Ref. Ares(2022)3181762 - 23/04/2022
★ ★
★ *
★ ★
***
European
Commission
PAOLO GENTILOMI Rue de la Loi, 200
B-1049 Brussels
MEMBER OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Tel. +32-2 295 02 50
ECONOMY
[email protected]
Brussels,
Dear Minister,
The attack on Ukraine is causing incalculable suffering of the Ukrainian people and a
deep wound to European values. Putin's senseless war has also an inevitable impact on
the European economy and aggravates the challenges we were already facing, notably
rising energy prices but also wheat prices, among others.
The European Commission is well aware of the need to cushion the impact of high
energy prices on households and businesses, in particular the most vulnerable ones, while
also avoiding supply disruptions. In its Communication of October 2021 on energy
prices, the Commission presented a toolbox to guide Member States’ action in this area.
More recently, EU leaders discussed a number of options to curb prices, on the basis of
the Commission Communication of 23 March.
As we discussed many times in the ECOFIN, a coordinated EU response is of the essence
to safeguard the Single Market and avoid further divergences across Member States. In
the last months, a majority of Member States have lowered taxation on energy,
introducing reduced VAT rates or reduced excise duties on energy products and
electricity, making use of the flexibility provided by the current EU legal framework. The
purpose of this letter is to provide further guidance to Member States in the area of
energy taxation by clarifying the applicable rules under EU law while recalling a number
of key principles that should guide our action in this field.
ECOFIN Ministers
First, as you know, the Commission does not envisage for the moment further revisions
of the EU taxation framework to respond to the current crisis. The new VAT directive
has just been adopted and the new provisions are in force since 6 April 2022'. The new
Energy Taxation Directive (ETD) is currently under discussion in the Council, where the
objective is to align the taxation of energy products with EU energy and climate policies
by favouring clean technologies over fossil fuels.
Let me recall the main applicable rules:
- As regards VAT, the new regime allows the application of reduced VAT rates
(respecting a minimum of 5%) to natural gas, electricity and district heating.
Reduced rates are now also available on solar panels and certain energy efficient
heating systems (including a zero rate on solar panels). Member States cannot
have more than two different reduced rates. Motor fuels cannot benefit from
reduced rates.
The consultation of the VAT Committee is no longer needed, which allows for a
swifter implementation. In compliance with the objectives of the EU Green Deal,
a sunset clause stipulates that Member States have to phase out reduced rates on
fossil fuels by 2030.
- As regards ETD, the current framework allows for a number of differentiations,
reductions and exemptions that are available to all Member States, including
reduced rates or exemptions for households and reductions for fuels.
Exceptionally, the Council may also authorise a Member State to go even below
the minimum taxation rates, for specific policy considerations and on a temporary
basis. Derogation requests are assessed by the Commission, including their
compliance with State aid rules, where needed.
While my services remain at the disposal of Member States for further clarification of the
legal framework, there are also relevant political considerations that should guide our
action. I would like to recall three principles: effectiveness, consistency and equity.
Effectiveness', our policy response should be implemented swiftly to respond to the
emergency and effectively support households and businesses in these challenging times.
Lowering taxation on energy is easy to implement, and this is probably the reason why
taxation measures have been used extensively in the first weeks and months of the crisis.
However in case of persistent high prices, the benefit for businesses and consumers is
more uncertain. Reductions in VAT rates, in particular, have a bad track record in
translating into lower prices for consumers as tax cuts may be compensated by increased
tariffs from energy suppliers. In such cases, non-energy businesses could even be worse
off: they do not benefit from lower rates (since they deduct VAT anyway) and suffer
from the price increase.
./.
1 EUR-Lex - 32022L0542 - EN - EUR-Lex (curopa.eu).
Consistency, our policy response should be consistent with our overarching goals of
energy autonomy and our 2030 and 2050 climate targets. Achieving any of these
objectives require tax relief measures on fossil fuels to be temporary and targeted at
improving affordability of energy products for businesses and households while prices
are high. This is important also to protect the capacity of Member States and of the EU to
generate adequate tax revenues to finance the recovery and the twin transitions in a fair
manner.
Equity, our policy response should promote equity within and among Member States. To
ensure transparency within the Single Market, Member States should inform the
Commission of the measures they intend to take, which should also be fully consistent
with the EU State Aid framework. Regarding social fairness, let me also stress that
lowering indirect taxation is not necessarily the most effective solution to tackle energy
affordability, especially if high prices persist. Recycling higher revenues from energy
taxes or from abnormal profits of energy companies can help financing targeted support
to vulnerable households and businesses or to specific categories of transport users in a
fairer and more sustainable way. Depending on national preferences, this can be
implemented in the form of checks or refunds, bearing in mind the regressive impact of
energy prices hikes.
Yours sincerely,
Paolo GENTILONI
Electronically signed on 23/04/2022 08:21 (UTC+02) in accordance with Article 11 of Commission Decision (EU) 2021/2121
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 23.04.2022 09:58
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Indirect taxation measures to mitigate recent increases in
energy costs - 23/04/2022
Tähtsus: Kõrgeim
From:
[email protected] <CAB-GENTILONI-
[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, April 23, 2022 9:33 AMTo: CAB-
[email protected]: Indirect taxation measures to
mitigate recent increases in energy costs - 23/04/2022Importance: High
Dear Minister,
Please find attached a letter from Commissioner Gentiloni to ECOFIN
Ministers on energy taxation.
Best regards,
Commissioner Gentilonis office
European CommissionBERL 10/026
B-1049 Brussels/Belgium+32 229-57535