dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Sotsiaalministeerium
Väljaminev kiriAvalik

Report on unratified conventions

Sotsiaalministeerium · 30. aprill 2019
Viit
4.1-2/2712-2
Registreeritud
30. aprill 2019
Dokumendi liik
Väljaminev kiri
Adressaat
International Labour Office
Saabumis/saatmisviis
Outlook
Funktsioon
4.1 Tööturu, töösuhete ja töökeskkonna korraldamine
Sari
4.1-2 Rahvusvaheliste tööstandardite ja töötingimuste järelevalvega (ILO) seotud kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
4.1-2/2018
Vastutaja
Liis Tõnismaa (Sotsiaalministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Tööala asekantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Tööelu arengu osakond)

Failid

  • 📎Cover letter.pdf223 KB
  • 📎Estonia_Unratified Conventions ILO_29.04.2019.pdf559 KB

Sisu (failidest)

REPORT to be made no later than 28 February 2019, in accordance with article 19 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization by the Government of ESTONIA, on the position of national law and practice in regard to matters dealt with in the instruments referred to in the following questionnaire. REPORTS ON UNRATIFIED CONVENTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS (Article 19 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization) EMPLOYMENT POLICY CONVENTION, 1964 (No. 122) VOCATIONAL REHABILITATION AND EMPLOYMENT (DISABLED PERSONS) CONVENTION, 1983 (No. 159) HOME WORK CONVENTION, 1996 (No. 177) VOCATIONAL REHABILITATION AND EMPLOYMENT (DISABLED PERSONS) RECOMMENDATION, 1983 (No. 168) EMPLOYMENT POLICY (SUPPLEMENTARY PROVISIONS) RECOMMENDATION, 1984 (No. 169) HOME WORK RECOMMENDATION, 1996 (No. 184) EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIP RECOMMENDATION, 2006 (No. 198) TRANSITION FROM THE INFORMAL TO THE FORMAL ECONOMY RECOMMENDATION, 2015 (No. 204) 1 National policy for the promotion of full, productive and freely chosen employment 1. Please indicate whether an active national policy for the promotion of full, productive and freely chosen employment has been declared and pursued as a major goal. If so, please indicate the manner in which it was developed and determined. If such a policy has been declared and pursued, please specify whether and how the policy aims to ensure that: (a) there is work for all who are available and seeking work; (b) work is as productive as possible; and (c) there is free choice of employment and occupation for all. If the policy integrates one or all of these objectives, please provide information on the challenges identified and on how the measures taken, if any, support achievement of these objectives. National Reform Programme “Estonia 2020” approved by Government describes the objectives established to improve competitiveness and activities needed to achieve these objectives for 2015 - 2020. Estonia 2020 is updated annually by a government decision at the end of April. The first main objective of the programme is to increase the productivity and second one is to increase employment. Estonia's goal is to increase the labor force participation rate to 74% by 15-64 and by 75% by 2020. Despite increased unemployment in times of economic crisis, economic activity and participation rates have shown steady growth in recent years. As a positive trend, a part of the increase in unemployment is caused by the decrease of the inactive population and the beginning of the job search for people who have been away from the labor market. The objective is to take into account the predicted pace of the economic environment and the labor market recovery and the decline in labor resulting from demographic trends. The focus on the areas of education and employment and the main objectives are to integrate the long-term and young unemployed into the labor market and develop their skills. In 2017, the employment rate among the population aged 15-64 was 78,5%. This means that the targets of both 2015 and 2020 have been meet. In addition to the main objectives, the programme includes objectives that comprise the quality and availability of education and skilled labour supply and policies that supports the improvement of the long-term competitiveness of companies. While preparing “Estonia 2020”, the objectives and priority actions agreed between the European Union heads of government as well as European Commission recommendations to Estonia have been taken into account. "Estonia 2020" was approved on April 28, 2011. The "Estonia 2020" plan will be renewed by a government decision by the end of April each year, with an annual report on the achievement of the set goals, the reforms already carried out and the implementation of EU recommendations. In addition to the report, the update of the development plan is based on recent statistics and the main challenges specified at ministerial meetings. 2 The renewal and implementation of "Estonia 2020" is coordinated by the Interministerial Working Group on Competitiveness, established by the Secretary of State. In addition to the working group, all relevant partners including social partners are involved in the preparation of the plan. In addition to the National Reform Programme “Estonia 2020”, there are several sectoral development plans which are aimed at promoting employment, education, equal treatment and increasing productivity. For example: 1) The “Welfare Development Plan 2016–2023“. This plan focuses on the strategic objectives of labour market, social protection and equal treatment policies for 2016–2023. The Welfare Development Plan has two general objectives: high employment rate and a high-quality working life and reducing social inequalities, poverty, supporting gender equality. 2) The Lifelong Learning Strategy 2020. The objective of this strategy is to ensure that lifelong learning opportunities are matching to the needs of the labour market. The strategy foresees development of study and career services in order to increase the number of qualified professionals in different age groups and regions of Estonia. 3) The Youth Field Development Plan for 2014-2020. The main goal of this plan is to provide young people with a wide range of opportunities for development and self-fulfillment, including for learning and working, including to ensure labour market success for young people. 4) The Estonian Entrepreneurship Growth Strategy 2014-2020 focuses on encouraging entrepreneurship, increasing productivity and encouraging innovation. 5) The Regional development strategy for 2014-2020 focuses on the developmental needs of all of Estonia's regions and is investing more than previously in the improvement of work availability and services in areas which have been adversely affected by urbanization by emphasizing the strengths and unique aspects of each region. 6) The development plan “Integrating Estonia 2020” objective is of integration policy is to increase social cohesion and ensure the social inclusion of people with different linguistic and cultural backgrounds. 2. Please provide detailed information on any measures taken, particularly in the framework of the national employment policy, where one exists, to respond to the needs of all categories of persons who face difficulties in finding lasting employment, including, for example, women, young women and men, women and men with disabilities,1 older workers, the long-term unemployed, female and male migrant workers lawfully within the territory, and other disadvantaged groups, such as workers in the informal economy.2 1 In relation to Convention No. 159 and its Recommendation No. 168, the term “disabled persons” is replaced throughout this text by the term “persons with disabilities”, in accordance with changes in usage as reflected in ILO instruments such as in Paragraphs 1 and 13 of the HIV and AIDS Recommendation, 2010 (No. 200), Paragraph 5 of Recommendation No. 198, Paragraph 7(I) of Recommendation No. 204 and the comments of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations (CEACR). 2 2 When questions are made on the basis of provisions in Recommendation No. 169, which refers to the “informal sector”, this should be understood as relating to the “informal economy” within the meaning of Paragraph 2 of 3 The purpose of the Labour Market Services and Benefits Act is to achieve maximum possible employment rates among the working population, and to prevent their long-term unemployment and exclusion from the labour market through the provision of labour market services and payment of labour market benefits. Labour market services are provided based on the profession, work experience, needs and possibilities of the persons and on their right to freely choose work, on the needs and rights of employers to freely choose their labour force, and on the situation on the labour market. The provision of labour market services facilitates the engagement in and continuation of employment of the persons and must assist employers in finding suitable labour force. The Labour Market Services and Benefits Act also regulates the preparation of fixed-term employment programme based on the needs of the labour market. The general objective of the Employment Programme 2017-2020 is to prevent unemployment, to reduce the duration of unemployment, and to provide help in finding work to people for whom finding work is difficult due to long-term unemployment or other special impediments. The sub-objectives of the programme that help achieve the general objective are: 1) supporting persons under the threat of losing their jobs in moving from one job to another; 2) supporting career choices and job-seeking; 3) supporting employers in finding and employing suitable employees; 4) supporting the sustainability of start-up companies; 5) improving the skills and knowledge and increasing the qualification of persons; 6) elimination of impediments to employment; 7) increasing readiness for work; 8) reducing the negative impact of regional labor market crises. There are special measures for long-term unemployed, young people, older persons, disabled persons, and other persons, who have special obstacles for employment. Long-term unemployed persons have right to special services like coaching for working life, wage subsidy etc. To keep the older workers employed, there are measures for preventing unemployment, such as ensuring the sustainability of work ability, promoting supplemental and re-training etc. To encourage employment in the retirement age and to prevent dropping out of the labour market, labour market services are also be provided for jobseekers in retirement age. Work ability reform started in 2016. A new evaluation system for work ability will identify the person’s work ability and his/hers operating limitations. This will help to identify a suitable job, working conditions, and necessary services. According to the Labour Market Services and Benefits Act disabled persons have right to four special services (adaptation of premises and equipment, special aids and equipment, communication support at interviews, working with Recommendation No. 204, which provides that “the term ‘informal economy’: (a) refers to all economic activities by workers and economic units that are – in law or in practice – not covered or insufficiently covered by formal arrangements; and (b) does not cover illicit activities … as defined in the relevant international treaties”. 