Saatja: General Secretary <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 10.07.2019 12:16
Adressaat: Bongelli Kristian <
[email protected]>; Cilento Marco <
[email protected]>;
Bir Juliane <
[email protected]>; Bonacina Emanuela <
[email protected]>;
LAZZARONI, Cecilia <
[email protected]>
Teema: Follow-up of the High Level Conference “A NEW START FOR COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING IN EUROPE” (Bucharest, 25 June 2019)
Manused: List of Participants Bucharest 25-06-2019.pdf; ETUC Leaflet 'Multiemployer
bargaining'.pdf; Report on High Level Conference on Collective Bargaining - Bucharest 25 June
2019 [final].pdf
Dear Minister,
Dear State Secretary,
First of all, I would like to thank you for the interest and support you have shown for the work the ETUC
is doing to relaunch multi-employer collective bargaining across Europe. I am particularly grateful to
those of you who have been able to personally attend or to be represented by a member of the
government.
The high level conference organised by the ETUC in cooperation with Minister Budai and the Romanian
Presidency of the EU has been a very successful event. This will surely pave the way for a deeper and
sounder cooperation among European Institutions, governments as well as European and national social
partners with the aim of promoting and strengthening collective bargaining.
As a follow-up of the conference and in order to foster our cooperation, I am forwarding you a short
note with key messages resulting from our discussions.
I look forward to discussing this further with all of you,
Best regards,
Luca Visentini
Luca Visentini - General Secretary
European Trade Union Confederation
Confédération Européenne des Syndicats
www.etuc.org
Follow us on twitter: @ETUC-CES
On facebook: www.facebook.com/ETUCCES
Multi-employer collective bargaining tackles inequality. The difference between wages at the top
of the distribution (ninth decile) and the bottom (first decile) and the middle (fifth decile) is more
limited in centralised multi-employer bargaining systems.
C. Collective bargaining and the wage distribution
Difference in percentage points with respect to fully decentralised system
0
-0,05
-0,1
-0,15
-0,2
-0,25
-0,3
MULTI-EMPLOYER
Predominantly Predominantly Organised decentrali- Largely decentralised
centralised and weakly centralised and sed and co-ordinated
co-ordinated co-ordinated
BARGAINING: GOOD
D9D1 D)D5 D5D1
The combined findings of above graphs show that collective bargaining,
FOR ECONOMY, GOOD
when undertaken at the multi-employer level, can address inequalities while
at the same time improving employment performance.
FOR SOCIETY
This leaflet was developed by the ETUC in cooperation with IndustriAll Europe.
The content is based on the work of ITUC Chief Economist Ronald Janssen
BACKGROUND THE CASE FOR new challenges in a concerted THE EVIDENCE FOR SECTOR-LEVEL BARGAINING2
SECTOR-LEVEL and widely accepted fashion.
In Europe, the crisis stopped BARGAINING Multi-employer bargaining
Multi-employer bargaining contributes to higher employment. The graph below shows how diffe-
upward social convergence rent collective bargaining systems3 compare to fully decentralised bargaining in terms of total
among our countries and the fights inequalities so contribu- employment and unemployment rates. The evidence is crystal clear: sector-level bargaining
Multi-employer bargaining ting to better social and econo-
fragile economic recovery which allows bargaining in a profes- systems lead to superior outcomes while fully decentralised (company level) systems underperform.
followed was not able to revita- mic outcomes. There is
sional and cost-effective way. overwhelming evidence that
lise it. The quality of employ- Instead of negotiations in each A. Labour market outcomes
ment, wage levels as well as countries with stronger systems
individual business, bargaining can of collective bargaining are more Difference in percentage points with respect to fully decentralised system
working and living conditions still be done by skilled and experien-
suffer from scars left by the crises resilient and that unequal
ced sector-level teams of negotia- economies perform badly1. p.p.
and vary deeply in European tors. Thus, realising tangible
4
countries while inequalities have Unequal economies experience
savings, especially for SMEs which shorter and weaker growth
widened in our society. The in many most EU countries repre- spurts as they harm aggregate 2
European Pillar of Social Rights sent the large majority.
and the Sustainable Development demand. High inequalities also
Goals are political initiatives undermine investment in human 0
Multi-employer bargaining helps capital thus also harming longer
aimed at reactivating such a build social trust and more
process. They encourage concer- growth performance. Prosperity, -2
stable relations between busi- when not widely shared, fuels
ted solutions and call for all ness and labour. It does so by
relevant stakeholders to step up citizens’ resentment and erodes
setting generally acceptable fair confidence in institutions, even Predominantly Predominantly Organised decentrali- Largely decentralised
efforts, to take responsibility and pay standards and by keeping
centralised and weakly centralised and sed and co-ordinated
to actively contribute to deliver in democracy. This creates co-ordinated co-ordinated
potentially tense and conflictual instability and a detrimental
such a vision of our societies. discussions and negotiations out environment for business. Employment rate (% of persons aged 25-64) Unemployment rate (% of persons aged 25-64)
of the workplace. In some cases,
In this framework, the promotion sector agreements include a
Multi-employer bargaining is the This is also true when looking at the most vulnerable groups of workers. Graph B shows that
of collective bargaining is not social peace obligation which
only a matter of ensuring a more commits parties to refrain from best and most effective way to youth, women and low-skilled workers have much lower unemployment rates under sectoral
democratic society, it is also a redistribute the wealth created bargaining compared to company-level bargaining.
industrial action for the duration in the economy. It helps coun-
matter of creating a more inclu- of the agreement itself. Expe-
sive and sustainable economy, tries tackle excessive inequality B. Unemployment rate by group
rience from the euro crisis by preventing wage competition
ensuring prosperity for all: teaches us that attempts to
citizens, working people and from driving down salaries within
lower conditions agreed at the sector. At the same time,
p.p.
2
businesses. Indeed, there is no sector level via a company
trade-off because collective sectoral wage scales also com-
agreement or a unilateral press inequality between
bargaining can contribute to decision can result in increased
0
economic growth with high workers themselves as they
social strife at the company and imply ‘equal pay for equal work’.
social standards. However, in expensive and time-consuming -2
many European countries social Moreover, experience shows that
court cases. multi-employer systems with
partners do not enjoy the right
conditions to allow them to higher collective bargaining -4
Multi-employer bargaining coverage better prevent in-work
deliver on their responsibilities. contributes to address market
For a wide range of different poverty and gender pay gap -6
failures and to tackle common while promoting higher employ-
reasons, social partner organisa- challenges. Multi-employer
tions meet obstacles to the ment rates and participation of Predominantly Predominantly Organised decentrali- Largely decentralised
agreements can result in pooling most vulnerable groups in the centralised and weakly
co-ordinated
centralised and
co-ordinated
sed and co-ordinated
autonomous and robust deploy- resources and share risks within
ment of industrial relations and, labour market. Finally, multi-em-
the sector. This is particularly ployer bargaining prevents
in particular, collective bargaining. important, for instance, when it Youth Women Low-skylled
This is why revamping upward economies and business from
comes to provide funding and
social convergence in Europe will access for workers to training, and getting caught in a ‘low wage 2 Source : OECD 2018 Employment Outlook.
inevitably have to involve (re-)bu- share the risk and cost of adjust- trap’ by incentivising companies 3 Classification of collective bargaining systems by OECD:
ilding and supporting stronger lagging behind in productivity to - Predominantly centralised and weakly coordinated : Switzerland, France, Spain, Italy, Portugal, and Slovenia
ment to structural change. These organise the workplace in a - Predominantly centralised and coordinated: Belgium,Finland
systems of multi-employer investments in human capital - Organised decentralized and coordinated sector level bargaining: Nordics, Germany,Austria, Netherlands
collective bargaining. better and more productive way. - Largely decentralized: Japan, Greece, Slovakia, Australia, Luxembourg, Ireland
help the labour market to adapt to - Fully decentralized : Canada, Chile, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Korea, Latvia,Lithuania, Mexico, New Zealand,Poland, Turkey, UK, US.
1 See, for instance. OECD (2015) In It Together. Why less inequality benefits all.
High-Level Conference
“A New Start for Collective Bargaining in Europe”
Tuesday, 25 June 2019
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
1. ALEXANDRU Luminița-Giliola Romania
JUSTICE
2. ALLUÉ BUIZA Ángel GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF LABOUR Spain
MINISTRY OF SOCIAL SECURITY AND
3. AUŠRA Bagdonaitė Lithuania
LABOUR
FEDERATIA SERVICIILOR DE
4. BADEA Gabriel Romania
SECURITATE
5. BALACEANU Gheorghe FGS FAMILIA - CSC Romania
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
6. BĂNESCU Dragoș-Ionuț Romania
JUSTICE
7. BARAN Petre Daniel Romeo ANTENA 3 Romania
8. BARASCU Leonard CNSLR-FRATIA Romania
1 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
9. BAUDOUR Mathieu ACV-CSC Belgium
10. BENTAHAR Sarrah ETUC Belgium
11. BONACINA Emanuela ETUC Belgium
12. BONGELLI Kristian ETUC Belgium
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
13. BUDĂI Marius-Constantin Romania
JUSTICE
14. BUZEK Tanja VER.DI Germany
15. CARLAN Paula CNS CARTEL ALFA Romania
CNS CARTEL ALFA
16. CARLAN Paula Romania
17. CAVALLINI Manola CGIL Italy
18. CILENTO Marco ETUC Belgium
19. COATMAN Clare TUC United Kingdom
20. COLOTTA Domenico MINISTRY OF LABOUR Italy
2 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
21. CONSTANTIN Paraschiv FSAB Romania
22. CONSTANTINOAIA Corneliu CNSLR-FRATIA Romania
23. COSTIN Dumitru BLOCUL NATIONAL SINDICAL Romania
24. COULON Pierre Jean EESC Belgium
25. CRAVERO Guillaume MINISTRY OF LABOUR France
26. CRUSE NAEYÉ Rasmus MINISTRY OF EMPLOYMENT Sweden
CONCORDIA EMPLOYERS
27. DABU Mihaela Adelina Romania
ORGANIZATION
28. DABU Adelina GLOBAL SHAPERS BUCHAREST HUB Romania
FEDERAL PUBLIC SERVICE FOR
29. DE POORTER Geert EMPLOYMENT, LABOUR AND SOCIAL Belgium
DIALOGUE
30. DEL RIO Cinzia UIL Italy
31. DIMITROV Plamen CITUB Bulgaria
3 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
32. EFTIMIE Marius ENGIE ROMANIA Romania
33. ENACHE Florentina CNSLR-FRATIA Romania
34. FLATEN Annika UNI EUROPA Belgium
35. FLORESCU Victor BLOCUL NATIONAL SINDICAL Romania
36. FONTANA Raffaele MINISTRY OF LABOUR Italy
37. FORSBERG Hans LO-SE Sweden
38. GALLI Ivana CGIL Italy
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
39. GEAMBAȘU Constantin Romania
JUSTICE
40. GILLIS Julienne ETUC Belgium
41. GODINAC Cristinel FAIR-MEDIASIND Romania
42. HAJNOS Miroslav KOZ SR Slovakia
43. HANSEN Robert LO-N Norway
4 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
44. HOSSU Bogdan Iuliu CARTEL ALFA Romania
45. HUEMER Gerhard SMEunited Belgium
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
46. HURKA Petr Czech Republic
AFFAIRS
47. IONESCU Ciprian BCR Romania
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
48. ION-MIHNEVICI Iulia Romania
JUSTICE
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
49. IORDĂCHESCU Tudor-Gheorghe Romania
JUSTICE
50. JANSSEN Ronald ITUC Belgium
51. JEFFLÉN Martin EUROCADRES Belgium
52. JENSEN Jesper David AKADEMIKERNE Denmark
MINISTRY OF ECONOMIC AFFAIRS
53. KARJALAINEN Jenni Finland
AND EMPLOYMENT
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND PENSION
54. KIKELJ Matija Croatia
SYSTEM
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR
55. KOLLER Heinz Switzerland
ORGANISATION
5 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
MINISTRY OF FAMILY, LABOUR AND
56. KUBERSKI Kazimierz Poland
SOCIAL POLICY
57. KÜNZEL Sebastian MINISTRY OF EMPLOYMENT Germany
58. LILL Heiki EAKL Estonia
59. LUNDBERG Magnus TCO Sweden
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
60. MAFTEI-GOLOPENȚIA Elena Romania
JUSTICE
61. MARE Grigore BLOCUL NATIONAL SINDICAL Romania
62. MARIN Adrian CSDR Romania
63. McCABE Patrick SIPTU Ireland
64. MELLI Daniele ETUC Belgium
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
65. MIHAI Jadwiga Bogumila Poland
JUSTICE
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
66. MOLDOVAN Anca-Maria Romania
JUSTICE
CONSILUIUL PATRONATELOR
67. MURGULESCU Georgiana Romania
BANCARE DIN ROMANIA
6 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
MNISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
68. NACHEV Petar Bulgaria
POLICY
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
69. NICHITEANU Simona-Elena Romania
JUSTICE
MINISTRY OF LABOUR, SOCIAL
70. ONDRUŠ Branislav Slovakia
AFFAIRS AND FAMILY
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND PENSION
71. OPALIĆ Dražen Croatia
SYSTEM OF REPUBLIC OF CROATIA
MINISTRY OF LABOUR, EMPLOYMENT
72. OSWALD Tom AND THE SOCIAL AND SOLIDARITY Luxembourg
ECONOMY
73. PATA Irene UIL Italy
74. PÉREZ SÁNCHEZ Marcos José GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF LABOUR Spain
MNISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
75. PETROVA Sultanka Bulgaria
POLICY
MINISTRY OF LABOR AND SOCIAL
76. PÎRCĂLAB Adriana Romania
JUSTICE
77. POPE Iulian CNSLR-FRATIA Romania
MINISTRY OF LABOR AND SOCIAL
78. POPESCU Iuliana Romania
JUSTICE
7 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
79. POPESCU Nicolaie-Claudiu Romania
JUSTICE
THE COUNCIL OF BANKING
80. PREDA Bogdan Romania
EMPLOYERS IN ROMANIA
81. RADOI Ion ETF - ATU ROMANIA Romania
GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF
82. RIBEIRO Sandra EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR Portugal
RELATIONS
83. ROGALEWSKI Adam OPZZ Poland
84. RÖPKE Oliver EESC Belgium
85. ROPSA Diana LSAB Latvia
86. ROTARU Costin ANTENA 3 Romania
87. RUSU Sabin CSDR Romania
88. SCOLA Julian ETUC Belgium
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND SOCIAL
89. SLAVESCU Dumitru Romania
JUSTICE
8 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
90. SPILLER Sergio CISL Italy
91. STOICA Alin Bogdan CONCORDIA Romania
92. SZEWCZYK Robert NSZZ "SOLIDARNOŚĆ" Poland
93. TAGGER Jörg EUROPEAN COMMISSION Belgium
94. TOMEV Lyuben CITUB Bulgaria
95. TRAMPE Nils BUSINESSEUROPE Belgium
96. TRIFU Cristian MINISTRY OF LABOUR Romania
97. VANDE KEYBUS Lars ABVV-FGTB Belgium
98. VANDERVEKEN Filip ETUC Belgium
99. VELEANU Mercedes Ramona FGS FAMILIA Romania
100. VELICU Patricia Petra INDUSTRIALL EUROPE Belgium
101. VICENTE PERALTA Maria Cruz CCOO Spain
9 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
Last Name First Name Organisation Country
MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND PENSION
102. VIDIŠ Ivan Croatia
SYSTEM
103. VINSENTINI Luca ETUC Belgium
104. VLASCEANU Silvia ACUE Romania
105. WANSART Jean-François CGSLB Belgium
MINISTRY OF FAMILY, LABOUR AND
106. ZEBER Joanna Poland
SOCIAL POLICY OF POLAND
10 European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.org
With financial support of the European Commission
High Level Conference
A NEW START FOR COLLECTIVE BARGAINING IN EUROPE
Bucharest, 25 June 2019
REPORT ON KEY RESULTS AND MESSAGES
The High Level Conference ”A New Start for Collective Bargaining in Europe” took place in Bucharest on
Tuesday 25th June 2019. More than one hundred people attended the event, including European and
national social partners, representatives of sixteen European governments, the European Commission
and the ILO (list of participants in attachment).
The idea of the conference was to raise awareness among policy-makers of the importance of multi-
employer collective bargaining as a key tool to create a fairer, more inclusive and sustainable economy
across Europe, by addressing inequalities and achieving a fairer wage share in the economy, supporting
productivity and competitiveness, building a level playing field for companies and equal treatment for
workers, as well as functioning as a macroeconomic stabiliser.
The conference also aimed to discuss possible frameworks and tools to be established at EU and national
levels to build and/or strengthen well-functioning collective bargaining systems and support the
capacity of social partners to deliver well-coordinated and successful industrial relations, including
through exchange of country cases and best practices. To achieve these objectives, the conference was
structured in four panels.
