@Am SOCIAL
DECENT
JUSTICE
WORK
Tel. (direct):
Fax (direct):
Email:
TO ALL MEMBER STATES
Ref.: 1LC108-500-7
Your Ref.:
10 May 2019
Dear Sir/Madam,
As has now been the practice since 2006, please find attached (Annex I) a preliminary list of
cases for possible discussion at the Coinmittee on the Application of Standards (CAS) of the 108th
Session (June 2019) of the International Labour Conference, which was prepared by the social
partners.
The social partners have asked me to specify that this preliminary list is only a tentative list
and should not in any way be considered definitive, as the adoption of a final list is a function that
only the Conference Committee itself can assume. Byproviding a preliminary list, the social partners
have expressed their desire to positively respond to the requests from governments for early
notification, so that they may better prepare themselves for a possible intervention before the
Committee. This list should not give rise to any form of pressure or other prejudicial act against
unions or employers' orgaruzations.
Your attention is drawn to the fact that the final list of individual cases will include those
cases, indicated in this preliminary list with a double asterisk, in wmch the Committee of Experts has
requested governrnents to supply full information to the Conference at its 108th Session (the so-called
"double footnote" cases).1 Please also note that the CAS will begin its discussion of individual cases
with those cases, during the afternoon of the Wednesday, 12 June 2019, starting with the letter "T".
During the informal tripartite consultations on the working methods of the Committee held
on 23 March 2019, it was decided to provide the opportunity for Governrnents appearing on the
preliminary list of cases to provide, if they so wished, written information to the Cornrnittee. This
information provided, on a purely voluntary basis, should concern only new developments not yet
examined by the Cornrnittee of Experts. They must be transmitted in one of the three working
languages of the Office at latest two weeks before the beginning of the opening of the session of the
Conference (27 May 2019) and shall not exceed 3 pages.
' Please see the table inserted in paraqraph 80 of the General Report of the Committee of Experts (ILC 2019,
Report Ill, part (A)).
International LabourOrganization
Route des Morillons 4 I CH-1211 Ger 22 I Tel.: +41 22 799 61 11 I Cenhal Fmi +41 22 798 86 85 I Email:
[email protected] I Websitei viivwv.ilo.org
2
As per the established practice, you will also find attached (Annexes II and III, respectively)
document D.O (Provisional Working Schedule), and document D.1 (Work of the Committee). These
two documents have been prepared by the Office taking into account the results of the infonnal
tiipartite consultations on the working methods of the CAS held on 3 November 2018 and 23 March
2019. They will be submitted to the CAS for adoption at the beginning of its work.
Finally, I wish to take this opp01tunity to recall that this year the CAS will discuss the General
Survey entitled "Universal social protection for human dignity, social justice and sustainable
development". The General Survey concerns the Social Protection Floors Recommendation, 2012
(No. 202).
The International Labour Office, and in particular, the International Labour Standards
Department and the Decent Work Technical Supp01i Team covering your country, remain at your
disposal to provide your Government with any technical assistance it may require in respect of the
preparation of the next session of the CAS.
I hope that the information contained in this letter and its attachments will assist your country
in its preparations for the forthcoming session of the International Labour Conference Committee on
the Application of Standards.
For the Director-General:
71A
· 1 /l
Corinne �rgha
Director of the International Labour
Standards Department
International Labour Organization
Route des Morillons 4 I CH-1211 Geneve 22 I Tel.: +41 22 799 61 11 I Central Fax: +41 22 798 86 85 I Email:
[email protected] I Website: www.ilo.org
ANNEX I
Preliminary list of cases as submitted by the social partners
Committee on the Application of Standards - ILC 2019
Country Convention(s) No(s)
1 Algeria 87
2 Argentina 87
3 Belarus 29
4 Plurinational State of Bolivia 131
5 Brazil 98
6 Cabo Verde 182
7 Chad 151
8 Colombia 29
9 Egypt 87
10 El Salvador 144
11 Equatorial Guinea 98
12 Ethiopia 138**
13 Fiji 87
14 Greece 98
15 Guatemala 169
16 Guinea 142
17 Honduras 87
18 India 81
19 Iraq 182**
20 Kazakhstan 87
21 Republic of Korea 111
22 Lao People’s Democratic Republic 182
23 Liberia 98
24 Libya 111**
25 Malawi 29
26 Myanmar 29**
27 Nicaragua 117**
28 Papua New Guinea 182
29 Philippines 87
30 Serbia 81/129
31 Sierra Leone 88
32 Switzerland 98
33 Tajikistan 111
34 Turkey 87**
35 Ukraine 95
36 United Kingdom 87
37 Uruguay 98
38 Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela 122
39 Yemen 182
40 Zimbabwe 87
** double footnoted
Total number of cases concerning 29
Fundamental Conventions
Total number of cases concerning 4
Priority Conventions
Total number of cases concerning 7
Technical Conventions
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR CONFERENCE C.App./D.0
108th Session, Geneva, June 2019
Committee on the Application of Standards
PROVISIONAL WORKING SCHEDULE
(See Daily Bulletin for actual time schedules)
Individual cases: Cases included in the final list will be automatically registered and evenly distributed
by the Office, on the basis of a rotating alphabetical system, following the French alphabetical order. This
year, the registration will begin with countries with the letter “T”.
Cases will be divided in two groups: the first group of countries to be registered following the above
alphabetical order will consist of those cases in which a double footnote was inserted by the Committee
of Experts and are found in paragraph 80 of the Committee’s report. The second group of countries will
consist of all the other cases on the final list and they will be registered by the Office following the above-
mentioned alphabetical order. The case numbers set in the provisional schedule below do not
correspond to any particular countries until the final list is adopted.
Monday, 10 June 14:30 – 16:30 – Election of Officers
– Centenary celebration and Opening
statements
– Discussion on the Committee’s working
methods
– Adoption of document D.1
(Work of the Committee)
17:00 – 19:30 Group meetings
20:00 – 21:00 Group meetings (if necessary)
Tuesday, 11 June 10:00 – 11:00 Group meetings
11:00 – 13:00 – General Discussion on the General Report
– Adoption of the list of cases (D.4)
Immediately followed by an informal information session for
Governments (Room II)
15:00 – 18:00 – Discussion on the CEART’s report 1
– Discussion on the General Survey
18:30 – 21:30 Discussion on the General Survey (cont.)
Wednesday, 12 June 10:00 – 13:00 – Discussion of cases of serious failure by
member States to respect their reporting and
other standards-related obligations
– General discussion (cont.) with replies of the
Chairperson of the Committee of Experts, the
representative of the Secretary-General and
the Vice-Chairpersons of the Employers’ and
the Workers’ groups
1 During the informal tripartite consultations on the working methods of the Committee held in March 2016, there was
agreement that, in view of time constraints, the examination of the report of the Joint ILO/UNESCO Committee of
Experts on the Application of the Recommendations concerning Teaching Personnel (CEART) should take no more
than one hour.
2019 - D.0 Provisional working schedule English.docx 1
Wednesday, 12 June 14:00 – 15:00 Group meetings
15:00 – 18:00 Individual cases 1–2 (double-footnoted cases)
18:30 – 21:00 Individual case 3 (double-footnoted case)
Thursday, 13 June 10:00 – 13:00 Individual cases 4–5 (double-footnoted cases)
15:00 – 18:00 Individual case 6 (double-footnoted case)
18:30 – 21:00 Individual case 7
Friday, 14 June 10:00 – 13:00 Individual cases 8–9
15:00 – 18:00 Individual case 10
18:30 – 21:00 Individual case 11
Saturday, 15 June 10:00 – 13:00 Individual cases 12–13
15:00 – 18:00 Individual case 14
Monday, 17 June 10:00 – 13:00 – Adoption of conclusions on individual cases
(1–11)
– Individual case 15
15:00 – 18:00 Individual cases 16–17
18:30 – 21:00 Individual case 18
Tuesday, 18 June 10:00 – 13:00 Individual cases 19–20
15:00 – 18:00 Individual case 21
18:30 – 21:00 Individual case 22
Wednesday, 19 June 10:00 – 13:00 – Adoption of conclusions on individual cases
(12–17)
– Individual cases 23 and 24
15:00 – 16:00 Individual case 24 (if necessary)
16:00 – 17:00 Examination of draft General Report by Officers
Thursday, 20 June 16:00 – Adoption of conclusions on individual cases
(18–24)
– Adoption of the outcome of the discussion on
the General Survey
– Adoption of the General Report
Friday, 21 June To be Adoption of report in plenary of the ILC
determined
2 2019 - D.0 Provisional working schedule English.docx
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR CONFERENCE C.App./D.1
108th Session, Geneva, June 2019
Committee on the Application of Standards
Work of the Committee
I. Introduction
This document (D.1) sets out the manner in which the work of the Committee on the
Application of Standards (CAS) is carried out. It is submitted to the Committee for adoption
when it begins its work at each session of the Conference. 1 This document reflects the
results of the discussions and informal tripartite consultations that have taken place, since
2002, on the working methods of the Committee, including on the following issues: the
elaboration of the list of individual cases to be discussed by the Committee; the preparation
and adoption of the conclusions relating to these individual cases; time management and
respect for parliamentary rules of decorum.
This document takes into account the results of the last informal tripartite consultations
on the working methods of the CAS held on 3 November 2018 and on 23 March 2019.
II. Terms of reference and composition
of the Committee, voting procedure
and report to the Conference
Under its terms of reference as defined in article 7, paragraph 1, of the Standing Orders
of the Conference, the Committee is called upon to consider:
(a) the measures taken by Members to give effect to the provisions of Conventions to
which they are parties and the information furnished by Members concerning the results
of inspections;
(b) the information and reports concerning Conventions and Recommendations
communicated by Members in accordance with article 19 of the Constitution;
(c) the measures taken by Members in accordance with article 35 of the Constitution.
In accordance with article 7, paragraph 2, of the Standing Orders of the Conference,
the Committee submits a report to the Conference. Since 2007, in response to the wishes
expressed by ILO constituents, the report of the Committee has been published both in the
Record of Proceedings of the Conference and as a separate publication, to improve the
visibility of the Committee’s work.
1
Since 2010, the document is appended to the General Report of the Committee.
ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx 1
Questions related to the composition of the Committee, the right to participate in its
work and the voting procedure are regulated by section H of Part II of the Standing Orders
of the Conference.
Each year, the Committee elects its Officers: its Chairperson and Vice-Chairpersons,
as well as its Reporter.
III. Working documents
A. Report of the Committee of Experts
The basic working document of the Committee is the report of the Committee of
Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations (Report III (Parts A
and B)), printed in two volumes.
Report III (Part A) contains, in Part One, the General Report of the Committee of
Experts, and in Part Two, the observations of the Committee of Experts concerning the
sending of reports, the application of ratified Conventions and the obligation to submit the
Conventions and Recommendations to the competent authorities in member States. At the
beginning of the report there is an index of comments by Convention and by country. In
addition to the observations contained in its report, the Committee of Experts has, as in
previous years, made direct requests which are communicated to governments by the Office
on the Committee’s behalf. 2
Report III (Part B) contains the General Survey prepared by the Committee of Experts
on a group of Conventions and Recommendations decided upon by the Governing Body.
B. Summaries of reports
At its 267th Session (November 1996), the Governing Body approved new measures
for rationalization and simplification of the arrangements for the presentation by the
Director-General to the Conference of summaries of reports submitted by governments
under articles 19, 22 and 35 of the Constitution. 3 Requests for consultation or copies of
reports may be addressed to the secretariat of the CAS.
C. Other information
The secretariat prepares documents (which are referred to, and referenced, as
“D documents”) which are made available 4 during the course of the work of the Committee
through its web page to provide the following information:
(i) reports and information which have reached the International Labour Office since the
last meeting of the Committee of Experts; based on this information, the list of
2
See para. 71 of the General Report of the Committee of Experts. A list of direct requests can be
found in Appendix VII of Report III (Part A).
3
See report of the Committee of Experts, Report III (Part A), Appendices I, II, IV, V and VI; and
Report III (Part B), Appendix III.
4
D documents will be made available online on the Committee’s dedicated web page (hard copies
will be made available to delegates upon request).
2 ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx
governments which are invited to supply information to the Conference Committee due
to serious failure to respect their reporting and other standards-related obligations is
updated; 5
(ii) written information supplied by governments to the Conference Committee in reply to
the observations made by the Committee of Experts, when these governments are on
the preliminary list of cases or on the list of individual cases adopted by the Conference
Committee. 6
IV. General discussion
In accordance with its usual practice, the Committee begins its work with the
consideration of its working methods on the basis of this document. The Committee then
holds a discussion on general aspects of the application of Conventions and
Recommendations and the discharge by member States of standards-related obligations
under the ILO Constitution, which is primarily based on the General Report of the
Committee of Experts.
It also holds a discussion on the General Survey, entitled Universal social protection
for human dignity, social justice and sustainable development. The General Survey concerns
the Social Protection Floors Recommendation, 2012 (No. 202). 7
V. Cases of serious failure by member
States to respect their reporting and
other standards-related obligations 8
Governments are invited to supply information on cases of serious failure to respect
reporting or other standards-related obligations for stated periods. These cases are
considered in a dedicated sitting of the Committee. Governments that submit the required
information before the sitting will not be called before the Committee. The discussion of the
Committee, including any explanations of difficulties that may have been provided by the
governments concerned, and the conclusions adopted by the Committee under each criterion
are reflected in its report.
5
See below Part V.
6
See below Part VI (supply of information).
7
It should be recalled that the subjects of General Surveys have been aligned with the strategic
objectives that are examined in the context of the recurrent discussions under the follow-up to the
ILO Declaration on Social Justice for a Fair Globalization (2008). The discussion of General Surveys
by the Committee will continue to be held one year in advance of the recurrent discussion under the
new five-year cycle of recurrent discussions adopted by the Governing Body in November 2016. The
full synchronization of General Surveys and their discussion by the Committee will be re-established
under the new cycle in the context of the recurrent discussion on social protection (social security) to
be held by the Conference in 2020 (see GB.328/INS/5/2 and GB.328/PV (paras 25 and 102)).
8
Formerly known as “automatic” cases (see Provisional Record No. 22, International Labour
Conference, 93rd Session, June 2005, para. 69).
ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx 3
The Committee identifies the cases on the basis of criteria which are as follows: 9
– None of the reports on ratified Conventions have been supplied during the past
two years or more.
– First reports on ratified Conventions have not been supplied for at least two years.
– None of the reports on unratified Conventions and Recommendations requested under
article 19, paragraphs 5, 6 and 7, of the Constitution have been supplied during the past
five years.
– No indication is available on whether steps have been taken to submit the instruments
adopted during the last seven sessions of the Conference to the competent authorities,
in accordance with article 19 of the Constitution. 10
– No information has been received as regards all or most of the observations and direct
requests of the Committee of Experts to which a reply was requested for the period
under consideration.
– The government has failed during the past three years to indicate the representative
organizations of employers and workers to which, in accordance with article 23,
paragraph 2, of the Constitution, copies of reports and information supplied to the
Office have been communicated.
At its 88th Session (November–December 2017), the Committee of Experts decided to
institute a new practice of launching “urgent appeals” on cases corresponding to certain
criteria of serious reporting failure 11 and to draw the attention of the Committee on the
Application of Standards to these cases, so that governments can be called before the
Conference Committee and thus advised that, in the absence of a report, the Committee of
Experts might examine the substance of the matter at its next session. Thus, at its session of
November–December 2018, the Committee of Experts issued urgent appeals to eight
countries which had failed to send a first report for at least three years. 12 In addition, the
Committee of Experts decided that, as of its next session, it would generalize this practice
by issuing urgent appeals in all cases where article 22 reports have not been received for
three consecutive years. 13 The eight countries to which urgent appeals have been addressed
will be invited to provide information to the Committee during the examination of cases of
serious failure to comply with reporting obligations.
9
These criteria were last examined by the Committee in 1980 (see Provisional Record No. 37,
International Labour Conference, 66th Session, 1980, para. 30).
10
This time frame begins at the 96th Session (2007) and concludes at the 106th Session (2017) of the
International Labour Conference, bearing in mind that the Conference did not adopt any Conventions
or Recommendations during the 97th (2008), 98th (2009), 102nd (2013) and 105th (2016) Sessions.
11
See paragraphs 9 and 10 of the General Report of the Committee of Experts (Report III (Part A),
International Labour Conference, 107th Session, 2018).
12
See para. 59 of the General Report of the Committee of Experts – Report III (Part A), ILC, 108th
Session, 2019.
13
As a result, repetitions of previous comments will be limited to a maximum of three years, following
which the Convention’s application will be examined in substance by the Committee on the basis of
publicly available information, even if the government has not sent a report (see para. 10 of the
General Report of the Committee of Experts – Report III (Part A), ILC, 108th Session, 2019).
4 ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx
VI. Individual cases
The Committee considers cases relating to the application of ratified Conventions.
These cases are selected on the basis of the observations published in the report of the
Committee of Experts.
Preliminary list. Since 2006, an early communication to governments of a
preliminary list of individual cases for possible discussion by the Committee concerning the
application of ratified Conventions has been instituted. Since 2015, the preliminary list of
cases has been made available 30 days before the opening of the International Labour
Conference. The preliminary list is a response to the requests from governments for early
notification, so that they may better prepare themselves for a possible intervention before
the Committee. It may not in any way be considered definitive, as the adoption of a final
list is a function that only the Committee itself can assume. During the informal tripartite
consultations of March 2019, it was decided to provide the opportunity for governments
appearing on the preliminary list of cases to provide, if they so wished, written information
to the Committee. This information provided, on a purely voluntary basis, should concern
only new developments not yet examined by the Committee of Experts. They must be
transmitted in one of the three working languages of the Office at least two weeks before the
beginning of the opening of the session of the Conference and shall not exceed three pages.
Establishment of the list of cases. The list of individual cases is submitted to the
Committee for adoption, after the Employers’ and Workers’ groups have met to discuss and
adopt it. The final list should be adopted at the beginning of the Committee’s work, ideally
no later than its second sitting.
ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx 5
As of the revision in 2015 of the criteria for the selection of cases, the selection should take into
consideration, on balance, the following elements:
– the nature of the comments of the Committee of Experts, in particular the existence of a footnote; *
– the quality and scope of responses provided by the government or the absence of a response on
its part;
– the seriousness and persistence of shortcomings in the application of the Convention;
– the urgency of a specific situation;
– comments received by employers’ and workers’ organizations;
– the nature of a specific situation (if it raises a hitherto undiscussed question, or if the case presents
an interesting approach to solving questions of application);
– the discussions and conclusions of the Conference Committee of previous sessions and, in
particular, the existence of a special paragraph;
– the likelihood that discussing the case would have a tangible impact;
– balance between fundamental, governance and technical Conventions;
– geographical balance; and
– balance between developed and developing countries.
* See paras 75–80 of the General Report of the Committee of Experts. The criteria developed by the Committee
of Experts for footnotes are also reproduced in Appendix I of this document.
There is also the possibility of examining one case of progress as was done in 2006,
2007, 2008 and 2013. 14
Since 2007, it has been the practice to follow the adoption of the list of individual cases
with an informal information session for governments, hosted by the Employer and Worker
Vice-Chairpersons, to explain the criteria used for the selection of individual cases.
Automatic registration. Since 2010, cases included in the final list have been
automatically registered and scheduled by the Office, on the basis of a rotating alphabetical
system, following the French alphabetical order; the “A+5” model has been chosen to ensure
a genuine rotation of countries on the list. This year, the registration will begin with countries
with the letter “T”. Cases will be divided into two groups: the first group of countries to be
registered following the above alphabetical order will consist of those cases in which the
Committee of Experts requested governments to submit full particulars to the Conference
(“double-footnoted cases”). 15 Since 2012, the Committee begins its discussion of individual
cases with these cases. The other cases on the final list are then registered by the Office also
following the above-mentioned alphabetical order.
14
See paras 83–89 of the General Report of the Committee of Experts. The criteria developed by the
Committee of Experts for identifying cases of progress are also reproduced in Appendix II of this
document.
15
See para. 80 of the General Report of the Committee of Experts.
6 ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx
Information on the agenda of the Committee and the date on which cases may be heard
is available:
(a) through the Daily Bulletin and the Committee’s dedicated web page;
(b) by means of a D document containing the list of individual cases and the working
schedule for the examination of these cases, which is made available to the Committee
as soon as possible after the adoption of the list of cases. 16
Supply of information. Prior to their oral intervention before the Conference
Committee, governments may submit written information that will be summarized by the
Office and made available to the Committee. 17 These written replies are to be provided to
the Office at least two days before the discussion of the case. They serve to complement the
oral reply that will be provided by the government. They may not duplicate the oral reply
nor any other information already provided by the government. The total number of pages
is not to exceed five pages.
Adoption of conclusions. The conclusions regarding individual cases are proposed by
the Vice-Chairpersons and submitted by the Chairperson to the Committee for adoption. The
conclusions should take due account of the elements raised in the discussion and information
provided in writing by the government. The conclusions should be short, clear and specify
the action expected of governments. They may also include reference to the technical
assistance to be provided by the Office. The conclusions should reflect consensus
recommendations. Divergent views can be reflected in the Committee’s record of
proceedings.
Conclusions on the cases discussed will be adopted at dedicated sittings. The
government representatives concerned will be informed of the sitting for the adoption of the
conclusions concerning their country by the secretariat through the Daily Bulletin and the
web page of the Committee. The conclusions are made visible on a screen and at the same
time a hard copy of these conclusions is provided to the government representative
concerned in one of the three working languages, chosen by the government. The
government representatives may take the floor after the Chairperson has announced the
adoption of the conclusions.
* * *
As per the Committee’s decision in 1980, 18 Part One of its report will contain a section
entitled “Application of ratified Conventions”, in which the Committee draws the attention
of the Conference to: (i) cases of progress, where governments have introduced changes in
their law and practice in order to eliminate divergences previously discussed by the
Committee; (ii) certain special cases, which are mentioned in special paragraphs of the
report; and (iii) cases of continued failure over several years to eliminate serious deficiencies
in the application of ratified Conventions which it had previously discussed – including
“urgent appeals” (see section V).
16
Since 2010, this document is appended to the General Report of the Committee.
17
See above Part III(C)(ii).
18
See footnote 9 above.
ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx 7
VII. Participation in the work of the Committee
As regards failure by a government to take part in the discussion concerning its country,
despite repeated invitations by the Committee, the following measures will be applied, in
conformity with the decision taken by the Committee at the 73rd Session of the Conference
(1987), as amended at the 97th Session of the Conference (2008), 19 and mention will be
made in the relevant part of the Committee’s report:
– In accordance with the usual practice, after having established the list of cases regarding
which Government delegates might be invited to supply information to the Committee,
the Committee shall invite the governments of the countries concerned in writing, and
the Daily Bulletin shall regularly mention these countries.
– Three days before the end of the discussion of individual cases, the Chairperson of the
Committee shall request the Clerk of the Conference to announce every day the names
of the countries whose representatives have not yet responded to the Committee’s
invitation, urging them to do so as soon as possible.
– On the last day of the discussion of individual cases, the Committee shall deal with the
cases in which governments have not responded to the invitation. Given the importance
of the Committee’s mandate, assigned to it in 1926, to provide a tripartite forum for
dialogue on outstanding issues relating to the application of ratified international labour
Conventions, a refusal by a government to participate in the work of the Committee is
a significant obstacle to the attainment of the core objectives of the International Labour
Organization. For this reason, the Committee may discuss the substance of the cases
concerning governments which are registered and present at the Conference, but which
have chosen not to be present before the Committee. The debate which ensues in such
cases will be reflected in the appropriate part of the report, concerning both individual
cases and participation in the work of the Committee. In the case of governments that
are not present at the Conference, the Committee will not discuss the substance of the
case, but will draw attention in its report to the importance of the questions raised. 20 In
both situations, a particular emphasis will be put on steps to be taken to resume the
dialogue.
VIII. Minutes of the sittings – Verbatim
In the context of the informal tripartite consultations on the working methods of the
Committee of November 2018 and March 2019, it was decided that the general discussion,
the discussion of the General Survey, as well as the discussion of cases of serious failure to
respect reporting or other standards-related obligations (“automatic” cases) and the
discussion of cases in which governments are invited to respond to the comments of the
Committee of Experts (“individual” cases) will be produced in the form of verbatim
transcripts. Each intervention will be reproduced in extenso in the language of work in which
it has been delivered, or failing that, chosen by the government – English, French or Spanish
19
See Provisional Record No. 24, International Labour Conference, 73rd Session, 1987, para. 33; and
Provisional Record No. 19, International Labour Conference, 97th Session, 2008, para. 174.
20
In the case of a government which is not accredited or registered to the Conference, the Committee
will not discuss the substance of the case, but will draw attention in its report to the importance of the
questions raised. It was considered that no country should use inclusion on the preliminary list of
individual cases as a reason for failing to ensure that it was accredited to the Conference. If a country
on the preliminary list registered after the final list was approved, it should be asked to provide
explanations (see Provisional Record No. 18, International Labour Conference, 100th Session, 2011,
Part I/54).
8 ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx
– and the verbatim draft minutes will be made available online on the Committee’s dedicated
web page. 21 It is the Committee’s practice to accept amendments to the verbatim draft
minutes of previous sittings prior to their adoption by the Committee. The time available to
delegates to submit amendments to the verbatim draft minutes will be clearly indicated by
the Chairperson when they are made available to the Committee. The amendments should
be clearly highlighted and submitted either electronically or in hard copy. Please refer to
Appendix III or contact the secretariat in relation to the procedure for amendments to draft
minutes and their electronic submission. In order to avoid delays in the preparation of the
Committee’s report, no amendments may be accepted once the draft minutes have been
approved. To the extent that the discussions are reproduced in extenso in the form of
verbatim draft minutes, their amendments will be limited exclusively to the elimination of
transcription errors.
Following the informal tripartite consultations, it was also decided to reorganize the
two parts of the Committee’s report. The first part of the report of the Committee will contain
the verbatim minutes of the General Discussion, the outcome of the discussions on the
General Survey, the conclusions adopted following the examination of the “automatic” cases
and the examination of the “individual” cases – including, where appropriate, the special
paragraphs, – as well as the verbatim minutes of the discussion on the adoption of the report
and the closing remarks. This first part of the report will be produced in the form of a
consolidated document and will be translated into the three languages for adoption by the
Conference in plenary session.
The second part of the report of the Committee will consist of trilingual (patchwork)
verbatim minutes of the discussion of the General Survey, the discussion of “automatic”
cases and the discussion of “individual” cases. These verbatim minutes will be available
online on the Committee’s web page as they are adopted. The second part of the report of
the Committee will be submitted to the plenary sitting of the Conference for adoption only
in electronic format.
The full report (first and second parts) translated into the three languages will be made
available online 30 days after its adoption by the plenary sitting of the Conference.
IX. Time management
– Every effort will be made so that sessions start on time and the schedule is respected.
– Maximum speaking time during the examination of individual cases will be as follows:
■ fifteen minutes for the government whose case is being discussed, as well as the
spokespersons of the Workers’ and the Employers’ groups;
■ ten minutes for the Employer and Worker members, respectively, from the
country concerned to be divided between the different speakers of each group;
■ ten minutes for Government groups;
■ five minutes for the other members;
21
These new modalities result from the informal tripartite consultations of March 2016. Delegates
who will be intervening in a language other than English, French or Spanish will be able to indicate
to the Secretariat in which of these three working languages their intervention should be reflected in
the verbatim draft minutes.
ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx 9
■ concluding remarks are limited to ten minutes for the government whose case is
being discussed, as well as spokespersons of the Workers’ and the Employers’
groups.
– Maximum speaking time will also apply to the discussion of the General Survey, as
follows: 22
■ fifteen minutes for the spokespersons of the Workers’ and the Employers’ groups;
■ ten minutes for Government groups;
■ five minutes for the other members;
■ concluding remarks are limited to ten minutes for spokespersons of the Workers’
and the Employers’ groups.
– However, the Chairperson, in consultation with the other Officers of the Committee,
could decide on reduced time limits where the situation of a case would warrant it, for
instance, where there was a very long list of speakers.
– These time limits will be announced by the Chairperson at the beginning of each sitting
and will be strictly enforced.
– During interventions, a screen located behind the Chairperson and visible by all
speakers will indicate the remaining time available to speakers. Once the maximum
speaking time has been reached, the speaker will be interrupted.
– The list of speakers will be visible on screens in the room. Early registration on that list
of delegates intending to take the floor is encouraged. 23
– In view of the above limits on speaking time, governments whose case is to be
discussed are invited to complete the information provided, where appropriate, by a
written document, not longer than five pages, to be submitted to the Office at least
two days before the discussion of the case. 24
X. Respect of rules of decorum and
role of the Chairperson
All delegates have an obligation to the Conference to abide by parliamentary language
and by the generally accepted procedure. Interventions should be relevant to the subject
under discussion and should avoid references to extraneous matters.
It is the role and task of the Chairperson to maintain order and to ensure that the
Committee does not deviate from its fundamental purpose to provide an international
tripartite forum for full and frank debate within the boundaries of respect and decorum
essential to making effective progress towards the aims and objectives of the International
Labour Organization.
22
These new modalities result from the informal tripartite consultations of March 2016.
23
These new arrangements result from the informal tripartite consultations of March 2016.
24
See Part VI above.
10 ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx
Appendix I
Criteria developed by the Committee of Experts
for footnotes
Excerpts of the General Report of the Committee
of Experts (108/III(A))
75. As in the past, the Committee has indicated by special notes (traditionally known as
“footnotes”) at the end of its comments the cases in which, because of the nature of the problems
encountered in the application of the Conventions concerned, it has deemed appropriate to ask
the government to supply a report earlier than would otherwise have been the case and, in some
instances, to supply full particulars to the Conference at its next session in June 2019.
76. In order to identify cases for which it inserts special notes, the Committee uses the
basic criteria described below, while taking into account the following general considerations.
First, the criteria are indicative. In exercising its discretion in the application of the criteria, the
Committee may also have regard to the specific circumstances of the country and the length of
the reporting cycle. Second, the criteria are applicable to cases in which an earlier report is
requested, often referred to as a “single footnote”, as well as to cases in which the government
is requested to provide detailed information to the Conference, often referred to as a “double
footnote”. The difference between these two categories is one of degree. Third, a serious case
otherwise justifying a special note to provide full particulars to the Conference (double footnote)
might only be given a special note to provide an early report (single footnote) when there has
been a recent discussion of the case in the Conference Committee. Finally, the Committee
wishes to point out that it exercises restraint in its recourse to “double footnotes” in deference
to the Conference Committee’s decisions as to the cases it wishes to discuss.
77. The criteria to which the Committee has regard are the following:
– the seriousness of the problem; in this respect, the Committee emphasizes that an
important consideration is the necessity to view the problem in the context of a particular
Convention and to take into account matters involving fundamental rights, workers’
health, safety and well-being, as well as any adverse impact, including at the international
level, on workers and other categories of protected persons;
– the persistence of the problem;
– the urgency of the situation; the evaluation of such urgency is necessarily case specific,
according to standard human rights criteria, such as life threatening situations or problems
where irreversible harm is foreseeable; and
– the quality and scope of the government’s response in its reports or the absence of response
to the issues raised by the Committee, including cases of clear and repeated refusal on the
part of a State to comply with its obligations.
78. In addition, the Committee wishes to emphasize that its decision not to double
footnote a case which it has previously drawn to the attention of the Conference Committee in
no way implies that it has considered progress to have been made therein.
79. At its 76th Session (November–December 2005), the Committee decided that the
identification of cases in respect of which a government is requested to provide detailed
information to the Conference would be a two-stage process: first, the expert initially
responsible for a particular group of Conventions recommends to the Committee the insertion
of special notes; second, in light of all the recommendations made, the Committee will, after
discussion, take a final, collegial decision once it has reviewed the application of all the
Conventions.
ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx 11
Appendix II
Criteria developed by the Committee of Experts
for identifying cases of progress
Excerpts of the General Report of the
Committee of Experts (108/III(A))
83. Following its examination of the reports supplied by governments, and in accordance
with its standard practice, the Committee refers in its comments to cases in which it expresses
its satisfaction or interest at the progress achieved in the application of the respective
Conventions.
84. At its 80th and 82nd Sessions (2009 and 2011), the Committee made the following
clarifications on the general approach developed over the years for the identification of cases of
progress:
(1) The expression by the Committee of interest or satisfaction does not mean that it considers
that the country in question is in general conformity with the Convention, and in the same
comment the Committee may express its satisfaction or interest at a specific issue
while also expressing regret concerning other important matters which, in its view,
have not been addressed in a satisfactory manner.
(2) The Committee wishes to emphasize that an indication of progress is limited to a
specific issue related to the application of the Convention and the nature of the
measures adopted by the government concerned.
(3) The Committee exercises its discretion in noting progress, taking into account the
particular nature of the Convention and the specific circumstances of the country.
(4) The expression of progress can refer to different kinds of measures relating to national
legislation, policy or practice.
(5) If the satisfaction relates to the adoption of legislation, the Committee may also consider
appropriate follow-up measures for its practical application.
(6) In identifying cases of progress, the Committee takes into account both the information
provided by governments in their reports and the comments of employers’ and workers’
organizations.
85. Since first identifying cases of satisfaction in its report in 1964, the Committee has
continued to follow the same general criteria. The Committee expresses satisfaction in cases in
which, following comments it has made on a specific issue, governments have taken
measures through either the adoption of new legislation, an amendment to the existing
legislation or a significant change in the national policy or practice, thus achieving fuller
compliance with their obligations under the respective Conventions. In expressing its
satisfaction, the Committee indicates to governments and the social partners that it considers the
specific matter resolved. The reason for identifying cases of satisfaction is twofold:
– to place on record the Committee’s appreciation of the positive action taken by
governments in response to its comments; and
– to provide an example to other governments and social partners which have to address
similar issues.
…
88. Within cases of progress, the distinction between cases of satisfaction and cases of
interest was formalized in 1979. In general, cases of interest cover measures that are
sufficiently advanced to justify the expectation that further progress would be achieved in
the future and regarding which the Committee would want to continue its dialogue with
the government and the social partners. The Committee’s practice has developed to such an
extent that cases in which it expresses interest may encompass a variety of measures. The
12 ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx
paramount consideration is that the measures contribute to the overall achievement of the
objectives of a particular Convention. This may include:
– draft legislation that is before parliament, or other proposed legislative changes forwarded
or available to the Committee;
– consultations within the government and with the social partners;
– new policies;
– the development and implementation of activities within the framework of a technical
cooperation project or following technical assistance or advice from the Office;
– judicial decisions, according to the level of the court, the subject matter and the force of
such decisions in a particular legal system, would normally be considered as cases of
interest unless there is a compelling reason to note a particular judicial decision as a case
of satisfaction; or
– the Committee may also note as cases of interest the progress made by a state, province or
territory in the framework of a federal system.
ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx 13
Appendix III
Procedure for amendments to verbatim draft minutes
This note provides information on the new procedure for amendments to verbatim draft minutes
referred to in Part VIII of document C.App./D.1. It should be noted that each intervention is reflected
in extenso in the verbatim draft minute only in the working language used or chosen by the delegate
for this purpose (English, French or Spanish). 1 The verbatim draft minutes will be made available
online on the Committee’s dedicated web page.
It is recalled that the Committee’s practice is to accept amendments to the draft verbatim minutes
of previous sittings prior to their adoption by the Committee. The time available to delegates to
submit amendments to the draft PVs will be clearly indicated by the Chairperson when the draft PVs
are made available to the Committee.
To the extent that the discussions are reproduced in extenso in the form of draft verbatim minutes,
the amendments will be limited exclusively to the elimination of transcription errors.
Delegates are encouraged to submit their amendments to the secretariat electronically in “track
changes” via the following email address:
[email protected]. In order to make amendments
directly in track changes, delegates are invited to request the “Word version” of the verbatim minutes
by sending an email to the address above.
Amendments will be received only if they are sent from the email address which will have
been provided by the delegate concerned when requesting the floor. The secretariat will acknowledge
receipt of the amendment and may contact the delegate concerned when the request does not fulfil the
requirements contained in document C.App./D.1. Delegates should specify the verbatim draft minute
concerned and make clearly visible the changes they wish to make.
Delegates who wish to submit hard copies of their amendments will still be able to do so from
1.30 p.m. to 2.30 p.m. each day, in Office No. 6-66. The secretariat will verify that the request fulfils
the requirements reproduced above. Delegates will therefore need to show their identification badge.
1
When filling in a request for the floor, delegates will be requested to indicate in which working
language (English, French or Spanish) their intervention should be reflected in the verbatim draft
minute, if this intervention is not in one of these three languages. They will also be requested to
provide an email address and a phone number.
14 ILC108-CApp-D1-NORME-190507-1-En.docx
Saatja: Nagarajan, Anitha <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 10.05.2019 15:48
Adressaat: AFGHANISTAN <
[email protected]>; ALBANIA
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; ARMENIA
<
[email protected]>; AUSTRALIA
<
[email protected]>; AUSTRIA <
[email protected]>;
AZERBAIJAN <
[email protected]>; BAHAMAS
<
[email protected]>; BAHAMAS <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; BARBADOS
<
[email protected]>; BELIZE <
[email protected]>; BOSNIA AND
HERZEGOVINA <
[email protected]>; BOTSWANA <
[email protected]>; BRUNEI
DARUSSALAM <
[email protected]>; BULGARIA <
[email protected]>;
CAMBODIA <
[email protected]>; CANADA <heather.calder@labour-
travail.gc.ca>; <
[email protected]>; <irene.zhou@labour-
travail.gc.ca>; CHINA <
[email protected]>; COOK ISLANDS
<
[email protected]>; COOK ISLANDS
<
[email protected]>; CROATIA <
[email protected]>; CROATIA
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; CYPRUS
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; CZECH REPUBLIC
<
[email protected]>; DENMARK <
[email protected]>; DOMINICA
<
[email protected]>; ERITREA
<
[email protected]>; SM Info <
[email protected]>; FINLAND
<
[email protected]>; GAMBIA <
[email protected]>; GEORGIA
<
[email protected]>; GERMANY <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; GRENADA <
[email protected]>; GUYANA
<
[email protected]>; HUNGARY <
[email protected]>; ICELAND
<
[email protected]>; INDONESIA <
[email protected]>; Amano, Maiko
<
[email protected]>; ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN <
[email protected]>;
IRELAND <
[email protected]>; ISRAEL <
[email protected]>; ITALY
<
[email protected]>; ITALY <
[email protected]>;
JAMAICA <
[email protected]>; JAPAN <
[email protected]>; JORDAN
<
[email protected]>; KENYA <
[email protected]>; KIRIBATI
<
[email protected]>; KUWAIT <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; LATVIA <
[email protected]>; LESOTHO
<
[email protected]>; LITHUANIA <
[email protected]>; Neringa Dulkinaite
<
[email protected]>; MALAYSIA <
[email protected]>; REPUBLIC OF
MALDIVES <
[email protected]>; MALTA <
[email protected]>;
MARSHALL ISLANDS <
[email protected]>; MARSHALL ISLANDS
<
[email protected]>; MARSHALL ISLANDS <
[email protected]>; MARSHALL
ISLANDS <
[email protected]>; MAURITIUS <
[email protected]>; REPUBLIC OF
MOLDOVA <
[email protected]>; MONGOLIA <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; NAMIBIA 1
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; NEPAL
<
[email protected]>; NEPAL <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; NEW
ZEALAND <
[email protected]>; NIGERIA <
[email protected]>;
NORWAY <
[email protected]>; OMAN <
[email protected]>;
PAKISTAN <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; PALAU
<
[email protected]>; POLAND <
[email protected]>;
POLAND <
[email protected]>; QATAR <
[email protected]>;
RUSSIAN FEDERATION <
[email protected]>; SAINT KITTS AND NEVIS
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; SAINT VINCENT AND THE
GRENADINES <
[email protected]>; SAMOA <
[email protected]>; SAUDI
ARABIA <
[email protected]>; SEYCHELLES
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; SLOVAKIA
<
[email protected]>; SLOVAKIA <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; SLOVENIA <
[email protected]>; SOLOMON
ISLANDS <
[email protected]>; SOMALIA <
[email protected]>; SOUTH
AFRICA <
[email protected]>; SOUTH SUDAN <
[email protected]>; SRI
LANKA <
[email protected]>; SUDAN <
[email protected]>; SURINAME
<
[email protected]>; SWAZILAND <
[email protected]>; SWAZILAND
<
[email protected]>; SWAZILAND <
[email protected]>; Thomas
Janson <
[email protected]>; SYRIAN ARAB REPUBLIC
<
[email protected]>; UNITED REPUBLIC OF TANZANIA
<
[email protected]>; THAILAND <
[email protected]>; NORTH
MACEDONIA <
[email protected]>; TIMOR-LESTE <
[email protected]>;
TONGA <
[email protected]>; TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO
<
[email protected]>; TURKMENISTAN <
[email protected]>;
TUVALU <
[email protected]>; UGANDA <
[email protected]>;
UNITED ARAB EMIRATES <
[email protected]>; UNITED STATES <contact-
[email protected]>; UZBEKISTAN <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
VIET NAM <
[email protected]>; ZAMBIA <
[email protected]>
Koopia: ALBANIA <
[email protected]>; <highcommission@antigua-
barbuda.com>; ARMENIA <
[email protected]>; AUSTRALIA
<
[email protected]>; AUSTRIA <
[email protected]>; BAHAMAS
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; BARBADOS
<
[email protected]>; BELIZE <
[email protected]>; BOSNIA AND
HERZEGOVINA <
[email protected]>; BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA
<
[email protected]>; BOTSWANA <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; BOTSWANA <
[email protected]>; BOTSWANA
<
[email protected]>; MALAYSIA <
[email protected]>; BRUNEI DARUSSALAM
<
[email protected]>; BULGARIA <
[email protected]>; CAMBODIA
<
[email protected]>; 'YANG Sokha' <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; CAMBODIA <
[email protected]>; CANADA <genev-
[email protected]>; CHINA <
[email protected]>; CROATIA
<
[email protected]>; CYPRUS <
[email protected]>; CZECH
REPUBLIC <
[email protected]>; DENMARK <
[email protected]>;
DOMINICA <
[email protected]>; ESTONIA
<
[email protected]>; FINLAND <
[email protected]>; GAMBIA
<
[email protected]>; GAMBIA <
[email protected]>;
GEORGIA <
[email protected]>; GERMANY <
[email protected]>;
GHANA <
[email protected]>; GRENADA <
[email protected]>; GUYANA
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; ICELAND
<
[email protected]>; INDONESIA <
[email protected]>;
ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN <
[email protected]>; IRELAND
<
[email protected]>; ISRAEL <
[email protected]>; ITALY
<
[email protected]>; JAMAICA <
[email protected]>; JAMAICA
<
[email protected]>; JAPAN <
[email protected]>; JORDAN
<
[email protected]>; KENYA <
[email protected]>; Elizabeth Onuko
<
[email protected]>; KYRGYZSTAN <
[email protected]>; LATVIA
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; MALAYSIA
<
[email protected]>; MALAYSIA <
[email protected]>; MALTA <malta-
[email protected]>; MAURITIUS <
[email protected]>; REPUBLIC OF
MOLDOVA <
[email protected]>; MONGOLIA <
[email protected]>; MONTENEGRO
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; NEPAL
<
[email protected]>; NETHERLANDS <
[email protected]>;
NETHERLANDS <
[email protected]>; NETHERLANDS <
[email protected]>; NEW
ZEALAND <
[email protected]>; NORWAY <
[email protected]>; OMAN
<
[email protected]>; PAKISTAN <
[email protected]>;
POLAND <
[email protected]>; RUSSIAN FEDERATION
<
[email protected]>; SAINT LUCIA <
[email protected]>;
SEYCHELLES <
[email protected]>; SINGAPORE <
[email protected]>;
SLOVAKIA <
[email protected]>; SLOVENIA <
[email protected]>; SOLOMON ISLANDS
<
[email protected]>; SOUTH AFRICA <
[email protected]>;
SOUTH AFRICA <
[email protected]>; SOUTH SUDAN
<
[email protected]>; SRI LANKA <
[email protected]>;
SWAZILAND <
[email protected]>; SWEDEN
<
[email protected]>; UNITED REPUBLIC OF TANZANIA
<
[email protected]>; THAILAND <
[email protected]>;
NORTH MACEDONIA <
[email protected]>; TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; UNITED ARAB
EMIRATES <
[email protected]>; UNITED STATES
<
[email protected]>; UZBEKISTAN <
[email protected]>;
Khankhodjaev, Azizkhon <
[email protected]>; VIET NAM
<
[email protected]>; ZAMBIA <
[email protected]>
Teema: Communication relating to the Preliminary list of Cases - CAS/ILC
2019
Tähtsus: Kõrgeim
Dear Madam/Sir,
Please find attached, a communication dated 10 May 2019 from Ms Corinne
Vargha, Director of the International Labour Standards Department,
transmitting the Preliminary list of Cases for the next session of the
Committee on the Application of Standards at the International labour
Conference, as submitted by the social partners.
You will find this communication, as well as the relevant attachments, at
the ILC/CAS webpage in the following address:
Best regards.
Ms Anitha Nagarajan
Legal Assistant
Reports and Chancellery Unit
NORM/OPS
International Labour Standards Department
International Labour Office
4, route des Morillons
CH-1211 Geneva 22
Switzerland
Office No.: 6-143
Tel.: +41-22-799-7049
Fax: +41-22-799-6771
E-mail:
----------------------------------------- This electronic message may
contain confidential, proprietary or privileged information intended
solely for the use of the named recipient. The ILO is not liable for any
error or virus connected with this transmission. ------------------------
----------------- Ce message électronique peut contenir des informations
confidentielles, ou spécialement protégées, à la seule intention du
destinataire. L'OIT ne peut être tenue responsable des erreurs ou des
virus qui s'y trouveraient. -----------------------------------------
Este mensaje electrónico puede contener información confidencial o
especialmente protegida para el uso exclusivo del destinatario indicado.
La OIT no se responsabiliza en caso de error o virus. -------------------
----------------------