Saatja: Endrik Kriisa </O=MAJANDUS-TEEDE-SIDEMINISTEERIUM/OU=FIRST ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=ENDRIK.KRIISA>
Saaja: '
[email protected]' (
[email protected])
Teema: Geneva 1984 Agreement
Our ref: 6.15-5/12-0792-002
6.15-5/12-1370-002
Your ref: 5082/721/2012
10943/721/2012
e-mail on 12.10.2012
e-mail on 16.10.2012
Dear Madam/Sir,
After reviewing your letters (ref) containing differences in calculation results for Finnish transmitters HÄMEENLINNA 98.2 MHz, LAHTI 101.0 MHz, ESPOO 91.1, 98.1 and 102.9 MHz I would like to inform you of the following:
Because the administrations of Estonia and Finland have no mutual VHF/FM related agreement, the GE84 is generally used. But this agreement is quite old and might be interpreted differently. In addition the GE84 describes mainly the calculation criteria that have been used during preparation of GE84 plan, but does not specify clearly if the same criteria should also be used for coordinating processes.
Looking at results it seems that we use different calculation parameters for coordination of VHF/FM transmitters. I would be very glad if we could come to a mutual consent regarding calculation method. And as I understand we both use the LS Telcom software which should make our task more easier if to use the same approach.
The main questions are:
1. Which calculation model is used – P.370? P.1546? Database? Terrain?
2. How many strongest interfering transmitters are taken into account? 20?
3. What should be considered as a service area to be protected? F-contour? I-contour?
4. How high is the allowable increase of usable field strength? 0.5dB? 0.3dB?
5. Which summation algorithm to use for usable field strength calculation? Simplified multiplication? Power sum?
6. Is the antenna discrimination used?
7. Is the polarization discrimination used?
8. Which land-sea discrimination method to use? ITU? ERO? IDWM?
Estonian administration uses the ITU-R P.1546-Database propagation model, as P.370 is suppressed. We take into account 20 strongest interferers and the IDWM land-sea discrimination model. We use I-contour as a service area, because it takes into account the interferences from other transmitters and reflects a more realistic coverage. Usable field strength is calculated in case of Finland with simplified multiplication method using 0.5 dB allowable threshold, and in case of Russia and Latvia with power sum method with 0.3 dB allowable threshold. Antenna and polarizations discriminations are being used.
We also would like to specify the time for replay to coordination requests. In practice we use up to 90 days.
Calculations show that the polarization and antenna discrimination option could change significantly the outcome result, which seems to be the biggest difference cause in our coordination mismatch. Are there any clear reasons why not to use those discriminations? Pros/cons? So far I know that only Sweden does not use polarisation and antenna discrimination. But other neighbouring countries take it into account in calculations.
The same topic was raised in early 2011, when I sent an e-mail to
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]> (on 11.04.2011), but no answer has been received.
Your comments will be appreciated.
Best regards,
Endrik Kriisa
Chief Specialist
Frequency Management Department
+ 372 667 2131
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]>
Estonian Technical Surveillance Authority
Sõle 23 A
10614 Tallinn
ESTONIA
[email protected] <mailto:
[email protected]>
www.tja.ee <http://www.tja.ee/>