The first panel shed light on the socio-economic benefits and outcomes of systems of multi-employer
collective bargaining. Arguments on the benefits of coordinated systems of multi-employer collective
bargaining were acknowledged by the stakeholders and provided a basis for the exchanges (see in
attachment the ETUC note “Multi-employer bargaining: good for economy, good for society”).
This panel also presented two models (the Italian and Belgian systems) which may represent a positive
benchmark and a source of inspiration for other countries. The recently reformed Italian system is
indeed an example of two-tier negotiating system which is largely self-regulated by social partners. The
coordinated system of Belgium is one of the most effective in increasing solidarity, tackling inequalities
and ensuring competitiveness.
The second panel analysed reasons and strategies of the trade union movement to revamp multi-
employer collective bargaining in countries where this has been dismantled in the past. The
presentations also showed benefits that the relaunch of collective bargaining may bring to the economic
sectors involved (in Ireland) as well as how this may help address current challenges as, for instance,
those related to the platform economy (in the United Kingdom).
The third session was focused on the current situation in two Eastern European countries. Romanian
social partners presented difficulties in collective negotiations and explained reasons and benefits
leading them to conclude the recent collective agreement in the banking sector. The Polish case put
under the spotlight the need for rebuilding sectoral collective bargaining and how this would help both
the economy and the labour market.
In the final session the stakeholders discussed their agendas and possible initiatives to reinforce, support
and promote multi-employer collective bargaining in Europe.
Discussions during the conference showed a broad consensus among all stakeholders about the need
to reinforce social dialogue and, in particular, collective bargaining at sectoral level, having the proper
implementation of the European Pillar of Social Rights and the ILO Convention 98 as a reference. In their
interventions, most EU member states and social partners representatives stressed that stronger
systems of collective bargaining are a key tool to achieve upward convergence of working and living
standards in Europe and to create a more inclusive and sustainable growth by:
- Promoting investment, productivity and quality jobs
- Fighting inequalities, and
- Managing technological and environmental transitions, through
- Fairer income, bargained wages and minimum wages in all the European countries.
Key messages from the conference show that there is a common understanding by all stakeholders on
the need for:
1. Analysing the positive effects of multi-employer collective bargaining on competitiveness,
productivity, equality, non-discrimination, inclusion, etcetera;
2. Exchanging best practices and benchmarks;
3. Supporting and reinforcing multi-employer collective bargaining;
4. Setting targets for wage developments linked to living costs and productivity;
5. Extending coverage of collective agreements in all sectors and for all categories of workers –
where needed, by introducing extension mechanisms, based on –
6. Reinforcing the representativeness of social partners and their autonomous capacity to regulate
the labour market;
7. Developing tools for transnational negotiations to build a level playing field for fair competition
between companies, in particular for big corporates/multinational enterprises and SMEs, and
within supply chains;
8. Guaranteeing the access of non-standard and self-employed workers to collective bargaining
rights, including through targeted interpretation of the competition laws;
9. Addressing the gender and age wage gaps;
10. Using the European Semester cycle, the European Pillar of Social Rights and the Multiannual
Financial Framework to enable governments and social partners to develop well-functioning
multi-employer collective bargaining;
11. Allocating dedicated EU and national funding for capacity building of social partners;
12. Fully implementing the ILO conventions and Council of Europe decisions on the right of access
to collective bargaining in all Member States – adopt at European level the ILO definition of
collective bargaining as a public good.
Most EU governments showed willingness to support actions to strengthen sectoral collective
bargaining under the umbrella of a European framework initiative as, for instance, a European
partnership, including considering legal tools (as a framework directive and/or a Council
recommendation).
Some countries also underlined the need to include targets and recommendations on minimum wages
in possible European frameworks. The German government announced its intention to set this as a
major priority for their Presidency in the second half of 2020.
The need to address the macroeconomic dimension of wage developments and the use of multi-
employer collective bargaining as a macroeconomic stabiliser was also discussed, as well as the need to
launch soon an initiative in the above-mentioned fields, steered by DG EMPL, the European social
partners and the Presidency Trio, which should involve the EPSCO Council, as well as DG ECFIN, the
ECOFIN Council and the Eurogroup.
The Tripartite Social Summit in October 2019 and the Macroeconomic Dialogue in November 2019 can
constitute intermediate steps for making progress in the discussion and implementation of such an
initiative.
***
Bucharest, 25 June 2019