POSITION PAPER
About a future
"EU Railscanner"
BRUSSELS, 4th November 2020:
ALLRAIL, the Alliance of Passenger Rail New Entrants in Europe, represents
independent passenger rail companies: both operators and digital rail ticket
sales platforms (otherwise known as "ticket vendors"). We promote competition
in the passenger rail market, aiming for an EU regulatory environment that
encourages innovative & attractive rail services.
INTRODUCTION:
In a joint letter sent to the EU Commissioner for Transport Mrs Adina-Ioana
Vălean in June 2020, twenty-four European countries stated that:
"Rail travellers have long called for an online platform similar to “Skyscanner”’
to be set up, perhaps by the EU ".1
We welcome the initiative of the current EU German Presidency to boost and
facilitate cross-border travel by trains
Then, during a conference hosted by the German Presidency of the EU Council
on September 21st 2020, EU transport ministers discussed the opportunity to
launch a joint booking platform – a so-called “EU Railscanner” in reference to
the aviation digital platform Skyscanner – for international passenger rail
services. In recent months, many other EU stakeholders (e.g. climate NGOs2)
have also called for setting up such a digital platform, where consumers can
find all available rail options to plan and book a one-way journey across all
passenger rail operators, regardless whether incumbent or new entrant.
(Continued Overleaf)
Page 1 of 7
1
https://www.euractiv.com/section/railways/news/24-countries-sign-pledge-to-boost-international-rail-routes/
2
https://www.railwaygazette.com/in-depth/ngos-propose-five-policies-for-climate-friendly-european-rail-
renaissance/57390.article
Consequently, the current German Presidency of the Council of the European
Union is apparently working right now on a concrete proposal on how to realise
such an EU Railscanner.
Indeed, it is very good that the European Union is taking the lead to look into how
booking and purchasing of tickets for sustainable mobility can be facilitated,
especially within the framework of the upcoming “Year of the Rail 2021”.
Ultimately, this is the perfect moment to unite all relevant stakeholders around
the table for an in-depth discussion on the future of mobility and rail services.
This is why we would also like to share our vision on the necessary prerequisites
for the successful introduction of an EU Railscanner.
WHY SETTLE FOR ONE - WHEN YOU CAN HAVE MANY?
The good news is that the work does not need to start from scratch. Across
Europe, there are already nine independent digital platforms that enable
customers to choose between different rail options and providers 3. Companies
like Omio, FromAtoB, Tictactrip or Koleo, to mention just a few, already offer
customers the choice between different rail operators in an impartial and
transparent way. They can also combine tickets of different operators to
provide customers with the most optimal (cheapest or fastest) multi-leg
journey between two rail stations, especially across EU borders.
These platforms are all privately owned independent digital rail platforms thus
demonstrating the full confidence that private investors have in them. For
example, in August 2020, German-based platform Omio managed to raise and
additional US$ 100 million of capital4, showing that investors are still willing to
invest in public transportation and believe in the resilience of the sector, despite
the COVID-19 crisis.
(Continued Overleaf)
Page 2 of 7
3
Please see the list at the bottom of this article: https://www.railwaygazette.com/passenger/call-for-booking-
platforms-to-be-given-access-to-train-operators-data/57521.article
4
Please see this article in the German business newspaper “Handelsblatt”: https://s3.eu-central-
1.amazonaws.com/uploads.mangoweb.org/allrail/prod/uploads/2020/08/Omio-schlie%C3%9Ft-neue-
Finanzierungsrunde-ab-%E2%80%93-Beschwerde-u%CC%88ber-Bahn-1.pdf
WE SHOULD SUPPORT THE GROWTH OF THESE EXISTING PLATFORMS -
RATHER THAN CREATE A NEW ONE
In reality, there is no need for a new EU taxpayer-funded platform as many such
impartial digital rail platforms already exist and have the technology ready and
functioning. Further, when the incumbent railways attempted in the past to
create a new booking platform ‘Railteam Broker’5, it failed fairly miserably – the
main change since then is that rail competition is now a reality and incumbents
should be competing with each other, not forming competition-distorting rail
ticket sales alliances.
It would be much easier to introduce a regulatory framework to make rail
ticketing less complex and fragmented at no additional cost, rather than
creating a new platform. All existing digital rail platforms can play their role as
EU rail scanners, provided the necessary market conditions are implemented.
The fact that this is not just one platform also guarantees that there will be the
necessary competition between different platforms to avoid the creation of a
monopoly or a dominant market position. Supporting their growth also is fully in
line with the EU ambition to support the creation and durability of homegrown
EU Technology Champions in critical sectors such as mobility.
To further support their development, there are several obstacles to the
creation of a truly single European market for travel and ticketing that still need
to be overcome.
Unfortunately, as many infraction procedures in EU Member States illustrate, a
significant number of state-owned rail operators continue to abuse their
market dominant position to impose unfair business practices and
discriminatory behaviour that hinders the development of such “Railscanners”.
(Continued Overleaf)
Page 3 of 7
5
https://www.railwaygazette.com/news/railteam-bids-to-relaunch-international-rail-travel/32212.article
These obstacles should be addressed as follows:
- Mandatory equal access to all necessary data
Essential information and real-time data, such as live travel information about
delays and cancellations, must be shared with independent digital rail
problems. We can see what happens when this does not take place:
• In recent months, the state-owned rail operator Deutsche Bahn ('DB') in
Germany has denied independent digital platforms access to a new kind of
data that is crucial for public safety: train occupancy information that helps
maintain social distancing during the pandemic.
• The anti-competitive strategy behind this policy is give exclusive access to
this data only to DB's in-house digital rail platform so that customers think
that they have a safer, less risky experience when booking directly there than
when using an independent digital rail platform.
• DB's in-house digital platform therefore receives a unique selling proposition,
which it then aggressively advertises:
DB is commercialising public safety:
Here is a poster advertising how social distancing data is available on DB's in-house digital rail
platform App "DB Navigator"- But no independent digital rail platform has access to such data!
(This advertisement spotted at a bus stop in Cologne, Germany, on 25th October 2020 )
Germany's competition regulator, the "Bundeskartellamt", has opened a formal
investigation against DB's behaviour vis-à-vis independent digital rail platforms
and is expecting to come out with its conclusions in the coming months.
Page 4 of 7 (Continued Overleaf)
The corrective solution is as follows: EU Member States must ensure that publicly
owned market dominant rail incumbents give equal access to the same data
to all digital rail platforms, both in-house and independent. Competition
between digital platforms should not be in terms of who has better access to
data but instead about who makes better use of it for the benefit of passengers,
providing the most user-friendly One Stop Shop.
- Commercial terms must be fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory
(‘FRAND’)
“Competition in the rail sector depends on competition in sales, i.e. beginning
with the sale of rail tickets” said Andreas Mundt, President of the German Federal
Cartel Office in 20166. Market dominant rail incumbents must offer to
independent digital rail platforms the same FRAND conditions that they offer to
their in-house digital rail platforms.
First, this means that independent digital rail platforms should be able to sell all
tickets and fares in all markets and channels, without marketing restrictions –
to ensure maximum exposure for all EU passenger rail products. This will
increase the share of voice for passenger rail.
Secondly, the market dominant, state-owned rail incumbents should not pay
lower commissions to independent digital rail platforms than what they pay to
their in-house digital rail platforms or indeed to the in-house digital rail
platforms of other incumbents, resulting in independent digital rail platforms
having to charge more at the expense of customers.
We call on the EU Commission to introduce a robust EU legislative framework
that provides for a fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory environment for
both independent and incumbent in-house digital rail platforms.
(Continued Overleaf)
Page 5 of 7
6
Press release by German Federal Cartel Office in 2016 about the German rail incumbent agreeing to make changes
to the previous rail ticket sales arrangements in Germany:
https://www.bundeskartellamt.de/SharedDocs/Meldung/EN/Pressemitteilungen/2016/24_05_2016_DB_Fahrkarten.html
- Possibility to offer passengers the same rights, including as part of a
combined journey
Independent digital rail platforms also offer the possibility to combine separate
tickets from different operators into a one-way journey as part of the same
booking transaction (adhering to standard minimum connection times), thus
removing the complexity that many passengers face when they are trying to
book domestic and cross-border rail tickets. Such combinations of separate
tickets from different operators open a myriad of better rail options (i.e. cheaper
and/or faster) to passengers than through tickets with one sole operator.
However, for such rail options to be attractive for passengers, they should offer
the same rights in the case of delay or cancellation for the entire one-way
journey (i.e. from the beginning until the end of the one-way trip), regardless of
which operators form part of the travel chain.
Alas, under the new provisional EU Rail Passenger Rights agreement between EU
Parliament and EU Council, passengers on multi leg journeys will only be
guaranteed basic rights such as journey continuation if connecting trains are
run by a sole rail operator7, making through-ticketing across different operators,
as in many of the cases offered by independent digital platforms, less attractive.
Sadly, this myriad of better rail options that independent digital rail platforms
can offer will become more risky for passengers if they do not have passenger
right coverage from the beginning until the end of the entire journey.
Consequently, the fragmentation of ticketing in EU passenger rail will continue.
➢ Solution: Passenger rights should cover all combinations of different rail
operators for a one-way journey, not just those of one sole operator.
➢ Solution: There must be mandatory through ticketing for EU passenger rail.
We call on the EU institutions to address these gaps to help grow already
existing independent digital rail platforms into true EU Railscanners.
Not just one, but many of them. Only this will offer a sustainable solution and
lead to better quality of transport, improved choice, cheaper prices, higher
demand and an eco-friendly modal shift to rail.
Page 6 of 7
7
For more details on this specific point, please read here: https://www.beuc.eu/publications/reform-rail-passenger-
rights-eu-policymakers-fail-meet-passenger-expectations/html
Links: For more information please contact:
• www.allrail.eu Nick Brooks, Secretary General
• Twitter Tel +32 485 832 991; Email
[email protected]
• LinkedIn
• YouTube channel
• Podcast
• Instagram
About ALLRAIL
ALLRAIL, the Alliance of Passenger Rail New Entrants in Europe, represents
independent passenger rail companies – both operators and digital rail ticket sales
platforms (otherwise known as "ticket vendors"). ALLRAIL promotes competition in
the passenger rail market, aiming for an EU regulatory environment that
encourages innovative & attractive rail services. Our members share the belief that
faster market opening is the only way to help Europe achieve its ambitious climate
change targets as set down in the EU Green Deal. ALLRAIL was established in May 2017,
and is based in Brussels, Belgium. It is also a member of the Group of Representative
Bodies in the EU rail sector. For more information please go to: www.allrail.eu
Page 7 of 7
Saatja: Silver Tammik <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 06.11.2020 08:54
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Yana Laurand <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: NEW * Position Paper * about an EU 'Railscanner'- rail
equivalent of Skyscanner
Tähtsus: Kõrgeim
Palun registreerida.
From: Taavi Aas Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2020 4:29 PMTo: Silver Tammik
<
[email protected]>Subject: FW: NEW * Position Paper * about an EU
'Railscanner'- rail equivalent of SkyscannerImportance: High
Edastan
Moonika
From: ALLRAIL Alliance of Rail New Entrants <> Sent: Thursday, November
5, 2020 2:16 PMTo: ALLRAIL Alliance of Rail New Entrants <>Subject: NEW *
Position Paper * about an EU 'Railscanner'- rail equivalent of
SkyscannerImportance: High
Good afternoon,
In recent months, many European stakeholders have called for setting up
an 'EU Railscanner', an online platform similar to Skyscanner in the
airline sector, where all passenger rail options in Europe can be found
in one place.
The current German Presidency of the Council of the European Union is now
working on a proposal on how to realise such an EU Railscanner.
But there is no need for yet another EU Railscanner. After all, nine such
digital rail platforms already exist!
Please find our new position paper on this issue attached to this e-mail.
If you have any questions, then please do not hesitate to get in touch.
Thank you and kind regards,
Nick BrooksSecretary General
Alliance of Passenger Rail New Entrants in EuropeALLRAIL asbl+32 485 832
991
· · · ·