Ref. Ares(2019)3071424 - 08/05/2019
Policy expectations for a Joint Action on the implementation of digitally enabled
integrated person-centred care
At the EU level, in the Communication on "enabling the digital transformation of health and
care in the Digital Single Market"1 the Commission commits to measures for building the
capacity of national and regional authorities to organise and deliver integrated person-centred
care. Fulfilling this commitment will address the need for technical assistance to the demand
side of health reforms and digital transformation of healthcare. This is in recognition of the
fact that the transformation of health systems is complex and one of the pre-conditions to
achieve it is having the required knowledge and capacity on how to design, and successfully
implement digitally enabled integrated person-centred care solutions.
The aim of this Joint Action is to focus on reinforcing the capacity of care authorities to
address successfully important aspects such as:
change management and re-organisation of the existing care models
embedding digital technologies and tools in care services
re-organisation of patient pathways
health workforce roles and skills with digital technologies and data
building the capacity of individuals and communities to participate in the care process
citizen empowerment
use of patient reported data
new payment methods
and performance assessment of new care models
The Joint Action shall aim to achieve the above through best practice transfer and with
practical means, for example, with activities to prepare the local environment for
implementation and purposely designed “twinning actions” such as dedicated seminars and
workshops, study visits, short-term secondment visits, face-to-face meetings, mentoring from
experts in the domain, availability of tools and knowledge resources etc.
This Joint Action shall involve entities that are directly organising and delivering care at
national and/or regional or local level. This will be one of the key elements to ensure it
reaches the objectives stated above. Particular attention will be paid to this element when
preparing the Joint Action.
The Joint Action is expected to build upon input from earlier work in the EU Health
Programme, the EU Framework Programmes for Research and Innovation as well as EU
initiatives such as the European Innovation Partnership on Active and Health Ageing (EIP
AHA). Examples include, for instance:
1
COM(2018) 233 final
Tools for deploying integrated care stemming from EU projects (e.g. ACT@Scale and
SCIROCCO), SANTE's Integrated Care Resource Centre and the work of the EIP
AHA
Guidance on how to design, implement and assess integrated care, from the work of
the EU expert group on Health Systems Performance Assessment
Guidance on the transfer and scaling-up of good practices, developed by the Joint
Action CHRODIS
Guidance for best practice transfer derived from the twinning projects SCIROCCO
Exchange and VIGOUR
Guidance concerning the management of multi-morbidities produced by the Joint
Actions CHRODIS and CHRODIS Plus
Suggestions regarding health workforce planning and skill-mix, prepared by the Joint
Action on Health Workforce Planning and Forecasting and the project SEPEN
Recommendations and tools from the current Joint Action eHAction
Following the meeting of the Steering Group on Health Promotion and Prevention and
Management on Non-Communicable Diseases (SGPP)2, the transfer of a number of good
practices will take place with the support of this Joint Action. The selected practices are the
following, with short descriptions provided in the accompanying document:
Basque Health Strategies in ageing and chronicity: integrated care (Spain),
Catalan open innovation hub on ICT-supported integrated care services for chronic
patients (Spain),
The OptiMedis Model – Population-Based Integrated Care (as implemented in
Gesundes Kinzigtal) (Germany) and
Digital roadmap towards an integrated health care sector (Region of Southern
Denmark, Denmark)
Activities under this Joint Action are expected to:
1) Reinforce the capacity of health authorities to successfully address important
aspects of health system transformation, in particular the transition to digitally-
enabled, integrated, person-centred care. This will be through transfer of knowledge,
technical support and use of tools and guidance derived from collaborative activities at
EU level. In particular, the Joint Action will give the interested authorities (the “next
adopters”) an opportunity to establish working contacts with owners of the above-
mentioned practices who have experience in transforming their health systems (the
“early adopters”). The participating entities from the “next adopter” authorities
should be organisations with direct responsibility for organising and delivering
care. The Joint Action will support activities enabling contact between the “next
2
Minutes of the SGPP meetings are published on this page:
https://ec.europa.eu/health/non_communicable_diseases/events_en#anchor0
adopters” and the “early adopters” to learn how to prepare and execute the complex
task of health system reform. These activities shall result in improving the capabilities
of the “next adopters” to implement in their respective health systems the practices
chosen by the SGPP (or their significant elements).
2) Support the best practice transfer from the systems of the “early adopters” to the
ones of the “next adopters”. Such transfers will need preparation of the latter, like
modification of their organisational structure, new financial arrangements, different
allocation of tasks to particular health professionals, implementation of appropriate
ICT solutions etc. This shall happen with the help and experience of the “early
adopters” in transforming health systems and the profound knowledge of the “next
adopters” of the local context of their respective systems. Exchanges between both
sides will be possible thanks to various means like designed “twinning actions” such
as dedicated seminars and workshops, study visits, short-term secondment visits, face
to face meetings, mentoring from experts in the domain, availability of tools and
knowledge resources etc. As a result, during the Joint Action, pilot projects
implementing the above-listed practices chosen by the SGPP (or their significant
elements) should be carried out in the systems of the “next adopters”. If Member State
authorities responsible for organising and delivering care (“next adopters”) decide to
scale-up the pilots after the end of the Joint Action, their increased capacity to
implement (realised in point 1 above) will enable them to do so.
Description of selected Good Practices on digitally-enabled, integrated,
person-centred care
Title of the practice Basque Health Strategies in ageing and chronicity: integrated care
Owner(s) of the Basque Government Department of Health. Contact person: Esteban de
practice Manuel Keenoy. Director of Kronikgune:
[email protected]
Location of Basque Country, Spain
implementation
Target group Frail adults and Patients with multi-morbidities
Number of people 12,000 people receive the services of the multi-morbidity care pathway. The
served by the practice target for 2019 is 18,000 patients.
Short description It is a population model focus based on preventive interventions, patient
empowerment, and personalised medical care, with emphasis towards
continuity of care, security, adherence and improving the patient
experience. It includes “Integrated Care Organisations” (ICO) with Joint
Governance bodies for primary care and hospital, with a defined population
catchment area, multidimensional assessment and action in people aged 70
or older (Care Plan for the Elderly). It includes risk stratification and care
plans based on needs of complex patient, new nursing roles such as liaison
nurses and case managers, safety in polypharmacy management, patient
empowerment and self-management and social and health coordination. It
is supported by an eHealth strategy and a 24x7 Nursing Call Centre.
Level of care Integration of structural (ICO) and care pathways. Integration takes place at
integration disease management, case management or population-levels. There is a
defined strategy for coordination of health and social care.
ICT technologies used Web Portals, Unified Electronic Health Record, Electronic Prescription,
Personal Health Folder, Telemonitoring (both telehealth and telecare),
mHealth, Risk Stratification and Data Analytics (Business Intelligence)
Evidence of impact Data of January-June 2018 (comparison in % with January-June 2017):
91,310 calls made to the eHealth centre (4.5% increase)
11,580 Patients in Telemonitoring Programmes (18.92% increase)
1,183,026 web appointments (13.21% increase)
981,849 telephone visits in Primary Care (3.27% decrease)
152,857 telephone visits in hospitals (14.3% increase)
265,585 accesses to the Personal Health Folder (42.4% increase)
66,438 digital consultations between professionals from primary and
specialized care (33% increase)
2016 data show 12.2% less hospital days for multi-morbid patients
(MMP) and a MMP Readmission rate decreased by 16.7%
Lessons learnt Account for stakeholders' needs when defining organisational models.
New care pathways have to be integrated into day to day practice.
Involvement of decision-makers facilitates new organisation and working
procedures and encourages up-taking new responsibilities.
eHealth key strategy: unified EHR, ePrescription, eHealth Call Centre…
Learning curve: It takes time and resources, facilitate them!
Links for detailed http://ec.europa.eu/research/innovation-union/pdf/active-healthy-
information ageing/how_to.pdf (pages 90-92)
1
https://www.scirocco-project.eu/basque-country-b6-care-plan-for-the-elderly/
https://www.act-at-scale.eu/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/ACT@Scale-Telehealth-
and-Care-Coordination-Lessons-Learned-WHINN-2017.pdf (pages 12-13)
https://www.scirocco-project.eu/basque-country-b5-design-implementation-of-
interventions-aimed-at-improving-the-safety-of-prescription/
Title of the practice Catalan open innovation hub on ICT-supported integrated care services for
chronic patients
Owner(s) of the practice AQuAS - Toni Dedeu, MD, PhD (
[email protected])
IDIBAPS - Josep Roca, MD, PhD (
[email protected])
Location of Region of Catalonia (7.5M citizens), Spain (ES)
implementation
Target group Chronic patients with focus on multimorbidity management and on
coordination with social support and dependence
Number of people Whole population, focus on Complex Chronic Patients (CCP) and Advanced
served by the practice Care Disease (ACD): 210,000 patients, 66% coverage. Full coverage in 2020.
Short description Core targets of the Catalan Health Plan 2016-2020 are: i) maturity of
comprehensive digital health services, ii) consolidation of achievements of
the period 2011-2015; and, iii) multilevel clinical risk assessment with a
preventive approach considering Adjusted Morbidity Groups (GMA) as the
population-health tool. Within this umbrella, innovative practices
continuously emerge both for testing and large scale deployment. Five
selected examples are:
- Collaborative self-management services promoting healthy lifestyles.
- Programme for complex chronic and frail patients.
- Complex patient management linking tertiary care and community.
- Healthcare support programmes for nursing homes.
- Integrated care for admission avoidance of subacute and frail patients.
Level of care integration Encompasses both vertical (specialised vs. community-based care) and
horizontal (healthcare vs. social support) integrations. Combines a
population-health orientation with a collaborative adaptive case
management approach.
ICT technologies used Fully deployed: i) regional Health Information Exchange platform (HC3), ii)
Personal Health Folder (La Meva Salut); iii) ePrescription; and, iv)
Population-based registries & GMA scoring system. In development: Multi-
level clinical predictive modelling & Clinical/Patient Decision Support
Systems (CDSS/PDSS).
Evidence of impact - Health-preserved expect. survival to expect. survival ratio: from 78 to
(2011-2015) 82.1%
- Percentage reduction of referrals to specialised care: - 50%
- Reduction of hospitalisations: - 7,500 admissions
- Reduction of 30-day re-admission rate in chronic patients: -9% (13% cases)
- Reduction of emergency room admissions in chronic patients: -40%
- Reduction in mortality rate of cardiovascular and respiratory disorders: -
15%
- Improvement of activity of home hospitalisation: + 53% (12,600 cases/yr.)
- Improvement of activity of palliative care: 100% coverage
2
- Improvement of coverage of ePrescription: 97% population
Lessons learnt - Promote ICT-supported value-generating services with a preventive focus.
- Develop & apply innovative evaluation methods in real world settings.
- Develop multilevel subject-specific risk predictive modelling feeding
CDSS/PDSS.
- Develop & implement cloud-based computing environments.
- Refine application of the regulatory frame for evaluation in real-world
settings.
Links for detailed NEXES/MECASS:
information http://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC93931/lfna270
56enn.pdf
http://ec.europa.eu/research/innovation-union/pdf/active-healthy-
ageing/how_to.pdf (p. 100-104)
NEXTCARE (deployment programme of five initiatives, COMRDI15-1-0016,
2016-2019):
http://www.nextcarecat.cat/publications.htm
Catalan Health Plan 2011-2015:
http://salutweb.gencat.cat/web/.content/home/el_departament/pla_de_sa
lut/documents/arxius/health_plan_english.pdf
Catalan Health Plan 2016-2020:
http://salutweb.gencat.cat/web/.content/home/el_departament/Pla_salut/
pla_salut_2016_2020/Documents/Pla_salut_Catalunya_2016_2020.pdf
Title of the practice The OptiMedis Model - Population-Based Integrated Care (as implemented
in Gesundes Kinzigtal)
Owner(s) of the OptiMedis AG, Hamburg, Germany. Represented by Dr Oliver Gröne, PhD
practice MSc, Vice-Chairman of the Board, OptiMedis.
Location of Germany (Kinzigtal, Hamburg, Werra-Meißner)
implementation
Target group The model focuses on population health management, addressing both major
chronic diseases groups as well as patients at-risk in the community
Number of people Current coverage Kinzigtal: 30,000. Current coverage Hamburg: 50,000.
served by the practice Werra-Meißner: scale-up target: 35,000 (2019)
Short description OptiMedis AG is a management company of integrated care networks,
providing advanced data analytics and designing innovative care models with
a focus on population health management. Its aim is to achieve the Quadruple
Aim, improving population health, improving the patient experience of care,
reducing unnecessary costs and ensuring provider satisfaction. The basis of its
work is a shared savings contract with insurers and a model including strong
stakeholder engagement, electronic integration across providers, patient
involvement and empowerment, and data-driven management. The model
focuses on patients with high needs and high costs, but also emphasises
prevention, health promotion and public health to generate value for the
population in the long run.
Level of care Integration of primary care and specialist care, nursing home care and
integration (expected from 2019) hospital care under an innovative regional health care
budget model. Integration Level: population-oriented integrated care
3
ICT technologies used Electronic records shared between primary care physicians and specialists,
comprehensive data warehouse infrastructure to run advanced data analytics
(algorithms to indicate over- and under-utilisation, prediction tools).
Evidence of impact External scientific evaluation: Longitudinal study with non-randomised control
group based on health insurers’ claims data from the years 2004–2011.
Fifteen out of the 18 indicators related to overuse or underuse; three related
to an outcome, namely avoidable hospital stays, the appearance of fractures
in patients with osteoporosis, and mortality. Two out of 5 indicators for
overuse and 2 out of 10 for underuse showed significant improvement for the
intervention population relative to the control group. The risk of a fracture in
patients with osteoporosis (HR: 0.809; 95 % CI: 0.740 to 0.885; p < 0.0001)
and mortality (HR: 0.944; 95% CI; 0.899-0.991; p = 0.0194) were significantly
lower in the Kinzigtal population. No negative trends were found. Total cost
savings from 2007-2016: €41.7 million (yearly costs savings around 5%).
Lessons learnt Start up investment needed to cover operations in the first 2-3 years, then
sustainable business model based on shared savings contract
Regional integrated care network becomes a test-space for a wide range
of digital & health innovations and public health interventions
Possible to reach the Quadruple Aim, but importance of advanced data
analytics to support every system change
Links for detailed http://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC93763/jrc93763.pdf
information https://healthpolicy.duke.edu/sites/default/files/atoms/files/germany_25jan2017.pdf
https://www.local.gov.uk/sites/default/files/documents/kinzigtal-funding-flows-a-
3fc.pdf
Title of the practice Digital roadmap towards an integrated health care sector
Owner(s) of the Representing the Region of Southern Denmark and the initiatives is The
practice Health Innovation Centre of Southern Denmark. Project Manager Lise Døj-
Bendixen is the official contact person.
Location of The initiatives are all located within the Region of Southern Denmark in
implementation Denmark
Target group The initiatives all target patients with chronic conditions
Number of people 540,000 as we include all citizens in the Region that are in contact with the
served by the practice hospital during a year
Short description The overall roadmap consists of different parts of an integrated and digital
patient-centred approach. The foundation is the SAM:BO, which is a regional
collaboration agreement between all actors in the health care sector in the
Region. The goal of the agreement is to ensure cohesive and integrated
patient experiences and the result is among other elements patient care
pathways, which are based on nationally adopted standards with more than
65,000 standardised electronic messages transmitted daily in the Region. On
top of this foundation are a number of services, such as the Generic
Telemedicine Platform, Digital Health Centre, Tele-COPD and Tele Psychiatry.
The common feature is using technology to bring more flexibility and quality
to the patients as well as using the clinical resources better.
Level of care In the overall initiative the aim is to involve all parts of the health care sector,
integration including hospitals, municipalities providing social care, general practitioners
4
and patients. This falls under Population-oriented integrated care.
ICT technologies used Standardised electronic messages connect the different Electronic Health
Records in the three sectors and are communicated to the patients through
national platforms, portals or applications. Telemonitoring is also used.
Evidence of impact - 59% of patients with diabetes have healthier eating habits after using
Digital Patient Education and the solution is more cost-effective than
traditional patient education.
- In a COPD-telemedicine project it was found that after 28 days the
readmission rate dropped 14%, and the length of readmission was
reduced by 1.43 days.
- In Mastermind, a tele-psychiatric solution, in total 29% of patients were
reported to experience a reduction in depressive symptoms.
Lessons learnt - Important to have organisational agreements in place first
- Participatory design is of value when designing patient solutions
- A common infrastructure is an important back-bone
- Innovation should be driven from the clinic
- Cultural change takes time
Links for detailed - http://www.healthcaredenmark.dk/ (learn more about Danish healthcare)
information - Tele-COPD
- Digital Health Centre
- http://mastermind-project.eu/ (Mastermind project)
- https://gtp-rsyd.dk/geri-toolbox/ (The geriatric tool-box project based on
The Generic Telemedicine Platform)
- https://www.regionsyddanmark.dk/wm228983 (The Region of Southern
Denmark)
- https://www.medcom.dk/medcom-in-english (MedCom - infrastructure
provider)
5
Ref. Ares(2019)3071424 - 08/05/2019
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
HEALTH AND FOOD SAFETY DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
Public health, country knowledge, crisis management
Crisis management and preparedness in health
Annex - Policy expectations for a Joint Action to strengthen health preparedness
and response to biological and chemical terror attacks
The Joint Action aims to strengthen health preparedness and response to terrorist attacks
across the health, security and civil protection sectors, focusing on biological and
chemical agents.
At EU level, Decision 1082/2013/EU on serious cross-border threats to health provides
the framework to improve preparedness and to strengthen the response capacities to
health emergencies of biological, chemical, environmental and unknown origin. The EU
is an important security actor as codified in numerous policy frameworks, e.g. civil
protection, health security, food security, infrastructure protection, hybrid threats and
disaster relief. Key initiatives have been adopted recently at the EU level to prevent and
prepare for terrorist attacks. In particular, security threats are addressed in the context of
the European Agenda on Security1 and the Security Union. The Commission
Communication on an EU Action Plan to enhance preparedness against chemical,
biological, radiological and nuclear security risks2, the 2016 Joint Communication on the
Joint Framework on countering hybrid threats3 and the Joint Communication of 2018 on
increasing resilience and bolstering capacities to address hybrid threats4, specifically
address many security threats.
Following the 2016 terrorist attacks in Paris and subsequent attacks in cities across
Europe, the Health Security Committee was exchanging lessons learned with regards to
health sector preparedness for terrorism, emergency planning, coordination mechanisms
and damage control practices, including psychological support. The Health Security
Committee reflected on challenges and action areas under the EU health security
framework based on the ‘Background paper on health preparedness and response to
terror attacks’ developed by the Commission with Member States.
The aim of the Joint Action is to improve:
1. Preparedness for biological and chemical attacks;
2. Threat detection and risk assessment for health related terrorism acts;
3. Bridging between the public health, security and civil protection sector partners;
4. Health systems response including diagnosis and treatment of patients exposed to
biological and chemical agents;
5. Availability and rapid response including the deployment of medical
countermeasures across borders;
1
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/cmsdata/125863/EU%20agenda%20on%20security.pdf
2
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=COM:2017:610:FIN
3
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A52016JC0018
4
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/ga/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52018JC0016
6. Implementation of non-pharmaceutical control measures, to avoid or mitigate the
disruption to societal functions, the free movement of people and goods and
economic losses;
7. Risk and crisis communication, including communication lines with the security,
civil protection and other critical sectors;
8. Rapid information exchange, consultation, and coordination within and between
Member States.
The Joint Action will focus on biological and chemical agents, considering the EU list of
high risk biological agents, including those which are known to have been weaponised as
well as risk/threat assessments indicating agents that terrorists are interested in.
An effective response requires preparedness in terms of coordination between the health
and other sectors; clear command and control mechanisms regularly tested; and the
capacity to rapidly mobilize health workers, health-care providers, emergency
responders, law enforcement and security services.
The overall objective of this Joint Action is to address gaps in health preparedness and
the urgent need to strengthen cross-sectoral work with the security, civil protection and
other relevant sectors, in order to effectively respond to security events, involving
chemical, biological and hybrid threats.
The Joint Action will build on work done by relevant projects and exercises under the
Health Programme. In particular, it will collaborate closely with the Joint Action
"Strengthened International Health Regulations and Preparedness in the EU" (SHARP)
and the Joint Action "Healthy Gateways" and contribute to the objectives of the Security
Union and the EU CBRN Action Plan.
Activities under this Joint Action may include:
• Sharing experience and guidelines between Member States, particularly using
experience of mass events across European cities;
• Developing guidelines for risk/threat assessments and joint incident evaluation
with the security and civil protection sectors;
• Mapping out key laboratory and specialised treatment capacities, improving the
availability and rapid deployment of essential medical countermeasures, and
developing mechanisms for cross-sectoral collaboration;
• Developing and organizing targeted trainings on damage control techniques to
improve health system preparedness and response to terrorist attacks, and inter-
sectoral capacity building;
• Developing/updating clinical guidelines for the recognition and case management
of highly pathogenic infectious diseases, or exposure to chemical agents;
• Cross-sectoral capacity building through exercises, trainings, and developing
networks in relation to crisis preparedness and response to key bio and chemical
agents and mass gatherings;
• Assessing and supporting crisis management including emergency operations,
non-pharmaceutical countermeasures and risk communication.
2
Work should focus on investing in strengthening collective preparedness and response
capacities against terror attacks in the EU. This includes improving Member States´
health systems’ readiness and response capacities related to the rapid mobilization of
resources, diagnosis, field and hospital treatment, and cross-sectoral support and
coordination.
The recent terrorist attacks across Europe and globally highlighted both gaps and
successful strategies in preparedness and response to terrorism. The Joint Action will
ensure that the Member States of the European Union have access to good practice from
across Europe and beyond and that the lessons learned from research, previous joint
actions, exercises and experience from the serious terrorist incidents will be made
available to improve cross-sectoral preparedness to withstand terrorist attacks.
3
Ref. Ares(2019)3071424 - 08/05/2019
Joint Actions 2019 – ANNEX 2
Eligibility criteria and nomination of
competent authorities in the Joint Actions 2019
Introduction: what is a joint action (JA) in the context of the Third EU health
Programme?
A joint action is a collaborative action among countries participating in the EU Health
Programme (participating countries) to develop, share, refine and test tools, methods and
approaches to specific health issues, and engage in capacity building in key areas of interest.
Due to its clear Union added value, a Joint Action is co-financed by the European
Commission and the participating competent authorities.
1. Criteria for financial contribution from the EU budget to actions co-financed with
Member State authorities (Joint Actions)
Eligibility criteria
According to the Health Programme Regulation1, grants may be awarded to fund:
actions having a clear Union added value co-financed by the competent authorities that are
responsible for health in the Member States or in the third countries participating in the
Programme, or by public sector bodies and non-governmental bodies acting individually or
as a network, mandated by those competent authorities;
Beneficiaries eligible for such grants2 are "legally established organisations, public
authorities, public sector bodies, in particular research and health institutions, universities and
higher education establishments."
Implementing process:
Member State and third countries participating in the programme are invited to nominate one
competent authority responsible for the implementation of the action on their behalf.
Competent authority means the authority responsible for health or for a specific health topic
including any body to which that competence has been conferred (e.g. regional authorities).
The nomination should confirm that:
the nominated entity is a competent authority responsible for a specific health topic;
the nominated entity and the entities affiliated to it are eligible to participate on behalf of
the respective member state/third country and under its responsibility in the action.
Selection criteria
Financial capacity
Applicants must have stable and sufficient sources of funding to maintain their activity
throughout the period during which the activity is being carried out and to participate in its co-
financing.
1
Article 7 (2.a) of regulation (EU) No 282/2014 of the European parliament and of the Council of 11
March 2014 on the establishment of a third Programme for the Union's action in the field of health
(2014-2020)
2
Article 8 (1) of the same regulation
Page 1 of 4
Joint Actions 2019 – ANNEX 2
Operational capacity
Applicants must have the professional resources, competences and qualifications required to
complete the proposed action.
Award criteria
Contribution to public health in Europe (10 points, threshold: 7 points)
Sub-criteria taken into account in the assessment:
quality of the Joint Action’s contribution to public health in Europe;
consideration of social, cultural and political context.
Technical quality of the proposal (10 points, threshold: 6 points)
Sub-criteria taken into account in the assessment:
quality of the evidence base;
quality of the content;
innovative nature, technical complementarity and avoidance of duplication of other
existing actions at EU level;
quality and relevance of the actions with regard to promoting the dialogue with NGOs in
the field;
quality of the evaluation strategy and plan;
quality of the dissemination strategy and plan.
Management quality of the proposal (10 points, threshold: 6 points)
Sub-criteria taken into account in the assessment:
quality of the planning and appropriate task distribution to implement the Joint Action,
relevance of the organisational capacity, including financial management,
quality of the partnership.
Overall and detailed budget (10 points, threshold: 6 points)
Sub-criteria taken into account in the assessment:
budget’s relevance to the activities;
consistency of the estimated cost per applicant and the corresponding activities;
realistic estimation of person days per deliverable and per work package;
appropriate budget allocated for evaluation and dissemination activities.
2. Role of the nominated competent authorities
Each country participating in the EU Health Programme is invited to nominate one competent
authority, which will become the grant beneficiary and be responsible for the implementation
of the action on its behalf.
Page 2 of 4
Joint Actions 2019 – ANNEX 2
The competent authority manages and carries out the Joint Action together with the
coordinator (lead competent authority for the joint action) contributing with their own funding
and ensuring that the objectives of the joint action are met.
The nominated competent authority may involve in the grant under its responsibility other
participants, such as affiliated entities, subcontractors and collaborating partners. Their names
shall be indicated by the competent authorities when submitting the proposal, together with
the activities they will perform.
1) Entities affiliated to the nominated competent authority:
Affiliated entities are "entities that satisfy the eligibility criteria and that do not fall within
one of the situations referred to in article 136 (1) and 141 (1) and that have a link with the
beneficiary, in particular a legal or capital link, which is neither limited to the action nor
established for the sole purpose of its implementation"3.
Affiliated entities in the public sphere covers:
The different levels of the administrative structure in case of decentralised
administration (e.g. national, regional or local administrations).
Public sector bodies (e.g. national institutes or schools for public health or national
research centres) which area formally established organisations and are (at least in
part) publically funded to deliver a public or government service. They are mandated
by the competent authority to participate in the joint action.
What is not an affiliated entity?
Entities that have entered into a (procurement) contract or subcontract with the
competent authority (beneficiary), or who act as concessionaires or delegates for
public services for the beneficiary.
Entities that cooperate with the beneficiary on the basis of a memorandum of
understanding or share some assets.
While affiliated entities do not sign the grant agreement, they actively contribute to the
implementation of the action. Costs incurred by such entities will be accepted as eligible
costs.
2) Subcontractors
These are entities subcontracted by the nominated competent authorities for the purpose of
providing special expertise to the joint action. It should be noted that coordination and other
essential tasks cannot be subcontracted.
Subcontracting must comply with the rules in force regarding public procurement.
3) Collaborating stakeholders or partners
The nominated competent authorities must also identify and select the civil society
organisations active at EU level that can make the most valuable contribution to the joint
action, e.g. significantly increasing the technical and scientific content of the joint action, as
well as its relevance for different users in the Union.
3
Article 187 of the Financial Regulation 2018/1046 of 18 July 2018
Page 3 of 4
Joint Actions 2019 – ANNEX 2
If identified, these organisations from civil society will be invited to participate in the JA
meetings as collaborating stakeholders and/or participate in advisory structures, for which
costs may be reimbursed.
Collaborating stakeholders have no contractual relationship, nor do they receive any EU
funding.
Eligibility checks
After the submission deadline, nominations will be verified to ensure that the eligibility
criteria are fulfilled.
Chafea reserves its right to assess the regularity of the nomination procedure and to carry out
checks. During this process, Chafea may request supporting documents, such as legal act
establishing the nominated organization.
Submission of nominations via EU Survey website
The submission of the competent authority nominations shall be done through the EU Survey
website following this link:
https://ec.europa.eu/eusurvey/runner/JA2019.
The password is: JA2019!
The instructions and the form are available on EU Survey website.
There are two steps to follow:
Step 1 - Instructions and completion of the nomination form:
The editable .pdf template of the nomination form should be downloaded, completed, printed
and signed by the nominating authority, normally the Ministry of Health or Health Board.
The editable .pdf template has a limited number of characters; all filled fields should be
visible and readable before signature.
Step 2 - Submission of the nomination form:
In this step, you should complete a short online registration form consistently with the
completed .pdf nomination form. Upload the scanned signed version of the latter and submit
the nomination.
In case you need assistance, please contact:
[email protected]
Privacy and data protection policy
Participation in the Joint Action will involve the collection, use and processing of personal
data (such as name, address and CV). This data will be processed in accordance with
Regulation No 2018/1725. It will be processed by Chafea solely for the purpose of evaluating
the proposal and subsequent management of the grant (e.g. list of participants of the Joint
Action and share data among those participants) and, if needed, programme monitoring,
evaluation and communication with DG Health and Food Safety, National Focal Points and
maybe published on the Chafea website. Details are available in the privacy policy pages of
the European Commission.
Page 4 of 4
Ref. Ares(2019)3071424 - 08/05/2019
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
HEALTH AND FOOD SAFETY DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
Public health, country knowledge, crisis management
Director
Luxembourg,
sante.ddg1.c.1(2019)DDW/ms 3216201
NOTE TO THE ATTENTION OF PERMANENT REPRESENTATIONS/MISSIONS TO THE EU
SUBJECT: PROGRAMME FOR THE UNION'S ACTION IN THE FIELD OF HEALTH (2014-
2020)- JOINT ACTIONS 2019-NOMINATION OF ONE COMPETENT AUTHORITY
Your Excellency,
The 2019 Annual Work Programme in the field of Health adopted by the Commission
on 29 March 2019 includes the three following Joint actions:
• Joint Action on implementation of validated best practices (EUR 6 000 000 EU co-
funding).
• Joint Action to strengthen health preparedness and response to biological and
chemical terror attacks (EUR 5 000 000 EU co-funding).
• Joint Action on implementation of digitally enabled integrated person-centred care
(EUR 4 000 000 EU co-funding).
Joint Actions are granted through a direct procedure, without an open call. This implies
that EU Member states and other countries participating in the Health Programme in
subject have to formally nominate competent authorities to participate on their behalf
before the proposal preparation process starts.
For the Joint Actions mentioned above each participating country is invited to nominate
one competent authority. The eligibility criteria are set up in Articles 6, 7 (2)(a) and 8 of
the Health Programme Regulation 282/2014/EU.
Therefore, I hereby invite you to nominate the competent authority which will
participate on behalf of your country in the joint actions mentioned above.
The deadline for the nomination is 11th June 2019. Nominations received after this
deadline will not be taken into account.
Commission européenne, 2920 Luxembourg, LUXEMBOURG - Tel. +352 43011
Office: HTC 01/074 - Tel. direct line +352 4301-39490 - Fax +352 4301-31018
The submission of the nominations will be done through the EU Survey website which
you can access here:
https://ec.europa.eu/eusurvey/runner/JA2019
The password is: JA2019!
I would be grateful if you could forward this message and the enclosed Annexes to the
relevant authorities in order to ensure your country's participation.
The Consumers, Health, Agriculture and Food Executive Agency (Chafea) is mandated
to implement the related procedures, once the nominations will be done.
I would also like to inform you that Chafea is going to organise a webinar on 21 May
2019 to present the 2019 Joint Actions and on 24 June an information day in
Luxembourg with the nominated authorities. I would be glad if you could already pass
this information to the nominated competent authority which will then receive more
details from Chafea.
Yours faithfully,
John F. Ryan
Director
Cc.: Programme Committee Members and National Focal Points,
S. Schreck, I. Athanassoudis and D. De Waal (SANTE C1), S. Giraud (B1),
W. Philipp, (SANTE C3), W. Kalamarz (C4),
D. Meroni, G. Margetidis, D. Meusel (Chafea)
Annexes:
ANNEX 1 Policy expectations for the three Joint Actions
ANNEX 2 Eligibility criteria and nomination of competent authorities in the Joint
Actions 2019
Electronically signed on 08/05/2019 14:14 (UTC+02) in accordance with article 4.2 (Validity of electronic documents) of Commission Decision 2004/563
2
Ref. Ares(2019)3071424 - 08/05/2019
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR HEALTH AND FOOD SAFETY
Public health, country knowledge, crisis management
Health programme and chronic diseases
Annex Policy expectations for a Joint Action on the Implementation of
validated Best Practices
Non-Communicable diseases are one of the biggest challenges in the area of health in all
Member States. Death from major non-communicable diseases translate into around 3.4
million life years lost or 115 billion euros in potential economic loss each year. It
represents a major source of human suffering and a huge economic burden for public and
personal budgets. The most recent OECD estimates indicate that in EU countries obesity
alone is reducing life expectancy by up to 4 years and removing up to 4,5pp of GDP
growth. Up to 12% of the healthcare budget of EU countries is spent on obesity and
related sick leaves, which costs 72 billion euros/year.
In this context, the Commission is proposing a Joint Action lending support to the
Members States to achieve the Sustainable Development Goal 3.4 on reducing mortality
caused by non-communicable diseases by 2030. This will also target the quality and
effectiveness of public expenditure.
This Joint Action will focus on adapting, replicating and implementing evaluated
effective health interventions (i.e., practices that have proven to work) in the areas of
food reformulation monitoring, framing of aggressive marketing of food, and public
procurement of healthy food in public settings.
The Member States represented in the Steering Group on Health Promotion and
Prevention and Management of Non-Communicable Diseases agreed on ‘nutrition and
physical activity’ to be the focus for best practice implementation in 2019 and selected
the above-mentioned best practices for implementation.1
The objective of the Joint Action is that each of the participating countries adopts or
improves:
A monitoring system for reformulation initiatives (for salt, sugar and saturated
fat) which will regularly inform authorities, consumers and industry about the
scope for improvements in food products.
Reformulation removes excess sugars, salt and fat from products that are bought
every day in EU supermarkets. It helps citizens of all social backgrounds to have
healthier diets and supports innovative companies. Monitoring the nutritional
quality of food products in the EU will inform authorities, consumers and
industry about the scope for improvements in food products. Since "what gets
measured gets done", this can strengthen national reformulation initiatives and
support consumer choice, innovation and a level playing field for industry.
1
This directly supports the high interest that the Member States have been showing over the recent years in healthy lifestyles through
the adoption of various Council conclusions (e.g. food reformulation, childhood obesity, healthy nutrition for children) and their
accompanying Presidency conferences and roadmaps.
Commission européenne, 2920 Luxembourg, LUXEMBOURG - Tel. +352 43011
Office: HTC 01/070 ‐ Tel. direct line +352 430136380
[email protected]
This outcome will be based on the successful experience of France (and also of
Austria, Romania and the Joint Action on Nutrition and Physical Activity). It will
also build on the EU Framework for reformulation Initiatives in the areas of salt,
saturated fat and added sugars.
A code of conduct to reduce the exposure of children to (TV and digital)
marketing of foods and beverages High in Fat, Sugar or Salt. This Code of
Conduct will be coordinated with and make the best use of the opportunity of the
transposition of the EU Audio-Visual Media Services Directive.
Parents in all Member States can relate to the challenge of protecting children
from inappropriate ads, and existing evidence on children’s exposure to food
marketing, especially online, is alarming.
This outcome will be based on the successful experience of Ireland and Slovenia.
It will also build on a study on the exposure of minors to TV and online
marketing of foods high in fat, salt or sugar launched by the Commission.
The Joint Research Centre was asked to produce a mapping of initiatives to
reduce marketing pressure to identify best practices that the Member States may
wish to adapt or build on. Relevant initiatives by the UNICEF and the WHO Euro
Action network on reducing marketing pressure to children are also under way
and can be supportive of these efforts.
- The national public procurement policy for food, with the objective of
improving its health impact and of promoting healthier supply and demand of
food products, in particular in schools.
This may include the development of model or template tender specifications and
contracts that include references to nutritional guidelines; the adaptation and roll
out of web tools which would help schools draft better food catering contracts;
the development of ‘catalogues of foods’, etc.
Public procurement of food represents an opportunity worth 80 billion euros/year
to help steer both demand and supply of healthier food options, first of all in
schools.
- This outcome will be based on the Slovene successful experience of improving its
food public procurement policy and of developing specific tools to support school
procurement. It will also build on the Joint Research Centre 2017 report on public
procurement of food for schools.
By participating in this JA, the Member States will have the opportunity to decisively
contribute to:
Increase the healthy choices for food products available in their supermarkets, for
the benefit for their citizens, while promoting innovative food companies;
Better protect children from aggressive food marketing;
Improve the health impact of public procurement of food, likely reducing its
environmental footprint and increasing its local input.
To achieve this, the countries will be able to:
2
Be inspired by, improve on and replicate the proven experiences from other
Member States, that will be available to discuss their experiences (mistakes and
successes, lessons learned);
Participate in a European initiative that will support all participating countries
with tools, engagement and financial support (6 million euros of EU co-funding).
3
Ref. Ares(2019)3071424 - 08/05/2019
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
HEALTH AND FOOD SAFETY DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
Public health, country knowledge, crisis management
Director
Luxembourg,
sante, dete I x. U2019)DD W/ms 3216201
Note to the attention of Permanent Representations/Missions to the EU
Subject: Programme for the Union's action in the field of health (2014
2020)- Joint Actions 2019-Nomination of one competent authority
Your Excellency,
The 2019 Annual Work Programme in the field of Health adopted by the Commission
on 29 March 2019 includes the three following Joint actions:
• Joint Action on implementation of validated best practices (EUR 6 000 000 EU co-
iunding).
• Joint Action to strengthen health preparedness and response to biological and
chemical terror attacks (EUR 5 000 000 EU co-funding).
• Joint Action on implementation of digitally enabled integrated person-centred care
(EUR 4 000 000 EU co-funding).
Joint Actions are granted through a direct procedure, without an open call. This implies
that EU Member states and other countries participating in the Health Programme in
subject have to formally nominate competent authorities to participate on their behalf
before the proposal preparation process starts.
For the Joint Actions mentioned above each participating country is invited to nominate
one competent authority. The eligibility criteria are set up in Articles 6, 7 (2)(a) and 8 of
the Health Programme Regulation 282/2014/EU.
Therefore, I hereby invite you to nominate the competent authority which will
participate on behalf of your country in the joint actions mentioned above.
The deadline for the nomination is 11th June 2019. Nominations received after this
deadline will not be taken into account.
Commission européenne, 2920 Luxembourg, LUXEMBOURG - Tel. +352 43011
Office: HTC 01/074 - Tel. direct line +352 4301-39490 - Fax +352 4301-31018
The submission of the nominations will be done through the EU Survey website which
you can access here:
https://ec.europa.eu/cusurvey/runner/JA2019
The password is: JA2019!
I would be grateful if you could forward this message and the enclosed Annexes to the
relevant authorities in order to ensure your country's participation.
The Consumers. Health. Apiculture and Food Executive Agency (Chafea) is mandated
to implement the related procedures, once the nominations will be done.
Yours faithfully,
c/l'X
Cc.: Programme Committee Members and National Focal Points,
S. Schreck, I. Athanassoudis and D. De Waal (SANTE Cl), S. Giraud (Bl),
W. Philipp, (SANTE C3), W. Kałamarz (C4),
D. Meroni, G. Margetidis, D. Meusel (Chafea)
Annexes:
ANNEX 1 Policy expectations for the three Joint Actions
ANNEX 2 Eligibility criteria and nomination of competent authorities in the Joint
Actions 2019
2
Electronically signed on 08/05/2019 14:14 (UTC+02) in accordance with article 4.2 (Validity of electronic documents) of Commission Decision 2004/563
Saatja:
[email protected] <
[email protected]>
Saaja:
[email protected],
[email protected]
Teema: FW: Official Invitation Joint Actions
Dear Health Programme Committee members, dear National Focal points,
We were informed that some of you haven’t received the e-mail with the official invitation for the Joint Actions.
The invitation was sent by e-mail to the members of the Health Programme Committee.
We are sorry that the letter did not reach all of you and apologize for any inconvenience.
Kind regards,
The Health Programme Team
From: DE WAAL Denise (SANTE) <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >
Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2019 4:10 PM
To: SANTE HEALTH PROGRAMME <
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> >
Subject: Official Invitation Joint Actions
Dear Health Programme Committee member,
In the framework of the 2019 Annual Work Programme <https://ec.europa.eu/health/funding/adoption_workplan_2019_en> adopted by the Commission on 29 March 2019, three joint actions are planned in the following areas:
· Joint Action on implementation of validated best practices (EUR 6 000 000 EU co-funding).
· Joint Action to strengthen health preparedness and response to biological and chemical terror attacks (EUR 5 000 000 EU co-funding).
· Joint Action on implementation of digitally enabled integrated person-centred care (EUR 4 000 000 EU co-funding).
Please find attached:
o The formal invitation letter for these Joint Actions (Two versions; one is a scanned version without working hyperlinks, the other one is a digital version with working hyperlinks)
o Annex 1a,1b,1c with additional information on each of the Joint Actions.
o An annex2 with information on eligibility to participate in a Joint Action.
Additionally I would like to remind you of some key dates:
1. A webinar on Joint Actions 2019 is scheduled for Tuesday 21 May 2019 (see invitation attached);
2. The deadline for nominations is Tuesday 11 June;
3. The information day, addressed to the representatives of the nominated competent authorities, is planned for Monday 24 June.
Kind Regards,
Dr. Denise de Waal
PhD Health Studies
Policy Officer
Programme and Chronic Disease Unit
Public Health Directorate
Directorate General for Health and Food Safety
European Commission
Luxemburg