Leadership • Cross-Collaboration • Winning Practices
VOLUME 19 • ISSUE 1 • 2019 • € 22 ISSN = 1377-7629
Unblock
the
Chain
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
EDITORIAL, C. LOVIS
IS BLOCKCHAIN THE RIGHT TECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTHCARE? K. LARDI ET AL.
HOW BLOCKCHAIN WILL TRANSFORM HEALTHCARE, A. CAHANA
WHO STANDS TO BENEFIT FROM HEALTHCARE BLOCKCHAIN? A. NORMAND
BLOCKCHAIN SOLVES HEALTHCARE DATA OBSTACLES, E. SCHEUER
IS BLOCKCHAIN IMPACTING THE HEALTHCARE ARENA? J. GRAAFF
CAN BLOCKCHAIN SUPPORT ADVANCES IN RADIOLOGY? M. MARENCO
CAN BLOCKCHAIN CHANGE THE HEALTHCARE ECOSYSTEM? K. KURIHARA
BLOCKCHAIN FOR RADIOLOGY, B. RAMAN & K. CHANDRASEKARAN
BLOCKCHAIN AND GDPR COMPLIANCE FOR THE HEALTHCARE INDUSTRY, D. MANSET ET AL.
HEALTHCARE 2019: THE YEAR OF THE BIG DATA BLOCKCHAIN, F. RICOTTA & R. LAIDLAW
HOW TO ANALYSE PAST ENCOURAGING HEALTH APP USE SOLUS PROJECT, P. TARONI ET AL.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE FOR WITH SENIORS, E. GATTNAR
THE EVOLUTION OF LEFT
FUTURE SUCCESS, M. VIRARDI
A PATIENT’S JOURNEY IS VENTRICULAR ASSIST DEVICES,
HOW CAN AUTOMATION IMPROVE LIKELY TO INCLUDE SURFING M. PAPATHANASIOU & P. LUEDIKE
OUTPATIENT CARE WHILE THE WEB: HOW CAN WE HELP?
TRANSFORMING LIVES A DRONE
REDUCING COSTS? F. MACVEAN & C. ATHANASOPOULOU ET AL.
DELIVERY AT A TIME, C. IRERE &
G. FITZGERALD
PATIENT SAFETY CULTURE, A. KABBATENDE
PATIENT RESPONSIBILITY FOR L. RIBEIRO ET AL.
HEAT WAVES: A CLIMATE CHANGE
FOLLOWING UP ON TEST RESULTS,
A MULTIMODAL SYSTEM FOR THE CHALLENGE TO HOSPITALS’
ECRI INSTITUTE
DIAGNOSIS OF BREAST CANCER: THE RESILIENCE, S. GANASSI
ECR #507
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
JOIN our
AI Community
Connect with like-minded developers and
customers, across many areas of interest. Sign up
for an account and join the EnvoyAI Entourage.
https://www.envoyai.com/become-a-developer
EDITORIAL
Unblock the Chain
B
lockchain. What diverse reactions the mention of this technology gets
both within and without the healthcare setting.
There are those who are convinced that it’s going to transform not
only healthcare but society as well.
Others see it as a hyped-up technology beset with limitations which has
nothing constructive to offer the healthcare sector – or, at least, for many
years to come.
The truth probably lies somewhere in between.
The application of healthcare Blockchain is not a ‘black and white’ proposition.
It depends on what we are trying to achieve and to whom that achievement is Christian Lovis
Professor and Chairman
a priority. Who wants improved data security? What about healthcare trans- Division of Medical Information Sciences
action transparency? Let’s not forget the power a patient could gain through University Hospitals of Geneva (HUG)
IT Editor-in-Chief, HealthManagement.org
having control of their health data. And what about the cost of implementing
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
[email protected]
Blockchain in terms of energy and disruption?
@chr_lovis
It’s controversial and it’s not going to go away any time soon. This is why
HealthManagement.org is passionate about examining the potential of Block-
chain in healthcare head-on, with views from esteemed experts in the field.
In our first journal of 2019, we look at the myths and facts about Blockchain
technology. We examine the potential of tokenomics for healthcare players,
weigh in with CISOs and their front line perspectives on the tech, look at data
privacy and compliance and, of course, cover the financial power Blockchain
could give patients with their data.
It’s all exciting food for thought and we hope, after reading Unblocking the
Chain, you’ll have gained new insights into what Blockchain could mean for
healthcare.
As always, for a taste of innovation, turn to Winning Practices where we put
hospital sustainability, the latest cardiology devices, mHealth for seniors and
patient safety in Imaging processes in the spotlight.
We hope you’re inspired and motivated by what you read in these pages.
Happy 2019! May it be a successful year for healthcare.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 11
HealthManagement.org Editorial Board
Promoting Management and Leadership in Healthcare
IMAGING HEALTHCARE IT CARDIOLOGY
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF EDITOR-IN-CHIEF EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Prof. Lluís Donoso Bach Prof. Christian Lovis Prof. Tienush Rassaf
Hospital Clinic – University of Barcelona, Spain University Hospitals of Geneva Westgerman Heart- and Vascular Center, University of
[email protected] [email protected] Essen, Germany
[email protected]
HONORARY EDITOR-IN-CHIEF EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERS
Prof. Iain McCall João Bocas EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERS
UK (Retired) Digital Salutem, UK Prof. Gunter Breithardt
Miguel Cabrer University of Munster, Germany
EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERS University Hospital Son Espases, University of the Prof. Hugo Ector
Prof. Stephen Baker Balearic Islands, Palma, Spain University Hospital Leuven, Belgium
Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, U.S. Richard Corbridge Prof. Michael Glikson
Prof. Hans Blickman Leeds Teaching Hospital NHS Trust, UK Shaare Zedek Medical Center, Israel
University of Rochester Medical Center, U.S. Dr. Marc Cuggia Priv.-Doz. Philipp Kahlert
Prof. Edward I. Bluth Pontchaillou Hospital, France Universitätsklinikum Essen, Germany
Ochsner Healthcare, U.S. Prof. Georges de Moor Prof. Peter Kearney
Prof. Georg Bongartz State University of Ghent, Belgium Cork University Hospital, Ireland
University of Basel, Switzerland Prof. Jacob Hofdijk Prof. Alexandras Laucevicius
Prof. Davide Caramella European Federation for Medical Informatics, Vilnius University Hospital, Lithuania
The Netherlands
University of Pisa, Italy Prof. Fausto J. Pinto
Dr. Ai-Lee Chang Dr. Peter Gocke Lisbon University, Portugal
Amedes Medizinische Dienstleistungen, Germany
Guys and St Thomas NHS Foundation Trust, UK Prof. Piotr Ponikowski
Prof. Michel Claudon Prof. Werner Leodolter Clinical Military Hospital, Poland
University of Graz, Austria
University Hospital of Nancy, France Prof. Silvia G. Priori
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Prof. Alberto Cuocolo Prof. Eric Lepage University of Pavia, Italy
Hôpitaux de Paris, France
University of Naples Federico II, Italy Prof. Amiran Revishvili
Prof. Johan de Mey Prof. Miroslav Madjaric Scientific Center for Cardiovascular Surgery, Russia
University Hospital Centre Zagreb, Croatia
Free University of Brussels, Belgium Prof. Massimo Santini
Prof. Nevra Elmas Prof. Josep M. Picas San Filippo Neri Hospital, Italy
Adaptive HS, Spain
Ege University, Turkey Prof. Ernst R. Schwarz
Dr. Mansoor Fatehi Prof. Eric Poiseau Cedars Sinai Medical Center, USA
IHE Europe, France
Medical Imaging Informatics Research Center, Iran Prof. Dan Tzivoni
Prof. Guy Frija Prof. Karl Stroetmann Israel Heart Society, Israel
Empirica Communication & Technology Research,
Georges-Pompidou European Hospital, France Prof. Alex Vahanian
Germany
Assoc. Prof. Frederik L. Giesel Bichat Hospital, France
University Hospital Heidelberg, Germany Prof. Rudi van de Velde
University Hospital Brussels, Belgium
Prof. Wolfram Knapp
Hannover Medical School, Germany Ms. Diane Whitehouse
The Castlegate Consultancy, UK Industry ambassadors
Prof. David Koff
Hamilton Health Sciences; McMaster University, Canada Ing. Martin Zeman Marc De Fré, Belgium
CESNET, Czech Republic
Prof. Elmar Kotter Prof. Mathias Goyen, UK
University Hospital Freiburg, Germany Prof. Jana Zvárová Dr. Rowland Illing, UK
EuroMise Center, Czech Republic
Prof. Heinz U. Lemke Jurgen Jacobs, Belgium
IFCARS - International Foundation for Computer Assisted Ljubisav Matejevic, Germany
Radiology and Surgery; University of Leipzig, Germany Gregory Roumeliotis, USA
Prof. Lars Lönn
National Hospital, Denmark
Prof. Elisabeth Schouman-Claeys
APHP Medical Organisation Directorate; University of
Paris 7, France
What do you think?
Prof. Valentin Sinitsyn Do you think Blockchain can fulfill its promise for more secure and
Federal Center of Medicine and Rehabilitation, Russia
transparent healthcare or do we need to be cautious about its imple-
Dr. Nicola H. Strickland
Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, UK mentation across the sector? Let us know your views. As a leading
Prof. Henrik S. Thomsen digital and print publication on healthcare management and leader-
Copenhagen University Hospital; University of
Copenhagen, Denmark ship, there are many ways to share your expertise and join our faculty
Prof. Vlastimil Valek of highly-esteemed contributors. To contribute, contact us on edito@
Masaryk University, Czech Republic
Prof. Berthold Wein healthmanagement.org.
Group Practice, Aachen, Germany
AUTHORS
EXEC Christina
Athanasopoulou,
EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERS Christos Lionis, Frank Ricotta,
Maritta Välimäki Robert Laidlaw
A patient’s journey is likely Healthcare 2019: the
Philippe Blua to include surfing the web: Christian Lovis year of the Big Data
Hospital Center of Troyes, France how can we help?, p. 59 Unblock the chain, p. 1 Blockchain, p. 45
Juraj Gemes
F.D. Roosevelt University Hospital, Slovakia
Prof. Sir Muir Gray
Better Value Healthcare, Oxford, UK David Manset, Laura
Bernal, Mirko Koscina,
Sjaak Haakman Alex Cahana Octavio Perz Kempner Eberhard Scheuer
Reinaert Kliniek, The Netherlands How Blockchain will Blockchain and GDPR Blockchain solves
transform compliance for the healthcare data
Marc Hastert healthcare, p. 20 healthcare industry, p. 42 obstacles?, p. 24
Federation of Luxembourg Hospitals
Freddy Iemants
IRIS Ziekenhuizen, Belgium
Prof. Karl Kob Francesca MacVean,
General Hospital Bolzano, Italy Gareth Fitzgerald
How can automation
Heinz Kölking Edzard Ernst
improve outpatient
care while reducing Zisis Sotiriou
Lilienthal Clinic, Germany The essential truth, p. 10 costs?, p. 48 Digitizing healthcare, p.14
Nikolaus Koller
President EAHM Editorial Board, Austria
Dr. Manu Malbrain
Paola Taroni, Alberto,
University Hospital Brussels, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Dalla Mora, Alberto
Belgium Tosi, Peter Gordebeke
Maria Marenco A multimodal system
Chris McCahan Eva Gattnar
Encouraging health app
Can Blockchain support for the diagnosis of
breast cancer: the SO
advances in radiology?,
International Finance Corporation (IFC ) use with seniors, p. 55 p. 31 LUS project, p. 66
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
World Bank Group, USA
Louise McMahon
Health and Social Care Board, Northern Ireland
Dr. Taner Özcan
MLPCare, Turkey
Alexis Normand Peter Thorausch
Prof. Denitsa Sacheva David C. Humphreys Who stands to benefit Better outcomes through
clinical decision
Integrating labs into from healthcare
Council of Ministers, Bulgaria clinical care pathways, p.8 Blockchain?, p. 22 support. p. 52
Jean-Pierre Thierry
Synsana, France
Hans-Peter Wyss
Spital Davos, Switzerland
Maria Papathanasiou,
Claudette Irere, Peter Luedike Simona Agger Ganassi
Alline Kabbatende The evolution of left Heat Waves: a climate
Transforming lives a drone ventricular assist change challenge to
delivery at a time, p. 73 devices, p. 70 hospitals’ resilience, 76
REGIONAL ambassadors
Prof. Frank Boudghene
Tenon Hospital, France
Joan Marques Faner
Son Dureta University Hospital, Spain Kohei Kurihara Bhargav Raman, Kritikha Joe Van De Graff
Chandrasekran
Dr. Thomas Kaier Can Blockchain
change the healthcare Blockchain for
Is Blockchain impacting
the healthcare
King’s College London, UK ecosystem?, p. 33 radiology, p. 38 arena?, p. 28
Dr. Sergej Nazarenko
Estonian Nuclear Medicine Society, Estonia
Dr. Nadya Pyatigorskaya
Pitié Salpêtrière Hospital, France Kamales Lardi,
Christian Lovis, Luís Ribeiro,
Dr. András Vargha Mark Abrams, Axel Anabela Ribeiro
Schumacher Kevin Azevedo, Michael Virardi
National Centre for Patients' Rights and Documentation, Is Blockchain the right António Abrantes How to analyse past
Hungary technology for Patient safety professional experience
healthcare?, p. 18 culture, p. 62 for future success, p. 16
Anton Vladzymyrskyy
Virtual Hospital m-Health, Russian Federation
Ieva Vitola
P.Stradina Clinical University Hospital, Latvia
table of contents
HealthManagement.org • Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019
EDITORIAL
EDITORIAL SPOTLIGHT
SPOTLIGHT
1 Unblock the Chain 10 The essential truth
Prof. Edzard Ernst speaks about his critical evaluation of CAM,
Christian Lovis, Switzerland
including uncontrolled pseudoscience and violation of medical
ethics. He highlights where change is urgently needed.
Edzard Ernst, UK
POINT OF VIEW
POINT OF VIEW
8 Integrating labs into clinical management
MANAGEMENT MATTERS matters
care pathways
Based on Abbott-sponsored symposium at 16 How to analyse past professional
EAHM 2018 'Diagnostics, Data and Integrated experience for future success
Clinical Care - From Insight to Action. A New Year represents a time to focus, regroup and set
David C. Humphreys, Abbott new professional targets. Corporate trainer, Michael Virardi,
provides tips on getting the most out of reflection time.
14 Digitizing healthcare Michael Virardi, Cyprus
Affidea launches a cloud-based KPI Dashboard
and a KPI Mobile App to improve patient
experience and boost operations workflow.
Zisis Sotiriou, Affidea
COVER STORY: UNBLOCK THE CHAIN
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
COVER STORY: UNBLOCK THE CHAIN
52 Better outcomes through
clinical decision support 18 Is Blockchain the right
How can a clinical decision support system help to technology for healthcare?
achieve measurably better healthcare outcomes? Experts weigh in with their views on if Blockchain is the right
Peter Thorausch, Abbott technology for healthcare.
Kamales Lardi, Switzerland; Christian Lovis, Switzerland; Mark Abrams,
USA; Axel Schumacher, Germany
Disclosure
Point-of-view articles are part of the HealthManagement.org 20 How Blockchain will transform healthcare
Corporate Engagement Programme Adoption of distributed ledger technology will benefit patients and providers.
Alex Cahana, USA
22 Who stands to benefit from
healthcare Blockchain?
Could Blockchain revolutionise data security, research and monetisation
in healthcare?
Alexis Normand, USA
24 Blockchain solves healthcare data obstacles
How can tokenisation of health data benefit both patients and the sector?
Eberhard Scheuer, Switzerland
28 Is Blockchain impacting the healthcare arena?
Do C-levels think Blockchain has anything to offer healthcare in the
near future?
Joe Van De Graaff, USA
31 Can Blockchain support
advances in radiology?
Blockchain can establish secure, reliable and efficient processes
and tools for exchanging and leveraging the growing wealth
of imaging data.
Maria Marenco, Sweden
4 HealthManagement.org
Consistent results, from
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
every perspective.
NEW
Introducing Quantra™ 2.2 Breast Density Assessment
• Enables quick and accurate breast density assessments across your entire patient population.
• Includes texture and pattern analysis, offering more consistent, reliable breast density scoring.
• Available with the only mammogram superior for women with dense breasts compared to 2D
mammography alone.1,2
Learn more at 3DimensionsSystem.com
1. FDA submissions P080003, P080003/S001. 2. Results from Friedewald, SM, et al. “Breast cancer screening using tomosynthesis in combination with digital mammography.” JAMA 311.24 (2014):
2499-2507; a multi-site (13), non-randomized, historical control study of 454,000 screening mammograms investigating the initial impact of the introduction of the Hologic Selenia® Dimensions® on
screening outcomes. Individual results may vary. The study found an average 41% increase and that 1.2 (95% CI: 0.8-1.6) additional invasive breast cancers per 1000 screening exams were found in
women receiving combined 2D FFDM and 3D™ mammograms acquired with the Hologic 3D™ Mammography System versus women receiving 2D FFDM mammograms only.
ADS-01953-EUR-EN Rev 002 © 2017 Hologic, Inc. All rights reserved. Hologic, 3D, 3Dimensions, 3D Mammography, Quantra, Dimensions, Selenia, The Science of Sure, and associated logos are
trademarks and/or registered trademarks of Hologic, Inc. and/or its subsidiaries in the US and/or other countries. All other trademarks, registered trademarks, and product names are the property of
their respective owners.
table of contents
HealthManagement.org • Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019
COVER STORY: UNBLOCK THE CHAIN 62 Patient safety culture
Researchers evaluate radiographers’ perceptions about patient
33 Can Blockchain change the safety culture in Portuguese public and private imaging facilities.
healthcare ecosystem? Luís Ribeiro, Anabela Ribeiro, Anabela Ribeiro, António Abrantes,
Decentralised Blockchain platform connects healthcare facilities, Oksana Lesyuk, Rui Almeida, Sara Fernandes, Carlos Alberto da
radiologists and AI algorithms, enables radiologists and results Silva, Sónia Rodrigues, Portugal
in lower costs giving radiologists high quality expertise access.
Kohei Kurihara, Japan 66 A multimodal system for the diagnosis
of breast cancer: the SOLUS project
38 Blockchain for radiology The SOLUS project is developing an innovative, multimodal
Three key areas where Blockchain can potentially tomographic system, combining diffuse optics and ultrasound
spark a revolution in the current radiology framework, to support the in vivo diagnosis of breast cancer.
increasing quality while decreasing healthcare cost. Paola Taroni, Italy; Peter Gordebeke, Austria; Alberto Dalla Mora, Alberto
Bhargav Raman & Krithika Chandrasekaran, USA Tosi, Antonio Pifferi, Italy; Jean-Marc Dinten, Mathieu Perriollat,
David Savery, Hélène Sportouche, Bogdan Rosinski, France; Simon
42 Blockchain and GDPR compliance Arridge, UK; Andrea Giudice, Simone Tisa, Elena Venturini, Pietro
for the healthcare industry Panizza, Italy; Pamela Zolda, Austria; Ing. Alexander Flocke, Germany
How Blockchain can connect hospitals and research centres
to enable sharing of medical data (from medical records 70 The evolution of left ventricular assist devices
to radiology images) in a private Blockchain network. LVADs have transformed the treatment of heart failure. What
David Manset, Switzerland; Laura Bernal, Mirko Koscina, Octavio does increased usage mean for clinicians and patients?
Perez Kempner, France Maria Papathanasiou & Peter Luedike, Germany
45 Healthcare 2019: the year of 73 Transforming lives a drone delivery at a time
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
the Big Data Blockchain Rwanda leading the way with life-saving drone tech
Big Data Blockchains are solving healthcare’s Claudette Irere & Alline Kabbatende, Rwanda
security and scalability challenges and hold the
potential to transform the healthcare industry: from 76 Heat Waves: a climate change
decision support to patient empowerment to image challenge to hospitals’ resilience
data sharing and operational improvement. The scientifically based forecast of more frequent
Frank Ricotta, USA; Robert Laidlaw, Australia devastating natural disasters is coming, and so is the
need for a proactive attitude against the related risks
47 Unblock the Chain Infographic Simona Agger Ganassi, Italy
WINNING PRACTICEs
WINNING PRACTICES
I-I-I BLOG
I-I-I BLOG
48 How can automation improve outpatient
care while reducing costs? 80 Michael A.E. Ramsay
How can outpatient automation quickly deliver Chairman, Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Management
an impressive return on investment? Baylor University Medical Center, USA
Francesca MacVean & Gareth Fitzgerald, UK
Karim Boussebaa
50 Patient responsibility for Senior Vice President & General Manager of CT and AMI,
following up on test results Philips, USA
Test results: the patient responsibility
ECRI Institute, UK Matthew Gierc
Head of Marketing,
55 Encouraging health app use with seniors 3AG Systems, Canada
A digital health coaching platform offers sustainable
support of the elderly population. Daniela Pedrini
Eva Gattnar, Germany Vice President,
International Federation of Healthcare Engineering
59 A patient’s journey is likely to include
surfing the web: how can we help?
A “whole patient” can be a person with schizophrenia, who is
also an internet user and searches for mental health
information online.
Christina Athanasopoulou, Finland; Christos Lionis, Greece; Maritta
Välimäki, Finland
6 HealthManagement.org
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Working together to understand your needs and
challenges drives valuable outcomes that positively
impact you and your patients’ future.
Canon Medical’s vision and commitment to improving life for all, lies at the
heart of everything we do. By partnering to focus on what matters, together
we can deliver intelligent, high quality solutions.
With Canon Medical, true innovation is made possible.
http://eu.medical.canon
POINT OF VIEW
Integrating labs into clinical
care pathways
Based on an Abbott-sponsored symposium “Diagnostics, Data and Integrated Clinical Care
– From Insight to Action” presented at European Association of Hospital Managers (EAHM)
congress, Cascais, Portugal, 27th September 2018.
Introduction issues or in setting these performance targets, and
Pressure on healthcare systems continues to rise as there appears to be little connection between the
the world’s population grows and lives longer; factors labs themselves and patients. The good news is that
such as lifestyle and obesity also play a part, with healthcare is changing rapidly, creating an opportu-
the cost of diabetes, as an example, set to double nity for labs to play a larger role in the care continuum
by 2030 to $2.5 trillion at current rates of increas- by bridging the gap between various stakeholders.
ing incidence. Providing value-based healthcare in
this scenario can be challenging and unfortunately Managing appropriate testing
cost, not outcome, is often the overriding factor As the number of tests requested and performed
David C. in the development of healthcare pathways. The each year continues to grow rapidly, it is vital that
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Humphreys obvious answer to reducing the economic burden of unnecessary testing is minimised to conserve
Practice Head, Health
disease, while still increasing the standard of care, resources. With over $200 billion a year wasted
Policy & Clinical Evidence,
Economist Intelligence is to improve population health as a whole. Better in diagnosis and treatment monitoring in the US
Unit, Washington, USA
diet, regular exercise and maintaining wellbeing all alone, reducing this excess would increase clinical
contribute to this, and predictive healthcare and efficiency and release valuable funds that could be
screening programmes – rather than simply treat- redirected to other care areas. Increasing the daily
ing illness – are also key. Closer integration of labo- interaction between lab and clinical staff all along
ratories into these kinds of initiatives, as well as care the care pathway can help this by ensuring more
pathways in general, is essential in order to make sig- timely and appropriate testing. On the other hand,
nificant improvements and ultimately achieve better under-testing is also an immense problem globally.
healthcare.
healthcare is changing
The role of the lab rapidly, creating an opportunity
The laboratory plays a vital function in today’s
healthcare systems, with over 70% of medical deci-
for labs to play a larger role in
sions based on test results. However, the role of the the care continuum
lab is still undervalued, with many senior health-
care managers seeing it as just a service pro- For example, over 50% of diabetes cases go undi-
vider – reducing it to either a profit or cost centre agnosed in Sub-Saharan Africa, opening up the
– especially where there is more pressure on health potential for complications and the development of
budgets. In reality, labs offer so much more; 77% advanced disease in untreated individuals, and ulti-
of healthcare professionals would welcome more mately leading to even higher treatment and man-
support from the lab for results interpretation that agement costs in the long run. Picking up these
has a direct bearing on clinical decision making. missed cases is vital to reduce the future economic
The laboratory is also one of the most important burden of disease.
departments when it comes to hospital key perfor- Lab data is critical for identifying current or
mance indicators (KPIs), from A&E turnaround times emerging health issues and predicting future
and numbers of bed days to complication rates and trends, especially for chronic conditions asso-
patient satisfaction. Despite this, lab managers have ciated with multiple risk factors, such as diabe-
relatively little involvement in hospital management tes or heart disease. Powerful bioinformatics tools
8 HealthManagement.org
POINT OF VIEW
60%
and advanced analytical systems, as well as much
closer collaborations with other departments, will
help labs to use this data to drive operational excel-
lence and develop a more integrated approach to
healthcare. As previously stated, healthcare pro- of healthcare
fessionals are keen for laboratories to provide more professionals say
diagnostic guidance, and there is clearly a desire they want to learn
within the system to follow this approach. However,
about the latest
closer examination of the current recognition of
the lab’s role highlights distinct differences in per-
standards within
ception between stakeholders. More than 75% of the lab, but less
health executives believe the lab is already well inte- than 30% of labs
grated, and outwardly acknowledge the fact that it communicate this kind
directly impacts on a number of critical KPIs. But, of Information
on the whole, lab directors do not agree, and lab
staff themselves often fail to understand how their
metrics influence outside outcomes. The miscon-
77 %
ception over perceived roles, values and expecta-
tions can also lead to missed opportunities. For
instance, around 60% of healthcare professionals
say they want to learn about the latest standards
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
within the lab, but less than 30% of labs commu- of healthcare
nicate this kind of information. Getting all stake- professionals
holders on the same page, involving labs in setting
would welcome
organisational goals, and investing in advanced data
processing and analytics, are essential steps leading
more support from
to a shared vision that will direct healthcare towards the lab for results
both operational excellence and integrated care. interpretation that
has a direct bearing
Conclusion on clinical decision
No other discipline within a healthcare organisa- making
tion has a base of scientific knowledge similar to
that of the lab. It is an integral part of value-based
healthcare and, by investing in data processing and
analytics, there is an immense opportunity to bring
stakeholders together and ensure timely, evidence- Against the background of
based decisions. challenges facing healthcare
While patients remain the focus for healthcare, today, labs offer so much more
organisational support is key to improving care. This for both outcomes and patient
begins with understanding an organisation’s current experience.
status and, from there, you can identify what steps No other discipline has a base
must be taken, and in what order, to make the most of knowledge to match it for
positive impact. All of these actions are under- better diagnoses and
pinned by health value and the outcomes of health- predictive medicine.
care, which not only affect individuals’ wellbeing,
but also have wider socio-economic implications.
The ultimate aim must be to move towards a more
integrated healthcare continuum, better diagnoses Download your copy of the white
paper "An Urgency for the
and predictive medicine, that together will lead to
Clinical Laboratory to Move to
improvements in both outcomes and patient expe-
the Forefront of Patient Care"
rience.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 9
SPOTLIGHT
Edzard Ernst
Emeritus Professor of
Complementary Medicine
Peninsula School
of Medicine
The essential truth
University of Exeter
Exeter, UK
[email protected]
Critical evaluation of complementary and
@EdzardErnst
edzardernst.com
alternative medicine
Due to a reverence for scientific truth in an area of healthcare
that is hazardously left uncontrolled, Professor Edzard Ernst left
his position as chair of physical and rehabilitation medicine at
the Medical Faculty of Vienna to become the world’s first chair
in complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). That was in
1993; for 25 years he has been refuting pseudoscience and vi-
olation of medical ethics, raising awareness and encouraging
action from the authorities, journalists, physicians and schools.
He speaks to HealthManagement.org about his findings and
the changes he believes are urgently needed.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Moving over to CAM research Do CAM practitioners appreciate that by putting
You left your post as chair of physical and reha- therapies and treatments under rigorous scru-
bilitation medicine at the Medical Faculty of the tiny, you will open the field to the discovery of
University of Vienna. Why were you convinced evidence which could render their treatments
that there was enough medicinal value in (if effective) more respected by doctors and
complementary and alternative therapies to medical boards?
dedicate your working life to it? No. Most of them do not see any point in research
I wasn’t convinced! This is why I insisted that my at all; those who do seem to view research more as
remit would be entirely research-based. There were a marketing tool than a means of finding the truth.
and still are many open questions in CAM, and I
thought it would be rewarding trying to answer some
of them. CAM Practitioners
continue to do more or less what
You became the first and only professor of they want and violate medical
CAM in the UK. How did doctors and medical
ethics on a daily basis
researchers respond to this? Are there many
such professors of complementary medicine
around the world? Performance of CAM therapies
The reaction was mixed; some thought it was a Your research spans acupuncture to herbs to
waste of a promising career, and others felt it was reflexology. In which area are you finding most
worth doing. At the time, in 1993, there was no other evidence of positive performance?
such professorship anywhere; now there are several, Apart from some mind-body therapies such as
but none has a particular focus on ‘critical’ evalu- relaxation techniques and some manual treat-
ation of CAM. ments such as massage, the best evidence by far
comes from herbal medicine. This is hardly surpris-
How did CAM practitioners take it? ing because many herbs contain pharmacologically
Once I started publishing, they were aghast. They active ingredients.
had expected the first professor to be a promoter of
CAM and did not understand why I insisted on criti- In your reports on the efficacy of CAM treat-
cal assessments. ments and therapies, you express that most
10 HealthManagement.org
SPOTLIGHT
of the findings are negative or inconclusive. Do you think that more research into CAM
What do you consider to be your most impor- treatments could lead to healthcare system
tant findings since you moved your focus to savings throughout the world?
CAM research? There have been several cost-ef fectiveness
Firstly, that many CAMs are not nearly as safe as analyses of CAM. Their findings are sobering.
the public is led to believe. Secondly, that most of As a rule of thumb, it is fair to say that where
the therapeutic claims for efficacy made by CAM there is no effectiveness, there can also be no
proponents are demonstrably false. cost-effectiveness.
Some herbal treatments are illegal in the UK, Homeopathy
despite evidence of positive medicinal value. You express that homeopathy as a treatment
Kava kava proved effective in relieving anxiety, is scientifically implausible, yet in centres
yet it was banned following some studies you’ve worked at, people have got better.
that linked it to liver damage (although mixed What do you put this down to?
research data exists about its liver toxicity). Do Patients tend to get better because of the placebo
you believe that authorities commonly address effect and—more importantly—because of the
risks in isolation and neglect the efficacy side natural history of the condition. Homeopaths are
of some treatments? specialists in treating self-limiting conditions and
By and large, the authorities act responsibly. Sadly, subsequently taking the credit for any improve-
they often are slow because they have little man- ment that would also have occurred without any
power and do rarely consider CAM a priority. treatment at all.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
UltraDrape_halfp_AD-34-15-3_REV_3_HealthMgmt_1-15-19.qxp_Health Management - January 1/15/19 4:37 PM Page 1
DRESS FOR SUCCESS
Introducing the World’s First Barrier and Securement Dressing
Minimize cost and eliminate secondary cleaning procedures with UltraDrape™ from Parker Laboratories.
UltraDrape is cost-efficient compared to the alternative use of sterile gels and covers, while its inventive
design allows a no-touch, aseptic procedure.
UltraDrape… the first-of-its-kind, sterile barrier and securement dressing uniquely designed for UGPIV.
To learn more about UltraDrape visit
parkerlabs.com/ultradrape
Patent www.parkerlabs.com/ultradrape.asp ISO 13485:2016
©2018 Parker Laboratories, Inc. UltraDrape and The sound choice in patient care are trademarks of Parker Laboratories, Inc. AD 34-15-3 REV 3
SPOTLIGHT
Do any randomised controlled trials (RCTs) for place? Are CAM researchers conducting more
homeopathy treatment indicate its efficacy? RCTs and sticking to better protocol and ethical
There are hundreds of such RCTs. This means that procedures?
pure chance, plus publication bias, plus flawed Sorry, but I do not believe that there is rigorous
methodology, plus wishful thinking all add up to the scrutiny of the CAM field. Practitioners continue to
fact that some studies come out positive. However, do more or less what they want and violate medical
the relevant point is that the totality of the reliable ethics on a daily basis. Their collective research
data fails to show that highly diluted homeopathic output is close to zero, and the few studies that do
remedies are more than placebos. emerge tend to be of deplorable quality.
Chiropractic Do you think your publications, articles and
D o yo u t h i n k v isi t i n g a c h i r o p r ac t o r is interviews will encourage people to be more
dangerous? sceptical, educate them on how to choose a
Potentially yes; chiropractic spinal manipulations therapy, and make the most dangerous thera-
can lead to stroke and even death. About 500 such pies commonly known in the mainstream?
cases are on record, and that figure is probably just On a good day, yes, I do hope my work has an effect.
the tip of an iceberg because there is no reporting There is now a growing group of active sceptics in
system that could monitor such events. the UK. But when I see the amount of nonsense
that is still out there, I sometimes despair.
Chiropractic Is there increasing literature on malpractice in
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
alternative medicine?
spinal manipulations can
No, by and large CAM practitioners continue to have
lead to stroke and a free ride. The UK Government seems to not care
even death very much, and it is up to a relatively small group
of highly motivated sceptics to try and prevent the
worst.
Chiropractic is a widely respected profession;
they are regulated, and in the UK we have the What more could be done to educate the
Royal College and General Chiropractic Council. public?
This suggests transparency. Is this not the About a million things! For starters, we urgently
case? need better science education in schools. And
I cannot find the lack of an adverse event report- then we require many more politicians to have a
ing system very transparent. minimum understanding of science. Their igno-
rance is often frightening, in my view. The same
Do you believe recent literature has raised sadly applies to many journalists.
awareness of the dangers of chiropractic and
that it can contribute more problems? What controls are in place to regulate clin-
When the British Chiropractic Association (BCA) ical competence in conducting CAM therapies?
sued my friend and co-author Simon Singh for libel Regulation is still very lax. Regulation should fore-
because he had stated that “they happily promote most protect consumers. However, in CAM it is
bogus treatments," they shot a huge own goal. Their mostly seen as giving practitioners a veneer of
behaviour caused huge reputational damage, and credibility.
people became aware that chiropractic is not what
it’s often made out to be. What do you believe to be the gravest area of
malpractice in CAM?
Research methods, analysis and Where to start? Perhaps the lack of proper informed
clinical competence consent is one of the gravest problems. It is almost
Do you believe that your rigorous scrutiny of the completely missing in CAM which basically means
CAM field has reduced the amount of uneth- that the current practice of CAM is unethical.
ical research and unethical assertions taking
12 HealthManagement.org
Leading European provider of advanced 7500
professionals
diagnostic imaging, outpatient
and cancer care services.
246 16
countries in
medical Europe
centres
1250
diagnostic and
cancer care
equipments
6.5
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
million
patients / year
POINT OF VIEW
Digitizing healthcare
Affidea launches new digital tools in its network to improve
patient experience and boost operations workflow
Affidea, the leading pan-European provider of advanced diagnostic imaging, outpatient and
cancer care services, has announced the launch of two new applications to drive forward
the digitisation of its operations and increase productivity and quality in imaging.
A
ffidea will introduce for almost 70% of its overall increase the quality of our medical services.
centres a cloud-based KPI Dashboard and a Radiology is no longer an industry driven only by
Mobile App to support the company’s drive state of the art technology. These digital tools will
for digital healthcare, in a bid to improve work- help us be more proactive by using predictive data.
flow management, utilize better the capacity of For example, we are one of the first healthcare pro-
the installed equipment base and enhance patient viders that can predict the replacement of a CT tube
experience across Affidea’s expanding network. before it breaks and avoid unpleasant incidents and
The new digital tools use machine learning and delays.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
complex algorithms to produce real-time and pre- Our goal in operational excellence is to use
Zisis Sotiriou dictive insights, with the purpose to increase pro- state of the art technology, insight-rich data out
Senior Vice-President ductivity while maintaining quality, preventing of our machines and the best human expertise all
Chief Operational Excellence
Affidea delays in appointments and reducing waiting times together. The positive impact of our digital dash-
which results in improved patient experience. board and KPI Mobile App will be felt immediately
by our expert clinical teams and technicians across
On this announcement, Affidea’s Chief Executive the business, and, most importantly, by our patients.
Officer, Giuseppe Recchi, stated: These two digital tools are initially installed in 165
“The launch of our KPI Dashboard and KPI Mobile centres across our network, the rest being com-
App rounds off a very successful year for Affidea, pleted by the end of the year.”
as we aim to become the premier digital healthcare
provider with the most extensive network of medical About the KPI Dasboard and KPI Mobile
centres powered by AI. App
Value can be created by utilizing data extracted KPI Dashboard
out of medical equipment in order to constantly Affidea will work with different vendors for the KPI
improve our operations and deliver faster, better, Dashboard which contains a set of key performance
more efficient care. We see healthcare transform- indicators to assess the quality and productivity of
ing to a more data driven industry, where we need Affidea’s service vendors across 16 countries in the
to continuously improve our daily operations and continent.
workflow management, enhancing patient safety These KPIs are displayed in a dashboard, where
and overall experience. We look forward to making a management can analyze workflows, machine utili-
number of exciting announcements as we move into zation, uptime and time in between failures to draw
2019, enhancing our offer to patients and doctors.” conclusions about productivity and workflow and
drive actions for improvements around efficiency,
Commenting on the launch of these two new digital quality and overall patient experience.
tools, Zisis Sotiriou, Affidea's Senior Vice-Presi- The KPIs allow Affidea’s teams to access data on
dent and Chief Operational Excellence, said: performance across different centres with aggre-
“This is the beginning of Affidea’s journey devel- gated metrics. Affidea’s team of over 7,000 health-
oping KPIs dashboards across our network to care professionals will benefit from a combination
address downtime, capacity, patient safety and of state of the art technology and insight-rich data
14 HealthManagement.org
POINT OF VIEW
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
KPI Dashboard
sets that will support them in:
• Continuing to improve upon Affidea’s award
winning patient safety record
• Maximizing the available capacity of Affidea’s Affidea at a glance:
state of the art medical equipment
• Becoming more proactive by using predictive
data, ensuring the maximum operational per- Multinational healthcare provider,
formance of medical equipment with presence in 246 centres
across 16 countries in Europe,
providing high quality affordable
KPI Mobile App care for millions of patients every
Affidea's new KPI Mobile App, developed by GE year.
Healthcare, will feature the service KPI Dashboard, Working with over 7,500 profes-
and will be installed directly on the mobiles of the sionals, producing 13 million scans
centre managers and operations managers. The every year.
app’s dashboard will display the health and status of Affidea is the only healthcare
Affidea’s advanced medical equipment in real time, operator in Europe to sit on the
sending dynamic information updates from our Imaging Advisory Board of IBM
equipment installed base across our 246 centres Watson Health and also sits on
in 16 countries. Microsoft Cloud’s board
By installing the app across Affidea’s network 50% of the European winning
of medical centres, clinical teams can be assured centres awarded by the European
of uninterrupted operations and equipment data Society of Radiology belong to
Affidea
sharing, with notifications on asset status and
service operations delivered in real time.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 15
MANAGEMENT MATTERS
How to analyse past
professional experience
for future success
Reviewing performance for focused and effective learning
A New Year represents a time to focus, regroup and set new professional targets.
Corporate trainer, Michael Virardi, provides tips on getting the most out of reflection time.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Michael R. Virardi
Speaker, Corporate Trainer, Author
Cyprus
[email protected]
michaelvirardi.com
@Michael_Virardi
A
s we head into 2019, I’d like to share with you Being true to yourself and your inner feelings is
three of the most vital lessons I learnt last not vulnerability but rather a philosophy for embrac-
year. ing situations, people and, above all, inner feelings.
Last year, I embraced vulnerability like never
Don’t be afraid to be vulnerable before. I stood in an auditorium, in front of 150 Uni-
I live on the small island of Cyprus where everyone versity College London business students and a
knows almost everyone else and, because of this, dozen UK industry professionals and shared – for
I had come to believe that vulnerability was a sign the first time ever since it happened – my decision
of weakness and that what others might say about to part ways with my wife-to-be just 23 hours before
you was perhaps more important than the cry from our wedding and with over 3,000 invitations sent
within. Since reading Rising Strong by Professor out. I was emotionally exposed but it felt good to
Brené Brown, I have come to understand that con- share a story that had been buried deep inside me
cealing your feelings and presenting them as society for 12-years.
dictates is certainly not a measure of courage but As Professor Brown says in her book, “Vulnerability
rather a yardstick of failure. is an act of courage because it helps us merge with
16 HealthManagement.org
MANAGEMENT MATTERS
our authentic self instead of hiding behind a facade Below are some of the highlights that profoundly
to appease others.” resonated with me. They are simple, direct, honest
My promise for 2019 is to be even more cou- and, above all, immediately actionable.
rageous as I have found vulnerability to be both • Focusing question: What's the ‘One Thing’ I
liberating and the path to – and the birthplace of can do, so that by doing it everything else will
– connection. be easier or unnecessary?
• Extraordinary results are directly determined
Preparation eats experience for breakfast by how narrow you can make your focus
Legend has it that Abraham Lincoln once said, “Give • The majority of what you want will come from
me six hours to chop down a tree and I will spend the the minority of what you do
first four sharpening the axe.” • Success is actually a short race – a sprint
‘Sharpen the axe’ has been my mantra ever since fuelled by discipline just long enough for habit
I can remember. From the long and arduous hours to kick in and take over
spent every weekend, preparing our in-house semi- • It takes an average of 66 days to acquire a
nars when I worked full time in the family business, new habit (University College London research)
to my recent 50 hours of preparation time to present • Our purpose sets our priority and our prior-
to a demanding, capable and knowledgeable audi- ity determines the productivity our actions
ence in New York City last September, preparation produce
has always been key. • Who we are and where we want to go deter-
mine what we do and what we accomplish
Based on the ‘One Thing’ philosophy, my top
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
professional success priority going into 2019 is to
The minor details are complete an online programme (which will also be
what may make a major turned into a book) on the topic of public speaking.
difference in your professional
and personal life Live and learn
Every year I look back and see that, once again, I have
lived and learned so many things. I have shared three
with you that stand out for me as having been sig-
The best preparation for tomorrow is doing your nificant last year and, on the surface, they appear to
best today by crosschecking information, triangu- be totally unconnected: discovering a positive side
lating and making sure that you are fully prepared to vulnerability, recognising the incalculable value
for each and every detail. The minor details are what of preparation, and learning to prioritise. And yet,
may make a major difference in your professional together, they have made me a better person and a
and personal life. better professional.
What did you learn in 2018? How do you intend
Do the one thing that matters most to implement it in 2019? At the University of Life,
I was browsing through the shelves of a bookstore in which we are all enrolled, learning never stops.
at the airport when I came across a book entitled
The One Thing. The Surprisingly Simple Truth Behind
Extraordinary Results. After devouring it, I can vouch
for the fact that it really delivers on its promise to
help you cut through the clutter and achieve better
results in less time.
Author Gary Keller and contributor Jay Papasan Key Points
argue that achievers always work with a clear sense
of priority. They also state their view that ‘To-Do • Vulnerability is strength and fosters authenticity
lists’ are just survival lists which get you through your
• Preparation is king; make adequate space for it
day and your life and that ‘Success lists’ are what
we need: lists that are purposefully created around • Identifying and doing the one thing that matters
most can save precious time and energy
extraordinary results.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 17
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
Is Blockchain the
right technology for
healthcare?
Blockchain technology is touted as being potentially revolutionary, but what’s the view
for the healthcare sector? Known for being an industry that’s slow to adopt and adapt to
new tech, could there be any value in Blockchain for healthcare? HealthManagement.org
spoke to four Blockchain experts for their views.
B lockchain technology initially gained recognition
in the framework of the cryptocurrency Bitcoin.
However, the benefits of Blockchain go far beyond
I believe Blockchain can
be a t ransfor mative tech-
nology solution for the health-
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
offering a simple payment method for medical bills care industr y, ef fectively
and healthcare with cryptocurrencies. Blockchain is addressing key challenges
an immutable, digitally-distributed ledger system that and disrupting business
provides the medical industry with real-time, universal models that currently fall
records. short of global needs.
Application of Blockchain technology will allow all However, as with any
stakeholders in the healthcare industry to access a technology solution,
single source of records that are timestamped and Blockchain is just an
tamper-proof, from anywhere in the world. In addi- enabler. Successful
tion to patients being able to fully manage their data transformation for
and control who gets access to it, they will be able the industr y will
to remain anonymous and, potentially even monetise depend on creating
their data. For example, there are new marketplace sustainable business
models that allow patients to receive tokens (crypto- models and changing
currency payments) in exchange for use of their data traditional mind-sets to
in pharmaceutical trials. focus on people’s needs.
Blockchain creates new security and data privacy
standards that never existed before. In order to tamper
with records, all nodes in a Blockchain network need
to be changed, making it extremely difficult to carry
out. This prevents incidents that have plagued health-
care institutions where hackers accessed computer Kamales
systems and held data ransom. The combination of Lardi
Blockchain with other disruptive technologies such as Managing Partner
Lardi & Partner
artificial intelligence and internet of things enables Consulting
real-time data collection, transparent supply chain GmbH,
President, Women
management, increased integrity of clinical research In Blockchain, Switzerland
results, optimised processes for payments, claims
[email protected]
management, and regulatory compliance, to name
@KamLardi
a few.
18 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
F irstly, there is no such thing as “the right technology for healthcare.” However,
there are appropriate technologies to address specific challenges in health-
care, at least as long they are not replaced by the next technology. Blockchain
is a distributed ledger. A distributed ledger is a database spread across several
nodes where each node replicates and saves an identical copy of the ledger.
Blockchain organises the database in blocks and validates addition to the data-
base through a consensual method between nodes. Blockchain could address
the problem of identities: a trusted source for the ID’s of citizen, care providers,
and other stakeholders. This is a major problem in the healthcare sector which
becomes even worse when it goes transborder. Blockchain cannot solve the
problem of data interoperability, but it can address accessibility of data and
Christian Lovis trace exchanges. This would suppose however to have a trusted source for citi-
Professor and Chairman
Division of Medical Information Sciences
zens and providers identities, which is not yet the case. Blockchain could help
University Hospitals of Geneva (HUG) developing a global, shared and dynamic approach to consent management,
IT Editor-in-Chief, HealthManagement.org
crossing the boundaries of research and care. There are some other points,
[email protected] but the important message is that Blockchain is a great technology that will
@chr_lovis really help addressing specific important challenges of the healthcare system.
A s a field that prides itself on data, technology, and being
on the cutting edge, cardiology has the potential to
Mark Abrams
Director of Patient
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
benefit highly from a new infrastructure built to help imple- Engagement
Heartbeat Health, U.S.
ment evidence-based medicine. By decentralising infor-
[email protected]
mation about patient care, research, cost effectiveness,
and clinical outcomes, Blockchain technology truly has the @heartbeat
power to recreate the foundation on which our system
operates, providing a turbo boost in a field ripe for innova-
tion. It could be the “X factor” that brings us to a next level
we can’t even imagine. Overall, I see Blockchain playing an
important role in cardiology in the years to come.”
Axel
Schumacher
Founder & Chief Scientific Officer
I
t is impossible for me to overstate the
importance of Blockchain to the health-
care industry. Healthcare will increas-
record, research data or anonymised
genomic data, cannot be altered. Block-
chain-based micropayments can help
Shivom, Germany
ingly move into the digital area, and to incentivise people to participate in
[email protected] that means sensitive healthcare data medical research by contributing their
@methylogix needs to be collected securely, shared, anonymised data to clinical trials. Using
analysed and adequately controlled. smart contracts and automated digital
For all those steps, distributed consents, patients can be empowered to
ledgers are highly useful. For manage their own health. Blockchain will
example, using immutable also improve the pharma supply chain,
Blockchain technology, enable trust-free collaboration, improve
all stakeholders in the interoperability and help to fight coun-
healthcare vertical can terfeit drugs and insurance fraud. Block-
easily share data with chain in healthcare will be particularly
a nyo n e wit h o u t t h e disruptive if it is combined with other
fear of data corruption technologies, ie artificial intelligence.
or tampering. There Despite some resistance, there cannot
will always be abso- be any doubt that Blockchain should and
lute proof and confi- will disrupt and improve many parts of
dence that a medical the healthcare ecosystem.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 19
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
How Blockchain will
transform healthcare
Adoption of distributed ledger technology will benefit patients
and providers
Blockchain is more than just a technology that allows us to do what we already do better,
faster and cheaper. This peer-to-peer new technology has the potential to create a more
inclusive economy, where patients can benefit from health data ownership.
O
ne reason people don’t understand Blockchain governance, holacracy is selfless and fearless in the
is because we describe it rather than explain way it achieves objectives.
it. When we say Blockchain is a distributed The whole idea of Blockchain is based on not
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
ledger to someone who is not familiar with append- needing to rely on a privileged minority operating
only databases, this is meaningless. It’s like saying behind closed doors. This doesn’t mean this is the age
water is H2O without knowing the table of elements. of distrust, but rather trust has shifted into a new form
In order to explain, not describe something, you must of distributed trust. Instead of trust flowing upwards
talk about the why or the intentionality behind it. If to institutions, experts, authorities and regulators, it
you say that water is the source of life, it sustains us, now flows horizontally to peers, friends, colleagues
Alex Cahana it makes more sense, it becomes meaningful. and fellow users. This distributed model creates a
Venture Partner and Head
Medtech and Healthcare
So what is Blockchain? It is a distributed ledger, decentralised ecosystem that is attack-resistant,
New York, USA but the intention behind it is to obviate the need collusion-resistant and censorship-resistant, when
[email protected] for a “trustful’ intermediary. With Blockchain through compared to centralised organisations, institutions
CryptoOracle.io encryption, transparency, immutability and verifia- and governments.
@CryptoOracleLLC
bility of data you can directly rely on the truthfulness
of information through a distributed trust network. Empowering patients with Blockchain
If you take the attributes of censorship and collusion
The human-driven approach resistance and translate them into healthcare, you can
The potential of Blockchain goes hand-in-hand with understand it will bring a few important changes in
the human-driven approach or holacracy. Holacracy how we practice healthcare. First, you can make sure
is a type of self-governance, which not only follows a that health data is not only secure but also private,
mission but is also evidence-based, data-driven and and that the ownership of that data is controlled by
situational-aware. You don’t just see holacracy in the patient (aka self-sovereign).
start-up or entrepreneurial worlds; you see it in agile Second, if you look at monetary transactions, it
corporations and in the military. When battle ensues, can disintermediate all kinds of third parties that lack
military units take initiatives within their frameworks value and create unnecessary friction that currently
and start to self organise in order to complete the make the healthcare experience less pleasurable
mission. This is very different from political represent- and increase costs. Third, and most importantly is
ative democracy where we freely elect someone else that through behavioural economics using monetary
to do our work. In fact, what we have seen is that the (rewards) and non-monetary (reputation) incentives,
representatives we elect can collude, do things that Blockchain-based solutions can transform people
are counter to ‘the mission’ they were elected for and from being passive health service consumers into
can be self-serving. In comparison to other forms of health producers.
20 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
What makes Blockchain even more interesting is understand that bad actors who badly impact the
that what we can add to value-based or outcome- community will be expunged because they make the
based care the opportunity to generate wealth whole system unviable.
through the use of tokens (utility tokens) or digit-
ised assets (security tokens). What that means in What’s in it for healthcare?
practical terms is, today I wear a fitbit and it gives What Blockchain does it is it changes the equation
me information that stimulates me to be a health of value. Value today is usually thought of as quality
producer. But the data that this fitbit generates divided by cost (V= Q/C). So if something has high
doesn’t belong to me. It belongs to a company that quality and low cost, it has high value. How does this
can sell it without my consent and they will make equation work in healthcare? Mostly by lowering the
money on it while I won’t. That’s not fair. Blockchain denominator, in other words doing more for less.
technology creates a more inclusive economy where if However excessive cost suppression (like not covering
a company makes $10,000, for example, on my infor- preventative care) has actually caused healthcare to
mation, I can get half of it and I can earn it through be more expensive and people are dying younger and
a utility token. In addition, through the use of secu- younger. So the current healthcare system offers a
rity tokens, I can actually have fractional ownership low quality proposition.
of fitbit stock, which will incentivise me even more to What Blockchain does is it transforms the value
use the platform. Blockchain really enables a human- equation into what you are willing to give divided by
driven approach in the sense that I can be the owner what you want to get (V= give/get). Using this equa-
and earner of my information. tion, a patient who is not willing give up unhealthy
behaviours (smoking, drinking, sedentary life), offers
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Blockchain adoption is a question of a zero-value proposition. A drug company that offers
time. cost-prohibitive treatments and is not willing to give
Blockchain will be more important for people who up profit has a zero-value proposition. A government
need it the most. In the western world, a lot of people that wants all of its citizens to be healthy but isn’t
sacrifice their privacy and their health and, to some willing to provide affordable care offers a zero-value
extent, their wealth for the convenience and comfort value proposition. The Blockchain economy doesn't
of their lives. But the more you are existentially threat- want everything cheap and easy, but is about creating
ened and don’t have the luxury to give up that health a sustainable and resilient business-ecosystem,
and wealth, the more you seek tools that empower where all stakeholders share a common mission,
you directly to be the master of your data. I can argue taxonomy and sense of purpose.
that I am too comfortable in my life to be bothered,
but when will I be bothered? People will start to care
when they understand the demands on their health,
wealth and environment are unsustainable.
I also think it’s a generational matter. Many people
don’t understand what self-sovereignty is in the sense
they’re are so used to living in a centralised system
that is opaque and full of friction, they sacrifice their Key Points
sovereignty for convenience or because they don’t • Blockchain is a foundational technology
believe a centralised world can be changed. that allows implementation of holacratic
However, my 12-year-old daughter and her gener- human-drive approach.
ation learn digital citizenry and what an intercon- • Trust is embedded in the technology,
nected interdependent world means. From their through decentralisation
perspective, Generation Zers interact through non- • Blockchain can make health records
monetary incentives leveraging their contributions to self-sovereign
society through reputation (think YouTube or social • Patients will own their health data and
media) as opposed to money. The younger generation its monetisation, incentivising long-term
doesn’t expect parents or governments to help. They healthy behaviors
already practice holacracy by creating chat groups • The decentralised society Blockchain
where they directly ask how to solve problems and creates is already accepted by Generation Z
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 21
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
Who stands to benefit
from healthcare
Blockchain?
Blockchain revolutionises data security, research and monetisation
Blockchain can provide the backbone for a health data infrastructure that enables pa-
tients to control and benefit financially from their health data.
The power of health data in 1996 to secure the confidentiality, integrity, and
The tsunami of personal data brought about by the availability of electronic Patient Health Information
digital revolution now extends far beyond consumer (ePHI).
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
preferences, as monetised by Facebook, Google and HIPAA imposes technical safeguards and processes
the likes. As life sciences merges with information to restrict access to data, avoid or report any disclo-
technology, our most precious health data is also sure. But HIPAA compliance is mostly self-declared,
being digitised. In the last 10 years, quantified health and providers share information freely with third
has gone from electronic medical records to massive parties, provided they sign a Business Associate
DNA or microbiome sequencing. The Precision Medi- Agreement. This transfers responsibility to third
Alexis Normand cine Initiative launched in 2015 prompted the National parties, but it does not extend controls. Most startups
Head of Embleema Blockchain
for Health Consortium
Institute of Health to create a research cohort gath- analysing ePHI on behalf of providers will say they
New York, USA ering all available data for one million people, allowing comply with HIPAA. Few are ever audited.
