each STS operation is detailed in the Ship Specific
RA. Refer to Vessel Compatibility section 3.2.
8.4.9 Cargo Hose Specifications
The maximum permissible flow velocity through a hose is limited by its construction. The hose
manufacturer’s instructions and certification provides details of recommended flow rates/velocities
and these should not be exceeded.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 51 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
The cargo quantity throughput of each hose is recorded by the Mooring Master in the STS Time Sheet
and records maintained.
In determining the flow rate velocity, due regard must be paid to the capabilities of the ships' pipelines,
turbidity of the cargo and the behaviour of the hoses at the manifold.
Hose Bore Construction Type Velocity Max Rate
4” Composite Oil / Chemical 7m/sec 198 m³/hr
6” Composite Oil / Chemical 7m/sec 446 m³/hr
6” Composite LPG 11.4m/sec 750 m³/hr
8” Composite Oil / Chemical 7m/sec 792 m³/hr
6” Rubber Oil / Petroleum Products 15m/sec 985 m³/hr
8” Rubber Oil / Petroleum Products 15m/sec 1750 m³/hr
10” Rubber Oil / Petroleum Products 15m/sec 2730 m³/hr
Table 3 - Hose Throughput vs Diameter
8.5 Vapour Balancing
8.5.1 Introduction
The following procedure is a mitigation measure that will significantly reduce hydrocarbon, noxious
and odorous vapour emissions to the environment during Ship-To-Ship (Transhipment) Operations.
This is achieved by provision of a vapour hose connecting the vapour manifolds of both ships engaged
in the operation, whereby the receiving ship (SS) in effect provides volumetric replacement of tank
gasses and vapours (including Inert Gas) to the discharging vessel (STBL) throughout the operation.
Whilst the procedure may be unable to guarantee emission free transhipment operations, particularly
when the transhipment involves transfer of volatile cargoes where vapour growth may be unavoidable,
vapour space emissions from the receiving vessel will be significantly reduced in ALL cases.
It is critical that the tanker personnel on both ships exercise due diligence in the following operational
aspects:
a. Close monitoring of cargo tank pressure and atmospheres on both vessels and regular comparison
to identify trends.
b. Minimisation of supply of Inert Gas to the cargo tanks on the discharging vessel to reduce cargo
tank pressures to a safe operating minimum level.
c. Handling the cargo in a manner that will reduce potential vapour growth. i.e by avoiding agitation
of the cargo by pump cavitation or high velocity discharges into empty tanks.
d. Minimisation of cargo tank temperatures, particularly on the receiving vessel.
STS operations at ARA are conducted under strict environmental conditions, including VOC emissions
to atmosphere.
8.5.2 Operational Procedure
Both the discharging ship (STBL) and the loading ship (SS) should ensure that their tank atmospheres
are at minimum pressure above Low Level Alarm Limits with a tank atmosphere having 8% or less O₂
by volume prior to berthing. Ideally, the tank atmosphere on both vessels should have 5% or less O₂
by volume to satisfy I.G supply standards and local port regulations.
Equipment should be provided on at least one of the vessels to enable the oxygen content of the gas
stream to be monitored. Ideally, this should draw samples continuously from a location close to the
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 52 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
vapour manifold connection and should include the facility for audible and visual alarms in the event
that the oxygen content of the vapour stream exceeds 8% by volume.
Following completion of vapour hose connection and prior to commencement of cargo transfer, both
ships should open their vapour manifolds to verify vapour transfer system integrity. Observe and
record Pressure Readings on both vessels to establish that pressure equalisation takes place, thereby
verifying pressure balancing integrity.
If the cargo tank pressure in the receiving ship is greater than that in the discharging ship then the
vapour manifolds should be left OPEN until pressure balance has been achieved between the cargo
tanks on both ships. Once this has been achieved then the vapour manifold on the discharging ship
should be SHUT.
If the cargo tank pressure in the discharging ship is greater than that of the receiving ship, once the
system integrity has been verified the vapour manifold on the discharging ship should be SHUT
At pre-operational (key) meeting, both the minimum and maximum operational tank atmosphere
pressures should be agreed by the personnel on both ships (Vapour Balancing Checklist). The objective
is to decide on an operating range that is sufficiently higher than the Low-Pressure Alarm setting and
perhaps 60% of the Pressure setting on the P/V valves. i.e For Low Pressure Alarm setting 200 mm w.g;
Pressure side of P/V valve rated for 1400 mm w.g. an operating range of 800 to 900 mm w.g may be
agreed as being appropriate.
When vapour balancing non-inert atmospheres, a maximum vapour flow of 7m/s shall be used
regardless of maximum flow rate of the cargo hose.
Prior to commencement of cargo transfer operations, the discharging ship should start her Inert Gas
plant and stabilise it on a pressure setting less than the Inert gas main to ensure gas regulator to deck
main is shut and I.G is being directed up funnel dump.
When cargo transfer is commenced, the pressure setting on the I.G system should be increased to
modulate gas regulator to deck main into Open status and funnel dump valve to Shut status. Ideally
the pressure setting of the I.G System should be between 300 mm and 400 mm w.g to obviate
excessive tank pressurisation.
When the pressure in the cargo system of the receiving ship exceeds that of the discharging ship the
vapour manifolds on both ships should be confirmed as being fully OPEN. Both ships should
communicate their cargo tank & inert gas main pressures to each other at frequent intervals to verify
that vapour balancing is being achieved. If vapour balancing is not being achieved (i.e receiving ship’s
tank atmosphere pressures are increasing and discharging ship’s tank atmosphere pressure is falling),
it may be necessary to reduce the cargo transfer rate.
Ideally when vapour balancing is being achieved, the tank and gas main pressures on both ships should
be very similar. However, there will always be pressure differentials due to flow dynamics and lag
effect. Practically, vapour balancing is being achieved when following parameters are evident and/or
being achieved:-
a. Tank and Gas Main Pressures on both ships are fairly constant with a fairly constant differential
being maintained between both vessels.
b. Inert Gas Flow is continually being directed up the funnel dump with the Gas Regulator Valve to
deck in fully shut status OR the I.G System in Standby Mode.
When the integrity of the vapour balancing operation has been confirmed beyond doubt, the I.G.
System should be kept on standby and the gas main deck isolating valve closed. In some cases, it may
be may be worth shutting down the Inert Gas Plant altogether (in standby) to prevent bleed-over of
gas if gas regulator valve should be passing, in this case, the receiving ship is providing the I.G supply.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 53 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
It is of paramount importance that the ships should communicate Inert Gas main pressures and Inert
Gas Main O2 % to each other at frequent intervals, particularly when comparing cargo transfer rates.
These pressures should be recorded in the Operational Log in the same way as cargo transfer rates,
r.o.bs’ etc. furthermore, the discharging ship should advise the receiving ship of any changes in the
operational status of it’s I.G system.
In the event that the tank atmosphere pressure increases in the receiving ship due to excessive supply
of I.G to deck main on the discharging ship or due to cargo transfer rate being in excess of the vapour
transfer rate. The following options should be considered:-
a. Reduce cargo transfer rate and monitor pressure trend on both ships to verify whether vapour
balancing is being achieved.
b. Cease cargo transfer temporarily to allow vapour pressure equalisation to take place.
c. If the receiving ship has a significant quantity of free water in her cargo tanks and the Shore
Terminal will allow, cease cargo transfer and discharge a quantity of water to the ballast settling
tanks ashore. The water being discharged will effectively reduce tank and gas main pressures on
both ships, if the vapour manifolds are left open between them.
d. Request the Terminal to open their vapour return connection on the shore-side of the Mother
Vessel to reduce tank and gas main pressure.
e. If the terminal allows, open the Master Riser on the lee vessel to release the excess pressure to
atmosphere in a controlled manor. The Mast Riser valve should be shut when the tank pressure
reaches manageable level (+/-800mm/Wg.)
8.5.3 Before Venting
Prior to venting the OOW of the loading tanker shall:
Notify the other vessel and own ship engine room (to put a/c on recirculation) before venting.
Check the sides of both vessels are clear of small boats, or other craft in the vicinity.
8.6 Precautions for high Hydrogen Sulphide (H₂S) Cargoes
Crude oil may contain high levels of hydrogen sulphide (see Section 5.3 Hydrogen Sulphide (H₂S)). The
Master of any vessel with high H₂S cargo must ensure that all personnel are aware of the toxicity of
this gas and the importance of precautionary measures to be taken. Consideration should be given to
the provision of breathing apparatus and personal H2S monitoring devices for use by the deck crew
during all cargo operations, in particular hose connection, loading, gauging and sampling.
It is imperative that any person working on deck during the cargo transfer operation have an H₂S gas
detector and immediate access to breathing apparatus. Where it is necessary for persons to manually
open and close vent risers these persons should carry with them a breathing apparatus.
The ISGOTT publication should be consulted for additional guidance on the hazards of H₂S.
8.6.1 Gauging and sampling
Vessels must conduct all gauging and sampling of cargo tanks in a ‘closed’ fashion. Performing these
operations in ‘open’ condition is not permitted.
8.6.2 Venting of cargo tanks
Should venting of cargo tanks be necessary, then it must take place in a controlled fashion.
This means that main vent risers shall be kept closed while loading, only to be opened from time to
time (if permitted) to regulate the cargo tank pressure should excess gas be generated during the
transfer process and only after having given prior notice to the other vessel of the requirement to vent,
and having received confirmation back from the other vessel that venting can proceed.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 54 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Venting is only permitted through main vent risers, not through any other venting arrangements.
When more than one main vent riser is available, due consideration should be given to the wind
direction when choosing the vent riser to be used.
The importance of giving the appropriate notice to the other vessel and following the MTS
requirements for the control of venting cannot be over emphasized.
During venting operations ALL ship staff, with the possible exception of the manifold watch-keeper,
shall remain inside the ships accommodation. The manifold watch-keeper may only remain at his post
if the prevailing wind condition is such that vented gases are being blown well clear of his location.
In the event that a vessel fails to follow these requirements all cargo operations will cease, and any
delays or other associated costs will be for the vessels account.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 55 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
9 MOORING EQUIPMENT
It is important that both ships are fitted with good quality mooring lines, efficient winches, well placed
and sufficiently strong closed fairleads, bollards and other associated mooring equipment which are
fit for purpose. Effective leads between fairleads and mooring bitts and mooring winches should be
available for the handling of all mooring lines. Only fairleads of the enclosed type should be used,
except on a ship that will always have a substantially greater freeboard than the other. This will ensure
that the fairleads will remain effective in controlling mooring line leads as the freeboard difference
between the two ships changes. Such fairleads should be strong enough to take the anticipated
mooring loads and large enough to allow the mooring line (plus any soft rope tail and shackle) to pass
through comfortably Open fairleads, even those fitted with stopper bars, are not recommended for
STS operations.
Before starting STS open water operations, the STS superintendent shall verify that the winch brakes
are correctly set for the mooring lines to be used. This in accordance with the OCIMF ‘Mooring
Equipment Guidelines (MEG)’. For double banking operations the attending STS Superintendent shall
verify that mooring winch brakes are correctly set during routine safety rounds. In accordance with
OCIMF Checklist No. 4 item 2 – ‘Is the ship securely moored?’
A prime consideration in mooring during STS operations is to provide fairleads and bitts for all lines
without the possibility of lines chafing against each other, the ships, or the fenders. This is critical in
view of the large relative freeboard changes between the ships.
Steel wire mooring lines should be fitted with synthetic fibre tails to provide the additional elasticity
required for STS mooring arrangements. Lengths, connections and properties of such synthetic fibre
tails should at least comply with the recommendation of the OCIMF Mooring Equipment Guidelines
(Reference 2).
High modulus synthetic fibre ropes, which are now increasingly being used as ship's moorings, should
(depending on type) also be fitted with soft rope tails to provide additional elasticity and to reduce the
susceptibility to fatigue failure. (See the OCIMF publication Guidelines on the Use of High-Modulus
Synthetic Fibre Ropes as Mooring Lines on Large Tankers for further details.) Some high modulus
synthetic fibre ropes are susceptible to axial compression fatigue due to tight radius bends and care
should be taken to follow the manufacturer's recommendations when choosing the connection to the
tail. Some types are more susceptible to chafing and may require greater protection in STS Service.
Strong rope messengers should be available on both ships. A minimum of four messengers should be
available, preferably made from a buoyant synthetic fibre material of 40mm diameter and at least
200m in length and fit for purpose.
In the case of ships where deck fittings or equipment do not meet the above recommendations, the
Master should be aware of any limitations and should advise the Master of the other ship, the Mooring
Master / POAC of this shortcoming so that they may take appropriate precautions.
The recommended minimum number of closed fairleads on the starboard side of the larger ship for
STS operations is three aft and four forward. Typically, a mooring pattern for exposed locations for
lightering vessels not fitted with special mooring arrangements would consist of at least six head- lines,
two forward and two back springs, and four stern lines. Where specialised mooring equipment is fitted
the number of headlines could be reduced to four where this has proven to be reliable for the local
operating environment.
The aft closed fairleads should be located as far aft as practicable and the forward closed fairleads
should be located on, or to starboard of, the centre line and clear of any protruding anchor housings.
In determining the location of closed fairleads consideration should be given to achieving a mooring
arrangement that allows mooring lines of the same function (headlines, stern lines, breast lines or
springs) to run as parallel as possible to each other in order most effectively to share the mooring load.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 56 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
It is desirable that each designated STS suitable closed fairlead on the larger ship be accompanied by
bitts capable of taking at least two mooring lines and rated to at least the same SWL as the fairlead.
Each set of bitts should be sited or arranged for safe use of messengers and attendant winches.
9.1 Mooring Preparations
A mooring plan (see Section 6.1) should be agreed before commencing the operation. The number of
mooring lines and where they are situated will depend on several factors including the size of the
vessels, their freeboards, the weather conditions and the location and relative positions of their
mooring fairleads. The usual practice is for the mooring lines to be passed by the manoeuvring ship to
the constant heading or anchored vessel.
Heaving lines and stoppers should be made ready for use and mooring lines and messengers should
be flaked out. The condition of all lines should be checked beforehand. Winches should be tested and
spare mooring lines should be readily to hand. Possible snap back zones should be discussed with the
mooring team and fire axes or bow saws should be placed at each mooring station ready to cut the
lines if deemed necessary.
The number of crewmembers available forward and aft should be sufficient to ensure that the mooring
operation can be undertaken safely and completed in a timely manner.
The master of both ships should make the following minimum preparation before manoeuvres begin:
• A study of the procedures given in PART ‘B’, supplemented by any instructions issued by ship-
owners or organisers.
• Testing of essential cargo and safety equipment. Procedures of this type are described in
ISGOTT.
• Crews fully briefed on procedures and hazards, with particular reference to mooring and
unmooring.
• Confirmation that each ship will be able to comply with all requirements of the
Operational/Safety Check-Lists.
• Steering gear and all navigation and communications equipment confirmed to be in working
order.
• Engine controls tested and main propulsion plant tested ahead and astern.
• Each ship to be upright (having no list) and at a suitable trim.
• Mooring equipment prepared in accordance with mooring plan.
• Fenders and transfer hoses correctly positioned, connected and secured as appropriate and as
required by STS transfer procedure.
• Cargo manifolds and hose handling gear prepared
• Area weather forecasts for the transfer period obtained.
• An agreement as to actions if the emergency signal on the ship's whistle is sounding.
• Confirmation of the Security Level at which the ship is operating in accordance with the
provisions of the IMO International Ship to Port Facility Security (ISPS) Code and the
requirements being undertaken on board to ensure compliance.
The Mooring Master is to brief the Master and key officers accordingly based upon his experience in
the local area and his experience within the STS industry.
9.1.1 Berthing Principles
The STS Team (Masters of both vessels and the Mooring Master) shall all agree, providing traffic and
weather conditions and local restrictions permit, for berthing and un-berthing operations to be
conducted during night.
During in-port double banking or within port limits STS, the person in charge of the berthing operation
is the local Licensed pilot in accordance with local Port Authority rules.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 57 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
9.1.2 Manoeuvring Alongside with Two Ships under Power
The larger vessel normally maintains steerage on a constant heading at a speed of about 5 knots. The
Manoeuvring ship then manoeuvres alongside, ensuring that the final approach angle is as slight as
possible and transverse closing speed is preferably less than 0.3 knots.
Manoeuvring vessels engaged in STS operations demands seamanship qualities of the higher order;
however, bridge team management plays an important role in the navigational support of their
respective vessels. The techniques which are described in the latest OCIMF STS GUIDE are those that
MTS fully expects its STS Superintendents to adhere to.
Techniques are described in the OCIMF Ship to Ship Transfer Guide (Petroleum, Chemicals and
Liquefied Gasses) First Edition 2013.
It is essential that both vessels prepare good heaving lines and messengers for Mooring. The vessel
with the highest freeboard is usually the one to pass the Heaving lines used to attach the messengers.
It is recommended to utilize Closed leads for all moorings.
Special care is required to avoid ropes and wires chafing in the same Fairlead. Ropes and wires passing
through the same fairlead and which lead in the same direction should be avoided.
During mooring operations, it is usual to send away headlines first, followed by the two springs
forward, at the same time the aft springs followed by the stern lines. It is considered safer to send
these moorings (wires with pennants) from drums to minimize manual handling, and one mooring
(wire) at a time.
Normal moorings during open water STS operations are 6 & 2 forward and 4 & 2 aft, all sent from the
manoeuvring vessel, however, this is dependent on the prevailing weather and any mooring
equipment constraints. It is advisable, during expected inclement weather, to send additional
moorings from each ship. These additional moorings serve to reduce the risk of a break out.
9.1.3 Reverse Lightering Operations
Reverse lightering operations means ship to ship transfer operation in which a laden tanker, is
manoeuvred alongside a partially laden tanker in order to transfer cargo to the larger vessel.
STS Superintendents should exercise extra caution because of the increased mass of the vessels.
Excessive transverse speed when performing reverse lightering will cause the safety valves of the
fender(s) to lift, resulting in reduced performance of the fenders.
When conducting reverse lightering at anchor, the Master, the Pilot and the STS Superintendent must
ensure that sufficient tugs, of suitable bollard pull, are utilised for mooring and unmooring, bearing in
mind the slower response of laden tankers.
OCIMF publication “Ship to Ship Transfers – Considerations Applicable to Reverse Lightering
Operations” should be referred.
9.1.4 Approach at Anchor
STS transfer operations involving one ship already positioned at anchor are performed frequently. For
such operations, one ship anchors in a pre-determined position using the anchor on the side opposite
to that on which the other ship will moor. A berthing operation should only be carried out after the
anchoring ship is brought up to her anchor and is lying on a steady heading with reference to the
prevailing current and wind conditions.
The type of berthing operation then undertaken by the manoeuvring ship is similar to a normal
approach to a jetty.
A careful watch should be kept on the heading of the anchored ship and the anchored ship should
advise the manoeuvring ship immediately if she has any tendency to yaw. To minimise movement of
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 58 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
the anchored vessel, a small Utility Boat may be connected during berthing to provide directional
stability. The vessel may be secured to the port side aft maindeck bitts or right astern of the anchored
vessel, controlled by the Mooring Master to stabilise the heading.
This manoeuvre can be preferred for more constrained transfer areas, especially when tug assistance
is available, or if the manoeuvring ship is fitted with a bow thruster. Where current and wind are not
from the same direction or the wind varies in speed or direction the anchored ship can yaw (or lie
cross-current), making it difficult for the manoeuvring ship to berth alongside. Also both ships could
experience different effects due to their different freeboards and draughts.
When the ship is alongside and mooring is completed, each ship is responsible for watch keeping
arrangement as required by STCW. It is recommended that the anchored ship maintain an anchor
watch (see Section 5.14). Nothing relieves a ship of the requirement to keep a navigational watch.
9.1.5 Assessment of Approach Velocity
The assessment of approach velocities is not a precise art and is often based on professional
estimations from experienced mariners. However, as stated in the STS Transfer Guide, the approach
velocity can have a dramatic effect on the berthing energy absorption requirements of the fender
system. As an example, an increase of about 0.02 m/sec (0.04 kts) in approach velocity could result in
approximately 28% increase in energy absorption requirements at berthing approach speeds in the
range of 0.15 m/sec (0.3 kts) and a 20% increase at berthing speeds in the range of 0.20 m/sec (0.4
kts).
In reverse lightering operations, the manoeuvring vessel is often fully laden and will therefore be more
difficult to manoeuvre alongside in anything other than calm weather conditions.
9.1.6 Mooring Operations
Mooring operations should be managed to ensure best mooring line handling. Mooring lines should
be arranged and rigged to allow safe, effective line tending when the ships are secured together. Both
on board the manoeuvring ship, whose mooring lines will normally be used, and also on the
anchored/constant heading ship where rope messengers have to be made ready between fairleads
and deck winches.
Figure 11 - Example of STS Mooring Plan
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 59 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
The mooring plan adopted will depend upon the relative size of each ship, the expected difference in
freeboards and displacement, the anticipated sea and weather conditions, the degree of shelter
offered by the location and, the efficiency of mooring line leads available. The Mooring Master will
compare the GA Plans for the ‘Mother’ and ‘Daughter’ vessels and generate a unique mooring plan for
each operation. It is important to ensure moorings allow for ship movement and freeboard changes to
avoid over stressing the lines throughout the operation, but that they are not so long that they allow
unacceptable movement between the ships. Mooring lines leading in the same direction should be of
similar material. Lines should only be led through closed fairleads suitable for STS operations. The use
of stopper bars to retrofit open fairleads is not recommended by OCIMF.
The order of passing mooring lines during mooring, and of releasing lines during unmooring, must be
agreed with both ship Masters’ prior to commencement of mooring operations.
It is normal for the mooring lines to be deployed from the manoeuvring ship. However, when prevailing
weather conditions or weather forecasts require it, sending lines from both ships can increase the
number of mooring lines. Loads should not be concentrated by passing most of the mooring ropes
through the same fairlead or onto the same mooring bitts. Use should be made of all available fairleads
and bitts.
