Saatja: ZEPPA Angela <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 28.01.2021 18:34
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>
Koopia: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Teema: Rail projects
Dear Mr Sepp, Kangur, Kõljalg, Tarand and Humal,
Please find enclosed the reply letter in the subject signed by our
Director Herald RUIJTERS (Directorate B Investment, Innovative &
Sustainable Transport).
Best regards,
Angela Zeppa
Secretary
European Commission
Directorate General for Mobility and Transport
Directorate B Investment, Innovative & Sustainable Transport
Unit B.1 Transport Networks
BRU-DM28 06/050
B- 1049 Brussels/ Belgium
Tel. 32-2-2981869
Ref. Ares(2021)707997 - 28/01/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR MOBILITY AND TRANSPORT
Directorate B - Investment, Innovative & Sustainable Transport
The Director
Brussels, 28 January 2021
MOVE B1/VK/az(2021)585761
Prof. Kalev Sepp, PhD
Chairperson of the Estonian Society for
Nature Conservation
[email protected]
Mihkel Kangur, PhD
Vice President of the Estonian
Geographical Society
[email protected]
Prof. Urmas Kõljalg, PhD
President of the Estonian Naturalists´
Society
[email protected]
Andres Tarand
Board member of the Estonian
Association for the Club of Rome
[email protected]
Priit Humal
Member of the Board of NGO Avalikult
Rail Balticust
[email protected]
By email only
Your letter to Director-General Henrik Hololei of 14 January 2021
Dear Mr Sepp, Kangur, Kõljalg, Tarand and Humal,
Thank you for your joint letter of 14 January 2021 to our Director-General Henrik Hololei,
who asked me to reply to you on his behalf.
First of all, I would like to recall that Rail Baltica is a project promoted and implemented by
Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland. The European Commission supports the project,
inter alia by providing EU co-financing, as Rail Baltica is a transport infrastructure that
Commission européenne, B-1049 Bruxelles / Europese Commissie, B-1049 Brussel - Belgium. Telephone: (32-2) 299 11 11.
Office: DM 28 06/109. Telephone: direct line (32-2) 29 68372
contributes to the achievement of the EU’s transport policy objectives as set out in the TEN-
T Regulation. In this context, Estonia is a beneficiary of EU co-funding from the
Connecting Europe Facility (CEF).
So far, the applications for CEF co-funding concerning Rail Baltica were evaluated
positively (by the external experts as well as by the internal evaluation panels). The
applications sufficiently demonstrated that the Global Project Rail Baltica to which the
individual Actions contribute will ultimately be economically viable.
Due to applicable EU legislation information or personal data of neither internal nor
external persons can be disclosed as disclosure would undermine the privacy and the
integrity of the individuals. However, INEA publishes once a year the list of all external
experts used.
Regarding the CBA, the Commission has replied to the authors of the document “Major
mistakes in Rail Baltica Cost-Benefit Analysis made by Ernst & Young” and could not
confirm that this CBA by Ernst & Young contains major errors. As for the AECOM 2011
study, the Commission has confirmed in previous correspondence that the methodology is
in line with the Commission’s guidelines for CBAs.
Furthermore, I would like to note that the European Court of Auditors (ECA) 2020 audit
report on “EU transport infrastructures: more speed needed in megaproject implementation
to deliver network effects on time”, did not identify specific shortcomings in the
methodology of the CBA of the Rail Baltica project or its traffic forecast. In its reply to the
audit, the Commission stressed that the Rail Baltica project should be assessed in view of its
future use by both passenger and freight traffic and not against separate freight or passenger
benchmarks in isolation.
I would also like to clarify that Art. 24.1 of the CEF Regulation refers to checks by the
Commission concerning fraud, corruption and any other illegal activities in the framework
of the implementation of actions financed by the CEF. This provision does not apply to the
co-financing decision as such.
With regard to your three questions:
1) It is not clear which weaknesses you refer to, but the Commission has replied to the
above-mentioned audit and the replies are part of the report published by the ECA. The
evaluation and selection process for projects to be co-funded by the EU through the CEF
programme is based on the principle of equal treatment of the proposals. This process
has proven to be robust and efficient. It foresees that for each proposal’s evaluation,
external experts form an opinion on the proposals following the award criteria.
However, the experts do not take decisions. They are not subject of penalties.
2) The technical expertise involved in the evaluation process of CEF proposals is deemed
appropriate to gather an expert opinion as foreseen in the procedures. There is no
intention to involve additional individuals or organisations in this process.
3) The European Court of Auditors (ECA) has stated “Traffic forecasts have a risk of being
overly optimistic and half of them are not well coordinated”. Traffic forecast and modal
shift calculations are assessed by external experts as part of the CBA, which is only one
of several elements of the applications for funding. The assessment of CEF applications
is done in accordance with the evaluation process stipulated in the relevant work
programmes and calls for proposals. The Commission replies to the audits and their
2
recommendations are part of the reports published by the ECA. The Commission
follows up accordingly on the relevant ECA audit recommendations.
With kind regards,
Herald RUIJTERS
Cc: Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of Estonia (
[email protected])
Electronically signed on 28/01/2021 17:11 (UTC+01) in accordance with article 11 of Commission
3 Decision C(2020) 4482