dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel
Otsing›Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Kiri

Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 11. jaanuar 2021
Viit
14-4/2021/144-1
Registreeritud
11. jaanuar 2021
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
Universal Postal Union
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
14 Postside korraldamine
Sari
14-4 Posti rahvusvaheliste organisatsioonidega seotud koostööalane kirjavahetus
Toimik
14-4/2021
Vastutaja
Tõnu Nirk (Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, Kantsleri valdkond, Side ja riigi infosüsteemide valdkond, Sideosakond)

Failid

  • 📎6850(DIRCAB.STRAT)1137_AN_annex.pdf270 KB
  • 📎6850(DIRCAB.STRAT)1137_AN.pdf147 KB

Sisu (failidest)

CA 2020.2–Doc 11.Rev 1 Original: English Published in English 17.12.2020, 17.49 (Previous version published 27.11.2020, 16.56) COUNCIL OF ADMINISTRATION Report of the task force on the opening up of the UPU to wider postal sector players Memorandum by the International Bureau (Agenda item 11) 1 Subject References/paragraphs Report of the task force on the opening up of the UPU to wider postal sector §§ 1 to 5 and Annex 1 players. 2 Decisions expected The CA is invited to: §§ 1 to 5 and Annex 1 – take note of the report; – approve the extension of the task force’s mandate until the April 2021 CA session (S9); and – allow all UPU member countries and observers to participate in its work from now onwards. I. Overview 1 At its October 2019 session (S6), the Council of Administration approved the creation of a task force to examine the specific topic of opening up the UPU to wider postal sector players and to provide recommenda- tions on the extent, elements and conditions for opening. 2 The first results of the task force’s work were presented to the CA at its February 2020 session (S7). These included the outcomes of a large-scale consultation of postal sector stakeholders and of a high-level forum specifically dedicated to this topic, both of which enjoyed an unprecedented level of participation from all constituencies of member countries and highlighted the considerable interest in the topic of opening up the UPU. 3 As it concluded its February 2020 session, the CA decided to give the task force (TF) a mandate to continue its work between March and August 2020, with the aim of presenting a proposal to the 27th Congress on three main areas: institutional change; opening up of products and services; and a timeline for implementation. In spite of the disruptions and delays caused by COVID-19, a considerable amount of work was completed up to October 2020, building on a wealth of input from member countries and other postal / sector stakeholders. The report in Annex 1 contains the current proposal resulting from the work of the TF since its inception. However, as yet the TF members have not reached a final consensus, since some TF members still have different views. 4 Nevertheless, a number of additional details still require careful analysis by the TF, notably in terms of the potential composition and functions of the proposed Business Council, the methodology for participation of sector members and their decision-making powers and the corresponding contribution model, as well as the finalization of draft amendments to be submitted to the 27th Congress, as per section 5.1 of Annex 1. DIRCAB Pro 2 5 Bearing in mind the above developments and the additional period of time afforded by the postponement of the 27th Congress, and in accordance with the possibility outlined in article 9.2 of the Rules of Procedure of the CA, it is recommended to extend the duration of the TF until the April 2021 session of the CA, so as to provide sufficient time to prepare the final recommendations to the 27th Congress. Berne, 17 December 2020 Bishar A. Hussein Secretary General CA 2020.2–Doc 11.Rev 1.Annex 1 Task force on opening up the UPU to wider postal sector players Draft report and proposed package to be submitted to the 27th Congress November 2020 Pro 2 Table of contents Page 1 Introduction 4 2 Basic rationale for opening up 5 2.1 The UPU’s mission 5 2.2 The current situation of DOs and USO in the postal sector 5 2.3 The UPU, USO and DOs 6 2.4 The UPU’s attempts to pursue its mission in the rapidly changing postal sector 6 2.5 The UPU compared to other sectoral agencies 7 3 Overview of past and current efforts towards opening up the UPU 8 3.1 Over two decades of efforts on opening up 8 3.2 Limited achievements over the 1999–2019 period 8 3.3 Acceleration of the work since 2019 9 4 The TF proposal 10 4.1 Key highlights 10 4.2 Main challenges faced by the UPU that the proposal is intended to address 11 4.3 Membership categories 11 4.4 Eligible stakeholders 12 4.5 Eligibility for accessing UPU products and services 12 4.6 Rights and obligations of membership 13 4.7 Funding 14 4.8 Reporting structure 14 5 Implementation 14 5.1 Amendments to the Acts of the Union and other internal rules of the organization 15 5.2 Timeline for implementation 16 6 Conclusion 16 Annexes 17 A. Further details on various aspects of the proposal 17 B. Work conducted by the TF between March and October 2020 23 Context 23 Phase 1 – Initiation and planning 23 Phase 2 – Institutional benchmarks and opening up of products and services 23 Phase 3 – Proposal preparation 24 Phase 4 – Congress decision 24 Pro 3 C. Results of the consultation with postal sector stakeholders (2019) 24 Government policies and organization of the sector 24 Regulatory frameworks in place 24 Status of the universal service obligation 25 Role and involvement of designated operators 25 Involvement of other players 25 Willingness to open up the UPU 25 Other players that could join the UPU 25 Other UPU solutions that could be opened up 26 Types of participation and related terms and conditions for these new players 26 D. Other reference information 26 4 1 Introduction The Universal Postal Union is an intergovernmental organization and specialized agency of the United Nations system with 192 member countries mandated, inter alia, “to stimulate the lasting development of efficient and accessible universal postal services of quality in order to facilitate communication between the inhabitants of the world”. For many years, the postal sector in most countries was run entirely by a single operator, formally the desig- nated operator (DO) in the UPU context, and also known in various countries as the “Post” or the “Post Office”. This single DO was usually part of government, and was in charge of covering the universal service obligation (USO). However, with the advent of liberalization and privatization and the concurrent surge in e-commerce, the boundaries of the traditional postal sector have been completely transformed, with DOs no longer covering the bulk of the market. As their market share decreases (76.7% for letters, 39.9% for express and 35.5% for parcels), DOs are relegated to low-growth segments. In spite of these transformations, wider postal sector players have mostly remained outside the operational activities of the UPU, potentially holding the organization back from maintaining its universal nature. Indeed, although many governments, especially in advanced economies, have liberalized their domestic markets and even privatized their historic postal operators, the latter are the only ones that have real access to UPU prod- ucts and services and are allowed to participate in the organization’s decision-making process. This is at odds with the transformations undertaken by other sectoral agencies in the UN system, all of which have expanded their representativeness to a wide range of stakeholders operating in their respective industries. Against this background, numerous UPU Congress decisions and positions from member countries over the past few decades1 have expressed the need for reforms to strengthen the global postal network under the UPU umbrella, giving a voice to other important players in the industry, and promoting synergy among all players. More specifically, the push for reforms has been inspired by the need to ensure a clear separation between governmental and operational dimensions in the organization’s decision-making process, in particular when it comes to the structure and composition of the UPU’s bodies. In 2018, the risk of a major withdrawal by a founding member contributed to the acceleration of the UPU’s transformation agenda, as it revealed how critical it was for the organization to address its long-term risks of relevance and funding. In the same vein, one year later, as the UPU prepared to enter the 2021–2024 cycle, the topic of opening up the UPU was actively taken up by the Council of Administration (CA), which formed a dedicated task force (TF) to look more closely into the matter. The first results of the TF’s work were presented to the CA in February 2020. They included the outcomes of a large-scale consultation of postal sector stakeholders and of a high-level forum specifically dedicated to this topic, both of which enjoyed an unprecedented level of participation from all constituencies of member coun- tries and highlighted the considerable interest in the topic of opening up the UPU. As it concluded its February 2020 session, the CA decided to give the TF a mandate to continue its work between March and August 2020, with the aim of presenting a proposal to the 27th Congress on three main areas: institutional change, opening up of products and services, and a timeline for implementation. In spite of the disruptions and delays caused by COVID-19, a considerable amount of work was completed up to October 2020, building on a wealth of input from representatives of member countries and other stakeholders. This report contains the final proposal resulting from the work of the TF since its inception. The document is organized into six sections: following the present introduction, section 2 outlines the basic rationale for opening up; section 3 explains the efforts undertaken towards this goal; section 4 presents the key elements of the proposal, such as membership categories, eligibility criteria for stakeholders to join the UPU and to access products and services, as well as mechanisms for funding and institutional structures; section 5 provides details on implementation; and section 6 draws conclusions. The report also includes numerous annexes with further information on the proposal and on the elements that underpinned its development. 1 C 105/1999, United States memorandum in 1999, establishment of the CC in 2004, multiple resolutions in 2012, C 10/2016. In addition, a risk analysis by EY in 2014 indicated relevance and funding as the UPU’s key risks. 5 2 Basic rationale for opening up 2.1 The UPU’s mission The preamble to the UPU Constitution states that that the mission of the organization is “to stimulate the lasting development of efficient and accessible universal postal services of quality in order to facilitate communication between the inhabitants of the world by: – guaranteeing the free circulation of postal items over a single postal territory composed of intercon- nected networks; – encouraging the adoption of fair common standards and the use of technology; – ensuring cooperation and interaction among stakeholders; – promoting effective technical cooperation; – ensuring the satisfaction of customers’ changing needs.” 2.2 The current situation of DOs and USO in the postal sector As briefly noted in the introduction, in the past, the postal sector in most countries was covered entirely by the DO, which was usually part of government and was in charge of ensuring the fulfilment of USO in those coun- tries. Nowadays, liberalization, privatization and e-commerce have completely transformed the boundaries of the traditional postal sector. DOs now generally represent a declining portion of postal markets, with 76.7% for letters, 39.9% for express and 35.5% for parcels.2 This actually reflects an evolution that is similar to the structural transformations observed in other industries. Indeed, the concept of USO is not unique to the postal sector. It has been applied in a number of industries and it has evolved over the past few decades to reflect global, regional and national trends. In this regard, two main aspects can be useful in better understanding how the notions associated with universal service have changed over the years: its definition; and the frameworks that have been put in place by governments to ensure fulfilment. The USO may be defined as the obligation of an operator (or several operators) “to offer either a full range or a basic package of services, of “good quality”, to all users, at “affordable” rates”.3 These broad terms are too vague to yield a common global or even regional definition, which is why the USO is understood and framed differently in every country. The postal sector is no exception in this regard. In fact, in some member countries such a definition does not even exist. A survey conducted by the UPU in 2018 found that 19% of countries responding in the Western Hemisphere and 11% in Africa had not yet defined the USO for postal services.4 The same survey also showed the significant diversity in national definitions when they do exist. For instance, while 152 countries consider priority/non-priority mail as part of the definition, only 65 see express as part of it, and 24 also include the opening of a giro account or savings account. These disparities are noticeable even in relatively well-integrated regions such as the European Union. In the 2019 edition of the annual postal market studies produced for the European Commission5, one can read the following: “Among the different Member States, there is still little harmonization and limited transparency as regards the classification of delivery services (parcel, express and emerging new delivery services).” National reports in other regions have also highlighted similar challenges in definition.6 The diversity is also reflected in the frameworks in place to ensure the USO. Regarding funding, this may include subsidies to the DO, contributions from all market players to a universal service fund, self-funding by 2 Global estimates based on UPU official statistics (2016–2018). 3 Cremer, H., Gasmi, F., Grimaud, A. and Laffont, J.J., 1998. The economics of universal service: Theory. Economic Development Institute of the World Bank. 4 Source: Publication of member replies to survey on main aspects of universal postal service (CA C 2 2018.1–Doc 7). 5 Consult, W.I.K., 2019. Development of cross–border e-commerce through parcel delivery. A study for DG GROW. 6 USPS (2020), Reevaluating the Universal Service Obligation, Report Number RISC-WP-20-004, Office of Inspector General; and USPS (2014), Guiding Principles for a New Universal Service Obligation, Report No. RARC-WP-15-001, Office of Inspector General. 6 the DO and/or a levy on all operators. Even the responsibility of delivering universal services may be assigned to several companies, thus transferring the responsibility from a single operator to the entire sector, with reg- ulation, taxes and other financial mechanisms used to ensure that the USO is delivered. Services to citizens will thus tend to evolve as a response to market demand, rather than the USO. Indeed, in the report for the European Commission mentioned above, one can read that “for intra-EU parcels, we con- clude that delivery markets have developed well without much regulation, and that the role of universal service obligations therefore has not been significant for the development of parcel markets. Indeed, carriers usually provide appropriate services in excess of the USO requirements, i.e. they offer better service, and generally lower prices to e-retailers and consumers than they are obliged to offer under their national postal legislation. Universal service providers are enhancing service levels of universal service products not in response to reg- ulation but as a reaction to market demand.” Diversity is therefore the most common factor of USO around the world nowadays, in the postal sector and beyond. 2.3 The UPU, USO and DOs The diversity of USO definitions and frameworks from one country to another explains why the UPU sets high- level principles for the provision of some basic services, but does not get involved in their definition or regula- tion. This is the mandate of national governments, which specify such matters in accordance with their own laws. Hence, the work of the UPU may often focus on other topics, where a common ground for cooperation in sector development can be more easily reached. In the CA, for instance, only one of the five committees deals directly with USO.7 In the Postal Operations Council (POC), only two committees out of four indirectly handle matters of this nature.8 Furthermore, in nearly 300 pages of UPU Acts, there are only four references to universal (postal) services: in the preamble to the Constitution, and in articles 1.18, 3 and 29.1 of the Convention. Therefore, the opening up of the UPU to wider postal sector players has no bearing on the issue of USO provided by DOs. 2.4 The UPU’s attempts to pursue its mission in the rapidly changing postal sector Over the past few decades, the demand for what the UPU has to offer has continuously increased, together with the variety and the depth of products and services provided by the organization. Traditionally, the organ- ization was structured to facilitate the efficient exchange of cross-border mail and to manage treaties to regu- late the terminal dues system. However, over time, the UPU has progressively morphed into a multi-functional organization serving a greater range of stakeholders. Nowadays, the organization serves governments, DOs and, to a much lesser extent, other wider postal sector players. It also has the potential to appeal to an even wider audience, by banking on its uniqueness as the only truly global organization of the postal sector that can set international postal standards, measure their implementation electronically, analyze corresponding trends, provide information and communication technol- ogy tools, and constitute a platform to discuss and negotiate multilateral agreements on postal matters. Given the rising challenges in the sector and mounting pressures on funding, the UPU has attempted a number of changes over the years. In 2004 it created the Consultative Committee (CC) in order to give a voice to other stakeholders in the sector. It has also expanded its value proposition to encompass a wide range of products and services for DOs, assisting them in the improvement and expansion of their activities. In doing so, it has accumulated a vast amount of data and knowledge about the postal sector. Furthermore, it has consistently increased its reliance on extrabudgetary funding in order to compensate for the effects of the zero nominal growth rule weighing on the organization’s regular budget. More recently, the threat by a major founding member to withdraw from the organization triggered the 2019 Extraordinary Congress, where the UPU-based rules for international settlement of cross-border mail were significantly altered. The change included an adjustment of the remuneration framework, with the aim of reflecting the structural changes in the nature of mail, which has increasingly moved away from social to com- mercial communication, and therefore from USO-related considerations, under the impulse of e-commerce. 7 CA Committee 2 on Universal Service Obligation, Regulatory Affairs and Postal Regulation. 8 POC Committee 1 on Supply Chain Integration and POC Committee 2 on Physical Services and E-Commerce. 7 Nevertheless, these adjustments may not have been sufficiently proportional to the magnitude of the transfor- mations that have impacted the postal sector in an environment of digital disruption, with an increasing demand for UPU services. Indeed, the organization’s main risks today still revolve around relevance and funding. With a total annual budget (42.86 million SDR)9 that is equivalent to less than 0.02% of the total operating revenues of DOs (243.7 billion SDR) worldwide, the UPU would need a substantial increase in investment to respond in a timely manner to the needs expressed by its traditional stakeholders. Its lack of interaction with wider postal sector players also means that the organization does not serve the entirety of the market, thus depriving it of additional sources of revenue and relevance. 2.5 The UPU compared to other sectoral agencies Benchmarking the UPU against other specialized agencies of the UN system can provide additional perspec- tives on the topic of opening up.10 While other organizations have mandates that may not be directly compa- rable to that of the UPU, a number of them display similar characteristics, by virtue of their technical nature and their particular ties to specific sectors. This is the case with the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), the International Maritime Organization (IMO), the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) and the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). In addition, although it is not an intergovernmental organization, it is worth including the International Air Transport Association (IATA) in the benchmark in order to facilitate the comparison with ICAO.11 It is worth noting that the UPU and ITU share a longer history (having been formed in the second half of the 19th century), while the other organizations were created during or after the creation of the UN. Most organi- zations in the sample have as many (or nearly as many) member states as the UN.12 In addition, all are focused on headquarters, but some have a greater presence in the field, although only with small field offices. The UPU is one of the smallest organizations, either in terms of staff members (269 versus over 1,500 for WIPO and IATA) or revenues (74 million CHF vs. 232.5 million CHF for ICAO or 430.6 million CHF for WIPO in 2018), and always considerably below the median of the sample. When it comes to governance and membership structures, the UPU currently has one higher body (i.e. Congress). The same applies to all other sampled agencies, with the exception of WIPO, which has three. Among all other UN agencies with a single higher body, the UPU is the only one with two reporting bodies: the CA and the POC. All sampled UN agencies have a higher body composed of member states. By contrast, IATA, which is not intergovernmental, gathers representatives of sector operators (i.e. airlines) in its higher body. In spite of its size, the UPU has more councils (two instead of one), and more members of these councils (81 instead of 44). In terms of frequency, the higher bodies of the UPU and ITU are the ones that meet less often (every four years). However, when it comes to its councils, the UPU's meeting frequency is aligned with the benchmark (i.e. a median of twice per year). Regarding its openness to wider sector players, although it has as many member states and more councils compared to peer agencies, the UPU has just one other membership category (on top of member countries), which comprised only 14 members in 2020 (and was down from 22 in 2016). By contrast, other agencies such as ITU can have as many as three other membership categories and 924 members. Even smaller agencies such as UNWTO can gather as many as 508 members. Among the sampled organizations, the UPU and ITU have the most challenging long-term financial situation. In particular, the UPU and ITU have hundreds of millions in negative net assets, including large employee- related liabilities. This is due to both organizations' relatively weak revenue base. 9 2017 figures, as per UPU postal statistics. The total UPU budget approved by the CA for the same year amounted to 60 million CHF, converted at an exchange rate of 1 SDR to 1.40 CHF. 10 The information presented in this benchmark is based on data available in the websites and consolidated financial statements of the respective organizations up to September 2020. 11 In the aviation sector, ICAO is generally known for predominantly covering governmental matters, whereas IATA covers operational issues. In the case of the UPU, both aspects are covered within the same organization; hence the usefulness of including both ICAO and IATA when benchmarking with the UPU. 12 In the case of the UPU, these are termed “member countries” for specific historical and legal reasons. 8 At the other end of the spectrum, WIPO displays a very successful model, with a significant revenue-generation capacity yielding millions of CHF in surpluses every year, in spite of a much higher cost base. In terms of funding, the UPU and the IMO have a similar funding model: nearly 50% of revenues from the regular budget, with a remaining mix of voluntary funding, sales of products and services and other sources. Each of the other organizations has its own particularities: ICAO relies strongly on voluntary funding; ITU on regular budget, and WIPO on sales of products and services. However, as indicated above, WIPO's model is undoubtedly the most successful. The key takeaway of this benchmark is that, in spite of being one of the smallest organizations in many respects (revenues, number of staff members, etc.), the UPU has a very complex, multi-layered structure. Yet, unlike its peers, it serves only a restricted number of categories of stakeholders. Moreover, financially, its situation is among the most challenging of all the sampled organizations. This suggests an urgent need for change, and opening up appears to be a solution to boost relevance and funding, both elements which are clearly not addressed by the status quo. 3 Overview of past and current efforts towards opening up the UPU Calls for opening up the UPU are not a new phenomenon. In fact, the UPU’s membership has repeatedly mandated such a transformation over the past few decades. This has been expressed by numerous Congress resolutions, statements from ministers and elements of the work programme of the CA and the POC. The acceleration of the transformation and opening up agenda in 2019 is thus not the start, but rather the culmina- tion of over 20 years of efforts towards (re)creating a more universal organization. 3.1 Over two decades of efforts on opening up The Beijing Congress in 1999 authorized the CA to create an Advisory Group that would increase the partici- pation of interested parties in the UPU’s work (C 105/1999). In addition, that same year, the United States of America issued a memorandum encouraging the UPU to “consider the reforms that may be needed to ensure that [the] UPU keeps pace with [these] global developments”. The US delegation also asserted that its goal was to “make the UPU more open and inclusive in its deliverables and decision making”, and proposed the convening of an Extraordinary Congress to discuss the issue of opening up. While the proposed Extraordinary Congress did not ultimately take place, the momentum from this initiative led to the replacement of the Advisory Group by a more permanent UPU body, in the form of the CC, at the 2004 Bucharest Congress. This was followed by various resolutions at the 2012 Doha Congress on extrater- ritorial offices of exchange (ETOEs), international mail processing centres (IMPCs), designation of multiple operators, and access to UPU products and services by other players. In 2016, the Istanbul Congress approved resolution C 10/2016 on access to UPU products and services by other players. This was followed by the Ministerial Strategy Conference as part of the 2018 Extraordinary Congress in Addis Ababa, during which ministers strongly recommended that the UPU include wider sector stakeholders as part of its remit in the upcoming strategic cycle (2021–2024). 3.2 Limited achievements over the 1999–2019 period Although the momentum of the Beijing Congress yielded the CC and a series of Congress resolutions that reaffirmed the same principles, it cannot be said that the opening up of the UPU was hastened or fully achieved. Indeed, more than two decades after most of these efforts were initiated, the CC has still not brought the wider postal sector into the UPU. At the same time, the UPU’s supply of products and services has remained almost exclusively directed towards designated operators. As indicated by its own Management Committee, since its inception, the CC’s main purpose has been to represent the interests and views of wider postal sector players interested in supporting the UPU’s mission and objectives. Yet, this body created in 2004 has not entirely managed to fulfil this purpose, for a number of reasons likewise pointed out by its Management Committee. These include the lack of clarity in the definition of its role and value proposition; the low institutionalization of its interaction with other UPU bodies; the low recognition of its potential contribution; and the unsustainability of its funding model. 9 Moreover, as shown in the consultation of postal sector stakeholders conducted in late 2019, among the main elements of the UPU’s value proposition for new players, respondents mentioned affordable technical solutions on governmental, regulatory and operational matters; participation in UPU meetings and forums; and access to the UPU’s wide range of data and analytics. As such, the CC’s restricted role of solely issuing opinions on the activities of other UPU bodies may not be sufficient to attract wider postal sector players to the organization. Indeed, having been created to be a separate body to only give opinions in an already oversized structure, the CC has struggled to grow, let alone to retain its members, over its 16 years of existence. As shown in Table 8, after “peaking” at 22 members in 2012, CC membership has stagnated and declined since 2015, with only 14 members in 2020. When comparing this number to the hundreds of members that other UN specialized agencies have managed to enlist, the UPU’s record in this area appears to be all the more challenging. In parallel, initiatives have been undertaken to open up a number of selected UPU products and services, under very specific conditions. Nonetheless, in a number of cases, even in the areas where specific items have been opened up, no additional transactions have yet been recorded. The key takeaway of efforts undertaken over the past two decades is that the CC has not been successful in attracting wider postal sector players to the UPU, and it is not clear how it can offer a viable alternative route in the future that would be substantially different from the one it has followed since 2004. Equally, UPU prod- ucts and services that have so far been opened up seem to be unattractive to external players. 3.3 Acceleration of the work since 2019 In September 2019, the need to accelerate transformation was one of the key drivers behind the decisions of the Extraordinary Congress in Geneva. The following month, as the UPU prepared its work for the 2021–2024 cycle, the topic of opening up was taken forward by the CA, which formed a dedicated task force to look more closely into this matter, based on specific terms of reference (CA 2019.2–Doc 18). As one of the first preparatory steps for its work, the TF launched a wide consultation on opening up the UPU to wider postal sector players. The exercise was conducted through four questionnaires, one for each main category of postal sector stakeholders with an interest in the opening up of the UPU, i.e. governments; regu- lators; DOs; and other private sector stakeholders. This exercise enjoyed an unprecedented level of participa- tion from all constituencies of member countries, with over 200 responses, thus highlighting the considerable interest in the topic of opening up the UPU. The consultation delved into a wide range of issues, including government policies and organization of the sector; regulatory frameworks in place; status of the universal service obligation; role and involvement of des- ignated operators and other players; willingness to open up the UPU; potential players to join the organization; solutions to be opened up; types of participation; and related terms and conditions. The majority of respondents in all categories confirmed their willingness to open up the UPU to external play- ers, with percentages of 54%, 64%, 77% and 80% among DOs, governments, regulators and other stakehold- ers, respectively. Only a minority said no to the idea of opening up (27%, 17%, 7% and 7% respectively for the same groups). The remainder expressed their willingness to consider alternatives and/or study the matter further.13 In addition, on 13 February 2020, the UPU high-level forum on wider postal sector engagement brought together senior representatives from governments, regulators, designated operators, international organiza- tions and other private sector players, as well as civil society. Divided into four panels, speakers discussed the need for the UPU to open itself up to wider postal sector players, the UPU’s value proposition, and ways in which the organization could transform itself to fulfil the needs of its stakeholders. On this basis, during its physical meeting on 14 February 2020, the TF agreed to make the following three key recommendations to the CA for consideration and approval: – “Institutional change: Congress will determine the membership, contribution and structure for the new proposed new members; 13 Further details on the results of the survey are available in document CA 2020.1–Doc 11. 10 – Opening of products and services: Congress will determine which products and services are to be opened to new players; – Roadmap for implementation: Congress will determine the timeline and roadmap for implementation of the opening up.” As it concluded its February 2020 session, the CA decided to give the TF a mandate to continue its work between March and August 2020, with the aim of presenting a proposal to the 27th Congress on three main areas mentioned above, in line with the TF’s recommendations. In spite of the disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, which led to additional delays in the activities of the TF as well as the eventual postponement of the 27th Congress, a considerable amount of work has been accomplished over this period, particularly as numerous input and contributions were gathered from member countries and other stakeholders through consultations, position papers and other sources of infor- mation (most of which have already been made available in the relevant UPU workspace). Further details of the work of the TF between March and October 2020 are provided in Annex B. 4 The TF proposal The proposal developed through the work of the TF is based on a wide range of information, and is intended to address the matter of opening up the UPU in a holistic manner, in which all the aspects of a new UPU are considered as interconnected blocks, i.e. without focusing solely on either structure, accessibility to products and services, funding or timeline. This section presents the key highlights of the proposal, the main rationale for developing the latter, as well as further details on each aspect of the proposal, i.e. membership categories to be created; eligible stakeholders; accessibility of UPU products and services; other pre-conditions for eligibility; funding mechanisms; and the reporting structure. 4.1 Key highlights The key highlights of the proposal may be presented as follows: – The UPU would have three membership categories (member countries, sector members and associate members), as to cover the full range of stakeholders present in the wider postal sector; – Stakeholders would be allocated to different membership categories according to their type; – Eligibility to access different products and services would be defined according to the membership cat- egory; – Each membership category would imply specific rights and obligations; – New members would have to pay annual fees, in addition to payments for on-demand products and services. Pricing should as far as possible reflect market rates as well as production costs; – A new structure would be created with two councils: an Executive Council for governmental and regu- latory matters, and a Business Council for business matters; – The corresponding amendments to the treaties would already be stipulated in the formal proposal to be submitted to Congress (without prejudice to other consequential, infra-Congress changes deemed nec- essary); – The implementation of the proposal would be based on a specific timeline, starting with approval of the proposal by Congress. These different aspects are explained in more detail in the sub-sections below. 11 4.2 Main challenges faced by the UPU that the proposal is intended to address The proposal is intended to address the wide range of challenges that are outlined in the previous sections of this report. Among these are the following: – Over more than 20 years, the postal sector has changed dramatically, while the UPU has adopted an approach of incremental change, with very limited success in addressing the organization’s long-term risks of relevance and funding. – Although the UPU’s activities are mostly non-USO-related, non-USO providers are de facto barred from participating in the UPU, undermining the latter’s relevance as a “universal” organization for the sector. – Among sectoral UN agencies, the UPU is one of the smallest and most closed to its sector. Yet it has an oversized structure for very few postal sector players, plus an unsuccessful funding model. In this sense, the organization does not have the means to further expand its structure and build additional silos. – Without genuine access to UPU products and services, membership from wider postal sector players is likely to stagnate or decline, as it has over more than 15 years. – Wider postal sector players are not interested in participating in meetings that add no business value. For instance, if barred from taking part in standardization activities with all other market participants, including DOs, they are likely not to join the UPU. – Owing to the UPU’s resistance to change, alternatives are already emerging.14. In the absence of rapid change, the organization may miss out on its last major opportunity to regain relevance and address its financial situation. – A truly inclusive and open UPU has the power to make the sector more vibrant and globally integrated, fostering growth opportunities for businesses and improved services to citizens. Based on the information available as at 13 October 2020, no existing proposal tabled to Congress addresses all these points as comprehensively as the one presented in this document. 4.3 Membership categories One of the key elements of the proposal is the creation of new membership categories that would enable wider postal sector players to engage more directly in the work of the organization. This would mean UPU member- ship comprising three major categories: – Member countries: this category would continue to include the member states15 that participate fully in the work of the organization (including full voting rights). Such participation would, in particular, encom- pass policy- and regulatory-related matters, general governance and oversight of the Union, as well as the various governmental obligations associated with their being parties to the UPU Acts. – Sector members: this category would comprise entities that operate in business segments in which postal operators are already present (e.g. letters, parcels and financial services), whether or not they have a postal licence. Sector members would, in principle, be able to participate in various activities of the Union and benefit from most of the specific solutions offered by the organization; and – Associate members: this category would comprise entities that do not directly operate international postal services, but are of relevance to the postal sector as defined and regulated by the UPU. They would, in principle, be able to benefit from specific UPU solutions and share their technical expertise in various UPU fora. These various postal stakeholders would thus be grouped according to their level of institutional connection with the organization; from tighter links (member countries) to looser ones (associate members). In the same vein, it must be emphasized that the existence of several categories of membership would by no means divert the UPU from its fundamental intergovernmental nature: sovereign decision-making and treaty-related changes would always lie with member countries. A more detailed list of eligible stakeholders for each category is provided in the next sub-section. 14 In a reform statement issued in 2020, the US Chamber of Commerce suggested creating a new successor organization for all postal operators, so that the UPU can remain fully intergovernmental. 15 As well as the two remaining non-sovereign territories currently classified as UPU member countries. 12 4.4 Eligible stakeholders The category “member countries” would solely comprise the following stakeholders: Member countries repre- sented through their respective governmental and/or regulatory authorities, or through any other entity to which the government of the member country concerned decides to delegate such responsibilities with regard to the UPU. The following stakeholders would, in principle, be eligible to join the UPU as “sector members”: – DOs (privately or publicly owned); – Other domestic postal operators (non-DOs); – Courier and integrator companies; – E-retailers and e-commerce merchants; – Logistics service providers; – Financial service providers. The following stakeholders would in principle be eligible to join the UPU as “associate members”: – Airlines; – Railways and other transport companies; – Manufacturers of postal and postal industry-related solutions; – Customer associations; – Unions or postal service worker associations; – Other civil society organizations concerning the postal sector; – Other stakeholders, subject to pre-defined conditions. – Upon joining the UPU in one of these membership categories, stakeholders would be eligible for access to various UPU solutions (i.e. products and services), as further explained in the next sub-section. 