STS transfer operations, by their very nature, create situations where two ships are moored close
alongside each other with considerable differences in freeboard. The steeper the orientation of the
mooring lines, the less effective they will be in resisting horizontal loads. The maximum anticipated
freeboard difference should therefore be taken into account when planning the mooring layout in
order to ensure that the vertical angle of each mooring line stays as small as practicable throughout
the operation. During the operation, freeboard differences should be kept to a minimum, with
consideration given to ballasting the higher ship and de-ballasting the lower one where this is possible.
Initial ship selection criteria are considered where large freeboard differences might become
significant during the Screening process. (See section 3.1).
A ship's standard complement of mooring lines is generally suitable for STS transfer operations, but
ships equipped with steel wire or high modulus synthetic fibre mooring lines should fit soft rope tails
to them. The connection between the primary line and the soft rope tail should be made with an
approved fitting e.g. Timm Bosslink, Mandal or Tønsberg Shackle. Additional information on mooring
lines, tails and the strength of mooring bitts is contained in Mooring Equipment Guidelines, 3rd Edition
(MEG3), High Modulus ropes may be “Cow Hitched” to the rope tails.
Strong rope messengers 200m x 40mm should be readied on both ships and in addition rope stoppers
should be rigged in way of relevant mooring bitts. Where possible, heaving lines and rope messengers
should be made of buoyant materials. A minimum of four messengers should be provided and ready
for immediate use.
9.2 Mooring Considerations
9.2.1 Safe Use of Equipment
Careful thought should be given to mooring, towing and hauling arrangements, so that the leads used
are those most suited and will not create sharp angles. Ropes and wires should not be fed through the
same leads or bollards. Fairleads which have previously been used for wires should be checked to
ensure they have no sharp metallic areas on the tension surfaces prior to being used for ropes. Pre-
planning of such operations is recommended and, a risk assessment of the operation should be
completed, especially in cases where it is necessary for the vessel to use an unusual or non-standard
mooring arrangement.
To ensure personal safety when mooring equipment is under load, personnel essential to the
operation should as far as reasonably practicable, be able to stand in a protected position. Immediate
action should be taken to reduce the load if signs of excessive strain appear in any part of the system.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 60 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Wherever practical the person in charge should avoid getting involved with the physical operations, so
that they can retain an effective oversight. Good communication must be maintained between all
members of the mooring team. Other persons who are not involved with mooring, towing or hauling
operations, including passengers waiting to embark or disembark, should always be kept well clear of
the area.
Where wire rope is joined to fibre rope, a thimble or other device should be inserted in the eye of the
fibre rope. Both wire and fibre rope should have the same direction of lay.
Ropes and wires which are stowed on reels should not be used directly from stowage unless a split
drum arrangement is available, but should be run off and flaked out on deck in a clear and safe manner,
ensuring sufficient slack to cover all contingencies. If there is doubt of the amount required, then the
complete reel should be run off.
It is often difficult to achieve an ideal mooring layout, but ship’s equipment can be employed to the
best advantage if the following general principles are borne in mind:
a. Breast-lines provide the bulk of athwartships restraint;
b. Back-springs provide the largest proportion of the longitudinal restraint; and,
c. Very short lengths of line should be avoided where possible, as such lines will take a greater
proportion of the total load when movement of the ship occurs.
Where moorings are to be heaved on a drum end, one person should be stationed at the drum end.
For heavy moorings and large vessel operations, they should be backed up by a second person backing
and coiling down the slack. The line must be tended at all times. In most circumstances up to three
turns on the drum end are sufficient to undertake a successful operation, and an excessive number of
turns should be avoided. A wire on a drum end should never be used as a check wire. A wire should
never be led across a fibre rope on a bollard; wires and ropes should be kept in separate fairleads or
bollards.
When stoppering off moorings:
a. Natural fibre rope should be stoppered with a natural fibre stopper.
b. Man-made fibre rope should be stoppered with a man-made fibre stopper (but not
polyamide).
c. The ‘West Country’ method (double and reverse stoppering) is preferable for fibre ropes.
d. Wire moorings should be stoppered with chain, using two half hitches in the form of a cow
hitch, suitably spaced with the tail backed up against the lay of wire, to ensure that the chain
neither jams nor opens-up the lay of the wire.
9.2.2 ‘Snap-Back’ Zones
Personnel should not in any circumstances stand in a bight of rope or wire. Operation of winches
should preferably be undertaken by competent personnel to ensure that excessive loads do not arise
on mooring, towing and hauling lines.
When mooring, towing and hauling lines are under strain all personnel in the vicinity should remain in
positions of safety, i.e. avoiding all ‘Snap-Back’ Zones. A bird’s eye view of the mooring deck
arrangement is recommended (an aerial view from a high point of the vessel can be utilised) to more
readily identify danger areas. Immediate action should be taken to reduce the load should any part of
the system appear to be under excessive strain. Care is needed so that ropes or wires will not jam
when they come under strain, so that if necessary they can quickly be slackened off. Where a mooring
line is led around a pedestal roller fairlead, the “Snap-Back” Zone will change and increase in area.
Where possible, lines should not be led around pedestals except during the operation of mooring the
vessel, thereafter lines should be made up on bitts, clear of pedestals if possible.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 61 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Figure 12 - Simple & Complex Mooring System illustrating the Potential for "Snap-Back" Zone.
Figure 13 - Forecastle Deck Mooring Arrangement Illustrating Potential "Snap-Back" Zones
9.2.3 Mooring Bitts
Section 8.2, of the Mooring Equipment Guidelines, 3rd Edition (MEG3) provides details on the strength
of mooring bitts to be used.
9.2.4 Tension in Mooring Lines
Excessive or uneven tension in mooring lines should be avoided because it can significantly reduce the
weather threshold at which the forces in mooring lines will exceed their SWL. Attention should be
given to this throughout the STS operation in order to ensure changes to the relative freeboards do
not create excessive strain in the moorings.
9.2.5 Mooring Line Lead Angles
Peak loads on individual head and stern-mooring lines can be minimised if the lead angles are similar
and thus more effectively share the mooring loads. Short leads MUST be avoided if possible due to
shock loading.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 62 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
9.3 Unmooring
Special care needs to be taken during such operations. There have been incidents and near misses
when unmooring with one ship still at anchor, an operation complicated by the unpredictability of
environmental conditions and the difficulty of accurately assessing such factors as tidal conditions. It
is therefore recommended not to unmoor during a change of tide. It is also recommended that
unmooring at anchor be carried out only by persons with considerable experience in STS operations
and use of tugs should be considered where available, especially if yawing of the anchored ship is
anticipated.
9.4 Unmooring Checks
Prior to unmooring STS Checklist No.5 must be completed satisfactorily by both vessels.
9.5 Ships Departure
Special care needs to be taken when unmooring to avoid the two ships coming into contact.
While there are other methods, a common method of unmooring is achieved by singling up fore and
aft to the Spring lines, then letting go the remaining moorings and the attending tugs remove the
manoeuvring vessel to a safe standoff position before she uses helm and engines to clear the STS.
Both tankers are encouraged to utilise a toggle pin mooring system for casting off lines faster,
especially on larger vessels and for spring lines.
9.5.1 Using Toggle Pins During Unmooring
The MTS Ship-to-Ship Transfer Checklist manual contains detailed instructions to the Master and ships
crews to unmoor using a 'toggle' pin in conjunction with a messenger to take the load of the mooring
line while it is removed from the mooring bitts.
Step 1: Shackle the toggle-pennant to the bitts
Step 2: Run the messenger (with a small eye spliced in the end) from the winch to the mooring
line to be released.
Step 3: Take the messenger and make a turn around the mooring line.
Step 4: Pass a bight of the messenger through the eye.
Step 5: Pass the toggle through the bight.
Step 6: Heave inn on the messenger.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 63 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Step 7: Remove the mooring line from the bitts.
Step 8: Slack the messenger line, the toggle will release itself, the messenger will be freed and
the mooring line will slide through the fairleads over the side. Two lines may be released
at the same time.
During severe cold weather, the mooring ropes and messenger lines become frozen, the messenger
line and toggle pin are therefore not effective in gripping the mooring rope. In this case four rope
grommets 2m x 24mm may be fabricated by ship staff. The grommet should be removed from the
basket on boarding the tanker and placed in a sheltered location. Immediately prior to unmooring the
grommet should be “Cow Hitched” to the messenger line and used in conjunction with the toggle pin
to assist in unmooring.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 64 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
10 PROCEDURES ALONGSIDE
When the two ships are alongside and securely moored, suitable communications should be
established for cargo operations. A pre-cargo operations meeting will be carried out on the loading
vessel. If there is safe access between the vessels (otherwise by radio), this will be attended by, as a
minimum, the following personnel:
• STS Superintendent/Mooring Master.
• Chief Officer (Loading Vessel)
• Chief Officer (Discharging Vessel)
During the meeting, pre-transfer checklists shall be completed and cargo transfer procedures agreed,
Checklist No.4 shall be completed.
10.1 Planning for Cargo Operations
10.1.1 Cargo / Ship Documentation
MTS STS Superintendents / STS Supervisors are only permitted to sign the “Notice of Readiness”. NOR
should be signed only with remarks “FOR RECEIPT ONLY” and stamped with the Company stamp. Time
of acceptance is the official time of completion of mooring operation between the ships involved in
STS operation. The balance of documents should be addressed to the nominated ships agent, cargo
surveyor or second vessel Master / Chief Officer.
10.1.2 Discharge / Loading Plans
When assessing cargo loading and discharging plans, due regard should be given to ensuring that
adequate stability is maintained, hull stresses remain within design sea-going limits and free surface
effects are kept to a minimum throughout.
The cargo transfer operation should be planned and agreed in writing in a pre-transfer conference
between the two ships and, where applicable, should include information on the following (where
applicable):
• Quantity of each grade of cargo to be transferred.
• Vapour balancing and venting procedures.
• Where applicable, IG System operational and ready for use.
• Cargo density, temperature and specific precautions such as those that might be necessary for
static accumulator products.
• Details of cargo transfer system, number of pumps, maximum pressure.
• Crude oil washing/tank cleaning procedures, as applicable.
• Cargo heating requirements.
• Initial, bulk and maximum topping off rates and notice period of rate change.
• Normal stopping and emergency shutdown procedures.
• Any critical stages of the operation.
• Local or government rules that apply to the transfer.
• Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) in respect of cargo to be transferred to ensure that the
receiving ship is aware of the properties of the cargo e.g. high Hydrogen Sulphide (H2S) content,
special fire-fighting requirements etc.
• Co-ordination of plans for cargo hose connection, monitoring, draining and disconnection.
Before starting cargo transfer, the discharging ship must be informed by the receiving ship of the flow
rates required for the different phases of the cargo operation. If variations in transfer rate become
necessary, the receiving ship should advise the discharging ship of its requirements. The discharging
ship should similarly inform the receiving ship of any variations in flow rates due to its operations.
The agreed transfer rate should not exceed the manufacturer's recommended flow rates for the cargo
hoses (see Section 8.4.8).
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 65 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
10.2 Additional Considerations for MARPOL Annex II cargoes (Chemicals)
10.2.1 Planning
The following additional items shall be agreed for bulk liquid chemical transfers:
a) Any applicable port regulations and terminal requirements.
b) Personnel transfers.
c) Inerting and final cargo padding.
d) Cargoes with a freezing/solidifying point higher than ambient temperature must be heated to
remain liquid.
e) Maximum/minimum temperatures expected during cargo transfer and any limitations imposed
due to cargo tank, pipeline and/or hose design.
f) Sampling procedures.
g) Pre-wash requirements.
h) Tank washing.
i) Any relevant simultaneous operations taking place on either vessel.
j) When vapour balancing non-inert atmospheres, a maximum vapour flow of 7m/s shall be used
regardless of maximum flow rate of the cargo hose.
10.2.1.1 Cargoes Requiring Pre-wash
For cargoes requiring pre-wash procedures as per MARPOL Annex II and where the pre-wash is to take
place while alongside, the authorities should be notified in advance so as to have the authorised
surveyor in attendance on completion of discharge. Where the vessel is to discharge the pre-wash to
a Slop Barge fort transportation to a reception facility, the barge should moor and conduct operations
in accordance with the recommendations contained in the STS Transfer Guide.
10.3 Additional Considerations for STS Transfers Involving Liquified Petroleum Gas (LPG) Cargoes
10.3.1 Planning
The following additional items shall be agreed for planning of STS transfers involving LPG transfers:
a) Line cooling requirements.
b) Hose connection pressure test.
c) Initial/maximum transfer rate and pressure.
d) Procedures for use of Booster Pump.
e) Agreed procedures if blending or mixing is to be employed (precautions against rollover).
f) Maximum allowable relief valve pressure (MARVS).
g) Procedures agreed for vapour management.
h) Emergency Shutdown (ESD) arrangements.
i) Manifold valve closing time.
j) Contingency plans for emergencies such as leakage or spillage.
k) Cargo odourisation during transfer.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 66 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
During cargo transfer, the maximum transfer rate should be kept consistent with the receiving ships
reliquefaction capacity. Alternatively, a vapour return hose connection should be made between the
ships.
Procedures for heating cargo, if transferring from refrigerated to pressurised storage should also be
considered.
10.4 Additional Considerations for STS Transfers Involving Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) Cargoes
10.4.1 Planning for Cargo Transfer
The LNG cargo transfer operation should be subject to normal cargo planning processes prior to the
operation and the plan should be agreed in writing between the two ships.
The planning of STS transfers involving LNG cargoes should include the following information:
a) Quantity to be transferred, including quantities on board before and after transfer.
b) Cargo and cargo tank temperatures.
c) Estimated saturated vapour pressure (SVP) of the cargo to be transferred.
d) Cool down procedures.
e) Initial Transfer rate.
f) Maximum transfer rate.
g) Vapour pressure differentials and maximum allowable values.
h) Procedures for the control of vapour pressures.
i) Draining and purging procedures.
j) Local or Government rules that apply to the transfer.
k) If applicable, sloshing zones and a contingency plan for internal cargo transfer in the event of
prolonged interruption of cargo transfer.
10.4.2 Cargo Transfer
10.4.2.1 Vapour Management
Close liaison on vapour management should be maintained between the vessels and a methodology
should be agreed prior to the start of the transfer to ensure no vapour is released to the atmosphere.
10.4.2.2 Line Inerting (after connection)
Once the cargo transfer equipment has been connected and all transfer lines have been purged with
nitrogen, the connections should be pressurised and tested. Purging is completed when the oxygen
level at the outlet has reduced to less than 5% by volume.
10.4.2.3 Transfer Line Cool Down
The use of one or more cargo spray pumps, set up to recirculate back to their respective tanks is
recommended for the cool down of the cargo transfer lines. Cool down should be considered complete
when the liquid lines, manifold and transfer lines on both vessels have reached the agreed
temperature.
10.4.2.4 Topping Off
LNG cargo tanks may be loaded to levels in excess of 98% capacity when the operation takes place
alongside a shore terminal. However, in open waters there is potential for greater vessel motions,
thereby risking activation of the tank protection and/or emergency shutdown (ESD) systems by high
tank levels at lower cargo volumes.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 67 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
10.5 Dealing with Small Oil Spills
Means should be provided for the prompt removal of any spillage on deck. Spill equipment should be
readily available at the manifold and there should be an adequate method (spill pumps or dumping
arrangements to a cargo tank or other equally effective means) for the rapid disposal of oil at the aft
end of the main deck on both sides of the vessel. If the use of a cargo tank or slop tank is not a viable
option, an alternative enclosed container with a capacity of at least 2 m³ should be available for the
disposal of spills and oily water from the deck.
Portable spill pumps should be bonded to the vessel’s structure to prevent electrical discharge to earth.
Bonding may be made by external means, or by the discharge hose, if this is attached by means of a
flanged connection to the vessel’s structure. Pumps should also be mounted to prevent movement
and subsequent damage during operation.
Where portable spill pumps are provided, and the discharge is led to a cargo tank, there should be a
suitable fixed connection. Disposal of a spill should not require the insertion of the spill pump discharge
hose through a tank opening such as a sighting port.
Where dump valves are installed at the after end of the main deck, ascertain whether opening the
valves will result in the disposal of spilled oil to the tank. Excessive cargo tank vapour pressure can
result in a release of pressure when the dump valve is opened, thereby aggravating the situation. ‘U’
bends fitted in the dumping line to the tank may allow spills to be safely disposed of without first
having to depressurise the tank, but this depends on the liquid level in the ‘U’-bend being adequate to
prevent back-flow of vapour. The ullage of the cargo in the tank may also affect the ability to drain
spills from the deck, particularly when the tank is full, and the vessel is trimmed by the stern.
If effective draining of a spill cannot be achieved or if pressure release is required, an alternative
method of immediately disposing of a spill should be provided.
It should be recognised that if the vessel is sagged a spill will accumulate amidships and if trimmed by
the head then it will accumulate forward. Spill equipment and disposal facilities must be arranged to
deal with these conditions.
10.6 Cargo Operations Watchkeeping
Cargo transfer operations are carried out in accordance with the requirements of the RECEIVING ship.
It is normal for the Chief Officer of each ship to be identified as the person in charge of the transfer.
He/she may delegate responsibility to qualified watch-keepers during rest periods.
The STS Superintendent is not directly responsible for cargo transfer but, must nevertheless monitor
cargo operations to the best of his/her ability, to ensure that the transfer is conducted in a safe and
controlled manner. Cargo transfer must be stopped if there is a breach of safety regulations or a risk
of environmental pollution.
A copy of the ship's approved STS operations plan should also be available on the bridge, CCR and ECR.
Throughout cargo transfer operations, the discharging ship and the receiving ship should station a
responsible person at the cargo manifold area to observe the hoses and to check for leaks. In addition,
throughout the cargo transfer, a responsible person equipped with a portable radio should be
stationed in the cargo control room on the discharging ship, to act as required.
Cargo transfer should begin at the agreed slow rate to enable the receiving ship to check that the cargo
pipeline system is correctly set. The transfer rate should also be reduced to an agreed topping off rate
when the receiving ship's tanks are reaching their filling limits. Throughout the transfer, as a minimum
hourly transfer rate checks and comparisons should be made between the two ships, and the results
logged. Refer to Mariflex Transfer Services BV Hourly Log included in Ship-to-Ship Safety Checklist
booklet. Any differences or anomalies should be carefully checked and if necessary cargo operations
should be suspended until the differences are resolved.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 68 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
When agreeing the transfer rate, account should be taken in addition to normal operational
considerations of factors including, but not limited to, the following:
• Limitations dictated by the cargo hoses (see Section 8.4.8).
• Any limitations imposed by flow velocities in the ships' fixed cargo piping or venting systems.
• Weather conditions that might cause movement of the hoses.
Cargo operations should be conducted under closed conditions i.e. with ullage, Sounding/sampling
ports securely closed. Where applicable, vapour balancing procedures are enforced and due regard
should therefore be given to maximum and minimum vapour pressures.
It should be noted that the incorrect operation of pumps and valves could produce pressure surges in
a pipeline system. These surges can be sufficiently severe to damage the pipeline or the hoses.
Consideration should be given to the prevention of pressure surges by careful planning and control of
pump speeds and the operation of valves.
During cargo transfer, appropriate ballast operations should be performed in order to minimise the
differences in freeboard between the two ships, and to avoid excessive trim by the stern. Listing of
either ship should be avoided, except as required for cargo tank draining on the discharging ship.
Constant attention should be paid to mooring lines and fenders to avoid chafing and undue stress,
particularly that caused by changes in relative freeboard. If at any time mooring lines need to be re-
positioned or adjusted this should only be done under strictly controlled conditions. Consideration
should be given to the need to suspend other operations to attend to these activities.
Environmental protection is of paramount importance. Therefore, the slow (start-up) speed checks for
hose integrity and ship cargo integrity are vital.
Once cargo transfer is up to full speed, in accordance with vessel and hose capacities and pressures,
then further checks must be made. The STS Superintendent must ensure that hourly cargo figures and
rates transferred are compared between the Chief Officers (or OOW’s).
A responsible watch-keeper must be in attendance at the manifold throughout transfer.
When venting of vapours (whether by vapour transfer or to atmosphere) occurs it must be carefully
monitored and controlled.
Mooring must be regularly checked and adjusted accordingly. During these routine checks all fair leads
must be greased to avoid any abrasion damage to the ropes.
Ballast water management plans (IMO recommendation) are encouraged to avoid the introduction of
alien species to the local environment. These should be checked with the relevant authorities at the
STS location.
10.7 Sloshing of cargo tanks
STS transfer operations that are subjected to adverse weather conditions may result in rolling and
pitching of the vessels involved which would in turn result in the sloshing of cargo in slack.
In general, the following are to be considered as a minimum:
a) Maintaining safe operational and environmental limits thereby ensuring that risks of damage to
cargo tank structures and fittings are minimized
b) Static accumulation of cargo or cargo mixed with water causing an electrostatically charged mist
c) P/V valves must operate correctly if the movement of the cargo liquid creates excessive pressure
fluctuation in the vapor space of the cargo tanks
d) Linked shutdown systems may be prematurely activated due to frequent variations in the tank
levels
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 69 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
e) To lower the possibility of exposure free surfaces in the cargo tanks of the vessels, the loading and
discharge are to be optimized
f) In order to minimize the effect of sloshing loads consideration may need to be given to suspending
operations for a period of time
10.8 Gas Accumulation on open decks
An STS transfer operation should be suspended if cargo vapour accumulates around the decks or
manifolds of either ship and should not be resumed until the vapour has dissipated and it is considered
safe to do so.
While it is normally anticipated that cargo vapours will be dissipated by environmental airflows across
open decks, airflows around vessels engaged in STS transfers are prone to eddies that prevent normal
dissipation. Surrounding structures, such as deck frames and deck houses, can impede air flows,
creating hazardous spaces where cargo vapours can accumulate. Risk assessments should be
conducted to determine control measures when working in these areas.
10.9 Completion of Cargo Operations
10.9.1 Prior to Completion
Immediately prior to cargo completion, ensure that the vessel with the least freeboard has isolated
her manifold MARPOL drain receiving cargo tank from the common vent system and de-pressurised
the tank to below 500mmWG (+/-5kpa).
10.9.2 Cargo Hose Draining
10.9.2.1 Oil & Chemical Tankers
When STS cargo transfer is complete, the following guidelines shall be followed as close as practicable
to avoid product under pressure spurting from the open end of a hose during disconnection.
a) Upon completion of the cargo transfer, close cargo manifold valves on both ships.
b) On the vessel with the least freeboard, open the MARPOL drain line to the receiving tank and
drain the cargo from cargo hose until the manifold stub piece is empty.
c) Check that the pressure in the cargo hose has been released by opening the drip tray drain
valve on the vessel with the greatest freeboard.
d) Disconnect the cargo hose from manifold on board the vessel with greatest free board.
e) Fit the blank plates to the ship’s cargo manifold and the hose flange.
f) Lift hose by ship’s crane.
g) Any remaining oil in the hoses should be drained by gravity to nominated cargo tank or slop
tank on board the ship with lowest free board.
h) If vacuum created, use valve on the sampling line on the vessel with the hose connected to
release the vacuum from cargo hose.
i) When hose is empty, close drain valve on the vessel with lowest freeboard.
j) Lower down the hose and secure on the ships sides.
k) Disconnect cargo hose from manifold on board the ship with lowest free board.
l) Fit the blank plate to the cargo hose flange and the cargo manifold.
m) Place the cargo hose string on deck of the vessel which will disconnect the hoses.
n) Ship's manifolds blanked.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 70 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Cargo and vapour hoses shall be blanked complete with suitable gasket and ALL bolts inserted
correctly, (bolt heads exposed and bolt threads beneath the flange, thus avoiding thread damage when
lifting). Where ‘Camlock’ couplings are used, ensure that lugs are tightened Properly.
For environmental reasons as well as practical reasons, hoses shall ALWAYS be drained prior to landing.
It is imperative that every precaution is taken to avoid the inadvertent spillage of oil on deck. It is
therefore necessary for the Mooring Master to be present during disconnection to monitor inter-ship
communications.
10.9.2.2 LPG Tankers
Upon completion of the cargo transfer, both vessels to close their respective “Liquid” manifolds, the
vessel with the greater freeboard (unless agreed otherwise) will line up her systems to pressurize the
Liquid cargo transfer hoses with hot gas. When the pressure at the receiving manifold valve reaches
an agreed value (normally 5 kg/cm2), the receiving vessel will then open her manifold valve to expel
the liquid in the hose to her cargo tanks. When the pressure falls back to zero, she will again close her
manifold valve and repeat the process until all liquid has been evacuated from the hose. The small-
bore bleed plug/valve located under the vessels manifold may now be opened to confirm that the
spool piece is drained.
Prior to hose disconnection, the discharging ship should purge the hoses with nitrogen.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 71 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
11 PERSONNEL TRANSFER
In general, it is recommended that the transfer of personnel between ships be kept to an absolute
minimum. If the transfer of personnel is unavoidable the following recommendations should be
considered:
• Gangways transfers between vessels are not permitted.
• Workboat transfer should only take place using appropriate pilot ladder/accommodation ladder
combinations taking into account the freeboard. Due consideration should always be given to
the presence of any oil boom, sea conditions, the suitability of the workboat and the experience
and fitness of transferring personnel.
• Personnel baskets should only be used if all the associated lifting equipment is suitable for
personnel transfer and adequate procedures are in place.
Refer to OCIMF Technical Paper – “Transfer of Personnel by Crane Between Vessels” and Personnel
Transfer by Crane Plan, see Appendix 3.
The OCIMF Checklist for Personnel Transfer by Crane and Personnel Transfer by Crane Plan must be
completed by the vessel carrying out the transfer.
11.1 Cranes
Because typical tanker cranes are large, heavy and primarily designed as cargo handling equipment,
they can be difficult to control precisely. It is recommended that cranes suitable for personnel transfer
are used for transferring personnel between ships. Alternative safe means, such as workboat transfer,
should be considered, keeping in mind that appropriate risk assessments for any method of personnel
transfer should be undertaken.
The following factors should be taken into account when considering the use of cranes and transfer
baskets:
• Transfer by personnel baskets using ships' cranes should only be undertaken when transfer is
essential and, it is not practicable to gain access by other means following the risk assessment.
• Any crane utilised should be suitable for the task and equipped with adequate safety devices to
prevent free fall. Hoisting and lowering limiters are preferred and their availability (or otherwise)
on the equipment intended for use should be addressed in the risk assessment.
See Appendix-4 “DNV Regulation 2.22 – Lifting Appliances”
Cranes intended to transfer personnel by PTB should meet the following criteria:
• Only cranes located within the mid- parallel body to be used.
• SWL of crane to be reduced to 50% of rated, during PTB use.
• Cranes should be marked with SWL
• Safety factor of crane wire to be >10:1
• All brakes to automatically activated when:
o Controls in Neutral position.
o ‘Emergency Stop’ has been activated.
o There is a power failure.
• Brakes fitted with ‘Manual Override’.
• Crane hooks fitted with positive locking latch.
• Freefall or non-powered lowering should not be used.
• Safety limit devises (upper/lower) for hoisting/luffing fitted & operational.
• Crane & all its components maintained in accordance with SMS and manufacturers
recommendations.
Following additional requirements should be met:
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 72 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Winches to be fitted with 2 independent braking systems each capable of holding the rated SWL.
• Emergency means for the recovery of PTB from any position.
11.1.1 Booms or Derricks
Due to a significant number of injuries and near misses, personnel transfers are NOT to be conducted
using booms or derricks.
11.2 Transfer by Personnel Transfer Basket
All lifting equipment should be inspected, maintained, weight tested and certified as required. This
includes personnel transfer baskets, rigging and straps. Lifting equipment is to be used only for that
purpose and must be accounted for on the ship's planned maintenance schedule. All load certifications
or class documents should be kept available for inspection.
• Transfer baskets should be of a design and in a condition, suitable for the intended purpose.
• Personal Transfer Baskets (PTB’s) should be certified and meet Flag State and Classification
Society requirements.
• PTB clearly marked with SWL or capacity.
The following features are recommended for PTB’s:
• The SWL based on appropriate testing & application of documented safety factors.
• Associated hooks, slings, shackles shall have equivalent testing/certification markings.
• The empty weight of PTB clearly stated.
• All PTB’s should float and rigid capsule types should be self-righting.
• A crane hook pennant that is long enough to keep crane block clear of riding personnel to be
used.
• Two tag lines fitted to PTB as follows:
o Tag lines to be between 16mm & 19mm dia.
o Tag lines to be secured to base ring at opposite ends.
o Be long enough to reach the water at the lightship draught of the active vessel with sufficient
handling allowance.
o Have ends that are seized. Knots or splices should not be used as they may snag causing PTB
to tip.
• A policy for inspection, maintenance and replacement of PTB’s at specified intervals conforming
to manufacturers guidance.
• Only cranes located within the mid-parallel body are to be used for personnel transfer.
• All hooks or shackles should be properly closed, “moused” or wired. Consideration should be
given to increasing the safety factor of the lifting equipment to be used for personnel transfer
by using one half of the crane's SWL in the risk assessment; i.e. a crane with a rated SWL of 2
tons would be limited to 1-ton SWL for personnel transfers.
• The reach of the lifting equipment should be long enough so that the basket need not be pulled
over excessively, jeopardizing the ability of personnel to hold on.
• The limitations of equipment arms' minimum or maximum angles. It is recommended that the
minimum outboard reach should be 6.85 metres at the lowest jib angle.
• Proper communications should be provided by the most effective method between the
signalman, the equipment controller (crane operator) and the personnel in the basket. Methods
to be employed must undergo thorough evaluation prior to operations commencing to assess
all scenarios and should include the following considerations:
• A combination of voice and hand signals may be necessary between personnel in the basket and
the signalman and the signalman and equipment controller due to varying operating
environments.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 73 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Personnel in the basket must be instructed to hold on at all times, which will restrict their ability
to use hand signals or operate radio equipment. Communications using one particular method
between basket personnel and signalman may therefore potentially be one-way.
• Signalmen are required to keep the basket and equipment controller in full view at all times to
maintain effective control of the operation.
• Operating areas should comply with appropriate noise level codes, however high background
noise levels and ambient conditions (e.g. hydraulic machinery, wind etc) should be anticipated
and may present difficulties with sound communications.
• Operators should be fully trained before using the equipment for personnel transfer. This should
not be limited to classroom training, but also include simulated dummy loads being transferred
under practice until the operation can be completed with minimal risk.
• When making personnel transfer lifts, the load must be under full control (both in raise and
lower modes) and the transfer basket should only be raised high enough off the deck to clear all
obstructions and minimise swinging.
• Sufficient personnel, trained not to stand in danger areas, should be available to provide
assistance.
• Equipment should be inspected and tested prior to each use, and the maximum and minimum
crane arm angles and safe working load reviewed.
Reliable means of rescue should be agreed for use in the event of failure of the crane.
11.3 Limitations
Except for emergency operations, the operational limitations for lifting of personnel shall be as follows:
• Mean wind velocity:10m/s
• Significant wave height: 2 m
• Visibility: daylight or equivalent.
11.4 Training
All personnel involved in the transfer operation to be trained and able to provide evidence of their
competence.
Key personnel, crane operator, signaller and responsible person should be provided with:
1. Theoretical training including company specific policies & procedures for crane operations and the transfer
of personnel by crane.
2. Practical training. This should familarise crew with ship-specific equipment.
It is recommended that Key Personnel involved in transfer by crane operations can demonstrate
competence in operating a crane, covering:
1. The safe use of cranes for transferring personnel.
2. The correct use and limitations of lifting equipment.
3. Best practices for operating cranes.
4. Pre-operational checks and shutdown procedures.
5. Effective planning of lifting operations.
6. Operation of the crane in a safe and controlled manner, regarding safety of personnel.
7. Use of manual hydraulic pump for slewing and lowering of crane, if fitted.
8. Contingency planning requirements.
9. Signalling and terminology used during personnel transfer operation.
Assisting crew should be provided with training to ensure they are familiar with:
1. The safe use of cranes for transferring personnel.
2. Procedures for transferring personnel by crane.
3. Best practices for transferring personnel by crane.
4. Signalling and terminology used during personnel transfer operation
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 74 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Personnel being transferred should be familiarised with the personnel transfer by crane procedure,
including:
1. The method of transfer.
2. Safe body mechanics.
3. How to use the PTB in accordance with manufacturer’s instructions.
4. How to embark/disembark safely.
5. What to do in the event of crane failure.
11.5 The Transfer by Crane Team.
On the active vessel, the transfer by crane team should include a responsible person, the crane
operator, the signaller and at least two crew members to tend tag lines & provide assistance.
On the passive vessel, the team should include a responsible person and at least two crew members
to provide assistance.
Anyone not directly involved should be kept well clear of the area.
All members of the team should be competent in transfer by crane operations. The crane operator
should be trained and competent as required by the vessel’s SMS.
The signaller should wear a distinguishing, high visibility vest for easy identification and located in
direct line of sight to the crane operator. The signaller should use agreed crane signals and be the only
person to signal the crane operator. The only exception is in the event of an emergency, when any
team member can raise the alarm.
11.6 Instructions for Use
Figure 14 - Personnel Transfer Basket
• Personnel carriers should not be utilized in weather, wind, or sea conditions that the qualified
person considers to be unsafe.
• Before any attempt is made to lift personnel with a carrier, clear instructions should be given to
all persons involved.
• No person suffering from acute seasickness or vertigo shall be transported by personnel carrier.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 75 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Any individual has the right to refuse transfer by a personnel basket.
• All personnel riding on a personnel carrier should wear an approved life vest or life preserver. An
approved Type I illuminated PFD should be required for all transfers conducted at night.
• All personnel riding on a personnel carrier should stand on the outer rim, evenly spaced, and
adjacent to a sidewall opening in the netting, facing inward.
• Passenger forearms should be interlocked on inside of sidewall netting.
Section 9.4 of the Ship-to-Ship Transfer Guide should be read in conjunction with this section.
11.7 Lighting
During STS transfers at night, normal in-port deck lighting should be adequate. The minimum
recommended lighting is five foot-candles (lumens) at transfer connection points and one foot-candle
in oil transfer operation work areas (measured one metre above the deck). Portable spotlights, which
should be flameproof, and bridge wing spotlights, are useful for night mooring and unmooring
operations.
11.8 Auxiliary Equipment
All auxiliary equipment - wires, messengers, stoppers, strops and shackles etc. should be inspected for
condition prior to commencing the STS operation.
Excess noise levels near mechanical equipment can influence operational communication safety, as
well as affecting off duty personnel during rest periods and contributing to fatigue. It is recommended
that ships involved in STS operations comply with an appropriate noise standard. IMO Resolution A.486
Code on Noise Levels on board Ships may be consulted. Reference may also be made to the noise level
standards used by some Classification Societies.
11.9 Personnel Transfer by Crane Plan
A Personnel Transfer by Crane Plan (see Appendix-3) should consider the following:
1. A Risk Assessment should be conducted before each transfer or group of transfers. This exercise
should include all personnel involved in a transfer operation, including personnel being
transferred.
2. An assessment of weather conditions, taking into account visibility, wind, seas, swell and vessel
movement plus agreed limitations to stop the transfer.
3. A Permit-to-Work for transfer by crane.
4. Confirmation that equipment to be used has been inspected and tested by a responsible person.
5. A compatibility analysis that confirms that the crane has sufficient outreach length to vertically
lower or raise the PTB to or from the deck of the passive vessel without interference or
obstruction.
6. Confirmation that all personnel performing the transfer are competent to do so, are familiar
with the specific equipment and have received appropriate training.
7. Confirmation that personnel being transferred have been given instruction, are familiar with and
agree to the transfer operation.
8. Additional precautions required to conduct transfer operations after dark or in poor visibility.
9. A requirement for appropriate PPE for the conditions, to be worn by the personnel being
transferred.
10. Confirmation that a Contingency Plan is in place.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 76 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
12 STS DOCUMENTATION
As soon as possible after commencing each STS operation, the ‘STS Time Sheet’ must be completed
up to date by the attending Mooring Master and sent electronically to the Duty Operator on the group
email address,
[email protected]”. Thereafter, an updated completion time and estimated look-ahead
programme shall be emailed to
[email protected] by 08:00 and 16:00 daily.
On completion of each STS operation, the final time sheet shall be emailed to
[email protected] and
uploaded into the “E-flex” database system.
A hard copy of the time sheet shall be created on board immediately after each operation and stamped
and signed by the Master or Chief Officer. The copy to be retained by the Mooring Master together
with the copies of the completed Checklists for that operation.
Figure 15 - Example of STS Time Sheet
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 77 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
12.1 Records
Hard copies of all STS records shall be maintained in accordance with Procedure 3.0.46 – Control of
Quality Records.
13 EMERGENCIES
13.1 Contingency Planning
Although STS transfer operations can be carried out safely, the risk of accident and the potential scale
of the consequences require that organisers develop contingency plans for dealing with emergencies.
For STS operations, a risk assessment study has been carried out, as set out in Operations Risk section
2.8 & 4.2. Risk mitigation and contingency plans, which are the products of the risk assessment, should
then be drawn up covering all possible emergencies and provide for a comprehensive response. In
addition, contingency plans should have relevance to the location of the operation and consider the
resources available both at the transfer area and with regard to nearby back-up support. Where
appropriate, the contingency plan should be integrated with similar plans prepared by the responsible
local authority.
A contingency plan is a collation of individual emergency procedures. It should be agreed between
ships, MTS and the local or national authorities (as appropriate) before STS operations commence.
13.2 Emergency Signal
The agreed signal to be used in the event of an emergency on either ship should be clearly understood
by the personnel on both ships. An emergency on either ship should be indicated immediately by
sounding the ship's internal alarm signal and by sounding seven or more short blasts on the whistle to
warn the other ship. All personnel should then proceed as indicated by the contingency plan. It is
emphasised that both ships should be in an advanced state of readiness at all times in order to be in a
position to deal with emergencies.
13.3 Cessation of transfer operations as a precautionary measure
All transfer operations should cease in the event an unsafe or environmentally hazardous condition
develops. Such conditions may include but are not limited to:
• Failure of hoses, moorings or fender pennants.
• Deterioration of weather and/or sea conditions, including lightning.
• A dangerous concentration of gas.
• Loss of containment.
• Loss of power (black-out) on either vessel.
• Close-quarters situation with another vessel or navigational hazard.
• Any emergency on the other vessels involved in the operation.
13.4 Emergency Situations
It is difficult to anticipate every emergency, which could arise during mooring or unmooring as well as
during transfer and therefore almost impossible to indicate precise remedial action. However, oil spill
and fire on either ship are examples of the more likely risk scenarios that organisers should include in
the contingency plan. MTS have performed risk analysis and included this in their local emergency
response plan (contingency plan.)
The Master, together with the Mooring Master, is responsible for deciding the best course of action
in accordance with the overall safety of both vessels and in accordance with local requirements.
The following actions should be taken, or considered, in the event of any emergency arising during an
STS transfer operation:
• Stop the transfer. Sound the emergency signal.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 78 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Inform crews on both ships of the nature of the emergency.
• Main engines either in standby mode or on short notice of readiness.
• Implement shipboard emergency procedures.
• Drain and disconnect cargo hoses.
• Send mooring gangs to stations.
• Confirm the ship's main engine is ready for immediate use.
• Advise standby boat of the situation and any requirements.
In addition, Masters should decide jointly, particularly in cases of fire, whether it is to their mutual
advantage for the ships to remain alongside each other.
13.4.1 During Manoeuvring
The Masters of both ships and the Mooring Master should always be prepared to abort a berthing
operation if necessary. The decision should be taken in ample time while the situation is still under
control. The Masters of both ships should be immediately informed of each other's actions.
The International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea (COLREGS) (Reference 4) must be
complied with.
13.4.2 Gas Accumulation
An STS transfer operation should be suspended if excessive cargo vapours are detected around the
decks or manifolds of either ship, and should not be resumed until the risk to both ships and their
personnel is considered to have been averted.
13.4.3 Accidental Cargo Spill
Any leakage or spillage should be reported immediately to the officers on cargo watch who should
stop the cargo transfer and advise the Mooring Master. The transfer must remain suspended until it is
agreed between the relevant persons/authorities that it is safe to resume.
13.4.4 SOPEP/SMPEP
Risk of oil pollution during STS transfer operations is no greater than during in-port cargo transfers.
However, as a transfer area may be out of range of port services, a contingency plan within the
SOPEP/SMPEP or VRP to cover such risk should be available and should be activated in the case of an
oil spill.
13.4.5 Emergency Breakaway
When the Mooring Master, in consultation with the Masters of the Vessel's, determines there is a need
for the vessels to separate before cargo transfer is complete, the following will be used as guidance. It
must be borne in mind, there are instances where breakaways may be necessary at less than the
indicated maximum weather parameters; unacceptable vessel motion, lines parting, excessive fender
motion, etc. The decision to breakaway should, if possible, be taken in ample time while the situation
is still under control. When a breakaway is necessary, safety of personnel and vessels should be a
paramount consideration. It is difficult to anticipate every emergency that could arise and therefore
almost impossible to indicate precise actions that should be taken, every breakaway will be different.
Personnel on both vessels must be prepared at all times to carry out emergency procedures as
instructed by the Mooring Master or Master of their vessel.
In an emergency, those involved should assess the situation and act accordingly. The following actions
should be taken in the event of any emergency arising during an STS transfer operation:
• Stop the cargo transfer
• Sound the emergency signal
• Inform crews on both ships of the nature of the emergency, man emergency stations
• Main engines either in standby mode or on short notice of readiness.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 79 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Initiate emergency procedures,
• If applicable, Initiate release of oil boom surrounding vessels by use of quick release coupling.
• Drain and disconnect the cargo hoses, in most cases the hoses will be left on the vessel with the
lesser freeboard
• Send mooring gangs to stations
• Advise attendant vessel of the situation and any requirements
Upon completion of breakaway, ensure all necessary personnel are notified. If there has been a
discharge of oil, which entered the water, this must also be reported to all necessary entities and
appropriate actions initiated. Both Vessels are to respond as required by the approved vessel response
plans.
13.5 ERT Organogram
Detailed emergency response procedures are located in the Mariflex Group Emergency Response Plan.
Figure 16 - ERT Organogram
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 80 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
14 NOTE OF PROTEST
The Mooring Master shall issue a note of protest to the Master of the applicable vessel if there is any breach
of the terminal procedures, contravention of Industry Guidelines or National/International regulations, or
excessive delay caused by vessel action or in-action.
Figure 17 - Example of Note of Protest
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 81 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Appendix-1 ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR DANISH MARITIME WATERS
1 SCOPE
The object of this procedure is to Establish, implement and monitor a procedure for STS operations in Danish
Territorial waters.
15 APPLICATION
Mariflex Transfer Services BV
16 DEFINITIONS
Refer to Procedure 3.0.3 - Abbreviations.
17 REFERENCES
17.1 Internal
• 3.4.14 STS Operations – Standard Operating Procedures
• 3.4.16C STS Operations – STS Checklists All Areas
• STS Transfer - Generic Risk Assessment
• STS Transfer - Area Specific Risk Assessment
• STS Transfer – Location Approval
17.2 External
• DMA Order 570 of the 4th June 2014 is implemented into the Quality System of MariFlex
Transfer Services and all STS transfers within Danish waters shall comply with this Order. DMA
Order 570 puts “STS Transfer Guide” for Petroleum, Chemicals and Liquefied Gases into force.
• CDI, ICS, OCIMF, SIGTTO - Ship to Ship Transfer Guide (Petroleum, Chemical and Liquefied Gas)
• OCIMF - The International Safety Guide for Oil Tankers and Terminals (OCIMF)
• IMO - MARPOL (Consolidated Edition 2011)
• IMO - Manual on Oil Pollution (MoOP).
• OCIMF - Mooring Equipment Guidelines (MEG)
• OCIMF - Effective Mooring
• IMO – STCW Regulations
• Nautical Institute – Bridge Team Management
• ICS – Bridge procedure Guide
• IMO – IMDG Code
18 REVISION RECORD
Version Date Description
1 January 2010 Created
2 April 2012 Includes MEPC 186(59)
3 February 2014 Amended in accordance with new “STS Transfer Guide” for
Petroleum, Chemicals and Liquefied Gases. (November 2013)
4 October 2014 Amended in accordance with new “DMA Order no. 570 of 4 June 2014”
5 June 2015 Revised
6 January 2016 Amended – Weather and Sea Conditions. STS Operational Parameters
7 February 2016 Amended – Chapter 2.2 Approval from Authorities – DMA phone number
in Contact details – page 13 Introduction – page 36 Hose Inspection and
testing – Appendix 3.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 82 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
19 PROCEDURES FOR STS OPERATIONS IN DANISH MARITIME WATERS
This Procedure must be read in conjunction with Procedure 3.4.14 – STS Operations – Standard Operating
Procedures.
19.1 Introduction
These procedures do not overrule any General Directions, Notice to Mariners or other instructions that
may be issued by The Danish Maritime Authority. The Danish Maritime Authority can order the STS
operation to stop at any time if it is believed that there is a risk of pollution or if the weather is forecast
to deteriorate to unsafe operational levels.
Masters of vessels are to be guided by the latest “STS Transfer Guide” for Petroleum, Chemicals and
Liquefied Gases, ISGOTT, Company Procedures, Harbour Byelaws, Danish Maritime Authority Byelaws
and General Directions for Navigation. The STS Superintendent will advise the Masters about local
requirements verbally during safety meeting, via letter to the master and via safety checklists.
The objective of this document is to ensure that all STS transfers are conducted in accordance with
DMA Order 570 of 4th June 2014, “STS Transfer Guide” for Petroleum, Chemicals and Liquefied Gases,
ISGOTT, the port Oil Spill Contingency Plan (OSCP) and the Shipboard Oil (marine) Pollution Emergency
Plan (SOPEP/SMPEP) in a consistently safe and efficient manner.
The requirements of MARPOL Annex 1, Chapter 8, ‘The Prevention of Pollution during the Transfer of
Oil Cargo between Oil Tankers at Sea’ should be adhered to for all applicable operations involving oil
cargoes. The requirement for vessels to be provided with an STS Operations Plan should be considered
for adoption by vessels involved in the STS transfer of other cargoes as being a recommended best
practice.
19.2 Control of Operations
The overall advisory control of an STS transfer in Danish Territorial Waters lies with the STS
Superintendent. It is not the intention to relieve the Master of either vessel of any of their duties,
requirements or responsibilities. An STS Superintendent shall be appointed to each STS operation.
The STS Agency shall assess the quality of nominated vessels or STS transfers within Danish Territorial
Waters, utilising the best information available.
The STS Agency is responsible for the condition and maintenance of the STS equipment. The STS
Superintendent must relay condition reports of the equipment to the Operations Manager of the STS
Agency after every STS.
During the STS operation, the following shall apply: -
• Pilots are engaged for all vessel movements, including mooring and unmooring. The Pilot will
work closely with the respective Masters and the STS Superintendent regarding safety and
mooring.
• During a STS transfer, in the event of an emergency situation, or in the event of deteriorating
weather, either the Master of the vessels involved or the STS Superintendent, shall call the Local
Agent and order suitable tugs to standby to unmoor the vessels.
• The STS Superintendent will be on board continually, monitoring the STS operation.
• The ship’s Local Agent shall normally co-ordinate the ships, and the Cargo Inspector normally
advises the amount of cargo to be transferred. The STS Superintendent shall work closely with
the STS Team to ensure safe and timely transfers.
• The principles of the ‘Bridge Management Team’ will be observed, with special emphasis on
teamwork and sharing of information. The STS Management Team consists of the Masters of
the two vessels, the pilot(s), the STS Superintendent, the ship’s Agent and the Cargo Inspector.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 83 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• The STS Agency and the STS Superintendent are responsible for the safe transit and delivery of
the STS equipment to site.
19.3 Approval from Authorities
For STS transfer within the territorial sea or the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), the Master or agent of
each tanker involved is required to notify the Admiral Danish Fleet not less than 48-hours in advance
of the scheduled operation. The notification should include the information detailed in appendix A2.2
“STS Transfer Guide 2013”.
The Master of the supplying ship or his Local Agent is responsible for initiating and updating the
“SafeSeaNet” web site for the upcoming STS operation in accordance with Order No.570, §10, phrase
9.
It is the responsibility of the ships’ Masters of both the receiving and the supplying ship to ensure that
the STS operator has been approved by the Danish Maritime Authority.
It is also the responsibility of the ship’s Masters of both the receiving and the supplying ship to ensure
that the operation can take place without risk of injury to the persons on board or damage to the to
the ships involved or other shipping in the area. The operation is to be planned with a view to
protecting the sea from pollution.
At least 48 hours before the scheduled performance of an STS operation the Masters of each ship shall
inform the Admiral Danish Fleet of the operation, including details of:
a) The ship’s name, flag, IMO number and call sign,
b) The quantity of oil that it is wished to transfer,
c) More details of the oil product,
d) The location where the STS operation is to be performed,
e) The date and time at which the STS operation will be commenced and the expected time of
completion of the operation,
f) The agent for the operation,
g) An approved STS Plan is on board.
If major changes are made to the information given pursuant to Appendix A2.2 in “STS Transfer Guide
2013”, including a deviation of more than 6 hours from the start of the operation, the Master, owner
or agent is required to provide a revised information to the Admiral Danish Fleet.
Checklist (1), see procedure 3.4.14C - STS Ops CL All Regions, and 'Introduction to the Proposed STS
Transfer' shall be sent by the STS Operator. This complies with MEPC 186(59).
A suitably qualified POAC will be in attendance for the entire STS transfer.
Once moored and prior to any cargo transfer taking place, the STS Superintendent or POAC shall
inspect the STS Plans of both vessels and highlight any conflicting issues. Any such issues shall be
amicably resolved prior to cargo transfer. Checklist No. 4 ensures that the STS Plans shall be
compatible.
19.4 Transfer Areas
STS transfers will take place within Danish Territorial Waters in areas deemed suitable by the ship’s
Master. Note that there are areas within Danish waters where STS transfers are not allowed. The pilots
will advise the Masters accordingly.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 84 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
19.5 Weather and Sea Conditions. STS Operational Parameters
The operational parameters depend on the shelter afforded. The following are guidelines for most
areas off Denmark: -
a) The movement of the two ships (i.e. severe wind and sea conditions).
b) The Pilot will board in winds up to 10 m/s.
c) The behaviour and integrity of the fenders.
d) Vessel mooring failure. Failure of one or more mooring lines between the vessels.
Due regard shall be paid to weather forecasts and early action taken to suspend transfers, if safe to do
so, when severe weather is imminent. To ensure that the latest relevant forecast information is
available it is recommended that service providers and ship operators utilise specialised weather
forecasting services, where available, to provide detailed information on the present and forecast
conditions.
STS shall not be carried out in icy conditions where the concentration of ice exceeds 1/10. The
operational parameters depend on the shelter afforded by the port. The following are guidelines: -
Sea Ht. Wind Wind
(m) Knots m/s Action Remarks
1.5 >20 >10 Abort Mooring Operations if vessels are Deteriorating
manoeuvring. If moored, call out Pilot to standby weather forecast
on the daughter (feeder) vessel
2.0 >26 >13 Pilot on Board, tug standing by. Utilise call-out
Stop transfer operation and disconnect transfer numbers. Advise
hoses Agent and MAS
>2.0 >35 >18 Separate vessels In accordance with
Pilot’s advice
19.6 Quality Assurance
The STS Agency retains a complete record of STS transfers it has completed. The STS Agency maintains
complete records of the equipment.
The STS Agency is normally vetted by clients to ensure consistent and safe practices.
19.7 Checklists
STS transfers are completed in accordance with the latest “STS Transfer Guide” for Petroleum,
Chemicals and Liquefied Gases.
STS checklist (1) will be sent to vessels programmed for STS transfer by the STS Operator. The replies
will be vetted by the STS Operator, who will confirm the suitability of nominated vessels for STS
transfer and advise the Agent and/or the Danish Maritime Authority accordingly.
Confirmation is based upon: -
a) Port state control records
b) Ship suitability (e.g. suitable moorings and leads)
c) Environmental suitability (e.g. clean ballast, no noxious gases in cargo tanks and normally double
hull)
During mooring and transfer it is the role of the STS Superintendent to confirm that all relevant
checklists are completed by senior Officers of both vessels, in a timely manner as follows: -
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 85 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Safety Checklist (2) ‘Before Operations Commence’
• Safety Checklist (3) ‘Before Run-In and Mooring’
• Safety Checklist (4) ‘Before Cargo Transfer’
• Safety Checklist (5) ‘Before Unmooring’
• Ship-to-Ship Safety Checklist
If the discharging vessel intends to crude oil wash, then it is the responsibility of the STS Supervisor to
ensure that a copy of the ‘Crude Oil Washing Checklist’, as per ISGOTT, is obtained from the Master of
the vessel for monitoring and record purposes.
19.8 Navigational Warnings
The Danish Maritime Authority will issue any navigational warnings that may be required.
19.9 OPERATIONAL PREPARATIONS BEFORE MANOEUVRING
19.9.1 Preparation of Ships
Ships Masters engaged in STS transfers must ensure that preparations and planning are conducted as
per DMA Order no. 570 of 4th June 2014 (Section-7 of this procedure) and “STS Transfer Guide” for
Petroleum, Chemicals and Liquefied Gases. To assist towards this, the STS Agency will supply checklists,
smoking notices and environmental inspection check sheets. The checklists should be completed in
good time, such that vital equipment (e.g. long messengers and oil spill emergency response
equipment) are identified and prepared early.
Each Master, together with key ships’ officers, will be briefed by the Pilot and/or the STS
Superintendent regarding the mooring plan, tug utilisation and contingency plans.
19.9.2 Joint plan of operation (JPO)
Before approaching commence, the STS Superintendent shall establish agreement and consensus
between all parties. Information to include the following:
• Environmental operating parameters/limits for each stage of the STS operation. These should
include environmental and operational limits that would trigger suspension of the transfer
operation and disconnection and unmooring of the vessels.
• Fender configuration and rigging arrangements.
• Mooring plans and arrangements and sequence of running lines, including use of any specialist
mooring equipment.
Before cargo transfer commence, the STS Superintendent shall confirm that all relevant checklists are
completed. Information to include the following:
• Emergency and spill containment procedures.
• Sequence of actions in case of spillage of cargo.
• Co-ordination of plans for cargo hose connection, draining, purging and disconnection, as
appropriate.
• Detailed unmooring sequence.
• Details of the cargo transfer plan(s).
• Relevant risk assessment(s).
19.9.3 Preparation of ship
The Masters of involved ships should make the following preparations as early as is practical:
• Review the operation-specific risk assessments and, where applicable, the related JPO and
ensure all identified preventive and mitigation measures have been implemented.
• Confirm that ships will be able to comply with the requirements of the relevant checklists.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 86 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
• Train and brief crews on procedures and hazards, with particular reference to mooring and
unmooring.
• Confirm that steering gear and all navigation and communications equipment is in working
order.
• Test engine and thruster controls and main propulsion plant ahead and astern.
• Test essential cargo and safety equipment.
• Confirm that each ship is upright, at a suitable trim with the propeller fully immersed. If one
vessel has a list, the possibility of safe stand-off distances being compromised should be
considered.
• Prepare mooring equipment, including messengers, in accordance with the agreed mooring
plan.
• Ensure that fenders and transfer hoses are correctly positioned, connected and secured.
• For specialised lightering vessels, confirm that fender davits are in the stowed position.
• Prepare cargo manifolds and hose handling gear.
• Obtain area weather forecasts for the transfer period.
• Confirm actions to be taken if the agreed emergency signal is sounded.
• Confirm the security level at which the ship is operating in accordance with the provisions of the
International Ship and Port Facility Security (ISPS) Code (reference 13), and the requirements
being undertaken on board to ensure compliance.
19.10 Planning for Cargo Transfer
When planning cargo transfer during an STS operation, the following points should be considered and
addressed accordingly: -
• “STS checklist 4” and “STS checklist upon ISGOTT” completed.
• Ensure adequate stability and endeavour to minimise free surface effect.
• Ensure stress limits are not exceeded
• Confirm grade(s) and rates of transfer
• Refer to DMA Order 570 in Section-7 of this procedure.
• Material Safety Data sheet (MSDS) to be transferred from loaded vessel.
• Whether crude oil washing is planned (ensure relevant COW checklist is completed)
• Cargo transfer / loading plans are exchanged accordingly
• ISPS Code ship security plan in operation in accordance with entry to Danish Territorial Waters.
19.11 Ballast Handling
Although oil tankers engaged in STS operations have double hulls and segregated ballast, two aspects
of ballast handling are monitored: -
• Ballast water contamination caused by Oil or Chemical inter-tank seepage or by poor quality
river ballast water.
• Harmful aquatic organisms and pathogens
It is essential that the IMO resolution A.868 (20) “Guidelines for the Control and Management of Ships’
Ballast Water to Minimise the Transfer of Harmful Aquatic and Pathogens” be followed in order to
avoid the introduction of alien species to the local environment.
Vessels must therefore state where they have ballasted and confirm that ballast has been checked
visually prior to discharge.
The STS Agency reserve the right to request the Master to follow IMO Resolution A.868 (20) and Danish
Act 929 of 24/09/2009 or to request laboratory tests prior to the discharge of water ballast. In Danish
waters discharge of oil is prohibited.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 87 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
20 ORDER NO. 570 OF 4 JUNE 2014 ISSUED BY THE DANISH MARITIME AUTHORITY
Order on the transfer of liquid cargo between ships in Danish and Greenland territorial waters (STS
operations)
This order has been notified in draft in accordance with directive 98/34/EC of the European Parliament
and of the Council (information procedure directive), as amended by directive 98/48/EC.
Pursuant to section 1(3), section 3(1)(ii), (iii), (vi), (viii) and (x), section 6, section 24(2) and section 32(8) of
the act on safety at sea (lov om sikkerhed til søs), cf. consolidated act no. 72 of 17 January 2014, and pursuant
to section 1(3), section 3(1)(ii), (iii), (vi), (viii) and (x), section 6, section 24(2), and section 32(2) of the act on
safety at sea (lov om sikkerhed til søs), as enacted for Greenland by decree no. 71 of 29 January 2013, the
following provisions are laid down:
Scope of application, etc.
Section 1. The order shall apply to Danish, Greenland and foreign ships that transfer liquid cargo consisting
of oil, chemical or gas products in Danish and Greenland territorial waters (STS operations).
Subsection 2. The order shall not limit any other provisions of the legislation to be observed in connection
with STS operations.
Subsection 3. The order shall not apply to the transfer of bunker products intended exclusively for operation
of the receiving ship.
Definitions
Section 2. For the purposes of this order, the following definitions shall apply:
1) “Supplying ship”: A tanker that is supplying gaseous or liquid products consisting of gas, chemicals or oil.
2) “Receiving ship”: A tanker that is receiving gaseous or liquid products consisting of gas, chemicals or oil.
3) “Bunker products”: Fuel oils and other types of oil products as well as inflammable gas to be used for
operation of the ship to which the oil or gas is transferred.
4) “Gas product” as defined in the “International Code for the Construction and Equipment of Ships Carrying
Liquefied Gases in Bulk (IGC Code)”, chapter 1, regulation 1.1.1.
5) “Gas tanker”: A ship as defined in the “International Code for the Construction and Equipment of Ships
Carrying Liquefied Gases in Bulk (IGC Code), chapter 1, regulation 1.3.16.
6) “Chemical product”: Harmful liquid substances as defined in MARPOL 73/78, as amended, Annex II,
regulation 1, paragraph 1.
7) “Chemical tanker”: A ship as defined in SOLAS 74/88, as amended, Annex VII, regulation 8, paragraph 2.
8) “Oil”: As defined in MARPOL 73/78, as amended, Annex I, regulation 8, paragraph 1.
9) “Oil tanker”: A ship as defined in MARPOL 73/78, as amended, annex I, regulation 1, paragraph 5.
10) “STS operation”: An operation during which all or part of a liquid or gaseous cargo consisting of gas,
chemical or oil products is transferred from one tanker to another tanker. The operation shall encompass the
arrival and departure of the ships involved as well as the transfer of the cargo as such. Operations in which
gas or oil is transferred between ships approved in accordance with the order on the bunkering of ships in
Danish territorial waters issued by the Danish Maritime Authority shall not, however, be regarded as STS
operations if the quantity transferred is less than 5,000 m3 and the gas or oil is to be used exclusively for the
operation of other ships.
11) “STS operator”: The person or enterprise responsible for guidance and supervision of the STS operation.
12) “Ship to Ship Service Provider Management”: The latest edition of the “Ship to Ship Service Provider
Management” published by the Oil Companies International Marine Forum (OCIMF).
13) “Ship to Ship Transfer Guide (For Petroleum, Chemicals and Liquefied Gases)”: The latest edition of the
“Ship to Ship Transfer Guide” published by the Chemical Distribution Institute (CDI), the International
Chamber of Shipping (ICS), the Oil Companies International Marine Forum (OCIMF) and the Society of
International Gas Tanker and Terminal Operators (SIGTTO).
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 88 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
14) "SafeSeaNet": The maritime information exchange system of the Community developed by the Com-
mission in cooperation with the Member States for implementing Community law.
Administrative provisions
Section 3. The Danish Maritime Authority may control STS operations and STS operators in order to ensure
compliance with the provisions of this order.
Subsection 2. Where the provisions of this order are not complied with, the Danish Maritime Authority may
prohibit the carrying out of an STS operation or may demand that an STS operation that is in progress be
stopped.
Subsection 3. The Danish Maritime Authority shall accept tests carried out by recognised test institutes,
including test institutes in other EU Member States, in EFTA states that are contracting parties to the EEA
Agreement and in Turkey, which provide suitable and satisfactory guarantees of the technical, expert and
independent nature of the testing.
Subsection 4. Where this order requires the possibility of presenting certificates or other documents or the
use of checklists, a copy of the documents on electronic media shall also be accepted. If the document in
question is to be signed, electronic documents provided with a digital signature with a level of security
equivalent to or greater than the OCES standard shall be accepted. In both cases, the necessary equipment
for dis-playing the documents shall be present on board the ship concerned.
The STS operator
Section 4. STS operations shall be carried out under the guidance and supervision of an STS operator
approved by the Danish Maritime Authority to carry out the relevant type of operations.
Subsection 2. Approval may be granted to persons meeting the qualification criteria in subsections 6 and 7
as well as to enterprises having at their disposal personnel having these qualifications.
Subsection 3. Persons approved as STS operators shall not put other persons in charge of guidance and
supervision of STS operations on their behalf.
Subsection 4. Enterprises approved as STS operators shall only allow personnel meeting the requirements in
subsections 6 and 7 to be responsible for guidance and supervision of STS operations.
Subsection 5. Approved STS operators shall:
1) to the widest extent possible use the recommendations of the “Ship to Ship Service Provider Manage-
ment”; and
2) use a quality assurance system ensuring that their tasks are performed in accordance with this order.
Subsection 6. Persons performing guidance and supervision of STS operations shall:
1) have internationally recognised skills and experience corresponding to that of a senior officer on a tanker
of the same type as those between which the STS operation is to be carried out,
2) be in possession of a valid health certificate,
3) depending on the planned operation, have completed a training programme in STS operations based on
the recommendations of the “Ship to Ship Transfer Guide”, and
4) have attended a suitable ship handling course focusing particularly on STS operations.
Subsection 7. The person guiding and supervising an STS operation shall have been responsible for guidance
and supervision of at least one independent STS operation of the relevant type during the last 6 months,
either on his own or under the supervision of a trained STS operator.
Subsection 8. When applying for approval as an STS operator, documentation of compliance with the
conditions stated in subsections 5-7 shall be submitted to the Danish Maritime Authority.
Subsection 9. It shall be possible to present the approval as an STS operator or a copy hereof upon request
to the Danish authorities.
Subsection 10. Approval shall be granted for a period of up to 2 years. The approval shall lapse if the
conditions stated in subsections 3-7 are no longer met.
Subsection 11. The Danish Maritime Authority may revoke an approval if an approved STS operator
participates in STS operations in which the provisions of this order are grossly or repeatedly contravened.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 89 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Management of the STS operation
Section 5. It is the responsibility of the ship’s masters of both the receiving and the supplying ship to ensure
that the STS operator has been approved by the Danish Maritime Authority to carry out the specific type of
STS operations.
Subsection 2. It is the responsibility of the ship’s masters of both the receiving and the supplying ship to
ensure that the operation can take place without risk of injury to those on board or damage to the ships
involved or other shipping in the area, and that the operation is planned with a view to protecting the sea
from pollution.
Subsection 3. If the requirements of the risk assessment drawn up pursuant to section 7(2)(i) can no longer
be maintained and the STS operator finds that the operation should be interrupted for safety and/or
environmental protection considerations, he shall inform the masters of the receiving and the supplying ships
as well as the authorities determined in section 10(1) of this.
Hoses for transfer of liquid cargo in connection with STS operations
Section 6. The recommendations concerning hoses in the “Ship to Ship Transfer Guide” shall be observed. In
addition, the hoses shall be pressure-tested with flanges and bolts fitted in accordance with their
specification:
1) before being taken into use,
2) periodically every four months, and
3) after the hoses have been repaired or subjected to unusually large loads.
Subsection 2. The date of the last pressure test shall be stated on the hose. It shall be possible to present a
record of the inspections and pressure tests performed on the hoses as well as the producer’s specifications
upon request.
Measures to be taken in connection with the STS operation
Section 7. Transfer of oil, chemical or gas cargoes between ships shall take place in accordance with the “Ship
to Ship Transfer Guide”.
Subsection 2. In addition to what follows from subsection 1, the following conditions shall be met:
1) Prior to the STS operation, a risk assessment shall be made of whether it can be carried out safely. In this
connection, inter alia any limitations in the area chosen, the participating ships, the equipment to be used,
the auxiliary vessels involved as well as the expected wind, weather and/or ice conditions shall be included.
2) STS operations shall not be carried out in icy conditions where the concentration of ice exceeds 1/10.
3) The largest ship shall lie securely at anchor before the other ship arrives. In special situations, however,
the STS operator and the 2 ship’s masters may decide in consultation to allow the smallest ship to lie securely
at anchor before the other ship arrives.
4) Arrival at the anchored ship shall be assisted by tugboats nudging the other ship into position.
5) The tugboats shall have sufficient tractive force for the arrival and uncoupling of the ships to be carried
out in complete safety.
6) Provided the STS operation can be carried out safely, at least one of the ships is approved as a bunker ship
and this ship has a gross tonnage of less than 8000, the use of assistance from tugboats may be reduced or
omitted entirely. A decision on this shall be made by agreement between the 2 ship’s mas-ters based on an
overall assessment of the entire operation, including the sizes of the ships, their ma-noeuvrability, the crews’
experience of STS operations, the weather conditions and other relevant circumstances.
7) In connection with STS operations where oil or chemical products are transferred, all relevant scuppers on
the supplying and receiving ships shall be closed.
8) The hoses shall be securely connected and both the supplying ship and the receiving ship shall have a
responsible officer who shall approve the coupling on their own ship. The hoses shall be placed in such a way
that the movements of the ships will not damage them.
9) On both ships it shall be ensured that all valves are set correctly and that the pipes on the manifolds not
used during the operation are provided with blind flanges.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 90 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
10) The drip-pans under the manifolds shall be drained of water, etc. before the operation is commenced.
11) Equipment for collecting minor oil or chemical leaks in the ship as laid down in the “OCIMF’s Ship
Inspection Report (SIRE) Programme” in force shall be available and ready for use on both ships.
12) In connection with LNG transfers, equipment for establishing a “water curtain” and similar measures that
may help prevent damage to the hull and other materials at the ships’ manifolds in case of leaking gas shall
have been tested and be ready for use.
13) A list of the nearest national bodies to be contacted in the event of a pollution accident shall be imme-
diately available on both ships.
14) A copy of the checklists included in the “Ship to Ship Transfer Guide shall be kept on board the ships
involved for at least 2 years and it shall be possible to present them to the Danish authorities upon request.
15) Both ships shall have good manoeuvrability such that it is possible to separate the ships in a situation in
which one of the ships has lost its propulsion machinery. If this is not the case, an auxiliary vessel shall be
available throughout the STS operation that can assist with the separation of the two ships at short notice.
16) During the entire STS operation, it shall be assessed on an ongoing basis whether the wind and weather
conditions and/or the ice conditions as well as the expected development herein warrants an interruption of
the operation.
Measures during the transfer
Section 8. In the immediate vicinity of the supplying ship’s manifold, a means shall be provided for stopping
the pumps delivering the oil, chemicals or liquid gas (an emergency stop).
Subsection 2. The level in the tanks that are being filled shall be monitored carefully throughout transfer.
Area in which the STS operation is to be performed
Section 9. STS operations shall be carried out only in areas and in weather conditions that are fit for the
purpose.
Notification of an STS operation
Section 10. At least 48 hours before the scheduled performance of an STS operation, the supplying ship shall
inform about this. The information shall be given to the following authorities:
1. For operations planned in Danish territorial waters: The Admiral Danish Fleet.
2. For operations planned in Greenland territorial waters: The Arctic Command.
Subsection 2. The information mentioned in subsection 1 shall contain the following information about the
operation:
1) The names, call signs and IMO numbers of the supplying ship and the receiving ship,
2) the location where the STS operation is to be performed,
3) the time at which the STS operation will be commenced and the expected time of completion of the
operation,
4) exact details of the product(s) it is intended to transfer,
5) the quantity or quantities of liquid cargo that it is intended to transfer,
6) the agent for the operation,
7) the approved STS operator, cf. section 4,
8) contact details of a shore-based emergency preparedness from where safety data sheets or similar
exhaustive information about the product(s) to be transferred, its properties as well as the form of combat
can be requested for the duration of the operation, and
9) as regards oil tankers, confirmation that the participating ships have an on-board STS operation plan
meeting the requirements of MARPOL, Annex I, regulation 41.
Subsection 3. If major changes are made to the information given pursuant to subsection 2, including a
deviation of more than 6 hours from the start of the operation, the supplying ship shall as soon as possible
inform the authorities mentioned in subsection 1 hereof.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 91 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Subsection 4. The information required in subsections 2 and 3 shall be reported electronically by means of
the Danish SafeSeaNet platform ("Reporting form as well as any updates on STS operation in the territorial
waters").
Penalty provisions
Section 11. Contraventions of this regulation shall be liable to punishment by fine or imprisonment for a term
of up to 1 year.
Subsection 2. The penalty may be increased to imprisonment for a term of up to 2 years if:
1) the contravention has caused harm to life or health or a risk hereof,
2) an injunction or order has been issued previously for the same or an equivalent circumstance, or
3) the contravention has brought about or was intended to bring about a financial advantage for the
contravener or others.
Subsection 3. If the contravention has caused harm to the life or health of persons below 18 years of age or
brought about a risk hereof, this shall be considered particularly aggravating circumstances, cf. sub-section
2(i).
Subsection 4. If the proceeds gained through the contravention are not confiscated, the size of the financial
advantage gained or sought shall be particularly taken into consideration when setting any fine, including
any supplementary fine.
Subsection 5. Companies etc. (legal persons) may be liable to punishment in accordance with the provisions
of part 5 of the penal code (straffeloven).
Section 12. If the contravention is covered by the decree on the entry into force for Greenland of acts
amending the act on safety at sea (lov om sikkerhed til søs), measures may be ordered in accordance with
the penal code for Greenland (kriminalloven for Grønland).
Subsection 2. The conditions mentioned in section 11(2) shall be considered especially aggravating
circumstances.
Subsection 3. If the financial benefit achieved is not confiscated, cf. part 37 of the penal code (kriminalloven),
special consideration shall be given to the size of the achieved or intended financial benefit when determining
the size of the fine, including supplementary fine.
Subsection 4. If the contravener is a company, etc. (legal personalities), the legal personality may be liable to
punishment by fine. If the contravener is the State, the Government of Greenland, a municipality, an inter-
municipal enterprise covered by section 64 of the act of the Landsting (Greenland Parliament) on municipal
councils and village councils, etc. or a village council, the relevant public authority shall be liable to
punishment by fine.
Subsection 5. If the person in question does not live in Greenland, or if his tie to Greenland society is of such
a rather loose nature that the preconditions for the application of the measures are not present, legal
proceedings may be instituted in Denmark or the case may be sent for trial in Denmark.
Entry into force
Section 13. The order shall enter into force on 1 October 2014.
Subsection 2. Order no. 734 of 25 June 2007 on the transfer of oil cargo between ships in Danish terri-torial
waters shall be repealed.
Danish Maritime Authority, 4 June 2014 / Anne Skov Strüver / Steen Møller Nielsen
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 92 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
20.1 Reporting form as well as any updates on STS operations in the territorial waters
(The form gives the information that the supplying ship is to report to the Admiral Danish Fleet, respectively
the Arctic Command, by means of the Danish SafeSeaNet platform).
Supplying ship
Name IMO no. Call sign
Receiving ship
Name IMO no. Call sign
The supplying ship Yes No Not relevant
uses an ap-proved
STS operation plan
(only oil tankers)
Product(s) – to be filled in for each product transferred
1. Technical term Exact technical term Quantity Metric tonnes (m3 if IGC is used)
Code reference IBC/IGC/MARPOL 24/7 contact Telephone no.
2. Technical term Quantity
Code reference 24/7 contact
3. Technical term Quantity
Code reference 24/7 contact
Area and position For example: N E
of the operation Aalbæk Bay,
Frederikshavn Roads,
Kalundborg Fjord
Start date/time End date/time
Agent
Name/address
STS operator
Name/address
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 93 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
21 DMA APPROVAL TO PERFORM STS OPERATIONS
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 94 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Appendix-2 ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR SOUTH AFRICAN WATERS
1 SCOPE
The object of this procedure is to Establish, implement and monitor a procedure for STS operations at
Saldanha, South Africa.
2 APPLICATION
Mariflex Africa
3 DEFINITIONS
Refer to Procedure 3.0.3 - Abbreviations.
4 REFERENCES
4.1 Internal
• 3.4.14 STS Operations – Standard Operating Procedures
• 3.4.16 STS Operations – STS Checklists All Areas
• STS Transfer - Generic Risk Assessment
• STS Transfer - Area Specific Risk Assessment
• STS Transfer – Location Approval
4.2 External
• CDI, ICS, OCIMF, SIGTTO - Ship to Ship Transfer Guide (Petroleum, Chemical and Liquefied Gas)
• OCIMF - The International Safety Guide for Oil Tankers and Terminals (ISGOTT)
• IMO - MARPOL (Consolidated Edition 2011)
• IMO - Manual on Oil Pollution (MoOP).
• OCIMF - Mooring Equipment Guidelines (MEG)
• OCIMF - Effective Mooring
• IMO – STCW Regulations
• Nautical Institute – Bridge Team Management
• ICS – Bridge procedure Guide
• IMO – IMDG Code
• SAMSA – Marine Notice No.3
5 REVISION RECORD
Version Date Description
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.4 10-02-2019 95 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6 PROCEDURES FOR STS OPERATIONS IN SOUTH AFRICAN WATERS
This Procedure must be read in conjunction with Procedure 3.4.14 – STS Operations – Standard Operating
Procedures.
6.1 Prior to STS Operations
The intension to carry out STS Transfer Operations at Saldanha Bay must be submitted to the Harbour Master,
Saldanha Bay for approval at least 5 ‘working days’ prior to the intended operation. Every vessel planning a
port call Saldanha shall comply with the current Port regulations for pre-arrival information, Pilot boarding
and berthing schedules.
6.2 Notification to and, Approval from Authorities
6.2.1 Mariflex Notification to South African Maritime Safety Authority (SAMSA)
Prior to Approval of STS Operations in South African Waters, the guidance contained in Maritime Notice No.3
of 2016 and in Maritime Notice No.10 of 2016 shall be complied with. Annex.1, 2, 3 & 4 of Maritime Notice
No.3 shall be completed in its entirety and submitted to SAMSA, Saldanha Office at least five (5) working
days before the transfer takes place, with the Principle Officer at the port nearest to the proposed
place of transfer.
6.2.2 SAMSA Requirements
The request should contain as least the following particulars:
1. The name of the ship supplying the bunkers (cargo);
2. The name of the receiving ship;
3. Their respective ports of registry, IMO number, official number, classification society gross registered
tons and drafts;
4. Their owners, agents or local operator with full contact details;
5. The type and quantity of oil to be transferred;
6. The position, date and estimated duration of transfer;
7. Names and local addresses of the P&I Clubs with which the ships are entered, with full contact details;
8. Proof that the above-mentioned P&I Clubs cover bunker transfer operations at sea;
9. Names of the master or person of the ship supplying the bunkers who is specifically appointed to conduct
the approach, docking and undocking (if necessary) of the two ships and co-ordinate, conduct and
supervise the transfer of the bunkers;
10. Extracts from the “Shipboard Oil Pollution Emergency Plan” of both ships showing the on board
procedures in the case of an accidental spill during a bunker transfer operation at sea;
11. Proof that the transfer hoses have been pressure tested in the preceding 12 months;
12. The list of equipment on board both ships for combating and cleaning up an oil spill;
13. Details of the procedure to terminate the operation in the event of an emergency;
14. A checklist (See Section 11 – Checklists) provided by the bunkering ship (to be completed by both ships)
showing the checks and procedures required for:
a. terminating the operation in the event of an emergency;
b. docking;
c. commencement of pumping;
d. completion of pumping; and
e. undocking
6.2.3 Conditions of approval for transfer
1. The docking of the two ships (if necessary), the connecting of hoses and the commencement of transfer
must take place during daylight hours;
2. Any emergency resulting in a spill or threatening to cause a spill must be brought to the attention of the
nearest Principal Officer as soon as possible;
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 96 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
3. Both ship’s main engines and pollution combating equipment must be ready for immediate use during
the proposed transfer;
Approval for transfer is also subject to the Authority’s right to:
1. Refuse permission for transfer;
2. Change the proposed position of the transfer operation;
3. Designate representative officer who may access to the bunkering ship for the duration of the transfer;
4. Make amendments to the matters mentioned in sub-paragraphs 6.12, 6.13 and 6.14 of Marine Notice
No.3;
5. Conduct inspections on both ships to ensure compliance with the Act and the Prevention and Combating
of Pollution of the sea by Oil regulations, 1984.
6.2.4 MARPOL Annex-1 Cargoes
For STS Transfers involving MARPOL Annex 1 cargoes within the territorial sea or the Exclusive Economic
Zone (EEZ) of a party to the MARPOL Convention, the Master or Agent of each tanker involved is required to
notify the relevant Coastal State authorities not less than 48-hours in advance of the scheduled operation.
The Local Agent, is responsible for notifying all concerned parties of the upcoming STS operation in
compliance with the MARPOL Convention.
6.2.5 Chemical cargoes
Government authorities may require notifications for STS transfers involving Annex II cargoes. Where these
transfers are conducted within port limits the harbour authority may require notification. In either case a
lightering plan may be required. If alongside a terminal, the operator, or owner may also require a copy of
the lightering plan.
6.2.6 Other cargoes
For STS transfer involving other cargoes, the STS organiser (Mariflex Africa) should check local and national
regulations to determine the level of approval required to conduct the transfer operation. Refer to Location
Approval.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 97 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
7 STS TRANSFER LOCATION
Mariflex Africa have been granted approval in principal by the Harbour Master, Saldanha Port, to carry out
STS operations at Alpha Anchorage 33°03.1’S 017°59.1’E in approximately 20m water depth for vessels with
a maximum draft of 16m.
Figure 18 - Location approved for STS Transfer operations at Saldanha Bay
The Saldanha Harbour Master has established a 500m exclusion zone around vessels carrying out STS
operations at this location, detailed on the “Port of Saldanha” website.
7.1 Anchoring Procedure
The Mother vessel shall anchor in the location designated by Saldanha Port Control and verified by the local
Pilot using a minimum of 5 shackles on her port anchor (the anchor opposite to the berthing side) in
accordance with the requirements of the Port Authority.
7.2 Environmental Conditions
The weather parameters for safe operation during STS operations at Alpha Anchorage depend mainly on the
wind speed and direction, Sea Height and Swell conditions.
The Mooring Master should obtain the latest weather reports for the transfer area 24-hours, 12-hours and
immediately prior to the planned operation. The Mooring Master may postpone the STS operation if the
weather reports indicate weather conditions exceeding the guidelines.
Under no circumstances should any operation commence if there is any doubt about the safety of the crew,
vessel or cargo. The following operational wind limits have been established by Mariflex Africa together with
the Port Authority Pilots during which STS mooring and cargo operation may take place:
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 98 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Responsible Wind Limit Max. Swell
Ship Type Sailing Fairway / Required Action
Person * Ht.
Conventional Tanker Pilot Pilot Boarding Area to ‘A’ <12m/s <3.5m
anchorage
Conventional Tanker Pilot Pilot Boarding Area to ‘D’ <15m/s <3.5m
anchorage
Conventional Tanker with 2 Tugs Mooring Maximum weather parameters 12m/s <2.0m
Master during berthing
Conventional Tanker with operational Mooring Maximum weather parameters <10m/s <2.0m
bow thruster - 1 Tug Master during berthing
Oil Spill Response Team – on standby Mooring For removal of Oil-boom >12m/s 2.5m
Master
Oil Spill Response Team – on station Mooring For removal of Oil-boom >15m/s 2.5m
Master
Pilot and Tugs - on Standby Mooring Cargo hoses drained and >15m/s 2.5m
Master disconnected
Pilot and Tugs - on Station Mooring Unmooring of vessels – remove >17m/s 3.0m
Master to safe area.
*Wind velocity limit based on 10-minute mean average
7.2.1 Special Conditions
If weather forecast received prior to operations commencing indicates wind velocity of 10 -12 m/s based on
10min. mean average then operations should not commence until a clear weather window, within acceptable
limits, is promulgated for the duration of the intended operation.
Do Not Start Cargo Operations if any of the following weather parameters are experienced:
• Wind velocity >25 knots (12 m/sec) or more.
• Wave height of >5 feet (1,5 metres) or more.
• Crosswind or seas causing undue working of mooring lines.
• Pilot instructions for visibility received, all tankers, (min. visibility 1 Nm.)
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 99 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
8 STS EQUIPMENT
8.1 Cargo Hoses
a) SPECIFICATION: BS/EN1765
b) FLUID TYPE: Crude Oil / Liquid Pet Products
c) RATED PRESSURE: 225psi (15 bar)
d) HOSE TYPE: 10” Rubber Reflex STS Hose, length 12M.
e) SPECIAL SPEC: Flanges Hot Dip Galvanised for Corrosion Resistance
f) FLANGE SPEC: ANSI 150
g) FLANGE FACE: FF
h) ELECTRICAL CONTINUITY: Electrically Continuous or discontinuous
Hoses used for STS operations by MTS are of the following specification: -
SBFF (Carbo
Yokohama Goodyear
Maker Amiflex Amiflex Amiflex Flat Bunker
“Seaflex” “Lightwing”
Hose)
Lay Flat
Type Rubber Rubber Composite Composite Composite
Rubber
Nominal
10" 10” 10" 8” 6” 6”, 8” & 10”
Diameter
Length 12m 12m 12m 8m & 10m 6m 10m & 12m
Operating
-20oC to +82oC -30oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC -25oC to +80oC
Temperature
Weight in Air
494 kg 670 kg 620 kg 15kg/m 11kg/m
(per piece)
16.7 Bar gauge 17 bar gauge 15 Bar gauge (225 14 bar (200 14 bar (203
Pressure rating 16 bar
(242 psi) (250 psi) psi) psi) psi)
Minimum burst 75 Bars gauge 86 bar (1250 56 Bars gauge 56 bar (812 56 bar (812
pressure (1088 psi) psi) (812 psi) psi) psi)
4 times hose 4 times hose
4 times hose
nominal bore nominal bore
Minimum nominal bore
when supported when supported 740mm (29”) 500mm (20”)
bending radius when empty or
by internal by internal
full
pressure pressure
Allowable flow
15 m/sec. 21 m/sec. 15 m/sec. 12 m/sec. 12 m/sec.
velocity
2730 m3/hr (10” 3800 m3/hr 2730 m3/hr (10”
Maximum flow
dia. (refer (10” dia. (refer dia. (refer
rate
ISGOTT) ISGOTT) ISGOTT)
Electrically
Electrical Electrically semi- Electrically semi-
semi- <1 ohm/m <1 ohm/m
continuity continuous. continuous.
continuous.
Number 6 10 4
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 100 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
8.2 Vapour Hoses
Vapour Hoses used for STS operations by MTS are of the following specification: -
Maker Amiflex Amiflex Amiflex Amiflex Amiflex Amiflex
Type Composite Composite Composite Composite Composite Composite
Nominal
10" 10” 8” 6” 6” 6”
Diameter
Length 12m 10m 10m 10m 6m 15m
Operating
-20oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC -20oC to +80oC
Temperature
Weight in Air
15kg/m 15kg/m 15kg/m 11kg/m 11kg/m 11kg/m
(per piece)
Pressure rating 7 bar (100 psi) 7 bar (100 psi) 7 bar (100 psi) 7 bar (100 psi) 7 bar (100 psi) 7 bar (100 psi)
Minimum burst
28 bar (400 psi) 28 bar (400 psi) 28 bar (400 psi) 28 bar (400 psi) 28 bar (400 psi) 28 bar (400 psi)
pressure
Minimum
740mm (29”) 740mm (29”) 740mm (29”) 500mm (20”) 500mm (20”) 500mm (20”)
bending radius
Electrical
<1 ohm/m <1 ohm/m <1 ohm/m <1 ohm/m <1 ohm/m <1 ohm/m
continuity
Number 7 1 18 8 5 8
8.2.1 Hose String
The hose string is made up of two or more hoses joined together with a fibre gasket and 12 x 36mm x
100mm M24 Tap bolts and nuts. The hose joints should be made up in accordance with the
requirements detailed in the “Joint Tightening Sheet” and torqued to approximately 328N/m.
8.3 Fenders
Fenders used for STS operations by MTS are of the following specification: -
Yokohama /
Sea & Tec / Sea & Tec Sea & Tec Sea & Tec
Maker / Type Yokohama Seamax
Seamax Pneumatic 50 Pneumatic 50 Pneumatic 50
Pneumatic 50
Diameter 0.5m 1.0m 1.5m 2.0m 2.5m 3.30m
Length 1.0m 2.0m 3.0m 3.5m 5.5m 6.50m
0.5 kgf/cm2 0.5 kgf/cm2 0.5 kgf/cm2 0.5 kgf/cm2 0.5 kgf/cm2 0.5 kgf/cm2
Initial Internal
(0.50 bar, (0.50 bar, (0.50 bar, (0.50 bar, (0.50 bar, (0.50 bar,
Pressure
50kPa) 50kPa) 50kPa) 50kPa) 50kPa) 50kPa)
Approx. weight
24kg (no
(incl. chain/tyre 310kg 780kg 1365kg 2940kg 4440 kg
net)
net)
Pressure Relief
N/A N/A N/A N/A 175 kPa 175 kPa
Valve setting
Number: 21 4 2 11 9 9
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 101 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
9 BERTHING OPERATIONS
9.1 STS Operations
The Pilot will board the Mother vessel at the Pilot Boarding Area, the vessel will proceed directly to the
STS position and anchor to await berthing of the Daughter vessel. The Mother vessel will drop the port
anchor at the STS transfer position as indicated on the chartlet or as per Pilot advise and the Daughter
vessel will be secured to the vessel’s starboard side.
The Mooring Master and the Cargo Surveyor will board the Mother vessel from a service vessel once
the Mother vessel is anchored at the STS transfer area and will remain on board throughout the loading
operation. The STS Team will either use a personnel basket and the starboard crane or the port side
accommodation ladder to board. After setting the fenders and transferring the hoses, the service
vessel will standby for mooring operations as required by the duty harbour Pilot.
Depending on the size of vessels, three (3) or four (4) STS fenders will be placed on the starboard side
of the Mother vessel and, depending on the available flat side, in one continuous string or
independently.
The Daughter vessel will berth alongside the starboard side Daughter vessel under the guidance of the
port Pilot and tugs. If compatible vessels, the Daughter vessel will provide all the moorings which will
be sent two at a time. The normal mooring plan is six headlines, two forward springs, two aft springs
and four stern lines. The mooring plan details the bitts and fairleads to be used for this. Should
inclement weather be forecast, an additional two headlines may be set, usually from Mother vessel,
normally, the spring lines are the first lines to be sent, however, this will be decided in consultation
between the Pilot and the Master.
The Mother vessel should have her STS messengers (200m x 40mm) rigged ready for the springs, as
well as messenger lines for head and stern lines.
Depending on the cargo to be transferred, suitable Cargo and Vapour Hoses will be utilised for the
cargo transfer. Hoses shall be connected, supported, drained and disconnected in accordance with
3.4.14 Standard Operating Procedures.
Both vessels must remain in “Sea-going” stress and stability condition at all times and in accordance
with Collision Regulations, “Anchor Watches” must be set.
After both vessels are secured, the Mooring Master and both Chief Officers will have a safety and pre-
transfer meeting on board your vessel.
9.1.1 Use of Tug for Mother Vessel Directional Stability During Tanker Berthing Operations
During berthing operations, the Mother vessel directional stability may be controlled by the use of a
small berthing assist tug connected on the port side at the break of the accommodation. This tug would
be under the control of the Mooring Master to maintain a steady heading during the approach of the
Daughter vessel.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 102 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
9.1.2 Task Risk Assessment for Berthing Assist Tug
TASK RISK MITIGATION
Tow line Connection Heaving line strikes a crew member or vessel Effective Communication – VHF 15/17,
equipment. back-up VHF-16
Tow line incorrectly secured All crew to wear PPE
Falling objects from tanker Inspect towline before use.
Heavy contact with Tanker
Pushing Heavy contact with Tanker Effective Communication
Loss of engine/rudder control resulting in Emergency let go
heavy contact with tanker. Side fendering
Off-centre pushing resulting in steel-to-steel
contact.
Pulling Towline parts/failure Effective Communication
Structural failure Certified towing connection/securing
Loss of power/steering point
No crew on deck.
Beware of SNAP-BACK Zones.
Towline Towline dropped by tanker crew & strikes a Effective Communication
Disconnection crew member. Towline to be lowered to Hansevik.
Falling objects from tanker All crew to wear PPE
Heavy contact with Tanker
Emergency let go Towline snap-back Effective communication
Personnel injury Towline to be slack prior to let go
Axe or sharp knife to be available.
9.2 500m Exclusion Zone - Purpose & Application
To provide guidance to authorized small craft/service vessels to approach within the 500-metre
(seaward) exclusion zone around an ongoing Ship-to-Ship Transfer (STS) operation for the following
purposes:
a. Oil Spill Response Craft - to connect/disconnect oil spill prevention boom and carry out routine
inspections during the course of an on-going STS operation.
b. Service Craft – to transfer personnel or stores.
This procedure does not apply to Port Authority “Pilot Boat” in the normal course of transporting the
Port Pilot to and from berthing operations.
9.2.1 Unauthorised Craft (ISPS Code)
Unauthorised craft are not allowed alongside either ship at any time prior to, during or after the STS
transfer. In this respect attention should be focused towards International Ship and Port Facility
Security Code (ISPS Code), which refers to the possibility of terrorist activity.
a. The Mooring Master or delegate has control of approved vessel operations within the 500-meter
safety zone of the STS operation.
b. All visitors and visiting craft must be vetted and authorised by the Mooring Master.
c. Service craft leave from an ISPS approved port.
d. The Agent will give prior notice and full details of any launch that is due to visit ships engaged in STS
transfers.
9.2.2 Radio Protocol
The primary communication channel during STS operations will be marine VHF channel 15 or 17, as
agreed during Key Meeting and stated in pre-transfer checklist and both vessels involved in the STS
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 103 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
continuously monitor this channel. Due to the congested nature of Marine VHF frequencies it is
essential that correct radio protocol be followed to prevent confusion and to promote efficient
operations.
9.2.3 Procedure for entering 500m Exclusion Zone
The Master of any Vessel, intending to enter the 500-metre zone must make contact with, and receive
permission from, the Mooring Master or his designate. At this time, the Mooring Master or his
designate will relay any pertinent information regarding activities within the area, e.g. venting
hydrocarbon gases or any other activity, which may affect operations.
All craft entering the 500-metre zone shall be supplied with an operational personal multi-gas detector.
On approach to the STS operation, should the alarm be activated, the craft must immediately reverse
its course and proceed outside the zone until the alarm is cancelled. The Mooring Master shall be
notified and the craft to standby for further instructions.
Should such a support craft be unable to make VHF (channel 71) contact with the Mooring Master or
his designate, every effort should be made to contact either of the two vessels involved in the STS
operation (primary channel VHF 71, secondary channel 16), but in no circumstances, should the vessel
enter the 500-metre zone without receiving permission. All vessels on departure from the STS
operation shall notify the Mooring Master or his designate of their departure.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 104 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
10 EMISSIONS DURING CARGO OPERATIONS
The main releases to the air from the cargo transfers will be combustion products from engines, generators
and, gases/vapours arising from Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) (during transfer operations) due to over
pressurization of the cargo tanks. Crude Oil VOC emissions to the air will be of carbon dioxide (CO₂), sulphur
oxides (SOx), nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). Emissions may also contain minimal
quantities of Hydrogen Sulphide (<10ppm). Refer to the Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) for a more
detailed composition and emergency response procedures.
10.1 Vapour Balancing
10.1.1 Introduction
The following procedure is a mitigation measure that will significantly reduce hydrocarbon, noxious
and odorous vapour emissions to the environment during Ship-To-Ship (Transhipment) Operations.
This is achieved by provision of a vapour hose connecting the vapour manifolds of both ships engaged
in the operation, whereby the receiving ship (SS) in effect provides volumetric replacement of tank
gasses and vapours (including Inert Gas) to the discharging vessel (STBL) throughout the operation.
Whilst the procedure may be unable to guarantee emission free transhipment operations, particularly
when the transhipment involves transfer of volatile cargoes where vapour growth may be unavoidable,
vapour space emissions from the receiving vessel will be significantly reduced in ALL cases.
It is critical that the tanker personnel on both ships exercise due diligence in the following operational
aspects: -
a. Close monitoring of cargo tank pressure and atmospheres on both vessels and regular comparison
to identify trends.
b. Minimisation of supply of Inert Gas to the cargo tanks on the discharging vessel to reduce cargo tank
pressures to a safe operating minimum level.
c. Handling the cargo in a manner that will reduce potential vapour growth. i.e by avoiding agitation of
the cargo by pump cavitation or high velocity discharges into empty tanks.
d. Minimisation of cargo tank temperatures, particularly on the receiving vessel.
STS operations at Saldanha Bay will be conducted under strict environmental conditions, including VOC
emissions to atmosphere.
10.1.2 Operational Procedure
Both the discharging ship (STBL) and the loading ship (SS) should ensure that their tank atmospheres
are at minimum pressure above Low Level Alarm Limits with a Tank atmosphere having 8% or less O₂
by volume prior to berthing. Ideally, the tank atmosphere on both vessels should have 5% or less O₂
by volume to satisfy I.G supply standards and satisfy local port regulations. i.e. 300 to 400 mm wg
Equipment may be provided on at least one of the vessels to enable the oxygen content of the gas
stream to be monitored. Ideally, this should draw samples continuously from a location close to the
vapour manifold connection and should include the facility for audible and visual alarms in the event
that the oxygen content of the vapour stream exceeds 8% by volume.
Following completion of vapour hose connection and prior to commencement of cargo transfer, both
ships should open their vapour manifolds to verify vapour transfer system integrity. Observe and
record Pressure Readings on both vessels to establish that pressure equalisation takes place, thereby
verifying pressure balancing integrity.
If the cargo tank pressure in the receiving ship is greater than that in the discharging ship then the then
the vapour manifolds should be left OPEN until pressure balance has been achieved between the cargo
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 105 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
tanks on both ships. Once this has been achieved then the vapour manifold on the discharging ship
should be SHUT.
If the cargo tank pressure in the discharging ship is greater than that of the receiving ship, once the
system integrity has been verified the vapour manifold on the discharging ship should be SHUT
At pre-operational (key) meeting, both the minimum and maximum operational tank atmosphere
pressures should be agreed by the personnel on both ships (Vapour Balancing Checklist). The objective
is to decide on an operating range that is sufficiently higher than the Low-Pressure Alarm setting and
perhaps 60% of the Pressure setting on the P/V valves. i.e For Low-Pressure Alarm setting 200 mm wg;
Pressure side of P/V valve rated for 1400 mm wg an operating range of 300 to 1000 mm wg may be
agreed as being appropriate.
Prior to commencement of cargo transfer operations, the discharging ship should start her Inert Gas
plant and stabilise it on a pressure setting less than the Inert gas main to ensure gas regulator to deck
main is shut and I.G is being directed up funnel dump.
When cargo transfer is commenced, the pressure setting on the I.G system should be increased to
modulate gas regulator to deck main into Open status and funnel dump valve to Shut status. Ideally
the pressure setting of the I.G System should be between 300 mm and 400 mm wg to obviate excessive
tank pressurisation.
When the pressure in the cargo system of the receiving ship exceeds that of the discharging ship the
vapour manifolds on both ships should be confirmed as being fully OPEN. Both ships should
communicate their cargo tank & inert gas main pressures to each other at frequent intervals to verify
that vapour balancing is being achieved. If vapour balancing is not being achieved (i.e. receiving ship’s
tank atmosphere pressures are increasing and discharging ship’s tank atmosphere pressure is falling),
it may be necessary to reduce the cargo transfer rate.
Ideally when vapour balancing is being achieved, the tank and gas main pressures on both ships should
be very similar. However, there will always be pressure differentials due to flow dynamics and lag
effect. Practically, vapour balancing is being achieved when following parameters are evident and/or
being achieved: -
a. Tank and Gas Main Pressures on both ships are fairly constant with a fairly constant differential being
maintained between both vessels.
b. Inert Gas Flow is continually being directed up the funnel dump with the Gas Regulator Valve to deck
in fully shut status OR the I.G System in Standby Mode.
When integrity of the vapour balancing operation has been confirmed beyond doubt, the I.G.S should
be kept on standby and the gas main deck isolating valve closed. In some cases, it may be may be worth
shutting down the Inert Gas Plant altogether (in standby) to prevent bleed-over of gas if gas regulator
valve should be passing. In this case, the receiving ship is providing I.G supply in severalty.
It is of paramount importance that the ships should communicate Inert Gas main pressures and Inert
Gas Main O₂% to each other at frequent intervals, particularly when comparing cargo transfer rates.
These pressures should be recorded in the Operational Log in the same way as cargo transfer rates,
r.o.bs’ etc. furthermore, the discharging ship should advise the receiving ship of any changes in the
operational status of it’s I.G system). In the event that the tank atmosphere pressure increases in the
receiving ship due to excessive supply of I.G to deck main on the discharging ship or due to cargo
transfer rate being in excess of the vapour transfer rate. The following options should be considered:
-
a. Reduce cargo transfer rate and monitor pressure trend on both ships to verify whether vapour
balancing is being achieved.
b. Cease cargo transfer temporarily to allow vapour pressure equalisation to take place.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 106 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
c. If the receiving ship has a significant quantity of free water in her cargo tanks and the Shore Terminal
will allow, cease cargo transfer and discharge a quantity of water to the ballast settling tanks ashore.
The water being discharged will effectively reduce tank and gas main pressures on both ships if the vapour
manifolds are left open between them.
10.1.3 Before Venting
Prior to venting the OOW of the loading tanker shall:
a. Notify the other vessel and own ship engine room (to put a/c on recirculation) before venting.
b. Check the sides of both vessels are clear of small boats, or other craft in the vicinity.
10.2 Oil Pollution Equipment
The respective oil tankers on-board oil spill clean-up (SOPEP/SMPEP) equipment shall be ready for
immediate use and each vessel is to maintain both a continuous manifold watch and a deck watch
throughout any transfer operation.
Oil Spill Response Ltd (OSR) has been contracted by Mariflex Africa to provide oil spill response
capability for STS operations at Saldanha in accordance with the terms and conditions laid down in
their licence to operate.
10.2.1 OSR Equipment
a. Level-1 barrier (Oil-boom) ‘H’ type - must be in place between both vessels prior to commencing
cargo operations involving marine polluting cargoes.
b. Two oil skimmers and oil bags
The OSR base (Saldanha) maintains an oil spill response Tier 1 Equipment Package as listed below:
• Disposable Boiler Suit x5
• Absorbent Pads x5
• Oil Absorbent Pads x 1 bale
• Safety Goggles x5
• HD Disposal Bags x1 roll
• Plastic Scoop and Brush x1 pair
• OSR Personnel
All OSR Personnel have been trained in Oil Spill Response by the OSR Ltd. Southampton, England
(approved by the UK MCA), to “Basic Level” (IMO Level-2) and, Response Team Leaders to “On-scene
Commander” level.
11 CHECKLISTS
The following Check Lists are taken from SAMSA Marine Notice No.3 and must be completed for each
operation:
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 107 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
11.1 ANNEX-1 - Transfer Particulars
11.2 ANNEX 2 - Berthing Checklist
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 108 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
11.3 ANNEX 3 - General Checklist
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 109 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
11.4 ANNEX 4 - Before Unmooring
12 RECORDS
F-3.4.9 Audit Report STS Superintendent - Mooring Master
F.3.4.7 Location Approval
F-3.0.28 Checklist - work place inspections
F.3.0.33 Site Visit Plan
13 FLOWCHART
If needed insert flowchart
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 110 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Appendix-3 PERSONNEL TRANSFER BY CRANE PLAN
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 111 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 112 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 113 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 114 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Appendix-4 DNV STANDARD 2.22 – LIFTING APPLIANCES
The following extract taken from the above regulations Section-9 Lifting of Personnel applies to ship
board cranes certified for “Man-riding”.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 115 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Appendix-5 OPERATIONS PERSONNEL HANDOVER CHECKLIST (FORM 3.0.34)
Figure 19 - Handover Checklist
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 116 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Appendix-6 “MANUAL ON OIL POLLUTION, SECTION I-PREVENTION” 2011
The requirements of the IMO Manual on Oil Pollution, Section-1 have been reproduced verbatim in
italics below:
Chapter 6 Ship-to-ship transfer of crude oil and petroleum products while underway or at anchor
6.1 Introduction
6.1.1 General provisions
This chapter of the manual includes general provisions, which may be supplemented by special instruction
from the shipowners on how to implement procedures based on the peculiarities of design, oil tanker equipment
and operational conditions. Ship-to-ship transfer operations can be performed efficiently, smoothly and without
danger if the Master and the crew are sufficiently experienced and trained. This chapter of the manual is
intended for Masters and crews directly involved in ship-to-ship oil transfer operations. A typical operation is
shown in figure 8. For further information, please refer to Ship-to-Ship transfer guide- petroleum.
6.1.2 Limitations of applicability
The contents of this chapter shall not apply to oil transfer operations associated with fixed or floating platforms
including drilling rigs; floating production, storage and offloading facilities (FPSOs) used for the offshore
production and storage of oil; and floating storage units (FSUs) used for the offshore storage of produced oil.
6.1.3 Non-applicability to bunker operations
In addition, the reporting requirements contained in this chapter may not necessarily apply to bunkering
operations. It is recommended that owners, chartered Masters and ships’ agents obtain advice from the
necessary local authorities.
6.1.4 Exclusions due to emergencies
The guidance contained in this chapter shall not apply to STS operations necessary for the purpose of securing
the safety of a ship or saving life at sea, or for combating specific pollution incidents in order to minimize the
damage from pollution, but does represent good practice.
6.1.5 Exclusions from Flag States
The contents of this chapter shall not apply to STS operations where either of the ships involved is a warship,
naval auxiliary or other ship owned or operated by a State and used, for the time being, only on government
non-commercial service. However, each State shall ensure, by the adoption of appropriate measures not
impairing operations or operational capabilities of such ships that the STS operations are conducted in a
manner consistent, so far as is reasonable and practicable, with this chapter
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 117 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
Adapted from © “Manual on Oil Pollution, Section I, Prevention” by IMO Publishing, 2011 Edition, p. 62.
Figure 20 - Two ship preparing for a ship-to-ship transfer (OCIMF).
6.2 General requirements for vessels involved in ship-to-ship transfer operations
6.2.1 Person in overall advisory control
6.2.1.1 A ship-to-ship transfer operation should be under the advisory control of a designated mooring/unmooring
Master, who will either be one of the Masters concerned or an STS Superintendent. It is not intended that the
person in overall advisory control in any way relieves the ships’ Masters of any of their duties, requirements or
responsibilities.
6.2.1.2 The person in overall advisory control of STS operations shall be qualified to perform all relevant duties, taking
into account the qualifications contained in the best practice guidelines for STS operations identified by the
Organization (IMO’s Manual on Oil Pollution, Section I, Prevention as amended, and the CS and OCIMF
publication Ship-to-ship transfer guide— petroleum, fourth edition, 2005). The Administration, cargo owners
or oil tanker’s operators should agree and designate the person in overall advisory control who should have at
least the following qualifications:
.1 an appropriate management level deck license or certificate meeting international certification
standards, with all International Convention on standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping
for Seafarers 1978, (STCW Convention) and dangerous cargo endorsements up to date and appropriate
for ships engaged in the STS operation;
.2 attendance at a suitable ship handling course;
.3 conduct of a suitable number of mooring/unmooring operations in similar circumstances and with
similar vessels;
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 118 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
.4 experience in oil tanker cargo loading and unloading;
.5 a thorough knowledge of the geographic transfer area and surrounding areas;
.6 a knowledge of spill clean-up techniques, including familiarity with the equipment and resources
available in the STS contingency plan; and
.7 a thorough knowledge of the STS operations plan.
6.2.1.3 The person in overall advisory control should:
.1 ensure that the cargo transfer, mooring and unmooring operations are conducted in accordance with
the required STS operations plan, the contents of this chapter of the manual, and take into account the
recommendations contained in the industry publication Ship-to-ship transfer guide — petroleum;
.2 advises the Master(s) of the critical phases of the cargo transfer, mooring and unmooring operation;
.3 ensure the provisions of the contingency plan are carried out in the event of a spill;
.4 ensure that all required reports are made to the appropriate authorities;
.5 ensure that crew members involved in each aspect of the operation are properly briefed and understand
their responsibilities;
.6 before any approach and mooring operations are attempted, ensure that proper and effective
communication has been confirmed between the two oil tankers and appropriate checks have been
completed;
.7 ensure that a pre-transfer STS safety check is undertaken in accordance with accepted industry
guidance; and
.8 ensure that appropriate checks are undertaken prior to unmooring.
6.2.1.4 The person in overall advisory control should have the authority to advise:
.1 suspend or terminate the STS operation; and
.2 review the STS operations plan for that particular operation.
6.2.1.5 Each oil tanker should have a person in charge of the cargo transfer operation on board, during each watch,
throughout the operation. Each person in charge shall:
.1 inspect the cargo transfer system before transfer;
.2 supervise all aspects of the transfer operation on board the oil tanker;
.3 conduct the transfer operation in accordance with the STS operations plan; and
.4 ensure that all moorings, fenders and safety measures are checked.
6.2.2 STS transfer area
6.2.2.1 The STS transfer area should be specially selected for safe operations, in co-ordination with the appropriate
authorities. In selecting the area for STS transfer, the following should be taken into account, in particular in
the absence of any applicable national legislation:
.1 the traffic density in the given area;
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 119 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
.2 the need for sufficient sea room and water depth required for maneuvering during mooring and
unmooring;
.3 the availability of safe anchorage with good holding ground;
.4 present and forecasted weather conditions;
.5 availability of weather reports for the areas;
.6 distance from shore logistical support;
.7 proximity to environmentally sensitive areas; and
.8 security threat.
6.2.3 Notification to authorities
6.2.3.1 Each oil tanker subject to regulation 42 of chapter 8, MARPOL Annex I, as amended by resolution
MEPC.186(59), that plans STS operations within the territorial sea, or the exclusive economic zone of a Party
to the present Convention shall notify that Party not less than 48 hours in advance of the scheduled STS
operations. Where, in an exceptional case, STS operations are to take place within 48 hours’ notice, the oil
tanker shall notify the Party to the present Convention at the earliest opportunity. The notification specified in
paragraph 1 of regulation 42 shall include at least the following:
.1 name, flag, call sign, IMO number and estimated time of arrival of the oil tankers involved in the STS
operations;
.2 date, time and geographical location at the commencement of the planned STS operations;
.3 whether STS operations are to be conducted at anchor or underway;
.4 oil type and quantity;
.5 planned duration of the STS operations;
.6 identification of STS operations service provider or person in overall advisory control and contact
information; and
.7 confirmation that the oil tanker has on board an STS operations plan.
If the estimated time of arrival of an oil tanker at the location or area for the STS operations changes by more
than six hours, the master, owner or agent of that oil tanker shall provide a revised estimated time of arrival to
the applicable national maritime authority.
6.2.3.2 When STS transfers are to be conducted in an area in international waters, a vessel(s) should transmit by
radio a navigational warning (security) to all ships stating:
.1 the name and nationality of the vessels involved in the operation;
.2 the geographical position of operations and general headings;
.3 nature of operations;
.4 the planned start time of the operations and expected duration; and
.5 request for wide berth and the need to exercise caution when navigating in the STS transfer area.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 120 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.2.3.3 On completion of the STS operation, the person having overall advisory control, or his designee should cancel
the navigational warning.
6.2.4 STS operations plan
6.2.4.1 Each oil tanker involved in the cargo transfer operation should have on board a plan approved by the relevant
national maritime Administration prescribing how to conduct STS operations. The STS operations plan must
be written in the working language understood by the ship’s officers.
The STS operations plan shall be developed taking into account the information contained in the best practice
guidelines for STS operations identified by the Organization. The STS operations plan may be incorporated
into an existing Safety Management System required by chapter IX of the International Convention for the
Safety of Life at Sea (‘SOLAS), 1974, as amended, if that requirement is applicable to the oil tanker in
question. Any oil tanker subject to this chapter and engaged in STS operations shall comply with its STS
operations plan.
6.2.4.2 A copy of the STS operations Plan should be available at the following locations on each oil tanker:
.1 the bridge;
.2 the cargo transfer control station; and
.3 the engine room.
6.2.4.3 The STS operations plan should contain the following information:
.1 a step-by-step description of the entire STS operation;
.2 a description of the mooring and unmooring procedures and arrangements, including diagrams where
necessary, and procedures for tending the oil tanker’s moorings during the transfer of cargo;
.3 a description of the cargo and ballast transfer procedures including those used while the ship is either
underway or anchored, as well as procedures for:
.1 connecting and testing the integrity of cargo hoses and the hose to manifold interface;
.2 topping off cargo tanks; and
.3 disconnecting cargo hoses.
.4 the titles, locations and duties of all persons involved in the STS operation;
.5 procedures for operating the emergency shutdown and communication systems, and for rapid
breakaway;
.6 a description of the drip trays and procedures for emptying them;
.7 procedures for reporting spillages of oil into the water;
.8 an approved contingency plan, which meets the requirements of paragraph 6.2.9; and
.9 a cargo and ballast plan.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 121 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.2.4.4 The Master of each oil tanker should ensure that the STS operations plan on board is current and that all
personnel on board follow the procedures in the Plan. Records of STS operations shall be retained on board for
three years and be readily available for inspection.
6.2.5 Communications
6.2.5.1 Good, reliable communications between the two oil tankers is an essential requirement for the safe and
successful conduct of STS transfer operations. In order to prevent misunderstanding and possibly incorrect
interpretations of commands and signals, communications between the oil tankers should be conducted in a
common language mutually agreed upon and known to personnel directly involved in transfer operations.
Adapted from © “Manual on Oil Pollution, Section I, Prevention,” by IMO Publishing, 2011 Edition, p. 68.
Figure 21 - Ship-to-ship transfer operation (Copyright: OCIMF).
6.2.5.2 The oil tankers should establish initial communications as early as practicable to plan operations and to
confirm the transfer area. During this initial communication, the person in overall advisory control must be
confirmed. Details of the operation, including approach, mooring, cargo transfer and unmooring plans should
be discussed and agreed, together with the joint use of operational safety checklists. (See examples contained in
the ICS/OCIMF Ship-to-ship transfer guide — petroleum, which are reproduced in the appendix)
6.2.5.3 Essential personnel on board both oil tankers involved in the operation of oil transfer should be provided with a
reliable means of communication (for instance, walkie-talkies) for the duration of the operation.
6.2.5.4 In the event a significant failure of communication occurs during an approach manoeuvre, the manoeuvre
should be aborted, if appropriate and safe to do so, and the subsequent actions taken by each oil tanker should
be indicated by the appropriate sound signals, as prescribed in the Convention on the International
Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea (COLREG),1972.
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 122 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.2.5.5 In the event of a breakdown of communications on either oil tanker during cargo operations, the vessel should
sound an agreed emergency signal. At this signal, the oil transfer operations should be suspended and only
resumed after the regular means of communication have been restored.
6.2.6 Equipment
6.2.6.1 Prior to starting the ship-to-ship transfer operation, the Masters of the oil tankers should exchange information
concerning the availability, readiness and compatibility of the equipment to be used in the operation.
Fenders
6.2.6.2 The oil tanker(s) should be provided with fenders (primary and secondary). These fenders should be capable of
withstanding the anticipated berthing energies and should be able to distribute the forces evenly over the
appropriate area of the hulls of both oil tankers. It is recommended that fenders constructed to ISO 17357
should be used. Industry best practice is that the safety valve on pneumatic fenders is inspected at intervals not
exceeding two years and a certificate provided to demonstrate this.
6.2.6.3 Except in cases where the STS transfer is conducted using a dedicated lightering ship, it is probable that
fendering operations will be carried out with the assistance of an STS service provider. Such companies
usually have service craft available and these vessels will normally assist in positioning fenders on the relevant
oil tanker.
6.2.6.4 Fenders may be secured on either oil tanker. However, landing on an unprotected hull section is less likely if
the fenders are rigged on the maneuvering ship and it is therefore preferable that fenders be secured to that
ship.
6.2.6.5 The person in overall advisory control should advise the position and method of securing the fenders to the oil
tankers in advance of the operation.
Hoses
6.2.6.6 The hoses used for the STS transfer of crude oils or petroleum products should be specially designed and
constructed for the product being handled and the purpose for which they are being used. Hoses used should
comply with EN1765 (or latest equivalent) with regard to specification for the assemblies and with BS1435 (or
latest equivalent) and OCIMF guidelines with regard to their handling, inspection and testing. Hoses should
bear the following durable indelible markings:
.1 the manufacturer’s name or trademark;
.2 identification of the standard specification for manufacture;
.3 factory test pressure (note: equal to rated working pressure,
.4 month and year of manufacture and manufacturer’s serial number;
.5 indication that the hose is electrically continuous or electrically discontinuous, semi-continuous or
anti-static
.6 the type of service for which it is intended, e.g. oil or chemical
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 123 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.2.6.7 Test data with respect to each hose should be available and should be sighted prior to the hose being used for
transfer.
6.2.6.8 Hoses should be withdrawn from service and retired against defined criteria, which may include the following:
.1 the presence of defects detected during visual inspections. Defects prompting retirement could include
irregularities in the outside diameter, such as kinking, damaged or exposed reinforcement or permanent
deformation of the casing and damage, slippage or misalignment of end fittings;
.2 after a defined period in service, established in consultation with the manufacturer; and
.3 when the temporary elongation of the hose, measured during routine pressure tests, exceeds maximum
allowable values.
6.2.6.9 A visual inspection of each of the hose assemblies should be carried out before they are connected to the
manifolds to determine that they are free of damage. If damage to a hose or flange is present, the hose should be
withdrawn from use for further inspection, repair or retirement.
6.2.6.10 STS transfer operations require hose connections to be well made. Flanges or if used, quick release couplings
should be in good condition and properly secured to ensure leak tight connections. Prior to transfer operations,
hose integrity should be confirmed at the manifold interfaces and intermediate flanges.
Mooring equipment
6.2.6.11 To ensure the security of moorings, it is important that both tankers are fitted with good quality mooring lines,
efficient winches and sufficiently strong closed fairleads, bitts and other associated mooring equipment that is
fit for purpose. Effective leads between fairleads and mooring bitts and mooring winches should be available for
the handling of all mooring lines.
6.2.6.12 All fairleads used should be of the enclosed type, except on an oil tanker that will always have a substantially
greater freeboard than the other.
This will ensure that the fairleads remain effective in controlling mooring line as the freeboard difference
between the two oil tankers changes.
6.2.6.13 A prime consideration in mooring during STS operations is to provide fairleads and bitts for all lines without
the possibility of lines chaffing and against each other, the oil tankers or the fenders.
6.2.6.14 Steel wire mooring lines and high modulus synthetic fiber ropes should be fitted with synthetic fiber tails to
provide the additional elasticity required for STS mooring arrangements.
6.2.6.15 A minimum of four strong rope messengers should be available on both oil tankers, preferably made from a
buoyant synthetic fiber material.
6.2.7 Precautions against pollution
6.2.7.1 All oil transfer operations should cease should an unsafe or environmentally hazardous condition develop.
Such conditions may include:
.1 failure of hoses or moorings;
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 124 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
.2 deterioration of weather and/or sea conditions;
.3 a dangerous concentration of gas on the deck of the oil tanker(s); and
.4 a significant spill of oil.
6.2.8 State of readiness for an emergency
.1 main engine and steering gear maintained ready for immediate use;
.2 cargo pump and all other equipment trips relevant to the transfer are tested prior to the operation;
.3 crew are readily available and systems are prepared ready to drain and disconnect hoses at short notice;
.4 oil spill containment equipment is prepared and ready for use;
.5 mooring equipment is maintained ready for immediate use with extra mooring lines available at
mooring stations as replacements in case of line failure; and
.6 firefighting equipment is ready for immediate use.
6.2.9 Contingency planning and emergency procedures
6.2.9.1 Although STS transfer operations can be carried out safely, the risk of accident and the potential scale of the
consequences require that organizers develop contingency plans for dealing with emergencies. Before
committing to an STS transfer operation, the parties involved should carry out a risk assessment covering
operational hazards and the means by which they are managed. The output from the risk assessment should be
used to develop risk mitigation measures and contingency plans covering all possible emergencies and
providing for a comprehensive response, including the notification of relevant authorities. The contingency
plan should have relevance to the location of the operation and take into account the resources available, both at
the transfer location and with regard to nearby backup support.
6.2.9.2 Each oil tanker must assign emergency duties to designated members of the crew in case of accidents that may
arise during the transfer of oil, particularly in the case of spillages of oil.
6.2.9.3 During each STS operation consideration should be given to having a tender or work vessel available to deploy
response equipment and to conduct clean-up of any oil which may be spilled during the transfer operation.
6.2.9.4 The risk of oil pollution from STS Operations is no greater than during in-port cargo transfers. However, as a
transfer area may be out of range of port services, a contingency plan with the Shipboard Oil Pollution
Emergency Plan (SOPEP) or Vessel Response Plan (VRP) should be available to cover such risk and should be
activated in the event of an oil spill.
6.2.9.5 Any leak or spillage during the transfer should be reported immediately to the officers on cargo watch who
should immediately stop the cargo transfer and notify the person in overall advisory control. The immediate
measures set forth in the contingency plan should be implemented. The transfer should remain suspended until
it is agreed between the relevant persons/authorities that it is safe to resume.
6.3 Risk assessment
6.3.1 Risk assessment scope
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 125 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
STS operations should be subjected to a risk assessment, the scope of which should include confirmation of the
following:
.1 adequate training, preparation or qualification of the oil tanker’s personnel;
.2 suitable preparation of oil tankers for operations and sufficient control over the oil tankers during
operations;
.3 understanding of signals or commands;
.4 adequate number of crew assigned to controlling and performing oil transfer operations;
.5 suitability of the agreed STS operations plan;
.6 adequate communications between oil tankers or responsible person(s);
.7 attention given to the differences in freeboard or the listing of the oil tankers when transferring cargo;
.8 the condition of transfer hoses;
.9 methods of securely connecting hose(s) to the oil tanker(s) manifold;
.10 recognition of the need to discontinue oil transfer when sea and weather conditions deteriorate; and
.11 adequacy of navigational processes.
6.4 Preparation for operations
6.4.1 Preparations before maneuvers
Prior to the STS operation, the Masters of both oil tankers and, if appointed, the STS Superintendent, should
make the following preparations before maneuvers begin:
.1 carefully study the operational guidelines contained herein and in the industry publication Ship-to-ship
transfer guide —petroleum, as well as any additional guidelines provided by the shipowner and cargo
owner;
.2 ensure that the crew is fully briefed on procedures and hazards, with particular reference to mooring
and unmooring;
.3 ensure that the oil tanker conforms to relevant guidelines, is upright and at a suitable trim;
.4 confirm that the steering gear and all navigation and communications equipment are in satisfactory
working order;
.5 confirm that engine controls have been tested and the main propulsion plant has been tested ahead and
astern;
.6 confirm that all essential cargo and safety equipment has been tested;
.7 confirm that mooring equipment is prepared in accordance with the mooring plan;
.8 fenders and transfer hoses are correctly positioned, connected and secured;
.9 cargo manifolds and hose handling equipment are prepared;
.10 obtain a weather forecast for the STS transfer area for the anticipated period of the operation;
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 126 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
.11 agree the actions to be taken if the emergency signal on the oil tanker’s whistle is sounded; and
.12 confirm completion of relevant pre-operational checklists (see examples in the appendix).
6.4.2 Communications
Communications with the master of the other oil tanker should be established in accordance with 6.2.5 at an
early stage to co-ordinate the rendezvous and the method and system of approach, mooring and disengaging.
6.4.3 Confirmation of readiness
When the preparation of either oil tanker has been completed, the other vessel should be so informed. The
operation may proceed only when both oil tankers have confirmed their readiness.
6.4.4 Joint Plan of Operation
A joint plan of operation in alignment with the STS operations plan established for each ship should be
developed on the basis of information exchanged between the two oil tankers, including the following:
.1 mooring arrangements;
.2 quantities and characteristics of the cargo(s) to be loaded (discharged) and identification of any toxic
components;
.3 sequence of loading (discharging) of tanks;
.4 details of cargo transfer system, number of pumps and maximum permissible pressure;
.5 rate of oil transfer during operations (initial, maximum and topping-up);
.6 the time required by the discharging oil tanker for starting, stopping and changing rate of delivery
during topping-off of tanks;
.7 normal stopping and emergency shutdown procedures;
.8 maximum draught and freeboard anticipated during operations;
.9 disposition and quantity of ballast and slops, and disposal if applicable;
.10 details of proposed method of venting or inerting cargo tanks;
.11 details of crude oil washing, if applicable;
.12 emergency and oil spill containment procedures;
.13 sequence of actions in case of spillage of oil;
.14 identified critical stages of the operation;
.15 watch or shift arrangements;
.16 environmental and operational limits that would trigger suspension of the transfer operation, and
disconnection and unmooring of the tankers;
.17 local or government rules that apply to the transfer;
.18 co-ordination of plans for cargo hose connection, monitoring, draining and disconnection; and
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 127 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
.19 unmooring plan.
6.4.5 Alignment of cargo manifolds
The cargo manifolds of the two oil tankers should be correctly aligned.
6.4.6 Suspension of Hoses
Hoses should be suspended in such a way that excessive strain on manifold fittings is prevented and the
possibility of twisting and pinching between the oil tankers is minimized. Care should be taken to ensure that
hoses are not bent to a radius less than that recommended by the manufacturer and that they do not rub
against the ships’ structure.
6.4.7 Responsible person(s) requirements
Before commencing the cargo transfer operation, the responsible person(s) on the oil tankers should ensure:
.1 proper mooring of the oil tanker;
.2 noting the information provided in the industry publication Ship-to-ship transfer guide — petroleum,
as amended, availability of safe and convenient access between the oil tankers;
.3 availability of reliable communication between the two oil tankers;
.4 emergency signals and shutdown signals are agreed;
.5 proper connection and securing of hoses to the oil tanker’s manifolds;
.6 proper condition and position of hoses, hose saddles and supports;
.7 flanged joints where used, are fully bolted and sealed and ensured oil tight;
.8 proper blanking of unused cargo and bunker connections;
.9 tools required for the rapid disconnection of hoses are located at the manifold;
.10 any valve through which oil could be discharged to the sea is closed and inspected and, if not used in the
operation, is sealed to ensure that it is not inadvertently opened;
.11 deck scuppers are properly plugged;
.12 availability of empty drip trays on both oil tankers under couplings of hoses, and means for drip tray
drainage;
.13 availability of materials on the oil tankers for on-deck clean-up in case of spillage;
.14 fire axes or suitable cutting equipment is in position at fore and aft mooring stations;
.15 an engine room watch will be maintained throughout the transfer and the main engine will be ready for
immediate use;
.16 a bridge watch and/or an anchor watch will be established;
.17 officers in charge of the cargo transfer are identified and details posted;
.18 a deck watch is established to pay particular attention to moorings, fenders, hoses and manifold
integrity;
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 128 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
.19 correct understanding of commands and signals by the responsible person(s) on the oil tankers during
operations; and
.20 confirm completion of relevant pre-transfer checklists.
6.4.8 Agreement between Vessels
The transfer operation may be started only after the responsible person(s) on both oil tankers have agreed to do
so, either verbally or in writing.
6.5 Performance of operations
6.5.1 Immediate checks on start of operation
The operation should be started at a slow rate in order to ensure that all connections and hoses are tight, the oil
is being directed into intended pipelines and tanks, no excessive pressure is building up in the hoses and
pipelines, and there is no evidence of oil leakage in way of the tankers hulls.
6.5.2 Confirmation of normality and permissibility to continue transfer
Only after being satisfied that there is no leakage, the oil is being transferred into the intended pipelines and
tanks, and if there is no excessive pressure, may the rate of transfer be increased up to the maximum indicated
in the plan of operation.
6.5.3 Periodical checks
The responsible persons on both oil tankers should periodically check the following and, if necessary, take
appropriate remedial action:
.1 for any leakage from the equipment and system, or through the oil tanker’s plating;
.2 that there is no leakage into pump rooms, ballast or void spaces or cargo tanks not scheduled to be
loaded;
.3 if there is any excessive pressure in piping and hoses;
.4 the mooring arrangements;
.5 the condition of hoses and their support arrangements; and
.6 tank ullages and quantities transferred.
6.5.4 Caution to avoid surge pressures
Care must be taken to prevent surge pressures when changing over tanks on the oil tanker being loaded. The
filling valves of the next tanks in sequence should be opened before the valves on the tank being filled are
closed.
6.5.5 Exchange of Information
Information on quantities transferred should be routinely and regularly exchanged between the two oil
tankers. Any significant discrepancies between the quantity discharged and the quantity received should be
promptly investigated
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 129 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.5.6 Vapor Emission
Cargo operations should be conducted under closed conditions with ullage, sounding and sampling ports
securely closed. Due regard must be given to any local regulations that may require the adoption of vapor
balancing procedures.
6.5.7 Ballast Operations
During the cargo transfer, appropriate ballast operations should be performed in order to minimize the
differences in freeboard between the two oil tankers and to avoid excessive trims by the stern. Listing of either
ship should be avoided, except as may be required by the discharging oil tanker between the oil tankers to
facilitate tank draining;
6.5.8 Attention to mooring lines
Constant attention should be paid to mooring lines and to avoid chafing and undue stress, particularly that
caused by changes in relative freeboard. If at any time mooring lines need to be repositioned or adjusted, this
should only be done under strictly controlled conditions.
6.6 Completion of operations
6.6.1 Adequate ullage space
It should be ensured that adequate ullage space is left in each tank being filled. When it is required to stop
cargo transfer operations, the responsible person should advise the pumping oil tanker in ample time.
6.6.2 Closure of valves and drainage of hoses
Upon completion of the oil transfer, the oil tanker with the greatest freeboard should close the valve at the
manifold and drain the oil contained in the hoses into the tank of the other oil tanker. Any remaining oil in the
hoses should be drained, after which the hoses should be disconnected and securely blanked. The cargo
manifolds should also be securely blanked.
6.6.3 Coordination of unmooring plan
Following completion of any relevant checklists, the Masters should co-ordinate the unmooring plan, taking
into account weather and sea conditions prevailing in the area.
6.6.4 Confirmation of items before unmooring
As soon as practicable after the transfer operation has been completed, and before unmooring, the responsible
person on each oil tanker should ensure that all valves in their system are closed and cargo tank openings are
closed and secured for sea.
6.6.5 Completion of documentation & unmooring
The oil transfer documents should be completed, communications checked and the readiness of both oil tankers
established, whereupon the ships should unmoor in accordance with the plan.
6.7 Suspension of operations
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 130 of 131
3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx
6.7.1 Examples of reasons for suspension of operations
Both oil tankers should be prepared to immediately discontinue the STS transfer operation, and to unmoor and
depart if necessary. The operation should be suspended when:
.1 movement of the oil tankers alongside reaches the maximum permissible and risks placing excessive
strain on hoses;
.2 under adverse weather and/or sea conditions;
.3 either oil tanker experiences a power failure;
.4 there is a failure of the main communication system between the oil tankers and there are no proper
standby communications;
.5 any escape of oil into the sea is discovered;
.6 there is an unexplained pressure drop in the cargo system;
.7 fire danger is discovered;
.8 any oil leakage is discovered from hoses, couplings, or the oil tanker’s deck piping;
.9 overflow of oil onto the deck occurs caused by overfilling of a cargo tank;
.10 any faults or damage threatening the escape of oil are discovered; and
.11 there is a significant, unexplained difference between the quantities of cargo delivered and received.
6.7.2 Resumption of operations
Operations may be resumed only after the weather and seas have abated or appropriate remedial action has
been taken.