4 support person and occupational rehabilitation). Additionally there is wide range of labour market services for that target group (for example peer support, protected employment up to two years etc.). Also employers, who are prepared to employ or have already employed people with disabilities, but need knowledge and guidance to support, can get advice and training. These measures are provided under two programs - "The provision of labour market services to the work capacity reform target group" and "Increasing the work capacity of the work capacity reform target group and promoting their working". One of the goals of National Reform Programme “Estonia 2020” is to bring youth unemployment down to at least the pre-crisis level (10.1% in 2007). The provision of high quality education and youth work, measures to combat early school leaving, the acquisition of early work experience and the development of practical career studies and entrepreneurial learning are especially important, as these would consequently ensure that young people are better equipped to enter the labour market. There are additional measures specifically aimed at the young generation, such as the support programme “Youth Prop Up Programme” and the labour market measure „My first job“, both offered within the framework of Estonian Youth Guarantee scheme. Labour market measure „My first job“ was introduced in 2015 and the service is offered to young people aged 16- 29, who have obtained primary, basic or general secondary education or professional education and who lack or have little work experience. A wage subsidy is granted to an employer up to 12 months and the employer must enter into an employment contract with a young person for an unspecified term or for a specified term of at least one year. Training compensation to employers is also granted and costs can be reimbursed up to 2500 euros. In order to prevent school dropouts, there is a plan to increase the number of support professionals in local governments. In May 2018 Youth Guarantee Support System was introduced, with an objective to significantly improve the outreach and identification of NEETs in municipalities and better integrate them into the labour market. Regarding the people with migration background Estonian language courses are available for those with insufficient Estonian skills. Until May 2017 Estonian language courses provided by the Estonian Unemployment Insurance Fund (EUIF) were limited to registered unemployed. Since May 2017 additional options to learn Estonian language were introduced including employees whose Estonian language skills are insufficient for occupational development. There are now two new possibilities for Estonian language learning: 1) employees whose yearly income is under certain limit can use a training voucher for Estonian language courses; 2) employers who want to increase their employees’ Estonian language proficiency can have the cost reimbursed by EUIF. In 2017 new package of services - My First Job in Estonia - was introduced to the recipients of international protection. The aim of the service package is to boost the employment among recipients of international protection and to contribute to their integration into Estonian society. As part of the service, employers can apply for a wage subsidy for recruiting a recipient of international protection an also receive compensation of the cost of obtaining qualifications, Estonian language training, work-related translation services and professional mentoring. Employment rate, % 5 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Total (20-64) 74,0 76,2 76,3 78,5 79,2 Males 77,6 79,9 80,1 81,9 82,9 Females 70,5 72,5 72,5 75,1 75,6 Total (15-24) 32,6 35,7 36,7 39,7 41,2 Males 32,1 38,1 37,3 41,2 42,4 Females 33,2 33,1 36,0 38,1 39,9 Total (55-64) 64,0 64,5 65,1 67,9 68,7 Males 65,1 63,1 63,5 66,3 65,5 Females 63,0 65,6 66,4 69,2 71,3 Source: Statistics Estonia, Labour Force Survey Unemployment rate, % 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Total (15-74) 7,4 6,2 6,8 5,8 5,4 Males 7,9 6,2 7,4 6,2 5,4 Females 6,8 6,1 6,1 5,3 5,3 Total (15-24) 15,0 13,1 13,4 12,1 11,8 Males 19,3 13,8 15,8 13,9 12,3 Females 10,0 12,2 10,6 10,0 11,4 Total (55-64) 5,4 6,0 8,1 5,7 5,4 Males 5,8 6,9 9,5 7,5 7,0 Females 5,1 5,4 6,9 4,3 4,2 Source: Statistics Estonia, Labour Force Survey Long-term unemployment rate, % 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Total (15-74) 3,3 2,4 2,1 1,9 1,3 Males 3,9 2,5 2,4 2,2 1,5 Females 2,7 2,2 1,8 1,6 1,2 Source: Statistics Estonia, Labour Force Survey 3. Are the national employment policy and related plans and programmes developed, reviewed and revised in the framework of a coordinated economic and social policy? If so, please explain. Policies and related plans and programmes are reviewed and revised periodically. See also comments to article 1 (policies, strategies etc. are set up for certain period). There is a system of regular assessments of the impacts. If necessary, policies and measure conditions are updated. 6 4. Please describe employment promotion programmes or other steps taken, if any, particularly those established within the framework of a national employment policy. The answer is given in article 2. 5. Please specify whether and to what extent the national employment policy takes account of the importance of small undertakings (including small traditional undertakings, cooperatives and associations, and micro-, small and medium-sized enterprises) as providers of jobs and their contribution to economic growth. In Estonia 99% of all enterprises are small and medium-sized enterprises. Policies support starting a business, developing and increasing the efficiency of companies, internationalisation, innovation, and cooperation. Subsidisation policy supports the implementation of companies’ ambitions for growth as well as making the processes more effective (counselling services and training for setting targets are provided etc). Measures aimed at supporting export and developing cooperation for entrepreneurs heading to international markets will be continued. The Green Paper on Estonia’s industrial policies and the infomation and communication technologies (ICT) sector development programme will facilitate digital revolution in the industrial sector. 6. Please provide information on any measures taken to encourage enterprises, including multinational enterprises, to promote the national employment policy, where one exists. Foreign investors have equal rights and obligations with local entrepreneurs. All foreign investors may establish a company and conduct business in Estonia in the same way as local investors. Estonia has a favourable corporate tax regime, which provides for numerous opportunities to use Estonia as a location for holding, financing or trading activities by multinational companies. Estonia has strategy of entrepreneurship growth. The general goal of The Estonian Entrepreneurship Growth Strategy 2014-2020 is to facilitate the achievement of the umbrella objectives within the competitiveness plan "Estonia 2020" to enhance productivity and employment. The plan seeks to reach the goal where Estonian entrepreneurs earn greater income through products and services with higher value added. To that end, entrepreneurial and innovation policy should be dealt within a single strategic framework that ensures the coherence between the policies that have, so far, stood apart at the strategic planning level, and by that ensure better performance. The strategy comprises five components: vision, goals, focal points, objectives and management. For specific level it is possible to apply for the the business start-up subsidy which is financial aid, the objective of which is to provide motivation and support in starting a business.This subsidy can be applied for from the Unemployment Insurance Fund by an unemployed person or a non- working person of retirement age registered as a jobseeker. Enterprise Estonia also offers financial assistance, counselling, cooperation opportunities and training for entrepreneurs, research institutions, the public and non-profit sectors. 7. Please indicate whether any measures have been taken or are envisaged to facilitate the re- employment of workers who have lost their jobs due to structural and technological changes. If so, please explain. 7 In 2017, new package of labour market measures aimed at preventing unemployment and contributing to structural change of economy was made available. The package includes training measures for employed persons (training vouchers and support for formal studies) and employers adapting to changes or recruiting in sectors facing labour shortages. National policy and protection for workers in an employment relationship 8. Is there a national policy that provides for the review at appropriate intervals of relevant laws and regulations with a view to ensuring effective protection for workers in an employment relationship? If so, please indicate whether and how the scope of relevant laws and regulations has been clarified or adapted, if necessary, as a result of the review. The Welfare Development Plan focuses on the strategic objectives of labour market, social protection, gender equality, and equal treatment policies for 2016-2023. The Development Plan provides a thorough overview of the main objectives, courses of action and problems regarding those policies. The Welfare Development Plan does not provide the review at appropriate intervals of relevant laws. However it gives the overview what are the aims of the state in that field. The Plan brings out that high-quality employment relationships are built on the fact that participants in working life know each other’s rights and obligations, and know how to apply them. In order to reduce the barriers for entering the labour market and to support participation in employment, the awareness of employers must be increased in collaboration with interest groups. Additionally, prejudicial attitudes towards different target groups (for example, the elderly, Estonian residents whose native language is not Estonian, and people with a decreased work ability) have to be reduced. To do so, the employers’ willingness and skills to manage diversity and consideration towards the principles of equal treatment in an organisation shall be increased. Additionally, investments must be made in shaping the conscious behaviour of the participants in working life, and in their adaption to changing working conditions. To do so, the capacity of working life participants must be increased for the implementation of rules for employment relationships and the working environment, including for coping with new working environment risks, and for the prevention of the employee’s loss of ability to work. This way, a sustainable and balanced working life that considers the interests of both parties shall be achieved. The Plan brings out that in order to establish a set of rules for trustworthy employment that meets the requirements of the labour market and economy, the principles of employee protection and competitiveness must be integrated into using different forms and conditions of work. To do so, the patterns of employment and the regulatory system for working conditions (including working time and rest period) must be reviewed. It is necessary to analyse the need for using flexible forms of employment and employment contracts, their obstacles and impact on labour market behaviour in conjunction with income security while the person is employed, during a temporary interruption, or termination of employment. In order to encourage part-time employment, it is important, among other things, to analyse the impact of the abolition of the minimum social tax on the use of part- time employment and labour market behaviour. 8 Overall in addition to the Welfare Development Plan there is on-going process of reviewing existing labour law in Ministry of Social Affairs and analysing new forms of work and how to implement them in Estonia. That includes transposition of new EU directives concerning employment relations. The Welfare Development Plan in English is available here: https://www.sm.ee/sites/default/files/content- editors/eesmargid_ja_tegevused/welfare_development_plan_2016-2023.pdf 9. Does the national policy provide guidance to employers and workers on effectively establishing the existence of an employment relationship and on the distinction between employed and self- employed workers? If so, please explain. Estonian Employment Contracts Act (ECA) provides guidance on distinction between employed and self-employed workers. According to ECA (§ 1) if a natural person does work for another person (employer) in subordination and under control of the employer, it is presumed to be an employment contract. The employer pays to the employee remuneration for such work. The provisions concerning employment contract shall not be applied to a contract where the person obligated to perform the work is to a significant extent independent in choosing the manner, time and place of performance of the work (self-employed workers). The provisions concerning employment contract shall also not be applied to the contract of a member of the directing body of a legal person or a director of a foreign company. Commercial Code (CC) regulates self-employed workers or sole proprietors. According to the CC any natural person may be a sole proprietor (CC § 3). Law of Obligations Act (LOA) regulates authorisation agreement. By an authorisation agreement, one person (the mandatary) undertakes to provide services to another person (the mandator) pursuant to an agreement (to perform the mandate) and the mandator undertakes to pay remuneration to the mandatary therefor if so agreed. LOA also defines and regulates the contract for services (§ 635). By a contract for services, one person (the contractor) undertakes to manufacture or modify a thing or to achieve any other agreed result by providing a service (work), and the other person (the customer) undertakes to pay remuneration therefor. The ECA is available in English here: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/520062016003/consolide The CC is available in English here: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/519122017001/consolide The LOA is available in English here: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/507032019001/consolide 10. Does the abovementioned policy address disguised employment relationships? If so, does it provide for measures to combat such practices and remove incentives that may exist to disguise an employment relationship, for example, in the context of contractual arrangements that may hide the true legal status of the parties? If so, please explain. 