Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 21. detsember 2020
Sisu (failidest)
16 December 2020
Ref: 12-16-2020/DG-55
TO: ALL PARTIES TO THE AGREEMENT RELATING TO THE
INTERNATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS SATELLITE
ORGANIZATION (ITSO)
SUBJECT: THIRTY-NINTH MEETING OF THE ASSEMBLY OF PARTIES
FINAL SUMMARY MINUTES OF DISCUSSION (AP-39-4 FINAL)
I have the honor to attach the FINAL version of the Summary Minutes of Discussion of
the Thirty-Ninth Assembly of Parties, held virtually during the period of 27-28 August 2020.
The Final Summary Minutes (document AP-39-4E FINAL) consists of all discussions
during the Assembly of Parties, and supersedes the provisional draft (dated 14 November 2020)
that was circulated for comment to all Parties.
Please note that these Final Summary Minutes, as well as other documents of the Assembly
of Parties, are available electronically at www.itso.int.
Please also note that the Summary Minutes of Discussion of the Thirty-Ninth Assembly of
Parties are being provided in the English language only at this point in time due to budgetary
constraints.
I would like to take this opportunity to thank the Party representatives who attended this
Thirty-Ninth Assembly of Parties meeting.
Yours sincerely,
Enclosure
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
16 December 2020
ITSO ASSEMBLY OF PARTIES
SUMMARY MINUTES OF DISCUSSIONS OF THE THIRTY-NINTH
(EXTRAORDINARY) VIRTUAL MEETING
WASHINGTON DC, USA
27-28 AUGUST 2020
INDEX
REFERENCES
AGENDA PARAGRAPH(S) PAGE(S)
ITEM
1 CALL TO ORDER BY THE CHAIR 1 – 64 1 – 10
2 ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA 65 - 75 10 - 13
3 ELECTION OF OFFICERS OF AP-39 76 – 78 12 – 13
4 APPOINTMENT OF THE CREDENTIALS 79 – 80 13 - 14
COMMITTEE
5 REPORT OF THE CREDENTIALS 282 - 285 57
COMMITTEE
6 INTELSAT’S BANKRUPTCY AND 81 – 281 14 – 57
IMPLICATIONS FOR ITSO’S MEMBER
STATES
7 APPROVAL OF FINAL RECORD OF 281 – 368 58 – 68
DECISIONS
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
16 December 2020
ITSO ASSEMBLY OF PARTIES
SUMMARY MINUTES OF DISCUSSIONS OF THE THIRTY-NINTH
(EXTRAORDINARY) VIRTUAL MEETING
WASHINGTON DC, USA
First Day, Thursday
27 AUGUST 2020
AGENDA ITEM NO. 1 – CALL TO ORDER BY THE CHAIR
1. The Thirty-Ninth (Extraordinary) Assembly of Parties as a virtual meeting was called
to order at 0700 Hours by H.E. Mrs. Stella Ndabeni Abrahams, representative of the Party
of South Africa, the Chair of the Thirty-Ninth Assembly of Parties. Others present at the
head table were Mr. V. Raghunandan, representative of the Party of India, the Deputy
Chairman of the Thirty-Ninth Assembly of Parties, Mr. Patrick Masambu, ITSO Director
General and Chief Executive Officer and Ms. Renata Brazil David, Director of Legal Affairs,
who acted as Secretary of the meeting.
2. The Chair of AP-39 welcomed the delegates to the 39th (Extraordinary) Assembly of
Parties and offered the following opening remarks:
3. Honorable members and distinguished representatives of the parties, the Director
General of ITSO, and members of the Secretariat, representatives of regional and
international organizations, friends and compatriots, good morning. I observe all protocols.
I wish to extend warm greetings to all and wish to thank the Director General, Mr. Patrick
Masambu, for giving South Africa as the chair of the Assembly of Parties the opportunity to
deliver these welcoming remarks.
4. I would like to thank members for availing themselves during this difficult and
challenging period while all members of the global community are tackling this global
pandemic, which has disrupted our lives and crippled our communities.
5. On behalf of the South African government, I extend our heartfelt condolences to the
families and loved ones of those who departed and support each of countries as we implement
our strategies to combat COVID-19. Through this COVID-19, it is evident that ICT and
connectivity are critical too, now more than ever. Therefore, our discussion at this
Extraordinary Meeting is crucial to ensuring that our citizens have access to affordable,
reliable ICT connectivity. More so, ICT connectivity is an essential infrastructure to small
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 2
6. and landlocked countries, island states, and, by and large, developing countries with
small economies that have limited capacity to building their own networks and infrastructure.
This reliance on satellite connection to provide basic services is something we need to take
into consideration as we deliberate. It is of great concern if we face the disruption to the
coordination and management of our Common Heritage and critical access that enable the
provisions of ICT connectivity.
7. I must remind us all, as parties to the ITSO Agreement, that the main purpose of ITSO
is to ensure through the Public Services Agreement, that the company—and in this instance,
Intelsat—provide public telecommunication services to ensure the performance of the Core
Principles. The Core Principles are detailed in Article III of the ITSO Agreement as follows:
the first one is to maintain global connectivity and global coverage; the second one is to serve
its lifeline connectivity customers; and the last one is to provide non-discriminatory access
to the company's system.
8. As South Africa, we express our continued commitment to supporting the values,
mission, and principles of ITSO and to supporting the non-discriminatory access to the
satellites to ensure the provision of communication services. It is our common goal to create
a stronger ITSO to better meet all service delivery expectations. As the Chair, I have been
following closely this matter and have intervened on several occasions, engaging with both
ITSO and Intelsat in hopes to reach a viable solution so that Intelsat honors its obligation,
this agreement, and ITSO remain stable in operations to look after the interest of its parties.
9. Sadly, members, our interventions have not been successful, and it brings us to
convene at this Extraordinary Assembly. It is our hope that we collectively will be able to
come up with strategies to safeguard the interest of all Parties. I hope that as we gather here,
we uphold our one common objective; that is, ensuring long-term global coverage, global
connectivity, non-discriminatory access to communication services.
10. Knowing that we have limited time for our deliberations, I now wish to formally open
this meeting and request that we proceed with our agenda and wish all of us progressive and
productive deliberations. Thank you, Director General.
11. Before the Director General offered his opening remarks, the Representative of the
Party of the United States raised a Point of Order. The Chairperson granted the floor for the
Point of Order from the Party of the United States.
12. The Representative of the Party of the United States made the following statement:
13. Thank you, Madam Chair. Madam Chair and Party Representatives, on August 4th
of this year, the Party of the United States sent a letter to Mr. Masambu and asked that he
shares this letter with all of you. You should have received that letter on or after August 7th.
In that letter, we raised very serious concerns with his proposal to convene an Extraordinary
Assembly as a virtual assembly meeting. In particular, we expressed our fundamental
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 3
concern that this proposal does not appear to be consistent with relevant provisions of the
ITSO Agreement and the Assembly of Parties' Rules of Procedure.
14. Mr. Masambu's response on August 10th did nothing to lessen our concerns. Our
concerns, Madam Chair, remain as valid today as they were when we sent the letter. In our
letter, Madam Chair, the Party of the United States proposed to Mr. Masambu that he
withdraws his convening letter for this virtual assembly meeting.
15. Mr. Masambu on his own chose not to agree with our proposal. In his response letter,
he discussed the global challenges associated with the COVID-19 pandemic and the impacts
it is having on international organizations such as this one. He indicated that this involves a
set of circumstances that was never anticipated under the ITSO Agreement or the Assembly
of Parties' Rules of Procedure. Mr. Masambu's own words support the very argument that
convening this assembly as a virtual meeting was not contemplated by the Assembly of
Parties when we approved the ITSO Agreement and our own Rules of Procedure.
16. The ITSO Agreement and more importantly the Rules of Procedure protect the rights
of parties, all parties, Madam Chair, as you said in your opening statement. Those protections
are not simply abandoned when the Director General on his own decides it is necessary to
vacate the Assembly's rules.
17. When the Party of the United States joined the decisions during the 25th Assembly
of Parties to approve the ITSO Agreement and subsequently to approve the current Rules of
Procedure, we did not agree to the convening of assembly meetings on a virtual platform.
Since then, there has been no discussion at any assembly meetings about the process and
Rules of Procedure to convene these important meetings virtually. In this respect, the rights
of parties, all parties, should not be dismissed by a unilateral act of the Director General.
18. Madam Chair, we take Mr. Masambu at his word that his unilateral decision to take
the unusual step of seeking to convene a virtual assembly meeting was motivated by his
genuine belief that a failure to do so would represent a dereliction of duty as Director General.
However, as I'm sure all of you noticed, Mr. Masambu was careful to shift the burden onto
us as parties to ensure that this meeting would be conducted in a manner consistent with the
rules and obligations that we as parties have all agreed to follow. He said in his letter, with
regard to the nature of any actions or decisions that may be taken by such a meeting, that will
ultimately be up to the Assembly of Parties to decide.
19. It is now up to us as Parties to not be derelict in our duty. We must ensure that this
virtual meeting is not used to take controversial decisions that do not have unanimous
consent. Let us have a meeting and a conversation, but let us not violate our own Rules of
Procedure to do so. There's one additional issue raised by Mr. Masambu. In his response,
Mr. Masambu noted that the current arbitration and bankruptcy filing represent an
extraordinary and unprecedented challenge for the organization. I happen to agree with Mr.
Masambu that these are, indeed, extraordinary times. He went on to cite the decision of the
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 4
38th Assembly concerning the convening of an Extraordinary Assembly should Intelsat file
for bankruptcy, and he cited this as the basis for convening this meeting today.
20. It is important to note that Intelsat is not bankrupt in the sense of insolvent or what I
believe each of the other parties would call "bankrupt" under their respected domestic laws.
In my view and my understanding as the U.S. Representative to the 38th meeting of the
Assembly of Parties, where the Assembly took this decision, quote/unquote, declaring
bankruptcy was intended to mean that Intelsat was shutting down its business, terminating
its services, and perhaps selling its assets. As it stands today, none of this is happening. In
fact, Intelsat's own words and actions tell a very different story, one of remaining committed
to providing services to its customers and completing the Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceeding
in a stronger financial position than when it initiated its filing. Moreover, Mr. Masambu's
own papers for this meeting mention several times how he envisions that Intelsat will be
stronger financially when all of this is over.
21. Madam Chair, based on the decisions of AP-38 concerning the ability to convene an
Extraordinary Assembly of Parties meeting should Intelsat, quote, declare bankruptcy, I do
not believe the precondition has been met. On this point, Madam Chair, the party of the
United States again expresses its serious concerns regarding convening of an Extraordinary
Assembly meeting.
22. In closing, Madam Chair, the convening of an Assembly as a virtual meeting does
not appear to be consistent with the ITSO Agreement or the Assembly's Rules of Procedure.
There are legitimate and serious concerns, thus, the concern that any decisions of this meeting
would lack both political legitimacy and a clear legal foundation. The Assembly's Rules of
Procedure and the ITSO Agreement are there to protect the rights of all Parties. They are not
there to serve the Director General, no matter how well intentioned he may be.
23. For these reasons, the Party of the United States opposes the convening of this
Extraordinary Assembly of Parties meeting, and we invite other parties to voice similar
concerns and to join the United States in opposing the convening of this Assembly meeting.
Thank you, Madam Chair.
24. The Representative of the Party of Germany raised a Point of Order and made the
following statement:
25. My name is Johann Gross, from Germany, and let me make the following statement.
We do support the Director General's letter of August 10 as a response to the letter from the
party of the United States, but we think there is a need to convene an Extraordinary Assembly
of Parties. I think this Assembly of Parties is in line with the Rules of Procedure. The
Assembly of Parties is technically makeable. May I refer to the International
Telecommunications Union, ITU, where yours truly represents Germany in the council, and
we exercised the virtual council meeting that ran smoothly. And please, ladies and
gentlemen, let's try to have a successful Assembly of Parties and let's also bank on the
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 5
compelling chair. Thank you, Madam Chair
26. The Representative of the Party of Canada raised a Point of Order and made the
following statement:
27. Thank you very much Madam Chair, I hope you are all well, you and your families
in this very challenging time. Madam Chair, I just have a question for clarification, and
probably ITSO's Legal Advisor would be able to address it. This relates to the previous
intervention by our distinguished colleague from Germany who is at the same time
Germany's counselor to the ITU, which is the same condition I have as the Canadian
counselor for Canada.
28. The question is, Madam Chair, although we're having a virtual assembly, it is unclear
to Canada—and we have some concerns in regards to the authority that a virtual assembly
may have of taking decisions, particularly related to treaty-binding instruments of this
organization. And I want to raise this concern because, as mentioned by our distinguished
colleague from Germany, we had a virtual consultation of counselors at the ITU, but that
meeting was non-decisional. That meeting only allowed the counselors to reach a set of
conclusions and further on to identify issues that would be subject to a decision by
correspondents.
29. Again, notwithstanding the importance of discussing all the issues that are on the
agenda, we would like to ask kindly, Mr. Mechanick, (ITSO’s Legal Counsel) if he is
attending this meeting to provide us with his interpretation of how this meeting would be
entitled to make any decisions. Thank you so much, Madam Chair.
30. The Chair of AP-39 thanked for the interventions from the Parties of the United
States, Germany, and Canada and offered the floor to the Director General and he delivered
the following statement:
31. Madam Chair, first of all, I want to thank the delegates representing the Party of the
USA as well as Canada for their initial comments. I would only say again, just to be quite
clear like mentioned by the delegate of the United States, we did receive his letter. I did
respond to the letter and copied to all Member States. To my knowledge as of now, I have
not received any letter from any other member state supporting the proposal by the United
States to not convene this meeting.
32. And secondly, there was consultation done by following up on the letter from the
United States with several countries who, I believe should be in the room. They supported
the idea of convening the meeting.
33. And so, in terms of first things first, whether the meeting can be convened, from my
point of view with the interim consultations, countries that responded to talk to the issues,
nobody supported the request to not convene the meeting or withdraw the letter. But,
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 6
secondly, we had support from several countries, specifically the regional vice chairs, in
terms of proceeding with convening the meeting.
34. So perhaps at this point, before we go to the issue of decisions which Mr. Maury
Mechanick will talk to, you may wish to invite any of the regional vice-chairs for their views
so that we are clear about the process of convening the meeting. The regional vice chairs we
have are: Jamaica for the Americas; Norway for Region B; Romania for Region C; Ghana
for Region D; and finally we have Japan for Region E. So, Madam Chair, in the interest of
ensuring that we don't have any doubts about the convening of the meeting, perhaps any of
those member states if they are present in the room, they could intervene at this point.
35. At the end of the Director General’s statement, a Point of Order was raised by the
Representative of the Party of Libya and said that he supports to the point of view that making
the meeting as a virtual meeting is of concern due to the bad internet connectivity and some
Parties may have to go back to their administrations. He concluded that he supports the point
that the Parties hear the reports from the Director General, the resolutions, and options to the
Intelsat bankruptcy crisis.
36. The Representative of the Party of New Zealand requested the floor to ask that if the
Chair of AP-39 sought a legal opinion of the ITSO for convening this virtual meeting, and if
so, what was the result of that legal opinion.
37. The Chair of AP-39 thanked both representatives of the Parties of Libya and New
Zealand and offered the floor to ITSO’s External Legal Counsel, Mr. Maury Mechanick, so
he could provide his legal opinion on the issue of convening the virtual Assembly of Parties
meeting as well as the decisional of elements as raised by the delegate of Canada.
38. Mr. Maury Mechanick delivered the following statement:
39. Thank you, Madam Chair. Both questions, I think, go hand in hand. Turning to the
issue of convening first, I think it's very clear that the Director General was given authority
at the last Assembly of Parties to convene an Extraordinary Assembly in the case of an
Intelsat bankruptcy. I don't think there was any discussion there regarding the intricacies
under United States law where bankruptcy doesn't mean bankruptcy or bankruptcy may mean
Chapter 11 versus Chapter 7.
40. If those distinctions were relevant, they should have been raised at that meeting, and
they weren't. I think there is a commonsense understanding of what the term "bankruptcy"
means. While Intelsat is talking about business as usual, in many respects, they've made it
clear that business as usual as regards ITSO is not what they've done and what they're
planning to do. And I think that in and of itself is sufficient to bring this within the ambit of
what the assembly had decided.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 7
41. I think the question of whether or not this meeting is consistent with the decision
taken at AP-38 or not, it's a very simple and clear decision. Intelsat filed a petition under the
U.S. bankruptcy laws for bankruptcy protection, and that is a legitimate trigger for the
Director General given the authority conferred on him at AP-38 to have convened this
meeting. So as far as the convening of this meeting, I think it is perfectly legal.
42. As to the decisional aspects, we are dealing in a new world and with things that were
not previously anticipated, and what the U.S. said is true in one sense. The Assembly of
Parties had never previously addressed this issue, but unfortunately, there was not any reason
to have done so before the current crisis hit because no one anticipated an event of this type.
43. I think there is some latitude here, although ultimately it will be up to the Assembly
itself and I think this goes to Canada's point—to determine what decisions, if any, it can take
and how those are to be taken. There are very clear steps laid out in the Rules of Procedure
as to how decisions can be taken, including those circumstances in which formal votes may
be required and how those votes can be conducted, and there's nothing to prevent those
procedures from being followed in a virtual meeting and taking decisions here.
44. It is then up to the assembly itself, however, to determine as to whether or not it
believes that is appropriate or being mindful of what happened at the ITU Council, putting
aside the issue of what the ITU Council rules require and how those may be adapted here. If
the Assembly decided it wanted some additional confirmation, that would ultimately be up
to the Assembly itself to determine.
45. But I think as far as the expectation as to whether the Rules of Procedure are
consistent with allowing decisions to be taken at a virtual meeting, I think my response would
be they certainly are unless the Assembly itself decides that they're not. Thank you.
46. The Chair of AP-39 thanked Mr. Mechanick for his legal opinion and started to
proceed with the meeting per Mr. Mechanick’s deliberations. She added that there were 87
Member Parties present at the meeting and no further time should be wasted and concluded
that if there is any issue with Assembly of Parties' decisions who are duly authorized to
participate and decide, she suggested that at the end of the meeting decide to validate the
decisions by correspondence.
47. At this juncture, the representative of the Party of the USA requested the floor for a
Point of Order.
48. The Representative of the Party of the USA apologized for interrupting and said that
the Chair will proceed with the meeting as she wishes, however, he will preserve the rights
of the Party of the United States such that they may attach a statement to the Summary Record
of Decisions concerning whether or not the meeting was properly convened. He concluded
that he wanted to take the floor to note that under the Rules of Procedure, they are allowed
to attach a statement.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 8
49. The Representative of the Party of the Czech Republic raised a Point of Order and
said that they share the concerns of Canada and the United States and about the way how
they can decide under these circumstances. She added that they have no evidence of
receiving the letter of the United States from the Director General and asked what date the
letter was circulated. She also added that they would like to support not to decide on this
Assembly because all the questions that have to be discussed are about the treaty, and it is a
complicated process and concluded that they would like to abstain and not to have a
decisional element on this Assembly.
50. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the representative of the Czech Republic and noted her
concerns and noted that the Czech Republic agrees with Canada’s proposal. She also stressed
that the meeting will proceed and she moved on to introduce the members of the head table
of the meeting and offered the floor to the Director General for his opening remarks.
51. The Director General delivered the following speech:
52. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Your Excellencies the Ministers, Your
Excellencies the Ambassadors, heads of delegations, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, a
very good morning, good afternoon, good evening to you all. It is my single pleasure to
welcome you all to the ITSO Extraordinary Assembly of Parties meeting, AP-39, and a very
special welcome to the Ministers and the Country Delegations of South Africa, Equatorial
Guinea, Ghana, Nigeria, Azerbaijan, and Ecuador. Additionally, my very sincere apologies
for any inconvenience that may have been caused you personally because of the time zone
challenges. I ask for your kind understanding. With all that said, most heartening and
thrilling is that despite all these circumstances, we have more than 250 delegates representing
more than 90 countries. I thank you.
53. As already explained by the Chair of the Assembly in her remarks, the convening of
the Extraordinary Assembly of Parties was in response to the decision by the last Assembly
of Parties meeting, AP-38, that was held in June 2018. It should have been a physical
meeting if circumstances permitted, but we have the unfortunate situation of the prevailing
global corona pandemic that makes virtual hosting the only practical solution.
54. As Secretariat, we have taken various measures to ensure that when we can hold a
successful virtual meeting, just like many other international institutions and organizations
facing similar circumstances are doing. We have an in-house team and external support at
your disposal should any challenges arise.
55. This being an extraordinary meeting, there is essentially one agenda item for
discussion, the Intelsat bankruptcy. However, the working agenda, as you are all aware, has
been structured in such a way that we address all the bankruptcy issues and the immediate
related consequences such as the ITSO-Intelsat Public Service Agreement, the consequences
of Intelsat bankruptcy on ITSO operations, arbitration, et cetera.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 9
56. And in order to provide an opportunity for the parties to have firsthand interaction
with Intelsat on the issues under discussion as they relate to the company, I invited the CEO
of Intelsat to make a presentation and answer any subsequent questions. The Executive Vice
President and General Counsel for Intelsat, Ms. Michelle Bryan, will be making that
presentation.
57. Today's meeting is very important and historic in ITSO's journey. It provides a
unique opportunity for the parties to adopt solutions that will bring an end to the current
impasse between ITSO and Intelsat while opening up a new path. On the other hand,
whatever decisions the parties make today, they will no doubt have a momentous impact for
a long time to come because they could lead to the end of a unique but noble vision of the
global community. The establishment of ITSO was the result of a political coalition by the
UN that communications by satellites should be available to nations all over the world as
soon as practicable on a global and nondiscriminatory basis.
58. Right from the word "go," there was concern about universality and connectivity.
That forms the core of the international treaty called the ITSO Agreement, to which there are
149 countries as signatories, and that journey started some 50 years ago has made a major
impact on the global community. And yet the needs remain, far from being met for many
countries, as exemplified through efforts like those espoused in the UN's 2030 Sustainable
Development Agenda.
59. There is a real risk that some colleagues sitting in this Assembly may see the impasse
between ITSO and Intelsat as a simple financial disagreement, a money issue, but let me
assure them that in reality, the issues at hand are far more complicated than that. It's about
many things: the traditional reluctance to be regulated, the belief that whoever has the purse
must be the one that pulls the strings, that the governments do not know what is good for
them and their people, that everybody in the world has the same opportunities, and if they
don't, it's their fault.
60. If I was sitting in this Assembly as a delegate, some questions would bother me. The
first would be the fact that the Assembly considers and approves the budget of ITSO. To
what extent can Intelsat on its own accord determine how much funding they'll provide to
ITSO, especially in light of what the ITSO Agreement requires for funding of ITSO?
Furthermore, how well does the present Public Service Agreement ensure that the objectives
of the parties are being met?
61. Secondly, given the financial benefits that accrue to Intelsat, resulting substantially
from the use of the orbital slots and associated frequency spectrum resources that were made
available to them by the Parties, to what extent is the current budget of ITSO burdensome to
Intelsat?
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 10
62. Intelsat, having paid consistently the same budget as approved by the Parties over the
last almost 20 years, taking into account inflation for the same activities, is it reasonable for
Intelsat to expect ITSO to operate on a financial 2021 budget that is less than 15 percent of
the budget approved by the AP? If that is not reasonably clear, there must be a total
disconnect between Intelsat the company, and ITSO.
63. Thirdly and finally, what is the real motivation of Intelsat in this whole setup, save
for trying to drive ITSO out of existence by starving them of funds, especially given the
declaration by the company itself that ITSO serves no purpose and should be wound down?
And finally, what does Intelsat stand to benefit with the closure of ITSO, and on the other
hand, how is the closure of ITSO beneficial to the Parties?
64. To my mind, it's for you to listen, to question, to judge, and then decide. I thank you
for listening to me.
AGENDA ITEM NO. 2 – ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA
Reference(s): AP-39-1 (DG)
65. The Chair of AP-39 called the Assembly to move forward to Agenda Item No. 2, the
adoption of the Agenda of the Thirty-Ninth (Extraordinary) meeting of the Assembly of
Parties.
66. The representative of the Party of the USA requested the floor to say that he did not
have any particular concerns with the agenda as presented; however, he felt it was appropriate
to raise at this time the ability of Intelsat to participate in this meeting. He added that these
issues are very serious and of concern to everyone. He continued that the papers are
presented by the Director General, and as they have seen, there has been some opportunity
for Intelsat to present a paper to this meeting. And they have also seen a few days ago,
Intelsat provided another document, and ITSO responded. These are very late documents,
and it's very difficult to address these documents in real-time. He requested that they take a
position that allows Intelsat full participation in this meeting. He also added that Intelsat not
only needs an ability to be able to defend and respond and to also answer questions from all
Parties, and he thinks it is equally important for Intelsat to hear from all Parties what the
issues and concerns are and that the Parties should be able to say to Intelsat directly so that
they can be prepared to respond and address the concerns. He concluded that he sees no
point in having this meeting, without Intelsat present at all times and able to respond, react,
and to hear.
67. The Chair of AP-39 requested to share the documents on the screen at the meeting.
She added that she acknowledged the concerns from the representative of the Party of the
United States and she wanted to assure him that in the agenda that was circulated, there is a
space for Intelsat to comment and make its submission. She commented that may not be able
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 11
to allow Intelsat to fully participate in this meeting because they are a service provider and
they are not a member of the Assembly of Parties. A representative from Intelsat will come
on the item that specifically deals with them, where they make their submission, and then the
members will ask all relevant questions that they need to ask, including matters that may
have been raised on the two documents. She concluded that when Intelsat is in the meeting,
they'll be able to respond to all the questions that will be raised.
68. The representative of the Party of the USA requested the floor to ask a question if the
Chair is aware of the Rules of Procedure that allow for observers to attend the Assembly. He
added that it is quite possible to accredit Intelsat as an observer so that they may fully
participate. He also added that he believes it is to the detriment of all of the Parties and if
Intelsat is limited to a few minutes or a few documents on which to participate, there will be
many gaps in what they know and what they hear and what they see, and it will lead them to
poor decisions that are not fully informed. He suggested that the Chair accredit Intelsat as
an observer and allow them to fully participate in the Assembly of Parties (Extraordinary)
Meeting.
69. The representative of the Party of Germany requested the floor to say that he agrees
that Intelsat has to have the possibility to attend the Assembly of Parties and it has to have
the possibility to lay down its position, and the Parties have to have the possibility to address
Intelsat. He added that Intelsat can respond to their questions, but he does not agree with the
proposal that Intelsat should attend the whole Assembly of Parties meeting. He concluded
that he echoes with the Chair’s statement that Intelsat joins the meeting as it is foreseen on
the agenda.
70. The representative of the Party of Canada requested the floor to say that he thinks
that at the end of the day, the whole purpose of this virtual Assembly is to try to ensure that
Intelsat and ITSO, reach an agreement on the financial issues related to the organization. For
that purpose and although Intelsat is not a Member State or a Party to the ITSO Agreement,
Canada seriously believes that, first of all, they have a right as a Party to the Assembly to ask
any reasonable questions and it would be extremely useful, if not necessary, for Intelsat to
be able to participate and answer any questions because if the Parties have a question at a
particular point during this virtual Assembly and Intelsat is only granted 10 of 15 minutes to
make a presentation, he asked how will the questions to which Parties are entitled an answer
be answered by Intelsat. He added that the Party of Canada sincerely hopes that Intelsat and
the ITSO Executive Organ continue their discussions and reach a prompt agreement on the
financial contribution from Intelsat for the operations at ITSO.
71. The Representative of the Party of Senegal requested the floor and he greets all
Member States. With regards to the question of Intelsat's participation for the entire meeting,
he supported the Chair’s position as well as what has been stated by the Party of Germany.
He added that the agenda does provide space for Intelsat to take the floor and that they have
received the documents from the General Directorate as to Intelsat's response to several
points. He also added that he believes that on the agenda they will have a good opportunity
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 12
to discuss issues with Intelsat, and it would not be appropriate for Intelsat to attend the entire
meeting. He concluded that it is not a matter of allowing an opposition between Intelsat and
ITSO and also the Member States. Therefore, he agrees with the Chair that they abide by
the agenda as presented.
72. The Representative of the Party of Libya strongly recommends that Intelsat should
have a slot to respond to their questions and clarification.
73. The Representative of the Party of Mali also recommends that Intelsat should have a
slot to respond to their questions and clarification.
74. The Representative of the Party of Cotê d’Ivoire requested the floor to say that it is
important for member states and for Parties to hear Intelsat per the agenda as drafted. He
understands that the agenda is providing a time slot for Intelsat to look at the documents and
refer to the documents presented by ITSO, and at that time, the Member States will have an
opportunity to ask questions to Intelsat and to have interaction and hear from them to make
decisions. He concluded that he has no objections with the Agenda and that Intelsat will be
given the floor according to the time slot assigned in the agenda.
75. The Chair of AP-39 noted the concerns from the Party of the USA and thanked the
delegates for the intervention from the Parties of Germany, Canada, Senegal, Libya, Mali,
and Cote d’Ivoire as well as acknowledged that it is important to have Intelsat represented in
order to express themselves in the matters that affect them, as the representative from the
Party of the USA had indicated. She stated that the members in the majority agreed to let
Intelsat come and take the platform during the allocated time as per the agenda item. With
no other Parties requesting the floor, the agenda was so adopted.
[Note: Item concluded]
AGENDA ITEM NO. 3 – ELECTION OF OFFICERS OF AP-39
Reference(s): AP-39-6 (DG)
76. The Chair of AP-39 continued with Agenda Item No. 3, the election of the officers
of the 39th Assembly of Parties. In this regard, the Rules of Procedure state that the Chair
and Deputy Chair of the Assembly shall maintain their position until the election of their
successors at the next ordinary meeting. The same rules state that the Vice-Chairs shall hold
office for the duration of the meeting at which they are elected. So, this means that we have
to elect the Vice-Chairs. However, as the Chair of the Assembly and as it was done at
previous Extraordinary Assembly of Parties, namely the AP-30 and AP-33, the Chair
proposed to elect the same original Vice-Chairs that served at AP-38 and having consulted
with them, she was pleased to inform the Parties that they all agreed to continue.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 13
77. The Secretary of the Meeting announced the nominations received for the positions
of Vice-Chairmen of the five respective ITU regions. The 39th Assembly of Parties then
decided to elect, by acclamation, the following Vice-Chairmen from the five regions defined
by the Plenipotentiary Conference of the ITU held in Kyoto, Japan, in 1994:
Ms. Wahkeen Murray
representative of the Party of Jamaica
(Region A, The Americas)
Ms. Karin Skyllingstad
representative of the Party of Norway
(Region B, Western Europe)
Mr. Alexandru Nazare
representative of the Party of Romania
(Region C, Eastern Europe & Northern Asia)
Mrs. Magdalene Apenteng
Representative of the Party of Ghana
(Region D, Africa)
Mr. Norifumi Yamaguchi
representative of the Party of Japan
(Region E, Asia and Australasia)
78. The Chair of AP-39 noted that Rule X of the Rules of Procedure provides that the
meeting of the Assembly is to establish a Steering Committee to assist the Chair in the
conduct of the work of the Assembly. She reminded the Assembly that Rule X provides that
the members of the Steering Committee shall be the Chair, Deputy Chairman, and Vice-
Chairmen of the Assembly. She also requested that the Director General and the Secretary
of the meeting join the work of the Steering Committee.
[Note: Item concluded.]
AGENDA ITEM NO. 4 – APPOINTMENT OF THE CREDENTIALS COMMITTEE
Reference(s): AP-39-6 (DG)
79. The Chair of AP-39 noted that Rules X (A) and (B) of the Rules of Procedure provide
for the establishment of a Credentials Committee for the purpose of examining the
credentials of the representatives. She said that the practice followed at previous Assemblies
was for the Chair to propose delegations to comprise the Credentials Committee. After
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 14
conducting consultation actions with various delegations and receiving the agreement of the
relevant members of the 39th Assembly of Parties, the Chair proposed the following
composition of the Credentials Committee:
Region A – Chile
Region B – Germany
Region C – Azerbaijan
Region D – Cote d’Ivoire
Region E – Malaysia
80. The proposal was adopted and the Chair of AP-39 requested that the Credentials
Committee select its Chairman, commence its work as soon as possible and, when ready,
present its verbal report to the Assembly. Additionally, the Chairman announced that the
ITSO Executive Organ would be available to assist the Committee, if necessary.
[Note: Item concluded.]
AGENDA ITEM NO. 6 – INTELSAT'S BANKRUPTCY AND IMPLICATIONS
FOR ITSO'S MEMBER STATES
Reference (s): AP-39-7 (DG)
AP-39-8 (DG)
AP-39-9 (DG)
AP-39-10 (DG)
AP-39-11 (DG)
AP-39-12 (DG)
AP-39-13 (DG)
81. The Chair of AP-39 proposed to consider Agenda Item 6, Intelsat's Bankruptcy and
Implications for ITSO's Member States. Under this agenda item, there are 7 documents, AP-
39-7, Report of the Director General on Intelsat's bankruptcy, AP-39-8, Report of the
Director General on C-band developments, AP-39-9, Report of the Director General on the
Financial Position of Intelsat S.A. for the Year Ended 2019 and Subsequent Events to June
2020, AP-39-10, Report of the Director General on revisions necessary for the Public
Services Agreement between ITSO and Intelsat, AP-39-11, Report of the Director General
on the consequences of Intelsat's bankruptcy on ITSO, AP-39-12, Intelsat's submission to the
ITSO Extraordinary Assembly of Parties, and AP-39-13, Response from the Director
General to Intelsat's submission to the ITSO Extraordinary Assembly of Parties. She
recognized Ms. Michelle Bryan, Intelsat's Executive Vice President, General Counsel, and
Chief Administrative Officer, to present Document AP-39-12, Intelsat's submission to the
ITSO Extraordinary Assembly of Parties.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 15
82. The Chair of AP-39 introduced Ms. Michelle Bryan, the representative of Intelsat to
present document AP-39-12, Intelsat's submission to the ITSO Extraordinary Assembly of
Parties.
83. Ms. Michelle Bryan introduced document AP-39-12 and made the following
statement:
84. Ladies and gentlemen, good morning, good afternoon to everyone attending the
meeting. First, I want to thank you for this opportunity to attend this meeting and for inviting
me to speak with you today. As they told you, my name is Michelle Bryan. I'm the Executive
Vice President, General Counsel, and Chief Administrative Officer for Intelsat. As part of
my duties, I oversee legal matters, regulatory matters, and government affairs. My team
manages spectrum filings, FCC licenses, as well as compliance with the requirements under
the Public Service Agreement with ITSO.
85. Intelsat has been anxious to have the opportunity to be heard on the matter of funding
and to fully explain its position. This dispute over the funding of ITSO has been going on
for nearly 2 years. It's important that the member states fully understand our perspective and
a perspective that can most properly be conveyed only by Intelsat.
86. More importantly, ITSO called this Extraordinary Meeting to discuss the impact of
Intelsat's bankruptcy. Again, the Assembly should have before it, accurate and complete
facts to make informed decisions. I know that each delegate here wants to make informed
decisions on behalf of their country, and I'm here to provide you with firsthand information
about our restructuring and to make myself available to answer questions that you have.
87. So, let's start with the bankruptcy. Plainly stated, Intelsat is not bankrupt. The word
"bankruptcy" is legally defined and has many different meanings, depending upon the legal
regime that's being discussed. In many countries, bankruptcy means that the company is
insolvent and can no longer survive. A trustee is appointed. The assets are liquidated, and
the company winds down. That is not the case for Intelsat under Chapter 11 of the U.S.
Bankruptcy Code.
88. This is what Intelsat has done. We filed for protection under Chapter 11 of the U.S.
Bankruptcy Code, and what we are doing is we are reorganizing. We're reorganizing our
capital structure, and that means restructuring our debt and our equity. And Chapter 11
allows us certain protections from payments to creditors to allow us to do so. While we are
under the protection of Chapter 11, we do not have to pay interest on our debt nor pay certain
other financial obligations while we work out a plan of reorganization with our debt and
equity holders.
89. There is a price the company pays for this protection period, and the court must
oversee and sometimes approve every expenditure of the company during this period. But
at the end of the legal case, Intelsat will emerge with significantly less debt, new
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 16
shareholders, and a fresh start. Our objective is to achieve a balance sheet that will allow us
to survive for the long term. The law allows a reorganizing company to shed unnecessary
and overly burdensome contractual obligations to allow us to emerge in a better position to
compete.
90. So why did Intelsat file a petition for reorganization? There are three main reasons.
The first is that the competitive environment has changed. Eight years ago, Intelsat was
getting annual revenues of $2.6 billion and was projecting a path to get to $3 billion annually,
but the competitive landscape quickly changed. There's been a proliferation of other GEO
satellite companies around the world. Countries have become nationalistic and moving
services to their local national satellites. More importantly, fiber has now covered the world,
and other technologies make it cheaper, easier, and faster to get services from means other
than satellite, and this is only going to get worse.
91. Intelsat lost $100 million in revenue each year for the last 7 years. Rather than
achieving a $3 billion annual revenue target, which we were projecting, we went into 2020
projecting revenues well below $2 billion. So, we've lost $700 million in value over the last
7 years. On top of that, the FCC ordered C-band proceeding is requiring us to give up 300
megahertz of C-band, which we use for media services in the U.S. This will limit and reduce
revenues for media. Then COVID hit. In our one growth area, the mobility market, we got
hit again. The cruise and aero markets are not anticipated to return to pre-COVID levels for
many years. So that's the number one reason for restructuring. Our revenue base is eroding
rapidly and will continue to decline.
92. The second reason is the obvious one. This revenue decline is a problem because we
had $15 billion in debt. We cannot service the debt with a declining revenue stream. We
have to reduce that debt.
93. Finally, the third reason is the C-band order. One of the positive elements of the C-
band order from the FCC provided the opportunity for Intelsat to receive nearly $5 billion in
proceeds if we can achieve the herculean task of clearing 300 megahertz of C-band in a short
amount of time. We need this $5 billion as part of our overall restructuring plan to reduce
our debt load. We need to get some reduction from the bankruptcy process. We'll get another
$5 billion in acceleration payments, and then we will emerge with the right level of debt.
But to get that $5 billion in acceleration payments, we need to pay upfront this year a billion
dollars in cost for satellites and ground equipment to achieve the timeline. We need to put
up seven new satellites to clear this spectrum, and that's money that Intelsat just doesn't have.
But we can get it through financing while in Chapter 11. So that's the third reason that we
filed. One of the benefits of Chapter 11 is the ability to obtain what's called "DIP financing."
94. So the reorganization plan for us is to negotiate a reduction of debt with our
debtholders, emerge from Chapter in the first quarter of 2021, and this plan of reorganization
is based upon our receipt of the $5 billion in C-band acceleration payments by the end of
2023, which will be applied to further reduce our debt. In the end, we hope to have a
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 17
manageable level of debt that will match our significantly reduced revenue streams but a debt
burden that we can manage for the long term. This is about the long-term survivability of
Intelsat.
95. Finally, as it relates to the impact of our filing on the Common Heritage filings,
plainly stated, there is none. There is no impact. The set of filings that are known as
Common Heritage was transferred to the U.S. and the UK administrations at the time of
privatization. It's the FCC's obligation to oversee this, not ITSO's. So Intelsat has been in
contact with the FCC routinely over the course of the bankruptcy and immediately upon
filing the bankruptcy. We've confirmed to them that there will be no impact on our assets.
We have no plan to sell anything, and our operations and our filings will remain as they are.
96. To close out on bankruptcy, we're fighting for the long-term survival of Intelsat in a
highly competitive environment, but in order to do so, we have to emerge having shed all
unnecessary expenses and being able to compete on a level playing field. After I'm done
speaking, I'm happy to answer any questions about our Chapter 11 filing that you may have.
97. Returning now to the funding dispute, I want to reiterate three simple facts. Intelsat
has always adhered to the remaining Core Principles, without any violation or need for
supervision. Global connectivity and nondiscriminatory access make good business sense,
and that's why Intelsat has always adhered to these principles, not because of the existence
of the PSA or the lack of a PSA. We've always said we will fund the amount necessary to
supervise the oversight of those two Core Principles and nothing more.
98. Just as Intelsat is reorganizing its business to adjust to the realities of today's
competitive environment, so too must ITSO readjust its budget to reflect the realities of
today's environment.
99. I'm not going to repeat everything that was in Intelsat's submission, but some facts
do bear repeating. There are only two core remaining principles—global coverage and
connectivity and nondiscriminatory access to the system. There can be no question or debate
on the global coverage. We have 50 satellite—52 satellites now that cover the globe. We're
putting up another seven. We will never abandon our global footprint because it's the core
of our business. Again, it makes good business sense.
100. On nondiscriminatory access, we will always provide access to the system to any
customer who's willing to pay, and in fact, we've continued to provide services to some
customers, some countries that haven't paid us. But Intelsat is loyal to its customers. Intelsat
has never denied any country access to our system, but in fact, the opposite has occurred. In
many of your countries, you've abandoned Intelsat.
101. But that's understandable. As strides have been made to improve connectivity around
the world, many countries are moving to cheaper methods of connectivity. Why? Because
it makes good business sense for them to do so. We understand that. Privatization means
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 18
that we are allowing the free market to drive business practices. Just as your countries are
making the decisions that are best for them, Intelsat needs to be free to compete to make the
best decisions for it. We need to be on a level playing field, and no other competitors are
fettered with this $2 million annual tax to support ITSO, an organization that brings no
benefit to our business.
102. So on the funding, our funding discussion started nearly 2 years ago, December of
2018, when ITSO sent over its funding demand for $1.85 million for 2020 and another $1.9
million for 2021. In January of 2019, I sat down with the Director General and explained
that the world has changed. Intelsat was no longer going to fund the unfettered activities of
ITSO, and I'm going to give you the same explanation that I gave to him 2 years ago. ITSO
has a decision to make in 2020 about whether ITSO should continue or should terminate.
While it's Intelsat's view that there is no longer a need for ITSO, that's not up to us, and we
get that.
103. While we believe ITSO's utility has passed, the world of GEO satellite doesn't exist
anymore. GEO satellite is now subsumed in a much larger world of multiple technologies:
5G, fiber, cellular, LEO/GEO/MEO. Now we're competing with the likes of Apple, Google,
Amazon, Facebook, SpaceX, all of whom are putting up their satellite constellations,
launching tens of thousands of LEO satellites. In the U.S., we're competing with AT&T and
Verizon, and around the world, a host of other mobile network operators. The world has
changed. There is no place in it to preserve an antiquated notion of one company adhering
to the principles established in 1960. They just don't apply in 2020.
104. But, again, as I told Patrick, Intelsat recognizes that this is not our decision to make.
The Assembly of Parties has to make it, but they should do so in an informed way and in a
way that makes sense for their countries. But to the extent ITSO decides to continue, we're
going to fund what we can afford to fund and what we think we're legally obligated to fund.
105. So, number one, the existence of ITSO, and the PSA has no real impact on member
countries. Any complaint about compliance with the Core Principles has multiple avenues
of redress. You can come to Intelsat directly anytime. You can go to the FCC, or you can
go to the U.S. State Department. ITSO has no regulatory or enforcement authority. So for
your countries, I'm not sure what value it brings if you could go directly to one of us to
redress a complaint, a complaint which has never occurred, by the way.
106. Number two, the best thing for your countries is for Intelsat to be healthy and free to
compete without constraints. Long-term survival is what you should be after.
107. Number three, we will not fund and the court will not force us to fund activities that
are not required to pay for under the PSA. Remember, Intelsat is not a party to the ITSO
Treaty. We are only obligated under the PSA Agreement, to which we are a party, and that
funding requires a negotiated amount related to the supervision of the Core Principles. It's a
bilateral agreement between ITSO and Intelsat. The Assembly of Parties cannot legally
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 19
amend the PSA and require Intelsat to sign it. We will not sign it, and if the PSA gets blown
up, I'm just not sure that any country benefits from that. We know Intelsat doesn't benefit
from it.
108. So, the bottom line is if the Assembly of Parties chooses to continue ITSO with the
full gamut of ITSO activities, it's free to do so, but they must be funded by the countries. It's
up to the countries to decide if this is the most impactful use of their resources. Like Intelsat,
each country needs to decide where their time and effort is best utilized. I think you will
conclude, as Intelsat has, that ITSO's impact has diminished over the years. It had an
important role at the beginning, but it's no longer the best use of the country's resources. We
know that it's not the best use of Intelsat's resources.
109. Again, I understand, Intelsat understands that the continuation of ITSO is not up to
us. We are not trying to dictate to you any decision. We understand it, but if ITSO decides
to continue, we've offered to fund an amount we think is appropriate for it to oversee Core
Principles which have always been complied with. That amount was offered in 2019, but the
amount that we can afford now is less because our circumstances have changed. We are now
in the reorganization, and we have to shed anything that is an expense that is not required.
So, we remain willing to provide that amount, but there's no indication that ITSO has been
willing to consider anything less than $1.9 million. As I said before, Intelsat is being forced
to change its structure as a result of the changing environment. ITSO has got to do the same.
110. Thank you for listening. I hope that I was clear, and I'm happy to answer any
questions that you have.
111. The Chair thanked Ms. Michelle Bryan and opened the floor for questions and
discussions.
112. The Representative of the Party of the United States said that the document that was
just presented by Intelsat has a direct response from the Director General. He requested that
the Director General present his document, which responds to the Intelsat document.
Together, those two documents formulate this conversation, and it's appropriate to have both.
113. The Representative of the Party of Libya asked if there is a clear view of how Intelsat
can commit to the PSA agreement without the existence of ITSO.
114. The Representative of the Party of Germany wanted to remind what happened in
2001, that there was the privatization of Intelsat, and that the basic deal was Intelsat received
the orbit presence for free and promised to offer universal services and that Intelsat said they
offered the same. However, what is clear is there must be some kind of body that supervises
so that these matters are in due order, and this is where ITSO had taken a role. He agreed
that the world has changed that there is more competition and, there will be a time to rethink
the deal. He stressed that it is up to the member States to decide if they need other
organizations or other treaties and that the Parties cannot accept that Intelsat, unilaterally
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 20
says that ITSO is no longer needed. He continued saying that is a matter of member States
to get into a negotiation with Intelsat. Indeed, we can talk about whether all services of ITSO
are necessary today. Therefore, he said he does not understand why Intelsat gets into these
difficulties, although they could have a deal and he reminded Intelsat that ITSO’s budget is
1.8 million U.S. dollars, and Intelsat’s turnover is $2 billion. He stressed and asked why
Intelsat confronts all member States with these issues knowing that Intelsat also depends on
member States. He added that some member States present at the meeting are clients of
Intelsat. As an example, he mentioned that Airbus is a client of Intelsat and that he knows
that it makes a very good impression when Intelsat confronts a member State with this, and
also Intelsat was aware that terrestrial stations also in some member States are clients. As
another example, he mentioned that Intelsat needs the licensing policy of the German
authorities, and so on. He concluded by asking Intelsat to explain why it creates all these
kinds of problems although, considering the overall business, the budget money requested
by ITSO is not so much.
115. The Representative of the Party of France raised a specific question on the bankruptcy
procedure and asked what is the schedule for ending the bankruptcy. He also asked if Intelsat
has to first complete the bankruptcy before Intelsat is granted licenses and before the FCC
begins its auction. Once Intelsat is finished with the bankruptcy, he asked if Intelsat is
thinking of having a new legal structure that could end up impacting the Public Service
Agreement.
116. The Representative of the Party of Ghana raised a question of clarification about the
Parties’ Common Heritage, how come in Intelsat’s statement, it is stated that it is the FCC
that Intelsat has Public Services Agreement with and not ITSO.
117. The Representative of the Party of Canada thanked Ms. Michelle Bryan for the
presentation and asked for any suggestion that the Parties of ITSO would be in any way or
manner responsible for the financial cooperation of ITSO would not be an issue that Canada
would entertain at all. He stressed that it is very important for the Parties to reiterate that at
the end of the day, the Parties are not there necessarily to discuss the financial situation of
Intelsat, the future of the satellite industry, the C-band issue, the LEO satellites, or any other
capacity-building activities. He added that the Party of Canada on multiple occasions at
ITSO meetings has reiterated that their priority is to ensure compliance with the ITSO
Agreement and the Public Services Agreement and that nothing undertaken by this
organization should interfere with their rights at the Radio Regulations Board of the ITU and
particularly with the Master Frequency Registry. He also added that they would wish to have
more clarity on what specifically is the amount that Intelsat and the ITSO Executive Organ
are negotiating because, on one hand, we hear about a backlog of satellites, and we are certain
that Intelsat will come out of their bankruptcy filing as a very successful company. He
concluded that they want to know what is the amount that is being discussed, and what is it
that ITSO Parties can do to encourage and help both the ITSO Executive Organ and Intelsat
to reach an amicable successful conclusion on the amount of money which may be required
for ITSO to continue its operations until at the next physical Assembly of Parties.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 21
118. The Representative of the Party of Cameroon took the floor to say that the document
provided some extremely useful information. This being said, they are particularly pleased
to note that Intelsat reiterates its willingness to respect the Core Principles which includes
allowing nondiscrimination in its access to the system and, therefore, enabling global
connectivity. They do believe that this is a key issue in the ITSO Agreement which has to be
fulfilled. They have also noted that Intelsat is expressing the fact that they're evolving in a
competitive environment, and this is a very important factor because they have one objective,
and that is to ensure access to all in order to achieve the Development Goals. He added that
he wishes to point out that to ensure performance of the Core Principles will require some
kind of supervisory mechanism. The idea of having a regulatory organ of one specific
country to ensure compliance with this principle, they do not believe is appropriate in an
international environment. Therefore, they believe they should retain the mechanism that is
currently in place. He also stressed that they have to consider the future of ITSO, and they
believe that the comparison should be made with similar organizations, in particular, IMSO
as well as EUTELSAT-IGO. He concluded that they also wish that Intelsat when having
problems such as reaching an agreement with the Director General in terms of the budget,
that this matter be dealt with by the member Parties because the Director General cannot
amend the budget or make any other commitment on behalf of the member States and would
like that Intelsat has a dialogue with member States on this key issue.
119. The Representative of the Party of Senegal took the floor to say that he fully
understands that presently Intelsat is in a highly competitive world and needs to adapt to it.
He stressed that the Parties entrusted the Parties’ Common Heritage to Intelsat, and it is
dependent upon the ITSO Agreement and that they need to refer to it in all circumstances.
He reminded the meeting that ITSO plays a fundamental role with regards to its mission, and
that the FCC in the manner Intelsat has proposed cannot play or do things on behalf of all
member States. He added that based on what they heard, the ITSO contribution accounts for
less than 1 percent of Intelsat's turnover, and given everything that has been said by previous
speakers, Intelsat needs to revisit its position with regards to ITSO from the point of view of
its contribution. He concluded that they should recall that the financial resources for the
future, if they did not take into account the Parties' position would be an unjustified position
with regards to the ITSO Agreement.
120. The Representative of the Party of Spain began by saying he that supports Germany's
position as well as stated by other member States that the decision about ITSO's future is a
decision to be made by member Parties. Parties are sovereign and will decide on the
continuity of ITSO. Secondly, he stressed that he would like to encourage ITSO to receive
the necessary legal counsel with regards to the bankruptcy situation and position, especially
to ensure the protection of the interests of the Parties and more specifically matters having
to do with the Parties' Common Heritage and the value of the orbital slots that belong to the
Parties.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 22
121. The Representative of the Party of India requested the floor to say that since the very
existence of the ITSO Agreement initially started with a legal binding from ITSO to Intelsat
it was all member States that endorsed this process. He stressed that Intelsat cannot act
without the member States endorsement on issues related to ITSO and disown its
commitment to ITSO. He also pointed out that whatever the Public Service Agreement
states, especially the supervision clause, has been endorsed by all the member States of ITSO.
He added that if at all Intelsat had any issues for this restructuring, proactively Intelsat could
have come to the ITSO Assembly to request ITSO to restructure.
122. The Representative of the Party of Iran said that in 2013, following a series of
unilateral actions by the U.S. against the entities in Iran, Intelsat announced to one of the
Iranian customers that Intelsat would no longer be able to continue servicing that customer
due to U.S. sanctions, which was a contradiction with the obligation of Intelsat against the
Member State, which has been one of the first countries to join Intelsat in 1960. The
immediate negotiation with Intelsat for resolving the problem did not come to results, but at
the same time, it still played a crucial role in resolving that problem by effective participation
and active integration in the meeting and negotiation between the parties and through the
process of issuing a waiver, which led to the continuation of service. He thanked Intelsat and
ITSO for resolving the matter, and he believes that without the existence and without the
intervention of ITSO, Intelsat would not have been able to—and also lacked the necessary
motivation to resolve that problem. Therefore, he believes that Intelsat should maintain all
of the obligations stated in PSA against all the countries on a global and non-discriminatory
basis as is stated in UN Resolution 1721 and other basic documents of ITSO. He stressed
that he has concerns regarding any proposal in replacing ITSO and handing over its duties to
other administrations or any other country, which may be affected by administration’s
political orientations. He concluded that he also believes that ITSO as an international
organization has the neutral role, which is the most important requirement for maintaining
and regulating the Core Principles, and without ITSO, it would not be possible for customers
from different countries to effectively pursue the probable future problems in the continuity
of their services with Intelsat.
123. The Representative of the Party of South Africa thanked the representative from
Intelsat for their submission and said she would like to find out from Intelsat why they have
changed their stance maintained over the years, as they have seen from the previous records,
they consistently paid the approved budget by the Assembly of Parties. She added that the
change now whether negotiating directly with the Director General, they know that the
Director General does not have the powers to change a budget as approved by the Assembly
of Parties. She also added that the Party of South Africa would like to submit that Intelsat
should duly honor its obligation until the decision of the next Assembly of Parties as they
have done in the past 7 years. Secondly, she asked why in the negotiations Intelsat has
conceded that they have moved from the initial amount of offering of 700,000 U.S. dollars
and they are now only proposing 250.000 U.S. dollars. She stressed that this negotiation is
in bad faith. Lastly, she would like to know whether now that Intelsat is before the Assembly
of Parties, they are willing to put in an offer that is reasonable to ensure that the ITSO can
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 23
sustain its operations until a decision is made at the next Assembly of Parties.
124. The Representative of the Party of Germany thanked Ms. Madam Michelle Bryan for
the presentation and in particular for making clear that Intelsat is not bankrupt, which proves
that ITSO did not prevent Intelsat from being a successful company. He added that ITSO is
not a member of Intelsat's supervisory board. He stressed that ITSO's role is clearly defined
in the PSA from 2001 and that Ms. Michelle Bryan has stated that the market has changed.
He reminded the meeting that since ITSO never touched Intelsat's everyday business, he
thinks this is not an argument to get rid of ITSO. He concluded by asking Intelsat to fulfill
the obligations defined in 2001.
125. There being no other request from the Parties take the floor, the Chair offered the
floor to the Director General for his comment on the presentation by the representative of
Intelsat.
126. The Director General offered the following comments:
127. Thank you, Madam Chair. My specific submission in terms of response to her earlier
submission is in Document AP-39-13, and I'll go through it very rapidly because, of course,
of time.
128. Simply stated, the submission to the Assembly of Parties from Intelsat is something
that has been discussed through various presentations before. So, I'll not go to the details
item by item. However, I'll answer some specifics.
129. First, on the comment that ITSO has not provided an opportunity to Intelsat to make
its position known to the parties, I disagree with that because at every Ordinary Assembly
meeting, —not only Ordinary, even the IAC meetings of ITSO, we have invited Intelsat, and
they have participated. The one example where they didn't participate was an IAC where we
invited them to come, and they specifically declined to attend. So, I just wanted to that real
straightaway.
130. Secondly, what has been addressed by several delegates and, of course, Intelsat
themselves is that unless and until the Assembly of Parties decides the amount of regulation
and its provision by ITSO as established by the agreement and the terms of the PSA, that
remains in force. It is a preserve of the member states.
131. Further, the proposal that was made in the paper by Intelsat to change the structured
oversight and have the oversight of ITSO being done by the U.S., we don't have any comment
on that because that's a matter which is for the Assembly to decide.
132. In my document, I specifically talk to five issues: the existence of ITSO where it is
proposed that it should be wound down, that ITSO performs several activities that Intelsat
deems unnecessary, that Intelsat has consistently and steadfastly adhered to the Core
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 24
Principles, Intelsat's bankruptcy is of no significance for ITSO or the ITSO parties, and the
Director General has gone against the will of the Parties by cancelling the AP and at this
stage wish to share this with the AP. So those are the five issues to which I specifically
wanted to make a direct response as part of my submission.
133. In terms of the position by Intelsat, again, as I said earlier, just a while ago, they have
made it very clear that they believe ITSO is solid, and therefore, Intelsat should no longer be
required to honor the binding obligations defined in the PSA.
134. I think what has been mentioned by distinguished delegates also is the fact that that
decision which was taken in 2001, if people may recall, was under the old Intelsat, an
intergovernmental organization that was doing both the operations as well as regulation if I
could put it that way. That decision led to the birth of both Intelsat and ITSO.
135. So it was a decision by the member states to establish Intelsat as a private company,
and when that was done, Intelsat as a private company was given assets. It was given rights
in terms of use of the Common Heritage and so on, and in return for that restructuring, the
agreement in terms of transfer of the assets as part of restructuring was for Intelsat to perform
certain activities. And those activities are enshrined within the Public Service Agreement,
and all that is part and parcel of the ITSO Agreement.
136. Let me also make it clear from my understanding that sometimes there have been
discussions where Intelsat has said that they are not party to the ITSO Agreement because
their only link with ITSO is through the PSA and therefore they don’t know what is contained
in the Agreement. But I think in my view and the view, I guess, of the legal people, I would
say that the PSA exists within the ambit of ITSO Agreement and that the ITSO Agreement
is very specific. So Intelsat has to be aware of what the ITSO Agreement in the first place
provides before you look at the PSA.
137. Now, while Intelsat, of course, is entitled to its opinion, the ultimate decision as to
whether ITSO exists or not belongs to 149 member states, and that issue is going to be a
specific item on the agenda of the ordinary Assembly of Parties meeting when it takes place.
138. There was an allusion to the activities in which ITSO participates, but even before
going to that, on the Core Principles, the key issue to note is that within the agreement say
there are three Core Principles. There has been no reduction from the three Core Principles
to two Core Principles, and if I may read, the first item is to maintain global connectivity and
global coverage. The second one is to serve its lifeline connectivity to customers, and third,
provide non-discriminatory access to the company system.
139. In terms of those three, to my knowledge, they all still have validity today. There has
been no change. None of them has fallen away. What fell away is the contracts. So the
contractual obligation to lifeline connectivity to customers, yes, it expired, and even then,
there is an issue as to whether all of them expired. According to our records, I think there is
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 25
still a couple of countries where those obligations still exist, but we have that dispute with
Intelsat. As to when they will expire, that's something that we can talk about another time.
140. So, the serving of lifeline connectivity customers, as a Core Principle, has not
disappeared. Lifeline countries were defined in 2001. Lifeline connectivity responsibility is
a moving target if I could put it that way, just like global connectivity, when it was defined.
That has not changed for us. So to my mind, the idea of the second principle, which requires
Intelsat to serve its lifeline connectivity having disappeared is not correct, but that's what I
believe.
141. So that having been said, when it comes to the issue of what activities ITSO engaged
in, the very fact that we went to arbitration at the very beginning of the negotiations with
Intelsat—and this, I spoke to Michelle—was that we had a fundamental disagreement as to
what Intelsat is obliged to do in so far as the agreement is concerned. The ITSO Agreement
says funding for ITSO will be coming from Intelsat. It does not provide for any other source,
and that is the basis under which the PSA also provides for funding.
142. The problem with the funding is the fact that for purposes of negotiations there is no
bottom or minimum amount at which the negotiation can stop. take place, and so we had
to—as part of the arbitration process, The fundamental disagreement was what activities are
supposed to be performed by ITSO in so far as the agreement is concerned, and we argue
that all activities that are included within the ITSO Agreement have to be provided or have
to be done by ITSO.
143. Funding for all those activities is required to come from Intelsat, and so the argument
that some of the activities being done by ITSO are not contained with the agreement is not
supportable, especially since the Assembly of Parties itself approves the strategic plan. It
approves the budget. It knows what activities ITSO is required to perform, and so we had
that as a basic argument.
144. And second, was the issue of the provision of information from Intelsat to ITSO. We
require certain information to be provided as a requirement of the PSA. That information is
in the technical areas, in the financial areas, in the legal areas, and that information is
supposed to be provided on a routine basis. Intelsat walked away from providing all the
information, arguing that all information is available through public sources. To my
knowledge, that is not true. For example, if you want to talk about deployment plans of
satellites, Common Heritage positions, use of Common Heritage positions, and so on, that
information is not available through a public site.
145. The second issue was an issue of what information should be provided to ITSO by
Intelsat, and that issue was discussed at a previous Assembly of Parties meeting in 2006, and
Intelsat agreed to several items that should be provided. So, all we required was that Intelsat
should continue providing that information, which it was providing until the second quarter
of 2018 when they suddenly decided to stop and yet it is important for us to carry out the
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 26
oversight function. Everybody knows the importance of data. The absence of data can make
you irrelevant, and so that was a fundamental issue that we put as a second item for
arbitration.
146. So there were these fundamental aspects, even before starting to talk about the
financing of the organization. It is the interpretation of what Intelsat is supposed to finance
concerning what the agreement provides. To us, our simple answer is that Intelsat is
supposed to finance everything as long as it's been approved by the Assembly of Parties, but
within limits in terms of negotiation. And that negotiation, unfortunately, has no bottom, has
no lower amount which they can finance. And you have seen that.
147. Michelle said they made an offer of 500,000 in negotiations. She didn't say when the
amount that amount was offered. I wish to disclose that. The amount which was offered at
the beginning of the negotiation was 500,000. It has now gone down to a figure of 250,000,
unilaterally changed from 500 to 250. So that is only possible because of the negotiation
arrangement within the PSA and also because there is no bottom amount. Tomorrow Intelsat
could say, "I will not finance anything. I'll give you $10," and yes, they can argue that that's
what they'll give you. And you'll be hard-pressed to make a difference. Now, we have
argued as to what the organization is supposed to do. We were hoping and expecting that
that would be resolved through arbitration. Unfortunately, of course, that has not happened
today.
148. The other items to talk to include the claim that we are performing activities which
should not be done, yet these are issues which have been requested by the Assembly, and the
Assembly accepted, for example, that we should carry out activities like capacity building,
not under the regular budget but when there have been savings. And so the budgets that we
present to Intelsat does not include funding for capacity building. Capacity building is done
if there is a saving in the ordinary budget.
149. The other item which has been of contention is the attendance of ITSO at meetings.
Intelsat says ITSO should not attend various international meetings because it is not part of
oversight, but anybody who has done regulatory work will know there is no way you are
going to oversee a company if you are not up to date with what is happening within the
regulatory sphere. Participating in world conferences like World Radio Conference and
others, which are done in the interest of working ICTs, there's no way ITSO as a team can
simply sit there and ensure the performance of the obligations without being aware of what
is taking place in the marketplace. I think, to my mind, that would not be responsible, but I
think in Intelsat's view, these are meetings which we should not participate in. All these are
arguments that have been raised in the briefs during the negotiation process, during the
arbitration process, and so on.
150. The other item which was raised, which I want to talk to, was the issue of whether
Intelsat has consistently and steadfastly adhered to the Core Principles since 2001. We beg
to differ because in 2005, Intelsat removed from its corporate bylaws the obligation to adhere
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 27
to the Core Principles. The change of putting them back in their bylaws was only after
pressure from member states. They were reinserted back after an Assembly of Parties
meeting. So for Intelsat to say that they have consistently and steadfastly adhered to the Core
Principles since 2001, I think it needs to be looked at more closely.
151. The other issue was in terms of LCO prices, and here, while Intelsat did not increase
prices for LCO services during the period in which the program was in place, but at the same
time, it did not reduce them even though prices for the services that they were offering were
being generally being reduced.
152. I would also like to talk about nondiscrimination. When you talk of nondiscrimination
access, it's not specifically talking about Intelsat not being able to offer services in terms of
pricing. It is really talking about the ability to access the Intelsat system, and it was meant
to protect member states such that if a member state wanted to have access to the Intelsat
system, they should not be discriminated against for reasons which are not commercial. And
that's what I want to emphasize: for reasons which are not commercial. It's about the ability
of any country to be able to have access to the Intelsat system, and that's essential because of
the global need.
153. And then finally on the issues I wanted to address is Intelsat bankruptcy being of
significance for ITSO and ITSO parties. Agreed, Intelsat may not have been on the brink of
insolvency, but the bankruptcy proceeding it initiated was a sign of significant financial
difficulty. I mean, you can say that you went under bankruptcy to restructure, yes, but we
also know that many companies go into Chapter 11 intending to reorganize and thereafter
end up in Chapter 7. They end up liquidating their assets. So that is something which is a
business decision, and it may start as a business decision saying you want to reorganize, but
in the process of that reorganization, you do not emerge from bankruptcy. We have no
guarantee as an oversight entity as to whether that will happen or will not happen. So that
was a concern I think which led to the member states deciding that it was important. If Intelsat
goes into bankruptcy, they needed to be able to know what should happen next.
154. Primarily, within that specific concern is the fact that the member states would
want—if there was a risk to the provision of global connectivity, they would wish to be able
to have services continue being provided by another operator apart from Intelsat. In other
words, they wish to be able to consider bankruptcy as not just a business issue. It's about the
strategic role that Intelsat plays today. Yes, it may be that now there's competition. There are
satellites all over the world, but remember the whole world is not connected in the same way.
155. Whereas for some of the countries which are developed, there's no issue if Intelsat
collapsed, for some of the countries in this organization, it is their lifeline. If Intelsat walked
off and decided to stop services because commercially it doesn't make sense, that may be the
case for Intelsat as a company, but for the countries, it would be a major issue. And that's
why going into bankruptcy is important to know about because we have no control over the
direction Intelsat will take. That's a decision taken in the board rooms of Intelsat, and
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 28
therefore, countries were concerned about what happens when it goes into bankruptcy.
156. The other thing of course that you may know about by now is that Intelsat
reorganization plan has been changed to May. That's the date by which they are now
expected to have submitted a reorganization plan, a 6-month shift from what it was supposed
to be before. Who knows whether when it comes that date Intelsat may not say that our
reorganization will not be complete until December of 2021? That's not under the control of
the member states. It's within the control of Intelsat as a company, and yet that has a direct
impact on the service provisions, not so much that the service provisions will not be there,
but rather if there is no certainty about where the company is going as a major player in the
connectivity, the member states ought to be concerned.
157. Yes, there's competition, and the other satellite providers are there. But if you walked
into a country and told them to switch off their services through Intelsat, it would not be a
matter of switching to another operator in the next instant. The whole arrangement of
switching services—and I'm talking to this as a person who has been involved in that for
quite some time—is not something that is just unilaterally done. Even for Intelsat, if it lost
one operational satellite, reorganizing its services to shift customers from one failed satellite
to another is not a simple matter. There are contingency plans, yes, to be able to do so, but
at the end of the day, they also have operational challenges. You can imagine if the whole
fleet for some reason was not able to continue providing services because of difficulties in
the company's operations, the challenge it would pose for customers, governments, whatever,
is not a small matter. And that's why it is important for member states to know, to watch,
and to be aware of what happens when bankruptcy takes place.
158. That having been said, we are closely following up on what's taking place in the
bankruptcy court, but separately it is to be noted that it costs money to be present in the
bankruptcy court. That money represents the legal fees that we need to pay.
159. Finally, with the issue of the Director General having circumvented the will of the
Parties by counseling the AP, we have a challenge. The challenge is financial. As I speak
today—and I will speak to it during the other papers later—the budget will only take us until
August 31st, next Monday. So, technically, if I don't receive money from Intelsat, ITSO will
close, close in the sense that staff will have to be laid off because there's no money to pay
them. And that may not be important to Intelsat, but I believe member states take it as an
important issue. The negotiations, their timing, uncertainties, all those are matters of
concern.
160. Now, we recognize that Intelsat as a big company with a lot of money, may have a
lot of reserves. They may be able to get a loan. They may be able to do any of those, but
ITSO as an international organization has only one source. And that source is Intelsat. If
Intelsat doesn't pay the money in time, adequate money in time, then the organization and all
the interests of member states may collapse. That's what we are looking at, and that's what
could happen next Monday.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 29
161. We raise these issues again to create sensitivity about what we are talking about, and
clearly, what Intelsat has said is that they don't have a problem with money. So, if they don't
have a problem with money and they are interested in global connectivity, I would have
hoped or would have thought that there would be more consideration given to all these things
as opposed to being stuck and going in one direction. That is insisting that they have a
problem with the requested budget and therefore, they will pay a figure which is not realistic.
162. And let me mention here to Michelle, just in case she will not be there when I present
the paper, why the budget that has been proposed of 250,000 is not sufficient to run the
Organization. As an example, in the documents that we have been submitting to the
arbitration court, and these same documents are available routinely to Intelsat, we have been
making a return of our expenses per month to Intelsat and the arbitration court. We spend,
on average, about $100,000 per month. A lot of that amount is in fixed costs, and issues, for
example, the rent for the offices that we have, it takes up about $110,000 a year and we are
not even in downtown D.C. The rent alone will take 110,000. So to my mind, I ask myself,
if the offer is 250,000 from Intelsat to finance ITSO and you take 110,000 to pay rent for a
lease, which is not cancellable until the end of June of 2021 is 140,000 dollars realistically
going to pay the salary and all other operations of the organization?
163. Those are the issues. We have such a large gap between what is being offered and
what is realistic, and even as raised by the delegate of South Africa, Intelsat has paid the
budget of ITSO at about 1.7 to1.8 million dollars consistently for about 20 years. What is it
that has changed suddenly so that now we can be expected to go down from whatever it is to
less than 15 percent of the budget approved by the AP?
164. Coming back to the final issue, which was the one of circumventing the will of the
Parties, I did not decide to change the holding of the AP just because I wished to. We had to
have an extraordinary AP because that was the decision of the AP-38, with respect to the
circumstances involving Intelsat bankruptcy. We had to have it while we had some funds to
be able to finance it, being virtual as it is, and that's why it was important to do it as soon as
possible. And the next activity will be to hold an ordinary Assembly of Parties meeting, but
holding that ordinary meeting also depends on whether we have the budget to hold it. That
also is in the hands of Intelsat. That's the context of the issues about holding the Assembly.
165. So, Madam Chair, those are just a few quick reactions to the presentation by Intelsat.
I think Michelle can answer the questions that were directed at her first. Thank you.
166. The Chair thanked the Director General for his remarks and granted the floor to Ms.
Michelle Bryan to respond to the questions raised by the Parties.
167. The Representative of Intelsat responded to some of the questions:
168. Thank you, Madam Chair, and I'm happy to respond to some of the questions and
comments that have been raised.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 30
169. Going in order, from Libya, the question was how would we comply with the Core
Principles if there is no ITSO, and again, I say that the compliance with the Core Principles
is not impacted one way or the other as a result of ITSO's existence. We comply with the
Core Principles because it makes good business sense and because, you know, as I said, it
could be written into the licenses.
170. But ITSO is not a regulatory body. It has no enforcement authority. So if we violated
it, there is nothing that ITSO can do other than raise a complaint to the U.S. or the FCC. So,
in effect, it's a middle man, but they don't have any independent ability to do so. So my
question to the countries is, do we need to have a middle man if they are unable to do any
enforcement?
171. The question that was posed by Germany, I think, is one that was posed by a number
of the member states, and that is if we have 2 billion in revenue, why is the small amount of
funding of $2 million for ITSO a problem? It's a small amount as a percentage.
172. I think that countries know that that's not how any business looks at expenses. The
first thing is you have to understand the overall cost structure. Yes, we have 2 billion in
revenue or less. Now it's more like 1.9 billion in revenue. Post-COVID, it might be even
1.8 or 1.7. We had over a billion dollars in interest expenses. So 1.2 in interest, that leaves
$800 million left for us to operate the business and invest.
173. As you know, we have probably $300 to $500 million in just operating expenses for
the company—salaries, wages, and other expenses. That leaves less than $300- to $400
million for us to invest in satellites, ground infrastructure, and other capital expenditures that
are required to operate our business. So, every dollar counts. We have to be good stewards
of every single dollar that goes out the door, and what my CFO asks me and what my
shareholders ask me is "What is this $2 million going for?" And I have to be able to say to
them we have a legal obligation to fund this, and I don't believe that we do have a legal
obligation to fund $2 million. That's the fundamental difference. I think we have a legal
obligation to fund something, but it is under the PSA to be a negotiated amount and not
dictated to us by ITSO.
174. France asked, "What is the schedule for the bankruptcy and the FCC auction, and is
there any new legal structure anticipated?" I'd like to answer this and also answer something
that Patrick said about a May reorganization plan. I don't have any idea where he got that
from, but that is not accurate. Our plan—and we have continued to state that—is that we
will submit a plan for reorganization in the fourth quarter of 2020, and we expect to get it
confirmed this year. Now, emergence takes some time because post confirmation of the plan
requires other actions to occur that could take—and some of it is regulatory approvals that
could take some time. So that's going to be somewhere not within our control, 4 to 6 months
from when our plan is confirmed, which may slip into the second quarter, but we anticipate
Q1 if everything goes well, Q2 at the latest is when we emerge. But our plan of reorganization
should be filed in the fourth quarter of this year.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 31
175. The FCC auction will go forward irrespective of what's happening in our bankruptcy
case. It has no impact on that, and the final thing is "Will there be a new legal structure?"
There will be a new corporate structure as it relates to the entities that we currently have that
are issuing equity and debt. Those will be restructured, and our shareholders will change.
The people that currently hold unsecured debt will get equity in the new company, and there
will be a big—what's the right word?"—negotiation over the value and the amount that each
one of those stakeholders will get. So while the shareholders will change and the legal boxes
will change for the corporate entities issuing debt and equity, the legal structure is not going
to change, and it will have no impact on our filings.
176. Responding to Ghana—and this is an important point and one in which I think some
of the other countries also mentioned. I know India and others mentioned this—Spain—this
Common Heritage. I think we have a fundamental misunderstanding of who owns the
Common Heritage, and I know this isn't a popular understanding. But Common Heritage
just refers to the filings, the set of filings that Intelsat had pre-privatization. Those filings
were transferred to the notifying administrations, both the UK and the U.S. ITSO, and the
member Parties have no standing or economic interest or ownership rights in those filings.
So when you say the Parties' Common Heritage belongs to the Parties, that is not accurate.
They do not belong. When we privatized, they were transferred. Intelsat is occupying them,
but they were transferred. They no longer belong to any of the member states, and that is a
kind of a critical element here because the ITSO Treaty talks about overseeing issues with
the Common Heritage in the transfer, but there is no ongoing—what is the right word? There
is no ongoing interest of the Parties in the Common Heritage as it relates to regulating it or
overseeing it like you don't have standing. ITSO doesn't have to stand at ITSO because they
don't—at ITU. After all, they don't operate anything.
177. Canada asked about why $250,000, and I think that was also a question from some
of the other countries. Where did we come up with that? Why is it so little, and why did we
change from what had happened in the past? Let me say this again. There are two governing
documents. There is the ITSO Treaty, which all the operations stuff was stripped out of it,
and it refers to the Parties’ Common Heritage, but Intelsat is not a Party to that nor do we
have any obligations under the ITSO Treaty.
178. The Public Services Agreement is the legal agreement between ITSO and Intelsat,
and we are obligated to fund to the extent that ITSO decided to continue beyond the original
12 years, which it did—we are obligated to fund an amount to be negotiated in good faith
between the parties to that agreement, not to exceed 1.8 million dollars. And yes, we did
fund that blindly because we didn't pay attention to what ITSO was doing.
179. The reason that we made a change now—and I said this to Patrick in January of
2019—is we can no longer afford to pay for activities that we're not obligated to pay for and
to be clear, I said, look, a decision is going to be made by ITSO whether to continue or not.
We have no part in that decision. I'm going to just assume that ITSO will decide to continue
itself. However, if this is going to go on ad infinitum for the rest of eternity, we are not going
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 32
to fund $1.8 million a year because that was not the original intent.
180. What the PSA says is that we are obligated to comply with the Core Principles. ITSO
is supposed to oversee it, and we're supposed to fund that. It is not even remotely reasonable
to think that the Assembly of Parties can set a budget and say, you know, ITSO is going to
do all of these things. And let's just say they decided that ITSO should, you know, start its
own company or something and then just expect that the bill will come to us because that's
not what the legal documents say. We're supposed to negotiate in good faith to fund ITSO's
oversight responsibilities on the Core Principles, and that's it. And so what I said is tell me
what is minimally required, and I ask each one of you to consider what is required to oversee
compliance with global connectivity and access to—and nondiscriminatory access to our
system. I think it's very little. So that's why we came up with 250,000 dollars.
181. And why did we change from the settlement discussions that were before? I don't
think we gave you the full picture. Back in 2019, we were talking about the 2020 funding,
and what I said to Patrick is, look, I can be reasonable. Let's ratchet down to where we need
to be to give you time to change your operations and your fixed expenditures. So let's do X
amount for 2020, and you can use up your reserve fund, which we were appalled to learn
existed, and which means we've been overfunding for years, and then in 2021, we'll go down
to a lower amount.
182. Well, now we're in bankruptcy, and now we're in 2021. And so the facts have
changed. I'm not trying to be—act in bad faith or to change anything. I'm trying to say we
will fund what is required for you to oversee the core principles. You cannot just go out and
spend and hand us the bill. That's not what was contemplated, nor is it fair. No one of you
would do that to your own countries. That's just not how business works.
183. So, Cameroon, you said that access to the system requires a supervisory organ, and it
should be funded similar to IMSO and EUTELSAT-IGO. And the reality is that IMSO and
EUTELSAT-IGO organizations are set up completely differently. IMSO has its funding from
different sources, and EUTELSAT-IGO, as you know, is partly owned by the French
government. So, they get funded in a different way than we do. We are a completely
privatized organization. The United States doesn't give us any money, nor do they help
capitalize us. So, I don't think that that's appropriate. I also just plain disagree that it requires
a supervisory organ for us to whether we can comply with the Core Principles, but again, it's
not my decision to make.
184. Spain. Again, what I wrote down is that the Parties' Common Heritage belongs to
the Parties. It does not. That's a fundamental misunderstanding, and many legal papers could
be written about this. But if you go back to the privatization, that Parties’ Common Heritage,
everybody's ownership stake was given and paid out. The Common Heritage is no longer
belonging to the Parties.
185. I want to speak to Iran on the sanctions, and I know that when the U.S. sanctions the
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 33
Iranian service potentially might have caused Intelsat to have to stop giving service. We
fought hard for that and won. I know that ITSO submitted a paper, and I know that you
probably only heard what ITSO did, which was submitting a paper and having a conversation
with State. But what you didn't know is all of the efforts that Intelsat made, and from our
perspective, we were the ones that convinced the government to give us a waiver. We're the
ones that every 6 months, continue to supply all of the information that the United States
government asks of us to comply with providing the service, which we want to do. We want
to continue providing the service, and we fought hard for it. We believe it was through our
efforts and not through the paper that ITSO submitted.
186. So, again, we're committed to the countries to give them non-discriminatory access.
I don't think that there's anything that ITSO can do to help that. It's incumbent upon Intelsat.
Let's just say that it didn't—the United States said, "No, not going to give you that waiver."
There is nothing that ITSO could do about it because they have no enforcement or regulatory
authority. The only entities that can make a difference here are the FCC, the U.S. State
Department, and Intelsat itself, and I think that the countries should deal directly with us.
187. Now, South Africa's questions were about the settlement offer and negotiations. I
think I've addressed that. And then I just want to comment for a few minutes on some of the
points that Patrick made. I want to reiterate when we use the word "regulator," ITSO is not
a regulator. They have some supervision limited to our compliance with the Core Principles.
They have no regulatory authority over us and no enforcement authority. They are not a
regulator. So I object to that use of the term because we are regulated by many, many bodies
but not by ITSO.
188. And the questions of what the activities ITSO is required to perform, again, there is
the ITSO Treaty, and what Patrick said is that attending these meetings and going to the—
doing capacity building and training and all of those things are required as a regulator. Well,
they're not a regulator. So, no, they are not required activities.
189. I think we have to go back to what is the supervisory role, which is the insurance of
compliance with the Core Principles, and I cannot articulate any good reason why attending
Broadband Commission, ITU conference—none of those things are related to the supervision
of Intelsat's compliance for the Core Principles. So we're not willing to pay for them
anymore, and I think that that's a fundamental disagreement. And what we said is, look, if
we just don't agree, we're going to have to go to arbitration. Again, we are not trying to walk
away from this. We just want to downsize it to the appropriate level if this is going to go on
forever. And I wanted to also talk a little bit about the fixed cost that he talked about. Again,
as I said 2 years ago.
190. The Chair of AP-39 reminded Ms. Michelle Bryan that due to the time constraint, she
asked to respond broadly to those specifics.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 34
191. Ms. Michelle Bryan agreed and said the following:
192. I'll talk about the information, the reports that Patrick has mentioned. You know,
again, we are a publicly-traded company that is regulated by the SEC. We are not able to
provide information to ITSO that is material and nonpublic information. It's simply against
the law, and we cannot do so. Everything ITSO needs to determine whether we're complying
with the Core Principles is in our public documents.
193. Our deployment plans for the future are not relevant to that, and we will not provide
them. Those are highly confidential, proprietary information, nor are they required under the
existing PSA.
194. Having said that, I want to just end by saying again Intelsat is not the decision-maker
about the continuation of ITSO. We have an opinion. We've articulated it, but we understand
that's not our decision. And we're not trying to supplant our views for the sovereign nations,
but what I am saying is if you do consider whether ITSO should continue, I hope that you
consider how times have changed. As it relates to this funding dispute, we are willing to
fund going forward on a basis that makes sense that we think is legally required, and we
should let the arbitrator decide that. But we will not be willing to agree to the PSA
amendment that has been circulated for today's meeting.
195. And, finally, I just want to confirm that the bankruptcy process will be over in 4 to 6
months and will have absolutely no impact on our operations at all. So, with that, I thank you
for the opportunity. I do feel like you must hear directly from me, from our company, and I
hope that I have the opportunity to address you again.
196. There being no further comments, the Chair of AP-39 asked the Assembly of Parties
to decide to note the document as presented, and if the Director General, therefore, has further
inputs to make on Intelsat's bankruptcy, to make those inputs if there are still any so that the
discussion can be concluded to move to the next agenda item.
197. The Representative of the Party of Canada requested the floor to say that he thinks
that the Director General has pointed to a critical issue, which is that the challenge is
financial. He added that it was a little exhausting to hear this back-and-forth on issues related
to matters that, in Canada's opinion, pertain more to the ITU Radio Communications Bureau
and the Radio Regulations, and he thinks that they should concentrate on a substantial issue
and he asked, what is the point of contention concerning the funding of ITSO. He also added
that he heard from one end that the budget for last year was 1.8 million dollars, that the offer
is 250,000 dollars. He stated that it is unclear how would that amount of money be able to
cover for what appears to be the salaries of at least five staff members plus six other
personnel, which are the consultants on a retainer. That's about 863,000 dollars for staff
salaries, 238,000 dollars for professional fees, 153,000 dollars for travel and hospitality,
115,000 dollars for meetings. He concluded by saying that he is certain that both parties are
working in good faith, and the Parties will do their best to help to ensure that they reach
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 35
before the end of the next day’s meeting a successful conclusion.
198. The Representative of the Party of Spain took the floor to say that he would like to
know and understand from Intelsat that the Parties have no rights over the Parties’ Common
Heritage and that this is a misunderstanding for the Parties to believe that they have rights
on the Parties’ Common Heritage. He stressed that he would like to know Intelsat's
understanding as to who has any rights over the Parties’ Common Heritage of the Parties.
199. The Chair of AP-39 said that the Representative of the Party of Canada raised a point
that she thinks may help in terms of moving forward, to check with Intelsat, while they are
still in the meeting, if they are prepared to review the offer that they had made to ITSO and,
negotiate whatever other arrangements by that day. And by the next day, they may be able
to report to the meeting. She again asked if Intelsat would be amenable to that, to review
that 250,000 dollars offered to ITSO, in light of what has been raised both by Canada and
the Director General.
200. The Representative of Intelsat took the floor to answer the three questions that were
posted and continued asking how does ITSO plans to cover the fixed costs that are existing
now with 250,000 dollars and with five staff members and other consultants. She added that
Intelsat does not believe those staff members are all required and that 2 years ago, Intelsat
spoke with the Director General about downsizing and figuring out what they do need to
oversee the Core Principles and that is what Intelsat will fund. She emphasized that Intelsat
will only fund the salaries of the Director General and one additional staff member and not
a technical director. She added that if ITSO believes that it needs other ancillary reasons,
ITSO needs to downsize and Intelsat cannot cover the cost of the fixed five people, the office
space, and all the rest of it. Intelsat is willing to review their offer but throughout the
negotiations, they have been forced to bid against themselves. She added that the offer keeps
going up, but they have never gotten anything other than this is the budget, these are the staff,
these are my fixed costs, Intelsat needs to pay $1.9 million until ITSO comes back with a
reasonable offer and one that they can explain how it is required to handle the Core
Principles, then Intelsat cannot keep negotiating against themselves. Concerning the question
from the Representative of the Party of Spain, she answered that the Parties’ Common
Heritage has been transferred to the Notifying Administrations, the bulk of which went to
the United States. To the extent that Intelsat is no longer using them, if the U.S. Notifying
Administrations is giving it to somebody else, they will comply with the requirements that
somebody signed on to a PSA. Alternatively, it goes back to the ITU, and they will issue it
again under their rules. But the countries have no say in that and that is legally what the
standard status is.
201. The Chair of AP-39 asked the Director General if he is prepared the engage with
Intelsat in the afternoon to negotiate and report back the next day to the Parties.
202. The Director General wanted to respond about the Parties’ Common Heritage and
said that it would be useful for member Parties as this is an ongoing subject, and there is no
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 36
way it is going to be swept away in one minute of discussion. He informed the
Representative of Intelsat that under the ITSO agreement, if the Party of the United States is
no longer a member to the ITSO Agreement, they cannot be a Notifying Administration and
it would simply mean that if the United States withdrew their membership from ITSO for
whatever reason and that is what is provided in the agreement, some other country would
have to be the Notifying Administration and take responsibility for looking after the filings
with the ITU. Secondly, the Parties’ Common Heritage orbital slots, and frequencies
assignments are specifically identified within the ITU Master Frequency Register, and there
has been a lot of discussion on that, and also, the transfer was not permanent, and it couldn't
have been permanent because of the recognition that the United States as a sovereign State
may choose not be a member of ITSO and in which case another Party would take
responsibility for the Parties’ Common Heritage. He also said that he would bring that to the
attention of the Representative of Intelsat so that they have a clear understanding, but
definitely, the issue of the Common Heritage cannot be just mentioned during the meeting
to say that member States have no interest in it. He added that he does not agree with
Intelsat’s statement and they can have another discussion for that specifically.
203. The Director General continued saying that he agrees to discuss with Intelsat to
negotiate the funding, and is available to do so. He added that the fact that ITSO and Intelsat
have a fundamental disagreement is why ITSO went to arbitration in order to establish clearly
what overseeing the Core Principles refers to. To his understanding, the Agreement is very
clear and there is no option for member States to fund ITSO. Secondly, ITSO's policies and
programs are approved by the AP and if the AP says they do not want to do A and B and C,
that is fine. Concerning reducing staff, the Director General said that this is an ongoing
activity which organizations do and he added that what is important is not about the people,
it is about the functions. The organization has specific functions that it must perform. It is
the cost of those functions being performed that needs to be taken into account in the budget.
He stressed that whether the people are two or one or five, there has to be realism, and he
thinks that's where they can talk to the specifics with Intelsat. He also reminded the meeting
that in terms of fixed costs, unless Intelsat is going to tell ITSO to walk out of our offices
today, which ITSO cannot, and even if ITSO walked out, someone has to pay the rent until
June 2021 because it is a non-cancellable lease. He also added that to change the fixed cost
in terms of rent from $110,000 to say $20,000 for the next 10 months is impossible. The
landlord didn't even want to talk to ITSO when it was suggested to defer payment to pay to
start in October instead of September 2020.
204. The Representative of the Party of Argentina requested the floor to express his
gratitude for the presentations by the Director General and Intelsat. He also added that the
Party of Argentina has always attempted to contribute to the achievement of the objectives
and compliance with the Core Principles of the Organization. He stressed that they
understand that this is a very complicated juncture and it is a situation that is paralyzing for
the organization and it is a complicated situation for Intelsat. He continued saying that the
ITSO Agreement is in force and effect right now, and the obligations assumed at some point
need to comply and that the financing obligations following the PSA need to be negotiated
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 37
on a good-faith basis. He also understands that the negotiations have been ongoing for more
than one year, and have not reached to a solution, and unfortunately, they find themselves
in a situation in which there are not many ways forward, both for the Organization that as of
next month has no more funding and also Intelsat that is facing a situation in which there is
a need to restructure the entity, both legally and economically, and this has an impact on its
operations. He also understands that Intelsat is doing everything possible, and in principle,
they don't doubt as to their compliance with obligations to provide international public
telecommunications services. He also understands and appreciates ITSO's function to
guarantee and comply with its fundamental principles that originally were spelled out in the
agreement. He also understands that both parties are facing difficult situations, and based on
the explanations that they both provided as to their position, he would like to take this
opportunity to say as the Party of Argentina that in these difficult pandemic times, they all
need to do more than the necessary when there have been economic and social impacts on
everyone. If they can perhaps reach in the spirit of compromise, always having in view the
well-being of the international community, this is something that was taken into account
when originally establishing the ITSO agreement. He suggested that both parties could set
aside positions that are inflexible and perhaps reach an agreement that goes beyond the
substantive issues and the rights that each one of the parties upholds, and also to reach some
kind of agreement on a financing amount for a certain time, setting aside the rights espoused
by each party and their positions, and then perhaps contemplate a period of 6 or 8 months,
that allows them to move forward towards a next Ordinary Assembly of Parties where all
these points can be raised that have to do with the continuity of ITSO. He continued saying
the Parties need to take into account the changing reality, the evolution, and perhaps some
actions can be complied with. He stressed that he does not want to express Argentina's
opinion right now on the substantive issues because that is not the purpose of this Assembly,
but he wanted to request goodwill and a good spirit of cooperation by both parties to reach
an agreement and to set an amount that can be agreed upon so that the administration can
meet the expenditures that are deemed essential today, that cannot be avoided right now and
to make it viable for the organization in the framework of the bankruptcy. And that way the
organization can be able to bridge the time to the next Ordinary Assembly of Parties which
that can be after Intelsat has been able to move through its bankruptcy proceedings and
Chapter 11 and emerged with a more solid position.
205. The Chair offered the floor to the ITSO External Human Resources Consultant.
206. The ITSO External Human Resources Consultant offered the following statement:
207. My role at ITSO is to assist the organization in managing human resources. I have
had the pleasure of serving Intelsat and ITSO for the past 28 years. I care for the professional
and dedicated people most of the members of the Assembly have known for years or even
decades in many cases, and as such, I've been monitoring the organization's current budget
closely.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 38
208. Since its inception, ITSO has employed a minimal number of staff, all of whom have
many complimentary hats, supplemented by consultant experts in various areas to keep the
costs down. The synergy has allowed ITSO to be highly effective while remaining quite
nimble, to be honest.
209. I hear the arguments on both sides, and I've been listening carefully this morning, but
it is important to keep in mind that a decision of Intelsat to withhold funding is directly
impacting the life of every person currently employed by ITSO. And with that in mind, it
may be helpful for the members of the Assembly to be aware of the following perspective.
The current estimate to put ITSO in a residual state of operations until Intelsat's bankruptcy
has ended is currently $900,000 plus the cost of moving out of its office and the disposal of
documents if ITSO were to end at that time, and this is not an over-estimation. It is based
on current contractual obligations and ITSO's rules and procedures that were approved by
the Assembly of Parties.
210. There are significant costs involved in closing an Organization. There are basic
contractual agreements that the Director General has already mentioned, such as the lease of
the offices and other obligations that have an end date well past the end of this month, which
ITSO cannot renegotiate. This is a very difficult economy. Landlords are not budging. If
they have contracts, they are not budging, and other organizations that are providing normal
services for the regular operations of offices are not willing to negotiate right now because
they are losing their customers left and right.
211. So, this is not something we can easily just toss to the side and say we're not paying
anymore. There would be significant costs and possibly other legal costs involved in just not
paying the rent, and, you know, I'm sure the landlord will try to sue ITSO or something,
which would involve additional costs probably and more expensive than the rent.
212. The Chair of AP-39 interrupted to say that there is a proposal on the table to allow
both parties to engage and she stressed that the Director General should then engage with the
Representative of Intelsat.
213. The ITSO External Human Resources Consultant took the floor to say that she
estimates 900,000 dollars for putting the organization in a residual state of operation and the
cost for operating the organization, the bare-bones cost through July 18, 2021, is currently
estimated at 1,250,000 dollars.
214. The Representative of the Party of the USA took the floor and asked the Director
General to offer his apology to the meeting for suggesting in any way that the Party of the
United States is withdrawing its membership from the organization and he added that was an
inappropriate comment and in a conversation that's not relevant at the moment, which is the
status of the Parties’ Common Heritage. He acknowledged what the Representative of
Intelsat said that she is ready, willing, and able to negotiate a sensible solution to the funding
dispute. He stressed that the Director General is not showing flexibility and that the Director
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 39
General is suggesting that he is required to have the amount of staff and consultants that he
has and the office space and the other expenses. He also agreed with the Representative of
the Party of Canada that Parties need to provide guidance, on how to properly calculate the
expenses that are necessary for the organization.
215. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the representative of the Party of the United States and
said that it is important to conclude and close this matter and that she had listened to the
different representatives that made their inputs. She added that the Parties agree that there is
a need for the Director General and Intelsat to engage to reach a final negotiation on the
funding. She also pleaded with both of them to consider ITSO first and what needs to be
done that must satisfy both parties and not to seek to destroy one another. The Chair also
added that there is a need for the existence of ITSO as of now and that whatever decision
will be taken on another platform, this meeting recognizes that there is a need to prepare for
the next meeting to decide the continuation of the ITSO agreement, but understands the
constraints that are in place. She also stressed that if an agreement for the funding is not
reached, the Assembly will request that Intelsat agrees to fund the arbitration and to comply
with the arbitral awards.
216. The Representative of the Party of Egypt took the floor to say that he fully supports
the proposal raised by the Chair, and hopes that both parties come to a final solution and
decision on the matter of the funding agreement.
217. The Director General requested the floor to say that the Chair raised a very good
proposal and that there is a need for a third party to witness the discussions for the funding.
He also wanted to say that in case of there is a misunderstanding, he apologizes to the Party
of the USA adding that he never suggested that the Party of the USA was to withdraw their
membership of ITSO and noted that the Party of the USA has indeed played an excellent role
throughout the period of ITSO existence. He also added that he wanted to put on record the
fact that the issue of Parties’ Common Heritage is not so straightforward, and it is a matter
that needs to be discussed in more detail at another time.
218. The meeting was adjourned at 1100 hours.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 40
ITSO ASSEMBLY OF PARTIES
SUMMARY MINUTES OF DISCUSSIONS OF THE THIRTY-NINTH
(EXTRAORDINARY) VIRTUAL MEETING
WASHINGTON DC, USA
Second Day, Friday
28 August 2020
AGENDA ITEM NO. 6 – INTELSAT’S BANKRUPTCY AND IMPLICATIONS
FOR ITSO’S MEMBER STATES (continue)
219. The last day of the meeting convened at 0700 Hours.
220. The Chair of AP-39 moved to Agenda Item No. 6 “Intelsat Bankruptcy and
Implications for ITSO’s Member States” and invited the Director General to report on the
outcome of the funding negotiation with Intelsat held on 27 August 2020.
221. The Director General thanked the Chair of AP-39 and said that several proposals were
made to Intelsat and the proposals included in light of all of the discussions that have gone
on, ITSO to revise its strategic plan under the acceptance of the Assembly so that the
Assembly can be able to reduce the budget. He added that there will be several things that
would need to be done, and it was proposed to reduce the budget to 1.142 million dollars. In
terms of staffing, there will have to be some changes to meet the changes that would occur
within the budget. It was also proposed to make some specific considerations. As an
example, on the side of travel, given the COVID situation and risks, ITSO is not planning to
have official travels during the period between now and the end of the financial year. It was
also proposed to make some changes in other aspects of the budget related to participation
in some of the activities and also in terms of some of the services that ITSO outsources.rs.
He continued to say that Intelsat responded that they are willing to fund ITSO on a reduced
schedule proposed through the end of December 2020, and their proposal is for a figure of
415,000 dollars. This proposal is conditioned on two things; ITSO to suspend and withdraw
from the arbitration process; and an ordinary AP meeting to be held virtually by December
15 of 2020. If that AP should decide that ITSO will continue, then future funding will be
negotiated or arbitrated. Should the AP decide that ITSO will terminate, Intelsat will provide
reasonable wind-down expenses, severance, lease payments, et cetera. The Director General
also said that a recalculation was done internally as a result of the offer from Intelsat, and the
Director General made a counter proposal of 575,000 dollars. The response from Intelsat was
that the settlement offer is firm and it is already higher than what they think is appropriate.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 41
222. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the Director General and opened the floor for
discussions.
223. The Representative of the Party of Canada requested a clarification on the
counteroffer from ITSO of 575,000 dollars as to whether it was up to the end of the current
calendar year, and also about the reference to another Extraordinary Assembly of Parties
meeting to be held virtually in December 2020 where the Parties would deliberate whether
the Organization will continue or would be terminated.
224. The Representative of the Party of the Russian Federation sought clarification and
wanted to understand better how these arrangements will be endorsed, whether the Parties
will have only the outcome document of the Assembly, or will be there any agreements
between ITSO and Intelsat as well.
225. The Director General responded to the Representative of the Party of Canada saying
that 415,000 dollars was offered by Intelsat and a counteroffer of 575,000 dollars was made
by ITSO which would correspond to a 6 months budget in comparison with what was the
original reduced budget, and Intelsat’s response on the counteroffer was to say that their first
offer is firm. On the second question from the Representative of the Party of Canada, the
Director General said that the proposal from Intelsat is conditioned on having an AP meeting
by December 15th, 2020. The Director General continued to respond to the question from the
representative of the Party of the Russian Federation and said that there would be an outcome
document and this budget negotiation is also linked to another document, “AP-39-11E
Report of the DG on the Consequences of Intelsat's Bankruptcy on ITSO”, which will be
discussed later. A conclusion will be reached taking into account the discussion between
Intelsat and ITSO.
226. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the Director General for the clarification and responses
and stated that since it is required to have a physical AP meeting, it would be unrealistic to
hold a physical AP meeting in December 2020 due to the COVID pandemic.
227. The Secretary of the Meeting requested the floor to say that the Parties of Costa Rica,
El Salvador, Brazil, and Nicaragua requested in the chat box if they could see the proposal
in writing and whether they can see the proposal sent from Intelsat on the screen.
228. The Representative of the Party of Cameroon said that he shares the concern that the
Chair of AP-39 expressed and as to the comment made by the representative of the Party of
the United States, a physical meeting should be held to deal with the future of ITSO, but
given the health crisis at the moment, he does not see the ability to set a date now for having
a physical meeting before the end of the year 2020. He continued to say that there was a
proposal made to have this meeting by the end of the first quarter of 2021, which may be
more realistic given the health crisis, and therefore, have an in-presence meeting to make
sure that all countries are present and would like to have that point kept in mind before a
decision is made on holding an AP meeting.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 42
229. The Representative of the Party of Germany thanked the meeting for making an effort
to close the different positions concerning the budget and he acknowledged the offer from
Intelsat of 415,000 dollars and ITSO’s counteroffer of 575,000 dollars until the end of 2020.
He proposed to negotiate at a 500,000 dollars figure with Intelsat. He added that he agrees
with the Representative of the Party of Cameroon, the need for an AP meeting to decide on
the future of the ITSO Agreement, but holding a physical meeting in December would be
challenging due to the COVID-19 pandemic. He suggested to think about the future and
presented several options; one option would be to negotiate a larger budget to redefine the
task of ITSO; another option would be to hand over the case to the ITU as a more political
Organization; and lastly, to hand the item to the Notifying Administration, the FCC, and
Ofcom. He concluded by saying that with these options, the Parties should start working on
an informal Working Group to examine the different options and also to respect the actual
situation which the world faces, in particular, there are competing satellite organizations;
therefore, the Parties’ Common Heritage is now dealt differently than it was done in the past.
230. The Representative of the Party of France asked to clarify if the 415,000 dollars offer
from Intelsat covers the budget until December 2020 or if it covers the entire Fiscal Year
2021. He added that he agreed with the Representative of the Party of Germany that is a step
forward compared to the 250,000 dollars that Intelsat had been offering originally for the
entire fiscal year. He also asked what is the purpose of the AP meeting in December 2020.
He added that what the Director General said was that the meeting is essentially to agree on
a budget for the first half of 2021 and wanted to clarify the purpose of that meeting if it is to
only focus on that budget, or will the purpose of the meeting be to discuss and agree on the
future of ITSO. He reminded the meeting that to discuss the future of ITSO was the purpose
or the objective of the meeting to be held in 2021. He concluded that the meeting needs to
agree, and maybe December 2020 will be a good opportunity to consider these steps. He also
asked for clarification if the offer was conditional on abandoning the arbitration process and
what does it mean if the arbitration process is removed against Intelsat.
231. The Representative of the Party of Argentina asked for greater clarity with regards to
the Assembly of Parties to be convened or at least the efforts to try and convene it in
December 2020. He added that the Assembly of Parties would be discussing matters highly
relevant for ITSO and the member Parties, and therefore, the relevance of the topics to be
discussed would be addressing the future of the Organization or its termination, and the AP
meeting should be held physically. He stressed that given the COVID situation, what would
happen if ITSO is unable to hold that meeting in December 2020, and suggested that the AP
meeting could be held in the first quarter of 2021, and also suggested to hold an informal
meeting or a meeting of the IAC virtually by the end of 2020 to prepare the work for
Assembly of Parties that would meet physically in 2021.
232. The Representative of the Party of Spain said that he would like to receive in writing
the detail of the agreement that will ultimately be reached between ITSO and Intelsat in
regards to financing and also, he would like to see all the details as to what is being covered.
He also asked for clarification, what does it mean that Intelsat will be covering the ITSO
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 43
liquidation or termination expenses, and he would like to understand and be able to see what
expenses are being covered by Intelsat.
233. The Director General said that he had taken note of the proposal raised by the
representative from the Party of Germany of 500,000 dollars as a midpoint figure. He added
that in terms of trying to come to the figures themselves, the proposal by the Party of the
United States to have Intelsat in the room would be something desirable because the final
solution at the end of the day would have to be reached with Intelsat and they would be able
to listen to the concerns of the member States. He also added that the main focus of the AP
meeting in December 2020, would be to decide on the future of the ITSO agreement, and in
that meeting, there will also be a discussion about the budget, the strategic plan, etc.
Regarding the question on the arbitration process, the Director General responded that the
conditions given by Intelsat were that the arbitration would have to be dropped, but there
would be two issues. One, there is the prior year, the financial year from July 2019 to June
2020, which is called the pre-petition claim, and Intelsat being in bankruptcy now, all those
pre-petition claims are suspended and that is why the focus has been on the financial year
2021. He also added that Intelsat, having paid the contingency fund towards the end of last
year as part of the arbitration process, they would not be paying for the arbitration cost that
would be necessary to continue the arbitration now. He reminded the meeting that, as he had
mentioned on day one of AP-39, ITSO already had the court approval to get out of the
bankruptcy court but no further action was taken on arbitration because both parties were
allowing for these negotiations to continue. That aside, ITSO does not have sufficient funds
to go back to the arbitration court. He continued to say that to go back to the arbitration
court, ITSO would still have to go back to the bankruptcy court, irrespective of what decision
is taken at the arbitration court. If the arbitration court made an award to ITSO, we would
still have to go back to the bankruptcy court for that award to be approved before anything
can happen. He also responded to the comments made by the Party of Argentina whether the
AP meeting in December would be a physical meeting or virtual. He said that this is within
the ambit of the Parties and added that at the end of the discussion, the Chair of AP-39 will
advise what would be practical. Regarding the request by the Party of Spain to have the
proposal in writing, he responded that the email which came from Intelsat will be shared with
all Parties.
234. The Secretary of the meeting said that there are some comments from the Parties in
the chatbox and would like to bring to the attention of the Chair of AP-39. Comment from
the Party of South Africa saying on the issue of the convening of AP, it is not for Intelsat to
decide on this but for the Parties to the ITSO Agreement. The norm is for the Parties to decide
on the agenda; for example, the future of the Parties’ Common Heritage. Also, we cannot
withdraw the arbitration process but only suspend it. The challenge, however, is to fund
ITSO and the AP, and therefore, if we still want the arbitration, there is unlikely to be
consensus around this, which may make things difficult. It would be better if can agree to
fund ITSO until one month after the agreed date of AP, and as suggested by the Party of
Cameroon and others, hold the AP by the end of the first quarter of 2021. We also need a
legal opinion as to whether we can convene the AP virtually and if the decisions as important
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 44
as this will be recognized and valid, noting the concern from the Party of the United State
urged yesterday.
235. The Representative of the Party of the United States requested the floor to ask for
clarification on Intelsat’s offer of 415,000 dollars and the counteroffer from ITSO of 575,000
dollars and if the latter figure would cover for 6 months of ITSO’s operations, whereas
Intelsat’s offer was for covering 4 months of ITSO’s operations with the hope or expectation
that an Assembly of Parties meeting might be held by December 2020. He added that if he
understood correctly, both parties are agreeing to something on the order of $100,000 per
month of operating expenses to be covered. He also said that the only difference that the
Director General is suggesting is that Intelsat is looking at 4 months and the Director General
is looking or asking for 6 months.
236. The Representative of the Party of Tanzania congratulated the Director General for
the efforts that he has taken to negotiate with Intelsat on the funding and he commented that
the Director General possibly did not have enough time to produce some recommendations
of some points that the member States can be provided with a way forward or available
options that can form a discussion towards what has been presented and what is being
suggested for December 2020. He also suggested that it is time now for the Parties to start a
discussion regarding the future of the Organization and the Parties’ Common Heritage. He
concluded by saying that from the points that have been presented in the meeting on the first
day, it is important that now the Parties start thinking about the Organization for the interest
of the Parties.
237. The Representative of the Party of the Czech Republic shared the concerns from other
Parties as it would be unsafe about the timing and the amounts of the financing. She requested
to see on paper the proposal whether it is for 4 months or 6 months and what is the plan to
hold the next AP meeting, and if it would be virtual of physically.
238. The Representative of the Party of Canada requested clarification on the intervention
from the Party of the United States, and he also said that he hopes there will not be a halt on
the negotiations due to the difference of 160,000 dollars, whether it is for 4 or 6 months. He
added saying that for a treaty-binding Organization, the Parties should make a concerted
effort, including by Intelsat and all present at the meeting, to reach an amicable conclusion,
and he does not necessarily see that $160,000 should be derailing the proceedings of an
Extraordinary Assembly of Parties meeting. On another issue, he raised that some of the
concerns are the conditions placed for reaching an agreement because, he believes that it is
entirely a sovereign right of the ITSO Parties to decide whether or not to have an Assembly
of Parties meeting, whether physical or virtual and hopefully, have Intelsat to participate in
this meeting so the Parties can clarify and reach two different conclusions; one, an agreement
that the Parties would then kindly request to be seen in writing, that ITSO's Executive Organ
and Intelsat have agreed to either $575,000 or $500,000 as suggested by the Party of
Germany. And secondly, the Parties can go to a discussion on whether or not and when the
Parties should have an AP meeting, either virtual or physical, particularly in light that it
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 45
would be very difficult for a treaty-binding Organization to meet virtually, to decide the
nature to terminate or continue the Organization.
239. The Director General said that the proposal of 575,000 dollars covers the period of
September to December 2020, and this is based on the amount of expenditure of 100,000
dollars per month but the amount of expenditure per month may go higher due to additional
expenditure. He added that there is some amount of money that is outstanding from July
through August 2020. Those amounts are now included in the figure of 575,000 dollars. He
continued saying that in terms of the decision by the Parties about holding the AP raised by
the Party of South Africa and also raised by the Party of Canada, in two separate issues, he
stressed that who determines when the AP should be held, it is not Intelsat but, it is the
Parties, and he added that a final opinion would need to come from the Parties as to whether
it is practical or not to hold an AP virtual or physical meeting.. He wanted to invite the legal
counsel to provide some comments on that issue. On the questions raised by the Party of
Tanzania about the time for discussion of the Parties’ Common Heritage, the Director
General affirmed that it will take place at the ordinary AP Meeting, and not at this present
meeting. He also added that some documents have been prepared, which will be circulated
to the Parties. On the issues raised by the Party of Canada, the Director General said that
since it had been raised earlier and the amounts are small, it would be helpful to be able to
have a shift, and hence the proposal made earlier by one of the Parties to have Intelsat come
or maybe postpone this discussion.
240. The Director General suggested reaching the Representative of Intelsat, Ms. Michelle
Bryan to join the meeting, and to move the discussion to combine with the discussion on
document AP-39-11.
241. The Chair of AP-39 requested the Director General to present document AP-39-7
“Report of the Director General on Intelsat’s Bankruptcy”.
242. The Director General presented document AP-39-7 “Report of the Director General
on Intelsat’s Bankruptcy” and made the recommendation that the Assembly of Parties
DECIDE to NOTE the Report of the Director General on Intelsat’s Bankruptcy; EXPRESS
its grave concern regarding Intelsat’s efforts to use its bankruptcy to disavow its obligation
to honor the Core Principles and to prevent ITSO from fulfilling its main mission under the
ITSO Agreement, by depriving ITSO of funds necessary to fulfill its main purpose, in a clear
attempt to force a de facto closure of ITSO; and REAFFIRM that Intelsat’s ability to use the
Parties Common Heritage must remain conditioned upon Intelsat honoring the commitments
it made in 2001 and any failure on its part to do so would result in an unprecedented breach
of the commitments made by the Notifying Administrations to all Parties to the ITSO
Agreement at the time of restructuring.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 46
243. The Representative of the Party of the United States said that the Director General
amended the recommendations on document AP-39-7 and he fully appreciated what he
attempted to do. He added that the amended second paragraph seemed to be acceptable to
him and was a movement in the right direction. Regarding the third recommendation, he said
it mentions the U.S Notifying Administration to ensure certain things. He offered to say along
the lines of the Parties reaffirm their desire that Intelsat's ability to use the ITU filings,
transferred to the United States in 2001, following the restructure of INTELSAT should
remain conditioned on Intelsat's continued provision of the public service obligations. He
restated that this is the consistent language with Article XII of the ITSO Agreement,
particularly for those for the Notifying Administration and something that the Parties
continued to live up to and will continue to honor. He concluded by saying that he is trying
to find the language that all can agree to.
244. The Representative of the Party of France said that the Party of France takes note of
the summary of the future of Intelsat and would like to thank the Director General for
following the situation very closely. He added that as proposed in recommendation (iii), the
Party of France supports Intelsat's ability to use the Parties’ Common Heritage must remain
conditioned to the Public Service Agreement, and as he said earlier, the Party of France
supports recommendation (ii), which speaks about the judgment of Intelsat and provisions
that have not been legally demonstrated about the future of Intelsat. He also added that what
the Party of France would like to propose is more factual wording for the second paragraph,
such as “The Assembly of Parties DECIDES to express serious concern about the bankruptcy
procedure that Intelsat has initiated, which may prevent it from fulfilling its main condition
as provided in the Public Service Agreement.
245. The Secretary of the meeting read the comments from the Party of Chile which says
“In terms that its revenue has diminished in 1 percent in the last year or so and has diminished
ITSO in over 80 percent of its payment, the figure requested by ITSO, it's most reasonable
making an effort to cut its budget. On the other hand, it is not to Intelsat to impose to the
Assembly to withdraw the arbitration process, and also, it is not for Intelsat to place
conditions on when and how the Assembly of Parties should be held”. The Secretary of the
meeting also read the comments from the Party of Nicaragua that requested the summary of
the proposal of both sides on the table that will be easier to understand. And the Party of
Indonesia would like information on the document regarding the legal position of the Parties’
Common Heritage.
246. The Chair of AP-39 asked the Director General to comment on the wording and the
proposal made by the Party of the United States and France.
247. The Director General said that the legal counsel will prepare the text and have it
distributed as soon as possible on the proposal by the Parties on the specifics and the wording.
He added that the recommendation will be distributed and shared on the screen, and then, it
would be done separately with the Party of the United States. He asked if the Party of the
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 47
United States could send their proposed text to the Secretariat, which would then look at in
coordination with what ITSO has prepared and sent out to the Parties.
248. The Representative of the Party of Canada suggested the Assembly address two
issues, one which is urgent and the other which is very important. The urgent issue is related
to agreeing to an agreement between Intelsat and ITSO on the budget up to December the
31st, 2020. The Assembly would ask for Intelsat's participation so that the Assembly can get
a confirmation that ITSO's Executive Organ and Intelsat have agreed on an X amount of
dollars up to December the 31st, 2020. He stressed that if the Assembly can have that as an
urgent issue resolved, it would be greatly appreciated, and then the Assembly can decide on
the text of some recommendations or the decision as to when, how, and if the Assembly
should hold an Assembly of Parties meeting.
249. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the representative of the Party of Canada and said that
the ITSO Executive Organ will look into the matters that have been raised. The Chair of AP-
39 then recognized Ms. Renata Brazil David, who is the Director of Legal Affairs, to present
Document AP-39-10, “Report of the Director General on revisions necessary for the Public
Services Agreement between ITSO and Intelsat”.
250. The Director of Legal Affairs presented document AP-39-10, “Report of the Director
General on revisions necessary for the Public Services Agreement between ITSO and
Intelsat” and said that when the original PSA was proposed by AP-25, the expectation was
that Intelsat would honor rather than seek to circumvent its obligations imposed on it by the
terms of the PSA. Unfortunately, in light of the recent negotiations with Intelsat and
considering Intelsat's action taken in the bankruptcy proceeding, it has become clear that it
is impossible to rely on Intelsat's goodwill. Therefore, it is necessary to make a few revisions
to the PSA to avoid the repetition of those problems once Intelsat exits bankruptcy. In
proposing these changes, our objective is not to seek major changes to the PSA but simply
to address the very specific problems where the current PSA has proven simply to be
unworkable. As such, a very limited number of modifications are being proposed dealing
primarily with the preamble and to Articles 3, 6, and 14. Regarding the preamble, we
incorporated a reference to Intelsat's bankruptcy, since this is a major event, and it's what
now requires the signing of a new PSA. With respect to Article 3, which addresses ITSO's
supervisory role, we have inserted additional language in Section 303 regarding the
information that Intelsat should provide to ITSO on a Part 30 basis to enable ITSO to
determine that Intelsat is meeting its public service obligations. This language is the same as
the language presented to AP-30 regarding the information that Intelsat had at the time agreed
to provide on a Part 30 basis. Regarding Article 6, which deals with governing law and
dispute resolution, we added specific language allowing for the expedited procedure rules
contained within the rules of arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce, ICC.
These are more recent procedures adopted by the ICC and are intended to simplify and
expedite the conduct of arbitration proceedings. Concerning Article 14 dealing with funding,
based on the current difficulties encountered by ITSO concerning the funding mechanism
established in the Intelsat PSA, it's clear that it's not possible to retain the good-faith
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 48
negotiation and standard currently in Article 14. Given that they are saying it had initially
decided on a figure of 1.3 million in the year 2001 dollars as representing an appropriate and
sufficient annual funding level for ITSO going forward and that amount is equal to 1.8
million in the year 2013 dollars, that amount represents the most reasonable baseline for
future funding. And it's fully consistent with the limitation imposed in the current language
of Article 14 on ITSO's funding. By having a set amount in the PSA, Intelsat will no longer
be able to use negotiations to starve ITSO from funding, as they are doing right now.
However, even with this as a set amount, the Director General in appropriate circumstances
would be authorized to agree to a different amount or payment arrangements according to
the budget approved by the Assembly. Of course, it's still in the hands of the Assembly.
Separately, as regards the contingency fund, the purpose of the provision replenishing the
contingency fund in the original PSA was to provide ITSO with a reasonable safety net in
the case it was necessary to raise claims against Intelsat going forward. Because of Intelsat's
action in the bankruptcy proceeding, the existing contingency fund has been depleted, and
Intelsat's action has made it impossible for that dispute to be properly resolved in the manner
that it was envisioned under Article 6 of the PSA. That being the case, under these very
unique circumstances, further replenishment of the contingency fund would be fully
appropriate and justified. We believe that those changes are necessary to ensure the stability
for ITSO. The Director General, therefore, recommends that the Assembly of Parties decide
to note the report of the Director General on the necessary revisions on the ITSO-Intelsat
Public Service Agreement; approve the revisions on the ITSO-Intelsat Public Service
Agreement to be used as soon as Intelsat emerges from bankruptcy, as contained in
Attachment No. 1 to Document AP-39-10; authorize the Director General to enter into the
revised Public Service Agreement as contained in Attachment No. 1 to Document AP-39-10
in conjunction with Intelsat's emergence from bankruptcy; and require the United States
Notifying Administration to ensure that Intelsat has entered into the Public Service
Agreement with ITSO as outlined in Attachment No. 1 to AP-39-10 as a precondition to the
approval of the assignment of license currently held by Intelsat license—LLC, debtor in
possession to any successor entity.
251. The Director General took the floor to say that the document presented by the
Director of Legal Affairs is extremely important in terms of timing and that is the reason why
it is coming at this time, It will be helpful to both ITSO and Intelsat. He also added that the
understanding is that Intelsat needs this PSA to be signed before they emerge from
bankruptcy, and that is why it is important to have it discussed and agreed upon at this point.
252. The Representative of the Party of Australia said that on the substantive modification
sought within the Public Service Agreement and particularly about the funding item under
Article 14, it needs to be subject to the earlier discussion and the Director General's
interaction within Intelsat on reaching a mutually acceptable amount. She stressed that in
general, that item should prejudice future decisions of the Assembly both on the continuation
of ITSO but also the amount requested in budget items. She noted there might be some
variation from what was read from the Director of Legal Affairs, that the Director General
may be able to agree on a lower number if the recommended decisions for the Assembly
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 49
reflect the capacity to agreel a smaller amount than is described in Article 14 of the proposed
modifications to the Public Service Agreement.
253. The Representative of the Party of Uganda said that she wanted to support the
recommendations that have been presented in the Director General's report based on the
discussions they have seen not just in this meeting but also in the period leading up to this
meeting and recommends the modification of the PSA.
254. The Representative of the Party of the United States took the floor to say that the
Party of the United States opposes the recommendation of the necessary revisions to the
Public Services Agreement and that the proposed changes of the PSA would make new
satellite companies to avoid to sign the PSA with ITSO. He reminded the meeting that the
PSA was introduced as a tool by the 25th Assembly of Parties to ensure that the initial 12
years of funding provided by the Parties through their signatories at the time of restructuring
was used by ITSO to ensure that the company continued to provide the public service
obligations. He added that the 25th Assembly of Parties also decided among the myriad of
decisions that it decided that if ITSO continued beyond 12 years after the funding provided
had been spent, future funding would then come from Intelsat and subject to good-faith
negotiation and the goal of the PSA approved by the 25th Assembly of Parties was to ensure
that ITSO maintained the oversight of the newly privatized Intelsat and that Intelsat has been
very successful in providing the public service obligations. He asked the meeting if the goal
of ITSO is to seek more arbitration, or if the goal is to create an environment where ITSO
attracts satellite companies to help to maintain global connectivity and global coverage. He
also reminded the meeting that the PSA has a funding requirement that led to the result where
ITSO received more money from Intelsat than what ITSO needed to perform its oversight
mission which resulted in the Organization to grow a reserve fund of nearly 1 million dollars
before the funding dispute began. He added that when Intelsat and ITSO began their
negotiations about funding, the reserve fund was a part of that conversation and Intelsat asked
to credit the reserve fund and then lower the annual funding to meet actual expenses. He
asked if the solution is to make the PSA a burden for Intelsat and that the PSA is a failure
with the proposed changes. He also stressed the last recommendation that concerns the Public
Services Agreement as attached to this document and wanted to ensure that the Assembly is
empowered to approve changes to the PSA, that is covered in Article IX (xvi) of the ITSO
Agreement. He suggested that the Director General be given maximum flexibility to achieve
a signed PSA, one that is can be signed by a company. He also raised that the last
recommendation, that says that to require the U.S. Notifying Administration to take a certain
action, and he asked for clarification wherein the ITSO Agreement does it allow this to take
the decision requiring a Party to accept a new obligation that does not exist in the ITSO
Agreement. He then requested that the word "require" should be deleted from the
recommendation. He concluded by saying that the U.S Notifying Administration is well
aware of their obligations, and they commit again to meet their obligations by the ITSO
Agreement; in particular, those under Article 12 and the Party of the United States would be
willing to consider amending the language of the recommendation such that, he quoted, "The
meeting noted the obligations of the Notifying Administrations articulated in Article XII of
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 50
the ITSO Agreement. In particular, Article 12(c)(ii) was amended by the 31st Assembly of
Parties," end quote. He ended by saying that having this meeting to take a decision that
exceeds this obligation would be inconsistent with the ITSO Agreement and an unacceptable
outcome of this meeting.
255. The External Legal Advisor said that the Party of the United States raised several
concerns and the most important one is their assessment that the PSA is a failure and what
the Party of the United States has not addressed is why it is a failure, and the answer very
simple, is that Intelsat through what it has done in the bankruptcy proceeding has made it a
failure. He added that there was a mechanism in the PSA to resolve the funding dispute that
had arisen and if the arbitration process had been permitted to proceed, ITSO and Intelsat
may have prevailed but, the approach that the Parties expected in 2001 for that type of dispute
to be resolved through an arbitration proceeding with an objective arbitrator has been
frustrated by Intelsat's actions in filing for bankruptcy and the actions it's taken in the
bankruptcy proceeding to essentially prevent the arbitrator from doing what the arbitration
was intended to accomplish, and that is the reason that the changes are now being proposed
to the PSA. He also said that he agrees in light of the discussions that have taken place at this
meeting, there may be a different approach taken to ITSO's funding needs in the future, and
the language that has been proposed is reflective of that. He stressed that if there is a change
in how ITSO is to perform its functions or the staffing levels that are appropriate and those
all result in a lower funding level, that is something that the Assembly will be involved with,
and the way the PSA would be worded under the changes that are now proposed would
allow for that to take place. He also agrees that the way the PSA is worded with the proposed
changes, Intelsat has some specific protections, some of which exist now. He added that if
ITSO were ever to seek more than the 1.8 million dollars in funding on an annual basis,
Intelsat has a very strong basis to say no and that is the most the Assembly obligated to fund
ITSO for any particular year. He also added that the Assembly of Parties can direct the
Director General or perhaps the Director General on his own, given the fact that there is a
need for less money to reach an agreement on a different amount. In contrast with the current
PSA and the problem with the current PSA is that one side of the negotiation process has
total control. If Intelsat refuses to provide funding and refuses to engage in good-faith
negotiations as to what that funding should be, Intelsat simply refuses to provide funding,
ITSO is deprived of that funding and has no recourse but to go to arbitration, and the one
time that has happened, Intelsat has frustrated the intent of the Parties in 2001 to allow that
arbitration process to go forward. He concluded by saying that a PSA that does not have
some mechanism to specify an amount, as the parties themselves cannot agree on an amount,
is unworkable, and it is unworkable because Intelsat has demonstrated it to be unworkable.
It is broken because Intelsat has broken it, not ITSO. That is the reason the funding change
is necessary and there could be a debate on whether or not $1.8 million is the right figure or
it should be a different figure, but there needs to be a figure because, without a figure, it
would leave on total control to Intelsat which has been proven to be unworkable.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 51
256. The Representative of the Party of Germany said that the Director General has to
guard the Parties’ Common Heritage and he sees that there are some failures done in the past
in terms of the PSA, then he must fix this failure. He added that there are two failures in the
current PSA, one is the funding and the new PSA should give stable funding for ITSO that
is necessary for fulfilling the task. On the second failure, he said that it is related to the
sharing of information by Intelsat, and without the information shared by Intelsat, how can
ITSO perform its supervisory role. He recommended to take note of the report and advised
to ease the language to make the PSA better for both Parties and decide on the new PSA at
the next ordinary AP meeting.
257. The Representative of the Party of Senegal said that on behalf of Senegal, he wanted
to say that one learns through experience and things have evolved over years, and their
relations with ITSO in particular with regards to the PSA also. He concluded by saying that
to guarantee ITSO's existence it requires significant financing and all of these considerations
lead Senegal to support the Director General's proposal to amend the PSA.
258. The Representative of the Party of Cameroon said that ITSO has played an important
role in the development of satellite telecommunications in recent years, and this role has been
instrumental in many areas, in which the Parties have highlighted and noted in particular
amongst the developing countries. He added that he believes that ITSO's work in the past 2
years has been more focused on resolving financing problems and the relationship with
Intelsat, which takes its attention away from the intended purpose. Given this experience,
he added that they should adopt measures, as the two previous speakers pointed out, to
address these issues. He also believes that it is important to adapt the PSA to be able to
address these matters and remain open to a revision of the wording of the recommendations,
but when it comes to the principles contained therein, it is necessary to review the PSA to
address the problems that have been highlighted at this point.
259. The Representative of the Party of Czech Republic said that she would like to bring
to the attention of the meeting the fact that the bankruptcy proceedings have not been finished
yet and it is preliminary to agree on something that yet is not in existence. Further, she would
like to have the fixed amounts for the cost of the Secretariat, which is very important at least
until the next AP meeting that will decide on the future of ITSO.
260. The Representative of the Party of China said that they agree with the proposed
change in the PSA to avoid unnecessary problems between ITSO and Intelsat, and believe
that the revision of PSA is very important. She concluded by saying that the Party of the
Peoples Republic of China supports discussing those proposals from Director General,
especially from the provisions.
261. The Representative of the Party of Canada said that he hasn't heard an answer to his
previous question as to whether or not the Assembly will have Intelsat participate in this
meeting so it can resolve the urgent issue of the funding and have an agreement in writing.
He added that if there is such an agreement, it is Canada's view that there is no need for this
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 52
Assembly to agree on a new Public Services Agreement precisely for the fact that there will
be an extension of the budget up to December 31st, 2020, and secondly, he said that he is not
entirely sure if Intelsat would be agreeing on one end to funding until the 31st of December,
$575,000, $500,000 or $415,000. He also added that if there is an agreement, the Assembly
decides when, about the date and nature of the Assembly of Parties, and in conclusion, he
would like to see the record of decisions of this Assembly be posted and shared with all the
Parties before they agree on such a record and to that effect, the Party of Canada will be
submitting a written statement.
262. The Representative of the Party of Argentina said that the Parties would have no
problem noting the document based on the discussions but, he believes this document is very
important because it has allowed the Organization and Intelsat to manage issues thus far.
Perhaps there has been some conflict more recently which means that amendment to the PSA
could be advisable. That is something that the Assembly of Parties needs to look into, and he
believes that this is not the right time to do it. He added saying that due to the current situation
that is difficult to resolve, and the Parties are still trying to find a solution and be able to take
the next step, so at the next Assembly, the Parties can then discuss ITSO's future among other
topics. He also believes that one of the items to be discussed at that AP but not at this present
meeting, given the conflict that exists, which is the Parties’ priority to resolve it and for which
requires greater clarity of this Assembly, especially what the Party of Canada said, given that
although there is a proposal from Intelsat to fund ITSO through December 2020, the Parties
don't know exactly what might happen until the first quarter of 2021. He wanted to reaffirm
Canada's request that the Parties also would like more clarity on the matter and to make
amendments proposed for Sections 3 and 14 and he proposed that this discussion be
continued at the next Assembly of Parties.
263. The Representative of the Party of France said that the Party of France has duly noted
the Director General's report on the changes to be made to the PSA and echoed what other
Parties have said as to the possibility of giving time to the Parties until the next Assembly
with regards to the proposed changes and to take into account the results of this Assembly.
This being said, the Party of France approves most, in principle, the amendments to the PSA
attached to Document AP-39-10. He also commented with regards to the fixed amount for
the financing of 1.8 million dollars. He stated that this is something that will require
discussion with Intelsat and their signature, and he understands the need to change this article
to overcome or avoid problems such as today, and there is a need for certain flexibility
incorporated focused on the evolution. He proposed that the text include that at the request
of one of the Parties, ITSO and Intelsat systematically review this amount on a period to be
determined that could be every 2 years between two Ordinary Assemblies, and then to try
and reduce it.
264. The Representative of the Party of Mali said that the Party Mali believes that to avoid
problems and contradictions between ITSO and Intelsat and to bring them together, it is truly
necessary to amend the PSA along the lines suggested by the Director General and they fully
support that position.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 53
265. The Representative of the Party of South Africa took the floor to say that on behalf
of the Party of South Africa he thanked the Director General for the work and the proposal
that he has put forward for the amendment of the PSA, and therefore, the Parties should all
appreciate what he is doing, that it is not for his gain, but it is to advance the mission of ITSO.
He added that the Party of South Africa wanted to support the proposals that have been
advanced by the Director General and would like also to support the view that the Parties
need certainty in terms of the funding of ITSO, and those proposals that are about the funding
of ITSO, they need to be carried through in the amendment of the PSA. He also added that
the Party of South Africa believes that these decisions then can be made in the next Assembly
of Parties, and their concern also is what then happens if a physical face-to-face Assembly
of Parties is not held by the first quarter of 2021 and that commitment that has been made by
Intelsat expires. He stressed that there is a concern in terms of the future sustainability of
ITSO, he supports the proposal that had been advanced and to accept the fact that the Parties
will have to have more time to discuss the substance of every amendment so that it becomes
agreeable to the Parties, ITSO and also to Intelsat as a party who has to bear all the funds for
the support of ITSO moving forward.
266. The Representative of the Party of Ghana said that the Party of Ghana also supports
the amendment of the PSA and believes that would go a very long way to first start the
relationship between Intelsat and ITSO.
267. The Director General said that any document proposed to the Assembly of Parties,
he does it with the consultation of the ITSO staff, consultants, and with the member states,
and that there is no expression of personal belief. He added that he wanted to make it clear
to the representative of the United States that there is no personal drive in trying to make the
presented document AP-39-10 to be agreed to by the Assembly. He also added that he
believes that if there is anything that is important and where he would like the future of the
Organization to go, it is in terms of stability arising out of the only document that ties ITSO
to Intelsat, the PSA. Intelsat have themselves said this is the only relationship that exists. He
stated that if the Assembly recognizes that there are any issues or any problems that can be
resolved to create certainty, he thinks it is incumbent upon the Director General to bring that
to the attention of the Parties, and the Parties have the authority to amend the PSA and will
decide whether it is worthwhile or it is not, and that is why the Director General must bring
that to the attention of the member States. As it was stated by the External Legal Counsel,
ITSO had problems for almost 2 years for one reason, because there is no minimum to the
amount that can be negotiated and it is good to use language, good-faith negotiation, but if
there is no good faith, then there is a problem, and if the problem cannot be solved through
good faith, it has to be resolved through the courts and courts cost money. He stressed that
these same issues were presented to the ITSO Advisory Committee (IAC), and going to the
courts to enter the arbitration process was as a result of not only management but also as an
executive decision by the IAC that it was necessary, and the IAC was acting on behalf of the
Assembly.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 54
268. The Director General added that if there is going to be blame for having gone to
arbitration, it is on all of us, not the Director General. Member states themselves sat in the
meeting in May 2019 and accepted that arbitration was necessary because of the situation
that was existing between Intelsat and ITSO. In terms of the areas where ITSO has had
problems with the PSA, it is because there is no minimum figure, and the Parties have
witnessed what has happened in the course of 1 or 2 days. There was a movement from
$250,000 to 415,000 dollars, which is still at issue, and there was also a movement from an
earlier figure, which was higher, to a lower figure, but all of that is because there are no limits
to where you can go. He stressed that the next time, maybe Intelsat could say, "We don't
have money. The minimum amount we shall pay you is $10," and this agreement according
to the current PSA, would have no solution for that at all. He asked the Parties how do you
protect such a situation. He also added saying that it was important, not just to specify the
maximum amount, which is already done, but also to provide some sort of floor.
269. The Director General continued to say that the agreement itself provides for
negotiations, noting that in fact that amount in the PSA is a guide. If the negotiations are for
the budget of ITSO, which budget would have been approved by the AP, if those negotiations
don't succeed, that's when you would apply the amount in question. If anything creates an
incentive for both parties to negotiate, it is not a hindrance. He also stressed that there is a
need to have an amount in the agreement and that amount can be negotiated for less than 1.8
million dollars, but it's important to have an amount.
270. The Director General continued to say that the second issue is about the principle,
and the wording which has been put in the PSA. It serves the purpose of having as a
minimum request to the Assembly to approve the changes in the principle, meaning that
negotiations can take place in terms of details, but the amendments set a principle on why it
is necessary to amend the PSA. He also mentioned that he believes that when Intelsat comes
to emerge from bankruptcy, they have to sign the PSA. The question then is whether the PSA
will be the same as what it was before, or should it be a new one which takes into account
what has been learned over some time. He recalled that when the Assembly approved the
current PSA in 2001 everyone recognized that it was a good decision at that time, and it
established a purpose, but perhaps it is time to reconsider, just like the Parties are looking at
the future of the Organization. He also added that as long as ITSO exists, a requirement
within the agreement itself requires that there must be a PSA, and it is a continuing discussion
and obligation. The timing for the approval is important because if it does not happen before
the next AP or at least have some principle agreement so that there is something on hand,
then it means a new draft may be required to be approved even in a much faster period than
is expected or desired. As an example, he said, suppose the same situation occurs during an
ordinary AP and the Parties do not reach an agreement on the Public Services Agreement,
that would mean that the Director General cannot sign any PSA with Intelsat, and if he signs,
it would have to be subject for approval by an Ordinary AP. Therefore, that would mean that
for 2 years, there would be no PSA that has been approved by member States. Before giving
the floor back, the Director General concluded by saying that he looks forward to receiving
the proposed amendment to the item (iv) within the recommendation, which specifically
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 55
addresses the Party of the United States, and that there was no malice in using the word
"require." It was a proposed solution to the number of requests coming from member States
expressing their wishes. If it cannot be shared by the Party of the United States, the member
States can look at it and see whether the context or what follows after "require" is something
they would like to see in their decision, and the Parties themselves take the decision.
271. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the Director General and asked the Assembly of Parties
to note the recommendations on the proposed Agreement nt, and said that per the Party of
France proposal the Assembly should focus on the funding side outside of the amendments
and to agree in principle with the amendments, but that they should be presented in the next
AP meeting. The Chair of AP-39 then recognized the Director General to present document
AP-39-11 “Report of the DG on the Consequences of Intelsat's Bankruptcy on ITSO”.
272. The Director General took the floor and responded to the request by the Party of
Canada that the representative of Intelsat is not available to join the meeting before 12:30
pm.
273. The Director General then presented document AP-39-11“Report of the DG on the
Consequences of Intelsat's Bankruptcy on ITSO”. He stated that in May 2020, Intelsat
declared Chapter 11 bankruptcy and as a result of that action, there have been several serious
consequences for ITSO. The uncertainties created by Intelsat’s decision and actions have a
major and direct impact on ITSO, including the effect on timely functioning of the Assembly
of Parties; availability of funding for ITSO’s operations; the impact on the ongoing
arbitration process instituted by ITSO against Intelsat; implementation of the Organization’s
Strategic Plan; and ITSO’s human resources. Furthermore, the ability of Intelsat itself to
perform Public Service Obligations is an area of concern. The Director General
recommended to the Assembly of Parties to decide to (i) note the Report of the Director
General on the Consequences of Intelsat’s Bankruptcy on ITSO; (ii) note that ITSO will be
compelled to go into a “Residual State of Operations” effective September 1, 2020, if Intelsat
does not meet its funding obligations to ITSO and strongly URGE Intelsat to reconsider its
failure to honor its funding obligations under the PSA; (iii) approve the convening of the
next ordinary Assembly of Parties meeting (AP-40) in the first half of 2021.
274. The Director General concluded his presentation by saying that to address these
developments, it is recommended to convene the next ordinary Assembly of Parties meeting
in the first half of 2021; make the necessary changes to the Public Services Agreement to be
signed with Intelsat when it emerges from bankruptcy; reaffirm that Intelsat’s ability to use
the Parties’ Common Heritage must remain conditioned upon Intelsat honoring the
commitments it made in 2001 and any failure on its part to do so would result in an
unprecedented breach of the commitments made by the Notifying Administrations to all
Parties to the ITSO Agreement at the time of restructuring; and move the Organization into
a Residual State of Operations if funding is not made available to ITSO by Intelsat by August
31, 2020.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 56
275. The Representative of the Party of the United States said that in regards to the last
recommendation which requires the approval of certain conditions that Intelsat must meet
first, there are certain limitations to the rules and procedures and laws of the United States
regarding the licensing of those Intelsat satellites. Therefore, he requests that the
recommendation be revised to allow the Parties the flexibility to ensure that Intelsat signs
the PSA to allow it to meet the Public Service Obligations and to allow it to meet the FCC
licensing conditions. He added that requiring a certain type of funding or a certain amount
of funding may lead to a discontinuation of that PSA, which would then put them in a very
difficult position to license those satellites. He concluded by saying that they must maintain
that flexibility, and as he has offered at previous meetings, the Party of the United States
stands ready to assist the executive organ in a PSA that accomplishes their collective
objectives.
276. The Representative of the Party Nigeria thanked the Director General for the
presentation and asked for clarification from the Legal Counsel if Intelsat has the powers to
make a major declaration such as filing of bankruptcy that can have serious implications and
negative impacts on the functions of the role of ITSO.
277. The Representative of the Party Cameroon said that this has been a very rich and
interesting discussion, and they support the proposal because it allows the Parties to address
the current situation. He added that as indicated by several of the speakers, he believes that
the purpose of the amendments is to ensure that the Organization can carry out its activities,
taking into account any decisions that may be made. He concluded by saying that as stated
2 years ago, everything seemed to go well and was effective, and as such the problems seen
today should not continue. They should be followed more closely as per the Director
General's recommendations, which will allow Intelsat to continue to be an effective
competitor in the telecommunications market as well and ITSO to survive.
278. The being no further request for the floor from the Parties, the Chair of AP-39 offered
the floor to the Director General.
279. The Director General said that as regards the issues raised by the Party of the United
States will be good to see the language that they would like to have in recommendation (iv)
of the document AP-39-11. He added that the key issue is that when the meeting ends the
Parties should not leave unresolved matters and that what he was trying to accomplish was
to make sure that someone has to meet the outstanding financial obligations, and that the
only party that can meet those obligations is Intelsat because of its responsibility to fund
ITSO. He agreed that there are national regulations that govern licensing, and therefore, those
must be respected. He continued to say that in light of the proposal from the Party of the
United States, the conditioning would take into account, the national regulations. He
concluded by saying that if there is a language from the Party of the United States that sort
of incorporates that principle, the Director General would be very happy to amend this
condition.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 57
280. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the Director General and said if there are no objections
to the recommendation that she made for noting the two reports that are supposed to follow,
she proposes to adjourn the meeting for 25 minutes.
281. The Secretary of the meeting took the floor to request the Chair of AP-39 to allow 2
minutes for a report of the Credentials Committee before the 25-minute break.
[Item concluded]
AGENDA ITEM 5: REPORT OF THE CREDENTIALS COMMITTEE
Reference: AP-39-5 (Credentials Committee)
282. The Chair of AP-39 reverted to Agenda Item 5, the Report of the Credentials
Committee. He then asked the Chairman of the Credentials Committee, the representative of
the Party of Germany, to present document AP-39-5, "Report of the Credentials Committee."
283. The Chairman of the Credentials Committee thanked the Chair and his colleagues
from the Credentials Committee. He stated that the Credentials Committee reviewed the
credentials of the delegations entitled to attend the 39th Extraordinary Assembly of Parties.
The committee found the credentials of 94 delegations to be fully in order. The delegations
whose credentials were found to be in order can be found in the attachment to this document,
AP-39-5.
284. The Chair of AP-39 opened the floor for comments and as there was none, he
proposed the Assembly decides to accept the Report of the Credentials Committee as set out
in the Document AP-39-5.
285. The Chair of AP-39 thanked the Chairman of the Credentials Committee for the
report.
[Item concluded]
286. The meeting was adjourned for 25-minute break.
287. The meeting was reconvened at 1130 hours.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 58
AGENDA ITEM 7: APPROVAL OF FINAL RECORD OF DECISIONS
288. Mr. Mlami Booi, the representative of the Party of South Africa said that the Chair
of AP-39 had to excuse herself and delegated her function to him as Acting Chairman of AP-
39.
289. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 called to order the session and brought to the
Assembly's attention the Record of Decisions of the Thirty-Ninth Extraordinary Assembly
of Parties and then proceeded to go page-by-page.
290. The Representative from the Pary of Canada requested the floor to ask if there any
way in which the Parties can know whether or not ITSO and Intelsat have agreed on any
funding up to December 31, 2020. He added that this is critical, as it is reflected in his written
comments, because on September the 1st, 2020, there will be no operational funds for ITSO
and if there is any way in which the Parties can have any confirmation or any information to
that regard.
291. The Director General said that he requested Intelsat to join the meeting but
unfortunately the representative for Intelsat was not available to join and the Director General
did not have a physical discussion with her. He had therefore emailed her to find out what
Intelsat’s final position is. He stated that Intelsat had indicated that the offer of 415,000
dollars is firm and therefore if an agreement is not reached, what may be a practical solution
given that there will be outstanding amounts even if ITSO accepted the offer of 415,000
dollars, would be that the final recommendation which was made about the outstanding
amount being by Intelsat would be applicable for any obligations that are not covered by the
budget.
292. The Representative from the Party of Germany said that it is not very satisfying now
to leave the Parties in this situation where they just do not know what happens next week.
He proposed to have a short virtual conference one week after the AP-39 meeting in case
there is no agreement which is satisfying so that at least a solution is found to cover the
survival costs until the end of 2020. He also said that in case there is no AP meeting in
December, the meeting could potentially take place in the 1st quarter of 2020, therefore, he
would like to know if there is no satisfying agreement on financing this period, when would
the Parties have to meet again to debate on this because the situation as of now is not resolved.
293. The Director General said that he either takes the decision of accepting the 415,000
dollars, or the Assembly allows him to be able to reach out to Intelsat a last effort in the
course in the day after the meeting, and then appraise the member States through the
Secretariat about the outcome of the negotiations. He will also let the Parties know what
position Intelsat takes, taking into account the decision of the Parties. He suggested forming
a small group of Parties to engage in the final result, to express the concerns of the member
States about the amount, as no decision was taken on that. He acknowledged some proposals
from the Parties, especially from the Party of Germany, which have specific numbers, and if
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 59
that is a position supported by several member States, it would be helpful to involve
Germany, having been the originator of that proposal.
294. The Representative from the Party of the United States raised a Point of Order and
asked to clarify as to what the Assembly is doing with the Record of Decisions, whether they
will approve, or will there be an ability to continue to edit the document after the meeting.
295. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 said that the point of the exercise is to go through
the decisions, satisfy the Parties, capture them as agreed by the Assembly and agree on the
accuracy of the decisions, as well as the other points raised earlier on the decision.
296. The Secretary of the meeting added that the practice is that the Parties have to approve
the Record of Decisions by going through item by item to confirm the approval, and that has
been the practice in all APs until now. She acknowledged the concerns that the Parties have
raised in the chat, specifically the Party of Canada and supported by other countries asking
for the parties to have extra time to look at the Record of Decisions and she deferred this to
the Director General.
297. The Director General took the floor to say that Parties are to go through the whole
document and if there is a substantive matter, it could be sorted out during the discussion.
He added that if the Parties would like to have some more time to reconfirm what has been
discussed and agreed on in principle, he proposed to set a two-week deadline for comments
once the Record of Decision is received by the Parties.
298. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 said that the participants will also have the
opportunity to share their comments through the chat-box as a way of communicating to the
meeting. He proposed how to move forward with the Record of Decisions, namely:
agreement in principle, editing and making sure the Parties are on the same page as far as the
accuracy of the decisions, and then finally adopting the decisions. He added that if the
members need more time to go and relook at how the decisions are worded and then advise
the Secretariat, that can be considered. But then the conclusion of the document will have to
be done electronically.
299. The Secretary of the meeting said that there is a comment from the Party of Norway
on Document AP-39-10, which says that their understanding is that this document would be
just for noting.
300. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 said that the Secretariat’s understanding of the
process is to note the documents where necessary and approve the accuracy of the decisions.
301. The Secretary of the meeting said that there is a comment from the Party of
Switzerland that supports the comment made by the Party of Norway and they would like
the results of the discussion between the Director General and Intelsat to be included in the
Record of Decisions.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 60
302. The Representative from the Party of the United States took the floor to say that at
the opening of the meeting, he expressed the concerns of the Party of the United States about
the convening of this meeting as a virtual Assembly. He noted at the time that they would
attach a statement to the Summary Record of Decisions regarding the decision of this
Assembly to convene this Assembly. He concluded by saying that the Party of the United
States will need to add a note under paragraph 1 that the Party of the United States attached
its concerns as expressed in Attachment No. 1 to this report.
303. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 continued reading the paragraphs of the Record of
Decisions and the Representative of the Party of the United States requested the floor to
comment on paragraph 5.
304. The Representative from the Party of the United States said that paragraph 5 is
currently incorrect as written. He recalled that there were many comments in the chat-box
regarding the decision and there were numerous interventions in support of deferring the
Public Services Agreement to the next AP meeting. He proposed to delete "approve in
principle" and suggested to change to “the Assembly of Parties decided to refer this PSA as
attached to the next meeting of the Assembly of Parties for its further consideration and
deliberation”.
305. The Director General suggested that the discussion will be on the revisions by the
principle, to avoid to restart a whole discussion that had been done thus far. He added that
the wording has to be such that it also captures the many voices that said that the issues which
were discussed were important and could be considered “as approved in the principle”, but
further discussion was still necessary. He also suggested that the representative from the
Party of the United States re-modify his proposal.
306. The Representative from the Party of the United States said that he had offered the
best language he could and he noted that in a few of his interventions, he was determined to
be in the minority, and he was dismissed, and now that he was in the majority, he was still
being dismissed. He continued to say that this decision should reflect what was expressed
by the Parties during the interventions and in the chat-box, and this decision cannot say that
Parties approved in principle the revisions of the Public Services Agreement. He stressed
that the Parties had several expressions or desires to continue talking about this PSA.
307. The Secretary of the meeting suggested adding some language to reflect what the
Parties agreed and that is there is a need to make revisions to the PSA.
308. The Representative from the Party of the United States said that all he is asking is
whether or not the Parties must approve certain revisions or not.. He agreed that the Parties
need to have that conversation at the next Assembly and he is looking for a decision of this
Assembly that says that the Parties will make decisions on the PSA at the next Assembly.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 61
309. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 said that was the spirit of the agreement and the
decision was that the Parties defer discussion of the PSA, although there was an agreement
on the principle need for some of revisions. The details of what the revisions should look
like was deferred to the next Assembly. He requested that the record be phrased such that it
captures that sense of the decision.
310. The Representative from the Party of the United States asked if the Secretariat could
make the changes on the screen in track changes.
311. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 agreed to the proposal from the Party of the United
States and said that would be done to capture the accurate decision and not to open the
discussion on the PSA.
312. The Secretary of the meeting requested the Executive Assistant to edit paragraph 5
of the Record of Decision on the screen in track changes as “the Assembly of Parties decided
to refer this PSA as attached to attached to Document AP-39-10 to the next meeting of the
Assembly of Parties for its consideration”. Then, she asked if the Director General agreed
with the edit.
313. The Director General said he agreed with the proposed edit on paragraph 5 of the
Record of Decisions.
314. The Representative from the Party of Romania said she agrees with the text proposed
by the Representative from the Party of the United States, and she wanted to note that the
Parties did agree on the fact that the PSA needs to be amended, and this should also be
reflected on the Record of Decisions and also had an agreement to have an improved PSA.
315. The Secretary of the meeting took the floor to say that the intervention from the Party
of Romania was also her understanding. She added that the Party of Cameroon has also
included that in the chat box it is stated that the meeting agreed with the principle for
revisions of the PSA and that the PSA should be finalized at the next AP. She proposed to
say that the Assembly of Parties decided to agree that the PSA needs revisions and refer the
revisions to this PSA as attached to Document AP-39-10 to the next meeting of the Assembly
of Parties for its consideration.
316. The Director General suggested that “the Assembly of Parties decided to approve the
need for revisions to this PSA or current PSA as contained in Document AP-39-10 and refer
the document to the AP-40 for further consideration”.
317. The Acting Chairman thanked the Director General and said that his proposal is
aligned with the proposal from the Secretary of the Meeting.
318. The Representative from the Party of Cameroon took the floor and suggested further
edits to paragraph 5 “the Assembly of Parties decided to approve the principle for the revision
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 62
of the current PSA as attached in the document AP-39-10, and refer the document to the AP-
40 for further consideration”.
319. The Representative from the Party of Germany suggested further edit to paragraph 5
as “the Assembly of Parties decided to refer this PSA as attached to the next meeting of the
Assembly of Parties for considering needed revisions”.
320. The Representative from the Party of Canada took the floor to suggest an edit in
paragraph 5 as “The Assembly of Parties decided to consider necessary revisions to the PSA
at the next Assembly of Parties, taking into account the text suggested in AP."
321. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 agreed with the proposal from the Party of Canada
and so did the Director General.
322. The Representative from the Party of the United States took the floor to comment on
paragraph 6 and said that the paragraph causes some concern as currently drafted as it
suggests obligations of the Notifying Administration, that do not exist in the ITSO agreement
today. He suggested to amend paragraph 6 to reflect those obligations under the ITSO
agreement and offered the following edit: “The Assembly of Parties affirm its desire that
Article 12 of the ITSO Agreement be followed when the U.S. Notifying Administration
considers the approval of the licenses currently held by Intelsat LLC, debtor in possession,
to any successor entity”.
323. The Representative from the Party of Canada suggested the following edit to
paragraph 6: "The Assembly of Parties decided to revise the proposal of the United States
notifying administration to endeavor to ensure that Intelsat enters into a PSA at the next
Assembly of Parties, AP- 40".
324. The Representative from the Party of Romania said she supports the proposed edit in
paragraph 6 from the Party of Canada.
325. The Representative from the Party of the United States requested the floor to
comment on the proposed edit from the Party of Canada and said that he wanted to be very
careful about the word "revised" when it comes to the PSA and as it stands today, Intelsat
and ITSO have a PSA in place, and if it is forced to limit the Party of the United States to a
revised PSA, the Parties are precluding their ability to license Intelsat based on the current
PSA and that is a regulatory problem for the Party of the United States. He concluded by
saying that they must be very careful what the Parties are asking the Party of the United
States to do.
326. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 granted the floor to the ITSO External Legal Counsel
for comments.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 63
327. The ITSO External Legal Counsel said that he understands the concern of the Party
of the United States, and he wanted to raise two points. One, the way paragraph 6 is drafted,
it is asking the Party of the United States to endeavor to do something, which is short of a
demand, and secondly, he reminded the Party of the United States that they acknowledged
in prior interventions that the existing PSA is broken and that they said that they want to
work with the Director General to come up with a better PSA. He concluded by saying that,
he does not understand their concern about acknowledging here that it is simply asking them
to try if they can, to have a revised PSA used.
328. The Representative from the Party of the United States responded to the ITSO
External Legal Counsel, that the number one mission of the Party of the United States as the
Notifying Administration is to be able to license Intelsat to provide the Public Service
Obligations. He added that if the Assembly restricts his ability to do that, he could violate
the ITSO Agreement. He stressed that he was asking to allow him the ability to license
Intelsat so that they do not cut off services. He also stressed that if the Assembly requires
the Party of the United States to require a new PSA, it could require them to terminate the
service, and then everybody's services are terminated because they cannot license to do what
the Assembly wants them to do. He acknowledged the edit to the text proposed by the Party
of Canada, and he requested the flexibility as to what the PSA is, due to the obligation for
the Party of the United States to license Intelsat to provide Public Service Obligations.
329. The Secretary of the meeting said that the Parties of Cameroon, Romania, Argentina.
Egypt and many others commented in the chat-box they support the proposed edit from the
Party of Canada to paragraph 6. She also, suggested to the Executive Assistant to type
Canada’s proposal on the screen to the Record of Decisions document.
330. The Director General took the floor to say that there are two issues: one is as a
Notifying Administration; the whole message was meant to mean that the Party of the United
States takes its responsibility as a Notifying Administration to ensure that the PSA is entered
into by Intelsat that meets the requirements of both the Parties and the notifying
administration. That is the main thrust of the message. He added that by having a proposal
from the Party of Canada that specifically wants to ensure that is done, it is simply putting
that responsibility on the Party of the United States. It could be further qualified by including
Article 12 of the ITSO agreement if the Party of the United States would be comfortable with
having that as a means of ensuring that it is in accordance with ITSO Agreement.
331. The Representative from the Party of Canada said that that he wanted to make a
further edit to paragraph 6 as “The Assembly of Parties decided to invite or request the U.S.
Notifying Administration to endeavor to ensure that Intelsat considers entering into a revised
PSA subject to the discussions on this issue to be taken at the next Assembly of Parties”.
332. The Director General agreed to the proposal from the Party of Canada.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 64
333. The Representative from the Party of the United States said that he would like to have
the word “revised” deleted.
334. The Director General agreed to the proposal from the Party of the United States.
335. The Secretary of the meeting continued reading the paragraphs of the Record of
Decisions and the Party of Canada requested the floor to comment on paragraph 8.
336. The Representative from the Party of Canada suggested editing paragraph 8 in the
last sentence as “strongly urge Intelsat to fulfill its obligations under the PSA”. He added
that the Assembly does not necessarily share the language that points to Intelsat's failure to
honor its funding obligations, and there may have been disagreements on the funding
obligations, and he suggested to tone down that language and state "and strongly urges
Intelsat to fulfill its obligations under the PSA."
337. The Director General agreed with the edit proposal from the Party of Canada in
paragraph 8.
338. The Representative from the Party of the United States requested the floor to
comment on paragraph 9 and suggested to edit paragraph 9 as "The Assembly of Parties noted
the concern of the United States that any Public Services Agreement must be in accordance
with the domestic laws and regulations of the United States".
339. The Secretary of the meeting said that the Party of the United Kingdom commented
in the chat-box that the Party of the United Kingdom echoed the words of the Party of the
United States and wishes to be also captured in this text as a Notifying Administration.
340. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 and the Director General agreed to the proposal of
the Party of the United Kingdom.
341. After the secretary for the meeting read paragraph 9, the Representative from the
Party of Nigeria requested the floor to suggest to change the word “must” to “should” and
explained that the word “must" seems to be kind of persuasive and say that there is no choice
but to abide by that.
342. The Representative from the Party of Canada also commented on paragraph 9 and
suggested to delete paragraph 9.
343. The Director General said that he does not understand why the Party of Canada
suggested deleting paragraph 9 as this is the most important part about document AP-39-11.
He reminded the Assembly on what he said that if there is a situation where funding from
Intelsat has not been adequate to meet existing obligations that the Organization cannot get
out of as a result of the funding being inadequate, someone has got to pay or to take
responsibility for that payment. He added that if ITSO should decide to lay off some staff,
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 65
there will be consequences, and someone has to pay that bill, and if the budget or the funding
from Intelsat is not adequate, this is where this protection becomes extremely important. He
concluded by saying it is important to maintain paragraph 9.
344. The Representative from the Party of the United States requested the floor to say that
he agreed to change the word "must" to "should," in paragraph 9, and added the Party of the
United States will not violate the national laws to license Intelsat. He also requested to
change the word "domestic" to "national” as it is with the national laws and regulations of
the U.S. and UK. While still having the floor, he requested to delete paragraphs 11 and 12
because those documents were not presented and were not debated.
345. The Director General said that the Chair of AP-39 at the beginning of the meeting
stated the reason why documents AP-39-8 and AP-39-9 were not being presented. He also
clarified that documents have been in circulation and within the convening invitation, the
participants were invited to make comments if they had any. He added that the fact that
nobody has raised any objection today to those documents that have been circulated and
neither has anybody said they have not received them, it would not be proper to delete
paragraphs 11 and 12. He concluded by saying that if on the other hand the member States
feel strongly that these paragraphs should be deleted, he has no objection to it.
346. The Representative from the Party of Germany said that he does not agree to delete
paragraphs 11 and 12 and when it comes to the next ordinary Assembly of Parties, the Parties
will have to decide upon the future of the ITSO Agreement. He added that it was important
to think about the proposals by ITSO and in particular for upcoming cases where the
involvement of ITSO is important for the world. It is extremely important to really present
very good cases, maybe even study about the satellite market, and continue this discussion
by email.
347. The Representative from the Party of Ghana disagreed with deleting paragraphs 11
and 12 and he stressed that both documents AP-39-8 and AP-39-9 were to be noted.
348. The Representative from the Party of France said that in paragraph 10, there is a
comment regarding the wording that is too vague. He suggested that the wording to end of
2020 or the first quarter of 2021 as has been discussed for the next AP meeting, and
presenting this deadline depends on the agreement expected between ITSO and Intelsat, the
amount and duration of the funding of ITSO for the next month.
349. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 said that it has been decided that the next AP
meeting will be held in the first quarter of 2021.
350. The Secretary of the meeting said that there were no further comments and asked if
the comments from the Party of Germany is to be included in paragraph 10 as "financing of
ITSO into the next date has to be secured by agreement between ITSO and Intelsat" or to say
"to approve the convening of the next in-person Ordinary Assembly of Parties meeting in the
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 66
first quarter of 2021 provided that financing is received from Intelsat". She added that if
Intelsat does not provide any funds, the Director General will not be in a position to hold an
AP.
351. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 agreed with the proposal from the Party of Germany.
352. The Secretary of the meeting concluded paragraph 11 as, "The Assembly of Parties
decided to note Document AP-39-8, report of the Director General, on C-Band
developments." and paragraph 12 as, "The Assembly of Parties decided to note Document
AP-39-9, report of the Director General on the financial position of Intelsat for the year
ended 2019 and subsequent events to June 2020."
353. The Representative from the Party of the United States suggested to add the wording
at the end of paragraphs 11 and 12 as “These documents were neither presented nor debated
by the Assembly”. And added that he had several concerns in those documents, but the Parties
were not allowed to address those concerns and he did not wish to have any sort of
endorsement of those documents that were neither presented nor debated by the Assembly.
354. The Director General agreed with the proposal from the Party of the United States.
The Director General asked if the assembly ruled out the hosting of the AP-40 meeting as a
virtual meeting.
355. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 said that this is a question to the floor and he recalled
that during the debates on day one of the meeting and the beginning of day two, there was a
specific desire that there be a face-to-face meeting. He concluded by saying that the question
from the Director General then is should the circumstances of COVID not allow their ruling
out a virtual meeting.
356. The Director General suggested adding some specific language that the member
States prefer an in-person meeting so that it does not rule out the possibility of having a
virtual meeting although the preference is for an in-person meeting. He also said that
flexibility would allow having a situation where due to circumstances, it becomes critical
that an AP is held and the countries still have to deal with the issues of the global pandemic.
357. The Representative from the Party of Canada asked when the Parties will have a
confirmation when there will be an agreement by Intelsat to fund ITSO as of December 31st,
2020. He added that they needed to be sure that there will be finances available for 1st of
September 2020, and confirmation from the Director General as to what the outcomes of the
final discussions with Intelsat were in order to assure the member States that there are funds
available to carry on with the business of ITSO. He also touched on the convening of an
Assembly in December, while at the same time, it was not clear to the Party of Canada,
whether or not ITSO will have any funds to open its offices on September 1st, 2020. It was
important to know what the decision will be and to the extent possible if that decision is
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 67
conveyed by email to all Parties. He concluded by saying that he hopes that ITSO and Intelsat
can agree on this and that the Parties are informed in due time.
358. The Director General said that he would aim to communicate with the Parties on
September 1st, but it also depends on the availability of Intelsat.
359. The Representative from the Party of Egypt asked a question of clarification about
paragraph 10 and what would happen in ITSO is unable to hold a physical AP meeting due
to COVID-19 and if there is no funding agreement with Intelsat by the 1st quarter of 2021.
360. The Director General said that there are various implications. First, the hosting the
AP will be important in respect of the emergence of Intelsat from bankruptcy, and that is
why it was stressed earlier that there is a need to have a Public Services Agreement sorted
out as soon as possible, either within this meeting or at the next AP. He stated that having
lost the opportunity to have a decision on that at this time means that the next AP becomes
even more crucial in terms of holding it to approve the PSA. He also said that Intelsat stated
on day 1 of the AP-39 meeting that according to their plans, they intend to get out of the
bankruptcy situation in the first quarter of 2021, and therefore the times align, and that is
why it is important to stress that timing of 1st quarter as sort of a practical time that would
enable member States to attend the next AP meeting physically.
361. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 thanked the Director General and said that this will
be subject to the challenges of COVID and the closure and opening of borders and he believes
that the Parties can leave it to the Director General to convene that meeting subject to the
circumstances prevailing at the time.
362. The Secretary of the meeting continued reading the paragraphs through the end of the
Record of Decisions.
363. The Representative from the Party of Nigeria commented on paragraph 10 regarding
the convening of the next AP-40 and said that the Director General presented an issue asking
whether the Parties also commit that in the event ITSO cannot hold an in-person AP meeting,
then the Parties should think of an ordinary AP meeting as a virtual meeting.
364. The Secretary of the meeting said that the Parties agreed to say that the Assembly of
Parties decided to approve the convening of the next Ordinary Assembly of Parties in the
first quarter of 2021 and that the preference of the Parties is to have an in-person meeting.
She added that the language proposed by the Party of Germany, namely "provided that
financing is received by Intelsat” would be included.
365. The Representative from the Party of the United States commented on the last
paragraph regarding the approval of the summary record of decisions and said that as he
stated at the beginning, he was still unaware what the Parties are approving, given the fact
that the language has been changed multiple times, and there are still submissions coming in
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 68
from the chat-box. He asked if the Parties can agree on what the process will be before
having the final text. He also asked if there will be a deadline to submit edits and fixes to
the executive organ, or is the Record of Decisions final as presented to the Assembly.
366. The Director General said that the Executive Organ of ITSO will circulate the draft
Record of Decisions to all Parties and suggested to allow 2 weeks for the Parties to send their
comments and edits in order to have the final version of the Record of Decisions.
367. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 thanked the Director General and confirmed that the
draft Record of Decisions will be circulated to all Parties to enable the member States to
review the document and submit whatever other editorial changes that might be necessary
for a period of 2 weeks.
368. As there were no further comments, the Acting Chairman of AP-39 declared that the
Record of Decisions for the 39th meeting of the Assembly of Parties has been adopted subject
to inputs that will be provided by members during a period of 2 weeks. He added that the
final document will then be circulated to all the member States. He concluded by saying that
the adoption of the Record of Decisions concludes the agenda of the official work of the
assembly and thanked all the participants.
[Item concluded]
369. The Acting Chairman of AP-39 offered the following closing remarks:
370. As we come to the end of this Extraordinary Assembly of Parties, let me thank all the
members who have sacrificed their time to engage in this forum. We can all agree that this
meeting was necessary because of the situation that we as members of ITSO find ourselves
in. I believe we have collectively taken the first few steps in a process that will determine
the future of ITSO and the Common Heritage.
371. In this regard, I would like to thank the Director General and the Deputy Director
General, and the Secretariat for looking out for the interests of this organization. To you,
Director General, Mr. Masambu, we have full confidence in you despite what may have been
said in the heat of discussions. On behalf of all the ITSO member parties, I extend our
appreciation to you and your team for the dedication you have shown and the sacrifices you
continue to make. Very few would continue to work under these current circumstances of
financial lack for the organization, even doing work when you are not being paid for what
you are doing for the interest of this organization.
372. I wish to appeal to all the Parties, while we may have political and economic
considerations about the future of ITSO, we need to also consider the human factor, what our
future decisions will mean to the staff and the families of ITSO Secretariat. They are, after
all, our employees and deserve our respect and support even during these difficult times.
ITSO RESTRICTED
AP-39-4E FINAL W/08/20
Page 69
373. We must make further strides to improve the efficiency and the role of ITSO. This
requires both technical expertise and political support. All of us here share the sentiments of
wanting to see a stable ITSO. The ability of satellite technology to provide ubiquitous and
increasingly fast connectivity to billions of people globally is at the core of the industrial
revolution and the future welfare of the world citizens. We need to continue providing
practical solutions to not only ensuring the sustainability of ITSO but ensuring that ITSO
remains relevant and efficient in this digital era.
374. Let me thank the technical support and the directors for supporting us during this
conference, and once again, thank you, Director General and ITSO staff, for your unwavering
commitment and support, and fellow members, I thank you for giving South Africa the honor
to chair this meeting. And I hope we continue to engage online to find solutions as we
prepare for our next engagement at an ordinary session, depending on the circumstances of
the pandemic.
375. I'd also like to thank you as the Parties of ITSO for your pragmatism, knowledge,
understanding, and flexibility both in the last two days and in the journey ahead as we shape
our collective future and step concerning ITSO and the Common Heritage. It is, indeed, my
privilege and pleasure to declare this Extraordinary Session officially closed. I thank you.
Merci. Gracias. And a good evening, and thank you very much.
376. The Director General offered the following closing statement:
377. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Deputy Chairman, Regional Vice-Chairs, Colleagues,
Ladies and Gentlemen. I would like on behalf of the Organization to express our sincere
thanks to all of you for having made the time to participate in this ITSO Extraordinary
Meeting of the Assembly of Parties. We understand the difficulties and circumstances under
which everybody is operating because of the pandemic, but we do appreciate that you have
made the time to discuss with candor all the important issues that are before us.
378. We take this support to be a very important declaration of willingness to ensure that
ITSO serves its purpose, and as we move into the future, we sincerely believe that this
meeting has been very instrumental and very enlightening in terms of the contributions and
exchanges we have had. And whatever difficulties we have faced individually we would still
like to wish to appreciate the support we have had during all the discussions that have taken
place. We believe firmly that we shall have another AP, perhaps under better circumstances.
379. To the interpreters who have been so faithful throughout this period, we want to thank
you, and to all colleagues, even if you are not traveling, we still want to wish you journey
mercies. Thank you, Chair, and thank you, everybody, for having participated in AP-39.
380. The meeting was adjourned at 1230 Hours.