[email protected]
scientists to explore why people get sick or stay
healthy. With similar ambitions, Verily Life Sciences’ Blockchain’s privacy promise
embleema.com
(formerly Google Life Sciences), Project Baseline It should come as little comfort to patients that unau-
@Embleema collects phenotypic health data from approximately thorised access to ePHI is commonplace. The numbers
@slarxe 10,000 participants over four years to identify tipping are staggering. HIPAA breaches affected more than 5
points in the transition from health to disease. These million patient records in 2017, 27 million in 2016 and
initiatives are paving the way for better diagnosis, more than 100 million in 2015. More than a third of
preventative alerts and more personalised treatments. medical records have been compromised in the last
Beyond research, this new wealth of data is being five years, mostly because of insiders mishandling
used by the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) to our data. With such figures, and lack of trust under-
modernise how it monitors the safety and efficacy of mines the very willingness of patients to share sensi-
new products. The FDA’s commissioner Scott Gottlieb tive information with care providers.
laid out a clear policy for the agency in 2018: “we are Because the laws that try to protect our privacy
expanding the opportunities for digital health tools to have essentially failed to achieve desired results, we
become a part of drug review, to couple these capabil- urgently need to invent tools that let patients become
ities to drug delivery to form a drug delivery system.” the custodians of their own data. The good news is
But to fulfill the outstanding promise of digital that this is exactly the value proposition of Blockchain
health, we must still trust third parties with our most for healthcare.
intimate data. Of course, regulations exist to protect How does it work? Today, no patient knows where
our privacy. In the U.S., the Health Insurance Patient his health data goes for lack of access to transaction
Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), was enacted logs ie who shares what with whom. By distributing
22 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
ledgers of transactions across all participants (nodes) Here, Blockchain opens up a revolutionary possi-
in a given network, Blockchain essentially creates bility: for the first time, individuals will be able to own
trust by design. Indeed, no participant of the network their digital assets. Quite simply, distributed ledgers
can falsify the log, because a consensus algorithm eliminate the need for a third-party reseller. It makes
reconciles the information across nodes, spotting any it possible to automate payments in cryptocurrencies
discrepancy. This means each participant, ie patient, via smart contracts. A person can be paid for giving his
knows at all time what happens to his data. It also consent to his data being aggregated within a cohort.
offers a way to share the same information with all
stakeholders in real time, fine-tuning who has access Data as ‘Information Age’ oil
to de-encrypted data. The technology is here. Now, the law must also evolve
to treat personal data-like property, much in the same
way that it evolved to create real estate laws when
The laws that try land was the prime asset, and to invent intellectual
property and finance during the industrial revolution.
to protect our privacy This would secure equitable trade for the Informa-
have failed to achieve tion Age’s new "oil". Citizens should be able to grant
licenses on their data for specific purposes and be
the desired results; compensated with royalties. This would also mean
patients need to become outlining the difference between data that cannot be
custodians of their sold, for instance one’s name or age, and that which
represents an economic asset
own data
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
In healthcare, the stakes far exceed the busi-
ness of selling health data, even though the possi-
To avoid any misconception, only the information bility of compensating patients does offer a prom-
on the Blockchain is public, ie the index of what data ising new way to reduce their economic dependence.
is shared with whom. Sensitive patient data, however, Pricing data provides unprecedented transparency,
can stay off-chain, secured in HIPAA compliant clouds, as opposed to current-day opacity. More importantly,
in accordance with legal requirements. Transparency giving patients access to a marketplace where their
with Blockchain technology is a first step to allowing health data could be funneled into clinical research
patients own their data. expands their medical options. This is especially true
for rare diseases, where wider access to data is acutely
Revolutionary elimination of the third party needed, and holds the potential to radically accel-
Ownership goes beyond controlling how data is shared. erate the development of treatments, and monitor
It involves appropriation of data as an economic asset. their effects in real time.
But today, our records are being sold without patient
buy-in. Typically, when life sciences companies inves-
tigate a particular disease, they are required by regu-
lators to benchmark the efficacy of new treatments
or monitor the safety of new. Studies are slow and
expensive. Brokers will buy datasets from hospitals
Key Points
and pharmacy chains, and resell it to pharma, for what • Health data is used for health and drug
constitutes a $15 billion business. The emergence of safety purposes, amongst other research
new digital platforms has created new ways to acquire • Unauthorised access to health data is
medical records. For instance, when Roche bought commonplace
Flatiron (a software vendor that tracks cancer data) • Patients rarely know how their health data
for $1.9 billion, it got hold of the complete medical is used and monetised
history of 200 thousand patient records. This valued • Blockchain provides framework for patient
each record at nearly $10,000. Even if pharmaceutical control over data
companies have good reasons to acquire these data- • This increases monetisation opportunities
sets, ie accelerate the discovery of new treatments, for patients and greater access to medical
patients never get a single dime for their own data. options
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 23
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
Blockchain solves
healthcare data
obstacles
Incentivising patients with tokenomics of health data
A cryptocurrency that represents the value of health information can motivate individu-
als to make their health data shareable to those who are willing to pay for it.
T
okens are well established in the context of develop better therapies. Tremendous amounts of
Blockchain technology and cryptocurren- data are being generated by medical documentation,
cies. It’s a digital asset that has a utility or a regulatory requirements, and patient care (Raghu-
payment function. Very often, it’s a hybrid token and pathi 2010). In addition, precision medicine and the
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
possesses both properties. However, technically, it general trend of digitisation in healthcare lead to a
is just a piece of cryptographic code of no intrinsic constant rise of data being gathered at the individual
value. Although Blockchain and its related cryptocur- user or patient’s level (Andreu-Perez et al 2015; HM
rencies are a recent development, tokens have been Government UK 2014). Another driving force in this
the subject of psychological research for a long time. massive growth of data is the individual himself
Eberhard Scheuer In psychology, tokens are used to shape a target when using a fitness or wellness app.
Founder and Chairman behavior, and therefore tokens have to be backed by
HIT Foundation
Zug, Switzerland
reinforcers. A relation between a token of no intrinsic
[email protected]
value with an unconditioned reinforcer like food or Today, it is still
a conditioned one like money has to be established
hit.foundation
by reinforcement. The law of effect (Thorndike
difficult to say we look at
@FoundationHit
1898) describes that behaviour which is followed the whole patient for the
by pleasant consequences as having a higher likeli-
hood of being repeated, whereas unpleasant conse-
follow-up of chronic and
quences decrease the likelihood of repeat behaviour. complex illnesses
The effectiveness of a token reward as a means of
behaviour modification has not only been observed in There are only estimates what personal health
humans but also in primates (Wolfe 1936) or pigeons data are worth, but it can be deducted from what
and rats (Skinner 1948; Skinner 1953). In humans, companies are willing to invest in order to gather
it is often applied in cognitive behavioural therapy those data. IBM bought Truven Health Analytics for
and childrearing. $2.6 billion to train Watson on 200 million patient
But how does that apply to health data and how records, meaning that one record was worth 13 USD.
could the tokenisation of health data be the solution It is a low price if you take into account what phar-
of some of the most pressing problems in modern maceutical companies invest in order to gather clin-
healthcare? ical trial data and real-world evidence. Prices that
are being paid for so-called post-market surveillance
Health data as the currency of healthcare might be a good indicator of the data value, with an
systems average of €441 per patient paid to the physician
Modern healthcare runs on data. Everybody is on providing the data (Spelsberg et al 2017).
the hunt for data in order to optimise processes or It is needless to say, that in today’s data economy,
24 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
Figure 1. HIT Token economy (HIT Foundation 2018)
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
wherever there is a value generated out of data, it data can ask individuals for their consent to make
is not the individual as a data provider who profits their health data shareable.
directly from the monetisation of its data. It results
in a lack of incentives for individuals to demand or A decentralised marketplace to tokenise
record, digitise, and update their health data. Hence, health data
it perpetuates the current system of monopolisa- Blockchain technology can facilitate such an infra-
tion of health data leading to siloes and inefficien- structure in the form of a decentralised marketplace
cies instead of motivating the individual being in where the access to health data is under the control
control of his data. of the individual.
Information seekers can post their query and indi-
Tokens as incentives to digitise health data viduals can remain anonymous and decide whether
Most people are only interested in their health data or not they want to share their data. With the tokens
when they are sick or when somebody they know is in a Blockchain-based marketplace, a reward can be
suffering from a health problem, but there are ways automatically transferred on the basis of a digital
to motivate them to tend to their health data. In a contract once the data has been delivered. Such a
recent survey in Switzerland, 43% of all people said system has a clear advantage over a fiat currency-
they would be willing to provide their personal data based system where always a middleman has to be
to medical research, either for free or for a reduction involved and the large population of unbanked indi-
of their health insurance premium (Tagesanzeiger viduals cannot participate.
2017). In comparison, 54% of internet users are In Figure 1 the token economy of the Health
willing to share their health data with their health Information Traceability platform is presented. A
insurance, if they receive incentives such as vouchers payment and utility token facilitates transactions
or premium reduction (Statista 2015). However, 79% of health information. Information seekers acquire
of German online users want the power to decide tokens to incentivise individuals to digitise and share
who can access their health data (BKK Dachverband their data, while individuals can: a) redeem bonuses/
Gesundheitsreport 2016). It shows that healthcare services that are offered by service providers on the
systems must incentivise individuals to take control platform; b) trade it for another cryptocurrency; or c)
over their data. At the same time a technical infra- exchange it for cash at designated exchanges. Indi-
structure is needed, where everybody who seeks viduals can also monetise their data that is stored
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 25
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
in external repositories and share revenues with the health goals that are incorporated in a digital
information holders such as personal health records, contract are achieved.
claims processing companies, hospitals and phar-
macies. The central asset to be exchanged in the So l u tions wit h B l ockchain-enab l ed
HIT-ecosystem is information that has a token value ecosystem
attached to it. The token value depends on how Such a distributed ecosystem can be implemented
much the network participant values the informa- with Blockchain technology, making transaction
tion in question. processes transparent and more efficient at the
same time. A Blockchain-based token system is
predestined to align incentives among ecosystem
A Blockchain-based participants, for example, providers of health infor-
mation and those who want to analyse health data.
token system would put It allows the latter to have direct access to providers
patients in control of the of health information without the need for inter-
mediaries. At the same time, it puts individuals in
use and monetisation of control of the use and monetisation of their health
their health data data. Tokenisation of health data motivates indi-
viduals to make their data shareable, thus solving
the fundamental problem of modern healthcare.
Use cases for tokenising health information
• Research
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Researchers have direct access to potential Key Points
study participants
• Population health data • Healthcare runs on huge volumes of data
Population survey and representative surveys • Value of health data varies
can be conducted via contacting individuals • Patients can be financially-incentivised to
directly control their health data
• Compliance Support • Blockchain technology can facilitate estab-
Individuals receive tokens when predefined lishment of decentralised data marketplace
REFERENCES
BKK Dachverband Gesundheitsreport Raghupathi W (2010) Data Mining in Ostrowski K., Witte T, Hüsgen D et al. sind wir. Available from mobile2. tage-
2016. Splendid Research. HealthCare. In Healthcare Informatics: (2017) Contribution of industry funded sanzeiger.ch/articles/599ac823ab5c37
Improving Efficiency and Productivity. postmarketing studies to drug safety: 455e000001
HIT Foundation (2018) Whitepaper. Edited by Kudyba S. Taylor & Francis survey of notifications submitted to reg-
Available from: hit.foundation/docu- 211–223. ulatory agencies. BMJ 356:j337 Thorndike, EL (1898) Animal intelligence:
ments/Personalised Health and Care An experimental study of the associa-
2020, Framework for Action. Skinner, BF (1948) 'Superstition' in Statista (2015). Gesundheitsdaten, tive processes in animals. Psychological
the pigeon. Journal of Experimental eine Frage des Preises. Available from: Monographs: General and Applied,
National Information Board HM Psychology 38, 168-172. de.statista.com/infografik/3822/eeber- 2(4), i-109.
Government UK (2014) Available from mittlung-elektronischer-gesundheits-
gov.uk/government/uploads/system/ Skinner, BF (1953) Science and human daten-fuer-verguenstigungen/ Wolfe, JB (1936) Effectiveness of token
uploads/attachment_data/file/384650/ behavior. SimonandSchuster. rewards for chim-panzees. Comparative
NIB_Report.pdf Tagesanzei ger (2017) So käufli ch Psychological Monographs 12, 1–72.
Spelsberg A, Prugger C., Doshi P,
26 HealthManagement.org
Revolutionizing
Hemodynamic Monitoring
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
One sensor - full hemodynamics
> Non-invasive and continuous
> Easy-to-use
> Cost-efficient and clinically proven
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
Is Blockchain impacting
the healthcare arena?
The Blockchain race in healthcare has yet to begin
Supporters say it has everything to offer healthcare security and transparency, but what do
practical, on-the-ground C-levels really think about Blockchain's potential today?
W
hile the technology trend-o-metre and KLAS context and insight
cryptocurrency world at large set off fire- Healthcare organisations historically tend to be risk
works of exciting talk and disruptive use averse, and understandably so. Changes in health
cases with Blockchain, the healthcare industry, by information technology and new, unproven standards
contrast, sits on the sidelines today as a mostly are often questioned—if not directly perceived — as
casual observer. Or maybe even as an opponent. placing potential or actual risks on direct patient care.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
When you consider that Blockchain is said to To be on the bleeding edge in terms of technology use
make data more secure and more transparent, more and adoption gives healthcare providers concern that
available and more reliable, the truth is that the very clinical care could be impacted. For healthcare, the
Joe Van De Graaff minimal use of Blockchain in healthcare today just bleeding edge isn’t just a matter of innovation where
Vice President and Analyst doesn’t seem to make a lot of sense. something could turn out to be a mistake and a widget
KLAS Research
Orem, US
In fact, with effective data sharing and security is compromised—it could possibly lead to bleeding
representing two of the biggest health information or other problems at the hospital bedside. In health-
[email protected]
technology (HIT) issues that we struggle with, you care, the quest for safety almost always comes before
klasresearch.com would naturally think that the built-up frustration starting a race on innovation, thus introducing a likely
@JoeV_KLAS around interoperability and the high-profile recent delay in the timing with which healthcare providers
cybersecurity attacks would create the ideal environ- adopt Blockchain or other new technologies.
ment in which Blockchain would take off. Not so fast.
Lacking vendor adoption
The healthcare C-suite views on Blockchain If vendors don’t actively embrace and support Block-
Taking a step back to seek out the on-the-ground chain, the technology isn’t feasible for the sector.
perspective and experience of healthcare CIOs and
CISOs, the current hesitation on Blockchain becomes KLAS context and insight.
more clear, perhaps even pronounced. The idea of a new technology standard in healthcare,
Asked if they would use Blockchain in the future, particularly as it relates to interoperability, is anything
three healthcare CISOs of influence and recognition but new. In recent years, standards such as Fast
each shared with KLAS that, without hesitation, today Healthcare Interoperability Resources (FIHR), Care-
they do not plan to use Blockchain for future projects. quality, CommonWell, and others have come on the
Following are key reasons they shared that contribute scene in hopes to help crack the thick interoperability
to their current conclusion, along with context and nut. There is a great deal of industry talk about FIHR,
insight from KLAS on each topic. and the recent connection of CommonWell to Care-
quality provides promising opportunity. However, we
Bleeding edge have not arrived at the destination of a healthcare
To use Blockchain means you are not just leading industry-wide and deeply adopted standard for all,
out in terms of a new technology standard, but that despite the best efforts of various healthcare leaders,
you are operating on the bleeding edge. influencers, and even the government.
28 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
Active support and ongoing investment from the a difficult time seeing the landscape beyond the
HIT vendor community in Blockchain is only just mountain of uncertainty and hesitation today. One
starting—at best — thus leaving healthcare provider CIO shared with KLAS that they are “watching Block-
organisations with uncertainty about the future of chain” but “don’t think anything is happening. Some
Blockchain and with reservations about if and when payers are using it. Some claims clearinghouses are
to jump in. using it. It is something that could be really cool, but
It’s not just a vendor thing, though. All stake- it is still really in its infancy, and there are not a lot
holders have a part to play. While not specific to of use cases you can attach to it.”
Blockchain but still related to security, one interesting The shine from what healthcare provider organ-
and important development KLAS has noticed is that isations today perceive as a “shiny toy” is far from
some leading US healthcare organisations, including shiny results. With the continued advance towards
the Cleveland Clinic, Tufts Medical Centre, Univer- and pressure from value-based payment and models,
sity of Pittsburgh Medical Centre, and others have the industry is turning its focus to practical results.
joined together to mandate that, within the next 24
months, any third party vendors desiring to work with The future of healthcare Blockchain
them must adopt “standard cybersecurity measures So, what does all this mean for Blockchain in
and achieve certification to demonstrate their prod- healthcare? Is it doomed?
ucts and services are safe and secure for use in a No. Even among the respected healthcare CIO and
hospital or other patient care settings” (Tufts 2018). CISO leaders who have been candid in sharing their
For Blockchain to be valid and valuable, support from views with KLAS about Blockchain thus far, Block-
the HIT community – vendors and healthcare organ- chain pilots have either already taken place or are
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
isations – will be necessary. That mature support is actively underway. And while in healthcare the tech-
years away, if it ever fully comes. nology isn’t seen as productive or practical as of
yet, it’s also not being written off. The potential and
promise of Blockchain has certainly not taken hold,
but its demise is not certain, either.
Prominent CISOs each Simply said, the Blockchain race in healthcare just
shared with KLAS that isn’t a real race yet.
today they do not plan to
use Blockchain for future
projects
Key Points
Shiny toys don’t guarantee shiny results • Healthcare is watching Blockchain closely
Blockchain today is a shiny toy, but it’s still far from but with reservations
practical. • In healthcare, patient safety usually (and
understandably) takes precedence over
innovation
KLAS context and insight.
Just a decade or so ago one could have argued that • Prominent CISOs say they don’t see a use
for Blockchain in the near to mid-term
electronic health records (EHRs) might be shiny toys,
far from reality or practicality. While the value and • HIT community support for Blockchain is
still in the distant future
clinical effectiveness of EHRs are widely researched
and disputed, it’s common knowledge that nearly all • It’s early days for HIT Blockchain viability,
hospitals use EHRs, with billions of dollars across the but the tech has not been written off
industry put into development, support, purchases,
and enhancements of those systems today. With
regard to Blockchain, the question stands, over the
REFERENCES
next decade, will Blockchain see such a rise?
The handful of respected healthcare professionals Tufts (2018) Cyber security in health care. Available from tuftsmedicalcenter.org/
who have shared their views with KLAS thus far have News-Events-Media/Press-Releases/2018/Cybersecurity
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 29
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
DISRUPTING BUILDING
THE PRESENT THE FUTURE
Embracing Innovation to
Deliver Results
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
IFC GLOBAL PRIVATE HEALTHCARE
CONFERENCE
MARCH 27-28, 2019 | MIAMI, FLORIDA, USA | ww.ifc.org/health-conference
As more governments pledge to deliver Universal Topics to be discussed at Miami include:
Healthcare to their citizens, many developing • Expanding the use of technology and digital
countries are experiencing a dramatic overhaul in health in health service delivery
how their healthcare systems function. Major trends • Emerging models of care that are guided by a
include the growth of health insurance (social and ‘value for money’ ethos
private), a sharper focus on value, and a renewed • Improving access to high quality, affordable
emphasis on access, affordability, and quality. There drugs
is increasing opportunity for the private sector • Better utilizing the limited supply of health
to pioneer disruptive innovations that challenge professionals
historical norms. Whatever the future holds, one • Harnessing Big Data to better plan and monitor
thing is clear: it cannot be business as usual! the purchase and provision of care
IFC—a member of the World Bank Group—is the largest global
development institution focused exclusively on the private sector in
developing countries.
30 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
Can Blockchain support
advances in radiology?
In 2019 we will embrace Blockchain and innovation as
necessary support for the healthcare of our time.
Blockchain can influence the design and implementation of new models by refining data
security; provide more robust audit trail mechanisms required, eliminate medical imag-
ing acquisitions repetition, reduce transaction costs, while allowing clinicians to access
data easily, compare images, and provide patients with better and quicker treatment
options.
T
he main technology trends of 2018 that is exposed– with the current technologies and
have been identified in Healthcare such approaches, to high risk of cyberattack. Fragmented
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
as AI, machine learning VR/AR, Internet of PACS systems, siloed databases for different kind
things (IoT’s) and Blockchain, should not be seen of data (notes in one system, medicine records in
as “trends” anymore. another system), has made it very difficult to prop-
In fact, in 2019 we will move from viewing these erly use data while ensuring proper security.
as over-hyped buzzwords to embracing them as
necessary support for the healthcare of our time.
The acknowledgement of the potential of these
technologies brings new opportunities for flour- APPROXIMATELY Maria Marenco
ishing new economies, new business models and
90% OF THE HEALTH DATA
President, Sweden/Nordic Chapter
Government Blockchain
most importantly the leverage for enabling true Association
citizen-centric care and efficiency in the care GENERATED IS MEDICAL Stockholm, Sweden
process.
Even though the healthcare landscape has seen
IMAGING eHealth and Healthcare
vertical lead
The Swedish Blockchain
benefits from these technologies, the industry is Association
Stockholm, Sweden
still on a learning process to better understand how
to fully unleash these tools. As a consequence, it is not surprising that Healthcare Informatics
Consultant and Founder
several cyberattacks have affected a fair number Mentfort Ltd
Blockchain as enabling technology for of organisations and institutions. One of the most London, UK
teleradiology notable ransom attacks called the WannaCry in
[email protected]
It has been said that approximately 90% of the 2017 was yet another reminder of the vulnerability
[email protected]
health data generated is medical imaging. A study of healthcare organisations and the need of contin-
@healthurbanista
indicated a growth of 35 ZB of imaging data by uously finding better ways to protect patient data
2020 produced by the world’s devices (Alexander but also obtain and maintain trust in the ecosystem
et al. 2018). In such a scenario, it becomes crit- and most importantly patient trust.
ical to establish secure, reliable and efficient In such a scenario, Blockchain could likely influ-
processes and tools for exchanging and leveraging ence the design and implementation of new storage
this growing wealth of data toward improving clin- models by not only refining the security of the data
ical outcomes and overall efficiency along the care and providing more robust audit trails mechanisms
process. required by regulatory bodies, but also eliminating
At the same time, such great amount of data the repetition of medical imaging acquisitions,
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 31
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
reducing transaction costs, at the same time accessibility, as key drivers for delivering proper
allowing clinicians to have access to data more care at the right time.
easily, compare images, and provide patients with Additionally, and coming to a conclusion, a
better and quicker treatment options. further layer of security and trust in the data
Such innovations can be of benefit in enabling exchange process could be added, also outlining a
distributed teleradiology, allowing offsite and onsite greater role for patients, by using smart contracts.
diagnostics to read data while providing transpar- In such cases, in which data are openly available
ency to all parties in the care chain. but still in control of the relevant providers and of
A real-world implementation of the above- the patients/data owners, personal smart-contract
described scenario was presented at the 2018 based tools could be entrusted by the patients for
Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) sharing the data on the basis of specific and pre-
annual meeting, where Medical Diagnostic Web defined consent and permission options – seeking
(MDW) presented the first radiology Blockchain for second opinions and allowing for data access by
platform for connecting stakeholders of the imaging third party (and data-driven services) in an auto-
ecosystem. mated fashion.
In conclusion, DLTs and their “cooperation”
Blockchain and AI: teaming up for with AI hold great promises for the future of radi-
improved care ology and healthcare at large, but we must always
The usage of AI and machine learning for processing remain mindful of the fact that an environment
large data sets, imaging analysis and clinical deci- of trust remains a challenge, for all parties within
sion support, is becoming more and more wide- institutions and between patients and healthcare
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
spread worldwide, along with progressive demys- providers.
tification of such technologies. Indeed, the impor-
tance and efficiency that is gained from AI in the
field of radiology is currently becoming more and
more difficult to argue against.
In particular in image analytics, AI – thanks to its
pattern recognition and data-crunching capabili-
ties, can play a fundamental role to support radi- Key Points
ology departments to deal with the ever-increasing
amount of available imaging, making sense of such • 2018 main technology trends in healthcare
enormous quantity of data and extracting valuable such as AI, machine learning VR/AR, IoT and
insight for improving diagnosis and therapies. It Blockchain, should not be seen as “trends”
doesn’t therefore come as a surprise that the rele- anymore.
vant AI in the medical imaging market is expected • Approximately 90% of the health data
to grow to 2 billion USD by 2023, according to generated is medical imaging.
recent forecasts (Harris 2018). • Fragmented PACS systems and siloed
Still, it is very important for the proper and databases make it very difficult to properly
successful implementation of these technolo- use data while ensuring security.
gies in an operational environment, that a thor- • Blockchain can benefit imaging by enabling
ough learning phase is completed. In such a distributed teleradiology, allowing offsite and
scenario, introducing a more open, distributed, onsite diagnostics, providing transparency to
all parties in the care chain.
and “democratised” way of accessing and sharing
medical images, via Blockchain-based open and
distributed database, could dramatically improve
REFERENCES
AI training process at the same time reducing the
risk of biases of the resulting algorithms, by taking Alexander A, McGill M, Tarasova A, Ferreira C, Zurkiya D (2018) Scanning the Future
data from a variety of sparse and different sources, of Medical Imaging. Journal of the American College of Radiology. Available from jacr.
org/article/S1546-1440(18)31282-1/abstract
therefore improving clinical value.
Harris S (2018) AI in Medical Imaging to Top $2 Billion by 2023. Signify
Such a new open environment would greatly Research. Available from signifyresearch.net/medical-imaging/
contribute in improving interoperabilit y and ai-medical-imaging-top-2-billion-2023/
32 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
Can Blockchain
change the healthcare
ecosystem?
Discovering the potential of Blockchain development; pursuing
advantages of creating decentralised architectures.
This article presents an abstract concept and predictive benefit of applying Blockchain
technology in the healthcare ecosystem. Some current working use cases show the poten-
tial short-term benefits of Blockchain database replacement.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
D
ata sensitiveness by nature and by law prevents Furthermore, what is worse, the data had been
it to be shared freely among institutions- sold to third parties without the permission or agree-
a silent obstacle- building barriers we find ment of patients and without ensuring any data safety
surrounding each of the clinical operations. Interoper- provisions in some cases. Medical data is one of the
ability is a necessary element to enable the seamless most sensitive assets for an individual. From Pew
distribution of medical data in order to provide patients Research analysis, “Americans Consider Certain Kinds
with efficient treatment and eliminate miscommuni- of Data to be More Sensitive than Others” in 2014
cation. From a medical viewpoint, Blockchain tech- (Madden 2014), over half of of American respondents
nology originally embraces some deployment features, said they consider private health and medical infor-
in addition to, propelling digital-driven healthcare mation to have the highest sensitivity level among Kohei Kurihara
counterparts. all their data. President of Tokyo Chapter
Government Blockchain
Exponentially, with the enormous amount of data Association
Who owns medical data? in healthcare, both the administration of this data and Co-Founder, CMO
Medical information is respectively administrated patient usability becomes significant. Blockchain tech- CollaboGate
Tokyo, Japan
within the specific healthcare institutions, derived nology is expected to disrupt the concept of privacy
[email protected]
from a patient’s data and diagnosis and is kept in its settlement from centralised ownership to empow-
@kuriharan
original format regardless of the standard within which ering the individual management of personal data.
similar categorised operations share it. It burdens the The asset in the case of Blockchain is that once @gbaglobal
patients and healthcare providers, when they wish to you have received any medical information in the clinic .linkedin.com/in/kuriharan/
visit other facilities, as data which can not be evalu- and are diagnosed with a specific symptom, your
ated or analysed through consecutive formats is of medical record inherits a personal database and is
no use or value. The Electric Data Interchange has encrypted in real time. As this output is not governed
revealed critical issues among different services by any third party, it will be able to submit unbiased or
that are harnessing information on a medical data- altered information within the available environment.
base with limited interoperation and a ‘connected’ The government has tried individual data authori-
environment. From a business point of view, this is a ties; My Health My Data (www.myhealthmydata.eu/)
nasty arrangement that leads the customer/patient for example is a European project, aiming to create
to reject their services and never come back again as a transmittable medical information transaction by
a consequence. storing data on Blockchain.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 33
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
From the operational point, a Blockchain data- a hacking incident and potential targeting, otherwise
base is capable of retaining multiple adaptions in risking to lose customer trust and ultimately any
parallel among some medical institutions, by all profits to their bottom line. Evaluating the security
means increasing effective access while releasing costs of implementing adequate measures strong
data management from centralised ownerships. enough to avoid critical assaults requires expertise
and additional cost.