9 In general ECA § 1 (sections 1 and 2) highlight the main criteria’s of an employment contract. According to ECA (§ 1) if a natural person does work for another person (employer) in subordination and under the control of the employer, it is presumed to be an employment contract. The employer pays to the employee remuneration for such work. Litigation practice complements how to assess whether it is an employment contract or some other form of contract. In the case of disguised employment relationship the Labour Inspectorate and the court have the right to assess, if necessary, the characteristics of the legal relationship between the person who carries out the work and the person who permits employment during the performance. In general addressing disguised employment relationships and undeclared work is the focus of two main institutions in Estonia: the Estonian Labour Inspectorate, and the Estonian Tax and Customs Board. The former focuses on making employment rights effective, including tackling undeclared work; the latter is responsible for collecting tax revenues. Both the authorities carry out different policy measures tackle undeclared work, including increasing commitment via awareness-raising and information campaigns to inform workers about the risks, and deterrence approaches that detect and punish non-compliance. Since 2017 a bigger effort by campaigns is directed on encouraging people and businesses to work legitimately or to help those already participating in undeclared work to legitimise their activities. Here are some measures to tackle undeclared work: Enabling compliance - fostering commitment via awareness rising. The Estonian Tax and Customs Board have launched a campaign website3 to inform workers and employers about ‘envelope wages’ and undeclared work. The key message is that these practices are illegal, introduce unhealthy competition and paralyse Estonia's development and the good functioning of society as a whole. In regard to information sharing, the website includes a calculator that estimates loss of income in cases of social risks like unemployment, parental leave, and sickness absence. Also, there are complementary channels of communication, including radio, to raise the awareness. Deterrence - improving detection. Since 1 July 2014, employers are obliged to register their employees in the employment register, which gathers information about employments. All businesses that provide work are required to register the persons employed by them in the register irrespective of the form or the length of the contract. In addition, data on people working on a voluntary basis must also be recorded in the employment register. Hence, all people doing some kind of work must be registered. The employment must be registered latest at the moment the employee starts working in order to avoid the ‘first day of employment’ excuses. The termination of employment must be registered within 10 calendar days. Registration is possible via The Board’s website, via personnel management programmes of a company or agency or by visiting the bureau of the Estonian Tax and Customs Board in person. It is also possible to use a simplified procedure for first registration by telephone or text message, although it must be supplemented within seven calendar days to be complete. If the employer does not register the start or the end of employment as required, the tax authority may claim penalty payment of maximum EUR 3 200. 3 See internet: http://www2.emta.ee/palk/ 10 Both the Labour Inspectorate and the Tax and Customs Board have carried out targeted control of enterprises for tax avoidance and undeclared work. The activities include inspection visits to company and work sites as well as notification letters. The objective is to prevent the infringement of tax laws and raise law-abiding behaviour among tax payers, thus instead of burdening employers and administrators with offence procedures in the first instance they are given the opportunity to revise their business activities and change them in accordance to the law. In these letters, the companies are asked to revise their accounting and tax related information and give feedback to the tax authority on the results of their business activities. The notification letters give companies a certain time to improve their tax behaviour. In those companies who do not improve their tax behaviour or cannot give satisfactory reasons to the results of their business activities, a control of tax payments and accounting are initiated. In the competence of the Labour Inspectorate is to find out whether employees have been notified of working conditions in writing (i.e amount of salary, taxes, description of duties, working time etc.) if not, the inspector has a right to make an injunction or start a misdemeanour proceedings. If the inspector suspects that the employer has not paid taxes on behalf of the employee or have not registered his/her employees, the inspector provides that information to Tax and Customs Board. 11. Please indicate the manner in which dependency is treated in law and practice in distinguishing between the status of workers as employed or self-employed. As indicated in question 9, the ECA and CC (Commercial Code) provides statuses of workers who are employed and self-employed. 12. Please indicate whether and how the national law and practice guarantees all workers effective protections, regardless of the type of contractual arrangement under which they are working? All employees working under employment contract are covered by the scope of the ECA. This includes employment contracts for specified term, part-time work or work, that also require on-call work and temporary agency work. According to ECA (§ 1) if a natural person does work for another person (employer) in subordination and under the control of the employer, it is presumed to be an employment contract. All contracts for services are regulated by Law of Obligations Act (LOA). LOA § 635 regulates and defines the contract for services - by a contract for services, one person (the contractor) undertakes to manufacture or modify a thing or to achieve any other agreed result by providing a service (work), and the other person (the customer) undertakes to pay remuneration therefor. Also, Working Conditions of Employees Posted to Estonia Act1 is in force and the objective of the Act is to ensure the protection of the rights of employees from a Member State of the European Union, a Member State of the European Economic Area or the Swiss Confederation who have been posted to Estonia for the provision of services, and fair competition between employers engaged in the provision of services. 11 The Labour Inspectorate carries out supervision on employment relationships. An employee or employer can choose whether they turn to court or to labour dispute committee (a labour dispute committee is an extrajudicial authority within the Labour Inspectorate). Since parties of the service contracts are equal, there is no subordination relationship between them, no supervision by the state is carried out. In case of dispute, parties have always the right to turn to court. The LOA in English is available here: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/508082018001/consolide The Working Conditions of Employees Posted to Estonia Act1 in English is available here: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/502072018002/consolide Determination of the existence of an employment relationship 13. Please indicate whether and how the national law, regulations or court decisions define: (a) employer; (b) self-employed person; and (c) employee/employed worker. (a)(c) The ECA gives the concept of the definition of employer. According to ECA if a natural person (employee) does work for another person in subordination to the management and control of the other person, then the person is the employer. The employer is also recognized by the fact that the employer pays to the employee remuneration for work. If a person does work for another person which, under the circumstances, can be expected to be done only for remuneration, it is presumed to be an employment contract. (b) Self-employed workers or sole proprietors are regulated by Commercial Code (CC). According to the CC any natural person may be a sole proprietor (CC § 3). A sole proprietor is obliged to submit a petition for his or her entry in the commercial register before the commencement of the activity. Law of Obligations Act (LOA) regulates authorisation agreement. By an authorisation agreement, one person (the mandatary) undertakes to provide services to another person (the mandator) pursuant to an agreement (to perform the mandate) and the mandator undertakes to pay remuneration to the mandatary therefor if so agreed. LOA also defines and regulates the contract for services (§ 635). By a contract for services, one person (the contractor) undertakes to manufacture or modify a thing or to achieve any other agreed result by providing a service (work), and the other person (the customer) undertakes to pay remuneration therefor. 14. Are specific criteria or indicators established by national law, regulation, court decisions or other competent bodies for the purpose of determining the existence of an employment relationship? If so, please explain. The ECA sets out criterias - in general on the basis of an employment contract a natural person (employee) does work for another person (employer) in subordination to the management and 12 control of the employer. The employer pays to the employee remuneration for such work. If a person does work for another person which, under the circumstances, can be expected to be done only for remuneration, it is presumed to be an employment contract. The practice from labour dispute committee’s and court helps to complement that. In several of its rulings, the Supreme Court has highlighted the starting points for the distinction between employment contracts. If there is a need to assess whether it is a contract of employment or another type of contract, the following questions might be used to assess if the relationship might be regulated by the employment contract:  who organizes and manages the work process?  who determines the time, place and method of doing the job?  who bears the risk of working?  who receives income or profit?  are the rules of work organization applicable to the employee applicable to the person performing the work? 15. Is there provision for a legal presumption that an employment relationship exists where one or more relevant indicators are present? If so, please explain. The legal presumption is that if a person does work for another person which, under the circumstances, can be expected to be done only for remuneration, it is presumed to be an employment contract (ECA § 1 section 2). 16. Please indicate whether measures have been taken or are envisaged to ensure that a national policy for the protection of workers in an employment relationship, where it exists, does not interfere with true civil or commercial relationships while ensuring that individuals in an employment relationship have the protection they are due. In general ECA § 1 (sections 1 and 2) highlight the main criteria’s of an employment contract. According to ECA (§ 1) if a natural person does work for another person (employer) in subordination and under the control of the employer, it is presumed to be an employment contract. The employer pays to the employee remuneration for such work. Litigation practice complements how to assess whether it is an employment contract or some other form of contract. In the case of disguised employment relationship the Labour Inspectorate and the court have the right to assess, if necessary, the characteristics of the legal relationship between the person who carries out the work and the person who permits employment during the performance. When the characteristics of the legal relationship do not comply with the ECA § 1, it is genuine service contract. Parties of the service contracts are equal, there is no subordination relationship between them and no supervision by the state is carried out. In case of dispute, parties have always the right to turn to court. 17. Please provide information on any measures taken or envisaged to ensure that workers and employers have access to appropriate, speedy, inexpensive, fair and efficient procedures and mechanisms to settle disputes concerning the existence and terms of an employment relationship. 