Saatja: Andres Tropp <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 18.04.2022 08:26
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: Eesti Energia selgituskiri Õiglase Ülemineku Fondist projektidele
toetuse taotlemise kohta
Tere
Lisatuna edastame teile Eesti Energia selgituskirja Õiglase Ülemineku
Fondist Eesti Energia projektidele toetuse taotlemise kohta.
Küsimuste korral palun võtke meiega kontakti esimesel võimalusel.
Lugupidamisega
Andres Tropp
Regulaatorsuhete osakonna juht Eesti Energia AS +372 5303 7113 |
Lelle 22, 11318 Tallinn |
Ministry of Finance
Republic of Estonia
E-mail:
[email protected]
14. April 2022 No KA-JUH-13/121
Explanatory letter by Eesti Energia AS regarding the proposed use of Just Transition Fund
for transformation of oil shale industry in Estonia
Eesti Energia AS is an Estonian state-owned energy and chemicals company, which is operating several
oil shale mines as well as chemicals and energy production installations in north-eastern region of Estonia,
Ida-Virumaa (NUTS3 region for Just Transition). The company acknowledges the emergency of tackling
climate change and global efforts to bring down carbon emissions:
- Climate change is a global emergency that goes beyond national borders. To combat climate
change and its negative impacts, the global community has agreed in the UN Climate Change
Conference in Paris1 to limit global warming preferably to 1.5 degrees Celsius compared to pre-
industrial levels.
- In the EU, the European Commission has submitted the European Green Deal package2 to
transform the EU into a modern, resource-efficient and competitive economic area and ensure net
zero emissions of greenhouse gases by 2050.
Oil shale industry is already in the midst of transition, which could be highlighted by the following:
- According to the statistical data from 2020, Estonia has reduced its carbon emissions by ca 70%
compared to 1990 level. This means that Estonia has already achieved its national target for 2030
in respect of reduction on carbon emissions. The largest contribution to emission reductions is
accredited to downsizing of oil-shale based energy industry.3
- Steep reduction in electricity generation from oil shale has had its toll on the number of jobs and,
consequently, unemployment rate in Ida-Virumaa. The number of jobs in Eesti Energia AS has
decreased from more than 14 000 in the end of 1980 to 4737 in January 2021. Therefore,
unemployment rate in the region (10,2%) is nearly two times higher than the average unemployment
rate in Estonia (5,3%).3
- According to a recent study conducted by KPMG4, one direct job in the oil shale industry creates
additionally 1,3 to 3,9 indirect jobs. Therefore, approximately 20 to 42% of the total workforce in Ida-
Virumaa is somehow linked to oil shale industry.
- Oil shale industry generates approximately 5% of Estonia’s GDP and has been able to offer its
employees considerably higher wages compared to average wage of the region. The average
monthly salary in the oil shale industry (1663 €/month per person) is nearly 50% higher than the
average salary in Ida-Virumaa (1161 €). It should be noted that average income levels in the region
are amongst the lowest in Estonia.3
- Reduction of jobs in electricity generation from oil shale is one of the reasons why population of Ida-
Virumaa is shrinking and ageing. In the beginning of 1990s, Ida-Virumaa had more than 220 000
people living and working there. In 2019, population of the region was only 136 000 inhabitants. By
2045, it is forecasted that the population could decline further by 50 000 people.3
1 https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/paris-agreement
2 https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/european-green-deal_en
3 Estonia’s Just Transition Territorial Plan (JTTP)
4 „Põlevkiviõli väärtusahela loodav Eesti rahvuslik rikkus“, KPMG, 2020
https://home.kpmg/ee/et/home/insights/2020/12/polevkivi-vaartusahel-on-prognoositud.html
EESTI ENERGIA AS
Lelle 22, 11318 Tallinn, ESTONIA Reg. code 10421629
Tel +372 465 2222
[email protected]
Fax +372 465 2200 www.energia.ee
Eesti Energia AS recognises and adheres to the EU Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability5:
- Chemicals are the building blocks of low-carbon, zero pollution and energy- and resource-efficient
technologies, materials and products. Chemicals are crucial to the competitiveness of many
European industries, especially in the area of green economy and key enabling technologies.
- In line with the European Green Deal, the strategy strives for a toxic-free environment, where
chemicals are produced and used in a way that maximises their contribution to society including
achieving the green and digital transition, while avoiding harm to the planet and to current and future
generations.
- EU’s resilience to supply disruptions is a guarantee for achieving the overall sustainability goals as
set in the European Green Deal, including technologies for climate neutrality, such as batteries,
wind turbines and photovoltaics, for clean material circularity and for the zero-pollution ambition.
Thereby, taking into consideration the following:
- In 2021, Eesti Energia AS adopted an ambitious strategy to transform current oil shale industry into
circular economy chemicals industry. According to the strategy, this transformation will be carried
out gradually in separate stages.
- As regards power generation, then Eesti Energia plans to phase out the usage of oil shale in its
electricity generation installations by 2030 at the latest. Electricity generation will become fully
carbon neutral by 2035 when also the usage of retort gas as by-fuel will be phased out in electricity
generation. Most of the currently available power generation units will be permanently closed by
that time, only two newest biomass-fired power generation units will remain in operation.
