The Common Principles for the Rail Baltica 1435 mm railway Spatial and Territorial Planning and
Preliminary Design Study (Jointly agreed version by Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania)
The below principles are for the single spatial/territorial planning study, if possible and feasible under
national procurement rules carried out by one consortium.
The below principles once agreed upon between Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania are to be entirely
entered and codified in the relevant tender dossiers (Terms of References, contracts, etc) of Estonia,
Latvia, and Lithuania. Should the need occur to change any of the below principles during the
spatial/territorial planning process and preliminary design the Task Force needs to agree upon the
relevant amendments.
Further study (spatial/territorial planning and preliminary design study) deals with the preferred
route, based on the Final report of the feasibility study (AECOM study).
Further study shall provide in depth analysis of the preferred route alignment and provide detailed
technical solutions.
Further study provides all necessary inputs to start technical design, land acquisition, and
construction phase.
In any phase of the planning process, any significant deviations in technical parameters designed by
AECOM study should be discussed, justified, and approved by the Task Force.
For the sake of clarity the principles have been divided into five sections: strategic principles,
technical principles, environmental principles, financial principles, and administrative principles.
Common outputs by the end of 2015 are outlined separately.
Common outputs achieved in line with the below principles by the end of 2015 (the so-called „Box”)
a) A final detailed alignment of the railway throughout the entire territories of Estonia, Latvia,
and Lithuania has been adopted.
b) Detailed spatial/territorial plans for the entire route to be adopted by the relevant
authorities according to relevant national legislation.
c) Spatial/territorial plans for the entire route in the scale of 1:20 000 or in the scale put
forward by the national legislation.
d) Preliminary design for the line and for the ancillary infrastructure in the scale of 1:2000 to
1:10 000 (depending on the urbanisation and population patterns). The preliminary design is
understood as the design phase that precedes detailed technical design. Detailed technical
design/technical project is understood as a final design phase before the construction works
can start.
1
e) Technical construction studies/site investigations necessary for the preliminary design to be
carried out (geology etc).
f) Strategic environmental impact assessment and environmental impact assessment is carried
out and finalised.
g) A list of pieces of land that need to be acquired for the construction works is compiled.
h) An updated CBA.
1) Strategic Principles
- The spatial/territorial plans and further studies in Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania aim to
seek most feasible alignment of the railway on the route Tallinn-Pärnu-Riga-Kaunas-
Warsaw (the most feasible preliminary alignment proposed by the AECOM study is taken
as a basis).
- The spatial/territorial plans are done in the scale of 1:20 000 or according to the relevant
national legislation. The preliminary design for railway infrastructure in urban areas is
done at least in the scale of 1:2000 and in rural or non-populated areas in the scale of
1:10 000.
- The railway is TEN-T core network fast conventional line with the maximum design speed
of 240 km/h and has mixed international passenger and cargo pattern. The countries
may investigate possibilities of regional traffic, and additional branches, however only
complementary and with purpose for further corridor development stages.
- The strategic environmental impact assessment and environmental impact assessment
as part of it is to be carried out as part of the spatial/territorial planning process
according to the national legislations.
- The consultants are tasked with keeping the stops for passengers the minimum possible
in order to maintain competitive speed and travel times for international passenger
services. Passenger stations must be provided only for places of great passenger
potential only. The consultants for the spatial/territorial planning study are to be tasked
with finding technically and economically most feasible locations for the stations for the
passengers. If necessary the needs for regional transport are solved with branch lines.
Consultants are to be tasked with developing the most feasible solutions to the stations
with all the necessary optimal ancillary infrastructures.
- While finding the final alignment of the route economically and financially the most
feasible option needs to be chosen. The relevant conditions in the nature and other
relevant criteria need to be taken into account.
2
- In parallel with finding the alignment for the 1435 mm line the consultants are tasked
with finding possibilities to use the existing railway land corridor, where it might prove to
be useful, and already in place infrastructure, whenever it is more feasible than
constructing an entirely new line or allows to avoid disproportionate costs for land
acquisition. The aim is to reduce costs; this means avoiding the use of dual gauge
solutions and any other interaction with existing 1520 mm rail system must be minimised
and complicated design solutions should be avoided as far as possible (except for freight
braches). Whenever such a possibility is used the consultants are obliged to thoroughly
justify such solutions.
- While finding the final alignment the Consultants are tasked with avoiding the villages,
towns, townships, and other areas with dense population to the maximum extent
possible. The latter is with the exception of planned stations for the passengers.
- The spatial/territorial plans need to provide locations and preliminary solutions to the
multimodal passenger terminals and public logistic centres, including the provision of
possibilities for the integration of the local public transport, airports, ports, etc.
- The preliminary design for the entire route and for the ancillary infrastructure in urban
areas at least in the scale of 1:2000 is to be carried out. In rural or non-populated areas
the preliminary design is to be carried out at least in the scale of 1:10 000. The level of
detail of the spatial/territorial plans needs to be sufficient to undertake detailed
technical design as a next step once the spatial/territorial plans have been adopted. The
detailed technical design is to be undertaken according to the relevant national laws. The
detailed technical design undertaken afterwards is the final step before the
procurements for construction can be launched.
- The level of detail of the spatial/territorial plans and preliminary design needs to be
sufficient to start with the land acquisitions once the spatial/territorial plans are adopted
and preliminary designs completed.
- The Rail Baltica is foreseen for the international movement of passengers and freight as
its principal purpose. Therefore it is to be designed and constructed from the latter point
of view. From point of view of the movement of passengers it is to become fast
conventional railway with the stops only at the key nodes for the passengers. From
current point of view the Rail Baltica does not serve as a railway for the domestic
interregional transport. This doesn’t preclude possibility of such traffic on later
operational stages (if such kind of traffic will be possible under actual train pattern and
will not affect efficiency of trains serving the principal tasks of the line).
- The number of crossings between the railway and roads needs to be minimum possible.
The number of different level crossings needs to be minimum possible. The crossings on
the same level between the railway and the roads are not allowed, except for branch
sections with allowed maximum speed of 120 km/h and whereas such of a solution is
significantly cheaper than crossing in different levels.
3
- The consultants need to choose the alignments in a way that minimises the later cost of
land acquisitions. The latter can be achieved via choosing the alignment that goes
through less valuable real estate, the land owned by the state, the real estate without
established buildings and without granted building titles, avoidance of cultural heritage
and densely populated areas, etc.
- While planning the final alignment the route and solutions that are able to attract more
freight in the future once the railway has been constructed are to be favoured.
- In parallel with the spatial/territorial planning and by the same consultant the
preliminary design is to be carried out for the final alignment of the route. The level of
detail for the preliminary design needs to be sufficient to carry out the detailed design
once the spatial/territorial planning phase is completed. The consultants are obliged to
carry out all the relevant site investigations according to the national laws. The detailed
technical design undertaken afterwards is the final step before the procurements for
construction can be launched. The preliminary design is to be undertaken to the final
track alignment according to which there is 1435 mm double track line with all the
necessary stations for the passengers, stops for cargo trains and with the ancillary
infrastructure in the optimal extent. The railway is to be entirely electrified and the
preliminary design needs to solve the electrification and the relevant infrastructure too.
The preliminary design also needs to be carried out for all the junctions, crossings,
(including level crossings where appropriate), stations for the passengers and multimodal
passenger/freight terminals.
- The relevant infrastructure and rolling stock maintenance facilities (for instance depots)
need to be foreseen.
- The consultants carrying out the study are obliged to provide detailed project
management and implementation plan including estimations of time and money needed
for the later technical detailed design and for the environmental impact assessment (if
necessary) once the preliminary design has been completed.
- The consultants are obliged to fully cooperate with the relevant consultants in the
neighbouring country with the aim of ensuring coherent alignment and - technical
solutions, fully interoperable railway across borders and the possibility to undertake
detailed design with single procurement for Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania. The latter at
least includes co-operation while carrying out strategic environmental impact
assessment, while carrying out cost-benefit analyses, while working out technical
solutions, and while carrying out preliminary design. The latter is to be included in the
contract with consultant. If necessary the practical issues of cooperation are to be done
via Task Force.
4
- The consultants must outline and propose the most feasible inter-state border crossing
points in each of the participating country (Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania). Based on the
latter proposal a joint memorandum of understanding is prepared for signing by the
relevant ministers from each of the country.
2) Technical principles
- The track alignment is planned in spatial/territorial plans as double track 1435 mm 25 KV
AC electrified line on the entire length. The line is fully electrified (if necessary except for
freight branches) with all the necessary stations, stops, and with all the necessary
ancillary infrastructures in the optimal extent.
- The spatial/territorial planning process needs to identify the exact locations and extent
for the permanent as well as temporary ancillary infrastructures (access roads,
technological crossings, service entrances of the electrical installations, communications
infrastructures, power stations, land needed by the contractor to carry out construction,
etc). The costs of the ancillary infrastructures need to be reflected in the total cost of
construction works and in the corresponding cost-benefit analysis.
- The railway is to be built according to the Railway Interoperability Directive 2008/57/EC
(Directive 2008/57/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 June 2008 on
the interoperability of the rail system within the Community) and the relevant Technical
Specifications for Interoperability (TSIs), taking in account the on-going process of high
speed and conventional rail TSIs being merged. The likelihood of the road users to
appear on the railway needs to be fully ruled out.
- The line category1 should be P2/F1, providing where possible without any additional cost
for the construction phase track geometry compliant with category P1 requirements.
Technical requirements should also be consistent with infrastructure parameters for
main international railway lines mentioned in appendix of European Agreement on Main
International Railway Lines (AGC).
- The spatial/territorial plans and the preliminary designs are compiled according to the
technical requirements from the TEN-T Guidelines Regulation (Regulation of the
European Parliament and of the Council on Union guidelines for the development of the
Trans-European Transport Network) in art 45 (2).
- The maximum speed is 240 km/h (projected speed for geometry).
- The likelihood of the appearance of the outsiders (including animals) on the railway
needs to be ruled out.
1
In accordance with Working document Draft Technical Specification for Interoperability Subsystem
Infrastructure v. 1.7.
5
- All the technical studies/construction surveys carried out in parallel with the
spatial/territorial planning need to be sufficient in order to compile a preliminary design
for the railway in parallel with the spatial/territorial plan. All data for construction
surveys/site investigations need to be as recent as possible. The consultant carrying out
the spatial/territorial planning study is responsible for engaging enough resources to be
able to deliver the required outcomes in due time.
- The consultants are obliged to find an efficient location of the stops for the cargo trains
overpassing by passenger trains with the aim to ensure efficient and flexible later
operation of the railway, and the efficient use of the lands.
- While solutions for the different level crossings are analysed the alternative options need
to be considered (bridge, tunnel, closing/eliminating the crossing road).
- The Specific Cases provided in TSIs as stated in Directive 2008/57/EC for Poland and
Germany need to be taken into account.
3) Environmental principles
- The consultant shall be obliged to carry out strategic environmental impact assessment
and environmental impact assessment and all the related activities according to the
relevant EU and national legislation.
- While setting the final alignment and the route of the railway all the existing and planned
Natura sites and other environmental protection areas where construction is prohibited
are to be avoided to the extent possible (entirely if possible). As a rule constructing
railway through the Natura sites needs to be ruled out. In order to achieve the latter aim
the total length of the line can be slightly increased (the best alternative needs to be
chosen). The consultants are to be tasked to find most feasible alignment of the route
and avoid any necessary extension of the total length proposed by the AECOM study. The
consultant for the spatial/territorial planning study is tasked with avoiding the Natura
sites. The burden of proof that Natura sites cannot be avoided is embedded with the
relevant consultant. The consultant is to be obliged to start with the determination of
the Natura sites immediately after the contract is signed and is obliged to carry out pre-
screening if necessary.
4) Financial principles
- An updated and more detailed Cost-Benefit analysis needs to be carried out after the
preliminary design is in its final stages. The consultant shall provide a CBA model and
train users to support the countries updating CBA in last project development stage,
which is detailed technical design.
6
- The consultants in Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania need to cooperate and exchange
information about the preliminary costs and benefits in order to be able to compile the
updated cost-benefit analyses for the entire route.
- As part of the spatial/territorial planning study and according to the cost assessments
based on the preliminary design carried out (including the cost of land and the cost of
the environmental mitigation measures) and according to the assessment of the benefits
(including realistic financial benefits and socio-economic benefits) a cost-benefit analysis
is carried out to the following alternatives:
a) Do maximum alternative. The railway is to be constructed as double track 1435
mm line with all the necessary stations for the passengers (including the relevant
ancillary infrastructure), stops for cargo trains and with the ancillary
infrastructure in the optimal extent. The railway is to be entirely electrified (with
the entire relevant infrastructure). The railway is built with all the necessary
junctions, crossings, level crossings (except for branch lines) stations for the
passengers and multimodal passenger terminals. (Do maximum alternative as
proposed by the AECOM study).
b) Do minimum alternative. Consultants need to provide additional technically
feasible alternative solutions to reduce costs. ‘Do minimum alternative’ must be
technically compiled in the manner that would leave the possibility for later
upgrades to the ‘Do maximum alternative’ on the same alignment.
The cost-benefit analysis is carried out according to the relevant guide from the European
Commission: „Guide to cost-benefit analysis of investment projects, 2008. The consultants
are obliged to bear in mind that the European Union can finance up to 85% of the cost and
that the cost of land acquisitions cannot exceed 10% of the eligible cost.
5) Administrative and miscellaneous principles
- Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania undertake all the necessary efforts to achieve hiring the
consultant (signing the contract) start carrying out spatial/territorial planning and
preliminary design in the second half of 2012. Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania undertake all
the necessary efforts to achieve completion of the spatial/territorial planning process,
the preliminary design, and updated cost-benefit analysis by the end of 2015.
- If permitted by the national procurement legislation the tender dossiers (especially the
contract and the payments) can and should foresee the provisions according to which
the consultant is additionally rewarded once the spatial/territorial planning and
preliminary design is carried out more quickly that end-2015. It must be ensured
7
however that the outcome of the consultants work is fully in line with the relevant
national legislation and according to the Terms of References.
- If permitted by the national procurement legislation the contracts should allow to order
additional services from the consultants carrying out spatial/territorial planning and
preliminary design (for the works that cannot be foreseen currently). The latter should
be up to 15% of the initial cost of the contract without VAT.
- To the extent possible international open tendering procedures are to be used.
- The consultants are to be obliged to use all the necessary key experts to undertake
spatial/territorial planning and preliminary design and to deliver the outcomes required
by the relevant contracts and the current principles.
- The consultants in Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania need to cooperate and exchange
information.
8
Trans-European Transport Network
Executive Agency
Work Programmes 2007-2013
CALLS FOR PROPOSALS 2012
APPLICATION FORM
for EU financial aid in the field of
the trans-European transport network
PART B.2
Technical and financial information
Spatial Planning and Technical Studies for Rail Baltic (Estonian
Title of the proposed action
section)
TENtec number 25982008
For TEN-T EA use only
Received on: Number:
Version 24/11/2012 2
To fill in this Application Form, follow guidelines provided in Annex 3 of the Guide for Applicants
1. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF THE GLOBAL PROJECT
1.1. General outline of the Global Project
Historically, railway transport in the Baltic States has been related with the East-West axis, which is also
reflected in the present railway traffic flow. From the physical point of view, railway transport services are
offered on a track gauge of 1 520 mm, which makes the operation of interworking with Poland difficult. The
railway system in the Baltic States is not compatible with the standards in the continental Europe, wherefore it
has been decided by now that Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania should be fully integrated in a wider railway
transport system.
In October 2001, the European Commission initiated revision of the TEN-T guidelines. As a result, the
European Parliament and the council adopted the resolution No. 884/2004 in April 2004, which changed the
community guidelines regarding the TEN-T development. This decision paid special attention to the
development of interstate infrastructure projects, as a response to the increase in international traffic, to the
promotion of the intra-EU coherence, especially with regard to European-wide transport corridors in new
member states, as well as to the conception of the motorways of the sea. Within the framework of this
th
decision, the Rail Baltic axis Warszawa – Kaunas – Riga – Tallinn was set as the 27 priority project with the
following time schedule:
i. Warszawa – Kaunas (2010);
ii. Kaunas – Riga (2014);
iii. Riga – Tallinn (2016).
th
On the 15 of September 2003, the Rail Baltic coordination group (representing Poland, Lithuania, Latvia and
Estonia) agreed on main aspects that should be taken into account in further studies related to the Rail Baltic
th
investments. Thereafter, on 27 March 2006, the ministers of transport of the four countries signed a
declaration of intent for the execution of the Rail Baltic project. From November 2005 until December 2006,
the EC Directorate General for Regional Policy prepared a strategic study for the Rail Baltic railway. In the
final report published in January 2007, it was stated that none of the options is considerably different from the
economic point of view.
th
On 8 of June 2010, at conference „TEN-T Days 2010: Trans-European Transport Networks” held in
Zaragoza/Spain, the ministers of transport of Poland, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia and Finland signed a
memorandum expressing their political intent to continue with the implementation of the Rail Baltic project.
th
Besides that, the Rail Baltic development plans have been assessed in the context of the White Paper of 28
March 2011: Roadmap to a Single European Transport Area – Towards a competitive and resource efficient
transport system. Hence, the Action is aimed at the maturisation and preparation of the future TEN-T Core
Network, which aims to become funded under the Connecting Europe Facility (CEF). Although, still a draft
Regulation, the Rail Baltic project is part of a TEN-T Core Network listed in the Annex of the Regulation.
Furthermore, the Rail Baltic is a crucial part of the Baltic-Adriatic corridor, which is currently absent.
The development of Rail Baltic meets the national planning strategies for the improvement of railway network
and stimulating economic development in all three Baltic countries.
Amongst others, further guidelines for the development of Rail Baltic have been established in the Joint
th
Declaration signed on 10 of November 2011 by the Prime Ministers of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania (Annex
th
3), and in the agreement signed by the ministers of transport of the same countries on 7 of December 2011.
The aforementioned Declarations (Annex 4) reflect the political consensus achieved between the three Baltic
States to move forward with the Rail Baltic 1435 mm gauge project.
The project aims to finalise the preferred alignment provided by Activity 1 of project “Studies for a European
gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S. Hence, the current application is directly
linked to the previous Decision. The current Action is necessary due to the need to fully mature the project
for construction works, for which the scope of works need to be extended to spatial planning and to
preliminary design. In order to maximise the potential to finance the construction phase of TEN-T Priority
Project No 27 “"Rail Baltica" axis: Warsaw-Kaunas-Riga-Tallinn-Helsinki” during EU financing period 2014-
Version 24/11/2012 3
2020 it is paramount to finalise the alignment of new 1435 mm gauge railway line in county plans of three
counties the preferred alignment passes through. To achieve the best results a preliminary technical design
for the railway line will be procured together with spatial planning activities.
1.2. Current situation and main needs addressed by the Global Project
Currently there is no 1435 mm railway connection in Warsaw-Kaunas-Riga-Tallinn corridor. The existing
railway lines only provide maximum speeds of 120 km/h on renovated sections. As a result there are no
direct passenger or freight services within the railway corridor as the existing infrastructure does not allow for
competitive services compared to alternative modes of transport. Hence, the aim of the current Action is to
fill in this gap and to prepare a fully mature project in order to contribute to the achievement of a fully
functional Trans-European Transport Network.
1.3. Main objectives of the Global Project
The objective of the project is the development of North-South railway corridor that is interoperable with the
rest of European railway network and competitive in terms of quality with other modes of transport. The
project would dramatically improve the connection possibilities in Baltic Sea region (Estonia, Latvia,
Lithuania and Finland) with Central Europe and vice versa, thus contributing significantly to the development
and functionality of the EU Internal Market. The creation of new railway infrastructure also aims towards
modal shift of passenger and freight traffic from road, air and maritime transport to rail. The modal shift from
road to rail transport will result in lessening of transport-related CO2 emissions throughout the region.
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED ACTION
2.1. General outline and context of the proposed Action
The Activity 1 of project “Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-
27010-S provided the Governments of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania with clearly defined options for further
th
development of Rail Baltic corridor. As a result the Joint Declaration signed on 10 of November 2011 by the
Prime Ministers of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, and the agreement signed by the ministers of transport of
th
the same countries on 7 of December 2011 foresee spatial planning activities to finalise the exact
alignment 1 435 mm gauge railway line as one of the most important steps in continuation of the
th
development of Rail Baltic. On 12 of April 2012 the Government of Estonia ordered the initiation of county
thematic plans for Harju, Rapla and Pärnu counties. Based on the mandate given by the Estonian, Latvian,
and Lithuanian Ministers of Transport (see Declaration in the Annex 4) an inter-ministerial coordination
group – Rail Baltic Task Force – was created. The aim of the coordinating group is the coordination of short
and long-term preparation activities of the new Rail Baltic 1435 mm line. The Task Force consists of two
senior officials from Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and Poland. The European Commission participates
as an observer. The Task Force has been mandated by the ministers to coordinate all the preparatory works
of the new 1435 mm Rail Baltic line throughout the Baltic States and Poland. Based on the latter mandate
given by the ministers, the Task Force agreed upon Common Principles for Spatial Planning (Annex 6,
hereinafter Common Principles for Spatial Planning), which Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania use as a basis for
carrying out the preparatory works. One of the most crucial elements of the document, effectively a work-
plan for the Member States concerned, is the achievement of preliminary design of the new 1435 mm gauge
railway throughout the Baltic States by the end of 2015. It is completely necessary that the preparatory
works are harmonised among the Baltic States and that the EU TEN-T grant decisions are geared at
achieving the outputs set forth by the Common Principles. The current proposal builds on the
aforementioned existing TEN-T grant decision and is directly linked to it.
2.2. Main objectives of the proposed Action
The proposed Action serves to prepare the implementation of the Global Project. The proposal is put forth to
fulfil the agreement on the level of the Rail Baltic Task Force, which is enshrined in the Common Principles
th
for Spatial Planning and Preliminary Design agreed upon on 13 of June 2012 (Annex 6). The main
objectives of the Action are following:
Finalisation of railway corridor within county plans;
Preparation of preliminary design of railway track and railway related structures in full compliance
with the relevant domestic legislation;
Updated financial studies reflecting the actual alignment and construction-related costs;
Preparation of tender documentation for the next stage of the Global Project (detailed design);
Version 24/11/2012 4
Preparations for the construction work of the Rail Baltic new 1435 mm gauge line to begin
2017/2018;
Guaranteeing legal basis and documents for continuation of the Global Project following the
proposed Action;
Contribution to the realisation of the TEN-T Core Network and the development of the EU Internal
Market.
2.3. Contribution of the proposed Action to the Global Project
The proposed Action creates a level of maturity within the Global Project that enables to apply for funding of
detailed design and construction from Connecting Europe Facility for programming period 2014-2020. The
applications for detailed design and for construction works shall preferably be joint applications by Estonia,
Latvia, Lithuania and Poland (including their respective Implementing Bodies). The current Action creates a
common technical basis and full maturity for such joint applications.
2.4. Indicators on proposed Action's implementation
As the Action consists of studies the possible indicators with objectively measurable numerical values and
are linked to the achievement of set formal project objectives within the implementation of the Action.
County plans prepared and adopted according to the applicable legislation
Preliminary design achieved and approved according to the applicable legislation and according to
the Common Principles for Spatial Planning
Updated financial studies achieved
Clear work plan on local and international level for future activities and joint applications achieved
The successful implementation of the Action works towards achievement of performance indicators of the
Global Project, such as:
Reduced travel time of 3.36 hours for section Tallinn – Riga;
Reduced CO2 emissions up to 617 Tonnes by 2040.
2.5. Description of the Activities of the proposed Action (including their interdependencies)
Activity 1: Spatial planning and preliminary technical design.
Subactivity 1: Preparation of thematic county plans.
The inclusion of railway corridor in strategic county plans is a legal prerequisite for continuation of
Rail Baltic project. In the framework of the Activity thematic plans for Harju, Rapla and Pärnu
counties are prepared.
The thematic county plans provide a predetermined corridor for the new railway line on territory of
Estonia on alignment Tallinn – Pärnu – Estonian/Latvian border. Alternative route corridor solutions
are analysed , an assessment methodology (economic, social, and environmental impacts) defined,
persons and authorities interested in the plan determined, as well as participated in the inclusion and
informing of the public, and creation of a technical possibility for combining the strategic assessment
of environmental impacts and the plan. Within the plans, the required studies, analyses and models
are carried out. As a part of the thematic county planning process strategic environmental impact
assessment (SEIA) and environmental impact assessment (EIA) are carried out. They are to be
carried out in full compliance with the relevant EU directives (the Directive 2011/92/EU, the Directive
2001/42/EC, the Directive 92/43/EEC). NOTE: SEA and EIA are carried out in the framework of
existing project “Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-
27010-S to optimise the use of available funding. SEA/EIA have been separated as they are
separable from other related activities and estimated cost of SEA/EIA corresponds to the available
finances still available in the aforementioned project. The amendment proposal for the existing
financing decision will be presented in parallel with the present application. Hence, the two Actions
are inter-related and part of a single continuum to mature the Rail Baltic project.
Subactivity 2: Preliminary technical design of railway track and essential railway related structures
(according to applicable legislation)
Based on the best route option, a final route axis is designed with an accuracy of a preliminary
technical design (including the plan and the longitudinal profile of the relevant locations) with all the
geometric parameters required by railway standards. The railway is design in full compliance of the
1
TSI standards already in force and TSI standards in development and with the relevant legislation
of the interoperability. In the preliminary technical design, all intersections with roads are indicated
1
Full list of TSIs available on European Railway Agency website (http://www.era.europa.eu/Core-
Activities/Interoperability/Pages/TechnicalSpecifications.aspx).
Version 24/11/2012 5
and the locations of perspective railway stations determined. In order to specify critical data,
technical studies (geology, survey, traffic studies, etc.) are carried out if necessary, based on which
a specific railway route can be drawn in the nature.
Preliminary technical design of railway track can be used to apply for construction permits of the new
railway line, significantly reducing the time needed for this kind of administrative activities during the
next phase of the Global Project.
Subactivity 3: Budgeting and cost-benefit analysis
Budgeting will be made with regard to alternative route corridors for the preparation of principal
designs and operational drawings as well as for building volumes under the framework of thematic
plans and the strategic environmental assessment (general), the detailed plans (general), the draft
designs of buildings required for the railway and its operation and the construction works related its
construction (general), and the preliminary designs for construction works required for the railway
and its operations, and preliminary designs for construction works related to the construction of the
railway (in detail). During the budgeting, in cooperation with owners/possessors of utility networks
the need of reconstruction of existing utility networks is determined and the cost of the required
works is calculated.
The feasibility and cost/benefit analysis is updated in accordance with the selected route solution.
Activity 2: Consultation with public and stakeholders. Publicity with the interested parties.
The publication process of Activity 1, thematic county planning involves a lot of activities. The legally
required publications of different stages of the process include public displays, public meetings,
announcements in national and local newspapers and written notifications to all interested persons.
Democratic and open engagement of the interested parties
Considering the national importance of the Rail Baltic project it is vitally important to achieve
maximum visibility of the project in the public eye and to ensure that the information in the public
sphere is at all times up-to-date and consistent.
The Activity involves both quantitative and qualitative studies to analyse the efficiency of publication
activities.
Activity 3: Project Management.
The successful implementation of Activities 1 and 2 involves direct control of national authorities
since a representative must be present at all meetings. Also it is imperative to ensure that the
information on all levels is homogenous. The Activities run parallel in three counties therefore the
amount of work is outside the capabilities of existing staff at all involved national authorities. For this
purpose at least two (2) specific positions whose responsibilities are strictly connected with the
fulfilment of the Action. Sufficient manning is crucial to prepare high-quality infrastructure projects.
The Activity includes meetings with other stakeholders (including Latvian, Lithuanian, Finnish and
Polish representatives) and taking part in management process of the Global Project.
Increasing stakeholder involvement and knowledge of Rail Baltic to maximise the potential of the
Global Project in the nearest possible implementation phases.
Activity 4: Expertise on technical solutions.
Estonia currently has very limited knowledge of designing and preparing the 1435 mm gauge railway
project, thus putting forward a justified need for the relevant expertise;
The most efficient and up to date technical solutions must be used in order to achieve best possible
value for money for the EU-funded projects;
National Building Act sets the requirement that all design documents that result in construction have
to be assessed by an independent assessor. As the preliminary technical design undertaken in
Activity 1 will be basis of application for permits for construction an independent expertise is needed
to validate the technical solutions described in preliminary technical design documents.
Activity 5: Preparation of tender dossier package for the next procurements and technical assistance on EU
applications.
The next stages of the Global Project (detailed technical design and construction) is directly
connected with the level of maturity achieved for the further financing from European Union
financing period 2014-2020. To achieve the maximum efficiency and maturity of the next steps, the
procurement documents for detailed technical design and the future applications for the future
Connecting Europe Facility will be compiled within the proposed Action.
Version 24/11/2012 6
2.6. Action Plan (graphic representations)
Please provide a Gantt chart detailing the critical path and including the milestones of the proposed
Action and their interdependencies.
Action Plan is provided in Annex 8
2.7. Location of the proposed Action
The Action will involve the area linked to Priority project No 27 “"Rail Baltica" axis: Warsaw-Kaunas-Riga-
Tallinn-Helsinki” on the territory of three Estonian counties – Harju, Rapla and Pärnu. The railway corridor
subject to the Action runs the entire length of western part of Estonia from Tallinn to Pärnu and to the
Estonian-Latvian border.
Provided that the Rail Baltic new 1435 mm gauge alignment runs through the territories of Estonia, Latvia,
Lithuania, and Poland, the current Action has a wide cross-border impact. In addition, to aforementioned
Member States, the Action shall have a very positive impact to Finland, thus representing a significant added
value in the Baltic Sea Region. Furthermore, the Rail Baltic project is one of the projects of the EU macro-
regional strategy – the Baltic Sea Strategy.
Version 24/11/2012 7
2.8. Overview of the Action
Activities Expected Results Milestones On critical path (yes/ Means of Verification
no)
Activity 1: Spatial planning and preliminary Thematic plans, - Publication of a tender yes - Tender documents have
technical design preliminary technical - Signature of a tender been published
designs of railway track contract - Tender contract has been
and associated - Approval of results signed
structures and cost- - All activities within tender
benefit analysis with contract are formally
updated budget are approved
approved
Subactivity 1: Preparation of thematic county Thematic plans have - Initial options of the yes - Formal approval of initial
plans been completed, thematic planning options is signed
approved and presented corridor - Formal approval of
to the Ministry of Interior - Preliminary designs of preliminary designs of
for supervision thematic plans thematic plans is signed
- Thematic plans - Formal approval of
- Thematic plans to thematic plans
supervision - Thematic plans are sent
- Thematic plans enacted to the Ministry of Interior for
by the county governors supervision
- Legal enactment act by
the county governors
Subactivity 2: Preliminary technical design of The preliminary technical - Submission of a list of yes - A list of present and
railway track and essential railway related design for railway track required railway sections future railway sections is
structures and essential railway - Sketch solutions for the presented
related structures have railway line - Sketch solutions are
been completed and - Preliminary technical approved
approved for the entire design - Preliminary technical
length of the railway line design is formally approved
Subactivity 3: Budgeting and cost-benefit Updated cost-benefit - Submission of general yes - General budgeting is
analysis analysis is completed budgeting of route approved
with the full budget of the corridors - Updated budgeting
next stage of the Global - Submission of results are approved
Project budgeting on draft - CBA is formally approved
designs and land
acquisition costs
- Submission of full CBA
Activity 2: Consultation with public and The required publication - Public website yes - Public website is created
stakeholders. Publicity with the interested parties. activities have been - Public announcement of - Public announcements
carried out, a central county plans are carried out
website for both Action - Public meetings related - Public meetings are
and Global Project have to county plans carried out
been created - Qualitative and - Studies are carried out
quantitative studies and formally approved
Activity 3: Project Management Appointments for - Appointments to the no - Appointments to the
sufficient staffing have relevant positions relevant positions have
been made to carry out - Taking part in project been made
the Activities 1 and 2, meetings - Project meetings have
have been thoroughly - Taking part in meetings been attended
monitored, Global Project with external - Meetings with
stakeholders are involved stakeholders stakeholders have been
attended
Activity 4: Expertise on technical solutions Expertise on preliminary - Publication of a tender no - Tender documents are
technical designs in - Signature of tender published
Activity 1 have been contract - Tender contract is signed
carried out - Tender contract is - The activities are formally
fulfilled approved
Activity 5: Preparation of tender dossier package Tender documents for - Publication of a tender no - Tender documents are
for the next procurements and technical detailed technical design - Signature of tender published
assistance on EU applications have been completed, contract - Tender contract is signed
application documents - Tender contract is - The activities are formally
for next stage of Global fulfilled approved
Project have been
prepared
Version 24/11/2012 9
2.9 Risk Assessment Grid by activities
Activity N° Risk Impact Likelihood Control Mitigating measure(s)
Activity 1: Spatial Public opposition High High Under Public consultations, sufficient involvement of
planning and of some of the the interested parties, sufficient information
preliminary interested about the project provided
design parties. NIMB
Activity 2: (Not In My
Consultation with Backyard) effect
public and
stakeholders.
Publicity with the
interested parties
Activity 1: Spatial Insufficient staff High Low Under Project Management, sufficient team for the
planning and to prepare a preparatory works; sufficient number of
preliminary mature and appointments at the right time
design efficient project
Activity 2: Insufficient staff High Low Under Project Management, sufficient team for the
Consultation with to prepare a preparatory works; sufficient number of
public and mature and appointments at the right time
stakeholders. efficient project
Publicity with the
interested parties
Version 24/11/2012 10
3. RELEVANCE: CONTRIBUTION OF THE PROPOSED ACTION TO THE TEN-T
POLICY OBJECTIVES AND EU DIMENSION
3.1. Contribution of the proposed Action to TEN-T priority projects, or classification as a project of
common interest
The Action is aimed to further development of Tallinn-Riga section of priority project No 27 “"Rail Baltica"
axis: Warsaw-Kaunas-Riga-Tallinn-Helsinki”. Along with similar actions undertaken by Latvian, Lithuanian,
and Polish authorities the Action creates a maturity level for the priority project to move forward into the
phase of physical implementation (works). The Action is geared at the realisation the Baltic-Adriatic corridor
of the TEN-T Core Network.
3.2. Contribution of the proposed Action to TEN-T priorities
The Action aims to eliminate the bottleneck in railway transport that exists on priority axis No 27
within the Baltic States due to separate 1 520 mm track gauge railway network that is not
interoperable with European 1 435 mm gauge railway network. As a result there are currently no
railway traffic flows on north-south axis within the priority corridor.
The action aims to develop interconnection of the Baltic States region with Central European railway
network (and vice versa) via Poland. No such active connection exists at the moment due to
interoperability constraints. Due to the nature and state of the existing 1 520 mm gauge network
there are currently no active railway passenger and freight services between Baltic capitals Tallinn,
Riga and Vilnius. Hence, the Action aims to create a link that is currently absent from the TEN-T
Core Network.
The new railway line will be designed with 1 435 mm gauge thus conforming to all requirements of
technical specifications of interoperability (TSIs). The new railway line will be the first railway line in
the region to fully comply with the requirements of TSIs.
The Action supports intermodality as on the territory of Estonia the Rail Baltic railway line will access
the Port of Muuga where the intermodal freight terminal will be accessible for rail, sea and road
transport, both passenger terminals will be interconnected with urban and suburban transport modes
(bus and tram services). In the further stages of Global Project a direct link between Ülemiste
passenger station and Tallinn Airport is envisaged. Therefore, the Action aims to connect and to
integrate the key passenger and freight nodes.
The Action is directly linked with development of sustainable mobility of persons and goods along
with the aim to achieve modal shift from road and air transport to limit CO 2 emissions.
3.3. Contribution of the proposed Action to the objectives of the (sub-) priority under which the
proposal is submitted.
For the Priority Projects concerning rail, road and inland waterways the Action aims to fulfil following
objectives:
The Action aims to eliminate the bottleneck in railway transport that exists on priority axis No 27
within the Baltic States due to separate 1 520 mm track gauge railway network that is not
interoperable with European 1 435 mm gauge railway network. As a result there are currently no
railway traffic flows on north-south axis within the priority corridor.
The Action aims towards modal shift of passenger traffic from road and air transport and freight
traffic from road and sea transport to railways that will result in decrease of traffic-related CO2
emissions.
The Action supports intermodality on the priority axis No 27 as on the territory of Estonia the Rail
Baltic railway line will access the Port of Muuga where the intermodal freight terminal will be
accessible for rail, sea and road transport, both passenger terminals will be interconnected with
urban and suburban transport modes (bus and tram services). In the further stages of Global Project
a direct link between Ülemiste passenger station and Tallinn Airport is envisaged. Therefore, the
Action aims to connect and to integrate the key passenger and freight nodes.
3.4. Contribution of the proposed Action to the internal market, the cohesion policy and the Europe
2020 strategy
Through the aim of removing the existing bottleneck on priority axis No 27 the Action aims to provide
individuals, consumers and businesses in Baltic States, Poland and Finland new and efficient
possibilities to access Central Europe and to increase the capacity for free movement of people,
goods, services and capital. Therefore, the Action significantly contributes to the functioning of the
EU Internal Market.
The Action prepares the project of a common interest, which would increase the competitiveness and
economic growth of the associated countries. Efficient and low-carbon transport connections are
inevitable pre-requisite of the future economic growth. The facilitation of free movement of goods and
people shall contribute to the economic growth.
As a result of the existing bottleneck on priority axis No 27 the Baltic States are not fully integrated
into the economic environment of European Union thus creating a bottleneck for regional
development in the area. Through the aim of removal of the aforementioned bottleneck the Action
aims to further economic and social cohesion between Baltic States and Central Europe. Hence,
improving the cross-border connectivity as a central aim.
Through the development of new railway line conforming to TSIs the Action aims to provide priority
axis No 27 with sustainable mode of transport as the modal shift from road, air and sea transport
towards electric rail traffic will result in decrease in traffic-related CO2 emissions.
3.5. Socio-economic benefits of the proposed Action at macro level
The feasibility study carried out as Activity 1 of project “Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica
(Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S analysed the demand models for both passenger and freight traffic,
taking into account both existing demand and demand created by new infrastructure.
For possible demand a common approach to forecasting changes in rail demand following changes in
service provision or pricing is through the application of simple elasticities. This approach can provide a
useful starting point for when there is an existing rail service and can reduce the need for more complex
transport modelling. Within the Baltic States however there is only a very limited existing rail service across
national borders, which means there is no existing rail demand to forecast forward from. Internal to each
country although there are existing rail services the proposed high speed Rail Baltic service is likely to
provide a “step change” in level of service which means that the simple elasticity approach will only provide
part of the answer. The main component of potential demand for Rail Baltic is transfer from existing
competing modes such as road, coach and air and therefore a modelling approach which captures the
transfer from other modes is required. A modelling suite was developed that represents both the existing
base year demand by different modes as well as the generalised cost (in terms of wait time, travel time,
fares and vehicle operating costs) of making journeys by these modes.
The results were compared with existing data from similar infrastructure projects to determine the level of
service that would result in a modal shift.
The existing passenger traffic volume between Tallinn and Pärnu is approximately around 3 500
passengers per day, only 2% of them using rail transport, 98% of passengers travelling either by
cars or coaches. The existing passenger traffic volumes on road between Tallinn and Riga are
approximately 1 500 per day with additional 400 using air traffic. These are the demand figures for
the existing infrastructure without stable railway connection on Tallinn-Pärnu-Riga alignment.
With the new conventional high-speed railway line the demand figures for 2030 would be
approximately 3 300 passengers per day on Tallinn-Pärnu section and approximately 2 400 on
Pärnu-Riga section.
Due to lack of services there is currently no existing demand of freight traffic on Tallinn-Pärnu-Riga
section.
With the new railway line the induced demand would amount to approximately 12.9 million tonnes.
3.6. Added-value of EU funding on the financing of the proposed Action and the commitment of the
different stakeholders
The proposed Action is unparalleled in scope for all the Baltic States. The estimated costs of all activities
within the Action are considerable in relation to available finances for infrastructure. Therefore the
implementation of the Action solely from national budget results in considerable strain on national budget
and would result in the Action to not be carried out or being significantly delayed. Therefore, EU funding is
crucial to the timely achievement of the Rail Baltic new 1435 mm gauge line and hence eliminating the
bottleneck of a currently absent link. The funding of the Action shall aim to mature the project to be funded
from the Connecting Europe Facility. The EU funding for the Action is the catalyst for pledging national
resources.
Version 24/11/2012 12
3.7. Cross-border section
This section aims at verifying whether or not any section of the proposed Action corresponds to the definition of
2
cross-border sections .
A. Does the Action require actions/construction works on both sides of the borders between Ye s
two Member States? No
If yes, indicate which Member States are directly concerned and which activities each of them will be carrying
out.
B. Does the Action ensure, via a third country, continuity of a priority action between two Ye s
Member States? No
If yes, indicate which Member States and third country are directly concerned and which activities each of them
will be carrying out.
C. Is the Action located on the territory or largely on the territory of a single Member State in Ye s
the proximity of the border but not actually crossing it, and is this Action necessary to link No
the network to the neighbouring Member State or a third country?
If yes, provide justification for classifying the Action (or part of the Action) as cross-border and explain which
activities the Member State(s) will be carrying out.
The Action is in line with the Common Principles for Spatial Planning, which aims to harmonise the
outcomes among the associated Member States of the Project. The Action is linked to similar activities
undertaken by the Government of Latvia on the Estonian-Latvian border-Riga-Latvian-Lithuanian border
section. The Ministry of Transport of Republic of Latvia has published a tender for similar activities that
constitute the Action. The Ministry of Transport of Lithuania is also preparing a similar tender for the railway
line on Lithuanian territory.
D. Has a written agreement been concluded between the Member States concerned or Ye s
between the Member States and third countries concerned relating to the completion of the No
cross border section, in accordance with Article 3.3 of the TEN Regulation?
If yes, describe the main elements of this agreement and attach a copy of it in annex.
E. Have the Member States concerned made a joint commitment regarding the action, i.e. (a) Ye s
concluded a formal written agreement at appropriate level, (b) agreed a common financial No
plan or coordinated financial plans, (c) agreed on a common timetable for studies and
works, including a coordinated date of opening to service, (d) agreed on how the Member States concerned
coordinate their procedures for assessing environmental effects and socio-economic effects thereof, and
how the use their best endeavours to conduct a trans-national enquiry prior to the granting of the building
permit?
Clarify and detail as appropriate, and attach copies of the related documents
2
http://tentea.ec.europa.eu/download/calls_2012/definition_cross_border_sections_en.pdf
Version 24/11/2012 13
The associated Member States act on the basis of the Joint Declarations by the Prime Ministers and by the
Transport Ministers (see Annexes). The partner countries have agreed the Common Principles for Spatial
Planning, which harmonise the preparatory works and set the level of maturity of the Action (see Annex).
The latter document is effectively the work-plan for the preparatory works of the Rail Baltic 1435 mm project
and foresees the common timetable for studies. A formal written agreement in the form of inter-state contract
is to be signed as an aftermath of the Action, which aims to outline mutual obligations between the partner
countries for the future actions and for the construction works. The financial plans and applications have
been and are to be coordinated on the level of Rail Baltic Task Force. The environmental effect of the Action
is limited, since the scope of the Action is studies.
F. Have the Member States (and potentially third countries) concerned created a common,
Ye s
technically and financially indivisible structure for the implementation of the action?
No
If Yes, explain the role and legal status of this structure, and attach the relevant legally binding
agreement(s).
G. Provide information on the financial viability of the cross-border action and on the timetable Ye s
for carrying it out. Explain which guarantees are issued - preferably jointly - by the Member No
State(s) to ensure this viability and the timetable. This applies also if the applicant is not a Member State.
Attach these guarantees in annex.
H. Have the Member States concerned already notified to the Commission that this Action has Ye s
been identified as a cross-border section, in accordance with Article 28 of the TEN-T No
Guidelines?
If Yes, attach in annex the related document. If No: shall this application for EU financial support at the
maximum rate of 30 % be considered as a notification of the Action as a cross-border section?
This application should not be considered as a notification of the Action as a cross-border section. The
application is made for Studies with the EU financial support of 50% as stipulated in Regulation (EC) No
680/2007 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2007 laying down general rules for the
granting of Community financial aid in the field of the trans-European transport and energy networks.
4. MATURITY OF THE PROPOSED ACTION
4.1. Approval of the proposed Action
The Action has been authorised by the Government of Estonia (see Annex5). Ministry of Economic Affairs
and Communications, Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority and Harju, Rapla and Pärnu county
governments have signed a co-operation contract for carrying out Activity 1 of the Action. Harju, Rapla and
Pärnu county governments have initiated SEIA for Activity 1. NOTE: SEA/EIA will be carried out within
Activity 2 of project “Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-
S. Tender for Activity 1 of the Action has been published by Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority on
th th
30 of January 2013. The opening of tenders is scheduled for 25 of March 2013 and the contract is
expected to be signed in April 2013.
Version 24/11/2012 14
4.2. Political commitments to the proposed Action (and Global Project)
Further guidelines for the development of Rail Baltic have been established in the Joint Declaration
signed on 10th of November 2011 by the Prime Ministers of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, and in the
agreement signed by the ministers of transport of the same countries on 7th of December 2011.
(see Annex 4). Among others the guidelines confirm the preferred alignment defined by Activity 1 of
project “Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S.
To fulfil the set objectives in Estonia the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications with the
cooperation of other relevant authorities has been tasked to begin thematic planning for Harju,
Rapla and Pärnu counties with additional task of organising sufficient funds for self-financing of the
Action. The guidelines of further development of Rail Baltic set the aim towards application for
funding from European Union Financial Framework 2014-2020 to finance the construction phase of
the Global Project.
th
The Joint Declaration signed on 10 of November 2011 by the Prime Ministers of Estonia, Latvia
and Lithuania declared the importance of finishing the preparatory phases and starting with the
construction of the new Rail Baltic standard gauge (1435 mm) railway line during the next EU
Financial Framework 2014-2020. The declaration agreed to start spatial and regional planning;
tasked their respective national authorities with preparing and implementing the necessary steps;
agreed, that the planning, including adjustments to routing solutions, must ensure real connections
between the key nodes and that the new corridor should not only complement, but also leverage the
existing transport infrastructure.
th
The agreement signed by the ministers of transport of the aforementioned countries on 7 of
December 2011 stated that all partner countries should take necessary steps to complete domestic
territorial planning processes for the 1 435 mm gauge electrified high-speed conventional railway
line by the end of 2015.
th
The order of the Government of Estonia from 12 of April 2012 initiated the process of thematic
planning for Harju, Rapla and Pärnu counties.
4.3. Public consultation
The activities undertaken during the Action require a high level of publicity by law.
A public website of the Action will be set up to provide up-to-date information on on-going planning
activities, environmental impact assessment processes and preliminary technical design.
Public displays of sketch thematic plans, SEA program, SEA/EIA reports and final thematic plans
will be held along with public meetings for stakeholders to voice their opinion and concerns. The
notifications of public displays and meetings involve publications in national and local newspapers
along with official letters to all persons concerned.
A central publication plan will be implemented to provide up-do-date information of the Action and
the Global Project through all available media channels.
4.4. Readiness / technical maturity of the proposed Action
th
For Activity 1 the tender has been published on 30 of January 2013. The contract is expected to be
signed in April 2013.
For Activities 2-5 the preparations will begin depending on the results and the time-schedule of
tender for Activity 1.
4.5. Building permits /N/A/
Subject of building permit procedure Date of award of If relevant, Foreseen start
building permit foreseen date of date of works
award of building
permit
Version 24/11/2012 15
4.6. Procurement
4.6.1 Procurement in general
The tender for Activity 1 is an open international tender. For Activities 2 and 3 the procurement process will
be limited due to its limited financial scope according to the Public Procurement Act of Estonia. Activities 4
and 5 will be procured via open tender procedure.
4.6.2 Contracts already awarded and procedure(s) applied
No contracts will be awarded before the submission of the proposal for the Action.
4.6.3 Procurements planned during implementation
In addition to the on-going tender at least two public tenders, for Activities 4 and 5, are planned. The actual
number and the need is to be determined according to the Estonian public procurement act.
4.7. Pending legal/administrative/technical issues
N/A
4.8. Information on funding sources (state budget(s), regional / local budget(s), applicant's self-
financing, EIB loan(s), other loan(s))
Co-funding for the Action will be provided by state budget.
4.9. Other sources of EU funding
No other sources for the implementation of the Action are currently available.
4.10. Public-private partnership
Public-private partnership is inapplicable as the Action consists of public functions that cannot be delegated
to private bodies.
4.11. Revenues of the proposed Action
The Action does not generate any revenue.
Version 24/11/2012 16
5. IMPACT OF THE PROPOSED ACTION
5.1. Impact of the study as a decision-making tool
The Action finalises the alignment of 1 435 mm gauge railway line defined by Activity 1 of project “Studies for
a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S and is a direct prerequisite for
entering construction phase of the Global Project.
Cost-benefit analysis with budgeting provides the Governments of the Baltic States with the final tool for
deciding whether to continue with the Global Project and enter to the construction phase. The cost-benefit
analysis also provides a specific amount of the European Union financing required for the successful
implementation of the Global Project.
5.2. Impact of the study in terms of policy-making and developing best practices
The Action is directly linked to TEN-T network priorities as a part of priority axis No 27 “"Rail Baltica" axis:
Warsaw-Kaunas-Riga-Tallinn-Helsinki”. The preferred alignment is named as one of the main priorities for
transport development within national development plan Estonia 2030+.
The Action is the only available instrument for finalisation of the 1 435 mm gauge railway line on the territory
of Estonia. The results of the Action will determine the national strategy for infrastructure development during
European Union Financial Framework 2014-2020.
The Action can be used as a development tool for best practices as it aims to use available time and
resources in the most efficient manner, bundling together spatial planning with preliminary technical design
and financial studies.
Version 24/11/2012 17
5.3. Ex-ante evaluation(s)
Ex-ante evaluation of the Action was undertaken as Activity 1 of project “Studies for a European gauge line for
Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S. The evaluation was co-financed by TEN-T at the rate of
50% (total costs have to date ran up to 125 292.67 Euro; however all the amounts available under the decision
2007-EE-27010-S shall be fully used).
Initially over 20 different route segments were considered before condensing them down to 4 key route
options, designated the red, orange, yellow and green routes. The red and yellow routes were for the most part
on new alignments the primary difference between them being in Estonia where the red route passes through
Pärnu and the yellow route passes through Tartu. The orange and green routes followed for the most part the
existing route corridors and again the primary difference is in Estonia where the orange route passes through
Pärnu and the green route passes through Tartu.
For each of the four options freight and passenger demand was assessed along with other issues including
environmental impacts and the wider economic benefits, based upon an initial assumption of a mixed service,
with passenger trains every 2 hours and freight trains running predominantly during the night. The results of
the assessment showed that for passengers the yellow option would be best. The reasons for this were that it
offered a fast journey time and picked up a significant internal demand at Tartu. For freight the greatest
demand was seen on the red route predominantly as a result of the shortest journey time. The key issue with
freight demand was however found to be price.
A full qualitative assessment of each route option was undertaken taking into account the wider economic
benefits, the potential planning impacts and environmental issues. From this analysis it was recommended that
the red route option should be investigated further, in the form of a detailed Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA) as it
was felt that it offered the potentially most viable solution.As stated above the red option is primarily on a new
alignment passing through mainly agricultural and forest land. Obviously a full Environmental Impact
Assessment will have to be undertaken as part of the future project development (NOTE: SEIA/EIA will be
undertaken as Activity 2 of project “Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” -
2007-EE-27010-S).
The results from the CBA, based on the assumptions made for the project are such that the project can be
considered as generally viable. With an overall discount rate of 5.5%, there is a positive NPV of 1,368M EUR,
at 2010 prices, and a benefit cost ratio of 1.75. The corresponding EIRR is 9.3%. However, in normal
circumstances to attract EU funding for transportation projects The EIRR would normally have to be greater
than 11.0% and the BCR higher. Political factors will be a serious factor in the future of this project both in
terms of the desire of the EU to link the Baltic States with the rest of the EU using a standard gauge railway
and in terms of the individual Baltic States whose development could be stimulated by this project.
In addition, the Financial Analysis shows the project having a positive cumulative cash flow in all years
suggesting that at this level the project is financially stable. Financial indicators of the investment, without EU
funding, show negative results emphasising the importance of securing the EU funding. Although, FRR/K on a
consolidated basis (IRR of national investments), which has been calculated in accordance with method set
out in the EC Guide to Cost Benefit Analysis of Investment Projects is 3.10%.
The project should be able to be implemented to comply with the Technical Standards of Interoperability, but
certain parameters will need to be carefully engineered in relation to infrastructure, energy, and control-
command and signalization systems. The overall framework and procurement of the required operational
equipment will also need close scrutiny to comply with directives related to rolling stock, operations and
information systems.
The Executive Summary of the studies is included in Annex 7 of the proposal
5.4. Financial analysis
The financial analysis was undertaken for the Global Project as Activity 1 of project “Studies for a European
gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S with the Action covering the Estonian
section. A reference period was 20 years, from 2020 to 2040.
The results from the CBA, based on the assumptions made for the project are such that the project can be
considered as generally viable. With an overall discount rate of 5.5%, there is a positive NPV of 1,368M
EUR, at 2010 prices, and a benefit cost ratio of 1.75. The corresponding EIRR is 9.3%. However, in normal
Version 24/11/2012 18
circumstances to attract EU funding for transportation projects the EIRR would normally have to be greater
than 11.0% and the BCR higher.
Sensitivity tests were run for the CBA on the whole route focussing on the key variables of capital cost,
spend profile, operation and maintenance costs, demand, cost of time savings and GDP growth. With each
parameter change the NPV remained positive, but in the case of a 50% freight demand drop only just. There
is no reason to believe that most of these variables are correlated; however, it is possible that some of them
will be downside whilst others are upside at the same time. For this reason, to assess the likely results of
parameter fluctuation a risk analysis was conducted using @Risk which uses a Monte Carlo simulation
approach. The result of the risk analysis is that there is a more than 95% chance that the NPV will be
positive.
5.5. Social and economic impact
The socio-economic analysis was undertaken for the Global Project as Activity 1 of project “Studies for a
European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S with the Action covering the
Estonian section.
A key element of the economic cost benefit analysis was allocation of monetary values to the non-market
impacts of the scheme. These are impacts that are relevant to society but for which a market value is not
available. Impacts include:
Savings in travel time
Prevention of road fatalities and accidents from diverting passengers and freight to the Rail Baltic
Reductions in road air pollution emissions from diverting passengers and freight to the Rail Baltic
Reductions in green house gas emissions from diverting passengers and freight to the Rail Baltic
The passenger group experiencing the greatest time saving benefit are Rail Baltic users who previously
travelled by train, there are however very low levels of existing international demand using rail in the corridor
meaning that this group is very small. Rail Baltic users who previously travelled by other modes, such as bus
or car, experience lower benefits per person than users who previously travelled by train due to the
application of the rule of a half. Nonetheless, this group forms the majority of the passenger time saving
benefits due to the large number of passengers who are expected to shift to Rail Baltic from competing
modes. There is also a benefit to users who remain on the road due to reduced congestion and improved
travel times in the Rail Baltic Corridor. It should be noted, however, that road decongestion benefits are
expected to be very low relative to time saving benefits experienced by users who shift to Rail Baltic.
The monetary benefit for casualties avoided is provided in the EC Guide to Cost Benefit Analysis of
Investment Projects. The total volume of traffic removed from road by passengers and freight shifting to the
Rail Baltic service was determined from the demand models by calculating the change in road vehicle km that
result from implementing the Rail Baltic service. It should be noted that the new rail service will remove a
significant volume of trucks from the road. This amounts to a large reduction in vehicle km due to the long
distance of truck trips, which in turn leads to significant accident savings. Reductions in vehicle km in each
country were calculated, allowing the country specific cost per accident provided by the EC guidance to be
applied. These benefits were calculated over a 24 hour period and then annualised. Over the 30 year
appraisal period 6 560 accidents are expected to be avoided, (leading to a reduction of fatalities of 856, a
reduction of severe injuries of 1 591 and a reduction of light injuries of 6 402). These accident reductions
have a corresponding monetary value of 1 652 million Euros, equivalent to an average annual benefit of 55.1
million Euros. The accident reduction benefits were discounted to a 2010 base to take account of the fact that
benefits and costs that occur in the future are valued less highly than those that occur in the shorter term.
This results in a total discounted accident reduction benefit over the 30 year appraisal period of 338 million
Euros. When splitting benefits between nations benefits have been allocated according to the country in
which the accident reduction occurs (including an element allocated to Poland). This leads to total discounted
accident saving over the 30 year appraisal period of 116 million Euros in Estonia, of 105 million Euros in
Latvia and of 89 million Euros in Lithuania.
Reductions in emissions were calculated separately for motorway, primary, secondary and urban roads. This
was necessary as the average speed of vehicles, and therefore the emission per vehicle km will vary
significantly across the different road types.
Over the 30 year appraisal period air pollution reduction benefits total 704 million Euros, equivalent to an
average annual benefit of 23.5 million Euros. The air pollution reduction benefits were discounted to a 2010
base to take account of the fact that benefits and costs that occur in the future are valued less highly than
those that occur in the shorter term. This results in a total discounted air pollution reduction benefit over the
Version 24/11/2012 19
30 year appraisal period of 148 million Euros.
When splitting benefits between nations benefits have been allocated according to the country in which the
emission reduction occurs (including an element to Poland). This leads to total discounted emissions saving
over the 30 year appraisal period of 35 million Euros in Estonia, of 29 million Euros in Latvia and of 77 million
Euros in Lithuania.
The EC Guide to Cost Benefit Analysis of Investment Projects provides estimates of monetary value of CO 2
emissions savings that have been identified by the IMPACT study. Over the 30 year appraisal period CO2
emission reduction benefits total 1 778 million Euros, equivalent to an average annual benefit of 59.3 million
Euros.
The CO2 emission reduction benefits were discounted to a 2010 base to take account of the fact that benefits
and costs that occur in the future are valued less highly than those that occur in the shorter term. This results
in a total discounted CO2 emission reduction benefit over the 30 year appraisal period of 342 million Euros.
When splitting benefits between nations benefits have been allocated according to the country in which the
emission reduction occurs (including an element to Poland). This leads to total discounted climate change
saving over the 30 year appraisal period of 117 million Euros in Estonia, of 108 million Euros in Latvia and of
85 million Euros in Lithuania.
5.6. Impact of the proposed Action on traffic management, congestion, modal split, inter-operability,
service quality, safety and security
The Action aims towards positive modal split in passenger and freight traffic flows on north-south axis. As
the sustainability of the Global Project is directly linked with modal shift from road and air transport towards
rail it will also have a positive effect on traffic congestion on roads on Tallinn-Riga direction. The modal shift
from road to rail will also significantly raise the safety of road traffic as indicated in section 5.5.
The Action aims to generate rail services on the north-south axis that are virtually non-existent at present.
As the aim of the Global Project is to provide interoperable railway line with the standard 1 435 mm gauge
railway network the Action has a distinct positive impact on the interoperability of Estonian railway network
with the rest of European railway network. As the existing network is operated on 1 520 mm gauge and is
largely interoperable with third countries the Action also results in two parallel railway traffic management
systems.
5.7. Impact of the proposed Action on regional and / or local development and land use
The proposed Action has definite positive impact on development of both Tallinn and Pärnu regions and the
entire western part of Estonia. For Tallinn the main impact is creation of a new transport link that is better
connected with other modes of transport via Ülemiste passenger station. For the Pärnu area the impact is
even greater, creating a fast connection with both Tallinn and Riga, creating both better possibilities for local
economy and providing local residents with better access to employment in both directions.
For other regions in the western part of Estonia the effects can also be moderately negative as the influence
of Tallinn and Pärnu as population and economic centres will grow, pulling away both population and some
areas of business while still opening new economic possibilities.
As the prospective railway line essentially cuts the territory of Estonia into two it can also have detrimental
effect to the agricultural sector in the region as some of the farmland will be inaccessible. Local transport
corridors will also be affected as there will be no level crossings on the entire length of the railway line.
5.8. Impact on competition
As stated in section 5.8 the Action will have definite effects on pulling power of some of the regions affected.
On a larger scale the Action considerably increases competition between alternative modes of transport for
both passenger and freight services.
On the Community level the Action considerably increases the competitive ability of Estonia and other Baltic
States as aims towards elimination of the existing bottleneck and providing a high quality and sustainable
mode of connection with Central Europe.
Version 24/11/2012 20
5.9. Impact on the environment
The impact of the Action on the environment is two-fold. On one hand it aims towards modal shift towards
sustainable mode of transport on the north-south axis and reduction of CO2 emissions. On the other hand the
projected railway line will affect natural and social habitats and disrupts existing wildlife corridors. Therefore,
the associated mitigation measures must be designed according to the relevant Impact Analyses.
A complete impact assessment will be carried out as Activity 2 of project “Studies for a European gauge line
for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S.
6. QUALITY OF THE PROPOSED ACTION
The breakdown of eligible costs is part of the quality of the proposed action. As this information is provided in
section A 3.3 of the application form it is not duplicated here.
6.1. Organisational structure
The Action is carried out in co-operation between the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications,
Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority and Harju, Rapla and Pärnu counties.
The contractor for all the activities will be Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority that will also issue all
formal approvals connected to the Action.
6.2. Control procedures and quality management during implementation
The thematic plans will be presented to the Ministry of Interior for supervision. The Ministry of Interior will
assess the soundness of both planning process and results.
Preliminary technical designs will be assessed by an independent body to be procured as Activity 4.
Everyday implementation of the Action will be supervised by the project management team composed of staff
of Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications and Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority. The
project management team will regularly report to the Minister of Economic Affairs and Communications, to the
Government of Estonia and on the level of the Global Project to the international Task Force of Rail Baltic.
6.3. Risk management methods and procedures
The main risks associated with the proposed Action are:
Public opposition of some of the interested parties or the so-called NIMB (Not In My Backyard) effect
that may delay implementation of Activity 1;
Insufficient staff to prepare a mature and efficient project that has an effect throughout all the
Activities
The associated risks are under control and manageable. The first risk is managed by public consultations,
sufficient involvement of the interested parties, sufficient information about the project provided that is also a
part of the current proposal and directly linked to the second main risk. The risk associated with insufficient
staff is also under control and manageable with project management, sufficient team for the preparatory
works and sufficient number of appointments at the right time. The risk is greatly managed by Activity 3 of
the current proposal.
6.4. Ex-post monitoring and audits
Completed thematic plans will be supervised by the Ministry of Interior after completion of Activity 1.
Preliminary technical design will be supervised by independent technical experts in the framework of Activity
4 of the current proposal.
Version 24/11/2012 21
6.5. Communication and visibility given to the TEN-T co-financing
The communication activities are carried out in accordance with TEN-T guidelines. The Action website will
have direct references to the TEN-T co-financing. All the materials compiled during the Action will be
equipped with relevant information and imagery, all press releases will include information on TEN-T co-
financing in accordance with the guidelines.
6.6. Other information
7. ANNEXES
All relevant information for assessing the proposal must be provided in the Application Form. The purpose of
annexes is to provide additional, supporting information. Annexes or their specific relevant sections should be
referred to in the application's relevant parts
Annex 1: Application form Part A
Annex 2: Application form Part B1
Annex 3: Joint Statement of the Prime Ministers
Annex 4: Declaration of Intent of Transport Ministers
Annex 5: Regulation of the Government of Estonia on implementation of thematic county plans
Annex 6: Common Principles for Spatial Planning
Annex 7: Executive Summary of Global Project Activity 1
Annex 8: Action Plan
Annex 9: Financial Identification form
Annex 10: Legal Entity form
Annex 11: Statute of Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority
Version 24/11/2012 22
FINAL
PRIME MINISTERS' COUNCIL OF
THE BALTIC COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
JOINT STATEMENT
The Prime Minister of Estonia Mr. Andrus Ansip, the Prime Minister of Latvia Mr. Valdis
Dombrovskis, and the Prime Minister of Lithuania Mr. Andrius Kubilius met within the framework of
the Baltic Council of Ministers on 10 November in Tallinn, Estonia. The Prime Ministers discussed the
key issues of trilateral cooperation and coordination of actions as prioritised at their informal meeting in
Vihula, Estonia on 10-11 February 2011.
Economy and finance
The Prime Ministers:
1. stressed the importance of the Single Market as the main engine for unleashing growth and job
creation and welcomed, in this context, the relevant steps for sustainability and growth foreseen
in the Commission’s roadmap and highlighted by the European Council on 23 October;
2. committed themselves to support the speedy adoption of necessary measures, in particular those
related to the Digital Single Market;
3. noted that the comprehensive set of measures adopted by the Euro Summit on 26 October helps
to restore confidence and address adequately the tensions of the financial markets and stressed
also the need for all Member States to continue with structural reforms and necessary fiscal
adjustments; noted with satisfaction that the adjustments implemented during the crises in
Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania have delivered good results;
4. reaffirmed their commitment to the single currency as a pillar of economic growth and stability
and in this context stressed the need to continue with the deepening and widening of the euro
area. Noted that enlargement of the single currency zone must be an open process based on the
fulfilment of established criteria;
5. The Prime Ministers of Latvia and Lithuania reaffirmed their commitment to join the euro area
as soon as possible;
6. reaffirmed their intent to strengthen mutual coordination in the negotiations on the Multiannual
Financial Framework 2014-2020, particularly focusing on Cohesion Policy and Common
Agriculture Policy, particularly focusing on Cohesion Policy and Common Agriculture Policy;
7. noted EU’s on-going commitment (as stated in the Lithuanian accession treaty) to ensure
adequate appropriations for the decommissioning of Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant during the
next Financial Perspectives and, in this context, expressed their conviction that this commitment
will be duly reflected in the Multiannual Financial Framework 2014-2020.
FINAL
Knowledge-based economy
The Prime Ministers:
8. acknowledged the efforts of the relevant experts addressing in detail the issues highlighted in the
Chairman’s conclusions of the Prime Ministers` informal meeting in Vihula and reiterated the
aim of the Baltic States to become the leading European region in electronic documents and e-
government solutions;
9. emphasized the importance of continuing to work in close co-operation on the interoperability of
digital signatures and on the common Baltic approach to digitally signed cross-border electronic
documents;
10. agreed to work together to accelerate the preparation of EU policy aimed at the harmonization of
copyright for the purpose of creating a functioning digital single market by 2015;
11. welcomed the “fund of fund” initiatives covering all the Baltic States for funding high-growth
innovative companies in the Baltic States and tasked the relevant experts to continue with
preparations aimed at finding the most effective and mutually acceptable solution by spring
2012;
12. concluded that comprehensive work carried out on the expert level provides a solid basis for
defining further co-operation potential for promoting a knowledge-based economy;
13. welcomed the European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) new vision and 2014-
2020 working priorities, and emphasised the need for closer cooperation of the EIT and the
Baltic States academic institutions and business community.
Energy
The Prime Ministers:
14. Acknowledged the importance of the Communication of 7th September, 2011 of the European
Commission on Security of Energy Supply and International Cooperation, and the Commission’s
proposals for a Regulation on guidelines for trans-European energy infrastructure and Regulation
establishing Connecting Europe Facility as appropriate measures in addressing the issue of
energy isolation of Baltic States;
15. welcomed the selection of the Strategic Investor into Visaginas nuclear power plant project and
the progress made in negotiations on the project agreements
16. underlined the need to apply the highest nuclear safety standards in the nuclear power plant
projects in the region, especially in the EU neighbouring states;
17. acknowledged the importance of BEMIP Reflection paper “Baltic electricity market and
operating Baltic electricity grid” and Communication of the European Commission on Security
of Energy Supply and International Cooperation as a substantial contribution in achieving
common interest of the Baltic States declared in Vihula to become synchronously operating
FINAL
integral part of European Continental Power Network, while agreeing that more clarity on the
details are needed before final decision is taken;;
18. emphasized the need for more visible progress in the introduction of a common power exchange
no later than January 1, 2013;
19. agreed to task their respective ministers to work out a solution with the view to introduce
common regime on electricity imports from third countries by 2016 (dependent on the outcomes
of the study) and to present this report during the next Prime Ministers meeting;
20. emphasized the need for closer cooperation in the unbundling of the transmission system
operators of electricity and gas sectors;
21. welcomed the Commission's willingness, as expressed in the BEMIP high level group meeting
on 24 October 2011, to conduct an independent regional feasibility study to analyze the viability
and location of a regional LNG terminal;
22. committed to co-operate within the BEMIP framework to develop the regional LNG (including
possibly the Amber Pipe Line) project feasibility study pending on the agreement and decision of
the Commission and other parties.
Transport
The Prime Ministers:
23. acknowledged the Commission proposal to establish the Connecting Europe Facility and
welcomed the proposal to develop the trans-European transport network, underlining the
importance of completing the core network of the trans-European transport network by 2030 at
the latest, and implement the comprehensive networks in due time;
24. welcomed the Commission’s initiative to include the Rail Baltic corridor Tallinn-Pärnu-Riga-
Kaunas-Warsaw in the pre-identified projects list of the core network and emphasized the
importance of support from various EU financial instruments for the implementation of the
project;
25. welcomed the conclusions of the Final Report of the Feasibility Study for a Standard Gauge
Separate Railway Line within the Rail Baltic Corridor through Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania
carried out by AECOM Limited and presented in May 2011, and expressed their political support
for this study;
26. declared the importance of finishing the preparatory phases and starting with the construction of
the new Rail Baltic standard gauge (1435 mm) railway line during the next EU Financial
Framework 2014-2020;
27. agreed to establish a joint venture of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania by the end of 2012 at the
latest, to implement the project;
FINAL
28. agreed to start spatial and regional planning; tasked their respective national authorities with
preparing and implementing the necessary steps; agreed, that the planning, including adjustments
to routing solutions, must ensure real connections between the key nodes and that the new
corridor should not only complement, but also leverage the existing transport infrastructure;
29. authorized their respective ministers to agree a memorandum of mutual understanding at the
meeting of the transport ministers of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania in December 2011 for the
further development of the new Rail Baltic railway infrastructure (including the establishment of
a joint venture and the beginning of spatial planning) and asked their ministers to report on the
progress made at the end of 2012;
30. agree that the EU financing for the project should be allocated outside the national cohesion fund
envelopes, and that the EU co-financing intensity should be around 85%;
31. invited Poland to join in the full implementation of the new Rail Baltic corridor, stressing the
need to coordinate implementation activities along the entire line between Tallinn and Warsaw;
32. reaffirmed the intent to finish the construction works and start preparations to operate interstate
passenger trains on the existing railway infrastructure by 2016.
Security and defence
The Prime Ministers:
33. exchanged views in preparation of the NATO Summit in Chicago, including on the Alliance's
present and future activities in Afghanistan;
34. stressed the need to achieve a long-term solution for NATO Air Policing in the Baltic States as a
clear demonstration of solidarity and commitment among the Allies;
35. underlined the importance of remaining committed to striving towards 2% of GDP for defence
expenditures even in the current challenging fiscal environment;
36. stressed the critical need for raising awareness in society regarding cyber threats and underlined
the importance of improving international cooperation between states, international institutions
as well as public and private sector for enhancing cyber security, and the fight against cyber
crimes;
37. reaffirmed the need to adequately address energy security risks and to further dialogue between
states to form a common vision for energy security in the region as well as welcomed Lithuanian
efforts to the accreditation of the Energy Security Center as a NATO Center of Excellence;
38. reiterated the need for further strengthening of defence cooperation among the Nordic and Baltic
countries with a special focus on practical mutually beneficial projects as well as global security
interests and challenges;
FINAL
39. emphasized the need for closer defence cooperation between Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania in
defence planning, capability development and procurement;
40. agreed to explore the possibilities of enhancing cooperation in the border security field, including
better use of European instruments like Frontex, and tasked national experts with providing
conclusions at the next BCM meeting.
Social issues
The Prime Ministers:
41. underlined the importance of the use of joint procurements of medicinal products and medical
devices with the aim of ensuring the rationalization of procurements and optimal use of available
resources;
42. welcomed the preparation of the Partnership Agreement on Joint Procurements of Medicinal
Products and Medical Devices and invited the Task Force for Health to prepare the Agreement
for signing in the beginning of 2012;
43. welcomed the efforts of the Task Force to continue cooperation in the transplantation field and to
establish an efficiently functioning human organ transplant system in the Baltic States;
44. called on the Task Force for Health to continue its work.
The next meeting of the Prime Ministers‘ Council of the Baltic Council of Ministers will be held during
the Lithuanian presidency in 2012, with a special emphases on energy issues.
Tallinn, 10 November 2011
Väljaandja: Majandus- ja kommunikatsiooniminister
Akti liik: määrus
Teksti liik: terviktekst
Redaktsiooni jõustumise kp: 24.12.2012
Redaktsiooni kehtivuse lõpp: Hetkel kehtiv
Avaldamismärge: RT I, 21.12.2012, 39
Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus
Vastu võetud 17.12.2007 nr 99
RTL 2007, 97, 1627
jõustumine 01.01.2008
Muudetud järgmiste aktidega
Vastuvõtmine Avaldamine Jõustumine
05.06.2009 RTL 2009, 47, 670 01.07.2009
26.08.2011 RT I, 30.08.2011, 2 02.09.2011
19.12.2012 RT I, 21.12.2012, 30 24.12.2012
Määrus kehtestatakse «Vabariigi Valitsuse seaduse» § 42 lõike 1 alusel.
1. peatükk
ÜLDSÄTTED
§ 1. Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti staatus
Tehnilise Järelevalve Amet (edaspidi amet) on Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumi
(edaspidi ministeerium) valitsemisalas tegutsev valitsusasutus, millel on juhtimisfunktsioon ja mis teostab
riiklikku järelevalvet ja kohaldab riiklikku sundi seaduses sätestatud alustel ja ulatuses.
§ 2. Esindamine
Oma ülesannete täitmisel esindab amet riiki.
§ 3. Ameti nimi eri keeltes
Ameti nimi on:
1) inglise keeles – Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority;
2) prantsuse keeles – Direction Estonienne de la Surveillance Technique;
3) saksa keeles – Estnische Technische Amt;
4) soome keeles – Viron Teknillinen Tarkastuslaitos;
5) vene keeles – Департамент Технического Надзора Эстонии.
§ 4. Ameti tegevust reguleerivad õigusaktid
Amet juhindub oma tegevuses Eesti Vabariigi seadustest, Euroopa Liidu õigusaktidest, Eesti Vabariigile
kohustuslikest rahvusvahelistest lepingutest, Vabariigi Valitsuse määrustest ja korraldustest, majandus- ja
kommunikatsiooniministri (edaspidi minister) määrustest ja käskkirjadest ning käesolevast põhimäärusest,
samuti teiste ministrite asjassepuutuvatest määrustest.
§ 5. Aruandekohustus
(1) Amet on aruandekohustuslik ministri ees, kes suunab ja koordineerib tema tegevust ja teostab ameti üle
teenistuslikku järelevalvet õigusaktidega sätestatud korras.
(2) Amet koostab ja esitab raamatupidamise, tegevus- ja statistilisi aruandeid õigusaktidega sätestatud korras.
Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus Leht 1 / 7
§ 6. Ameti tegevuse koordineerimine ja koostöö
(1) Ameti tegevust koordineerib ja korraldab kantsler.
(2) Amet teeb koostööd ministeeriumi siseturu-, side- ning teede- ja raudtee-, ehitus- ja elamuosakonnaga ja
ministeeriumi teiste osakondadega.
§ 7. Ameti eelarve
(1) Ameti kulud kaetakse riigieelarvest. Ameti eelarve kinnitab, muudab ja eelarve täitmist kontrollib minister.
(2) Ametil on arvelduskontod Riigikassa kontsernikonto koosseisus.
§ 8. Ameti pitsat ja sümboolika
Ametil on väikese riigivapi kujutise ja oma nimega pitsat ning kehtestatud korras registreeritud sümboolika.
§ 9. Ameti dokumentide vormistamine
(1) Ameti kirjaplangil, üldplangil ja turvaplangil kasutatakse Riigikantselei poolt registreeritud embleemi.
(2) Ameti poolt väljastatavad litsentsid, load, tunnistused ja kooskõlastused ning koostatavad ettekirjutused,
protokollid, otsused ning muud dokumendid vormistatakse ja allkirjastatakse õigusaktides ettenähtud korras.
§ 10. Asukoht
Ameti asukohaks on Tallinn. Ameti postiaadress on Sõle 23A, 10614 Tallinn. Väljaspool ameti asukohta
asuvate struktuuriüksuste asukohad näidatakse nende põhimäärustes.
2. peatükk
AMETI TEGEVUSVALDKOND,
EESMÄRK JA PÕHIÜLESANDED
§ 11. Ameti tegevusvaldkond
Amet teostab seadusega sätestatud ülesannete ulatuses juhtimisfunktsiooni ja riiklikku järelevalvet ning
kohaldab riiklikku sundi ning menetleb süütegusid:
1) elektroonilise side, infoühiskonna teenuse, ringhäälingu sagedushalduse valdkondades ning digitaalallkirja
sertifitseerimis- ja ajatempliteenuse osutajate registreerimise alal;
2) raudteevaldkonnas, sh raudteeinfrastruktuuri läbilaskevõime jaotusorganina, samuti Euroopa Liidu
abifondide rakendusüksuse funktsioonide täitjana transpordivaldkonnas;
[RT I, 21.12.2012, 30- jõust. 24.12.2012]
3) kaevandamise, lõhkematerjalide ja pürotehniliste toodete, ohtlike kemikaalide käitlemise, surveseadmete,
tõsteseadmete, masina-, küttegaasi- ja elektriohutuse ning ehituse ja legaalmetroloogia valdkondades.
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
§ 12. Ameti tegevuse eesmärk
Ameti tegevuse eesmärgiks on riigi majanduspoliitika elluviimine §-s 11 nimetatud tegevusvaldkondades.
§ 13. Ameti põhiülesanded
Ameti põhiülesanded on:
1) riikliku järelevalve teostamine ameti tegevusvaldkondi reguleerivate õigusaktide nõuete täitmise üle ja
nende nõuete rikkumise korral riikliku sunni rakendamine;
2) osalemine ameti tegevusvaldkondi reguleerivate õigusaktide väljatöötamisel ning nende õigusaktide
muutmiseks ettepanekute tegemine, samuti osalemine ameti tegevusvaldkondade standardimises ja
terminoloogia korrastamises;
3) ameti tegevusvaldkondadega seotud poliitikate, strateegiate ja arengukavade väljatöötamisel osalemine;
4) ameti tegevusvaldkondadega seotud projektide ettevalmistamine ja elluviimine, sealhulgas rahvusvahelistes
projektides ja nende ettevalmistamisel osalemine.
§ 14. Ameti tegevus põhiülesannete täitmiseks
Põhiülesannete täitmiseks amet:
1) teeb koostööd teiste riigiasutuste, kohaliku omavalitsuse üksuste, sihtasutuste, mittetulundusühingute,
ettevõtlus- ja tarbijaorganisatsioonidega ning teiste riikide vastavate asutuste ja rahvusvaheliste
organisatsioonidega;
2) esindab kooskõlastatult ministeeriumiga riiki ameti tegevusvaldkondadega seonduvates rahvusvahelistes
organisatsioonides;
Leht 2 / 7 Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus
3) osaleb ameti tegevusvaldkondi puudutavatest välislepingutest tulenevate Eesti Vabariigi kohustuste
täitmises;
4) koostab ameti eelarve projekti ning eelmise aasta eelarve täitmise aruande;
5) töötab välja ja viib ellu ameti strateegia ja tööplaanid;
6) jälgib, hindab ja analüüsib tegevusvaldkondades kujunenud olukorda ning informeerib olukorrast
ministeeriumi siseturu-, side-, teede- ja raudteeosakonda, ehitus- ja elamuosakonda või transpordi arengu ja
investeeringute osakonda;
[RT I, 21.12.2012, 30- jõust. 24.12.2012]
7) informeerib avalikkust ja asjassepuutuvaid isikuid arengutest, muudatustest ja saavutatud tulemustest oma
tegevusvaldkondades;
8) korraldab nõuetele vastavuse kontrollimiseks hindamisteenust ja ekspertiise;
9) korraldab ehitistega toimunud avariide põhjuste uurimist;
10) teeb ettekirjutusi ja otsuseid vastavalt oma pädevusele seadustes sätestatud korras;
11) tagab ametile riikliku järelevalve teostamisel teatavaks saanud äri- ja tehnikaalase teabe konfidentsiaalsuse,
kui seadus ei näe ette selle avaldamist;
12) lahendab oma tegevusvaldkonnas kaebusi ja vaidlusi ning osaleb oma pädevuse piires kohtumenetluses;
13) menetleb oma pädevuse piires süütegusid;
14) täidab talle õigusaktidega pandud andmekogu vastutava või volitatud töötleja ülesandeid;
15) täidab õigusaktidest tulenevaid kriisireguleerimisalaseid ülesandeid ning töötab välja või osaleb oma
tegevusvaldkonna kriisireguleerimisplaanide väljatöötamisel, teavitab vastavalt õigusaktidele oma ülesannete
täitmisel või tegevusalal tekkinud hädaolukorrast või selle tekkimise vahetust ohust ja teostab järelevalvet oma
tegevusvaldkondades elutähtsate teenuste toimepidevuse tagamise üle;
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
16) korraldab ohutusalaseid ja arendustegevuse valdkonna teabepäevi, õppepäevi ja erialaseid koolitusi;
17) annab oma pädevuse piires õigusaktidega sätestatud korras välja litsentse, lube, tunnistusi, kooskõlastusi ja
muid dokumente;
18) nõustab isikuid ameti tegevusvaldkondadega seotud küsimustes;
19) täidab muid talle õigusaktidega pandud ülesandeid.
3. peatükk
AMETI STRUKTUUR
§ 15. Struktuuriüksused
(1) Ameti struktuuriüksusteks on teenistused, mis jagunevad põhitegevuste alusel osakondadeks. Ameti
koosseisu kuulub ka üldosakond, mis ei ole ühegi teenistuse koosseisus. Osakonna koosseisu võivad kuuluda
talitused, kui need on ameti struktuuris ette nähtud. Lisaks võivad kuuluda ameti struktuuri ametnikud, kes ei ole
ühegi struktuuriüksuse koosseisus ning kes alluvad vahetult peadirektorile.
[RTL 2009, 47, 670- jõust. 01.07.2009]
(2) Ameti struktuuri ja teenistujate koosseisu kinnitab minister ameti peadirektori ettepanekul.
§ 16. Struktuuriüksuste struktuur ja ülesanded ning teenistujate õigused, kohustused ja vastutus
(1) Struktuuriüksuste struktuurid ning ülesanded määratakse peadirektori poolt kinnitatud põhimäärustega.
(2) Teenistujate õigused, kohustused ja vastutus määratakse peadirektori poolt kinnitatud ametijuhenditega.
§ 17. Struktuuriüksuse juhtimine
Struktuuriüksust juhib teenistuse juhataja – peadirektori asetäitja, osakonnajuhataja või peadirektori poolt
määratud muu ametnik, kes vastutab struktuuriüksusele pandud ülesannete täitmise eest.
§ 18. Ameti teenistused
Ameti struktuuri kuuluvad järgmised teenistused:
1) elektroonilise side teenistus;
2) transporditeenistus;
[RT I, 21.12.2012, 30- jõust. 24.12.2012]
3) tööstusohutuse teenistus.
§ 19. Elektroonilise side teenistuse põhiülesanded
Elektroonilise side teenistuse põhiülesanneteks on:
1) Eesti raadiosageduste plaani koostamine ja raadiosagedusalade kasutamise planeerimine, koordineerimine,
notifitseerimine ning haldamine;
Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus Leht 3 / 7
2) raadiosagedusalade kasutamiseks sageduslubade andmine;
3) raadioamatööri kvalifikatsioonitunnistuste ja amatöörraadiojaamade töölubade väljastamine;
4) vee- ja õhusõiduki raadiolubade väljastamine;
5) ringhäälingukanalite ja -sageduste määramine, koordineerimine ning notifitseerimine;
6) raadiosagedusala kasutamise üle järelevalve teostamine;
7) raadiosagedusala häirepuhtuse tagamine;
8) raadiohäireteadete vastuvõtt ja nende lahendamine;
9) ringhäälinguloa tehniliste tingimuste üle järelevalve teostamine;
10) [Kehtetu - RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
11) aparatuurile esitatavate nõuete väljatöötamine ja rakendamise korraldamine;
12) aparatuuri maaletoomisest teavituste vastuvõtmine;
13) aparatuuri nõuetele vastavuse ning elektromagnetilise ühilduvuse üle järelevalve teostamine ja ameti
turujärelevalve alase tegevuse korraldamine;
[RT I, 21.12.2012, 30- jõust. 24.12.2012]
14) sideteenust osutada soovivate ettevõtjate tegevuse alustamise teadete vastuvõtmine;
15) sideteenustele ja -võrkudele esitatavate nõuete väljatöötamine ja nende rakendamine;
16) sideteenustele ja -võrkudele kehtestatud nõuete täitmise üle järelevalve teostamine;
17) sideteenuste lõppkasutaja õiguste kaitse;
18) liinirajatise kaitsevööndis tegutsemise tingimuste täitmise ja liinirajatise märgistamise nõuete üle
järelevalve teostamine;
19) infoühiskonna teenuse seaduse täitmise üle järelevalve teostamine vastavalt ameti pädevusele;
20) Eesti numeratsiooniplaani haldamine, mis seisneb selle kavandamises, koostamises ja kasutamise
planeerimises ning kasutamise efektiivsuse analüüsimises ja korraldamises;
21) numeratsiooni haldamine, mis seisneb numeratsiooni eraldamises ja broneerimises vastavuses Eesti
numeratsiooniplaaniga, numbrilubade andmises ning järelevalves numeratsiooni kasutamise üle;
22) numeratsiooni kasutamise osas esitatud tehniliste kaebuste ja vaidluste lahendamine;
23) numeratsioonialase tehnoloogia arengu, regulatsiooni ning õigusaktide ja soovituste, sealhulgas
rahvusvaheliste, jälgimine ja analüüs, ülevaadete koostamine ning ettepanekute tegemine;
24) numeratsioonialase teabevahetuse tagamine Euroopa Komisjonile ning vastava nõude esitamise korral
Eesti ja välisriikide järelevalveasutustele;
25) numbri liikuvuse rakendamine ja numbri liikuvuse nõuete täitmise üle järelevalve teostamine;
26) digitaalallkirja teenuste osutajate ning teenuste osutamise lõpetamise registreerimine;
27) õigusaktidest tulenevate kriisireguleerimisalaste ülesannete täitmine.
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
§ 20. Transporditeenistuse põhiülesanded
[RT I, 21.12.2012, 30- jõust. 24.12.2012]
Transporditeenistuse põhiülesanneteks on:
[RT I, 21.12.2012, 30- jõust. 24.12.2012]
1) erinevate finantsvahendite raames rahastatavate projektidega seotud ülesannete täitmine, sealhulgas Euroopa
Liidu abifondidest kaasrahastatavate arendusprojektide rakendusüksuse ülesannete täitmine;
2) teiste raudteevaldkonna arendusprojektide algatamine, haldamine ja juhtimine;
3) raudteeinfrastruktuuri läbilaskevõime jaotamisel seaduses sätestatud juhul läbilaskevõimeosade jaotamise
otsuse ettevalmistamine, koordineerimisotsuse ettevalmistamine, läbilaskevõime ammendunuks tunnistamise
ettevalmistamine, läbilaskevõime jaotamise otsuse ettevalmistamine läbilaskevõime ammendumise korral,
liiklusgraafiku kinnitamise otsuse ettevalmistamine, kehtiva metoodika ja raudteeinfrastruktuuri-ettevõtja
raamatupidamisandmete alusel raudteeinfrastruktuuri kasutustasu määramise otsuste ettevalmistamine;
4) raudteeveeremi ning raudteeinfrastruktuuri ja raudteeliikluse korralduse nõuetele vastavuse kontrollimise
aruannete ning raudtee tehnokasutuseeskirjas ja teistes õigusaktides raudteeveeremi ja raudteeinfrastruktuuri
valdajatele kehtestatud nõuete täitmise kontrollimine ning ohutustunnistuste väljaandmise, kehtivuse
pikendamise ja kehtetuks tunnistamise ettevalmistamine;
5) veoeeskirjade ja tegevuseeskirjade ning nende muudatuste läbivaatamine;
6) raudtee-ehituse riikliku järelevalve korraldamine ning raudtee-ehituse ehitusloa, kirjaliku nõusoleku ja
kasutusloa andmise ning ehitusloa, kirjaliku nõusoleku ja kasutusloa kehtetuks tunnistamise ettevalmistamine;
7) raudteeliiklusõnnetuste, raudteeintsidentide ja otsasõitude kohta raudtee-ettevõtjatelt saadud teabe
ministeeriumile edastamise korraldamine ning ministeeriumile raudteeavariide, raudteeintsidentide või raudteel
viibinud inimestele otsasõitude kohta hinnangute andmine;
8) vedurijuhiloa taotlemisel katsesõidu korraldamine, vedurijuhiloa väljastamise ja selle kehtivuse pikendamise
üle otsustamine, raudteeveeremi juhtimise õiguse peatamist ettevalmistava menetluse läbiviimine või juhtimise
õiguse peatamine;
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
9) õigusaktidest tulenevate kriisireguleerimisalaste ülesannete täitmine raudteevaldkonnas ja raudteevaldkonna
kriisireguleerimisplaanide ja hädaolukorra riskianalüüsi väljatöötamine;
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
10) raudteealaste väärtegude kohtuväline menetlemine.
§ 21. Tööstusohutuse teenistuse põhiülesanded
Tööstusohutuse teenistuse põhiülesanneteks on:
Leht 4 / 7 Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus
1) järelevalve teostamine kaevandamise ja allmaakaeveõõne teisese kasutamise ja projekti koostamise nõuete
ning isiku nõuetele vastavuse hindamise ja tõendamise üle; objektidel toimunud õnnetuse või avarii põhjuste
väljaselgitamine;
2) järelevalve teostamine tsiviilkäibes oleva lõhkematerjali ja pürotehniliste toodete, nende kasutamise ohutuse
ja nõuetele vastavuse ning toodete käitleja ja käitlemise üle;
3) järelevalve teostamine ohtlikus ja suurõnnetuse ohuga ettevõttes ohtliku kemikaali arvestuse pidamise ja
tegevusloa kontrolliesemesse kuuluvate nõuete ning vastutuskindlustuse nõuete täitmise üle;
4) järelevalve teostamine turule lastud surveseadme nõuetele vastavuse üle, surveseadme kasutamise ja
surveseadmetööde teostamise nõuete üle, tunnustatud asutuse, tunnustatud erapooletu asutuse, tehnilise kontrolli
teostaja ja ettevõtja üle; surveseadmega toimunud avarii või õnnetuse tekkepõhjuste väljaselgitamine;
5) järelevalve teostamine tõsteseadme, selle kasutamise ja teostatavate tööde ohutuse ja nõuetele vastavuse
üle, teavitatud asutuse, tehnilise kontrolli teostaja ja ettevõtja üle; tõsteseadmega toimunud avarii või õnnetuse
tekkepõhjuste väljaselgitamine;
6) järelevalve teostamine turule lastud või kasutusele võetud masina ja plahvatusohutsooni seadme nõuetele
vastavuse üle, masina kasutamise, masinatööde, tehnilise kontrolli ning personali sertifitseerimise üle,
järelevalve teavitatud asutuse, tehnilise kontrolli teostaja ja ettevõtja üle; masina, plahvatusohutsooni
seadme, kaitsesüsteemi või tarvikuga toimunud avarii või sellega kaasnenud õnnetusjuhtumi tekkepõhjuste
väljaselgitamine;
7) järelevalve teostamine turule lastud, kasutusele võetud või kasutatava gaasi- või abiseadme ja nende
kasutamise vastavuse üle, gaasipaigaldise ehitamise, kasutusele võtmise ja kasutamise ning gaasitööde ja
tehnilise kontrolli nõuetele vastavuse üle;
8) järelevalve teostamine elektriseadmete, elektritööde, elektripaigaldiste ja elektromagnetilise ühilduvuse
ning elektriseadmete energiatõhususe, märgistuse ja ökodisaini, ohtlikke aineid sisaldavate elektri- ja
elektroonikaseadmete ning tehnilise kontrolli ja personali sertifitseerimisasutuse nõuetele vastavuse üle;
elektriseadmetega toimunud avarii või sellega kaasnenud õnnetusjuhtumi tekkepõhjuste väljaselgitamine;
9) järelevalve teostamine ehitamise, ehitise, ehitusprojekti, ehitise energiamärgise ja energiaauditi, ehitustoote
ning ehitusvaldkonnas tegutsevate ettevõtjate nõuetele vastavuse üle; avalikku veekogusse kavandatava
ehitise projekteerimistingimuste kooskõlastamise ja lubade väljastamise menetlustes osalemine ning avalikku
veekogusse ehitamisega seotud tasude arvestamise korraldamine; ehitistega toimunud avariide põhjuste uurimise
korraldamine;
10) järelevalve teostamine kohustuslikule metroloogilisele kontrollile kuuluvate mõõtevahendite turule
laskmise, kasutusele võtmise ja kasutamise, kohustuslike mõõtühikute kasutamise, mõõtetulemuste jälgitavuse
tõendamise, taatluskohustuse täitmise ja taatluslaborite taatlustegevuse üle; legaalmetroloogia asutuse
ülesannete täitmine.
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
§ 22. Üldosakonna põhiülesanded
Üldosakonna põhiülesanneteks on:
1) ameti halduskorralduse tagamine;
2) ameti valduses oleva riigivara ja vahendite haldamine;
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
3) töövahendite ja inventari olemasolu tagamine;
4) koolituste korraldamine;
5) töötervishoiu ja tööohutusalase tegevuse korraldamine;
6) klienditeeninduse ning dokumendihalduse ja arhiivi haldamise korraldamine;
7) avalikkuse informeerimine ameti tegevusest ning ameti ja avalikkuse vaheliste suhete korraldamine;
8) ameti ürituste korraldamine;
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
9) teabetoa ja raamatukogu tegevuse korraldamine:
[RTL 2009, 47, 670- jõust. 01.07.2009]
10) personalitöö korraldamine.
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
§ 221. Struktuuriüksusse mittekuuluvad ametnikud
(1) Struktuuriüksusesse mittekuuluvad ametnikud on järgnevad:
1) nõunik;
2) finantsnõunik;
3) õigusnõunik;
4) jurist.
[RT I, 30.08.2011, 2- jõust. 02.09.2011]
(2) Struktuuriüksusse mittekuuluv ametnik allub vahetult peadirektorile või teda asendavale ametnikule.
Struktuuriüksusse mittekuuluva ametniku ülesanded määratakse ametniku ametijuhendis, mille kinnitab
peadirektor.
[RTL 2009, 47, 670- jõust. 01.07.2009]
Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus Leht 5 / 7
4. peatükk
AMETI JUHTIMINE
§ 23. Ameti juhtimine
Ametit juhib peadirektor, kelle nimetab ametisse ja vabastab ametist minister kantsleri ettepanekul. Peadirektori
äraolekul asendab teda ja täidab tema ülesandeid peadirektori poolt määratud teenistuse juhataja – peadirektori
asetäitja, osakonnajuhataja või muu peadirektori poolt määratud ametnik.
§ 24. Ameti peadirektori õigused, kohustused ja vastutus
Ameti peadirektor:
1) juhib ameti tööd, otsustab ja korraldab ameti pädevusse kuuluvate ülesannete täitmise; tagab ameti
ülesannete õiguspärase, täpse ja õigeaegse täitmise ja annab aru ministrile;
2) kinnitab struktuuriüksuste põhimäärused, ameti asjaajamiskorra, sisekorraeeskirja ja muud ameti sisemist
töökorraldust reguleerivad juhendid ja korrad ning teenistujate ametipalgad ja ametijuhendid vastavuses
õigusaktidega;
3) nimetab ametisse ja vabastab ametist ameti koosseisu kuuluvad ametnikud ja teised teenistujad; sõlmib,
muudab ja lõpetab töölepingud ameti abiteenistujatega;
4) rakendab koostöös ministeeriumi siseauditi osakonnaga ametis otstarbeka sisekontrolli süsteemi;
5) teostab teenistuslikku järelevalvet ameti teenistujate toimingute üle õigusaktidega ettenähtud korras, määrab
ergutusi ja distsiplinaarkaristusi ameti ametnikele ja abiteenistujatele;
6) esitab ministrile ettepanekuid ameti kulude eelarve kohta, tagab eelarve täpse ja otstarbeka täitmise ning
riigivara sihipärase kasutamise;
7) esindab ametit teistes riigiasutustes ja organisatsioonides;
8) annab haldusakte sõltumatult ja iseseisvalt kooskõlas õigusaktidega, sealhulgas lahendab vaideid ja
väärteomenetluses ameti kui kohtuvälise menetleja tegevuse peale esitatud kaebusi või volitab selleks ameti
muu ametniku;
9) tagab ametnikele tööriietuse ja isikukaitsevahendid kooskõlas õigusaktidega;
10) esitab ministrile ettepanekuid ameti tegevusvaldkonna korraldamiseks;
11) kehtestab ameti pitsati kasutamise korra ja tagab selle täitmise;
12) moodustab töörühmi tegevusvaldkonna üksikküsimuste lahendamiseks;
13) annab volitusi ameti esindamiseks, järelevalve toimingute teostamiseks ning haldusaktide andmiseks,
sealhulgas volitab teenistuste tegevuse sõltumatuse tagamiseks teenistuse juhatajat – peadirektori asetäitjat
andma haldusakte vastava teenistuse põhiülesannete täitmiseks;
14) kinnitab kooskõlastatult vastava konkursi- ja atesteerimiskomisjoniga atesteerimisnõuded;
15) omab esimese allkirja õigust ameti panga- ja raamatupidamisdokumentidel, määrab teised
allkirjaõiguslikud ametnikud;
16) täidab muid õigusaktides sätestatud ülesandeid.
§ 25. Peadirektori käskkirjad
(1) Ameti peadirektor annab seaduse, Vabariigi Valitsuse määruse või korralduse ning ministri määruse või
käskkirja alusel teenistusalastes ja seadusega sätestatud juhtudel muudes küsimustes käskkirju.
(2) Ameti peadirektor võib anda ameti sisemises asjaajamises ka muid kirjalikke korraldusi.
(3) Ameti peadirektori käskkirjad ja muud kirjalikud korraldused vormistatakse ja registreeritakse vastavalt
asjaajamiskorrale.
§ 26. Teenistuse juhataja – peadirektori asetäitja õigused, kohustused ja vastutus
Teenistuse juhataja – peadirektori asetäitja:
1) koordineerib, suunab, juhendab, kontrollib ja analüüsib teenistusele pandud ülesannete täitmist, korraldab
osakondade vahelist koostööd ning vastutab ülesannete efektiivse täitmise eest;
2) esindab ametit oma pädevuse ja peadirektorilt saadud volituste piires;
3) annab riikliku järelevalve menetluses teenistuse ülesannete täitmiseks haldusakte peadirektorilt saadud
volituste piires;
4) täidab muid õigusaktidega sätestatud või peadirektori antud ülesandeid.
5. peatükk
LÕPPSÄTE
§ 27. Ümberkorraldamine ja tegevuse lõpetamine
Ameti ümberkorraldamine või tema tegevuse lõpetamine toimub seaduse alusel.
6. peatükk
Leht 6 / 7 Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus
RAKENDUSSÄTE
§ 28. [Käesolevast tekstist välja jäetud]
§ 29. Määruse jõustumine
Määrus jõustub 2008. aasta 1. jaanuaril.
Tehnilise Järelevalve Ameti põhimäärus Leht 7 / 7
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A1
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S (25982008)
Multi-Annual Calls 2012 (please see the amended Multi-Annual Work Programme 2012)
European Rail Traffic Management Systems (ERTMS)
Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS), including the European Electronic Toll Service (EETS)
Air Traffic Management (ATM)
Motorways of the Sea (MoS)
Priority Projects concerning rail, road and inland waterways (PPs)
River Information Services (RIS)
For Priority Projects only:
New actions on Priority Projects concerning rail, road and inland waterways (PPs)
Ongoing actions Priority Projects concerning rail, road and inland waterways (PPs) with new activities
Ongoing actions Priority Projects concerning rail, road and inland waterways (PPs) without new activities
Proposal type
Please select the proposal type:
Work
Study
Page 1 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
General Information On The Proposal
Title of the proposed action Spatial Planning and Technical Studies for Rail Baltic (Estonian section)
Priority / horizontal project 27 Section (only for PP) 2703
Transport mode Rail (Conventional)
Start date of the action 01/01/2012 End date of the action 31/12/2015
Summary
The project aims to finalise required studies for Priority Project No 27 "Rail Baltica" Axis Warsaw-Kaunas-Riga-
Tallinn-Helsinki. The spatial planning procedures have to be carried out on the territory of three separate counties to
finalise the exact route on the preferred alignement defined during Activity 1 of project “Studies for a European gauge
line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S. Along the spatial planning a preliminary design will also
be procured with updated financial studies to achieve the level of maturity that would enable to begin with detailed
technical design and construction procurement immediately after the end of spatial planning.
The Activity 1 of project “Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)” - 2007-EE-27010-S
provided the Governments of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania with clearly defined options for further development of
Rail Baltic corridor. As a result the Joint Declaration signed on 10th of November 2011 by the Prime Ministers of
Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, and the agreement signed by the ministers of transport of the same countries on 7th of
December 2011 foresee spatial planning activities to finalise the exact alignment 1 435 mm gauge railway line as one
of the most important steps in continuation of the development of Rail Baltic. On 12th of April 2012 the Government
of Estonia ordered the initiation of county thematic plans for Harju, Rapla and Pärnu counties. Based on the mandate
given by the Estonian, Latvian, and Lithuanian Ministers of Transport (see Declaration in the Annex 4) an inter-
ministerial coordination group – Rail Baltic Task Force – was created. The aim of the coordinating group is the
coordination of short and long-term preparation activities of the new Rail Baltic 1435 mm line. The Task Force
consists of two senior officials from Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and Poland. The European Commission
participates as an observer. The Task Force has been mandated by the ministers to coordinate all the preparatory
works of the new 1435 mm Rail Baltic line throughout the Baltic States and Poland. Based on the latter mandate
given by the ministers, the Task Force agreed upon Common Principles for Spatial Planning (Annex 6, hereinafter
Common Principles for Spatial Planning), which Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania use as a basis for carrying out the
preparatory works. One of the most crucial elements of the document, effectively a work-plan for the Member States
concerned, is the achievement of preliminary design of the new 1435 mm gauge railway throughout the Baltic States
by the end of 2015. It is completely necessary that the preparatory works are harmonised among the Baltic States
and that the EU TEN-T grant decisions are geared at achieving the outputs set forth by the Common Principles. The
current proposal builds on the aforementioned existing TEN-T grant decision and is directly linked to it.
Page 2 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A2.1
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S (25982008) Applicant nr. 1
APPLICANT
Applicant's legal name Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority
Administrative Data
Legal address
Street name Sõle Number 23A
Town / city Tallinn
Postal code / cedex 10614
Country Republic of Estonia
Legal Status Of The Applicant
Public Sector body (including Joint Undertaking established under Article 187 of the Treaty on the Functionning of the
European Union (ex Article 171 TCE)) / Body governed by public law / International organisation
Page 3 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A2.2
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S (25982008) Applicant nr. 1
Contact Points
Person in charge (the person who will be contacted by the EC in the first instance)
Family name Simon First name(s) Jaak
Function Project Expert
Is the address different from the legal address (of section A2.1)? NO
Street name Sõle Number 23A
Town / city Tallinn
Postal code / cedex 10614
Country Republic of Estonia
Phone +3726672043
Fax +3726672001
Email
[email protected]
Representative authorized to sign this application
Family name Soom First name(s) Priit
Function Deputy Director General in Duties of Director General
Is the address different from the legal address (of section A2.1)? NO
Street name Sõle Number 23A
Town / city Tallinn
Postal code / cedex 10614
Country Republic of Estonia
Phone +3726672070
Fax +3726672001
Email
[email protected]
Date
Stamp + signature
Page 4 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A2.3
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S (25982008) Applicant nr. 1
FINANCIAL IDENTIFICATION
All applicants must provide the official Financial Identification Form. The form is available for downloaded in all EU
languages at: http://ec.europa.eu/budget/contracts_grants/info_contracts/financial_id/financial_id_en.cfm
Please attach this form filled and stamped to the proposal, along with additional documents referred to in the Financial
Identificati on Form.
Information to be provided by applicants classified 'EEIG' or 'private undertaking or body' in section A 2.1 only:
The indicated bank account is interest bearing No
Page 5 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A2.4
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S (25982008) Applicant nr. 1
IF THE APPLICANT IS A PUBLIC OR PRIVATE UNDERTAKING OR BODY, FILL IN THE BELOW SECTION ON
THE MINISTRY APPROVING THIS PROPOSAL
Ministry's legal name Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
Administrative data
Legal address
Street name Harju Number 11
Town / city Tallinn
Postal code / cedex 15072
Country Republic of Estonia
Representative authorized to sign this proposal
Family name Pärgmäe First name(s) Eero
Function Deputy Secretary General
Is the address different from the legal address? YES/NO NO
Street name Harju Number 11
Town / city Tallinn
Postal code / cedex 15072
Country Republic of Estonia
Phone +3726256310
Fax +3726313660
Email
[email protected]
Date
Stamp(*) + signature
(*) Stamp of the competent Ministry.
Page 6 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A3.1
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S
LOCATION OF THE ACTION
Member States(s) Estonia
Region(s) Eesti
(1) NUTS 2 nomenclature will be used for the regions.
GEOGRAPHICAL CO-ORDINATES
DMS Format(2) DD Format (3)
Longitude Latitude Longitude Latitude
Start point 59° 25' 24.996" E 24° 44' 17.016" N +59.42361 +24.73806
End point 57° 52' 32.016" E 24° 24' 24.012" N +57.87556 +24.40667
Please note that these coordinates are a minimum requirement. In addition, you are strongly encouraged to submit
cartographic information on the geographical location of the planned activities. Please see Annex 3, Point 2.7 of the
Guide for Applicants for technical specifications.
(2) DMS stands for Degrees, Minutes and Seconds.
(3) DD stands for Decimal Degrees. In this case, longitude and latitude must be given in a seven digit number (+ or -
sign followed by three digits and four decimals).
(4) Please see the definition of cross border sections endorsed by the Committee for Monitoring Guidelines and the
Exchange of Information available at:
http://tentea.ec.europa.eu/download/calls2012/definition_cross_border_sections_en.pdf .
ACTIVITIES OF THE ACTION
Activity ISIC Activity name Start date End date Verifying
number code(5) milestone
1 Architectur Spatial planning and preliminary technical design 31/01/2013 31/12/2015 4
al,
engineerin
g and
other
technical
activities
2 Architectur Consultation with public and stakeholders. Publicity 26/04/2013 31/12/2015
al, with the interested parties
engineerin
g and
other
technical
activities
3 Business Project management 26/04/2013 31/12/2015
and
managem
ent
consultanc
y activities
Page 7 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
4 Architectur Expertise on technical solutions 01/05/2013 31/12/2015 1
al,
engineerin
g and
other
technical
activities
5 Business Preparation of tender dossier package for the next 01/12/2014 31/12/2015 6
and procurements and technical assistance on EU
managem applications
ent
consultanc
y activities
(5) For complete description and other codes, see: http://unstats.un.org/unsd/cr/registry/regcst.asp?Cl=17
MILESTONES OF THE ACTION
Milestone Milestone name Expected Means of verification
number date
1 Publication of thematic county planning tender 31/01/2013 Tender published
2 Publication of tender of expertise on technical 01/05/2013 Tender published
solutions
3 Publication of tender for : Preparation of tender 01/12/2014 Tender published
dossier package for the next procurements and
technical assistance on EU applications
4 Contract for thematic county plans fulfilled 31/12/2015 Letter of formal acceptance
5 Expertise on technical solutions completed 31/12/2015 Letter of formal acceptance
6 Tender documents for next stage completed 31/12/2015 Letter of formal acceptance
Contribution Of The Action To The TEN-T Objectives
If the Action is part of a Global Project previously supported under the TEN-T budget, please specify:
Decision number Title
C (2008)7494 Concerning the granting of Community financial support to the project of common
interest " Studies for a European gauge line for Rail Baltica (Estonian section)" - 2007-
EE-27010-S”
CROSS-BORDER
Does the proposal address a cross-border section? YES/NO NO
Page 8 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A3.2
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Global Project
Sources of financing Financial Contribution (euros)
1. State budget(s) 5,128,700
2. Regional/local budget(s) 0
3. Project Promoter 0
4. EIB loan 0
5. Other loans 0
6. TEN-T financing 5,128,700
7. Other EU funds 0
8. Public/private 0
partnerships
9. Other sources 0
Total 10,257,400
For multi-beneficiary projects, please give only the total amounts per category.
Proposed Action
Sources of financing * Total financial 2012 2013 2014 2015
contribution
1. State budget(s)
Applicant 1 5,128,700 0 0 2,564,350 2,564,350
2. Regional/local budget(s)
Applicant 1 0 0 0 0 0
3. Action Promoter
Applicant 1 0 0 0 0 0
4. EIB loan 0 0 0 0 0
5. Other loans 0 0 0 0 0
6. TEN-T financing 5,128,700 0 0 2,564,350 2,564,350
7. Other sources 0 0 0 0 0
Total 10,257,400 0 0 5,128,700 5,128,700
(*) contribution to eligible costs only
For multi-beneficiary actions, please spli t state, regional budgets and applicant's self-financing by applicant.
All amounts must be in euros.
If applicable, please indicate the exchange rate used for preparing the applications:
Page 9 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A3.3
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S
INDICATIVE BREAKDOWN OF ESTIMATED ELIGIBLE COSTS OF THE PROPOSED ACTION BY ACTIVITY
Activities 2012 2013 2014 2015 Total eligible costs
(euros)
1. DIRECT COSTS
Activity 1 0 0 4,843,200 4,843,200 9,686,400
Activity 2 0 0 105,500 105,500 211,000
Activity 3 0 50,000 50,000 50,000 150,000
Activity 4 0 0 75,000 75,000 150,000
Activity 5 0 0 0 60,000 60,000
TOTAL DIRECT COSTS 0 50,000 5,073,700 5,133,700 10,257,400
2. INDIRECT COSTS* 0 0 0 0 0
TOTAL ELIGIBLE COSTS 0 50,000 5,073,700 5,133,700 10,257,400
Please give an indicative breakdown of the estimated eligible costs of the proposed Action (i.e. the action for which a financial contribution from the TEN-T Programme is
requested in this proposal) by activity (as defined in section A3.1) and year (all amounts must be in euros).
*Costs which are not identifiable as direct costs, but which have nevertheless been incurred in connection with the eligible direct costs of the action. Indirect costs shall
satisfy the general criteria specified at article III.3.7.1 of the General Conditions and may be eligible for flat rate funding fixed at not more than 7% of the total direct eligible
costs.
Applicants will be asked to explain the methodology used in determining the percentage of the flat rate (between O and 7%) before concluding the individual decision.
Page 10 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Application Form Part A
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TRANS-EUROPEAN TRANSPORT NETWORK
A4
Proposal TENtec nr. 2012-EE-27001-S
Project Summary Application
In what language have you completed the project English
summary in Application Form Part A?
If the project summary in Application Form Part A is not in N/A
English, will you submit an English translation before the
deadline specified in the Guide for Applicants (see
Section 6.3.2 of the Guide for Applicants )?
Application Form Part B1
In what language have you completed the project English
summary in Application Form Part B1?
If Form Part B1 is not in English, will you submit an N/A
Please
Englishspecify, for each
translation Part
before theofdeadline
the Application
specifiedForm,
in thethe language in which it is being submitted. If the language is
Guide
not for Applicants
English, (see Section
indicate whether 6.3.2
you will of thean
provide Guide for translation before the deadline specified in the Guide for
English
Applicants )?
Applicants.
Will an English translation of the proposal be provided?
Application Form Part B2
Annexes do not need to be translated unless the applicant deems this necessary.
In what language have you completed the project English
summary in Application Form Part B2?
If Form Part B2 is not in English, will you submit an N/A
English translation before the deadline specified in the
Guide for Applicants (see Section 6.3.2 of the Guide for
Applicants )?
Translation cost
If you will submit any English translations, please give an 0
estimate of the total cost of the translation.
Page 11 (27/02/2013 00:00:00)
Transportation May 2011
Rail Baltica
Final Report
Executive Summary
Prepared by: ............................................................. Checked by: ........................................................................
P Constable A Kakulis
Deputy Project Manager Local Project Coordinator
Approved by: .............................................................
M Elton
Project Manager
Rail Baltica
Final Report
Rev No Comments Checked by Approved Date
by
1 Final Report v2 AK PC 31/05/11
Saxon House, 27 Duke Street, Chelmsford, Essex, CM1 1HT
Telephone: 01245 771200 Website: http://www.aecom.com
Job No Reference Date Created May 2011
This document has been prepared by AECOM Limited for the sole use of our client (the “Client”) and in accordance with
generally accepted consultancy principles, the budget for fees and the terms of reference agreed between AECOM Limited and
the Client. Any information provided by third parties and referred to herein has not been checked or verified by AECOM Limited,
unless otherwise expressly stated in the document. No third party may rely upon this document without the prior and express
written agreement of AECOM Limited.
c:\backup\my documents\documents\aecom\aecom lv\projects\rail baltica\project administration\final report\submittal v2\executive
summary\rail_baltica_final_report_executive_summary_31_05_11 final v2.doc
Table of Contents
1.0 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................... 2
1.1 ECONOMIC AND SECTOR CONTEXT ................................................................................................................ 3
1.2 ECONOMIC, ENVIRONMENTAL, REGULATORY AND TECHNICAL CONSTRAINTS ....................................... 5
1.3 OPTION IDENTIFICATION ................................................................................................................................... 8
1.4 TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF PACKAGES ........................................................................................................... 11
1.5 BEST FEASIBLE OPTION .................................................................................................................................. 15
1.6 COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS ................................................................................................................................ 18
1.7 INTEROPERABILITY ASSESSMENT ................................................................................................................. 24
1.8 IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES............................................................................................................................... 26
1.9 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS .................................................................................................... 28
Executive Summary
2
1.0 INTRODUCTION
This report is the output from a feasibility study undertaken to identify the most feasible development option for a standard
European gauge (1435mm) line between Marijampole and Tallinn via Kaunas and Riga using a ‘top-down’ transport strategy
covering all three Baltic States and an EU – wide rail network rationale.
The role of this project is to deliver a comprehensive decision base for the construction of a new 1435 mm gauge line. The study
focusses on detailed and quantitative analysis of various issues identified for further research within "Feasibility Study on Rail
Baltica Railways, January 2007", financed by Directorate-General for Regional Policy.
The final objective of this study is to give a complete and substantiated picture for the authorities of the 3 Baltic countries and the
EU if the project seems viable enough to justify a more detailed analysis on the respective national levels and to propose a
possible period for implementation of further studies at the national levels.
This Rail Baltica project aims at ensuring a safe, fast and high quality connection between the Baltic States and the major
economic, administrative and cultural centres of Western Europe. Interoperability with Polish and German 1435mm gauge
networks is an important aspect of the project as a whole because international traffic in the North-South direction with the
present 1520mm gauge rail network in the Baltic States is very inefficient and not effective.
Before a preferred route could be arrived at and analysed it was important to understand the economic position of the Baltic
States, the levels of transport service currently provided, and the various constraints that will govern the route selection. From
this information an assessment was made of the likely patronage on the route, both passenger and freight, and thus the potential
revenues. An initial qualitative assessment of the various options proposed led to the selection of a preferred route which was
then subjected to a cost benefit analysis to determine the true feasibility.
The issue of an interoperable North-South railway corridor linking the Baltic Countries (Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia) with Poland
and the rest of the EU rail network can be seen as pivotal from the perspective of development of the railway transport mode in
the region. The idea of Rail Baltica first appeared in 1994 in the joint political document “Vision and Strategies around the Baltic
Sea 2010” as an important element for spatial development in the Baltic Sea Region.
The Baltic countries have historically been linked in transportation terms on an east-west axis and this is reflected in current rail
traffic flows. In physical terms, the provision of rail transport services is through the 1520 mm gauge system which makes
interconnecting traffic with Poland both difficult to operate and costly to provide. For all intents and purposes, the Baltic rail
system is incompatible with mainland European standards. Until, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania joined the European Union, the
issue was not considered a high priority. Now, within the European Union, there is a full consensus that the 3 countries need to
be fully integrated into the wider rail transport system.
In October 2001 the European Commission initiated a revision of the TEN-T guidelines. This resulted in the adoption by the
European Parliament and the Council in April 2004 of Decision No. 884/2004/EC amending the community guidelines for the
development of the TEN-T. This Decision dedicated particular attention to the development of the trans-national infrastructure
projects providing a response to the growth of international traffic whilst promoting cohesion within the EU, notably in the sections
of the pan-European corridors situated within the territory of the new Member States as well as to the concept of “motorways of
the sea”. Within this Decision the Rail Baltica axis Warsaw – Kaunas – Riga – Tallinn was identified as priority project No. 27 with
the following timeframe for implementation:
i) Warsaw – Kaunas (2010)
ii) Kaunas – Riga (2014)
iii) Riga – Tallinn (2016)
On 15 September 2003 the Rail Baltica Coordination Group (representing Poland, Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia) agreed on the
key aspects to be considered in future studies for investment in Rail Baltica. This was followed on 27 March 2006 by the
signature of a Declaration of Intent by the transport ministers of the four project countries and Finland to implement Rail Baltica.
In the meantime between November 2005 and December 2006 the European Commission Directorate – General Regional Policy
commissioned a strategic study of the Rail Baltica railway. The final report, published in January 2007, acknowledged that none
of the options identified had a dominant business case.
Most recently, on 8 June 2010 representatives of the transport ministries of Poland, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia and Finland during
the conference “TEN-T Days 2010: Trans-European Transport Networks” held in Zaragoza, Spain, signed a memorandum
expressing their political will to continue with the implementation of the Rail Baltica project. In addition, the Rail Baltica
3
development plans have been evaluated in the context of the White Paper – Roadmap to a Single European Transport Area –
Towards a competitive and resource efficient transport system, dated March 28, 2011.
The development of Rail Baltica complies with the National Level Planning Strategies of all three Baltic States in terms of
improvements to the national transport networks and thus in providing a stimulus to economic growth. In addition one of the most
important factors in national and international planning is that of providing a sufficiently high standard of transport infrastructure to
support the defence and security needs of member states of different organisations. The three Baltic States are part of the 27
countries that make up the European Union. They are also members of NATO whose mission is a political one to share
democratic values and cooperate on defence with its 28 members. NATO is committed to peaceful resolution of disputes but if
diplomacy fails it has the military capacity needed to undertake crisis management operations. In a worst case scenario a fast,
direct rail route connecting the Baltic States to Central Europe would facilitate the swift movement of military equipment to the
necessary locations. Increasingly military equipment is being moved in containers and the provision of intermodal terminals
enables this to happen seamlessly.
1.1 ECONOMIC AND SECTOR CONTEXT
The key factors examined in determining the macroeconomic and sector context are population, Gross Domestic Product (GDP),
Gross Value Added (GVA) and trade and commodity flows.
Within the three Baltic States and the surrounding area the population is generally in decline. The exception to this is Finland
which is showing a small average growth of 0.2% over the life of the study. In determining the trend data was obtained from
multiple sources. In addition to the overall decline the population is also aging. By 2025, the median age within the Baltic region
will be more than 10 years greater than it is now in about half of the countries in the region. Within the three Baltic States the
populations are not large with a great percentage of the total population living in a relatively small number of towns. For example
there are only 7 towns in Estonia with a population greater than 20,000 inhabitants.
GDP is the internationally recognised measure used in the analysis and forecasting of economic performance and growth. In
determining the forecast of GDP growth an average of data obtained from numerous sources such as the IMF and Eurostat was
used. The forecast GDP growth in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania is 2.4%, 2,2% and 2.2% respectively. These values are typical
for all the countries likely to be served by Rail Baltica.
Gross added value (GVA) is a measure of the value of goods and services produced in an economy and is linked to GDP as
follows: GVA + Taxes on Products – Subsidies on Products = GDP
The average values of GVA growth in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania are 2.6%, 2.2% and 2.2% respectively. In the passenger
demand modelling GVA has been used as it enables regional differences in growth to be taken into account as GVA historic data
is available at a NUTS 3 level. This historic data combined with forecast GDP growth has been used to derive forecasts of GVA
growth at NUTS 3 level.
The key to the success of Rail Baltica will be its ability to capture a significant percentage of the international trade between the
Baltic States and the surrounding countries particularly that percentage of the overall trade moving in a north/south direction. The
major commodity flows (greater than 300,000 tonnes) have been examined and are listed in below:
Table 1 – Major commocity flows in the Baltics
Origin - Destination Commodity Thousands metric tons (2008)
Finland - Germany Paper 2 549
Latvia – Finland Wood Products 1 257
Finland – Poland Mineral Fuels and Oils 1 149
Finland – Germany Wood Products 1 084
Lithuania – Latvia Mineral Fuels and Oils 825
Lithuania – Estonia Mineral Fuels and Oils 599
Lithuania – Finland Wood Products 411
Finland – Poland Paper 404
Germany – Finland Iron and Steel 404
Finland – Germany Mineral Fuels and Oils 347
Latvia – Germany Wood products 325
Poland - Lithuania Food 305
4
A conservative approach was taken in forecasting future freight demand. In fact, since the preparation of the freight model, a
number of factors, some of which were expected, have all enhanced the case about rail freight’s prospects given the right
infrastructure and market conditions:
1) Continuing rise in world fuel prices.
2) Competition – which is starting to evolve in the Baltic States
3) Container market is growing again
4) EU Policy is favouring a move to more sustainable transport, as referenced in the EC White Paper “Roadmap to a Single
European Transport Area”
In addition to the global economic factors it is important to understand the existing supply of transport services and the level of
current demand before a prognosis of the Rail Baltica patronage levels can be undertaken.
In terms of rail throughout the Baltics the international passenger service is poor and whilst there are a number of key internal
routes served the services are generally perceived as being infrequent and slow. The services however are relatively cheap and
do offer reasonable quality. For freight there is a developed east/west network but not a competitive north/south one.
The lack of a passenger rail service, combined with a comprehensive road network, has led to the development of a reasonable
quality coach network offering both internal and international services which is very popular particularly for the shorter distances.
For longer distances air becomes more popular even though its cost is significantly higher.
For north/south freight movement road and sea are the main options.
In assessing the existing passenger and freight demand use was made of a number of data sources including the statistics
offices of the individual member states, the Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority, LDZ Latvia, JSC Lithuanian Railways,
Eurostat etc.
From the existing passenger demand data it can be seen that Passenger demand is generally low for cross border movements
e.g 2,270 travelling from Tallinn to Riga daily of which 81% travel by road (car or coach). For ‘in Country’ movements passenger
demand could be classified as moderate over certain sections e.g. Riga to Jelgava but road still has an 80% market share. In
general terms it can be seen that road is the preferred mode of travel for shorter distances but that this changes to air for longer
journeys e.g Tallinn to Warsaw 76% travel by air.
The existing freight demand falls into three layers for non-bulk flows. These are transit traffic from Central Europe and St.
Petersburg Area, exports from the Baltic States of goods such as wood and paper products, food and drink etc and inter Baltic
traffic. In the case of the first type it requires good service levels, reliability, a modern fleet and is sensitive to journey times. The
second type is currently generally carried by road and is seen as that most likely to transfer to a new rail service. In addition to
the non-bulk freight there is also the bulk traffic currently operating within the Rail Baltica catchment area.
In terms of tonnage the 2008 demand revealed the movement of 20.6m tonnes of bulk and 15.2m tonnes of non-bulk cargo. In
both cases the percentage of cargo carried by rail was very small, just 11% of the bulk and 4% of the non-bulk cargo. The
remainder was split roughly 50/50 between road and sea.
To predict the likely patronage by both passenger and freight traffic on the new Rail Baltica line two separate models were
constructed. In terms of predicting future passenger traffic a common approach to forecasting changes in rail demand following
changes in service provision or pricing is through the application of simple elasticities. This approach can provide a useful
starting point for when there is an existing rail service and can reduce the need for more complex transport modelling. Within the
Baltic States however there is only a very limited existing rail service across national borders, which means there is no existing
rail demand to forecast forward from. Internal to each country although there are existing rail services the proposed high speed
Rail Baltic service is likely to provide a “step change” in level of service which means that the simple elasticity approach will only
provide part of the answer.
As a result we have therefore developed a modelling suite that represents both the existing base year demand by different
modes as well as the generalised cost (in terms of wait time, travel time, fares and vehicle operating costs) of making journeys by
these modes. Based on these base year costs a mode choice model was then developed and calibrated to reflect the split
between modes on existing movements. This modelling base provides, along with an estimation of trip growth, a tool to assess
how mode shares for all modes will alter in future when Rail Baltica becomes an option for travellers. A key strength of this
approach is that the forecasts of Rail Baltica patronage is driven not from the very small number of exiting international trips, but
from an calculation of the proportion of the existing rail, air, bus and car trips that will shift to Rail Baltica.
5
For freight the model that was created is a mode choice model accounting for road, rail and sea traffic. The model has two
streams which run in parallel; demand and modal split. By considering all modes and calculating the modal split based on the
generalised cost the model can predict future potential for shift from existing road, rail and sea onto the Rail Baltica line.
Within the model base demand is split into bulk and non bulk commodities. Demand growth was forecast using GDP growth
forecasts and separate timber industry forecasts where applicable. Change in future costs was predicted using growth in fuel,
labour and other costs.
For the freight model the model base year was taken as 2008. 2009 saw dramatic changes in tonnage levels for the majority of
origins / destinations north-south due to the global recession. The Future of Transport, Focus Groups’ Report, 20.02.2009 states
that transport demand is closely linked to economic growth. In times of economic slowdown, there tends to be a sudden fall in
transport demand, which however is bound to recover more quickly than the rest of the economy. Reactions during previous
recessions clearly confirm this resilience of transport demand. In times of economic recovery, freight transport usually grows
faster than overall GDP. This can in part be explained with the faster growth in international trade. Based upon this reasoning it
was decided to take 2008 as the base year as this is likely to be more representative of long term volumes than 2009 information.
1.2 ECONOMIC, ENVIRONMENTAL, REGULATORY AND TECHNICAL CONSTRAINTS
Economic Constraints. Government debt in the Baltic States is an important economic constraint on the development of the Rail
Baltica project, as the situation in the government budget will affect the decisions about the necessary minimum of 15% co-
financing made by each of the Baltic State authorities. Further, each of the Baltic States still have differing currencies, which
imposes currency and exchange rate risk. In January 2011 Estonia joined the Euro zone; Latvia and Lithuania is planned to join
in 2015. Nevertheless, the join of Latvia and Lithuania is still uncertain and depends on the economic development of the
countries.
Currently, there is no singular EU fund that would be legally allowed to support all the included stakeholder countries together
(Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania, as well as neighbouring countries of the Baltic States - Finland, Russia, Belarussia and Poland)
without a multi-national cooperation agreement in which a leading partner is identified. Article 4 of Regulation (EC) No 680/2007
defines general rules for the granting of EU TEN financial aid. An application for EU financial aid should be submitted to the
Commission by one or more Member States, with the agreement of the MS concerned, by international organizations, joint
undertakings, or public or private undertakings or bodies.
Usual practice in infrastructure projects in Eastern Europe (that are financed through EU structural funds - ERDF) is that:
(1) all countries involved nominate a leading partner (the one who can be considered as a final beneficiary), who is responsible
for submission of application form and provides overall project management for the whole project and implements project in its
domicile country;
(2) Partners establish a Programme Steering Committee (PSG) and an Integrated Programme Organization (IPO) that act as
project management team on behalf of the leading partner;
(3) The IPO can prepare the grant, but it has to be signed either by a leading partner or by all partners that may be considered as
a final beneficiaries.
Furthermore, it should be emphasized that right now there are only forecasts of the allocation and management of the EU co-
financing for the 2014 - 2020, as well as the structure of EU funding programmes. The available information about the next EU
financial period varies and is not yet reliable. However, the uncertainty of the funding allocation for the next financial period of
2014-2020 can be used in the interests of Rail Baltica. By increasing the awareness of the necessity of Rail Baltica, the funding
can be allocated in the most beneficial way for infrastructure of the Baltics.
Environmental Constraints. Four major areas of environmental constraints were investigated: noise, emissions, protected
territories and sustainability targets.
The European Directive 2001/16 Interoperability of the Trans – European Conventional Rail System prescribes noise limits for
rolling stock in the following categories: stationary noise, starting noise, pass by noise, and interior noise. Currently in the specific
case for Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania these noise limits do not have to be complied with as a series of measurements are being
carried out in the three countries that will lead to a revision to the TSI. By the time the line is constructed compulsory noise limits
will have been established. The limiting noise values, as measured at the building facades, are different in Estonia, Latvia and
Lithuania. In general the levels vary between 35 dBA for residential and other critical areas at night to 50 dBA during the day.
Emission limits are based on the requirements of EU Directive 2004/26/EC as amended by the Corrigendum to the Directive
2004/26/EC dated 25 June 2004. The limits are expressed for both locomotive engines and railcar engines and summarize
criteria for carbon monoxide, the sum of hydrocarbons and oxides of nitrogen and particulates.
6
Within the Baltic States there are a large number of Natura 2000 sites. Natura 2000 is the main part of EU nature & biodiversity
policy. It is an EU wide network of nature protection areas established under the 1992 Habitats Directive. The aim of the network
is to assure the long-term survival of Europe's most valuable and threatened species and habitats. It is comprised of Special
Areas of Conservation (SAC) designated by Member States under the Habitats Directive (SCI), and also incorporates Special
Protection Areas (SPAs) which are designated under the 1979 Birds Directive. Wherever possible in the development of the
route options these areas should be avoided.
All three countries have long term national strategies setting overall targets for sustainable development. These documents are
consistent with EU Sustainable Development Strategy and intended to implement EU sustainability targets at the national level.
Regulatory Constraints. The key regulatory contraints that impact Rail Baltica are the beraucracy of planning at the national,
regional and municipal levels, the process of land expropriation, and the setting of tariffs for freight and passenger service.
The time taken to complete the planning process is different in all three countries but in the worst case could take in excess of
seven years. In some European countries the designation of a project as being in the ‘national interest’ allows a reduction in the
planning process but that is not the case in the the Baltics.
In all three countries the process of land expropriation can only be instigated by the state or under certain circumstances by the
municipalities. The process can only be started once the plans justifying the need for the land have been approved. Each country
has a well defined expropriation process and whilst there is no overall defined timeframe, historically in Estonia the process can
take between 2 – 2.5 years.
Setting of tariffs for freight and passenger service varies between the three member states. Since existing policies and
regulations are based on existing railway infrastructure and existing operational and maintenance procedures, it has been
decided to apply a generalized approach to infrastructure tariffs that is more based on EU standards than local calculation
methodology.
Technical Constraints. Rail Baltica will be constructed to the latest Technical Specifications for Interoperability (TSI). The primary
scheme parameters have been developed based on a New Core TEN-T line operating as a mixed traffic line.
Key TSI Parameters are:
Line Category IV-M
Structure Gauge GC
Maximum axle Load 25 tonne
Maximum line speed 240 kmh
(the speed which is used for the design of the track alignment / geometry)
Maximum Train Length 750m
Since the success of Rail Baltica is founded on a mix of freight and passenger service on the line, fast conventional service is
being proposed rather than very high speed rail service. In order to run at very high speeds, HSR trains need to be far more
powerful than conventional trains. In order to maintain their top speeds, the lines that they travel on must be built with the fewest
possible curves – and where curves are unavoidable, they must use larger turning circles to change direction. Braking distances
must also be longer to allow the trains to slow down safely and rail construction tolerances are far more exact, all of which
considerably increase construction and maintenance costs.
7
Table 2 – Design parameter comparison (conventional vs.HSR)
Conventional
HS Rail
Rail
Top speed (kph) 200 400
Installed power (MW) 4 20
Maximum gradient incline (%) 1 3
Minimum radius of curvature (m) 1800 7200
Average braking distance (m) 2000 5500
(Note: these figures are representational and are based on typical design parameters for comparison purposes only)
In addition, the train design and the stations serving them must also have different characteristics. High speed stations are more
comparable to airport terminals than conventional train stations, which in the context of Rail Baltica is not required based on
passenger densities anticipated as calculated and validated via journey time sensitivity analyses in the passenger demand
models of this study
Three different infrastructure implementation scenarios were evaluated – independent 1435mm gauge line (new alignments),
1435mm Gauge Line adjacent to the existing 1520mm gauge line (existing alignments), and dual gauge 1435/1520mm line.
Technical constraints were outlined for rail infrastructure, civil and structures, signalling and telecoms, electrification,
maintainability and rolling stock. Each option under consideration includes various combinations of the infrastyructure scenarios
depicted below. The dual guage scenario, due to the technical constraints inherent in the design of such layouts, is to be
considered a worst-case scenario and is contemplated only in urban areas where other options are not viable.
Figure 1 – Infrastructure implementation scenarios
8
1.3 OPTION IDENTIFICATION
By identifying areas to be avoided wherever possible, such as the various Natura 2000 sites, and the areas of demand drivers
such as the major cities over 20 initial sections of possible routes were identified. This process also suggested that the
geography between the key destinations dicussed in the terms of reference should be broken down into segments. Four
segments were identified: 1) Tallinn to Parnu/Tartu, 2) Parnu/Tartu to Riga, 3) Riga to Radviliskis/Panevežys and 4)
Radviliskis/Panevežys to the Lithuanian border via Kaunas. When looking at new alignments care was taken to miss settlement
areas wherever possible to minimise the environmental impact.
Considering various technical and environmental constraints 4 key options were identified. In assessing journey times and
average speeds, particularily for alignments adjacent to existing raoutes, consideration was given to the various constraints
governing the existing alignment speed and where it was felt that these could not be easily negated a similar speed was used for
the new route. Due consideration was given to station dwell time, acceleration and deceleration.
Table 3 – Key option distance, journey time and average speed comparison
PASSENGER / FREIGHT
Distance Journey Time (hrs) Ave. Speed (kph)
(km) (hours_minutes)
Option 1 New Alignment
4.13/10.38
LT Border – Kaunas – Panevežys – Riga – Parnu – 701/708 170/68
(4h8m/10hr23m)
Tallinn
Option 2 Existing Alignment
6.14/11.56
LT Border – Kaunas – Jelgava – Riga – Parnu – 788/804 128/70
(6h8m/11h34m)
Tallinn
Option 3 New Alignment
4.81/11.17
LT Border – Kaunas - Panevežys – Riga – Valmiera – 791/792 165/71
(4h49m/11h10m)
Tartu - Tallinn
Option 4 Existing Alignment
6.74/11.88
LT Border – Kaunas – Jelgava – Riga – Valmiera – 858/859 127/72
(6h44m/11h53m)
Tartu – Tallinn
(Note: Distances differ between passenger and freight routes due to differing locations of passenger stations and freight ports/facilities)
9
Figure 2 – Route options
10
Option 1 – Red Route
This alignment has been selected and designed to be the most direct and shortest route from the southern most point to the
northern most point of the corridor.
Option 2 – Orange Route
This alignment has been selected as the most direct existing rail route from the southern most point to the northern most point of
the corridor.
Option 3 – Yellow Route
This alignment has been selected to try and maximise potential passenger demand by passing through the majority of the major
population centres.
Option 4 – Green Route
This alignment has been selected to utilize ALL existing routes from the southern most point to the northern most point of the
corridor.
Figure 3 – Distance/passenger journey time comparison with the Business As Usual case scenario and the Existing Service.
Red = 728 km Orange = 815 km Yellow = 818 km Green = 885 km BAU = 885 km EXISTING = 885 km
P = 4.13 hours (170) P = 6.14 hours (128) P = 4.81 hours (165) P = 6.74 hours (127) P = 7.86 hours (109) P = 10.64 hours (81)
F = 10.38 hours (68) F = 11.56 hours (70) F = 11.17 hours (71) F = 11.88 hours (72) F = 13.26 hours (65) F = 16.02 hours (54)
Tallinn Tallinn Tallinn Tallinn Tallinn Tallinn
140 km 178 km
.81 hrs 150 km .89 hrs 190 km 190 km
1.16 hrs 1.4 hrs 1.79 hrs 190 km
Parnu 2.13 hrs
Tartu
200 km Parnu 134 km Tartu
1.08 hrs .82 hrs Tartu
134 km
218 km .82 hrs
Riga 134 km Tartu
1.56 hrs Valmiera 1.17 hrs
Valmiera
160 km 120 km
.88 hrs Riga 124 km Valmiera 134 km
.75 hrs
1.04 hrs 1.35 hrs
42 km 124 km
Panevezys .35 hrs Riga 1.09 hrs
Riga
105 km Jelgava 160 km Valmiera
.49 hrs .88 hrs 42 km Riga
94 km .35 hrs
.65 hrs 42 km 124 km
Kaunas Panevezys Jelgava .50 hrs 1.24 hrs
105 km
Sauliai .49 hrs 94 km
.65 hrs Riga
Jelgava
148 km Kaunas
.93 hrs Sauliai 42 km
94 km .53 hrs
Warsaw .83 hrs
Kaunas 148 km
.93 hrs Jelgava
Sauliai
Warsaw Kaunas 148 km
1.29 hrs 94 km
1.18 hrs
Warsaw
Kaunas
Sauliai
Warsaw
148 km
1.48 hrs
Warsaw
Kaunas
Warsaw
(Note: Total duration noted at the top of the figure includes time spent at stations along the route. Times shown between stations represent only
travel times)
11
1.4 TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF PACKAGES
In the analysis of the various options it is necessary to compare them against the defined ‘business as usual’ option. In terms of
rail, the ‘business as usual’ is the essential upgrade of the existing route between Marijampole and Tallinn to give a speed of 120
kph wherever it is practically possible. In addition other specific road and rail improvements were also specified.
Passenger Demand
To be able to assess the potential passenger demand on each route assumptions had to be made on the frequency of service to
be provided and the likely fares. In the initial estimates a 2 hour frequency was assumed and the fare used was €0.05/km. This
latter value was chosen as it was in line with the current typical fares.
Table 4 – Passenger demand by option (2020, 2030, 2040)
Red Orange Yellow Green
Flow (2-way Daily)
2020 2030 2040 2020 2030 2040 2020 2030 2040 2020 2030 2040
Tallinn to Parnu 4,029 4,734 5,545 2,834 3,339 3,923 - - - - - -
Parnu to Riga 3,004 3,566 4,204 1,964 2,343 2,775 - - - - - -
Tallinn to Tartu - - - - - - 4,261 5,017 5,916 2,677 3,191 3,808
Tartu to Valmiera - - - - - - 2,564 3,113 3,644 1,397 1,695 2,008
Valmiera to Riga - - - - - - 3,730 4,417 5,109 2,306 2,706 3,136
Riga to Jelgava - - - 3,963 4,581 5,200 - - - 4,307 4,965 5,600
Jelgava to Kaunas - - - 2,724 3,188 3,624 - - - 2,902 3,402 3,855
Riga to Panevezys 3,572 4,172 4,736 - - - 3,578 4,180 4,733 - - -
Panevezys to Kaunas 6,523 7,428 8,336 - - - 6,529 7,435 8,331 - - -
Kaunas to Poland 2,272 2,486 2,654 1,730 1,889 2,004 2,267 2,483 2,653 1,727 1,887 2,002
As the success of the service will be measured on the revenues generated an exercise was carried out to determine the revenue
maximising fare for each section of each route. As fare rates increase passenger demand falls. At low fare rates generally
demand falls by less than the fare has risen meaning there will be an increase in revenue as a result of the fare rise. However, a
point will be reached where further increases in fare result in a reduction in demand greater than the fare increase. When this
happens the revenue starts to fall. This feature of demand/cost relationship means that for each route there is a fare rate that
gives the maximum revenue which will be different for different routes depending upon the route characteristics.
Table 5 – Optimum Revenue Generating Fares for each Option.
2020 2030 2040
Red Tallinn – Riga € 0.075 € 0.084 € 0.095
Riga-Poland € 0.108 € 0.126 € 0.158
Orange Tallinn – Riga € 0.067 € 0.076 € 0.087
Riga-Poland € 0.099 € 0.119 € 0.141
Yellow Tallinn – Riga € 0.076 € 0.086 € 0.099
Riga-Poland € 0.108 € 0.126 € 0.158
Green Tallinn – Riga € 0.063 € 0.073 € 0.084
Riga-Poland € 0.099 € 0.119 € 0.141
(Example: Fare from Tallinn to Riga on Rail Baltica in 2040 would be 32.30 EUR using the Red Route)
12
Table 6 – Anticipated revenues from using optimized fares (m eur)
2020 2030 2040
Total Yellow Option 68.0 85.6 108.2
Total Green Option 44.2 55.8 70.3
Total Red Option 61.4 76.9 97.2
Total Orange Option 41.3 52.2 66.2
Various sensitivity tests were then run on the above scenario to consider the effect of a more frequent service and faster journey
times.
Doubling the service frequency i.e. providing an hourly service increases the revenue and demand by 40-65% depending upon
the route option considered. This indicates that the average train load factors and revenue per train would be lower for an hourly
service and would therefore not offset the increase in operating costs. However on certain discrete sections the demand did
double showing that there may be an option of developing a local shuttle service on these sections.
Not unexpectedly the introduction of faster journey times did have an increase on both demand and revenue. Two scenarios
were examined namely reducing the journey times by 15% and 30% respectively. The impact is less marked for the faster routes
(Red route Option 1 and Yellow route Option 3), however, as these route options already offer significant journey time savings
over the alternative modes of travel. It was also seen that the increases in revenues are greater when increasing the speeds by
15% than when increasing the speeds from +15% to +30%. This implies there is limited scope to generate much higher
revenues by increasing design speed. In addition it must be noted that even a 15% faster journey time would require the
introduction of high speed trains which in turn would mean that the line could no longer operate as a mixed line. Freight would
then have to be incorporated of further new lines and obviously the capital costs associated with providing two sets of tracks
would significantly outweigh the benefits of the increased revenue.
Freight Demand
In determining the potential freight demand a set of core parameters were assumed to determine the central case against which
the various sensitivity tests were undertaken. These key core parameters were:
• Medium Freight Price
• Average Speed 70kph
• 15% induced demand
• No green agenda
Results were derived for key freight service indicators, including:
• Volume of Freight Carried (in million Tonnes)
• Revenue (in million Euros)
• Journey Time savings (in million Euros)
• CO2 Savings in Tonnes
• GHG CO2E Savings in Tonnes
13
Table 7 – Freight Demand Core Parameters
Options Sensitivity 2020 2030 2040
Volume in Million Tonnes 9.8 12.9 15.8
Revenue in Million Euros 132 176 222
Red Route Journey Time savings in Million Euros 37 52 69
CO2 Saved Tonnes 374 517 672
GHG CO2E Saved Tonnes 380 525 683
Volume in Million Tonnes 7.6 10.1 12.6
Revenue in Million Euros 106 144 188
Orange Route Journey Time savings in Million Euros 25 36 50
CO2 Saved Tonnes 264 377 514
GHG CO2 E Saved Tonnes 269 383 522
Volume in Million Tonnes 8.1 10.6 13.2
Revenue in Million Euros 107 144 187
Yellow Route Journey Time savings in Million Euros 25 36 50
CO2 Saved Tonnes 268 380 513
GHG CO2 E Saved Tonnes 273 386 521
Volume in Million Tonnes 6.6 8.7 10.9
Revenue in Million Euros 88 120 160
Green Route Journey Time savings in Million Euros 18 26 38
CO2 Saved Tonnes 200 287 405
GHG CO2 E Saved Tonnes 204 291 412
With the core parameters as described above the red route performed best in terms of revenue generated and volume carried.
This was due to the journey times and cost competing favourably with road and sea freight for similar journeys. In all of the
options shown above these parameters attract some bulk traffic but the majority is intermodal traffic where the focus on speed
and price is far more important. This is best illustrated by the fact that in 2040, 18 of the 21 freight trains per day are expected to
be carrying intermodal traffic on long distance trips. Rail Baltica would connect into the internationally significant European TEN-T
rail network at Warsaw and provide much enhanced connectivity from Central and Western Europe to the Baltic States, Finland
and North West Russia.
Although the ‘business as usual’ option could potential capture some of the road or shipping bulk traffic it is unlikely to attract
significant volumes of intermodal traffic due to the slow journey times. Sensitivity analyses were carried out on the key elements
of price, speed, level of induced demand and the green agenda. The results, using the red route as an example, show change
from the central case, in terms of volume carried between +120% (low price, high induced demand, high speed, strong green
agenda) and -54% (high price, low speed, no induced demand, no green agenda). Detailed review of the individual components
shows that price is the most significant demand driver.
Table 8 – Freight Demand Sensitivities
Sensitivity Indicator 2020 2030 2040
Volume in Million Tonnes 19.1 23.5 27.5
Low Price
Revenue in Million Euros 200 245 287
Volume in Million Tonnes 9.8 12.9 15.8
Medium Price
Revenue in Million Euros 132 176 222
Volume in Million Tonnes 5.1 6.8 8.1
High Price
Revenue in Million Euros 87 120 152
As seen in the table above a reduction in price below the medium level increased the level of demand significantly, and this
increase in demand results in a greater cost incurred by the operator, for example, through needing to purchase additional rolling
stock. Further analysis of this concluded that the medium price offered the best value option by maximising the profit for the
operator whilst maintaining a satisfactory level of freight demand.
Thus by selecting the red route for fast journey times with pricing options favourable to intermodal traffic the line is given the best
chance of operating successfully as a fast “mixed use” railway. The type of freight trains on a mixed use railway has a bearing on
14
timetabling. As intermodal trains are usually able to travel at a top speed of 120km/hour they are easier to slot into a timetable
than bulk trains which traditionally have a top speed of around 90km/hour. Over the full length of Rail Baltica the fact that there
are likely to be few bulk trains makes a difference to potential capacity. It is our belief that the existing rail network will continue
to serve the bulk freight market well.
Other Key Factors
None of the route options proposed is fully defined within the spatial plans of the three Baltic States and as such each option
poses various levels of risk from a planning perspective. Of the four options the red and yellow routes are perceived as having a
lower planning risk although even in these cases it has been designated as a medium level. Within the orange and green options
because the route utilises much of the existing rail corridor it might be expected that the planning process would be easier
however as they pass through numerous settlement areas it is highly likely that many of the existing plans will require adjustment
and therefore the chances of objections much higher. These two route options have therefore been designated as offering a high
risk from a planning perspective.
Each of the four route options was also considered from an environmental perspective in terms of noise, landscape/townscape,
biodiversity, heritage sites and water environment. Issues such as greenhouse gasses and CO2 are considered within the freight
demand results.
From a noise aspect the yellow and red route cross the least number of settlement areas, 28 and 29 respectively and as such
have been assessed as having a medium impact. The orange and green routes cross 44 and 46 areas respectively and have
therefore been assessed as having a high impact.
From a landscape/townscape perspective the converse position is true with the red and yellow routes being assessed as having
a high impact and the orange and yellow routes as having a medium or medium/low impact. This is because running new lines
adjacent to existing tracks will have little effect of the overall townscape in any location.
Throughout the option development phase one of the key considerations was to minimise the impact on the numerous Natura
200 sites designated within the Baltics. Whilst it was not possible for any option to avoid all the sites the yellow route impacts the
lowest number. The red and orange routes impact the greatest number of sites.
The potential impact on heritage sites has also been assessed and the again because of the limited number of settlement areas
crossed by the red and yellow route options they have the lowest impacts.
The effect of the routes on the water environment was also qualitatively assessed; In this case the orange and green routes had
the lower impacts as they generally fall inside the existing rail corridors.
The results of the various analyses undertaken on the route options identified are summarised in the table below. In identifying
which route is the best under each category either actual values have been used e.g. the actual revenues, a ranking has been
assigned between 1 and 4 or they were assigned an impact (high, medium or low).
Aspect Best Route
Capital Cost Red
Journey time savings Red
Revenues Red
Wider Economic Benefits Red and Yellow equal
Environment Red , in terms of CO2
savings
As a result of the analysis it was considered that the Red Route Option 1 appeared to be the route that offered the greatest
benefits for the least capital cost.
15
1.5 BEST FEASIBLE OPTION
The preferred alignment (Option 1 – Red Route) for the Core TEN-T Rail Baltic 1435mm route was selected and designed to
offer the most direct and shortest route from the southern-most point to the northern most point of the corridor. The new 1435mm
gauge line starts at the LT border and proceeds into Kaunas on a new alignment to minimize curves and speed restrictions. At
Kaunas the route will not serve the Central Station directly but will use Palemonas station as the transfer connection to the
existing 1520mm gauge line to link to the Central Station and a transfer location for shuttle service to the airport via bus or 1520
mm rail. The new proposed intermodal facility is also in this area and can also be easily served by this route. The line progresses
northbound through the west-side of Panevezys, where a stop for passengers and freight is planned, and continues north into
Latvia. In Latvia the alignment proceeds adjacent to Iecava and then crosses the Daugava River to the east of Riga, at Salaspils
at which point an east-west intermodal transfer station is contemplated. Riga City is served by new 1435mm gauge rail
infrastructure utilizing the old "Ergli" alignment through to the Central Station. Trains from Central Station use the same route to
arrive back at the main north south section. From this connection point the line proceeds northbound following parallel to the Via
Baltica roadway alignment to Parnu, another intermediate stop and subsequently to Tallinn Central Station stopping first at
Tallinn Airport. In the vicinity of Tallinn spurs are provided from the main line to serve both Muuga Port and the proposed location
of the proposed fixed crossing to Helsinki.
The key features of the route are:
• Overall length of new track 728km
o Estonia = 229km
o Latvia = 235km
o Lithuania = 264km
• Design speed 240 kph maximum
• The route is a mixed traffic conventional route
• Journey times between Tallinn and the Lithuanian/Polish Border (Table 1.1)
o Passenger 4.13 hrs (4h8m)
o Freight 10.38 hrs (10h29m) (variable time depending on the number of calls)
• Average speeds
o Passenger 170 kph
o Freight 68 kph
• Passenger service frequency every 2 hrs starting at 06.00 and finishing at 24.00hrs approximately
• New/Upgraded passenger stations at Palemonas (serving both Kaunas Centre and the Airport along the existing 1520mm
gauge line), Panevežys, Riga Central Station, Parnu, Tallinn Airport and Tallinn Central Station.
• Primary intermodal terminals at Tallinn, Riga and Kaunas and secondary intermodal terminals at Panevezys and Parnu.
• Maintenance facilities at Rapla, Riga, and Jonava.
• The route is twin track for its entire length on mainly new alignment
• Some dual gauge (1520/1435) sections are required.
Various sub-options were identified that merit further definition in later stages of the implementation process including:
1) Sub-option 1: an approach to Tallinn via the existing N-S railway alignment from Rapla to Tallinn,
2) Sub-option 2: an alternate route south of Parnu to Saulkrasti that utilizes portions of the already reserved planning
territories in and south of Limbazi, and
3) Sub-option 3: using the existing rail alignment from Marijampole to the LT/Polish border, since this section is already
undergoing 1435mm/1520mm gauge infrastructure upgrades and has been approved by the Republic of Lithuania.
16
Figure 4 – Best Feasible Option – Red Route
17
To maximize effectiveness, the operational framework for Rail Baltica aims to utilize the infrastructure asset to the maximum
extent possible which in turn will require less train sets for both passenger and freight service. This gives the best return on
investment, utilization of assets and lower operating costs. Initial assumptions for the mixed-train service:
1) The timetable has been based on a 24 hour day operating on six days of the week.
2) The track will need to be inspected roughly once a week.
3) Sundays have been identified for a limited service to enable planned maintenance or reactive maintenance should
inspection and testing require it.
4) Facing and trailing crossovers will be situated along the track to facilitate single line working
5) Maintenance can be carried out on a single line at a time (this will not apply to crossover areas where all lines will need
to be blocked to undertake works.
6) Periodic blocks of a longer period (18-27 hours) will be available but not on a planned weekly basis
7) Time difference between Warsaw and Baltic States not taken into consideration duration are critical factors in
determining service provisions. Exact and time zones need to be clarified at final design stages and integration with
local arrivals and departures.
These assumptions provide the basis for enabling the passenger and freight traffic to meet its market demand requirements in a
more cost effective manner (i.e. reduce the number of train sets through availability of a longer operating day; and need for less
stabling/handling sidings; less crew).
Journey times will differ between the Rail Baltica Core TEN-T 1435mm route and the regional 1520mm rail network. The regional
rail network journey times as were considered in the future Business as Usual case scenario (at max speeds of at least 120 kmh
without any restrictions) are roughly similar to travel times via the road network. The current passenger rail network is
considerably slower (i.e. journey time from Riga to Valmiera is currently 2 hours 20 minutes). Other key urban centers in the
Baltic States that are not directly on the 1435mm gauge line that have been considered for connection to the Rail Baltica line are
Tartu, Daugavpils, Ventspils, Jelgava, Liepaja, Sauliai, Klaipeda and Vilnius.
Figure 5 – Journey Times (core vs. regional network) and Connectivity (Destinations)
18
1.6 COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
The costs of implementing and operating Rail Baltica are extremely important inputs to determine the economic costs and
benefits of the project. Given that the project is in the early stage of the planning process and the cost model is subject to various
uncertainties and therefore contingencies have been included to mitigate these uncertainties. The costing information for the
preferred alignment includes various elements that relate to capital costs (CAPEX - planning, design, land, and construction
costs), as well as operational costs. All costs represented in the analysis do not include VAT.
Capital Costs (CAPEX)
The track infrastructure estimate is based on materials (50%), equipment (20%), labour (22%) and other (8%) costs associated
with double railway track, power network, electrification, SCB network, telecommunications, and GSM-R network. In addition,
costs related to topographic surveys, geotechnical investigations, planning and design, author/technical supervision and a 5%
contingency have been added to calculate the total expenditures related to track infrastructure. The total track-related
construction costs are roughly 2,430M EUR.
In addition to the track infrastructure, additional above-grade road crossings and water crossings need to be considered along
the entire alignment since TSI’s dictate grade – separated crossing along the entire route (exceptions in urban areas). A total of
st nd
521 road crossings or road diversions were identified that included crossings of main roads, 1 class roads, 2 class roads and
other roads. A total of 228 water crossings were identified. Each crossing was assigned a unit cost. Total cost related to bridges
is roughly 438M EUR.
In addition to rail infrastructure and bridges, additional costs were included for passenger station upgrades/construction,
intermodal terminal construction, maintenance facility construction, cross-over integration and required passing-loops. Total
additional costs for facilities related improvements and construction is roughly 522M EUR.
Costs for land expropriation were established by reviewing current market assessment values (using 2011 market data) for the
various types of land that will be required for implementing the preferred alternative. Various territory types will be required as
referenced in the Land Uses (forest, agricultural and wetlands) and various settlement types will be impacted (towns/cities and
suburbs). It is also assumed that a new alignment will require 100m ROW and an existing alignment will require 50m additional
ROW. Total cost for land expropriation (based on 2011 values) is roughly 149M EUR.
TOTAL CAPEX = 3,539M EUR
Table 9 – Capital cost breakdown by Country
CAPEX SUMMARY (M EUR) Construction Land TOTAL %
Estonia € 935 € 108 € 1 043 29%
Latvia € 1 196 € 26 € 1 222 35%
Lithuania € 1 259 € 15 € 1 274 36%
TOTAL € 3 390 € 149 € 3 539
Operational Costs (OPEX)
Cost estimates have been also made for the operating costs of the proposed passenger and freight Rail Baltica services.
Passenger service is assumed to be electric and passenger freight service is assumed to be diesel.
The Rail Manager will incur operational costs related to maintaining the rail infrastructure including track maintenance and
replacement, signalling and telecommunications maintenance and replacement, catenary system maintenance and replacement
and surrounding area maintenance.
The track access charge is paid by the passenger and freight operators to the rail manager. It is a reservation charge and allows
the operator to use the infrastructure that is provided by the manager for a specific train path. The EC document
2010/0253(COD) ‘Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the council establishing a single European railway
area (recast)’ outlines proposals for changes to the directives covering the rail sector. This document includes changes to the
principles of charging (article 31); and introduces exceptions to charging principles (article 32) to improve the coherence of
national track access charging schemes through the introduction of common criteria for identifying market segments on which
operators may be able to pay a mark-up in access charge.
19
The EC document indicates that the starting point for setting track access charges should be a calculation of direct costs to the
rail manager of the services running. This is calculated based on the total rail managers maintenance cost over the appraisal
period, and the total number of train km. Article 32 of EC document 2010/0253(COD) states that mark-ups may be applied to
obtain full recovery of the costs incurred by the infrastructure manager. Therefore, track access charges have been calculated
in an iterative process to minimise the financial losses of the rail manager whilst still providing financial return for the operators.
The following optimal track access charges were determined:
Passenger services € 3.95 per train km
Freight services € 5.92 per train km
The Rail Operator also has to incur operating and train maintenance costs in order to provide a service. These costs are offset to
some degree by the revenue that is paid to the operator by both passengers and freight hauliers.
Freight service operating costs consist of fuel costs (diesel fuel consumption), labour costs, total cost of rolling stock (lease
charges for locomotives and wagons and maintenance costs for locomotives and wagons), overheads, and track access
charges. Passenger service operating costs consist of fuel costs (electricity), labour costs, total cost of rolling stock (lease
charges and maintenance charges), overheads and track access charges.
Table 10 – Total Operating Costs
Total Annual Cost Total Annual Cost Total Annual Cost
EUR/train km
2020 (M EUR) 2030 (M EUR) 2040 (M EUR)
Freight 11.55 52.9 77.1 117.1
Passenger 8.63 54.2 54.2 54.2
In addition, other key factors were evaluated and calculated for passenger and freight service including revenues, social costs
and benefits, journey time savings, accidents, air pollution, and climate change.
Economic Analysis
The Economic Cost Benefit uses discounted cash flow techniques to take account of the fact that benefits and costs that occur
further into the future are valued less highly than those that occur in the short term. The positive impact of the project is
measured by the economic indicators of the Net Present Value (NPV) of the project, which is the sum of the net benefits of the
project discounted using the given rate to base year (2010) values, and in terms of the Economic Rate of Return (EIRR), which is
the discount rate which gives a Net Present Value of zero.
In line with EU guide to Cost benefit analysis of investment projects a discount rate of 5.5% has been used in the economic
assessment with an appraisal period of 30 years after opening.
National Governments and international bodies such as the European Union set certain standards for the EIRR of transport
infrastructure projects: as a benchmark the EIRR of rail projects sponsored by the EU during the previous programming period
was 11.6%.
20
Table 11 – Economic Analysis Summary
Rail Baltica Total Rail Baltica Estonia Rail Baltica Latvia Rail Baltica Lithuania
Economic Impact Discounted Discounted Discounted
Discounted Share in Discounted Discounted Discounted
Cost or Cost or Cost or
Cost or Total Costs/ Cost or Cost or Cost or
(€,000,000) Benefit (per Benefit (per Benefit (per
Benefit Benefits Benefit Benefit Benefit
km of track) km of track) km of track)
Cost to Infrastructure
Manager/Government
Capital / Investment Costs 1,886 103% 565 2.47 648 2.76 674 2.55
Residual Value -117 -6% -34 -0.15 -43 -0.18 -41 -0.16
Maintenance Costs 61 3% 19 0.08 20 0.08 22 0.08
Benefit to Manager
Track access charges 521 16% 108 0.47 111 0.47 125 0.47
Passenger 170 35 0.15 36 0.15 41 0.15
Freight 351 73 0.32 75 0.32 84 0.32
Benefit to Operator
Passenger Operator
Operating costs
-372 -12% -77 -0.34 -79 -0.34 -89 -0.34
(including track access charges)
Revenues 605 19% 129 0.56 160 0.68 215 0.81
Freight Operator
Operating costs
-685 -21% -142 -0.62 -146 -0.62 -164 -0.62
(including track access charges)
Revenues 1,142 36% 353 1.54 339 1.44 322 1.22
Benefit to Users
Value of Time Savings 1,158 36% 397 1.73 340 1.45 284 1.08
Passenger 340 135 0.59 88 0.38 71 0.27
Freight 818 262 1.14 252 1.07 213 0.81
External Impacts
On Safety (Accidents) 338 11% 116 0.51 105 0.44 89 0.34
Air Pollution 148 5% 35 0.15 29 0.13 77 0.29
Climate Change 342 11% 117 0.51 108 0.46 85 0.32
Total Costs 1,829 550 2.41 625 2.66 654 2.48
Total Benefits 3,198 1,034 4.52 967 4.11 944 3.58
Net Present Value (NPV) 1,368 484 342 289
EIRR 9.3% 9.7% 8.4% 7.9%
Benefit/Cost Ratio 1.75 1.88 1.55 1.44
The elements of the total costs and benefits that are experienced by each nation have been isolated. This allows the CBA to be
run for each individual Baltic nation. It should be noted however, that the benefits allocated to each country will only be
generated if the whole scheme is implemented.
To breakdown the CBA to a national level the costs and benefits have been split across the states. This allocation has been
based on either allocating benefits to the country in which they occur, such as accident savings and emissions reductions; or,
allocating them to the country from which the trip originated or was destined, such as journey time savings. Details of how costs
and benefits have been split are given below.
Capital Investment Costs – calculated for each nation by considering the length of track and specific land type and
infrastructure elements required within each country. This means the cost per km of track varies with countries that contain a
greater number of crossings and infrastructure experiencing a greater average cost per km.
21
Maintenance Costs – calculated for each nation by considering the share of the track length within each country. This means
the maintenance cost per km of track is constant across the countries; however, the total cost varies due to differing track lengths
within each country.
Operating Costs - Calculated for each nation by considering the share of the total annual train- km within each country. For
Passenger services, which run from Warsaw to Tallinn the share of train-km is the same as the share of track km. however, for
freight services, as service patterns vary with differing numbers of services on different sections of track the share of train-km is
not the same as the share of track km.
Track Access Charges – Calculated for each nation by considering the share of the total annual train- km within each country.
For Passenger services, which run from Warsaw to Tallinn the share of train-km is the same as the share of track km. however,
for freight services, as service patterns vary with differing numbers of services on different sections of track the share of train-km
is not the same as the share of track km.
Revenue Benefits – Calculated for each nation by considering the share of the total annual train- km within each country. For
Passenger services, which run from Warsaw to Tallinn the share of train-km is the same as the share of track km. however, for
freight services, as service patterns vary with differing numbers of services on different sections of track the share of train-km is
not the same as the share of track km.
Passenger Time Savings Benefits – Calculated on a matrix level, therefore benefits have been allocated to each nation based
on the origin and destination of each trip. Benefits associated with trips internal to a country have been entirely allocated against
that nation, whilst the benefits associated with international trips have been split equally between the origin and destination
nations. This means the benefits are higher for countries with large volumes of internal trips, and for countries where there are
key trip attractors.
Freight Time Savings Benefits – Calculated on a network basis. Journey time savings have been allocated to the country in
which they occur. This means that the journey time saving for a freight trip from Estonia to Lithuania will be split between all
three nations depending upon the difference between the ‘with project’ and ‘without project’ times on the stretches of the route
within each country.
External Benefits, such as accidents and emissions benefits have been allocated to the nation where the reduction in accidents
or emissions occurs.
Job Creation - Over the five year construction period 11,900 FTE jobs will be created (3,283 in Estonia, 4,199 in LV and 4,419 In
Lithuania). From opening the passenger service creates 221 FTE jobs. As the number of freight services increased the number
of FTE jobs created ranges from 110 on opening, 160 in 2030 to 244 in 2040. The impact of direct job creation has not been
explicitly included in the CBA analysis. The EC guidance indicates that job creation benefits should not be included explicitly as
they are already accounted for in the adjustment to shadow prices (conversion factors).
The allocation of benefits and costs to nations means that there are elements of the whole scheme benefits and costs which are
allocated to nations outside the Baltic region; these include revenue, operating costs and track access charges from the
Lithuanian border to Warsaw and elements of the time savings for trips originating or destined outside the Baltic states (e.g. trips
to/from Poland).
22
Financial Analysis
The nature of the construction and operation of Rail Baltica mean that there are two sets of stakeholders, from whose viewpoint
the financial analysis needs to be undertaken. These are:
1) the Rail Manager, who constructs and maintains the rail line, these costs are offset to some extent by the track access
charges paid by the operators
2) the Passenger and Freight Service Operators who operate the services whose costs include maintenance of the train fleet
and payment of access charges to the rail manager in exchange for the opportunity to run services on the track. These
costs are offset to some extent by the revenue paid by the passengers and hauliers who use the service.
Financial projections are calculated in real prices on a base of 2010, in Euro. In accordance with EC guidance a discount value
of 5.0% is used with an appraisal period covering 30 years post opening. The 30 years appraisal period, recommended for rail
projects, is applied after opening as it related to the project lifetime.
• Investment period (13 years): 2012 – 2024;
• Operational period (30 years): 2025 – 2054.
Table 12 – Financial Return on the Investment Cost (excludes the impact of any EU grant)
Total (€ million)
Indicator To Rail To Rail Operator
Consolidated
Manager Total Freight Passenger
Investment Cost excluding EU Grant 3,678 3,678
Maintenance 353 353
Residual Asset Value -1,569 -1,569
Operating Costs 2,559 1,676 882 2,559
Track Access Charges 2,508 1,764 744 2,508
Total Outflows 2,463 5,066 3,440 1,626 7,529
Track Access Charges 2,508 2,508
Revenues 8,270 5,429 2,842 8,270
Total Inflows 2,508 8,270 5,429 2,842 10,778
Net Cash Flows 45 3,204 1,988 1,216 3,249
Net Cash Flows (discounted) -1,386 785 517 268 -601
Financial NPV of Investments (FNPV/C) -1,386 785 517 268 -601
Financial IRR of Investments (FIRR/C) 0.05% - - - 3.10%
Financial MIRR of Investments (MIRR) 6.22% 6.18%
(Note: Investment Costs include Capital Costs + Planning/Design Costs +Project Management Costs + Site Supervision Costs)
For this project the funding gap calculation considers the following cash flow elements related to the rail managers account in the
calculation of the Funding Gap Rate:
• Investment costs – Total cost of design and construction
• Operating costs – cost of maintenance of the trail infrastructure
• Revenues – Track access charge payments from the rail operators.
23
Table 13 – Funding Gap Calculation
Value Not Discounted Value Discounted (NPV)
No. Main Elements and parameters
€ million
1 Reference period (years) 30
2 Financial discount rate (%) 5.0%
3 Total investment cost excluding contingencies 3,678
4 Total investment cost 2,093
5 Residual value 1,569
6 Residual value 183
7 Revenues 594
8 Operating costs 71
Funding Gap
Net revenue = revenues – operating costs +
9 707
residual value = (7) – (8) + (6)
10 Investment cost – net revenue = (4) – (9) 1,386
Funding gap rate (%) = (10) /
11 66%
(4)
Table 14 – Community Contribution Calculation
Value
No.
(€ million)
1 Eligible cost (not discounted) 3,678
2 Funding gap rate (%) 66.2%
Decision amount, i.e. the “amount to which the co-financing rate for the priority axis applies” =
3 2,436
(1)*(2).
4 Co-financing rate of the priority axis (%) 85.0%
5 Union contribution (in euro) = (3)*(4) 2,070
24
Following calculation of the EU grant, the financial return on the national capital has been calculated (FNPV/K). This includes the
impact of EU funding in terms of a reduced investment cost. In effect this is a measure of the value for money in terms of the
balance between benefits and only the element of capital investment made by the member states.
Table 15 – Financial Return on National Capital
Total (€ million)
Indicator To Rail To Rail Operator
Consolidated
Manager Total Freight Passenger
Investment Cost 3,678 3,678
Maintenance 353 353
EU Grant -2,070 -2,070
Residual Asset Value -1,569 -1,569
Operating Costs 2,559 1,676 882 2,559
Track Access Charges 2,508 1,764 744 2,508
Total Outflows 392 5,066 3,440 1,626 5,458
Track Access Charges 2,508 2,508
Revenues 8,270 5,429 2,842 8,270
Total Inflows 2,508 8,270 5,429 2,842 10,778
Net Cash Flows 2,115 3,204 1,988 1,216 5,319
Net Cash Flows (discounted) -208 785 517 268 577
Financial NPV of Investments (FNPV/K) -208 785 517 268 577
Financial IRR of Investments (FIRR/K) 3.70% - - - 8.17%
Financial MIRR of Investments (MIRR) 6.22% 6.18%
Having determined the investment costs, operating costs and sources of finance, it is possible to determine the project’s financial
sustainability. A project is financially sustainable when it does not incur the risk of running out of cash in the future. The
sustainability assessment determines whether the timing of cash spending and generation results in the cash inflows consistently
matching the cash outflows. Stability occurs if the cumulative net cash flow is positive in all years.
Overall the project shows positive cumulative cash flow in all years suggesting that at this level the project is financially stable.
The net cash flow for the rail manager is positive in all years. The positive annual cash flow leads to a large cumulative net cash
flow by the end of the appraisal period.
1.7 INTEROPERABILITY ASSESSMENT
Interoperability Directive and its related TSIs are designed to facilitate the “optimal level of technical harmonisation” of the entire
EU rail system with a view to improving its competitiveness, for example, by lowering production, acceptance, operation and
maintenance costs. The aim is, on one hand, to facilitate international railway services and, on the other hand, to set up common
EU-wide rules for conformity assessment and placing in service of infrastructure, fixed facilities and vehicles.
In respect to the Rail Baltica 1435mm railway, the Directive and its related TSIs must set the “optimal level of technical
harmonisation” of the entire Rail Baltica system, as well as within each of the three (3) distinct and different Baltic States and in
relation to the neighbouring counties Poland and Helsinki.
25
Table 16 – Key Issues related to Compliance with Interoperability Directives
Interoperability Directives Related to Rail Baltica
Subsystem Reference Specification Parameter Potential Impacts/Risks
Infrastructure CR INF TSI Line Layout, Track Parameters, Adjacency to existing 1520mm gauge
Switches, and Crossings tracks, dual gauge track complications,
minimum radius of curves in constrained
locations, internal (1435mm) and external
(1435/1520mm) switching and crossings.
Track and Structure Resistance Resistance of existing bridges and
to Loads earthworks to traffic loads
Track Geometrical Quality Geometrical quality at locations near
stations, terminals and facilities where
1520mm gauge exists
Platforms Lenghts and heights of platforms in existing
stations, access and entry/exit to stations
and dedicated platform locations
Energy CR ENE TSI Power Supply Overall capacity and grid, substation
connections and location on new corridors,
sectioning locations, separation sections
and return circuits
Geometry of the OCL and Contact line systems and interference with
Quality of Current Collection adjacent existing electrified 1520mm lines,
geometry, pantograph gauge and contact
force at cross-overs with existing 1520mm
electrification.
Control-Command 2006/679/EC On-board systems ERTMS implications on ETCS functionality,
and Signalling (CCS) interfaces to internal and external control-
command, electromagetic compatibility
Track-side systems ERTMS implications on ETCS functionality,
interfaces to internal and external control-
command, track-side train detection
systems in urban areas/cross-overs of
various gauge lines.
Rolling Stock - Noise 2006/66/EC & Noise Emitted by Freight Development of new noise TSIs during
2011/229/EU Wagons project development that currently are not
mandated based on "Specific Cases" for
Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania.
Noise Emitted by Locomotives, Development of new noise TSIs during
Multiple Units and Coaches project development that currently are not
mandated based on "Specific Cases" for
Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania.
Interior Noise of Locomotives, Development of new noise TSIs during
Multiple Units and Driving project development that currently are not
Trailers mandated based on "Specific Cases" for
Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania.
Operation and Traffic 2006/920/EC Staff/Organization Establishing appropirate roles and
Management responsibilities for railway undertakings staff
and infrastructure manager staff to ensure
safety, reliability, availability, health,
environmental protection and technical
compatibility of the line.
Telematic 2001/16/EC Information Systems & State-of-the-art systems and monitoring
Applications for Monitoring devices will be employed and will be required
Freight and to share data and information with existing
Passenger Services inforamtion systems at the national level.
Marshalling and Allocation Marshalling and allocation systems will need
Systems to interface with existing 1520mm gauge
freight systems at intermodal terminal
locations.
Management of Connections Specifically at transfer points for both
with Other Modes of Transport passenger services (ports/airports/train
stations) and freight services
(ports/intermodal terminals).
26
1.8 IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES
The current feasibility study has provided the economic and technical justification for a single option route alignment to be
considered further. Given the strategic and feasibility nature of the study, it cannot be assumed that the route identified is now in
a position where more detailed design can be considered. The study has simply identified the broad parameters of a major rail
programme which can now be further developed and refined as projects within their own right. The identification of a single route
option cannot be considered as the definition of a single option for a rail system. This requirement is the starting place for the
next phase of the Rail Baltica Programme.
It is recommended that the principle objectives of the Rail Baltica implementation should encompass the principle elements:
1) the definition of an overriding sponsorship remit for the Rail Baltic programme in general and the key individual national
programme elements,
2) the development of a refined statement of benefits and costs arising from the preferred route option,
3) an assessment of the current capability of the existing systems and railway facilities which would be impacted on or be
part of the Rail Baltica programme,
4) the development of stage 1 single option designs to route sections noting the overall programming phasing
requirements. These designs will be required to generate to a satisfactory standard, programme costs. In addition they
will provide the basis on which market testing can be carried out in respect of future scheme procurement. Of particular
concern will be the need to ensure designs conform to national, EU and international environmental and sustainability
requirements,
5) the Rail Baltica programme will consist of a number of individual (but in their own right) major projects. Under the single
option developed in this study, there will be a range on individual programme options. As part of the overall programme
assessment, each individual option should be assessed in respect of its ability to meet both the overall programme
requirements and those identified at a local level. This process will require value engineering studies to be carried out of
system wide component options and geographically defined route choices,
6) refinement of system functional specifications. It is noted that Rail Baltica may be developed over a number of time
periods and as such, the demands placed on the system and the emergence of new technological solutions is likely to
require refinements to functional specifications at a local and regional level,
7) a report into the constructability of the whole programme and the individual components. This ongoing report is required
at all stages of the programme to confirm not only are the individual design proposals capable of meeting the
commercial specification, but also to ensure that it is feasible to build. The report will be a key component in assessing
overall programme construction risk, and
8) the definition of a robust national and international consultation strategy.
The Rail Baltic programme is in its early stages of development and significant activities will need to be undertaken prior to
concluding final service specifications, technical requirements, route alignments and final single option design components. Such
a situation is commonplace amongst all major transport projects. The position is however complicated by the following factors:
• the presence of up to 4 nation stakeholders in addition to other national interested parties
• the existence of differing regional economic objectives
• the need to accommodate the requirements of a range of stakeholders including potential users, railway undertakings,
infrastructure managers
• an acknowledgement that the programme will challenge existing regional transport provision and will impact on current
rail solutions employed
Setting these issues in context, it is important to note the high degree of co-operation which has been achieved to date between
the project countries and the acceptance that robust arrangements need to be in place to facilitate project delivery including
construction and finance. Further, the strategic objectives of the European Union, their ongoing support and the existence of
mandatory technical standards will have a significant positive impact on programme delivery. The mandatory requirement to
conform to interoperability requirements will do much to remove technical risks associated with the introduction of new systems.
The ongoing political support of the EU will also provide support in mitigating some financial risks associated with the
programme.
It is recommended that Rail Baltica development should as now be overseen by a programme steering group (PSG). The PSG
function would be to have overall control of the strategic delivery of the Rail Baltica programme. The PSG would comprise of
representatives from the principle member states and assisted by other key stakeholders including the European Union.
Whatever development option is chosen, it is recommended that an integrated programme organisation (IPO) is established at
the earliest opportunity with the principle objective of facilitating project development. The IPO must be a technical based
organisation operating within defined terms of reference and be of short term of regional, national and local influences.
27
International experience suggests that an independent IPO will be able to execute programme functioned quickly within the terms
of reference. Project activities can be effectively undertaken without time consuming and costly interventions.
It is recommended that one of the key objectives of the PSG would be to put in place an independent review group (IRG) which
would allow programme business objectives to be kept under review. The role of an independent review board would be to
provide the PSG (and through them, the IPO) with the very latest information on:
• emerging national, regional and international commercial requirements in terms of rail systems looking ahead in a 5, 10
and 30 year time period
• a review of the current and future technical capabilities of rail systems which may warrant inclusion within the Rail Baltica
programme.
It is recommended that the international group be comprised of independent rail and commercial experts who can draw on both
regional and international experience.
The following Implementation Road Map provides an indicative timeframe for the implementation of the Rail Baltica programme.
At all stages of the programme, options will exist for decision review criteria to be applied by the PSG. It should be noted that
many tasks can be undertaken simultaneously as is conceptually defined in the following Rail Baltica Implementation
Programme.
Table 17 – Implementation Road Map
Task Duration Notes
1 Review and confirm high level 6 months Accepting strategic objectives and preferred routing will
feasibility report require significant consultation
2 Establish PSG, IPO and the 2 IRGs 6 months Agreeing composition, terms of reference and governance
structures will be complex but can be undertaken in parallel
with task 1.
3 Strategic stakeholder consultation 6 months A critical process to ensure all parties endorse strategy
4 Definition of programme plan, 9 months Establishing at a strategic level, overall structures for
resourcing and financing arrangements progressing with the programme including high level
procurement and financing strategies. Opportunities to
propose financing arrangements including PPP.
5 Review of options assessment for 12 months Process designed to allow scheme to move towards single
individual projects within the option design for all components of the system. Opportunity
programme to test proposal option]s and apply value and risk
management processes
6 Environmental Impact Statement 24 months Environmental Impact Assessment of proposed option,
including alternative solutions. Strategic environmental
assessment has to be done by municipalities in parallel.
7 Spatial and Regional Planning 36 months Detail planning and reservation of territories
8 Single option design 24 months Activity to cover all elements
9 Scheme procurement 48 months Rolling programme to procure all necessary elements
associated with scheme construction. Land acquisition will be
a significant issue and consideration will need to be given to
corridor reservation and acquisition.
10 Construction 60 months
11 Testing and commissioning 6 months
28
Figure 6 – Implementation Programme
1.9 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
An interoperable North-South railway corridor linking the Baltic Countries with Poland and the rest of the EU rail network has
been seen by many as pivotal from the perspective of development of the railway transport mode in the region. The idea of Rail
Baltica first appeared in 1994 in the joint political document “Vision and Strategies around the Baltic Sea 2010” as an important
element for spatial development in the Baltic Sea Region.
Initially over 20 different route segments were considered before condensing them down to 4 key route options, designated the
red, orange, yellow and green routes. The red and yellow routes were for the most part on new alignments the primary difference
between them being in Estonia where the red route passes through Parnu and the yellow route passes through Tartu. The
orange and green routes followed for the most part the existing route corridors and again the primary difference is in Estonia
where the orange route passes through Parnu and the green route passes through Tartu.
For each of the four options freight and passenger demand was assessed along with other issues including environmental
impacts and the wider economic benefits, based upon an initial assumption of a mixed service, with passenger trains every 2
hours and freight trains running predominantly during the night. The results of the assessment showed that for passengers the
yellow option would be best. The reasons for this were that it offered a fast journey time and picked up a significant internal
demand at Tartu. For freight the greatest demand was seen on the red route predominantly as a result of the shortest journey
time. The key issue with freight demand was however found to be price.
29
A full qualitative assessment of each route option was undertaken taking into account the wider economic benefits, the potential
planning impacts and environmental issues. From this analysis it was recommended that the red route option should be
investigated further, in the form of a detailed Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA) as it was felt that it offered the potentially most viable
solution.
As stated above the red option is primarily on a new alignment passing through mainly agricultural and forest land. Whilst it
passes through a number of Natura 2000 sites and this will have an effect on the planning process it is not anticipated that this
will present a major problem to the projects implementation. Obviously a full Environmental Impact Assessment will have to be
undertaken as part of the future project development.
The results from the CBA, based on the assumptions made for the project are such that the project can be considered as
generally viable. With an overall discount rate of 5.5%, there is a positive NPV of 1,368M EUR, at 2010 prices, and a benefit cost
ratio of 1.75. The corresponding EIRR is 9.3%. However, in normal circumstances to attract EU funding for transportation
projects The EIRR would normally have to be greater than 11.0% and the BCR higher. Political factors will be a serious factor in
the future of this project both in terms of the desire of the EU to link the Baltic States with the rest of the EU using a standard
gauge railway and in terms of the individual Baltic States whose development could be stimulated by this project.
In addition, the Financial Analysis shows the project having a positive cumulative cash flow in all years suggesting that at this
level the project is financially stable. Financial indicators of the investment, without EU funding, show negative results
emphasising the importance of securing the EU funding. Although, FRR/K on a consolidated basis (IRR of national investments),
which has been calculated in accordance with method set out in the EC Guide to Cost Benefit Analysis of Investment Projects is
3.10%
The figures also show that there should be no need for subsidies during the operational period, although in order to help
stimulate initial demand, in particular for freight traffic subsidies may be helpful during the start up period.
On a country basis it is seen that the best results are in Estonia. This is not particularly surprising as passenger benefits are
accrued by having three stations; Tallinn Central, Tallinn Airport and Parnu as opposed to one station in Latvia and two in
Lithuania. In addition freight demand is strong and therefore the benefits higher as a result of the strong flows from St Petersburg
and Finland. Construction costs are also lower in Estonia as there are no major structures required.
Sensitivity tests were run for the CBA on the whole route focussing on the key variables of capital cost, spend profile, operation
and maintenance costs, demand, cost of time savings and GDP growth. With each parameter change the NPV remained
positive, but in the case of a 50% freight demand drop only just. There is no reason to believe that most of these variables are
correlated; however, it is possible that some of them will be downside whilst others are upside at the same time. For this reason,
to assess the likely results of parameter fluctuation a risk analysis was conducted using @Risk which uses a Monte Carlo
simulation approach. The result of the risk analysis is that there is a more than 95% chance that the NPV will be positive.
The project should be able to be implemented to comply with the Technical Standards of Interoperability, but certain parameters
will need to be carefully engineered in relation to infrastructure, energy, and control-command and signalization systems. The
overall framework and procurement of the required operational equipment will also need close scrutiny to comply with directives
related to rolling stock, operations and information systems.
From an implementation perspective, it is recommended that Rail Baltica development should be overseen by a programme
steering group (PSG). The PSG function would be to have overall control of the strategic delivery of the Rail Baltica programme.
The PSG would comprise of representatives from the principle member states and assisted by other key stakeholders including
the European Union. Upon commencement of the implementation, it is recommended that an integrated programme organisation
(IPO) is established at the earliest opportunity with the principle objective of facilitating project development. The IPO must be a
technical based organisation operating within defined terms of reference and be of short term of regional, national and local
influences. The IPO should be both organisationally and financially separate and independent from existing national and
international bodies.
By separating the functions of strategic control and programme, the delivery risk which has surrounded many international
projects in the past can be more effectively controlled.
In order to successfully implement such a large scale project it is also necessary to have sound project communication with and
between the parties involved. It is very necessary to provide appropriate marketing and public communications support – a solid
public affairs strategy to build consensus among the various stakeholders of the project including, but not limited to: decision
makers of the involved countries of Rail Baltica; the involved countries and the EU member states; the involved countries and EU
institutions; all involved parties within each of the involved countries (governments and local municipalities), and the general
public.
2013 2014 2015
ID Task Name Start Finish Duration
veebr märts apr mai juuni juuli aug sept okt nov dets jaan veebr märts apr mai juuni juuli aug sept okt nov dets jaan veebr märts apr mai juuni juuli aug sept okt nov dets
1 Activity 1: Spatial Planning 31.01.2013 31.12.2015 1065d
2 Publication of tender 31.01.2013 31.01.2013 0d
3 Signature of contract 26.04.2013 26.04.2013 0d
Subactivity 1: Preparation of
4 26.04.2013 15.08.2015 842d
thematic county plans
5 Initial options 26.04.2013 20.06.2013 56d
6 Preliminary designs 21.06.2013 1.06.2014 346d
7 Thematic planning 2.06.2014 28.03.2015 300d
8 Thematic plans approved 29.03.2015 15.07.2015 109d
9 Thematic plans enacted 16.07.2015 15.08.2015 31d
Subactivity 2: Preliminary
10 26.04.2013 31.12.2015 980d
technical design
11 List of sections 26.04.2013 20.06.2013 56d
12 Sketch solutions 21.06.2013 15.07.2013 25d
13 Preliminary technical design 16.07.2013 31.12.2015 899d
Subactivity 3: Budgeting and
14 26.04.2013 31.12.2015 980d
cost-benefit analysis
15 General budgeting 26.04.2013 15.07.2013 81d
Budgeting of draft design
16 16.07.2013 2.12.2014 505d
and land acquisition
17 CBA 3.12.2014 31.12.2015 394d
18 Approval of documents 31.12.2015 31.12.2015 0d
Activity 2: Consultation with public and
19 stakeholders. Publicity with the interested 26.04.2013 31.12.2015 980d
parties
20 Activity 3: Project Management 26.04.2013 31.12.2015 980d
21 Project managers appointed 26.04.2013 26.04.2013 0d
22 Taking part in project meetings 26.04.2013 31.12.2015 980d
Arranging and taking part in
23 26.04.2013 31.12.2015 980d
stakeholder meetings
24 Activity 4: Expertise on technical solutions 1.05.2013 31.12.2015 975d
25 Publication of tender 1.05.2013 1.05.2013 0d
26 Signature of contract 10.07.2013 10.07.2013 0d
27 Contract completed 31.12.2015 31.12.2015 0d
Activity 5: Preparation of tender dossier
28 1.12.2014 31.12.2015 396d
and technical assistance
29 Publication of tender 1.12.2014 1.12.2014 0d
30 Signature of contract 9.02.2015 9.02.2015 0d
31 Contract completed 31.12.2015 31.12.2015 0d
Väljaandja: Vabariigi Valitsus
Akti liik: korraldus
Teksti liik: algtekst-terviktekst
Redaktsiooni jõustumise kp: 12.04.2012
Redaktsiooni kehtivuse lõpp:
Avaldamismärge: RT III, 17.04.2012, 10
Maakonnaplaneeringu koostamise algatamine Rail
Balticu raudtee trassi koridori asukoha määramiseks
Vastu võetud 12.04.2012 nr 173
Planeerimisseaduse § 10 lõike 3 alusel ja kooskõlas sama seaduse § 7 lõikega 3, § 291lõike 1 punktiga 2 ja
lõikega 2 ning keskkonnamõju hindamise ja keskkonnajuhtimissüsteemi seaduse § 35 lõikega 1:
1. Algatada Harju, Rapla ja Pärnu maakonnas maakonnaplaneering Rail Balticu raudtee trassi koridori asukoha
määramiseks (edaspidi planeering).
2. Harju, Rapla ja Pärnu maavanemal (edaspidi maavanemad) algatada planeeringu keskkonnamõju strateegiline
hindamine.
3. Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumil moodustada planeeringu koostamise koordineerimiseks
juhtkomitee, kuhu kuuluvad Keskkonnaministeeriumi, Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumi ja
Siseministeeriumi esindajad ning maavanemad.
4. Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumil ja maavanematel sõlmida planeeringu koostamiseks ja
rahastamiseks ning ülesannete jaotamiseks koostöökokkulepe hiljemalt 30. maiks 2012. a.
5. Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumil koostöös Siseministeeriumi, Keskkonnaministeeriumi ja
maavanematega koostada planeeringu koostamise lähteseisukohad hiljemalt 30. maiks 2012. a.
6. Maavanematel korraldada planeeringu koostamine koos keskkonnamõju strateegilise hindamisega ning
esitada planeering ja planeeringu elluviimise tegevuskava Siseministeeriumile järelevalve teostamiseks hiljemalt
30. novembriks 2015. a.
Andrus Ansip
Peaminister
Heiki Loot
Riigisekretär
Maakonnaplaneeringu koostamise algatamine Rail Balticu raudtee trassi koridor... Leht 1 / 1