13 New Labour Dispute Resolution Act was updated from 1st of January 2018. The amendments that were made, focused on the modernization of labour dispute committes. Overall the Act governs the establishment and the rules of procedure of labour dispute committees and the procedure for the resolution of a labour dispute. An employee or employer can choose whether they turn to court or to labour dispute committee. Filing an application to labour dispute committee is free of state fee. A labour dispute committee is an extrajudicial authority within the Labour Inspectorate. A labour dispute committee is independent and base its decisions on laws and other legislation, international agreements binding on Estonia and other regulations that govern employment relationships, including collective agreements and employment contracts. Each party to the labor dispute settlement proceedings shall bear its own procedural expenses. An application submitted to a labor dispute committee shall be reviewed within 45 calendar days as of the receipt thereof in the labor dispute committee, unless the prolongation of the proceedings results from objective circumstances or the provisions of the Labor Dispute Resolution Act. Labour Dispute Resolution Act in English is available here: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/506022018004/consolide. Estonia has a three-level court system. County courts and administrative courts adjudicate matters in the first instance. Appeals against decisions of courts of first instance shall be heard by courts of second instance. Courts of appeal are courts of second instance (sometimes also called circuit courts or district courts). A statement of claim is filed with the court of first instance, an appeal with the court of second instance and an appeal in cassation with the court of third or the highest instance. A matter shall be heard in the Supreme Court only after all previous court instances have been passed. The filing of an appeal is governed by respective codes of court procedure. A state fee is not charged for the following acts: hearing of an action or appeal concerning remuneration or wages, ascertainment of invalidity of cancellation of a contract of employment, reinstatement in service, or amendment of the written legal basis for release from service. A statement of claim submitted to the court shall be reviewed approximately within 100-200 days.4 18. Please provide information regarding any mechanism established or already in existence, if any, for monitoring developments in the labour market and the organization of work, as well as for formulating advice on the adoption and implementation of measures concerning the employment relationship in the framework of a national policy, where it exists. In the event that such mechanisms exist, please also indicate whether and how the most representative organizations of employers and workers are represented therein. The occupational barometer is a qualitative method of forecasting short-term labour demand by occupation, which is operated by the Estonian Unemployment Insurance Fund. 4 https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/justice_scoreboard_2019_en.pdf 14 The estimates are compiled by the regional departments of the Estonian Unemployment Insurance Fund, which involve external experts wherever possible. Labour demand forecasts look at two indicators. Firstly, an evaluation is made of how employers' demand for labour force will change in the next 12 months, and especially how employers' demand for specific occupations will change. Will it increase, decrease or remain unchanged? Secondly, the balance between labour supply and demand after the next 12 months is evaluated: what will the ratio be between the existing labour force on the labour market and employers' demand by occupation? Will there be a labour surplus, labour shortage or a balance in occupations on the labour market? The barometer evaluates general trends on the labour market, which means that the barometer does not take seasonality into account. The Working Life Survey (TEU) is a nationwide survey of labor relations and, more broadly, of working life. The aim of the study is to collect information on working and working time arrangements, occupational health, remuneration, employee development, inclusion and collective employment in Estonia, to assess all factors affecting it and to compare the changes that have taken place over time. The study addresses these issues by interviewing the manager / representative of the company / institution as well as the employees. The study is organized so that the employee and the head of the company / institution know the answers to different questions. For example, a manager may not know whether an employee belongs to a trade union, but the employee may not know how many employees of the company / institution work with an indefinite contract. Employee and company / institution manager estimates may also differ in terms of working life and strength or weakness in employment relationships as their expectations and role in the company / institution are different. For example, employee satisfaction with the employment relationship may differ from that of the manager of the company / institution. Collecting data on both sides of the work relationship will help you get a more complete picture of working life and relationships. Such data collection enables statistics on companies / institutions and employees. 19. Is there a specific national mechanism to ensure that employment relationships can be effectively identified in the framework of the transnational provision of services? If so, has consideration been given to developing systematic contact and exchange of information on the subject with other States? For this, within European Union the European Commission has an Internal Market System (IMI). The Estonian Labour Inspectorate uses it on a daily basis to respond to cross-border inquiries from other countries and to send inquiries itself. With a view to mediating the data collected in the supervision of companies providing cross-border services. For aliens who are coming outside the European Union, the employment must be registered with the Police and Border Guard Board (only an alien who is legally staying temporarily in Estonia, for example, on the basis of a visa or visa waiver, may work in Estonia for a short period of time. 15 Persons with disabilities 20. Please specify whether there is a legal definition of persons with a disability. If so, please describe. The Social Benefits for Disabled Persons Act defines disability as a loss of or an abnormality in an anatomical, physiological or mental structure or function of a person which in conjunction with different relational and environmental restrictions prevents participation in social life on equal bases with the others. The purpose of that Act is to support the ability of disabled persons to cope independently, social integration and equal opportunities and to promote studies and work through partial compensation for the additional expenses caused by the disability. The Labour Market Services and Benefits Act defines a disabled unemployed person as an unemployed person who has a disability within the meaning of Social Benefits for Disabled Persons Act or who has been declared permanently incapacitated for work on the basis of the State Pension Insurance Act or who has been established to have partial or no work ability on the basis of the Work Ability Allowance Act. 21. Please indicate whether there is a national policy for the employment of persons with disabilities. If so, please describe and indicate its scope of application. Does the policy promote employment opportunities for persons with disabilities in the open labour market? The work ability reform (incl. creating a system for assessing work ability, the provision of services to the target group, and providing grants) started in 2016. Labour market services are provided under the Labour Market Services Act and two programs - "The provision of labour market services to the work capacity reform target group" and "Increasing the work capacity of the work capacity reform target group and promoting their working". Employment opportunities for persons with disabilities in the open labour market are promoted by subsidies for employers, like wage subsidy, compensation of employee’s training costs and social tax compensation. 22. Does the national policy, if it exists, contain provisions to ensure that appropriate vocational rehabilitation measures are made available to all categories of women and men with disabilities? If so, please describe whether and how vocational guidance, training, placement, employment and related services are made available to persons with disabilities to assist them in securing, retaining and advancing in employment. Please also indicate if and how adjustments to such existing services for workers are available to enable persons with disabilities to access them. There are vocational rehabilitation measures for all categories of women and men with disabilities. People who are working or looking for work are entitled to occupational rehabilitation under the Labour Market Services and Benefits Act. Occupational rehabilitation is a labour market service provided to a person for preparation for working life and commencement or continuation of employment, which involves rehabilitation activities. 16 People who are not working are entitled to social rehabilitation under the Social Welfare Act. The social rehabilitation service is a set of rehabilitation services provided on the basis of an activity plan, rehabilitation plan or rehabilitation programme. Social rehabilitation purpose is to: 1) increase motivation and readiness for participation in the activities of the community in accordance with the person's abilities, develop cognitive and physical abilities and teach and develop everyday skills as a result of which the person is living as independently as possible; 2) offer support necessary in the study process as a result of which the person acquires education in accordance with his or her abilities or additional skills necessary for work; 3) increase self-awareness, develop self-regulation, communication and co-operation skills as a result of which the person participates in social life in accordance to his or her abilities; 4) develop the readiness of the person to commence employment in accordance with his or her abilities. Persons with disabilities are entitled to wide range of other labour market services like vocational guidance, training, placement, employment etc. The Unemployment Insurance Fund provides career services to all people and the service is free for all. Also placement service is available to unemployed, employed persons and other job seekers. Labour market training is offered to unemployed persons and to employed persons with a disability in order to eliminate disability-related hindrances of commencing work or working. Estonian Chamber of Disabled People and other representative organisations of disabled people are involved in policymaking; the Ministry and Estonian Unemployment Insurance Fund (EUIF) are conducting the informative campaigns about changes in work ability assessment and services. Persons with disabilities are entitled to labour market services (training, placement, employment and other related services). The EUIF provides career services to all people and the service is complimentary for all. In addition, placement service is available to unemployed, employed and other job seekers. Unemployed persons and employed persons with a disability are entitled to labour market training in order to eliminate disability-related hindrances of commencing work or working. People with disabilities can also participate in sheltered employment, have assistance at job interviews or support person at work, get-commuting benefits. When participating in services disabled person can have the assistance if needed – f.e. sign language translator. 23. Is the national policy for the vocational rehabilitation and employment of persons with disabilities based on the principle of equality of opportunity and treatment in employment and occupation? If so, please explain if and how the policy ensures respect for equality of opportunity and treatment for workers with disabilities, particularly in relation to vocational rehabilitation and employment assistance. There are vocational rehabilitation measures for all categories of women and men with disabilities. People who are working or looking for work are entitled to vocational rehabilitation under the Labour Market Services and Benefits Act. Vocational rehabilitation is a labour market service 17 provided to a person for preparation for working life and commencement or continuation of employment, which involves rehabilitation activities. People who are not working are entitled to social rehabilitation under the Social Welfare Act. The social rehabilitation service is a set of rehabilitation services provided on the basis of an activity plan, rehabilitation plan or rehabilitation programme. 24. Please provide information on whether and, if so, how, measures have been taken or are envisaged to promote the establishment and development of vocational guidance, rehabilitation and employment services for women and men with disabilities in rural areas and remote communities. Career services that are high quality and take into account the needs of the labour market contribute to enhance the quality of employment offers. The Unemployment Insurance Fund provides career services to all people and the service is free for all. Every department of the EUIF offers career services face to face or via e-mail and Skype. Career counselling for people who are inactive on labour market and counsellors training is co-financed by the European Social Fund. 25. Please indicate whether and, if so, how it is aimed to ensure that there is training and availability of suitably qualified staff for the provision of vocational guidance, training, placement and employment of persons with disabilities. In order to ensure the necessary number of doctors and assess work ability for the Unemployment Insurance Fund, new expert doctors will be trained in work ability assessment method. To improve the knowledge of the target group and support them in the process of work ability assessment, cooperation in the provision of counselling service is organised with the Estonian Chamber of Disabled People. Information dissemination is continued to improve the knowledge about the new work ability system. In 2020, a summary analysis of the implementation of the measures of the new work ability support system will be prepared and it will be the basis for the preparation of the operational plan for further implementation of the measures. Homeworkers 26. Does your national legislation contain a definition of “employee” and “employer” in the context of homework? If so, please explain. The ECA does not contain a definition of “employee” and “employer” in the context of home work. Homeworkers are treated like ordinary employees and they are covered by the protection of the ECA. ECA paragraph 6 subsection 4 states that if an employer and employee can agree that the employee does work, which is usually done in the employer’s enterprise, outside the place of performance of the work, including at the employee’s place of residence (teleworking). 