20, AVENUE APPIA – CH-1211 GENEVA 27 – SWITZERLAND – TEL CENTRAL +41 22 791 2111 – FAX CENTRAL +41 22 791 3111 – WWW.WHO.INT
Ref.: C.L.8.2019
Informal consultations on the Proposed Programme Budget 2020–2021
and WHO Impact Framework
The World Health Organization (WHO) presents its compliments to Member States and
has the honour to refer to the approval of the Thirteenth General Programme of Work (GPW13)
2019–2023 at the Seventy-first World Health Assembly in resolution WHA71.1 that requests the
Director-General “to use the Thirteenth General Programme of Work as the basis for the
strategic direction of planning, monitoring and evaluation of WHO’s work during the period
2019–2023, and to develop programme budgets in consultation with Member States, based on a
realistic assessment of income and WHO’s capacity”.
At the recently concluded Executive Board Meeting (EB144), Member States requested an
informal consultation on the Proposed Programme Budget 2020–2021 and on the WHO Impact
Framework prior to the World Health Assembly in May.
Member States are invited to participate in the following informal consultations:
(a) 19 March: Proposed Programme Budget 2020–2021 (working hours: 09:30–12:30
and 14:00–17:00) in the Executive Board room and
(b) 25 and 26 March: WHO Impact Framework on 25 (working hours: 09:30–12:30
and 14:00–17:00) and 26 March (working hours: 09:30–12:30) in Salle A.
Related documents will be available at http://www.who.int/about/what-we-do/gpw-
thirteen-consultation/en/ two weeks prior to the meeting.
The World Health Organization takes this opportunity to renew to Member States the
assurance of its highest consideration.
GENEVA, 1 March 2019
Saatja: <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 08.03.2019 19:54
Koopia: <
[email protected]>
Teema: WHO: C.L.8.2019. Informal consultation on the Proposed Programme Budget 2020-
2021 (19 March 2019) in the EB room
Manused: PB 2020-21 Operationalization inf doc 08032019.pdf; C.L.8.2019 (informal
consultations).pdf
Dear Member States of the World Health Organization,
With reference to the attached circular letter, please find attached the draft working document
on the operationalization of the Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021.
The document will be posted on the following website shortly:
https://www.who.int/about/what-we-do/thirteenth-general-programme-of-work-2019-2023.
Best regards,
WHO Secretariat
Draft Working Document on the Operationalization
Operationalization of the Proposed
Programme Budget 2020-
2020-2021
Introduction
1. The draft proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 was discussed at the 144th Executive Board in
January 2019. Member States supported the consistent translation of the Thirteenth General
Programme of Work (GPW13) into the budget document and the new approach: (i) to focus on
measurable impacts to improve people’s health; (ii) to prioritize its work to drive public health
impacts in every country and (iii) to depart from a disease-specific approach to a more integrated
and health systems-oriented approach to drive sustainable outcomes.
2. At the same time, Member States requested that the Secretariat addresses the following for the
finalization of the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021:
• more details about how this programme budget will be implemented in the new results
framework;
• updated budget figures to remove inflation and UN levy;
• comparison of the proposed budget 2020-2021 with the approved budget 2018-2019;
• details on the USD 99 million “savings through reallocation and efficiencies”,
• clarity on the proposed budget appropriation resolution for the World Health Assembly
• clarity on how the budget will be financed under the new results framework;
• ensuring that the normative functions of the Organization are preserved or even
strengthened;
• identify how the Secretariat’s contributions (Outputs) will be measured and reported.
3. This information document addresses the above requests and provides more background and
update on further work done by the Secretariat to address these issues. Some of the information
(revised figures, output measurement) presented here will be part of the revised proposed
Programme Budget 2020-2021 for the consideration of the World Health Assembly (WHA). Some
information contained here, e.g., cross-walk between 2018-2019 and 2002-2021, is for
information purposes and will not be included in the programme budget document to be
submitted to WHA.
4. GPW13 represents a fundamental shift in the vision and strategic directions of WHO as it calls for
a much more integrated and health systems-based approach. Implementing these shifts starts
with the results framework (i.e., clarity on what we aim to achieve) and budget structure (i.e.,
clarity as to how we maximize resources to achieve our goals).
5. The changes in the results framework help implement the GPW13 in several ways:
- It helps to clearly align the work towards the vision and strategic priorities, i.e. the triple billion
goals: One billion more people benefiting from universal health coverage – One billion more
people better protected from health emergencies – One billion more people enjoying better
health and well-being;
1
- By focusing on the shared results, instead of on programmatic arrangements, it fosters more
cohesive working arrangements; and
- It helps orient the planning and measurement systems towards the triple billion to which the work
of the Organization is contributing.
6. The new results framework will be the primary organizing concept for planning, budgeting,
implementation, monitoring and reporting.
Details about how this programme budget will be implemented in the new results framework
7. The draft proposed Programme Budget is based on a new planning process that started with
prioritization using the new results framework. This was done together with Member States. Each
country, has a prioritized set of outcomes with impact targets to which, they had expressed, will
contribute. This prioritization is guiding the subsequent planning of work to articulate how the
each of the levels of the Organization will strengthen its support to countries and its delivery of
the normative and leadership roles.
8. In the new results framework, human resources and activities will be planned around the delivery
of the outputs. This means that each Budget Centre across the Organization will define the human
resources and activities that will be needed to achieve the outputs in the new results framework.
In some cases, the outputs are underpinned by the delivery of programme-specific strategies
contributing to their achievement.
9. The planning process allows for articulating the most optimal way for delivering results. For
example, an entity responsible for a specific programme will continue to plan human resources
and activities based on the agreed strategies and evidence-based interventions. However, the
difference in this new results framework is that the planning within these programmes is geared
not simply towards the delivery of expected programmatic impacts but such planning is oriented
towards the integrated delivery that follows the pathway towards the triple billion goals.