Who covers security costs? Recently, Korea’s Myongji Hospital announced they
The onslaught of data theft further burdens health- signed an agreement with BICube, to collaborate on
care providers with issues of liability concerning the development of a Blockchain-based medical infor-
information ownership, the constant need to mation exchange system. In the recent announce-
strengthen security teams and the increasing cost of ment by the hospital, the main purpose of the agree-
compensation. This will continue to put great pres- ment is to “Build a hybrid cloud that combines public
sure on institutions that have large centralised data and private clouds, and to secure the safety of online
pools. In 2015, the Japanese Pension Service was medical information exchange system by combining
hacked and 1.25 million files of personal data were blockchain technology in the process of exchanging
leaked instantly, including sensitive personal infor- medical data through the cloud”, essentially to
mation like people’s pension IDs, names, addresses combine Blockchain technology and a cloud data-
and birth dates, according to a report published in base (Myongji Hospital News 2014).
the Japan Times. Managing medical information will require a great
deal of expenses on behalf of the data holder, it is
therefore preferable to adopt a decentralised opera-
THE PROBLEM BECOMES
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
tion system cutting cost in the long-run of all future
WORSE SINCE THERE IS ALREADY endeavours.
A SHORTAGE OF RADIOLOGY Who trusts the information?
SUBSPECIALISTS IN THE US Pharmaceutical supply chains are faced with immeas-
TO MAINTAIN SUFFICIENT urable issues, in the meanwhile, from the top to
bottom of their distribution, to take measures that
SERVICES will prevent contaminated drugs and errors in the
mixture of drugs until they are ready and placed for
This incident happened as a result of an agency sale in retail drug stores and pharmacies. According
officer opening a suspicious file which then instantly to a recent World Health Organization report, coun-
infected the PC. All emails sent from there contained terfeit drug production has been increasing; the top
the virus and helped it spread infecting the entire three countries where threats originate are India at
administration core storage files simultaneously. 31%, UAE at 31% and China at 20% (Robles et al. nd).
When it comes to preventing a data hacking invasion A few years ago, there were serious incidents
from outside threats, it is not easy to predict; educa- in Paraguay and Pakistan when a large number of
tion and anti-virus software alone are not enough, a patients were administered cough syrups containing
comprehensive safety plan requires serious scrutiny contaminated agents while they were in the hospital.
inside the management process. In accordance with Although these incidents affected many people,
the set protocols in any operation structure and the manufactures and the hospitals were unaware and
relevant data sharing regulations put in place, the unable to provide tracking to the original sources of
owner of the information is held accountable and this supply chain. Despite the severity of the contam-
forced to pay attention and do the utmost to predict ination, the complicated routes of the data could not
and protect the network against potential unknown allow officials to locate the precise factor of infections
attacks. In particular, medical data is one of the in order to provide timely treatment to the infected
most valuable and sensitive sets of information and patients. Information asymmetry leads to ubiquitous
contains varieties of tangled asset records. Patients consumption ratios and inescapable influences due
and healthcare providers are becoming more anxious to unknown nature of the structure, so that trace-
demanding that their security service is perfect, in ability is recognised as an imminent requirement in
an effort to prove the best safety capabilities against order to recall and clear the tainted drugs from the
34 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
Social security numbers, health info and phone conversations among the most
sensitive data
% of adults who report varying levels of sensitive about the following kinds of info
Very Somewhat Not Not
Sensitive sensitive too at all
5
Your social securtity number 90 5 21
State of your health and the medications you take 55 26 12 5
Content of your phone conversation 54 27 13 4
Content of your email messages 52 25 13 7
Details of your physical location over time 50 32 11 5
Content of your text messages 49 26 13 8
Numbers you have called or texted 45 30 16 6
Your birth date 41 25 19 14
Your relationship history 40 31 14 12
Websites you have visited 27 43 20 8
Searches you have made using search engines 24 41 22 10
Your religious and spiritual views 22 23 29 25
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Your friends and what they are like 22 46 23 7
Your political views and the candidates you support 20 31 30 17
The media you like 9 22 45 21
Your basic purchasing habits 8 33 44 14
Source: Pew Reseach Privacy Panel Survey, January 2014, N=607 adults, ages 18 and older.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
entire distribution channels. Who insures your healthcare security?
Pharmaceutical giant, Novartis has started to Medical insurance provides access for financial
experiment with the use of Blockchain technology support while you are making payment with negoti-
since 2016, even at the early stages of Proof of ating discounted prices and in some cases supported
Concept, in an effort to demonstrate an imagined from third party payers and government health-
future with IoT harnessing services, storing tempera- care systems. However, the insurance process gets
tures and the ability to locate and identify counterfeit more complicated through a series of identification
ingredients inside supply chain provisions. and assessment requirements within each specific
Having the data to track elements of the distribu- payment coverage and the potential of accepting or
tion chain like the spots where the delivery truck has denying a patients claim. Currently, most insurance
been routed through for example, or how and when contractors spend significant time intervals, even
the products are delivered to the final vendor will help when the patient has been diagnosed with a clear
to increase the accuracy and minimise the margin for and acceptable healthcare symptom, because of
outside tampering of products. Besides, the tamper- congested administrative processes; and the patient
proof Blockchain database guarantees increased is left to wait until the needed verification in order to
quality of trust compared to the current mostly hand- receive treatment.
written documentation records while securing preven- Healthcare data is continuously being refined
tive storage against intentionally malicious attempts. through beneficiaries to be able to provide more
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 35
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
accurate information yet needs to be rethought by enterprises need to follow this enforcement, in terms
minimising the effect of human error. This entire veri- of administrate privacy and medical data (Edemekong
fication system costs both in financial and human et al. 2018).
resources capital to complete, maintain and manage. In 2015, there was a massive hacking incident
Blockchain technology provides the tools to help that leaked more than 3.9 million patients’ medical
decompose these complex procedures, improving the information nationwide by EHR vendor Medical Infor-
shortage of information and data, replacing them to matics Engineering. In this case, the electronic health-
integrate data flow in a single operation. care record vendor was suspected to be in violation
Actually, new healthcare organisation alliances have of HIPPA rules and other state regulations, and held
started out between groups of insurance providers. accountable for the breach of records including radi-
UnitedHealthcare and Humana, Optum, Quest Diag- ology patients.
nostics and MultiPlan are now launching Blockchain In this case, the electronic medical record vendor
pilot programmes, helping out payers to tackle complex was in direct violation of the process of operation to
bureaucracies within their organisations. These store information, and handle sensitive patient data.
programmes focus on improving data quality and elim- The problem becomes worse since there is already
inating the administration procedures, to pursue cost a shortage of radiology subspecialists in the US to
efficient operation. maintain sufficient services. According to the Merritt
Hawkins figure the number varies from the 2016 ACR
Commission on Human Resources Workforce Survey
A DECENTRALISED in the article published in Diagnostic Imaging showing
28% of the radiology workforce is 56 or older (Kaplan
BLOCKCHAIN PLATFORM THAT
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
2016). In both cases, though, a significant number of
CONNECTS HEALTHCARE radiologists are nearing retirement age. It is evident
FACILITIES, RADIOLOGISTS that there is a need for more resources to improve
service delivery.
AND AI ALGORITHMS, ENABLES In order to solve this issue, the MDW project, a
RADIOLOGISTS TO PREVIEW decentralised Blockchain platform that connects
healthcare facilities, radiologists and AI algorithms,
AND PURCHASE VERIFIABLE enables radiologists to preview and purchase verifi-
ALGORITHMS able algorithms to enhance their practice. Radiologists
gain compensation once their report is accepted. This
results in lower costs giving radiologists the ability to
According to healthcare IT news, insurance providers access high quality expertise.
have received similar requests from dozens of payers. It There is a lack of talent to manage the current
takes a lot of time and money to reach out to providers medical system structure. As such, it is unable to
on each 90-day cycle. Congested calls and emails delay sustain the needs of healthcare overall and imaging
those inquiries, heavy access traffic jams. in particular. These issues can be resolved with new
In this pilot, alliance members curated information technology like Blockchain. Blockchain databases can
to be shared, confirming the overlapping with other help secure the environment by following the regula-
provider’s data and highlighting the need to prevent tory requirements and by only distributing encrypted
the duplication of processes within each of them. information more efficiently.
How to deal with patient images? Who is aggressively betting on health-
Medical imaging information is sensitive and crucial care Blockchain?
for both diagnosis and treatment. The patient retains From PwC’s 2018 Global Blockchain survey, 49% of
ownership of the imaging data, and has secure indi- global healthcare companies have started Blockchain
vidual rights against any service provider failing to pilot programmes (PwC Global Blockchain Survey
protect the data from risk of leaking or malicious 2018). Even though this survey was conducted within
manipulation. In the US, the Health Insurance Port- a limit of 74 healthcare enterprises, other evidence
ability and Accountability Act (HIPPA) defines the rule suggests there is an increase in healthcare trials using
of privacy and medical data security; respectively Blockchain pilot programmes.
36 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
From the healthcare perspective, it tends to certification credits in order to prove data accuracy.
combine health privacy data with payment or other For example, the American Drug Supply Chain
financial access. Some companies explore the tech- Security Act (DSCSA) outlines the steps required to
nology as an alternative to the traditional process build an electronic and interoperable system, capable
that requires endless paperwork and human centric of identifying and tracing prescription drugs distrib-
enforcement. Blockchain companies are making uted in the US market (Drug Supply Chain Security Act
a move to explore the potential of the healthcare FDA). In order to protect consumers from contami-
market, adding significant value by cost cutting and nated products and otherwise harmful incidents,
providing simplified overall management. companies need to adhere to legal frameworks set
in place for distribution. However, regulatory require-
How to build a decentralised operation ments are not the same between multilateral nations,
system in healthcare? so that it is now necessary to develop solutions such
In terms of healthcare areas, a decentralised network as Blockchain pipelines with the potential to securely
facilitates private data transformation from a central- service international healthcare delivery systems.
ised database to the individual end user or owner of In conclusion, Blockchain is a decentralised data-
the data, the patient. In accordance with the growth base, potentially a tool that will be widely imple-
of health-tech and medical-tech innovation, data mented in the next generation of our society to
ownership has certainly come on the table, and solu- disrupt traditional healthcare ecosystems. However,
tions to tackle the sovereignty issues of ownership we still have to fill knowledge and experience gaps
and privacy will ultimately be provided by new plat- by empirical operation and trials in various areas to
forms. As a result, architectural concepts will have determine how this technology can be further applied
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
to be changed while information ownership and indi- in healthcare and imaging as a natural extension.
vidual control will rely on the effective operation of From industry and government viewpoints, the
these platforms. inclusion of multiple stakeholders is the key element,
Basically, when it comes to the application of even at the stage of discussion because Blockchain
Blockchain, it is important to involve all the stake- solutions must combine each player of the healthcare
holders, visualise a consensus algorithm and incen- continuum if they are to produce meaningful value.
tive structure, and choose an appropriate govern-
ance and maintenance model. It is also important to
consider some risks in advance that could possibly
have an impact on governance or breach the rules. Key Points
However, the entire mechanism differs from the
number of audiences and stakeholders; moreover, • Data ownership discussion becomes more
consensus algorithms influence the management serious by harnessing Blockchain-based
block scales in consequences. Regardless of the operations
technical aspects, government regulation is going • Accurate traced information secures
to enforce Blockchain modeling unless it conflicts customer protection under the regulations
with enacted items on existing laws. Data privacy is • Single pipelines are more cost effective than
controversial and on the table in a constant attempt congested current operations
to ‘synchronise’ governance and technology innova- • First experiment, second create the standard,
tion. Ultimately, Blockchain systems will be utilised as third follow with operation
REFERENCES
A new paradigm in health- Kaplan DA (2016) Is Radiology part of Blockchain-based medical info containment of spurious/substand-
care data privacy and security. the physician shortage? Diagnostic exchange system (2014) Myongji ard/falsely-labelled/falsified/counter-
MyHealthMyData.eu. Imaging. Hospital News. feit medical products through sus-
tainable multi-stakeholder collabo-
Drug Supply Chain Security Act Madden, Mary (2014) Americans con- PwC global Blockchain survey (2018). ration and community/consumer-
(DSCSA). FDA US Food & Drug sider certain kinds of data to be more PwC. based Interventions. Medicines
Administration. Edemekong PF, sensitive than others. Pew Research Transparency Alliance, Philippines.
Haydel MJ (2018) Health Insurance Center. Robles, YR, Casauay JF, Bulatao
Portability and Accountability Act BP (n.d.) Addressing the barriers to
(HIPAA). StatPearls Publishing. Myongji Hospital, BICube to develop effective monitoring, reporting and
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 37
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
Blockchain for radiology
Key areas where Blockchain has the potential to spark a revolution
& increase quality while decreasing healthcare cost.
Blockchain is an exciting new technology that promises to address many problems that exist
within the current framework in radiology. We discuss three key areas where Blockchain can
potentially spark a revolution and increase quality while decreasing healthcare cost.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Bhargav Raman
Radiologist, Chief
Innovation Officer
Medpixels Inc.
San Francisco Bay Area, USA
[email protected]
linkedin.com/in/bhargavraman
Krithika
Chandrasekaran
Radiologist, COO
B
Medpixels Inc.
San Francisco Bay Area, USA lockchain technology is an exciting new tech- read blind. Finally, the rise of AI is imminent and has
[email protected] nology that promises to address many prob- brought the need for massive amounts of good data
lems that exist within the current framework for training. Blockchain can help create the needed
linkedin.com/in/krithika-chan-
drasekaran-md-mph-can- in radiology. The radiology economic model is ripe datasets and support the continuous evaluation and
didate-1164b6144/
for disruption with the possibility to eliminate profit- improvement process needed by AI.
focused intermediaries to better connect the referring
clinician and radiologist. Data sharing between radiol- Economics
ogists and their referring clinicians is key to improving The practice of radiology is in crisis. Rampant
the quality of radiology reports – radiologists cannot commoditisation of radiology has resulted in a race
38 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
to the bottom in terms of quality in the name of the details. Legally speaking, this is fine, but the
decreasing cost and decreasing turnaround times unhelpful radiology report that ends with ‘clinically
for busy, Diagnosis Related Group (DRG) capitated correlate’ is a running joke in the clinical community.
emergency rooms and hospitals. The entire economy Finally, there is the erosion of the doctor-doctor
is based on cranking through as many patients as relationship between the radiologist and the refer-
possible in as little time as possible. The practice ring clinician. These conversations often lead to major
of radiology and indeed healthcare in general has changes in the report or lead to major clarifications
become a factory, a factory in which both doctors and that directly affect patient care. However, the radi-
patients are exploited for monetary gain by private ologist increasingly has little incentive to engage in
equity and large consolidated hospital systems. these conversations and has less time to actually
have a fruitful conversation. Time spent talking is
time spent not reading another scan, and more time
THE PRACTICE OF spent at the office finishing work.
RADIOLOGY HAS BECOME A Ultimately these issues are caused by profit-
FACTORY IN WHICH BOTH focused intermediaries whose incentive is to create
the situation where every clinician is working as hard
DOCTORS AND PATIENTS as possible to increase RVU and billing. Quality is
ARE EXPLOITED FOR an afterthought or a regulatory necessity. The busi-
ness of radiology is ripe for decentralisation, as the
MONETARY GAIN diagnostic radiologist can work from any location
and indeed could be in any part of the world. With
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
The question of quality also looms large in today’s the right structure, a blockchain-based decentral-
high-volume environments. One could put in normal ised teleradiology system would completely disrupt
radiology reports without looking, but that is unac- the industry by eliminating adverse incentives and
ceptable. But how little looking is really ‘not looking’? creating healthy competition between radiologists
During training, we are taught to always use an to provide timely, quality reads, and competition
unchanging mental system, such that we do not between clients to pay for these reads.
miss anything on any scan. In practice, radiologists Imagine a system whereby any client, whether it
still often miss, misinterpret or fail to mention find- be a large hospital system or small imaging centre,
ings, most of no clinical consequence, some with does not need to negotiate pricing with any vendor.
significant consequences. This is not because of a Instead, the client need only use open-sourced soft-
lack of a system or that the radiologists in question ware and standards to connect to a decentralised
are incompetent, it is because radiologists look too Blockchain-based system that gives them direct
fast, and in the worst case, are financially incentiv- access to individual radiologists, each of whom
ised to look too fast. have set pricing for their reads, credentialing infor-
Additionally, one could just describe imaging mation, speed and quality metrics. Other software
findings without giving a differential or helping the built on top of the system can automatically send
clinician interpret these findings in any way. This studies to particular radiologists based on this public
approach treats radiology as akin to laboratory test, data. Reporting times, referring physician feedback
which it plainly is not. Radiologists make critical deci- and quality scores can be immutably stored on the
sions on every scan outside of simply reporting find- Blockchain. Clients who need faster reads would
ings. Carefully constructed language in the report need to pay more to compete for radiologist atten-
reflects our confidence in our findings and their clin- tion. Similarly, radiologists who are faster, have a sub
ical significance. Yet, again due to lack of time and specialisation or have higher quality can potentially
sometimes due to sheer burnout from volume, radi- charge more for their services. This kind of compe-
ologists will often just describe the findings, give a tition leads to a healthy ecosystem where incentives
pro-forma differential, and offer no customisation to are aligned towards better value and optimisation
patient’s unique presentation or symptomatology. along the quality, cost and timeliness dimensions.
Unstructured, often unreadable reports pervade Versions of such a system have also been proposed
this space, where the referring clinician often just or have reached partial implementation and are also
reads the impression without really understanding worth a read (Patel 2018); (Reinsmith 2017); (MDW
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 39
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
n.d.). There are several issues that need to be solved clinicians, due to the same factory mentality.
before such a system can become a reality. First, While there have been trends towards value-based
most large hospital systems have draconian creden- practice for healthcare in general there seems to be
tialing requirements that include submission of paper little movement for incorporating this for medical
documentation of licensing and other information imaging. Programmes such as Merit Based Incentive
in order to be credentialed at a hospital to provide Payments System (MIPS) have taken first steps but
services. Private imaging centres are more agile in do not address the important issue that the radiol-
this respect and may be the first target customers. ogist is essentially blinded to the patient history and
In addition, in the United States, medical licensing treated like a lab technician rather than a doctor. The
requirements differ from state-to-state and main- radiologist needs to be patient-centric not image-
taining a 50-state license is close to impossible for centric. But this can only be done through effective
a single person. These functions would also need and easy data sharing between institutions.
to be decentralised and outsourced in order for the Much has been discussed regarding Blockchain-
system to function. Privacy is another major issue, based EMRs and there is already great momentum
though solvable. For example, it is a given that each around storing and accessing EMRs on the Block-
client already has their own storage. The Blockchain chain (Dubovitskaya et al. 2018). Coupled with algo-
could simply store an encrypted access link with rithms designed to show relevant data to the remote
unique keys provided only to the radiologist to whom radiologist, the radiologist would have enough data to
the case has been assigned. No patient information connect the dots in order to provide a better quality
need actually be stored on-chain. Indeed, storing read. In addition, if any follow-up recommendations
vast amounts of information on-chain is not effi- are given, these recommendations can also be stored
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
cient as the chain size can exponentially increase and validated on the Blockchain.
causing increased computational resource needs to
run the Blockchain.
While simple in concept, the implementation can CHANGES CAN BE
become highly complex as anyone who has run a ACCELERATED WITH
teleradiology company can attest. However, these
kinds of solutions are needed on the road to decen- BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY
tralise healthcare economics, align incentives and WITHOUT THE NEED FOR
ultimately drive value optimisation.
EXPENSIVE, PROFIT-FOCUSED
Data sharing and quality INTERMEDIARIES AND ADMINIS-
When we talk about health data siloes, one must
acknowledge the elephant in the room: medical
TRATIVE STRUCTURES
imaging. Radiology is not only siloed with respect
to the data availability and data sharing but the Additionally, through implementing smart-contract
radiologists themselves are often cut off from the based value-based models and payment systems,
patients for whom they are reading a scan. Due to we can not only create novel quality metrics, one
lack of actual interaction with the patient the radiol- can also directly incentivise the improvement of
ogist often has to deal with vague symptom descrip- these metrics in a trustless, decentralised manner
tions such as “pain,” which is often entered more for that reduces burdensome administrative cost and
the purposes of successful billing than for actual complexity that generally come with value-based
accuracy. The quality of communication in radiology payment programs. For example, quality metrics
requisitions is in alarming decline (Wassermann & could include referring provider and patient satis-
Straus 2018). Without an appropriate background the faction, compliance with MIPS criteria, structured
quality of the read suffers and ultimately results in reports, extent of report editing, number of correctly
poor patient outcomes. Often, the common advice protocolled exams, appropriate follow up in concert
is: why not call the ordering physician? Unfortunately, with ACR guidelines, among others (Heller 2016).
while this seems like the obvious solution the main Blockchain can do all this in complete transparency
problem is time. As already mentioned, radiologists without the added administrative costs burdening
are extremely time-limited, but so are the referring implementations today.
40 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
The rise of artificial intelligence (AI) designers can track and evaluate its learning by
Whether we like it or not, AI is coming. The extent looking back or simply replaying the chain, giving
of its impact on the practice of radiology and radi- more insight and greater human oversight on AI deci-
ology training is yet to be seen. That said, if one sion making. True and false positives and true and
looks at mammography (arguably the simplest of false negatives as determined by users and vali-
the modalities to write and train an algorithm or AI dated on the Blockchain by other radiologists on
for), it has already undergone a fundamental change the network can eventually create the kind of large
due to the introduction of computer aided detection dataset needed to train complex systems.
of anomalies on breast mammograms. Radiologists
most often use the system as a second reader and Conclusion
evaluate every one of the false positives detected Provision of healthcare in the United States and else-
by such systems for the elusive true positive, but where will undergo a fundamental change in the next
the impact on sensitivity for suspicious lesions is 20 years as the current downward spiral of value
significant. Most likely, as AI interpretation of images changes. Market solutions that align incentives to
becomes more and more common, the combined provide that value will ultimately lead to optimisation
human and machine approach will be the wave of the along the quality, cost and timeliness dimensions. In
future throughout radiology. Radiology will eventually addition to fundamental economic changes, the shift
morph into not only how to interpret images but how to value-based incentivisation will require creation of
to use the various AI systems for maximum value. novel models. Finally, AI is bursting onto the scene
The problem here is dependable data that is and the need for massive amounts of good data
distributed, secure, available and constantly updated. will drive efficient, decentralised methods of data
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
To train the best deep learning networks, one needs sharing and training dataset creation. All of these
as much good data as possible. Otherwise, often rare changes can be accelerated with Blockchain tech-
events will not be reliably detected without exten- nology without the need for expensive, profit-focused
sive feature engineering and the influence of selec- intermediaries and administrative structures.
tion bias will affect the generalisability of the final
product. Because we often lack insight into deep
learning models, biases can be insidious and become
dangerous. Unlike mammograms, the number of Key Points
possible pathologies increases exponentially on
• Economics - Key economic factors in
other modalities, increasing multifold the compu-
the practice of radiology render it ripe for
tational complexity, and therefore the needed data decentralisation
and training time. After initial training, the next major
• Data Sharing – Data sharing between
step is a continual improvement process where the radiologists and their referring clinicians
AI constantly evolves using real-world data. This is can be enabled by blockchain technology
where decentralised, trustless data sharing can have • AI – The rise of AI has brought the need for
a major impact. A Blockchain-based AI can not only massive amounts of good data for training.
learn from shared data from multiple institutions, Blockchain can help.
REFERENCES
Dubovitskaya A, Xu Z, Ryu S, Measures in Diagnostic Radiology with and decentralized sharing of medical b0bacb356374
Schumacher M, Wang F (2018) Secure Suggestions for Future Advancement. imaging data via blockchain consensus.
and Trustable Electronic Medical Journal of the American College of Health Informatics Journal. Wassermann TB & Straus CM (2018)
Records Sharing using Blockchain. Radiology, 13:(10), 1182–87. A Failure to Communicate?: Trends in
AMIA Annual Symposium Proceedings, Reinsmith L (2017) A Blockchain the Radiology Requisition, 2011–2016.
2017, 650–59. MDW (n.d.). Available from mdw.io/ for Medical Imaging. Available from Academic Radiology, 25:(7) 943–50.
from medium.com/@semanticmd/a- doi.org/10.1016/j.acra.2017.11.029
Heller RE (2016) An Analysis of Quality Patel V (2018) A framework for secure blockchain-for-medical-imaging-
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 41
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
Blockchain and GDPR
compliance for the
healthcare industry
Permissioned blockchains for healthcare data sharing
management
In times of rising concerns about data privacy among services providers and consumers,
the arrival of the new GDPR alongside cutting-edge technologies can help to better act
and benefit the healthcare industry.
C
oncepts like traceability, compliance, access across multiple devices that may operate geographi-
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
David Manset control, and risk control and assessment cally distant from each other. In this scenario, govern-
Head of Research and Innovation
Be-Studys (Almerys group) have always been of utmost importance for ance over the data in a distributed ledger is achieved
Geneva, Switzerland the healthcare industry. Not only from an economic using a consensus mechanism among the parties that
[email protected] point of view but also because the associated involved hold a copy of the ledger. In this context, consensus
@dmanset
responsibility and management are difficult to handle. refers to a protocol that ensures that parties agree
Over the last years, researchers have identified to a specific state of the system as the valid one.
Laura Bernal many use cases within the Blockchain ecosystem According to the definition given by the Hyperledger
Marketing and communication to tackle such problems. Moreover, patient data project, a distributed ledger relies on three essential
Be-Studys (Almerys group)
Paris, France
management, clinical trials, and even drug tracea- components:
bility are currently being studied as use cases for • A data model that captures the current state
Master’s degree in entrepre-
neurship and management Blockchain (Quora 2018), posing new challenges for of the ledger.
Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne a promising 2019. • A language of transactions that can change
[email protected] One of the biggest challenges has to do with the the ledger state.
arrival of the new European General Data Protec- • A protocol used to build consensus among
Mirko Koscina tion Regulation (GDPR), which came into force in participants around which transactions will
Research Project Manager May 2018. The GDPR was introduced to protect and be accepted, and in what order, by the ledger.
Be-Studys (Almerys group)
Clermont-Ferrand, France empower EU citizen’s data privacy and to better deal
with the asymmetry between organizations that With the above in mind, a Blockchain can be
PhD student in infor-
mation security handle and work with personal data and individuals defined as a type of DLT with specific characteris-
École Normal Supérieure (ENS)
control over their data. In this context, some prin- tics that differentiate it from other types of distrib-
[email protected] ciples or rights conferred by the regulation such as uted ledgers. It is an append-only ledger organized as
the right to be forgotten may clash at first with the a chain of blocks that relies on a peer-to-peer network
Octavio Perez usage of distributed ledger technologies (DLT), due to to perform its management, updates and operations.