- As regards chemicals production facilities, then currently these facilities use oil shale for production
of fossil liquid fuels (gasoline and fuel oil). According to the strategy, usage of oil shale as an energy
source for production of fossil liquid fuels will be fully phased out by 2040. Transition towards this
target is planned to start already in the nearest future. The aim of the first stage is to stop using oil
shale as an energy source for fossil gasoline production but as a raw material for production of
feedstock (such as aromatics and paraffines) to chemicals industry.
- In second stage, the company is planning to start co-processing of shredded tyres, plastic waste
and oil shale in its pyrolysis units with the aim of decreasing the share of fuel oil production and
increase the production of feedstock to chemical industry. In third stage, the company will phase
out all fossil liquid fuels production and will treat all intermediary products of pyrolysis process to
chemicals feedstock (please see the whole planned process description chart in attached Annex).
As a result of the final stage of transition, Eesti Energia plans to reach total yearly production level
of 540 000 tons of chemicals.
- As regards the process emissions of pyrolysis, then the company is planning to install to its
chemicals installation CCS technology equipment and achieve carbon neutrality by 2045 at the
latest.
- The company estimates that the total required investments for making this plan happen will amount
to approx. 1,5-2 billion euros. Beside substantial investment, such industrial transformation will also
enable to increase the resilience and sustainability of currently offered jobs and create
approximately 210 new high-skilled jobs in the region.
- Point (d) of Article 9 of the Just Transition Regulation stipulates that Just Transition Fund (JTF) shall
not support investments related to the production, processing, transport, distribution, storage or
combustion of fossil fuels. Given the latter, it is important to underline that the planned investments
are not related to any of the mentioned areas. None of the investments are planned to be made to
currently available facilities. Investments are planned to new facilities for creating a new value chain
which will initially enable to reduce and eventually phase out current production of fossil liquid fuels.
The products which will be produced in the new facilities will be used as a feedstock to chemical
industry. None of the to be produced products which will be exported from the boundaries of
the installation will be combusted for energy production purposes. Hence, production of
these products cannot be associated with fossil fuels.
5 https://ec.europa.eu/environment/pdf/chemicals/2020/10/Strategy.pdf
- Eesti Energia is of the view that financial support from the Just Transition Fund would facilitate
bringing the planned investment in the 1st chemicals’ upgrade facility forward so that it would be
possible to complete it already by 2027. This would enable the company to achieve both early
carbon emission reductions as well as to create new high-skilled jobs in Ida-Virumaa. Next
installations, the 2nd chemicals’ upgrade facility and the 3rd chemicals’ upgrade facility will be
executed thereafter, pursuant to the roadmap and timelines of Eesti Energia’s strategy (please see
the roadmap of chemicals’ upgrade facilities build-up in attached Annex).
and referring to the following provisions of the respective legal acts:
- Regulation 2021/1056 establishing the Just Transition Fund (JTF) is targeted to provide support for
the people, economies and environment of territories which face serious socio-economic challenges
deriving from the transition towards the Union’s 2030 targets for energy and climate and a climate-
neutral economy of the Union by 2050, based on the Paris Agreement.
- Article 8 section 2 of the Regulation 2021/1056 stating that the JTF may also support investments
to achieve the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions from activities listed in Annex I to Directive
2003/87/EC provided that such investments have been approved as part of the territorial just
transition plan based on the information required under point (i) of Article 11(2) of this Regulation.
Such investments shall only be eligible where they are necessary for the implementation of the
territorial just transition plan.
- Article 11 section 2 point (i) of the Regulation 2021/1056 stating that a territorial just transition plan
shall contain a list of operations to be supported and a justification that they contribute to a transition
to a climate-neutral economy and lead to a substantial reduction in greenhouse gas emissions going
substantially below the relevant benchmarks established for free allocation under Directive
2003/87/EC and provided that these operations are necessary for the protection of a significant
number of jobs.
Eesti Energia AS hereby requests from the competent authorities of Estonia and the European Commission
that its efforts to restructure and decarbonize oil shale sector in a sustainable and cost-efficient manner
would be supported from the Just Transition Fund on terms which would provide minimum but sufficient
certainty for making the necessary investments.
Therefore, we would like to ask the competent authorities of Estonia and the European Commission to
provide its opinion regarding the eligibility of the described first stage investments for co-financing from the
Just Transition Fund.
Let us hereby confirm our readiness to provide further and more detailed explanation regarding our plans
to your esteemed authorities.
Annex: the planned process description chart of oil shale based chemical industry and roadmap of
chemicals’ upgrade facilities build-up pursuant to Eesti Energia’s strategy
Sincerely,
(signed digitally)
Margus Vals
Member of the Management Board
Projects, Technology and New Business
Eesti Energia AS
ANNEX:
1. The planned process description chart of oil shale based chemical industry:
2. Roadmap of chemicals’ upgrade facilities build-up: