350 Fifth Avenue, 34th Floor
New York, NY 10118-3299
Tel: 212-290-4700
Fax: 212-736-1300; 917-591-3452
3 June 2019
WOMEN’S RIGHTS Riina Sikkut
DIVISION
Liesl Gerntholtz, Executive Director
Minister of Health and Labour
Heather Barr, Acting Co-Director
Amanda Klasing, Acting Co-Director
Ministry of Social Affairs
Janet Walsh, Deputy Director Estonia
Nisha Varia, Advocacy Director
Aruna Kashyap, Senior Counsel
Agnes Odhiambo, Senior Researcher
Rothna Begum, Senior Researcher Your Excellency,
Hillary Margolis, Researcher
Juliana Nnoko-Mewanu, Researcher
Skye Wheeler, Researcher
Nesha Abiraj, Northwestern Pritzker School
I write to urge your government to support the drafting and adoption of a
of Law Schuette Fellow
Annerieke Daniel, Fellow
robust International Labour Organization (ILO) convention to combat violence
Agnieszka Bielecka, Coordinator and harassment in the world of work during its final negotiation at the
Erika Nguyen, Coordinator
International Labour Conference in Geneva in June.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Donna Slaight, Chair
Betsy Karel, C0-Chair Emerita
We are grateful for the support your government extended last year by voting in
Joan Platt, Co-Chair Emerita favor of a binding convention accompanied by a recommendation.
Kathleen Peratis, Chair Emerita
Karen Ackman
Mahnaz Afkhami Human Rights Watch has extensively documented violence and harassment in
Helen Bernstein
David Brown the world of work including in relation to domestic workers, garment workers,
Charlotte Bunch
Ellen Chesler farmworkers, fishers, and military personnel in many countries around the
Nagin Cox
Yasmine Ergas
world. We have attached to this letter a briefing of our research findings,
Lawton Fitt
Judy Gaynor
examples of government best practices, and recommendations.
Kate Gellert
Adrienne Germain
Marina Pinto Kaufman The ILO has found significant gaps in legal protections around the world
Hollis Kurman
Lenora Lapidus relating to violence and harassment including a lack of coherence in laws, lack
Stephen Lewis
Samuel Murumba of coverage of workers most exposed to violence, and an overly narrow
Sylvia Neil
Susan Osnos definition of “workplace.” There is little by way of international law specifically
Lynn Povich
Bruce Rabb addressing violence and harassment in the world of work.
Amy Rao
Susan Rose
Pascaline Servan-Schreiber
Lorraine Sheinberg
The negotiation of a new ILO instrument offers a rare and critical opportunity to
Domna Stanton
Ellen Stone Belic
address this important human rights issue.
Ellen Susman
Hilary Thomas Lake
Rita W. Warner We would be happy to discuss any concerns or questions you may have with
Sarah Zeid
the draft text and to further discuss our recommendations. Please direct your
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH response to my colleague, Rothna Begum, who can be reached by email at
Kenneth Roth, Executive Director
Nic Dawes, Deputy Executive Director
[email protected]. We hope to work together to end all forms of violence and
Michele Alexander, Deputy Executive
harassment in the world of work.
Director, Development and Global Initiatives
Emma Daly, Acting Deputy Executive
Director, Media Thank you for your time and consideration.