18 27. Please indicate whether there is national legislation or policy affecting the situation of homeworkers and, if so, specify its scope and whether it is periodically reviewed. Please indicate whether the national legislation also applies to homeworkers working in the “gig economy”. There is neither national policy nor legislation, which would directly concern the homeworkers. Depending on which features of the contract the relationship has, either ECA, LOA or CC applies. 28. Please provide information on any measures taken or envisaged to ensure equality of treatment between homeworkers and other workers, particularly in relation to: (a) homeworkers’ right to establish or join organizations of their own choosing and to participate in the activities of such organizations; (b) protection against discrimination in employment and occupation; (c) protection in the field of occupational safety and health; (d) remuneration; (e) statutory social security protection; (f) minimum age for admission to employment or work; (g) access to training; and (h) maternity protection. Homeworkers are treated like ordinary employees and they are covered by the protection of the ECA. According to the ECA an employer shall ensure the protection of employees against discrimination, follow the principle of equal treatment and promote equality in accordance with the Equal Treatment Act and Gender Equality Act. All employees have the right to establish or join organizations of their own choosing. The ECA also provides protection concerning the remuneration, statutory social security, minimum age for admission to employment, training and maternity protection. The Occupational Health and Safety Act cover all employees. Occupational Health and Safety Act in English is available https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/526062018002/consolide 29. Please indicate whether any measures have been adopted or are envisaged to encourage collective bargaining as a means of determining the terms and conditions of home work. If so, please describe. In 2017 the Trade unions and the employers signed an agreement on teleworking. There are ten recommendations in the agreement, which favour teleworking. In 2018, The Ministry of Finance and the Union of State and Local Government Employees' Trade Unions signed an agreement favoring teleworking, which helps to modernize work organization and increase labor choice. Teleworking is deemed to be work outside the usual place of work under the agreement. Teleworking provides an opportunity to apply for public service in rural areas. Therefore it is also easier to balance work and family life when doing teleworking because work can be done either at home or near home. 30. Is the use of intermediaries in home work permitted under national law and practice? If so, please indicate whether and how the respective responsibilities of employers and intermediaries are determined and allocated. Please also indicate whether the intermediary and the employer are jointly and severally liable for payment of the remuneration due to homeworkers. 19 National law does not define and contain the definition of “intermediary”. However the Labour Market Services and Benefits Act regulates job mediation- which is a job-seeking job for the job seeker. According to the Labour Market Services and Benefits Act the employee is not allowed to charge a person who has applied for a job to pay for his / her job and the data of the employer. 31. Is the registration of employers of homeworkers and of intermediaries required under national law? If so, please explain. Homeworkers are treated like ordinary employees and they are covered by the protection of the ECA. If a person does work for another person which, under the circumstances, can be expected to be done only for remuneration, it is presumed to be an employment contract and should be registered according to the Taxation Act. Taxation Act defines that a person who permits employment is required to register in the employment register the information concerning the commencement, suspension, termination and the type of employment of the persons and other work related to the work. Private legal person and sole proprietor providing employment mediation (employment broker) must submit an economic activity report to the register of economic activities before commencing business. 32. Are there provisions in place to ensure that homeworkers are informed of their terms and conditions of work in writing and/or in an accessible format, as well as a requirement that employers keep records? If so, please explain. ECA subsection 5 sets out notification of employee of working conditions. According to the section a written document of an employment contract shall contain several data- the name, the agreed remuneration, the time when the employee performs the agreed duties (working time), the place of performance of work etc. The employer shall preserve the written employment contract during the term of validity of the employment contract and for ten years after the expiry of the employment contract (ECA § 5 subsection 5). 34. Please indicate whether and, if so, how the remuneration of piece-rate homeworkers is regulated in your country. All the employees are covered by the ECA. An employer is, above all, obligated to pay wages for work under the conditions and at the time agreed on (ECA § 28 (2 p 2)). The amount of the wages is regulated by § 29 (ECA) - if a person does work which, considering the circumstances, can be expected to be done for remuneration, it is presumed that wages have been agreed on (§ 29 (1)). If the amount of wages payable to an employee under a contract has not been agreed on or if the agreement cannot be proven, the amount of the wages is the remuneration specified in a collective agreement or, upon absence of a collective agreement, the remuneration usually paid for similar work under similar circumstances (§ 29 (2)).The Government of the Republic shall establish by a regulation the minimum wage corresponding to a specific unit of time (§ 28 (5)) (the minimum wage is set every year by the government according to the agreement between the employers and trade unions). 20 35.Please specify the measures adopted or envisaged, if any, to ensure that a deadline to complete a work assignment does not deprive a homeworker of the possibility to have periods of daily and weekly rest comparable to those enjoyed by other workers. In addition, please provide information regarding the conditions, if any, under which homeworkers benefit, in the same manner as other workers, from paid public holidays, annual paid leave and paid sick leave. There are no special measures adopted on the subject. All the employees are covered by the ECA and the ECA provides protection concerning the paid public holidays. According to the ECA § 51, an agreement by which an employee is left over a period of 24 hours with less than 11 hours of consecutive rest time is void, unless otherwise provided by law. In case of minors, daily rest periods are different (ECA § 51 (2)). According to the ECA § 52, an agreement by which an employee is left over a period of seven days with less than 48 hours of consecutive rest time is void, unless otherwise provided by law. An agreement by which, in the case of calculation of the summarised working time, an employee is left over a period of seven days with less than 36 hours of consecutive rest time is void, unless otherwise provided by law. According to the ECA § 52, it is presumed that the weekly rest time is granted on Saturday and Sunday. 36.Please indicate whether and, if so, how provision is made for a system of labour inspection to ensure compliance with laws and regulations concerning home work, including whether the system provides for access to the home or to other private premises where home work is performed. Please also provide information on any remedies, including penalties where appropriate, if any, applied in the event of violation of relevant laws and regulations. Estonian Labour Inspectorate exercises state supervision over employment relations/contracts including homeworking/teleworking. The exemption is that the Labour Inspectorate is not allowed to enter someones private premises withaout owners permission.. For example Estonian Occupational Health and Safety Act § 12 section 1 states that an employer shall ensure the conformity with occupational health and safety requirements in every work-related situation. Thus the employer is also responsible for ensuring safe and healthy working environment in case of homeworking/teleworking. Estonian Occupational Health and safety Act is available in English https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/ee/Riigikogu/act/530122016003/consolide ) The circumstances of an occupational accident and reasons therefor shall be established in the course of an investigation which is carried out by the employer and by a working environment representative or, in his or her absence, an employees’ trustee shall participate with the right to vote. If the employer lacks necessary knowledge, the employer shall involve a competent expert to the investigation. 21 An employer is responsible for investigating all occupational accidents (incl. accidents that happen in case of homeworking/teleworking). In our legislation, there are no exceptions in this case for homeworking/teleworking. Same remedies from ECA and from Estonian Occupational Health and Safety Act apply. For example if there is a violation of occupational health and safety requirements established for workplace and if it involved a threat to the health or life of an employee the that is punishable by a fine of up to 300 fine units (§ 271 Estonian Occupational Health and Safety Act). The same act, if committed by a legal person, is punishable by a fine of up to 32,000 euros. Transition from the informal to the formal economy 37.Please describe any measures taken or envisaged to enable the progressive transition from the informal economy to the formal economy of: (a) women and men workers; and (b) enterprises. In Estonia starting a business is relatively easy. Everything concerning the registration of a business can be done online. The private limited company (osaühing or OÜ in Estonian) is the most common form of business in Estonia. The advantages of the private limited company is: •simple and quick registration; •a relatively low share capital requirement (2500 euros); •shareholders have no personal proprietary liability for the private limited company’s obligations. The private limited company can be established without contributing the share capital if the proposed area of activity does not require capital investments. The share capital of such a company will be formed by the liabilities of the founders amounting to the sum they promised to provide as share capital contribution. For more information please see https://www.eesti.ee/en/life-events/i-would-like-to-establish-a- company. Under the Simplified Business Taxation Act, from 2018 the individual micro-entrepreneur is entitled to open a separate bank account in the credit institution to which customers will make payments for the services rendered or goods sold. In practice, the application of entrepreneurship account scheme should be considered by such micro-entrepreneurs, who will not incur any significant expenses in relation to their business tools or materials and whose customers are mainly private individuals. Estonia is also tackling undeclared work. The main cooperation model/tool on undeclared work is the ‘Employment register’. Since 1 July 2014, all people who are employed or who are working on a voluntary basis in Estonia must be registered by employers in the new employment register. For more detailed information, please see question no 57. 38. Has your country developed or does it envisage developing an integrated policy framework to facilitate the transition to the formal economy, and is it included in national development strategies 22 or plans as well as in poverty reduction strategies and budgets? If so, is your approach embedded in a national employment policy? No, there is no such integrated policy separately. However the Welfare Development Plan focuses on the strategic objectives of labour market and social protection, gender equality, and equal treatment policies for 2016–2023. The Development Plan provides a thorough overview of the main objectives, courses of action, and problems regarding those policies. The priority of the Development Plan is to support participation in the workforce and a long-term working life, which is also the main method for ensuring the economic survival and welfare of people. 39. With respect to the formalization of micro and small economic units, has your country or is your country envisaging to: (a) undertake business entry reforms; (b) reduce compliance costs; (c) promote access to public procurement; (d) improve access to inclusive financial services; (e) improve access to entrepreneurship training, skills development and tailored business development services; and (f) improve access to social security coverage? Please explain. In order to reduce compliance costs and simplify tax payment regimes for micro and small economic units the threshold of taxable person was raised from 16,000 euros to 40,000 euros. Obligation to pay value added tax and register an economic unit as a taxable person applies if the taxable supply of the transactions exceeds 40,000 euros as calculated from the beginning of a calendar year. The amendment came into force on 01.01.2018. As answered in question no 37, staring a business is quite easy in Estonia. Estonia also offers several benefits/support to start a company. For example Enterprise Estonia (EAS) promotes business and regional policy in Estonia and is one of the largest institutions within the national support system for entrepreneurship by providing financial assistance, counselling, cooperation opportunities and training for entrepreneurs, research institutions, the public and non-profit sectors. For instance there is a start-up grant to support the creation of enterprises that have a lot of development potential, and thereby expand regional entrepreneurship and number of exporters. For more details and services please see https://www.eas.ee/teenused/?lang=en. The Unemployment Insurance Fund offers the business start-up subsidy which is financial aid and the objective of which is to provide motivation and support in starting a business. The subsidy is granted for the commencement of economic activity through a new company being founded or as a sole proprietor. This subsidy can be applied for from the Unemployment Insurance Fund by an unemployed person or a non-working person of retirement age registered as a jobseeker, who is at least 18 years old and, has completed business training or has vocational or higher education in economics or experience in business. For more information please see https://www.tootukassa.ee/eng/content/subsidies-and- benefits/business-start-subsidy. As indicated in answer 37 there is a special entrepreneur account for natural person. From January 2019 a natural person has the opportunity to open an Entrepreneur Account in LHV Pank 23 and fulfil his or her tax liability according to the Simplified Business Income Taxation Act. The entrepreneur account creates a new simple and affordable way of doing business. A person who has opened an entrepreneur account is not obliged to register as an entrepreneur and to calculate revenues and expenses. Accounting and tax reports are not required when using an entrepreneur account because the tax liability is calculated on the basis of the payments to the entrepreneur account. An entrepreneur account is useful for a person who provides services to other natural persons in the areas of activity that do not involve any direct expenses, or for a person who sells self-produced goods or handicraft goods or the goods with low costs of materials or acquisition. Examples include baby-sitting, housekeeping, gardening, repair or construction services that do not involve direct costs or in which a customer pays for the costs. For example, a customer orders the repair or construction service and has bought the tools and materials for the repair himself or herself. An example would also be the sale of self-produced goods to natural persons as well as to legal persons if the cost of raw material or source material is low compared to the selling price of the goods. For example, the sale of handicraft and art, or the sale of food, plants etc. grown or produced by the natural person. An entrepreneur account is also an appropriate solution for new forms of entrepreneurship, such as the payments received from the provision of services from one natural person to another natural person through ride-sharing service platforms, e.g., Uber, Taxify, etc. By signing the agreement, the entrepreneur account owner will give arrangement LHV Pank to reserve business income tax from the total amounts received on the entrepreneur account and transfer the business income tax to the Estonian Tax and Customs Board. The business income tax rate is 20% of the total amount received on the entrepreneur account if the amount does not exceed 25,000 euros per calendar year and 40% of the amount exceeding 25,000 euros received on the entrepreneur account per calendar year. Estonian Tax and Customs Board distributes the received business income tax: income tax rate of 20/53 and social tax (pension and health insurance) rate of 33/53. 40. Are there policies or strategies that provide for protection of human rights and fundamental principles and rights at work in the context of the informal economy? If so, please explain. Estonia does not separately regulate informal work, but if the prerequisites for the existence of the employment contract are met, all the requirements according to ECA must be fulfilled. It does not matter whether the employment contract is concluded or not. Also, there is possibility that in some cases the Penal Code applies. 41. Please indicate whether any measures have been taken or are envisaged to progressively extend to all workers in the informal economy, social security, maternity protection and decent working conditions. If so, please explain. Estonia does not separately regulate informal work, but if the prerequisites for the existence of the employment contract are met, all the requirements according to ECA must be fulfilled. It does not matter whether the employment contract is concluded or not. For example according to ECA § 18 (1) pregnant employee and an employee who has the right to pregnancy and maternity leave have the right to demand that the employer temporarily provide 24 them with work corresponding to their state of health if the employee’s state of health, does not allow the performance of the duties prescribed in the employment contract on the agreed conditions. According to regulation nr 95 by the Government of the Republic of Estonia “Occupational Health and Safety Requirements for Work of Pregnant and Breastfeeding Women” in order to ensure a safe working environment for the female worker, the employer has to temporarily provide the female worker with work that is in accordance with her state of health and prevents being exposed to hazards by changing the organisation of working time, including reduction of working day, granting suitable breaks, transfer to daytime work. If the employer cannot provide the employee with work corresponding to her health condition, the employee may temporarily refuse to perform the duties. In this case the employee shall submit to the employer a certificate from a doctor or midwife indicating the restrictions on work due to her state of health and, where possible, proposals regarding duties and working conditions corresponding to her state of health (ECA § 18 (2) (3)). 42. Are there policies or strategies that address workers who are especially vulnerable to the most serious decent work deficits in the informal economy, including but not limited to women, young people, migrants, older people, indigenous and tribal peoples, persons living with HIV or affected by HIV or AIDS, persons with disabilities, domestic workers and subsistence farmers? If so, please describe. The policies do not address issues in the informal economy specifically, all the policies are nationwide roofing strategies. The Welfare Development Plan provides a thorough overview of the main objectives, courses of action, and problems regarding those policies (the list of policies are covered in question no 1). Overall The Welfare Development Plan sets out four general objectives: 1) Correlation between the demand and supply of the workforce ensures a high level of employment and high-quality working conditions support long-term participation in working life; 2) Supporting an activating, adequate, and sustainable social protection has increased the economic coping of people; 3) Efficient legal protection and high-quality personal assistance have improved people’s opportunities to cope independently, live in a community, and participate in society; 4) Men and women have equal rights, obligations, opportunities, and responsibilities in all social sectors. Equality of opportunity and treatment Special categories of workers 43. Does the national policy provide for effective protections for those workers particularly affected by uncertainties as to the existence of an employment relationship, which may include: (a) women workers; (b) young women and men; (c) older workers; (d) women and men in the informal economy; (e) female and male migrant workers; and (f) women and men with disabilities. If so, please explain. 25 The Welfare Development Plan 2016–2023 does not provide special protection as to the existence of an employment relationship. However the Development Plan aims to reduce general segregation in the labour market, the gender pay gap, and to increase the gender balance in every decision-making level of the society (a, b and d). To achieve this, all legal, administrative, cultural, behavioural, social, and economic barriers or structural reasons that hinder the equal participation of men and women in social life and decision-making processes must be eliminated. To promote gender equality, the gender perspective shall be taken into account in the development of policies in all areas, and specific special measures shall be implemented as well. To keep the elderly employed (c), it is important to develop measures for preventing unemployment, such as ensuring the sustainability of work ability, promoting supplemental and re-training, and reacting to redundancies. In collaboration with the Ministry of Education and Research, principles for lifelong learning shall be established in addition to the compliance of trainings with the needs of the employers. To encourage employment in the retirement age and to prevent dropping out of the labour market, labour market services shall also be provided for jobseekers of retirement age. Developing pension schemes within sub-objective No. 2 will also help prevent the elderly from leaving the labour market prematurely. To reduce the unemployment risk among residents who do not speak Estonian and to improve their labour market position (e), it is important to support the achievement of a good proficiency in Estonian and overall integration (see sub-objective No. 1 of Integrating Estonia 2020). To bring people of other nationalities into the labour market and help them find employment, the labour market services based on individual needs shall be continuously provided. To reduce regional unemployment in Ida-Viru County, projects for areas with a higher unemployment rate shall be preferred in open application rounds and the development of measures for the prevention of unemployment shall consider the sectoral component of unemployment. Greater attention shall be paid to the integration of new immigrants with different linguistic-cultural background in the labour market, and the awareness of the public, employers, and service providers about immigrants’ cultural background shall be increased. In order to ensure that new immigrants (including beneficiaries of international protection) remain employed and receive equal treatment, special attention must be paid to monitoring their working conditions and the possible additional counselling and guidance. People with disabilities (f), including disabled people of retirement age, are ensured an additional income with the state benefits for people with disabilities. These aim to partly compensate the additional costs arising from the disability and promote independent coping, social integration, and equal opportunities. However, it is estimated that the actual scope of the additional costs of people with disabilities is significantly larger than that which the benefits cover.5 Additionally, the monetary benefits planned for the compensation of additional costs are not adequately connected with the provision of social and other services, which aim to compensate for the need of personal assistance among people with disabilities 5 Study on Disabled People and the Caretaking Burden of Their Family Members 2009. Saar Poll OÜ, Centre for Applied Social Sciences, University of Tartu. 