ASSESSMENT OF THE NEEDS OF THE PUBLIC SECTOR FOR A CENTRE DEVOTED TO PROMOTING PPPs IN
THE HEALTHCARE SECTOR
prepared within the framework of an initiative to establish a UNECE-affiliated PPP Specialist Centre of
Excellence in Sustainable Health in Germany
Background
This survey has been developed by the initiative group for the establishment of the UNECE-affiliated PPP
Specialist Centre of Excellence in Sustainable Health, located in Germany. The aim of this document is to
capture, through direct feedback from the public officials of the target countries, their experiences and
priorities in the preparation of healthcare sector PPPs. The purpose of this survey is, therefore, to understand
the specific needs, challenges, shortcomings and strategies in the design and implementation of PPPs in
countries’ healthcare sector and to ensure that the prospective Centre will be well placed to respond to the
specific needs of the Centre's clients. Additionally, the Centre aims to strengthen the international dialogue
on Sustainable Development Goals for sustainable health and people-first PPPs.
1. Introduction
1.1. Country:
1.2. Authority responsible for healthcare PPPs in the country
Responsible authority for regulating of PPPs
Responsible authority for healthcare
Responsible authority/ies for implementation for PPPs in
healthcare (national and local levels)
1.3. Name of your organization (and its acronym)
1.4. Contact person(s)
Name Position Contact Information (e-mail
address, phone, Skype, etc.)
2. International policies
2.1. What policy documents and guidelines are you using in your work for preparation and
implementation of PPPs in the healthcare sector (UN, WB, ADB, AfDB, EU, etc.)?
Page 1 of 7
2.2. Are you familiar with the UNECE concept of “People-First” PPPs? If yes, do you have an intention to
apply the Guiding Principles of “People-First” PPPs for the development and implementation of your PPP
projects in the healthcare sector? (See Guiding Principles document here)
3. Overall stocktaking: where you are now?
3.1. Could you please kindly give us a brief update regarding any special legislation on PPPs in general
and/or on PPP legislation in the healthcare sector? What laws, by-laws, guidelines, manuals are already
available at the national level? Please list the relevant laws or regulations.
3.2. What is the current status of development of PPP projects in the healthcare sector in your country? Do
you have any healthcare PPP projects in your pipeline, and if yes - how many? (please kindly fill out a
form 8 in case of positive response)
3.3. Have any PPP projects in the health care sector been implemented? What is your experience in this
regard? Please mention both positive and negative experiences.
3.4. What do you believe were the main factors that contributed to success or which were responsible for
failed projects in PPP in the healthcare sector?
3.5. From which sources do you fund the project preparation costs for PPPs in the healthcare sector in your
country (e.g. domestic national or local budget, development aid, international or multilateral financial
organizations, other)? Please elaborate.
3.6. Do you have any standard template documents available for PPPs in the healthcare sector for
scoping, planning and approvals, procurement, delivery and management of PPPs? (e.g. value for money
analysis/PSC, procurement guidelines, standard building specifications, standard service specifications,
model contracts, reporting standards, IT and medical equipment specifications, etc.)
3.7. Do you use any IT tools in your work (e-health tools, e-procurement tools, BIM, MIS, etc.)? If yes,
please list them below.
3.8. Have you ever considered using advanced analytics and technologies such as machine learning,
blockchain, statistical modeling for effective implementation of PPP’s in healthcare?
4.Quo Vadis? - Validation of the Centre’s possible activities against your needs
4.1. Which of the following activities of the planned Centre are mostly relevant to your needs?
Page 2 of 7
High priority Medium Low priority
Priority
1. Development and implementation of
international PPP health standards:
Facility Management Models
Clinical Services Models
Integrated Models
Health Information Systems
Dialysis Center Models
Pharma PPPs
Other (please specify)
2. Adjustment and adaptation of international
PPP guidelines, standards to national legislation?