Liesl Gerntholtz, Acting Deputy Executive
Director, Program
Chuck Lustig, Deputy Executive Director,
Operations Sincerely,
Bruno Stagno Ugarte, Deputy Executive
Director, Advocacy
Dinah PoKempner, General Counsel
James Ross, Legal & Policy Director
Hassan Elmasry, Co-Chair
Robert Kissane, Co-Chair Nisha Varia
Advocacy Director
Women’s Rights Division
AMSTERDAM · BEIRUT · BERLIN · BRUSSELS · CHICAGO · GENEVA · GOMA · JOHANNESBURG · KIEV · KINSHASA · LONDON · LOS ANGELES · MIAMI · MOSCOW
NAIROBI · NEW YORK · PARIS · SAN FRANCISCO · SÃO PAULO · SEOUL · SILICON VALLEY · STOCKHOLM · SYDNEY · TOKYO · TORONTO · WASHINGTON · ZÜRICH
H U M A N
R I G H T S
W A T C H
ENDING VIOLENCE
AND HARASSMENT AT WORK
The Case for Global Standards
Ending Violence and Harassment at Work
The Case for Global Standards
Ending Violence and Harassment at Work
The Case for Global Standards
Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 1
The Case for a Binding International Standard.......................................................................... 2
Definitions and Coverage ..........................................................................................................3
Violence and Harassment in the World of Work ...................................................................3
Workers at Heightened Risk of Harassment and Violence ................................................... 6
What Is the Workplace? ..................................................................................................... 8
The Impact of Domestic Violence on the World of Work ............................................................ 9
Shifting the Burden of Proof .................................................................................................... 10
Good Practices ....................................................................................................................... 12
Definitions and Coverage ................................................................................................. 12
Prevention and Response ................................................................................................. 12
Procedural Clarity and Protections .................................................................................... 13
Penalties, Sanctions, Compensation, and Other Remedies ............................................... 13
Enforcement, Monitoring, and Reporting........................................................................... 14
Domestic Violence ........................................................................................................... 14
Recommendations.................................................................................................................. 14
Definitions, Coverage, and Equal Protection ..................................................................... 14
Prevention and Response ................................................................................................. 15
Procedural Clarity and Protections .................................................................................... 15
Penalties, Sanctions, Compensation, and Other Remedies ............................................... 16
Enforcement, Monitoring, and Reporting........................................................................... 16
Domestic Violence ........................................................................................................... 16
Introduction
The “Me Too” movement—coined in 2006 by Tarana Burke for a grassroots social
movement in the US against sexual harassment, and which exploded as the hashtag
#MeToo in October 2017—highlighted the pervasiveness of gender-based violence in the
world of work in both well-known and powerful industries and marginalized sectors often
invisible to public scrutiny. While women and girls are often the main victims of sexual
harassment, men and boys also experience such violence and harassment.
The World Bank’s “Women, Business and the Law 2018” report found that 59 out of 189
economies had no specific legal provisions covering sexual harassment in employment.1
More broadly, the International Labour Organization (ILO), in its 2016 meeting of experts,
noted that gaps in legal protections relating to violence and harassment in the world of
work include: lack of coherence in laws; lack of coverage of workers most exposed to
violence; and an overly narrow definition of “workplace.” It also observed that criminal
justice approaches are not sufficient for responding to sexual harassment and bullying
and that an employer’s general duty to protect the health and safety of workers often
excludes protection from violence.2
The discussion for a new ILO instrument to combat violence and harassment in the world
of work, beginning in 2018, offers a unique opportunity at a critical juncture to help end all
forms of violence and harassment in the world of work.
This briefing presents the findings of Human Rights Watch research on violence and
harassment in the world of work, particularly for domestic workers, garment workers,
fishers, farm workers, and migrant workers; highlights examples of best government
practices; and outlines recommendations for essential elements to a proposed ILO
convention, accompanied with a recommendation, on ending violence and harassment in
the world of work.
1 World Bank, “Women, Business and the Law 2018,” http://wbl.worldbank.org/en/reports (accessed May 18, 2018).
2 International Labour Organization (ILO), “Meeting of Experts on Violence against Women and Men in the World of Work (3–
6 October 2016),” 2016, http://www.ilo.org/gender/Informationresources/Publications/WCMS_546303/lang--en/index.htm
(accessed May 18, 2018).
1 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
The Case for a Binding International Standard
While regional human rights treaties and authoritative interpretations of existing
international human rights treaties establish sexual harassment at work as a human rights
violation, there is little by way of international law specifically addressing violence and
harassment in the world of work.3 An ILO convention, accompanied with a
recommendation, would address this gap and could lead the development of effective
national laws and policies.
Moreover, an ILO convention, accompanied with a recommendation, would also further
help to direct the responses to violence and harassment, including sexual harassment, as
states more actively grapple with violence and harassment at work. The proposed
instruments, through taking an integrated approach, could recognize the interactions
between anti-discrimination laws, labor laws, occupational safety and health laws, and
other civil laws to provide essential protections for workers, and complement the penalties
under criminal provisions, which often focus solely on the most extreme forms of violence
and harassment. Civil laws can strengthen prevention and monitoring as well as remedies
for a broader range of violence and harassment, offer victims greater participation and
reduce barriers for access to justice.
3 United Nations General Assembly Resolution 48/104 on the Declaration on the Elimination of Violence Against Women, art.
2(b), A/RES/48/104, http://www.un.org/documents/ga/res/48/a48r104.htm (accessed May 18, 2018); UN Committee on
Discrimination against Women (CEDAW Committee), General Recommendation No. 19, Violence Against Women, (Eleventh
session, 1992), art. 24,
http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/Treaties/CEDAW/Shared%20Documents/1_Global/INT_CEDAW_GEC_3731_E.pdf (accessed May
18, 2018); CEDAW Committee, General recommendation No. 35 on gender-based violence against women, updating general
recommendation No. 19, UN. Doc. CEDAW/C/GC/35, July 26, 2017,
http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/treatybodyexternal/Download.aspx?symbolno=CEDAW/C/GC/35&Lang=en (accessed
May 18, 2018); UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, General comment No. 23 (2016) on the right to just
and favourable conditions of work (article 7 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights),
http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/treatybodyexternal/Download.aspx?symbolno=E%2fC.12%2fGC%2f23&Lang=en
(accessed May 18, 2018); Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa,
adopted by the 2nd Ordinary Session of the Assembly of the Union, Maputo, September 13, 2000, CAB/LEG/66.6, entered
into force November 25, 2005, art. 13(c); Southern African Development Community Protocol on Gender and Development,
art.22; Inter-American Convention on the Prevention, Punishment and Eradication of Violence Against Women (Belem do
Para)art. 2; Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence (the
Istanbul Convention), art. 40; European Council Directive 2004/113/EC, 13 December 2004, art. 4(3), http://eur-
lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2004:373:0037:0043:EN:PDF (accessed May 18, 2018).
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 2
Definitions and Coverage
Violence and Harassment in the World of Work
He would take down his trousers, and would say: “Look, did you see? it is
nice?” … Always doing that, just pulling down his pants. When we saw him,
we would start running.
—“Anisa L.,” 28, Tanzanian former domestic worker in Dubai, on how her employer repeatedly
exposed his genitals to her and a fellow domestic worker.
Human Rights Watch has documented psychological, physical, and sexual violence in the
world of work including in relation to domestic workers, farmworkers, fishers, garment
workers, miners, and military personnel in many countries around the world.4 The impact
includes physical, psychological, sexual, and economic harm.
Domestic workers for instance described to Human Rights Watch psychological abuse
where their employers humiliated, insulted, and shouted at them daily leading some to
experience mental health problems that continued even after ending employment. They
also reported physical violence ranging from slaps to severe beatings with sticks,
household items, belts, and shoes, or burnings with hot water or food, irons, and
chemicals. In some cases, physical abuse is so severe it has led to paralysis, blindness,
and death while others described chronic pain such as back pain.
Human Rights Watch has documented workers being physically abused aboard Thai fishing
vessels in 2016. Senior crew members beat fishers who did not work fast enough or to their
expectations. Some fishers reported being beaten for failing to understand orders given in
different dialects. Fishers described being punched and kicked, and beaten with iron rods,
stingray tails, coils of rope, and blocks of wood. Humiliating practices used to discipline
workers included being drenched with water and culturally specific forms of submission
such as skippers forcibly putting the soles of their feet on the heads of crew members.5
4 See for instance, Human Rights Watch, “Gender-based Violence in the Workplace,” https://www.hrw.org/tag/gender-
based-violence-workplace.
5 Human Rights Watch, Hidden Chains: Rights Abuses and Forced Labor in Thailand’s Fishing Industry, January 2018,
https://www.hrw.org/report/2018/01/23/hidden-chains/rights-abuses-and-forced-labor-thailands-fishing-industry.
3 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
Cecilia, 22, Tanzanian former domestic worker in Oman said her employer made sexual advances towards
her and hit her after she refused. Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. © 2017 Sophie Stolle for Human Rights Watch
Women workers and gender non-conforming workers are particularly vulnerable to sexual
harassment at the workplace. The ILO Committee of Experts on the Application of
Conventions and Recommendations (CEACR) has addressed sexual harassment primarily
as a form of discrimination in the workplace. CEACR has categorized sexual harassment in
employment and occupation in two ways: “quid pro quo” or “hostile working
environment.”6 “Quid pro quo” sexual harassment is when there is “any physical, verbal or
non-verbal conduct of a sexual nature” which is “unwelcome, unreasonable, and offensive
to the recipient; and a person’s rejection of, or submission to, such conduct is used
explicitly or implicitly as a basis for a decision which affects that person’s job.” “Hostile
working environment” harassment covers conduct that creates an intimidating, hostile, or
humiliating working environment.7
6 See International Labour Organization (ILO), “Report of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and
Recommendations, (articles 19, 22 and 35 of the Constitution) General Report and observations concerning particular
countries,” General observation, Convention No. 111, 2003, p. 463,
http://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/P/09661/09661(2003)1A.pdf (accessed May 18, 2018).
7 Ibid.
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 4
Human Rights Watch has documented both forms of harassment. For instance, in a “quid
pro quo” example, Teresa G., a woman in North Carolina in the United States who works on
a tobacco farm, told Human Rights Watch that in 2011 a supervisor told two of her co-
workers they had to have sex with him in order to get the job. When Teresa found one of
the women crying, she asked why she had done it, and she replied, “My husband doesn’t
have work. I don’t have work.”8
Domestic workers—who live in the homes of their employers—described to Human Rights
Watch both situations of “quid pro quo” and “hostile working environment.” Susanne K., a
14-year-old domestic worker in Guinea, told Human Rights Watch how she was forced to
have sex with her male employer in return for food: “Otherwise I do eat not very much, and
sometimes even nothing. I never get breakfast.”9 Domestic workers—adult and children—
also recounted how their male employers or their relatives groped them, exposed
themselves, chased them around the house, attempted to rape, and raped them. When
they tried to complain about the abuse they said they were either blamed, told to avoid it,
or fired. Others fled their employers’ homes for fear of further harm.
In addition, some employers fail to take action for behavior of such perpetrators, or
retaliate against workers who report sexual harassment or violence. For instance, Human
Rights Watch found that both male and female US military personnel who report sexual
assault are 12 times as likely to experience some form of retaliation as to see their attacker
convicted of a sex offense. Retaliation against survivors ranges from new assaults, threats,
and harassment to poor work assignments, loss of promotion opportunities, disciplinary
action including discharge, and even criminal charges.10
Many garment workers across different countries told Human Rights Watch that when they
complained about working conditions including violence and harassment, their managers
or supervisors applied “pressure” on them which they perceived as deliberate strategies
used to demoralize and harass them. Workers described how their employers denied them
overtime work; forced them to work longer hours with higher production targets; or
8 Human Rights Watch, Cultivating Fear: The Vulnerability of Immigrant Farmworkers in the US to Sexual Violence and Sexual
Harassment, May 2012, https://www.hrw.org/report/2012/05/15/cultivating-fear/vulnerability-immigrant-farmworkers-us-
sexual-violence-and-sexual.
9 Human Rights Watch, Bottom of the Ladder: Exploitation and Abuse of Girl Domestic Workers in Guinea, June 2007,
https://www.hrw.org/report/2007/06/15/bottom-ladder/exploitation-and-abuse-girl-domestic-workers-guinea.
10 Human Rights Watch, Embattled: Retaliation against Sexual Assault Survivors in the US Military, May 2015,
https://www.hrw.org/report/2015/05/18/embattled/retaliation-against-sexual-assault-survivors-us-military, Booted: Lack of
Recourse for Wrongfully Discharged US Military Rape Survivors, May 2016,
https://www.hrw.org/report/2016/05/19/booted/lack-recourse-wrongfully-discharged-us-military-rape-survivors.
5 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
transferred them to a different department or to a different manufacturing site further away
from home. Such measures often forced them to quit their jobs. Workers also reported that
factory managers or hired “thugs” beat workers attempting to form unions, or physically
forced workers to sign blank paper that can later be turned into resignation letters.11
Workers at Heightened Risk of Harassment and Violence
Some workers may be at greater risk of harassment and violence at work because of the
sectors they work in, or because of the discrimination they face because of their gender,
sexual orientation, immigration status, race, ethnicity, or other status.
Domestic workers, farmworkers, and those in precarious employment may not have equal
protections against workplace violence under labor laws as other workers. For example,
domestic workers may be excluded entirely from some countries’ labor laws, or in other
cases are not entitled to sexual harassment protections because their workplace does not
cross a threshold for a minimum number of workers, as in the United States.
Children—whether above the legal minimum age of employment or engaged in child
labor—may be at particular risk of sexual harassment and abuse, as employers may
perceive them as easier to intimidate. Because of their young age and relative lack of
maturity, children may also be less able to resist sexual harassment or lodge complaints.
Human Rights Watch’s reporting on garment workers has found that workers on short-term
contracts, daily wages, and other casual forms of employment are more vulnerable to
abusive working conditions including sexual harassment than workers who have
employment security and legal protections against arbitrary dismissals.12 A lack of
effective grievance redress mechanisms and whistleblower protections can also leave
workers exposed to risks.
11 See for example Human Rights Watch, “Work Faster or Get Out”: Labor Rights Abuses in Cambodia’s Garment Industry,
March 2013, https://www.hrw.org/report/2015/03/11/work-faster-or-get-out/labor-rights-abuses-cambodias-garment-
industry; "Whoever Raises their Head Suffers the Most": Workers’ Rights in Bangladesh’s Garment Factories, April 2015,
https://www.hrw.org/report/2015/04/22/whoever-raises-their-head-suffers-most/workers-rights-bangladeshs-garment.
12 Aruna Kashyap (Human Rights Watch), “Tackling Sexual Harassment in the Garment Industry” commentary, Just-Style,
December 11, 2017, https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/12/11/tackling-sexual-harassment-garment-industry.
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 6
Migrant workers, refugees, and asylum
seekers may face barriers due to their
status, language barriers, and unfamiliarity
with local laws. Migrant workers with
undocumented status may be afraid to
approach authorities to report abuse for
fear of arrest or deportation. Migrant
workers whose legal status is tied to their
employers are more likely to face abusive
situations because their employers know
that they cannot leave their employment
without losing their status. Human Rights
Watch has documented violence, including
sexual violence, faced by migrant domestic
workers in the Middle East, where countries
implement the kafala (sponsorship) system
under which workers visas are tied to their
employers and they are not allowed to leave Hundreds of domestic workers organized by the
South African Domestic and Allied Workers’ Union
or change jobs without their employer’s
(SADSAWU) rallied in April 2013 before the Office of
permission.13 In 2016, Human Rights Watch the Department of Labour to speed South Africa’s
found the potential loss of legal residency ratification of the ILO Domestic Workers
Convention. South Africa ratified the convention in
made Syrian refugees vulnerable to labor
June 2013. © 2013 Norman Mampane/COSATU
and sexual exploitation by employers in
Lebanon, and limited their ability to turn to
authorities for protection.14
Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) workers also face particular risks of violence
and harassment and barriers to accessing justice. For instance, lack of privacy for sanitation
13 See for example Human Rights Watch, “I Was Sold”: Abuse and Exploitation of Migrant Domestic Workers in Oman, July
2016, https://www.hrw.org/report/2016/07/13/i-was-sold/abuse-and-exploitation-migrant-domestic-workers-oman; Human
Rights Watch, “I Already Bought You”: Abuse of Female Migrant Domestic Workers in the United Arab Emirates, October 2014,
https://www.hrw.org/report/2014/10/22/i-already-bought-you/abuse-and-exploitation-female-migrant-domestic-workers-
united.
14 Human Rights Watch, “I Just Wanted to be Treated like a Person” How Lebanon’s Residency Rules Facilitate Abuse of
Syrian Refugees, January 2016, https://www.hrw.org/report/2016/01/12/i-just-wanted-be-treated-person/how-lebanons-
residency-rules-facilitate-abuse.
7 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
US military sexual assault survivors make banners inscribed with their sexual assault experiences in the US
Navy. They later hung the banners in front of Naval Base San Diego. © 2014 Mary F. Calvert
facilities may expose transgender or gender non-conforming people to harassment or
violence. Alina, a transgender woman in Ukraine, told Human Rights Watch in 2014 that on
one occasion, an employer discovered her identity as transgender because he observed her
urinating. He subsequently sexually harassed her, leading her to quit her job.15
What Is the Workplace?
It is important to include a variety of spaces which relate to the world of work when it
comes to violence and harassment. Several ILO instruments consider the notion of the
workplace to go beyond the physical place where work is done to include situations arising
out of, or in the course or connection to, employment including commuting to and from
work.16 Failure to include such language can leave workers exposed to violence and
15 Human Rights Watch, “Allegation letter regarding the legal gender recognition procedure in Ukraine, as specified in Order
No. 60 of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine,” April 27, 2015, https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/04/27/allegation-letter-
regarding-legal-gender-recognition-procedure-ukraine-specified.
16 For instance, ILO Convention No. 155, article 11 refers to “in the course of or in connection with work,” and the ILO Protocol
of 2002 to Convention No. 155, article 1, notes that the term “occupational accident” covers an occurrence arising not only in
the course of work, but “arising out of” work. The definition proposed for “industrial accidents” in Paragraph 5(a) of ILO
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 8
harassment. For instance, an employee who harasses a fellow colleague on the commute
to work or in a restroom outside of the physical workplace may not be liable for their
actions if the law does not deem it their physical place of work.
Employers should also take into account factors that can increase the likelihood of
violence and harassment against employees even where it may be committed by a member
of the public. For instance, requiring workers to work late at night but without offering
them transport home, can leave female workers more vulnerable to harassment or violence
on public transport in their commute home.
Human Rights Watch documented in 2013 how the lack of safe changing rooms and toilets
for women at police stations in Afghanistan endangered the safety of female police officers.
An international advisor working closely with female Afghan police officers told Human
Rights Watch that sexual assaults of police women often occur in isolated locations such
as unsafe toilets and changing areas. Many female police officers cannot travel to work in
their police uniforms due to security threats posed by Taliban insurgents or others
opposed to women police. Only a handful of police stations have separate safe and
accessible toilets for women; police stations in rural areas sometimes have no toilets at all,
and both women and men are forced to seek secluded locations outside. As the number of
women in the police force has risen, so have the allegations by female officers of having
been raped, assaulted or sexually harassed by male colleagues.17
The Impact of Domestic Violence on the World of Work
Domestic violence is the most common form of violence experienced by women globally.
The World Health Organization (WHO) in its 2013 report found that 35 percent of women
worldwide have experienced either physical and/or sexual intimate partner violence or
non-partner sexual violence.18 Domestic violence affects a range of human rights and
impedes economic growth and development.
Recommendation No. 121 covers any accidents “regardless of their cause, sustained during working hours”, at “any place
where the worker would not have been except for his employment”. Paragraphs 5(b) and (c) call for the inclusion of
commuting accidents that occur while the worker prepares for work and on the way to and from work.
17 Human Rights Watch, “Afghanistan: Urgent Need for Safe Facilities for Female Police,” April 25, 2015,
https://www.hrw.org/news/2013/04/25/afghanistan-urgent-need-safe-facilities-female-police.
18 World Health Organization (WHO), “Global and regional estimates of violence against women, Prevalence and health
effects of intimate partner violence and non-partner sexual violence,” 2013,
http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/violence/9789241564625/en/ (accessed May 18, 2018).
9 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
Survivors can be at further risk of violence if their employer does little to help protect them
or retaliates against them for actions such as missing work to attend a court hearing.
Employers can take measures that would help to keep survivors of domestic violence at
work—sometimes a place of safety—and that would help their economic security. Without
such measures, survivors may remain trapped and economically dependent on their
abuser. In some cases, employers retaliate against survivors who take time off to recover,
come to work with visible injuries, or if their abuser turns up to their place of work.
“Armine” told Human Rights Watch how in 2015 she lost her job in a medical center in
Armenia after her then-husband twice came to her workplace:
I worked a 24-hour shift. He came one night and was drunk. He said “I came
to see if you are actually working or if you are doing something with some
lover. I won’t let you work anywhere. I will slit your throat!” After that the
director came and told me I shouldn’t come to work anymore. He said, ‘It’s
not ok for your husband to come here and sort out your family problems.’
The medical center director did not offer Armine any assistance.19
Shifting the Burden of Proof
Reducing barriers to justice in civil cases and shifting the burden of proof in labor cases
relating to discrimination, including harassment, would acknowledge the unequal power
relations that exist between the employer and employee, as well as the obligations that
the employer has to take measures, both preventative and disciplinary, to combat
workplace discrimination, including harassment.
19 Human Rights Watch, “Armenia: Little Protection, Aid for Domestic Violence Survivors,” January 12, 2018,
https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/01/12/armenia-little-protection-aid-domestic-violence-survivors.
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 10
Children and a woman pan for gold at an artisanal gold mine, Kéniéba circle, Mali. Sexual exploitation is
common in mining areas, particularly in large mines that bring together many different populations from
within and outside Mali. © 2010 International Labour Organization/IPEC
The ILO Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations
(CEACR) considers, in relation to labor discrimination cases, that once the complainant has
produced plausible or prima facie evidence of discrimination, then shifting the burden of
proof to the employer “is a useful tool of correcting a situation that could otherwise result
in inequality.”20
The CEACR in its 2017 report on Albania welcomed “the allocation of the burden of proof
contained in the amendments [to the Labour Code], namely that the complainant has the
burden of proving the conduct that is alleged to constitute harassment. Thereafter the
burden falls on the perpetrator/employer to prove that the harassment was not intended
(objectively determined).” The committee noted that the “employer has a responsibility to
20 ILO, “Special survey on the application of Convention No. 111 on Discrimination in Employment and Occupation, Report of
the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations (articles 19, 22 and 35 of the
Constitution),” 1996, para. 231, http://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/P/09661/09661(1996-83-4B).pdf (accessed May 18,
2018).
11 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
take all reasonable measures, both preventative and disciplinary, for ensuring that the
workplace environment is free from harassment—in other words a work environment that
is not hostile, intimidating, degrading or humiliating.”21
Good Practices
Definitions and Coverage
• Belgium prohibits “violence, harassment and sexual harassment” against
apprentices, interns and non-employees performing work under the authority of
another person (subcontractors and similar professional categories).
• Australia and Tanzania have adopted specific statutes protecting persons with
disabilities from harassment and discrimination in employment. United States,
Honduras, and the EU provide that disability-based harassment, similarly to sexual
harassment, can take the form of a hostile working environment.
• India’s law governing sexual harassment extends workplace protection against
such harassment to a wide variety of women including students, those “visiting a
workplace” (such as customers or clients), and those directly or indirectly
employed (including trainees, apprentices, volunteers, employed through an
agent). The law applies both to the organized and unorganized sectors.
• Malaysia provides that workplace sexual harassment includes any employment-
related sexual harassment “arising out of and in the course of employment”
extending beyond the confines of a physical office.
Prevention and Response
• Uruguay’s National Women’s Institute’s 2013 national policy recognizes companies
that include in their internal polices a commission which receives and monitors
cases of sexual harassment.
• South Korea’s Institute for Gender Equality Promotion and Education provides
training to public officials on sexual harassment counselling education, and sexual
harassment and sexual violence prevention education.
21 ILO, Direct Request (CEACR) - adopted 2016, published 106th ILC session (2017); Discrimination (Employment and
Occupation) Convention, 1958 (No. 111) - Albania (Ratification: 1997),
http://www.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:13100:0::NO::P13100_COMMENT_ID:3301428 (accessed May 18,
2018).
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 12
• Belgium’s Welfare Control Directorate requires notification from a prevention
adviser when, during formal psychosocial intervention following an act of violence
in the workplace, she/he believes that a grave and immediate danger for the
workers exists.
Procedural Clarity and Protections
• North America, the EU, and many Latin American countries provide protections for
the worker from retaliation/reprisals from employers or co-workers for filing or
participating in a workplace violence complaint.
• Germany provides that employees have the right to refuse to work if the employer
does not take suitable measures to stop harassment in the workplace.
• EU laws, that apply in all member states, require that the burden of proof is shifted
to the defendant, after facts are established that they may presume that there has
been discrimination. This includes harassment as a specific form of discrimination.
• Peru allows the employer to take precautionary measures, including moving the
harasser or the victim, if the latter so requests, the temporary suspension of the
harasser, psychological assistance to the victim, and the issuance of restraining
orders against the harasser.
Penalties, Sanctions, Compensation, and Other Remedies
• Ireland, Germany, and the UK provide for a doctrine of vicarious liability that results
in the employer being held liable for harassment or mobbing (collective
harassment) perpetrated by an employee, unless the employer proves that
reasonable steps had been taken to prevent the employee from engaging in
harassment. In Brazil, binding case law has been used to hold employers civilly
liable for the acts of employees who physically or sexually harass their colleagues
where the employer has failed to take protective measures.
• In India, the law governing sexual harassment at the workplace carries penalties
for employers who do not discharge their responsibilities under the law.
• In Finland, compensation is extended to aggressions committed by third parties,
where appropriate steps were not taken by the employer to mitigate risks.
• Australia and courts in Spain and Canada provide compensation for work-related
injuries resulting from violence and harassment.
13 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
Enforcement, Monitoring, and Reporting
• Colombia, Costa Rica, and Kenya have laws addressing workplace violence that
provide instructions to labor inspectors on how to proceed in cases of harassment
once a complaint is initiated by the victim.
• Namibia instructs labor inspectors to raise awareness during inspections regarding
workplace violence.
Domestic Violence
• Australia requires employers to accommodate requests for changes in working
arrangements to protect domestic violence or gender-based violence victims.
• Puerto Rico allows an employer to request a protection order in favor of her/his
employees against visitors if one of her/his employees has been a victim of
domestic violence in the workplace.
• Spain provides women workers who are victims of gender-based violence to a
reduction and reorganization of working time, and the use of flexible time and
other forms of organization of their working time.
• The Canadian Province of Manitoba, the US states of Oregon and California and in
the District of Columbia, and Italy, provide for statutory paid leave for victims of
domestic violence. Australia, the United Kingdom, Yukon territory in northwestern
Canada, and Brazil have some sectoral collective agreements which provide paid
leave and other entitlements for domestic violence survivors.
• Brazil authorizes judges to order employers to maintain the employment
relationship of victims of domestic violence and, when necessary, to grant victims
leave from work for a maximum of six months.
Recommendations
Human Rights Watch recommends that any ILO convention on ending violence and
harassment in the workplace includes:
Definitions, Coverage, and Equal Protection
• An inclusive definition of all forms of violence and harassment including sexual
harassment.
• Recognition that gender-based violence is a form of discrimination.
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 14
• A broad definition of workplace and work-related environment, to include
situations arising out of, in the course, or in connection to, employment such as
commuting to and from work.
• Equal application to individuals of any gender identity, while requiring gender-
sensitive implementation in light of the unequal power relations between men and
women and widespread discrimination against women.
• A wide array of work-based relationships, including supervisors, co-workers,
customers, and clients.
• Equal protections for at-risk groups, including migrant workers, refugees and
asylum seekers, irregular migrants, LGBT people, members of
racial/ethnic/caste/religion/language minorities, pregnant women, younger
workers, workers with precarious employment contracts, and people with
disabilities.
• All employment sectors, including public and private sectors and the informal
economy.
Prevention and Response
• Provisions ensuring that national policies and other guidance include prevention
measures such as training, clear human resources policies and procedures, and
awareness-raising campaigns.
• Provisions to develop training, model best practices, and support for employer
guidelines on investigating and handling complaints.
• Protection of freedom of association and encouragement of collective bargaining
and union activities to help prevent and address violence and harassment, with full
participation of women workers.
• Multiple grievance-redress mechanisms and channels that are accessible to all
workers.
Procedural Clarity and Protections
• Judicial and administrative procedures that respect privacy of survivors.
• Clarity on burden of proof for civil and administrative or other non-judicial
complaints.
• Protections against retaliation for workers and worker representatives (e.g. unions)
who report violence or harassment.
15 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | MAY 2018
• Due process for all parties.
Penalties, Sanctions, Compensation, and Other Remedies
• Combination of civil (remedial and disciplinary) and criminal penalties for the
perpetrator.
• Compensation, reparations, and other forms of support and remedies for victims.
• Development of model codes of conduct and protocols for employers on remedial
and disciplinary measures.
Enforcement, Monitoring, and Reporting
• Enforcement and monitoring body/bodies with power to investigate, enforce law,
assist victims, collect data, publish periodic reports, and identify and address
patterns of non-enforcement of violence and harassment, including sexual
harassment, laws and policies by institutions.
• Mandatory, regular reporting obligations to such bodies on private and public
employers.
Domestic Violence
• Protections for workers who are also victims of domestic violence from retaliation
from their employers including dismissals.
• Provisions for reasonable accommodation for domestic violence survivors (for
example to seek medical treatment, attend court hearings).
ENDING VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT AT WORK 16
ADVOCACY GUIDE: A CALL FOR COUNCIL OF EUROPE ACTION ON THE HUMAN RIGHTS SITUATION IN AZERBAI-
H U M A N
R I G H T S
W A T C H
Women workers in a garment factory in Cambodia.
© 2014 Samer Muscati for Human Rights Watch
HRW.org
2 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH
Saatja: ILC <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 03.06.2019 17:35
Adressaat: SM Info <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>
Teema: Human Rights Watch letter to the Minister of Health and Labour on ILO discussion on
violence and harassment at work
Manused: image002.png; image001.emz; Human Rights Watch letter to the Minister of Health
and Labour of Estonia.pdf; HRW ILO brochure ENGLISH.pdf
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please find attached and copied below a letter addressed to the Minister of Health and Labour to urge
your government to support the drafting and adoption of a robust International Labour Organization
(ILO) convention to combat violence and harassment in the world of work during its final negotiation at
the International Labour Conference in Geneva in June. We have attached a briefing with our
recommendations for such an instrument, including why we are calling for a binding convention.
We would be grateful if you could bring this to the attention of the Minister and to other relevant
colleagues in the Ministry.
Your Excellency,
I write to urge your government to support the drafting and adoption of a robust International Labour
Organization (ILO) convention to combat violence and harassment in the world of work during its final
negotiation at the International Labour Conference in Geneva in June.
We are grateful for the support your government extended last year by voting in favor of a binding
convention accompanied by a recommendation.
Human Rights Watch has extensively documented violence and harassment in the world of work
including in relation to domestic workers, garment workers, farmworkers, fishers, and military personnel
in many countries around the world. We have attached to this letter a briefing of our research findings,
examples of government best practices, and recommendations.
The ILO has found significant gaps in legal protections around the world relating to violence and
harassment including a lack of coherence in laws, lack of coverage of workers most exposed to violence,
and an overly narrow definition of “workplace.” There is little by way of international law specifically
addressing violence and harassment in the world of work.
The negotiation of a new ILO instrument offers a rare and critical opportunity to address this important
human rights issue.
We would be happy to discuss any concerns or questions you may have with the draft text and to further
discuss our recommendations. Please direct your response to my colleague, Rothna Begum, who can be
reached by email at
[email protected]. We hope to work together to end all forms of violence and
harassment in the world of work.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Nisha Varia
Advocacy Director
Women’s Rights Division