26 44. Please indicate whether national laws and policies effectively address the gender dimension, in that women predominate in certain occupations and/or sectors where there is a high proportion of disguised employment relationships, or where there is lack of clarity with regard to the employment relationship. If so, please provide detailed information in this regard. The Welfare Development Plan sets out a sub-objective (No. 4) - men and women have equal rights, obligations, opportunities, and responsibilities in all social sectors. The fourth sub-objective of the Development Plan focuses on the special measures of promoting gender equality, which, among other things, include activities that support the implementation of gender mainstreaming. To reduce gender inequality, prevent its resurgence, and achieve gender equality in different spheres of life, attention shall be paid to reducing social stereotypes that cause social inequality and their negative impact, as well as reducing gender segregation in education and the labour market, supporting the economic independence of men and women, therein reducing the gender pay gap, achieving a gender balance on the decision-making levels of society, enhancing the protection of rights, and ensuring institutional capacity, including the analysis and management capabilities necessary for the promotion of gender equality. The achievement of this sub-objective is supported by: 1) the Development Plan for Children and Families for 2012–2020, which includes a strategic objective to establish equal possibilities for the reconciliation of working, family, and private life, 2) Strategy for Preventing Violence for 2015– 2020, which deals with the prevention and reduction of violence against women, 3) the National Health Plan 2009–2020, which aims to contribute to the increased life expectancy of men and women and the time they live healthily, and which, among other things, deals with the topics of reproductive health, healthy living environments, and healthy lifestyles, and 4) the Estonian Lifelong Learning Strategy 2020, which includes a strategic objective to establish equal possibilities for lifelong learning for everybody. 45. Please indicate any measures taken or envisaged after consultation with the social partners, and where appropriate in collaboration with other member States, to provide effective protection to, and prevent abuses of, male and female migrant workers in your territory who may be affected by uncertainty as to the existence of an employment relationship. In April 2017, the Parliament adopted amendments to the Citizen of the European Union Act and the Equal Treatment Act, which aims to ensure consistency with the Directive 2014/54/EU of the European Parliament and the Council on measures facilitating the exercise of rights conferred on workers in the context of freedom of movement for workers. The directive and its transposing legislation are intended to enable improved and more uniform application of the rights of workers from EU Member States and their family members who are EU Member State or third country nationals, and to ensure measures against discrimination based on the nationality of an EU Member State. The amendments came into force in May 2017. According to the amendments to the Citizen of the European Union Act, regardless of their citizenship, workers and officials who are citizens of a member state of the European Union (EU) or of the European Economic Area (EEA) must be treated equally with Estonian citizens in the following areas: 1) access to employment; 2) conditions of employment and work, in particular as 27 regards remuneration, termination of employment, health and safety at work, and, when becoming unemployed, reinstatement or re-employment, and appointment to a position or dismissal; 3) access to social and tax advantages; 4) membership of trade unions and eligibility for workers' representative bodies; 5) access to training; 6) access to housing; 7) access to education, apprenticeship and vocational training for the children of workers; 8) assistance afforded by the employment offices. In order to ensure the protection of the rights, it is specified that a worker or official who is a citizen of a member state of the EU or of the EEA and members of his or her family who consider that they have suffered or are suffering from unjustified restrictions and obstacles to their right to free movement or who consider themselves wronged by a failure to apply the principle of equal treatment to them, may have recourse to any legal remedy on the same grounds and to the same extent as Estonian citizens. Amendments to the Equal Treatment Act expanded the competence of the Gender Equality and Equal Treatment Commissioner, stipulating that the Commissioner also acts as a contact point for cooperation between the Member States of the European Union, in order to facilitate the exercise of the right to free movement of the workers who are citizens of a Member State of the European Union and of the European Economic Area, and of their family members. In order to improve the legal protection, the Ministry of Social Affairs has also prepared an amendment to the Equal Treatment Act, which extends the anti-discrimination protection provided by this law on the basis of disability, age, religion or beliefs and sexual orientation beyond the working life. The aim of the amendment is to harmonise the scope of application of the Equal Treatment Act with the protection provided by the law on the basis of nationality (ethnicity), race or skin colour, so that, in addition to working life, a more specific prohibition of discrimination, in the case of all the characteristics, would also include social protection, (including social security and health care) and the provision of social benefits, the acquisition of education and access to goods and services offered to the public (including housing). The amendment would also extend the competence of the Gender Equality and Equal Treatment Commissioner. There are also plans to better ensure the independence of the Commissioner. To this end, it is planned to change the appointment procedure for the Commissioner and to specify restrictions on activities of the Commissioner during his or her term of office. Also, Ministry of the Interior implements an “Action Plan on illegal employment”. The Action Plan focuses on reducing the illegal employment of aliens in Estonia. 46. Please provide information on any bilateral (or other) agreements concerning women and men workers recruited in one country for work in another entered into to prevent abuses and fraudulent practices, which have as their purpose the evasion of the existing arrangements for the protection of workers in the context of an employment relationship. Estonia does not have such an agreement across borders. Below there is a list of EU directives that also deal with aspects of working and worker protection are listed below with directives on equal treatment. In all these directives, the protection and treatment of a third-country national is equivalent to that of a national of a Member State in terms 28 of working conditions, wages, health protection, further training, leave, social protection, access to goods and services, etc. 1. 2011/98/EU DIRECTIVE 2011/98/EU OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 13 December 2011 on a single application procedure for a single permit for third-country nationals to reside and work in the territory of a Member State and on a common set of rights for third-country workers legally residing in a Member State; 2. COUNCIL DIRECTIVE 2009/50/EC of 25 May 2009 on the conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for the purposes of highly qualified employment 3. DIRECTIVE 2014/36/EU OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 26 February 2014 on the conditions of entry and stay of third-country nationals for the purpose of employment as seasonal workers 4. DIRECTIVE 2014/66/EU OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 15 May 2014 on the conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals in the framework of an intra- corporate transfer 5. DIRECTIVE 2014/66/EU OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 15 May 2014 on the conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals in the framework of an intra- corporate transfer It should be borne in mind that these directives are specific and targeted at workers in a particular field and that the rights in the different directives vary slightly, but the EU single permit directive is the basis and applies to all third-country nationals who are issued a residence permit. Dialogue and the role of employers’ and workers’ organizations 47. Please indicate whether consultations are held concerning the development, implementation and review of employment policies with: (a) representatives of employers and workers; and (b) representatives of the persons affected by the measures to be taken, including women and other categories of persons vulnerable to decent work deficits and exclusion. If so, please specify whether and how their experience and views have been taken into account and their cooperation secured in formulating and supporting such policies. Representatives of employers and employees are involved in the development of employment legislation. All draft legislation concerning employment policies is sent to the employers 'and workers' representatives for an opinion. Representatives of employers and employees are always involved in the welfare development plan. Also, whenever there is a specific legislative or other project, relevant partners are involved. 29 Representatives of employers and employees are involved also in implementation of the legislation as the supervisory board of the unemployment insurance fund (UIF). The objective of the UIF is implementation of the labour market policy and organisation of unemployment insurance (pay unemployment benefits, provide labour market services, assess work ability and pay work ability allowance etc.). The highest body of the UIF is the supervisory board. Representatives of employers and employees are members of supervisory board (The Government of the Republic shall appoint one member, The Estonian Central Federation of Trade Unions and the Estonian Employees' Unions' Confederation shall both appoint one member of the supervisory board. The Estonian Employers’ Confederation shall appoint two members of the supervisory board.) Estonian Chamber of Disabled People and other representative organisations of disabled people are involved to policymaking, the Ministry and EUIF are conducting the informative campaigns about changes in work ability assessment and services. Representatives of employers and workers are part of regular policy making procedure in the field of labour migration. Social partners also are involved in the Government mandated working group (for the period of 2017 to 1st half of 2019) working on immigration policy review. First set of proposals from the working group were approved by the Government in 2018 February and entered into force in July 2018. Amendments included exempting top specialist from annual immigration quota and Extending maximum period for short-term employment from 9 months to 1 year. 50. Please indicate whether any measures have been taken to consult with employers’ and workers’ organizations: (a) with regard to small undertakings, to improve working conditions in these undertakings and their access to product markets, credit, technical expertise and advanced technology; and (b) to promote employment in underdeveloped areas that have not benefited satisfactorily from national development. If so, please explain. For small undertakings subsidisation policy supports the implementation of companies’ ambitions for growth as well as making the processes more effective (counselling services and training for setting targets are provided etc). Measures aimed at supporting export and developing cooperation for entrepreneurs heading to international markets will be continued. The Green Paper on Estonia’s industrial policies and the information and communication technologies (ICT) sector development programme will facilitate digital revolution in the industrial sector. Please also see answer no 39 and no 5. To update the action plan for north-eastern Estonia (IdaViru country) with regard to the activities aimed at developing the regional business environment and prepare a similar action plan for south-eastern Estonia Monitoring and updating of Ida-Viru County and southeastern Estonia action plans for 2015–2020 has been carried out regularly once a year. At the Government cabinet meeting on 8 February 2018, it was decided to start the implementation of the Ida-Virumaa programme from the second half of 2018 (the programme was developeded in the first half of 2018). The objective of the programme is to boost economy in Ida-Virumaa, increase the attractiveness of the region as a living environment, decelerate outflow of younger people, and reduce the 30 development gap of the region compared to other regions in Estonia by prioritising this region in terms of development. The indicative volume of the programme is 3.8 million euros in 2018 and 4,95 million euros from 2019. Similarly to the Ida-Viru County programme, the launching of southeastern Estonia programme in 2019 has been discussed to help decelerate the reduction of the size of population and improve business and labour market indicators in southeastern Estonia. To support the development of the business environment by using SF measures "Improving regional competitiveness" and "Development of regional competence centres". The implementation of measures regarding improving the competitiveness of the regions and development of regional competence centres is going as planned. As at the end of 2017, financing decisions from the measure for improving the competitiveness of the region to implement 21 regional business and industrial infrastructure development and incubation and product development centres projects have been made for the total support amount of over 16 million euros. In 2017, the second application round of the measure was opened in all counties and in three counties (Harju County, Ida-Viru County, Jõgeva County) the round was completed. Preparations for organising the measure’s reserve projects round were made in 2017. 