3. Professional advice/consultancy on particular
PPP projects in the health care sector in
developing countries and assistance to implement
these projects to reach a successful operational
phase
4. Development of feasibility, case studies and
business cases
5. Development of an open source database for
PPPs in the health care sector
6. Development of an open source database of
PPP experts in various areas (technical, financial,
legal, other relevant areas)
7. Peer-to-Peer consultations (public officials to
public officials) and exchange of information
between various stakeholders
8. Development of technology and advanced
analytics tools for all stakeholders of PPP’s
9. Organisation of PPP training and study tours
10. Other activities you regard as relevant to
your needs (please specify)
4.2. Do you have any lessons learnt or best practices to share with others? Perhaps, you have done
successful projects and gained expertise which you wish to share, or vice versa you wish to share
experience about problems you encountered and ways to solve them.
4.3. If you are asked to participate in the contemplated pilot projects of the planned Centre, which
projects would you choose? (you could tick several, all or none.)
Page 3 of 7
1. Executive course on PPPs in the healthcare sector
2. Training on Sustainable Development Goals for PPPs in the healthcare sector
3. Training on people- first PPPs in the healthcare sector
4. Training on PPP financing
5. Training on blockchain and digital solutions for PPPs in the health care sector
6. Training on regulatory and legal aspects of PPPs in healthcare sector
7. Establishment of a Biotechnology Innovation Center based on a PPP facility
management model
8. Establishment of PPP dialysis project
9. Mentoring activities from international PPP experts (public and private)
10. Other ideas regarding possible pilot projects that could of interest to you?
Please elaborate.
5. Capacity building
5.1. Please describe the professional background and level of your team managing the development and
implementation of PPPs. What is the ratio of internal to external experts?
5.2. What training have you already received regarding PPPs in the healthcare sector?
1. Topic Duration Cost In-country Abroad
Provider Provider
5.3. Specific modalities of capacity building delivery. Which modality of capacity building delivery do
you prefer?
High Medium Low priority
priority Priority
Seminars, workshops, or training of officials abroad
Seminars, workshops or training of officials in your country
Long-term resident international experts
Short-term international advisors
On-line training
Access to on-line data, documentation, and information on specific
websites, webinars
Other (Please specify)
5.4. Priority Areas for Capacity Building: In the next three years, in which priority areas do you wish to
engage in capacity building? Please indicate up to 5 priorities in descending order.
Page 4 of 7
6. Technology implementation for projects in healthcare in your country for past 5 years
(if you don’t intend to share this information with third parties, please indicate so)
6.1. Data Collection process (please indicate what sort of
data is maintained in healthcare sector)
6.2. Technology used for data storage and retrieval
6.3. Current estimated annual expenditure in IT/technology
(in USD).
6.4. Are you performing any analytics and generating
weekly/monthly/yearly report for consumption of
stakeholders in PPP’s? If yes, please describe the types of
reports.
6.5. Have you utilized big data, statistical modelling and
machine learning tools for PPP projects in healthcare
implemented in the past? If yes, please describe the most
successful implementation
7. Conclusions:
7.1. Reflecting on your experience with PPP projects in the healthcare sector, which have been the most
successful / unsuccessful in your opinion and why?
7.2. Do you support the idea to establish of a UNECE PPP Specialist Centre of Excellence in Sustainable
Health? If so, would you like to contribute? If the answer is in the affirmative, please specify which
contribution you might wish to deliver (validation of Centre’s documents, contribution to the development of
international guidelines, standards, development of business cases based on your hands-on experience,
being a speaker, trainer, etc.). Feel free to elaborate.
7.3. Please indicate an area where your country has been quite successful in PPPs, in a way that would be
useful to share your experience with other countries? Would you be able to share with us the details of
PPP projects and documents you have developed to allow others to benefit from your experience? If yes,
please describe such details/documents.
7.4. Are you aware of another country that has succeeded in your view in healthcare PPPs and/or
implemented an interesting policy) that you would like to learn from? If yes, please describe.
7.5. Do you have any comments on how to make the planned UNECE-affiliated PPP Specialist Centre of
Excellence in Sustainable Health more effective?
Page 5 of 7
7.6. Would you like to subscribe to the newsletter on PPPs in Sustainable Health and join a LinkedIn
Group “PPPs in Sustainable Health”?
Yes No
Newsletter
LinkedIn Group
8. Project Identification Form - for the projects in planning and development (if you don’t intend to share this
information with third parties, please indicate so).
Project name
Estimated project cost/
Source of funding and/or financing
Planned duration
Project implementing public authority
Private partner (the scope of work: provision of
infrastructure/services or both)
Short summary of project
Current stage (pipeline, feasibility study, procurement)
Planned procurement method
Planned allocation of risks
Governmental support (guarantees, subsidies, equity etc.)
Type of PPP (e.g. BOT, facility management, service
contracts, other)
Greenfield or Brownfield project?
Ownership of (please indicate private or public)
- the land
- the building
- the medical equipment
- other facilities (e.g. dormitory, canteen,
hospital retail facilities)
Source of revenues:
- Availability fees
- Insurance payments
- Payments from patients
- Rental income
- Other (please specify)
Page 6 of 7
9. Privacy statement on the protection of personal data
This survey is committed to user privacy. We collect and process your personal information exclusively for the
purpose of enabling you to participate in surveys, registration forms or questionnaires and to willingly
participate in follow-up.
Your data is processed under the responsibility of the members of the executive board of the initiative on
establishment of UNECE-affiliated Centre of Excellence in Sustainable Health. This survey will process the
personal data only for the purposes for which they were transmitted. In addition to the personal information
processed by this survey service itself, there are personal data being used within questionnaires, for example
in the answers to a survey.
User's address might be stored if requested by the survey owner. If so, it will be only used for the needs of the
said survey.
Cookies and local storage (if survey is completed on-line)
The system uses:
• session "cookies" in order to ensure communication between the client and the server. Therefore, user's
browser must be configured to accept "cookies". The cookies disappear once the session has been terminated.
• local storage to save copies of the inputs of a participant to a survey in order to have a backup if the
server is not available during submission or the user's computer is switched off accidentally or any other cause.
Once a participant has submitted one's answers successfully to the server or has successfully saved a draft on
the server, the data is removed from the local storage.
Only the staff carrying out the processing of your information, and dealing with this survey will have access to
your data. The survey team does not transmit any data to third parties which are outside these recipients.
Contributors' personal data will remain in the database until the results of the questionnaire have been
completely processed and analyzed or until the survey owners have requested their removal. The cookies
disappear once the session has been terminated.
You can contact the survey support team at
[email protected] to access your data, check
the accuracy and, if needed, correct the data or address any concerns about the processing of your personal
information.
Page 7 of 7
Saatja: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 14.02.2019 14:45
Adressaat: SM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Survey "PPPs in Healthcare sector"
Tere,
Edastame SOM le, kuna on tervishoiu valdkonna küsimustik.
Lugupidamisega,
Mari-Ann Meikas
Ühisosakond
Dokumendihaldus
Rahandusministeerium
From: Claudio Meza [mailto:
[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, February
13, 2019 9:20 PMTo: ECE-ppp <
[email protected]>Subject: Survey "PPPs in
Healthcare sector"
Distinguished Representatives of Governments and National PPP Units,
We are pleased to kindly invite you to take a few moments of your time to
complete the on-line (or fill out in the attached form).
The survey has been developed by the initiative group for the
establishment of the UNECE-affiliated PPP Specialist Centre of Excellence
in Sustainable Health, located in Germany. The aim of this document is to
capture, through direct feedback from the public officials of the target
countries, their experiences and priorities in the preparation of
healthcare sector PPPs. The purpose of this survey is, therefore, to
understand the specific needs, challenges, shortcomings and strategies in
the design and implementation of PPPs in countries healthcare sector and
to ensure that the prospective Centre will be well placed to respond to
the specific needs of the Centre's clients. Additionally, the Centre
aims to strengthen the international dialogue on Sustainable Development
Goals for sustainable health and people-first PPPs.
Your input will help to shape a concept of Centre of Excellence, which
shall assist governments around the world to develop PPPs for a
sustainable and most innovative healthcare. The aim of this survey is to
capture, through direct feedback, from the public officials of the target
countries, their experiences and priorities in the preparation of
healthcare PPPs.
A completion of the questionnaire will require approximately 15 minutes
of your time. It would be appreciated if the survey could be returned by
22nd February 2019. Please fill out an on-line form or kindly send the
populated questionnaire to the address: , with a copy to .
We look forward to hearing from you.
Thank you.
Kind regards,
Claudio Meza
Claudio MezaEconomic Cooperation and Trade Division United Nations
Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE)Address: CH-1211 Geneva 10,
SwitzerlandTel.: +41 (0) 22 917 1366E-mail: Website: