Saatja: Office of Union Health Minister <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 13.05.2019 15:30
Adressaat: SM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: Candidature of Controller & Auditor General (CAG) of India for
External Auditor for WHO (2020-2023).
Tähtsus: Kõrgeim
Excellency,
Please find attached my letter in connection with the subject matter, for
which I solicit your cooperation.
Excellency, please accept the assurances of my highest consideration.
With regards
Jagat Prakash Nadda,
CAG's Proposal for WHO Audit Comptroller and
1. Comprehensive audit coverage
Auditor General
n Audit will cover WHO headquarters, selected
of India
Regional and Country Offices, IARC, ICC, SHI,
UNAIDS and UNITAID, within the quoted cost.
Mr. Rajiv Mehrishi
n Wi l l p e r f o r m f i n a n c i a l , c o m p l i a n c e a n d
performance audit (one every year).
Comptroller and
n Audit of specific projects, if requested by WHO,
Auditor General of India
will also be conducted.
Mr. Rajiv Mehrishi assumed office as the Comptroller
2. Director of Audit to be posted at WHO and Auditor General of India on 25 September 2017.
Headquarters at Geneva Mr. Mehrishi has rich and diverse public service
experience of nearly four decades at senior positions
Candidature for External Audit of
n Will post a Director of External Audit (DEA) at
WHO headquarters in Geneva. in finance, administration and public policy. His
immediate previous position was as Home Secretary
World Health
n DEA will be responsible for risk assessment,
planning and coordinating field audits, audit
reports and interacting with management and
in the Government of India. Prior to that, he held key
positions as the Finance Secretary, Secretary
(Fertilizers) and Secretary (Overseas Indian Affairs)
Organization
those charged with governance. to the Government of India. Mr. Mehrishi has also (2020-2023)
3. Experienced and professional audit teams worked in the Ministry of Agriculture, the Cabinet
Secretariat and the President's Secretariat. He has
n Will deploy 7 Audit teams with auditors of 8 to 33 also held important positions in the Provincial
years of experience; will be experienced in IPSAS, Government of Rajasthan as the Chief Secretary, With vast experience in auditing at national
Data Analytics, IT security, ERP systems and
Applications.
Principal Secretary (Finance), Chairman of Indira and international levels, including auditing
Gandhi Nahar Board and District Magistrate and
Collector of Bikaner. With his vast experience in
national health sector and WHO, CAG of India is
n Auditors fluent in English; auditors knowing
French and Spanish also available. public service, Mr. Mehrishi possesses a perceptive ideally placed to provide high quality,
n About 70 officers have already audited WHO.
insight into the governance process in the public professional external audit services to WHO.
sector. He has been instrumental in promoting and
4. Cost effective and Value for money implementing innovative practices in various
departments in the Government at both Federal and
n Being a non-profit SAI, no audit fees is charged; the Provincial levels.
cost quoted consists of only the projected cost of
travel and logistics related expenditure.
n Most competitive proposal in terms of cost and Contact Person
deployment of audit resources. Mr. Praveen Kumar Tiwari
Additional Deputy Comptroller & Auditor General
n The auditor-months to be deployed i.e. 56 each
year, is the highest of all 6 proposals. 9, Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Marg, New Delhi-110124, India
Tel: 00-91-11-23237822 | Fax: 00-91-11-23236818
n The per auditor-day cost proposed viz. $268 is the E-mail:
[email protected]
lowest of all 6 proposals.
8. Extensive experience of auditing health sector
CREDENTIALS n Being the sole auditor of federal and state
governments in India, we audit annual
expenditure of around US $ 35 billion on health
1. Independence 4. IT Audit expertise
sector affecting 1,300 million people.
n CAG of India is a Constitutional authority with full n Leadership role in IT Audit; chair INTOSAI n Audit of health sector has a multi sectoral and
financial and operational independence. The Working Group on IT Audit since 1994. whole of government approach, also covering rural
salary and expenses of CAG are not subject to vote development, sanitation, drinking water and
n Institutional framework for use of data analytics in
of Parliament. preventive health care.
audit; 2 centres for the same.
n Cannot be removed from office except by n Diversity of health sector audit covers areas as
n Assisted several SAIs (Bangladesh, Oman, Saudi hospitals, teaching & research, dr ugs &
impeachment in Parliament, as in the case of Arabia and Vietnam, and others) in capacity
Supreme Court judges. pharmaceuticals, and flagship programmes
building in IT audit through training and aligned to WHO priorities and goals.