4.5 Eligibility for accessing UPU products and services The UPU’s products and services, also referred to as “solutions”, can be grouped into 10 major groups: 1 Events and meetings of UPU bodies; 2 Treaties and international agreements; 3 Settlement systems; 4 Consultancy and capacity building; 5 Information technology solutions; 6 Standards; 7 Data storage and protection; 8 Research and insights on market trends; 9 Focused analysis on various topical issues; 10 General support and other activities. Each membership category would be eligible to benefit from a range of UPU solutions. There would be three levels of access: – Full eligibility: the corresponding stakeholders would be eligible for full access to the corresponding UPU solutions; 13 – Partial or conditional access: access to the solutions would be possible, but only partially, or if certain conditions (to be determined by the corresponding UPU bodies) were met; – No access: access to the solutions would not possible. This would apply to the different membership categories as follows: – Member countries would have full eligibility for all UPU solutions; – Sector members would be eligible for a wide range of solutions, except for those activities that involve governmental prerogatives, in particular in the area of treaties and international agreements, as well as other areas potentially subject to governmental regulation; – Associate members, owing to their looser institutional link with the organization, would have a more partial and conditional access to UPU solutions. Regardless of the level of access that would apply to each membership category, all stakeholders would be required to comply with the rules and obligations associated with each type of solution, including standardized contractual conditions and payment of fees, where applicable. A more detailed list of applicable products and services for each membership category is provided in Annex A – Table 2. 4.6 Rights and obligations of membership Membership of the UPU would cover a certain number of rights, depending on the membership category. These rights would include: – Definition and amendment of specific rules on access to UPU solutions; – Access to UPU solutions according to the rules defined for each product and service (see details in section 4.5 above); – Access to governmental prerogatives, including the right to vote on treaty-related matters and to appoint the delegates authorized to represent the member country within the UPU; – Involvement in USO-related matters, as designated by member countries; – Overall right to vote on non-treaty matters, e.g. standard-setting (specific aspects to be defined). Only member countries would have the right to define and amend the rules on access to UPU solutions by sector and associate members. They would also be the only membership category with access to governmen- tal prerogatives, including the right to vote on treaty-related matters and to appoint the delegates authorized to represent the member country within the UPU. As for involvement in USO-related matters, this would, in principle, be restricted to member countries and DOs responsible for the fulfilment of the USO. Last but not least, voting rights on non-treaty matters, e.g. the setting of operational standards and other postal matters, would in principle also be applicable to sector members, depending on the rules of each UPU body. In addition, all members would have to abide by a certain number of obligations in the following areas: – Acknowledgment of both rights and obligations of membership; – No objectives/values in conflict with those of the UPU (including the UN Sustainable Development Goals); – Compliance with the general terms and conditions and other rules applicable to each category of UPU solution (including the UPU rules on data protection and security); – Compliance with principles of equal access and non-discriminatory treatment of market players; – In the case of sector and associate members, application for UPU membership approved by govern- mental representatives as a precondition for joining. Further details on rights and obligations of each membership category are provided in Annex A – Tables 3 and 4. 14 4.7 Funding To maintain the financial sustainability of the organization in the process of expansion to include new members, a new funding model would be created with the following sources of funding: – Mandatory membership fees: these would constitute the regular budget of the organization, with two main elements:  Member countries would be required to make payments to the regular budget of the Union, as per the legacy system in place as at 1 October 2020, but without prejudice to any new discussions, such as on the redistribution of contribution units;  Sector and associate members would have to pay annual fees applicable to their corresponding membership category, with the fees to be based on pricing and benchmarking of membership fees; – Voluntary membership fees: these fees would have the purpose of funding any specific extrabudgetary mechanism, such as user-funded bodies; – Direct funding of projects and other payments: this would include any voluntary contribution to finance the Union or fund specific projects; – Purchase of UPU solutions: this would consist of payment for any solution labelled as on-demand, with fees to be determined separately for each product and service. The exact amounts to be paid would be determined at a later stage, following a detailed analysis, which would be aimed at ensuring that pricing remained consistent with market realities as well as with the need to cover the costs of producing and distributing the various UPU solutions. A tabular overview of the funding model is provided in Annex A – Table 5. 4.8 Reporting structure To ensure an appropriate introduction of the new members into the work of the organization, a new reporting structure would also be required, following the principle of efficiency, in particular the need to avoid a structure that is too complex and/or large for the relatively small size of the organization. The UPU would have two councils: – an Executive Council for governmental and regulatory matters; and – a Business Council for business matters. As the successor body of the CA, the Executive Council would ensure the intergovernmental nature of the organization and would deal with matters such as treaties, international agreements, dispute resolution and postal regulation. It would also cover areas related to UPU administration, such as finance, human resources and governance. Participation and decision-making in this body would be reserved to member countries. As the successor body of the POC, the Business Council would enable the organization to be a forum for the wider postal sector. Participation in this council would be open to all membership categories, with the exception of USO-related matters, which would, in principle, be restricted to member countries and DOs responsible for the fulfilment of the USO, both in terms of participation and decision-making. To ensure this clear separation, a dedicated committee for USO (and associated remuneration systems) would be created within this council. A tabular summary of the composition of these councils and of the authorized participation from different mem- bership categories is presented in Annex A – Table 6. 5 Implementation If the proposal package contained in this report is approved by Congress, it will require a number of actions in order to be fully implemented. Subject to final confirmation of the scope of the proposed package mentioned above, this section aims to outline the main amendments to the Acts of the Union deemed necessary for the purposes presented herein, as well as an indicative timeline for their implementation. 15 5.1 Amendments to the Acts of the Union and other internal rules of the organization In principle, the following provisions would have to be created/amended/deleted in order to ensure due imple- mentation of the proposed package: – Amendments to the Constitution (to be adopted by Congress);  Article 1.6bis – theoretical possibility for other sector members to operate postal services;  Article 1.7 – adjustments to the definition of designated operator, particularly in order to refer more clearly to DOs’ statutory obligation to operate “basic” international postal services and fulfil the USO;  Article 2bis – introduction of sector and associate members as a part of the UPU legal framework;  Article 4 – possibility for sector members to entertain exceptional relations with territories not included in the Union, if so permitted by the legislation of their respective member countries;  Article 8 – possibility for sector members to create/form part of restricted unions, if so permitted by the legislation of their respective member countries;  Article 21 – introduction of the principle of financial contributions for sector and associate members;  Article 22 – also reflecting the theoretical possibility for other sector members to operate postal services;  Article 29 – same as above;  Various articles – consequential amendments to reflect the new names of the councils. – Amendments to the General Regulations (to be adopted by Congress);  Article 105 – inclusion of a reference to sector and associate members as de jure observers;  Article 106 – minor redrafting to clarify that only member countries may be members of the Executive Council;  Article 112 – revised, “bicameral” composition of the Business Council (or similar structure) with 48 member countries, plus a number of sector members to be determined in the final version of the proposal to be prepared by April 2021; reference to a statutory “basic services/universal ser- vice obligation” committee whose participation will be open only to member countries and DOs (in the latter case as sector members);  Article 113 – redefinition of certain functions as being under the purview of member countries only;  Article 117ter – definition of the entities potentially eligible to join as sector and associate mem- bers and other associated conditions;  Article 131.2 – International Bureau obligation to maintain lists of sector and associate members;  Article 153.2 – possibility for sector members to participate in arbitrations if so authorized by their respective member countries;  Various articles – consequential amendments to reflect the disbandment of the CC;  Various articles – consequential amendments to reflect the new names of the councils. – Amendments to the Universal Postal Convention and Postal Payment Services Agreement (to be adopted by Congress, or exceptionally via postal ballot between Congresses);  To be confirmed; consequential to the above (probably in terms of allowing certain categories of sector members to operate international postal services as well). – Amendments to the Convention Regulations and to the Postal Payment Services Regulations (to be adopted by the POC);  To be confirmed; consequential to the above (probably in terms of allowing certain categories of sector members to operate international postal services as well). – Amendments to the Rules of Procedure of Congresses (to be adopted by Congress); 16  To be confirmed; consequential to the disbandment of the CC and the introduction of sector and associate members. – Amendments to the Rules of Procedure of the councils (to be adopted by each respective council fol- lowing the relevant amendments to the Constitution and General Regulations).  To be confirmed; consequential to the disbandment of the CC and the introduction of sector and associate members. 5.2 Timeline for implementation Based on the information presented above, the full package containing the proposal is to be formally submitted for approval at the 27th Congress, including the present report as well as amendments to the Acts of the Union as described in the previous sub-section (including higher-level organic provisions in the Constitution and General Regulations, notably on the general principle of opening up, new membership categories and adjust- ments to the bodies of the Union). If approved, the proposal would have the implications outlined in section 4 of this document. Between December 2020 and April 2021, the TF will further work on the details regarding the composition and functions of the Business Council, in particular the proposed number of sector members, their decision- making powers and the corresponding contribution model, as well as on the finalization of the draft amendments to be submitted for adoption by the 27th Congress, as outlined in section 5.1 of this report. 6 Conclusion The task of opening up the UPU to wider postal sector players has eluded numerous Congresses over the past few decades. While digitalization, liberalization, privatization and other macro-trends have accelerated the transformation of societies around the world, the pace of change at the UPU has been much slower. Entire new markets and actors have emerged in areas very much connected with the organization’s mission of facil- itating the communication between the inhabitants of the world, generating wealth and jobs that are beneficial to the well-being of citizens. Yet, the UPU has struggled to more directly integrate this new reality into its daily work. In failing to do so, it has exacerbated its long-term risks of relevance and funding, which remain as acute as ever In this context, the proposal presented in this report constitutes a unique historical opportunity for genuine change. If approved by Congress, it offers the promise of a revamped organization that will finally and com- prehensively address its long-term risks of relevance and funding. Conversely, in the absence of an alternative proposal that presents a comparatively forceful and rapid solution to the UPU’s major challenges, there is a high likelihood that the organization’s future may already be compromised in the short term. 17 Annexes A. Further details on various aspects of the proposal Table 1 – Eligible stakeholders for each membership category Stakeholders Member Sector Associate countries members members Governments (including regulators) Yes No No DOs (whether private or public postal operators) No Yes No E-retailers No Yes No Courier companies No Yes No Logistics service providers No Yes No Financial service providers No Yes No Airlines No No Yes Railways and other transport companies No No Yes Manufacturers of postal and postal No No Yes industry-related solutions Customer associations No No Yes Unions or postal worker associations No No Yes Other civil society organizations concerning the No No Yes postal sector Others, subject to pre-defined conditions No No Yes Table 2 – Products and services accessible to each membership category Solution offered by the UPU Member Sector Associate countries members members 1 – Events/meetings of UPU bodies 1.1 Possibility of attending any events/meetings Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility organized by all UPU bodies, with the potential exception of restricted meetings of standing groups and user-funded subsidiary bodies 1.2 Access to chairing roles, with the exception of Full eligibility Partial or Partial or user-funded subsidiary bodies conditional conditional access access 1.3 Access to contact lists Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or conditional access 1.4 Access to secretariat support, with the Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or exception of ad hoc or value-added secretariat conditional services access 1.5 Possibility of taking part in meetings of the Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility UPU’s councils and their subsidiary bodies 1.6 Possibility of chairing standing groups and task Full eligibility Partial or Partial or forces of the UPU’s councils conditional conditional access access 18 Solution offered by the UPU Member Sector Associate countries members members 1.7 Access to the entire membership of the Union Full eligibility Partial or Partial or (governments, including regulators; operators; conditional conditional e-retailers, etc.) access access 1.8 Secretariat support from the International Full eligibility Partial or Partial or Bureau conditional conditional access access 1.9 Any other event or meeting organized on the Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility premises of the UPU, or under the responsibility of the UPU, and which is not part of the organization’s ordinary schedule (including the provision of infrastructure for anything not directly related to UPU activities) 2 – Treaties and international agreements 2.1 Access to defined UPU legal frameworks as Full eligibility No access No access well as treaty rights and obligations as member countries 2.2 Ability to designate the entities authorized to Full eligibility No access No access issue postage stamps on their respective territories 2.3 Ability to engage governmental agencies Full eligibility Partial or Partial or (including designated operators where they are conditional conditional not a separate legal entity, i.e. they are part of access access the government) in UPU activities 2.4 Access to all the legal frameworks that underpin Full eligibility Partial or Partial or the UPU and to the multilateral framework conditional conditional provided by the UPU (saving time and costs access access compared to bilateral solutions) 2.5 Ability to exchange and/or assist in the provision Full eligibility Partial or Partial or of UPU-defined international postal services conditional conditional with all relevant entities under the umbrella of access access the UPU, including provisions associated with definitions of such services, their associated regulations and relevant inquiry/liability/prohibition rules 2.6 Ability to label international traffic to other Full eligibility Partial or Partial or countries as “postal”, i.e. non-cargo (to benefit conditional conditional from UPU forms/regulations and WCO-defined access access customs facilities under the Kyoto Convention) 2.7 Ability to transit items as international postal Full eligibility Partial or Partial or items throughout the country’s territory conditional conditional access access 2.8 Subject to governmental authorization, ability to Full eligibility Partial or Partial or establish/use ETOEs/IMPCs (unlimited number conditional conditional of IMPC codes for entities of member countries, access access paid for others – Convention article 13 would require amendment) 2.9 Subject to governmental authorization, ability to Full eligibility Partial or No access issue stamps for international postal services conditional (Convention article 6 would require amendment) access 19 Solution offered by the UPU Member Sector Associate countries members members 3 – Settlement systems 3.1 Access to the possibility of invoking dispute Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility settlement provisions 3.2 Membership of one of the UPU’s clearing Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility systems 3.3 Membership of the UPU’s remuneration system Full eligibility Partial or Partial or conditional conditional access access 3.4 On-demand UPU-managed dispute settlement Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or services/mechanism conditional access 4 – Consulting and capacity building 4.1 Access to the possibility of benefiting from Full eligibility Partial or Partial or capacity-building activities conditional conditional access access 4.2 Access to advisory and capacity-building Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility support in operational matters, e.g. EMS, security, transport, customs, quality-of-service improvement, financial inclusion 4.3 Ability to benefit from capacity-building projects Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or funded by the UPU conditional access 4.4 Ability to contribute to capacity-building funds Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility (e.g. QSF) 4.5 On-demand UPU-managed consulting and Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility capacity building 5 – IT solutions 5.1 Access to general IT solutions Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility 5.2 Access to the Postal Technology Centre’s first- Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility level suite of IT solutions 5.3 Access to the EMS Cooperative’s first-level Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility suite of IT solutions 5.4 Access to the Global Monitoring System’s first- Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or level suite of IT solutions conditional access 5.5 Access to the .POST domain Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or conditional access 5.6 Access to other quality of service reporting tools Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or conditional access 5.7 Access to customized developments outside the Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility scope of existing UPU IT solutions 20 Solution offered by the UPU Member Sector Associate countries members members 6 – Standards 6.1 Access to general standards solutions Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility 6.2 Access to IMPC codes and EMS and other Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or standards when transacting with stakeholders of conditional UPU member countries or authorized access companies of non-member countries 6.3 Access to WADP Numbering System standards Full eligibility Partial or No access (register of all official postal stamps) conditional access 6.4 Possibility of promoting and enforcing standards Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or and certification in various areas, such as conditional security, transport and customs access 6.5 Possibility of taking part in and chairing Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or meetings of the UPU’s standards-setting bodies conditional access 6.6 On-demand certification missions by the UPU Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or conditional access 7 – Data storage and protection 7.1 Access to data storage and protection solutions Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility 7.2 Possibility of recording transactions between the Full eligibility Partial or Partial or player and any other stakeholder operating conditional conditional under the UPU’s system (e.g. POST*Net) access access 7.3 Assurance of data storage and protection for Full eligibility Partial or Partial or any such recorded transactions conditional conditional access access 7.4 Customized developments outside the scope of Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or existing data storage and protection solutions conditional access 8 and 9 – Focused analysis, research and insights on market trends 8.1 Access to solutions related to focused analysis, Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility research and insights on market trends 8.2 Access to the UPU’s first-level suite of analytics Full eligibility Partial or Partial or on the transactions between the player and any conditional conditional other stakeholder operating under the UPU’s access access system (e.g. using POST*Net data) 8.3 Second-level suite of analytics Full eligibility Partial or Partial or conditional conditional access access 8.4 On-demand analytical services Full eligibility Partial or Full eligibility conditional access 21 Solution offered by the UPU Member Sector Associate countries members members 10 – General support or other activities 10.1 Access to the possibility of benefiting from Full eligibility Full eligibility Full eligibility general support or other activities 10.2 Access to the UPU’s first-level suite of support Full eligibility Full eligibility Partial or services, including legal, logistics, executive conditional office, etc., in dealings with other stakeholders access that are operating in the UPU’s framework Table 3 – Rights applicable to each membership category Rights Member Sector Associate countries members members Definition and amendment of specific rules on access Yes No No to UPU products and services Access to UPU solutions according to the rules Yes Yes Yes defined for each product and service (see details in the section on eligibility to access products and services) Access to governmental prerogatives, including the Yes No No right to vote on treaty-related matters and appoint delegates authorized to represent the member country at the UPU Involvement in USO-related matters, as designated Yes USO providers No by member countries only Overall right to vote on non-treaty matters, e.g. Yes Yes No standard-setting (specific aspects to be defined) Table 4 – Obligations applicable to each membership category Obligations Member Sector Associate countries members members Agreement to both rights and obligations of Yes Yes Yes membership No objectives/values in conflict with those of the UPU Yes Yes Yes (including the UN Sustainable Development Goals) Compliance with rules of each category of products Yes Yes Yes and services (including UPU rules on data protection) Compliance with principles of equal access and non- Yes Yes Yes discriminatory treatment of market players Application for UPU membership approved by N/A Yes Yes government representatives before joining 22 Table 5 – Funding model – overview Source Member countries Sector Associate members members Mandatory membership fees (regular budget) Payments to the Annual fees for the regular budget of the corresponding Union, as per the membership category system in place, (fees to be based on without prejudice to pricing and benchmarking new discussions of membership fees) Voluntary membership fees Membership fees to fund any specific extrabudgetary mechanism, such as user-funded bodies Direct funding of projects and other payments Any voluntary contribution to finance the Union or fund specific projects Purchase of products and services Payment for any product and service labelled as on-demand (fees to be determined separately for each product and service) Table 6 – Authorized participation of each membership category in the work of the UPU’s councils Council Committee or sub-body Member Sector Associate countries members members Executive Council Committee on treaties, Yes No No international agreements and dispute resolution Committee on UPU Yes No No administration (e.g. finance, HR and governance) Committee on postal Yes No No regulation Business Council Committee on universal Yes USO providers No service obligation and only remuneration Committee on development Yes Yes Yes cooperation and capacity building Committee on standards, Yes Yes Yes certification and supply chain integration Committee on IT solutions and Yes Yes Yes digitalization Committee on data storage Yes Yes Yes and protection Committee on postal Yes Yes Yes economics, research and analytics 23 B. Work conducted by the TF between March and October 2020 Context As instructed by the CA at its February 2020 session, the task force on the opening up of the UPU to wider postal sector players, which had been constituted in October 2019, continued its work between March and August 2020, with the aim of preparing a proposal for consideration by Congress. On this basis, a more detailed timeline was drafted, but remained subject to developments resulting from the COVID-19 crisis. Phase 1 – Initiation and planning In this phase, the TF was expected to complete two deliverables: constitute TF membership, ensuring full geographical representation (by 27 March); and confirm the deliverables and timeline (by 9 April). Both were completed. The task force was constituted at the CA, ensuring full geographical representation, with the aim of presenting a proposal to the 27th Congress on three main areas: institutional change; opening up of products and services; and a timeline for implementation. Subsequently, the deliverables and timelines were drafted by the Co-Chairs and secretariat, and circulated to participants. A revised version was re-circulated, taking into account the impact of COVID-19 and the related postponement of the 2020 Congress. Phase 2 – Institutional benchmarks and opening up of products and services The second phase consisted of five deliverables: send a questionnaire to TF participants for inputs on the three main areas mandated by the CA (by 10 April); receive their responses (by 30 May); compile inputs by the secretariat and hold a conference call with the Co-Chairs (by 15 June); and hold a conference call with all TF participants (by 20 June). All deliverables were completed. A questionnaire was drafted and sent to TF participants in order to gather further information on the three main elements comprising the mandate of the reconstituted TF (institutional change; opening up of products and services; and a timeline for implementation). The survey consisted of six questions, and built on past information while seeking additional detailed input and knowledge from TF participants. At the request of participants, the deadline for the receipt of questionnaire responses was extended from 30 April to 30 May. In all, 71% of the TF participants responded to the questionnaire, with representation from all geographical regions of the UPU. A detailed report on the results of the questionnaire was prepared, including areas such as definitions of proposed membership, stakeholders to be considered in each membership category, and UPU solutions for different members. In addition, many TF participants requested the International Bureau to provide further information on one of the questions related to governance models in peer UN agencies. An additional report was thus prepared on this topic. Furthermore, a number of virtual coordination meetings were held between the Co-Chairs and the secretariat to prepare for the conference call with TF participants. The latter was held on 24 June to ensure maximum attendance. During the call, the results of the questionnaire and the detailed report on the UN benchmark were presented, along with other sources of input, i.e. proposals from the CC and Indonesia, as well as elements for the way forward. Copies of the presentation and all related proposals were made available in the UPU workspaces. TF participants appreciated the work conducted up to that point, and requested additional time to provide written feedback on the presentation. Therefore, all materials were circulated with a deadline for inputs set for 6 July. After receipt of the inputs, work progressed towards building a first draft proposal and subsequent steps in the timeline. 24 Phase 3 – Proposal preparation The focus of the third phase was on preparing and refining the proposal to be presented at the 2020 Congress. The first presentation of the draft was ready by the beginning of September 2020, and a conference call was held with TF participants to discuss it on 7 September 2020. Any additional inputs from TF participants were subsequently integrated into a first draft proposal, to be presented to the CA in December 2020. Moreover, between December 2020 and April 2021, the TF is expected to work further on the details regarding the composition and functions of the Business Council, in particular the proposed number of sector members, their decision-making powers and the corresponding contribution model. Phase 4 – Congress decision The final phase of the work of the TF will be the presentation of the proposal at the 27th Congress. C. Results of the consultation with postal sector stakeholders (2019) In late 2019, a consultation was launched on opening up the UPU to wider postal sector players. The survey comprised four questionnaires, one for each main category of postal sector stakeholders with an interest in the opening up of the UPU: 1) governments; 2) regulators; 3) DOs; and 4) other private sector stakeholders. Overall, a total of 235 stakeholders responded, including 59 governments, 45 regulators, 115 DOs, and 16 private sector stakeholders. Regional representation was relatively balanced, with 56 responses from Africa, 68 from the Americas, 38 from Eastern Europe and Northern Asia, 38 from Southern Asia and Oceania and 35 from Western Europe. The consultation delved into a wide range of issues including government policies and organization of the sector, regulatory frameworks in place, status of the universal service obligation, role and involvement of designated operators and other players, willingness to open up the UPU, potential players to join the organization, solutions to be opened, types of participation and related terms and conditions. Government policies and organization of the sector Of the countries surveyed, 76% have a national policy in place for the postal sector. Among the policies in place, over 80% encourage the participation of multiple players. Indeed, there are numerous objectives pursued by these policies, but the most frequent ones are affordable access, universal geographical coverage and the same quality standards to all customers, as well as fair competition and free entry into the market of postal services. Probably as a consequence of the high prevalence of policies that encourage multiple players, there are a plethora of stakeholders operating in the sector, such as courier companies, logistics service providers, airlines, and railways and transport companies. Unsurprisingly, nearly all respondents consider letters and parcels as “postal”. Regulatory frameworks in place When it comes to the responsibility for regulating the postal sector, the most common configuration is for the regulatory authority to operate independently (80% of cases). In 58% of countries surveyed, the market is liberalized with several postal service providers. In terms of licensing requirements, 71% of regulators surveyed require other players to obtain a licence in order to supply postal services, while 13% do not. Moreover, as regards geographical scope, 76% of licences give the right to operate throughout the country, and 59% apply to the international business. Business areas applicable under the licences mainly include letter, parcel and express delivery services (between 68 and 74%), as well as letter-box/locker/pick-up and postal payment services (29%). Finally, when it comes to reserved services for DOs, there are a wide variety of cases, such as letters under a certain weight, USO services, postal payment services, and even all postal services in some cases. 25 Status of the universal service obligation According to the respondents to the regulators’ questionnaire, 89% of countries have formally defined the USO with a legal or regulatory basis. In most cases, the objectives covered by such definitions include ensuring full geographical coverage of postal services throughout the country (96%), affordable access to postal services (93%) and/or the same standard of quality for all consumers (82%). Meanwhile, the definition of the USO mainly covers letter delivery services (91%) and parcel delivery services (80%), but areas such as letter-box/locker/pick-up (33%), government/citizen services (24%) or postal payment services (24%) may also be included in some cases. In 96% of cases, the DO is the only operator responsible for the USO. When it comes to funding of the USO, there are a wide variety of mechanisms in place. Although subsidies to the DO are the most common feature (39%), contributions to a USO fund (32%) or direct investments through revenues generated by the operators (27%) are not rare. Role and involvement of designated operators The status of DOs can vary considerably from country to country. The most common profile is for them to be part of the public administration, e.g. as a government department or entity (34%); as a public company, listed or not (28%); or as a statutory corporation under public law (26%). In addition, when it comes to their interaction with other players, a majority of DOs already collaborate with airlines (88%), financial service providers (61%), courier companies (57%), unions or postal workers’ associations (56%) and logistics service providers (51%). DOs enter into such collaborations for a variety of reasons, including enabling interconnection for end-to-end delivery (73%), increasing revenues (69%), providing additional services to customers (64%) or reducing operating costs (51%). Involvement of other players Of the other players that responded to the survey, the majority are composed of logistics service providers (43.8%), followed by courier companies (12.5%), as well as manufacturers of postal and postal industry-related solutions (12.5%). These stakeholders collaborate with a variety of other players, including e-retailers (87%), logistics service providers (87%), DOs (73%), courier companies (67%) and airlines (53%). The most frequent areas of collaboration are parcel delivery services (87%), letter-box/locker/pick-up (60%), letter delivery (53%) and express delivery services (47%). The main reasons for this collaboration include attempting better interconnection/end-to-end delivery (80%), increasing revenues (67%), providing additional services to customers (60%) and reducing operating costs (60%). Willingness to open up the UPU The majority of respondents in all categories confirmed their willingness to open up the UPU to external players, with percentages of 54%, 64%, 77% and 80% among DOs, governments, regulators and other stakeholders, respectively. Only a minority said no to the idea of opening up (27%, 17%, 7% and 7% respectively for the same groups). The remainder expressed their willingness to consider alternatives and/or study the matter further. Other players that could join the UPU According to the respondents from all groups, the preferred types of other players to be allowed into the UPU would be airlines, customs organizations, courier companies, logistics service providers, e-retailers and manufacturers of postal solutions (between 93 and 122 responses each). However, there was also a sizeable portion of respondents that would like to see the UPU welcome financial service providers, railways and transport companies and regulators of other industries (between 66 and 77 each). 26 Other UPU solutions that could be opened up According to the respondents, among the main elements of the UPU’s value proposition for new players, one should mention affordable technical solutions on governmental, regulatory and operational matters, as well as participation in UPU meetings and forums (138 responses each). Many respondents (93) also see the UPU’s wide range of data and analytics as another important element of the offering. In addition, there were 52 responses highlighting other products and services or providing additional details about their demand for those cited above. Types of participation and related terms and conditions for these new players When it comes to defining the type of membership or the modality of participation of these new players, respondents provided a wide a variety of responses. But, as the response was provided in free text, it is difficult to provide summarized indications on the preferences. However, the detailed information is provided in the TF workspace (https://bit.ly/2SO7w3Q). The same comment applies to the terms and conditions for the accession of these new players. The results of the survey were presented in more detail in the TF report presented to the CA in February 2020 (CA 2020.1–Doc 11). D. Other reference information Table 7 – Number of members of the Consultative Committee (CC) since its inception (2004) Year 2004 2008 2012 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Number of 19 19 22 15 14 13 13 14 14 members UPU International Bureau To: All UPU member countries Weltpoststrasse 4 3015 BERNE SWITZERLAND T +41 31 350 31 11 F +41 31 350 31 10 www.upu.int Contact: Mr Mutua Muthusi T +41 31 350 31 33 Berne, 5 January 2021 [email protected] Reference: 6850(DIRCAB.STRAT)1137 Subject: Participation of member countries in the task force on opening up the UPU to wider postal sector players Dear Sir/Madam, At its October 2019 session (S6), the UPU’s Council of Administration (CA) approved the creation of a task force to examine the specific topic of opening up the UPU to wider postal sector players and to provide rec- ommendations on the extent, elements and conditions involved. At the conclusion of its February 2020 session, the CA decided to give the task force a mandate to continue its work between March and August 2020, with the aim of presenting a proposal to the 27th Congress on three main areas: institutional change; opening up of products and services; and a timeline for implementation. Despite the disruption and delays caused by COVID-19, a considerable amount of work was completed up to October 2020, building on a wealth of input from member countries and other postal sector stakeholders. The associated report (CA 2020.2–Doc 11) contains the results of the work conducted by the task force since its inception. During its most recent session in December 2020, the CA approved the extension of the task force’s mandate until the April 2021 CA session (S9), and invited all UPU member countries and observers to participate in its work. As a follow-up to this decision, all member countries and observers are thus invited to review the report, avail- able at documents.upu.int/Bodies/2020/CA/CA%20PLEN/MEETING/CA%20PLEN%202020.2/Doc%2011/ EN/ca_plen-2%20_d011.pdf, and provide the following: a Comments on the proposals contained in the document; b Suggestions on any improvements in specific areas geared towards achieving results in the work assigned to the task force; c Any other comments that will help progress the work of the task force. 2 Any input should be sent to [email protected] by 25 January 2021 at the latest. I hope that you will be able to participate actively in the work of this important task force. Yours faithfully, Bishar A. Hussein Director General
Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium dokumendiregister →