Rahandusministeerium · 2. mai 2022
Sisu (failidest)
REPUBLIC OF ESTONIA
1
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
Our ref. b 04. Mo 41-.4jWO1
Valdis Dombrovskis
Elisa Ferreira
Johannes Hahn
Ylva Johansson
Margaritis Schinas
Nicolas Schmit
Dear Commissioners
1 have the pleasure of enciosing a joint staternent of Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Estonia,
Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania and Slovakia on the needs and challenges
regarding the unprecedented humanitarian migration to the European Union and response of
Cohesion Policy to the consequences of the Russian aggression in Ukraine.
Minister of Finance of the Republi4stonia)
Minister Responsible for Cohesiono1c,,/
JOINT STATEMENT
Of Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech
Republic, Estonia, Hungary,
Latvia, Lithuania, Poland,
Romania and Slovakia on the needs
and challenges regarding the
unprecedented humanitarian
migration to the European Union
and response of Cohesion Policy to
the consequences of the Russian
aggression in Ukraine
Dear Commissioners
Vaidis Dombrovskis
Elisa Ferreira
Johannes Hahn
Ylva Johansson
Margaritis Schinas
Nicolas Schmit
Unfortunately, war has been ignited again on the European continent. Due to illegal Russia’s
military aggression, Ukraine is being forced to suffer tragic losses of lives, humanitarian
challenges, together with the destruction of its steadily growing econorny, infrastructure and
richly unique society and culture. It’s of utmost importance to do everything possible to
support Ukraine and its people at this critical time.
The Russian invasion in Ukraine causes unprecedented challenges for the European Union as
weil. Many of those challenges are still unfolding, however, it is already clear that the
negative impact is asymmetric and that severa! of the effects, especially humanitarian ones,
are particularly and disproportionately severe in the undersigned Member States. At this
moment more than 5.3 miflion Ukrainians have arrived in our countries, while nearly haif of
them are children.
We are of the opinion that as a first step the means still available in the EU budget should be
mobilized to tackle the ramifications of the war, including special instruments (mainly
Solidarity and Emergency Aid Reserve and Flexibility Instrument, margin of the EU Budget
2022) and budgetary flexibility planned for future years, as necessary. However, given the
exceptional nature of the circumstances, ad hoc solutions may be necessary to provide an
adequatc response at EU level to the evolving refugee crisis.
We welcome the recent Commission’s actions and proposals so far enabling to take full use
of the existing funding still available from the financial period 2014-2020 to support the
reception of refugees, i.e. Cohesion’s Action for Refugees in Europe (CARE), access to EU
funding via simplified cost options and the increase of REACT-EU pre-financing. However,
the possibilities to use the funding from the period 20 14-2020 in our countries are lirnited or
in some cases non-existent. The remaining REACT-EU allocations are still needed for its
original objective, i.e. to respond the COVID-19 crisis and to prepare a green, digital and
resilient recovery of the economy. Therefore, more solutions ought to be provided to help
Member States assist the people fleeing to the European Union from Ukraine.
While Cohesion Policy has helped us to withstand economic crises in the past and has helped
to build strong foundations to our economies, it cannot and should not be the only and main
financial answer to this crisis in Member States as this would endanger reaching the long-term
EU convergence objectives of the Policy set out in the Treaty. Therefore, we recail the
European Council conciusions of 24 and 25 March 2022, which invited the Commission to
work on additional proposals to reinforce EU support for refugees and their hosts. These
proposals should consider options for mobilizing additional financial resources.
Furthermore, our economies are severely affected by the consequences of the war. Supply
chains have been disrupted and there is a lack of sorne key construction materials (in ter alia
steel and timber). As most Ukrainian workers have left our countries to fight for the
sovereignty of their country, the shortages of labour force have already become evident, in
particular in the construction and transport sectors. The prices of construction services and
materials have been increasing at a very high pace, even 50% and above. This comes on top
of already high inflation and energy costs. Moreover, the national, regional and local budgets
face even higher and very significant budgetary burdens directly related to hosting the
refugees, including the provision of social and health care benefits to mothers and children
who are currently not available for the integration into the labour market. A vast majority of
Member States most exposed to the new crisis will very likely see a lowering of their grants
under the Recovery and Resilience Facility as weil. This ftirther increases the fiscal pressure
on those Member States. In this regard appropriate measures to address this should be
considered by the Commission in the relevant work streams.
All those factors disrupt the implementation of Cohesion Policy projects to a large extent,
both in terms of costs and timeframe and should be classified as Force Maj eure as they are
clearly beyond the control of Member States and beneficiaries. It should be of our common
interest to help beneficiaries overcome these obstacles since they are the essential ones who
fulfil the Cohesion Policy objectives. In consequence some adjustments to the regulatory
framework should be made.
Regarding the regulatory framework for 20 14-2020 an extension of the eligibility period for
at least one year should be provided for the sectors or projects directly affected by the current
2
circumstances. Extension of the 100% co-financing rate for another accounting year is also
needed. Remaining allocations of the Cohesion Fund should be made available to address the
migratory challenges. And all other possibilities, which do not require legislative changes,
must also be implemented (i.e. by amending the guidelines for the closure of 2014-2020
programmes).
Regarding the financial period and the respective regulatory framework for 202 1-2027,
phasing options for projects started in the period 2014-2020, which could not be completed
on time, need to be improved. This requires lowering the minimum limits for projects that can
be phased and partially financed from the 202 1-2027 programmes and exempting them from
the thematic concentration requirernents, as these are the main obstacles to use phasing in a
rneaningful way.
We also propose to create an optional reserve up to 5% in the national Cohesion envelopes,
which could be used by Member States to address the direct and indirect impacts of war
without additional bureaucracy and without delaying the ongoing negotiations on the content
of new programmes. In addition, we need more flexibility to transfer resources between
priorities and programmes, a possibility to support already completed or fully implemented
operations and we propose a 100% co-financing rate for at least the first year of the
programming period, counting from the date of a programme approval (supported with
sufficient payments from the EU budget for the year 2022 and 2023).
Finally, while the management of immediate effects of the war is a priority, many structural
challenges and transformations have also become even more pressing because of this war. The
new generation of Cohesion Policy programmes and Partnership Agreements should be
approved without delays and maintain their strategic focus on mid- and long-term challenges
such as structural reforms, green, just and digital transition.
Please find in the annex our more detailed proposals.
Yours sincerely,
3
Assen Vassilev
Deputy Prirne Minister for EU Funds and Minister of Finance
BULGARIA
E
Zdravko Marié
Minister of Finance
CROATIA
Nataa Trarniak
Minister of Regional Development and EU Funds
CROATIA
\I%91
Zbynk Stanjura
Minister of Finance
CZECH REPUBLIC
/
Ivan Barto
Deputy Prime Minister for Digitization and Minister of Regional Development
CZECH REPUBLIC
4
2 i4
Keit Pentus-Rosimannus
Minister of Finance
ESTONL&
Mihåly Varga
Minister of Finance
HUNGARY
Gergely Gu1yts
Minister of the Prime Minister’s Office
HUNGARY
( ‘//
Jänis Reirs
Minister for Finance
LATVIA
Gintaré Skaisté
Minister of Finance
LITHUANIA
5
Grzegorz Puda
Minister of Development Funds and Regional Policy
POLAND
Adrian Cäciu
Minister of Finance
ROMANIA
loan Marcel Bobs
Minister of European Investments and Projects, interim
ROMANIA
Igor Matovi
Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Finance
SLOVAK REPUBLIC
1ÅMPQVIQ
Veronika Remiov
Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Investments, Regional Development and
Informatization
SLOVAK REPUBLIC
6
Annex to the Joint Statement
Technical proposals — implications of refuqee crisis to the Cohesion policy
1. 2014—2020 programming period
Legislative or
Proposal (short) Explication non-legislative
:changes needed
Extension of the • An extension of the eligibility period for CPR 2014-2020
eligibility period at sectors or projects directly affected by (Art. 2, 65(2), 136,
least until 31 one year to allow the completion of 141)
December 2024 and projects currently ongoing and Closure Guidelines
decommitment: disrupted by the Force Majeure within chapter3.1, 4.1,
extension of the the eligibility period and with EU 11.1
deadline for support. CPR 2014-2020
cancelling liabilities (Art. 136)
until 31 December
2024 (by one year,
ana logous to
extending the period
of eligibility of
expenditure)
Phasing of projects • Lower the financial limit applied, so it CPR 2014-2020
started in 2014-2020 would be possible to phase smaller (Art. 111)
period into 2021-2027 projects (currently a minimum of 5M CPR 2021-2027
without restrictions EUR is applied). (Art. 118)
• Solution is needed also for operations, Closure Guidelines
*Requires adaptations where there is no funding for the chapter 6
across both 2014- phase currently envisaged in 2021-
2020 and 2021-2027 2027 or where thematic concentration
periods rules limit de facto phasing.
Major projects and ln case of member states where
phased projects environmental impact assessment (EIA) is
two stage process (as it covers
environmental decision stage and executive
decision stage e.g., construction permit)
Commission should accept the option of
conditional project financing even in relation
to investments with pending EIA to be
completed at executive decision stage. ln
other words, contract for financing or major
project decision should be possible after
completion of the first stage of EIA.
Additionally, Commission should accept
financing of phased projects even in
situation where environmental decision for
the second phase of the project has not
been obtained and will be planned to obtain
after concluding contract for financing or
issu ing major project decision.
The approach which is presented above will
facilitate the project implementation
process and contribute to better absorption
.
Legislativeor
Proposal (short) Explication non-legislative
- changes needed
of EU funds so required in the times of
economic slowdown.
lncrease the threshold • Extension of flexibility applied to the CPR 2014-2020
of the flexibility contribution from the Funds to a (Art. 130(3))
mechanism from 10 % priority through payment of the final Closure Guidelines
to 20 % and enable to balance is needed. chapter 4.3
decare overbooked • Allow using this flexibility also
expenditure before across different funds and
final accounting year. categories of regions.
• It should be made possible to carry
over expenditure declared to the
Commission in excess of the
priority’s allocation to the next CPR 2014-2020
accounting year. (Art. 130 (3))
• if a priority using 100% co-financing Closure Guidelines
above this maximum Funds chapter 4.3, 4
contribution from the priority, e.g.
due to expenditure already deciared
in 2021, the Member State will not
at the moment be able to make use
of the above mentioned flexibility,
which is only possible in the final
accounting year.
Regarding the replacement of ineligible
expenditure with overbooked expenditure,
flexibility is needed to be able to declare
overbooked expenditure, which meets the
eligibility conditions also for interim
payments.
This will make it possible to contract and
certify up to 110% (or 120% if increased) of
the allocation of the priority axis at the
expense of allocation in another priority
axis (with in the same fund and category of
regions), without the need to change the
program.
Immediate (earlier
than in the last
accounting year) the
possibility of using the
10% (or increased)
flexibility mechanism
between priority axes
Legislative or
Proposal (short) Explication non-legislative
changes needed
of the same program
(within the same fund
and category of
reg ions).
More flexibility to • Longer period for completion of Closure Guidehnes
complete projects projects after the eligibility period, chapter 7
after the eligibility where it has been impossible to
period underway and complete them before the eligibility
major projects (non period runs out.
functioning projects) • More flexible approach of the COM as
regards the amendments to MP
• A lower lim it for total costs of the
projects that can be completed after
the eligibility period without recovery of
the support from the European Union
budget (currently a minimum of 2M
EUR).
• Higher hmit for the percentage
regarding the allocation from the
operational program me that can be
affected by such projects (currently 10
%) = increase to 30 % or no limit at all.
Extension of the The extension is justified in connection with CPR 2014-2020
validity of the the crisis situation related to the ongoing (Art. 92b (10))
regulations (related to armed conflict in Ukraine, with regard to
the COVID-19 quick approval of changes to the
pandemic). operational program, similar to the solutions
applied in REACT-EU
Allowing transfers between thematic CPR 2014-2020
objectives within the same priority without (Art. 30(5))
the need for a decision of the Commission
approving the amendment of the
programme, but only on the basis of
inform ing the Commission about such a
chanqe.
“CARE+” additional measures
-
Extension of the Extension of the 100% EU co-financing rate CPR 2014-2020
100% co-financing for another year to achieve a sufficient (Art. 25a)
rate (by CARE) to effect of the measure.
another accounting
year (2022—2023)
Other measures
Cohesion fund Given that the capital regions receive large
amounts of refugees but have very limited
allocations from ERDF and ESF to begin
with, the possibility of using the remaining
Legislative or
Proposal (short) Explication non-legislative
.... -
chagesneeded
allocation from the Cohesion Fund to aid
refugees should be expiored. While the
scope of the Cohesion Fund is restricted, an
option of using the remaining funding
available there, possibly via transfers to
other funds would be helpful.
2. 2021—2027 programming period
. Changeof
Proposal (short) . : Explication . . the
-....-.-—
100% co-financing for Increase of the co-financing rate is an efficient CPR 2021—
the first year(s) of the measure in a crisis period (as COVID-19 2027
programming period experience has demonstrated), therefore it (Art. 1 12)
makes sense to use it also in the current
situation.
Quick and smooth Given the deterioration of the economic
approval of ouUook due to the war and the pressing need
Partnership to improve resilience in multiple areas, the
Arrangements and 2021-2027 programmes need to be up and
programmes running as soon as possible. We ask the
Commission to adopt the partnership
agreements and programmes as a matter of
priority.
Optional reserve up to Given that the effects of the war have only YES
5% in the new started to unfold and that the new
programmes to programmes cannot be delayed until clarity on
manage the effects of its effects arrives, we propose a possibility to
the war create an optional reserve in the national
envelope, that could be used in programmes
to tackle the direct and indirect impacts of war
as they anse without additional bureaucracy
and additional negotiations of the Operational
Programmes
Exception from the Similarly to CR11 and CRII+. YES
thematic ERDF/CF
concentration Regulation
requirements for (Art. 4)
selected operations
Flexibility for transfers Permit transfer up to 8 % of the programme
across priorities and priority allocation and no morethan 4% of the
operational overaH programme budget to another priority
programmes of the other programmes without Commission
consent. This will increase the agility of
response to an evolving situation.
Eligibility of completed Similarly to CRII+ for the COVID-19 crisis, CPR 2021—
or fully implemented exception from the measure prohibiting to 2027 (Art.
operations support physically completed or fully 63 (6))
implemented operations before the
application for funding is submitted. The
operations mitigating the immediate effects of
the crisis need to be implemented as swiftly
as possible and there is a risk that they could
be completed before the approval of the new
2021-2027 programmes, which would make
them ineligible according to the current rules.