10. To illustrate this, for example, the Tuberculosis programme will continue to plan for the
Secretariat’s work on implementing the End TB Strategy, which consists of the three pillars, i.e.,
Integrated, patient-centred care and prevention; Bold policies and supportive systems; Intensified
research and innovation. These pillars correspond to the following outputs in the new results
framework:
- Output 1.1.1. Countries enabled to provide high-quality, people-centred health services, based on
primary health care strategies and comprehensive essential service packages
- Output 1.1.2. Countries enabled to strengthen their health systems to deliver on condition- and
disease-specific service coverage results
11. Budget Centres, the assigned planning and cost entities within the Organization, that are involved
with implementing the End TB Strategy will plan WHO’s human resources and activities under
these outputs. The planning system will make it possible to track the specific human resources
and activities (including their costs, funding, expenditures) contributing both to these outputs and
to the End TB Strategy, ensuring accountability over the outputs, and at the same time over the
specific End TB Strategy impacts.
2
12. This example demonstrates that the new integrated results framework paves the way for a public
health approach which identifies the most optimal way of delivering results - through a health
systems approach, programme-specific approach or a combination of the two. As a result, the
Secretariat will strengthen its accountability for more effective, more efficient and more
sustainable delivery of results.
Updated high-level budget for the biennium 2020-2021
13. The budget figures of the WHA draft proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 will reflect several
changes compared to the EB document EB144/5:
1) Based on Member States recommendations during the Executive Board meeting in January
2019, the Base programme budget 2020-2021 is decreased by excluding inflation (US$ 58.3
million) and UN levy (US$ 42.4 million). The updated increase of the Base programme budget is
summarized in Figure 1 (to replace Fig. 2 of the Draft programme budget document1). Removal of
the inflation has affected high-level Base budget of all major offices, both Regional Offices and
Headquarters (Table 1).
Table 1. Adjustments to the Major Office envelopes from EB to WHA draft proposed Programme
Budget 2020-2021, Base segment (figures will be incorporated into the updated budget tables of
the WHA PB document)
South-East Eastern Western
Africa Americas Asia Europe Mediterranean Pacific Headquarters Total
Base EB document 144/5 1,007.1 219.0 393.5 282.0 398.0 313.8 1,332.0 3,945.4
Inflation (14.7) (3.2) (5.0) (4.1) (6.8) (4.6) (19.9) (58.3)
Special programmes - - - - - - (118.4) (118.4)
WHA proposed Base budget 992.4 215.8 388.5 277.9 391.2 309.2 1,193.7 3,768.7
1
References will be given to the elements of this document, which will be part of the draft proposed Programme Budget 2020-
2021 for WHA approval
3
Figure 1. Proposed programme budget 2020-2021 increases in detail (US$ million)
2) While special programmes HRP2 and TDR3 are shown as distinct budget lines (from the base
budget) in the programme budget 2018-2019 and PIP4 is fully accounted outside of Programme
Budget 2018-2019, these three special programmes were included into the Base segment of the
draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 presented to the Executive Board in January 2019.
Following the EB, due consideration was given to retain Special programmes segment in the draft
Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 similar to the 2018-2019 budget based on the following:
a) These special programmes have additional governance and resource mobilization mechanisms
and budget cycles which inform their annual/biennial budgets;
b) Having a distinct budget setting for these programmes provides the necessary flexibility for
accommodating their requirements, while enhancing the transparency of their contributions to
the agreed results in the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 and therefore showing
full investment to achieve the results;
c) These special programmes are fully funded, however, with very specific purpose-intended funds,
which cannot be used for any other programmes. Therefore, any analyses of budget and funding
of the Base segment will be skewed by including special programmes;
d) The distinct budget setting of special programmes has proven to be working very efficiently
internally, providing sufficient flexibility in budget management, yet allowing for the same level
of accountability and oversight as with the Base programmes.
2
UNDP/UNFPA/WHO/World Bank Special Programme of Research, Development and Research Training in Human
Reproduction
3
UNICEF/UNDP/World Bank/WHO Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases
4
Pandemic Influenza Preparedness Framework
4
14. The Draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 for WHA therefore includes an extra segment
of special programmes (Table 2). The Base budget of Headquarters was decreased by the
equivalent amount of HRP, TDR and PIP budgets (Table 1).
Table 2: Comparison of the Programme budget 2018-2019 with the updated draft Proposed programme
budget 2020-2021 (US$ millions). This table is to replace Table 1 of the next version of theprogramme
budget.
Approved Programme Draft proposed programme Increase or
Segment
budget 2018-2019 budget 2020-2021 (decrease) amount
Base 3,400.3 3,768.7 368.4
Polio eradication 902.8 798.0 (104.8)
Special programmes1 118.4 208.7 90.3
Total 4,421.5 4,775.4 353.9
Emergency operations and appeals - 1,000.0 1,000.0
Total 4,421.5 5,775.4 1,353.9
1
Increase in Special programmes compared to programme budget 2018-2019 is due to (1) accounting PIP within the budget, (2)
increase in HRP budget for 2020-2021 based on the decision of the HRP Policy and Coordination Committee
3) Work is currently ongoing in every Regional office to review Country Support plans in addition
to review of regional and global goods. Both reviews will result in fine-tuned budget figures by
outcome, by Major offices. Additionally, Major offices have to readjust their budget to remove
inflation. Final figures by strategic priority, outcome and Major office will be presented in the
WHA draft Proposed programme budget 2020-2021.
Comparison of the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-21 with the approved Programme Budget
2018-2019
15. One of the main aims of the new proposed budget structure for the biennium 2020-2021 is to
facilitate the new way of working, i.e. “the how”: integrated approach, bringing departments
together, and delivering value for money. Both outcomes and outputs of the draft Proposed
Programme Budget 2020-2021 are crosscutting in nature as illustrated above, which is also
captured in the budget figures.
16. There are two sets of comparisons provided in this paper:
- Current programme areas in the Programme Budget 2018-2019 are presented in a ‘crosswalk’:
how the Secretariat’s current work will be reflected in the new results structure (Annex 2).
- How the new GPW13 results structure is translated into the outcomes of Programme Budget
2018-2019 (Annex 3).
17. The comparisons demonstrate that in most cases there is no one-to-one relationship between the
current programme area and the outputs of the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021.
Nearly no output and, therefore, outcome can be achieved through an effort of one single
programme area or department.
5
18. Annex 3 shows relative contribution of various technical areas to achieve a certain output: for
example output 1.1.2 (Countries enabled to strengthen their health systems to deliver on
condition- and disease-specific service coverage results) is planned to be achieved through
contributions of the programmes: HIV, Tuberculosis, Malaria, Neglected Tropical Diseases,
Vaccine Preventable Diseases, Noncommunicable Diseases, Mental Health, Violence and Injuries,
Disability and Rehabilitation, Ageing and Health, Integrated people-centred health services. In this
case, the budget for the output 1.1.2 will be planned, shared and implemented among these
programmes. This is in contrast to the current programme budget implementation where most
often one programme/department will “own” and implement the entire budget of one output.
Sharing budget of one output is a prerequisite for an integrated approach.
19. Annex 4 briefly describes the methodology and process to arrive at the crosswalk.
20. As requested by the Member States at the Executive Board session in January 2019 and based on
the crosswalk presented in Annex 2, Table 3 presents a comparison of the Programme Budget
2018-2019 to the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021. Two limitations of the crosswalk
should be noted: (1) in order to keep the focus, the final crosswalk of Annex 2 and 3 had to be
limited to a manageable number of splits of the effort (and potentially budget), leading to less
precision in transposing budget figures from one results framework to another; (2) when
programmes reflect on their current work in the new results structure, there is always an element
of how it will/should also work in the future.
6
Table 3. Detailed comparison of the approved Programme Budget 2018-2019 and draft Proposed
Programme Budget 2020-2021 (this is for illustrative purposes only; this will not be part of the draft
Programme Budget 2020-2021 to be proposed to WHA in May 2019)
2018-2019 Approved 2020-2021 Proposed Increase /
Budget segments programme budget programme budget (Decrease)
1 - Communicable diseases 805.4 710.3 (95.1)
1.1 HIV and hepatitis 144.7 104.9 (39.8)
1.2 Tuberculosis 123.9 94.6 (29.3)
1.3 Malaria 115.8 139.3 23.5
1.4 Neglected tropical diseases 107.3 82.6 (24.7)
1.5 Vaccine-preventable diseases 272.0 216.7 (55.3)
1.6 Antimicrobial resistance 41.7 72.2 30.5
2 - Noncommunicable diseases 351.4 373.9 22.5
2.1 Noncommunicable diseases 179.0 191.9 12.9
2.2 Mental health and substance abuse 47.0 46.4 (0.6)
2.3 Violence and injuries 30.4 27.0 (3.4)
2.4 Disability and rehabilitation 16.5 18.4 1.9
2.5 Nutrition 46.5 53.6 7.1
2.6 Food safety 32.0 36.6 4.6
3 - Promoting health through the life-course 384.3 402.0 17.7
3.1 Reproductive, maternal, newborn, child and adolescent health 211.3 227.0 15.7
3.2 Ageing and health 14.9 19.1 4.2
3.5 Health and the environment 107.6 113.4 5.8
3.6 Equity, social determinants, gender equality and human rights 50.5 42.5 (8.0)
4 - Health systems 589.5 751.2 161.7
4.1 National health policies, strategies and plans 142.7 181.1 38.4
4.2 Integrated people-centred health services 155.9 216.8 60.9
4.3 Access to medicines and health technologies, and strengthening 167.9 183.7 15.8
regulatory capacity
4.4 Health systems Information and evidence 123.0 169.7 46.7
12 - Health Emergencies Programme 554.2 583.9 29.7
12.1 Infectious hazard management 93.8 109.1 15.3
12.2 Country health emergency preparedness and the International 146.8 163.6 16.8
Health Regulations (2005)
12.3 Health emergency information and risk assessment 63.5 74.9 11.4
12.4 Emergency operations 154.0 134.1 (19.9)
12.5 Emergency core services 96.1 102.3 6.2
6 - Corporate services / enabling functions 715.5 719.9 4.4
6.1 Leadership and governance 224.2 193.2 (31.0)
6.2 Transparency, accountability and risk management 54.2 57.7 3.5
6.3 Strategic planning, resource coordination and reporting 38.7 58.2 19.5
6.4 Management and administration 354.5 352.3 (2.2)
6.5 Strategic Communications 43.9 58.4 14.5
Polio transition - 227.4 227.4
Base 3,400.3 3,768.7 368.4
Polio eradication 902.8 798.0 (104.8)
Special Programmes 118.4 208.7 90.3
Pandemic influenza preparedness (PIP) framework - 40.3 40.3
Research in human reproduction 68.4 118.4 50.0
Tropical disease research 50.0 50.0 -
Humanitarian response plans and other appeals - 1,000.0 1,000.0
Grand Total 4,421.5 6,002.8 1,353.9
a) Table 3 shows a decrease in the budget of diseases-specific programme areas, especially in
current Category 1. The limitation of the crosswalk’s mixing current work and future approaches
is clearly reflected here: the focus on these diseases remains but their delivery is envisaged in a
UHC / health systems approach. This results in the redistribution of budget: while Category 1
budget decreases, Category 4 Health Systems sees a significant increase, with health services
7
programme area increasing its budget by ~40%. Similarly, the investment in the budget for
noncommunicable diseases is bigger than currently reflected given the shift of approach towards
a UHC and health systems.
b) Antimicrobial resistance, Maternal, Newborn, Child and Adolescent health, Health Emergencies
are proposed to be strengthened budget-wise in the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-
2021.
c) The envisaged budget increase of US$ 108 million for normative work, and especially data and
innovation, is reflected in ~38% increase of the programme area 4.4 Health systems Information
and evidence, with remaining increases being spread across programme areas in line with the hub
and spoke arrangement proposed for strengthening this area of work.
d) In response to Member States’ concern over the enabling functions, Table 3 shows that there is
no significant change in the overall budget level of Category 6. There are adjustments planned
among enabling areas, for example, the budget for Leadership and Governance is reduced due to
strategic partnerships being captured as part of Strategic Planning and Resource Coordination in
2020-2021 as compared to 2018-2019, as well as strengthening planning and resource
coordination function across all levels. There is also an element of efficiency gains such as
paperless governing bodies meetings, which will reduce the costs of the Leadership and
governance area, more specifically.
e) Decrease in Polio eradication budget of ~ US$ 105 million reflects the decision of the Polio
oversight board for the Global Polio Eradication Initiative budget for 2019-2023. Further details
could be found in the Information Note to Member States on Polio and Polio Transition.
22. The budget figures for 2020-2021 are based on the current status of planning as described in
the above paragraph. As such, they are subject to further adjustments.
USD 99 million “savings through reallocation and efficiencies”
23. In the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 presented to the Executive Board in
January 2019, the Secretariat indicated a projected amount of US$ 99 million “savings through
reallocation and efficiencies” that offsets part of the proposed budget increase.
24. This demonstrates the commitment of the Secretariat to create a more efficient and
economical Organization, able and ready to address the many new challenges in public health
and deliver on GPW13 strategic priorities.
25. To realize this, the development of the detailed plan will be guided by the following principles:
• sustainability;
• the Organization’s ability to perform its normative work is not compromised;
• the quality and the level of support to technical programmes is maintained or further
improved;
• the internal control structure is not weakened; unacceptable risks are avoided, and the
culture of compliance is maintained; and
8
• applied to all offices and not only to Headquarters
- The draft budget figures for the biennium 2020-2021 which were presented to the EB in January
2019 already incorporated the USD 99 Million projections, and therefore have already been
reflected in the respective proposed budget envelopes. In fact, in the area of management and
administration (i.e., efficiency gains from travel, meeting management, procurement), many
initiatives are now operational and already paying dividends and covers part of the USD 99 M
projected savings through efficiencies.
-
- Following the launch of the new travel policy, the change in business class entitlement resulted in
some 35% fewer business class tickets purchased in the second quarter of 2018. In addition, the
introduction of the Preferred Hotel Programme (PHP) will lower the per-diem rates for staff and
non-staff travelling to the most popular destinations, thus bringing the total amount of savings to
US$ 20 million globally on a yearly basis. Furthermore, a more strategic and closer coordination
of meetings in each Major Office will help avoid overlaps and reduce the amount of travel. In
addition, the enhancement of tools such as iLearn and other virtual training or capacity building
platforms will enable the Secretariat to reach out to a wider audience with less cost for travels
associated with centralized training.
26. In addition, a full scoping of efficiency gains is being done together with all Major Offices.
Some of the areas that have been identified include the following:
- Rigorous Review of human resources plans, including vacancies in line with the needs being
expressed in the country support plans and on the planning for the Global Public Health Goods
will be implemented. Aligning the supply side to the demand side brings responsiveness and
efficiency
- Relocating some functions from high-cost duty stations to less expensive locations would
produce savings for the Organization. Efforts made to outpost functions to Kuala Lumpur,
Budapest and Pretoria already proved this. This process should be guided by putting human
resources closer to delivery, increased access to highly-qualified local labour markets,
accessibility from and connectivity with the rest of the world, and other considerations to
ensure effective delivery.
- Finding efficiency savings from further improved outreach to suppliers, locally and
internationally. This can lower the cost of contracting external parties.
- As part of the transformation agenda, 13 business processes have been re-engineered and
this will help achieve efficiency savings through streamlining, eliminating duplication,
benefiting from greater automation of processes. Applying information technology tools that
drives efficiency savings in the long-run is also high in the agenda of strengthening IT
governance.
32. The Secretariat will be developing a detailed plan during the Operational Planning process to fully
scope and estimate the efficiency savings/gains from various initiatives.
9
Proposed budget appropriation resolution for the World Health Assembly
33. It is proposed that the Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 is appropriated at four strategic
priorities. This will offer budget flexibility necessary to accommodate integrated and interlinked
nature of outcomes. The Member States will provide a budget oversight at the strategic level of
billions where the contribution made to outcomes and impact is demonstrated and where there
is a need for both collective action and accountability.
34. Internally this will require determining and adjusting operational allocations from very high levels
downwards, requiring simultaneous balancing of strategic oversight with operational details. This
will be ensured through the strict adherence to the budget management policy across all Major
offices with regular reviews and monitoring. The budget management policy is built around the
following main principles:
- DG’s delegated authority to make budget transfers between appropriations as will be
approved and specified in the WHA resolution;
- A decentralized policy of operational budget management with Regional Offices
exercising authority to modify their total Base Programme budget up to 5%. This flexibility
ensures that Regions can respond to country office budget issues and thus country offices
can be more responsive to emerging needs / requests under the Base programme budget;
- In Headquarters the Director-General approves modification and/or increases of the
programme budget;
- Flexibility and responsiveness in handling budget for the outbreak responses.
Financing of the Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 under the new results framework
Improving financing of the programme budget
35. Financing the draft Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 also requires a transformation in the
way the Organization mobilizes resources.
36. A new draft resource mobilization and partnership strategy, 2019-2023 has been developed. It
aims to increase financing based on the following four approaches to meet the increased financial
target set in WHO’s investment case:
a. Employing tailored approaches to grow, diversify, and maintain funding from government
donors;
b. Build effective partnerships and increase funding from philanthropic donors;
c. Maintain and increase funding from funds, banks, and multilaterals; and
d. Explore and exploit funding potential of revenue producing activities.
37. It is envisaged that a new resource mobilization and partnership strategy will improve the quality
of the funding, increase funding potential at country level, and strengthen resource coordination
through streamlining grant management and systematic capture of future funding opportunities.
10
Increasing flexibility while strengthening accountability to donor funding
38. Once the plans and budgets are established, the question is how to align financing and resource
mobilization with the new results framework in ways that the Secretariat is able to demonstrate
accountability over the resources it received from Member States and donors.
39. The new results framework opens different avenues for donors to commit funding allowing for
greater convergence of donor objectives and investments opportunities for delivering health
impacts through WHO (See illustration on thematic funding below).
Figure 1: Available options for thematic funding windows
40. The new results framework allows for committing funds to support the Organization’s mission
(above the triple billion goals), the triple billion goals, the impact framework programmatic
targets, the outcomes, the output level or to support the implementation of specific programme
strategies and cross-cutting themes, with varying degrees of flexibility provided to WHO.
41. The new results framework and with additional measures that are already in place in the WHO’s
management system (ERP system) allows for the Secretariat to continue to receive, allocate,
implement, monitor and report as per donor agreement.
42. Following the earlier Tuberculosis example, when a donor invests in the implementation of the
End TB Strategy for WHO, the donor can choose to stipulate what flexibilities it wants to give WHO
to utilize the funding. Taking an example where the donor wants to direct the funding towards
the achievement of the End TB Strategy’s impact without specifying which interventions the
Secretariat should undertake in relation to this funding, WHO could then choose to invest in a
combination of health systems (e.g., Output 1.1.1). and disease specific related approaches
(Output 1.1.2). Even as the funding is used under the different outputs, WHO’s management
system would still be able ensure that the donor-specific funding was dedicated for achieving the
End TB Strategy impacts and be able to track, monitor and report back to a contributor on the
spending. This tracking is even more specific if the donor specifically earmarks the funding to
11
specific Budget Centres that are responsible for implementing the End TB Strategy in the
Organization.
43. Existing WHO’s standard operating procedures for planning, budgeting, grant management,
monitoring and reporting ensure the funding to be used as per donor agreement, track how it is
allocated and spent, and monitor and report on the results achieved.
Strengthening the normative work of the Organization
44. The GPW 13 requires WHO to build on its normative role, work seamlessly across programmes,
major offices and its three levels to achieve a measurable improvement in the health of people at
country level.
45. As part of the efforts to strengthen the important normative role of the Organization, the
Secretariat embarked on a rigorous process for identifying and prioritizing the Global Public Heath
Goods (GPHGs) that WHO commits to undertake during biennium 2020-2021. This is a critical
part of ensuring that the Organization can enhance and build on its normative role
46. GPHGs include all normative and standard setting products, data products and products
describing priority setting for innovation and research. Together these are the foundation of
WHOs normative work.
47. The ongoing GPHG process is, for the first time, enabling WHO to describe the extent of the
normative work undertaken by the Secretariat. It is also the first step towards ensuring that the
organization can dedicate its resources to the delivery of the GPHGs that deliver ensure
measurable impact at country level. Furthermore, where resource constraints require a
prioritization of GPHGs the process enables an evidence-based decision to be made. This is in line
with the vision of GPW 13 and the transformation agenda. The identification and prioritization of
GPHGs has been driven by three criteria:
o Demonstrable link to a clearly articulated need from countries through the country support
planning processes
o Responding to the needs articulated through the governing bodies mechanisms (e.g. WHA
resolutions, etc.).
o Responding to emerging needs (e.g. gene editing, artificial intelligence, etc.)
48. In addition, the process through which WHO produces GPHGs will need to change if they are to
deliver more impactful global public health goods. The aim is to ensure that all priority GPHGs
produced by WHO would adhere to the highest technical standards and are delivered in a
timeframe that meets the needs of countries and partners. Where each product is developed
through a process with managed and consistent quality assurance points, support for utilization
of methods to improve evidence synthesis and decision-making, and coordination of internal
services to support development. The development of each GPHG will be guided by a
comprehensive plan that outlines the steps from design through to dissemination,
implementation, and evaluation of the uptake and impact at country level.
49. This will require dedicating predictable and sufficient resources to produce them and to track
their results.
12
How Secretariat’s contributions (Outputs) will be measured and reported
50. The new results framework paves the way for a more robust measurement system for GPW13
and the programme budget (See Annex 1: New GPW13 Results Framework and Measurement
System). At the higher level of the results hierarchy (i.e. triple billion goals and outcomes), the
three-level measurement system, which provides the rigorous methodology for assessing
progress and achievement of GPW13 implementation, is currently being finalized. There is an
additional consultation process for finalizing the index that will measure the progress towards
attaining each of the ‘Billions’.
51. At the heart of demonstrating the Secretariat’s accountability for results is the assessment of the
Secretariat’s contributions to the achievement of the GPW13 triple Billion goals and outcomes,
by way of measuring the GPW13 Organization-wide outputs. The draft Proposed Programme
Budget 2020-21 has articulated 42 outputs encompassing the results under the direct influence
of the Secretariat.
52. The integrated nature of the results framework, in particular the outputs, calls for an innovative
way of measuring the outputs to promote real accountability and more meaningful measurement
of Secretariat’s delivery. To this end, the Secretariat is proposing a new approach for measuring
the outputs, departing from identifying large number of output indicators, which proved to be
insufficient to ensure transparency and accountability as they measure a small part of the
achievement of the outputs,
53. The new output approach to measurement adopts a Balanced Scorecard approach. In a Balanced
Scorecard approach, the Secretariat will be able to:
- prioritize what dimensions of the output will be measured
- communicate what specific result the Secretariat is trying to accomplish
- align the day-to-day work of each staff to contribute to the strategic targets
- measure and monitor progress towards strategic targets
54. This replaces the old approach of having enormous number of divergent output indicators that
are less reliable in measuring the Secretariat contributions and its inability to provide useful
information to guide implementation and link to individual accountability.
55. It takes a multi-method, multi-level approach to measuring the outputs. In this methodology, it
is proposed that each output is measured using six dimensions (See Figure 2 for illustration), which
includes:
1. Effective delivery of leadership functions
2. Effective delivery of global goods
3. Effective delivery of differentiated technical support
4. Impactful integration of gender, equity and human rights
5. Achievement of results in ways that lead to impacts
6. Delivering value for money
56. The first three of these dimensions relate directly to the GPW13 strategic shifts. The 4th and 6th
dimension puts additional emphasis on these two important cross-cutting elements that
13
enhances delivery. The 5th dimension ensures that the Secretariat’s delivery is sharply focused on
contributing to the impacts (higher level results in the results chain).
Figure 2. Illustration of the six dimensions to measure the outputs
Effective delivery:
Leadership function
4
3
Effective delivery: Global
2 Delivering value for money
Goods
1
0
Effective delivery: Technical Achievement of results in
support at the country level ways leading to impacts
Impactful integration of GER
57. These dimensions will be used to measure outputs under each of the Triple Billion goals and under
Outcome 4.1 on Data and Innovation. These dimensions are slightly modified for outputs under
4.2 (Leadership and Governance) and 4.3 (Management and Administration) replacing the
dimensions on global goods and technical support with ‘transparency and accountability’ and
‘expected services delivery’ to be more relevant.
58. Specific sets of attributes describe each of the dimensions and standardizes the way these
dimensions will be measured. In Annex 5 for detailed attributes to illustrate what is being
measured for each of the dimensions.
59. It is envisaged that the methodology will be applied consistently across the Budget Centres at all
levels of the Organization for each output to which they contribute. This means that the
Secretariat will have the ability to apply a standard measure of each of the implementing entity’s
contribution to the outputs. Because of the consistent and transparent approach, the
Organization will have the ability to pin point issues and identify where they occur in the chain for
producing results.
60. The assessment results will be presented to the Member States through the annual reporting of
the Programme Budget. An assessment rating for each of the outputs will be presented, which
will be an aggregate of the assessment of each of the Budget Centres at all levels. Progress can
be tracked by setting baseline and expected achievements for the biennium for each of the
dimensions.
61. This new GPW13 Balance Scorecard approach ensures that the assessment of the outputs is:
- Consistent - Outputs will be measured using similar sets of parameters
- Transparent – The assessment criteria is made available for each output
14
- Rigorous – the measurement method for each dimension will be laid out clearly, and the collection
of data will be done by each Budget Centre contributing to the output
- More objective – well-defined set of criteria and checklist will be provided for each output and a
validation mechanism will be put in place of the methodology itself and the assessment findings.
62. This new approach strengthens accountability by enabling more rigorous assessment of the
achievement of the outputs and contribution to impacts. Its aim of strengthening monitoring on
a regular basis, and providing more precise and timely information to be used for decision-making
during implementation, and holding implementation entities and individuals to account will also
help transform the Organization.
15
Annex 1. The new GPW13 Results Framework
- Programmatic targets
Assessing achievement of specific
impacts to which countries
contribute
Output Balanced Scorecard:
- Multi-dimentional
assessment
- Multi-method
- Bottom-up assessment of all
budget centres performance
16
Goal 1 billion more people benefiting from Universal Health Coverage
Improved access to essential medicines, vaccines, diagnostics and
Outcome 1.1. Improved access to quality essential health services 1.2. Reduced number of people suffering financial hardships 1.3.
devices for primary health care
Countries enabled to provide high-quality, people-centred health services, Provision of authoritative guidance and standards on quality, safety and efficacy
Countries enabled to develop and implement equitable health financing
1.1.1. based on primary health care strategies and comprehensive essential service 1.2.1. 1.3.1. of health products, including through prequalification services, essential
strategies and reforms to sustain progress towards universal health coverage
packages medicines and diagnostics lists
Countries enabled to produce and analyse information on financial risk
Countries enabled to strengthen their health systems to deliver on condition- Improved access to essential medicines, vaccines, diagnostics and devices for
1.1.2. 1.2.2. protection, equity and health expenditures, and to use this information to track 1.3.2.
and disease-specific service coverage results primary health care
progress and inform decision-making
Countries enabled to improve institutional capacity for transparent decision-
Countries enabled to strengthen their health systems to address population- Country and regional regulatory capacity strengthened and supply of quality-
Output 1.1.3. 1.2.3. making in priority-setting and resource allocation, and analysis of the impact of 1.3.3.
specific health needs and barriers to equity across the life course assured and safe health products improved
health in the national economy
Research and development agenda defined and research coordinated in line
1.1.4. Countries enabled to ensure effective health governance 1.3.4.
with public health priorities
Countries enabled to address antimicrobial resistance through strengthened
1.1.5. Countries enabled to strengthen their health workforce 1.3.5. surveillance systems, laboratory capacity, infection prevention and control,
awareness-raising and evidence-based policies and practices
Goal 1 billion more people better protected from health emergencies
Outcome 2.1 Countries prepared for health emergencies 2.2 Epidemics and pandemics prevented 2.3 Health emergencies rapidly detected and responded to
All-hazards emergency preparedness capacities in countries assessed and Research agendas, predictive models and innovative tools, products and Potential health emergencies rapidly detected, and risks assessed and
2.1.1 2.2.1 2.3.1.
reported interventions available for high-threat health hazards communicated
Proven prevention strategies for priority pandemic-/epidemic-prone diseases Acute health emergencies rapidly responded to, leveraging relevant national
2.1.2. Capacities for emergency preparedness strengthened in all countries 2.2.2. 2.3.2.
implemented at scale and international capacities
Output
Countries operationally ready to assess and manage identified risks and Essential health services and systems maintained and strengthened in fragile,
2.1.3. 2.2.3. Mitigate the risk of the emergence and re-emergence of high-threat pathogens 2.3.3.
vulnerabilities conflict and vulnerable settings
Polio eradication and transition plans implemented in partnership with the
2.2.4.
Global Polio Eradication Initiative
Goal 1 billion people enjoying better health and well-being
Outcome 3.1. Determinants of health addressed 3.2. Risk factors reduced through multi-sectoral action 3.3 Healthy settings and Health in All Policies promoted
Countries enabled to adopt, review and revise laws, regulations and policies to
Countries enabled to address social determinants of health across the life Countries enabled to develop and implement technical packages to address risk
3.1.1. 3.2.1. 3.3.1. create an enabling environment for healthy cities and villages, housing, schools
course factors through multisectoral action
and workplaces
Output
Countries enabled to address environmental determinants of health, including Multisectoral determinants and risk factors addressed through engagement with Global and regional governance mechanisms used to address health
3.1.2. 3.2.2. 3.3.2.
climate change public and private sectors, as well as civil society determinants and multisectoral risks
Goal More effective and efficient WHO better supporting countries
Financial, human, and administrative resources managed in an
Outcome 4.1. Strengthened country capacity in data and innovation 4.2. Strengthened WHO leadership, governance, and advocacy for health 4.3.
efficient, effective, results-oriented and transparent manner
Leadership, governance and external relations enhanced to implement GPW 13
Countries enabled to strengthen health information1 and information systems
and drive impact in an aligned manner at the country level, on the basis of Sound financial practices and oversight managed through an efficient and
4.1.1. for health,2 including at the subnational level, and to use this information to 4.2.1. 4.3.1.
strategic communications and in accordance with the Sustainable Development effective internal control framework
inform policy-making
Goals in the context of United Nations reform
WHO Impact Framework and triple billion targets, global and regional health The Secretariat operates in an accountable, transparent, compliant and risk
Effective and efficient management and development of human resources to
4.1.2. trends, Sustainable Development Goal indicators, health inequalities and 4.2.2. management-driven manner including through organizational learning and a 4.3.2.
attract, recruit and retain talent for successful programme delivery
disaggregated data monitored culture of evaluation
Effective, innovative and secure digital platforms and services aligned with the
Countries enabled to strengthen research capacity and systems, conduct and use Strategic priorities resourced in a predictable, adequate and flexible manner
4.1.3. 4.2.3. 4.3.3 needs of users, corporate functions, technical programmes and health
research on public health priorities and scale effective innovations sustainably through strengthening partnerships
Output emergencies operations
Planning, allocation of resources, implementation, monitoring and reporting
Safe and secure environment with efficient infrastructure maintenance, cost-
4.2.4. based on country priorities, achieving country impact and ensuring value for 4.3.4.
effective support services, and responsive supply chain, including duty of care
money and the strategic priorities of GPW 13
Cultural change fostered and critical technical and administrative processes
4.2.5. strengthened through a new operating model that optimizes organizational
performance and enhances internal communications
“Leave no one behind” approach focused on equity, gender and human rights
4.2.6.
progressively incorporated and monitored
17
Annex 2. Crosswalk of programme areas of the programme budget 2018-2019 to the outputs of the Proposed programme budget 2020-2021 (this is for illustrative purposes only; not to form part of the WHA draft proposed
programme budget 2020-2021)
18
Annex 3. Crosswalk of programme budget 2020-2021 outputs to the programme areas of the programme budget 2018-2019 (this is for illustrative purposes only; not to form part of the WHA draft proposed programme budget 2020-
2021)
19
Annex 4. Methodology and process to arrive at a crosswalk from the 2018-2019 to 2020-2021 results
structure
Following WHO’s Regional Committee meetings - during which the overall regional budgetary
envelopes were agreed for 2020-2021 - WHO Secretariat assessed the best way to crosswalk the
2018-2019 results structure into a GPW13-compatible one.
In the past, such tools proved very helpful in supporting budget centres go through their strategic
and operational planning phases, serving as a red line to ensure consistency between General
programmes of work. It also helped Member States in the transition from one General Programme
of Work to the next to see continuity of priorities, both in emphasis and budget figures.
To keep the development of this crosswalk simple and efficient, the Secretariat mobilized the
Category and Programme Area Networks to coordinate - throughout the three levels of the
organization – for each output within the 2018-2019 structure, the way it would be split in the 2020-
2021 ones.
Of course, the crosswalk depends very much on qualitative, and therefore subjective, assessments.
With the transformation from the GPW12 structure to the more cross-cutting GPW13 structure, the
work conducted across today’s Programme Areas output have components in many GPW13 outputs.
It was decided that each 2018-2019 output be split into a maximum of 5 2020-2021 outputs for
clarity and efficiency purposes.
Once all the feedback was received, aggregated and consolidated, the deliverable went back to the
Category and Programme Area Networks for a second and final round of iteration.
As a result, Annexes I and II present a double-dimension crosswalk, that links 18-19 outputs to 20-21
ones, as well as 20-21 outputs into 18-19 programme areas. The second dimension was engineered
to provide Member States with more clarity as to how the 20-21 proposed programme budget
mirrors within the 18-19 results structure.
20
Annex 5. Output Balanced Scorecard Dimensions and Attributes
For B1, B2, B3; and Pillar 4.1
1. Effective delivery – Leadership function 2. Effective delivery – Global Goods 3. Effective delivery – Technical support at the country level
‘Truth to power’ - evidence Initiation and completion Planning and prioritising
1.a. Deliver authoritative and influential advice to world leaders that 2.a. Prioritise, initiate and complete the agreed global goods in a
drives thinking on key public health risks and priorities timely fashion 3a. Effective planning and prioritisation to ensure that CSPs are relevant to
country needs, differentiated by capacity and vulnerability
Convening Quality Capacity building
1.b. Convene world experts to anticipate and address the key public 2.b. Develop high quality and relevant global goods, measured by 3.b. Build capacity as agreed/planned, including staffing and resources to deliver
health risks and challenges independent feedback the necessary country support
Negotiating and finding solutions Uptake and influence Implementation
1.c. Negotiate innovative solutions with Member States and public and 2.c. Achieve strong uptake, use and influence of global goods among 3.c. Implement agreed priorities in CSP on time and to quality standards
private partners to address politically sensitive issues targeted groups
Driving the agenda (keeping health on the radar) Adaptive and agile
1.d. Drive health issues up the political agenda through impactful 3.d. Ensure flexibility and responsiveness to changing needs and context in
communication and advocacy countries
Mobilizing and aligning resources Leveraging partnerships
1.e. Ensure human and financial resources are aligned and mobilized with 3.e. Demonstrate effective leveraging of partnerships at country level
strategic priorities and deliverables
4. Impactful integration of GER 5. Achievement of results in ways which ultimately will lead to 6. Delivering value for money
impact
Evidence & Analysis Results indicators Overall VFM
4.a. Develop high quality evidence and analysis to identify who is being 5.a. Progress on agreed indicators for your area (select up to 5 6.a. Overall VFM = effectiveness + equity combined (using ratings from other
left behind and why tailored to each output area) domains of performance), relative to expenditure
Reduce inequities Regional KPIs Choices to drive VFM
4.b. Use evidence in policies and programming to address barriers and 5.b. For countries, % of (regional) KPIs by output delivered to agreed 6.b. WHO is able to make managerial decision making to make choices and
reduce inequities standard (cf. AFRO framework) trade-offs which improve VFM
Accountability Tracer indicators Timeliness
4.c. Monitor and report inequities and use these to improve delivery of 5.c. Progress on tracer indicators of early impact (where available e.g. 6.c. Timeliness in disbursing and using available resources, addressing
results primary care coverage and link to WHO Impact Framework Targets) bottlenecks as required.
Capacity and resources Flexibility of resources
4.d. Build capacity and dedicate appropriate resources on GER 6.d. WHO is able to leverage flexible resources to maximize impact
Note: For some outputs (e.g. 1.1.2, 1.1.3, 4.1.1., further detailing of the attributes and measurement checklists might be needed more precise measurement of performance of specific area (diseases, conditions, health information
systems), thus enhancing accountability.
21
For Pillar 4 – 4.2 and 4.35
1. Effective delivery – Leadership function 2. Effective delivery – accountability 3. Effective delivery – client service delivery
1.a. Drive the health agenda in large multilateral fora 2.a. Comply with and promote the WHO regulatory framework Able to respond to clients’ needs in a timely manner
1.b. Support and implement transformation in a timely manner as agreed 2.b. Ensure senior management, programmatic leadership, Able to suggest solutions to clients’ needs within the existing regulatory
with Member States stewardship and ethical behaviour framework
1.c. Align CSP (or equivalent instruments) with national development Able to develop policies to ensure strengthening of the Able to successfully integrate the perspective of all three levels of the
plans and priorities accountability framework Organization in policy development processes
1.d. Ensure human and financial resources are aligned and mobilized to Able to transparently report on partnership engagement Able to build capacity in managerial and administrative areas across all three
strengthen capacity in countries. levels of the Organization
Able to establish and leverage functional networks to support service delivery
across the three levels of the Organization
4. Impactful integration of GER 5. Achievement of results in ways which ultimately will lead to 6. Delivering value for money
impact
Evidence & Analysis Overall VFM
4.a. Develop high quality evidence and analysis to identify who is being 6.a. Overall VFM = effectiveness + equity combined (using ratings from other
left behind and why domains of performance), relative to expenditure
Reduce inequities Choices to drive VFM
4.b. Use evidence in policies and programming to address barriers and 6.b. WHO is able to make managerial decision making to make choices and
reduce inequities trade-offs which improve VFM
Accountability Timeliness
4.c. Monitor and report inequities and use these to improve delivery of 6.c. Timeliness in disbursing and using available resources, addressing
results bottlenecks as required.
Capacity and resources Flexibility of resources
4.d. Build capacity and dedicate appropriate resources on GER 6.d. WHO is able to leverage flexible resources to maximize impact
5 As 4.2 and 4.3 are enabling functions, this framework does not seek to claim direct impact on countries; but more focusses on contributing to country offices.
22
Saatja:
[email protected] <
[email protected]>
Saaja:
[email protected]
Teema: WHO: C.L.8.2019. Informal consultation on the Proposed Programme Budget 2020-2021 (19 March) in the EB room
Dear Member States of the World Health Organization,
Please find attached an information note on the Budgetary Aspects of Polio Eradication and Polio Transition, which is also a background document for the Informal consultation on 19 March 2019.
The document is also available on the following website: https://www.who.int/about/what-we-do/thirteenth-general-programme-of-work-2019-2023.
Best regards,
WHO Secretariat