Terms of Reference - Expert Advisory Group (EAG)
The second review of the relevance and effectiveness of the WHO Global Code of Practice
on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel
The WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel (hereafter
“Code”) was adopted as resolution WHA63.16 in May 2010. The second review of the relevance
and effectiveness of the Code is scheduled to be undertaken during the period May - October 2019,
with findings from the review to be submitted to the 146th session of the Executive Board and the
Seventy-third World Health Assembly.
As per the first review, it is proposed that the review covers the following:
• Relevance: the extent to which the objectives, principles and articles of the Code continue
to be pertinent and can inform solutions related to the global challenges of the migration of
health personnel and health systems strengthening.
• Effectiveness: the extent to which the implementation of the Code’s objectives, principles
and articles have influenced actions and policies concerning health workforce strengthening
(such as those related to health workforce information systems, planning, education and
retention strategies) at country, regional and global levels. Is there evidence that countries
are changing directives and policies aimed at strengthening human resources for health in
line with the intentions of the Code? What is the success of a voluntary instrument in
comparison to other governance initiatives and instruments in global health?
Expert Advisory Group - The Code:
To facilitate that process, the Director-General will convene an expert advisory group (EAG), with
responsibility for the following:
• Review evidence consolidated by the Secretariat to assess the Code’s relevance and
effectiveness;
• Provide guidance on whether enhancement of the Code is needed to ensure its relevance
and effectiveness;
• Submit a report of its findings and recommendations to the Director-General in advance
of the 146th session of the Executive Board.
Process and timeline:
The WHO Secretariat will facilitate the work of the EAG. A first meeting will be organized in
June 2019 to initiate discussions related to the above-mentioned terms of reference. A second
meeting will be organized in October 2019 to finalize the report to the Director General. The
deadline for the report submission is October 2019. Other communication will take place by
teleconferences as needed.
1
EXECUTIVE BOARD EB144/25
144th session 12 December 2018
Provisional agenda item 6.3
Human resources for health
WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of
Health Personnel: third round of national reporting
Report by the Director-General
1. In 2010, following six years of deliberation, the Sixty-third World Health Assembly adopted the
WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel in resolution
WHA63.16.1
2. The Code is a comprehensive, multilateral framework that advances cooperation and information
sharing on health worker migration. It establishes ethical principles and practices for the international
recruitment of health personnel and the strengthening of health systems. Although non-binding in nature,
it includes a robust monitoring framework.
3. In 2016, the Sixty-ninth World Health Assembly noted the second report on implementation of
the Code.2 By the completion of the second round, 74 Member States had submitted national reports –
a substantial increase compared with the first round, during which 56 Member States reported.
4. This report on the third round of national reporting is submitted in line with the requirements of
Articles 9.2 and 7.2(c) of the Code. The content will form the basis for the second review of the Code’s
relevance and effectiveness in 2019, as called for by the Health Assembly in decision
WHA68(11) (2015).
5. An important context for this report is the adoption of the Global Compact for Safe, Orderly and
Regular Migration at the Intergovernmental Conference to Adopt the Global Compact for Safe, Orderly
and Regular Migration, held in Marrakech, Morocco, 10 and 11 December 2018. The final text of the
document includes important linkages to the Code. Of note, also, the United Nations Secretary-General’s
report on International Migration and Development,3 highlights the importance of the Code and health
workforce-related data to the broader migration agenda.
1 In resolution WHA57.19 (2004), on International migration of health personnel: a challenge for health systems in
developing countries, the Health Assembly requested the Director-General to develop a code of practice on the international
recruitment of health personnel.
2 See document WHA69/2016/REC/3, summary records of Committee B, fourth meeting, section 2.
3 United Nations General Assembly document 73/286.
EB144/25
Progress on implementation of the Code
6. Within the resources available, the Secretariat has supported the Code’s implementation and
monitoring, including technical cooperation and provision of support to Member States, and facilitating
the third round of national reporting by the designated national authorities.
Third round of national reporting: process and results
Designated national authorities
7. As at 4 October 2018, 113 Member States have provided contact information for their designated
national authorities with responsibility for exchanging information on health personnel migration and Code
implementation during the third round (see Table 1 and Fig. 1); 24 Member States did so for the first time.
Table 1. Number of designated national authorities, by WHO region
Region First round of reporting Second round of reporting Third round of reporting
(2012–2013) (as at 30 September 2015) (as at 4 October 2018)
African 13 12 13
The Americas 11 15 14
South-East Asia 4 7 10
European 43 43 42
Eastern Mediterranean 8 13 16
Western Pacific 6 24 18
Total 85 114a 113
a Consolidated figure of designated national authorities confirmed during the first and second rounds of reporting.
Submission of national reports: status as at 4 October 2018
8. Member States and the Secretariat collaborated to simplify the National Reporting Instrument
while maintaining consistency with its previous iterations. Data elements were harmonized with the tool
and reporting on national health workforce accounts (as urged on Member States by the Health
Assembly in resolution WHA69.19 (2016)). The Independent Stakeholders Reporting Instrument and
outreach were also strengthened to improve engagement with “relevant stakeholders” in the reporting
process.
2
EB144/25
9. As at 4 October 2018, 63 Member States (see Table 2) had submitted a national report.1 The
63 Member States concerned represent almost two thirds of the world’s population, and 16 of the
63 countries were reporting for the first time.
Fig. 1 Status of designated national authorities and submitted national reports, by Member States
– as at 4 October 2018
Designated National Authority available
No Designated National Authority
Designated National Authority available and national report submitted
Data not available
Not applicable
Table 2. National authorities that reported to the Secretariat, by WHO region
Region First round of reporting Second round of Third round of reporting
(2012–2013) reporting (as at 4 October 2018)
(as at 30 September 2015)
Report submitted Report submitted Report Report Submitted/
submitted in process in process
African 2 5 5 2 7
The Americas 4 8 7 2 9
South-East Asia 3 6 9 0 9
European 40 25 29 4 33
Eastern Mediterranean 3 5 6 5 11
Western Pacific 4 11 7 3 10
Total 56 60 63 16 79
1 The following Member States reported during the current round: Afghanistan, Armenia, Austria, Bangladesh,
Belarus, Belgium, Belize, Bhutan, Cambodia, Canada, China, Cyprus, Czechia, El Salvador, Estonia, Finland, Georgia,
Germany, Hungary, Iceland, India, Indonesia, Iran (Islamic Republic of), Iraq, Ireland, Italy, Jordan, Lao People’s
Democratic Republic, Latvia, Lithuania, Malaysia, Maldives, Malta, Monaco, Montenegro, Namibia, Nepal, Netherlands,
New Zealand, Nigeria, Norway, Panama, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Qatar, Republic of Moldova,
Saint Lucia, Sao Tome and Principe, Saudi Arabia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sri Lanka, Sweden, Switzerland, Thailand,
Timor-Leste, Trinidad and Tobago, United Republic of Tanzania, United States of America, and Zimbabwe.
3
EB144/25
10. Strong engagement is particularly evident in the South-East Asia Region, where more than
three quarters of its Member States have submitted a national report.
Selected results from submitted national reports (n = 63)
11. Altogether 57 Member States provided quantitative data, with 52 Member States providing data
on the five health professions (dentist, midwife, nurse, pharmacist and physician) that represent the
largest share of regulated health professions and which are most associated with international migration.
A total of 42 Member States provided data on the share of foreign-born and/or foreign-trained health
workers, with disaggregated data by country of training available for 26 Member States. This figure is
an improvement from the second round of reporting in 2016.
12. The data submitted by Member States provides new insights into the international mobility of
dentists, midwives and pharmacists.
13. Data on foreign-born and/or foreign-trained health workers provide evidence of a blurring of the
distinction between source and destination countries. The inference is that a simplistic binary narrative
of source/destination or sending/receiving countries is outdated. Countries that may previously have
been identified as source countries are themselves reliant on foreign-trained health workers.1
14. Member States also reported on policies and processes consistent with the Code. About 70% of
Member States (44 out of 63) identified that they had taken steps to implement the Code. Of these
44 Member States, 27 identified laws and policies, consistent with the Code, being introduced or
currently under consideration, and 23 identified good practices, consistent with the Code, being
encouraged and promoted among recruitment agencies.
15. Nearly half the Member States (29 out of 63) reported the use of bilateral, regional or multilateral
arrangements with respect to the international recruitment and migration of health personnel. Of these
29, 23 identified that the Code’s recommendations were incorporated in the arrangements. Notably,
55 separate bilateral, multilateral and regional arrangements with respect to international recruitment
and migration were notified to the Secretariat,2 and text and Internet links to 30 bilateral, multilateral
and regional arrangements were shared with the Secretariat.
16. This information complements the findings of the Secretariat’s analysis of trade in service
agreements notified to WTO and available through its Integrated Trade Intelligence Portal, which
identified 12 additional agreements with a health worker mobility component.
17. More than three quarters of Member States, 50 out of 63, requested technical support from the
Secretariat to strengthen implementation of the Code. Requests included support in the areas of
strengthening data, policy dialogue and development, and the development of bilateral agreements.
Member States also requested the Secretariat to enhance work of relevance to all countries, including:
the development, negotiation and implementation of bilateral agreements; the review of both the criteria
1 For example, the following percentages of health workers were reported as having been foreign trained: 83% of
medical doctors in Bhutan; 12% of medical doctors in El Salvador; 10% of dentists in the Islamic Republic of Iran; 70% of
medical doctors in Jordan; 11% of medical doctors, 9% of pharmacists and 7% of nurses in the public sector in Lao People’s
Democratic Republic with numbers rising to 40% in the private sector; and 17.5% of medical doctors and 50% of
pharmacists in Zimbabwe.
2 China additionally identified health personnel-related arrangements for government-to-government cooperation
with 56 countries.
4
EB144/25
and the list of countries with critical health workforce shortages; and the strengthening of the network
of designated national authorities to further facilitate information exchange.
Independent stakeholders’ reports
18. As at 4 October 2018, 14 independent stakeholders’ reports have been submitted to the
Secretariat. This figure is an improvement from the second round when there was only one such
submission. The 14 submissions in the third round were received from diverse stakeholders including
academia, civil society, national regulatory bodies and international federations. They included country
case studies, progress reports and recommendations for implementation of the Code, description of and
perspective on bilateral agreements, and requests for technical support.
Targeted support for implementation of the Code at country and global levels
Support from the European Union and Norway
19. Financial support from the European Union and Norwegian Agency for Development
Cooperation enabled the Secretariat to provide targeted support for advancing implementation of the
Code in five countries – India, Ireland, Nigeria, South Africa and Uganda – and at the global level. The
work has provided a more dynamic understanding of health worker migration, with substantial
intraregional, South–South and North–South movement. It has also informed policy dialogue and
development.1
Establishment of the International Platform on Health Worker Mobility
20. In 2016, responding to the increasing volume and complexity of health professional migration,
the United Nations Secretary-General’s High-Level Commission on Health Employment and Economic
Growth called on ILO, OECD and WHO to establish an international platform on health worker mobility
in order to advance dialogue, knowledge and international cooperation in the area, including support to
strengthening of implementation of the Code. In 2017, the Seventieth World Health Assembly in
resolution WHA70.6 on human resources for health and implementation of the outcomes of the United
Nations’ High-Level Commission on Health Employment and Economic Growth adopted the five-year
action plan on health employment and inclusive economic growth (2017–2021) with the United Nations
General Assembly also supporting its operationalization in resolution 71/159.
21. At the first meeting of the International Platform (Dublin, 14 November 2017), on the margins of
the 4th Global Forum on Human Resources for Health, Member States, representatives of regional
organizations and international organizations shared information on the challenges and opportunities to
maximize the benefits from health worker mobility.2
22. Thirty Member States attended the following meeting of the International Platform (Geneva,
13 and 14 September 2018). Participants discussed promising policy measures and proposed strategic
actions to strengthen the management and governance of health worker mobility. As in the third round
1 See A dynamic understanding of health worker migration (www.who.int/hrh/HWF17002_Brochure.pdf, accessed
29 October 2018).
2 See http://www.who.int/hrh/news/2017/high_level-dialogue-int-health-worker-migration-meeting-
summary.pdf?ua=1 (accessed 29 October 2018).
5
EB144/25
of reporting, Member States requested the Secretariat to strengthen information sharing; to support the
development, implementation and monitoring of bilateral agreements; to review the criteria and list of
countries with critical shortages as part of the second review of the Code’s relevance and effectiveness;
to strengthen information and policy at the national level; and to maintain knowledge repositories in
relevant areas (containing, for example, the texts of bilateral agreements, national competency
frameworks and mapping of qualifications across jurisdictions).1
The way forward
23. In collaboration with Member States and independent stakeholders the Secretariat will seek to
further strengthen the reporting on the third round ahead of the Seventy-second World Health Assembly.
24. The Secretariat will seek to provide support in response to all requests for technical assistance
from Member States and independent stakeholders. Member States’ requests rose to 50 in 2018 – a
significant increase. In order to service this level of demand, the Secretariat, together with ILO and
OECD, will continue dialogue with Member States, bilateral, multilateral and philanthropic agencies to
identify financial resources for the Working for Health Multi-Partner Trust Fund, which serves as a
pooled mechanism to implement the Code and the International Platform on Labour Mobility.
25. As called for by the Health Assembly in decision WHA68(11) (2015) on the Code and as indicated
in the timeline shown in Fig. 2, the Secretariat is preparing for the further assessment of the Code’s
relevance and effectiveness. The findings of the second review, scheduled to be undertaken during the
period May–October 2019, will be submitted to the Seventy-third World Health Assembly.
Fig. 2 Timeline for further assessment of the Code
26. The process for the second review of the Code’s relevance and effectiveness will adopt the
mechanism successfully applied in the first review.2 As was done in the first review, the Director-
General will convene an expert advisory group with the task of preparing and conducting the review.
The expert advisory group will consist of 20 members, comprising 12 representatives of Member States
(two nominated from each WHO region) and eight representatives of organizations with institutional
knowledge of the Code’s development, negotiation and implementation and individual experts. The
group shall elect, from among its members, two co-chairpersons. The Secretariat will provide support
for the work of the expert advisory group.
1 See http://www.who.int/hrh/migration/InternationalPlatformHealthWorkerMobilityMeetingNotes.pdf?ua=1
(accessed 29 October 2018).
2 As described in document EB136/28, noted by the Executive Board at its 136th session (see document
EB136/2015/REC/2, summary records of the eighth meeting, section 3).
6
EB144/25
ACTION BY THE EXECUTIVE BOARD
27. The Board is invited to note this report and request the Secretariat to submit an updated version
to the Seventy-second World Health Assembly; to encourage all Member States to designate a national
authority and to report during the third round of national reporting; and to request the Director-General
to proceed with the second review of the Code’s relevance and effectiveness.
= = =
7
Saatja: WHO EURO HRH Framework for Action <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 15.03.2019 16:24
Adressaat: Elen Ohov <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Triin Uusberg <
[email protected]>; SM Info <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; REINAP, Marge
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; EURO Strategic Relations
with Countries <
[email protected]>
Teema: Letter from WHO EUROPE
Dear National Counterpart,
Please find attached important communication for your attention.
Kind regards,
HRH Programme
WHO Regional Office for Europe
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION
ORGANISATION MONDIALE DE LA SANTÉ
WELTGESUNDHEITSORGANISATION Date: 15 March 2019
ВСЕМИРНАЯ ОРГАНИЗАЦИЯ ЗДРАВООХРАНЕНИЯ
REGIONAL OFFICE FOR EUROPE Ms Elen Ohov
BUREAU RÉGIONAL DE L’EUROPE
REGIONALBÜRO FÜR EUROPA
Adviser
ЕВРОПЕЙСКОЕ РЕГИОНАЛЬНОЕ БЮРО European Union Affairs and International Co-
Head office:
operation Department
UN City, Marmorvej 51, Ministry of Social Affairs
DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark Suur-Ameerika 1
Tel.: +45 45 33 70 00; Fax: +45 45 33 70 01
Email:
[email protected] 10122 Tallinn
Website: http://www.euro.who.int Estonia
Our reference: Your reference:
Notre référence: Votre référence:
Unser Zeichen: Ihr Zeichen:
См. наш номер: На Ваш номер:
Dear Ms Ohov,
The WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health Personnel (hereafter
“the Code”) was adopted as resolution WHA63.16 in May 2010. Following the first review of the
relevance and effectiveness of the Code (WHA 68/32 Add.1), consistent with Code Article 9.5, the
World Health Assembly decided that a further assessment of the Code’s relevance and effectiveness
should be considered in line with the third round of national reporting (WHA 68 (11)).
The second review of the relevance and effectiveness of the Code is scheduled to be undertaken
during the period June to October 2019, with findings from the review to be submitted to the 146th
Executive Board and the 73rd World Health Assembly.
As clarified in EB document 144/25, the process for the second review of the Code’s relevance and
effectiveness will adopt the mechanism successfully applied in the first review. The Director-General
will convene an expert advisory group (EAG), with the task of preparing and conducting the review.
The EAG will consist of 20 members, comprising 12 representatives of Member States (two
nominated from each WHO region) and 8 representatives of organizations with institutional
knowledge of the Code’s development, negotiation and implementation and individual experts. Terms
of Reference for the EAG and document EB/144 are enclosed.
Member States with a potential interest in contributing to this process as Member State representatives
of the WHO European Region are requested to indicate same in writing to Ms Gabrielle Jacob,
Programme Manager. Human Resources for Health Programme, Division for Health Systems and
Public Health by email (
[email protected]) no later than 5 April 2019.
The determination of nominations for the WHO European Region will be undertaken by the Regional
Director taking into account considerations including ensuring geographical balance and distribution
across the Region, representation from predominantly source and predominantly destination countries,
and experience of engagement with the provisions of the Code.
UN City, Marmorvej 51 Tel.: +45 45 33 70 00 Email:
[email protected]
DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø Fax: +45 45 33 70 01 Website: http://www.euro.who.int
Denmark
With sincere appreciation for consideration of this request.
Sincerely yours,
Dr Hans Kluge
Director, Division of Health Systems and Public Health
Encls:
Human resources for health: WHO Global Code of Practice on the International Recruitment of Health
Personnel: third round of national reporting; Report by the Director-General;
Terms of Reference - Expert Advisory Group (EAG)
Copy for information to:
Ms Pille Saar, Healthcare Services Department, Health Board, Paldiski mnt 81, 10617 - Tallinn, Estonia
Ms Triin Uusberg, Head, European and International Coordination Department, Ministry of Social Affairs,
Suur-Ameerika 1, 10129 Tallinn, Estonia
H.E. Mr Andre Pung, Ambassador, Permanent Mission of the Republic of Estonia to the United Nations Office
and other international organizations in Geneva, Chemin du Petit-Saconnex 28A, CH-1209 Genève,
Switzerland
H.E. Mr Märt Volmer, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary, Embassy of the Republic of Estonia,
Frederiksgade 19, 4th floor, 1265 Copenhagen K, Denmark
Ms Marge Reinap, Head of WHO Office, WHO Country Office, Estonia, Paldiski Road 81, 10617 Tallinn,
Estonia
–2–