Estonia-Latvia
Cross-Border Co-operation Programme
2014-2020
Project No: EST-LAT 137
Project name: SpectroScreen
Project Partners Name (LP/PP): Interspectrum OÜ (LP)
Fund: European Regional Development Fund
Target objective: SO 1.2 More jointly developed products and
services in the programme area.
Audit No: ELP-20/2022
Audit organisation: Ministry of Finance
Final audit report
01.06.2022
SUMMARY OF AUDIT RESULTS
Audit outcome:
Based on the audit work performed, the auditors have concluded the implementing project partner
Interspectrum OÜ has not taken competitive price offers in compliance with the Public Procurement Act
article 3.
Audit opinion1:
➢ significant findings
List of significant findings:
Audit Finding No. 4.1: Project lead partner has not carried out obligation to take competitive price offers
in compliance with the Public Procurement Act article 3. Detected ineligible amount in the audit scope
375,00 EUR and outside the audit scope 375,00 EUR.
The project audit has been carried out in compliance with the International Standards for the Professional Practice
of Internal Auditing.
We wish to thank the auditee for the assistance and cooperation provided during the audit.
We confirm that the final audit report consists of 11 pages.
1
Significant findings are those that have or may have a financial impact (i.e. ineligible expenditure). Non-significant findings are those that have no financial
impact but whose correction will help the beneficiary to lower risks while implementing the project.
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SUMMARY OF AUDIT RESULTS .............................................................................................................................. 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................................................ 3
PART A .................................................................................................................................................................. 4
1. AUDIT OBJECT AND AUDITED EXPENSES ..................................................................................................... 4
2. LIMITATIONS ......................................................................................................................................... 5
3. AUDIT FOLLOW-UP ACTIVITIES .................................................................................................................. 6
PART B .................................................................................................................................................................. 7
AUDIT FINDINGS ...................................................................................................................................... 7
3
PART A
1. Audit object and audited expenses
1.1 GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE AUDIT
Project name: Developing a remote breast cancer screening service based
on FTIR spectroscopy „SpectroScreen“
Project number: Est-Lat 137
Priority and target objective: SO 1.2 More jointly developed products and services in the
programme area.
Beneficiary (LP/PP): Interspectrum OÜ (LP)
Contact person: Teofilus Tõnnisson
Date of subsidy contract: 15.11.2019
Audit scope and period: Report 4.1, period 01.08.2020 – 30.11.2020, € 23 426.32
Report 5.1, period 01.12.2020 - 31.03.2021, € 22 545.36
Report 6.1, period 01.06.2020 - 30.09.2020, € 29 583.54
1.2 INFORMATION ABOUT THE AUDIT
Basis: - Article 127(1) of the Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 of the
European Parliament and of the Council of 17 December
2103
- Audit Authority’s work plan for 2022.
Objective: To provide an audit opinion that:
- the operation was selected in accordance with the
selection criteria for the operational programme;
- the expenditure declared to the Commission corresponds
to the accounting records and that the required
supporting documentation demonstrates an adequate
audit trail;
- for expenditure declared to the Commission, outputs and
results underpinning payments to the beneficiary have
been delivered.
Person(s) carrying out the audit: Katrin Vaher, Financial Control Department, Audit Unit I,
auditor
Kaisa Kallas, Financial Control Department, Audit Unit II, audit
supervisor
Audit duration: 09.03.2022 – 01.06.2022
Methodology: Audit manual of the Estonia-Latvia Programme
4
Audit procedures performed at the During the on-the-spot check, interviews were conducted with
beneficiary: the persons involved in project implementation and
analysis/evaluation was made of the following:
- project’s actual implementation,
- documentation related to project implementation,
- eligibility of costs,
- arrangement of book-keeping related to the project,
- existence of co-financing,
- use of the logos.
Sampling methodology (if applicable, then - Not applicable
information shall be provided by the AA ):
1.3 AUDITED EXPENSES
Total amount of certified expenses subject Report 4.1, period 01.08.2020 – 30.11.2020, € 23 426.32
to auditors’ opinion on the basis of cost
Report 5.1, period 01.12.2020 - 31.03.2021, € 22 545.36
documents:
Report 6.1, period 01.06.2020 - 30.09.2020, € 29 583.54
Size of the sample (EUR; %)2: € 75 555.22; 100%
Ineligible expenditure identified (EUR): Total ineligible expenditure identified (EUR), lead partner
Interspectrum OÜ €750.00, within the audit scope €375.00
National
EU Private sector
public Total
contribution contribution
contribution
Ineligible amount (EUR): 318.75 0.00 56.25 375.00
Ineligible amount outside the audit scope 318.75 0.00 56.25 375.00
(EUR):
Error rate (%)3: 0.50
2. Limitations
The audit procedures were carried out in compliance with internationally accepted auditing standards4 and the
audit report was prepared using the principles of independence and objectivity.
Auditors conclude that all data presented during the audit and other oral and written information made available
during the audit presents a true and fair view of the activities performed during the project implementation and are
2
If a sample was not used for auditing, the size of the sample is the total population in euros and the share of audited
expenses to total population is 100%.
3
Share of ineligible expenses to audited expenses (%). If a sample was used for auditing, the share of ineligible expenses to
the sample size shall be used.
4
The International Professional Practices Framework (IPPF) of the Institute of Internal Auditors.
5
sufficient to provide an opinion about the project. In case of additional information that was not provided or was
not known to auditors, the conclusions reached by auditors might have been different.
3. Audit follow-up activities
The beneficiary shall take into account the findings and recommendations made in Part B and the decisions made
by the MA. The AA shall monitor the implementation of recommendations made by the auditors.
6
PART B
AUDIT FINDINGS
1. Use of funding as intended
The funding has been used in material aspects in the intended manner, in a reasonable and efficient way and in
accordance with the objectives and requirements laid down in the subsidy contract and the programme manual.
2. Accuracy of book-keeping records
The book-keeping records for the project are in all material aspects in compliance with the current legislation.
3. Amount and timing of funding
The granting of funding has in all material aspects been made available in the amount foreseen and on time, and
the co-financing has been guaranteed.
4. Carrying out of public procurements
Auditors have identified non-compliances with the Estonian Public Procurement Act article 3 and one significant
finding has been formalized.
Significant finding no 4.1 – Project lead partner has not carried out obligation to take competitive
price offers in compliance with the Public Procurement Act article 3. Detected ineligible amount in
the audit scope 375,00 EUR and outside the audit scope 375,00 EUR.
According to the Cooperation Programme Interreg V-A — Estonia–Latvia Programme Manual point 5.5.2 all
Estonian project partners are obliged to take competitive price offers to purchases from 5000 euros (excluding
VAT) in accordance with Public Procurement Act (hereinafter referred to as PPA) article 3. Project lead partner
Interspectrum OÜ is a private limited company and therefore not a contracting authority or contracting entity of
public sector pursuant to § 5 of the PPA and is thus obliged to follow the principles stipulated in the PPA article 3.
Project lead partner Interspectrum OÜ has taken competitive price offers for finding project management
consulting and reporting services provider under application´s budget line “External expertise and services”, sub-
line “Project management support” with total expected cost as per application 20 000 EUR. The invitation to tender
was sent by e-mail on 07.08.2019 to 5 potential tenderers. When the first successful tenderer was submitted to the
ESTLAT Secretariat for approval, the Secretariat identified a potential conflict of interest between the successful
tenderer and the contracting authority. New invitation to tender with same conditions was sent to a new potential
tenderer, Seerav OÜ, on 06.11.2019, which submitted its tender the following day. The contract was awarded to
Seerav OÜ with a total contract amount of 20 300 EUR.
Auditors have identified the following non-compliance with the Estonian PPA article 3:
1. Disproportionate and discriminative evaluation criteria
PPA’s § 3 subsection 1 states that the contracting authority or the contracting entity acts transparently, verifiably
and proportionately upon carrying out public procurement;
7
PPA´s § 3 subsection 2 states that the contracting authority or the contracting entity treats all persons whose
place of residence or seat is in Estonia, in another Member State of the European Union, in another contracting
state of the European Economic Area or in a country that has joined the Government Procurement Agreement of
the World Trade Organization equally and the contracting authority or the contracting entity makes certain that all
restrictions and criteria imposed on the persons are proportional, relevant and reasoned in relation to the purpose
of the public procurement;
PPA´s § 3 subsection 3 states that the contracting authority or the contracting entity ensures effective use of
competition in public procurement, whereby the participation of a public legal person or a private legal person
using public funds in public procurement must not distort competition due to its use of public funds.
The evaluation criterias in Interspectrum OÜ´s (contracting authority) invitation to tender for finding project
management consulting and reporting services provider under applications budget line “External expertise and
services”, sub-line “Project management support” were:
1) Cost of the offer - share in value points: 55
2) Previous experience in reporting and managing EstLat projects - share in value points: 45
(Each previous EstLat project gives 15 points, maximum of 45 points can be awarded)
Contracting authority has commented that the reason for asking previous experience only with EstLat projects was
because each program has its own specifics, rules and reporting features. The procurement does not restrict
submission of tenders with different experience, i.e., this criteria is not set as a condition for qualification but as an
evaluation criteria, as an important aspect in making the final selection was knowledge of the specifics of the
EstLat program.
Auditor agrees that setting previous experience as one of the evaluation criteria is relevant but taking into account
PPA’s § 3 subsection 1, 2 and 3, the auditors find that the share in value points for evaluation criterion no 2 and the
exclusion of the experience in reporting and managing projects which are not financed or gained by the EstLat
programme (EST-RUS, CB, BSR, NOR-EMP, SF, SOLID etc.) is disproportionate, discriminative and does not ensure
real competition.
Tenderers without previous experience in reporting and managing EstLat projects should make an unreasonably
low-price offer in order to win the contract or all the tenderers with the previous experience should have
unreasonably high-price offers for that matter (for example – expected cost in the application for this budget line
was 20 000 EUR. If there is one tenderer with 3 previous EstLat experiences and one without any EstLat experience
and the experienced tenderer makes an offer in line with the expected cost - 20 000 EUR, the inexperienced
tenderer´s offer should be about 3200 EUR in order to win the contract).
Therefore, the evaluation criterion is non-compliant with § 3 subsection 1 of the PPA as regards to acting
proportionately upon carrying out public procurement; with subsection 2 as regards to the proportionality,
relevance and reasonableness of restrictions and criteria imposed on the persons in relation to the purpose of the
public procurement; with subsection 3 as regards to the effective use of competition in public procurement.
Due to the nature of the irregularity, it is not possible to precisely quantify the financial impact. Thus, the amount of
the correction to apply is based on flat rates. Annex 6. Guidelines to Financial Corrections point 2.3.2. financial
correction in case of irregularity related to non-compliance with the general rules on procurement when the
Estonian partner is not a contracting authority for the purposes of the public procurement. If Estonian beneficiary
or partner is not a contracting authority for the purposes of the public procurement and it has violated the
obligation to comply with the general principles of procurement, the support paid for the expenditure of the
contract shall be reduced by 10 percent. Depending on the severity of the violation, the financial correction rate of
up to 5, 25 or 100 percent may be applied.
8
Annex to the COMMISSION DECISION 14.5.2019 (C(2019) 3452 final) section 2 subsection 2.1 point 11: use of
criteria for exclusion, selection, award that are not discriminatory in the sense of the previous type of irregularity
but still restrict access for economic operators. Cases in which restrictive criteria/conditions/specifications were
applied but still a minimum level of competition was ensured, i.e., a number of economic operators submitted
tenders that were accepted and fulfilled the selection criteria, the rate of correction is 5%.
Since there were 4 tenderers altogether in Interspectrum OÜ´s procurement and all were verified as correspondent
to the evaluation criterias (one was eliminated due to a potential conflict of interest), a correction rate of 5%
applies.
Conclusion:
In auditors´ opinion the evaluation criteria no 2 is disproportionate and discriminative since it is not ensuring equal
competition for tenderers. According to the Annex 6. Guidelines to Financial Corrections point 2.3.2 and above-
mentioned Commission decision from 14.5.2019, the finding above will result in a financial correction of 5% of
eligible costs related to this contract.
1) Risk and recommendation to the auditee:
Risk: Failure by the beneficiary to comply with its legal obligations may lead to the partial or full recovery of the
grant.
Recommendation: Auditors recommend the beneficiary Interspectrum OÜ to reimburse 750,00 EUR EUR (incl.
375,00 EUR in the scope of the audit) for the identified ineligible ERDF costs and deduct 637,50 EUR (including
318,75 EUR in the scope of the audit) from the eligible co-financing of the project.
Comments of the beneficiary: Interspectrum OÜ ei nõustu võrreldavate pakkumuste võtmisega seotud auditi
seisukohaga, kuna:
1) riigihangete seaduse kohaselt võib hankija seada hindamiskriteeriumiks hankelepingu täitmises vahetult
osalevate isikute spetsiifilisele tõendatud töökorralduse, kvalifikatsiooni või kogemuse, millest otseselt sõltub
hankelepingu täitmise kvaliteet.
Hankelepingu täitmise kvaliteet sõltub igal juhul sellest, kas projektijuhil on olemas spetsiifilise programmi
projektijuhtimise kogemus.
2) ebaproportsionaalseks või konkurentsi piiravaks võiks pidada antud hindamiskriteeriumi, kui hankele ei oleks
laekunud võrreldavaid pakkumusi või enamuse pakkujate hindepunktide arv antud alakriteeriumis oleks olnud väga
madal või 0. Lõplik laekunud pakkumuste arv oli 4 ning kolmel pakkujal oli olemas varasem kogemus EstLat
projektide juhtimisel sellises mahus, et kõik said antud kriteeriumi all maksimumpunktid, seega sai eduka pakkuja
valikul määravaks mitte EstLat kogemus, vaid hind.
Eeltoodule tuginedes ei pea me põhjendatuks väidet, et tagatud ei ole piisavat konkurentsi ja eksitud on riigihangete
seaduse üldpõhimõtete vastu.
Auditors´ brief summary of the beneficiary's comments translated into English: Beneficiary does not agree with the
finding, stating that:
1) contracting authority may set specific evaluation criteria about work-management, qualification or experience to
the persons directly involved in the performance of the procurement contract and on which the quality of the
performance of the procurement contract directly depends on; and
9
2) evaluation criteria could be considered disproportionate or restricting to the competition in the absence of
comparable offers or if the number of points of the majority of tenderers in this sub-criterion had been very low or
0. But there were 4 offers altogether and 3 of them had previous experience in managing EstLat projects to such
an extent that everyone received maximum points under this criterion. Thus, the price (and not this evaluation
criteria) was decisive and the beneficiary does not agree that sufficient competition was not ensured and that the
general principles of the Public Procurement Act have been violated.
2) Risk and recommendation to the Managing Authority and Financial Control:
Risk: If the Managing Authority and/or Financial Control does not execute necessary checks on the beneficiary's
compliance, there is a risk that the grant will not be used legally and that the grant will have to be recovered in part
or in whole.
Recommendation: We recommend that the Managing Authority initiate the recovery process for ineligible costs
identified in the audit related to the above-mentioned procurement and apply financial correction of 5% of the
submitted costs of the procurement contract.
Comments of the Managing Authority and Financial Control:
Financial Control would like to bring out that earlier experience with the same programme is definitely helpful and
supportive in implementing agreement but agrees that the criteria is somewhat restrictive and does not provide a
significant advantage in fulfilling the contract.
By now Estonian Financial Control is more aware and will check the proportionality and suitability of the
procurement conditions in more detail.
Joint Secretariat recommended Interspectrum OÜ to follow the rules and take competitive offers. The experience
of the programmes is mentioned in the exchange of e-mails. The Joint Secretariat did not have the competence to
control the correctness of the tender procedure, thus they were not in the position to confirm the chosen offer.
However, Interspectrum OÜ was informed that for the financial controllers and auditors they would need to prove
that the prices of a service providers are comparable.
Managing Authority agrees with the Auditor that restrictive criteria have been used by Interspectrum OÜ. Managing
Authority will launch a process to make a financial correction decision and recover the ineligible amount.
The ineligible costs that are included to the partner report of Interspectrum OÜ and are in Financial Control for
management verification, will be deducted by the Financial Control. Managing Authority will take it into account
when making Financial correction decision.
Person responsible for implementation of the recommendation and date at the Managing Authority and Financial
Control: -
Final comment from the auditors:
The auditors maintain the position expressed in the audit finding. Auditee needed to comply with PPA article 3
when taking competitive price offers. Taking into account PPA’s § 3 subsection 1, 2 and 3, the auditors find that
the share in value points for evaluation criterion no 2 and the exclusion of the experience in reporting and
managing projects which are not financed or gained by the EstLat programme (EST-RUS, CB, BSR, NOR-EMP, SF,
SOLID etc.) is disproportionate, discriminative and does not ensure real competition.
10
5. Granting of state aid
The state aid has been granted to the project and used by the beneficiary in correct manner, in accordance with the
state aid rules.
6. Communication and publicity
When informing and disclosing the use of funding, the beneficiary has in all material aspects followed the current
legislation.
We confirm that the final audit report has 11 pages.
Audit manager: Audit supervisor:
(Signed electronically) (Signed electronically)
Katrin Vaher Kaisa Kallas
Auditor of Audit Unit I Head of Audit Unit II
Financial Control Department Financial Control Department
Tallinn, 01.06.2022
11
Teofilus Tõnnisson
Interspectrum OÜ Meie 01.06.2022 nr 10-5/4793-1
[email protected]
Auditi lõpparuande edastamine
Austatud härra Tõnnisson
Edastame Teile projekti nr EST-LAT 137 „SpectroScreen“ auditi lõpparuande nr ELP-20/2022.
Auditi eesmärk oli anda hinnang struktuuritoetuse kasutamisele Vabariigi Valitsuse 7. augusti
2014. a määruse nr 127 „Perioodi 2014-2020 struktuuritoetuse andmise ja kasutamise
auditeerimine” § 4 lõike 1 järgi.
Täname Teid meeldiva koostöö ja osutatud abi eest.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kaur Siruli
Finantskontrolli osakonna juhataja
Auditeeriva asutuse juht
Lisa:
Auditi lõpparuanne (11 lehel)
Teadmiseks:
Pr Ege Ello, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]);
Pr Imbi Uusjärv, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]);
Hr Martin Karro, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]);
Hr Urmo Merila, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]);
Pr Karin Viikmaa, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]).
Katrin Vaher 611 3113
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272