6.8 References
Table 4 – MoOP References
No. Item
1 International safety guide for oil tankers and terminals (ISGOTT) - (IAPH/ICS/OCIMF)
2 Ship-to-ship transfer guide- petroleum- (ICS and OCIMF)
3 Convention on International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea (COLREG),
1972-(IMO)
4 Convention on International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea (COLREG),
1972-(IMO)
5 Recommendations for oil tanker manifolds and associated equipment - (OCIMF)
6 Guidelines for the handling, storage, inspection and testing of hoses in the field -
(OCIMF)
7 EN 1765:2004 - Rubber hose assemblies for oil suction and discharge Services-
specification for the assemblies (European Committee for Standardization-CEN)
8 BS 1435-2:2005 - Rubber hose assemblies for oil suction and discharge services -
recommendations for storage, testing and use - (British Standards Institution - BSI)
Title: 3.4.14 - STS Ops SOP Manual.docx Version: Date: Page:
1.5 03-04-2019 131 of 131
Saatja: Indrek Nuut <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 22.02.2021 15:35
Adressaat: Agni Kaldma <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
MKM info <
[email protected]>; Ahti Kuningas <
[email protected]>
Koopia: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>
Teema: RE: VV määruse nr 51 muutmise eelnõu - laevalt laevale
kaubaoperatsioonidest ankrualadel
Tere
Käesolevaga esitan Navest Agency OÜ seisukoha seoses kavaga muuta VV
määrust nr 51, mis puudutab ohtlike kaupade käitlemist merel, ehk nn
laevalt laevale (STS ship to ship) kaubaoperatsioone.
Lugupidamisega
Indrek Nuut
MALSCO LAW OFFICE
Navest Agency OÜ
Lepinguline esindaja
From: Viktor Palmet <> Sent: esmaspäev, 22. veebruar 2021 10:24To: Janno
Laende <>; NAVEST agency <>; ; ; ; ; ; ; Marje Gutmann <>Subject: VV
määruse nr 51 muutmise eelnõu
Tere ja INFOKS
Siin ka Sadamate Liidu ning Logistika ja Transiidi Assotsiatsiooni
ühiskiri, mille saatsime Keskkonnaminile juba eelmisel nädalal.
Teema vajaks siiski edasist arutelu. Hetkel käsitletakse määrusega
peamiselt sisemere keskkonnatundlikke alasid. Kuid käitlus vajaks
siiski sisulisemat käsitlust.
Vastavad õigussätted on mitmes seaduses juba olemas, kuid tundub, et
tuleks täiendusi teha.
Teatud veeldatud gaaside sissetoomine Eestisse StS meetodil vajaks
täpsemaid õiguslikke aluseid, üldistaval arusaadaval viisil. Veeseadus ja
sellest tulenev määrus nr.51 kindlasti ei anna alust
lastimisteenuste laiendamiseks…selleks on vastavad seadused.
Kuid tuleks läbi mõelda mitte ainult õiguslikud, vaid ka majanduslikud,
keskkonnakaitse, korralduslikud ja ka piirirežiimiga seonduvad
aspektid. Need on erinevate ministeeriumide haldusalas ja erinevates
seadustes.
Parimat
Viktor Palmet
Sadamate Liit
On 21 Feb 2021, at 23:23, Janno Laende <> wrote:
Tere.
Palun leidke manusest Eesti Laevajuhtide Liidu tagasiside VV määruse nr
51 muutmise eelnõu kohta.
Parimate soovidegaJanno Laende
GSM: +372 50 76 452E-post:
From: Agni Kaldma <> Sent: Thursday, February 18, 2021
12:00 PMTo: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; Cc: Marje Gutmann <>Subject: VV
määruse nr 51 muutmise eelnõu
Tere!
Ekslikult läks eile saadetud VV määruse nr 51 muudatuse eelnõu Teile
välja märkega „teadmiseks. Soovin täpsustada, et ootame eelnõule siiski
Teie tagasisidet.
Tervitades
Agni Kaldma
Peaspetsialist | Merekeskkonna osakond
Senior Officer | Marine Environment Department
+372 5265815 | |
Keskkonnaministeerium | Ministry of the Environment of Estonia | Narva
mnt 7a, 15172 Tallinn, Eesti
<ELJL vastus KEM pöördumisele 21.02.21.asice>
Keskkonnaministeerium Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium Te a dmiseks: hr. Kristen Michal, Riigikogu M ajanduskomisjoni esimees ja VV määruse muutmise ümarlaual osalejad 22.02.2021 Vabariigi Valitsuse määruse nr . 51 „ Merel, Narva jõel ja Peipsi järvel ohtlike ja kahjulike ainete käitlemise kord“ 17.02.2021 muutmise eelnõu st Käesolevaga esitame NavEst Agency OÜ seisukoha vabariigi valitsuse määruse nr . 51 „ Merel, Narva jõel ja Peipsi järvel ohtlike ja kahjulike ainete käitlemise kord“ 17.02.2021 muutmise eelnõu kohta . eelnõu kohaselt plaanitakse teha määrusesse järgmised muudatused: Paragrahv 5 lõige 2 sõnastatakse järgmiselt: „(2) Laevaliikluse korraldamise süsteemi tööpiirkonnas on ohtlike ja kahjulike käitlemine lubatud navigatsiooniteabes avaldatud ankrualadel, välja arvatud ankrualal, mis kattub osaliselt või täielikult kaitstava loodusobjekti alaga ning ankrualal, kus kavandatav tegevus toob eeldatavalt kaasa olulise keskkonnamõju kaitstaval loodusobjektil.“; Paragrahvi 12 täiendatakse lõikega 2 järgmises sõnastuses: „(2) Ohtlike ja kahjulike ainete käitlemine, välja arvatud punkerdamine, on keelatud Eesti Vabariigi sisemeres mereala ruumilise planeeringu kehtestamiseni, kuid mitte kauem kui 2022. aasta 1. märtsini.“. STS (Ship to ship lastimine) versus punkedamine, võrdne kohtlemine ja STS operatsioonide tegelik ohtlikkus Esmalt ei saa nõustuda STS operatsioonide ja punkerdamise erineva käsitlemise ja kohtlemisega. Sisuliselt on tegu samalaadse te kaubaoperatsiooni de ga. Ühel juhul pu m batakse punkrilaevalt kütust ümber vastuvõtva laeva omatarbeks, teisel ühelt laevalt teisele kaubana. Võimalused keskonnareostuseks on täpselt ühesugused ning kaitsemeetmed saavad olla ühesugused. Võimalik reostuse maht mlemal juhu piirdub hetkel voolikutes oleva kütuse kogusega. Suure tõenäosusega satub kütus mitte otse merre vaid, esmalt laeva tekile, kus on võimalik see lokaliseerida. See kui kiiresti suudetakse lekke korral pupamine peatada ja laeva tekilt merre sattunud reostus lokaliseerida on mõlema operatsiooni (nii punkerdamine kui STS) puhul täpselt ühesugune. Mõlemad operatsioonid alluvad eraldi sel l eks välja töötatud ohutusreglitele, mis üksteisest ei erine. Vastava dokumentatsiooni lisame oma kirjale. Kahetsusväärselt on seni ajakirjaduses avaldatud äärmiselt triviaalseid käsitlusi STS operatsioonidest nagu oleks tegu mingi suvalise regelem en teerimata tegevusega, kus ohutusmeetmeid kas ei ole või rakendatakse neid suvaliselt . Seejuures on oluline, et punkerdamine toimub oluliselt tihedamini ja väiksemates kogust e s ning seega kujutab endast oluliselt suuremat riski, kui harva toimuvad STS operatsioonid. STS operatsioonide tulemusena ei ole esinenud ühtegi reostusjuhtumit. STS operatsiooni kontrollinud keskonnaametnikel ei olnud selle läbiviimise kohta ühtegi märkust. Kavandatava muudatuse tegemisega rikutakse võrdse kohtlemise põhimõtet ning alusetult erisatakse punkerdamist ja laevalt laevale ümberlaadimise (S TS – Ship to Ship) operatsiooni nende ohtlikkuse seisukohalt. Väidetav STS operatsioonidelt Eesti riigil ja sadamatel saamata jää v tulu Erinevalt levinud (ja levitatud) eksiarvamusest ei too STS operatsioonide keelamine ankrualadel neid laevu Eesti sadamatesse STS operatsioone läbi viima. Tänasel päeval ei ole Eesti sadamate (NB valdavalt riigimonopol) tasud konkurentsivõimelised, et laevad üldse sadamaid külastaksid. Kui rääkida konkreetselt STS operatsioonidest, siis AS Tallinna Sadam sa da maeeskiri välistab STS operatsiooni sadamas, teadaolevalt ei ole ka sellist kaikohta, kus saaks sellist operatsiooni sellises su u ruses laevadega (LOA 250m) läbi viia. STS operatsioon eeldab, et laevad on kõrvuti, mitte ei sildu kai ääres ükteise järel vms. STS operatsioone viiakse reegline läbi Taani väinade piirkonnas . Juhul kui Eesti keelab ankrualadel STS operatsioonid ja sunnib laevad selleks sadmasse (koos kõrgete sadamatasudega) edaspidi neid operatsioonie Eesti ankrualadel ei teostata ja need teostatakse Taani väinade piirkonnas, sest pudub igasugune majanduslik mõte tuua laevad selleks kõrgete tasude eest Eesti sadamasse. Mõned päevad lisaaega, et jõuda STS operatsiooni k s Taani väinade piirkonda on igal juhul ratsionaalsem, kui saata selleks laev vastu Eesti sadam a sse ning tasuda kahe suure tankeri sad a matasud. Seega , keelamise tulemuseks on STS operatsioonide ärajäämine ja Eesti riiki hakkab saatma kahtlane maine riigist, kes ühel hetkel otsustab midagi lubada ja siis poole aasta pä r ast otsustab jälle majandustegevuse keelata populistlikel eesmärkidel. STS operatsioonide ärajäämine toob lisakas mainekahjule kaasa selle, et STS operatsioonis osalevatele laevadele ei saa STS operatsiooni väliselt osutada muid teenuseid nagu punkerdamine, ülevaatused , ankrus seistes teostatavad remondid ja hooldused, varustamine. Täna osutatakse seoses STS operatsiooniga järgnevaid lisateenuseid : P unker damine Saybolt (kauba inspektorid) Sadamad (abilaeva sadama külastus ) Agent Vendrite vedu ja stevedore teenus T erminal (stevedoring ja vendrit/voolikute ladustamine) Meeskonna vahetused Tehnikud Laveva varustamine Remont Veeteetasu 30% määr Teenuse arenedes nimekiri täieneks. Leiame, et üldkokkuvõttes toob majandustegevuse keelamine suuremat kahju kui kasu ning see ei ole vajalik keskkonn a riskide maandamiseks . Ettevaatusphimõtte rakendamine Muudatuse kohaselt keelatakse ohtlike ja kahjulike ainete käitlemine, välja arvatud punkerdamine , Eesti Vabariigi sisemeres mereala ruumilise planeeringu kehtestamiseni, kuid mitte kauem kui 2022. aasta 1. märtsini. Määruse muudatuse e e lnõus ei ole selgitatud , ega põhjendatud, miks ohtlike ja kahjulike ainete käitlemine on keelatud, kuid seejuures vastav piirang punkerdamisele ei kehti. Keskkonnaohutuse seisukohalt lähtudes ei saa ohtlike ainete käitlemist STS operatsiooni raames käsitleda punkerdamisest ohtlikuma tegevusena, kuna mõlema tegevuse puhul sõltub võimaliku õnnetuse korral kahjulik tagajärg reageerimiskiirusest, mitte ümberpumbatava kütuse mahust. Mõlemal juhul piirdub reostuse võimalik maht hetkel voolikutes oleva kütuse kogusega. Eelnõu seletuskirja kohaselt on ülalviidatud muudatuse vajadus tingitud asjaolust, et tuleb hinnata olemasolevad ankrualad ning määrata kindlaks, milliseid toiminguid saab ja tohib konkreetsel ankrualal teha. Ettevaatusprintsiibist lähtudes tuleb sellise analüüsi valmimiseni ja selle mereala ruumilises planeeringus kehtestamiseni ohtlikud tegevused keelata, sest seni pole tehtud ühtki analüüsi, mis hindaks, millistel ankrualadel oleksid need tegevused kõige ohutumad. Eeltooduga ei saa nõustuda, kuna E esti varasema õiguspraktika kohaselt keskkonnariskide puhul ei seata eesmärgiks nende täielikku vältimist, vaid vähendamist mõistlikus ulatuses. Vastasel juhul tuleks keelata enamus majandustegevusi. Seega ei ole ettevaatuspõhimõte tegevuste täieliku keelamise aluseks. Tegevuste läbiviimine on lubatud siis, kui võetakse kohased (proportsionaalsed) meetmed keskkonnariskide vähendamiseks võimalikult suures ulatuses. Tegevuste keelamine tuginedes ettevaatuspõhimõttele võib olla põhjendatud vaid siis, keskkonnahäiringu mõju vähendamiseks ei ole muid proportsionaalseid meetmeid. Antud juhul mingit keskkonnahäiret ei toimu, vaid toiming sisaldab endas riski keskkonna saastamiseks, mis saab reaalseks ainuüksi õnnetuste korral. Riski hindamiseks peaks läbi vaatama STS opeatsiooni ohutsjuhendid, mis meie arvates viivad riskiteguri miinimumini . Seega on rakendatud kõik vajalikud ja proportsionaalsed ohutusmetmed. Samas on tänaseks päevaks on ka keskkonnainspektorid STS operatsiooni realaselt jälginud ja märkusi neil ei olnud. Tähelepanuväärne on see, et punkerdamisel on reostusjuhtumeid väidetavalt esinenud, kuid seda tegevust ei ole ära keelatud, ega keelata ka määruse muutmisel. Muuhulgas tuleb arvesse võtta asjaolu, et võimaliku keskkonnaohu hindamine toimus juba esialgse määruse vastuvõtmisele eelnevalt. Ei ole usutav ega keskkonnakaitse põhimõtetega kooskõlas, et 25.06.2020 võeti vastu määrus, millega tegelikult ekslikult lubati äärmiselt keskkonnaohtlik tegevus. Keskkonnaseadustiku üldosa seaduse § 11 lg 2 sätestab, et keskkonnariskiga tegevuste suhtes otsuste tegemisel selgitatakse välja nende tegevuste mõju keskkonnale. Määruse muutmise eelnõust ei selgu, et oleks avastatud mingi uus asjaolu või viga varasemates hinnagutes olukorrale. Õiguspärase ootuse põhimõte ja hea õigusloome tava Õiguspärase ootuse põhimõtte järgi peab isikul olema õigus realiseerida oma õigusi mõistlikus ootuses, et talle lubatu ka kehtima jääb. Õigusloomeprotsess peab olema ettenähtav ja avatud. Õigusloomes tehtavad otsused peavad olema läbipaistvad ja põhjendatud. Mida olulisem muudatus, seda põhjalikum peab olema põhjendus. Õiguskorras tehtavad muudatused ei või olla õigusakti adressaatide suhtes meelevaldsed ega sõnamurdlikud. Antud juhul ei nähtu, et oleks järgitud head õigusloome tava ja õiguspärase ootuse phimõtet. Lisaks rõhutame, et võimu tuleb teostada avalikes huvides, kaaludes kõiki aspekte ning võimu teostamisel ei tohi lähtuda kitsalt väikese ringi isikute huvidest , ega populistlikest eesmärkidest. Eelmise aasta suvel võttis Vabariigi Valitsus vastu määruse, mille kohaselt on laevaliikluse korraldamise süsteemi tööpiirkonnas käitlemine lubatud navigatsiooniteabes avaldatud ankrualadel (§ 5 lg 2). Jääb arusaamatuks, miks on ootamatult leitud, et see tegevus võib endaga siiski kaasa tuua mingeid selliseid keskkonnariske või lausa ohte, et tegevus tuleb täielikult keelata . Juhul kui leitakse, et enne „Merel, Narva jõel ja Peipsi järvel ohtlike ning kahjulike ainete käitlemise kord“ määruse vastuvõtmist tehtud kavandatava määruse analüüs ei olnud piisav, eelkõige piisaval määral ei hinnatud käitlemisest tulenevaid võimalikke keskkonna saastamise riske, siis on võimalik need analüüsid nüüd teha, kuid analüüside koostamiseni tegevuse täielik keelamine ei ole õigusriigi põhimõtetega kooskõlas, kuna ettevõtjale peab säilima võimalus oma ettevõtlusega tegelemiseks, kui see võimalus on talle lähiminevikus kord juba antud. Ei ole põhjendatud kuni täiendavate analüüside valmimiseni tegevuse täielik keelamine. Vaid vastupidi, ükskord juba lubatu keelamine peab põhinema väga selgetel argumentidel ja alustel. Ettevõtlusvabaduse piiramine Eesti Vabariigi põhiseaduse § 31 sätestab õiguse tegelda ettevõtlusega. Eesti Vabariigi 2020. a põhiseaduse kommentaaride kohaselt ettevõtlusvabadus annab isikule õiguse nõuda, et avalik võim ei sekkuks tema ettevõtlusena käsitatavasse tegevusse. Ettevõtlusvabaduse tuumaks on Riigikohus pidanud riigi kohustust mitte teha põhjendamatuid takistusi ettevõtluseks (vt RKPJKo 28.04.2000, 3-4-1-6-00, p 11; RKPJKo 06.07.2012, 3-4-1-3-12, p 41): „Ettevõtlusvabadus kaitseb ettevõtja võimalust toimida turu tingimustes riigi põhjendamatu sekkumiseta.“ (RKÜKo 09.12.2013, 3-4-1-2-13, p 112). Riigikohtu selgituse kohaselt ettevõtlusvabaduse piiramiseks piisab küll igast mõistlikust põhjusest (RKHKo 11.04.2016, 3-3-1-75-15), kuid see põhjus peab johtuma avalikust huvist või teiste isikute õiguste ja vabaduste kaitse vajadusest, olema kaalukas ja enesestmõistetavalt õiguspärane. Mida intensiivsem on ettevõtlusvabadusse sekkumine, seda mõjuvamad peavad olema sekkumist õigustavad põhjused (RKPJKo 10.05.2002, 3-4-1-3-02; RKPJKo 06.07.2012, 3-4-1-3-12, p 51). Ettevõtlusvabadust riivab iga abinõu, mis takistab, kahjustab või kõrvaldab mõne ettevõtlusega seotud tegevuse (vt RKPJKo 28.04.2000, 3-4-1-6-00). Ettevõtlusvabaduse kaitseala on riivatud juba siis, kui avalik võim mõjutab seda vabadust ebasoodsalt – nt halvendatakse varem kehtinud õigusraamistikku (vt RKPJKo 06.03.2002, 3-4-1-1-02; RKPJKo 16.12.2013, 3-4-1-27-13). Antud juhul ei ole esitatud seletuskirjas mõjuvaid ja selgeid põhjusi, miks on selline keeld kehtestatud. V iide edaspidise analüüsi vajadusele ei ole õigusriigi põhimõtte kohaselt põhjendus ükskord juba lubatu d ettvõtlustegevuse keelamisele. Puudub vastav volitusnorm Vabariigi Valitsuse poolt tegevuse keelamiseks - põhiõiguste ja vabaduste piiranguid võib kehtestada ainult seadusjõulise õigusaktiga Põhiseaduse § 31 teine lause lubab seadusega kehtestada piirangud ettevõtlusvabadusele. Seaduse reservatsioon ei kohusta seadusandjat kõiki piiranguid detailselt seaduses kirjeldama, üksikasjad võib jätta täitevvõimu otsustada. Küll aga peab seadus määrama raamid, mille piirides võib täitevvõim seaduse sätteid täpsustada (vt RKPJKo 17.03.1999, 3-4-1-1-99). Seadusliku aluse nõude osas tuleb silmas pidada piirangu iseloomu. Vabariigi Valitsuse 22.12.2011 määruse „Hea õigusloome ja normitehnika eeskiri“ § 11 lg 3 sätestab, et volitusnormis esitatakse määrusandliku volituse selge sisu ja ulatus, milles tuleb seaduse sätteid täpsustada või nende rakendamiseks vajalik kord kehtestada. Veeseaduse § 143 lg 7 sätestab, et Vabariigi Valitsuse määrusega määratakse kord. Seega valitsus saab sätestada tingimused ja korra tegevuse läbiviimiseks, kuid vastav säte ei anna õigust tegevuse keelamiseks. Kavandavata aktiga on Vabariigi Valitus ületanud volitusnormi piire. Põhiseaduse kommentaaride kohaselt PS § 3 lg 1 esimesest lausest tulenev parlamendireservatsiooni ehk olulisuse põhimõte nõuab, et kõik riigielus olulised küsimused otsustab Riigikogu või kõrgeima võimu kandjana rahvas. Olulisuse põhimõtte kohaselt ei saa seda, mida PS järgi on kohustatud tegema seadusandja, edasi delegeerida täitevvõimule ega ühelegi teisele isikule või organile. Selline on Riigikohtu järjekindel praktika. PS § 3 lõike 1 esimesest lausest tulenevalt on määrus põhiseadusega vastuolus muuhulgas juhul, kui see ei ole volitusnormiga kooskõlas. HMS § 90 lõike 1 kohaselt võib määruse anda ainult seaduses sisalduva volitusnormi olemasolul ja kooskõlas volitusnormi piiride, mõtte ja eesmärgiga. Kõik põhiõiguste seisukohalt olulised otsused peab langetama seadusandja, vaid vähem intensiivseid põhiõiguste piiranguid võib kehtestada täpse, selge ja piirangu intensiivsusega vastavuses oleva volitusnormi alusel määrusega (RKÜKo 03.12.2007, 3-3-1-41-06, p-d 21 ja 22). Riigikohtu lahendi nr 3-3-1-41-06 p 22 järgi on Riigikohus oma praktikas korduvalt rõhutanud põhimõtet, et PS § 3 lõike 1 esimesest lausest ja §-st 11 tulenevalt tohib põhiõiguste ja vabaduste piiranguid kehtestada ainult seadusjõulise õigusaktiga. Oleme seisukohal, et kehtestades täieliku keelu väljub valitsus määruse keht e stamiseks antud volitusnormi piiridest, mis toob kaasa määruse õigustühisuse. Lugupidamisega (allkirjastatud digitaalselt) Indrek Nuut MALSCO LAW OFFICE OÜ Navest Agency OÜ Lepnguline esindaja