Kempner
their permanent nature. To correctly assess the risks Roughly speaking, blocks are merely containers for
Research Engineer
Be-Studys (Almerys group) related to the GDPR-DLT relationship and to better transactions and they can be linked to an existing
Clermont-Ferrand, France
determine how the two of them can be used together chain of blocks allowing it to grow. As a data struc-
PhD student in infor- to address existing problems, common ground and ture, a Blockchain has two distinctive features which
mation security
École Normal Supérieure (ENS)
clear definitions should be established first. are block timestamps and hash pointers that link the
To start with, a distributed ledger is a type of data last block of the chain to the previous one in such a
[email protected]
structure which is replicated, shared, and synchronized way that any modification made on a block compels
@octaviopk
42 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
Figure 1. Use cases for blockchain tech in healthcare. (Hello tomorrow, 2018)
the regeneration of the following blocks in the chain. between Maersk and IBM to develop TradeLens, a
Together, timestamps and hash pointers can supply chain system supported by the permissioned
provide a tamper-proof capability to a Blockchain and Blockchain Hyperledger Fabric.
this, in turn, allows it to achieve a high level of secu- Moreover, the European Blockchain Observatory
rity thanks to the immutability guarantees of its data and Forum has published a technical report which
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
structure. This immutability feature makes the Block- recommends, in case of needing to store sensitive
chain suitable for accounting, financial transactions, data, to use private and permissioned Blockchains.
and asset ownership management and transfer. For In particular, achieving privacy is very challenging and
instance, the idea of the so-called “Internet of Value” the current absence of mechanisms to keep user’s
(Leonard 2018) is based on those use cases. privacy in permissioned Blockchains is turning highly
Alongside immutability, a very close concept is that relevant.
of compliance. Since it is possible to create tamper- Illustrating such a possible scenario, MyHealth-
proof (or immutable) records using a Blockchain even MyData (MHMD) is a project carried out by a consor-
in scenarios where parties may not fully nor partially tium of companies that connects hospitals and
trust each other. This also makes a Blockchain suit- research centers in Europe to enable the sharing
able for attestation of compliance. A Blockchain can of medical data (from medical records to radiology
be very useful when one needs to attest compliance, images) in a private Blockchain network. MHMD is a
for example, in relation to the manipulation of certain European project with the ambition to become the
data. first research data network focused on linking organi-
Another relevant aspect is that of the Blockchain's zations and individuals to the health ecosystem. This
network being permissionless (open, everyone can initiative encourages hospitals to pseudonymize their
join) or permissioned (closed, permission is needed). data for research while giving individuals control of
In scenarios where partially or fully trusted parties their health data. MHMD wants to become the refer-
want to work together or need from each other, a ence data “marketplace”, providing verified informa-
permissioned Blockchain is better suitable. In such tion to value networks in the health ecosystem.
scenarios, since parties are known to each other, they MHMD is a scenario in which the proposed block-
can be identified and thus can be granted or revoked chain (private and permissioned) grants the possibility
with permission. of sharing any kind of sensitive health data example:
Permissioned Blockchains have contributed to the behavioral data, clinical data, biological data, imaging
Blockchain adoption in closed ecosystems and busi- data (CT, ultrasound, MRI, X-ray, scintigraphy), bacte-
ness applications. Some examples include the Plas- riological / parasitology data, IoT data among others.
ticTwist project that creates a new circular economy (Hello Tomorrow 2018)
based on an ERC20 cryptocurrency implemented Here, the health ecosystem which is composed
on the top of a permissioned ledger to encourage of European citizens, hospitals, research centers
plastics recycling across Europe and the joint effort and businesses is faced with two contradictory
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 43
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
requirements. On the one hand, the principle of and evaluation of the data cycle have to be carried
open science defined by the European Commission out to correctly understand how to attest compliance
as a new approach to the scientific process based at the same time as being able to empower citizens
on cooperative works, sharing and using all avail- over the control of their own data.
able knowledge at an early stage in the research MHMD’s approach to this is to ensure that looking
process with new ways of diffusing knowledge by at the transactions stored on the Blockchain it is
using digital technologies and collaborative tools impossible to know the parties involved in a trans-
(European Commission 2018). On the other hand, action (i.e., unlinkability) nor the concerned data.
the GDPR regulation and its application to health This property increases the overall level of privacy
data compliance. of the resulting system. For this purpose, a privacy-
preserving consensus algorithm was designed based
HEALTH DATA RELATES on PBFT (Liskov s.d.), so-called “proof-of-privacy”, that
relies on Okamoto-Schnorr's blind signature scheme
TO PHYSICAL OR MENTAL (Tatsuki Okamoto s.d.). This, together with the fact
HEALTH, PAST, PRESENT OR that the data lifecycle is managed through a catalog
in a way that it can be indexed and referenced in the
FUTURE, OF A NATURAL PERSON Blockchain by storing a hash value of the indexed
THAT REVEAL INFORMATION data items. This process allows the MHMD Block-
chain to maintain the records of available data and
ABOUT THE HEALTH STATUS OF its associated history without the need to record the
THAT PERSON private data itself, the latter remaining off chain. Using
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
one-way cryptographic algorithms to describe data
In order to succeed, however, challenges arising and transactions results in an anonymous ledger,
from the GDPR must be addressed. A major one is which also prevents from statistical inference to
to enforce the privacy of the citizens while allowing locate data or individuals thanks to k-anonymity like
the organisations to continue their clinical research models. Following two years of intense prototyping,
(public interest) and to respect the law. Since GDPR, a GDPR-compliant permissioned Blockchain is now
health data has a more precise definition, health data under deployment in pioneer hospital and research
“relates to physical or mental health, past, present centers in Europe, to validate the concept.
or future, of a natural person that reveal information
about the health status of that person.” (Aumage Key Points
2018)
Due to this and the introduction of new individu- • Blockchain and the European General Data
al’s rights such as the right to be forgotten, one has Protection Regulation.
to be very careful with the immutability property of • Permissioned Blockchains.
a Blockchain, when dealing with personal data. To
• Solutions based on “proof-of-privacy” for the
solve these paradoxical matters, in-depth analysis Healthcare industry.
REFERENCES
Behlow JD, Aumage B (2018) Health in-the-year-but-this-has-happened- the-internet-of-value-what-it-means- tech in healthcare? (2018) IBM.
data and data privacy: challenges for before-2018-1 and-how-it-benefits-everyone/ Available from ibm.com/blogs/block-
data processors under the GDPR. chain/2018/12/what-are-the-use-cases-
Global data hub. Available from European Commission (2018) Castro M, Liskov B. (n.d) Practical for-blockchain-tech-in-healthcare/
globaldatahub.taylorwessing.com/ Europa.eu. Available from Byzantine Fault Tolerance. USENIX.
article/health-data-and-data-privacy- ec.europa.eu/programmes/ Available from usenix.org/legacy/events/ Tatsuaki O (2001) Provably Secure and
challenges-for-data-processors-under- horizon2020/en/h2020-section/ osdi99/full_papers/castro/castro_html/ Practical Identification Schemes and
the-gdpr open-science-open-access castro.html Corresponding Signature Schemes.
Advances in Cryptology: 31-53
Chaparro F (2018) Cryptocurrency Hello tomorrow (2018). Blockchain et Njui JP (2018) Bitcoin (BTC) Under $6k,
markets are crashing early in the new données patients. Total Crypto Market Cap under $200 Vries AD (2018) Bitcoin's Growing
year — but bitcoin investors have seen Billion. What Next? EWN. Available Energy Problem. Joule 2/5:801-805
Leonard S (2018) The Internet of from ethereumworldnews.com/
this before. Business Insider. Available
Value: What It Means and How It bitcoin-btc-under-6k-total-crypto-
from businessinsider.fr/us/cryptocur-
Benefits Everyone. Ripple Insights.
rency-bitcoin-markets-tumbled-early-
Available from ripple.com/insights/ What are the use cases for blockchain
44 HealthManagement.org
Unblock the Chain COVER STORY
Healthcare 2019:
the year of the Big Data
Blockchain
An in-depth discussion of how Big Data Blockchain solutions
address the complex data needs of the healthcare industry.
Big Data Blockchains are solving the industry’s security and scalability challenges and hold
the potential to transform all facets of the healthcare industry: from decision support to pa-
tient empowerment to data sharing and operational improvement.
T
he healthcare industry generates a ton of data. healthcare data. In particular, it provides a level of
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Large, complex, diverse, highly regulated, messy transparency and trust that can help healthcare
data. And while EMRs have traditionally sat at systems gain better control over how data is shared,
the epicenter of all this data, the industry is beginning with whom, and under what circumstances. And the
to recognise that the data we traditionally think of as industry is taking notice: according to a 2018 report
healthcare data – that is, a person’s medical record by PwC Health Research Institute, 49% of global
– is only one part of a person’s overall health profile. healthcare companies are developing blockchain solu-
Their social, environmental and behavioral profile is tions (pwc.com/us/en/industries/health-indus-
just as important in determining which medical inter- tries/health-research-institute/blockchain-in-
ventions will work best for them. In addition, each healthcare.html). Frank Ricotta
Co-Founder and CEO
person is part of a community, and each person in In the last 12 months, over 100 companies have BurstIQ
that community has valuable information that can been founded with the goal of developing health- Denver,USA
CO
help healthcare providers make better decisions. care data sharing services using Blockchain. Most
[email protected]
Going into 2019, the healthcare industry finds of these solutions use Blockchain only as an access
@fricotta
itself faced with a multifaceted challenge: how to log and permission management system; the actual
bring together all of this large, complex, messy data; health data is stored and managed using traditional
how to securely make it available to providers, deci- centralised databases and data warehouses. While
sion support tools and AI algorithms, researchers and this limited use of Blockchain does improve transpar-
other stakeholders; how to give consumers visibility ency and patient control over data sharing, it does
and control over how their data is used; and how to not provide the necessary scalability to support global
achieve all of this without running afoul of data privacy interoperability and compliance. And perhaps most
and security regulations. importantly, data on these systems is still shared
using 1:1 data integrations and transfer protocols,
Blockchain may be the answer. making it nearly impossible to recall previously-shared
Yes, Blockchain is the technology behind cryptocur- data and comply with GDPR and other “right to be
rencies such as Bitcoin. However, its utility extends forgotten” laws. Robert Laidlaw
Co-Founder
far beyond the financial sector. Efforts are underway Image Chain
Wollongong, NSW
to deploy Blockchain-based data networks to energy, Bringing data onto the chain Australia
education, real estate, agriculture and more. For the BurstIQ, a Denver-based startup, was the first Block-
[email protected]
healthcare industry, Blockchain includes a number of chain company to successfully develop and commer-
@blockchainbob
attributes that are particularly useful for managing cialise a Blockchain protocol that addresses these
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 45
COVER STORY Unblock the Chain
challenges. The company, founded in 2015, recog- mining algorithms to allow radiologists and patholo-
nised the inherent limitations of standard Blockchain gists to remotely view and interpret images through a
protocols and understood that, in order to achieve global decentralised network, without compromising
truly global interoperability, they would need to start patient privacy or accuracy of the interpretation.
from scratch. The result is a unique, Blockchain-based
Big Data platform that enables large, complex data to The future of health is Blockchain
be stored, managed, shared, analysed and monetised The implications of Big Data Blockchain for the global
on a secure, HIPAA-compliant Blockchain. Their plat- healthcare industry are enormous. Instead of being
form is specifically designed to enable global inter- relegated to the periphery, Big Data Blockchain allows
operability, bringing together data from any source people to operate at the center of the value stream –
onto a Big Data Blockchain network that uses special- controlling how their own data is used and monetised.
ised smart contracts to manage everything from Big Data Blockchain enables interoperability and data
person-to-person data sharing to national regula- liquidity to be achieved on a global scale. It allows
tory enforcement. The company has commercialised regulatory compliance to be automated and adapt-
the platform with large health systems, health infor- able at both a corporate and governmental level. Busi-
mation exchanges (HIEs), independent software and ness intelligence departments, decision support tools,
service vendors (ISVs), governments and government AI engines and other intelligence systems can gain
agencies. access to new data sets, forming a comprehensive
So far, BurstIQ is the only Big Data Blockchain that and longitudinal view of clinical, operational, environ-
has achieved commercial success at the enterprise mental, social and other data. It eliminates the slow
level. Their success has been driven by strong part- and manual processes that have become standard
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
nerships with health systems and Big Data compa- practice for provider credentialing, prior authorisa-
nies. One such company is Australia-based Image tions and claim adjudication. It enables and enhances
Chain, the first online marketplace for dermatology- real-time analytics and intelligence algorithms. It
related images and associated medical data. The allows data to be managed with far greater speci-
company is using BurstIQ’s Big Data Blockchain plat- ficity, control and accountability. It opens the door
form to enable providers and researchers to securely to new research collaborations and medical discov-
access a treasure trove of images and data that can eries, greater individual empowerment and engage-
help them make better clinical decisions and discover ment, and global health access and equity.
new medical breakthroughs. And as part of BurstIQ’s Like all cutting-edge technologies, Blockchain is
global network, they are able to supplement their continuously evolving; both the technology and the
marketplace with complementary data sets that add market will continue to develop over the next five to
value and deepen insights. Most importantly, Image ten years. As the technology evolves, early adopters
Chain is placing people at the centre of that process like Image Chain will be well-positioned to lead the
– providing individuals with the power to control if market and shape global Blockchain standards. And
and how their data is available on the marketplace companies like BurstIQ are proving that Blockchain is
and to participate in the monetisation of their data. ready for the healthcare industry today and will likely
For radiology and other imaging-related specialties, become critical infrastructure in the future.
Big Data Blockchain and global data marketplaces like
the one being offered by Image Chain offer an oppor-
tunity to significantly broaden medical knowledge and Key Points
reduce operational costs. By connecting images and
videos to complementary patient and population-level • Blockchain holds the potential to
transform how the healthcare industry
data sets, providers and researchers are able to use
delivers care, and how individuals access
machine intelligence and AI tools to reveal correlations care, on a global scale
and trends – leading to improved diagnostic accuracy
• Traditional Blockchain models offer
and more personalised, effective treatments. In the incremental benefit, but the future of
future, Big Data Blockchains will enable companies Blockchain in healthcare is being delivered
to offer low-cost radiology and pathology services through Big Data Blockchains
with near real-time turnaround speeds. These inter- • Early adopters are proving the value of
pretation services rely on Blockchain’s consensus and Blockchain and gaining market traction
46 HealthManagement.org
unblock the chain
Why healthcare needs Blockchain Benefits of
$250 86%
billion is spent to process of mistakes in healthcare
400,000
people die per year because
Blockchain
Better management of healthcare data
30 billion healthcare are administrative. of these mistakes.
transactions per year. Patient-centric health records
Faster transaction processes
Lower administrative costs
80% 3
of medical errors
of every10 30% 20%
tests are reordered of visits don’t have of malpractice
More effective healthcare analytics
More efficient supply chain
involve because the information patient charts. claims involve Improved protection of patient identity
miscommunication. cannot be found. missed or delayed
Greater security and trust of data integrity
diagnosis
Source: https://iii.hm/qnd Reduced medical errors
Improved care quality
Application in healthcare More empowered patients
Smart contracts
Source: https://iii.hm/qly
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
An excellent way Doctor Patient A smart Patient performs If the patient
to ensure patient recommends agrees to doctor contract is actions which fulfills the smart
compliance treatment recommendation created and placed are tracked by contract they are
solution in the patient’s wearables rewarded; if not
wallet they are penalised.
Source: https://iii.hm/qm0
Medical records Implementation challenges
Blockchain is still an immature
1 2 3 4 technology in healthcare
Security still remains a concern in terms of
Doctor creates a Patient gets The ID gets Doctor creates patient data
patient record. a unique ID called a list of an order which
a hash. approved users. goes on patient Switching to advanced technology that
record. Blockchain would need means higher
costs for healthcare organisations.
5 6 7 8 Lack of common standards and
regulations for Blockchain applications
poses a challenge for a highly-regulated
Patient shares Through Remote doctor Chain is updated sector like healthcare
his records with Blockchain, the gives diagnosis so everyone
another remote remote doctor without any knows who did Need for increased coordination for
physician. receives data face-to-face what and when. proper implementation of Blockchain
through a secure interaction. applications.
URL.
Source: https://iii.hm/qm1 Source: https://iii.hm/qm2
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 Promoting Management and Leadership
WINNING PRACTICES
How can automation improve
outpatient care while
reducing costs?
The new role of hospitals and the triple aim challenge
Rather than being an unaffordable luxury, automation can quickly deliver an impressive
return on investment.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Francesca
MacVean
Healthcare expert
PA Consulting
London, UK
Francesca.MacVean@
PAConsulting.com
Gareth Fitzgerald
Healthcare expert
PA Consulting
London, UK
Gareth.Fitzgerald@
PAConsulting.com
T
@PA_Consulting he list of advanced technology and auto- genome sequencing. Automation improves quality,
mation in healt hcare is growing, f rom decreases costs and reduces human error. It’s an
using A ma zon Echoes to provide adult especially valuable tool as healthcare systems focus
social care (paconsulting.com/our-experi- more attention on patient outcomes—a practice
ence/argenti-using-technology-to-drive- referred to as value-based care. Yet the opportuni-
social-care-transformation/), to automating ties of automation aren’t well understood, slowing
48 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
the pace of adoption. MD, which is taking the idea further by using AI and
Healthcare often sees automation as a luxury— machine learning to provide personalised health
very few healthcare organisations are exploiting information. It uses algorithms trained on validated
the benefits that automation has to offer. In fact, medical literature, allowing the chatbot to learn
only a few of the UK’s 152 acute National Health common symptoms and provide care recommen-
Service (NHS) Trusts have started to use new forms dations to the patient.
of automation such as robotic process automation.
But as it has the potential to reduce staffing costs Managing capacity more effectively
and improve quality and efficiency, more organ- By looking at historical data around peak times for
isations should see it as a valuable opportunity appointments, the use of advanced analytics, where
during this time of financial challenges. Robotic the system is automated to examine large data sets
solutions for finance and human resources func- to generate recommendations, can tell when and
tions, for example, can be launched quickly and where healthcare organisations are likely to need
rapidly generate a good return on investment and more capacity. Organisations can then tweak the
improve insight into process performance. capacity to ensure the most people are helped in
While these technologies have clear application the most cost-efficient way. PA Consulting applied
in the back office, some of the biggest benefits of this in recent work at Hillingdon Hospitals NHS
automation may be for front office processes such Foundation Trust (paconsulting.com/our-expe-
as outpatient appointment management. rience/saving-10-million-by-managing-time-
and-resources-with-care/) New software was
used to improve systems for scheduling surgery
created capacity
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
and booking outpatient clinics by giving a clearer
for 80 additional view of the time and capacity available. This created
hours of operations capacity for 80 additional hours of operations and
and 430 outpatient 430 outpatient appointments a month.
appointments a month
Bring automation to healthcare
Looking at outpatient processes through the lens
Improving the booking process of automation highlights immediate opportunities
Automation is perfect for improving the booking in the front and back office. Rather than being an
process, which in many Trusts is a cumbersome, unaffordable luxury, automation can quickly deliver
manual process. For example, a software robot an impressive return on investment.
could gather empty slots and clearly present them
to schedulers for rebooking. Or it could automati-
cally move patients from a cancelled clinic to the
next suitable available one based on defined rules.
We’re developing such a smart booking system with
an NHS Trust with the aim of improving appoint- Key Points
ment attendance.
• Automation can improve outpatient
Speeding up customer service care while reducing costs. It is an
especially valuable tool as healthcare
Chatbots are more advanced than ever and are
systems focus more attention on
being used by a variety of businesses around the patient outcomes
world. So why not replicate this in healthcare? A
patient with a query about their outpatient appoint- • Looking at outpatient processes
ment could initially speak to a chatbot that handles through the lens of automation
highlights immediate opportunities in
all basic questions by following rules. When there the front and back office
are more complex problems, or instances where
the patient wants to speak to a person, the chatbot • Rather than being an unaffordable
transfers them to the human team. We have seen luxury, automation can quickly deliver
the effective use of chatbots in apps such as Your. an impressive return on investment
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 49
WINNING PRACTICES Reprinted with permission from ECRI Institute
Patient responsibility for
following up on test results
ECRI
ECRI Institute
Welwyn Garden City, UK
[email protected]
@ECRI_Institute
ecri.org.uk
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
A
risk manager recently asked for guidance on bottom of this email for more information on general
the patient's responsibility in following up on practices for test result reporting and tracking.
the results of tests that have been ordered. Policies and procedures may outline the means
In our response, we note that providers are of contacting patients and the number of attempts
responsible for reviewing and following up on the that are required; if that is in place, it is very impor-
results of the tests they order. That responsibility tant that providers follow those steps. But even if the
typically includes ensuring that results that require provider follows the policies and procedures, other
involvement of patients or action on their part are factors specific to the situation may come into play
communicated to patients. However, ECRI Institute (eg multiple modes of contact that are outdated).
recommends reporting all test results to patients, The provider should make all possible attempts to
including results that are normal or not clinically contact a patient with a critical or abnormal result,
significant. which may include enlisting the help of local author-
Clinicians' responsibility for following up on test ities or contacting homeless shelters. Attempts and
results should be clearly outlined in organisational results of those attempts (eg voice mail greeting
policies and procedures, and backups should be indicating that the organisation had reached the
designated. Organisations also typically have proto- correct person, mail returned) should be docu-
cols for how and when different kinds of tests or mented. Providers can also ask patients to verify
different kinds of results (eg normal, abnormal, crit- or update their contact information on every visit.
ical) need to be communicated to the responsible When patient action is recommended, it's a good
clinician and to the patient. See the resources at the idea to “close the loop" and seek (and document)
50 HealthManagement.org copyright ECRI Institute
Reprinted with permission from ECRI Institute WINNING PRACTICES
confirmation from the patient that the result and
recommendation were received. Some organisa-
tions ask whether the patient has taken necessary
follow-up steps, and some offer help in scheduling
appointments with other providers when necessary.
If a patient was informed of his or her test results
and recommended actions but failed to take those ECRI Institute, a nonprofit organisation, dedicates
actions, contributory or comparative negligence itself to bringing the discipline of applied scientific
may be a possible defence (legal counsel can deter- research in healthcare to uncover the best
mine which defence strategies are optimal in each approaches to improving patient care. As pioneers
specific case). Patients may argue that they were in this science for 50 years, ECRI Institute marries
not informed of the results and recommendations— experience and independence with the objectivity
because of factors such as those discussed above,
of evidence-based research.
for example. The defence may have a particularly
ECRI’s focus is medical device technology, health-
large burden to overcome if the provider's actions or
inactions, which will be scrutinised, failed to conform care risk and quality management, and health tech-
with organisational policies and procedures. But nology assessment. It provides information services
again, the inquiry doesn't necessarily end with poli- and technical assistance to more than 5,000 hospi-
cies and procedures. A related question is whether tals, healthcare organisations, ministries of health,
the provider made it clear what the patient had to government and planning agencies, voluntary sector
do and why the patient had to do it. Health literacy organisations and accrediting agencies worldwide.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
strategies can help providers communicate with all Its databases (over 30), publications, information
patients about the purpose and significance of tests,
services and technical assistance services set the
test results, recommended follow-up, and actions
standard for the healthcare community.
patients should take.
All of these principles bear on the use of patient More than 5,000 healthcare organisations world-
portals to communicate test results. Because clini- wide rely on ECRI Institute’s expertise in patient
cians are responsible for following up on test results, safety improvement, risk and quality manage-
providers should actively reach out to patients to ment, healthcare processes, devices, procedures
communicate test results, rather than simply inform and drug technology. ECRI Institute is one of only
them that test results will be available through the a handful of organisations to have been desig-
patient portal once they're processed. Provider
nated as both a Collaborating Centre of the World
involvement is also necessary to place the result into
Health Organization and an evidence-based prac-
context. For example, even if patients have access
to their results, they might not know how to interpret tice centre by the US Agency for healthcare research
them or what they should do in response. and quality in Europe. For more information, visit
What about using an automated process to notify ecri.org.uk
patients that results are now available in the patient
portal—for example, having the system automati-
cally email the patient when a test result becomes
available? Although automated processes might communicated, is received. Ultimately, if a patient
conceivably supplement other forms of commu- fails to take prudent actions in response to a test
nication with patients regarding test results, they result, suffers injury because of it, and sues, it might
might not be sufficient means of notifying patients be hard to successfully defend the case if the patient
of test results in and of themselves. What if the portal was the only means used to communicate the
patient is not computer savvy or has no or limited test results to a patient.
access to a computer? What if the patient's email Note: The recommendations contained in Ask
address is outdated or the email is caught in a spam ECRI do not constitute legal advice. Facilities
filter? The brave new world of electronic communi- should consult legal counsel for specific guidance
cation underscores the importance of closing the and develop clinical guidance in consultation with
loop and confirming that the message, however it is their clinical staff.
copyright ECRI Institute Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 51
POINT OF VIEW
Better outcomes through
clinical decision support
How can a clinical decision support system help to achieve measurably better
healthcare outcomes?
“T
he Collaboratory” reflects the trans- and 4) improve the quality of reports provided to
formation through collaboration that clinicians. According to Dr. Peter Thorausch, co-
Abbott wants to ignite by working in founder and CEO “A huge part of our time is spent
partnership with clients. Abbott supports health- processing and analyzing data and writing reports.
care organizations to overcome their challenges Being able to automate much of this work – and
and materialize their future state vision, by break- providing guidance to the requesting clinician –
ing down the silos and barriers that exist today in will lead to smarter, leaner and quicker diagnos-
healthcare. The results of a global study show the tics and ultimately adding real value to the ser-
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
contribution expected from labs to facilitate this vices we provide.”
Dr. Peter Thorausch transformation as shown in the data points below.
Co-founder & CEO of MVZ By leveraging their data and teaming up with
Cottbus, Cottbus, Germany
other services and stakeholders, labs can shift Being able to automate
from being a manufacturing facility to a deci- much of this work will lead
sion support engine, helping the decision making to smarter, leaner and quicker
across the system and achieve measurably better diagnostics adding
healthcare performance.
real value
With advancements in medical research and
technolog y break t hroughs happening daily,
doctors and clinicians must remain on top of After 3 months, the MVZ Cottbus phase 1 of
latest medical guidelines, patient historical and the project demonstrated that AlinIQ CDS was
holistic information to reduce unwarranted var- able to provide recommendations to improve test
iations, improve patient outcomes and reduce ordering and identify secondary diagnosis and
costs. comorbidities. The implementation of CDS live
The Limbach Group is a leading private provider has the potential to improve patient outcomes,
of laboratory services in Germany, with more than materialize operational efficiencies and achieve
6,000 staff and 32 laboratories. MVZ Cottbus, cost savings. Additionally, with just the 70 rules
the group’s laboratory, serves four hospitals and created by MVZ Cottbus and Abbott in this phase,
a rehabilitation center, and provides diagnostic AlinIQ CDS not only recommended testing and
services for a population of more than 1 million provided results interpretations for the four ICD/
people. Burdened by the extensive employee- DRG targeted conditions, but also for other con-
hours needed to process and analyze laboratory ditions that originally were outside the scope of
data, MVZ Cottbus, in partnership with Abbott, the project. These results show the benefits that
recently completed phase 1 of a project to estab- AlinIQ CDS can deliver for healthcare organiza-
lish how the use of Abbott’s AlinIQ Clinical Deci- tions. Beyond that, AlinIQ CDS flagged potential
sion Support (CDS) solution could: 1) standardize co-morbidities for further investigation, which
the application of clinical guidelines and evidence- could have a significant impact in terms of opti-
based medicine, 2) improve clinician test-ordering mizing patient treatments and improving reim-
practices, 3) save laboratory time and resources, bursement coding for the organization.
52 HealthManagement.org
POINT OF VIEW
For phase 1 there were 2 main objectives chosen:
1 By targeting 4 main conditions (COPD, AMI,
Pneumonia, AF) see if AlinIQ CDS could
improve test ordering based on patient’s
2 By targeting 5 diagnostic procedures for
renal, thyroid, diabetes, anemia, and lipid
diseases – demonstrate that AlinIQ CDS
initial diagnoses. For example, for a patient could identify secondary diagnosis and
with a diagnosis of COPD, Cottbus wanted comorbidities as well as Interpreting results
to identify cases where diagnostic tests and providing relevant recommendations.
related to COPD were not ordered.
12,395 randomly selected cases were analyzed by AlinIQ using the 70 rules and the
following results could be identified:
1 As per the 1st objective 338 cases were
identifi ed corresponding to the 4 main
conditions. 100% of the cases received
2 As per the 2nd objective 4,616 recom-
mendations were provided linked to the 5
diseases (renal, thyroid, diabetes, anemia,
interpretation reports including proper and lipid diseases).
ICD/DRG coding and testing ordering
recommendations.
Terminology:
Rule = Structure responsible for implementing and automating algorithm steps; ICD= International Statistical Classification
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
of Diseases and Related Health Problems list by the World Health Organization; DRG= Diagnosis Related Group is a system
to classify hospital cases into groups;
Disease = The term “disease” broadly refers to any condition that impairs the normal functioning of the body
93%
Following the success of phase 1, AlinIQ CDS
has now been integrated with the laboratory’s
database and live data streams at MVZ Cottbus
to enable real-time analysis and reporting. Prior
to commencing this phase, Abbott trained the
of hospital executives
staff to ensure a smooth transition and the
team worked to review the results of the phase
believe the laboratory can
1 and adjust the CDS rules before the system impact healthcare IT and
went live with reports and comments for the analytics
physicians. Additional work is ongoing to eval-
77%
uate the strategic, operational and financial
impact of AlinIQ CDS in a live setting, compar-
ing performance metrics against the baseline
benchmark. In the future, MVZ Cottbus will be
able to expand the reach of AlinIQ CDS to other
clinical use cases, disease states and laboratory
of doctors would
locations. Additional data streams will be inte- value the lab providing
grated to enrich the clinical information available additional interpretation
and enhance the generation of patient-specific to support diagnosis
recommendations.
For further information please talk to our experts at the Abbott booth during Arab Health or
MEDLAB 2019, get in touch with a local Abbott representative, or send an email to wired@
abbott.com.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 53
Applications will be accepted until
February 4th, 2018
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Why you should apply
• Boost your initiative through exposure to >350,000 healthcare professionals
worldwide;
• Receive feedback from an internationally renowned jury of VBHC experts;
• Be recognized as a leading initiative in patient- centered care and inspire others;
• Network with VBHC pioneers;
• Push your initiative to the next level;
• The winner of the VBHC Prize 2019 will also be awarded a VIP presentation slot on
the main stage at the ICHOM 2019 Conference in Rotterdam.
6th VBHC Prize Event with Prof. E. Teisberg, PhD
April 18, 2019 | The Netherlands
For more information or to apply for the VBHC Prize 2019 visit: www.vbhcprize.com
www.vbhcprize.com @VBHCEurope Value-Based Health Care Center Europe
WINNING PRACTICES
Encouraging health app use
with seniors
Prevention, patient autonomy and use of digital goods
A digital health coaching platform offers sustainable support of the elderly population to
improve their mental, emotional and physical fitness.
T
he German healthcare system is still one of the for their health; they should contribute to preventing
best in the world. Nevertheless, for many years the onset of illness and disability and to overcoming
the contribution of healthcare to society has their consequences through a health-conscious life-
still largely been interpreted through the framework of style, early participation in preventive health meas-
cost reductions. Increasingly, however, the willingness ures and active participation in medical treatment
of the involved actors to improve healthcare in the and rehabilitation”.
sense of a holistic, patient-oriented understanding
is growing. This is now being addressed in more and
Consumers are more open
more social debates under the heading of “value-
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
based healthcare” (Porter 2010). Here, the quality of
to technological innovations Eva Gattnar
service provision is placed in relation to its costs and than institutions, which clearly CEO proVITALcoach
Hamburg, Germany
thus the so-called “value” of a health service for the sets them apart from most
[email protected]
individual is evaluated (Lehr et al. 2016). healthcare players
proVITALcoach.com
Recently, support has also increasingly been given
to measures in the field of prevention that make a Value-based healthcare requires the coopera-
value-oriented contribution to promoting self-help tion and joint responsibility of all institutional and
and patient autonomy (Landry 2015, Boulos 2011). private actors involved in care. The human being, ie
This is reflected in the adoption of the German the consumer of the health service, is placed at the
Prevention Act, which came into force in its essential centre of attention. Thereby, more and more people
parts on 25 July 2015, thereby increasing support for want to actively commit themselves to their health.
health self-help (Albrecht 2016). The German Social This can also be clearly felt in the healthcare market,
Code Book V (§1) also states that health is the duty as more and more essential impulses in the design of
of every individual: “The insured are jointly responsible new health products emerge from the consumer side.
Figure 1: Usage of mobile technology in healthcare is growing and is becoming more pervasive. Source: Deloitte, Connected health, 2018
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 55
WINNING PRACTICES
Consumers are more open to technological innova- health services has so far been observed predomi-
tions than institutions, which clearly sets them apart nantly in the second health market. Thereby, digital
from most healthcare players. This openness also health applications (so-called “mHealth”) range from
corresponds to a “cultural change towards a more simple solutions to complex medical applications
sovereign and active shaping of one's own health (Figure 2).
actions” (Knöppler et al. 2016). In view of the fact that the lifespan in Germany
C o nsu m e r s in t h e h ealt h c are m ar ket are has increased by well over ten percent in the rela-
demanding digital goods, including those in the tively short period of 40 years, due in part to medical
field of prevention (Figure 1). They are assigned to progress and significantly better working, living and
the so-called “second health market”. According to housing conditions, the market is set for steady
general understanding, the second health market growth in health apps. The proportion of people over
comprises, in particular, over-the-counter medicines 65 in the total population will rise from 21% today in
and individual health services, fitness and wellness, 2030 to over 29%. According to the Federal Statis-
health tourism as well as, to some extent, sports, tical Office, the number of people in Germany who
leisure, nutrition and housing. In addition, digital are 65 years and older already amounts to almost
goods are also becoming increasingly important as 17 million. Nowhere else in Europe is this share as
a preventive instrument in the first health market. high as in Germany, at 20.6%.
The first health market comprises the area of “clas-
sical” health care, which is largely characterised by Digital applications address the chal-
statutory health insurance and private health insur- lenges of best agers
ance, including long-term care insurance, and to a The market development outlined above represents a
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
lesser extent by employers (ie continued payment of great opportunity for innovative digital solutions such
wages in the event of illness), the state (ie contri- as online platforms and health apps. Young people
butions to health insurance) and other social insur- in particular are demanding digital goods in the form
ance institutions. of health apps, as these promise immediate positive
Overall, there are increasing efforts on the part of effects on the improvement of their health. Increas-
the players to assume the remuneration for digital ingly, health apps are also experiencing increasing
goods for the insured (Albrecht 2016). Nevertheless, demand among senior citizens, as older people are
the sluggishness of institutional providers means that becoming more technology-savvy and, for their part,
digital goods still play a subordinate role in the first interest in technology-supported health services is
health market compared to the second health market, steadily increasing.
which is why the dynamic development of digital The elderly become ill more frequently and for
Single use mHealth Social mHealth Integrated mHealth Complex mHealth
Focuses on a single Draws upon the support Links apps and devices Leverages advanced,
purpose for a single and encouragement with the formal integrated analytocs
user, typically cosumer provided through social healthcare system: for decision support:
initiated: networks: • mobile technology linking • predictive analytics
• smartphone apps and • gamification and compe- patients and HCPs applied to complex
wearable tech products tition based apps which • tailored tp multiple end data generated through
that support the user to encourage users to meet users: consumers, physi- mHealth applications
record data which may be goals cians and administrators. • focus on achieving
communicated to others • consumer likely to pursue optimal management of
• consumer driven, focus on activities independently. a specific disease.
wellness, diet and exercise.
Figure 2: Categorisation of digital health applications. Source: Four Dimensions of Effective mHealth, Deloitte US Center for Health Solutions, 2014
56 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
Best Ager Relatives
• Entering tasks and reminders • Mobilization of the elderly
• Adaptation of the configuration of • Defining and regulation of
the fitness programs activities
• Following recommendations, • Activation of internal and external
activities and fitness programs resources
• Measuring own progress • Verifiacation of the user's
comfort compliance
• Exchange of reports with relatives
and caregivers Coaching reminders • Receiving possible emergency calls
• Sending of possible emergency calls. • Adaptation of the configuration of
Usage
the fitness programs
usability
Caregivers
Coach
• Mobilization of the elderly
• Mobilization of resources activites • Defining and regulation of
• Stress management and relaxation activities
support
• Exercise and sports • Activation of internal resources
• Establishment of other activities Fitness • Monitoring and tracking of
• Management of social contacts Safety progress
• Building and expanding stable emergency programms • Receiving possible emergency calls
relationships • Adaptation of the configuration of
• Regulation of emotions the fitness programs
Quality of Care
Patient's Commitment Value in Healthcare
Quality of Care
Figure 3: proVITALcoach platform: concept, stakeholders and outcomes for patients and the healthcare system. Source: proVITALcoach
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
longer periods of time and often suffer from several • Building, maintaining and improving mental
illnesses simultaneously. The psychological stress and emotional fitness
associated with this can promote the occurrence of The functional scope of proVITALcoach is aimed
depression. These include particular burdens such to be expanded by psychological components using
as fears of loss related to one's own identity, one's current neuroscientific findings applied in the form of
own professional role as a result of relinquishing a guided self-tests, checklists and tasks derived from
professional career, changes in family circumstances them. Furthermore, for the extended version of proVI-
(eg when children leave home), independence and TALcoach a superior coaching concept including a
one's own life (ie the inevitability of one's own death). coaching guide will be developed. The objective here
Cognitive abilities also change over the years. is to help people already in earlier age groups to
actively shape ageing and to achieve a fulfilled life
proVITALcoach: Digital coaching platform through a positive assessment and attitude towards
for the elderly population ageing and the associated changes in their lives.
People in old age are subject to strong changes, In addition, proVITALcoach addresses digital
which require a high degree of change management. information exchange between the user of the
This and the associated physical and psychological application and an optional authorised person who
challenges require completely new coping compe- looks after the user. The software including various
tences, which are adequately addressed by proVI- coaching mechanisms will remind the user and help
TALcoach through a holistic concept for the main- him to perform certain activities (eg taking medica-
tenance and improvement of mental, emotional and tion, fitness exercises), thus supporting elderly people
physical fitness. proVITALcoach sets itself the goal in their everyday life.
of enabling older people, their relatives and nursing
staff to take effective measures and make neces- Positioning and target groups
sary adjustments for the maintenance of the health According to a Bertelsmann study published in 2016
of senior citizens. The extension of the so-called (Knöppler et al. 2016), proVITALcoach is assigned
“health span”, ie the life span in good physical and to the group of health services to promote indi-
mental health, is particularly important. proVITAL- rect intervention and thus strengthen self-efficacy,
coach strives for this through the following measures: adherence and security. proVITALcoach is realised
• Building, maintaining and improving physical by means of an online platform in connection with a
fitness and reducing over- and under-exertion health app. In addition to the intelligent technology,
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 57
WINNING PRACTICES
proVITALcoach includes professional coaching As part of the coaching concept, proVITALcoach
(Figure 3). will also develop a coaching guideline that will guide
proVITALcoach addresses the following primary qualified coaches beyond the application of the
target groups: health app to support the elderly in the challenges
• The elderly who take the initiative to contribute and opportunities of old age. The health app func-
to their own health and fitness. tions as a core technological element and will be
• Caregivers and family members who look after sold individually as a digital good via an app store,
or care for elderly. as well as embedded in personal and/or media-
• Institutions (associations, nursing homes, retire- supported coaching. proVITALcoach thus contrib-
ment homes, other inpatient facilities, etc.). utes to increasing “value” by improving self-preven-
The secondary target groups of proVITALcoach are: tive measures for seniors, contributing to cost reduc-
• People with disabilities and chronic illnesses. tions in the health care system. Caregivers can
• All fitness enthusiasts who value comfortable support their caregivers and family members their
operation, coaching and safety. elderly relatives by creating appropriate compliance
tracking programmes.
The primary focus on elderly users and caregivers
Dedicated “best agers" allows them to truly focus on elderly unique needs of
stay healthier and actively this generation and their families. Dedicated “best
agers” stay healthier and actively contribute to a
contribute to a higher "value"
higher “value" in healthcare. Elderly people who are
in healthcare not used to mobile technologies are encouraged by
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
their children to get in touch and benefit from the
solutions offered and their user-friendly applica-
Results and discussion tions.
proVITALcoach, a multifunctional personalised
mobile health app positioned in the second health-
care market, combines features and programs devel-
oped by personal, fitness and health coaches to
support best agers and their potential caregivers. Key Points
The psychologically relevant content will be imple-
mented in the form of guided self-tests and check- • Healthcare consumers are increasingly
lists and will be developed together with psycholo- demanding apps to monitor their care and
gists applying recent neuroscientific findings. Self- bolster engagement
tests and checklists serve to assess the psycho- • Apps are more prominent in the second
logical health status of the user and to automati- health market than in the first health
cally develop a coaching concept using intelligent market
and tested rules. This serves as a basis for develop- • proVitalcoach helps the elderly adapt to
ment of personalised tasks, memories and fitness physical and psychological changes as they
age
programs and thus extends the health app in the
sense of a holistic, value-oriented approach for the • More health savvy consumers assist the
healthcare system in the long term
elderly population.
References
Albrecht, UV (2016) Kapitel Rationale. example from eCAALYX, BioMedical Stiftung. GmbH, ISSN 1614-029X 13. Jahrgang
In: Albrecht, UV (Hrsg.), Chancen Engineering OnLine 10(1), 24. 2016.
und Risiken von Gesundheits- Landry, KE (2015) Using eHealth to
Apps (CHARISMHA). Medizinische Knöppler, K. Neisecke, T. improve health literacy among the Porter, ME (2010) “What is Value in
Hochschule Hannover. Nölke, L (2016) Digital-Health- patient population, Creat Nurs 21(1), Health Care?” The New England
Anwendungen für Bürger, 53-57. Journal of Medicine. 363:2477-2481.
Boulos, MN; Wheeler, S. Tavares, C. & Kontext, Typologie und Relevanz December 2010.
Jones, R (2011) How smartphones are aus Public-Health-Perspektive Lehr, A. et al (2016). Value based
changing the face of mobile and par- Entwicklung und Erprobung eines Healthcare, Das Onlinemagazin
ticipatory healthcare: an overview, with Klassifikationsverfahrens. Bertelsmann zur Gesundheitspolitik, LetV-Verlag
58 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
A patient’s journey is likely
to include surfing the web:
how can we help? Christina
Athanasopoulou
Researcher
Internet and people with mental disorders Department of Nursing Science
Faculty of Medicine
University of Turku
A “whole patient” can be a person with schizophrenia, who is also an internet user and Turku, Finland
searches for mental health information online. Product Manager, Researcher
NeilTheLittleExplorer
Another Circus
Athens, Greece
B
etween 2000–2018 the internet has grown mental health patients. We face a period of economic
[email protected]
by 1,052%, with about 4.2 billion people crisis, and since schizophrenia is a costly disease,
@tina_turku
surfing the Web (Internet World Stats 2018). affecting people of working age, there is an urgent
In Europe, about 81% of citizens use the internet at need for governments to effectively meet their citi-
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
least once per week (Eurostat 2018). The number zens’ health needs, while at the same time to mini-
of internet users who search for health and mental mise direct and indirect health-related costs (Tajima-
health information online has been growing. About Pozo et al. 2015). The ‘whole patient’ approach
89% of Americans (Pew Research Center 2018) and focuses on understanding the patient holistically—as
approximately 51% of European internet users (Euro- a patient, as an internet user who searches for health
stat 2017) search for health information online. It is information in order to feel empowered, as a friend
apparent that the internet has influenced how we who wants to connect online, etc. By understanding
search and gather health information and how we patients’ needs, skills and attitudes, for example,
generally conduct our day-to-day lives. towards the internet, healthcare professionals can Christos Lionis
People with mental or substance use disorder use this knowledge to support their patients better Professor
Clinic of Social and Family
comprise between 13 to 22% of the global popula- and more affordably, as internet connection has Medicine (CSFM)
tion (Ritchie and Roser 2018), which is approximately minimal cost. One of the main components of the Department of Social Medicine
Faculty of Medicine
1.1 billion people. Among this population, 21 million ‘whole patient’ approach is the exploration of the University of Crete
Heraklion, Greece
are diagnosed with schizophrenia. As a consequence patient’s information and communication prefer-
of the global trends, people with mental disorders, ences. For example, how someone is seeking for
[email protected]
including those with schizophrenia, use the internet information or how someone prefers to exchange
similarly to the general population (Schrank et al. online information with a peer or health professional.
2010; Kalckreuth et al. 2014; Miller et al. 2015; Atha-
nasopoulou et al. 2017). About 80% of people with Lessons learned from people with schizo-
psychiatric conditions are internet users (Kalckreuth phrenia spectrum disorders
et al. 2014). They use the internet for health infor- In a study performed in two distant European coun-
mation seeking, email exchange, social media, web tries (Greece and Finland) (Athanasopoulou et al.
2.0 use (Miller et al. 2015; Athanasopoulou et al. 2017), we aimed to explore internet use patterns,
2017), and to communicate with peers and health attitudes and eHealth literacy among adults with
professionals (Miller et al. 2014; Schrank et al. 2010). schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SSD). We found
However, does this population easily find and under- that: Maritta Välimäki
stand the health information retrieved online? 1. About one third were never internet users, a few Professor
Department of Nursing Science
Studies focusing on mental health and internet were previous internet users, and more than half Faculty of Medicine
University of Turku
use are important, since there is a literature gap were current internet users. More than half of the Turku, Finland
in exploring internet use by various populations of internet users in each country group used the
[email protected]
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 59
WINNING PRACTICES
internet for health-related purposes, such as to source of health information in both groups), then
search for health-related information, commu- pharmacists and the internet. First, mental health
nicate with health professionals about health- professionals should realise their important role in
related issues, and communicate with other users educating their patients about their diagnosis and
about health-related issues providing them with reliable health information.
2. Previous and current internet users had moderate Second, health professionals (and pharmacists) could
scores in ehealth literacy. This could mean that it be trained and then show their patients how to judge
is very likely they could not find, access and eval- which online (mental) health information is reliable, in
uate online health information accurately order to assess the reliability and trustworthiness of
3. The majority of internet users accessed the the information they find online. Luckily, the signifi-
internet from home, had an email address, used cance of health literacy is growing as it has received
it at least once per day, and used it for web 2.0 prompt attention by the World Health Organization
activities (ie watching videos, social networking Region of Europe (M-POHL Network 2018). In addi-
and/or dating websites) tion, strengthening integrated care and multidisci-
4. More than half of internet users accessed plinary work, especially in primary and community
the internet for health-related purposes (ie to health care (primary health care professionals and
research health-related information, commu- pharmacists) is very important, especially for coun-
nicate with health professionals about health- tries with fewer resources and weak primary care
related issues, communicate with other users systems, including Greece (Tsiachristas et al. 2015).
about health-related issues) Third, (mental) health organisations could organise
5. More than half searched for online health informa- continuing education ehealth programmes, since
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
tion; most consider it always or most of the times people with SSD need education and training in order
easy to locate the website they wanted and the to acquire the essential skills to find, read, and under-
most prevalent problem that complicated their stand online (mental) health information. Last, online
internet use was their difficulty concentrating for campaigns to raise awareness about the importance
long periods of sharing accurate mental health information could
6. For the Finnish group, top health information be useful.
sources were face-to-face contact with medical
professionals and the internet. On the other hand, Key Points
for the Greek participants face-to-face contact
with medical professionals and pharmacies were • The internet has changed the way we
perceived to be the most important sources of search for (mental) health information
health information. • People with mental disorders search for
(mental) health information online
Conclusion and future initiatives • ehealth literacy is the important skill to
In order to support the “whole patient”, who happens search, find and understand the health
to be an internet user, various sectors and stake- information you can find online
holders need to cooperate, eg organisations, ICT • High levels of eHealth literacy can
experts, administrators, educators, even the average support patients to find and understand
the online health information they access
internet user. However, the most important role is that
of the healthcare professional who comes in contact • Health professionals can support patients
in finding reliable health information
with the patient (found to be the most important
online
REFERENCES
Athanasopoulou C et al. (2017). internet for seeking health-related infor- Internet World Stats (2018) World inter- Miller BJ et al. (2015) How connected
Internet use, ehealth literacy and atti- mation. Available from ec.europa.eu/ net usage and population statistics. are people with schizophrenia? Cell
tudes toward computer/internet among eurostat/web/products-datasets/-/ Available from internetworldstats.com/ phone, computer, email, and social
people with schizophrenia spectrum tin00101 stats.htm media use. Psychiatry Res 225: 458–63.
disorders: a cross-sectional study in
two distant European regions. BMC Eurostat (2018) Internet use and activ- Kalckreuth S et al. (2014) Mental health For full references, please email
Med Inform Decis Mak 17:136. ities. Available from ec.europa.eu/ related internet use among psychiat-
[email protected] or
eurostat/web/products-datasets/-/ ric patients: a cross-sectional analysis. visit https://iii.hm/r15
Eurostat (2017) Individuals using the isoc_bde15cua BMC Psychiatry 14: 368.
60 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
Venue
Point of Care ultrasound
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Simple. Fast. Precise.
Venue™ is a powerful ultrasound system which helps simplify your
patients’ care.
Empowering you with:
• Simple user interface
• Fast advanced automation tools
• Precise visualization
Venue tools and automation help you focus on what’s most important – your patient.
For more information or to arrange a demonstration,
please contact your GE sales representative or visit
gehealthcare.com/venue
gehealthcare.com © 2018 General Electric Company.
GE, the GE Monogram and Venue are trademarks of General Electric Company.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 61
WINNING PRACTICES
Patient safety culture
Radiographers’ perceptions
Research to evaluate radiographers’ perceptions about patient safety culture in Portuguese
public and private imaging facilities found that overall perception is positive but the safety
Luís Ribeiro
culture dimensions rating should guide culture development of safety culture improvement
Professor of Medical Imaging action plans.
P
and Radiotherapy Department
Health School atient safety is defined as the avoidance of unin- maintaining, monitoring or restoring patients' health,
University of Algarve, Portugal
Researcher in CIDAF – tended or unexpected harm to people during the the healthcare process is subject to the occurrence of
University of Coimbra
provision of healthcare. It is a process whereby incidents and adverse events that should be recorded
[email protected] an organisation makes care delivery safer to prevent and reported (Portuguese Health Portal 2011).
healthcare users from being harmed by the effects of In Portugal in 2012 the General Directorate of Health
their services, thereby reducing the risk of unneces- (GDS) made available to all healthcare professionals
sary harm to the minimum acceptable (National Health and citizens the National Incident and Adverse Event
Service 2004). While imaging facilities have become Notification System (NIAENS). NIAENS is an anony-
more effective they have also become more complex, mous, confidential and non-punitive management
with greater use of new technologies. Thus, patients platform for incidents and adverse events occurring
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
should be treated in a safe environment and protected at healthcare facilities. The notifications are analysed
from avoidable harm. to identify patterns and trends on patient safety and
The National Patient Safety Agency’s Seven steps to develop solutions to avoid such incidents, based on
Anabela Ribeiro to patient safety, the full reference guide identifies the Standard No 008/2013 of 05/15/2013 (GDS 2013).
Professor steps it considers essential to ensure patient safety:
Medical Imaging and
Radiotherapy Department
safety culture, lead and support professionals, manage In general, radiographers
Health School risk in an integrated way, promote reporting, engage
University of Algarve, Portugal have a positive perception
and communicate with patients and the public, learn
Radiographer and Head of
and share safety lessons and implement solutions
about patient safety of their
Radiology Department
Centro Hospitalar for harm prevention (National Patient Safety Agency departments
Universitário do Algarve
Faro, Portugal 2004).
Patient safety is a core dimension of the quality of It should also be considered that the imaging
Kevin Azevedo care provided. Unfortunately, in Portuguese healthcare department is an area that favours the appearance
Professor
Medical Imaging and institutions, there is still a lack of adequate knowledge of errors, especially due to the multiplicity of the tech-
Radiotherapy Department
Health School
regarding all the aspects of the organisational safety niques used, the various professionals involved and
University of Algarve, Portugal culture, which are essential for the implementation of the complexity of the whole circuit involving exami-
Radiographer effective measures to avoid and prevent errors and nations, associated with a rational use of human and
Centro Hospitalar
Universitário do Algarve
incidents that occur from the provision of healthcare economic resources, and the current organisational
Faro, Portugal to patients (Sousa 2013). culture (Brandão et al. 2011; Pereira 2013). In addition,
There is a need to promote a culture of safety in the fear of becoming victims of medical error may lead
António Abrantes
all areas of healthcare services, reflecting a collec- patients to avoid medical care, leading to a worsening
Professor and Director
Medical Imaging and tive consciousness related to values, attitudes, skills of their health status (Pereira 2013).
Radiotherapy Department
Health School - University and behaviours that determine commitment to health Given the above, and considering the constant
of Algarve, Portugal and safety management, and to look at incidents not development of imaging departments and the search
Researcher in CICS.NOVA.UÉvora simply as problems, avoiding blaming those profes- for continuous improvement, the main goal of this
Interdisciplinary Centre of Social
Sciences – Évora Centre sionals who make unintentional mistakes, but seeing study was to evaluate radiographers’ perceptions about
the situation as an opportunity to improve healthcare patient safety culture in nationwide public and private
quality (Costa 2014). imaging facilities and to compare them in order to
Since radiographers in the performance of their identify the positive aspects of safety culture of each
duties are fundamentally involved in promoting, department and make improvement suggestions.
62 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
Oksana Lesyuk
Professor
Medical Imaging and
Radiotherapy Department
Health School
University of Algarve, Portugal
Radiographer
Centro Hospitalar
Universitário do Algarve
Portimão, Portugal
Rui Almeida
Professor
Medical Imaging and
Radiotherapy Department
Health School - University
of Algarve, Portugal
Radiographer
Centro Hospitalar
Universitário do Algarve
Faro, Portugal
Researcher in CICS.NOVA.
Figure 1. How radiographers classified the patient safety culture (%). UÉvora (Interdisciplinary
Centre of Social Sciences
– Évora Centre)
Web-based survey of Portuguese • D9 Teamwork within units PhD student
radiographers • D10 Staffing Faculty of Medicine
University of Murcia, Spain
For this study, a web-based survey composed by a • D11 Hospital handoffs and transitions
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
sociodemographic characterisation was added to the • D12 Nonpunitive response to error Sara Fernandes
translated and validated Portuguese version of the Collaborator
Medical Imaging and
Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture (HSOPSC) The final sample was composed of 144 radiog- Radiotherapy Department
Health School
(ahrq.gov/sops/quality-patient-safety/patient- raphers (27.78% from private imaging departments University of Algarve, Portugal
safetyculture/hospital/index.html) and made avail- and the remaining 72.22% from public facilities). Data
Radiographer
able to all radiographers who wished to participate at was also divided according to the six main regions of Hospital Particular do
Algarve, Portugal
a nationwide level. Portugal: 13.89% from Algarve, 6.94% from Alentejo,
The sociodemographic data included professional 27.78% from Lisbon, 14.58% from Central region, Carlos Alberto
experience (years), the nature of the imaging facility 34,72% from the North region and 2.08% from the da Silva
(public or private), geographical area, weekly working islands. Professor with aggregation in
the Sociology Department
hours and the professional category (band). This study followed the ethical considerations of University of Évora, Portugal
The HSOPSC was composed of 52 questions/items research. Respondents were free to exercise their Researcher in CICS.NOVA.
grouped into twelve dimensions evaluated on a five- right to participate and answer the questionnaire at UÉvora (Interdisciplinary
Centre of Social Sciences
point Likert scale, which evaluates 3 main components their will. Information obtained is solely for research – Évora Centre)
(organisational culture, safety culture and reported purposes and is held with utmost confidentiality.
errors). The original items have been validated by the Anonymity of both the respondents and hospitals/ Sónia Rodrigues
Professor in the Medical
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) for clinics were honoured in the study to protect the data Imaging and Radiotherapy
the USA hospital setting and Factor analysis resulted and names of the subjects. The data gathering was Department, Health School -
University of Algarve, Portugal.
in the following 12 factors (dimensions): done accordingly and to the convenience of the institu- Radiographer in Centro
Hospitalar Universitário do
• D1 Teamwork across units tions without hindering their daily operations. For data Algarve - Faro, Portugal.
• D2 Supervisor/manager expectations and analysis, Statistical Package for the Social Sciences
actions promoting patient safety (SPSS) V.23 was used.
• D3 Organisational learning – continuous
improvement Results: how do radiographers perceive
• D4 Hospital management support for patient patient safety culture?
safety The internal consistency of the questionnaire assessed
• D5 Overall perceptions of safety by the Cronbach’s alpha was excellent (α=0.927). Only
• D6 Feedback and communication about error 9 radiographers classified the patient safety culture as
• D7 Communication openness excellent, whilst 68 radiographers classified the safety
• D8 Frequency of event reporting culture as very good and 55 classified it as acceptable
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 63
WINNING PRACTICES
(Figure 1). The remaining participants classified safety part of their professional culture. From this increase
culture as weak (8) or very weak (4). in awareness, a strengthened safety culture will allow
It should also be noted that an expressive number safer patient care.
of 58 radiographers did not file any error in the last In general, radiographers have a positive percep-
12 months in the risk management system. tion about patient safety of their departments. Despite
To identify the differences between public and this perception, in some dimensions, there are fail-
private imaging facilities, t-student-test was used ures, more evident in the areas of Feedback and
and it was verified that for the private facilities communication about errors and Staffing. The first
some dimensions scored statistically higher than in weak dimension results from the cultural sense of
the public sector, namely in Teamwork across units error as a reason for punishment instead of an opor-
(p=0.03), Hospital management support (p=0.013), tunity for improvement. The second weak dimension
Feedback and communication about error (p=0.008), results from the concern regarding the number of
Teamwork within units (p=0,001) and Hospital hand- hours worked, which was considered to be excessive
offs and transitions (p=0.00). by the participants.
To verify the differences between the geographical It is noteworthy that private healthcare imaging
areas, the Kruskal Wallis test was used and no statis- departments have significantly higher scores in
tically significant differences were found (p>0.05). several dimensions of patient safety, which allow us
A Pearson correlation test was performed to verify to conclude that the investment in patient safety was
the existence of relationships between the degree that higher or at least more evident in this sector.
defines the safety culture of the imaging facilities and Adverse events are not reported frequently, and
the organisational culture, safety culture and reported almost half of participants revealed that they have
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
errors. Regarding the organisational culture, there are not fulfilled any error report. This does not mean that
three significant negative correlations between the the errors did not occur, but it means that they were
dimension referring to Teamwork across units (r = not relevant, which shows that this awareness for
-0.554; p = 0.000), Organisational learning (r = -0.636; safety improvement must be developed or partici-
p = 0.000) and Teamwork within units (r = -0.517; p = pants were afraid of revealing them. Despite the exist-
0.000). There is also a significant moderate negative ence of some weaker dimensions, the overall safety
correlation between the Hospital handoffs and tran- perception of radiographers is positive.
sitions (r = -363; p =0.000) and a significant weak
negative correlation with respect to the Staffing (r =
-201; p = 0.015).
In relation to the safety culture there are three
significant negative correlations between the dimen-
Key Points
sion Supervisor/manager expectations and actions
promoting patient safety (r = -554, p =.000), Hospital • Radiographers have an overall positive
perception of patient safety culture in
management support for patient safety (r = -525, p most of the evaluated dimensions
= 0.000) and Overall perceptions of safety (r = -595,
• Core areas such “Feedback and
p =.000).
Communication about errors” and
Relative to reported errors, there are two significant “Staffing” are negatively listed by radiog-
negative correlations with the dimensions Feedback raphers and should be further analysed
and communication about error (r = -531; p =, 000) • Manager support for patient care is
and Communication openness (r = -520, p =, 000); scored higher in private radiology facilities
and two significant moderate negative correlations than in the public sector
between the dimensions Frequency of event reporting • Safety culture dimensions rating should
(r = -444, p =, 000) and Non-punitive response to error guide future development of safety
(r = -343; p = 000). culture improving action plans
Conclusion
Safety culture has received increasing attention in the REFERENCES
recent past. This can be seen when healthcare facility For full references, please email
[email protected] or
members prioritise safety and when this becomes visit https://iii.hm/r16
64 HealthManagement.org
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
25
th
NOW !
myesr.org/registration
REGISTER
WINNING PRACTICES
A multimodal system for the
diagnosis of breast cancer:
the SOLUS project
SOLUS is developing a multimodal breast imaging system
involving diffuse optics and ultrasound.
The SOLUS project develops a novel multimodal system that significantly improves the
characterisation of breast lesions.
B
reast cancer is one of the most common to assess the morphology of breast lesions and
Paola Taroni cancers in the world. It is estimated that guide breast biopsies. Based on the morphological
Project Coordinator about one in eight women in Europe will features of a lesion, a distinction between malig-
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
SOLUS
Professor develop breast cancer before the age of 85 (Interna- nant and benign lesions is possible using the Breast
Department of Physics,
Politecnico di Milano (POLIMI) tional Agency for Research on Cancer 2018; Curado Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS)
Milano, Italy
et al. 2007). The chances for survival increase (Mendelson et al. 2003). BI-RADS provides stand-
[email protected]
substantially upon early diagnosis of breast cancer, ardised terminology to describe and assess breast
so the availability of diagnostic tools with a high lesions, as well as recommendations for further
sensitivity and specificity is vital. follow-up.
The International Agency for Research on Cancer
has confirmed the effectiveness of mammographic
screening in reducing breast cancer mortality THE SOLUS PROJECT IS
(Lauby-Secretan et al. 2015). Unfortunately, such DEVELOPING AN INNOVATIVE,
screening programmes return a significant number MULTIMODAL TOMOGRAPHIC SYSTEM,
of false positive cases (Lancet 2012). These require
COMBINING DIFFUSE OPTICS, US
further examination, such as additional imaging or
invasive procedures such as biopsies. Approximately
AND SWE, TO SUPPORT THE IN VIVO
Peter Gordebeke DIAGNOSIS OF BREAST CANCER
Project Manager 50% of positive breast screening outcomes turn out
SOLUS
Project Manager to be false positives, meaning that a large number
European Institute for
Biomedical Imaging Research
of additional examinations could have been avoided.
Vienna, Austria These additional examinations not only have BI-RADS categor y 3 are considered benign
[email protected] a negative impact on the patient’s quality of life, lesions, with a very low rate of malignancy. However,
@EIBIR_biomed
they also represent a high economic burden. Thus, BI-RADS category 4 covers a wide range of lesions
there is a clear need for an affordable point-of- whose malignancy status is less predictable.
Alberto Dalla Mora care system with a high specificity to improve the The diagnostic results of conventional US are
Associate Professor
Department of Physics, in-depth characterisation of breast lesions. frequently unsatisfactory. Improved characterisa-
Politecnico di Milano (POLIMI)
Milano, Italy
This article summarises the rationale behind the tion of lesions might allow better BI-RADS catego-
SOLUS project whose aims are the development risation and decrease invasive follow-ups.
Alberto Tosi of a multimodal breast imaging system involving
Assistant Professor
Department of Electronics,
diffuse optics and ultrasound. Shear wave elastography
Politecnico di Milano Recently, shear wave elastography (SWE) has
Milano, Italy
Ultrasound been introduced as an advanced US technique.
Ultrasonography (US) is the first-choice technique SWE provides a quantitative and reproducible
66 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
measurement of tissue stiffness. Tissue stiffness malignant and benign breast lesions (Quarto et al. Antonio Pifferi
Professor
can serve as a marker of malignancy, as malignant 2014; Taroni et al. 2009; Dalla et al. 2015; Konu- Department of Physics,
Politecnico di Milano (POLIMI)
tissue generally contains more extracellular matrix, golu et al. 2012). Milano, Italy
increasing its rigidity. A recent meta-analysis has With diffuse optical imaging using multiple
evaluated the performance of SWE for the diagnosis extremely short light pulses at different wave- Jean-Marc Dinten
Head of CEA-LETI
of breast cancer (Liu et al. 2016). The specificity of lengths, a complete optical characterisation of Grenoble, France
conventional US was 55%. The combination of SWE tissue is possible in a single measurement. However,
and conventional US resulted in a specificity of 80%. its spatial resolution is a well-established limita- Mathieu Perriollat
Optical systems project manager
This is a promising increase, but further improve- tion. To better exploit the information from diffuse CEA-LETI
Grenoble, France
ment in specificity is desirable to achieve a signifi- optical imaging, and to overcome its limited spatial
cant reduction in the false-positive rate. resolution, morphologic data obtained from other David Savery
imaging modalities, such as mammography, MRI, Research Engineer
SuperSonic Imagine
Diffuse optical imaging PET or US, have been used to provide so-called Aix-en-Provence, France
Optical imaging is an appealing candidate as a prior information for the diffuse optical tomography
method complementary to US. Optical imaging reconstruction, or for combined imaging to provide Hélène
Sportouche
methods can give insight into tissue composition, anatomical landmarks. Clinical Product Specialist
which US is unable to do. Contrary to conventional x-ray mammography or SuperSonic Imagine
Aix-en-Provence, France
With diffuse optics, a form of optical imaging, PET, US does not involve the use of ionising radia-
it is possible to measure the light absorption and tion and does not have many of the disadvantages Bogdan Rosinski
scattering properties of tissue. The absorption and of these modalities (complexity, high cost, size of Research Engineer
VERMON
scattering properties of light at different wave- equipment, long examination times, use of contrast Tours, France
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
lengths provides information about tissue struc- agents, limited patient acceptance). This makes US
Simon Arridge
ture, composition and functional blood parameters, an ideal method from which to derive anatomical Professor
such as haemoglobin concentration, oxygen satu- information and to complement diffuse optics. Centre for Medical Image
Computing, University
ration, and water and lipid content. Diffuse optical College London
London, UK
imaging can probe tissue to a depth of a few centi- The SOLUS project
metres, which makes it suited for the non-invasive The SOLUS project is developing an innovative, Andrea Giudice
diagnosis of breast cancer. multimodal tomographic system, combining diffuse CTO
Micro Photon Devices
Cancerous breast tissue is typically character- optics, US and SWE, to support the in vivo diagnosis Bolzano, Italy
ised by high haemoglobin and water content, while of breast cancer. Our multimodal system will improve
lipid content is correspondingly low. High scattering the classification of breast lesions, more specifi- Simone Tisa
Research Engineer
has also often been detected in malignant lesions cally the discrimination of lesions that are border- Micro Photon Devices
Bolzano, Italy
(Durduran et al. 2010; Leff et al. 2008). These obser- line between benign and malignant (BI-RADS 3 vs.
vations all correlate with known changes associated 4a). These presently have high false-positive rates. Elena Venturini
with tumour development, such as neoangiogenesis, Combining diffuse optics with US can be achieved Radiologist
San Raffaele Hospital
alterations of stromal components and increased via the development of a portable, cost-effective, Milano, Italy
extracellular matrix deposition. non-invasive, point-of-care diagnostic tool.
Collagen can also be measured using diffuse The SOLUS project is exploiting innovative
Pietro Panizza
Head of the Breast Imaging Unit
optics. Alterations in the composition of the extra- photonics concepts for the development of new San Raffaele University Hospital
Milano, Italy
cellular matrix are well-known aspects of patho- components. By employing diffuse optics with a
logical breast conditions and a causal link between small source-detector distance and a time-gated Pamela Zolda
collagen and tumour formation and progression approach, the SOLUS system will achieve unprec- European Research Manager
European Institute for
has been established (Luparello 2013). Thus, infor- edented sensitivity, spatial resolution, and depth Biomedical Imaging Research
Vienna, Austria
mation on the collagen content in breast tissue penetration, thereby providing effective, diagnostic
could provide useful information for breast lesion information on tissue composition and functional Ing. Alexander
classification. blood parameters to complement the anatomical Flocke
Sales / Application specialist
Pioneering research on the optical characterisa- information and characteristics of tissue stiffness iC-Haus GmbH
tion of tissue by the Politecnico di Milano, Italy, has provided by conventional US and SWE, respectively. Bodenheim, Germany
recently shown encouraging preliminary results that We are developing an innovative photonics
collagen may be even more crucial than haemo- module, called a smart optode to perform the
globin concentration in the differentiation between diffuse optical tomography. The smart optode
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 67
WINNING PRACTICES
Left: front of the multimodal probe with the eight optodes in two banks of four, with the ultrasound transducer in the middle. Right: mockup of the mul-
timodal probe.
includes a novel laser driver and newly developed The system will also allow more effective treat-
detector and acquisition electronics. The smart ment and therapy management. New and improved
optode itself will be small in size (measuring about therapy response prediction and monitoring enable
1 cm2 at the front). Multiple smart optodes will be personalised decision-making, therapy planning and
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
combined with a conventional US transducer into optimisation for each patient. This also contributes
a multimodal probe capable of carrying out diffuse to a significant decrease in the total cost of breast
optical tomography as well as US and SWE meas- cancer diagnosis.
urements all at once.
This multimodal probe is at the heart of the
SOLUS system for high-specificity, multi-parametric SOLUS WILL SUBSTANTIALLY
breast imaging and diagnosis of breast cancer. IMPROVE BREAST CANCER
The examination procedure will be very similar
DIAGNOSIS, LEADING TO REDUCTION
to current standard US practices. This facilitates
acceptance by both patients and clinicians.
IN UNNECESSARY BIOPSIES &
A more comprehensive characterisation of breast DECREASING THE ECONOMIC BURDEN
tissue, a higher diagnostic specificity, and reduc- ON HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS
tion in the number of invasive follow-up examina-
tions are expected.
After assessment of the specificity, sensitivity Conclusion, first results and
and spatial resolution of the system in laboratory achievements
trials, we plan to validate the SOLUS system in real The project partners are currently finishing the
clinical settings. A pilot clinical study on patients development of the components for the system.
with benign and malignant breast lesions (20 each) The overall design of the smart optode has
has been designed to demonstrate the overall already been completed. Subcomponents of the
feasibility of the proposed approach, the practical smart optode, such as the compact laser driver and
usability of the multi-modal instrument, and at the the time-gated single-photon detector, have been
same time to provide insights into the real diag- developed and are currently in the final stages of
nostic advantages that can be achieved. testing prior to their integration.
Furthermore, phantoms and protocols for perfor-
Impact of SOLUS mance assessment have been completed.
The SOLUS system will achieve substantially Work on the integration of the multimodal probe
improved breast cancer diagnosis, leading to a is currently ongoing. The practical ergonomics of
reduction in unnecessary biopsies and decreasing the probe are very important, so special attention
the economic burden on our healthcare systems. is being paid to feedback from our collaborating
68 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
clinicians on this aspect. • European Institute for Biomedical Imaging
Highly automated image processing and recon- Research, Vienna, Austria
struction algorithms are being developed and tested • iC-Haus, Bodenheim, Germany
with promising early results. These use anatomical
information from US for the reconstruction of the SOLUS has received funding from the Euro-
diffuse optics measurements. Additional software pean Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innova-
for the operation of the entire system is also under tion programme under grant agreement No 731877.
development. The SOLUS project is an initiative of the Photonics
Ultimately, the multimodal probe will be incorpo- Public Private Partnership.
rated into an existing, commercially available ultra-
sound system from project partner SuperSonic
Imagine.
Facts, figures and acknowledgement
The SOLUS project is coordinated by Prof. Paola Key Points
Taroni from the Politecnico di Milano, Italy. It started
• A high number of breast lesions,
in November 2016 and will conclude in October detected by screening programmes, are
2020. The consortium brings together physi- false-positives.
cists, engineers, clinicians and industry partners • Better discrimination between benign and
to develop the SOLUS system for improved breast malignant breast lesions is necessary to
cancer diagnosis. The consortium consists of nine reduce the number of unnecessary proce-
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
partners from five European countries: dures and the economic burden.
• Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy • Optical imaging methods provide an
• CEA-Leti, Grenoble, France excellent addition to conventional ultra-
sound imaging.
• SuperSonic Imagine, Aix-en-Provence, France
• Vermon, Tours, France • The SOLUS project is developing an
innovative, multimodal tomographic
• University College London, London, UK
system, combining diffuse optics and
• Micro Photon Devices, Bolzano, Italy ultrasound to support the in vivo diagnosis
• Ospedale San Raffaele, Milan, Italy of breast cancer.
References
Curado M, Edwards B, Shin H, Storm Independent UK Panel on Breast Yang G, Darzi A (2008) A diffuse optical Pearlman PC, Adams A, Elias SG,
H, Ferlay J, Heanue M, Boyle P (2007) Cancer Screening. The benefits and imaging of the healthy and diseases Mali WP, Viergever MA, Pluim J (2012)
Cancer Incidence in Five Continents. harms of breast cancer screening: an breast: a systematic review. Breast Mono- and multimodal registration of
IARC Press, Lyon Vol. 9 independent review. (2012) The Lancet Cancer Research and Treatment 108:9. optical breast images. J Biomed Opt
380: 1778 17: 080901
Dalla Mora A, Contini D, Arridge S, Liu B, Zheng Y, Huang G, Lin M, Shan
Martelli F, Tosi A, Boso G, Farina A, Konugolu Venkata Sekar S, Beh JS, Q, Lu Y, Tian W, Xie X (2016) Breast Quarto G, Spinelli L, Pifferi A, Torricelli
Durduran T, Martinenghi E, Torricelli Farina A, Dalla Mora A, Pifferi A, Taroni Lesions: Quantitative Diagnosis A, Cubeddu R, Abbate F, Balestreri N,
A, Pifferi A (2015) Towards next-gen- P (2017) Broadband diffuse optical Using Ultrasound Shear Wave Menna S, Cassano E, Taroni P (2014)
eration time domain diffuse optics for characterization of elastin for biomedi- Elastography—A Systematic Review Estimate of tissue composition in
extreme depth penetration and sen- cal applications. Biophys Chem 229: and Meta-Analysis. Ultrasound in malignant and benign breast lesions by
sitivity. Biomedical Optics Express 130 14. Medicine and Biology 42: 835 time-domain optical mammography.
6:1749. Biomedical Optics Express 5:3684.
Lauby-Secretan B, Scoccianti C, Luparello C (2013) Aspects of Collagen
Durduran T, Choe R, Baker W, Yodh A Loomis D, Benbrahim-Tallaa L, Changes in Breast Cancer J of Taroni P, Pifferi A, Salvagnini E, Spinelli
(2010) Diffuse optics for tissue moni- Bouvard V, Bianchini F, Straif K (2015) Carcinogenesis & Mutagenesis S13. L, Teoricelli A, Cubeddu R (2009)
toring and tomography. Reports on Breast Cancer Screening — Viewpoint Seven-wavelength time-resolved
Progress in Physics 73: 1 of the IARC Working Group. New Mendelson E, Baum J, Berg W, Merritt optical mammography extend-
England Journal of Medicine 372: 2353 C, Rubin E (2003) Breast imaging, ing beyond 1000 nm for breast col-
International Agency for Research on Reporting and Data System, BI-RADS: lagen quantification. Optics Express
Cancer. “Global Cancer Observatory” Leff D, Warren O, Enfield L, Gibson ultrasound. American College of 17: 15932
(2018) Available from gco.iarc.fr. A, Athanasiou T, Patten D, Hebden J, Radiology.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 69
WINNING PRACTICES
The evolution of left
ventricular assist devices
Cutting-edge therapy at a high price
Left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) have transformed the treatment landscape of heart
failure. As the number of implants continues to increase, clinicians will have to integrate dedicat-
ed programmes in their clinics and be actively involved in the care of patients on LVAD support.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Maria
Papathanasiou
Department of Cardiology
and Vascular Medicine
West-German Heart
and Vascular Center
University Hospital
Essen, Germany
maria.papathana-
[email protected]
H
eart failure is one of the most common have reduced ejection fraction, and 10% of these
cardiovascular conditions worldwide. The patients experience refractory heart failure symp-
estimated prevalence of heart failure is toms (New York Heart Association functional class
increasing at epidemic proportions. By the end of IIIb to IV, Stage D), yielding an estimated cohort of
Peter Luedike 2014, 6.5 million Americans ≥ 20 years of age had 200,000 to 250,000 patients. These patients are
Department of Cardiology
and Vascular Medicine been diagnosed with heart failure. This prevalence is typically referred to cardiac transplant centres, where
West-German Heart
and Vascular Center
projected to increase to > 8 million by the year 2030. they undergo evaluation to determine their candi-
University Hospital
Essen, Germany
(Heidenreich et al. 2013). Data from the NHLBI-spon- dacy for heart transplantation. The short- and long-
sored CHA, ARIC and CHS cohorts indicate that heart term outcomes following cardiac transplantation
[email protected]
failure incidence approaches 21 per 1000 people have been exceptional, with a median survival of
older than 65 years (Huffman et al. 2013). The total 10.7 years (Stehlik et al. 2011). The major limita-
costs for HF are projected to reach $69.7 billion by tion to cardiac transplantation has been the insuf-
2030, which represents an increase of 127% from ficient donor supply, which is currently limited to
2012 (Benjamin et al. 2018). approximately 2,500 hearts annually in the United
Approximately 50% of heart failure patients States. Obviously, transplantation is not available
70 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
for the majority of patients with advanced disease. need for a dedicated team of qualified healthcare
Fortunately, mechanical circulatory support with the workers in order to ensure appropriate long-term care
implantation of cardiac assist devices has emerged in the outpatient setting. Previous analyses have
as a novel therapeutic option for patients with demonstrated that LVAD was accompanied by vola-
refractory symptoms despite optimal medical and tile increases in healthcare expenses, compared to
conservative treatment. heart transplantation. Compared to non-bridged
heart transplant recipients, receiving an LVAD as
Left Ventricular Assist Devices a bridge to transplantation increased survival, with
Left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) have revolu- greater associated cost (range, $84964 per life-year
tionised the management of patients with advanced to $119574 per life-year for high-risk and low-risk
heart failure, providing an alternative to heart trans- patients, respectively). Open heart transplantation
plantation. LVADs were initially implanted as a bridge increased life expectancy and was cost-effective (8.5
to transplant, aiming to reduce the high mortality years with <$100000 per quality-adjusted life years
rates among hospitalised patients awaiting donor [QALY] relative to medical therapy), but LVAD either
hearts. However, the paucity of donor organs along- as a bridge to transplantation (12.3 years at $226
side a substantial increase in the burden of comor- 000 per QALY) or as destination therapy (4.4 years at
bidities and the ageing of the heart failure popula- $202000 per QALY) was not cost-effective (Alba et
tion has put the focus to non-transplant surgical al. 2013; Baras et al. 2016). These conflicting inter-
therapies for advanced heart failure. LVAD therapy ests are reflected to an ongoing dialogue between
was shown to improve survival and quality of life, healthcare policymakers, hospital leaders, and front-
either as a bridge to transplant or as a destina- line clinicians, aiming to counteract healthcare
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
tion therapy (Slaughter et al. 2009; Aaronson et disparities in a cost-effective manner and improve
al. 2012). Following FDA approval for destination clinical outcomes of this devastating disease.
therapy (DT) in 2010, LVAD implantations have
rapidly increased. The proportion of patients allo-
cated to DT increased from 19.6% during the period Left ventricular
2008-2010 to 45.7% of all implants in 2014. The assist devices (LVADs)
miniaturisation of devices, the evolution of device have revolutionised the
technology and the improvisation of the operative management of patients
techniques as well as better patient selection and with advanced heart failure,
complication management have led to a signifi- providing an alternative to
cant improvement in survival rates. The 8th Inter- heart transplantation
agency Registry for Mechanically Assisted Circula-
tory Support (INTERMACS) report on > 20.000 LVAD
implantations from 2006 to 2016 announced 1-year
survival of 81% and 2-year survival of 70% (Kirklin Under these circumstances, clinics pursuing to
et al. 2017). Nowadays, LVAD therapy constitutes initiate LVAD programmess are confronted with
an established treatment option for well-selected a challenging environment and have to take into
patients with advanced heart failure. As a result, the consideration various aspects of this exceptional
number of transplant and non-transplant centres mode of therapy before moving to capital invest-
integrating LVAD programmes in their facilities is ments. In general, an LVAD programme is consid-
rapidly expanding, and a further increase in device ered a challenging endeavour with regard to receiving
implantations is anticipated in the near future. funding, administrative support, and local accept-
ance from affiliated institutes and healthcare
Economic impact of LVAD on healthcare providers. Hereafter, we summarise some aspects
Despite these advantages, LVAD therapy is accom- from our own experience:
panied by a disproportionately high resource • Ideally, an LVAD programme should be part of
consumption and has an immense economic impact an interdisciplinary heart failure unit consisting
on the healthcare system. This results from the of a cardiology and a cardiac surgery depart-
frequent hospital readmissions, the broad spec- ment with an adequate number of potential
trum of severe device-related complications and the LVAD candidates.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 71
WINNING PRACTICES
• Considering the multi-organ manifestations on-site consulting service should be available
of advanced heart failure and the broad spec- for the end-of-life care of LVAD patients.
trum of non-surgical interventions indicated in LVADs have transformed the treatment land-
this patient cohort, the candidate centre should scape of heart failure and are now adopted for long-
be able to provide interventional and surgical term ambulatory support of patients with advanced
cardiac procedures, cardiac electronic device disease. As the number of implants is anticipated
implants and intensive care. A dedicated outpa- to rise, clinicians in administrative positions will be
tient clinic is part of the required infrastruc- surged to integrate dedicated programmes in their
ture in order to provide high-quality care of the clinics and be actively involved in the care of patients
ambulatory patients on the long term. on LVAD support. Consequently, all aspects of this
• The physician leadership team is the core of the mode of therapy will have to be considered, in order
LVAD project. An experienced heart failure cardi- to provide optimal care at a reasonably acceptable
ologist and a cardiothoracic surgeon with exper- cost.
tise in mechanical circulatory support should
supervise all aspects of device implementa-
tion, including patient selection, staff training,
quality controls, and cost-effectiveness.
• A qualified team of surgeons, heart failure
cardiologists, and nurses familiar with the
complexity of LVAD therapy should be of high Key Points
priority. Two VAD coordinators should oversee
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
the entire process from candidacy to follow- • LVADs have revolutionised the
up care and take on administrative and organ- management of patients with advanced
isational tasks. Staff training in special skills heart failure
and familiarity with psychosocial, technical and • LVAD therapy improves survival and quality
pharmaceutical issues is of paramount impor- of life, either as a bridge to transplant or as
tance for all parties. Rehabilitation physicians a destination therapy
should be part of the caring team and stay • An LVAD programme should be part of an
interconnected with the implantation clinic if interdisciplinary heart failure unit consisting
of a cardiology and a cardiac surgery
not regionally located. department
• At last , an in-hospit al hear t transplant
• The physician leadership team is the core
programme or a transplant centre affiliation
of the LVAD project
is vital for patients who are or may become
eligible for bridging therapy and should be • An in-hospital heart transplant programme
or a transplant centre affiliation is vital for
offered transplantation candidacy. Participa- patients who are or may become eligible
tion in a palliative care network or at least an for bridging therapy
References
Aaronson KD, Slaughter MS, Miller LW Baras Shreibati J, Goldhaber-Fiebert et al. (2013) Forecasting the impact of Slaughter MS, Rogers JG, Milano CA
et al. (2012) Use of an intrapericardial, JD, Banerjee D, Owens DK, Hlatky MA heart failure in the united states. Circ et al. (2009) Advanced heart failure
continuous-flow, centrifugal pump in (2017) Cost-effectiveness of left ven- Heart Failure, 6:606-619. treated with continuous-flow left ven-
patients awaiting heart transplantation. tricular assist devices in ambulatory tricular assist device. N Engl J Med,
Circulation, 125:3191-200. patients with advanced heart failure. Huffman MD, Berry JD, Ning H et al. 361:2241-2251.
JACC Heart Fail, 5:110-119. (2013) Lifetime risk for heart failure
Alba AC, Alba LF, Delgado DH, Rao among white and black americans. J Stehlik J, Edwards LB, Kucheryavaya
V, Ross HJ, Goeree R (2013) Cost- Benjamin EJ, Virani SS, Callaway CW Am Coll Cardiol, 61:1510-1517. AY et al. (2011) The Registry of the
effectiveness of ventricular assist et al. (2018) Heart disease and stroke International Society for Heart and
device therapy as a bridge to trans- statistics—2018 update: A report Kirklin JK, Pagani FD, Kormos RL et Lung Transplantation: Twenty-eighth
plantation compared with non- from the American Heart Association. al. (2017) Eighth annual INTERMACS Adult Heart Transplant Report--2011. J
bridged cardiac recipients. Circulation, Circulation, 137:e67-e492. report: Special focus on framing the Heart Lung Transplant, 30:1078-1094.
127:2424-2435. impact of adverse events. J Heart Lung
Heidenreich PA, Albert NM, Allen LA Transplant, 36:1080-1086.
72 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
Transforming lives a drone
delivery at a time
Rwanda leading the way with life-saving drone tech
Rwanda shows how rapidly-developing drone technology can improve healthcare
infrastructure at a national scale.
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Claudette Irere
Director General
Ministry of Information Technology
and Communications (MiTEC)
Kigali, Rwanda
[email protected]
@RwandaICT
mitec.gov.rw
I
n late 2016, the Government of Rwanda entered is notified by SMS text message.
a Public Private Partnership with automated logis- Today Zipline’s deliveries save the National Centre
tics company Zipline to deliver blood and medical for Blood Transfusion an estimated 20 percent,
supplies, becoming the first country to deploy drones compared to costs of the prior delivery mechanisms,
at national scale. Based out of Half Moon Bay in Silicon and is integrated to the National Hemo-vigilance
Valley, Zipline is operating in Rwanda in partnership system to support monitoring and forecasting for the
with Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance and UPS Foundation. blood distribution cold chain – the network for critical
The current first phase of the partnership is with 21 and perishable medical products. Alline Kabbatende
hospitals in the southwestern region of the country, The use of drones has addressed a number of chal- Technology Writer
Kigali, Rwanda
reputed for its rugged mountainous terrain, making lenges including slow response time to remote hospi-
access to hospitals difficult, especially during the rainy tals (about two hours to deliver blood) and improved
[email protected]
season. resource management, including refrigeration facili- rwandaonline.rw
As of December 2017 the partnership told a ties and delivery vehicles.
compelling story: over 3,200 on-demand deliveries Within the next two years the partnership with
by SMS text message had been made, predominantly Zipline will expand to the Eastern region of the country.
to serve postpartum haemorrhaging mothers. When In the long term the Government is looking to explore
an order is made, the drone leaves Zipline’s warehouse the use of drones for other opportunities such as
facility within 12 minutes, dropping the supplies in a delivery of vaccines, medicines, lab samples, supplies
designated zone of the hospital in a biodegradable for artificial insemination of livestock and other essen-
package. Upon fulfillment delivery the hospital staff tial and lifesaving products.
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 73
WINNING PRACTICES
Laying the foundation a training institute for drones to serve as a regional
With few benchmark examples, in 2016 when the Center of Excellence.
Government of Rwanda embarked on this partner-
ship, stakeholders from various Government institu- A model
tions (Health, ICT, Aviation and Infrastructure) focused Rwanda’s experience is a demonstration that it is
on strong collaboration to establish the appropriate possible for Government to collaborate with the private
policy and regulatory frameworks for drone delivery. In sector to harness technology to benefit its citizens. In
addition to this, awareness programmes were carried 2017 the Government of Tanzania entered a partner-
out in communities across the country, to ensure the ship with Zipline to deliver blood and medical supplies.
acceptance of this new technology. These partnerships with Zipline may serve as
models for other governments looking to unlock the
potential of drones in improved healthcare delivery.
These partnerships This is especially true for environments with inade-
with Zipline may serve as models quate transportation and road infrastructure, resulting
for other governments looking in increased costs for distribution, and hampering the
to unlock the potential of cold supply chain management to healthcare facilities.
Every context shall be different, but a clear vision;
drones in improved healthcare
appropriate governance (policy and regulatory frame-
delivery works) and an emphasis on developing local capacity
have proven to be paramount. It is also important for
The public private partnership model was imper- policy-makers to actively engage with a diverse set
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
ative to ensure maximum impact and the ability to of stakeholders in order to maximise the benefits of
sustainably scale the project. Eighteen months later, adopting drone technology to transform their health-
as Zipline deliveries increase, and as the industry care systems and improve their citizens’ lives.
grows, key actions have been taken to foster invest-
ment and innovation in drones, including the adop-
tion of performance-based regulations.
Earlier this year Jean de Dieu Rurangirwa, Rwanda’s
Minister of ICT noted that: “As we look to the future,
we will continue to put in place the infrastructure
and policy frameworks that accelerate the adoption
of emerging technologies to transform people’s lives.” Key Points
• Rwanda and Silicon Valley company
Capacity building Zipline entered into a PPI on drone cold
The Government of Rwanda recognises that working chain delivery of medical supplies in late
with technology pioneers like Zipline presents an 2016
opportunity, not only to improve service delivery to • The network serves 21 hospitals in
its people, but also to spur innovation and multiplier the rugged southwestern region of the
country
effects as a result of employing Rwandans. In fact
technology is a pillar of the country’s plan to become • Orders are made with text and take no
a knowledge-based economy by 2050. more than 12 minutes to deploy
A cornerstone of the partnership with Zipline is • Within 12 months, 3,200 on-demand
that the company employs Rwandans and ensures the deliveries had been made, primarily to
postpartum haemorrhaging mothers
diffusion of technical knowledge in the development
and operation of their drone technology. Today over • As part of the agreement with Zipline,
95% of network staff are Rwandans
95 percent of the staff are locals including pharma-
cists, engineers, nurses and biotechnologists. • The technology supports the country’s
ambitions to become a knowledge-based
As drone innovation and other technologies
economy by 2050
continue to play a pivotal role in delivering quality
healthcare to Rwandans, the Government of Rwanda • Zipline is expanding to the eastern part of
Rwanda
and Zipline entered a new partnership to establish
74 HealthManagement.org
The European Health Management Association (EHMA) will be holding its Annual
Conference in Espoo, Finland from 17 – 19 June 2019 on the theme of ‘Health
Management 2.0’ in collaboration with the Helsinki University Hospital (HUS) and the
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
National Institute for Health and Welfare, Finland.
The three days will give participants the opportunity to learn about the challenges, new
skills, share ideas and acquire effective practices on health management. This will be an
excellent opportunity to network as the conference will bring together educators,
researchers, managers and health professionals from Europe and beyond.
Different format sessions from abstract presentations and panel debates to “in
conversation with an expert” and coaching sessions will provide you with insights, new ideas
and knowledge that is needed in order to make the shift to 2.0 happen.
They will cover areas of leadership, skills and competencies, innovation, planning.
For more information about the Call for abstracts and the registration, please visit www.ehma2019.org
WINNING PRACTICES
Heat Waves: a climate
change challenge
to hospitals’ resilience
The scientifically based forecast of more frequent devastating natural disasters is coming,
and so is the need for a proactive attitude against the related risks. Hospitals and healthcare
systems should get engaged in such activity.
Scientific evidence of the relation Environment Agency gave evidence to a new policy
between natural disasters and climate approach with the publication on “Climate Change
change adaptation and disasters risk reduction in Europe” (EEA
It is becoming a constant in our daily life the call for 2017). International scientists have formed important
attention from the media to climate-related natural organisations, such as the World Weather Attribution
disasters. Until recent years, important institutions (worldweatherattribution.com), working since 2015, and
such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change focusing on “research and develop scientific tools and
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
(IPCC) were encountering scepticism when they, as early methodologies to perform timely and robust assess-
as in 2001, were underlining that “there is new and ments of whether and to what extent human-induced
Simona Agger stronger evidence that most of the warming observed climate change played a role in the magnitude and
Ganassi over the last 50 years is attributable to human activ- frequency of extreme weather events.”
Architect and Urban Planner
Independent Consultant -
ities” (IPCC Climate Change 2001). The main argu- The growing evidence coming from the scien-
Policlinico Universitario ment against this conclusion was the lack of scien- tific society of climate change as mostly produced by
Sant’ Orsola, Italy
Chairman of the Board of tific evidence of the relation between anthropogenic anthropogenic behaviour has still to face some doubt
European Health Property
network (EuHPn) activities and global warming, the main cause of climate or even the implicit denial. The United States, relevant
[email protected] change. nation, has recently declared to cease all participation
euhpn.eu
The European Parliament's Environment, Public in the initiatives foreseen by the above mentioned Paris
Health and Food Safety Committee requested a agreement.
study representing the uncertainty, or the diplo- The scientifically based forecast of more frequent
matic prudence, of that period among policymakers. devastating natural disasters is coming, and so is the
The study was titled “Climate Change and Natural need for a proactive attitude against the related risks.
Disasters: Scientific evidence of a possible relation Hospitals and healthcare systems should get engaged
between recent natural disasters and climate change.” in such activity. Climate change is, in fact, responsible
The conclusion was: “with or without climate change, for major health problems.
physical damage from extreme weather is increasing
in Europe …… with climate change having made certain The area and focus of the article
extreme events more likely and the likelihood that it will Climate change has produced and is producing two
be even worse in the future, it is prudent an adequate types of different impacts: the “long-term” and “imme-
response” (Anderson and Bausch 2006). diate” disasters.
The scientific evidence of the cause and effect rela- Without disregarding the need of our awareness and
tionship between climate change and natural disas- concern for the destruction of the Australian coastal
ters is now irrefutable. It has become, in fact, the basis reef, the progressive desertification of North-East Africa,
of relevant public initiatives such as the Conference the icebergs melting and glaciers shrinking, we will focus
of Parties (COPs). Specifically, the 21st COP, held in on the geographic framework of Europe and the risks
December 2015 in Paris, concluded with the impor- associated with it.
tant “Agreement on Climate Change Mitigation.” Actions Healthcare systems should mostly be concerned with
and scientific studies followed. In 2017 the European immediate impact. These were identified in the article
76 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
“Increasing risk over time of weather-related hazards it difficult to compare different reports and studies.
to the European population” (Forzieri et al. 2017) as: For our article, we will refer to the definition proposed
• Extreme heat waves in the report “The social impacts of heat waves” issued
• Cold waves by the public “Environment Agency” dealing with the
• Increased precipitation and flooding protection of the environment in England and Wales,
• Storms and high winds which considers heat waves as periods of “anomalous
• Related events such as landslides and fires heat that generate a societal response” (McGregor et
We aim to focus on the extreme heat waves, al. 2007).
because of their relevance in giving evidence to the new This definition is relevant for our work, posing the
needs of social and health care and consequently of accent on the effects on society, which are the ones
appropriate consciousness in a hospital’s management that can or will determine the pressure on hospitals,
and staff, medical or otherwise, planner and designer with the increased need for care.
of health facilities about: The heat wave of 2003 that involved a large part of
• The importance of health systems collabora- Europe, with its dramatic effects had stimulated some
tion with policymakers for impact reduction in attention to this natural risk. However, to date, heat
the new reality of climate change-related risk of as a social hazard connected to climate change is still
natural disasters not sufficiently understood and studied. Some of the
• The community value of healthcare infrastructure possible reasons lay on social factors. The few studies
resilience, as part of a strategic system available, give evidence to the fact that outcomes of
• The potential of hospitals in enhancing public mortality and morbidity, infrastructures failures and even
understanding and community preparedness criminality as a consequence of heat waves, are marked
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
by a heavy social component, ie they are much higher
the scientific evidence of in the poorest areas of cities, where in fact, the impact
of heat waves are more extreme and longer lasting.
the cause and effect relationship
An article of January 18, 2018, in an Australian web-
between climate change and paper, reported the social un-preparedness on coping
natural disasters is now with heat waves in spite of being Australia’s deadliest
irrefutable natural hazard (Gissing and Coates 2018).
This could happen in Europe, where the heat waves
Scientific studies and climate modelling have indi- and parallel drought facilitate bush and forest fires. In
cated that the measures to counteract climate change England, the major heat waves coincided with diffused
could not have, in the best of the circumstances, a drought, and they all had in common high ozone level,
relevant short-term impact; consequently, we are very the combined effects of which are reported poten-
likely to experience in the near and medium future an tially lethal. The most advanced clime model has been
increase in extreme weather events. Also, the sceptics predicting increases in heat waves frequency, intensity,
that human causes have given the greatest contribu- and longer duration.
tion to the rising of temperatures are admitting that The new report of IPCC that is starting to be made
the disastrous natural events will keep increasing in public keeps very high the guard against the natural
number and also in severity. hazard, including heat waves, also in their relation with
The concern among the public policymakers is drought and wildfires.
becoming more evident, and new strategies suggested, World Weather Attribution has published at the end
envisaging the need for more systemic approaches and of July 2018 a detailed study on “the heat waves in
visions that start in finding the most efficient measures Northern Europe,” confirming that all Europe has been
for adaptation to climate change and natural disaster kept under the potential risks of natural disasters, with
reduction. an increased number and duration of heat waves.
Heatwaves: a nasty enemy Vulnerability to heat
Heatwaves are difficult to define and classify. In fact, in As underlined before, the vulnerability to heat for
addition to magnitude, how rapidly they hit, and dura- a human being is a component of many factors,
tion, there are multiple local conditions and factors depending on:
influencing their perception and impact. This makes • level and the duration of the exposure to the hazard
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 77
WINNING PRACTICES
• age, health conditions of the person of the community health) geographic, environmental,
• home situation urban conditions. The advancing of the knowledge also
• environment characteristics and conditions put in the picture the difference between this natural
An interesting comparison comes from the study disaster and others, such as floods, the impact of which
dedicated to the social impact of heat waves. is evident almost immediately.
Summary of health-related threshold temperatures Heat waves can produce effects that come out
and mortality rates above threshold (McGregor et al.) slowly and/or could be incremented by other factors
Among studies dealing with the vulnerability of in subsequent times. From the studies available, heat
persons, evidence-based in qualitative terms, the waves can be divided into those that have a:
organisation Physicians for Social Responsibility (PSR
2018) indicate the following levels in the difference of Direct impact on health
susceptibility: • Immediate, that is requiring direct hospitalisation
• The elderly who suffer from poor health and/or emergency home services
• The elderly in general because of diminished ability • Time delayed, needs for hospitalisation or other
to regulate body temperature forms of help and assistance grow and become
• Babies and young children necessary in a progressive way
• Pregnant and nursing mothers • Demanding more studies and evaluations, which
• Those chronically ill with pre-existing cardiovas- is the case for the effects on mentally ill persons
cular, respiratory, neurologic, and psychiatric condi- or for types of violent behaviour
tions, or obesity.
• Outdoor workers Direct impact on healthcare infrastructures
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
• People who abuse drugs and alcohol • Electricity systems that could fail under high
• People without access to air conditioning demand inside the hospital or in the community
• Urban populations as city environments generally • Other systems such as water, medicines, space
have temperatures some degrees warmer than for services,
country areas. More frequently in urban areas, there • Emergency vehicles and staff requested for the
are situations of poor housing, connected very poor services inside and outside the hospital
economic situations It is also necessary to consider the possibility of
After the devastating effects in many parts of other events which, as mentioned, are happening as
Europe of the 2003 and 2005 hot waves, more studies a consequence of the heat wave, such as fires and
were developed focused especially in giving scientific the sufficient critical conditions of temperature and
evidence to the connections between natural disas- humidity following the heat wave.
ters and health. The health problems that could be more likely related
In the part dedicated to heat waves of “Global and to heat wave include:
planetary change,” the authors underline that the • Cardiovascular problems,
impact on health increases when extreme daytime • Respiratory problems
temperatures combine with warm night-time temper- • Heat strokes, with the rise of temperature, delirium,
atures, high humidity and light warm winds for several convulsions, and coma that can result in death
consecutive days. They define two types of impact on • Milder effects such as rashes, cramps, heat
human health related to strong and extreme events exhaustion
according to specified thresholds of thermal stress Among the long-lasting effects of stress exacer-
and duration (Amengual et al. 2014). This has specific bated by heat there could be:
importance for hospitals preparedness for those events. • Increase in symptoms of mental illness
In this regard, it needs to be stressed that the lack • Increase in violent behaviour
of sufficient and comparable studies leaves several • Higher risk of suicide and homicide
aspects still unclear, important especially for hospi- The side events that could develop and have devel-
tals preparation and awareness. oped in some instances are the explosion of fires, with
It also needs to be acknowledged, as said before, consequences that could go from many victims and
that the impact on mortality, morbidity, community destruction of the environment and build urban areas,
disruption depends from the social situation (eg age to minor destructions, but intoxications and problems
structure), epidemiologic situation (eg general situation with animals.
78 HealthManagement.org
WINNING PRACTICES
Hospital as a strategic institution • If there is a potential risk of fire related to its area
The set of issues that we have only partially highlighted of catchment and the structure has been selected,
poses serious questions to people working in hospital for example, to be the reference in case of persons
structures, in all capacity, but especially the managers severely burned, the hospital will have to prepare
and technical staff who are involved in keeping the ad hoc specific structures.
functionality of their structures, responding to the • To prepare adequate plants is crucial for energy
needs of their communities and performing the neces- supply. It has happened in several instances,
sary services. that the hospital did not have access to energy
• Functionality Preparedness for several days, without even the possibility of
This is the first step for preventive management. receiving fuel for producing its own energy. The
Disasters’ managers say: the moment that the disas- updating of storages based on different energy
trous event happens, it is too late to get ready. Acting production is essential, possibly eliminating diesel
with the community and all the staff, in the framework motors for such use.
of the general Strategic Plan of Prevention and Miti- • The other essential resource, water, also has to be
gation of the Community, and other superior territorial a priority in case of a heat wave, also for medical
levels of Government, the crucial elements of prevention needs, de-hydration being one of the possible major
have to be put in place, according to the major disasters problems
that the community could be suffering. The necessary
preparation has to be programmed and realised imme- What lies ahead
diately after general consensus and roles agreement. The social aspects deriving from heat waves impact are
The hospital can and should be one of the points of important. We have stressed how poor people are more
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
diffusion of information toward the community, through likely to suffer from heat waves, not to speak of the
its staff, the patients and their families and specific marginalised part of society. The technical dimensions
diffusion events. are also of relevance, since health facilities, first of all,
The internal preparedness should focus on: hospitals, are and will remain strategic pillars in support
• Managing massive presence of people at the of the social fabric for adaptation and mitigation.
hospital, some for treatments, others for searching It is, therefore, necessary that we prepare staff as
for relatives or simply for general information. A list well as health facilities about all aspects: medical, social
of available psychologists should be made. Among and technical, against extreme risks of natural disasters,
the studies produced, it is worth mentioning the and start addressing the one risk that has not received
European project IPPHEC (Improving Preparedness sufficient attention: heat waves. A follow-up analysis
to give Psychological help in Hospital in case of will be dedicated to highlight the technical factors that
massive emergency Crises). This international study, need to be tackled in order to have hospital prepared
directed by the Italian Ministry of Health, produced for heat extremes, in the certainty that preparedness
guidelines, addressed to cases of terrorism, but against heat waves risks, will assure to the hospitals the
certainly should also be considered for natural capacity to cope also for other climate change related
disasters (EAHC 2010). potential disasters.
• Control of technical systems, first of all of the elec-
trical, water, waste disposal, the supply of essential Key Points
medicine and food.
• There are no tools prepared, up to now, with regard • There is a scientifically-proven link between
to resilience, providing measures as for other natural disasters and climate change
aspects (eg fire or seismic norms for prevention in • Heatwaves are a growing threat to
new hospitals constructions) vulnerable populations
One of the aspects needing in-depth studies is • The hospital can operate as a strategic
“redundancy,”ie the evaluation of which are persons, institution to mitigate impact of extreme
medicines, equipment and services that are absolutely
necessary to have the possibility of alternative sources References
of supply for guaranteeing the continuity of the hospital
activity. Getting to the specific of heat waves, the first For full references, please email
[email protected] or
visit https://iii.hm/r17
consideration to make is:
Volume 19 • Issue 1 • 2019 79
I-I-I Blog
The Journal
is published by MindByte Communications Ltd
Brussels Office
Rue Villain XIV 53-55, B-1000 Brussels, Belgium
Michael A.E. Ramsay Tel: +32 2 2868500, Fax: +32 2 2868508
[email protected]
Chairman - Department of Anesthesiology and Pain
Limassol Office
Management, Baylor University Medical Center, U.S. 166 Agias Filaxeos, CY-3083 Limassol, Cyprus
Tel: +357 25 822 133, Fax: +32 2 2868508
[email protected]
TOP QUOTE FROM ZOOM ON PROFILE: Headquarters
“The hospital should be the safest place for our 9, Vassili Michaelides, CY-3026, Limassol, Cyprus
[email protected]
patients and yet mistakes and infections occur that
should not. It takes leadership from the top down to Executive Team
create the “Culture of Safety” that must exist.” Christian Marolt, Executive Director
[email protected]
See more at: https://iii.hm/qnz Iphigenia Papaioanou, Project Director
[email protected]
Carine Khoury, Director CEP Programmes
[email protected]
Marilena Patatini, Creative Director
[email protected]
KARIM Editorial Team
BOUSSEBAA Lucie Robson, Senior Editor
[email protected]
Senior Vice President &
Venetia Kyritsi, Staff Editor
General Manager of CT and AMI,
[email protected]
Philips, U.S.
Samna Ghani, Staff Editor
[email protected]
TOP QUOTE FROM BLOG Marianna Keen, Staff Editor
[email protected]
‘What imaging trends will
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Dran Coronado, Staff Editor
impact radiology depart-
[email protected]
ments in 2019?’
“We are already starting to Matthew Communications Team
see AI augment the radiologist’s role in tangible
ways, such as improving operational efficiency and
Gierc Katya Mitreva, Communications Director
[email protected]
Head of Marketing, 3AG Maria Christodoulidou, Communications Manager
diagnostic confidence, and we can only expect that Systems, Canada
[email protected]
momentum to continue in 2019 and beyond.”
Mahjabeen Farooq, Communications Assistant
TOP QUOTE FROM BLOG
[email protected]
See more at: https://iii.hm/qo0 ‘How nurse scheduling Uttam Sah Gond, Communications Assistant
can be the difference
[email protected]
between satisfaction Subscription Rates (6 Issues/Year)
and burnout’. One year: Euro 106 + 5% VAT, if applicable
Two years: Euro 184 + 5% VAT, if applicable
“Ensuring fair-
Daniela ness, consistency and
uniformity in sched-
Production & Printing
Total classic and digital circulation: 65,000
Pedrini
ISSN = 1377-7629a
Printed in Hungary by ABEL Printing, Budapest
uling is not just a nice
Vice President, International thing to do, but it can © HealthManagement.org is published six times per year. The Publisher
Federation of Healthcare is to be notified of any cancellations six weeks before the end of the
help your organisation subscription. The reproduction of (parts of) articles is prohibited without
Engineering the consent of the Publisher. The Publisher does not accept any liability
get the most from your for unsolicited material. The Publisher retains the right to republish all
nurses.” contributions and submitted materials via the internet and other media.
TOP QUOTE FROM THE BLOG
‘Climate change and Legal Disclaimer
See more at: https:// The Publishers, Editor-in-Chief, Editorial Board, Ambassadors and
healthcare architecture’. Editors make every effort to ensure that no inaccurate or misleading
iii.hm/qo2 data, opinion or statement appears in this publication. All data and
“The enormous challenge opinions appearing in the articles and advertisements herein are the
presented by climate change-related problems, sole responsibility of the contributor or advertiser concerned. Therefore
the Publishers, Editor-in-Chief, Editorial Board,
leads to the need for safer hospitals, in terms of Ambassadors and Editors and their respective
employees accept no liability whatsoever for the
physical structure and for proactive institutions in consequences of any such inaccurate or mislead-
the battle against this environmental situation.” ing data, opinion or statement.
Verified Circulation
According to the standards of International
See more at: https://iii.hm/qo3 Business Press Audits.
HealthManagement.org
is independently audited by TopPro Audit
Visit healthmanagement.org/blog/index for more I-I-I Blogs from healthcare thought leaders
80 HealthManagement.org
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
DO YOU CONSIDER THE COST OF
OWNERSHIP WHEN PURCHASING
IMAGING EQUIPMENT?
While customers focus primarily on purchase price and secondarily on future costs, they often
overlook what are known as “soft costs.”
Read the article on which categories should be taking into account when calculating the total cost
of ownership. Scan the QR code to read the full article.
SONOSITE and the SONOSITE logo are trademarks and registered trademarks of FUJIFILM SonoSite, Inc. in various jurisdictions.
FUJIFILM is a trademark and registered trademark of FUJIFILM Corporation in various jurisdictions. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Copyright © 2018 FUJIFILM SonoSite, Inc. All rights reserved. Subject to change. MKT03147 02/18
DIAGNOSTICS
WELCOME TO THE
COLLABORATORY
WHEN BARRIERS ARE REMOVED,
THE WHOLE SYSTEM WORKS BETTER TOGETHER
of healthcare of healthcare
executives believe
93%
executives believe labs
can lead the way in 70% the lab can impact
healthcare analytics* patient satisfaction*
©For personal and private use only. Reproduction must be permitted by the copyright holder. Email to
[email protected].
Connect with Abbott Diagnostics to see the impact collaboration can
* Data on file at Abbott
ADD-00065798A_EN
have on your laboratory and the entire healthcare institution! CHOOSE TRANSFORMATION
www.collaboratory.abbott
Saatja: Lucie Robson, Senior Editor <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 04.02.2019 12:58
Adressaat: SM Info <
[email protected]>
Koopia: <
[email protected]>
Teema: Invitation to contribute: Personalised Medicine - HealthMangement.org
Manused: HealthM_grey_180X50.png; PastedGraphic-3.tiff; Blockchain in healthcare-
HealthManagement.org.pdf
Dear Riina Sikkut
I am an editor with HealthManagement.org, the leading publication in healthcare management and
leadership.
Our third journal issue of 2019 has a cover story focusing on personalised medicine. We will be looking at
how technology is playing a role in the development of personalised medicine and at challenges such as
standardisation, interoperability, scalability and its relationship with population health.
As Minister of Health and Labour for Estonia and, as the country is a leader in the area of personalised
medicine, I would like to invite you to contribute an article on recent developments and how the country is
tackling the challenges. I understand that the objective is the harness the power of personalised medicine
to promote prevention rather than cure and to deal with chronic diseases and issues connected to the ageing
population. How is this being implemented and what sort of cooperation is needed from all stakeholders to
achieve this?
The deadline would be April 1, 2019. All contributors have the opportunity to review, request any amends
and approve material before it goes to print. We accept pieces from 600 words to 2, 800 words. If more
convenient, we could conduct an interview (email, phone, Skype or Zoom) from which to prepare a piece.
We are proud to say that, over the years, our contributors have included leading international thought
leaders such as Michael Porter, Robert Kaplan, Elizabeth Teisberg, Bertalan Mesko, Robert Wachter, Axel
Schumacher, Erin Sullivan (Harvard Medical School), Luciano Floridi (Oxford University), Marie Ennis-
O'Connor, ePatient Dave and Regina Halliday to name a few experts from the academic, technology,
healthcare and policy-making fields.
To provide you with a visual of our publication, I had attached a PDF of our most recent journal which
focused on Blockchain in healthcare.
I would be delighted if you could offer a view on this topic. Please let me know if you are interested and I
can provide more details.
Many thanks
Lucie Robson | HealthManagement
Senior Editor
-------------------------------------------------
[email protected]
Office: +357/25 82 21 33
HealthManagement.org
MindBYTE Communications Ltd |166 Agias Filaxeos | 3083 Limassol | CY
This email and any attached files are confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended
recipient, any disclosure, reproduction, copying, distribution, or other dissemination or use of this communication
is strictly prohibited. If you have received this transmission in error please notify the sender immediately and then
delete this email. Email transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error free as information could be
intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete, or contain viruses. The sender therefore is in no
way liable for any errors or omissions in the content of this message, which may arise as a result of email
transmission.