CAG ' s i n t e r n a t i o n a l c o m m i t m e n t s a re secondment of experts.
n n Audit national programmes on maternal and child
independent of national obligations. 5. Auditing Sustainable Development Goals health, medical education and human resources
for health, financial assistance to poor patients,
n Not obliged to share Audit Reports of International n Conducted audit of Preparedness for SDG control of AIDS, tuberculosis, cancer, diabetes,
Organizations with Indian Parliament or Implementation in India, covering also SDG 3 cardio vascular diseases, blindness and visual
government. “Good Health and Well-Being”. impairment, mental health, health care for elderly,
n C o llab o r ating w ith IN TOSAI in cap acity and organ transplant programme.
2. More than 150 years of experience in public
development for SDG audit. n Deploy over 1,100 auditor-days for health sector
auditing audit at federal level, covering performance,
n Conducted audit of SDGs in UN in 2017 and of UN
n In existence since 1860; constitutional status compliance and financial audits and all aspects of
Department of Economic and Social Affairs with health care.
conferred when the Constitution of India was focus on SDGs in 2018-19.
enacted on 26 January 1950. n During previous WHO audit, reviewed areas such
6. Constructive approach to Audit as Technical Services agreements, contracting and
n One of the largest SAIs in the world; over 45,000 n Constructive and comprehensive approach to procurement services, Global Management
staff, including 36,000 professional staff, over 3,000 audit, aimed at value addition and providing high system project, Iraq Trust Fund operations, Global
IT support staff, and over 135 offices across India quality professional audit services in conformity Service Centre, etc.; made recommendations for
and abroad. with international standards. improvement of governance, accountability and
transparency in the delivery of services.
3. International auditing experience n Recommendations aim at systemic improvements
n Large pool of auditors having competencies in
w i t h f o c u s o n e f f i c i e n c y, e c o n o m y a n d health sector audit; several auditors with
n Over 86 years of cumulative international audit effectiveness. understanding of WHO policies, procedures and
experience.
n Recommendations have contributed to the programmes.
n Audited 12 international agencies like the UN improvement of management and performance, n Uniquely positioned to audit WHO in light of
(1993-1999 and currently since 2014), World governance, accountability and transparency, and national and international experience of auditing
Health Organization (2004-2011), FAO (2002-08), delivery of services. health sector; will provide inputs for
WFP (2010-16), IAEA (2012-15), WIPO (2012-17), 7. Professional and trained Staff, bound by Code implementation of WHO's goals of universal health
IMO (2000-12), OPCW (1997-2003), UNWTO (2000- coverage, health emergencies and promoting
of Ethics and Conduct Rules healthier populations.
2014), IOM (2010-2016), ITER (2011) and ICGEB
(1996-2004). n 15 training institutes, including 2 international
training centres for IT Audit and Environmental
n Reports appreciated by all stakeholders, including Audit, which are Designated Global Training
ACABQ and Fifth Committee of the UN, for quality Facilities.
and content. n Regular in-career training programs for auditors, in
n Pro m i n e n t p l a y e r i n i n t e r n a t i o n a l a u d i t collaboration with premier institutes in India and
community; on Governing Boards of INTOSAI and abroad.
ASOSAI; chair INTOSAI's Knowledge Sharing n Staff bound by a strong code of ethics and conduct
Committee, Compliance Audit Sub-committee and rules, with graded system of penalty, including
Working Group on IT Audit. dismissal from service.
8. Extensive experience of auditing health sector
CREDENTIALS n Being the sole auditor of federal and state
governments in India, we audit annual
expenditure of around US $ 35 billion on health
1. Independence 4. IT Audit expertise
sector affecting 1,300 million people.
n CAG of India is a Constitutional authority with full n Leadership role in IT Audit; chair INTOSAI n Audit of health sector has a multi sectoral and
financial and operational independence. The Working Group on IT Audit since 1994. whole of government approach, also covering rural
salary and expenses of CAG are not subject to vote development, sanitation, drinking water and
n Institutional framework for use of data analytics in
of Parliament. preventive health care.
audit; 2 centres for the same.
n Cannot be removed from office except by n Diversity of health sector audit covers areas as
n Assisted several SAIs (Bangladesh, Oman, Saudi hospitals, teaching & research, dr ugs &
impeachment in Parliament, as in the case of Arabia and Vietnam, and others) in capacity
Supreme Court judges. pharmaceuticals, and flagship programmes
building in IT audit through training and aligned to WHO priorities and goals.
CAG ' s i n t e r n a t i o n a l c o m m i t m e n t s a re secondment of experts.
n n Audit national programmes on maternal and child
independent of national obligations. 5. Auditing Sustainable Development Goals health, medical education and human resources
for health, financial assistance to poor patients,
n Not obliged to share Audit Reports of International n Conducted audit of Preparedness for SDG control of AIDS, tuberculosis, cancer, diabetes,
Organizations with Indian Parliament or Implementation in India, covering also SDG 3 cardio vascular diseases, blindness and visual
government. “Good Health and Well-Being”. impairment, mental health, health care for elderly,
n C o llab o r ating w ith IN TOSAI in cap acity and organ transplant programme.
2. More than 150 years of experience in public
development for SDG audit. n Deploy over 1,100 auditor-days for health sector
auditing audit at federal level, covering performance,
n Conducted audit of SDGs in UN in 2017 and of UN
n In existence since 1860; constitutional status compliance and financial audits and all aspects of
Department of Economic and Social Affairs with health care.
conferred when the Constitution of India was focus on SDGs in 2018-19.
enacted on 26 January 1950. n During previous WHO audit, reviewed areas such
6. Constructive approach to Audit as Technical Services agreements, contracting and
n One of the largest SAIs in the world; over 45,000 n Constructive and comprehensive approach to procurement services, Global Management
staff, including 36,000 professional staff, over 3,000 audit, aimed at value addition and providing high system project, Iraq Trust Fund operations, Global
IT support staff, and over 135 offices across India quality professional audit services in conformity Service Centre, etc.; made recommendations for
and abroad. with international standards. improvement of governance, accountability and
transparency in the delivery of services.
3. International auditing experience n Recommendations aim at systemic improvements
n Large pool of auditors having competencies in
w i t h f o c u s o n e f f i c i e n c y, e c o n o m y a n d health sector audit; several auditors with
n Over 86 years of cumulative international audit effectiveness. understanding of WHO policies, procedures and
experience.
n Recommendations have contributed to the programmes.
n Audited 12 international agencies like the UN improvement of management and performance, n Uniquely positioned to audit WHO in light of
(1993-1999 and currently since 2014), World governance, accountability and transparency, and national and international experience of auditing
Health Organization (2004-2011), FAO (2002-08), delivery of services. health sector; will provide inputs for
WFP (2010-16), IAEA (2012-15), WIPO (2012-17), 7. Professional and trained Staff, bound by Code implementation of WHO's goals of universal health
IMO (2000-12), OPCW (1997-2003), UNWTO (2000- coverage, health emergencies and promoting
of Ethics and Conduct Rules healthier populations.
2014), IOM (2010-2016), ITER (2011) and ICGEB
(1996-2004). n 15 training institutes, including 2 international
training centres for IT Audit and Environmental
n Reports appreciated by all stakeholders, including Audit, which are Designated Global Training
ACABQ and Fifth Committee of the UN, for quality Facilities.
and content. n Regular in-career training programs for auditors, in
n Pro m i n e n t p l a y e r i n i n t e r n a t i o n a l a u d i t collaboration with premier institutes in India and
community; on Governing Boards of INTOSAI and abroad.
ASOSAI; chair INTOSAI's Knowledge Sharing n Staff bound by a strong code of ethics and conduct
Committee, Compliance Audit Sub-committee and rules, with graded system of penalty, including
Working Group on IT Audit. dismissal from service.
8. Extensive experience of auditing health sector
CREDENTIALS n Being the sole auditor of federal and state
governments in India, we audit annual
expenditure of around US $ 35 billion on health
1. Independence 4. IT Audit expertise
sector affecting 1,300 million people.
n CAG of India is a Constitutional authority with full n Leadership role in IT Audit; chair INTOSAI n Audit of health sector has a multi sectoral and
financial and operational independence. The Working Group on IT Audit since 1994. whole of government approach, also covering rural
salary and expenses of CAG are not subject to vote development, sanitation, drinking water and
n Institutional framework for use of data analytics in
of Parliament. preventive health care.
audit; 2 centres for the same.
n Cannot be removed from office except by n Diversity of health sector audit covers areas as
n Assisted several SAIs (Bangladesh, Oman, Saudi hospitals, teaching & research, dr ugs &
impeachment in Parliament, as in the case of Arabia and Vietnam, and others) in capacity
Supreme Court judges. pharmaceuticals, and flagship programmes
building in IT audit through training and aligned to WHO priorities and goals.
CAG ' s i n t e r n a t i o n a l c o m m i t m e n t s a re secondment of experts.
n n Audit national programmes on maternal and child
independent of national obligations. 5. Auditing Sustainable Development Goals health, medical education and human resources
for health, financial assistance to poor patients,
n Not obliged to share Audit Reports of International n Conducted audit of Preparedness for SDG control of AIDS, tuberculosis, cancer, diabetes,
Organizations with Indian Parliament or Implementation in India, covering also SDG 3 cardio vascular diseases, blindness and visual
government. “Good Health and Well-Being”. impairment, mental health, health care for elderly,
n C o llab o r ating w ith IN TOSAI in cap acity and organ transplant programme.
2. More than 150 years of experience in public
development for SDG audit. n Deploy over 1,100 auditor-days for health sector
auditing audit at federal level, covering performance,
n Conducted audit of SDGs in UN in 2017 and of UN
n In existence since 1860; constitutional status compliance and financial audits and all aspects of
Department of Economic and Social Affairs with health care.
conferred when the Constitution of India was focus on SDGs in 2018-19.
enacted on 26 January 1950. n During previous WHO audit, reviewed areas such
6. Constructive approach to Audit as Technical Services agreements, contracting and
n One of the largest SAIs in the world; over 45,000 n Constructive and comprehensive approach to procurement services, Global Management
staff, including 36,000 professional staff, over 3,000 audit, aimed at value addition and providing high system project, Iraq Trust Fund operations, Global
IT support staff, and over 135 offices across India quality professional audit services in conformity Service Centre, etc.; made recommendations for
and abroad. with international standards. improvement of governance, accountability and
transparency in the delivery of services.
3. International auditing experience n Recommendations aim at systemic improvements
n Large pool of auditors having competencies in
w i t h f o c u s o n e f f i c i e n c y, e c o n o m y a n d health sector audit; several auditors with
n Over 86 years of cumulative international audit effectiveness. understanding of WHO policies, procedures and
experience.
n Recommendations have contributed to the programmes.
n Audited 12 international agencies like the UN improvement of management and performance, n Uniquely positioned to audit WHO in light of
(1993-1999 and currently since 2014), World governance, accountability and transparency, and national and international experience of auditing
Health Organization (2004-2011), FAO (2002-08), delivery of services. health sector; will provide inputs for
WFP (2010-16), IAEA (2012-15), WIPO (2012-17), 7. Professional and trained Staff, bound by Code implementation of WHO's goals of universal health
IMO (2000-12), OPCW (1997-2003), UNWTO (2000- coverage, health emergencies and promoting
of Ethics and Conduct Rules healthier populations.
2014), IOM (2010-2016), ITER (2011) and ICGEB
(1996-2004). n 15 training institutes, including 2 international
training centres for IT Audit and Environmental
n Reports appreciated by all stakeholders, including Audit, which are Designated Global Training
ACABQ and Fifth Committee of the UN, for quality Facilities.
and content. n Regular in-career training programs for auditors, in
n Pro m i n e n t p l a y e r i n i n t e r n a t i o n a l a u d i t collaboration with premier institutes in India and
community; on Governing Boards of INTOSAI and abroad.
ASOSAI; chair INTOSAI's Knowledge Sharing n Staff bound by a strong code of ethics and conduct
Committee, Compliance Audit Sub-committee and rules, with graded system of penalty, including
Working Group on IT Audit. dismissal from service.
CAG's Proposal for WHO Audit Comptroller and
1. Comprehensive audit coverage
Auditor General
n Audit will cover WHO headquarters, selected
of India
Regional and Country Offices, IARC, ICC, SHI,
UNAIDS and UNITAID, within the quoted cost.
Mr. Rajiv Mehrishi
n Wi l l p e r f o r m f i n a n c i a l , c o m p l i a n c e a n d
performance audit (one every year).
Comptroller and
n Audit of specific projects, if requested by WHO,
Auditor General of India
will also be conducted.
Mr. Rajiv Mehrishi assumed office as the Comptroller
2. Director of Audit to be posted at WHO and Auditor General of India on 25 September 2017.
Headquarters at Geneva Mr. Mehrishi has rich and diverse public service
experience of nearly four decades at senior positions
Candidature for External Audit of
n Will post a Director of External Audit (DEA) at
WHO headquarters in Geneva. in finance, administration and public policy. His
immediate previous position was as Home Secretary
World Health
n DEA will be responsible for risk assessment,
planning and coordinating field audits, audit
reports and interacting with management and
in the Government of India. Prior to that, he held key
positions as the Finance Secretary, Secretary
(Fertilizers) and Secretary (Overseas Indian Affairs)
Organization
those charged with governance. to the Government of India. Mr. Mehrishi has also (2020-2023)
3. Experienced and professional audit teams worked in the Ministry of Agriculture, the Cabinet
Secretariat and the President's Secretariat. He has
n Will deploy 7 Audit teams with auditors of 8 to 33 also held important positions in the Provincial
years of experience; will be experienced in IPSAS, Government of Rajasthan as the Chief Secretary, With vast experience in auditing at national
Data Analytics, IT security, ERP systems and
Applications.
Principal Secretary (Finance), Chairman of Indira and international levels, including auditing
Gandhi Nahar Board and District Magistrate and
Collector of Bikaner. With his vast experience in
national health sector and WHO, CAG of India is
n Auditors fluent in English; auditors knowing
French and Spanish also available. public service, Mr. Mehrishi possesses a perceptive ideally placed to provide high quality,
n About 70 officers have already audited WHO.
insight into the governance process in the public professional external audit services to WHO.
sector. He has been instrumental in promoting and
4. Cost effective and Value for money implementing innovative practices in various
departments in the Government at both Federal and
n Being a non-profit SAI, no audit fees is charged; the Provincial levels.
cost quoted consists of only the projected cost of
travel and logistics related expenditure.
n Most competitive proposal in terms of cost and Contact Person
deployment of audit resources. Mr. Praveen Kumar Tiwari
Additional Deputy Comptroller & Auditor General
n The auditor-months to be deployed i.e. 56 each
year, is the highest of all 6 proposals. 9, Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Marg, New Delhi-110124, India
Tel: 00-91-11-23237822 | Fax: 00-91-11-23236818
n The per auditor-day cost proposed viz. $268 is the E-mail:
[email protected]
lowest of all 6 proposals.
CAG's Proposal for WHO Audit Comptroller and
1. Comprehensive audit coverage
Auditor General
n Audit will cover WHO headquarters, selected
of India
Regional and Country Offices, IARC, ICC, SHI,
UNAIDS and UNITAID, within the quoted cost.
Mr. Rajiv Mehrishi
n Wi l l p e r f o r m f i n a n c i a l , c o m p l i a n c e a n d
performance audit (one every year).
Comptroller and
n Audit of specific projects, if requested by WHO,
Auditor General of India
will also be conducted.
Mr. Rajiv Mehrishi assumed office as the Comptroller
2. Director of Audit to be posted at WHO and Auditor General of India on 25 September 2017.
Headquarters at Geneva Mr. Mehrishi has rich and diverse public service
experience of nearly four decades at senior positions
Candidature for External Audit of
n Will post a Director of External Audit (DEA) at
WHO headquarters in Geneva. in finance, administration and public policy. His
immediate previous position was as Home Secretary
World Health
n DEA will be responsible for risk assessment,
planning and coordinating field audits, audit
reports and interacting with management and
in the Government of India. Prior to that, he held key
positions as the Finance Secretary, Secretary
(Fertilizers) and Secretary (Overseas Indian Affairs)
Organization
those charged with governance. to the Government of India. Mr. Mehrishi has also (2020-2023)
3. Experienced and professional audit teams worked in the Ministry of Agriculture, the Cabinet
Secretariat and the President's Secretariat. He has
n Will deploy 7 Audit teams with auditors of 8 to 33 also held important positions in the Provincial
years of experience; will be experienced in IPSAS, Government of Rajasthan as the Chief Secretary, With vast experience in auditing at national
Data Analytics, IT security, ERP systems and
Applications.
Principal Secretary (Finance), Chairman of Indira and international levels, including auditing
Gandhi Nahar Board and District Magistrate and
Collector of Bikaner. With his vast experience in
national health sector and WHO, CAG of India is
n Auditors fluent in English; auditors knowing
French and Spanish also available. public service, Mr. Mehrishi possesses a perceptive ideally placed to provide high quality,
n About 70 officers have already audited WHO.
insight into the governance process in the public professional external audit services to WHO.
sector. He has been instrumental in promoting and
4. Cost effective and Value for money implementing innovative practices in various
departments in the Government at both Federal and
n Being a non-profit SAI, no audit fees is charged; the Provincial levels.
cost quoted consists of only the projected cost of
travel and logistics related expenditure.
n Most competitive proposal in terms of cost and Contact Person
deployment of audit resources. Mr. Praveen Kumar Tiwari
Additional Deputy Comptroller & Auditor General
n The auditor-months to be deployed i.e. 56 each
year, is the highest of all 6 proposals. 9, Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Marg, New Delhi-110124, India
Tel: 00-91-11-23237822 | Fax: 00-91-11-23236818
n The per auditor-day cost proposed viz. $268 is the E-mail:
[email protected]
lowest of all 6 proposals.