51. Please provide information on any consultations on the development, implementation and review of policies and programmes for vocational rehabilitation and the employment of persons with disabilities that have been held with: (a) representative organizations of employers and workers; and (b) representative organizations of and for persons with disabilities. All the representatives are involved in the negotiations of the development of the rehabilitation service. Employers, service providers and beneficiaries are involved in the study concerning the performance and quality of the service analysis. The analysis will be carried out this year (2019). 52. Please indicate whether consultations on home work have been held with the most representative employers’ and workers’ organizations and/or with the organizations concerned with homeworkers and those of employers of homeworkers, where these exist. The ECA and Estonian legislation does not contain a special definition of “employee” and “employer” in the context of home work. Homeworkers are treated like ordinary employees and they are covered by the protection of the ECA. The ECA was composed together with the employers and trade unions. In 2017 the trade unions and the employers signed an agreement on teleworking. There are ten recommendations in the agreement, which favour teleworking. The Ministry of Social Affairs has prepared a proposal to amend the ECA. During the process, regulating homeworking/teleworking was under discussion. 53. Please indicate whether your country has made use of tripartite mechanisms to: (a) identify the nature and extent of the informal economy and its relationship to the formal economy with a view to its formalization; and (b) regularly review the effectiveness of the policies and measures, if any, to facilitate transition to the formal economy. If so, please explain, and indicate whether these mechanisms include membership-based organizations and economic units in the informal economy. The Welfare Development Plan has a Steering Committee. The task of the Steering Committee is to manage the preparation of the development plan and its implementation, including confirming 31 the objectives of the development plan. The Welfare Development Plan brings together the strategic objectives of the policies for employment, social protection, gender equality and equal treatment for 2016–2023, giving a comprehensive view of the main challenges, objectives and lines of action in these policy areas. Statistical data 54. Please indicate whether, in consultation with employers’ and workers’ organizations, statistical data are collected, analysed and disseminated, disaggregated by sex, age, workplace and other specific socio-economic characteristics on the size and composition of the informal economy, including the number of informal economy units, the number of workers employed and their sectors. If so, please provide detailed information in this regard. Statistical data are not specifically collected on informal economy. The Estonian Labour Force Survey gives an indication of the number of self-employed persons and family workers. The data can be disaggregated by sex, age and other socio-economic characteristics. Estonian Institute of Economic Research gathers yearly data on shadow economy in Estonia, including the estimated number of employees receiving undeclared wages and employees’ general attitudes towards undeclared wages. Summary of the collected data is published online each year. 55. Please provide information regarding any statistical data and research undertaken on changes in the patterns and structure of work at the national and sectoral levels, taking into account the distribution of men and women and other relevant factors. Statistical data on the structure of work can be derived quarterly from the Estonian Labour Force Survey. The data can be disaggregated by sector, employed persons’ sex, age and other socio- economic characterstics. Statistical data on the patterns and structure of work are also collected in the Estonian Work Life Survey which has taken place twice so far (in 2009 and 2015). The survey covers topics such as management of work, working time and vacation, relations at workplace, employees’ inclusion in enterprise’s/institution’s activities, collective work relations, occupational health and safety, payment and employees’ skills and knowledge. Both employers and employees are surveyed. The data can be disaggregated by all relevant background characteristics. A collection of articles based on both 2009 and 2015 results was published in 2017 (in Estonian with conclusions also in English) and can be found here: https://www.sm.ee/sites/default/files/content- editors/Ministeerium_kontaktid/Uuringu_ja_analuusid/eesti_tooelu_uuring_2015.pdf The next Estonian Work Life Survey is planned for 2021. 56. Please indicate whether data and other information are compiled and analysed, including data disaggregated by age and sex, on the nature, size and characteristics of home work in your country. Data specifically on home work is not compiled. Data on working from home is available in the Estonian Labour Force Survey. Estonian Work Life Survey includes questions regarding remote work. 32 Monitoring and implementation 57. Please describe any measures taken to ensure respect for and implementation of laws and regulations concerning the employment relationship, for example, through labour inspection services and their collaboration with the social security administration and tax authorities. Please also describe any measures taken to ensure that special attention is paid to occupations and sectors with a high proportion of women workers. The Estonian Labour Inspectorate is a government agency working under the authority of the Ministry of Social Affairs. The main tasks of the Inspectorate are implementation of work environment policy, national supervision of requirements of legal acts regulating health and safety at work and labour relations in the work environment, notification of the general public, employees and employers about hazards in the work environment, and resolution of individual labour disputes at an extra-judicial labour dispute resolution body. In the Inspectorate, the Supervision Department is responsible for making employment rights effective and supervision of requirements of legal acts regulating labour relations and the working environment. About 52 labour inspectors are working in this department. The area of activity of the Estonian Tax and Customs Board includes administration of state revenues, implementation of national taxation and customs policies and protection of society and legal economic activities. The Board has a directing function and exercises state supervision and apply enforcement powers of the state on the basis and to the extent prescribed by tax legislation. The Board is accountable to the Minister of Finance who directs and coordinates its activities and exercises supervisory control over it. Departments of the Board are: 1) Administration Department; 2) Legal Department; 3) Audit Department; 4) Tax Department; 5) Personnel Department; 6) Internal Control Department; 7) Intelligence Department; 8) Service Department; 9) Customs Department; 10) Revenue Department; 11) Investigation Department. The Board has its central office in the capital Tallinn, and regional offices across Estonia. The main cooperation model/tool on undeclared work is the ‘Employment register’. Since 1 July 2014, all people who are employed or who are working on a voluntary basis in Estonia must be registered by employers in the new employment register. On the one hand, the register should reduce undeclared work and increase tax revenue by requiring registration of employees before the actual employment starts, and by making the supervision by taxation officials easier. On the other hand, the purpose of the register is also to increase the amount of electronically gathered data for administrative decisions and to ease the data exchange between different state institutions. The employment register is also the basis for determining the employment related social guarantees (health insurance, pension, and unemployment insurance premiums) and for supervision over the fulfilment of the employment related obligations. Additionally, the Labour Inspectorate and the Estonian Tax and Customs Board cooperate by sharing case-by-case information on establishments and employers that are suspected of infringing employment and tax law. Also, the Labour Inspectorate and the Police and Border Guard 33 cooperate by carrying out joint inspections based on a cooperation agreement and plan for detection of illegal employment and cases of labour exploitation (e.g. trafficking). Cooperation with other Member States is mostly based on data sharing. The Estonian Tax and Customs Board shares data with other tax authorities based on the council directive 2011/16/EU and council regulation 904/2010/EC on administrative cooperation in the field of direct taxation. There are also number of bilateral agreements6 for the avoidance of fiscal evasion with respect to taxes on income and capital. These regulations stipulate both automatic exchange of information and also case-by-case exchange of information on possible employment relations and tax obligations. Additionally, the Labour Inspectorate cooperates with other member state authorities in case the undeclared work is related to posting of workers in the framework of the provision of services as stipulated in the Directive 96/71/EC. In these cases, the Inspectorate shares the available administrative data or additionally carries out inspection to gather evidence. Impact of ILO instruments/prospects of ratification 58.Please indicate whether any modifications have been made or are envisaged to national laws, regulations or practice, with a view to giving effect to all or some of the provisions of the Conventions or Recommendations that are the subject of this questionnaire. Internationally acknowledged principles were taken into consideration in the process of drafting of the ECA. 59.Please provide information regarding any prospects of ratification and identify any challenges or obstacles with regard to the possible ratification of Conventions No’s 122, 159 and 177, where these exist. Since ratification of the conventions would not improve the conditions compared to the current situation ratification of above-mentioned conventions is not considered necessary at this point. 60. Please indicate the representative employers’ or workers’ organizations to which copies of the present questionnaire have been communicated in accordance with article 23(2) of the ILO Constitution and indicate whether you have received observations from such organizations concerning the effect given, or to be given, to any of the instruments to which this questionnaire relates. If so, please communicate a copy of the observations received together with any comments that you may consider useful. Copies of the present report have been communicated with the Estonian Trade Unions Confederation and the Estonian Employers’ Confederation. 6 See internet: http://www.emta.ee/eng/business-client/income-expenses-supply- profits/international-agreements/conventions-avoidance-double 34 Possible need for standards-related action and for technical assistance 61. Please provide your country’s views regarding any existing gaps or inconsistencies that should be addressed by future standard setting in regard to the instruments to which this questionnaire relates, particularly with regard to the promotion of employment and decent jobs for all workers and any required labour protections. There is no need for revision of existing instruments or adoption of new instruments. Existing standards should be reviewed regularly to determine whether they are relevant to the changing world of work. 62. Has your country formulated any requests for technical assistance by the ILO to assist it in giving effect to all or some of the provisions of the instruments covered by this questionnaire? If not, please indicate the manner in which the ILO could best provide appropriate assistance within its mandate to support country efforts to ensure effective promotion of employment and protection for workers covered by the instruments that are the subject of this questionnaire. There have been no requests for technical assistance. Taking into account a nowadays situation, there are not any special needs for technical assistance in this field. 35
Allikas: Sotsiaalministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel