ESTONIAN
MARITIME
SPATIAL PLAN
Maritime spatial planning is a tool for the long-term
planning of the use of the sea in order to ensure economic
benefits resulting from the exploitation of marine
resources as well as the value of the sea and coastal areas
as socially and culturally important areas.
Upon maritime spatial planning, it has to be kept in mind
that any human activity is based on the achievement and
maintenance of the good status of the marine
environment.
2021
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................... 3
2. STARTING POINTS .................................................................................................................. 4
3. MARINE AREA TRENDS, VISION AND PRINCIPLES FOR SPATIAL DEVELOPMENT .................. 7
4. METHODOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK......................................................................................... 9
4.1 A broad-based planning process ..................................................................................... 9
4.2 Taking into account the results of impact assessment ................................................. 10
4.3 Superficies license applications in the marine area ...................................................... 15
4.4 MSPs for the marine areas bordering with Hiiu and Pärnu counties ............................ 16
5. USE OF THE MARINE AREA .................................................................................................. 17
5.1 Principles of combined use of the marine area............................................................. 17
5.2 Fisheries ......................................................................................................................... 21
5.3 Aquaculture ................................................................................................................... 23
5.3.1 Fish farming ............................................................................................................ 23
5.3.2 Shellfish and algae farming .................................................................................... 26
5.4 Maritime transport ........................................................................................................ 31
5.4.1 Vessel traffic ........................................................................................................... 31
5.4.2 Ports ....................................................................................................................... 33
5.4.3 Ice roads ................................................................................................................. 34
5.4.4 Maritime transport guidelines and conditions....................................................... 34
5.5 Maritime rescue, pollution response and guarding the state border ........................... 36
5.6 Renewable energy production ...................................................................................... 39
5.6.1 Guidelines for renewable energy production ........................................................ 39
5.6.2 Starting points for wind energy development ....................................................... 40
5.6.3 Establishment of suitable areas for wind energy development ............................ 41
5.6.4 Areas suitable for wind energy development ........................................................ 51
5.6.5 Wind energy development guidelines and conditions ........................................... 52
5.6.6 Cable corridors from wind energy development areas to land ............................. 60
5.7 Seabed infrastructure .................................................................................................... 64
5.8 Sea tourism and recreation ........................................................................................... 66
5.9 Protected natural objects .............................................................................................. 67
5.10 Marine culture ............................................................................................................. 70
5.11 Cultural monuments.................................................................................................... 71
5.12 National defense ......................................................................................................... 73
5.13 Mineral resources ........................................................................................................ 75
5.14 Dumping ...................................................................................................................... 76
5.15 Permanent Connections .............................................................................................. 77
5.16 Land-sea interactions .................................................................................................. 78
5.17 Refinement of the national plan "Estonia 2030+" ...................................................... 83
6. DEFINITIONS ........................................................................................................................ 84
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
3
1. INTRODUCTION
The aim of the Maritime Spatial Plan (MSP) is to agree on the long-term principles of
the use of the Estonian marine area in order to attain and maintain a good status of the
marine environment and to promote the maritime economy. The plan identified the
areas and conditions under which activities in the marine area could be carried out.
During the preparation of the MSP, the synergies between the existing marine uses and
the planned activities were considered. Assessment of their impact on the marine
environment and the economy and the social and cultural impact of the activities was
also carried out. The results of the impact assessment are reflected in the memorandum,
(Summary Chapter 4.2), and a separate Impact Assessment Report has been prepared.
The adopted MSP serves as a basis for decision-making by various ministries and
agencies and also guides the activities of businesses, investors, local governments, and
coastal communities. The MSP must be taken into account in the preparation of
subsequent plans, in the admission of permits for different uses and in composing of
national and local government's strategic development documents.
This document is the explanatory memorandum of the MSP. The memorandum
explains the development of the solution (Chapters 2, 4), outlines the future trends,
vision and spatial development principles of the marine area (Chapter 3) and provides
guidelines and conditions for the future use of the marine area (Chapter 5). The
memorandum provides general principles for the development of combined use in the
Estonian marine area (Chapter 5.1) and explanations of terms used in the planning
(Chapter 6). The spatial data of the MSP is reflected in the map application available
on the website of the Ministry of Finance1. An action plan for the implementation of
the MSP is attached as a separate annex.
1
https://www.fin.ee/riik-ja-omavalitsused-planeeringud/ruumiline-planeerimine/mereala-planeering
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
4
2. STARTING POINTS
The Estonian MSP was drafted on the basis of both European and Estonian framework
documents and substantive planning guidelines (see spatial layout 2.1). Directive
2014/89/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a framework
for the MSP sets out the need to draw up a plan for the management of the intensified
use of the marine area. The main principles for the use and protection of the sea are
derived from the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
Achieving and preserving good environmental status of the marine environment is a
cross-cutting principle stemming from both UNCLOS and the Convention on
Biological Diversity, as well as from a number of EU legal instruments (in particular
the Marine Strategy Framework Directive and the EU Strategy for the Baltic Sea
Region).
In the Estonian legal space, the Planning Act, which entered into force on 01.07.2015,
provides guidance for the preparation of the MPS. Effective and sustainable use of the
marine area and Estonia's openness to the sea are emphasized in the national plan
"Estonia 2030+" established by the Government of the Republic Order No. 368 on 30
August 2012. Marine use will also be guided in the long term by the strategic goals,
reforms, and key activities of the country, which will be determined by the “Estonia
2035+” strategy.
Maritime spatial planning is being conducted simultaneously in many countries around
the world. The long-term use of the marine area in the European Union is based on the
Integrated Maritime Policy (IMP) and its development program2 along with guidelines
such as the Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the
Council, the European Economic and Social Committee, and the Committee of the
Regions Blue Growth opportunities for marine and maritime sustainable growth3.
Common principles4 and guidelines for the implementation of an ecosystem-based
approach5 have been developed for comprehensive and well-considered planning of the
Baltic Sea. As the Estonian representative, the Ministry of Finance regularly
participates in the work of the European Commission and HELCOM-VASAB
Maritime Spatial Planning Working Groups. The principles agreed in 2010 will
contribute to the achievement of good environmental status in the Baltic Sea and thus
enable the use of ecosystem services provided by the sea.
2
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/ET/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:L:2011:321:FULL&from=EN
3
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:52012DC0494
4
http://www.helcom.fi/action-areas/maritime-spatial-planning/msp-principles
5
http://www.helcom.fi/action-areas/maritime-spatial-planning/msp-guidelines/
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
5
Spatial layout 2.1 Starting points for Estonian MSP
The Estonian MSP covers the entire Estonian marine space: the internal waters, the
territorial sea, and the exclusive economic zone (see spatial layout 2.2). In the MSP,
land area is defined through the functional interactions (so-called land-sea interactions)
(see Chapter 5.16)6. In order to ensure the implementation of maritime spatial planning,
it provides general guidelines for terrestrial planning, for the national designated spatial
plan, comprehensive and designated spatial plans for local governments, and for
detailed spatial plans, as well as for decision-making related to marine uses.
6
Land-sea interactions here and hereafter refer to activities that are performed at sea or on land, but
which support land or sea activities, respectively. For example, fishing requires a land-based fishing port
or landing place; in order to organize rescue at sea, land access to the sea must be guaranteed, and ports
are essential for sea transport.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
6
Spatial layout 2.2. Estonian marine space as an MSP area
The Estonian MSP is a strategic spatial development document on the national level,
which plans the basic developments in marine space for the next 15 years or so.
Therefore, the plan focuses on the principles of spatial development, and the activities
are not planned on a detailed scale. The plan provides guidelines7 and states conditions8
for the next stages of planning the activities, including at the local government level.
The planning solution was drafted on the basis of environmental considerations and the
best available knowledge.9 The inclusion of the best available knowledge is ensured by
a broad-based expert group, cooperation with other countries, authorities and
stakeholders, and further studies appropriate to the planning level.
As in many traditional uses (e.g., fishing, maritime transport), the rules of marine uses
have predominantly been established; the plan focuses more on the combined use of
the marine area and new uses of the sea. Guidelines are provided for all areas of activity
to accommodate all different uses in the marine space.
For a more detailed description of the starting points for the MSP, including references
to relevant documents guiding sectoral developments, see the Initial Outline for the
Estonian MSP and the Memorandum of Intention to Conduct an Impact Assessment.
7
Guidelines: general guidance from the plan, the following of which is desirable and based on the long-
term vision of the marine area and the needs for combined use. Compliance with the guideline will be
monitored by the authority responsible for the area. Deviations from the guideline must be made in
collaboration with other involved or affected parties to ensure the full implementation of the planning
solution.
8
Condition - a requirement set by the plan, compliance with which is mandatory.
9
The approach is based on EU Directive 2014/89/EU establishing a framework for the MSP, see also
Planning Impact Assessment Report, Chapter 2.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
7
3. MARINE AREA TRENDS, VISION AND
PRINCIPLES FOR SPATIAL
DEVELOPMENT
The Estonian marine area is characterized by the following long-term trends:
1. Use of marine area intensifies.
2. Improving the status of the marine environment requires close attention by all
Baltic Sea countries.
3. New uses are emerging: renewable energy, aquaculture, infrastructure
networks.
4. Traditional uses of the sea are diversifying. Potential permanent connections
will be affecting passenger traffic. Recreational fishing and sailing are
growing. The fishing sector is not an important employer, but it is an industry
that values local resources. Recreational use is going to be more versatile.
Following an ecosystem-based approach, planning was based on marine area risk
factors and cumulative impacts.10
The most significant negative anthropogenic impacts on the Baltic Sea are
eutrophication, chemical pollution, overfishing of marine biological resources, and the
spread of alien species. Particularly sensitive areas of the Baltic Sea are closed or
shallow areas with limited water exchange. Climate change considerations can have a
major impact. Poor environmental status can have significant negative economic
impact on, for example, the maritime tourism-related economic sector, fisheries and
aquaculture, and can lead to deterioration of human health and well-being.
The long-term vision of the Estonian marine area is:
The Estonian marine area has good environmental status, diverse and balanced use,
and promotes the sustainable growth of a blue11 economy.
10
Guideline for the implementation of ecosystem-based approach in MSP in the Baltic Sea area
11
Blue economy, including blue growth - sustainable maritime economy, covering all areas related to
the sea: tourism, renewable energies, aquaculture, fisheries, biotechnology, use of seabed mineral
resources, etc.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
8
To achieve this vision, all traditional and new activities in the Estonian marine area
must be based on an ecosystem-based approach (see also Chapter 4.1) and follow the
following spatial development principles:
1. The Estonian marine area is characterized by synergistic combined use.
2. The use of the marine area must be diversified, favoring activities that are
more suited to the region.
3. The marine area is used as a public good, including through ecosystem
services.
4. Marine area related decisions are knowledge-based.
5. Cooperation and communication between states, authorities and stakeholders
in decision-making on the use of the marine area takes place.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
9
4. METHODOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK
4.1 A broad-based planning process
The development of the MSP was based on the generalized spatial layout below.
Spatial layout 4.1. Methodological framework of Estonian MSP
The methodological approach to planning is characterized by an ecosystem-based
approach (see Chapter 2.1 of the Planning Impact Assessment Report for more details),
which emphasizes the functioning of ecosystems and values broad-based expertise in
both the know-how and interests involved.12 In addition to the starting points described
in the previous chapter, the solution was developed based on various baseline studies13
and marine values mapped in the public discussions that took place in the coastal
counties in June 2018. Values and interests, as well as existing usage and new
directions, were brought together in a draft solution that was discussed with
stakeholders and impact assessment experts. During the draft phase, issues related to
the combined use of the marine area were also discussed (see Chapter 5.1). The
maximum possible positive synergies have been sought in the design of combined use
of the marine area. In the occurrence of conflicts and significant adverse impacts, an
attempt was made to avoid overlapping incompatible uses. As a result of the
discussions, the planning solution was refined. The solution was also updated based on
the results of the impact assessment (see Chapter 4.2).
A detailed overview of the cooperation with authorities, stakeholders, and the public in
the preparation of the plan and impact assessment is provided in Annex 3.
12
see Helcom-Vasab guidelines for using an ecosystem-based approach in MSP.
13
see http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/uuringud.html
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
10
4.2 Taking into account the results of impact assessment
Impact assessment of the MSP has gone hand in hand with the development of a
planning solution. As a result, most of the planning guidelines and conditions were
formulated, taking into account impact assessment considerations, already at the draft
plan stage. After the draft was made public, the planning solution was updated, some
baseline studies and a main solution were completed. Further proposals were made by
the Impact Assessment Task Group on a comprehensive review of the main planning
solution. Proposals were considered by the planners, and team experts were further
consulted as necessary. The following table gives an overview of the main proposals
that have been made during the impact assessment and how they have been taken into
account.
Table 4.2.1 Overview of how the proposals made in the impact assessment have been
taken into account in the planning
Impact Assessment proposal Taking account of the proposal
1. Take account of ice conditions: The proposals were accepted, guideline
1. In view of the formation of ice cover No 4 in Chapter 5.6.6, guideline No 3 in
and the movement of hummocked ice, Chapter 5.7, condition No 13e in
it is essential to protect the planned Chapter 5.3.1 and condition No 10c in
submarine cables in the shallow Chapter 5.3.2 were supplemented. The
coastal zone so that the ice cannot subject was already reflected in Chapter
break the cable. 5.6.5, condition 12(h).
2. The design of facilities (type of wind
turbine, fish farms, etc.) proposed in
the marine area at the level of the
licensing procedure must take into
account the risk of ice conditions to
ensure that the facilities are resilient
to impacts.
3. At the level of the licensing procedure
for the proposed activities, an
assessment must be made of how the
proposed activity, in combination
with other similar developments, will
affect changes in the ice cover and the
movement of sea ice. Also, the impact
of the activities related to the ice
breakingactivities during the period
of ice occurrence.
2. Take into account spawning grounds for fish The proposals were accepted, and the
and benthic biota; include the obligation to planning solution improved:
carry out a more detailed assessment and - Guideline No 2 was added to
study of the impact (both during the Chapter 5.2 Fisheries, outlining a
construction and dismantling phase) on fish map of sensitive areas.
fauna at the level of the superficies license, - Guideline No 3 was added to
incl to the migration of fish. In order to Chapter 5.3.1 Fish farming,
mitigate impacts during construction, it is Sensitive areas for
necessary to set a condition that noisy fisheries/Potential spawning areas
activities (e.g. installation of wind turbine up to 5 m depth were added in the
foundations) are not to take place during the spatial layout of areas unsuitable for
fish spawning season and in the fish spawning fish farming.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
11
area, when large numbers of fish are - In Chapter 5.6.4 Wind Energy
concentrated in a limited area. Guidelines and Conditions, the
condition 12 c was supplemented.
3. Address the issue of biosecurity in fish The proposal was accepted, condition
farming. 13c was added to Chapter 5.3.1 Fish
farming.
4. Reduce wind energy development area No 1 The proposal was accepted, and wind
in and around the migratory bird corridor, energy development area No 1 was
remove area No 3. reduced and area No 3 was removed.
5. Supplement the conditions for wind energy on The proposals were accepted, condition
the basis of the expert assessment by the 12 e of Chapter 5.6.5 Guidelines and
Estonian Ornithological Society from 2021: conditions for wind energy was
a. to provide that the minimum height of supplemented.
the wind turbine rotor above sea level
shall be 25 metres, subject to the
ancillary condition that this can be
specified (increased to 30 or 35
metres if necessary) on the basis of a
study to be carried out during the
licensing procedure.
b. At the stage of the licensing
procedures of Area No 1 suitable for
wind energy development in the Gulf
of Riga, clarify the actual width of the
migratory flow of terrestrial birds
near the eastern part of the
development area along the Kihnu-
Ruhnu axis and identify other
information necessary for the
assessment of the risk of collision. Set
a condition that a radar survey
covering at least two years’ bird
migration periods shall be carried out
in parallel with visual examinations.
c. For Area No 2, west of Saaremaa,
suitable for wind energy
development, specify what proportion
of all migrating terrestrial birds do not
use the main migration route. Set a
condition that a radar survey of birds
covering at least two years’ migration
periods must be carried out in parallel
with visual examinations.
d. In the case of Area No 2, west of
Saaremaa, suitable for wind energy
development, taking into account the
principle of combined use of marine
areas, the principle passage corridor
for shipping traffic should be
specified, where possible, to better
coincide with the expected
predominant migration pattern of
birds.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
12
6. In the context of the licensing procedure, the The proposal was accepted, condition
impacts will need to be clarified with the 12 f of Chapter 5.6.5 was
involvement of the necessary expertise and, if supplemented.
necessary, studies will need to be carried out
in the marine area to be developed prior to the
construction of the wind farm and, if
necessary, mitigation measures will need to be
implemented. Monitoring of bats should
continue during construction and operation of
the wind farm.
7. The choice of different types of foundations The proposal was accepted, condition
and technologies for wind turbines must take 12(c) of Chapter 5.6.5 was
into account and assess the environmental supplemented.
impact on the seabed and its biota during
construction and dismantling.
8. Consider additional guidelines to mitigate the The proposals were accepted, Chapter
visual impacts of wind energy development: 5.6.5 Guidelines and conditions for
a. Explore the possibility of leaving/creating wind energy was supplemented.
an area free of wind turbines in wind
energy development area No. 2 looking
from the three coastal sections of the west
coast of Saaremaa, as well as in
development area No. 1, looking from the
northern tip of Ruhnu.
b. for the wind farms closest to the coast
(11.1 km), indicate that the design of wind
farms of the same height is preferable.
c. avoid the formation of small clusters of
wind turbines on the periphery of the wind
farm, which appear as isolated clusters
from the main row of wind turbines.
d. in the development of wind farms by
different developers, it is recommended to
use, wherever possible, regular formations
to reduce the visual impact of the wind
turbines. Creating a wheel effect should
also be avoided, where possible.
e. it is recommended that the need to take
into account the synergies of wind farms
is more explicitly stated in the planning.
f. it is desirable to make it more explicit in
the planning that the visual impact
assessment should be carried out
methodologically, in accordance with
generally accepted developed guidance
material and by a specialist.
Visualisations must be truthful and
verifiable.
9. Recommendation: As a result of the Natura The proposal was accepted. The
assessment, plan the locations of the marine locations of the principle cable
cables in the new proposed corridors to connection corridors were specified
exclude impacts on Natura 2000 sites and their based on the results of the impact
protection objectives. assessment. In the development of wind
farms during the superficies license
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
13
phase, an alternative location for cable
installation may be found, provided that
it does not have a significant adverse
effect on wildlife and adverse impacts
on Natura 2000 sites and their
conservation objectives. The
establishment of a cable corridor at an
alternative location does not require a
new plan to be carried out, provided
that the conditions set out in this plan
are complied with and significant
impacts on protected natural objects,
including Natura 2000 sites, are
avoided (Chapter 5.6.6, condition 2).
10. Proposals resulting from impact on nature were taken into account when clarifying the
wording of the conditions of the permit procedure phase. The wording of the wind
energy and aquaculture development conditions were improved to minimise impacts on
fish, birds and bats and benthic fauna.
11. Consider including a condition in the MSP, The proposal was not taken into
which also takes into account the interest of account. The conditions already
fishermen in applying for aquaculture contained in the planning solution
permits: the most used and yielding fisheries adequately protect the interests of the
would not be adversely affected. Consider fishing sector, and it is not considered
including a condition requiring fishermen and appropriate to impose additional
local authorities to be involved in decision- conditions on the well-being of a
making processes in order to increase specific group of marine users.
synergies and prevent/mitigate conflicts in Stakeholders may be involved in the
aquaculture development. permit application process.
12. Further consider balancing the interests of the The proposal was not taken into
developer-current user and the developer- account. The introduction of additional
local government in terms of the permitting balancing mechanisms in the plan is not
procedure, including the consideration of considered appropriate as the permit
possible local benefit mechanisms in the procedure already allows for additional
planning. conditions to be imposed. On the basis
of the proposal, the action plan for the
implementation of the MSP was
supplemented, including the need to
develop local benefit mechanisms. For
wind energy development areas, the
obligation to involve the local
government was imposed on the visual
impact assessment (Chapter 5.6.5).
13. Consider allowing for the combined use of The proposal was already included in
wind farms and fish farms. the planning solution, and was also
highlighted in the chapter on fish
farms (see Chapters 5.3.1 and 5.6.5 ).
14. Consider the principle of enabling the The proposal was partially taken into
combined use of aquaculture farms with account. In the absence of specific
renewable energy (e.g., solar and wave solutions and regulations at present, a
energy). reference to the general possible
direction of development was added to
Chapter 5.6.1.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
14
15. Consideration should also be given in the The proposal was not taken into
functional classification of the purpose of new account. It was not considered
marine use service vessels - the needs of new necessary to include the purpose of the
branches in ports may differ slightly from new marine use service vessels in the
those of established ones. functional classification of the ports as
they are not so specific vessels.
16. Consider adding a condition for wind farm The proposal was accepted. The need
cable corridors that requires cooperation with for co-operation with the National
the National Heritage Board (to avoid Heritage Board and the Ministry of
damaging seabed cultural assets) and the Defense on the introduction of cabling
Ministry of Defense (to identify potential was included in the planning (Chapters
historical explosives and hazardous objects). 5.6.6 and 5.7).
17. Consider highlighting in the memorandum the The proposal was already in the plan.
importance of an international electric grid The development of the energy
corridor that promotes the development of network is described in Chapter 5.6.6.
wind farms and/or indicate the need for Known trends are reflected in spatial
direction in a spatial layout of possible cable layout No 5.6.6.1. In the spatial layout,
connections. the innovation area was connected to
the Ventspils-Hall basic passage
corridor.
18. Consider encouraging the development of On the basis of the proposal, the
local small-scale distributed energy solutions guidelines in section 5.6.1 were
(individual wind turbines, etc.). clarified. Precise solutions were not
proposed in the current MSP because of
the cost and complexity of local
solutions at sea in the short term.
19. Consider treating seabed cultural assets as a The proposal was not taken into
single chapter and include both cultural account. Merging the chapters was not
monuments and unprotected wrecks. considered useful, as the National
Heritage Board has previously
requested information on national
cultural monuments as a separate
chapter. Maritime culture is concerned
with wider activities, cultural assets are
part of this and are covered as specific
objects.
20. Consider the need to improve conditions for The proposal was not taken into
the use of mineral resources in terms of other account. The inclusion of additional
potential interests (including threats) (e.g., conditions was not considered
need for cooperation with the Ministry of necessary as the existing legislation
Defense on historic explosives, etc.). sufficiently regulates this area.
21. Consider supplementing the memorandum The proposal was accepted. Regional
with the introduction of more location-based location-based land-sea interactions are
land-sea interactions. included in Chapter 5.16 in the form of
a spatial layout.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
15
4.3 Superficies license applications in the marine area
Several superficies license applications have been submitted in the area covered by the
MSP. The MSP was initiated by the Government of the Republic by Order No 157 on
25.05.2017. An Act to Implement the Building Code and the Planning Act (AIBCPA)
provides for processing the special regulation for the applications for superficies
licenses submitted before the entry into force of the Act, i.e., before 01.07.2015,
providing that an application for a superficies license application submitted before the
entry into force of the Act shall be processed in accordance with the legislation in force
at the time of application.
Requirements for the procedure of superficies license (incl. initiation) are provided by
the Water Act. The Water Act currently in force provides that initiation of a superficies
license procedure shall be refused, inter alia, if planning has been initiated in the area
applied for, and the planning procedure has not been completed (§ 221 (2) 2). The
foregoing does not apply if the applicant for the superficies license agrees that the
superficies license shall be granted for a term of one year after the establishment of the
plan.
Several applications for a superficies license have been submitted before the
commencement of the planning. The Water Act currently in force does not apply to
them. Taking into account the provisions of the AIBCPA, the provisions of the Water
Act applicable at the time of submitting the applications must be followed. The Water
Act, which was in force until 30.06.2015, provided that initiation of the superficies
license procedure shall be refused if county planning has been initiated in the requested
area, and the planning procedure has not been completed. Thus, the ground for refusal
to initiate proceedings in respect of the application for a superficies license submitted
before 01.07.2015 is the fact that county planning has been initiated in the area, and its
preparation has not been completed. The establishment of the MSP does not affect the
initiation of the procedure for the superficies licenses. Similarly, the decision to grant
superficies licenses on the basis of applications for superficies license submitted before
01.07.2015 shall be based on the legal regulation in force at the time of submitting the
applications. The said regulation, i.e., the Water Act which was in force until
30.06.2015, provided that the superficies licenses shall not be issued if the conditions
of the superficies license applied for are in conflict with the valid county-wide spatial
plan – the regulation in force at that time did not provide for contradiction with the
MSP.
Thus, the processing, including decisions of applications for a superficies license
submitted before 01.07.2015, shall be carried out in accordance with the requirements
provided by the legislation in force at the time of submitting the superficies license, in
particular in the Water Act. They have no relation to the MSP, i.e., in their proceedings,
there is no need to consider what is planned in the MSP. However, in order to achieve
a balanced spatial design and good environmental status, it is desirable to follow the
principles, conditions and guidelines set out in the maritime spatial plan. In the
processing and deciding on applications for superficies licenses submitted after
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
16
01.07.2015, the principles, guidelines, and conditions set out in the MSP shall be taken
into account. There is also a difference with regard to applications that were submitted
after 01.07.2015, but the initiation of which was decided on before 25.05.2017, i.e.,
before the launch of the MSP. In these cases, the initiation of the procedure could not
be refused on the ground that the planning on the site had been initiated, and the
planning procedure had not been completed. However, when deciding on granting the
superficies license, the provisions of the MSP must be taken into account if the
maritime plan has already been established at the time of the decision.
4.4 MSPs for the marine areas bordering with Hiiu and
Pärnu counties
The Estonian MSP was drawn up on the basis of the experience of drafting the MSPs
for the marine areas of Hiiu and Pärnu counties. The solution of the spatial plans of the
marine areas of Hiiu and Pärnu counties have been taken into account in the
development of this solution and in the impact assessment. Because of the different
preparation times and degrees of accuracy of the plans, there are differences in the
output data. As a result, the approaches to the topics are partly different. For example,
a more detailed methodology for dealing with water traffic areas has been developed
for this solution in cooperation with the Transport Administration. Therefore, the
spatial information related to the MSP for Hiiu and Pärnu counties and to the water
traffic covered in this solution does not coincide. The existence of differences does not
mean that the plans are in material contradiction or their implementation is impeded.
All plans have been prepared in collaboration with the relevant authorities, and they
reflect the best available information at a given point in time. Continued inter-agency
cooperation is a prerequisite for a more comprehensive implementation of the plans.
The MSP for Hiiu and Pärnu counties remains in force upon the establishment of the
National Maritime Spatial Plan. The Supreme Court ruling of August 8, 2018, annulled
the Hiiu Island MSP for wind energy development areas (Case 3-16-1472). For other
topics discussed, Hiiu Island MSP is valid. The implementation shall take into account
the provisions of the corresponding MSP.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
17
5. USE OF THE MARINE AREA
5.1 Principles of combined use of the marine area
The increasingly diverse use of the marine area necessitates accommodating a variety
of activities into the marine space. Facilitating combined use reduces spatial pressure
on the marine area. The aim is to share and sustainably exploit the sea as a resource and
to enhance the positive synergies between different uses. As a result, the general
guideline of this plan is to promote the combined use of the marine area wherever
possible.
Combined use means the conscious joint use of the marine area within a single marine
space, in geographical proximity. The term covers both the location of activities in the
same sea area and the use of the same infrastructure.
The combined use of the marine area marks a turning point in the current way in which
the sea is used. European guidance documents14 emphasize that the deployment of
combined use requires efforts from all parties involved (see spatial layout 5.1.1). The
Estonian MSP is the first step in promoting combined use, the development activities
of the combined use have been included in the action plan for the implementation of
the MSP.
14
vt https://www.msp-platform.eu/practices/ocean-multi-use-action-plan
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
18
Spatial layout 5.1.1 Recommendations and obstacles to the development of combined
use of the marine area, based on the European Commission’s MUSES project Ocean
Multi-Use Action Plan
A pan-European approach15 has been taken to promote the following combined uses of
the marine area:
1) Tourism, fisheries and environmental protection
The so-called fishing tourism, where tourists are introduced to fishing traditions
on fishing boat trips. It provides additional income opportunities for fishermen
and helps to promote an environmentally friendly attitude to fish stocks. Well
developed, especially in southern Europe.
2) Tourism, underwater archaeological heritage, and protection of the environment
Wreck visit for divers, which also introduces the marine ecosystem. It creates
an additional source of support for heritage conservation and raises awareness.
Widespread in the Baltic Sea and eastern Atlantic.
3) Tourism and aquaculture
Boat trips, snorkelling, and diving near or in the immediate vicinity of
aquaculture infrastructure. Provides an alternative source of income for
aquaculture, raises awareness of local aquaculture products, and increases the
tolerance needed to develop aquaculture. Currently operating on a small scale,
predominantly in the Mediterranean and the Atlantic Ocean, popular in Malta
and Portugal.
4) Wind energy and tourism
Visits to offshore wind farms (unique wind turbine patterns can be an
attraction), observation platforms built on wind turbines (rookeries for seals,
resting place for divers, a restaurant). Helps mitigate resistance and provides
economic benefits to nearby areas through additional attractions. Examples are
found in the North Sea and the Baltic Sea.
5) Wind Energy and Fisheries
Effective space sharing (setting conditions for fishing near wind turbines),
sharing labor, and watercraft. Providing an alternative source of income for
fishermen, e.g., for monitoring purposes, and relieves the conflict between the
so-called New and Old Worlds. Examples from England, the Netherlands, and
Denmark (fishing allowed between wind turbines).
6) Wind energy and aquaculture
Use of wind turbine structures for fastening aquaculture infrastructure, or to
develop new infrastructure solutions. Use of wind turbine areas for fish and/or
shellfish farming that allows saving costs and directing farms deeper into the
sea. There are only a few examples yet.
The first six combinations are also suitable for the Estonian marine area. However, the
interactions of some uses may require concessions in development plans or significant
changes in existing uses (e.g. wind energy and fisheries). The following combined uses
do not directly fit into the Estonian marine area due to the nature of our sea, the
15
European Commission MUSES project Ocean Multi-Use Action Plan, see https://www.msp-
platform.eu/practices/ocean-multi-use-action-plan
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
19
resources used, and the state of the infrastructure, but they show potential for combined
use elsewhere.
7) Recycling of oil and gas platforms
Alternative (partial) reuse of disused platforms – artificial reefs; LNG
platforms, aquaculture, or renewable energy infrastructure, that enables cost
savings and sustainable use of the marine space with human impact. There are
currently no examples, but development projects for oil and gas platforms in the
North Sea and the Adriatic Sea have been prepared.
8) Wave energy and aquaculture
Development of aquaculture farms and wave energy infrastructure physically
linked or in the immediate vicinity, allowing direct use of wave energy on the
farm – reduces associated costs. The first examples are based in Scotland.
9) Wind energy and wave and tidal energy
Creation of a single renewable energy infrastructure in the form of specific
physical platforms that can be used by different types of energy. Enables
production of maximum energy per nautical mile, reducing installation and
maintenance costs, and alleviates conflict between different stakeholders. The
first development projects are underway in Scotland.
.
All marine uses have their own character. Some uses of the sea are limited to a specific
location; others cover the entire marine area; some uses exclude other uses, some work
better with others (see spatial layout 5.1.2). The feasibility of combined use is further
specified in the following chapters by the guidelines and conditions for the uses of the
marine area. The combined use of the marine area is reflected in the planning solution
in the spatial overlap between different uses (see spatial layout 5.1.3).
Spatial layout 5.1.2 Examples of interrelationships between different uses
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum 20
Spatial layout 5.1.3. Planning solution. The combined use of the marine area.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
21
5.2 Fisheries
Fishing takes place throughout the Estonian marine area, except in areas with statutory
fishing restrictions. Areas that are more heavily used for fishing are well-established
and, to a large extent, are preserved by the combined use of the marine area.
Spatial layout 5.2.1 Intensity of coastal fishing
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
22
Spatial layout 5.2.2 Intensity of trawl fishing
Guidelines:
1. Coastal and recreational fishing is more intensified in coastal and shallow-sea
areas.
2. Preserve important spawning grounds for the natural recovery of fish stocks in
the various marine areas (summarized in the spatial layout 5.2.3 below). The
spawning grounds are areas that are more hidden from the waves in the coastal
sea, especially in the Väinameri Sea, as well as at the ends of the peninsula
(flounder) and the open sea shoals (autumn herring, flounder).
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
23
Spatial layout 5.2.3. Potential spawning grounds. Potential spawning grounds
are shown in general, only depth of the sea is considered
3. Maintain/create open access to fishing areas (coastal fishing and trawl fishing),
fishing ports, and landing sites for efficient exploitation of fisheries resources.
Conditions:
1. Trawling for fish (Baltic herring and sprat) is permitted in Estonia in marine
areas deeper than 20 m. In shallower areas, trawling would damage the seabed
and hence biodiversity.
2. When constructing harbors and bridges, developing aquaculture, constructing
pipelines, wind turbines, dams, and heat pumps, dredging cables on the seabed
or establishing other objects at sea, the permit procedure shall ensure that no
significant long-term adverse impacts on fish spawning grounds would occur;
if necessary, further studies shall be carried out.
5.3 Aquaculture
5.3.1 Fish farming
As a maritime country, Estonia has great potential for the industrial cultivation of fish
in the marine area. The MSP does not designate areas suitable for fish farming, as
offshore farm technology is in the process of development, and therefore the
designation of suitable areas may unduly restrict the development of the blue economy,
taking into account the environmental status. The establishment of fish farms is not
allowed in unsuitable areas (see spatial layout 5.3.1.1 below).
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
24
Spatial layout 5.3.1.1. Areas not suitable for the development of fish farms, i.e.
excluded areas
Guidelines:
1. It is desirable to favor areas outside the water traffic areas for fish farms. Co-
operation with the Transport Administration is required to use up-to-date water
traffic data
2. “Cluster solutions” are favored in aquaculture: combining a nutrient adding fish
farm at sea with the nutrient-removing algae and/or shellfish farming in the
same location or in a close-by area. Different types of aquaculture can also be
developed separately and independently. In addition, wider cluster solutions
through land-sea interactions (e.g., shared labor, use of common infrastructure,
joint vessels, etc.) are favored. It is important to involve fishermen and other
marine users in the maintenance of aquaculture facilities in order to alleviate the
seasonal nature of sea-based employment.
3. Fish farms in wind energy areas are favoured in order to achieve positive co-
benefits through spatial combined use of the marine area (co-location in the
same marine space), possibly use of common infrastructure, etc.
Conditions:
1. The balanced development of fish farms is encouraged outside the areas that
exclude fish farms (see spatial layout 5.3.1.1).
2. Fish farms will be established in deeper (> 5 m) and open sea areas to reduce
the possible impact of pollution. In the open sea, nutrients are dispersed better
due to the intensive movement of water, and deeper sea areas tend to have less
affected biota (seabed habitats, fish spawning grounds, etc.).
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
25
3. The impacts associated with the establishment of a fish farm must be at an
acceptable load for the state of the marine environment, if necessary,
environmental measures must be implemented16.
4. Fish farms cannot overlap with special areas of national defense.
5. Fish farms cannot overlap with fairways, including international ship traffic
areas.
6. Fish farms cannot overlap with protected natural objects.
7. Fish farms cannot overlap with dumping areas.
8. Fish farms cannot overlap with anchorage areas.
9. Fish farms cannot overlap with the places of refuge for ships.
10. Fish farms cannot overlap with a cultural monument and the preservation area
of an underwater cultural heritage.
11. Fish farms will be planned in cooperation with the Ministry of Rural Affairs,
e.g. to take into account historical trawling areas.
12. When establishing a fish farm in the cable corridor, the risk of cable damage
must be avoided17.
13. When deciding the location and technological solutions of a fish farm at the
level of permit procedure/Environmental Impact Assessment, it is necessary:
a. to assess the impact on fish spawning grounds and the fishery on a larger
scale, define the necessary mitigating environmental measures.
b. to assess the impact on protected natural objects (including those being
designed) if they are located within the area of influence of the activity.
Significant impacts on protected natural objects and adverse impacts on
Natura 2000 sites must be ruled out.
c. to assess the biosecurity risks associated with different farm
interactions18. To ensure biosecurity, a buffer must be left between fish
farms19.
d. to assess the risks associated with the establishment of farms with regard
to the distribution of alien species, genetic mixing of cultivated and wild
species.
e. to take into account the risk of ice conditions to ensure that facilities are
resilient to impacts. Assess the impact of the proposed activities and
possible icebreaking works on ice cover changes and sea ice mobility.
f. to cooperate with the Ministry of Defense to determine the likelihood
that historic explosives and other dangerous objects will be found in the
area of interest.
g. to cooperate with the owners of technical installations to determine the
location and potential interaction of cables and pipelines.
h. in case of overlap with the water traffic areas, specify the location of
the fish farm and the functioning of shipping in cooperation with the
16
As a result of the fish farm's activities, the state of the marine environment must not deteriorate if it
is good or very good, nor must the fish farm prevent attaining at least good status in areas where the
status is currently not good, or interfere with the objectives of the Baltic Sea Action Plan. If nutrients
and contaminants are added to the sea from the fish farm, they must be removed if necessary.
17
The submarine cable is shielded differently in different places. The risk is lower for recessed cables
and/or cable covered with concrete slabs.
18
Biosecurity refers to the need to prevent the introduction of pathogens and parasites from farms into
the nature and vice versa, as well as the movement of pathogens and parasites between different nearby
farms.
19
The extent of the buffer depends on the specific circumstances (fish species, depth, technology).
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
26
Transport Administration, based on up-to-date data, assessing, inter
alia, the impact on vessel traffic (among other things, assess the
economic impact of longer travel distances and the increased level of
risk associated with limiting and increasing traffic).
i. In case of overlap with underwater cultural heritage, specify the
interaction in cooperation with the National Heritage Board, carry out
an underwater archaeological survey if necessary.
j. In case of overlap with a mineral deposit, specify interaction in
cooperation with the Land Board.
5.3.2 Shellfish and algae farming
The Estonian marine area has great potential for the production of Mytilus (edible
mussels). Based on current knowledge, mussels yield in the Estonian offshore with the
best regional technologies are in the same range as the Danish straits, and the cost of
production of large farms is expected to be economically competitive.
Based on basic marine area research,20 the naturally most suitable areas for shellfish
farming are mainly located in marine areas west of Saare County and Hiiu County. In
addition, algae cultivation is from a natural point of view also promising in the Western
part of the Väinameri Sea and the Gulf of Finland.
20
The best available information on the physical and chemical characteristics of the marine area under
study and on the seabed biota and habitats was used to identify areas suitable for aquaculture of
invertebrates and algae and to determine the growth potential of the mussel. Identifying areas suitable
for aquaculture modeled growth potential maps of the most important invertebrates and macroalgae
species in aquaculture were used as input. The maps were prepared with the support of the EMFF project
"Development of regional plans for aquaculture to manage possible environmental pressures". Modeling
was revised in the summer of 2019. The survey can be found here.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
27
Spatial layout 5.3.2.1 Natural growth potential of shellfish
Spatial layout 5.3.2.2 Natural growth potential of algae
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
28
The most naturally suitable areas for the growth of the gutweed (Ulva intestinalis) are
to the west and south of Saaremaa and in the Gulf of Riga, as well as around Ruhnu.
Spatial layout 5.3.2.3 Natural growth potential of gutweed (Ulva intestinalis)
Marine spatial planning maps the natural growth potential of algae and shellfish
farming (spatial layouts above). The development of algae and shellfish farming is
possible outside areas of high and moderate potential but may not be feasible there due
to unfavourable growing conditions. Areas unsuitable for shellfish and seaweed
cultivation are outlined in the following spatial layout.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
29
Spatial layout 5.3.2.4 Areas excluded for the development of shellfish and algae
production
Aquaculture, in particular shellfish farming, is expected to have a positive synergy with
the establishment of wind turbines. The foundations of wind turbines are a growth
medium suitable for shellfish and provide favorable solutions for fixing mussel lines.
Guidelines:
1. Encourage the balanced development of shellfish and algae cultivation in
naturally suitable areas and outside the excluded areas (see the spatial layout
above).
2. For shellfish and algae cultivation, it is advisable to favor areas outside the water
traffic areas. Co-operation with the Transport Administration is required to use
up-to-date water traffic data.
3. “Cluster solutions” are favored in aquaculture: combining nutrient adding fish
farming at sea with the nutrient-removing algae and/or shellfish farming. It is
also possible to develop algae and/or shell farming spatially separately from fish
farming. In addition, wider cluster solutions through land-sea interactions (e.g.,
shared labor, use of common infrastructure, joint vessels, etc.) are favored. It is
important to involve fishermen and other marine users in the maintenance of
aquaculture facilities in order to alleviate the seasonal nature of sea-based
employment.
4. Shellfish and/or algae cultivation in wind energy development areas is favored
to achieve a positive synergy through the spatially combined use of the sea area
(located in the same sea space), if possible the use of common infrastructure
etc.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
30
5. The use/production of renewable energy for the farm’s own use is preferred in
shellfish and algae farms, except wind energy development/production.
Conditions:
1. Shellfish and algae cultivation cannot overlap with a special area of national
defense.
2. Shellfish and algae cultivation cannot overlap with fairways, including
international ship traffic areas.
3. Shellfish and algae cultivation cannot overlap with the anchorage area.
4. Shellfish and algae cultivation cannot overlap with the dumping area.
5. Shellfish and algae cultivation cannot overlap with the places for the refugee of
ships.
6. Shellfish and algae cultivation cannot overlap with cultural monuments and the
preservation area of underwater cultural heritage.
7. When planning shellfish and algae cultivation in a protected natural site
(including the one under design), the possibility of synergy is specified with the
Environmental Board.
8. Planning shellfish and algae cultivation will be done in cooperation with the
Ministry of Rural Affairs, e.g. to take into account historical trawling areas.
9. When designing shell and algae cultivation in the cable corridor, care must be
taken to avoid the risks of cable damage21.
10. When deciding the location and technological solutions of a fish farm at the
level of permit procedure/Environmental Impact Assessment, it is necessary:
a. to assess the impact on fish spawning grounds and the fishery on a larger
scale, define the necessary mitigating environmental measures.
b. to assess the impact on protected natural objects (including those being
designed) if they are located within the area of influence of the activity.
Significant impacts on protected natural objects and adverse impacts on
Natura 2000 sites must be ruled out.
c. to take into account the risk of ice conditions to ensure that facilities are
resilient to impacts. Assess the impact of the proposed activities and
possible icebreaking works on ice cover changes and sea ice mobility.
d. to cooperate with the Ministry of Defense to determine the likelihood
that historic explosives and other dangerous objects will be found in the
area of interest.
e. to cooperate with the owner of the technical installation to determine the
location and potential synergies of cables and pipelines.
a. in case of overlap with the water traffic area, to specify the location of
the fish farm and the functioning of water traffic in cooperation with the
Transport Administration, based on up-to-date data, assessing, inter alia,
the impact on vessel traffic (among other things, the economic impact
of longer travel distances and the increased level of risk associated with
limiting and increasing traffic).
f. in case of overlap with underwater cultural heritage, to specify
interaction in cooperation with the National Heritage Board, if necessary
to carry out an underwater archaeological survey.
21
The submarine cable is shielded differently in different places. The risk is lower for recessed cables
and/or cable covered with concrete slabs.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
31
g. in case of overlap with a mineral deposit, to specify interaction in
cooperation with the Land Board.
5.4 Maritime transport
5.4.1 Vessel traffic
Historically, ships have been the main users of marine areas. Based on navigation, very
wide areas are used to navigate between ports – the choice of an optimal route depends
on the size and type of the ship, hazards in the marine area, wind and waves, etc. New
uses of the marine area may, in many places, be a constraint, necessitating alteration,
narrowing, or redirecting of shipping lanes. This is reasonable in each case, taking into
account the specificity of the location, the current pattern of traffic and the needs of
new uses of the marine area of interest, and not restrict or divert ship traffic to narrower
“passage corridors” where no competing interests exist.
The maritime plan shall reflect the fairways22 published in the navigation information
and shall determine water traffic areas23 based on the volume of traffic and the main
directions of navigation. In the rest of the marine area, ship traffic is scattered and rare.
Vessel traffic is also permitted outside fairways and water traffic areas where the
natural conditions, the size of the vessel, and existing restrictions allow and where it is
necessary.
In places where fairway location is determined by natural constraints, in most cases,
the designed, marked, and mapped fairways already exist, and changing their location
is difficult or impossible. Compared to water traffic areas, fairways occupy a relatively
narrow area, except for international ship traffic areas regulated by the International
Maritime Organization24. Exceptionally, a fairway may overlap with other uses of the
sea, but in this case, the preservation of the fairway and, where possible, the avoidance
of additional restrictions to ensure the safety of water traffic, shall be a priority.
22
For fairways of international importance with large ships and heavy vessel traffic, the area W is calculated by the formula W =
Ws + 2 (Wr + Wc), where Ws is the lane width 4 ship lengths, Wc is the safety margin necessary for full collision avoidance 6
lengths of ship and Wr is the margin of 0.3 M necessary for the maneuver made to avoid collision.* The length of the ships has
been analyzed on the basis of AIS data and the maximum length of 98.5% the ships moving in the fairways has been selected for
the formula. On fairways which, in addition to the axis, have a fairway area published in the navigation information, the width of
the fairway is the width of the fairway area and no safety margin is added. Fairways with only an axis published in the navigation
information shall be 200 m or 400 m wide along the axis of the fairway, based on the largest vessels moving on the fairway.
23
The water traffic areas are determined in cooperation with the Maritime Administration according to the following methodology.
The axes of water traffic areas are determined by AIS footprints. For fairways of international importance with large ships and
heavy vessel traffic, the area W is calculated by the formula W = Ws + 2 (Wr + Wc), where Ws is the lane width 4 ship lengths,
Wc is the safety margin necessary for full collision avoidance 6 lengths of ship and Wr is the margin of 0.3 M necessary for the
maneuver made to avoid collision.* The length of the ships has been analyzed on the basis of AIS data and the maximum length
of 98.5% the ships moving in the fairways has been selected for the formula. Water traffic areas of local importance with shorter
vessels (e.g., fishing vessels, ferries and recreational craft) have a width of 400 m or 200 m. For major ports that do not have
fairways published in the navigation information, a 400 m wide water traffic area is designated according to the location of the
AIS footprints (e.g., Saaremaa, Veere harbor). At the point where the water traffic area passes through a shallow or protection
zone, the width of the area is reduced, taking into account the size of the vessels in the area. At the point where AIS footprints are
fading and no longer run in one clear direction, the water traffic area is terminated.
24
The international ship traffic area is the area through the Estonian EEZ where there are vessel traffic management measures
approved by the International Maritime Organization (IMO), with a safety margin added according to the methodology for
determining the safety margin for a water traffic area. International ship traffic areas are considered equivalent to fairways in the
context of the MSP.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
32
The extent of water traffic areas usually leaves an opportunity for allocating space for
other activities, leaving a sufficient margin for vessel traffic safety. Water traffic areas
are thus designated, taking into account the need to allow other uses of the sea. For the
purposes of this plan, water traffic areas may overlap with other uses of the sea.
The construction of new fairways takes place under the leadership (in public water
areas) or with the approval (in port access roads) of the Transport Administration.
Water traffic areas are explanatory information to planning, this plan will not be
regulating the creation of new water traffic areas. When determining other uses for the
sea in the future, the current traffic situation (based on the guidelines of the Transport
Administration) and not the situation fixed at the time of planning (water traffic areas)
should be taken into account at the permit procedure level and in the drawing up of
subsequent strategic documents.
Spatial layout 5.4.1.1. Maritime transport
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
33
Spatial layout 5.4.1.2. Vessel traffic volume
5.4.2 Ports
In contrast to the deep waters of the Baltic Sea and the central Gulf of Finland, the
Estonian coastal sea is mostly shallow and full of dangers. This requires proper signage
of safe fairways and also imposing restrictions on the construction of ports. The most
suitable harbors on the coast are already in use for this purpose. A naturally unfavorable
harbor site, in particular, entails high costs (e.g., the need for repeat dredging to
maintain the desired depth, the need for more abundant navigation signage, etc.).
Although the network of cargo and passenger ports is largely developed, these ports are
being expanded if needed. The network of small-craft harbors is developing, old
harbors are being reorganized, and totally new small-craft harbors are being built.
The construction of new small-craft harbors and the reconstruction of existing ones are
directly dependent on the existence of appropriate support programs, which make the
bulk of large-scale investments. In addition to the new ports being built to complement
the network of guest ports, a number of existing ports, whose facilities are coming to
an end, will also require major investment.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
34
Spatial layout 5.4.2.1. Port network
5.4.3 Ice roads
With suitable weather conditions, ice roads will be established in the Estonian marine
area, which will facilitate the lives of the inhabitants of the islands and peninsulas and
will also be tourist attractions. There are six official ice road routes in the marine area
(Heltermaa-Rohuküla, Kuivastu-Virtsu, Tärkma-Triigi, Rohuküla-Sviby, Lao-Kihnu,
Haapsalu-Noarootsi).
In addition to a cold winter, the formation of ice suitable for road construction depends
on many other factors (ice quality, the thickness of snow cover on ice, water level
fluctuations, etc.). In view of the increase in temperature during the winter months due
to climate change, conditions suitable for the construction of ice roads tend to be less
frequent. Maritime spatial plan does not spatially determine the location of ice roads.
The exact location of the ice roads will depend on the particular winter ice conditions
and will be determined by the Transport Administration.
5.4.4 Maritime transport guidelines and conditions
International ship traffic areas and local ship traffic areas, as well as the connection
with the major and small islands, are important for the further development of maritime
transport. The development is based on functioning transport infrastructure: a well-
established network of ports with possible new small-craft harbors in naturally suitable
locations. Ongoing attention to maritime safety is important.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
35
Guidelines:
1. Water traffic areas may overlap in planning, for example, with wind energy
development areas, aquaculture areas, and other uses of the sea. The location of
areas with different uses will be specified at the permit procedure level, taking
into account up-to-date water traffic data.
2. It is important to ensure the functioning of the established port network.
3. The aim of the intensification of the port network is:
a. the construction of new small-craft harbors in naturally suitable
locations, with suitable depths of sea and taking into account economic
sustainability and safety to avoid disproportionately high environmental
impacts and costs for dredging, protection from waves, etc.
b. provision of primary port services for small vessels (the average daily
distance of about 30 nautical miles, i.e., 6 hours traveling time with an
average speed of 5 knots);
c. the possibility of refueling motor yachts at a sufficient distance;
d. creating safe mooring facilities to complement the network of guest
ports.
4. With suitable weather conditions, ice roads will be established in the Estonian
marine area, which will facilitate the lives of the inhabitants of the islands and
peninsulas and enliven tourist activities.
Conditions:
1. Changing the location of fairways and imposing significant restrictions on water
traffic should generally be avoided when planning other uses. The possibility of
a change that is strictly necessary depends on the specific location and requires
the approval of the Transport Administration.
2. Objects placed at sea shall not interfere with the distinction of navigational signs
or lights for waterborne traffic and shall be marked in accordance with
applicable regulations and international guidelines.
3. In order to ensure safe water traffic and the protection of objects, man-made
objects (including fish cages, wind turbines, diving pontoons, etc.) must be
marked in accordance with applicable legislation and international guidelines.
4. No aquaculture development area shall be established on the fairway or at the
anchorage area to avoid damage to both the farm and the vessels.
5. Wind turbines shall not be placed on the fairway or at the anchorage area to
ensure safety at sea.
6. When creating a new protected natural object, the spatial shape of the protected
object shall, if possible, be adapted to the fairway. The process will involve
cooperation with the Transport Administration and carrying out social and
economic impact assessments to determine the impact on vessel traffic,
including the economic impact of possible route extensions and the increase in
the level of risk associated with traffic restrictions and increases.
7. Upon overlapping of the water traffic area with the wind energy development
area the location of wind turbines and the functioning of water traffic will be
determined based on up-to-date data in cooperation with the Transport
Administration, assessing the impact on shipping (including the economic
impact of possible route extensions and the increase in the level of risk
associated with traffic restrictions and increases). In wind energy areas, basic
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
36
passage corridors for shipping must be kept free of wind turbines25 (see the
spatial layout No 11 and conditions in Chapter 5.6.4), to ensure smooth
international freight transport and optimal length of the journey26 and the need
for turns27.
8. When the water traffic area overlaps with existing protected objects, the
interaction is based on protected natural objects and up-to-date water traffic
data.
9. When the aquaculture development area overlaps with the water traffic area, the
location and the operation of the vessel traffic will be specified based on up-to-
date data in cooperation with the Transport Administration.
10. In the case of a conflict of interest between maritime transport and the
establishment of a recreational area, co-operation with the Transport
Administration shall be made in the preparation of the municipal
comprehensive plan to ensure that both maritime transport and recreational
needs are taken into account.
5.5 Maritime rescue, pollution response and guarding the
state border
In the light of the intensification of the use of the marine area and the rapid growth of
maritime transport, the functioning of maritime rescue and pollution response and
guarding of state border are of great importance.
Maritime rescue needs are largely determined by land-sea interactions – the availability
of ports and alternative vessel launching points, the availability of facilities for storing
equipment in ports (response points), etc. The adequacy of these needs for the marine
area of the region must be taken into account by the municipalities in the comprehensive
plan, including in cooperation with the neighboring municipalities, since the coverage
of marine areas by means of maritime rescue must be looked at over the whole water
area and not at the municipal boundary, i.e., by the sections of the coastline. The volume
of maritime rescue activities on land and at sea (including the number of members,
number and density of response points, number of calls) is expected to be in line with
and growing with the growth of the number of small craft as local traffic and maritime
tourism progress.
From the point of view of the Estonian marine area as a whole, it should be borne in
mind that although the resources required for disaster response (ships and equipment)
are concentrated in the Tallinn area, the regional response capacity is primarily based
25
In wind energy development area 2, there is a basic passage corridor for vessel traffic with a width of
approximately 6250 m. The minimum breadth required for shipping is calculated according to the
formula in footnote 21: W = Ws + 2 (Wr + Wc).
26
When bypassing wind energy areas, the ship's voyage can be calculated to increase by 10 - 30 km
depending on the destination and the time spent can increase by 0.5 - 1.5 hours. Depending on this, fuel
consumption also increases, which is difficult to determine because it depends on the type of ship, the
size of the cargo and many other factors.
27
When bypassing wind energy areas, the ship has to make more turns compared to the existing
directions of movement. Turning points should be avoided when designing fairways (IMO, 2008, Ships’
routeing, section A chapter 6 clause 6.4), (PIANC, 2014, MarCom Wg 121 Harbour approach channels
design guidelines, chapter 3.1.2.1), as they reduce the safety of vessel traffic.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
37
on port pollution response duty (insofar as they are the risk sources) and portable
pollution response containers of the Police and Border Guard Board. A regional
response capacity is also needed to address the growing awareness of the so-called “sea
litter.” In the case of the sea litter washed to the shore, the main measure is removing
litter from the shore and preventing new litter from being carried from the shore to the
sea.
Places of refuge have been designated by Government Order No 529 of 18.08.2005 to
ensure the safety of water traffic navigation, protect the marine environment and
facilitate rescue at seaports and water areas to which a ship in distress or a ship which
seeks to avoid getting in distress is directed, for example, until weather conditions or
other hazards to shipping are eliminated. The ship is directed to the place for refuge by
the Police and Border Guard Board.
Spatial layout 5.5.1 Places of refuge
Guidelines:
1. It is important to increase pollution control capacity at both the national and
regional levels.
2. It is important to be aware of the growing problem of marine litter washed onto
the shore.
Conditions:
1. It is necessary to ensure that vessels can be launched for maritime rescue
purposes.
2. The activities carried out and planned at sea must not interfere with the
operation of maritime surveillance radars.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
38
3. Aquaculture development areas cannot overlap with a place of refuge for
vessels in order to avoid damage to both the farm and the vessels in distress.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
39
5.6 Renewable energy production
The development of renewable energy will minimize the environmental impact of the
energy sector, strengthen energy security, and increase the competitiveness of the
economy. The "Basic Principles of Climate Policy until 2050" aims at a gradual
increase in the use of renewable energy sources in all sectors of final consumption.
Estonia's National Energy and Climate Plan28 plans to reach 42% of total final energy
consumption (~50% of final energy consumption) from renewable energy by 2030.
According to the Communication "National Energy and Climate Plan 2030", which
specifies and complements the Energy Roadmap 2030, the offshore wind potential is
7000 MW.
Wind is the main potential source of energy in the Estonian marine area. This is
supported by both strategic development documents and the Supreme Court, which in
its decision No 3-17-2013 of 26.05.2021 found that the production of renewable energy
is an important public interest and serves the goals of sustainable use of natural
resources and sustainable development. When considering the possibilities of wind
energy production, the renewable energy production targets set by the state must be
taken into account. It is also worth paying attention to the use of the coastal sea adjacent
to densely populated areas for cooling and thermal energy, as well as hydrogen
production. Also, in exceptional cases (e.g., for the own use of aquaculture facilities)
and in the future, floating solar plants and wave energy solutions may be worth
considering. In the longer term, an important development trend could be distributed
energy29, which enables coastal communities, for example, to develop energy solutions
that meet their needs.
5.6.1 Guidelines for renewable energy production
Guidelines and conditions for wind energy development areas are given in Chapter
5.6.5.
Guidelines:
1. The Estonian marine area must be used for the production of renewable
energy. In the near future, the focus will be on developing wind energy (see
Chapters 5.6.2 – 5.6.6).
2. In the longer term, it is expedient to consider wider opportunities for
renewable energy production (e.g., hydrogen, solar and wave energy)
throughout the Estonian marine area. The need to draw up a plan for wider
renewable energy production capacity will be determined by the legal
framework in place at a given time.
3. In the longer term, the development of distributed energy in the marine area,
which will allow coastal communities, for example, to develop distributed
energy solutions that meet their needs, may also be appropriate. The need to
draw up a plan for the development of distributed energy will be determined
28
Vt https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/default/files/documents/ee_final_necp_main_ee.pdf
29
Distributed energy - the production of electricity generated at the consumer's site in micro- and mini-
generation and heating plants located in isolated and dispersed locations
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
40
by the legal framework in place at a given time, including taking into
account the spatial impacts of the proposed site.
5.6.2 Starting points for wind energy development
Long-term planning for wind energy needs to take into account the rapid evolution of
the technology. Wind turbines are increasing in size, both in tip height and, even faster,
in rotor diameter. The capacity of wind turbines is also increasing and could reach 20
MW by the end of the planning period. Both the capacity and the other parameters of
the wind turbines will depend on the specific location and siting, as well as on the timing
of their realisation. It is likely that the realisation of the wind energy areas proposed in
this plan will result in a situation where different wind turbines are located close to each
other. In different wind farms, the height of the tips of the wind turbines, the rotor
diameter and the distances between the turbines may vary. It is expected that the wind
turbines will initially be sited in a shallower sea, with lower tip heights (at the beginning
of the planning period) and closer spacing. In a later phase, more powerful and taller
wind turbines are expected to be installed, with greater spacing between turbines.
However, as the distance between the turbines will remain linked to the rotor diameter
(see below), the change may not be noticeable in real space (i.e. the arrangement of the
turbines will not be noticeably sparser). The planning solution has been developed on
the basis of international experience, expert opinion and the assessments of wind energy
developers30 in order to identify suitable sites for wind energy development. On the
basis of the recommendations of the Planning Expert Group, the following indicators
have been used as a basis for the development of the solution, including the impact
assessment:
- The tip height of the wind turbine is in the order of 300 m.
- The rotor diameter is in the order of 250 m.
- The wind turbine foundation shall be of the gravity-based foundation
technology type or similar in its impacts. The expected diameter of the
foundation is less than 100 m (probably 60 m).
- The spacing between wind turbines in a wind farm is between 4 and 7 rotor
diameters, with a minimum of 800m.
- The minimum spacing between wind farms31 will be approximately 8 rotor
diameters of the rotor of a later wind farm, with a minimum of 2 km.
30
In 2020, the Ministry of Finance, in cooperation with the Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications, carried out a survey among developers to identify the likely parameters of proposed
wind turbines.
31
A future offshore wind farm development will be able to locate its wind turbines in such a way as to
minimise wind-shadow effect in its wind farm compared to the existing one(s). It is also likely that the
newer wind farm will already have newer and taller wind turbines, which will provide more wind-shadow
effect for the previously established wind farm than equivalent wind turbines with a similar siting pattern.
It is likely that wind farms will be built first in the eastern part of wind energy development areas, where
the sea is shallower and the connection point is closer. The most productive winds in Estonia are
southerly, southwesterly and westerly, with very low productivity in the northeast and east winds, so the
first wind farm to be built in the east or northeast of the development area will provide little wind-shadow
effect compared to a wind farm added to the west, but the opposite impact will be very significant.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
41
5.6.3 Establishment of suitable areas for wind energy development
During the development of the MSP, the suitability of the Estonian marine area for the
development of wind energy was analyzed (for a comprehensive methodology, see
spatial layout 5.6.3.1 and diagrams; for weight setting, class distribution, and raster
analysis methodology see Annex 2). The selection of suitable areas was based on a
gravity-based foundation technology, which, according to current knowledge, is most
suitable for the ice conditions which occur in Estonia.
Areas suitable for wind energy development based on natural conditions and the
distance of the substations were associated with other uses of the sea and with known
limitations. Environmental aspects were considered, and the best information available
was used (see the methodological spatial layout below and thematic maps). The areas
were further analyzed during the impact assessment. The proposals from maritime
transport and aviation was also taken into account. Thus, areas where potential conflicts
with other uses are absent or minimized were identified.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
42
Spatial layout 5.6.3.1 Finding areas suitable for wind energy development.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
43
As part of the consideration process described above, schematic thematic maps were
prepared:
1. As a first step, areas that
are in principle suitable for
the development of wind
energy were identified.
Wind energy potential
(weight 0.55), depth
(0.25), distance from
nearest high voltage
substation (0.1),
probability of ice
occurrence (0.06), and
wave height (0.04) were
used as the basis.
Suitable areas are marked
in green.
Possible wind energy development areas based on natural conditions
2. As a second step, the Proposed wind energy development areas energy with protected nature and abiotic
overlap of the suitable conditions
areas with natural values
was analyzed. The
overlapping areas were cut
out.
Existing protected natural
objects and Natura 2000
sites are marked in pink,
while the proposed marine
protected areas are
marked with dark pink
diagonal lines. The dataset
is as of September 2018.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
44
3. With the deduction of Areas suitable for wind energy development of wind energy (predominantly
protected areas from good/very good abiotic conditions + no overlap with nature protection objects)
basically suitable areas, an
initial proposal for the
planning of wind energy
development areas was
obtained.
Areas suitable for wind
energy development are
indicated by blue diagonal
lines.
4. The so-called visual
Areas suitable for the development of wind energy (predominantly good/very
buffer, 11.1 km from the
good abiotic conditions + no overlap with nature protection objects)
coastline, was deducted
from the initial wind
energy development areas.
Wind energy development
are indicated by blue
diagonal lines.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
45
5. The overlap of the wind Proposed wind energy development areas with bird migration zoning
energy development areas
with the zoning of bird
migration was observed.
The proposed wind energy
development areas do not
overlap with particularly
important migratory areas
of birds. The interaction
with areas of importance
to birds was further
considered during the
impact assessment (see
step 10).
Areas of particular
importance for bird
migration are indicated in
red, areas of major
importance in yellow,
areas of importance in
green.
As an interim decision, it was considered that due to the size of the areas and national defense interests,
the development of wind energy is not feasible in the northern part of the Estonian marine area on the
time scale of the planning.
6. Possible wind energy Areas suitable for wind energy development (predominantly good/very good
development areas were abiotic conditions + no overlap with nature protection objects)
analyzed in the light of
national defense interests.
Areas No 4, 5, 6, and 7 (in
accordance with the
interim decision taken in
cooperation with the
Ministry of Defence, not
to plan wind energy
development areas in the
northern part of the
Estonian marine area, in
the Gulf of Finland) and
the northern part of Area 1
have been deducted
because of the need for air
surveillance and
operational radar
capability.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
46
7. For on-depth Areas suitable for wind energy development
observation and
assessment of feasibility, Proposal February 2019
two stages were
distinguished by depth:
areas up to 35 m deep
(stage I) and areas 35-45
m deep (stage II)32. The
deeper (> 35 m) marine
area is less promising due
to the winter ice
conditions in the timeline
of the current planning as
there is no suitable
technology for Estonian
sea conditions33.
Blue hatching with pink
indicates Stage I, blue
indicates Stage II.
Based on the feedback of the draft solution and in view of the rapid development of
technology, an innovation area of wind energy development areas was also included in
the plan. The area free of fast ice targeted especially for wind turbines and wind farms
predominantly on floating foundations, but also for other innovative solutions, remains
within the exclusive economic zone west of the wind energy development area No 2.
The area covers 88 km2. The location of the innovation area is based on the layout of
the international ship traffic areas and other water traffic areas, the depth restriction has
not been considered important. The need to ensure a larger social buffer was also taken
into account, which is why the area was set further away from the coast. The
introduction of the innovation area does not require the prior exhaustion of other
development areas of wind energy.
In the framework of the impact assessment of the main solution, the overlap with
protected natural objects was checked as of December 2020 (see section 4.2.6 of the
Impact Assessment Report) and the compatibility of areas suitable for the development
of wind energy with bird staging areas and migratory trends was further analyzed, based
on a study prepared by the Estonian Ornithological Society (2019, 2021). The overlap
of the proposed wind energy development areas with the areas used by seals was also
examined (see section 4.2.3 of the Impact Assessment Report).
32
The distinction between the phases of wind energy development has taken into account the need for
creation of more compact areas. Implementing the 35 m limit will also create larger areas in stage I,
where there is more opportunities for efficient placement of wind turbines, taking into account other
factors. For the next decade, 35 m will be a critical boundary, where the construction of foundations
using gravity-based foundation technology in sea areas with icy and random drift ice may prove
economically viable.
33
The wind energy development areas do not have to be established strictly in a phased manner, i.e., it
is possible to start the development wish in Phase II areas even if no development activities have been
carried out in Phase I areas.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
47
8. The impact assessment Protected natural objects and proposed wind energy development areas
confirmed that wind
energy development areas
do not overlap with
existing and planned
protected areas, based on
December 2020 data.
It was acknowledged that
offshore protected areas
have been proposed in the
interim period, with a
possible Kolgi Shoal
Protected Area
overlapping with wind
energy development area
No 2. According to the
Impact Assessment Task
Group it would not be
prudent to put the
overlapping area into
economic use until the
protected area
establishment proposal has
been finalised and the
specific restrictions have
been clarified.
9. Based on a survey of
bird staging areas and
migratory directions and
an impact assessment,
wind energy development
area No 1 was revised to
reduce area coverage by
13% (from the surface
area of the area No 1). In
addition, it was decided to
abandon wind energy area
No 3, which was partly
located in the sensitive
area of Hülgerahu, an
important winter staging
area and spring migration
area for waterbirds, and
had therefore high
development risk. Due to
its small area, the viability
would have been doubtful, Sensitive areas and planned wind energy areas
and the area was also
within the line of sight of Area no 1 and area no 3 have been revised to mitigate the impacts
important developed
onshore viewpoints.
The wind energy
development area No 3 to
be removed as a result of
the impact assessment is
marked with a red hatch.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
48
10. The impacts of wind Bats and proposed wind energy development areas
energy development on
bats were analysed (see
Chapter 4.2.4 of the Impact
Assessment Report).
Major migration corridors
do not overlap with wind
energy areas.
11. The impact on seals,
especially on the
Baltic ringed seal migration areas and planned wind energy areas
movement areas of the
Baltic ringed seal, that is
more sensitive to human
influences, was analysed.
In the main, wind energy
development areas are
outside marine areas of
importance for seals. The
Gulf of Riga wind energy
area partially overlaps
with areas used by Baltic
ringed seal. According to
the final conclusion of the
impact assessment, the
implementation of the
MSP is not expected to
result in significant
adverse impacts on seals,
when respective
environmental measures
and recommendations are
implemented at the permit
level (see Chapter 5.6.5).
At the public display of the main solution (17.02-18.03.2020), the Maritime
Administration (now: Transport Administration) and the Civil Aviation Administration
submitted their proposals regarding the areas suitable for the development of wind
energy. Based on the proposals, the scope of the areas was reduced (see the spatial
layouts below). The reasons for the changes are presented under the spatial layouts.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
49
12. Based on the input of
the Maritime Synergies of maritime transport and wind energy development areas
Administration, the scope
of wind energy areas No.
1 and 2 was reduced. In
these areas, the basic
passage corridors for
shipping, which need to be
kept free of wind turbines,
were also marked. Precise
solutions are developed at
the superficies license
stage. In addition, the
location of the innovation
area was specified based
on the needs of maritime
transport.
Maritime transport needs
are marked with a red
hatch and lines.
Grounds for changes:
Considering the combined impact of the planned wind farms on vessel
traffic (incl. the area planned the Latvian MSP and the area planned with
the Pärnu MSP south of Kihnu), the extent of area No. 1 in the southern
part was reduced by 31 km2. The reduction will ensure safe and optimal
vessel traffic in the direction of Pärnu in a situation where prospective wind
turbines create artificial obstacles to water traffic. The movement of the
water traffic area - delimiting the area No. 1 from the south - to the south
is hindered by the shoal extending from the island of Ruhnu.
In addition, in order to ensure smooth international ship traffic, wind
energy area No. 2 was reduced by cutting off the area that overlaps with
the water traffic area southwest of the Sõrve Peninsula (approx. 36 km2).
This water traffic area is a continuation of a fairway designed in Latvian
waters, which is the only possible way to cross the Irbe Strait for ships with
a higher draft due to the depths of the sea. It is an internationally important
fairway with high traffic density.
A basic passage corridor was designated in area No. 2 to ensure the safety
of intensive international shipping in the area. If offshore installations
impede the movement of ships over a very large area and ships have to
start to travel in a large circle compared to optimal routes, this will have a
significant negative economic and environmental impact. Area No. 2 is
passed through by several water traffic areas where international freight
transport takes place and the main destinations are the ports of the Gulf of
Riga, the Gulf of Finland and the Gulf of Bothnia. Therefore, in area no 2,
a corridor as straight, optimal and safe as possible must remain open to
shipping.
The basic passage corridor for shipping was also marked in area No. 1 in
order to ensure the most direct possible crossing for the Roomassaare-
Ringsu shipping line, which would not direct ships to the high seas and
would thus be even more affected by suitable weather conditions. The
operation of the Roomassaare-Ringsu shipping line is of national
importance.
The specification of water traffic areas caused the shift of the innovation
area in the north-east-southeast direction, the size and depth dimensions of
the area did not change significantly with the shift.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
50
13. Based on the input of
Synergies of air transport and wind energy development areas
the Civil Aviation
Administration, the south-
western part of wind
energy area No. 1 and the
southern part of area No. 2
(the latter partially
coincides with the
proposal of the Maritime
Administration) were
reduced in order to ensure
safe air traffic.
The needs of air transport
are marked with purple
grid.
Grounds for changes:
Reduction of Area No. 1 by approx. 22 km2 is necessary to ensure air traffic
in the direction of Ruhnu-Kuressaare. Due to weather conditions, it is
estimated that three quarters of flights during the flight season have to be
performed around wind farms due to the cloud height. Therefore, a free
passage corridor is needed, which would ensure the possibility to turn
around even in case of emergency without crossing the state border.
The reduction in Area No. 2 will ensure safe and optimal air traffic on the
route Kuressaare - Gotland. It will also provide the Defense Forces aircraft
with the fastest possible connection to Central and Western Europe.
During the public display of the main solution (July-August 2020), a conflict arose for
local trawling businesses over the potential impact of offshore wind farm development
on their business. In Estonia, 4.5% of trawling areas overlap with areas suitable for
wind energy development. Overall, the overlap with trawling is 38% of the total wind
energy areas, with the following overlaps for individual areas:
Area No 1 overlaps with trawling 92%;
Area No 2 overlaps with trawling 17%;
Innovation area overlaps with trawling 27% (only two fishing trips were made
in total in the innovation area in the period 2017-2019, so the overlap is not of
major impact here).
The share of fish caught by trawling in wind energy areas was 7% of the total fish
caught in 2019 (about 3 800 tonnes, out of a total of 55 000 tonnes caught). Thus, the
economic impact is not significant for the Estonian trawling sector as a whole, but the
impact on the local economic environment is significant. As both trawling and wind
energy are important economic sectors for the Estonian state, further cooperation was
carried out with the Ministry of Rural Affairs and the Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications to find a solution, and a survey was conducted with representatives of
wind energy developers as well as with the professional association representing the
trawling sectors. Both sectors pointed out that active trawling in offshore wind farms is
not possible, and that there are no concrete examples in international practice in
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
51
circumstances similar to Estonia, where active trawling in wind farms would be
allowed.
The trawling sector pointed out that the Estonian quota in the Gulf of Riga can only be
fished in the Gulf of Riga. Considering the developments of offshore wind farms
already taking place in the Pärnu marine area and the areas that are now being planned,
the situation will be that the fishing areas will be significantly reduced and the pressure
on the remaining areas will increase. The areas will also remain largely distant from
ports. This in turn will lead to increased time and fuel consumption, reduced revenue
from catches (reduced catches), reduced quantities landed in ports, and potentially
reduced fish quality due to time consumption. When fishing areas are far offshore, thus
reducing the number of fishing days, weather-related risks also arise (storm resistance).
The wind energy sector argued that the areas for wind energy development should not
be reduced, as they cannot be fully covered by wind turbines given all the different
conditions. In order to achieve the 2050 climate neutrality targets, it is essential that
there are sufficient wind energy development areas. The availability of sufficient areas
will also ensure competition and the best price for consumers.
Taking into account the above sectoral considerations, the Government of the Republic
decided to take an interim decision (29.04.2021), designating as reserve areas those
areas proposed in the marine spatial plan for wind energy that coincide with historically
more intensive trawling areas (see spatial layout 5.6.4.1). The reserve areas were
defined on the basis of the trawling data of the last 3 years (2018-2020), by marking
their concentration points according to the coordinates of the trawl hauls, and taking
into account the minimum size of the area (90 km2) that is economically viable for
wind energy development.
5.6.4 Areas suitable for wind energy development
The MSP will determine areas (total area 1783 km2, including the innovation area and
the reserve areas), guidelines, and conditions for the development of wind energy.
Suitable areas determined by the plan are expected to be realized to the extent of
approximately 70%. This shows that neither the technological aspects (including the
buffer zone between different offshore wind farms), the results of the specifying studies
carried out during the superficies license stage, nor the needs of maritime transport
make it possible or realistic to wholly cover the area with wind turbines34. If the studies
carried out at the superficies license/ EIA level identify significant adverse impacts that
cannot be mitigated, establishment of the wind farms should be abandoned or their size
or other parameters reduced so that no adverse impacts are created. The aim is to avoid
associated significant adverse impacts.
34
No account has been taken of the potential offshore protected area overlapping with area No 2
suitable for wind energy development.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
52
Spatial layout 5.6.4.1. Areas suitable for wind energy development
5.6.5 Wind energy development guidelines and conditions
Guidelines:
1. The development of aquaculture (fish farms, algae and shellfish farming) is
favoured in wind energy development areas, in order to achieve a positive
synergy.
2. Wider cluster solutions through land-sea interactions (e.g., shared labor,
common infrastructure, common vessels, etc.) are favored. It is important to
involve fishermen and other sea users in the maintenance of wind farms in order
to alleviate the seasonal employment associated with sea use.
3. In the case of a procedure for the protection of a natural object in wind energy
development areas, an expert assessment of the justification and feasibility of
protecting the natural object shall be carried out. The expert assessment shall
include an assessment of the social and economic impacts of the establishment
of the protected area and the impact on Estonia's climate and renewable energy
objectives.
4. When developing wind energy, it is advisable to give preference to areas outside
water traffic areas. Co-operation with the Transport Administration is required
to use up-to-date water traffic data35.
5. In wind energy development areas, it is desirable to base the siting of wind
turbines on the location of the habitat types. Where possible, avoid installing
wind turbines in areas with habitats of high nature protection value. Cooperation
with the Environmental Board is necessary.
35
The interaction between water traffic areas and wind energy development areas will be refined in
February-March 2020 in cooperation between the Maritime Administration, the Ministry of Economic
Affairs and Communications and the planning team.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
53
6. As technology develops, when wind farms are built, preference should be given
to foundation structures with a smaller "footprint", both in terms of seabed area
and ecological footprint36.
7. In the case of more sensitive habitats, a monolithic foundation is preferable, as
the impact on the seabed biota will be one-off. Where possible, use a foundation
material that is as similar as possible to the natural substrate (surface roughness,
neutral chemical reaction), and consider enriching the outer surface of the
foundation with natural rock material. This will allow the creation of an
attachment substrate for marine organisms that is as similar as possible to the
natural one.
8. In the wind energy development areas, wind turbine-free areas/corridors will be
formed based on different interests, which should, if possible, perform as many
different functions as possible (combining, for example, a shipping corridor, a
waterbird autumn migration corridor, habitats of high nature conservation value
etc. in the same location).
9. The horizon must be sectioned (i.e. not fully covered by wind turbines). To this
end, it is recommended:
a. To explore the possibility of leaving areas free of wind turbines in wind
energy development area No 2 when looking from the west coast of
Saaremaa and in wind energy development area No 1 when looking
from the coastal sections on the northern tip of Ruhnu (see the spatial
layout 5.6.5.1 below). These sections concentrate the viewpoints located
in valuable landscapes that are most affected37;
b. The feasibility, location and extent of leaving wind turbine-free areas
will be determined through a visual impact assessment at the superficies
license stage, cumulatively with adjacent windfarms and with the
involvement of the local municipality. In the case of wind farms visible
from a single coastline section, it is desirable to carry out a joint
assessment of visual impacts;
c. In addition, it is important to consider the values identified in the
comprehensive plan, the more specific landscape character of the view38
(viewpoint on the peninsula, in the turn of the coastline) and also the
opinion of the municipality and the community (including how the
viewpoints will be used, how the municipality will direct the viewpoints
in the context of the comprehensive plan to be prepared).
36
The smaller the area of seabed under the foundation (and the part prepared for this purpose), the smaller
the loss of natural seabed in a given location. Consideration must be given to ensuring that the physical
installation of wind turbines during the construction or dismantling phase does not generate significant
and extensive noise and does not cause significant sediment movement.
37
As part of the impact assessment of the plan, a coastal viewpoint mapping was carried out, based on
the beautiful viewpoints of the Saare County Plan, the coastal objects of the Saare Geopark, and the
information of the State Forest Management Centre’s recreation sites, and the potential viewpoints of
the Class I valuable landscapes of the County Plan were added. For the viewpoints found, the sites most
affected by the planning of wind energy developments were identified. See in more detail the impact
assessment report Chapter 4.4.1.6.
38
The "Guidelines for Methodological Recommendations for Visual Impact Assessment to Promote the
Development of Offshore Windfarms", AB Artes Terrae OÜ, 2020 (available on the website of the
Ministry of Finance) or another at least equivalent methodology, the conditions of which can be applied
to the circumstances in Estonia, should be followed.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
54
Spatial layout 5.6.5.1. Coastal sections where it is necessary to look for opportunities
to leave areas free of wind turbines at the level of the permit procedure/EIA.
10. Wherever possible, wind turbines will be positioned in an orderly manner to
minimise their visual impact39. Orderly wind turbine formations should also be
taken into account in different developments/wind farms located behind each
other, where possible. Where possible, the 'wheel effect'40 should be avoided.
11. For wind farms closest to the coast, the design of wind turbines of the same
height (+/- 10% of the total height) is recommended. Avoid, where possible, the
disturbing view created by the topography of the seabed and the siting of the
wind turbines, where towers of different heights "bounce" against the sky,
creating a "broken silhouette". Visual similarity in both the layout and the
parameters of the wind turbines will help to reduce visual distraction.41.
39
It is important to keep this condition in mind in Area 2 from Sõrve to the Elda peninsula and in Area
1 northwards from Ruhnu from the viewpoints closest to the wind farms and where the proposed wind
energy development areas extend deepest into the high seas.
40
A situation where the rotors of the wind turbines lined up one behind the other overlap, creating a
"spinning wheel" on the horizon that attracts the observer's attention. This effect is to be avoided when
deciding on the siting of the wind turbines, see more details in „Guidelines for Methodological
Recommendations for Visual Impact Assessment to Promote the Development of Offshore Windfarms",
AB Artes Terrae OÜ, 2020.
41
See more details in „Guidelines for Methodological Recommendations for Visual Impact
Assessment to Promote the Development of Offshore Windfarms", AB Artes Terrae OÜ, 2020.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
55
Conditions:
1. In order to increase the share of energy production based on renewable
resources, suitable areas for the development of wind energy must be used for
the production of wind energy.
2. Areas suitable for wind energy development overlapping with historically more
intensive trawling areas are designated as reserve areas.
a. The reserve areas can be brought into use from 2027 if the procedures
and studies carried out in other areas suitable for offshore wind
development show that it is not possible to develop sufficient volume of
offshore wind farms in these areas.
b. The criterion of 70% of the volume of all areas suitable for wind energy
development (including reserve areas) is set out in Chapter 5.6.4 as
sufficient volume. The definition of sufficient volume is based on an
assessment carried out jointly by the Consumer Protection and Technical
Regulatory Authority and the Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications.
c. The introduction of reserve areas should be based on an analysis of the
existing situation42 and the economic impact of wind park development
on the fisheries sector trawling and should promote combined use of the
fields of activity in the overlapping areas, including, where appropriate,
implementing compensatory measures.
3. In areas suitable for the development of wind energy, wind turbines will be built
with foundation solutions the environmental impacts of which are equivalent to
or less than the impacts of building wind turbines using gravity-based
foundation technology.
4. If the impact of wind energy development on other technologies is estimated to
be greater than the present one, the gravity-based foundation technology of wind
turbines, a new plan needs to be prepared for the relevant part of the marine
area, and areas suitable for other technologies should be identified.
5. In the light of the rapid development of technology and in order to promote
innovation, the wind energy innovation area shall be designated43.
a. Wind turbines will be built primarily on floating foundations in the wind
energy innovation area. The environmental impact of floating
foundations is equivalent to or smaller than that of the gravity-based
foundation technology underlying this planning solution.
b. The introduction of the innovation area does not require the prior
exhaustion of other wind energy development areas.
c. The conditions set out in this plan must be followed when introducing
the innovation area.
6. In order to reduce the risk of collision with waterbirds the minimum permissible
height of the wind turbine rotor must be at least 25 m above the average high
sea level44. The minimum permissible height can be specified (increased to 30
42
The analysis of the existing situation will be based on e.g. the status of superficies licenses, studies
and EIAs carried out, national climate and energy targets, and other relevant factors.
43
In the designation of the innovation area, overlaps with water traffic areas and areas of high importance
for bird migration were avoided; following the depth limitation (up to 40 m) was not considered
important due to the innovative technology.
44
The average sea level plus the average wave height of the corresponding sea area.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
56
or 35 m, if necessary) on the basis of a study to be carried out during the permit
procedure.
7. The minimum distance between wind farms to mitigate potential wind-shadow
impacts is about 8 wind turbine rotor diameters of the later added wind farm,
with a minimum of 2 km.
8. To minimize the visual impact:
a. Wind turbines shall not be located closer than six nautical miles (11.1
km from the nearest wind turbine) to the mainland and an island with a
permanent settlement).
b. Where several wind farms are planned at the same time, the combined
visual impact of the wind farms shall be assessed. Where possible, the
interaction with other proposed wind farms45 in the same area shall also
be assessed.
9. For reasons of maritime safety, wind turbines shall not be placed on fairways,
including international ship traffic areas and anchorages.
10. In wind energy areas, basic passage corridors for shipping must be maintained
free of wind turbines46 (see step nr 12 in the wind energy development table),
in order to ensure smooth international freight transport and as optimal journey
length as possible47 and the need for turns48. Precise solutions are developed at
the superficies license stage in cooperation with the Transport Administration
and the relevant authorities in neighbouring countries.
11. Wind turbines must not cause the operational capacity of national defense air
surveillance system and sea surveillance system to be impaired, and, where
necessary, compensation mechanisms should be developed and implemented.
In order to avoid a situation where it would be possible to erect buildings that
could pose a threat to security, the competent authority and the developer must
comply with the coordination requirements under the Building Code.
12. When deciding the location and technological solutions of the location of wind
turbines at the level of permit procedure/Environmental Impact Assessment, it
is necessary:
45
Proposed wind farms are wind farms for which the permit procedure has been completed or for which
a positive interim decision has been taken (e.g. an EIA report has been submitted for public consultation).
The approach is based on the European Commission Communication 2021/C 437/01
"Assessment of plans and projects in relation to Natura 2000 sites – Methodological guidance on
the provisions of Article 6(3) and (4) of the Habitats Directive 92/43/EEC“, whereby the provision on
interactions refers to other plans or projects which have been completed, which have been approved but
not completed, or which are proposed (i.e. where a request for approval or consent has been submitted).
46
In Area no 1, the width of the basic passage corridor, based on current knowledge (vessel traffic density
and dimensions), shall be at least 2000 m in order to avoid the extension of the Roomaassaare-Ringsu
shipping line and its diversion towards the high seas. Area no 2 shall have a corridor width of at least
6250 m to ensure the safety and optimal journey of heavy international vessel traffic. The minimum
width required for vessel traffic is calculated according to the formula in footnote 21: W = Ws + 2 (Wr
+ Wc).
47
When bypassing wind energy development areas, the ship's voyage can be calculated to increase by
10 - 30 km depending on the destination and the time spent can increase by 0.5 - 1.5 hours. Depending
on this, fuel consumption also increases, which is difficult to determine because it depends on the type
of ship, the size of the cargo and many other factors.
48
When bypassing wind energy development areas, the ship has to make more turns compared to the
existing directions of movement. Turning points should be avoided when designing fairways (IMO,
2008, Ships' routing, Part A, Chapter 6, Section 6.4), ( PIANC, 2014, MarCom Wg 121 Harbor approach
channels design guidelines, Chapter 3.1.2.1), as they reduce the safety of vessel traffic.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
57
a. To assess noise-related impacts (during construction, operation and
dismantling, with a particular focus on underwater noise, but also
addressing atmospheric airborne noise). Conduct noise modelling
and, upon modelling, consider other wind farms located or planned
in the area.
b. to assess the possible significant adverse impacts of the released heat
energy and possible vibrations related to the magnetic field and
facilities. Carry out modelling, if necessary, and take into account
other wind farms and infrastructure in the area and possibly planned
wind farms in the area.
c. To assess the impact on the living environment of fish, including
fish spawns and migration and benthos. In line with the
precautionary principle, when wind farms are planned, more
detailed studies49 must be carried out at the level of the licensing
procedure in the area of the wind farm and in the area of influence
(e.g. studies describing the impacts of wind turbine operating noise
on fish migration, including mass migrations of economically
important fish to important spawning grounds). In order to mitigate
the impacts during construction, it must be stipulated that noisy
activities (such as the installation of wind turbine foundations,
dismantling of wind turbines) should not take place in the fish
spawning period nor area where a large amount of fish has
accumulated in a limited area.
d. To assess the impact on the living environment of seals. The design
of waterways planned for the maintenance of wind turbines must
take into account the need to minimise disturbance to Baltic ringed
seals.
e. To assess the impact on birds. In collaboration with an avian expert, to
specify the impacts on birds in the light of the scale of the proposed
activity, its exact location, and the technical solution.
i. The eastern part of Area No 1, which is suitable for wind
energy development in the Gulf of Riga, is located close to
an important migration corridor for terrestrial birds
(including birds of prey) across the sea. Clarify the actual
width of the migratory flyway of terrestrial birds near the
eastern part of the development area along the Kihnu-Ruhnu
axis and identify other information necessary for collision
risk assessment (species flight intensities and flight
altitudes). To this end, it will be necessary to carry out a radar
survey covering at least two years of bird migration periods,
in parallel with visual observations50.
49
If an experimental noise study (or other study) is carried out in the Estonian marine area and it is found
that certain fish species are not affected by noise during migration, then this result can be taken as a basis
and no further studies are to be carried out. If a noise study shows that noise is impeding fish migration,
further detailed studies are necessary to map fish migration corridors. If the study shows that there are
significant adverse impacts on fish migration that cannot be mitigated, the scale or other parameters of
the proposed activity should be reduced to avoid adverse impacts or the activity should be abandoned.
50
The methodology should broadly follow the standard survey protocol established in Germany. (BSH,
2013).
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
58
ii. In the case of Area No 2, west of Saaremaa, which is suitable
for wind energy development, specify which part of all
migratory terrestrial birds flies over the sea from the
direction of Hiiumaa to Kuramaa (NNE-SSW) and which
part does not use the main migration route, i.e. does not go
via the Sõrve peninsula to Sääre and from there over the sea
to Kuramaa, but takes the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. To this
end, it will be necessary to carry out a radar survey covering
at least two years of bird migration periods, in parallel with
visual observations51. If necessary, design wind turbines
within the wind farm so that birds can fly through the farm.
iii. In the case of Area No 2, west of Saaremaa, suitable for wind
energy development, the principle of combined use of
marine area should be taken into account and the principle
passage corridor for vessel traffic (currently NNW-SSE)
should be specified, if possible, to better coincide with the
expected predominant migration direction of birds (NNE-
SSW). Birds will then be able to use the area as a migration
corridor, as the width of the shipping corridor for Area 2 is
estimated to be approximately 6250 m.
f. In cooperation with the bat expert, the impacts on bats in the light of the
scope, exact location and technical solution of the proposed activity are
to be specified, by conducting field surveys of bats before construction
of the wind park in the sea area to be developed. Monitoring of bats is
to be continued during construction and operation of the wind farm52.
g. Carry out geological surveys53 and assess the impact on the seabed.
h. assess the impact of the proposed activities and possible icebreaking
works on changes in ice cover and the mobility of sea ice; and consider
the risk to the resilience of installations due to ice conditions.
i. to design a sea-grid substation in cooperation with AS Elering in wind
energy area No 1 and area No 254. The approximate construction area of
the substation is 200 x 200 m (see also the explanation on the sea-grid
in Chapter 5.7).
j. To assess the spread of suspended solids during construction (potential
impact on habitats, plants, spawning ground).
k. To assess landscape and visual impacts. The assessment must be carried
out by an appropriate expert using the guidance material developed55 or
51
The methodology should broadly follow the standard survey protocol established in Germany. (BSH,
2013).
52
This requirement is also included in Resolution No. 8.4 of the Meeting of the Parties to the European
Agreement on the Conservation of Bats (EUROBATS) (adopted in October 2018, see
https://www.eurobats.org/node/1422#1).
53
The "Overview of marine geological datasets for the planning of offshore wind farms", prepared by
the Geological Survey of Estonia in 2021, provides a starting point for the studies.
54
If the cooperation during the licensing procedure shows that the design of a sea-grid substation is not
necessary in the context of a specific permit procedure, there is no need to address the issue.
55
See more details in „Guidelines for Methodological Recommendations for Visual Impact Assessment
to Promote the Development of Offshore Windfarms", AB Artes Terrae OÜ, 2020.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
59
an equivalent generally accepted methodology appropriate to Estonian
circumstances, involving the local municipality and the coastal
community56. Attention should be paid, inter alia, to the following
points:
i. The need to meet climate objectives and the fact that the siting of
wind turbines may also be constrained by the preservation of
natural assets and other uses of the sea (e.g. maritime transport).
ii. The methodological assessment of the visual impact for the
optimal siting of wind turbines must start at an early stage of the
wind farm design and take into account the realistic visibility
distance.
iii. The visualisations elaborated for the wind farm shall give as true
a representation of the wind farm as possible to the human eye
without distortion, and the execution of visualisations must be
verifiable.
iv. Wind turbines should be grouped as compactly as possible,
taking into account the needs of the technological solutions of
the wind turbine (e.g., dispersion to maximize power production
and longevity).
v. avoiding the formation of small clusters of wind turbines, or
individual isolated wind turbines on the periphery of the wind
farm, which appear to be isolated clusters from the main row of
wind turbines.
l. To set conditions for wind turbine demolition, including considering the
additional damage to benthic biotopes associated with the removal of
wind turbine foundations.
m. To cooperate with the Police and Border Guard Board in ensuring the
operational capability of maritime surveillance radar communications
and protecting national borders. Where appropriate, a study shall be
conducted to clarify the effect on the surveillance radar and to determine
compensatory measures.
n. To cooperate with the Ministry of Defense to ensure the operational
capability of national defense air surveillance.
o. To cooperate with the Transport Administration in order to specify the
possible air traffic corridors, and to avoid disturbances in navigation
systems.
p. In case of overlap with the water traffic areas, to specify the location of
the wind turbines and the functioning of water traffic in cooperation with
the Transport Administration, based on up-to-date data, assessing, inter
alia, the impact on vessel traffic (among other things, the economic
impact of longer travel distances and the increased level of risk
associated with limiting and increasing traffic and taking into account
the needs of neighbouring countries). In cooperation with the Transport
Administration, the need for cross-border maritime transport
cooperation will be determined.
q. To specify the width of the buffer zone required for maritime safety
when bordering the water traffic area, based on up-to-date data in
cooperation with the Transport Administration.
56
E.g. through the use of workshops, debates, surveys or other participatory methods.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
60
r. Wind turbines cannot overlap with cultural monuments. To evaluate the
impact on cultural heritage, which will be the subject of a preliminary
underwater archaeological study.
s. To cooperate with the Ministry of Defense to determine the likelihood
that historic explosives and other dangerous objects will be found.
t. To co-operate with the Ministry of Rural Affairs when placing wind
turbines in areas overlapping with trawl fishing, analyse the economic
impacts of trawling on the fisheries sector and promote combined cross-
sectoral use in overlapping areas, including, where appropriate, through
implementing compensatory measures.
u. when designing wind farms, the combined impacts of wind turbines and
cables (both internal and external) in the marine area must be assessed.
5.6.6 Cable corridors from wind energy development areas to land
In order to transmit the electricity planned to be generated, it is necessary to create an
energy network that is connected to the onshore transmission network. The specific
connection capacity in wind farms depends on the connection conditions provided by
AS Elering. Reinforcement work is also needed in the current transmission network. In
the long run, in order to connect wind farms to today's transmission network, an energy
network connecting the development of offshore wind energy must be created based on
the total social cost. With the help of it, the planned wind energy development areas
must be connected to each other and also to the wind energy development areas of
neighboring countries. In this case, it is possible to use the wind resource of areas for
wind energy development planned for the entire Estonian marine area. The construction
of the energy network of marine areas will be resolved separately; following the
conditions set out in Chapters 5.6.6 and 5.7, it does not constitute a change to this
Maritime Spatial Plan. In the long run, so-called off-grid solutions (e.g., hydrogen
technology) or electricity-to-gas solutions, where energy is transferred from marine
areas to land in the form of gas, may also be likely.
Pursuant to the Planning Act, the task of the national Maritime Spatial Plan is to define
areas suitable for the development of the energy network. For the purposes of the
solution of this plan, this also means the need to determine the conceptual locations of
the cable corridors for the connection of the planned wind farms to the onshore
transmission network (see the spatial layout below). Determining the conceptual
locations of cable corridors is necessary at the strategic level for impact assessment to
ensure that the plan is implementable. For the same purpose, the estimated width of the
corridors was determined to be 200 m57. The real need for space of the seabed, technical
solution and exact location will become clear at the stage of the permit procedure. An
57
The conceptual width of the cable corridor is determined on the basis of the extent of protection
zones, 100 m on each side of the cable in accordance with Regulation No. 73 of the Minister of
Economic Affairs and Infrastructure of 25.06.2015 „Extent of the protection zone of a structure,
procedures for activities within the protection zone and requirements for the marking of the protection
zone“. The experience of other countries is similar, for example, in the largest wind farm in
Scandinavia, in Vattenfall wind farm in Denmark, the width of the corridor was calculated to be 100 m,
to which a safety buffer was added.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
61
impact assessment has been carried out in the marine area on the conceptual locations
of the cable corridors. The guidelines for the creation of connections have been set for
the mainland (see the guidelines below).
The conceptual locations of cable corridors in areas suitable for the development of
wind energy in the marine area are arranged in such a way that they take into account
Natura 2000 sites and their conservation objectives, i.e., do not affect them. The shortest
possible distance to the connection point, the location and capacity of the existing
transmission network and the development trends of electricity supply known today
have also been considered important in the planning of connections.
An alternative location to the cable corridor may be found in the development of wind
farms at the superficies license stage, provided that this does not have a significant
adverse impact on wildlife and adverse impacts on Natura 2000 sites. The conservation
objectives of national nature protection areas must also be taken into account. The
construction of the cable corridor in an alternative location, but in compliance with the
conditions set by this plan, does not necessarily require the preparation of a new plan,
as it does not have a significant spatial impact and does not affect the implementation
of the planning solution58.
In the planning area of the marine area of Pärnu County, the construction of cables must
take into account the conditions of the MSP of the marine area bordering Pärnu County.
Wind energy development areas will be connected to onshore substations, the likely
connections are shown on spatial layout 5.6.6.1. Wind energy development areas can
also be connected to the Harku substation, for example, a cable corridor can run in the
exclusive economic zone, on the border of the territorial sea. When constructing a cable
corridor, the conditions set by this plan must be followed.
58
The need for a plan depends on the site-specific situation, the technology of the facility to be built and
the legislation in force at the time. It is necessary to assess whether or not a plan needs to be compiled
each time an alternative site is used.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
62
Spatial layout 5.6.6.1 Conceptual locations of electricity transmission systems from
wind energy development areas and connections to the onshore energy network.
Electricity transmission systems may also be established inside wind energy
development areas in accordance with guidelines and conditions.
Guidelines:
1. It is most appropriate to connect the offshore wind farms to the onshore
transmission network by means of separate radial direct current links, given that
the capacity of one independent part should not cause a change in the system of
more than 350 MW. It is also possible to connect the offshore wind farm to a
perspective offshore energy network or another network that is necessary for
the transmission of energy generated in the wind farm. The exact maximum
capacity of one independent part depends on the technical connection
conditions issued by the network holder on the basis of real circumstances59.
2. In the case of the construction of adjacent wind farms and same direction
connections, it is expedient to use the same cable corridors to the maximum
extent possible in order to use the seabed more rationally. The aim is to avoid,
as far as possible, the interference with the natural environment associated with
the additional artificial site and to reduce the load on the seabed with the various
cable corridors and their protection zones.
3. When creating new protected natural objects in cable corridors, it is important
to maintain the possibility to perform the necessary cable maintenance works
and install additional cables in the width of the same corridor when developing
the protection regime of the objects.
59
https://elering.ee/eeluuring-ja-tehnilised-tingimused-1
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
63
4. In higher risk areas (e.g., heavy ship traffic - crossing with shipping routes,
overlapping with trawling areas, the area inside the wind farm where
maintenance vessels move, ice movement in shallow water), the cable must be
protected from potential hazards, if necessary, either by covering with concrete
slabs or dredging into the seabed. In order to mitigate the impact of cables, it is
recommended to consider the possibility of burying the cable, for example in
the case of sandbanks. In the case of a hard substrate (for example, in the case
of a “reef” habitat type), it is not practical to bury or cover the cable in deeper
parts of the high seas. Where possible, the external surface of the cable should
have a neutral reaction and allow the organisms to attach.
5. Where possible, give preference to cable lines to minimise negative impacts on
bird populations.
Conditions:
1. When installing wind farm cables, significant adverse environmental impacts
associated with the proposed activity, including cumulative environmental
impacts with nearby structures and objects, must be assessed at the stage of the
superficies license.
2. During the development of wind farms at the stage of the superficies license, an
alternative location for the installation of cables may be found, provided that
this does not lead to significant adverse environmental impacts. Significant
adverse environmental impact on the marine habitats and marine life, including
significant adverse impact on protected natural sites and adverse impact on
Natura 2000 sites must be avoided.
3. When installing cables, apply best available techniques to avoid impacts
(including electromagnetic field impacts) on biodiversity during cable
installation and operation.
4. In the shallow coastal area, the planned submarine cables must be protected in
such a way that ice cannot break the cable. Installations must take account of
the risk posed by ice conditions and be durable.
5. When planning the installation of cables, cooperation with the National
Heritage Board is required at the stage of applying for a superficies license to
avoid damaging seabed cultural heritage.
6. Planning the laying of cables at the stage of applying for a superficies license
must be carried out in co-operation with the Ministry of Defense in order to find
out the need to take into account possible historical explosives and dangerous
objects.
7. Following the construction of the cables, the extraction of mineral resources,
dumping and anchoring in the cable corridors is prohibited.
If offshore wind farms are connected to the onshore transmission network, the
following guidelines must be met.
Guidelines for connecting offshore wind farms onshore:
1. The technical solution of land connections (cable or overhead line, necessary
parameters) and the need for land will be solved in parallel with the superficies
license procedure, either through the planning or design criteria procedure, in
accordance with the legislation in force.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
64
2. The activities necessary for the establishment of the land connection (planning,
public procedure for design criteria, necessity of environmental impact
assessment, etc.) will be solved in parallel with the superficies license
procedure in accordance with the applicable legislation, in cooperation with the
local municipality and the network holder.
3. If a land connection is established with an overhead line, the following must be
taken into account:
a. Avoid placing the overhead line close to residential buildings (up to 100
m) and, if possible, erecting masts in the immediate field of view of
residential buildings to reduce the visual impact.
b. When passing between residential buildings, use the principle of
equality, if possible, so that the residential buildings remain at equal
distances from the overhead line, unless there is an agreement with the
owners of the real estate.
c. Where possible, the overhead corridor shall be located in close
proximity to an existing power line or other technical infrastructure
corridor in order to avoid interference with the natural environment
associated with the additional man-made object and to reduce land
encumbrance through different protection zones.
d. Design the overhead line in as straight segments as possible.
e. If possible, avoid the overlap of the overhead line and its protection zone
with a protected natural object. Significant adverse impacts on protected
objects during construction and operation of the power line and adverse
impacts on Natura 2000 sites must be ruled out.
4. If a land connection is established with a cable line, the following must be taken
into account:
a. When choosing the location of the land cable corridor, it is necessary to
avoid individual nature conservation objects, cultural values and the
immediate vicinity of residential and recreational buildings.
b. Significant adverse impacts on protected natural objects during
construction and operation of the land cable line and adverse impacts on
Natura 2000 sites must be ruled out.
c. Where possible, the cable line should be located in or in close
proximity to the existing technical infrastructure corridor in order to
avoid interference with the natural environment associated with the
additional man-made object and to reduce the encumbrance of the land
through different protection zones
d. When constructing a land cable line, the route corridor may be winding
if necessary, as there is no extensive protection zone.
5. Where possible, give preference to cable lines to minimise negative impacts on
bird populations.
5.7 Seabed infrastructure
The seabed infrastructure promotes better interconnection of Estonia with unified
transmission networks and ensures energy supply to the major islands. Effective
connections with the Nordic market and the islands should be considered important. No
other additional large-scale international connection projects (except for the
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
65
Easternlight and Lilaco communication cables) are currently known. AS Elering is
planning prospective submarine cable lines to improve the security of supply on the
larger islands. Baltic Sea electricity transmission grid operators are also planning a
maritime grid to connect offshore wind farms, helping to achieve climate and energy
policy objectives in a cost-effective way and ensuring security of energy supply. The
exact location of the offshore network will depend on the location of wind energy
development areas in Estonian and Baltic Sea waters. The Maritime Network
Development Plan is planned to be completed in 2023 and the first projects by 2030.
In the longer term, the use of the coastal sea adjacent to densely populated areas for
cooling and thermal energy may be a possible development trend. It is also likely that
pipelines will be built to transport hydrogen, both as a source of energy and as an input
for the chemical industry.
The planned LNG terminals on the Pakri Peninsula and the Muuga and Sillamäe
harbors will also be included in the energy infrastructure.
The MSP as a strategic national level spatial development document does not specify
spatial locations for existing and prospective cables and pipelines (including the use of
the coastal sea for cooling and thermal energy). The exception is the conceptual
interconnection corridors for the wind energy development areas provided in the
current Plan (Chapter 5.6.5). The design and construction of cables and pipelines
(including for the use of the sea for cooling and heating and for the construction of
cables for wind energy developments not related to this plan) is permitted subject to the
following guidelines and conditions and is not an activity changing this Maritime
Spatial Plan.
When laying cables in the Pärnu County Maritime Spatial Plan area, the conditions of
the planning of the marine area bordering Pärnu County shall be taken into account.
Guidelines:
1. In the case of connections in the same direction, it is expedient to use the same
cable/pipeline corridor as much as possible in order to use the seabed more
rationally. The aim is to avoid, as far as possible, the interference with the
natural environment associated with the additional artificial site and to reduce
the load on the seabed with the various cable corridors/pipelines and their
protection zones.
2. When creating new protected natural objects in cable/pipeline corridors, it is
important to maintain the possibility to perform the necessary cable
maintenance works and install additional cables in the width of the same
corridor when developing the protection regime of the objects.
3. In higher risk areas (e.g., heavy ship traffic - crossing with shipping routes,
overlapping with trawling areas, ice movement in areas with shallow water), the
cable/pipeline must be protected from potential hazards, if necessary, either by
covering with concrete slabs or dredging into the seabed. In order to mitigate
the impact of cables/pipelines, it is recommended to consider the possibility of
burying the cable, for example in the case of sandbanks. In the case of a hard
substrate (for example, in the case of a “reef” habitat type), it is not practical
cover the cable/pipeline. Where possible, the external surface of the
cable/pipeline should have a neutral reaction and allow the organisms to attach.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
66
Conditions:
1. Existing cables and pipelines must be taken into account for all uses in the
marine area. If necessary, a qualitative study shall be carried out to assess the
location and condition of the cables, and cooperation with the cable owner shall
be pursued.
2. The details of the laying of the cables and pipelines (location/technical solution,
etc.) will be specified in the framework of specific permit procedures. The need
for an impact assessment, including the nature, scale, and scope of the impact
at the local level, will also be specified.
3. When laying cables, apply the best available technology to avoid possible
significant adverse impacts of electromagnetic fields on biodiversity, incl., fish
stocks.
4. The proposed submarine cables and pipelines shall be protected in the shallow
coastal area so that the cable cannot be broken by ice. Installations must take
account of the risk posed by ice conditions and be durable.
5. When constructing cables and pipelines, it is necessary to exclude significant
adverse impacts on protected natural objects and adverse impacts on Natura
2000 network areas through an appropriate technical solution and location
selection. Cooperation with the Environmental Board is required.
6. When laying cables and pipelines, cooperation with the National Heritage
Board is required at the stage of application for the superficies license to avoid
damage to the seabed cultural heritage.
7. When laying cables and pipelines, cooperation with the Ministry of Defense is
required in the superficies license phase in order to determine the need to take
into account possible historical explosives and dangerous objects.
8. When laying cables and pipelines, the local governments with a cable or
pipeline within 3 nautical miles of its maritime border must be involved at the
superficies license stage.
9. In order to mitigate the impacts of cables and pipelines, for example, in the case
of a sandbank, it is appropriate to consider the possibility of burying the cable.
For hard substrates (such as "reef" habitat types), it is not practical to bury or
cover the cable. Where possible, the external surface of the cable should have a
neutral reaction and allow organisms to attach.
10. Following the installation of the cables, the extraction of mineral resources,
dumping and anchoring in the cable corridors is prohibited.
5.8 Sea tourism and recreation
The marine area is of great value from the point of view of recreation, both as a location
for water-based activities (recreational boating, powerboating, sailing) as well as beach-
based leisure facilities.
Maritime recreational activities are largely regulated by local governments. The
conditions for marine tourism and recreation vary across the Estonian marine area and
coastline, and the nature and intensity of recreational use depend on this.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
67
Due to the nature of the MSP as a strategic spatial development document at the national
level, MSP does not determine areas for the development of marine tourism and
recreation. The designation of areas requires a place-based approach and substantive
discussion at the local level. The MSP provides guidelines based on combined use for
the spatial development of the marine area. The proposal to strengthen land-sea
interactions through land-sea co-operation clusters (see Chapter 5.16) promotes the
development of maritime tourism and recreation.
Guidelines:
1. Expansion of international passenger ship traffic in suitable areas (e.g. Virumaa,
Saaremaa) is important.
2. In order to provide sailing tourists and other recreational craft boatmasters with
more diversified and suitable conditions for route selection and mooring for
yachts, options are planned for stopping yachts, with the widest range of port
services available with at least the distance of 30 nautical miles (approx. 56 km)
(preferred length of day’s sail).
3. The development of sea-based recreational and sporting activities in the
appropriate locations is encouraged.
4. Potential tourist value (e.g., visits to wind farms or aquaculture farms) will also
be considered when developing new uses for the sea - aquaculture, wind energy.
5. Visual impacts are mitigated in the development of wind energy development
areas (see Chapter 5.6.5).
6. Public areas such as beaches, sailing and water sports facilities, and public
access to the sea, as well as important recreational areas and resting places, are
addressed at the local level. Beach-based activities are planned based on the
spatial development needs of the local government in the comprehensive plan60.
7. The recreational needs and safety of the wider public, as well as the impacts on
fish during the spawning period, should be taken into account when designing
areas for water sports and recreation. Powerboating should not jeopardize the
achievement of nature protection goals. By way of exception, the use of
personal watercraft in surveillance and rescue operations is permitted without
restrictions.
5.9 Protected natural objects
Balanced marine use is based on the protection of marine biodiversity and the
sustainable use of natural resources. 19% (6800 km2) of the Estonian marine area is
covered with protected natural objects. The protected part of the Estonian marine area
includes predominantly coastal and shallow water areas and less offshore areas. When
using the marine area, it is also important to keep in mind the marine protection
objectives of partially land-based national parks (Vilsandi, Matsalu, Lahemaa).
HELCOM has set a target of defining at least 10% of the marine basins of each of the
Baltic Sea sub-basins as coastal or marine protected areas. In the marine areas
60
During the preparation of the MSP, the topic of the rights and obligations of local governments in the
use and planning of the marine area emerged. The issue needs regulation and is included in the MSP
Implementation Action Plan.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
68
surrounding Estonia, this objective has not been fulfilled in the case of the Baltic
Proper, whereas Estonia has no protected zones in the exclusive economic zone.61 The
current EU Biodiversity Strategy calls for 30% of marine space to be protected, of
which one third would be strictly protected.
Following the recommendations of the EU Marine Strategy Framework Directive and
HELCOM, the establishment of offshore protected areas in the exclusive economic
zone is under consideration. During a project completed in 202062 it was proposed to
create two protected areas in the exclusive economic zone (areas 73.3 and 36.7 km2).
The larger of these (the proposed 'Kolgi Shoal Marine Protected Area') overlaps in part
with the suitable wind energy development area proposed in this plan (see spatial layout
8 in Chapter 5.6.3). The proposal for the protected area also includes a description of
the restrictions proposed for its protection, which stipulates that the following must be
restricted within the protected area: construction (all renewable energy installations:
wind turbine piles and gravity-based foundation technology, high voltage DC and AC
cables; communication cables); extraction of mineral resources; dredging and dumping;
fishing with seabed-damaging fishing gear; and any disturbance of the seabed. The final
description of the restrictions proposed for protection will be determined during the
process of setting up the protected areas in accordance with the provisions of the Nature
Conservation Act. To this end, it is necessary to consider the impact of the
establishment of protected areas on the social and economic environment, and on
Estonian climate and renewable energy objectives. The establishment of protected areas
is a process separate from the MSP.
61
Estonian Marine Strategy Action Plan, 2016 Tallinn.
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/meetmekava_032017_f.pdf
62
"Preparing a proposal for offshore protected areas in the Estonian Exclusive Economic Zone",
responsible: Martin G; EMI 2020 (https://mereinstituut.ut.ee/et/projektid/avamere-kaitsealade-
ettepaneku-koostamine-eesti-majandusvoondis)
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
69
Spatial layout 5.9.1 Natura 2000 network areas
The MSP takes into account the Habitats Directive and Birds Directive and protected
natural objects63 and values their protection objective. No additional protected natural
objects are planned in the MSP. The creation of new objects shall be carried out in
accordance with the procedure laid down by law. In addition, it is suggested to take into
account the guidelines set out in the plan, which are set in accordance with the objective
of combined use of the marine area and the balancing principles.
Guidelines:
1. Also outside the network of protected areas, the use of the marine space is
guided by the principle of maintaining the good status and functioning of the
ecosystem and thereby ensuring the sustainability of ecosystem services. To
boost the maritime economy, natural resources need to be both used and
maintained at the same time.
2. When planning new developments64 at sea, if necessary, nature values surveys
are carried out, the results of which are taken into account when deciding on the
feasibility of the developments or in the selection of scale, technology, etc.
3. Creating offshore protected areas will be based on the principle of combined
use of the marine area and the need to use marine resources also for energy
production, aquaculture development, national defense, and other uses.
4. When creating a new protected natural object, the spatial shape of the protected
nature object shall, if possible, be adapted to the fairway. The process will
involve cooperation with the Transport Administration and carrying out social
and economic impact assessments to determine the impact on vessel traffic,
63
Consideration is given to both existing protected natural objects in 2021 as well as the planned ones.
64
New developments include both new maritime uses as well as developments related to traditional
maritime uses.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
70
including the economic impact of possible route extensions and the increase in
the level of risk associated with traffic restrictions and increases.
5. For the creation of new protected natural objects for the sea and preparing
protection conditions, additional restrictions must be taken into account so that
the achievement of environmental objectives in the marine area is balanced.
Conditions:
1. The use of marine areas in protected areas is subject to the protection objectives
of the protected areas and the restrictions in force.
2. When planning shellfish and algae cultivation on a protected natural object, the
possibility of synergy is specified in cooperation with the Environmental Board.
5.10 Marine culture
Estonian marine culture is reflected in both its tangible and intangible cultural heritage,
which contributes to meaningfulness and enriches everyday life. Marine culture is
created by users of the marine area and the coast: fishermen, shipbuilders, vacationers,
surfers, divers, etc., also the tangible cultural heritage located in the marine area has an
important role to play (including, e.g., wrecks not yet protected as cultural monuments).
The results of the cultural mapping of the Estonian coast and marine area (see Annex 2
to the Impact Assessment Report) show that the whole Estonian coast is valuable in one
way or another. Sparsely populated coastal areas are valuable either naturally and/or
culturally, and both recreational services as well as and social infrastructures supporting
maritime culture at local level are concentrated in coastal villages and towns. The
coastal sea contains valuable landscapes (e.g., Neugrund Bank), wreckage areas, and
marine areas used for water sports. Sea views of the Tallinn skyline are also important
values65. The protection objectives of national parks (Vilsandi, Matsalu, Lahemaa) also
affect marine culture.
In order to link the cultural values of the sea to the wider uses of the sea and the coast,
the so-called land-sea clusters which allow the meaningful use of the "maritime aspect"
to guide the future development of the region were proposed in the impact assessment
(see Chapter 5.16).
The MSP does not designate specific areas of marine culture due to the strategic nature
of the spatial development document at the national level. Both intangible and tangible
marine culture is valued by planning through setting priorities and guidelines.
Guidelines:
1. Take into account the use of the marine area that is appropriate in respect of the
natural and cultural characteristics of the area when drawing up plans for a tract
of land.
2. Encourage the coexistence of traditional and emerging marine cultures. In order
to preserve marine culture values on the coast and in the coastal sea, it is
important to agree on synergies at the local level.
65
View corridors are set out in documents separate from the present plan (Statutes of Tallinn Old Town
Heritage Site, Thematic Planning of High-Rise Buildings of Tallinn, etc).
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
71
3. Strengthen traditional marine culture through harbors operating in naturally
suitable sites and effective regulations in the field of fisheries.
5.11 Cultural monuments
Shipwrecks, for which the Baltic Sea offers unique preservation conditions, represent
the largest part of the maritime material cultural heritage. Interest in exploring Estonia's
underwater cultural heritage is growing, and diving clubs also host visitors from
Finland, Latvia, Russia, and Germany.
Spatial layout 5.11.1 Cultural Monuments
The taking of new cultural heritage sites under protection or changes to the protection
regime shall not be deemed to constitute a change to the MSP.
The maritime spatial plan will designate preservation areas for underwater cultural
heritage , the location of which has been based on the following criteria:
- depth of 15-30 metres,
- location does not overlap with anchorage areas, refuges, fairways and water traffic
areas,
- location does not overlap with wind energy development areas,
- location does not overlap with dumping areas,
- location does not overlap with mineral deposits, special areas of national defense,
possible cables,
- if possible, proximity to wrecks that have already been sunk.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
72
The purpose of designating the sites is to ensure the preservation of underwater cultural
objects that have come to light, in a situation where they cannot be preserved in their
original location, nor can they be preserved, stored or exhibited in museum collections.
The transfer of underwater cultural objects shall be considered only in justified cases,
which involve preliminary underwater archaeological research of the site in order to
determine the condition of the thing, the extent of the archaeological layer and the
feasibility of the transfer. If the condition of the thing allows it to be moved, underwater
archaeological excavations must be performed at the site.
Wrecks of cultural value dating from the first half of the 20th century can pose a threat
to the environment66 in three ways:
1) fuel/fuel oils;
2) explosives;
3) ghost nets.
Wrecks of ships that were sunk in the first half of the 20th century, which pose a
potential risk to the environment and are of cultural value, are not among the wrecks
that can be moved and sunk in the preservation area.
Spatial layout 5.11.2. Preservation areas for underwater cultural heritage
66
As a result of the project "Mapping, documentation and risk assessment of environmentally hazardous
wrecks", which ended in 2019, ships that sank in the 20th century were mapped and their environmental
hazards analysed. The assessment of the environmental hazards of ships that sank in the 20th century
identified 72 ships that could pose a medium risk and one wreck that could pose a high risk to the
environment in terms of fuel, based on historical sources. Of these, 44 wrecks have been found to date.
The locations of the remaining 28 wrecks are still unknown, but their approximate locations are known.
Studies have identified that the wreck's condition is also influenced by the amount of time the wreck has
been submerged, how deeply it is buried in sediments, and chemical, physical and biological factors. It
has been found that the deeper a wreck is buried in soft sediments, the better it resists external agents.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
73
Guidelines:
1. The design of "dive parks" to facilitate access to wrecks in monument-rich and
highly visible marine areas is favored.
2. When planning new developments, and in case of the emergence of underwater
cultural heritage, responsive and sustainable access to the original site for the
purpose of observing or documenting the cultural heritage will be encouraged.
3. The importance of sea views of land-based cultural monuments is emphasized.
Conditions:
1. Anchoring, trawling, dredging, and dumping of solids are prohibited in the area
of cultural monuments (site with a buffer zone). Other activities (e.g., fishing,
diving) are allowed, provided they do not endanger the preservation of the
cultural heritage.
2. Diving in an underwater monument and its protection zone may be carried out
under the supervision of a competent person of a company providing diving
services or on the basis of a diving permit.
3. Preference is given to the preservation of monuments in their original location.
4. An underwater monument and archaeological find may be relocated from its
location to a preservation area designated by the plan (see spatial layout 5.11.2),
if it is essential to ensure a high-level of public interest and the preservation of
the monument in the existing environment is endangered (e.g., existing port
waters, filled former marine areas) and its preservation cannot be guaranteed in
any other way. Only such wrecks of cultural value that do not pose a threat to
the environment, such as hulls of wooden ships, may be relocated to the
preservation area. The conditions for relocation of underwater monuments and
archaeological finds are determined by the National Heritage Board in
accordance with the regulations on the relocation of monuments and
archaeological finds and the sinking of things with underwater cultural value.
Sinking of shipwrecks in the area designated by the plan will require registration
of activities involving a risk to the aquatic environment in accordance with
current legislation.
5. An underwater archaeological study shall be carried out before planning
activities that may endanger the preservation of the underwater cultural
heritage.
5.12 National defense
Consideration of national defense interests is necessary to ensure the state's defense
capability. According to the National Defense Development Plan 2017-2026, the
strategic goals of the state are prevention and management of threats and tensions
related to national defense, increased deterrence against any military aggressor, faster
development of the state's independent defense capability, the ability to resist attack by
the actions of society as a whole, the ability to quickly resolve national defense crises
and conflicts, increasing the coherence of Estonian society and ensuring the readiness
to resist the information war. National defense interests at sea include the definition of
special areas and the maintenance of airborne radar capability. Special areas of national
defense have been formed by orders of the Minister of Defense to conduct anti-aircraft,
artillery, naval or other types of exercises.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
74
Spatial layout 5.12.1 Special Areas of National Defense
The MSP takes into account the spatial needs of national defense. The introduction of
new areas is allowed, including outside the existing and prospective areas shown in
Spatial layout 5.12.1. The creation of new areas shall be carried out in accordance with
the procedure laid down by law and with the guidelines laid down in the MSP.
Guidelines:
1. The need for new special areas of national defense and the boundaries of
existing areas may be adjusted in the light of changes in armaments, training
methods, and other factors.
2. National defense activities shall, as far as possible, take into account other uses
of the sea and the interests of local coastal communities.
3. Major blasting in the water should be planned so that it does not occur in a fish
spawning season and in an area where a large amount of fish has accumulated
in a limited area. In order to mitigate the potential impact, it is advisable to repel
the fish out of the area with smaller charges before using larger explosive
charges.
4. It is desirable to have an environmental action plan in place to ensure a
minimum of damage to wildlife.
5. Special national defense areas are open for navigation all year round, except
when closed for national defense training. During the exercises, maritime traffic
is regulated, if necessary, in cooperation with the Transport Administration and
the Police and Border Guard Board.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
75
6. In the interest of safety, information on training shall be given in navigation
information, including, where appropriate, in the mass media, on local
government websites, and at local information points.
Condition:
1. Aquaculture development area cannot overlap with the special area of national
defense.
5.13 Mineral resources
Mineral resources located in the Estonian marine space help to ensure the security of
supply and relieve the burden on the resources of the earth's crust. The European
Commission's Integrated Maritime Policy sees the extraction of mineral resources from
the bottom of the sea as an important part of the blue economy.
It is estimated that67 mining of non-living natural resources will continue in Estonia at
current levels until 2030, but the environmental impact of mining activities is expected
to increase in the long term as a result of pressure to exploit the resource more.
Spatial layout 5.13.1 Mineral deposits
No new mineral deposits are planned with maritime planning, but it is important to
ensure that existing mineral resources remain minable. The designation of new mining
assignments or deposits under the terms of the planning shall not be deemed to be a
modification of the maritime plan.
67
Marine Strategy Marine Environmental Assessment Report 2018
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
76
Guideline:
1. Mineral deposits that are located outside important fish spawning grounds are
to be preferred.
Conditions:
1. If the mineral deposits overlap with the water traffic areas, the use of the mineral
deposits shall be ensured, if necessary; in cooperation with Transport
Administration ship traffic and shall be temporarily reorganized based on up-
to-date water traffic data.
2. Mining of mineral deposits must be done in cooperation with the National
Heritage Board so that the condition of the seabed's cultural assets is not
affected by the mining activities.
3. In case of overlap of the mineral deposit with protected natural objects, the
conditions set for the protection of natural values must be taken into account.
4. The permit process must include environmental measures to minimize impact,
including mitigation of the emerging of suspended solids in the water column.
5.14 Dumping
Controlled use of the marine area for discharges or burying in the seabed is required for
the disposal of sediments emerging from port dredging, and other materials. The main
dredging in Estonian waters is the maintenance dredging of harbors and ship canals,
where the dredged material is predominantly sand and fine-grained sediment. Dumping
areas have been designated in the past (separately from the marine spatial plan) for
regular large-scale dumping of dredging spoil68.
68
Kaadamisala on eelkõige ala, kuhu pikema aja jooksul planeeritakse regulaarselt hakata
süvenduspinnast paigutama.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
77
Spatial layout 5.14.1 Dumping areas (existing areas designated separately from the
maritime spatial planning process).
No new dumping areas are planned with the maritime plan. Priority shall be given to
the use of existing dumping areas. The designation of new dumping areas shall not be
considered as a modification of the maritime plan provided that the conditions laid
down in the maritime plan are complied with.
Guidelines:
1. When designating new dumping areas, avoid very shallow sea areas where
possible to preserve their biodiversity, and to avoid coastal erosion.
2. As a general principle, dumping during an ecologically sensitive period
(e.g., fish spawning season, etc.) should be avoided where technically and
economically feasible.
Conditions:
1. Further use of existing dumping areas and the introduction of new areas will
be specified during the process of issuing a permit for dredging of the water
body or for dumping. Dumping shall be based on the conditions specified
in the environmental permit.
2. Priority shall be given to areas outside protected natural objects when
creating new dumping areas. When carrying out the proposed activity, the
potential accompanying impacts must be assessed and adverse impacts must
be excluded.
3. The choice of dumping site (including depth), time (e.g., outside fish
spawning periods and critical period of juveniles) and technology (e.g.,
measures to limit the generation and spread of suspended solids) should take
into account wider impacts on marine biota, but more narrowly impact on
fish and thereby on the fishing industry along with its socio-economic
aspect.
4. Aquaculture development areas cannot overlap with dumping areas.
5. The impact on existing bathing areas shall be taken into account when
introducing new dumping areas. The dumping float must not impair the
quality of the bathing water.
6. When planning new dumping sites, an underwater archaeological study of
the undiscovered or unexplored underwater cultural heritage must be carried
out.
7. When introducing new dumping areas, the Ministry of Defense should be
consulted on the issue of the potential danger of floating mines, and if
necessary, additional safety studies of the area should be conducted.
8. When introducing new dumping areas, the activities must be coordinated
with the Transport Administration and the Environmental Board.
5.15 Permanent Connections
Estonia's national plan, "Estonia 2030+", considers the importance of a coherent
settlement structure: access to services, educational institutions, and jobs. In addition
to better linking of the functional areas, faster and more convenient connections to the
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
78
outside world are also aimed. Functioning transport infrastructure is key to achieving
the objectives.
In the field of transport infrastructure, a national designated spatial plan and a strategic
environmental impact assessment have been initiated for the planning of the permanent
connection of the Suur Strait (tunnel or bridge) and designing the infrastructure needed
for its operation69. The planning of the Tallinn-Helsinki railway tunnel in close
cooperation with the Finnish state is likely to be the second major development project
in the next decade. These are facilities with significant spatial impact, the
implementation of which is expected to have a significant impact on the living and
natural environment. The impact will depend to a large extent on the precise design of
the permanent connections (e.g., bridge or tunnel, specific location, etc.). Both
development projects require a thorough substantive approach, location-based research
with feasibility and cost-benefit analysis. Also important is the public planning process
for reaching a social contract.
The detailed planning of the permanent connection of the Suur Strait is based on the
Saare County and Lääne County plans, which cover the terrestrial part of the potential
permanent connection. For more detailed planning of the Tallinn-Helsinki railway
tunnel, the general basis is provided by the national plan "Estonia 2030+", and Harju
County Planning, which deals with the terrestrial part of the connection, provides basic
guidance. When drawing up local government plans, the provisions of the county-wide
spatial plans concerning permanent connections shall be taken into account.
Permanent connections are planned with separate and more precise plans at the state
level by the decision of the Government of the Republic. In the case of connections
with a neighboring country, such plans are drawn up on the basis of intergovernmental
agreements. Simultaneously with preparation of the plan, an appropriate impact
assessment, including a strategic environmental assessment, must be carried out. The
planning area shall cover both the sea and the land area to the extent necessary to enable
the most appropriate site selection for the particular site and the implementation of the
planning.
5.16 Land-sea interactions
Most marine area activities are functionally or spatially related to land. Therefore, it is
important to have a substantive link between marine and land-based planning and the
integration of development documents. The topics covered in this chapter are also
guidelines for planning by local authorities. The topics should be considered in the
context of the preparation of the comprehensive plan, taking into account the specific
local circumstances and the spatial development principles set by the comprehensive
plan. References to the content chapters and previous studies are provided by topic to
facilitate further development of the topic in the comprehensive and detail plans.
69
Vabariigi Valitsus 18.06.2020 korraldus nr 213, https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/319062020004
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
79
Land-sea interactions include both broader impacts (e.g., agricultural pollution as a
deteriorating factor for water) and site-specific spatial interfaces (ports, cable
connections). The following summary is based on the approach to the MSP and focuses
on spatial interfaces.
1. Ports and maritime transport
The presence of ports is the main prerequisite for the exploitation of the marine
area. Ports as a focal point for maritime transport provide access to fishing
grounds, enable installation and maintenance of offshore facilities, development
of freight and passenger traffic, carry out pollution control, and rescue at sea.
Ports and maritime transport create preconditions for other maritime uses.
Guidelines and conditions for ports and maritime transport are provided in
Chapter 5.4.3.
2. Maritime recreational activities.
The maritime recreational industry is related to both ports and coastal areas in
general. In order to increase the recreational use of the sea, attention should be
paid on the local level to the use of public beaches, sailing and powerboating
sites, recreational areas, and public accesses to the sea. At the same time,
temporal restrictions on the use of recreational watercraft (e.g. scooters) should
be considered to avoid adverse impacts on fish fauna (movement in spawning
grounds immediately during spawning). Free access to the sea and public use of
the seashore is an essential element of quality of life, especially in and in the
immediate vicinity of densely populated areas.
The beach-based activities are planned based on the spatial development needs
of the local government in the comprehensive plan. The planning of recreational
activities can be based on the baseline studies made in the framework of the
MSP (see http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/uuringud.html, baseline studies on both
wildlife and socio-cultural issues).
Guidelines and conditions for recreational activities are provided in Chapter 5.8.
3. Protection of marine culture.
The preservation and viability of marine culture depend to a large extent on
local interests and values. It is expedient to pay attention to the valuing of
marine culture in the comprehensive plans of the local governments of the
coastal area.
Guidelines and conditions for marine culture are given in Chapters 5.10 and
5.11.
4. Cable corridors for offshore wind farms
The operation of offshore wind farms requires real space also onshore through
cable corridors. Infrastructure related to offshore activities (e.g. cable
connections for wind farms) will be planned onshore through planning and
design processes, in line with existing legislation.
Guidelines and conditions for cable corridors are given in Chapters 5.6.6 and
5.7.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
80
5. National defense
Special areas of national defense have been formed to conduct anti-aircraft,
artillery, and naval exercises. Training exercises can have an impact on land
(noise) and can also involve land (land-to-sea shooting exercises).
Guidelines and conditions for national defense are provided in Chapter 5.12.
6. Permanent Connections
The possible establishment of permanent connections will have a major impact
on the further development of coastal regions. The detailed planning of
permanent connections is based on the Saare County, Lääne County, and Harju
County planning guidelines and the relevant sectoral decisions of the state.
The topic of permanent connections is covered in Chapter 5.15.
7. Viability of coastal areas.
Offshore activities support the viability of coastal communities by providing
jobs and creating a consumer community for services. In addition to traditional
fishing and port services, the maintenance of new facilities (aquaculture, wind
turbines), as well as the development of distributed energy, may be added in the
long term. Guidelines for providing additional employment to traditional sea
users are set out in Chapters 5.3.1, 5.3.2, and 5.6.5.
Coastal areas are home to communities carrying diverse marine cultures-in
addition to coastal fishermen, also surfers, sailors, birdwatchers, etc. In order to
preserve the different values of marine culture, it is important to agree on
synergies at the local level, e.g., in the context of the comprehensive planning
process, taking into account local specificities.
Marine culture mapping has been carried out in the framework of the MSP,
where the most important keywords are drawn up by counties, which may be
helpful in the preparation of comprehensive plans (see
http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/lähteseisekohad.html, mapping of the cultural
values of the sea). Source data for the assessment of social and cultural impacts
collected as a baseline studies of MSP is also informative (see
http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/uuringud.html).
The regional specificity of the Estonian marine space and coastline is expressed by the
so-called land-sea clusters. The development of land-sea clusters is based on the
Estonian Regional Development Strategy 2014-2020, the newly developed maritime
strategies of the counties (2018-2019), and the cultural mapping of the maritime
counties carried out in the framework of the MSP. These clusters are based on the direct
visions and development directions of the county strategies (e.g., the development of
the Tallinn-Helsinki twin city in Harju County) as well as analytical generalizations
based on the development strategy (e.g., Ida-Viru County as an Estonian adventure
tourism region and ranking second as a place for visiting after Harju County). Cultural
mapping carried out under the MSP (see http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/uuringud.html
collection and analysis of source data to assess the social and cultural impacts;
http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/lähteseisukohad.html, regional portraits) provided input
on regional specificities, strengths, and potentials. The keywords in the cluster names
help to strengthen the local specificity for further development.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
81
Spatial layout 5.16.1 Land-sea clusters
The above issues, together with the guidelines and conditions of this plan, must be taken
into account in the preparation of comprehensive plans for the municipalities with a sea
border and other development documents.
The following spatial layout shows the general picture of the spatial trends of the
Estonian marine and terrestrial areas.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum 82
Spatial layout 5.16.2. Use of the marine area and National Spatial Plan Estonia 2030+
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
83
5.17 Refinement of the national plan "Estonia 2030+"
The Maritime Spatial Plan has been drafted as a thematic plan of the national plan,
which complements and refines the "Estonia 2030+" solution.
The MSP specifies the national plan for electricity supply. The national plan foresaw
the construction of a high-voltage ring line (circular line) connecting the islands of
western Estonia and the mainland, which will allow better connection of offshore wind
farms to the grid, in order to increase security of supply on islands and to promote the
use of local renewable energy sources.
In the process of elaborating the MSP, a West-Estonian ring line is foreseen in the
direction of Saaremaa. The connection of Hiiumaa to the 110kV line has been
abandoned on the basis of input from the Estonian energy system operator Elering AS.
The principal direction indicated in the national plan is not suitable for connecting
offshore wind farms, as the planning of a high-voltage line corridor across Hiiumaa is
not possible due to constraints. Elering AS has confirmed that the 110 kV connection
to Hiiumaa proposed in the national plan will not be realised in the next 15 years.
Electricity network developments are planned on a needs basis. Elering AS has clarified
that a new 110 kV power line has just been completed in the Suur Strait and that no
other major transmission developments are planned in this direction in the next 15
years. Elektrilevi is in the process of strengthening the Saare-Hiiu connection, which
will also improve the security of supply in Hiiumaa.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
84
6. DEFINITIONS
The following list summarises explanations of definitions used in the Estonian maritime
spatial planning and impact assessment. The definitions are based on the purpose of the
plan and the issues that have emerged during the planning and impact assessment
process.
Relevant impact – Any impact, including both significant and non-significant,
associated with the implementation of a specific plan that needs to be evaluated.
Offshore – the deeper part of the sea beyond the coastal zone, and the islands, where
the formation and movement of water masses do not directly reflect the impact of the
coast.
Biosecurity – the need to prevent the introduction of pathogens and parasites from
farms into the nature and vice versa, as well as the movement of pathogens and parasites
between different nearby farms.
Distributed energy – the production of electricity generated at the consumer's site in
micro- and mini-generation and heating plants located in isolated and dispersed
locations
HELCOM – the Helsinki Commission, also the Baltic Marine Environment Protection
Commission, which organizes international co-operation under the Convention on the
Protection of the Marine Environment of the Baltic Sea Area.
Dumping – any deliberate disposal at sea or the burial in the seabed of wastes or other
matter or objects from a ship, aircraft, platform or other offshore installation.70
Dumping of waste is not allowed in the Baltic Sea and dumping is only allowed from
dredging surfaces.
Dumping area – a dumping area is, in particular, an area where dredged material is
planned to be placed on a regular basis over a longer period of time. A single dumping
does not immediately transform an area into a dumping area.
Kavandatav tuulepark tuulepark, mille loamenetlus on lõpule viidud või mille osas
on langetatud positiivne vaheotsus (nt on avalikustamiseks esitatud KMH aruanne).
Käsitluses tuginetakse Euroopa Komisjoni teatisele nr 2021/C 437/01 „Natura 2000
aladega seotud kavade ja projektide hindamine. Metoodilised suunised elupaikade
direktiivi 92/43/EMÜ artikli 6 lõigete 3 ja 4 sätete kohta“, mille järgi koosmõju
käsitlevas sättes peetakse silmas teisi kavasid või projekte, mis on lõpule viidud, mis
on heakskiidetud, kuid lõpule viimata, või mille kohta on tehtud ettepanek (st on
esitatud heakskiitmis- või nõusolekutaotlus).
Proposed wind farm – a wind farm for which the permit procedure has been completed
or for which a positive interim decision has been taken (e.g. an EIA report has been
70
Convention on the Prevention of Marine Pollution by Dumping of Wastes and Other Matter (LC),
1972 (and the 1996 London Protocol); veeseadus
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
85
submitted for public consultation). The approach is based on the European Commission
Communication 2021/C 437/01
"Assessment of plans and projects in relation to Natura 2000 sites – Methodological g
uidance on the provisions of Article 6(3) and (4) of the Habitats Directive 92/43/EEC“,
whereby the provision on interactions refers to other plans or projects which have been
completed, which have been approved but not completed, or which are proposed (i.e.
where a request for approval or consent has been submitted).
Environmental measures - measures for the prevention, reduction and mitigation, and,
in justified cases, remediation of adverse environmental impacts accompanying the
implementation of activities proposed pursuant to the Environmental Impact
Assessment and Environmental Management System Act. Environmental measures
also include environmental monitoring.
Average high sea level – the average sea level plus the average wave height of the
corresponding sea area.
EIA – Environmental Impact Assessment. In a narrower sense, environmental impact
assessment is the assessment of the impact at the planning level of a specific activity,
i.e., the so-called project level (construction project, superficies license, environmental
permit etc.).
SEA – Strategic Environmental Assessment. The SEA is used to assess the impact of
planned activities at a more general level (strategic development documents, such as
planning, development plans, etc.), i.e., at a "higher altitude." The SEA is more general
and less detailed than the EIA.
Guest Harbor – A small-craft harbor for recreational boats, with a high culture of
service and versatile support services and amenities.
Fairway – that part of the waterway that is most suitable for navigation and published
in navigation information and, where appropriate, marked in nature. The location of the
fairway is mostly due to natural conditions and changing it would cause significant
disruption to water traffic. Traffic separation schemes are also considered as part of the
fairway.
The Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) – part of the marine area located outside the
territorial sea adjacent to the latter, the boundaries of which are determined by
agreements between the Republic of Estonia and the neighboring countries. In the
exclusive economic zone, the coastal state has priority over the living marine resources
and the exclusive right to exploit the natural resources of the seabed and to establish
artificial islands. The exclusive economic zone is governed by the United Nations
Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
Conditions of use of the marine area – the plan sets out the prerequisites and
requirements for the use of the marine area by functions and areas to ensure sustainable
and balanced use of the marine area.
Implementing the MSP – authorizing the use of the marine area and carrying out
activities in accordance with the guidelines and conditions agreed upon in the plan.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
86
Marine culture – all human activities and their impact on the sea. Marine culture is
created by users of the marine area and the coast: fishermen, shipbuilders, vacationers,
surfers, divers, etc., as well as the tangible cultural heritage located in the marine area.
Marine culture encompasses the lives of both seafarers and coastal people, as well as
the expression of the maritime sphere in culture.
Sea county – a county that has a sea border.
Nautical mile – the unit of length. One nautical mile equals one arc minute (latitude
minute) of the Earth's meridian. For the purposes of this plan, the length of the nautical
mile is 1852 meters.
Marine transport – in a narrower sense, a mode of transport, in a wider sense, a
domain that includes among other things, ships, ports and shipping routes, goods and
passengers, which together constitute a fully functioning system and individually would
not exist in this form.
Bunkering – Supplying ships with motor fuel or oils, discharge of bilge and tank wash
water and oil residues.
Permanent connection – for the purposes of this plan, the part of the transport
infrastructure which allows continuous movement over the sea.
International ship traffic area – the area through the Estonian EEZ where there are
vessel traffic management measures approved by the International Maritime
Organization (IMO), with a safety margin added according to the methodology for
determining the safety margin for water traffic areas. International ship traffic areas are
considered equivalent to fairways in the context of the MSP.
Wheel effect – A situation where the rotors of the wind turbines lined up one behind
the other overlap, creating a "spinning wheel" on the horizon that attracts the observer's
attention. This effect is to be avoided when deciding on the siting of the wind turbines,
see more details in „Guidelines for Methodological Recommendations for Visual
Impact Assessment to Promote the Development of Offshore Windfarms", AB Artes
Terrae OÜ, 2020.
Special National Defense Area – a special area of the sea formed by order of the
Minister of Defense for conducting anti-aircraft, artillery, naval or other sorts of
exercises.
Blue economy, i.e blue growth – sustainable maritime economy, covering all areas
related to the sea: tourism, renewable energies, aquaculture, fisheries, biotechnology,
use of seabed mineral resources, etc.
Internal waters – is the part of the marine area lying between the baselines of the
territorial sea and the coast. The baseline of the territorial sea is the imaginary line
connecting the points of land, islands, islets, rocks, and individual rocks protruding
from the water that is the furthest from the coast.
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
87
Guideline – general guidance from the plan following of which is desirable and based
on the long-term vision and the needs for the combined use of the marine area.
Compliance with the guideline will be monitored by the authority responsible for the
area. Deviations from the guideline must be made in collaboration with other involved
or affected parties to ensure the full implementation of the planning solution.
Conditions – requirements set by the plan, the compliance with which is mandatory.
Territorial sea – a part of the marine area adjacent to the internal waters, with a width
of 12 nautical miles. Exceptions may be made to the width of the territorial sea on the
basis of international conventions and agreements with neighboring countries. The
jurisdiction of the Estonian state extends to the territorial sea. The external border of
the territorial sea is the state border of Estonia. The average depth of the territorial sea
is approximately 30 m. The territorial sea, together with the internal waters, shall be
considered as territorial waters.
Wind energy development area – an area designated by this plan as suitable for wind
energy development.
New developments – both new uses of the sea and developments related to traditional
uses of the sea.
Study – responding to a research objective, using appropriate and feasible methods,
e.g. analysis of existing data, modelling, fieldwork.
Viewpoint – a fixed, valued place on the coast, identified in the framework of the
impact assessment of the plan.
Water traffic area – an area used intensively for waterborne traffic not published in
navigation information. The areas have been designated in cooperation with the
Transport Administration (for methodology see Chapter 5.3.4) and taking into account
the need to allow for other uses of the sea. When implementing the plan, up-to-date
data from the Transport Administration shall be used for water traffic areas.
Preservation area of an underwater cultural heritage – an area designated by this
plan for the preservation of underwater objects of cultural value which have come to
light, in situations where they cannot be preserved in their original location or
conserved, stored or exhibited in museum collections. Underwater cultural heritage is
defined as any cultural, historical or archaeological trace of human presence that has
been partially or totally submerged, temporarily or permanently, for at least 100 years,
for example:
- monuments, structures, buildings, artefacts and human remains, together with their
archaeological and natural surroundings;
- vessels, aircraft and other vehicles or parts thereof, their cargo or other contents,
together with their archaeological and natural surroundings;
- prehistoric objects.
Aquaculture – means the keeping or rearing of aquatic organisms (fish, shellfish,
crustaceans, and aquatic plants (e.g., algae) by use of the technology means to obtain
Estonian maritime special plan explanatory memorandum
88
their production in larger quantities than the natural environment status conditions
would permit.
Small-craft harbor – a port or a part of a port where port services are provided to
watercraft with an overall length of less than 24 meters.
Network – used in this document as an annex to ports and (recreational craft) shipping
routes and infrastructure and nature conservation topics to cover and generalize objects
that are inherently connected as spatial networks. The term does not include officially
organized or legally defined sets or lists (port network, recreational craft route network,
etc.).
Ecosystem service – features of ecosystems necessary for people, such as food,
recreation facilities, climate-control features, etc. Ecosystem services are valued but
generally not sold (they have no market value).
Ecosystem based approach – according to the Convention on Biological Diversity,
the ecosystem-based approach is a strategy for the integrated management of land,
water and living resources that pays equal attention to both protection and sustainable
use.
1
ESTONIAN MARITIME SPATIAL
PLAN
IMPACT
ASSESSMENT
REPORT
The maritime spatial plan is a tool for the long-term plan of
the use of the sea in order to ensure both the economic
benefits of the use of marine resources and the value of the
sea and the coast as a socially and culturally important area.
The maritime spatial plan takes into account the fact that any
human activity is based on the achievement and maintenance
of good status of the marine environment.
2
2021
Table of contents
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 4
1 PURPOSE AND NATURE OF THE ESTONIAN MARITIME SPATIAL PLAN ....... 5
2 IMPACT ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY ................................................................... 6
2.1 THE ECOSYSTEM-BASED APPROACH ........................................................................ 6
2.2 FOCUS ON ASSESSING THE RELEVANT IMPACT OF THE MARITIME SPATIAL
PLAN ....................................................................................................................................... 15
2.3 TAKING INTO ACCOUNT ENVIRONMENTAL CONSIDERATIONS IN THE
DEVELOPMENT OF THE MSP ............................................................................................ 16
3 RELATIONSHIP OF THE MARITIME SPATIAL PLAN TO STRATEGIC
PLANNING DOCUMENTS AND ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY.................................. 25
3.1 RELATIONSHIP TO RELEVANT PLANNING DOCUMENTS ................................... 25
3.2 COMPLIANCE WITH ENVIRONMENTAL OBJECTIVES .......................................... 27
4 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT AFFECTED AND THE IMPACT OF
IMPLEMENTING THE PLAN ............................................................................................ 32
4.1 HYDROMETEOROLOGY AND HYDRODYNAMICS ................................................. 32
4.1.1 Water temperature and salinity .................................................................................. 32
4.1.2 Wind ........................................................................................................................... 34
4.1.3 Ice conditions ............................................................................................................. 37
4.1.4 Waves and currents .................................................................................................... 41
4.1.5 Water quality .............................................................................................................. 42
4.2 HABITATS AND BIOTA ................................................................................................. 54
4.2.1 Fish ............................................................................................................................. 54
4.2.2 Birds,........................................................................................................................... 70
4.2.3 Seals ........................................................................................................................... 81
4.2.4 Bats, ............................................................................................................................ 88
4.2.5 Seabed habitats and biota ........................................................................................... 93
4.2.6 Protected natural objects .......................................................................................... 106
4.2.7 Affect on terrain ....................................................................................................... 115
4.3 EVALUATION OF NATURA 2000 ............................................................................... 117
4.4 SOCIAL AND CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT ............................................................. 157
4.4.1 Impact on socio-cultural needs and well-being ........................................................ 157
4.4.2 Impact on property ................................................................................................... 198
4.5 IMPACT ON HUMAN HEALTH ................................................................................... 201
4.5.1 Fisheries ................................................................................................................... 202
4.5.2 Aquaculture .............................................................................................................. 203
4.5.3 Maritime transport .................................................................................................... 204
3
4.5.4 Energy production..................................................................................................... 206
4.5.5 Sea tourism and recreation ........................................................................................ 211
4.6 ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT ...................................................................................... 212
4.6.1 Fisheries .................................................................................................................... 212
4.6.2 Maritime transport .................................................................................................... 221
4.6.3 Maritime tourism ...................................................................................................... 225
4.6.4 Energy production..................................................................................................... 227
4.7 IMPACT ON CLIMATE CHANGE ................................................................................ 233
4.8 CUMULATIVE IMPACTS ............................................................................................. 237
4.9 TRANSBOUNDARY IMPACT ...................................................................................... 243
5 OVERVIEW OF THE ORGANIZATION AND INVOLVEMENT OF THE IMPACT
ASSESSMENT ...................................................................................................................... 246
5.1 ORGANIZATION OF IMPACT ASSESSMENT ........................................................... 246
5.2 COOPERATION AND INCLUSION .............................................................................. 247
5.3 DIFFICULTIES WHICH AROSE WHILE CONDUCTING THE SEA REPORT ........ 248
6 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION .................................................................................. 251
6.1 SUMMARY OF IMPACTS ............................................................................................. 251
6.2 CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................ 252
7 ANNEXES .......................................................................................................................... 253
Annex 1. Impact assessment VTK ......................................................................................... 253
Annex 2. Socio-cultural values of maritime counties............................................................. 253
Annex 3. Summary table of visual impact assessments (presented as a separate .xls file) .... 253
Annex 4. Overview of the cooperation with authorities, stakeholders and the public in the
framework of planning and impact assessment ...................................................................... 253
Annex 5. Proposals received and responses submitted in the course of cross-border
involvement (presented as a separate file directory) .............................................................. 253
4
INTRODUCTION
This Impact Assessment (hereinafter IA) is being carried out for the Estonian Maritime
Spatial Plan. The preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan and the IA of the
plan has been initiated by the Government of the Republic Order No. 157 of 25 May
2017. The aim of the MSP is the long-term planning of the use of the Estonian marine
space, which takes into account social, economic, cultural as well as environmental
impacts and needs in a balanced way.
The overall objective of the Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) is to take
environmental considerations into account in the preparation and implementation of
the plan, thereby ensuring a high level of environmental protection and promoting the
principles of sustainable development. Well-established common practices, supported
by the SEA Directive and Estonian legislation, is rather a natural environment -centered
approach. However, the impact on the social (including health), cultural and economic
environment is also important when implementing plans. Therefore, the so -called
Extended Impact Assessment is carried out on the Maritime Spatial Plan, i.e., the
MSP impact assessment process integrates the SEA with the assessment of the social,
cultural, and economic impacts.
The plan and IA have been prepared by OÜ Hendrikson & Ko (chief expert Riin Kutsar,
chief planner Pille Metspalu) in cooperation with the experts of the University of
Tartu, Estonian Marine Institute of the University of Tartu, Centre for Applied Social
Sciences of the University of Tartu, Tallinn University, MTÜ Hiiu Purjelaeva Selts
and OÜ Roheline Rada (OÜ Hobikoda). In addition, the entire plan and IA were
prepared together with several good partners such as the Estonian Ornithological
Society, Estonian Fund for Nature, Praxis, Department of Marine Systems of Tallinn
University of Technology, Tallinn University of Technology, MTÜ Eesti
Merebioloogia Ühing, MTÜ Pro Mare, Artes Terrae, etc. The Ministry of Finance
organizes the preparation of the plan and the impact assessment and the Government
of the Republic establishes it.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 5
1 PURPOSE AND NATURE OF THE
ESTONIAN MARITIME SPATIAL PLAN
The Maritime Spatial Plan is a tool for long-term planning of the use of the sea.
The aim of maritime spatial planning is to agree on the principles of the use of
the Estonian marine area in the long term in order to attain and maintain a good
status of the marine environment and to promote the maritime economy.
The plan under assessment is a national level strategic document guiding the
spatial development of the marine area. The plan addresses the long -term vision
of the Estonian marine area, defines the principles of spatial development, and
provides general guidelines and conditions for the use of the marine area.
Interconnections with the land include functional links between the sea and the
land, such as ports and cables for prospective cooperation. The guidelines for
land-based spatial planning are provided to help ensure that the plan is feasible.
The MSP does not impose binding conditions on land.
The Estonian maritime spatial planning focuses on the combined use of the
marine area and new uses of the sea. For traditional uses, such as fishing,
maritime transport, the rules of using the sea are already well established and
do not require significant additional regulation. Guidelines for all uses are
provided to accommodate new uses of the sea into the marine space .
Among the new uses of the sea, the maritime spatial plan determines the basic
spatial locations of the wind energy development areas together with the
necessary infrastructure objects outside the wind energy development areas.
Preservation areas for underwater cultural heritage will also be established as
new spatial locations. In order to direct aquaculture areas, the plan sets out the
information on areas with suitable growth potential for shellfish and algae
cultivation and defines areas that are not suitable or excluded from the plan for
this activity. In case of aquaculture areas (fish farming, shellfish and algae
farming), the plan sets clear guidelines and conditions for development
activities. Other uses of the sea are not defined as spatially binding areas.
The Maritime Spatial Plan is the basis for issuing superficies licenses and
environmental permits determining the more precise use of the sea (hereinafter
referred to as license). The lifespan of the maritime spatial plan and its use have
been considered as a basis for spatial development of approx imately 15 years,
ie until 2035.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 6
2 IMPACT ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY
2.1 THE ECOSYSTEM-BASED APPROACH
The principle that the Maritime Spatial Plan must be based on an ecosystem -
based approach has been internationally recognized in recent years. The EU
Maritime Spatial Planning Directive also states that the Member States shall
apply the ecosystem-based approach to the establishment and implementation
of the Maritime Spatial Plan (Article 5 (1)).
The principle of the ecosystem-based approach in the Baltic Sea Region has
been embodied in the guidance documents of the HELCOM VASAB MSP
Working Group and in the framework of the Baltic Scope project.
The guidance material is titled "The Ecosystem-Based Approach in the
Maritime Spatial Plan – A Checklist Toolbox" and guidelines for the
aforementioned project implementation in Estonia, drafted in the framework of
the Baltic Scope project, 1 highlights the following:
1) Maritime Spatial Planning must become the basis for directing economic
and other activities at sea to avoid conflicts between different sectors
and to ensure the sustainable use of marine areas and the p reservation of
the marine environment.
The planning process and the impact assessment shall be carried out
simultaneously, taking into account as far as possible the environmental impact,
including socio-economic, cultural, and health impact, of the implementation
of the plan, in order to ensure sustainable and balanced spatial development.
2) Because the marine environment offers a wide range of benefits to
mankind, environmental activities are largely horizontal in spatial
planning, meaning that other areas must be planned in an
environmentally sensitive way. Taking into account the marine
environment is the only way to ensure the development of a sustainable
maritime economy.
This comprehensive impact assessment provides an important input for the
implementation of the ecosystem-based approach to Maritime Spatial Plan (see
Chapter 4 for more details), the most important part of which is, among other
things, the environmental considerations set out in the framework of the
strategic environmental impact assessment and their consideration in the
implementation of the planning solution.
1 Implementation of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive in Maritime spatial Planning,
Estonian Marine Biological Society 2018
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 7
3) As the sea is very dynamic in nature and knows no national borders, such
horizontal impacts should be considered for the Baltic Sea as a whole
and not separately for all countries. Therefore, Member States should,
wherever possible, respecting international law and conventions,
cooperate with the third countries concerned in the relevant marine
areas.
In the preparation of the Maritime Spatial Plan, the potential transboundary
impact was also assessed (see Chapter 4.9), and international cooperation with
several countries took place. An important role is also played by the ongoing
Baltic Sea projects and international seminars where the Ministry of Finance
will introduce the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan process (e.g., Pan Baltic
Scope, BalticRIM, LandSeaAct, The Gulf of Finland Science Days, MSP
Global Conference, Connecting Seas Conference, etc.). More specifically,
cooperation and inclusion are discussed in Chapter 5.
In addition, Chapter 4.8 of the Impact Assessment Report - Cumulative impacts
- has assessed the planned impacts of the Maritime Spatial Plan in conjunction
with, for example, the proposed wind energy development areas in the Latvian
maritime area.
4) The Maritime Spatial Plan must be based on an ecosystem -based
approach. An important measure to ensure integrated ecosystems is to
support Blue Sea Economy initiatives during the Maritime Spatial Plan.
An ecosystem-based approach gives priority to protecting marine
ecosystems while recognizing the need for society to maximize the profit
from the use of marine resources. The Blue Growth Strategy emphasizes
the need to harness untapped marine resources (such as seaweed and
shellfish) for the creation of new jobs and economic growth, while
protecting biodiversity and preserving the ecosystem services that our
healthy marine and coastal ecosystems provide.
So far, knowledge on the management of the Blue Economy has been
inadequate, and as a result of the impact assessment, areas suitable and
unsuitable for the development of aquaculture have been proposed, taking into
account existing knowledge and studies. A study has been carried out on marine
areas suitable for growing shellfish and/or algae 2, and a model has been created
for the economic benefits from the exploitation of marine resources, including
aquaculture (The Marine Economic Benefit Model) 3. In 2019, KAUR
commissioned a survey to develop a methodology for evaluating the benefits of
selected marine ecosystems and to model the maps of their ecosystem benefits
2 Identification of areas suitable for invertebrate and algae cultivation, Estonian Marine
Institute, University of Tartu 2016
3 Estonian economic model: The Marine Economic Benefit Model (Model of Economic Profit,
Costs and Benefits of Using Marine Resources to Assess Current Economic Activities in the
Marine Area), Praxis Center for Policy Studies 2017
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 8
to the entire Estonian marine area 4. On the basis of this work, the Marine
Economic Benefit Model was complemented by ecosystem services
(PlanWise4Blue) 5.
The HELCOM / VASAB Ecosystem-Based Approach Guide 6 outlines a number
of principles that must be followed when drafting the Maritime Spatial Plan and
conducting Impact Assessment to ensure an ecosystem-based approach.
1) Taking account of environmental objectives, maintaining and
achieving good environmental status, and the precautionary
principle. The overall objective is that the Maritime Spatial Plan ensures
the long-term good environmental status of the marine area, and thus the
precautionary principle should be used when planning activities and
assessing impact. Activities that, according to current scientific
knowledge, are expected to have a significant impact on the marine
ecosystem, and the impact of which may not be sufficiently predictable
at present or in certain parts, will require additional specific research
and risk consideration at subsequent planning stages or at a project level.
During the preparation of the plan, both the planning and impact assessment
expert group have worked closely together to avoid significant adverse
environmental impacts at the earliest possible stage of strategic planning, i.e.
to select suitable development areas for the new uses of the marine area and to
avoid key wildlife sensitive areas, proceeding from the prevention and
precautionary principle. At the strategic level it provides assurance that
sensitive areas and issues have been taken into account and that preventive
mitigation measures have been put in place to prevent potential adverse effects
at the next level of authorization and to avoid conflicts between different uses
of the sea and reduce environmental risks. Where appropriate,
recommendations for the implementation of monitoring measures will be
provided by the expert group.
The sensitivity mapping methodology 7 recommended by the European
Commission has been used in the development of the planning solution and
impact assessment. The methodology has been described in more detail both in
the explanatory memorandum to the planning solution (Chapter 5.6.2) and in
4 Base analysis for Selected Ecosystem Services in Marine Areas (commissioned by KAUR),
OU Hobikoda, 2019
5 Nõmmela, K, University of Tartu CASS; Kotta, J., OÜ Hobikoda; Piirimäe, K., OÜ
Roheline Rada Supplementing the model of economic benefits from the use of marine
resources with ecosystem services; Commissioned by Ministry of Finance, 2019
(https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/et/system/files_force/document_files/mudeli_taiendam
ine_okosusteemiteenustega_aruanne.pdf)
6 Guideline for the implementation of ecosystem-based approach in Maritime Spatial Planning
(MSP) in the Baltic Sea area, 2016
7
THE WILDLIFE SENSITIVITY MAPPING MANUAL. Practical guidance for renewable
energy planning in the European Union; https://circabc.europa.eu/sd/a/6a1d06ae-ef34-478a-
a322-006b09079efb/20200429%20WSM%20Manual.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 9
Chapter 2.3 of the Impact Assessment below (also throughout Chapters 4.2 and
4.3 of the Impact Assessment).
All environmental protection principles were applied in the development of the
maritime spatial plan and impact assessment, including the prevention and
precautionary principles, resulting in the elimination of overlaps with Natura
2000 sites for new marine uses, such as wind energy development areas and
fish farms, already at the current strategic level (including protected marine
areas of nationally protected natural objects overlapping with Natura 2000
sites). The application of the prevention principle to preserve and achieve the
state of the environment is more effective than implementing the precautionary
principle.
Therefore, the prevention principle was applied in the cases where the impact
assessment indicated that it is sufficiently likely that adverse effects on the
conservation objectives and integrity of the Natura 2000 site from the
implementation of wind farms or fish farms cannot be ruled out. The position
has been taken by placing Natura 2000 sites (as well as national protected
natural objects) under protection that the primary objective in the selected areas
is the habitat types and species in need of protection and the exercise of other
interests and implementation of activities in those areas which is not in line
with the conservation objectives of the protected area are secondary.
Based on the best available information the sensitive areas for ecosystems, i.e.
the areas that are important as habitats or foraging habitats for a particular
marine habitat or species (including the movement corridors and migrations of
birds, bats, seals, potential fish spawning grounds, etc.), were excluded from
the selection of new marine uses. See Chapter 4 of the Impact Assessment for
more details.
In addition, the precautionary principle was applied throughout the impact
assessment, which, among other things, set precautionary measures for the next
level of the authorization in order to specify and assess the possible significant
environmental impacts if more precise volumes, technical solutions and time
feasibility become clear. The ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES proposed in
the Impact Assessment is the basis for the operational guidelines and conditions
set by the plan which will be the basis for future decisions concerning the
maritime area, including the issue of authorizations.
2) Consideration of the best available knowledge. In-depth and up-to-
date knowledge can best help protect the components of the marine
ecosystem. These include understanding the state of the marine
environment as well as understanding the various social and cultural
values of the marine area.
Extensive thoroughness has been considered a priority in assessing the impacts
of maritime spatial planning as a strategic development document. In addition
to the usual environmental impact assessment, attention has also been paid to
social, economic and cultural impacts.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 10
The main complaint from the public and stakeholders in impact assessment
processes is often that the impact assessment processes do not include sufficient
field research in a specific planning area on site and that there is insufficient
scientific data to predict impacts. The meaning behind the term "research" has
also been left undefined. This is often understood by the public as narrowly
conducting fieldwork in the area being researched and assessed. However, in
the process of impact assessment, it is an extended concept which means the
performance of an established research task, i.e. it may be the performance of
fieldwork in a specific area, but also the analysis and mapping , modelling etc
of the data based on the existing information.
The preparation of the maritime spatial plan and its impact assessment is based
on the best available knowledge at the time of drafting the documents - the best
specialists in their field and their expertise have been involved, information
from previous surveys in the whole marine area (relevant environmental data
layers and reports), additional analyses/studies based on it and modelling
performed covering the whole marine area, have been taken into account. The
impact assessment is based not only on international practice but also on
international knowledge of the effects of new marine uses, in parti cular wind
farms and aquaculture, on the marine environment.
According to Directive 2001/42/EC, the SEA Directive, the SEA report should
include the information that may reasonably be required taking into account
current knowledge and methods of assessment, the contents and level of detail
in the plan or programme, its stage in the decision-making process and the
extent to which certain matters are more appropriately assessed at different
levels in that process in order to avoid duplication of the assessmen t. In the
opinion of the Supreme Court (this is explained in Hiiu Maritime spatial
Planning case 8), this refers instead to the scientific data reasonably available at
the time of the assessment, including, if necessary, to be collected with new
research.
In the course of compiling the maritime spatial plan, in addition to the existing
information, several additional analyses and studies have been conducted (see
also http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/uuringud.html), which summarize the overall
picture of the Estonian maritime area in various topics. During the compilation
and preparation of the maritime spatial plan the following basic analy ses/
studies commissioned by the Ministry of Finance have been prepared, for
example:
▪ Implementation of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive in
Maritime spatial Planning, Estonian Marine Biological Society 2018
▪ Collection and analysis of baseline data for assessing social and cultural
impacts, OÜ Hendrikson & Ko, 2017
▪ Survey of bats migrating south or southwest across the sea from the
island of Saaremaa, Estonian Fund for Nature, 2017
8
https://maakonnaplaneering.ee/documents/2845826/18586325/3 -16-
1472+Hiiu+Tuul.pdf/a44b906e-e5a9-4f72-b2c5-cfe0258db0d3
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 11
▪ Compilation of data on migratory corridors of birds in the Estonian
marine area, creation of corresponding map layers and analysis of the
impact of wind farms on bird feeding areas, Estonian Ornithological
Society, 2017
▪ Identification of suitable fish farming areas in the Estonian marine area,
EULS Institute of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Husbandry, 2017
▪ Economic Benefits of Using Marine Resources (Model of Economic
Profit, Costs and Benefits of Using Marine Resources to Assess Current
Economic Activities in the Marine Area), Praxis Center for Policy
Studies 2017
▪ Analysis of ice conditions and drawing of maps (ice probability map and
ice cover duration map, worst-case scenario map based on 2010/2011,
hummock ice probability map, etc.), TUT Institute of Marine Systems,
2016
▪ Identification of areas suitable for invertebrate and algae cultivation,
Estonian Marine Institute, University of Tartu 2016
▪ Assessment of the distribution and marine use of seals NGO Pro Mare,
2019
▪ Bird staging area analysis, Estonian Ornithological Society, 2019
▪ Do the offshore wind turbines with the height of about 300 m affect the
migration of birds and how? Estonian Ornithological Society, 2021
▪ Guide to methodological recommendations for visual impact assessment
to promote the development of offshore wind farms, Artes Terrae 2020
A number of new studies on the state of the marine area have also been
completed during the preparation of the Maritime Spatial Plan and this Impact
Assessment Report, such as:
▪ Possible effects of offshore wind farms planned for Estonia on fish in
the Baltic Sea, University of Tartu, 2020
▪ Survey of bats at sea around Saaremaa from July to October 2018,
Estonian Fund for Nature, 2019
▪ Survey of bats in the Gulf of Riga and Finland from June to October
2020. Phase II of identification of the marine areas important for bats,
Lutsar, L; Estonian Fund for Nature, 2021
▪ Survey of seabed biota and habitats to assess the distribution of Natura
and HELCOM habitat types and to elucidate the CO2 sequestration
potential of the sea, Estonian Marine Institute, University of Tartu, 2020
In addition, the innovative tool PlanWise4Blue
(http://www.sea.ee/planwise4blue) was used to assess the environmental
impacts of Estonian maritime spatial planning, which assesses the cumulative
impact of planned human activities on various natural values (see also Chapter
4.8). Such an impact assessment is based on the following scientific
information and working principles:
▪ The tool is based on the best available information on natural values,
including the latest monitoring and mapping work. All important natural
values have been mapped or modelled at all points in Estonian maritime
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 12
space. The application includes the information on seabed habitats, fish
(including fish spawning grounds), birds and mammals.
▪ The tool is based on the best available scientific information on how
different human activities cumulatively affect different natural values.
The available scientific information has been gathered into the
application in such a way that it is possible to calculate the impact of
specific human activities on a specific nature value on a factual basis.
For example, it is possible to calculate the extent to which the
construction of a wind farm potentially increases or decreases the area
of a seabed habitat for each point in the sea area. The data have been
obtained for the application either during monitoring measurements
and/or experimental work.
▪ There are a total of 257 surveys on wind farms (including surveys of
seals and birds in the maritime portal), including 120 surveys on fish and
102 surveys on seabed habitats and their condition.
3) Development of alternative solutions. Reasonable alternatives must be
developed, taking into account the environmental, socio-economic, and
cultural impact involved and the measures proposed to avoid or mitigate
them. The planning process must reflect, in a transparent manner, the
trade-offs between different maritime interests and users in the different
uses of the marine area.
According to the Environmental Impact Assessment and Environmental
Management System Act, the SEA report should include an overview of the
reasons on the basis of which the alternative development scenarios were
selected during the preparation of the strategic planning document and an
overview of how the best alternative development scenario was obtained. The
development of the maritime spatial plan and this impact assessment took place
in parallel, which enabled the information identified in the impact assessment
process to be taken into account on an on-going basis in the planning solution
for the development of the so-called best alternative development scenario.
It has been described in more detail in Chapters 2.2. and 2.3 and throughout
Chapter 4 how the principal locations identified in the current plan for new
marine uses, including the areas suitable for wind energy development,
Preservation areas for underwater cultural heritage were developed and how the
areas suitable and/or unsuitable for the plan activities were defined (e.g.
aquaculture areas), on the basis of which the guidelines and conditions for the
implementation of the plan were in its turn developed.
The purpose of the Impact Assessment was to determine the suitability of the
proposed development areas for the new uses of the marine space (e.g.,
development areas suitable for wind energy, see the detailed description of the
development of suitable areas in the Plan, Chapter 5.6.2 and in addition check
chapters from this report 2.3, 4.2 and 4.3).
During the preparation of the plan, both the planning and the impact assessment
expert group have worked closely together to rule out significant adverse
environmental effects at the earliest possible stage of strategic planning. The
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 13
aim has been not to plan new uses for the marine area, including, for example,
wind energy development areas as well as aquaculture areas, for sensitive or
unsuitable marine areas, in order to avoid adverse effects on Natura 2000
network conservation objectives and significant adverse environmental effects
on wider marine life.
While it was not possible or reasonable to spatially define the development
areas in the plan for some areas of activity, the impact assessment identified,
for example, the areas unsuitable for fish farming and set out specific mitigation
measures for the implementation of the activities. This was done by mapping
sensitive areas, which are often used at the level of a species group, habitat type
or species that are sensitive to development and associated impacts (species-
rich areas). Thus, the solution of the maritime spatial plan was developed in
close cooperation on the basis of the information and knowledge received by
the drafters of the plan, various members of the impact assessment expert
group, involved authorities as well as stakeholders.
Mapping suitable or unsuitable areas for development activities and thereby
assessing the impact will help to avoid the environmental risks associated with
implementation at subsequent planning stages or at the project level.
The planning guidelines and conditions for already regulated traditional
maritime uses (e.g. maritime transport, seabed infrastructure) have been
analyzed by an impact assessment expert group. By considering the suggestions
of the experts, the wording of the guidelines and conditions has been specified
in the plan.
The process and methodologies that the expert group considered to be the best
planning solution has been described throughout the impact assessment report .
The adverse effects related to the implementation of the planning solution on
the conservation objectives of Natura 2000 sites or significant adverse effects
on the marine ecosystem and, if necessary, precautionary measures for the next
level of the authorization (which is the basis for setting the conditions of the
plan) have been identified for the planning team on an ongoing basis.
It has also been emphasized in the professional literature 9 that in order for the
strategic assessment of environmental impact to effectively fulfil its objectives,
the assessment should be fully integrated into the planning process. The
strategic environmental assessment has a significant impact on the decision-
making process only in this way, from specifying the original objectives of the
plan up to the implementation of the decisions and monitoring of the actual
effects. The parallel ongoing procedures allow for a continuous and up-to-date
exchange of information with good timing. On the one hand, the strategic
environmental assessment provides the planners with the necessary
9
Handbook on Strategic Environmental Assessment, P eterson, K., Kutsar, R., Metspalu, P.,
Vahtrus, S. ja Kalle, H. 2017 - https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/raamat_2017_final.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 14
information, and on the other hand, depending on how the plan takes shape, it
is possible to make a more accurate assessment of its environmental impact.
4) Mitigation measures: The aim of the measures is to prevent and
reduce possible significant adverse effects on the environment and to
avoid adverse effects on the integrity and conservation objectives of
the Natura 2000 site. To achieve this, planning must take into account
environmental objectives, including marine biodiversity and the
maintenance of a network of protected areas.
The prevention and precautionary principles out of environmental protection
principles were applied in the development of the maritime spatial planning
solution and impact assessment. The main objective of this impact assessment
of maritime spatial plan is to identify the likely adverse effects on the
conservation objectives of Natura 2000 sites and significant adverse effects on
the marine ecosystem with the aim to avoid these already at the strategic level.
The methodology for mapping sensitive areas was used for this purpose in the
impact assessment.
This helps prevent or reduce the number of potential site-specific conflicts later
in the development process with less room for manoeuvring. In addition, the
impact assessment report identified, based on the best available knowledge, the
proposed activities that could have an adverse effect on the conservation
objectives of Natura 2000 sites or significant adverse effect on the marine
ecosystem and proposed measures for the reduction and mitigation of t he
impact for their elimination. The impact assessment analysis anticipates the
adverse effects of the proposed activities on the conservation objectives of
Natura 2000 sites and significant adverse effects on the marine ecosystem and
identifies which impacts need to be assessed more accurately at the
authorization level of the project by taking into account the site and location
specific and technological solutions. It provides developers with relevant
information and certainty about environmental issues ( conditions) that may
need to be taken into account as they develop their initial project concept. It
can also be more cost-effective in the long run. If possible, mitigation measures
are taken into account in the early planning process; it is likely to be technically
easier and cheaper to integrate them at the project level. This, in turn, can lead
to the development of new, creative, and innovative solutions.
The implementation of the principles of environmental protection and the
methodology used in the impact assessment have been described in more detail
in the first section of this list.
5) Participation and communication. All relevant authorities and
stakeholders, as well as the wider public, are involved at an early stage
in the planning and impact assessment process. Participation processes
must take into account existing power structures, resources, and the
diverse needs of stakeholders.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 15
An ecosystem-based approach is created involving different stakeholders
throughout the planning and impact assessment process. See Chapter 5 for
details.
6) Adaptation. Changes in nature and in the management of ecosystems
are inevitable. Sustainable use of the ecosystem should be accompanied
by a process that involves monitoring, reviewing, and evaluating both
the process and the outcome, as changing circumstances and new
knowledge may require tailored guidance at project level evaluation.
The plan includes an action plan that maps the follow-up activities for the
implementation and application of marine-related activities and the
specification and ongoing updating of marine area information. In addition, as
a result of the impact assessment, the conditions and guidelines for the
authorization level have become part of the planning solution.
Taken together, the ecosystem-based approach implies that the use of
marine space should be planned in a way that ensures the long-term
viability of marine ecosystems. This, in turn, means that planning decisions
should be considered primarily from the perspective of maintaining good
state of ecosystems and the environment, by proceeding from the
prevention and precautionary principles and by taking into account the
conclusions of this impact assessment and the proposed mitigating
precautionary measures. Chapter 2.3 describes how environmental
considerations have been taken into account when developing a planning
solution, taking into account the above principles of the ecosystem -based
approach.
See chapter 4.2 of the Plan for an overview of the consideratio n of the proposals
made in the Impact Assessment.
2.2 FOCUS ON ASSESSING THE RELEVANT IMPACT OF THE
MARITIME SPATIAL PLAN
In addition to the coherence between different uses of the sea, it is important
to take into account broad-based environmental considerations from the early
stages of planning. The sustainable use of the marine environment is based on
directing the various uses of the sea, taking into account their nature and natural
conditions. Therefore, the potential impact of the use of the sea on the natural,
social, and cultural environment and the economic environment were analyzed
in an integrated way parallel to the development of the planning solution.
Broad-based impact analysis has made it possible to direct activities bot h
spatially and through guidelines and conditions set out in planning, with the
aim of achieving and maintaining good environmental status. The impact
assessment has been carried out, taking into account the degree of accuracy of
the planning document and the extent of its content.
The Spatial Planning Solution provides an overview of the uses of the marine
area and provides guidelines and conditions for the sustainable development of
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 16
each use, also taking into account other uses. For many uses (fisheries,
aquaculture, maritime transport, marine rescue, pollution control, border
management, seabed infrastructure, marine tourism and recreation,
nature protection, marine culture, national defence, mineral resources, and
dumping), the Maritime Spatial Plan does not foresee significant spatial
changes. Legislation and maritime practices are already well established in
many of these areas of use (e.g. maritime transport, etc.). Following the
implementation of the plan, the existing situation in the maritime space for
these uses will remain predominant, also in terms of environmental impact. In
order to direct aquaculture areas the plan sets out information on the areas with
suitable growth potential for shellfish and algae cultivation and defines the
areas that are not suitable or excluded from the plan for this activity. With
regard to combined use, both planning and impact assessment provides
guidance on developments in the field through guidelines and conditions.
The Maritime Spatial Plan focuses primarily on new uses of the sea where
development interest already exists or is predictable due to good preconditions:
aquaculture and energy production. In order to develop these areas and
promote combined use, the plan defines both guidelines and conditions and, for
wind energy, spatial development areas. See the following subchapter 2.3 about
how the suitable and/or unsuitable development areas for new marine uses and
precautionary and mitigation measures were developed to implement the
proposed activity. For new uses, the plan can be seen as a document that creates
new opportunities and can also have environmental impacts .
2.3 TAKING INTO ACCOUNT ENVIRONMENTAL
CONSIDERATIONS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MSP
One of the most important new uses of the marine area is wind energy
development, for which the spatial development areas are determined in the
plan, in addition to guidelines and conditions.
The sensitivity mapping methodology 10 recommended by the European
Commission has been used in the development of the planning solution and
impact assessment (see also the description in Chapter 2.1, article 1). It is
considered to be an effective tool for identifying naturally sensitive areas ( i.e.
biologically diverse areas that need to be protected) where the development of
renewable energy (or other planned marine activities) may affect the
conservation of good environmental status of biological diversity and the
10
THE WILDLIFE SENSITIVITY MAPPING MANUAL. Practical guidance for renewable
energy planning in the European Union; https://circabc.europa.eu/sd/a/6a1d06ae-ef34-478a-
a322-006b09079efb/20200429%20WSM%20Manual.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 17
integrity of the areas 11 and provide a basis to apply prevention and/or
precautionary principles through the impact assessment process.
The mapping of areas suitable for spatially planned activities in the marine
area, including wind energy, and of sensitive wildlife areas, will help to
identify:
▪ Environmental risks related to the development areas of the proposed
activities and their implementation for protected natural objects,
including Natura 2000 network sites and marine habitats and biota
(discussed in Chapter 4.2).
▪ Sets out the conditions for the licensing phase of proposed activities and
the baseline task of the impact assessment, which must be the basis for
assessing significant adverse impacts at the project level
The preparation of maritime spatial planning and impact assessment were based
on the best available marine surveys/analyses and expert assessments (several
marine analyses were prepared in the planning process to map sensitive areas,
see subchapter 2.1 (2) for a more detailed description). This impact assessment
has suggested the avoidance of key wildlife sensitive areas already at the
strategic level. The impact assessment was based on the basic principles of
environmental law and it applied the prevention principle which prohibits the
activities that pose a threat to the environment (i.e. significant environmental
disturbance or adverse effects on the conservation objectives of Natura 2000
site or significant adverse effect on the marine ecosystem) and the
precautionary principle which obliges to mitigate uncertain environmental risks
as much as possible.
In order to achieve and maintain the good environmental status of the sea, the
planning solution has foremost taken into account the network of natural areas
protected both internationally and nationally (Natura 2000), including the
planned (protected areas planned in EELIS) areas, and the spatially planned
new uses of the sea were excluded for these areas, in particular wind energy
development areas which could have an adverse effect on the environment . In
2020 the proposals have also been made for the establishment of two EEZ
marine protected areas. These proposals are currently being processed. Thus,
this impact assessment has recommended to refrain from describing the
proposed restrictions on the protected area due to the economic use of these
areas (see Chapter 4.2.6 for more details) up to the completion of the relevant
procedures.
The development areas of wind energy were fist determined based on the
conditions suitable for wind energy (wind, sea depth, icing, w ave height), on
the basis of which the suitable areas for the construction of wind farms were
selected. The selected wind energy areas were already specified during the
11
Guidance document on wind energy developments and EU nature legislation. 18.11.2020,
Guide of the European Commission.
https://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/natura2000/management/docs/wind_farms_en.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 18
preparation of the draft plan, by excluding the overlaps with the first known
naturally valuable areas on the basis of the information available at that time,
including Natura 2000 network sites and national protected areas and the most
important known migration corridors of birds 12.
In order to reduce the effects (visual impact, noise, shad ing, etc.) on people,
the areas of wind turbines closer to the mainland than approx imately 11.1 km
(incl. from permanently inhabited islands) were excluded. In order to avoid
conflict the areas of wind farms in special areas of national defen ce were
excluded, as well as in the areas unsuitable for national defence for other
reasons (see Figure 2.3-1). The overlap with water traffic areas and bird
migration areas of major importance was avoided when designating the
innovation area, the compliance with the depth limit (up to 40 m) was not
considered important when proceeding from the innovative technology . The
initial analysis of the impacts already in the draft plan stage helped to develop
the best possible solution for the strategic level.
12
Compilation of data on migratory corridors of birds in the Estonian marine area, creation
of corresponding map layers and analysis of the impact of wind farms on bird feeding areas,
Estonian Ornithological Society, 2017
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 19
Figure 2.3-1. Finding areas suitable for the development of wind energy
In order to prepare the main solution for the selected wind energy development
areas, several detailed studies were commissioned under the leadership of the
Ministry of Finance, including:
▪ analysis of bird staging areas 13, how the height of wind turbines affects
the birds staging area 14,
13
Basic study of maritime spatial planning “Analysis of bird staging areas” Estonian
Ornithological Society, 2019
14
Whether and how can the offshore wind turbines with the height of about 300 m affect bird
migration? Estonian Ornithological Society, 2021
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 20
▪ Assessment of the distribution and marine use of seals 15 etc.
The more detailed list of surveys has been provided in Chapter 2.1, article 2.
During the analysis of bird staging areas, all known bird information was
mapped in the Estonian marine area. Bird experts also took into account the
migratory corridors of marine area birds and designated sensitive areas for
birds. In addition to the sensitive areas, the IA also mapped the main migratory
corridors of terrestrial birds above the sea and consequently proposed a
reduction in wind energy development area No 1 (see Chapter 4.2.2 and Figure
4.2.2-4).
The areas suitable for the development of wind energy have been repeatedly
reviewed by the experts of birds, bats and seals outside the expert group
throughout the development of the planning solution and no additional
proposals have been made to change the development areas of wind energy.
The assessment of wind energy development areas and the effects of their
implementation is based on the starting points for the development of wind
energy defined in the plan (see also the explanatory memorandum to the plan,
Chapter 5.6.3). The rapid development of technology should be taken into
account in the long-term planning of wind energy. During the life of the plan
the dimensions of the wind turbines increase, both the top height and the
diameter of the rotor increase even faster. In developing the planning solution,
the design of the wind turbines has been based on both international experience
and the assessments of wind energy developers. The recommendation of the
planning expert team is based on the following indicators:
- The tip height of the wind turbine is in the order of 300 m.
- The diameter of the blade (rotor) is in the order of 250 m.
- The wind turbine foundation shall be of the gravity type or similar in
its effects. The expected diameter of the foundation is less than 100 m
(probably 60 m).
- The distance between the wind turbines in one wind farm is between
4 and 7 blade diameters, with a minimum of 800m.
- The minimum distance between the wind farms will be
approximately 8 rotor diameters of the rotor of a later wind farm, with
a minimum of 2 km.
Both the power of the wind turbines and other parameters depend on the
specific location and layout, as well as the time of reali sation. Therefore, the
more detailed assessment of the environmental impacts at the level of
authorization is needed.
15
Basic study of maritime spatial planning “Estonian maritime spatial plan: assessment of
seal distribution and marine use”. Report of applied research, contract No. 1.9 -1 / 404-1 I.,
Jüssi; M., Jüssi, 2019.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 21
Along with the wind energy development area, their potential cable connections
to the land must be considered. The planning solution proposed possible cable
corridors, and the role of the impact assessment was to assess their impact at
the strategic planning document level, in particular on the conservation
objectives of the Natura 2000 sites. As the exact technological solutions for the
proposed activity are unknown at this stage of the planning process, the IA
suggested alternative locations for cable corridors, which would exclude any
impact on the conservation objectives of the Natura 2000 network (see Chapter
4.3 for details). The assessment of Natura 2000 sites brought out proposals for
amending the planning solution and required amendments were made in th e
MSP. The impact assessment did not preclude the laying of cables in the
proposed corridors and pointed out that the laying of cables at other locations
is more economically feasible. However, in such a case, an appropriate location
alternative at the project level of wind farms would have to be found, which
long-term impact on the conservation objectives of the Natura 2000 network
would be excluded.
Pursuant to the disclosure of the main solution the following specifications
of the main solution have been made in relation to the wind energy
development areas (and consequently the impact assessments have been
specified throughout in Chapter 4):
▪ Addition of the starting points for wind energy planning (see Chapter
5.6.2 of the explanatory memorandum to the plan).
The purpose of adding the relevant subchapter was to clarify which
development trends and indicators of wind energy have been taken into
account in the development of the planning solution.
▪ Abandonment of wind energy development area no. 3 (in the northwest
of Harilaiu).
The area of the wind energy development area no. 3 was only 15 km 2 ,
incl the area passes through the water traffic area where the location of
wind turbines could appear to be complicated. The area was partly
located in an important sensitive area of Hülgerahu as a winter stopover
and spring migration area for waterfowl and was therefore with high
risk of development.
▪ Specification of the possibilities of joint use of the sea area (see the
explanatory memorandum of the plan, Chapter 5.1).
Based on the facts highlighted by the trawlers' interest group and input
from line ministries, the bottlenecks were identified that are not expected
to allow the joint use of the same sea area for active trawling and wind
energy development.
▪ Improving the guidelines and conditions for the development of wind
energy based on trawling and the completed visual impact assessment
guide (see 4.4.1 for details).
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 22
The additional inputs from interest groups and ministries enabled to
specify the conditions for the development of wind energy. Based on the
visual impact assessment guide 16 completed by the beginning of 2021,
the conditions were supplemented and the approach to impact
assessment was reviewed.
▪ Specification of the impact of wind energy development on birds (for
more details see Chapter 4.2.2).
The approximate top height of the wind turbines was also determined
during the specification of the starting points for wind energy planning.
In order to achieve relevance, an additional expert assessment 17 was
ordered from the Estonian Ornithological Society to assess the impact
of approximately 300 m high wind turbines on birds as the most affected
part of wildlife.
▪ Specification of the the conceptual locations of the offshore grid (for
more details see chapter 4.3).
Based on the additional input of Elering AS the basic locations of the
cable corridors related to wind energy development area no. 2 were
specified (in addition to the land crossing of the Sõrve foothills, the sea
area south of the Sõrve peninsula was assigned as the location).
▪ Designation of wind energy reserve areas (for more details, see the
explanatory memorandum to the plan in Chapter 5.6.5)
The areas suitable for the development of wind energy that overlap with
the areas of historically more intensive trawling have been designated
as the reserve areas on the basis of the interim decision of the
Government of the Republic (29 April 2021).
The starting point for the impact assessment corresponding to the
generalization level of the plan (incl SEA) has been the ecosystem approach,
which has been described in Chapter 2.1 above. The impact assessment of
maritime spatial planning has already recommended the avoidance of important
sensitive areas of wildlife at the strategic level based on the prevention and
precautionary principles and has ensured at the strategic level that sensitive
areas have been taken into account and that the adverse effect s of the proposed
activity on the conservation objectives of the Natura 2000 site and the
significant adverse effects on the marine ecosystem have been addressed .
http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/dokumendid/Uuringud/Meretuuleparkide_visuaalse_mõju_hin
16
damise_juhend_final.pdf
17
Whether and how can the offshore wind turbines with a height of about 300 m affect the
migration of birds?, Estonian Ornithological Society, 2021
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 23
The plan sets the conditions for the level of authorization, including preventive
precautionary and/or mitigation measures to prevent possible adverse effects
on Natura 2000 sites and significant adverse effects on the marine ecosystem.
Following the mapping of naturally sensitive areas and the impact assessment
carried out during the planning procedure and impact assessment, the locations
suitable for wind energy development have been developed, where it is possible
to plan further activities at the authorization stage under the assumptions set by
the plan and impact assessment for wind farm planning.
In the cases where marine mapping for wildlife needs to be clarified and the
impact of the proposed activity depends on technical solutions, it is proposed
to include in the conditions of the planning solution that the respective studies
need to be clarified or further performed at the authorization stage. In addition,
the impact assessment has proposed the inclusion of various studies in the
action plan of the plan, which would require additional information collection
in the maritime area and would provide better input during the authorization
processes. As a feature of the marine environment, it should be borne in mind
that there is much less data on the marine environment than on land and that
the collection of new data covering the whole marine area is time consuming.
The second new area of marine use in Estonian maritime spatial plan is
aquaculture (fish, algae and shellfish farming). The mapping methodology
for sensitive areas described above was also used to identify potential suitable
and/or unsuitable areas for aquaculture. The impact assessment revealed that
the maritime spatial plan does not specify specific principal locations for this
use and that aquaculture development is permitted throughout the marine area,
except in the areas unsuitable for aquaculture or excluded from this activity. In
order to direct aquaculture areas, the plan provides information on the areas
with suitable growth potential for shellfish and algae cultivation. Aquaculture
areas will be identified within the authorization procedure (incl environmental
impact assessment), taking into account the specific guidelines and conditions
of the area set out in the maritime spatial plan by considering the location of
the sensitive areas of wildlife and unsuitable areas for aquaculture.
With regard to fish farming, more extensive exclusion zones have been
established, i.e. the establishment of fish farms in the areas of protected natural
objects, including the Natura 2000 network, is prohibited and excluded. This
prevention principle and condition minimizes the expected impacts of fish
farming (based on the so-called "worst case scenario", i.e. in the light of
currently known technology) on natural value sites and their conservation
objectives. The major impact of fish farming is associated with changes in
water quality and the loss of seabed habitats near the farm (see chapter 4.2.5
for details).
The maritime spatial plan also establishes Preservation areas for underwater
cultural heritage in the area of Tallinn Bay, near Käsmu, Abruka and Ruhnu,
as new spatial locations. At the request of the National Heritage Board and
taking into account the terms of reference of the board, additional areas were
found for flooding wrecks near the ports, by taking into account, among other
things, nature conservation conditions. The Abruka Nature Conservation Area,
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 24
originally proposed by the board, overlapped with the conservation area of the
same name in the Kura kurgu Special Protection Area. Therefore, in order to
avoid possible associated environmental risks, the impact assessment expert
group proposed to move the Abruka Nature Conservation Area north of the
originally designated location outside sensitive marine protected areas. The
plan took the made proposal into account.
The impact assessment has also addressed the cumulative and synergistic
effects of the various proposed activities. The guidelines provided in the plan
favour cluster solutions, i.e. the co-development of several different uses of the
sea, e.g. the effects of nutrients released from fish farms into the water will be
mitigated by shellfish and algae farming. In order to achieve positive socio -
cultural and economic synergies, the development of aquaculture, in particular
the establishment of shellfish farms but also fish farms, is a priority in the wind
energy development areas.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 25
3 RELATIONSHIP OF THE MARITIME SPATIAL PLAN
TO STRATEGIC PLANNING DOCUMENTS AND
ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY
3.1 RELATIONSHIP TO RELEVANT PLANNING DOCUMENTS
The relationship between the plan and the relevant planning documents,
including international framework documents and planning guidelines, is
described in Chapter 2 of the Plan. Starting points. The relevant section of the
Plan sets out the main approaches and agreements that underpin the Maritime
Spatial Plan. The following is a brief overview of the Estonian spatial plan
related to maritime spatial planning.
National Spatial Plan Estonia 2030+
National planning emphasizes the efficient and sustainable use of the marine
area and Estonia's openness to the sea and sets out general directions for
achieving this as a principle theme development. In the field of energy
production, national planning foresees strong development in wind energy,
including in the offshore area. In the longer term, the development of energy
networks provides for the possibility of connecting to Latvia by submarine
cable. In order to increase the security of supply on the isl ands and the
introduction of local renewable energy sources, the aim has been to establish a
high-voltage loop connecting West-Estonian islands and the mainland, which
will allow better connection of offshore wind farms to the grid. The planning
predicts an increase in international trade flows using sea transport. National
planning also identifies major global trends with a spatial impact, which also
have a major impact on the future use of the marine area:
▪ shifting the focus of the global economy to Asia;
▪ transition to a knowledge-based economy;
▪ population aging;
▪ urbanization;
▪ changes in climate
▪ increasing the influence of ecological values;
▪ transition to the widespread use of renewable energy;
▪ the fast growth of the so-called green and silver economies.
National planning provides a general basis for the Maritime Spatial plan in the
form of spatial trends.
County-Wide Spatial Plans
The valid plans of Estonian counties concern land. However, maritime affairs
play an important role in the planning of marine counties, reflecting in overall
trends, mobility, and infrastructure through ports and maritime transport, as
well as in recreation and rescue capacity. Most of the issues related to the sea
have been dealt with in Saaremaa that is locat ed in the middle of the sea.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 26
The Saare County-wide spatial plan sees an increasing role for the blue
economy - trade, shipbuilding, fishing, boat storage, repair, and production,
etc. The development of small craft harbors will be promoted, small craft
harbors of national and county importance and community harbors will be
distinguished. The county plan states that restoring the passenger ship
connection to Latvia and visiting Saaremaa harbors by more cruise ships is a
priority for tourism. The trend is that ports are increasingly multifunctional,
fulfilling many functions other than mooring and enabling traditional fishing.
The multifunctional use of ports has been prioritized for further development.
The Saare County-wide spatial plan notes that the locations of offshore wind
farms will be determined by a national Maritime Spatial Plan.
The spatial vision of the Lääne County-wide Spatial Plan specifically
highlights openness to the sea and fast maritime connections. Business areas
are being developed near ports. The Spatial Development Principles outline
recreational opportunities for coastal areas.
The Harju County-wide Spatial Plan sets the guideline for openness to the
sea - the attractiveness of the coastal area in terms of residential preferences
and economic activity. The development potential of ports has been especially
emphasized.
The Lääne-Viru County-wide Spatial Plan gives priority to sea access (incl.,
sets the rule for beaches of recreational value to be accessible from public roads
every 500 m in sparsely populated areas and every 200 m in densely populated
areas) and maritime connections facilitating the development of the
recreational economy. For the development of maritime tourism, a chain of
ports along the coast, consisting of various small craft harbors, is planned to
complement the land connections.
The Ida-Viru County-wide Spatial Plan emphasizes the role of the Port of
Sillamäe with the international cargo and passenger port. The plan links the sea
to the diverse recreational, economic potential of Ida-Viru County's cultural
environment, natural and industrial landscapes, highlighting the development
of the resort, spa, and marine tourism on the north coast.
Maritime county plans have also linked the sea to the theme of valuable
landscapes. In some counties, marine areas have been seen as parts of valuable
landscapes (e.g., Harju County, Lääne-Viru County). Coastal areas with
attractive nature and unique coastal culture have been designated as valuable
landscapes in all counties. The Saare County-wide Spatial Plan most closely
associates the marine area with valuable landscapes. For example, land use
conditions for valuable landscapes require the preservation and restoration of
marine culture-related features on the sea-bound landscapes - historic berths,
net shelters, trawl ramps, piers, agar collecting sites, etc; nor should the
location of new buildings on the sea-side landscape disturb the sea views.
County plans highlight the regional importance and specificity of the sea and
thus serve as an input for the preparation of a maritime spatial plan.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 27
Hiiu Island MSP
The plan established in 2016 sets out the general conditions for the use of Hiiu
Island MSP. Ship transport, pipelines and cables, waste, mineral extraction,
agar fishing, recreation, development areas of wind energy, and aquaculture are
identified (aquaculture can be developed outside the designated areas, if
necessary).
The Supreme Court ruling of 08.08.2018 has abolished Hiiu County Governor's
Planning Order No. 1-1/2016/114 with regard to the development areas of wind
energy production.
The Hiiu Island Maritime Spatial Plan will remain valid as a separate
document from the national Maritime Spatial Plan. The methodological
experience of Hiiu Island Maritime Spatial Plan has been taken into account in
the preparation of the national plan.
Pärnu Bay area MSP
The spatial plan established in 2017, bordering Pärnu County, defines the use
of marine space, which takes into balanced account the different interests and
spatial development needs at sea. The time horizon of the planning is 2030+.
The Maritime Spatial Plan covers an area of ca 2600 km 2. Areas covered by
the plan are fisheries, aquaculture, maritime transport, and related
infrastructure, recreation and tourism, cultural goods, renewable energies,
dumpsites, infrastructure outside of maritime transport, national defence, and
maritime safety. For each area, principles are outlined for future development,
licensing, impact assessment, and planning other activities in the marine area.
The use of the sea in Pärnu Bay has been discussed in more detail . Functional
relationships between land and sea are shown. Proposals for legislative changes
have been made to extend the scope of rights for local governments to operate
within one nautical mile in the marine area in the future. The activities required
to implement the Maritime Spatial Plan are outlined
The Pärnu County Maritime Spatial Plan will remain valid as a separate
document from the national maritime spatial plan. The methodological
experience of Pärnu County Maritime Spatial Planning has been take n into
account in the preparation of the national plan
3.2 COMPLIANCE WITH ENVIRONMENTAL OBJECTIVES
The following section provides an overview of the international, European
Union, and national environmental objectives relevant to the planning
document and describes how these objectives have been taken into account in
the preparation of the planning Document.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 28
Water Framework Directive 2000/60/EC
The EU Water Framework Directive (2000/60/EC) is a piece of legislation
designed to provide a coherent framework for action to plan and organize water
protection in the European Union. The directive sets out, among other things,
environmental objectives. Among other things, measures must be taken to
prevent the deterioration of surface water bodies.
The framework for action established by the Directive covers all other water
directives and sets as the main objective of water protection the achievement
of good status for all waters (including surface water and groundwater) by
2015. 18 The implementation of the requirements of the Water Framework
Directive and the framework for action set out therein is carried out nationally
through water management plans.
The vision of the plan to be assessed underlines the good environmental status
of the marine area. As a general principle of the planning solution, it has been
developed, taking into account, in particular, the network of protected areas
both nationally and internationally (including areas under planning). No new
uses have been spatially planned for these areas, which could have adverse
impacts on the environment.
Marine Strategy Framework Directive 2008/56/EC
The Marine Strategy Framework Directive provides the framework within
which the Member States shall take the necessary measures to achieve or
maintain good environmental status in their marine waters by 2020 at the latest.
Marine Strategies shall adopt an ecosystem-based approach to the management
of human activities, ensuring that these activities are under overall pressure to
achieve good environmental status and that the ability of marine ecosystems to
respond to human-induced change is not compromised while ensuring the
sustainable use of marine goods and services for present and future generations.
The Directive contributes to the coherence of the various policies, agreements,
and legislative measures affecting the marine environment and aims at ensuring
the integration of environmental concerns into such policies, agreements, and
measures.
The achievement of the objectives of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive
in Estonia is achieved through the Estonian Marine Strategy.
The vision of the plan to be assessed underlines the good environmental status
of the marine area. As a general principle of the planning solution, it has been
developed, taking into account, in particular, the network of protected areas
both nationally and internationally (including areas under planning). No new
18 https://www.envir.ee/et/eesmargid-tegevused/vesi/veemajanduskavad/veepoliitika -
raamdirektiivi-rakendamine
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 29
uses have been spatially planned for these areas, which could have adverse
impacts on the environment.
European Union Strategy for the Baltic Sea Region
The strategy unites eight EU Member States around the Baltic Sea - Estonia,
Lithuania, Latvia, Poland, Sweden, Germany, Finland, and Denmark. The
strategy has three general objectives:
▪ saving the sea,
▪ connecting the region,
▪ increasing well-being
and a wide range of policy and cross-cutting issues stemming from these
objectives:
▪ capacity building,
▪ climate change,
▪ cooperation with neighboring non-member countries,
▪ spatial planning.
The plan emphasizes the good environmental status of the sea and the
importance of the conservation of fish stocks. The conditions set, in conjunction
with the legislation, help to reduce the use of hazardous substances and their
associated impacts. The plan sets conditions for compensatory measures for
the fish farms that potentially release the most nutrients into the sea. The plan
designates waterways and reflects fairways. Erection of potentially obstructing
structures (e.g., wind turbines) on fairways under the conditions of the plan is
excluded. Important areas affecting maritime safety (e.g., wind energy,
aquaculture) are subject to conditions to specify the synergy during the
licensing process. The plan does not regulate issues related to agriculture,
forestry, education, and health.
Estonian Marine Strategy
The main objective of the EU Marine Strategy Framework Directive
(2008/56/EC; MSRD) is to maintain or achieve, by 2020, at the latest, good
environmental status (GES) in its marine environment, which can be achieved
through taking national measures. Each country needs to develop and
implement a Marine Strategy for its maritime domain to promote the
sustainable use of the seas and preserve marine ecosystems .
The implementation of the Marine Strategy takes place in six-year cycles, with
one cycle consisting of the assessment of the status of the marine area, the
development and subsequent updating of the monitoring program, and the
establishment, implementation, and updating of the corresponding Action Plan .
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 30
The Action Plan of the Estonian Marine Strategy 19 takes into account the
already established development plans and their implementation plans, and new
measures have been proposed in addition to the measures already implemented
and being implemented. Measures include the establishment of a network of
marine protected areas in the Estonian EEZ, the establishment of regional plans
for aquaculture to manage potential environmental pressures, the enhancement
of marine pollution response capacities to respond to env ironmental
emergencies at sea, and other activities.
The Maritime Spatial Plan is in line with the main objective of the Marine
Strategy. The activities outlined in the Marine Strategy Action Plan are largely
in line with those needed to implement the Maritime Spatial Plan.
The Climate Policy Principles until 2050
The Climate Policy Principles Document was prepared under the leadership of
the Ministry of the Environment and with the support of stakeholders. For the
first time, this document agreed on a long-term vision of Estonia's climate
policy and on the path towards it. According to the vision of climate policy, by
2050, Estonia will be a competitive, low-carbon emission economy. The
country's readiness and capacity to minimize the negative impacts o f climate
change and to make the most of the positive impacts are assured. Estonia's long -
term target is to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by almost 80 percent by
2050 compared to 1990 levels. Moving towards this target will reduce
greenhouse gas emissions by approximately 70 percent by 2030 and 72 percent
by 2040 compared to 1990 levels. The Climate Policy Principles Document
contains policy guidelines covering the whole economy), sectorial policies to
mitigate climate change in the areas of energy and industry, transport,
agriculture, forestry, and land use, and sectorial policies to adapt to the impacts
of climate change
In line with the climate policy goal to ensure a low-carbon emission economy
by 2050, the Maritime Spatial Plan has placed great emphasis on the balanced
development of wind energy and the identification of appropriate areas .
The Development plan for adaptation to climate change until 2030 20
The main objective of the development plan is to increase the preparedness and
capacity of the national, regional, and local levels to adapt to the impacts of
climate change.
The Development Document provides a framework for action to reduce
Estonia's vulnerability to the impacts of climate change. The Development Plan
19 https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/meetmekava_032017_f.pdf
20
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/kliimamuutustega_kohanemise_arengukava_aastani_
2030_1.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 31
was drawn up on the basis of in-depth studies and analyses to identify the
impact of climate change on priority areas and adaptation measures to be
implemented over a period of time up to 2030 as part of a long -term vision for
2100.
The Development Plan sets eight sub-objectives according to the priority areas
of the established economic and administrative structure in the Republic of
Estonia (separately and partly in synergy). The measures required are set out
according to the objectives.
The need for adaptation to climate change has been taken into account in the
design of the Maritime Spatial Plan. Attention has been paid to rescue
capabilities, the natural environment, and the balanced development of the blue
economy. Energy has a significant focus on finding suitable area s for wind
energy development.
EU Biodiversity Strategy up to 2030
The biodiversity strategy addresses the root causes of biodiversity loss such as
the unsustainable use of land and sea, overexploitation of natural resources,
problems related to pollution and invasive alien species.
The strategy aims to make the biodiversity considerations an important part of
the EU's overall economic growth strategy. Among other things, the strategy
proposes to establish binding targets to restore damaged ecosystems and rivers,
improve the condition of EU protected habitats and species, bring pollinators
back to farmland, reduce pollution, increase urban landscaping, promote
organic farming and other biodiversity-friendly farming practices and improve
the condition of European forests.
The strategy sets out the specific measures to help Europe's biodiversity to
recover, including by making at least 30% of Europe's land and marine areas
protected areas, i.e. at least 30% of the EU's land area and 30% of its marine
area should be protected and at least a third of the protected areas, i.e. 10% of
the EU's land area and 10% of the EU's marine area, should be strictly
protected.
The general objective of the maritime spatial plan is to ensure that the good
environmental status of the marine area is maintained and achieved. The use
of marine areas provided for in the maritime spatial plan leaves at least 30%
scope for marine protection.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 32
4 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT AFFECTED
AND THE IMPACT OF IMPLEMENTING THE PLAN
4.1 HYDROMETEOROLOGY AND HYDRODYNAMICS
4.1.1 Water temperature and salinity
Water temperature and salinity largely determine the ecosystem characteristics
of the area, including, e.g., species composition. The temperature and salinity
fields of the Baltic Sea are characterized by great variation in time and space,
due to complex topography, strong gradients both horizontally and vertically,
and great variability of the atmosphere at different time scales.
The exchange of water in the Baltic Sea with the ocean is limited as it occurs
only through the narrow and shallow straits of Denmark. Saltier water flowing
through the Strait and Beld Strait does not easily mix with lower density Baltic
Sea water and tends to sink into deeper basins. At the same time, less saline
surface water flows out of the Baltic Sea. The boundary between the two masses
of water, called the halocline, consists of a layer of water whose salinity
changes rapidly. For example, in the Baltic Sea offshore and in the Gulf of
Finland, a halocline is located approximately 60 to 80 meters deep. The
halocline acts as a lid, limiting water mixing in the vertical direction.
In the deeper parts of the open sea (> 80 m), there is usually a triple layer of
temperature and salinity in summer and a double layer in winter. The seasonal
upper mixed warm and fresh layer is typically 10-30 m thick, and its
temperature and salinity depend on the hydrometeorological conditions of a
particular period. Salinity in the upper layer is usually between 6 and 7.5 g/kg,
and the temperature does not normally exceed 20°C. Below the upper mixed
layer is a seasonal jump layer in temperature and salinity that separates the
upper layer from the cold intermediate layer. The temperature of the
intermediate layer generally varies between 1 and 4°C, and the salinity varies
between 7 and 8g/kg. Below the intermediate layer, at a depth of 60-100 m, is
the salinity jump layer, under which is in turn warmer (5 -6 °C) and saltier (10-
12 g/kg) water from the North Sea. The water in the bottom layer is often
hypoxic or even anoxic. In winter, the upper mixed lay er usually reaches the
halocline, i.e., 60 to 80 m deep 21.
Water temperatures reach their peak in the Estonian coastal sea, usually in late
July and August. In calm and sunny weather, shallow coastal areas can warm
up quickly, but as the wind intensifies, coastal water mixes with cool offshore
water or is replaced completely by offshore water. In the autumn, when the sea
21 Estonian Marine Strategy Action Plan for Achieving and Maintaining Good Environmental
Status of the Estonian Marine Area and the Strategic Assessmen t of the Environmental
Impact, 2015 (compiled by: Tallinn University of Technology Marine Systems Institute, OÜ
Alkranel)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 33
loses heat to the atmosphere, the opposite is true: calm and cool weather cools
off the coastal water more quickly, but over a period of time, the currents bring
warmer water to the coast again.
During the coldest months, water temperatures throughout the sea remain
suboptimal (<10 °C). During the warmest month, water temperatures on the
surface are above optimal almost throughout the marine area (>18ºC), taking
into account average temperatures for the warmest month (August for the
surface layer, September for the bottom layer) and the coldest month (March ).
Impact of the MSP
There is no direct environmental impact of the planning solution on the salinity
or temperature of the water (except on the soil directly in contact with the
cable).
Significant impacts in the larger salinity regime can be related, in particular, to
changes in the intensity of water exchange between the Baltic Sea and the North
Sea or to changes in rainfall patterns. The impact of wind turbines on currents and
mixing has been extensively studied in connection with the large offshore wind farms
planned in the southern part of the Baltic Sea (Rennau et al., 201222). In these
circumstances, taking into account the impact of wind turbines on the transport of water
and substances is very important in the context of the environmental condition of the
Baltic Sea as a whole, as the area is essential for water exchange between the Baltic Sea
and the North Sea.
To assess the integrated and maximum impact of the wind turbines,
approximately 1200 wind turbines planned for the shallow sea area between
Germany, Denmark and Sweden were taken into account (which was the most
extensive modelled scenario, where the wind turbines were located at a distance
of 400-800 m after a narrow channel of 20 km and the diameter of the foot of
the wind turbine placed in the water was calculated to be up to 10 m ). According
to the study, the construction of offshore wind farms on this scale has a
relatively small effect on water exchange in the Baltic and North Seas -
maximum salinity changes in the deeper layers of the region can reach about
0.3g/kg, which is significantly lower than natural seawater salinity variation -
5-10 g/kg 23.
22
Rennau, H.; Schimmels, S.; Burchard, H. On the Effect of Structure-Induced Resistance
and Mixing on Inflows into the Baltic Sea: A Numerical Model Study. Coast. Eng. 2012, 60,
53–68
23
Clark S.; Schroeder F.; Baschek B. The influence of large offshore wind farms on the
North Sea and Baltic Sea – a comprehensive literature review. HZG REPORT 2014-6 //
ISSN 2191-7833.
https://www.hzg.de/imperia/md/content/hzg/zentrale_einrichtungen/bibliothek/berichte/hzg
_reports_2014/hzg_report_2014_6.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 34
There is no direct environmental impact of the planning solution on the salinity
or temperature of the water (except on the soil directly in contact with the cable .
4.1.2 Wind
The Estonian wind climate is shaped by the frequent low -pressure and high-
pressure alternation, or cyclonic activity, characteristic of the northern part of
the temperate zone, which causes windy weather. The intensity of cyclical
activity in the Baltic Sea area depends on the general atmospheric circulation
over the Atlantic and the Eurasian continent, generally defining the speed and
direction of the wind blowing in the Estonian territory, and seasonal variability
- the strongest winds and more frequent storms are characteristic of the period
October to January, the period with the days of weaker wind and longer lulls is
usually from May to August. The direct impact of the Baltic Sea on winds is
mainly limited to islands and coastal areas (about 10 km from the coast to the
sea and a 20 km wide inland zone), where the power of the winds gathering
speed over a wide water field gradually declines due to the obstacles in the
form of forests and hills. In addition to higher wind speeds, there are more
winds and breezes in the coastal areas compared to the hinterland. Because of
the presence of breezes, i.e., the land and sea winds, the direction of the wind
on the coast is often different from that of inland winds.
The average annual wind speed is 150 meters to 8.5 to 9 meters per second in
sea areas west of the islands, with gusts above 30 m/s. The average annual wind
speed in the open middle part of the Gulf of Riga is 8 to 8.5 m/s, with gusts 26
to 28 m/s. The winds of the Väinamere Sea are heavily shaded by islands and
the mainland, with annual average wind speeds of less than 8 m/s, however,
gusts can still exceed 29 m/s. In the Gulf of Finland, both the wind speed and
the intensity of the gusts are clearly decreasing in the west -east direction: the
open western part of the Gulf has an average wind speed at the height of 150 m
at 8-8.8 m/s, eastern only 7 to 7.5 m/s and gusts > respectively 30 m/s and
below 28 m/s.
The number of days with storm winds (>15 m/s) and strong winds is also rapidly
decreasing from the coast in the direction of inland. Offshore and windy coasts
have an average of up to 40 storm days per year, but in the transitional coastal
zone, there are usually 10-20 storm days above the sea and 10-20 km inland,
mostly less than 10.
Long-term average wind energy (energy density, W/m 2 ) is 150 m high in the
central part of Gulf of Riga, averaging 700-780 W/m 2 and 810-880 W/m 2
offshore west from Saaremaa, 800-840 W/m 2 near Hiiu Island, in the Gulf of
Finland the energy density decreases in the western part (750 W/m 2 ) to the east
(550 W/m 2 ).
Impact of the MSP
The activities proposed in the context of Maritime Spatial Plan are not of a
scale capable of affecting the regional wind climate and have no national or
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 35
transboundary impact on the spread of air and pollutants. Large wind farms
have the strongest local impact on the wind (speed, turbul ence, direction,
mixing of air layers in the layer close to the substrate), but their impact
disappears depending on the configuration of the wind farm to be built within
7 to 9 km of the outermost wind turbine. Wind speeds are affected in offshore
wind farms and to varying degree within this area:
▪ the strongest effect on wind occurs directly downwind of the wind
turbine rotor (from a few meters to twenty meters), where the kinetic
energy of the wind can theoretically decrease by up to 59.3% (Betz limit,
also expressed as a ratio or Cp = 0.593) compared to the initial, in reality
the Cp factor weighted by the frequency distribution of the wind speeds
of newer modern offshore wind turbines is between 0.3 and 0.4 . The Cp
factor depends on the wind speed and the wind turbine is optimized to
receive maximum wind energy at speeds of 6–11 m/s, when the Cp factor
is in the maximum range of 0.4–0.5 in case of the most efficient wind
turbines.
Due to the cubic dependent relationship between wind speed and energy
(wind energy is proportional to wind speed cube and vice versa, wind
speed is proportional to the cubic root of wind energy), the average wind
speed in and around the wind farm cannot theoretically decrease from
the Betz limit. The decrease of wind speed below the Betz limit is only
possible for a short time, with a very low impact zone and in exceptional
situations (very low wind speed) where the cross -section of the wind
turbines acts as the on-site physical obstacle to air movement (similar to
a building wall or a single tree);
▪ the height of the wind turbine rotors (which affects the wind) above sea
level is between 40 meters in the lower position and 300 meters in the
upper position of the rotor during the current maximum and the period
covered by the maritime spatial plan. The maximum effect remains as a
decreasing cone behind each rotor in each individual wind turbine, and
the impact on the wind directly at sea level (40 m from the lower
operating limit of the rotor to the sea level) is weakly affected. The effect
is also insignificant from the upper operating limit of the wind turbine
rotor (approximately 300 m above sea level).
It should be noted that the distance between the wind turbines in a wind
farm depends on the diameter of the rotors (and thus indirectly on the
wind turbine power), usually between 4-8 rotor diameters and as the
theoretical energy efficiency is limited by the Betz limit (actually with
even lower value Cp=0.3-0.4), then the real rate of wind energy
reduction in the Estonian maritime spatial plan modelled with
perspective future wind turbines (rotor diameter 200 m, tower height 150
m) in a rectangular park with 100 wind turbines (the so-called worst case
scenario, distances of wind turbine of 4-8 diameters) remains within 8.8-
17.8% on average.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 36
The decrease in wind speed is thus smaller in proportion to the cubic
root. Only the area most affected by the wind farm was taken into
account and the area around the wind farm (7-9 km) was excluded, where
the impact decreases very rapidly due to the absence of sur face
roughness factors (wind turbines), however, the climatic factors that
cause the wind (and restore the wind speed and other properties) (air
pressure difference, thermal difference of the substrate and gradient) are
retained 24;
▪ the change in wind direction due to wind turbines occurs only due to the
general increase in surface roughness (identical to the change in surface
roughness due to transition from sea to land, forest effects, construction
effects and other physical obstacles that alter the roughn ess of the
substrate) and thereby to a lesser extent than, for example, the change in
forest cover on land, as due to the offshore wind turbines there is no
change in the thermal properties of the substrate (the sea surface remains
free and the radiation regime and thermal properties do not change) less
to the change in thermal properties (the sea surface remain s free and the
radiation regime and the thermal properties do not change) and the
average change in wind direction is only 2 degrees counterclockwise,
which is insignificant as an influence on water flow or currents.
However, the air flow behind the wind turbines is more turbulent than in
the undisturbed area of the wind farm and this strongly just behind each
wind turbine (altitude range from 40 to 280 meters above sea level) in
the form of a cone decreasing downwind for a few hundred meters
(depending on the current wind speed) and the difference in turbulence
disappears at the distance of 2 km from the wind turbine. The natural
transition in the coastal zone (from sea to land), where both the surface
roughness and the nature of the substrate change (radiation and thermal
regime) is many times larger vertically and horizontally (at least 10 km
towards the sea and vertically within the atmospheric boundary layer)
and changes in turbulence due to land use changes (afforestation or
clear-cutting areas, densely populated areas, hedges) are more turbulent
than wind turbines scattered in the offshore wind farm (distance of 4-8
rotor diameters).
Consequently, the effect of the offshore wind farm on the wind outside the
offshore wind farm can be considered insignificant and the wind parameters
significantly affected only locally in the wind farm just behind the wind
turbines as a descending cone downwind of the rotor. At sea level the impact
of wind farms on the winds and thus on marine life is insignificant, as the slight
decrease in wind speed in the wind farm immediately above the sea does not
affect the wave, thermal regime or oxygen diffusion at sea level and both in
and around the wind farm the climatic factors influencing wind generation (air
24
The technical data of the wind turbine manufacturers (Enercon, Siemens Gamesa Renewable
Energy, MHI Vestas Offshore Wind and GE Renewable Energy) have been used in the
estimates
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 37
pressure gradient, thermal gradient) have remained unchanged and the original
wind characteristics are restored (similar to what happens on land between the
areas with different surface roughness). The wind speed and other properties
will recover due to the general regional air pressure gradient and within very
limited area (a few kilometres) and time (a few to tens of minutes).
Air quality may also be affected to a limited extent by ship traffic, but air
exchange on the high seas is so good that pollution levels are not exceeded
locally or regionally. Possible mitigation measures to reduce air pollution
include the use of fuels with lower sulfur content, the use of main engines with
lower NO x emissions, and general speed limitation, which reduces the fuel
consumption of ships. In exceptional cases (inversion, a lull in warm weather),
ship emissions may only exceed the emission limits when stationary or
manoeuvring with the engine running in the port/aquatic area/roadstead. The
mitigating measures, in this case, could be in particular, better logistics (shorter
downtime with the main engine running, fewer ships main engines running at
one time in port), and use of ships with a lower level of pollution .
The activities proposed in the context of Maritime Spatial Planning a re not of
a scale capable of affecting the regional wind climate and have no national or
transboundary impact on the spread of air and pollutants .
4.1.3 Ice conditions25
In the Estonian marine area, at least in Pärnu Bay and the Väinameri Sea, ice
cover occurs every year. In extremely mild winters (e.g., 2007/2008), ice is
only found in Pärnu Bay and the Gulfs of Väinameri. In harsh winters (e.g.,
2010/2011), the entire Estonian sea area is covered with ice, and even on the
west coast of Hiiumaa and Saaremaa, ice is present for 30 days.
On average, Pärnu Bay, Väinameri Sea, and Narva Bay are covered with ice
50% of the time (December 15 to May 1), but in severe winters, th e figure can
be 85%. In the western and central parts of the Gulf of Finland, the ice period
is shorter - 30% on average and 60% during severe winters. However, in the
western and central parts of the Gulf of Finland, an important barrier to offshore
activities is the ice drift and its potential damage to offshore and coastal
facilities.
25
The chapter is largely based on a basic research of Maritime Spatial Plan: Analysis of ice
conditions and drawing of maps (ice probability map and ice cover duration map, worst case
scenario map based on 2010/2011, hummock ice probability map, etc.), TUT Institute of
Marine Systems, 2016
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 38
Figure 4.1.3-1. Figure (a) shows the average duration of the ice season in days
2000-2016 at each network point. The duration of the ice season in days with
different winter scenarios: (b) mild winters average, (c) average winters
average, and (d) harsh winters average. Source: TUT Institute of Marine
Systems, 2016.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 39
Figure 4.1.3-2. The figure shows the probability (%) of ice occurrence at each
point of the space during the period 2000-2016. The likelihood of ice occurring
in different winter scenarios: (b) mild winters, (c) average winters, and (d)
severe winters. (source: TTU Institute of Marine Systems, 2016 )
Drifting ice occurs mainly in areas with a shorter average duration of ice cover
- the western and central parts of the Gulf of Finland, the open part of the Gulf
of Riga, and the western coast of Saaremaa. In these areas, the sea is deeper,
and the coastline does not allow ice cover to anchor permanently, such as in the
Väinameri Sea between islands and mainland or in the closed Gulf of Pärnu.
The western part of the Gulf of Finland (north of Hiiu County and Vormsi) is
characterized by ice flows both east-west (mean 0.02 m/s) and north-south
(mean 0.025 m/s). Meanwhile, in the central part of the Gulf of Finland
(Paldiski to Kunda), due to the elongated shape of the Gulf of Finland, the drift
along the Gulf dominates with an average speed of up to 0.04 m/s. Ice drift is
likely to cause damage to stationary offshore installations in the western and
central parts of the Gulf of Finland and in the open part of the Gulf of Riga. In
these areas, ice fields of tens of square kilometres can drift at 0.23 m/s for 30
to 40 km within 48 hours.
The movement of drift ice causes the formation of hummock ice, which makes
it difficult for ships to move during the winter. The analyzed data show that a
significant number of hummocks were formed in the border areas of fast ice ,
where drift ice was piled up/pushed by wind and currents. In severe winters,
hummocks can occur in most marine areas of Estonia, including the western
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 40
Gulf of Finland, where they can persist for a period of 30 days. The areas most
affected by the hummocks are Pärnu Bay, Väinameri, and Narva Bay, as these
areas also have the longest ice cover duration.
Impact of the MSP
In the western and central parts of the Gulf of Finland and in the opening of the
Gulf of Riga, drift ice and the potential damage to offshore and coastal
structures are important barriers to maritime activities. Due to the ice
conditions, it is necessary to take into account, with more precise designs of
facilities (wind turbine type, fish farms, etc.) for the marine area or at the
project level that the facilities need to be more resilient to the impacts of ice.
In connection with the formation of ice cover and the movement of hummock
ice, it is also necessary to protect the proposed submarine cables in the shallow
coastal area in such a way that the cable cannot be broken by the ice. One way
to protect the cables from ice would be to immerse them in seabed sediments
or to bury the cables. This ensures the safety of wind farms, fish farming
facilities, etc., and avoids environmental risks.
In the stage of drawing up the Maritime Spatial Plan, it will not be known, due
to the strategic nature of the plan, what the specific solutions will be for the
proposed activities, e.g., traffic load related to the maintenance of wind farms
(icebreaking works) or possible changes to the sea ice mobility and their
consequences, e.g., on seals, as animals may gather for farrowing on fairways
maintained by icebreakers or in wind farms with the standing ice. Therefore, at
the project level of the proposed activities, it is necessary to assess how the
proposed activity, in synergy with other similar development activities, will
have an impact on ice cover changes and sea ice mobility. Also, what is the
impact of ice-breaking activities during the ice period.
The proposed activities of the maritime spatial plan will not affect regional ice
conditions.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. In connection with the formation of ice cover and the movement of
hummock ice, it is also necessary to protect the proposed submarine
cables in the shallow coastal area in such a way that the cable cannot be
broken by the ice.
2. Upon more precise design of facilities (wind turbine type, fish farms,
etc.) for the marine area or at the project level, that the facilities need to
be more resilient to the risks arising from ice conditions .
3. At the project level of the proposed activities, it is necessary to assess
how the proposed activity, in synergy with other similar development
activities, will have an impact on ice cover changes and sea ice mobility.
Also, what is the impact of ice-breaking activities during the ice period.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 41
4.1.4 Waves and currents
The currents of the Baltic Sea depend on the direction and strength of the wind.
Water flow along the Estonian coast in the eastern direction is more common.
The water level is raised by strong western winds and lowered by east winds.
In extreme cases, fluctuations have been 2–2.5 m above and 1.2 m below the
mean water level. The wave height is usually 1-2 m, the offshore wave height
is 5-6 m during a storm, and up to 10 m during an exceptional western storm.
The wave height is 6 meters in the Gulf of Finland and 3-4 meters in the Gulf
of Riga. Temporary, short-term elevations and decreases in water levels depend
on the topography of the coast and local wind conditions. Changes in water
levels are smallest on the offshore coast and increasing towards the eas tern part
of the Gulf of Finland.
The characteristic current velocity in the surface layer of the Estonian marine
area is 10–20 cm/s. However, currents are highly volatile and highly dependent
on the local wind. The inertia period, the period of Baltic Se a self-oscillation,
and mesomastic processes (synoptic scale) dominate the variability. Maximum
current velocities in excess of 1 m/s have been recorded for occasional strong
coastal jets in the straits (e.g., Suur Strait) and along the coast (e.g., Gulf o f
Finland). As the sea area is vertically stratified during the summer months, the
vertical distribution of currents is also characterized by stratification. It is
important to note that in the deeper layers of the sea (including near the seabed),
currents of 40-50 cm/s may occur.
Impact of the MSP
Offshore installations, including aquaculture installations, wind turbines and
the associated infrastructure, where waves, currents and mixing in the
immediate vicinity are directly affected by obstacles placed in the water. The
concomitant effects are rather local and, in case of aquaculture facilities,
depend on the chosen technology.
The areas suitable for the development of wind energy found in the Estonian
maritime spatial plan are dominated by weak unstable currents caused by winds.
Long-term effects on currents/ecosystems due to changes in wind
characteristics within 10 km of the offshore wind farm is insignificant, as the
changes in wind speed as an average of the wind farm area are very small due
to the sparse location of the wind turbines (the distance between wind turbines
is 4-8 rotor diameters): the wind energy affecting the formation of waves at sea
level (0-40 m above sea level below the wind turbine rotors) is reduced by less
than 5% for a park with 100 wind turbines (200 m rotor, wind turbine spacing
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 42
4 diameters, tower height 150 m, rectangular arrangement in the worst case
scenario) 26.
This decrease in speed, combined with a 2 degree change in direction, cannot
significantly change the generation, direction, or intensity of wind currents.
Considering the distance between the wind turbines (4-8 rotor diameters) and
the largest diameter variant of the foundation (gravitational foundation,
diameter of the widest part of the cone foot is expected to be 50 -60 m for
potential 10+ MW wind turbines, up to a maximum of 100 m), it is possible
only in the worst-case scenario in very shallow water, where the foundation is
cylindrical instead of a truncated cone. The Estonian maritime spatial plan
excludes the construction of wind turbines closer than 6 nautical miles (approx.
11.1 km) to the coast. (See Chapters 4.1.1 and 4.1.2).
In case of the ratio between such an obstacle and the area open to the movement
of water, it is not possible to have a significant adverse effect by considering
the speed of water flow in the currents. Other results of modelling the impact
of offshore wind farm foundations in the Baltic Sea have provided a similar
assessment 27.
There are no permanent changes in wind speed, directional turbulence and other
characteristics due to the wind farm: the changes disappear outside the win d
farm within 7-9 km downwind and within 1 km headwind at the latest. At the
same time the climatic factors affecting the wind characteristics of the wind
farm are not affected which ensures the full recovery of wind properties outside
the area of influence of the wind farm, as well as the area of the wind farm after
its liquidation for a longer period of time.
However, the impact of wind turbines on water flow and currents has so far
been considered to be insignificant and local. The activities planned by the
planning solution do not have a significant impact on the waves and currents;
the impacts on the facilities tend to remain local (Also check chapter 4.1.2
Wind).
The activities planned by the planning solution do not have a significant impact
on the waves and currents, the effects in case of facilities tend to remain local .
4.1.5 Water quality
Seawater quality refers to the set of values and status estimates used to assess
the status of seawater. The quality (status) of seawater is assessed through a
26
The significance assessment is agreed, the 5% and 10% limits are more widely used in
science. Thus, the phenomenon should be affected by at least 5% or 10%, and this difference
should be in addition to the natural variability.
27
Rennau, H., 2011. Natural, numerical and structure-induced mixing in dense gravity
currents: idealised and realistic model studies. PhD thesis, Uni Rostock . https://www.io-
warnemuende.de/tl_files/staff/burchard/pdf/thesis_hannes.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 43
number of different assessment instruments, depending on the geographical
coverage of seawater within the scope of different legal instruments. In Estonia,
the methodology for assessing seawater quality differs between coastal waters
(up to 1 m from the coastline towards the high seas from the datum line) and
offshore. Estimates of coastal water status are based on the evaluation matrix
of the EU Water Framework Directive (Estonia's own assessment system is
provided by the Minister of the Environment Regulation No 19 28).
The aggregate status used to characterize coastal waters consists of two
components - the ecological status and chemical status. Depending on the
magnitude of the human impact, the ecological status of coastal bodies of water
is assessed on a 5-point scale: from very good status with little or no
anthropogenic changes to biological status to very poor status (biological
parameters deviate very much from the reference conditions, or there is no
biota). The biological parameters assessed are divided into three 'quality
elements': phytoplankton, benthic flora, and benthic fauna. The physi cal and
chemical parameters of the seawater (nutrient concentrations and water
transparency) are additional parameters used to explain the state of the
biological parameters and the causes of the changes. The chemical status of a
body of water is assessed on a 2-point scale: good - priority pollutants are below
a threshold value established as an ecological quality standard; poor - the
content of the priority substance is above the quality standard 29.
The hydromorphological quality indicators for determining the ecological
status class of the coastal water body are the bottom surface load index of the
coastal water body (abbreviation PÕKI) and coastline load index of the coastal
water body (abbreviation RAKI), which are calculated by using the following
indicators: naturalness of currents, alternation of water depth and its
naturalness, naturalness of the bottom in different ecological zones and the rate
of anthropogenic changes in the coastline.
The official assessment of the ecological and aggregate status of the Estonian
coastal waters dates from 2019. According to the latter the ecological status of
the Estonian coastal water reservoirs (abbreviation RVK) in Haapsalu Bay and
Matsalu Bay is poor, the status is “moderate” in case of RVK of Muuga-Tallinn-
Kakumäe and RVK of Pärnu Bay. All other coastal waters are "moderate". The
assessment of the overall status is "poor" for all coastal water bodies (Figure
4.1.5-1 and Figure 4.1.5-2.). The ecological as well as chemical status of
coastal water bodies is also provided separately, by single coastal water bodies
in the respective annual reports of the National Environmental Monitoring and
28 Regulation No. 19 of the Minister of the Environment of 16 April 2020 “List of surface
water bodies, procedure for determining surface water bodies and territorial sea status classes,
values of quality indicators of ecological status classes of surface water bodies and values of
quality indicators of non-surface water bodies” (hereinafter Regulation No. 19)
29
https://www.keskkonnaagentuur.ee/et/eesmargid-
tegevused/vesi/meri/rannikuveekogumite-seisund
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 44
is displayed in the map application of water bodies of the Environment
Agency 30.
Figure 4.1.5-1. Ecological status of Estonian coastal water bodies based on
2019 assessment (Source: Environment Agency)
30
https://kaur.maps.arcgis.com/apps/MapSeries/index.html?appid=fd27acd277084f2b97eee82
891873c41
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 45
Figure 4.1.5-2. Aggregate status of Estonian coastal water bodies based on
2019 assessment (Source: Environment Agency)
Marine areas outside the coastal zone are assessed according to the guidelines
of the EU Marine Strategy Framework Directive. The MSFD describes the
status of a marine area on the basis of eleven Good Environmental Status (GEA)
attributes, of which Indicator 5 includes indicators of eutrophication.
Eutrophication is one of the biggest environmental problems in the Baltic Sea
today. Eutrophication is caused by the accumulation of nutrients (especially
nitrogen and phosphorus compounds) in the marine environment. Due to the
nature of the Baltic Sea basin (located in a rainy climate zone, intensive land
use) and hydrological features (water exchange with the ocean is very limited,
long water retention time is up to 30 years), nutrient accumulation in the Balti c
Sea environment is also a natural process, fueled by human activity. The
manifestations of eutrophication are a number of simple and complex
symptoms, both by individual ecosystem components and at the level of the
ecosystem as a whole, including both positive (high secondary production
including planktonic fish biomass) and numerous negative (increased primary
production - algal blooms, deficiency of oxygen in the demersal water layers,
depletion of species diversity) and other phenomena.
The state of the eutrophication of the Estonian marine area has been extensively
evaluated in the context of reporting under the EU Marine Strategy Framework
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 46
Directive (TUT MSI, 2017 31). The status assessment methodology is based on
a comparison of measured values with predetermined threshold values and is
reported on a five-class scale similar to the Water Framework Directive
methodology. The units of assessment are the coastal water bodies and the
distribution of the high sea areas according to the HELCOM division.
Corresponding threshold values are determined either by Estonia's own
regulation or according to the values used by relevant HELCOM working
groups.
Nitrogen and phosphorus indicators were evaluated as for nutrient
concentrations in seawater. Assessments of the total nitrogen concentration in
summer were generally in the good and poor classes. Assessments of the total
nitrogen concentration in summer were generally in the poor, bad, and very bad
classes. The three coastal water bodies between the mainland and th e islands
and the northern basin of the Baltic Proper were assessed to be in very poor
status. Assessments of winter concentrations of inorganic nitrogen were mostly
in the poor and very poor class. Nine coastal water bodies were not assessed
due to the lack of monitoring data. Assessments of the state of winter phosphate
concentrations were mostly in a very poor class. Also, nine coastal water bodies
were not assessed due to the lack of monitoring data. Water bodies to the west
of the mouth of the Gulf of Finland were in a very poor state.
The nutrients of the Estonian coastal seawater come from many different
sources. Land-based sources play a greater role in the areas closer to the coast,
while in the case of offshore areas, the movement of seawater and t he exchange
of water between the various basins of the Baltic Sea are of greater importance .
31 EL merestrateegia raamdirektiivi (2008/56/EÜ)kohane merekeskkonna seisundihinnang
teemadeleutrofeerumine ja hüdrograafilised muutused (D5 ja D7), TTÜ MSI 2017,
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/d5_d7.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 47
Figure 4.1.5-3. Estimates of the status of the Estonian marine area based on
four nutrient indicators in 2011-2016 (Source: TUT MSI, 2017)
Condition assessments based on chlorophyll-a content (mg/m 3 ) were mostly in
the poor category, with four water bodies also in a very bad class (Figure 4.1.5 -
4). In water bodies where the GES (Good Environmental Status) for this
indicator has been achieved, this may be due to the fact that data have only
been collected once every six years. In general, there is a discrepancy between
estimates for coastal and offshore areas. The difference may be due to the data
aggregation methodology since arithmetic averages are used in offshore areas
and median averages in coastal areas.
Assessments of phytoplankton biomass (mg/m 3 ) status were mostly in the
moderate, poor, and very poor class, with good status achieved in three coastal
water bodies. The variability in estimates of water bodies in the Gulf of Finland
may also be due to the frequency of data collection (some water bodies are not
adequately covered by monitoring and estimates are based on a small amount
of data).
Figure 4.1.5-4. Status assessments of phytoplankton indicators (chlorophyll a
and phytoplankton biomass) in the Estonian marine area according to MSFD
reporting (Source TUT MSI 2017)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 48
The status assessments based on the transparency of the seawater (Secchi depth)
were mostly in the poor class, with four bodies of water also in bad, three in
very bad, and two in the good class (Figure 4.1.5-5). Again, two coastal water
bodies of the Gulf of Finland qualified for a good class, where only one year of
monitoring was performed during the assessment period, and thus this
assessment is of low reliability. Three indicators were considered as indicators
based on the oxygen concentration of seawater: the Deepwater Oxygen
Deficiency Indicator, the oxygen content of the demersal water of the shallow
coastal sea, and the oxygen consumption in the deepwater layer. Estimates were
given only for the Deep-Water Oxygen Deficiency Indicator, as there is no
common methodology or monitoring data for the other two indicators. The
results again showed moderate status for offshore areas.
Figure 4.1.5-5. Status assessment of water transparency and oxygen
concentration-based indicators in Estonian marine area according to MSFD
reporting (Source TUT MSI 2017)
In addition to the above, a number of indicators used mainly for shallow coastal
waters were used to provide an overall assessment of eutrophication, such as :
▪ the proportion of opportunistic species in benthic communities ,
▪ depth distribution of benthic vegetation,
▪ depth distribution of bladderwrack,
▪ percentage of perennial species in communities,
▪ zoobenthos community index,
▪ soft-bottom benthic fauna.
The status estimates for all of the above-mentioned indicators were
significantly better than those based on physical and chemical parameters.
The aggregate assessment of eutrophication (Figure 4.1.5 -6) was obtained by
aggregating the assessment results of the individual indicators according to the
methodology used in the HELCOM HOLAS eutrophication report. According
to the aggregate assessment, the Estonian marine area is divided into "very
bad," "bad," and "poor" status classes, which is dominated by the "bad" status
class
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 49
Figure 4.1.5-6. The general assessment of the state of eutrophication
(aggregated assessment of all indicators) for the Estonian marine area
according to the GES assessment of the Estonian marine area according to
MSFD (source TUT MSI 2017).
Impact of the MSP
In the case of the shallow coastal sea and the Väinameri Sea, it can be assumed
that the main influencers of the condition are on land, and the impact itself is
manifested through the nutrient flow from inland. In the offshore area, water
exchange with other marine areas and the overall level of eutrophication in the
Baltic Sea are the major influencing factors.
The impact of the proposed planning solution on a larger scale (assessment
units at the level of offshore or coastal water bodies) is likely to be very
minimal since the spatial activities foreseen in the planning are all local and
have very little impact on the larger scale nutrient flows. None of the status
assessments at the assessment unit level are likely to be affected by any of the
activities provided by the planning (in any case, the status class of the spatial
assessment unit will not change due to the planned activity).
At the same time, several proposed activities (e.g., the establishment of fish
farming, installation of wind turbines, etc.) will have a short-term or spatially
limited impact on water quality. For example, there can be a certain impact on
water quality during the construction phase of the wind farm, where the
following earthworks are carried out: leveling the bottom where necessar y at
the location of each wind turbine installation, stabilizing the foundation base
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 50
with the filling, filling the foundation cone with sand and laying the cable. For
all operations causing bottom disturbances, the impact on water quality will
depend on the amount and quality of sediment discharged from the bottom to
the water column and the prevailing hydrodynamic conditions. The impact on
water quality during the construction phase of the wind farm and the cable
corridore is negative but is likely to be insignificant due to its short-term and
local impact and small impact compared to natural variability and other human
activities. At the licensing level, it is necessary to assess the impact of the
proposed activities on a site-by-site basis and to provide more specific
measures to reduce the adverse impacts.
In mining, the main impact on water quality is the generation of suspended
matter in the water column. More specific measures to minimize impact must
be foreseen in the extraction licensing process.
Large-scale changes in water quality may be associated with fish farms. Impact
from the fish farm can be divided into local and larger -scale processes, which
require different approaches and depend on the precise size and technology of
the fish farm being planned.
With open fish cages that today are the most commonly used, the biggest
contributor is the nutrient leaking from the fish cage (nitrogen and phosphorus),
which is released into the environment in very different forms - feed, fish
excrement, and fish mucus. Local nutrient and organic matter accumulation
cause significant problems in the immediate vicinity of the cages. At the same
time, in offshore conditions where water movement is intense, this local impact
is negligible as substances leaking from the cages are dispersed over large sea
areas.
Local impact is related to adverse events due to increased nutrient
concentrations. These include, for example, increased organic matter content
in the seabed below fish cages, oxygen depletion, loss of biota, increased water
nutrition, the proliferation of pelagic micro-algae, changes in macro-algae and
invertebrate communities, and mass exchanges in the immediate vicinity of
opportunistic species. Depending on the specific location of the development
and/or existing pressures, the extent and nature of local changes/impact may
vary widely. Therefore, the assessment of the impacts of a particular fish farm
should take into account, in particular, the technological features of the fish
farm and all local features (e.g., the character of the coastal slope, the openness
aspect) and hydrological conditions (the nature of tides and waves) affecting
the movement of nutrients released from the fish cage in the marine
environment (including the rate of nutrient dissolution).
Measures which directly affect the availability of nutrients in the water column
are suitable for mitigating local impacts. These may include algae and shellfish
farming near fish cages, technological techniques to prevent nutrient leaching
from the fish cage (for example, collecting feed residues and feces in or in the
immediate vicinity of the cage) as well as chemical bonding or more efficient
dilution of fish farming nutrients. Such measures will make it possible to reduce
the negative impacts of the added nutrient flow in the immediate vicinity of the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 51
fish farm. It is important to consider the development and location specifics.
The intensity of the negative impacts is highly dependent on the fish farm's own
parameters and natural conditions in the immediate vicinity of the fish cage.
Negative environmental impact is particularly likely to occur in sea areas with
limited water exchange (nearshore locations, locations hidden from the wind,
narrow and deep bays, extensive shallows). Consequently, during the
preparation of the planning solution, unsuitable or excluding areas for the
development of the fish farm (resulting from the worst technological scenario)
have been identified due to the precautionary principle. In the course of th e
planning solution the protected natural objects were identified as unsuitable
areas for fish farming, including Natura network areas, with the aim of
excluding any possible adverse effects on the protected natural values (see also
Chapter 2). In addition, the planning solution directs the establishment of fish
farms to deeper (> 5 m) and more open sea areas in order to reduce the local
impact of pollution. In the deeper sea areas nutrients are better dispersed due
to the intensive movement of water, in addition, the deeper sea areas usually
have less affected biota (seabed habitats, fish spawning grounds, etc.).
The purpose of the maritime spatial plan is to promote the development of the
blue maritime economy and nutrient-neutral aquaculture, i.e. the condition of
the marine environment should not deteriorate as a result of the planned
activities. The impact of aquaculture, including fish farming, depends largely
on the technology chosen and the species cultivated. The aquaculture sector is
undergoing rapid technological development (e.g. semi-enclosed on-board fish
farming systems, closed cages, etc.), which has the potential to develop
nutrient-neutral and nutrient-removing aquaculture. The selection of fish
farming technology and the assessment of the environmental impacts related to
this activity is carried out at the level of authorization.
Large-scale processes include nutrient balances in sea basins, which depend on
the total nutrient load in the Baltic Sea on the one hand and on climatic factors
on the other. The latter determines the movement of nutrients between marine
sediments and the water column. It is also important to understand the natural
dynamics of nutrient loads in the basin, which, as a rule, depends on climatic
and other large-scale factors. For example, the overall nutrient load in the
north-eastern part of the Baltic Sea is directly related to the amount of
precipitation in the region, and the resulting difference in nutrient loads
between years can be dozens of percent.
There are other ways of smoothing out large-scale processes to maintain the
overall nutrient balance of the basin. In particular, activities that take into
account the overall metabolism, such as the use of local feed (production of
fish feed from raw materials from the same basin) are suitable measures.
Alternative solutions to balance the nutrient balance of the basin can also be
used as compensatory or mitigation measures. For example, more most
effective nutrients removal options can be developed for the other nutrient load
sources flowing into the same basin drains into nutrient loading sources can
contribute in more efficient treatment of the settlement and industrial
wastewater, reduction of agricultural burden resulting from the land use or
other options of removal of nutrients from the marine environment, such as
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 52
additional fishing 32 or picking of coastal rejects. It is important to understand
the magnitude of the impact of all processes and measures, i.e., larger basins
need to consider the transport of nutrients and water between basins, the
metabolism between the water column and the seabed. A more detailed national
analysis is needed because without adequate assessment of water exchange, and
nutrient flows between different parts of the sea, adequate regional measures
(e.g., by coastal bodies of water) cannot be proposed, which in turn can lead to
inefficient use of resources and unreasonable fish farming costs. On the basis
of a more detailed study, it is possible to assess the importance of the proposed
load on the marine environment in the context of a natural process .
The development of algae and shellfish farming has the potential to contribute
to the achievement and maintenance of the good status of the marine
environment by contributing to the removal of nutrients from the marine
environment. Based on the average growth rate of shellfish, it is already
possible to remove 35 tons of nitrogen and 2.7 tons of phosphorus per 1 km 2 of
marine waters from the coastal area of West Estonia at the estimated rate of one
year. In addition to nutrient removal, this shell farm significantly increases the
transparency of water within a radius of about 1 km 2 and reduces the risk of
local algal blooms due to, for example, fish farming or other human act ivities
that add nutrients to the marine environment. Consequently, it is prudent to
place shellfish farms in the vicinity of fish farms in the coastal sea, as this
combination can compensate for the nutrient fluxes from fish farms to the sea
and keep the water in the vicinity of the fish farm transparent. However, it
should be borne in mind that shellfish farming, and algae farming may, in some
cases, also have negative impacts such as local over-nutrition of the seabed, but
such impacts are smaller in magnitude than similar environmental impacts of
fish farms 33, 34. The plan, therefore, favors algae and shellfish farming as a
measure to mitigate the impacts of other activities (e.g., fish farming) and does
not preclude their creation in protected natural areas where aquaculture could
also help to improve the status of the marine environment. However, the
development of shellfish and algae cultivation in protected areas must be
guided primarily by the conservation objectives of the protected area an d the
32 Developing measures to compensate for nitrogen and phosphorus loads directed to the sea
through fish farming; J.Kotta, R.Eschbaum, G.Martin, University of Tartu 2019
33
Kotta, J.; Futter, M.; Kaasik, A.; Liversage, K.; Rä tsep, M.; Barboza, F.R.; Bergström, L.;
Bergström, P.; Bobsien, I.; Díaz, E.; Herkül, K.; Jonsson, P.R.; Korpinen, S.; Kraufvelin, P.;
Krost, P.; Lindahl, O.; Lindegarth, M.; Lyngsgaard, M.M.; Mühl, M.; Sandman, A.N.; Orav -
Kotta, H.; Orlova, M.; Skov, H.; Rissanen, J.; Šiaulys, A.; Vidakovic, A.; Virtanen, E. 2020.
Response to a letter to editor regarding Kotta et al. 2020: Cleaning up seas using blue growth
initiatives: Mussel farming for eutrophication control in the Baltic Sea. STOTEN , 709,
136144.
34
Andreas Holbach, Marie Maar, Karen Timmermann, Daniel Taylor. 2020. A spatial model
for nutrient mitigation potential of blue mussel farms in the western Baltic Sea. Science of
The Total Environment, 736,139624.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 53
legislation applicable therein, and therefore the plan requires that the impact be
specified in cooperation with the Environmental Board.
The impact on water quality during the construction phase of the wind farm and
the cable corridore is negative but insignificant due to its short-term and local
impact and its impact is small compared to natural variability and other human
activities.
Large-scale changes in water quality may be associated with establishment of
fish farms. Fish farm effects can be divided into local and large-scale processes
that require different approaches. The development of algae and shellfish
farming has the potential to contribute to the achievement and maintenance of
good status of the marine environment by contributing to the removal of
nutrients from the marine environment. Therefore, the planning solution should
favour multitrophic aquaculture.
The impact of the proposed planning solution on a larger scale (assessment
units at the level of offshore areas or coastal water bodies) is not relevant since
the spatial activities foreseen in the planning are all local and have very little
impact on the larger scale nutrient flows, therefore, the implementation of the
maritime spatial plan does not foresee the occurrence of signific ant adverse
effects by implementing the envisaged environmental measures and
recommendations at the level of authorization.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. Possible measures to mitigate the impact of the planned activities on the
water quality in the Estonian marine area are very area and activity
specific and should be envisaged in the planning of each specific
development project. At the licensing level, it is necessary to assess the
impacts of the proposed activities on a site-by-site basis and to provide
more specific measures to minimize the adverse effects.
2. The effects of wind farms during construction will be short-term and can
be mitigated by technical measures proposed at the project level . The
installation of wind turbines does not have a lasting effect on water
quality. However, at the level of authorization, the effects of the
proposed activities should be assessed on a site-by-site basis and, where
necessary, more specific measures should be taken to minimize the
significant adverse effects.
3. The main impact of mining on water quality is the generation of
suspended matter in the water column. More specific measures to
minimize impacts must be foreseen in the licencing process .
4. The impact of aquaculture, including fish farming, depends to a lar ge
extent on the technology chosen and the species cultivated. The fish
farming sector is undergoing rapid technological development ( e.g.
semi-enclosed on-board fish farming systems, closed cages, etc.), which
enables to develop nutrient-removing aquaculture. The selection of fish
farming technology and the assessment of the environmental impacts of
this activity is carried out at the level of authorization. Nutrient-neutral
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 54
aquaculture should be favoured, i.e. the proposed activity should not
lead to the deterioration of the marine environment.
5. Measures that directly affect the availability of nutrients to the water
column are appropriate to mitigate the local effects of the fish farm.
These may include algae and shellfish farming near fish cages,
technological techniques to prevent nutrient leaching from the fish cage
(for example, collecting feed residues and feces in or in the immediate
vicinity of the cage) as well as chemical bonding or more efficient
dilution of fish farming nutrients. Further measures to minimize the
impact must be foreseen in the licensing process.
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. Understanding the magnitude of the effects of all processes and
measures is important to smoothing out large-scale processes in fish
farms. Larger basins must take into account the transport of nutrients
and water between basins, the metabolism between the water column and
the seabed. A more detailed national analysis is needed because without
adequate assessment of water exchange and nutrient flows between
different parts of the sea, adequate regional measures (e.g., by coastal
bodies of water) cannot be proposed, which in turn can lead to inefficient
use of resources and unreasonable fish farming costs .
4.2 HABITATS AND BIOTA
4.2.1 Fish
Due to the low and variable salinity in the Baltic Sea, spreading of fish of both
marine and freshwater origin is prevented, and therefore the number of species
is lower than in the sea with normal salinity. At the same time, the fish
populations of the Baltic Sea are numerous, which is characterized by the fact
that about 1% of the total catch of the world's sea is caught here. One of the
main assets of the Baltic Sea is its fish stock.
There are about 30 species of marine fish in Estonian waters, 10 spec ies of
migratory fish, and about 20 species of freshwater fish in the coastal sea. These
three groups may be further subdivided into different groups according to
origin, systematics, the importance of fisheries and nature conservation,
reproductive biology, etc. However, species still have very different
preferences for habitats and spawning grounds: while some species require
deeper areas of the Baltic Sea for spawning, depending on their oxygen and
salinity conditions, other species depend on free passag e for freshwater spawns
or spawn at different depths at the coastal area, due to different preferences in
terms of temperature, salinity, substrate, etc.
Many fish species in the Baltic Sea live under stress due to the local salinity
and temperature, which makes them more sensitive to environmental changes.
And as elsewhere in the world and in the Baltic Sea, Estonian fish fauna is
mainly affected by human activity, which has resulted in a decrease in both
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 55
species richness and the abundance of most fish species. In addition to fishing,
there are other human activities that affect fish abundance in the Baltic Sea,
such as migration barriers on rivers flowing into the Baltic Sea and river
pollution, which are a limiting factor for many fish species in the Balt ic Sea.
Anoxia in the deeper areas of the Baltic Sea is primarily affected by nutrient
inflows resulting from land use, and the proportion of the pollution load
resulting from the use of marine is still low. However, it is an important
problem for fish spawning in the deeper areas of the Baltic Sea, such as cod
and flounder, so it is important that marine area use does not increase the
concentration of biogenes.
The vast majority of the indicators of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive
for fish in the state of the Estonian marine environment in 2018 35 did not meet
the level of good environmental status, which was mainly due to overfishing,
but also the situation of spawning grounds for salmon and flounder. There are
also species endangered and the ones with limited spread in our waters, such as
whitefish, whose scarce extinct local populations could be fatally affected by
even the smallest damage to the spawning grounds.
In general, shallow coastal waters (less than 15 m) and offshore shoals are mor e
important for fish than sea areas. Most spawning grounds and juvenile fish
breeding sites are located in the shallower coastal areas (up to 5 m), or they are
crossed by species heading for spawning in freshwater (check Figure 4.2.1-3 to
4.2.1-6). More open sea areas with depths> 5 m may be spawning grounds for
Baltic herring (check Figure 4.2.1-1) and Baltic flounder (Figure 4.2.1- 2). The
deepest areas of the Estonian EEZ are generally unsuitable for spawning
because they lack the conditions - the required salinity and oxygen regimes -
necessary for spawning sea fish (cod, flounder, sprat (check Figure 4.2.1-6 to
4.2.1-8). For several fish species, information has been gathered from the
researchers in the Baltic Sea region within the HELCOM PanBalti cScope
project based on available data who have mapped the key habitats and spawning
grounds for more important fish species by using models 36 that take into account
species-specific criteria for different fish species, such as salinity, depth,
exposure to waves, extent of the photic zone, water transparency, etc. (see
figures below). These are modelled map layers that indicate potential spawning
grounds based on previous research and knowledge that there are natural
conditions for spawning in these areas.
35
Estonian Maritime Institute, University of Tartu. " The state of the Estonian marine
environment 2018". Report, 2018. https://www.envir.ee/sites/de-
fault/files/mere_seisund_2018.pdf
36
The maps prepared based on the models have been validated by experts of the relevant
species and countries.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 56
Figure 4.2.1-1. Potential spawning grounds for herring (source: Pan Baltic
Scope)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 57
Figure 4.2.1-2. Potential spawning grounds for Baltic flounder (source: Pan
Baltic Scope)
Figure 4.2.1-3. Potential spawning grounds for perch (source: Pan Baltic
Scope)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 58
Figure 4.2.1-4. Potential spawning grounds for pikeperch (source: Pan Baltic
Scope)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 59
Figure 4.2.1-5. Potential spawning grounds for flounder (source: Pan Baltic
Scope)
Figure 4.2.1-6. Potential spawning grounds for sprat (source: Pan Baltic Scope)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 60
Figure 4.2.1-7. Potential spawning grounds for cod (source: Pan Baltic Scope)
Figure 4.2.1-8. Potential spawning grounds for European flounder (source: Pan
Baltic Scope)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 61
Impact of the MSP
As fish are distributed throughout the marine area, most marine activities
interact with fish and fisheries. Many traditional uses of the marine area have,
over the years, achieved a balance and it has been established by law how the
use of the marine area is permitted (including minimal or no damage to the fish)
whereas, in case of a threat, procedure monitoring and surveillance have been
provided. Such uses of the marine area include maritime transport with the
construction and dredging of ports, dumping, and selection of new dumping
areas, use of deposits, and other marine area use with a long tradit ion. These
uses will not increase significantly according to the Maritime Spatial Plan, and
therefore the implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan will not lead to
greater and uncontrolled impact on the fisheries. The most important aspect of
these activities is to ensure that, when altering the seabed, the potential fish
spawning areas are taken into account.
Another important aspect that needs to be considered is the suspended matter
and its spread, which can kill the offspring of fish even when settli ng on the
spawn and larvae further away from the marine area being manipulated.
Therefore, in addition to the immediate spawning grounds, the distribution of
suspended matter must be taken into account when altering the seabed. No
environmental license is generally granted for the use of marine areas that
release significant suspended matter into the water column during the fish
spawning period.
According to the Maritime Spatial Plan, areas suitable for the development of
wind energy are envisaged to be somewhat offshore and in deeper areas of the
sea. Large-scale fish farming is also conditionally directed to deeper sea areas.
Given that the majority of fish spawning grounds and juvenile fish feeding
grounds are located in the shallow waters, and coastal areas (up to 5 m in depth)
or they are passed through by species heading for spawning in freshwater,
conservation of these areas is essential for the sake of maintaining and
reproduction of the good status of fish stocks, and this Impact Assessment
Report, therefore, recommends that offshore fish farms be established in the
marine areas with the depths of at least 5 m (check Figure 4.2.1-9).
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 62
Figure 4.2.1-9. Sensitive areas for fish (potential spawning grounds important
for young marine fish)
Based on the knowledge of the depth preferences of the spawning grounds of
commercially important fish species (Baltic flounder up to ~ 30 m, herring ~
15 m), salinity data and some other spawning ground criteria, the potential
spawning grounds of the Baltic flounder modelled within the Pan Baltic Scope
project (Figure 4.2.1-1 and 4.2.1 -2) and to some extent also herring spawning
grounds overlap with the energy production areas and deeper sea areas suitable
for fish farming in the draft plan.
The potential spawning grounds overlapping with wind energy development
areas need to be further investigated at the authorization level to determine the
extent to which these or some other species actually spawn in the areas
concerned or the importance of the spawning grounds within the proposed area.
To this end, the maritime spatial plan stipulates that when planning the new
activities in the maritime area, it should be ensured during the authorization
procedure that there will be no significant adverse effects on the fish spawning
grounds.
For some new and intensifying uses of the marine space, such as energy
production, aquaculture, and recreational industries, there is little experience
of environmental impact assessment and ex-post evaluation. Experiences from
other marine areas are helpful, although there are few analogs in the Baltic Sea,
especially those with a long history.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 63
In 2020 M. Rohtla has completed a review and analysis of the literature entitled
“Possible impacts of offshore wind farms planned in Estonia on fish in the
Baltic Sea” 37, by using the reports and research articles describing the results
of research conducted primarily in the North Sea as well as elsewhere as the
sources of literature. The following assessment of the impact of wind farms on
fish is largely based on the assessments and conclusions provided in M. Rohtla's
report.
The impacts related to the construction of offshore wind farms are divided into
the impacts of construction, operation and dismantling. The operational and
physical impacts are related to the location of the wind farm and submarine
cable. However, the operational noise of the wind turbines and the
electromagnetic fields of the submarine cables during the operation phase of
the wind turbines also have an impact on the fish. According to current
knowledge the biggest potential negative impacts of the planned offshore wind
farms on the Estonian coastal sea are probably the activities during construction
and dismantling works.
The construction work may be accompanied by construction noise and
unfavourable effects on the fish due to the suspended matter generated during
earthworks. Although construction and dismantling works are relatively short -
term in nature, these activities involve significant environmental d isturbances
other than increased noise levels (e.g. due to increased ship traffic), such as the
installation of gravity-based foundations and the burial of electrical cables on
the seabed will re-float sediments from the seabed, which could lead to the
death of fish in their early stages of development. Thus, it has been found that
such work should be carried out during the period there is no reproduction of
fish and juveniles are able to leave the area (e.g. in mid-summer) 38.
The impact of construction noise associated with the construction, operation
and dismantling phase of offshore wind farms is the most extensive, but in case
of the planned offshore wind farms in Estonia it is not so acute due to the
planned use of gravity-based foundations that do not require the drilling or
ramming of the seabed of the tower. The operating noise of wind turbines is
more or less constant, but (depending on the strength of the wind) it is still
relatively quiet compared to, for example, ship noise. In general, scientists are
currently of the opinion that the operating noise of wind turbines can only
disturb fish in the immediate vicinity of wind turbines and that there are no
significant negative effects. The results of the recently published noise impact
modelling have also indicated that the construction and operating noise from
37
Potential impacts of offshore wind farms planned for Estonia on fish in the Baltic Sea
(University of Tartu, 2020)
https://www.kalateave.ee/images/pdf/Uuringud/Eestisse_planeeritavate_avamere_tuuleparki
de_v%C3%B5imalikud_m%C3%B5jud_L%C3%A4%C3%A4nemere_kaladele.pdf
38
Sama, mis eelmine
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 64
the offshore wind farms does not have a significant impact on the Norwegian
fish and mammal populations (Wang, W (2019) 39.
Depending on the type of fish and the intensity of the noise, the fish will
definitely hear the operating noise of the wind turbines from different distances.
According to the current knowledge sprat and especially herring from amongst
the ones in the Baltic Sea are likely to be the most vulnerable to the potential
negative effects of offshore wind farms. In other words, these species could
potentially be most affected by the operating noise of wind turbines. These
species have the best hearing out of the important commercial fish in the Baltic
Sea and are likely to sense the wind turbine operating noise even from tens of
kilometres away. The sea areas suitable for offshore wind farms overlap in part
with the herring spawning grounds (see Figure 4.2.1-1), which may deter
herring spawning groups from such spawning grounds due to the proximity of
the noise source.
As herring is concentrated in large shoals during spawning, the noise from the
wind turbines during spawning can interfere with the mutual communication
and shoaling of the fish. However, no studies have yet proven that the herring
spawning groups are somehow disturbed by the noise from offshore wind farms
(no specific studies have been conducted) 40. The fish monitoring at Utgrunden
wind farm off the Swedish coast caught herrings with flowing roe near the wind
turbines 41. Due to the precautionary principle, when planning the wind farms at
the authorization level, more detailed studies should be carried out at the
authorization level on spawning grounds of potential fish (especially herring)
found in the area of the wind farm and within its outreach and on possible
blockage of access to the spawning grounds (e.g. studies describing the impact
of wind turbine noise on fish migration, including the spawning grounds
important for the mass migration of commercially important fish) and, if
necessary, provide for the necessary mitigation measures at the level of the
authorization (ensuring fish migration in the wind energy development areas,
noise reduction measures, etc.).
The re-suspended sediments and their impacts occur only during the
construction phase of the wind farms (installation of gravity-based foundations
in the wind farms planned for Estonia and burial of electric cables on the
seabed) and thus their impact is relatively short -term and avoidable, for
39
Wang, W. (2019). Significance of offshore wind farm sound on marine populations.
Master’s thesis. Norwegian University of Science and Technology. 95 pp. (Thesis referred
by M.Rohtla)
40
Potential impacts of offshore wind farms planned for Estonia on fish in the Baltic Sea
(University of Tartu, 2020)
https://www.kalateave.ee/images/pdf/Uuringud/Eestisse_planeeritavate_avamere_tuuleparki
de_v%C3%B5imalikud_m%C3%B5jud_L%C3%A4%C3%A4nemere_kaladele.pdf
41
Bergström, L., Kautsky, L., Malm, T., Ohlsson, H., Wahlberg, M., Rosenberg, R., Åstrand
Capetillo, N. (2012). The effects of wind power on marine life. A Synthesis. Report 6512.
https://www.su.se/polopoly_fs/1.120458.1358860002!/menu/standard/file/Effects%20of%20
wind%20power%20on%20marine%20life.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 65
example, when carrying out construction work beyond spawning period and
using devices to warn/repel fish 42.
Given that, to the best of our knowledge, flounder is one of the most hearing -
impaired groups of fish and, moreover, relatively tolerant of the effects of re -
suspended sediments, it can be here assumed that operating noise and re-
suspended sediments are unlikely to affect the sustainability of the local
flounder population 43.
Offshore wind farms may be accompanied by electromagnetic fields in their
operational phases, which may affect both marine mammals and fish.
Submarine cables can be AC or DC cables. The fish species that use the Earth's
magnetic field for orientation and navigation may be affected to some extent
by artificial electromagnetic fields caused by AC electrical cables for offshore
wind farms and the like. It is known that the strength of artificial
electromagnetic fields transmitted from submarine cables to the environment
decreases abruptly when moving away from the cable, and therefore it is
possible that significant biological effects will only occur if the fish are in the
immediate vicinity of the cable.
Even if several studies have indicated that many fish perceive electric and/or
magnetic fields, there is still very little evidence that fish are adversely affected
by the electromagnetic fields generated by submarine cables 44, 45, 46. Today,
submarine cables are predominantly powered by direct current cables ( HVDC,
short for high-voltage direct current), which have indicated that the Earth's own
magnetic field is many times larger than that of an electric cable 47. In case of
maritime spatial plans of other countries, such as Germany and Denmark, the
electromagnetic effects associated with the construction of electric cables have
also been considered insignificant.
The DC cable should be preferred when building the wind farms, as this will
only create a magnetic field around the cable that will not have a significant
42
Potential impacts of offshore wind farms planned for Estonia on fish in the Baltic Sea
(University of Tartu, 2020
https://www.kalateave.ee/images/pdf/Uuringud/Eestisse_planeeritavate_avamere_tuuleparki
de_v%C3%B5imalikud_m%C3%B5jud_L%C3%A4%C3%A4nemere_kaladele.pdf
43
The same as previous
44
Gill, A. B., Bartlett, M., Thomsen, F. (2012). Potential interactions between diadromous
fishes of U.K. conservation importance and the electromagnetic fields and subsea noise
from marine renewable energy developments. Journal of Fish Biology 81: 664-695.
45
Westerberg, H., Lagenfelt, I. (2008). Sub-sea power cables and the migration behaviour
of the European eel. Fisheries Management and Ecology 15: 369-375.
46
Öhman, M. C., Sigray, P. and Westerberg, H. (2007). Offshore Windmills and the Effects
of Electromagnetic Fields on Fish. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment 36: 630-
633.
47
SEA of the Danish Maritime Spatial Plan
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/KKO/KMH/taani_mereala_planeerimise_ksh_dokum
ent.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 66
adverse effect. In case of AC cables it is recommended that the measures
reducing the potential adverse effects of the cables should be applied. Where
possible, the burial of cables on the seabed or careful shielding should be
considered. The mitigation measures in the construction and installation of the
cable are also necessary, as the cumulative effects of different power cables in
the Baltic Sea could become a problem in the future.
However, the effects of electromagnetic fields generated by submarine cables
can be further reduced and even eliminated in the future due to technical
progress and continuous improvement of cable shielding (e.g. it is theoretically
already now possible to build submarine cables that do not emit electromagnetic
fields to the environment, i.e. zero-emission submarine cables) 48. More detailed
cabling measures to minimize impacts need to be provided in the authorization
process. Whenever possible, the best available technology should be used for
the construction of the wind farms.
In certain situations the construction of wind farms may also have a positive
effect on the number of fish, as the foundations of the wind turbines and towers
(including substations) add a hard substrate to the seabed, which often have a
local effect of concentrating and/or increasing the production of fish 49.
The production of energy affects spawning grounds with the spread of noise
and suspended matter during the construction phase, which can be avoided by
shifting the construction phase beyond the spawning time, while the impacts of
the fish farm are longer lasting.
In fish farms, fish are close together with each other, which is why fish dis eases
and parasites, which are transmitted and can infect fish freely living on nature,
spread there. Antibiotics, drug residues, and disinfectants used in fish farms
can affect the natural ecosystem. The selection of farmed fish depends on
whether the (alien) species that come out of the farm can live independently
and establish free-living populations or alter the genetic structure of wild
populations. In order to avoid this impact or to disseminate a significant impact,
the risks associated with biosecurity must be assessed at the licensing level,
both at the individual project level and in conjunction with the activities of the
area in the near vicinity (e.g., assessing and determining the distances of fish
farms of different companies to avoid biosecurity risks). We also recommend
that a buffer be included in the area applied for the establishment of fish farms
(e.g. when applying for an authorization) to establish the possible nearby fish
farm for ensuring biosecurity.
Energy production and aquaculture will certainly have indirect impacts,
including positive ones. For example, changes in the environmental balance
48
Potential impacts of offshore wind farms planned for Esto nia on fish in the Baltic Sea
(University of Tartu, 2020)
https://www.kalateave.ee/images/pdf/Uuringud/Eestisse_planeeritavate_avamere_tuuleparki
de_v%C3%B5imalikud_m%C3%B5jud_L%C3%A4%C3%A4nemere_kaladele.pdf
49
The same as previous
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 67
(wind turbine foundations and bases, cages, algae, and shellfish farming
infrastructure, fish feed released into the marine environ ment and feces of
farmed species) will also alter the species balance of the area. The changing
environment will attract and favor some species, while the abundance of other
species may decline. At the same time, shellfish and algae farming has certainly
a positive impact on the fish on a large scale, as it helps to reduce the problems
of over-nutrition in the Baltic Sea. Therefore, shellfish farming, and algae
farming can be used as a mitigation measure to capture phosphorus and nitrogen
from fish farms (see also Chapter 4.1.5 Water quality) and therefore the
planning solution should encourage multitrophic aquaculture.
Energy production in the sea area also has a potential impact on fish fauna
through connecting cables, which during the construction phase, when being
embedded into the seabed, affect spawning areas, similarly to other seabed
alteration activities. In addition, during their operation, and depending on their
physical characteristics, cables have a potential negative impact on fish
migration, especially in shallower areas. Electric cables have been shown to
slow fish migration somewhat, but this impact can be minimized by shielding
the cables. More specific cable laying measures to minimize impact must be
foreseen in the licensing process.
Special national defence areas are predominantly located in the Gulf of Finland.
The use of ammunition and explosives may have a direct impact on fish in the
area. National defence activities (munitions blasting, mine clearance) can
directly kill or damage fish or scare them away from the area (spawning
grounds). Ammunition and hazardous substances can also enter the marine
environment. However, the threat to fish stocks is rather theoretical and, even
then, short-term. Major blasting in the water should be planned so that it does
not occur in a fish spawning season and in an area where a large amount of fish
has accumulated in the restricted area. As a mitigation measure, fish can be
pushed out of the area with smaller charges before using larger explosive
charges. It is advisable to draw up a protection management plan for the
national defense sites, which will map the environmental risks of the activities
to the marine biota and measures to prevent or reduce them .
The protected part of the Estonian marine area includes predominantly coastal
and shallow water areas. The larger protected marine areas designated as the
marine areas determined as Natura 2000 networks cover a large part of the
coastal waters of Western Estonia and its islands, including, for exa mple, the
whole Väinameri Sea and extensive areas around the Sõrve peninsula in
Saaremaa. In the coastal waters of the Gulf of Finland, the Natura special
protection areas are less extensive and include areas such as Osmussaar, Pakri
islands and Kolga Bay, and the marine area of Lahemaa National Park. If, as a
rule, a protected marine area has a positive impact on fish, the restrictions may
also have negative impacts. For example, protected areas have seen an
explosion of the abundance of cormorants. The amount of critically endangered
eels consumed by cormorants (the main causes of the critical state of the
population are fishing and the impact of environmental changes ( e.g. Rohtla et
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 68
al 2021 50)) is estimated to be in the same size class as the ones caught by people
in the Baltic Sea 51.
The implementation of the maritime spatial plan is not expected to result in the
significant adverse effects on any species of fish based on the available
information, by applying the following foreseen environmental measures at the
level of authorization.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. Given that the majority of fish spawning grounds and juvenile fish
feeding grounds are located in the shallow waters and coastal areas or
they are passed through by species heading for spawning in freshwater,
conservation of these areas is essential for the sake of maintaining and
reproduction of the good status of fish stocks, therefore this Impact
Assessment Report recommends that fish farms to be established in
the marine areas with the depths of at least 5 m.
2. During the implementation of the activities proposed in the Maritime
Spatial Plan (in particular wind energy development and aquaculture), it
is necessary to specify the impact within the licensing process and,
where appropriate, to implement mitigation measures for fish .
3. Energy production affects the spawning grounds with the spread of noise
and suspended matter rather during the construction and dismantling
phase, which can be avoided by shifting the construction and dismantling
phase beyond spawning time.
4. Due to the precautionary principle the design of wind farms at the
authorization level should be subject to more detailed studies on the
potential fish spawning grounds and blocking of access to spawning
grounds in the wind farm area and within its outreach (e.g. studies
describing the impact of wind turbine noise on fish migration, including
spawning grounds important for the mass migration of commercially
important fish 52) and if necessary, provide for mitigation measures
(ensuring fish migration in the wind energy development areas, noise
reduction measures, etc.). In order to mitigate the effects during
construction, the condition should be set that noisy activities (e.g. laying
50Mehis Rohtla, Maidu Silm, Jouni Tulonen, Päärn Paiste, Håkan Wickström, Melanie
Kielman-Schmitt, Ellen Kooijman, Väino Vaino, Redik Eschbaum, Lauri Saks, Aare Verliin,
Markus Vetemaa, Conservation restocking of the imperilled European eel does not necessar ily
equal conservation, ICES Journal of Marine Science, Volume 78, Issue 1, January -February
2021, Pages 101–111, https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsaa196
51 Hansson S., Bergström U., Bonsdorff E., Härk önen T., Jepsen N., Kautsky L., Lundström
K. 2018. Competition for the fish – fish extraction from the Baltic Sea by humans, aquatic
mammals, and birds. ICES Journal of Marine Science , 75: 999–1008.
52 If experimental noise studies (or any ohter studies) ar e carried out in the Estonian sea area,
in the course of which it turns out that there is no impact of noise as to certain fish species
on migration, then this result can be proceeded from and further relevant studies can be
waived. If a noise study reveals that noise is an obstacle to fish migration, further detailed
studies are required to map fish migration corridors.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 69
wind turbine foundations) do not take place during the spawning season
and in an area where a large number of fish have accumulated in the
restricted area.
5. More specific cabling measures to minimize the impacts should be
provided for in the authorization process, if needed. Whenever possible,
the best available technology should be used for the construction of wind
farms. The DC cable should be preferred, as this will only create a
magnetic field around the cable that will not have an adverse effect. In
case of AC cables, burial, careful shielding or other mitigation measures
should be considered.
6. For both proposed new activities and existing activities in the marine
area, the most important thing to do is to ensure that any spawning areas
of the fish are taken into account when altering the seabed .
7. The potential biosecurity risks associated with aquaculture must be
assessed in the licensing process, both at the individual project level and
in conjunction with the activities of a near vicinity fish farm (e.g., to
assess and determine the distance between farms of different companie s
to avoid biosecurity risks). We also recommend that the area applied for
the establishment of fish farms (e.g. when applying for a superficies
licence) be taken into account in order to ensure the biosecurity of the
buffer by establishing a fish farm in a possible area.
We also recommend that a buffer be included in the area applied for the
establishment of fish farms (e.g. when applying for superficies licence)
to establish the possible nearby fish farm for ensuring biosecurity .
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. Identification of spawning grounds of important fish species in the
Estonian marine area (modeling and research).
2. It is advisable to draw up a protection management plan for the national
defense sites, which will map the environmental risks of the activities to
the marine biota and measures to prevent or reduce them .
3. It is necessary to provide for time constraints areas on the use of
recreational craft in the municipal comprehensive plans which are
bordered by marine areas.
4. Development of the bases for the determination of buffers between
different farms to ensure the biosecurity of fish farms. The extent of the
buffer depends on the specific circumstances (species, depth,
technology).
5. Impact of wind farm noise on herring migration. The aim is to identify
significant (disturbing) noise level for herring.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 70
4.2.2 Birds53,54
More than 60 waterfowl species are associated with the Estonian marine area
during their life cycle. In the Estonian waters, waterfowl stop during different
seasons, for example, for moulting, wintering, and migration. Waterfowl
nesting on the coast and on small islets feed and breed their younglings at sea.
In addition, many terrestrial birds are linked to the sea through migration.
The importance of the Estonian coastal sea to waterfowl is primarily due to its
geographical location, as it remains directly on one important branch of the
East Atlantic migratory route. This branch is used by most Arctic waterfowl
species on their way from Eurasian Arctic breeding grounds to wintering areas
extending to South Africa. The Estonian marine shoals are suitable migration
stops for replenishing the fats for further migration; these shoals are also used
as wintering areas. Despite the relatively small area of our aquatic environment,
a significant proportion of all birds of some species stop here. According to
rough estimates, for example, 48% of the migratory populations of the scaup,
25% of the migratory populations of long-tailed ducks, and 20 - 22% of scoters
can stage in our waters.
Bird protection in Estonian marine areas is mainly based on the so -called Birds
Directive (Council of Europe Directive on the conservation of wild birds,
2009/147/EC), which obliges EU Member States to implement sp ecial measures
to protect regularly occurring migratory species, designating the most suitable
areas, both in number and size, for their protection as bird sanctuaries. To meet
the requirements of the Birds Directive, Estonia established a network of Natur a
Site of Community Importance at the beginning of this century, which includes,
among other things, 26 areas that include marine areas. One of the main reasons
for the inclusion of marine birds into the composition of Site of Community
Importance was the presence of migratory staging areas of international
importance. Important Site of Community Importance for the staging of
offshore species are the Site of Community Importance of Kabli, Kahtla-
Kübassaare, Koorunõmme, Vilsandi, Tagamõisa, Kura Gorge, Küdem a Bay,
Nõva-Osmussaar, Pakri, Pärnu Bay and the Väinameri Sea. Outside the
boundaries of the bird protection areas, important staging areas are located in
national protected areas (Apollo marine shoal nature reserve) and in protected
areas (Hiiu shoal and Gretagrund conservation area). The extension of the
Neugrund Nature Reserve and the Kõpu Nature Reserve is to be mentioned as
protected areas designed as of today. A discussion of Natura 2000 Site of
Community Importance can be found in Chapter 4.3. The Special Protection
Area Network was created at the beginning of this century and reflects the state
of knowledge at the time. The network covers well the area’s most important
53
The chapter is largely based on the basic research of the Maritime spatial Plan “Analysis
of bird staging areas” Estonian Ornithological Society, 2019
54
Whether and how do about 300 m high offshore wind turbines affect bird migration?,
Estonian Ornithological Society, 2021
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 71
for birds in shallow coastal waters, but most of the data on the high seas have
only been collected since the establishment of the network of Site of
Community Importance.
As part of the preparation of the Estonian Maritime spatial Plan, the available
information on the results of the census of birds staging in the high seas and
coastal waters since 2000 was collected for analysis. As a result of the analysis,
the abundance forecasts of staging birds with a resolution of 1 km² were
prepared covering the entire Estonian marine area. In addition, existing
knowledge on the main autumn and spring migration corridors for different bird
groups (land birds, geese, black geese, swans, arctic waterfowl) was gathered.
Based on the importance of the high seas as bird staging areas as well as
migratory corridors, the whole sea was divided into three types of areas (Figure
4.2.2-1):
▪ 'sensitive areas' - according to best available knowledge, the most
important areas of the high seas for birds that stage and/or fly over the
sea. Long-term activities - the construction of high artificial objects
(wind farms, bridges) on the high seas, and activities with significant
spatial impact on the seabed and its biota (e.g., the establishment of new
mines) - in sensitive areas should be avoided;
▪ most suitable areas for wind energy development due to birdlif e - as
wind energy development is one of the major new uses in Maritime
Spatial Plan with a potentially significant impact on birds, the most
suitable wind energy development areas have been identified. These are
areas where, with today's knowledge, the negative impact of wind farms
on birds would be minimal;
▪ remaining unclassified areas - areas outside the previous areas.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 72
Figure 4.2.2-1. Sensitive areas of the Estonian marine area from the point of
view of birds and the most suitable areas for the development of wind energy
(source: “Analysis of bird staging areas” Estonian Ornithological Society,
2019)
Figure 4.2.2-2 shows the sensitive areas for birds, where in addition to the
sensitive areas identified in the marine area (incl the most important migration
directions), migration corridors above the sea area important for terrestrial
birds have been added.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 73
Figure 4.4.2-2. Sensitive areas for birds (source of drawing: “Bird staging area
analysis.” Estonian Ornithological Society, 2019)
Impact of the MSP
The implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan will not bring (significant)
changes to many uses (fisheries; sea transport; search and rescue, pollution
control and border management; seabed infrastructure; marine tourism and
recreation; protected nature; marine culture; cultural monuments; national
defense; dumping, and permanent connections) and for most areas of activity,
the current use and regulation of the marine space will continue through
existing legislation. From the standpoint of birds, it is important to assess the
uses of the marine areas that are likely to have a significant impact on bird
species. Of the marine uses planned by the Maritime Spatial Plan, this is
primarily wind energy alongside proper infrastructure (cables, substations).
The development of wind energy means the construction of massive objects in
the maritime area. The impacts associated with the construction of wind farms
on birds are usually divided into four major categories: habitat loss or
alteration, obstacles on flying and migration routes (barrier effect), collisions
with wind turbines, disruptive and repulsive effects. The disturbing and
repulsive effects are of the utmost importance in case of important staging areas
for waterfowl when the birds are no longer able to use their preferred habitats
or use these significantly less.
It is appropriate for the level of accuracy of the Maritime Spatial Plan to find
suitable locations for the wind energy development areas, and mitigation
through technical solutions, etc., can be applied in the next steps (licensing
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 74
process), if necessary. The Maritime Spatial Plan Solution identifies areas for
development in wind energy, which, among other things, take into
consideration bird-based considerations. To minimize the impact, the wind
energy development areas have been placed outside the existing marine area
bird protection areas (Natura 2000 Special Protection Areas ). In addition, an
analysis of birds was carried out (EOÜ, 2019), which in the light of existi ng
knowledge identified the most important areas of the marine area for stopping
and migrating birds, i.e. the so-called sensitive areas - the areas most important
for waterfowl migration, feeding and staging. The development areas of wind
energy proposed in the Maritime Spatial Plan are largely outside these sensitive
areas. The study also identified the marine areas most suitable for the
development of wind energy, which largely overlaps with the planned wind
energy development areas (Figure 4.4.2-1). On the basis of the information
currently available, the location of the planned wind energy development areas
can be considered successful from the point of birds in case of area 2 and partly
also in case of area 1. The proposed wind energy development area 1 in the
Gulf of Riga will overlap with a migratory corridor for land birds, so the Impact
Assessment Task Group will propose an adjustment to the planning solution as
shown in Figure 4.4.2-4. The proposal was taken into account in the planning
solution and thus the areas suitable for the development of wind energy do not
overlap with the most important migration corridors of terrestrial birds (as of
May 2021). The wind energy development area no. 3 is located partly in the
sensitive area of Hülgerahu, which is especially important as a winter stop for
waterfowl but also as a spring migration area for waterfowl . The wind energy
development area no. 3 (northwest of Saaremaa) has been removed during the
planning process due to, among other things, bird protection reasons.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 75
Figure 4.2.2-3. Location of the initial wind energy development areas (as of
2019) in relation to the areas sensitive to birds
Figure 4.2.2-4. Proposal for the adjustment of the wind energy development
areas 1 and 3 in the maritime spatial planning solution
Thus, the use of the areas suitable for wind energy development in the most
important areas for birds (sensitive areas for waterfowl and migratory
corridors for terrestrial birds) will not lead to habitat destruction or alteration,
obstructions to flying and migration routes (barrier effects), wind collisions
with wind turbines or disruptive and repulsive effects. The wind farms in the
marine area are an obstacle to birds on flying and migratory routes (they will
avoid these by flying around and thus the length of their migration route
increases and the amount of energy consumed during migration increases to
such an extent that they have a negative impact on the population) and pose a
risk of collisions for birds which causes injuries to the birds or, in the worst
case, death 55.
Bird flight altitude and risk of collision. The starting point of the Estonian
maritime spatial plan is about 300 metres high wind turbines. Such wind
turbines are not yet in production and the data on their effects on birds are not
yet available. Based on the studies carried out in parks with lower wind turbines
55
Compilation of the data on the migration corridors of birds in the Estonian sea area and
creation of relevant map layers and preparation of an analysis of the impact of wind farms on
bird feeding areas, Estonian Ornotology Society 2017
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 76
and general knowledge about the flight altitude and behavio ur of birds,
conclusions can be drawn that are also valid for higher wind turbines, including
altitudes up to about 300 metres.
The flight altitudes of birds above the sea exceed one kilomet re and it is
impossible to find the wind turbine dimensions that completely eliminate the
risk of collisions with birds. The general rule is to reduce the flight intensity of
birds according to the increase in altitude. Most seabirds fly in the lower 20 -
metre air layer and only mainly seagulls reach the altitude of the working zone
of wind turbine rotors. The birds of prey and black storks cross sea areas
predominantly in the altitude range threatened by wind turbines. The flight
altitudes of the Passeriformes are distributed over a wide range of altitude.
The flight altitude depends on the species, time (season and night/day), the
reason for the flight (migration or "local flight"), weather, geographical
location (above land, near the beach, above high seas) and the p resence of a
wind farm. The lower the lower limit of the working range of a rotating rotor,
the more dangerous the wind turbines are in terms of collision risk . As the
altitude increases, the number of flying birds usually decreases, and in case of
high-rotating rotors a large proportion of (water) birds fly below the working
area of the rotors. Even if the flight altitudes overlap with the working areas of
the rotors, the risk of collision at the bottom of the working areas is lower than
at the height of the rotor axes.
From the point of view of the risk of collision, wind turbines are all the more
dangerous the larger the total working area of the rotors. In case of a single
wind turbine an increase in the rotor radius is accompanied by an increase in
the area of the rotor working area; at the same time, as the radius of the rotor
increases, the distance between the wind turbines increases and the total number
of wind turbines decreases, which all in all can reduce the sum of the operating
areas of the rotors of the entire wind farm. The Belgian Offshore Wind Farm
Monitoring Report 56 concludes that the turbines with a greater distance between
the sea level and the lower limit of the rotor working zone cause fewer collision
casualties and higher turbine densities lead to greater number of collisions.
As the height of the wind turbines and the working area of the rotor increase,
so does their rated power and the distance between the wind turbines, and all
in all there are fewer of them per unit area. Most species have a lower risk of
death in case of the wind turbines with a high rated power and a large rotor
area, as there are fewer of them per unit area. Therefore, in order to reduce the
negative impact of fatalities, it is recommended to use fewer but larger wind
generators in the proposed wind farms. It is also recommended that the
minimum height of the wind turbine blade be 25 meters above sea level
(provided that it can be specified, increased to 30 or 35 metres if necessary, on
the basis of a study carried out during the authorization procedure ). Height
56 Degraer, S., Brabant, R., Rumes, B., & Vigin, L. (2020). Environmental Impacts of Offshore
Wind Farms in the Belgian Part of the North Sea: Empirical Evidence Inspiring Priority
Monitoring, Research and Management. Brussels.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 77
adjustment is necessary in particular to reduce the risk of collisions with
waterfowl.
In conclusion, most birds use sensitive areas for migration and st aging.
However, the risk of collision cannot be completely ruled out in the areas
suitable for the development of wind energy. The level of collision risk and
possible mitigation measures can be specified after the following on -site
inspections in the authorization stage:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of wind
energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant migration
corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across the sea. There, in
order to specify the width and location of the migration corridor an d to
determine the effects of a specific wind farm, it is necessary to carry out
a radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least two
years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of the area no. 2 suitable for the development of wind energy in
the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify which part of all
migratory terrestrial birds do not use the main migration route, i.e. do
not fly along Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but takes the direction from the west coast of Saaremaa
towards Gotland. This, too, needs to be clarified at the stage of the
authorization procedure with a radar survey of birds covering the
migration periods of at least two years, carried out in parallel with visual
observations.
Barrier effect. The barrier effect is a behavioural reaction of birds to the wind
farm, which increases the flight distance of the birds. The barrier effect is
stronger in case of pochards, divers and razorbills as to waterfowl, but its
negative impact through the extension of the migratory route has mostly been
assessed as marginal. If there are many wind farms on the same migration route,
the cumulative effect may be significant. In case of birds of p rey, the barrier
effect can lead to a significant change in migratory behavio ur and some birds
that have encountered a wind farm during their flight may return to the
mainland. It has been found that the impact of wind farms on birds can be
reduced by leaving a wider corridor for birds in the main wind direction, and
the barrier effect can be reduced by leaving sufficient free sea space between
neighbouring wind farms.
The location of the wind turbines has an impact on how many of the migratory
birds pass through the wind farm and which part avoids it by trying to pass the
wind farm. Considering that the distance between the wind turbines is four to
five times the diameter of the rotor, the distance between the wind turbines in
the planned offshore wind farms in Estonia will be 800–1000 m and even larger
in case of larger wind turbines. In this case the proportion of birds entering the
wind farm is expected to be higher than in most offshore wind farms where
such studies have been carried out. Some more sensitive species groups (divers,
some pochards) will be avoiding the wind farms even at a distance of 1 km
between the wind turbines.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 78
Waterfowl avoid the wind farm less if the distance between the wind turbines
is greater. Due to the lack of data on passeriformes and birds of prey, it is
difficult to make generalizations. The larger the number of birds entering the
wind farm, the smaller the barrier effect. At the same time the risk of death
increases. Birds prefer to fly in these areas of the wind farm where
neighbouring wind turbines are further apart. If the wind turbines are arranged
in rows and the distance between the wind turbines is greater than the distance
between neighbouring winds of the same row, birds prefer to fly in the corridors
between the rows. Based on previous research, it has been found that the best
way to reduce the movement barrier of birds and also the risk of collisions is
to place wind turbines in clusters and to leave windmill-free corridors on the
high seas in the large wind energy development areas that enable the birds to
easier pass the wind farms.
The width of an efficient corridor could be at least 5 kilomet res, but it has been
indicated within wind farms that the birds also make more use of the areas
where individual wind turbines (or part of a wind turbine) have not been built,
meaning that any corridor wider than normal wind turbine distance is assumed
to more or less coincide with the predominant direction of flight, mitigation of
the barrier effect at least in case of waterfowl:
▪ The wind energy innovation area in the EEZ has a small area and there
is no need for internal corridors.
▪ The area no. 1 suitable for the development of wind energy in the Gulf
of Riga is favourably located in relation to the predominant migratory
destination of birds (SW-NE) and does not represent a significant
obstacle to migration. The main migration route runs between Saaremaa
and the area suitable for wind energy production, where the easte rn part
of the development area has already been adjusted during the impact
assessment, by removing the part of the terrestrial bird migration route
(13% of the area).
Therefore, there is no need for SW-NE corridor within the development
area. At the authorization stage the preliminary study should specify the
actual width of the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern
part of the development area in Kihnu-Ruhnu direction (to determine
whether the available free area is sufficient) and to clarify other
information necessary to assess the risk of collision (species flight
intensity and flight altitudes). A corridor for water traffic has been
planned in the direction of the southern coast of Saaremaa-Ruhnu, which
should ensure the most direct crossing possible for Roomassaare-Ringsu
shipping line. The water traffic corridor is sufficient to facilitate the
journey of birds flying in the direction of the southern coast of Saaremaa
- Ruhnu.
▪ The area no. 2 in the west of Saaremaa, which is suitable for the
development of wind energy, has a large area and would need to leave a
free flight corridor for birds in order to reduce the barrier effect of birds.
Therefore, a radar survey of birds covering migration periods of at least
two years should be carried out in the area during the authorization
phase, in parallel with visual observations, in order to identify the main
migratory patterns of birds. Given the principle of combined use set out
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 79
in the maritime spatial plan, the planning of the waterway area fo r
vessels (currently in the direction of NNW-SSE) should, where possible,
be designed to better coincide with the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the area as
a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway required for
shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m for area 2.
In sensitive areas, long-term (or irreversible) offshore activities should be
avoided, in particular the construction of high-rise objects (wind farms,
bridges) and major alterations to the seabed (e.g., the establishment of new
mines).
Further wind energy development within and outside the designated areas,
irrespective of the location of the sensitive area, is required. The main purpose
of the studies is to clarify the suitability of the proposed wind farm from bird
protection perspective. In addition, the studies allow specifying possible
conditions and mitigation measures for carrying out the activities. The studies
should include a census of staging waterfowl in all seasons, in addition to visual
and radar surveys of migratory birds in the case of migratory corridor areas.
The preferred method for counting staging waterfowl could be ship counting,
except for areas that are very shallow or very far from the home ports of the
ships. The exact research methodology will be developed as part of project
development.
Maritime Spatial Plan also identifies prospective cable corridor locations to
connect wind farms to land. The impact of laying submarine cables occurs
primarily during construction and are local in nature. The disadvantageous
impacts of cable laying can be reduced by the appropriate technical solution
and site selection at the project solution level as well as by the selection of the
timing of the works.
In the light of current knowledge, the MSP solution in terms of wind energy
priority areas 1, 2 and the spatial location of the innovation area takes into
account the important staging areas and main migration corridors of the birds,
and the application of the following environmental measures will not have a
significant adverse effect with the MSP solution.
The wind farm areas can have a disruptive and deterrent effect on more
sensitive bird species. The areas suitable for the development of wind energy,
which are known to be of minor importance as staging areas for birds but which
are used to some extent by different bird species, may have local habitat
destruction or alteration and disturbing and repulsive effects. Although
migration over the high seas has not been explained in any field study in
Estonia, it should be considered probable that there is an obstacle on the
migration route (barrier effect).
The collisions with wind turbines cannot be ruled out for any wind farm, so the
significance of the local level impact of each planned wind farm and the
mitigation measures to be implemented should be identified in the authorization
procedure. The main way to minimize these local impacts is to locate the wind
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 80
farms to the place where the impact on birds would be minimal. In addition,
when developing a specific wind farm, it is possible to apply the technical
solutions that minimize the impact, such as the location, size, number of wind
turbines, the height of the wind blades above sea level, etc.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. Proposal for adjustment of the planning solution according to Figure
4.2.2-4.
2. It is recommended to use modern large wind turbines (the starting point
of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the height of the
wind turbines increases, the number of wind turbines (per area)
decreases and the risk of collision (death) for most bird species
decreases.
3. To stipulate as the condition of planning that the minimum permissible
height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 met res, provided
that it can be specified (increased to 30 or 35 met res, if necessary) on
the basis of the study carried out during the authorization procedure.
4. The eastern part of the area no 1 suitable for the development of wind
energy in the Gulf of Riga is located close to a significant migratory
corridor of terrestrial birds (including birds of prey) across the sea. At
the authorization stage the actual width of the migratory flow of
terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the development area in the
direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify whether the existing free area is
sufficient) and other necessary matters for collision risk assessment
(species flight intensity and altitudes) should be specified. To this end,
it is necessary to carry out a radar survey of birds covering the migration
periods of at least two years in parallel with visual observations (the
methodology should generally follow the survey protocol established in
Germany as a standard (BSH, 2013)).
5. In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of wind energy in the
west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the authorization stage
which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do not use the main migration
route, this means not going along Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there
across the sea to Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast
of Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs to be
clarified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of birds covering at
least two years of migration, carried out in parallel with visual
observations (the methodology should generally follow the survey
protocol established in Germany as a standard (BSH, 2013)).
6. In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime spatial
plan, the vessel traffic area (currently in the direction NNW-SSE) should
be specified at the level of authorization, where possible, to better match
the expected predominant migratory direction of birds (NNE -SSW).
Birds will then be able to use the area as a migration corridor, as the
width of the passageway required for shipping is calculated to be
approximately 6250 m for area 2.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 81
7. The impact of short-term activities (such as disturbance resulting of
offshore activities or reduced water transparency) can be reduced by
choosing the time of the activities.
8. The disadvantageous effects of cable laying can be reduced by the
appropriate technical solution and site selection at the project solution
level as well as by the selection of the timing of the works .
4.2.3 Seals57
Two seal species are common among marine mammals in Estonia - gray seal
(Halichoerus grypus) and ringed seal (Pusa hispida).
Ringed seal is a species with occasional distribution in the Baltic Sea, with
subpopulations comprising the coasts of Estonia on the Väinameri Sea/Livonian
Gulf and the Gulf of Finland. Animals move between different subpopulations
rarely, and rather at the level of individual specimens. The key habitats for
ringed seals in Estonia are the Väinameri Sea and the Gulf of Riga - these areas
are associated with seal wintering and reproduction areas (Figure 4.2.3 -1).
During the ice-free period, the main animal resting areas are in the Väinameri
Sea and in the southern estuaries of the Väike and Suur Strait (Figure 4.2.3 -2).
There is regular migration between these areas, in particular south of the Suur
Strait, where a migration corridor of vital importance has developed (Figure
4.2.3-3). In addition, the existence of sea ice, whose types, extent and location
vary from year to year, is indispensable for the successful reproduction of
animals.
The resting areas, mainly in the Väinameri Sea and the southern estuaries of
the Väike and Suur Strait, are of great importance throughout the year. The
islets of Hiiumaa are abandoned when the sea freezes, but they are used from
ice to ice, and in warm winters this use can be practically year -round. Nutrition
areas are of great seasonal importance from May to November. The migratory
areas are associated with a period of intensive feeding and the main migratory
route is important from May to November.
57
The chapter is largely based on the basic research of the Maritime Spatial Plan “Estonian
Maritime Spatial Plan: Assessment of the spread of seals and use of sea”. Report of applied
study, contract no. 1.9-1 / 404-1. I., Jüssi; M., Jüssi, 2019.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 82
Figure 4.2.3-1. Sensitive areas for ringed seals, and ringed seal wintering and
breeding areas (darker areas are more intensively used). Source: Assessment of
the distribution and marine use of seals”. Report on Applied Research Contract
No. 1.9-1/404-1. I., Jüssi; M., Jüssi, 2019.
Figure 4.2.3-2. Sensitive areas for ringed seal, ringed seal feeding areas (darker
areas are more intensively used). Source: Assessment of the distribution and
marine use of seals”. Report on Applied Research Contract No. 1.9 -1/404-1. I.,
Jüssi; M., Jüssi, 2019.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 83
Figure 4.2.3-3. Sensitive areas for ringed seal, ringed seal wintering and
breeding areas (darker areas are more intensively used). Source: Assessment of
the distribution and marine use of seals”. Report on Applied Research Contract
No. 1.9-1/404-1. I., Jüssi; M., Jüssi, 2019.
Gray seals are freely mobile throughout the Baltic Sea (Figure 4.2.3-2), but are
associated with specific rookery areas and marine areas during the ice -free
period and over the years. The animals are prevalent in the central part of the
Baltic Sea at the coast of Sweden, Finland and Estonia. This species freely uses
the coastal waters of entire Estonia. The most important rest areas are
predominantly covered by the existing protection regime (permanent habitats
for gray seals). The Gray seal is a highly adaptable species that is often
accustomed to human activities.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 84
Figure 4.2.3-4. Distribution pattern of gray seal in the Baltic Sea based on
telemetry data from HELCOM (source: HELCOM 2015)
While the good environmental status of the gray seal population of the Baltic
Sea in the Estonian marine area has been achieved by assessing its abundance,
distribution area and distribution pattern, the good environmental status of the
ringed seal has not been achieved 58.
Among the most important anthropogenic factors affecting seals and the well-
being of their populations are sensitivity to environmental pollution, mortality
in fishing nets (by-catch), and disturbance in breeding grounds. For ringed
seals, the impacts of climate change on breeding su ccess are also particularly
important. In winter, when suitable ice is not formed or does not persist, the
species cannot successfully breed. Particularly in the case of the ringed seal, as
58
“Environmental status of Estonian marine area 2018 ”, Ministry of the Environment 2018
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/mere_seisund_2018.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 85
a more endangered and sensitive species, it is important to avoid the additional
impacts of anthropogenic factors.
Impact of the MSP
The implementation of Maritime Spatial Plan will not lead to (significant)
changes in many uses of the marine area and in terms of most of the areas of
activity, the current use of marine area and the regulation will continue through
existing legislation. The uses of the marine area addressed in Maritime Spatial
Plan do not contradict the established patterns of marine use of ringed seals and
gray seals. The key habitats are covered by various nature conservation
measures in the plan. For example, the Väinameri Sea region is an existing
protected area, which the plan does not direct to use differently from the current
use, and the implementation of the plan will not bring any changes to the ringed
seal (or gray seal) population there.
Maritime spatial Planning identifies areas suitable for the development of wind
energy, which are predominantly outside marine areas of importance to seals.
The Gulf of Riga wind energy development area partially overlaps with the
areas used by ringed seals. At the same time, marine mammal experts see no
conflict between wind energy development and the use of the marine area by
the ringed seal in the Gulf of Riga. The areas suitable for the development of
wind energy that overlap with historically more intensive trawling areas will
be designated as reserve areas (the reserve areas can be used from 2027),
including the central part of the planned development area no. 1 for the Gulf of
Riga, which provides wider movement corridors for seals (telemetry refers to
the ability of ringed seals to travel long distances on the high seas, e.g. to the
mouth of the Great Strait or in case of gray seals from Irbe Strait to Allirahu in
an almost straight line). While the choice of location for wind energy uses can
be considered successful in the level of precision of the maritime spatial plan,
it is necessary to pay attention to the environmental aspects related to marine
mammals and consider the need for more detailed research at the authorization
level of each project.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 86
Figure 4.2.3-5. Ringed seal migration areas and proposed wind energy
development areas. Source: “Assessment of spread of seal and marine use”.
Report of applied study, contract no. 1.9-1 / 404-1. I., Jüssi; M., Jüssi, 2019;
aggregate map Hendrikson & Ko
The impact of wind farms on marine mammals is manifested primarily during
the construction phase, and the significance of this impact depends on the
technical solution used. For example, the manner in which wind turbines are
secured will depend on the intensity of the underwater noise involved and the
amount of volatile float that may adversely affect the migration and living
conditions of seals in the wind farm during the construction period .
In terms of impact during operation, for example, the disruptive impacts of ship
traffic related to the maintenance of wind farms, or possible changes to, for
example, marine ice mobility, icebreaking, etc. This also means, for example,
planning a maintenance waterway to wind farms where disturbance to ringed
seals would be minimized. However, the impact during construction and
operation will be specified in the development of specific project solutions,
which will clarify the exact locations of the wind turbines, the technical
solutions, including cables, maintenance procedures, etc .
Maritime Spatial Plan does not provide for new national defense areas or extend
existing ones, but it does take into account the current spatial needs of national
defense. The implementation of maritime spatial plans will not bring about
changes in the implementation of national defense activities; the status quo for
marine mammals is maintained. Existing national defense areas remain in the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 87
Gulf of Finland, and a special area south of the Kõpu Peninsula (Hiiu Island
area of the Maritime Spatial Plan) is being planned. These areas are not
important habitat for breeding and reproduction of the ringed seal, but the
potential area of influence is the gray seal as species spreading on the entire
marine area. The use of ammunition and explosives may have a direc t impact
on marine mammals both in the water and on ice in the area. National defense
activities (mine control, various exercises) can directly damage or, in the worst
case, kill nearby seals. Ammunition and hazardous substances to which marine
mammals are a particularly sensitive species may also be released into the
marine environment. When carrying out national defense activities in these
areas, it is necessary to pay attention to the environmental aspects highlighted
and to cooperate with species conservation experts to minimize the impact of
the activities, e.g., to prepare an environmental protection plan .
Developing offshore aquaculture is not an activity of major impact for marine
mammals. However, the establishment of fish farms in the sea must take into
account the potential damage caused by gray seals. It is widely known that the
gray seal is a highly adaptable species that grow accustomed to human activities
and, unlike the ringed seal, even takes advantage of it, comes to catch fish, for
example, in ports, near fishing traps, and aquaculture facilities. This is certainly
important when planning fish farms - keep in mind that they can attract animals
and cause so-called "pressure" from seals, which can disrupt activity .
The implementation of the maritime spatial plan does not envisage the
occurrence of significant adverse effects on seals by applying the prescribed
environmental measures and recommendations at the level of authorization.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. During the implementation of the activities proposed in the Maritime
Spatial Plan (in particular the development of wind energy), the impact
assessment process needs to include clarification of the impacts,
including the necessary expertise and, where appropriate, mitigation
measures for marine mammals. The need for further research needs to
be considered within each specific project.
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. It is advisable to draw up a protection management plan for the national
defense sites, which will map the environmental risks of the activities to
the marine biota, including seals, and measures to prevent or reduce
them.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 88
4.2.4 Bats59,60
So far, 14 species of bats have been identified in Estonia, which falls into two
groups with different adaptations. Brown long-eared bats, Northern bats and
species belonging to the Myotis genus winter in Estonia (or neighboring
countries), undertaking only regional migrations from summer habitats to
hibernation sites. Nathusius's pipistrelle, Common pipistrelle, and Soprano
pipistrelle and Common noctule are migratory and fly to winter in southern
Europe. 64 The habitats, breeding and feeding areas of bats are generally
terrestrial. According to relatively limited knowledge to date, marine areas are
primarily associated with bat migration, but there are also species that make
foraging flights above the sea.
The research on bats at sea has become a topical issue with the establishment
of offshore wind farms (Ahlén et al., 2007). It should be borne in mind that bats
are able to cross large areas of the sea. Isolated overseas bats have been found
in the Faroe Islands, Iceland, as well as in oil rigs and ships in the North Sea,
sometimes these have been the species originating from America (Ahlén, 2009;
Russ et al., 2001). When crossing the Gulf of Riga bats do not need to take such
long flights. The distance at the narrowest point of the Kura kurk is only 29
km.
In Sweden 11 species of bats have been observed above the sea, 10 of which
are also present in Estonia: water bat (Myotis daubentonii), pond bat (Myotis
dasycneme), park bat, dwarf bat, pygmy bat, lesser white-fronted gull, great
crested grebe, northern bat, silver bat and brown-eared plover (Ahlén, Baagøe
& Bach, 2009). In Estonia previous studies have indicated that northern bats,
park bats, great crested grebe and unspecified bat (Myotis) fly more than 1.5
km from the shore above the sea (Lutsar, 2012; Lutsar, 2013; Lutsar, 2016).
In addition, there are reports of bats flying over the sea in the Estonian
territorial waters seen from the passenger and yacht ships. In one case the
species of a bat was determined by a photograph - it was a great crested grebe
that landed on a yacht in the morning in the west of the Sõrve Peninsula at dawn
(L. Lutsar's species identification, data from Mart Jüssi from 2011 61).
Only a few studies have been carried out in the marine area, covering very
limited marine areas. So far, bats have been studied above the sea in Estonia in
three areas: around Kõpu peninsula (Lutsar, 2012), in the Gulf of Finland in the
shallows of Tallinn, in Kuradimuna and Uusmadala (Lutsar, 2013), in
Veiserahu, south of Saaremaa (2016) and in three places around Saaremaa in
59
The chapter is largely based on the basic research of the Maritime Spatial Plan “Survey of
bats at sea around Saaremaa from July to October 2018” Estonian Fund for Nature, 2019
60
In March 2021, based on the work “Bat survey in the Gulf of Riga and the Gulf of Finland
from June to October 2020. Phase II identification of important marine areas for bats”, Lutsar,
L; Estonian Fund for Nature, 2021
61
The same as previous
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 89
2018: in Mustpank, near Irbe axle buoy no. 1 and again in Veiserahu (Lutsar,
2019) which was the first stage in the implementation of point 10.9 of the
Action Plan for the Conservation of Bats (Vespertilionidae) - Identification of
Marine Seas Important for Bats. The 2020 survey “Bat survey in the Gulf of
Riga and Gulf of Finland from June to October 2020”. Phase II of the
identification of important marine areas for bats was a continuation of the above
work. The observations in 2020 took place at three points in Veiserahu, Kihnu
Shoal and Neugrund 62.
According to current knowledge it can be assumed that migratory species are
rare in the Gulf of Finland in autumn and their relative abundance is lower there
than in the vicinity of Saaremaa. Bats are not expected to gather in autumn on
the Northern Estonian peninsula, as there is a migration route from Finland to
Estonia across the sea. The bats flying across the Gulf of Finland to Estonia are
likely to reach scattered near the Estonian islands and coast. It can be assumed
that the bats will gather on the southern coast of Saaremaa in autumn, especially
on the Sõrve peninsula (the main direction of autumn migration is to the
southwest), where they are waiting for suitable weather to cross the Gulf of
Riga. The moving towards the west to Sweden is less likely, but it cannot be
ruled out.
The existing information suggests that the autumn migration of bats is more
active just in Kura kurk. On a few favourable nights migrating bats can head
west from Saaremaa. Little is known about the spring migration of bats. The
bat population is smaller in spring than in autumn, as not all of them survive
the winter. Thus, during spring migration, the probability to meet bats at sea is
smaller than in autumn. So far, the autumn migration of bats has been mainly
observed, as the largest numbers can be expected at that time and based on the
direction of migration it can be assumed where in the sea bats can fly more in
numbers.
In case of bat migration it is important to note that when flying over the sea
bats usually fly up to 10 m above sea level, but at the sea objects (masts, wind
turbines, etc.) bats rise much higher, for example when flying around the blades
of wind turbines. Bats, especially migratory species, may congregate in certain
areas close to the coast, waiting for the weather suitable to cross the sea.
Migration is possible only in case of relatively quiet weather and favourable
wind direction. According to the bat survey 63 bats flew over the sea when the
wind speed was 0.3–7.7 m/s (0.4–7.1 m/s based on the 2020 survey). At the
same time, based on the study, bats were mostly detected above sea level at
wind speeds below 5–6 m / s.
62
The same as previous
63 "Survey of bats at sea around Saaremaa from July to October 2018" Estonian Fund for
Nature, 2019
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 90
The Action Plan for Protection of Bats 64 points out that the main general
hazards of the Estonian bat fauna are the loss and degradation of both summer
and winter habitats, deaths in wind farms and traffic, environmental poisons,
and natural influences.
64
Action plan for the protection of bats (Vespertilionidae). Approved by the Directive no.
1-1/17/150 of the Director General of the Environmental Board of 15 March 2017
https://www.keskkonnaamet.ee/sites/default/files/liigikaitse/nahkhiirlaste_tk.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 91
Impact of the MSP
Bats mainly use the marine area for the migratory period flyover, and there is
no contact with the aquatic environment. Bats may be affected by activities that
disrupt bat flight corridors and migratory routes, thus increasing the risk of bats
being killed. Wind energy is the only potential activity affecting bats in
maritime spatial planning.
Bats may be killed in offshore wind farms located in important flight corridors
(migratory routes). The more intensively used the migration route, the more
specimens can be killed.
The larger wind energy development areas proposed in the Maritime Spatial
Plan are located in the Gulf of Riga and west of Saaremaa (Figure 4.2.4 -1).
According to current knowledge, the planning solution can be considered
suitable for the migration of bats, as the expected main migration direction from
the southern coast of Saaremaa (Sõrve spit) to Latvia in Courland has been left
open. There are nature reserves in this area which ensure the preservation of
the migration corridor. The planned migration corridor also runs across the Gulf
of Riga above the islands of Kihnu and Ruhnu, where the plan does not foresee
development areas of wind energy either.
Figure 4.2.4-1. Sensitive areas for bats (source: “Survey of bats at sea around
Saaremaa from July to October 2018” Estonian Fund for Nature, 2019 and
“Survey of bats in the Gulf of Riga and Gulf of Finland from June to October
2020. Phase II of the identification of important marine areas for bats”)
Estonian Fund for Nature, 2021)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 92
The potential conflict between wind turbines and bats is mitigated by the fact
that wind turbines operate at higher wind speeds (average wind speed in the
wind farm area above 9 m/s) with little or no bat activity. The wind turbines
start working with the wind speed of about 5 m/s and by taking the migration
speed of bats (approx. 5-6 m/s) into account, the migration usually takes place
in relatively quiet weather when the wind turbines do not work or operate at
slow revs with low risk to bats.
Knowing the relationship between wind speed and bat flight activity will allow
wind turbines to be stopped at certain times and at certain wind speeds in the
future to protect bats. According to the survey conducted in 2020 65, the autumn
migration of bats was most active at the end of July and in August, the most
active period of which within this short period of about 19-30 August and in
the period from 22:00 to 4:00. This is a very limited period of time, so it is
possible to develop technological solutions for wind turbines in the future,
where it would be possible, for example, to limit the rotor speed of the wind
turbine until the wind turbines stop automatically during a certain period of
time. Whenever possible, wind farms should always use the best available
technology to minimize the potential related effects.
In the light of current knowledge, it can be said that the mariti me spatial
planning solution for the spatial arrangement of priority areas for wind energy
is consistent with the anticipated migration routes of bats and the proposed
environmental measures regarding the spatial plan will not result in significant
adverse impacts on bats.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. In the further development of wind energy development areas, it is
necessary to assess in more detail the occurrence of effects and
significance of the effects on bats. In the context of the authorization
procedure, the effects should be specified by including the necessary
expertise and, if necessary, studies should be carried out in the marine
area to be developed and, if necessary, mitigation measures should be
applied. The monitoring of bats should be continued during construction
and operation of the wind farm.
2. It is important to keep the main migratory routes of bats free from wind
farms (to mitigate the risk of collision) or to provide for appropriate
mitigation measures if necessary. For example, limiting wind turbine
rotor speed to stall (during migration); installation of ultrasonic
repellants on wind turbines that guide potential bats in the area away
from the wind farm, etc.
65 “Bat survey in the Gulf of Riga and Finland from June to October 2020. Phase II
identification of important marine areas for bats”, Lutsar, L; Estonian Fund for Nature, 2021 “
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 93
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. The research on bats in the Estonian marine area should be continued in
order to gather information on the most important migration directions
and intensities of bats, as well as on the relations between wind speed
and bat flight activity.
4.2.5 Seabed habitats and biota
Seabed habitats
Habitat types considered important for nature conservation in the European
Union were listed in 1992 in Annex I to the Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC on
the conservation of natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora), which
combines habitat types from land, sea, and freshwater. There are a total of eight
marine habitat types in Annex I of the Habitats Directive, of which six occur in
the Estonian marine area (in brackets the Habitats Directive Annex I code ):
▪ sandbanks flooded with seawater (1110, hereinafter "sandbanks"),
▪ river estuaries (1130),
▪ mudflats and sandflats (1140, hereinafter "flats") expose with a low
tide,
▪ coastal lagoons (1150),
▪ wide shallow coves and bays (1160),
▪ reefs (1170).
Sandbanks and reefs can be considered fully seabed habitat types as they are
not related to the shape of the coastline or the land. Far from the coast, in
offshore conditions, the presence of river estuaries, mud and sand flats, coastal
lagoons, and wide shallow coves and bays, as all these habitat types are directly
related to the coastline 66. Habitats of reefs (1170) and sandbanks (1110), which
are more widespread in the Estonian marine area, are, therefore, the focus of
attention in the context of Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan.
Seabed habitat mapping was started in Estonia in 2005, and approximately one
third (38%) of the Estonian marine area has been covered by inventories (spring
2019) (Figure 4.2.5-1). With respect to the extent of the marine area covered
by the inventories, it should be borne in mind that, as of now, 38% coverage is
obtained by aggregating the areas of the survey polygons of all mapping areas,
regardless of specific mapping techniques and density of sampling points . All
mapping work to date has been project-based, and the results are based on a
very sparse sampling point network for large area mapping. The greater the
distances between the sampling points, the less reliable the maps are. Detailed
66
Habitats directives, inventory of the marine habitats in the selected areas in the Estonian
EEZ, TÜ EMI, 2016
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 94
knowledge of the seabed is derived from the points visited at sea . Estimates of
the distribution of the seabed substrate and biota for the area between the
sampling points are obtained through indirect mathematical methods -
interpolation or directed modeling.
Major unmapped areas within the territorial sea are located in the eastern part
of the Gulf of Finland and the western and northwestern parts of the territorial
sea. Seabed habitats in the EEZ are much less mapped compared to the
territorial sea (Figure 4.2.5-1).
In 2018, modeling of the distribution of reefs and sandbank habitat types for
the entire Estonian marine area was performed based on the available materials
(Figure 4.2.5- 2).
Figure 4.2.5-1. Areas mapped in the Estonian marine area (source: Estonian
Maritime Institute, UT, as of spring 2019)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 95
Figure 4.2.5-2. Modeled distribution of habitat types in Annex I of the Habitats
Directive - reefs and sandbanks - with the reliability of the habitat distribution
model in the Estonian marine area (Source of the map material: Updating map
data of Estonian marine habitats, UT Estonian Marine Institute 2018 67)
According to the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSRD ), it is also
necessary to consider general large-scale habitats in the environmental
assessment. EU Commission Decision 2017/848 68, which establishes the main
types of MSFD seabed habitats, has only recently been published, and,
therefore, no MSFD seabed habitats have been mapped in Estonia. However, in
2018, MSFD has conducted modeling of the distribution of key types of seabed
habitats, based on the same source data as the previous Habitats Directive
habitat modeling (Figure 4.2.5-3). The mereRITA project "Innovative solutions
for the assessment and monitoring of the Estonian marine environment and
natural values 69" is underway, in the course of which several innovative
solutions will be developed to enable the mapping and assessment of marine
ecosystems and the development of blue economy.
67
The reliability of the habitat distribution model provided in the figure is due to the density
of sampling points - the higher the density of samples taken from the seabed, the higher the
reliability of the habitat model in a specific area.
68
eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/ET/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32017D0848&from=NE
69
mereRITA website: https://sisu.ut.ee/mererita/avaleht
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 96
Figure 4.2.5-3. Modeled distribution of the main types of MSFD seabed
habitats in the Estonian marine area. (Source: Estonian Maritime Institute, UT
2018)
In addition, a modeled distribution map of HELCOM 70seabed biotopes
(HELCOM HUB or Helcom underwater biotope and habitat classification
system), level 3, is available from earlier studies (Figure 4.2.5 -4) 71.
70 Baltic Marine Environment Protection Commission - Helsinki Commission
71
Reporting of the NEMA project: “Habitats directive of modeling the distribution of marine
habitat types and EUNIS level 3 habitats in the Estonian EEZ”, UT Estonian Maritime
Institute, 2016. http://nema.bef.ee/en/
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 97
Figure 4.2.5-4. Modeled HELCOM HUB Level 3 Habitat Distribution in the
Estonian Marine Area (Source: Estonian Marine Institute, UT 2016)
In 2018, the status of reefs, sandflats, and sandbanks from the seabed habitats
was assessed for reporting in accordance with the Estonian Marine Strategy 72
and all three habitat types were found to be in a favorable state. In addition,
oxygen deprivation and macrofauna communities in soft-bottom areas were
assessed. Their assessment is predominantly favorable in the Estonian marine
area, but no good status was achieved in the Väinameri Sea, Pärnu Bay, and the
eastern and offshore parts of the Gulf of Finland.
In 2020 the study “Study of seabed biota and habitats to assess the distribution
of Natura and HELCOM habitat types and to elucidate the CO2 sequestration
potential of the sea” (Estonian Marine Institute, University of Tartu, 2020) 73
was completed, which, as one of the areas, examined the marine area in the
west of Saaremaa proposed for the development of wind energy set out in the
maritime spatial plan This project carried out studies on the chemical and
72“Environmental Status of Estonian Marine Area 2018” Report, 2018.
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/mere_seisund_2018.pdf
73 Study of seabed biota and habitats to assess the distribution of Natura and HELCOM
habitat types and to elucidate the CO2 sequestration potential of the sea ”(Estonian Marine
Institute, University of Tartu, 2020)
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/inventuuri_lopparuanne_02.06.2020.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 98
physical characteristics of the seabed biota and habitats and the water column
within that part of the territorial sea.
During the inventory the distribution of the Habitats Directive habitat type 1170
(reefs) was identified in the study area (total area 228 km 2 , 48% of the study
area). No other seabed habitat types or species in the directives or other lists of
natural values were found in the study area. The presence of a habitat type in
the Habitats Directive in an area does not in itself require its separate
protection. Based on the information available in the marine area under
Estonian jurisdiction, the habitat type of reefs covers an area of 3421.3 km 2 .The
existing natural areas in Estonia cover 19.2% of this. The Estonian areas offered
by the HELCOM network of marine protected areas (includes both natur al areas
and Site of Community Importance) cover 27.8% of the reef habitat type present
in all Estonian marine areas. Estonia has reported that the reefs of the habitat
type in the Estonian marine area are in a favourable nature conservation status.
Considering that no objects of nature protection importance were identified in
the study area other than the Habitats Directive habitat 1170 (reefs), which has
been already sufficiently covered by the existing network of protected areas in
Estonia, and by taking into account the two potential new marine protected
areas in the immediate vicinity of the study area (the ongoing extension of
Vilsandi National Park and the proposal to establish an offshore protected area
in the EEZ, see Chapter 4.2.6 for more details), the expert group that conducted
the study does not see a direct need to establish new nature protection
restrictions in the study area if the planned and pending protected areas will be
realized and will ensure the preservation of the favourable status of the habitat
type 1170.
Seabed habitats
In the Estonian marine area, macroscopic seabed biota is formed of flora (large
algae and higher plants) and benthic fauna. In terms of species composition,
the biota is quite diverse, with both marine and freshwater species.
Seabed vegetation. On the basis of the data from the years 1992 - 2018, 60
major vegetation taxa (including 57 species and taxa Ulotrix,
Pseudolithoderma, and fontinalis the genus level) have been recorded in the
Estonian marine area.
The most frequently occurring species in the Estonian marine area are
Vertebrata fucoides, Cladophora glomerata, and Ceramium tenuicorne. The
species/ taxa of the brown algae are the most abundant in the Estonian marine
area. The differences between vegetation species/taxa in the HELCOM sub -
basins are relatively small, with the Gulf of Riga being the most abundant in
species.
Large vertebrates. According to the data of the years 1992-2018, 92 zoobenthos
taxa (including 73 species and 19 taxa) data are registered in the Estonian
marine area.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 99
The most frequently occurring invertebrates in the Estonian marine area are the
blue mussel (Mytilus trossulus), Baltic clam (Limecola balthica) and barnacle
attaching to the substrate (Amphibalanus improvisus). 59% of the benthic
species/taxa belong to the arthropod family. Species diversity is highest in the
Gulf of Riga lower basin and lowest in the eastern Gotland basin .
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 100
Impact of the MSP
Seabed habitats and biota are influenced by two types of anthropogenic factors :
▪ local factors (in particular mechanical impact on the seabed, local
sources of pollution);
▪ regional influences (general level of eutrophication in the Baltic
Sea, the total level of hazardous substances).
The spatial solutions to the activities to be established by the plan are primarily
of local impact and are related to the mechanical impact of the activities on the
seabed (disturbance, removal, replacement of the seabed substrate). The
specific impact is very specific to the site and the proposed activity, so it is
possible to assess the impact of the activities during the licensing process for
specific projects.
From the standpoint of the seabed and its biota, the development of wind energy
is one of the most important areas of activity proposed in the Maritime Spatial
Plan, which may include direct actions that locally affect the seabed. According
to current experience, the impact on seabed habitats and biota associated with
wind energy development are in particular foundations of wind turbines and
erosion control 74,75,76,77.
Impact on benthic habitats. Of the proposed activities, technical
developments, i.e., any physical intervention in the seabed environment, will
have a greater impact on the seabed habitats. There are reefs (1170) and
sandbanks (1110) in the planned wind energy development areas of the EU
Habitats Directive Annex I habitat types of conservation value, see Figure
4.2.5-2.
In particular the construction of wind farms on the seabed will have an impact
by occupying or destroying the habitat under the foundation of the specific wind
turbine or substation and power cables. Depending on the specific conditions
of the seabed, it may be necessary to prepare the seabed for installation of the
foundation. Prior to the installation of gravitational foundations it may be
necessary to level and strengthen the seabed.
74Boehlert, G. W., and Gill, A. B. 2010. Environmental and ecological effects of ocean
renewable energy development: A Current Synthesis. Oceanography , 23: 68-81
75 ICES. 2012. Report of the Workshop on Effects of Offshore Windfarms on Marine Benthos
- Facilitating a closer international collaboration throughout the North Atlantic Region
(WKEOMB), 27–30 March 2012, Bremerhaven, Germany. ICES CM 2012/SSGEF:13. 57 pp.
76 Lindeboom, H. J., Kouwenhoven, H. J., Bergman, M. J. N., Bouma, S., Brasseur, S., Daan,
R., Fijn, R. C., et al. 2011. Short-term ecological effects of an offshore wind farm in the Dutch
coastal zone; a compilation. Environmental Research Letters , 6.
77 Linley EAS, Wilding TA, Black K, Hawkins AJS, Mangi. 2007. Review of the effects of
offshore windfarm structures and their potential for enhancment and mitigation .
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 101
To date, gravitational foundations have been developed that do not requ ire the
prior preparation of the seabed (eg Gravitas 78, Seatower 79), but may require
filling with concrete to fill the gap between the seabed and the foundation after
installation. The capacity of wind turbines as well as other parameters depend
on the specific location and layout, as well as the time of realization of wind
farms. Depending on the height of the wind turbines and diameter of the rotor,
as well as the distances between the locations of the wind turbines ( i.e. the
location of the foundations).
The extent of the impact depends on the technical details and material of the
foundation and the area of the seabed below the foundation, i.e. the smaller the
power wind turbines and the larger the foundations, the greater the impact. The
larger the area of the foundation and the area of the seabed under it, the greater
the loss of natural seabed at a particular location.
The preference should be given to the foundation structures with the smaller
"footprint" when constructing wind farms in the future alongside with
technological developments (including taking into account that their physical
construction in the construction stage does not cause significant and extensive
noise and sediment movement and, for example, the seabed being prepared will
be affected to a minimum). When establishing the offshore wind farms, the
location of wind turbines should be based primarily on the location of habitat
types and, if possible, the installation of wind turbines in an area with habitats
of reefs (1170) of high nature conservation value should be foremost avoided.
The current technological solutions of the wind turbine foundation are the most
suitable gravity-based foundation for the conditions of the Estonian marine
area, which can be solved both as a monolith and as a combination of several
smaller interconnected elements. In the case of more sensitive habitat, a
monolithic foundation should be preferred, as in this case, the impact will be
one-off (when one monolithic foundation block is laid on the seabed). The
foundation material should be as close as possible to the natural substrate
(surface roughness, neutral chemical reaction). Enriching the exterior surface
of the foundation with natural rock material may also b e considered. This
allows the creation of an attachment substrate that is as natural as possible, to
which marine organisms can attach. In the case of material facilitating
attachment of biota, a so-called reef effect is expected 80, which is a very
complex phenomenon with both positive and negative impacts. Positive impacts
include an increase in biomass attached to the seabed, an increase in the species
78 https://www.arup.com/-
/media/arup/files/publications/g/gravitas_brochure_final_press_quali ty2.pdf
79 http://seatower.com/
80 An artificial reef is a man - made structure or structure that has been laid on the seabed,
either intentionally or unintentionally, and serves as a basis for the growth and production of
marine life (Hoffmann et al. 2001)
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 102
diversity of the benthic biota, and the foundations of wind turbines attracting
fish (easier access to food, shelter, spawning substrate, etc).
The reef effect is also accompanied by negative impacts, such as the
accumulation of dead biomass at the wind turbine foundation and nutrient
enrichment of sediments - local eutrophication symptoms; the possible
promotion of alien species (the so-called ' stepping stone ' effect); and the
formation of hard substrates at depth ranges where they do not occur naturally
(in turn, colonization of species is unpredictable). Experiments on colonizing a
new substrate conducted in the northern Baltic Sea have shown that it is very
difficult to predict which species will colonize a particular new substrate in the
high seas. Each specific site is different in its conditions, and evaluation (and
study) of substrate colonization should be made prior to the implementation of
a particular project. Seabed disturbance experiments conducted in Estonia
(Neugrund shallow, limestone bottom) have also shown that disturbance of the
limestone seabed - mechanical damage - produces changes that can be observed
over many years. The soft bottom uses erosion barriers and increases the area
of impact of the foundation of each particular wind turbine. Thus, when using
erosion barriers, natural material from land-based sources should be used to
minimize the impact.
When dismantling wind turbines, it must first be assessed whether removing
the foundation can cause more damage than leaving it in the marine
environment. Perhaps the option of removing the foundation should be
preferred, but in some cases, it may be expedient not to dismantle the
foundation.
The development of offshore wind farms will also involve the laying of seabed
cables. Their specific impact will also depend on the technology used for the
laying of the cable on the seabed, the material of the cable covering, and the
voltage inside the cable, which must be addressed in more detail in the licensing
and assessment of the proposed activities. Today, cable installation technology
has advanced in the direction where laying the cable on the seabed is
accompanied with protection thereof along its entire length from potential
damage. One of the more commonly used methods of protecting a cable is by
burying it in seabed sediments, which ensures safety and avoidance of
economic damage, as well as mitigating the environmental impact of some
(magnetic field, heat). The construction of cable corridores does not, by its very
nature, destroy the habitat under the cable corridore and has a limited
geographical impact. In the case of a soft seabed, a temporary groove is created
to bury the cable, and the sediment will fall on the installed cable. A sufficient
burial depth of the cable to protect the cable from the main external influences
is generally considered to be 1- 1.5 m. The success and methods of burial in the
sediments are highly dependent on the seabed geology. The establishment and
subsequent operation of the cable corridore will not significantly affect the
distribution of habitats. For a particularly hard substrate, there is no significan t
change in habitat distribution, for a soft substrate there may be some habitat
loss and habitat diversification through the addition of hard substrate, but under
certain conditions, the added hard substrate (the cable itself) may get buried
under soft sediment, in which case the distribution and health of the habitat is
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 103
not comparable to the previous situation, especially in offshore areas. All in
all, the establishment of a cable corridore to the spread of habitats has a small
and short-term impact during both construction and operation.
An important parameter characterizing the status of the seabed habitats is the
quality of the habitats (compliance of the biota with the typical structure and
preservation of the biological function of the abiotic compon ents of the
environment). The establishment of a cable corridore can affect habitat quality
through changes in the substrate and the distribution of species important to the
habitat. As the cable corridore is a particularly hard substrate added to the
seabed and its associated additional reef effect, a greater change is expected to
occur in the habitat quality in particular on soft bases, as the addition of a hard
substrate and a reef effect will increase the species diversity of this habitat
through additional substrate formation. 81, 82. The impact on hard bottoms is
minimal since the addition of substrate does not fundamentally alter the
conditions of the species populating the habitat. To date, apart from isolated
cases 83, the magnetic and electric fields associated with the cables have no
impact on benthic biota and individual species, so the impact of these fields on
the species composition cannot be assessed. In conclusion, it can be expected
that the installation and further operation of the cable corridore will have only
a minor and short-term impact on the quality of the seabed habitats.
Impact on benthic biota. Benthic vegetation is a component of benthic biota
that primarily inhabits the photic zone of the seabed. The vegetation
communities vary depending on the substrate. In offshore conditions (openness
to waves), as a rule, soft beds (sandy and clayey seabeds) have no vegetation.
The benthic vegetation of the hard bottoms consists primarily of algae, which
have a typical zonality in accordance with the depth in the northern Baltic Sea.
In the shallower part, there is usually a green algae zone, followed by the brown
algae or bladderwrack zone, and in the deepest part (up to 30 m in the open sea
condition), the red algae zone. As a rule, the bladderwrack zone is the richest
in biomass and species.
Cable routing creates a substrate suitable for attachment to the bottom
vegetation at depth ranges where it may not have been present (especially on
soft bottoms). Under hard substrate conditions, the hard substrate formed in the
case of the cable corridore is not significantly different from that of the natural
substrate, and thus no impact on the species composition of benthic vegetation
is expected. Thus, the added substrate has a significant local impact only on
soft bottoms, which is rather rare in the wind energy development areas
81 Ambrose, R. F., and Anderson, T. W. 1990. Influence of an artificial reef on the surrounding
infaunal community. Marine Biology [Mar. Biol.], 107: 41 -52.
82Langhamer O. 2012. Artificial Reef Effect in relation to Offshore Renewable Energy
Conversion: State of the Art. Sci. World J. 2012:1–8. doi:10.1100/2012/386713.
83 Scott, K., Harsanyi, P., and Lyndon, A. R. 2018. Understanding the effects of
electromagnetic field emissions from Marine Renewable Energy Devices (MREDs) on the
commercially important edible crab, Cancer pagurus (L.). Marine Pollution Bulletin, 131:
580-588.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 104
proposed in the Maritime Spatial Plan. To date, the electromagnetic impacts of
cables on benthic species have not been identified.
The benthic fauna is composed of both sessile (sedentary) and mobile species.
The sessile species need either a hard substrate to attach or softer sediment to
dig itself into. For species attaching to a hard substrate (e.g., shellfish), the
addition of a hard substrate is primarily additional habitat and often allows for
a more complex, three-dimensional habitat 84. This has often led to the
abundance of anchored benthos and the increased biomass in the vicinity of
wind farms.
The impact of fitting the cable lines on the soft-bottom benthos may occur
particularly in close proximity to the cable through the change of sediment
dynamics 85, 86. In the vicinity of cables and other artificial structures, usually
under favorable hydrodynamic conditions, forms in sediments w ill begin to
proliferate 87, 88 The electromagnetic impact on mobile species has been
described several times 89. Mostly it has been either fish or crabs. Such impacts
have not been described in our waters, and knowledge to date tends to indicate
a lack of impacts.
As a separate risk, cable corridores can be highlighted as potential contributors
to the spread of alien species, in particular by forming an uninterrupted network
of hard substrates in the area of soft sediment. 90 In this way, species attaching
to a hard substrate will be able to propagate along the cable corridores in a
84 Kerckhof F, De Mesel I, Degraer S (2016). Do wind farms favour introduces hard subatrata
species? In: Degraer S, Brabant R, Rumes B, Vigin L (eds.): Environmental impact of offshore
wind farms in the Belgian part of the North Sea: Environmental impact monitoring reloaded.
Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences, OD Natural Environment, Marine Ecology and
Management Section: 61-75.
85 Davis, N., van Blaricom, G. R., and Day ton, P. K. 1982. Man-made structures on marine
sediments: Effects on adjacent benthic communities. Marine Biology [Mar. Biol.], 70: 295 -
303.
86Hall, S. J. 1994. Physical Disturbance And Marine Benthic Communities - Life In
Unconsolidated Sediments. Oceanography and Marine Biology: an Annual Review, 32: 179 -
239.
87 Coates D, Vanaverbeke J, Vincx M, others (2012) Enrichment of the soft sediment
macrobenthos around a gravity-based foundation on the Thorntonbank. Offshore Wind Belg
Part North Sea Head Underst Environ Impacts R Belg Inst Nat Sci Manag Unit North Sea
Math Models Mar Ecosyst Manag Unit Bruss:41 –54
88 Coates, D. A., Deschutter, Y., Vincx, M., and Vanaverbeke, J. 2014. Enrichment and shifts
in macrobenthic assemblages in an offshore wind farm area in the Belgian part of the North
Sea. Marine Environmental Research, 95: 1-12.
89 Hutchinson, Z, Sigray, P, He H, Gill, A, King J, Gibson, C (2018)
Electromagnetic Field
(EMF) Impacts on Elasmobranch (shark, rays, and skates) and American Lobster Movement
and Migration from Direct Current Cables. Sterling (VA): U.S. Department of the Interior,
Bureau of Ocean Energy Management. OCS Study BOEM 2018 -003. Sterling (VA): U.S.
90 Ricciardi,A., and Rasmussen, J. B. 1998. Predicting the identity and impact of future
biological invaders: A priority for aquatic resource management. Canadian Journal of
Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences [Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci.], 55: 1759-1765.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 105
situation where this would naturally be impossible. Cables may also be
associated with low-frequency vibration propagation, especially near wind
turbines, which in turn may cause changes in the distribution of benthic fauna
on the local scale 91.
To mitigate the impacts of cables, for example, in case of a cay, it is useful to
consider burying the cable. For hard substrates (such as "reef" habitat ty pes), it
is not practical to bury or cover the cable in deeper parts of the high seas. Where
possible, the external surface of the cable should be neutral and allow the
organisms to attach. At the same time, protecting the cable in the shallow
coastal area, which is therefore strongly affected by ice and storms, is
indispensable (recommended depth approx. 1.5 meters). In addition to the
shallow areas, international shipping lanes and intersections with other cables
or pipelines are potential risk areas. Solutions for advanced cable protection
methods are being developed in the design of wind farms.
In addition to wind energy, aquaculture is another type of marine use that is
directly related to seabed habitats and biota. The impact of aquaculture on
seabed habitats and biota depends on many factors - environmental factors at a
given location, the type of aquaculture, and the technology used. Fish farms are
primarily associated with eutrophication. The impact of the fish farm is by the
nutrients added to the marine environment through the fish farm (see Chapter
4.1.5), which may alter the ecological conditions of the seabed biota, thereby
causing changes in the species composition of the biota and the quality of the
habitat. At the same time the shellfish and algae farming can remove nutrients
from the marine environment and their effect is rather to reduce the level of
eutrophication (see Chapter 4.1.5 for more details). The impacts associated with
fish farming depend to a large extent on the location of the proposed activity,
technology and the species cultivated, so the associated impacts need to be
further assessed in the authorization procedure and, where necessary, the
measures to mitigate significant adverse effects need to be developed. As
technology advances, the aim should be to encourage only nutrient -neutral fish
farming in the marine environment.
The implementation of the maritime spatial plan does not envisage the
occurrence of significant adverse effects on the seabed habitats and bi ota by
applying the prescribed environmental measures and recommendations at the
level of authorization.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. The implementation of the uses of the marine areas considered in the
Maritime Spatial Plan will have an impact primarily on t he local level
(mechanical intervention on the seabed, etc.). Because the impacts are
91 Solan, M., Hauton, C., Godbold, J. A., Wood, C. L., Leighton, T. G., and White, P. 2016.
Anthropogenic sources of underwater sound can modify how sediment -dwelling invertebrates
mediate ecosystem properties. Scientific Reports, 6: 20540.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 106
site and activity specific, impacts are assessed at the licensing level for
most areas activities and can be mitigated as appropriate.
2. The selection of different foundation types and technologies for wind
turbines shall take into account and assess the environmental impact of
their construction and dismantling on the seabed and its biota.
3. In the areas suitable for the development of wind energy, it is
recommended that the location of the wind turbines is based on the
location of the habitat types. Avoid installing wind turbines in areas of
habitats of high conservation value where possible.
4. As technology advances, preference should be given to smaller
"footprint" foundation structures, i.e. the smaller the area of the seabed
under the foundation (and the part to be prepared for it), the lower the
loss of natural seabed at a specific location (incl it must be taken into
account that their physical construction during the construction and
dismantling phases would not cause significant and extensive noise and
would not cause significant sediment movement).
5. To mitigate the effects of cables connecting wind farms to land, consider
burying of cables when they pass through a soft substrate (e.g., sandbank
habitat type), whereas for hard substrate (e.g., reef habitat type), burying
and coating of the cables in deeper offshore areas is not feasible. W here
possible, the external surface of the cable should be neutral and allow
the organisms to attach.
6. The effects related to the offshore fish farm should be further assessed
in the licensing procedure and, if necessary, mitigation measures should
be developed. As technology advances, the aim should be to encourage
only nutrient-neutral fish farming in the marine environment.
4.2.6 Protected natural objects
Approximately 19% of the entire Estonian marine area (including the exclusive
economic zone) is covered by various types of protected natural objects. The
existing network of marine protected areas is very unevenly distributed. All of
the existing protected areas are located in the territorial sea. There are
predominantly special conservation areas and protected areas for the protection
of the sea. The list of protected natural objects in the Maritime Spatial Plan
area is given in the following table, and protected sea areas are illustrated in
Figure 4.2.6-1.
Table 4.2.6-1. Protected natural objects related to the Estonian maritime spatial
plan (the table does not include information on natural objects located in the
area covered by Hiiu and Pärnu maritime spatial plans)
Area name Code
Special conservation areas
Gretagrundi Conservation Area KLO2000344
Kahtla-Kübassaare Conservation Area KLO2000309
Karala-Pilguse Conservation Area KLO2000310
Kasti lahe Conservation Area KLO2000312
Kaugatoma-Lõu Conservation Area KLO2000313
Küdema lahe Conservation Area KLO2000318
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 107
Kolga lahe Conservation Area KLO2000003
Koorunõmme Conservation Area KLO2000315
Kura kurgu Conservation Area KLO2000316
Kuressaare lahe Conservation Area KLO2000316
Nõva-Osmussaare Conservation Area in Harjumaa and KLO2000165
Läänemaa KLO2000166
Pakri Conservation Area KLO2000167
Paljassaare Conservation Area KLO2000168
Pammana Conservation Area KLO2000222
Prangli Conservation Area KLO2000169
Riksu ranniku Conservation Area KLO2000327
Ruhnu Conservation Area KLO2000328
Siiksaare-Oessaare Conservation Area KLO2000330
Sutu lahe Conservation Area KLO2000331
Tagamõisa Conservation Area KLO2000332
Vaindloo Conservation Area KLO2000037
Väikese väina Conservation Area KLO2000048
Väinamere Conservation Area (Läänemaa and KLO2000241
Saaremaa) KLO2000339
Nature reserves
Allirahu Nature Reserve KLO1000146
Apollo meremadaliku Nature Reserve KLO1000674
Puhtu-Laelatu Nature Reserve KLO1000176
Rahuste Nature Conservation Area KLO1000305
Silma Nature Reserve KLO1000197
Sääre Nature Reserve KLO1000662
Suurupi Nature Reserve KLO1000612
Toolse Nature Reserve KLO1000180
Uhtju Nature Reserve KLO1000017
Landscape protection areas
Kasti Landscape Protection Area KLO1000485
Kübassaare Landscape Protection Area KLO1000295
Kolga lahe Landscape Protection Area KLO1000495
Letipea Landscape Protection Area KLO1000516
Vormsi Landscape Protection Area KLO1000220
National parks
Lahemaa National park KLO1000511
Matsalu National park KLO1000300
Vilsandi National park KLO1000250
Permanent habitat
Kerju Gray Seal Permanent Habitat KLO3000094
Krassi Island Gray Seal Permanent Habitat KLO3000092
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 108
Proposed protected areas 92
Krassi Nature Reserve -
Laidevahe Nature Reserve (extension) PLO1001325
Neugrundi Nature Reserve PLO1000854
Paljassaare Nature Reserve -
Mustjõe ranna Landscape Protection Area -
Vilsandi National park (extension) -
Figure 4.2.6-1. Protected natural objects on the marine area
Most protected natural objects on the marine area are also internationally
protected within the Natura 2000 network of nature and/or special protection
area. The impact on Natura sites is assessed in a separate chapter in the Natura
Assessment Form (Chapter 4.3).
This chapter outlines the environmental aspects of nationally protected natural
objects without international protection, which are related to the
implementation of the plan. Out of the existing protected areas, Uhtju Nature
Reserve is partially outside of the Natura special protection areas, and Apollo
Shoal Nature Reserve is entirely outside the Natura special protection areas.
92 In the proposed protected that are highlighted are areas covering the new marine area or
extensions to existing protected areas
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 109
Also, all proposed new protected areas and planned extensions to existing areas
provided in Table 4.2.6-1 are located outside the Natura site network..
Until now the protection of marine areas has taken place in Estonia by area,
and the reasons for the protection have mostly been the presence of either birds
or marine mammals. In a few cases seabed habitats have also been considered
as protected natural values. So far, the effectiveness of the existing protected
areas and measures in the Estonian marine area has not been assessed, nor has
the coherence of the network been assessed or taken into account when creating
the network of protected areas. This would require a comprehensive analysis of
a separate marine area, led by the Ministry of the Environment and the
Environmental Board, which are responsible for the protection and selection of
nature reserves and Natura 2000 sites.
At the time of preparing the maritime spatial plan there were essentially no
protected areas in the Estonian EEZ. Only a small part of one protected area,
considering the extent of the EEZ, also reached the EEZ - about 43 km 2 of the
Kura kurgu Conservation Area is located in the EEZ. The need to protect the
marine natural values of the exclusive economic zone has been emphasized both
at the world level (CBD) and in the Baltic Sea region (HELCOM). In the course
of the project, which ended in 2020 93, it has been proposed to establish two
protected areas in the exclusive economic zone (areas 73.3 and 36.7 km 2 ). The
larger of them (according to the proposal "Kolgi shallow marine reserve")
partially overlaps with the wind energy development area propo sed in this
plan 94.
Impact of the MSP
With regard to protected nature, the main objective of the Maritime spatial Plan
shall be the sustainable use of marine space in a manner that ensures the
preservation of protected natural objects and marine reserves and their
93 "Preparation of the proposal for offshore protected areas in the Estonian EEZ", responsible
executor: Martin G; EMI 2020 (https://mereinstituut.ut.ee/et/projektid/avamere -kaitsealade-
ettepaneku-koostamine-eesti-majandusvoondis)
94 The grounds for protection in the context of the EEZ are as follows: The area is
representative of the "reefs" habitat type. An important part of the habitat type of the “reefs”
of the Habitats Directive located in the Estonian EEZ is located in the area (25.58% of all
reefs in the EEZ are located in the area). The habitat type “reefs” in the area is in a very good
condition - the human impact is currently limited to indirect effects (general level of
eutrophication in the Baltic Sea, general pollution load of hazardous substances), there are
practically no local anthropogenic pressures. The area is a “hot -spot” for biodiversity in terms
of seabed biota (UT Estonian Marine Institute 2020a). The area is a spawning ground for
Baltic flounder, autumn spawning herring, shorthorn sculpin and long-spined bullhead, an
important feeding area for juvenile cod and an important feeding area for European and Baltic
flounder (UT Estonian Marine Institute 2020b). The site is an important Special Protection
Area (previously identified in the studies as an important non -protected Special Protection
Area). The area is especially important for the resting and migrating area of long-tailed duck,
divers (gull and red-throated diver) and small gulls (different species use the area as migration
stops, as a wintering area and as a summer feeding area) (UT Estonian Marine Institute
2020c).
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 110
conservation objectives and does not impede the achievement of
conservation objectives. To achieve these goals, the main principles applied
in the planning are:
▪ The plan map reflects all the natural features protected at sea and does
not target other areas of activity for those areas that may be expected to
have adverse impacts (e.g., wind energy);
▪ It is established as a guideline that the use of the marine area in prot ected
natural objects is subject to the site's conservation objectives and
restrictions.
The plan identifies three areas for the development of wind energy - in the Gulf
of Riga (No. 1), in the East Gotland Basin (No. 2) to the west of Saaremaa and
in the North Sea Basin (No. 3). The choice of the spatial location of wind energy
development areas was based on the location of protected areas and was taken
as an exclusionary factor in order to exclude direct impacts on protected areas
(e.g. physical changes to the seabed (including habitat destruction) and changes
in waves, water movement, etc.). Protected areas have been established to
preserve Estonia's natural wealth, and therefore human activities that cause
environmental disturbances in these territories are either restricted or even
prohibited. The selection of the spatial location of wind energy development
areas was based on the location of the protected areas and was taken as an
exclusionary factor in order to exclude direct impacts on the protected areas
(e.g. physical changes to the seabed (including habitat destruction) and changes
in waves, water movement, etc.). The protected areas have been established to
preserve Estonia's natural wealth and therefore human activities that caus e
environmental disturbances in these territories are either restricted or even
prohibited. During the planning process the planning of the wind energy
development area no. 3 (northwest of Saaremaa) has been removed. The
planning of the area was abandoned for the reasons of nature conservation,
among other things: the area was partly located in an important sensitive area
of Hülgerahu as an area for winter stopping and spring migration of waterfowl,
and was therefore with high development risk.
However, the wind energy development areas designated by the plan may have
indirect impacts on adjacent parts of the protected area (suspended matter
spread, noise during construction, etc). The potential for indirect impacts on
birds, including protected nature objects related to bird protection, is largely
minimized by site selection at the strategic planning level. In addition to
excluding the development of wind energy in nature reserves, the development
of wind energy in other marine areas is also directed to the areas of low
ornithological value (see also Chapters 4.2.2 and Figure 4.2.2 -4). To this end,
an analysis of bird staging areas and migration routes was carried out during
the maritime spatial planning process, the results of which indicate that the
planned wind energy development areas 1 and 2, as well as the innovation area,
are located outside the sensitive marine areas for birds.
However, the more specific impacts related to the wind energy development
areas need to be addressed in the subsequent stages of wind energy development
in the context of specific projects, once the exact location, volume, technology,
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 111
etc. of the proposed activity has been identified and mitigation measures should
be implemented, if necessary (e.g. required buffer zones). Here it is appropriate
to highlight the environmental aspects related to the planning of wind energy
development areas for nationally protected natural objects without international
protection (including the proposed natural objects which are provided for in
EELIS, i.e. the table below does not include the proposal to establish two
protected areas in the EEZ discussed above).
Table 4.2.6-2 Impact of wind energy development areas on national (planned)
protected natural objects
Natural object
protected or
Conservation objective Impact assessment
planned to be
protected
Apollo Shallow The conservation objective is to protect
Nature Reserve Apollo shallow and its biota; habitat The plan envisages the wind energy
types: underwater sandy shoals (1110) and
development areas to be more than 100
reefs (1170); species: long-tailed duck
(KLO1000674) km and these will not endanger the Apollo
(Clangula hyemalis), little gull (Larus
shallow or its conservation values.
minutus), black grouse (Melanitta nigra)
and woodpecker (Somateria mollissima).
The conservation objective is to protect
marine and coastal habitats, important
Uhtju Nature staging and nesting sites for birds and The plan envisages the wind energy
Reserve protected species: habitat types reefs development areas to be more than 200
(1170) and small islands and islets km away and Uhtju Nature Reserve will
(KLO1000017) (1620); species: ringed seal (Phoca not be affected.
hispida) and gray seal (Halichoerus
grypus); razorbill (Alca torda).
The conservation objective is to protect The wind energy development areas 1 and
marine and coastal habitats: reefs (1170), 2 envisaged in the plan are adjacent to the
primary embankments with annual Conservation Area. The location of wind
vegetation (1210), coastal meadows (1630 areas has taken into account both the
*), small islands and islets (1620), sandy location of bird protection areas and the
beaches with permanent vegetation location of sensitive sea areas for birds /
(1640), gray dunes (2130 *), blue pearl migratory birds, which is the main option
communities (6410) and species: gray seal for minimizing impacts at the strategic
(Halichoerus grypus). level. Kura kurgu Conservation Area as an
important stopping place / migration area
Kura kurgu Bird species whose habitats are protected for birds will be preserved and the most
are: red-throated diver (Gavia stellata), important flight corridors to the
Conservation
diver (Gavia arctica), cormorant Conservation Area will be preserved.
Area
(Phalacrocorax carbo), mute swan
(Cygnus olor), small swan (Cygnus The mitigation measures set out in the
(KLO2000316)
columbianus bewickii), gray goose (Anser impact assessment report and the
anser), white-cheeled eagle (Branta implementation of the conditions and
leucopsis), blackbird (Branta guidelines set in the planning solution
bernicla), wigeon (Anas have adverse effects on the Conservation
penelope), common teal (Anas Area of Kura kurk. When developing wind
crecca), mallard (Anas energy development areas, the potential
platyrhynchos), pintail (Anas acuta), environmental impacts of the location
Northern shoveler (Anas and/or technical solutions proposed in the
clypeata), gadwall (Anas project solution should be further
strepera), greater scaup (Aythya considered and assessed in the
marila), common eider (Somateria authorization process, including the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 112
Natural object
protected or
Conservation objective Impact assessment
planned to be
protected
mollissima), long-tailed duck (Clangula effects on the birds of the Conservation
hyemalis), velvet scoter (Melanitta Area.
fusca), common goldeneye (Bucephala
clangula), lesser kestrel (Mergus The maritime spatial plan foresees
albellus), red-breasted merganser (Mergus possible submarine cable locations that
serrator), common merganser (Mergus will also pass through the Conservation
merganser), pied avocet (Recurvirostra Area. The selection of the location of the
avosetta), common ringed plover cables avoids passing through the habitats
(Charadrius hiaticula), grey plover to be protected. According to the data of
(Pluvialis squatarola), red knot (Calidris the current conservation management plan
canutus), little stint (Calidris of 2017-2026 of Kura kurgu Conservation
minuta), alpina (Calidris alpina), bar- Area, Vesitükimaa Conservation Area,
tailed godwit (Limosa lapponica), spotted Vesitükimaa islets and Vesitükimaa
redshank (Tringa erythropus), ruddy permanent habitat of gray seal, the
turnstone (Arenaria interpres), razorbill planned cable corridors do not pass the
(Alca torda) and black guillemot habitat types of the area, including the
(Cepphus grylle). only marine habitat, reefs and these will
remain as they are. The potential
disruptive effects of the proposed cables
on the gray seal are expected to be
temporary and not significantly different
from the usual shipping disruption.
Adverse effects on the gray seal are not
expected.
In case of specific development projects,
the locations of the cable corridors may
change and their impact will need to be
assessed in the context of the
authorization procedure, together with the
design of the wind farms. At the level of
authorization, suitable locations,
technologies, etc. of the cables should be
found that do not have an adverse effect
on the protected natural objects.
The proposal to establish the protected
area (for the extension of the existing
Krassi Conservation Area and The plan envisages wind energy
Krassi Nature
establishment of Nature Reserve) was development areas to be more than 140
Reserve
made in 2010 with the aim of ensuring the km away and the planned Krassi Nature
(proposed)
integrity of Krassi marine area in the Gulf Reserve will not be affected.
of Finland and the preservation of
habitats.
The proposal to establish the protected
area was made in 2012 with the aim of The plan envisages wind energy
Kõpu Marine
preserving the unique ecosystem of the development areas to be more than 140
Reserve
Kõpu coastal sea, which is an important km away and the planned Kõpu marine
(proposed)
bottleneck for birds on the eastern reserve will not be affected.
Atlantic migration route.
Laidevahe The protected area will be extended, in
The wind energy development area no. 1
Nature Reserve particular, to the Conservation Area
planned by the plan is located
(PLO1001325, adjacent to the protected area and and to a
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 113
Natural object
protected or
Conservation objective Impact assessment
planned to be
protected
proposed small extent outside the sea. Conservation approximately 25 km south of the
extension of the objectives are still related to, among other proposed Nature Reserve in Laidevahe.
protected area) things, bird protection.
When developing the wind energy
development area, the possibility that the
Nature Reserve is expanding should be
taken into account, and it is necessary to
proceed from the protection regime of the
area in force at a particular time. It is
necessary to specify the environmental
impacts of the location and/or technical
solutions proposed in the project solution
in the process of the authorization
procedure and, if necessary, to develop
the mitigation measures.
Neugrund The proposal to establish the protected
The plan envisages the wind energy
Nature Reserve area was made in 2010 primarily with the
development areas to be more than 140
(PLO1000854, aim of protecting the Neugrund
km away and the proposed Neugrund
proposed nature underwater crater, bird staging areas and
Nature Reserve will not be affected.
reserve) marine habitat types.
The proposal to establish the protected The plan envisages the wind energy
area (expansion of the existing Paljassaare development areas to be more than 150
Paljassaare
Conservation Area and establishment of a km away and the proposed Paljassaare
Nature Reserve
Nature Reserve) was made in 2009 Nature Reserve will not be affected.
(proposed)
primarily with the aim of protecting birds
and marine habitats.
The proposal to establish the protected
Mustjõe Beach area was made in 2012 with the aim of The plan envisages the wind energy
Landscape ensuring the favourable status of development areas to be more than 160
Protection Area protected animal species and habitat km away and the proposed Landscape
(proposed) types, preserving the stands of the historic Protection Area will not be affected.
manor park and ponds of the spa and
ensuring the preservation of the migration
corridor.
The plan envisages the wind energy
development area no. 2 adjacent to the
area of the planned extension of the
national park.
The proposal to expand the national park
Vilsandi When developing the wind energy
was made in 2012 with the aim of
National park development area, the possibility that the
preserving the integrity of the offshore
(proposed National Park is expanding should be
shallows in the west of Saaremaa and
extension of the
ensuring the integrity of the habitat of the taken into account, and it is necessary to
protected area) proceed from the protection regime of the
area's marine life and birds.
area in force at a particular time. It is
necessary to specify the environmental
impacts of the location and/or technical
solutions proposed in the project solution
in the process of the authorization
procedure and, if necessary, to develop
mitigation measures.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 114
With regard to aquaculture, the plan gives priority to the balanced dev elopment
of the sector in naturally suitable places. In terms of environmental impact
aquaculture clearly distinguishes between the environmental impacts of the
classic (fish farming) and innovative (algae and shellfish farming) aquaculture
sectors, which are also the basis for targeting marine use as to the protected
areas. The main impacts of fish farms on the marine environment, given the so -
called known technology (as the worst technological scenario), are the release
of nutrients and favouring of eutrophication, which results in the disturbance
of the natural balance and, in the worst case, the destruction of biota and
habitats close to farming.
The impact of the fish farm can be mitigated by the selection of appropriate
location, technology (nutrient neutral), scale and intensity of farming
(described in more detail in Chapter 4.1.5). Based on the precautionary
principle, maritime spatial planning directs the establishment of fish farms
outside the protected natural areas, as well as to deeper and more open marine
areas, where nutrients are better dispersed and the impacts on the conservation
values and the environment have been minimized.
One area (currently known as Kolgi shallow marine reserve) has been proposed
as a possible new nature reserve in the EEZ, currently overlapping with wind
energy development area no. 2 in this plan. The proposal for the establishment
of the protected area also includes the description of the restrictions proposed
for the protection, which stipulates that the following should be restricted in
the protected area: construction (all renewable energy installations: wind and
gravity-based foundations for wind turbines, high voltage DC and AC cables;
communication cables); extraction of mineral resources; dredging and
dumping; fishing with gear that damages the seabed; any disturbance to the
seabed. The description of the restrictions finally proposed for protection
will become clear during the process of establishing protected areas, which
will take place beyond the maritime spatial planning process.
The proposals for the establishment of two marine reserves in EEZ have been
made and are being processed. Therefore, it would be reasonable to refrain from
describing the proposed restrictions on the protected area due to the economic
exploitation of these areas until the end of the respective procedures.
In the degree of accuracy of the maritime spatial plan, the potential for adverse
effects on protected natural objects have been minimized. When implementing
activities under the licensing process, it is possible to specify the impact and,
if necessary, to apply environmental measures.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. The two areas have been proposed in the EEZ as potential new nature
reserves. The proposals for the establishment of two marine reserves in
EEZ have been made and are being processed. Therefore, it would be
reasonable to refrain from describing the proposed restrictions on the
protected area due to the economic exploitation of these areas until the
end of the respective procedures.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 115
2. The development of the wind energy development area should take into
account the possibility that Laidevahe Nature Reserve or Vilsandi
National Park will expand and it is necessary to follow the protection
regime of the area in force at a particular time. It is necessary to specify
the environmental impacts of the location and/or technical solutions
proposed in the project solution in the process of the authorization
procedure and, if necessary, to develop mitigation measures.
3. The more specific impacts of wind energy development areas sh ould be
addressed in the subsequent stages of wind energy development in the
framework of specific projects, once the exact location, volume,
technology, etc. of the proposed activity has been determined and
mitigation measures (including necessary buffer zones) have been
implemented, if necessary.
4. In case of specific development projects the locations of the cable
corridors may change and their impact should be assessed in the context
of the authorization procedure, together with the design of the wind
farms. At the level of authorization suitable locations, technologies, etc.
of the cables should be found that do not have an adverse effect on the
protected natural objects.
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. The effectiveness of existing protected areas and measures in the marine
area has not been evaluated, and the coherence of the network has not
been evaluated or taken into account. This would require a
comprehensive analysis of a separate marine area under the leadership
of those responsible for nature reserves and Natura 2000 network sites,
i.e. the Ministry of the Environment and Environmental Board.
4.2.7 Affect on terrain
The impact on the landscape can be assessed both through human perception
(so-called social impact caused by visual change, see Chapter 4.4.1.6) and as
an impact on the natural environment.
The following chapter focuses on the landscape in a natural geographical view.
Landscape as an ecological phenomenon, a geosystem, has developed in the
interrelationships of natural parts (seabed, water system, vegetation). The
landscape in this approach is the natural geographical basis for many
components of the natural environment. Landscapes, in turn, are based on
landforms with their own matter. Landscapes are characterized by their constant
change, both by themselves and by human influence. Until now, the majority
of scientific literature on landscapes and also practice has focused on terrestrial
landscapes. One of the basic works of Estonian natural geography, I.Arold's
"Estonian landscapes" (UT Publishing House 2005), also focuses on terrestrial
landscapes.
Marine landscape ecology is a young discipline, where the first serious
scientific review of the application of research methods and concepts was
published only in 2017. Marine landscape ecology is based on the principles
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 116
known from landscape ecology, exploring places and locations, their
composition, configuration and relationships that correlate with the region's
ecosystems and biodiversity. The focus is on the links between ecological
processes and spatial patterns in marine environments. At the same time marine
landscapes may not only denote the physical geography of the underwater
landscape, but also describe the change in the chemical composition of the
water column. These so-called chemical landscapes play an important role in
the ecology of pelagic organisms. Most of the ecology of marine landscapes
sees the sea as a mosaic of places that offer different habitats 95.
The important topics of landscape ecology are the coherence and fragmentation
of landscapes, boundary dynamics, as well as connections with resource
management 96. These issues are also transferable to the ecology of marine
landscapes. However, there are also views that, as the dynamics and
characteristics of marine areas differ so much from those of terrestrial
landscapes, analogues with the ecology of terrestrial landscapes should be
avoided.
Until now, the prevailing understanding is that although the marine
environment can be considered more homogeneous in terms of landscape, it is
also characterized by the gaps or unevenness of marine landscapes in
environmental conditions, both in time and space. The gaps are affected by both
internal and external factors, i.e. marine landscapes change as a result of both
natural processes and human impact, and it is often very difficult to make a
clear distinction between the causes of change. Minimizing the potential
fragmentation of marine landscapes, "preserving blue corridors", will help to
ensure the sustainability of habitats and biota.
Impact of the MSP
The landscape as a geosystem is formed by the interconnections of parts of
nature and is also a component that affects them. All parts of the natural
environment in interaction mentioned in Chapters 4.1 and 4.2 of this report are
therefore ecologically relevant to the landscape. Fundamental changes and
significant adverse effects on a natural component can also affect landscapes.
The most significant influencing factors may be the uses of the sea, the
formation or intensification of which is provided for in the planning solution,
and which may also affect the landforms during which the physical intervention
in the seabed environment takes place.
In particular, the potential influencing factor is the offshore wind farms that the
maritime spatial plan envisages. Extraction and dumping of mineral resources
and infrastructure on the seabed may also have an impact. From an ecological
point of view, an important issue is coherence, avoiding fragmentation and
isolation in the areas sensitive to biota.
95 Wu, J (2017) Seascape ecology and landscape ecology:Distinct, related and synergistic in
Pittman, SJ. Seascape Ecology.
96 Wiens and Moss (2005) in Pittman, SJ. Seascape Ecology.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 117
In the course of the impact assessment of the maritime spatial plans of the
neighbouring countries, the impact of the planning solution on the marine
landscapes has not been dealt with in the natural geographical sense. In the
scientific literature the ecological perspective of marine landscapes has become
a more active research area during recent years, especially through the issue of
biota and habitats (see Chapter 4.2.5). The rapidly developing technological
capability for the study of the marine environment suggests that in the near
future it will be possible to better distinguish the role of various impact factors
and provide more accurate assessments of the planned activities.
The Estonian maritime spatial planning solution has been developed by taking
the natural components and the impact on them into account throughout.
Additional conditions have been set for the protection of biota, which, for
example, provide instructions for the extraction and dumping of mineral
resources to avoid shallow sea areas, fish spawning grounds, protected natural
objects as the location. The areas suitable for the development of wind energy
have been selected to avoid spatial overlaps with natural values. The areas
sensitive to birds and important migration corridors for birds and bats, as well
as marine patterns and key habitats for ringed and gray seals, have been taken
into account.
The impact on fish has been analyzed, by setting additional conditions and the
obligation to carry out research at the level of the superficies licence in order
to ensure the conservation of fish stocks and to avoid the blocking of fish
migration. In this way the principle of preserving sensitive areas, which can
also be considered as 'blue corridors', has been applied, which can also be
expressed in the importance of landscape coherence.
The assessment of the impacts on the various natural components pr ovided in
Chapters 4.1 and 4.2 of this report concludes that the implementation of the
Maritime spatial Plan does not anticipate the occurrence of significant adverse
effects by implementing the envisaged environmental measures and
recommendations at the authorization level. Due to the above the impact of the
implementation of the plan on the landscapes cannot be significant either. The
impacts may occur in the interaction of different natural components, but as the
predominant use of different marine uses is already in place, the
implementation of the plan is not expected to result in significant adverse
effects. Landscapes, including seascapes, are constantly changing, which is
why it is important to follow the action plan for implementation of the plan,
marine strategy and other monitoring measures that will be set with the strategic
development documents and the ones already functioning.
4.3 EVALUATION OF NATURA 2000
In addition to the nationally protected natural objects, the planned area
includes, in whole or in part, marine Natura 2000 sites. Natura 2000 is a
Europe-wide network of protected areas which aims to ensure the conservation
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 118
of rare or endangered birds, animals and plants and their habitats, or to restore,
if necessary, the favorable status of threatened species and habitats across
Europe. Natura 2000 sites of community importance and special protection
areas have been designated pursuant to Council of Europe Directives 92/43 /
EEC and 2009/147/EC. Possible direct and indirect impact on Natura sites have
to be taken into account when planning activities with the plans .
The assessment of Natura is a process carried out in accordance with Article 6
(3) and (4) of the Habitats Directive 92/43/EEC. The assessment outlined in
this work will be based on the following guidance documents :
▪ „ Evaluation of plans and projects that have a significant impact on
Natura 2000 sites. Methodological guidance for the interpretation of
Article 6 (3) and (4) of the Habitats Directive“ 97;
▪ Kutsar, R.; Eschbaum, K. and Aunapuu, A. 2019. Guidelines for carrying
out Natura assessment in the implementation of Article 6 (3) of the
Habitats Directive in Estonia. (Environmental Board, 2020) 98;
▪ „Wind energy developments and Natura 2000“ (European Union,
2011) 99;
▪ The Wildlife Sensitivity Mapping Manual. Practical guidance for
renewable energy planning in the European Union (European Union,
2020) 100.
The Natura assessment begins with the Natura pre-assessment phase, which
aims to identify and determine the potential impact of a project or plan on a
Natura 2000 site and to assess whether it is possible to objectively conclude
that potential adverse impacts are excluded. As Maritime Spatial Plan
provides already for one of the new uses of the marine area for the
development of wind energy, the likely impact on Natura 2000 sites is
expected, and an appropriate assessment of Natura has been carried out.
In the case of plans with a higher level of generalization (as is the case with
maritime spatial planning), Natura assessments will be carried out with the
required level of precision, having regard to the degre e of accuracy of the
strategic planning document, which should allow identification of
97 https://envir.ee/media/1376/download
98 Kutsar, R.; Eschbaum, K. ja Aunapuu, A. 2019. Guidelines for carrying out Natura
assessment in the implementation of Article 6 (3) of the Habitats Directive in Estonia.
Client: Environmental Board. https://envir.ee/media/1353/download
99https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/65364c77-b5b8-4ab6-919d-
8f4e3c6eb5c2
100 THE WILDLIFE SENSITIVITY MAPPING MANUAL. Practical guidance for renewable
energy planning in the European Union; https://circabc.europa.eu/sd/a/6a1d06ae-ef34-478a-
a322-006b09079efb/20200429%20WSM%20Manual.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 119
sensitive/threatened areas and conflicts/risks that need to be considered in
future planning stages 101, 102.
In the following, the impact of the Estonian MSP solution on th e Natura 2000
network areas will be assessed according to the level of accuracy of the
Maritime Spatial Plan.
▪ Information on the planned activity
The implementation of the Estonian maritime spatial plan and the uses of the
maritime space covered in the plan based on their spatial location, established
guidelines and conditions are considered as the planned activities in this
assessment. The explanatory memorandum of the plan provides an accurate
overview of the planned activities.
▪ Characterization of the Natura sites affected by the proposed
activity
The total area of Natura 2000 network areas in the Estonian marine area is 6787
km², which is 18.6% of the total marine area. Eighty -seven sites of community
importance and 27 special protection areas overlap with the Estonian marine
area to a greater or lesser extent. However, 31 of these sites of community
importance and 21 special protection areas have conservation objectives
directly related to the marine environment, as well as overlapping with the
Estonian maritime spatial planning area. Figure 4.3-1 illustrates the location of
the Natura special protection areas in the proposed marine area, and an
overview of the areas is provided in Table 4.3-1. The table lists the areas of
Natura sites that are within the planning area and lists marine habitats/species
for conservation purposes.
101
Kutsar, R.; Eschbaum, K. ja Aunapuu, A. 2019. Guidelines for carrying out Natura
evaluation in the implementation of Article 6 (3) of the Habitats Directive in Estonia.
Client: Environmental Board.
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/KKO/KMH/kemu_natura_hindamise_juhendi_uuend
us_2020.pdf
102
https://www.gov.si/assets/ministrstva/MOP/Dokumenti/CPVO/Usposabljanje/7nov19_assess
ment_off_plans.pdf
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 120
Figure 4.3-1 Location of Natura 2000 sites
Tabel 4.3-1 Natura 2000 network Special Protection Areas (LoA) and Site of
Community Importance (LiA) are fully or partially covered by the Estonian
maritime spatial plan territory
Area in
Name and Code the sea Purpose fo protection 103
(km²)
Allirahu Site of Marine habitat types (1 pc): reefs (1170).
Community Importance 20 Marine species (1 pc): Gray seal.
EE0040402 + 1 coastal and land -based habitat type.
Gretagrundi Site of
Community Importance 147 Marine habitat types (2): sandbanks (1110) and reefs (1170).
EE0040500
Kahtla-Kübassaare Site Marine habitat types (5): sandbanks (1110), sandy and muddy foreshore (1140), coastal lagoons
of Community Importance 103 (*1150), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs (1170)
EE0040412 + 15 coastal and land -based habitat types.
Kahtla-Kübassaare
Special Protection Area 103 39 bird species.
EE0040412
Karala-Pilguse Site of
Marine habitat types (1 pc): coastal lagoons (1150).
Community Importance 14
+ 17 coastal and land -based habitat types and 1 species.
EE0040414
103
List of Natura 2000 sites to be submitted to the European Commission in accordance with the
order ( https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/304042017006?leiaKehtiv )
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 121
Area in
Name and Code the sea Purpose fo protection 103
(km²)
Karala-Pilguse Special
Protection Area 14 11 bird species.
EE0040414
Kasti Bay Site of Marine habitat types (5 pcs): sandbanks (1110), sandy and muddy foreshore (1140), coastal
Community Importance 27 lagoons (*1150), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs (1170)
EE0040418 + 10 coastal and land -based habitat types.
Kasti Bay Special
Protection Area 27 8 bird species.
EE0040418
Kaugatoma-Lõu Site of
Marine habitat types (4 pcs): sandy and muddy foreshores (1140), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs
Community Importance
43 (1170)
+ 13 coastal and land -based habitat types and 1 species.
EE0040441
Kaugatoma-Lõu Bay
Special Protection Area 43 15 bird species.
EE0040441
Kaunispe Site of
Marine habitat types (1 pc): coastal lagoons (*1150).
Community Importance 0.02
+ 7 coastal and land -based habitat types.
EE0040420
Kerju Site of Community Marine species (1 pc): Gray seal.
0.7
Importance EE0040421 + 1 coastal and land -based habitat type.
Kolga Bay Site of Marine habitat types (3 pcs): underwater sandbanks (1110), coastal lagoons (*1150), reefs (1170).
Community Importance 22 Marine species (1 pc): Gray seal.
EE0010171 + 11 coastal and land -based habitat types.
Kolga Bay Special
Protection Area 22 14 bird species.
EE0010171
Koorunõmme Site of
Community Importance 21 + 16 coastal and land -based habitat types and 2 species.
EE0040428
Koorunõmme Special
Protection Area 21 3 bird species.
EE0040428
Marine habitat types (1 pc): reefs (1170).
Krassi Site of Community
0.8 Marine species (1 pc): Gray seal.
Importance EE0010154
+ 1 coastal and land -based habitat type.
Irben Strait Special
Protection Area 1916 38 bird species.
EE0040434
Marine habitat types (4 pcs): underwater sandbanks (1110), coastal lagoons (*1150), wide shallow
Küdema Bay Site of
bays (1160), reefs (1170).
Community Importance 40
Marine species (1 pc): river lamprey.
EE0040432
+ 15 coastal and land -based habitat types and 3 species.
Küdema Bay Special
Protection Area 40 12 bird species.
EE0040432
Marine habitat types (5): underwater sandbanks (1110), sandy and muddy foreshores
Lahemaa Site of
(1140), coastal lagoons (* 1150), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs (1170).
Community Importance 269
Marine species (4 pcs): spined loach, European bullhead, river lamprey, salmon.
EE0010173
+ 43 coastal and land-based habitat types and 8 species.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 122
Area in
Name and Code the sea Purpose fo protection 103
(km²)
Lahemaa Special
Protection Area 269 65 bird species.
EE0010173
Laulasmaa Site of
Marine habitat types (1 pc): coastal lagoons (1150).
Community Importance 0.02
+ 6 coastal and land-based habitat types and 1 species.
EE0010122
Letipea Site of Marine habitat types (5 pcs): underwater sandbanks (1110), sandy and muddy foreshores
Community Importance 5 (1140), wide shallow bays (1160).
EE0060231 + 4 coastal and land-based habitat types.
Mullutu-Loode Site of
Marine habitat types (1 pc): coastal lagoons (1150).
Community Importance 0.1
+ 14 coastal and land-based habitat types and 3 species.
EE0040443
Mullutu-Loode
Special Protection
7.4 34 bird species.
Area
EE0040444
Marine habitat types (5): underwater sandbanks (1110), sandy and muddy foreshores
Nõva-Osmussaare Site
(1140), coastal lagoons (* 1150), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs (1170).
of Community 219
Marine species (2 pcs): European bullhead, river lamprey
Importance EE0040201
+ 28 coastal and land-based habitat types and 2 species.
Nõva-Osmussaare
Special Protection 219 17 bird species.
Area EE0040201
Pakri Site of
Marine habitat types (5 pcs): underwater sandbanks (1110), river estuaries (1130),
Community
173 coastal lagoons (*1150), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs (1170).
Importance
+ 17 coastal and land-based habitat types and 5 species.
EE0010129
Pakri Special
Protection Area 173 18 bird species.
EE0010129
Paljassaare Special
Protection Area 1.4 44 bird species.
EE0010170
Pammana Site of
Marine habitat types (1 pc): coastal lagoons (1150).
Community Importance 9
+ 10 coastal and land-based habitat types.
EE0040452
Prangli Site of
Marine habitat types (2 pc): coastal lagoons (*1150) and reefs (1170).
Community Importance 9
+ 11 coastal and land-based habitat types.
EE0010126
Riksu Site of
Marine habitat types (1 pc): coastal lagoons (1150).
Community Importance 17
+ 11 coastal and land-based habitat types.
EE0040461
Riksu Coast Special
Protection Area 17 8 bird species.
EE0040461
Ruhnu Nature
Marine habitat types (1 pc): wide shallow bays (1160).
Conservation Area 0.9
+ 14 coastal and land-based habitat types.
EE0040462
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 123
Area in
Name and Code the sea Purpose fo protection 103
(km²)
Siiksaare-Oessaare Marine habitat types (5): underwater sandbanks (1110), sandy and muddy foreshores
Site of Community 18 (1140), coastal lagoons (* 1150), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs (1170).
Importance EE0040469 + 14 coastal and land-based habitat types.
Siiksaare-Oessaare
bays Special
18 41 bird species.
Protection Area
EE0040469
Sutu Bay Site of Marine habitat types (3pcs): sandy and muddy foreshores (1140), coastal lagoons
Community Importance 17 (*1150), wide shallow bays (1160)
EE0040472 + 10 coastal and land-based habitat types.
Sutu Bay Special
Protection Area 17 9 bird species.
EE0040472
Suurupi Site of
Community Importance 0.1 + 12 coastal and land-based habitat types and 2 species.
EE0010140
Tagamõisa Site of Marine habitat types (2 pcs): coastal lagoons (*1150), reefs (1170).
Community Importance 85 Marine species (1 pc): Gray seal.
EE0040476 + 25 coastal and land-based habitat types and 3 species.
Tagamõisa Special
Protection Area 85 20 bird species.
EE0040476
Toolse Site of Marine habitat types (2 pcs): underwater sandbanks (1110), wide shallow bays (1160).
Community Importance 3 Marine species (1 pc): river lamprey.
EE0060271 + 5 coastal and land-based habitat types and 1 species.
Toolse Special
Protection Area 3 6 bird species.
EE0060271
Uhtju Site of Marine habitat types (1 pc): reefs (1170).
Community Importance 24 Marine species (2 pcs): Gray seal, ringed seal.
EE0060220 + 1 coastal and land-based habitat type.
Vaindloo Special
Protection Area 0.7 6 bird species.
EE0060270
Vesitükimaa Site of Marine habitat types (1 pc): reefs (1170).
Community Importance 8 Marine species (1 pc): Gray seal.
EE0040490 + 11 coastal and land-based habitat types and 1 species.
Marine habitat types (4): underwater sandbanks (1110), sandy and muddy foreshores
Vilsandi Site of
(1140), coastal lagoons (*1150), wide shallow bays (1160).
Community Importance 123
Marine species (2 pc): Gray seal, river lamprey.
EE0040496
+ 14 coastal and land-based habitat types and 4 species.
Vilsandi Special
Protection Area 123 13 bird species.
EE0040496
Marine habitat types (3 pcs): underwater sandbanks (1110), coastal lagoons (*1150),
Väike Site of
wide shallow bays (1160).
Community Importance 140
Marine species (1 pc): ringed seal.
EE0040486
+ 15 coastal and land-based habitat types and 3 species.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 124
Area in
Name and Code the sea Purpose fo protection 103
(km²)
Marine habitat types (6 pcs): underwater sandbanks (1110), river estuaries (1130), sandy
and muddy foreshores (1140), coastal lagoons (*1150), wide shallow bays (1160), reefs
Väinameri Site of
(1170).
Community Importance 2106
Marine species (6 pcs): Gray seal, ringed seal, spined loach, European bullhead, river
EE0040002
lamprey, European weatherfish.
+ 32 coastal and land-based habitat types and 17 species.
Väinameri Special
Protection Area 2255 76 bird species.
EE0040001
▪ The relevance of the proposed activity to the management of
protection
The proposed activities in the Maritime Spatial Plan are neither related nor
necessary to the management of any Natura 2000 site and do not contribute
directly or indirectly to the conservation objectives of the sites .
▪ Assessment of likely adverse impacts on the integrity of Natura
sites and achievement of conservation objectives and design of
mitigation measures
The spatial solution of the plan and the guidelines and conditions set out in the
Plan are the basis for the prediction of the impact of t he uses of the sea on the
Natura 2000 network.
The principle of not targeting marine uses to Natura 2000 sites have been
applied in the development of the Maritime Spatial Plan. For many uses
(fisheries, aquaculture, maritime transport, maritime rescue, po llution control,
border control, seabed infrastructure, maritime tourism and recreation, nature
conservation, marine culture, national defense, mineral resources and
dumping), the Maritime Spatial Plan does not foresee significant spatial
changes and sets out the conditions and guidelines for the next steps of the
proposed action. Targeting activities outside Natura 2000 sites will help
prevent potential direct impact (e.g., physical alteration or destruction of
habitats, etc.) onsite conservation objectives. The table below gives an estimate
of the impact of the implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan by activity .
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 125
Table 4.3-2 Forecast of the impact of the planned activities on Natura 2000 sites
Design of mitigation
The use of the measures and
Content designed by the plan Appropriate assessment of Natura
marine area recommendations for next
steps
Aquaculture (fish The Maritime Spatial Plan does not designate spatial In terms of environmental impact, aquaculture clearly distinguishes In the case of planning for fish farms and/or
farming; algae and areas suitable for fish farming and algae and shellfish between the environmental impacts of the classical (fish farming) and algae and shellfish farming, the
shellfish farming) farming, as the technology of offshore fish farms and innovative (algae and shellfish farming) aquaculture sectors, which are environmental impacts of the location
algae and shellfish farming is still in the development also the basis for directing the use of marine areas regarding protected and/or technical solutions proposed in the
stage and therefore, the designation of suitable spatial areas, including the Natura special protection areas. The main impacts of project solution must be specified in the
areas may unduly restrict the development of a blue fish farms on the marine environment are the release of nutrients and the licensing process and a Natura assessment
economy that respects environmental conditions. The promotion of eutrophication, which can lead to changes in the natural must be carried out if necessary. Adverse
establishment of fish farms and algae and shellfish balance. At the same time, shellfish and algae farming can remove impact on the conservation objectives of the
farms in unsuitable areas determined by the planning nutrients from the marine environment and their impact is rather to reduce Natura 2000 site must be ruled out during
solution must be avoided. The development of fish the level of eutrophication. The impact of the farm can be mitigated the implementation of the proposed activity
farms and algae and shellfish farming is guided through appropriate site selection. The Maritime Spatial Plan directs the and as a result of the Natura assessment
through guidelines and conditions. One of the establishment of fish farms outside protected natural areas, including (and through the implementation of the
conditions set out in the plan is that the impacts Natura 2000 network areas, as well as into deeper and more open sea mitigation measures proposed therein).
associated with the establishment of a fish farm should areas, where nutrients are better dispersed and impacts on conservation
be an acceptable burden for the state of the marine values and the environment are minimal - therefore, the so-called
environment, and environmental measures should be unsuitable areas for fish farming have been designated.
implemented if necessary.
In the level of precision of the Maritime Spatial Plan, the chances of
adverse impacts on the Natura special protection areas and their protection
objectives have been minimized through the conditions and guidelines set
for the implementation of the Plan. When implementing activities within
the licensing process, it is necessary to specify the impacts and, if
necessary, to implement environmental measures.
Maritime transport The Maritime Spatial Plan reflects the fairways As the implementation of the Plan does not change the existing situation, -
published in the navigation information and no impact on Natura sites is expected during the implementation of the
determines the water traffic areas on the basis of the Plan.
main ship traffic directions and the current traffic
density.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 126
Design of mitigation
The use of the measures and
Content designed by the plan Appropriate assessment of Natura
marine area recommendations for next
steps
Maritime rescue, The plan does not envisage any changes. The plan does not envisage any changes in these areas and therefore the -
pollution control, implementation of the plan is not expected to have an impact on Natura
state border guarding sites.
Energy production The Plan identifies areas suitable for the development The exclusion of spatial overlaps of areas suitable for the development ofThe planning solution has been adjusted in
(wind energy, of wind energy, which, among other things, take into wind energy with Natura sites excludes any direct impact on the accordance with the recommendations of
including cable account the areas of the Natura 2000 network: wind conservation objectives of Natura sites (see Figure 4.3-2). When planning the impact assessment report, including the
connections) energy development areas are directed outside Natura a wind farm near a Natura site, temporary/indirect impacts may also circumstances set out in the Natura
special protection areas and sites of community occur in some cases, e.g., temporary impacts on nature species/habitats assessment, as follows:
importance. during construction (suspended solids, disturbance) The temporary 1) In the planning process the planning of
impacts can be mitigated, if necessary, by clarifying the exact details ofwind energy development area no. 3 has
The Plan also determines conceptual locations of the the activity within the project solution. been abandoned
cable corridors for the connection of the planned wind , including for nature conservation reasons.
farms to the onshore transmission network, which The maritime spatial plan provides for the development of wind energy 2) According to the proposals for the
will be directed outside the Natura 2000 network outside the Site of Community Importance of the Natura 2000 network relocation of the submarine cable corridor,
areas if possible. and thus eliminates adverse effects within the areas. However, the mobile the impact on the conservation objectives
lifestyle of birds (e.g. migration) should also be taken into account, so of Natura 2000 Special Protection Areas
Natura assessments have been carried out in the that adverse effects (obstacles/deaths on migration, etc.) on Site of and Sites of Community Importance is
marine area for the conceptual locations of the cable Community Importance, their coherence and birds may in some cases excluded (see Figure 4.3-5).
corridors. The Plan determines the conditions occur in wind turbines planned outside Natura sites. At the level of 3) The measures proposed as a result of the
necessary for the establishment of connections on the strategic planning, in the process of selecting suitable areas for the Natura assessment as additional conditions/
land. development of wind energy, the main option for minimizing the impact guidelines in the explanatory memorandum
on birds and excluding significant adverse effects is the selection of to the planning solution to reduce the
location - the development of wind energy is favoured in areas of low impact on birds.
ornithological value, which helps to minimize the cumulative effects on
birds and maintain the coherence of Natura 2000 sites. When developing the wind energy
development areas, the environmental
As a result, an analysis of bird staging areas and migration routes was impacts associated with the location and /
carried out in the Maritime spatial Planning process (see Chapter 4.2.2 for or technical solutions proposed in the
more details), the results of which indicate that the planned wind energy project solution in the process of
development areas 1, 2 and the innovation area are located outside the sea authorization procedure should be
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 127
Design of mitigation
The use of the measures and
Content designed by the plan Appropriate assessment of Natura
marine area recommendations for next
steps
areas sensitive to birds (i.e. which, according to current knowledge, are specified and, if necessary, Natura
the most important areas for birds stopping on the high seas and / or assessment should be carried out. The
flying over the sea). The wind energy development area no. 3 (2019 adverse effects on the conservation
planning solution in the northwest of Saaremaa) was partly overlapping objectives of the Natura 2000 site should
with the Special Protection Area of Hülgerahu, which is particularly be ruled out during the implementation of
important as a spring and winter staging site for waterfowl (it is important the proposed activity and as a result of the
to ensure that migration is possible in order to ensure the coherence of the Natura assessment (and through the
Natura network). In the planning process, the planning of wind energy implementation of the mitigation measures
development area no. 3 has been abandoned, for reasons such as nature proposed therein).
conservation.
In the level of precision of the maritime
The first basic cable connections in the offshore area proposed in the plan spatial plan, the possibility of adverse
for wind farms (as of 2019) are planned mostly outside the Natura effects on the Natura sites and their
network areas. However, in some cases the cables were designed to pass conservation objectives through the
through Natura sites (Figure 4.3-2): conditions and guidelines set for the
• the cable corridor from the wind energy development area no. 1 to implementation of the planning solution is
Virtsu passes through Väinamere Site of Community Importance and excluded.
the Special Protection Area in the sea for a section of approx. 5 km;
• the perspective cable corridor from the wind energy development area
no. 2 to Latvia passes Kura kurgu Special Protection Area in a sea
section of approx. 28 km;
•. the cable corridor running from the wind energy development area no.
2 to the village of Jaagupi or Haapsi through Saaremaa to the coast of
Pärnumaa passes Kaugatoma-Lõu Site of Community Importance and
Kaugatoma-Lõu Bay Special Protection Area in a few hundred metres
long section and Kura kurgu Special Protection Area in the sea in the
section of about 17 km.
The impact of the construction of wind farms and associated cabling has
been appropriately discussed in more detail in the next subsection.
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 128
Design of mitigation
The use of the measures and
Content designed by the plan Appropriate assessment of Natura
marine area recommendations for next
steps
Seabed infrastructure The plan will take into account existing seabed The plan does not envisage any changes to the existing seabed
In the case of seabed infrastructure,
infrastructure but will not design any new infrastructure, and therefore no impact on Natura sites is expected when
planned on the basis of the conditions and
infrastructure (except for the proposed cable corridors the plan is implemented.
guidelines of the Plan, the impact of any
for the connection of wind energy development areas,
planned activity must be assessed in the
which will be discussed under wind energy
licensing process and adverse impacts on
development). Otherwise, the implementation of the
the conservation objectives of the Natura
plan will not entail any changes, and the status quo
2000 site must be ruled out.
will be maintained.
Sea tourism and The plan does not determine the development areas As the implementation of the plan will not change the existing situation, -
recreation for sea tourism and recreation. The implementation of no impact on Natura sites is expected when the plan is implemented.
the plan will not bring about any significant changes
but will set guidelines and conditions for the
development of the sector.
Protected natural No additional protected natural objects are planned in With regard to protected natural objects, the plan does not change the -
objects the Maritime Spatial Plan, although two new nature current situation at the moment, and therefore no impact on Natura sites
reserves have been proposed in the EEZ during the is expected during the implementation of the plan.
preparation of the Maritime spatial Plan (for more Taking into account the existing network of protected areas indirectly
details, see Chapter 4.2.6). The plan takes into contributes to the protection of Natura network sites, as the protection of
account the existing and planned network of protected Natura 2000 network sites is also ensured through the protection regime
areas. of national sites.
Marine culture Maritime spatial planning does not determine specific As the implementation of the plan will not change the existing situation, -
areas of marine culture due to the degree of no impact on Natura sites is expected when the plan is implemented.
generalization.
Cultural monuments With regard to cultural monuments, the maritime Preservation areas for underwater cultural heritage have been designed In the case of preservation areas for
spatial plan does not envisage any significant outside the Natura 2000 network to avoid the potential conflict with the underwater cultural heritage planned on the
changes. As a new use, the maritime spatial plan conservation objectives of Natura sites. At the strategic level, the basis of the conditions and guidelines of
envisages four areas for the preservation of potential impact on Natura 2000 sites is therefore ruled out. the Plan, the impacts associated with the
archaeological finds (wrecks) (in the area of Tallinn proposed activity must be assessed each
Bay, near Käsmu, Abruka and Ruhnu). time in the licensing process and adverse
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 129
Design of mitigation
The use of the measures and
Content designed by the plan Appropriate assessment of Natura
marine area recommendations for next
steps
impacts on the conservation objectives of
the Natura 2000 site must be ruled out.
National defense Maritime Spatial Plan takes into account the spatial As the implementation of the plan will not change the existing situation, In the case of national defense objects
needs of national defense, but the plan itself does not no impact on Natura sites is expected when the plan is implemented. planned on the basis of the conditions and
envisage changes, but sets guidelines and conditions guidelines of the Plan, the impacts
for the development of the area. associated with the proposed activity must
be assessed each time in the licensing
process and adverse impacts on the
conservation objectives of the Natura 2000
site must be ruled out.
Mineral resources No new deposits are planned with the Maritime As the implementation of the plan will not change the existing situation, When creating new deposits, preference
Spatial Plan, the important to ensure that existing no impact on Natura sites is expected when the plan is implemented. should be given to areas outside the Natura
mineral resources remain minable is pointed out. At the same time, the plan leaves room for the creation of new deposits. 2000 network. In carrying out the proposed
activity, the accompanying impacts must
be assessed and adverse impacts on the
conservation objectives of the Natura 2000
site must be ruled out.
Dumping No new dumping areas are planned with the maritime As the implementation of the plan will not change the existing situation, When creating new dumping areas,
spatial plan. Priority shall be given to the use of no impact on Natura sites is expected when the plan is implemented. preference should be given to areas outside
existing dumping areas. At the same time, the plan leaves room for the creation of new dumping the Natura 2000 network. In carrying out
areas. the proposed activity, the accompanying
impacts must be assessed and adverse
impacts on the conservation objectives of
the Natura 2000 site must be ruled out.
Permanent The plan does not envisage any new permanent As the implementation of the plan will not change the existing situation, In case of the permanent connection
Connections connections, and the existing situation is maintained. no impact on Natura sites is expected when the plan is implemented. planned on the basis of the conditions and
guidelines of the plan, the possible effects
of the proposed activity should be assessed
at the level of authorization and adverse
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report 130
Design of mitigation
The use of the measures and
Content designed by the plan Appropriate assessment of Natura
marine area recommendations for next
steps
effects on the conservation objectives of
the Natura 2000 site should be ruled out.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 131
Assessment of wind energy development areas, including perspective cable
connections
The areas suitable for the development of wind energy. The Maritime Spatial Plan
identifies two sea areas suitable for the development of wind energy (1 and 2) and also
one innovation area, the location of which also includes Natura 2000 network areas:
wind energy development areas are directed outside the protected Natura Site of
Community Importance and Special Protection Areas. The areas are also planned
outside the sensitive areas for birds, i.e. the most important st aging places and
migration areas. At the level of strategic planning the selection of a suitable location
for wind energy development areas therefore minimizes and eliminates the possibility
of significant adverse effects on the conservation objectives of Natura 2000 Site of
Community Importance. The impact assessments have been provided in Table 4.3-3 by
Natura Site of Community Importance and mitigation measures are identified to rule
out any possible adverse effects on the integrity and conservation values of the Natura
2000 network.
Cable connections. The maritime spatial plan determines the basic cable connections
of the proposed wind farms to the marine area with mainland. These proposed cable
corridors (200 m wide) indicate the possibilities for connecting wind farms and have
been assessed according to the level of detail of the strategic planning document. In
case of specific development projects the locations of the cable corridors may change
and their impact will need to be assessed in the context of the authorization procedure,
together with the design of the wind farms. The basic cable corridors in marine area in
the maritime spatial planning solution are generally located in such a way that they do
not pass through predominantly Natura 2000 sites, but this has not been possible in
certain locations. The proposed cable corridors pass through Väinamere Site of
Community Importance and Special Protection Areas , Kura kurgu Site of Community
Importance, Kaugatoma-Lõu Site of Community Importance and Kaugatoma-Lõu Site
of Community Importance (see Figure 4.3-2), so an appropriate Natura assessment will
be carried out for the key locations of the cable corridors.
The construction of the cables is expected to have a temporary and local impact.
Impacts are generally limited in time to the construction period and spatially to the
seabed, its habitats, vegetation and species in a specific location. Therefore, the natural
areas from whose territory the cables pass are located in the area affected by the
construction of the seabed cables. The impact of cables laid on the seabe d (or in the
ground) on birds is not significant and adverse effects on the conservation objectives
of the Natura site will be ruled out in the implementation of mitigation measures. The
estimates of the impact of cable corridors by Natura Special Protection Areas and Sites
of Community Importance have been provided in Table 4.3-3.
The conditions necessary for the establishment of cable connections have been
determined for the mainland as a proposal for a planning solution (cable corridors may
also be constructed outside principal locations if this does not have a significant
environmental impact). One of the conditions is that the adverse effects of the
construction and operation of both the overhead line and underground cable on the
conservation objectives of the Natura 2000 site should be ruled out by finding a
suitable location and technical solution. The maps show the main locations outside the
current planning area and the direct connection to the possible network connection
points. The maritime spatial plan also points out that it is expedient for local
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 132
governments to consider including in the comprehensive plan a condition that
infrastructure facilities related to offshore activities (e.g. cable connections of wind
farms) be planned in sensitive areas on land, if necessary, through public planning and
design processes.
Figure 4.3-2 Natura 2000 network and planned wind energy development areas with
possible proposed cable connections (red circles indicate the locations where the cable
passes through Special Protection Areas) (as of November 2019).
The impact of the development of wind energy and the construction of related
infrastructure is assessed by Natura sites in Table 4.3-3. As the development of wind
energy in the selected areas may have a larger spatial impact, the present assessment
is based on the precautionary principle and the impact on the Site of Community
Importance up to 30 km from the wind energy development areas has been assessed.
In addition, given the impact and nature of the cable -laying, Table 4.3-3 provides a
more detailed assessment of the impact on the Natura sites that potential cable
corridors pass through.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 133
Table 4.3-3 Potential adverse effects on Natura 2000 sites
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
The proposed wind energy development At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of During the development of the wind
area (no. 2) is located at a distance of the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant energy development areas, the potential
approximately 10 km from the Special adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site has been ruled out environmental impacts of the location
Protection Areaand thus there are no direct with the selection of location. There is no need to change the maritime and / or technical solutions proposed in
physical impacts on the conservation spatial plan solution. the project solution in the authorization
objectives of the area. application process should be further
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk considered and assessed and, if
migration) should also be taken into of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see necessary, the Natura assessment
account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be should be carried out for Karala-Pilgus
deaths during migration, etc.) on the mitigated through the following mitigation measures: Special Protection Area. As a result of
Special Protection Area, coherence of the the Natura assessment of the proposed
areas and birds may in some cases occur in activity, including the mitigation
case of the wind turbines planned outside ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting measures and the implementation of the
Natura sites. point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the conditions and guidelines set in the
height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind planning solution, adverse effects on
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for the Karala-Pilgus Special Protection
most bird species decreases. Area of the Natura 2000 network have
▪ To stipulate as a planning condition that the minimum been ruled out.
Karala-Pilgus permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25
Special Protection 11 bird species metres with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30 or
35 meters if necessary) on the basis of the study carried out
Area (EE0040414)
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 134
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2.
In the wind energy development areas the possible side effects of the
Natura (pre-) assessment process for Karala-Pilgus Special Protection Area
should be assessed at the authorization stage.
The proposed wind energy development At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of
During the development of wind energy
area (no. 1) is located more than 20 km the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant
development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area and adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of
environmental impacts of the location
therefore has no direct physical impact on location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial
and / or technical solutions proposed in
the site's conservation objectives. plan solution.
the project solution in the authorization
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g.
application process should be further
migration) should also be taken into Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk
considered and assessed and, if
account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see
necessary, the Natura assessment
Kasti bay Special deaths during migration, etc.) on the Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be
should be carried out for Kasti bay
Protection Area 8 bird species Special Protection Area, coherence of the mitigated through the following mitigation measures:
Special Protection Area As a result of
areas and birds may in some cases occur in ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting
(EE0040418) the Natura assessment of the proposed
case of wind turbines planned outside point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the
activity, including the mitigation
Natura sites. height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind
measures and the implementation of the
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for
conditions and guidelines set in the
most bird species decreases.
planning solution, adverse effects on
▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum
the Special Protection Areaof Kasti bay
permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25
in the Natura 2000 network have been
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30
ruled out.
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out
during the authorization application procedure.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 135
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas, the possible accompanying effects on
the Special Protection Area of Kasti bay should be assessed during the
authorization stage through the Natura (pre) assessment process.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 136
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
The proposed wind energy development At the strategic level, the potential for impact on the conservation During the development of wind energy
site (No. 2) is located more than 11 km objectives of the Special Protection Area is minimized with the selection of development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area and the location. There is no need to change the maritime spatial plan solution. environmental impacts of the location
therefore has no direct physical impact on and / or technical solutions proposed in
the site's conservation objectives. At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of the project solution in the authorization
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant application process should be further
migration) must also be taken into account, adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of considered and assessed and, if
so that adverse effects (obstacles / deaths location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial necessary, the Natura assessment
during migration, etc.) on the Special plan solution. should be carried out for Kaugatoma-
Protection Area, coherence of the areas and Lõu bay Special Protection Areaa. As a
birds may in some cases occur in case of Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk result of the Natura assessment of the
the wind turbines planned outside Natura of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see proposed activity, including the
sites. Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be mitigation measures and the
mitigated through the following mitigation measures: implementation of the conditions and
The proposed cable corridor passes through ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting guidelines set in the planning solution,
the Special Protection Area. The point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the adverse effects on the Special
construction of the cables is expected to height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind Protection Area of Kaugatoma-Lõu
have a temporary and local impact. Impacts turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for bay in the Natura 2000 network have
Kaugatoma-Lõu bay are generally limited in time to the most bird species decreases. been ruled out.
Speciall Protection 15 bird species construction period and spatially to the ▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum
Area (EE0040441) seabed, its habitats, vegetation and species The impact of the laying of the cables
in a specific location. permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 buried on the seabed (or in the ground)
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30 on the birds is not significant and an
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out adverse effect on the conservation
during the authorization application procedure. objectives of the Special Protection
Area is excluded through a measure to
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be mitigate the timing of the works.
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 137
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas, the possible accompanying effects on
the Special Protection Areaof Kaugatoma-Lõu bay should be assessed
during the authorization stage through the Natura (pre) assessment process.
The adverse effects of cable laying can be reduced through a suitable
technical solution and site selection at the design level, as well as through
the timing of the works.
Marine habitat The potential cable corridor is planned In order to avoid adverse impacts, it is proposed to shift the underwater According to the proposal to shift the
types (4 pcs): from wind energy development area no. 2 cable corridor so that it does not want overlap with the conservation submarine cable corridor, Figure 4.3-4,
sandy and through Saaremaa to the coast of Pärnu objectives of the nature area, see Figure 4.3-4 showing the location of the the plan solution has been adjusted and
muddy County in the village of Jaagupi or Haapsi a direct impact on the protection
Kaugatoma-Lõu alternative cable corridor
foreshores and it will pass through Kaugatoma-Lõu objectives of the Kaugatoma-Lõu Site
Site of Community (1140), wide Site of Community Importance on a few of Community Importance has been
Importance shallow bays hundred-meter section of the sea and land. ruled out.
EE0040441 (1160), reefs There will be no registered place of finding
(1170) of any of the protected species of the The details of the cable construction
special area of conservation nor marine (location/technical solution, etc.) will
Land and coastal protected habitats along the cable corridor. be specified in the context of specific
habitat types at At the same time, the corridor passes project solutions, which will also
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 138
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
the proposed through two coastal habitats of the Site of specify the nature, scale, and scope of
cable location (2 Community Importance (Figure 4.3-4) the impact at the local level. Adverse
pcs): coastal regarding which emergence of adverse impact on Natura 2000 sites can be
meadows impacts (e.g., reduction in area) cannot be ruled out through appropriate technical
(*1630), alvars - excluded. solution and site selection when laying
*6280). cables.
The proposed wind energy development At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of During the development of wind energy
areas (no 1 and 2) are adjacent to the bird the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant development areas the potential
area. There are no direct physical impacts adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of environmental impacts of the location
on the site's conservation objectives. location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial and / or technical solutions proposed in
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. plan solution. the project solution in the authorization
migration) must also be taken into account, application process should be further
so that adverse effects (obstacles / deaths Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk considered and assessed and, if
during migration, etc.) on the Special of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see necessary, the Natura assessment
Protection Area, coherence of the areas and Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be should be carried out for Kura kurgu
birds may in some cases occur in case of mitigated through the following mitigation measures: Special Protection Area.
the wind turbines planned outside Natura ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting As a result of the Natura assessment of
sites. point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the the proposed activity, including the
The proposed cable corridor passes through height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind mitigation measures and the
the Special Protection Area. The turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for implementation of the conditions and
construction of the cables is expected to most bird species decreases. guidelines set in the planning solution,
have a temporary and local impact. Impacts ▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum adverse effects on the Special
Kura kurgu Special
are generally limited in time to the permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 Protection Areaa of Kura kurgu in the
Protection Area 38 bird species construction period and spatially to the meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30 Natura 2000 network have been ruled
(EE0040434) seabed, its habitats, vegetation and species or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out out.
in a specific location. during the authorization application procedure.
The impact of the laying of the cables
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be buried on the seabed (or in the ground)
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level: on the birds is not significant and an
adverse effect on the conservation
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of objectives of the Special Protection
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant Area is excluded through a measure to
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across mitigate the timing of the works.
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 139
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas, the possible side effects on the Kura
kurgu Special Protection Area should be assessed during the application for
authorization through the Natura (pre) assessment process.
The adverse effects of cable laying can be reduced through a suitable
technical solution and site selection at the design level, as well as through
the timing of the works.
The proposed wind energy development At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of During the development of wind energy
area (no. 1) is located approximately 28 km the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area and thus adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of environmental impacts of the location
there are no direct physical impacts on the location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial and / or technical solutions proposed in
site's conservation objectives. plan solution. the project solution in the authorization
Mullutu-Loode However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. application process should be further
Special Protection 34 bird species. migration) must also be taken into account, Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk considered and assessed and, if
Area (EE0040444) so that adverse effects (obstacles / deaths of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see necessary, the Natura assessment
during migration, etc.) on the Special Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be should be carried out for Mullutu-
Protection Area, coherence of the areas and mitigated through the following mitigation measures: Loode Special Protection Area.
birds may in some cases occur in case of ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting As a result of the Natura assessment of
the wind turbines planned outside Natura point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the the proposed activity, including the
sites. height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind mitigation measures and the
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 140
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for implementation of the conditions and
most bird species decreases. guidelines set in the planning solution,
▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum adverse effects on the Special
permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 Protection Area of Mullutu-Loode in
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30 the Natura 2000 network have been
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out ruled out.
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 141
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas the possible side effects of the Natura
(pre-) assessment process for the Mullutu-Loode Special Protection Area
should be assessed at the authorization application stage.
The proposed wind energy development At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of During the development of wind energy
area (no. 1) is located approximately 16 km the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area, and thus adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of environmental impacts of the location
there are no direct physical impacts on the location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial and / or technical solutions proposed in
site's conservation objectives. plan solution. the project solution in the authorization
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. application process should be further
migration) should also be taken into Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk considered and assessed and, if
account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see necessary, the Natura assessment
deaths during migration, etc.) on the Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be should be carried out for Pärnu bay
Special Protection Area, coherence of the mitigated through the following mitigation measures: Special Protection Area.
areas and birds may in some cases occur in ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting As a result of the Natura assessment of
case of the wind turbines planned outside point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the the proposed activity, including the
Natura sites. height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind mitigation measures and the
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for implementation of the conditions and
most bird species decreases. guidelines set in the planning solution,
Pärnu bay Special ▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum adverse effects on the Special
Protection Area 43 bird species permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 Protection Area of Pärnu bay in the
(EE0040346) meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30 Natura 2000 network have been ruled
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out out
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 142
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas the possible side effects of the Natura
(pre-) assessment process for Pärnu bay Special Protection Area should be
assessed at the authorization application stage.
The proposed wind energy development At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of During the development of wind energy
area (no. 2) is located approximately 8 km the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area, and thus adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of environmental impacts of the location
there are no direct physical impacts on the location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial and / or technical solutions proposed in
site's conservation objectives. plan solution. the project solution in the authorization
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. application process should be further
Riksu coastal migration) should also be taken into Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk considered and assessed and, if
Special Protection 8 bird species account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see necessary, the Natura assessment
Area(EE0040461) deaths during migration, etc.) on the Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be should be carried out for Riksu coastal
Special Protection Area, coherence of the mitigated through the following mitigation measures: Special Protection Area.
areas and birds may in some cases occur in ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting As a result of the Natura assessment of
case of the wind turbines planned outside point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the the proposed activity, including the
Natura sites. height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind mitigation measures and the
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for implementation of the conditions and
most bird species decreases. guidelines set in the planning solution,
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 143
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum adverse effects on Riksu coastal Special
permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 Protection Area in the Natura 2000
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30 network have been ruled out.
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 144
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas the possible side effects of the Natura
(pre-) assessment process for Riksu coastal Special Protection Area should
be assessed at the authorization stage.
The proposed wind energy development During the development of wind energy
area (no. 1) is located approximately 23 km At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area, and thus the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant environmental impacts of the location
there are no direct physical impacts on the adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of and / or technical solutions proposed in
site's conservation objectives. location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial the project solution in the authorization
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. plan solution. application process should be further
migration) should also be taken into considered and assessed and, if
account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk necessary, the Natura assessment
deaths during migration, etc.) on the of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see should be carried out for Siiksaare-
Special Protection Area, coherence of the Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be Oessaare bay Special Protection Area.
areas and birds may in some cases occur in mitigated through the following mitigation measures: As a result of the Natura assessment of
case of the wind turbines planned outside ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting the proposed activity, including the
Natura sites. point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the mitigation measures and the
height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind implementation of the conditions and
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for guidelines set in the planning solution,
Siiksaare-Oessaare most bird species decreases. adverse effects on Siiksaare-Oessaare
Special Protection 41 bird species. ▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum Special Protection Area area in the
Area (EE0040469) permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 Natura 2000 network have been ruled
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30 out.
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 145
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas the possible side effects through the
Natura (pre-) assessment process for Siiksaare-Oessaare Special Protection
Area should be assessed at the authorization stage.
The proposed wind energy development During the development of wind energy
area (no. 1) is located approximately 18 km At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area, and thus the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant environmental impacts of the location
there are no direct physical impacts on the adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of and / or technical solutions proposed in
site's conservation objectives. location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial the project solution in the authorization
Sutu bay Special However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. plan solution. application process should be further
Protection Area 9 bird species migration) should also be taken into considered and assessed and, if
(EE0040472) account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk necessary, the Natura assessment
deaths during migration, etc.) on the of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see should be carried out for Sutu bay
Special Protection Area, coherence of the Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be Special Protection Area.
areas and birds may in some cases occur in mitigated through the following mitigation measures: As a result of the Natura assessment of
case of the wind turbines planned outside ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting the proposed activity, including the
Natura sites. point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the mitigation measures and the
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 146
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind implementation of the conditions and
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for guidelines set in the planning solution,
most bird species decreases. adverse effects on Sutu bay Special
▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum Protectio Area area in the Natura 2000
permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 network have been ruled out.
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 147
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas the possible side effects through the
Natura (pre-) assessment process for Sutu bay Special Protection Area
should be assessed at the authorization stage.
The proposed wind energy development During the development of wind energy
area (no. 2) is located approximately 21 km At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of development areas the potential
from the Special Protection Area, and thus the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant environmental impacts of the location
there are no direct physical impacts on the adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of and / or technical solutions proposed in
site's conservation objectives. location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial the project solution in the authorization
However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. plan solution. application process should be further
migration) should also be taken into considered and assessed and, if
account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk necessary, the Natura assessment
deaths during migration, etc.) on the of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see should be carried out for Tagamõisa
Special Protection Area, coherence of the Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be Special Protection Area.
areas and birds may in some cases occur in mitigated through the following mitigation measures: As a result of the Natura assessment of
case of the wind turbines planned outside ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting the proposed activity, including the
Natura sites. point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the mitigation measures and the
height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind implementation of the conditions and
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for guidelines set in the planning solution,
Tagamõisa Special most bird species decreases. adverse effects on Tagamõisa Special
Protection Area 20 bird species. ▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum Protection Area in the Natura 2000
(EE0040476) permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 network have been ruled out.
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 148
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas the possible side effects through the
Natura (pre-) assessment process for Tagamõisa Special Protection Area
should be assessed at the authorization stage.
The proposed wind energy development During the development of wind energy
area (no. 2) is located at a distance of At the strategic level the potential impact on the conservation objectives of development areas the potential
approx. 10 km from the Special Protection the Special Protection Area has been minimized and thus a significant environmental impacts of the location
Area and thus there are no direct physical adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site with the selection of and / or technical solutions proposed in
impacts on the protection objectives of the location has been ruled out. There is no need to change the maritime spatial the project solution in the authorization
Vilsandi Special area. plan solution. application process should be further
Protection Area However, the mobile lifestyle of birds (e.g. considered and assessed and, if
13 bird species.
migration) should also be taken into Although most birds use sensitive areas for migration and stopping, the risk necessary, the Natura assessment
(EE0040496) account, so that adverse effects (obstacles / of collision and the barrier effect cannot be completely ruled out (see should be carried out for Vilsandi
deaths during migration, etc.) on the Chapter 4.2.2 for details). The risk of collision and the barrier effect can be Special Protection Area.
Special Protection Area, coherence of the mitigated through the following mitigation measures: As a result of the Natura assessment of
areas and birds may in some cases occur in ▪ It is recommended to use large modern wind turbines (the starting the proposed activity, including the
case of the wind turbines planned outside point of the plan allows the use of large wind turbines). As the mitigation measures and the
Natura sites. height of the wind turbines increases, the number of wind implementation of the conditions and
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 149
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
turbines (per area) decreases and the risk of collision (death) for guidelines set in the planning solution,
most bird species decreases. adverse effects on Vilsandi Special
▪ As a planning condition, to stipulate that the minimum Protection Area in the Natura 2000
permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25 network have been ruled out.
meters, with the proviso that it can be specified (increased to 30
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out
during the authorization application procedure.
The magnitude of these risks and possible mitigation measures can be
specified after the following on-site studies at the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to
Kuramaa, but taking the direction from the west coast of
Saaremaa towards Gotland, in which case the wind energy
development area may remain on the migration route. This needs
to be identified at the authorization stage by a radar survey of
birds covering the migration periods of at least two years, carried
out in parallel with visual observations.
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 150
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2
In wind energy development areas the possible side effects through the
Natura (pre-) assessment process for Vilsandi Special Protection Area
should be assessed at the authorization stage.
Marine habitat The potential cable corridor is planned In order to avoid adverse impact, this assessment proposes to shift the According to the proposal to shift the
types (3 pcs): from the wind energy development area No underwater cable corridor so that it does not overlap with the conservation underwater cable corridor, Figure 4.3-3,
sandy and 1 to Virtsu and passes through the objectives of the Site of Community Importance see Figure 4.3-3, which the plan solution has been adjusted and
muddy Väinameri Sea Site of Community shows the location of the alternative cable corridor. The location of the a direct impact on the conservation
foreshores Importance in the section of ca 5 km in the alternative cable completely avoids the passage of both terrestrial and objectives of the Väinameri Site of
(1140), wide sea and to a small extent also on the land coastal habitats and reefs from marine habitats, by thus preventing damage Community Importance has been ruled
shallow bays (islets, the coast). There will be no to these habitats. The alternative cable corridor partly passes through out.
(1160), reefs registered places of finding of any of the shallow sand habitats. Due to the nature of the shallow sand habitat (soft The details of the cable construction
(1170) protected species, nor marine protected sediments) permanent and irreversible adverse effects on the habitat (location/technical solution, etc.) will
habitats along the cable corridor. At the associated with the installation and operation of the cable can be prevented be specified in the context of specific
Marine species same time, the corridor passes through by technical solutions and the like. The habitat can restore later in the project solutions, which will also
(6 pcs): Gray coastal habitats (including priority habitat corridor of the cable sunk into the soft sediments (see also chapter 4.2.5). specify the nature, scale and scope of
seal, ringed types) in the site of community importance the impact at the local level. Adverse
seal, spined (Figure 4.3-3) regarding which adverse impacts on Natura 2000 sites can be
Väinamere Site of loach, impacts (e.g. reduction in area) cannot be ruled out through appropriate technical
Community European excluded. solution and site selection when laying
Importance bullhead, river cables.
EE0040002 lamprey,
European
weatherfish.
Land and
coastal habitat
types at the
proposed cable
location (3
pcs): Small
islands and
wide (1620),
coastal
meadows
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 151
Protection
Natura 2000 sites Identification of impacts Mitigation measures Conclusion of the Natura assessment
objectives
(*1630), alvars
-*6280).
The proposed cable corridor passes through The adverse effects of cable laying can be reduced through a suitable The impact of the installation of cables
the Special Protection Area. The technical solution and site selection at the design level, as well as through buried on the seabed (or in the ground)
Väinamere Special construction of the cables is expected to the choice of time to carry out the work. on birds is not significant and an
Protection Area have a temporary and local impact. Impacts adverse effect on the conservation
76 bird species. are generally limited in time to the objectives of the Special Protection
EE0040001
construction period and spatially to the Area is excluded through a mitigation
seabed, its habitats, vegetation and species measure of choosing the time for the
in a specific location. execution of the works.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 152
Figure 4.3-3 Proposed location of the cable corridor and a proposal (alternative
cable corridor in the figure) for its relocation in the Väinameri Site of
Community Importance based on the location of habitat types according to the
site conservation management plan
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 153
Figure 4.3-4 Proposed location of the cable corridor in Kaugatoma -Lõu Site of
Community Importance and proposal (alternative cable corridor in the figure)
to move it to an alternative location
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 154
Figure 4.3-5 Wind energy development areas (as of April 2021) and the related
infrastructure, i.e. principal locations of cable corridors, taking into account the
conclusions of the Natura assessment
▪ Results and conclusion of the Natura assessment
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan addresses several uses of the sea, which do not
envisage any spatial changes (or significant spatial changes) to the existing situation;
therefore, it can be said that the implementation of the plan does not lead to a different
situation for Natura 2000 sites. Such uses of the sea include fisheries; aquaculture;
maritime transport; maritime rescue, pollution control, border guarding; seabed
infrastructure; marine tourism and recreation; protected natural objects; marine culture;
cultural monuments; National defense; mineral resources; dumping; permanent
connections. These uses do not have an adverse impact on Natura 2000 sites and
conservation objectives when implementing the plan, in case the conditions and
guidelines laid down for that purpose are complied with.
Energy production is an area of activity for which the planning defines the basic
spatial locations of the offshore area as wind energy development areas as well
as the accompanying infrastructure (possible offshore substation and cable
corridors outside the wind energy development areas). The location of the
Natura 2000 network areas has been taken into account in the selection of the
spatial solution and locations of the wind energy development areas in the
maritime spatial plan, i.e. due to the precautionary principle these areas were
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 155
excluded as development areas to ensure favourable status of Natura 2000 areas
and their conservation objectives. No activities or sites are generally planned
for Natura 2000 sites. With regard to the seabed cables passing through Natura
areas (Väinamere and Kaugatoma-Lõu Special Protection Areas), the
possibilities of impact were assessed in more detail, and in order to exclude
adverse effects, it was proposed to change the location of the cables in the plan
which has also been taken into account when changing the planning solution
(as of January 2021).
The implementation of the Maritime spatial Plan will not have an adverse
effect on the Natura 2000 network areas or their conservation objectives,
by taking into account the environmental measures provided for in this
Impact Assessment and the conditions set in the plan.
The degree of accuracy of the Maritime Spatial Plan (lacking detailed
information on the locations/technical solutions of the proposed activities, etc.)
does not foresee any adverse impacts on Natura 2000 sites or their conservation
objectives, taking into account the conditions and guidelines laid down in the
plan and the environmental measures provided for in this Impact Assessment
to the licensing level.
As a result of the Natura assessment the alternatives for the location of
submarine cables have been suggested in the new proposed corridors to exclude
impacts on Natura 2000 sites and their conservation objectives. The
amendments to Natura assessment have been taken into account when
supplementing the planning solution. The details of the cable construction
(location/technical solution, etc.) will be specified within the framework of
specific design solutions, as a result of which the nature, extent and scope of
the impact will be specified at the local level. Consequently, a further
assessment of possible side effects through the Natura (pre-) assessment
process at the authorization level is needed.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. In case of activities planned in the maritime spatial plan, in particular
the development of wind farms, the establishment and/or dumping of
fish farms, the environmental impacts of the location and / or technical
solutions proposed in the project solution in the process of the
authorization procedure should be specified and, if necessary, a Natura
assessment must be carried out. Adverse effects on the conservation
objectives of the Natura 2000 site should be ruled out during the
implementation of the proposed activity and as a result of the Natura
assessment (and through the implementation of the mitigation measures
proposed therein). The likelihood of potential adverse effects occurring
can be prevented and reduced by continuing to take into account Natura
conservation objectives and, if necessary, implementing mitigation
measures when directing development to the next stages (at the level of
authorization). The adverse effects of wind turbines and fish farms can
also be ruled out, if necessary, through a suitable technical solution and
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 156
a more precise location selection design solution at the level of
authorization.
2. In the case of specific development projects, the locations of the cable
corridors may change, and their impact will need to be assessed in the
licensing procedure, together with the design of wind farms. At project
level, suitable cable locations, technologies, etc. that have no significant
impact on the integrity of the Natura 2000 site and the site's conservation
objectives shall be identified.
3. The adverse effects of cable laying can be reduced through a suitable
technical solution and site selection at the design level, as well as
through the selection of time for carrying out the work.
4. In the implementation of all marine uses planned on the basis of the
terms and guidelines of the plan, the effects of the proposed activity on
the conservation objectives of the Natura 2000 site should be each time
assessed at the authorization level and, if necessary, to prevent the
implementation of mitigation measures from adversely affecting the
conservation objectives of the Natura 2000 site.
5. To reduce the risk of collisions and the barrier effect, the use of large
modern wind turbines is recommended, as the increasing of the height
of the wind turbines reduces the number of wind turbines (per the same
area) and this reduces the risk of collisions for most bird species (death
risk).
6. To eliminate and minimize the risk of collision and the barrier effect:
▪ as a condition of the plan, to stipulate that the minimum
permissible height of the wind turbine blade above sea level is 25
meters, with the provison that it can be specified (increased to 30
or 35 meters if necessary) on the basis of a study carried out
during the authorization application procedure.
7. The magnitude of the collision risk and barrier effect and possible
mitigation measures can be specified after subsequent on-site studies at
the authorization level:
▪ The eastern part of the area no. 1 suitable for the development of
wind energy in the Gulf of Riga is located near the significant
migration corridor of terrestrial birds (incl birds of prey) across
the sea. At the authorization stage, to specify the actual width of
the migratory flow of terrestrial birds near the eastern part of the
development area in the direction of Kihnu-Ruhnu (to clarify
whether the existing free area is sufficient) and clarify other
necessary matters for the collision risk assessment (species flight
intensity and altitudes). To this end, it is necessary to carry out a
radar survey of birds covering the migration periods of at least
two years in parallel with visual observations .
▪ In case of area no. 2 suitable for the development of the wind
energy in the west of Saaremaa, it is necessary to specify at the
authorization stage which part of all migratory terrestrial birds do
not use the main migratory route, this means not going along the
Sõrve peninsula to Säär and from there across the sea to Kuramaa,
but taking the direction from the west coast of Saaremaa towards
Gotland, in which case the wind energy development area may
remain on the migration route. This needs to be identified at the
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 157
authorization stage by a radar survey of birds covering the
migration periods of at least two years, carried out in parallel with
visual observations
▪ In view of the principle of combined use set out in the maritime
spatial plan, the water traffic area of vessels (currently NNW-
SSE) should be specified at the authorization level, where
possible, to better match the expected predominant migratory
direction of birds (NNE-SSW). Birds will then be able to use the
area as a migration corridor, as the width of the passageway
required for shipping is calculated to be approximately 6250 m
for area 2.
4.4 SOCIAL AND CULTURAL ENVIRONMENT
4.4.1 Impact on socio-cultural needs and well-being
4.4.1.1 Starting points for socio-cultural impact assessment
The assessment of the impact on the social and cultural environment is
inherently very closely linked to the development of a planning solution. The
inherent part of planning is the shaping of the social and cultural environment,
which makes it sometimes difficult to distinguish between planning and impact
assessment. Due to the above, this chapter differs from the rest in its structure,
and specific planning concepts are also presented. This approach, while
different from the rest of the report, is necessary to convey the logic of impact
assessment. In the field of social and cultural influences, there is no single
standard; the involvement of different stakeholders is important. It is also
important that people perceive changes in social and cultural envir onments
differently, i.e., it is difficult to predict the nature and intensity of the impact.
The Estonian marine area fulfills a wide range of social and cultural needs and
has a direct and indirect impact on human well-being. The sea offers a variety
of resources for human well-being or opportunities stemming from the marine
environment. This has led to the emergence of various uses of the sea: from
traditional, such as shipping and shipbuilding, fishing to various recreational
and sporting facilities, and the emerging blue economy sectors.
There are also very different cultural values associated with the Estonian
marine area: material values (e.g., wrecks) and intangible values - historical-
cultural, aesthetic, and identity values. Cultural values may o r may not have
direct economic or livelihood benefits, supporting identity, self -fulfillment, a
sense of place, and the quality of the living environment in a wider sense.
Because the sea offers a wide range of benefits, user groups also differ in their
social and cultural needs and values. They can also be considered as different
communities of marine culture for the purposes of impact assessment. Estonian
marine culture is created by a wide variety of marine areas and coastal users -
fishermen, shipbuilders, vacationers, surfers, divers, recreational craft owners,
and others. Today's Estonian marine culture is therefore also diverse: besides
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 158
traditional shipping and fishing, and coastal lifestyle, new communities have
emerged that have an equal interest in the use of the sea and the coast. With the
increase in uses of the sea, the number of different marine culture communities
and the pressure on the use of the sea and the coast is increasing. In the context
of the assessment of the social and cultural impact of the marine area, the
consideration of different interests and the sharing of the marine area are thus
important issues.
The results of the cultural mapping of the Estonian coastal and marine area
show that the entire Estonian coast is valuable in one way or another (see
figures in Annex 2 to the report) - sparsely populated coastal areas are of natural
and/or culturally valuable nature, recreational services and social infrastructure
(such as community centers, shipbuilding sites, but also museums) that carry
local marine culture are concentrated in coastal villages and towns. The coastal
sea contains valuable landscapes (e.g., Neugrund Bank), wreckage areas, and
marine areas used for water sports. What is planned in the marine area has a
direct or indirect impact on the preservation of these values and uses and, thus,
on the interests of the user groups. The Impact Assessment addresses the impact
on the broader public interest (including international interest) as well as,
where appropriate, on the narrow interest of the user group. Alongside the wider
public interest, it is also important to consider the interests of local
communities, whose well-being, income, and identity are directly dependent on
what is planned in the marine area 104.
Regionally, the specific marine culture of a region and the interest of
communities in a particular marine area depend on both the natural features and
the historical background of the coastal sea: for example, the relatively shallow
and warm sea of Lääne County offers somewhat different sea uses than the
relatively cold sea coast of Ida-Viru County. The different nature of the marine
area (e.g., wind conditions, salinity, ice cover, etc.) will, among other things,
allow or limit new marine uses planned by the plan. The activities planned in
the Maritime Spatial Plan will, therefore, where appropriate, also assess the
regional socio-cultural impact (in addition to the coastal/marine area level) in
addition to the overall impact.
As the proposed activities in the marine area can take place on the surface, in
the water column or on the seabed, where appropriate, the location of socio-
cultural 105 Regionally, the specific marine culture of a region and the interest
104The need to distinguish between general public and local interests stems from the fact that
some users are more connected to the coast and the sea on a daily basis than others - eg
holidaymakers use the sea/coast occasionally, holidaymakers in summer seasonally, etc.
Thus, the dependence of different user groups on the maritime sector also differs. Due to the
degree of accuracy of the MSP it is important to consider the impact in terms of general
interest-user group interest and general interest-local interest.
105 From the standpoint of impact assessment, it is not always necessary or possible to
distinguish whether the impacy is cultural or social because they are intertwined and may
also have an economic dimension. For example, the identity of the coastal fisherman derives
from his place and area of activity, fishing has both a social impact (e.g., food) and a potential
economic impact (e.g., additional income).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 159
of communities in a particular marine area depend on both the natural features
and the historical background of the coastal sea: for example, the relatively
shallow and warm sea of Lääne County offers somewhat different sea uses than
the relatively cold sea coast of Ida-Viru County. The different nature of the
marine area (e.g., wind conditions, salinity, ice cover, etc.) will, among other
things, allow or limit new marine uses planned by the plan. The activities
planned in the Maritime Spatial Plan will, therefore, where appropriate, also
assess the regional socio-cultural impact (in addition to the coastal/marine area
level) in addition to the overall impact.
As the proposed activities in the marine area can take place on the surface, in
the water column or on the seabed, where appropriate, the location of socio-
cultural 106 impact will be highlighted.
Impact of the MSP
The plan has an overall positive long-term impact. The thoughtful development
agreed upon in the plan as a guideline and condition will allow the expansion
and sustainable management of the use of the sea. Positive impacts will be
based on the well-thought-out opportunities for the sustainable development of
new blue economy sectors such as aquaculture and wind energy. The plan
values the marine culture and gives it a wider resonance. When designing a
planning solution, the prevention or mitigation of significant adverse impacts
has already been taken into account by setting conditions to prevent a negative
impact (e.g., grouping, 11 km, etc.). The following section s of the Impact
Assessment contain, where appropriate, proposals that mitigate and amplify
impact from a socio-cultural perspective. See chapter 4.2 of the MSP for an
overview of the consideration of the proposals.
In order to increase the positive impact, the socio-cultural impact assessment
identifies three general issues that should be addressed when supplementing the
planning solution. More detailed recommendations for supplementing the
planning solution are given in the thematic subchapters.
▪ One of the key issues in the Maritime Spatial Plan is the combined
use of the marine space, which can range from tolerating the different
uses to synergistic combined use. The combined use of the marine
area is also a new trend in terms of more general approaches and
practices. According to the Muses project (Multi-Use in European
Seas, 2018 107), the success of proposed combined uses will depend
on a thorough analysis of interactions, funding models and support
106 From the standpoint of impact assessment, it is not always necessary or possible to
distinguish whether the impacy is cultural or social because they are intertwined and may
also have an economic dimension. For example, the identity of the coastal fisherm an derives
from his place and area of activity, fishing has both a social impact (e.g., food) and a potential
economic impact (e.g., additional income).
107See the Report https://muses-project.eu/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2018/10/D4.3 -Sea-
Basin-Syntheses.pdf
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 160
mechanisms, and the responsiveness of coastal communit ies for new
uses, etc. From the standpoint of assessing the socio-cultural impact,
the role of Maritime Spatial Plan is to highlight possible synergies at
the national level, while also taking a helpful starting point .
▪ Enabling the plan. The Maritime Spatial Plan, as a national spatial
plan, focuses primarily on major developments in new uses of the
sea. In the case of new uses of the sea, which can also be developed
closer to the coast, it is advisable to state this clearly. For example,
the planning could consider promoting the development of local
small-scale distributed energy solutions.
▪ Planning that supports innovation. Areas of the blue economy are
rapidly evolving in terms of technology and institutional, financial,
and other aspects, which can make it difficult in the plans to take into
consideration the unforeseeable and unpredictable future. However,
Maritime Spatial Plan should aim to support innovation and provide
general guidance based on known values or threats (e.g., all energy
equipment that needs to be anchored must take into account the
preservation of cultural values, working with the Ministry of Defense
to avoid historic explosives, etc. to find safe anchoring areas )
4.4.1.2 Fisheries
Fishing is one of the oldest uses of marine areas, divided into coastal and trawl
fisheries in Estonia. Fishing is also a hobby. Although the number of people
employed in fisheries has declined significantly over the last decade, fisheries
continue to be a major socio-economic source of employment both on the
islands and on the coast. As a traditional maritime industry, fishing contributes
to the vitality and employment of the local community, as well as to the
maintenance of coastal fishing settlements (coastal villages, boat, and net
shelters, docks, ports, etc.) and intangible culture (from maritime traditions and
knowledge of the sea in the way of fishing events and societies). As a traditional
maritime branch, the land-sea interaction between fisheries is strong. From the
point of view of impact assessment, these are the cultural and social (as well
as economic) effects of fishing. The effects on fisheries depend on what the plan
envisages and what may change in the fisheries sector as a result.
In the marine environment, the impact of fishing as an acti vity on the surface
of the water occurs (while there is no significant environmental impact or visual
disturbance), but other uses are restricted/influenced by, e.g., nets in the water
column or bottom trawling (including trawler movement trajectories) .
According to the Maritime Spatial Plan, developed and intensified marine areas
will be preserved in the marine area, which means that the current more catch
rich areas will be preserved. The plan also supports the rebuilding of fishery
resources (spawning grounds) and access to both fisheries at sea and
infrastructure on the coast (ports, landing sites). At a general level, the
Maritime spatial Plan thus contributes to the social and cultural viability of
fishing communities and has a long-term positive impact on fisheries.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 161
However, there are certain differences from region to region: the marine areas
around West Estonia surrounding the big islands are more suitable for the new
marine uses such as wind energy, shellfish and algae farming. Thus, there is
also a somewhat greater pressure in the “capacity” of the sea area in Western
Estonia: for example, due to the design of wind farms the trawled sea areas in
the Baltic Sea, west of the Sõrve foothills and in the Gulf of Riga , are
decreasing to a small extent. Trawling within the wind energy development area
is considered unlikely by fishermen due to its technical complexity. Thus,
despite the fact that only 4.5% of trawl fisheries in the national perspective are
located in wind energy development areas 108, yielding 7% of the catch, this is a
significant regional impact. In order to mitigate the regionally significant
socio-economic impact, it is necessary to reduce the overlap between wind
energy and trawl areas (to adjust the extent of wind energy development areas)
and / or to agree with the fishing communities on compensatory measures 109.
The maritime spatial plan does not prohibit the continuation of trawling in the
wind energy development areas. However, if fishermen find that it is
technically possible to engage in (to some extent) trawling, the stakeholder
cooperation is needed for wind farms and trawling to work together.
There is very little overlap between the wind turbines' innovation area and the
trawled sea area. Thus, there is no significant adverse socio -economic impact
on trawling areas in the national perspective, the impact is in the regional
perspective. There are no significant socio-economic adverse effects on coastal
and recreational fishing: wind turbines are planned to be 6 nautical miles or
more from the coast, thus preserving fisheries (see Figures 4.4.1.2 -1 and
4.4.1.2-2).
There is very little overlap between the wind turbines' innovation area and the
trawled sea area. Thus, there is no significant adverse socio -economic impact
on trawling areas in the national perspective, the impact is in the regional
perspective. There are no significant socio-economic adverse effects on coastal
and recreational fishing: the wind turbines are planned to be 6 nautical miles
or more from the coast, thus preserving the fisheries (see Figures 4.4.1.2-1 and
4.4.1.2-2).
108
Ministry of Rural Affairs 2020
109
An interim decision of the Government of the Republic (29 April 2021) designated those
areas of the wind energy development areas proposed in the maritime spatial plan as reserve
areas that coincide with the historically more intensive trawling areas (see the explanatory
memorandum to the maritime spatial plan, Chapter 5.6).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 162
Figure 4.4.1.2-1 Coastal fishing and wind energy development
Figure 4.4.1.2-2 Trawling and wind energy
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 163
In terms of aquaculture, the plan does not define areas, but it sets out the
conditions: fish farm development is preferred in the deeper high seas. With
regard to shellfish and algae farming, the most suitable marine areas are
highlighted. The conditions create a fundamental opportunity for trawling and
fish farming (e.g., in the Baltic Sea) or algae farming and coastal fishing (e.g.,
in the Väinameri) in the same marine area. Based on the interest of the
fishermen, the socio-cultural impact assessment proposes to consider including
a condition in the MSP that also takes into account the interest of fishermen
when applying for aquaculture permits: there would be no significant negative
impact on the most used and yielding fishing grounds.
From the standpoint of the conservation and future uses of fishing grounds,
maximum combined use is recommended - spatial concentration of activities
rather than dispersal on the marine area, which is already supported by the
planning for certain uses. As combined use pressures are expected to fall most
heavily on the Hiiu Shoal, Baltic Sea, Väinameri Sea and Gulf of Riga waters,
it is important, especially in these areas, to allow fishermen to enter new blue
economy sectors if they wish, utilizing established prerequisites (seafaring
skills, regional sea knowledge, etc).
4.4.1.3 Aquaculture
In Estonia, the aquaculture sector has so far been engaged in fish farming and
gathering of agar, which is of interest to the food and confectionery industry
and thus to the Estonian population at large. Aquaculture is a developing sector:
developing technologies and fields of application (food industry,
biotechnology, bioplastics, shellfish farming, for example, as the feed for fish
farms, poultry, and domestic animals, etc.). There is potential for fish farms,
algae and shellfish farming in Estonian waters.
The impacts of aquaculture on the water surface are local and of low impact
(visual disturbance) and may occur in the water column as a growing medium
and on the seabed (possible anchoring needs).
Fish farming. Maritime Spatial Plan does not designate fish farm areas but
identifies areas that are expected to be inappropriate (e.g., national defense and
nature protection, ship-to-ship areas, etc.), and shallow and more enclosed
marine areas are also inappropriate. Fish farming supports combined use with
algae and shellfish farming (for ecological reasons) and states that fish farming
can only take place upon application of compensatory measures.
Fish farm planning needs to be done in cooperation with various authorities to
ensure the functioning and safety of other important maritime sectors, such as
the Maritime Administration to ensure vessel traffic, the Land Board in terms
of deposits, etc. Concerning cultural impact, it is important to desi gn fish farms
in cooperation with the National Heritage Board, which supports ensuring the
good condition of wrecks and maintaining water quality suitable for their
preservation.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 164
The conditions set out in the plan largely adjust the state-developer relationship
(i.e., the guidelines from top to bottom). The terms do not explicitly state how
the developer-current user/stakeholder relationship is weighed; therefore,
decision-making may not be balanced. The developer-current user relationship
is, for example, balancing the interests of fishermen and aquaculture: under the
current planning solution, only spawning grounds are the basis for the decision,
not, e.g., finding coherence in the designation of areas suitable for aquaculture
in the fisheries used. The proposed activities may also affect coastal values and
related activities (recreation, entrepreneurship), so local government
involvement may be required. The socio-cultural impact assessment, therefore,
proposes that further consideration be given to balancing the interests of the
developer-current user and the developer-local government in the licensing
procedure.
The plan excludes the combined use planning of wind farm cable corridors and
fish farms, but not the combined use planning of wind farms and the fish farms.
The socio-cultural impact assessment suggests that consideration be given to
enabling this combined use. As both are new areas of development, public
support for the development and implementation of the rules and practic es of
combined use is essential. The socio-cultural impact assessment proposes to
include the topic of the development of rules and practices for combined use
and their implementation in the planning agenda. The results of the Maribe
project highlight the biggest barriers to entry into the blue economy (Table
4.2.1.4-1).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 165
Figure 4.4.1.3-1. Reason, obstacles, and recommended public support for
investing in the blue economy. (Source: Marine investment for the blue
economy. Maribe project booklet: work packages, case studies, and results.
http://maribe.eu/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/maribe-booklet-final.pdf)
Shellfish and algae farming Maritime Spatial Plan also does not define
shellfish and algae farming areas, but rather guides development through
conditions and identifies areas that are naturally most suitable for that. The
potential for algae cultivation is wider, extending from the Baltic Sea to the
Gulf of Finland and also covering the Väinameri Sea and the Gulf of Riga.
Areas naturally suitable for shellfish farming lie west of the major islands.
Farming is excluded in shipping lanes, STS areas, and areas used for national
defense purposes. In the rest of the marine area, shellfish farming, and algae
farming can be planned either independently or in combined use (with wind
turbines and fish farms). Similarly, to the design of fish farms, the parties
involved in the licensing procedure who have an interest in the ope ration of
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 166
other economic sectors and in the protection of values are identified. The
conditions and guidelines set out in the plan support the functioning of different
sectors more broadly.
Because algae farming, in particular, is naturally possible over a wider marine
area and is not subject to depth/openness constraints, farms can be located in
both deeper and shallower seas, spatially overlapping with the areas of both
trawl and coastal fisheries, and have an impact on the coast. Overlaps can lead
to the emergence of both synergies and conflicts: for example, aquaculture
supports land-sea interactions both on the coast (port operations and local
employment) and more broadly (e.g., processing of produce; local marketing of
certain products). Conflicts can occur, for example, in terms of fishing grounds
and, in principle, with recreational water and coastal uses. In order to increase
synergies and prevent/mitigate conflicts, it is important to involve both
fishermen and the local authority in the location-based decision-making
processes (e.g., within one nautical mile; the scope needs to be clarified as part
of a comprehensive analysis of the potential rights and obligations of local
authorities in the Maritime Spatial Plan. Involvement process es are foreseen at
the licensing procedure stage but are expected to require further discussion on
the issue of local government rights in the Action Plan. As a new field of
application, there is potential for new land-sea interactions (see Figure 4.4.1.9-
1 for more land-sea interactions).
In order to encourage combined use, the socio-cultural impact assessment also
proposes that consideration be given in principle to the combined use of
aquaculture farms and solar and wave energy. The potential of wave ene rgy is
not considered high in Estonia - the main focus is on developing wind energy.
At the same time, it cannot be ruled out that the establishment of farms and the
development of energy technologies will create the opportunity and need to use
other sources on a small scale. For example, the Maribe project (Marine
Investment for the Blue Economy, see http://maribe.eu/) highlights the already
existing combined uses in other marine areas: combined use of wave energy
and algae farming. A wave trap will create a quieter sea area in the windward
side, creating a suitable environment for algae cultivation; the energy produced
enables the transport of both the wave trap and the algae farm, if necessary).
At the same time, solutions in one marine area may not be suitable for another
marine area. Uncertainty is compounded by the lack of awareness of the
direction in which technologies are evolving and, consequently, of new
opportunities for synergies. However, from a socio-cultural impact standpoint,
the Maritime Spatial Plan has to take an enabling approach and consistently
support innovation, mitigating known risks based on value preservation needs
or anticipated operational conflicts (e.g., when a device requires anchoring, it
is necessary to consider the location of monuments, underwater cables, etc.,
similar to other operating conditions; certain combined uses are not possible -
for example, national defense and wave energy).
Technologically, the nature of combined use in linking wind turbine areas and
shellfish farming may also be the simultaneous use of the marine area, i.e., the
shellfish lines are not directly attached to the wind turbine foundations, but
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 167
farms use the same area in the sea. Synergies between activities can also be
evident in other areas: e.g., shared service vessels and onshore infrastructures,
shellfish farming lines can impede access to the space between wind turbines,
which contributes to the security of the area's operation; shellfish lines can calm
the waves somewhat, which reduces pressure on wind turbine structures 110.
4.4.1.4 Maritime transport
Maritime transport is also one of the longer-term uses of the sea, and therefore
the cultural impact of maritime transport is widespread: besides material
heritage (e.g., ancient finds, ships, maritime schools, shipbuilding sites, etc.,)
intangible heritage, which still affects global values (e.g., the sea as freedom
and opportunity) and regional perception of place (regional captains and
captains' villages, home ports or construction sites of legendary ships, etc.)
plays an important role. In Estonia, maritime transport has had very different
purposes - e.g., Baltic German land exploration, from legal friendly trade to
illegal spirit smuggling, from pleasure trips to fleeing the country.
Today's cultural and socio-economic impact of maritime transport is related to
both passenger and freight transport and recreational shipping. Maritime
transport related to the activities planned under the plan is also of a service
nature. The impact of maritime transport in the water area can be manifested
on the water surface (also on ice in the case of ice routes) and partly in the
water column, on anchoring on the seabed. The most important basis for
maritime transport is safety, which affects or even excludes certain other uses
of the sea.
Maritime Spatial Plan reflects known shipping lanes and designates waterborne
traffic areas based on traffic volume and directions elsewhere. Outside these
areas, traffic is allowed, but it depends on the size and natural conditions of the
ship and is rather rare. As a traditional form of marine use, maritime transport
is, at the same time, a domain using the marine area that needs to also
“accommodate” other activities. The operation of shipping lanes, which is
subject to stricter conditions, is therefore essential for maritime transpo rt. At
the same time, other maritime uses can take place in waterborne traffic areas if
there is a corresponding site-specific interest. The guidelines and conditions to
be set have a positive overall and widespread impact on the functioning of
maritime transport and other maritime uses.
Maritime Spatial Plan points out that naturally suitable harbors are often
already in use and stipulates that when designing new small craft harbors, it is
necessary to give priority to naturally suitable locations. In vie w of the land-
sea interactions and the wider socio-economic benefits of the coastal area, it is
advisable to design ports also where, in addition to the port's own services, it
is possible to use other services of the area, visit sights, etc. within a reas onable
110 Maribe project: https://maribe.eu/blue-economy-growth-science-research-aquaculture-
floating-offshore-wind-2/, Maribe final report „Maribe recommendations for future funding
calls in Blue Growth MUS and MUP”.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 168
distance. The need to take into account the functional hinterland of the port
when selecting new small craft harbors is a proposal for the Action Plan: an
input to complement the concept of small craft harbors or to prepare another
development document.
Ports play an important role in land-sea interactions. The plan proposes a
functional classification of ports. The socio-cultural impact assessment also
suggests that the functional classification of new maintenance vessels of marine
use be considered - the needs of new branches in ports may differ slightly from
those of established branches.
The plan also reflects the ice routes typical of the Estonian marine area, also as
marine transport, but there is no need to direct the topic further .
4.4.1.5 Maritime rescue, pollution control and guarding the state border
The need for maritime rescue, pollution control, and guarding the state border
is present throughout the Estonian marine area due to wider social and national
defense needs. In these functions, it is primarily important to ensure coverage
and capability in the marine area.
The plan emphasizes the importance of ensuring maritime rescue capabilities
throughout the water area, which in terms of land-sea interaction, means
systematic planning of accesses and rescue infrastructure across the coastline
(i.e., in cooperation between local governments and across local government
boundaries). As Maritime Spatial Plan increases diversification of the use of
the marine area and intensification of activities, the n eed for marine rescue is
increasing. Addressing the issue is targeted at local government comprehensive
plans while identifying a wider need for both maritime rescue and pollution
control is important already at the national level, also considering what is
planned by the Maritime Spatial Plan: for example, specific sea rescue in the
area (for example, when the plan is implemented, new marine uses are expected
to occur in the waters of the major islands and of western Estonia, which may
require additional and/or region-specific maritime rescue (e.g., potential
dangers are collisions wind turbines, encroachment on aquaculture facilities,
etc.). The analysis of rescue capabilities and needs assessment at the national
level is important in cooperation between the Police and Border Guard Board
and interested parties - the assessment of socio-cultural impact proposes to
consider including such activities in the Action Plan.
Marine pollution response capacity is concentrated mainly in the Tallinn area,
but regional ports must also be prepared for pollution response. The plan
considers it important to increase national pollution control capacity. The plan
also identifies the growing problem of sea litter, but not the measures or
responsible parties to raise awareness and solve the problems. The socio-
cultural impact assessment proposes to include the topic in the Action Plan .
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 169
4.4.1.6 Energy production
The use of the marine area for the development of renewable energy is a new
use of the sea in Estonia and thus an important focus of maritime spatial
planning. As for the region, the greatest potential Estonia has for developing
wind energy is offshore. As energy technologies evolve, the plan points out that
in the longer term, the coastal sea can also be used for cooling and thermal
energy (on a densely populated coast), and in the longer term, wider
opportunities for renewable energy production (e.g., sol ar and wave energy) are
envisaged.
Renewable marine energy has a broader positive and long-term impact. The
design of wind farms has a significant impact on the achievement of national
renewable energy targets and the direction of the carbon -neutral economy.
Wind energy development also plays an important role in generating and
transferring economic and social innovation and opportunities for additional
employment (see also the impact of energy production on the economic
environment in Chapter 4.6.4).
The Maritime Spatial Plan identifies offshore wind farm areas and innovation
areas for the design of wind turbines on floating foundations. In both cases, the
impact occurs both on the water surface, on the water column, and on the
seabed. Wind energy development planning also necessitates the construction
of cable corridors from land to wind farms, with the impact on the seabed. The
Socio-cultural impact in wind farms is manifested by the visual impact on the
water surface and the potential for combined use from the water column to the
seabed. Combined use and visual impacts are important impacts that the IA
focuses on.
The design of wind energy development areas in the plan was carried out by
phased exclusion, where areas that are suitable for natural and wind conditions
are gradually excluded from suitable areas for various reasons. Various national
interests and needs and nature conservation interests have been taken into
account when finding suitable areas for wind farms. The exclusion process has
also taken into account the need to mitigate visual impacts and has set wind
turbines at least 6 nautical miles from the shoreline (the distance of the wind
turbine at the border of the wind zone, closest to the coast is ~ 11.1 km). Based
on the interim decisions made during the exclusion, wind energy will not be
developed in the Gulf of Finland as it is not feasible in the timeline of the
planning. As a result of the exclusion, three development areas have been
identified suitable for wind energy development, which are located in the Baltic
Proper and the Gulf of Riga. The innovation area of wind turbines is farthest
from the coast offshore. Depth variations in wind farm developme nt areas are
outlined, but the planning does not specify the stages/phases which area
suitable for wind farms should be deployed first. The innovation area of wind
turbines can also be immediately deployed. In terms of impact assessment, the
methodology generally takes into account balancing different national interests
and mitigating the local impact. Considering the need to balance national and
local interests, wind turbines may cause visual disturbance for some groups of
residents, despite the distance limitation (see further below for visual impact
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 170
assessment). The infrastructure involved in the design of wind farms (e.g.
cables, substations 111) is expected to have little visual impact.
4.4.1.6.1 Combined use
For wind farms, the possibility of combined use with aquaculture is outlined,
in particular with shellfish and algae farming, but fish farm planning is also
possible.
For additional opportunities for combined use, the Muses project (Multi-use in
European Seas 112) highlights the possibility of combining marine tourism and
wind farms in the Baltic Sea, as well as the combined use of diving and wind
farms in case of high visibility.
A theoretical long-term option is also the combined use of wind farm areas with
other forms of energy as opportunities and technologies develop (including
solar and wave energy).
With regard to combined use, Plan4Blue 113 highlights the risk that the combined
use areas may be designed too intensively: while pursuing multiple objectives,
activities become mutually exclusive or endangering.
From the standpoint of the socio-cultural impact assessment, risks can be
mitigated by combined zoning uses: for example, combined use area for wind
turbines and shellfish, combined use area for wind turbines and marine tourism,
etc. A set of rules can be agreed between interested parties on which parts of
the wind farm can be used for visiting and diving, and under what rules, as well
as which areas of combined use are so-called "closed." Deploying combined
use is a time-consuming activity, and this Maritime Spatial Plan takes the first
steps in implementing combined use. The role of the state in the development
of combined use is support for the development and implementation of rules
and practices, the promotion of bodies/platforms for co-operation and the
setting of rules for possible combined use in the development licensing process
(a similar recommendation is given in the aquaculture chapter for the Action
Plan).
In addition to combined use, the socio-cultural assessment also makes the
following suggestions for renewable energy production planning :
111 Based on the data of Elering AS the bottom area of the offshore substation platform is approximately
100 x 100 m, eg in the case of a 1500 MW station, the height of the building is up to 100 m, but the main
part of it is the high-rise building of about 5-storey house.
112
https://muses-project.eu/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2018/10/D4.3-Sea-Basin-
Syntheses.pdf
113
Ida Maria Bonnevie (2019) Spatial analysis of co -location in MSP, Plan4Blue, Final
conference 4–5 June 2019, presentation.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 171
▪ the introduction of wind farms also requires the design of cable
corridors on the seabed for connection. The proposal is to include, as
a condition for the design of the cable corridors, the n eed for
cooperation with the National Heritage Board (to avoid damaging the
seabed's cultural assets) and the Ministry of Defense (to identify
potential historic explosives and dangerous objects ).
▪ the threshold for introducing a wind energy innovation area is
relatively high, as the area is farthest from the coast. In principle, a
cable connection to the innovation area would also be possible via
the Venstpils-Hall corridor. The proposal is to consider highlighting
the importance of the international corridor in MSP and/or to show
the direction on the figures showing the possible cable connections
(there is currently no connection to the cable corridor in the
innovation area).
▪ to support marine renewable energy innovation on a broader basis
and to include the topic in the Action Plan. It is expedient to develop
cooperation in the field of innovation with Latvia and Finland .
▪ As the distributed generation is being developed globally, the
planning could also consider promoting, for example, the
development of local small-scale distributed generation solutions
(single wind turbines, etc.
4.4.1.6.2 The visual impact of wind turbines
The construction of the wind turbines involves a visual change in the landscape
both at sea and on land, the visual impact is perceived through landscape
change. The importance of the landscape and the visual impact is reflected in
the relation between the extent of the change and the receptivity of its recipient
(i.e. the landscape and the observer) 114.
The effects on the landscape are mostly understood through the effects on and
caused by a person, by understanding the human-perceived surroundings as a
landscape. The landscape is an environment where social and economic
activities take place, creating a basis for the framework of feelings, emotions
and perceptions 115. Arold has pointed out that in folk parlance, a landscape
(field of view) is usually understood as a landscape which surrounds the
observer in its forms and colours. The visible surroundings are named here
according to the visual impression.
There is no legal definition of the concept of landscape in Estonian national
law, but the European Landscape Convention, which entered into force for
Estonia in 2018, defines the landscape as an area, as perceived by people, whose
114 "Guidance material of methodological recommendations for visual impact assessment t o
promote the development of offshore wind farms" (Artes Terrae, 2021), p 7
115
Arold, I. Estonian landscapes, p 9. Tartu Ülikooli Kirjastus 2005.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 172
character is the result of the action and interaction of natural and/or human factors 116.
As the convention applies to the entire territory of a Contracting Party,
including the maritime area, in addition to the land and inland waters, the
Estonian legal space also includes the territorial sea as the landscape.
Estonian legislation does not deal with visual impacts or their assessment, nor
are there any norms or standards for this. The visual impact of the wind turbines
is both an environmental impact and an appropriate social impact under the
Planning Act 117. Therefore, the impact assessment proposes the mitigation
measures for the authorization phase and for further studies.
Background
The visibility of wind turbines from the coast depends on many factors: the
distance, height and location of the wind turbines; the height of the observation
point and the landscape nature of the field of view, etc. The curvature of the
earth will also play a role in the visibility of offshore wind turbines (see Figure
4.4.1.6.2-1 below).
Figure 4.4.1.6.2-1. Impact of the curvature of the earth on visibility: due to the
curvature the visibility of wind turbines decreases, but the visual acuity is
primarily limited by the visual acuity of the human eye 118 (AOD stands for
Above Ordnance Datum,i.e. height above sea level).
The visibility of the wind turbines varies by night/day and weather conditions:
in the dark you can't see the wind turbines, but in the sea you can see the lights
116
European Landscape Convention https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/228022018001, article 1
clause a
117
Ministry of Finance, 2018. Recommendations for the preparation of a comprehensive plan
Chapter 6. The legal framework and principles for the assessment of relevant impacts in this
guidance material also apply to the assessment of the relevant impacts of a maritime spatial
plan as a thematic plan of a national plan.
118
White S., Michaels, S., King, H. (2019) Seascape and visual sensitivity to Offshore wind
farms in Wales: Strategic assessment and guidance. Stage 1 - Ready reckoner of visual
effects related to turbine size. Report No 315
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 173
placed on top of the masts. Cloudy and foggy weather conditions 119 reduce the
visibility of wind turbines, the latter are more visible in contrasting
conditions 120 (e.g. in clear weather at sunset).
The visual impact of seeing the wind turbines depends on the observer's
subjective perception (sensitivity), cultural value and landscape quality
attributed to the observation point or view, extent of the change in view,
previous experience and other factors 121.
The observer's experience is also different: although wind turbines may be a
visual disturbance to some sections of the population, some sections of the
population may be neutral or positive: wind turbines may be interesting and
progressive. Negative and positive experiences can occur at the sa me time (e.g.
wind turbines can be visually disturbing but recognized as necessary). The
perception of the wind turbines as a disturbance can change over time - for
example, getting used to wind farms can reduce the visual impact and make the
new situation normal 122. The visibility of wind turbines and the associated
visual impact are therefore very multifaceted. The visual impact of each
specific wind farm, as well as the combined effect of wind farms, and the
sensitivity of the viewer will be determined during the impact assessment
during each authorization procedure.
Visual impact of wind turbines
The visual impact of the wind turbines is especially evident on the west coast
of Saaremaa, where the smaller wind turbine area (area 3) is located northwest
of the Tagamõisa peninsula and the larger area (area 2) from Vilsandi to Sõrve.
The nearest wind turbine is 6 nautical miles (ca 11.1 km 123). In the Gulf of Riga,
119
See, for example, the Visibility Threshold Study conducted in New York State. New York
State Offshore Wind Comprehensive plan (2017), which took into account the prevailing local
weather conditions by seasons and different times of day and found the probabilities of
visibility of the proposed offshore winds at different distances from the coast.
120
Visibility Threshold Study. New York State Offshore Wind Comprehensive plan (2017),
NYSERDA Report 17-25s; Bishop, I.D., & Miller, D. (2007). Visual assessment of off-shore
wind turbines: The influence of distance, contrast, movement and social variables. Renewable
Energy.
121
Visual impacts have been assessed in the scientific literature on various onshore wind
turbines around the world, with offshore wind farms based primarily on European samples
(Denmark, Germany and the UK) but increasingly also on US offshore wind farms (eg Rhode
Island, Massachusetts and New York).
122
Ladenburg J. (2009) Visual impact assessment of offshore wind farms and prior experience.
Applied Energy.
123
In addition to economic circumstances, the results of the GorWind (2010 –2012,
http://gorwind.msi.ttu.ee/home/info) project survey data have been taken into account in
determining the closest distance of wind tur bine areas from the coast in Estonia, on the basis
of which about 41% of the respondents would accept wind turbines as a distance of 10 km
from the coast (38% remained hesitant). In the planning solution the distance of the wind
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 174
wind turbines have the most visual impact on the island of Ruhnu (distance ~
11 km), the wind farms are also visible from Kolka cape in Latvia (the location
of the nearest possible wind farm in the area is about 21 km), which is why the
impact is cross-border 124. The innovation area is not expected to have a visual
impact on the coastal viewer: there are wind turbines in the wind energy
development area 2 between the innovation area and the coast, and the area is
also furthest from the coast and outside the limit of the resolution of human eye
(50+ km).
The scope and significance of the visual impact will be influenced by the
guidelines and conditions set by the plan. The maritime spatial plan has already
set conditions to reduce the visual impact. The basis for identifying additional
necessary conditions was the guide “Guide to methodologi cal recommendations
for visual impact assessment to promote the development of offshore wind
farms” completed in January 2021 (Artes Terrae, 2021 125), which has also been
used in this impact assessment.
As the draft plan has been supplemented with the starting points for wind
energy planning after its publication (autumn 2020), it is also possible to
analyze the impact of these parameters in more detail. For the purpose of visual
impact assessment the following expected parameters have an impact: the
height of the wind turbines (in the size class of 300 m), the diameter of the rotor
(in the size class of 250 m), the minimum distance between the wind turbines
(min 800 m) and the distance between wind farms (min 2 km). Following the
publication of the main solution of the plan (2020), the scope of the wind energy
development areas found for the first time has also changed slightly.
The impact assessment therefore focused on the visual impact of the wind
turbine parameters and on the guidance material already set and required in the
light of the guidance material. The assessment also highlights the link between
the change in the scope of the wind energy development areas and the visual
impact.
Visual effects due to the height of the wind turbines
The starting point for the maritime spatial plan is the wind turbines in the size
class of 300 m. However, the wind turbines to be built closer to the coast in the
first phase are likely to be lower due to the technologies available on the
turbine areas was determined a little further than the results of the survey: 6 nautical miles
or approx. 11.1 km from the coast.
124 21 km is outside the zone with the greatest impact (see further analysis), but a change in
views is possible. As the wind turbines are expected to remain visible from only one view
(northeast view), this is not a significant impact. The Latvian state has not submitted any
proposals or views on this issue in the framework of cross -border co-operation, although the
wind turbines remain visible.
125
The abbreviation guidance material is used to refer to the document in Chapter 4.4.1.6
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 175
market. Given the models developed today and the rapid development of
technology, the wind turbines closest to the coast are likely to be at least 200
m high 126.
The designing of the wind turbines in the height class of 300 m involves:
▪ the implementation of the plan will have a significant visual impact
in certain areas, both on the coast and inland. Due to the height of
the wind turbines, the impact area is not limited to the coast: the area
with the highest local impact of 300 m high wind turbines is
approximately 20 km from the wind farm (the wind farms are visible
approximately within 50 km 127). The area with the greatest local
impact in case of the development area no 2 thus extends
approximately 9 km to the mainland (see Figure 4.4.1.6.2 -2),
covering a part of Vilsandi National Park and the coastal zone in the
southern direction, including the entire Sõrve Peninsula. The entire
island of Ruhnu remains within the area with the greatest local impact
of the development area no 1.
126
At the stage of the impact assessment it is difficult to say the more precise size class, as
the selection/height of the wind turbine will become clear during the authorization phase. It
is probable that the design of wind turbines in the size class of approx. 250 m will be po ssible,
as the models reaching the market are already in this size class.
127
The scope of the sites is based on guidance material. The area with the greatest local impact
is considered to be ~ 20 km from wind turbines, at or near which the wind turbines of 200 m
and higher can cause significant visual effects. Approximately 50 km is the approximate
visibility distance, this distance should be taken into account when assessing the visual
impact.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 176
Figure 4.4.1.6.2-2. Area with the greatest local impact (approximately 20 km)
and visibility distance (~ 50 km, maximum distance to the human eye in clear
weather) calculated from the outer boundary of the wind energy development
area
▪ The area with the greatest local impact should definitely be considered
as an approximate distance - for example, both the island of Abruka and
the Vätta peninsula are located on the border of the area with the greatest
local impact, and the southern coast of Saaremaa is open to development
area 1. The wind turbines closest to the coast of the development area 1
would be about 21 km from the end of Kolka cape in Latvia, which
makes it possible for the area with the greatest local impact to reach the
Latvian mainland.
▪ The impact will remain significant on the coast even if the wind turbines
with a height of 200-300 m are planned in the farms closest to the coast,
as the primary line of wind turbines is still 11.1 km from the coast. The
extent of the local impact area may change. As the specific heights of
the wind farms to be developed are not known at the planning stage of
the marine area, the impact assessment is based on the height specified
in the plan as a starting point. When planning individual wind farms and
assessing landscapes/visual impacts at the level of authorization, the
scope of the area with the greatest local impact should be specified based
on the location of the specific wind farm, technical parameters, taking
into account the specifics of the landscape, etc.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 177
▪ The wind farms of different heights can be realized within the entire
wind energy development area. The main solution of the plan as of
August 2020 does not provide guidelines that adjacent wind farms
should be of similar height. As the found wind energy development areas
are relatively wide in some places (area 2 max approx. 35 km), the
difference in the height of the wind farms located in the deeper offshore
is not decisive. Visually, the most noticeable is the first row of wind
turbines at different heights when viewed from the coast. This is
especially true for the wind farms closest to the coast - 11.1 km off the
coast.
The assessment of the significance of the impact is based on the analy ses
performed and scientific literature. For example, Sullivan (2013) 128, by
comparing the already built wind farms, found that under good observation
conditions the wind turbines of about 137 m high, 10–16 km from the coast,
clearly attract the viewer's attention with contrast, colour, texture, glow and
movement. Thus, the wind turbines developed to date (with a total height almost
twice as high as in Sullivan's comparative analysis) 129 can be considered to
have the greatest impact at the same distance (the wind turbine dominates
visually). Recent analyses also point out the same 130. As modern higher wind
turbines are still largely undeveloped, the extent of the greatest local impact
presented above is an estimated expert opinion and should therefore be
considered as indicative.
The main possible measure to mitigate the effects of wind turbine altitudes
would be to install the wind turbines offshore. Planning the wind turbines
further offshore (e.g. 20 km off the coast to prevent the area with the greatest
impact from falling to land) would mean the decrease of wind energy
development areas by half. The moving of wind turbines further out to sea can
therefore have a positive effect on reducing visual impacts, but it also increases
the unit cost of renewable energy, which affects th e wider population socio-
economically.
128
Sullivan, R.G., Kirchler,L.B., Cothren, J., Winters, L.J. (2 013) Offshore Wind Turbine
Visibility and Visual Impact Threshold Distances. Environmental Practice, Volume 15.
129
Eg Haliade-X, with a top height of 248 m
130
The expert opinions based on analyses have been provided according to the samples of the
UK, for example, by White Consultants with Northumbria University, 2020. Offshore Energy
Strategic Environmental Assessment. Review and Update of Seascape and Visual Buffer study
for Offshore Wind farms. Final report for Hartley Anderson. The guide compiled by Arte s
Terrae (2020) also refers to this topic.
.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 178
The depth of Estonia's sea area is increasing rapidly as it moves away from the
coast, which is a significant obstacle to the development of wind energy. By
considering Estonia's renewable energy and climate goals and the strategic
direction for renewable energy, it is not in the country's interest to reduce the
development areas of wind energy to such a significant extent. In addition, as
the wind turbines up to 300 m high can be designed, wind turbines would st ill
be visible 20 km from the coast.
As a planning measure the next step would be to selectively design wind
turbines for deeper seas in those coastal areas that are known to be the most
valuable: near potential landscapes of national importance, i.e. Vilsandi
National Park and Ruhnu Island. If the wind turbines were moved to a distance
of approx. 20 km from the coast in these valuable landscapes, the result would
be analogous to the above: the development areas of wind energy would
decrease significantly, which again does not support Estonia's renewable
energy and climate goals.
In addition, it can be pointed out from White Consultants et al. (2020) 131 that
the significance of the impact on landscapes and thus the need for mitigation
measures depends on how sensitive the landscape is to change. The sensitivity
of the landscape depends on both the value of the landscape and the planned
activity (extent of change). However, the highest class of valuable landscape
(e.g. potential landscape of national importance or national park) does not mean
that the landscape is automatically the most sensitive or equally susceptible.
At the time of the impact assessment the value classes and general descriptions
of the landscapes are known on the basis of the thematic plan Environmental
conditions guiding settlement and land use (2007) of the county which first
addressed the topic of Saare county plan and valuable landscapes. However, the
descriptions of the landscapes are not sufficiently precise and focused for the
design of offshore wind turbines, there are no descriptions of the views (see
explanation below). During the preparation of the maritime spatial plan the
largest extent of the wind energy development areas is also known, however,
the location of wind turbines (which also depends on the more detailed studies
and analyses based on the conditions of the plan) and exact parameters (to be
found out at the authorization stage) are unknown.
The landscape sensitivity assessment can therefore be carried out at the level
of the authorization procedure. The moving of wind turbines farther to the sea
to a smaller extent (e.g. by a few km, in a certain section, at a certain angle,
etc.), reducing the height of the wind turbines, colouring the wind turbines, etc.
may be one of the mitigation measures also in the context of the impact
assessment conducted during the authorization phase. The topic of landscape
131
Sama, mis eelmine.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 179
sensitivity has been explained in more detail in the Guide to Visual Impact
Assessment 132.
It is important that the sensitivity assessment is based on an additional analysis
/ inventory of the affected landscapes, including a review of the already
identified valuable landscapes.
It can be seen from Figure 4.4.1.6.2-2 above that several of the valuable
landscapes determined by the Saare County Plan 2030+ remain in the zone with
the greatest local impact. As the zone with the greatest local impact may be
wider, other coastal landscapes (e.g. potential landscapes of national
importance Abruka, landscapes of the southern coast of Saaremaa), from which
the wind energy development areas are visible, may also be significantly
affected.
The inventory of the landscapes is important in order to create a renewed
common basis on which to base more detailed planning and impact assessments
of different wind farms. As the treatment of valuable landscapes in Saare
county plan is land-centric and the status quo in the marine area is not expected
to change significantly, the description of coastal landscapes is sometimes
rather general. One of the valuable components of landscapes is the beautiful
views of the sea, but their content is not sufficiently explained. The mapping
carried out in the framework of the impact assessment of the maritime spatial
plan (see below) revealed that certain usable viewing points are missing from
the county plan, therefore the information may be somewhat inaccurate or
changed.
The need for an inventory is also due to the fact that a general mapping based
on one methodology is required, rather than mapping by different developers
and presumably based on a different methodology. As several wind farms are
expected to be visible from one valuable landscape, it is not practical for
different developers to map the same onshore area multiple times. It is possible
to carry out the inventory of landscapes, for example, within the framework of
the comprehensive plan of Saare local municipality to be prepared or at another
more general level or in cooperation with developers by areas. When
inventorying/ assessing landscapes, it is expedient to take into account the
existing mapping (incl county valuable landscapes, mapping of viewing points
carried out within the framework of this impact assessment). The focus could
be primarily on coastal landscapes, from which the planned wind energy
development areas can be seen (up to approx. 5 km inland).
132
See in more detail “Guidance material of methodological recommendations for visual
impact assessment to promote the development of offshore wind farms”, AB Artes Terrae
OÜ, 2020.
http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/dokumendid/Uuringud/Meretuuleparkide_visuaalse_ m%C3%B
5ju_hindamise_juhend_final.pdf
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 180
In addition, in order to reduce the visual impact on the wind farms closest to
the coast (11.1 km), it is considered to add a guideline or condition that the
design of wind turbines of the same altitude is preferred.
Breakdown of wind areas
The approach to maritime spatial planning creates the potential to mitigate the
visual impacts by setting a guideline: the horizon must be sectioned (i.e. not
completely covered by a wind farm). The plan also states that wind turbines
should be located in as compact a group as possible (i.e. not scattered, but
concentrated). These conditions are interpreted in the impact assessment as the
planning of areas free of wind turbines in the wind energy development areas.
The possibility of planning wind turbine free areas and their width will become
clear during the superficies licence procedure and on the basis of more detailed
analyses (incl. landscape analysis).
It is probable that the found wind energy development areas do not completely
overlap with the wind farms, according to the plan to the extent of approx. 70%.
In terms of visual impact assessment this also creates the potential for the
breakdown of wind areas. This principle has also been taken into account in the
plan, by setting the general guideline that the areas/corridors free of wind
turbines will be created in the development areas of wind energy due to
different interests, which should perform as many different functions as
possible.
At the time of the impact assessment only one waterway corridor is known that
could act as an articulator for the observer on the coast: Ringsu -Roomassaare
waterway is planned (approx. 2 km minimum) through the wind energy
development area 1. It is also known that wind farms should have a minimum
distance of 2 km, but it is not known where these are located in the wind energy
development areas. At the same time, the min 2 km wide distances between the
wind farms and the given fairway width may not be sufficient to create a
perceptible articulation of the horizon and the area free of wind turbines in both
areas 1 and 2. In other words, the area free of wind turbines should be wider to
perceive the articulation. The location of wind turbines also depends on more
detailed research and analysis at the level of the authorization based on the
conditions of the plan.
The extent of the areas free of wind turbines can be analyzed in more detail, if
more information is available as part of the authorization procedure. As much
of the more detailed information will be provided at the authorization level, the
impact assessment will focus on which coastal areas need to be addressed in
order to find the possibilities to retain the wind turbine-free areas when locating
the wind turbines.
As part of the impact assessment the mapping of coastal views was carried out,
based on the beautiful views of the county-wide spatial plans and the coastal
sites of the Island Geopark. The additional viewing points were added to the
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 181
established class I valuable landscapes (if not mentioned in the county plan 133)
and additional viewing points that emerged from the Instagram mapping. The
sights were mapped as cultural and landscape values, the preservation of which
is important for both local and regional visitors.
In case of the found sights the distance of the viewing point from the wind area
and the presence / absence of free viewing directions was determined and the
significance of the effect on the viewing point in the combined effect of these
features was assessed. In addition, social media mapping was conducted on
Instagram, which provided quantitative information on how many view ing
points are estimated to be used and qualitative information on which values
were associated with one or the other viewing point 134. As a result of the visual
impact assessment the following Figure 4.4.1.6.2-3 has been completed, the
summary table of the analysis has been provided in Annex 3.
The mapping results indicate that for wind turbines in the size class of 300 m
in height, the sites with the greatest local impact shown in Figure 4.4.1.6. -3 are
the most affected, the wind area is closest to the coast and there are few
windmill less views (red arrows in the diagram below). Such view ing points
are located on the west coast of Saaremaa from the bank of Elda to the top of
the Sõrve foothills (no. 16–29 135) and in Ruhnu (no. 42). The view of Ruhnu
Island is also cumulatively affected by the wind energy development areas
planned in other maritime spatial plans (in the maritime areas of Pärnu and
Latvia). The impact on these views is significant and the impact assessment
addresses these coastal sections in more detail below.
133
For example, the seaviews have been set out as the value of Ruhnu Island, but no views
were mentioned in the county planning materials.
134
The mapping of social media was carried out on the basis of Instagram, the res ults of the
mapping have been provided in Annex 3. Although there are some restrictions on the use of
social media (eg younger and middle-aged users), users provide so-called direct and voluntary
qualitative information on what the coast and sea area mean to them. Due to the nature of
social media, posts that share a positive emotion dominate; sharing negative (unpleasant, sad,
etc.) emotions is rather underrepresented. The mapped values primarily reflect the aesthetic,
identity and recreational values of the coast and the sea, historical-cultural, especially in
terms of tangible objects (eg lighthouses, ships, etc.), but less so in terms of intangible culture
(place perception, stories, customs, etc).
135 Excluding viewing point 17
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 182
Figure 4.4.1.6.2-3. Results of the analysis of the viewing points carried out
during the visual impact assessment (for more information on the number
provided for each viewing point, see the analysis table, see Annex 3).
In addition to the sights that have been assessed as having a significant impact,
it is necessary to consider viewing points 12, 15, 17 and 30 136 in the area with
the greatest local impact (orange arrows in the figure) for more detailed
planning of wind farms.
As the extent of the area with the greatest local impact is given in the plan as
approximate, the mapping also distinguishes the viewing points that are approx.
20–27.5 km away from the wind energy development area 137. Such viewing
points are, for example, Abruka (no. 36, including the landscape of potential
national importance), as well as Kolka cape (no. 48, international impact),
which may need further planning precisely as these are located directly on the
border of the area with the greatest local impact of the development area 1. It
is reasonable to pay attention to viewing points 13 and 14 as these are located
in a potential landscape of national importance. In case of view ing points 37
and 38 on the southern coast of Saaremaa, it is also appropriate to specify the
magnitude of the impact.
136 The mapping of the views carried out in the framework of the Maritime spatial Plan
(Annex 3) is the input and background information for the impact assessment of the marine
area.
137 The range of 20-27.5 km is considered to be a moderately affected area. The distances of
20 and 27.5 km have been determined on the basis of previous surveys (see Annex 3)
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 183
The remaining mapped viewing points are located more than 27.5 km from the
wind area and, due to the distance, the impact on the viewing points is expected
to be moderate or insignificant. The viewing points in the area with the greatest
local impact in the development area 2 (no. 31-33) are also classified in this
class. The views of these sights open to the Gulf of Riga, so in case of the
impact on these viewing points the visibility of the development area 1 has been
taken into account.
In order to mitigate the visual impact in the viewing points where the impact is
significant, when locating the wind turbines it is necessary to look for
opportunities to leave areas free of wind turbines in the coasta l sections of the
west coast of Saaremaa and the northern part of Ruhnu in the areas suitable for
the development of wind energy. As the west coast of Saaremaa is densely
covered with beautiful viewing points, an area free of wind turbines in the wind
energy development area cannot be created above every viewing point at sea.
Spatially, however, there are certain coastal sections where the most significant
sights are concentrated: from the end of Sõrve foothill to Kaunispen, on the
beautiful seafront section of Lõmala-Kaugatoma road 138, in Tiirimetsa-
Kaugatoma region and from Elda peninsula to Pilguse Bay.
The proposal of the impact assessment is to pay attention to the possibility
of leaving / creating a wind-turbine-free area in the three coastal sections
of the west coast of Saaremaa, as well as in the northern tip of Ruhnu (see
the following figure). With more detailed planning of wind farms, it may
become apparent that there is no need or opportunity to leave / cr eate areas free
of wind turbines. Therefore, a wind-turbine-free area may not be created over
every stretch of coastline shown in the figure. Given the curvature of the
coastline, the wind-turbine-free area may already be provided in some
directions from the wind farm development area (e.g. between the coastline and
the wind energy development area), but the issue needs further analysis at the
authorization stage.
138
The road was designated as a beautiful section of the road in the thematic plan
Environmental conditions guiding the settlement and land use . The new county plan does not
reflect beautiful road sections, but the thematic plan opens the background for determining
beautiful views.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 184
Figure 4.4.1.6.2-4. Coastal areas where, due to the concentration of views, it
is necessary to look for possibilities to leave the area free of wind turbines
On the one hand, the proposal stems from providing more flexibility in the
design of the wind-turbine-free area in a situation where a large part of the
information affecting the location of the wind turbines (e.g. more detailed
studies, analyses, etc.) becomes apparent in the next planning stage.
On the other hand, the proposal also stems from the fact th at the level of
accuracy of the mapping does not differ the viewing points so clearly that it is
possible to give a clear preference to each other (the use of the viewing point
of the top of Sõrve foothills comes out vigorously, but as stated above, there
are also more free viewing sectors from this viewing point).Thus, in addition
to the mapping carried out with the previous county plan, the more detailed
landscape analysis 139 of the view is needed to specify the effects, as well as the
opinion of the local government / community (incl how many viewing points
are used by the local government in the general plan). The mapping carried out
can therefore be used as a guide to the decision. The involvement of local
139
For example, some viewing points also have significant views of the islands and
peninsulas, others to a lesser extent. Landscape features and details are not as accurately
mapped in the current level of mapping accuracy. Also, since it is possible to design about
300 m high wind turbines, which can be seen over mainland, it is all the more important to
have visualizations to analyze the visibility of t he wind turbines.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 185
people in landscape decision-making is supported by the approach of the
Landscape Convention.
The location and extent of the area free of wind turbines should be specified by
the landscape architect at the stage of the authorization and in cooperation with
the local government, including by preparing the visualizations that take into
account the parameters of a specific wind farm(s). The visual impact
assessment guide also provides instructions for making visualizations. As the
planning / leaving of a wind-turbine-free area is expected to affect several wind
farms, it is necessary to consider the free area cumulatively.
The analysis of the abandonment / creation of a wind -turbine-free area in one
of the coastal sections shown can be carried out with more detailed planning,
for example as follows:
1. to find out possible locations of wind turbines in the wind farm:
a. to find the primary location of wind turbines, taking into account various
factors that preclude the location of wind turbines. At this stage it should be
clarified whether the wind farm will become relatively compact or whether
there will be sparser areas in the park, where there is a corridor with at least 2
km width between different wind farms, and so on.
2. in case of the found location of the wind turbines, analyze whether it is
necessary and where it is possible to leave / create an area free of wind turbines.
To take into account the landscape analysis of the views of the coastal section
and the visual impact on the views, to use visualizations.
a. The need to leave the area free of wind turbines is when the location
of the wind turbines significantly affects the views of the coastal viewing
points (i.e. the impact on the main direction / most valuable direction
from the viewing point is significant).
b. If necessary, consider the possibility of leaving the area free of wind
turbines: for example, the area free of wind turbines may pass through
the wind farm, the area free of wind turbines may form a corridor
between different wind farms (or the waterway corridor) or the area free
of wind turbines will not be left.
c. The area free from wind turbines is not left, for example, if the wind
farm is evenly dense (there are no sparse areas in the area that would
support leaving / creating a free area).
2. To cooperate with the local government and the community in leaving /
creating wind-free areas.
3. To cumulatively consider other proposed wind farms.
4. To document the course of the analysis of wind-turbine-free areas so that
the decision-maker can follow the bases of considerations.
Another way to mitigate the impact on viewing points in the degree of precision
of a maritime spatial plan is to compensate- this means that wind-turbine-free
areas are not planned in the wind energy development areas and a significant
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 186
change in views will be compensated in justified cases and on the basis of
legislation (e.g. through the proposed local benefit instrument). The
articulations in the development areas may occur for other reasons (e.g.
corridor between wind farms, waterway, etc.), but landscape values in the form
of views are not considered separately in this case. From the point of view of
impact assessment this is not the preferred method, as it is possible to conflict
with the guideline set by the plan itself: the horizon should be articulated (i.e.
not completely covered by the wind farm). In addition, the opinion of the local
government (community) on this is very important for the acceptance of the
wind farms.
The plan has already paid attention to the compact (concentrating) arrangement
of wind turbines. At the same time the visual impact assessment guide has also
identified the condition that also supports the creation of wind-turbine-free
areas in the wind areas: to avoid the formation of small groups of wind
turbines on the outskirts of the wind farm, which appear to be separate sets
from the main wind turbine row. The impact assessment proposes to include
this in the planning as a condition for the authorization phase.
Wind turbine formations
Different formations are possible when designing the wind farms (see Figure
4.4.1.6.2-5). In case of the built environment, Maslov et al. (2017) 140 point out
that a regular and symmetrical arrangement is visually more pleasing than a
chaotic (random) arrangement. The symmetrical regular arrangements are
therefore preferred for visual impact mitigation.
140 Maslov jt (2017). Evaluating the Visual Impact of an Offshore Wind Farm. Energy
Procedia, Volume 105
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 187
Figure 4.4.1.6.2-5. Wind farm formations 141
At the same time a regular and thus more pleasant arrangement can open up in
a few directions to the observer standing on the shore - even if the wind turbines
are placed along straight or diagonal lines, the wind turbines aligned behind
each other are visible for the viewer on the shore only in case of few rows or
diagonals (see Figure 4.4.1.6.2-6). As the angle of view increases, the
symmetry of the wind turbine placement inevitably decreases and the wind
turbines are irregularly located in the sea area for the observer.
Figure 4.4.1.6.2-6. The placement and angle of view of the wind turbines affect
visual symmetry / irregularity (Source: Scott et al. 142). In a conventional grid,
141
Nak Joon Choi, Sang Hyun Nam, Jong Hyun Jeong and Kyung Chun Kim (2014).CFD
Study on Aerodynamic Power Output Changes with Inter -Turbine Spacing Variation for a 6
MW Offshore Wind Farm settings. Energies 2014, 7(11), 7483-7498
142 Scott, K.E., Anderson, C., Dunsford, H., Benson, J.F. and MacFarlane, R. (2005). An
assessment of the sensitivity and capacity of the Scottish seascape in relation to
offshorewindfarms. Scottish Natural Heritage Commissioned Report No.103 (ROAME No.
F03AA06).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 188
regular lines of wind turbines appear in the cent re of the view, but not at the
edge of the view.
In addition, the irregularity may be exacerbated by the fact that wider wind
energy development areas (e.g. the northern part of no. 2) are developed by
different developers who, due to the specific nature of the seabed and other
factors, may wish to change the formation of the wind turbines ( e.g. to place
their wind turbine rows under another angle, etc. compared to the coastal
formation). In terms of visual impact it is therefore possible that when viewed
from the coast, there may be no view of the wind turbines located in a regular
way.
To illustrate how the regularly arranged wind farm looks from different coastal
viewing points, an example by Maslov et al. (2017) of the location, viewing
points and visual profiles of the Saint-Nazare (France) wind farm (Figure
4.4.1.6.2-7 a; b) has been provided. In the example of Saint-Nazare, the wind
turbines are 80 m high and the distance between the wind turbines is 1 km. The
wind farm is about 10-30 km away from the different viewing points on the
coast.
As shown by the figures of Maslov et al. the formations are better distinguished
from observation points closer to the wind farm. In case of views opening from
the viewing points 5, 6 and 8, the formation has both regular sections with wind
turbines aligned behind each other and irregular sections. The existence of
regular sections is expected to alleviate some of the visual impact on those
sections of the coast where large areas of wind turbines near the coast are
planned.
In case of more distant observation points the ability to distinguish formations
decreases (e.g. points 2, 3 and 10 in the figure and the corresponding visual
profiles below) or the importance of the formations is less important due to the
distance from the wind turbine area (viewing point 4).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 189
Figure 4.4.1.6.2-7 a;b. The observation points on the French coast and the
opening possible wind turbine formations (the point number on the map
corresponds to the number of the visual profile on the right vertical axis of the
lower diagram. The left vertical axis represents the perceived height at the
horizon and the horizontal axis the perceived distance. The diagram explains
the difference in views of the same wind farm from different specific viewing
points).
However, the regular placement of wind turbines behind each other can have
an additional negative effect - the so-called wheel effect, where the rotor blades
of wind turbines lined up behind each other overlap and the “rotating wheel”
appears on the horizon that attracts the observer's attention. When planning the
wind farms more precisely, the wheel effect should therefore be avoided if
possible 143.
The impact assessment suggests considering the inclusion of a condition in
the plan that when developing the wind farms of different developers, it is
recommended to use regular formations where possible, which would
reduce the visual impact of the wind turbines. Also it is recommended to
avoid the wheel effect, if possible.
143 The given guideline is also provided by the guidance material.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 190
The location of the wind farms is also taken into account in the guidance
material prepared in the framework of the preparation of the mari time spatial
plan, which sets out guidelines both for individual wind farms and for the se to
be taken into account cumulatively when planning several wind farms in the
same field of view. The formations of the wind farms should be addressed
within the impact assessment to be carried out during the authorization
phase.
Impact from the diameter of wind turbine rotors
The diameter of the rotors also increases with the height of the wind turbines.
The rotor diameter of the wind turbines is related to the distance between the
wind turbines (minimum 800 m). It follows that since the wind farms of
different heights (and rotor diameters) may coexist in the wind energy
development areas, it is also likely that the farms of different densities will
coexist.
▪ From a coastal point of view, no additional visual impacts are expected
if only one farm with the same parameters is realized in the full depth of
the found wind energy development area or if the wind farm planned for
a deeper offshore area is of the same density. In this case it is expected
to be easier to arrange the wind turbine formations more regularly.
▪ Additional visual effects may occur if the wind farms planned behind
each other have different densities and there may be several formations.
This is most likely in the northern part of the wind area 2, where the
width of the suitable wind area is about 35 km and it is expected that 2
or more wind farms can be planned from the coast towards the open sea.
Due to the creation of several formations these development areas may
appear to be less regular when viewed from the coast.
When planning the wind farms in more detail and assessing the visual impact,
it should therefore be borne in mind that adjacent farms or the ones located
behind each other may have different densities and may form several formations
that may appear less regular when viewed from the coast.
Additional conditions for visual impact assessment
On the basis of the guidance material for the assessment of the visual impacts
of offshore wind farms prepared within the framework of the preparation of a
maritime spatial plan, it is expedient to set the following additional guidelines
or conditions in the plan.
With regard to the general conditions it is recommended to emphasize the need
to take into account the combined effect of wind farms in the plan. As the wind
energy development areas are relatively large and the areas are expected to be
divided into several farms, it is very important to consider the combined effect
in order to mitigate the visual effects. The importance of synergies has also
become apparent in case of the previously analyzed topics.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 191
The guidance material covers the various aspects of visual impact and impact
assessment in detail, including the examples of international experience. On the
basis of the guidance material it is appropriate to bring those conditions to
which it is important to pay particular attention to the authorization level.
At the level of authorization it is important in the process that the visual impact
assessment is carried out methodologically, in accordance with the developed
guidance material and by an expert in the field. During the process it is
necessary that the methodological assessment of the visual impact starts at an
early stage in the development of the wind farm. This helps to achieve the
optimal placement of the wind turbines through the process. As mentioned in
the previous impact assessment, the involvement of the local community/
government is very important.
The guidance material on which it is based need not be compiled by Artes
Terrae (2021), but may be an equivalent recognized methodology. As other
recognized methodologies can be used, it is not necessary to duplicate the more
detailed steps of the analysis in the explanatory memorandum, as the
instructions / sequence of work may slightly differ.
However, as one of the important tools for the wind farm designing is the
production of visualizations, it is useful to set out in the explanatory
memorandum the principles that visualisations must generally comply with, in
particular truthfulness and verifiability. The steps used to create more detailed
visualizations can already be based on the instructions used and it is not
necessary to duplicate these in the explanatory memorandum.
Based on the guidelines the definitions of the area with the local greatest
impact and range of vision have been used in the framework of the impact
assessment, approx. 20 and 50 km of the found wind energy development area,
respectively. As such zones provide important information on the design of the
wind turbines in the size class of 300 m, consider including them in the plan.
Change in the scope of wind energy development areas
After the public display (spring 2020) the wind energy development area 3
(northwest of Harilaiu) has been removed from the plan, the scope of the
development areas 1 and 2 has slightly decreased.
The removal of the wind energy development area 3 from the plan means that
the impact on Vilsandi National Park as a potential valuable landscape of
national importance will decrease and the view from the west and north, which
are the main viewing directions of the place, will not change from the viewing
point above Harilaiu lighthouse. However, as it is possible to design the wind
turbines in the size class of 300 m in height, the wind farms in the wind energy
development area 2 are expected to be visible in certain directions from
Harilaiu area (see the analysis above).
The wind energy development area 2 has slightly decreased from the southern
tip, which thus shortens the range of the wind farms visible from the tip of
Sõrve foothills. The change has a small but positive effect in terms of visual
effects.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 192
The wind energy development area 1 has been slightly adjusted from the
southwestern tip, which slightly reduces the visibility of wind farms from
Ruhnu Island. The wind turbines would also be a few kilometres away from the
important viewing point on Kolka cape in Latvia. However, as up to 300 m high
wind turbines can be designed, the wind turbines are still visible (see the
analysis above).
4.4.1.7 Sea tourism and recreation
Sea tourism and recreation is a growing and increasingly diversified area of
maritime use. The interest groups in the field are both Estonian -based and
international. Recreation has strong land-sea interactions, as more common
activities take place on the beach (e.g., beach use, bathing) or rather near the
coast (water sports, recreational fishing), and some sports can also take place
in wider sea areas (e.g., sailing regattas). Both seaports and small craft ports
are important for the functioning of marine tourism.
Maritime Spatial Plan does not designate marine tourism and recreational areas,
but sets up supportive conditions, in particular with a view to the need for the
combined use of the marine area. The plan supports the provision of
recreational facilities in the overall level of accuracy of national planning (e.g.,
ensuring access to the sea, planning small craft harbors, etc.), but site -based
planning is largely done through comprehensive plans.
Although much of the recreation area is planned on the land use plans of local
governments, it is likely that user groups will expect the preservation of the
status quo in the marine area. Maritime county cultural mapping in the context
of Maritime Spatial Plan (June 2018) gave different input as in what marine
area means to people: space, openness, and peace; the sea as a grounding means
and a place for organizing thoughts, etc. Environmental psychologists have
pointed out that the sea has a psychologically restoring impact on attention and
concentration, which includes feelings of absence (mental distance from
everyday life and disturbances) and fascination (effortless redirection of
attention) 144. Based on the above, user groups can be expected to expect
preservation of a " switchable environment " on most of the coast, both for
activities with softer values (e.g., sunset watching) and creative activities (e.g.,
photography and other arts). Devine-Wright (2009) points out that there is
socio-cultural opposition to new developments (including energy projects)
when they disrupt the emotional connections or identity creation related to a
place 145. The socio-economic interest in preserving the switching environment
is also expected to apply to companies that have made investment decisions
based on the vicinity of the sea or the sea view. Therefore, in terms of maritime
144
Vt nt Hartig, Korpela, Evans, & Garling, 1996; Kaplan, Kaplan, &Brown, 1989; J. Aaron
Hippa,*, Oladele A. Ogunseitan, 2011.
145
Devine-Wright (2009), Rethinking NIMBYism: The Role of PlaceAttachment and Place
Identity inExplaining Place-protective Action. Journal of Community & Applied Social
Psychology.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 193
tourism and recreation (but also in terms of broader identity creation), the
consideration of visual impacts (e.g., the impact of wind turbines, in particular,
Chapter 4.4.1.6.2), as well as noise, plays an important role. It is also important
to consider the interests of local governments when planning activities in the
marine area and to give them the opportunity to have a say in planning
decisions. This topic has been specified in the wind energy guidelines in the
planning solution after its publication (autumn 2020). The need to mitigate the
visual effects has also been provided in the maritime tourism and recreation
chapter of the plan.
Implementing the Maritime Spatial Plan would also create new opportunities
for marine tourism and combined use of the areas - e.g., visiting wind and
aquaculture farms and farms as potential new diving sites (see Chapters 4.4.1.3
and 4.4.1.6). Using this opportunity also means addressing the issue of "
ownership " of the sea to a large extent: although the marine area is state
property, there is a legitimate interest for planners of permanent maritime
activities to know and control what takes place in the marine area they use in
terms of security and property conservation. The overarching assessment of the
socio-cultural impact assessment is, therefore, that enabling the combined use
of the marine space requires the development of new rules and practices, with
the support of the state.
The impact of offshore travel and sailing tourism is covered in Chapter 4.4.1.4
Maritime Transport.
4.4.1.8 Cultural Monuments
Several wrecks are protected as cultural monuments in the Estonian marine
area. Wrecks are part of the wider maritime cultural heritage, and their survival
is in the wider public interest. The relatively small community (divers,
underwater archaeologists, rescuers) has a real opportunity to visit the wrecks
and is therefore not a public good consumed by a wider public. At the same
time, diving communities are international, and there is also international
interest in Estonian wrecks.
What is planned at a marine area may have a direct physical impact on the
wrecks: e.g., activities may endanger the survival or good condition of the
wreck; indirectly, what is planned may also have an impact on the wreck's
preservation environment or water quality.
In Maritime Spatial Plan, wrecks have been valued throughout, and conditions
have been set to ensure that wrecks remain as they are. The u pdated planning
solution as of June 2020 defines preservation areas for archaeological finds (wrecks) in
the deeper marine area where there is no conflict with other important marine uses146.
The designation of preservation areas ensures clearer rules, and also provides a direct
spatial opportunity for the preservation of archaeological monuments. The need to
146
Due to the complexity and cost of transporting wrecks it is advisable to relocate them to
the storage area as close as possible, if necessary.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 194
involve the National Heritage Board in several uses of the sea has also been
highlighted. The Impact Assessment has, where appropriate, made proposals in
the above chapters to clarify the conditions for the preservation of cultural
monuments.
Maritime Spatial Plan favors the creation of so-called "diving parks" in high
visibility marine areas, which support the possibility of exploring wrecks more
widely and practicing diving as water sports. It also allows directing diving
activities to wrecks. Maritime Spatial Plan thus has a positive impact both on
the preservation of wrecks and on access to cultural sites . When specifying the
main solution of the planning solution, the condition has also been added that
diving competence is essential by the diving of wrecks (competent instructor,
diving permit), which supports more informed practices when diving to the
wrecks and thus maintaining the condition of the wrecks.
IA wishes to point out that not all wrecks in the marine area have been
recognized as cultural monuments, but that does not mean that wrecks have no
cultural value. Preservation of this value is currently not reflected in the
broader chapter on marine culture or the chapter on cultural monuments. The
socio-cultural impact assessment proposes to treat the seabed cultural assets as
a single chapter, covering both monuments and non-protected wrecks.
4.4.1.9 Other uses of the sea, and land-sea interactions
Maritime spatial Planning also identifies protected natural sites, national
defense, mineral resources, dumping, and permanent links as separate thematic
areas and seabed infrastructures.
Protecting natural objects has both positive and negative social and cultural
implications. Nature conservation is needed more broadly to preserve a clean
marine and living environment, protection of specific sites to preserve marine
biodiversity, which is why nature conservation is generally and more widely
needed to meet people's social and cultural needs. Maritime Spatial Plan also
takes into account the existing protected areas.
Similarly, to terrestrial planning, conflicts between nature conservation and
marine activities that are considered socio-economically necessary may arise
in the marine area. Maritime Spatial Plan sets out conditions for mitigating the
conflict, highlighting the need to consider other interests and need for combined
use in the design of new protected areas, while also assessing socio-economic
impact. Planning thus has a positive impact on enabling combined use.
Maritime spatial Planning highlights the areas used for national defense that
are mainly concentrated along the Gulf of Finland. Additional special areas of
national defense may be created if necessary. Other activities in national
defense areas are not unequivocally excluded: there is a time limit for combined
use during exercises, but at other times the areas are open for navigation. Due
to the specific nature of national defense exercises, no objects/facilities that
could be damaged by the exercises (e.g., fish cages, aquaculture farm lines) can
be located in the special national defense areas. Areas used by national defense
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 195
thus have both positive and negative impacts on the combined use of the marine
space and the consideration of the needs of different stakeholders .
Infrastructures on the seabed are necessary to ensure energy transmission.
The plan outlines the planned submarine cable lines between the main islands ,
in the long run the submarine cables may also occur in the coastal sea on the
coasts of the densely populated areas, if the coastal sea is used for cooling/ he at
energy. The maritime spatial plan does not specify the exact locations of the
cables, but guides action through guidelines and conditions: spatial aggregation
of cables and cooperation with other stakeholders is important to reduce and
avoid conflicts (e.g. consideration of cultural heritage) and increase safety (e.g.
cable covering / burial, historical explosives to be identified).
The plan identifies mineral deposits and guides the further development of this
branch through mineral resources guidelines and conditions. The conditions
for the use of mineral resources are also aimed at enabling combined use, taking
into account fish spawning grounds, cultural sites, nature conservation sites,
and waterways. The designation of new deposits and mining reserves shall not
be deemed to alter the planning. In principle, therefore, it is possible to
designate new deposits also in areas where other interests have been identified.
The socio-cultural impact assessment proposes to consider the need to
complement the conditions in terms of other potential interests (including
threats) (e.g., the need for cooperation with the Ministry of Defense on
historical explosives, etc.).
Dumping in the marine area takes place to discharge dredged material into the
sea. Maritime Spatial Plan outlines existing dumping areas, and it is also
possible to design new dumping areas based on established guidelines.
Dumping is not permitted in very shallow marine areas. The conditions for
dumping are regulated by law.
Maritime Spatial Plan highlights the need for permanent connections but does
not explicitly set guidelines or conditions: the permanent connections of both
Tallinn-Helsinki and Saaremaa are planned as separate plans and to a greater
degree of accuracy than national Maritime Spatial Plan. Permanent
connections, however, have a very important direct and indirect (social,
economic, cultural) impact on land-sea interactions. Maritime Spatial Plan
highlights the most important land-sea interactions by topic, based on spatial
interfaces. As Estonian marine areas are relatively diverse, the socio -cultural
impact assessment proposes to supplement the Plan with the introduction of
more regionally location-based land-sea interactions (see Figure 4.4.1.9-1).
The development of land-sea clusters is based on the Estonian Regional
Development Strategy 2014-2020, the newly developed maritime strategies of
the counties (2018-2019), and the cultural mapping of the maritime counties
carried out in the framework of Maritime Spatial Plan. These clusters are based
on the direct visions and development directions of the county strategies (e.g.,
the development of the Tallinn-Helsinki twin city in Harju County) as well as
analytical generalizations based on the development strategy (e.g., Ida -Viru
County as the Estonian adventure tourism region and ranking second as a place
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 196
to visit after Harju County). The cultural mapping carried out in the context of
the Maritime Spatial Plan provided input on regional specificities, strengths,
and potential.
As county development strategies have recently been drafted, it is advisable to
discuss and further develop land-sea clusters in the preparation of Estonia's new
regional development strategy.
Figure 4.4.1.9-1. Land-sea clusters
Preventing or mitigating significant socio-cultural negative impacts have
already been taken into account in the design of the Maritime Spatial Plan. The
following are suggestions for further mitigating changes that are perceived
negatively by some stakeholders/individuals. Implementation of the plan will
have a long-term positive impact on the social and cultural environment.
Combined use, enabling and innovative planning plays a key rol e in leveraging
the positive impact. The suggestions below also reflect the potential for
leveraging positive impact.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
Suggestions to improve the planning solution:
1. In cases where statutory licensing processes do not reflect cooperation
with stakeholders, consider including a clause in MSP that also takes
into account fishermen's interest in applying for aquaculture licenses: to
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 197
avoid having a negative impact on the most used and yield rich fishing
grounds.
2. Consider introducing the joint use of wind farms and fish farming in the
chapter of fish farms of the main solution.
3. Consider including a condition that both fishermen and local government
should be involved in decision-making processes in order to increase
synergies and prevent/mitigate conflicts in the aquaculture sector, in
case in the current legal space procedural processes do not reflect this
need.
4. Consider the principle of enabling the combined use of aquaculture
farms with renewable energy (e.g., solar and wave energy.
5. Consideration should also be given in the functional classification of the
purpose of new marine use service vessels - the needs of new branches
in ports may differ slightly from those of established ones .
6. Consider adding a condition for wind farm cable corridors that requires
cooperation with the National Heritage Board (to avoid damaging seabed
cultural assets) and the Ministry of Defense (to identify potential
historical explosives and hazardous objects).
7. Consider highlighting in MSP the importance of an international
network corridor for the development of wind farms and/or show the
principle direction of connecting the innovation area in a schematic map
showing possible cable connections.
8. Consider further guidelines to mitigate the visual impact related to the
wind energy development:
a. look for opportunities to leave / create the wind-turbine-free area
in the wind energy development area no. 2 in the views from the
three coastal sections of the west coast of Saaremaa, as well as in
the views from the northern tip of Ruhnu to the development area
no. 1.
b. in case of the wind farms closest to the coast (11.1 km) to point
out that the design of the wind turbines of the same size class is
preferred.
c. avoid the formation of small groups of wind turbines on the
outskirts of the wind farm, which appear as separate sets from the
main row of wind turbines.
d. when developing the wind farms of different developers it is
recommended to use regular formations, if possible, which would
reduce the visual impact of the wind turbines. Also avoid the
wheel effect if possible.
e. it is recommended to emphasize the need to take into account the
combined effect of wind farms in the plan.
f. it is advisable to point out in the plan that the visual impact
assessment should be carried out methodologically, in accordance
with generally accepted developed guidance material and by an
expert in the field. The visualizations should be true and
verifiable.
9. Consider treating seabed cultural assets as a single chapter and include
both monuments and unprotected wrecks.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 198
10. It is recommended to provide the definitions of the area with the greatest
local impact and range of vision, 20 and 50 km of the found wind area,
respectively.
11. Consider the need to improve conditions for the use of deposits in terms
of other potential interests (including threats) (e.g. need for cooperation
with the Ministry of Defense on historic explosives, etc ).
12. Consider supplementing MSP with the introduction of more location -
based land-sea interactions (See figure 4.4.1.9-1).
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. Developing measures for traditional maritime users (e.g., fishermen) to
enter new sectors of the blue economy, taking advantage of established
prerequisites (maritime skills, knowledge of the regional sea, etc ).
2. Developing rules for combined use of the marine area and national
support measures.
3. Include the principle of taking into account the functional hint erland of
the port when reviewing the concept of small craft harbors / preparing a
new development plan.
4. Analyzing the rescue capacity and assessing needs at the state level, in
cooperation with the Police and Border Guard Board and interested
parties in the light of the situation in the implementation of the plan .
5. Establishment of a sea litter mitigation plan.
6. Development of a marine renewable energy innovation support program,
preferably in cooperation with Latvia and Finland.
7. Further development of land-sea clusters (e.g., in preparation of the new
Estonian strategy for regional development).
8. Developing potential local benefit mechanisms to balance the interests
of the developer-current user and the developer-local government.
4.4.2 Impact on property
In the marine area, a direct impact on the property may result from natural
conditions (e.g., stranding, impacts of waves or ice banks, storms), ship -facility
collisions, incompatibility of marine activities, or poor operational practices
(e.g., damage to wrecks by divers). Indirect impacts may include factors such
as the restoration of damaged vessels or facilities/infrastructure, loss of revenue
due to production stoppages, etc. Due to the environment, the impact on the
property may also result in a higher impact/risk to life (risk of drowning,
distance to the maritime rescue).
Planning has predominantly reduced the risks to the property by increasing the
safety of the conditions imposed on various areas of marine use, such as setting
rules for shipping and highlighting the importance of shipping lanes, working
with the Ministry of Defense to identify the locations of historic explosives in
the context of planned seabed activities. Proposals for improvements have been
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 199
made to the different chapters of the Impact Assessment, where necessary for
safety reasons.
The marine area favors a variety of combined uses of marine area, but at the
same time, combined use also brings with it certain risks to the property:
combined use, on the one hand, brings together planned marine area activities
which, on the one hand, increase safety and, on the other hand, may increase
the magnitude and/or accumulation of impact (for example, a ship getting stuck
in shellfish lines or in fish cages in wind farm areas where, under adverse
conditions, an uncontrolled ship may collide with wind turbines). Methods to
mitigate the impact include developing rules, practices, and practices for
combined use and assessing the risks of combined use. In the light of what is
planned in the Maritime Spatial Plan, where new uses are emerging in the
marine area, it is necessary to complement national risk assessments and,
where appropriate, maritime rescue strategies.
The impact on assets is also possible due to sectoral developments – e.g.,
intensification of shipping. Measures to mitigate the impact include improving
the coverage and effectiveness of marine rescue, which is also highlighted in
the planning.
From the standpoint of land-sea clusters, property owners may feel that certain
offshore developments (such as wind turbines) may affect their income earned
from the property or value of the property. Scientific articles show that
planned activities in the marine area can have both positive and negative
impacts on tourism revenues, for example. For example, Kuehn (2005 ) 147 has
pointed out that 148 offshore wind farms in Denmark did not reduce the number
of tourists or summer rental rates. At the same time, Cook (2004) has 149
compared Denmark with Scotland and pointed out that because of different
landscape experiences in different countries, the impact is also different:
Denmark is a highly developed and urbanized country with many onshore wind
farms already in operation. At the same time, tourists in Scotland are looking
for a different experience with wildlife and less cultivated landscapes, so
expectations and, therefore, the impact may be different from Denmark. For the
UK's Scroby Sands offshore wind farm, the positive impact on tourism in terms
of visitors to the wind farm (~ 30,000 people in the first half of the year) has
also been highlighted) 150.
147
Kuehn, S. (2005). Sociological investigation of the reception of Horns Rev and Nysted
offshore wind farms in the local communities. ECON Analyse, March.
148
Horns Rev offshore wind farm in the North Sea, 14 -20 km from the coast.
149
Cook, G. (2004) Renewable Energy Policy in Denmark - An Introduction; Scottish
Parliament Information Centre (SPICe): Edinburgh, UK.
150
British Wind Energy Association (2006). The Impact of Wind Farms on the Tourist
Industry in the UK; London, UK.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 200
Regarding changes in real estate prices, Sunak and Madlener (2016) 151 point
out that, according to studies in Germany, offshore wind farms reduced real
estate prices by 9 to 14% when there was a significant number of wind turbines
in the views from the real estate. When few wind turbines were located in the
field of view or their impact was marginal, no decline in property prices was
observed. In Denmark, however, Jensen et al., (2018) 152 found that while wind
turbines influenced property prices, there was no significant impact on offshore
wind turbines, as the wind turbines were at least 9 km from the beach or from
a particular plot 153. There are no known studies conducted in Estonia, which
makes it difficult to assess the impact on real estate values. It can be assumed
that the real estate price change could be perceived as a threat by the
landowners from whose land plot opens a direct view of the sea area where the
wind turbines are planned and where the wind turbines are located closest to
the coast; according to the Maritime Spatial Plan, these areas would be
Tagamõisa peninsula, the western coast of Saaremaa from Vilsandi to Sõrve
and Ruhnu. In terms of population density, coastal areas are sparsely populated
(see Figure 4.4.2-1), due to which the impact may be rather local depending on
the specific nature of the landscape (lack of forests on the coast, etc ).
Figure 4.4.2.-1. Population density (people per square kilometer) and planned areas
of the wind energy (Extract from the planning map application:
mereala.hendrikson.ee )
151
Sunak, Y., & Madlener, R. (2016). The impact of wind farm visibility on property values:
A spatial difference-in-differences analysis. Energy Economics
152
Jensen et al.(2018). The impact of on-shore and off-shore wind turbine farms on property
prices. Energy Policy.
153Jensen et al.(2018). The impact of on-shore and off-shore wind turbine farms on property
prices. Energy Policy.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 201
The implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan may have indirect effects on
people’s property through visual impacts.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. Consider further mitigating the visual impact of wind energy
development to prevent potential impacts on landowners whose property
may have a direct view of wind turbines. An alternative, but also
complementary, measure may be the development of a local benefit
mechanism to compensate the landowner, whose dwelling or
recreational outbuilding has a direct view of the wind turbine, the
potential impact on property prices.
4.5 IMPACT ON HUMAN HEALTH
Marine areas are important for human health and well -being. Many people live
in the immediate vicinity of the marine areas, go fishing or consume fish and
fish products, spend their leisure time at and by the sea, and the wind blowing
at sea gives us energy in the future. All these activities can have both negative
and positive impacts on people's health and well -being. The impact can be
direct, for example, through accidents at sea or through exposure to various
food and airborne contaminants, or indirect, through stress and increased and/or
reduced well-being. There are also various recreational activities at sea that
improve the health of the population and have a positive impact.
Given the focus of Maritime Spatial Plan, potential health impact, and measures
to mitigate and enhance them, in the areas of fisheries, aquaculture, maritime
transport, energy production, and marine tourism and recreation will be further
analyzed below.
Apart from these, a certain impact may also occur in other areas covered by the
Maritime Spatial Plan. For example, some negative impact on public health
may occur with the construction of new infrastructures (cables, pipes, etc.),
where pollutants are released from bottom sediments back into the water mass,
where they pass through fish to the food consumed by people. However, such
an impact needs to be assessed on a site-specific basis in the application for a
specific project permit and in the EIA (including a prior assessment of
contaminant concentrations in sediments, as in the case of the NordStream
projects) and, where appropriate, mitigation measures proposed.
It is also important for public health to develop marine rescue and pollution
control, which has a positive impact on health and has no direct nega tive
impacts.
Taking into account the marine conservation values addressed in the plan
contributes to the creation and maintenance of a clean, species -rich
environment, which in turn contributes to human well-being, creates
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 202
opportunities for movement in the natural environment and acts as a stress
reliever.
Marine culture and the appreciation of cultural heritage enhance people's well -
being by, among other things, creating opportunities for exercise and engage in
sports which have a stress-relieving effect.
National defense activities, such as exercises at sea and seashore, can generate
noise that can distract local residents and cause them health and stress -related
issues. The potential negative impact of noise can be mitigated through better
timing of activities and wider awareness of the population. The plan does not
regulate national defense activities.
As Maritime Spatial Plan does not change the current use of the sea area for the
extraction of mineral resources, the use of mineral resources and the extraction
of mineral resources in the marine area are not associated with any positive or
a negative impact on human health. In addition, different regulations must
ensure that the material used for dumping is safe for human health and does not
contain hazardous substances.
4.5.1 Fisheries
Fish is an important part of the Estonian diet, although we are smaller than
average fish consumers compared to many EU countries (EUMOFA, 2018 154).
According to a study commissioned by the Ministry of Rural Affairs, in 2016,
the Estonian population consumed 9.6 kg of fish and fishery products per
inhabitant (product weight), which included 0.4 kg of self -caught fish or fish
obtained free of charge 155. (Estonian Institute of Economic Research, 2016) In
2015, the consumption of fresh fish was the highest in Western Estonia (6.1 kg
per family member) and the lowest in Southern Estonia (2.4 kg per family
member), elsewhere 3.8–3.9 kg per family member. Fish consumption is higher
than average among fishermen's families.
Impact of the MSP
The Maritime Spatial Plan sees the continuation of fishing as a traditional use
throughout the Estonian sea. No significant additional guidelines and
conditions will be set for fisheries. In view of the above, the implementation of
the Maritime Spatial Plan in the context of fisheries will not have a significant
impact on health. The general health impacts of fishing are described below.
Because of the presence of toxic substances such as heavy metals, dioxins,
dioxin-like polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) in the Baltic Sea, they can end
154
EUMOFA. 2019. The EU Fish Market – 2018 Edition. European Market Observatory for
Fisheries and Aquaculture Products.
155
Institute of Economic Research. 2016. Consumption of fish and fish products. Estonian
Institute of Economic Research, Tallinn.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 203
up in fish and hence into the diet of the population. At the same time, the results
of different years of assessments of the environmental status of the Estonian
marine area are contradictory: high levels of heavy metals have been found at
certain points in certain periods, while low levels have been found in other
areas. Thus, the environmental status of the Estonian marine area in 2018 does
not allow for a coherent assessment of the heavy metals content of fish i n the
Baltic Sea, and the reliability of the assessment of the status of the high seas
has to be considered low due to the lack of monitoring data (Klauson et al.,
2018). According to the same overview, it is difficult to estimate the levels of
dioxins and dioxin-like PCBs in different fish and other marine organisms. For
example, levels above the food safety limits have been found in the Baltic
herring and in the Gulf of Finland and the Gulf of Riga and in the flounder in
the mouth of the Gulf of Finland, but the levels in the majority of the samples
analyzed remain low. This generally indicates that there is a risk, but due to
average fish consumption, the risk is low for most people in Estonia. At the
same time, there are several risk groups, such as preg nant women and, above
all, fishermen's families, whose fish consumption is many times higher,
exposure to pollutants is much higher, and there is a real health risk (Roots,
2011 156).
Fish are generally considered to be healthy foods because they contain omega-
fatty acids beneficial to the cardiovascular system, various vitamins (A, E, B1,
B6, B12, D) and minerals (potassium, calcium, phosphorus, selenium, and
iodine). In addition, fish is a relatively low-fat protein food, and fish protein is
easily absorbed. As a result, eating fish has many positive impacts on human
health.
The implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan does not entail any significant
health effects that need to be mitigated.
4.5.2 Aquaculture
In addition to fish caught freely in the Baltic Sea, Estonian residents may in the
future also consume fish, shellfish and algae cultivated in the Baltic Sea. The
pollutants found in the Baltic Sea can also get into them.
Impact of the MSP
The fish feed may be the main source of dioxins and other harmful substances
in farmed fish. Because fish in the Baltic Sea may contain various pollutants
(see Chapter 4.3.1), prior control of the feed is important. Pollutants in the
Baltic Sea (especially heavy metals) can also reach the farmed shellfish a nd
algae. However, since aquaculture takes place primarily in the upper aquifers,
156
Roots O. 2011. Expert assessment of exposure of coastal fishermen to dioxins and dioxin -
like polychlorinated biphenyls. Estonian Environmental Resear ch Centre: Tallinn
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 204
where pollutant levels are lower than in the bottom sludge, and because
HELCOM (Helsinki Commission) has assessed the water quality status as good
for pollutants (HELCOM, 2018 157), it poses a low risk to human health.
Like fish caught in the Baltic Sea, fish farmed in the Baltic Sea has a positive
effect on health. As a rule, fatty fish (e.g., rainbow trout) with higher levels of
omega-fatty acids beneficial to the cardiovascular system are reared. Low
carbohydrate-containing shells and algae rich in minerals are also beneficial to
health. In addition, fish, shellfish, and algae farmed locally in Estonia can be
better controlled and regulated than imported goods where only spot checks are
carried out.
The implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan does not entail any significant
health effects that need to be mitigated.
4.5.3 Maritime transport
A large number of ships pass through the Estonian marine area, which emits
exhaust gases and causes noise. Exhaust gases can be transported by winds from
the marine areas to the coast, where they deteriorate air quality. Similarly,
people living near ports are affected by air quality and noise. In Estonia, air
pollution from ships and harbors has disturbed residents of Muuga and Sillamäe
areas, where the number of odor nuisances increases significantly in certain
adverse weather conditions (Maasikmets et al., 2014 158).
Air emissions from maritime transport are governed by Annex VI of MARPOL
73/78, Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, administered by
the International Maritime Organization (IMO), which lays down different
emission requirements based on shipbuilding years and engine characteristics
(IMO, 2017 159). In addition, the sulfur content of marine fuels has been
regulated and has been significantly reduced in recent years, which has reduced
sulfur dioxide (SO 2 ) emissions from maritime transport (Sofiev et al., 2018 160;
157HELCOM. 2018. HELCOM Thematic assessment of hazardous substances 2011 -2016.
Baltic Marine Environment Protection Commission (HELCOM).
158 Maasikmets M, Teinemaa E, Saare K, Vainumäe K, Arumäe T, Palu M. 2014. Assessment
of ambient air quality, odor nuisance and pollutant emissions in Ida -Virumaa, Sillamäe and
Vaivara region. Estonian Environmental Research Centre: Tallinn.
159 IMO. 2017. Amendments to MARPOL Annex VI. International Maritime Organization .
http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Environment/PollutionPrevention/AirPollution/Documents
/Res_MEPC_ 286%2871%29_Tier%20III%20ECA%20and%20BDN.pdf
160 Sofiev M, Winebrake JJ, Johansson L, Carr EW, Prank M, Soares J, Vira J, Kouznetsov
R, Jalkanen JP, Corbett JJ. 2018. Cleaner fuels for ships provide public health benefits with
climate tradeoffs. Nature Communications 9(1):406.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 205
Campara et al., 2018 161). In addition, air pollution and noise are caused by the
loading of goods (including petroleum products) onboard ships, and the service
transport related to maritime transport (including cars carried by ships)
(Institute of Marine Systems of Tallinn University of Technology, Alkranel,
2015 162). In June 2016, HELCOM submitted a proposal to the IMO to change
the Baltic Sea into NECA (Nitrogen Oxides Emission Control Area) in addition
to SECA (Sulfur Emission Control Area) by 2021 and to apply even stricter
Tier III requirements to ships built after 1 January 2021.
Impact of the MSP
Historically, ships have been the main users of marine areas, and the planning
solution has pointed out that changing the location of shipping lanes and
imposing significant restrictions on shipping should generally be avoided when
planning other uses. Therefore, no significant additional guidelines and
conditions are set for maritime transport. In view of the above, the
implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan will not have a significant health
impact. The general health impacts of maritime transport are described below .
The impact of shipping on the inhabitants near the Baltic Sea has been assessed
in a recent study by Barregard et al., 2019 163. In their research they modelled
the content of ultra-fine particles (PM 2.5 ) from ships both in 2014 before the
SECA regulations and in 2016 after the SECA regulations came into force in
the network in the Baltic Sea region 0.1 ° × 0.1 ° (almost 10 × 10 km). The fine
particles in air pollution have been shown to affect both cardiovascular and
respiratory morbidity (WHO, 2013 164). In addition, the fine particles are
associated with premature birth and low birth weight (Li et al., 2017 165), risk of
diabetes (Thiering and Heinrich, 2015 166), rheumatic (Sun et al., 2016 167) and
161 Campara L, Hasanspahić N, Srdjan V. 2018. Overview of MARPOL ANNEX VI regulations
for prevention of air pollution from marine diesel engine s. SHS Web of Conferences
58:01004.
162 Strategic Environmental Assessment of the National Development Plan “Estonian
Maritime Policy 2012-2020”. Institute of Marine Systems, Tallinn University of Technology,
OÜ Alkranel: Tartu-Tallinn, 2015
163 Barregard L, Molnàr P, Jonson JE. 2019. Impact on population health of baltic shipping
emissions. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 16:1954.
164 WHO. 2013. Review of Evidence on Health Aspects of Air Pollution. REVIHAAP Project
Technical Report. World Health Organisation: Copenhagen.
165 Li X, Huang S, Jiao A, Yang X, Yun J, Wang Y, Xue X, Chu Y, Liu F, Liu Y, Ren M,
Chen X, Li N, Lu Y, Mao Z, Tian L, Xiang H. 2017. Association between ambient fine
particulate matter and preterm birth or term low birth weight: An updated systematic review
and meta-analysis. Environmental Pollution 227:596-605.
166Thiering E, Heinrich J. 2015. Epidemiology of air pollu tion and diabetes. Trends in
Endocrinology & Metabolism 26:384–394
167 Sun G, Hazlewood G, Bernatsky S, Kaplan GG, Eksteen B, Barnabe C. 2016. Association
between air pollution and the development of rheumatic disease: a systematic review.
International Journal of Rheumatology 2016:5356307
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 206
neurodegenerative diseases (Xu et al., 2016 168), and the International Agency
for Research on Cancer (IARC) has identified these as carcinogenic to humans.
Figure 4.3.3.-1 shows the population-based content of ultra-fine particles from
shipping, taking into account the location of the population and the population
density. On this basis, taking into account SECA regulations, air pollution in
maritime transport causes 17–38 early deaths in Estonia every year, plus an
average of 34 cases of ischemic heart disease and 20 strokes per year (Barregard
et al., 2019 12 ).
Figure 4.5.3-1. Impact of shipping emissions on the exposure of the Baltic Sea
population to ultrafine airborne particles (PM 2.5 ) in 2016 (after the SECA
regulations came into force) in the 0.1 ° × 0.1 ° network (based on Barregard
et al., 2019).
Maritime spatial planning does not envisage changes in maritime transport, so
there is no significant impact.
4.5.4 Energy production
With this plan, wind energy development areas located six nautical miles from
the coast are planned for the Estonian marine area. In recent years, increasingly
more attention has been paid to the health impact of wind turbines, in particular
in terms of low-frequency noise, including infrasound (below 20 Hz). However,
the research carried out so far has focused on onshore wind farms (van Kamp
& van den Berg, 2018 169), so the results cannot be transferred to offshore wind
farms. Although several animal studies have shown minor physiological
168Xu X, Ha SU, Basnet R. 2016. A review of epidemiological research on adverse
neurological effects of exposure to ambient air pollution. Frontiers in Public Health 4:157
van Kamp I, van den Berg. 2018. Health effects rel ated to wind turbine sound, including
169
low-frequency sound and infrasound. Acoustics Australia 46(1):31–57.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 207
changes in the outer hair cells of the cochlea following exposure to infrasound,
similar human data are lacking, so it is unclear whether such inner ear impacts
can causally explain individual symptoms such as tinnitus, dizzi ness and
Meniere's disease (Schmidt & Klokker, 2014 170). In general, the main
complaints about wind turbines are stress, poor quality of sleep, difficulty
concentrating, nervousness, exhaustion, headache, dizziness, ringing in the ears
(Royy et al., 2014 171). These symptoms have also been termed "Wind Turbine
Syndrome" but have not been recognized as a clinical diagnosis (Pierpon,
2009 172).
However, wind turbines per se, and seeing them seems to be the most disturbing
aspect of wind turbines for people (Freiberg et al., 2019 173). Wind turbines that
can be seen from a home window are often not considered aesthetically pleasing
(Pedersen et al., 2007 174). The picture below shows the Sheringham Shoal
offshore wind farm, 17 to 23 km off the coast of England (P hoto 4.3.4). Wind
turbine distress, in turn, causes stress associated with sleep deprivation,
headaches, and difficulty concentrating (Roy et al., 2014 20 ). People who live
near wind turbines rate their quality of life worse than those who live further
away or the average of the population (Shephard et al., 2011 175). However,
people living in the vicinity who benefit directly from wind farms have
significantly less feeling of being bored (Pedersen et al., 2009 176).
170
Schmidt JJ, Klokker M. 2014. Health effects related to wind turbine noise exposure: a
systematic review. PLoS One 9(12):e114183
Roy J, Krogh C, Horner B. 2014. Adverse health effects of industrial wind turbines.
171
Canadian journal of rural medicine: the official journal of the Society of Rural Physicians of
Canada 19: 21–26.
Pierpon N. 2009. Wind Turbine Syndrome: A Report on a Natural Experiment. K-Selected
172
Books.
173
Freiberg A, Schefter C, Hegewald J, Seidler A. 2019. The influence of wind turbine
visibility on the health of local residents: a systematic review. International Archives of
Occupational and Environmental Health 92(5):609–628.
Pedersen E, Persson-Waye K. 2007. Wind turbine noise, annoyance and self -reported health
174
and well-being in different living environments. Occupational and Environmental Medicine
64:480–486.
Shepherd D, McBride D, Welch D, Driks KN, Hill EM. 2011. Evaluating the impact of
175
wind turbine noise on health-related quality of life. Noise & Health 13(54):333–339.
Pedersen E, Frits van den Berg. 2009. Response to noise from modern wind farms in The
176
Netherlands. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 126(2):634–643.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 208
Photo 4.5.4-1. Sheringham Shoal Offshore Wind Park (source
https://www.flickr.com/photos/windeurope/28687503031)
A third explanation for the health problems of people living near wind farms is
the nocebo effect, where people have a negative association in their brain
between wind turbines and health impacts (Crichton et al., 2014a 177). In this
case, negative health expectations result in clinical symptoms and do not
depend on whether or not the perceived health risk is actually present. The
nocebo effect is not only related to the wind turbines but may also occur with
other subjects. The low-frequency sound produced by wind turbines must not
exceed the legal limits, and the human hearing system has been developed so
that we are not disturbed, for example, by the low -frequency sounds produced
by our own breathing and heartbeat that are produced beyond the capacity of
one wind farm (Crichton et al., 2014b 178). However, when a person thinks that
wind turbines affect their health, they develop health problems because
negative associations induce stress-related physiological activity in the
autonomic nervous system and brain, and cause irritation, anxiety, fear, and the
like. Moreover, with the current knowledge, it cannot be completely excluded
that infrasound generated by wind turbines affects human health (Farboud et
al., 2013 179).
177 Crichton F, Chapman S, Cundy T, Petrie KJ. 2014a. The link between health complaints
and wind turbines: support for the nocebo expectations hypothesis. Frontiers in Public Health
2:220.
178Crichton F, Dodd G, Schmid G, Gamble G, Cundy T, Petrie KJ. 2014. The power of
positive and negative expectations to influence reported symptoms and mood during exposure
to wind farm sound. Health Psychology 33(12):1588–1592.
179 Farboud A, Crunkhorn R, Trinidade A. 2013. Wind turbine syndrom e’: fact or fiction? The
Journal of Laryngology & Otology 127:222–226.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 209
Impacts of the MSP
This Maritime Spatial Plan solution is designed to minimize the direct human
health impact of wind farms. However, in the planning phase, it is not possible
to provide specific numerical data (for example, carry out modeling) on how
big the noise wind farms noise could become. In the planning phase, the main
locations of the wind farms will be determined, but the exact number, height,
and technology of the wind turbines are currently unknown. However, for
specific project evaluations, modeling of such noise (including low -frequency
noise) would certainly be necessary and should take into account other planned
wind farms.
As the areas of wind farms are planned to be at least 6 nautical miles (~ 11.1
km) from land and islands, this will greatly reduce the spread of noise,
including infrasound, to the coast. However, reaching and hearing infrasound
depends on both the wind direction and strength (Keith, 2018 180). Because wind
and waves also produce infrasound themselves (Le Pichon 181 et al., 2004), it can
be unrealistic to distinguish it from wind farm noise in most cases. There are
currently no studies showing the health impacts of noise coming from offshore
wind farms. As mentioned above, the results of surveys of onshore wind farms
cannot be transferred to offshore wind farms. In addition, land -based studies
have shown that the effect of the noise of a wind turbine located more than 7
km away on sleep disorders (Nissenbaum et al., 2012 182).
At the same time, offshore wind farms may have some negative impact and
reduced well-being due to distraction and nocebo impacts. Following the plan,
the areas of the offshore wind turbines will only be visible in certain directions
from the nearest land-based points. Because many of these health impacts are
related to psychological mechanisms, health impacts are largely independent of
exposure - if a person sees a wind farm, they may develop a negative association
and health symptoms that are, in many cases, true. It would, therefore, be
important to minimize the visibility of wind farms and to create wind -free
corridors. Maslov et al. (2018 183) have shown that visual impacts can vary
significantly across the coast, depending on whether you see wind turbines
directly or at an angle and how many you see. According to a study by
Sullivan 184 et al., wind turbines can be seen up to 42 km (22.7 nautical miles)
away, and they are in visual focus at up to 16 km (8.6 nautical miles) (Sullivan
et al., 2013). Therefore, it would be important to reduce visibility in areas
180 Keith S. 2018. Wind turbine low frequency and infrasound propagation and sound pressure
level calculations at dwellings. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 144:981.
Le Pichon A, Maurer V, Raymond D, Hyvernaud O. 2004. Infrasound from ocean waves
181
observed in Tahiti. Geophysical research letters 31:L19103.
182 Nissenbaum MA, Aramini JJ, Hanning CD. 2012. Effects of industrial wind turbine noise
on sleep and health. Noise & Health 14:237–243.
183Maslov N, Claramunt C, Wang T, Tang T. 2017. Evaluating the visual impact of an offshore
wind farm. Energy Procedia 105:3095–3100.
184 Sullivan RG, Kirchler L, Cothren J, Winters SL. 2013. Offshore wind turbine visibility and visual impact threshold
distances. Environmental Practice 15(1):33–49
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 210
where more people are living or where people are walking by the sea to enjoy
the sunset.
In addition, Crichton et al. (2013) have shown that the occurrence of health
impacts depends on the information provided to people: by talking more about
the positive impacts of wind turbines, the negative impacts can be reduced.
Wind energy helps, firstly, to reduce carbon emissions, which mitigates climate
change, and climate change has a significant impact on the health of the
Estonian population, for example, through the increase in heat waves (Orru et
al., 2015 185). On the other hand, wind energy development would help reduce
air pollution from oil shale energy. A study conducted under the Estonian
Energy Sector Development Plan 2030 (ENMAK) found that air pollution from
oil shale burning causes at least 20 early deaths in Estonia each year (Orru et
al., 2014 186) and tens of thousands of people in Ida-Viru County have been
significantly disturbed by air pollution from the oil shale sector (Orru et al.,
2018 187). By using more wind energy, these health impacts can be greatly
reduced.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. Performing accurate modeling of wind farm locations at the licensing
environmental impact assessment stage to minimize disruption, making
them less visually visible on more visited seacoasts .
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. Developing compensatory measures of tolerating wind farms for the
local community.
2. As the potential health effects of offshore wind farms are likely to be
psychogenic to some extent, people should be made more aware of the
benefits of wind turbines (reduction in mortality due to reduced air
pollution and mitigation of climate change).
185 OrruH, Lanki T, Forsberg B, Saava A, Åström DO, Indermitte E, Orru K, Åström K,
Rekker K, Tillmann K, Kangur T. 2015. Health Report: Assessing the Impacts of Climate
Change and Developing Adaptation Measures on Planning, Land Use, Human Health and
Rescue Capacity (KATI), pp. 168-262. Edited by Roose A. University of Tartu: Tartu
186 Orru, H. 2014. Assessment of changes in health effects expected to be caused by airborne
pollution through sectoral scenarios using ultra fine particulate matter content as pollution
indicator in the framework of ENMAK 2030+ Development Fund: Tallinn
187 Orru H, Idavain J, Pindus M, Orru K, Kesanurm K, Lang A, Tomasova J. 2018. Residents'
self-reported health effects and annoyance in relation to air pollution exposure in an industrial
area in Eastern-Estonia. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
15(2).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 211
4.5.5 Sea tourism and recreation
Maritime tourism and recreation have a significant impact on public health
through the promotion and enhancement of active mobility. However, there are
several risks associated with the recreational use of marine areas. Thus, 15
people drowned in the sea in 2018, which is 35% of all drownings in Estonia
(Oidersalu, 2019 188). It is also important to note that the number of drownings
in the sea has more than doubled compared to 2016 (while the total number of
drownings in Estonia has remained at the same level). Another part of the
accidents involves fishermen in distress at sea and vessels rescued by the
Rescue Board. Therefore, it is extremely important to ensure rescue on la rger
beaches and at sea.
Water-related accidents also include explosives found on the seabed. As
recreational diving is gaining in popularity, the risk of accidents is also
increasing. Occupational health hazards arise from both marine rescue, and
explosive mine clearance: highly volatile hydrocarbons are toxic when inhaled,
and mine clearance entail is a risk of accidents. Safety and accident issues have
also been raised in connection with water tourism, which has also increased and
is rather more likely to be promoted by the plan. Generally speaking, the
creation of various recreational facilities at the seaside and at sea is beneficial
to public health as it improves the physical health of the population and reduces
stress. Increasing the potential incremental risks, such as the number of skin
cancer cases, can be mitigated through awareness -raising and wider use of
remedies.
Another part of the water quality risks is related to bathing water. Previous
plans have stressed that popular bathing areas (beaches) would be managed as
official beaches/bathing areas with accompanying water sample testing, etc.
This monitoring is organized by the Health Board, which also gives regular
warnings of deteriorated water quality. The main cause of water quality
deterioration is water blooms, including cyanobacteria in water. Cyanobacterial
toxins are toxic to humans both by the ingestion of water and by inhalation of
airborne droplets (aerosols) on the beach. The problem of cyanobacteria occurs
only in hot periods and with certain winds when the cyanobacteria are carried
to the coast from the high seas. In Estonia, cyanobacteria are regularly
monitored, and warnings are given to the population when these levels are high .
188 Oidersalu E. 2019. Fatalities in water accidents, 2018. Estonian Rescue Board: Tallinn.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 212
Impact of the MSP
The plan supports the development of maritime tourism and recreation, which
in turn supports the active movement of the population, which has a very
important impact on the prevention of chronic diseases. With regard to the
adverse impacts associated with the development of the sector, the risk of
accidents (drowning, injuries, etc.) may be highlighted. There are also noises
in water motorsport activities that can cause disturbance to nearby residents
and tourists.
Maritime spatial Planning does not plan activities for marine tourism and
recreation, which would have a significant environmental impact .
4.6 ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT
4.6.1 Fisheries
Fishing is an important sector for the Estonian economy. In 2017, 125
economically active companies 189 engaged in sea fishing 190 as their main
activity. The number of companies has increased by 34% compared to 2014.
The sales revenue of the companies totaled approximately 42.7 million euros
in the same year, 17% more than in 2014. In addition, th ere are 884 sole
proprietors registered in Estonia in 2019, whose main activity is sea fishing,
according to the Commercial Register. Companies engaged in sea fishing as
their main activity employed around 263 people in 2017, 5% less than in 2014.
The number of employees per company has also decreased (from 3.0 to 2.1),
which is 3.3 times less than the average for Estonian companies. In addition,
there is a large number of sea fishing companies in the coastal areas, whose sea
fishing is a secondary activity due to its periodic nature (up to four months per
year, according to fishermen, which prevents obtaining a stable income). In
2017, the sales revenue of the companies operating in the field of sea fishing
accounted for approximately 0.09% of the total sal es revenue of Estonian
companies and the number of employees for approximately 0.07% of the total
number of employees in Estonian companies.
According to Statistics Estonia and the Ministry of Rural Affairs, Estonian
professional fishermen caught 64,477 tons of fish in the Baltic Sea in 2017, of
which 17% was coastal fishing, and 83% was offshore trawling. Baltic herring
189 Companies which have indicated sea fishing as the main activity in the Commercial
Register (EMTAK 2008 code 03111).
190 An economically active company is a company, which according to the Commercial
Register has generated revenue for the financial year.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 213
(55%) and sprat (41%) were the main catches in the Baltic Sea that year. In
2017, Pärnu County coastal fishing accounted for 76% of the t otal coastal
fishery. This was followed by Ida-Viru County (11%), Saare County (7%), and
Lääne County (4%). In 2017, the number of fishermen entered in fishing
permits in Estonian coastal waters was 1950. The highest numbers of
professional fishermen were in Saare County (including Ruhnu) (23%), Pärnu
County (including Kihnu and Manija) (21%), Hiiu County (17%) and Harju
County (16%).
The Marine Economic Benefit Model 191 shows that the total economic benefits
from fishing (both trawling and coastal fishing) are highest in the Gulf of Pärnu,
amounting to approximately 100,000 euros per km 2 (Tõrge! Ei leia
viiteallikat.). In terms of the benefits gained, the next important areas are near
Lao beach, reaching 3.500 km 2 /year, near Konju beach reaching 2,000 euros
km 2 /year and near Aseri beach, Kakurahu marine area and Kumari -Papilaiu,
reaching in these regions over 1000-euro km 2 /year. In other areas, the benefits
of fishing are lower.
191
Estonian economic model: The Marine Economic Benefit Model is a simulation model
commissioned by the Ministry of Finance, developed in 2016 and is still being updated to
date (Pihor, K. et al. Basic Study of Maritime Spatial Planning: The Marine Economic Benefit
Model. Praxis Center for Policy Studies. 2016; Nõmmela, K., Kotta, J., Piirimäe, K. (2019).
Complementing the model of economic benefits from the use of marine resources with
ecosystem services. Tartu Ülikool, OÜ Hobikoda and OÜ Roheline Rada,
(https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/et/system/files_force/document_files/mudeli_taiendam
ine_okosusteemiteenustega_aruanne.pdf).
When interpreting the results of the economic model, it is important to consider that this is a
discussion platform rather than a means of reflecting reality. The values of the model
parameters are highly uncertain, because in Estonian circumstances there a re often no reliable
measured indicators, so the results of the model should be indicative.
The Marine Economic Benefit Model was updated for fisheries data. For trawling, data were
entered for the period 2014-2017, a four-year period, and annual average catches per species
and per square kilometer of sea area were calculated. As regards coastal fishing, only the data
for 2017 were taken into account. Both topics were transferred to the time step of one year.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 214
Figure 4.6.1-1. Economic benefits of fisheries in Estonian marine areas, €/km 2 /year
(Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
The added value of coastal fishing 192 is highest in the Gulf of Pärnu, amounting
to over 4,000 euros per km 2 /year. The added value is also higher in the
Väinameri region, up to 735 euros km 2 /year. Near Aseri beach, it is 638 euros
km 2 /year. Elsewhere, the added value of coastal fishing is less than 1000 euros
km 2 /year (Figure 4.6.1-2).
Value added is calculated by multiplying gross income by the value added parameter (60%
192
by default, assuming that the added value of coastal fishing is analogous to trawling in the
absence of more accurate data) (Pihor, K. et al. Basic Study of Maritime Spatial Planning:
The Marine Economic Benefit Model. Praxis Center for Policy Studies. 2016).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 215
Figure 4.6.1-2. Added value of coastal fishing in Estonian marine areas, €/km 2 /year
(Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
The added value of trawling in the Estonian marine areas are the largest in the
Gulf of Riga, where at times it amounted to 1 500 euros km 2 /year. It is also
higher in the marine areas near Harju County and in the marine areas near
Lääne-Viru County. Elsewhere, the value-added of trawling was less than 1000
euros km 2 /year (Figure 4.6.1-3).
Figure 4.6.1-3. Added value of trawling in Estonian marine areas, €/km 2 /year
(Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 216
The state income from coastal fishing in 193 Estonian marine areas was
proportional to the added value, being the highest in the Gulf of Pärnu, where
it reached up to 700 euros per km 2 /year. The state revenue is also significant in
the vicinity of Lao Beach, Konju Beach and Aseri Beach, Kakurahu mar ine
area, and Kumari-Papilaiu marine area. In other areas, the state income from
fisheries is lower (Figure 4.6.1-4).
Figure 4.6.1-4. State value from coastal fishing in Estonian marine areas, €/km 2 /year
(Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
State revenue from trawling in Estonian marine areas is also proportional to the
added value of trawling. The state revenue from trawling is highest on the
southern coast of Saaremaa, amounting to 760 euros km 2 /year. The state
revenue from trawling is also significant in the sea areas near Harju County and
Lääne-Viru County. In other areas, the national income from trawling is lower
(Figure 4.6.1-5).
State income is calculated as a fraction of the gross income (10% by default, assuming these
193
are small businesses, for which coastal fishing is an ancillary activity not subject to VAT),
multiplied by the fish catches at primary purchase price of the fish. As a result, the state
income is the income tax of the natural person from the dividends paid out. (Pihor, K. et al.
Basic Study of Maritime Spatial Planning: The Marine Economic Benefit Model. Praxis
Center for Policy Studies. 2016).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 217
Figure 4.6.1-5. State value from trawling in Estonian marine areas, €/km 2 /year
(Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
Impact of the MSP
The Maritime Spatial Plan does not foresee changes in fisheries -related marine
areas, so the plan has no direct economic impact on the sector. Maritime spatial
Planning provides a guideline and condition for ensuring the preservation of
spawning grounds located in different marine areas that are important for the
natural recovery of fish stocks and for ensuring that spawning grounds would
not be subject to significant adverse impacts, which are also important from an
economic standpoint - ensuring the sustainability of fish stocks is a key factor
in the functioning of the fisheries sector. The Maritime Spatial Plan also
identifies as a guideline the maintenance or creation of free access to fishing
areas, fishing ports, and landing sites, which is also very important from an
economic standpoint since free access is a prerequisite for the operation of
fishing companies. In addition, the Maritime Spatial Plan sets a minimum depth
requirement for trawl fishing, which does not deviate from the current rule and
therefore has no economic impact.
Fishing activities require the existence of ports and access to and proper
operating condition of the infrastructure there. As of the beginning of 2019,
there are 171 seaports in Estonia (data from the Port Register). Fishing at sea
does not generally preclude other activities.
Overlap between trawling and wind energy development areas
According to the maritime economic model there are theoretical areas of
conflict in the 20-40 m depth range of areas suitable for trawling and wind
energy development, where trawling is allowed due to sufficient depth and wind
farms are still economically viable due to sufficient shallowness. The largest
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 218
such area of conflict is in the wind farm area of the Gulf of Riga, which
according to the calculations of the generalized economic model (1x1 km grid),
almost completely overlaps with the trawling area ( Figure 4.6.1-6). In the area
to the west of Saaremaa there is a more intense overlap in the south -eastern part
of the area.
Figure 4.6.1-6. Overlap of trawling and wind energy development areas in
Estonian marine areas (Source: Marine Economic Benefit Model)
Trawling has increased in recent years in the wind farm areas set out in the
plan. In the wind area of the Gulf of Riga the average share of companies'
catches in 2019 was 35% of the total catch in the Gulf of Riga 194. Considering
that the area of the wind farm in the Gulf of Riga has also been established by
the plan of Pärnu County, the area added to this plan will further reduce the
opportunities for economic activities related to trawling. (Fishermen's Union
19 February 2021).
As to the ports the wind farm area in the Gulf of Riga affects the port of
Roomassaare in Saaremaa and the port of Virtsu in Pärnu County the most. In
recent years the port of Roomassaare has landed an average of 49% of the total
catch from this wind farm area. (Ministry of Rural Affairs, 5 January 2021). If
fishing decreases due to wind farms, the income of these ports will also
decrease significantly. In the area to the west of Saaremaa there are intensive
fishing areas for sprat and herring in the south-eastern part of the area. The
decrease in fishing opportunities in this area has the greatest impact on the port
of Mõntu in Saaremaa, where 79% of the fish caught in this wind farm area has
been landed in recent years. In addition, it should be borne in mind that wind
194
Letter of the Minister of Rural Affairs to the Ministry of Finance, 5 January 2021
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 219
farm areas are not expected to be fully realizable and the extent of their impact
on trawling will depend on the latter.
Although the plan allows shipping traffic in the wind farm areas, the
shipowners, considering the experience of foreign countries, avoid moving
there due to an increase in the risk factor (especially the risk of collisions due
to bad weather or engine failure), which insurance companies do not want to
compensate. As a result, the cost of fuel and time for shipping, including fishing
vessels, is increasing, which is changing the amount of income. It is not
possible to assess the exact financial implications of this work due to the lack
of detailed information.
Brief overview of the experience of the European countries in the
coexistence of offshore wind farms and fishing, in particular trawling
In the United Kingdom the fishing activities are permitted in offshore wind
farms. During the construction of the wind farm the safety zone with a radius
of 500 m has been established around the main construction vessel, during the
operation of the wind farm the safety zones with a radius of 50 m have been
established around all fixed equipment, i.e. especially wind turbines. Fishermen
are compensated for the loss of income for the areas where fishing is prohibited.
At the same time fishermen are responsible for any damage that may occur to
wind farm equipment and it is the fishermen's responsibility to compensate
them. In order to reduce risks, fishermen generally avoid activities in the wind
energy development areas 195, 196.
The German maritime spatial plan identifies "priority areas " for various
activities, where other activities are generally prohibited. Such areas are also
designed for wind energy, which means that fishing activities are not allowed
in these areas. However, no such areas have been designated for fishing due to
the spatial variability of their activities 197.
The 500m wide safety zone has been established around the Belgian offshore
wind farm (the total of 36 wind turbines, 650 to 1000 m apart) and has been
closed to shipping since 2006 198.
In the Dutch offshore wind farms all fishing was completely banned until 2015,
when it was decided to change the law so that the three areas could coexist
195
Schupp, M. F., Kafas, A., Buck, B. H., Krause, G., Onyango, V., Stelzenmüller, V., Davies,
I., Scott, B. E. (2021). Fishing within offshore wind farms in the North Sea: Stakeholder
perspectives for multi-use from Scotland and Germany. Journal of Environmental
Management 279 (2021) 111762
196
Arcadis, 2018. Review on Risk Assessment on Transit and Co -Use of Offshore Wind Farms
in Dutch Coastal Water, Commissioned by the Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Climate Policy, Arcadis Nederland B.V.
197
(Shupp, at al. 2021)
198
(Bergman, jt. 2015 198)
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 220
under certain conditions 199. The amendments to the law allowed conditional 200
fishing, but the activities that disturb the seabed, i.e. trawling, remained
prohibited 201.
The cable protection zones have been established for the areas of Danish
offshore wind farms, covering the entire area of the wind farm and the cables
connecting it with a width of 200 m. The law requires fishermen who normally
fish in these areas to be compensated for the loss of income. The exact amount
of compensation will be agreed with each fisherman individually 202.
The coexistence of offshore wind farms and fisheries is essential for achieving
the goals of the European climate policy. The European MSP platform sees the
planning of the wind areas to the less intensive fishing areas, allowing fishing
in the wind farm areas under certain conditions, planning transit corridors,
taking into account the seasonality of fishing when planning the wind farm
construction, supporting cross-sectoral cooperation agreements, compensating
fishermen, etc. and other opportunities to promote synergies. 203 However,
fishermen are sceptical about these solutions, as trawling is prohibited or
hampered even under such conditions, compensation usually only compensates
for a certain part of the income and other authorized fishing inv olves risks, as
the insurance companies are generally reluctant to insure the movement
between the wind turbines.
The implementation of the maritime spatial plan will not have a direct economic
impact on fisheries, except for the impact of wind energy development areas on
fishing, in particular trawling.
The wind energy development areas proposed in the plan partially overlap with
the trawling fishing areas, but as the overlap is small (4.5% of the Estonian
trawling fishing areas overlap with the wind energy development areas), this is
a significant but local impact. The guidelines and conditions set out in the plan
support the functioning of the fishery, but the more detailed analysis of the
impact of wind farms requires a more detailed analysis at the leve l of the
authorization procedure and environmental impact assessment.
On 29 April 2021 the Government of the Republic made an interim decision,
designating those of the wind energy development areas proposed in the
199
European MSP Platform. Conflict fiche 5: Offshore wind and commercial fisheries
200
Additional restrictions were imposed on fishing, such as vessels up to 24 m, fishing
during the day, etc.
201
Arcadis, 2018. Review on Risk Assessment on Transit and Co -Use of Offshore Wind
Farms in Dutch Coastal Water, Commissioned by the Dutch Ministry o f Economic Affairs
and Climate Policy, Arcadis Nederland B.V.
202
Danish Energy Agency (2018). Offshore Wind and Fisheries in Denmark, Danish Energy
Agency, December 2018. Kättesaadav:
https://ens.dk/sites/ens.dk/files/Globalcooperation/offshore_wind_and_fis heries_in_dk.pdf
203
European MSP Platform. Conflict fiche 5: Offshore wind and commercial fisheries
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 221
maritime spatial plan as reserve areas which coincide with the areas of
historically more intensive trawling.
4.6.2 Maritime transport
Maritime transport has always played an important role in the Estonian
economic environment by providing international and national connectivity
opportunities and by being an important employer and business developer. In
2017, 60 economically active companies were engaged in shipping 204 in
Estonia. The number of companies has increased by 15% compared to 2014.
Corporate sales totaled approximately 0.5 billion euros in the same year 205, 5%
lower than in 2014. Sales per company have also fallen. The sale s revenue of
shipping companies accounted for approximately 1% of the total sales revenue
of Estonian companies in the same year.
Shipping companies employed around 7,676 people 206 in 2017, up 3% from
2014. However, when comparing the number of employees without one of the
largest shipping companies, AS Tallink Grupp, the number of employees has
decreased by 45% (from 494 to 270) during the period 2014 -2017. The average
number of employees per company has also decreased (excluding AS Tallink
Grupp from 9.7 to 4.6). Similarly, to the decline in the number of employees in
shipping companies, the total number of employees in Estonian companies has
decreased over the same period (from 7.6 to 6.9). The number of employees in
shipping companies accounted for approximately 2% of the total number of
employees in Estonian companies in 2017. There are also ports related to
maritime transport 207, which provide a service to shipping companies and which
employed around 800 more people in 2017. In addition, Estonian seafare rs work
in shipping companies of other countries, but there is no reliable information
on their numbers.
According to the Port Register, there are 220 ports in Estonia as of 2019, of
which 171 are seaports, of which 73% or 125 are small craft ports. Accord ing
to Statistics Estonia, approximately 7 million passengers traveled on the main
international regular services 208 in2017, and approximately 2.5 million
passengers on the main domestic regular 209 services. In the same year, 311
cruise ships with 564,280 cruise tourists visited the Port of Tallinn. In total,
approximately 6,500 passenger and cruise ships from abroad visited Estonian
123
Companies which have designated as main activities in the Commercial Register (EMTAK 2008 codes): Sea and coastal freight water
transport (50101), Sea and coastal passenger water transport (50101) or Towing of ships (50202).
205 90% of the total sales revenue was generated by AS Tallink Grupp (only the Company's
revenue in the field of maritime transport is included).
206 96% of the number of employees was comprised of the employees of AS Tallink Grupp.
207 Companies that have designated port and waterway activities as the main activity in the
Commercial Register (EMTAK 2008 code 52221).
208 Tallinn - Helsinki - Tallinn; Tallinn - Stockholm - Tallinn; Paldiski - Kappelskär - Paldiski; Riga-Stockholm-Riga
209 Virtsu - Kuivastu - Virtsu; Rohuküla - Sviby - Rohuküla; Rohuküla - Heltermaa - Rohuküla; Triigi - Sõru - Triigi;
Munalaid - Kihnu - Munalaid; Pärnu - Kihnu - Pärnu
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 222
ports. The volumes of passenger transport have increased year by year. In
passenger transport, international ferry connections are mainly concentrated in
the Tallinn area, and domestic ferry connections serve traffic between the
mainland and the islands.
In 2017, approximately 34.8 million tons of cargo were transported through
Estonian ports, which is 20% less than in 2014. The number of foreign cargo
ships visiting Estonian ports and arriving from abroad has also decreased; in
2017, the number of visits of cargo ships was approximately 5,000, which is
4% less than in 2014. The largest cargo ports for cargo transportation are the
ports of AS Tallinna Sadam, and the ports of Sillamäe, Pärnu, Paldiski, and
Kunda.
According to the Marine Economic Benefit Model, the added value of shipping is
up to 0.3 million euros km 2 /year. The added value created by the shipping is
greatest in the area of international shipping lanes on the high seas, as well as
in the vicinity of Tallinn, Muuga, Paldiski, Sillamäe, and Pärnu and on the
North-South shipping lane in the Väinameri Sea (Figure 4.6.2 -1). The total
added value of shipping in the Estonian marine area is approximately 407
million €/year.
Figure 4.6.2-1 Added value of shipping in Estonian marine areas, €/km 2 /year
(Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
State revenue from shipping is proportional to the added value of shipping,
amounting to 0.1 million euros km 2 /year on more active shipping lanes (Figure
4.6.2-2). The largest areas in terms of state revenue are just like in case of
added value, international shipping lanes, and the Tallinn, Muuga, Paldiski,
Sillamäe, and Pärnu regions and the North-South shipping lane in the
Väinameri Sea. The country's total shipping revenue is approximately 200
million euros/year.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 223
Figure 4.6.2-2. Public revenues from shipping in Estonian marine areas, €/km 2 /year
(Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
Maritime transport is an international sector whose development is highly
dependent on global trends and the competitiveness of the surrounding area.
New regulatory developments, technological developments, changes in
intergovernmental economic policy relations, etc., may lead to changes in
freight and passenger transport, including the opening of new shipping lanes or
ports. Also, the volume of sea transport may be significantly affected by the
planned tunnel between Tallinn and Helsinki or plans to build bridges between
the islands and the mainland, which may change the intensity of use of the sea
areas.
Impact of the MSP
The Maritime Spatial Plan does not foresee any changes in the marine areas
associated with maritime transport and therefore has no direct economic impact
on the sector. As a guideline, Maritime Spatial Plan highlights the potential
overlap of waterborne traffic areas with other uses of the sea (including wind
energy, aquaculture, etc.), which is a situation where the current functioning of
maritime transport is not hindered will have a positive impact on the economic
environment. The more economic sectors use the marine areas more
multifunctionality, without negative synergies, the greater the positive impact
on the economic environment as a whole. As part of the improvement of the
planning solution in May-June 2020, the needs of maritime transport in the
areas suitable of wind energy development have been taken into account more
clearly and better. The surface area of the wind energy development areas was
reduced to avoid overlaps with heavy ship traffic areas. The basic passage
corridors were also designated for shipping, which must be left free of wind
turbines. This avoids possible additional hazard situations and ensures the most
optimal routes for maritime transport. Ensuring optimal traffic routes has a
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 224
clear positive economic impact - additional time and fuel consumption due to
lengthening of the voyage is avoided. When bypassing wind energy
development areas, the ship's calculated voyage can increase by 10 - 30 km
depending on the destination and the time consumption can increase by 0.5 -
1.5 hours. The rate of increase in fuel consumption is difficult to determine, as
it depends on the type of vessel, the size of the cargo and many other factors.
In addition, Maritime Spatial Plan sets the guideline, on designing a network
of ports, taking into account naturally suitable locations and optimum distances
for sailing and motor yachting. From an economic standpoint, this limits the
development of potential entrepreneurship in areas where there are capable
entrepreneurs and local demand, but naturally unsuitable conditions or the area
is outside the optimal range for yachting. From an economic standpoint, the
selection criteria for port network design should not be narrowed down to the
two factors set out in the Maritime Spatial Plan guidelines, but entrepren eurship
should be comprehensively promoted, i.e., all factors should be taken into
account when designing new small craft ports or existing port networks.
Shipping requires the availability of ports and access to and the good operating
condition of their infrastructure. Shipping may be restricted by nature reserves,
where shipping may be subject to additional restrictions and environmental
requirements, while Maritime Spatial Plan makes it necessary to consider
shipping lanes when creating a new nature site, which is an essential condition
for maintaining the positive economic impact of shipping. Shipping may also
be obstructed by cables and pipelines located on the seabed and by cultural
heritage sites in the vicinity of which anchoring is restricted. For t he latter,
Maritime Spatial Plan makes it a condition for shipwrecks to be taken into
account in cooperation with the National Heritage Board. Contradictions can
also occur in the case of overlapping of shipping lanes and aquaculture areas,
but to avoid this, Maritime Spatial Plan has made it a condition that the
aquaculture development area is not designed for shipping lanes.
Port activities support activities related to shipping, fisheries, aquaculture,
marine tourism, recreation, energy generation, marine rescue, border control,
pollution control, and national defense, providing access to the sea (including
related services). There are no conditions for port activities in Maritime Spatial
Plan, and therefore there is no direct economic impact on port acti vities.
From the economic standpoint of maritime transport, it is important to keep
open the shipping routes, especially the shipping lanes, including national and
international, and areas suitable for ports, and to avoid the emergence of
restrictions in these areas in order to maintain the competitiveness of Estonian
maritime transport.
The implementation of the Maritime Spatial Plan does not have a direct
economic impact on maritime transport. The conditions set out in the plan will
encourage synergies between maritime transport and other economic activities
in maritime uses.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 225
4.6.3 Maritime tourism
Maritime tourism and recreation 210 is an important business area for the
Estonian economy. In 2017, 441 economically active businesses were engaged
in providing maritime tourism and recreational services 211 (including lodging,
dining, and drinking, surfing, and sailing clubs) on the coastal areas. The
number of companies has increased by 9% compared to 2014. The total sales
revenue of the companies in 2017 was approximately 400 million euros, which
is 25% more than in 2014. In 2017, hotel revenue accounted for 58% and food
and beverage revenue for 36% of the sales revenue. According to the
Commercial Register, 75 economically active companies in Estonia were
operating in the same year engaged in the construction of pleasure boats and
sports boats and in the rental of water transport equipment. The number of
companies has increased by 9% compared to 2014. The total sales revenue of
these companies in the same year was approximately 35 million euros, which
is approximately the same as in 2014.
Companies engaged in the provision of maritime tourism and recreational
services employed around 7,875 people in 2017, about 10% more than in 2014.
Hotel staff accounted for 60% of the workforce, and employees of food and
drink establishments accounted for 35%. The number of employees per
company has remained stable between 2014 and 2017 (approximately 18
employees per company). Companies engaged in the construction of pleasure
boats and sports boats, and the renting of wat er transport equipment employed
approximately 252 people in 2017, down by 13% compared to 2014. The
number of employees per company has also decreased in recent years (from 4.2
to 3.4). In 2017, the number of enterprises actively engaged in the provision o f
maritime tourism and recreational services, as well as the construction of
pleasure and sports boats and the renting of water transport equipment
accounted for approximately 0.9% of the total number of enterprises in Estonia.
In the same year, the sales revenue of companies accounted for approximately
0.9% of the total sales revenue of Estonian companies and the number of
employees for approximately 2.1% of the total number of employees of
Estonian companies.
In addition, nature tourism is actively developing (especially bird watching on
the west coast of Estonia and the Kihnu region, as well as elsewhere in the Gulf
of Riga). Maritime tourism and recreation also have an indirect impact on other
Based on the availability of data, the economic impact of maritime tourism and recreation
210
has been assessed by taking into account he economic performance of companies engaged in
providing services in coastal areas (accommodation (including home accommodation/guest
apartments, guest houses, hotel; holiday accommodation), eating and drinking places, surfing
and sailing clubs) and in the construction of pleasure and sports boats and in the renting of
water transport equipment.
The companies involved in providing maritime tourism and recreational services have been
211
selected based on the sites located in the coastal areas mapped in the "Maritime Spatial
Planning Baseline: Mapping Social and Cultural Objects" (2016), adding to the m the
companies that provide related services and their financial performance.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 226
business sectors (adjacent support and ancillary services), whose activities are
highly dependent on the competitiveness of maritime tourism and recreation.
To complement the Marine Economic Benefit Model with ecosystem services 212,
a methodology for mapping recreational value as a cultural service in Estonian
coastal areas was developed. As part of the work, the recreational, economic
value of coastal local governments, which consisted of assessing the material
benefits of maritime cultural services, was mapped. In terms of economic value,
the value of the socio-cultural objects located in Tallinn was highest. Tallinn
was followed by the city of Pärnu. Figure 4.6.3-1 shows the distribution of the
economic value of the Estonian coastline on a scale of 0 -100 in the comparison
of local authorities by the sea.
Figure 4.6.3-1. Economic value of socio-cultural objects located in Estonian coastal
and marine areas by local governments (scale 0 -100 )
212 The work was commissioned by the Ministry of Finance. Reference: Nõmmela, K., Kotta,
J., Piirimäe, K. (2019). Complementing the model of economic benefits from the use of
marine resources with ecosystem services. University of Tartu, OÜ Hobikoda and OÜ
Roheline-Rada,
(https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/et/system/files_force/document_files/mudeli_taienda
mine_okosusteemiteenustega_aruanne.pdf).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 227
The Estonian maritime tourism and recreation sector has great development
potential. In recent years, passenger traffic in Estonia's largest port has grown
- in 2017, 311 cruise ships with 564,280 tourists visited the Port of Tallinn. At
the same time, the number of visits of these ships can be increased in the long
term by providing more attractive tourism services in coastal areas and
elsewhere in Estonia. It is also possible to open new shipping lines and receive
cruise ships in other Estonian ports. Sailing and recreational tourism also have
the potential to grow, in particular, through the rearranging of the network of
small craft harbors and the development of coastal tourism services .
Impact of the MSP
Maritime Spatial Plan does not foresee any changes in the marine areas
associated with maritime tourism and recreation and therefore has no direct
economic impact on the sector. Maritime Spatial Plan, as a guideline, promotes
the development of international passenger ship traffic and maritime
recreational and sporting activities in suitable areas, but does not set criteria
for the selection of suitable areas. From an economic standpoint, maritime
tourism and recreational activities should be encouraged wherever there is a
supply and demand. In addition, the plan provides guidance as to considering
the potential tourism value in developing new uses of the sea, which is of great
economic importance, while encouraging the development of diversified and
mutually supportive business in marine areas.
Maritime tourism-related and recreational areas are generally located in the
vicinity of the coast and therefore do not interfere with other marine use
activities. When visiting cultural heritage sites or other areas offshore,
maritime tourism companies must take into account the activities of other
economic sectors at sea. Maritime tourism and recreation are directly linked to
port operation areas, as many activities require access to the sea. Maritime
tourism and recreational activities are also linked to attractive nature reserves
and cultural heritage sites and access thereto. Maritime tourism can also be
boosted by new uses such as aquaculture (e.g., diving in aquaculture areas) and
wind energy (visits to wind farms).
In the field of maritime tourism and recreation, it is important that marine areas
have access to ports and access to nature reserves and cultural heritage sites in
order to preserve the sector's competitiveness and development potential .
The implementation of Maritime Spatial Plan does not have a direct economic
impact on maritime tourism. The guidelines set out in the plan support the
functioning of maritime tourism and encourage its development in the planning
of new maritime uses.
4.6.4 Energy production
Offshore energy production is a forward-looking industry considering global
developments. According to the Energy Development Plan 2030, the aim is to
set up wind turbines with a total installed capacity of up to 500 MW in offshore
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 228
wind farms, the construction of which would significantly develop the business
of the sector. In 2017, there were 14 economically active companies in Estonia,
whose main activity was generating electricity from wind energy 213. Compared
to 2014, the number of such companies has increased by 56%, from 9 to 14. In
2017, the total sales revenue of these companies was approximately 15 million
euros, doubling revenue per company compared to 2014. However, in 2017,
only three companies had created jobs in wind energy companies, a total o f 4,
which was less than in 2014. As of autumn, 2019, 25 companies have been
registered in Estonia, whose main activity is generating electricity from wind
energy, but the companies currently registered are engaged in wind energy
development from onshore wind farms. Analysis of companies' economic
performance reveals that wind energy development does not generate a large
number of direct jobs, but indirectly (construction, repair, and maintenance,
etc.), job creation can still be significant. In addition, it should be borne in mind
that wind energy-related economic activity is largely dependent on more windy
months of the year when both business profits and labor demand are higher .
According to the Marine Economic Benefit Model, out of the wind energy
development areas in the Maritime Spatial Plan, the area with the largest
amount of energy produced (MWh/y) is west of Saaremaa, with 32 to 34
GWh/y/km 2 . The amount of energy produced in the Gulf of Riga is around 32
GWh/y/km 2 .
213According to the Commercial Register, the main activity EMTAK 2008 code 35113
“Electricity generation from wind energy”.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 229
Figure 4.6.4-1. Energy production in planned wind farm areas, MWh/a (The
Marine Economic Benefit Model )
According to the Marine Economic Benefit Model, the value-added of the
Maritime Spatial Plan wind energy development areas in the Gulf of Riga area
is positive throughout most of the area, ranging from -0.04 to 0.23 million
€/km2/y. By contrast, the value-added of the wind farm area in the Baltic Sea
is negative, almost by half being -0.12. 0.04 million €/km2/y. The area with the
highest maximum added value for businesses is the Gulf of Riga. This is
followed by Harilaid and then the area west of Saaremaa. The maximum,
average, and minimum values of the wind energy development areas are given
in the Table . The variation in the potential added value of wind energy
development areas is shown in 4.6.4.1. When interpreting the values in the table
and the figure, the limitations of the model must be taken into account,
including in particular that the model takes into account the network connection
to the 330 kV high-voltage line of mainland Estonia, and in case of creation of
the connection to the nearby 330 kV high-voltage line in Latvia, the area west
of Saaremaa could start providing a significantly higher added value .
Table 4.6.4-1. Value-added of wind energy development areas 214, €/km2/y (Source:
The Marine Economic Benefit Model)
Maximum, minimum and mean values were obtained from the output of The Marine
214
Economic Benefit Model using the Zonal Statistics Tool.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 230
Wind energy
Maximum Mean Minimum
development area
Area west of Saaremaa
36 071 -32 439 -3 625 113
(area 2)
Gulf of Riga (area 1) 227 717 96 671 -20 749
Figure 4.6.4-2. The potential added value of wind energy in planned wind farm
areas, €/km 2 /y (Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model )
The wind energy development areas in the Maritime Spatial Plan in terms of
potential state income in the Gulf of Riga will be stably at slightly less than 0.3
M €/km 2 /y, in the area west of Saaremaa at slightly more than 0.3 M
€/km 2 /year. The area with the highest maximum state income from wind energy
is the area west of Saaremaa, which had the lowest maximum added value for
companies 215. Areas in the Gulf of Riga and close to Harilaid would provide
the maximum amount of state revenue in equal amounts (€ per km 2 per year).
The maximum, average and minimum state revenues for wind energy
development areas are given 4.6.4-2. The variation in potential state revenues
for wind energy development areas is shown in 4.6.4 -3. The limitations of the
model must be taken into account when interpreting the values in the table and
the figure.
215 For a company, higher costs mean less added value, while higher costs mean more taxes for the state.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 231
Table 4.6.4-2. State revenue from wind energy 216 in the planned wind energy
development areas, €/km 2 /y (Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model)
Wind energy
Maximum Mean Minimum
development area
Area west of Saaremaa 602 164 310 074 297 377
Gulf or Riga 299 899 292 291 282 004
Figure 4.6.4-3. State value from wind energy development in Estonian marine
areas, €/km 2 /year (Source: The Marine Economic Benefit Model)
Impact of the MSP
The introduction of offshore wind energy would increase economic
competitiveness and, as a new field of activity, bring added value to various
areas (new skills, technological developments, etc.). The 1,000 MW wind farm
would mean an investment of more than 2 billion euros to the Estonian economy
and create 70 to 100 direct long-term jobs (plus thousands of temporary jobs).
The construction of wind farms would have a significant impact on the
country's GDP and could become an important export item. The construction
and operation of the wind farm will also have an impact on other sectors (during
Maximum, minimum and mean values were obtained from the output of The Marine
216
Economic Benefit Model using the Zonal Statistics Tool.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 232
construction, in particular, the transport of materials, labour, construction work
and maintenance and repair work during operation). The operation of the wind
farm also has an impact on nearby ports, the service of which is actively
consumed, creating additional jobs there. (MKM, 16 February 2021).
The maritime spatial plan has taken into account other areas of marine use,
known natural, national defence, social, etc. restrictions and other possible
contradictions, which is why offshore wind energy development areas generally
do not impose restrictions on planning/developing other economic activities
except fishing, especially trawling. The maritime spatial plan sets a guideline
not to plan new protected natural objects to the wind energy development areas
without assessing the social and economic impacts, which is very important for
the economic activity of the sector. In addition, maritime spatial planning
makes it a condition to favour aquaculture, in particular shellfish and algae
farming, in the wind energy development areas, which is important for
strengthening the synergies between economic activities. The plan also defines
the area of innovation in wind energy, which is primarily intended for the wind
turbines and other innovative solutions on floating foundations. The
designation of an innovation area promotes the economic development of the
sector.
Maritime spatial planning will determine the marine areas suitable for wind
energy development, taking into account other areas of the maritime economy
and their possible synergies. Of the planned areas, the area with the highest
maximum added value for enterprises is located in the Gulf of Riga and the area
with the highest maximum state revenue is located west of Saaremaa. The
guidelines and conditions set out in the Maritime Spatial Plan will support the
economic development of wind energy, subject to other known limitations .
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 233
4.7 IMPACT ON CLIMATE CHANGE
Impact of climate change on planned activities
Climate change is primarily attributable to anthropogenic greenhouse gas
emissions. Potential consequences of climate change are expected to be an
increase in average temperature, rising sea levels, and an increase in extreme
weather events (storms, droughts, floods). Reducing the combustion of fossil
fuels and the use of renewable energy are considered to be important for climate
change management.
The national development plan for adaptation to climate change until 2030 217
has been prepared in Estonia and the report prepared by the Environmental
Agency entitled “Climate scenarios for Estonia's future until 2100” 218 has been
used as a scientific basis. The climate projections in this report have been
prepared for two global climate scenarios: RCP4.5 (recommended baseline
scenario; moderate scenario requiring significant national mitigation measures)
and RCP8.5 (recommended additional scenario; based on pessimistic, weak
transnational cooperation and predominantly carbon economy).
In case of both scenarios the increase in temperature is greatest in the spring
and winter months, at about 2.3–2.9 ° C (forecast for 2070). By the end of the
21st century the significant decrease in snow cover is predicted. The scenario
modelling indicates that, under the RCP4.5 scenario, the ice cover of the Baltic
Sea would have decreased in the typical winter of 2040. The coastal areas of
the Gulf of Finland, Väinameri and the Gulf of Riga will be still frozen, but the
thickness of the ice has decreased two to three times. According to RCP8.5
scenario the ice cover of the 2040s is slightly lower than in case of RCP4.5, but
still quite similar to the more optimistic scenario. Most of the survey sources
point to an increase in average wind speeds in winter and partly also in spring.
The probable range for growth is 3-18% and this is linked to the increase in the
number of cyclones moving from the Atlantic to our areas. Summer average
wind speeds increase less or not at all. It has been pointed out that , compared
to the period 1970–1999, sea surface temperatures in the coastal waters of
Estonia in the period of 2061–2090 are 2.1–2.8 ° C higher in winter and spring,
and 1.0–2.0 ° C higher in summer and autumn. The warming is greater in the
Gulf of Finland. By the end of the 21st century an increase in the average sea
level on the Estonian coast could mean 20–40 cm for the future scenario RCP4.5
and almost 40–60 cm for RCP8.5.
The projected increase in temperature and total precipitation in climatic
scenarios, and the increase in storms will lead to different directions. Changes
217
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/kliimamuutustega_kohanemise_arengukava_aastani_
2030_1.pdf
218
https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/kliimastsenaariumid_kaur_aruann e_ver190815.pdf
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 234
such as the intensification of eutrophication, the growth of southern alien
species, and the decline of key cold-water species will have a negative impact
on marine biodiversity and the balance of the marine environment. One of the
most important environmental problems in the Baltic Sea is the eutrophication
of the sea. In addition, climate change will result in regime shifts in food chains
and longer vegetation periods, as well as increasing overall secondary and
primary production, the impacts of which on the various processes and general
functioning of the marine environment are unknown. The decline in salinity in
the Baltic Sea, as well as mechanical disturbances in storms, can affect the
species composition and diversity of communities.
According to the 2030 Climate Change Adaptation Development Plan the
changes in the climate factors forecasted until 2100 will have a relatively small
effect on the availability of energy resources, much less on the basis of the
projections until 2040. The lifetime of the maritime spatial plan currently being
prepared is projected to run until 2030, but as the investments in the maritime
sector, especially in the wind farms, are long-term investments in the future,
the climate change should be taken into account in the chosen technology.
The impact of the MSP on climate change and the achievement of climate goals
In 2017 the Riigikogu (the parliament of Estonia) adopted the General
Principles of Climate Policy until 2050, which aims to reduce greenhouse gas
emissions by at least 80% by 2050 and to replace the carbon-intensive energy
production mainly with local renewable energy production 219. As regards the
local renewable energy production opportunities, increasing the share of
electricity produced in offshore wind farms has the greatest CO2 reduction
potential in absolute terms. It is estimated that the total volume of wind energy
in Estonia will be 12% of total consumption by 2030 220..
The general principles of climate policy until 2050 (KPP) and the Energy Sector
Development Plan until 2030 (ENMAK) have been prepared and adopted at a
time when the ambitions of both Estonia and the EU to curb climate change
were considerably lower than at present. While the EU has now committed itself
to achieving a carbon-neutral economy by 2050, the goal that has also been
confirmed nationally by the Estonian government, the KPP adopted in 2017 is
based on the goal of reducing collective emissions by 80% by 2050 compared
to 1990 levels. Similarly, both ENMAK and KPP are currently based on an
intermediate target of a 40% reduction in emissions in the EU as a whole by
2030, although the European Commission has now proposed raising this target
to 55%, which was also supported by the leaders of the EU Member States in
December. The current targets in both ENMAK and KPP are not clear and
219
General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050, Ministry of the Environment 2017
220
Analysis of the possibilities of raising Estonia's climate ambition, SEIT 219
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 235
detailed enough to achieve the goals of the Paris Climate Agreement and do not
provide the necessary certainty for renewable energy developers 221.
In its current form KPP does not reflect the role of the energy sector and
renewable energy in achieving climate neutrality with more ambitious
intermediate and final targets (2030, 2040, 2050), thus KPP should be updated
accordingly and a trajectory should be added that clearly shows the specific
goals and targets for the development of Estonia's renewable energy economy
for 2030, 2040 and 2050 222.
KPP and ENMAK form the main basis for the Estonian national energy and
climate plan coordinating the sector which was approved by the government in
2019 until 2030, where the following national energy and climate goals are set
for Estonia:
▪ the share of renewable energy in total final energy consumption in 2030
is 42%, including 50% of final energy consumption,
▪ the volume of electricity production from renewable sources in 2030 is
40% of the total final electricity consumption,
▪ the share of renewable sources in the heat economy is 63% of the total
final heat consumption,
▪ the share of renewable sources in the transport sector is 14% of the total
final consumption of transport fuels,
▪ to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions by 13% in the sectors covered
by the Shared Commitment Regulation by 2030 compared to 2005,
▪ the final energy consumption should remain at 32-33 TWh/y up to 2030.
The long-term development strategy “Estonia 2035” (adopted by the Riigikogu
on 12 May 2021) sets out the basic principle that by 2050 Estonia will be a
competitive, climate-neutral country with a knowledge-based society and
economy, where a high quality and species-rich living environment is ensured
and readiness and ability to reduce the adverse effects of climate change and
make the most of the positive effects is ensured. Estonia does not set precise
goals and targets for setting climate neutrality in the action plan of “Estonia
2035” strategy.
According to the Estonian Renewable Energy Chamber, as of the end of 2018,
140 wind turbines with the total capacity of 314 MW have been connected to
the grid in Estonia. In 2018, 591 GWh of wind energy was generated for th e
grid, which is 12% less than a year earlier, when the total production of wind
221
Application of environmental associations to the Government of the Republic for
opening KPP and ENMAK (2 March
2021),https://media.voog.com/0000/0037/1265/files/KPP%26ENMAK%20avamise%20taotl
us%20keskkonnauhendustelt.pdf
222
The same as previous
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 236
electricity reached 669 GWh. The wind energy also accounts for about 7% of
final electricity consumption 223.
The construction of the wind farms for electricity production means increasing
the share of renewable electricity production, which creates the preconditions
for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from the combustion of fossil fuels. The
construction of offshore wind farms will help to achieve these goals. If we look at the
entire life cycle of a wind farm, which includes the manufacture, transport, erection,
operation and demolishing (dismantling) of a wind turbine, less than 1% of the CO2
emitted by a fossil fuel power plant is emitted per kwh of electricity production.
During its lifetime the wind farm produces 33 times more energy than spent on
its production, maintenance and demolition 224. In addition, the utilization factor
of offshore wind farms in the development of wind farms is considered to be
twice as high as on land, approximately 45… 50%. With this maritime spatial
plan the wind energy development areas are planned for an area of approx. 1710
km 2 . At present, several areas of the offshore wind farm are already in the
process of being developed. If the production potential of the existing wind
farms is currently 2+ GW, then the potential of the new offshore areas would
be about 8.5 GW.
In the global and national context the use of wind energy is generally more
environmentally friendly than the use of fossil fuels (such as oil shale , which
is predominant in Estonia). For example, about 1.4 kg of oil shale is needed to
produce 1 kWh of electricity. If 5% of electricity were produced in Estonia with
the help of wind, the need for oil shale would decrease by 0.67 million tons per
year, which would save 15 ha of land per year from direct excavation. The
impact of the mine / quarry on vegetation, fauna and especially groundwater
may be considerably greater. In the production of oil shale electricity, the
production of 1 MWh of electricity (with today's technology) emits 1,350 kg of
CO2, 1.1–1.5 kg of NOx and 10–18 kg of SO2.
A study of the Vestas V90-3.0 MW wind turbine 225 found that the wind turbine
produces the amount of energy it needs in a lifetime within 6.6 months.
However, during its lifetime, this wind turbine generates about 158,000 MWh
of energy or 36 times more energy than it consumes in its lifetime. In a very
good location, this wind turbine generates about 280,000 MWh during its
lifetime (over 20 years). Compared to its environmental impact, this wind
turbine emits 230,000 tons less carbon dioxide than when burning coal to
produce the same amount of energy. In addition, 80% of the wind turbine can
be reused at the end of its life.
223
Renewable Energy Yearbook 2018, ETEK 2019
224 http://hiiumeretuulepark.ee/projekt/meretuulepargi -elutsukkel
225 Life cycle assessment of offshore and onshore sited wind energy plants based on Vestas
V90-3,0 MW turbines. Vestas Wind Systems A/S, 200 6
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 237
With the introduction of the planned wind energy development areas, the total
production of renewable energy in Estonia would increase significantly. The
implementation of the maritime spatial plan will have a direct positive impact
on climate change and it is moved closer to achieving climate goals.
PROPOSALS FOR THE ACTION PLAN:
1. To update and formulate clear climate goals at the national level, which
would clearly indicate, among other things, the specific goals and
objectives for the development of Estonia's renewable energy economy
for 2030, 2040 and 2050
4.8 CUMULATIVE IMPACTS
Cumulative impacts are the combined impacts of one or more activities, which
can be manifested by the accumulation of similar impacts of several activities,
where there may be many activities, and an important aspect is that the addition
of activities results in a change 226. Cumulative impacts may occur when spatial
or temporal overlaps, repeated removal or inflow of resources, or landscape
changes occur due to the plan (s) and its intended activities 227.
Impact of the MSP
Cumulative impacts on the natural environment can occur in a marine area
where, for example, several large-scale activities are planned close by. One of
the biggest threats for birds, as well as for other species and marine habitats
and biota, is certainly the simultaneous construction of large wind farms. In
particular, an impact may accumulate in the Gulf of Riga, where the current
MSP designates wind energy development area No 1 (see Figure 4.8 -1). Close
to this area, there are also wind energy development areas foreseen in the
Maritime Spatial Plan of Pärnu and Latvia, as well as several applications for
superficies license for the construction of wind farms that have been initiated
by far. Adverse impacts can be most pronounced on birds (see section 4.2.2)
and bats (see section 4.2.4), both during the construction phase of wind farms
and during their operation.
226Peterson, K., Kutsar, R., Metspalu, P., Vahtrus, S. and Kalle, H. 2017. Strategic
Environmental Assessment Handbook. Ministry of the Environment, 137 p.
227
Cooper, L. M. 2004. Guidelines for Cumulative Effects Assessment in SEA of Plans.
EPMG Occasional Paper 04/LMC/CEA. imperial College London.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 238
Figure 4.8-1. Wind energy development areas initially planned for the entire
marine area and applications for superficies licences initiated for the
construction of wind farms together with important nature conservation areas
In the course of the present Maritime Spatial Plan, information on bird
migration and staging areas for all Estonian marine areas was compiled and
based on this, sensitive areas for marine birds were identified (Chapter 4.2.2).
According to the current information, several wind energy development areas
previously defined by Pärnu County Planning, as well as several initiated
superficies license applications, will be in the sensiti ve Site of Community
Importance (see Figure 4.8-2). If the proposed wind farm areas planned for
those areas are realized, it is not known in advance how the birds will adapt to
the wind farm and how different bird species will change their behavior
patterns. The authorization procedure for each proposed project should be
based on the best and most up-to-date environmental information.
The surveys of bats in the marine area in recent years have also shown that one
of the most important migration corridors runs across the islands of Kihnu and
Ruhnu in the Gulf of Riga (see Chapter 4.2.4 for details).
Cumulative impacts on birds and bats may occur when several wind farms are
simultaneously built close to each other. Unexpectedly, large -scale flight
obstruction may occur, and adaptation to it will take longer than when just
building a single wind farm. Therefore, in order to avoid cumulative impacts,
it is important to provide important migratory corridors for birds and bats
(Figure 4.8-2) and to further assess synergies with other envisaged plans and
projects during each licensing procedure to avoid bottlenecks and/or obstacles
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 239
to migration in the marine area. The design of the offshore wind farm areas
included in this Maritime Spatial Plan takes into account imp ortant migratory
corridors as well as sensitive areas for species in order to avoid a significant
adverse impact.
The proposed wind farms in the Gulf of Riga may also have a combined effect
on seals. The exact mechanism of navigation of seals is not known, but
telemetry refers to the ability of ringed seals to travel long distances on the
high seas, e.g. to the mouth of the Great Strait (see Chapters 4.2.3 and Figure
4.2.3-3) or as to gray seals from Irbe Strait to Allirahu almost in a straight line.
The wind farms may affect the trajectories of seals in the "bottleneck" in the
Gulf of Riga, as the migration corridor between the wind farms has been
significantly compressed in an east-west direction.
The areas suitable for the development of wind energy that overlap with
historically more intensive trawl fisheries will be designated as reserve areas
(to be operational from 2027), which will help to reduce impediment as
movement corridors and allow better knowledge of seal behaviour over time.
Other potential spatial effects of wind farms are also indirectly linked to seals,
such as the concentration of fishing vessels / offshore fishing in the areas where
trawling is difficult in the wind farms in other parts of the gulf and the overlap
of fisheries between humans and animals will be significantly higher than
today.
The primary objective of the impact assessment was to avoid conflicting uses
of the sea in inappropriate areas; thus, the plan excludes new offshore activities
such as wind energy and the establishment of fish farming areas in nature
protection areas.
Aquaculture areas are not specifically spatially envisaged the current Maritime
Spatial Plan, so in case of planned establishment of fish farms close to each
other, it is important to always assess synergies with other activities in the area
and, in particular, what changes in water quality and how it affects the status
of the water body.
While fish farms in natural waters increase the burden on the environment, the
cultivation of seaweed and shellfish as nutrient -depleting aquaculture is
considered to be environmentally sustainable management. In addition to
nutrient removal, this shell farm significantly increases the transparenc y of
water within a radius of about 1 km 2 and reduces the risk of local algal blooms.
Consequently, it is prudent to place shellfish farms in the vicinity of fish farms
in the coastal sea, as this combination can compensate for the nutrient fluxes
from fish farms to the sea and keep the water in the vicinity of the fish farm
transparent.
The Maritime Spatial Plan foresees the need to direct and increase developers'
knowledge and confidence in implementing cooperative solutions. Synergistic
impacts will also occur, for example, in the joint development of a wind farm
and shellfish farming. Compact and well-thought-out development has
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 240
synergistic positive impacts on both the natural and economic environment, and
the proposed activities have a multiplicative or exponential impact on each
other.
Cumulative impact model
During the course of the Maritime Spatial Plan, PlanWise4Blue 228, a web
application for public use was prepared containing a model of the cumulative
environmental impact of human activities. Such a model 229 enables access in
the Estonian marine area the environmental impact of the proposed activities
on the marine area.
The sub-model of environmental impact dynamically links the existing
situation (modeled existing environmental data layers), and the impact matrix
(i.e., knowledge of how different human uses and intensity of uses potentially
affect a particular marine region) to planned human uses. The sub -model of
cumulative impacts allows for the calculation of major environmental risks
associated with human use and allows for the display of spatial overlaps
between natural values and different human uses. In a sub -model of
environmental impact, an impact can be combined through summation,
compensation, etc. One effect can increase or decrease the other. In synergism,
the combined effect of the two impacts is greater than the sum effect of the
individual impacts.
This Impact Assessment used the main solution of the Estonian Maritime
Spatial Plan as input to the cumulative impacts sub-model to assess the
environmental impact of the activities planned by the Maritime Spatial Plan. In
addition, other data layers of human activities available in the marine area that
are not reflected in the planning solution were used as input (Pärnu County and
Hiiu Island (except for its wind energy development areas that have been
abolished) Marine Area County Plans, etc.). The PlanWise4Blue model
assessed the combined impacts of marine activities - trawling, inland waterway,
dumping and deposits - and wind energy development areas foreseen in the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan on different ecosystem components, as these
activities can have a significant impact on the environment .
228 Nõmmela, K, University of Tartu CASS; Kotta, J., OÜ Hobikoda; Piirimäe, K., OÜ
Roheline Rada “PlanWise4Blue: A Web-Based Model for Estimating the Cumulative
Environmental Impact of Human Activities and The Marine Economic Benefit Model”;
Commissioned by Ministry of Finance, 2019
(https://www.financingministeerium.ee/en/system/files_force/ document_files/planwise4blue
_model_description.pdf)
229 When interpreting the results of PlanWise4Blue application, it is important to consider
that it is currently used as a discussion platform rather than a means of reflecting reality, as
due to the lack of sufficient measurement results, some parameter values have a high degree
of uncertainty. In addition, many new human uses (particularly for interactive effects) still
have a high level of uncertainty, and further research is needed to determine more accu rately
the interactive environmental impacts of human use.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 241
The analysis of the environmental impact of the wind energy developments was
based on the following technical solutions. The wind turbines have been built
on the concrete foundation with a texture similar to natural material, i.e. the
material is suitable for attaching to seaweeds and large invertebrates, then the
foundation is filled with natural stone material. The expected diameter of the
wind turbine foundation is less than 100 m. The height of the concrete truncated
cone is 10 m. The top height of the wind turbine is about 300 m and the diameter
of the rotor is in the size class of 250 m. The distance between the wind turbines
was calculated to be 4-7 wind turbine diameters, i.e. a minimum of 800 m. The
cumulative impact model does not take into account the environmental impacts
during construction, but the environmental impact of gravity-based foundations
is clearly lower than the other existing solutions.
In the scenario described above, the model analysis showed that the human uses
studied do not have a clear negative environmental impact on a large number
of ecosystem indicators. Of the human activities studied, the Estonian marine
environment is most affected by water traffic areas and trawling. Fish -eating
birds are the most disturbed of these activities, and ship traffic also influences
the formation of wintering areas for birds. In addition, waterborne traffic and
trawling have a negative impact on bladderwrack and agar habitats and,
consequently, on Baltic herring spawning grounds. However, in the case of the
predictions described above, the natural recovery potential is greater than the
rate of anthropogenic degradation. Water traffic areas and trawling do not have
a significant negative impact on other natural values, including marine
mammals, other key habitats, and Habitats Directive habitats.
Illustratively, the results of the model analysis are shown in Figure 4.8-4 below
as combined impacts of marine activities (trawling, waterborne traffic areas,
dumping areas, and deposits) with wind energy development areas foreseen in
the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan for Habitats Directive Habitats (1170) reefs.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 242
Figure 4.8-2. Using the PlanWise4Blue model the combined impact of the
activities in the maritime area - trawling, water traffic areas, dumping areas and
deposits - and the wind energy development areas provided for in the Estonian
maritime spatial plan on different natural values was assessed. The present
figure illustrates the cumulative environmental impacts on the LoD habitat type
reefs (1170). The area loss of reefs is shown in red, the addition of reef habitat
is shown in blue, and areas where the area of reefs does not change significantly
are shown in green. The projected changes are less than 1% everywhere, i.e.
the natural recovery potential is many times higher than the rate of human -
induced depletion.
According to the predetermined scenario of the model (i.e., wind turbine
technical solution – gravity-based foundations, built on concrete foundations
with a texture similar to natural material, etc.), the development of wind energy
does not lead to significant negative environmental impact. Even in such more
open areas of the Baltic Sea, the construction of wind farms can increase the
Habitats Directive's Habitat type reef (1170) area by up to 1.7% due to the
natural scarcity of stable rocky substrates in the planned wind energy
development areas. The growth of this valuable habitat will only be realized if
the texture of the concrete foundations of the wind turbines is suitable as an
anchorage for seaweed and invertebrates, and there are no other adverse
environmental impacts not considered in the model. If a solution other than the
one described above is to be used, the parameters of the desired solution for
environmental impact assessment must be analyzed with PlanWise4Blue (or a
similar approach, i.e., incorporate existing research into the analysis of the
impact of wind farms and use the most recent source data map layers on natural
values).
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 243
The implementation of the maritime spatial plan will not have a significant
adverse cumulative effect if the key migratory corridors for birds and bats are
secured on the basis of current knowledge at the level of decisions and areas
sensitive to wildlife, such as fish spawning grounds, sensitive Site of
Community Importance, etc., are taken into account. The planning of wind
energy development areas provided for in this Maritime Spatial Plan shall take
into account both important areas of the migration corridor and sensitive areas
in order to avoid significant adverse effects.
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. In the licensing procedure, synergies with other similar implemented
and, if possible, planned plans and projects shall be assessed in order to
avoid cumulative impacts in the marine area, including bottlenecks of
and/or obstacles to migration.
2. The potential biosecurity risks associated with aquaculture must be assessed in
the licensing process, both at the individual project level and in conjunction with
the activities of a near vicinity fish farm (e.g., to assess and determine the
distance between farms of different companies to avoid biosecurity risks).
4.9 TRANSBOUNDARY IMPACT
The transboundary environmental impact assessment of Estonia will be carried
out in accordance with the international agreements, the Convention on
Environmental Impact Assessment in a Transboundary Context (Espoo
Convention), and the Environmental Impact Assessment and Environmental
Management System Act. The process and involvement of the transboundary
impact assessment are managed by the Ministry of the Environment .
The Ministry of the Environment has sent notifications of the cross-border SEA
process three times according to the table below.
Notification Replies received
Denmark, Germany and Poland have indicated that
they do not wish to participate in the cross -border
process.
The notification of the intention to develop the
initial outlines for the maritime spatial plan and Feedback was received from Sweden, Finland,
the SEA process (26 November 2018) was sent to Latvia and Lithuania, who indicated their
Denmark, Finland, Germany, Latvia, Lithuania, willingness to be involved in the cross -border
Poland, Russia and Sweden. process.
Russia did not respond with regard to the initial
notification, so with regard to wider involvement
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 244
Notification Replies received
in terms of information, notifications will also be
sent to Russia.
The proposals and comments were received from
Sweden, Finland and Latvia in the cross -border
involvement process.
Notification of the draft maritime spatial plan and
the completion of the initial draft plan (with the The feedback given by the neighbouring countries
initial input of the SEA) (20 May 2019) to Finland, to the explanatory memorandum to the plan and
Latvia, Lithuania, Russia and Sweden. the SEA process and their summaries by different
proposals are provided in Annex 5.
The proposals and comments were received from
Sweden, Finland and Latvia in the cross -border
involvement process.
The feedback given by the neighbouring countries
Notification of completion of the main solution of
to the explanatory memorandum to the plan and
the maritime spatial plan and SEA report (15
the SEA process and their summaries by different
September 2020) to Finland, Latvia, Lithuania,
proposals have been provided in Annex 5. The
Russia and Sweden.
most important issues highlighted are: 1) the
proposed wind energy development areas should
not impede international shipping traffic; and 2)
the impacts associated with aquaculture areas and
the planning conditions affecting them.
Wider involvement and international cooperation with other countries has been
addressed in Chapter 5.
There are no direct cross-border effects of the plan. Most of the spatially
planned areas are located at a sufficient distance from the border of the Estonian
territorial sea. The proposed wind energy development area no. 1 is located
approximately 5 km from the Latvian border. The change of views may also
take place on the Cape of Kolka, but as the wind turbines are expected to remain
visible from only one view (northeast view), this is not a significant impact.
The Latvian state has not submitted any proposals or views on this is sue in the
framework of cross-border co-operation.
In order to transform energy in Europe, including the Baltic Sea region, into an
environmentally friendly and climate-neutral one, in addition to wind power
generation areas producing electricity from renewable sources, it is necessary
to develop high-capacity transnational electricity connections, such as
submarine cable connections to Sweden and/or Latvia. The strategic plans and
more specific actions for the Baltic Sea Region energy network have not yet
been finalized. Potential transboundary impacts need to be specified and
assessed during the environmental impact assessment process at each project
level.
Indirect impact on marine habitats and biota may include:
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 245
▪ Possible adverse transboundary impact on the lifetime impact of the
offshore wind farm on birds;
▪ Potential transboundary impact on fish and seals during the construction
phase of the proposed activities (noise, sediment spreading, etc ;
▪ If the planned wind farm areas are to be connected to a foreign country
by a cable (Latvia, Finland, or Sweden) in the future, this activity may
lead to a transboundary impact;
▪ Potential adverse transboundary impacts on the underwater cultural
heritage during the construction phase (to be mitigated by the following
the conditions set out in the plan)
The objective of both the Maritime Spatial Plan, to be prepared, and the present
impact assessment was to develop a planning solution that takes into account
the values of the natural environment (including synergies with other marine
activities) and excludes potential conflicts at the project level .
There is no direct transboundary impact associated with the MSP .
ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES:
1. Potential transboundary impacts need to be specified and assessed
during the EIA process at the project level.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 246
5 OVERVIEW OF THE ORGANIZATION
AND INVOLVEMENT OF THE IMPACT
ASSESSMENT
5.1 ORGANIZATION OF IMPACT ASSESSMENT
The organizer of the planning and impact assessment is the Planning
Department of the Ministry of Finance and OÜ Hendrikson & Ko, a consultant
for the preparation of the planning and impact assessment, together with a
broad-based Task Group.
Hendrikson & Ko's broad-based expert group on Maritime Spatial Plan and
impact assessment included:
Name Role Authority
Pille Metspalu Project manager, planner Hendrikson & Ko OÜ
Riin Kutsar SEA Leading Expert Hendrikson & Ko OÜ
Marika Pärn Planner, additional specialist Hendrikson & Ko OÜ
Ann Ideon Specialist in Social Impact Assessment Hendrikson & Ko OÜ
Jaanus Padrik, Kairit
Geoinformatics specialist Hendrikson & Ko OÜ
Kase
Environmental specialist, additional
Kaile Eschbaum Hendrikson & Ko OÜ
specialist
Maritime Institute of the University of
Georg Martin Marine Environment Specialist
Tartu
Maritime Institute of the University of
Redik Echbaum Fisheries specialist
Tartu
Marine Environment Specialist (Cartography, Maritime Institute of the University of
Jonne Kotta
Geographic Information Systems, Modeling) Tartu
Center for Applied Social Sciences,
Kaidi Nõmmela Specialist in Economic Impact Assessment
University of Tartu
Kristjan Piirimäe Geoinformatics consultant OÜ Roheline Rada
Helen Sooväli-
Specialist in Cultural Impact Assessment Tallinn University
Sepping
Ain Kull Energy Specialist University of Tartu
Hans Orru Specialist in Health Impact Assessment University of Tartu
Liina Härm Marine Transport Specialist Hiiu Sailing Ship Society
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 247
The planning process and the impact assessment were carried out
simultaneously, taking into account as far as possible the environmental impact
associated with the implementation of the plan, including socio -economic,
cultural, and health impact, of the implementation of the plan, in order t o ensure
sustainable and balanced spatial development. The overall timeline for the
planning and impact assessment is illustrated in Figure 5.1-1. Annex 4 provides
an overview of the cooperation with authorities, stakeholders, and the public in
the framework of the planning and impact assessment, together with a more
detailed timetable.
Figure 5.1-1. Schedule for the planning and impact assessment
5.2 COOPERATION AND INCLUSION
In accordance with the Planning Act, persons were included whose rights may
be affected by the planning, persons who have expressed a wish to be included
in the preparation thereof, as well as authorities who may have a legitimate
interest in the relevant social, cultural, economic, natural environmental impact
or spatial development trends in the planning area, including environmental
non-governmental organizations through an organization unifying them, and
non-profit organizations and foundations representing the inhabitants of the
planned area. Stakeholders are brought together in a separate planning
document - the plan for inclusion, see the planning portal
mereala.hendrikson.ee 230.
Co-operation with stakeholders, authorities, and interested parties started in the
initial phase of planning. In addition to the activities required by the Planning
Act, regional discussions were conducted at the SP and DP stages as well as at
the draft planning stage. The aim of the regional discussions was to map the
values of the marine space and to discuss the regional specificities of mar itime
use and the resulting principles. Annex 4 provides an overview of the
230 ESTONIAN MARITIME SPATIAL PLANNING COOPERATION AND INCLUSION
PLAN,
http://mereala.hendrikson.ee/dokumendid/L%C3%A4hteseisukohad/MSP_kaasamiskava_okt
oober_2018.pdf
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 248
cooperation with authorities, stakeholders, and the public in the framework of
the planning and impact assessment.
The EU Maritime Spatial Planning Directive states that as part of the planning
and management process, the Member States bordering marine waters shall
cooperate with the aim of ensuring that maritime spatial plans are coherent and
coordinated across the marine region concerned (Article 11 (1)). Furthermore,
the Directive states that where possible, to cooperate with third countries on
their actions with regard to maritime spatial planning in the relevant marine
regions and in accordance with international law and conventions (Article 12).
Estonia has cooperated with all BRS countries, especially Finland, Sweden,
Latvia, and Russia, in the maritime spatial planning process. Different
international forums, such as the European Commission and the HELCOM -
VASAB Maritime Spatial Planning Working Group, or international
cooperation projects such as Baltic SCOPE, Pan Baltic Scope, Plan4Blue,
BalticLines, etc., have been used to organize this cooperation.
Within the framework of the Baltic SCOPE project, Estonia has worked closely
with the authorities responsible for maritime spatial planning in Sweden and
Latvia. The project has streamlined approaches to cross-border maritime spatial
planning and set goals and recommendations for further cooperation. The
Plan4Blue project was a co-operation project between Estonia and Finland
aimed at creating blue economy scenarios for the Gulf of Finland region .
5.3 DIFFICULTIES WHICH AROSE WHILE
CONDUCTING THE SEA REPORT
The strategic environmental assessment was somewhat complicated by the
delay in preparing the planning solution beyond the initially planned schedule.
This was largely due to the situation caused by the spread of the COVID -19
pandemic and the related operational problems.
The content and generalization level of the strategic planning document have
been taken into account in compiling the impact assessment report, but the
Supreme Court decisions that have entered into force in recent years have
created ambiguity and uncertainty about the correct and sufficient accuracy of
general strategic level impact assessments, including the thoroughness of the
studies and analyses performed. Based on the decisions of the Supreme Court,
there are no more specific guidelines regarding the content of the impact
assessment set by the relevant institutions and there are conflicting views
regarding the interpretations of the decisions.
The task of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan as a national strategic
development document is to guide the use of the Estonian maritime space in
the long term, setting out the basic principles and rules for t he spatial
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 249
development of various maritime uses. The aim of the plan is to create a
comprehensive picture of the interaction of different marine uses and to agree
on the spatial principles of the use of the Estonian marine area for the next 15
years in order to contribute to achieving and maintaining the good state of the
marine environment and promoting the maritime economy. In order to achieve
the long-term directions and an overall picture at the national level, maritime
spatial planning is based on international trends, national interests and national
development documents. As the goal is a balanced spatial approach to the entire
Estonian maritime area at the national level, the degree of generalization is high
- the focus is on setting general principles and the activities are not planned in
detail (which, however, are necessary for the preparation of the impact
assessment and for the assurance in this respect). The guidelines and conditions
set by the plan will be the basis for future decisions concerning the maritime
area, including the issue of authorizations.
The recent decisions of the Supreme Court regarding the maritime spatial plan
bordering Hiiu County and the Rail Baltic region County-wide spatial plan have
emphasized that the impact assessment should be based on the data reasonably
available at the time of the assessment, including the data collected through
new surveys. It has also been pointed out that at the general planning level it is
necessary to form a conviction that the selected areas of wind energy
development are in principle suitable, i.e. at least under certain conditions, for
the production of wind energy. Although the decision of the Supreme Court
referred to was made at a time when the maritime spatial plan was already being
prepared, the bottlenecks identified in the decision have been taken into account
when conducting the impact assessment.
Some of the parties involved have had the expectation that the detailed field
studies of various natural values in the marine area will be carried out and that
detailed conditions for the construction of wind farms will be established on
the basis of this. This expectation is not in line with the strategic nature of the
plan. Namely, the plan answers the question of whether, where and under what
conditions it is possible to build offshore wind farms by selecting suitable areas
for wind energy production, by setting specific conditions and guidelines at the
authorization level, including a comprehensive framework for research and
other important follow-up activities. As a result of the research of the next
stage, it will become clear, taking into account the particularities of the specific
location and technological solutions, how many wind turbines and with which
parameters can be installed to the selected areas and what will be the exact
location. The strategic nature of the plan and the activities of the authorization
stage have been explained to the parties.
As part of the impact assessment of the maritime spatial plan, it is known that
for the first time in Estonia the visual impacts of the implementation of the
strategic development document were thoroughly discussed. It was concluded
within the framework of the visual impact assessment that the wind turbines
located in the areas suitable for the production of wind energy selected in the
Estonian maritime spatial plan will inevitably be visible from the coast, ie there
will be a visual change in the sea views. It is not possible to build offshore wind
farms in such a way that they are not visible from the shore at all, for the latter
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 250
purpose the wind farms should be designed at a distance of 50 km from the
coast. However, the sea in Estonia is becoming deep fast and it is not possible
to plan the wind farms so far from the coast with the current technologies and
capabilities. The possibilities for reducing the visibility of each specific wind
farm and/or the needs to tolerate disturbances (the need of compensation)
should be identified in the authorization procedure of the wind farm. The
maritime spatial plan sets out the conditions and guidelines for the latter
purpose.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 251
6 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
The comprehensive impact assessment of the Maritime Spatial Plan has
analyzed the planning solution in the context of the relevant impact on the
natural, economic, cultural, and social environment. In other words, the
significant and common impacts of the implementation of the plan, which for
some reason needed to be assessed when the plan was being prepared, were
assessed. Proposals to prevent and reduce significant environmental impact and
recommendations for the consideration of environmental measures fo r further
development and implementation of the planning solution have been made by
various environmental sectors.
The preparation of the Maritime Spatial Plan and the Impact Assessment was
based on existing marine studies and expert analyses (during the planning
process, a number of marine space analyzes were carried out to map sensitive
areas). This Impact Assessment has already proposed, at a strategic level, the
avoidance of more important wildlife sensitive areas on the basis of the
principle of prevention and the precautionary principle. The impact assessment
has been carried out, taking into account the degree of accuracy of the planning
document and the extent of its content. In cases where marine wildlife mapping
needs to be refined, and the impact of the proposed activity depends on
technical solutions, it was proposed to include in terms of the planning decision
that relevant studies need to be specified or further conducted in the licensing
stage to ensure significant marine ecosystems and good condition of the marine
environment.
6.1 SUMMARY OF IMPACTS
The role of the planning solution and its assessment, due to the degree of
accuracy of the Strategic Planning Document, was to review the existing
activities and planned activities in synergy and to promote the diversified use
of the marine area. Due to the focus of the planning solution, the cumulative
impacts will occur, particularly in areas where new uses for the sea are being
planned. The most important points of cumulative impacts are:
1. Wind energy development area No 1 in the Gulf of Riga
Although nature values have also been used as a basis for the designation of
wind energy development areas, a further study of bird migration corridors and
staging points showed a significant impact in the eastern part of wind area 1.
In the areas of the Gulf of Riga and Pärnu Bay, wind energy development areas
have also been planned with the Pärnu Maritime Spatial Plan and the Latvian
Maritime Spatial Plan. The maximum realization of these areas would be a
large-scale wind energy production area, which requires very good wind
resources. As a result, it was decided to reduce the wind energy development
area No 1 by removing the southeast edge of the area, which accounts for 13%
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 252
of the total area. Reducing the wind energy development area will have a
negative economic impact as well as slightly worsen the chances of meeting the
climate targets. In this case, however, the need to mitigate the impacts on birds
must be given priority. As it is a large wind energy devel opment area
concentrated in one area, the reduction of the area can also be considered as not
a significant negative impact in terms of economic impact as it helps to avoid
over-consumption of wind resources. This will also free up additional trawl
fishing grounds, which would, however, be expected to operate also in
conjunction with wind energy.
2. Water traffic areas and principles of port network development
In order to ensure the optimal functioning of maritime transport, it was decided
to designate, in addition to water traffic areas, the basic passage corridors for
shipping, which must remain free of wind turbines. The surface area of wind
energy development areas was also further reduced to ensure safety in specific
heavy ship traffic areas. The economic impact assessment states that, from an
economic standpoint, the selection criteria for port network design should not
be limited to the factors (natural compatibility and distance) provided as
guidelines in Maritime Spatial Plan. At the same time, it mus t be borne in mind
that the creation of new ports is an activity that has a significant impact on the
natural environment, and the necessity of this must be carefully considered.
During the planning process, it has become clear that in the near future, the
existing port network needs attention in particular in order to avoid the poor
return on investments already made. The purpose of the planning is to better
target the port network, and therefore, some restrictions must be considered
indispensable.
Proposals must be taken into account in a balanced way in the further
development of the planning solution.
The impact assessment focused on identifying the impact of marine activities
in order to avoid conflicts. The MSP excluded new marine activities such as
offshore wind farms and the establishment of fish farming areas in nature
conservation areas
6.2 CONCLUSION
The level of detail in the preparation of Maritime Spatial Plan does not foresee
any adverse impacts from the implementation of the spatial plan, taking i nto
account the conditions and guidelines set out in the spatial plan and the
environmental measures 231 provided in this Impact Assessment for the spatial
planning and future licensing levels.
231 A broad-based approach is meant here, the environmental measures can be targeted at the natural, cultural, social
and / or economic environment.
Mereala planeeringu mõjuhindamine 253
7 ANNEXES
Annex 1. Impact assessment VTK
Annex 2. Socio-cultural values of maritime counties
Annex 3. Summary table of visual impact assessments
(presented as a separate .xls file)
Annex 4. Overview of the cooperation with authorities,
stakeholders and the public in the framework of planning
and impact assessment
Annex 5. Proposals received and responses submitted in the
course of cross-border involvement (presented as a separate
file directory)
GOVERNMENT OF THE REPUBLIC
ORDER
12 May 2022 No 146
Establishment of the Thematic Spatial Plan of
the National Spatial Plan’s Estonian
Maritime Area and the Adjacent Coastal
Area, as well as the Exclusive Economic Zone
The Order is established pursuant to § 24 (1) of the Planning Act and in accordance with § 13
(2) of the same Act.
I FACTS AND PROCEDURE
1. On the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan
The Government of the Republic, with its Order No. 368 "Establishment of the National Spatial
Plan “Estonia 2030+""1 from August 30, 2012, established the National Spatial Plan "Estonia
2030+" (hereinafter referred to as National Spatial Plan). Pursuant to § 13 (2) of the Planning
Act (hereinafter the Planning Act), a national spatial plan may be prepared as a thematic spatial
plan that extends to marine areas, the adjacent coastal areas and also the exclusive economic
zone, and the functions to be solved by the thematic spatial plan are specified in § 14 (2) of the
Planning Act. The present thematic spatial plan specifies the existing National Spatial Plan.2
The Government of the Republic of Estonia issued Order No 157 of 25 May 2017 "Initiation
of the Strategic Environmental Assessment and the Thematic Spatial Plan of the National
Spatial Plan’s Estonian Maritime Area and the Adjacent Coastal Area, as well as the Exclusive
Economic Zone"3 initiating the preparation of the Thematic Spatial Plan of the National Spatial
Plan’s Estonian Maritime Area and the Adjacent Coastal Area, as well as the Exclusive
Economic Zone (hereinafter the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan).
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan has been drawn up taking into account the solutions of the
Maritime Spatial Plan for the Maritime Area Bordering Hiiu County4 and the Maritime Spatial
Plan for the Maritime Area Bordering Pärnu County5 . The Hiiu and Pärnu Maritime Spatial
Plans will remain valid with the adoption of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan.6
1
RT III, 06.09.2012,1
2
An overview of the clarifications is given in the Explanatory Memorandum to the Plan, Chapter 5.17, available
on the website of the Ministry of Finance: https://www.fin.ee/media/4765/download
3
https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/330052017003
4
Established by Order No 1-1/2016/114 of the County Governor of Hiiu County, 20.06.2016.
5
Established by the Order No 1-1/17/152 of 17.04.2017 of the County Governor of Pärnu County
6
For more details, see the Explanatory Memorandum, Chapter 4.4.
1
In addition, Directive 2014/89/EU7 of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing
a framework for Maritime Spatial Planning, which among other things obliges Member States
to establish Maritime Spatial Plans by March 2021 at the latest, has been taken into account in
the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan. The said directive sets out a framework
for Maritime Spatial Planning to promote the sustainable growth of maritime economies, the
sustainable development of maritime areas and the sustainable use of marine resources. The
main objectives of Maritime Spatial Planning, as set out in the Directive, are to support the
sustainable development of the energy, maritime transport, fisheries and aquaculture sectors
and to protect, preserve and enhance the environment, including its resilience to the impacts of
climate change.
2. On impact assessment
Pursuant to § 13 (4) of the Planning Act, a strategic environmental assessment (SEA) is
mandatory when preparing a national spatial plan, including the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan,
which is its thematic spatial plan.
Based on § 4 (2) 5) of the Planning Act, in addition to the SEA, a comprehensive assessment
of the relevant economic, social, cultural and environmental impact to result from
implementation of the spatial plan, was carried out. A single joint impact assessment report was
prepared8, which covers both the above-mentioned impacts and the impacts on the natural
environment, and which, inter alia, presents the impact assessment methodology, providing an
overview of the impact assessment methodologies, the principles of the approach and the
guidance materials used (for details, see Chapter 2 of the report).
The level of precision/level of generalization (in other words, the level of detail) of the impact
assessment depends on the level of precision/level of generalization at which the proposed
activity is planned. A distinction is made between strategic planning (various sectoral
development plans, national spatial plans and other plans, programmes and strategies) and
authorisations (various environmental permits, superficies licence, building permits, etc.).
Strategic planning documents are subject to an SEA, while authorisations are subject to an
environmental impact assessment (hereinafter EIA).The SEA, which is carried out at a higher
level of the decision-making process, assesses the impacts in relation to the level of detail of
the strategic level planning and must provide a framework for further assessments and leave for
future procedures issues that can be more effectively assessed at a lower level of the decision-
making process, i.e. the EIA. The SEA and the EIA are intended to complement each other,
leaving the SEA to deal with the environmental impacts of strategic decisions and the EIA to
assess the environmental impacts of the activities that will actually implement them.
In the course of the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, a number of additional
analyses and studies9 have been carried out, which bring together a comprehensive picture of
7
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/ET/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32014L0089&from=EN; (ELT L 257,
28.08.2014, lk 135–145)
8
https://www.fin.ee/media/4733/download
9
See also https://www.fin.ee/riik-ja-omavalitsused-planeeringud/ruumiline-planeerimine/mereala-
planeering#mereala-planeeringu-
2
the Estonian maritime space on various topics. In addition, an innovative tool, PlanWise4Blue
(http://www.sea.ee/planwise4blue) which assesses the cumulative impacts of planned human
activities on different natural assets, was used during the Estonian marine spatial planning
process to assess the environmental impacts. For example, it has identified sensitive areas for
birds, important migration corridors for birds and bats, as well as marine use patterns and key
habitats for Baltic ringed seals and grey seals. Impacts on fish have also been analysed to ensure
the conservation of fish stocks and to avoid blocking fish migrations. Also an experimental
study commissioned by the Ministry of the Environment will be carried out from 2022 to 2024
as a follow-up to the planning, to determine the hearing ability and behaviour of Baltic herring
under different noise levels, in order to clarify the significance of the impact of wind turbine
noise on Baltic herring in the Estonian coastal waters. The information to be obtained will be
used as a basis for decisions on the granting of authorisations, the design of subsequent activities
and the assessment of impacts. The cumulative impact of the proposed activities has also been
assessed in the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, which will contribute to the
smooth functioning of the different activities in parallel and will avoid any adverse impacts on
the natural environment.
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan identified the principle locations of cable corridors in wind
energy development areas and the impact assessment assessed the associated impacts, including
proposing more environmentally suitable locations for the cables. The SEA assessed
cumulative and cross-cutting impacts, including interactions between cable corridors and with
wind farms and onshore areas. The linkages of submarine cables with the onshore areas have
been taken into account, as the proposed Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan will also affect the
onshore areas by connecting submarine cables to the shore.
A Natura 2000 assessment has been carried out, including an appropriate assessment. A Natura
2000 assessment, including an appropriate assessment to avoid adverse effects on the
conservation objectives of the network sites, was carried out in the strategic environmental
assessment of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, with the participation of experts with relevant
expertise. Natura 2000 network sites located in the Estonian Maritime Spatial Planning area,
located either entirely or partly within the marine area. All environmental protection principles,
including the avoidance and precautionary principle, were applied in the development of the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan and in the impact assessment, which already at the strategic
level excluded overlaps with Natura 2000 network sites (including nationally protected marine
protection areas for natural objects, overlapping Natura 2000 sites within the same boundaries)
for new marine uses such as wind energy development areas and fish farms.
In the Strategic Environmental Assessment of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, a visual and
landscape impact assessment of the wind turbines was carried out to mitigate the visual change
associated with the construction of the wind turbines during the implementation phase, which
is not explicitly foreseen in Estonian legislation and is not covered by norms and standards. The
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, unlike those of neighbouring countries such as Latvia and
Sweden, pays careful attention to the social, including visual, impacts of wind energy
development.
3
The impact assessment also included a health impact assessment, as the marine area is also an
important asset for human health and well-being. As the wind farm areas are planned at a
distance of at least 6 nautical miles (~11.1 km) from the mainland and permanently inhabited
islands, this will greatly reduce the propagation of noise, including infrasound, to the coast.
However, the arrival and hearing of infrasound will depend on both wind direction and strength.
Since wind and waves themselves generate infrasound, distinguishing it from wind farm noise
may be unrealistic in most cases. There are currently no known studies that have demonstrated
health effects from noise from offshore wind farms. The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan
solution has been designed to minimise the direct effects of wind farms on human health and
the necessary conditions for this have been set for the authorisation stage. For a more detailed
overview and references to the literature on health effects, see Chapter 4.5 of the impact
assessment (pp. 188-189).
A formal cross-border Strategic Environmental Assessment was also carried out as part of the
impact assessment and the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, in line with the
recommendations of the Baltic Sea Region10 . The cross-border process was carried out by the
Ministry of Environment in cooperation with the Ministry of Finance. All Baltic Sea Region
countries were given the opportunity to participate in the process. Suggestions made during the
cross-border SEA process were taken into account in the development of the materials,
discussed at various meetings, and further details are provided in Chapter 4.9 of the Impact
Assessment (pp. 230-232).
In the impact assessment and in the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, among
other things, settled case-law was taken into account, including the Supreme Court's decision
No 3-16-1472 of 8 August 2018, which abolished the order of the Hiiu County Governor of 20
June 2016 on wind energy production areas (for details, see Chapter 2 of the Planning Impact
Assessment Report). In other words, first of all, the so-called ranking principle has been
followed, according to which the assessment carried out at a higher level of the decision-making
process must provide a framework for further assessments and leave for assessment in the
framework of future procedures issues that can be assessed more effectively at a lower level of
the decision-making process. To this end, the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan provides clear
guidelines and conditions to be taken into account in the next stages of the activities (in
particular in the procedures of superficies licences and building permits). Among other things,
the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan answers the question of whether, where and under what
conditions offshore wind farms can be established and provides a comprehensive framework
for studies and other relevant follow-up activities as a prerequisite for subsequent decision-
making. Secondly, the impact assessment of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan has gone hand
in hand with the development of the planning solution, i.e. the SEA has played an active role
in the development of the planning solution, rather than being limited to assessing the impacts
of the solution developed during the planning process, making ex-post adjustments and
10
Recommendations for the cross-border process developed by the Helcom-VASAB MSP working group:
https://vasab.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Guidelines_transboundary_consulations_public_participation_24-
25Feb2016-1.pdf
4
proposing mitigation measures. In addition to the inputs related to the consideration of
environmental considerations in the development of the various conditions and guidelines,
possible alternative locations for the cable corridors in areas suitable for wind energy
production have been identified in the planning process and the associated impacts have been
assessed. Third, the SEA report contains the information reasonably required, taking into
account the best available knowledge and assessment methods.
3. Structure of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan covers the entire Estonian maritime space: the internal
waters, the territorial sea and the exclusive economic zone (see Figure 1). The Estonian
Maritime Spatial Plan treats the land area through functional land-sea interactions (see the
Explanatory Memorandum of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, Chapter 5.16)11.
Figure 1 / Spatial layout 1. The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan solution has been drawn up
for the entire Estonian maritime area (both territorial sea and exclusive economic zone), except
for the previously planned maritime areas bordering the counties of Hiiu and Pärnu, which will
continue to be valid.
11
Land-sea interactions refer to activities that are carried out either at sea or on land, but which support activities
carried out on land or at sea respectively.
5
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan consists of an Explanatory Memorandum, including the
spatial layouts in it. The annexes to the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, including the Action
Plan for Implementation, the Impact Assessment Report, etc., are available on the website of
the Ministry of Finance.
Chapter 1 of the Explanatory Memorandum of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan contains an
introduction and Chapter 2 the starting points for the preparation of the Estonian Maritime
Spatial Plan. Chapter 3 sets out the future trends in the use of the Estonian maritime area, the
vision and the principles of spatial development (in accordance with § 14 (2) 1) of the Planning
Act). In Chapter 5, the planning solution is set out in the form of sub-themes for the various
marine uses (in accordance with § 14(2) 2) to 9) of the Planning Act). In each thematic area,
the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan provides guidelines (indicative guidance) and sets
conditions (mandatory to follow).
In order to ensure the implementation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, general guidelines
are given for onshore planning, for the preparation of national designated spatial plans, local
government comprehensive plans, designated special plans and detailed spatial plans, as well
as for decisions related to marine use.
Pursuant to § 3(4) of the Planning Act, a plan may be accompanied by an action plan for its
implementation, on the basis of which an Action Plan for Implementation has been drawn up
as an annex to the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan. The activities set out in the action plan have
been mapped and approved by the relevant parties responsible for implementation. It covers all
the main areas of activity on which the achievement of the objectives of the plan depends and
which have been agreed with the relevant partners. The Action Plan will be used as a basis for
monitoring progress towards the objectives of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan at the level
of strands and individual actions. § 25(1) of the Planning Act stipulates that the Ministry of
Finance is obliged to review the national spatial plan together with county-wide spatial plans at
least once every five years and presents an overview of the findings of the review to the
Government of the Republic within six months following its completion. The Action Plan will
help to monitor the implementation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan and to provide
relevant reviews to the Government of the Republic and conclusions on the timeliness and
relevance of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan.
4. The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan preparation process
Pursuant to the Planning Act, planning must be prepared by persons possessing the relevant
knowledge and skills (Planning Act § 6 (1)). Persons with different expertise12, as well as a
steering group of representatives of ministries and agencies13 and stakeholders14 participated in
12
E.g. planners, SEA lead expert, social and cultural impacts expert, geo-informatics specialists, marine
environment expert, fisheries expert, economic impact assessment expert, energy expert, health impacts expert,
cultural impacts expert, maritime transport experts and various species experts.
13
The steering group was composed of representatives of the Ministry of Defence, Ministry of the Environment,
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Interior, Ministry of Rural Affairs,
Environmental Board, Transport Administration, National Heritage Board, Police and Border Guard Board,
Consumer Protection and Technical Regulatory Authority, Health Board, Land Board and Association of
Estonian Cities and Municipalities.
14
E.g. aquaculture developers, wind energy developers, environmental organisations, recreational organisations,
seaside municipalities, various species specialists, etc.
6
the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan. Thematic meetings were held at different
stages of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan process to obtain direct feedback from
stakeholders and to identify the best solutions, in addition to formal public consultations. The
whole drafting and involvement process (including cross-border) is detailed in Annex 3 of the
Plan15.
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan was prepared through three public displays, followed by
public discussions: at the stage of the initial positions16 (public display 12.04.-14.05.2018;
discussions at 5 locations during the period 30.05-12.06.2018), at the draft. i.e. draft plan stage17
(public display 23.04.-23.05.2019; discussions at 5 locations during the period 11.06.-
20.06.2019), and additionally at the main solution stage18 (public display 17.02.-18.03.2020;
discussions at 3 locations during the period 17.08.-19.08.2020). In addition, the planning was
disseminated to the public on the website of the Ministry of Finance: in parallel with the
coordination phase19 (period 18.05.-18.06.2021) and in the final solution phase20 (period 8.11.-
8.12.2021). According to the Planning Act, the preparation of a National Spatial Plan must be
subject to one public display (§ 19 of the Planning Act) and one public discussion (§ 20 of the
Planning Act), and the plan must be disseminated to the public on the website of the authority
arranging its preparation immediately before adoption (§ 23 of the Planning Act). Thus, the
cooperation and inviting the public to participate was carried out in a much more comprehensive
manner than required by the Planning Act.
In the course of the procedure of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, the material has been
coordinated with all the relevant ministries and authorities, and interested parties (e.g.
professional associations, developers, persons who expressed their wish to participate in the
procedure, etc.) and the above-mentioned authorities have been consulted. In accordance with
the principle of inviting the public to participate and of informing the public as stipulated in the
Planning Act and on the basis of § 15 (5) of the Planning Act, all relevant and up-to-date
material (including background information) related to the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan has
been disseminated throughout the process on the website of the Ministry of Finance as well as
on the Maritime Portal. The Maritime Portal was set up for the duration of the proceedings of
the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, which ensured the possibility of publishing the most up-to-
date information at any time throughout the process. For example, the portal provided up-to-
date information on the state of play of the process and published video and map material related
to the plan.
In addition, during the drafting of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, the solution has been
presented several times to the Environment and Economic Affairs Committees of the parliament
15
https://fin.ee/media/4877/download
16
https://www.fin.ee/media/4729/download
17
https://www.fin.ee/media/4736/download
18
https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/sites/default/files/Ruumiline_planeerimine/msp_pohilahenduse_ettepanek
ute_koondtabel.pdf
19
https://www.fin.ee/media/4751/download
20
https://www.fin.ee/media/4880/download
7
of Estonia (Riigikogu), to all local authorities with maritime borders, at various seminars and
sectoral conferences, as well as at the meetings of the Member States Expert Group of Maritime
Spatial Plan set up by the EU Commission to discuss issues related to the Marine Strategy
Framework Directive21, at meetings of the Helcom-VASAB MSP Working Group, at
international conferences and seminars. The process has been covered and the solution
explained in various sectoral publications (e.g. Eesti Loodus, TööstusEST, national and
regional newspapers) and in the wider media (e.g. ERR and other TV and radio stations).
Environmental considerations and the best available knowledge were taken into account in the
preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan solution.22 The inclusion of the best
knowledge was ensured by a broad-based group of experts23, cooperation with other countries,
agencies and stakeholders24 and additional studies appropriate to the level of the plan25.
21
https://envir.ee/keskkonnakasutus/merekeskkonna-kaitse/merestrateegia-raamdirektiiv
22
The approach is based on EU Directive 2014/89/EU, which established the framework for Maritime Spatial
Planning.
23
An overview of the planning team can be found on the website of the Ministry of Finance:
https://www.fin.ee/media/4766/download
24
An overview of the cooperation and invitation to participate is reflected in Annex 3 of the plan, available on
the website of the Ministry of Finance: https://www.fin.ee/media/4730/download
25
A list of the studies is available in Annex 5 to the plan, and the list and the studies themselves are available on
the website of the Ministry of Finance:https://www.fin.ee/riik-ja-omavalitsused-planeeringud/ruumiline-
planeerimine/mereala-planeering#mereala-planeeringu-
8
II CONSIDERATIONS
1. Objective of adoption of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan is a national strategic development document. Pursuant to
§ 13 (3) of the Planning Act, the purpose of a national spatial plan is to define the principles
and directions of spatial development in Estonia. The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, as a
thematic spatial plan of the National Spatial Plan, guides the use of the Estonian maritime area
in the long term, setting out the basic principles and rules for the spatial development of the
various marine uses.
The purpose of establishing the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan is to create a holistic picture of
the interaction between different marine uses and to agree on spatial principles for the use of
Estonia's marine areas for the next 15 years26, in order to contribute to achieving and
maintaining good environmental status of the marine environment and to promote sustainable
maritime economy. In order to achieve long-term directions and a holistic picture at national
level, the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan will be guided by national interests and national
development documents. As the aim is to provide a balanced spatial approach of the whole of
the Estonian maritime area at the national level, the degree of generalisation is relatively high,
as foreseen for this type of a document - focus is put mainly on setting general principles and
providing a framework to guide authorisation and other follow-up activities. The guidelines and
conditions set out in the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan will form the basis for future decisions
concerning the Estonian maritime area.
The adoption of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan will create the possibility to initiate the
superficies licence procedure for all buildings requiring a superficies licence. It follows from §
1131 (1) of the Building Code (hereinafter the Building Code) that a superficies licence must
be applied to encumber a delimited part of a public water body with a building permanently
connected to the bottom of the water body and not permanently connected to the shore (wind
farms, fish cages, etc.). Pursuant to Section § 11311 (2) of the Building Code, a superficies
licence shall be refused if the application is contrary to the existing planning in the delimited
area of the water body for which the application is made. Therefore, after the adoption of the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, the decision to grant a superficies licence must be based on it,
i.e. the superficies licence granted must comply with the conditions set out in the Estonian
Maritime Spatial Plan.
As for several traditional uses (e.g. fisheries, maritime transport), the rules for marine use are
largely established, the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan focuses more on combined use and new
uses of the sea. New uses are aquaculture and energy production, for which the Estonian
26
15 years has been taken as the time perspective, as the development period for larger activities is estimated at
10 years. The experience of European countries in implementing Maritime Spatial Planning (e.g. Germany and
Belgium) has been similar. The time perspective also takes into account the fact that according to Planning Act
§ 25 (1), the Ministry of Finance is obliged to review the national Maritime Spatial Plan at least once every five
years, to assess the implementation of the plan (in accordance with Planning Act § 25) and its timeliness and
relevance.
9
Maritime Spatial Plan sets out guidelines and conditions and identifies spatially feasible
development areas for wind energy production. Guidelines will be provided for all sectors to
accommodate the different uses of the sea.
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan has been prepared taking into account a number of
strategies and development plans, including the "Development Plan for Agriculture and
Fisheries 2030"27, "Estonia 2035"28, "General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050"29,
"Energy Roadmap until 2030"30, the Baltic Sea Strategy31, the Marine Strategy Framework
Directive32 and others. For a number of uses, Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan does not, in
principle, provide for binding spatial locations. For these uses (e.g. maritime transport, etc.),
there is sufficient legal regulation in place (International Regulations for Preventing Collisions
at Sea (COLREGs), Act on Maritime Safety, etc.), as well as well-established practice in marine
use. Following the implementation of the plan, the maritime space will remain as it currently is
for these uses. The above is in line with the principle of sufficiency of information mentioned
in § 12 of the Planning Act, according to which (1) the authority that organises planning work
must, when making planning arrangements, take into account the relevant strategies, risk
analyses, existing spatial plans that are in effect, development plans and other documents that
have an impact on spatial development, as well as any other relevant information.
Based on the results of the impact assessment, the plan sets conditions to ensure that the
planning of different activities takes into account habitats and biota (including seabed habitats
and biota) and avoids adverse impacts on them. At present, proposals have been made by the
Estonian Marine Institute (outside the planning process) for the establishment of two marine
protection areas within the Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZs), but these proposals are being
processed outside the planning process under the Nature Conservation Act. In addition,
conditions have been set to ensure the preservation of sensitive areas for fisheries (migration
areas, potential spawning grounds and areas important for juvenile marine fish). For example,
development of new uses is excluded in shallow coastal waters, which are sensitive areas for
fish. Adverse impacts on landscapes are also excluded. This is in particular through the
conditions set for the protection of the different natural components that are part of the
landscape.
The Natura appropriate assessment concluded that, at the level of detail of the Estonian
Maritime Spatial Plan, no adverse effects on Natura 2000 sites or their conservation objectives
are foreseen from the implementation of the plan, taking into account the conditions set out in
the plan and the environmental measures foreseen in the impact assessment at the level of
authorisation (see in more detail the Planning Impact Assessment Report, Chapter 4.3).
27
https://www.agri.ee/et/pollumajanduse-ja-kalanduse-valdkonna-arengukava-aastani-2030
28
https://valitsus.ee/strateegia-eesti-2035-arengukavad-ja-planeering/strateegia
29
https://envir.ee/kliimapoliitika-pohialused-aastani-2050
30
https://www.mkm.ee/sites/default/files/enmak_2030.pdf
31
https://vm.ee/et/euroopa-liidu-laanemere-strateegia-lms
32
https://envir.ee/keskkonnakasutus/merekeskkonna-kaitse/merestrateegia-raamdirektiiv
10
Therefore, the proper implementation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan will not have any
adverse effects on the conservation objectives of Natura 2000 sites.
2. Public interest in the introduction of new uses of the sea
2.1. Aquaculture33
According to the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan solution, aquaculture can be developed in the
entire Estonian maritime area, except for the areas excluded for this purpose (fairways, areas
sensitive to fish, places of refuges, dumping areas, anchorage areas; see the spatial layout
5.3.1.1 in the Explanatory Memorandum), taking into account the guidelines and conditions set
out in the plan. The guidelines and conditions, together with the reasons for setting them, are
set out in the Explanatory Memorandum to the plan (pp. 23-24). As the growing preferences of
marine fish, algae and shellfish are relatively different and technologies in this field are
evolving rapidly, areas have been designated where development is clearly excluded. This
approach provides sufficient flexibility to encourage innovation in this area, while at the same
time providing adequate protection of the marine environment under the conditions laid down,
and taking into account the spatial needs of other marine uses.
Aquaculture - the farming of fish, shellfish, crustaceans and aquatic plants (e.g. algae) - is one
of the fastest growing sectors of the global blue economy34 . The main activities of the
aquaculture sector in Estonia are commercial fish farming, farming for reintroduction into
natural water bodies, crustacean farming, and algae and shellfish farming, which are at a
development stage. Shellfish and algae farming are not yet commercially practised in Estonia,
but several experiments have been carried out.35 The majority of aquaculture production, i.e.
rainbow trout, is currently still derived from terrestrial farms. The future strategic objective for
the development of sustainable marine aquaculture is to increase the volume of offshore
aquaculture to 10 000 tonnes increment per year over the next five years.36 The development of
marine aquaculture will thus contribute to the growth of the Estonian economy and is therefore
important for the development and well-being of the country as a whole.
2.2. Wind energy37
Developing renewable energy minimises the environmental impact of the energy sector,
strengthens energy security and increases competitiveness of economy. The "General Principles
of Climate Policy until 2050" sets the objective of gradually increasing the uptake of renewable
energy sources in final consumption in all sectors. In addition, the EU's long-term energy and
33
For more details on the solution, see the Explanatory Memorandum, Chapter 5.3.
34
FAO 2018 http://www.fao.org/3/i9540en/I9540EN.pdf
35
https://kalateave.ee/images/pdf/Vetika_ja_karbiuuringud_2011_2020_veeb.pdf
36
Agriculture and fisheries development plan to 2030
https://www.agri.ee/sites/default/files/content/arengukavad/poka-2030/poka-2030-taistekst.pdf
37
See the development of the solution and the guidelines-conditions in more detail in the Explanatory
Memorandum, Chapter 5.6.
11
climate policy guides Member States to reduce their CO2 emissions and increase renewable
energy production and energy efficiency. The energy sector is responsible for the largest share
of greenhouse gas emissions in Europe38. Estonia's National Energy and Climate Plan plans to
reach a share of 42% of renewable energy in total final energy consumption (~50% of final
energy consumption) by 2030.
In 2020, the share of renewable electricity in total final electricity consumption was 22%
(production 2.84 TWh)39. Given the rapid changes in electricity production in Estonia, the need
for new renewable energy is particularly high in the power generation sector. By 2030, the share
of renewable electricity must almost double to 40%40 . Estonia has set a target to switch to
climate-neutral power generation by 205041 . Wind energy has the highest growth potential,
with production expected to quadruple by 2030 to reach this target. The development of wind
energy (both onshore and offshore) is a cost-effective solution for renewable electricity
production in Estonia (capacity factor42 between 30...40% onshore and 45...55% offshore).
To ensure security of supply, Estonia's electricity system will need investment in new
production capacity - the production capacity and its location will be decided by the electricity
market, but onshore and offshore wind farms, solar energy, batteries, pumped-storage
hydropower plants and gas-fired power plants with green gas capacity are likely to be the
production resources of the future electricity system. Therefore, to ensure long-term security of
supply, it is necessary to ensure a competitive investment environment for the development of
low-carbon production capacity.
The deployment of wind energy in maritime areas would increase economic competitiveness
and, as a new activity, would bring additional value to various sectors (new skills, technological
developments, etc.). A wind farm of 1000 MW is estimated to represent an investment of more
than € 2 billion in the Estonian economy and would create 70 to 100 direct long-term jobs (plus
thousands of temporary jobs).
Compared to onshore wind farms, offshore wind farms have less direct impact on the living
environment. Despite the easing of national defence restrictions in the coming years in the
onshore part of the country, there are still a number of areas with high wind potential in Estonia
that will continue to be subject to extensive restrictions due to national defence, nature
conservation, settlement, location of infrastructure, subsoil and other factors. Finding suitable
areas for offshore wind energy development is therefore necessary.
38
https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/indicators/greenhouse-gas-emission-trends-6/assessment-3
39
https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/energy/data/shares
40
https://www.mkm.ee/et/eesmargid-tegevused/energeetika/eesti-riiklik-energia-ja-kliimakava-aastani-2030
41
https://valitsus.ee/strateegia-eesti-2035-arengukavad-ja-planeering/strateegia
42
Capacity factor - the ratio of the actual output of an energy production unit to the theoretical maximum output
per year.
12
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan defines the areas suitable for wind energy development
(including innovation areas and reserve areas totalling nearly 1700 km2), guidelines and
conditions. The identification of suitable areas for wind energy development was based on the
gravity-based foundation technology, which, according to the current state of knowledge, is the
most suitable for Estonia's ice conditions. Wind energy areas have been identified based on a
combination of a number of external criteria (e.g. known nature conservation constraints,
national defence constraints, necessary air routes and fairways etc.)43 . First, areas suitable in
principle for wind energy development were identified on the basis of wind energy potential,
water depth, distance to the nearest high-voltage substation, likelihood of ice and wave height,
then nature protection areas were excluded, as well as a visual buffer zone of 11 km from the
coastline. Due to the size of the areas and national defence interests, wind energy development
in the northern part of the Estonian marine area was excluded. In the remaining areas, national
defence needs have been taken into account and the conditions set out the obligation to ensure
the operational capability of national defence. Important migratory corridors for birds and bats,
bird staging areas and marine areas important for seals were also excluded from the
development areas. Also water traffic corridors of major importance for maritime transport and
areas necessary to ensure the safety of air traffic were excluded. The consideration process of
suitable areas for wind energy development is described in more detail in Chapter 5.6.3 of the
Explanatory Memorandum of the Plan (pp. 37-46).
The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan also defines the conceptual locations of cable corridors for
connecting the proposed wind farms to the onshore transmission network (see Chapter 5.6.6,
pp. 55-59 of the Explanatory Memorandum). The identification of the conceptual locations of
the cable corridors is necessary for the strategic level impact assessment to verify the feasibility
of the plan. The guidelines for the laying of onshore cables are set out as a prerequisite for the
establishment of connections. During the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan and
the impact assessment, it was established that the onshore connection of submarine cables from
wind farms is feasible in principle (see Chapter 4.3 of the planning impact assessment report),
and the guidelines have been presented to the relevant local authorities during the process.
In determining the areas suitable for wind energy development, the associated impacts have
been assessed with the level of precision inherent in and necessary for planning. In order to
concretise the high degree of generalisation and indeterminacy inherent in Estonian Maritime
Spatial Plan (the state's vision of what it considers to be possible in principle), the planning
defines the starting points for wind energy development (see also chapter 5.6.3 of the
Explanatory Memorandum), which are used as a basis for assessing the development areas for
wind energy and the impacts of their realisation. The baselines can also be considered as a
maximum scenario for the implementation of the plan.
Although scientists have generally taken the view44 that the noise from wind turbine operations
may disturb fish only in the immediate vicinity of the turbines and that there are no significant
43
For more details, see the Explanatory Memorandum, Chapter 5.6.3.
44
For more details, see the impact assessment report on pages 60-66.
13
adverse effects, the precautionary principle requires that when wind farms are planned, at the
level of authorisation more detailed studies should be carried out on the potential fish (in
particular Baltic herring) spawning grounds and possible blockage of access to spawning
grounds in the wind farm area and its impact zone. As mentioned above, an additional
experimental study (the first of its kind in the Baltic Sea region) commissioned by the Ministry
of the Environment will be carried out between 2022 and 2024 (clause 3.1 of the Plan’s Action
Plan) to determine the hearing ability and behaviour of the Baltic herring under different noise
levels, in order to clarify the significance of the impact of wind turbine noise on Baltic herring
in Estonian coastal waters. If the noise study shows that there is no effect of noise on the
migration of the Baltic herring, this result can be used as a basis. If the noise study shows that
noise is an obstacle to fish migration, further detailed studies are needed to map fish migration
corridors. If the study shows that there are significant adverse impacts on fish migration that
cannot be mitigated, the scale or other parameters of the proposed activity should be reduced to
avoid adverse impacts or the activity should be abandoned.
Wind energy areas are defined on the basis that mass migration corridors important for both
water and terrestrial birds and staging, feeding and resting areas important for water birds are
free (no barrier effect). The known mass migration corridors for bats and staging, feeding,
breeding and resting areas for Baltic ringed seals and grey seals are also free. Conditions are
also imposed (with an additional obligation to undertake a survey at the authorisation stage) to
ensure that the design of wind farms takes into account the bird, bat and seal populations.
As a result of the Maritime Spatial Planning process in Estonia, it was concluded that the
identified areas, including wind energy development areas, are suitable and in the interest of
the state. Also a conviction developed that there are no better alternatives, including for the
identification of potential wind energy development areas. For example, different alternatives
for the location of wind energy development areas and their cables were considered, including
environmental considerations in the area selection (see Chapter 5.6.3 of the Explanatory
Memorandum and Chapter 4.3 of the Planning Impact Assessment Report).
The Ministry of the Environment, as the ministry responsible for the area, has taken the view
that the construction of wind turbines will have a visual impact on the landscape, which, in the
light of the Council of Europe's Landscape Convention, can be considered to include the marine
area, which is an environmental element in the same way as land, soil, water, ambient air,
climate and biodiversity. The visual impact of wind turbines is therefore also an environmental
impact within the meaning of Directive 2011/92/EU of the European Parliament and of the
Council. It can also be considered as a relevant social impact under the Planning Act 45. The
visual impact of wind turbines is particularly pronounced on the west coast of Saaremaa, where
the wind energy development area (area No 2) is located from the Vilsandi National Park to the
top of the Sõrve peninsula. The closest possible wind farm to the west coast of Saaremaa is 6
45
Ministry of Finance. 2018. Nõuandeid üldplaneeringu koostamiseks Chapter 6. The legal framework and the
principles for the assessment of the relevant impacts set out in this guidance material also apply to the assessment
of the relevant impacts of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan as a National Spatial Plan’s thematic spatial plan.
14
nautical miles (about 11.1 km). In the Gulf of Riga, wind farms have the greatest visual impact
on the island of Ruhnu (a distance of about 11 km), and wind farms are also visible from Cape
Kolka in Latvia (the nearest potential wind turbine in Area 1 is about 21 km away). The
visibility of offshore wind farms is about 50 km from the coast (maximum visibility of a wind
farm with a tip height of about 200 m on a clear day). It is not possible to plan offshore wind
farm development areas beyond these locations. The Estonian sea is rapidly deepening, which
makes the establishment of wind farms in more remote areas neither economically viable nor
technologically feasible in Estonia's climatic conditions, given the currently available
technologies. Therefore, the visual change caused by wind turbines cannot be completely
avoided by planning them further out to sea, and moving them a few kilometres further out will
not have any effect in terms of visual impact. In addition, there are important international
maritime transport corridors to the west of Saaremaa, so there is no room for shifting the areas
further west.
In the preparation of the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan and in the impact assessment, the focus
has been on mitigation options for visual change (see Chapter 5.6.5 of the Explanatory
Memorandum and Chapter 4.4.1.6.2 of the impact assessment), e.g. it is foreseen that wind
turbines will not be located closer than 6 nautical miles (11.1 km; the distance is calculated
from the nearest wind turbine) to the mainland and to islands with permanent inhabitants, and
that the visual interaction of wind farms must be assessed in case of simultaneous planning of
several wind farms. The visual impact will also need to be assessed in more detail at the
superficies licence stage. Guidelines and conditions to mitigate visual impacts were developed
in cooperation with landscape architects, including a visual impact assessment expert46 . The
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan has been approved without comments by the Ministry of the
Environment, the ministry responsible for the Strategic Environmental Assessment.
At the time of drafting the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, neither the location of the wind
turbines (which will also depend on the more detailed studies and analyses foreseen as
conditions of the plan) nor the exact parameters (to be determined at the authorisation stage)
are known. For example, in the dissemination to the public of the Estonian Maritime Spatial
Plan materials47, proposals are consistently made to visualise the wind turbines proposed in the
wind energy development areas during the authorisation procedure, but this is not possible, as
the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan envisages areas suitable for wind energy development, not
specific wind farms, where wind turbine formations and exact locations are known. It is
expected that the respective technologies will also evolve during the validity period of the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan.
Similarly, the views from the coast to the sea vary greatly depending on the configuration of a
particular coastal area and the location of the park area. At the level of detail of the national
46
https://www.fin.ee/media/4766/download
47
Proposals related to the topic of the visualisations have been submitted by Sunly Wind OÜ, Saaremaa
municipality, Muhu municipality, Ruhnu municipality, Saare Arenduskeskus SA, Saaremaa Entrepreneurs'
Association NGO, Meretööstuse Liit NGO, Energiaühistu NGO, Sõrvemaa Arengu Ühing NGO, private persons.
15
spatial plan, due to the legal framework the assessment of the impacts of the implementation of
the plan focuses on the provision of conditions and guidelines to the next more detailed level
of authorisation for the mitigation of impacts. Areas suitable for wind energy production have
been selected in recognition of the fact that wind turbines will be visible from the coast. This
was taken into account in the selection of the conditions and guidelines for the authorisation
level, as well as for the detailed study framework and other relevant follow-up activities. The
impact assessment provided a description of the affected environment, the impacts of
implementing the plan and the measures to mitigate and avoid impacts at the authorisation stage
(see Chapter 4 of the report). The impact assessment report has consistently concluded that, if
the proposed approaches and mitigation measures are implemented, there will be no significant
adverse impacts as a result of the implementation of the plan. The table in Chapter 4.2 of the
Explanatory Memorandum to the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan provides an overview of the
main suggestions made in the impact assessment and how they have been taken into account in
the plan.
In the next stage, during the superficies licence procedure, studies will be carried out to
determine the exact size, parameters and location of wind turbines in the areas selected in the
plan, taking into account the specific characteristics of the location and technological solutions.
There is an obligation to assess the landscape and visual impact, to analyse and implement
mitigation measures and to visualise the wind turbines. The assessment must be carried out on
the basis of the framework set out in the plan, including an assessment by an appropriate expert
using the guidance material developed48 or an equivalent generally accepted methodology
appropriate to Estonian circumstances. The guidance material provides, among other things,
recommendations for the presentation and modelling of visualisations.
3. Justification for the establishment of reserve areas
Of the total trawling areas in Estonia, 4.3% overlap with planned wind energy areas. In 2017-
2019, less than 10% of the Estonian trawl catches were taken from overlapping areas. During
the planning process (in August 2020, when the planning solution was disseminated to the
public), trawlers objected to the areas proposed for wind energy development in the Estonian
Maritime Spatial Plan, as the areas suitable for wind energy development overlap partially with
important trawling areas. The overlap of trawling is 92% in wind energy area 1 and 17% in
wind energy area 2. The total overlap with trawling in the wind energy areas is 39%. However,
in the event that future trawling in the overlapping areas is not possible due to the development
of wind energy, this will have a significant regional impact on the fisheries sector.
The Ministry of Rural Affairs, in its letter No 6.2-15/2691-1 of 5 January 2021, following the
opposition of trawlers, pointed out that if the trawling areas currently in use were to be reduced,
the pressure on the areas remaining for trawling would increase and a reduction in catches could
be expected. The problem may be most acute in the Gulf of Riga, where fishing is already
48
See in more detail "Guidelines for Methodological Recommendations for Visual Impact Assessment to Promote
the Development of Offshore Windfarms" , AB Artes Terrae OÜ, 2020. https://www.fin.ee/media/4718/download
16
severely restricted by various measures. In combination with the realisation of wind energy
areas proposed in the Pärnu Maritime Spatial Plan and the Latvian Maritime Spatial Plan, the
areas where trawling can take place will be further reduced. With the reduction of established
trawling areas, companies will have to start looking for alternative fishing grounds, which, if
shifted away from ports, will increase time and fuel consumption, reduce the number of fishing
days and deteriorate fish quality. The quantity of fish landed in the hitherto used landing ports
may also be reduced, and some of the hitherto used fishing harbours may lose their function.
This in turn will have an adverse impact on fish processing businesses in the port area and thus
on the income of the fishing and fish processing sector.
Trawling is a traditional, seasonal use of the sea (trawling season is January-April and
September-December) and is carried out by local fishing companies. The economic success of
the sector has supported investments in port networks, fishing fleets, fish processing plants, etc.
For example, there are companies that catch more than 15% of their total annual catch from the
proposed wind energy areas. Looking at the Gulf of Riga separately, the share of catch from
the proposed wind energy areas is higher, averaging 35% in 2019, with all companies above
20% and one company even above 50%.
On the other hand, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications stressed in its letter
No 17-2/2020/3011 of 8 May 2020 that in order to achieve the climate neutrality targets set for
2050, it is important that there are sufficient wind energy areas. The designation of wind energy
areas was based first on the conditions suitable for wind energy and then the areas were
specified, using the exclusion methodology, which means that the needs of several other areas
were taken into account (e.g. overlapping with protected natural values, including Natura sites,
areas with heavy shipping traffic, installation of wind turbines closer than 11.1 km from the
coast, national defence areas, etc.). If only the conditions suitable for wind energy development
were taken into account, the total potential areas amounted to ~5800 km2, but after the
application of the exclusion methodology (including the necessary precautionary principles),
the total wind energy areas currently amount to ~1700 km2. The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan
solution indicates that up to 70% of the remaining wind energy areas will be realised. This
shows that it is neither possible nor realistic to cover the entire area fully with wind turbines,
given the technological aspects (including the buffer zone between the various offshore wind
farms), the results of the detailed studies to be carried out at the superficies licence stage, and
the needs of maritime transport. The availability of sufficient areas also ensures sufficient
competition and the best price for consumers. Completely cutting off the more intensive
trawling areas from the wind energy areas would make it economically unviable to develop
them, given the size of the remaining areas. It should be borne in mind that offshore wind farms
have a long development cycle (around 10+ years with the necessary studies) during which time
trawling can continue at its current level. In conclusion, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications was of the opinion that there should be no reduction in the areas designated
in the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan solution as of August 2020.
In order to assess the feasibility of continued trawling between wind turbines, the Ministry of
Economic Affairs and Communications carried out a survey in September 2020, based on
17
information compiled by the Ministry of Finance, among developers in the wind energy sector
to clarify technical information on wind farms. The results of the survey showed that allowing
trawling between wind turbines is theoretically possible, but would require a very high level of
investment (e.g. in the form of covering cables). According to the representatives of the trawling
sector, such a solution is not feasible, entails a number of risks and would require a more in-
depth analysis before a decision could be taken. There are also no concrete examples in
international practice where active trawling is allowed in wind farms, as allowing trawling in
wind farms may pose a risk to cables on the seabed, etc.
Trawling and wind energy are both economic activities of national interest for the Estonian
state49. In order to find a solution, further cooperation was carried out with representatives of
both the trawling sector and the wind energy developers' interest group. It was not possible to
reach a compromise that fully took into account the views of the two stakeholders and the
disagreement slowed down the planning process. In order to continue the procedure of the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan solution that takes into account the different interests in a
balanced way and taking into account the above-mentioned circumstances, including the
arguments put forward by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications and the
Ministry of Rural Affairs, the Government of the Republic has decided not to reduce the wind
energy areas proposed in the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, but to designate as reserve areas
until 2027 those areas of the wind energy areas proposed in the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan
that overlap with historically more intensive trawling areas. The definition of the reserve areas
was based on specific data, i.e. trawling data for the last 3 years (2018-2020), by marking their
concentration points according to the coordinates of the trawl hauls and by considering a
minimum area size (90 km2) for wind energy that is economically viable for development.
The establishment of reserve areas means that until 2026, reserve areas will not be made
available for wind farm development through the authorisation procedures, but will remain
usable in their current form. After 2026, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
and the Consumer and Technical Regulatory Authority will assess whether and to what extent
the use of the reserve areas is necessary to meet the climate objectives (see the conditions set
out in more detail in the Explanatory Memorandum to the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan,
Chapter 5.6.5). This timeframe (of around 4 years) can be considered sufficient to carry out
procedures and studies in other areas suitable for offshore wind development to assess the
feasibility of developing offshore wind farms on a sufficient scale. This is also in line with §
25(1) of the Planning Act, which requires the Ministry of Finance to review the Estonian
Maritime Spatial Plan every five years, assess the implementation of the plan (in line with § 25
of the Planning Act) and its timeliness and relevance. The assessment of the need to deploy the
reserve areas shall include an overview of the existing situation to the Government of the
Republic. The analysis of the existing situation will be based, inter alia, on the status of, for
example, superficies licences, studies and environmental impact assessments carried out,
national climate and energy objectives, the economic impact of trawling on the fisheries sector,
49
The existence of an important national interest in the development of wind farms is also confirmed by the
Supreme Court's decision of 26.05.2021 in case 3-17-2013.
18
and other relevant important factors. The Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan solution has been
approved without comments by both the Ministry of Rural Affairs and the Ministry of
Economic Affairs and Communications.
In order to compensate those directly affected, including trawlers, for the disturbance caused
by wind farms, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications has developed a local
benefits regulation50. According to the above-mentioned draft, trawlers in municipalities
affected by wind farms will be compensated for restrictions on their activities caused by wind
farms if the activities of the wind farms lead directly to a reduction in catches.
The designation of wind energy areas, including reserve areas, is based on the above-mentioned
reasons, and is also in line with the principle of balancing and integrating interests set out in §
10 of the Planning Act, which stipulates that the authority that organises planning work must
balance different interests, including public interests and values, consider them in the light of
the principles of planning and the goals of the spatial plan, and integrate them in the planning
solution. This principle helps to ensure, inter alia, that planning is feasible. Balancing interests
does not automatically mean taking a proposal into account - a proposal may be taken into
account, but a different solution may be found, which is what has been done in this case. Both
wind energy and trawling are important industries for the country. In this case, the decision has
been taken on the basis of the spatial priorities of the fisheries sector, as well as climate and
energy policy objectives and trends. Thus, the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan solution balances
the interests of the state - the development of wind energy and trawling.
In conclusion
The aim of Maritime Spatial Planning is to agree on the long-term principles for the use of
Estonia's maritime space in order to contribute to achieving and maintaining good
environmental status of the marine environment and to promote the maritime economy. The
need for planning to regulate the intensifying use of the maritime space is laid down in Directive
2014/89/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a framework for
Maritime Spatial Planning. Estonia has complied with the requirement of the aforementioned
Directive by drawing up and adopting the plan. In order to accommodate all the different types
of marine uses in the maritime space, the planning determined in which areas and under which
conditions activities can be carried out in the maritime space. The guidelines and conditions set
out in the plan will form the basis for future decisions concerning the Estonian maritime area.
This will change the current practice, which is based on individual decisions, because once the
Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan is in place, there will be both general principles and clear
guidelines and conditions on how activities can be spatially planned. In the next stage, the
authorisation procedure, the studies carried out will determine, in the light of the specificities
of the location and the technological solutions, the scale and parameters of the various facilities
that can be built and exactly where they can be built within the areas defined in the plan. Given
50
Draft Act amending the Energy Sector Organization Act and other related acts. The intention to elaborate the
draft has been subject to a coordination procedure (https://eelnoud.valitsus.ee/main/mount/docList/e7038a4e-
4d3d-4a4d-a4af-fecdb2511e94)
19
that the planning process, including the impact assessment, has been based on the principle of
'ranking', the plan provides a framework for further action. The plan therefore sets out
guidelines and conditions to be followed in the subsequent stages (in particular in superficies
licences and building permits procedures). In addition, the planning process has taken into
account and assessed the interactions of different activities, which will provide the basis for
parallel activities in the maritime area, including the future expansion of renewable energy.
III DECISION
On the basis of the foregoing and pursuant to § 24 (1) of the Planning Act and in accordance
with § 13 (2) of the same Act, the Government of the Republic decides:
1. To establish the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan.
2. The Ministry of Finance is to publish this Order, together with the Explanatory
Memorandum, and the Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan, together with all annexes, including the
Action Plan for its Implementation, on its website.
3. The Ministry of Finance is to organise the notification of the adoption of the Estonian
Maritime Spatial Plan in accordance with the provisions of subsections 2-4 of § 24 of the
Planning Act. The Government Office of the Republic of Estonia is to organise the notification
provided for in § 24 (3) of the Planning Act on the website of the Government of the Republic.
IV. CONTESTATION
The order may be contested in accordance with the procedure laid down in the Code of
Administrative Court Procedure within 30 days of the date of publication of the order in the
State Gazette (Riigi Teataja).
Kaja Kallas
Prime Minister
Taimar Peterkop
State Secretary
Annex: Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan
20
Annex 4: Action Plan for Implementation of the Plan
The Action Plan sets out the follow-up actions needed to implement the Plan. The Action Plan includes proposals for improvements to best practice
and the legal framework that have emerged throughout the planning process, as well as studies, analyses and follow-up actions needed for
sustainable use of the maritime areas.
In order to facilitate the implementation of the Action Plan and the implementation of the MSP, it is recommended to set up a working group/task
force on the implementation of the MSP, composed of representatives of the ministries and agencies responsible for the sectors. The aim is not to
duplicate the work of the working groups that have been set up to date, but to facilitate the implementation of the plan and to promote cooperation
between the different areas covered by the plan (including between the working groups). The working group will meet on an ad hoc basis,
presumably once a year, to monitor the implementation of the Action Plan and, where appropriate, to discuss cross-cutting issues related to the
implementation of the MSP. It must also ensure that the activities of the ministries and agencies thereof that are members of the working group
are in line with the principles set out in the Maritime Spatial Plan. The activities of the working group can be coordinated by the Spatial Planning
Department of the Ministry of Finance.
When carrying out implementation activities, consideration should always be given to whether a relevant impact assessment is also necessary.
Purpose Activities Time of Outcome/Output Responsible Authority with
execution/ (to be filled in where shared
deadline possible) authority responsibility
1. Synergistic 1.1 Guiding spatial combined use (including continuous Wherever possible, RaM Working Group
combined use of in a way that respects the marine ecosystem) activities in the (all sectoral
the maritime and collecting best practice. maritime area will ministries-
take into account the agencies)
area
combined use
principles outlined in
the Plan. Information
on best practice on
combined use in
Estonia has been
collected.
1.2 Encourage and monitor the continuous Activities in the All sectoral -
implementation of ecosystem-supportive maritime area will be ministries-
and sustainable uses with positive guided by the agencies
interactions. guidelines and according to
combined use their
principles set out in competences.
the Plan.
1.3 Establishment of the Implementation 2022 The Implementation RaM, All sectoral
Working Group/Task Force and adoption of Working ministries-
its rules of procedure Group/Task Force agencies
has been set up and
is working as
intended.
1.4 Representation of Estonian interests in continuous Estonian interests RaM -
international working groups related to are represented
maritime spatial planning and ensuring
cross-border cooperation in implementation.
1.5 Promote the further development of continuous Online tools are RaM Working Group
PlanWise4Blue (including cooperation with publicly available (all sectoral
research institutions) to implement an and take into account ministries-
ecosystem approach. the best available agencies)
knowledge.
1.6 Promoting the combined use of maritime continuous Spatial data on the All sectoral -
spatial data (actions needed to create a maritime domain are ministries-
coherent picture). available and agencies
interoperable according to
their
competences.
1.7 Development of a Maritime Spatial Plan 2023 A monitoring RaM -
monitoring framework framework for
Maritime Spatial
Plan is ready and
ready for
implementation.
2. Maritime uses 2.1 Analysing the legal framework and, if 2022-2027 Justified needs and RaM, ELVL All sectoral
that better necessary, developing proposals for options for ministries-
respect local amendments to develop the rights and legislative change agencies
values. possibilities of local authorities in the are identified.
planning and use of the maritime areas.
2.2 Enhancing the competence of specialists continuous On-going training to RaM All sectoral
in seaside local authorities on issues related improve ministries-
to maritime uses. competences as agencies as
necessary. appropriate
2.3 Identification of valuable underwater 2027 Instruction on the MKA KuM, KeM,
landscapes identification of RaM
valuable underwater
landscapes has been
prepared.
2.4 Preparation of coastal (pilot) thematic 2022-2026 Relevant areas have RaM All sectoral
spatial plan(s) to address in more detail the been identified, ministries-
land-sea interactions (specifying in advance planning is agencies as
the sections of coastline needed). underway. appropriate
2.5 Developing frameworks to manage local 2022 The framework has MKM RaM, JuM,
benefits to support the development of wind been developed and KaM, SiM
turbines in maritime areas and mitigate the is in force. (maritime
associated impacts. radars), ELVL
3. Knowledge- 3.1 Effects of wind farm noise on Baltic 2022-2024 A national survey KeM MeM, RaM
based decisions herring migration. The aim is to identify the has been prepared.
and diversified noise levels that are significant (disturbing)
maritime uses for the Baltic herring.
3.2 Inventories of birds staging, moulting 2027 The inventory has KAUR, KeA KeM
and wintering in the maritime areas during been carried out.
migration (maritime area wide aerial
surveys) and inventories of bats migrating in
the maritime areas (using detectors in
selected maritime areas), in line with PAF
2021-2027.
3.3 Developing a cooperative approach for continuous Activities related to MKA, KuM MKM,
submersible wrecks and vessel traffic to submersible wrecks Transport
ensure diving safety and wreck preservation. are organised in such Administration,
a way as to ensure PPA, Estonian
the safety and Maritime
preservation of the Museum
wrecks.
3.4 Preparation of/supplementing Upon Action plans for KaM KeM, KeA
environmental action plans for special areas significant special areas of
of national defence to mitigate impacts on change in national defence
seals. activities include appropriate
conditions to
mitigate impacts on
seals.
3.5 Periodic updating of vessel traffic continuous Data are available. Transport -
density data and ensuring availability of Administration
information
3.6 Ensuring a regionally significant port continuous Actions have been MKM -
network and promoting developments implemented to
support the
development of the
port network.
3.7 Inventory of underwater cultural heritage continuous Underwater cultural MKA PPA, Transport
(including wrecks) heritage inventoried Administration,
Estonian
Maritime
Museum
3.8 Preparing, ensuring preparedness, continuous Coastal and marine PPA, PäA ELVL, SiM,
maintaining and improving coastal and pollution response KeA, Transport
marine pollution response prevention and preparedness plan in Administration
preparedness agenda and plans. place, capabilities in
place.
4. Promoting the 4.1 Promoting economically sustainable continuous Necessary actions to MeM -
development of algae and shellfish farming developments facilitate
aquaculture developments have
been taken.
4.1.1 Sectoral innovation surveys continuous Research has MeM -
identified innovation
opportunities in the
sector
4.2 Biosecurity of fish farms. Developing A knowledge-based KeM, MeM -
the basis for establishing buffers between basis for determining
different farms buffers between
different farms has
been developed.
4.3 Mapping areas with natural potential for 2025 The mapping has MeM -
fish growth been carried out.
4.4 Awareness and promotion of the health continuous Awareness-raising MeM Health Board,
benefits of aquaculture products (fish activities have been Institute for
products) and promoting their consumption. carried out. Health
Development
5. Fostering the 5.1 Encourage the uptake of innovative continuous The necessary MKM -
development of energy technologies (e.g. floating solar actions to encourage
the renewable plants, wave energy, use of the coastal sea innovative solutions
energy sector for cooling and thermal energy). have been taken.
5.2 For larger scale offshore wind farm 2022 The prerequisites are Elering MKM
developments, the development of a cross- in place to develop
border offshore grid solution connecting transnational links.
wind farms, including additional HVDC
interconnections between countries.
5.3 Analysis prior to the deployment of the 2026-2027 An analysis of the MKM, TTJA -
reserve areas, on the basis of which the deployment of
Government of the Republic will be given reserve areas has
an overview of the current situation and a been completed, an
decision will be taken on follow-up overview given to
activities. the Government of
the Republic and
decisions on follow-
up activities taken.
6. Better awareness 6.1 Creation of websites on maritime uses continuous Relevant information All sectoral -
of the diversity is available. ministries-
of maritime uses agencies
and maritime according to
issues in general their
competences.
Abbreviations used in the table:
JuM - Ministry of Justice
KaM - Ministry of Defence
KeM - Ministry of the Environment
KuM - Ministry of Culture
MeM - Ministry of Rural Affairs
MKM - Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
RaM - Ministry of Finance
SiM - Ministry of the Interior
ELVL - Association of Estonian Cities and Municipalities
KAUR - Environment Agency
KeA - Environmental Board
MKA - National Heritage Board
PPA - Police and Border Guard Board
PäA - Rescue Board
TTJA - Consumer Protection and Technical Regulatory Authority
Proposal for a functional classification of ports:
The MSP proposes introduction of the following functional classification of ports. The proposal aims to make the use of the maritime area simpler
and easier to understand. The proposed classification will make it possible to assess the functioning of the port network and the regional balance,
and will provide a better basis for allocating the resources needed to operate ports. The current classification does not reflect the sector of activity
or the size of the ports, which give rise to environmental impacts and spatial needs to be taken into account, both on land and at sea.
The planning process does not define the types of existing ports - each port will be able to do this in the future, based on its actual activities, the
vessels it serves and the services it offers. The proposed classification aims to ensure that ports are treated on a similar basis. The following
proposal was discussed during the preparation of the plan, and it was considered that the issue needed further analysis, as the proposal would
require legislative changes, development of information systems and other activities. The proposal is linked to the extended vision for maritime
policy, which will discuss with the various stakeholders both the need for a new classification and its substance.
One and the same port can perform several functions. Exceptions to this are ports with defence and public administration functions, whose function
is defined by law.
Indicative functional classification Classification on the Maritime
Spatial Plan spatial layout
Port with defence functions Not shown on the spatial layout
For mooring and servicing of warships
and naval auxiliary vessels only.
Port with public administrative functions Port
Intended exclusively for the mooring and
servicing of vessels performing public
administrative functions, the chapter of the
Ports Act on security requirements does
not apply.
Commercial port / Freight port
including large fishing port, repair port
Passenger port
including ferry port
Port connecting to small islands
Regionally important, consider the need
to create a rescue and pollution response
capacity. Could at the same time function
as a guest harbour.
Fishing port Small harbour
Small harbour, may be related to
trawling.
Guest harbour
including home harbour, boat harbour
"Single-family/community harbour" MSP does not reflect
Often a former landing place with a small
floating pier
Kaupo Heinma
Keskkonnaministeerium Meie 10.06.2022 nr 15-1/5049-1
[email protected]
Eesti mereala planeeringu
piiriülene teavitus
Austatud härra Heinma
Vabariigi Valitsus võttis vastu 12. mai 2022 korralduse nr 148 „Üleriigilise planeeringu Eesti
mereala ja sellega piirneva rannikuala, samuti majandusvööndi teemaplaneeringu
kehtestamine“.
Palume Keskkonnaministeeriumil oma pädevusest lähtuvalt korraldada KeHJS § 44 kohane
piiriülese keskkonnamõju strateegilise hindamise konsultatsioonides osalenud mõjutatavate
riikide teavitamine Eesti mereala planeeringu kehtestamisest.
Planeeringu kehtestamise korraldus, planeeringu seletuskiri, keskkonnamõjude hindamise
aruanne ja elluviimise tegevuskava on lisatud kirjale. Samuti on kõik materjalid saadavad
https://www.fin.ee/en/state-local-governments-spacial-planning/spatial-planning/maritime-
spatial-planning
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Katri-Liis Ennok
planeeringute osakonna juhataja
Lisa(d):
1. Government of the Republic Order
2. Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Explanatory Memorandum
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272
3. Estonian Maritime Spatial Plan Impact Assessment Report
4. Annex 4: Action Plan for Implementation of the Plan
Lembe Reiman 611 3615
[email protected]
2