Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 5. jaanuar 2021
Sisu (failidest)
5 January 2021
Industry amendments to the Commission’s proposal for temporary relief from slot use for
Summer 2021
As you will be aware the European Commission adopted on 16 December 2020 a proposal for a
Regulation regarding temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to the
COVID-19 pandemic. This proposal will go through the European Parliament and Council in the coming
weeks. While we acknowledge the European Commission’s efforts to adapt the rules governing the
allocation of slots at Community airports for the next Summer season, its proposal falls short of
expectations and ignores the joint aviation industry WASB Recommendation “Airport slot alleviation
measures for Northern Summer 2021” which was adopted end of November with the full support of
European airlines, airports and coordinators. The WASB recommendation reflects the needs of our
industry 10 months into the worst crisis in our history and needs to be implemented in full within the
EU/EEA.
Unfortunately, some of the core elements of the WASB recommendation are missing from the
Commission proposal while other provisions are either too restrictive or cannot be implemented as such.
In particular:
• The Commission proposal fails to provide any possibility for full slot-series alleviation which is
essential at this stage of the crisis to create the conditions for our industry to recover. Conversely,
the WASB recommendation allows airlines to benefit from full slot alleviation if they return the full
slot series they will not use to the pool early. This in turn increases the chances to reallocate
these series of slots to other airlines in a position to use them. It also benefits airports through
increased planning visibility allowing them to scale their operation to actual traffic levels and thus
reduce their costs. This is critical at this time. The Commission proposal on the other hand aims
to incentivize a return of slots to the pool but without creating the conditions for this to happen;
• The Commission’s proposals on Force majeure are too restrictive and discriminate among flights
based on the date of entry into force of travel restrictions. This criteria is difficult to accept as
travel restrictions are the exclusive prerogative of Governments with no possibility for industry to
influence. As such, the criteria used by the Commission impacts some operations in a
disproportionate way (e.g. long haul);
• Some provisions of the Commission’s proposal cannot be enforced e.g. the multiple utilization
thresholds of 40% and 80%. This creates unnecessary complexity for coordinators and legal
uncertainty for all.
…/…
Airlines (IATA and A4E1) as well as the European coordinators (EUACA) have already submitted detailed
comments to the Commission’s proposal. Airlines and airports have prepared joint industry amendments
to the Commission’s proposal for which we are seeking the support of the Council and the European
Parliament. The allocation of slots follows a very strict calendar Worldwide, and it is therefore critical for
the amended slot Regulation to enter into force by the end of January to coincide with the Worldwide
Historic Baseline Date of 31 January.
We hope we can count on your support to ensure that the slot rules in the next phase of this crisis are
conducive to preserving connectivity and competition, and to make the necessary changes to the
European Commission proposal with the greatest urgency. We will be pleased to answer any query you
may have on the above.
Yours sincerely,
Rafael Schvartzman Thomas Reynaert Olivier Jankovec
RVP Europe Managing Director Director-General
International Air Transport Airlines for Europe ACI EUROPE
Association
Enclosed: Industry amendments to the Commission’s proposal – Slot relief S21
1
A4E member Ryanair does not share this position and will communicate its views separately.
2
Proposed amendments on the proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC)
No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at
Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
1/ 40/60 and full series return
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 10-a-2-a
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
In respect of the period from 28 March 2021 In respect of the period from 28 March 2021
until 30 October 2021 and for the purposes of until 30 October 2021 and for the purposes of
Article 8(2) and Article 10(2), if an air carrier Article 8(2) and Article 10(2), if an air carrier
demonstrates to the satisfaction of the demonstrates to the satisfaction of the
coordinator that the series of slots in question coordinator that it either (i) returned the entire
has been operated, as cleared by the series to the coordinator for reallocation
coordinator, by that air carrier for at least 40% before [8 February 2021] or (ii) the series of
of the time during the scheduling period for slots in question has been operated, as cleared
which it has been allocated, the air carrier shall by the coordinator, by that air carrier for at
be entitled to the same series of slots for the least 50% of the time during the scheduling
next equivalent scheduling period. period for which it has been allocated, the air
In respect of the period referred to in the first carrier shall be entitled to the same series of
subparagraph, the percentage values referred to slots for the next equivalent scheduling period.
in Article 10(4) and point (a) of 14(6) shall be In respect of the period referred to in the first
40%.’; subparagraph, the percentage values referred to
in Article 10(4) and point (a) of 14(6) shall be
50%.’
Justification:
The industry including airlines, airports and coordinators are ready to move to a threshold of 50/50 to balance
the restart of existing services while facilitating new services when accompanied by the ability to return full series
of slots early in the process for reallocation and planning purposes that will benefit consumers, airports and
airlines. These full series returns will be alleviated from use in Summer 2021 to preserve international aviation
networks and connectivity while demand recovers and operating restrictions remain in place. The returned series
give opportunity to establish entry for other carriers able to operate this summer season, with priority to return
in S22 subject to capacity. Consumers benefit from better schedules, meeting their demand for travel this
summer, while historic slot holdings and the connectivity they provide for consumers and trade are not
deconstructed.
It is essential this relief is combined – as per the industry recommendation – to allow sustainable operations from
an economic and environmental perspective. Without series returns alleviated from use the slot pool remains
insufficient to mobilize slot retimes and new services because airlines will not have ability to return full series
(often full season slots) without losing them. Early returns to the pool will allow airports to scale their operation
to the appropriate level of traffic, in particular opening or closing parts of terminals, and thus reduce their costs,
while airlines need to make crew and fleet decisions for their network. This benefits both intra-European and
international schedule planning and matches the approach taken by other regulators outside the EU to preserve
slots while enabling optimal planning for summer 2021.
1
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19
2/ Force majeure
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 10-4-e
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
during the period referred to in Article 10a(2a), during the period referred to in Article 10a(2a),
the introduction, after 31 January for the the introduction, after 31 January for the
following summer season or after 31 August following summer season or after 31 August
for the following winter season, by public for the following winter season, by public
authorities of measures intended to address the authorities of measures intended to address the
spread of the COVID-19 pandemic at one end spread of the COVID-19 pandemic at one end
of a route for which the slots in question were of a route for which the slots in question were
used or planned to be used, on condition that used or planned to be used, on condition that
the measures had not been published at the time the measures had not been published at the
the series of slots had been allocated and that time the series of slots had been allocated and
the measures lead to either of the following: that the measures lead to either of the
– a partial or total closure of the border, airport following:
or airspace during a substantial part of the – a partial or total closure of the border,
relevant scheduling period, airport or airspace during a substantial part
– a severe impediment to passengers’ ability to of the relevant scheduling period,
travel with any carrier on that direct route – a severe impediment to passengers’ ability to
during a substantial part of the relevant travel with any carrier on that direct route
scheduling period.’ during a substantial part of the relevant
scheduling period.’
any restrictions that prevent or severely
restrict travel to specific airports, destinations
(including intermediate points) or countries
for which the slot was held. Such restrictions
include but are not limited to:
- Government travel restrictions based on
nationality, closed borders, government
advisories related to COVID-19 that warn
against all but essential travel, or complete
bans on flights from/to certain countries or
geographic areas.
- Severe government restrictions related to
COVID-19 on the maximum number of
arriving or departing passengers on a specific
flight or through a specific airport.
- Government restrictions on movement or
quarantine/isolation measures within the
country or region where the airport or
destination (including intermediate points) is.
- Government-imposed closure of businesses
essential to support aviation activities (e.g.
closure of hotels).
- Unforeseeable restrictions on airline crew,
including sudden bans on entry or crew
stranded in unexpected locations due to
quarantine measures.
2
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19
Justification:
The Commission is proposing force majeure only for services impacted by country restrictions after January 31 for
next summer i.e. not by restrictions currently in force that restrict their ability to operate and which have not
been lifted by the time of the summer season. This is extremely harmful for recovery. Carriers need to be
motivated to take risks and schedule services consumers will demand – this particular policy limits the application
of Force Majeure beyond normal application of the slot regulation and normal circumstances. Constraining the
industry further during a crisis is simply unthinkable – the Industry defined approach should be adopted to ensure
alignment.
There are severe practical limitations of the Commission’s proposal due to the current restrictions in place on
markets served to/from the EU. All of these markets would be prevented from receiving the Commissions
proposed relief if the slots cannot be used. This policy would be punitive towards airlines and risk harming
airport connectivity in the long term because they must use the slots at least a minimum amount (50%) of the
series to retain them, with no justification for non-use and no alleviation – which could lead to bilateral
implications. In other words, US carriers, many Asian carriers, will be required to operate flights with no demand
just to preserve their access to congested EU airports for future years, or they lose the historic. EU carriers would
be affected in a similar way. For example, it remains to be seen if the United States will lift its travel ban on
Schengen area countries by 31 January 2021. Should this not be the case, an EU carrier would not be able to
invoke force majeure for slots held for flights to the US this summer under the EC’s proposal.
3/ 80:20 for new and exchanged slots
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 10-a-3-a-a
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
Paragraph 2a shall not apply: deleted
(a) in respect of a series of slots allocated to an
air carrier for a given scheduling period, where
that carrier had not been allocated the same
series of slots for the previous equivalent
scheduling period;
Justification:
There should be one usage threshold for all operators when there is no complete waiver (i.e. 0/100 threshold)
from use.
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 10-a-3-a-b
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
3a. Paragraph 2a shall not apply: deleted
3
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19
(b) in respect of a series of slots which, with
effect from the scheduling period in question,
have been exchanged between air carriers in
accordance with point (c) of Article 8a(1) and
where the exchange has included monetary or
any other kind of compensation.’;
Justification:
The current regulation does not refer to secondary trades – monetary exchanges – and therefore this addition is
superfluous to the operation of the Regulation in the EU. Secondary Trading is a specific type of exchange, most
common in the UK. Coordinators cannot be privy to highly sensitive, commercial contracts between carriers: they
do not have oversight of these arrangements. The coordinator will know of an exchange for the basis of
approving the capacity available, not the commercial (if any) terms associated with this. Furthermore, this
provides a form of mobility to ensure best use of capacity and should not be restricted in use during a period of
crisis recovery.
4/ 3 weeks return deadline
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 10-a-7
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
During the period referred to in paragraph 2a, During the period referred to in paragraph 2a,
air carriers shall make available to the air carriers shall make available to the
coordinator for reallocation to other air carriers coordinator for reallocation to other air carriers
any slot they do not intend to use, no less than any slot they do not intend to use, no less than
three weeks before the date of operation. three weeks before the date of operation.
Justification:
Should repeat and intentional offenses occur the Coordinators are asked to sanction the air carriers. Under
normal usage rules there is no deadline, because the usage allows a proportion of slots to be “non-used”. This
advance return deadline was only applicable in the conditions related to a full slot waiver, i.e. Winter 2020/21
season. It makes no sense to have this condition when the use-it or lose-it rule applies again, even with a
reduced threshold because the spirit of the current Regulation is to return slots as soon as a carrier knows it
would not operate them. Furthermore a 3-week return deadline is redundant if carriers are able to return full
series earlier in the pre-planning phase. A lot of the cancellations will have taken place upfront. Carriers will plan
to operate – or feel confident of meeting 50% for - the slots they hold after that.
4
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19
5/ Sanctions
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 14 (a) - 5
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
Member States shall establish and apply Member States shall establish and apply
effective, dissuasive and proportionate effective, dissuasive and proportionate
sanctions or equivalent measures in the event sanctions or equivalent measures in the event
an air carrier repeatedly and intentionally fails an air carrier repeatedly and intentionally fails
to comply with Article 10a(7). Such sanctions to comply with Article 10a(7) and 14(5). Such
and measures shall include the possibility to sanctions and measures shall include the
possibility to withdraw the benefit of Article
withdraw the benefit of Article 10a(2a), where
10a(2a), where justified by the individual
justified by the individual case.’; case.’;
Justification:
Should repeat and intentional offenses occur the Coordinators are asked to sanction the air carriers.
6/ Slots of a carrier that ceases operation
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 14 - 6c
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
‘(c) During the period referred to Article ‘(c) During the period referred to Article
10a(2a), when a coordinator determines, on the 10a(2a), when a coordinator determines after a
basis of information at its disposal, that an air reasonable deadline set by the coordinator for
carrier has ceased its operations at an airport an air carrier to provide the necessary
and is no longer able to operate the slots which information about its potential intention to re-
it has been allocated, the coordinator shall start operations at an airport, and on the basis
withdraw from that air carrier the series of slots of information at its disposal, that an air carrier
in question for the remainder of the scheduling has ceased its operations at an airport
period and place them in the pool, after having permanently and is no longer able to operate
heard the air carrier concerned.’. the slots which it has been allocated, the
coordinator shall not apply the alleviation
measures to that air carrier at that airport
withdraw from that air carrier the series of
slots in question for the remainder of the
scheduling period and place them in the pool,
after having heard the air carrier concerned.’.
Justification:
5
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19
This provision should be amended given the coordinators already have power to monitor and withdraw series of
slots and place the series of slots in question in the pool for the remainder of the scheduling period, after having
heard the air carrier concerned if the slots allocated are not being used anymore. As the SWD accompanying the
EC proposal recognizes: If an airline fails to provide necessary information on its plans for a certain airport by a
reasonable deadline date set by the coordinator, and after having heard the airline concerned, the coordinator
may withdraw and reallocate the slots.
7/ Coordination parameters
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 8-6a
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
Within the period during which COVID-19 Within the period during which COVID-19
coordination parameters apply and in order to coordination parameters apply and in order to
enable the proper application of such enable the proper application of such
coordination parameters, the coordinator may coordination parameters and following
amend the timing of requested or allocated Coordination Committee consultation, the
slots falling within the period specified in coordinator may cancel slots or amend the
timing of requested or allocated slots falling
paragraph 2a of Article 10a or cancel them
within the period specified in paragraph 2a of
after hearing the air carrier concerned. In this
Article 10a, or cancel them after hearing the air
context, the coordinator shall take into account carrier concerned. The slots cancelled or
additional rules and guidelines referred to in amended should be treated as according to
Article 8(5), under the conditions set out Article 10(4). In this context, the coordinator
therein.’; shall take into account additional rules and
guidelines referred to in Article 8(5), under the
conditions set out therein.’;
Justification:
Any change to an air carrier’s slots must be through communication with the coordinator and airline concerned,
based on parameters presented at the Coordination Committee. This maintains alignment with the industry
agreement for managing temporary changes in airport capacity during COVID-19.
8/ Priority for allocation of slots: process of slot allocation
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 8-2-a
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
During the period referred to in Article 10a(2a), During the period referred to in Article 10a(2a),
a series of slots which is returned to the slot a series of slots which is returned to the slot
6
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19
pool in accordance with Article 8(1) at the end pool in accordance with Article 8(1) at the end
of the scheduling period (the “reference of the scheduling period (the “reference
scheduling period”), shall, upon request, be scheduling period”), shall, upon request, be
allocated for the next equivalent scheduling allocated for the next equivalent scheduling
period to an air carrier which has operated at period to an air carrier which has operated at
least five slots of the series in question least five slots of the series in question
following the application of Article 10a(7) following the application of Article 10a(7)
during the reference scheduling period. during the reference scheduling period. as
approved, on a non-historic basis in the
In the event that more than one applicant fulfils
scheduling period. This series, when
the requirements of the first subparagraph,
requested by the air carrier, shall have priority
priority shall be given to the air carrier having
over new demands for the same timings in the
operated the greater number of slots of that
next equivalent season, subject to capacity
series.’;
availability and any other legal conditions.
In the event that more than one applicant fulfils
the requirements of the first subparagraph,
priority shall be given to the air carrier having
operated the greater number of slots of that
series.’; consideration should be given to
industry guidelines that enable the
coordinator to determine the most appropriate
allocation including the effective period of
operation.’;
Justification:
Under normal circumstances a carrier would be granted slots according to the series operated and can request
the next equivalent season for the extended series subject to capacity. Fragmentation is a feature of highly
constrained airports with specific market demand, such as summer leisure traffic. The WASG details that when
there are competing requests for slots, coordinators should not simply allocate the remaining slots pro-rata
among all requesting airlines. Instead, consideration should be given to a number of factors (in no particular
order) to determine which of the competing requests should be allocated a slot, this includes:
Effective Period of Operation: Whether an airline’s schedule that will be effective for a longer period of operation
in the same season than other competing requests.
9/ Delegated Act
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 10a 4 – (c)
indicators relating to demand for passenger and indicators relating to demand for passenger and
cargo air transport, including trends regarding cargo air transport, including trends regarding
fleet size, fleet utilisation, and load factors. fleet size, fleet utilisation, and load factors.
Delegated acts pursuant to this paragraph shall Delegated acts pursuant to this paragraph shall
be adopted no later than 24 January for the be adopted no later than 31 December for the
following summer scheduling period and no following summer scheduling period and no
7
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19
later than 24 August for the following winter later than 31 July for the following winter
scheduling period.’; scheduling period.’;
Justification:
The date for decision making must be sooner for airline and airport planning, industry slot decisions are made in
Jan and Aug for the seasons, therefore the Commission must provide certainty prior to this.
Proposal amending Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 as regards temporary relief from the slot
utilisation rules at Community airports due to the COVID-19 pandemic
Article 12a
The power to adopt delegated acts referred to in The power to adopt delegated acts referred to in
Article 10a shall be conferred on the Article 10a shall be conferred on the
Commission until 24 August 2024.’; Commission until 31 July 2024.’;
Justification:
The date for decision making must be sooner for airline and airport planning, industry slot decisions are made in
Jan and Aug for the seasons, therefore the Commission must provide certainty prior to this.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
8
Proposed amendments on the proposal to amend Regulation 95/93 – temporary relief from the slot utilisation rules at Community airports due to COVID-19